
Gutenberg · ebook 46026
Virginia's Attitude Toward Slavery and Secession
by Beverley B. Munford · English · public domain in the US
PREFACE
This work is designed as a contribution to the volume of information from which the historian of the future will be able to prepare an impartial and comprehensive narrative of the American Civil War, or to speak more accurately—The American War of Secession.
No attempt has been made to present the causes which precipitated the secession of the Cotton States, nor the states which subsequently adopted the same policy, except Virginia. Even in regard to that commonwealth the effort has been limited to the consideration of two features prominent in the public mind as constituting the most potent factors in determining her action—namely, devotion to slavery and hostility to the Union.
That the people of Virginia were moved to secession by a selfish desire to extend or maintain the institution of slavery, or from hostility to the Union, are propositions seemingly at variance with their whole history and the interests which might naturally have controlled them in the hour of separation.
Yet how widespread the impression and how frequent the suggestion from the pen of historian and publicist that the great and compelling motives which led Virginia to secede were a desire to extend slavery into the territories and to safeguard the institution within her own borders, coupled with a spirit of hostility to the Union and the ideals of liberty proclaimed by its founders. To present the true attitude of the dominant element of the Virginia people with respect to these subjects is the work which the author has taken in hand.
As cognate to this purpose the effort has been made to show what was the proximate cause which influenced the great body of the Virginia people in the hour of final decision. There were unquestionably many and widely severed causes—some remote in origin and some immediate to the hour, yet it may be safely asserted that but for the adoption by the Federal Government of the policy of coercion towards the Cotton States, Virginia would not have seceded. That was the crucial and determining factor, which impelled her secession.
She denied the right of the Federal Government to defeat by force of arms the aspiration of a people as numerous and united as those of the Cotton States to achieve in peace their independence. She believed that such a course and the exercise of such a power on the part of the Federal Government, if not actually beyond the scope of its powers as fixed in the constitution, were clearly repugnant to the ideals of the Republic, and subversive of the principles for which their Fathers had fought and won the battles of the Revolution.
Upon the question, shall the Cotton States be permitted to withdraw in peace, or shall their aspirations be defeated by force of arms, Virginia assumed no new position. She simply in the hour of danger and sacrifice held faithful to the principles which she had ofttimes declared and which have ever found sturdy defenders in every part of the Republic.
In the preparation of this volume the author has been the grateful recipient of the labors of many historians and publicists, accredited citations from whose works will be found throughout its pages.
In addition, he desires to acknowledge his indebtedness to the following gentlemen:
First and foremost, to Dr. Philip Alexander Bruce of Virginia, for his generous sympathy and invaluable assistance, with respect to every feature of the book; also to Edward M. Shepard, Esquire, and Reverend Samuel H. Bishop of New York and to Colonel Archer Anderson and Henry W.
Anderson, Esquire, of Richmond, for their kindness in reading his manuscript and making many helpful suggestions.
For none of the errors of the book, nor for any expression of opinion, are these gentlemen responsible.
Thanks are due and tendered to Dr. Herbert Putnam, Librarian of Congress, Dr. H. R. McIlwaine, State Librarian of Virginia, and Mr. W.
G. Stanard, Corresponding Secretary of the Virginia Historical Society, and to their courteous assistants, for the generous use accorded the author of the wealth of historical data in the custody of those institutions.
In addition to the foregoing, acknowledgments are gratefully made to a great company of librarians, lawyers, antiquarians, clerks of courts, custodians of private manuscripts and others who have assisted the author in collecting from widely separated sections of the Union the mass of information from which he has drawn, in the preparation of this work. In many instances, the facts so kindly furnished do not appear, but have been of service to the author, in enabling him to form more accurate conclusions.
The willingness exhibited by citizens of states, other than Virginia, to furnish information with respect to the subject under consideration, is indicative of a growing desire throughout the Union to know the facts and appreciate the viewpoint of our once separated but now united people. If this book, in presenting the attitude of Virginia, shall contribute to this result, it will afford the author the sincerest gratification.
Richmond, Virginia, June, 1909
------------------------------------------------------------------------
ERRATA
Page 142, line 8, for "stately," read "noble."
Page 142, line 10, for "over," read "above."
Page 162, line 7, for "MacMaster," read "McMaster."
Page 162, footnote, for "MacMaster," read "McMaster."
Page 214, line 12, for "Cathargo," read "Carthago."
Page 242, footnote, for "Vol. IV." read "Vol. VI."
------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONTENTS
THE AUTHOR'S PREFACE
Part I
VIRGINIA'S ATTITUDE TOWARD SLAVERY
AND SECESSION DEFINED
I. Introduction 1
II. Virginia—Slavery and Secession 10
Part II
VIRGINIA DID NOT SECEDE IN ORDER TO EXTEND SLAVERY
INTO THE TERRITORIES, OR TO PREVENT ITS THREATENED
DESTRUCTION WITHIN HER OWN BORDERS
III. Virginia's Colonial Record with Respect to Slavery 15
IV. Virginia's Statute Abolishing the African Slave Trade
and Her Part in Enacting the Ordinance of 1787 25
V. Slavery and the Federal Constitution—
Virginia's Position 29
VI. The Foreign Slave Trade—
Virginia's Efforts to Abolish It 33
VII. Some Virginia Statutes with Respect to Slavery 41
VIII. The Movement in the Virginia Legislature of 1832
to Abolish Slavery in the State 45
IX. The Northern Abolitionists and Their Reactionary
Influence upon Anti-Slavery Sentiment in Virginia 51
X. Negro Colonization—State and National 60
XI. Instances of Colonization by Individual Slaveholders 66
XII. Emancipation and Colonization—Views of
Jefferson, Clay and Lincoln 75
XIII. Anti-Slavery Sentiments of Prominent Virginians 82
XIV. Anti-Slavery Sentiments of Prominent Virginians.
Continued 91
XV. Anti-Slavery Sentiments of Prominent Virginians.
Concluded 96
XVI. Specimens of Deeds and Wills Emancipating Slaves 104
XVII. Specimens of Deeds and Wills Emancipating Slaves.
Concluded 114
XVIII. The Small Number of Slaveholders in Virginia,
as Compared with Her Whole White Population 125
XIX. The Injurious Effects of Slavery upon the
Prosperity of Virginia 128
XX. The Custom of Buying and Selling Slaves—
Virginia's Attitude 139
XXI. The Custom of Buying and Selling Slaves—
Virginia's Attitude. Concluded 147
XXII. Small Proportion of Slaveholders among Virginia
Soldiers 154
XXIII. Some of the Almost Insuperable Difficulties which
Embarrassed Every Plan of Emancipation 159
XXIV. Some of the Almost Insuperable Difficulties which
Embarrassed Every Plan of Emancipation. Continued 164
XXV. Some of the Almost Insuperable Difficulties which
Embarrassed Every Plan of Emancipation. Concluded 175
XXVI. The Status of the Controversy Regarding Slavery at
the Time Virginia Seceded from the Union 185
XXVII. The Status of the Controversy Regarding Slavery at
the Time Virginia Seceded from the Union. Concluded 193
XXVIII. The Attitude of Certain Northern States 201
XXIX. The Attitude of Certain Northern States. Concluded 206
XXX. The Abolitionists 214
XXXI. The Abolitionists and Disunion 217
XXXII. The Abolitionists and Disunion. Concluded 225
XXXIII. The Emancipation Proclamations and the Virginia
People 230
Part III
VIRGINIA DID NOT SECEDE FROM A WANTON DESIRE TO
DESTROY THE UNION, OR FROM HOSTILITY TO THE
IDEALS OF ITS FOUNDERS
XXXIV. Virginia's Part in the Revolution 237
XXXV. Virginia's Part in Making the Union under the
Constitution 242
XXXVI. Virginia's Efforts to Promote Reconciliation
and Union in 1861 248
XXXVII. The People of Virginia Declare for Union 255
Part IV
THE ATTEMPT OF THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT TO COERCE
THE COTTON STATES—THE PROXIMATE CAUSE OF
VIRGINIA'S SECESSION
XXXVIII. The Coercion of the Cotton States—
Virginia's Position 263
XXXIX. The Contest in the Virginia Convention for and
against Secession 269
XL. The Contest in the Virginia Convention for and
against Secession. Concluded 277
XLI. The Attempted Reinforcement of Fort Sumter and
its Significance 284
XLII. The Attempt to Coerce the Cotton States Impels
Virginia to Secede 290
XLIII. Conclusion 301
Bibliography 305
Index 313
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART I
VIRGINIA'S ATTITUDE TOWARD SLAVERY
AND SECESSION DEFINED
------------------------------------------------------------------------
I
INTRODUCTION
The story of the American Civil War presents a subject fraught with interest, not destined to die with the passing years. Even the finality of the verdict then rendered on the issues joined will not abate the desire of men to fix with precision the political and ethical questions involved and the motives which impelled the participants in that deplorable tragedy. The sword may determine the boundaries of empire or the political destinies of a people, but the great assize of the world's thought and conscience tries again and again the merits of controversies and brings victor and vanquished to the bar of its increasingly fair and discriminating judgment.
CHARACTER OF WAR
What was the character of the War? Though one of the greatest wars of modern times, having its rise and fall before the eyes of all the world, yet men are to-day in doubt as to the true term by which to describe it.
Was it a Civil War? Such a conception omits the claim of the North that the Federal Government as such fought to maintain its constitutional supremacy, and the claim of the South that the seceding states but exercised their constitutional rights in seceding, and as states fought to maintain that principle. A civil war betokens one people, in the same country, subjects of the same power, at war among themselves. Here, though afore-time countrymen, when the battle was joined, there were two rival governments, and the territories of the contending parties were distinguished, not by shibboleths and banners, but by rivers and mountain ranges.
It was a sectional rather than a community war, a conflict between governments rather than between citizens of the same government.
Was it a Rebellion? Such a conflict indicates a revolt of citizens or subjects against their acknowledged sovereign. Whether in the United States the citizen owed allegiance to the Federal Government as against his State Government was a question upon which men had divided since the birth of the Republic. The men of the North responded to the call of the sovereign to whose allegiance they acknowledged fealty—the men of the South did the same. It was a battle between rival conceptions of sovereignty rather than one between a sovereign and its acknowledged citizens.
Was it a Revolution? A revolution is a successful movement of citizens or subjects against their sovereign. Here the identity of the Sovereign was in dispute, and the effort, though of unexampled magnitude, was unsuccessful. In addition the parties to the conflict held irreconcilable conceptions as to what constituted the right of revolution—one insisting that it was a God-given right inherent in any people sufficiently numerous to maintain a National existence; the other, that it was a mere power to strike, dependent upon success to prove the legitimacy of the claim.
PARTIES TO CONFLICT
The parties to the Conflict were not rival nations, but compatriots of the same flag; joint inheritors of the English Common Law and the ideals of liberty consecrated by centuries of heroic struggle; descendants of an ancestry knit in political sympathy by their successful battle for independence from the Mother Country, and the achievements by which they made their new-born nation great; children of Puritan and Cavalier, Quaker and Huguenot; Dutchman and Catholic-Frenchman; men of strong individual and community traits, accustomed to rule and untutored in the art of surrender.
CAUSES OF WAR
The causes of the War were deep-seated and complex. They were Old-World antagonisms, religious and political, antedating, and yet surviving, the settlements at Jamestown and Plymouth Rock, New Amsterdam, and New Orleans;—
The early development in the two great divisions of the country, of diverse economic conditions—a land of small farms and multiplied industrial activities confronting one of large plantations and agricultural supremacy;—
The Protective Tariff, at first enacted to secure for American manufactures a chance to compete successfully with those of the Old World, but, in its results, a burdensome system, under which the agriculturists of the South paid onerous tribute to the manufacturers of the North;—
Slavery—an institution which specialized more and more the interests of the South in the great exporting staples of cotton, rice and tobacco, driving manufactures and mining into the more hospitable regions of the North;—an institution whose life or death was within the exclusive power of the separate states where it was legalized, and yet the manifold incidents of whose existence were the subject of frequent National legislation, and hence ever recurring occasions of sectional strife;—an institution which quickened in time among the people of the non-slaveholding states the conviction that it was a sin, with the consequent charge that all responsible for its existence were parties to a crime, thus arousing the bitter resentment of devout men in the slaveholding states, who, protesting their innocence of wrong, challenged the right of their Northern brethren to sit in judgment upon them;—
The Annexation of Texas: A new cause and occasion for sectional jealousy, precipitating the war with Mexico, and bringing additional territory into the Union with fresh disputes over the powers of Congress in regard thereto;—
The Immense Foreign Immigration into the North and West;—thus developing in those sections the strongest sentiments of Nationalism, while the South, unaffected by any such forces, adhered to the early ideals of state pride and state supremacy;—
State Sovereignty versus National Supremacy;—the first, the shield behind which aggrieved minorities sought to curb arrogant majorities and safeguard the rights and interests of community life; the second, the ideal by which the preservation of the Union was to be assured and its dignity and power at home and abroad vindicated;—
The Missouri Compromise—its enactment and repeal, the controversies as to the power of Congress to prohibit slaveholders from migrating with their slaves into the territories, the enactment by Congress of the Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 and the attitude of certain Northern States in attempting to defeat its execution, the Underground Railroad, the decision in the Dred Scott case, the armed conflicts in Kansas, the John Brown Raid and the sympathy evinced at the North for the man and his venture; and finally:
The asserted right of the Cotton States to withdraw from the Union, and the declared purpose of the Federal Government to defeat their aspiration by force of arms.
Add to all the foregoing the vision of mighty armies struggling for mastery, the terrors and miseries of war—contrasted with the heroism and devotion which it aroused, and there results a combination of causes which will continue to make their compelling appeal to the hearts and imaginations of men.
THE ISSUES INVOLVED
If the causes of the war were manifold and perplexing, the exact object for which each of the contending parties did battle is only less difficult of precise definition. A brief consideration of some of the many forms in which the popular voice has sought to express the conception will serve to illustrate the truth of this suggestion.
"The North fought to preserve the Union—the South, to destroy it."
That one great element of the Northern people took up arms at the call of the Federal Government to prevent a dismemberment of the Union is undoubtedly true. That another element regarded the maintenance of the Union under the existing constitution as unworthy of effort is equally true. The first went forth at the earliest call to preserve the Union under the old constitution; the second came later to the battle to fight for a Union with a constitution which should decree the abolition of slavery.
That the Southern people sought to establish the independence of their new Confederacy and to that extent a dismemberment of the Union is true, but that they desired the destruction of the Union and the principles of liberty and law which its establishment was designed to assure are conclusions not easily deducible from their aspirations or necessities.
"The North fought for empire, the South for independence."
That the North fought to keep within the limits of the Union the domain stretching from the Potomac to the Rio Grande is true, but that the great mass of her people were actuated by a desire to hold the land as tributary and its people as subjects is not true. The splendid ideal of a Republic, stretching from ocean to ocean, and securing to its growing millions the dual blessings which spring from National integrity and home rule, we may well believe was ever before them.
That one great element of the Southern people fought for independence and all the inspiring ideals which the term implies is true, though it is equally true that joined with them in the battle were states the dominant elements of whose people cherished no primal desire for separation from the Union, but resisted the authorities of the latter because of their convictions that its policy of coercion was illegal and destructive of the principle upon which the Republic had been founded.
"The North fought to destroy slavery; the South, to extend and maintain it."
That slavery was the most potent factor in developing the conditions which finally precipitated war is true. That the two parties to the conflict joined battle upon the issue of its maintenance or destruction seems inconsistent with their solemnly declared purposes and promises, made at the time. President Lincoln at his inauguration proclaimed: "I have no purpose directly or indirectly to interfere with the institution of slavery in the states where it exists.
I believe I have no lawful right to do so, and I have no inclination to do so." This pledge of the President was but a reaffirmation of the platform of his party, and both were, in turn, confirmed by the declaration of Congress that the war was fought, "to defend and maintain the supremacy of the constitution and to preserve the Union with all the dignity, equality and rights of the several states unimpaired."
President Davis presented the attitude of his people and government when he declared: "All we ask is to be let alone—that those who never held power over us shall not now attempt our subjugation by arms." And after three years of desperate war, he declared to the representatives of President Lincoln:—
"We are not fighting for slavery. We are fighting for
independence.... Say to Mr. Lincoln for me that I shall at any
time be pleased to receive proposals for peace, on the basis of
our independence. It will be useless to approach me with any
other."[1]
That the people of America in the nineteenth century of the Christian era should have resorted to war in order to settle questions of constitutional and moral right must forever constitute an impeachment of the capacity for self-government and the ethical standards of the men responsible for its occurrence.
The charge that the people of twenty-three states in four of which slavery was legalized arose in arms against their fellow-citizens of the remaining eleven and, despite the constitutional safeguards with which the institution in the latter states was confessedly surrounded, invaded their land, burnt thousands of their homes and killed tens of thousands of their citizens in a desperate determination to destroy slavery, is as compromising to American character as the counter accusation that the people of eleven states, with no existing menace to their constitutional rights in regard to slavery, resorted to secession and aggressive war in order to secure new guarantees for the safety of the institution.
Charges so dishonoring to the American people should not be made and above all should not be accepted as true—unless compelled by the inexorable facts of history.
STATE RIGHTS vs. FEDERAL RIGHTS
"The South fought for States' Rights—Home Rule; the North, for Federal rights—National Supremacy."
In the large measure of truth contained in this declaration lay the profound tragedy of the Civil War—a battle for the supremacy of one of two ideals, thus brought into antagonism, upon the maintenance of both of which, in their true proportions, depended so largely the success of the unique experiment in government established by the Fathers. In this union of states how were the rights of personal liberty and community life to be harmonized with the National ideals and powers essential to its preservation? Liberty and law—the consent of the governed and the integrity of the Government—how were these great ends to be assured?
From the birth of the Republic, there were views radically divergent as to the character and powers of the government then created; and there were aspirations of devoutest patriotism alike yearning for the triumphs of liberty and law, though seeking these ideals by policies almost irreconcilable. Thus, upon the fair prospect of the new Republic, there lowered from its natal hour forebodings of strife and separation.
With these warring ideals, intensified by divergent economic and political interests, there arose the forces which drove the shuttle of discord back and forth through the web and woof of the nation's life, and wrought the forbidding pattern of sectionalism, division and hate. What were the causes—what the issues—of that "strange and most unnatural" war?
What were the motives which impelled the people of the South, utterly unprepared for battle, to risk the unequal contest, and never to desist until the hand of destruction had paralyzed the very heart of effort? What were the motives which impelled the people of the North to give without stint their wealth of blood and treasure; to marshal armies more numerous than those with which Napoleon confronted a world in arms, and, for four years, to hurl them against the homes of their brethren?
Analysis is the foe of confusion and the friend of the light. Motives and methods, grouped and commingled, present difficulties of right appreciation which ofttimes vanish if separated into their component parts.
The commonwealth of Virginia bore a not inconspicuous part in the Civil War. It will subserve the cause of truth and assist to a clearer understanding of the complex conditions referred to, if we endeavor to portray the motives which impelled the people of this one state during those fateful days of 1860-61.
-----
Footnote 1:
History of the United States, Rhodes, Vol. IV, p. 515.
II
VIRGINIA: SLAVERY AND SECESSION
It is not questioned that among the people of Virginia were men of widely divergent views; Secessionists of the most ultra type, insisting on the state's right to secede, and demanding her immediate withdrawal from the Union; anti-secessionists of the strongest mould, denying the right of secession and protesting against its attempted exercise;
Unionists who admitted the right in the state, as a desperate measure of relief, but denying that any such occasion had arisen; advocates of slavery who regarded the institution as approved of Heaven,—a blessing to the blacks, and essential to the safety of the whites; apostles of emancipation who denounced slavery and called for its abolition; men who would make Virginia "neutral territory" between the hostile sections, and those who would fight for her rights, but "fight within the Union."
