The Life and Letters of George John Romanes, M.A., LL.D., F.R.S.
by George John Romanes · English · Gutenberg #49182 · 586,709 chars · public domain (US)
The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Life and Letters of George John Romanes, M.A., LL.D., F.R.S.
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: The Life and Letters of George John Romanes, M.A., LL.D., F.R.S.
Author: George John Romanes
Ethel Duncan Romanes
Release date: June 9, 2015 [eBook #49182]
Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/49182
Credits: Produced by Marilynda Fraser-Cunliffe, John Campbell and
the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images
generously made available by The Internet Archive)
*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE LIFE AND LETTERS OF GEORGE JOHN ROMANES, M.A., LL.D., F.R.S. ***
TRANSCRIBER'S NOTE
Italic text is denoted by _underscores_.
Superscripts are denoted by ^ eg A^n.
Obvious punctuation errors have been corrected after careful
comparison with other occurrences within the text and consultation
of external sources.
More detail can be found at the end of the book.
GEORGE JOHN ROMANES
[Illustration: Frontispiece, signed:
Yours ever the same,
G. J. Romanes]
THE
LIFE AND LETTERS
OF
GEORGE JOHN ROMANES
M.A., LL.D., F.R.S.
WRITTEN AND EDITED BY HIS WIFE
SECOND EDITION
LONGMANS, GREEN, AND CO.
LONDON, NEW YORK, AND BOMBAY
1896
_All rights reserved_
LIBERIS NOSTRIS
RECORDATIO
PATRIS DESIDERATISSIMI
MEMORIA JUSTI CUM LAUDIBUS
PREFACE
TO
THE SECOND EDITION
In sending out this Second Edition of my husband's Life, I cannot but
acknowledge the extreme kindness with which it has been received.
But I think it is also due to his memory to say a word in view of
various statements that have been made in America and elsewhere, to
the effect that his mental vigour and powers were impaired before his
death. These statements are absolutely untrue.
I can best refute them by calling attention to the obituary notice
written by Professor Burdon Sanderson for the Royal Society.
In this paper it is said: 'Up to the end he [Romanes] preserved not
only his mental vigour, but the keenness of his interest in his
scientific pursuits.'
This, I think, needs no additional comment from me.
E. R.
OXFORD: _March 1896_.
PREFACE
In writing my husband's life I have tried, so far as it was possible,
to let him, especially in matters scientific, speak for himself.
For the purpose of his biographer it is unfortunate that my husband
lived in almost daily intercourse for parts of many years with more
than one of his most intimate friends. Hence there are no letters
to several people with whom he was in the habit of discussing
scientific, philosophic, and theological questions.
The letters relating to his work will, I hope, interest any one who
cares for biological science. Whatever may be the exact place which
shall be assigned to him, by those who come after, in the great army
of workers for Science, this much may be said: that no one ever
served in the cause of Science with more passionate and whole-hearted
devotion, more entire disinterestedness--
_All for Love, and nothing for Reward._
I have to acknowledge the kindness of many who have put letters
at my disposal. I cannot sufficiently express my thanks to Mr.
Francis Darwin for generously allowing me to print portions of the
correspondence which for seven or eight years was one of the chief
pleasures and privileges of my husband's life. I must also thank
my brother and sister-in-law, the Dean of Christ Church, Professor
Poulton, Professor Schäfer, Professor Le Conte, Mr. Thiselton-Dyer,
and others for like permission.
And I must express my most sincere gratitude to the Rev. P. N.
Waggett, to Professor C. Lloyd Morgan, and to my cousin Mrs. St.
George Reid (late of Newnham College, Cambridge), for their constant
help and advice.
To Mrs. Reid I owe more than I can well express. Her scientific
knowledge and ability have been simply invaluable, and have been used
with ever-ready and ungrudging generosity and kindness.
There are other aspects of my husband's life which are interesting,
but again I think he has told his own story, and it is needless for
me here to speak of what, to some extent, he has laid bare--of mental
perplexity and of steadfast endurance and loyalty to Truth. It may be
that others, wandering in the twilight of this 'dimly lighted world,'
may be stimulated and encouraged and helped to go on in patience
until on them also dawns that Light. If this be so it will not be
altogether in vain that he bore long years of very real and very
heavy sorrow.
E. R.
OXFORD: 1895.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER PAGE
I. BOYHOOD--YOUTH--EARLY MANHOOD, 1848-1878 1
II. LONDON, 1879-1890 89
III. LONDON--GEANIES, 1881-1890 136
IV. OXFORD, 1890-1894 248
INDEX 358
ILLUSTRATIONS
PORTRAIT OF MR. ROMANES _Frontispiece_
GEANIES, ROSS-SHIRE _To face p._ 146
94 ST. ALDATE'S " 256
GEORGE JOHN ROMANES
CHAPTER I
_BOYHOOD--YOUTH--EARLY MANHOOD_
BOYHOOD. 1848-1867
George John Romanes was born at Kingston, Canada, on May 20, 1848,
the third son of the Rev. George Romanes, D.D., then Professor of
Greek in the University of that place.
The Professor had come out to Canada some years previously, and,
after a short experience of work in country parishes, had settled
down to teach Greek to the _alumni_ of the little University.
Dr. Romanes was descended from an old Scottish family settled since
1586 in Berwickshire: he had been educated at the High School and
University of Edinburgh, and was an excellent classic and learned
theologian, with views of a strictly 'Moderate' type. From him his
distinguished son inherited the sweetness of temper and calmness of
manner which characterised George John Romanes through life, and
which earned for him amongst his friends the playful sobriquet of
'The Philosopher.'
Dr. Romanes married, after his arrival in Canada, Miss Isabella Gair
Smith, daughter of the Rev. Robert Smith, for many years parish
minister of Cromarty. Mrs. Romanes was connected with several
old Highland families, and was a thorough Highlander. Handsome,
vivacious, unconventional, and clever, she was in all respects a
great contrast to her husband, who, as years went on, seems to have
lived mainly the life of a student, and to have left the care of
mundane things to his wife. Three sons and two daughters were born.
Of these, only two, the eldest son and youngest daughter, now survive.
In 1848, the inheritance of a considerable fortune relieved Dr.
Romanes from any necessity to continue the duties of his chair, and
the family returned home, wandering about for a few years and finally
settling in 18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park. There was a good deal
of continental travel during these first years after their return,
and as he grew into boyhood George Romanes spent several months at
various times in Heidelberg and other German towns, and the family
performed a journey from Nice to Florence in a delightful and now
bygone fashion, travelling with a vetturino.
Probably the beauty of the scenery, the fascination of travel, and
the charm of the beautiful surroundings exercised an unconscious
influence over the boy, and did something to rouse the poetic
sense which was to be so great an element in his life. Otherwise
there seems to have been little or no sense of pleasure in the art
treasures or the historic associations of Italy, and at no time of
his life did he ever care for pictures in anything like the same
degree as he loved poetry or music.
After the family settled in London, George Romanes was sent to a
preparatory school near his own home. Two of his schoolfellows became
in after life intimate friends. These were Francis Paget, the present
Dean of Christ Church, and his brother, Henry Luke Paget, now Vicar
of St. Pancras, London.
An attack of measles put a stop once and for all to his preparatory
school career, and the idea of a public school was never entertained.
He was educated in a desultory and aimless fashion at home, and was
regarded by his family as a shocking dunce. Parts of two years were
spent in Heidelberg, and here he picked up some German, and had a few
lessons on the violin, and saw as he grew up something of student
life in Germany. Music was always a perfect passion with George
Romanes, and if a little wholesome discipline had been exercised, the
boy might have become a very good musician.
Heidelberg and the days at Heidelberg represented to the younger
Romanes the 'golden age.'
They lived in an old house outside the town, surrounded by woods, and
here the children, George and his younger sister, roamed about to
their hearts' content, making collections and keeping pets, like the
born naturalists they were. Shockingly idle children but marvellously
happy ones, and in the peculiar 'let alone' system of their
household, they grew up, neither of them remembering any reproof, far
less any punishment, nor any attempt to make them learn lessons or
carry on studies for which they were not inclined. A long interval
of years separated the brothers, now only two in number,[1] and the
younger brother and sister were looked on and treated as children
long after they had emerged from childhood.
The father and mother seem to have attended Presbyterian and Anglican
churches with entire impartiality, but the younger members of the
family preferred the English church, and were confirmed in it.
Religion was a potent influence with the boy in quite early years,
and there grew up in him a purpose of taking Holy Orders, a purpose
which met with no encouragement from either of his parents.
If of intellectual achievement he gave as yet no promise, at least
there were the signs of a singularly pure and unselfish nature which
seemed to grow and develope with the growing years. All through his
life he was peculiarly tender, gentle, and unselfish, and his younger
sister describes a little scene of how, while a children's party was
going on downstairs, George found her upstairs alone and miserable,
suffering from some odd childish misery of nerves, unable to go down,
and yet hating to be alone; how he at once soothed and petted her,
sat by her the whole evening, telling her stories and successfully
driving away her unhappiness. The most characteristic bit appears at
the end. This sort of unselfish conduct was so usual, that his little
sister really forgot to thank him, nor did it occur to her till long
after that there was anything unusual in his willingness to sacrifice
a whole evening's amusement to what most boys would have regarded as
mere fancifulness, only deserving a due amount of severe teasing.
During these years the Romanes family spent their summers at
Dunskaith, on the shores of the Cromarty Firth. Here George Romanes
had his first lessons in sport at the hands of Dr. Brydon, the
well-known survivor of the fatal retreat from Cabul, 1842.[2] He soon
became an ardent sportsman and excellent shot, and not until his
fatal illness began did he ever fail to keep August 12 and September
1 in the proper way.
When George Romanes was about seventeen, he was sent to a tutor to
read in preparation for the University, his mother having suddenly
awakened to the fact that he was nearly grown up and not at all
ready for college. One of his fellow pupils was Mr. Charles Edmund
Lister, brother of the present owner of Shibden Hall, Halifax. With
Mr. Lister he formed a friendship destined to be only broken by Mr.
Lister's premature death in 1889. This friendship had important
results for George Romanes. He had been intended for Oxford, and his
name had been entered at Brasenose College, but Mr. Lister was to go
to Cambridge, and he easily persuaded his friend to follow him.
In October 1867 George John Romanes entered Gonville and Caius
College, Cambridge.
CAMBRIDGE. 1867-1873
Most men feel that their University life is one of the most marked
phases of their career. Even to those who come up from a public
school, with all the prestige and with all the friendships, the sense
of fellowship, the hundred and one influences, the customs of a great
school 'lying thick' upon them, realise more and more, as time goes
on, how great a part Oxford or Cambridge plays in their lives; how it
is in their University life they make their intellectual choice, and
receive the bias which, for good or for evil, will influence their
whole life.
And to this raw boy, fresh from a secluded and somewhat narrow
atmosphere, plunged for the first time into a great society,
brought for the first time under some of the influences of the then
'Zeitgeist,' into contact with some of the leaders of thought,
entrance into the University was the beginning of an entirely new
life.
He entered Cambridge, half-educated, utterly untrained, with no
knowledge of men or of books. He left it, to all intents and
purposes, a trained worker and earnest thinker, with his life work
begun--that work which was an unwearied search after truth, a work
characterised by an ever-increasing reverence for goodness, and,
as years went on, by a disregard for applause or for reward. His
Cambridge life was happy; he made several friends, chief of whom was
Mr. Proby Cautley, the present rector of Quainton near Aylesbury.
He enjoyed boating, and once narrowly escaped drowning in the Cam.[3]
At first George Romanes fell completely under Evangelical influences,
at that time practically the most potent religious force in
Cambridge. He was a regular communicant, and it is touching to look
at the little Bible he used while at Cambridge, worn, and marked,
and pencilled, with references to sermons which had evidently caught
the boy's attention. He used to attend meetings for Greek Testament
study, and enjoyed hearing the distinguished preachers who visited
the University.
But of the _intellectual_ influences in the religious world of the
University he knew nothing. F. D. Maurice was still in Cambridge,
but he seems to have repelled rather than to have attracted George
Romanes, nor did he ever come under the influence of Westcott, or of
Lightfoot, or of Hort.
And, when the intellectual struggles began, he seems in early years
to have owed very little to any Christian writer, Bishop Butler alone
excepted.
His summers were spent in Ross-shire, and there is no doubt these
months were of great use to him. He was perfectly unharassed so far
as pecuniary cares or family ambition were concerned, and he had
abundant time to think. Years afterwards, Mr. Darwin said to him:
'Above all, Romanes, cultivate the habit of meditation,' and Mr.
Romanes always quoted this as a most valuable bit of advice. His
intellectual development was rapid in these Cambridge years, and
it is not improbable that his slowly growing mind had not been ill
served by being allowed to mature in absolute freedom, although he
himself bitterly regretted and, through his whole life, deplored the
lack of early training, and of mental discipline.
Through these early Cambridge years he still cherished the idea
of Holy Orders, and with his friend, Mr. Cautley, he had many
talks about the career they both intended to choose. They spent
a part of one long vacation together, and occupied themselves in
reading theology--such books as 'Pearson on the Creed,' Hooker's
'Ecclesiastical Polity,' Bishop Butler's 'Analogy,' and in writing
sermons. Some of Mr. Romanes' are still extant, and are curious bits
of boyish composition--crude, unformed in style, and yet full of
thought, and showing a remarkable knowledge of the Bible.
He seems to have been, for the rest, a bright, good-tempered,
popular lad, always much chaffed for absent-minded mistakes, for
his long legs, for his peculiar name; and he certainly gave no one
the faintest idea of any particular ability, any likelihood of
future distinction.[4] Some slight chance, as it seemed, turned his
attention to natural science; one or two friends were reading for the
Natural Science Tripos, and George Romanes ceased to read mathematics
and began to work at natural science, competing for and winning a
scholarship in that subject.
Eighteen months only remained for him to work for his Tripos, and
it is not surprising that he only obtained a Second Class. In the
Tripos of 1870, in the same list among the First-Class men, Mr.
Francis Darwin's name appears.
Mr. Romanes had gone but a little distance along the road on which
he was destined to travel very far. He had up to this time read none
of Mr. Darwin's books, and to a question on Natural Selection which
occurred in the Tripos papers he could give no answer.
By this time he had abandoned the idea of Holy Orders, perhaps
on account of the opposition at home, perhaps because of the
first beginnings of the intellectual struggles of doubt and of
bewilderment. He began to study medicine, and made a lifelong
friendship with Dr. Latham, the well-known Cambridge physician, of
whose kindness Mr. Romanes often spoke, and to whom he dedicated his
first book, which was the Burney Prize for 1873. But he also began
to study physiology under the direction of Dr. Michael Foster, the
present Professor of Physiology at Cambridge, to whom she owes her
famous medical school, at that time in its very early beginnings.
Science entirely fascinated him; his first plunge into real
scientific work opened to him a new life, gave him the first sense
of power and of capacity. Now he read Mr. Darwin's books, and it is
impossible to overrate the extraordinary effect they had on the young
man's mind. Something of the feeling which Keats describes in the
sonnet 'On Looking into Chapman's Homer' seems to have been his:
'Then felt I like some watcher of the skies
When a new planet swims into his ken;
Or like stout Cortez when, with eagle eyes,
He stared at the Pacific--and all his men
Looked at each other with a wild surmise
Silent, upon a peak in Darien.'
About the spring of 1872 Mr. Romanes began to show signs of
ill-health. He was harassed by faintness and incessant lassitude,
but struggled on, going up to Scotland in the summer and beginning to
shoot, under the belief that all he wanted was hard exercise. At last
he broke down and was declared to be suffering from a bad attack of
typhoid fever. He had a very hard struggle for life, and owed a great
deal to Dr. Latham, who from Cambridge kept up a constant telegraphic
communication with the Ross-shire doctors. It was a long and weary
convalescence, beguiled in part by writing an essay on 'Christian
Prayer and General Laws,' the subject assigned for the Burney Prize
Essay of 1873.
Much of this essay was dictated to one or other of his sisters,
and it is a curious fact that his first book and his last should
have been on theological subjects. Both were written when he was
struggling with great bodily weakness, and in these months of early
manhood he showed the same almost pathetic desire to work, the same
activity of thought which he displayed more than twenty years later
in the last days of his life.
The essay was successful, and its author was more than once claimed
as a champion of faith on the strength of it.
It is a very hard bit of reading, and of course has to some extent
the drawback of a prize essay, a work written not simply to convince
the public, but to impress examiners. It is full of knowledge and of
intellectual agility, but is perhaps needlessly difficult in style.
His success was absolutely unexpected by his family, and made him
very happy, as the following letters show, written in the first glow
of success.
_To Mrs. Romanes._
18 Cornwall Terrace.
My dearest Mother,--Your letter of surprise and rejoicing has
been to me one of the best parts of the result. All the letters
of congratulation which are now coming in mention you: 'How
delighted your mother will be,' &c.; and it is a great thing for
me to find that you are so. Without appreciative sympathy success
soon palls; but the two combined go to make up the best happiness.
I went to Cambridge yesterday to get the manuscript, and as there
happened to be a congregation in the afternoon, I also took my
degree. I saw all my friends, who were overflowing with delight.
Indeed, I never before realised how great the competition is,
for I never had an opportunity of knowing how the successful man
is lionised. The Caius dons especially are up in the air about
it, as this is the first time in the history of the college
that one of its members has got the Burney; so that, as Ferrers
writes to me, 'when the same year produces a Senior Wrangler and
a Burney Prizeman, the college may be said to be looking up.'
I was invited to breakfast with the Professor of Divinity (who
is the principal adjudicator), and I found him very pleasant
indeed. Afterwards I went to the Vice-Chancellor, from whom I
got the well-remembered 'pages' (but now with Prize I. written
across them); and lastly, to the third adjudicator, the master
of Christ's. They all said more in praise of the essay than I
would care to repeat, but, to tell you the simple truth, I was
perfectly astonished. For example, 'In the history of the Burney
Prize there have only been two equals and no superiors.'
The Vice-Chancellor told me that there was another essay well
deserving of a prize which was written by a man of whom I dare
say you will remember I said I was most afraid, viz., Mr. ----. I
knew him very well when we were undergraduates, and three years
ago he obtained the Trinity Scholarship in Philosophy, open to
all competitors, and ended up eighteen months ago by graduating
as Senior of the Moral Science Tripos. It is a great satisfaction
to me that the man who was universally admitted to be the best
of the Cambridge metaphysicians should have written, and that,
notwithstanding, the decision should have been given unanimously
in my favour.
_To James Romanes, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace: April 24.
My dearest James,--I am sure you will be as much pleased with
the result of my labours as I am myself. I remember so well our
speculating upon the probable chances of success, and how low we
set them down. Had I known for certain that ---- was going to
compete, I think I should have given up altogether. His essay
does seem to have been extraordinarily good, and yet he cannot
get a second prize, because the foundation requires that every
penny of the interest shall go to the first man. As this seems
rather hard lines for ----, I have to-day written to the Divinity
Professor offering to share the prize money, on condition that
the University recognise ---- as a prizeman.
The extraordinary thing about the whole affair is, not so much
the award, as the opinion which the adjudicators entertain of
the work. I do not know how it is that, stranded on a sandbank
and in a half dead-and-alive state, without thinking I was doing
anything unusual, I should have written the prize essay. But I
don't care how it is so long as it is so, as ---- writes, 'You
certainly have achieved a great success, handicapped as you were
in so many ways.' This, of course, relates to the award; but, as
I said before, what surprised me most is that I should not only
be first, but such a good first. The praise given by each of the
adjudicators separately, in as strong terms as it is possible
in donnish phraseology to convey it, was very gratifying to me,
especially as pronounced in the studiously dignified manner of
the Vice-Chancellor.
