Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis, vol. 1, parts 1 and 2.
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 44986

The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis, vol. 1, parts 1 and 2.

by Julius Stieglitz · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2014
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    PREFACE

    In venturing to add another book on Qualitative Chemical Analysis to the long list of publications on this subject, the author has been moved chiefly by the often expressed wish of students and friends to have his lectures on qualitative analysis rendered available for reference and for a wider circle of instruction. Parts I and II of the present book embody these lectures in the form to which they have developed in the course of the last sixteen years, since, in 1894, the teaching of analytical chemistry, along the lines followed, was first suggested by Ostwald's pioneer "Wissenschaftliche Grundlagen der Analytischen Chemie."

    The author believes that instruction in qualitative analysis, besides teaching analysis proper, should demand of the student a very distinct advance in the study of general chemistry, and should also, consciously, pave the way for work in quantitative analysis, if it is not, indeed, accompanied by work in that subject.

    The professional method of work, whether routine or research work of the academic or the industrial laboratory is involved, inevitably consists in first making an exhaustive study of the ‹general chemical› aspects of the subject under examination: it includes a thorough study of books of reference and of the original literature on the subject; and when the experimental work is finally undertaken, it is carried out with a critical, searching mind, which questions every observation made, every process used.

    The method of instruction in this book aims at developing these habits of the professional, productive chemist.

    For the reasons given, a rather thorough and somewhat critical study is first made (in Part I) of the fundamental general chemical principles which are most widely involved in analytical work. The applications of these principles to the subject matter of elementary qualitative analysis are then discussed (in Part II), in closest connection with the laboratory work covering the study of analytical reactions (in Part III). The material is presented, not as a finished subject, but as a growing one, with which the present generation of chemists is still busy, and which contains many important, unsolved problems of a fundamental character.

    Numerous references to standard works and to the current literature are given, of which those suitable for reading by the young student are specially designated.

    The obvious demand is thereby made on the student to aim to remain in touch with the growth of the science, after he has completed his studies under the guidance of an instructor. Finally, to arouse and develop the critical, questioning attitude of the professional chemist, referred to above, the subject matter of the laboratory work, given in Part III, is put very largely in the form of questions, which demand not only careful observation on the part of the student, but also a thoughtful interpretation of the observations made.

    In the experience of the author, although the majority of students attending his lectures had already acquired some knowledge of chemical and physical equilibrium, of the theories of solutions and of ionization and of their applications, the more exhaustive treatment of parts of these subjects and of related topics, to which a course in qualitative analysis lends itself, has been of particular benefit to them, bringing them into closer touch with the method of detailed study of a chemical topic, than the broader, more varied work of general chemistry courses usually does.

    Throughout the theoretical treatment of the subject, the attempt is made to prepare the student for a more general ‹quantitative› expression of chemical relations. For this reason, chemical and physical equilibrium constants are given and used, wherever it is possible. The author is aware that these "constants" have, in part, only a temporary standing; that more exact work will continually modify their numerical values and, probably, limit the field for their ‹rigorous› application.

    The latter facts can be impressed on the student and still the invaluable principle be inculcated in his mind, that chemistry is striving to express its relations, as far as possible, in mathematical terms, exactly as its sister science, physics, has long been doing. At the same time the treatment of physicochemical topics has been kept within the bounds set by the subject matter, and by the chemical maturity of the students addressed: it is elementary in form, and quantitative relations are used, in the main, only to elucidate qualitative facts.

    The rigorous development of the subjects presented and their elaboration from a purely physicochemical standpoint are left to advanced courses. It has been found that this method interests the better class of students in seeking such advanced courses.

    The relations of qualitative to quantitative analysis are touched upon in the theoretical treatment, where it has been feasible to do so. The laboratory methods aim also at beginning the training of students in the habit of accuracy demanded by quantitative analysis, by laying special emphasis on the methods of detecting traces of a number of the common elements and by requiring a report on the relative quantities of components found. The study of reactions is carried out, almost wholly, with solutions of known and uniform molar concentration.