VIRGINIA'S ATTITUDE
None of these elements, separately, spoke the sentiments of the majority, nor represented the controlling force in her citizenship. We shall accept as the true expression of the dominant element the returns from the ballot box, the enactments of her legislative and constitutional assemblies, and the deliverances of her great sons.
Tried by these criteria, it may be truthfully declared that the institution of slavery was regarded with disfavor by a majority of her people; that they tolerated its existence as a modus vivendi to meet the dangers and difficulties of the hour, but looking forward to the time when the increase of her white population from within and without, and the decrease of her blacks by emigration and colonization would render feasible its abolition, with a maximum of benefit to the slaves and their owners, and a minimum of danger to society and the state; that while cherishing an almost romantic love for their commonwealth, they felt genuine loyalty to the Union, and contemplated with profound sorrow the suggested withdrawal therefrom of any group of states; and, finally, that they carried their state out of the Union and into the Southern Confederacy because the authorities of the former sought by force of arms to defeat the latter in their efforts to achieve independence, and demanded of Virginia her quota of men to accomplish the deed.
SLAVERY AND SECESSION
Secession they deplored because it broke the married calm of a union which its makers fondly hoped would endure forever, but war upon the states seeking independence they also deplored, because subversive of the principles upon which the Union was founded. Could the Federal Government deny to six millions of people the boon of independence which they were seeking by orderly and peaceful methods, and still remain true to the principles of the great Declaration, to maintain which the Fathers of the Republic had fought and won the battles of the Revolution?
Have people the right to determine for themselves their political destiny? Are the just powers of governments to be measured by the consent of the governed? These were the questions which, carrying their own answers, impelled the Virginian opponents of coercion in 1861 to stand, as they believed, for the political and ethical principles which the Flag symbolized, rather than for the Flag itself.
That Virginia revered the institution of slavery, and from selfish motives fought to make more sure the muniments of its existence; that she desired the destruction of the Union, and the degenerate abandonment of the inspiring dreams of liberty and progress, which it was designed to assure,—are propositions unthinkable to men acquainted with her history and the genius and aspirations of her people. It was for no such cause that she gave her sons to the sword, and her bosom as the battleground for the fiercest war of modern times. Her people fought because they felt the occasion made its imperious demand upon their duty and their honor.
Virginia had persistently declared that the right asserted by the Cotton States was God-given and inalienable. Thus her sense of honor, as well as the imperilled right of self-government, impelled her to battle.
Twenty years after the surrender at Appomattox Lord Wolseley wrote: "The Right of Self-Government which Washington won, and for which Lee fought, was no longer to be a watchword to stir men's blood in the United States."[2]
We need not accept the conclusion of this distinguished soldier that the cause of self-government no longer commands the allegiance of the American people, in order to believe that amid the trials and conflicts of the Civil War Virginia stood faithful for the vindication of that great principle.
-----
Footnote 2:
R. E. Lee, Wolseley, p. 51.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
PART II
VIRGINIA DID NOT SECEDE IN ORDER TO EXTEND
SLAVERY INTO THE TERRITORIES,
OR TO PREVENT ITS THREATENED
DESTRUCTION WITHIN HER
OWN BORDERS
------------------------------------------------------------------------
III
VIRGINIA'S COLONIAL RECORD WITH RESPECT TO SLAVERY
President Lincoln in his inaugural address declared:—"One section of our country believes slavery is right and ought to be extended, while the other believes slavery is wrong and ought not to be extended. This is the only substantial dispute."
Other voices proclaimed that there existed an "irrepressible conflict" between the North and the South in which the abolition or maintenance of slavery was the gage of battle. The two assertions may be combined and the question considered whether Virginia seceded either to extend slavery into the territories or to perpetuate the institution within her borders.
SLAVERY IN VIRGINIA
In considering these questions it will be well to review Virginia's record with respect to slavery both during the period of her existence as a colony and her career as a state;
To collate the sentiments of her great sons antagonistic to the institution;
To show the small number of her citizens holding slaves as compared with the great company of those who possessed no such interest;
To note the injurious effects upon her prosperity resulting from the presence of the institution;
To summarize what were considered the almost insuperable difficulties which embarrassed every plan of emancipation—difficulties that were augmented and intensified by the bitterness and partizanship with which, during the three decades immediately preceding the Civil War, the subject had become invested;
To present the situation with respect to the controversy at the time Virginia seceded from the Union; and finally,
To consider the effects, if any, upon her position, of President Lincoln's Proclamations of Emancipation issued subsequent thereto.
VIRGINIA'S COLONIAL RECORD
African slaves were first brought to Virginia in 1619 by a Dutch vessel.
George W. Williams, the negro historian of his race in America, says, "It is due to the Virginia colony to say that the slaves were forced upon them."[3]
Though slaves were thus introduced as early as 1619, it was not until 1661 that the institution of slavery was recognized in Virginia by statute law.[4]
For a long period after their first introduction, very few slaves were imported. At the end of the first half-century there were only some two thousand, and as late as the year 1715 they numbered only about twenty-five thousand. In the sixty years, however, immediately preceding the Revolution, they came in ever-increasing numbers, so that at the latter date they almost equalled the white population of the colony.[5]
EFFORTS TO EXCLUDE SLAVES
With the great increase of this element in the population, the colonists were quick to realize their danger[6] and numerous acts were passed by the Colonial Legislature designed to lessen, if not actually to stop, further importations. Alluding to these efforts of the Virginia people, Mr. Bancroft says:
"Again and again they had passed laws restraining the importation of
negroes from Africa, but their laws were disallowed. How to prevent
them from protecting themselves against the increase of the
overwhelming evil was debated by the King in Council; and on the 10th
of December, 1770, he issued an instruction under his own hand
commanding the Governor 'upon pain of the highest displeasure, to
assent to no laws by which the importation of slaves should be in any
respect prohibited or obstructed.'"[7]
Edmund Burke, in his speech on conciliating America, in response to the suggestion that the slaves might be freed and used against the colonies, said,
"Dull as all men are from slavery, must they not a little suspect the
offer of freedom from the very nation which had sold them to their
present masters—from that nation, one of whose causes of quarrel with
those masters is their refusal to deal any more in that inhuman
traffic. An offer of freedom from England would come rather oddly,
shipped to them in an African vessel, which is refused an entry into
the ports of Virginia or Carolina, with a cargo of three hundred
Angola Negroes."[8]
In addition to legislative enactments, appeals were addressed directly to the throne. But the great personages interested in the slave trade proved more influential with the King than the prayers of his imperilled people. There is something at once pathetic and prophetic in the appeals made by these Virginians to their sovereign against the slave trade. The petition presented by the House of Burgesses in 1772 recites:
"We implore your Majesty's paternal assistance in averting a calamity
of a most alarming nature. The importation of slaves into the colonies
from the coast of Africa hath long been considered as a trade of great
inhumanity, and under its present encouragement we have too much
reason to fear will endanger the very existence of your Majesty's
American dominions.
We are sensible that some of your Majesty's
subjects may reap emoluments from this sort of traffic, but when we
consider that it greatly retards the settlement of the colonies with
more useful inhabitants and may in time have the most destructive
influence, we presume to hope that the interests of a few will be
disregarded when placed in competition with the security and happiness
of such numbers of your Majesty's dutiful and loyal subjects.
We,
therefore, beseech your Majesty to remove all these restraints on your
Majesty's Governor in this colony which inhibits their assenting to
such laws as might check so pernicious a consequence."[9]
This petition was reported from a Committee of the House which included Edmund Pendleton, Richard Henry Lee, Benjamin Harrison and others of equal prominence.[10]
But the King and Ministers continued to turn deaf ears and except with respect to more moderate measures the Royal Veto was interposed to annul all anti-slavery laws.
ORIGINAL DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE
Chief among the causes which aroused the opposition of the Virginia colonists and placed them in the forefront of the Revolution was the course of the King with respect to this momentous subject. When Thomas Jefferson came to write the Declaration of Independence and to epitomize the grounds of indictment which the colonists presented against the British King, it was the latter's veto of the laws passed by Virginia to suppress the slave trade, and the active aid lent by his Government to force the captives of Africa upon his defenseless subjects, that evoked the fiercest arraignment in that historic document. Mr. Jefferson declared:
"George the Third has waged cruel war against humanity itself,
violating its most sacred rights of life and liberty, in the persons
of a distant people who never offended him; captivating and carrying
them into slavery in another hemisphere, or to incur a miserable death
in their transportation thither. This piratical warfare, the
opprobrium of infidel powers, is the warfare of the Christian King of
Great Britain. Determined to keep open a market where men should be
bought and sold, he has prostituted his negative by suppressing every
legislative attempt to prohibit, or to restrain, this execrable
commerce.
And that this assemblage of horrors might want no fact of
distinguished dye, he is now exciting these very people to rise in
arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he has deprived
them, by murdering the people on whom he obtruded them; thus paying
off former crimes committed against the liberties of one people with
crimes which he urges them to commit against the lives of
another."[11]
"These words," says Mr. Bancroft, "expressed precisely what had happened in Virginia."
REASONS FOR AMENDING DECLARATION
That this portion of the Declaration was stricken out by Congress before its formal presentation to the world does not negative the fact that, in thus declaring, Mr. Jefferson proclaimed the sentiments of his native state. It was ominous of her future experience with respect to this baneful subject, that the voice of Virginia was then silenced in deference to the states of the far South and certain of their Northern sisters. Mr. Jefferson has left upon record that this clause in the Declaration of Independence was stricken out:
"In compliance to South Carolina and Georgia, who had never attempted
to restrain the importation of slaves, and who, on the contrary, still
wished to continue it. Our Northern brethren also, I believe, felt a
little tender under these censures, for though their people had very
few slaves, yet they had been pretty considerable carriers of them to
others."[12]
The biographers of Abraham Lincoln, Nicolay and Hay, say:
"The objections of South Carolina and Georgia sufficed to cause the
erasure and suppression of the obnoxious paragraph. Nor were the
Northern States guiltless; Newport was yet a great slave mart, and the
commerce of New England drew more advantages from the traffic than did
the agriculture of the South."[13]
VIRGINIA'S ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS, 1774
But the position of Virginia with respect to slavery and the vetoes of
George III and the slave trade was not left to be determined by
unofficial utterances though coming from one of her greatest sons. As
early as 1774 her people registered their sentiments in the most
varied and emphatic forms. Mass meetings in many of the counties
adopted resolutions, the purport and tenor of which may be gathered
from those of Fairfax County,—"We take the opportunity of declaring
our most earnest wishes to see an entire stop forever put to such a
wicked, cruel and unnatural trade."[14]
VIRGINIA'S FIRST CONSTITUTION
In August, 1774, the Virginia Colonial Convention resolved: "We will
neither ourselves import, nor purchase any slave or slaves imported by
any other person, after the first day of November, next, either from
Africa, the West Indies or any other place."[15]
On the fifth of September, 1774, when the Continental Congress
assembled for the first time, her delegates in that body submitted the
memorial known in history as, "A Summary View of the Rights of British
America," in which the course of George III was arraigned and the
sentiments of Virginia in regard to the slave trade declared as
follows:
"For the most trifling reasons, and sometimes for no conceivable
reason at all, His Majesty has rejected laws of the most salutary
tendency. The abolition of domestic slavery is the great object of
desire in those colonies, where it was, unhappily, introduced in
their infant state. But, previous to the enfranchisement of the
slaves we have, it is necessary to exclude all further importations
from Africa.
Yet, our repeated requests to effect this by
prohibitions, and by imposing duties which might amount to a
prohibition, have been hitherto defeated by His Majesty's negative;
thus preferring the immediate advantage of a few British Corsairs to
the lasting interests of the American States, and to the rights of
human nature deeply wounded by this infamous practice."[16]
The representatives from Virginia in the Continental Congress were
active in their efforts to secure the adoption of the Non-Importation
Agreement which included a resolve to discontinue the slave trade and
a pledge neither to hire "our vessels nor sell our commodities or
manufactures to those who are concerned in it."[17]
W. E. B. DuBois declares: "Virginia gave the slave trade a special
prominence and was in reality the leading spirit to force her views on
the Continental Congress."[18]
Nor were these resolves of the Virginia people idle, for numerous
evidences can be cited of the activity of her vigilance committees. At
Norfolk, the committees, finding that one John Brown had purchased
slaves from Jamaica, reported that we "hold up for your just
indignation Mr. John Brown, merchant of this place ... to the end ...
that every person may henceforth break off all dealings with him."[19]
VIRGINIA'S BILL OF RIGHTS
Two years later, but before the proclamation of the Declaration of
Independence, Virginia adopted a written constitution and Bill of
Rights. In the preamble to the former there are set forth the reasons
which influenced the colony to cast off her allegiance to the British
King.
Among the foremost was his action in "perverting his kingly
powers," ... "into a detestable and insupportable tyranny by putting
his negative on laws the most wholesome and necessary for the public
good"; and again, for "prompting our negroes to rise in arms among
us—those very negroes whom, by an inhuman use of his negative, he
hath refused us permission to exclude by law."[20]
Her Bill of Rights opened with the then novel and far reaching
declaration:
"That all men are by nature equally free and independent, and have
certain inherent rights, of which when they enter into a state of
society, they cannot, by any contract deprive or divest their
posterity; namely the enjoyment of life and liberty, with the means
of acquiring and possessing property and pursuing and obtaining
happiness and safety."[21]
With respect to this great document, Mr. Bancroft declares:
"Other colonies had framed Bills of Rights in reference to their
relations with Britain; Virginia moved from charters and customs to
primal principles; from the altercation about facts to the
contemplation of immutable truth. She summoned the eternal laws of
man's being to protest against all tyranny. The English Petition of
Right, in 1688, was historic and retrospective; the Virginia
declaration came out of the heart of nature and announced governing
principles for all peoples in all times. It was the voice of reason
going forth to speak a new political world into being.
At the bar of
humanity Virginia gave the name and fame of her sons as hostages
that her public life should show a likeness to the highest ideals of
right and equal freedom among men."[22]
CANONS OF LIBERTY
This Bill of Rights was incorporated in every subsequent constitution
of Virginia and is to-day a part of her organic law. Two months after
its first adoption came the Declaration of American Independence. The
words of Mason: "That all men are by nature equally free and
independent," are re-echoed in the words of Jefferson, "That all men
are created equal," and both declare that among the inalienable rights
of man are "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness."
To these principles, Virginia acknowledged allegiance; to the Bill of
Rights, by the unanimous vote of her Constitutional Convention; and to
the Declaration of Independence by the united voices of her delegates
in the Continental Congress. The institution of slavery could not
square with these great canons. Henceforth its existence in Virginia
could be justified only by the difficulties and dangers attending its
abolition.
These recitals bring us down to the close of Virginia's life as a
colony, and the assumption by her people of the rights and obligations
of statehood.
In the more than one hundred and fifty years of her
colonial existence—despite protests, appeals and statutes—the
inflowing tide from Africa had continued, so that out of a population
of some six hundred thousand souls, over two-fifths were negro slaves.
It was amid such conditions that Virginia met the problems incident to
her birth into statehood, bore her part in founding the Republic,
furnished her quota of soldiers to resist the armies of Great Britain,
and held with fixed determination her ever advancing border line
against the craft and courage of the Red Men.
-----
Footnote 3:
History of the Negro Race in America, Williams, Vol. 1, p. 119.
Footnote 4:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 34.
Footnote 5:
History of the Negro Race in America, Williams, Vol. 1, p. 133.
Footnote 6:
A letter from the celebrated Colonel William Byrd of "Westover" to
Lord Egmont, under date of July 12, 1736, will serve to illustrate
this fact. Colonel Byrd writes, "Your Lord's opinion concerning Rum
and Negroes is certainly very just, and your excluding both of them
from your colony of Georgia will be very happy....
I wish, my Lord, we could be blessed with the same prohibition. They
import so many negroes here that I fear this colony will some time
or other be confirmed by the name of New Guinea. I am sensible of
the many bad consequences of multiplying the Ethiopians amongst us.
They blow up the pride and ruin the Industry of our White People,
who seeing a Rank of poor creatures below them, detest work for fear
it should make them look like slaves. Then that poverty which will
ever attend upon Idleness disposes them as much to pilfer as it does
the Portuguese....
But these private mischiefs are nothing if compared to the publick
danger. It were therefore worth the consideration of a British
Parliament, my Lord, to put an end to this unchristian traffick of
making merchandise of our Fellow Creatures. At least, the further
importation of them into our Colony should be prohibited lest they
prove as troublesome and dangerous elsewhere as they have been
lately in Jamaica.... All these matters duly considered, I wonder
the Legislature will Indulge a few ravenous traders to the danger of
the Publick Safety." (From Unpublished Byrd Manuscripts at Lower
Brandon, Va.)
Footnote 7:
History of United States, Bancroft, Vol. III, p. 410.
Footnote 8:
Burke's Works, Little, Brown & Co.'s. Ed., Vol. II, p. 135.
Footnote 9:
Journal of House of Burgesses, p. 131, and Tucker's Blackstone,
appendix, note H. Vol. II, p. 351.
Footnote 10:
Defense of Virginia, Dabney, p. 48.
Footnote 11:
History of United States, Bancroft, Vol. IV, p. 445.
Footnote 12:
Writings of Thomas Jefferson, P. L. Ford, 1892, p. 28.
Footnote 13:
Abraham Lincoln, A History, Nicolay & Hay, Vol. I, p. 314.
Footnote 14:
Suppression of the Slave Trade, DuBois, p. 43.
Footnote 15:
Idem, p. 43.
Footnote 16:
Writings of Thomas Jefferson, Ford, 1892, Vol. I, p. 440.
Footnote 17:
Suppression of the Slave Trade, DuBois, p. 45.
Footnote 18:
Idem, p. 43.
Footnote 19:
Idem, p. 47.
Footnote 20:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. IX, pp. 112-113.
Footnote 21:
Idem, p. 109.
Footnote 22:
History of United States, Bancroft, Vol. IV, p. 419.
IV
VIRGINIA'S STATUTE ABOLISHING THE AFRICAN SLAVE
TRADE AND HER PART IN ENACTING THE
ORDINANCE OF 1787
Foremost among the laws enacted by her General Assembly after
Virginia's declaration of independence from British rule was her
celebrated statute prohibiting the slave trade. This act was passed in
1778—thus antedating by thirty years the like action of Great
Britain.
By this law, it was provided, "that from and after the
passing of this act no slaves shall hereafter be imported into this
commonwealth by sea or land, nor shall any slaves so imported be sold
or bought by any person whatsoever." The statute imposed a fine of one
thousand pounds upon the person importing them for each slave
imported, and also a fine of five hundred pounds upon any person
buying or selling any such slave for each slave so bought or sold. The
crime of bringing in slaves is still further guarded against by a
provision which declares that every slave "shall upon such importation
become free."[23] Of this act, Mr.
Ballagh, in his History of Slavery
in Virginia, says, "Virginia thus had the honor of being the first
political community in the civilized modern world to prohibit the
pernicious traffic."[24]
VIRGINIA'S CONQUEST OF THE NORTHWEST
Next in the sequence of great events linked with this subject was the
work of her sons in the preparation and adoption of the ordinance for
the government of the northwest territory. This imperial domain from
which have been created the states of Ohio, Indiana, Illinois,
Michigan and Wisconsin had been conquered by her soldiers, led by her
son, George Rogers Clark, acting under a commission of her Governor,
Patrick Henry, and her Council.[25] "Virginians," says Mr.