I hope soon to see you and tell you more about the whole thing;
for one of the best parts of it is, that 'if one member be
honoured, all the members rejoice with it.'
Ever your loving Brother,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
During his convalescence Mr. Romanes finally abandoned the idea of a
profession and resolved to devote himself to scientific research.
It was about this time that a letter of his in 'Nature' (see
'Nature,' vol. viii. p. 101) attracted Mr. Darwin's attention, and
caused him to send a friendly little note to the youthful writer.
Probably Mr. Darwin had little idea of the effect his letter produced
on its recipient, who was then recovering from his long illness. That
Darwin should actually write to _him_ seemed too good to believe. It
was a great encouragement to go on with scientific work.
Up to 1873 or 1874 Mr. Romanes had been working, when at Cambridge,
in Dr. Michael Foster's laboratory, and was a member of that band
who formed the nucleus of what was destined to be the famous
physiological school of Cambridge. Side by side with Mr. Romanes were
working Mr. Gaskell, Mr. Dew Smith, and others now well known for
their work and achievements.
In some ways Mr. Romanes suffered from not remaining at Cambridge and
becoming a permanent member of the band.
It is impossible not to feel that had he stayed on at the University
he would have devoted himself more and more to strictly experimental
work and less to what may be called philosophical natural history.
Some will regard his removal as a misfortune, and others as a happy
accident, but the might-have-beens of life are never very profitable
subjects for speculation.
In order to be with his now widowed mother, he returned to London,
and made his home with her and his sisters. They spent their summers
at Dunskaith, and Mr. Romanes embarked on researches on the nervous
system of the Medusæ. He began also to work in the physiological
laboratory of University College under Dr. Sharpey and Dr. Burdon
Sanderson. Both he regarded as masters and friends, and perhaps, next
to Mr. Darwin, Dr. Sanderson was the scientific friend George Romanes
most valued and loved, although it is impossible to overrate what he
owed to Cambridge, and to those early longings for biological study
which were inspired by Dr. Foster.
As has been said, a letter in 'Nature' attracted Mr. Darwin's notice,
and somewhere about 1874 he invited Mr. Romanes to call on him.
From that time began an unbroken friendship, marked on one side by
absolute worship, reverence, and affection, on the other by an almost
fatherly kindness and a wonderful interest in the younger man's
work and in his career. That first meeting was a real epoch in Mr.
Romanes' life. Mr. Darwin met him, as he often used to tell, with
outstretched hands, a bright smile, and a 'How glad I am that you are
so young!'
Perhaps no hero-worship was ever more unselfish, more utterly loyal,
or more fully rewarded. As time went on, and intimacy increased,
and restraint wore off, Mr. Romanes found that the great master
was as much to be admired for his personal character as for his
wonderful gifts, and to the youth who never, in the darkest days of
utter scepticism, parted with the love for goodness, for beauty of
character, this was an overwhelming joy.
In a poem written about 1884 Mr. Romanes has expressed something
of what he felt for Mr. Darwin, and in this he has poured out his
'hero-worship' in terms which were to him the expressions of simple
truth.
It is interesting to look over the long series of letters from 1874
to 1882 and notice how the formal 'Dear Mr. Romanes' drops into
the familiar 'Dear Romanes,' and the letters become more and more
affectionate, intimate, personal.
About this time also Mr. Romanes made many other scientific friends,
Professor Schäfer, Professor Cossar Ewart, Mr. Francis Darwin,
Dr. Pye Smith, Professor R. Lankester, Professor Clifford, Dr.
Lauder Brunton, and many more; and as his work became known it is
pleasant to see with what kindness of welcome the new recruit was
welcomed to the scientific army by such men as Professor Huxley, Sir
John Lubbock, Sir Joseph Hooker, Mr. Busk, Mr. F. Galton, and Mr.
Spottiswoode, then President of the Royal Society.
Just at that time there was a set of rising young biologists who
all seemed destined to do good work, and it is melancholy to look
back and to see 'how of that not too numerous band a number have been
taken from us in the prime of life, Garrod, Frank Balfour, Moseley,
H. Carpenter, Milnes Marshall, Romanes.'[5]
At Dunskaith a little laboratory was fitted up in an adjoining
cottage, and here during the summer Mr. Romanes worked constantly
for some years, diversifying his labours by shooting. It was in his
country home also that he began those series of observations on
animals which he worked up into the 'Animal Intelligence' of the
International Scientific Series, perhaps the most popular of his
books. The terrier Mathal was his special companion, and he observed
various traits of her intelligence which are recorded in 'Mental
Evolution in Animals,' pp. 156, 157, 158. It was also at Dunskaith
that he began his first attempts at verse making, but for some years
these did not come to much.
His scientific work at Dunskaith led to a paper communicated to the
Royal Society in 1875, and entitled 'Preliminary Observations on the
Locomotor System of Medusæ.'
This paper the Royal Society honoured by making it the Croonian
Lecture, an honour awarded to the best biological paper of each
year.[6]
Mr. Romanes had worked for two years, or rather two summers, very
constantly and very strenuously on the Medusæ. He set himself to try
and discover whether or not the rudiments of a nervous system existed
in these creatures. Agassiz had maintained it did, others considered
his deductions premature, and Huxley, in his 'Classification of
Animals,' summed up the much-debated question by saying that 'no
nervous system had yet been discovered in Medusæ.'
Microscopically, it had already been shown that in some forms of
Medusæ there are present certain fine fibres running along the margin
of the swimming bell, from their appearance said to be nerves, but
in no case had it been shown that they functioned as such. Thus it
was to solve this question, whether or not a nervous system, known
to be present in all animals higher in the zoological scale, makes
its first appearance in the Medusæ, that Mr. Romanes entered upon
a long series of physiological experiments, first on the group of
small 'naked-eyed' Medusæ, and then on the larger 'covered-eyed'
form, the latter division containing the common jelly-fish. These
names, 'naked-eyed' and 'covered-eyed,' are given to the two groups
on account of a difference in their sense organs, which are situated
on the margin of the umbrella or swimming bell, and are protected by
a hood of gelatinous matter in the 'covered-eyed' forms, so called in
contradistinction to the 'naked-eyed' group, where the hood is absent.
Romanes first carefully observed the movements of the Medusæ,
which, it will be remembered, are effected by the dilatation and
contraction of the entire swimming bell, and he found that if, in
the 'naked-eyed' group, the extreme margin of this swimming bell
be excised, immediate, total, and permanent paralysis of the whole
organ took place. This result was obtained with every species of this
group which he examined; he therefore concluded that in the margin
of all these forms there is situated a localised system of centres
of spontaneity, having for one of its functions the origination of
impulses to which the contraction of the swimming bell is, under
ordinary circumstances, exclusively due. This deduction was confirmed
by the behaviour of the severed thread-like portion of the margin,
which continued its rhythmical contractions quite unimpaired by its
severance from the main organism, the latter remaining perfectly
motionless. In the 'covered-eyed' forms Romanes found that excision
of the margin of the umbrella, or rather excision of the sense organs
or marginal bodies, produced paralysis; in this case, the paralysis
was of a temporary character, as in the great majority of cases
contractions were resumed after a variable period. From this series
of experiments he was led to believe that in the 'covered-eyed'
Medusæ the margin is the _principal_, but not the _exclusive_,
seat of spontaneity, there being other locomotor centres scattered
throughout the general contractile tissue of the swimming bell.
Having demonstrated the existence of a central nervous system capable
of originating impulses, Romanes had yet to prove the identity of
this nervous tissue of the Medusæ with that of nervous tissues
in general: therefore, he next proceeded to test whether it was
also capable of responding to external stimulation by light, heat,
electricity, &c.
As regards appreciation of light, he was able to prove conclusively
for at least two species of the 'naked-eyed' forms that as long as
their marginal bodies remained intact they would always respond to
luminous stimulation, and would crowd along a beam of light cast
through a darkened bell jar in which they were swimming; if their
marginal bodies were removed, they remained indifferent to light.
With regard to the 'covered-eyed' forms, he obtained sufficient
evidence to induce him to believe they possessed a visual sense
localised in their marginal sense organs.
The effects of electrical stimulation agreed in all respects with
those produced on the excitable tissues of other animals. He next
experimentally investigated in the jelly-fish the paths along which
the nervous impulses must pass in their passage from the locomotor
centres, where they originate, to the general contractile tissues of
the animal.
The results of these experiments led him to infer the existence of a
very fine plexus of nerve fibres, in which the constituent threads
cross and re-cross one another without actually coalescing. This
conclusion, which he arrived at from purely experimental grounds, was
some years afterwards confirmed by minute histological research.
Finally, the effect of various poisons, chloroform, alcohol, &c., was
tried, and the striking resemblance of their action on the nervous
system of the Medusæ with that which they exert on that of higher
animals supports the belief that nerve tissue when it first appears
in the scene of life has the same fundamental properties as it has in
higher animals.
This piece of work was important, as the facts threw light, as
Professor Sanderson has said, on elementary questions of physiology
relating to excitability and conduction, and it was a characteristic
of Mr. Romanes that in all his work, of whatever kind, he was always
searching for principles. The minutest detail never escaped his
attention if it appeared at all likely in any way to throw light on
some biological or psychological problem. Only a trained scientific
worker can appreciate the amount of labour these Royal Society papers
represented. In 1875 he gave a Friday evening lecture at the Royal
Institution on his work on Medusæ.
He was also at this time working on the subject of 'Pangenesis,'[7]
and a series of letters to Mr. Darwin and to Professor Schäfer may
interest some readers.
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.:
January 14, 1875.
Dear Mr. Darwin,--I should very much like to see the papers
to which you allude. _A priori_ one would have thought the
bisecting plan the more hopeful, but if the other has yielded
positive results, in the case of an eye and tubers, I think it
would be worth while to try the effect of transplanting various
kinds of pips into the pulps of kindred varieties of fruit;
for the homological relations in this case would be pretty much
the same as in the other, with the exception of the bud being
an impregnated one. If positive results ensued, however, this
last-mentioned fact would be all the better for 'Pangenesis.'
You have doubtless observed the very remarkable case given in
the 'Gardener's Chronicle' for January 2--I mean the vine in
which the _scion_ appears to have notably affected the _stock_.
Altogether vines seem very promising; and as their buds admit
of being planted in the ground, it would be much more easy to
try the bisecting plan in their case than in others, where one
half-bud, besides requiring to be fitted to the other half, has
also to have its shield fitted into the bark. All one's energies
might then be expended in coaxing adhesion, and if once this
were obtained, I think there would here be the best chance of
obtaining a hybrid; for then all, or nearly all, the cells of
the future branch would be in the state of gemmules. I am very
sanguine about the buds growing under these circumstances, for
the vigour with which bisected seeds germinate is perfectly
astonishing.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
P.S.--I have been to see Dr. Hooker, and found his kindness and
courtesy quite what you led me to expect. Such men are rare.
April 21, 1875.
In returning you ----'s papers, I should like to say that
the one on 'Inheritance' appears to me quite destitute of
intelligible meaning. It is a jumble of the same confused ideas
upon heredity about which I complained when you were at this
house. How in the world can 'force' act without any material
on which to act? Yet, unless we assume that it can, the whole
discussion is either meaningless, or else assumes the truth of
some such theory as 'Pangenesis.' In other words, as it must be
'unthinkable' that force should act independently of matter,
the doctrine of its persistence can only be made to bear upon
the question of heredity, by supposing that there is a material
connection between corporeal and germinal cells--_i.e._ by
granting the existence of _force-carriers_, call them gemmules,
or physiological units, or what we please.
Lawson Tait says (p. 60)--'The process of growth of the ovum
after impregnation can be followed only after the assumption
either expressed or _unconsciously accepted_ of such a hypothesis
as is contained in Mr. Darwin's "Pangenesis;"' and it is
interesting, as showing the truth of the remark, to compare,
for example, p. 29 of the other pamphlet--for, of course,
'Pangenesis' assumes the truth of the persistence of force as
the prime condition of its possibility. If ever I have occasion
to prepare a paper about heredity, I think it would be worth
while to point out the absurdity of thinking that we explain
anything by vague allusions to the most ultimate generalisation
of science. We might just as well say that Canadian institutions
resemble British ones because force is persistent. This
doubtless is the ultimate reason, but our explanation would be
scientifically valueless if we neglected to observe that the
Canadian colony was founded by British individuals.
The leaf from 'Nature' arrived last night. I had previously
intended to try mangold-wurzel, as I hear it has well-marked
varieties. The reference, therefore, will be valuable to me.
Before closing, I should like to take this opportunity of
thanking you again for the very pleasant time I spent at Down.
The place was one which I had long wished to see, and now that
I have seen it, I am sure it will ever remain one of the most
agreeable and interesting of memory's pictures.
With kind regards to Mrs. Darwin, I remain, very sincerely and
most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_To Professor E. Schäfer._
Dunskaith, Ross-shire.
My dear Schäfer,--I am glad to hear that your rest has been
beneficial, and also about all the other news you give.
I should like to have your opinion about the meaning of the
following facts.
In Sarsia gentle irritation of a tentacle or an eye-speck causes
the _polypite_ to respond, but not the bell (stronger irritation,
of course, causes both to respond); this seems to show that there
are nervous connections between the eye-specks and the polypite.
By introducing cuts between former and latter, these connections
may be destroyed--the tolerance of the tissue to such sections
being variable in different cases, but never being anything
remarkable. So far, then, the matter seems favourable to the
nerve-plexus theory.
In another disc-shaped species of naked-eyed Medusæ with a long
polypite, which I have called _Tiaropsis indicans_, from its
habit of applying this long polypite to any part of the bell
which is being injured, the _localising_ function of the polypite
is destroyed as regards any area of bell-tissue between which
and the polypite a circumferential section has been introduced.
In other words, the connections between the bell and the
polypite, on which localising function of the latter depends,
are exclusively radial. But not so the connections between the
bell and the polypite, which render it possible for the one to be
aware that something is wrong _somewhere_ in the other. For if
the whole animal be cut into a spiral with the polypite at one
end, irritation of the other end of the spiral, or any part of
its length, causes the polypite to sway about from side to side
trying to find the offending body. And here it is important to
observe that wherever a portion of one of the radial tubes occurs
in the course of the spiral, irritation of that portion causes
a much stronger response on the part of the polypite than does
irritation of any of the general bell-tissue, even though this be
situated much nearer to the polypite. This seems to show that the
nervous plexus, if present, has its constituent fibres aggregated
into trunks in the course of the nutriment tubes.
Thus far, then, I should be inclined to adopt the nerve-plexus
theory. But lastly, we come to another species with a very
large bell and a very small polypite. Irritation of margin or
radial tubes causes the animal to go into a violent spasm, but
irritation of the general muscular layer only causes an ordinary
locomotor contraction. On cutting the whole animal into a spiral,
and irritating the extreme end of several marginal strips,
the entire muscular part of the spiral goes into spasm. On
interposing a great number of interdigitating cuts in the course
of the spiral, there is no difference in these results. Now the
question is, What is the nature of the tissue that conducts
impressions from the ganglionic tissue to the muscular, making
the latter go into a spasm? A spasm is as different as possible
from an ordinary contraction, and will continue to pass long
after the ordinary contractions have been blocked by severity
of section. It is scarcely possible to suppose a nerve-plexus
here--the tolerance towards section being so great, although it
varies in different cases. Besides, suppose this to be a segment
of animal cut as represented. On irritating margin at _a_ all
the bell goes into a spasm, and it is evident that whatever the
nature of the conductile tissue, all the connections must pass
through the tract of tissue at _b_. Yet on irritating that tract
no spasm is given. I cannot understand this on any view as to the
nature of the conductile tissue.
[Illustration: FIG. 1.]
Altogether, then, this part of the inquiry is very perplexing.
Other parts are definite enough. All the poisons, for instance,
yield very definite results, which are in conformity with their
actions elsewhere.
I have had no time to do anything at the histology as yet. Would
it be worth while for me to send you various species in a little
sea water? They would arrive in a tolerably fresh condition,
but would require to be examined at once. I might try sending
some in spirit and others in chromic acid. I have made a few
preliminary experiments with the galvanometer on Sarsia, placing
one electrode on the margin and another on the muscular sheet,
but without any decided results. I also tried placing a Sarsia in
one beaker and simple sea water in another, connecting by means
of the electrodes, but no disturbance was observable.
June 4.
I am working very hard just now, as there are so many irons to
keep hot at once. It is too soon yet to see the results of spring
grafting on the many plants I have operated on, and I have not
had time to do anything with animals since I left London.
The Medusæ have now come on in their legion, and occupy my
undivided attention. The results so far have proved as definite
as they are interesting and important. The following is a summary
of the principal.
All genera of naked-eyed yet examined become immediately and
permanently paralysed (except polypite) upon excision of margin,
but not so with the covered-eyed.
The organism thus mutilated responds with a single contraction
to a nip with the forceps, also to various chemical stimuli. The
chain of ganglia do the same, and further resemble the mutilated
organism in contracting once to both make and break of direct
or of induced shock. They differ, however, in one important
particular: the severed margin retains its sensibility to the
induced shock much longer than to the direct, while with the
necto-calyx the converse is the case--the latter responding
vigorously to make and break of direct current after it has
ceased to be affected by even interrupted current with secondary
coil pushed up to zero (one cell).
A strange and, so far as I am aware, an unparalleled phenomenon
is sometimes manifested by Sarsia after removal of ganglia. It
only happens in about one case out of ten, and _never_ except in
response to either chemical or electrical stimulation. A bell
quite paralysed, and which may have responded normally enough
to stimulation for a number of times, suddenly begins an active
shivering motion, which may last from a minute to half an hour.
This motion is totally different from anything exhibited by the
animal when alive, and after ceasing never recommences without
fresh stimulation. The shivering appearance, I think, is due to
the various systems of muscles contracting without co-ordination,
but why it should take place in some cases and not in others, I
am quite unable to determine.
Irritability of bell to shocks increases progressively from
centre to circumference, and is greatest when electrodes are
placed on marginal canal. Also a similar progressive increase
is observable on approaching one of the _radial_ canals, and
is greatest when electrodes are placed on one of these. (I may
observe that however neat a person's fingers may be it would be
simply impossible to conduct these and other observations of the
same nature without a mechanical stage. The electrodes must be
needle-points passed through cords, the latter being supported
by a copper wire fixed to the stage, and therefore moveable with
it; and I defy anybody to get the electrodes into the field, and
at the same time upon the marginal canal, unless they all move
together.)
[Illustration: FIG. 2.]
Sarsia stands an astonishing amount of section without losing
nervous conductibility. For instance, the whole organism may be
cut into a three-turned spiral, and on irritating the end, the
whole contracts; yet a moment's thought will show how trying
this mode of section is to nervous connections. As the animal
may be cut, as in the following diagram, which represents the
whole organism in projection--the dotted lines being the canals,
and the thick ones the cuts--on now irritating any part of the
animal, the whole contracts, but the co-ordination power is lost,
both in spontaneous contraction and for those in response to
stimuli.
If the entire margin be cut out in a continuous piece save a
small portion to unite it with the bell, and if the distal end
be now irritated, a main of contraction runs along the entire
severed part till it arrives at the small united part, when
the whole bell contracts. I should like to try whether under
such circumstances the margin would be thrown into a state of
electrotonus, but only having one cell I am not able to make out
this point satisfactorily.