    However, the actual development of quantitative accuracy is left to the instruction in the courses in quantitative analysis, in which a successful training in this direction is far more readily attained. Simultaneous courses in the two branches of analysis seem to the author to be highly desirable, whenever practicable.

    The study of quantitative analysis adds neatness of manipulation and accuracy to the work in qualitative analysis; and the latter supplies the opportunity for the further development of a student's knowledge of general chemistry, for which there is a much smaller scope in quantitative analysis courses, and thus relieves a condition where a serious pedagogical defect is likely to exist in the development of our students.

    Parts III and IV of this book are published in a separate volume, as a laboratory manual for qualitative analysis. They comprise the instructions for laboratory work introductory to systematic analysis (the study of reactions and of the analysis of groups, in Part III) and an outline for elementary systematic analysis (Part IV).

    The attempt has been made, in particular, to bring the laboratory work, which otherwise follows the usual lines of instruction in systematic analysis, ‹also into closest relations to the development of the scientific foundations of analytical chemistry›, as represented in Parts I and II.

    It is believed that the subject matter lends itself especially well to such a close interweaving of the two sides of the study, without any special loss of time to the student, and with the result, it is hoped, of a greatly increased interest on his part and an increased stimulus of the habit of scientific thought.

    The following plan of work is used by the author with his classes:

    The first section (lasting eleven weeks) of the course in qualitative analysis is started with some seven to ten (according to the ability of the class) lectures or classroom exercises, given daily, and covering the first seven or the eight chapters of Part I. At the end of the second week the laboratory work is started.

    During the remainder of this section of the course, two hours of classroom work and eight hours of laboratory work per week are required, and, in this period, Part III, comprising the first half of the laboratory manual, is studied in the laboratory in closest connection with the classroom work on Part II of the book. As far as possible, the laboratory work on a given topic ‹precedes› the classroom work. This first course is followed by an eleven weeks' course in systematic analysis, covering Part IV of the book.

    A third (graduate) course, optional for students specializing in chemistry, is offered, in which very complex commercial and natural products are analyzed and in which special attention is also given to rare elements. During this course, particular care is taken to familiarize students with other works on qualitative analysis, such as the outlines of A. A. Noyes and Bray, and the special parts of Fresenius's manual.

    Students who have been prepared in general chemistry along physicochemical lines, as represented, for instance, by Smith's textbooks, make more rapid and more easy progress in the first course than do students otherwise prepared. But the treatment of the subject is intended to make it possible for students, who have not paid particular attention to chemical equilibrium and to the modern theories of solution in their general chemistry course, to complete the course within the time limit indicated. Perhaps one-third of the students in an average class, in the past, have taken the course under these conditions and no special difficulty was encountered by them.

    In the theoretical treatment the author is particularly indebted to the original articles and to the larger works of Arrhenius, van 't Hoff, Nernst, A. A. Noyes, Ostwald, and Walker. For the systematic analytical material acknowledgment is due, in particular, to Fresenius's "Qualitative Chemical Analysis," and to the important publications by A. A. Noyes and Bray in the ‹Journal of the American Chemical Society›. Some of the excellent methods of the latter authors have been adopted outright, as indicated in the text. For some special matters the author is indebted to the texts of W.

    A. Noyes and of Böttger. Constant references to his sources of information have been made by the author, partly as a matter of acknowledgment, and more particularly to give students and teachers the opportunity for more extended, first-hand reading on any topic of interest. References suitable for college students are indicated by the addition of («Stud.»). In two or three instances, the original source of information has been forgotten and diligent search has failed to trace it. For use in preparing any future edition of the book, the author will be glad to have his attention called to the facts by authors.

    The author wishes to express here his particular appreciation of the generous assistance given him by his former colleague, Prof.

    Alexander Smith of Columbia University, whose suggestions and advice, especially in the editing of the manuscript and proof, have been invaluable. He also wishes to make grateful acknowledgment to his colleagues, Profs. H. N. McCoy, H. Schlesinger, and Dr. Edith Barnard, to Prof. L. W. Jones of the University of Cincinnati, Prof.

