Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 46572

Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)

by unknown · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2014
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2) is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #46572). In this transcription, paired _underscores_ denote _italicised text_ and a ^ (caret) indicates that the next character was superscripted in the original text. Footnotes are located at the end of the book.

    INTRODUCTION

    The record of men and of movements, History teaches us the growth and development of ideas. Our civilization is the final expression of the two great master-thoughts of the race. Seeking an explanation of the pressing phenomena of life, man has peopled the world with spiritual beings to whom he has assigned benign or malign influences, to be invoked or propitiated.

    To the great ‘uncharted region’ (Gilbert Murray) with its mysteries, his religions offer a guide; and through ‘a belief in spiritual beings’ (Tylor’s definition of religion) he has built an altar of righteousness in his heart. The birth of the other dominant idea, long delayed, is comparatively recent. ‘The discovery of things as they really are’ (Plato) by a study of nature was the great gift of the Greeks.

    Knowledge, scientia, knowledge of things we see, patiently acquired by searching out the secrets of nature, is the basis of our material civilization. The true and lawful goal of the sciences, seen dimly and so expressed by Bacon, is the acquisition of new powers by new discoveries--that goal has been reached. Niagara has been harnessed, and man’s dominion has extended from earth and sea to the air. The progress of physics and of chemistry has revolutionized man’s ways and works, while the new biology has changed his mental outlook.

    The greater part of this progress has taken place within the memory of those living, and the mass of scientific work has accumulated at such a rate that specialism has become inevitable. While this has the obvious advantage resulting from a division of labour, there is the penalty of a narrowed horizon, and groups of men work side by side whose language is unintelligible to each other.

    Here is where the historian comes in, with two definite objects, teaching the method by which the knowledge has been gained, the evolution of the subject, and correlating the innumerable subdivisions in a philosophy at once, in Plato’s words, a science in itself as well as of other sciences. For example, the student of physics may know Crookes’s tubes and their relation to Röntgen, but he cannot have a true conception of the atomic theory without a knowledge of Democritus; and the exponent of Madame Curie and of Sir J. J. Thomson will find his happiest illustrations from the writings of Lucretius.

    It is unfortunate that the progress of science makes useless the very works that made progress possible; and the student is too apt to think that because useless now they have never been of value.

    The need of a comprehensive study of the methods of science is now widely recognized, and to recognize this need important Journals have been started, notably Isis, published by our Belgian colleague George Sarton, interrupted, temporarily we hope, by the war; and Scientia, an International Review of Scientific Synthesis published by our Italian Allies. The numerous good histories of science issued within the past few years bear witness to a real demand for a wider knowledge of the methods by which the present status has been reached.

    Among works from which the student may get a proper outlook on the whole question may be mentioned Dannemann’s Die Naturwissenschaften in ihrer Entwicklung und in ihrem Zusammenhange, Bd. IV; De la Méthode dans les Sciences, edited by Félix Thomas (Paris: Alcan); Marvin’s Living Past, 3rd ed. (Clarendon Press, 1917); and Libby’s Introduction to the History of Science (Houghton Mifflin & Co., 1917).

    This volume of Essays is the outcome of a quiet movement on the part of a few Oxford students to stimulate a study of the history of science.

    Shortly after his appointment to the Philip Walker Studentship, Dr.

    Charles Singer (of Magdalen College) obtained leave from Bodley’s Librarian and the Curators to have a bay in the Radcliffe Camera set apart for research work in the history of science and a safe installed to hold manuscripts; and (with Mrs. Singer) offered £100 a year for five years to provide the necessary fittings, and special books not already in the Library. The works relating to the subject have been collected in the room, the objects of which are:

    First, to place at the disposal of the general student a collection that will enable him to acquire a knowledge of the development of science and scientific conceptions.

    Secondly, to assist the special student in research: (a) by placing him in relationship with investigations already undertaken; (b) by collecting information on the sources and accessibility of his material; and (c) by providing him with facilities to work up his material.

    In spite of the absence of Dr. Singer on military duty for the greater part of the time, the work has been carried on with conspicuous success, to use the words of Bodley’s Librarian. Ten special students have used the room. Professor Ramsay Wright has made a study of an interesting Persian medical manuscript. Professor William Libby, of Pittsburg, during the session of 1915-16, used the room in the preparation of his admirable History of Science just issued. Dr. E.

    T. Withington, the well-known medical historian, is making a special study of the old Greek writers for the new edition of Liddell and Scott’s Dictionary. Miss Mildred Westland has helped Dr. Singer with the Italian medical manuscripts. Mr. Reuben Levy has worked at the Arabic medical manuscripts of Moses Maimonides. Mrs. Jenkinson is engaged on a study of early medicine and magic. Dr. J. L. E.

    Dreyer, the distinguished historian of Astronomy, has used the room in connexion with the preparation of the Opera Omnia of Tycho Brahe.

    Miss Joan Evans is engaged upon a research on mediaeval lapidaries.

    Mrs. Singer has begun a study of the English medical manuscripts, with a view to a complete catalogue. How important this is may be judged from the first instalment of her work dealing with the plague manuscripts in the British Museum. With rare enthusiasm and energy Dr.

    Singer has himself done a great deal of valuable work, and has proved an intellectual ferment working far beyond the confines of Oxford. I have myself found the science history room of the greatest convenience, and it is most helpful to have easy access on the shelves to a large collection of works on the subject. Had the war not interfered, we had hoped to start a Journal of the History and Method of Science and to organize a summer school for special students--hopes we may perhaps see realized in happier days.

    Meanwhile, this volume of essays (most of which were in course of preparation when war was declared) is issued as a ballon d’essai.

    WILLIAM OSLER.

    CONTENTS

    PAGE

    CHARLES SINGER

    The Scientific Views and Visions of Saint Hildegard (1098-1180) 1

    J. W. JENKINSON

    Vitalism 59

    CHARLES SINGER

    A Study in Early Renaissance Anatomy, with a new text: The
    ANOTHOMIA of Hieronymo Manfredi, transcribed and translated
    by A. Mildred Westland 79

    RAYMOND CRAWFURD

    The Blessing of Cramp-Rings; a Chapter in the History of the
    Treatment of Epilepsy 165

    E. T. WITHINGTON

    Dr. John Weyer and the Witch Mania 189

    REUBEN LEVY

    The ‘Tractatus de Causis et Indiciis Morborum’, attributed to
    Maimonides 225

    SCHILLER, F. C. S.
    Scientific Discovery and Logical Proof 235

    INDEX 291

    LIST OF PLATES

    PLATE FACING PAGE

    I. Hildegard receiving the Light from Heaven (Wiesbaden
    Codex B, fo. 1 r) Frontispiece

    II. The Three Scripts of the Wiesbaden Codex B (fo. 17 r,
    col. b; fo. 32 v, col. b; fo. 205 r, col. b) 4

    III. Title-page of the Heidelberg Codex of the Scivias 5

    IV. The Universe (from the Heidelberg Codex of the Scivias) 12

    V. (a) Opening lines of the Copenhagen MS. of the Causae
    et Curae
    . (b) Opening lines of the Lucca MS. of
    the Liber divinorum operum simplicis hominis 13

    VI. Nous pervaded by the Godhead and controlling Hyle
    (Lucca MS., fo. 1 v) 20

    VII. Nous pervaded by the Godhead embracing the Macrocosm with
    the Microcosm (Lucca MS., fo. 9 r) 21

    VIII. The Macrocosm, the Microcosm, and the Winds (Lucca MS.,
    fo. 27 v) 28

    IX. Celestial Influences on Men, Animals, and Plants (Lucca
    MS., fo. 371) 28

    X. A Crucifix in the Uffizi Gallery; about the middle of the
    thirteenth century 30

    XI. The Structure of the Mundane Sphere (Lucca MS.,
    fo. 86 v) 32

    XII. (a) Man’s Fall and the Disturbance of the Elemental
    Harmony (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 4 r). (b) The New
    Heaven and the New Earth (Wiesbaden Codex B,
    fo. 224 v) 33

    XIII. The Last Judgement and Fate of the Elements (Wiesbaden
    Codex B, fo. 224 r) 36

    XIV. Diagram of the Relation of Human and Cosmic Phenomena:
    ninth century (Bibliothèque Nationale MS. lat. 5543,
    fo. 136 r) 37

    XV. An Eleventh-century French Melothesia (Bibliothèque
    Nationale MS. lat. 7028, fo. 154 r) 40

    XVI. A Melothesia of about 1400 (from Bibliothèque Nationale
    MS. lat. 11229, fo. 45 v) Between 40 and 41

    XVII. Facsimile from the Symbolum Apostolicorum, a German
    Block Book of the first half of the Fifteenth Century
    (Heidelberg University Library) Between 40 and 41

    XVIII. An Anatomical Diagram of about 1298 (Bodleian MS.
    Ashmole 399, fo. 18 r) 41

    XIX. Birth. The Arrival and Trials of the Soul (Wiesbaden
    Codex B, fo. 22 r) 44

    XX. Death. The Departure and Fate of the Soul (Wiesbaden
    Codex B, fo. 25 r) 45

    XXI. The Fall of the Angels (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 123 r) 46

    XXII. The Days of Creation and the Fall of Man (Wiesbaden
    Codex B, fo. 41 v) 48

    XXIII. The Vision of the Trinity (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 471) 50

    XXIV. (a) Sedens Lucidus (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 213 v).
    (b) Zelus Dei (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 153 r) 52

    XXV. The Heavenly City (Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 30 r) 54

    XXVI. John Wilfred Jenkinson 57

    XXVII. Mundinus (?) lecturing on Anatomy (from the 1493 edition
    of ‘Ketham’) 78

    XXVIII. (a) Four Diagrams, to illustrate the Anatomy of Henri
    de Mondeville (Bibliothèque Nationale MS. fr. 2030,
    written in 1314). (b) A Dissection Scene, circa 1298
    (Bodleian MS. Ashmole 399, fo. 34 r) 79

    XXIX. A Post-Mortem Examination: late fourteenth century to
    illustrate Guy de Chauliac (Montpellier, Bibliothèque
    de la Faculté de Médecine MS. fr. 184, fo. 14 r) 80

    XXX. (a) A Demonstration of Surface Markings: second half
    of fifteenth century (Vatican MS. Hispanice 4804,
    fo. 8 r). (b) A Demonstration of the Bones to
    illustrate Guy de Chauliac: first half of fifteenth
    century (Bristol Reference Library MS., fo. 25 r) 81

    XXXI. Anatomical Sketches from the MS. of Guy de Vigevano of
    1345 at Chantilly 84

    XXXII. Anatomical Sketches from the MS. of Guy de Vigevano of
    1345 at Chantilly 85

    XXXIII. The Five-Figure Series: Veins, &c., Arteries, Nerves,
    Bones, Muscles (Bodleian MS. Ashmole 399,
    fos. 18 r-22 r): about 1298 92

    XXXIV. Demonstrations of Anatomy: second half of fifteenth
    century (Dresden Galen MS.) 93

    XXXV. A View of the Internal Organs: Leonardo da Vinci (from
    a drawing in the Library, Windsor Castle) 96

    XXXVI. Two Persons dissecting, traditionally said to represent
    Michelangelo and Antonio della Torre (from a drawing
    in the Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, attributed to
    Bartolomeo Manfredi (1574?-1602)) 97

    XXXVII. Portrait of Giovanni Bentivoglio II, from his tomb in
    the Church of S. Giacomo Maggiore at Bologna 102

    XXXVIII. (a) Roger Bacon’s Diagram of the Eye: thirteenth century
    (British Museum MS. Roy. 7 F. VIII, fo. 50 v).
    (b) Leonardo da Vinci’s Diagram of the Heart: early
    sixteenth century (from a drawing in Windsor Castle) 103

    XXXIX. Miracles at the Tomb of Edward the Confessor, from
    Norman-French thirteenth-century MS. (University
    Library, Cambridge, MS. Ee. iii. 59) 166

    XL. Queen Mary Tudor blessing Cramp-Rings (from Queen
    Mary’s Illuminated MS. Manual, in the Library of the
    Roman Catholic Cathedral at Westminster) 178

    XLI. Facsimile of the Tractatus de Causis et Indiciis Morborum,
    attributed to Maimonides (Bodleian MS., Marsh 379) 225

    ILLUSTRATIONS IN TEXT

    SCIENTIFIC VIEWS AND VISIONS OF SAINT HILDEGARD

    FIGURE PAGE

    1. The Hildegard Country 3
    1. Hildegard’s First Scheme of the Universe (slightly simplified

    from the Wiesbaden Codex B, fo. 14 r) 9

    1. Hildegard’s Second Scheme of the Universe (reconstructed from

    her measurements) 29

    1. Dante’s Scheme of the Universe (slightly modified from

    Michelangelo Caetani, duca di Sermoneta, La materia della
    Divina Commedia di Dante Allighieri dichiarata in VI tavole
    ) 31

    1. Diagram of the Zones (from Herrade de Landsberg, Hortus

    deliciarum) 40

    6, 7. Melothesiae (from R. Fludd, Historia utriusque cosmi, 1619) 41

    1. The Microcosm (from R. Fludd, Philosophia sacra seu astrologia

    cosmica, 1628) 42

    1. Diagram illustrating the relationship of the Planets to the Brain

    (from Herrade de Landsberg, Hortus deliciarum) 48

    A STUDY IN EARLY RENAISSANCE ANATOMY

    1. The first printed picture of Dissection (from the French

    translation of Bartholomaeus Anglicus, 1482) 80

    1. Dissection Scene in the open air (Title-page of Mellerstadt’s

    edition of the Anatomy of Mondino, 1493) 82

    1. Dissection Scene (from the 1495 edition of ‘Ketham’) 83
    1. The first picture of Dissection in an English-printed book

    (from the English translation of Bartholomaeus Anglicus,
    printed by Wynkyn de Worde, 1495) 85

    1. A Lecture on Anatomy (from the 1535 edition of Berengar of

    Carpi’s Commentary on Mondino) 85

    1. Diagrams of the Internal Organs (after Bodleian MS. Ashmole

    399, of about 1298) 88

    1. A Female Figure laid open to show the Womb and other Organs

    (from the 1493 edition of ‘Ketham’) 91

    1. The Abdominal Muscles (from Berengar of Carpi’s Commentary

    on Mondino, 1521) 96

    1. The first printed Map of England (from the 1472(?) Bologna

    Ptolemy, edited by Manfredi and others) 100

    1. Facsimile of the last page of Manfredi’s Prognosticon ad

    annum 1479 102

    1. Diagram showing the ten Layers of the Head, the Cerebral

    Ventricles and Cranial Nerves, and the Relation of the
    Nerves to the Senses (from M. Hundt, Antropologium, 1501) 112

    1. The Layers of the Head (from the Anatomia of Johannes

    Dryander, 1537) 112

    1. Diagram showing the Ventricles of the Brain (from Illustrissimi

    philosophi et theologi domini Alberti magni compendiosum
    insigne ac perutile opus Philosophiae naturalis
    , 1496) 114

    1. Diagram of the Senses, the Humours, the Cerebral Ventricles,

    and the Intellectual Faculties. To illustrate Roger Bacon,
    De Scientia Perspectiva, (British Museum MS. Sloane 2156,
    fo. 11 r) 116

    1. Diagram illustrating the general ideas on Anatomy current at

    the Renaissance (from K. Peyligk. Philosophiae naturalis
    compendium
    , 1489) 116

    1. Diagrams of the Cerebral Ventricles viewed from above and

    from the side (from K. Peyligk, Philosophiae naturalis
    compendium
    , 1489) 117

    1. The Localization of Cerebral Functions (from the 1493 edition

    of ‘Ketham’) 117

    1. Diagram of the Ventricles and the Senses, with their relation

    to the intellectual processes, according to the doctrine of
    the Renaissance anatomists (from G. Reisch, Margarita
    philosophiae
    , 1503) 117

    1. The Anatomy of the Eye (from G. Reisch, Margarita

    philosophiae, 1503) 120

    1. The Anatomy of the Eye (from Vesalius, De humani corporis

    fabrica, 1543) 121

    1. The Heart (from the Roncioni MS., Pisa 99) 127
    1. Diagram showing the two Lateral Ventricles and the ‘Central’

    Ventricle, (from Johannes Adelphus, Mundini de omnibus
    humani corporis interioribus menbris Anathomia
    , 1513) 128

    1. The Heart (from Hans von Gersdorff, Feldt- und Stattbüch

    bewerter Wundartznei, 1556) 129

    DR. JOHN WEYER AND THE WITCH MANIA

    Portrait of Dr. John Weyer at the age of 60, 1576 189

    THE SCIENTIFIC VIEWS AND VISIONS OF SAINT HILDEGARD (1098-1180)

    By Charles Singer

    PAGE

    I. Introduction 1
    II. Life and Works 2
    III. Bibliographical Note 6
    IV. The Spurious Scientific Works of Hildegard 12
    V. Sources of Hildegard’s Scientific Knowledge 15
    VI. The Structure of the Material Universe 22
    VII. Macrocosm and Microcosm 30
    VIII. Anatomy and Physiology 43
    IX. Birth and Death and the Nature of the Soul 49
    X. The Visions and their Pathological Basis 51

    I. INTRODUCTION

    In attempting to interpret the views of Hildegard on scientific subjects, certain special difficulties present themselves. First is the confusion arising from the writings to which her name has been erroneously attached. To obtain a true view of the scope of her work, it is necessary to discuss the authenticity of some of the material before us. A second difficulty is due to the receptivity of her mind, so that views and theories that she accepts in her earlier works become modified, altered, and developed in her later writings. A third difficulty, perhaps less real than the others, is the visionary and involved form in which her thoughts are cast.

    But a fourth and more vital difficulty is the attitude that she adopts towards phenomena in general. To her mind there is no distinction between physical events, moral truths, and spiritual experiences. This view, which our children share with their mediaeval ancestors, was developed but not transformed by the virile power of her intellect.

    Her fusion of internal and external universe links Hildegard indeed to a whole series of mediaeval visionaries, culminating with Dante.

    In Hildegard, as in her fellow mystics, we find that ideas on Nature and Man, the Moral World and the Material Universe, the Spheres, the Winds, and the Humours, Birth and Death, and even on the Soul, the Resurrection of the Dead, and the Nature of God, are not only interdependent, but closely interwoven. Nowadays we are well accustomed to separate our ideas into categories, scientific, ethical, theological, philosophical, and so forth, and we even esteem it a virtue to retain and restrain our thoughts within limits that we deliberately set for them. To Hildegard such classification would have been impossible and probably incomprehensible.

    Nor do such terms as parallelism or allegory adequately cover her view of the relation of the material and spiritual. In her mind they are really interfused, or rather they have not yet been separated.

    Therefore, although in the following pages an attempt is made to estimate her scientific views, yet the writer is conscious that such a method must needs interpret her thought in a partial manner. Hildegard, indeed, presents to us scientific thought as an undifferentiated factor, and an attempt is here made to separate it by the artificial but not unscientific process of dissection from the organic matrix in which it is embedded.

    The extensive literature that has risen around the life and works of Hildegard has come from the hands of writers who have shown no interest in natural knowledge, while those who have occupied themselves with the history of science have, on their side, largely neglected the period to which Hildegard belongs, allured by the richer harvest of the full scholastic age which followed. This essay is an attempt to fill in a small part of the lacuna.

    II. LIFE AND WORKS

    Hildegard of Bingen was born in 1098, of noble parentage, at Böckelheim, on the river Nahe, near Sponheim. Destined from an early age to a religious life, she passed nearly all her days within the walls of Benedictine houses. She was educated and commenced her career in the isolated convent of Disibodenberg, at the junction of the Nahe and the Glan, where she rose to be abbess. In 1147 she and some of her nuns migrated to a new convent on the Rupertsberg, a finely placed site, where the smoky railway junction of Bingerbrück now mars the landscape.

    Between the little settlement and the important mediaeval town of Bingen flowed the river Nahe, spanned by a bridge to which still clung the name of the pagan Drusus (see Fig. 1). At this spot, a place of ancient memories, secluded and yet linked to the world, our abbess passed the main portion of her life, and here she closed her eyes in the eighty-second year of her age on September 17, 1180.

    [Illustration: Fig. 1. THE HILDEGARD COUNTRY]

    Hildegard was a woman of extraordinarily active and independent mind.

    She was not only gifted with a thoroughly efficient intellect, but was possessed of great energy and considerable literary power, and her writings cover a wide range, betraying the most varied activities and remarkable imaginative faculty. The best known, and in a literary sense the most valuable of her works, are the books of visions. She was before all things an ecstatic, and both her Scivias (1141-50) and her Liber divinorum operum simplicis hominis (1163-70) contain passages of real power and beauty.

