Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll - Latest
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 8389

Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll - Latest

by Robert Green Ingersoll · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2005
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    Ingersoll's Lecture on "Orthodoxy"

    Ladies and Gentlemen: It is utterly inconceivable that any man believing in the truth of the Christian religion could publicly deny it, because he who believes in that religion would believe that, by a public denial, he would peril the eternal salvation of his soul. It is conceivable, and without any great effort of the mind, that millions who don't believe in the Christian religion should openly say that they did. In a country where religion is supposed to be in power--where it has rewards for pretense, where it pays a premium upon hypocrisy, where it at least is willing to purchase silence--it is easily conceivable that millions pretend to believe what they do not.

    And yet I believe it has been charged against myself, not only that I was insincere, but that I took the side I am on for the sake of popularity; and the audience tonight goes far toward justifying the accusation.

    It gives me immense pleasure to say to this immense audience that orthodox religion is dying out of the civilized world. It is a sick man. It has been attacked with two diseases--softening of the brain and ossification of the heart. It is a religion that no longer satisfies the intelligence of this county; a religion that no longer satisfies the brain; a religion against which the heart of every civilized man and woman protests. It is a religion that gives hope only to a few; a religion that puts a shadow upon the cradle; a religion that wraps the coffin in darkness and fills the future of mankind with flame and fear.

    It is a religion that I am going to do what little I can while I live to destroy; and in its place I want humanity, I want good-fellowship, I want a brain without a chain, I want a religion that every good heart will cheerfully applaud.

    We must remember that this is a world of progress, a world of change.

    There is perpetual death and there is perpetual birth. By the grave of the old forever stands youth and joy; and, when an old religion dies, a better one is born. When we find out that an assertion is a falsehood, a shining truth takes its place, and we need not fear the destruction of the false. The more false we destroy the more room there will be for the true. There was a time when the astrologer sought to read in the stars the fate of men and nations. The astrologer has faded from the world, but the astronomer has taken his place.

    There was a time when the poor alchemist, bent and wrinkled and old, over his crucible, endeavored to find some secret by which he could change the baser metals into purest gold. The alchemist is gone; the chemist took his place; and, although he finds nothing to change metals into gold, he finds something that covers the earth with wealth. There was a time when the soothsayer and auger flourished, and after them came the parson and the priest; and the parson and priest must go.

    The preacher must go, and in his place must come the teacher--that real interpreter of nature. We are done with the supernatural. We are through with the miraculous and the wonderful. There was once a prophet who pretended to read in the book of the future. His place was taken by the philosopher, who reasons from cause to effect--a man who finds the facts by which he is surrounded and endeavors to reason from these premises, and to tell what in all probability will happen in the future. The prophet is gone, the philosopher is here.

    There was a time when man sought aid entirely from heaven--when he prayed to the deaf sky. There was a time when the world depended upon the supernaturalist. That time in Christendom has passed. We now depend upon the naturalist--not upon the disciple of faith, but upon the discoverer of facts--upon the demonstrator of truth. At last we are beginning to build upon a solid foundation, and just as we progress the supernatural must die.

    Religion of the supernatural kind will fade from this world, and in its place we will have reason. In the place of the worship of something we know not of, will be the religion of mutual love and assistance--the great religion of reciprocity. Superstition must go. Science will remain. The church, however, dies a little hard. The brain of the world is not yet developed. There are intellectual diseases the same as diseases of the body. Intellectual mumps and measles still afflict mankind. Whenever the new comes, the old protests, and the old fights for its place as long as it has a particle of power.

    And we are now having the same warfare between superstition and science that there was between the stagecoach and the locomotive. But the stage-coach had to go. It had its day of glory and power, but it is gone. It went West.

    In a little while it will be driven into the Pacific, with the last Indian aboard. So we find that there is the same conflict between the different sects and the different schools, not only of philosophy, but of medicine. Recollect that everything except the demonstrated truth is liable to die. That is the order of nature. Words die. Every language has a cemetery. Every now and then a word dies and a tombstone is erected, and across it is written the word "obsolete."

    New words are continually being born. There is a cradle in which a word is rocked. A thought is molded to a sound, and the child-word is born. And then comes a time when the word gets old, and wrinkled, and expressionless, and is carried mournfully to the grave, and that is the end of it. So in the schools of medicine. You can remember, so can I, when the old alopathists reigned supreme. If there was anything the matter with a man, they let out his blood.

    Called to the bedside, they took him to the edge of eternity with medicine, and then practiced all their art to bring him back to life. One can hardly imagine how perfect a constitution it took a few years ago to stand the assault of a doctor. And long after it was found to be a mistake, hundreds and thousands of the old physicians clung to it, carried around with them, in one pocket, a bottle of jalap, and in the other a rusty lancet, sorry that they couldn't find some patient idiotic enough to allow the experiment to be made again.

    So these schools, and these theories, and these religions die hard.

    What else can they do? Like the paintings of the old masters, they are kept alive because so much money has been invested in them. Think of the amount of money that has been invested in superstition! Think of the schools that have been founded for the more general diffusion of useless knowledge! Think of the colleges wherein men are taught that it is dangerous to think, and that they must never use their brains except in an act of faith! Think of the millions and billions of dollars that have been expended in churches, in temples and in cathedrals! Think of the thousands and thousands of men who depend for their living upon the ignorance of mankind!

    Think of those who grow rich on credulity and who fatten on faith! Do you suppose they are going to die without a struggle? They will die if they don't struggle. What are they to do?

    From the bottom of my heart I sympathize with the poor clergyman that has had all his common sense educated out of him, and is now to be thrown out upon the cold and uncharitable world. His prayers are not answered; he gets no help from on high, and the pews are beginning to criticize the pulpit. What is the man to do? If he suddenly change, he is gone. If he preaches what he really believes, he will get notice to quit. And yet if he and the congregation would come together and be perfectly honest, they would all admit they didn't believe anything of it.

    Only a little while ago a couple of ladies were riding together from a revival in a carriage late at night, and one said to the other; as they rode along: "I am going to say something that will shock you, and I beg of you never to tell it to anybody else. I am going to tell it to you." "Well, What is it?" Says she: "I don't believe in the bible."

    The other replied: "Neither do I." I have often thought how splendid it would be if the ministers could but come together and say: "Now let us be honest. Let us tell each other, honor bright--like Dr.

    Currie did in the meeting here the other day--let us tell just what we believe." They tell a story that in the old time a lot of people, about twenty, were in Texas in a little hotel, and one fellow got up before the fire, put his hands behind him, and says he: "Boys, let us all tell our real names." If the ministers and the congregations would only tell their real thoughts they would find that they are nearly as bad as I am, and that they believe just about as little.

    Now, I have been talking a great deal about the orthodox religion; and, after having delivered a lecture, I would meet some good, religious person, and he would say to me: "You don't tell it as we believe it." "Well, but I tell it as you have it written in your creed." "Oh, well," he says, "we don't mind that any more." "Well, why don't you change it?" "Oh, well," he says, "we understand it." Possibly the creed is in the best possible condition for them now. There is a tacit understanding that they don't believe it.

    There is a tacit understanding that they have got some way to get around it, that they read between the lines; and if they should meet now to form a creed, they might fail to agree; and the creed is now so that they can say as they please, except in public. Whenever they do so in public, the church, in self-defense, must try them; and I believe in trying every minister that doesn't preach the doctrine as he agrees to.

    I have not the slightest sympathy with a Presbyterian preacher who endeavors to preach infidelity from his pulpit and receive Presbyterian money. When he changes his views, he should step down and out like a man, and say: "I don't believe your doctrine, and I will not preach it. You must hire some bigger fool than I am."

    But I find that I get the creed very nearly right. Today there was put into my hands the new Congregational creed.

    I have just read it, and I thought I would call your attention to it tonight, to find whether the church has made any advance; to find whether it has been affected by the light of science; to find whether the sun of knowledge has risen in the heavens in vain; whether they are still the children of intellectual darkness; whether they still consider it necessary for you to believe something that you by no possibility, can understand, in order to be a winged angel forever. Now, let us see what their creed is. I will read a little of it.

    They commence by saying that they "believe in one God, the Father Almighty, maker of heaven, and of earth, and of all things visible and invisible." I am perfectly willing that He should make the invisible, if they want Him to. They say, now, that there is this one personal God; that He is the maker of the universe, and its ruler. I again ask the old question: of what did He make it? If matter has not existed through eternity, then this God made it. Of what did He make it? What did He use for the purpose?

    There was nothing in the universe except this God. What had the God been doing for the eternity He had been living? He had made nothing--called nothing into existence; never had had an idea, because it is impossible to have an idea unless there is something to excite an idea. What had He been doing? Why doesn't the Congregational Church tell us? How do they know about this infinite being? And if He is infinite, how can they comprehend Him? What good is it to believe something that you don't understand--that you never can understand?

    In the old creeds they described this God as a being without body and parts or passions. Think of that! Something without body and parts or passions. I defy any man in the world to write a letter descriptive of nothing. You can not conceive of a finer word-painting of a vacuum than a something without body and parts or passions. And yet this God, without passions, is angry at the wicked every day; this God, without passions, is a jealous God, whose anger burneth to the lowest hell.

    This God, without passions, loves the whole human race, and this God, without passions, damns a large majority of the same. So, too, He is the ruler of the world, and I find here that we find His providence in the government of the nations. What nations? What evidence can you find, if you are absolutely honest and not frightened, in the history of nations, that this universe is presided over by an infinitely wise and good God? How do you account for Russia? How do you account for Siberia? How do you account for the fact that whole races of men toiled beneath the master's lash for ages without recompense and without reward?

    How do you account for the fact that babes were sold from the arms of mothers--arms that had been reached toward God in supplication?

    How do you account for it? How do you account for the existence of martyrs? How do you account for the fact that this God allows people to be burned simply for loving Him? How do you account for the fact that justice doesn't always triumph? How do you account for the fact that innocence is not a perfect shield? How do you account for the fact that the world has been filled with pain, and grief, and tears? How do you account for the fact that people have been swallowed by volcanoes, swept from the earth by storms, dying by famine, if there is above us a ruler who is infinitely good and infinitely powerful?

    I don't say there is none. I don't know. As I have said before, this is the only planet I was ever on. I live in one of the rural districts of the universe. I know not about these things as much as the clergy.

    And if they know no more about the other world than they do about this, it is not worth mentioning. How do they answer all this? They say that God "permits it." What would you say to me if I stood by and saw a ruffian beat out the brains of a child, when I had full and perfect power to prevent it? You would say truthfully that I was as bad as the murderer. That is what you would say. Is it possible for this God to prevent it? Then, if He doesn't, He is a fiend; He is not good. But they say He "permits it." What for? So we may have freedom of choice.

    What for? So that God may find, I suppose, who are good and who are bad. Didn't He know that when He made us? Did He not know exactly just what He was making? Why should He make those whom He knew would be criminals? If I should make a machine that would walk your streets and commit murder, you would hang me. Why not? And if God made a man whom He knew would commit murder, then God is guilty of that murder.

    If God made a man, knowing he would beat his wife, that he would starve his children, that he would strew on either side of his path of life the wrecks of ruined homes, then, I say, the being who called that wretch into existence is directly responsible. And yet we are to find the providence of God in the history of nations. What little I have read shows me that when man has been helped, man had to do it; when the chains of slavery have been broken, they have been broken by man; when something bad has been done in the government of mankind, it is easy to trace it to man, and to fix the responsibility upon human beings.

    You will not look to the sky; you need throw neither praise nor blame; you can find the efficient causes nearer home--right here.

    What is the next thing I find in this creed? "We believe that man was made in the image of God, that he might know, love and obey God, and enjoy Him for ever." I don't believe that anybody ever did love God, because nobody ever knew anything about Him. We love each other. We love something that we know. We love something that our experience tells us is good and great, and good and beautiful. We cannot by any possibility love the unknown. We can love truth, because truth adds to human happiness. We can love justice, because it preserves human joy.

    We can love charity. We can love every form of goodness that we know, or of which we can conceive, but we cannot love the infinitely unknown.

    And how can we be made in the image of something that has neither body and parts nor passions?

    "That our first parents, by disobedience, fell under the condemnation of God, and that all men are so alienated from God that there is no salvation from the guilt and power of sin except through God's redeeming power." Is there an in

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll - Latest
    Author
    Robert Green Ingersoll
    Release date
    June 1, 2005 [eBook #8389]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Jake Jaqua. HTML version by Al Haines.
    Most recently updated
    December 26, 2020
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by Jake Jaqua.  HTML version by Al Haines.
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll--Latest
    
    
    
    
    Contents
    
       Thomas Paine
       Liberty of Man, Woman and Child
       Orthodoxy
       Blasphemy
       Some Reasons Why
       Intellectual Development
       Human Rights
       Talmagian Theology (Second Lecture)
       Talmagian Theology (Third Lecture)
       Religious Intolerance
       Hereafter
       Review of His Reviewers
       How the Gods Grow
       The Religion of our Day
       Heretics And Heresies
       The Bible
       Voltaire
       Myth and Miracle
       Ingersoll's Letter, on The Chinese God
       Ingersoll's Letter, Is Suicide a Sin?
       Ingersoll's Letter, The Right To One's Life
    
    
    
    
    Ingersoll's Lecture on Thomas Paine--Delivered in Central Music Hall,
    Chicago, January 29, 1880 (From the Chicago Times, Verbatim Report)
    
    
    Ladies and Gentlemen:--It so happened that the first speech--the very
    first public speech I ever made--took occasion to defend the memory of
    Thomas Paine.
    
    I did it because I had read a little something of the history of my
    country.  I did it because I felt indebted to him for the liberty I
    then enjoyed--and whatever religion may be true, ingratitude is the
    blackest of crimes.  And whether there is any God or not, in every star
    that shines, gratitude is a virtue.
    
    The man who will tell the truth about the dead is a good man, and for
    one, about this man, I intend to tell just as near the truth as I can.
    
    Most history consists in giving the details of things that never
    happened--most biography is usually the lie coming from the mouth of
    flattery, or the slander coming from the lips of malice, and whoever
    attacks the religion of a country will, in his turn, be attacked.
    Whoever attacks a superstition will find that superstition defended by
    all the meanness of ingenuity.  Whoever attacks a superstition will
    find that there is still one weapon left in the arsenal of
    Jehovah--slander.
    
    I was reading, yesterday, a poem called the "Light of Asia," and I read
    in that how a Boodh seeing a tigress perishing of thirst, with her
    mouth upon the dry stone of a stream, with her two cubs sucking at her
    dry and empty dugs, this Boodh took pity upon this wild and famishing
    beast, and, throwing from himself the Yellowrobe of his order, and
    stepping naked before this tigress, said:  "Here is meat for you and
    your cubs." In one moment the crooked daggers of her claws ran riot in
    his flesh, and in another he was devoured.  Such, during nearly all the
    history of this world, has been the history of every man who has stood
    in front of superstition.
    
    Thomas Paine, as has been so eloquently said by the gentleman who
    introduced me, was a friend of man, and whoever is a friend of man is
    also a friend of God--if there is one.  But God has had many friends
    who were the enemies of their fellow-men.  There is but one test by
    which to measure any man who has lived.  Did he leave this world better
    than he found it?  Did he leave in this world more liberty?  Did he
    leave in this world more goodness, more humanity, than when he was
    born?  That is the test.  And whatever may have been the faults of
    Thomas Paine, no American who appreciates liberty, no American who
    believes in true democracy and pure republicanism, should ever breathe
    one word against his name.  Every American, with the divine mantle of
    charity, should cover all his faults, and with a never-tiring tongue
    should recount his virtues.
    
    He was a common man.  He did not belong to the aristocracy.  Upon the
    head of his father God had never poured the divine petroleum of
    authority.  He had not the misfortune to belong to the upper classes.
    He had the fortune to be born among the poor and to feel against his
    great heart the throb of the toiling and suffering masses.  Neither was
    it his misfortune to have been educated at Oxford.  What little sense
    he had was not squeezed out at Westminster.  He got his education from
    books.  He got his education from contact with fellow-men, and he
    thought, and a man is worth just what nature impresses upon him.  A man
    standing by the sea, or in a forest, or looking at a flower, or hearing
    a poem, or looking in the eyes of the woman he loves, receives all that
    he is capable of receiving--and if he is a great man the impression is
    great, and he uses it for the purpose of benefiting his fellow-man.
    
    Thomas Paine was not rich, he was poor, and his father before him was
    poor, and he was raised a sailmaker, a very lowly profession, and yet
    that man became one of the mainstays of liberty in this world.  At one
    time he was an excise man, like Burns.  Burns was once--speak it
    softly--a gauger--and yet he wrote poems that will wet the cheek of
    humanity with tears as long as the world travels in its orb around the
    sun.
    
    Poverty was his brother, necessity his master.  He had more brains than
    books; more courage than politeness; more strength than polish.  He had
    no veneration for old mistakes, no admiration for ancient lies.  He
    loved the truth for truth's sake and for man's sake.  He saw oppression
    on every hand, injustice everywhere, hypocrisy at the altar, venality
    on the bench, tyranny on the throne, and with a splendid courage he
    espoused the cause of the weak against the strong, of the enslaved many
    against the titled few.
    
    In England he was nothing.  He belonged to the lower classes--that is,
    the useful people.  England depended for her prosperity upon her
    mechanics and her thinkers, her sailors and her workers, and they are
    the only men in Europe who are not gentlemen.  The only obstacles in
    the way of progress in Europe were the nobility and the priests, and
    they are the only gentlemen.
    
    This, and his native genius, constituted his entire capital, and he
    needed no more.  He found the colonies clamoring for justice; whining
    about their grievances; upon their knees at the foot of the throne,
    imploring that mixture of idiocy and insanity, George III., by the
    grace of God, for a restoration of their ancient privileges.  They were
    not endeavoring to become free men, but were trying to soften the heart
    of their master.  They were perfectly willing to make brick if Pharaoh
    would furnish the straw.  The colonists wished for, hoped for, and
    prayed for reconciliation.  They did not dream of independence.
    
    Paine gave to the world his "Common Sense."  It was the first argument
    for separation; the first assault upon the British form of government;
    the first blow for a republic, and it aroused our fathers like a
    trumpet's blast.  He was the first to perceive the destiny of the new
    world.  No other pamphlet ever accomplished such wonderful results.  It
    was filled with arguments, reasons, persuasions, and unanswerable
    logic. It opened a new world.  It filled the present with hope and the
    future with honor. Everywhere the people responded, and in a few months
    the Continental Congress declared the colonies free and independent
    states. A new nation was born.
    
    It is simple justice to say that Paine did more to cause the
    Declaration of Independence than any other man.  Neither should it be
    forgotten that his attacks upon Great Britain were also attacks upon
    monarchy, and while he convinced the people that the colonies ought to
    separate from the mother country, he also proved to them that a free
    government is the best that can be instituted among men.
    
    In my judgment Thomas Paine was the best political writer that ever
    lived.  "What he wrote was pure nature, and his soul and his pen ever
    went together."  Ceremony, pageantry, and all the paraphernalia of
    power had no effect upon him.  He examined into the why and wherefore
    of things.  He was perfectly radical in his mode of thought.  Nothing
    short of the bed-rock satisfied him. His enthusiasm for what he
    believed to be right knew no bounds. During all the dark scenes of the
    revolution never for a moment did he despair.  Year after year his
    brave words were ringing through the land, and by the bivouac fires the
    weary soldiers read the inspiring words of "Common Sense," filled with
    ideas sharper than their swords, and consecrated themselves anew to the
    cause of freedom.
    
    Paine was not content with having aroused the spirit of independence,
    but he gave every energy of his soul to keep that spirit alive.  He was
    with the army.  He shared its defeats, its dangers, and its glory.
    When the situation became desperate, when gloom settled upon all, he
    gave them the "Crisis."    It was a cloud by day and a pillar of fire
    by night, leading the way to freedom, honor, and glory.  He shouted to
    them "These are the times that try men's souls."  The summer soldier
    and the sunshine patriot, will, in this crisis, shrink from the service
    of his country; but he that stands it now deserves the love and thanks
    of man and woman.
    
    To those who wished to put the war off to some future day, with a lofty
    and touching spirit of self-sacrifice, he said:  "Every generous parent
    should say: 'If there must be war, let it be in my day, that my child
    may have peace'."  To the cry that Americans were rebels, he replied:
    "He that rebels against reason is a real rebel; but he that in defense
    of reason rebels against tyranny, has a better title to 'Defender of
    the Faith' than George III."
    
    Some said it was to the interest of the colonies to be free. Paine
    answered this by saying:  "To know whether it be the interest of the
    continent to be independent, we need ask only this simple, easy
    question:  'Is it the interest of man to be a boy all his life?"'  He
    found many who would listen to nothing, and to them he said:  "That to
    argue with a man who has renounced his reason is like giving medicine
    to the dead."  This sentiment ought to adorn the walls of every
    orthodox church.
    
    There is a world of political wisdom in this: "England lost her liberty
    in a long chain of right reasoning from wrong principles;"  and there
    is real discrimination in saying:  "The Greeks and Romans were strongly
    possessed of the spirit of liberty, but not the principles, for at the
    time they were determined not to be slaves themselves, they employed
    their power to enslave the rest of mankind."
    