    E. P. Schoch of the University of Texas, Prof. B. B. Freud of Armour Institute, and Prof. W. J. Hale of the University of Michigan, who have assisted him by reading the proofs or the manuscript, or by carrying out experimental studies underlying part of the work, or in other ways. Corrections of his mistakes of omission and commission, and suggestions, will be gratefully received by the author.

    JULIUS STIEGLITZ.

    CHICAGO, ‹September, 1911›.

    CONTENTS

    PART I

    FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES

    CHAPTER PAGE

    I. INTRODUCTION 3

    II. OSMOTIC PRESSURE AND THE THEORY OF SOLUTION, I 8

    III. OSMOTIC PRESSURE AND THE THEORY OF SOLUTION, II 21

    IV. THE THEORY OF IONIZATION: IONIZATION AND ELECTRICAL

    CONDUCTIVITY 33

    V. THE THEORY OF IONIZATION, II: IONIZATION AND OSMOTIC

    PRESSURE; IONIZATION AND CHEMICAL ACTIVITY 67

    VI. CHEMICAL EQUILIBRIUM. THE LAW OF MASS ACTION 90

    VII. PHYSICAL OR HETEROGENEOUS EQUILIBRIUM.—THE COLLOIDAL

    CONDITION 118

    VIII. SIMULTANEOUS CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL EQUILIBRIUM.—THE

    SOLUBILITY- OR ION-PRODUCT 139

    PART II

    SYSTEMATIC ANALYSIS AND THE APPLICATION OF FUNDAMENTAL

    PRINCIPLES

    IX. SYSTEMATIC ANALYSIS FOR THE COMMON METAL IONS. THE IONS

    OF THE ALKALIES AND OF THE ALKALINE EARTHS. ORDER OF

    PRECIPITATION OF DIFFICULTLY SOLUBLE SALTS WITH A

    COMMON ION 157

    X. ALUMINIUM; AMPHOTERIC HYDROXIDES; HYDROLYSIS OF SALTS.
    THE ALUMINIUM AND ZINC GROUPS 171

    XI. THE COPPER AND SILVER GROUPS. PRECIPITATION WITH HYDROGEN

    SULPHIDE 199

    XII. THE COPPER AND SILVER GROUPS (‹Continued›). THE THEORY OF

    COMPLEX IONS 216

    XIII. THE ARSENIC GROUP. SULPHO-ACIDS AND SULPHO-SALTS 242

    XIV. OXIDATION AND REDUCTION REACTIONS, I 251

    XV. OXIDATION AND REDUCTION, II. OXIDATION BY OXYGEN,

    PERMANGANATES, ETC.; OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS 277

    XVI. SYSTEMATIC ANALYSIS FOR ACID IONS 299

    LIST OF REFERENCES AND THEIR ABBREVIATIONS

    NOTE.—(«Stud.») affixed to a reference indicates that the original article is recommended as suitable reading for college students taking their second year of work in chemistry.

    ‹Am. Chem. J.›—American Chemical Journal. ‹Ann. de Chim. et de Phys.›—Annales de Chimie et de Physique. ‹Ber. d. chem. Ges.›—Berichte der deutschen chemischen Gesellschaft.

    LE BLANC'S ‹Lehrbuch der Elektrochemie› (1903).

    BÖTTGER'S ‹Qualitative Analyse› (1908). ‹Compt. rend.›—Comptes rendus.

    FRESENIUS'S ‹Manual of Qualitative Chemical Analysis› (1909).

    FRESENIUS'S ‹Quantitative Chemical Analysis› (1904).

    VAN 'T HOFF'S ‹Lectures on Theoretical and Physical Chemistry› (1898).

    H. C. JONES'S ‹The Elements of Physical Chemistry›. ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›—Journal of the American Chemical Society. ‹J. Chem. Soc.› (London).—Journal of the Chemical Society (London). ‹J. of Physiology.›—Journal of Physiology. ‹J. Phys. Chem.›—Journal of Physical Chemistry. ‹J. prakt. Chem.›—Journal für praktische Chemie.

    KOHLRAUSCH UND HOLBORN'S ‹Leitvermögen der Elektrolyte› (1898).