Bancroft,
"in the service of Virginia." Virginia claimed the country as
comprised within the limits fixed by her colonial charter.
Massachusetts, Connecticut and New York also asserted claims, but, as
John Fiske declares, "It was Virginia that had actually conquered the
disputed territory."[26] And again he writes, "Virginia gave up a
magnificent and princely territory of which she was actually in
possession."[27] When, by the valor of her sons, Virginia had won the
land from the English and the Indians, she silenced the murmurings of
sister states and consummated the efforts for union by formally
relinquishing the great domain to the common weal.
The day that Virginia's deed of cession, March the first, 1784, was
accepted by the Continental Congress, Mr. Jefferson reported his
bill—the Ordinance of 1784. This measure was one of far reaching
importance in that it provided not only for many of the governmental
needs of this great territory, but declared that after the year 1800,
slavery should never exist in any portion of the vast domain west of a
line drawn north and south between Lake Erie and the Spanish dominions
of Florida.
Had this clause been retained in the ordinance, slavery
would have been excluded not only from the five states created out of
the northwest territory but from the country south of it and from
which were subsequently formed the states of Kentucky, Tennessee,
Alabama and Mississippi.
This provision of the ordinance, however, failed of adoption—the
votes of six states being recorded in its favor, one less than the
requisite majority. Mr. Jefferson's colleagues present, Hardy and
Mercer, refused to join him in voting for this novel enactment. Its
failure was a matter of profound regret to its author. In a letter to
M. de Munier, Mr. Jefferson wrote:
"The voice of a single individual of the state which was divided, or
one of those which were of the negative, would have prevented this
abominable crime from spreading itself over the new country. Thus we
see the fate of millions unborn hanging on the tongue of one man and
Heaven was silent in that awful moment."[28]
ORDINANCE OF 1787
This ambition of Mr. Jefferson was not destined to complete defeat.
Three years later, the now celebrated Ordinance of 1787 was enacted
into law. "No one was more active," says Mr. Fiske, "in bringing about
this result than William Grayson of Virginia, who was earnestly
supported by Lee."[29]
Mr. Bancroft says:
"Thomas Jefferson first summoned Congress to prohibit slavery in all
the territory of the United States; Rufus King lifted up the measure
when it lay almost lifeless on the ground, and suggested the
immediate instead of the prospective prohibition; a Congress
composed of five Southern States to one from New England and two
from the Middle States, headed by William Grayson, supported by
Richard Henry Lee, and using Nathan Dane as scribe, carried the
measure to the goal in the amended form in which King had caused it
to be referred to a committee; and, as Jefferson had proposed,
placed it under the sanction of an irrevocable compact."[30]
VIRGINIA CONFIRMS ORDINANCE OF 1787
The ordinance as passed contained many provisions in addition to those
set out in Virginia's deed of cession. It was necessary, therefore,
that Virginia should by proper enactment reaffirm her deed. The
General Assembly of Virginia at its next session accordingly passed an
act fixing for all time the validity of both deed and ordinance.[31]
Mr. Bancroft says:
"A powerful committee on which were Carrington, Monroe, Edmund
Randolph and Grayson, successfully brought forward the bill by which
Virginia confirmed the ordinance for the colonization of all the
territory then in the possession of the United States, by freemen
alone."[32]
Thus the old commonwealth which had won the land from England and the
Indians bore a foremost part in the legislative work by which slavery
was forever excluded from the empire north of the Ohio River.
-----
Footnote 23:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. IX, p. 471.
Footnote 24:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 23.
Footnote 25:
Life of Patrick Henry, W. W. Henry, Vol. I, p. 583.
Footnote 26:
Critical Period of American History, Fiske, p. 191.
Footnote 27:
Idem, p. 195.
Footnote 28:
Writings of Jefferson, Ford, Vol. IV, p. 181.
Footnote 29:
Critical Period of American History, Fiske, p. 205.
Footnote 30:
History of United States, Bancroft, Vol. VI, p. 290.
Footnote 31:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. XII, p. 780.
Footnote 32:
History of United States, Bancroft, Vol. VI, p. 291.
V
FOREIGN SLAVE TRADE AND THE CONSTITUTION:
## VIRGINIA'S POSITION
The supreme opportunity for suppressing the importation of slaves and
thus hastening the day of emancipation came with the adoption of the
Federal Constitution. As we have seen, with every increase in the
number of slaves the difficulties and dangers of emancipation were
multiplied. The hope of emancipation rested in stopping their further
importation and dispersing throughout the land those who had already
found a home in our midst.
To put an end to "this pernicious traffic"
was therefore the supreme duty of the hour, but despite Virginia's
protests and appeals the foreign slave trade was legalized by the
Federal Constitution for an additional period of twenty years. The
nation knew not the day of its visitation—with blinded eyes and
reckless hand it sowed the dragon's teeth from which have sprung the
conditions and problems which even to-day tax the thought and
conscience of the American people.
This action of the convention is declared by Mr. Fiske, to have been
"a bargain between New England and the far South."
"New Hampshire, Massachusetts and Connecticut," he adds, "consented to
the prolonging of the foreign slave trade for twenty years, or until
1808; and in return South Carolina and Georgia consented to the clause
empowering Congress to pass Navigation Acts and otherwise regulate
commerce by a simple majority of votes."[33]
OPPOSITION TO FOREIGN SLAVE TRADE
George W. Williams, the negro historian, avers that,
"Thus, by an understanding or, as Gouverneur Morris called it, 'a
bargain' between the commercial representatives of the Northern
States and the delegates of South Carolina and Georgia, and in spite
of the opposition of Maryland and Virginia, the unrestricted power
of Congress to enact Navigation Laws was conceded to the Northern
merchants; and to the Carolina rice planters, as an equivalent,
twenty years' continuance of the African slave trade."[34]
Continuing, Mr. Fiske says, "This compromise was carried against the
sturdy opposition of Virginia." George Mason spoke the sentiments of
the Mother-Commonwealth when in a speech against this provision of the
constitution, which reads like prophecy and judgment, he said:
"This infernal traffic originated in the avarice of British
merchants. The British Government constantly checked the attempts of
Virginia to put a stop to it. The present question concerns, not the
importing states alone, but the whole Union.... Maryland and
Virginia, he said, had already prohibited the importation of slaves
expressly. North Carolina had done the same in substance. All this
would be in vain if South Carolina and Georgia be at liberty to
import.
The Western people are already calling out for slaves for
their new lands; and will fill that country with slaves if they can
be got through South Carolina and Georgia. Slavery discourages arts
and manufactures. The poor despise labor when performed by slaves.
They prevent the emigration of whites, who really enrich and
strengthen a country. They produce the most pernicious effect on
manners. Every master of slaves is born a petty tyrant. They bring
the judgment of Heaven on a country. As nations cannot be rewarded
or punished in the next world, they must be in this.
By an
inevitable chain of causes and effects, Providence punishes National
sins by National calamities. He lamented that some of our Eastern
brethren had, from a lust of gain, embarked in this nefarious
traffic. As to the states being in possession of the right to
import, this was the case with many other rights, now to be properly
given up. He held it essential, in every point of view, that the
General Government should have power to prevent the increase of
slavery."
"But these prophetic words of George Mason," adds Mr. Fiske, "were
powerless against the combination of New England and the far
South."[35]
Some seven decades later, Virginia erected under the shadow of her
Capitol a bronze statue to commemorate the fame of this illustrious
son.
Governor Randolph and Mr. Madison earnestly supported their colleague,
the former declaring that this feature rendered the constitution so
odious as to make doubtful his ability to support it; and the latter
asserting, "Twenty years will produce all the mischief that can be
apprehended from the liberty to import slaves. So long a term will be
more dishonorable to the American character than to say nothing about
it in the constitution."[36]
FOREIGN SLAVE TRADE LEGALIZED
Thus it was by the votes of New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut,
Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina and Georgia, and against the
votes of New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware and Virginia, that the
slave trade was legalized by the National Government for the period
from 1787 to 1808.
DISASTERS RESULTING THEREFROM
If it be argued that this provision of the constitution offered no
menace to Virginia or to any other state not willing to admit the
importations, the reply is obvious that this action of the National
Government was deplorable because it placed the imprimatur of its
supreme law upon the morality as well as legality of the slave trade;
and further, because with the advent from abroad of every additional
slave the difficulties and dangers of emancipating those in the
South—their natural habitat—was increased. New England and the North
were not menaced. Climatic and economic conditions, as well as their
local laws, raised a protecting barrier.
Beneath the hot skies of the
South—where flourished the much sought for crops of cotton, rice and
sugar cane—was the land to which with unerring instinct the Trader
piloted his craft freighted with ignorance and woe. As long,
therefore, as one port remained open and the National Government
sanctioned the traffic, just so long would the inflowing tide
continue, each new arrival adding to the difficulties of the
situation.
Thus the nation, under its new charter, entered upon its career
handicapped by the curse of slavery and further menaced by the new
lease of life accorded the slave trade. Upon Virginia the maximum of
burden rested. She had within her borders nearly one-third of the
whole slave population of the Union.
Hers was the ceaseless task of
guarding against further importations from home or abroad; of devising
some practicable plan for gradually emancipating the slaves in her
midst, and meanwhile to continue day by day the work of teaching these
children of the Dark Continent an intelligible language, the use of
tools, the necessity for labor and the rudiments of morality and
religion.
-----
Footnote 33:
Critical Period of American History, Fiske, p. 264.
Footnote 34:
History of Negro Race in America, Williams, Vol. I, p. 426.
Footnote 35:
Critical Period of American History, Fiske, p. 264.
Footnote 36:
Life and Times of Madison, Rives, Vol. II, p. 446.
VI
THE FOREIGN SLAVE TRADE
VIRGINIA'S EFFORTS TO ABOLISH IT
Despite Virginia's failure to secure the immediate suppression of the
foreign slave trade, her sons were active in their efforts to restrict
its growth and at the earliest possible moment to drive the slave
ships from the seas.
In the first Congress under the constitution, April, 1789, Josiah
Parker of Virginia sought to amend the Tariff Bill under discussion by
inserting a clause levying an import tax of ten dollars upon every
slave brought into the country.
"He was sorry the constitution prevented Congress from prohibiting
the importation altogether. It was contrary to Revolution principles
and ought not to be permitted.... He hoped Congress would do all in
their power to restore to human nature its inherent privileges; to
wipe off, if possible, the stigma under which America labored; to do
away with the inconsistence in our principles justly charged upon
us; and to show by our actions, the pure beneficence of the doctrine
held out to the world in our Declaration of Independence."
Mr. Parker was supported by two other Virginians, Theodoric Bland and
James Madison, the latter declaring:
"The clause in the constitution allowing a tax to be imposed though
the traffic could not be prohibited for twenty years, was inserted,
he believed, for the very purpose of enabling Congress to give some
testimony of the sense of America with respect to the African trade.
By expressing a national disapprobation of that trade it is to be
hoped we may destroy it, and so save ourselves from reproaches and
our posterity from the imbecility ever attendant on a country filled
with slaves."[37]
But notwithstanding these appeals the movement was defeated, though
the discussion was evidently fruitful in bringing to the attention of
the country that under the constitution, Congress had authority not
only to levy a tax of ten dollars per capita on slaves imported, but
to prohibit citizens of the United States from engaging in the traffic
with foreign countries. These latter conclusions were formally
embodied in a report made to Congress on the 23rd of March, 1790, by a
committee of which Josiah Parker of Virginia was one of the leading
members.
The adoption of this report stirred the opponents of the
slave trade to greater activity and numerous petitions were presented
at the next session of Congress from Maryland and Virginia and almost
every one of the Northern States. In the Virginia petition, the slave
trade was denounced as "an outrageous violation of one of the most
essential rights of human nature."[38]
In his message to Congress, at its session, 1806-7, Mr. Jefferson,
then President, brought to the attention of that body the fact that
under the constitution the time was at hand when the African slave
trade could be abolished, and urged the speedy enactment of such a
law. He said:
"I congratulate you, fellow-citizens, on the approach of a period at
which you may interpose your authority constitutionally to withdraw
the citizens of the United States from all further participation in
those violations of human rights which have so long been continued
on the unoffending inhabitants of Africa, and which the morality,
the reputation and the best interests of our country have long been
eager to proscribe."
An act was accordingly passed prohibiting the slave trade and imposing
forfeitures and fines upon ships and ships' crews engaged in the
traffic. The law also forfeited slaves so illegally imported and
provided that the disposition of such slaves should be left to the
states wherein they were found.
The African slave trade had flourished so long under the patronage and
support of the leading nations of Christendom and with the
acquiescence, at least, of the United States during the previous
twenty years, that it was difficult by simple statutory enactment to
put an end to the nefarious traffic. It will be seen, therefore, that
the trade continued from time to time between the coast of Africa, the
United States, West Indies and Brazil, despite the efforts of the
Federal authorities to enforce the laws made for its suppression.
In
all these efforts Virginians, holding official places, were most
earnest and energetic in their warfare against the trade.
In his message to Congress, December 5, 1810, President Madison
declares:
"Among the commercial abuses still committed under the American flag
... it appears that American citizens are instrumental in carrying
on the traffic in enslaved Africans, equally in violation of the
laws of humanity and in defiance of those of their own country,"
and urges Congress to devise further means for suppressing the evil.
Again, in his message to Congress of December 3, 1816, President
Madison brings the subject to the attention of Congress and urges the
enactment of such amendments as will suppress violations of the
statute.
In the progress of time, certain slaves brought into the country in
violation of the act were captured and sold, thus in effect defeating
one of the prime objects of the law, which was to prevent any increase
in the slave population.
Thereupon, at the session of Congress, 1819,
under the leadership of Charles Fenton Mercer and John Floyd of
Virginia a bill was passed amending the existing statute, requiring
the President to use armed cruisers off the coasts of Africa and
America to suppress the trade, providing for the immediate return to
Africa of any imported slaves, directing the President to appoint
agents to receive and care for them on their return and appropriating
One Hundred Thousand Dollars to carry out the general purposes of the
law.[39]
In the House, on motion of Hugh Nelson, of Virginia, the death penalty
was fixed as the punishment for violating the law, but this provision
was stricken out by the Senate.[40]
In February, 1823, Charles Fenton Mercer, a representative from
Virginia, in the House, secured the adoption of the following joint
resolution:
"RESOLVED, That the President of the United States be requested to
enter upon and to prosecute from time to time such negotiations with
the maritime powers of Europe and America as he may deem expedient
for the effectual abolition of the African slave trade and its
ultimate denunciation as Piracy under the laws of Nations by the
consent of the civilized world."[41]
Mr. Mercer, in urging the adoption of this resolution, denounced the
African slave trade "as a crime begun on a barbarous shore, claimed by
no civilized state, and subject to no moral law; a remnant of ancient
barbarism, a curse extended to the New World by the colonial policy of
the Old."[42]
Mr. Mercer supplemented his congressional action by visits made at his
own expense to the Governments of the Old World to urge upon them the
adoption of the policy set forth in his resolution.'[43]
It was early appreciated that unless at least a qualified "right of
search" was accorded the war vessels of the leading nations engaged in
the effort to suppress the slave trade, these efforts would be
seriously hindered. Accordingly the lower house of Congress, in May,
1821, under the leadership of Charles Fenton Mercer, from whose
committee the resolution was reported, adopted the recommendation that
a "right of search" be accorded the British Government in return for a
like privilege accorded the United States.[44] This resolution,
however, was defeated in the Senate.
Subsequently President Monroe submitted to Congress the draft of a
treaty with England embodying this provision. In a special message,
under date of May 21, 1824, he gave at length his reasons for
approving the treaty—saying:
"Should this convention be adopted there is every reason to believe
that it will be the commencement of a system destined to accomplish
the entire abolition of the slave trade."
Unfortunately, the ratification of this treaty was defeated in the
Senate, and not until 1862 was the "right of search" between Great
Britain and America established.
In his message to Congress June 1, 1841, President Tyler writes:
"I shall also at the proper season invite your attention to the
statutory enactments for the suppression of the slave trade which
may require to be rendered more effective in their provisions. There
is reason to believe that the traffic is on the increase.... The
highest consideration of public honor as well as the strongest
promptings of humanity require a resort to the most vigorous efforts
to suppress the trade."
Again, in his message of December 7, 1841, President Tyler writes:
"I invite your attention to existing laws for the suppression of the
African slave trade, and recommend all such alterations as may give
to them greater force and efficiency. That the American flag is
grossly abused by the abandoned and profligate of other nations is
but too probable."
In 1842, in the preparation of the Ashburton Treaty President Tyler
secured the insertion of a clause providing for the maintenance and
co-operation of squadrons of the United States and Great Britain off
the coast of Africa for the suppression of the trade.[45]
The ratification of this treaty was urged upon the Senate by the
President in his message of August 11, 1842, as conducive to the
abolition of what he termed the "unlawful and inhuman traffic."
Though Brazil, by statute, prohibited the African slave trade in 1831,
yet the traffic continued and in this trade citizens of the United
States as ship owners, or crew, were engaged despite the Federal
statutes against such a practice. Henry A. Wise of Virginia, Consul at
Rio Janeiro, made frequent and earnest reports to the State Department
calling the attention of the authorities to these violations. Under
date of February 18th, 1845, he writes to the Secretary of State at
Washington:
"I beseech, I implore the President of the United States to take a
decided stand on this subject. You have no conception of the bold
effrontery and the flagrant outrages of the African slave trade, and
of the shameless manner in which its worst crimes are licensed here,
and every patriot in our land would blush for our country did he
know and see, as I do, how our citizens sail and sell our flag to
the uses and abuses of that accursed practice."[46]
In his message to Congress, under date of December 4th, 1849,
President Taylor writes:
"Your attention is earnestly invited to an amendment of our existing
laws relating to the African slave trade with a view to the
effectual suppression of that barbarous traffic. It is not to be
denied that this trade is still in part carried on by means of
vessels built in the United States and owned or navigated by some of
our citizens."
The foregoing recitals will serve to illustrate the uncompromising
attitude of hostility on the part of leading Virginians toward the
African slave trade. They sought by Federal statutes and concerted
action with foreign nations to drive the pernicious traffic from the
seas.
They denounced the trade as inhuman, because it stimulated men
to reduce free men to slavery and then entailed upon slaves the
horrors and dangers of the "middle passage." They resolutely opposed
any addition to the slave population of America because profoundly
convinced that every such importation was fraught with menace to the
social, economic and moral well-being of the nation and rendered more
difficult the emancipation of those who had already been brought to
her shores. As we have seen, her representatives at the first meeting
of the Continental Congress had defined Virginia's position in the
notable memorial which declared:
"The abolition of domestic slavery is the great object of desire in
those colonies, where it was unhappily introduced in their infant
state. But, previous to the enfranchisement of the slaves we have,
it is necessary to exclude all further importations from
Africa."[47]
This was the philosophy of the situation as defined by the great
statesmen of the Revolutionary period and to their views their ablest
successors in Virginia adhered down to the outbreak of the Civil War.
-----
Footnote 37:
Annals of Congress, Vol. I, col. 336.
Footnote 38:
Suppression of the Slave Trade, DuBois, p. 80.
Footnote 39:
Annals of Congress, 15th Congress, 2nd section, part I, pp. 442-3.
Footnote 40:
Suppression of the Slave Trade, DuBois, p. 120, Note 3.
Footnote 41:
Annals of Congress, 17th Congress, second session, pp. 435 and
928.
Footnote 42:
Rise and Fall of the Slave Power in America, Wilson, Vol. I, p.
