Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 50922

Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay

by Immanuel Kant · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2016
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay by Immanuel Kant is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #50922). * Italics are denoted by underscores as in _italics_. * Bold text is denoted by equals as in =bold=. * Small caps are represented in upper case as in SMALL CAPS. * Original spelling was kept, but variant spellings were made consistent when a predominant usage was found. * Obvious printer errors have been silently corrected.

    PERPETUAL PEACE

    A PHILOSOPHICAL ESSAY

    BY

    IMMANUEL KANT

    1795

    TRANSLATED WITH INTRODUCTION

    AND NOTES BY

    M. CAMPBELL SMITH, M.A.

    WITH A PREFACE BY PROFESSOR LATTA

    LONDON: GEORGE ALLEN & UNWIN LTD.
    RUSKIN HOUSE 40 MUSEUM STREET, W.C.
    ## NEW YORK: THE MACMILLAN COMPANY

    First Edition, 1903
    Second Impression, February 1915
    Third ” February 1917

    PREFACE

    This translation of Kant’s essay on Perpetual Peace was undertaken by Miss Mary Campbell Smith at the suggestion of the late Professor Ritchie of St.

    Andrews, who had promised to write for it a preface, indicating the value of Kant’s work in relation to recent discussions regarding the possibility of “making wars to cease.” In view of the general interest which these discussions have aroused and of the vague thinking and aspiration which have too often characterised them, it seemed to Professor Ritchie that a translation of this wise and sagacious essay would be both opportune and valuable.[1] His untimely death has prevented the fulfilment of his promise, and I have been asked, in his stead, to introduce the translator’s work.

    [1] Cf. his Studies in Political and Social Ethics, pp. 169,
    170.

    This is, I think, the only complete translation into English of Kant’s essay, including all the notes as well as the text, and the translator has added a full historical Introduction, along with numerous notes of her own, so as (in Professor Ritchie’s words) “to meet the needs (1) of the student of Political Science who wishes to understand the relation of Kant’s theories to those of Grotius, Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau etc., and (2) of the general reader who wishes to understand the significance of Kant’s proposals in connection with the ideals of Peace Congresses, and with the development of International Law from the end of the Middle Ages to the Hague Conference.”

    Although it is more than 100 years since Kant’s essay was written, its substantial value is practically unimpaired. Anyone who is acquainted with the general character of the mind of Kant will expect to find in him sound common-sense, clear recognition of the essential facts of the case and a remarkable power of analytically exhibiting the conditions on which the facts necessarily depend.

    These characteristics are manifest in the essay on Perpetual Peace.

    Kant is not pessimist enough to believe that a perpetual peace is an unrealisable dream or a consummation devoutly to be feared, nor is he optimist enough to fancy that it is an ideal which could easily be realised if men would but turn their hearts to one another. For Kant perpetual peace is an ideal, not merely as a speculative Utopian idea, with which in fancy we may play, but as a moral principle, which ought to be, and therefore can be, realised.

    Yet he makes it perfectly clear that we cannot hope to approach the realisation of it unless we honestly face political facts and get a firm grasp of the indispensable conditions of a lasting peace. To strive after the ideal in contempt or in ignorance of these conditions is a labour that must inevitably be either fruitless or destructive of its own ends. Thus Kant demonstrates the hopelessness of any attempt to secure perpetual peace between independent nations.

    Such nations may make treaties; but these are binding only for so long as it is not to the interest of either party to denounce them. To enforce them is impossible while the nations remain independent. “There is,” as Professor Ritchie put it (Studies in Political and Social Ethics, p. 169), “only one way in which war between independent nations can be prevented; and that is by the nations ceasing to be independent.”

    But this does not necessarily mean the establishment of a despotism, whether autocratic or democratic. On the other hand, Kant maintains that just as peace between individuals within a state can only be permanently secured by the institution of a “republican” (that is to say, a representative) government, so the only real guarantee of a permanent peace between nations is the establishment of a federation of free “republican” states. Such a federation he regards as practically possible.

    “For if Fortune ordains that a powerful and enlightened people should form a republic—which by its very nature is inclined to perpetual peace—this would serve as a centre of federal union for other states wishing to join, and thus secure conditions of freedom among the states in accordance with the idea of the law of nations. Gradually, through different unions of this kind, the federation would extend further and further.”

    Readers who are acquainted with the general philosophy of Kant will find many traces of its influence in the essay on Perpetual Peace. Those who have no knowledge of his philosophy may find some of his forms of statement rather difficult to understand, and it may therefore not be out of place for me to indicate very briefly the meaning of some terms which he frequently uses, especially in the Supplements and Appendices.

    Thus at the beginning of the First Supplement, Kant draws a distinction between the mechanical and the teleological view of things, between “nature” and “Providence”, which depends upon his main philosophical position. According to Kant, pure reason has two aspects, theoretical and practical. As concerning knowledge, strictly so called, the a priori principles of reason (e.g. substance and attribute, cause and effect etc.) are valid only within the realm of possible sense-experience.

    Such ideas, for instance, cannot be extended to God, since He is not a possible object of sense-experience. They are limited to the world of phenomena. This world of phenomena (“nature” or the world of sense-experience) is a purely mechanical system. But in order to understand fully the phenomenal world, the pure theoretical reason must postulate certain ideas (the ideas of the soul, the world and God), the objects of which transcend sense-experience.

    These ideas are not theoretically valid, but their validity is practically established by the pure practical reason, which does not yield speculative truth, but prescribes its principles “dogmatically” in the form of imperatives to the will. The will is itself practical reason, and thus it imposes its imperatives upon itself. The fundamental imperative of the practical reason is stated by Kant in

    Appendix I. (p. 175):—“Act so that thou canst will that thy maxim

    should be a universal law, be the end of thy action what it will.”

    If the end of perpetual peace is a duty, it must be necessarily deduced from this general law. And Kant does regard it as a duty. “We must desire perpetual peace not only as a material good, but also as a state of things resulting from our recognition of the precepts of duty” (loc. cit.). This is further expressed in the maxim (p.

    177):—“Seek ye first the kingdom of pure practical reason and its righteousness, and the object of your endeavour, the blessing of perpetual peace, will be added unto you.” The distinction between the moral politician and the political moralist, which is developed in Appendix I., is an application of the general distinction between duty and expediency, which is a prominent feature of the Kantian ethics.

    Methods of expediency, omitting all reference to the pure practical reason, can only bring about re-arrangements of circumstances in the mechanical course of nature. They can never guarantee the attainment of their end: they can never make it more than a speculative ideal, which may or may not be practicable. But if the end can be shown to be a duty, we have, from Kant’s point of view, the only reasonable ground for a conviction that it is realisable. We cannot, indeed, theoretically know that it is realisable.

    “Reason is not sufficiently enlightened to survey the series of predetermining causes which would make it possible for us to predict with certainty the good or bad results of human action, as they follow from the mechanical laws of nature; although we may hope that things will turn out as we should desire” (p. 163). On the other hand, since the idea of perpetual peace is a moral ideal, an “idea of duty”, we are entitled to believe that it is practicable.

    “Nature guarantees the coming of perpetual peace, through the natural course of human propensities; not indeed with sufficient certainty to enable us to prophesy the future of this ideal theoretically, but yet clearly enough for practical purposes” (p. 157). One might extend this discussion indefinitely; but what has been said may suffice for general guidance.

    The “wise and sagacious” thought of Kant is not expressed in a simple style, and the translation has consequently been a very difficult piece of work. But the translator has shown great skill in manipulating the involutions, parentheses and prodigious sentences of the original. In this she has had the valuable help of Mr. David Morrison, M.A., who revised the whole translation with the greatest care and to whom she owes the solution of a number of difficulties.

    Her work will have its fitting reward if it succeeds in familiarising the English-speaking student of politics with a political essay of enduring value, written by one of the master thinkers of modern times.

    R. LATTA.

    University of Glasgow, May 1903.

    CONTENTS

    PAGE

    PREFACE BY PROFESSOR LATTA v

    TRANSLATOR’S INTRODUCTION 1

    PERPETUAL PEACE 106

    FIRST SECTION CONTAINING THE PRELIMINARY ARTICLES OF

    PERPETUAL PEACE BETWEEN STATES 107

    SECOND SECTION CONTAINING THE DEFINITIVE ARTICLES OF

    PERPETUAL PEACE BETWEEN STATES 117

    FIRST SUPPLEMENT CONCERNING THE GUARANTEE OF PERPETUAL

    PEACE 143

    SECOND SUPPLEMENT—A SECRET ARTICLE FOR PERPETUAL PEACE 158

    APPENDIX I.—ON THE DISAGREEMENT BETWEEN MORALS AND POLITICS

    WITH REFERENCE TO PERPETUAL PEACE 161

    APPENDIX II.—CONCERNING THE HARMONY OF POLITICS WITH MORALS

    ACCORDING TO THE TRANSCENDENTAL IDEA OF PUBLIC RIGHT 184

    INDEX 197

    TRANSLATOR’S INTRODUCTION

    This is an age of unions. Not merely in the economic sphere, in the working world of unworthy ends and few ideals do we find great practical organizations; but law, medicine, science, art, trade, commerce, politics and political economy—we might add philanthropy—standing institutions, mighty forces in our social and intellectual life, all have helped to swell the number of our nineteenth century Conferences and Congresses. It is an age of Peace Movements and Peace Societies, of peace-loving monarchs and peace-seeking diplomats.

    This is not to say that we are preparing for the millennium. Men are working together, there is a newborn solidarity of interest, but rivalries between nation and nation, the bitternesses and hatreds inseparable from competition are not less keen; prejudice and misunderstanding not less frequent; subordinate conflicting interests are not fewer, are perhaps, in view of changing political conditions and an ever-growing international commerce, multiplying with every year.

    The talisman is, perhaps, self-interest, but, none the less, the spirit of union is there; it is impossible to ignore a clearly marked tendency towards international federation, towards political peace. This slow movement was not born with Peace Societies; its consummation lies perhaps far off in the ages to come.

    History at best moves slowly. But something of its past progress we shall do well to know. No political idea seems to have so great a future before it as this idea of a federation of the world. It is bound to realise itself some day; let us consider what are the chances that this day come quickly, what that it be long delayed.

    What obstacles lie in the way, and how may they be removed? What historical grounds have we for hoping that they may ever be removed?

    What, in a word, is the origin and history of the idea of a perpetual peace between nations, and what would be the advantage, what is the prospect of realising it?

    The international relations of states find their expression, we are told, in war and peace. What has been the part played by these great counteracting forces in the history of nations? What has it been in prehistoric times, in the life of man in what is called the “state of nature”?

    “It is no easy enterprise,” says Rousseau, in more than usually careful language, “to disentangle that which is original from that which is artificial in the actual state of man, and to make ourselves well acquainted with a state which no longer exists, which perhaps never has existed and which probably never will exist in the future.” (Preface to the Discourse on the Causes of Inequality, 1753, publ. 1754.) This is a difficulty which Rousseau surmounts only too easily.

    A knowledge of history, a scientific spirit may fail him: an imagination ever ready to pour forth detail never does. Man lived, says he, “without industry, without speech, without habitation, without war, without connection of any kind, without any need of his fellows or without any desire to harm them ... sufficing to himself.”[2] (Discourse on the Sciences and Arts, 1750.) Nothing, we are now certain, is less probable.

    We cannot paint the life of man at this stage of his development with any definiteness, but the conclusion is forced upon us that our race had no golden age,[3] no peaceful beginning, that this early state was indeed, as Hobbes held, a state of war, of incessant war between individuals, families and, finally, tribes.

    [2] For the inconsistency between the views expressed by Rousseau
    on this subject in the Discourses and in the Contrat Social
    (Cf. I. Chs. VI., VIII.) see Ritchie’s Natural Right, Ch.
    III., pp. 48, 49; Caird’s essay on Rousseau in his Essays on
    Literature and Philosophy
    , Vol. I.; and Morley’s Rousseau,
    Vol. I., Ch. V.; Vol. II., Ch. XII.

    [3] The theory that the golden age was identical with the
    state of nature, Professor D. G. Ritchie ascribes to Locke
    (see Natural Right, Ch. II., p. 42). Locke, he says, “has an
    idea of a golden age” existing even after government has come
    into existence—a time when people did not need “to examine the
    original and rights of government.” [Civil Government, II., §
    111.] A little confusion on the part of his readers (perhaps in
    his own mind) makes it possible to regard the state of nature as
    itself the golden age, and the way is prepared for the favourite
    theory of the eighteenth century:—

    “Nor think in nature’s state they blindly trod;
    The state of nature was the reign of God:
    Self-love and social at her birth began,
    Union the bond of all things and of man.
    Pride then was not, nor arts that pride to aid;
    Man walk’d with beast, joint tenant of the shade;
    The same his table, and the same his bed;
    No murder cloath’d him, and no murder fed.”

    [Essay on Man, III., 147 seq.]

    In these lines of Pope’s the state of nature is identified with
    the golden age of the Greek and Latin poets; and “the reign of
    God” is an equivalent for Locke’s words, “has a law of nature to
    govern it.”

    The Early Conditions of Society.

    For the barbarian, war is the rule; peace the exception. His gods, like those of Greece, are warlike gods; his spirit, at death, flees to some Valhalla. For him life is one long battle; his arms go with him even to the grave. Food and the means of existence he seeks through plunder and violence. Here right is with might; the battle is to the strong. Nature has given all an equal claim to all things, but not everyone can have them. This state of fearful insecurity is bound to come to an end. “Government,” says Locke, (On Civil Government, Chap.

    VIII., § 105) “is hardly to be avoided amongst men that live together.”[4] A constant dread of attack and a growing consciousness of the necessity of presenting a united front against it result in the choice of some leader—the head of a family perhaps—who acts, it may be, only as captain of the hosts, as did Joshua in Israel, or who may discharge the simple duties of a primitive governor or king.[5] Peace within is found to be strength without.

    The civil state is established, so that “if there needs must be war, it may not yet be against all men, nor yet without some helps.” (Hobbes: On Liberty, Chap. I., § 13.) This foundation of the state is the first establishment in history of a peace institution. It changes the character of warfare, it gives it method and system; but it does not bring peace in its train.

    We have now, indeed, no longer a wholesale war of all against all, a constant irregular raid and plunder of one individual by another; but we have the systematic, deliberate war of community against community, of nation against nation.[6]

    [4] Cf. Republic, II. 369. “A state,” says Socrates, “arises
    out of the needs of mankind: no one is self-sufficing, but all of
    us have many wants.”

    [5] See Hume’s account of the origin of government (Treatise,
    III., Part II., Sect. VIII.). There are, he says, American
    tribes “where men live in concord and amity among themselves
    without any established government; and never pay submission
    to any of their fellows, except in time of war, when their
    captain enjoys a shadow of authority, which he loses after their
    return from the field, and the establishment of peace with the
    neighbouring tribes.

    This authority, however, instructs them in
    the advantages of government, and teaches them to have recourse
    to it, when either by the pillage of war, by commerce, or by any
    fortuitous inventions, their riches and possessions have become
    so considerable as to make them forget, on every emergence, the
    interest they have in the preservation of peace and justice....
    Camps are the true mothers of cities; and as war cannot be
    administered, by reason of the suddenness of every exigency,
    without some authority in a single person, the same kind of
    authority naturally takes place in that civil government, which
    succeeds the military.”

    Cf. Cowper: The Winter Morning Walk:—

    “. . . . . . . . . . . . . . and ere long,
    When man was multiplied and spread abroad
    In tribes and clans, and had begun to call
    These meadows and that range of hills his own,
    The tasted sweets of property begat
    Desire of more; . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    Thus wars began on earth. These fought for spoil,
    And those in self-defence. Savage at first
    The onset, and irregular. At length
    One eminent above the rest, for strength,
    For stratagem, or courage, or for all,
    Was chosen leader.

    Him they served in war,
    And him in peace for sake of warlike deeds
    Rev’renced no less. . . . . . . . . . . . .
    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    Thus kings were first invented.”

    [6] “Among uncivilised nations, there is but one profession
    honourable, that of arms. All the ingenuity and vigour of the
    human mind are exerted in acquiring military skill or address.”
    Cf. Robertson’s History of Charles V., (Works, 1813, vol. V.)
    Sect. I. vii.

    War in Classical Times.

    In early times, there were no friendly neighbouring nations: beyond the boundaries of every nation’s territory, lay the land of a deadly foe. This was the way of thinking, even of so highly cultured a people as the Greeks, who believed that a law of nature had made every outsider, every barbarian their inferior and their enemy.[7] Their treaties of peace, at the time of the Persian War, were frankly of the kind denounced by Kant, mere armistices concluded for the purpose of renewing their fighting strength.

    The ancient world is a world of perpetual war in which defeat meant annihilation. In the East no right was recognised in the enemy; and even in Greece and Rome the fate of the unarmed was death or slavery.[8] The barbaric or non-Grecian states had, according to Plato and Aristotle, no claim upon humanity, no rights in fact of any kind. Among the Romans things were little better. According to Mr. T. J. Lawrence—see his Principles of International Law, III., §§ 21, 22—they were worse.

    For Rome stood alone in the world: she was bound by ties of kinship to no other state. She was, in other words, free from a sense of obligation to other races. War, according to Roman ideas, was made by the gods, apart altogether from the quarrels of rulers or races.

    To disobey the sacred command, expressed in signs and auguries would have been to hold in disrespect the law and religion of the land.

    When, in the hour of victory, the Romans refrained from pressing their rights against the conquered—rights recognised by all Roman jurists—it was from no spirit of leniency, but in the pursuit of a prudent and far-sighted policy, aiming at the growth of Roman supremacy and the establishment of a world-embracing empire, shutting out all war as it blotted out natural boundaries, reducing all rights to the one right of imperial citizenship. There was no real jus belli, even here in the cradle of international law; the only limits to the fury of war were of a religious character.

    [7] Similarly we find that the original meaning of the Latin word
    “hostis” was “a stranger.”

    [8] In Aristotle we find the high-water mark of Greek thinking
    on this subject. “The object of military training,” says he,
    (Politics, Bk. IV. Ch. XIV., Welldon’s translation—in older
    editions Bk. VII.) “should be not to enslave persons who do
    not deserve slavery, but firstly to secure ourselves against
    becoming the slaves of others; secondly, to seek imperial power
    not with a view to a universal despotic authority, but for the
    benefit of the subjects whom we rule, and thirdly, to exercise
    despotic power over those who are deserving to be slaves.

    That
    the legislator should rather make it his object so to order his
    legislation upon military and other matters as to promote leisure
    and peace is a theory borne out by the facts of history.” ...
    (loc. cit. Ch. XV.). “War, as we have remarked several times,
    has its end in peace.”

    Aristotle strongly condemns the Lacedæmonians and Cretans for
    regarding war and conquest as the sole ends to which all law and
    education should be directed. Also in non-Greek tribes like the
    Scythians, Persians, Thracians and Celts he says, only military
    power is admired by the people and encouraged by the state.
    “There was formerly too a law in Macedonia that any one who had
    never slain an enemy should wear the halter about his neck.”
    Among the Iberians too, a military people, “it is the custom to
    set around the tomb of a deceased warrior a number of obelisks
    corresponding to the number of enemies he has killed....

    Yet
    ... it may well appear to be a startling paradox that it should
    be the function of a Statesman to succeed in devising the means
    of rule and mastery over neighbouring peoples whether with or
    against their own will. How can such action be worthy of a
    statesman or legislator, when it has not even the sanction of
    law?” (op. cit., IV. Ch. 2.)

    We see that Aristotle disapproves of a glorification of war for
    its own sake, and regards it as justifiable only in certain
    circumstances. Methods of warfare adopted and proved in the East
    would not have been possible in Greece. An act of treachery,
    for example, such as that of Jael, (Judges IV. 17) which was
    extolled in songs of praise by the Jews, (loc. cit. V. 24) the
    Greek people would have been inclined to repudiate.

    The stories
    of Roman history, the behaviour of Fabricius, for instance,
    or Regulus and the honourable conduct of prisoners on various
    occasions released on parole, show that this consciousness of
    certain principles of honour in warfare was still more highly
    developed in Rome.

