Gutenberg · e01.org

← catalogue

The Evolution of Man — Volume 2

by Ernst Haeckel · English · Gutenberg #6710 · 660,142 chars · public domain (US)

The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Evolution of Man — Volume 2
    
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.

Title: The Evolution of Man — Volume 2

Author: Ernst Haeckel

Translator: Joseph McCabe


        
Release date: October 1, 2004 [eBook #6710]
                Most recently updated: December 29, 2020

Language: English

Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/6710

Credits: Produced by Sue Asscher


*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE EVOLUTION OF MAN — VOLUME 2 ***




Produced by Sue Asscher <asschers@bigpond.com>




THE EVOLUTION OF MAN

A POPULAR SCIENTIFIC STUDY


BY

ERNST HAECKEL

VOLUME 2.

HUMAN STEM-HISTORY, OR PHYLOGENY.



TRANSLATED FROM THE FIFTH (ENLARGED) EDITION BY JOSEPH MCCABE.



[ISSUED FOR THE RATIONALIST PRESS ASSOCIATION, LIMITED.]




WATTS & CO.,
17, JOHNSON'S COURT, FLEET STREET, LONDON, E.C.
1911.




CONTENTS OF VOLUME 2.


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.


INDEX.


CHAPTER 2.16. STRUCTURE OF THE LANCELET AND THE SEA-SQUIRT.


CHAPTER 2.17. EMBRYOLOGY OF THE LANCELET AND THE SEA-SQUIRT.


CHAPTER 2.18. DURATION OF THE HISTORY OF OUR STEM.


CHAPTER 2.19. OUR PROTIST ANCESTORS.


CHAPTER 2.20. OUR WORM-LIKE ANCESTORS.


CHAPTER 2.21. OUR FISH-LIKE ANCESTORS.


CHAPTER 2.22. OUR FIVE-TOED ANCESTORS.


CHAPTER 2.23. OUR APE ANCESTORS.


CHAPTER 2.24. EVOLUTION OF THE NERVOUS SYSTEM.


CHAPTER 2.25. EVOLUTION OF THE SENSE-ORGANS.


CHAPTER 2.26. EVOLUTION OF THE ORGANS OF MOVEMENT.


CHAPTER 2.27. EVOLUTION OF THE ALIMENTARY SYSTEM.


CHAPTER 2.28. EVOLUTION OF THE VASCULAR SYSTEM.


CHAPTER 2.29. EVOLUTION OF THE SEXUAL ORGANS.


CHAPTER 2.30. RESULTS OF ANTHROPOGENY.


LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.

FIGURE 2.210. THE LANCELET.

FIGURE 2.211. SECTION OF THE HEAD OF THE LANCELET.

FIGURE 2.212. SECTION OF AN AMPHIOXUS-LARVA.

FIGURE 2.213. DIAGRAM OF PRECEDING.

FIGURE 2.214. SECTION OF A YOUNG AMPHIOXUS.

FIGURE 2.215. DIAGRAM OF A YOUNG AMPHIOXUS.

FIGURE 2.216. TRANSVERSE SECTION OF LANCELET.

FIGURE 2.217. SECTION THROUGH THE MIDDLE OF THE LANCELET.

FIGURE 2.218. SECTION OF A PRIMITIVE-FISH EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.219. SECTION OF THE HEAD OF THE LANCELET.

FIGURES 2.220 AND 2.221. ORGANISATION OF AN ASCIDIA.

FIGURES 2.222 TO 2.224. SECTIONS OF YOUNG AMPHIOXUS-LARVAE.

FIGURE 2.225. AN APPENDICARIA.

FIGURE 2.226. Chroococcus minor.

FIGURE 2.227. Aphanocapsa primordialis.

FIGURE 2.228. PROTAMOEBA.

FIGURE 2.229. ORIGINAL OVUM-CLEAVAGE.

FIGURE 2.230. MORULA.

FIGURES 2.231 AND 2.232. Magosphaera planula.

FIGURE 2.233. MODERN GASTRAEADS.

FIGURES 2.234 AND 2.235. Prophysema primordiale.

FIGURES 2.236 AND 2.237. Ascula of Gastrophysema.

FIGURE 2.238. Olynthus.

FIGURE 2.239. Aphanostomum Langii.

FIGURES 2.240 AND 2.241. A TURBELLARIAN.

FIGURES 2.242 AND 2.243. Chaetonotus.

FIGURE 2.244. A NEMERTINE WORM.

FIGURE 2.245. AN ENTEROPNEUST.

FIGURE 2.246. SECTION OF THE BRANCHIAL GUT.

FIGURE 2.247. THE MARINE LAMPREY.

FIGURE 2.248. FOSSIL PRIMITIVE FISH.

FIGURE 2.249. EMBRYO OF A SHARK.

FIGURE 2.250. MAN-EATING SHARK.

FIGURE 2.251. FOSSIL ANGEL-SHARK.

FIGURE 2.252. TOOTH OF A GIGANTIC SHARK.

FIGURES 2.253 TO 2.255. CROSSOPTERYGII.

FIGURE 2.256. FOSSIL DIPNEUST.

FIGURE 2.257. THE AUSTRALIAN DIPNEUST.

FIGURES 2.258 AND 2.259. YOUNG CERATODUS.

FIGURE 2.260. FOSSIL AMPHIBIAN.

FIGURE 2.261. LARVA OF THE SPOTTED SALAMANDER.

FIGURE 2.262. LARVA OF COMMON FROG.

FIGURE 2.263. FOSSIL MAILED AMPHIBIAN.

FIGURE 2.264. THE NEW ZEALAND LIZARD.

FIGURE 2.265. Homoeosaurus pulchellus.

FIGURE 2.266. SKULL OF A PERMIAN LIZARD.

FIGURE 2.267. SKULL OF A THEROMORPHUM.

FIGURE 2.268. LOWER JAW OF A PRIMITIVE MAMMAL.

FIGURES 2.269 AND 2.270. THE ORNITHORHYNCUS.

FIGURE 2.271. LOWER JAW OF A PROMAMMAL.

FIGURE 2.272. THE CRAB-EATING OPOSSUM.

FIGURE 2.273. FOETAL MEMBRANES OF THE HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.274. SKULL OF A FOSSIL LEMUR.

FIGURE 2.275. THE SLENDER LORI.

FIGURE 2.276. THE WHITE-NOSED APE.

FIGURE 2.277. THE DRILL-BABOON.

FIGURES 2.278 TO 2.282. SKELETONS OF MAN AND THE ANTHROPOID APES.

FIGURE 2.283. SKULL OF THE JAVA APE-MAN.

FIGURE 2.284. SECTION OF THE HUMAN SKIN.

FIGURE 2.285. EPIDERMIC CELLS.

FIGURE 2.286. RUDIMENTARY LACHRYMAL GLANDS.

FIGURE 2.287. THE FEMALE BREAST.

FIGURE 2.288. MAMMARY GLAND OF A NEW-BORN INFANT.

FIGURE 2.289. EMBRYO OF A BEAR.

FIGURE 2.290. HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.291. CENTRAL MARROW OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.292 AND 2.293. THE HUMAN BRAIN.

FIGURES 2.294 TO 2.296. CENTRAL MARROW OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.297. HEAD OF A CHICK EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.298. BRAIN OF THREE CRANIOTE EMBRYOS.

FIGURE 2.299. BRAIN OF A SHARK.

FIGURE 2.300. BRAIN AND SPINAL CORD OF A FROG.

FIGURE 2.301. BRAIN OF AN OX-EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.302 AND 2.303. BRAIN OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.304. BRAIN OF THE RABBIT.

FIGURE 2.305. HEAD OF A SHARK.

FIGURES 2.306 TO 2.310. HEADS OF CHICK-EMBRYOS.

FIGURE 2.311. SECTION OF MOUTH OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.312. DIAGRAM OF MOUTH-NOSE CAVITY.

FIGURES 2.313 AND 2.314. HEADS OF HUMAN EMBRYOS.

FIGURES 2.315 AND 2.316. FACE OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.317. THE HUMAN EYE.

FIGURE 2.318. EYE OF THE CHICK EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.319. SECTION OF EYE OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.320. THE HUMAN EAR.

FIGURE 2.321. THE BONY LABYRINTH.

FIGURE 2.322. DEVELOPMENT OF THE LABYRINTH.

FIGURE 2.323. PRIMITIVE SKULL OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.324. RUDIMENTARY MUSCLES OF THE EAR.

FIGURES 2.325 AND 2.326. THE HUMAN SKELETON.

FIGURE 2.327. THE HUMAN VERTEBRAL COLUMN.

FIGURE 2.328. PIECE OF THE DORSAL CORD.

FIGURES 2.329 AND 2.330. DORSAL VERTEBRAE.

FIGURE 2.331. INTERVERTEBRAL DISK.

FIGURE 2.332. HUMAN SKULL.

FIGURE 2.333. SKULL OF NEW-BORN CHILD.

FIGURE 2.334. HEAD-SKELETON OF A PRIMITIVE FISH.

FIGURE 2.335. SKULLS OF NINE PRIMATES.

FIGURES 2.336 TO 2.338. EVOLUTION OF THE FIN.

FIGURE 2.339. SKELETON OF THE FORE-LEG OF AN AMPHIBIAN.

FIGURE 2.340. SKELETON OF GORILLA'S HAND.

FIGURE 2.341. SKELETON OF HUMAN HAND.

FIGURE 2.342. SKELETON OF HAND OF SIX MAMMALS.

FIGURES 2.343 TO 2.345. ARM AND HAND OF THREE ANTHROPOIDS.

FIGURE 2.346. SECTION OF FISH'S TAIL.

FIGURE 2.347. HUMAN SKELETON.

FIGURE 2.348. SKELETON OF THE GIANT GORILLA.

FIGURE 2.349. THE HUMAN STOMACH.

FIGURE 2.350. SECTION OF THE HEAD OF A RABBIT-EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.351. SHARK'S TEETH.

FIGURE 2.352. GUT OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.353 AND 2.354. GUT OF A DOG EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.355 AND 2.356. SECTIONS OF HEAD OF LAMPREY.

FIGURE 2.357. VISCERA OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.358. RED BLOOD-CELLS.

FIGURE 2.359. VASCULAR TISSUE.

FIGURE 2.360. SECTION OF TRUNK OF A CHICK-EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.361. MEROCYTES.

FIGURE 2.362. VASCULAR SYSTEM OF AN ANNELID.

FIGURE 2.363. HEAD OF A FISH-EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.364 TO 2.370. THE FIVE ARTERIAL ARCHES.

FIGURES 2.371 AND 2.372. HEART OF A RABBIT-EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.373 AND 2.374. HEART OF A DOG-EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.375 TO 2.377. HEART OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.378. HEART OF ADULT MAN.

FIGURE 2.379. SECTION OF HEAD OF A CHICK-EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.380. SECTION OF A HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.381 AND 2.382. SECTIONS OF A CHICK-EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.383. EMBRYOS OF SAGITTA.

FIGURE 2.384. KIDNEYS OF BDELLOSTOMA.

FIGURE 2.385. SECTION OF EMBRYONIC SHIELD.

FIGURES 2.386 AND 2.387. PRIMITIVE KIDNEYS.

FIGURE 2.388. PIG-EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.389. HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.390 TO 2.392. RUDIMENTARY KIDNEYS AND SEXUAL ORGANS.

FIGURES 2.393 AND 2.394. URINARY AND SEXUAL ORGANS OF SALAMANDER.

FIGURE 2.395. PRIMITIVE KIDNEYS OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURES 2.396 TO 2.398. URINARY ORGANS OF OX-EMBRYOS.

FIGURE 2.399. SEXUAL ORGANS OF WATER-MOLE.

FIGURES 2.400 AND 2.401. ORIGINAL POSITION OF SEXUAL GLANDS.

FIGURE 2.402. UROGENITAL SYSTEM OF HUMAN EMBRYO.

FIGURE 2.403. SECTION OF OVARY.

FIGURES 2.404 TO 2.406. GRAAFIAN FOLLICLES.

FIGURE 2.407. A RIPE GRAAFIAN FOLLICLE.

FIGURE 2.408. THE HUMAN OVUM.




CHAPTER 2.16. STRUCTURE OF THE LANCELET AND THE SEA-SQUIRT.

In turning from the embryology to the phylogeny of man--from the
development of the individual to that of the species--we must bear in
mind the direct causal connection that exists between these two main
branches of the science of human evolution. This important causal
nexus finds its simplest expression in "the fundamental law of organic
development," the content and purport of which we have fully
considered in the first chapter. According to this biogenetic law,
ontogeny is a brief and condensed recapitulation of phylogeny. If this
compendious reproduction were complete in all cases, it would be very
easy to construct the whole story of evolution on an embryonic basis.
When we wanted to know the ancestors of any higher organism, and,
therefore, of man--to know from what forms the race as a whole has
been evolved we should merely have to follow the series of forms in
the development of the individual from the ovum; we could then regard
each of the successive forms as the representative of an extinct
ancestral form. However, this direct application of ontogenetic facts
to phylogenetic ideas is possible, without limitations, only in a very
small section of the animal kingdom. There are, it is true, still a
number of lower invertebrates (for instance, some of the Zoophyta and
Vermalia) in which we are justified in recognising at once each
embryonic form as the historical reproduction, or silhouette, as it
were, of an extinct ancestor. But in the great majority of the
animals, and in the case of man, this is impossible, because the
embryonic forms themselves have been modified through the change of
the conditions of existence, and have lost their original character to
some extent. During the immeasurable course of organic history, the
many millions of years during which life was developing on our planet,
secondary changes of the embryonic forms have taken place in most
animals. The young of animals (not only detached larvae, but also the
embryos enclosed in the womb) may be modified by the influence of the
environment, just as well as the mature organisms are by adaptation to
the conditions of life; even species are altered during the embryonic
development. Moreover, it is an advantage for all higher organisms
(and the advantage is greater the more advanced they are) to curtail
and simplify the original course of development, and thus to
obliterate the traces of their ancestors. The higher the individual
organism is in the animal kingdom, the less completely does it
reproduce in its embryonic development the series of its ancestors,
for reasons that are as yet only partly known to us. The fact is
easily proved by comparing the different developments of higher and
lower animals in any single stem.

In order to appreciate this important feature, we have distributed the
embryological phenomena in two groups, palingenetic and cenogenetic.
Under palingenesis we count those facts of embryology that we can
directly regard as a faithful synopsis of the corresponding
stem-history. By cenogenesis we understand those embryonic processes
which we cannot directly correlate with corresponding evolutionary
processes, but must regard as modifications or falsifications of them.
With this careful discrimination between palingenetic and cenogenetic
phenomena, our biogenetic law assumes the following more precise
shape:--The rapid and brief development of the individual (ontogeny)
is a condensed synopsis of the long and slow history of the stem
(phylogeny): this synopsis is the more faithful and complete in
proportion as the original features have been preserved by heredity,
and modifications have not been introduced by adaptation.

In order to distinguish correctly between palingenetic and cenogenetic
phenomena in embryology, and deduce sound conclusions in connection
with stem-history, we must especially make a comparative study of the
former. In doing this it is best to employ the methods that have long
been used by geologists for the purpose of establishing the succession
of the sedimentary rocks in the crust of the earth. This solid crust,
which encloses the glowing central mass like a thin shell, is composed
of different kinds of rocks: there are, firstly, the volcanic rocks
which were formed directly by the cooling at the surface of the molten
mass of the earth; secondly, there are the sedimentary rocks, that
have been made out of the former by the action of water, and have been
laid in successive strata at the bottom of the sea. Each of these
sedimentary strata was at first a soft layer of mud; but in the course
of thousands of years it condensed into a solid, hard mass of stone
(sandstone, limestone, marl, etc.), and at the same time permanently
preserved the solid and imperishable bodies that had chanced to fall
into the soft mud. Among these bodies, which were either fossilised or
left characteristic impressions of their forms in the soft slime, we
have especially the more solid parts of the animals and plants that
lived and died during the deposit of the slimy strata.

Hence each of the sedimentary strata has its characteristic fossils,
the remains of the animals and plants that lived during that
particular period of the earth's history. When we make a comparative
study of these strata, we can survey the whole series of such periods.
All geologists are now agreed that we can demonstrate a definite
historical succession in the strata, and that the lowest of them were
deposited in very remote, and the uppermost in comparatively recent,
times. However, there is no part of the earth where we find the series
of strata in its entirety, or even approximately complete. The
succession of strata and of corresponding historical periods generally
given in geology is an ideal construction, formed by piecing together
the various partial discoveries of the succession of strata that have
been made at different points of the earth's surface (cf. Chapter
2.18).

We must act in this way in constructing the phylogeny of man. We must
try to piece together a fairly complete picture of the series of our
ancestors from the various phylogenetic fragments that we find in the
different groups of the animal kingdom. We shall see that we are
really in a position to form an approximate picture of the evolution
of man and the mammals by a proper comparison of the embryology of
very different animals--a picture that we could never have framed from
the ontogeny of the mammals alone. As a result of the above-mentioned
cenogenetic processes--those of disturbed and curtailed
heredity--whole series of lower stages have dropped out in the
embryonic development of man and the other mammals especially from the
earliest periods, or been falsified by modification. But we find these
lower stages in their original purity in the lower vertebrates and
their invertebrate ancestors. Especially in the lowest of all the
vertebrates, the lancelet or Amphioxus, we have the oldest stem-forms
completely preserved in the embryonic development. We also find
important evidence in the fishes, which stand between the lower and
higher vertebrates, and throw further light on the course of evolution
in certain periods. Next to the fishes come the amphibia, from the
embryology of which we can also draw instructive conclusions. They
represent the transition to the higher vertebrates, in which the
middle and older stages of ancestral development have been either
distorted or curtailed, but in which we find the more recent stages of
the phylogenetic process well preserved in ontogeny. We are thus in a
position to form a fairly complete idea of the past development of
man's ancestors within the vertebrate stem by putting together and
comparing the embryological developments of the various groups of
vertebrates. And when we go below the lowest vertebrates and compare
their embryology with that of their invertebrate relatives, we can
follow the genealogical tree of our animal ancestors much farther,
down to the very lowest groups of animals.

In entering the obscure paths of this phylogenetic labyrinth, clinging
to the Ariadne-thread of the biogenetic law and guided by the light of
comparative anatomy, we will first, in accordance with the methods we
have adopted, discover and arrange those fragments from the manifold
embryonic developments of very different animals from which the
stem-history of man can be composed. I would call attention
particularly to the fact that we can employ this method with the same
confidence and right as the geologist. No geologist has ever had
ocular proof that the vast rocks that compose our Carboniferous or
Jurassic or Cretaceous strata were really deposited in water. Yet no
one doubts the fact. Further, no geologist has ever learned by direct
observation that these various sedimentary formations were deposited
in a certain order; yet all are agreed as to this order. This is
because the nature and origin of these rocks cannot be rationally
understood unless we assume that they were so deposited. These
hypotheses are universally received as safe and indispensable
"geological theories," because they alone give a rational explanation
of the strata.

Our evolutionary hypotheses can claim the same value, for the same
reasons. In formulating them we are acting on the same inductive and
deductive methods, and with almost equal confidence, as the geologist.
We hold them to be correct, and claim the status of "biological
theories" for them, because we cannot understand the nature and origin
of man and the other organisms without them, and because they alone
satisfy our demand for a knowledge of causes. And just as the
geological hypotheses that were ridiculed as dreams at the beginning
of the nineteenth century are now universally admitted, so our
phylogenetic hypotheses, which are still regarded as fantastic in
certain quarters, will sooner or later be generally received. It is
true that, as will soon appear, our task is not so simple as that of
the geologist. It is just as much more difficult and complex as man's
organisation is more elaborate than the structure of the rocks.

When we approach this task, we find an auxiliary of the utmost
importance in the comparative anatomy and embryology of two lower
animal-forms. One of these animals is the lancelet (Amphioxus), the
other the sea-squirt (Ascidia). Both of these animals are very
instructive. Both are at the border between the two chief divisions of
the animal kingdom--the vertebrates and invertebrates. The vertebrates
comprise the already mentioned classes, from the Amphioxus to man
(acrania, lampreys, fishes, dipneusts, amphibia, reptiles, birds, and
mammals). Following the example of Lamarck, it is usual to put all the
other animals together under the head of invertebrates. But, as I have
often mentioned already, the group is composed of a number of very
different stems. Of these we have no interest just now in the
echinoderms, molluscs, and articulates, as they are independent
branches of the animal-tree, and have nothing to do with the
vertebrates. On the other hand, we are greatly concerned with a very
interesting group that has only recently been carefully studied, and
that has a most important relation to the ancestral tree of the
vertebrates. This is the stem of the Tunicates. One member of this
group, the sea-squirt, very closely approaches the lowest vertebrate,
the Amphioxus, in its essential internal structure and embryonic
development. Until 1866 no one had any idea of the close connection of
these apparently very different animals; it was a very fortunate
accident that the embryology of these related forms was discovered
just at the time when the question of the descent of the vertebrates
from the invertebrates came to the front. In order to understand it
properly, we must first consider these remarkable animals in their
fully-developed forms and compare their anatomy.

We begin with the lancelet--after man the most important and
interesting of all animals. Man is at the highest summit, the lancelet
at the lowest root, of the vertebrate stem.

It lives on the flat, sandy parts of the Mediterranean coast, partly
buried in the sand, and is apparently found in a number of seas.* (*
See the ample monograph by Arthur Willey, Amphioxus and the Ancestry
of the Vertebrates; Boston, 1894.) It has been found in the North Sea
(on the British and Scandinavian coasts and in Heligoland), and at
various places on the Mediterranean (for instance, at Nice, Naples,
and Messina). It is also found on the coast of Brazil and in the most
distant parts of the Pacific Ocean (the coast of Peru, Borneo, China,
Australia, etc.). Recently eight to ten species of the amphioxus have
been determined, distributed in two or three genera.