    Less valuable, perhaps, is her third long mystical work (the second in point of time), the Liber vitae meritorum (1158-62). She is credited with the authorship of an interesting mystery-play and of a collection of musical compositions, while her life of St. Disibode, the Irish missionary (594-674) to whom her part of the Rhineland owes its Christianity, and her account of St.

    Rupert, a local saint commemorated in the name ‘Rupertsberg’, both bear witness alike to her narrative powers, her capacity for systematic arrangement, and her historical interests. Her extensive correspondence demonstrates the influence that she wielded in her own day and country, while her Quaestionum solutiones triginta octo, her Explanatio regulae sancti Benedicti, and her Explanatio symboli sancti Athanasii ad congregationem sororum suorum give us glimpses of her activities as head of a religious house.

    Her biographer, the monk Theodoric, records that she also busied herself with the treatment of the sick, and credits her with miraculous powers of healing.[1] Some of the cited instances of this faculty, as the curing of a love-sick maid,[2] are, however, but manifestations of personal ascendancy over weaker minds; notwithstanding her undoubted acquaintance with the science of her day, and the claims made for her as a pioneer of the hospital system, there is no serious evidence that her treatment extended beyond exorcism and prayer.

    For her time and circumstance Hildegard had seen a fair amount of the world. Living on the Rhine, the highway of Western Germany, she was well placed for observing the traffic and activities of men. She had journeyed at least as far north as Cologne, and had traversed the eastern tributary of the great river to Frankfort on the Main and to Rothenburg on Taube.[3] Her own country, the basin of the Nahe and the Glan, she knew intimately.

    She was, moreover, in constant communication with Mayence, the seat of the archbishopric in which Bingen was situated, and there has survived an extensive correspondence with the ecclesiastics of Cologne, Speyer, Hildesheim, Trèves, Bamberg, Prague, Nürnberg, Utrecht, and numerous other towns of Germany, the Low Countries, and Central Europe.

    [Illustration: Folio 17 r col. b Folio 32 v col. b Folio 205 r col. b

    Plate II. THE THREE SCRIPTS OF THE WIESBADEN CODEX B]

    Hildegard’s journeys, undertaken with the object of stimulating spiritual revival, were of the nature of religious progresses, but, like those of her contemporary, Bernard of Clairvaux, they were in fact largely directed against the heretical and most cruelly persecuted Cathari, an Albigensian sect widely spread in the Rhine country of the twelfth century, whom Hildegard regarded as ‘worse than the Jews’.[4] In justice to her memory it is to be recalled that she herself was ever against the shedding of blood, and had her less ferocious views prevailed, some more substantial relic than the groans and tears of this people had reached our time, while the annals of the Church had been spared the defilement of an inexpiable stain.

    [Illustration: Plate III. TITLE PAGE OF THE HEIDELBERG CODEX OF THE

    SCIVIAS]

    Hildegard’s correspondence with St. Bernard, then preaching his crusade, with four popes, Eugenius III, Anastasius IV, Adrian IV, and Alexander III, and with the emperors Conrad and Frederic Barbarossa, brings her into the current of general European history, while she comes into some slight contact with the story of our own country by her hortatory letters to Henry II and to his consort Eleanor, the divorced wife of Louis VII.[5]

    To complete a sketch of her literary activities, mention should perhaps be made of a secret script and language, the lingua ignota, attributed to her. It is a transparent and to modern eyes a foolishly empty device that hardly merits the dignity of the term ‘mystical’. It has, however, exercised the ingenuity of several writers, and has been honoured by analysis at the hands of Wilhelm Grimm.[6]

    Ample material exists for a full biography of Hildegard, and a number of accounts of her have appeared in the vulgar tongue. Nearly all are marred by a lack of critical judgement that makes their perusal a weary task, and indeed it would need considerable skill to interest a detached reader in the minutiae of monastic disputes that undoubtedly absorbed a considerable part of her activities. Perhaps the best life of her is the earliest; it is certainly neither the least critical nor the most credulous, and is by her contemporaries, the monks Godefrid and Theodoric.[7]

    The title of ‘saint’ is usually given to Hildegard, but she was not in fact canonized. Attempts towards that end were made under Gregory IX (1237), Innocent IV (1243), and John XXII (1317). Miraculous cures and other works of wonder were claimed for her, but either they were insufficiently miraculous or insufficiently attested.[8] Those who have impartially traced her life in her documents will agree with the verdict of the Church. Hers was a fiery, a prophetic, in many ways a singularly noble spirit, but she was not a saint in any intelligible sense of the word.

    III. BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTE

    There is no complete edition of the works of Hildegard. For the majority of readers the most convenient collection will doubtless be vol. 197 of Migne, Patrologia Latina. This can be supplemented from Cardinal J. B. Pitra’s well-edited Analecta sacra, the eighth volume of which contains certain otherwise inaccessible works of Hildegard,[9] and is the only available edition of the Liber vitae meritorum per simplicem hominem a vivente luce, revelatorum.

    Manuscripts of the writings of our abbess are numerous and are widely scattered over Europe. Four of them are of special importance for our purpose, and are here briefly described.

    (A) is a vast parchment of 480 folios in the Nassauische Landesbibliothek at Wiesbaden. This much-thumbed volume, still bearing the chain that once tethered it to some monastic desk, is written in a thirteenth-century script. There is evidence that it was prepared in the neighbourhood of Hildegard’s convent, if not in that convent itself. It is interesting as a collection of those works that the immediate local tradition attributed to her, and is thus useful as a standard of genuineness.[10] Reference will be made to it in the following pages as the Wiesbaden Codex A. Its contents are as follows:

    1. Liber Scivias.
    1. Liber vitae meritorum.
    1. Liber divinorum operum.
    1. Ad praelatos moguntienses.
    1. Vita sanctae Hildegardis. By Godefrid and Theodoric.
    1. Liber epistolarum et orationum. This collection contains 292

    items, and includes the Explanatio symboli Athanasii, the
    Exposition of the Rule of St. Benedict, and the Lives of St.
    Disibode and St. Rupert.

    1. Expositiones evangeliorum.
    1. Ignota lingua and Ignotae litterae.
    1. Litterae villarenses.
    1. Symphonia harmoniae celestum revelationum.

    (B) is also at Wiesbaden, and will be cited here as the Wiesbaden Codex B. It contains the Scivias only, and is a truly noble volume of 235 folios, beautifully illuminated, in excellent preservation, and of the highest value for the history of mediaeval art. It has been thoroughly investigated by the late Dom Louis Baillet,[11] who concluded that it was written in or near Bingen between the dates 1160 and 1180. Its miniatures help greatly in the interpretation of the visions, illustrating them often in the minutest and most unexpected details.

    In view of the great difficulty of visualizing much of her narrative, these miniatures afford to our mind strong evidence that the MS. was supervised by the prophetess herself, or was at least prepared under her immediate tradition. This view is confirmed by comparing the miniatures with those of the somewhat similar but inferior Heidelberg MS. (C).

    Both the miniatures and the script of the Wiesbaden Codex B are the work of several hands. There are three distinct handwritings discernible (Plate II). The earliest is attributed by Baillet in his careful work to the twelfth century, while the later writing is in thirteenth-century hands.[12] It thus appears to us that while Hildegard herself probably supervised the earlier stages of the preparation of this volume, its completion took place subsequent to her death. This view is sustained by the fact that some of the later miniatures are far less successful than the earlier figures in aiding the interpretation of her text.

    The two Wiesbaden MSS. appear to have remained at the convent on the Rupertsberg opposite Bingen until the seventeenth century. They were studied there by Trithemius in the fifteenth century, and one of them at least was seen by the Mayence Commission of 1489. Later they were noted by the theologians Osiander (1527) and Wicelius (Weitzel, 1554), and by the antiquary Nicolaus Serarius (1604).

    In 1632, during the Thirty Years’ War, the Rupertsberg buildings were destroyed, the MSS. being removed to a place of safety in the neighbouring settlement at Eibingen, where they were again recorded in 1660 by the Jesuits Papenbroch and Henschen.[13] At some unknown date they were transferred to Wiesbaden, where they were examined in 1814 by Goethe,[14] and a few years later by Wilhelm Grimm,[15] and where they have since remained.

    [Illustration: Fig. 2. HILDEGARD’S FIRST SCHEME OF THE UNIVERSE

    Slightly simplified from the Wiesbaden Codex B, folio 14 r.]

    (C) This MS. is at the University Library at Heidelberg. It also contains only the Scivias, and it is the only known illuminated MS. of that work except the Wiesbaden Codex B. The Heidelberg MS. was prepared with great care in the early thirteenth century, only a little later than its fellow, but its figures afford little aid in the interpretation of the text. Thus, for instance, the Heidelberg diagram of the universe (Plate IV) is of a fairly conventional type which quite fails to illustrate the difficult description.

    The obscurities of the text are, however, at once explained by a figure in the Wiesbaden Codex B (Fig. 2): we thus obtain further indirect evidence of the personal influence of Hildegard in the preparation of that MS. The representation of Hildegard in the Heidelberg MS. (Plate III) shows no resemblance to those in the Wiesbaden Codex B (Plate I) or in the Lucca MS. (Plates VI to IX), which will now be described.

    (D) is an illustrated codex of the Liber divinorum operum simplicis hominis at the Municipal Library at Lucca. It contains ten beautiful miniatures, some of which are here reproduced (Plates VI to IX and XI), as they are of special value for the interpretation of Hildegard’s theories on the relation of macrocosm and microcosm.

    This Lucca MS. was described and its text printed in 1761 by Giovanni Domenico Mansi,[16] a careful scholar, who was himself sometime Archbishop of Lucca. Mansi concluded that it was written at the end of the twelfth or the beginning of the thirteenth century. On palaeographical grounds a slightly later date would nowadays probably be preferred (Plate V b).

    The work consists of ten visions, each illustrated by a figure.

    The date, character, and meaning of these miniatures raise special problems to which only very superficial reference can here be made.

    Unfortunately but little work has been done on early Italian schools of miniaturists, and it is not a subject on which any exact knowledge can yet be said to exist.[17]

    Of these ten miniatures we may dismiss the last five in a few words.

    The sixth to the tenth visions are of purely theological interest, and the miniatures illustrating them are by a different hand to the rest.

    They are all relatively crude products, which appear to us to resemble other Italian work of the period at which the MS. was written. We shall concentrate our attention on the first five miniatures.

    The first three miniatures of the Lucca MS. (Plates VI to VIII) may be attributed to the same hand on the following grounds:

    1. All have a very similar inset figure of the prophetess below the

    main picture.

    1. The character of the principal figure of the first miniature

    (Plate VI) is almost identical with the curious universe-embracing double-headed figure of the second miniature (Plate VII).

    1. The features and draughtsmanship of the central figure of the second

    miniature (Plate VII) are identical with those of the third (Plate VIII).

    1. The beasts’ heads arranged round the second miniature (Plate VII)

    are exactly reproduced in the third miniature (Plate VIII).

    Now although these three miniatures are in some respects unique, they contain elements enabling us to date them with an approach to accuracy.

    These elements are to be found especially in the central figure of the second and third miniatures (Plates VII and VIII).

    About the middle of the thirteenth century, as Venturi has shown,[18] there was a well-marked change in Northern Italy in the traditional representation of the form on the Cross. This change was followed with almost slavish accuracy, and the new form is well represented by a painting in the Uffizi Gallery (Plate X). It is this figure of Christ which is reproduced by our miniaturist.

    The central figure of Plates VII and VIII resembles that of the Uffizi crucifix, for instance, in the general pose of the body, in the position of the legs and of the arms, in the treatment of the abdominal musculature, in the method of outlining the muscles of the legs and of the arms, and in a minute and very constant detail by which the outline of the left side is continued with the fold of the groin, thus giving an impression of the left thigh being advanced on the right.

    Furthermore, the somewhat Byzantine cast of countenance of the figure can be closely paralleled from Northern Italian work of the same period. We therefore regard these first three miniatures of the Lucca MS. as dating from about the middle of the thirteenth century.

    The remaining two miniatures (Plates IX and XI) offer special difficulties. Plate XI (illustrating the fifth vision) presents us with no complete human figures, except the small and probably copied inset of the prophetess below the miniature. The faces bear some resemblance to those of the last five miniatures; the wings, on the other hand, to those of the first miniature (Plate VI). It is perhaps possible that this miniature was the work of an early thirteenth-century artist, and that the wings and some other details were added by a later hand. The abnormal orientation, east to the left and south above, suggests that we have here to do with some special influence.

    The most anomalous of all is, however, the beautiful fourth miniature (Plate IX). This picture has a general feeling of the early Renaissance, though it is hard to find in it any definite humanistic element. The nude female figure in the upper left quadrant is especially striking. No parallel to it is to be found in the thirteenth-century Italian miniatures that have so far been reproduced, and it appears to us difficult to date the miniature anterior to the fourteenth century at the very earliest. It is, in any event, by a different hand to the others.

    The rashes on the patients in the two upper and the right lower quadrants are perhaps an attempt to render the fatal ‘God’s tokens’ of those waves of pestilence that devastated the Italian peninsula in the fourteenth century.

    Whatever the date of these miniatures, however, they reproduce the meaning of the text of the Liber divinorum operum with a convincing certainty and sureness of touch. This work is the most difficult of all Hildegard’s mystical writings. Without the clues provided by the miniatures, many passages in it are wholly incomprehensible. It appears to us therefore by no means improbable that the traditional interpretation of Hildegard’s works, thus preserved to our time by these miniatures and by them alone, may have had its origin from the mouth of the prophetess herself, perhaps through another set of miniatures that has disappeared or has not yet come to light.[19]

    IV. THE SPURIOUS SCIENTIFIC WORKS OF HILDEGARD

    The scientific views of Hildegard are embedded in a theological setting, and are mainly encountered in the Scivias and the Liber divinorum operum simplicis hominis. To a less extent they appear occasionally in her Epistolae and in the Liber vitae meritorum.

    [Illustration: From the HEIDELBERG CODEX OF THE SCIVIAS

    Plate IV. THE UNIVERSE]

    Two works of non-theological tone and definitely scientific character have been printed in her name. One of these was recently edited under the title Beatae Hildegardis causae et curae.[20] A single MS. only of this work is known to exist, and is now deposited in the Royal Library of Copenhagen.[21] It is an ill-written document of the thirteenth century, and the original work probably dates from this period.

    It has none of the characteristics of the acknowledged work of Hildegard, and indeed the only link with her name is the title, which is written in a hand different from that of the text (Plate V a). Nothing could be more unlike the ecstatic but well-ordered and systematic work of the prophetess of Bingen than the prosy disorder of the Causae et curae. Linguistically, also, it differs entirely from the typical writings of Hildegard, for it is full of Germanisms, which never interrupt the eloquence of her authentic works.

    Again, Hildegard’s tendency to theoretical speculation, as for instance on the nature of the elements or on the form of the Universe, finds no place in the scrappy paragraphs of this apocryphal compilation.

    [Illustration: Plate V a. OPENING LINES OF THE COPENHAGEN MS. OF THE

    CAUSAE ET CURAE]

    [Illustration: Plate V b. OPENING LINES OF THE LUCCA MS. OF THE LIBER

    DIVINORUM OPERUM SIMPLICIS HOMINIS]

    A second work, of somewhat similar character, is entitled Subtilitatum diversarumque creaturarum libri novem. This is clearly a compilation, and numerous passages in it can be traced to such sources as Pliny, Walafrid Strabus, Marbod, Macer, the Physiologus, Isidore Hispalensis, Constantine the African, and the Regimen Sanitatis Salerni, only the last three of which exerted a traceable influence on the genuine works of our authoress.

    Nevertheless this Liber subtilitatum was early printed as Hildegard’s work, along with a treatise attributed with as little justification to another woman writer, Trotula, one of the ladies of Salerno, whose name was also a household word in the Middle Ages, and was freely attached to medical writings with which she had little or nothing to do.[22] It is true that Hildegard’s contemporary biographer, the monk Theodoric, assures us that she had written De natura hominis et elementorum, diversarumque creaturarum,[23] but there is nothing to suggest that the Liber subtilitatum is intended thereby.

    The modern scholars Daremberg and Reuss have edited the Liber subtilitatum as Hildegard’s composition,[24] and the work attracted the attention of Virchow,[25] but notwithstanding the authority of these names, the objections which apply to the genuineness of the Causae et curae are also valid here:

    (a) The Liber subtilitatum is not included in the Wiesbaden Codex A.

    (b) The phrase De natura hominis et elementorum diversarumque creaturarum, used by Theodoric as a description and by Reuss as a title,[26] would lead one to expect great emphasis on the nature of the elements and their entry into the human frame. Such emphasis is not, in fact, discoverable in the Liber subtilitatum, which, moreover, does not treat of human anatomy or physiology.

    (c) On the other hand, the genuine Liber divinorum operum simplicis hominis does lay stress on these points. This is possibly therefore the work to which Theodoric refers, and to it his description certainly applies well.

    (d) As in the Causae et curae, there are linguistic difficulties that prevent us attributing the Liber subtilitatum to Hildegard.

    Such, for instance, is the number of Germanisms as well as the marked difference from the style and method of her acknowledged work.

    (e) There are statements in the Liber subtilitatum that can scarcely be attributed to our authoress. Having largely explored the Rhine basin, and corresponding constantly with writers beyond the Alps, how could she possibly derive all rivers, Rhine and Danube, Meuse and Moselle, Nahe and Glan, from the same lake (of Constance) as does the author of the Liber subtilitatum?[27]

    (f) Furthermore, although that spurious work has a chapter De elementis, it reveals none of Hildegard’s most peculiar and definite views as to their nature, origin, and fate,[28] nor does it refer to the sphericity of the earth, to the vascular system of man, to the humours and their relation to the winds and the elements, or to a dozen other points on which, as we shall see, Hildegard had views of her own.

    Before leaving the subject of Hildegard’s apocryphal works, brief reference may be made to the Speculum futurorum temporum, a spurious production to which her name is often attached. It exists in innumerable MSS., and has been frequently edited and translated.

    It is the work of Gebeno, prior of Eberbach, who wrote it in 1220, claiming that he extracted it from Hildegard’s writings. Another work erroneously attributed to Hildegard is entitled Revelatio de fratribus quatuor mendicantium ordinum, and is directed against the four mendicant orders--Franciscans, Dominicans, Carmelites, and Augustinians. It also has been printed, but is wholly spurious, and was probably composed towards the latter part of the thirteenth century.

    V. SOURCES OF HILDEGARD’S SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE

    In the works of Hildegard we are dealing with the products of a peculiarly original intellect, and her imaginative power and mystical tendency make an exhaustive search into the origin of her ideas by no means an easy task. With her theological standpoint, as such, we are not here concerned, and unfortunately she does not herself refer to any of her sources other than the Biblical books; to have cited profane writers would indeed have involved the abandonment of her claim that her knowledge was derived by immediate inspiration from on high.

    Nevertheless it is possible to form some idea, on internal evidence, of the origin of many of her scientific conceptions.

    The most striking point concerning the sources of Hildegard is negative.

    There is no German linguistic element distinguishable in her writings, and they show little or no trace of native German folk-lore.[29] It is true that Trithemius of Sponheim (1462-1516), who is often a very inaccurate chronicler, tells us that Hildegard ‘composed works in German as well as in Latin, although she had neither learned nor used the latter tongue except for simple psalmody’.[30] But with the testimony before us of the writings themselves and of her skilful use of Latin, the statement of Trithemius and even the hints of Hildegard[31] may be safely discounted and set down to the wish to magnify the element of inspiration.[32] So far from her having been illiterate, we shall show that the structure and details of her works betray a considerable degree of learning and much painstaking study of the works of others.

    Thus, for instance, she skilfully manipulates the Hippocratic doctrines of miasma and the humours, and elaborates a theory of the interrelation of the two which, though developed on a plan of her own, is yet clearly borrowed in its broad outline from such a writer as Isidore of Seville. Again, as we shall see, some of her ideas on anatomy seem to have been derived from Constantine the African, who belonged to the Benedictine monastery of Monte Cassino.[33]

    Hildegard lived at rather too early a date to drink from the broad stream of new knowledge that was soon to flow into Europe through Paris from its reservoir in Moslem Spain.

    Such drops from that source as may have reached her must have trickled in either from the earlier Italian translators or from the Jews who had settled in the Upper Rhineland, for it is very unlikely that she was influenced by the earlier twelfth-century translations of Averroes, Avicenna, Avicebron, and Avempace, that passed into France from the Jews of Marseilles, Montpellier, and Andalusia.[34] Her intellectual field was thus far more patristic than would have been the case had her life-course been even a quarter of a century later.