    Socrates in the Republic (V. 469, 470) gives expression to a
    feeling which was gradually gaining ground in Greece, that war
    between Hellenic tribes was much more serious than war between
    Greeks and barbarians. In such civil warfare, he considered,
    the defeated ought not to be reduced to slavery, nor the slain
    despoiled, nor Hellenic territory devastated.

    For any difference
    between Greek and Greek is to “be regarded by them as discord
    only—a quarrel among friends, which is not to be called war”....
    “Our citizens [i.e. in the ideal republic] should thus deal
    with their Hellenic enemies; and with barbarians as the Hellenes
    now deal with one another.” (V. 471.)

    The views of Plato and Aristotle on this and other questions were
    in advance of the custom and practice of their time.

    The treatment of a defeated enemy among the Jews rested upon a similar religious foundation. In the East, we find a special cruelty in the conduct of war. The wars of the Jews and Assyrians were wars of extermination. The whole of the Old Testament, it has been said, resounds with the clash of arms.[9] “An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth!” was the command of Jehovah to his chosen people. Vengeance was bound up in their very idea of the Creator.

    The Jews, unlike the followers of Mahomet, attempted, and were commanded to attempt no violent conversion[10]; they were then too weak a nation; but they fought, and fought with success against the heathen of neighbouring lands, the Lord of Hosts leading them forth to battle. The God of Israel stood to his chosen people in a unique and peculiarly logical relation. He had made a covenant with them; and, in return for their obedience and allegiance, cared for their interests and advanced their national prosperity.

    The blood of this elect people could not be suffered to intermix with that of idolaters. Canaan must be cleared of the heathen, on the coming of the children of Israel to their promised land; and mercy to the conquered enemy, even to women, children or animals was held by the Hebrew prophets to be treachery to Jehovah. (Sam. XV.; Josh. VI. 21.)

    [9] “The Lord is a man of war,” said Moses (Exodus XV. 3). Cf.
    Psalms XXIV. 8. He is “mighty in battle.”

    [10] This was bound up with the very essence of Islam; the devout
    Mussulman could suffer the existence of no unbeliever. Tolerance
    or indifference was an attitude which his faith made impossible.
    “When ye encounter the unbelievers,” quoth the prophet (Koran,
    ch. 47), “strike off their heads, until ye have made a great
    slaughter among them.... Verily if God pleased he could take
    vengeance on them without your assistance; but he commandeth you
    to fight his battles.”

    The propagation of the faith by the sword was not only commanded
    by the Mohammedan religion: it was that religion itself.

    Hence the attitude of the Jews to neighbouring nations[11] was still more hostile than that of the Greeks. The cause of this difference is bound up with the transition from polytheism to monotheism. The most devout worshipper of the national gods of ancient times could endure to see other gods than his worshipped in the next town or by a neighbouring nation. There was no reason why all should not exist side by side. Religious conflicts in polytheistic countries, when they arose, were due not to the rivalry of conflicting faiths, but to an occasional attempt to put one god above the others in importance.

    There could be no interest here in the propagation of belief through the sword. But, under the Jews, these relations were entirely altered. Jehovah, their Creator, became the one invisible God. Such an one can suffer no others near him; their existence is a continual insult to him. Monotheism is, in its very nature, a religion of intolerance. Its spirit among the Jews was warlike: it commanded the subjugation of other nations, but its instrument was rather extermination than conversion.

    [11] See Acts X. 28:—“Ye know that it is an unlawful thing for
    a man that is a Jew to keep company, or come unto one of another
    nation.”

    The Attitude of Christianity and the Early Church to War.

    From the standpoint of the peace of nations, we may say that the Christian faith, compared with other prominent monotheistic religious systems, occupies an intermediate position between two extremes—the fanaticism of Islam, and to a less extent of Judaism, and the relatively passive attitude of the Buddhist who thought himself bound to propagate his religion, but held himself justified only in the employment of peaceful means. Christianity, on the other hand, contains no warlike principles: it can in no sense be called a religion of the sword, but circumstances gave the history of the Church, after the first few centuries of its existence, a character which cannot be called peace-loving.

    This apparent contradiction between the spirit of the new religion and its practical attitude to war has led to some difference of opinion as to the actual teaching of Christ. The New Testament seems, at a superficial glance, to furnish support as readily to the champions of war as to its denouncers. The Messiah is the Prince of Peace (Is. IX. 6, 7; Heb. VI.), and here lies the way of righteousness (Rom. III. 19): but Christ came not to bring peace, but a sword (Matth. X. 34).

    Such statements may be given the meaning which we wish them to bear—the quoting of Scripture is ever an unsatisfactory form of evidence; but there is no direct statement in the New Testament in favour of war, no saying of Christ which, fairly interpreted, could be understood too regard this proof of human imperfection as less condemnable than any other.[12] When men shall be without sin, nation shall rise up against nation no more.

    But man the individual can attain peace only when he has overcome the world, when, in the struggle with his lower self, he has come forth victorious. This is the spiritual sword which Christ brought into the world—strife, not with the unbeliever, but with the lower self: meekness and the spirit of the Word of God are the weapons with which man must fight for the Faith.

    [12] Neither, however, is there any which regards the soldier as
    a murderer.

    An elect people there was no longer: Israel had rejected its Messiah.

    Instead there was a complete brotherhood of all men, the bond and the free, as children of one God. The aim of the Church was a world-empire, bound together by a universal religion. In this sense, as sowing the first seeds of a universal peace, we may speak of Christianity as a re-establishment of peace among mankind.

    The later attitude of Christians to war, however, by no means corresponds to the earliest tenets of the Church. Without doubt, certain sects, from the beginning of our era and through the ages up to the present time, held, like the Mennonites and Quakers in our day, that the divine command, “Love your enemies,” could not be reconciled with the profession of a soldier.

    The early Christians were reproached under the Roman Emperors, before the time of Constantine, with avoiding the citizen’s duty of military service.[13] “To those enemies of our faith,” wrote Origen (Contra Celsum, VIII., Ch.

    LXXIII., Anti-Nicene Christian Library), “who require us to bear arms for the commonwealth, and to slay men, we can reply: ‘Do not those who are priests at certain shrines, and those who attend on certain gods, as you account them, keep their hands free from blood, that they may with hands unstained and free from human blood offer the appointed sacrifices to your gods; and even when war is upon you, you never enlist the priests in the army.

    If that, then, is a laudable custom, how much more so, that while others are engaged in battle, these too should engage as the priests and ministers of God, keeping their hands pure, and wrestling in prayers to God on behalf of those who are fighting in a righteous cause, and for the king who reigns righteously, that whatever is opposed to those who act righteously may be destroyed!’ ...

    And we do take our part in public affairs, when along with righteous prayers we join self-denying exercises and meditations, which teach us to despise pleasures, and not to be led away by them. And none fight better for the king than we do. We do not indeed fight under him, although he require it; but we fight on his behalf, forming a special army—an army of piety—by offering our prayers to God.” The Fathers of the Church, Justin Martyr, Clement of Alexandria, Tertullian, Ambrose and the rest gave the same testimony against war.

    The pagan rites connected with the taking of the military oath had no doubt some influence in determining the feeling of the pious with regard to this life of bloodshed; but the reasons lay deeper. “Shall it be held lawful,” asked Tertullian, (De Corona, p. 347) “to make an occupation of the sword, when the Lord proclaims that he who uses the sword shall perish by the sword? And shall the son of peace take part in the battle when it does not become him even to sue at law?

    And shall he apply the chain, and the prison, and the torture, and the punishment, who is not the avenger even of his own wrongs?”

    [13] In the early centuries of our era Christians seem to
    have occasionally refused to serve in the army from religious
    scruples. But soldiers were not always required to change their
    profession after baptism. And in Acts X., for example, nothing
    is said to indicate that the centurion, Cornelius, would have to
    leave the Roman army. See Tertullian: De Corona (Anti-Nicene
    Christian Library), p. 348.

    The doctrine of the Church developed early in the opposite direction.

    It was its fighting spirit and not a love of peace that made Christianity a state religion under Constantine. Nor was Augustine the first of the Church Fathers to regard military service as permissible. To come to a later time, this change of attitude has been ascribed partly to the rise of Mahometan power and the wave of fanaticism which broke over Europe. To destroy these unbelievers with fire and sword was regarded as a deed of piety pleasing to God.

    Hence the wars of the Crusades against the infidel were holy wars, and appear as a new element in the history of civilisation. The nations of ancient times had known only civil and foreign war.[14] They had rebelled at home, and they had fought mainly for material interests abroad.

    In the Middle Ages there were, besides, religious wars and, with the rise of Feudalism, private war:[15] among all the powers of the Dark Ages and for centuries later, none was more aggressive than the Catholic Church, nor a more active and untiring defender of its rights and claims, spiritual or temporal. It was in some respects a more warlike institution than the states of Greece and Rome.

    It struggled through centuries with the Emperor:[16] it pronounced its ban against disobedient states and disloyal cities: it pursued with its vengeance each heretical or rebellious prince: unmindful of its early traditions about peace, it showed in every crisis a fiercely military spirit.[17]

    [14] There were so-called “Sacred Wars” in Greece, but these were
    due mainly to disputes caused by the Amphictyonic League. They
    were not religious, in the sense in which we apply the epithet to
    the Thirty Years’ war.

    [15] “The administration of justice among rude illiterate people,
    was not so accurate, or decisive, or uniform, as to induce men
    to submit implicitly to its determinations. Every offended baron
    buckled on his armour, and sought redress at the head of his
    vassals. His adversary met him in like hostile array. Neither
    of them appealed to impotent laws which could afford them no
    protection. Neither of them would submit points, in which their
    honour and their passions were warmly interested, to the slow
    determination of a judicial inquiry.

    Both trusted to their swords
    for the decision of the contest.” Robertson’s History of Charles
    V.
    , (Works, vol. V.) Sect. I., p. 38.

    [16] Erasmus in the “Ἰχθυοφαγία” (Colloquies, Bailey’s ed.,
    Vol. II., pp. 55, 56) puts forward the suggestion that a general
    peace might be obtained in the Christian world, if the Emperor
    would remit something of his right and the Pope some part of his.

    [17] Cf. Robertson, op. cit., Sect. III., p. 106, seq.

    For more than a thousand years the Church counted fighting clergy[18] among its most active supporters. This strange anomaly was, it must be said, at first rather suffered in deference to public opinion than encouraged by ecclesiastical canons and councils, but it gave rise to great discontent at the time of the Reformation.[19] The whole question of the lawfulness of military service for Christians was then raised again.

    “If there be anything in the affairs of mortals,” wrote Erasmus at this time (Opera, II., Prov., 951 C) “which it becomes us deliberately to attack, which we ought indeed to shun by every possible means, to avert and to abolish, it is certainly war, than which there is nothing more wicked, more mischievous or more widely destructive in its effects, nothing harder to be rid of, or more horrible and, in a word, more unworthy of a man, not to say of a Christian.”[20] The mediæval Church indeed succeeded, by the establishment of such institutions as the Truce of God, in setting some limits to the fury of the soldier: but its endeavours (and it made several to promote peace)[21] were only to a trifling extent successful.

    Perhaps custom and public opinion in feudal Europe were too strong, perhaps the Church showed a certain apathy in denouncing the evils of a military society: no doubt the theoretical tenets of its doctrine did less to hinder war than its own strongly military tendency, its lust for power and the force of its example did to encourage it.

    [18] Robertson (op. cit., Note XXI., p. 483) quotes the
    following statement: “flamma, ferro, caede, possessiones
    ecclesiarum praelati defendebant.” (Guido Abbas ap. Du Cange, p.
    179.)

    [19] J. A. Farrar, in a pamphlet, (reprinted from the
    Gentleman’s Magazine, vol. 257, 1884) on War and
    Christianity
    , quotes the following passage from Wycliffe in
    which he protests against this blot upon the Church and Christian
    professions.—“Friars now say that bishops can fight best of all
    men, and that it falleth most properly to them, since they are
    lords of all this world.

    They say Christ bade His disciples sell
    their coats, and buy them swords; but whereto, if not to fight?
    Thus friars make a great array, and stir up many men to fight.
    But Christ taught not His apostles to fight with a sword of iron,
    but with the sword of God’s Word, and which standeth in meekness
    of heart and in the prudence of man’s tongue.... If man-slaying
    in others be odious to God, much more in priests, who should be
    vicars of Christ.” See also the passage where Erasmus points
    out that King David was not permitted to build a temple to God,
    because he was a man of blood. “Nolo clericos ullo sanguine
    contaminari.

    Gravis impietas!” (Opera, IX., 370 B.)

    This question had already been considered by Thomas Aquinas, who
    decided that the clergy ought not to be allowed to fight, because
    the practices of warfare, although right and meritorious in
    themselves, were not in accordance with a holy calling. (Summa,
    II. 2: Qu. 40.)

    Aquinas held that war—excluding private war—is justifiable in a
    just cause. So too did Luther, (cf. his pamphlet: Ob Kriegsleute
    auch in seligem Stande sein können?
    ) Calvin and Zwingli, the
    last of whom died sword in hand.

    With regard to the question of a fighting clergy, the passage
    quoted from Origen (pp. 14, 15, above) has considerable interest,
    Origen looks upon the active participation of priests in warfare
    as something which everyone would admit to be impossible.

    [20] See also the Querela Pacis, 630 B., (Opera,
    IV.):—“Whosoever preaches Christ, preaches peace.” Erasmus even
    goes the length of saying that the most iniquitous peace is
    better than the most just war (op. cit., 636 C).

    [21] Cf. Robertson, op. cit., Note XXI. p. 483 and Sect. I., p.
    39.

    Hence, in spite of Christianity and its early vision of a brotherhood of men, the history of the Middle Ages came nearer to a realization of the idea of perpetual war than was possible in ancient times.

    The tendency of the growth of Roman supremacy was to diminish the number of wars, along with the number of possible causes of racial friction. It united many nations in one great whole, and gave them, to a certain extent, a common culture and common interests; even, when this seemed prudent, a common right of citizenship. The fewer the number of boundaries, the less the likelihood of war. The establishment of great empires is of necessity a force, and a great and permanent force working on the side of peace. With the fall of Rome this guarantee was removed.

    The Development of the New Science of International Law.

    Out of the ruins of the old feudal system arose the modern state as a free independent unity. Private war between individuals or classes of society was now branded as a breach of the peace: it became the exclusive right of kings to appeal to force. War, wrote Gentilis[22] towards the end of sixteenth century, is the just or unjust conflict between states. Peace was now regarded as the normal condition of society. As a result of these great developments in which the name “state” acquired new meaning, jurisprudence freed itself from the trammelling conditions of mediæval Scholasticism.

    Men began to consider the problem of the rightfulness or wrongfulness of war, to question even the possibility of a war on rightful grounds.

    Out of theses new ideas—partly too as one of the fruits of the Reformation,[23]—arose the first consciously formulated principles of the science of international law, whose fuller, but not yet complete, development belongs to modern times.

    [22] It is uncertain in what year the De Jure Belli of Gentilis
    was published—a work to which Grotius acknowledges considerable
    indebtedness. Whewell, in the preface to his translation of
    Grotius, gives the date 1598, but some writers suppose it to have
    been ten years earlier.

    [23] This came about in two ways. The Church of Rome discouraged
    the growth of national sentiment. At the Reformation the
    independence and unity of the different nations were for the
    first time recognised. That is to say, the Reformation laid the
    foundation for a science of international law. But, from another
    point of view, it not only made such a code of rules possible,
    it made it necessary. The effect of the Reformation was not to
    diminish the number of wars in which religious belief could play
    a part. Moreover, it displaced the Pope from his former position
    as arbiter in Europe without setting up any judicial tribunal in
    his stead.

    From the beginning of history every age, every people has something to show here, be it only a rudimentary sense of justice in their dealings with one another. We may instance the Amphictyonic League in Greece which, while it had a merely Hellenic basis and was mainly a religious survival, shows the germ of some attempt at arbitration between Greek states. Among the Romans we have the jus feciale[24] and the jus gentium, as distinguished from the civil law of Rome, and certain military regulations about the taking of booty in war. Ambassadors were held inviolate in both countries; the formal declaration of war was never omitted.

    Many Roman writers held the necessity of a just cause for war. But nowhere do these considerations form the subject matter of a special science.

    [24] Cf. Cicero: De Officiis, I. xi. “Belli quidem aequitas
    sanctissime feciali populi Romani jure perscripta est.” (See the
    reference to Lawrence’s comments on this subject, p. 9 above.)

    “Wars,” says Cicero, “are to be undertaken for this end,
    that we may live in peace without being injured; but when we
    obtain the victory, we must preserve those enemies who behaved
    without cruelty or inhumanity during the war: for example,
    our forefathers received, even as members of their state, the
    Tuscans, the Æqui, the Volscians, the Sabines and the Hernici,
    but utterly destroyed Carthage and Numantia....

    And, while
    we are bound to exercise consideration toward those whom we
    have conquered by force, so those should be received into
    our protection who throw themselves upon the honour of our
    general, and lay down their arms,” (op. cit., I. xi., Bohn’s
    Translation).... “In engaging in war we ought to make it appear
    that we have no other view but peace.” (op. cit., I. xxiii.)

    In fulfilling a treaty we must not sacrifice the spirit to the
    letter (De Officiis, I. x). “There are also rights of war, and
    the faith of an oath is often to be kept with an enemy.” (op.
    cit.
    , III. xxix.)

    This is the first statement by a classical writer in which the
    idea of justice being due to an enemy appears. Cicero goes
    further. Particular states, he says, (De Legibus, I. i.) are
    only members of a whole governed by reason.

    In the Middle Ages the development of these ideas received little encouragement. All laws are silent in the time of war,[25] and this was a period of war, both bloody and constant. There was no time to think of the right or wrong of anything. Moreover, the Church emphasised the lack of rights in unbelievers, and gave her blessing on their annihilation.[26] The whole Christian world was filled with the idea of a spiritual universal monarchy. Not such as that in the minds of Greek and Jew and Roman who had been able to picture international peace only under the form of a great national and exclusive empire.

    In this great Christian state there were to be no distinctions between nations; its sphere was bounded by the universe.

    But, here, there was no room or recognition for independent national states with equal and personal rights. This recognition, opposed by the Roman Church, is the real basis of international law. The Reformation was the means by which the personality of the peoples, the unity and independence of the state were first openly admitted.

    On this foundation, mainly at first in Protestant countries, the new science developed rapidly. Like the civil state and the Christian religion, international law may be called a peace institution.

    [25] The saying is attributed to Pompey:—“Shall I, when I am
    preparing for war, think of the laws?”

    [26] This implied, however, the idea of a united Christendom as
    against the infidel, with which we may compare the idea of a
    united Hellas against Persia. In such things we have the germ not
    only of international law, but of the ideal of federation.

    Grotius, Puffendorf and Vattel.

    In the beginning of the seventeenth century, Grotius laid the foundations of a code of universal law (De Jure Belli et Pacis,

    1. independent of differences of religion, in the hope that its

    recognition might simplify the intercourse between the newly formed nations. The primary object of this great work, written during the misery and horrors of the Thirty Years’ war, was expressly to draw attention to these evils and suggest some methods by which the severity of warfare might be mitigated. Grotius originally meant to explain only one chapter of the law of nations:[27] his book was to be called De Jure Belli, but there is scarcely any subject of international law which he leaves untouched.

    He obtained, moreover, a general recognition for the doctrine of the Law of Nature which exerted so strong an influence upon succeeding centuries; indeed, between these two sciences, as between international law and ethics, he draws no very sharp line of demarcation, although, on the whole, in spite of an unscientific, scholastic use of quotation from authorities, his treatment of the new field is clear and comprehensive.

    Grotius made the attempt to set up an ethical principle of right, in the stead of such doctrines of self-interest as had been held by many of the ancient writers. There was a law, he held, established in each state purely with a view to the interests of that state, but, besides this, there was another higher law in the interest of the whole society of nations. Its origin was divine; the reason of man commanded his obedience. This was what we call international law.[28]

    [27] See Maine’s Ancient Law, pp. 50-53: pp. 96-101. Grotius
    wrongly understood “Jus Gentium,” (“a collection of rules
    and principles, determined by observation to be common to
    the institutions which prevailed among the various Italian
    tribes”) to mean “Jus inter gentes.” The Roman expression for
    International Law was not “Jus Gentium,” but “Jus Feciale.”