    In his letter to the British people, in which he tried to convince them
    that war was not to their interest, occurs the following passage
    brimful of common sense:  "War never can be the interest of a trading
    nation any more than quarreling can be profitable to a man in business.
    But to make war with those who trade with us is like setting a bull-dog
    upon a customer at the shop door."
    
    The Writings of Paine fairly glitter with simple, compact, logical
    statements that carry conviction to the dullest and most prejudicial.
    He had the happiest possible way of putting the case, in asking
    questions in such a way that they answer themselves, and in stating his
    premises so clearly that the deduction could not be avoided.
    
    Day and night he labored for America.  Month after month, year after
    year, he gave himself to the great cause, until there was "a government
    of the people and for the people," and until the banner of the stars
    floated over a continent redeemed and consecrated to the happiness of
    mankind.
    
    At the close of the Revolution no one stood higher in America than
    Thomas Paine.  The best, the wisest, the most patriotic were his
    friends and admirers; and had he been thinking only of his own good he
    might have rested from his toils and spent the remainder of his life in
    comfort and in ease.  He could have been what the world is pleased to
    call "respectable."  He would have died surrounded by clergymen,
    warriors, and statesmen, and at his death there would have been an
    imposing funeral, miles of carriages, civic societies, salvos of
    artillery, a Nation in mourning, and, above all, a splendid monument
    covered with lies. He choose rather to benefit mankind.  At that time
    the seeds sown by the great infidels were beginning to bear fruit in
    France. The eighteenth century was crowning its gray hairs with the
    wreath of progress.
    
    On every hand science was bearing testimony against the church.
    Voltaire had filled Europe with light.  D'Holbach was giving to the
    elite of Paris the principles contained in his "System of Nature."  The
    encyclopaedists had attacked superstition with information for the
    masses.  The foundation of things began to be examined.  A few had the
    courage to keep their shoes on and let the bush burn.  Miracles began
    to get scarce.  Everywhere the people began to inquire.  America had
    set an example to the world.  The word liberty was in the mouths of
    men, and they began to wipe the dust from their superstitious knees.
    The dawn of a new day had appeared.   Thomas Paine went to France.
    Into the new movement he threw all his energies.  His fame had gone
    before him, and he was welcomed as a friend of the human race and as a
    champion of free government.
    
    He had never relinquished his intention of pointing out to his
    countrymen the defects, absurdities, and abuse of the English
    government.  For this purpose; he composed and published his greatest
    political work. "The Rights of Man."  This work should be read by every
    man and woman.  It is concise, accurate, rational, convincing, and
    unanswerable.  It shows great thought, an intimate knowledge of the
    various forms of government, deep insight into the very springs of
    human action, and a courage that compels respect and admiration.  The
    most difficult political problems are solved in a few sentences.  The
    venerable arguments in favor of wrong are refuted with a
    question--answered with a word.  For forcible illustration, apt
    comparison, accuracy and clearness of statement, and absolute
    thoroughness, it has never been excelled.
    
    The fears of the administration were aroused, and Paine was prosecuted
    for libel, and found guilty; and yet there is not a sentiment in the
    entire work that will not challenge the admiration of every civilized
    man.  It is a magazine of political wisdom, an arsenal of ideas, and an
    honor not only to Thomas Paine, but to nature itself.  It could have
    been written only by the man who had the generosity, the exalted
    patriotism, the goodness to say:  "The world is my country, and to do
    good my religion."
    
    There is in all the utterances of the world no grander, no sublimer
    sentiment.  There is no creed that can be compared with it for a
    moment. It should be wrought in gold, adorned with jewels, and
    impressed upon every human heart:  "The world is my country, and to do
    good my religion."
    
    In 1792, Paine was elected by the department of Calais as their
    representative in the National Assembly.  So great was his popularity
    in France, that he was selected about the same time by the people of no
    less than four departments.
    
    Upon taking his place in the assembly, he was appointed as one of a
    committee to draft a constitution for France.  Had the French people
    taken the advice of Thomas Paine, there would have been no "reign of
    terror."  The streets of Paris would not have been filled with blood in
    that reign of terror.  There were killed in the City of Paris not less,
    I think, than seventeen thousand people--and on one night, in the
    massacre of St. Bartholomew, there were killed, by assassination, over
    sixty thousand souls--men, women, and children.  The revolution would
    have been the grandest success of the world.  The truth is that Paine
    was too conservative to suit the leaders of the French revolution.
    They, to a great extent, were carried away by hatred and a desire to
    destroy. They had suffered so long, they had borne so much, that it was
    impossible for them to be moderate in the hour of victory.
    
    Besides all this, the French people had been so robbed by the
    government, so degraded by the church, that they were not fit material
    with which to construct a republic.  Many of the leaders longed to
    establish a beneficent and just government, but the people asked for
    revenge.  Paine was filled with a real love for mankind.  His
    philanthropy was boundless.  He wished to destroy monarchy--not the
    monarch.  He voted for the destruction of tyranny, and against the
    death of the tyrant.  He wished to establish a government on a new
    basis--one that would forget the past; one that would give privileges
    to none, and protection to all.
    
    In the assembly, where all were demanding the execution of the
    king,--where to differ with the majority was to be suspected, and where
    to be suspected was almost certain death--Thomas Paine had the courage,
    the goodness, and the justice to vote against death. To vote against
    the execution of the king was a vote against his own life.  This was
    the sublimity of devotion to principle.  For this he was arrested,
    imprisoned, and doomed to death.  There is not a theologian who has
    ever maligned Thomas Paine that has the courage to do this thing.  When
    Louis Capet was on trial for his life before the French convention,
    Thomas Paine had the courage to speak and vote against the sentence of
    death. In his speech I find the following splendid sentiments:
    
    
    "My contempt and hatred for monarchical governments are sufficiently
    well known, and my compassion for the unfortunate, friends or enemies,
    is equally profound.
    
    I have voted to put Louis Capet upon trial, because it was necessary to
    prove to the world the perfidy, the corruption, and the horror of the
    monarchical system.
    
    To follow the trade of a king destroys all morality, just as the trade
    of a jailer deadens all sensibility.
    
    Make a man a king today and tomorrow he will be a brigand.
    
    Had Louis Capet been a farmer, he might have been held in esteem by his
    neighbors, and his wickedness results from his position rather than
    from his nature.
    
    Let the French nation purge its territory of kings without soiling
    itself with their impure blood.
    
    Let the United States be the asylum of Louis Capet, where, in spite of
    the overshadowing miseries and crimes of a royal life, he will learn by
    the continual contemplation of the general prosperity that the true
    system of government is not that of kings, but of the people.
    
    I am an enemy of kings, but I can not forget that they belong to the
    human race.
    
    It is always delightful to pursue that course where policy and humanity
    are united.
    
    As France has been the first of all the nations of Europe to destroy
    royalty, let it be the first to abolish the penalty of death.
    
    As a true republican, I consider kings as more the objects of contempt
    than of vengeance."
    
    
    Search the records of the world and you will find but few sublimer acts
    than that of Thomas Paine voting against the king's death.  He, the
    hater of despotism, the abhorer of monarchy, the champion of the rights
    of man, the republican, accepting death to save the life of a deposed
    tyrant--of a throneless king!  This was the last grand act of his
    political life--the sublime conclusion of his political career.
    
    All his life he had been the disinterested friend of man.  He had
    labored not for money, not for fame, but for the general good. He had
    aspired to no office.  He had no recognition of his services, but had
    ever been content to labor as a common soldier in the army of progress,
    confining his efforts to no country, looking upon the world as his
    field of action.  Filled with a genuine love for the right, he found
    himself imprisoned by the very people he had striven to save.
    
    Had his enemies succeeded in bringing him to the block, he would have
    escaped the calumnies and the hatred of the Christian world. And let me
    tell you how neat they came getting him to the block. He was in prison,
    there was a door to his cell--it had two doors, a door that opened in
    and an iron door that opened out.  It was a dark passage, and whenever
    they concluded to cut a man's head off the next day, an agent went
    along and made a chalk mark upon the door where the poor prisoner was
    bound. Mr. Barlow, the American minister, happened to be with him and
    the outer door was shut, that is, open against the wall, and the inner
    door was shut, and when the man came along whose business it was to
    mark the door for death, he marked this door where Thomas Paine was,
    but he marked the door that was against the wall, so when it was shut
    the mark was inside, and the messenger of death passed by on the next
    day.  If that had happened in favor of some Methodist preacher, they
    would have clearly seen, not simply the hand of God, but both hands.
    In this country, at least, he would have ranked with the proudest
    names.  On the anniversary of the Declaration, his name would have been
    upon the lips of all orators, and his memory in the hearts of all the
    people.
    
    Thomas Paine had not finished his career.  He had spent his life thus
    far in destroying the power of kings, and now turned his attention to
    the priests.  He knew that every abuse had been embalmed in
    scripture--that every outrage was in partnership with some holy text.
    He knew that the throne skulked behind the altar, and both behind a
    pretended revelation of God.  By this time he had found that it was of
    little use to free the body and leave the mind in chains.  He had
    explored the foundations of despotism, and had found them infinitely
    rotten.  He had dug under the throne, and it occurred to him that he
    would take a look behind the altar.  The result of this investigation
    was given to the world in the "Age of Reason."  From the moment of its
    publication he became infamous.  He was calumniated beyond measure.
    To slander him was to secure the thanks of the church.  All his
    services were instantly forgotten, disparaged, or denied.  He was
    shunned as though he had been a pestilence. Most of his old friends
    forsook him.  He was regarded as a moral plague, and at the bare
    mention of his name the bloody hands of the church were raised in
    horror.  He was denounced as the most despicable of men.
    
    Not content with following him to his grave, they pursued him after
    death with redoubled fury, and recounted with infinite gusto and
    satisfaction the supposed horrors of his death-bed: gloried in the fact
    that he was forlorn and friendless, and gloated like fiends over what
    they supposed to be the agonizing remorse of his lonely death.
    
    It is wonderful that all his services are thus forgotten.  It is
    amazing that one kind word did not fall from some pulpit; that some one
    did not accord to him, at least--honesty.  Strange that in the general
    denunciation some one did not remember his labor for liberty, his
    devotion to principle, his zeal for the rights of his fellow-men.  He
    had, by brave and splendid effort, associated his name with the cause
    of progress.  He had made it impossible to write the history of
    political freedom with his name left out.  He was one of the creators
    of light, one of the heralds of the dawn.  He hated tyranny in the name
    of kings, and in the name of God, with every drop of his noble blood.
    He believed in liberty and justice, and in the sacred doctrine of human
    equality. Under these divine banners he fought the battle of his life.
    In both worlds he offered his blood for the good of man.  In the
    wilderness of America, in the French assembly, in the sombre cell
    waiting for death, he was the same unflinching, unwavering friend of
    his race; the same undaunted champion of universal freedom.  And for
    this he has been hated; for this the church has violated even his grave.
    
    This is enough to make one believe that nothing is more natural than
    for men to devour their benefactors.  The people in all ages have
    crucified and glorified.  Whoever lifts his voice against abuses,
    whoever arraigns the past at the bar of the present, whoever asks the
    king to show his commission, or question the authority of the priest,
    will be denounced as the enemy of man and God.  In all ages reason has
    been regarded as the enemy of religion.  Nothing has been considered so
    pleasing to the Deity as a total denial of the authority of your own
    mind. Self-reliance has been thought deadly sin; and the idea of living
    and dying without the aid and consolation of superstition has always
    horrified the church. By some unaccountable infatuation, belief has
    been and still is considered of immense importance.  All religions have
    been based upon the idea that God will forever reward the true
    believer, and eternally damn the man who doubts or denies.  Belief is
    regarded as the one essential thing.  To practice justice, to love
    mercy, is not enough; you must believe in some incomprehensible creed.
    You must say: "Once one is three, and three times one is one."  The man
    who practiced every virtue, but failed to believe, was execrated.
    Nothing so outrages the feelings of the church as a moral unbeliever,
    nothing so horrible as a charitable atheist.
    
    When Paine was born the world was religious, the pulpit was the real
    throne, and the churches were making every effort to crush out of the
    brain the idea that it had the right to think.  He again made up his
    mind to sacrifice himself.  He commenced with the assertion  "That any
    system of religion that had anything in it that shocks the mind of a
    child can not be a true system." What a beautiful, what a tender
    sentiment!  No wonder the church began to hate him.  He believed in one
    God, and no more.  After his life he hoped for happiness.  He believed
    that true religion consisted in doing justice, loving mercy; in
    endeavoring to make our fellow-creatures happy, and in offering to God
    the fruit of the heart. He denied the inspiration of the scriptures.
    This was his crime.
    
    He contended that it is a contradiction in terms to call anything a
    revelation that comes to us at secondhand, either verbally or in
    writing.  He asserted that revelation is necessarily limited to the
    first communication, and that after that it is only an account of
    something which another person says was a revelation to him.  We have
    only his word for it, as it was never made to us.  This argument never
    had been, and probably never will be answered.  He denied the divine
    origin of Christ and showed conclusively that the pretended prophecies
    of the Old Testament lead no reference to Him whatever.  And yet he
    believed that Christ was a virtuous and amiable man; that the morality
    he taught and practiced was of the most benevolent and elevated
    character, and that it had not been exceeded by any.  Upon this point
    he entertained the same sentiments now held by the Unitarians, and in
    fact by all the most enlightened Christians.
    
    In his time the church believed and taught that every word in the Bible
    was absolutely true.  Since his day it has been proven false in its
    cosmogony, false in its astronomy, false in its chronology and geology,
    false in its history, so far as the Old Testament is concerned, false
    in almost everything.  There are but few, if any, scientific men, who
    apprehend that the Bible is literally true.  Who on earth at this day
    would pretend to settle any scientific question by a text from the
    Bible?  The old belief is confined to the ignorant and zealous.  The
    church itself will before long be driven to occupy the position of
    Thomas Paine. The best minds of the orthodox world, today, are
    endeavoring to prove the existence of a personal Deity.  All other
    questions occupy a minor place.  You are no longer asked to swallow the
    Bible whole, whale, Jonah and all; you are simply required to believe
    in God and pay your pew-rent.
    
    There is not now an enlightened minister in the world who will
    seriously contend that Sampson's strength was in his hair, or that the
    necromancers of Egypt could turn water into blood, and pieces of wood
    into serpents.  These follies have passed away, and the only reason
    that the religious world can now have for disliking Paine, is that they
    have been forced to adopt so many of his opinions.
    
    Paine thought the barbarities of the Old Testament inconsistent with
    what he deemed the real character of God.  He believed the murder,
    massacre, and indiscriminate slaughter had never been commanded by the
    Deity.  He regarded much of the Bible as childish, unimportant and
    foolish.  The scientific world entertains the same opinion.  Paine
    attacked the Bible precisely in the same spirit in which he had
    attacked the pretensions of the kings.  He used the same weapons.  All
    the pomp in the world could not make him cower.  His reason knew no
    "Holy of Holies," except the abode of truth.  The sciences were then in
    their infancy.  The attention of the really learned had not been
    directed to an impartial examination of our pretended revelation. It
    was accepted by most as a matter of course.
    
    The church was all-powerful, and no one else, unless thoroughly imbued
    with the spirit of self-sacrifice, thought for a moment of disputing
    the fundamental doctrines of Christianity.  The infamous doctrine that
    salvation depends upon belief, upon a mere intellectual conviction, was
    then believed and preached.  To doubt was to secure the damnation of
    your soul.  This absurd and devilish doctrine shocked the common sense
    of Thomas Paine, and he denounced it with the fervor of honest
    indignation.  This doctrine, although infinitely ridiculous, has been
    nearly universal, and has been as hurtful as senseless.  For the
    overthrow of this infamous tenet, Paine exerted all his strength. He
    left few arguments to be used by those who should come after him, and
    he used none that have been refuted.
    
    The combined wisdom and genius of all mankind can not possibly conceive
    of an argument against liberty of thought.  Neither can they show why
    anyone should be punished, either in this world or another, for acting
    honestly in accordance with reason; and yet a doctrine with every
    possible argument against it has been, and still is, believed and
    defended by the entire orthodox world. Can it be possible that we have
    been endowed with reason simply that our souls may be caught in its
    toils and snares, that we may be led by its false and delusive glare
    out of the narrow path that leads to joy into the broad way of
    everlasting death?  Is it possible that we have been given reason
    simply that we may through faith ignore its deductions and avoid its
    conclusions? Ought the sailor to throw away his compass and depend
    entirely upon the fog?  If reason is not to be depended upon in matters
    of religion, that is to say, in respect to our duties to the Deity, why
    should it be relied upon in matters respecting the rights of our
    fellows?  Why should we throw away the law given to Moses by God
    Himself, and have the audacity to make some of our own?  How dare we
    drown the thunders of Sinai by calling the ayes and naes in a petty
    legislature?  If reason can determine what is merciful, what is just,
    the duties of man to man, what more do we want either in time or
    eternity?
    
    Down, forever down, with any religion that requires upon its ignorant
    altar its sacrifice of the goddess Reason; that compels her to abdicate
    forever the shining throne of the soul, strips from her form the
    imperial purple, snatches from her hand the sceptre of thought and
    makes her the bond-woman of senseless faith.
    
    If a man should tell you he had the most beautiful painting in the
    world, and after taking you where it was should insist upon having your
    eyes shut, you would likely suspect either that he had no painting or
    that it was some pitiful daub.  Should he tell you that he was a most
    excellent performer on the violin, and yet refused to play unless your
    ears were stopped, you would think, to say the least of it, that he had
    an odd way of convincing you of his musical ability.  But would this
    conduct be any more wonderful than that of a religionist who asks that
    before examining his creed you will have the kindness to throw away
    your reason?  The first gentleman says:  "Keep your eyes shut; my
    picture will bear everything but being seen.  Keep your ears stopped;
    my music objects to nothing but being heard."  The last says:  "Away
    with your reason; my religion dreads nothing but being understood."
    
    So far as I am concerned, I most cheerfully admit that most Christians
    are honest and most ministers sincere.  We do not attack them; we
    attack their creed.  We accord to them the same rights that we ask for
    ourselves.  We believe that their doctrines are hurtful, and I am going
    to do what I can against them.  We believe that the frightful text, "He
    that believes shall be saved, and he that believeth not shall be
    damned," has covered the earth with blood.  You might as well say that
    all that have red hair shall be damned.  It has filled the heart with
    arrogance, cruelty, and murder.  It has caused the religious wars;
    bound hundreds of thousands to the stake; founded inquisitions; filled
    dungeons; invented instruments of torture; taught the mother to hate
    her child; imprisoned the mind; filled the world with ignorance;
    persecuted the lovers of wisdom; built the monasteries and convents;
    made happiness a crime, investigation a sin, and self-reliance a
    blasphemy.  It has poisoned the springs of learning; misdirected the
    energies of the world; filled all countries with want; housed the
    people in hovels; fed them with famine; and but for the efforts of a
    few brave infidels, it would have taken the world back to the midnight
    of barbarism, and left the heavens without a star.
    
    The maligners of Paine say that he had no right to attack this
    doctrine, because he was unacquainted with the dead languages, and, for
    this reason, it was a piece of pure impudence to investigate the
    scriptures.
    
    Is it necessary to understand Hebrew in order to know that cruelty is
    not a virtue, that murder is inconsistent with infinite goodness, and
    that eternal punishment can be inflicted upon man only by an eternal
    fiend?  Is it really essential to conjugate the Greek verbs before you
    can make up your mind as to the probability of dead people getting out
    of their graves?  Must one be versed in Latin before he is entitled to
    express his opinion as to the genuiness of a pretended revelation from
    God? Common sense belongs exclusively to no tongue.  Logic is not
    confirmed to, nor has it been buried with, the dead languages. Paine
    attacked the Bible as it is translated.  If the translation is wrong,
    let its defenders correct it.
    
    The Christianity of Paine's day is not the Christianity of our time.
    There has been a great improvement since then.  It is better now
    because there is less of it.  One hundred and fifty years ago the
    foremost preachers of our time--that gentleman who preaches in this
    magnificent hall--would have perished at the stake.  Lord, Lord, how
    John Calvin would have liked to have roasted this man, and the perfume
    of his burning flesh would have filled heaven with joy.  A Universalist
    would have been torn to pieces in England, Scotland, and America.
    Unitarians would have found themselves in the stocks, pelted by the
    rabble with dead cats, after which their ears would have been cut off,
    their tongues bored, and their foreheads branded.  Less than one
    hundred and fifty years ago the following law was in force in Maryland:
    
    
    "Be it enacted by the right honorable, the lord proprietor, by and with
    the advice and consent of his lordship's governor, and the upper and
    lower houses of the assembly, and the authority of the same:  That if
    any person shall hereafter, within this province, willingly,
    maliciously, and advisedly, by writing or speaking, blaspheme or curse
    God, or deny our Savior, Jesus Christ, to be the son of God, or shall
    deny the Holy Trinity, the Father, Son, and the Holy Ghost, or the
    God-head of any of the three persons, or the unity of the God-head, or
    shall utter any profane words concerning the Holy Trinity, or the
    persons thereof and shall therefore be convicted by verdict, shall, for
    the first offense, be bored through the tongue, and fined L20, to be
    levied on his body.  As for the second offense, the offender shall be
    stigmatized by burning in the forehead the letter B, and fined L40.
    And that for the third offense, the offender shall suffer death without
    the benefit of clergy."
    