(FIGURE 2.210. The lancelet (Amphioxus lanceolatus), twice natural
size, left view. The long axis is vertical; the mouth-end is above,
the tail-end below; a mouth, surrounded by threads of beard; b anus, c
gill-opening (porus branchialis), d gill-crate, e stomach, f liver, g
small intestine, h branchial cavity, i chorda (axial rod), underneath
it the aorta; k aortic arches, l trunk of the branchial artery, m
swellings on its branches, n vena cava, o visceral vein.

FIGURE 2.211. Transverse section of the head of the Amphioxus. (From
Boveri.) Above the branchial gut (kd) is the chorda, above this the
neural tube (in which we can distinguish the inner grey and the outer
white matter); above again is the dorsal fin (fh). To the right and
left above (in the episoma) are the thick muscular plates (m); below
(in the hyposoma) the gonads (g). ao aorta (here double), c corium, ec
endostyl, f fascie, gl glomerulus of the kidneys, k branchial vessel,
ld partition between the coeloma (sc) and atrium (p), mt transverse
ventral muscle, n renal canals, of upper and uf lower canals in the
mantle-folds, p peribranchial cavity, (atrium), sc coeloma (subchordal
body-cavity), si principal (or subintestinal) vein, sk perichorda
(skeletal layer).)

Johannes Muller classed the lancelet with the fishes, although he
pointed out that the differences between this simple vertebrate and
the lowest fishes are much greater than between the fishes and the
amphibia. But this was far from expressing the real significance of
the animal. We may confidently lay down the following principle: The
Amphioxus differs more from the fishes than the fishes do from man and
the other vertebrates. As a matter of fact, it is so different from
all the other vertebrates in its whole organisation that the laws of
logical classification compel us to distinguish two divisions of this
stem: 1, the Acrania (Amphioxus and its extinct relatives); and 2, the
Craniota (man and the other vertebrates). The first and lower division
comprises the vertebrates that have no vertebrae or skull (cranium).
Of these the only living representatives are the Amphioxus and
Paramphioxus, though there must have been a number of different
species at an early period of the earth's history.

Opposed to the Acrania is the second division of the vertebrates,
which comprises all the other members of the stem, from the fishes up
to man. All these vertebrates have a head quite distinct from the
trunk, with a skull (cranium) and brain; all have a centralised heart,
fully-formed kidneys, etc. Hence they are called the Craniota. These
Craniotes are, however, without a skull in their earlier period. As we
already know from embryology, even man, like every other mammal,
passes in the earlier course of his development through the important
stage which we call the chordula; at this lower stage the animal has
neither vertebrae nor skull nor limbs (Figures 1.83 to 1.86). And even
after the formation of the primitive vertebrae has begun, the
segmented foetus of the amniotes still has for a long time the simple
form of a lyre-shaped disk or a sandal, without limbs or extremities.
When we compare this embryonic condition, the sandal-shaped foetus,
with the developed lancelet, we may say that the amphioxus is, in a
certain sense, a permanent sandal-embryo, or a permanent embryonic
form of the Acrania; it never rises above a low grade of development
which we have long since passed.

The fully-developed lancelet (Figure 2.210) is about two inches long,
is colourless or of a light red tint, and has the shape of a narrow
lancet-formed leaf. The body is pointed at both ends, but much
compressed at the sides. There is no trace of limbs. The outer skin is
very thin and delicate, naked, transparent, and composed of two
different layers, a simple external stratum of cells, the epidermis,
and a thin underlying cutis-layer. Along the middle line of the back
runs a narrow fin-fringe which expands behind into an oval tail-fin,
and is continued below in a short anus-fin. The fin-fringe is
supported by a number of square elastic fin-plates.

In the middle of the body we find a thin string of cartilage, which
goes the whole length of the body from front to back, and is pointed
at both ends (Figure 2.210 i). This straight, cylindrical rod
(somewhat compressed for a time) is the axial rod or the chorda
dorsalis; in the lancelet this is the only trace of a vertebral
column. The chorda develops no further, but retains its original
simplicity throughout life. It is enclosed by a firm membrane, the
chorda-sheath or perichorda. The real features of this and of its
dependent formations are best seen in the transverse section of the
Amphioxus (Figure 2.211). The perichorda forms a cylindrical tube
immediately over the chorda, and the central nervous system, the
medullary tube, is enclosed in it. This important psychic organ also
remains in its simplest shape throughout life, as a cylindrical tube,
terminating with almost equal plainness at either end, and enclosing a
narrow canal in its thick wall. However, the fore end is a little
rounder, and contains a small, almost imperceptible bulbous swelling
of the canal. This must be regarded as the beginning of a rudimentary
brain. At the foremost end of it there is a small black pigment-spot,
a rudimentary eye; and a narrow canal leads to a superficial
sense-organ. In the vicinity of this optic spot we find at the left
side a small ciliated depression, the single olfactory organ. There is
no organ of hearing. This defective development of the higher
sense-organs is probably, in the main, not an original feature, but a
result of degeneration.

Underneath the axial rod or chorda runs a very simple alimentary
canal, a tube that opens on the ventral side of the animal by a mouth
in front and anus behind. The oval mouth is surrounded by a ring of
cartilage, on which there are twenty to thirty cartilaginous threads
(organs of touch, Figure 2.210 a). The alimentary canal divides into
sections of about equal length by a constriction in the middle. The
fore section, or head-gut, serves for respiration; the hind section,
or trunk-gut, for digestion. The limit of the two alimentary regions
is also the limit of the two parts of the body, the head and the
trunk. The head-gut or branchial gut forms a broad gill-crate, the
grilled wall of which is pierced by numbers of gill-clefts (Figure
2.210 d). The fine bars of the gill-crate between the clefts are
strengthened with firm parallel rods, and these are connected in pairs
by cross-rods. The water that enters the mouth of the Amphioxus passes
through these clefts into the large surrounding branchial cavity or
atrium, and then pours out behind through a hole in it, the
respiratory pore (porus branchialis, Figure 2.210 c). Below, on the
ventral side of the gill-crate, there is in the middle line a ciliated
groove with a glandular wall (the hypobranchial groove), which is also
found in the Ascidia and the larvae of the Cyclostoma. It is
interesting because the thyroid gland in the larynx of the higher
vertebrates (underneath the "Adam's apple") has been developed from
it.

(FIGURE 2.212. Transverse section of an Amphioxus-larva, with five
gill-clefts, through the middle of the body.

FIGURE 2.213. Diagram of the preceding. (From Hatschek.) A epidermis,
B medullary tube, C chorda, C1 inner chorda-sheath, D visceral
epithelium, E sub-intestinal vein. 1 cutis, 2 muscle-plate (myotome),
3 skeletal plate (sclerotome), 4 coeloseptum (partition between dorsal
and ventral coeloma), 5 skin-fibre layer, 6 gut-fibre layer, I myocoel
(dorsal body-cavity), II splanchnocoel (ventral body-cavity).)

Behind the respiratory part of the gut we have the digestive section,
the trunk or liver (hepatic) gut. The small particles that the
Amphioxus takes in with the water--infusoria, diatoms, particles of
decomposed plants and animals, etc.--pass from the gill-crate into the
digestive part of the canal, and are used up as food. From a somewhat
enlarged portion, that corresponds to the stomach (Figure 2.210 e), a
long, pouch-like blind sac proceeds straight forward (f); it lies
underneath on the left side of the gill-crate, and ends blindly about
the middle of it. This is the liver of the Amphioxus, the simplest
kind of liver that we meet in any vertebrate. In man also the liver
develops, as we shall see, in the shape of a pouch-like blind sac,
that forms out of the alimentary canal behind the stomach.

The formation of the circulatory system in this animal is not less
interesting. All the other vertebrates have a compressed, thick,
pouch-shaped heart, which develops from the wall of the gut at the
throat, and from which the blood-vessels proceed; in the Amphioxus
there is no special centralised heart, driving the blood by its
pulsations. This movement is effected, as in the annelids, by the thin
blood-vessels themselves, which discharge the function of the heart,
contracting and pulsating in their whole length, and thus driving the
colourless blood through the entire body. On the under-side of the
gill-crate, in the middle line, there is the trunk of a large vessel
that corresponds to the heart of the other vertebrates and the trunk
of the branchial artery that proceeds from it; this drives the blood
into the gills (Figure 2.210 l). A number of small vascular arches
arise on each side from this branchial artery, and form little
heart-shaped swellings or bulbilla (m) at their points of departure;
they advance along the branchial arches, between the gill-clefts and
the fore-gut, and unite, as branchial veins, above the gill-crate in a
large trunk blood-vessel that runs under the chorda dorsalis. This is
the principal artery or primitive aorta (Figure 2.214 D). The branches
which it gives off to all parts of the body unite again in a larger
venous vessel at the underside of the gut, called the subintestinal
vein (Figures 1.210 o and 2.212 E). This single main vessel of the
Amphioxus goes like a closed circular water-conduit along the
alimentary canal through the whole body, and pulsates in its whole
length above and below. When the upper tube contracts the lower one is
filled with blood, and vice versa. In the upper tube the blood flows
from front to rear, then back from rear to front in the lower vessel.
The whole of the long tube that runs along the ventral side of the
alimentary canal and contains venous blood may be called the
"principal vein," and may be compared to the ventral vessel in the
worms. On the other hand, the long straight vessel that runs along the
dorsal line of the gut above, between it and the chorda, and contains
arterial blood, is clearly identical with the aorta or principal
artery of the other vertebrates; and on the other side it may be
compared to the dorsal vessel in the worms.

(FIGURE 2.214. Transverse section of a young Amphioxus, immediately
after metamorphosis, through the hindermost third (between the
atrium-cavity and the anus).

FIGURE 2.215. Diagram of preceding. (From Hatschek.) A epidermis, B
medullary tube, C chorda, D aorta, E visceral epithelium, F
subintestinal vein. 1 corium-plate, 2 muscle-plate, 3 fascie-plate, 4
outer chorda-sheath, 5 myoseptum, 6 skin-fibre plate, 7 gut-fibre
plate, I myocoel, II splanchnocoel, I1 dorsal fin, I2 anus-fin.)

The coeloma or body-cavity has some very important and distinctive
features in the Amphioxus. The embryology of it is most instructive in
connection with the stem-history of the body-cavity in man and the
other vertebrates. As we have already seen (Chapter 1.10), in these
the two coelom-pouches are divided at an early stage by transverse
constrictions into a double row of primitive segments (Figure 1.124),
and each of these subdivides, by a frontal or lateral constriction,
into an upper (dorsal) and lower (ventral) pouch.

These important structures are seen very clearly in the trunk of the
amphioxus (the latter third, Figures 2.212 to 2.215), but it is
otherwise in the head, the foremost third (Figure 2.216). Here we find
a number of complicated structures that cannot be understood until we
have studied them on the embryological side in the next chapter (cf.
Figure 1.81). The branchial gut lies free in a spacious cavity filled
with water, which was wrongly thought formerly to be the body-cavity
(Figure 2.216 A). As a matter of fact, this atrium (commonly called
the peribranchial cavity) is a secondary structure formed by the
development of a couple of lateral mantle-folds or gill-covers (M1,
U). The real body-cavity (Lh) is very narrow and entirely closed,
lined with epithelium. The peribranchial cavity (A) is full of water,
and its walls are lined with the skin-sense layer; it opens outwards
in the rear through the respiratory pore (Figure 2.210 c).

On the inner surface of these mantle-folds (M1), in the ventral half
of the wide mantle cavity (atrium), we find the sex-organs of the
Amphioxus. At each side of the branchial gut there are between twenty
and thirty roundish four-cornered sacs, which can clearly be seen from
without with the naked eye, as they shine through the thin transparent
body-wall. These sacs are the sexual glands they are the same size and
shape in both sexes, only differing in contents. In the female they
contain a quantity of simple ova (Figure 2.219 g); in the male a
number of much smaller cells that change into mobile ciliated cells
(sperm-cells). Both sacs lie on the inner wall of the atrium, and have
no special outlets. When the ova of the female and the sperm of the
male are ripe, they fall into the atrium, pass through the gill-clefts
into the fore-gut, and are ejected through the mouth.

(FIGURE 2.216. Transverse section of the lancelet, in the fore half.
(From Ralph.) The outer covering is the simple cell-layer of the
epidermis (E). Under this is the thin corium, the subcutaneous tissue
of which is thickened; it sends connective-tissue partitions between
the muscles (M1) and to the chorda-sheath. N medullary tube, Ch
chorda, Lh body-cavity, A atrium, L upper wall of same, E1 inner wall,
E2 outer wall, Lh1 ventral remnant of same, Kst gill-reds, M ventral
muscles, R seam of the joining of the ventral folds (gill-covers), G
sexual glands.)

Above the sexual glands, at the dorsal angle of the atrium, we find
the kidneys. These important excretory organs could not be found in
the Amphioxus for a long time, on account of their remote position and
their smallness; they were discovered in 1890 by Theodor Boveri
(Figure 2.217 x). They are short segmented canals; corresponding to
the primitive kidneys of the other vertebrates (Figure 2.218 B). Their
internal aperture (Figure 2.217 B) opens into the body-cavity; their
outer aperture into the atrium (C). The prorenal canals lie in the
middle of the line of the head, outwards from the uppermost section of
the gill-arches, and have important relations to the branchial vessels
(H). For this reason, and in their whole arrangement, the primitive
kidneys of the Amphioxus show clearly that they are equivalent to the
prorenal canals of the Craniotes (Figure 2.218 B). The prorenal duct
of the latter (Figure 2.218 C) corresponds to the branchial cavity or
atrium of the former (Figure 2.217 C).

(FIGURE 2.217. Transverse section through the middle of the Amphioxus.
(From Boveri.) On the left a gill-rod has been struck, and on the
right a gill-cleft; consequently on the left we see the whole of a
prorenal canal (x), on the right only the section of its fore-leg. A
genital chamber (ventral section of the gonocoel), x pronephridium, B
its coelom-aperture, C atrium, D body-cavity, E visceral cavity, F
subintestinal vein, G aorta (the left branch connected by a branchial
vessel with the subintestinal vein), H renal vessel.

FIGURE 2.218. Transverse section of a primitive fish embryo
(Selachii-embryo, from Boveri.). To the left pronephridia (B), the
right primitive kidneys (A). The dotted lines on the right indicate
the later opening of the primitive kidney canals (A) into the prorenal
duct (C). D body-cavity, E visceral cavity, F subintestinal vein, G
aorta, H renal vessel.)

If we sum up the results of our anatomic study of the Amphioxus, and
compare them with the familiar organisation of man, we shall find an
immense distance between the two. As a fact, the highest summit of the
vertebrate organisation which man represents is in every respect so
far above the lowest stage, at which the lancelet remains, that one
would at first scarcely believe it possible to class both animals in
the same division of the animal kingdom. Nevertheless, this
classification is indisputably just. Man is only a more advanced stage
of the vertebral type that we find unmistakably in the Amphioxus in
its characteristic features. We need only recall the picture of the
ideal Primitive Vertebrate given in a former chapter, and compare it
with the lower stages of human embryonic development, to convince
ourselves of our close relationship to the lancelet. (Cf. Chapter
1.11.)

It is true that the Amphioxus is far below all other living
vertebrates. It is true that it has no separate head, no developed
brain or skull, the characteristic feature of the other vertebrates.
It is (probably as a result of degeneration) without the auscultory
organ and the centralised heart that all the others have; and it has
no fully-formed kidneys. Every single organ in it is simpler and less
advanced than in any of the others. Yet the characteristic connection
and arrangement of all the organs is just the same as in the other
vertebrates. All these, moreover, pass, during their embryonic
development, through a stage in which their whole organisation is no
higher than that of the Amphioxus, but is substantially identical with
it.

(FIGURE 2.219. Transverse section of the head of the Amphioxus (at the
limit of the first and second third of the body). (From Boveri) a
aorta (here double), b atrium, c chorda, co umlaut coeloma
(body-cavity), e endostyl (hypobranchial groove), g gonads (ovaries),
kb gill-arches, kd branchial gut, l liver-tube (on the right,
one-sided), m muscles, n renal canals, r spinal cord, sn spinal
nerves, sp gill-clefts.)

In order to see this quite clearly, it is particularly useful to
compare the Amphioxus with the youthful forms of those vertebrates
that are classified next to it. This is the class of the Cyclostoma.
There are to-day only a few species of this once extensive class, and
these may be distributed in two groups. One group comprises the
hag-fishes or Myxinoides. The other group are the Petromyzontes, or
lampreys, which are a familiar delicacy in their marine form. These
Cyclostoma are usually classified with the fishes. But they are far
below the true fishes, and form a very interesting connecting-group
between them and the lancelet. One can see how closely they approach
the latter by comparing a young lamprey with the Amphioxus. The chorda
is of the same simple character in both; also the medullary tube, that
lies above the chorda, and the alimentary canal below it. However, in
the lamprey the spinal cord swells in front into a simple pear-shaped
cerebral vesicle, and at each side of it there are a very simple eye
and a rudimentary auditory vesicle. The nose is a single pit, as in
the Amphioxus. The two sections of the gut are also just the same and
very rudimentary in the lamprey. On the other hand, we see a great
advance in the structure of the heart, which is found underneath the
gills in the shape of a centralised muscular tube, and is divided into
an auricle and a ventricle. Later on the lamprey advances still
further, and gets a skull, five cerebral vesicles, a series of
independent gill-pouches, etc. This makes all the more interesting the
striking resemblance of its immature larva to the developed and
sexually mature Amphioxus.

While the Amphioxus is thus connected through the Cyclostoma with the
fishes, and so with the series of the higher vertebrates, it is, on
the other hand, very closely related to a lowly invertebrate marine
animal, from which it seems to be entirely remote at first glance.
This remarkable animal is the sea-squirt or Ascidia, which was
formerly thought to be closely related to the mussel, and so classed
in the molluscs. But since the remarkable embryology of these animals
was discovered in 1866, there can be no question that they have
nothing to do with the molluscs. To the great astonishment of
zoologists, they were found, in their whole individual development, to
be closely related to the vertebrates. When fully developed the
Ascidiae are shapeless lumps that would not, at first sight, be taken
for animals at all. The oval body, frequently studded with knobs or
uneven and lumpy, in which we can discover no special external organs,
is attached at one end to marine plants, rocks, or the floor of the
sea. Many species look like potatoes, others like melon-cacti, others
like prunes. Many of the Ascidiae form transparent crusts or deposits
on stones and marine plants. Some of the larger species are eaten like
oysters. Fishermen, who know them very well, think they are not
animals, but plants. They are sold in the fish markets of many of the
Italian coast-towns with other lower marine animals under the name of
"sea-fruit" (frutti di mare). There is nothing about them to show that
they are animals. When they are taken out of the water with the net
the most one can perceive is a slight contraction of the body that
causes water to spout out in two places. The bulk of the Ascidiae are
very small, at the most a few inches long. A few species are a foot or
more in length. There are many species of them, and they are found in
every sea. As in the case of the Acrania, we have no fossilised
remains of the class, because they have no hard and fossilisable
parts. However, they must be of great antiquity, and must go back to
the primordial epoch.

The name of "Tunicates" is given to the whole class to which the
Ascidiae belong, because the body is enclosed in a thick and stiff
covering like a mantle (tunica). This mantle--sometimes soft like
jelly, sometimes as tough as leather, and sometimes as stiff as
cartilage--has a number of peculiarities. The most remarkable of them
is that it consists of a woody matter, cellulose--the same vegetal
substance that forms the stiff envelopes of the plant-cells, the
substance of the wood. The tunicates are the only class of animals
that have a real cellulose or woody coat. Sometimes the cellulose
mantle is brightly coloured, at other times colourless. Not
infrequently it is set with needles or hairs, like a cactus. Often we
find a mass of foreign bodies--stone, sand, fragments of
mussel-shells, etc.--worked into the mantle. This has earned for the
Ascidia the name of "the microcosm."

(FIGURE 2.220. Organisation of an Ascidia (left view); the dorsal side
is turned to the right and the ventral side to the left, the mouth (o)
above; the ascidia is attached at the tail end. The branchial gut
(br), which is pierced by a number of clefts, continues below in the
visceral gut. The rectum opens through the anus (a) into the atrium
(cl), from which the excrements are ejected with the respiratory water
through the mantle-hole or cloaca (a); m mantle. (From Gegenbaur.)

FIGURE 2.221. Organisation of an Ascidia (as in Figure 2.220, seen
from the left). sb branchial sac, v stomach, i small intestine, c
heart, t testicle, vd sperm-duct, o ovary, o apostrophe ripe ova in
the branchial cavity. The two small arrows indicate the entrance and
exit of the water through the openings of the mantle. (From
Milne-Edwards.))