    “Having adopted from the Antonine jurisconsults,” says Maine,
    “the position that the Jus Gentium and the Jus Naturæ were
    identical, Grotius, with his immediate predecessors and his
    immediate successors, attributed to the Law of Nature an
    authority which would never perhaps have been claimed for it,
    if “Law of Nations” had not in that age been an ambiguous
    expression.

    They laid down unreservedly that Natural Law is the
    code of states, and thus put in operation a process which has
    continued almost down to our own day, the process of engrafting
    on the international system rules which are supposed to have
    been evolved from the unassisted contemplation of the conception
    of Nature. There is, too, one consequence of immense practical
    importance to mankind which, though not unknown during the early
    modern history of Europe, was never clearly or universally
    acknowledged till the doctrines of the Grotian school had
    prevailed.

    If the society of nations is governed by Natural
    Law, the atoms which compose it must be absolutely equal. Men
    under the sceptre of Nature are all equal, and accordingly
    commonwealths are equal if the international state be one of
    nature. The proposition that independent communities, however
    different in size and power, are all equal in the view of the Law
    of Nations, has largely contributed to the happiness of mankind,
    though it is constantly threatened by the political tendencies
    of each successive age.

    It is a doctrine which probably would
    never have obtained a secure footing at all if International Law
    had not been entirely derived from the majestic claims of Nature
    by the Publicists who wrote after the revival of letters.” (Op.
    cit.
    , p. 100.)

    [28] The name “International Law” was first given to the law of
    nations by Bentham. (Principles of Morals and Legislation, XIX.
    § xxv.)

    Grotius distinctly holds, like Kant and Rousseau, and unlike Hobbes, that the state can never be regarded as a unity or institution separable from the people; the terms civitas, communitas, coetus, populus, he uses indiscriminately. But these nations, these independent units of society cannot live together side by side just as they like; they must recognise one another as members of a European society of states.[29] Law, he said, stands above force even in war, “which may only be begun to pursue the right;” and the beginning and manner of conduct of war rests on fixed laws and can be justified only in certain cases. War is not to be done away with:

    Grotius accepts it as fact,[30] (as Hobbes did later) as the natural method for settling the disputes which were bound constantly to arise between so many independent and sovereign nations. A terrible scourge it must ever remain, but as the only available form of legal procedure, it is sanctioned by the practice of states and not less by the law of nature and of nations. Grotius did not advance beyond this position. Every violation of the law of nations can be settled but in one way—by war, the force of the stronger.

    [29] In the Peace of Westphalia, 1648, the balance of power in
    Europe was recognised on the basis of terms such as these.

    [30] Grotius, however, is a painstaking student of Scripture, and
    is willing to say something in favour of peace—not a permanent
    peace, that is to say, the idea of which would scarcely be
    likely to occur to anyone in the early years of the seventeenth
    century—but a plea for fewer, shorter wars. “If therefore,”
    he says, “a peace sufficiently safe can be had, it is not
    ill secured by the condonation of offenses, and damages, and
    expenses: especially among Christians, to whom the Lord has given
    his peace as his legacy. And so St. Paul, his best interpreter,
    exhorts us to live at peace with all men....

    May God write these
    lessons—He who alone can—on the hearts of all those who have
    the affairs of Christendom in their hands.” (De Jure Belli et
    Pacis
    , III. Ch. XXV., Whewell’s translation.)

    See also op. cit., II., Ch. XXIII., Sect. VIII., where
    Grotius recommends that Congresses of Christian Powers should
    be held with a view to the peaceful settlement of international
    differences.

    The necessary distinction between law and ethics was drawn by Puffendorf,[31] a successor of Grotius who gave an outwardly systematic form to the doctrine of the great jurist, without adding to it either strength or completeness. His views, when they were not based upon the system of Grotius, were strongly influenced by the speculation of Hobbes, his chronological predecessor, to whom we shall have later occasion to refer.

    In the works of Vattel,[32] who was, next to Rousseau, the most celebrated of Swiss publicists, we find the theory of the customs and practice in war widely developed, and the necessity for humanising its methods and limiting its destructive effects upon neutral countries strongly emphasised.

    Grotius and Puffendorf, while they recommend acts of mercy, hold that there is legally no right which requires that a conquered enemy shall be spared. This is a matter of humanity alone. It is to the praise of Vattel that he did much to popularise among the highest and most powerful classes of society, ideas of humanity in warfare, and of the rights and obligations of nations. He is, moreover, the first to make a clear separation between this science and the Law of Nature.

    What, he asks, is international law as distinguished from the Law of Nature? What are the powers of a state and the duties of nations to one another? What are the causes of quarrel among nations, and what the means by which they can be settled without any sacrifice of dignity?

    [31] Puffendorf’s best known work, De Jure Naturæ et Gentium,
    was published in 1672.

    [32] Le Droit des Gens was published in 1758 and translated
    into English by Joseph Chitty in 1797, (2nd ed., 1834).

    They are, in the first place, a friendly conciliatory attitude; and secondly, such means of settlement as mediation, arbitration and Peace Congresses. These are the refuges of a peace-loving nation, in cases where vital interests are not at stake. “Nature gives us no right to use force, except where mild and conciliatory measures are useless.” (Law of Nations, II.

    Ch. xviii. § 331.) “Every power owes it in this matter to the happiness of human society to show itself ready for every means of reconciliation, in cases where the interests at stake are neither vital nor important.” (ibid. § 332.) At the same time, it is never advisable that a nation should forgive an insult which it has not the power to resent.

    The Dream of a Perpetual Peace.

    But side by side with this development and gradual popularisation of the new science of International Law, ideas of a less practical, but not less fruitful kind had been steadily making their way and obtaining a strong hold upon the popular mind. The Decree of Eternal Pacification of 1495 had abolished private war, one of the heavy curses of the Middle Ages. Why should it not be extended to banish warfare between states as well? Gradually one proposal after another was made to attain this end, or, at least, to smooth the way for its future realisation.

    The first of these in point of time is to be found in a somewhat bare, vague form in Sully’s Memoirs,[33] said to have been published in 1634. Half a century later the Quaker William Penn suggested an international tribunal of arbitration in the interests of peace.[34] But it was by the French Abbé St. Pierre that the problem of perpetual peace was fairly introduced into political literature: and this, in an age of cabinet and dynastic wars, while the dreary cost of the war of the Spanish succession was yet unpaid. St.

    Pierre was the first who really clearly realised and endeavoured to prove that the establishment of a permanent state of peace is not only in the interest of the weaker, but is required by the European society of nations and by the reason of man. From the beginning of the history of humanity, poets and prophets had cherished the “sweet dream” of a peaceful civilisation: it is in the form of a practical project that this idea is new.

    [33] Mémoires ou Œconomies Royales D’Estat, Domestiques,
    Politiques et Militaires de Henri le Grand, par Maximilian de
    Bethune, Duc de Sully.

    [34] See International Tribunals (1899), p. 20 seq. Penn’s
    Essay towards the Present and Future Peace of Europe was
    written about 1693, but is not included in all editions of his
    works.

    The ancient world actually represented a state of what was almost perpetual war. This was the reality which confronted man, his inevitable doom, it seemed, as it had been pronounced to the fallen sinners of Eden. Peace was something which man had enjoyed once, but forfeited.

    The myth- and poetry-loving Greeks, and, later, the poets of Rome delighted to paint a state of eternal peace, not as something to whose coming they could look forward in the future, but as a golden age of purity whose records lay buried in the past, a paradise which had been, but which was no more. Voices, more scientific, were raised even in Greece in attempts, such as Aristotle’s, to show that the evolution of man had been not a course of degeneration from perfection, but of continual progress upwards from barbarism to civilisation and culture.

    But the change in popular thinking on this matter was due less to the arguments of philosophy than to a practical experience of the causes which operate in the interests of peace. The foundation of a universal empire under Alexander the Great gave temporary rest to nations heretofore incessantly at war.

    Here was a proof that the Divine Will had not decreed that man was to work out his punishment under unchanging conditions of perpetual warfare. This idea of a universal empire became the Greek ideal of a perpetual peace. Such an empire was, in the language of the Stoics, a world-state in which all men had rights of citizenship, in which all other nations were absorbed.

    Parallel to this ideal among the Greeks, we find the hope in Israel of a Messiah whose coming was to bring peace, not only to the Jewish race, but to all the nations of the earth. This idea stands out in the sharpest contrast to the early nationalism of the Hebrew people, who regarded every stranger as an idolater and an enemy.

    The prophecies of Judaism, combined with the cosmopolitan ideas of Greece, were the source of the idea, which is expressed in the teaching of Christ, of a spiritual world-empire, an empire held together solely by the tie of a common religion.

    This hope of peace did not actually die during the first thousand years of our era, nor even under the morally stagnating influences of the Middle Ages. When feudalism and private war were abolished in Europe, it wakened to a new life. Not merely in the mouths of poets and religious enthusiasts was the cry raised against war, but by scholars like Thomas More and Erasmus, jurists like Gentilis and Grotius, men high in the state and in the eyes of Europe like Henry IV. of France and the Duc de Sully or the Abbé de St. Pierre whose Projet de Paix Perpétuelle (1713)[35] obtained immediate popularity and wide-spread fame.

    The first half of the eighteenth century was already prepared to receive and mature a plan of this kind.

    [35] Projet de traité pour rendre la paix perpétuelle entre les
    souverains chrétiens.
    The first two volumes of this work were
    published in 1713 (trans. London, 1714); a third volume followed
    in 1717.

    Henry IV. and St. Pierre.

    The Grand Dessein of Henry IV. is supposed to have been formed by that monarch and reproduced in Sully’s Memoirs, written in 1634 and discovered nearly a century later by St. Pierre. The story goes that the Abbé found the book buried in an old garden. It has been shewn, however, that there is little likelihood that this project actually originated with the king, who probably corresponded fairly well to Voltaire’s picture of him as war hero of the Henriade.

    The plan was more likely conceived by Sully, and ascribed to the popular king for the sake of the better hearing and greater influence it might in this way be likely to have, and also because, thereby, it might be less likely to create offence in political circles. St. Pierre himself may or may not have been acquainted with the facts.

    The so-called Grand Dessein of Henry IV. was, shortly, as follows.[36] It proposed to divide Europe between fifteen Powers,[37] in such a manner that the balance of power should be established and preserved. These were to form a Christian republic on the basis of the freedom and equality of its members, the armed forces of the federation being supported by fixed contribution.

    A general council, consisting of representatives from the fifteen states, was to make all laws necessary for cementing the union thus formed and for maintaining the order once established. It would also be the business of this senate to “deliberate on questions that might arise, to occupy themselves with discussing different interests, to settle quarrels amicably, to throw light upon and arrange all the civil, political and religious affairs of Europe, whether internal or foreign.” (Mémoires, vol. VI., p. 129 seq.)

    [36] The main articles of this and other peace projects are to
    be found in International Tribunals, published by the Peace
    Society.

    [37] Professor Lorimer points out that Prussia, then the Duchy
    of Brandenburg, is not mentioned. (Institutes of the Law of
    Nations
    , II. Ch. VII., p. 219.)

    This scheme of the king or his minister was expanded with great thoroughness and clear-sightedness by the Abbé St. Pierre: none of the many later plans for a perpetual peace has been so perfect in details. He proposes that there should be a permanent and perpetual union between, if possible, all Christian sovereigns—of whom he suggests nineteen, excluding the Czar—“to preserve unbroken peace in Europe,” and that a permanent Congress or senate should be formed by deputies of the federated states.

    The union should protect weak sovereigns, minors during a regency, and so on, and should banish civil as well as international war—it should “render prompt and adequate assistance to rulers and chief magistrates against seditious persons and rebels.” All warfare henceforth is to be waged between the troops of the federation—each nation contributing an equal number—and the enemies of European security, whether outsiders or rebellious members of the union.

    Otherwise, where it is possible, all disputes occurring within the union are to be settled by the arbitration of the senate, and the combined military force of the federation is to be applied to drive the Turks out of Europe. There is to be a rational rearrangement of boundaries, but after this no change is to be permitted in the map of Europe. The union should bind itself to tolerate the different forms of faith.

    The objections to St. Pierre’s scheme are, many of them, obvious. He himself produces sixty-two arguments likely to be raised against his plan, and he examines these in turn with acuteness and eloquence.

    But there are other criticisms which he was less likely to be able to forestall. Of the nineteen states he names as a basis of the federation, some have disappeared and the governments of others have completely changed. Indeed St. Pierre’s scheme did not look far beyond the present. But it has besides a too strongly political character.[38] From this point of view, the Abbé’s plan amounts practically to a European coalition against the Ottoman Empire.

    Moreover, we notice with a smile that the French statesman and patriot is not lost in the cosmopolitan political reformer. “The kingdom of Spain shall not go out of the House of Bourbon!”[39] France is to enjoy more than the privileges of honour; she is to reap distinct material and political advantages from the union. Humanity is to be a brotherhood, but, in the federation of nations, France is to stand first.[40] We see that these “rêves d’un homme de bien,” as Cardinal Dubois called them, are not without their practical element.

    But the great mistake of St. Pierre is this: he actually thought that his plan could be put into execution in the near future, that an ideal of this kind was realisable at once.[41] “I, myself, form’d it,” he says in the preface, “in full expectation to see it one Day executed.” As Hobbes, says, “there can be nothing so absurd, but may be found in the books of philosophers.”[42] St. Pierre was not content to make his influence felt on the statesmen of his time and prepare the way for the abolition of all arbitrary forms of government.

    This was the flaw which drew down upon the good Abbé Voltaire’s sneering epigram[43] and the irony of Leibniz.[44] Here, above all, in this unpractical enthusiasm his scheme differs from that of Kant.

    [38] The same objection was raised by Leibniz (see his
    Observations on St. Pierre’s Projet) to the scheme of Henry
    IV., who, says Leibniz, thought more of overthrowing the house of
    Austria than of establishing a society of sovereigns.

    [39] Project, Art. VI., Eng. trans. (1714), p. 119.

    [40] St. Pierre was not blind to this aspect of the question.
    Among the critical objections which he anticipates to his plan is
    this,—that it promises too great an increase of strength to the
    house of France, and that therefore the author would have been
    wiser to conceal his nationality.

    [41] St. Pierre, in what may be called an apology for the wording
    of the title of his book (above, p. 32, note), justifies his
    confidence in these words:—“The Pilot who himself seems uncertain
    of the Success of his Voyage is not likely to persuade the
    Passenger to embark.... I am persuaded, that it is not impossible
    to find out Means sufficient and practicable to settle an
    Everlasting Peace among Christians; and even believe, that the
    Means which I have thought of are of that Nature.” (Preface to
    Project, Eng. trans., 1714.)

    [42] Leviathan, I. Ch. V.

    [43] See too Voltaire’s allusion to St. Pierre in his
    Dictionary, under “Religion.”

    [44] Leibniz regarded the project of St. Pierre with an
    indifference, somewhat tinged with contempt. In a letter to
    Grimarest, (Leibnit. Opera, Dutens’ ed., 1768, Vol. V., pp.
    65, 66: in Epist., ed. Kortholt., Vol. III., p. 327) he
    writes:—“I have seen something of M. de St. Pierre’s plan for
    maintaining perpetual peace in Europe. It reminds me of an
    inscription outside of a churchyard which ran, ‘Pax Perpetua.
    For the dead, it is true, fight no more.

    But the living, are of
    another mind, and the mightiest among them have little respect
    for tribunals.’” This is followed by the ironical suggestion
    that a court of arbitration should be established at Rome of
    which the Pope should be made president; while at the same time
    the old spiritual authority should be restored to the Church,
    and excommunication be the punishment of non-compliance with the
    arbitral decree. “Such plans,” he adds, “are as likely to succeed
    as that of M. de St. Pierre.

    But as we are allowed to write
    novels, why should we find fault with fiction which would bring
    back the golden age?” But see also Observations sur le Projet
    d’une Paix Perpétuelle de M. l’Abbé de St. Pierre
    (Dutens, V.,
    esp. p. 56) and the letter to Remond de Montmort (ibid. pp. 20,
    21) where Leibniz considers this project rather more seriously.

    Rousseau’s Criticism of St. Pierre.

    Rousseau took St. Pierre’s project[45] much more seriously than either Leibniz or Voltaire. But sovereigns, he thought, are deaf to the voice of justice; the absolutism of princely power would never allow a king to submit to a tribunal of nations. Moreover war was, according to Rousseau’s experience, a matter not between nations, but between princes and cabinets. It was one of the ordinary pleasures of royal existence and one not likely to be voluntarily given up.[46] We know that history has not supported Rousseau’s contention.

    Dynastic wars are now no more. The Great Powers have shown themselves able to impose their own conditions, where the welfare and security of Europe have seemed to demand it. Such a development seemed impossible enough in the eighteenth century.

    In the military organisation of the nations of Europe and in the necessity of making their internal development subordinate to the care for their external security, Rousseau saw the cause of all the defects in their administration.[47] The formation of unions on the model of the Swiss Confederation or the German Bund would, he thought, be in the interest of all rulers. But great obstacles seemed to him to lie in the way of the realisation of such a project as that of St. Pierre.

    “Without doubt,” says Rousseau in conclusion, “the proposal of a perpetual peace is at present an absurd one.... It can only be put into effect by methods which are violent in themselves and dangerous to humanity. One cannot conceive of the possibility of a federative union being established, except by a revolution. And, that granted, who among us would venture to say whether this European federation is to be desired or to be feared?

    It would work, perhaps, more harm in a moment than it would prevent in the course of centuries.” (Jugement sur la Paix Perpétuelle.)

    [45] “C’est un livre solide et sensé,” says Rousseau (Jugement
    sur la Paix Perpétuelle
    ), “et il est très important qu’il
    existe.” [This Jugement is appended to Rousseau’s Extrait du
    Projet de Paix Perpétuelle de Monsieur l’Abbé de Saint-Pierre
    ,
    1761.]

    [46] Cf. Cowper: The Winter Morning Walk:—

    “Great princes have great playthings. Some have play’d
    At hewing mountains into men, and some
    At building human wonders mountain high.
    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    Some seek diversion in the tented field,
    And make the sorrows of mankind their sport.
    But war’s a game, which, were their subjects wise,
    Kings should not play at. Nations would do well
    T’extort their truncheons from the puny hands
    Of heroes, whose infirm and baby minds
    Are gratified with mischief, and who spoil,
    Because men suffer it, their toy the world.”

    [47] “Les troupes réglées, peste et dépopulation de l’Europe,
    ne sont bonnes qu’a deux fins: ou pour attaquer et conquérir
    les voisins, ou pour enchâiner et asservir les citoyens.”
    (Gouvernement de Pologne, Ch. XII.)

    The Position of Hobbes.

    The most profound and searching analysis of this problem comes from Immanuel Kant, whose indebtedness in the sphere of politics to Hobbes, Locke, Montesquieu and Rousseau it is difficult to overestimate. Kant’s doctrine of the sovereignty of the people comes to him from Locke through Rousseau. His explanation of the origin of society is practically that of Hobbes. The direct influence on politics of this philosopher, apart from his share in moulding the Kantian theory of the state, is one we cannot afford to neglect.

    His was a great influence on the new science just thrown on the world by Grotius, and his the first clear and systematic statement we have of the nature of society and the establishment of the state.

    The natural state of man, says Hobbes, is a state of war,[48] a bellum omnium contra omnes, where all struggle for honour and for preferment and the prizes to which every individual is by natural right equally entitled, but which can of necessity fall only to the few, the foremost in the race. Men hate and fear the society of their kind, but through this desire to excel are forced to seek it: only where there are many can there be a first.

    This state of things, this apparent sociability which is brought about by and coupled with the least sociable of instincts, becomes unendurable. “It is necessary to peace,” writes Hobbes (On Dominion, Ch. VI. 3) “that a man be so far forth protected against the violence of others, that he may live securely; that is, that he may have no just cause to fear others, so long as he doth them no injury.