    LANDOLT-BÖRNSTEIN-MEYERHOFFER'S ‹Physikalisch-Chemische Tabellen›. ‹Liebig's Ann.›—Liebig's Annalen der Chemie.

    NERNST'S ‹Theoretical Chemistry› (1904).

    NERNST'S ‹Theoretische Chemie› (1909).

    OSTWALD'S ‹Lehrbuch der allgemeinen Chemie› (1893).

    OSTWALD'S ‹Scientific Foundations of Analytical Chemistry› (1908).

    OSTWALD'S ‹Wissenschaftliche Grundlagen der analytischen Chemie› (1894). ‹Phil. Mag.›—Philosophical Magazine. ‹Phil. Trans. Royal Soc.›—Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society. ‹Poggendorff's Ann.›—Poggendorff's Annalen der Physik und Chemie. ‹Proc. Am. Acad.›—Proceedings of the American Academy.

    REMSEN'S ‹Inorganic Chemistry›, Advanced Course, 1904.

    SMITH'S ‹General Inorganic Chemistry› (1909).

    SMITH'S ‹General Chemistry for Colleges› (1908).

    TREADWELL'S ‹Qualitative Analyse› (1902).

    WALKER'S ‹Introduction to Physical Chemistry› (1909). ‹Wiedemann's Ann.›—Wiedemann's Annalen der Physik und Chemie. ‹Z. analyt. Chem.›—Zeitschrift für analytische Chemie. ‹Z. anorg. Chem.›—Zeitschrift für anorganische Chemie. ‹Z. für Elektrochem.›—Zeitschrift für Elektrochemie. ‹Z. phys. Chem.›—Zeitschrift für physikalische Chemie.

    QUALITATIVE CHEMICAL ANALYSIS

    PART I

    «FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES»

    CHAPTER I

    «INTRODUCTION»

    Qualitative chemical analysis is concerned with the determination of the kinds of matter present in any given substance. In its broadest sense it includes the determination of all kinds of matter, the elements, rare as well as common, and all their combinations, organic compounds as well as inorganic.

    The recognition of the presence of rare elements, such as radium, uranium, thorium, tungsten, cerium, etc., is becoming a matter of growing importance with the modern development of the subject of radioactivity and the technical exploitation of the rarer elements, and it is a common experience for an analytical chemist to be called upon to determine the presence or absence of alcohol in beverages, of formalin in milk or other foods, and not a rare experience to be obliged to make tests for the presence of alkaloids like strychnine, morphine, cocaine, or for the presence of numerous other organic compounds.

    In this book, however, we shall limit our material to the more common elements and their most important inorganic combinations, including only a few typical organic acids.

    The limitation of our experimental material will make it possible to devote special attention to the scientific principles underlying analysis, to secure a clear and definite grasp of them, and to impart with simple material such experience in the technique and methods of analysis as will train the student to apply both his theoretical and practical knowledge to any field of analysis occasion may require.

    Accurate qualitative analysis, [p004] in any field, will depend on the care taken in mastering the theoretical significance and the technique of the methods recommended for the specific problem before the analyst; the details of the methods themselves, in any problem involving more than elementary analysis, are sought and found by him as a matter of practice in suitable larger works, in monographs and in the original literature.

    With the object of suggesting this broader application of the training acquired and of cultivating the invaluable habit of the professional chemist of consulting larger works and the literature, frequent reference will be made to such larger works, and to original papers in which more special subjects of analysis or theory are elaborately treated.

    To recognize, in a substance, the presence of any element or compound, one must know its characteristic reactions, which will make it possible to distinguish it from all other elements or compounds.

    Further, in order to reach conclusions with the greatest possible speed, directness, and conclusiveness, it is usually best to carry out an examination in some systematic way, rather than in a haphazard and irregular fashion. We distinguish, accordingly, two parts in our laboratory work: first, the study of characteristic tests or ‹reactions› of the common elements and such of their compounds as are of importance in elementary analysis (Part III), and, secondly, practice in a ‹systematic› method of analysis (Part IV).