The hind end, which corresponds to the tail of the Amphioxus, is
usually attached, often by means of regular roots. The dorsal and
ventral sides differ a good deal internally, but frequently cannot be
distinguished externally. If we open the thick tunic or mantle in
order to examine the internal organisation, we first find a spacious
cavity filled with water--the mantle-cavity or respiratory cavity
(Figure 2.220 cl). It is also called the branchial cavity and the
cloaca, because it receives the excrements and sexual products as well
as the respiratory water. The greater part of the respiratory cavity
is occupied by the large grated branchial sac (br). This is so like
the gill-crate of the Amphioxus in its whole arrangement that the
resemblance was pointed out by the English naturalist Goodsir, years
ago, before anything was known of the relationship of the two animals.
As a fact, even in the Ascidia the mouth (o) opens first into this
wide branchial sac. The respiratory water passes through the
lattice-work of the branchial sac into the branchial cavity, and is
ejected from this by the respiratory pore (a apostrophe). Along the
ventral side of the branchial sac runs a ciliated groove--the
hypobranchial groove which we have previously found at the same spot
in the Amphioxus. The food of the Ascidia also consists of tiny
organisms, infusoria, diatoms, parts of decomposed marine plants and
animals; etc. These pass with the water into the gill-crate and the
digestive part of the gut at the end of it, at first into an
enlargement of it that represents the stomach. The adjoining small
intestine usually forms a loop, bends forward, and opens by an anus
(Figure 2.220 a), not directly outwards, but first into the mantle
cavity; from this the excrements are ejected by a common outlet (a
apostrophe) together with the used-up water and the sexual products.
The outlet is sometimes called the branchial pore, and sometimes the
cloaca or ejection-aperture. In many of the Ascidiae a glandular mass
opens into the gut, and this represents the liver. In some there is
another gland besides the liver, and this is taken to represent the
kidneys. The body-cavity proper, or coeloma, which is filled with
blood and encloses the hepatic gut, is very narrow in the Ascidia, as
in the Amphioxus, and is here also usually confounded with the wide
atrium, or peribranchial cavity, full of water.

There is no trace in the fully-developed Ascidia of a chorda dorsalis,
or internal axial skeleton. It is the more interesting that the young
animal that emerges from the ovum HAS a chorda, and that there is a
rudimentary medullary tube above it. The latter is wholly atrophied in
the developed Ascidia, and looks like a small nerve-ganglion in front
above the gill-crate. It corresponds to the upper "gullet-ganglion" or
"primitive brain" in other vermalia. Special sense-organs are either
wanting altogether or are only found in a very rudimentary form, as
simple optic spots and touch-corpuscles or tentacles that surround the
mouth. The muscular system is very slightly and irregularly developed.
Immediately under the thin corium, and closely connected with it, we
find a thin muscle tube, as in the worms. On the other hand, the
Ascidia has a centralised heart, and in this respect it seems to be
more advanced than the Amphioxus. On the ventral side of the gut, some
distance behind the gill-crate, there is a spindle-shaped heart. It
retains permanently the simple tubular form that we find temporarily
as the first structure of the heart in the vertebrates. This simple
heart of the Ascidia has, however, a remarkable peculiarity. It
contracts in alternate directions. In all other animals the beat of
the heart is always in the same direction (generally from rear to
front); it changes in the Ascidia to the reverse direction. The heart
contracts first from the rear to the front, stands still for a minute,
and then begins to beat the opposite way, now driving the blood from
front to rear; the two large vessels that start from either end of the
heart act alternately as arteries and veins. This feature is found in
the Tunicates alone.

Of the other chief organs we have still to mention the sexual glands,
which lie right behind in the body-cavity. All the Ascidiae are
hermaphrodites. Each individual has a male and a female gland, and so
is able to fertilise itself. The ripe ova (Figure 2.221 o apostrophe)
fall directly from the ovary (o) into the mantle-cavity. The male
sperm is conducted into this cavity from the testicle (t) by a special
duct (vd). Fertilisation is accomplished here, and in many of the
Ascidiae developed embryos are found. These are then ejected with the
breathing-water through the cloaca (q), and so "born alive."

If we now glance at the entire structure of the simple Ascidia
(especially Phallusia, Cynthia, etc.) and compare it with that of the
Amphioxus, we shall find that the two have few points of contact. It
is true that the fully-developed Ascidia resembles the Amphioxus in
several important features of its internal structure, and especially
in the peculiar character of the gill-crate and gut. But in most other
features of organisation it is so far removed from it, and is so
unlike it in external appearance, that the really close relationship
of the two was not discovered until their embryology was studied. We
will now compare the embryonic development of the two animals, and
find to our great astonishment that the same embryonic form develops
from the ovum of the Amphioxus as from that of the Ascidia--a typical
chordula.


CHAPTER 2.17. EMBRYOLOGY OF THE LANCELET AND THE SEA-SQUIRT.

The structural features that distinguish the vertebrates from the
invertebrates are so prominent that there was the greatest difficulty
in the earlier stages of classification in determining the affinity of
these two great groups. When scientists began to speak of the affinity
of the various animal groups in more than a figurative--in a
genealogical--sense, this question came at once to the front, and
seemed to constitute one of the chief obstacles to the carrying-out of
the evolutionary theory. Even earlier, when they had studied the
relations of the chief groups, without any idea of real genealogical
connection, they believed they had found here and there among the
invertebrates points of contact with the vertebrates: some of the
worms, especially, seemed to approach the vertebrates in structure,
such as the marine arrow-worm (Sagitta). But on closer study the
analogies proved untenable. When Darwin gave an impulse to the
construction of a real stem-history of the animal kingdom by his
reform of the theory of evolution, the solution of this problem was
found to be particularly difficult. When I made the first attempt in
my General Morphology (1866) to work out the theory and apply it to
classification, I found no problem of phylogeny that gave me so much
trouble as the linking of the vertebrates with the invertebrates.

But just at this time the true link was discovered, and at a point
where it was least expected. Towards the end of 1866 two works of the
Russian zoologist, Kowalevsky, who had lived for some time at Naples,
and studied the embryology of the lower animals, were issued in the
publications of the St. Petersburg Academy. A fortunate accident had
directed the attention of this able observer almost simultaneously to
the embryology of the lowest vertebrate, the Amphioxus, and that of an
invertebrate, the close affinity of which to the Amphioxus had been
least suspected, the Ascidia. To the extreme astonishment of all
zoologists who were interested in this important question, there
turned out to be the utmost resemblance in structure from the
commencement of development between these two very different
animals--the lowest vertebrate and the mis-shaped, sessile
invertebrate. With this undeniable identity of ontogenesis, which can
be demonstrated to an astounding extent, we had, in virtue of the
biogenetic law, discovered the long-sought genealogical link, and
definitely identified the invertebrate group that represents the
nearest blood-relatives of the vertebrates. The discovery was
confirmed by other zoologists, and there can no longer be any doubt
that of all the classes of invertebrates that of the Tunicates is most
closely related to the vertebrates, and of the Tunicates the nearest
are the Ascidiae. We cannot say that the vertebrates are descended
from the Ascidiae--and still less the reverse--but we can say that of
all the invertebrates it is the Tunicates, and, within this group, the
Ascidiae, that are the nearest blood-relatives of the ancient
stem-form of the vertebrates. We must assume as the common ancestral
group of both stems an extinct family of the extensive vermalia-stem,
the Prochordonia or Prochordata ("primitive chorda-animals").

In order to appreciate fully this remarkable fact, and especially to
secure the sound basis we seek for the genealogical tree of the
vertebrates, it is necessary to study thoroughly the embryology of
both these animals, and compare the individual development of the
Amphioxus step by step with that of the Ascidia. We begin with the
ontogeny of the Amphioxus.

From the concordant observations of Kowalevsky at Naples and Hatschek
at Messina, it follows, firstly, that the ovum-segmentation and
gastrulation of the Amphioxus are of the simplest character. They take
place in the same way as we find them in many of the lower animals of
different invertebrate stems, which we have already described as
original or primordial; the development of the Ascidia is of the same
type. Sexually mature specimens of the Amphioxus, which are found in
great quantities at Messina from April or May onwards, begin as a rule
to eject their sexual products in the evening; if you catch them about
the middle of a warm night and put them in a glass vessel with
seawater, they immediately eject through the mouth their accumulated
sexual products, in consequence of the disturbance. The males give out
masses of sperm, and the females discharge ova in such quantity that
many of them stick to the fibrils about their mouths. Both kinds of
cells pass first into the mantle-cavity after the opening of the
gonads, proceed through the gill-clefts into the branchial gut, and
are discharged from this through the mouth.

The ova are simply round cells. They are only 1/250 of an inch in
diameter, and thus are only half the size of the mammal ova, and have
no distinctive features. The clear protoplasm of the mature ovum is
made so turbid by the numbers of dark granules of food-yelk or
deutoplasm scattered in it that it is difficult to follow the process
of fecundation and the behaviour of the two nuclei during it (Chapter
1.7). The active elements of the male sperm, the cone-shaped
spermatozoa, are similar to those of most other animals (cf. Figure
1.20). Fecundation takes place when these lively ciliated cells of the
sperm approach the ovum, and seek to penetrate into the yelk-matter or
the cellular substance of the ovum with their head-part--the thicker
part of the cell that encloses the nucleus. Only one spermatozoon can
bore its way into the yelk at one pole of the ovum-axis; its head or
nucleus coalesces with the female nucleus, which remains after the
extrusion of the directive bodies from the germinal vesicle. Thus is
formed the "stem-nucleus," or the nucleus of the "stem-cell" (cytula,
Figure 1.2). This now undergoes total segmentation, dividing into two,
four, eight, sixteen, thirty-two cells, and so on. In this way we get
the spherical, mulberry-shaped body, which we call the morula.

The segmentation of the Amphioxus is not entirely regular, as was
supposed after the first observations of Kowalevsky (1866). It is not
completely equal, but a little unequal. As Hatschek afterwards found
(1879), the segmentation-cells only remain equal up to the
morula-stage, the spherical body of which consists of thirty-two
cells. Then, as always happens in unequal segmentation, the more
sluggish vegetal cells are outstripped in the cleavage. At the lower
or vegetal pole of the ovum a crown of eight large entodermic cells
remains for a long time unchanged, while the other cells divide, owing
to the formation of a series of horizontal circles, into an increasing
number of crowns of sixteen cells each. Afterwards the
segmentation-cells get more or less irregularly displaced, while the
segmentation-cavity enlarges in the centre of the morula; in the end
the former all lie on the surface of the latter, so that the foetus
attains the familiar blastula shape and forms a hollow ball, the wall
of which consists of a single stratum of cells (Figure 1.38 A to C).
This layer is the blastoderm, the simple epithelium from the cells of
which all the tissues of the body proceed.

These important early embryonic processes take place so quickly in the
Amphioxus that four or five hours after fecundation, or about
midnight, the spherical blastula is completed. A pit-like depression
is then formed at the vegetal pole of it, and in consequence of this
the hollow sphere doubles on itself (Figure 1.38 D). This pit becomes
deeper and deeper (Figure 1.38 E and F); at last the invagination (or
doubling) is complete, and the inner or folded part of the
blastula-wall lies on the inside of the outer wall. We thus get a
hollow hemisphere, the thin wall of which is made up of two layers of
cells (Figure 1.38 E). From hemispherical the body soon becomes almost
spherical once more, and then oval, the internal cavity enlarging
considerably and its mouth growing narrower (Figure 2.213). The form
which the Amphioxus-embryo has thus reached is a real "cup-larva" or
gastrula, of the original simple type that we have previously
described as the "bell-gastrula" or archigastrula (Figures 1.29 to
1.35).

As in all the other animals that form an archigastrula, the whole body
is nothing but a simple gastric sac or stomach; its internal cavity is
the primitive gut (progaster or archenteron, Figure 1.38 g, 1.35 d),
and its aperture the primitive mouth (prostoma or blastoporus, o). The
wall is at once gut-wall and body-wall. It is composed of two simple
cell-layers, the familiar primary germinal layers. The inner layer or
the invaginated part of the blastoderm, which immediately encloses the
gut-cavity is the entoderm, the inner or vegetal germ-layer, from
which develop the wall of the alimentary canal and all its appendages,
the coelom-pouches, etc. (Figures 1.35 and 1.36 i). The outer stratum
of cells, or the non-invaginated part of the blastoderm, is the
ectoderm, the outer or animal germ-layer, which provides the outer
skin (epidermis) and the nervous system (e). The cells of the entoderm
are much larger, darker, and more fatty than those of the ectoderm,
which are clearer and less rich in fatty particles. Hence before and
during invagination there is an increasing differentiation of the
inner from the outer layer. The animal cells of the outer layer soon
develop vibratory hairs; the vegetal cells of the inner layer do so
much later. A thread-like process grows out of each cell, and effects
continuous vibratory movements. By the vibrations of these slender
hairs the gastrula of the Amphioxus swims about in the sea, when it
has pierced the thin ovolemma, like the gastrula of many other animals
(Figure 1.36). As in many other lower animals, the cells have only one
whip-like hair each, and so are called flagellate (whip) cells (in
contrast with the ciliated cells, which have a number of short lashes
or cilia).

In the further course of its rapid development the roundish
bell-gastrula becomes elongated, and begins to flatten on one side,
parallel to the long axis. The flattened side is the subsequent dorsal
side; the opposite or ventral side remains curved. The latter grows
more quickly than the former, with the result that the primitive mouth
is forced to the dorsal side (Figure 1.39). In the middle of the
dorsal surface a shallow longitudinal groove or furrow is formed
(Figure 1.79), and the edges of the body rise up on each side of this
groove in the shape of two parallel swellings. This groove is, of
course, the dorsal furrow, and the swellings are the dorsal or
medullary swellings; they form the first structure of the central
nervous system, the medullary tube. The medullary swellings now rise
higher; the groove between them becomes deeper and deeper. The edges
of the parallel swellings curve towards each other, and at last unite,
and the medullary tube is formed (Figures 1.83 m and 1.84 m). Hence
the formation of a medullary tube out of the outer skin takes place in
the naked dorsal surface of the free-swimming larva of the Amphioxus
in just the same way as we have found in the embryo of man and the
higher animals within the foetal membranes.

Simultaneously with the construction of the medullary tube we have in
the Amphioxus-embryo the formation of the chorda, the coelom-pouches,
and the mesoderm proceeding from their wall. These processes also take
place with characteristic simplicity and clearness, so that they are
very instructive to compare with the vermalia on the one hand and with
the higher vertebrates on the other. While the medullary groove is
sinking in the middle line of the flat dorsal side of the oval embryo,
and its parallel edges unite to form the ectodermic neural tube, the
single chorda is formed directly underneath them, and on each side of
this a parallel longitudinal fold, from the dorsal wall of the
primitive gut. These longitudinal folds of the entoderm proceed from
the primitive mouth, or from its lower and hinder edge. Here we see at
an early stage a couple of large entodermic cells, which are
distinguished from all the others by their great size, round form, and
fine-grained protoplasm; they are the two promesoblasts, or polar
cells of the mesoderm (Figure 1.83 p). They indicate the original
starting-point of the two coelom-pouches, which grow from this spot
between the inner and outer germinal layers, sever themselves from the
primitive gut, and provide the cellular material for the middle layer.

Immediately after their formation the two coelom-pouches of the
Amphioxus are divided into several parts by longitudinal and
transverse folds. Each of the primary pouches is divided into an upper
dorsal and a lower ventral section by a couple of lateral longitudinal
folds (Figure 1.82). But these are again divided by several parallel
transverse folds into a number of successive sacs, the primitive
segments or somites (formerly called by the unsuitable name of
"primitive vertebrae"). They have a different future above and below.
The upper or dorsal segments, the episomites, lose their cavity later
on, and form with their cells the muscular plates of the trunk. The
lower or ventral segments, the hyposomites, corresponding to the
lateral plates of the craniote-embryo, fuse together in the upper part
owing to the disappearance of their lateral walls, and thus form the
later body-cavity (metacoel); in the lower part they remain separate,
and afterwards form the segmental gonads.

In the middle, between the two lateral coelom-folds of the primitive
gut, a single central organ detaches from this at an early stage in
the middle line of its dorsal wall. This is the dorsal chorda (Figures
1.83 and 1.84 ch). This axial rod, which is the first foundation of
the later vertebral column in all the vertebrates, and is the only
representative of it in the Amphioxus, originates from the entoderm.

In consequence of these important folding-processes in the primitive
gut, the simple entodermic tube divides into four different
sections:--

1. underneath, at the ventral side, the permanent alimentary canal or
permanent gut;

2. above, at the dorsal side, the axial rod or chorda; and

3. the two coelom-sacs, which immediately sub-divide into two
structures:--

3A. above, on the dorsal side, the episomites, the double row of
primitive or muscular segments; and

3B. below, on each side of the gut, the hyposomites, the two lateral
plates that give rise to the sex-glands, and the cavities of which
partly unite to form the body-cavity. At the same time, the neural or
medullary tube is formed above the chorda, on the dorsal surface, by
the closing of the parallel medullary swellings.

All these processes, which outline the typical structure of the
vertebrate, take place with astonishing rapidity in the embryo of the
Amphioxus; in the afternoon of the first day, or twenty-four hours
after fertilisation, the young vertebrate, the typical embryo, is
formed; it then has, as a rule, six to eight somites.

The chief occurrence on the second day of development is the
construction of the two permanent openings of the gut--the mouth and
anus. In the earlier stages the alimentary tube is found to be
entirely closed, after the closing of the primitive mouth; it only
communicates behind by the neurenteric canal with the medullary tube.
The permanent mouth is a secondary formation, at the opposite end.
Here, at the end of the second day, we find a pit-like depression in
the outer skin, which penetrates inwards into the closed gut. The anus
is formed behind in the same way a few hours later (in the vicinity of
the additional gastrula-mouth). In man and the higher vertebrates also
the mouth and anus are formed, as we have seen, as flat pits in the
outer skin; they then penetrate inwards, gradually becoming connected
with the blind ends of the closed gut-tube. During the second day the
Amphioxus-embryo undergoes few other changes. The number of primitive
segments increases, and generally amounts to fourteen, some
forty-eight to fifty hours after impregnation.

Almost simultaneously with the formation of the mouth the first
gill-cleft breaks through in the fore section of the Amphioxus-embryo
(generally forty hours after the commencement of development). It now
begins to nourish itself independently, as the food material stored up
in the ovum is completely used up. The further development of the free
larvae takes place very slowly, and extends over several months. The
body becomes much longer, and is compressed at the sides, the head-end
being broadened in a sort of triangle. Two rudimentary sense-organs
are developed in it. Inside we find the first blood-vessels, an upper
or dorsal vessel, corresponding to the aorta, between the gut and the
dorsal cord, and a lower or ventral vessel, corresponding to the
subintestinal vein, at the lower border of the gut. Now, the gills or
respiratory organs also are formed at the fore-end of the alimentary
canal. The whole of the anterior or respiratory section of the gut is
converted into a gill-crate, which is pierced trellis-wise by numbers
of branchial-holes, as in the ascidia. This is done by the foremost
part of the gut-wall joining star-wise with the outer skin, and the
formation of clefts at the point of connection, piercing the wall and
leading into the gut from without. At first there are very few of
these branchial clefts; but there are soon a number of them--first in
one, then in two, rows. The foremost gill-cleft is the oldest. In the
end we have a sort of lattice work of fine gill-clefts, supported on a
number of stiff branchial rods; these are connected in pairs by
transverse rods.

(FIGURES 2.222 TO 2.224. Transverse sections of young Amphioxus-larvae
(diagrammatic, from Ralph.) (Cf. also Figure 2.216.) In Figure 2.222
there is free communication from without with the gut-cavity (D)
through the gill-clefts (K). In Figure 2.223 the lateral folds of the
body-wall, or the gill-covers, which grow downwards, are formed. In
Figure 2.224 these lateral folds have united underneath and joined
their edges in the middle line of the ventral side (R seam). The
respiratory water now passes from the gut-cavity (D) into the
mantle-cavity (A). The letters have the same meaning throughout: N
medullary tube, Ch chorda, M lateral muscles, Lh body-cavity, G part
of the body-cavity in which the sexual organs are subsequently formed.
D gut-cavity, clothed with the gut-gland layer (a). A mantle-cavity, K
gill-clefts, b = E epidermis, E1 the same as visceral epithelium of
the mantle-cavity, E2 as parietal epithelium of the mantle-cavity.)

At an early stage of embryonic development the structure of the
Amphioxus-larva is substantially the same as the ideal picture we have
previously formed of the "Primitive Vertebrate" (Figures 1.98 to
1.102). But the body afterwards undergoes various modifications,
especially in the fore-part. These modifications do not concern us, as
they depend on special adaptations, and do not affect the hereditary
vertebrate type. When the free-swimming Amphioxus-larva is three
months old, it abandons its pelagic habits and changes into the young
animal that lives in the sand. In spite of its smallness (one-eighth
of an inch), it has substantially the same structure as the adult. As
regards the remaining organs of the Amphioxus, we need only mention
that the gonads or sexual glands are developed very late, immediately
out of the inner cell-layer of the body-cavity. Although we can find
afterwards no continuation of the body-cavity (Figure 2.216 U) in the
lateral walls of the mantle-cavity, in the gill-covers or mantle-folds
(Figure 2.224 U), there is one present in the beginning (Figure 2.224
Lh). The sexual cells are formed below, at the bottom of this
continuation (Figure 2.224 S). For the rest, the subsequent
development into the adult Amphioxus of the larva we have followed is
so simple that we need not go further into it here.

We may now turn to the embryology of the Ascidia, an animal that seems
to stand so much lower and to be so much more simply organised,
remaining for the greater part of its life attached to the bottom of
the sea like a shapeless lump. It was a fortunate accident that
Kowalevsky first examined just those larger specimens of the Ascidiae
that show most clearly the relationship of the vertebrates to the
invertebrates, and the larvae of which behave exactly like those of
the Amphioxus in the first stages of development. This resemblance is
so close in the main features that we have only to repeat what we have
already said of the ontogenesis of the Amphioxus.

The ovum of the larger Ascidia (Phallusia, Cynthia, etc.) is a simple
round cell of 1/250 to 1/125 of an inch in diameter. In the thick
fine-grained yelk we find a clear round germinal vesicle of about
1/750 of an inch in diameter, and this encloses a small embryonic spot
or nucleolus. Inside the membrane that surrounds the ovum, the
stem-cell of the Ascidia, after fecundation, passes through just the
same metamorphoses as the stem-cell of the Amphioxus. It undergoes
total segmentation; it divides into two, four, eight, sixteen,
thirty-two cells, and so on. By continued total cleavage the morula,
or mulberry-shaped cluster of cells, is formed. Fluid gathers inside
it, and thus we get once more a globular vesicle (the blastula); the
wall of this is a single stratum of cells, the blastoderm. A real
gastrula (a simple bell-gastrula) is formed from the blastula by
invagination, in the same way as in the amphioxus.