The severed margin continues its rhythmical contractions for
two or three days. I am now trying the effect of different
chemical stimuli, and if you can suggest any further line of
experimentation, of course I shall be very pleased. Only, if
you can think of anything which might be tried and which is
not mentioned in this letter, please write soon, as the Sarsia
will not last much longer, and they are the best adapted for my
purposes.
I remain, very sincerely yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
P.S.--I should have said that neither gold nor silver brings out
any nervous tissue.
Medusa muscle is not doubly refracting, but then none that I
have here seen is striated, and unstriated muscle is not doubly
refracting anywhere, is it?
Dunskaith: June 24.
Many thanks for your long and suggestive letter. The poisons
also are most acceptable. I have waited before writing to try
effect of the latter, but the weather has been so stormy that no
jelly-fish could be got.
The most interesting observations I have made since writing
before are the following. Unmutilated Sarsia in a dark room seek
a beam of light thrown into the bell-jar containing them, and
this as keenly as do moths. But when the so-called eye-specks are
cut out, the animal no longer cares for light.
I have only come across two species of luminous Medusæ--both, I
believe, as yet undescribed--and in these the light is emitted
from the margin alone, and, with electrical stimulus, is strictly
confined to the intra-polar regions, being strongest at the two
poles.
There is no doubt at all about the muscular nature of the fibres
we saw. In the larger kinds of Medusæ (the covered-eyed) these
fibres are much coarser, and are clearly seen to be arranged in
concentric bundles, having four or five fibres in each bundle.
Alternating with these bundles, and about the same width as
these, are strands of undifferentiated protoplasm. These strands
are not spontaneously contractile, although their dimensions
are altered by the contraction of the muscular branch on each
of their sides. No part of the tissue is doubly refracting in
the fresh state. Is there any way of treating it with a view
of bringing out this property if latent, so to speak? The
peculiarity is not due to the _transparency_ of the tissue, for
I find that the muscular fibre of the transparent osseous fish
_Leptocephalus_ is as doubly-refracting as could be wished. There
are no signs of striæ, but Agassiz says that in some of the
Mediterranean species striæ are well marked. But if both striated
and unstriated fibres are elsewhere doubly-refracting, it does
not, I suppose, much signify whether or not the muscles of Medusæ
are striated--so far, I mean, as the peculiarity in question is
concerned.
I wish you would say what you think about this peculiarity in
relation to a subject that I have been working up. You no doubt
remember that in ----'s paper that we heard read, he said that
the snail's heart had no nerves or ganglia, but nevertheless
behaved like nervous tissue in responding to electrical
stimulation. He hence concluded that in undifferentiated tissue
of this kind, nerve and muscle were, so to speak, amalgamated.
Now it was principally with the view of testing this idea about
'physiological continuity' that I tried the mode of spiral and
other sections mentioned in my last letter. The result of these
sections, it seems to me, is to preclude, on the one hand, the
supposition that the muscular tissue of Medusæ is merely muscular
(for no muscle would respond to local stimulus throughout its
substance when so severely cut), and, on the other hand, the
supposition of a nervous plexus (for this would require to be
so very intricate, and the hypothesis of scattered cells is
without microscopical evidence here or elsewhere). I think,
therefore, that we are driven to conclude that the muscular
tissue of Medusæ, though more differentiated into _fibres_ than
is the contractile tissue of the snail's heart, is, as much as
the latter, an instance of 'physiological continuity.' (Whether
or not the interfascicular protoplasmic substance before
spoken of is the seat of this physiological continuity is here
immaterial.) Dr. Foster fully agrees with me in this deduction
from my experiments, and is very pleased about the latter, thus
affording additional support to his views. But what I want to ask
you is, supposing the interfascicular substance to have no share
in conducting stimulus (and I have no evidence of its presence
in Sarsia), and hence that the properties of nerve and muscle
are united in the contractile fibres of Medusæ--supposing this,
do you think that the peculiarity you observed in the molecular
conformation of this tissue, considered as muscular, is likely to
have anything to do with this peculiarity in its function?
I know you do not like theory, so I shall return to fact. There
can be no doubt whatever that the seat of spontaneity is as
much localised in the margin as the sensibility to stimulus
is diffused throughout the bell. There _must_, therefore, be
some structural difference in the tissue here to correspond to
this great functional difference. Agassiz is very positive in
describing a chain of cells running round the inner part of the
marginal canal. Now, although I sometimes see a thin cord-like
appearance here, I should not dare to say it was nervous. Gold
certainly stains it, but it also stains many other parts of the
tissue, and until I can see _cells_ here I cannot be sure about
a _visible_ nervous cord. The cord I do see may be the wall of
the marginal canal. I intend to persevere, however, trying your
suggestions, also osmic acid.
I can get no indications of electrical disturbance during
contraction in the way you suggest--at least not with Sarsia; but
I intend to try with some of the larger Medusæ.
Some apparatus is coming from Cambridge to enable me to test
for electrotonus and Pflüger's law. I shall apply it to the
luminous Medusæ also, whose light, I forgot to say, is seen under
the microscope in the dark to proceed not only from the margin
alone, but from that particular part of the margin where Agassiz
describes his chain of nervous cells.
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
Down, Beckenham, Kent: July 18, 1875.
I have been much interested by your letter, and am truly
delighted at the prospect of success. Such energy as yours is
almost sure to command victory. The world will be much more
influenced by experiments on animals than on plants. But in
any case I think a large number of successful results will be
necessary to convince physiologists. It is rash to be sanguine,
but it will be splendid if you succeed. My object in writing has
been to say that it has only just occurred to me that I have not
sent you a copy of my 'Insectivorous Plants;' if you would care
to have a copy, and do not possess one, send me a postcard, and
one shall be sent. If I do not hear, I shall understand.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
Dunskaith, Nigg P.O., Ross-shire, N.B.: July 20, 1875.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--Your letter arrived just in time to prevent
my sending an order to my bookseller for 'Insectivorous Plants,'
for, of course, it is needless to say that I shall highly value
a copy from yourself. At first I intended to wait until I should
have more time to enjoy the work, but a passage in this week's
'Nature' determined me to get a copy at once. This passage was
one about reflex action, and I am very anxious to see what you
say about this, because in a paper I have prepared for the 'B.A.'
on Medusæ I have had occasion to insist upon the occurrence of
reflex action in the case of these, notwithstanding the absence
of any distinguishable system of afferent and efferent nerves.
But as physiologists have been so long accustomed to associate
the phenomena of reflex action with some such distinguishable
system, I was afraid that they might think me rather audacious in
propounding the doctrine, that there is such a thing as reflex
action without well-defined structural channels for it to occur
in. But if you have found something of the same sort in _plants_,
of course I shall be very glad to have your authority to quote.
And I think it follows deductively from the general theory of
evolution, that reflex action ought to be present before the
lines in which it flows are sufficiently differentiated to become
distinguishable as nerves.
I am very glad that you are pleased with my progress so far.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
Down, Beckenham, Kent: Sept. 24.
I shall be very glad to propose you for Linnean Soc., as I have
just done for my son Francis. There is no doubt about your
election. I have written for blank form. Please let me have your
title, B.A. or M.A., and title of any book or papers, to which I
could add 'various contributions to "Nature."' Also shall I say
'attached to Physiology and Zoology'? When I have signed whole,
shall I send a paper to Hooker and others at Kew; or do you wish
it sent to some one else for signature? Three signatures are
required. The paper will have to be read twice or thrice when
Soc. meets in November. But you could get books out of library or
out of that of Royal Soc. by my signature or that of any other
member.
I am terribly sorry about the onions, as I expected great things
from them, the seeds coming, I believe, always true. As tubers of
potatoes graft so well, would it not be good to try other tubers
as of dahlias and other plants? I have been re-writing a large
portion of the chapter on Pangenesis, and it has been awfully
hard work. I will, of course, send you a copy when the work is
printed. How I do hope that your fowls will survive! F. Galton
was here for a few hours yesterday; I see that he is much less
sceptical about Pangenesis than he was.
Dunskaith, Nigg, Ross-shire, N.B., Sept. 29, 1875.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--Many thanks for your kind letter. I am an
M.A. and a fellow of the Philosophical Society of Cambridge,
but otherwise I am nothing, nor have I any publication worth
alluding to. I suppose, however, this will not matter if I am
proposed by yourself, Dr. Hooker, and Mr. Dyer. I think there
would be no harm in saying 'attached to Physiology and Zoology.'
I may read a paper before the Linnean next November on some new
species of Medusæ, but I think it is better not to allude to any
contributions in advance.
Your letter about Pangenesis made me long for success more even
than does the biological importance of the problem.[8] Yesterday
I dug up all my potatoes. Some of the produce looked suspicious,
but more than this I should not dare to say. By this post I send
you a box containing some of the best specimens, thinking you may
like to see them. The lots marked A and B are sent for comparison
with the others, being the kinds I grafted together. If you think
it worth while to have the eyes of any of the other lots planted,
you might either do so yourself or send them back to me. Lot C is
the queerest, and to my perhaps too partial eye looks very like
a mixture. In the case of this graft the seed potato was rotten
when dug up yesterday, and this may account for the small size
of the tubers sent.
I did try dahlias and peonies, but in the former the 'finger and
toe' shape of the tubers, with the eyes situated in the worst
parts for cutting out clearly, prevented me from getting adhesion
in any one case. With the peonies I was too late in beginning.
It was also too late in the year when I began Pangenesis to try
the spring flowers, but I hope to do so extensively this winter.
Next year I shall try grafting beets and mangolds by cutting the
young white root into a square shape and placing four red roots
all round. In this way the white one will have a maximum surface
exposed to the influence of the red ones. I shall also try
grafting the crown of the red in the root of the white variety,
and _vice versâ_. I have already done this very successfully with
carrots--making a little hole in the top of the root, and fitting
in the crown like a cork in a bottle.
I shall look forward with great interest to the appearance of
the new edition of the 'Variation.' I only wish I had begun
Pangenesis a year earlier, when perhaps by this time the
graft-hybrid question might have been settled. Perhaps, however,
it is as well to have this question once more presented in its
_a priori_ form, for if it can soon afterwards be proved that a
graft hybrid is possible, the theoretical importance of the fact
may be more generally appreciated.
A day or two ago I saw on a farm near this a beautiful specimen
of striping on a horse. The animal is a dark dun cob, with a very
divided shoulder stripe coming off from the spinal one on either
side. Each shoulder stripe then divides into three prongs, and
each prong ends in a sharp point. All the legs are black as far
as the knees (_carpi_ and _tarsi_), and above the black part for
a considerable distance all four legs are deeply marked with
numerous stripes. I can get no history of parentage. If you would
like a drawing I can send one, but perhaps you have already as
many cases as you want in the 'Variation.'
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_To Professor E. Schäfer._
Dunskaith: Sept. 1875.
My dear Schäfer,--I have to apologise for having left your last
letter so long unanswered, but there has really been nothing
going on here to make it worth while writing.
I gave my careful consideration to all you said about publishing,
and at one time nearly decided to wait another year. But
eventually I sent in the paper.[9] It seems to me that the
histology can very well wait for future treatment--that its
absence is not sufficient justification for withholding the
results I have already observed. These results, after all,
are the most important; for they prove that some structural
modification there _must_ be; whether or not this modification
is _visible_ is of subordinate interest. Besides, I do not,
of course, intend to abandon the microscopical part of the
subject altogether. In my view, inquiry into function in this
case must certainly always precede inquiry into structure; for
although, when all the work shall have been collected into one
monograph, the histology must occupy the first place in order of
presentation, very little way could have been made by following
this order of investigation.
I also had to reflect, that if I postponed publication, it would
be impossible to expect the R.S. to publish the results _in
extenso_,--_i.e._, I should have to bring out the work through
some other medium.
And in addition to all this, there came a letter from Foster
preaching high morality about it being the duty of all scientific
workers to give their results to others as soon as possible.
As I said before, I thank you very much for the consideration and
advice you have given, but I know that you would not like me to
feel that the expression of your opinion in a matter with which
you are not so fully acquainted as myself should lay me under any
obligation to be led by it, after mature consideration seemed to
show that the best course for me to follow was the one which I
took.
Hoping soon to see you, I remain, very sincerely yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
P.S.--I forgot to say that I acted upon your suggestion about the
Linnean, and have been proposed by Darwin, Hooker, and Huxley.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
Down, Beckenham, Kent: July 12, 1875.
I am correcting a second edition of 'Var. under Dom.,' and
find that I must do it pretty fully. Therefore I give a short
abstract of potato graft hybrids, and I want to know whether I
did not send you a reference about beet. Did you look to this,
and can you tell me anything about it? I hope with all my heart
that you are getting on pretty well with your experiments; I have
been led to think a good deal on the subject, and am convinced
of its high importance, though it will take years of hammering
before physiologists will admit that the sexual organs only
collect the generative elements.
The edition will be published in November, and then you will see
all that I have collected, but I believe that you saw all the
more important cases. The case of vine in 'Gardeners' Chronicle'
which I sent you I think may only be a bud-variation, not due to
grafting.
I have heard indirectly of your splendid success with nerves of
Medusæ. We have been at Abinger Hall for a month for rest which I
much required, and I saw there the cut-leaved vine, which seems
splendid for graft hybridisation.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
_To C. Darwin_, _Esq._
Dunskaith: July 14, 1875.
I was very glad to receive your letter, having been previously
undecided whether to write and let you know how I am getting on,
or to wait until I got a veritable hybrid.
In one of your letters you advised me to look up the 'beet'
case, but I could nowhere find any references to it. Dr. Hooker
told me that although he could not then remember the man's name,
he remembered that the experimenter did not save the seed, but
dug up his roots for exhibition. I forget whether it was Dr.
Masters, Bentham, or Mr. Dyer who told me that the experiment
had been performed in Ireland, although they could not remember
by whom. But if the experimenter did not save the seed, the mere
fact of his sticking two roots together would have no bearing on
Pangenesis, and so I did not take any trouble to find out who the
experimenter was.
As you have heard about the Medusæ, I fear you will infer that
they must have diverted my attention from Pangenesis; but
although it is true that they have consumed a great deal of
time and energy, I have done my best to keep Pangenesis in the
foreground.
The _proximate_ success of my grafting is all that I can desire,
although, of course, it is as yet too early in the year to know
what the _ultimate_ success will be. I mean that, although I
cannot yet tell whether the tissue of one variety is affecting
that of the other, I have obtained intimate adhesion in the great
majority of experiments. Potatoes, however, are an exception,
for at first I began with a method which I thought very cunning,
and which I still think would have been successful but for one
little oversight. The method was to punch out the eyes with an
electroplated cork-borer, and replace them in a flat-bottomed
hole of a slightly smaller size made with another instrument in
the other tuber. The fit, of course, was always perfect; but
what I went wrong in was not having the cork-borers made of the
best steel; for after I got about one hundred potatoes planted
out, I found that the inserted plugs did not adhere. I therefore
tried some sections with an exceedingly sharp knife that surgeons
use for amputating, and the surfaces cut with this always adhered
under pressure. The knife, however, must be set up in a guide,
in order to get the surfaces perfectly flat. Next year I shall
get cork-borers made of the same steel as this knife is made
of, and then hope to turn out graft-hybrids by the score. Even
this year, however, a great many of my potatoes are coming up,
so I hope that some of the eyes may have struck. I think it is
desirable to get some easy way of experimenting with potatoes
(such as the cork-boring plan), and one independent of delicacy
in manipulation, for then everybody could verify the results for
himself, and not, as now, look with suspicion upon the success of
other people.
With beans I get very good adhesion of the young shoots, but the
parts which grow after the operation always continue separate. In
some cases I am trying a succession of operations as the plant
grows.
With beetroots and mangold-wurzel of all varieties, adhesion is
certain to occur with my method of getting up great pressure by
allowing the plants to grow for a few days inside the binding. I
have therefore made grafts of all ages, beginning with roots only
an inch or two long and as thin as threads.
The other vegetables also are doing well, but with flowers I have
had no success. The vine-cuttings were too young to do anything
with this year, but I hear from my cousin, who has charge
of them, that they are doing well. They certainly have very
extraordinary leaves.
This year I never expected to be more than one in which to gain
experience, for embryo grafting, as it has never been tried by
anybody, cannot be learned about except by experiments. But as I
am a young man yet, and hope to do a good deal of 'hammering,' I
shall not let Pangenesis alone until I feel quite sure that it
does not admit of being any further driven home by experimental
work; and even if I never get positive results, I shall always
continue to believe in the theory.
I am very sorry to hear that you 'much needed rest,' and do
earnestly hope that you will not work too hard over the new
edition of one of the most laborious treatises in our language--a
treatise to which we always refer for every kind of information
that we cannot find anywhere else.
Dunskaith: November 7.
I have to-day sent you a beautifully successful graft. It is
of a red and white carrot, each bisected longitudinally, and
two of the opposite halves joined. You will see that the union
is very intimate, and _that the originally red half has become
wholly white_. The graft was made about three months ago, at
which time the carrots were very small, but the colours very
decided. I think, therefore, that unless red carrots ever turn
into white ones--which, I suppose, is absurd--the specimen I
send is a graft-hybrid so far as the parts in contact are
concerned. It will be of great importance, as you observed in
your last letter, in a case like this, to see if the other parts
are affected--_i.e._ to get the plant to seed if possible. This,
I suppose, can only be done at this late season with so young
a plant by putting it in a greenhouse. Perhaps, therefore, you
might pot it, as soon as it arrives, and keep it till I go up.
If you do not care, to take charge of it altogether, I can then
get a home for it somewhere in the South. It will not require a
deep pot, for I see that I have cut through the end of one of
the roots. It would be as well, before potting, to cut off the
end of the other root also, so that the one half may not grow
longer than the other, and thus perhaps assert an undue amount
of influence during the subsequent history of the hybrid. If
the plant when you get it, or after potting, shows signs of
drooping, I should suggest clipping off the older leaves to check
evaporation: having found this a good plan with beets, &c.
In the same box with the hybrid there is another carrot. This is
for comparison, it having been from the same seed and grafted
(upon the crown) at the same time as the originally red half of
the hybrid.
I am doubtful about the potatoes I sent. On looking over a number
of 'red flukes,' I find some here and there are mottled. At any
rate, I shall try other varieties next year, and not say anything
about this doubtful case.
I forgot to say that the hybrid carrot is the only specimen
of longitudinal grafting which I tried with carrots, having
been somewhat disheartened with this method by the persistent
way in which beets and mangolds refuse to blend when grafted
longitudinally. There have thus been no _failures_ with carrots
grafted in this way.
If it is not too late, I may suggest that the passage in the
'Variation' about the deformity of the sternum in poultry had
better be modified. I have this year tried some experiments
upon Brahma chickens, and find that the deformity in question
is caused by lazy habits of roosting--the constantly recurring
pressure of the roost upon the cartilaginous sternum causing
it to yield at the place where the pressure is exerted. The
experiments consisted merely in confining some of a brood of
young chickens in a place without any roost, and allowing the
others to go about with all the March chickens. The former lot
have the sternum quite straight, and the latter lot have it
deeply notched.
I write to thank you for the copy of the new edition of the
'Variation' which I received a few days ago. I am very glad to
see that you have thought my views about rudimentary organs worth
a place, and that you speak so well of them.
The chapter on Pangenesis is admirable. The case is so strong,
that it makes me more anxious than ever to get positive results
in this year's experiments. I mean there seems less doubt
than ever that such results must be obtainable if one hammers
long enough. I did not know that there were so many cases of
graft-hybridisation in potatoes. Perhaps it will be better this
year to give one's _main_ energies to other vegetables.