    Indeed, to make men altogether safe from mutual harms, so as they cannot be hurt or injuriously killed, is impossible; and, therefore, comes not within deliberation.” But to protect them so far as is possible the state is formed. Hobbes has no great faith in human contracts or promises. Man’s nature is malicious and untrustworthy. A coercive power is necessary to guarantee this long-desired security within the community.

    “We must therefore,” he adds, “provide for our security, not by compacts, but by punishments; and there is then sufficient provision made, when there are so great punishments appointed for every injury, as apparently it prove a greater evil to have done it, than not to have done it. For all men, by a necessity of nature, choose that which to them appears to be the less evil.” (Op. cit., Ch. VI. 4.)

    [48] Hobbes realises clearly that there probably never was such a
    state of war all over the world nor a state of nature conforming
    to a common type. The case is parallel to the use of the term
    “original contract” as an explanation of the manner in which the
    civil state came to be formed. (Cf. p. 52, note.)

    See also Hume (Inquiry concerning the Principles of Morals,
    Sect. III. Part I.). “This poetical fiction of the golden age
    is, in some respects, of a piece with the philosophical fiction
    of the state of nature; only that the former is represented
    as the most charming and most peaceable condition, which can
    possibly be imagined; whereas the latter is painted out as a
    state of mutual war and violence, attended with the most extreme
    necessity.” This fiction of a state of nature as a state of war,
    says Hume, (in a note to this passage) is not the invention of
    Hobbes. Plato (Republic, II. III.

    IV.) refutes a hypothesis
    very like it, and Cicero (Pro Sext. l. 42) regards it as a fact
    universally acknowledged.

    Cf. also Spinoza (Tract. Pol. c. ii. § 14): “Homines ex natura
    hostes.” And (c. v. § 2): “Homines civiles non nascuntur sed
    fiunt.” These expressions are to be understood, says Bluntschli
    (Theory of the State, IV. Ch. vi., p. 284, note a), “rather
    as a logical statement of what would be the condition of
    man apart from civil society, than as distinctly implying a
    historical theory.”

    While starting from the same premises, Spinoza carries Hobbes’
    political theories to their logical conclusion.

    If we admit that
    right lies with might, then right is with the people in any
    revolution successfully carried out. (But see Hobbes’ Preface to
    the Philosophical Rudiments and Kant’s Perpetual Peace, p.
    188, note.) Spinoza, in a letter, thus alludes to this point of
    difference:—“As regards political theories, the difference which
    you inquire about between Hobbes and myself, consists in this,
    that I always preserve natural right intact, and only allot to
    the chief magistrates in every state a right over their subjects
    commensurate with the excess of their power over the power of
    the subjects.

    This is what always takes place in the state of
    nature.” (Epistle 50, Works, Bohn’s ed., Vol. II.)

    These precautions secure that relative peace within the state which is one of the conditions of the safety of the people. But it is, besides, the duty of a sovereign to guarantee an adequate protection to his subjects against foreign enemies. A state of defence as complete and perfect as possible is not only a national duty, but an absolute necessity. The following statement of the relation of the state to other states shows how closely Hobbes has been followed by Kant. “There are two things necessary,” says Hobbes, (On Dominion, Ch. XIII.

    7) “for the people’s defence; to be warned and to be forearmed. For the state of commonwealths considered in themselves, is natural, that is to say, hostile.[49] Neither, if they cease from fighting, is it therefore to be called peace; but rather a breathing time, in which one enemy observing the motion and countenance of the other, values his security not according to pacts, but the forces and counsels of his adversary.”

    [49] The italics are mine.—[Tr.]

    Hobbes is a practical philosopher: no man was less a dreamer, a follower after ideals than he. He is, moreover, a pessimist, and his doctrine of the state is a political absolutism,[50] the form of government which above all has been, and is, favourable to war.

    He would no doubt have ridiculed the idea of a perpetual peace between nations, had such a project as that of St. Pierre—a practical project, counting upon a realisation in the near future—been brought before him. He might not even have accepted it in the very much modified form which Kant adopts, that of an ideal—an unattainable ideal—towards which humanity could not do better than work.

    He expected the worst possible from man the individual. Homo homini lupus. The strictest absolutism, amounting almost to despotism, was required to keep the vicious propensities of the human animal in check. States he looked upon as units of the same kind, members also of a society. They had, and openly exhibited, the same faults as individual men. They too might be driven with a strong enough coercive force behind them, but not without it; and such a coercive force as this did not exist in a society of nations.

    Federation and federal troops are terms which represent ideas of comparatively recent origin. Without something of this kind, any enduring peace was not to be counted upon. International relations were and must remain at least potentially warlike in character. Under no circumstances could ideal conditions be possible either between the members of a state or between the states themselves. Human nature could form no satisfactory basis for a counsel of perfection.

    [50] Professor Paulsen (Immanuel Kant, 2nd ed., 1899, p.
    359—Eng. trans., p. 353) points out that pessimism and absolutism
    usually go together in the doctrines of philosophers. He gives as
    instances Hobbes, Kant and Schopenhauer.

    Hobbes (On Dominion, Ch. X. 3, seq.) regarded an absolute
    monarchy as the only proper form of government, while in the
    opinion of Locke, (On Civil Government, II. Ch. VII. §§ 90,
    91) it was no better than a state of nature. Kant would not have
    gone quite so far. As a philosopher, he upheld the sovereignty
    of the people and rejected a monarchy which was not governed in
    accordance with republican principles; as a citizen, he denied
    the right of resistance to authority. (Cf. Perpetual Peace, pp.
    126, 188, note.)

    Hence Hobbes never thought of questioning the necessity of war.

    It was in his eyes the natural condition of European society; but certain rules were necessary both for its conduct and, where this was compatible with a nation’s dignity and prosperity, for its prevention. He held that international law was only a part of the Law of Nature, and that this Law of Nature laid certain obligations upon nations and their kings.

    Mediation must be employed between disputants as much as possible, the person of the mediators of peace being held inviolate; an umpire ought to be chosen to decide a controversy, to whose judgment the parties in dispute agree to submit themselves; such an arbiter must be impartial. These are all what Hobbes calls precepts of the Law of Nature. And he appeals to the Scriptures in confirmation of his assertion that peace is the way of righteousness and that the laws of nature of which these are a few are also laws of the heavenly kingdom.

    But peace is like the straight path of Christian endeavour, difficult to find and difficult to keep. We must seek after it where it may be found; but, having done this and sought in vain, we have no alternative but to fall back upon war. Reason requires “that every man ought to endeavour peace,” (Lev. I. Ch. XIV.) “as far as he has hope of obtaining it; and when he cannot obtain it, that he may seek, and use, all helps, and advantages of war.”[51] This, says Hobbes elsewhere, (On Liberty, Ch. I.

    15) is the dictate of right reason, the first and fundamental law of nature.

    [51] We find the same rule laid down as early as the time of
    Dante. Cf. De Monarchia, Bk. II. 9:—“When two nations quarrel
    they are bound to try in every possible way to arrange the
    quarrel by means of discussion: it is only when this is hopeless
    that they may declare war.”

    Kant’s Idea of a Perpetual Peace.

    With regard to the problems of international law, Kant is of course a hundred and fifty years ahead of Hobbes. But he starts from the same point: his theory of the beginning of society is practically identical with that of the older philosopher. Men are by nature imperfect creatures, unsociable and untrustworthy, cursed by a love of glory, of possession, and of power, passions which make happiness something for ever unattainable by them. Hobbes is content to leave them here with their imperfections, and let a strong government help them out as it may.

    But not so Kant. He looks beyond man the individual, developing slowly by stages scarcely measurable, progressing at one moment, and the next, as it seems, falling behind: he looks beyond the individual, struggling and never attaining, to the race. Here Kant is no pessimist. The capacities implanted in man by nature are not all for evil: they are, he says, “destined to unfold themselves completely in the course of time, and in accordance with the end to which they are adapted.” (Idea of a Universal History from a Cosmopolitan Point of View, 1784. Prop.

    1.) This end of humanity is the evolution of man from the stage of mere self-satisfied animalism to a high state of civilisation. Through his own reason man is to attain a perfect culture, intellectual and moral. In this long period of struggle, the potential faculties which nature or Providence has bestowed upon him reach their full development. The process in which this evolution takes place is what we call history.

    To man nature has given none of the perfect animal equipments for self-preservation and self-defence which she has bestowed on others of her creatures. But she has given to him reason and freedom of will, and has determined that through these faculties and without the aid of instinct he shall win for himself a complete development of his capacities and natural endowments. It is, says Kant, no happy life that nature has marked out for man. He is filled with desires which he can never satisfy.

    His life is one of endeavour and not of attainment: not even the consciousness of the well-fought battle is his, for the struggle is more or less an unconscious one, the end unseen. Only in the race, and not in the individual, can the natural capacities of the human species reach full development. Reason, says Kant, (Prop. 2, op. cit.) “does not itself work by instinct, but requires experiments, exercise and instruction in order to advance gradually from one stage of insight to another.

    Hence each individual man would necessarily have to live an enormous length of time, in order to learn by himself how to make a complete use of all his natural endowments.

    Or, if nature should have given him but a short lease of life, as is actually the case, reason would then require an almost interminable series of generations, the one handing down its enlightenment to the other, in order that the seeds she has sown in our species may be brought at last to a stage of development which is in perfect accordance with her design.” Man the individual shall travel towards the land of promise and fight for its possession, but not he, nor his children, nor his children’s children shall inherit the land.

    “Only the latest comers can have the good fortune of inhabiting the dwelling which the long series of their predecessors have toiled—though,” adds Kant, “without any conscious intent—to build up without even the possibility of participating in the happiness which they were preparing.” (Proposition 3.)

    The means which nature employs to bring about this development of all the capacities implanted in men is their mutual antagonism in society—what Kant calls the “unsocial sociableness of men, that is to say, their inclination to enter into society, an inclination which yet is bound up at every point with a resistance which threatens continually to break up the society so formed.” (Proposition 4.) Man hates society, and yet there alone he can develop his capacities; he cannot live there peaceably, and yet cannot live without it.

    It is the resistance which others offer to his inclinations and will—which he, on his part, shows likewise to the desires of others—that awakens all the latent powers of his nature and the determination to conquer his natural propensity to indolence and love of material comfort and to struggle for the first place among his fellow-creatures, to satisfy, in outstripping them, his love of glory and possession and power.

    “Without those, in themselves by no means lovely, qualities which set man in social opposition to man, so that each finds his selfish claims resisted by the selfishness of all the others, men would have lived on in an Arcadian shepherd life, in perfect harmony, contentment, and mutual love; but all their talents would forever have remained hidden and undeveloped. Thus, kindly as the sheep they tended, they would scarcely have given to their existence a greater value than that of their cattle.

    And the place among the ends of creation which was left for the development of rational beings would not have been filled. Thanks be to nature for the unsociableness, for the spiteful competition of vanity, for the insatiate desires of gain and power! Without these, all the excellent natural capacities of humanity would have slumbered undeveloped.

    Man’s will is for harmony; but nature knows better what is good for his species: her will is for dissension. He would like a life of comfort and satisfaction, but nature wills that he should be dragged out of idleness and inactive content and plunged into labour and trouble, in order that he may be made to seek in his own prudence for the means of again delivering himself from them. The natural impulses which prompt this effort,—the causes of unsociableness and mutual conflict, out of which so many evils spring,—are also in turn the spurs which drive him to the development of his powers.

    Thus, they really betray the providence of a wise Creator, and not the interference of some evil spirit which has meddled with the world which God has nobly planned, and enviously overturned its order.” (Proposition 4: Caird’s translation in The Critical Philosophy of Kant, Vol. II., pp. 550, 551.)

    The problem now arises, How shall men live together, each free to work out his own development, without at the same time interfering with a like liberty on the part of his neighbour? The solution of this problem is the state. Here the liberty of each member is guaranteed and its limits strictly defined. A perfectly just civil constitution, administered according to the principles of right, would be that under which the greatest possible amount of liberty was left to each citizen within these limits.

    This is the ideal of Kant, and here lies the greatest practical problem which has presented itself to humanity. An ideal of this kind is difficult of realisation. But nature imposes no such duty upon us. “Out of such crooked material as man is made,” says Kant, “nothing can be hammered quite straight.” (Proposition 6.) We must make our constitution as good as we can and, with that, rest content.

    The direct cause of this transition from a state of nature and conditions of unlimited freedom to civil society with its coercive and restraining forces is found in the evils of that state of nature as they are painted by Hobbes. A wild lawless freedom becomes impossible for man: he is compelled to seek the protection of a civil society. He lives in uncertainty and insecurity: his liberty is so far worthless that he cannot peacefully enjoy it. For this peace he voluntarily yields up some part of his independence.

    The establishment of the state is in the interest of his development to a higher civilisation. It is more—the guarantee of his existence and self-preservation.

    This is the sense, says Professor Paulsen, in which Kant like Hobbes regards the state as “resting on a contract,”[52] that is to say, on the free will of all.[53] Volenti non fit injuria. Only, adds Paulsen, we must remember that this contract is not a historical fact, as it seemed to some writers of the eighteenth century, but an “idea of reason”: we are speaking here not of the history of the establishment of the state, but of the reason of its existence. (Paulsen’s Kant, p. 354.)[54]

    [52] Rousseau (Contrat Social: I. vi.) regards the social
    contract as tacitly implied in every actual society: its articles
    “are the same everywhere, and are everywhere tacitly admitted
    and recognised, even though they may never have found formal
    expression” in any constitution. In the same way he speaks of
    a state of nature “which no longer exists, which perhaps never
    has existed.” (Preface to the Discourse on the Causes of
    Inequality
    .) But Rousseau’s interpretation of these terms is, on
    the whole, literal in spite of these single passages.

    He speaks
    throughout the Contrat Social, as if history could actually
    record the signing and drawing up of such documents. Hobbes,
    Hooker, (Ecclesiastical Polity, I. sect. 10—see also Ritchie:
    Darwin and Hegel, p. 210 seq.) Hume and Kant use more careful
    language. “It cannot be denied,” writes Hume, (Of the Original
    Contract
    ) “that all government is, at first, founded on a
    contract and that the most ancient rude combinations of mankind
    were formed chiefly by that principle. In vain are we asked in
    what records this charter of our liberties is registered.

    It was
    not written on parchment, nor yet on leaves or barks of trees. It
    preceded the use of writing and all the other civilised arts of
    life. But we trace it plainly in the nature of man, and in the
    equality, or something approaching equality, which we find in all
    the individuals of that species.”

    This fine passage expresses admirably the views of Kant on this
    point. Cf. Werke, (Rosenkranz) IX. 160. The original contract
    is merely an idea of reason, one of those ideas which we think
    into things in order to explain them.

    Hobbes does not professedly make the contract historical, but in
    Locke’s Civil Government (II. Ch. VIII. § 102) there is some
    attempt made to give it a historical basis.—By consent all were
    equal, “till by the same consent they set rulers over themselves.
    So that their politic societies all began from a voluntary union,
    and the mutual agreement of men freely acting in the choice of
    their governors, and forms of government.”

    Bluntschli points out (Theory of the State, IV. ix., p. 294
    and note) that the same theory of contract on which Hobbes’
    doctrine of an absolute government was based was made the
    justification of violent resistance to the government at the time
    of the French Revolution. The theory was differently applied by
    Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau. According to the first, men leave
    the “state of nature” when they surrender their rights to a
    sovereign, and return to that state during revolution. But, for
    Rousseau, this sovereign authority is the people: a revolution
    would be only a change of ministry. (See Cont. Soc., III.

    Ch.
    xviii.) Again Locke holds revolution to be justifiable in all
    cases where the governments have not fulfilled the trust reposed
    by the people in them. (Cf. Kant’s Perpetual Peace, p. 188,
    note).

    [53] “If you unite many men,” writes Rousseau, (Cont. Soc., IV.
    I.) “and consider them as one body, they will have but one will;
    and that will must be to promote the common safety and general
    well-being of all.” This volonté générale, the common element
    of all particular wills, cannot be in conflict with any of them.
    (Op. cit., II. iii.)

    [54] In Eng. trans., see p. 348.

    In this civil union, self-sought, yet sought reluctantly, man is able to turn his most unlovable qualities to a profitable use. They bind this society together. They are the instrument by which he wins for himself self-culture. It is here with men, says Kant, as it is with the trees in a forest: “just because each one strives to deprive the other of air and sun, they compel each other to seek both above, and thus they grow beautiful and straight.

    Whereas those that, in freedom and isolation from one another, shoot out their branches at will, grow stunted and crooked and awry.” (Proposition 5, op. cit.) Culture, art, and all that is best in the social order are the fruits of that self-loving unsociableness in man.

    The problem of the establishment of a perfect civil constitution cannot be solved, says this treatise (Idea for a Universal History), until the external relations of states are regulated in accordance with principles of right. For, even if the ideal internal constitution were attained, what end would it serve in the evolution of humanity, if commonwealths themselves were to remain like individuals in a state of nature, each existing in uncontrolled freedom, a law unto himself? This condition of things again cannot be permanent.

    Nature uses the same means as before to bring about a state of law and order. War, present or near at hand, the strain of constant preparation for a possible future campaign or the heavy burden of debt and devastation left by the last,—these are the evils which must drive states to leave a lawless, savage state of nature, hostile to man’s inward development, and seek in union the end of nature, peace.

    All wars are the attempts nature makes to bring about new political relations between nations, relations which, in their very nature, cannot be, and are not desired to be, permanent. These combinations will go on succeeding each other, until at last a federation of all powers is formed for the establishment of perpetual peace. This is the end of humanity, demanded by reason. Justice will reign, not only in the state, but in the whole human race when perpetual peace exists between the nations of the world.

    This is the point of view of the Idea for a Universal History. But equally, we may say, law and justice will reign between nations, when a legally and morally perfect constitution adorns the state.

    External perpetual peace presupposes internal peace—peace civil, social, economic, religious. Now, when men are perfect—and what would this be but perfection—how can there be war? Cardinal Fleury’s only objection—no light one—to St. Pierre’s project was that, as even the most peace-loving could not avoid war, all men must first be men of noble character. This seems to be what is required in the treatise on Perpetual Peace. Kant demands, to a certain extent, the moral regeneration of man.

    There must be perfect honesty in international dealings, good faith in the interpretation and fulfilment of treaties and so on (Art. 1)[55]: and again, every state must have a republican constitution—a term by which Kant understands a constitution as nearly as possible in accordance with the spirit of right. (Art. 1.)[56] This is to say that we have to start with our reformation at home, look first to the culture and education and morals of our citizens, then to our foreign relations. This is a question of self-interest as well as of ethics.

    On the civil and religious liberty of a state depends its commercial success. Kant saw the day coming, when industrial superiority was to be identified with political pre-eminence. The state which does not look to the enlightenment and liberty of its subjects must fail in the race. But the advantages of a high state of civilisation are not all negative.

    The more highly developed the individuals who form a state, the more highly developed is its consciousness of its obligations to other nations. In the ignorance and barbarism of races lies the great obstacle to a reign of law among states. Uncivilised states cannot be conceived as members of a federation of Europe. First, the perfect civil constitution according to right: then the federation of these law-abiding Powers. This is the path which reason marks out.

    The treatise on Perpetual Peace seems to be in this respect more practical than the Idea for a Universal History. But it matters little which way we take it. The point of view is the same in both cases: the end remains the development of man towards good, the order of his steps in this direction is indifferent.

    [55] See p. 107.

    [56] See p. 120.

    The Political and Social Conditions of Kant’s Time.

    The history of the human race, viewed as a whole, Kant regards as the realisation of a hidden plan of nature to bring about a political constitution internally and externally perfect—the only condition under which the faculties of man can be fully developed.

    Does experience support this theory? Kant thought that, to a certain degree, it did. This conviction was not, however, a fruit of his experience of citizenship in Prussia, an absolute dynastic state, a military monarchy waging perpetual dynastic wars of the kind he most hotly condemned. Kant had no feeling of love to Prussia,[57] and little of a citizen’s patriotic pride, or even interest, in its political achievements.