Up to this there is no definite ground in the embryology of the
Ascidiae for bringing them into close relationship with the
Vertebrates; the same gastrula is formed in the same way in many other
animals of different stems. But we now find an embryonic process that
is peculiar to the Vertebrates, and that proves irrefragably the
affinity of the Ascidiae to the Vertebrates. From the epidermis of the
gastrula a medullary tube is formed on the dorsal side, and, between
this and the primitive gut, a chorda; these are the organs that are
otherwise only found in Vertebrates. The formation of these very
important organs takes place in the Ascidia-gastrula in precisely the
same way as in that of the Amphioxus. In the Ascidia (as in the other
case) the oval gastrula is first flattened on one side--the subsequent
dorsal side. A groove or furrow (the medullary groove) is sunk in the
middle line of the flat surface, and two parallel longitudinal
swellings arise on either side from the skin layer. These medullary
swellings join together over the furrow, and form a tube; in this
case, again, the neural or medullary tube is at first open in front,
and connected with the primitive gut behind by the neurenteric canal.
Further, in the Ascidia-larva also the two permanent apertures of the
alimentary canal only appear later, as independent and new formations.
The permanent mouth does not develop from the primitive mouth of the
gastrula; this primitive mouth closes up, and the later anus is formed
near it by invagination from without, on the hinder end of the body,
opposite to the aperture of the medullary tube.

During these important processes, that take place in just the same way
in the Amphioxus, a tail-like projection grows out of the posterior
end of the larva-body, and the larva folds itself up within the round
ovolemma in such a way that the dorsal side is curved and the tail is
forced on to the ventral side. In this tail is developed--starting
from the primitive gut--a cylindrical string of cells, the fore end of
which pushes into the body of the larva, between the alimentary canal
and the neural canal, and is no other than the chorda dorsalis. This
important organ had hitherto been found only in the Vertebrates, not a
single trace of it being discoverable in the Invertebrates. At first
the chorda only consists of a single row of large entodermic cells. It
is afterwards composed of several rows of cells. In the Ascidia-larva,
also, the chorda develops from the dorsal middle part of the primitive
gut, while the two coelom-pouches detach themselves from it on both
sides. The simple body-cavity is formed by the coalescence of the two.

When the Ascidia-larva has attained this stage of development it
begins to move about in the ovolemma. This causes the membrane to
burst. The larva emerges from it, and swims about in the sea by means
of its oar-like tail. These free-swimming larvae of the Ascidia have
been known for a long time. They were first observed by Darwin during
his voyage round the world in 1833. They resemble tadpoles in outward
appearance, and use their tails as oars, as the tadpoles do. However,
this lively and highly-developed condition does not last long. At
first there is a progressive development; the foremost part of the
medullary tube enlarges into a brain, and inside this two single
sense-organs are developed, a dorsal auditory vesicle and a ventral
eye. Then a heart is formed on the ventral side of the animal, or the
lower wall of the gut, in the same simple form and at the same spot at
which the heart is developed in man and all the other vertebrates. In
the lower muscular wall of the gut we find a weal-like thickening, a
solid, spindle-shaped string of cells, which becomes hollow in the
centre; it begins to contract in different directions, now forward and
now backward, as is the case with the adult Ascidia. In this way the
sanguineous fluid accumulated in the hollow muscular tube is driven in
alternate directions into the blood-vessels, which develop at both
ends of the cardiac tube. One principal vessel runs along the dorsal
side of the gut, another along its ventral side. The former
corresponds to the aorta and the dorsal vessel in the worms. The other
corresponds to the subintestinal vein and the ventral vessel of the
worms.

With the formation of these organs the progressive development of the
Ascidia comes to an end, and degeneration sets in. The free-swimming
larva sinks to the floor of the sea, abandons its locomotive habits,
and attaches itself to stones, marine plants, mussel-shells, corals,
and other objects; this is done with the part of the body that was
foremost in movement. The attachment is effected by a number of
out-growths, usually three, which can be seen even in the
free-swimming larva. The tail is lost, as there is no further use for
it. It undergoes a fatty degeneration, and disappears with the chorda
dorsalis. The tailless body changes into an unshapely tube, and, by
the atrophy of some parts and the modification of others, gradually
assumes the appearance we have already described.

(FIGURE 2.225. An Appendicaria (Copelata), seen from the left. m
mouth, k branchial gut, o gullet, v stomach, a anus, n brain (ganglion
above the gullet), g auditory vesicle, f ciliated groove under the
gills, h heart, t testicles, e ovary, c chorda, s tail.)

Among the living Tunicates there is a very interesting group of small
animals that remain throughout life at the stage of development of the
tailed, free Ascidia-larva, and swim about briskly in the sea by means
of their broad oar-tail. These are the remarkable Copelata
(Appendicaria and Vexillaria, Figure 2.225). They are the only living
Vertebrates that have throughout life a chorda dorsalis and a neural
string above it; the latter must be regarded as the prolongation of
the cerebral ganglion and the equivalent of the medullary tube. Their
branchial gut also opens directly outwards by a pair of branchial
clefts. These instructive Copelata, comparable to permanent
Ascidia-larvae, come next to the extinct Prochordonia, those ancient
worms which we must regard as the common ancestors of the Tunicates
and Vertebrates. The chorda of the Appendicaria is a long, cylindrical
string (Figure 2.225 c), and serves as an attachment for the muscles
that work the flat oar-tail.

Among the various modifications which the Ascidia-larva undergoes
after its establishment at the sea-floor, the most interesting (after
the loss of the axial rod) is the atrophy of one of its chief organs,
the medullary tube. In the Amphioxus the spinal marrow continues to
develop, but in the Ascidia the tube soon shrinks into a small and
insignificant nervous ganglion that lies above the mouth and the
gill-crate, and is in accord with the extremely slight mental power of
the animal. This insignificant relic of the medullary tube seems to be
quite beyond comparison with the nervous centre of the vertebrate, yet
it started from the same structure as the spinal cord of the
Amphioxus. The sense-organs that had been developed in the fore part
of the neural tube are also lost; no trace of which can be found in
the adult Ascidia. On the other hand, the alimentary canal becomes a
most extensive organ. It divides presently into two sections--a wide
fore or branchial gut that serves for respiration, and a narrower hind
or hepatic gut that accomplishes digestion. The branchial or head-gut
of the Ascidia is small at first, and opens directly outwards only by
a couple of lateral ducts or gill-clefts--a permanent arrangement in
the Copelata. The gill-clefts are developed in the same way as in the
Amphioxus. As their number greatly increases we get a large
gill-crate, pierced like lattice work. In the middle line of its
ventral side we find the hypobranchial groove. The mantle or
cloaca-cavity (the atrium) that surrounds the gill-crate is also
formed in the same way in the Ascidia as in the Amphioxus. The
ejection-opening of this peribranchial cavity corresponds to the
branchial pore of the Amphioxus. In the adult Ascidia the branchial
gut and the heart on its ventral side are almost the only organs that
recall the original affinity with the vertebrates.

The further development of the Ascidia in detail has no particular
interest for us, and we will not go into it. The chief result that we
obtain from its embryology is the complete agreement with that of the
Amphioxus in the earliest and most important embryonic stages. They do
not begin to diverge until after the medullary tube and alimentary
canal, and the axial rod with the muscles between the two, have been
formed. The Amphioxus continues to advance, and resembles the
embryonic forms of the higher vertebrates; the Ascidia degenerates
more and more, and at last, in its adult condition, has the appearance
of a very imperfect invertebrate.

If we now look back on all the remarkable features we have encountered
in the structure and the embryonic development of the Amphioxus and
the Ascidia, and compare them with the features of man's embryonic
development which we have previously studied, it will be clear that I
have not exaggerated the importance of these very interesting animals.
It is evident that the Amphioxus from the vertebrate side and the
Ascidia from the invertebrate form the bridge by which we can span the
deep gulf that separates the two great divisions of the animal
kingdom. The radical agreement of the lancelet and the sea-squirt in
the first and most important stages of development shows something
more than their close anatomic affinity and their proximity in
classification; it shows also their real blood-relationship and their
common origin from one and the same stem-form. In this way, it throws
considerable light on the oldest roots of man's genealogical tree.


CHAPTER 2.18. DURATION OF THE HISTORY OF OUR STEM.

Our comparative investigation of the anatomy and ontogeny of the
Amphioxus and Ascidia has given us invaluable assistance. We have, in
the first place, bridged the wide gulf that has existed up to the
present between the Vertebrates and Invertebrates; and, in the second
place, we have discovered in the embryology of the Amphioxus a number
of ancient evolutionary stages that have long since disappeared from
human embryology, and have been lost, in virtue of the law of
curtailed heredity. The chief of these stages are the spherical
blastula (in its simplest primary form), and the succeeding
archigastrula, the pure, original form of the gastrula which the
Amphioxus has preserved to this day, and which we find in the same
form in a number of Invertebrates of various classes. Not less
important are the later embryonic forms of the coelomula, the
chordula, etc.

Thus the embryology of the Amphioxus and the Ascidia has so much
increased our knowledge of man's stem-history that, although our
empirical information is still very incomplete, there is now no defect
of any great consequence in it. We may now, therefore, approach our
proper task, and reconstruct the phylogeny of man in its chief lines
with the aid of this evidence of comparative anatomy and ontogeny. In
this the reader will soon see the immense importance of the direct
application of the biogenetic law. But before we enter upon the work
it will be useful to make a few general observations that are
necessary to understand the processes aright.

We must say a few words with regard to the period in which the human
race was evolved from the animal kingdom. The first thought that
occurs to one in this connection is the vast difference between the
duration of man's ontogeny and phylogeny. The individual man needs
only nine months for his complete development, from the fecundation of
the ovum to the moment when he leaves the maternal womb. The human
embryo runs its whole course in the brief space of forty weeks (as a
rule, 280 days). In many other mammals the time of the embryonic
development is much the same as in man--for instance, in the cow. In
the horse and ass it takes a little longer, forty-three to forty-five
weeks; in the camel, thirteen months. In the largest mammals, the
embryo needs a much longer period for its development in the womb--a
year and a half in the rhinoceros, and ninety weeks in the elephant.
In these cases pregnancy lasts twice as long as in the case of man, or
one and three-quarter years. In the smaller mammals the embryonic
period is much shorter. The smallest mammals, the dwarf-mice, develop
in three weeks; hares in four weeks, rats and marmots in five weeks,
the dog in nine, the pig in seventeen, the sheep in twenty-one and the
goat in thirty-six. Birds develop still more quickly. The chick only
needs, in normal circumstances, three weeks for its full development.
The duck needs twenty-five days, the turkey twenty-seven, the peacock
thirty-one, the swan forty-two, and the cassowary sixty-five. The
smallest bird, the humming-bird, leaves the egg after twelve days.
Hence the duration of individual development within the foetal
membranes is, in the mammals and birds, clearly related to the
absolute size of the body of the animal in question. But this is not
the only determining feature. There are a number of other
circumstances that have an influence on the period of embryonic
development. In the Amphioxus the earliest and most important
embryonic processes take place so rapidly that the blastula is formed
in four hours, the gastrula in six, and the typical vertebrate form in
twenty-four.

In every case the duration of ontogeny shrinks into insignificance
when we compare it with the enormous period that has been necessary
for phylogeny, or the gradual development of the ancestral series.
This period is not measured by years or centuries, but by thousands
and millions of years. Many millions of years had to pass before the
most advanced vertebrate, man, was evolved, step by step, from his
ancient unicellular ancestors. The opponents of evolution, who declare
that this gradual development of the human form from lower animal
forms, and ultimately from a unicellular organism, is an incredible
miracle, forget that the same miracle takes place within the space of
mine months in the embryonic development of every human being. Each of
us has, in the forty weeks--properly speaking, in the first four
weeks--of his development in the womb, passed through the same series
of transformations that our animal ancestors underwent in the course
of millions of years.

It is impossible to determine even approximately, in hundreds or even
thousands of years, the real and absolute duration of the phylogenetic
period. But for some time now we have, through the research of
geologists, been in a position to assign the relative length of the
various sections of the organic history of the earth. The immediate
data for determining this relative length of the geological periods
are found in the thickness of the sedimentary strata--the strata that
have been formed at the bottom of the sea or in fresh water from the
mud or slime deposited there. These successive layers of limestone,
sandstone, slate, marl, etc., which make up the greater part of the
rocks, and are often several thousand feet thick, give us a standard
for computing the relative length of the various periods.

To make the point quite clear, I must say a word about the evolution
of the earth in general, and point out briefly the chief features of
the story. In the first place, we encounter the principle that on our
planet organic life began to exist at a definite period. That
statement is no longer disputed by any competent geologist or
biologist. The organic history of the earth could not commence until
it was possible for water to settle on our planet in fluid condition.
Every organism, without exception, needs fluid water as a condition of
existence, and contains a considerable quantity of it. Our own body,
when fully formed, contains sixty to seventy per cent of water in its
tissues, and only thirty to forty per cent of solid matter. There is
even more water in the body of the child, and still more in the
embryo. In the earlier stages of development the human foetus contains
more than ninety per cent of water, and not ten per cent of solids. In
the lower marine animals, especially certain medusae, the body
consists to the extent of more than ninety-nine per cent of sea-water,
and has not one per cent of solid matter. No organism can exist or
discharge its functions without water. No water, no life!

But fluid water, on which the existence of life primarily depends,
could not exist on our planet until the temperature of the surface of
the incandescent sphere had sunk to a certain point. Up to that time
it remained in the form of steam. But as soon as the first fluid water
could be condensed from the envelope of steam, it began its geological
action, and has continued down to the present day to modify the solid
crust of the earth. The final outcome of this incessant action of the
water--wearing down and dissolving the rocks in the form of rain,
hail, snow, and ice, as running stream or boiling surge--is the
formation of mud. As Huxley says in his admirable Lectures on the
Causes of Phenomena in Organic Nature, the chief document as to the
past history of our earth is mud; the question of the history of past
ages resolves itself into a question about the formation of mud.

As I have said, it is possible to form an approximate idea of the
relative age of the various strata by comparing them at different
parts of the earth's surface. Geologists have long been agreed that
there is a definite historical succession of the different strata. The
various superimposed layers correspond to successive periods in the
organic history of the earth, in which they were deposited in the form
of mud at the bottom of the sea. The mud was gradually converted into
stone. This was lifted out of the water owing to variations in the
earth's surface, and formed the mountains. As a rule, four or five
great divisions are distinguished in the organic history of the earth,
corresponding to the larger and smaller groups of the sedimentary
strata. The larger periods are then sub-divided into a series of
smaller ones, which usually number from twelve to fifteen. The
comparative thickness of the groups of strata enables us to make an
approximate calculation of the relative length of these various
periods of time. We cannot say, it is true, "In a century a stratum of
a certain thickness (about two feet) is formed on the average;
therefore, a layer 1000 feet thick must be 500,000 years old."
Different strata of the same thickness may need very different periods
for their formation. But from the thickness or size of the stratum we
can draw some conclusion as to the RELATIVE length of the period.

The first and oldest of the four or five chief divisions of the
organic history of the earth is called the primordial, archaic, or
archeozoic period. If we compute the total average thickness of the
sedimentary strata at about 130,000 feet, this first period comprises
70,000 feet, or the greater part of the whole. For this and other
reasons we may at once conclude that the corresponding primordial or
archeolithic period must have been in itself much longer than the
whole of the remaining periods together, from its close to the present
day. It was probably much longer than the figures I have quoted (7 :
6) indicate--possibly 9 : 6. Of late years the thickness of the
archaic rocks has been put at 90,000 feet.

SYNOPSIS OF THE PALEONTOLOGICAL FORMATIONS, OR THE FOSSILIFEROUS
STRATA OF THE CRUST.

COLUMN 1 : Groups (V. down to I.).

COLUMN 2 : Systems (XIV. down to I.).

COLUMN 3 : Formations (38 down to 1).

COLUMN 4 : Synonyms of Formations.

V. Anthropolithic group, or anthropozoic (quaternary) group of strata
: XIV. Recent (alluvium) : 38. Present : Upper alluvial.

V. Anthropolithic group, or anthropozoic (quaternary) group of strata
: XIV. Recent (alluvium) : 37. Recent : Lower alluvial.

V. Anthropolithic group, or anthropozoic (quaternary) group of strata
: XIII. Pleistocene (diluvium) : 36. Post-glacial : Upper diluvial.

V. Anthropolithic group, or anthropozoic (quaternary) group of strata
: XIII. Pleistocene (diluvium) : 35. Glacial : Lower diluvial.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : XII.
Pliocene (neo-tertiary) : 34. Arverne : Upper pliocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : XII.
Pliocene (neo-tertiary) : 33. Subapennine : Lower pliocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : XI.
Miocene (middle tertiary) : 32. Falun : Upper miocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : XI.
Miocene (middle tertiary) : 31. Limbourg : Lower miocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : Xb.
Oligocene (old tertiary) : 30. Aquitaine : Upper oligocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : Xb.
Oligocene (old tertiary) : 29. Ligurium : Lower oligocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : Xa.
Eocene (primitive tertiary) : 28. Gypsum : Upper eocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : Xa.
Eocene (primitive tertiary) : 27. Coarse chalk : Middle eocene.

IV. Cenolithic group, or cenozoic (tertiary) group of strata : Xa.
Eocene (primitive tertiary) : 26. London clay : Lower eocene.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : IX.
Chalk (cretaceous) : 25. White chalk. : Upper cretaceous.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : IX.
Chalk (cretaceous) : 24. Green Sand : Middle cretaceous.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : IX.
Chalk (cretaceous) : 23. Neocomian : Lower cretaceous.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : IX.
Chalk (cretaceous) : 22. Wealden : Weald-formation.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VIII.
Jurassic : 21. Portland : Upper oolithic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VIII.
Jurassic : 20. Oxford : Middle oolithic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VIII.
Jurassic : 19. Bath : Lower oolithic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VIII.
Jurassic : 18. Lias : Liassic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VII.
Triassic : 17. Keuper : Upper triassic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VII.
Triassic : 16. Muschelkalk : Middle triassic.

III. Mesolithic group, or mesozoic (secondary) group of strata : VII.
Triassic : 15. Bunter : Lower triassic.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : VIb.
Permian : 14. Zechstein : Upper permian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : VIb.
Permian : 13. Neurot sand : Lower permian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : VIa.
Carboniferous (coal-measures) : 12. Carboniferous sandstone : Upper
carboniferous.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : VIa.
Carboniferous (coal-measures) : 11. Carboniferous limestone : Lower
carboniferous.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : V.
Devonian : 10. Pilton : Upper devonian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : V.
Devonian : 9. Ilfracombe : Middle devonian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : V.
Devonian : 8. Linton : Lower devonian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : IV.
Silurian : 7. Ludlow : Upper silurian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : IV.
Silurian : 6. Wenlock : Middle silurian.

II. Paleolithic group, or paleozoic (primary) group of strata : IV.
Silurian : 5. Llandeilo : Lower silurian.

I. Archeolithic group, or archeozoic (primordial) group of strata :
III. Cambrian : 4. Potsdam : Upper cambrian.

I. Archeolithic group, or archeozoic (primordial) group of strata :
III. Cambrian : 3. Longmynd : Lower cambrian.

I. Archeolithic group, or archeozoic (primordial) group of strata :
II. Huronian : 2. Labrador : Upper laurentian.

I. Archeolithic group, or archeozoic (primordial) group of strata : I.
Laurentian : 1. Ottawa : Lower laurentian.

The primordial period falls into three subordinate sections--the
Laurentian, Huronian, and Cambrian, corresponding to the three chief
groups of rocks that comprise the archaic formation. The immense
period during which these rocks were forming in the primitive ocean
probably comprises more than 50,000,000 years. At the commencement of
it the oldest and simplest organisms were formed by spontaneous
generation--the Monera, with which the history of life on our planet
opened. From these were first developed unicellular organisms of the
simplest character, the Protophyta and Protozoa (paulotomea, amoebae,
rhizopods, infusoria, and other Protists). During this period the
whole of the invertebrate ancestors of the human race were evolved
from the unicellular organisms. We can deduce this from the fact that
we already find remains of fossilised fishes (Selachii and Ganoids)
towards the close of the following Silurian period. These are much
more advanced and much younger than the lowest vertebrate, the
Amphioxus, and the numerous skull-less vertebrates, related to the
Amphioxus, that must have lived at that time. The whole of the
invertebrate ancestors of the human race must have preceded these.

The primordial age is followed by a much shorter division, the
paleozoic or Primary age. It is divided into four long periods, the
Silurian, Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian. The Silurian strata
are particularly interesting because they contain the first fossil
traces of vertebrates--teeth and scales of Selachii (Palaeodus) in the
lower, and Ganoids (Pteraspis) in the upper Silurian. During the
Devonian period the "old red sandstone" was formed; during the
Carboniferous period were deposited the vast coal-measures that yield
us our chief combustive material; in the Permian (or the Dyas), in
fine, the new red sandstone, the Zechstein (magnesian limestone), and
the Kupferschiefer (marl-slate) were formed. The collective depth of
these strata is put at 40,000 to 45,000 feet. In any case, the
paleozoic age, taken as a whole, was much shorter than the preceding
and much longer than the subsequent periods. The strata that were
deposited during this primary epoch contain a large number of fossils;
besides the invertebrate species there are a good many vertebrates,
and the fishes preponderate. There were so many fishes, especially
primitive fishes (of the shark type) and plated fishes, during the
Devonian, and also during the Carboniferous and Permian periods, that
we may describe the whole paleozoic period as "the age of fishes."
Among the paleozoic plated fishes or Ganoids the Crossopterygii and
the Ctenodipterina (dipneusts) are of great importance.