106.
Footnote 43:
The Confederate Cause and Conduct in the War Between the States,
McGuire and Christian, p. 17.
Footnote 44:
Suppression of Slave Trade, DuBois, p. 137.
Footnote 45:
Letters and Times of the Tylers, Tyler, Vol. II, p. 219.
Footnote 46:
American Slave Trade, Spear, p. 81.
Footnote 47:
Writings of Jefferson, Ford, Vol. I, p. 440.
VII
SOME VIRGINIA STATUTES WITH RESPECT TO SLAVERY
Having by her act of 1778, prohibiting the importation of slaves,
provided against any increase in their number from without, Virginia
at the close of the Revolution proceeded to legislate with respect to
those already in her midst, permitting and encouraging their gradual
emancipation.
STATUTE PERMITTING EMANCIPATIONS
Under British rule, slaveholders were forbidden to manumit their
slaves, except with the permission of the Council.[48] In 1782, the
General Assembly of Virginia enacted a law, under which slaveholders
were authorized to emancipate their slaves by deed or will duly made
and recorded.[49]
By an act passed in 1785, it was provided that slaves brought into the
state and remaining twelve months should be free.[50]
In 1787, acts were passed validating certain manumissions made by
wills prior to 1782, the General Assembly declaring that it was "just
and proper" that "the benevolent intentions" of the testators should
be carried into effect.[51]
In 1788, an act was passed making the enslaving of the child of free
blacks a crime punishable by death upon the scaffold.[52]
In 1795, an act was passed allowing a slave to sue in forma pauperis
in any court proceedings affecting his freedom. He might make
complaint to the nearest magistrate or court and the owner was then
required to give bond to permit the slave to attend the next term of
the court and maintain his cause.
If the owner failed or refused to
comply, the slave was taken into the custody of the state, counsel was
assigned to defend his cause and every process of the law allowed him
without cost.[53] Following the adoption of the foregoing laws, the
General Assembly, in 1803, passed an act to still further safeguard
the rights of negroes who had secured their freedom. By this last act
the authorities were required to keep registers in each county in
which were to be recorded the names of all the free negroes and also
the names of slaves whose right to manumission would accrue upon the
death of the person having only an estate for life in such slaves.
STATUTE RESTRICTING EMANCIPATION
The effect of these acts facilitating and encouraging manumissions at
length began to appear. At the close of the Revolution there were less
than three thousand free negroes in Virginia.[54] In the ten years
next succeeding, they reached thirteen thousand, and the census of
1810 records their number at thirty thousand, five hundred and
seventy. Here was a new problem—the presence in a state dominated by
white men of a considerable body of negroes possessing neither the
privileges of the whites nor amenable to the restrictions imposed upon
the great mass of the blacks.
As a result of these conditions, acts
were passed in 1806 providing that no slaves thereafter manumitted
should remain in Virginia.
In 1819 an act was passed authorizing the
County Courts to permit such as were "sober, peaceful, orderly and
industrious to remain in the state."[55] Later, it was provided by
statute that all slaves thereafter manumitted should leave the state
within twelve months from the date of their emancipation.
Thenceforward slaveholders were accorded the right to manumit their
slaves, subject to the claims of their creditors and to the obligation
upon the former slaves of going beyond the state within twelve months
following their manumission.
While these last mentioned statutes embarrassed the work of
emancipation, they stimulated the sentiment in favor of colonization.
However, despite the difficulties which confronted them, slaveholders
still continued to emancipate their slaves and hostility to the
institution of slavery—the conviction that it was a burden upon the
commonwealth—became more and more widespread among the people. The
growth of these sentiments continued until the year 1832. The Rev.
Philip Slaughter, a writer with pro-slavery sympathies, records:
"That was the culminating point—the flood tide of anti-slavery
feeling which had been gradually rising for more than a century in
Virginia was then precipitated upon us before its time by the
Southampton convulsion."[56]
To the disastrous effects upon public sentiment of this tragic event
which occurred in August, 1831, must be added the reactionary
influence of the Abolitionists, who now began their work of agitation
and their arraignment, not simply of slavery nor of slaveholders, but
of the morality and civilization of every community in which the
institution existed. The failure, too, of the General Assembly of
Virginia at its session of 1832 to adopt any plan for the gradual
abolition of slavery or for the removal beyond the state of the free
negroes then within her borders was also strongly reactionary.
Despite
the ability and influence of the anti-slavery leaders in that body no
remedial legislation was adopted and thousands of the people accepted
the result as proof of the fact that the practical difficulties in the
way of emancipation were such as to shut out the hope of its
accomplishment.
-----
Footnote 48:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. IV, p. 132.
Footnote 49:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. XI, p. 39.
Footnote 50:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. XII, p. 182.
Footnote 51:
Hening's Statutes, Vol. XII, pp. 611 and 613.
Footnote 52:
Idem, p. 531.
Footnote 53:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 123.
Footnote 54:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 121.
Footnote 55:
Idem, p. 125.
Footnote 56:
The Virginian History of African Colonization, Slaughter, p. 55.
VIII
THE MOVEMENT IN THE VIRGINIA LEGISLATURE OF 1832
TO ABOLISH SLAVERY IN THE STATE
The Southampton Insurrection, which occurred in August, 1831, was one
of those untoward incidents which so often marked the history of
slavery. Under the leadership of one Nat Turner, a negro preacher, of
some education, who felt that he had been called of God to deliver his
race from bondage, the negroes attacked the whites at night and before
the assault could be suppressed fifty-seven whites, principally women
and children, had been killed.
This deplorable event assumed an even
more portentous aspect when it was realized that the leader was a
slave to whom the privilege of education had been accorded and that
one of his lieutenants was a free negro. In addition there existed a
widespread belief among the whites that influences and instigations
from without the state were responsible for the insurrection.
The General Assembly of Virginia met in regular session in December,
1831, and the effect upon the popular mind of this tragic occurrence
was evidenced in the numerous petitions presented praying for the
removal beyond the state of all free negroes, or the enactment of such
laws as should provide for the abolition of slavery. The institution
itself, the feasibility of its abolition, the status of the free
negroes, the danger to the state from their presence, were thus
brought before the Legislature.
It was a body containing many able men
but elected without reference to this great subject, and with no
previous interchange of views or formulation of plans among the
advocates of reform. The discussions which followed were more notable
for the fierce arraignment of the institution than for the
presentation of practical plans for its abolition.
Henry Wilson, in his Rise and Fall of the Slave Power in America,
says of this discussion:
"It was one of the ablest, most eloquent and brilliant debates that
ever took place in the Legislature of any of the states. Most of
those who participated in it were young and rising men who afterward
achieved high positions and commanding influence."[57]
Mr. Ballagh records that:
"Day after day multitudes thronged the Capitol to hear the speeches.
The Assembly in its zeal for the discussion set aside all prudential
considerations, such as the possible effect of incendiary utterances
that might make the slave believe his lot one of injustice and
cruelty, and so give him the excuse of a revolt, or might encourage
further aggressions by Northern Abolitionists."[58]
LEADERS OF THE MOVEMENT
Thomas Jefferson Randolph, Mr. Jefferson's grandson; Thomas Marshall,
son of the Chief Justice; James McDowell, afterward Congressman and
Governor; Charles J. Faulkner, afterward Congressman and Minister to
France, and William Ballard Preston, afterward Congressman and
Secretary of the Navy in President Taylor's Cabinet, were among the
leaders of the anti-slavery men, and some idea may be formed of the
character of their speeches from the extracts hereinafter cited.
The principal discussion revolved around the report of a committee
which declared "that it is inexpedient for the present Legislature to
make any legislative enactment for the abolition of slavery," to which
Mr. Preston moved the substitution of the word "expedient" for
"inexpedient," and Mr. Bryce moved, as a substitute for both, that the
commonwealth should provide for the immediate removal of the negroes
now free and those who may hereafter become free "believing that this
will absorb all of our present means." By a vote of 58 to 73 Mr.
Preston's amendment was defeated,[59] and Mr.
Bryce's substitute
adopted by a vote of 65 to 58.[60] In line with this declaration, the
House thereupon passed a bill which provided by a comprehensive and
continuous system for the deportation and colonization of the free
negroes of the commonwealth, and such as thereafter might become free.
The measure carried an appropriation of Thirty-five Thousand Dollars
for the first year (1832) and Ninety Thousand Dollars for the year
1833 and was adopted by a vote of 79 to 41.[61] In urging its passage,
William H.
Broadnax insisted that many owners "would manumit their
slaves if means for their removal were furnished by the state, but who
could not if the additional burden of removal were placed upon
them."[62] This bill, so fraught with far-reaching consequences, was
subsequently defeated in the Senate by one vote.
PLANS PROPOSED
Several plans for the gradual emancipation and deportation of the
slaves were brought forward and discussed, but all failed of
enactment. Thomas R. Dew declares that, "no enlarged, wise or
practical plan of operations was proposed by the Abolitionists."[63]
And Mr. Ballagh says, that "will was not wanting but method unhappily
was."[64]
THE EFFECTS OF FAILURE
The failure of this General Assembly to adopt any plan of emancipation
or any comprehensive scheme for the deportation of the free negroes
already in the state had a disastrous effect upon the attitude of
thousands of Virginians towards slavery.
Despairing of relief from
either of these sources and yet facing the peril of which the Nat
Turner Insurrection was the warning sign, her lawmakers sought in
repressive legislation to nullify the dangers of slave insurrection.
Many accepted the institution as permanent and busied themselves
marshalling arguments in vindication of its rightfulness and in
refuting with growing bitterness the assaults of its opponents.
ABOLITIONISTS AND PRO-SLAVERY MEN
But in addition to the Southampton Massacre, and the failure of the
Legislature to enact any effective legislation, the contemporary rise
of the Abolitionists in the North came as an even more powerful factor
to embarrass the efforts of the Virginia emancipators. Unlike the
anti-slavery men of former years, this new school not only attacked
the institution of slavery but the morality of slaveholders and their
sympathizers.
In their fierce arraignment, not only were the humane
and considerate linked in infamy with the cruel and intolerant, but
the whole population of the slave-owning states, their civilization
and their morals were the object of unrelenting and incessant
assaults. Thus thousands sincerely desiring the abolition of slavery
were driven to silence or into the ranks of its apologists in the
widespread and indignant determination of Virginians to resent these
libels upon their character and defeat these attempts to excite
servile insurrections.
"What have we done to her," said the Rev. Nehemiah Adams of Boston,
"but admonish, threaten and indict her before God, excommunicate her,
stir up insurrection among her slaves, endanger her homes, make her
Christians and ministers odious in other lands."[65]
From this period, too, may be noticed the gradual increase in the
number of pro-slavery men in Virginia. This element did not justify
slavery simply because of the difficulties and dangers attending
emancipation, but they asserted that the institution was good in
itself, sanctioned by religion, a blessing to the blacks and essential
to the well-being of the whites. The growth of this new school in its
aggressiveness and the extreme character of its utterances kept pace
with the like development of the Abolitionists.
As the latter
denounced slavery as "man-stealing"—and slaveholders—as "thieves,"
the former marshalled Bible texts to show the divine origin and
Heaven-approved character of the institution. As the Abolitionists
portrayed the "degrading" and "brutalizing" effects of slavery upon
the character of slaveholding communities, the pro-slavery men pointed
to the moral and civic virtues which undoubtedly existed in such
communities, and claimed that these very virtues were attributable to
the institution of slavery.
As Abolitionists, relying upon the
insistence that slavery was a "monstrous oppression," justified slave
insurrections to effect freedom, the pro-slavery men sought to drive
into silence their fellow Virginians of anti-slavery sentiments
because any acknowledgment that it was illegal and that the condition
of the slave was at war with the laws of natural right warranted the
slave in killing his master to secure his freedom.
THE GROWTH OF PRO-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS
Thus, from 1833 on to the time of the war, the pro-slavery advocates
grew in influence and aggressiveness, though what proportion of the
population of Virginia they represented it is impossible to determine.
Their extreme utterances undoubtedly gave them great prominence, as
the march of events, in like manner, augmented their power. The
sentiments of the anti-slavery men found little place in the turmoil
of the times. Their position was strongly analogous to that of the
majority of the Northern people, who, in the midst of the war cries of
the Abolitionists, continued in silence their business pursuits.
-----
Footnote 57:
Rise and Fall of the Slave Power in America, Wilson, Vol. I, p.
195.
Footnote 58:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 138.
Footnote 59:
Journal of House of Delegates, 1832, p. 109.
Footnote 60:
Idem, p. 110.
Footnote 61:
Idem, p. 158.
Footnote 62:
Virginian History of African Colonization, Slaughter, p. 48.
Footnote 63:
An Essay on Slavery, Thomas R. Dew, 1849, p. 6.
Footnote 64:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 138.
Footnote 65:
South Side View of Slavery, Adams, p. 127.
IX
THE NORTHERN ABOLITIONISTS AND THEIR REACTIONARY
INFLUENCE UPON ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENT
IN VIRGINIA
Thomas Jefferson Randolph was the foremost advocate of gradual
emancipation in the Virginia Legislature of 1832. In a pamphlet
printed in 1870 reviewing political conditions in Virginia he makes
the following statement with reference to the subject of emancipation
and the influences which hindered its accomplishment after the year
1833:
"After the adjournment of the Legislature in 1833, the question was
discussed before the people fairly and squarely, as one of the
abolition of slavery. I was re-elected on that ground in my county.
The feeling extended rapidly from that time in Virginia, Kentucky
and Missouri until Northern abolitionism reared its head. Southern
abolition was reform and an appeal to the master; Northern abolition
was revolution and an appeal to the slave.
One was peaceful and the
other mutually destructive of both races by a servile insurrection.
The Southern people feared to trust to the intervention of persons
themselves exempt by position from the imagined dangers of the
transition."[66]
VIEWS OF PROMINENT VIRGINIANS
George Tucker, Professor of Political Economy, in the University of
Virginia, in his work, The Progress of the United States in
Population and Wealth, published in 1843, referring to the subject,
writes:
"This is not the place for assailing or defending slavery; but it
may be confidently asserted that the efforts of Abolitionists have
hitherto made the people in the slaveholding states cling to it more
tenaciously. Those efforts are viewed by them as an intermeddling in
their domestic concerns that is equally unwarranted by the comity
due to sister states, and to the solemn pledges of the Federal
compact.
In the general indignation which is thus excited, the
arguments in favor of negro emancipation, once open and urgent, have
been completely silenced, and its advocates among the slaveholders,
who have not changed their sentiments, find it prudent to conceal
them.... Such have been the fruits of the zeal of Northern
Abolitionists in those states in which slavery prevails; and the
fable of the Wind and the Sun never more forcibly illustrated the
difference between gentle and violent means in influencing men's
wills."[67]
In 1847, Dr. Henry Ruffner, President of Washington College, delivered
an address upon the subject of slavery in Virginia which attracted
widespread attention. In this speech, made in the midst of the growing
controversy, he refers to the reactionary influence of the
Abolitionists as follows:
"But this unfavorable change of sentiment is due chiefly to the
fanatical violence of those Northern anti-slavery men usually called
Abolitionists.... They have not, by honourable means, liberated a
single slave, and they never will by such a course of procedure as
they have pursued. On the contrary they have created new
difficulties in the way of all judicious schemes of emancipation by
prejudicing the minds of slaveholders, and by compelling us to
combat their false principles and rash schemes in our rear; whilst
we are facing the opposition of men and the natural difficulties of
the case in our front."[68]
If it be thought, that Mr. Randolph, Professor Tucker, and Dr. Ruffner
were influenced by their environment and a desire to shift from the
people of Virginia to the Abolitionists responsibility for the growth
in the state of reactionary sentiments, with regard to slavery, it may
be well to quote the contemporary views of prominent anti-slavery men
of the North.
VIEWS OF CHANNING
Dr. William Ellery Channing, writing in 1835, said:
"The adoption of the common system of agitation by the Abolitionists
has not been justified by success. From the beginning it created
alarm in the considerate and strengthened the sympathies of the free
states with the slaveholder. It made converts of a few individuals
but alienated multitudes.
"Its influence at the South has been almost wholly evil. It has
stirred up bitter passions and a fierce fanaticism which have shut
every ear and every heart against its arguments and persuasions.
These effects are more to be deplored because the hope of freedom to
the slaves lies chiefly in the disposition of his master. The
Abolitionist proposed indeed to convert the slaveholders; and for
this reason he approached them with vituperation and exhausted upon
them the vocabulary of reproach. And he has reaped as he sowed....
Thus, with good purpose, nothing seems to have been gained.
Perhaps
(though I am anxious to repel the thought) something has been lost
to the cause of freedom and humanity."[69]
VIEWS OF LINCOLN
In 1837, the Legislature of Illinois adopted a series of resolutions
of a pro-slavery character reprobating the methods of the
Abolitionists. Against the resolutions as adopted, Abraham Lincoln
prepared a memorandum and, together with Daniel Stone, a fellow member
of the body, had the same spread upon its journal as a more accurate
expression of their views. After referring to the resolutions, the
paper declares:
"They believe that the institution of slavery is founded on both
injustice and bad policy, but that the promulgation of abolition
doctrines tends rather to increase than abate its evils."[70]
This declaration of Mr. Lincoln was at once a protest and a prophecy.
It is sometimes urged that because of Mr. Lincoln's youth, at this
time, his estimate of the injuries wrought by the "promulgation of
abolition doctrines" is not entitled to much weight. It is true that
he was then in his twenty-ninth year. A quotation from an even more
notable deliverance, made fifteen years later, will show that
reflection and observation served to confirm his convictions of the
earlier date. In his eulogy on Henry Clay, delivered in the State
House, at Springfield, Illinois, July 16th, 1852, he said:
"Cast into life when slavery was already widely spread and deeply
seated, he did not perceive, as I think no wise man has perceived,
how it could be at once eradicated without producing a greater evil
even to the cause of human liberty itself. His feeling and his
judgment, therefore, ever led him to oppose both extremes of opinion
on the subject.
Those who would shiver into fragments the Union of
these states, tear to tatters its now venerated constitution, and
even burn the last copy of the Bible, rather than slavery should
continue a single hour, together with all their more halting
sympathizers, have received, and are receiving their just
execration; and the name and opinion and influence of Mr. Clay are
fully and, as I trust, effectually and enduringly arrayed against
them."[71]
VIEWS OF WEBSTER
This estimate of Mr. Lincoln had already been anticipated by that of
Mr. Webster who, in his speech of March 7th, 1850, in the United
States Senate made a special reference to the disastrous influence
exerted by the Abolitionists upon the cause of emancipation in
Virginia.
"Public opinion," he said, "which in Virginia had begun to be
exhibited against slavery and was opening out for the discussion of
the question, drew back and shut itself up in its castle. I would
like to know whether anybody in Virginia can now talk openly as Mr.
Randolph, Governor McDowell and others talked in 1832, and sent
their remarks to the press? We all know the facts and we all know
the cause; and everything that these agitating people have done has
been not to enlarge but to restrain, not to set free, but to bind
the faster the slave population of the South."[72]
VIEWS OF DOUGLAS
Stephen A. Douglas, speaking at Bloomington, Illinois, July 16, 1859,
said:
"There is but one possible way in which slavery can be abolished and
that is by leaving the state according to the principle of the
Kansas-Nebraska Bill, perfectly free to form and regulate its
institutions in its own way. That was the principle upon which this
Republic was founded.... Under its operations slavery disappeared
from ... six of the twelve original slaveholding states; and this
gradual system of emancipation went on quietly, peacefully and
steadily so long as we in the free states minded our own business
and left our neighbors alone.