    Her science is primarily of the usual degenerate Greek type, disintegrated fragments of Aristotle and Galen coloured and altered by the customary mediaeval attempts to bring theory into line with scriptural phraseology, though a high degree of independence is obtained by the visionary form in which her views are set. She exhibits, like all mediaeval writers on science, the Aristotelian theory of the elements, but her statement of the doctrine is illuminated by flashes of her own thoughts and is coloured by suggestions from St. Augustine, Isidore Hispalensis, Bernard Sylvestris of Tours, and perhaps from writings attributed to Boethius.

    The translator Gerard of Cremona (1114-87) was her contemporary, and his labours made available for western readers a number of scientific works which had previously circulated only among Arabic-speaking peoples.[35] Several of these works, notably Ptolemy’s Almagest, Messahalah’s De Orbe, and the Aristotelian De Caelo et Mundo, contain material on the form of the universe and on the nature of the elements, and some of them probably reached the Rhineland in time to be used by Hildegard.

    The Almagest, however, was not translated until 1175, and was thus inaccessible to Hildegard.[36] Moreover, as she never uses an Arabic medical term, it is reasonably certain that she did not consult Gerard’s translation of Avicenna, which is crowded with Arabisms.

    On the other hand, the influence of the Salernitan school may be discerned in several of her scientific ideas. The Regimen Sanitatis of Salerno, written about 1101, was rapidly diffused throughout Europe, and must have reached the Rhineland at least a generation before the Liber Divinorum Operum was composed. This cycle of verses may well have reinforced some of her microcosmic ideas,[37] and suggested also her views on the generation of man,[38] on the effects of wind on health,[39] and on the influence of the stars.[40]

    On the subject of the form of the earth Hildegard expressed herself definitely as a spherist,[41] a point of view more widely accepted in the earlier Middle Ages than is perhaps generally supposed. She considers in the usual mediaeval fashion that this globe is surrounded by celestial spheres that influence terrestrial events.[42] But while she claims that human affairs, and especially human diseases, are controlled, under God, by the heavenly cosmos, she yet commits herself to none of that more detailed astrological doctrine that was developing in her time, and came to efflorescence in the following centuries.

    In this respect she follows the earlier and somewhat more scientific spirit of such writers as Messahalah, rather than the wilder theories of her own age. The shortness and simplicity of Messahalah’s tract on the sphere made it very popular. It was probably one of the earliest to be translated into Latin; and its contents would account for the change which, as we shall see, came over Hildegard’s scientific views in her later years.

    The general conception of the universe as a series of concentric elemental spheres had certainly penetrated to Western Europe centuries before Hildegard’s time. Nevertheless the prophetess presents it to her audience as a new and striking revelation. We may thus suppose that translations of Messahalah, or of whatever other work she drew upon for the purpose, did not reach the Upper Rhineland, or rather did not become accepted by the circles in which Hildegard moved, until about the decade 1141-50, during which she was occupied in the composition of her Scivias.

    There is another cosmic theory, the advent of which to her country, or at least to her circle, can be approximately dated from her work.

    Hildegard exhibits in a pronounced but peculiar and original form the doctrine of the macrocosm and microcosm. Hardly distinguishable in the Scivias (1141-50), it appears definitely in the Liber Vitae Meritorum (1158-62),[43] in which work, however, it takes no very prominent place, and is largely overlaid and concealed by other lines of thought. But in the Liber Divinorum Operum (1163-70) this belief is the main theme.

    The book is indeed an elaborate attempt to demonstrate a similarity and relationship between the nature of the Godhead, the constitution of the universe, and the structure of man, and it thus forms a valuable compendium of the science of the day viewed from the standpoint of this theory.

    From whence did she derive the theory of macrocosm and microcosm? In outline its elements were easily accessible to her in Isidore’s De Rerum Natura as well as in the Salernitan poems. But the work of Bernard Sylvestris of Tours, De mundi universitate sive megacosmus et microcosmus,[44] corresponds so closely both in form, in spirit, and sometimes even in phraseology, to the Liber Divinorum Operum that it appears to us certain that Hildegard must have had access to it also. Bernard’s work can be dated between the years 1145-53 from his reference to the papacy of Eugenius III.

    This would correspond well with the appearance of his doctrines in the Liber Vitae Meritorum (1158-62) and their full development in the Liber Divinorum Operum (1163-70).

    Another contemporary writer with whom Hildegard presents points of contact is Hugh of St. Victor (1095-1141).[45] In his writings the doctrine of the relation of macrocosm and microcosm is more veiled than with Bernard Sylvestris. Nevertheless, his symbolic universe is on the lines of Hildegard’s belief, and the plan of his De arca Noe mystica presents many parallels both to the Scivias and to the Liber Divinorum Operum. If these do not owe anything directly to Hugh, they are at least products of the same mystical movement as were his works.

    We may also recall that at Hildegard’s date very complex cabalistic systems involving the doctrine of macrocosm and microcosm were being elaborated by the Jews, and that she lived in a district where Rabbinic mysticism specially flourished.[46] Benjamin of Tudela, who visited Bingen during Hildegard’s lifetime, tells us that he found there a congregation of his people. Since we know, moreover, that she was familiar with the Jews,[47] it is possible that she may have derived some of the very complex macrocosmic conceptions with which her last work is crowded from local Jewish students.

    The Alsatian Herrade de Landsberg (died 1195), a contemporary of Hildegard, developed the microcosm theory along lines similar to those of our abbess, and it is probable that the theory, in the form in which these writers present it, reached the Upper Rhineland somewhere about the middle or latter half of the twelfth century.

    [Illustration: From the LUCCA MS. fo. 1 v

    Plate VI. NOUS PERVADED BY THE GODHEAD AND CONTROLLING HYLE]

    Apart from the Biblical books, the work which made the deepest impression on Hildegard was probably Augustine’s De Civitate Dei, which seems to form the background of a large part of the Scivias.

    The books of Ezekiel and of Daniel, the Gospel of Nicodemus, the Shepherd of Hermas, and the Apocalypse, all contain a lurid type of vision which her own spiritual experiences would enable her to utilize, and which fit in well with her microcosmic doctrines. Ideas on the harmony and disharmony of the elements she may have picked up from such works as the Wisdom of Solomon and the Pauline writings, though it is obvious that Isidore of Seville and the Regimen Sanitatis Salerni were also drawn upon by her.

    [Illustration: From the LUCCA MS. fo. 9 r

    Plate VII. NOUS PERVADED BY THE GODHEAD EMBRACING THE MACROCOSM WITH

    THE MICROCOSM]

    Her figure of the Church in the Scivias reminds us irresistibly of Boethius’ vision of the gracious feminine form of Philosophy. Again, the visions of the punishments of Hell which Hildegard recounts in the Liber Vitae Meritorum[48] bear resemblance to the work of her contemporary Benedictine, the monk Alberic the younger of Monte Cassino, to whom Dante also became indebted.[49]

    Hildegard repeatedly assures us that most of her knowledge was revealed to her in waking visions. Some of these we shall seek to show had a pathological basis, probably of a migrainous character, and she was a sufferer from a condition that would nowadays probably be classified as hystero-epilepsy. Too much stress, however, can easily be laid on the ecstatic presentment of her scientific views. Visions, it must be remembered, were ‘the fashion’ at the period, and were a common literary device.

    Her contemporary Benedictine sister, Elizabeth of Schönau, as well as numerous successors, as for example Gertrude of Robersdorf, adopted the same mechanism. The use of the vision for this purpose remained popular for centuries, and we may say of these writers, as Ampère says of Dante, that ‘the visions gave not the genius nor the poetic inspiration, but the form merely in which they were realized’.

    The contemporaries of Hildegard who provide the closest analogy to her are Elizabeth of Schönau (died 1165), whose visions are recounted in her life by Eckbertus;[50] and Herrade de Landsberg, Abbess of Hohenburg in Alsace, the priceless MS. of whose Hortus Deliciarum was destroyed by the Germans in the siege of Strasbourg in 1870.[51] With Elizabeth of Schönau, who lived in her neighbourhood, Hildegard was in frequent correspondence. With Herrade she had, so far as is known, no direct communication; but the two were contemporary, lived not very far apart, and under similar political and cultural conditions.

    Elizabeth’s visions present some striking analogies to those of Hildegard, while the figures of Herrade, of which copies have fortunately survived, often suggest the illustrations of the Wiesbaden or of the Lucca MSS.

    VI. THE STRUCTURE OF THE MATERIAL UNIVERSE

    To the student of the history of science, Hildegard’s beliefs as to the nature and structure of the universe are among the most interesting that she has to impart. Her earlier theories are in some respects unique among mediaeval writers, and we possess in the Wiesbaden Codex B a diagram enabling us to interpret her views with a definiteness and certainty that would otherwise be impossible.

    Hildegard’s universe is geocentric, and consists of a spherical earth,[52] around which are arranged a number of concentric shells or zones. The inner zones are spherical, the outer oval, and the outermost of all egg-shaped, with one end prolonged and more pointed than the other (Fig. 2). The concentric structure is a commonplace of mediaeval science, and is encountered, for instance, in the works of Bede, Isidore, Alexander of Neckam, Roger Bacon, Albertus Magnus, and Dante.

    To all these writers, however, the universe is spherical. The egg-shape is peculiar to Hildegard. Many of the Mappaemundi of the Beatus and other types exhibit the surface of the habitable earth itself as oval, and it was from such charts that Hildegard probably gained her conception of an oval universe. In her method of orientation also she follows these maps, placing the east at the top of the page where we are accustomed to place the north.[53]

    It is unfortunate that she does not deal with geography in the restricted sense, and so we are not in full possession of her views on the antipodes, a subject of frequent derision to patristic and of misconception to scholastic writers. She does, however, vaguely refer to the inversion of seasons and climates in the opposite hemisphere,[54] though she confuses the issue by the adoption of a theory widespread in the Middle Ages and reproduced in the Divina Commedia, that the antipodean surface of the earth is uninhabitable, since it is either beneath the ocean or in the mouth of the Dragon[55] (Plate XI, cp. Fig. 4).

    The nature of the antipodean inversion of climates was clearly grasped by her contemporary, Herrade de Landsberg (Fig. 5).

    Hildegard’s views as to the internal structure of the terrestrial sphere are also somewhat difficult to follow.

    Her obscure and confused doctrine of Purgatory and Hell has puzzled other writers besides ourselves,[56] nor need we consider it here, but she held that the interior of the earth contained two vast spaces shaped like truncated cones, where punishment was meted out and whence many evil things had issue.[57] Her whole scheme presents analogies as well as contrasts to that of her kindred spirit Dante.[58] Hildegard, however, who died before the thirteenth century had dawned, presents us with a scheme far less definite and elaborated than that of her great successor, who had all the stores of the golden age of scholasticism on which to draw.

    In Hildegard’s first diagram of the universe, which is of the nature of an ‘optical section’, the world, the sphaera elementorum of Johannes Sacro Bosco and other mediaeval writers, is diagrammatically represented as compounded of earth, air, fire, and water confusedly mixed in what her younger contemporary, Alexander of Neckam (1157-1217), calls ‘a certain concordant discord of the elements’. In the illustrations to the Wiesbaden Codex B the four elements have each a conventional method of representation, which appears again and again in the different miniatures (Fig. 2 and Plates XII and XIII).

    Around this world with its four elements is spread the atmosphere, the aer lucidus or alba pellis, diagrammatically represented, like the earth which it enwraps, as circular. Through this alba pellis no creature of earth can penetrate. Beyond are ranged in order four further shells or zones. Each zone contains one of the cardinal winds, and each cardinal wind is accompanied by two accessory winds, represented in the traditional fashion by the breath of supernatural beings.

    Of the four outer zones the first is the aer aquosus, also round, from which blows the east wind. In the outer part of the aer aquosus float the clouds, and according as they contract or expand or are blown aside, the heavenly bodies above are revealed or concealed.

    Enwrapping the aer aquosus is the purus aether, the widest of all the zones. The long axis of this, as of the remaining outer shells, is in the direction from east to west, thus determining the path of movement of the heavenly bodies. Scattered through the purus aether are the constellations of the fixed stars, and arranged along the long axis are the moon and the two inner planets. From this zone blows the west wind. The position and constitution of this purus aether is evidently the result of some misinterpretation of Aristotelian writings.

    The next zone, the umbrosa pellis or ignis niger, is a narrow dark shell, whence proceed the more dramatic meteorological events. Here, following on the hints of the Wisdom of Solomon (chap. v) and the Book of Job (chap. xxxviii), are situated the diagrammatically portrayed treasuries of lightning and of hail. From here the tempestuous north wind bursts forth. This ignis niger is clearly comparable to the dry earthy exhalation that works of the Peripatetic school regard as given off by the outer fiery zone.

    The presence of the ignis niger thus suggests some contact on the part of the authoress with the teaching of the Meteorologica of Aristotle.[59]

    The outermost layer of all is a mass of flames, the lucidus ignis.

    Here are the sun and the three outer planets, and from here the south wind pours its scorching breath (Fig. 2).

    The movements of the four outer zones around each other, carrying the heavenly bodies with them, are attributed to the winds in each zone. The seasonal variations in the movements of the heavenly bodies, along with the recurring seasons themselves, are also determined by the prevalent winds, which, acting as the motive power upon the various zones, form a celestial parallelogram of forces. In this way is ingeniously explained also why in spring the days lengthen and in autumn they shorten until in either case an equinox is reached (Fig. 2).

    ‘I looked and behold the east and the south wind with their
    collaterals, moving the firmament by the power of their breath,
    caused it to revolve over the earth from east to west; and in the
    same way the west and north winds and their collaterals, receiving
    the impulse and projecting their blast, thrust it back again from
    west to east....

    ‘I saw also that as the days began to lengthen, the south wind and
    his collaterals gradually raised the firmament in the southern
    zone upwards towards the north, until the days ceased to grow
    longer. Then when the days began to shorten, the north wind with
    his collaterals, shrinking from the brightness of the sun, drove
    the firmament back gradually southward until by reason of the
    lengthening days the south wind began yet again to raise it up’[60]
    (Plates VII and VIII).

    Intimately bound up not only with her theory of the nature and structure of the universe but also with her eschatological beliefs is Hildegard’s doctrine of the elements. Before the fall of man these were arranged in a harmony,[61] which was disturbed by that catastrophe (Plate XII a),[62] so that they have since remained in the state of mingled confusion in which we always encounter them on the terrestrial globe. This mistio, to use the mediaeval Aristotelian term, is symbolized by the irregular manner in which the elements are represented in the central sphere of the diagram of the universe (Fig. 2).

    Thus mingled they will remain until subjected to the melting-pot of the Last Judgement (Plate XIII),[63] when they will emerge in a new and eternal harmony, no longer mixed as matter, but separate and pure, parts of the new heaven and the new earth (Plate XII b).[64]

    ‘But the heavens and the earth, which are now,... are kept in
    store and reserved unto fire against the day of judgment and
    perdition of ungodly men.... But the day of the Lord will come ...
    in the which the heavens shall pass away with a great noise, and
    the elements shall melt with fervent heat, the earth also and the
    works that are therein shall be burned up.... Nevertheless we,
    according to his promise, look for new heavens and a new earth,
    wherein dwelleth righteousness’ (2 Peter iii. 7, 10, and 13).

    So Hildegard, acting on a scriptural hint, is enabled to dematerialize her doctrine of the after-things.

    But although since man’s fall the elements have lost their order and their harmony on this terrestrial orb, yet is that harmony still in part preserved in the celestial spheres that encircle and surround our globe; and water, air, earth, and fire have each their respective representatives in the four concentric zones, the aer aquosus, the purus aether, the umbrosa pellis, and the lucidus ignis (Fig. 2). These are the ‘superior elements’ which still retain some at least of their individuality and primal purity.

    From each of their spheres blows, as we have seen, one of the cardinal winds, and each wind partakes of the elemental character of the zone whence it issues, and has a corresponding influence on man’s body, since each of the four humours is specifically affected by the element to which it corresponds.

    ‘Then I saw that by the diverse quality of the winds, and of the
    atmosphere as they in turn sweep through it, the humours in man
    are agitated and altered. For in each of the superior elements
    there is a breath of corresponding quality by which, through the
    power of the winds, the corresponding element [below] is forced to
    revolve in the atmosphere, and in no other way is it moved. And by
    one of those winds, with the agency of sun, moon, and stars, the
    atmosphere which tempers the world is breathed forth’[65] (Plate
    VII).

    This doctrine of the relation of the various winds to the four elements and through them to the four humours is found in the De Rerum Natura of Isidore of Seville, and is occasionally illustrated in European MSS. from the ninth century onward,[66] but we meet it set forth with special definiteness in the twelfth century in the translations from Messahalah. It is encountered also in the work of Herrade de Landsberg.

    In and after the thirteenth century it had become a commonplace.

    The description we have given of the universe was in the main set forth by Hildegard in her first work, the Scivias (1141-50).[67] Subsequently she became dissatisfied with the account she had given, and while not withdrawing it, she sought in the Liber Divinorum Operum (1163-70) so to modify the original presentment as to bring it more into line with accepted views. Thus she writes: ‘There appeared to me in vision a disk very like that object which I saw twenty-eight years ago of the form of an egg, in the third vision of my book Scivias.

    In the outer part of the disk there was as it were the lucidus ignis, and beneath it the circle of the ignis niger was portrayed ... and these two circles were so joined as to be one circle.’ There was thus one outer zone representing the fire. ‘Under the circle of the ignis niger there was another circle in the likeness of the purus aether which was of the same width as the two conjoined [outer] fiery circles. And below this circle again was the circle of the aer aquosus as wide as the lucidus ignis.

    And below this circle was yet another circle, the fortis et albus lucidusque aer ... the width whereof was as the width of the ignis niger, and these circles were joined to make one circle which was thus again of width equal to the outer two. Again, under this last circle yet another circle, the aer tenuis, was distinguishable, which could be seen to raise itself as a cloud, sometimes high and light, sometimes depressed and dark, and to diffuse itself as it were throughout the whole disk....

    The outermost fiery circle perfuses the other circles with its fire, while the watery circle saturates them with its moisture, [cp.

    Wisdom of Solomon, xix. 18-20]. And from the extreme eastern part of the disk to the extreme west a line is stretched out [i.e. the equator] which separates the northern zones from the others’[68] (see Fig. 3 and Plates VII and VIII).

    [Illustration: Fig. 3. HILDEGARD’S SECOND SCHEME OF THE UNIVERSE

    Reconstructed from her measurements. AB, CD, and EF are all equal to each other, as are also GH, HK, and KL. The clouds are situated in the outer part of the aer tenuis, and form a prolongation downwards from the aer aquosus towards the earth.]

    The earth lies concentrically with the aer tenuis, and its measurements are given thus: ‘In the midst of the aer tenuis a globe was indicated, the circumference of which was everywhere equidistant from the fortis et albus lucidusque aer, and it was as far across as the depth of the space from the top of the highest circle to the extremity of the clouds, or from the extremity of the clouds to the circumference of the inner globe’[68] (Fig. 3).

    In her earlier work, the Scivias, Hildegard had not apparently realized the need of accounting for the independent movements of the planets other than the sun and moon. She had thus placed the moon and two of the moving stars in the purus aether, and the sun and the three remaining moving stars in the lucidus ignis. Since these spheres were moved by the winds, their contained planets would be subject to the same influences.

    In the Liber Divinorum Operum, however, she has come to realize how independent the movements of the planets really are, and she invokes a special cause for their vagaries. ‘I looked and behold in the outer fire (lucidus ignis) there appeared a circle which girt about the whole firmament from the east westward.

    From it a blast produced a movement from west to east in the opposite direction to the movement of the firmament. But this blast did not give forth his breath earthward as did the other winds, but instead thereof it governed the course of the planets.’[69] The source of the blast is represented in the Lucca MS. as the head of a supernatural being with a human face (Plate VIII).

    [Illustration: From the LUCCA MS. fo. 27 v

    Plate VIII. THE MACROCOSM THE MICROCOSM AND THE WINDS]

    [Illustration: Plate IX. From THE LUCCA MS fo. 37 r

    CELESTIAL INFLUENCES ON MEN ANIMALS AND PLANTS]

    These curious passages were written at some date after 1163, when Hildegard was at least 65 years old. They reveal our prophetess attempting to revise much of her earlier theory of the universe, and while seeking to justify her earlier views, endeavouring also to bring them into line with the new science that was now just beginning to reach her world. Note that (a) the universe has become round; (b) there is an attempt to arrange the zones according to their density, i.e. from without inwards, fire, air (ether), water, earth; (c) exact measurements are given; (d) the watery zone is continued earthward so as to mingle with the central circle.

    In all these and other respects she is joining the general current of mediaeval science then beginning to be moulded by works translated from the Arabic.