I find that a German, Dr. Eimer, is on the scent of the
jelly-fish, but he does not seem to have done much work as
yet. It is arranged that I am to have a Friday evening at the
Institution soon after Easter, to tell the people about my own
work.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
6 Queen Anne Street: April 29, 1876.
I must have the pleasure of saying that I have just heard that
your lecture was a splendid success in all ways. I further hear
that you were as cool as the Arctic regions. It is evident
that there is no occasion for you to feel your pulse under the
circumstances which we discussed.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
I write to thank you for the slip about graft hybrids, and to
say that as yet I have obtained no results myself. This place
is too far north to admit of the seeds ripening properly after
the plants have been thrown back several weeks by the operation.
This applies especially to onions, so next year--the neck of
Medusæ having now been broken--I intend to wait in London till
all the grafting and planting out is finished. I do not think you
will regret my not having followed such a course this year when
you come to read the paper I am now writing. I never did such a
successful four months' work, and if as many years suffice to
answer all the burning questions that are raised by it, I think
they will require to be years well spent.
And this makes me remember that I have to apologise for the
inordinate time I have kept your copy of Professor Häckel's essay
on Perigenesis. Since you sent it I have scarcely had any time
for reading, and as you said there was no hurry about returning
it, I have let it stand over till this paper is off my hands.
Lankester seems to have doubled up Slade in fine style. I suppose
the latter has always trusted to his customers not liking to
resort to violent methods. His defence in the 'Times' about the
locked slates was unusually weak. 'Once a thief always a thief'
applies, I suppose, to his case; but it is hard to understand
how Wallace could not have seen him inverting the table on his
head. In this we have another of those perplexing contradictions
with which the whole subject appears to be teeming. I do hope
next winter to settle for myself the simple issue between Ghost
_versus_ Goose.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace.
Professor Häckel's paper on the Medusæ is called 'Beitrag zur
Naturgeschichte der Hydromedusen' (Leipzig, 1865). Professor
Huxley has lent me his copy, but says he wants it returned in
a week or two. I ought certainly to have the work by me next
summer, so I thought that if you happen to have it and can
spare it till next autumn, I need not send to Germany for it,
remembering what you said when I last saw you. I should also much
like to see the other paper of Häckel's about cutting up the ova
of Medusæ.
I have an idea that you are afraid I am neglecting Pangenesis for
Medusæ. If so, I should like to assure you that such is not the
case. Last year I gave more time to the former than to the latter
inquiry; and although the results proved very disproportionate,
this was only due to the fact that the one line of work was more
difficult than the other. However, I always expected that the
first year would require to be spent in breaking up the ground,
and I am quite satisfied with the experience which this work has
brought me. I confess, however, that but for personal reasons
I should have postponed Pangenesis and worked the Medusæ right
through in one year. There is a glitter about immediate results
which is very alluring.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
I will send the books off by railway on Monday or Tuesday. You
may keep that on Medusæ until I ask for it, which will probably
be never. That on Siphonophora I should like to have back at some
future time.
So far from thinking that you have neglected Pangenesis, I have
been astonished and pleased that your splendid work on the
jelly-fishes did not make you throw every other subject to the
dogs. Even if your experiments turn out a failure, I believe
that there will be some compensation in the skill you will have
acquired.
P.S.--I have been having more correspondence with Galton about
Pangenesis, and my confusion is more confounded with respect to
the points in which he differs from me.
About this time Mr. Romanes made the acquaintance of Mr. Herbert
Spencer and also that of Mr. G. H. Lewes, and of the wonderful woman
known to the outer world as George Eliot, and to a small circle of
friends as Mrs. Lewes.
Mr. Romanes was one of the favoured few who were allowed to join the
charmed circle at the Priory on Sunday afternoons. He enjoyed the few
talks he had with George Eliot, and, amongst other reminiscences, he
told a characteristic story of Lewes. One afternoon, when there were
very few people at the Priory, the conversation drifted on to the
Bible, and George Eliot and Mr. Romanes began a discussion on the
merits of the two translations of the Psalms best known to English
people--the Bible and the Prayer Book version. They 'quoted' at each
other for a short time, and then Lewes, who had not his Bible at his
finger ends to the extent the other two had, exclaimed impatiently,
'Come, we've had enough of this; we might as well be in a Sunday
school.' Both George Eliot and Mr. Romanes, by the way, preferred the
Bible version.
In one of the letters to Mr. Darwin, Mr. Romanes alludes to the
question of spiritualism, and his own determination to investigate
the question so far as in him lay for himself.
He worked a good deal at spiritualism for a year or two, and he
never could assure himself that there was absolutely nothing in
spiritualism, no unknown phenomena underlying the mass of fraud,
and trickery, and vulgarity which have surrounded the so-called
manifestations.
He was always willing to investigate such subjects as hypnotism,
thought reading, &c., and in 1880 he wrote an article for the
September number of the 'Nineteenth Century.' in which he pleads for
a candid and unprejudiced investigation of the facts. The article was
a review of Heidenhain's "Der sogenannte thierische Magnetismus."
The work on Pangenesis and on Medusæ went on through 1876, and some
letters to and from Mr. Darwin are here inserted.
_From C. Darwin, Esq., to G. J. Romanes._
Dear Romanes.--As you are interested in Pangenesis, and will
some day, I hope, convert an 'airy nothing' into a substantial
theory, therefore I send by this post an essay by Häckel,
attacking 'Pan.,' and substituting a molecular hypothesis. If I
understand his views rightly, he would say that with a bird which
strengthened its wings by use, the formative protoplasm of the
strengthened parts becomes changed, and its molecular vibrations
consequently changed, and that their vibrations are transmitted
throughout the whole frame of the bird. How he explains reversion
to a remote ancestor I know not. Perhaps I have misunderstood
him, though I have skimmed the whole with some care. He lays much
stress on inheritance being a form of unconscious memory, but how
far this is part of his molecular vibration I do not understand.
His views make nothing clearer to me, but this may be my fault.
No one, I presume, would doubt about molecular movements of
some kind. His essay is clever and striking. If you read it (but
you must not on my account), I should much like to hear your
judgment, and you can return it at any time.
We have come here for rest for me, which I much needed, and shall
remain here for about ten days more, and then home to work, which
is my sole pleasure in life. I hope your splendid Medusæ work
and your experiments on Pan. are going on well. I heard from my
son Frank yesterday that he was feverish with a cold, and could
not dine with the Physiologists, which I am very sorry for, as
I should have heard what they think about the new Bill.[10] I
see that you are one of the secretaries to this young society.
I was very much gratified by the wholly unexpected honour of
being elected one of the hon. members. This mark of sympathy has
pleased me to a very high degree.
Believe me, yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
Häckel gives reference to a paper on Pan. of which I have never
heard.
I fear that you will have difficulty in reading my scrawl.
Do you know who are the other hon. members of your Society?
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin._
Dunskaith, Nigg, Ross-shire, N.B.: June 1, 1876.
Many thanks for your long and kind letter. Also for the
accompanying essay. It seems to me, from your epitome of the
latter, that if Pangenesis is 'airy,' Perigenesis must be almost
vacuous. However, I anticipate much pleasure in reading the
work, for anything by Häckel on such a subject cannot fail to be
interesting.
I am sorry to hear that you 'much needed rest,' and also about
Frank. I had hoped, too, that you would have mentioned Mrs.
Litchfield.
Having been away from London for several weeks, I cannot say
anything about the feeling with regard to the Bill. Sanderson
and Foster think it 'stringent,' and so I suppose will all the
Physiologists. The former wants me to write articles in the
'Fortnightly,' 'to make people take more sensible views on
vivisection:' but I cannot see that it would be of any use. The
heat of battle is not the time for us to expect fanatics to
listen to 'sense.' Do you not think so?
I am sure the Physiological Society will be very pleased that
you like being an hon. member, for it was on your account that
honorary membership was instituted. At the committee meeting
which was called to frame the constitution of the Society, the
chairman (Dr. Foster) ejaculated with reference to you--'Let us
pile on him all the honour we possibly can,' a sentiment which
was heartily enough responded to by all present; but when it came
to considering what form the expression of it was to take, it was
found that a nascent society could do nothing further than make
honorary members. Accordingly you were made an hon. member all
by yourself; but later on it was thought, on the one hand, that
you might feel lonely, and on the other that in a Physiological
Society the most suitable companion for you was Dr. Sharpey.
Perhaps a 'secretary' ought not to be giving all the details
about committee meetings, but if not, I know you will take it
in confidence. It seems to me that you never fully realise
the height of your pedestal, so that I am glad of any little
opportunity of this kind to show you the angle at which the
upturned faces are inclined. I am glad, too, to see from the
inscription in Häckel's essay, that he is still doing his
best to show that in Germany this angle is fast being lost in
horizontality.
As the spring was so backward, the plants at Kew were too small
to graft before I had to leave for the Medusæ. But this does not
much matter, as I had a lot of vegetables planted down here also,
which are doing well. Pangenesis I always expected would require
a good deal of patience, and one year's work on such a subject
only counts for apprenticeship. If, by the time I am a skilled
workman, I am not able to send anything to the international
exhibitions, I shall not envy any one else who may resolve to
enter the same trade.
I am working hard at the jelly-fish just now, and have succeeded
in extracting several new confessions. The nerve-plexus theory,
in particular, is coming out with greater clearness. The new
poisons, too, are giving very interesting results. I suppose you
do not happen to know where I could get any snake poison. The
'Phil. Trans.' seem very long in coming out. I have not yet got
the proofs of my paper.
June 6, 1877.
I am very glad you sent me the extract from Lamarck, for I had
just been to the R.S., hunting up several of the older authors
to see whether any mention had been made of the theory before
Spencer wrote.
While at Down I forgot my speculations about inter-crossing, and,
therefore, although I do not think they are much worth, I send
you a copy of my notes. The ideas are not clearly put--having
been jotted down a few years ago merely to preserve them--but
no doubt you will be able to understand them. Do not trouble to
return the MS.
I had intended to ask you while at Down if you happen to know
whether stinging nettles are endemic plants in South America.
The reason I should like to know is, that last year it occurred
to me that the stinging property probably has reference to some
widely distributed class of animals, and being told--rightly or
wrongly, I do not know--that ruminants do not object to them, I
tried whether my tame rabbits would eat freshly plucked nettles.
I found they would not do so even when very hungry, but in the
same out-house with the rabbits there were confined a number
of guinea-pigs, and these always set upon the nettles with
great avidity. Their noses were tremendously stung, however,
so that between every few nibbles they had to stop and scratch
vigorously. After this process had been gone through several
times, the guinea-pig would generally become furious, and
thinking apparently that its pain must have had some more obvious
cause than the nettles, would fall upon its nearest neighbour
at the feast, when a guinea-pig fight would ensue. I have seldom
seen a more amusing spectacle than twenty or thirty of these
animals closely packed round a bunch of nettles, a third part or
so eating with apparent relish, another third scratching their
noses, and the remaining third fighting with one another. But
what I want to ask you is this. Does it not seem that the marked
difference in the behaviour of the rabbits and the guinea-pigs
points to inherited experience on the part of the former which
is absent in the case of the latter? If nettles are not endemic
in South America, this inference would seem almost irresistible.
Dr. Hooker tells me nettles grow there now, but he does not know
whether they did so before America was visited by Europeans.
Possibly there might be some way of ascertaining.
I have now made a number of grafts at Kew. In about a month, I
should think, one could see which are coming up as single and
which as double sprouts. If, therefore, Frank is going to work
in the laboratory in July, he might perhaps look over the bed
(which is just outside the door), and reject the double-stalked
specimens. I could trust him to do this better than any one at
Kew, and if the useless specimens were rejected, there would
afterwards be much less trouble in protecting the valuable
ones. But do not suggest it unless you think it would be quite
agreeable to him. If he is in town within the next fortnight, I
wish he would look me up.
June 16.
I have deferred answering your letter until having had a talk
with Mr. Galton about rudimentary organs. He thinks with me that
if the normal size of a useful organ is maintained in a species,
when natural selection is removed, the average size will tend to
become progressively reduced by inter-crossing, and this down to
whatever extent economy of growth remains operative in placing a
premium on variations below the average at any given stage in the
history of reduction.
I think I thoroughly well know your views about natural
selection. In writing the manuscript note, so far as I remember,
I had in view the possibility which Huxley somewhere advocates,
that nature may sometimes make a considerable leap by selecting
from single variations. But it was not because of this point that
I sent you the note; it was with reference to the possibility of
natural selection acting on organic _types_ as distinguished from
individuals--a possibility which you once told me did not seem at
all clear, although Wallace maintained it in conversation.
I do not myself think that Allen[11] made out his points,
although I do think that he has made an effort in the right
direction. It seems to me that his fundamental principle has
probably much truth in it, viz. that æsthetic pleasure in its
last analysis is an effect of normal or not excessive stimulation.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
Down, Beckenham, Kent: August 9.
My dear Romanes,--I have read your two articles in 'Nature,' and
nothing can be clearer or more interesting, though I had gathered
your conclusions clearly from your other papers. It seems to me
that unless you can show that your muslin (in your simile) is
rather coarse, the transmission may be considered as passing in
any direction from cell or unit of structure to cell or unit; and
in this case the transmission would be as in Dionæa, but more
easily effected in certain lines or directions than in others.
It is splendid work, and I hope you are getting on well in all
respects. The Mr. Lawless to whom you refer is the Hon. Miss
Lawless, as I know, for she sent me a very good manuscript about
the fertilisation of plants, which I have recommended her to send
to 'Nature.'
As for myself, Frank and I have been working like slaves on
the bloom on plants, with very poor success; as usual, almost
everything goes differently from what I had anticipated. But I
have been absolutely delighted at two things: Cohn, of Breslau,
has seen all the phenomena described by Frank in Dipsacus, and
thinks it a very remarkable discovery, and is going to work with
all reagents on the filaments as Frank did, but no doubt he will
know much better how to do it. He will not pronounce whether the
filaments are some colloid substance or living protoplasm; I
think he rather leans to latter, and he quite sees that Frank
does not pronounce dogmatically on the question.
The second point which delighted me, seeing that half of the
botanists throughout Europe have published that the digestion
of meat by plants is of no use to them--(a mere pathological
phenomenon as one man says!)--is that Frank has been feeding
under exactly similar conditions a large number of plants of
Drosera, and the effect is wonderful. On the fed side the leaves
are much larger, differently coloured, and more numerous--flower
stalks taller and more numerous, and, I believe, far more
seed-capsules, but these not yet counted. It is particularly
interesting that the leaves fed on meat contain very many more
starch granules (no doubt owing to more protoplasm being first
formed), so that sections stained with iodine of fed and unfed
leaves are to the naked eye of very different colour.
There, I have boasted to my heart's content; and do you do the
same, and tell me what you have been doing.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
_From G. J. Romanes._
Dunskaith, Ross-shire: August 11, 1877.
I was very pleased to get your long and genial letter, which I
will answer _seriatim_.
The 'muslin' in the hypothetical plexus seems to be very coarse
in some specimens and finer in others--the young and active
individuals enduring severer forms of section than the old.
And in exploring by graduated stimuli, areas of different
degrees of excitability may be mapped out, and these areas are
pretty large, averaging about the size of one's finger-nails.
I am rather inclined to think that these areas are determined
by the course of well-differentiated nerve-tracts, while the
less-differentiated ones are probably more like muslin in their
mesh. But the only reason why I resort to the supposition
of nerve-tracts at all is because of the sudden blocking of
contractile waves by section, and the fact that stimulus
(tentacular) waves very often continue to pass after the
contractile ones have been thus blocked.
I am sorry I made the ungallant mistake about Miss Lawless, but I
had no means of knowing. If I had known I should not have written
the letter, because I am almost sure the movements of the Medusa
were accidental, and my pointing out this source of error may be
discouraging to a lady observer.
I remember thinking you were too diffident about the bloom, but
I suppose that is the advantage of experience; it keeps one from
forming too high hopes at the first.
The rest of your letter contains glorious news. Cohn, I suppose,
is about the best man in Europe to take up the subject, and
although I cannot conceive what else he can do than Frank has
done already, it is no doubt most desirable that his opinion
should be formed by working at the problems himself.
The other item about the effects of feeding Drosera is really
most important, and in particular about the starch. I have heard
the doubts you allude to expressed in several quarters, but this
will set them all at rest. It was just the one thing required to
cap the work on insectivorous plants. What capital work Frank is
doing!
I have nothing in the way of boasting to set off against it. The
year has been a very bad one for jelly-fish, so that sometimes I
have not been able to work at them for several days at a time.
The most important new observation is perhaps the following.
[Illustration: FIG. 3.]
Suppose a portion of Aurelia to be cut into the form of a pair
of trousers, in such a way that a ganglion, _a_, occupies the
bottom of one of the legs. Usually, of course, contractile
waves starting from _a_ course along to _b_, and thence round
to _c_ and backwards to _d_. But in one specimen I observed
that every now and then the exact converse took place--viz. the
contractile wave starting at _d_ to course to _c_, _b_, and _a_.
On now excising the ganglion at _a_ both sets of contractile
waves ceased--thus showing that even in the case where they
started from _d_ it was the ganglion at _a_ which started them.
This power on the part of Medusoid ganglia to discharge their
influence at a distance from their own seat I have also observed
in other forms of section, and it affords the best kind of
evidence in favour of nerves.
On the days when I could get no jelly-fish I took to star-fish.
I want, if possible, to make out the functions of the sand-canal
and the aviculæ; but as yet I have only discovered the
difficulties to be overcome. I had intended to make a cell to
cover the calcareous plate at the end of the sand-canal, and to
fill the cell with dye, in order to test Siebold's hypothesis
that the whole apparatus is a filter for the ambulacral system;
but Providence seems to have specially designed that no substance
in creation should be adapted for sticking to the back of a
starfish.
The aviculæ are very puzzling things. I am sure Allen is wrong
in his hypothesis of their function being to remove parasitical
growths; for, on the one hand, parasites are swarming around them
unheeded, and on the other, they go snapping away apparently at
nothing. It is more easy, however, to say what they are not than
what they are.
I went a few days ago to see the vine. It is now five feet
high and vigorous, but I believe spring is the proper time for
grafting.
With best thanks for your 'boasting' and good wishes, I remain
very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
Down: June 4.
Sir Joseph Fayrer supplied me with cobra poison. It is very
precious, but I have no doubt that by explaining your motive he
would give you a little, and your best plan of applying would be
through Lauder Brunton.
Your letter has made me as proud and conceited as ten peacocks.
I am inclined to think that writing against the bigots about
vivisection is as hopeless as stemming a torrent with a reed.
Frank, who has just come here, and who speaks with indignation
on the subject, takes an opposite line, and perhaps he is right;
anyhow he had the best of an argument with me on the subject. By
the way, I think Frank has made a fine discovery, but I won't
say what, for fear it should break down. It seems to me the
Physiologists are now in the position of a persecuted religious
sect, and they must grin and bear the persecution, however cruel
and unjust, as well as they can.
I shall be very glad to hear what you think about Häckel; perhaps
I have shamefully misrepresented him. About the other subject
(never mentioned to a human being) I shall be glad to hear, but I
fear that I am a wretched bigot on the subject.[12]
Yours very sincerely,
CHARLES DARWIN.
The rest has done me much good. We return on the 10th. My
daughter is certainly better a good deal, but not up to her
former poor standard.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
Dunskaith, Nigg, Ross-shire: June 11.
We had a good laugh over some parts of your letter. I have not,
as yet, had time to read any of Häckel's book.