During this period some of the fishes began to adapt themselves to
living on land, and so gave rise to the class of the amphibia. We find
in the Carboniferous period fossilised remains of five-toed amphibia,
the oldest terrestrial, air-breathing vertebrates. These amphibia
increase in variety in the Permian epoch. Towards the close of it we
find the first Amniotes, the ancestors of the three higher classes of
Vertebrates. These are lizard-like animals; the first to be discovered
was the Proterosaurus, from the marl at Eisenach. The rise of the
earliest Amniotes, among which must have been the common ancestor of
the reptiles, birds, and mammals, is put back towards the close of the
paleozoic age by the discovery of these reptile remains. The ancestors
of our race during this period were at first represented by true
fishes, then by dipneusts and amphibia, and finally by the earliest
Amniotes, or the Protamniotes.

The third chief section of the organic history of the earth is the
Mesozoic or Secondary period. This again is subdivided into three
divisions Triassic, Jurassic, and Cretaceous. The thickness of the
strata that were deposited in this period, from the beginning of the
Triassic to the end of the Cretaceous period, is altogether about
15,000 feet, or not half as much as the paleozoic deposits. During
this period there was a very brisk and manifold development in all
branches of the animal kingdom. There were especially a number of new
and interesting forms evolved in the vertebrate stem. Bony fishes
(Teleostei) make their first appearance. Reptiles are found in
extraordinary variety and number; the extinct giant-serpents
(dinosauria), the sea-serpents (halisauria), and the flying lizards
(pterosauria) are the most remarkable and best known of these. On
account of this predominance of the reptile-class, the period is
called "the age of reptiles." But the bird-class was also evolved
during this period; they certainly originated from some division of
the lizard-like reptiles. This is proved by the embryological identity
of the birds and reptiles and their comparative anatomy, and, among
other features, from the circumstance that in this period there were
birds with teeth in their jaws and with tails like lizards
(Archeopteryx, Odontornis).

Finally, the most advanced and (for us) the most important class of
the vertebrates, the mammals, made their appearance during the
mesozoic period. The earliest fossil remains of them were found in the
latest Triassic strata--lower jaws of small ungulates and marsupials.
More numerous remains are found a little later in the Jurassic, and
some in the Cretaceous. All the mammal remains that we have from this
section belong to the lower promammals and marsupials; among these
were most certainly the ancestors of the human race. On the other
hand, we have not found a single indisputable fossil of any higher
mammal (a placental) in the whole of this period. This division of the
mammals, which includes man, was not developed until later, towards
the close of this or in the following period.

The fourth section of the organic history of the earth, the Tertiary
or Cenozoic age, was much shorter than the preceding. The strata that
were deposited during this period have a collective thickness of only
about 3,000 feet. It is subdivided into four sections--the Eocene,
Oligocene, Miocene, and Pliocene. During these periods there was a
very varied development of higher plant and animal forms; the fauna
and flora of our planet approached nearer and nearer to the character
that they bear to-day. In particular, the most advanced class, the
mammals, began to preponderate. Hence the Tertiary period may be
called "the age of mammals." The highest section of this class, the
placentals, now made their appearance; to this group the human race
belongs. The first appearance of man, or, to be more precise, the
development of man from some closely-related group of apes, probably
falls in either the miocene or the pliocene period, the middle or the
last section of the Tertiary period. Others believe that man properly
so-called--man endowed with speech--was not evolved from the
non-speaking ape-man (Pithecanthropus) until the following, the
anthropozoic, age.

In this fifth and last section of the organic history of the earth we
have the full development and dispersion of the various races of men,
and so it is called the Anthropozoic as well as the Quaternary period.
In the imperfect condition of paleontological and ethnographical
science we cannot as yet give a confident answer to the question
whether the evolution of the human race from some extinct ape or lemur
took place at the beginning of this or towards the middle or the end
of the Tertiary period. However, this much is certain: the development
of civilisation falls in the anthropozoic age, and this is merely an
insignificant fraction of the vast period of the whole history of
life. When we remember this, it seems ridiculous to restrict the word
"history" to the civilised period. If we divide into a hundred equal
parts the whole period of the history of life, from the spontaneous
generation of the first Monera to the present day, and if we then
represent the relative duration of the five chief sections or ages, as
calculated from the average thickness of the strata they contain, as
percentages of this, we get something like the following relation:--

I. Archeolithic or archeozoic (primordial) age : 53 : 6.

II. Paleolithic or paleozoic (primary) age : 32 : 1.

III. Mesolithic or mesozoic (secondary) age : 11 : 5.

IV. Cenolithic or cenozoic (tertiary) age : 2 : 3

V. Anthropolithic or anthropozoic (quaternary) age : 0 : 5.

Total : 100 : 0.

In any case, the "historical period" is an insignificant quantity
compared with the vast length of the preceding ages, in which there
was no question of human existence on our planet. Even the important
Cenozoic or Tertiary period, in which the first placentals or higher
mammals appear, probably amounts to little over two per cent of the
whole organic age.

Before we approach our proper task, and, with the aid of our
ontogenetic acquirements and the biogenetic law, follow step by step
the paleontological development of our animal ancestors, let us glance
for a moment at another, and apparently quite remote, branch of
science, a general consideration of which will help us in the solving
of a difficult problem. I mean the science of comparative philology.
Since Darwin gave new life to biology by his theory of selection, and
raised the question of evolution on all sides, it has often been
pointed out that there is a remarkable analogy between the development
of languages and the evolution of species. The comparison is perfectly
just and very instructive. We could hardly find a better analogy when
we are dealing with some of the difficult and obscure features of the
evolution of species. In both cases we find the action of the same
natural laws.

All philologists of any competence in their science now agree that all
human languages have been gradually evolved from very rudimentary
beginnings. The idea that speech is a gift of the gods--an idea held
by distinguished authorities only fifty years ago--is now generally
abandoned, and only supported by theologians and others who admit no
natural development whatever. Speech has been developed simultaneously
with its organs, the larynx and tongue, and with the functions of the
brain. Hence it will be quite natural to find in the evolution and
classification of languages the same features as in the evolution and
classification of organic species. The various groups of languages
that are distinguished in philology as primitive, fundamental, parent,
and daughter languages, dialects, etc., correspond entirely in their
development to the different categories which we classify in zoology
and botany as stems, classes, orders, families, genera, species, and
varieties. The relation of these groups, partly co-ordinate and partly
subordinate, in the general scheme is just the same in both cases; and
the evolution follows the same lines in both.

When, with the assistance of this tree, we follow the formation of the
various languages that have been developed from the common root of the
ancient Indo-Germanic tongue, we get a very clear idea of their
phylogeny. We shall see at the same time how analogous this is to the
development of the various groups of vertebrates that have arisen from
the common stem-form of the primitive vertebrate. The ancient
Indo-Germanic root-language divided first into two principal
stems--the Slavo-Germanic and the Aryo-Romanic. The Slavo-Germanic
stem then branches into the ancient Germanic and the ancient
Slavo-Lettic tongues; the Aryo-Romanic into the ancient Aryan and the
ancient Greco-Roman. If we still follow the genealogical tree of these
four Indo-Germanic tongues, we find that the ancient Germanic divides
into three branches--the Scandinavian, the Gothic, and the German.
From the ancient German came the High German and Low German; to the
latter belong the Frisian, Saxon, and modern Low-German dialects. The
ancient Slavo-Lettic divided first into a Baltic and a Slav language.
The Baltic gave rise to the Lett, Lithuanian, and old-Prussian
varieties; the Slav to the Russian and South-Slav in the south-east,
and to the Polish and Czech in the west.

We find an equally prolific branching of its two chief stems when we
turn to the other division of the Indo-Germanic languages. The
Greco-Roman divided into the Thracian (Albano-Greek) and the
Italo-Celtic. From the latter came the divergent branches of the
Italic (Roman and Latin) in the south, and the Celtic in the north:
from the latter have been developed all the British (ancient British,
ancient Scotch, and Irish) and Gallic varieties. The ancient Aryan
gave rise to the numerous Iranian and Indian languages.

This "comparative anatomy" and evolution of languages admirably
illustrates the phylogeny of species. It is clear that in structure
and development the primitive languages, mother and daughter
languages, and varieties, correspond exactly to the classes, orders,
genera, and species of the animal world. In both cases the "natural"
system is phylogenetic. As we have been convinced from comparative
anatomy and ontogeny, and from paleontology, that all past and living
vertebrates descend from a common ancestor, so the comparative study
of dead and living Indo-Germanic tongues proves beyond question that
they are all modifications of one primitive language. This view of
their origin is now accepted by all the chief philologists who have
worked in this branch and are unprejudiced.

But the point to which I desire particularly to draw the reader's
attention in this comparison of the Indo-Germanic languages with the
branches of the vertebrate stem is, that one must never confuse direct
descendants with collateral branches, nor extinct forms with living.
This confusion is very common, and our opponents often make use of the
erroneous ideas it gives rise to for the purpose of attacking
evolution generally. When, for instance, we say that man descends from
the ape, this from the lemur, and the lemur from the marsupial, many
people imagine that we are speaking of the living species of these
orders of mammals that they find stuffed in our museums. Our opponents
then foist this idea on us, and say, with more astuteness than
intelligence, that it is quite impossible; or they ask us, by way of
physiological experiment, to turn a kangaroo into a lemur, a lemur
into a gorilla, and a gorilla into a man! The demand is childish, and
the idea it rests on erroneous. All these living forms have diverged
more or less from the ancestral form; none of them could engender the
same posterity that the stem-form really produced thousands of years
ago.

It is certain that man has descended from some extinct mammal; and we
should just as certainly class this in the order of apes if we had it
before us. It is equally certain that this primitive ape descended in
turn from an unknown lemur, and this from an extinct marsupial. But it
is just as clear that all these extinct ancestral forms can only be
claimed as belonging to the living order of mammals in virtue of their
essential internal structure and their resemblance in the decisive
anatomic characteristics of each ORDER. In external appearance, in the
characteristics of the GENUS or SPECIES, they would differ more or
less, perhaps very considerably, from all living representatives of
those orders. It is a universal and natural procedure in phylogenetic
development that the stem-forms themselves, with their specific
peculiarities, have been extinct for some time. The forms that
approach nearest to them among the living species are more or
less--perhaps very substantially--different from them. Hence in our
phylogenetic inquiry and in the comparative study of the living,
divergent descendants, there can only be a question of determining the
greater or less remoteness of the latter from the ancestral form. Not
a single one of the older stem-forms has continued unchanged down to
our time.

We find just the same thing in comparing the various dead and living
languages that have developed from a common primitive tongue. If we
examine our genealogical tree of the Indo-Germanic languages in this
light, we see at once that all the older or parent tongues, of which
we regard the living varieties of the stem as divergent daughter or
grand-daughter languages, have been extinct for some time. The
Aryo-Romanic and the Slavo-Germanic tongues have completely
disappeared; so also the Aryan, the Greco-Roman, the Slavo-Lettic, and
the ancient Germanic. Even their daughters and grand-daughters have
been lost; all the living Indo-Germanic languages are only related in
the sense that they are divergent descendants of common stem-forms.
Some forms have diverged more, and some less, from the original
stem-form.

This easily demonstrable fact illustrates very well the analogous case
of the origin of the vertebrate species. Phylogenetic comparative
philology here yields a strong support to phylogenetic comparative
zoology. But the one can adduce more direct evidence than the other,
as the paleontological material of philology--the old monuments of the
extinct tongue--have been preserved much better than the
paleontological material of zoology, the fossilised bones and imprints
of vertebrates.

We may, however, trace man's genealogical tree not only as far as the
lower mammals, but much further--to the amphibia, to the shark-like
primitive fishes, and, in fine, to the skull-less vertebrates that
closely resembled the Amphioxus. But this must not be understood in
the sense that the existing Amphioxus, or the sharks or amphibia of
to-day, can give us any idea of the external appearance of these
remote stem-forms. Still less must it be thought that the Amphioxus or
any actual shark, or any living species of amphibia, is a real
ancestral form of the higher vertebrates and man. The statement can
only rationally mean that the living forms I have referred to are
COLLATERAL LINES that are much more closely related to the extinct
stem-forms, and have retained the resemblance much better, than any
other animals we know. They are still so like them in regard to their
distinctive internal structure that we should put them in the same
class with the extinct forms if we had these before us. But no direct
descendants of these earlier forms have remained unchanged. Hence we
must entirely abandon the idea of finding direct ancestors of the
human race in their characteristic EXTERNAL FORM among the living
species of animals. The essential and distinctive features that still
connect living forms more or less closely with the extinct common
stem-forms lie in the internal structure, not the external appearance.
The latter has been much modified by adaptation. The former has been
more or less preserved by heredity.

Comparative anatomy and ontogeny prove beyond question that man is a
true vertebrate, and, therefore, man's special genealogical tree must
be connected with that of the other Vertebrates, which spring from a
common root with him. But we have also many important grounds in
comparative anatomy and ontogeny for assuming a common origin for all
the Vertebrates. If the general theory of evolution is correct, all
the Vertebrates, including man, come from a single common ancestor, a
long-extinct "Primitive Vertebrate." Hence the genealogical tree of
the Vertebrates is at the same time that of the human race.

Our task, therefore, of constructing man's genealogy becomes the
larger aim of discovering the genealogy of the entire vertebrate stem.
As we now know from the comparative anatomy and ontogeny of the
Amphioxus and the Ascidia, this is in turn connected with the
genealogical tree of the Invertebrates (directly with that of the
Vermalia), but has no direct connection with the independent stems of
the Articulates, Molluscs, and Echinoderms. If we do thus follow our
ancestral tree through various stages down to the lowest worms, we
come inevitably to the Gastraea, that most instructive form that gives
the clearest possible picture of an animal with two germinal layers.
The Gastraea itself has originated from the simple multicellular
vesicle, the Blastaea, and this in turn must have been evolved from
the lowest circle of unicellular animals, to which we give the name of
Protozoa. We have already considered the most important primitive type
of these, the unicellular Amoeba, which is extremely instructive when
compared with the human ovum. With this we reach the lowest of the
solid data to which we are to apply our biogenetic law, and by which
we may deduce the extinct ancestor from the embryonic form. The
amoeboid nature of the young ovum and the unicellular condition in
which (as stem-cell or cytula) every human being begins its existence
justify us in affirming that the earliest ancestors of the human race
were simple amoeboid coils.

But the further question now arises: "Whence came these first amoebae
with which the history of life began at the commencement of the
Laurentian epoch?" There is only one answer to this. The earliest
unicellular organisms can only have been evolved from the simplest
organisms we know, the Monera. These are the simplest living things
that we can conceive. Their whole body is nothing but a particle of
plasm, a granule of living albuminous matter, discharging of itself
all the essential vital functions that form the material basis of
life. Thus we come to the last, or, if you prefer, the first, question
in connection with evolution--the question of the origin of the
Monera. This is the real question of the origin of life, or of
spontaneous generation.

We have neither space nor occasion to go further in this Chapter into
the question of spontaneous generation. For this I must refer the
reader to the fifteenth chapter of the History of Creation, and
especially to the second book of the General Morphology, or to the
essay on "The Monera and Spontaneous Generation" in my Studies of the
Monera and other Protists.* (* The English reader will find a luminous
and up-to-date chapter on the subject in Haeckel's recently written
and translated Wonders of Life.--Translator.) I have given there fully
my own view of this important question. The famous botanist Nageli
afterwards (1884) developed the same ideas. I will only say a few
words here about this obscure question of the origin of life, in so
far as our main subject, organic evolution in general, is affected by
it. Spontaneous generation, in the definite and restricted sense in
which I maintain it, and claim that it is a necessary hypothesis in
explaining the origin of life, refers solely to the evolution of the
Monera from inorganic carbon-compounds. When living things made their
first appearance on our planet, the very complex nitrogenous compound
of carbon that we call plasson, which is the earliest material
embodiment of vital action, must have been formed in a purely chemical
way from inorganic carbon-compounds. The first Monera were formed in
the sea by spontaneous generation, as crystals are formed in the
mother-water. Our demand for a knowledge of causes compels us to
assume this. If we believe that the whole inorganic history of the
earth has proceeded on mechanical principles without any intervention
of a Creator, and that the history of life also has been determined by
the same mechanical laws; if we see that there is no need to admit
creative action to explain the origin of the various groups of
organisms; it is utterly irrational to assume such creative action in
dealing with the first appearance of organic life on the earth.

This much-disputed question of "spontaneous generation" seems so
obscure, because people have associated with the term a mass of very
different, and often very absurd, ideas, and have attempted to solve
the difficulty by the crudest experiments. The real doctrine of the
spontaneous generation of life cannot possibly be refuted by
experiments. Every experiment that has a negative result only proves
that no organism has been formed out of inorganic matter in the
conditions--highly artificial conditions--we have established. On the
other hand, it would be exceedingly difficult to prove the theory by
way of experiment; and even if Monera were still formed daily by
spontaneous generation (which is quite possible), it would be very
difficult, if not impossible, to find a solid proof of it. Those who
will not admit the spontaneous generation of the first living things
in our sense must have recourse to a supernatural miracle; and this
is, as a matter of fact, the desperate resource to which our "exact"
scientists are driven, to the complete abdication of reason.

A famous English physicist, Lord Kelvin (then Sir W. Thomson),
attempted to dispense with the hypothesis of spontaneous generation by
assuming that the organic inhabitants of the earth were developed from
germs that came from the inhabitants of other planets, and that
chanced to fall on our planet on fragments of their original home, or
meteorites. This hypothesis found many supporters, among others the
distinguished German physicist, Helmholtz. However, it was refuted in
1872 by the able physicist, Friedrich Zollner, of Leipzig, in his
work, On the Nature of Comets. He showed clearly how unscientific this
hypothesis is; firstly in point of logic, and secondly in point of
scientific content. At the same time he pointed out that our
hypothesis of spontaneous generation is "a necessary condition for
understanding nature according to the law of causality."

I repeat that we must call in the aid of the hypothesis only as
regards the Monera, the structureless "organisms without organs."
Every complex organism must have been evolved from some lower
organism. We must not assume the spontaneous generation of even the
simplest cell, for this itself consists of at least two parts--the
internal, firm nuclear substance, and the external, softer cellular
substance or the protoplasm of the cell-body. These two parts must
have been formed by differentiation from the indifferent plasson of a
moneron, or a cytode. For this reason the natural history of the
Monera is of great interest; here alone can we find the means to
overcome the chief difficulties of the problem of spontaneous
generation. The actual living Monera are specimens of such organless
or structureless organisms, as they must have boon formed by
spontaneous generation at the commencement of the history of life.


CHAPTER 2.19. OUR PROTIST ANCESTORS.

Under the guidance of the biogenetic law, and on the basis of the
evidence we have obtained, we now turn to the interesting task of
determining the series of man's animal ancestors. Phylogeny us a whole
is an inductive science. From the totality of the biological processes
in the life of plants, animals, and man we have gathered a confident
inductive idea that the whole organic population of our planet has
been moulded on a harmonious law of evolution. All the interesting
phenomena that we meet in ontogeny and paleontology, comparative
anatomy and dysteleology, the distribution and habits of
organisms--all the important general laws that we abstract from the
phenomena of these sciences, and combine in harmonious unity--are the
broad bases of our great biological induction.

But when we come to the application of this law, and seek to determine
with its aid the origin of the various species of organisms, we are
compelled to frame hypotheses that have essentially a DEDUCTIVE
character, and are inferences from the general law to particular
cases. But these special deductions are just as much justified and
necessitated by the rigorous laws of logic as the inductive
conclusions on which the whole theory of evolution is built. The
doctrine of the animal ancestry of the human race is a special
deduction of this kind, and follows with logical necessity from the
general inductive law of evolution.

I must point out at once, however, that the certainty of these
evolutionary hypotheses, which rest on clear special deductions, is
not always equally strong. Some of these inferences are now beyond
question; in the case of others it depends on the knowledge and the
competence of the inquirer what degree of certainty he attributes to
them. In any case, we must distinguish between the ABSOLUTE certainty
of the general (inductive) theory of descent and the RELATIVE
certainty of special (deductive) evolutionary hypotheses. We can never
determine the whole ancestral series of an organism with the same
confidence with which we hold the general theory of evolution as the
sole scientific explanation of organic modifications. The special
indication of stem-forms in detail will always be more or less
incomplete and hypothetical. This is quite natural. The evidence on
which we build is imperfect, and always will be imperfect; just as in
comparative philology.

The first of our documents, paleontology, is exceedingly incomplete.
We know that all the fossils yet discovered are only an insignificant
fraction of the plants and animals that have lived on our planet. For
every single species that has been preserved for us in the rocks there
are probably hundreds, perhaps thousands, of extinct species that have
left no trace behind them. This extreme and very unfortunate
incompleteness of the paleontological evidence, which cannot be
pointed out too often, is easily explained. It is absolutely
inevitable in the circumstances of the fossilisation of organisms. It
is also due in part to the incompleteness of our knowledge in this
branch. It must be borne in mind that the great majority of the
stratified rocks that compose the crust of the earth have not yet been
opened. We have only a few specimens of the innumerable fossils that
are buried in the vast mountain ranges of Asia and Africa. Only a part
of Europe and North America has been investigated carefully. The whole
of the fossils known to us certainly do not amount to a hundredth part
of the remains that are really buried in the crust of the earth. We
may, therefore, look forward to a rich harvest in the future as
regards this science. However, our paleontological evidence will (for
reasons that I have fully explained in the sixteenth chapter of the
History of Creation) always be defective.