    Her knowledge of the movements of the heavenly bodies is entirely innocent of the doctrine of epicycles, but in other respects her views have come to resemble those, for instance, of Messahalah, one of the simplest and easiest writers on the sphere available in her day. Furthermore, her conceptions have developed so as to fit in with the macrocosm-microcosm scheme which she grasped about the year 1158.

    Even in her latest work, however, her theory of the universe exhibits differences from that adopted by the schoolmen, as may be seen by comparing her diagram with, for example, the scheme of Dante (Fig. 4).

    [Illustration: Fig. 4. DANTE’S SCHEME OF THE UNIVERSE

    Slightly modified from Michelangelo Caetani, duca di Sermoneta, La materia della Divina Commedia di Dante Allighieri dichiarata in VI tavole, Monte Cassino, 1855.]

    Like many mediaeval writers, Hildegard would have liked to imagine an ideal state of the elemental spheres in which the rarest, fire, was uppermost, and the densest, earth, undermost. Such a scheme was, in fact, purveyed by Bernard Sylvestris and by Messahalah. Her conceptions were however disturbed by the awkward facts that water penetrated below the earth, and indeed sought the lowest level, while air and not water lay immediately above the earth’s surface. Mediaeval writers adopted various devices and expended a great amount of ingenuity in dealing with this discrepancy, which was a constant source of obscurity and confusion.

    Hildegard devotes much space and some highly involved allegory both in the Scivias and in the Liber Divinorum Operum to the explanation of the difficulty, while Dante himself wrote a treatise in high scholastic style on this very subject.[70]

    [Illustration: Plate X. A CRUCIFIX IN THE UFFIZI GALLERY

    About the middle of the XIIIth Century.]

    VII. MACROCOSM AND MICROCOSM

    The winds and elements of the outer universe, the macrocosm, become in Hildegard’s later schemes intimately related to structures and events within the body of man himself, the microcosm, the being around whom the universe centres. The terms macrocosm and microcosm are not employed by her, but in her last great work, the Liber Divinorum Operum, she succeeds in most eloquent and able fashion in synthesizing into one great whole, centred around this doctrine, her theological beliefs and her physiological knowledge, together with her conceptions of the working of the human mind and of the structure of the universe.

    The work is thus an epitome of the science of the time viewed through the distorting medium of this theory. In studying it the modern reader is necessarily hampered by the bizarre and visionary form into which the whole subject is cast. Nevertheless the scheme, though complex and difficult, is neither incoherent nor insane, as at first sight it may seem. On the contrary, it is a highly systematic and skilful presentment of a cosmic theory which for centuries dominated scientific thought.

    As an explanation of the complexity of existence which thinkers of all ages have sought to bring within the range of some simple formula, this theory of the essential similarity of macrocosm and microcosm held in the Middle Ages, during the Renaissance, and even into quite modern times, a position comparable to that of the theory of evolution in our own age. If at times it passed into folly and fantasy, it should be remembered that it also fulfilled a high purpose.

    It gave a meaning to the facts of nature and a formula to the naturalist, it unified philosophic systems, it exercised the ingenuity of theologians, and gave a convenient framework to prophecy, while it seemed to illumine history and to provide a key and meaning to life itself. Even now it is not perhaps wholly devoid of message, but as a phenomenon in the history of human thought, a theory which appealed to such diverse scientific writers as Seneca, Albertus Magnus, Paracelsus, Gilbert, Harvey, Boyle, and Leibnitz, is surely worthy of attention.

    In essaying to interpret the views of our authoress on this difficult subject, we rely mainly on the text of the Liber Divinorum Operum, supplemented by the beautiful illuminations of that work which adorn the Lucca MS. The book opens with a truly remarkable vision (Plate VI):

    ‘I saw a fair human form and the countenance thereof was of such
    beauty and brightness that it had been easier to gaze upon the
    sun. The head thereof was girt with a golden circlet through which
    appeared another face as of an aged man. From the neck of the
    figure on either side sprang a pinion which swept upward above the
    circlet and joined its fellow on high. And where on the right the
    wing turned upward, was portrayed an eagle’s head with eyes of
    flame, wherein appeared as in a mirror the lightning of the angels,
    while from a man’s head in the other wing the lightning of the
    stars did radiate.

    From either shoulder another wing reached to the
    knees. The figure was robed in brightness as of the sun, while the
    hands held a lamb shining with light. Beneath, the feet trampled a
    horrible black monster of revolting shape, upon the right ear of
    which a writhing serpent fixed itself.’[71]

    [Illustration: From the LUCCA MS. fo. 86 v

    Plate XI. THE STRUCTURE OF THE MUNDANE SPHERE]

    The image declares its identity in words reminiscent of the Wisdom literature or of passages in the hermetic writings, but which seem in fact to be partly borrowed from Bernard Sylvestris.

    ‘I am that supreme and fiery force that sends forth all the sparks
    of life. Death hath no part in me, yet do I allot it, wherefore I
    am girt about with wisdom as with wings. I am that living and fiery
    essence of the divine substance that glows in the beauty of the
    fields. I shine in the water, I burn in the sun and the moon and
    the stars. Mine is that mysterious force of the invisible wind. I
    sustain the breath of all living. I breathe in the verdure and in
    the flowers, and when the waters flow like living things, it is I.
    I formed those columns that support the whole earth....

    I am the
    force that lies hid in the winds, from me they take their source,
    and as a man may move because he breathes so doth a fire burn but
    by my blast. All these live because I am in them and am of their
    life. I am wisdom. Mine is the blast of the thundered word by which
    all things were made. I permeate all things that they may not die.
    I am life.’[72]

    [Illustration: WIESB. COD. B. fo. 4 r

    Plate XIIa. MAN’S FALL AND THE DISTURBANCE OF THE ELEMENTAL HARMONY]

    [Illustration: WIESB. COD. B. fo. 224 v

    Plate XIIb. THE NEW HEAVEN AND THE NEW EARTH]

    Hildegard thus supposes that the whole universe is permeated by a single living spirit, the figure of the vision. This spirit of the macrocosm, the Nous or ‘world spirit’ of the hermetic and Neoplatonic literature, the impersonated Nature, as we may perhaps render it, is in its turn controlled by the Godhead that pervades the form and is represented rising from its vertex as a second human face.

    Nature, the spirit of the cosmic order, controls and holds in subjection the hideous monster, the principle of death and dissolution, the Hyle or primordial matter of the Neoplatonists, whose chaotic and anarchic force would shatter and destroy this fair world unless fettered by a higher power.

    With the details of the visionary figure we need not delay,[73] but we pass to the description of the structure of the macrocosm itself, to which the second vision is devoted (Plate VII). Here appears the same figure of the macrocosmic spirit. But now the head and feet only are visible, and the arms are outstretched to enclose the disk of the universe which conceals the body.

    Although the macrocosm now described is considerably altered from Hildegard’s original scheme of the universe, she yet declares, ‘I saw in the bosom of the form the appearance of a disk of like sort to that which twenty-eight years before I had seen in the third vision, set forth in my book of Scivias’.[74] The zones of this disk are then described (Plates VII, VIII, and XI and Fig. 2). They are from without inwards:

    (a) The lucidus ignis, containing the three outer planets, the
    sixteen principal fixed stars, and the south wind.

    (b) The ignis niger, containing the sun, the north wind, and the
    materials of thunder, lightning, and hail.

    (c) The purus aether, containing the west wind, the moon, the two
    inner planets, and certain fixed stars.

    (d) The aer aquosus, containing the east wind.

    (e) The fortis et albus lucidusque aer, where certain other fixed
    stars are placed.

    (f) The aer tenuis, or atmosphere, in the outer part of which is
    the zone of the clouds.

    From all these objects, from the spheres of the elements, from the sun, moon, and other planets, from the four winds each with their two collaterals, from the fixed stars, and from the clouds, descend influences, indicated by lines, towards the figure of the macrocosm.

    The microcosm is then introduced.

    ‘And again I heard the voice from heaven saying, “God, who created
    all things, wrought also man in his own image and similitude, and
    in him he traced [signavit] all created things, and he held him
    in such love that he destined him for the place from which the
    fallen angel had been cast.”’[75]

    The various characters of the winds are expounded in a set of curious passages in which the doctrine of the macrocosm and microcosm is further mystically elaborated. An endeavour is made to attribute to the winds derived from the different quarters of heaven qualities associated with a number of animals.[76] The conception is illustrated and made comprehensible by the miniatures in the Lucca MS. (Plates VII and VIII).

    ‘In the middle of the disk [of the universe] there appeared the
    form of a man, the crown of whose head and the soles of whose feet
    extended to the fortis et albus lucidusque aer, and his hands
    were outstretched right and left to the same circle.... Towards
    these parts was an appearance as of four heads; a leopard, a wolf,
    a lion, and a bear.

    Above the head of the figure in the zone of the
    purus aether, I saw the head of the leopard emitting a blast from
    its mouth, and on the right side of the mouth the blast, curving
    itself somewhat backwards, was formed into a crab’s head ... with
    two chelae; while on the left side of the mouth a blast similarly
    curved ended in a stag’s head. From the mouth of the crab’s head,
    another blast went to the middle of the space between the leopard
    and the lion; and from the stag’s head a similar blast to the
    middle of the space between the leopard and the bear ... and all
    the heads were breathing towards the figure of the man.

    Under his
    feet in the aer aquosus there appeared as it were the head of a
    wolf, sending forth to the right a blast extending to the middle
    of the half space between its head and that of the bear, where it
    assumed the form of the stag’s head; and from the stag’s mouth
    there came, as it were, another breath which ended in the middle
    line. From the left of the wolf’s mouth arose a breath which went
    to the midst of the half space between the wolf and the lion, where
    was depicted another crab’s head ... from whose mouth another
    breath ended in the same middle line....

    And the breath of all the
    heads extended sideways from one to another.... Moreover on the
    right hand of the figure in the lucidus ignis, from the head of
    the lion, issued a breath which passed laterally on the right into
    a serpent’s head and on the left into a lamb’s head ... similarly
    on the figure’s left in the ignis niger there issued a breath
    from the bear’s head ending on its right in the head of [another]
    lamb, and on its left in another serpent’s head....

    And above the
    head of the figure the seven planets were ranged in order, three
    in the lucidus ignis, one projecting into the ignis niger and
    three into the purus aether.... And in the circumference of the
    circle of the lucidus ignis there appeared the sixteen principal
    stars, four in each quadrant between the heads....

    Also the purus
    aether
    and the fortis et albus lucidusque aer seemed to be full
    of stars which sent forth their rays towards the clouds, whence ...
    tongues like rivers descended to the disk and towards the figure,
    which was thus surrounded and influenced by these signs.’[77]

    The third vision is devoted to an account of the human body, the microcosm (Plate VIII), with a comparison of its organs to the parts of the macrocosmic scheme, together with a detailed account of the effects of the heavenly bodies on the humours in man, the whole brought into a strongly theological setting. Some of these views are set forth below in the chapter on anatomy and physiology.

    The fourth vision explains the influence of the heavenly bodies and of the superior elements on the power of nature as exhibited on the surface of the earth. It is illustrated by a charming miniature in the Lucca MS. (Plate IX).

    ‘I saw that the upper fiery firmament was stirred, so that as it were ashes were cast therefrom to earth, and they produced rashes and ulcers in men and animals and fruits.’ These effects are shown in the left upper quadrant of Plate IX, where the ashes are seen proceeding from the lucidus ignis, the ‘upper fiery firmament’. Two figures are seen, a female semi-recumbent, who lifts a fruit to her mouth, and a male figure fully recumbent, on whose legs a rash is displayed. The trees also in this quadrant show the effects of the ashes, two of them being denuded of fruit and foliage.

    ‘Then I saw that from the ignis niger certain vapours (nebulae) descended, which withered the verdure and dried up the moisture of the fields. The purus aether, however, resisted these ashes and vapours, seeking to hold back these plagues.’ These vapours may be seen in the right upper quadrant of Plate IX. They descend from the ignis niger, attenuate for a space in the purus aether, and then descend through the other zones on to an arid and parched land. Here are two husbandmen; one sits forlornly clasping his axe, while the other leans disconsolately upon his hoe. On the legs of the latter a rash may be distinguished.

    ‘And looking again I saw that from the fortis et albus lucidusque aer certain other clouds reached the earth and infected men and beasts with sore pestilence, so that they were subjected to many ills even to the death, but the aer aquosus opposed that influence so that they were not hurt beyond measure.’ This scene is portrayed in the right lower quadrant of Plate IX. Here is a husbandman in mortal anguish. He has gathered his basket of fruit and now lies stricken with the pestilence.

    His left hand is laid on his heart, while his right hangs listless on his thigh, pointing to tokens of plague upon his legs. Beyond lies the dead body of a beast on which a carrion bird has settled.

    ‘Again I saw that the moisture in the aer tenuis was as it were boiling above the surface of the earth, awakening the force of the earth and making fruits to grow.’[78] This happier scene is represented in the left lower quadrant of Plate IX. Here the beneficent fertilizing influence is falling on trees and herbs and the happy husbandmen are reaping its results.

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 224 r

    Plate XIII. THE LAST JUDGEMENT AND FATE OF THE ELEMENTS]

    The main outline of the Liber Divinorum Operum is, we believe, borrowed from the work of Bernard Sylvestris of Tours, De mundi universitate libri duo sive megacosmus et microcosmus.[79] In this composition by a teacher at the cathedral school of Chartres,[80] the gods and goddesses of the classical pantheon flit across the stage, for all the world as though the writer were a pagan, and the work might be thought to be the last one from which our pious authoress would borrow.

    The De mundi universitate is alternately in prose and verse and betrays an acquaintance with the classics very rare at its date. ‘The rhythm of the hexameters is clearly that of Lucan, while the vocabulary is mainly of Ovid.’[81] The mythology is founded mainly on the Timaeus. The eternal seminaria of created things are mentioned, and it has been conjectured that the work exhibits traces of the influence of Lucretius,[82] but the general line of thought is clearly related to Neoplatonic literature.

    Thus the anima universalis of Neoplatonic writings can be identified with the Nous or Noys of Bernard. This principle is contrasted with primordial matter or Hyle. The parallel character of the Liber Divinorum Operum and the De mundi universitate can be illustrated by a few extracts from the latter.

    It will be seen that although the general setting is changed, yet Hildegard’s figure of the spirit of the macrocosm is to be identified with Bernard’s Noys. Hyle, on the other hand, becomes in Hildegard’s plan the monstrous form, the emblem of brute matter, on which the spirit of the universe tramples.

    [Illustration: From BIBL. NAT. MS. LAT. 5543 fo. 136 r

    Plate XIV. DIAGRAM OF THE RELATION OF HUMAN AND COSMIC PHENOMENA IXth

    Century]

    ‘In huius operis primo libro qui Megacosmus dicitur, id est
    maior mundus, Natura ad Noym, id est Dei providentiam, de primae
    materiae, id est hyles, confusione querimoniam quasi cum lacrimis
    agit et ut mundus pulchrius petit. Noys igitur eius mota precibus
    petitioni libenter annuit et ita quatuor elementa ab invicem
    seiungit. Novem ierarchias angelorum in coelo ponit. stellas
    in firmamento figit. signa disponit. sub signis orbes septem
    planetarum currere facit. quatuor ventos cardinales sibi invicem
    opponit. Sequitur genesis animantium et terrae situs medius....

    ‘In secundo libro qui Microcosmus dicitur, id est minor mundus,
    Noys ad Naturam loquitur et de mundi expolitione gloriatur et in
    operis sui completione se hominem plasmaturam pollicetur. Iubet
    igitur Uraniam, quae siderum regina est, et Physin, quae rerum
    omnium est peritissima, sollicite perquirat. Natura protinus
    iubenti obsequitur et per caelestes circulos Uraniam quaeritans eam
    sideribus inhiantem reperit. eiusque itineris causa praecognita
    se operis et itineris comitem Urania pollicetur....

    Subitoque ibi
    Noys affuit suoque velle eis ostenso trinas speculationes tribus
    assignando tribuit & ad hominis plasmationem eas impellit. Physis
    igitur de quatuor elementorum reliquiis hominem format et a capite
    incipiens membratim operando opus suum in pedibus consummat....

    ‘Noys ego scientia et divinae voluntatis arbitraria ad
    dispositionem rerum, quem ad modum de consensu eius accipio, sic
    meae administrationis officia circumduco....

    ‘(Noys) erat fons luminis, seminarium vitae, bonum bonitatis
    divinae, plenitude scientiae quae mens altissimi nominatur. Ea
    igitur noys summi & exsuperantissimi Dei est intellectus et ex
    eius divinitate nata natura.... Erat igitur videre velut in
    speculo tersiore quicquid generationi quicquid operi Dei secretior
    destinarat affectus.’[83]

    Hildegard’s conception of macrocosm and microcosm, which was thus probably borrowed from Bernard Sylvestris, has analogies also to those well-known figures illustrating the supposed influence of the signs of the zodiac on the different parts of the body.[84] Such figures, with the zodiacal symbols arranged around a figure of Christ, may be seen in certain MSS. anterior to Hildegard,[85] while the influence of the ‘Melothesia’, to give it the name assigned by Porphyry, has been traced through its period of efflorescence at the Renaissance (Plates XV,[86] XVI,[87] and XVII,[88] compare with Plates VII and VIII) right down to our own age and country, where it still appeals to the ignorant and foolish.[89]

    Hildegard often interprets natural events by means of a peculiarly crude form of the doctrine, as when she describes how ‘if the excess of waters below are drawn up to the clouds (by the just judgment of God in the requital of sinners), then the moisture from the aer aquosus transudes through the fortis et albus lucidusque aer as a draught drunk into the urinary bladder; and the same waters descend in an inundation’.[90]

    Again, events in the body of man are most naively explained on the basis of the nature of the external world as she has pictured it.

    ‘The humours at times rage fiercely as a leopard and again they are
    softened, going backwards as a crab;[91] or they may show their
    diversity by leaping and goring as a stag, or they may be as a
    wolf in their ravening, and yet again they may invade the body of
    man after the manner of both wolf and crab. Or else they may show
    forth their strength unceasingly as a lion, or as a serpent they
    may go now softly, now violently, and at times they may be gentle
    as a lamb and at times again they may growl as an angered bear,
    and at times they may partake of the nature of the lamb and of the
    serpent.’[92]

    Having completed her general survey of the macrocosm (Vision II), and having investigated in detail the structure of man’s body, the microcosm, in terms of the greater universe (Vision III), and discussed the influence of the heavenly bodies on terrestrial events (Vision IV), Hildegard turns to the internal structure of the terrestrial sphere (Vision V). This vision is illustrated by the figure in the Lucca MS. reproduced in Plate XI.

    [Illustration: Fig. 5. From Herrade de Landsberg’s Hortus deliciarum, after Straub and Keller.]

    Upon the surface of the earth towards the east stands the building which symbolizes the aedificium of the church, a favourite conception of our authoress. This church is surmounted by a halo, whence proceed a pair of pinions which extend their shelter over a full half of the earth’s circumference. As for the rest of the earth’s surface, part is within the wide-opened jaws of a monster, the Destroyer, and the remainder is beneath the surface of the ocean. Within the earth are five parts analogous, as she would have us believe, to the five senses.

    An eastern clear arc and a western clouded one signify respectively the excellence of the orient where Zion is situated, and the Cimmerian darkness of the occidental regions over which the shadow of the dragon is cast. Centrally is a quadrate area divided into three zones where the qualities of heat and cold and of a third intermediate ‘temperateness’ (temperies) are stored. North and south of this are two areas where purgatory is situate. Each is shaped like a truncated cone and composed also of three sectors.

    Souls are seen suffering in one sector the torment of flame, in another the torment of water, while in the third or intermediate sector lurk monsters and creeping things which add to the miseries of purgatory or at times come forth to earth’s surface to plague mankind. These northern and southern sections exhibit dimly by their identically reversed arrangement the belief in the antipodean inversion of climate, an idea hinted several times in Hildegard’s writings, but more definitely illustrated by a figure of Herrade de Landsberg (Fig. 5).

    [Illustration: From BIBL. NAT. MS. LAT. 7028 fo. 154 r

    Plate XV. AN XIth CENTURY FRENCH MELOTHESIA]

    [Illustration: From BIBL. NAT. MS. LAT. 11229 fo. 45 v

    Plate XVI. A MELOTHESIA OF ABOUT 1400]

    [Illustration: From the SYMBOLUM APOSTOLICORUM

    Plate XVII. A GERMAN BLOCK BOOK

    First Half of XVth Century. Heidelberg University Library]

    [Illustration: From BODLEIAN MS. ASHMOLE 399 fo. 18 r

    Plate XVIII. AN ANATOMICAL DIAGRAM OF ABOUT 1298

    From the Five-Figure Series. Cp. Plate XXXIII]

    [Illustration: Fig. 6.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 7.