I am delighted to hear about the discovery, and hope, if it turns
out well, to have my stimulated curiosity satisfied with regard
to it. If it is as interesting as the observations about the
seeds, people will think Frank a very lucky fellow to hook so
many good fish in such a short time.
Not having heard his arguments about the article-writing, I am
still strongly of your opinion, and, being besides ill able to
afford any time just now, I shall not bother with it. When I
think that in this one county (Ross, and still more in Cromarty)
there are more rabbits expressly bred every year for trapping
than could be vivisected in all the physiological laboratories
in Europe during the next thousand years, it seems hopeless
to reason with people who, knowing such facts, expend all
their energies in straining at a wonderfully small gnat, while
swallowing, as an article of daily food, such an enormously large
camel.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
Down: August 10.
Dear Romanes,--When I wrote yesterday, I had not received
to-day's 'Nature,' and I thought that your lecture was finished.
This final part is one of the grandest essays which I ever read.
It was very foolish of me to demur to your lines of conveyance
like the threads in muslin, knowing how you have considered the
subject, but still I must confess I cannot feel quite easy. Every
one, I suppose, thinks on what he has himself seen, and with
Drosera, a bit of meat put on any one gland on the disc causes
all the surrounding tentacles to bend to this point; and here
there can hardly be differentiated lines of conveyance. It seems
to me that the tentacles probably bend to that point whence a
molecular wave strikes them, which passes through the cellular
tissue with equal ease in all directions in this particular case.
But what a fine case that of the Aurelia is!
Forgive me for bothering you with another note.
Yours very sincerely,
C. DARWIN.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
Dunskaith, Ross-shire, N.B.: August 13, 1877.
I thought you had given me quite enough praise in your first
letter, but am not on that account the less pleased at the high
compliment you pay me in the second one. The ending up was what
the people at the Institution[13] seemed to like best.
Pray do not think that I have yet made up my mind about the
'muslin.' On the contrary, the more I work at the tissues of
Aurelia the more puzzled I become, so that I am thankful for
all criticisms. If Aurelia stood alone, I should be inclined to
take your view, and attribute blocking of contractile waves in
spiral strips, &c., to some accidental strain previously suffered
by the tissue at the area of blocking. But the fact that in
Tiaropsis the polypite is so quick and precise in localising a
needle prick, seems to show that here there must be something
more definite in the way of conducting tissue than in Drosera,
although I confess it is most astonishing how precise the
localising function, as described by you, is in the latter. In
'Nature' I did not express my doubts, but it was because I feared
there may yet turn out to be a skeleton in the cupboard that I
kept all these more or less fishy deductions out of the R.S.
papers. Further work may perhaps make the matter more certain
one way or another. Possibly the microscope may show something,
and so I have asked Schäfer to come down, who, as I know from
experience, is what spiritualists call 'a sensitive'--I mean he
can see ghosts of things where other people can't. But still, if
he can make out anything in the jelly of Aurelia, I shall confess
it to be the best case of clairvoyance I ever knew.
I am very glad you have drawn my attention prominently to the
localising function in Drosera, as it is very likely I have been
too keen in my scent after nerves; and I believe it is chiefly by
comparing lines of work that in such novel phenomena truth is to
be got at. And this reminds me of an observation which I think
ought to be made on some of the excitable plants. It is a fact
not generally known, even to professed physiologists, that if you
pass a constant current through an excised muscle two or three
times successively in the same direction, the responses to make
and break become much more feeble than at first, so that unless
you began with a strong current for the first of the series,
you have to strengthen it for the third or fourth of the series
in order to procure a contraction. But on now reversing the
direction of the current, the muscle is tremendously excitable
for the first stimulation, less so for the second, and so on.
Now this rapidly exhausting effect of passing the current
successively in the same direction, and the wonderful effect of
reversing it, point, I believe, to something very fundamental in
the constitution of muscular tissue. The complementary effects
in question are quite as decided in the jelly-fish as in frog's
muscle; so I think it would be very interesting to try the
experiment on the contractile tissues of plants. But there are so
many things to write about that I am afraid of 'bothering you,'
and this with much more reason that you can have to be afraid of
'bothering' me.
Aurelia is, as you say, 'a fine case,' and I often wish you could
see the experiments.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
The leading Physiologists felt the importance of co-operation and of
alliance, and a society entitled the Physiological Society was formed
of which Mr. Romanes and Professor Gerald Yeo were the first honorary
secretaries.
In 1876 Mr. Romanes made his first appearance at the British
Association; he recounts his experiences in the following letter.
_To Miss C. E. Romanes._
British Association, Glasgow: Monday, 1876.
My dearest Puffin,--I have received all your letters, and had a
good laugh over them; it is evident that I must get back soon to
pilot the way. We shall indeed have a jolly time.
I have just got out from the section room, and my work is over. I
had a splendid audience both as to number and quality.
When I had finished, all the great guns had their say, Professor
Häckel leading off with a tremendous eulogium on the work, laying
special stress on the great difficulty of conducting an inquiry
of the kind, and complimenting me highly on the success obtained.
Sanderson then made a long speech, and then Stirling and Balfour,
&c.
The latter stated it as his opinion that my investigation is the
most important that has as yet been conducted in any department
of invertebrate physiology. The discussion was then cut short
by the president to leave time for the other papers, my own
exposition having taken so long. I replied briefly.
Shortly after this, Mr. Romanes delivered a lecture on the Evidences
of Organic Evolution, which he reprinted in the 'Fortnightly,' and
afterwards worked up into a little book called 'The Scientific
Evidences of Organic Evolution.' About this lecture Mr. Darwin
wrote:--
Down.
My dear Romanes,--I have just finished your lecture. It is an
admirable scientific argument and most powerful. I wish that it
could be sown broadcast throughout the land. Your courage is
marvellous, and I wonder that you were not stoned on the spot.
And in Scotland! Do please tell me how it was received in the
Lecture Hall. About man being made like a monkey (p. 37) is
quite new to me; and the argument in an earlier place on the law
of parsimony admirably put. Yes, p. 21 is new to me. All strikes
me as very clear, and considering small space you have chosen
your lines of reasoning excellently.
But I am tired, so good night!
C. DARWIN.
The few last pages are awfully powerful in my opinion.
Sunday Morning.--The above was written last night in an
enthusiasm of the moment, and now this dark, dismal Sunday
morning I fully agree with what I said.
I am very sorry to hear about the failure in the graft
experiments, and not from your own fault or ill-luck. Trollope,
in one of his novels, gives us a maxim of constant use by a
brick-maker, 'It is dogged as does it!' and I have often and
often thought this is the motto for every scientific worker.
I am sure it is yours if you do not give up Pangenesis with
wicked imprecations. By the way, G. Jäger has just brought out
in 'Kosmos' a chemical sort of Pangenesis, bearing chiefly on
inheritance.
I cannot conceive why I have not offered my garden for your
experiments. I would _attend_ to the plants, as far as mere care
goes, with pleasure, but Down is an awkward place to reach.
C. D.
(Would it be worth while to try if the 'Fortnightly' would
publish it?)
To this Mr. Romanes replied:
18 Cornwall Terrace: Dec. 2, 1877.
It was most kind of you to write me such a long and glowing
letter. In one way it is a good thing that all the world are
not so big-hearted as yourself--it would make young men awfully
conceited. Yet I value your opinion more than the opinion of
anybody, because in other things I have always found your
judgment more deep and sound than anybody's. However, I will go
to Huxley next Saturday for an antidote, as it is quite true
what he said about himself at Cambridge, that he is not given to
making panegyrics.
On the whole, as I have said, I was surprised how well it was
taken. And still more so in Yorkshire last week--where I was
lecturing at Leeds and Halifax on Medusæ, and took occasion to
wind up about you and your degree. I was perfectly astonished at
the reception you got among such popular audiences. What a change
you have lived to see! If ever human being had a right to cry
'_Vici_'--but you know it all better than I do.
About the grafts, I thought it most natural that you should not
like the bother of having them done at Down, when there are such
a multitude of other gardens belonging to do-nothing people.
But as you have mentioned it, I may suggest that in the case of
onions there is a difficulty in all the gardens I know--viz.,
that they are more or less infested with onion worms. If,
therefore, you should know any part of your garden where onions
have not grown for some years, I might do the grafts here in
pots, and bring the promising ones to plant out at Down in May.
Seed could then be saved in the following autumn. All the other
plants could be grown in the other gardens, and well attended to.
That is a very interesting letter in 'Nature.' What do you think
of Dr. Sanderson's paper in the same number, as to its philosophy
and expression? I have sent a letter about animal psychology
which I think will interest you.
With kind regards to all, I remain, very sincerely and most
respectfully (this is a bow which I specially reserve for you,
and would make it lower, but for the fear of making myself
ridiculous),
GEO. J. ROMANES.
P.S.--I fear Mr. Morley would think my lecture too long, and not
original enough for the 'Fortnightly.'[14]
Early in the year 1878, a great sorrow fell on the Romanes family.
The elder of the two sisters, Georgina, died in April, and to her
brother, her junior by two or three years, her loss was very great.
She was a brilliant musician, and had done much to prevent her young
brother from becoming too entirely absorbed in science, and in
keeping alive in him the passionate love for music which was always
one of his characteristics.
They went much together to concerts, and the house was the centre of
a good deal of musical society. Among the many musicians who came and
went may be mentioned Gounod. He had a great admiration and liking
for Miss Romanes, and used to make her sing to him. And also there
was Dr. Joachim who with characteristic kindness came in the last
days of Georgina's life and played, as only he can play, to her.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace: April 10, 1878.
Many thanks for your kind expressions of sympathy. When the
sad event occurred I had some thoughts of sending you an
announcement; but as you had scarcely ever seen my sister, I
afterwards felt that you might think it superfluous in me to let
you know.
The blow is indeed felt by us to be one of dire severity, the
more so because we only had about a fortnight's warning of its
advent. My sister did not pass through much suffering, but there
was something painfully pathetic about her death, not only
because she was so young and had always been so strong, but
also because the ties of affection by which she was bound to
us, and we to her, were more than ordinarily tender. And when
in her delirium she reverted to the time when our positions
were reversed, and when by weeks and months of arduous heroism
she saved my life by constant nursing--upon my word it was
unbearable.[15] The blank which her death has created in our
small family is very distressing. She always used to be so proud
of my work that I feel that half the pleasure of working will
now be gone--but I do not know why I am running on like this.
Of course it will give me every pleasure to go to Down before
leaving for Scotland. If you have no preference about time, I
suppose it would be best to go when you return home in May, as
the onions might possibly be then ready for grafting. Unless,
therefore, I hear from you to the contrary, I shall write again
some time between the middle and end of May.
Then came a second appearance at the British Association. Mr. Romanes
was asked to deliver one of the evening lectures at the meeting of
1878, which took place at Dublin.
The subject was animal intelligence, and seems to have excited a good
deal of attention. The following letters relate to the lecture and to
his book on Animal Intelligence:
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: June 18.
Very many thanks for your permission to use your observations, as
well as for the additional information which you have supplied.
If all the manuscript chapter on instinct is of the same quality
as the enclosed portion, it must be very valuable. Time will
prevent me from treating very fully of instinct in my lecture,
but when I come to write the book for the International Science
Series on Comparative Psychology, I shall try to say all that I
can on instinct. Your letter, therefore, induces me to say that I
hope your notes will be published somewhere before my book comes
out (_i.e._ within a year or so), or, if you have no intention of
publishing the notes, that you would, as you say, let me read the
manuscript, as the references, &c., would be much more important
for the purposes of the book than for those of the lecture. But,
of course, I should not ask to publish your work in my book,
unless you have no intention of publishing it yourself. I do not
know why you have kept it so long unpublished, and your having
offered me the manuscript for preparing my lecture makes me think
that you might not object to lending it me for preparing my book.
But please understand that I only think this on the supposition
that, from its unsuitable length, isolated character, or other
reason, you do not see your way to publishing the chapter
yourself.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
Down: June 19.
My dear Romanes,--You are quite welcome to have my longer
chapter on instinct. It was abstracted for the Origin. I have
never had time to work it up in a state fit for publication,
and it is so much more interesting to observe than to write.
It is very unlikely that I should ever find time to prepare my
several long chapters for publication, as the material collected
since the publication of the Origin has been so enormous. But I
have sometimes thought that when incapacitated for observing,
I would look over my manuscripts, and see whether any deserved
publication. You are, therefore, heartily welcome to use it, and
should you desire to do so at any time, inform me and it shall be
sent.
Yours very sincerely,
CHARLES DARWIN.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace: June 21, 1878.
I am of course very glad to hear that you have no objection to
letting me have the benefit of consulting your notes.
Most observers are in a frantic hurry to publish their work,
but what you say about your own feelings seems to me very
characteristic. Like the bees, you ought to have some one to take
the honey, when you make it to give to the world--not, however,
that I want to play the part of a thieving wasp. I will send you
my manuscript about instinct (or the proofs when out), and you
can strike out anything that you would rather publish yourself.
I shall not be able to begin my book till after the jelly-fish
season is over. This will be in September or October; but I will
let you know when I want to read up about instinct.
With very many thanks, I remain, yours very sincerely and most
respectfully,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
The Palace, Dublin: August 17, 1878.
Your letter and enclosure about the geese arrived the day after I
left Dunskaith, but have been forwarded here, which accounts for
my delay in answering, for I only arrived in Dublin a few days
ago.
I am sorry to hear about the onions, and can only quote the
beatitude which is particularly applicable to a worker in
science, Blessed is he that expecteth nothing, for he shall not
be disappointed.
But I am still more sorry to hear of your feeling knocked up. I
meet your son here, who tells me about you.
Yesterday was the evening of my big lecture, and I send you a
copy as well as a newspaper account. (The latter was in type
before delivery, and so no 'applauses,' &c. are put in.) The
thing was a most enormous success, far surpassing my utmost
expectations. I had a number of jokes which do not appear in
the printed lecture, and I never saw an audience laugh so much.
The applause also was really extraordinary, especially at some
places, and most of all at the mention of your name at the grand
_finale_. In fact, it was here tremendous, and a most impressive
sight to see such a multitude of people so enthusiastic. I
expected an outburst, but the loud and long-continued cheering
beat anything that ever I heard before. I do not know whether
your son was there, but if so he will tell you.
Hooker, Huxley, Allen, and Sir W. Thomson, Flower, D. Galton,
and a lot of other good men were present, and had nothing but
praise to give, Captain Galton going so far as to say that it
was the most successful lecture he had ever heard. So I am quite
conceited.
Ever your devoted worshipper,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
August 20, 1878.
My dear Romanes,--I am most heartily glad that your lecture (just
received and read) has been so eminently successful. You have
indeed passed a most magnificent eulogium on me, and I wonder
that you were not afraid of hearing 'Oh! oh!' or some other sign
of disapprobation. Many persons think that what I have done
in science has been much overrated, and I very often think so
myself; but my comfort is that I have never consciously done
anything to gain applause. Enough and too much about my dear
self. The sole fault that I find with your lecture is that it is
too short, and this is a rare fault. It strikes me as admirably
clear and interesting. I meant to have remonstrated that you
had not discussed sufficiently the necessity of signs for the
formation of abstract ideas of any complexity, and then I came
on to the discussion on deaf mutes. This latter seems to me one
of the richest of all the mines, and is worth working carefully
for years and very deeply. I should like to read whole chapters
on this one head, and others on the minds of the higher idiots.
Nothing can be better, as it seems to me, than your several lines
or sources of evidence, and the manner in which you have arranged
the whole subject. Your book will assuredly be worth years of
hard labour, and stick to your subject. By the way, I was pleased
at your discussing the selection of varying instincts or mental
tendencies, for I have often been disappointed by no one ever
having noticed this notion.
I have just finished _La Psychologie, son présent et son avenir_,
1876, by Delbœuf (a mathematician and physicist of Belgium), in
about one hundred pages; it has interested me a good deal, but
why I hardly know; it is rather like Herbert Spencer; if you do
not know it, and would care to see it, send me a post-card.
Thank Heaven we return home on Thursday, and I shall be able to
go on with my humdrum work, and that makes me forget my daily
discomfort.
Have you ever thought of keeping a young monkey,[16] so as to
observe its mind? At a house where we have been staying there
were Sir A. and Lady Hobhouse, not long ago returned from India,
and she and he kept three young monkeys, and told me some curious
particulars. One was that the monkey was very fond of looking
through her eyeglass at objects, and moved the glass nearer and
further so as to vary the focus. This struck me, as Frank's son,
nearly two years old (and we think much of his intellect!), is
very fond of looking through my pocket lens, and I have quite in
vain endeavoured to teach him not to put the glass close down on
the object, but he will always do so. Therefore I conclude that a
child just under two years is inferior in intellect to a monkey.
Once again I heartily congratulate you on your well-earned
present and I feel assured grand future success.
Yours very truly,
CH. DARWIN.
P.S. 28th.--Can you spare time to come down here any day this
week, except Saturday, to dine and sleep here? We should be very
glad indeed if you can come. If so, I would suggest your leaving
Charing Cross by the 4.12 train, and we would send a carriage to
Orpington to meet you, and send you back next morning. In this
case let us have a line fixing your day. It will be dull for you,
for none of my sons except Frank are at home.
The extraordinary modesty, the absolute simplicity, the fatherly
kindness, which breathe in this letter, cannot but give some idea of
what Mr. Darwin was and why he was so much loved.
Dunskaith, Ross-shire: August 29, 1878.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--I only returned here yesterday and found
your letter awaiting me.
Your letter has made me as proud as Punch, and as you have such
a good opinion of the line of work, I think I shall adopt your
plan of working up the subject well before I publish the book.
The greatest difficulty I had in writing the lecture was to make
it _short enough_, but it will be splendid to be able to spread
oneself over the whole subject in a book. I was at one time in
doubt whether it would be better to spend time over this subject
or over something more purely physiological, but of late I had
begun to incline towards the former, and your opinion has now
settled mine.
I have not previously heard of the book by the Belgian physicist,
and should much like to read it. I have already such a number of
your books that I fear you must sometimes miss them; but I can
return any of them at a minute's notice.
I had thought of keeping a monkey and teaching its young ideas
how to shoot, and wrote to Frank Buckland for his advice as to
the best kind to get, but he has never answered my letter. The
case about the lens is a capital one.
I have such a host of letters to answer, which have accumulated
during my absence, that I must make this a short one. Your
'congratulations' are of more value to me than any of the others,
and I thank you for them much.
Ever your devoted disciple,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
P.S.--Science is not a world where a man need trouble himself
about getting more credit than is due.
_From C. Darwin._
Down: Sept. 2, 1878.
My dear Romanes,--Many thanks for your letter. I am delighted to
hear that you mean to work the comparative psychology well. I
thought your letter to the 'Times' very good indeed. Bartlett, at
the Zoological Gardens, I feel sure, would advise you infinitely
better about hardiness, intellect, price, &c., of monkeys than F.
Buckland, but with him it must be _vivâ voce_.
Frank says you ought to keep an idiot, a deaf mute, a monkey, and
a baby in your house!
Ever yours sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
Dunskaith, Ross-shire, N.B.: Sept. 10, 1878.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--Having been away for a week's deer-stalking
in the hills, I have only to-day received your letter together
with the book. Thank you very much for both, and also for the
hints about Espinas and Bartlett. I am glad you thought well of
the letter to the 'Times.' In a book I shall be able to make more
evident what I mean.
Frank's idea of 'a happy family' is a very good one; but I think
my mother would begin to wish that my scientific inquiries had
taken some other direction.
The baby too, I fear, would stand a poor chance of showing itself
the fittest in the struggle for existence.