    
    The strange thing about this law is, that it has never been repealed,
    and was in force in the District of Columbia up to 1875.  Laws like
    this were in force in most of the colonies and in all countries where
    the church had power.
    
    In the Old Testament the death penalty was attached hundreds of
    offenses.  It has been the same in all Christian countries. Today, in
    civilized governments, the death penalty is attached only to murder and
    treason; and in some it has been entirely abolished.  What a commentary
    upon the divine systems of the World!
    
    In the days of Thomas Paine the church was ignorant, bloody, and
    relentless.  In Scotland the "kirk" was at the summit of its power.  It
    was a full sister of the Spanish Inquisition.  It waged war upon human
    nature.  It was the enemy of happiness, the hater of joy, and the
    despiser of liberty.  It taught parents to murder their children rather
    than to allow them to propagate error.  If the mother held opinions of
    which the infamous "kirk" disapproved, her children were taken from her
    arms, her babe from her very bosom, and she was not allowed to see
    them, or write them a word.  It would not allow ship-wrecked sailors to
    be rescued from drowning on Sunday.
    
    Oh, you have no idea what a muss it kicks up in heaven to have anybody
    swim on Sunday.  It fills all the wheeling worlds with sadness to see a
    boy in a boat, and the attention of the recording secretary is called
    to it.  In a voice of thunder they say, "Upset him!"  It sought to
    annihilate pleasure, to pollute the heart by filling it with religious
    cruelty and gloom, and to change mankind into a vast horde of pious,
    heartless fiends.  One of the most famous Scotch divines said:  "The
    kirk holds that religious toleration is not far from blasphemy."  And
    this same Scotch kirk denounced, beyond measure, the man who had the
    moral grandeur to say, "The world is my country, and to do good my
    religion."  And this same kirk abhorred the man who said, "Any system
    of religion that shocks the mind of a child can not be a true system."
    
    At that time nothing so delighted the church as the beauties of endless
    torment, and listening to the weak wailing of damned infants struggling
    in the slimy coils and poison folds of the worm that never dies.
    
    About the beginning of the nineteenth century a boy by the name of
    Thomas Aikenhead was indicted and tried at Edinburgh for having denied
    the inspiration of the scriptures, and for having, on several
    occasions, when cold, wished himself in hell that he might get warm.
    Notwithstanding the poor boy recanted and begged for mercy, he was
    found guilty and hanged.  His body was thrown in a hole at the foot of
    the scaffold and covered with stones, and though his mother came with
    her face covered with tears, begging for the corpse, she was denied and
    driven away in the name of charity.  That is religion, and in the
    velvet of their politeness there lurks the claws of the tiger.  Just
    give them the power and see how quick I would leave this part of the
    country. They know I am going to be burned forever; they know I am
    going to hell, but that don't satisfy them.  They want to give me a
    little foretaste here.
    
    Prosecutions and executions like these were common in every Christian
    country, and all of them based upon the belief that an intellectual
    conviction is a crime.  No wonder the church hated and traduced the
    author of the "Age of Reason."  England was filled with Puritan gloom
    and Episcopal ceremony.  The ideas of crazy fanatics and extravagant
    poets were taken as sober facts. Milton had clothed Christianity in the
    soiled and faded finery of the gods--had added to the story of Christ
    the fables of mythology.  He gave to the Protestant church the most
    outrageously material ideas of the Deity.  He turned all the angels
    into soldiers--made heaven a battle-field, put Christ in uniform, and
    described God as a militia-general.  His works were considered by the
    Protestants nearly as sacred as the Bible itself, and the imagination
    of the people was thoroughly polluted by the horrible imagery, the
    sublime absurdity of the blind Milton.
    
    Heaven and hell were realities--the judgment-day was expected--books of
    accounts would be opened.  Every man would hear the charges against him
    read.  God was supposed to sit upon a golden throne, surrounded by the
    tallest angels, with harps in their hands and crowns on their heads.
    The goats would be thrust into eternal fire on the left, while the
    orthodox sheep, on the right, were to gambol on sunny slopes forever
    and ever.  So all the priests were willing to save the sheep for half
    the wool.
    
    The nation was profoundly ignorant, and consequently extremely
    religious, so far as belief was concerned.  In Europe liberty was lying
    chained up in the inquisition, her white bosom stained with blood.  In
    the new world the Puritans had been hanging and burning in the name of
    God, and selling white Quaker children into slavery in the name of
    Christ, who said, "Suffer little children to come unto Me."
    
    Under such conditions progress was impossible.  Some one had to lead
    the way.  The church is and always has been, incapable of a forward
    movement.  Religion always looks back.  The church has already reduced
    Spain to a guitar, Italy to a hand-organ, and Ireland to exile.
    
    Some one, not connected with the church, had to attack the monster that
    was eating out the heart of the world.  Some one had to sacrifice
    himself for the good of all.  The people were in the most abject
    slavery; their manhood had been taken from them by pomp, by pageantry,
    and power.
    
    Progress is born of doubt and inquiry.  The church never doubts--never
    inquires.  To doubt is heresy--to inquire is to admit that you do not
    know--the church does neither.
    
    More than a century ago Catholicism, wrapped in robes red with the
    innocent blood of millions, holding in her frantic clutch crowns and
    scepters, honors and gold, the keys of heaven and hell, tramping
    beneath her feet the liberties of nations, in the proud movement of
    almost universal dominion, felt within her heartless breast the deadly
    dagger of Voltaire.  From that blow the church can never recover.
    Livid with hatred she launched her eternal anathema at the great
    destroyer, and ignorant Protestants have echoed the curse of Rome.
    
    In our country the church was all-powerful, and, although divided into
    many sects, would instantly unite to repel a common foe.  Paine did for
    Protestantism what Voltaire did for Catholicism.  Paine struck the
    first blow.
    
    The "Age of Reason" did more to undermine the power of the Protestant
    church than all other books then known.  It furnished an immense amount
    of food for thought.  It was written for the average mind, and is a
    straightforward, honest investigation of the Bible, and of the
    Christian System.
    
    Paine did not falter from the first page to the last.  He gives you his
    candid thought, and candid thoughts are always valuable.
    
    The "Age of Reason" has liberalized us all.  It put arguments in the
    mouths of the people; it put the church on the defensive, it enabled
    somebody in every village to corner the parson; it made the world wiser
    and the church better; it took power from the pulpit and divided it
    among the pews.  Just in proportion that the human race has advanced,
    the church has lost its power. There is no exception to this rule.  No
    nation ever materially advanced that held strictly to the religion of
    its founders.  No nation ever gave itself wholly to the control of the
    church without losing its power, its honor, and existence.
    
    Every church pretends to have found the exact truth.  This is the end
    of progress.  Why pursue that which you have?  Why investigate when you
    know.  Every creed is a rock in running water; humanity sweeps by it.
    Every creed cries to the universe, "Halt!"  A creed is the ignorant
    past bullying the enlightened present.
    
    The ignorant are not satisfied with what can be demonstrated. Science
    is too slow for them, and so they invent creeds.  They demand
    completeness. A sublime segment, a grand fragment, are of no value to
    them.  They demand the complete circle--the entire structure.
    
    In music they want a melody with a recurring accent at measured
    periods. In religion they insist upon immediate answers to the
    questions of creation and destiny.  The alpha and omega of all things
    must be in the alphabet of their superstition.  A religion that can not
    answer every question, and guess every conundrum, is in their
    estimation, worse than worthless.  They desire a kind of theological
    dictionary--a religious ready reckoner, together with guide-boards at
    all crossings and turns. They mistake impudence for authority,
    solemnity for wisdom, and pathos for inspiration. The beginning and the
    end are what they demand.  The grand flight of the eagle is nothing to
    them.  They want the nest in which he was hatched, and especially the
    dry limb upon which he roosts. Anything that can be learned is hardly
    worth knowing.  The present is considered of no value in itself.
    Happiness must not be expected this side of the clouds, and can only be
    attained by self-denial and faith; not self-denial for the good of
    others, but for the salvation of your own sweet self.
    
    Paine denied the authority of Bibles and creeds; this was his crime,
    and for this the world shut the door in his face and emptied its slops
    upon him from the windows.
    
    I challenge the world to show that Thomas Paine ever wrote one line,
    one word in favor of tyranny--in favor of immorality; one line, one
    word against what he believed to be for the highest and best interest
    of mankind; one line, one word against justice, charity, or liberty,
    and yet he has been pursued as though he had been a fiend from hell.
    His memory had been execrated as though he had murdered some Uriah for
    his wife; driven some Hagar into the desert to starve with his child
    upon her bosom; defiled his own daughters; ripped open with the sword
    the sweet bodies of loving and innocent women; advised one brother to
    assassinate another; kept a harem with seven hundred wives and three
    hundred concubines, or had persecuted Christians even unto strange
    cities.
    
    The church has pursued Paine to deter others.  The church used
    painting, music, and architecture simply to degrade mankind.  But there
    are men that nothing can awe.  There have been at all times brave
    spirits that dared even the gods.  Some proud head has always been
    above the waves. Old Diogenes, with his mantle upon him, stiff and
    trembling with age, caught a small animal bred upon people, went into
    the Pantheon, the temple of the gods, and took the animal upon his
    thumb nail, and, pressing it with the other, "he sacrificed Diogenes to
    all the gods." Just as good as anything!  In every age some Diogenes
    has sacrificed to all the gods. True genius never cowers, and there is
    always some Samson feeling for the pillars of authority.
    
    Cathedrals and domes, and chimes and chants, temples frescoed and
    grained and carved, and gilded with gold, altars and tapers, and
    paintings of virgin and babe, censer and chalice, chasuble, paten and
    alb, organs, and anthems and incense rising to the winged and blest,
    maniple, anice and stole, crosses and crosiers, tiaras, and crowns,
    mitres and missals and masses, rosaries, relics and robes, martyrs and
    saints, and windows stained as with the blood of Christ, never, never
    for one moment awed the brave, proud spirit of the infidel.  He knew
    that all the pomp and glitter had been purchased with liberty, that
    priceless jewel of the soul. In looking at the cathedral he remembered
    the dungeon.  The music of the organ was not loud enough to drown the
    clank of fetters. He could not forget that the taper had lighted the
    fagot.  He knew that the cross adorned the hilt of the sword, and so
    where others worshiped, he wept and scorned.  He knew that across the
    open Bible lay the sword of war, and so where others worshiped he
    looked with scorn and wept.  And so it has been through all the ages
    gone.
    
    The doubter, the investigator, the infidel, have been the saviors of
    liberty.  The truth is beginning to be realized, and the truly
    intellectual are honoring the brave thinker of the past.  But the
    church is as unforgiving as ever, and still wonders why any infidel
    should be wicked enough to attempt to destroy her power. I will tell
    the church why I hate it.
    
    You have imprisoned the human mind; you have been the enemy of liberty;
    you have burned us at the stake, roasted us before slow fires, torn our
    flesh with irons; you have covered us with chains, treated us as
    outcasts; you have filled the world With fear; you have taken our wives
    and children from our arms; you have confiscated our property; you have
    denied us the right to testify in courts of justice; you have branded
    us with infamy; you have torn out our tongues; you have refused us
    burial.  In the name of your religion you have robbed us of every
    right; and after having inflicted upon us every evil that can be
    inflicted in this world, you have fallen upon your knees, and with
    clasped hands implored your God to finish the holy work in hell.
    
    Can you wonder that we hate your doctrines; that we despise your
    creeds; that we feel proud to know that we are beyond your power; that
    we are free in spite of you; that we can express our honest thought,
    and that the whole world is gradually rising into the blessed light?
    Can you wonder that we point with pride to the fact that infidelity has
    ever been found battling for the rights of man, for the liberty of
    conscience, and for the happiness of all?  Can you wonder that we are
    proud to know that we have always been disciples of reason and soldiers
    of freedom; that we have denounced tyranny and superstition, and have
    kept our hands unstained with human blood?
    
    I deny that religion is the end or object of this life.  When it is so
    considered it becomes destructive of happiness.  The real end of life
    is, happiness.  It becomes a hydra-headed monster, reaching in terrible
    coils from the heavens, and thrusting its thousand fangs into the
    bleeding, quivering hearts of men.  It devours their substance, builds
    palaces for God (who dwells not in temples made with hands), and allows
    His children to die in huts and hovels.  It fills the earth with
    mourning, heaven with hatred, the present with fear, and all the future
    with fear and despair.  Virtue is a subordination of the passion of the
    intellect.  It is to act in accordance with your highest convictions.
    It does not consist in believing, but in doing. This is the sublime
    truth that the infidels in all ages have uttered.  They have handed the
    torch from one to the other through all the years that have fled.  Upon
    the altar of reason they have kept the sacred fire, and through the
    long midnight of faith they fed the divine flame.  Infidelity is
    liberty; all superstition is slavery.  In every creed man is the slave
    of God, woman is the slave of man, and the sweet children are the
    slaves of all. We do not want creeds; we want some knowledge.  We want
    happiness.  And yet we are told by the church that we have accomplished
    nothing; that we are simply destroyers; that we tear down without
    building again.
    
    Is it nothing to free the mind?  Is it nothing to civilize mankind?  Is
    it nothing to fill the world with light, with discovery, with science?
    Is it nothing to dignify man and exalt the intellect.  Is it nothing to
    grope your way into the dreary prisons, the damp and dropping dungeons,
    the dark and silent cells of superstition, where the souls of men are
    chained to floors of stone; to greet them like a ray of light, like the
    song of a bird, the murmur of a stream, to see the dull eyes open and
    grow slowly bright; to feel yourself grasped by the shrunken and unused
    hands, and hear yourself thanked by a strange and hollow voice?  Is it
    nothing to conduct these souls gradually into the blessed light of
    day--to let them see again the happy fields, the sweet, green earth,
    and hear the everlasting music of the waves?  Is it nothing to make men
    wipe the dust from their swollen knees, the tears from their blanched
    and furrowed cheeks? Is it a small thing to reave the heavens of an
    insatiate monster and write upon the eternal dome, glittering with
    stars, the grand word liberty?  Is it a small thing to quench the
    thirst of hell with the holy tears of piety, break all the chains, put
    out the fires of civil war, stay the sword of the fanatic, and tear the
    bloody hands of the church from the white throat of progress?  Is it a
    small thing to make men truly free, to destroy the dogmas of ignorance,
    prejudice, and power, the poisoned fables of superstition, and drive
    from the beautiful face of the earth the fiend of fear?
    
    It does seem as though the most zealous Christians must at times
    entertain some doubt as to the divine origin of his religion. For
    eighteen hundred years the doctrine has been preached.  For more than a
    thousand years the church had, to a great extent, the control of the
    civilized world, and what has been the result? Are the Christian
    nations patterns of charity and forbearance? On the contrary, their
    principal business is to destroy each other.  More than five millions
    of Christians are trained and educated and drilled to murder their
    fellow-Christians.  Every nation is groaning under a vast debt incurred
    in carrying on war against other Christians, or defending itself from
    Christian assault.  The world is covered with forts to protect
    Christians from Christians, and every sea is covered with iron monsters
    ready to blow Christian brains into eternal froth.  Millions upon
    millions are annually expended in the effort to construct still more
    deadly and terrible engines of death.  Industry is crippled, honest
    toil is robbed, and even beggary is taxed to defray the expenses of
    Christian murder.  There must be some other way to reform this world.
    We have tried creed and dogma, and fable, and they have failed--and
    they have failed in all the nations dead.
    
    Nothing but education--scientific education--can benefit mankind. We
    must find out the laws of nature and conform to them.  We need free
    bodies and free minds, free labor and free thought, chainless hands and
    fetterless brains.  Free labor will give us wealth.  Free thought will
    give us truth.  We need men with moral courage to speak and write their
    real thoughts, and to stand by their convictions, even to the very
    death.  We need have no fear of being too radical.  The future will
    verify all grand and brave predictions.  Paine was splendidly in
    advance of his time, but he was orthodox compared to the infidels of
    today.
    
    Science, the great iconoclast, has been very busy since 1809, and by
    the highway of progress are the broken images of the past.  On every
    hand the people advance.  The vicar of God has been pushed from the
    throne of the Caesars, and upon the roofs of the Eternal city falls
    once more the shadow of the eagle.  All has been accomplished by the
    heroic few.  The men of science have explored heaven and earth, and
    with infinite patience have furnished the facts.  The brave thinkers
    have aided them. The gloomy caverns of superstition have been
    transformed into temples of thought, and the demons of the past are the
    angels of today.
    
    Science took a handful of sand, constructed a telescope, and with it
    explored the starry depths of heaven.  Science wrested from the gods
    their thunderbolts; and now, the electric spark freighted with thought
    and love, flashes under all the waves of the sea.  Science took a tear
    from the cheek of unpaid labor, converted it into steam, and created a
    giant that turns with tireless arm the countless wheels of toil.
    
    Thomas Paine was one of the intellectual heroes, one of the men to whom
    we are indebted.  His name is associated forever with the great
    republic.  He lived a long, laborious, and useful life. The world is
    better for his having lived.  For the sake of truth he accepted hatred
    and reproach for his portion.  He ate the bitter bread of neglect and
    sorrow.  His friends were untrue to him because he was true to himself
    and true to them.  He lost the respect of what is called society, but
    kept his own.  His life is what the world calls failure, and what
    history calls success.
    
    If to love your fellow-men more than self is goodness, Thomas Paine was
    good.  If to be in advance of your time, to be a pioneer in the
    direction of right, is greatness, Thomas Paine was great.  If to avow
    your principles and discharge your duty in the presence of death is
    heroic, Thomas Paine was a hero.
    
    At the age of 73, death touched his tired heart.  He died in the land
    his genius defended, under the flag he gave to the skies. Slander can
    not touch him now; hatred can not reach him more. He sleeps in the
    sanctuary of the tomb, beneath the quiet of the stars.  A few more
    years, a few more brave men, a few more rays of light, and mankind will
    venerate the memory of him who said:
    
    "Any system of religion that shocks the mind of a child can not be a
    true system.  The world is my country, and to do good my religion."
    
    The next question is:  Did Thomas Paine recant?  Mr. Paine had
    prophesied that fanatics would crawl and cringe around him during his
    last moments.  He believed that they would put a lie in the mouth of
    death.  When the shadow of the coming dissolution was upon him, two
    clergymen, Messrs. Milledollar and Cunningham, called to annoy the
    dying man.  Mr. Cunningham had the politeness to say:  "You have now a
    full view of death; you can not live long; whoever does not believe in
    the Lord Jesus Christ, will assuredly be damned."  Mr. Paine replied:
    "Let me have none of your popish stuff.  Get away with you.  Good
    morning." On another occasion a Methodist minister obtruded himself.
    Mr. Willet Hicks was present.  The minister declared to Mr. Paine that
    "unless he repented of his unbelief he would be damned." Paine,
    although at the door of death, rose in his bed and indignantly
    requested the clergyman to leave the room.  On another occasion, two
    brothers by the name of Pigott sought to convert him.  He was
    displeased, and requested their departure. Afterward, Thomas Nixon and
    Capt. Daniel Pelton visited him for the express purpose of ascertaining
    whether he had, in any manner, changed his religious opinions.  They
    were assured, by the dying man that he still held the principles he had
    expressed in his writings.
    
    Afterward, these gentlemen, hearing that William Cobbet was about to
    write a life of Paine, sent him the following note:  I must tell you
    now that it is of great importance to find out whether Paine recanted.
    If he recanted, then the Bible is true--you can rest assured that a
    spring of water gushed out of a dead dry bone.  If Paine recanted,
    there is not the slightest doubt about that donkey making that speech
    to Mr. Baalam--not the slightest--and if Paine did not recant, then the
    whole thing is a mistake.  I want to show that Thomas Paine died as he
    has lived, a friend of man and without superstition, and if you will
    stay here I will do it.
    
    
    "New York, April 21, 1818.--Sir:  Having been informed that you have a
    design to write a history of the life and writings of Thomas Paine, if
    you have been furnished with materials in respect to his religious
    opinions, or rather of his recantation of his former opinions before
    his death, all you have heard of his recanting is false.  Being aware
    that such reports would be raised after his death by fanatics who
    infested his house at the time it was expected he would die, we, the
    subscribers, intimate acquaintances of Thomas Paine since the year
    1776, went to his house.  He was sitting up in a chair, and apparently
    in full vigor and use of all his mental faculties.  We interrogated him
    upon his religious opinions, and if he had changed his mind, or
    repented of anything he had said or wrote on that subject.  He
    answered, "Not at all," and appeared rather offended at our supposition
    that any change should take place in his mind.  We took down in writing
    the questions put to him and his answers thereto, before a number of
    persons then in his room, among whom were his doctor, Mrs. Bonneville,
    etc.  This paper is mislaid and can not be found at present, but the
    above is the substance, which can be attested by many living
    witnesses.--Thomas Nixon, Daniel Pelton"
    
    
    Mr. Jarvis, the artist, saw Mr. Paine one or two days before his death.
    To Mr. Jarvis he expressed his belief in his written opinions upon the
    subject of religion.  B.F. Haskin, an attorney of the City of New York,
    also visited him, and inquired as to his religious opinions.  Paine was
    then upon the threshold of death, but he did not tremble, he was not a
    coward.  He expressed his firm and unshaken belief in the religious
    ideas he had given to the world.
    