    MELOTHESIAE

    From R. Fludd, Historia utriusque cosmi, Oppenheim, 1619, pp. 112 and 113.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 8. THE MICROCOSM

    From R. Fludd, Philosophia sacra seu astrologia cosmica, Frankfurt, 1628, p. 52.]

    Macrocosmic schemes of the type illustrated by the text of Hildegard and by the figures of the Lucca MS. had a great vogue in mediaeval times, and were passed on to later ages. Some passages in Hildegard’s work read curiously like Paracelsus (1491-1541),[93] and it is not hard to find a link between these two difficult and mystical writers.

    Trithemius, the teacher of Paracelsus, was abbot of Sponheim, an important settlement almost within sight of Hildegard’s convents on the Rupertsberg and Disibodenberg. Trithemius studied Hildegard’s writings with great care and attached much importance to them, so that they may well have influenced his pupil. The influence of mediaeval theories of the relation of macrocosm and microcosm is encountered among numerous Renaissance writers besides Paracelsus, and is presented to us, for instance, by such a cautious, balanced, and scientifically-minded humanist as Fracastor. But as the years went on, the difficulty in applying the details of the theory became ever greater and greater.

    Facts were strained and mutilated more and more to make them fit the Procrustean bed of an outworn theory, which at length became untenable when the heliocentric system of Copernicus and Galileo replaced the geocentric and anthropocentric systems of an earlier age. The idea of a close parallelism between the structure of man and of the wider universe was gradually abandoned by the scientific, while among the unscientific it degenerated and became little better than an insane obsession.

    As such it appears in the ingenious ravings of the English follower of Paracelsus, the Rosicrucian, Robert Fludd, who reproduced, often with fidelity, the systems which had some novelty five centuries before his time (Figs. 6, 7, and 8). As a similar fantastic obsession this once fruitful hypothesis still occasionally appears even in modern works of learning and industry.[94]

    VIII. ANATOMY AND PHYSIOLOGY

    Hildegard’s ideas on these subjects are set out in the fourth vision of the Liber Divinorum Operum, which is devoted to a description of man’s body according to the macrocosmic scheme. This setting makes her account by no means easy to read, while it increases the difficulty of tracing the origin of her views.

    The list of works containing anatomical descriptions available to a German writer in the early Middle Ages is not long. Avicenna was hardly yet accessible, and only such scraps of Galen as appear in Constantine and the Salernitans. The available works may be enumerated thus:

    (a) The short Anatomia porci of Copho of Salerno, dating from
    about 1085.[95]

    (b) An anonymous Salernitan anatomy,[96] written about 1100 and
    largely based on Copho and Constantine.

    (c) The Liber de humana natura of Constantine the African,
    written probably between 1070 and 1085 at Monte Cassino.[97]

    (d) Constantine’s De communibus medico cognitu necessariis locis,
    written about the same time as the above.[98] This work is in
    four books, of which the second, third, and fourth are devoted
    to anatomy and physiology.

    (e) Here may be placed also Constantine’s translation of the
    Viaticum of Isaac Judeus. Both these latter works of
    Constantine are long and technical, and designed for the use of
    the trained physician.

    In addition to these there was in the Middle Ages a definite anatomic tradition, which expressed itself constantly in:

    (f) A series of five anatomical diagrams representing respectively
    the arteries, veins, bones, nerves, and muscles[99] (see Plate
    XXXIII, opposite page 92 of the present volume). These diagrams
    were copied in the most servile fashion for centuries, and
    something very like them has remained in use to this day in
    Tibet.[100] The versions, whether in Persia or England, in
    Germany or Italy, were remarkably uniform.

    (g) In several MSS. there has been found attached to these
    remarkable diagrams a short text describing the five systems,
    arteries, veins, nerves, bones, and muscles. This text,
    however, purporting to be from Galen, has little relation to
    the figures, which it does not really explain, and it should
    therefore be regarded as a separate work.[101]

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 22 r

    Plate XIX. BIRTH. THE ARRIVAL AND TRIALS OF THE SOUL]

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 25 r

    Plate XX. DEATH. THE DEPARTURE AND FATE OF THE SOUL]

    Of these seven sources it appears to us that (c) and (f)--the short De humana natura of Constantine, and the five-figure series--are those on which Hildegard drew.

    The absence of Arabisms and the scarcity of technical anatomical terms in her writings, her failure to distinguish between veins and arteries, the absence of anything of the nature of myology or osteology, together with the neglect of the spinal marrow as an important organ, make it very unlikely that she consulted Constantine’s longer works or the Salernitan authorities or the text of the five-figure series.

    Her anatomical descriptions resemble those of Constantine’s shorter work, on the other hand, in the description of the three vesicles of the brain and their relations to the faculties of the mind, in the treatment of the five senses, in the view of the influence of the planets on the child and the emphasis laid on epilepsy, as well as in the absence of any distinction between arteries and veins, and in the loose doctrines of the humours and of the causes of deformities and monstrosities.

    In some of these respects also her account of the human body presents points of resemblance to the De hominis membris ac partibus of Hugh of St. Victor,[102] with whom, however, her contact appears to be less close than with Constantine.

    We may infer that Hildegard had consulted anatomical diagrams and was accustomed to this method of representing the organs from a passage descriptive of the microcosm, in which she says that ‘in the mouth of the figure in whose body was the disk, I saw a light brighter than the light of day, in the form of threads, some circular, some in other geometrical forms, and some shaped like human members belonging to the figure, which was clearly portrayed on the disk upright and accurately limned’.[103] These ‘circles and geometrical figures’ fairly describe the highly diagrammatic manner in which the five-figure series represents the internal organs, and several points suggest that she does indeed refer to this series.

    Her description of the abdominal muscles (umbilicus) ‘covering the viscera like a cap’, her general descriptions of the vessels (venae) and the muscles, and especially her account of the vessels of the leg and of the intimate relations of the main venae to the organ of hearing, fits in perfectly with the form of these remarkable diagrams (Plate XVIII).

    We here render some of the most important of her general anatomical descriptions:

    ‘The humours may pass to the liver, where wisdom is tested, having
    been already tempered in the brain by the strength of the spirit,
    and having absorbed its moisture so that now it is plump, strong,
    and healthy.

    ‘In the right of man is the liver and its great heat, so that the
    right is swift to act and to work;[104] but towards the left are
    heart and lung, which fortify the body for its task and receive
    their heat from the liver as from a furnace. But the vessels of
    the liver, affected by the agitation of the humours, trouble the
    venules of the ear of man and sometimes confound the organ of
    hearing....

    ‘I saw also that sometimes the humours seek the navel, which covers
    the viscera as a cap, and holds them in, lest they be dissipated,
    and maintains their course and preserves the heat both of them
    and of the veins.... But sometimes the humours seek the loins
    (lumbos),[105] which mock, deceive, and endanger the virile
    powers and which are held in place by nerves and other vessels; in
    which, nevertheless, reason nourishes so that man may know what to
    do and what to avoid....

    ‘And the same humours go to the vessels of the reins and of other
    members, and pass in their turn to the vessels of the spleen, and
    then to the lungs and to the heart; and they meet the viscera
    on the left where they are warmed by the lungs, but the liver
    warms the right-hand side of the body. And the vessels of the
    brain, heart, lung, liver, and other parts carry strength to the
    reins, whose vessels descend to the legs, strengthening them; and
    returning along with the leg vessels, they unite with the virile
    organ or with the womb as the case may be.

    ‘And as the stomach absorbs food, or as iron is sharpened on a
    stone, so do they bring the reproductive power to those parts.

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B, fo. 123 r

    Plate XXI. THE FALL OF THE ANGELS]

    ‘Again, the muscles of the arms, legs, and thighs contain vessels
    full of humours; and just as the belly has within it viscera
    containing nourishment, so the muscles of arms, legs, and thighs
    have both vessels and the [contained] humours which preserve man’s
    strength.... But when a man runs or walks quickly, the nerves about
    the knees and the venules in the knees become distended.

    And since
    they are united with the vessels of the legs, which are numerous
    and intercommunicate in a net-like manner, they conduct the fatigue
    to the vessels of the liver, and thus they reach the vessels of the
    brain, and so send the fatigue throughout the body. But the vessels
    from the reins pass rather to the left leg than to the right,
    because the right leg gets its strength more from the heat of the
    liver. And the vessels of the right leg ascend as far as the renal
    and kindred vessels, and these latter vessels unite with those of
    the kidney.

    And the liver warms the reins which lie in the fatness
    derived from the humours....

    ‘The humours in man are distributed in just measure. But when they
    affect the veins of the liver, his humidity is decreased and also
    the humidity of the chest is attenuated; so that thus dried, he
    falls into disease of such a nature that the phlegm is dry and
    toxic and ascends to the brain. There it produces headache and pain
    in the eyes and wasting of the marrow, and thus if the moon is in
    default he may develop the falling evil [epilepsy].

    ‘The humidity also which is in the umbilicus is dispersed by the
    same humours, and turned into dryness and hardness, so that the
    flesh becomes ulcerated and scabby as though he were leprous,
    if indeed he do not actually become so. And the vessels of his
    testicles, being adversely affected by these humours, similarly
    disturb the other vessels, so that the proper humidity is dried up
    within them; and thus, the humours being withdrawn, impetigos may
    arise ... and the marrow of the bones and the vessels of the flesh
    are dried up, and so the man becomes chronically ill, dragging out
    his days in languor.

    ‘But sometimes the humours affect breast and liver ... so that
    various foolish thoughts arise ... and they ascend to the brain
    and infect it and again descend to the stomach and generate fevers
    there, so that the man is long sick.

    Yet again they vex the minor
    vessels of the ear with superfluity of phlegm; or with the same
    phlegm they infect the vessels of the lung, so that he coughs and
    can scarce breathe; and the phlegm may pass thence into the vessels
    of the heart and give him pain there, or the pain may pass into the
    side, exciting pleurisy; under such circumstances also, the moon
    being in defect, the man may lapse into the falling sickness.’[106]
    #/

    Sometimes Hildegard’s anatomical ideas can be paralleled among her contemporaries. Thus the following passage on the relationship of the planets to the brain is well illustrated by a diagram of Herrade de Landsberg.

    [Illustration: Fig. 9. From Herrade de Landsberg’s Hortus deliciarum, after Straub and Keller’s reproduction.[107]]

    ‘From the summit of the vessel of the brain to the extremity of the
    forehead seven equal spaces can be distinguished. Here the seven
    planets are designated, the uppermost planet in the highest part,
    the moon in front, the sun in the middle and the other planets
    distributed among the other spaces’ (Fig. 9).

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 41 v

    Plate XXII. THE DAYS OF CREATION AND THE FALL OF MAN]

    IX. BIRTH AND DEATH AND THE NATURE OF THE SOUL

    The method by which the soul enters the body is set forth in a very striking vision in the Scivias and is illustrated in the Wiesbaden Codex B by a no less remarkable miniature (Plate XIX). The soul, which contains the element of wisdom, passes into the infant’s body while yet within the mother’s womb. The Wisdom of God is represented as a four-square object, with its angles set to the four quarters of the earth, this form being the symbol of stability. From it a long tube-like process descends into the mother’s womb.

    Down this there passes into the child a bright object, described variously as ‘spherical’ and as ‘shapeless’, which ‘illumines the whole body’ and becomes or develops into the soul.

    The birth scene is strikingly portrayed. In the foreground lies the mother with the head and shoulders supported and the right arm raised.

    In her womb is the infant in the position known to obstetricians as a ‘transverse presentation’. Around the child may be distinguished clear traces of the uterine membranes. Near the couch are ranged a group of ten figures who carry vessels containing the various qualities of the child. Above and to the left the Evil One may be seen pouring some noxious substance into one of these vessels, or perhaps abstracting some element of good. The whole scene suggests the familiar fairy tale in which, while all bring pleasant gifts to the child’s birth, there comes at last the old witch or the ill-used relative who adds a quota of spitefulness.

    The scene is described and expounded as follows:

    ‘Behold, I saw upon earth men carrying milk in earthen vessels
    and making cheeses therefrom. Some was of the thick kind from
    which firm cheese is made, some of the thinner sort from which
    more porous [tenuis] cheese is made, and some was mixed with
    corruption [tabes] and of the sort from which bitter cheese is
    made. And I saw the likeness of a woman having a complete human
    form within her womb.

    And then, by a secret disposition of the
    Most High Craftsman, a fiery sphere having none of the lineaments
    of a human body possessed the heart of the form, and reached the
    brain and transfused itself through all the members....

    And I saw
    that many circling eddies possessed the sphere and brought it
    earthward, but with ever renewed force it returned upward and with
    wailing asked, “I, wanderer that I am, where am I?” “In death’s
    shadow.” “And where go I?” “In the way of sinners.” “And what is my
    hope?” “That of all wanderers.”’[108] The vision is explained as
    follows: ‘Those whom thou seest carrying milk in earthen vessels
    are in the world, men and women alike, having in their bodies the
    seed of mankind from which are procreated the various kinds of
    human beings.

    Part is thickened because the seed in its strength
    is well and truly concocted, and this produces forceful men to
    whom are allotted gifts both spiritual and carnal.... And some
    had cheeses less firmly curdled, for they in their feebleness
    have seed imperfectly tempered, and they raise offspring mostly
    stupid, feeble, and useless....

    And some was mixed with corruption
    ... for the seed in that brew cannot be rightly raised, it is
    invalid and makes misshapen men who are bitter, distressed, and
    oppressed of heart, so that they may not lift their gaze to higher
    things....[109] And often in forgetfulness of God and by the
    mocking devil, a mistio is made of the man and of the woman and
    the thing born therefrom is deformed, for parents who have sinned
    against me return to me crucified in their children.’[110] (Compare
    Constantine De humana natura, sections ‘De perfectione’ and ‘De
    impeditione’.)

    Hildegard thus supposes that the qualities and form of a child are inherited from its parents, but that two factors, the formless soul from the Almighty and the corrupt fluid instilled by the devil, also contribute to the character of offspring. This is the usual mediaeval view and is broadly portrayed in the figure.

    The strange conception of the body being formed from the seed, as cheese is precipitated and curdled from milk, is doubtless derived from a passage in the Book of Job:

    ‘Hast thou not poured me out as milk,
    And curdled me like cheese?
    Thou hast clothed me with skin and flesh,
    And knit me together with bones and sinews’ (Job x. 10, 11).[111]

    When the body has thus taken shape there enters into it the soul which, though at first shapeless, gradually assumes the form of its host, the earthly tabernacle; and at death the soul departs through the mouth with the last breath, as a fully developed naked human shape, to be received by devils or angels as the case may be (Plate XX).

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B. fo. 47 r

    Plate XXIII. THE VISION OF THE TRINITY]

    During its residence in the body the soul plays the part usually assigned to it in the earlier mediaeval psychology, before the ideas of Nemesius and Ibn Ghazali had been elaborated and systematized by Albert and Aquinas. Hildegard regards the brain as having three chambers or divisions, corresponding to the three parts of man’s nature, an idea encountered in the writings of St. Augustine. Parallel to these there are, she tells us,

    ‘three elements in man by which he shows life; to wit, soul
    (anima), body (corpus), and sense (sensus). The soul vivifies
    the body and inspires the senses; the body attracts the soul and
    reveals the senses; the senses affect the soul and allure the
    body. For the soul rules the body as a flame throws light into
    darkness, and it has two principal powers or limbs, the intellect
    (intellectus) and the will (voluntas); not indeed that the soul
    has limbs to move itself, but that it manifests itself thereby as
    the sun declares himself by his brightness....

    For the intellect
    is attached to the soul as the arms to the body: for as the body
    is prolonged into arms with fingers and hands attached, so the
    intellect is produced from the soul by the operation of its various
    powers.’[112]

    We need follow Hildegard no further into her maze of micro-cosmology, in which an essential similarity and relationship is discovered between the qualities of the soul, the constitution of the external cosmos, and the structure of the body, a thought which appears as the culmination of her entire system and provides the clue to the otherwise incomprehensible whole.[113]

    X. THE VISIONS AND THEIR PATHOLOGICAL BASIS

    For the physical accompaniments and phenomena of Hildegard’s visions we have three separate lines of evidence: her own account; the statements of her contemporary biographers, Theodoric and Godefrid; and the miniatures of the Wiesbaden Codex B, probably prepared under her supervision.

    It is clear that despite the length and activity of her life, Hildegard did not enjoy normal health. From a very early age she was the subject of trances and visions, and from time to time she was prostrated with protracted illness.

    ‘God punished me for a time by laying me on a bed of sickness so
    that the blood was dried in my veins, the moisture in my flesh
    and the marrow in my bones, as though the spirit were about to
    depart from my body. In this affliction I lay thirty days while my
    body burned as with fever, and it was thought that this sickness
    was laid upon me for a punishment. And my spirit also was ailing,
    and yet was pinned to my flesh, so that while I did not die, yet
    did I not altogether live. And throughout those days I watched
    a procession of angels innumerable who fought with Michael and
    against the dragon and won the victory....

    And one of them called
    out to me, “Eagle! Eagle![114] why sleepest thou?... All the eagles
    are watching thee.... Arise! for it is dawn, and eat and drink.”
    And then the whole troop cried out with a mighty voice,... “Is not
    the time for passing come? Arise, maiden, arise!” Instantly my
    body and my senses came back into the world; and seeing this, my
    daughters who were weeping around me lifted me from the ground and
    placed me on my bed, and thus I began to get back my strength.

    ‘But the affliction laid upon me did not fully cease; yet was my
    spirit daily strengthened.... I was yet weak of flesh, timid of
    mind, and fearful of pain ... but in my soul I said, “Lord! Lord!
    all that Thou puttest upon me I know to be good ... for have I not
    earned these things from my youth up?” Yet was I assured He would
    not permit my soul to be thus tortured in the future life....[115]
    Thus was my body seethed as in a pot ... yet gave I thanks to God,
    for if this affliction had not been from Him I had surely not lived
    so long.

    But although I was thus tortured, yet did I, in supernal
    vision, often repeat, cry aloud, and write those things which the
    Holy Spirit willed to put before me.

    ‘Three years were thus passed during which the Cherubim pursued me
    with a flaming sword ... and at length my spirit revived within me
    and my body was restored again as to its veins and marrows, and
    thus I was healed.’[116]

    This illness of Hildegard was the longest and the most typical, but by no means the only one through which she passed. She describes her affliction as continuing for long periods, but there can be little doubt, from her history, that during much of the time she was able to carry on some at least of her functions as head of a religious house.

    [Illustration: WIESB. COD. B. fo. 213 v

    SEDENS LUCIDUS]

    [Illustration: From WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 153 r

    Plate XXIV. ZELUS DEI]

    The condition from which she was suffering was clearly a functional nervous disorder; this is sufficiently demonstrated by her repeated complete recoveries, her activity between the attacks, and the great age to which she lived. At first sight, the long procession of figures and visions suggests that she might have been the victim of a condition similar to that of which Jerome Cardan has left us so complete a personal record. But on reading the books of visions, the reader will easily convince himself that we are not here dealing with a dream-state.

    The visions are indeed essentially vivid. ‘These visions which I saw’, she repeatedly assures us, ‘I beheld neither in sleep, nor in dream, nor in madness, nor with my carnal eyes, nor with the ears of the flesh, nor in hidden places; but wakeful, alert, with the eyes of the spirit and with the inward ears I perceived them in open view and according to the will of God. And how this was compassed is hard indeed for human flesh to search out.’[117]

    Nevertheless, though the visions exhibit great originality and creative power--the reader will often be reminded of William Blake--all or nearly all present certain characters in common. In all a prominent feature is a point or a group of points of light, which shimmer and move, usually in a wavelike manner, and are most often interpreted as stars or flaming eyes. In quite a number of cases one light, larger than the rest, exhibits a series of concentric circular figures of wavering form; and often definite fortification figures are described, radiating in some cases from a coloured area.

    Often the lights gave that impression of working, boiling or fermenting, described by so many visionaries, from Ezekiel onwards.

    This outline of the visions the saint herself variously interpreted.

    We give examples from the more typical of these visions, in which the medical reader or the sufferer from migraine will, we think, easily recognize the symptoms of scintillating scotoma. Some of the illuminations, here reproduced in their original colours, will confirm this interpretation.

    ‘I saw a great star most splendid and beautiful, and with it
    an exceeding multitude of falling sparks which with the star
    followed southward. And they examined Him upon His throne almost
    as something hostile, and turning from Him, they sought rather the
    north. And suddenly they were all annihilated, being turned into
    black coals ... and cast into the abyss that I could see them no
    more’[118] (Plate XXI).