I am now going to write my concluding paper on Medusæ, also to
try some experiments on luminosity of marine animals.
Ever sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
In addition to other scientific and purely philosophical work, Mr.
Romanes had, even while writing his Burney Prize, entered on that
period of conflict between faith and scepticism which grew more and
more strenuous, more painful, as the years went on, which never
really ceased until within a few weeks of his death, and which was
destined to end in a chastened, a purified, and a victorious faith.
His was a religious nature, keenly alive to religious emotion,
profoundly influenced by Christian ideals, by Christian modes of
thought. As time went on he felt, like all philosophically minded
men, the impossibility of a purely materialistic position, and as he
pondered on the final, ultimate mysteries, on[17] 'God, Immortality,
Duty,' he arrived very slowly, very painfully, but very surely, at
the Christian position.
But these years were, to him and to many, years of peculiar and of
extraordinary difficulty. Roughly speaking, the time between 1860 and
1880 was a time of great perplexity to those who wished to adhere to
the faith of Christendom.
It is impossible to exaggerate the influence which Mr. Darwin's great
work has had on every department of science, of literature, and also
of art. Thirty-six years have passed away since the publication of
the 'Origin of Species,' and we have lived to see that again _tempora
mutantur, nos et mutamur in illis_. Now we see that a man can fully
accept the doctrine of evolution, and yet can also believe in a
personal God and in the doctrines which logically follow on such a
belief. But it was not so at first. To many on both sides the new
teaching seemed to threaten destruction to Theism, at least to Theism
as understood either by Newman or by Martineau.
Again, in philosophy Herbert Spencer seemed to many to have
constructed a lasting system of philosophy, a system sufficient to
account for all things in heaven, in earth, and under the earth.
And German criticism seemed to many to be rapidly destroying the
credibility of the early documents of Christianity.
Many a noble soul made shipwreck of its faith, nor is this disaster
wonderful. For popular theology had made many unwise, many untenable
claims, and the ground had to be cleared before the battle could be
fought out on its real issues. There were some who, amidst all the
strife of tongues, kept their heads, remembered bygone storms, and
did not lose their courage, their whole-heartedness, but they were
few, and were not over much heard or heeded.[18] For the most part,
those on the Christian side adopted the line taken by the Bishop
of Oxford in his review of Mr. Darwin's 'Origin of Species' in the
'Quarterly Review,' and in his famous speech at Oxford during the
British Association of 1860.
Certainly the outlook now is more encouraging than it was twenty
years ago.
It has been well and eloquently said by one than whom none is
more qualified to speak on this subject:[19] 'It is quite certain
that this scientific obstacle has been, in the main, removed. In
part, it has been through the theologians abandoning false claims,
and learning, if somewhat unwillingly, that they have no "Bible
revelation" in matters of science; in part, it has been through its
becoming continually more apparent, that the limits of scientific
"explanation" of nature are soon reached; that the ultimate causes,
forces, conditions of nature are as unexplained as ever, or rather
postulate as ever for their explanation a Divine mind. Thus, if
one "argument from design" was destroyed, another was only brought
into prominence. No account which science can give, by discovery or
conjecture, of the method of creation, can ever weaken the argument
which lies from the universality of law, order, and beauty in the
universe to the universality of mind. The mind of man looks forth
into nature, and finds nowhere unintelligible chance, but everywhere
an order, a system, a law, a beauty, which corresponds, as greater
to less, to his own rational and spiritual intuitions, methods, and
expectations. Universal order, intelligibility, beauty, mean that
something akin to the human spirit, something of which the human
spirit is an offshoot and a reflection, is in the universe before it
is in man.
'Or, again, a prolonged period of controversy and reflection has
resulted in making it fairly apparent that no scientific doctrine
or conjecture about the dim origins of the spiritual life of man
can affect the argument from its development and persistence. It
has developed and persisted, as one of the most prominent features
of human life, solely on the postulate of God. And is it not out
of analogy with all that science teaches us to imagine that so
important, continuous, and universal a development of human faculty
could have arisen and persisted unless it were in correspondence with
reality?
'In fact we may almost say that the obstacles to belief on the side
of science were gone when once it was admitted that God Who has
revealed to us His nature and ours, and made this revelation in part
through an historical process and in the literature of a nation,
has yet, and for obvious reasons, given us no revelation at all on
matters which fall within the domain of scientific research.
'A similar removal of obstacles must be claimed in the region of
historical criticism. There, again, it has become apparent that,
whatever turns out true about this or that Old Testament narrative,
no question really vital to the Christian religion can be said to be
at stake in this field; while in the region of the New Testament the
most sifting criticism has had a result emphatically reassuring. The
critical evidence justifies, or more than justifies, the belief of
the Church which is expressed in her Creeds.'
But this has been a hard-won fight for most--
'Friends, companions, and train
The avalanche swept from our side,'[20]
and no one felt the strain, the positive agony of soul, in greater
degree than did George Romanes. Step by step he abandoned the
position he had maintained in his Burney Prize, with no great pauses,
rather, as it seems, with startling rapidity, and with sad and with
reluctant backward glances he took up a position of agnosticism,
for a time almost of materialism. He wrote a book, published in
1876, which was entitled 'A Candid Examination of Theism.' It is
almost needless to discuss the work, as it has been dealt with by
its author in his posthumous 'Thoughts on Religion.' It is an able
piece of work, and is marked throughout by a lofty spirit, a profound
sadness, and a belief (which years after he criticised sharply) in
the exclusive light of the scientific method in the Court of Reason.
His education had been on strictly scientific lines, and the
limitations of thought produced by such education are clearly
seen in that essay; 'limitations' which the philosophical and the
metaphysical tendencies of his mind soon led him to overstep.
The reaction against the conclusions of the essay set in far sooner
than has been at all suspected. Perhaps the first published mark of
reaction is the Rede Lecture[21] of 1885.
Yet anyone who reads carefully the conclusion of the 'Candid
Examination'[22] will see the note of 'longing and thirsting for God.'
There are many who abandon belief for various reasons, and who in
various methods stifle regret and call in stoicism to their aid.
There are those who really care very little about the 'ultimate
problems,' and who find the world of sense quite enough to occupy
them. And there are souls who seem to be constantly crying out in
their darkness for light, the burden of whose cry seems to be:
'_Fecisti nos ad te, Domine, et inquietum est cor nostrum donec
requiescat in te._' These last have within them the capacity for
holiness, the capacity for a real and tremendous power to witness for
the truth, to do and to suffer _pro causa Dei_. To this class George
Romanes belonged. By nature he was deeply and truly religious, and
interested and absorbed as he was in science, it is no exaggeration
to say he was just as keenly interested in theology, that is to say,
in the deepest and ultimate problems of theology. By the questions
which divide Christians he was not greatly attracted, and he never
could see any reason for the bitterness which exists between _e.g._
Roman and Anglican.
This is anticipating. In 1878 he had touched the very depths of
scepticism, and he would have rejected the idea of a possibility of
return, and would have rejected it in terms of unmeasured regret.
A letter from Mr. Darwin is interesting.
Down: December 5, 1878.
My dear Romanes,--I am much pleased to send my photograph to the
future Mrs. Romanes.
I have read your anonymous book--some parts twice over--with
very great interest; it seems admirably, and here and there very
eloquently written, but from not understanding metaphysical
terms I could not always follow you. For the sake of outsiders,
if there is another edition, could you make it clear what is
the difference between treating a subject under a 'scientific,'
'logical,' 'symbolical,' and 'formal' point of views or manner?
With regard to your great leading idea, I should like sometimes
to hear from you verbally (for to answer would be too long for
letters) what you would say if a theologian addressed you as
follows:
'I grant you the attraction of gravity, persistence of force
(or conservation of energy), and one kind of matter, though the
latter is an immense admission; but I maintain that God must
have given such attributes to this force, independently of its
persistence, that under certain conditions it develops or changes
into light, heat, electricity, galvanism, perhaps even life.
'You cannot prove that force (which physicists define as that
which causes motion) would inevitably thus change its character
under the above conditions. Again I maintain that matter,
though it may in the future be eternal, was created by God with
the most marvellous affinities, leading to complex definite
compounds and with polarities leading to beautiful crystals,
&c. &c. You cannot prove that matter would necessarily possess
these attributes. Therefore you have no right to say that you
have "demonstrated" that all natural laws necessarily follow
from gravity, the persistence of force, and existence of matter.
If you say that nebulous matter existed aboriginally and from
eternity with all its present complex powers in a potential
state, you seem to me to beg the whole question.'
Please observe it is not I, but a theologian who has thus
addressed you, but I could not answer him. In your present
'idiotic' state of mind, you will wish me at the devil for
bothering you.[23]
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park: Sunday, Dec. 1878.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--Many thanks for your portrait--not only from
myself but also from the 'future Mrs. Romanes.'
I am glad that you think well of the literary style of the book
on Theism. As regards the remarks of the supposed theologian, I
have no doubt that he is entitled to them. The only question is
whether I have been successful in making out that _all_ natural
cases must reasonably be supposed to follow from the conservation
of energy. If so, as the transmutations of energy from heat to
electricity &c. all take place in accordance with law, and as the
phenomena of polarity in crystals &c. do the same, it follows
that neither these nor any other class of phenomena afford any
better evidence of Deity than do any other class of phenomena.
Therefore, if all laws follow from the persistence of force, the
question of Deity or no Deity would simply become the question
as to whether force requires to be created or is self-existent.
And if we say it is created, the fact of self-existence still
requires to be met in the Creator.
Of course it may be denied that all laws do follow from the
persistence of force. And this is what I mean by the distinction
between a scientific and a logical proof. For in the last resort
all _scientific_ proof goes upon the assumption that energy is
permanent, so that if from this assumption all natural laws
and processes admit of being deduced, it follows that for a
scientific cosmology no further assumption is required; all the
phenomena of Nature receive their last or ultimate _scientific_
explanation in this the most ultimate of scientific hypotheses.
But now _logic_ may come in and say, 'This hypothesis of the
persistence of force is no doubt verified and found constantly
true within the range of science (_i.e._ experience), so that
thus far it is not only an hypothesis but a fact. But before
logic can consent to allow this ultimate fact of science to be
made the ultimate basis of all cosmology, I must be shown that it
_is_ ultimate, not merely in relation to human modes of research,
but also in a sense absolute to all else.'
But the more I think about the whole thing the more am I
convinced that you put it into a nutshell when you were here,
and that there is about as much use in trying to illuminate
the subject with the light of intellect as there would be in
trying to illuminate the midnight sky with a candle. I intend,
therefore, to drop it, and to take the advice of the poet,
'Believe it not, regret it not, but wait it out, O Man.'
G. J. R.
I return the papers, having taken down the references. The books
I shall return when read, but honey-mooning may prolong the time.
FOOTNOTES:
[1] Robert, the second son, died in childhood.
[2] Dr. Brydon resided on a small but beautiful property overlooking
the Cromarty Firth, and, after his death, Dr. Romanes rented the
place from its owners, who were distant cousins of Mrs. Romanes, in
order that 'George might have some shooting.'
[3] His younger sister records an odd experience of hers. At the
time of her brother's accident she was travelling in Spain with
her father and sister, and one day was taken suddenly ill, became
slightly delirious, and expressed great anxiety on George's account.
Afterwards, on comparing notes, it was found that the time of his
accident coincided with that of her illness.
[4] Mr. Cautley writes: 'I have never seen Romanes, under the
greatest provocation, out of temper. Always gentle, always kind,
never overbearing ... never forgetful of friends.'
[5] Prof. E. R. Lankester in _Nature_, May 1894.
[6] But he also communicated a paper to the Royal Society entitled,
'The Influence of Injury on the Excitability of Motor Nerves.' Of
this paper Professor Burdon Sanderson says that the observations were
made with great care, and that the new facts recorded have been fully
confirmed by later observers. This work was done at Cambridge.
[7] The following extract from 'An Examination of Weismannism,' pp.
2, 3, will possibly explain the theory of Pangenesis, which assumes:
1. That all the component cells of a multicellular organism throw off
inconceivably minute germs, or 'gemmules,' which are then dispersed
throughout the whole system.
2. That these gemmules, when so dispersed and supplied with proper
nutriment, multiply by self-division, and, under suitable conditions,
are capable of developing into physiological cells like those from
which they were originally and severally derived.
3. That, while still in this gemmular condition, these cell-seeds
have for one another a mutual affinity, which leads to their being
collected from all parts of the system by the reproductive glands of
the organism; and that, when so collected, they go to constitute the
essential material of the sexual elements--ova and spermatozoa being
thus aggregated packets of gemmules, which have emanated from all the
cells of all the tissues of the organism.
4. That the development of a new organism out of the fusion of
two such packets of gemmules is due to a summation of all the
developments of some of the gemmules which these two packets contain.
5. That a large proportional number of the gemmules in each packet,
however, fail to develop, and are then transmitted in a dormant
state to future generations, in any of which they may be developed
subsequently, thus giving rise to the phenomena of reversion or
atavism.
6. That in all cases the development of gemmules into the form
of their parent cells depends on their suitable union with other
partially developed gemmules which precede them in the regular course
of growth.
7. That gemmules are thrown off by all physiological cells, not only
during the adult state of the organism, but during all stages of
its development. Or, in other words, that the production of these
cell-seeds depends upon the adult condition of parent cells, not upon
that of the multicellular organism as a whole.
[8] The experiments in graft-hybridisation were to prove that
formative material (or gemmules) was actually present in the general
tissues of plants and was capable of uniting with the gemmules of
another plant and thus of reproducing the entire organism. For if
the hybrid, afterwards produced, presents equally the characters
of the scion and the stock, then formative material must have been
present in the tissues of the scion, and it is demonstrated that the
somatic tissues of the scion have exercised an effect on the germinal
elements of the stock, inasmuch as it has caused their offspring in
part to resemble it. Such facts Romanes considered to be fully in
harmony with the theory of Pangenesis, and inconsistent with any
theory which supposes that _no_ part of the parent organism generates
_any_ of the formative material.
[9] To the Royal Society.
[10] For the Suppression of Vivisection.
[11] Mr. Grant Allen.
[12] Spiritualism.
[13] He had just lectured at the Royal Institution.
[14] It was subsequently published in the _Fortnightly_.
[15] He refers to the attack of typhoid fever in 1873.
[16] Mr. Romanes carried out this suggestion, or rather his sister,
Miss C. E. Romanes, did; she kept a monkey for observation for
several months, as is recorded at p. 484 of 'Animal Intelligence.'
[17] Cf. F. Myers's 'Essay on George Eliot,' Modern Essays, p. 269.
[18] Cf. 'Life and Letters of Dean Church,' p. 154.
[19] 'Buying up the Opportunity,' a sermon by the Rev. C. Gore,
preached before the University of Oxford, and published by the
S.P.C.K.
[20] 'Rugby Chapel', M. Arnold.
[21] Now republished in a book called 'Mind and Motion.'
[22] And forasmuch as I am far from being able to agree with those
who affirm that the twilight doctrine of the 'new faith' is a
desirable substitute for the waning splendour of 'the old,' I am
not ashamed to confess that with this virtual negation of God the
universe to me has lost its soul of loveliness; and although from
henceforth the precept to 'work while it is day' will doubtless but
gain an intensified force from the terribly intensified meaning of
the words that 'the night cometh when no man can work,' yet when at
times I think, as think at times I must, of the appalling contrast
between the hallowed glory of that creed which once was mine, and the
lonely mystery of existence as now I find it, at such times I shall
ever feel it impossible to avoid the sharpest pang of which my nature
is susceptible. For whether it be due to my intelligence not being
sufficiently advanced to meet the requirements of the age, or whether
it be due to the memory of those sacred associations which to me at
least were the sweetest that life has given, I cannot but feel that
for me, and for others who think as I do, there is a dreadful truth
in those words of Hamilton, philosophy having become a meditation not
merely of death but of annihilation, the precept _know thyself_ has
become transformed into the terrific oracle to Œdipus--
'Mayest thou ne'er know the truth of what thou art.'
[23] He was engaged to be married.
CHAPTER II
LONDON, 1879-1890
Mr. Romanes married, on February 11, 1879, Ethel, only daughter of
Andrew Duncan, Esq., of Liverpool, whom he had met at the house of
her cousin and guardian, Sir James Malcolm, of Balbedie and Grange,
Fifeshire.
From 1879 to 1890 Mr. Romanes resided in 18 Cornwall Terrace, which
his mother gave up to him, and these eleven years were perhaps the
brightest and most fruitful of his life.
It is difficult to give any just idea of the extreme happiness and
pleasantness of the home life and of outward circumstances; happiness
which only seemed to increase as years went on. He grew more boyish,
more playful, and seemed to have an endless capacity for enjoyment,
for friendship, for happiness of the best and purest kind.
He greatly enjoyed society, and had full opportunities for seeing the
kind he liked best, the cream of the intellectual world of London,
and perhaps one may be allowed to say that no one was ever more
unspoilt by success, by popularity. He seemed to grow more simple,
more single-hearted each year.
The amount of work he did was very considerable. His books, 'Animal
Intelligence,' 'Mental Evolution in Animals,' 'Mental Evolution in
Man,' 'Jelly-Fish and Star-Fish,' 'Darwin and after Darwin,' 'An
Examination of Weismannism,' represent an enormous amount of reading
and thought; and besides all these, there was experimental work in
University College and in his own laboratory in Scotland, and a
succession of important articles in reviews, chiefly the 'Nineteenth
Century,' 'Fortnightly' and 'Contemporary' Reviews, and 'Nature.'[24]
It would be quite absurd to deny that Mr. Romanes liked a fair and
free fight, and there was a good deal of scientific controversy,
but he was absolutely incapable of anything but fairness, and never
imported into private life any quarrel in print. He had plenty of
stiff fights, chiefly with Mr. Thiselton-Dyer, Professor Lankester,
and Mr. Wallace, but the first two were always his friends, and with
the latter he had a very slight acquaintance. The following letter,
though it belongs to a later date, will show his feelings on the
subject of controversy:
Christ Church, Oxford.
Dear Professor Meldola,--I trust that our differences--and
_disagreements_--as presented in 'Nature,' will not disturb our
relations in private. Anyhow, I send the inclosed circular, which
I am addressing to English biologists, and hope you will testify
to your desire for 'facts' by signing the memorial.
Yours truly,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
He lectured a good deal in provincial towns, and gave several Friday
evening discourses at the Royal Institution. Lecturing, even in days
of failing health, was always a pleasure, never a burden to him.
The following letter is a mock triumphant description of a lecture
in Glasgow, written purely to amuse his wife, and provoke some mock
depreciatory remarks.
Glasgow: 1880.
Now for my news. Everything was splendid, much the best thing in
the way of lecturing that I have done since Dublin,[25] and I was
so sorry that you were not there.
First of all we had a dinner given by my host in my honour, the
guests being all the chief men in the University, including
Professor Caird[26] and the biggest of all big swells, Sir W.
Thomson.[27]
The dinner was to me highly interesting, as I talked nearly all
the time to Sir William, who is a wonderful psychological study.
We then went to the lecture, where Sir William took the chair,
and introduced me to the audience with such a glowing oration
that it would have startled you. (It quite astonished me.)
The audience being thus led to suppose that I was one of the
brightest of all bright lights, received me very warmly; I got
enthusiastic, discarded my notes, and swam along in the most
magnificent style even for me, which, you know, is the highest
praise I can bestow upon myself. I spoke for an hour and a half;
at the end the people applauded so, I felt really awfully sorry
you were not there. There seems to be a cruel fate preventing you
from witnessing my performances.