The second chief source of evidence, ontogeny, is not less incomplete.
It is the most important source of all for special phylogeny; but it
has great defects, and often fails us. We must, above all, clearly
distinguish between palingenetic and cenogenetic phenomena. We must
never forget that the laws of curtailed and disturbed heredity often
make the original course of development almost unrecognisable. The
recapitulation of phylogeny by ontogeny is only fairly complete in a
few cases, and is never wholly complete. As a rule, it is precisely
the earliest and most important embryonic stages that suffer most from
alteration and condensation. The earlier embryonic forms have had to
adapt themselves to new circumstances, and so have been modified. The
struggle for existence has had just as profound an influence on the
freely moving and still immature young forms as on the adult forms.
Hence in the embryology of the higher animals, especially,
palingenesis is much restricted by cenogenesis; it is to-day, as a
rule, only a faded and much altered picture of the original evolution
of the animal's ancestors. We can only draw conclusions from the
embryonic forms to the stem-history with the greatest caution and
discrimination. Moreover, the embryonic development itself has only
been fully studied in a few species.

Finally, the third and most valuable source of evidence, comparative
anatomy, is also, unfortunately, very imperfect; for the simple reason
that the whole of the living species of animals are a mere fraction of
the vast population that has dwelt on our planet since the beginning
of life. We may confidently put the total number of these at more than
a million species. The number of animals whose organisation has been
studied up to the present in comparative anatomy is proportionately
very small. Here, again, future research will yield incalculable
treasures. But, for the present, in view of this patent incompleteness
of our chief sources of evidence, we must naturally be careful not to
lay too much stress in human phylogeny on the particular animals we
have studied, or regard all the various stages of development with
equal confidence as stem-forms.

In my first efforts to construct the series of man's ancestors I drew
up a list of, at first ten, afterwards twenty to thirty, forms that
may be regarded more or less certainly as animal ancestors of the
human race, or as stages that in a sense mark off the chief sections
in the long story of evolution from the unicellular organism to man.
Of these twenty to thirty stages, ten to twelve belong to the older
group of the Invertebrates and eighteen to twenty to the younger
division of the Vertebrates.

In approaching, now, the difficult task of establishing the
evolutionary succession of these thirty ancestors of humanity since
the beginning of life, and in venturing to lift the veil that covers
the earliest secrets of the earth's history, we must undoubtedly look
for the first living things among the wonderful organisms that we call
the Monera; they are the simplest organisms known to us--in fact, the
simplest we can conceive. Their whole body consists merely of a simple
particle or globule of structureless plasm or plasson. The discoveries
of the last four decades have led us to believe with increasing
certainty that wherever a natural body exhibits the vital processes of
nutrition, reproduction, voluntary movement, and sensation, we have
the action of a nitrogenous carbon-compound of the chemical group of
the albuminoids; this plasm (or protoplasm) is the material basis of
all vital functions. Whether we regarded the function, in the monistic
sense, as the direct action of the material substratum, or whether we
take matter and force to be distinct things in the dualistic sense, it
is certain that we have not as yet found any living organism in which
the exercise of the vital functions is not inseparably bound up with
plasm.

The soft slimy plasson of the body of the moneron is generally called
"protoplasm," and identified with the cellular matter of the ordinary
plant and animal cells. But we must, to be accurate, distinguish
between the plasson of the cytodes and the protoplasm of the cells.
This distinction is of the utmost importance for the purposes of
evolution. As I have often said, we must recognise two different
stages of development in these "elementary organisms," or plastids
("builders"), that represent the ultimate units of organic
individuality. The earlier and lower stage are the unnucleated
cytodes, the body of which consists of only one kind of albuminous
matter--the homogeneous plasson or "formative matter." The later and
higher stage are the nucleated cells, in which we find a
differentiation of the original plasson into two different formative
substances--the caryoplasm of the nucleus and the cytoplasm of the
body of the cell (cf. Chapter 1.6.)

(FIGURE 2.226. Chroococcus minor (Nageli), magnified 1500 times. A
phytomoneron, the globular plastids of which secrete a gelatinous
structureless membrane. The unnucleated globule of plasm (bluish-green
in colour) increases by simple cleavage (a to d).

The Monera are permanent cytodes. Their whole body consists of soft,
structureless plasson. However carefully we examine it with our finest
chemical reagents and most powerful microscopes, we can find no
definite parts or no anatomic structure in it. Hence, the Monera are
literally organisms without organs; in fact, from the philosophic
point of view they are not organisms at all, since they have no
organs. They can only be called organisms in the sense that they are
capable of the vital functions of nutrition, reproduction, sensation,
and movement. If we were to try to imagine the simplest possible
organism, we should frame something like the moneron.

The Monera that we find to-day in various forms fall into two groups
according to the nature of their nutrition--the Phytomonera and the
Zoomonera; from the physiological point of view, the former are the
simplest specimens of the plant (phyton) kingdom, and the latter of
the animal (zoon) world. The Phytomonera, especially in their simplest
form, the Chromacea (Phycochromacea or Cyanophycea), are the most
primitive and the oldest of living organisms. The typical genus
Chroococcus (Figure 2.226) is represented by several fresh-water
species, and often forms a very delicate bluish-green deposit on
stones and wood in ponds and ditches. It consists of round, light
green particles, from 1/7000 to 1/2500 of an inch in diameter.

(FIGURE 2.227. Aphanocapsa primordialis (Nageli), magnified 1000
times. A phytomoneron, the round plastids of which (bluish-green in
colour) secrete a shapeless gelatinous mass; in this the unnucleated
cytodes increase continually by simple cleavage.)

The whole life of these homogeneous globules of plasm consists of
simple growth and reproduction by cleavage. When the tiny particle has
reached a certain size by the continuous assimilation of inorganic
matter, it divides into two equal halves, by a constriction in the
middle. The two daughter-monera that are thus formed immediately begin
a similar vital process. It is the same with the brown Procytella
primordialis (formerly called the Protococcus marinus); it forms large
masses of floating matter in the arctic seas. The tiny plasma-globules
of this species are of a greenish-brown colour, and have a diameter of
1/10,000 to 1/5000 of an inch. There is no membrane discoverable in
the simplest Chroococcacea, but we find one in other members of the
same family; in Aphanocapsa (Figure 2.227) the enveloping membranes of
the social plastids combine; in Gloecapsa they are retained through
several generations, so that the little plasma-globules are enfolded
in many layers of membrane.

Next to the Chromacea come the Bacteria, which have been evolved from
them by the remarkable change in nutrition which gives us the simple
explanation of the differentiation of plant and animal in the protist
kingdom. The Chromacea build up their plasm directly from inorganic
matter; the Bacteria feed on organic matter. Hence, if we logically
divide the protist kingdom into plasma-forming Protophyta and
plasma-consuming Protozoa, we must class the Bacteria with the latter;
it is quite illogical to describe them--as is still often done--as
Schizomycetes, and class them with the true fungi. The Bacteria, like
the Chromacea, have no nucleus. As is well-known, they play an
important part in modern biology as the causes of fermentation and
putrefaction, and of tuberculosis, typhus, cholera, and other
infectious diseases, and as parasites, etc. But we cannot linger now
to deal with these very interesting features; the Bacteria have no
relation to man's genealogical tree.

We may now turn to consider the remarkable Protamoeba, or unnucleated
Amoeba. I have, in the first volume, pointed out the great importance
of the ordinary Amoeba in connection with several weighty questions of
general biology. The tiny Protamoebae, which are found both in fresh
and salt water, have the same unshapely form and irregular movements
of their simple naked body as the real Amoebae; but they differ from
them very materially in having no nucleus in their cell-body. The
short, blunt, finger-like processes that are thrust out at the surface
of the creeping Protamoeba serve for getting food as well as for
locomotion. They multiply by simple cleavage (Figure 2.228).

(FIGURE 2.228. A moneron (Protamoeba) in the act of reproduction. A
The whole moneron, moving like an ordinary amoeba by thrusting out
changeable processes. B It divides into two halves by a constriction
in the middle. C The two halves separate, and each becomes an
independent individual. (Highly magnified.))

The next stage to the simple cytode-forms of the Monera in the
genealogy of mankind (and all other animals) is the simple cell, or
the most rudimentary form of the cell which we find living
independently to-day as the Amoeba. The earliest process of inorganic
differentiation in the structureless body of the Monera led to its
division into two different substances--the caryoplasm and the
cytoplasm. The caryoplasm is the inner and firmer part of the cell,
the substance of the nucleus. The cytoplasm is the outer and softer
part, the substance of the body of the cell. By this important
differentiation of the plasson into nucleus and cell-body, the
organised cell was evolved from the structureless cytode, the
nucleated from the unnucleated plastid. That the first cells to appear
on the earth were formed from the Monera by such a differentiation
seems to us the only possible view in the present condition of
science. We have a direct instance of this earliest process of
differentiation to-day in the ontogeny of many of the lower Protists
(such as the Gregarinae).

The unicellular form that we have in the ovum has already been
described as the reproduction of a corresponding unicellular
stem-form, and to this we have ascribed the organisation of an Amoeba
(cf. Chapter 1.6). The irregular-shaped Amoeba, which we find living
independently to-day in our fresh and salt water, is the least
definite and the most primitive of all the unicellular Protozoa
(Figure 1.16). As the unripe ova (the protova that we find in the
ovaries of animals) cannot be distinguished from the common Amoebae,
we must regard the Amoeba as the primitive form that is reproduced in
the embryonic stage of the amoeboid ovum to-day, in accordance with
the biogenetic law. I have already pointed out, in proof of the
striking resemblance of the two cells, that the ova of many of the
sponges were formerly regarded as parasitic Amoebae (Figure 1.18).
Large unicellular organisms like the Amoebae were found creeping about
inside the body of the sponge, and were thought to be parasites. It
was afterwards discovered that they were really the ova of the sponge
from which the embryos were developed. As a matter of fact, these
sponge-ova are so much like many of the Amoebae in size, shape, the
character of their nucleus, and movement of the pseudopodia, that it
is impossible to distinguish them without knowing their subsequent
development.

Our phylogenetic interpretation of the ovum, and the reduction of it
to some ancient amoeboid ancestral form, supply the answer to the old
problem: "Which was first, the egg or the chick?" We can now give a
very plain answer to this riddle, with which our opponents have often
tried to drive us into a corner. The egg came a long time before the
chick. We do not mean, of course, that the egg existed from the first
as a bird's egg, but as an indifferent amoeboid cell of the simplest
character. The egg lived for thousands of years as an independent
unicellular organism, the Amoeba. The egg, in the modern physiological
sense of the word, did not make its appearance until the descendants
of the unicellular Protozoon had developed into multicellular animals,
and these had undergone sexual differentiation. Even then the egg was
first a gastraea-egg, then a platode-egg, then a vermalia-egg, and
chordonia-egg; later still acrania-egg, then fish-egg, amphibia-egg,
reptile-egg, and finally bird's egg. The bird's egg we have experience
of daily is a highly complicated historical product, the result of
countless hereditary processes that have taken place in the course of
millions of years.

The earliest ancestors of our race were simple Protophyta, and from
these our protozoic ancestors were developed afterwards. From the
morphological point of view both the vegetal and the animal Protists
were simple organisms, individualities of the first order, or
plastids. All our later ancestors are complex organisms, or
individualities of a higher order--social aggregations of a plurality
of cells. The earliest of these, the Moraeada, which represent the
third stage in our genealogy, are very simple associations of
homogeneous, indifferent cells--undifferentiated colonies of social
Amoebae or Infusoria. To understand the nature and origin of these
protozoa-colonies we need only follow step by step the first embryonic
products of the stem-cell. In all the Metazoa the first embryonic
process is the repeated cleavage of the stem-cell, or first
segmentation-cell (Figure 2.229). We have already fully considered
this process, and found that all the different forms of it may be
reduced to one type, the original equal or primordial segmentation
(cf. Chapter 1.8). In the genealogical tree of the Vertebrates this
palingenetic form of segmentation has been preserved in the Amphioxus
alone, all the other Vertebrates having cenogenetically modified forms
of cleavage. In any case, the latter were developed from the former,
and so the segmentation of the ovum in the Amphioxus has a great
interest for us (cf. Figure 1.38). The outcome of this repeated
cleavage is the formation of a round cluster of cells, composed of
homogeneous, indifferent cells of the simplest character (Figure
2.230). This is called the morula (= mulberry-embryo) on account of
its resemblance to a mulberry or blackberry.

(FIGURE 2.229. Original or primordial ovum-cleavage. The stem-cell or
cytula, formed by fecundation of the ovum, divides by repeated regular
cleavage first into two (A), then four (B), then eight (C), and
finally a large number of segmentation-cells (D).

FIGURE 2.230. Morula, or mulberry-shaped embryo.)

It is clear that this morula reproduces for us to-day the simple
structure of the multicellular animal that succeeded the unicellular
amoeboid form in the early Laurentian period. In accordance with the
biogenetic law, the morula recalls the ancestral form of the Moraea,
or simple colony of Protozoa. The first cell-communities to be formed,
which laid the early foundation of the higher multicellular body, must
have consisted of homogeneous and simple amoeboid cells. The oldest
Amoebae lived isolated lives, and even the amoeboid cells that were
formed by the segmentation of these unicellular organisms must have
continued to live independently for a long time. But gradually small
communities of Amoebae arose by the side of these eremitical Protozoa,
the sister-cells produced by cleavage remaining joined together. The
advantages in the struggle for life which these communities had over
the isolated cells favoured their formation and their further
development. We find plenty of these cell-colonies or communities
to-day in both fresh and salt water. They belong to various groups
both of the Protophyta and Protozoa.

To have some idea of those ancestors of our race that succeeded
phylogenetically to the Moraeada, we have only to follow the further
embryonic development of the morula. We then see that the social cells
of the round cluster secrete a sort of jelly or a watery fluid inside
their globular body, and they themselves rise to the surface of it
(Figure 1.29 F, G). In this way the solid mulberry-embryo becomes a
hollow sphere, the wall of which is composed of a single layer of
cells. We call this layer the blastoderm, and the sphere itself the
blastula, or embryonic vesicle.

This interesting blastula is very important. The conversion of the
morula into a hollow ball proceeds on the same lines originally in the
most diverse stems--as, for instance, in many of the zoophytes and
worms, the ascidia, many of the echinoderms and molluscs, and in the
amphioxus. Moreover, in the animals in which we do not find a real
palingenetic blastula the defect is clearly due to cenogenetic causes,
such as the formation of food-yelk and other embryonic adaptations. We
may, therefore, conclude that the ontogenetic blastula is the
reproduction of a very early phylogenetic ancestral form, and that all
the Metazoa are descended from a common stem-form, which was in the
main constructed like the blastula. In many of the lower animals the
blastula is not developed within the foetal membranes, but in the open
water. In those cases each blastodermic cell begins at an early stage
to thrust out one or more mobile hair-like processes; the body swims
about by the vibratory movement of these lashes or whips (Figure 1.29
F).

We still find, both in the sea and in fresh water, various kinds of
primitive multicellular organisms that substantially resemble the
blastula in structure, and may be regarded in a sense as permanent
blastula-forms--hollow vesicles or gelatinous balls, with a wall
composed of a single layer of ciliated homogeneous cells. There are
"blastaeads" of this kind even among the Protophyta--the familiar
Volvocina, formerly classed with the infusoria. The common Volvox
globator is found in the ponds in the spring--a small, green,
gelatinous globule, swimming about by means of the stroke of its
lashes, which rise in pairs from the cells on its surface. In the
similar Halosphaera viridis also, which we find in the marine plancton
(floating matter), a number of green cells form a simple layer at the
surface of the gelatinous ball; but in this case there are no cilia.

Some of the infusoria of the flagellata-class (Signura, Magosphaera,
etc.) are similar in structure to these vegetal clusters, but differ
in their animal nutrition; they form the special group of the
Catallacta. In September, 1869, I studied the development of one of
these graceful animals on the island of Gis-Oe, off the coast of
Norway (Magosphaera planula), Figures 2.231 and 2.232). The
fully-formed body is a gelatinous ball, with its wall composed of
thirty-two to sixty-four ciliated cells; it swims about freely in the
sea. After reaching maturity the community is dissolved. Each cell
then lives independently for some time, grows, and changes into a
creeping amoeba. This afterwards contracts, and clothes itself with a
structureless membrane. The cell then looks just like an ordinary
animal ovum. When it has been in this condition for some time the cell
divides into two, four, eight, sixteen, thirty-two, and sixty-four
cells. These arrange themselves in a round vesicle, thrust out
vibratory lashes, burst the capsule, and swim about in the same
magosphaera-form with which we started. This completes the life-circle
of the remarkable and instructive animal.

If we compare these permanent blastulae with the free-swimming
ciliated larvae or blastulae, with similar construction, of many of
the lower animals, we can confidently deduce from them that there was
a very early and long-extinct common stem-form of substantially the
same structure as the blastula. We may call it the Blastaea. Its body
consisted, when fully formed, of a simple hollow ball, filled with
fluid or structureless jelly, with a wall composed of a single stratum
of ciliated cells. There were probably many genera and species of
these blastaeads in the Laurentian period, forming a special class of
marine protists.

It is an interesting fact that in the plant kingdom also the simple
hollow sphere is found to be an elementary form of the multicellular
organism. At the surface and below the surface (down to a depth of
2000 yards) of the sea there are green globules swimming about, with a
wall composed of a single layer of chlorophyll-bearing cells. The
botanist Schmitz gave them the name of Halosphaera viridis in 1879.

The next stage to the Blastaea, and the sixth in our genealogical
tree, is the Gastraea that is developed from it. As we have already
seen, this ancestral form is particularly important. That it once
existed is proved with certainty by the gastrula, which we find
temporarily in the ontogenesis of all the Metazoa (Figure 1.29 J, K).
As we saw, the original, palingenetic form of the gastrula is a round
or oval uni-axial body, the simple cavity of which (the primitive gut)
has an aperture at one pole of its axis (the primitive mouth). The
wall of the gut consists of two strata of cells, and these are the
primary germinal layers, the animal skin-layer (ectoderm) and vegetal
gut-layer (entoderm).

The actual ontogenetic development of the gastrula from the blastula
furnishes sound evidence as to the phylogenetic origin of the Gastraea
from the Blastaea. A pit-shaped depression appears at one side of the
spherical blastula (Figure 1.29 H). In the end this invagination goes
so far that the outer or invaginated part of the blastoderm lies close
on the inner or non-invaginated part (Figure 1.29 J). In explaining
the phylogenetic origin of the gastraea in the light of this
ontogenetic process, we may assume that the one-layered cell-community
of the blastaea began to take in food more largely at one particular
part of its surface. Natural selection would gradually lead to the
formation of a depression or pit at this alimentary spot on the
surface of the ball. The depression would grow deeper and deeper. In
time the vegetal function of taking in and digesting food would be
confined to the cells that lined this hole; the other cells would see
to the animal functions of locomotion, sensation, and protection. This
was the first division of labour among the originally homogeneous
cells of the blastaea.

(FIGURE 2.231. The Norwegian Magosphaera planula, swimming about by
means of the lashes or cilia at its surface.

FIGURE 2.232. Section of Magosphaera planula, showing how the
pear-shaped cells in the centre of the gelatinous ball are connected
by a fibrous process. Each cell has a contractile vacuole as well as a
nucleus.)

The effect, then, of this earliest histological differentiation was to
produce two different kinds of cells--nutritive cells in the
depression and locomotive cells on the surface outside. But this
involved the severance of the two primary germinal layers--a most
important process. When we remember that even man's body, with all its
various parts, and the body of all the other higher animals, are built
up originally out of these two simple layers, we cannot lay too much
stress on the phylogenetic significance of this gastrulation. In the
simple primitive gut or gastric cavity of the gastrula and its
rudimentary mouth we have the first real organ of the animal frame in
the morphological sense; all the other organs were developed
afterwards from these. In reality, the whole body of the gastrula is
merely a "primitive gut." I have shown already (Chapters 1.8 and 1.9)
that the two-layered embryos of all the Metazoa can be reduced to this
typical gastrula. This important fact justifies us in concluding, in
accordance with the biogenetic law, that their ancestors also were
phylogenetically developed from a similar stem-form. This ancient
stem-form is the gastraea.

The gastraea probably lived in the sea during the Laurentian period,
swimming about in the water by means of its ciliary coat much as free
ciliated gastrulae do to-day. Probably it differed from the existing
gastrula only in one essential point, though extinct millions of years
ago. We have reason, from comparative anatomy and ontogeny, to believe
that it multiplied by sexual generation, not merely asexually (by
cleavage, gemmation, and spores), as was no doubt the case with the
earlier ancestors. Some of the cells of the primary germ-layers
probably became ova and others fertilising sperm. We base these
hypotheses on the fact that we do to-day find the simplest form of
sexual reproduction in some of the living gastraeads and other lower
animals, especially the sponges.

The fact that there are still in existence various kinds of
gastraeads, or lower Metazoa with an organisation little higher than
that of the hypothetical gastraea, is a strong point in favour of our
theory. There are not very many species of these living gastraeads;
but their morphological and phylogenetic interest is so great, and
their intermediate position between the Protozoa and Metazoa so
instructive, that I proposed long ago (1876) to make a special class
of them. I distinguished three orders in this class--the Gastremaria,
Physemaria, and Cyemaria (or Dicyemida). But we might also regard
these three orders as so many independent classes in a primitive
gastraead stem.