    Dr. Manly was with him when he spoke his last words.  Dr. Manly asked
    the dying man, and Dr. Manly was a Christian, if he did not wish to
    believe that Jesus was the Son of God, and the dying philosopher
    answered:  "I have no wish to believe on that subject."  Amasa
    Woodsworth sat up with Thomas Paine the night before his death.  In
    1839 Gilbert Vale, hearing that Woodsworth was living in or near
    Boston, visited him for the purpose of getting his statement, and the
    statement was published in The Beacon of June 5, 1830, and here it is:
    
    
    "We have just returned from Boston.  One object of our visit to that
    city was to see Mr. Amasa Woodsworth, an engineer, now retired in a
    handsome cottage and garden at East Cambridge, Boston.  This gentleman
    owned the house occupied by Paine at his death, while he lived next
    door.  As an act of kindness, Mr. Woodsworth visited Mr. Paine every
    day for six weeks before his death.  He frequently sat up with him and
    did so on the last two nights of his life.  He was always there with
    Dr. Manly, the physician, and assisted in removing Mr. Paine while his
    bed was prepared.  He was present when Dr. Manly asked Mr. Paine if he
    wished to believe that Jesus Christ was the Son of God.  He said that
    lying on his back he used some action and with much emphasis replied:
    'I have no wish to believe on that subject.'  He lived some time after
    this, but was not known to speak, for he died tranquilly.  He accounts
    for the insinuating style of Dr. Manly's letter by stating that that
    gentleman, just after its publication, joined a church.  He informs us
    that he has openly proved the doctor for the falsity contained in the
    spirit of that letter, boldly declaring before Dr. Manly, who is still
    living, that nothing which he saw justified the insinuations.  Mr.
    Woodsworth assures us that he neither heard nor saw anything to justify
    the belief of any mental change in the opinions of Mr. Paine previous
    to his death; but that being very ill and in pain, chiefly arising from
    the skin being removed in some parts by long lying, he was generally
    too uneasy to enjoy conversation on abstract subjects.  This, then, is
    the best evidence that can be procured on this subject, and we publish
    it while the contravening parties are yet alive, and with the authority
    of Mr. Woodsworth.--Gilbert Vale"
    
    
    A few weeks ago I received the following letter, which confirms the
    statement of Mr. Vale:
    
    
    "Near Stockton, Cal., Greenwood Cottage, July 9. 1877.--Col. Ingersoll:
    In 1812 I talked with a gentleman in Boston.  I have forgotten his
    name; but he was then an engineer of the Charleston navy yard.  I am
    thus particular so that you can find his name on the books.  He told me
    that he nursed Thomas Paine in his last illness and closed his eyes
    when dead.  I asked him if he recanted and called upon God to save him.
    He replied:  No; he died as he had taught.  He had a sore upon his
    side, and when we turned him it was very painful, and he would cry out,
    'O God!' or something like that.  'But,' said the narrator, 'that was
    nothing, for he believed in a God.'  I told him that I had often heard
    it asserted from the pulpit that Mr. Paine had recanted in his last
    moment.  The gentleman said that it was not true, and he appeared to be
    an intelligent, truthful man.  With respect, I remain, etc., Philip
    Graves, M.D."
    
    
    The next witness is Willet Hicks, a Quaker preacher.  He says that
    during the last illness of Mr. Paine he visited him almost daily, and
    that Paine died firmly convinced of the truth of the religious opinions
    that he had given to his fellow-men.  It was to this same Willet Hicks
    that Paine applied for permission to be buried in the cemetery of the
    Quakers.  Permission was refused. This refusal settles the question of
    recantation.  If he had recanted, of course there would have been no
    objection to his body being buried by the side of the best hypocrites
    in the earth.  If Paine recanted, why should he denied "a little earth
    for charity?"  Had he recanted, it would have been regarded as a vast
    and splendid triumph for the gospel.  It would, with much noise and
    pomp and ostentation, have been heralded about the world.
    
    Here is another letter:
    
    "Peoria, Ill., Oct. 8, 1877.--Robert G. Ingersoll--Esteemed Friend:  My
    parents were Friends (Quakers).  My father died when I was very young.
    The elderly and middle-aged Friends visited at my mother's house.  We
    lived in the City of New York.  Among the number I distinctly remember
    Elias Hicks, Willet Hicks, and a Mr. -- Day, who was a bookseller in
    Pearl St.  There were many others whose names I do not now remember.
    The subject of the recantation of Thomas Paine of his views about the
    Bible in his last illness, or any other time, was discussed by them in
    my presence at different times.  I learned from them that some of them
    had attended upon Thomas Paine in his last sickness, and ministered to
    his wants up to the time of his death.  And upon the question of
    whether he did recant there was but one expression.  They all said that
    he did not recant in any manner. I often heard them say they wished he
    had recanted.  In fact, according to them, the nearer he approached
    death the more positive he appeared to be in his convictions.  These
    conversations were from 1820 to 1822.  I was at that time from ten to
    twelve years old, but these conversations impressed themselves upon me
    because many thoughtless people then blamed the society of Friends for
    their kindness to that "arch-infidel," Thomas Paine.  Truly yours, A.C.
    Hankenson"
    
    
    A few days ago I received the following:
    
    
    "Albany, N.Y., Sept. 27, 1877.--Dear Sir:  It is over twenty years ago
    that, professionally, I made the acquaintance of John Hogeboom, a
    justice of the peace of the County Rensselaer, New York.  He was then
    over seventy years of age, and had the reputation of being a man of
    candor and integrity.  He was a great admirer of Paine.  He told me he
    was personally acquainted with him, and used to see him frequently
    during the last years of his life in the City of New York, where
    Hogeboom then resided.  I asked him if there was any truth in the
    charge that Paine was in the habit of getting    drunk.  He said that
    it was utterly false; that he never heard of such a thing during the
    lifetime of Mr. Paine, and did not believe anyone else did.  I asked
    him about the recantation of his religious opinions on his deathbed,
    and the revolting deathbed scenes that the world heard so much about.
    He said there was no truth in them; that he had received his
    information from persons who attended Paine in his last illness, and
    that he passed peacefully, as we may say, in the sunshine of a great
    soul.  Yours truly, W.J. Hilton"
    
    
    The witnesses by whom I substantiate the fact that Thomas Paine did not
    recant, and that he died holding the religious opinions he had
    published are:
    
    1.  Thomas Nixon, Capt. Daniel Pelton, B.F. Haskin.  These gentlemen
    visited him during his last illness for the purpose of ascertaining
    whether he had, in any respect, changed his views upon religion.  He
    told them that he had not.
    
    2.  James Cheetham.  This man was the most malicious enemy Mr. Paine
    had, and yet he admits that "Thomas Paine died placidly, and almost
    without a struggle."--Life of Thomas Paine, by James Cheetham.
    
    3.  The ministers, Milledollar and Cunningham.  These gentleman told
    Mr. Paine that if he died without believing in the Lord Jesus Christ,
    he would be damned, and Paine replied:  "Let me have none of your
    popish stuff.  Good morning."--Sherwin's Life of Paine, page 220.
    
    4.  Mrs. Hedden.  She told these same preachers, when they attempted to
    obtrude themselves upon Mr. Paine again, that the attempt to convert
    Mr. Paine was useless; "that if God did not change his mind, no human
    power could."
    
    5.  Andrew A. Dean.  This man lived upon Paine's farm, at New Rochelle,
    and corresponded with him upon religious subjects.--Paine's Theological
    Works, page 308.
    
    6.  Mr. Jarvis, the artist with whom Paine lived.  He gives an account
    of an old lady coming to Paine, and telling him that God Almighty had
    sent her to tell him that unless he repented and believed in the
    blessed savior he would be damned.  Paine replied that God would not
    send such a foolish old woman with such an impertinent message.--Clio
    Rickman's Life of Paine.
    
    7.  William Carver, with whom Paine boarded.  Mr. Carver said again and
    again that Paine did not recant.  He knew him well, and had every
    opportunity of knowing.--Life of Paine, by Vale.
    
    8.  Dr. Manly, who attended him in his last sickness, and to whom Paine
    spoke his last words.  Dr. Manly asked him if he did not wish to
    believe in Jesus Christ. and he replied:  "I have no wish to believe on
    that subject."
    
    9.  Willet Hicks and Elias Hicks, who were with him frequently during
    his last sickness, and both of whom tried to persuade him to recant.
    According to their testimony Mr. Paine died as he lived--a believer in
    God and a friend to man.  Willet Hicks was offered money to say
    something false against Paine.  He was even offered money to remain
    silent, and allow others to slander the dead.  Mr. Hicks, speaking of
    Thomas Paine, said:  "He was a good man.  Thomas Paine was an honest
    man."
    
    10.  Amasa Woodsworth, who was with him every day for some six weeks
    immediately preceding his death, and sat up with him the last two
    nights of his life.  This man declares that Paine did not recant, and
    that he died tranquilly.  The evidence of Mr. Woodsworth is conclusive.
    
    11.  Thomas Paine himself.  The will of Mr. Paine, written by himself,
    commences as follows:  "The last will and testament of me, the
    subscriber, Thomas Paine, reposing confidence in my Creator, God, and
    in no other being, for I know of no other, nor believe in any other,"
    and closes with these words:  "I have lived an honest and useful life
    to mankind.  My time has been spent in doing good, and I die in perfect
    composure and resignation to the will of my Creator, God."
    
    12.  If Thomas Paine recanted, why do you pursue him?  If he recanted
    he died in your belief.  For what reason, then, do you denounce his
    death as cowardly?  If upon his death-bed he renounced the opinions he
    had published, the business of defaming him should be done by infidels,
    not by Christians.  I ask Christians if it is honest to throw away the
    testimony of his friends, the evidence of fair and honorable men, and
    take the putrid words of avowed and malignant enemies?  When Thomas
    Paine was dying he was infested by fanatics, by the snaky spies of
    bigotry.  In the shadows of death were the unclean birds of prey
    waiting to tear, with beak and claw, the corpse of him who wrote the
    "Rights of Man," and there lurking and crouching in the darkness, were
    the jackals and hyenas of superstition, ready to violate his grave.
    These birds of prey--these unclean beasts--are the witnesses produced
    and relied upon to malign the memory of Thomas Paine.  One by one the
    instruments of torture have been wrenched from the cruel clutch of the
    church, until within the armory of orthodoxy there remains but one
    weapon--Slander.
    
    Against the witnesses that I have produced there can be brought just
    two--Mary Roscoe and Mary Hinsdale.  The first is referred to in the
    memoir of Stephen Grellet.  She had once been a servant in his house.
    Grellet tells what happened between this girl and Paine.  According to
    this account, Paine asked her if she had ever read any of his writings,
    and on being told that she had read very little of them, he inquired
    what she thought of them, adding that from such an one as she he
    expected a correct answer.
    
    Let us examine this falsehood.  Why would Paine expect a correct answer
    about his writings from one who read very little of them? Does not such
    a statement devour itself?  This young lady further said that the "Age
    of Reason" was put in her hands, and that the more she read in it, the
    more dark and distressed she felt, and that she threw the book into the
    fire.  Whereupon Mr. Paine remarked:  "I wish all had done as you did,
    for if the devil ever had any agency in any work, he had in my writing
    that book."
    
    The next is Mary Hinsdale.  She was a servant in the family of Willet
    Hicks.  The church is always proving something by a nurse. She, like
    Mary Roscoe, was sent to carry some delicacy to Mr. Paine.  To this
    young lady Paine, according to his account, said precisely the same
    that he did to Mary Roscoe, and she said the same thing to Mr. Paine.
    
    My own opinion is that Mary Roscoe and Mary Hinsdale are one and the
    same person, or the same story has been, by mistake, put in the mouths
    of both.  It is not possible that the identical conversation should
    have taken place between Paine and Mary Roscoe and between him and Mary
    Hinsdale.  Mary Hinsdale lived with Willet Hicks, and he pronounced her
    story a pious fraud and fabrication.
    
    Another thing about this witness.  A woman by the name of Mary
    Lockwood, a Hicksite Quaker, died.  Mary Hinsdale met her brother about
    that time and told him that his sister had recanted, and wanted her to
    say so at her funeral.  This turned out to be a lie.
    
    It has been claimed that Mary Hinsdale made her statement to Charles
    Collins.  Long after the alleged occurrence Gilbert Vale, one of the
    biographers of Paine, had a conversation with Collins concerning Mary
    Hinsdale.  Vale asked him what he thought of her. He replied that some
    of the Friends believed that she used opiates, and that they did not
    give credit to her statements.  He also said that he believed what the
    Friends said, but thought that when a young Roman she might have told
    the truth.
    
    In 1818 William Cobbett came to New York.  He began collecting material
    for a life of Thomas Paine.  In this way he became acquainted with Mary
    Hinsdale and Charles Collins.  Mr. Cobbett gave a full account of what
    happened in a letter addressed to The Norwich Mercury in 1819.  From
    this account it seems that Charles Collins told Cobbett that Paine had
    recanted.  Cobbett called for the testimony, and told Mr. Collins that
    he must give time, place, and circumstances.  He finally brought a
    statement that he stated had been made by Mary Hinsdale.  Armed with
    this document, Cobbett, in October of that year, called upon the said
    Mary Hinsdale, at No. 10 Anthony Street, New York, and showed her the
    statement.  Upon being questioned by Mr. Cobbett she said that it was
    so long ago that she could not speak positively to any part of the
    matter; that she would not say that any part of the paper was true;
    that she had never seen the paper, and that she had never given Charles
    Collins authority to say anything about the matter in her name.  And so
    in the month of October, in the year of grace 1818, in the mist of fog
    and forgetfulness, disappeared forever one Mary Hinsdale, the last and
    only witness against the intellectual honesty of Thomas Paine.
    
    A letter was written to the editor of The New York World by the Rev.
    A.W. Cornell, in which he says:
    
    
    "Sir: I see by your paper that Bob Ingersoll discredits Mary Hinsdale's
    story of the scenes which occurred at the death bed of Thomas Paine.
    No one who knew that good old lady would for one moment doubt her
    veracity, or question her testimony.  Both she and her husband were
    Quaker preachers, and well known and respected inhabitants of New York
    City.
    
    "Ingersoll is right in his conjecture that Mary Roscoe and Mary
    Hinsdale were the same person.  Her maiden name was Roscoe and she
    married Henry Hinsdale.  My mother was a Roscoe, a niece of Mary
    Roscoe, and lived with her for some time.--Rev. A.W. Cornell,
    Harpersville, N.Y."
    
    
    The editor of the New York Observer took up the challenge that I had
    thrown down.  I offered $1000 in gold to any minister who would prove,
    or to any person who would prove that Thomas Paine recanted in his last
    hours.  The New York Observer accepted the wager, and then told a
    falsehood about it.  But I kept after the gentlemen until I forced
    them, in their paper, published on the 1st of November, 1877; to print
    these words:
    
    
    "We have never stated in any form, nor have we ever supposed, that
    Paine actually renounced his infidelity.  The accounts agree in stating
    that he died a blaspheming infidel."
    
    
    This, I hope, for all coming time will refute the slanders of the
    churches yet to be.
    
    The next charge they make is that Thomas Paine died in destitution and
    want.  That, of course, would show that he was wrong.  They boast that
    the founder of their religion had not whereon to lay his head, but when
    they found a man who stood for the rights of man, when they say that he
    did, that is an evidence that this doctrine was a lie.  Won't do!  Did
    Thomas Paine die in destitution and want?  The charge has been made
    over and over again that Thomas Paine died in want and destitution;
    that he was an abandoned pauper--an outcast, without friends and
    without money. This charge is just as false as the  rest.  Upon his
    return to this country, in 1802, he was worth $30,000, according to his
    own statement, made at that time in the following letter, and addressed
    to Clio Rickman:
    
    
    "My dear friend, Mr. Monroe, who is appointed minister extraordinary to
    France, takes charge of this, to be delivered to Mr. Este, banker, in
    Paris, to be forwarded to you.
    
    "I arrived in Baltimore, 30th of October, and you can have no idea of
    the agitation which my arrival occasioned.  From New Hampshire to
    Georgia (an extent of 1,500 miles), every newspaper was filled with
    applause or abuse.
    
    "My property in this country has been taken care of by my friends, and
    is now worth six thousand pounds sterling, which, put in the funds,
    will bring about L400 sterling a year.
    
    "Remember me in affection and friendship to your wife and family, and
    in the circle of your friends.--Thomas Paine"
    
    
    A man in those days worth $30,000 was not a pauper.  That amount would
    bring an income of at least $2,000.  Two thousand dollars then would be
    fully equal to $5,000 now.  On the 12th of July, 1809, the year in
    which he died, Mr. Paine made his will.  From this instrument we learn
    that he was the owner of a valuable farm within twenty miles of New
    York.  He was also owner of thirty shares in the New York Phoenix
    Insurance Company, worth upward of $1,500.  Besides this, some personal
    property and ready money. By his will he gave to Walter Morton and
    Thomas Addis Emmet, a brother of Robert Emmet, $200 each, and $100 to
    the widow of Elihu Palmer.  Is it possible that this will was made by a
    pauper, by a destitute outcast, by a man who suffered for the ordinary
    necessities of life?
    
    But suppose, for the sake of argument, that he was poor, and that he
    died a beggar, does that tend to show that the Bible is an inspired
    book, and that Calvin did not burn Servetus?  Do you really regard
    poverty as a crime?  If Paine had died a millionaire, would Christians
    have accepted his religious opinions?  If Paine had drank nothing but
    cold water, would Christians have repudiated the five cardinal points
    of Calvinism? Does an argument depend for its force upon the pecuniary
    condition of the person making it?  As a matter of fact, most
    reformers--most men and women of genius--have been acquainted with
    poverty. Beneath a covering of rags have been found some of the
    tenderest and bravest hearts.  Owing to the attitude of the churches
    for the last fifteen hundred years, truth telling has not been a very
    lucrative business.  As a rule, hypocrisy has worn the robes, and
    honesty the rags.  That day is passing away. You can not now answer a
    man by pointing at the holes in his coat.  Thomas Paine attacked the
    church when it was powerful; when it had what is called honors to
    bestow; when it was the keeper of the public conscience; when it was
    strong and cruel. The church waited till he was dead, and then attacked
    his reputation and his clothes.  Once upon a time a donkey kicked a
    lion. The lion was dead.  You just don't know how happy I am tonight
    that justice so long delayed at last is going to be done, and to see so
    many splendid looking people come here out of deference to the memory
    of Thomas Paine.  I am glad to be here.
    
    The next thing is:  Did Thomas Paine live the life of a drunken beast,
    and did he die a drunken, cowardly, and beastly death? Well, we will
    see.  Upon you rests the burden of substantiating these infamous
    charges.  The Christians have, I suppose, produced the best evidence in
    their possession, and that evidence I will now proceed to examine.
    Their first witness is Grant Thorburn. He made three charges against
    Thomas Paine:
    
    1.  That his wife obtained a divorce from him in England for cruelty
    and neglect.
    
    2.  That he was a defaulter and fled from England to America.
    
    3. That he was a drunkard.
    
    These three charges stand upon the same evidence--the word of Grant
    Thorburn.  If they are not all true, Mr. Thorburn stands impeached.
    The charge that Mrs. Paine obtained a divorce on account of the cruelty
    and neglect of her husband is utterly false.  There is no such record
    in the world, and never was. Paine and his wife separated by mutual
    consent. Each respected the other.  They remained friends.  This charge
    is without any foundation.  In fact, I challenge the Christian world to
    produce the record of this decree of divorce.  According to Mr.
    Thorburn, it was granted in England.  In that country public records
    are kept of all such decrees.  I will give $1,000 if they will produce
    a decree, showing that it was given on account of cruelty, or admit
    that Mr. Thorburn was mistaken.
    
    Thomas Paine was a just man.  Although separated from his wife, he
    always spoke of her with tenderness and respect, and frequently lent
    her money without letting her know the source from whence it came.  Was
    this the conduct of a drunken beast?
    
    The next is that he was a defaulter, and fled from England to America.
    As I told you in the first place, he was an exciseman; if he was a
    defaulter, that fact is upon the records of Great Britain.  I will give
    $1,000 in gold to any man who will show, by the records of England,
    that he was a defaulter of a single, solitary cent.  Let us bring these
    gentlemen to Limerick.
    
    And they charge that he was a drunkard.  That is another falsehood.  He
    drank liquor in his day, as did the preachers.  It was no unusual thing
    for a preacher going home to stop in a tavern and take a drink of hot
    rum with a deacon, and it was no unusual thing for the deacon to help
    the preacher home.  You have no idea how they loved the sacrament in
    those days.  They had communion pretty much all the time.
    