The vote of thanks was proposed by Professor McKendrick. I was
met by another storm of applause; I began to feel quite overcome.
But I said a few words with all becoming humility, and then Sir
William summed up.
Here is an affectionate outburst to his mother, written about this
time:
'When thou art feeble, old, and grey,
My healthy arm shall be thy stay,
My mother.'
_When._ But you are not yet either so feeble, old, or grey as to
make me imagine that you have lost a needful prop in the absence
of your 'peerless son!' And I am sure you are not more proud of
him than he is of you. With your eyes as bright as the bright
starlight, and your face as ruddy as the morning, I am glad you
are _my_ mother.
In 1881 Mr. Romanes was at Garvock, Perthshire. And he was for a
short time also at Oban, working with his friend Professor Ewart
on _Echinodermata_, and their joint paper was made the 'Croonian
Lecture.'[28]
This was the last bit of work on marine zoology, excepting a trifling
research on the smelling power of anemones, at which he worked with
Mr. Walter Herries Pollock, who had been tempted to make a temporary
excursion from the paths of literature into the walks of science.
They contributed a joint paper to the Linnean Society on indications
of smell in Actinia, and it is greatly to be feared, such is the
frivolity of literary men, that Mr. Pollock regarded the whole affair
as a very good joke.
The following letters describe the work of the years 1880 and 1881.
The summer of 1879 and 1880 had been spent at Westfield.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin_, _Esq._
By this post I return you Häckel's essay on Perigenesis. Although
I have kept it so long, I have only just read it, as you said
there was no need to return it at any particular time.
To me it seems that whatever merit Häckel's views may have in
this matter, they certainly have no claim to be regarded as
_original_; for I cannot see that his 'Plastidules' differ in
anything but in name from Spencer's 'Physiological Units.' Why
he does not acknowledge this, it is difficult to understand.
Anyhow, the theories being the same, the same objections apply;
and to me it has always seemed that this theory is unsatisfactory
because so general. As you observe in your letter, everyone
believes in molecular movements of some kind; but to offer
this as a full explanation of heredity seems to me like saying
that the cause, say, of an obscure disease like diabetes, is
the persistence of force. No doubt this is the ultimate cause,
but the pathologist requires some more proximate causes if his
science is to be of any value. Similarly, I do not see that
biology gains anything by a theory which is really but little
better than a restatement of the mystery of heredity in terms
of the highest abstraction. Pangenesis at least has the merit
of supplying us with some conceivable carriers, so to speak, of
the modified protoplasm from the various organs or parts of the
parent to the corresponding organs or parts of the offspring, and
the multiplication of gemmules seems to me to avoid a difficulty
with which Perigenesis (as stated by Häckel) is beset, viz. that
atavism sometimes occurs over too large a gap to be reasonably
attributed to what remains of the original 'stem-vibrations'
after their characters have been successively modified at each
'bifurcation.' But it would be tedious to enter into details.
Perigenesis, in my opinion, is 'more simple' than Pangenesis,
only because its terms are so much more general.
P.S.--I forgot to tell you, when we were at lunch, that the seed
of the grafted beets is ready for sowing; also that the vine is
now four feet high, and so, I should think, might be grafted next
spring.
_From C. Darwin, Esq., to G. J. Romanes._
Down: February 3, 1880.
I will keep your diagram for a few days[29] but I find it very
difficult now to think over new subjects, so that it is not
likely that I shall be able to send any criticisms; but you may
rely on it that I will do my best.
I am glad you like Guthrie's book. If you care to read a little
book on pure instinct, get Fabre, 'Souvenirs Entomologiques,'
1879. It is really admirable, and very good on the sense of
direction in insects. I have sent him some suggestions such as
rotating the insects, but I do not know whether he will try them.
Yours very sincerely,
CHARLES DARWIN.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
February 6, 1880.
I have to thank you very much for your two letters, and also for
the enclosures from ----, which I now return. The latter convey
exactly the criticism that I should have expected from ----, for
while writing my essay on Theism I had several conversations with
him upon the subject of Spencer's writings, and so know exactly
what he thinks of them. But in none of these conversations could
I get at anything more definite than is conveyed by the returned
letters. In no point of any importance did he make it clear to me
that Spencer was wrong, and the only result of our conversation
was to show me that in ---- opinion it was only my ignorance of
mathematics that prevented me from seeing that Mr. Spencer is
merely a 'word philosopher.' Upon which opinion I reflected,
and still reflect, that the mathematicians must be a singularly
happy race, seeing that they alone of men are competent to think
about the facts of the cosmos. And this reflection becomes
still more startling when supplemented by another, viz. that
although one may not know any mathematics, everybody knows what
mathematics are: they are the sciences of number and measurement,
and as such, one is at a loss to perceive why they should be so
essentially necessary to enable a man to think fairly and well
upon other subjects. But it is, as you once said, that when a man
is to be killed by the sword mathematical, he must not have the
satisfaction of even knowing how he is killed. Of course, in a
general way I quite understand and agree with ---- that Spencer
has done but little service to science. But I believe that he has
done great service to thinking, and all the mathematicians in the
world would not convince me to the contrary, even though they
should all deliver their judgment with the magnificent authority
of a ----.
Coming now to the diagram, I am much obliged to you for your
suggestions. The 'Descent of Man,' with all its references upon
the subject, and also your paper on the 'Baby,' were read, and
the results embodied in the diagram, so I am very glad you did
not take the needless trouble of consulting these works. By
'Love' I intend to denote the complex emotion (dependent on the
representative faculties) which, having been so lately smitten
myself, I am perhaps inclined to place in too exalted a position.
But you did not observe that I placed 'Parental Affection' and
'Social Feeling' very much lower down.
In my essay I carefully explain the two cases of Drosera and
Dionæa as being the best hitherto observed for my purpose in
establishing the principle of discrimination among stimuli, as a
principle displayed by non-nervous tissues.
April 22, 1880.
As soon as I received your first intimation about Schneider's
book I wrote over for it, and received a copy some weeks ago. I
then lent it to Sully, who wanted to read it, so do not yet know
what it is worth. I, together with my wife--who reads French much
more quickly than I can--am now engaged upon all the French
books on animal intelligence which you kindly lent me. I am also
preparing for my Royal Institution lecture on the 7th of May. I
will afterwards publish it in some of the magazines, and, last of
all, in an expanded and more detailed form, it will go into my
book on Animal Intelligence.
I went to see ---- the other day on Spiritualism. He answered
privately a letter that I wrote to 'Nature,' signed 'F.R.S.,'
which was a feeler for some material to investigate. I had
never spoken to ---- before, but although I passed a very
pleasant afternoon with him, I did not learn anything new about
Spiritualism. He seemed to me to have the faculty of deglutition
too well developed. Thus, for instance, he seemed rather queer on
the subject of astrology! and when I asked whether he thought it
worthy of common sense to imagine that, spirits or no spirits,
the conjunctions of _planets_ could exercise any causative
influence on the destinies of children born under them, he
answered that having already 'swallowed so much,' he did not know
where to stop!!
My wife and baby are both flourishing. I noticed that the latter,
at four days old, could always tell which hand I touched,
inclining its head towards that hand.
_From C. Darwin to G. J. Romanes._
September 14, 1880.
We send you our best thanks for your magnificent present of game.
I have not tasted black-game for _nearly half a century_, when I
killed some on my father-in-law's land in Staffordshire.
I hope that you are well and strong and do not give up all your
time to shooting. Pray tell Mrs. Romanes, if you turn idle, I
shall say it is her fault, and being an old man, shall scold her.
But you have done too splendid work to turn idle, so I need not
fear, and shall never have audaciously to scold Mrs. Romanes. But
I am writing great rubbish. You refer to some Zoological station
on your coast, and I now remember seeing something about it, and
that more money was wanted for apparatus, therefore I send a
cheque of 5_l._ 5_s._ just to show my goodwill.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
We went to the Lakes for three weeks to Coniston, and the scenery
gave me more pleasure than I thought my soul, or whatever remains
of it, was capable of feeling. We saw Ruskin several times, and
he was uncommonly pleasant.
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace: November 18, 1880.
Very many thanks for your kind assistance and expressions of
approval. It was stupid of me to forget your article in 'Nature'
about the geese. I now quite well remember reading it when it
came out.
Focke's book is just the very thing I wanted, as it supplies such
a complete history of the subject. If I do not hear from you
again, I shall keep it for a few days to refer to when the proof
which I have sent to press shall be returned with my historical
sketch added.
I have now nearly finished my paper on the physiology of the
locomotor system in Echinoderms. The most important result in it
is the proof, both morphological and physiological, of a nervous
plexus, external to everything, which in Echinus serves to
co-ordinate spines, feet, and pedicellariæ in a wonderful manner.
By the way, I remember once talking with you about the function
of the latter, and thinking it mysterious. There is no doubt
now that this function is to seize bits of seaweed, and hold
them steady till the sucking feet have time to establish their
adhesions, so assisting locomotion of animal when crawling about
seaweed-covered rocks.
November 5, 1880.
I was sorry to hear on my return from Scotland that I had missed
the pleasure of a call from you, and also to hear from Mr.
Teesdale to-day that you had returned to Down, owing, he fears,
to the alarming condition of Miss Wedgwood. I trust, however,
that her state of health may not be so serious as he apprehends.
On my way South I stayed for a couple of days at Newcastle, to
give two lectures on Mental Evolution, and hence my absence
when you called. I stayed with Mr. Newall, who has the monster
telescope, and 'as good luck would have it, Providence was on
my side,' in the matter of giving us a clear sky for observing,
rather a rare thing at Newcastle.
You will be glad to hear that our season's work at the
'Zoological station' has been very successful. A really
interesting research has been conducted by Ewart and myself
jointly on the locomotor system of Echinoderms, he taking the
morphological and I the physiological part. When next I see you
I shall tell you the principal points, but to do so in a letter
would be tedious.
I think it is probable that Mivart and I shall have a magazine
battle some day on Mental Evolution, as I think it is better to
draw him in this way before finally discussing the whole subject
in my book.
18 Cornwall Terrace: November 13, 1880.
I am grieved to hear from Mr. Teesdale that his fears were only
too well founded. Although I had not myself the privilege of Miss
Wedgwood's acquaintance, I know, from what I have been told by
those who had, how greatly your household must feel her loss.
I should not, however, have written only to trouble you with
expressions of sympathy. I desire to ask you one or two questions
with reference to an article on Hybridism which I have written
for the 'Encyclopædia Britannica,' and the corrected proof of
which I send. It is in chief part an epitome of your own chapters
upon the subject, and therefore you need not trouble to read the
whole, unless you care to see whether I have been sufficiently
clear and accurate. But there are two points on which I should
like to have your opinion, both for my own benefit and for that
of my readers. First, I think it is desirable to append a list of
the more important works bearing upon the subject, and if I make
such a list I should not like to trust to my own information,
lest I should do unwitting injustice to some observing writers.
If, therefore, you could, _without taking any special trouble_,
jot down from memory the works you think most deserving of
mention, I think it would be of benefit to the reading public.
_From C. Darwin, Esq._
Down: November 14, 1880.
My dear Romanes,--Many thanks for your kind sympathy. My wife's
sister was, I fully believe, as good and generous a woman as ever
walked this earth.
The proof-sheets have not arrived, but probably will to-morrow. I
shall like to read them, though I may not be able to do so _very_
quickly, as I am bothered with a heap of little jobs which must
be done. I will send by to-day's post a large book by Focke,
received a week or two ago, on Hybrids, and which I have not had
time to look at, but which I see in Table of Contents includes
full history of subject and much else besides. It will aid you
far better than I can; for I have now been so long attending
to other subjects, and with old age, I fear I could make no
suggestions worth anything. Formerly I knew the subject well.
Kölreuter, Gärtner, and Herbert are certainly far the most
trustworthy authorities. There was also a German, whose name I
mention in 'Origin,' who wrote on Hybrid Willows. Naudin, who is
often quoted, I have much less confidence in. By the way, Nägeli
(whom many think the greatest botanist in Germany) wrote a few
years ago on Hybridism; I cannot remember title, but I will hunt
for it if you wish. The title will be sure to be in Focke.
I quite agree with what you say about Passiflora. Herbert
observed an analogous case in Crinum.
November 15, 1880.
I have just read your article. As far as my judgment goes it
is excellent and could not be improved. You have skimmed the
cream off the whole subject. It is also very clear. One or two
sentences near the beginning seem rather too strong, as I have
marked with pencil, without attending to style. I have made one
or two small suggestions. If you can find my account in 'Nature'
(last summer I think)[30] about the hybrid Chinese geese [being
fertile] _inter se_, it would be worth adding, and would require
only two or three lines. I do not suppose you wish to add, but in
my paper on Lythrum, and I think requoted in 'Var. under Dom.'
vol. ii. 2nd edit. bottom of page 167, I have a good sentence
about a man finding two vars. of Lythrum, and testing them by
fertility, and coming to egregiously wrong conclusion.
I think your idea of reference to best books and short history
of subject good. By the way, you have made me quite proud of
my chapter on Hybridism, I had utterly forgotten how good it
appears when dressed up in your article.
Yours very sincerely,
CHARLES DARWIN.
I have had a hunt and found my little article on Geese, which
please hereafter return.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: December 10, 1880.
I return by this post the book on Hybridism, with many thanks. It
has been of great use to me in giving an abstract of the history.
I have read your own book with an amount of pleasure that I
cannot express.
One idea occurred to me with reference to luminous stimulation,
which, if it has not already occurred to you, would be well worth
trying. The suggestion suggests itself. How about the period
of latent stimulation in these non-nervous and yet irritable
tissues? And especially with reference to luminous stimulation it
would be most interesting to ascertain whether the tissues are
affected by brief _flashes_ of light. If you had an apparatus to
give bright electrical sparks in a dark room, and were to expose
one of your plants to flashes of timed intervals between each
other, you might ascertain, first, whether _any_ number of sparks
in _any_ length of time would affect the plants at all; and
second, if so, what number in a given time. I should not wonder
(from some of my experiments on Medusæ, see 'Phil. Trans.' vol.
clxvii. pt. ii. pp. 683-4) if it would turn out that a continuous
uninterrupted series of sparks, however bright, would produce no
effect at all, owing to the plant tissues being too sluggish to
admit of being affected by a succession of stimuli each of such
brief duration. But if any effect were produced, it would still
be interesting to make out whether this interrupted source of
flashing light were considerably less effective than a continuous
source of the same intensity.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
Linnean Society, Burlington House, Piccadilly, London, W.:
December 14, 1880.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--I am glad that you think the experiment
worth trying. As you say you have not got the requisite apparatus
for trying it, I have written to Professor Tyndall to see if he
would allow it to be carried through at the Royal Institution.
If I had known you were in town I should have called to tell
you about the Echinoderms. My paper on them is now written (70
pages), so I have begun to come here (Burlington House) to
read up systematically all the literature I can find on animal
intelligence. Hence it is that, having left your letter at home,
and not remembering the address upon it, I have to send this
answer to Down.
---- is a lunatic beneath all contempt--an object of pity were it
not for his vein of malice.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: December 17, 1880.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--Just a line to let you know that Professor
Tyndall has kindly placed at my disposal the apparatus required
to conduct the experiment with flashing light.
Frank's papers at the Linnean were, as you will probably have
heard from other sources, a most brilliant success, as not only
was the attendance enormously large and the interest great,
but his exposition was a masterpiece of scientific reasoning,
rendered with a choice and fluency of language that were really
charming. I knew, of course, that he is a very clever fellow, but
I did not know that he could do that sort of thing so well.
I have now got a monkey. Sclater let me choose one from the Zoo,
and it is a very intelligent, affectionate little animal. I
wanted to keep it in the nursery for purposes of comparison, but
the proposal met with so much opposition that I had to give way.
I am afraid to suggest the idiot, lest I should be told to occupy
the nursery myself.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
Down, Beckenham, Kent: January 24.
My dear Romanes,--I have been thinking about Pompilius and its
allies. Please take the trouble to read on 'Perforation of the
Corolla by Bees,' p. 425 of my Cross Fertilisation to end of
chapter. Bees show so much intelligence in their acts, that it
seems not improbable to me that the progenitors of Pompilius
originally stung caterpillars and spiders, &c., in any part of
their bodies, and then observed by their intelligence that if
they stung them in one particular place, as between certain
segments on the lower side, their prey was at once paralysed.
It does not seem to me at all incredible that this action should
thus become instinctive, _i.e._ memory transmitted from one
generation to another. It does not seem necessary to suppose that
when Pompilius stung its prey in the ganglion that it intended
or knew that the prey would long keep alive. The development of
the larvæ may have been subsequently modified in relation to
their half-dead instead of wholly dead prey, supposing that the
prey was at first quite killed, which would have required much
stinging. Turn this notion over in your mind, but do not trouble
yourself by answering.
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
N.B. Once on a time a fool said to himself that at an ancient
period small soft crabs or other creatures stuck to certain
fishes; these struggled violently, and in doing so, discharged
electricity, which annoyed the parasites, so that they often
wriggled away. The fish was very glad, and some of its children
gradually profited in a higher degree and in various ways by
discharging more electricity and by not struggling. The fool who
thought thus persuaded another fool to try an eel in Scotland,
and lo and behold electricity was discharged when it struggled
violently. He then placed in contact with the fish, or near it, a
small medusa or other animal which he cleverly knew was sensitive
to electricity, and when the eel struggled violently, the little
animals in contact showed by their movements that they felt a
slight shock. Ever afterwards men said that the two fools were
not such big fools as they seemed to be.
STULTUS.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: Sunday, March 1881.
I have got a lot of cats waiting for me at different houses round
Wimbledon Common, and some day next week shall surprise our
coachman by making a round of calls upon the cats, drive them
several miles into the country, and then let them out of their
respective bags. If any return, I shall try them again in other
directions before finally trying the rotation experiment.
I am also getting the experiment on flashing light agoing. The
first apparatus did not answer, so now I have invested in a large
eight-day clock, the pendulum of which I intend to make do the
flashing.
18 Cornwall Terrace. Regent's Park, N.W.: March 24, 1881.
I write to ask you what you think of the following idea as to a
possible method of attacking Pangenesis. Why not, I mean, inarch,
at an early period of their growth, the seed-vessels or ovaries
of plants belonging to different varieties? If adhesion takes
place, the ovary might then be severed from its parent plant, and
left to develop upon the foreign one.
If you think this a possible experiment, now would be the time of
year to try it. Therefore I write to ask whether you do think it
possible, and if so, what plants you may think it would be best
to try it with.
All the cats[31] I have hitherto let out of their respective bags
have shown themselves exceedingly stupid, not one having found
her way back.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin, Esq., to G. J. Romanes._
Down, Beckenham, Kent: March 26, 1881.
You are very plucky about Pangenesis, and I much wish that you
could have any success. I do not understand your scheme. Do you
intend to operate on an ovarium with a single ovule, and to
bisect it after being fertilised? I should fear that this was
quite hopeless. If you intend to operate on ovaria with many
seeds, whether before or after fertilisation, I do not see how
you could possibly distinguish any effect from the union of the
two ovaria. Any operation before fertilisation would, I presume,
quite prevent the act; for very few flowers can be fertilised if
the stem is cut and placed in water. Gärtner, however, says, that
some Liliaceæ can be fertilised under these circumstances.
If Hooker is correct, he found that cutting off or making a hole
into the summit of the ovarium and then inserting pollen caused
the fertilisation of the ovules. This has always stretched my
belief to the cracking point. I think he has published a notice
on this experiment, but forget where, and I think it was on
'Papaver.' Dyer could probably tell you about it. Perhaps your
plan is to remove one half of the ovarium of a one-seeded plant
and join it on to the ovary of another of a distinct var., with
its ovule removed; but this would be a frightfully difficult
operation.