But the moment the abolition societies
were organized throughout the North, preaching a violent crusade
against slavery in the Southern States, this combination necessarily
caused a counter-combination in the South, and a sectional line was
drawn which was a barrier to any further emancipation. Bear in mind
that emancipation has not taken place in any one state since the
Free-soil Party was organized as a political party in this
country....
The moment the North proclaimed itself the determined
master of the South, that moment the South combined to resist the
attack, and thus sectional parties were formed and gradual
emancipation ceased in all the Northern slaveholding states."[73]
In this speech, Mr. Douglas not only points out the methods by which
slavery had been abolished in six of the twelve original slaveholding
states, but he bears testimony, like his great contemporaries, to the
reactionary influence resulting from the attitude of the Northern
Abolitionists.
This estimate of Senator Douglas was reaffirmed in the frank
declaration of Thomas Ewing, of Ohio, who, speaking in the Peace
Conference, at Washington, February, 1861, declared: "The North has
taken the business of abolition into its own hands and from the day
she did so we hear no more of abolition in Virginia. This was but the
natural effect of the cause."[74]
VIEWS OF LUNT AND CURTIS
If it be urged that the views of Channing, Lincoln, Webster, Douglas
and Ewing were unfair in their estimate of the reactionary influence
of the Abolitionists, because of the temper of the times in which they
lived, it may be well to quote the conclusions of publicists not so
situated. Mr. George Lunt, of Boston, writing in December, 1865, says:
"After the years of 1820-21, during which that great struggle which
resulted in what is called the Missouri Compromise was most active
and came to its conclusion, the States of Virginia, Kentucky and
Tennessee were earnestly engaged in practical movements for the
gradual emancipation of their slaves. This movement continued until
it was arrested by the aggressions of the Abolitionists upon their
voluntary action."[75]
Mr. George Ticknor Curtis, of Boston, writing in 1883, after
describing the discussions in the General Assembly of Virginia in
1831-32, and stating that Thomas Jefferson Randolph, the leader of the
movement for the abolition of slavery, was re-elected in 1833 from
Albemarle, one of the largest slaveholding counties in the state,
because of his position, declares:
"But in the meantime came suddenly the intelligence of what was
doing at the North. It came in an alarming aspect for the peace and
security for the whole South; since it could not be possible that
strangers should combine together to assail the slaveholder as a
sinner and to demand his instant admission of guilt, without
arousing fears of the most dangerous consequences for the safety of
Southern homes, as well as intense indignation against such an
unwarrantable interference. From that time forth emancipation
whether immediate or gradual could not be considered in Virginia or
anywhere else in the South."[76]
VIEWS OF ROOSEVELT AND SMITH
As representative of a later generation and voicing sentiments of one
more removed from the period of controversy, the views of Theodore
Roosevelt are of value. Writing in 1898, he says:
"In 1833 the abolition societies of the North came into prominence;
they had been started a couple of years previously. Black slavery
was such a grossly anachronistic and un-American form of evil that
it is difficult to discuss calmly the efforts to abolish it and to
remember that many of these efforts were calculated to do and
actually did more harm than good.... The cause of the Abolitionists
has had such a halo shed around it by the course of events, which
they themselves in reality did very little to shape, that it has
been usual to speak of them with absurdly exaggerated praise.
Their
courage and, for the most part, their sincerity, cannot be too
highly spoken of, but their share in abolishing slavery was far less
than has commonly been represented; any single, non-abolitionist
politician, like Lincoln or Seward, did more than all the
professional Abolitionists combined really to bring about its
destruction."[77]
Writing still later, Mr. William Henry Smith, of Ohio, in his book, A
Political History of Slavery, alluding to the work of the
Abolitionists, says:
"What befell is what has always been the experience, which must
needs be ever the experience of society when men 'encounter with
such bitter tongues,' when full play is given to passion, prejudice
and all uncharitableness.... After fifteen years of this commotion,
the testimony of the judicious was 'that the tendency to general
emancipation in the Border States had been checked, and that the
Abolitionists had done more to rivet the chains of the slave and to
fasten the curse of slavery upon the country than all the
pro-slavery men in the world had done or could do in half a
century.'"[78]
EMANCIPATION AND COLONIZATION
Despite, however, the growing embarrassments of the situation, there
remained with the people of Virginia the conviction that in the
dispersion or colonization beyond her borders, of a substantial part
of her negro population, lay the surest road to ultimate emancipation
and relief from the racial problems incident to slavery. The practice,
therefore, of emancipation by deeds and wills continued, and
individually and by concerted action, the various schemes for
colonization were fostered and encouraged.
The Legislature at its
session, 1833, passed a bill appropriating $18,000.00 per annum, for a
period of five years to assist in transporting and subsisting "free
persons of color who may desire to migrate from Virginia to
Liberia."[79]
This appropriation, as we shall see, was followed by others of larger
amounts to further colonization; and, in no state of the Union, with
the possible exception of Maryland, did the cause receive greater
assistance, in money and sympathy, than in Virginia.
-----
Footnote 66:
See printed pamphlet T. J. Randolph, September 25th, 1870, on file
with Virginia Historical Society.
Footnote 67:
Progress of Population and Wealth, Tucker, p. 108. Note—The
author concludes his review of slavery in Virginia by saying: "As
the same decline in the value of labor once liberated the villeins,
or slaves, of western Europe, and will liberate the serfs of Russia,
so must it put an end to slavery in the United States, should it be
terminated in no other way."
Footnote 68:
The Ruffner Pamphlet, Lexington, 1847.
Footnote 69:
The Works of William E. Channing, 1889, American Unitarian
Society, p. 735.
Footnote 70:
The following is a full text of the paper:
"Resolutions upon the subject of domestic slavery having passed both
branches of the General Assembly at its present session, the
undersigned hereby protest against the passing of the same.
They believe that the institution of slavery is founded on both
injustice and bad policy, but that the promulgation of abolition
doctrines tends rather to increase than abate its evils.
They believe that the Congress of the United States has no power
under the constitution to interfere with the institution of slavery
in the different states.
They believe that the Congress of the United States has the power
under the constitution to abolish slavery in the District of
Columbia, but that the power ought not to be exercised unless at the
request of the people of the District.
The difference between these opinions and those contained in the
above resolutions, is their reason for entering this protest.
(Signed) DAN STONE,
A. LINCOLN."
Representatives from the County of Sangamon. (Abraham Lincoln, A
History, N. & H., Vol. I, p. 140.)
Footnote 71:
Abraham Lincoln, Speeches, Letters and State Papers, N. & H, Vol.
I, p. 174.
Footnote 72:
Webster's Great Speeches, Whipple, p. 619.
Footnote 73:
Lincoln-Douglas Debates, Columbus, 1860, p. 31.
Footnote 74:
Proceedings of Peace Convention, Crittenden, p. 142.
Footnote 75:
The Origin of the Late War, Lunt, 1865, p. 33.
Footnote 76:
Life of James Buchanan, Curtis, 1883, p. 278.
Footnote 77:
Thomas H. Benton, Roosevelt, p. 141.
Footnote 78:
A Political History of Slavery, William Henry Smith, 1903, Vol. I,
pp. 40-41.
Footnote 79:
Virginian History of African Colonization, Slaughter, p. 67.
X
NEGRO COLONIZATION—STATE AND NATIONAL
The idea of colonization seems to have originated with Mr. Jefferson,
who, in 1777, submitted a plan to a committee of the General Assembly
of Virginia.
In 1787, Dr. William Thornton published an address to the free negroes
of the whole country offering to lead them in person back to Africa.
In December, 1800, the General Assembly passed a resolution requesting
the Governor to communicate with the President of the United States
with the view of purchasing lands beyond the limits of Virginia for
colonization purposes. A considerable correspondence ensued between
Mr. Monroe, the Governor, and Mr. Jefferson, the President.
Nothing practical, however, resulted from these negotiations, though
on the 27th of December, 1804, Mr. Jefferson wrote Governor Page: "I
beg you to be assured that, having the object of the House of
Delegates sincerely at heart, I will keep it under my constant
attention, and omit no occasion which may occur of giving it
effect."[80]
EARLY SCHEMES OF COLONIZATION
In January, 1805, the Legislature passed another resolution requesting
Virginia's representatives in Congress to use every effort to secure a
portion of the territory of Louisiana for the colonization "of such
people of color as have been or shall be emancipated in Virginia."
The difficulties with France and England at this time prevented
further prosecution of the subject, but, after the termination of the
war between the United States and England, a resolution was passed by
the General Assembly of Virginia, in December, 1816, requesting the
Governor to correspond with the President with a view of acquiring
upon the coast of Africa, or at some point in the United States, an
asylum "for such persons of color as are now free and desire the
same," or "that may hereafter be emancipated in Virginia."
AMERICAN COLONIZATION SOCIETY
About the time of this action of the Virginia Legislature there
assembled at Washington on the 21st of December 1816, a body of
prominent citizens from various states, who effected a tentative
organization, from which resulted the American Colonization Society.
Over this meeting Henry Clay presided, and among the notable persons
present were Daniel Webster, Bushrod Washington and John Randolph of
Roanoke. The Rev. Robert Finley, of New Jersey, and Mr. E. B.
Caldwell, at that time Clerk of the Supreme Court at Washington, were
especially active in bringing about the assemblage.
Charles Fenton
Mercer, of Virginia, and Francis Scott Key, of Maryland, were also
among the most zealous friends of the enterprise. In addition to
Randolph and Washington, Bishop William Meade, Rev. William H. Wilmer,
John Taylor, Edmund I. Lee and other Virginians were also present. Mr.
Clay has left upon record that "the original conception of the project
is to be traced to a date long anterior," to the meeting and that "the
State of Virginia, always prominent in works of benevolence, prior to
the formation of the American Colonization Society ... had expressed
her approbation of the plan of colonization."[81]
On the first of January, 1817, the permanent organization of the
society was effected by the selection of Mr. Justice Bushrod
Washington, of Virginia, as President, a position which he held for
thirteen years. Judge Washington was succeeded by Charles Carroll, of
Carrollton, James Madison, Henry Clay and John H. B. Latrobe, the last
named holding office until after the Civil War.
FOUNDING OF COLONY OF LIBERIA
The Society having been organized, immediate steps were taken to
acquire land upon the coast of Africa upon which to establish the
colony. For this purpose Samuel J. Mills, so well known and venerated
for his missionary labors, and Ebenezer Burgess were sent to Africa,
the money to defray their expenses being raised by Charles Fenton
Mercer and Bishop Meade, of Virginia.[82] The report of these
commissioners established the practicability of securing the necessary
land on the coast of Africa and establishing the emigrants in their
new home.
The Society, however, was without sufficient means for the
successful initiation of its great work and possessed no relation to
the government, state or National. By a fortuitous train of
circumstances and the zeal of certain of its members, among whom
Virginians bore an active part, all of these objects were in a measure
attained.
Under the terms of the Federal statute prohibiting the foreign slave
trade it was provided that any slave whose importation was attempted
in violation of the act should be seized by the authorities of the
state where the importation occurred, and disposed of at its pleasure.
The State of Georgia had, accordingly, acquired possession of a number
of imported negroes and had advertised them for sale at Milledgeville,
May 4, 1819. Such an event and such a policy would have defeated the
statute, one of whose objects was to prevent the increase of the slave
population.
Learning of these facts, Bishop Meade, of Virginia, was
sent as the representative of the Colonization Society, to Georgia,
where he secured the release of the negroes advertised to be sold,
upon condition that the Society would reimburse the state for the
costs incurred in their maintenance.[83] George Washington Parke
Custis, of Virginia, offered an island near Cape Charles, Virginia, as
a place of refuge until they could be transported to Africa.[84]
Knowledge of the foregoing facts induced Charles Fenton Mercer and
John Floyd, of Virginia, to present to Congress, of which they were
members, a bill which became a law in 1819, whereby all negroes
imported since the passage of the act should be returned to their own
country, appointing agents upon the coast of Africa to receive them;
and appropriating $100,000.00 to carry this law into effect.
President
Monroe was zealous in enforcing the provisions of this law, and acted
in cordial co-operation with the Colonization Society to effectuate
its purposes. Under the provisions of the act, territory was acquired
upon the coast of Africa, and there the colony of Liberia was
established. In 1824, in recognition of Mr. Monroe's services, the
inhabitants of the colony named their capital Monrovia.
VIRGINIA'S EFFORTS AT COLONIZATION
In the great work of the American Colonization Society, the leading
people of Virginia took a most active and sympathetic interest. This
was evinced in the organization of Auxiliary Societies at Richmond,
Norfolk, Fredericksburg, Petersburg, Alexandria, Lynchburg, Wheeling,
Charlestown, Shepherdstown, Hampton and Harper's Ferry and in the
Counties of Isle of Wight, Sussex, Albemarle, King William, Dinwiddie,
Amherst, Berkeley, Nansemond, Buckingham, Nelson, Fluvanna, Frederick,
Augusta, Kanawha, Powhatan, Loudoun, Rockingham, Mecklenburg,
Campbell, and others.
The officials of these Societies numbered many
of the most prominent men of Virginia; John Marshall, then Chief
Justice of the United States, was President of the Richmond branch.
The Virginia Auxiliary Societies collected money by private
subscription, and facilitated in every way the transportation of such
free negroes as desired to emigrate. In 1826, upon the petition of the
Societies, the Legislature of Virginia made its first appropriation to
assist in their work. In addition to those in Virginia, Auxiliary
Societies were organized in Massachusetts, Connecticut, New York, New
Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Kentucky.
In 1828 the Colonization Society of Virginia was established and
thereafter Virginians directed their energies largely through this
Virginia organization. John Marshall was elected President of the
Virginia Society, and James Madison, James Monroe, John Tyler and
William H. Broadnax, were among its Vice-Presidents.
By an act passed in 1850 the General Assembly of Virginia appropriated
the sum of $30,000.00 per annum for five years for the transportation
and sustenance of free negroes who desired to emigrate. Certain
qualifications of the measure limited its effectiveness, and in 1853,
the Virginia Colonization Society secured its repeal and the enactment
of a new law appropriating $30,000.00 per annum for five years, with
much more liberal provisions as to the method of its expenditure.
Private benevolence supplemented the state.
The reports of the Society
show that during the years 1850-51-52 private contributions from the
people of Virginia aggregated over $21,000.00.[85]
The work of the Society was endorsed by the churches and more and more
it assumed the character of a Christian enterprise. It was commended
because it brought relief to Virginia, blessings to the ex-slaves,
greater hope of freedom to those still in bondage, and carried
Christianity and civilization to Africa. Among the first of many white
men who gave their lives to the cause of colonization was Samuel J.
Mills, who died at sea on his way home from Africa. Mills was the
leader in the band of students at Williams College, Massachusetts, so
well known for their missionary zeal and labours, and hence has a
double claim upon our gratitude.
ABOLITIONISTS AND PRO-SLAVERY MEN
The problems and difficulties of colonization, admittedly great, were
seriously augmented by the active opposition of the extreme
pro-slavery men at the South and the Abolitionists at the North. Each
of these two antagonistic forces strenuously opposed the work of
colonization, the first because it facilitated eventual emancipation,
the second, among other reasons, because it rendered conditions more
tolerable and thus postponed the day of the universal and immediate
abolition of slavery.
In addition to the colonizations made through the aid of the
colonization societies, many Virginia slaveholders emancipated their
slaves and at their own expense colonized them in some of the free
states. A few instances will illustrate the custom and the
difficulties often encountered by these emancipators and their
ex-slaves.
-----
Footnote 80:
Virginian History of African Colonization, Slaughter, pp. 1-6.
Footnote 81:
The African Repository and Colonial Journal—Vol. VI, No. 1, p.
13.
Footnote 82:
Liberia Bulletin. No. 16—February, 1900, p. 21.
Footnote 83:
Memoir of Bishop Meade, Johns, 1867, p. 120.
Footnote 84:
History of United States, McMaster, Vol. IV, p. 65.
Footnote 85:
Virginian History of African Colonization, Slaughter, p. 100.
XI
INSTANCES OF COLONIZATIONS BY INDIVIDUAL SLAVEHOLDERS
By the will of Samuel Gist, his slaves were emancipated and William F.
Wickham and Carter B. Page, of Richmond, appointed trustees to acquire
land in some one of the free states on which to provide homes for the
newly manumitted freedmen. Accordingly, these trustees purchased two
tracts of land in Brown County, Ohio, one containing one thousand and
the other twelve hundred acres at a cost of $4400.00.[86]
In 1819, the freedmen, consisting of one hundred and thirteen from
Hanover County and one hundred and fifty from Goochland and Amherst
Counties, were transported to Ohio and settled on the lands purchased,
as above indicated, by the trustees.
The facts are meagre with respect to the reception accorded these
negroes and the measure of success which attended the colonization.
From the best information obtainable, it seems that they were treated
in no very friendly manner and that, in time, the negroes lost most of
the lands provided for them by their former owner.
Edward Coles, of Albemarle County, inherited from his father a large
number of slaves. Determining to give them their freedom, he conducted
them in April, 1819, to Illinois, where he established them in their
own homes near the town of Edwardsville, giving to each head of a
family a tract of one hundred and sixty acres of land.[87] Mr. Coles,
like many other Virginians, who attempted a like emancipation, not
only incurred the great pecuniary loss resulting from the liberation
of his slaves and the expenses of their removal and establishment, but
he incurred the ill will and opposition of the inhabitants of the
state in which they settled.
The biographers of Abraham Lincoln, Nicolay and Hay, referring to the
attitude of the people of Illinois towards free negroes, record:
"Even Governor Coles, the public-spirited and popular politician,
was indicted and severely fined for having brought his own freedmen
into this state and having assisted them in establishing themselves
around him upon farms of their own."[88]
Mr. Coles was a neighbor and friend of Jefferson, Madison and Monroe.
He was Madison's private secretary and was appointed by President
Monroe Registrar of the Land Office at Edwardsville, Ill., in March,
1819, a position of influence and importance. Three years later he was
elected Governor of the state and his career as such was notable for
the great part he bore in defeating the movement to change the state
constitution of Illinois so as to permit the introduction and
maintenance of slavery within that state. In 1832 Governor Coles
removed to Philadelphia where he lived until his death.
When Virginia
seceded, his son, Roberts Coles, volunteered in her service and was
killed at the Battle of Roanoke Island.
By his will, admitted to probate on the 20th of November, 1826, John
Ward, Sr., of Pittsylvania, emancipated all of his slaves, giving to
each of them over fifteen years of age twenty dollars, except to
certain enumerated ones, to whom the sum of one hundred and fifty
dollars each was bequeathed.[89] In April, 1827, these freedmen,
emancipated under the will of Ward (seventy in number), were
transported to Ohio and settled in Lawrence County.[90]
By his will, John Randolph of Roanoke, who died in 1833, emancipated
all of his slaves and directed his executor, Judge William Leigh, to
transport them to some one of the free states and settle them upon
lands which he was directed to purchase for the purpose. The will
bequeathed the sum of thirteen thousand dollars to defray the expenses
incident to their colonization and to pay for the land.
Howe in his Historical Collections of Ohio (Edition of 1891) says:
"In 1846 Judge Leigh, of Virginia, purchased 3200 acres of land in
this settlement for the freed slaves of John Randolph of Roanoke.
These arrived in the Summer of 1846 to the number of about four
hundred but were forcibly prevented from making a settlement by a
portion of the inhabitants of the county. Since then acts of
hostility have been commenced against the people of this settlement
and threats of greater held out if they do not abandon their lands
and homes."