    Thorburn says that in 1802 Paine was an "old remnant of mortality,
    drunk, bloated, and half asleep."  Can anyone believe this to be a true
    account of the personal appearance of Mr. Paine in 1802?  He had just
    returned from France.  He had been welcomed home by Thomas Jefferson,
    who had said that he was entitled to the hospitality of every American.
    In 1802 Mr. Paine was honored with a public dinner in the City of New
    York.  He was called upon and treated with kindness and respect by such
    men as De Witt Clinton.  In 1806 Mr. Paine wrote a letter to Andrew A.
    Dean upon the subject of religion.  Read that letter and then say that
    the writer of it was an old remnant of mortality, drunk, bloated, and
    half asleep.  Search the files of Christian papers, from the first
    issue to the last, and you will find nothing superior to this letter.
    In 1803 Mr. Paine wrote a letter of considerable length, and of great
    force to his friend Samuel Adams.  Such letters are not written by
    drunken beasts, nor by remnants of old mortality, nor by drunkards.  It
    was about the same time that he wrote his "Remarks on Robert Hall's
    Sermons."  These "Remarks" were not written by a drunken beast, but by
    a clear-headed and thoughtful man.
    
    In 1804 he published an essay on the invasion of England and a treatise
    on gun-boats, full of valuable maritime information; in 1805 a treatise
    on yellow fever, suggesting modes of prevention. In short, he was an
    industrious and thoughtful man.  He sympathized with the poor and
    oppressed of all lands.  He looked upon monarchy as a species of
    physical slavery.  He had the goodness to attack that form of
    government.  He regarded the religion of his day as a kind of mental
    slavery.  He had the courage to give his reasons for his opinion.  His
    reasons filled the churches with hatred.  Instead of answering his
    arguments they attacked him.  Men who were not fit to blacken his shoes
    blackened his character.  There is too much religious cant in the
    statement of Mr. Thorburn.  He exhibits too much anxiety to tell what
    Grant Thorburn said to Thomas Paine.  He names Thomas Jefferson as one
    of the disreputable men who welcomed Paine with open arms.  The
    testimony of a man who regarded Thomas Jefferson as a disreputable
    person, as to the character of anybody, is utterly without value.
    
    Now, Grant Thorburn--this gentleman who was "four feet and a half high,
    and who weighed ninety-eight pounds three and one-half ounces"--says
    that he used to sit nights at Carver's, in New York, with Thomas Paine.
    Mrs. Ferguson, the daughter of William Carver, says that she knew
    Thorburn when she saw him, but that she never saw him in her father's
    house.  The denial of Mrs. Ferguson enraged Thorburn, and he at once
    wrote a few falsehoods about her.  Thereupon a suit was commenced by
    Mrs. Ferguson and her husband against Thorburn, the writer, and
    Fanshaw, the publisher, of the libel.  Thorburn ran away to
    Connecticut. Fanshaw wrote him for evidence of what he had written.
    Thorburn replied that what he had written about Mrs. Ferguson could not
    be proved.  Fanshaw then settled with the Fergusons, paying them the
    amount demanded.
    
    In 1859 the Fergusons lived at 148 Duane Street, New York.  In The
    Commercial Advertiser of New York, in 1830, appeared the written
    acknowledgement of this same little Grant Thorburn that he did, on the
    22d of August, 1830, at half-past 6 in the morning, take four bottles
    of cider from the cellar of Mr. Comstock.
    
    Mr. Comstock says that Thorburn was arrested, and that when brought
    before him he pleaded guilty and threw himself upon his (Comstock's)
    mercy.
    
    The Philadelphia Tract Society gave Thorburn $100 to write his
    recollections of Thomas Paine.
    
    Let us dispose of this four feet and a half of wretch.  In October,
    1877, I received the following letter from James Parton:
    
    
    "Newburyport, Mass., Oct 27, 1877.--My dear Sir:  Touching Grant
    Thorburn, I personally knew him to have been a liar.  At the age of 92
    he copied with trembling hand a piece from a newspaper and brought it
    to the office of The Rome Journal as his own.  It was I who received it
    and detected the deliberate forgery..... James Parton"
    
    
    So much for Grant Thorburn.  In my judgment, the testimony of Mr.
    Thorburn should be thrown aside as utterly unworthy of belief.
    
    The next witness is the Rev. J.D. Wickham, D.D., who tells what an
    elder in his church said.  This elder said that Paine passed his last
    days on his farm at New Rochelle, with a solitary female attendant.
    This is not true.  He did not pass his last days at New Rochelle,
    consequently, this pious elder did not see him during his last days at
    that place.  Upon this elder we prove an alibi.  Mr. Paine passed his
    last days in the City of New York, in a house upon Columbia Street.
    The story of the Rev. J.D. Wickham, D.D., is simply false.
    
    The next competent false witness was the Rev. Charles Hawley, D.D., who
    proceeds to state that the story of the Rev. J.D. Wickham, D. D., is
    corroborated by older citizens of New Rochelle.  The names of these
    ancient residents are withheld. According to these unknown witnesses,
    the account given by the deceased elder was entirely correct.  But as
    the particulars of Mr. Paine's conduct "were too loathsome to be
    described in print," we are left entirely in the dark as to what he
    really did.
    
    While at New Rochelle, Mr. Paine lived with Mr. Purdy, Mr. Dean, with
    Capt. Pelton, and with Mr. Staple.  It is worthy of note that all of
    these gentlemen give the lie direct to the statements of "older
    residents" and ancient citizens spoken of by the Rev. Charles Hawley,
    D.D., and leave him with the "loathsome particulars" existing only in
    his own mind.
    
    The next gentleman brought upon the stand is W.H. Ladd, who quotes from
    the memoirs of Stephen Grellett.  This gentleman also has the
    misfortune to be dead.  According to his account, Mr. Paige made his
    recantation to a servant girl of his by the name of Mary Roscoe.  Mr.
    Paine uttered the wish that all who read his book had burned it.  I
    believe there is a mistake in the name of this girl.  Her name was
    probably Mary Hinsdale, as it was once claimed that Paine made the same
    remark to her.
    
    These are the witnesses of the church, and the only ones you bring
    forward to support your charge that Thomas Paine lived a drunken and
    beastly life, and died a drunken, cowardly, and beastly death.  All
    these calumnies are found in a life of Paine by James Cheetham, the
    convicted libeler already referred to. Mr. Cheetham was an enemy of the
    man whose life he pretended to write.  In order to show you the
    estimation in which this libeler was held by Mr. Paine, I will give you
    a copy of a letter that throws light upon this point:
    
    
    "Oct. 27, 1807.--Mr. Cheethan:  Unless you make a public apology for
    the abuse and falsehood in your paper of Tuesday, Oct. 27, respecting
    me, I will prosecute you for lying.--Thomas Paine"
    
    
    In another letter, speaking of this same man, Mr. Paine says: "If an
    unprincipled bully can not be reformed, he can be punished."  Cheetham
    has been so long in the habit of giving false information, that truth
    is to him like a foreign language. Mr. Cheetham wrote the life of Mr.
    Paine to gratify his malice and to support religion.  He was prosecuted
    for libel--was convicted and fined.  Yet the life of Paine, written by
    this liar, is referred to by the Christian world as the highest
    authority.
    
    As to the personal habits of Mr. Paine, we have the testimony of
    William Carver; with whom he lived; of Mr. Jarvis, the artist, with
    whom he lived; of Mr. Purdy, who was a tenant of Paine's; of Mr. Buyer,
    with whom he was intimate; of Thomas Nixon and Capt. Daniel Pelton,
    both of whom knew him well; of Amasa Woodsworth, who was with him when
    he died; of John Fellows, who boarded at the same house; of James
    Wilburn, with whom he boarded; of B.F. Haskins, a lawyer, who was well
    acquainted with him, and called upon him during h is last illness; of
    Walter Morton, President of the Phoenix Insurance Company; of Clio
    Rickman, who had known him for many years; of Willet and Elias Hicks,
    Quakers, who knew him intimately and well; of Judge Hertell, H.
    Margary, Elihu Palmer and many others.  All these testified to the fact
    that Mr. Paige was a temperate man.  In those days nearly everybody
    used spirituous liquors.  Paine was not an exception, but he did not
    drink to excess. Mr. Lovett, who kept the City Hotel, where Paine
    stopped, in a note to Caleb Bingham declared that Paine drank less than
    any boarder he had.
    
    Against all this evidence Christians produce the story of Grant
    Thorburn, the story of the Rev. J.D. Wickham, that an elder in his
    church told him that Paine was a drunkard, corroborated by the Rev.
    Charles Hawley, and an extract from Lossing's history to the same
    effect.  The evidence is overwhelmingly against them. Will you have the
    fairness to admit it?  Their witnesses are merely the repeaters of the
    falsehoods of James Cheetham, the convicted libeler.
    
    After all, drinking is not as bad as lying.  An honest drunkard is
    better than a calumniator of the dead.  "A remnant of old mortality
    drunk, bloated, and half-asleep," is better than a perfectly sober
    defender of human slavery.  To become drunk is a virtue compared with
    stealing a babe from the breast of its mother.  Drunkenness is one of
    the beatitudes, compared with editing a religious paper devoted to the
    defense of slavery upon the ground that it is a divine institution.  Do
    you think that Paine was a drunken beast when he wrote "Common Sense,"
    a pamphlet that aroused three millions of people, as people were never
    aroused by words before?  Was he a drunken beast when he wrote the
    "Crisis?"  Was it to a drunken beast that the following letter was
    addressed:
    
    
    "Rocky Hill, September 10, 1783.--I have learned, since I have been at
    this place, that you are at Bordentown.  Whether for the sake of
    retirement or economy, I know not.  Be it for either, or both, or
    whatever it may, if you will come to this place and partake with me, I
    shall be exceedingly happy to see you at it. Your presence may remind
    Congress of your past services to this country; and if it is in my
    power to impress them, command my best exertions with freedom, as they
    will be rendered cheerfully by one who entertains a lively sense of the
    importance of your works, and who, with much pleasure, subscribes
    himself your sincere friend.--George Washington"
    
    
    Do you think that Paine was a drunken beast when the following letters
    were received by him:
    
    
    "You express a wish in your letter to return to America in a national
    ship.  Mr. Dawson, who brings over the treaty, and who will present you
    with this letter, is charged with orders to the Captain of the Maryland
    to receive and accommodate you back, if you can be ready to depart at
    such a short warning.  You will, in general, find us returned to
    sentiments worthy of former times; in these it will be your glory to
    have steadily labored, and with as much effect as any man living.  That
    you may live long to continue your useful labors, and reap the reward
    in the thankfulness of nations, is my sincere prayer.  Accept the
    assurances of my high esteem and affectionate attachment.--Thomas
    Jefferson"
    
    
    "It has been very generally propagated through the continent that I
    wrote the pamphlet "Common Sense."  I could not have written anything
    in so manly and striking a style.--John Adams"
    
    
    "A few more such flaming arguments as were exhibited at Falmouth and
    Norfolk, added to the sound doctrine and unanswerable reasoning
    contained in the pamphlet "Common Sense," will not leave numbers at a
    loss to decide on the propriety of a separation.--George Washington"
    
    
    "It is not necessary for me to tell you how much all your countrymen--I
    speak of the great mass of the people--are interested in your welfare.
    They have not forgotten the history of their own revolution, and the
    difficult scenes through which they passed; nor do they review its
    several stages without reviving in their bosoms a due sensibility of
    the merits of those who served them in that great and arduous conflict.
    The crime of ingratitude has not yet stained, and I trust never will
    stain, our national character.  You are considered by them as not only
    having rendered important services in our revolution, but as being on a
    more extensive scale the friend of human right and a distinguished and
    able advocate in favor of public liberty.  To the welfare of Thomas
    Paine, the Americans are not, nor can they be, indifferent.--James
    Monroe"
    
    
    "No writer has exceeded Paine in ease and familiarity of style, in
    perspicuity of expression, happiness of elucidation, and in simple and
    unassuming language.--Thomas Jefferson"
    
    
    Was it in consideration of the services of a drunken beast that the
    Legislature of Pennsylvania presented Thomas Paine with L500 sterling?
    Did the State of New York feel indebted to a drunken beast, and confer
    upon Thomas Paine an estate of several hundred acres?  Did the Congress
    of the United States thank him for his services because he had lived a
    drunken and beastly life?  Was he elected a member of the French
    convention because he was a drunken beast?  Was it the act of a drunken
    beast to put his own life in jeopardy by voting against the death of
    the King?  Was it because he was a drunken beast that he opposed the
    "Reign of Terror "--that he endeavored to stop the shedding of blood,
    and did all in his power to protect even his own enemies?  Do the
    following extracts sound like the words of a drunken beast:
    
    
    "I believe in the equality of man, and I believe that religious duties
    consist in doing justice, loving mercy, and endeavoring to make our
    fellow creatures happy.
    
    "My own mind is my own church.
    
    "It is necessary to the happiness of man that he be mentally faithful
    to himself.
    
    "Any system of religion that shocks the mind of a child can not be a
    true system.
    
    "The work of God is the creation which we behold.
    
    "The age of ignorance commenced with the Christian system.
    
    "It is with a pious fraud as with a bad action--it begets a calamitous
    necessity of going on.
    
    "To read the Bible without horror, we must undo everything that is
    tender, sympathizing, and benevolent in the heart of man.
    
    "The man does not exist who can say I have persecuted him, or that I
    have, in any case, returned evil for evil.
    
    "Of all the tyrants that afflict mankind, tyranny in religion is the
    worst.
    
    "The belief in a cruel God makes a cruel man.
    
    "My own opinion is, that those whose lives have been spent in doing
    good, and endeavoring to make their fellow-mortals happy, will be happy
    hereafter.
    
    "The intellectual part of religion is a private affair between every
    man and his Maker, and in which no third party has any right to
    interfere. The practical part consists in our doing good to each other.
    
    "No man ought to make a living by religion.  One person can not act
    religion for another--every person must act for himself.
    
    "One good school-master is of more use than a hundred priests. Let us
    propagate morality, unfettered by superstition.
    
    "God is the power, or first cause; nature is the law, and matter is the
    subject acted upon.
    
    "I believe in one God and no more, and I hope for happiness beyond this
    life.
    
    "The key of happiness is not in the keeping of any sect, nor ought the
    road to it to be obstructed by any.
    
    "My religion, and the whole of it, is the fear and love of the Deity,
    and universal philanthropy.
    
    "I have yet, I believe, some years in store, for I have a good state of
    health and a happy mind.  I take care of both, by nourishing the first
    with temperance and the latter with abundance.
    
    "He lives immured within the Bastille of a word."
    
    
    How perfectly that sentence describes the orthodox.  The Bastille in
    which they are immured is the word "Calvinism."
    
    "Man has no property in man."
    
    "The world is my country, to do good my religion."
    
    I ask again whether these splendid utterances came from the lips of a
    drunken beast?
    
    "Man has no property in man."
    
    What a splendid motto that would make for the religious newspapers of
    this country thirty years ago.  I ask, again, whether these splendid
    utterances came from the lips of a drunken beast?
    
    Only a little while ago--two or three days--I read a report of an
    address made by Bishop Doane, an Episcopal Bishop in apostolic
    succession--regular line from Jesus Christ down to Bishop Doane. The
    Bishop was making a speech to young preachers--the sprouts, the
    theological buds.  He took it upon him to advise them all against early
    marriages.  Let us look at it.  Do you believe there is any duty that
    man owes to God that will prevent a man marrying the woman he loves?
    Is there some duty that I owe to the clouds that will prevent me from
    marrying some good, sweet woman?  Now, just think of that!  I tell you,
    young man, you marry as soon as you can find her and support her.  I
    had rather have one woman that I know than any amount of gods that I am
    not acquainted with.  If there is any revelation from God to man, a
    good woman is the best revelation he has ever made; and I will admit
    that that revelation was inspired.
    
    Now, on the subject of marriage, let me offset the speech of Bishop
    Doane by a word from this "wretched infidel:"
    
    
    "Though I appear a sorry wanderer, the marriage state has not a
    sincerer friend than I.  It is the harbor of human life, and is, with
    respect to the things of this world, what the next world is to this.
    It is home, and that one word conveys more than any other word can
    express.  For a few years we may glide along the tide of a single life,
    but it is a tide that flows but once, and, what is still worse, it ebbs
    faster than it flows, and leaves many a hapless voyager aground.  I am
    one, you see, that has experienced the fall I am describing.  I have
    lost my tide; it passed by while every throb of my heart was on the
    wing for the salvation of America, and I have now, as contentedly as I
    can, made myself a little tower of walls on that shore that has the
    solitary resemblance of home."
    
    
    I just want you to know what this dreadful infidel thought of home.  I
    just wanted you to know what Thomas Paine thought of home.  Then here
    is another letter that Thomas Paine wrote to congress on the 21st day
    of January, 1808, and I wanted you to know those two.
    
    It is only a short one:
    
    
    "To the Honorable Senate of the United States:  The purport of this
    address is to state a claim I feel myself entitled to make on the
    United States, leaving it to their representatives in congress to
    decide on its worth and its merits.  The case is as follows:
    
    "Toward the latter end of the year 1780 the continental money had
    become depreciated--the paper dollar being then not more than a
    cent--that it seemed next to impossible to continue the war.  As the
    United States was then in alliance with France it became necessary to
    make France acquainted with our real situation.  I therefore drew up a
    letter to the Count De Vergennes, stating undisguisedly the whole case,
    and concluding with a request whether France could not, either as a
    subsidy of a loan, supply the United States with a million pounds
    sterling, and continue that supply, annually, during the war.  "I
    showed this letter to Mr. Morbois, secretary of the French minister.
    His remark upon it was that a million sent out of the nation exhausted
    it more than ten millions spent in it.  I then showed it to Mr. Ralph
    Izard, member of congress from South Carolina.  He borrowed the letter
    of me and said:  'We will endeavor to do something about it in
    congress.'  Accordingly, congress then appointed John A. Laurens to go
    to France and make representation for the purpose of obtaining
    assistance.  Col. Laurens wished to decline the mission, and asked that
    congress would appoint Col. Hamilton, who did not choose to do it.
    Col. Laurens then came and stated the case to me, and said that he was
    well enough acquainted with the military difficulties of the army, but
    he was not acquainted with political affairs, or with the resources of
    the country, to undertake such a mission.  Said he, 'If you will go
    with me I will accept the mission.' This I agreed to do, and did do.
    We sailed from Boston in the Alliance frigate February, 1781, and
    arrived in France in the beginning of March. The aid obtained from
    France was six millions of livres, as at present, and ten millions as a
    loan, borrowed in Holland on the security of France.  We sailed from
    Brest in the French frigate Resolue the 1st of June, and arrived at
    Boston on the 25th of August, bringing with us two millions and a half
    in silver, and conveying a chip and a brig laden with clothing and
    military stores.
    
    "The money was transported with sixteen ox teams to the National bank
    at Philadelphia, which enabled our army to move to Yorktown to attack
    in conjunction with the French army under Rochambeau, the British army
    under Cornwallis.
    
    "As I never had a single cent for these services, I felt myself
    entitled, as the country is now in a state of prosperity, to state the
    case to congress.
    
    "As to my political works, beginning with the pamphlet 'Common Sense,'
    published the beginning of January 1776, which awakened America to a
    declaration of independence as the president and vice-president both
    know, as they were works done from principle I can not dishonor that
    principle by ever asking any reward for them.  The country has been
    benefited by them, and I make myself happy in the knowledge of that
    benefit.  It is, however, proper for me to add that the mere
    independence of America, were it to have been followed by a system of
    government modeled after the corrupt system of the English government,
    would not have interested me with the unabated ardor it did.  It was to
    bring forward and establish a representative system of government.  As
    the work itself will show, that was the leading principle with me in
    writing that work, and all my other works during the progress of the
    revolution, and I followed the same principle in writing in English the
    'Rights of Man.'
    
    "After the failure of the 5 percent duty recommended by congress to pay
    the interest of the loan to be borrowed in Holland, I wrote to
    Chancellor Livingston, then minister for foreign affairs, and Robert
    Morris, minister of finance, and proposed a method for getting over the
    difficulty at once, which was by adding a continental legislature which
    should be empowered to make laws for the whole union instead of
    recommending them. So the method proposed met with their future
    probation.  I held myself in reserve to take a step up whenever a
    direct occasion occurred.
    
    "In a conversation afterward with Gov. Clinton, of New York, now
    vice-president, it was judged that for the purpose of my going fully
    into the subject, and to prevent any misconstruction of my motive or
    object, it would be best that I received nothing from congress, but to
    leave it to the states individually to make the what acknowledgement
    they pleased. The State of New York presented me with a farm which
    since my return to America, I have found it necessary to sell, and the
    State of Pennsylvania voted me L500 of their currency, but none of the
    states to the east of New York, or the south of Pennsylvania, have made
    me the least acknowledgment.  They had received benefits from me which
    they accepted, and there the matter ended.  This story will not tell
    well in history.  All the civilized world knows I have been of great
    service to the United States, and have generously given away that which
    would easily have made me a fortune.  I much question if an instance is
    to be found in ancient or modern times of a man who had no personal
    interest in the case to take up that of the establishment of a
    representative government and who sought neither place nor office after
    it was established; that pursued the same undeviating principles that I
    had for more than thirty years, and that in spite of dangers,
    difficulties, and inconveniences of which I have had my share.--Thomas
    Paine"
    
    
    An old man in Pennsylvania told me once that his father hired a old
    revolutionary soldier by the name of Thomas Martin to work for him.
    Martin was then quite an old man; and there was an old Presbyterian
    preacher used to come there, by the name of Crawford, and he sat down
    by the fire and he got to talking one night, among other things about
    Thomas Paine--what a wretched, infamous dog he was; and while he was in
    the midst of this conversation the old soldier rose from the fireplace,
    and he walked over to the preacher, and he said to him "Did you ever
    see Thomas Paine?"  "No."  "Well," he says, "I have; I saw him at
    Valley Forge.  I heard read at the head of every regiment and company
    the letters of Thomas Paine.  I heard them read the 'Crisis,' and I saw
    Thomas Paine writing on the head of a drum, sitting at the bivouac
    fire, those simple words that inspired every patriot's bosom, and I
    want to tell you Mr. Preacher, that Thomas Paine did more for liberty
    than any priest that ever lived in this world."
    