    This was partly because of his sympathy with republican doctrines: partly due to his love of justice and peculiar hatred of war,[58] a hatred based, no doubt, not less on principle than on a close personal experience of the wretchedness it brings with it. It was not the political and social conditions in which he lived which fostered Kant’s love of liberty and gave him inspiration, unless in the sense in which the mind reacts upon surrounding influences.

    Looking beyond Prussia to America, in whose struggle for independence he took a keen interest, and looking to France where the old dynastic monarchy had been succeeded by a republican state, Kant seemed to see the signs of a coming democratisation of the old monarchical society of Europe. In this growing influence on the state of the mass of the people who had everything to lose in war and little to gain by victory, he saw the guarantee of a future perpetual peace. Other forces too were at work to bring about this consummation.

    There was a growing consciousness that war, this costly means of settling a dispute, is not even a satisfactory method of settlement. Hazardous and destructive in its effect, it is also uncertain in its results. Victory is not always gain; it no longer signifies a land to be plundered, a people to be sold to slavery. It brings fresh responsibilities to a nation, at a time when it is not always strong enough to bear them.

    But, above all, Kant saw, even at the end of the eighteenth century, the nations of Europe so closely bound together by commercial interests that a war—and especially a maritime war where the scene of conflict cannot be to the same extent localised as on land—between any two of them could not but seriously affect the prosperity of the others.[59] He clearly realised that the spirit of commerce was the strongest force in the service of the maintenance of peace, and that in it lay a guarantee of future union.

    [57] Unlike Hegel whose ideal was the Prussian state, as it was
    under Frederick the Great. An enthusiastic supporter of the power
    of monarchy, he showed himself comparatively indifferent to the
    progress of constitutional liberty.

    [58] Isolated passages are sometimes quoted from Kant in support
    of a theory that the present treatise is at least half ironical[A]
    and that his views on the question of perpetual peace did not
    essentially differ from those of Leibniz. “Even war,” he says,
    (Kritik d. Urteilskraft, I. Book ii. § 28.) “when conducted in
    an orderly way and with reverence for the rights of citizens has
    something of the sublime about it, and the more dangers a nation
    which wages war in this manner is exposed to and can courageously
    overcome, the nobler does its character grow.

    While, on the other
    hand, a prolonged peace usually has the effect of giving free
    play to a purely commercial spirit, and side by side with this,
    to an ignoble self-seeking, to cowardice and effeminacy; and the
    result of this is generally a degradation of national character.”

    [A] Cf. K. v. Stengel: Der Ewige Friede, Munich, 1899; also
    Vaihinger: Kantstudien, Vol. IV., p. 58.

    This is certainly an admission that war which does not violate
    the Law of Nations has a good side as well as a bad. We could
    look for no less in so clear-sighted and unprejudiced a thinker.
    Kant would have been the first to admit that under certain
    conditions a nation can have no higher duty than to wage war.
    War is necessary, but it is in contradiction to reason and the
    spirit of right. The “scourge of mankind,” “making more bad men
    than it takes away,” the “destroyer of every good,” Kant calls it
    elsewhere. (Theory of Ethics, Abbott’s trans., 4th ed., p. 341,
    note.)

    [59] Cf. Idea for a Universal History, Prop. 8; Perpetual
    Peace
    , pp. 142, 157.

    This scheme of a federation of the nations of the world, in accordance with principles which would put an end to war between them, was one whose interest for Kant seemed to increase during the last twenty years of his life.[60] It was according to him an idea of reason, and, in his first essay on the subject—that of 1784—we see the place this ideal of a perpetual peace held in the Kantian system of philosophy.

    Its realisation is the realisation of the highest good—the ethical and political summum bonum, for here the aims of morals and politics coincide: only in a perfect development of his faculties in culture and in morals can man at last find true happiness. History is working towards the consummation of this end. A moral obligation lies on man to strive to establish conditions which bring its realisation nearer. It is the duty of statesmen to form a federative union as it was formerly the duty of individuals to enter the state.

    The moral law points the way here as clearly as in the sphere of pure ethics:—“Thou can’st, therefore thou ought’st.”

    [60] The immediate stimulus to Kant’s active interest in this
    subject as a practical question was the Peace of Basle (1795)
    which ended the first stage in the series of wars which followed
    the French Revolution.

    Let us be under no misapprehension as to Kant’s attitude to the problem of perpetual peace. It is an ideal. He states plainly that he so regards it[61] and that as such it is unattainable. But this is the essence of all ideals: they have not the less value in shaping the life and character of men and nations on that account. They are not ends to be realised but ideas according to which we must live, regulative principles. We cannot, says Kant, shape our life better than in acting as if such ideas of reason have objective validity and there be an immortal life in which man shall live according to the laws of reason, in peace with his neighbour and in freedom from the trammels of sense.

    [61] It is eine unausführbare Idee. See the passage quoted from
    the Rechtslehre, p. 129, note.

    Hence we are concerned here, not with an end, but with the means by which we might best set about attaining it, if it were attainable.

    This is the subject matter of the Treatise on Perpetual Peace (1795), a less eloquent and less purely philosophical essay than that of 1784, but throughout more systematic and practical. We have to do, not with the favourite dream of philanthropists like St. Pierre and Rousseau, but with a statement of the conditions on the fulfilment of which the transition to a reign of peace and law depends.

    The Conditions of the Realisation of the Kantian Ideal.

    These means are of two kinds. In the first place, what evils must we set about removing? What are the negative conditions? And, secondly, what are the general positive conditions which will make the realisation of this idea possible and guarantee the permanence of an international peace once attained? These negative and positive conditions Kant calls Preliminary and Definitive Articles respectively, the whole essay being carefully thrown into the form of a treaty.

    The Preliminary Articles of a treaty for perpetual peace are based on the principle that anything that hinders or threatens the peaceful co-existence of nations must be abolished. These conditions have been classified by Kuno Fischer. Kant, he points out,[62] examines the principles of right governing the different sets of circumstances in which nations find themselves—namely, (a) while they are actually at war; (b) when the time comes to conclude a treaty of peace; (c) when they are living in a state of peace.

    The six Preliminary Articles fall naturally into these groups. War must not be conducted in such a manner as to increase national hatred and embitter a future peace. (Art. 6.)[63] The treaty which brings hostilities to an end must be concluded in an honest desire for peace. (Art. 1.)[64] Again a nation, when in a state of peace, must do nothing to threaten the political independence of another nation or endanger its existence, thereby giving the strongest of all motives for a fresh war.

    A nation may commit this injury in two ways: (1) indirectly, by causing danger to others through the growth of its standing army (Art. 3)[65]—always a menace to the state of peace—or by any unusual war preparations: and (2) through too great a supremacy of another kind, by amassing money, the most powerful of all weapons in warfare. The National Debt (Art. 4)[66] is another standing danger to the peaceful co-existence of nations. But, besides, we have the danger of actual attack. There is no right of intervention between nations. (Art.

    5.)[67] Nor can states be inherited or conquered (Art. 2),[68] or in any way treated in a manner subversive of their independence and sovereignty as individuals. For a similar reason, armed troops cannot be hired and sold as things.

    [62] Geschichte der neueren Philosophie, (4th ed., 1899), Vol.
    V., I. Ch. 12, p. 168 seq.

    [63] See p. 114.

    [64] See p. 107.

    [65] See p. 110.

    [66] See p. 111.

    [67] See p. 112.

    [68] See p. 108.

    These then are the negative conditions of peace.[69] There are, besides, three positive conditions:

    [69] A large part of Kant’s requirements as they are expressed in
    these Preliminary Articles has already been fulfilled. The first
    (Art. 1) is recognised in theory at least by modern international
    law. More cannot be said. A treaty of this kind is of necessity
    more or less forced by the stronger on the weaker. The formal
    ratification of peace in 1871 did not prevent France from longing
    for the day when she might win back Alsace-Lorraine and be
    revenged on Prussia. Not the treaty nor a consciousness of defeat
    has kept the peace west of the Rhine, but a reluctant respect for
    the fortress of Metz and the mighty army of united Germany.

    Articles 2 and 6 are already commonplaces of international
    law. Article 2 refers to practices which have not survived the
    gradual disappearance of dynastic war. Art. 6 is the basis of
    our modern law of war. Art. 3 has been fulfilled in the literal
    sense that the standing armies composed of mercenary troops to
    which Kant alludes exist no longer. But it is to be feared that
    Kant would not think that we have made things much better, nor
    regard our present system of progressive armaments as a step in
    the direction of perpetual peace. Art. 4 is not likely to be
    fulfilled in the near future.

    It is long since Cobden denounced
    the institution of National Debts—an institution which, as Kant
    points out, owes its origin to the English, the “commercial
    people” referred to in the text. Art. 5 no doubt came to Kant
    through Vattel. “No nation,” says the Swiss publicist, (Law of
    Nations
    , II. Ch. iv. § 54) “has the least right to interfere
    with the government of another,” unless, he adds, (Ch. v. §
    70) in a case of anarchy or where the well-being of the human
    race demands it. This is a recognised principle of modern
    international law.

    Intervention is held to be justifiable only
    where the obligation to respect another’s freedom of action comes
    into conflict with the duty of self-preservation.

    Puffendorf leaves much more room for the exercise of benevolence.
    The natural affinity and kinship between men is, says he, (Les
    Devoirs de l’homme et du citoien
    , II. Ch. xvi. § xi.) “a
    sufficient reason to authorise us to take up defence of every
    person whom one sees unjustly oppressed, when he implores our
    aid and when we can do it conveniently.” (The italics are
    mine.—[Tr.])

    (a) The intercourse of nations is to be confined to a right of hospitality. (Art. 3.)[70] There is nothing new to us in this assertion of a right of way. The right to free means of international communication has in the last hundred years become a commonplace of law. And the change has been brought about, as Kant anticipated, not through an abstract respect for the idea of right, but through the pressure of purely commercial interests.

    Since Kant’s time the nations of Europe have all been more or less transformed from agricultural to commercial states whose interests run mainly in the same direction, whose existence and development depend necessarily upon “conditions of universal hospitality.” Commerce depends upon this freedom of international intercourse, and on commerce mainly depends our hope of peace.

    [70] See p. 137. The main principle involved in this passage
    comes from Vattel (op. cit., II. Ch. viii. §§ 104, 105: Ch. ix.
    §§ 123, 125). A sovereign, he says, cannot object to a stranger
    entering his state who at the same time respects its laws. No one
    can be quite deprived of the right of way which has been handed
    down from the time when the whole earth was common to all men.

    (b) The first Definitive Article[71] requires that the constitution of every state should be republican. What Kant understands by this term is that, in the state, law should rule above force and that its constitution should be a representative one, guaranteeing public justice and based on the freedom and equality of its members and their mutual dependence on a common legislature. Kant’s demand is independent of the form of the government.

    A constitutional monarchy like that of Prussia in the time of Frederick the Great, who regarded himself as the first servant of the state and ruled with the wisdom and forethought which the nation would have had the right to demand from such an one—such a monarchy is not in contradiction to the idea of a true republic.

    That the state should have a constitution in accordance with the principles of right is the essential point.[72] To make this possible, the law-giving power must lie with the representatives of the people: there must be a complete separation, such as Locke and Rousseau demand, between the legislature and executive. Otherwise we have despotism. Hence, while Kant admitted absolutism under certain conditions, he rejected democracy where, in his opinion, the mass of the people was despot.

    [71] See p. 120.

    [72] Kant believed that, in the newly formed constitution of the
    United States, his ideal with regard to the external forms of
    the state as conforming to the spirit of justice was most nearly
    realised. Professor Paulsen draws attention, in the following
    passage, to the fact that Kant held the English government of
    the eighteenth century in very low esteem. (Kant, p. 357,
    note. See Eng. trans., p.

    352, note.) It was not the English
    state, he says, which furnished Kant with an illustration of
    his theory:—“Rather in it he sees a form of despotism only
    slightly veiled, not Parliamentary despotism, as some people
    have thought, but monarchical despotism. Through bribery of the
    Commons and the Press, the King had actually absolute power, as
    was evident, above all, from the fact that he had often waged war
    without, and in defiance of, the will of the people.

    Kant has
    a very unfavourable opinion of the English state in every way.
    Among the collected notes written by him in the last ten years
    of the century and published by Reicke (Lose Blätter, I. 129)
    the following appears:—‘The English nation (gens) regarded as
    a people (populus) and looked upon side by side with other
    races is, as a collection of individuals, of all mankind the
    most highly to be esteemed. But as a state, compared with other
    states, it is the most destructive, high-handed and tyrannical,
    and the most provocative of war among them all.’”

    Kuno Fischer (op. cit., Vol. V., I. Ch. 11, pp. 150, 151) to
    whom Professor Paulsen’s reference may here perhaps allude,
    states that Kant’s objection to the English constitution is that
    it was an oligarchy, Parliament being not only a legislative
    body, but through its ministers also executive in the interests
    of the ruling party or even of private individuals in that party.
    It seems more likely that what most offended a keen observer of
    the course of the American War of Independence was the arbitrary
    and ill-directed power of the king. But see the passage quoted
    by Fischer (pp. 152, 153) from the Rechtslehre (Part II.

    Sect.
    I.) which is, he says, unmistakeably directed against the English
    constitution and certain temporary conditions in the political
    history of the country.

    An internal constitution, firmly established on the principles of right, would not only serve to kill the seeds of national hatred and diminish the likelihood of foreign war. It would do more: it would destroy sources of revolution and discontent within the state. Kant, like many writers on this subject, does not directly allude to civil war[73] and the means by which it may be prevented or abolished.

    Actually to achieve this would be impossible: it is beyond the power of either arbitration or disarmament. But in a representative government and the liberty of a people lie the greatest safeguards against internal discontent. Civil peace and international peace must to a certain extent go hand in hand.

    [73] St. Pierre actually thought that his federation would
    prevent civil war. See Project (1714), p. 16.

    We come now to the central idea of the treatise: (c) the law of nations must be based upon a federation of free states. (Art. 2.)[74] This must be regarded as the end to which mankind is advancing. The problem here is not out of many nations to make one. This would be perhaps the surest way to attain peace, but it is scarcely practicable, and, in certain forms, it is undesirable.

    Kant is inclined to approve of the separation of nations by language and religion, by historical and social tradition and physical boundaries: nature seems to condemn the idea of a universal monarchy.[75] The only footing on which a thorough-going, indubitable system of international law is in practice possible is that of the society of nations: not the world-republic[76] the Greeks dreamt of, but a federation of states.

    Such a union in the interests of perpetual peace between nations would be the “highest political good.” The relation of the federated states to one another and to the whole would be fixed by cosmopolitan law: the link of self-interest which would bind them would again be the spirit of commerce.

    [74] See p. 128.

    [75] This was the ideal of Dante. Cf. De Monarchia, Bk. I.
    54:—“We shall not find at any time except under the divine
    monarch Augustus, when a perfect monarchy existed, that the world
    was everywhere quiet.”

    Bluntschli (Theory of the State, I. Ch. ii., p.

    26 seq.)
    gives an admirable account of the different attempts made to
    realise a universal empire in the past—the Empire of Alexander
    the Great, based upon a plan of uniting the races of east and
    west; the Roman Empire which sought vainly to stamp its national
    character upon mankind; the Frankish Monarchy; the Holy Roman
    Empire which fell to pieces through the want of a central
    power strong enough to overcome the tendency to separation and
    nationalisation; and finally the attempt of Napoleon I., whose
    mistake was the same as that which wrecked the Roman Empire—a
    neglect of the strength of foreign national sentiment.

    [76] Reason requires a State of nations. This is the ideal,
    and Kant’s proposal of a federation of states is a practical
    substitute from which we may work to higher things. Kant, like
    Fichte, (Werke, VII. 467) strongly disapproves of a universal
    monarchy such as that of which Dante dreamed—a modern Roman
    Empire.

    The force of necessity, he says, will bring nations at
    last to become members of a cosmopolitan state, “or if such a
    state of universal peace proves (as has often been the case
    with too great states) a greater danger to freedom from another
    point of view, in that it introduces despotism of the most
    terrible kind, then this same necessity must compel the nations
    to enter a state which indeed has the form not of a cosmopolitan
    commonwealth under one sovereign, but of a federation
    regulated by legal principles determined by a common code of
    international law.” (Das mag in d. Theorie richtig sein,
    Werke, (Rosenkranz) VII., p.

    225). Cf. also Theory of Ethics,
    (Abbott), p. 341, note; Perpetual Peace, pp. 155, 156.

    This scheme of a perpetual peace had not escaped ridicule in the eighteenth century: the name of Kant protected it henceforth.

    The facts of history, even more conclusively than the voices of philosophers, soldiers and princes, show how great has been the progress of this idea in recent years. But it has not gained its present hold upon the popular mind without great and lasting opposition. Indeed we have here what must still be regarded as a controversial question. There have been, and are still, men who regard perpetual peace as a state of things as undesirable as it is unattainable. For such persons, war is a necessity of our civilisation: it is impossible that it should ever cease to exist.

    All that we can do, and there is no harm, nor any contradiction in the attempt, is to make wars shorter, fewer and more humane: the whole question, beyond this, is without practical significance.

    Others, on the other hand,—and these perhaps more thoughtful—regard war as hostile to culture, an evil of the worst kind, although a necessary evil. In peace, for them, lies the true ideal of humanity, although in any perfect form this cannot be realised in the near future. The extreme forms of these views are to be sought in what has been called in Germany “the philosophy of the barracks” which comes forward with a glorification of war for its own sake, and in the attitude of modern Peace Societies which denounce all war wholesale, without respect of causes or conditions.

    Hegel, Schiller and Moltke.

    Hegel, the greatest of the champions of war, would have nothing to do with Kant’s federation of nations formed in the interests of peace. The welfare of a state, he held, is its own highest law; and he refused to admit that this welfare was to be sought in an international peace. Hegel lived in an age when all power and order seemed to lie with the sword. Something of the charm of Napoleonism seems to hang over him.

    He does not go the length of writers like Joseph de Maistre, who see in war the finger of God or an arrangement for the survival of the fittest—a theory, as far as regards individuals, quite in contradiction with the real facts, which show that it is precisely the physically unfit whom war, as a method of extermination, cannot reach.

    But, like Schiller and Moltke, Hegel sees in war an educative instrument, developing virtues in a nation which could not be fully developed otherwise, (much as pain and suffering bring patience and resignation and other such qualities into play in the individual), and drawing the nation together, making each citizen conscious of his citizenship, as no other influence can.

    War, he holds, leaves a nation always stronger than it was before; it buries causes of inner dissension, and consolidates the internal power of the state.[77] No other trial can, in the same way, show what is the real strength and weakness of a nation, what it is, not merely materially, but physically, intellectually and morally.

    [77] See the Philosophie d. Rechts, (Werke, Vol. VIII.) Part
    iii. § 324 and appendix.

    With this last statement most people will be inclined to agree. There is only a part of the truth in Napoleon’s dictum that “God is on the side of the biggest battalions”; or in the old saying that war requires three necessaries—in the first place, money; in the second place, money; and in the third, money. Money is a great deal: it is a necessity; but what we call national back-bone and character is more.

    So far we are with Hegel. But he goes further. In peace, says he, mankind would grow effeminate and degenerate in luxury. This opinion was expressed in forcible language in his own time by Schiller,[78] and in more recent years by Count Moltke. “Perpetual peace,” says a letter of the great general,[79] “is a dream and not a beautiful dream either: war is part of the divine order of the world.

    During war are developed the noblest virtues which belong to man—courage and self-denial, fidelity to duty and the spirit of self-sacrifice: the soldier is called upon to risk his life.

    Without war the world would sink in materialism.”[80] “Want and misery, disease, suffering and war,” he says elsewhere, “are all given elements in the Divine order of the universe.” Moltke’s eulogy of war, however, is somewhat modified by his additional statement that “the greatest kindness in war lies in its being quickly ended.” (Letter to Bluntschli, 11th Dec., 1880.)[81] The great forces which we recognise as factors in the moral regeneration of mankind are always slow of action as they are sure.

    War, if too quickly over, could not have the great moral influence which has been attributed to it. The explanation may be that it is not all that it naturally appears to a great and successful general.