"From a statement in the county history issued in 1882 we see that a
part of the Randolph negroes succeeded in effecting a settlement at
Montezuma, Franklin Township, just south of the reservoir."[91]
By his will which was probated March 23, 1848, John Warwick, of
Amherst County, Virginia, emancipated all his slaves, and in like
manner bequeathed his whole estate to create a fund for removing them
to one of the free states, purchasing farms, and establishing them in
their new homes. The testator indicated that he preferred Indiana as
the place of residence for his slaves.[92] Dr.
David Patteson, of
Buckingham County, was appointed executor and charged with the duties
of settling the estate and removing the freedmen to their new homes.
Before arrangements for their removal to Indiana could be perfected,
that state adopted its constitution of 1851, whereby free negroes and
mulattoes were inhibited from coming into the state. Accordingly Dr.
Patteson purchased for the ex-slaves a large tract of land in Ohio,
near Kenton, and thither they were transported and settled in their
new homes. The inventory of Mr. Warwick's estate shows that at the
time of his death he owned seventy-four slaves.[93]
By his will, admitted to probate July 9th, 1849, Sampson Sanders, of
Cabell County, emancipated all of his slaves and directed his
executors to provide for their colonization "in the State of Indiana,
or some one of the free states of the United States."[94] The testator
bequeathed to these slaves the sum of fifteen thousand dollars, out of
which fund should be paid the amount necessary for the purchase of
land for their homes, the balance to be distributed among them. Before
the intentions of the testator could be carried into effect, Indiana
enacted a law denying to freed negroes the privileges of settling in
that state.
Accordingly these freedmen were carried to Cass County,
Mich., where they were settled in homes purchased for them under the
provisions of the will of their former owner. This colony seems to
have succeeded, and many of the descendants of the former slaves of
Sanders are to-day living upon the lands purchased by his bounty.[95]
SENTIMENTAL DIFFICULTIES
In addition to the many difficulties already enumerated, that invested
colonization, there were other deterrent causes only less real. Was it
right to send these newly manumitted slaves off, upon the hazard of
maintaining themselves in the face of difficulties for which they had
had so little training? This was the question for the master. What of
their future in the far away and unknown land? That was the question
for the slave. Then too, there came to both a genuine reluctance to
meet the pain of separation.
Of the fact of the existence of a strong
affection between masters and slaves, in a great majority of the homes
in Virginia where the institution of slavery existed, there can be no
question. From the great number of instances illustrating the sorrows
of masters and servants in the hour of separation, we select two.
INSTANCES ILLUSTRATING DIFFICULTIES
David W. Barton, of Winchester, Virginia, emancipated many of his
slaves a short time prior to the Civil War. Some of these were sent to
Liberia, and others, who from age or youth were not regarded as equal
to the trials of the trip, were settled in this country. Robert T.
Barton, Esq., a son of the emancipator, in a letter to the author
bears testimony to the fact of the affection which subsisted between
the members of his father's family and these freedmen. "I was quite a
small boy at the time," he writes, "but I remember the incident
perfectly.
I recall the weeping family that parted with these
servants, who were very dear to us."[96]
Traverse Herndon, of Fauquier, who died in 1854, by his last will
emancipated his slaves, some fifty in number, and made provision for
their transportation to Liberia. Two years later his brother, Thaddeus
Herndon, emancipated his slaves, some twenty in number, and the two
groups of freedmen, except such as were too old to bear the dangers of
the voyage and life in the new country, were sent to Liberia in the
fall of 1857, under the care of an agent of the American Colonization
Society.
The Rev. Charles T. Herndon, of Salem, Virginia, has furnished the
author with an account of the parting between these freedmen and his
father, Thaddeus Herndon, which occurred on board of the ship
"Euphrasia," written by the Rev. John Seys,[97] a former missionary to
Liberia, who was present on the occasion. The subjoined extract from
Mr.
Seys' account of the separation, which was published soon
afterwards in the Maryland Colonization Journal, presents in the
most vivid manner the sorrow attending the parting of Thaddeus Herndon
and his former slaves, and the reverence and affection with which the
slaves of Traverse Herndon regarded their dead master.
OPPOSITION OF FREEDMEN TO COLONIZATION
Not infrequently the many difficulties which embarrassed the efforts
of Virginia slaveholders to colonize their ex-slaves at points beyond
the state were increased by the attitude of the slaves themselves. The
experience of John Thom, of Berry Hill, Culpeper County, as related in
a letter to the author under date of July 15th, 1908, by his son
Cameron E. Thom, of Los Angeles, Cal., will serve as an illustration.
Mr. Cameron Thom is at present a man of venerable years who seems to
retain a vivid impression of the scenes incident to the attempt at
colonization made by his father in the later thirties. Mr.
Thom, after
narrating that his father was a soldier in the War of 1812, where he
gained his title as commander of a Virginia regiment, and was for
thirty years a member of the State Senate, proceeds to write with
reference to his father's attitude towards slavery as follows:
"He was not satisfied with it, and was restive under it. In his
discussions of the subject he often quoted as expressive of his
views Mr. Jefferson, who declared that 'We have the wolf by the
ears, and it is as dangerous to let go as it is to hold on.' I
believe they were both gradual emancipationists. The idea of
practical and immediate emancipation through the medium of
colonization seems to have crystallized in his mind and stimulated
him to action.
He sent my eldest brother, Catesby Thom, to
Pennsylvania to spy out the land and to make definite arrangements
for the location, settlement and comfort of the proposed colony.
After an absence of several weeks, he returned and reported that he
had selected an ideal location for the experiment. Every desideratum
seems to have been taken into consideration, climate, wood, water,
fertility of the soil, products, neighbors, etc.
"To carry out my father's plan, the next step was to call for
eighteen volunteers to make up the colony. Here came a great
disappointment. Of the number called for only one suitable man
responded.... The volunteer idea was abandoned and conscription was
resorted to. When the names of the eighteen chosen ones were
announced the plantation was indeed a house of mourning. Prayers,
protests and petitions came up, but were of no avail. A complete
outfit was made up of three wagons, twelve oxen, three cows, tools,
farming utensils, provisions, clothing, &c.
The expedition got off
all right, my brother Catesby being chief in command, and Uncle
Billy Guinn, the only volunteer, a full second. Before the
expiration of a week from the time of departure, two of the
colonists had deserted and were back at Berry Hill, and in less than
a year nearly all the others had found their way back. My brother,
after some two months' absence, got back and reported that he would
not go through with his experience again for all the negroes in
Virginia.
"I left Virginia for the South in 1848; returning in a few weeks, I
took my final departure from the state in the early Spring of 1849
for California where I have resided ever since, never having seen my
father again. I believe he manumitted all or nearly all of the
servants by deed or will."
-----
Footnote 86:
See Record of Deeds, Vol. A., p. 230, Recorder's Office, Brown
County, Ohio.
Footnote 87:
Sketch of Edward Coles, Washburne, pp. 47-52.
Footnote 88:
Abraham Lincoln, A History, N. & H., Vol. I, p. 145.
(Note. The fine imposed upon Governor Coles was subsequently
remitted by an act of the Legislature because the law under which he
was fined had not been published at the date of his offense.)
Footnote 89:
See Will Book No. 1, p. 109, Clerk's Office, Pittsylvania County,
Va.
Footnote 90:
See Public Ledger of Philadelphia, April 14, 1827.
Footnote 91:
Historical Collections of Ohio, History of Mercer County, Ohio, by
Henry Howe, 1891, Vol. II, p. 505.
Footnote 92:
See Will Book No. 11, p. 575, Clerk's Office, Amherst County, Va.
Footnote 93:
John Warwick was the great-uncle of the Hon. John Warwick Daniel,
now (1908) and for many years past a member from Virginia in the
United States Senate.
Footnote 94:
See Will Book A., p. 391, in the Clerk's Office of Cabell County,
West Virginia.
Footnote 95:
See Outlook Magazine, N. Y., February 9th, 1903.
Footnote 96:
Under date of March 19, 1907, Mr. Barton writes the author: "My
father manumitted his slaves, or rather, certain of them, before the
war. Under the law as I remember it, it was not necessary to put on
record a deed of manumission of a slave who was sent out of the
state.... I was quite a small boy at the time, but I remember the
incident perfectly. I recall the weeping family that parted with
these servants, who were very dear to us....
Many years after that I
received a visit from one of the women who had been the assistant in
the nursery, and to whom, as a child, I remember I was very devoted.
I do not believe that two near relations could have had a more
affecting greeting. She stayed in Winchester for nearly a week,
coming to my house every day, and finally went away without bidding
us good bye, writing back from her home that she had done so because
she could not stand the parting.
The other servants who went away
also kept up with our family the most affectionate relations for
many years, and the old ones, who could not get away, were supported
by my brothers and myself after the war until they died."
Footnote 97:
Mr. Seys records that his experience as a missionary in Liberia
prompted him to visit these emigrants on board ship, just
preparatory to their departure, and at the request of Mr. Herndon,
make them a short address. He then writes: "I closed my remarks and
Mr. Herndon followed me." The latter said: "I may not see you again,
I may as well say all I have to say now." And then he became so
choked for utterance, and tears fell so fast that a silence ensued
only broken by sighs and sobs of the entire party. Again he
continued:
"My heart is too full. I can hardly speak. You know how we have
lived together. Servants, hear me, we have been brothers and
sisters, we have grown up together. We have done the best for you.
For two or three years this has been contemplated and you are now on
the point of starting for the land of your ancestors.
Besides your
freedom, we have spent $2,000.00 in procuring everything we could
think of to make you comfortable—clothing, bedding, implements of
husbandry, mechanics' tools, books for the children, Bibles, a
family Bible for each family, all these have been provided, and when
you have been there some few months, we will send you out another
supply of provisions and will continue to do so. And now, you three
brethren, who formed the committee appointed by the church to watch
over your brethren, a word to you.
You are chosen to admonish,
guide, counsel the others, not to lord it over them, but gently and
kindly to watch over their souls; and now, may God bless you. I can
never forget you. Write to me, Washington, you can write; I have
provided you with paper. Keep a journal, put all of your names down,
even the children, and write opposite to each one everything that
happens concerning you.
I shall feel much interested in hearing from
you—especially will your Miss Frances. (Here the bare mention of
their almost adored mistress started their grief afresh.) Now, as we
may never meet again, let us part with prayer, let all kneel down,
and Brother Seys will lead in prayer to Almighty God for you all."
We knelt there, and under feelings words but poorly express, engaged
in prayer as best we could amid cries and sobs and tears.
XII
EMANCIPATION AND COLONIZATION:
## VIEWS OF JEFFERSON, CLAY AND LINCOLN
If it be urged that Virginia had reached the conclusion that without
the dispersion or colonization of the whole or a large portion of her
slave population emancipation was impracticable, it may be
acknowledged that to a qualified extent this was true. The position,
however, did not involve an abandonment of the principle of
emancipation, but rather the insistence that with emancipation should
go the work of solving the race problem by a method which gave some
assurance of complete success.
That this attitude of Virginia cannot be regarded as wholly
unreasonable or reactionary will appear when we consider the views of
some of the leading friends of negro emancipation. From the number of
those whose sanity kept pace with their zeal, we select Thomas
Jefferson, Henry Clay and Abraham Lincoln.
VIEWS OF JEFFERSON AND CLAY
Mr. Jefferson in 1820 wrote:
"Nothing is more certainly written in the book of fate than that
these people are to be free; nor is it less certain than that the
two races, equally free, cannot live in the same government. Nature,
habit, opinion, have drawn indelible lines of distinction between
them."[98]
Writing to Jared Sparks, President of Harvard College, in 1824, he
said:
"In the disposition of these unfortunate people there are two
rational objects to be distinctly kept in view. First, the
establishment of a colony on the coast of Africa, which may
introduce among the aborigines the arts of cultivated life and the
blessings of liberty and science. By doing this, we may make them
some retribution for the long course of injuries we have been
committing on their population....
Second object, and the most
interesting to us, as coming home to our physical and moral
characters, to our happiness and safety, is to provide an asylum to
which we can, by degrees, send the whole of that population from
among us, and establish them under our patronage and protection, as
a separate, free, and independent people, in some country and
climate friendly to human life and happiness."[99]
VIEWS OF CLAY
Mr. Clay's attitude with respect to the institution of slavery will
appear from his oft-quoted declaration:
"Those who would repress all tendencies to liberty and ultimate
emancipation must do more than put down the benevolent efforts of
the Colonization Society, they must go back to the era of our
liberty and independence, and muzzle the cannon that thunders its
annual joyous return—they must blot out the moral lights around
us—they must penetrate the human soul, and eradicate the light of
reason and the love of liberty."[100]
His sentiments, however, with respect to the wisdom and necessity for
colonizing the manumitted slaves were equally decided. In an address
before the Colonization Society of Kentucky at Frankfort, December 17,
1829, Mr. Clay presented at length his reasons for supporting the
movement to colonize all ex-slaves in the Republic of Liberia. In the
course of this address he said:
"If the question were submitted, whether there should be either
immediate or gradual emancipation of all the slaves in the United
States, without their removal or colonization, painful as it is to
express the opinion, I have no doubt that it would be unwise to
emancipate them. For I believe, that the aggregate of the evils
which would be engendered in society upon the supposition of such
general emancipation, and of the liberated slaves remaining
promiscuously among us, would be greater than all the evils of
slavery."[101]
Continuing, he said:
"Is there no remedy I again ask for the evils of which I have
sketched a faint and imperfect picture? Is our posterity doomed to
endure forever not only all the ills flowing from the state of
slavery, but all which arise from incongruous elements of
population, separated from each other by invincible prejudices and
by natural causes?
Whatever may be the character of the remedy
proposed, we may confidently pronounce it inadequate, unless it
provides efficaciously for the total and absolute separation, by an
extensive space of water or of land, at least of the white portion
of our population from that which is free of the colored."[102]
In conclusion he said:
"If we were to invoke the greatest blessing on earth, which Heaven,
in its mercy, could now bestow on this nation, it would be the
separation of the two most numerous races of its population and
their comfortable establishment in distinct and different
countries."[103]
VIEWS OF LINCOLN
The biographers of Abraham Lincoln, Nicolay and Hay, declare:
"The political creed of Abraham Lincoln embraced among other tenets,
a belief in the value and promise of colonization as one means of
solving the great race problem involved in the existence of slavery
in the United States.... Without being an enthusiast, Lincoln was a
firm believer in colonization."[104]
Speaking at Springfield, Illinois, June 26, 1857, Mr. Lincoln said:
"I have said that the separation of the races is the only perfect
prevention of amalgamation. I have no right to say that all the
members of the Republican Party are in favor of this nor to say that
as a party they are in favor of it. There is nothing in their
platform directly on the subject. But I can say a very large
proportion of its members are for it and that the chief plank in
that platform—opposition to the spread of slavery—is most
favorable to that separation. Such separation, if ever effected at
all, must be effected by colonization....
The enterprise is a
difficult one but where there is a will there is a way; and what
colonization needs most is a hearty will. Will springs from the two
elements of moral sense and self-interest. Let us be brought to
believe it is morally right, and at the same time favorable to, or,
at least, not against our interests, to transfer the African to his
native clime, and we shall find a way to do it, however great the
task may be."[105]
Upon his assumption of the office of President Mr. Lincoln sought to
carry into effect his colonization views. In his first annual message
to Congress—December, 1861—after alluding to the act "to confiscate
property used for insurrectionary purposes," enacted by Congress at
its extra session, under the operations of which thousands of slaves
had come into the custody of the Federal authorities and the further
fact that some of the states might adopt similar statutes with similar
results, he proceeds to say:
"In such cases I recommend that Congress provide for accepting such
persons from such states according to some mode of valuation in lieu
pro tanto of direct taxes, or upon some other plan to be agreed on
with such states respectively; that such persons, on such
acceptance, by the General Government, be at once deemed free, and
that in any event steps be taken for colonizing both classes (or the
first mentioned if the other shall not be brought into existence) at
some place or places in a climate congenial to them.
It might be
well to consider too whether the free colored people already in the
United States could not, so far as individuals may desire, be
included in such colonization.
"To carry out the plan of colonization may involve the acquiring of
territory, and also the appropriation of money beyond that to be
expended in the territorial acquisition. Having practised the
acquisition of territory for nearly sixty years the question of
constitutional power to do so is no longer an open one with us....
"If it be said that the only legitimate object of acquiring
territory is to furnish homes for white men this measure effects
their object, for the emigration of colored men leaves additional
room for white men remaining or coming here. Mr. Jefferson however
placed the importance of procuring Louisiana more on political and
commercial grounds than on providing room for population. On this
whole proposition, including the appropriation of money with the
acquisition of territory, does not expediency amount to absolute
necessity—that without which the government itself cannot be
perpetuated."[106]
As a result of these urgent representations Congress, at its session
of 1862, placed at the disposal of the President the sum of
$600,000.00 to be expended at his discretion in colonizing with their
consent free persons of African descent in some country adapted to
their condition and necessities.[107]
Mr. Lincoln, with a view of carrying out this act of Congress, invited
a number of prominent colored men to meet him at the White House on
the 14th of August, 1862, and then and there urged upon them the
wisdom of availing themselves of the opportunity thus offered to make
for themselves a home beyond the borders of this country. Mr. Lincoln
said that the action of Congress in placing at his disposal a sum of
money for the purpose of aiding the colonization of the people of
African descent made it his duty, as it had for a long time been his
inclination, to favor that cause. Continuing, he said:
"And why should the people of your race be colonized, and where? Why
should you leave this country? This is perhaps the first question
for proper consideration. You and we are different races. We have
between us a broader difference than exists between almost any other
two races. Whether it is right or wrong I need not discuss; but this
physical difference is a great disadvantage to us both as I think.
Your race suffer very greatly, many of them by living among us,
while ours suffer from your presence. In a word, we suffer on each
side. If this be admitted, it affords a reason, at least, why we
should be separated.
"The aspiration of men is to enjoy equality with the best when free,
but on this broad continent not a single man of your race is made
the equal of a single man of ours. Go where you are treated the
best, and the ban is still upon you. I do not propose to discuss
this, but to present it as a fact with which we have to deal. I
cannot alter it if I would."
In conclusion he said:
"I ask you then to consider seriously not pertaining to yourselves
merely, nor for your race and ours for the present time but as one
of the things if successfully managed, for the good of mankind—not
confined to the present generation."[108]
In his special message to Congress April 16th, 1862, after alluding to
the passage of the bill abolishing slavery in the District of
Columbia, he approves the same and declares: "I am grateful that the
principles of compensation and colonization are both recognized and
practically applied in this act."[109]
-----
Footnote 98:
Jefferson Manuscript, Raynor, p. 64.
Footnote 99:
Writings of Jefferson, Ford, Vol. X, p. 290
Footnote 100:
Lincoln and Slavery, Arnold, p. 124.
Footnote 101:
The African Repository and Colonial Journal, Vol. II, No. 1, p. 5.
Footnote 102:
The African Repository and Colonial Journal, Vol. II, p. 12.
Footnote 103:
Idem, p. 23.
Footnote 104:
Abraham Lincoln, A History, N. & H., Vol. VI, p. 355.
Footnote 105:
Abraham Lincoln, Speeches, Letters and State Papers, N. & H., Vol.
I, p. 235.
Footnote 106:
Messages and Papers of the Presidents, Vol. VI, p. 64.
Footnote 107:
The Life, Public Services and State Papers of Abraham Lincoln,
Raymond, p. 504.
Footnote 108:
The Life, Public Services and State Papers of Abraham Lincoln,
Raymond, p. 504.
Footnote 109:
Messages and Papers of the Presidents, Vol. VI, p. 73.