    "And yet they say he was afraid to die!  Afraid of what?  Is there any
    God in heaven that hates a patriot?  If there is Thomas Paine ought to
    be afraid to die.  Is there any God that would damn a man for helping
    to free three millions of people?  If Thomas Paine was in hell tonight,
    and could get God's attention long enough to point him to the old
    banner of the stars floating over America, God would have to let him
    out.  What would he be afraid of?  Had he ever burned anybody?  No.
    Had he ever put anybody in the inquisition?  No.  Ever put the
    thumb-screw on anybody?  No.  Ever put anybody in prison so that some
    poor wife and mother would come and hold her little babe up at the
    grated window that the man bound to the floor might get one glimpse of
    his blue-eyed babe? Did he ever do that?"
    
    "Did he ever light a fagot?  Did he ever tear human flesh?  Why, what
    had he to be afraid of?  He had helped to make the world free.  He had
    helped create the only republic then on the earth. What was he afraid
    of?  Was God a tory?  It won't do."
    
    One would think from the persistence with which the orthodox have
    charged for the last seventy years that Thomas Paine recanted, that
    there must be some evidence of some kind to support these charges.
    Even with my ideas of the average honor of the believers in
    superstition, the average truthfulness of the disciples of fear, I did
    not believe that all those infamies rested solely upon poorly-attested
    falsehoods.  I had charity enough to suppose that something had been
    said or done by Thomas Paine capable of being tortured into a
    foundation of all these calumnies.  What crime had Thomas Paine
    committed that he should have feared to die?  The only answer you can
    give is that he denied the inspiration of the scriptures.  If that is
    crime, the civilized world is filled with criminals.  The pioneers of
    human thought, the intellectual leaders of this world, the foremost men
    in every science, the kings of literature and art, those who stand in
    the front of investigation, the men who are civilizing and elevating
    and refining mankind, are all unbelievers in the ignorant dogma of
    inspiration.
    
    Why should we think Thomas Paine was afraid to die? and why should the
    American people malign the memory of that great man? He was the first
    to advocate the separation from the mother country.  He was the first
    to write these words:  "The United States of America."  Think of
    maligning that man!  He was the first to lift his voice against human
    slavery, and while hundreds and thousands of ministers all over the
    United States not only believed in slavery, but bought and sold women
    and babes in the name of Jesus Christ, this infidel, this wretch who is
    now burning in the flames of hell, lifted his voice against human
    slavery and said: "It is robbery, and a slaveholder is a thief; the
    whipper of women is a barbarian; the seller of a child is a savage."
    No wonder that the thieving hypocrite of his day hated him!  I have no
    love for any man who ever pretended to own a human being.  I have no
    love for a man that would sell a babe from the mother's throbbing,
    heaving, agonized breast. I have no respect for a man who considered a
    lash on the naked back as a legal tender for labor performed.  So write
    it down, Thomas Paine was the first great abolitionist of America.
    
    Now let me tell you another thing.  He was the first man to raise his
    voice for the abolition of the death penalty in the French convention.
    What more did he do?  He was the first to suggest a federal
    constitution for the United States.  He saw that the old articles of
    confederation were nothing; that they were ropes of water and chains of
    mist, and he said, "We want a federal constitution so that when you
    pass a law raising 5 percent you can make the states pay it."  Let us
    give him his due.  What were all these preachers doing at that time?
    
    He hated superstition; he loved the truth.  He hated tyranny; he loved
    liberty.  He was the friend of the human race.  He lived a brave and
    thoughtful life.  He was a good and true and generous man, and "he died
    as he lived."  Like a great and peaceful river with green and shaded
    banks, without a murmur, without a ripple, he flowed into the waveless
    ocean of eternal peace.  I love him; I love every man who gave me, or
    helped to give me the liberty I enjoy tonight; I love every man who
    helped me put our flag in heaven.  I love every man who has lifted his
    voice in any age for liberty, for a chainless body and a fetterless
    brain.  I love everyman who has given to every other human being every
    right that he claimed for himself.  I love every man who has thought
    more of principle than he has of position.  I love the men who have
    trampled crowns beneath their feet that they might do something for
    mankind, and for that reason I love Thomas Paine.
    
    I thank you all, ladies and gentlemen, every one--every one, for the
    attention you have given me this evening.
    
    
    
    
    
    Ingersoll's Lecture on Liberty of Man, Woman and Child
    
    
    
    Ladies and Gentlemen:  In my judgment slavery is the child of
    ignorance. Liberty is born of intelligence.  Only a few years ago there
    was a great awakening in the human mind.  Men began to inquire, By what
    right does a crowned robber make me work for him?  The man who asked
    this question was called a traitor. Others said, by what right does a
    robed priest rob me?  That man was called an infidel.  And whenever he
    asked a question of that kind, the clergy protested.  When they found
    that the earth was round, the clergy protested; when they found that
    the stars were not made out of the scraps that were left over on the
    sixth day of creation, but were really great, shining, wheeling worlds,
    the clergy protested and said:  "When is this spirit of investigation
    to stop?"  They said then, and they say now, that it is dangerous for
    the mind of man to be free.  I deny it.  Out on the intellectual sea
    there is room  for every sail. In the intellectual air, there is space
    enough for every wing. And the man who does not do his own thinking is
    a slave, and does not do his duty to his fellow men.  For one, I expect
    to do my own thinking. And I will take my own oath this minute that I
    will express what thoughts I have, honestly and sincerely.  I am the
    slave of no man and of no organization.  I stand under the blue sky and
    the stars, under the infinite flag of nature, the peer of every human
    being.  Standing as I do in the presence of the Unknown, I have the
    same right to guess as though I had been through five theological
    seminary.  I have as much interest in the great absorbing questions of
    origin and destiny as though I had D.D., L. L. D. at the end of my name.
    
    All I claim, all I plead is simple liberty of thought.  That is all.  I
    do not pretend to tell what is true and all the truth.  I do not claim
    that I have floated level with the heights of thought, or that I have
    descended to the depths of things; I simply claim that what idea I have
    I have a right to express, and any man that denies it to me is an
    intellectual thief and robber. That is all.  I say, take those chains
    off from the human soul; I say, break these orthodox fetters, and if
    there are wings to the spirit let them be spread.  That is all I say.
    And I ask you if I have not the same right to think that any other
    human has? If I have no right to think, why have I such a thing as a
    thinker. Why have I a brain?  And if I have no right to think, who has?
    If I have lost my right, Mr. Smith, where did you find yours?  If I
    have no right, have three or four men or 300 or 400, who get together
    and sign a card and build a house and put a steeple on it with a bell
    in it--have they any more right to think than they had before?  That is
    the question.  And I am sick of the whip and lash in the region of mind
    and intellect.  And I say to these men, "Let us alone.  Do your own
    thinking; express your own thoughts."  And I want to say tonight that I
    claim no right that I am not willing to give to every other human being
    beneath the stars--none whatever.  And I will fight tonight for the
    right of those who disagree with me to express their thoughts just as
    soon as I will fight for my own right to express mine.
    
    In the good old times, our fathers had an idea that they could make
    people believe to suit them.  Our ancestors in the ages that are gone
    really believed that by force you could convince a man. You cannot
    change the conclusion of the brain by force, but I will tell you what
    you can do by force, and what you have done by force.  You can make
    hypocrites by the million.  You can make a man say that he has changed
    his mind, but he remains of the same opinion still.  Put fetters all
    over him; crush his feet in iron boots; lash him to the stock; burn him
    if you please, but his ashes are of the same opinion still.  I say our
    fathers, in the good old times--and the best thing I can say about them
    is, they are dead--they had an idea they could force men to think their
    way, and do you know that idea is still prevalent even in this country?
    Do you know they think they can make a man think their way if they say,
    "We will not trade with that man; we won't vote for that man; we won't
    hire him, if he is a lawyer; we will die before we take his medicine,
    if he is a doctor, we won't invite him; we will socially ostracize him;
    he must come to our church; he must think our way or he is not a
    gentleman."  There is much of that even in this blessed country--not
    excepting the city of Albany itself.
    
    Now in the old times of which I have spoken, they said, "We can make
    all men think alike."  All the mechanical ingenuity of this earth
    cannot make two clocks run alike, and how are you going to make
    millions of people of different quantities and qualities and amount of
    brain, clad in this living robe of passionate flesh--how are you going
    to make millions of them think alike? If the infinite God, if there is
    one, who made us, wished us to think alike, why did he give a spoonful
    of brains to one man, and a bushel to another?  Why is it that we have
    all degrees of humanity, from the idiot to the genius, if it was
    intended that all should think alike?  I say our fathers concluded they
    would do this by force, and I used to read in books how they persecuted
    mankind, and do you know I never appreciated it; I did not.  I read it,
    but it did not burn itself, as it were, into my very soul what infamies
    had been committed in the name of religion, and I never fully
    appreciated it until a little while ago I saw the iron arguments our
    fathers used to use.  I tell you the reason we are through that, is
    because we have better brains than our fathers had.  Since that day we
    have become intellectually developed, and there is more real brain and
    real good sense in the world today than in any other period of its
    history, and that is the reason we have more liberty, that is the
    reason we have more kindness.  But I say I saw these iron arguments our
    fathers used to use. I saw here the thumb-screw--two little innocent
    looking pieces of iron, armed on the inner surface with protuberances
    to prevent their slipping--and when some man denied the efficacy of
    baptism, or maybe said, "I do not believe that the whale ever swallowed
    a man to keep him from drowning," then they put these pieces of iron
    upon his thumb, and there was a screw at each end, and then, in the
    name of love and forgiveness, they began screwing these pieces of iron
    together.  A great many men, when they commenced, would say, "I
    recant."  I expect I would have been one of them.   I would have said,
    "Now you just stop that; I will admit anything on earth that you want.
    I will admit there is one god or a million, one hell or a billion; suit
    yourselves, but stop that."  But I want to say, the thumbscrew having
    got out of the way, I am going to have my say.
    
    There was now and then some man who wouldn't turn Judas Iscariot to his
    own soul; there was now and then a man willing to die for his
    conviction, and if it were not for such men we would be savages
    tonight. Had it not been for a few brave and heroic souls in every age,
    we would have been naked savages this moment, with pictures of wild
    beasts tattooed upon our naked breasts, dancing around a dried snake
    fetish; and I tonight thank every good and noble man who stood up in
    the face of opposition, and hatred, and death for what he believed to
    be right.  And then they screwed this thumbscrew down as far as they
    could and threw him into some dungeon, where, in throbbing misery and
    the darkness of night, he dreams of the damned; but that was done in
    the name of universal love.
    
    I saw there at the same time what they called the "collar of torture."
    Imagine a circle of iron, and on the inside of that more than a hundred
    points as sharp as needles.  This being fastened upon the throat, the
    sufferer could not sit down, he could not walk, he could not stir
    without being punctured by those needles, and in a little while the
    throat would begin to swell, and finally suffocation would end the
    agonies of that man, when may be the only crime he had committed was to
    say, with tears upon his sublime cheeks, "I do not believe that God,
    the father of us all, will damn to eternal punishment any of the
    children of men."  Think of it!  And I saw there at the same time
    another instrument, called "the scavenger's daughter," which resembles
    a pair of shears, with handles where handles ought to be, but at the
    points as well.  And just above the pivot that fastens the blades, a
    circle of iron through which the hands would be placed, into the lower
    circles the feet, and into the center circle the head would be pushed,
    and in that position he would be thrown prone upon the earth, and kept
    there until the strain upon the muscles produced such agony that
    insanity and death would end his pain.  And that was done in the name
    of "Whosoever smiteth thee upon one cheek, turn him the other also."
    Think of it!
    
    And I saw also the rack, with the windlass and chains, upon which the
    sufferer was laid.  About his ankles were fastened chains, and about
    his wrists also, and then priests began turning this windlass, and they
    kept turning until the ankles, the shoulders and the wrists were all
    dislocated, and the sufferer was wet with the sweat of agony.  And they
    had standing by a physician to feel his pulse.  What for?  To save his
    life?  Yes.  What for?  In mercy?  No.  Simply that they might preserve
    his life, that they might rack him once again.  And this was
    done--recollect it--it was done in the name of civilization, it was
    done in the name of law and order, it was done in the name of morality,
    it was done in the name of religion, it was done in the name of God.
    
    Sometimes when I get to reading about it, and when I get to thinking
    about it, it seems to me that I have suffered all these horrors myself,
    as though I had stood upon the shore of exile and gazed with a
    tear-filled eye toward home and native land; as though my nails had
    been torn from my hands, and into my throat the sharp needles had been
    thrust; as though my feet had been crushed in iron boots; as though I
    had been chained in the cells of the Inquisition, and had watched and
    waited in the interminable darkness to hear the words of release; as
    though I had been taken from my fireside, from my wife and children,
    and taken to the public square, chained, and fagots had been piled
    around me; as though the flames had played around my limbs, and
    scorched the sight from my eyes; as though my ashes had been scattered
    to the four winds by the hands of hatred; as though I had stood upon
    the scaffold and felt the glittering ax fall upon me.  And while I feel
    and see all this, I swear that while I live I will do what little I can
    to augment the liberty of man, woman and child.
    
    My friends, it is all a question of sense; it is all a question of
    honesty.  If there is a man in this house who is not willing to give to
    everybody else what he claims for himself he is just so much nearer to
    the barbarian than I am.  It is a simple question of honesty; and the
    man who is not willing to give to every other human being the same
    intellectual rights he claims himself is a rascal, and you know it.  It
    is a simple question, I say, of intellectual development and of
    honesty. And I want to say it now, so you will see it.  You show me the
    narrow, contracted man; you show me the man who claims everything for
    himself and leaves nothing for others, and that man has got a distorted
    and deformed brain.  That is the matter with him.  He has no sense; not
    a bit.  Let me show you.
    
    A little while ago I saw models of everything man has made for his use
    and for his convenience.  I saw all the models of all the watercraft,
    from the dug-out, in which floated a naked savage--one of our
    ancestors--a naked savage, with teeth two inches long, with a spoonful
    of brains in the back of his head; I saw the watercraft of the world,
    from that dug-out up to a man-of-war that carries a hundred guns and
    miles of canvas; from that dug-out to the steamship that turns its
    brave prow from the port of New York through 3,000 miles of billows,
    with a compass like a conscience, that does not miss throb or beat of
    its mighty iron heart from one shore to the other.  I saw at the same
    time the weapons that man has made, from a rude club, such as was
    grasped by that savage when he crawled from his den, from his hole in
    the ground, and hunted a snake for his dinner--from that club to the
    boomerang, to the sword, to the cross-bow, to the blunderbuss, to the
    flint-lock, to the cap-lock, to the needle-gun, up to the cannon cast
    by Krupp, capable of hurling a ball of 2,000 pounds through eighteen
    inches of solid steel.  I saw, too, the armor from the turtle-shell
    that our ancestor lashed upon his skin when he went out to fight for
    his country, to the skin of the porcupine, with the quills all
    bristling, which he pulled over his orthodox head to defend himself
    from his enemies--I mean, of course, the orthodox head of that day--up
    to the shirts of mail that were worn in the middle ages, capable of
    resisting the edge of the sword and the point of the spear; up to the
    iron-clad, to the monitor completely clad in steel, capable only a few
    years ago of defying the navies of the globe.
    
    I saw at the same time the musical instruments, from the tomtom, which
    is a hoop with a couple of strings of rawhide drawn across it--from
    that tomtom up to the instruments we have today, which make the common
    air blossom with melody.  I saw, too, the paintings, from the daub of
    yellow mud up to the pieces which adorn the galleries of the world.
    And the sculpture, from the rude gods, with six legs and a half dozen
    arms, and the rows of ears, up to the sculpture of now, wherein the
    marble is clad with such loveliness that it seems almost a sacrilege to
    touch it; and in addition I saw there ideas of books--books written
    upon skins of wild beasts, books written upon shoulder-blades of sheep;
    books written upon leaves, upon bark, up to the splendid volumes that
    adorn the libraries of our time.  When I think of libraries, I think of
    the remark of Plato, "The house that has a library in it has a soul."
    
    I saw there all these things, and also the implements of agriculture,
    from a crooked stick up to the plow which makes it possible for a man
    to cultivate the soil without being an ignoramus.  I saw at the same
    time a row of skulls, from the lowest skull that has ever been found;
    skulls from the central portion of Africa, skulls from the bushmen of
    Australia, up to the best skulls of the last generation.
    
    And I notice that there was the same difference between those skulls
    that there is between the products of those skulls.  And I said to
    myself:  "It is all a question of intellectual development.  It is a
    question of brain and sinew."  I noticed that there was the same
    difference between those skulls that there was between that dug-out,
    and that man-of-war and that steamship.  That skull was low.  It had
    not a forehead a quarter of an inch high.  But shortly after, the
    skulls became doming and crowning, and getting higher and grander.
    That skull was a den in which crawled the base and meaner instincts of
    mankind, and this skull was a temple in which dwelt joy, liberty and
    love.  So said I:  "This is all a question of brain, and anything that
    tends to develop, intellectually, mankind, is the gospel we want."
    
    Now I want to be honest with you.  Honor bright!  Nothing like it in
    the world!  No matter what I believe.  Now, let us be honest. Suppose a
    king, if there was a king at the time this gentleman floated in the
    dugout and charmed his ears with the music of the tomtom; suppose the
    king at that time, if there was one, and the priest, if there was one,
    had said:  "That dug-out is the best boat that ever can be built.  The
    pattern of that came from on high, and any man who says he can improve
    it, by putting a log or a stick in the bottom of it, with a rag on the
    end, is an infidel."  Honor bright, what, in your judgment, would have
    been the effect upon the circumnavigation of the globe?  That is the
    question.  Suppose the king, if there was one, and the priest, if there
    was one--and I presume there was, because it was a very ignorant
    age--suppose they had said:  "That tomtom is the most miraculous
    instrument of music that any man can conceive of; that is the kind of
    music they have in heaven.  An angel, sitting upon the golden edge of a
    fleecy cloud, playing upon that tomtom became so enraptured, so
    entranced with her own music, that she dropped it, and that is how we
    got it--and any man that says that it can be improved by putting a back
    and front to it, and four strings and a bridge on it, and getting some
    horsehair and resin, is no better than one of the weak and
    unregenerate."
    
    I ask you what effect would that have had upon music?  I ask you, honor
    bright, if that course had been pursued, would the human ears ever have
    been enriched with the divine symphonies of Beethoven?  That is the
    question.  And suppose the king, if there was one, and the priest had
    said:  "That crooked stick is the best plow we can ever have invented.
    The pattern of that plow was given to a pious farmer in a holy dream,
    and that twisted straw is the ne plus ultra of all twisted things; and
    any man who says he can make an improvement, we will twist him."  Honor
    bright, what, in your judgment, would have been the effect upon the
    agricultural world?
    
    Now, you see, the people said, "We want better weapons with which to
    kill our enemies;" so the people said, "we want better plows;"  the
    people said, "we want better music;"  the people said, "we want better
    paintings;"  and they said, "whoever will give us better plows, and
    better arms, and better paintings, and better music, we will give him
    honor; we will crown him with glory; we will robe him in the garments
    of wealth;" and every incentive has been held out to every human being
    to improve something in every direction.  And that is the reason the
    club is a cannon; that the reason the dugout is a steamship; that the
    reason the daub is a painting, and that is the reason that that piece
    of stone has finally become a glorified statue.
    
    Now, then, this fellow in the dug-out had a religion.  That fellow was
    orthodox.  He had no doubt; he was settled in his mind.  He did not
    wish to be insulted.  He wanted the bark of his soul to lie at the
    wharf of orthodoxy, and rot in the sun.  He wanted to hear the sails of
    old opinions flap against the mast of old creeds.  He wanted to see the
    joints in the sides open and gape, as though thirsty for water, and he
    said:  "Now don't disturb my opinions; you'll get my mind unsettled; I
    have got it all made up, and I don't want to hear any infidelity,
    either." As far as I am concerned, I want to be out on the high sea; I
    Want to take my chance with wind and wave and star; and I had rather go
    down in the glory and grandeur of the storm than to rot at any orthodox
    wharf.  Of course I mean by orthodoxy all that don't agree with my
    doxy. Do you understand?
    