The Gastremaria and Cyemaria, the chief of these living gastraeads,
are small Metazoa that live parasitically inside other Metazoa, and
are, as a rule, 1/50 to 1/25 of an inch long, often much less (Figure
2.233, 1 to 15). Their soft body, devoid of skeleton, consists of two
simple strata of cells, the primary germinal layers; the outer of
these is thickly clothed with long hair-like lashes, by which the
parasites swim about in the various cavities of their host. The inner
germinal layer furnishes the sexual products. The pure type of the
original gastrula (or archigastrula, Figure 1.29 I) is seen in the
Pemmatodiscus gastrulaceus, which Monticelli discovered in the
umbrella of a large medusa (Pilema pulmo) in 1895; the convex surface
of this gelatinous umbrella was covered with numbers of clear
vesicles, of 1/25 to 1/8 inch in diameter, in the fluid contents of
which the little parasites were swimming. The cup-shaped body of the
Pemmatodiscus (Figure 2.233, 1) is sometimes rather flat, and shaped
like a hat or cone, at other times almost curved into a semi-circle.
The simple hollow of the cup, the primitive gut (g), has a narrow
opening (o). The skin layer (e) consists of long slender cylindrical
cells, which bear long vibratory hairs; it is separated by a thin
structureless, gelatinous plate (f) from the visceral or gut layer
(i), the prismatic cells of which are much smaller and have no cilia.
Pemmatodiscus propagates asexually, by simple longitudinal cleavage;
on this account it has recently been regarded as the representative of
a special order of gastraeads (Mesogastria).

Probably a near relative of the Pemmatodiscus is the Kunstleria
Gruveli (Figure 2.233, 2). It lives in the body-cavity of Vermalia
(Sipunculida), and differs from the former in having no lashes either
on the large ectodermic cells (e) or the small entodermic (i); the
germinal layers are separated by a thick, cup-shaped, gelatinous mass,
which has been called the "clear vesicle" (f). The primitive mouth is
surrounded by a dark ring that bears very strong and long vibratory
lashes, and effects the swimming movements.

Pemmatodiscus and Kunstleria may be included in the family of the
Gastremaria. To these gastraeads with open gut are closely related the
Orthonectida (Rhopalura, Figure 2.233, 3 to 5). They live
parasitically in the body-cavity of echinoderms (Ophiura) and
vermalia; they are distinguished by the fact that their primitive
gut-cavity is not empty, but filled with entodermic cells, from which
the sexual cells are developed. These gastraeads are of both sexes,
the male (Figure 1.3) being smaller and of a somewhat different shape
from the oval female (Figure 1.4).

The somewhat similar Dicyemida (Figure 1.6) are distinguished from the
preceding by the fact that their primitive gut-cavity is occupied by a
single large entodermic cell instead of a crowded group of sexual
cells. This cell does not yield sexual products, but afterwards
divides into a number of cells (spores), each of which, without being
impregnated, grows into a small embryo. The Dicyemida live
parasitically in the body-cavity, especially the renal cavities, of
the cuttle-fishes. They fall in several genera, some of which are
characterised by the possession of special polar cells; the body is
sometimes roundish, oval, or club-shaped, at other times long and
cylindrical. The genus Conocyema (Figures 1.7 to 1.15) differs from
the ordinary Dicyema in having four polar pimples in the form of a
cross, which may be incipient tentacles.

The classification of the Cyemaria is much disputed; sometimes they
are held to be parasitic infusoria (like the Opalina), sometimes
platodes or vermalia, related to the suctorial worms or rotifers, but
having degenerated through parasitism. I adhere to the
phylogenetically important theory that I advanced in 1876, that we
have here real gastraeads, primitive survivors of the common
stem-group of all the Metazoa. In the struggle for life they have
found shelter in the body-cavity of other animals.

(FIGURE 2.233. Modern gastraeads.
Figure 1. Pemmatodiscus gastrulaceus (Monticelli), in longitudinal
section.
Figure 2. Kunstleria gruveli (Delage), in longitudinal section. (From
Kunstler and Gruvel.)
Figures 3 to 5. Rhopalura Giardi (Julin): Figure 3 male, Figure 4
female, Figure 5 planula.
Figure 6. Dicyema macrocephala (Van Beneden).
Figures 7 to 15. Conocyema polymorpha (Van Beneden): Figure 7 the
mature gastraead, Figures 8 to 15 its gastrulation. d primitive gut, o
primitive mouth, e ectoderm, i entoderm, f gelatinous plate between e
and i (supporting plate, blastocoel).)

The small Coelenteria attached to the floor of the sea that I have
called the Physemaria (Haliphysema and Gastrophysema) probably form a
third order (or class) of the living gastraeads. The genus Haliphysema
(Figures 2.234 and 2.235) is externally very similar to a large
rhizopod (described by the same name in 1862) of the family of the
Rhabdamminida, which was at first taken for a sponge. In order to
avoid confusion with these, I afterwards gave them the name of
Prophysema. The whole mature body of the Prophysema is a simple
cylindrical or oval tube, with a two-layered wall. The hollow of the
tube is the gastric cavity, and the upper opening of it the mouth
(Figure 2.235 m). The two strata of cells that form the wall of the
tube are the primary germinal layers. These rudimentary zoophytes
differ from the swimming gastraeads chiefly in being attached at one
end (the end opposite to the mouth) to the floor of the sea.

In Prophysema the primitive gut is a simple oval cavity, but in the
closely related Gastrophysema it is divided into two chambers by a
transverse constriction; the hind and smaller chamber above furnishes
the sexual products, the anterior one being for digestion.

The simplest sponges (Olynthus, Figure 2.238) have the same
organisation as the Physemaria. The only material difference between
them is that in the sponge the thin two-layered body-wall is pierced
by numbers of pores. When these are closed they resemble the
Physemaria. Possibly the gastraeads that we call Physemaria are only
olynthi with the pores closed. The Ammoconida, or the simple tubular
sand-sponges of the deep-sea (Ammolynthus, etc.), do not differ from
the gastraeads in any important point when the pores are closed. In my
Monograph on the Sponges (with sixty plates) I endeavoured to prove
analytically that all the species of this class can be traced
phylogenetically to a common stem-form (Calcolynthus).

(FIGURES 2.234 AND 2.235. Prophysema primordiale, a living gastraead.

FIGURE 2.234. The whole of the spindle-shaped animal (attached below
to the floor of the sea).

FIGURE 2.235. The same in longitudinal section. The primitive gut (d)
opens above at the primitive mouth (m). Between the ciliated cells (g)
are the amoeboid ova (e). The skin-layer (h) is encrusted with grains
of sand below and sponge-spicules above.

FIGURES 2.236 TO 2.237. Ascula of gastrophysema, attached to the floor
of the sea. Figure 2.236 external view, 2.237 longitudinal section. g
primitive gut, o primitive mouth, i visceral layer, e cutaneous layer.
(Diagram.)

FIGURE 2.238. Olynthus, a very rudimentary sponge. A piece cut away in
front.)

The lowest form of the Cnidaria is also not far removed from the
gastraeads. In the interesting common fresh-water polyp (Hydra) the
whole body is simply an oval tube with a double wall; only in this
case the mouth has a crown of tentacles. Before these develop the
hydra resembles an ascula (Figures 2.236 and 2.237). Afterwards there
are slight histological differentiations in its ectoderm, though the
entoderm remains a single stratum of cells. We find the first
differentiation of epithelial and stinging cells, or of muscular and
neural cells, in the thick ectoderm of the hydra.

In all these rudimentary living coelenteria the sexual cells of both
kinds--ova and sperm cells--are formed by the same individual; it is
possible that the oldest gastraeads were hermaphroditic. It is clear
from comparative anatomy that hermaphrodism--the combination of both
kinds of sexual cells in one individual--is the earliest form of
sexual differentiation; the separation of the sexes (gonochorism) was
a much later phenomenon. The sexual cells originally proceeded from
the edge of the primitive mouth of the gastraead.


CHAPTER 2.20. OUR WORM-LIKE ANCESTORS.

The gastraea theory has now convinced us that all the Metazoa or
multicellular animals can be traced to a common stem-form, the
Gastraea. In accordance with the biogenetic law, we find solid proof
of this in the fact that the two-layered embryos of all the Metazoa
can be reduced to a primitive common type, the gastrula. Just as the
countless species of the Metazoa do actually develop in the individual
from the simple embryonic form of the gastrula, so they have all
descended in past time from the common stem-form of the Gastraea. In
this fact, and the fact we have already established that the Gastraea
has been evolved from the hollow vesicle of the one-layered Blastaea,
and this again from the original unicellular stem-form, we have
obtained a solid basis for our study of evolution. The clear path from
the stem-cell to the gastrula represents the first section of our
human stem-history (Chapters 1.8, 1.9, and 2.19).

The second section, that leads from the Gastraea to the Prochordonia,
is much more difficult and obscure. By the Prochordonia we mean the
ancient and long-extinct animals which the important embryonic form of
the chordula proves to have once existed (cf. Figures 1.83 to 1.86).
The nearest of living animals to this embryonic structure are the
lowest Tunicates, the Copelata (Appendicaria) and the larvae of the
Ascidia. As both the Tunicates and the Vertebrates develop from the
same chordula, we may infer that there was a corresponding common
ancestor of both stems. We may call this the Chordaea, and the
corresponding stem-group the Prochordonia or Prochordata.

From this important stem-group of the unarticulated Prochordonia (or
"primitive chorda-animals") the stems of the Tunicates and Vertebrates
have been divergently evolved. We shall see presently how this
conclusion is justified in the present condition of morphological
science.

We have first to answer the difficult and much-discussed question of
the development of the Chordaea from the Gastraea; in other words,
"How and by what transformations were the characteristic animals,
resembling the embryonic chordula, which we regard as the common
stem-forms of all the Chordonia, both Tunicates and Vertebrates,
evolved from the simplest two-layered Metazoa?"

The descent of the Vertebrates from the Articulates has been
maintained by a number of zoologists during the last thirty years with
more zeal than discernment; and, as a vast amount has been written on
the subject, we must deal with it to some extent. All three classes of
Articulates in succession have been awarded the honour of being
considered the "real ancestors" of the Vertebrates: first, the
Annelids (earth-worms, leeches, and the like), then the Crustacea
(crabs, etc.), and, finally, the Tracheata (spiders, insects, etc.).
The most popular of these hypotheses was the annelid theory, which
derived the Vertebrates from the Worms. It was almost simultaneously
(1875) formulated by Carl Semper, of Wurtzburg, and Anton Dohrn, of
Naples. The latter advanced this theory originally in favour of the
failing degeneration theory, with which I dealt in my work, Aims and
Methods of Modern Embryology.

This interesting degeneration theory--much discussed at that time, but
almost forgotten now--was formed in 1875 with the aim of harmonising
the results of evolution and ever-advancing Darwinism with religious
belief. The spirited struggle that Darwin had occasioned by the
reformation of the theory of descent in 1859, and that lasted for a
decade with varying fortunes in every branch of biology, was drawing
to a close in 1870-1872, and soon ended in the complete victory of
transformism. To most of the disputants the chief point was not the
general question of evolution, but the particular one of "man's place
in nature"--"the question of questions," as Huxley rightly called it.
It was soon evident to every clear-headed thinker that this question
could only be answered in the sense of our anthropogeny, by admitting
that man had descended from a long series of Vertebrates by gradual
modification and improvement.

In this way the real affinity of man and the Vertebrates came to be
admitted on all hands. Comparative anatomy and ontogeny spoke too
clearly for their testimony to be ignored any longer. But in order
still to save man's unique position, and especially the dogma of
personal immortality, a number of natural philosophers and theologians
discovered an admirable way of escape in the "theory of degeneration."
Granting the affinity, they turned the whole evolutionary theory
upside down, and boldly contended that "man is not the most highly
developed animal, but the animals are degenerate men." It is true that
man is closely related to the ape, and belongs to the vertebrate stem;
but the chain of his ancestry goes upward instead of downward. In the
beginning "God created man in his own image," as the prototype of the
perfect vertebrate; but, in consequence of original sin, the human
race sank so low that the apes branched off from it, and afterwards
the lower Vertebrates. When this theory of degeneration was
consistently developed, its supporters were bound to hold that the
entire animal kingdom was descended from the debased children of men.

This theory was most strenuously defended by the Catholic priest and
natural philosopher, Michelis, in his Haeckelogony: An Academic
Protest against Haeckel's Anthropogeny (1875). In still more
"academic" and somewhat mystic form the theory was advanced by a
natural philosopher of the older Jena school--the mathematician and
physicist, Carl Snell. But it received its chief support on the
zoological side from Anton Dohrn, who maintained the anthropocentric
ideas of Snell with particular ability. The Amphioxus, which modern
science now almost unanimously regards as the real Primitive
Vertebrate, the ancient model of the original vertebrate structure,
is, according to Dohrn, a late, degenerate descendant of the stem, the
"prodigal son" of the vertebrate family. It has descended from the
Cyclostoma by a profound degeneration, and these in turn from the
fishes; even the Ascidia and the whole of the Tunicates are merely
degenerate fishes! Following out this curious theory, Dohrn came to
contest the general belief that the Coelenterata and Worms are "lower
animals"; he even declared that the unicellular Protozoa were
degenerate Coelenterata. In his opinion "degeneration is the great
principle that explains the existence of all the lower forms."

If this Michelis-Dohrn theory were true, and all animals were really
degenerate descendants of an originally perfect humanity, man would
assuredly be the true centre and goal of all terrestrial life; his
anthropocentric position and his immortality would be saved.
Unfortunately, this trustful theory is in such flagrant contradiction
to all the known facts of paleontology and embryology that it is no
longer worth serious scientific consideration.

But the case is no better for the much-discussed descent of the
Vertebrates from the Annelids, which Dohrn afterwards maintained with
great zeal. Of late years this hypothesis, which raised so much dust
and controversy, has been entirely abandoned by most competent
zoologists, even those who once supported it. Its chief supporter,
Dohrn, admitted in 1890 that it is "dead and buried," and made a
blushing retraction at the end of his Studies of the Early History of
the Vertebrate.

Now that the annelid-hypothesis is "dead and buried," and other
attempts to derive the Vertebrates from Medusae, Echinoderms, or
Molluscs, have been equally unsuccessful, there is only one hypothesis
left to answer the question of the origin of the Vertebrates--the
hypothesis that I advanced thirty-six years ago and called the
"chordonia-hypothesis." In view of its sound establishment and its
profound significance, it may very well claim to be a THEORY, and so
should be described as the chordonia or chordaea theory.

I first advanced this theory in a series of university lectures in
1867, from which the History of Creation was composed. In the first
edition of this work (1868) I endeavoured to prove, on the strength of
Kowalevsky's epoch-making discoveries, that "of all the animals known
to us the Tunicates are undoubtedly the nearest blood-relatives of the
Vertebrates; they are the most closely related to the Vermalia, from
which the Vertebrates have been evolved. Naturally, I do not mean that
the Vertebrates have descended from the Tunicates, but that the two
groups have sprung from a common root. It is clear that the real
Vertebrates (primarily the Acrania) were evolved in very early times
from a group of Worms, from which the degenerate Tunicates also
descended in another and retrogressive direction." This common extinct
stem-group are the Prochordonia; we still have a silhouette of them in
the chordula-embryo of the Vertebrates and Tunicates; and they still
exist independently, in very modified form, in the class of the
Copelata (Appendicaria, Figure 2.225).

The chordaea-theory received the most valuable and competent support
from Carl Gegenbaur. This able comparative morphologist defended it in
1870, in the second edition of his Elements of Comparative Anatomy; at
the same time he drew attention to the important relations of the
Tunicates to a curious worm, Balanoglossus: he rightly regards this as
the representative of a special class of worms, which he called
"gut-breathers" (Enteropneusta). Gegenbaur referred on many other
occasions to the close blood-relationship of the Tunicates and
Vertebrates, and luminously explained the reasons that justify us in
framing the hypothesis of the descent of the two stems from a common
ancestor, an unsegmented worm-like animal with an axial chorda between
the dorsal nerve-tube and the ventral gut-tube.

The theory afterwards received a good deal of support from the
research made by a number of distinguished zoologists and anatomists,
especially C. Kupffer, B. Hatschek, F. Balfour, E. Van Beneden, and
Julin. Since Hatschek's Studies of the Development of the Amphioxus
gave us full information as to the embryology of this lowest
vertebrate, it has become so important for our purpose that we must
consider it a document of the first rank for answering the question we
are dealing with.

The ontogenetic facts that we gather from this sole survivor of the
Acrania are the more valuable for phylogenetic purposes, as
paleontology, unfortunately, throws no light whatever on the origin of
the Vertebrates. Their invertebrate ancestors were soft organisms
without skeleton, and thus incapable of fossilisation, as is still the
case with the lowest vertebrates--the Acrania and Cyclostoma. The same
applies to the greater part of the Vermalia or worm-like animals, the
various classes and orders of which differ so much in structure. The
isolated groups of this rich stem are living branches of a huge tree,
the greater part of which has long been dead, and we have no fossil
evidence as to its earlier form. Nevertheless, some of the surviving
groups are very instructive, and give us clear indications of the way
in which the Chordonia were developed from the Vermalia, and these
from the Coelenteria.

While we seek the most important of these palingenetic forms among the
groups of Coelenteria and Vermalia, it is understood that not a single
one of them must be regarded as an unchanged, or even little changed,
copy of the extinct stem-form. One group has retained one feature,
another a different feature, of the original organisation, and other
organs have been further developed and characteristically modified.
Hence here, more than in any other part of our genealogical tree, we
have to keep before our mind the FULL PICTURE of development, and
separate the unessential secondary phenomena from the essential and
primary. It will be useful first to point out the chief advances in
organisation by which the simple Gastraea gradually became the more
developed Chordaea.

We find our first solid datum in the gastrula of the Amphioxus (Figure
1.38). Its bilateral and tri-axial type indicates that the
Gastraeads--the common ancestors of all the Metazoa--divided at an
early stage into two divergent groups. The uni-axial Gastraea became
sessile, and gave rise to two stems, the Sponges and the Cnidaria (the
latter all reducible to simple polyps like the hydra). But the
tri-axial Gastraea assumed a certain pose or direction of the body on
account of its swimming or creeping movement, and in order to sustain
this it was a great advantage to share the burden equally between the
two halves of the body (right and left). Thus arose the typical
bilateral form, which has three axes. The same bilateral type is found
in all our artificial means of locomotion--carts, ships, etc.; it is
by far the best for the movement of the body in a certain direction
and steady position. Hence natural selection early developed this
bilateral type in a section of the Gastraeads, and thus produced the
stem-forms of all the bilateral animals.

The Gastraea bilateralis, of which we may conceive the bilateral
gastrula of the amphioxus to be a palingenetic reproduction,
represented the two-sided organism of the earliest Metazoa in its
simplest form. The vegetal entoderm that lined their simple gut-cavity
served for nutrition; the ciliated ectoderm that formed the external
skin attended to locomotion and sensation; finally, the two primitive
mesodermic cells, that lay to the right and left at the ventral border
of the primitive mouth, were sexual cells, and effected reproduction.
In order to understand the further development of the gastraea, we
must pay particular attention to: (1) the careful study of the
embryonic stages of the amphioxus that lie between the gastrula and
the chordula; (2) the morphological study of the simplest Platodes
(Platodaria and Turbellaria) and several groups of unarticulated
Vermalia (Gastrotricha, Nemertina, Enteropneusta).

We have to consider the Platodes first, because they are on the border
between the two principal groups of the Metazoa, the Coelenteria and
the Coelomaria. With the former they share the lack of body-cavity,
anus, and vascular system; with the latter they have in common the
bilateral type, the possession of a pair of nephridia or renal canals,
and the formation of a vertical brain or cerebral ganglion. It is now
usual to distinguish four classes of Platodes: the two free-living
classes of the primitive worms (Platodaria) and the coiled-worms
(Turbellaria), and the two parasitic classes of the suctorial worms
(Trematoda) and the tape-worms (Cestoda). We have only to consider the
first two of these classes; the other two are parasites, and have
descended from the former by adaptation to parasitic habits and
consequent degeneration.

(FIGURE 2.239. Aphanostomum Langii (Haeckel), a primitive worm of the
platodaria class, of the order of Cryptocoela or Acoela. This new
species of the genus Aphanostomum, named after Professor Arnold Lang
of Zurich, was found in September, 1899, at Ajaccio in Corsica
(creeping between fucoidea). It is one-twelfth of an inch long,
one-twenty-fifth of an inch broad, and violet in colour. a mouth, g
auditory vesicle, e ectoderm, i entoderm, o ovaries, a spermaries, f
female aperture, m male aperture.)

The primitive worms (Platodaria) are very small flat worms of simple
construction, but of great morphological and phylogenetic interest.
They have been hitherto, as a rule, regarded as a special order of the
Turbellaria, and associated with the Rhabdocoela; but they differ
considerably from these and all the other Platodes (flat worms) in the
absence of renal canals and a special central nervous system; the
structure of their tissue is also simpler than in the other Platodes.
Most of the Platodes of this group (Aphanostomum, Amphichoerus,
Convoluta, Schizoprora, etc.) are very soft and delicate animals,
swimming about in the sea by means of a ciliary coat, and very small
(1/10 to 1/20 inch long). Their oval body, without appendages, is
sometimes spindle-shaped or cylindrical, sometimes flat and
leaf-shaped. Their skin is merely a layer of ciliated ectodermic
cells. Under this is a soft medullary substance, which consists of
entodermic cells with vacuoles. The food passes through the mouth
directly into this digestive medullary substance, in which we do not
generally see any permanent gut-cavity (it may have entirely
collapsed); hence these primitive Platodes have been called Acoela
(without gut-cavity or coelom), or, more correctly, Cryptocoela, or
Pseudocoela. The sexual organs of these hermaphroditic Platodaria are
very simple--two pairs of strings of cells, the inner of which (the
ovaries, Figure 2.239 o) produce ova, and the outer (the spermaria, s)
sperm-cells. These gonads are not yet independent sexual glands, but
sexually differentiated cell-groups in the medullary substance, or, in
other words, parts of the gut-wall. Their products, the sex-cells, are
conveyed out behind by two pairs of short canals; the male opening (m)
lies just behind the female (f). Most of the Platodaria have not the
muscular pharynx, which is very advanced in the Turbellaria and
Trematoda. On the other hand, they have, as a rule, before or behind
the mouth, a bulbous sense-organ (auditory vesicle or organ of
equilibrium, g), and many of them have also a couple of simple optic
spots. The cell-pit of the ectoderm that lies underneath is rather
thick, and represents the first rudiment of a neural ganglion
(vertical brain or acroganglion).