    Hegel, Moltke, Trendelenburg, Treitschke[82] and the others—not Schiller[83] who was able to sing the blessings of peace as eloquently as of war—were apt to forget that war is as efficient a school for forming vices as virtues; and that, moreover, those virtues which military life is said to cultivate—courage, self-sacrifice and the rest—can be at least as perfectly developed in other trials.

    There are in human life dangers every day bravely met and overcome which are not less terrible than those which face the soldier, in whom patriotism may be less a sentiment than a duty, and whose cowardice must be dearly paid.

    [78] Cf. Die Braut von Messina:—

    “Denn der Mensch verkümmert im Frieden,
    Müssige Ruh’ ist das Grab des Muths.
    Das Gesetz ist der Freund des Schwachen,
    Alles will es nur eben machen,
    Möchte gerne die Welt verflachen;
    Aber der Krieg lässt die Kraft erscheinen,
    Alles erhebt er zum Ungemeinen,
    Selber dem Feigen erzeugt er den Muth.”

    This passage perhaps scarcely gives a fair representation of
    Schiller’s views on the question, which, if we judge from
    Wilhelm Tell, must have been very moderate. War, he says, in
    this oft-quoted passage, is sometimes a necessity. There is
    a limit to the power of tyranny and, when the burden becomes
    unbearable, an appeal to Heaven and the sword.

    Wilhelm Tell: Act. II. Sc. 2.

    “Nein, eine Grenze hat Tyrannenmacht.
    Wenn der Gedrückte nirgends Recht kann finden,
    Wenn unerträglich wird die Last greift er
    Hinauf getrosten Muthes in den Himmel
    Und holt herunter seine ew’gen Rechte,
    Die droben hangen unveräusserlich
    Und unzerbrechlich, wie die Sterne selbst—
    Der alte Urstand der Natur kehrt wieder,
    Wo Mensch dem Menschen gegenüber steht—
    Zum letzten Mittel, wenn kein andres mehr
    Verfangen will, ist ihm das Schwert gegeben.”

    [79] Letter to Bluntschli, dated Berlin, 11th Dec., 1880
    (published in Bluntschli’s Gesammelte Kleine Schriften, Vol.
    II., p. 271).

    [80] Cf. Tennyson’s Maud: Part I., vi. and xiii.

    “Why do they prate of the blessings of Peace? we have made them a curse,
    Pickpockets, each hand lusting for all that is not its own;
    And lust of gain, in the spirit of Cain, is it better or worse
    Than the heart of the citizen hissing in war on his own hearthstone?
    For I trust if an enemy’s fleet came yonder round by the hill,
    And the rushing battle-bolt sang from the three-decker out of the foam,
    That the smooth-faced snub-nosed rogue would leap from his counter and till,
    And strike, if he could, were it but with his cheating yardwand, home.”

    See too Part III., ii. and iv.

    “And it was but a dream, yet it lighten’d my despair
    When I thought that a war would arise in defence of the right,
    That an iron tyranny now should bend or cease,
    The glory of manhood stand on his ancient height,
    Nor Britain’s one sole God be the millionaire:
    No more shall commerce be all in all, and Peace
    Pipe on her pastoral hillock a languid note,
    And watch her harvest ripen, her herd increase,
    Nor the cannon-bullet rest on a slothful shore,
    And the cobweb woven across the cannon’s throat
    Shall shake its threaded tears in the wind no more.

    Let it go or stay, so I wake to the higher aims
    Of a land that has lost for a little her lust of gold,
    And love of a peace that was full of wrongs and shames,
    Horrible, hateful, monstrous, not to be told;
    And hail once more to the banner of battle unroll’d!
    Tho’ many a light shall darken, and many shall weep
    For those that are crush’d in the clash of jarring claims,
    For God’s just wrath shall be wreak’d on a giant liar;
    And many a darkness into the light shall leap,
    And shine in the sudden making of splendid names,
    And noble thought be freer under the sun,
    And the heart of a people beat with one desire.”

    [81] Moltke strangely enough was, at an earlier period, of the
    opinion that war, even when it is successful, is a national
    misfortune. Cf. Kehrbach’s preface to Kant’s essay, Zum Ewigen
    Frieden
    , p. XVII.

    [82] See his discussion on constitutional monarchy in Germany.
    (Hist. u. Pol. Aufsätze, Bd. III., p. 533 seq.)

    [83] See Die Piccolomini: Act. I. Sc. 4.

    War under Altered Conditions.

    The Peace Societies of our century, untiring supporters of a point of view diametrically opposite to that of Hegel, owe their existence in the first place to new ideas on the subject of the relative advantages and disadvantages of war, which again were partly due to changes in the character of war itself, partly to a new theory that the warfare of the future should be a war of free competition for industrial interests, or, in Herbert Spencer’s language, that the warlike type of mankind should make room for an industrial type.

    This theory, amounting in the minds of some thinkers to a fervid conviction, and itself, in a sense, the source of what has been contemptuously styled our British “shopkeeper’s policy” in Europe, was based on something more solid than mere enthusiasm. The years of peace which followed the downfall of Napoleon had brought immense increase in material wealth to countries like France and Britain.

    Something of the glamour had fallen away from the sword of the great Emperor. The illusive excitement of a desire for conquest had died: the glory of war had faded with it, but the burden still remained: its cost was still there, something to be calmly reckoned up and not soon to be forgotten. Europe was seen to be actually moving towards ruin. “We shall have to get rid of war in all civilised countries,” said Louis Philippe in 1843. “Soon no nation will be able to afford it.” War was not only becoming more costly.

    New conditions had altered it in other directions. With the development of technical science and its application to the perfecting of methods and instruments of destruction every new war was found to be bloodier than the last; and the day seemed to be in sight, when this very development would make war (with instruments of extermination) impossible altogether. The romance and picturesqueness with which it was invested in the days of hand-to-hand combat was gone.

    But, above all, war was now waged for questions fewer and more important than in the time of Kant. Napoleon’s successful appeal to the masses had suggested to Prussia the idea of consciously nationalising the army. Our modern national wars exact a sacrifice, necessarily much more heavy, much more reluctantly made than those of the past which were fought with mercenary troops.

    Such wars have not only greater dignity: they are more earnest, and their issue, as in a sense the issue of conflict between higher and lower types of civilisation, is speedier and more decisive.

    In the hundred years since Kant’s death, much that he prophesied has come to pass, although sometimes by different paths than he anticipated. The strides made in recent years by commerce and the growing power of the people in every state have had much of the influence which he foretold. There is a greater reluctance to wage war.[84] But, unfortunately, as Professor Paulsen points out, the progress of democracy and the nationalisation of war have not worked merely in the direction of progress towards peace. War has now become popular for the first time.

    “The progress of democracy in states,” he says, (Kant, p. 364[85]) “has not only not done away with war, but has very greatly changed the feeling of people towards it. With the universal military service, introduced by the Revolution, war has become the people’s affair and popular, as it could not be in the case of dynastic wars carried on with mercenary troops.” In the people the love of peace is strong, but so too is the love of a fight, the love of victory.

    [84] An admirable short account of popular feeling on this matter
    is to be found in Lawrence’s Principles of International Law, §
    240.

    [85] The first Peace Society was founded in London in 1816, and
    the first International Peace Congress held in 1843.

    It is in the contemplation of facts and conflicting tendencies like these that Peace Societies[86] have been formed. The peace party is, we may say, an eclectic body: it embraces many different sections of political opinion. There are those who hold, for instance, that peace is to be established on a basis of communism of property.

    There are others who insist on the establishment throughout Europe of a republican form of government, or again, on a redistribution of European territory in which Alsace-Lorraine is restored to France—changes of which at least the last two would be difficult to carry out, unless through international warfare. But these are not the fundamental general principles of peace workers. The members of this party agree in rejecting the principle of intervention, in demanding a complete or partial disarmament of the nations of Europe, and in requiring that all disputes between nations—and they admit the prospects of dispute—should be settled by means of arbitration.

    In how far are these principles useful or practicable?

    [86] In Eng. trans. see p. 358.

    The Value of Arbitration.

    There is a strong feeling in favour of arbitration on the part of all classes of society. It is cheaper under all circumstances than war.

    It is a judgment at once more certain and more complete, excluding as far as possible the element of chance, leaving irritation perhaps behind it, but none of the lasting bitterness which is the legacy of every war. Arbitration has an important place in all peace projects except that of Kant, whose federal union would naturally fulfil the function of a tribunal of arbitration. St.

    Pierre, Jeremy Bentham,[87] Bluntschli[88] the German publicist, Professor Lorimer[89] and others among political writers,[90] and among rulers, Louis Napoleon and the Emperor Alexander I. of Russia, have all made proposals more or less ineffectual for the peaceful settlement of international disputes. A number of cases have already been decided by this means. But let us examine the questions which have been at issue.

    Of a hundred and thirty matters of dispute settled by arbitration since 1815 (cf. International Tribunals, published by the Peace Society, 1899) it will be seen that all, with the exception of one or two trifling cases of doubt as to the succession to certain titles or principalities, can be classified roughly under two heads—disputes as to the determination of boundaries or the possession of certain territory, and questions of claims for compensation and indemnities due either to individuals or states, arising from the seizure of fleets or merchant vessels, the insult or injury to private persons and so on—briefly, questions of money or of territory.

    These may fairly be said to be trifling causes, not touching national honour or great political questions. That they should have been settled in this way, however, shows a great advance.

    Smaller causes than these have made some of the bloodiest wars in history. That arbitration should have been the means of preventing even one war which would otherwise have been waged is a strong reason why we should fully examine its claims.

    “Quand l’institution d’une haute cour,” writes Laveleye, (Des causes actuelles de guerre en Europe et de l’arbitrage) “n’éviterait qu’une guerre sur vingt, il vaudrait encore la peine de l’établir.” But history shows us that there is no single instance of a supreme conflict having been settled otherwise than by war.

    Arbitration is a method admirably adapted to certain cases: to those we have named, where it has been successfully applied, to the interpretation of contracts, to offences against the Law of Nations—some writers say to trivial questions of honour—in all cases where the use of armed force would be impossible, as, for instance, in any quarrel in which neutralised countries[91] like Belgium or Luxembourg should take a principal part, or in a difference between two nations, such as (to take an extreme case) the United States and Switzerland, which could not easily engage in actual combat.

    These cases, which we cannot too carefully examine, show that what is here essential is that it should be possible to formulate a juridical statement of the conflicting claims. In Germany the Bundestag had only power to decide questions of law. Other disputes were left to be fought out. Questions on which the existence and vital honour of a state depend—any question which nearly concerns the disputants—cannot be reduced to any cut and dry legal formula of right and wrong.

    We may pass over the consideration that in some cases (as in the Franco-Prussian War) the delay caused by seeking mediation of any kind would deprive a nation of the advantage its state of military preparation deserved. And we may neglect the problem of finding an impartial judge on some questions of dispute, although its solution might be a matter of extreme difficulty, so closely are the interests of modern nations bound up in one another. How could the Eastern Question, for example, be settled by arbitration?

    It is impossible that such a means should be sufficient for every case. Arbitration in other words may prevent war, but can never be a substitute for war. We cannot wonder that this is so. So numerous and conflicting are the interests of states, so various are the grades of civilisation to which they have attained and the directions along which they are developing, that differences of the most vital kind are bound to occur and these can never be settled by any peaceful means at present known to Europe.

    This is above all true where the self-preservation[92] or independence of a people are concerned. Here the “good-will” of the nations who disagree would necessarily be wanting: there could be no question of the arbitration of an outsider.

    [87] See “A Plan for a Universal and Perpetual Peace” in the
    Principles of International Law (Works, Vol. II). One of
    the main principles advocated by Bentham in this essay (written
    between 1787 and 1789) is that every state should give up its
    colonies.

    [88] See his Kleine Schriften.

    [89] Institutes of the Law of Nations (1884), Vol. II., Ch. XIV.

    [90] John Stuart Mill holds that the multiplication of federal
    unions would be a benefit to the world. [See his Considerations
    on Representative Government
    (1865), Ch. XVII., where he
    discusses the conditions necessary to render such unions
    successful.] But the Peace Society is scarcely justified, on the
    strength of what is here, in including Mill among writers who
    have made definite proposals of peace or federation. (See Inter.
    Trib.
    )

    [91] See what Lawrence says (op. cit., § 241) of neutralisation
    and the limits of its usefulness as a remedy for war.

    [92] Montesquieu: Esprit des Lois, X. Ch. 2. “The life of
    governments is like that of man. The latter has a right to kill
    in case of natural defence: the former have a right to wage war
    for their own preservation.”

    See also Vattel (Law of Nations, II. Ch. XVIII. § 332):—“But
    if anyone would rob a nation of one of her essential rights, or
    a right without which she could not hope to support her national
    existence,—if an ambitious neighbour threatens the liberty of a
    republic, if he attempts to subjugate and enslave her,—she will
    take counsel only from her own courage. She will not even attempt
    the method of conferences, in the case of a contention so odious
    as this. She will, in such a quarrel, exert her utmost efforts,
    exhaust every resource and lavish her blood to the last drop if
    necessary.

    To listen to the slightest proposal in a matter of
    this kind is to risk everything.”

    But, indeed, looking away from questions so vital and on which there can be little difference of opinion, we are apt to forget, when we allow ourselves to talk extravagantly of the future of arbitration, that every nation thinks, or at least pretends to think, that it is in the right in every dispute in which it appears (cf. Kant: Perpetual Peace, p. 120.): and, as a matter of history, there has never been a conflict between civilised states in which an appeal to this “right” on the part of each has not been made.

    We talk glibly of the right and wrong of this question or of that, of the justice of this war, the iniquity of that. But what do these terms really mean? Do we know, in spite of the labour which has been spent on this question by the older publicists, which are the causes that justify a war? Is it not true that the same war might be just in one set of circumstances and unjust in another?

    Practically all writers on this subject, exclusive of those who apply the biblical doctrine of non-resistance, agree in admitting that a nation is justified in defending its own existence or independence, that this is even a moral duty as it is a fundamental right of a state. Many, especially the older writers, make the confident assertion that all wars of defence are just. But will this serve as a standard? Gibbon tells us somewhere, that Livy asserts that the Romans conquered the world in self-defence.

    The distinction between wars of aggression and defence is one very difficult to draw. The cause of a nation which waits to be actually attacked is often lost: the critical moment in its defence may be past. The essence of a state’s defensive power may lie in a readiness to strike the first blow, or its whole interests may be bound up in the necessity of fighting the matter out in its enemy’s country, rather than at home.

    It is not in the strictly military interpretation of the term “defensive”, but in its wider ethical and political sense that we can speak of wars of defence as just. But, indeed, we cannot judge these questions abstractly. Where a war is necessary, it matters very little whether it is just or not.

    Only the judgment of history can finally decide; and generally it seems at the time that both parties have something of right on their side, something perhaps too of wrong.[93]

    [93] The difficulties in the way of hard and fast judgments on a
    complicated problem of this kind are convincingly demonstrated in
    a recent essay by Professor D. G. Ritchie (Studies in Political
    and Social Ethics
    , Sonnenschein, 1902).

    Professor Ritchie
    considers in detail a number of concrete cases which occurred
    in the century between 1770 and 1870. “Let any one take the
    judgments he would pass on these or any similarly varied cases,
    and I think he will find that we do not restrict our approval
    to wars of self-defence, that we do not approve self-defence
    under all circumstances, that there are some cases in which we
    approve of absorption of smaller states by larger, that there
    are cases in which we excuse intervention of third parties in
    quarrels with which at first they had nothing to do, and that
    we sometimes approve war even when begun without the authority
    of any already existing sovereign.

    Can any principles be found
    underlying such judgments? In the first place we ought not to
    disguise from ourselves the fact that our judgments after the
    result are based largely on success. ... I think it will be
    found that our judgments on the wars of the century from 1770 to
    1870 turn very largely on the question, Which of the conflicting
    forces was making for constitutional government and for social
    progress? or, to put it in wider terms, Which represented the
    higher civilisation? And thus it is that we may sometimes approve
    the rise of a new state and sometimes the absorption of an old.”
    (Op. cit., pp. 152, 155.)

    A consideration of difficulties like these brings us to a realisation of the fact that the chances are small that a nation, in the heat of a dispute, will admit the likelihood of its being in the wrong. To refuse to admit this is generally tantamount to a refusal to submit the difficulty to arbitration. And neither international law, nor the moral force of public opinion can induce a state to act contrary to what it believes to be its own interest. Moreover, as international law now stands, it is not a duty to have recourse to arbitration.

    This was made quite clear in the proceedings of the Peace Conference at the Hague in 1899.[94] It was strongly recommended that arbitration should be sought wherever it was possible, but, at the same time definitely stated, that this course could in no case be compulsory. In this respect things have not advanced beyond the position of the Paris Congress of 1856.[95] The wars waged in Europe subsequent to that date, have all been begun without previous attempt at mediation.

    [94] See Fred. W. Holls: The Peace Conference at the Hague,
    Macmillan, 1900.

    [95] The feeling of the Congress expressed itself thus
    cautiously:—“Messieurs les plénipotentiaires n’hésitent pas à
    exprimer, au nom de leur gouvernements, le voeu, que les Etats
    entre lesquels s’éléverait un dissentiment sérieux, avant d’en
    appeler aux armes, eussent recours, en tant que les circonstances
    l’admettraient, aux bons offices d’une puissance amie.”

    But the work of the peace party regarding the humaner methods of settlement is not to be neglected. The popular feeling which they have been partly the means of stimulating has no doubt done something to influence the action of statesmen towards extreme caution in the treatment of questions likely to arouse national passions and prejudices. Arbitration has undoubtedly made headway in recent years.

    Britain and America, the two nations whose names naturally suggest themselves to us as future centres of federative union, both countries whose industrial interests are numerous and complicated, have most readily, as they have most frequently, settled disputes in this practical manner. It has shown itself to be a policy as economical as it is business-like. Its value, in its proper place, cannot be overrated by any Peace Congress or by any peace pamphlet; but we have endeavoured to make it clear that this sphere is but a limited one.

    The “good-will” may not be there when it ought perhaps to appear: it will certainly not be there when any vital interest is at stake. But, even if this were not so and arbitration were the natural sequence of every dispute, no coercive force exists to enforce the decree of the court. The moral restraint of public opinion is here a poor substitute. Treaties, it is often said, are in the same position; but treaties have been broken, and will no doubt be broken again.

    We are moved to the conclusion that a thoroughly logical peace programme cannot stop short of the principle of federation. Federal troops are necessary to carry out the decrees of a tribunal of arbitration, if that court is not to run a risk of being held feeble and ineffectual. Except on some such basis, arbitration, as a substitute for war, stands on but a weak footing.

    Disarmament.

    The efforts of the Peace Society are directed with even less hope of complete success against another evil of our time, the crushing burden of modern armaments. We have peace at this moment, but at a daily increasing cost. The Peace Society is rightly concerned in pressing this point. It is not enough to keep off actual war: there is a limit to the price we can afford to pay even for peace.

    Probably no principle has cost Europe so much in the last century as that handed down from Rome:—“Si vis pacem, para bellum.” It is now a hundred and fifty years since Montesquieu[96] protested against this “new distemper” which was spreading itself over Europe; but never, in time of peace, has complaint been so loud or so general as now: and this, not only against the universal burden of taxation which weighs upon all nations alike, but, in continental countries, against the waste of productive force due to compulsory military service, a discontent which seems to strike at the very foundations of society.

    Vattel relates that in early times a treaty of peace generally stipulated that both parties should afterwards disarm. And there is no doubt that Kant was right in regarding standing armies as a danger to peace, not only as openly expressing the rivalry and distrust between nation and nation which Hobbes regards as the basis of international relations, but also as putting a power into the hand of a nation which it may some day have the temptation to abuse.

    A war-loving, overbearing spirit in a people thrives none the worse for a consciousness that its army or navy can hold its own with any other in Europe. Were it not the case that the essence of armed peace is that a high state of efficiency should be general, the danger to peace would be very great indeed. No doubt it is due to this fact that France has kept quietly to her side of the Rhine during the last thirty years. The annexation of Alsace-Lorraine was an immediate stimulus to the increase of armaments; but otherwise, just because of this greater efficiency and the slightly stronger military position of Germany, it has been an influence on the side of peace.