    This vision, illustrated by the beautiful figure of stars falling into the waves, is interpreted by her as signifying the Fall of the Angels.

    The concentric circles appear in numerous visions, and notably in that of the Days of the Creation of the World and the Fall of Man, illustrated by what is perhaps the most beautiful of all the miniatures of the Wiesbaden Codex B (lib. ii, vis. 1, Plate XXII). It is in this concentric form that Hildegard most frequently pictures the Almighty, and the idea again appears in the eleventh miniature, here reproduced in its original colours, which she describes as ‘a most shining light and within it the appearance of a human form of a sapphire colour which glittered with a gentle but sparkling glow’ (lib. ii, vis. 2, Plate XXIII). Appearances of this type are recorded again and again.

    The type with fortification figures is encountered in a whole series of visions, of which we reproduce the account and illumination of the Zelus Dei (lib. iii, vis. 5, Plate XXIV, lower section).

    ‘I looked and behold a head of marvellous form ... of the colour
    of flame and red as fire, and it had a terrible human face gazing
    northward in great wrath. From the neck downward I could see no
    further form, for the body was altogether concealed ... but the
    head itself I saw, like the bare form of a human head. Nor was it
    hairy like a man, nor indeed after the manner of a woman, but it
    was more like to a man than a woman, and very awful to look upon.

    ‘It had three wings of marvellous length and breadth, white as a
    dazzling cloud. They were not raised erect but spread apart one
    from the other and the head rose slightly above them ... and at
    times they would beat terribly and again would be still. No word
    uttered the head, but remained altogether still, yet now and again
    beating with its extended wings.’

    From the head extended a series of fortification lines, and this peculiar form of vision is reproduced on several occasions and variously interpreted (Plate XXIV, upper section). It is united with similar visions in what we regard as a reconstructed conception of exceedingly complex structure. This she claims to see separately, and she interprets it as the aedificium of the city of God (Plate XXV).

    Such reconstructed visions are clearly of a different type and origin to the simple group in which a shining light or group of lights is encountered and interpreted as a speaking figure.

    [Illustration: From THE WIESBADEN CODEX B fo. 30 r

    Plate XXV. THE HEAVENLY CITY]

    Hildegard’s visions, perhaps without exception, contain this element of a blinding or glittering light, which she interprets in a more or less spiritual manner. We terminate our account with the passage in which she sums up her experiences of it.

    ‘From my infancy’, she says, ‘up to the present time, I being now
    more than seventy years of age, I have always seen this light in
    my spirit and not with external eyes, nor with any thoughts of my
    heart nor with help from the senses. But my outward eyes remain
    open and the other corporeal senses retain their activity. The
    light which I see is not located but yet is more brilliant than the
    sun, nor can I examine its height, length, or breadth, and I name
    it the “cloud of the living light”. And as sun, moon, and stars are
    reflected in water, so the writings, sayings, virtues, and works
    of men shine in it before me.

    And whatever I thus see in vision
    the memory thereof remains long with me. Likewise I see, hear, and
    understand almost in a moment and I set down what I thus learn....

    ‘But sometimes I behold within this light another light which I
    name “the Living Light itself”.... And when I look upon it every
    sadness and pain vanishes from my memory, so that I am again as a
    simple maid and not as an old woman....[119]

    ‘And now that I am over seventy years old my spirit according
    to the will of God soars upward in vision to the highest heaven
    and to the farthest stretch of the air and spreads itself among
    different peoples to regions exceeding far from me here, and thence
    I can behold the changing clouds and the mutations of all created
    things; for all these I see not with the outward eye or ear, nor
    do I create them from the cogitations of my heart ... but within
    my spirit, my eyes being open, so that I have never suffered any
    terror when they left me.’[120]

    NOTE.--The author’s thanks are due to the Rev. H. A. Wilson, Mr.
    C. C. J. Webb, and Mr. R. R. Steele, who have read the proofs of this
    article and have made valuable suggestions; to Mr. J. A. Herbert of
    the MS. Department of the British Museum, who drew his attention to
    the work of Herrade de Landsberg; and to Mr. M. H. Spielmann, who
    brought to his notice the crucifix figured in Plate X. He owes a
    special debt of gratitude to the late Dom Louis Baillet of Oosterhoot
    for his courtesy and generosity in lending him reproductions of the
    illuminations of the Wiesbaden Codex.

    Baillet was a young scholar of
    great promise, whose early death is a severe loss to the knowledge of
    mediaeval science.

    The author has also to thank Professor Henrici of the Nassauische
    Landesbibliothek at Wiesbaden, Professor Wille and Professor Sillib
    of the Universitätsbibliothek at Heidelberg, and Signor Boselli
    of the R. Bibliotica Governativa at Lucca, who have all given him
    exceptional facilities for the study of the treasures under their
    charge.

    [Illustration: Signed photograph of John Wilfred Jenkinson]

    JOHN WILFRED JENKINSON

    John Wilfred Jenkinson was born in 1871, and came from Bradfield to Exeter College, Oxford, with a classical scholarship in 1890.

    After taking his degree in Literae Humaniores he came, in 1894, to University College, London, where he devoted himself with extraordinary and never-flagging energy to biological studies.

    Without having had the usual preliminary scientific teaching, he brought, on the other hand, a well-trained mind to bear on his new work, and the rapidity and completeness with which he acquired his scientific equipment was one of the most striking and interesting points in his career. Jenkinson very soon turned to original investigation, and from the first he showed a predilection for Embryology.

    For a short time he held a post at one of the great London hospitals, but he soon returned to Oxford to join the teaching staff of the Department of Comparative Anatomy. He used the opportunity of University vacations to work in the laboratory of the late Professor A. A. W. Hubrecht at Utrecht, where part of his first published research was written. During the fifteen years of life that remained to him, he established himself as the foremost English writer on Embryology, devoting himself especially to its experimental aspect, a line of work in which he will rank as one of the pioneers.

    Jenkinson became Doctor of Science in 1905, and in the same year he married Constance Stephenson. In 1906 he was appointed University Lecturer in Embryology, and in 1909 he was elected to a Research Fellowship at Exeter College.

    Jenkinson’s mind was not of the type that matures early, but one felt in him a power of solid intellect that gained in force from year to year. The gap in the ranks of British Science caused by his death has been generally recognized, but his loss seems greatest to those personally acquainted with him, who know that he had by no means reached the zenith of his powers.

    Jenkinson led a single-minded and unselfish life, wholly free from worldly and ignoble ambitions. Of simple and winning humour, happy in his domestic life and absorbed in his studies, he represented the very best type of scientific worker.

    He was gifted with a powerful physique, and on the outbreak of war he became an ardent member of the Oxford Volunteer Training Corps.

    His qualities of calm courage and high sense of duty marked him out as a valuable officer. Although forty-three years of age, he took a commission in the 12th Worcester Regiment in January, 1915, and was promoted Captain in the following April. On May 10 he left for the Dardanelles, having been selected for service with the 2nd Royal Fusiliers. He was killed in action on June 4, only ten days after his arrival at the Gallipoli peninsula.

    BOOKS AND PAPERS BY J. W. JENKINSON

    1. ‘A Re-investigation of the Early Stages of the Development of the

    Mouse.’ Quart. Jour. Micr. Science, xliii. 1900.

    1. ‘Observations on the Histology and Physiology of the Placenta of

    the Mouse.’ Tijdschr. Nederland. Dierkund. Vereen., vii (2).
    1902.

    1. ‘Observations on the Maturation and Fertilization of the Egg of

    the Axolotl.’ Quart. Jour. Micr. Science, xlviii. 1905.

    1. ‘Remarks on the Germinal Layers of Vertebrates and on the

    Significance of Germinal Layers in general.’ Mem. and Proc.
    Manchester Lit. and Phil. Soc.
    , 1906.

    1. ‘Notes on the Histology and Physiology of the Placenta in

    Ungulata.’ Proc. Zool. Soc. 1906.

    1. ‘On the Effects of certain Solutions upon the Development of the

    Frog’s Egg.’ Arch. Ent.-Mech., xxi. 1906.

    1. ‘On the Relation between the Symmetry of the Egg and the Symmetry

    of the Embryo in the Frog (Rana temporaria).’ Biometrika, v.
    1906.

    1. Experimental Embryology. Oxford, 1909.
    1. ‘On the Relation between the Symmetry of the Egg, the Symmetry

    of Segmentation, and the Symmetry of the Embryo in the Frog.’
    Biometrika, vii. 1909.

    1. ‘The Effects of Sodium Chloride on the Growth and Variability of

    the Tadpole of the Frog.’ Arch. Ent.-Mech., xxx (2). 1910.

    1. ‘Vitalism.’ Hibbert Journal. 1911.
    1. ‘On the Development of Isolated Pieces of the Gastrulae of the

    Sea-Urchin Strongylocentrotus lividus.’ Arch. Ent.-Mech.,
    xxxii. 1911.

    1. ‘On the Effect of certain Isotonic Solutions on the Development

    of the Frog.’ Arch. Ent.-Mech., xxxii. 1911.

    1. ‘On the Origin of the Polar and Bilateral Structure of the Egg of

    the Sea-Urchin.’ Arch. Ent.-Mech., xxxii. 1911.

    1. ‘The Development of the Ear-Bones in the Mouse.’ Jour. Anat. and

    Phys., vi (3). 1911.

    1. ‘Growth, Variability, and Correlation in Young Trout.’

    Biometrika, viii. 1912.

    1. Vertebrate Embryology. Oxford, 1913.
    1. ‘The Effect of Centrifugal Force on the Structure and Development

    of the Egg of the Frog.’ Quart. Jour. Micr. Science. 1914.

    1. ‘The Placenta of a Lemur.’ Quart. Jour. Micr. Science. July

    1915.

    1. Three Lectures on Experimental Embryology. Oxford, 1917.

    VITALISM

    By J. W. Jenkinson

    In one of the oldest biological treatises in the world, the soul or life of an organism is defined in the most general way as an activity of a natural organic living body--ἐντελέχεια σώματος φυσικου̑ ὀργανικου̑ δυνάμει ζωὴν ἔχοντος--life being autonomous nutrition and growth and decay. The activity may, however, be latent or patent, passive or active, sleeping or waking, without losing its peculiar characters. It is substance (οὐσία), but substance as ‘form’ as opposed to the material substance of the body, and the living body is therefore also a substance in a double sense.

    It is not identical with the body; but as form, proportion (λόγος), activity (ἐνέργεια), essence (τὸ τί ἠν εἰναι), it is related to the body, mere matter (ὕλη), and potentiality (δύναμις) in just the same way as the seal is related to the wax; and the body is the instrument whereby it effects its purposes; though subsequent in time, it is prior in thought to the body, as all activities are to the materials with which they operate.

    At the same time neither it nor its parts are separable from the body, with the exception, possibly, of mind (νου̑ς); it is indeed the actual or possible functioning of the body, like the seeing of the eye or the cutting of the axe, and with the disappearance of the capacity of this functioning the soul itself also perishes. Lastly, it is a cause (ἀρχὴ καὶ αἰτία) in a triple sense: first, as the source of motion; secondly, as that for the sake of which the body exists; and thirdly, as its essence (οὐσία) or formal cause. The soul or life is of several kinds, which form together an ascending series each member of which is necessarily involved in those above it.

    The lowest is the nutritive soul (θρεπτική), found in all living things, and the only soul possessed by plants. It is defined as motion in respect of nutrition, decay, and growth, processes which involve alteration (ἀλλοίωσις) in the body; and its functions (ἔργα) are to utilize food for the maintenance and reproduction of the form of the body, and to control and limit growth.

    The second is the perceptive soul (αἰσθητική), the possession of which distinguishes animals from plants. This also is a kind of alteration (ἀλλοίωσις τίς) and consists in being moved and affected.

    The fundamental and indispensable perception is touch (ἁφή), for it is concerned in the acquisition of the food. It is invariably present: the others may or may not, some or all, coexist with it.

    Thirdly, some animals are possessed of a capacity for locomotion, and the performance of this function requires again a special kind of soul.

    Lastly, there is the reasoning soul (διανοητικά) or mind (νου̑ς). This is found in man alone, unless there be other beings similar to him, or even nobler than he. Mind alone is eternal and separable from the body.

    Though the observation and experiment of modern science would doubtless find much to alter in the details of these simple definitions, yet it must be conceded that, by what is certainly a most fortunate guess if it is not the most wonderful insight, Aristotle has laid his finger on the cardinal point of modern physiological doctrine. For, putting aside for the moment the mental faculties, it is here laid down in the clearest manner that not only the functions of growth and decay, nutrition, and reproduction, but also the capacity of responding to stimuli are to be ultimately resolved into some kind of movement of the particles of which the body is composed.

    Life, in short, as we might say with Virchow, is a mode of motion.

    The biology of to-day distinguishes living from inanimate bodies by the possession and exercise of the three principal properties or functions of metabolism, irritability, and reproduction; and further, the body which performs these functions is not only composed of chemically complex substances--proteids--which are not found in things that are not alive, but possesses a structure.

    In no case, even the simplest, is the organism a mere homogeneous lump of protoplasm, but it has parts or organs, visibly different from one another, and obviously correlated with the activities appropriated to each; and it is the preservation of that structure, in the individual and in the race, which is the end towards which the collective performance of all these functions, or the life of the organism, is apparently directed.

    Some of these peculiarities are shared by certain things that are not commonly regarded as alive. Crystals have of course a definite structure; they can divide, and when broken they can make good the missing part, but they do not assimilate to the substance of their own bodies a food-material which is less complex than it, and they are not irritable.

    The differences, indeed, between the living and the lifeless are so profound, that it is not to be wondered at that there should have been in all ages natural philosophers who have held that living activities are phenomena sui generis, differing toto caelo from the properties exhibited by lifeless bodies, and never by any conceivability to be expressed in terms of these.

    This doctrine is vitalism.

    It exists in several varieties, but one at least is of very ancient lineage and can be traced back through mediaeval times to the biological speculations of the Greeks.

    Whether Aristotle really held the vitalistic views which have since been attributed to him is a matter we shall have to discuss later on, but it is certain that in the writings of Galen there is to be found a theory of life which bears the stamp of Aristotelian influence, and was destined to hand that influence on to future generations. Galen admits the sensitive soul of Aristotle as the peculiarity of animals, and the rational soul for man, but substitutes for the nutritive soul certain works of nature--attraction, repulsion, retention, alteration.

    And further, the rational soul is no longer immortal, but perishable, and is dependent on the body, where its seat is in the brain; it is material or quasi-material, a πνευμα, most efficient when dry.

    After a long interval this doctrine reappears in the sixteenth century in the writings of Vesalius, who tells us that the heart has a vital soul, the liver a natural soul, while there is elaborated in the ventricles of the brain an animal spirit or principal soul.

    Meanwhile, however, the conception of life as something material had been discarded by Paracelsus for the belief that the soul, or as he called it, the ‘Archaeus’, by which the chemical processes of the body are governed, is not a material but a spiritual force, a view restated by Stahl more than a hundred years afterwards. ‘The events of the body’, says this author, ‘may be rough-hewn by chemical and physical forces, but the soul will shape them to its own ends, and will do that by its instrument, motion.’

    This, of course, is vitalism, and vitalism in its extreme or ‘animistic’ form. The idea recurs later on in the biology of Treviranus. To be living is to have a soul, he tells us, and the conscious Lebenskraft employs the forces of the material world to form the organism. ‘Das Weitzenkorn hat allerdings Bewusstsein dessen, was in ihm ist und aus ihm werden kann, und träumt wirklich davon.’

    Though he adds quaintly enough, ‘Sein Bewusstsein und seine Träume mögen dunkel genug sein’. It is curious to observe the revival, at the beginning of the twentieth century, of this mediaeval mysticism in the speculative writings of so accomplished an experimentalist as Hans Driesch.

    Driesch is an embryologist who in his earlier days had enunciated an invaluable analytical theory of development, a theory which suggests that while the formation of the first or elementary organs that appear in the embryo or larva--such structures as the larval gut or sense-organ, or the germ-layers--depends upon the presence in the germ of certain specific organ-forming substances (and this is a fact which has since been abundantly demonstrated by experiment), the origin of parts that appear later in development may be accounted for by the action of the first-formed structures upon one another, these actions being in the nature of physiological responses to stimuli; and for this also some evidence has been produced.

    On this view differentiation is a mechanical process, set in motion by fertilization or some other cause, and, given a certain initial structure of the germ or ovum, given the presence in it of a certain number of parts or substances capable of acting upon one another with a fixed co-ordination or harmony of the stimuli and the responses, given further a proper constitution of the external environment, then a definite result must follow, the production of an organism which is like the parents that gave it birth.

    But in his later treatises this hypothesis has been repudiated, and, by a remarkable volte-face, replaced by a dogma of a wholly different kind. For now it is urged that no merely material factors can possibly account either for the harmony of development--the due co-ordination of mutually reacting parts; or for the secondary harmony of composition--the formation of complex organs by the union of tissues; or for the functional harmony seen in the activities of the adult.

    For example, it is asserted that any fragment of an egg of a sea-urchin, if not too small (not less than 1/32 of the egg), can give rise to a whole and normal larva. We are told that the cells of the segmented ovum may be disarranged to any extent by various means, such as raising the temperature, diluting the sea-water, removing the calcium from the sea-water, or by shaking, without prejudice to the ultimate normality of development. Each part of the ovum can therefore, according to the needs of the case, give rise to any part of the resulting organism. ‘Jeder Teil kann nach Bedürfniss jedes.’

    And thirdly, when the gastrula of a sea-urchin is transversely divided into two, each half, it is stated, develops into a diminished whole larva in which the gut becomes divided into the characteristic three regions, and all the other organs are formed in correct proportion.

    For each of these acts of development in the whole uninjured larva an explanation may conceivably be given in terms of formative stimuli exerted by the originally distinct parts of the egg and calling forth responses in other parts.

    A mechanism may be thought of which, when set in motion, will achieve a certain end in accordance with its own pre-established harmony; but a mechanism which can be subdivided ad libitum, or almost ad libitum, and the parts of which will still achieve the same end, will still behave as wholes with their parts co-ordinated in the same ratio, temporally and spatially!

    Such a mechanism is inconceivable; for to ensure the uniform result, the relative amounts and positions of the necessary substances must be imagined as identical in every possible fragment of the egg that is not too small. Something is therefore required to superintend, to co-ordinate the causes of development in the case not only of the part but of the whole egg as well; and this something is not material.

    A corroborative proof of the inadequacy of the purely material explanation--the causal explanation in the ordinary sense of the phrase--may be derived from a consideration of certain other vital processes. The facts of acclimatization and immunity betray an extraordinary adaptability of the organism to a change in its environment; an organ will adapt itself structurally to an alteration, quantitative or qualitative, of function [Roux’s ‘Functional Adaptation’]; lost parts can be regenerated; and then there is the physiology of the nervous system.

    In all these cases of ‘regulation’--and indeed in all other responses to stimuli--the same element, inexplicable in chemical and physical terms, exists and must exist in development. This entity is not a form of energy, but a vital constant, analogous to the constants or ultimate conceptions of mechanics and physics and chemistry and crystallography, but not reducible to these, just as these cannot be translated into one another.

    Driesch describes it as a rudimentary feeling and willing, a ‘psychoid’, ‘morphaesthetic’ or perceptive of that form which is the desired end towards which it controls and directs all the material elements of differentiation, like the grain of wheat of Treviranus, dreaming dimly of its destiny. It is thus a vera causa--an unconditional and invariable antecedent--a psychical factor which can intervene in the purely physical series of causes and effects, and for it he revives the Aristotelian term ‘Entelechy’.

    Such is the ‘vitalism’ introduced by Hans Driesch, a teleological theory clearly, but no mere metaphysical doctrine of final causes: rather a dynamic teleology which not only sees an end in every organic process, but postulates an immaterial entity to guide the merely mechanical forces towards the realization of that end.

    Such a theory is open to very serious criticism from both the scientific and the philosophical side. But before we pass to that criticism let us turn aside to examine some of the other aspects under which the Proteus of Vitalism presents himself.

    Thus the modern physiologist Bunge, while owning that it would be a lack of intelligence to expect to make with our senses discoveries in living nature of a different order to those revealed to us in inorganic nature, yet insists that we must transfer to the objects of our sensory perception, to the organs, to the tissue elements, and to every minute cell, something which we have acquired from our own consciousness, something, that is to say, which is not motion, and is not in space, but is in time only.

    The essence of vitalism, so Bunge would have it, lies in starting from what we know, the internal world, to explain what we do not know, the external world. We can only remark that this position appears to rest upon an epistemological confusion, for Bunge has evidently failed to distinguish between the idealism which teaches that the world of nature, including our own bodies, only exists in so far as it is an object of knowledge, that reality is ultimately ideal, and the ‘animism’ which, as we have seen, gives every object, at least every living object, in nature a directive consciousness of its own.