The Turbellaria, with which the similar Platodaria were formerly
classed, differ materially from them in the more advanced structure of
their organs, and especially in having a central nervous system
(vertical brain) and excretory renal canals (nephridia); both
originate from the ectoderm. But between the two germinal layers a
mesoderm is developed, a soft mass of connective tissue, in which the
organs are embedded. The Turbellaria are still represented by a number
of different forms, in both fresh and sea-water. The oldest of these
are the very rudimentary and tiny forms that are known as Rhabdocoela
on account of the simple construction of their gut; they are, as a
rule, less than a quarter of an inch long and of a simple oval or
lancet shape (Figure 2.240). The surface is covered with ciliated
epithelium, a stratum of ectodermic cells. The digestive gut is still
the simple primitive gut of the gastraea (d), with a single aperture
that is both mouth and anus (m). There is, however, an invagination of
the ectoderm at the mouth, which has given rise to a muscular pharynx
(sd). It is noteworthy that the mouth of the Turbellaria (like the
primitive mouth of the Gastraea) may, in this class, change its
position considerably in the middle line of the ventral surface;
sometimes it lies behind (Opisthostomum), sometimes in the middle
(Mesostomum), sometimes in front (Prosostomum). This displacement of
the mouth from front to rear is very interesting, because it
corresponds to a phylogenetic displacement of the mouth. This probably
occurred in the Platode ancestors of most (or all?) of the Coelomaria;
in these the permanent mouth (metastoma) lies at the fore end (oral
pole), whereas the primitive mouth (prostoma) lay at the hind end of
the bilateral body.

In most of the Turbellaria there is a narrow cavity, containing a
number of secondary organs, between the two primary germinal layers,
the outer or animal layer of which forms the epidermis and the inner
vegetal layer the visceral epithelium. The earliest of these organs
are the sexual organs; they are very variously constructed in the
Platode-class; in the simplest case there are merely two pairs of
gonads or sexual glands--a pair of testicles (Figure 2.241 h) and a
pair of ovaries (e). They open externally, sometimes by a common
aperture (Monogonopora), sometimes by separate ones, the female behind
the male (Digonopora, Figure 2.241). The sexual glands develop
originally from the two promesoblasts or primitive mesodermic cells
(Figure 1.83 p). As these earliest mesodermic structures extended, and
became spacious sexual pouches in the later descendants of the
Platodes, probably the two coelom-pouches were formed from them, the
first trace of the real body-cavity of the higher Metazoa
(Enterocoela).

The gonads are among the oldest organs, the few other organs that we
find in the Platodes between the gut-wall and body-wall being later
evolutionary products. One of the oldest and most important of these
are the kidneys or nephridia, which remove unusable matter from the
body (Figure 2.240 nc). These urinary or excretory organs were
originally enlarged skin-glands--a couple of canals that run the
length of the body, and have a separate or common external aperture
(nm). They often have a number of branches. These special excretory
organs are not found in the other Coelenteria (Gastraeads, Sponges,
Cnidaria) or the Cryptocoela. They are first met in the Turbellaria,
and have been transmitted direct from these to the Vermalia, and from
these to the higher stems.

Finally, there is a very important new organ in the Turbellaria, which
we do not find in the Cryptocoela (Figure 2.239) and their gastraead
ancestors--the rudimentary nervous system. It consists of a couple of
simple cerebral ganglia (Figure 2.241 g) and fine nervous fibres that
radiate from them; these are partly voluntary nerves (or motor fibres)
that go to the thin muscular layer developing under the skin; and
partly sensory nerves that proceed to the sense-cells of the ciliated
epiderm (f). Many of the Turbellaria have also special sense-organs; a
couple of ciliated smell pits (na), rudimentary eyes (au), and, less
frequently, auditory vesicles.

On these principles I assume that the oldest and simplest Turbellaria
arose from Platodaria, and these directly from bilateral Gastraeads.
The chief advances were the formation of gonads and nephridia, and of
the rudimentary brain. On this hypothesis, which I advanced in 1872 in
the first sketch of the gastraea-theory (Monograph on the Sponges),
there is no direct affinity between the Platodes and the Cnidaria.

(FIGURE 2.240. A simple turbellarian (Rhabdocoelum). m mouth, sd
gullet epithelium, sm gullet muscles, d gastric gut, nc renal canals,
nm renal aperture, au eye, na olfactory pit. (Diagram.)

FIGURE 2.241. The same, showing the other organs. g brain, au eye, na
olfactory pit, n nerves, h testicles, male symbol male aperture,
female symbol female aperture, e ovary, f ciliated epiderm. (Diagram.)

(FIGURES 242 AND 243. Chaetonotus, a rudimentary vermalian, of the
group of Gastrotricha. m mouth, s gullet, d gut, a anus, g brain, n
nerves, ss sensory hairs, au eye, ms muscular cells, h skin, f
ciliated bands of the ventral surface, nc nephridia, nm their
aperture, e ovaries.))

Next to the ancient stem-group of the Turbellaria come a number of
more recent chordonia ancestors, which we class with the Vermalia or
Helminthes, the unarticulated worms. These true worms (Vermes, lately
also called Scolecida) are the difficulty or the lumber-room of the
zoological classifier, because the various classes have very
complicated relations to the lower Platodes on the one hand and the
more advanced animals on the other. But if we exclude the Platodes and
the Annelids from this stem, we find a fairly satisfactory unity of
organisation in the remaining classes. Among these worms we find some
important forms that show considerable advance in organisation from
the platode to the chordonia stage. Three of these phenomena are
particularly instructive: (1) The formation of a true (secondary)
body-cavity (coeloma); (2) the formation of a second aperture of the
gut, the anus; and (3) the formation of a vascular system. The great
majority of the Vermalia have these three features, and they are all
wanting in the Platodes; in the rest of the worms at least one or two
of them are developed.

Next and very close to the Platodes we have the Ichthydina
(Gastrotricha), little marine and fresh-water worms, about 1/250 to
1/1000 inch long. Zoologists differ as to their position in
classification. In my opinion, they approach very close to the
Rhabdocoela (Figures 2.240 and 2.241), and differ from them chiefly in
the possession of an anus at the posterior end (Figure 2.242 a).
Further, the cilia that cover the whole surface of the Turbellaria are
confined in the Gastrotricha to two ciliated bands (f) on the ventral
surface of the oval body, the dorsal surface having bristles.
Otherwise the organisation of the two classes is the same. In both the
gut consists of a muscular gullet (s) and a glandular primitive gut
(d). Over the gullet is a double brain (acroganglion, g). At the side
of the gut are two serpentine prorenal canals (water-vessels or
pronephridia, nc), which open on the ventral side (nm). Behind are a
pair of simple sexual glands or gonads (Figure 2.243 e).

While the Ichthydina are thus closely related to the Platodes, we have
to go farther away for the two classes of Vermalia which we unite in
the group of the "snout-worms" (Frontonia). These are the Nemertina
and the Enteropneusta. Both classes have a complete ciliary coat on
the epidermis, a heritage from the Turbellaria and the Gastraeads;
also, both have two openings of the gut, the mouth and anus, like the
Gastrotricha. But we find also an important organ that is wanting in
the preceding forms--the vascular system. In their more advanced
mesoderm we find a few contractile longitudinal canals which force the
blood through the body by their contractions; these are the first
blood-vessels.

(FIGURE 2.244. A simple Nemertine. m mouth, d gut, a anus, g brain, n
nerves, h ciliary coat, ss sensory pits (head-clefts), au eyes, r
dorsal vessel, l lateral vessels. (Diagram.)

FIGURE 2.245. A young Enteropneust (Balanaglossus). (From Alexander
Agassiz.) r acorn-shaped snout, h neck, k gill-clefts and gill-arches
of the fore-gut, in long rows on each side, d digestive hind-gut,
filling the greater part of the body-cavity, v intestinal vein or
ventral vessel, lying between the parallel folds of the skin, a anus.

Figure 2.246. Transverse section of the branchial gut. A of
Balanoglossus, B of Ascidia. r branchial gut, n pharyngeal groove,
asterisk ventral folds between the two. Diagrammatic illustration from
Gegenbaur, to show the relation of the dorsal branchial-gut cavity (r)
to the pharyngeal or hypobranchial groove (n).)

The Nemertina were formerly classed with the much less advanced
Turbellaria. But they differ essentially from them in having an anus
and blood-vessels, and several other marks of higher organisation.
They have generally long and narrow bodies, like a more or less
flattened cord; there are, besides several small species, giant-forms
with a width of 1/5 to 2/5 inch and a length of several yards (even
ten to fifteen). Most of them live in the sea, but some in fresh water
and moist earth. In their internal structure they approach the
Turbellaria on the one hand and the higher Vermalia (especially the
Enteropneusta) on the other. They have a good deal of interest as the
lowest and oldest of all animals with blood. In them we find
blood-vessels for the first time, distributing real blood through the
body. The blood is red, and the red colouring-matter is haemoglobin,
connected with elliptic discoid blood-cells, as in the Vertebrates.
Most of them have two or three parallel blood-canals, which run the
whole length of the body, and are connected in front and behind by
loops, and often by a number of ring-shaped pieces. The chief of these
primitive blood-vessels is the one that lies above the gut in the
middle line of the back (Figure 2.244 r); it may be compared to either
the dorsal vessel of the Articulates or the aorta of the Vertebrates.
To the right and left are the two serpentine lateral vessels (Figure
2.244 l).

After the Nemertina, I take (as distant relatives) the Enteropneusta;
they may be classed together with them as Frontonia or Rhyncocoela
(snout-worms). There is now only one genus of this class, with several
species (Balanoglossus); but it is very remarkable, and may be
regarded as the last survivor of an ancient and long-extinct class of
Vermalia. They are related, on the one hand, to the Nemertina and
their immediate ancestors, the Platodes, and to the lowest and oldest
forms of the Chordonia on the other.

The Enteropneusta (Figure 2.245) live in the sea sand, and are long
worms of very simple shape, like the Nemertina. From the latter they
have inherited: (1) The bilateral type, with incomplete segmentation;
(2) the ciliary coat of the soft epidermis; (3) the double rows of
gastric pouches, alternating with a single or double row of gonads;
(4) separation of the sexes (the Platode ancestors were
hermaphroditic); (5) the ventral mouth, underneath a protruding snout;
(6) the anus terminating the simple gut-tube; and (7) several parallel
blood-canals, running the length of the body, a dorsal and a ventral
principal stem.

On the other hand, the Enteropneusta differ from their Nemertine
ancestors in several features, some of which are important, that we
may attribute to adaptation. The chief of these is the branchial gut
(Figure 2.245 k). The anterior section of the gut is converted into a
respiratory organ, and pierced by two rows of gill-clefts; between
these there is a branchial (gill) skeleton, formed of rods and plates
of chitine. The water that enters at the mouth makes its exit by these
clefts. They lie in the dorsal half of the fore-gut, and this is
completely separated from the ventral half by two longitudinal folds
(Figure 2.246 A*). This ventral half, the glandular walls of which are
clothed with ciliary epithelium and secrete mucus, corresponds to the
pharyngeal or hypo-branchial groove of the Chordonia (Bn), the
important organ from which the later thyroid gland is developed in the
Craniota (cf. Chapter 2.16). The agreement in the structure of the
branchial gut of the Enteropneusts, Tunicates, and Vertebrates was
first recognised by Gegenbaur (1878); it is the more significant as at
first we find only a couple of gill-clefts in the young animals of all
three groups; the number gradually increases. We can infer from this
the common descent of the three groups with all the more confidence
when we find the Balanoglossus approaching the Chordonia in other
respects. Thus, for instance, the chief part of the central nervous
system is a long dorsal neural string that runs above the gut and
corresponds to the medullary tube of the Chordonia. Bateson believes
he has detected a rudimentary chorda between the two.

Of all extant invertebrate animals the Enteropneusts come nearest to
the Chordonia in virtue of these peculiar characters; hence we may
regard them as the survivors of the ancient gut-breathing Vermalia
from which the Chordonia also have descended. Again, of all the
chorda-animals the Copelata (Figure 2.225) and the tailed larvae of
the ascidia approach nearest to the young Balanoglossus. Both are, on
the other hand, very closely related to the Amphioxus, the Primitive
Vertebrate of which we have considered the importance (Chapters 2.16
and 2.17). As we saw there, the unarticulated Tunicates and the
articulated Vertebrates must be regarded as two independent stems,
that have developed in divergent directions. But the common root of
the two stems, the extinct group of the Prochordonia, must be sought
in the vermalia stem; and of all the living Vermalia those we have
considered give us the safest clue to their origin. It is true that
the actual representatives of the important groups of the Copelata,
Balanoglossi, Nemertina, Icthydina, etc., have more or less departed
from the primitive model owing to adaptation to special environment.
But we may just as confidently affirm that the main features of their
organisation have been preserved by heredity.

We must grant, however, that in the whole stem-history of the
Vertebrates the long stretch from the Gastraeads and Platodes up to
the oldest Chordonia remains by far the most obscure section. We might
frame another hypothesis to raise the difficulty--namely, that there
was a long series of very different and totally extinct forms between
the Gastraea and the Chordaea. Even in this modified chordaea-theory
the six fundamental organs of the chordula would retain their great
value. The medullary tube would be originally a chemical sensory
organ, a dorsal olfactory tube, taking in respiratory-water and food
by the neuroporus in front and conveying them by the neurenteric canal
into the primitive gut. This olfactory tube would afterwards become
the nervous centre, while the expanding gonads (lying to right and
left of the primitive mouth) would form the coeloma. The chorda may
have been originally a digestive glandular groove in the dorsal middle
line of the primitive gut. The two secondary gut-openings, mouth and
anus, may have arisen in various ways by change of functions. In any
case, we should ascribe the same high value to the chordula as we did
before to the gastrula.

In order to explain more fully the chief stages in the advance of our
race, I add the hypothetical sketch of man's ancestry that I published
in my Last Link [a translation by Dr. Gadow of the paper read at the
International Zoological Congress at Cambridge in 1898]:--

   A. MAN'S GENEALOGICAL TREE, FIRST HALF: EARLIER SERIES OF ANCESTORS,
      WITHOUT FOSSIL EVIDENCE.

COLUMN 1 : CHIEF STAGES.
COLUMN 2 : ANCESTRAL STEM-GROUPS.
COLUMN 3 : LIVING RELATIVES OF ANCESTORS.


STAGES 1 TO 5. PROTIST ANCESTORS. UNICELLULAR ORGANISMS.

1 to 2. Protophytes. : 1. Monera. Without nucleus. : Chromacea.
(Chroococcus.) Phycochromacea.

1 to 2. Protophytes. : 2. Algaria. Unicellular algae. : 2. Paulotomea.
Palmellacea. Eremosphaera.

3 to 5. Protozoa. : 3. Lobosa. Unicellular (amoebina) rhizopods. : 3.
Amoebina. Amoeba Leucocyta.

3 to 5. Protozoa. : 4. Infusoria. Unicellular. : 4. Flagellata.
Euflagellata. Zoomonades.

3 to 5. Protozoa. : 5. Blastaeades. Multicellular hollow spheres. : 5.
Catallacta. Magosphaera, Volvocina, Blastula.

STAGES 6 TO 11. INVERTEBRATE METAZOA ANCESTORS.

6 to 8. Coelenteria, without anus and body-cavity. : 6. Gastraeades.
With two germ-layers. : 6. Gastrula. Hydra, Olynthus, Gastremaria.

6 to 8. Coelenteria, without anus and body-cavity. : 7. Platodes I.
Platodaria (without nephridia). : 7. Cryptocoela. Convoluta, Proporus.

6 to 8. Coelenteria, without anus and body-cavity. : 8. Platodes II.
Platodinia (with nephridia). : 8. Rhabdocoela. Vortex, Monotus.

9 to 11. Vermalia, with anus and body-cavity. : 9. Provermalia.
(Primitive Worms.) Rotatoria. : 9. Gastrotricha. Trochozoa,
Trochophora.

9 to 11. Vermalia, with anus and body-cavity. : 10. Frontonia.
(Rhynchelminthes.) Snout-worms. : 10. Enteropneusta. Balanoglossus,
Cephalodiscus.

9 to 11. Vermalia, with anus and body-cavity. : 11. Prochordonia.
Chorda-worms. : 11. Copelata. Appendicaria. Chordula-larvae.

STAGES 12 TO 15. MONORHINA ANCESTORS.

Oldest vertebrates without jaws or pairs of limbs, single nose. : 12.
Acrania I. (Prospondylia.) : 12. Amphioxus larva.

Oldest vertebrates without jaws or pairs of limbs, single nose. : 13.
Acrania II. More recent. : 13. Leptocardia. Amphioxus.

Oldest vertebrates without jaws or pairs of limbs, single nose. : 14.
Cyclostoma I. (Archicrania.) : 14. Petromyzonta larvae.

Oldest vertebrates without jaws or pairs of limbs, single nose. : 15.
Cyclostoma II. More recent. : 15. Marsipobranchia. Petromyzonta.

B. MAN'S GENEALOGICAL TREE, SECOND HALF: LATER ANCESTORS, WITH FOSSIL
EVIDENCE.

COLUMN 1 : GEOLOGICAL PERIODS.
COLUMN 2 : ANCESTRAL STEM-GROUPS.
COLUMN 3 : LIVING RELATIVES OF ANCESTORS.

Silurian. :  16. Selachii. Primitive fishes. Proselachii. : 16.
Natidanides. Chlamydoselachius. Heptanchus.

Silurian. 17. Ganoides. Plated-fishes. Proganoides. : 17.
Accipenserides. (Sturgeons.) Polypterus.

Devonian. : 18. Dipneusta. Paladipneusta. : 18. Neodipneusta.
Ceratodus. Protopterus.

Carboniferous. : 19. Amphibia. Stegocephala. : 19. Phanerobranchia.
Salamandrina. (Proteus, triton.)

Permian. : 20. Reptilia. Proreptilia. : 20. Rhynchocephalia. Primitive
lizards. Hatteria.

Triassic. : 21. Monotrema. Promammalia. : 21. Ornithodelphia. Echidna.
Ornithorhyncus.

Jurassic. : 22. Marsupalia. Prodidelphia. : 22. Didelphia. Didelphys.
Perameles.

Cretaceous. : 23. Mallotheria. Prochoriata. : 23. Insectivora.
Erinaceida. (Ictopsida +.)

Older Eocene. : 24. Lemuravida. Older lemurs. Dentition. 3. 1. 4. 3. :
24. Pachylemures. (Hyopsodus +), (Adapis +).

Neo-Eocene. : 25. Lemurogona. Later lemurs. Dentition. 2. 1. 4. 3. :
25. Autolemures. Eulemur. Stenops.

Oligocene. : 26. Dysmopitheca. Western apes. Dentition. 2. 1. 3. 3. :
26. Platyrrhinae. (Anthropops +), (Homunculus +).

Older Miocene. : 27. Cynopitheca. Dog-faced apes (tailed). : 27.
Papiomorpha. Cynocephalus.

Neo-Miocene. : 28. Anthropoides. Man-like apes (tail-less). : 28.
Hylobatida. Hylobates. Satyrus.

Pliocene. : 29. Pithecanthropi. Ape-men (alali, speechless). : 29.
Anthropitheca. Chimpanzee. Gorilla.

Pleistocene. : 30. Homines. Men, with speech. : 30. Weddahs.
Australian negroes.


CHAPTER 2.21. OUR FISH-LIKE ANCESTORS.

Our task of detecting the extinct ancestors of our race among the vast
numbers of animals known to us encounters very different difficulties
in the various sections of man's stem-history. These were very great
in the series of our invertebrate ancestors; they are much slighter in
the subsequent series of our vertebrate ancestors. Within the
vertebrate stem there is, as we have already seen, so complete an
agreement in structure and embryology that it is impossible to doubt
their phylogenetic unity. In this case the evidence is much clearer
and more abundant.

The characteristics that distinguish the Vertebrates as a whole from
the Invertebrates have already been discussed in our description of
the hypothetical Primitive Vertebrate (Chapter 1.11, Figure 1.98 to
1.102). The chief of these are: (1) The evolution of the primitive
brain into a dorsal medullary tube; (2) the formation of the chorda
between the medullary tube and the gut; (3) the division of the gut
into branchial (gill) and hepatic (liver) gut; and (4) the internal
articulation or metamerism. The first three features are shared by the
Vertebrates with the ascidia-larvae and the Prochordonia; the fourth
is peculiar to them. Thus the chief advantage in organisation by which
the earliest Vertebrates took precedence of the unsegmented Chordonia
consisted in the development of internal segmentation.

The whole vertebrate stem divides first into the two chief sections of
Acrania and Craniota. The Amphioxus is the only surviving
representative of the older and lower section, the Acrania
("skull-less"). All the other vertebrates belong to the second
division, the Craniota

Showing first 200,000 characters. Full text: gutenberg.org/ebooks/6710