    [96] Esprit des Lois, XIII. Chap. 17. “A new distemper has
    spread itself over Europe: it has infected our princes, and
    induces them to keep up an exorbitant number of troops. It has
    its redoublings, and of necessity becomes contagious. For as
    soon as one prince augments what he calls his troops, the rest
    of course do the same: so that nothing is gained thereby but the
    public ruin. Each monarch keeps as many armies on foot as if his
    people were in danger of being exterminated: and they give the
    name of Peace to this general effort of all against all.”

    Montesquieu is of course writing in the days of mercenary troops;
    but the cost to the nation of our modern armies, both in time of
    peace and of war, is incomparably greater.

    The Czar’s Rescript of 1898 gave a new stimulus to an interest in this question which the subsequent conference at the Hague was unable fully to satisfy. We are compelled to consider carefully how a process of simultaneous disarmament can actually be carried out, and what results might be anticipated from this step, with a view not only to the present but the future. Can this be done in accordance with the principles of justice? Organisations like a great navy or a highly disciplined army have been built up, in the course of centuries, at great cost and at much sacrifice to the nation.

    They are the fruit of years of wise government and a high record of national industry. Are such visible tokens of the culture and character and worth of a people to be swept away and Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Turkey to stand on the same level? And, even if no such ethical considerations should arise, on what method are we to proceed? The standard as well as the nature of armament depends in every state on its geographical conditions and its historical position.

    An ocean-bound empire like Britain is comparatively immune from the danger of invasion: her army can be safely despatched to the colonies, her fleet protects her at home, her position is one of natural defence. But Germany and Austria find themselves in exactly opposite circumstances, with the hard necessity imposed upon them of guarding their frontiers on every side. The safety of a nation like Germany is in the hands of its army: its military strength lies in an almost perfect mastery of the science of attack.

    The Peace Society has hitherto made no attempt to face the difficulties inseparable from any attempt to apply a uniform method of treatment to peculiarities and conditions so conflicting and various as these. Those who have been more conscientious have not been very successful in solving them. Indeed, so constantly is military technique changing that it is difficult to prophesy wherein will lie, a few years hence, the essence of a state’s defensive power or what part the modern navy will play in this defence.

    No careful thinker would suggest, in the face of dangers threatening from the East,[97] a complete disarmament. The simplest of many suggestions made—but this on the basis of universal conscription—seems to be that the number of years or months of compulsory military service should be reduced to some fixed period. But this does not touch the difficulty of colonial empires[98] like Britain which might to a certain extent disarm, like their neighbours, in Europe, but would be compelled to keep an army for the defence of their colonies elsewhere.

    It is, in the meantime, inevitable that Europe should keep up a high standard of armament—this is, (and even if we had European federation, would remain) an absolute necessity as a protection against the yellow races, and in Europe itself there are at present elements hostile to the cause of peace. Alsace-Lorraine, Polish Prussia, Russian Poland and Finland are still, to a considerable degree, sources of discontent and dissatisfaction.

    But in Russia itself lies the great obstacle to a future European peace or European federation: we can scarcely picture Russia as a reliable member of such a union. That Russia should disarm is scarcely feasible, in view of its own interest: it has always to face the danger of rebellion in Poland and anarchy at home.

    But that Europe should disarm, before Russia has attained a higher civilisation, a consciousness of its great future as a north-eastern, inter-oceanic empire, and a government more favourable to the diffusion of liberty, is still less practicable.[99] We have here to fall back upon federation again. It is not impossible that, in the course of time, this problem may be solved and that the contribution to the federal troops of a European union may be regulated upon some equitable basis the form of which we cannot now well prophesy.

    [97] Even St. Pierre was alive to this danger (Projet,
    Art. VIII: in the English translation of 1714, p. 160):—“The
    European Union shall endeavour to obtain in Asia, a
    permanent society like that of Europe, that Peace may be
    maintain’d There also; and especially that it may have no cause
    to fear any Asiatic Sovereign, either as to its tranquillity,
    or its Commerce in Asia.”

    [98] Bentham’s suggestion would be useful here! See above, p. 79,
    note.

    [99] The best thing for Europe might be that Russia (perhaps
    including China) should be regarded as a serious danger by all
    the civilised powers of the West. That would bring us nearer to
    the United States of Europe and America (for the United States,
    America, is Russia’s neighbour on the East) than anything else.

    European federation would likewise meet all difficulties where a risk might be likely to occur of one nation intervening to protect another. As we have said (above, p. 64, note) nations are now-a-days slow to intervene in the interests of humanity: they are in general constrained to do so only by strong motives of self-interest, and when these are not at hand they are said to refrain from respect for another’s right of independent action.

    Actually a state which is actuated by less selfish impulses is apt to lose considerably more than it gains, and the feeling of the people expresses itself strongly against any quixotic or sentimental policy.

    It is not impossible that the Powers may have yet to intervene to protect Turkey against Russia. Such a step might well be dictated purely by a proper care for the security of Europe; but wars of this kind seem not likely to play an important part in the near future.

    We have said that the causes of difference which may be expected to disturb the peace of Europe are now fewer. A modern sovereign no longer spends his leisure time in the excitement of slaying or seeing slain. He could not, if he would. His honour and his vanity are protected by other means: they play no longer an important part in the affairs of nations. The causes of war can no more be either trifling or personal. Some crises there are, which are ever likely to be fatal to peace. There present themselves, in the lives of nations, ideal ends for which everything must be sacrificed: there are rights which must at all cost be defended.

    The question of civil war we may neglect: liberty and wise government are the only medicine for social discontent, and much may be hoped from that in the future.

    But now, looking beyond the state to the great family of civilised nations, we may say that the one certain cause of war between them or of rebellion within a future federated union will be a menace to the sovereign rights, the independence and existence of any member of that federation. Other causes of quarrel offer a more hopeful prospect. Some questions have been seen to be specially fitted for the legal procedure of a tribunal of arbitration, others to be such as a federal court would quickly settle.

    The preservation of the balance of power which Frederick the Great regarded as the talisman of peace in Europe—a judgment surely not borne out by experience—is happily one of the causes of war which are of the past. Wars of colonisation, such as would be an attempt on the part of Russia to conquer India, seem scarcely likely to recur except between higher and lower races. The cost is now-a-days too great.

    Political wars, wars for national union and unity, of which there were so many during the past century, seem at present not to be near at hand; and the integration of European nations—what may be called the great mission of war—is, for the moment, practically complete; for it is highly improbable that either Alsace-Lorraine or Poland—still less Finland—will be the cause of a war of this kind.

    Our hope lies in a federated Europe. Its troops would serve to preserve law and order in the country from which they were drawn and to protect its colonies abroad; but their higher function would be to keep peace in Europe, to protect the weaker members of the Federation and to enforce the decision of the majority, either, if necessary, by actual war, or by the mere threatening demonstrations of fleets, such as have before proved effectual.

    We have carefully considered what has been attempted by peace workers, and we have now to take note that all the results of the last fifty years are not to be attributed to their conscientious but often ill-directed labour. The diminution of the causes of war is to be traced less to the efforts of the Peace Society, (except indirectly, in so far as they have influenced the minds of the masses) than to the increasing power of the people themselves.

    The various classes of society are opposed to violent methods of settlement, not in the main from a conviction as to the wrongfulness of war or from any fanatical enthusiasm for a brotherhood of nations, but from self-interest. War is death to the industrial interests of a nation.

    It is vain to talk, in the language of past centuries, of trade between civilised countries being advanced and markets opened up or enlarged by this means.[100] Kings give up the dream of military glory and accept instead the certainty of peaceful labour and industrial progress, and all this (for we may believe that to some monarchs it is much) from no enthusiastic appreciation of the efforts of Peace Societies, from no careful examination of the New Testament nor inspired interpretation of its teaching. It is self-interest, the prosperity of the country—patriotism, if you will—that seems better than war.

    [100] Trade in barbarous or savage countries is still increased
    by war, especially on the French and German plan which leaves no
    open door to other nations. Here the trade follows the flag. And
    war, of course, among civilised races causes small nations to
    disappear and their tariffs with them. This is beneficial to
    trade, but to a degree so trifling that it may here be neglected.

    What may be expected from Federation.

    Federation and federation alone can help out the programme of the Peace Society. It cannot be pretended that it will do everything. To state the worst at once, it will not prevent war.

    Even the federations of the states of Germany and America, bound together by ties of blood and language and, in the latter case, of sentiment, were not strong enough within to keep out dissension and disunion.[101] Wars would not cease, but they would become much less frequent. “Why is there no longer war between England and Scotland?

    Why did Prussian and Hanoverian fight side by side in 1870, though they had fought against each other only four years before?... If we wish to know how war is to cease, we should ask ourselves how it has ceased” (Professor D. G. Ritchie, op. cit., p. 169). Wars between different grades of civilisation are bound to exist as long as civilisation itself exists. The history of culture and of progress has been more or less a history of war.

    A calm acceptance of this position may mean to certain short-sighted, enthusiastic theorists an impossible sacrifice of the ideal; but, the sacrifice once made, we stand on a better footing with regard to at least one class of arguments against a federation of the world.

    Such a union will lead, it is said, to an equality in culture, a sameness of interests fatal to progress; all struggle and conflict will be cast out of the state itself; national characteristics and individuality will be obliterated; the lamb and the wolf will lie down together: stagnation will result, intellectual progress will be at an end, politics will be no more, history will stand still. This is a sweeping assertion, an alarming prophecy. But a little thought will assure us that there is small cause for apprehension.

    There can be no such standstill, no millennium in human affairs. A gradual smoothing down of sharply accentuated national characteristics there might be: this is a result which a freer, more friendly intercourse between nations would be very likely to produce.

    But conflicting interests, keen rivalry in their pursuit, difference of culture and natural aptitude, and all or much of the individuality which language and literature, historical and religious traditions, even climatic and physical conditions produce are bound to survive until the coming of some more overwhelming and far-spreading revolution than this.

    It would not be well if it were otherwise, if those “unconscious and invisible peculiarities” in which Fichte sees the hand of God and the guarantee of a nation’s future dignity, virtue and merit should be swept away. (Reden an die deutsche Nation,[102] 1807.) Nor is stagnation to be feared. “Strife,” said the old philosopher, “is the father of all things.” There can be no lasting peace in the processes of nature and existence.

    It has been in the constant rivalry between classes within themselves, and in the struggle for existence with other races that great nations have reached the highwater mark of their development.

    A perpetual peace in international relations we may—nay, surely will—one day have, but eternity will not see the end to the feverish unrest within the state and the jealous competition and distrust between individuals, groups and classes of society. Here there must ever be perpetual war.

    [101] Cf. also the civil war of 1847 in Switzerland.

    [102] See Werke, VII., p. 467.

    It was only of this political peace between civilised nations that Kant thought.[103] In this form it is bound to come. The federation of Europe will follow the federation of Germany and of Italy, not only because it offers a solution of many problems which have long taxed Europe, but because great men and careful thinkers believe in it.[104] It may not come quickly, but such men can afford to wait. “If I were legislator,” cried Jean Jacques Rousseau, “I should not say what ought to be done, but I would do it.” This is the attitude of the unthinking, unpractical enthusiast. The wish is not enough: the will is not enough.

    The mills of God must take their own time: no hope or faith of ours, no struggle or labour even can hurry them.

    [103] The other he knew was impossible. Peace within the state
    meant decay and death. In the antagonism of nations, he saw
    nature’s means of educating the race: it was a law of existence,
    a law of progress, and, as such, eternal.

    [104] For a vivid picture of the material advantages offered by
    such a union and of the dismal future that may lie before an
    unfederated Europe, we cannot do better than read Mr. Andrew
    Carnegie’s recent Rectorial Address to the students of St.
    Andrews University (Oct 1902). Unfortunately, Mr. Carnegie’s
    enthusiasm stops here: he does not tell us by what means the
    difficulties at present in the way of a federation, industrial or
    political, are to be overcome.

    It is a misfortune that the Peace Society has identified itself with so narrow and uncritical an attitude towards war, and that the copious eloquence of its members is not based upon a consideration of the practical difficulties of the case. This well-meaning, hard working and enthusiastic body would like to do what is impossible by an impossible method. The end which it sets for itself is an unattainable one. But this need not be so.

    To make unjustifiable aggression difficult, to banish unworthy pretexts for making war might be a high enough ideal for any enthusiasm and offer scope wide enough for the labours of any society. But the Peace Society has not contented itself with this great work. Through its over-estimation of the value of peace,[105] its cause has been injured and much of its influence has been weakened or lost.

    Our age is one which sets a high value upon human life; and to this change of thinking may be traced our modern reform in the methods of war and all that has been done for the alleviation of suffering by the great Conventions of recent years. For the eyes of most people war is merely a hideous spectacle of bloodshed and deliberate destruction of life: this is its obvious side. But it is possible to exaggerate this confessedly great evil.

    Peace has its sacrifices as well as war: the progress of humanity requires that the individual should often be put aside for the sake of lasting advantage to the whole. An opposite view can only be reckoned individualistic, perhaps materialistic. “The reverence for human life,” says Martineau, (Studies of Christianity, pp. 352,

    1. “is carried to an immoral idolatry, when it is held more sacred

    than justice and right, and when the spectacle of blood becomes more horrible than the sight of desolating tyrannies and triumphant hypocrisies.... We have, therefore, no more doubt that a war may be right, than that a policeman may be a security for justice, and we object to a fortress as little as to a handcuff.”

    [105] Professor D. G. Ritchie remarks that it is less an
    over-estimation of the value of peace than a too easy-going
    acceptance of abstract and unanalysed phrases about the rights of
    nations that injures the work of the Peace Society. Cf. his note
    on the principles of the Peace Congresses (op. cit., p. 172).

    The Peace Society are not of this opinion: they greatly doubt that a war may be right, and they rarely fail to take their doubts to the tribunal of Scripture. Their efforts are well meant, this piety may be genuine enough; but a text is rarely a proof of anything, and in any case serves one man in as good stead as another. We remember that “the devil can cite Scripture for his purpose.” This unscientific method of proof or persuasion has ever been widely popular.

    It is a serious examination of the question that we want, a more careful study of its actual history and of the possibilities of human nature; less vague, exaggerated language about what ought to be done, and a realisation of what has been actually achieved; above all, a clear perception of what may fairly be asked from the future.

    It used to be said—is perhaps asserted still by the war-lovers—that there was no path to civilisation which had not been beaten by the force of arms, no height to which the sword had not led the way. The inspiration of war was upon the great arts of civilisation: its hand was upon the greatest of the sciences. These obligations extended even to commerce. War not only created new branches of industry, it opened new markets and enlarged the old. These are great claims, according to which war might be called the moving principle of history. If we keep our eyes fixed upon the history of the past, they seem not only plausible: they are in a great sense true.

    Progress did tread at the heels of the great Alexander’s army: the advance of European culture stands in the closest connection with the Crusades.

    But was this happy compensation for a miserable state of affairs not due to the peculiarly unsocial conditions of early times and the absence of every facility for the interchange of ideas or material advantages? It is inconceivable that now-a-days[106] any aid to the development of thought in Europe should come from war. The old adage, in more than a literal sense, has but too often been proved true:—“Inter arma, Musae silent.” Peace is for us the real promoter of culture.

    [106] The day is past, when a nation could enjoy the exclusive
    advantages of its own inventions. Vattel naively recommends that
    we should keep the knowledge of certain kinds of trade, the
    building of war-ships and the like, to ourselves. Prudence, he
    says, prevents us from making an enemy stronger and the care of
    our own safety forbids it. (Law of Nations, II. Ch. I. § 16.)

    We have to endeavour to take an intermediate course between uncritical praise and wholesale condemnation, between extravagant expectation and unjustifiable pessimism. War used to be the rule: it is now an overwhelming and terrible exception—an interruption to the peaceful prosperous course of things, inflicting unlimited suffering and temporary or lasting loss. Its evils are on the surface, apparent to the most unthinking observer.

    The day may yet dawn, when Europeans will have learned to regard the force of arms as an instrument for the civilisation of savage or half-savage races, and war within their continent as civil war, necessary and justifiable sometimes perhaps, but still a blot upon their civilisation and brotherhood as men. Such a suggestion rings strangely. But the great changes, which the roll of centuries has marked, once came upon the world not less unexpectedly.

    How far off must the idea of a civil peace have seemed to small towns and states of Europe in the fifteenth century! How strange, only a century ago, would the idea of applying steam power or electrical force have seemed to ourselves! Let us not despair. War has played a great part in the history of the world: it has been ever the great architect of nations, the true mother of cities. It has justified itself to-day in the union of kindred peoples, the making of great empires. It may be that one decisive war may yet be required to unite Europe.

    May Europe survive that struggle and go forward fearlessly to her great future! A peaceful future that may not be. It must never be forgotten that war is sometimes a moral duty, that it is ever the natural sequence of human passion and human prejudice. An unbroken peace we cannot and do not expect; but it is this that we must work for. As Kant says, we must keep it before us as an ideal.

    TRANSLATION[107]

    “PERPETUAL PEACE”[108]

    [107] The text used in this translation is that edited by
    Kehrbach. [Tr.]

    [108] I have seen something of M. de St. Pierre’s plan for
    maintaining perpetual peace in Europe. It reminds me of an
    inscription outside of a churchyard, which ran “Pax Perpetua.
    For the dead, it is true, fight no more. But the living are of
    another mind, and the mightiest among them have little respect
    for tribunals.” (Leibniz: Letter to Grimarest, quoted above, p.
    37, note 44.) [Tr.]

    We need not try to decide whether this satirical inscription, (once found on a Dutch innkeeper’s sign-board above the picture of a churchyard) is aimed at mankind in general, or at the rulers of states in particular, unwearying in their love of war, or perhaps only at the philosophers who cherish the sweet dream of perpetual peace. The author of the present sketch would make one stipulation, however.

    The practical politician stands upon a definite footing with the theorist: with great self-complacency he looks down upon him as a mere pedant whose empty ideas can threaten no danger to the state (starting as it does from principles derived from experience), and who may always be permitted to knock down his eleven skittles at once without a worldly-wise statesman needing to disturb himself.

    Hence, in the event of a quarrel arising between the two, the practical statesman must always act consistently, and not scent danger to the state behind opinions ventured by the theoretical politician at random and publicly expressed. With which saving clause (clausula salvatoria) the author will herewith consider himself duly and expressly protected against all malicious misinterpretation.

    FIRST SECTION

    CONTAINING THE PRELIMINARY ARTICLES OF PERPETUAL PEACE BETWEEN STATES

    1.—“No treaty of peace shall be regarded as valid, if made with the secret reservation of material for a future war.”

    For then it would be a mere truce, a mere suspension of hostilities, not peace. A peace signifies the end of all hostilities and to attach to it the epithet “eternal” is not only a verbal pleonasm, but matter of suspicion. The causes of a future war existing, although perhaps not yet known to the high contracting parties themselves, are entirely annihilated by the conclusion of peace, however acutely they may be ferreted out of documents in the public archives.

    There may be a mental reservation of old claims to be thought out at a future time, which are, none of them, mentioned at this stage, because both parties are too much exhausted to continue the war, while the evil intention remains of using the first favourable opportunity for further hostilities. Diplomacy of this kind only Jesuitical casuistry can justify: it is beneath the dignity of a ruler, just as acquiescence in such processes of reasoning is beneath the dignity of his minister, if one judges the facts as they really are.[109]

    [109] On the honourable interpretation of treaties, see Vattel
    (op. cit., II. Ch. XVII., esp. §§ 263-296, 291). See also what
    he says of the validity of treaties and the necessity for holding
    them sacred (II. Ch. XII. §§ 157, 158: II. Ch. XV). [Tr.]

    If, however, according to present enlightened ideas of political wisdom, the true glory of a state lies in the uninterrupted development of its power by every possible means, this judgment must certainly strike one as scholastic and pedantic.