    Now this man had a religion.  That fellow believed in hell.  Yes, sir;
    and he thought he would be happier in heaven if he could just lean over
    and see certain people that he disliked, broiled. That fellow has had a
    great many intellectual descendents.  It is an unhappy fact in nature
    that the ignorant multiply much faster than the intellectual.  This
    fellow believed in the devil, and his devil had a cloven hoof.  (Many
    people think I have the same kind of footing.)  He had a long tail,
    armed with a fiery dart, and he breathed brimstone.  And do you know
    there has not been a patentable improvement made on that devil for
    4,000 years?  That fellow believed that God was a tyrant.  That fellow
    believed that the earth was flat.  That fellow believed, as I told you,
    in a literal burning, seething lake of fire and brimstone.  That is
    what he believed in.  That fellow, too, had his idea of politics, and
    his idea was, "Might makes right."  And it will take thousands of years
    before the world will believingly say, "Right makes might."  Now all I
    ask is the same privilege of improving on that gentleman's theology as
    upon his musical instrument; the same right to improve upon his
    politics as upon his dug-out. That is all.  I ask for the human soul
    the same liberty in every direction.  And that is all.  That is the
    only crime that I have committed.  That is all.  I say, let us have a
    chance. Let us think, and let each one express his thoughts.  Let us
    become investigators, not followers; not cringers and crawlers.  If
    there is in heaven an infinite being, he never will be satisfied with
    the worship of cowards and hypocrites.  Honest unbelief will be a
    perfume in heaven when hypocrisy, no matter however religious it may be
    outwardly, will be a stench.  That is my doctrine.  That is all there
    is to it; give every other human being all the chance you claim for
    yourself.  To keep your mind open to the voices of nature, to new
    ideas, to new thoughts, and to improve upon your doctrine whenever you
    can; that is my doctrine.
    
    Do you know we are improving all the time?  Do you know that the most
    orthodox people in this town today, three hundred years ago would have
    been burned for heresy?  Do you know some ministers who denounce me
    would have been in the Inquisition themselves two hundred years ago?
    Do you know where once burned and blazed the bivouac fires of the army
    of progress, the altars of the church glow today?  Do you know that the
    church today occupies about the same ground that unbelievers did one
    hundred years ago?  Do you know that while they have followed this army
    of progress, protesting and denouncing, they have had to keep within
    protesting and denouncing distance, but they have followed it? They
    have been the men, let me say, in the valley; the men in swamps,
    shouting to and cursing the pioneers on the hills; the men upon whose
    forehead was the light of the coming dawn, the coming day--but they
    have advanced. In spite of themselves, they have advanced!  If they had
    not, I would not speak here to night.  If they had not, not a solitary
    one of you could have expressed your real and honest thought.  But we
    are advancing, and we are beginning to hold all kinds of slavery in
    utter contempt; do you know that?  And we are beginning to question
    wealth and power; we are questioning all creeds and all dogmas; and we
    are not bowing down, as we used to, to a man simply because he is in
    the robe of a clergyman, and we are not bowing down to a man now simply
    because he is a king.  No!  We are not bowing down simply because he is
    rich.  We used to worship the golden calves, but we do not now.  The
    worst you can say of an American, is, he worships the gold of the calf,
    not the calf; and even the calves are beginning to see this distinction.
    
    It no longer fills the ambition of a man to be emperor or king. The
    last Napoleon was not satisfied with being Emperor of the French; he
    was not satisfied with having a circlet of gold about his head; he
    wanted some evidence that he had something within his head, so he wrote
    the life of Julius Caesar, that he might become a member of the French
    Academy. Compare, for instance, in the German Empire, King William and
    Bismarck. King William is the one anointed of the most high, as they
    claim--the one upon whose head has been poured the divine petroleum of
    authority. Compare him with Bismarck, who towers, an intellectual
    Colossus, above this man.  Go into England and compare George Eliot
    with Queen Victoria--Queen Victoria, clothed in the garments given to
    her by blind fortune and by chance.  George Elliot, robed in garments
    of glory, woven in the loom of her own genius.  Which does the world
    pay respect to?  I tell you we are advancing! The pulpit does not do
    all the thinking; the pews do it; nearly all of it.  The world is
    advancing, and we question the authority of those men who simply say
    "it is so."  Down upon your knees and admit it!  When I think of how
    much this world has suffered, I am amazed.  When I think of how long
    our fathers were slaves, I am amazed. Why, just think of it!  This
    world has only been fit for a gentleman to live in fifty years.  No, it
    has not.  It was not until the year 1808 that Great Britain abolished
    the slave trade. Up to that time her judge, sitting upon the bench in
    the name of justice; her priests, occupying the pulpit in the name of
    universal love, owned stock in slave ships and luxuriated in the
    profits of piracy and murder.  It was not until the year 1808 that the
    United States abolished the slave trade between this and other
    countries, but preserved it as between the States.  It was not until
    the 28th day of August, 1833, that Great Britain abolished human
    slavery in her colonies; and it was not until the 1st day of January,
    1863, that Abraham Lincoln wiped from our flag the stigma of disgrace.
    Abraham Lincoln--in my judgment, the grandest man ever president of the
    United States, and upon whose monument these words could truthfully be
    written:  "Here lies the only man in the history of the world who,
    having been clothed with almost absolute power, never abused it except
    on the side of mercy."
    
    Think, I say, how long we clung to the institution of human slavery;
    how long lashes upon the naked back were the legal tender for labor
    performed!  Think of it! when the pulpit of this country deliberately
    and willfully changed the Cross of Christ into the whipping-post.
    Think of it!  And tell me then if I am right when I say this world has
    only been fit for a gentleman to live in fifty years.  I hate with
    every drop of my blood every form of tyranny.  I hate every form of
    slavery.  I hate dictation--I want something like liberty; and what do
    I mean by that?  The right to do anything that does not interfere with
    the happiness of another, physically.  Liberty of thought includes the
    right to think right and the right to think wrong.  Why? Because that
    is the means by which we arrive at truth; for if we knew the truth
    before, we needn't think.  Those men who mistake their ignorance for
    facts, never do think.  You may say to me, "How far is it across this
    room?"  I say 100 feet.  Suppose it is 105; have I committed any crime?
    I made the best guess I could. You ask me about any thing; I examine it
    honestly, and when I get through, what should I tell you--what I think
    or what you think?  What should I do?
    
    There is a book put in my hands.  They say "That is the Koran; that was
    written by inspiration; read it."  I read it.  Chapter VII, entitled
    "The Cow," chapter IX, entitled "The Bee," and so on.  I read it.  When
    I get through with it, suppose I think in my heart and in my brain, "I
    don't believe a word of it;"  and you ask me, "What do you think of
    it?" Now, admitting that I live in Turkey, and have a chance to get an
    office, what should I say?  Now, honor bright, should I just make a
    clean breast of it and say "Upon my honor, I don't believe it?"  Then
    is it right for you to say "That fellow will steal--that fellow is a
    dangerous man--he is a robber?"  Now, suppose I read the book called
    the bible (and I read it, honor bright), and when I get through with it
    I make up my mind that book was written by men; and along comes the
    preacher of my church, and he says "Did you read that book?"  "I did."
    "Do you think it is divinely inspired?"  I say to myself, "Now if I say
    it is not, they will never send me to Congress from this district on
    earth."  Now, honor bright, what ought I to do?  Ought I to say, "I
    have read it.  I have been honest about it; don't believe it?" Now,
    ought I to say that, if that is a real transcript of my mind, or ought
    I to commence hemming and hawing and pretend that I do believe it, and
    go away with the respect of that man, hating myself for a cringing
    coward? Now which?  For my part I would rather a man would tell me what
    he honestly thinks, and he will preserve his manhood.  I had rather be
    a manly unbeliever than an unmanly believer.  I think I will stand
    higher at the judgment day, if there is one, and stand with as good a
    chance to get my case dismissed without costs as a man who sneaks
    through life pretending he believes what he does not.  I tell you one
    thing; there is going to be one free fellow in this world.  I am going
    to say my say, I tell you.  I am going to do it kindly, I am going to
    do it distinctly, but I am going to do it.
    
    Now, if men have been slaves, what about women?  Women have been the
    slaves of slaves; and that's a pretty hard position to occupy for life.
    They have been the slaves of slaves; and in my judgment it took
    millions of ages for women to come from the condition of abject slavery
    up to the institution of marriage. Let me say right here, tonight, I
    regard marriage as the holiest institution among men.  Without the
    fireside there is no human advancement; without the family relation,
    there is no life worth living.  Every good government is made up of
    good families.  The unit of government is family, and anything that
    tends to destroy the family is perfectly devilish and infamous.  I
    believe in marriage, and I hold in utter contempt the opinions of
    long-haired men and short-haired women who denounce the institution of
    marriage.  Let me say right here--and I have thought a good deal about
    it--let me say right here, the grandest ambition that any man can
    possibly have is to so live and so improve himself in heart and brain
    as to be worthy of the love of some splendid woman; and the grandest
    ambition of any girl is to make herself worthy of the love and
    adoration of some magnificent man.  That is my idea, and there is no
    success in life without it.  If you are the grand emperor of the world,
    you had better be the grand emperor of one loving and tender heart, and
    she the grand empress of yours.  The man who has really won the love of
    one good woman in this world, I do not care if he dies in the ditch a
    beggar, his life has been a success.
    
    I say it took millions of years to come from the condition of abject
    slavery up to the condition of marriage.  Ladies, the ornaments you
    bear upon your person tonight are but the souvenirs of your mothers'
    bondage. The chains around your necks and the bracelets clasped upon
    your wrists by the thrilling hand of love, have been changed by the
    wand of civilization from iron to shining, glittering gold.  But nearly
    every religion has accounted for the devilment in this world by the
    crime of woman. What a gallant thing that is!  And if it is true, I had
    rather live with the woman I love in a world full of trouble, than to
    live in heaven with nobody but men.
    
    I say that nearly every religion has accounted for all the trouble in
    this world by the crime of woman.  I read in a book--and I will say now
    that I cannot give the exact language; my memory does not retain the
    words--but I can give the substance.  I read in a book that the supreme
    being concluded to make a world and one man; that he took some nothing
    and made a world and one man, and put this man in a garden:  but he
    noticed that he got lonesome; he wandered around as if he was waiting
    for a train; there was nothing to interest him; no news; no papers; no
    politics; no policy; and as the devil had not yet made his appearance,
    there was no chance for reconciliation; not even for civil service
    reform.  Well, he would wander about this garden in this condition
    until finally the supreme being made up his mind to make him a
    companion; and having used up all the nothing he originally took in
    making the world and one man, he had to take a part of the man to start
    a woman with, and so he caused a deep sleep to fall upon this man--now,
    understand me. I didn't say this story is true. After the sleep fell
    upon this man, he took a rib, or, as the French would call it, a cutlet
    out of this man, and from that he made a woman; and considering the raw
    material, I look upon it as the most successful job ever performed.
    Well, after He got the woman done, she was brought to the man; not to
    see how she liked him, but to see how he liked her.  He liked her, and
    they started housekeeping; and they were told of certain things they
    might do, and one thing they could not do--and of course they did it.
    I would have done it in fifteen minutes, and I know it.  There wouldn't
    have been an apple on that tree half an hour from date, and the limbs
    could have been full of clubs.  And then they were turned out of the
    park, and an extra force was put on to keep them from getting back.
    Then devilment commenced.  The mumps, and the measles, and the whooping
    cough and the scarlet fever started in their race for man, and they
    began to have the toothache, the roses began to have thorns, and snakes
    began to have poisoned teeth, and people began to divide about religion
    and politics; and the world has been full of trouble from that day to
    this. Now, nearly all of the religions of this world account for the
    existence of evil by such a story as that.
    
    I read in another book what appeared to be an account of the same
    transaction.  It was written about 4,000 years before the other; but
    all commentators agree that the one that was written last was the
    original, and that the one that was written first was copied from the
    one that was written last; but I would advise you all not to allow your
    creed to be disturbed by a little matter of four or five thousand
    years.  In this other story the Supreme Brahma made up his mind to make
    the world and man and woman; and he made the world, and he made the man
    and he made the woman, and he put them on the island of Ceylon; and
    according to the account, it was the most beautiful island of which man
    can conceive. Such birds, such songs, such flowers and such verdure!
    And the branches of the trees were so arranged that when the wind swept
    through them every tree was a thousand aeolian harps.  The Supreme
    Brahma when he put them there said, "Let them have a period of
    courtship, for it is my desire and will that true love should forever
    precede marriage."  When I read that, it was so much more beautiful and
    lofty than the other, that I said to myself, "If either one of these
    stories ever turns out to be true, I hope it will be this one."
    
    Then they had their courtship, with the nightingales singing and the
    stars shining and the flowers blooming, and they fell in love.  Imagine
    the courtship!  No prospective fathers or mothers in law; no prying and
    gossiping neighbors, nobody to say, "Young man, how do you expect to
    support her?"  Nothing of that kind. They were married by the Supreme
    Brahma, and he said to them:  "Remain here; you must never leave this
    island."  Well, after a little while the man--and his name was Amend,
    and the woman's name was Heva--and the man said to Heva:  "I believe
    I'll look about a little;"  and he went to the northern extremity of
    the island, where there was a little, narrow neck of land connecting it
    with the mainland; and the devil, who is always playing pranks with us,
    got up a mirage, and when he looked over to the mainland, such hills
    and dells, vales and dales; such mountains, crowned with silver; such
    cataracts, clad in robes of beauty, did he see there, that he went back
    and told Heva:  "The country over there is a thousand times better than
    this; let us migrate."  She, like every other woman that ever lived,
    said: "Let well enough alone; we have all we want; let us stay here."
    But he said, "No, let us go;" so she followed him, and when they came
    to this narrow neck of land he took her on his back like a gentleman
    and carried her over.  But the moment they got over they heard a crash,
    and, looking back, discovered that this narrow neck of land had fallen
    into the sea, with the exception of now and then a rock, and the mirage
    had disappeared and there was naught but rocks and sand; and then a
    voice called out, cursing them.  Then it was that the man spoke up--and
    I have liked him ever since for it--"Curse me, but curse not her; it
    was not her fault, it was mine."  That's the kind of man to start a
    world with. The Supreme Brahma said, "I will save her but not thee."
    She spoke up out of her feelings of love, out of a heart in which there
    was love enough to make all of her daughters rich in holy affection,
    and said, "If thou wilt not spare him, spare neither me; I do not wish
    to live without him; I love him." Then the Supreme Brahma said--and I
    have liked him first-rate ever since I read it--"I will spare you both
    and watch over you."
    
    Honor bright, isn't that the better story?
    
    And from that same book I want to show you what ideas some of these
    miserable heathen had--the heathen we are trying to convert.  We send
    missionaries over yonder to convert heathen there, and we send soldiers
    out on the plains to kill heathen there.  If we can convert the
    heathen, why not convert those nearest home?  Why not convert those we
    can get at?  Why not convert those who have the immense advantage of
    the example of the average pioneer?  But to show you the men we are
    trying to convert--in this book it says:  "Man is strength, woman is
    beauty; man is courage, woman is love.  When the one man loves the one
    woman and the one woman loves the one man, the very angels leave heaven
    and come and sit in that house and sing for joy."  They are the men we
    are converting.  Think of it!  I tell you when I read these things I
    begin to say, "Love is not of any country; nobility does not belong
    exclusively here;"  and through all the ages there have been a few
    great and tender souls lifted far above their fellows.
    
    Now, my friends, it seems to me that the woman is the equal of the man.
    She has all the rights I have, and one more, and that is the right to
    be protected.  That's my doctrine.  You are married; try and make the
    woman you love happy; try and make the man you love happy.  Whoever
    marries simply for himself will make a mistake; but whoever loves a
    woman so well that he says "I will make her happy," makes no mistake;
    and so with the woman who says "I will make him happy."  There is only
    one way to be happy, and that is to make somebody else so, and you
    can't be happy cross-lots; you have got to go the regular turnpike road.
    
    If there is any man I detest, it is the man who thinks he is the head
    of the family--the man who thinks he is "boss".  That fellow in the
    dug-out used that word "boss;"  that was one of his favorite
    expressions--that he was "boss".  Imagine a young man and a young woman
    courting, walking out in the moonlight, and the nightingale singing a
    song of pain and love, as though the thorn touched her heart--imagine
    them stopping there in the moonlight and starlight and song, and saying
    "Now here, let's settle who's boss!"  I tell you it is an infamous
    word, and an infamous feeling--a man who is "boss," who is going to
    govern his family, and when he speaks let all the rest of them be
    still--some mighty idea is about to be launched from his mouth.  Do you
    know I dislike this man unspeakably; and a cross man I hate above all
    things.
    
    What right has he to murder the sunshine of the day?  What right has he
    to assassinate the joy of life?  Where you go home you ought to feel
    the light there is in the house; if it is in the night it will burst
    out of doors and windows and illuminate the darkness.  It is just as
    well to go home a ray of sunshine as an old sour, cross curmudgeon, who
    thinks he is the head of the family.  Wise men think their mighty
    brains have been in a turmoil; they have been thinking about who will
    be alderman from the fifth ward; they have been thinking about
    politics; great and mighty questions have been engaging their minds;
    they have bought calico at 8 cents, or 6, and want to sell it for 7.
    Think of the intellectual strain that must have been upon a man, and
    when he gets home everybody else in the house must look out for his
    comfort.  A woman who has only taken care of five or six children, and
    one or two of them may be sick; has been nursing them and singing to
    them, and taking care of them, and trying to make one yard of cloth do
    the work of two--she, of course, is fresh and fine, and ready to wait
    upon this great gentleman--the head of the family I don't like him a
    bit!
    
    Do you know another thing?  I despise a stingy man.  I don't see how it
    is possible for a man to die worth fifty millions of dollars, or ten
    millions of dollars, in a city full of want, when he meets almost every
    day the withered hand of beggary and the white lips of famine.  How a
    man can withstand all that, and hold in the clutch of his greed twenty
    or thirty millions of dollars, is past my comprehension.  I do not see
    how he can do it.  I should not think he could do it any more than he
    could keep a pile of lumber where hundreds and thousands of men were
    drowning in the sea.  I should not think he could do it.
    
    Do you know I have known men who would trust their wives with their
    hearts and their honor, but not with their pocketbook; not with a
    dollar.  When I see a man of that kind I always think he knows which of
    these articles is the most valuable.  Think of making your wife a
    beggar!  Think of her having to ask you every day for a dollar, or for
    two dollars, or for fifty cents!  "What did you do with that dollar I
    gave you last week?"  Think of having a wife that was afraid of you!
    What kind of children do you expect to have with a beggar and a coward
    for their mother? Oh, I tell you, if you have but a dollar in the
    world, and you have got to spend it, spend it like a king; spend it as
    though it were a dry leaf and you the owner of unbounded forests!
    That's the way to spend it!  I had rather be a beggar and spend my last
    dollar like a king, than be a king and spend my money like a beggar.
    If it's got to go, let it go.
    
    Get the best you can for your family--try to look as well as you can
    yourself.  When you used to go courting, how nice you looked! Ah, your
    eye was bright, your step was light, and you just put on the very best
    look you could.  Do you know that it is insufferable egotism in you to
    suppose that a woman is going to love you always looking as bad as you
    can?  Think of it!  Any woman on earth will be true to you forever when
    you do your level best.  Some people tell me, "Your doctrine about
    loving, and wives, and all that is splendid for the rich, but it won't
    do for the poor."  I tell you tonight there is on the average more love
    in the homes of the poor than in the palaces of the rich; and the
    meanest but with love in it is fit for the gods, and a palace without
    love is a den only fit for wild beasts.  That's my doctrine!
    
    You can't be so poor but that you can help somebody.  Good nature is
    the cheapest commodity in the world; and love is the only thing that
    will pay 10 percent to borrower and lender both. Don't tell me that you
    have got to be rich!  We have all a false standard of greatness in the
    United States.  We think here that a man to be great, must be
    notorious; must be extremely wealthy, or his name must be between the
    lips of rumor.  It is all nonsense!  It is not necessary to be rich to
    be great, or to be powerful to be happy; and the happy man is the
    successful man. Happiness is the legal tender of the soul.  Joy is
    wealth.
    
    A little while ago I stood by the grave of the old Napoleon, a
    magnificent tomb, fit for a dead deity almost, and gazed into the great
    circle at the bottom of it.  In the sarcophagus, of black Egyptian
    marble, at last rest the ashes of that restless man.  I looked over the
    balustrade, and I thought about the career of Napoleon.  I could see
    him walking upon the banks of the Seine contemplating suicide.  I saw
    him at Toulon.  I saw him putting down the mob in the streets of Paris.
    I saw him at the head of the army of Italy.  I saw him crossing the
    bridge at Lodi.  I saw him in Egypt, fighting the battle of the
    pyramids.  I saw him cross the Alps, and mingle the eagles of France
    with the eagles of the crags.  I saw him at Austerlitz.  I saw him with
    his army scattered and dispersed before the blast.  I saw him at
    Leipsic when his army was defeated and he was taken captive.  I saw him
    escape.  I saw him land again upon French soil, and retake an empire by
    the force of his own genius.  I saw him captured once more, and again
    at St. Helena, with his arms behind him, gazing out upon the sad and
    solemn sea; and I thought of the orphans and Widows he had made.
    
    I thought of the tears that had been shed for his glory.  I thought of
    the only woman who ever loved him, who had been pushed from his heart
    by the cold hand of ambition; and as I looked at the sarcophagus, I
    said, "I would rather have been a French peasant and worn wooden shoes;
    I would rather have lived in a hut, with a vine growing over the door,
    and the grapes growing and ripening in the autumn sun; I would rather
    have been that peasant, with my wife by my side and my children upon my
    knees, twining their arms of affection about me; I would rather have
    been that poor French peasant, and gone down at last to the eternal
    promiscuity of the dust, followed by those who loved me; I would a
    thousand times rather have been that French peasant than that imperial
    personative of force and murder."  And so I would, ten thousand times.
    