XIII
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS OF PROMINENT VIRGINIANS
No account of Virginia's record in regard to slavery would be complete
which failed to set forth the position of her foremost men with
respect to the institution. From a mass of data we have selected the
following declarations as fairly expressive of their sentiments. We
have not recorded the views of Virginians, however worthy, who were
not by birth, training and sympathies, representative of the dominant
element of her people.
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS PRIOR TO 1810
Richard Henry Lee, speaking in the Virginia House of Burgesses 1772,
in support of a bill prohibiting the slave trade, said:
"Nor, sir, are these the only reasons to be urged against the
importation. In my opinion not the cruelties practised in the
conquest of South America, not the savage barbarity of a Saracen,
can be more big with atrocity than our cruel trade to Africa.
There
we encourage those poor ignorant people to wage eternal war against
each other; ... that by war, stealth or surprise, we Christians may
be furnished with our fellow-creatures, who are no longer to be
considered as created in the image of God as well as ourselves and
equally entitled to liberty and freedom by the great law of Nature,
but they are to be deprived forever of all the comforts of life and
to be made the most wretched of the human kind."[110]
Patrick Henry, writing on the 18th day of January, 1773, said:
"Is it not a little surprising that Christianity, whose chief
excellency consists in softening the human heart, cherishing and
improving its finer feelings, should encourage a practice so totally
repugnant to the first impressions of right and wrong? What adds to
the wonder is that this abominable practice has been introduced in
the most enlightened ages....
"Would any one believe I am the master of slaves of my own purchase!
I am drawn along by the general inconvenience of living here without
them. I will not, I cannot justify it.... I believe the time will
come when an opportunity will be offered to abolish this lamentable
evil. Everything we can do is to improve it, if it happens in our
day; if not, let us transmit to our descendants, together with our
slaves, a pity for their unhappy lot and an abhorrence for
slavery."[111]
At another time he wrote: "Our country will be peopled. The question
is, shall it be with Europeans, or Africans?... Is there a man so
degenerate as to wish to see his country the gloomy retreat of
slavery?"[112]
George Washington, writing in 1786, to Robert Morris, of Philadelphia,
after alluding to an Anti-slavery Society of Quakers in that city and
suggesting that unless their practices were discontinued, "None of
those whose misfortune it is to have slaves as attendants will visit
the city if they can possibly avoid it," continues:
"I hope it will not be conceived from these observations that it is
my wish to hold the unhappy people, who are the subjects of this
letter, in slavery. I can only say that there is not a man living
who wishes more sincerely than I do to see a plan adopted for the
abolition of it. But there is only one proper and effectual mode by
which it can be accomplished, and that is by legislative authority;
and this, as far as my suffrage will go, shall never be wanting."
Writing in the same year to John F. Mercer, he said:
"I never mean, unless some particular circumstance shall compel me
to it, to possess another slave by purchase, it being among my first
wishes to see some plan adopted by which slavery in this country may
be abolished by law."[113]
George Mason, speaking in the Virginia Convention of 1788 having the
adoption of the Federal Constitution under consideration, said:
"Mr. Chairman, this is a fatal section (Article 1, Section 9) which
has created more dangers than any other. The first clause allows the
importation of slaves for twenty years. Under the royal government
this evil was looked upon as a great oppression, and many attempts
were made to prevent it; but the interest of the African merchants
prevented its prohibition. No sooner did the Revolution take place
than it was thought of. It was one of the great causes of our
separation from Great Britain. Its exclusion has been a principal
object of this state, and most of the states in the Union.
The
augmentation of slaves weakens the state; and such a trade is
diabolical in itself and disgraceful to mankind; yet by this
constitution, it is continued for twenty years. I have ever looked
upon this as a most disgraceful thing to America. I cannot express
my detestation of it."[114]
John Tyler, Sr., speaking in the same Convention in condemnation of
the clause permitting the slave trade:
"Warmly enlarged on the impolicy, iniquity and disgracefulness of
this wicked traffic. He thought the reasons urged by gentlemen in
defense of it were inconclusive and ill-founded. It was one cause of
the complaints against British tyranny that this trade was
permitted. The Revolution had put a period to it; but now it was to
be revived. He thought nothing could justify it.... His earnest
desire was that it should be handed down to posterity that he had
opposed this wicked cause."[115]
Edmund Randolph, in 1789, wrote to Madison that he desired to go to
Philadelphia to practise law, saying, "For if I found that I could
live there I could emancipate my slaves, and thus end my days without
undergoing any anxiety about the injustice of holding them."[116]
St. George Tucker,[117] in his edition of Blackstone's Commentaries,
reviewing the origin of slavery in Virginia, and the status of the
institution at the time he writes, 1803, declares:
"Among the blessings which the Almighty hath showered on these
states, there is a large portion of the bitterest draught that ever
flowed from the cup of affliction. Whilst America hath been the land
of promise to Europeans and their descendants, it hath been the vale
of death to millions of the wretched sons of Africa....
Whilst we
adjured the God of Hosts to witness our resolution to live free, or
die; and imprecated curses on their heads who refused to unite with
us in establishing the empire of freedom, we were imposing upon our
fellowmen who differ in complexion from us, a slavery ten thousand
times more cruel than the utmost extremity of those grievances and
oppressions of which we complained."[118]
At the conclusion of his carefully prepared article showing the
efforts made by the people of Virginia during the period of British
rule to suppress the slave trade, their prompt prohibition of the
traffic immediately upon the assertion of their independence, and the
various statutes enacted to mitigate the hardships of the institution,
he uses these earnest yet almost pathetic words:
"Tedious and unentertaining as this detail may appear to all others,
a citizen of Virginia will feel some satisfaction in reading a
vindication of his country from the opprobrium, but too lavishly
bestowed upon her, of fostering slavery in her bosom, whilst she
boasts a sacred regard for the liberty of her citizens, and of
mankind in general."[119]
The foregoing quotations express the sentiments of the leading
Virginians of the Revolutionary period with respect to slavery.
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS FROM 1810-1831
The following quotations, taken from speeches and letters of the
period between 1810 and 1831, express the sentiments of men, many of
whom, though contemporaries of Washington and Mason and Henry, yet
survived them by a quarter of a century.
Jefferson, in his Notes on Virginia, wrote:
"Can the liberties of a nation be thought secure when we have
removed their only firm basis, a conviction in the minds of the
people that these liberties are of the gift of God; that they are
not violated but with His wrath? Indeed I tremble for my country
when I reflect that God is just; that His justice cannot sleep
forever."[120]
Writing in 1820 to John Holmes, he said:
"I can say with conscious truth that there is not a man on earth who
would sacrifice more than I would to relieve us from this heavy
reproach, in any practicable way. The cession of that kind of
property—for so it is misnamed—is a bagatelle which would not cost
me a second thought if, in that way, a general emancipation and
expatriation could be effected; and gradually, and with due
sacrifice, I think it might be; but as it is, we have the wolf by
the ears and can neither hold him nor safely let him go. Justice is
in one scale, and self-preservation in the other."[121]
John Tyler, in February, 1820, speaking in Congress as a
Representative from Virginia when the bill for the admission of
Missouri was under discussion, together with the amendment prohibiting
the admission of slaves into the territories, said:
"Slavery has been represented on all hands as a dark cloud and the
candor of the gentleman from Massachusetts, Mr. Whitman, drove him
to the admission that it would be well to disperse this cloud. In
this sentiment I entirely concur with him. How can you otherwise
disarm it? Will you suffer it to increase in its darkness over one
particular portion of this land till its horrors shall burst upon
it?... How is the North interested in pursuing such a course? The
man of the North is far removed from its influence; he may smile and
experience no disquietude.
But exclude this property from Missouri
by the exercise of an arbitrary power; shut it out from the
territories; and I maintain that you do not consult the interests of
this Union.
"The gentleman from Massachusetts also conceded that for which we
contend—that by diffusing this population extensively you increase
the prospects of emancipation. What enabled New York, Pennsylvania
and other states to adopt the language of universal emancipation?
Rely on it, nothing but the paucity of the number of their slaves.
That which would have been criminal in those states not to have done
would be an act of political suicide in Georgia or South Carolina to
do. By this dispersion you also ameliorate the condition of the
black man."[122]
John Randolph of Roanoke, speaking in Congress, March 2, 1826, said:
"My feelings and instincts were in opposition to slavery in every
shape; to the subjugation of one man's will to that of another; and,
from the time I read Clarkson's celebrated pamphlet, I was, I am
afraid, as mad as Clarkson himself. I read myself into this madness,
as I have read myself into some agricultural improvements; but, as
with these last, I worked myself out of them.... The disease will
run its course. It has run its course in the Northern States; it is
beginning to run its course in Maryland. The natural death of
slavery is the unprofitableness of its most expensive labor."[123]
Replying to a Northern member in Congress, in 1826, he said: "Sir, I
envy neither the head nor the heart of the man from the North who
arises here to defend slavery upon principle."[124]
Francis W. Gilmer, writing to William Wirt, from England in July,
1824, said:
"I begin to be impatient to see Virginia once more. It's more like
England than any other part of the United States—slavery non
obstanti. Remove the stain—blacker than the Ethiopian's skin, and
annihilate our political schemers and it would be the fairest realm
on which the sun ever shone."[125]
John Marshall, writing in 1826, said:
"I concur with you that nothing portends more calamity and mischief
to the Southern States than their slave population. Yet, they seem
to cherish the evil, and to view with immovable prejudice and
dislike everything which may tend to diminish it. I do not wonder
that they should resent any attempt, should one be made, to
interfere with the rights of property, but they have a feverish
jealousy of measures which may do good without the hazard of harm,
that I think very unwise."[126]
James Monroe, speaking in the Virginia Constitutional Convention on
the 2nd of November, 1829, said:
"What has been the leading spirit of this state ever since our
independence was attained? She has always declared herself in favor
of the equal rights of man. The Revolution was conducted on that
principle. Yet there was at that time a slavish population in
Virginia. We hold it in the condition in which the Revolution found
it, and what can be done with this population?... As to the
practicability of emancipating them, it can never be done by the
state itself, nor without the aid of the Union....
"Sir, what brought us together in the Revolutionary War? It was the
doctrine of equal rights. Each part of the country encouraged and
supported every other part. None took advantage of the other's
distresses. And if we find that this evil has preyed upon the vitals
of the Union and has been prejudicial to all the states where it has
existed, and is likewise repugnant to their several state
constitutions and Bills of Rights, why may we not expect that they
will unite with us in accomplishing its removal?"[127]
Benjamin Watkins Leigh, speaking in the Virginia Constitutional
Convention of 1829-30, said:
"I wish indeed that I had been born in a land where domestic and
negro slavery is unknown—no, sir,—I misrepresent myself—I do not
wish so. I shall never wish that I had been born out of
Virginia—but I wish that Providence had spared my country this
moral and political evil. It is supposed that our slave labor
enables us to live in luxury and ease, without industry, without
care. Sir, the evil of slavery is greater to the master than to the
slave.
He is interested in all their wants, all their distresses,
bound to provide for them, to care for them, to labor for them,
while they labor for him, and his labor is by no means the less
severe of the two. The relation between master and slave imposes on
the master a heavy and painful responsibility."[128]
James Madison, in 1831 wrote concerning slavery and the American
Colonization Society:
"Many circumstances of the present moment seem to concur in
brightening the prospects of the Society and cherishing the hope
that the time will come when the dreadful calamity which has so long
afflicted our country and filled so many with despair, will be
gradually removed, and by means consistent with justice, peace, and
general satisfaction; thus giving to our country the full enjoyment
of the blessings of liberty, and to the world the full benefit of
its great example."[129]
-----
Footnote 110:
Life of R. H. Lee, Lee, Vol. I, p. 18.
Footnote 111:
The True Patrick Henry, Morgan, p. 246.
Footnote 112:
Life of Patrick Henry, William Wirt Henry, Vol. I, p. 114.
Footnote 113:
The Writings of Washington, Marshall, Vol. II, p. 159.
Footnote 114:
Madison Papers, Vol. II, p. 1391.
Footnote 115:
Letters and Times of the Tylers, Tyler, Vol. I, p. 154.
Footnote 116:
Life of Edmund Randolph, Conway, p. 125.
Footnote 117:
Judge Tucker, who was professor of law at William & Mary College,
made it a part of his course of lectures to demonstrate the moral
and economic objections to slavery.
Mr. Roosevelt points out that Thomas H. Benton acquired his
deep-rooted antagonism to the institution while studying Blackstone
"as edited by the learned Virginian Judge Tucker who in an appendix
treated of and totally condemned black slavery in the United
States." (Thomas H. Benton, Roosevelt, p. 297).
Footnote 118:
Tucker's Blackstone, Vol. II, Appendix, note H., p. 31.
Footnote 119:
Idem, p. 53.
Footnote 120:
Writings of Jefferson, Ford, Vol. III, p. 267.
Footnote 121:
Idem, Vol. VII, p. 157.
Footnote 122:
Letters and Times of the Tylers, Tyler, Vol. I, p. 312.
Footnote 123:
Abridgment of Debates in Congress 1789-1856, Vol. VIII, p. 40.
Footnote 124:
American Conflict, Greeley, Vol. I, p. 109.
Footnote 125:
Kennedy's Life of Wirt, Kennedy, Vol. II, p. 188.
Footnote 126:
John Marshall, Life, Character and Judicial Services, Dillon, Vol.
I, p. 216.
Footnote 127:
Debates of Virginia Convention of 1829-30, p. 149.
Footnote 128:
Idem, p. 173.
Footnote 129:
Life of James Madison, Hunt, p. 369.
XIV
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS OF PROMINENT VIRGINIANS (Continued)
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS, 1832
The anti-slavery sentiments of prominent Virginians, expressed in the
speeches delivered in the notable debate which occurred in the
Virginia Legislature of 1832, may well be considered in a group by
themselves. The speakers were all young men and represented a later
generation than those from whom quotations have already been given.
Many of them were destined to fill important roles in the political
life of the state and some of them, with undiminished influence,
survived the period of the Civil War.
McDowell became Governor of the
state and a member of Congress; Preston was a member of Congress, a
member of President Taylor's Cabinet, and one of the leading spirits
in the Virginia Convention of 1861; Randolph was repeatedly returned
to the Legislature and was a prominent member of the Reform Convention
of 1850-51, and Faulkner was for years a member of Congress and also
Minister to France.
The position of these Virginians was significant as representative of
the widespread anti-slavery sentiments which pervaded the state.
Chandler, of Norfolk County, represented the largest slaveholding
county in Tide-water Virginia; Broadnax and Bolling, two large
slaveholding counties in the Black Belt; Randolph and Marshall,
counties in the Piedmont section; Preston, the Southwest; McDowell,
the Upper Valley, and Berry and Faulkner, the two counties in the
extreme lower end of the valley.
Thomas Marshall, of Fauquier County, speaking in the Virginia House of
Delegates, January 14th, 1832, when the subject of the gradual
abolition of slavery was under discussion, said:
"Wherefore, then, object to slavery? Because it is ruinous to the
whites, retards improvements, roots out an industrious
population—banishes the yeomanry of the country—deprives the
spinner, the weaver, the smith, the shoemaker, the carpenter, of
employment and support. The evil admits of no remedy, and it is
increasing and will continue to increase until the whole country
will be inundated by one black wave covering its whole extent, with
a few white faces here and there floating on the surface."[130]
John A. Chandler, a representative from Norfolk County, speaking on
the 17th of January in the same debate, said:
"It will be recollected, sir, that when the memorial from Charles
City was presented by the gentleman from Hanover, and when its
reference was opposed, I took occasion to observe that I believed
the people of Norfolk County would rejoice could they even in the
vista of time see some scheme for the general removal of this
curse from our land. I should have voted, sir, for its rejection
because I was desirous to see a report from the committee declaring
the slave population an evil and recommending to the people of this
commonwealth the adoption of some plan for its riddance."[131]
William H. Broadnax, speaking as a representative from the County of
Dinwiddie, on the 19th of January, in the same debate, said:
"That slavery in Virginia is an evil and a transcendent evil it
would be idle and worse than idle for any human being to doubt or
deny. It is a mildew which has blighted in its course every region
it has touched from the creation of the world. Illustrations from
the history of other countries and other times might be instructive
and profitable had we time to review them, but we have evidence
tending to the same conviction nearer at hand in the short histories
of the different states of this great confederacy which are
impressive in their admonitions and conclusive in their
character."[132]
Henry Berry, speaking as a representative from Jefferson County, on
the 20th of January, in the same debate, said:
"Sir, I believe that no cancer on the physical body was ever more
certain, steady and fatal in its progress than is this cancer on the
political body of the State of Virginia. It is eating into her very
vitals. And shall we act the part of a puny patient, suffering under
the ravages of a fatal disease, who would say the remedy is too
painful, the dose is too nauseous, I cannot bear it; who would close
his eyes in despair and give himself up to death? No, sir, I would
bear the knife and the cautery, for the sake of health. I would
never despair of the Republic.
For myself, I would abandon hope on
this subject and the state together."[133]
Charles James Faulkner, speaking as a representative from Berkeley
County, on the 20th of January, in the same debate, said:
"Wherever the voice of your people has been heard since the
agitation of this question, it has sustained your determination and
called for the present enquiry. I have heard of county meetings,
county petitions, and county memorials; I have heard from the North,
the East, and the South. They are all, with one voice, against the
continuance of slavery. None for it. The press, too, that mirror of
public sentiment, that concentrated will of a whole community, has
been heard from one extremity of the state to the other. Its power
is with us, its moral force is united, efficient and encouraging.
In
this city, the capital of the Old Dominion, the heart of the
commonwealth, which by one ventricle receives and through the other
discharges the life blood of intelligence and public spirit
throughout your empire, aye, and from a quarter and from many
quarters where such a voice was least expected its tones have been
firm, manly, and intrepid. Honor, sir, to those who dare speak the
truth in the worst of times."
In conclusion he said:
"In the language of the wise and prophetic Jefferson, 'you must
approach it, you must bear it, you must adopt some plan of
emancipation, or worse will follow.'"[134]
James McDowell, speaking as a representative from Rockbridge County,
on the 21st of January, in the same debate, said:
"Sir, you may place the slave where you please—you may dry up to
your uttermost the fountains of his feelings, the springs of his
thought—you may close upon his mind every avenue of knowledge and
cloud it over with artificial night—you may yoke him to your labors
as the ox which liveth only to work and worketh only to live—you
may put him under any process, which, without destroying his value
as a slave, will debase and crush him as a rational being—you may
do this and the idea that he was born to be free will survive it
all.
It is allied to his hope of immortality—it is the ethereal
part of his nature which oppression cannot reach; it is a torch lit
up in his soul by the hand of the Deity and never meant to be
extinguished by the hand of man."[135]
Thomas Jefferson Randolph, speaking as a representative from Albemarle
County, on the 21st of January, in the same debate, said:
"Does slavery exist in any part of civilized Europe? No, sir, in no
part of it. America is the only civilized Christian nation that
bears the opprobrium. In every other country where civilization and
Christianity have existed together they have erased it from their
codes."[136]
Philip A. Bolling, speaking as a representative from Buckingham
County, on the 25th of January, in the same debate, said:
"Mr. Speaker, it is vain for gentlemen to deny the fact that the
feelings of society are fast becoming adverse to slavery. Moral
causes which produce that feeling are on the march and will on until
the groans of slavery are heard no more in this else happy country.
Look over this world's wide page—see the rapid progress of liberal
feelings—see the shackles falling from nations who have long
writhed under the galling yoke of slavery. Liberty is going over the
whole earth, hand in hand with Christianity."[137]
-----
Footnote 130:
Virginia Slavery Debate, 1832, White, Speech of Thomas Marshall,
p. 6.