I am very sorry to hear about your ill success with cats, and I
wish you could get some detailed account of the Belgium trials.
Yours very sincerely,
C. DARWIN.
April 16, 1881.
My manuscript on Worms has been sent to printers, so I am going
to amuse myself by scribbling to you on a few points; but
you must not waste your time in answering at any length this
scribble. Firstly, your letter on intelligence was very useful
to me, and I tore up and rewrote what I sent you. I have not
attempted to define intelligence, but have quoted your remarks on
experience, and have shown how far they apply to worms. It seems
to me, that they must be said to work with some intelligence,
anyhow, they are not guided by a blind instinct.
Secondly, I was greatly interested by the abstract in 'Nature'
of your work on Echinoderms; the complexity, with simplicity,
and with such curious co-ordination of the nervous system, is
marvellous; and you showed me before what splendid gymnastic
feats they can perform.
Thirdly, Dr. Roux has sent me a book just published by him,
'Der Kampf der Theile,' &c., 1881 (240 pages in length). He
is manifestly a well-read physiologist and pathologist, and
from his position a good anatomist. It is full of reasoning,
and this in German is very difficult to me, so that I have only
skimmed through each page, here and there reading with a little
more care. As far as I can _imperfectly_ judge, it is the most
important book on evolution which has appeared for some time. I
believe that G. H. Lewes hinted at the same fundamental idea,
viz. that there is a struggle going on _within_ every organism
between the organic molecules, the cells, and the organs. I
_think_ that his basis is that every cell which best performs
its function is as a consequence at the same time best nourished
and best propagates its kind. The book does not touch on mental
phenomena, but there is much discussion on rudimentary or
atrophied parts, to which subject you formerly attended. Now if
you would like to read this book, I will send it after Frank has
glanced at it, for I do not think he will have time to read it
with care. If you read it and are struck with it (but I may be
_wholly_ mistaken about its value), you would do a public service
by analysing and criticising it in 'Nature.' Dr. Roux makes, I
think, a gigantic oversight in never considering plants; these
would simplify the problem for him.
Fourthly, I do not know whether you will discuss in your book
on the 'Mind of Animals' any of the more complex and wonderful
instincts. It is unsatisfactory work, as there can be no
fossilised instincts, and the sole guide is their state in other
members of the same order and mere probability. But if you do
discuss any (and it will perhaps be expected of you) I should
think that you could not select a better case than that of the
sand-wasps, which paralyse their prey, as formerly described
by Fabre in his wonderful paper in 'Annales des Sciences,' and
since amplified in his admirable 'Souvenirs.' Whilst reading this
latter book, I speculated a little on the subject. Astonishing
nonsense is often spoken of the sand-wasp's knowledge of
anatomy. Now will anyone say that the Gauchos on the plains of
La Plata have such knowledge, yet I have often seen them prick
a struggling and lassoed cow on the ground with unerring skill,
which no mere anatomist could imitate. The pointed knife was
infallibly driven in between the vertebræ by a single slight
thrust. I presume that the art was first discovered by chance,
and that each young Gaucho sees exactly how the others do it, and
then with a very little practice learning the art. Now I suppose
that the sand-wasps originally merely killed their prey by
stinging them in many places (see p. 129 of Fabre, 'Souvenirs,'
and page 241), on the lower and softer side of the body, and that
to sting a certain segment was found by far the most successful
method, and was inherited, like the tendency of a bull-dog to pin
the nose of a bull, or of a ferret to bite the cerebellum. It
would not be a very great step in advance to prick the ganglion
of its prey only slightly, and thus to give its larvæ fresh meat
instead of old dry meat. Though Fabre insists so strongly on the
unvarying character of instinct, yet it shows that there is some
variability, as on pp. 176, 177.
I fear that I shall have utterly wearied you with my scribbling
and bad handwriting.
My dear Romanes,
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: April 17, 1881.
Your long letter has been most refreshing to me in every way.
I am looking forward with keen interest to the appearance of your
book on Worms, and am unexpectedly glad to hear that my letter
was of any use.
I should very much like to see the book you mention, and from
what you say about sending it I shall not order it. But there is
no need to send it soon, as I have already an accumulation of
books to review for 'Nature.'
I am very glad that you think well of the Echinoderm work.
Several other experiments have occurred to me to try, and I
hope to be able to do so next autumn, as also the interesting
experiment suggested by Frank of rotating by clockwork (as you
did the plants) an Echinus inverted upon its aboral pole, to see
whether it would right itself when the influence of gravity is
removed.
No doubt I must in my second book deal with instincts of all
kinds, complex or otherwise. Your 'speculations' on the sand-wasp
seem to me very pithy--excuse the pun suggested by the analogy
of the cattle--and I think there can be little doubt that such
is the direction in which the explanation is to be sought. I
also think that the difficulty is mitigated by the consideration
that both the ganglion of the spider and the sting of the wasp
are organs situated on the median line of their respective
possessors, and therefore that the origin of the instinct may
have been determined or assisted by the mere anatomical form of
the animals--the wasp not stinging till securely mounted on the
spider's back, and when so mounted the sting might naturally
strike the ganglion. But I have not yet read Fabre's own account,
so this view may not hold. Anyhow, and whatever determining
conditions as to origin may have been, it seems to me there can
be little doubt that natural selection would have developed it in
the way you suggest.
I have now grown a number of seeds exposed to the flashing light,
but am not yet quite sure as to the result. About one seedling
out of ten bends towards the flashing source very decidedly,
while all the rest, although exposed to just the same conditions,
grow perfectly straight. But I shall, no doubt, find out the
reason of this by further trials. It is strange that the same
thing happens when I expose other seedlings to constant light of
exceedingly dim intensity. It looks as if some individuals were
more sensitive to light than others. I do not know whether you
found any evidence of this.
I have just found that this year again I have been too late in
asking them to send me cuttings of the vine for grafting. I did
not know that the sap in vines began to run so early.
I remain ever yours, very sincerely and most respectfully,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_From C. Darwin, Esq., to G. J. Romanes._
Down: April 18, 1881.
I am extremely glad of your success with the flashing light. If
plants are acted on by light, like some of the lower animals,
there is an additional point of interest, as it seems to me, in
your results. Most botanists believe that light causes a plant
to bend to it in as direct a manner as light affects nitrate of
silver.
I believe that it merely tells the plant to which side to bend,
and I see indications of this belief prevailing even with Sachs.
Now it might be expected that light would act on a plant in
something the same manner as on the lower animals. As you are
at work on this subject, I will call your attention to another
point. Wiesner, of Vienna (who has lately published a good book
on Heliotropism) finds that an intermittent light during 20 m.
produces same effect as a continuous light of same brilliancy
during 60 m. So that Van Tieghem, in the first part of his book,
which has just appeared, remarks, the light during 40 m. out
of the 60 m. produced no effect. I observed an analogous case
described in my book. Wiesner and Tieghem seem to think that this
is explained by calling the whole process 'induction,' borrowing
a term used by some physico-chemists (of whom I believe Roscoe is
one), and implying an agency which does not produce any effect
for some time, and continues its effect for some time after the
cause has ceased. I believe (?) that photographic paper is an
instance. I must ask Leonard whether an interrupted light acts
on it in the same manner as on a plant. At present I must still
believe in my explanation that it is the contrast between light
and darkness which excites a plant.
I have forgotten my main object in writing, viz. to say that I
believe (and have so stated) that seedlings vary much in their
sensitiveness to light; but I did not prove this, for there are
many difficulties, whether time of incipient curvature or amount
of curvature is taken as the criterion. Moreover, they vary
according to age and perhaps from vigour of growth; and there
seems inherent variability, as Strasburger (whom I quote) found
with spores. If the curious anomaly observed by you is due to
varying sensitiveness, ought not _all_ the seedlings to bend if
the flashes were at longer intervals of time? According to my
notion of contrast between light and darkness being the stimulus,
I should expect that if flashes were made sufficiently slow it
would be a powerful stimulus, and that you would _suddenly_
arrive at a period when the result would _suddenly_ become great.
On the other hand, as far as my experience goes, what one expects
rarely happens.
I heartily wish you success, and remain, yours ever very
sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
Do you read the 'Times'? As I had a fair opportunity, I sent a
letter to the 'Times' on Vivisection, which is printed to-day.
I thought it fair to bear my share of the abuse poured in so
atrocious a manner on all physiologists.
_From G. J. Romanes to C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace: April 22.
I have left your last letter so long unanswered in order that I
might be able to let you know the result of the next experiment
I was trying on the seeds with flashing light. I think in the
end the conclusion will be that short flashes, such as I am now
using, influence the seedlings, but only to a comparatively small
degree, so that it is only the more sensitive seedlings that
perceive them.
Your letter in the 'Times' was in every way admirable, and coming
from you will produce more effect than it could from anybody
else. The answer to-day to ---- is also first-rate--just enough
without being too much. It would have been a great mistake to
have descended into a controversy. I thought ---- had more
wit than to adopt such a tack and tone, and am sure that all
physiologists will be for ever grateful to you for such a
trenchant expression of opinion.
I have a little piece of gossip to tell. Yesterday the Council of
the Linnean nominated me Zoological Secretary, and some of the
members having pressed me to accept, I have accepted. I also hear
that your son is to be on the same Council, and that Sir John
Lubbock is to be the new President.
I have at length decided on the arrangement of my material for
the books on Animal Intelligence and Mental Evolution. I shall
reserve all the heavier parts of theoretical discussion for the
second book--making the first the chief repository of facts,
with only a slender network of theory to bind them into mutual
relation, and save the book as much as possible from the danger
that you suggested of being too much matter-of-fact. It will
be an advantage to have the facts in a form to admit of brief
reference when discussing the heavier philosophy in the second
book, which will be the more important, though the less popular,
of the two.
Just then some correspondence had been going on in the 'Times' on
the subject of Vivisection, and Mr. Darwin wrote to Mr. Romanes as
follows:--
Down, Beckenham, Kent: April 25, 1881.
My dear Romanes,--I was very glad to read your last notes with
much news interesting to me. But I write now to say how I, and
indeed all of us in the house, have admired your letter in the
'Times.'[32] It was so simple and direct. I was particularly glad
about Burdon Sanderson, of whom I have been for several years
a great admirer. I was, also, especially glad to read the last
sentences. I have been bothered with several letters, but none
abusive. Under a selfish point of view I am very glad of the
publication of your letter, as I was at first inclined to think
that I had done mischief by stirring up the mud, now I feel sure
that I have done good....
The following letters relate to the portrait of Mr. Darwin which was
painted by the Hon. John Collier for the Linnean Society.
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: May 25.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--When at the Linnean this afternoon, I was
told by Dr. M---- that he had obtained your consent to sit for
a portrait for the Society. Now, as it appears to me a great
favour to ask of you to sit for yet another portrait, the least
we can do, if you consent, is to employ a thoroughly good man
to paint it. Therefore, if you have not already entered into
any definite agreement, I write to suggest a little delay (say
of a month), when, as Secretary, I might ascertain the amount
of the subscription on which we might rely, and arrange matters
accordingly. John Collier (Huxley's son-in-law) told me some time
ago that he would dearly like to have you to paint, and I doubt
not that he would do it at less than his ordinary charges if
necessary. He would be sure to do the work well, and so I write
to ascertain whether you would not prefer him, or some other
artist of known ability, to do the work, if I were to undertake
to provide the needful.
Please give to Mrs. Darwin, and take to yourself, our best
thanks for your kind congratulations on the opportune arrival of
another baby--just in time to be worked into the book on Mental
Evolution. Everything is going well.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: July 1.
I have told Collier that he had now better write to you direct
at whatever time he intends to make his final arrangements with
you as to place and time of sitting. He has just finished a
portrait of me, which my mother had painted as a present to my
wife. It is exceedingly good, and as all his recent portraits are
the same--notably one of Huxley--I am very glad that he is to
paint you. Besides, he is such a pleasant man to talk to, that
the sittings are not so tedious as they would be with a less
intelligent man.
I shall certainly read the 'Creed of Science' as soon as I can.
The German book on Evolution I have not yet looked at, as I have
been giving all my time to my own book. This is now finished. But
talking of my time, I do not see how the two or three hours which
I have spent in arranging to have a portrait, which will be of so
much historical importance, taken by a competent artist, could
well have been better employed.
You will see that I have got into a row with Carpenter over the
thought-reading. Everybody thinks he made a mistake in lending
himself to Bishop's design of posing as a scientific wonder.
Bishop is a very sly dog, and has played his cards passing well.
In an article which he published two years ago in an American
newspaper, he explains the philosophy of advertising, and says
the first thing to attend to is to catch good names. He has now
succeeded well.
Very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
Down: August 7.
My dear Romanes,--I received yesterday the enclosed notice, and I
send it to you, as I have thought that if you notice Dr. Roux's
book in 'Nature' or elsewhere the review might possibly be of use
to you. As far as I can judge the book ought to be brought before
English naturalists. You will have heard from Collier that he has
finished my picture. All my family who have seen it think it the
best likeness which has been taken of me, and, as far as I can
judge, this seems true. Collier was the most considerate, kind,
and pleasant painter a sitter could desire.
My dear Romanes,
Yours very sincerely,
CH. DARWIN.
_To C. Darwin, Esq._
18 Cornwall Terrace, Regent's Park, N.W.: August 8, 1881.
Many thanks for the notice of Roux's book. I have not yet looked
at the latter, but Preyer, of Jena (who has been our guest during
the Congress meeting,[33] and who knows the author), does not
think much of it.
I am delighted that the portrait has pleased those who are the
best judges. I saw it the day it came up, and feel no doubt at
all that it is far and away the best of the three. But I did not
like to write and venture this opinion till I knew what you all
thought of it.
I have been very busy this past week with the affairs of the
Congress in relation to Vivisection. It has been resolved by the
Physiological Section to get a vote of the whole Congress upon
the subject, and I had to prepare the resolution and get the
signatures of all the vice-presidents of the Congress, presidents
and vice-presidents of sections, and to arrange for its being put
to the vote of the whole Congress at its last general meeting
to-morrow. The only refusal to sign came appropriately enough
from the president of the section 'Mental Diseases.'
We leave for Scotland to-morrow, when I shall hope to get time
to read Roux's book, though I shall first review 'The Student's
Darwin.'
I remain, very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
The following letters relate to the burning question of Vivisection:--
Garvock, Perthshire: August 31, 1881.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--It is not often that I write to dun you, and
I am sorry that duty should now impose on me the task of doing
so, but I have no alternative, as you shall immediately see.
The Physiological Society was formed, as you may remember, for
the purpose of obtaining combined action among physiologists on
the subject of Vivisection. The result in the first instance
was to resolve on a tentative policy of silence, with the view
of seeing whether the agitation would not burn itself out. It
is now thought that this policy has been tried sufficiently
long, and that we are losing ground by continuing it. After much
deliberation, therefore, the society has resolved to speak out
upon the subject, and the 'Nineteenth Century' has been involved
as the medium of publication. Arrangements have been made with
Knowles for a symposium-like series of short essays by all the
leaders of biology and medicine in this country--each to write
on a branch of the subject chosen by himself or allotted to him
by the society. In this matter of organising the contributions,
the society is to be represented by Dr. Pye Smith, who combines
science, medicine, and literary culture better than any other
member of our body.
As secretary I am directed to write to all the men whose names
are mentioned in a resolution passed by the society in accordance
with the report of a committee appointed by the society to
consider the subject. Hence these tears.
Of course, your name in this matter is one of the most important,
and as the idea is to get a body of great names, it would
be a disappointment of no small magnitude if yours should
fail. It does not matter so much that you should write a long
dissertation, so long as you allow yourself to stand among this
noble army of martyrs. Two or three pages of the 'Nineteenth
Century' on one, say, of the following topics would be all that
we should want:--
'The limits and safeguards desirable in carrying on scientific
experiments on animals.'
'Mistaken humanity of the agitation: real humanity of
vivisection.'
'The Royal Commission and its report.'
Or any other topic connected with Vivisection on which you may
feel the spirit most to move you to write.
Any further information that you may desire I shall be happy to
give; but please remember how much your assistance is desired.
This is a very delightful place, though not very conducive to
work. If any of your sons are in Scotland and should care for a
few days' sport with other scientific men on the spree, please
tell them that they will find open house and welcome here.
The proofs of my book on Animal Intelligence are coming in. I
hope your work on Worms will be out in time for me to mention it
and its main results.
Ewart has pitched his zoological laboratory at Oban, so as to be
as near this as possible. I shall go down when I can to keep his
pot of sea-eggs upon the boil.
I remain, very sincerely and most respectfully yours,
GEO. J. ROMANES.
Down, Beckenham, Kent: September 2, 1881.
My dear Romanes,--Your letter has perplexed me beyond all
measure. I fully recognise the duty of everyone, whose opinion is
worth anything, expressing his opinion publicly on vivisection,
and this made me send my letter to the 'Times.' I have been
thinking at intervals all morning what I could say, and it is
the simple truth that I have nothing worth saying. You, and men
like you, whose ideas flow freely, and who can express them
easily, cannot understand the state of mental paralysis in which
I find myself. What is most wanted is a careful and accurate
attempt to show what physiology has already done for man, and
even still more strongly what there is every reason to believe it
will hereafter do. Now I am absolutely incapable of doing this,
or of discussing the other points suggested by you.
If you wish for my name (and I should be glad that it should
appear with that of others in the same cause), could you not
quote some sentence from my letter in the 'Times,' which I
inclose, but please return it. If you thought fit you might
say that you quoted it with my approval, and that, after still
further reflection, I still abide most strongly in my expressed
conviction. _For Heaven's sake_, do think of this; I do not
grudge the labour and thought, but I could write nothing worth
anyone's reading.
Allow me to demur to your calling your conjoint article a
'symposium,' strictly a 'drinking-party;' this seems to me very
bad taste, and I do hope everyone of you will avoid any semblance
of a joke on the subject. I know that words like a joke on this
subject have quite disgusted some persons not at all inimical
to physiology. One person lamented to me that Mr. Simon, in his
truly admirable address at the Medical Congress (by far the best
thing which I have read), spoke of the 'fantastic sensuality'[34]
(or some such term) of the many mistaken, but honest men and
women who are half mad on the subject.
Do pray try and let me escape, and quote my letter, which in some
respects is more valuable, as giving my independent judgment
before the Medical Congress. I really cannot imagine what I could
say.
I will now turn to another subject: my little book on Worms
has been long finished, but Murray was so strongly opposed to
publishing it at the dead season, that I yielded. I have told
the printers to send you a set of clean sheets, which you can
afterwards have stitched together. There is hardly anything in it
which can interest you.
Two or three papers by Hermann Müller have just appeared in
'Kosmos,' which seem to me interesting, as showing how soon,
_i.e._ after how many attempts, bees learn how best to suck a new
flower; there is also a good and laudatory review of Dr. Roux. I
could lend you 'Kosmos' if you think fit.
You will perhaps have seen that my poor dear brother Erasmus has
just died, and he was buried yesterday here at Down.
Garvock. Bridge of Earn, Perthshire: September 4.
My dear Mr. Darwin,--I hasten to relieve your mind about writing
on vivisection, as I am sure that none of the physiologists would
desire you to do so if you feel it a bother. After all, there are
plenty of other men to do the writing, and if some of them quote
the marked sentences in your letter (w
Showing first 200,000 characters. Full text: gutenberg.org/ebooks/49182