    It is not necessary to be great to be happy; it is not necessary to be
    rich to be just and generous, and to have a heart filled with divine
    affection.  No matter whether you are rich or poor, use your wife as
    though she were a splendid creation, and she will fill your life with
    perfume and joy.  And do you know, it is a splendid thing for me to
    think that the woman you really love will never grow old to you?
    Through the wrinkles of time, through the music of years, if you really
    love her, you will always see the face you loved and won.  And a woman
    who really loves a man, does not see that he grows older; he is not
    decrepit; he does not tremble; he is not old; she always sees the same
    gallant gentleman who won her hand and heart.  I like to think of it in
    that way.  I like to think of all passions; love is eternal, and, as
    Shakespeare says, "Although Time, with his sickle, can rob ruby lips
    and sparkling eyes, let him reach as far as he can, he cannot quite
    touch love; that reaches even to the end of the tomb."  And to love in
    that way, and then go down the hill of life together, and as you go
    down hear, perhaps, the laughter of grandchildren--the birds of joy and
    love sing once more in the leafless branches of age.  I believe in the
    fireside. I believe in the democracy of home.  I believe in the
    republicanism of the family.  I believe in liberty and equality with
    those we love.
    
    If women have been slaves, what shall I say of children; of the little
    children in the alleys and sub-cellars; the little children who turn
    pale when they hear their father's footsteps; little children who run
    away when they only hear their names called by the lips of another;
    little children--the children of poverty, the children of crime, the
    children of brutality wherever you are--flotsam and jetsam upon the
    wild, mad sea of life, my heart goes out to you, one and all.  I tell
    you the children have the same rights that we have, and we ought to
    treat them as though they were human beings; and they should be reared
    by love, by kindness, by tenderness, and not by brutality.  That is my
    idea of children.  When your little child tells a lie, don't rush at
    him as though the world were about to go into bankruptcy.  Be honest
    with him.  A tyrant father will have liars for children; do you know
    that? A lie is born of tyranny upon the one hand and weakness upon the
    other, and when you rush at a poor little boy with a club in your hand,
    of course he lies.  I thank Mother Nature that she has put ingenuity
    enough in the breast of a child, when attacked by a brutal parent, to
    throw up a little breastwork in the shape of a lie.  When one of your
    children tells a lie, be honest with him; tell him you have told
    hundreds of them yourself. Tell him it is not the best way; you have
    tried it. Tell him, as the man did in Maine when his boy left home:
    "John, honesty is the best policy; I have tried both."  Just be honest
    with him.  Imagine now; you are about to whip a child five years of
    age. What is the child to do? Suppose a man, as much larger than you
    are larger than a child five years old, should come at you with
    liberty-pole in hand, and in a voice of thunder shout, "Who broke the
    plate?"  There is not a solitary one of you who wouldn't swear you
    never saw it, or that it was cracked when you found it.  Why not be
    honest with these children?  Just imagine a man who deals in stocks
    putting false rumors afloat!
    
    Think of a lawyer beating his own flesh and blood for evading the
    truth, when he makes half of his own living that way!  Think of a
    minister punishing his child for not telling all he thinks!  Just think
    of it! When your child commits a wrong, take it in your arms; let it
    feel your heart beat against its heart; let the child know that you
    really and truly and sincerely love it.  Yet some Christians, good
    Christians, when a child commits a fault, drive it from the door, and
    say, "Never do you darken this house again."  Think of that!  And then
    these same people will get down on their knees and ask God to take care
    of the child they have driven from home.  I will never ask God to take
    care of my children unless I am doing my level best in that same
    direction. But I will tell you what I say to my children:  "Go where
    you will; commit what crime you may; fall to what depth of degradation
    you may; you can never commit any crime that will shut my door, my
    arms, my heart to you; as long as I live you shall have no more sincere
    friend."
    
    Do you know, I have seen some people who acted as though they thought
    when the Savior said, "Suffer little children to come unto me, for such
    is the Kingdom of Heaven," that he had a rawhide under his mantle and
    made that remark to get the children within striking distance.  I don't
    believe in the government of the lash.  If any one of you ever expect
    to whip your children again after you hear me, I want you to have a
    photograph taken of yourself when you are in the act, with your face
    red with vulgar anger; and then the face of the little child, with eyes
    swimming in tears, and the little chin dimpled with fear, like a piece
    of water struck by a sudden, cold wind.  Have the picture taken.  If
    that little child should die, I cannot find a sweeter way to spend an
    autumn afternoon than to go out to the cemetery, when the maples are
    clad in bright colors, and little scarlet runners are coming, like
    poems of regret, from the sad heart of the earth--than to go out to the
    cemetery and sit down upon the grave and look at this photograph, and
    think of the flesh, now dust, that you beat.
    
    I tell you it is wrong; it is no way to raise children!  Make your home
    happy.  Be honest with them, divide fairly with them in everything.
    Give them a little liberty, and you cannot drive them out of the house.
    They will want to stay there.  Make home pleasant.  Let them play any
    game they want to.  Don't be so foolish as to say:  "You may roll balls
    on the ground, but you must not roll them on green cloth.  You may
    knock them with a mallet, but you must not push them with a cue.  You
    may play with little pieces of paper which have 'Authors' written on
    them, but you must not have 'keerds.'"  Think of it!  "You may go to a
    minstrel show, where people blacken themselves up and degrade
    themselves, and imitate humanity below themselves, but you must not go
    to the theater and see the characters of immortal genius put upon the
    stage."  Why? Well, I can't think of any reason in the world except
    "minstrel" is a word of two syllables and theater has three.  Let
    children have some daylight at home if you want to keep them there, and
    don't commence at the cradle and yell, "Don't!"  "Don't!"  "Stop!"
    That is nearly all that is said to a young one from the cradle until he
    is twenty one years old, and when he comes of age other people begin
    saying "Don't!" And the church says "Don't!"  And the party that he
    belongs to says "Don't!"  I despise that way of going through this
    world. Let us have a little liberty--just a little bit.  There is
    another thing.  In old times, you know, they thought some days were too
    good for a child to enjoy himself in.  When I was a boy Sunday was
    considered altogether too good to be happy in; and Sunday used to
    commence then when the sun went down Saturday night.  That was to get
    good ready--a kind of running jump; and when the sun went down, a
    darkness ten thousand times deeper than that of night fell on that
    house.  Nobody said a word then; nobody laughed; and the child that
    looked the sickest was regarded the most pious.  You couldn't crack
    hickory nuts; you couldn't chew gum; and if you laughed, it was only
    another evidence of the total depravity of man. That was a solemn
    night; and the next morning everybody looked sad, mournful,
    dyspeptic--and thousands of people think they have religion when they
    have only got dyspepsia--thousands!  But there is nothing in this world
    that would break up the old orthodox churches as quick as some specific
    for dyspepsia--some sure cure.
    
    Then we went to church, and the minister was up in a pulpit about
    twenty feet high, with a little sounding-board over him, and he
    commenced with Firstly and went on to about twenty-thirdly, and then
    around by way of application, and then divided it off again once or
    twice, and after having put in about two hours, he got to Revelations.
    We were not allowed to have any fire, even if it was in the winter.  It
    was thought to be outrageous to be comfortable while you are thanking
    the Lord, and the first church that ever had a stove put in it in New
    England was broken up on that account.  Then we went a-nooning, and
    then came the catechism, the chief end of man.  We went through that;
    and then this same sermon was preached, commencing at the other end,
    and going back. After that was over we started for home, solemn and
    sad--"not a soldier discharged his farewell shot;"  not a word was
    said--and when we got home, if we had been good boys, they would take
    us up to the graveyard to cheer us up a little.
    
    It did cheer me!  When I looked at those tombs the comforting
    reflection came to my mind that this kind of thing couldn't last
    always.  Then we had some certain books that we read just by way of
    cheerfulness.  There was Milner's "History of the Wilderness," Baxter's
    "Call to the Unconverted," and Jenkins' "On the Atonement."  I used to
    read Jenkins' "On the Atonement;"  and I have often thought the
    atonement would have to be very broad in its provisions to cover the
    case of a man who would write a book like that for a boy to read.
    Well, you know, the Sunday had to go at last; and the moment the sun
    went down Sunday night we were free.  About 4 or 5 o'clock we would go
    to see how the sun was coming out.  Sometimes it seemed to me that it
    was just stopping from pure cussedness; but finally it had to go down,
    and when the last rim of light sank below the horizon, out would come
    our traps, and we would give three cheers for liberty once more.  In
    those times it was thought wrong for a child to laugh on Sunday.  Think
    of that!  A little child--a little boy--could go out in the garden, and
    there would be a tree laden with blossoms, and this little fellow would
    lean up against the tree, and there would be a bird singing and
    swinging, and thinking about four little speckled eggs, warmed by the
    breast of its mate--singing and swinging, and the music coming rippling
    out of its throat, and the flowers blossoming and the air full of
    perfume, and the great white clouds floating in the sky; and that
    little boy would lean up against that trunk, and think of hell.
    
    That's true!  I have heard them preach when I sat in the pew, and my
    feet didn't come within eighteen inches of the floor, about that hell.
    And they said, "Suppose that once in a million years a bird would come
    from some far distant planet, and carry in its bill a grain of sand,
    the time would finally come when the last atom composing this earth
    would be carried away;"  and the old preacher said, in order to impress
    upon the boys the length of time they would have to stay, "it wouldn't
    be sun-up in hell yet."
    
    Think of that to preach to children!  I tell you, my friends, no day
    can be so sacred but that the laugh of a little child will make it
    holier still--no day!  And yet, at that time, the minds of children
    were polluted by this infamous doctrine of eternal punishment; and I
    denounce it today as an infamous doctrine beyond the power of language
    to express.  Where did that doctrine of eternal punishment for the
    children of men come from?  It came from that wretch in the dug-out.
    Where did he get it?  It was a souvenir from the animals, and the
    doctrine of eternal punishment was born in the eyes of snakes when they
    hung in fearful coils watching for their prey.  It was a doctrine born
    of the howling and barking and growling of wild beasts; it was born in
    the grin of the hyenas, and of the depraved chatter of the baboons; and
    I despise it with every drop of my blood.  Tell me there is a God in
    the serene heaven that will damn his children for the expression of an
    honest belief!
    
    There have been more men who died in their sins, according to your
    orthodox religion, than there are leaves on all the forests of this
    world ten thousand times over.  Tell me they are in hell! Tell me they
    are to be punished for ever and ever!  I denounce it as an infamous lie!
    
    And when the great ship containing the hope and aspiration of the
    world, when the great ship freighted with mankind goes down in the
    night of death and disaster, I will go down with the ship.  I don't
    want to paddle off in any orthodox canoe.  I will go down with the
    ship; and if there is a God who will damn his children forever I had
    rather go to hell than to go to heaven and keep the society of such an
    infamous Deity.  I make my choice now.  I despise that doctrine, and
    I'll tell you why.  It has covered the cheeks of this world with tears.
    It has polluted the heart of children.  It has been a pain and terror
    to every man that ever believed it.  It has filled the good with horror
    and fear, but it has had no effect upon the infamous and base.  I tell
    you it is a bad doctrine.  I read in the papers today what Henry Ward
    Beecher, whom I regard as the most intellectual preacher in the pulpit
    of the United States--I will read from the paper what he said
    yesterday, and you will see an abstract of it in the New York Times of
    today.  He has had the courage, and he has had the magnificent manhood,
    to say:
    
    "I say to you, and I swear to you, by the wounds in the hands of
    Christ--I swear to you by the wounds in the body and feet of Christ,
    that this doctrine of eternal hell is a most infamous nightmare of
    theology!  It never should be preached again."
    
    What right have you, sir; you, minister, as you are, to stand at the
    portal of eternity, or the portal of the tomb, and fill the future with
    horror and with fear?  You have no right to do it.  I don't believe it,
    and neither do you.  You would not sleep one night.  Any man who
    believes it, who has got a decent heart in his bosom, will go insane.
    Yes, sir, a man that really believes that doctrine and does not go
    insane, has got the conscience of a snake and the intellect of a hyena.
    O! I thank my stars that you do not believe it.  You cannot believe it,
    and you never will believe it.  Old Jonathan Edwards, the dear old
    soul, he is in heaven I suppose, said:  "Can the believing husband in
    heaven be happy with his unbelieving wife in hell?  Can the believing
    father in heaven be happy with his unbelieving children in hell? Can
    the loving wife in heaven be happy with her unbelieving husband in
    hell?  I tell you yea.  Such will be their sense of justice that it
    will increase rather than diminish their happiness."
    
    Think of these infamous doctrines that have been taught in the name of
    religion!  Do not stuff these things into the minds of your children.
    Give them a chance.  Let them read.  Let them think.  Do not treat your
    children like posts, to be set in the orthodox road, but like trees,
    that need light and sun and air. Be honest with them.  Be fair with
    them.  In old times they used to make all children go to bed when they
    were not sleepy, and all of them got up when they were sleepy.  I say
    let them go to bed--when they are sleepy and get up when they are not.
    But they say that will do for the rich, but not for the poor.  Well, if
    the poor have to wake their children early in the morning, it is as
    easy to wake them with a kiss as with a club.  I believe in letting
    children commence at which end of the dinner they want to.
    
    Let them eat what they want.  It is their business.  They know what
    they want to eat.  And if they have had their liberty from the first,
    they can beat any doctor in the world.  All the improvement that has
    ever been made in medicine has been made by the recklessness of
    patients. Yes, sir.  Thousands and thousands of years the doctors
    wouldn't let a man have water in fever. Every now and then some fellow
    got reckless and said:  "I will die, I am so thirsty," and drank two or
    three quarts of water and got well.  And they kept that up until
    finally the doctors said, "that is the best thing for a fever you can
    do."
    
    I have more confidence to agree with nature about these things than any
    of the conclusions of the schools.  Just let your children have
    freedom, and they will fall right into your ways and do just as you do.
    But you try to make them, and there is some magnificent, splendid thing
    in the human heart that will not be driven.  And do you know it is the
    luckiest thing for this world that ever happened that people are so.
    What would we have been if the people in any age of the world had done
    just as the doctors told them?  They would have been all dead.  What
    would we have done if, at any age of the world, we had followed
    implicitly the direction of the church?  We would have been all idiots,
    every one.
    
    It is a splendid thing that there is always some fellow who won't mind,
    and will think for himself.  And I believe in letting children think
    for themselves.  I believe in having a family like a democracy.  If
    there is anything splendid in this world it is a home of that kind.
    They used to tell us, "Let your victuals close your mouth."  We used to
    eat as though it was a religious performance.  I like to see the
    children about, and every one telling what he has seen and heard.  I
    like to hear the clatter of the knives and spoons mingling with the
    laughter of their voices.  I had rather hear it than any opera that has
    ever been put upon the boards.  Let them have liberty; let them have
    freedom, and I tell you your children will love you to death.
    
    Now, I have some excuses to offer for the race to which I belong. I
    have two.  My first excuse is that this is not a very good world to
    raise folks in anyway.  It is not very well adapted to raising
    magnificent people.  There's only a quarter of it land to start with.
    It is three times better fitted for raising fish than folks, and in
    that one quarter of land there is not a tenth part fit to raise people
    on.  You can't raise people without a good climate.  You have got to
    have the right kind of climate, and you have got to have certain
    elements in the soil, or you can't raise good people.  Do you know that
    there is only a little zig-zag strip around the world within which have
    been produced all men of genius?
    
    The southern hemisphere has never produced a man of genius, never; and
    never will until civilization, fighting the heat that way and the cold
    this, widens this portion of the earth until it is capable of producing
    great men and great women.  It is the same with men that it is with
    vegetation; you go into a garden, and find there flowers growing.  And
    as you go up the mountain, the birch and the hemlock and the spruce are
    to be found.  And as you go toward the top, you find little, stunted
    trees getting a miserable subsistence out of the crevices of the rocks,
    and you go on up and up and up, until finally you find at the top
    little moss-like freckles.  You might as well try to raise flowers
    where those freckles grow as to raise great men and women where you
    haven't got the soil.
    
    I don't believe man ever came to any high station without woman. There
    has got to be some restraint, something to make you prudent, something
    to make you industrious.  And in a country where you don't need any bed
    quilt but a cloud, revolution is the normal condition of the people.
    You have got to have the fireside; you have got to have the home, and
    there by the fireside will grow and bloom the fruits of the human race.
    I recollect a while ago I was in Washington when they were trying to
    annex Santo Domingo.  They said:  "We want to take in Santo Domingo."
    Said I:   "We don't want it."  "Why," said they, "it is the best
    climate the earth can produce.  There is everything you want."  "Yes,"
    said I, "but it won't produce men. We don't want it.  We have got soil
    enough now.  Take 5,000 ministers from New England, 5,000 presidents of
    colleges, and 5,000 solid business men, and their families, and take
    them to Santo Domingo; and then you will see the effect of climate. The
    second generation, you will see barefooted boys riding bareback on a
    mule, with their hair sticking out of the top of their sombreros, with
    a rooster under each arm, going to a cock-fight on Sunday."
    
    You have got to have the soil; you have got to have the climate, and
    you have got to have another thing--you have got to have the fireside.
    That is one excuse I have for us.
    
    The next excuse is that I think we came up from the lower animals.
    Else how can you account for all this snake and hyena and jackal in
    man? Now, when I first heard that doctrine, I didn't like it.  I felt
    sorry for people who had nothing but ancestors to be proud of.  It
    touched my heart to think that they would have to go back to the Duke
    Orangutan or the Duchess Chimpanzee.  I was sorry, and I hated to
    believe it.  I don't know that it is the truth now.  I am not satisfied
    upon that question; I stand about eight to seven.  I thought it over.
    I read about it.  I read about these rudimentary bones and muscles. I
    didn't like that.  I read that everybody had rudimentary muscles coming
    from the ear right down here (indicating); that the most intellectual
    people in the world have got them.  I say, "What are they?"
    "Rudimentary muscles."  "What kind of muscles?" "Muscles that your
    ancestors used to have fully developed." "What for?"  "To flap their
    ears with."
    
    Well, whether we ever had them or not, I know of lots of men who ought
    to have them yet.  And finally I said, "Well, I guess we came up from
    the lower animals."  I thought it all over; the best I could, and I
    said, "I guess we did."  And after a while I began to like it, and I
    like it better now than I did before.
    
    Do you know that I would rather belong to a race that started with
    skull-less vertebrae in the dim Laurentian seas, wiggling without
    knowing why they wiggled, swimming without knowing where they were
    going; but kept developing and getting a little further up and a little
    further up, all through the animal world, and finally striking this
    chap in the dug-out.  A getting a little bigger, and this fellow
    calling that fellow a heretic, and that fellow calling the other an
    infidel, and so on.  For in the history of the world, the man who has
    been ahead has always been called a heretic.  Recollect this!  I would
    rather come from a race that started from that skull-less vertebrae,
    and came up and up and up, and finally produced Shakespeare, who found
    the human intellect wallowing in a hut, and touched it with a wand of
    his genius, and it became a palace--dome and pinnacle.  I would rather
    belong to a race that commenced then, and produced Shakespeare, with
    the eternal hope of an infinite future for the children of progress
    leading from the far horizon, beckoning men forward--forward and onward
    forever.  I had rather belong to this race, and commence there, with
    that hope, than to have sprung from a perfect pair on which the Lord
    has lost money every day since.
    
    These are the excuses I have for my race.
    
    Now, my friends, let me say another thing.  I do not pretend to have
    floated even with the heights of thought; I do not pretend to have
    fathomed the abyss.  All I pretend is to give simply my honest thought.
    Every creed that we have today has upon it the mark of whip and chain
    and fagot.  I do not want it.  Free labor will give us wealth, and has
    given us wealth, and why?  Because a free brain goes into partnership
    with a free hand.  That is why. And when a man works for his wife and
    children, the problem of liberty is, how to do the most work in the
    shortest space of time; but the problem of slavery is, how to do the
    least work in the longest space of time.  Slavery is poverty; liberty
    is wealth.
    
    It is the same in thought.  Free thought will give us truth; and the
    man who is not in favor of free thought occupies the same relation to
    those he can govern that the slaveholder occupied to his slaves,
    exactly.  Free thought will give us wealth.  There has not been a
    generation of free thought yet.
    
    It will be time to write a creed when there have been a few generations
    of free-brained men and splendid women in this world. I don't know what
    the future may bring forth; I don't know what inventions are in the
    brain of the future; I don't know what garments may be woven, with the
    years to come; but I do know, coming from the infinite sea of the
    future, there will never touch this "bank and shoal of time" a greater
    blessing, a grander glory, than liberty for man, woman and child.
    
    Oh, liberty!  Float not forever in the far horizon!  Remain not forever
    in the dream of the enthusiast and the poet and the philanthropist!
    But come and take up thine abode with the children of men forever!
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll - Latest
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Lectures of Col. R. G. Ingersoll - Latest
    
    Author: Robert Green Ingersoll
    
    
            
    Release date: June 1, 2005 [eBook #8389]
                    Most recently updated: December 26, 2020
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/8389
    
    Credits: Produced by Jake Jaqua.  HTML version by Al Haines.
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #8389. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 8389
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.