    2.—“No state having an independent existence—whether it be great or small—shall be acquired by another through inheritance, exchange, purchase or donation.”[110]

    [110] “Even the smoothest way,” says Hume, (Of the Original
    Contract
    ) “by which a nation may receive a foreign master, by
    marriage or a will, is not extremely honourable for the people;
    but supposes them to be disposed of, like a dowry or a legacy,
    according to the pleasure or interest of their rulers.” [Tr.]

    For a state is not a property (patrimonium), as may be the ground on which its people are settled. It is a society of human beings over whom no one but itself has the right to rule and to dispose.

    Like the trunk of a tree, it has its own roots, and to graft it on to another state is to do away with its existence as a moral person, and to make of it a thing. Hence it is in contradiction to the idea of the original contract without which no right over a people is thinkable.[111] Everyone knows to what danger the bias in favour of these modes of acquisition has brought Europe (in other parts of the world it has never been known).

    The custom of marriage between states, as if they were individuals, has survived even up to the most recent times,[112] and is regarded partly as a new kind of industry by which ascendency may be acquired through family alliances, without any expenditure of strength; partly as a device for territorial expansion. Moreover, the hiring out of the troops of one state to another to fight against an enemy not at war with their native country is to be reckoned in this connection; for the subjects are in this way used and abused at will as personal property.

    [111] An hereditary kingdom is not a state which can be inherited
    by another state, but one whose sovereign power can be inherited
    by another physical person. The state then acquires a ruler, not
    the ruler as such (that is, as one already possessing another
    realm) the state.

    [112] This has been one of the causes of the extraordinary
    admixture of races in the modern Austrian empire. Cf. the lines
    of Matthias Corvinus of Hungary (quoted in Sir W. Stirling
    Maxwell’s Cloister Life of Charles the Fifth, Ch. I., note):—

    “Bella gerant alii, tu, felix Austria, nube!
    Nam quae Mars aliis, dat tibi regna Venus.” [Tr.]

    3.—“Standing armies (miles perpetuus) shall be abolished in course of time.”

    For they are always threatening other states with war by appearing to be in constant readiness to fight. They incite the various states to outrival one another in the number of their soldiers, and to this number no limit can be set. Now, since owing to the sums devoted to this purpose, peace at last becomes even more oppressive than a short war, these standing armies are themselves the cause of wars of aggression, undertaken in order to get rid of this burden.

    To which we must add that the practice of hiring men to kill or to be killed seems to imply a use of them as mere machines and instruments in the hand of another (namely, the state) which cannot easily be reconciled with the right of humanity in our own person.[113] The matter stands quite differently in the case of voluntary periodical military exercise on the part of citizens of the state, who thereby seek to secure themselves and their country against attack from without.

    [113] A Bulgarian Prince thus answered the Greek Emperor who
    magnanimously offered to settle a quarrel with him, not by
    shedding the blood of his subjects, but by a duel:—“A smith who
    has tongs will not take the red-hot iron from the fire with his
    hands.”

    (This note is a-wanting in the second Edition of 1796. It is
    repeated in Art. II., see p. 130.) [Tr.]

    The accumulation of treasure in a state would in the same way be regarded by other states as a menace of war, and might compel them to anticipate this by striking the first blow. For of the three forces, the power of arms, the power of alliance and the power of money, the last might well become the most reliable instrument of war, did not the difficulty of ascertaining the amount stand in the way.

    4.—“No national debts shall be contracted in connection with the external affairs of the state.”

    This source of help is above suspicion, where assistance is sought outside or within the state, on behalf of the economic administration of the country (for instance, the improvement of the roads, the settlement and support of new colonies, the establishment of granaries to provide against seasons of scarcity, and so on).

    But, as a common weapon used by the Powers against one another, a credit system under which debts go on indefinitely increasing and are yet always assured against immediate claims (because all the creditors do not put in their claim at once) is a dangerous money power.

    This ingenious invention of a commercial people in the present century is, in other words, a treasure for the carrying on of war which may exceed the treasures of all the other states taken together, and can only be exhausted by a threatening deficiency in the taxes—an event, however, which will long be kept off by the very briskness of commerce resulting from the reaction of this system on industry and trade.

    The ease, then, with which war may be waged, coupled with the inclination of rulers towards it—an inclination which seems to be implanted in human nature—is a great obstacle in the way of perpetual peace. The prohibition of this system must be laid down as a preliminary article of perpetual peace, all the more necessarily because the final inevitable bankruptcy of the state in question must involve in the loss many who are innocent; and this would be a public injury to these states.

    Therefore other nations are at least justified in uniting themselves against such an one and its pretensions.

    5.—“No state shall violently interfere with the constitution and administration of another.”

    For what can justify it in so doing? The scandal which is here presented to the subjects of another state? The erring state can much more serve as a warning by exemplifying the great evils which a nation draws down on itself through its own lawlessness. Moreover, the bad example which one free person gives another, (as scandalum acceptum) does no injury to the latter.

    In this connection, it is true, we cannot count the case of a state which has become split up through internal corruption into two parts, each of them representing by itself an individual state which lays claim to the whole. Here the yielding of assistance to one faction could not be reckoned as interference on the part of a foreign state with the constitution of another, for here anarchy prevails.

    So long, however, as the inner strife has not yet reached this stage the interference of other powers would be a violation of the rights of an independent nation which is only struggling with internal disease.[114] It would therefore itself cause a scandal, and make the autonomy of all states insecure.

    [114] See Vattel: Law of Nations, II. Ch. IV. § 55. No
    foreign power, he says, has a right to judge the conduct and
    administration of any sovereign or oblige him to alter it. “If
    he loads his subjects with taxes, or if he treats them with
    severity, the nation alone is concerned; and no other is called
    upon to offer redress for his behaviour, or oblige him to follow
    more wise and equitable maxims....

    But (loc. cit. § 56) when
    the bands of the political society are broken, or at least
    suspended, between the sovereign and his people, the contending
    parties may then be considered at two distinct powers; and, since
    they are both equally independent of all foreign authority,
    nobody has a right to judge them. Either may be in the right; and
    each of those who grant their assistance may imagine that he is
    giving his support to the better cause.” [Tr.]

    6.—“No state at war with another shall countenance such modes of hostility as would make mutual confidence impossible in a subsequent state of peace: such are the employment of assassins (percussores) or of poisoners (venefici), breaches of capitulation, the instigating and making use of treachery (perduellio) in the hostile state.”

    These are dishonourable stratagems. For some kind of confidence in the disposition of the enemy must exist even in the midst of war, as otherwise peace could not be concluded, and the hostilities would pass into a war of extermination (bellum internecinum).

    War, however, is only our wretched expedient of asserting a right by force, an expedient adopted in the state of nature, where no court of justice exists which could settle the matter in dispute. In circumstances like these, neither of the two parties can be called an unjust enemy, because this form of speech presupposes a legal decision: the issue of the conflict—just as in the case of the so-called judgments of God—decides on which side right is.

    Between states, however, no punitive war (bellum punitivum) is thinkable, because between them a relation of superior and inferior does not exist. Whence it follows that a war of extermination, where the process of annihilation would strike both parties at once and all right as well, would bring about perpetual peace only in the great graveyard of the human race. Such a war then, and therefore also the use of all means which lead to it, must be absolutely forbidden.

    That the methods just mentioned do inevitably lead to this result is obvious from the fact that these infernal arts, already vile in themselves, on coming into use, are not long confined to the sphere of war. Take, for example, the use of spies (uti exploratoribus).

    Here only the dishonesty of others is made use of; but vices such as these, when once encouraged, cannot in the nature of things be stamped out and would be carried over into the state of peace, where their presence would be utterly destructive to the purpose of that state.

    Although the laws stated are, objectively regarded, (i.e. in so far as they affect the action of rulers) purely prohibitive laws (leges prohibitivæ), some of them (leges strictæ) are strictly valid without regard to circumstances and urgently require to be enforced.

    Such are Nos. 1, 5, 6. Others, again, (like Nos. 2, 3, 4) although not indeed exceptions to the maxims of law, yet in respect of the practical application of these maxims allow subjectively of a certain latitude to suit particular circumstances. The enforcement of these leges latæ may be legitimately put off, so long as we do not lose sight of the ends at which they aim.

    This purpose of reform does not permit of the deferment of an act of restitution (as, for example, the restoration to certain states of freedom of which they have been deprived in the manner described in article 2) to an infinitely distant date—as Augustus used to say, to the “Greek Kalends”, a day that will never come. This would be to sanction non-restitution.

    Delay is permitted only with the intention that restitution should not be made too precipitately and so defeat the purpose we have in view. For the prohibition refers here only to the mode of acquisition which is to be no longer valid, and not to the fact of possession which, although indeed it has not the necessary title of right, yet at the time of so-called acquisition was held legal by all states, in accordance with the public opinion of the time.[115]

    [115] It has been hitherto doubted, not without reason, whether
    there can be laws of permission (leges permissivæ) of pure
    reason as well as commands (leges præceptivæ) and prohibitions
    (leges prohibitivæ). For law in general has a basis of
    objective practical necessity: permission, on the other hand, is
    based upon the contingency of certain actions in practice. It
    follows that a law of permission would enforce what cannot be
    enforced; and this would involve a contradiction, if the object
    of the law should be the same in both cases.

    Here, however,
    in the present case of a law of permission, the presupposed
    prohibition is aimed merely at the future manner of acquisition
    of a right—for example, acquisition through inheritance: the
    exemption from this prohibition (i.e. the permission) refers
    to the present state of possession. In the transition from a
    state of nature to the civil state, this holding of property can
    continue as a bona fide, if usurpatory, ownership, under the
    new social conditions, in accordance with a permission of the Law
    of Nature.

    Ownership of this kind, as soon as its true nature
    becomes known, is seen to be mere nominal possession (possessio
    putativa
    ) sanctioned by opinion and customs in a natural state
    of society. After the transition stage is passed, such modes of
    acquisition are likewise forbidden in the subsequently evolved
    civil state: and this power to remain in possession would not
    be admitted if the supposed acquisition had taken place in the
    civilized community. It would be bound to come to an end as an
    injury to the right of others, the moment its illegality became
    patent.

    I have wished here only by the way to draw the attention of
    teachers of the Law of Nature to the idea of a lex permissiva
    which presents itself spontaneously in any system of rational
    classification. I do so chiefly because use is often made of
    this concept in civil law with reference to statutes; with this
    difference, that the law of prohibition stands alone by itself,
    while permission is not, as it ought to be, introduced into that
    law as a limiting clause, but is thrown among the exceptions.
    Thus “this or that is forbidden”,—say, Nos.

    1, 2, 3, and so on
    in an infinite progression,—while permissions are only added to
    the law incidentally: they are not reached by the application of
    some principle, but only by groping about among cases which have
    actually occurred. Were this not so, qualifications would have
    had to be brought into the formula of laws of prohibition which
    would have immediately transformed them into laws of permission.
    Count von Windischgrätz, a man whose wisdom was equal to his
    discrimination, urged this very point in the form of a question
    propounded by him for a prize essay.

    One must therefore regret
    that this ingenious problem has been so soon neglected and left
    unsolved. For the possibility of a formula similar to those of
    mathematics is the sole real test of a legislation that would be
    consistent. Without this, the so-called jus certum will remain
    forever a mere pious wish: we can have only general laws valid
    on the whole; no general laws possessing the universal validity
    which the concept law seems to demand.

    SECOND SECTION

    CONTAINING THE DEFINITIVE ARTICLES OF A PERPETUAL PEACE BETWEEN STATES

    A state of peace among men who live side by side is not the natural state (status naturalis), which is rather to be described as a state of war:[116] that is to say, although there is not perhaps always actual open hostility, yet there is a constant threatening that an outbreak may occur. Thus the state of peace must be established.[117] For the mere cessation of hostilities is no guarantee of continued peaceful relations, and unless this guarantee is given by every individual to his neighbour—which can only be done in a state of society regulated by law—one man is at liberty to challenge another and treat him as an enemy.[118]

    [116] “From this diffidence of one another, there is no way for
    any man to secure himself, so reasonable, as anticipation; that
    is, by force, or wiles, to master the persons of all men he can,
    so long, till he see no other power great enough to endanger him:
    and this is no more than his own conservation requireth, and is
    generally allowed.” (Hobbes: Lev. I. Ch. XIII.) [Tr.]

    [117] Hobbes thus describes the establishment of the state. “A
    commonwealth is said to be instituted, when a multitude
    of men do agree, and covenant, every one, with every one,
    that to whatsoever man, or assembly of men, shall be given
    by the major part, the right to present the person of them
    all, that is to say, to be their representative; everyone,
    as well he that voted for it, as he that voted against it,
    shall authorize all the actions and judgments, of that man, or
    assembly of men, in the same manner, as if they were his own, to
    the end, to live peaceably amongst themselves, and be protected
    against other men.” (Lev. II.

    Ch. XVIII.)

    There is a covenant between them, “as if every man should say to
    every man, I authorise and give up my right of governing myself,
    to this man, or to this assembly of men, on this condition, that
    thou give up thy right to him, and authorize all his actions in
    like manner
    .” (Lev. II. Ch. XVII.) [Tr.]

    [118] It is usually accepted that a man may not take hostile
    steps against any one, unless the latter has already injured
    him by act. This is quite accurate, if both are citizens of a
    law-governed state. For, in becoming a member of this community,
    each gives the other the security he demands against injury, by
    means of the supreme authority exercising control over them both.
    The individual, however, (or nation) who remains in a mere state
    of nature deprives me of this security and does me injury, by
    mere proximity.

    There is perhaps no active (facto) molestation,
    but there is a state of lawlessness, (status injustus) which,
    by its very existence, offers a continual menace to me. I can
    therefore compel him, either to enter into relations with me
    under which we are both subject to law, or to withdraw from my
    neighbourhood. So that the postulate upon which the following
    articles are based is:—“All men who have the power to exert
    a mutual influence upon one another must be under a civil
    government of some kind.”

    A legal constitution is, according to the nature of the
    individuals who compose the state:—

    (1) A constitution formed in accordance with the right of
    citizenship of the individuals who constitute a nation (jus
    civitatis
    ).

    (2) A constitution whose principle is international law which
    determines the relations of states (jus gentium).

    (3) A constitution formed in accordance with cosmopolitan law,
    in as far as individuals and states, standing in an external
    relation of mutual reaction, may be regarded as citizens of one
    world-state (jus cosmopoliticum).

    This classification is not an arbitrary one, but is necessary
    with reference to the idea of perpetual peace. For, if even
    one of these units of society were in a position physically to
    influence another, while yet remaining a member of a primitive
    order of society, then a state of war would be joined with these
    primitive conditions; and from this it is our present purpose to
    free ourselves.

    FIRST DEFINITIVE ARTICLE OF PERPETUAL PEACE

    I.—“The civil constitution of each state shall be republican.”

    The only constitution which has its origin in the idea of the original contract, upon which the lawful legislation of every nation must be based, is the republican.[119] It is a constitution, in the first place, founded in accordance with the principle of the freedom of the members of society as human beings: secondly, in accordance with the principle of the dependence of all, as subjects, on a common legislation: and, thirdly, in accordance with the law of the equality of the members as citizens. It is then, looking at the question of right, the only constitution whose fundamental principles lie at the basis of every form of civil constitution.

    And the only question for us now is, whether it is also the one constitution which can lead to perpetual peace.

    [119] Lawful, that is to say, external freedom cannot be defined,
    as it so often is, as the right [Befugniss] “to do whatever one
    likes, so long as this does not wrong anyone else.”[B] For what
    is this right? It is the possibility of actions which do not lead
    to the injury of others. So the explanation of a “right” would be
    something like this:—“Freedom is the possibility of actions which
    do not injure anyone.

    A man does not wrong another—whatever his
    action—if he does not wrong another”: which is empty tautology.
    My external (lawful) freedom is rather to be explained in
    this way: it is the right through which I require not to obey
    any external laws except those to which I could have given my
    consent. In exactly the same way, external (legal) equality in a
    state is that relation of the subjects in consequence of which
    no individual can legally bind or oblige another to anything,
    without at the same time submitting himself to the law which
    ensures that he can, in his turn, be bound and obliged in like
    manner by this other.

    [B] Hobbes’ definition of freedom is interesting. See Lev. II.
    Ch. XXI.:—“A FREEMAN, is he, that in those things, which by his
    strength and wit he is able to do, is not hindered to do what he
    has a will to
    .” [Tr.]

    The principle of lawful independence requires no explanation,
    as it is involved in the general concept of a constitution.
    The validity of this hereditary and inalienable right, which
    belongs of necessity to mankind, is affirmed and ennobled by the
    principle of a lawful relation between man himself and higher
    beings, if indeed he believes in such beings. This is so, because
    he thinks of himself, in accordance with these very principles,
    as a citizen of a transcendental world as well as of the world
    of sense.

    For, as far as my freedom goes, I am bound by no
    obligation even with regard to Divine Laws—which are apprehended
    by me only through my reason—except in so far as I could have
    given my assent to them; for it is through the law of freedom
    of my own reason that I first form for myself a concept of a
    Divine Will.

    As for the principle of equality, in so far as it
    applies to the most sublime being in the universe next to God—a
    being I might perhaps figure to myself as a mighty emanation of
    the Divine spirit,—there is no reason why, if I perform my duty
    in the sphere in which I am placed, as that aeon does in his,
    the duty of obedience alone should fall to my share, the right
    to command to him. That this principle of equality, (unlike the
    principle of freedom), does not apply to our relation to God is
    due to the fact that, to this Being alone, the idea of duty does
    not belong.

    As for the right to equality which belongs to all citizens as
    subjects, the solution of the problem of the admissibility of
    an hereditary nobility hinges on the following question:—“Does
    social rank—acknowledged by the state to be higher in the case
    of one subject than another—stand above desert, or does merit
    take precedence of social standing?” Now it is obvious that, if
    high position is combined with good family, it is quite uncertain
    whether merit, that is to say, skill and fidelity in office, will
    follow as well.

    This amounts to granting the favoured individual
    a commanding position without any question of desert; and to
    that, the universal will of the people—expressed in an original
    contract which is the fundamental principle of all right—would
    never consent. For it does not follow that a nobleman is a man
    of noble character.

    In the case of the official nobility, as one
    might term the rank of higher magistracy—which one must acquire
    by merit—the social position is not attached like property to the
    person but to his office, and equality is not thereby disturbed;
    for, if a man gives up office, he lays down with it his official
    rank and falls back into the ra

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay
    Author
    Immanuel Kant
    Release date
    January 14, 2016 [eBook #50922]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Turgut Dincer, Ramon Pajares Box and the Online
    Most recently updated
    October 22, 2024
    Transcriber and production notes
    TRANSCRIBER’S NOTE
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
      * Italics are denoted by underscores as in _italics_.
      * Bold text is denoted by equals as in =bold=.
      * Small caps are represented in upper case as in SMALL CAPS.
      * Original spelling was kept, but variant spellings were made
        consistent when a predominant usage was found.
      * Obvious printer errors have been silently corrected.
    
    
    
    
    PERPETUAL PEACE
    
    
    [Illustration]
    
    
      “For I dipt into the future, far as human eye could see,
      Saw the Vision of the world, and all the wonder that would be;
      Saw the heavens fill with commerce, argosies of magic sails,
      Pilots of the purple twilight, dropping down with costly bales;
      Heard the heavens fill with shouting, and there rain’d a ghastly dew
      From the nations’ airy navies grappling in the central blue;
      Far along the world-wide whisper of the south-wind rushing warm,
      With the standards of the peoples plunging thro’ the thunder-storm;
      Till the war-drum throbb’d no longer, and the battle-flags were furl’d
      In the Parliament of man, the Federation of the world.
      There the common sense of most shall hold a fretful realm in awe,
      And the kindly earth shall slumber, lapt in universal law.”
    
      TENNYSON: _Locksley Hall_.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Perpetual Peace: A Philosophical Essay
    
    Author: Immanuel Kant
    
    Translator: Mary Campbell Smith
    
    
            
    Release date: January 14, 2016 [eBook #50922]
                    Most recently updated: October 22, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/50922
    
    Credits: Produced by Turgut Dincer, Ramon Pajares Box and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This
            file was produced from images generously made available
            by The Internet Archive)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #50922. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 50922
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.