    The former does not lie immediately within the scope of the present inquiry; the latter we shall have occasion to discuss again.

    How far the tenets of animism are to be attributed to Johannes Müller is not very clear. For while Müller maintained that an organism is due to an idea which regulates its structure, is the cause of its harmony, and is in action in the organism itself, exerting on it a formative power, yet he held that the process was unconscious. Müller indeed distinguished explicitly between the vital and the mental or conscious principle, for in the operations of the former the manifestation of design is the result of necessity, not of choice.

    At the same time the two resemble one another in being homogeneous, in existing throughout the mass of the organism which they animate, and in being divided together with the organism (as in regeneration) without suffering any diminution or change of their powers.

    In this conception of the unconscious idea there may possibly be some confusion between the formal and the final cause, between the idea of the end to be realized, present at the beginning in the mind of the artificer, and the end itself. The former is animism: the latter is sound enough as metaphysics, but is not science at all.

    There is still another school of vitalists which, while not going so far as to commit itself to a belief in a ‘psychoid’, yet proclaims in no uncertain voice the autonomy of the organism, and not content with the assertion that at present we have not succeeded in reducing the activities of the organism to chemical, physical, and mechanical processes, maintains the utter futility of such endeavour, and pronounces over the hidden mysteries of life an eternal Ignorabimus.

    Some such view as this we must, I think, attribute to Dr. Haldane. ‘In biology’, he says, ‘the phenomena which are or ought to be observed from the very beginning are not physical and chemical phenomena as self-existent events, but these phenomena as expressions of the activity of living organisms. It is the living organism, and not the physical phenomenon, which is the reality for biology.’ His belief in organic autonomy is based on the physiology of metabolism, secretion and absorption, the circulation of the blood, and the nervous system.

    Thus in discussing the blood, after pointing to the constancy in its volume and composition, he proceeds: ‘Neither starvation nor ingestion of food and drink materially affect it: liquid injected into it is got rid of with remarkable rapidity; and any loss of blood by bleeding is soon replaced. This vital metabolism of the circulatory system is doubtless due chiefly to the activity of its lining endothelium, which most certainly does not play the mere mechanical part which has often been attributed to it.

    The other so-called “mechanisms” can likewise be shown to have all the characteristics of the living body, inasmuch as they actively maintain their structure, just as the organism as a whole does so. There is thus no warrant for calling them mechanisms, and thus ignoring what is one of their essential characteristics.’ In passages such as these we seem to catch an echo of Müller’s unconscious idea, and again we ask ourselves, Are we dealing with a final or a formal cause? Indeed, Dr. Haldane insists that his ground conception is teleological.

    There is still one other vitalistic theory to which we must allude, although its interest is now merely historical. This is the belief in a special vital material, unlike the material of which lifeless bodies are composed, and endowed with a special vital force, different from but co-ordinate with the forces of mechanics and physics.

    In his Histoire Générale des Animaux Buffon, after referring to the obvious peculiarities of animals and vegetables--that their actions are directed to an end, the conservation of a durable species--proceeds to elaborate a thesis in which it is held that they are composed of organic germs, and that germs of the same kind are distributed throughout nature, lifeless as well as living. When an animal or plant dies, its body is dissolved into these germs, which are then scattered abroad; when it assimilates, it is by separating these ubiquitous particles from the brute inorganic portion of the food.

    The former is utilized for its own growth, the latter it gets rid of by evacuation and excretion. Lifeless matter is therefore never converted into living material.

    Another advocate of the doctrine of a vital force, a property of the tissues of the body, and at perpetual war with those inorganic forms which tend to their destruction, was the physiologist Bichat, Such a conception as this could not of course survive the rise of modern chemistry. Its death-knell was sounded when Lavoisier and Laplace showed that the bodies of organisms were composed of the same elements as are found in inanimate nature, and it has long since passed into the limbo of discredited speculations.

    Apart from this, vitalistic theories would appear to be in the main of two kinds.

    First, there is the metaphysical vitalism which tells us we can never explain the living in terms of the lifeless, insists on the permanent separation of the sciences of biology on the one hand from chemistry and physics on the other, and preaches the autonomy of the organism without venturing to tell us in what that autonomy consists.

    Secondly, there is the psychological theory of animism which posits an autonomous psychical entity to preside over the chemical and mechanical operations of the body, whether already formed or in process of development, and to direct them towards its own ends, the conservation and reproduction of that body’s specific form.

    A third party, halting between two opinions, suggests an unconscious idea, without, however, clearly explaining whether this is to be taken in a metaphysical or a psychological sense. Frankly opposed to vitalism in all its forms is the conception of the living body as a mechanism.

    This has also an honourable ancestry behind it. How far the biology of Aristotle is to be looked upon as mechanistic we shall presently have to inquire, but in Galen the soul is certainly material, or quasi-material, as we have already observed. It is, however, in the physiology of Descartes that mechanism first appears unmistakably in its modern guise.

    For Descartes the body is simply an earthly machine. The nerves are tubes up which--in sensation--the animal spirits flow to the brain only to be reflected (whence our term reflex action) down other tubes to the muscles.

    ‘All the functions of the body’, he tells us, ‘follow naturally from the sole disposition of its organs, just in the same way that the movements of a clock or other self-acting machine or automaton follow from the arrangement of its weights and wheels. So that there is no reason on account of its functions to conceive that there exists in the body any soul, whether vegetative or sensitive, or any principle of movement other than the blood and its animal spirits agitated by the heat of the fire which burns continually in the heart and does not differ in nature from any of the other fires which are met with in inanimate bodies.’

    The rational soul, the soul which thinks, that is, understands, wishes, imagines, remembers, and feels, is not material. Yet it always acts through the machine, though that machine can go on perfectly well without the soul. ‘When the body has all its organs properly arranged for a particular movement it has no need of the soul to carry them out.

    All movements, even those which we call voluntary, depend principally on the same disposition of the organs. One and the same cause renders the dead body unfit to produce the movements and leads the soul to quit the body.’

    The biology of Descartes appears to have been accepted by contemporary physiologists like van Helmont and Borelli, and certainly commended itself to another philosopher of eminence, Leibnitz. Like Descartes, Leibnitz also affirms that the body is a machine or natural automaton; unlike Descartes, however, he refuses to believe that the mind directs the machine in any way. Rather there is a complete series of psychical parallel to a complete series of physical events, and between the two a pre-established harmony.

    Although the details of Cartesian physiology have long since been exploded, yet the mechanical principle which that philosophy enunciated so clearly has persisted and has indeed proved to be the rock on which modern physiological science has been built. For, when once the chemists had discovered animal and plant structure to be composed of elements found in lifeless bodies, and had proved that compounds found only in the organism could yet be synthesized in vitro, there was no longer any reason why the properties of the compounds should be considered as of a different order to the properties of their component elements.

    A method applicable to one was applicable to the other, and as Claude Bernard has put it, mechanical, physical, and chemical forces are the only effective agents in the living body, and they are the only agencies of which the physiologist has to take account.

    The substances of which the living body is made up are no doubt extremely complex, yet none the less--to quote a more recent writer, Verworn--‘physiology is in the last resort the chemistry of the proteids’. This is the principle that has now for nearly a century guided and stimulated research into the functions of the organism: to this principle physiologists, too numerous to name, have not been ashamed to subscribe: under its banner some of the proudest triumphs of the science have been won. Yet it is precisely this which modern or neo-vitalism has challenged and asks us to relinquish in favour of a theory of psychoids or a pseudo-metaphysical view of life.

    The vitalistic position may be assailed from two points, the scientific and the philosophical.

    In the first place the vitalist asserts that mechanism is inadequate to explain the phenomena of metabolism, of transmission of nervous stimuli, or of development. It is upon the last of these that Driesch lays special stress.

    He has urged, as we have seen, that although a mechanical explanation might be given (such an explanation has indeed been put forward by himself) of the specific differentiation of the organism by supposing the first-formed elementary organs, developed out of the substances given in the initial structure of the germ, to act and react upon one another in accordance with a certain harmony, provided for by the same structure; yet a mechanism which can be subdivided ad libitum or almost ad libitum, and each part of which will still give rise to a complete organism, is not to be conceived.

    The answer to this objection has, however, been supplied by the experiments of Driesch himself and of many others. For though it is true that each of the first two, four, eight, or even in some cases each of the first sixteen cells into which the fertilized ovum becomes segmented, can, when separated from its fellows, give rise to a complete organism, yet in all cases there comes a time when the parts cease to be totipotent and produce not whole but partial structures.

    This invariable restriction of potentialities, which occurs earlier in some cases than in others, and is not due to mere deficiency of substance, is not hard to account for.

    Those substances on the presence of which in the ovum, as experiment has taught us, the formation of the elementary organs of the embryo or larva depends, are arranged in different cases in different ways: and they certainly may be, and very frequently are, so distributed that while each of the first four cells contains a like quantity of each of these specific substances, arranged in it exactly as they were in the whole ovum, the next division will sunder these materials in such a way that of the resulting eight blastomeres four will have more of one of the primary egg-substances, less of another; the amounts apportioned to the other four being in just the inverse ratio of this: and the result will be a difference in the fate of the cells when they are isolated from one another.

    In those of the one group the proportions of the organs developed out of these substances will not be the same as they are in the other. This is precisely the result which experiment has revealed; it is exactly this result which Driesch has ignored, or rather attempted to explain away.

    It is evident, then, that to some extent the parts of this mechanism are interchangeable, that it can be subdivided, and that each part, brought now under new conditions, will still possess the potentialities of the whole, just as such a mechanism as a rocket, out of which, under the appropriate stimulus, a certain pattern of stars is developed, might be subdivided into two or more rockets of half size or less.

    There is, however, a limit to this interchangeability, while if the subdivision be carried beyond a certain point the totipotence of the parts is lost.

    If the number of these organ-forming substances given in the germ were very large, as large, let us suppose, as the total number of separately inheritable characters, it might indeed be difficult to imagine a mechanism divisible into even two totipotent parts. But from the need for this assumption we are saved by the second part of Driesch’s own Analytische Theorie, which accounts for subsequent processes of differentiation by attributing the production of new parts to the mutual interactions of those that are the first to appear.

    For this also experimental evidence, though meagre, is not lacking, while a close parallel is found in the dependence of certain bodily functions upon substances--the hormones of Professor Starling--secreted by other organs.

    In the second place the vitalist maintains that the processes of metabolism defy, nay more, always will defy, chemical and physical analysis. The first part of this statement may be a true description of the knowledge of to-day, but the existence in the living body of the same elements as are met with elsewhere, the synthesis of complex organic substances, the establishment of the equivalence of the energy which leaves the body as mechanical work or heat to that which enters it in chemical form in the food, should surely make us hesitate before abandoning all hope of attaining to a chemistry of life.

    And thirdly, there are physiologists who believe that the complex phenomena presented to us in the activities of the nervous system are susceptible of a purely mechanical explanation.

    ‘A feature’, says Gotch, ‘which more particularly suggests spontaneous cellular activity is the well-known fact that centrifugal discharges may continue after the obvious centripetal ones have ceased. This is pre-eminently the case when the central mass is rendered extremely unstable by certain chemical compounds, such as strychnine, &c. There are, however, suggestive indications in connexion with such persistent discharges.

    The more completely all the centripetal paths are blocked by severance and other means, the less perceptible is such persistent discharge, and since nervous impulses are continually streaming into the central mass from all parts, even from those in apparent repose, it would seem that could we completely isolate nerve-cells, their discharge would probably altogether cease.’ Even in the hyper-excitable condition produced by strychnine the spinal motor nerve cells do not discharge centrifugal impulses when cut off from the centripetal connexions.

    The physiologist, therefore, has ‘definite grounds for believing that, as far as present knowledge goes, both the production and cessation of central nervous discharges are the expression of propagated changes and that these changes reveal themselves as physico-chemical alterations of an electrolytic character.

    The nervous process, which rightly seems to us so recondite, does not, in the light of this conception, owe its physiological mystery to a new form of energy, but to the circumstance that a mode of energy displayed in the non-living world occurs in colloidal electrolytic structures of great chemical complexity.’

    To all these considerations we must add the fact that life did once originate upon this planet from matter which was not alive, and that even now some inorganic phenomena present at least remote analogies with certain vital processes. Such are the structure, the spontaneous division, and the regeneration of crystals.

    We turn now to the philosophical objections that may be raised to vitalistic speculations; and here we must be careful to distinguish what we may term the psychological from the metaphysical form of the theory.

    Driesch has maintained that the belief in a morphaesthetic psychoid finds support in the philosophies of Kant and Aristotle. Let us examine the merits of this claim.

    Like the scientists of to-day, Kant, in his Critique of the Teleological Judgement, lays it down as a rule that the mechanical method, by which natural phenomena are brought under general laws of causation and so explained, should in all cases be pushed as far as it will go, for this is a principle of the determinant judgement.

    There are cases, however, in which this alone does not suffice. The possibility of the growth and nutrition, above all of the reproduction and regeneration of organisms, is only fully intelligible through another quite distinct kind of causality, their purposiveness.

    Organisms are not mere machines, for these have simply moving power.

    Organisms possess in themselves formative power of a self-propagating kind, which they communicate to their materials. They are, in fact, natural purposes, both cause and effect of themselves, in which the parts so combine that they are reciprocally both end and means, existing not only by means of one another but for the sake of one another and the whole. The whole is thus an end which determines the process, a final cause which brings together the required matter, modifies it, forms it, and puts it in its appropriate place.

    Such purposiveness is internal, for the organism is at once its own cause and an end to itself, not merely a means to other ends, like a machine whose purposiveness is relative and whose cause is external.

    Such is the principle of the teleological judgement. It is a heuristic principle rightly brought to bear, at least problematically, upon the investigation of organic nature, by a distant analogy with our own causality according to purposes generally, and indispensable to us, as anatomists, as a guiding thread if we wish to learn how to cognize the constitution of organisms without aspiring to an investigation into their first origin.

    Could our cognitive faculties rest content with this maxim of the reflective judgement it would be impossible for them to conceive of the production of these things in any other fashion than by attributing them to a cause working by design, to a Being which would be productive in a way analogous to the causality of intelligence.

    Natural science, however, needs not merely reflective but determinant principles which alone can inform us of the possibility of finding the ultimate explanation of the world of organisms in a causal combination for which an understanding is not explicitly assumed, since the principle of purposes does not make the mode of origination of organic beings any more comprehensible. And then, in a passage remarkable for its prophetic insight, Kant proceeds to show how this might be.

    This ‘analogy of forms’, he says, ‘which with all their difference seem to have been produced according to a common original type, strengthens our suspicion of an actual relationship between them in their production from a common parent, through the gradual approximation of one genus to another--from those in which the principle of purposes seems to be best authenticated, that is from man down to the polype, and again from this down to mosses and lichens, and finally to the lowest stage of nature noticeable by us, namely, crude matter’.

    And so the whole technic of nature, which is so incomprehensible to us in organized beings that we believe ourselves compelled to think a different principle for it, seems to be derived from matter and its powers according to mechanical laws like those by which it operates in the formation of crystals. A purposiveness must, however, be attributed even to the crude matter, otherwise it would not be possible to think the purposive form of animals and plants.

    Although there are doubtless in the Critique many obscurities and inconsistencies, to which we cannot allude now, the general meaning of Kant’s reflections upon organisms is perfectly clear. He who would ‘complete the perfect round’ of his knowledge must think not only in beginnings but in ends. The end in the case of a living being is apparently plain--it is the maintenance and reproduction of its form; the end in the case of the cosmic process is to be sought in the ethical, or, in Kantian phraseology, the ‘practical’ concept of the freedom of the moral consciousness of man.

    Such a position is quite intelligible, philosophically, but the testimony it brings to the theory of the psychoid is of very doubtful value, as Driesch is well aware. He complains indeed that Kant’s teleology is descriptive or ‘static’, rather than ‘dynamic’, as is perfectly true, except in the case of man, a point of which Driesch naturally makes the most.

    There are, no doubt, passages where Kant speaks of ‘a cause which brings together the required matter, modifies it, forms it and puts it in its appropriate place’; but against these must be set the explicit statement ‘that if the body has an alien principle (the soul) in communion with it, the body must either be the instrument of the soul--which does not make the soul a whit more comprehensible--or be made by the soul, in which case it would not be corporeal at all.’ Vitalism can glean small comfort from this. Let us turn, then, to the second authority.

    As we have seen already, the souls or functions of nutrition and perception are, in the Aristotelian biology, ultimately to be expressed as alterations or movements of the particles of the body; mind alone is separable from body and eternal.

    In the development of the individual organism the mind comes in from outside, but the two souls of lower order are present in the σπέρμα, or κύημα, as Aristotle calls it, which results from the commingling of the male and female elements, or, as we should say, the fertilized ovum.

    The material and efficient causes of development are not, however, both contributed by each of the parents. ̑̑ The teaching of Aristotle is that the matter is provided by the female and the female alone. The egg (or catamenia in mammals) is described as being mere matter (ὕλη), body (σω̑μα), potentiality (δύναμις), passive (παθητικόν) and merely quantitative, although it is true that a sort of soul, the nutritive, is somewhat grudgingly conceded to it, since unfertilized eggs appear in some sense to be alive.

    The male element, on the other hand, provides the principle of motion (ἀρχὴ τη̑ς κινήσεως) and the form (εἰδος); it is qualitative, it is activity, it produces the perceptive soul, if it is not itself that soul, and it is responsible for the ‘correct proportionality’ (λόγος) of the organization.

    The male element contributes only motion, but no matter; it acts upon the female element as rennet acts when it coagulates milk, except that the analogy is incomplete, since the γονή brings about a qualitative and not merely a quantitative change in the material on which it operates. To this it imparts the same kind of motion which itself possesses, the motion which was present in the particles of the food in its final form from which it was itself derived.

    The communication of this motion is enough to set going the machinery (αὐτόματον); the rest then follows of itself in proper order.

    Lastly, the sperm of the male acts like a cunning workman who makes a work of art, using heat and cold as the workman uses his tools: for this heat and this cold could never of themselves--by coagulations and condensations--produce the form of the body as the older naturalists had supposed, regarding only the efficient and ignoring the formal and the final cause: for the organic body is not what it is because it is produced in such and such a fashion, rather it is because it is to be such and such that it must be developed as it is.

    And here lies the kernel of the whole matter.

    For while Aristotle has made it perfectly plain that, according to his idea, the soul, at least its nutritive and perceptive faculties, is to be regarded as a function of matter and that this function may be ultimately expressed in terms of movement, and further that development is a mechanism which is set going by the communication of motion proceeding from the ‘soul’ of the male element and derivable eventually from the motions into which the ‘functions’ or ‘soul’ of the parent can be resolved to the mere matter which the female provides, it is equally evident that he does not regard this mechanical explanation--in terms of material and efficient causes--as satisfactory or complete.

    But when we inquire why, he gives us no certain nor consistent answer. On the one hand, there are passages in which he tells us that there must be something which controls the material forces and imposes on them a limit and proportionality of growth; that the soul makes use of them as the artist makes use of his implements, and such passages are naturally interpreted by Driesch in the sense of a ‘dynamic’ teleology; it is the ψυχή which superintends and controls, and the ψυχή is ‘entelechy’.

    Elsewhere, however, we are informed that even the proportionality of the developing parts is simply the outcome of the motion imparted by the male, which is actu what the female element only is potentia.

    Moreover, it may be questioned whether Aristotle ever intended to imply more than an ‘analogy with the causality of purpose’ when he uses the figure of the workman and his implements to illustrate his meaning of the formal cause.

    The formal cause of a work of art is an intelligible vera causa; it is the idea in the mind of the artist antecedent to the execution of the work; but the formal or final cause of an organism, the end which it apparently strives to attain, can only be said by a metaphor to be prior in time to the existence of the organism itself.

    Prior in thought, however, it certainly is, for it is only the performance of its functions (ἐντελέχεια) by the organism complete in all its parts that makes the mere mechanism of development comprehensible to us; the process, therefore, exists for the sake of the end. Only as efficient cause is the soul prior in time; only so far as it is prior in thought can it be said to be a final cause.

    Such a teleology is, it is obvious, indistinguishable in principle from the position in which Kant leaves us. It is the position adopted by Driesch himself in his earlier Analytische Theorie, but abandoned in the Vitalismus in favour of a theory of ‘psychoids’.

    Now quite apart from the meaning which Aristotle may or may not have intended to convey, there are grave objections to this belief. This ‘psychoid’, to which the name ‘entelechy’ is surely misapplied, this rudimentary feeling and willing, which is aware of the form it desires to produce, must be psychically at least as complex as the phenomena it is designed to account for, and stands, therefore, as much in need of explanation as they; as Kant has observed, this will involve us at once in an infinite series of such entities. In fact it is only a photograph of the problem, and not a solution at all.