Footnote 131:
Idem, Speech of J. A. Chandler, p. 3.
Footnote 132:
Idem, Speech of William H. Broadnax, p. 10.
Footnote 133:
Idem, Speech of Henry Berry, p. 2.
Footnote 134:
Idem, Speech of C. J. Faulkner, p. 5 and p. 22.
Footnote 135:
Idem, Speech of James McDowell, p. 20.
Footnote 136:
Idem, Speech of T. J. Randolph, p. 15.
Footnote 137:
Idem, Speech of Philip A. Bolling, p. 15.
XV
THE ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS OF PROMINENT VIRGINIANS (Concluded)
The period from 1833-1860 witnessed, as we have seen, the rise and
progress of the abolition movement at the North and the growth of
pro-slavery sentiment in Virginia and the South. These conditions are
reflected in the deliverances of many prominent anti-slavery
Virginians, and by a growing indisposition on the part of others of
this element to publicly declare their sentiments or to take part in
the discussions, which, with growing bitterness, marked the times.
ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS FROM 1833-1860
George Washington Parke Custis, speaking on the 21st of January, 1833,
before the American Colonization Society, said:
"Some alarmists tell us that the slave population is to be freed.
And, sir, does any one regret that the hope is held out, that with
our own consent, we shall one day see an end of slavery? Should this
Society be, as I doubt not it will, the happy means of producing
this result, it will be renowned as having done one of the greatest
and best deeds that have blessed the world."[138]
The following extract from a speech of William C. Rives serves not
only to illustrate his anti-slavery sentiments, but the rise of the
two antagonistic parties—the Abolitionists in the North and the
Pro-slavery men in the South. The speech of Dr. Ruffner, delivered ten
years later, also indicates the same condition and the fresh
difficulties with which the cause of gradual emancipation in Virginia
was thus confronted.
William C. Rives, speaking in the United States Senate on the 6th day
of February, 1837, after deprecating the action of Mr. Webster in
presenting abolition petitions as precipitating controversy over a
subject with respect to which Congress had no jurisdiction, then
replied to the position of Mr. Calhoun, that slavery was a beneficent
institution, as follows:
"But, sir, while I have been thus prepared and determined to defend
the constitutional rights of the South at every hazard, I have not
felt myself bound to conform my understanding and conscience to the
standard of faith that has recently been set up by some gentlemen in
regard to the general question of slavery.
I have not considered it
a part of my duty as a representative from the South, to deny, as
has been done by this new school, the natural freedom and equality
of man; to contend that slavery is a positive good; that it is
inseparable from the condition of man; that it must exist in some
form or other in every political community; and that it is even an
essential ingredient in Republican government.
No, sir, I have not
thought it necessary, in order to defend the rights and institutions
of the South, to attack the great principles which lie at the
foundation of our political system, and to revert to the dogmas of
Sir Robert Filmer, exploded a century and a half ago by the immortal
works of Sidney and Locke....
"In pursuing this course I have the satisfaction of reflecting that
I follow the example of the greatest men and purest patriots who
have illustrated the annals of our country—of the Fathers of the
Republic itself.
"It never entered into their minds, while laying the foundation of
the great and glorious fabric of our free government, to contend
that domestic slavery was a positive good—a great good. Washington,
Jefferson, Madison, Marshall, the brightest names of my own state,
are known to have lamented the existence of slavery as a misfortune
and an evil to the country, and their thoughts were often anxiously,
however unavailingly, exercised in devising some scheme of safe and
practical relief, proceeding always, however, from the states which
suffered the evil....
"In following such lights as these, I feel that I sin against no
principle of republicanism, and against no safeguard of Southern
rights and Southern policy when I frankly say in answer to the
interrogatory of the gentleman from South Carolina, that I do regard
slavery as an evil—an evil not uncompensated, I know, by collateral
effects of high value on the social and intellectual character of my
countrymen; but still in the eye of religion, philanthropy and
reason, an evil."[139]
Charles Fenton Mercer, in his work, An Exposition of the Weakness and
Inefficiency of the Government of the United States, published in
1845, said:
"How shall we approach the horrid subject of slavery, the blackest
of all blots, the foulest of all deformities? Here are a people
descended from the very centre of civilization and free institutions
of Europe, bearing with them the full tide of liberal principles,
and the very cap and essence of liberty, and boasting not only of
their descent, but that they are more than worthy of their
ancestors, that have sanctioned slavery in its most abject form, and
now, by actual enumeration, have upwards of three millions of
them."[140]
R. R. Howison, the Virginia historian, in his History of Virginia,
published in 1848, alluding to slavery in the state, said:
"We apprehend that in general, the people of Virginia hold slavery
to be an enormous evil, bearing with fatal power upon their
prosperity. This sentiment has been gaining ground during many
years.... Under these circumstances, we hail with pleasure any
indications that this part of our population (the slave portion) is
decreasing in number and that the time shall come when Virginia
shall be a free state."[141]
Dr. Henry Ruffner, President of Washington College, delivered in 1847
an address which was printed in pamphlet form and widely distributed,
dealing with the subject of slavery and emancipation. Referring to the
attitude and efforts of the Abolitionists and the effect upon
anti-slavery sentiment in the state, he said:
"But, fellow-citizens, shall we suffer this meddlesome sect of
Abolitionists to blind our eyes to the evils of slavery and to tie
up our hands when the condition of the country, and the welfare of
ourselves and our children, summon us to immediate action?...
"Having failed in their first mode of action by denunciatory
pamphlets and newspapers, and by petitions to Congress, the most
violent class of Abolitionists have now formed themselves into a
political party aiming to subvert the Federal Constitution which
guarantees the rights of slaveholders, and to destroy the Federal
Union which is the glory and safeguard of us all.
Thus they have
armed against themselves every American patriot; and what is most
remarkable, they have met from the opposite extreme those Southern
politicians and ultra pro-slavery men—called 'Chivalry' and
'Nullifiers,' who so often predict and threaten a dissolution of the
Union."[142]
Matthew F. Maury, writing in 1851, said:
"I am sure you would rejoice to see the people of Virginia rise up
to-morrow and say, 'From and after a future day, say January 1st,
1855, there shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude in
Virginia.' Although this would not strike the shackle from off a
single arm nor command a single slave to go free, yet it would
relieve our own loved Virginia of that curse."[143]
Bishop William Meade in 1854, writing of slavery, said:
"While we must acknowledge that the advantage of the African trade
notwithstanding the cruelties accompanying it has been on the side
of that people both temporally and spiritually; yet we can never be
brought to believe that the introduction into, and the
multiplication of slavery in Virginia has advanced either her
religious, political, or agricultural interests. On the contrary we
are confident that it has injured all."
In 1857, alluding to the foregoing statement, he wrote:
"I have been for the last fifty years, and more especially for the
last thirty, travelling much the length and breadth of Virginia,
making observations for myself, conversing with intelligent farmers,
politicians, ministers of the gospel, and other Christians on the
subjects referred to above. ... I have not only reconsidered them
myself, but freely conversed with many sound-minded persons
concerning the views there presented; and the result has been an
increased conviction that they are correct and have been in time
past, and still are held by the great body of our citizens,
Christians, and statesmen."[144]
The statement of Howison, made in 1848—that, "in general, the people
of Virginia hold slavery to be an enormous evil, bearing with fatal
power upon their prosperity," is confirmed by these conclusions of
Bishop Meade, expressed ten years later.
Robert E. Lee writing in December, 1856, said:
"In this enlightened age, there are few, I believe, but will
acknowledge that as an institution slavery is a moral and political
evil in any country. It is useless to expatiate on its
disadvantages. I think it, however, a greater evil to the white than
to the black race, and while my feelings are strongly enlisted in
behalf of the latter, my sympathies are strongly for the former...."
"While we see the course of the final abolition of slavery is
onward, and we give it the aid of our prayers and all justifiable
means in our power, we must leave the progress as well as the result
in His hands, who sees the end and chooses to work by slow
influences."[145]
RESULTS OF ANTI-SLAVERY SENTIMENTS
If it be urged that despite the foregoing anti-slavery sentiments the
institution remained intrenched in the laws of Virginia, and supported
by a strong body of public opinion, it may be replied that the views
of these Virginians, and others of like mind, were nevertheless
productive of far-reaching and beneficent results. They were effective
in robbing slavery of many of its most abhorrent and oppressive
incidents. Under the public opinion thus generated the institution in
Virginia assumed, as a rule, the patriarchal character—master and
slave being bound by ties of mutual obligation and affection.
Many of
the legal hardships inseparable from the system were reduced to a
minimum. Thus the breaking up of families, by sale of their members,
was confined as nearly as possible to the distribution of estates and
the collection of debts by process of law. In all the category of
disreputable callings, there were none so despised as the
slave-trader. The odium descended upon his children and his children's
children.
Against the legal right to buy and sell slaves for profit,
this public sentiment lifted a strong arm, and rendered forever odious
the name of "Negro-trader." The good results of these conditions were
evidenced in the higher measure of character, courtesy and capacity,
which, as a whole, distinguished the negroes of Virginia.
NUMBER OF EMANCIPATIONS IN VIRGINIA
The position of these Virginians was also of great importance in
keeping before the mind of the people the conception that slavery was
an abnormal institution, and that with her growth in wealth and white
population, Virginia could and would free herself from what Robert E.
Lee described as "a moral and political evil." Furthermore these
sentiments were productive of an actual emancipation, the character
and extent of which has been little appreciated.
If devotion to the
cause is to be measured by the actual manumissions effected, then
Virginia's emancipators could contemplate with pride their record.
George Wythe liberated his slaves at the close of the Revolution.
Robert E. Lee, executor of George Washington Parke Custis, left his
place at the front with the Army of Northern Virginia to emancipate
the slaves of his testator as directed by the latter in his will.[146]
Between these two there stretches a long line of emancipators, who,
without compensation, liberated thousands of slaves. Mr.
Ballagh
estimates this number as high as one hundred thousand.[147] These
slaveholders incurred not only the pecuniary loss of this great
emancipation, but in many instances the expense of colonization. When,
too, it is remembered that their communities were often thus further
burdened by the problems incident to the presence of an increasing
body of freedmen, the full import of the beneficence is better
appreciated.
That many of these ex-slaves, despite statutes and the
efforts of masters and others to settle them at points beyond the
state, remained in Virginia is attested by the Federal census, from
which it appears that in 1860 there were still fifty-eight thousand
and forty-two free negroes within her borders.
-----
Footnote 138:
See Proceedings of Sixteenth Annual Meeting of American
Colonization Society, January, 1833, p. XVII.
Footnote 139:
Congressional Debates, Vol. XIII, part I, p. 717.
Footnote 140:
An Exposition of the Weakness and Inefficiency of the Government of
the United States, p. 167.
Footnote 141:
History of Virginia, Howison, Vol. II, p. 519.
Footnote 142:
The Ruffner Pamphlet, Lexington, 1847.
Footnote 143:
Life of Matthew F. Maury, Corbin, p. 131.
Footnote 144:
Old Churches, Ministers and Families of Virginia, Vol. I, pp.
89-90, note.
Footnote 145:
Life of R. E. Lee, Fitzhugh Lee, p. 64.
Footnote 146:
Will Book No. 4, p. 267, Clerk's Office, Alexandria County,
Virginia.
Footnote 147:
History of Slavery in Virginia, Ballagh, p. 144.
XVI
SPECIMENS OF DEEDS AND WILLS EMANCIPATING SLAVES
An examination of a few of the great number of deeds and wills which
are to be found on record throughout Virginia will serve to illustrate
the motives of her emancipators and the many difficulties which
confronted them. These emancipations may be grouped in three
periods,—from 1782 to 1806, from 1806 to 1833, and from 1833 to the
outbreak of the Civil War. Each of these periods had its peculiar
characteristics with reference to the problem of emancipation in
Virginia.
From 1782 to 1806 the law permitted emancipation without
qualification, and public opinion, in the state, while deploring the
existence of slavery was willing to permit the slaveholders to
control, in large measure, the times and methods of its abolition. The
period from 1806 to 1833 marked the years when anti-slavery sentiment
showed increasing strength. The antipathy, however, to the presence of
the free negro was equally pronounced and resulted in the laws which
required his removal from the state within a year after his
emancipation. This requirement invested emancipation with new,
practical, as well as ethical difficulties.
This period opened with
the act which denied to slaveholders the unqualified right of
emancipation—and it ended with the Nat Turner Insurrection and the
futile attempts of the General Assembly to successfully meet the
difficulties of the situation. The years from 1833 to 1860 were
burdened with all the difficulties of the previous periods, as well as
with the embarrassments growing out of the efforts of the
Abolitionists beyond the state and of the pro-slavery advocates within
her borders.
An examination of the following extracts from the deeds and wills of
emancipators will serve to illustrate the truth of these views.
SPECIMENS OF DEEDS AND WILLS, 1782-1806
Extract from deed of Joseph Hill, of Isle of Wight County, dated March
6th, 1783:
"I, Joseph Hill, of Isle of Wight County in Virginia, after full and
deliberate consideration, and agreeable to our Bill of Rights, am
fully persuaded that freedom is the natural life of all mankind, and
that no law, moral or divine, hath given me a just right or property
in the persons of any of my fellow-creatures, and desirous to fulfil
the injunction of our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ, by doing to
all others as I would be done by in a like situation ... do hereby
emancipate and set free all and every of the above named slaves,
&c."[148]
Extract from deed of Charles Moorman, of Campbell County, dated
September 1st, 1789:
"I, Charles Moorman, from mature consideration and the conviction of
my own mind, being fully persuaded that freedom is the natural right
of all mankind, and that no law, moral or divine, has given me a
right to or property in the persons of any of my fellow-creatures,
and being desirous to fulfil the injunction of our Lord and Saviour,
Jesus Christ, by doing to others as I would be done by—do therefore
declare that having under my care twenty-eight slaves, (naming
them), I do for myself, my heirs, executors and administrators,
hereby release unto them the said slaves all my rights, interest,
claims or pretensions of claims whatsoever to their persons or any
estate they may acquire, &c."[149]
Extracts from deeds of Robert Carter, of Westmoreland County, each
dated the 1st day of January, 1793:
"Whereas the General Assembly of the Commonwealth of Virginia did in
the year seventeen hundred and eighty-two enact a law entitled 'An
Act to Authorize the Manumission of Slaves,' know all men by these
presents that I, Robert Carter, of Nomony Hall, in the County of
Westmoreland, do under the said act for myself, my heirs, executors
and administrators, emancipate and forever set free from slavery the
following slaves." (Here follow the names of the slaves,
twenty-seven in number.)[150]
And on the same day a similar deed emancipating thirty slaves.[151]
Extract from deed of Francis Preston, of Washington County, dated the
20th day of September, 1793:
"Whereas my negro man, John (alias) John Broady, claims a promise of
freedom from his former master, General William Campbell, for his
faithful attendance on him at all times, and more particularly while
he was in the army in the last war, and I who claim the said negro,
in right of my wife, daughter of said General William Campbell,
feeling a desire to emancipate the said negro man John as well for
the fulfilment of the above mentioned promise as the gratification
of being instrumental of promoting a participation of liberty to a
fellow-creature, who by nature is entitled thereto, do by these
presents, for myself, my heirs, executors and administrators, fully
emancipate and make free, to all intents and purposes, the said
negro man John (alias) John Brody from me and my heirs
forever."[152]
Extract from the will of Richard Randolph, Jr., admitted to record in
Clerk's Office of Prince Edward County, April 8th, 1797:
"In the first place—to make retribution as far as I am able to an
unfortunate race of bondsmen over whom my ancestors have usurped and
exercised the most lawless and monstrous tyranny, and in whom my
countrymen by their iniquitous laws in contradiction of their own
Declaration of Rights ... have vested me with absolute property; ...
to exculpate myself to those who may perchance think or hear of me
after death from the black crime which otherwise would be imputed to
me of voluntarily holding the above mentioned miserable beings in
the same state of abject slavery in which I found them on receiving
my patrimony at lawful age; to impress my children with just horror
at a crime so enormous and indelible, and to adjure them in the last
words of a fond father never to participate in it ...
I do declare
that it is my will and desire, nay, most anxious wish, that my
negroes, all of them, be liberated, and I do declare them by this
writing free and emancipated to all intents and purposes
whatsoever."[153]
Extract from the will of George Washington, dated July 9th, 1799,
recorded in the Clerk's Office of Fairfax County:
"Upon the decease of my wife, it is my will and desire that all the
slaves whom I hold in my own right shall receive their freedom. To
emancipate them during her life would, though earnestly wished by
me, be attended with such insuperable difficulties on account of
their intermixture by marriage with the dower negroes as to excite
the most painful sensations, if not disagreeable consequences to the
latter, while both descriptions are in the occupancy of the same
proprietor; it not being in my power under the tenure by which the
dower negroes are held to manumit them."
The will further provides that all slaves who at the time of their
emancipation are unable, by reason of old age, bodily infirmities, or
youth, to support themselves shall be cared for out of his estate, the
testator declaring:
"I do moreover most pointedly and most solemnly enjoin it upon my
executors hereafter named, or the survivors of them, to see that
this clause respecting slaves and every part thereof be religiously
fulfilled at the epoch at which it is directed to take place without
evasion, neglect or delay, after the crops which may then be in the
ground are harvested, particularly as it re
Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence
The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.
Transcriber and production notes
TRANSCRIBER'S NOTES: The Errata following the Preface had already been corrected by the publisher in the source text used. Only obvious typographical errors were changed, including a few page numbers in the index. Unusual or inconsistent spellings were retained. Footnotes were consecutively numbered through the entire volume and placed at the ends of chapters. In the Index of the four note references the two which could be ascribed to footnotes on those pages had those footnote numbers inserted.
Front matter as received (title page, contents)
VIRGINIA'S ATTITUDE TOWARD SLAVERY AND SECESSION
------------------------------------------------------------------------
VIRGINIA'S ATTITUDE
TOWARD
SLAVERY AND SECESSION
BY
BEVERLEY B. MUNFORD
HUMANITATEM AMOREMQUE PATRIAE COLITE
NEGRO UNIVERSITIES PRESS
NEW YORK
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally published in 1909
by Longmans, Green, and Co.
Reprinted 1969 by
Negro Universities Press
A DIVISION OF GREENWOOD PUBLISHING CORP.
NEW YORK
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number 69-16579
PRINTED IN UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_TO_
MY WIFE
------------------------------------------------------------------------Header as received
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Virginia's Attitude Toward Slavery and Secession
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: Virginia's Attitude Toward Slavery and Secession
Author: Beverley B. Munford
Release date: June 18, 2014 [eBook #46026]
Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/46026
Credits: Produced by Mark C. Orton, Elizabeth Oscanyan and the
Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.netFull Project Gutenberg licence
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
States without permission and without paying copyright
royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
license, especially commercial redistribution.
START: FULL LICENSE
THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
www.gutenberg.org/license.
Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
electronic works
1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
you share it without charge with others.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
country other than the United States.
1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
beginning of this work.
1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
Gutenberg License.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
provided that:
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation.”
• You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
works.
• You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
receipt of the work.
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
forth in Section 3 below.
1.F.
1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
cannot be read by your equipment.
1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
DAMAGE.
1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
without further opportunities to fix the problem.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
remaining provisions.
1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
Defect you cause.
Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
from people in all walks of life.
Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation
Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
public support and donations to carry out its mission of
increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
status with the IRS.
The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
approach us with offers to donate.
International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
volunteer support.
Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
edition.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.
This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #46026. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.