    Again, when we ask what the modus operandi of this cause is, we get no reply either from Driesch or from any other neovitalist. The objection that the intervention of a psychical cause in a physical process is unintelligible, an objection which would probably appeal to many, may be waived, for in the last resort the connexion between any--even simple mechanical--causes and effects is equally hard to understand.

    It may, however, be doubted whether these entities are not being multiplied beyond necessity, and whether the progress of science would not be better served by an adherence to a simpler philosophy. But even when it has discarded the psychoid we find vitalism still denying the possibility of mechanical explanation, still preaching the autonomy of the organism. The ‘dynamic’ teleology of Driesch has only disappeared to be replaced by the metaphysical doctrine of the final cause.

    We may point out, perhaps, in passing, that the organism is by no means as autonomous as might be desired. The end towards which the creature strives, the maintenance and reproduction of its own specific form, is not a constant terminus ad quem, for species are as mortal as individuals: nor is it always achieved; the autonomy of a worm, which, bisected in a certain way, regenerates a tail instead of a head, or of a frog, which, after a particular injury, develops six legs instead of two, has surely renounced its rights.

    But, setting this aside, it must be seriously questioned whether any good purpose is served in biological discussion by decrying the value of mechanical conceptions or by confounding two distinct orders of thought. The questions are grave ones: for the issue at stake is no less than the existence of physiology as the science of the causes of living activities.

    ‘Recte ponitur’, said Francis Bacon, ‘vere scire esse per causas scire.’ The maxim of the great founder of modern inductive science has been the lode-star of biology in the past, and is still its watchword to-day.

    By exact observation and crucial experiment, utilizing every canon of induction, the activities of the living organism are to be brought under wide general laws of causation, which will be, in the first instance, physiological laws--of response to stimuli, of metabolism, and of growth: by means of these laws predictions can be made, and verified as often as we please.

    But no bar can legitimately be set to the scope of human inquiry; the thought process will not rest here, and ultimately it may be possible to state the widest generalizations of biology in chemical and physical, and these again in purely mechanical terms. The maintenance and evolution of form in the individual, as well as the larger evolution of form in the race, become but the final terms in a far vaster cosmic process, from ‘homogeneity to heterogeneity’.

    The idea is, of course, perfectly familiar: it is the analysis of purely physical causes, carried to its extreme limit. Phenomena are thought out in terms not of origins merely, but of one origin, and that one origin is the only mystery that remains. This unification of the sciences has always been and must still remain the dream and the faith and the inspiration of the scientific man, and could such an edifice of the intellect ever be realized, the task of science would have been completed. Only when this purely deterministic method has been pushed as far as it will go does science leave off; only where science leaves off does philosophy begin.

    There is an order of time, and there is an order of thought. Science works in the order of time, and necessarily so: for although science can never say what constitutes the invariable link between antecedent and consequent which it terms causal, yet it rightly speaks of the first as cause, determining the second as effect, since it is its function to predict from the past which is known to the future which is not.

    But the outlook of philosophy is different. Dissatisfied with the endless regress of cause and effect, sceptical of first causes and original homogeneities, out of which by no conceivability could any heterogeneity have ever been developed, philosophy looks to the end.

    The activities of living organisms at least appear to be directed to an end; they are apparently purposive, and it is this purposiveness which lends to biology, though built on the fundamental conceptions of chemistry and physics, peculiar features of its own, and is, of course, answerable for the teleological language which biologists so frequently employ. And by a knowledge of the end, the view of science, to which qua science it cannot too rigidly confine itself, will doubtless be supplemented and enlarged.

    But, plain and definite though the end of an individual life may be, the end of the race--of the human or any other race--the end of the universe, are things only to be guessed at, and all we are left with is an indefinite series of evolving systems emerging out of an infinite past and fading into an infinite future.

    In the final issue, indeed, the last effect is as delusive an ignis fatuus as the first cause. The philosophy which has rejected one must divest itself of the other, and seek its end, if anywhere, in the logical prius of the mind, which, though last in time, is yet first in thought, since through it alone can that ordered knowledge of nature which we call science be born and brought to perfection.

    [Illustration: From the Italian translation of ‘KETHAM’, VENICE 1493

    Plate XXVII. MUNDINUS(?) LECTURING ON ANATOMY]

    [Illustration: BIBLIOTHÈQUE NATIONALE MS. fr. 2030 Written in 1314

    TO ILLUSTRATE THE ANATOMY OF HENRI DE MONDEVILLE]

    [Illustration: BODLEIAN MS. ASHMOLE 399 fo. 34 r

    Plate XXVIII. A DISSECTION SCENE circa 1298]

    A STUDY IN EARLY RENAISSANCE ANATOMY,

    WITH A NEW TEXT:

    THE ANOTHOMIA OF HIERONYMO MANFREDI (1490)

    By Charles Singer

    TEXT TRANSCRIBED AND TRANSLATED BY A. MILDRED WESTLAND

    I. Anatomy in the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Centuries 79

    II. Bolognese Works on Anatomy 92

    III. Hieronymo Manfredi, Professor at Bologna, 1463-93 97

    IV. The Manuscript Anatomy of Manfredi 103

    V. Translation of Selected Passages from the Anothomia,
    with Commentary 106
    (a) The Brain, Cranial Nerves, &c. 106
    (b) The Eye 118
    (c) The Heart 122
    Italian Text of the Anothomia 130

    I. ANATOMY IN THE FOURTEENTH AND FIFTEENTH CENTURIES

    There was little or no progress in the knowledge of anatomy between the death of Mondino in 1327 and the sixteenth century. This appears the more remarkable when we recall how widespread was the practice of dissection during the period.

    In France, at the University of Montpellier, public dissections were decreed in the year 1377,[121] and Catalonian Lerida followed suit in 1391.[122] At Bologna, where dissection had long been customary, it received official recognition in the University Statutes in 1405,[123] and the same event took place at Padua in 1429.

    Public anatomies were instituted at the University of Prague in 1460, of Paris in 1478, and of Tübingen in 1485.[124] For these ‘Anatomies’ the bodies of executed criminals were usually employed, and therefore the number of subjects available varied greatly in different localities.[125] In addition to these regular dissections, there was certainly a considerable amount of post-mortem examination, surreptitious (Plate XXVIII_b_[126]), or even open (Plate XXIX[127]), long before Benivieni published his memorable list of cases.[128]

    [Illustration: Fig. 1. From the French translation of Bartholomaeus Anglicus, Lyons, 1482. The first printed picture of dissection.]

    [Illustration: MS. fr. 184 fo. 14 r

    Plate XXIX. A POST-MORTEM EXAMINATION. Late XIVth Century]

    [Illustration: VATICAN MS. HISPANICE 4804 fo. 8 r

    Plate XXX a. A DEMONSTRATION OF SURFACE MARKINGS]

    [Illustration: BRISTOL REFERENCE LIBRARY MS. fo. 25 r

    Plate XXX b. A DEMONSTRATION OF THE BONES TO ILLUSTRATE GUY DE CHAULIAC]

    That so much industry was rewarded by so small an increase in knowledge may probably be attributed to the method adopted. The so-called ‘anatomies’ were conducted in the most formal manner. Bertuccio, for example, who succeeded Mondino as professor of Surgery at Bologna, was accustomed, as we learn from his pupil Guy de Chauliac, to give short systematic anatomical demonstrations on a fixed and rigid method.[129] The occupant of the chair at this period was indeed no professor in the modern sense of the word.

    To expound the tradition of anatomy as it had reached him was regarded as the limit of his duty. Of any attempt to extend the bounds of knowledge, of any systematic endeavour to correct or improve the anatomical views of his predecessors, we find little or no trace. Indeed, at Padua it was expressly laid down in the statutes that the exposition of anatomy should follow the very words of Mondino.[130]

    Early figures portraying the teaching of anatomy (Plate XXVII and Figs. 1-3, 5) usually show us a medical doctor sitting at a desk, well removed from the subject of dissection, and reading from his text-book the description of the part. Meanwhile an assistant, who is usually also a doctor, performs the actual work of dissection. The professor of Surgery, to whom the teaching of anatomy was entrusted, stands by with a pointer to indicate the different organs.

    [Illustration: Fig. 2. Title-page of Mellerstadt’s edition of the Anatomy of Mondino, Leipzig, 1493. The scene is laid in the open air.[131]]

    [Illustration: Fig. 3. A DISSECTION SCENE

    From the Venice 1495 edition of ‘Ketham’ (compare Plate XXVII).]

    [Illustration: Fig. 4. From the English translation of Bartholomaeus Anglicus, printed by Wynkyn de Worde, 1495. The first picture of dissection in an English-printed book.]

    [Illustration: VENETIIS ANNO .D. M.CCCCC.XXXV.

    Fig. 5. A LECTURE ON ANATOMY

    From the 1535 Venice edition of Berengar of Carpi’s Commentary on Mondino.]

    Sometimes the professor changes places with the reader at the desk. In some later MSS. the teacher is figured as himself handling the body and demonstrating to his pupil (Plate XXX a[132] and b[133]), but there is evidence that the miniatures portraying this are the work of artists unfamiliar with dissection and with the teaching of anatomy.

    The study of anatomy had to contend with two great difficulties, want of subjects for dissection, and faith in the written word.

    Thus, at Bologna, where it was arranged that every medical student of over two years’ standing should attend an Anatomy once a year, no less than twenty students were admitted to see the anatomy of each man, and thirty to the anatomy of each woman.[134] This was all the practical instruction received. Some other Universities had to be content with the cadaver of a single criminal per annum for the whole body of students.

    In the first period during which the human body was dissected in Europe, the thirteenth century, a certain amount of progress was certainly made, despite the rarity of subjects. The rebirth of learning in the thirteenth century was not, however, as favourable to anatomical progress as might have been hoped. Galen, indeed, ceased to be a mere name, and the Latin translations of his text, or of its adumbra in the writings of the Arabians, became ever more familiar.

    On the other hand, with more authoritative texts in their hands, men were but the more inclined to follow the evil scholastic way, and to trust rather to the written words of the master than to the evidence of their own senses. Thus it came about that the second period, which covers the fourteenth and most of the fifteenth century, was really stationary so far as the first-hand knowledge of anatomy was concerned. With the last decade of the fifteenth century, however, there opens a new and third period in the history of our subject.

    From that time dates the true era of anatomical renaissance, which may be regarded as continuing until the commencement of modern anatomy with the great work of Vesalius in 1543.

    [Illustration: Plate XXXI. From the MS. of GUY DE VIGEVANO of 1345 at

    CHANTILLY]

    [Illustration: Plate XXXII. From the MS. of GUY DE VIGEVANO of 1345 at

    CHANTILLY]

    We have said that throughout the second period, the formal demonstrations based on the declaimed text of Galen or Avicenna or Mondino were practically the sole opportunities afforded to either teacher or pupil for the investigation of the minuter details of the human frame.

    But in making this statement concerning the arrest of anatomical progress, we must expressly exclude the products of the mighty genius of Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519), whose anatomical researches were without influence, and remained long unnoticed.[135] We must also omit evidence gathered from the work of such early Renaissance painters as Antonio Pollaiuolo (1429-98) or Andrea del Verrocchio (1435-88), for these pursued the study of anatomy in a special field and with a special object.[136] Furthermore, there are a number of artists of similar date of whose anatomical studies we have no direct evidence, but who yet outlined the muscles of the nude human figure in such a way as leads us to suppose that they had investigated the superficial structures at least of flayed parts.

    Such is the suggestion of some of the work of Luca Signorelli (c. 1442–c. 1524), and of Andrea Mantegna (died 1506). With such reservations, however, it is probably true that no evidence is forthcoming until the last decade of the fifteenth century of any advance from the standpoint of Mondino.[137]

    But if descriptive anatomy developed slowly in the hands of the physicians, the art of graphic representation of anatomical structures was still more backward. Several groups of anatomical drawings of mediaeval date have come down to our time, but examination of them shows that they have been drawn without direct reference to the human frame.

    Some of these figures are of the crude type known as the ‘five-figure series’ (Plate XXXIII), mere traditional diagrammatic sketches.[138] Hardly better or more instructive are the series of dissections which illustrate certain MS. works of Henri de Mondeville (Plate XXVIII a)[139] and Guido de Vigevano (Plates XXXI and XXXII), 1345.[140] A few sketches representing the separate organs have also survived (Fig.

    6),[141] but these never suggest that the draughtsman had before him the structure which he seeks to depict, and the drawings appear to have been made in order to illustrate contemporary physiological theory rather than observed anatomical fact.

    Even the magnificent illuminated Dresden Codex of Galen, prepared in France or Flanders as late as the second half of the fifteenth century, betrays not the slightest first-hand knowledge of anatomy.[142] Although the illustrations of this MS. are prepared with the utmost technical skill, they yet show us a teacher exhibiting to his pupils a heart of the form found on playing-cards, and other anatomical figures scarcely more faithful to the facts (Plate XXXIV).

    [Illustration: Fig. 6. DIAGRAMS OF THE INTERNAL ORGANS

    After Bodleian Library MS. Ashmole 399 of about 1298, fos. 23 recto–24 recto.]

    The spirit of investigation of the artist who perforce went direct to nature, dissecting with his own hands and observing with his own eyes (Plate XXXVI), showed itself indeed far more fruitful than the tedious ex cathedra methodization of the professor.[143] Yet the system of the schools needed to be combined with the freedom of the artist for the production of an effective anatomical work.

    What the projected treatise of Marcantonio della Torre (1473–1506) might have been we may guess from the anatomical sketches of Leonardo da Vinci (Plate XXXV), who was to have been associated with him in the work.[144] In the event, however, the medical schools had to wait yet another generation before the subject was placed on a sound basis by André Vesale.

    The Mondino pamphlet--for it is little more--used since its author’s death in 1327 as a text-book in the schools of northern Italy, was first printed in 1478. Not until the last decade of the fifteenth century did there appear another work bearing evidence of the hand of a practical anatomist.

    This was an Italian translation of Ketham’s Fasciculus medicinae, impressed at Venice in the year 1493.[145] The volume comprises Mondino’s pamphlet and a collection of other medical tracts that were probably put together by Giorgio di Monteferrato from the work of a writer of the previous century, for their contents are traceable to a fourteenth-century MS.[146] The text is neither original nor remarkable, but the Venice volume derives its importance from certain figures which appear in it for the first time.

    Two of these plates are of great interest both intrinsically and also in relation to the history of anatomy. One of them is the magnificent representation of a dissection scene, which is regarded as perhaps the finest example of book illustration produced during the first century of typography[147] (Plate XXVII). This work of the ‘maître aux dauphins’, as the unknown artist is called by critics,[148] is doubly interesting, for it is the subject of an experiment in colour printing, no less than four pigments being laid on by means of stencils.

    As early as 1457 the method of stencilling was employed for colouring the initials of a Psalter, and in 1485 Erhard Ratdolt in an astronomical work added yellow to the earlier red and black. The figure from which our plate is taken represents, however, the first attempt at a complex colour scheme and leads up to the work of Hugo da Carpi.[149]

    In this picture the professor, a youthful figure perhaps intended to represent Mondino himself, is shown standing at a desk which hides his book. Around a corpse, laid on a trestle table before him, there cluster a number of men in doctor’s robes. Their valid faces are sufficient to convince us that the artist is here presenting us with portraits. One of the listeners has removed his robe and stands with upturned sleeves and knife in

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
    Release date
    August 12, 2014 [eBook #46572]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Thiers Halliwell, Jason Isbell and the Online
    Most recently updated
    October 24, 2024
    Transcriber and production notes
    Transcriber’s notes:
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    In this transcription, paired _underscores_ denote _italicised text_
    and a ^ (caret) indicates that the next character was superscripted in
    the original text. Footnotes are located at the end of the book.
    
    The cover image of the book was created by the transcriber and is
    placed in the public domain.
    
    Potential problems:
    
    The text contains numerous foreign and uncommon typographic characters.
    In addition to Greek, there are passages of Hebrew and Arabic text
    (which read from right-to-left and are normally right justified) that
    will not necessarily display correctly with all devices. The book
    is most easily read with a browser using the HTML version of the
    transcription. If some of the characters look abnormal, first ensure
    that the ‘character encoding’ of your device/browser is set to Unicode
    (UTF-8). You might also need to change the default font. Standard
    fonts such as Times New Roman, Georgia or Lucida Sans Unicode are
    sometimes adequate, but it might be necessary to use a less-common
    font such as Arial Unicode MS, DejaVu, Segoe UI Symbol or FreeSerif to
    see all characters correctly. Right alignment of the Hebrew and Arabic
    paragraphs will generally only be apparent with a monospaced font such
    as DejaVuSansMono.
    
    
    Some diacritics don’t display consistently. For example, the Greek
    letter υ̑ occurs in several words and with some browsers and fonts the
    inverted breve is displaced towards the following letter; the same
    anomaly occurs with macrons above letters in some old English words.
    The Hebrew passage contains several letters with single or double
    overhead dots (of uncertain significance) that can’t be replicated on
    screen – the HTML version has a hyperlinked image of the original for
    anyone wishing to see it.
    
    Roman numerals are widely used and often in archaic ways. Numerals
    followed by an italicised _l_, _s_, or _d_ indicate monetary values
    in imperial pounds shillings and pence units, e.g. xxxiii_l_. vi_s_.
    viii_d_. represents 33 pounds 6 shillings 8 pence (a space sometimes
    separates the numeral from the unit). The last ‘i’ (‘one’) in a roman
    numeral was often represented by the letter ‘j’; hence iiij_d_ is
    equivalent to 4 pence, and ‘ij holownesses’ should be read as ‘two
    holownesses’.
    
    Numerous portions of text enclosed within square brackets were inserted
    by the author (not the transcriber) for clarification or translation,
    as were several (sic) entries in the Hebrew and Arabic texts.
    
    The index has many references to both page numbers and footnote
    numbers, e.g. 24 n. (a single unnumbered footnote), 93 n. 3, 126 nn. 4,
    5, (pages containing multiple footnotes), and also to numbered figures
    and plates. The original footnote numbering began afresh at 1. on each
    page, but in this transcription footnotes are numbered sequentially
    from the beginning of the book and the numbers no longer correspond
    to those shown in the index. Many of the illustrations have been
    moved from their original location to be closer to the relevant text
    discussion.
    
    Errors and inconsistencies:
    
    Punctuation anomalies have been corrected silently (e.g. missing
    periods, commas and semicolons, incorrect or missing quotation marks,
    unpaired parentheses).
    
    Unambiguous typographic errors such as the following, have been
    corrected silently:
    
        Lexico nder-->Lexicon der
        Aa-->As [a matter of fact]
        Chiru gie-->Chirurgie
        Weisbaden-->Wiesbaden
    
      but inconsistent spellings such as those below have not been altered:
        paniculi/panniculi
        paniculo/panniculo
        feçe/fece
        Literatur/Litteratur
        literae/litterae
        aligati/alligati
        cf./cp.
        dilatare/dillatare
        dilitano/dillitano
        diuidendo/dividendo
        judgement/judgment
    
    Inconsistent capitalisation of Fig. and Plate has been standardised,
    as has inconsistent spacing of expressions such as A.D. i.e. and § 6
    (a paragraph number).
    
           *       *       *       *       *
    
    
    
    
                                    STUDIES
    
                                     IN THE
    
                               HISTORY AND METHOD
                                   OF SCIENCE
    
                            OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
    
                    LONDON   EDINBURGH   GLASGOW   NEW YORK
                     TORONTO  MELBOURNE  CAPE TOWN  BOMBAY
    
                                HUMPHREY MILFORD
                          PUBLISHER TO THE UNIVERSITY
    
    [Illustration: WIESBADEN CODEX B, fo. 1 r
    
    Plate I. HILDEGARD RECEIVING THE LIGHT FROM HEAVEN]
    
                                    STUDIES
                                     IN THE
                               HISTORY AND METHOD
                                   OF SCIENCE
    
                                   EDITED BY
                                 CHARLES SINGER
    
                                     OXFORD
                             AT THE CLARENDON PRESS
                                      1917
    
                               PRINTED IN ENGLAND
                         AT THE OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Studies in the History and Method of Science, vol. 1 (of 2)
    
    Editor: Charles Singer
    
    Author of introduction, etc.: Sir William Osler
    
    
            
    Release date: August 12, 2014 [eBook #46572]
                    Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/46572
    
    Credits: Produced by Thiers Halliwell, Jason Isbell and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This
            file was produced from images generously made available
            by The Internet Archive/Canadian Libraries)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #46572. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 46572
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.