    In the study of the reactions, the way will be paved for systematic analysis, by taking the elements in the groups, which form the basis of the system of analysis employed, and by analyses of mixtures of the elements of a group immediately after the group has been studied.

    Reliable and intelligent analysis is possible only with a clear knowledge of the chemistry of the reactions used, and the chemistry of the most important typical reactions will therefore be considered (in Part II), simultaneously with the laboratory study of the reactions and of systematic analysis.

    The reactions for identifying an element or compound must bring physical evidence which can be recognized by our senses. The sense of ‹touch› is scarcely ever appealed to; perhaps the numbness or paralysis of the sense of touch imparted to the tongue or eyelid by the alkaloid cocaine and a few modern substitutes for it, and the tingling sensation produced on the tongue [p005] by aconite and its preparations, are the most important, but rare, instances of an appeal to this sense in analytical work.

    The sense of ‹taste› is also rarely used, and always with the greatest care to prevent poisonous effects. Acids and bases, bitter alkaloids, such as strychnine and brucine, sweet substances, such as cane sugar, glucose, glycerine, are instances of compounds which affect our sense of taste. In all these cases the taste is used rather as a confirmative test than as a conclusive proof of the identity of a suspected substance.

    The sense of ‹smell› is rather more useful in qualitative analysis than that of taste or of touch. Hydrogen sulphide and ammonia, unless present in traces only, readily reveal themselves by their odor. Every chemist should be familiar with the faint but very characteristic odor of hydrocyanic acid,[1] which should instantly and automatically warn him of the presence of this potent poison.

    Owing to partial decomposition by the moisture and carbonic acid absorbed from the atmosphere, alkali cyanides also give this important warning signal. Tests based on the odors of compounds are particularly valuable in the field of organic chemistry, where the sense of smell is extensively used for qualitative purposes; for instance, the pleasant smell of acetic ester, and the nauseating odor of an organic arsenic derivative, cacodyl oxide, may be used with advantage in identifying acetic acid.

    But the evidence of touch, taste, and smell is, on the whole, only occasionally available in chemical analysis—almost all the tests employed are ‹visual› ones. A small proportion of these are ‹color› tests. The color of iodine vapor or of the solution of iodine in chloroform, the colors of metallic copper or gold, of copper salts in ammoniacal solutions, of sulphides, such as the orange sulphide of antimony (‹exps.›), may be mentioned as instances, in which a test of identity depends on the observation of some characteristic color.

    But the great majority of analytical tests depend on ‹observations of changes of state›; evidence consisting in the solution of solids, the formation of precipitates, the evolution of gases, forms the most important part of the observations, [p006] on which our conclusions are based. In organic chemistry, determinations of melting-points and of boiling-points, which are very commonly used for the qualitative identification of compounds, form further instances of the application, to qualitative purposes, of observations based on changes of state.

    In very many cases, where the formation or nonformation of a precipitate is intended to be used as an indication of the presence or absence of a given substance, the precipitating agent may throw down one or more of several different precipitates, which, seen without the aid of a microscope, cannot be identified without further examination. It is, thus, commonly necessary to use a sequence of such tests for the complete identification.

    For instance, the addition of hydrochloric acid to a solution of lead, mercurous or silver nitrate will produce a white precipitate. The precipitates may be distinguished by a further examination of their solubilities: hot water will dissolve the lead chloride, ammonia readily dissolves the chloride of silver and converts the mercurous chloride into a black insoluble mixture containing finely divided mercury (‹exps.›). By the same means the chlorides, if present together, may be separated from one another and subsequently identified.

    Systematic analysis consists very largely in the use of a proper, logical sequence of such precipitation and solution reactions, and in the drawing of definite conclusions from the results obtained.

    By far the greatest part of the experimental work in qualitative analysis has to do, then, with solution and precipitation. For intelligent and accurate analytical work a clear knowledge of the nature of solution and, in particular, of the simple ‹laws governing chemical action in solution›, and of those ‹governing the formation and the solution of precipitates›, is indispensable.

    The discoveries of van 't Hoff, in 1885–8, concerning the nature of solution, and the subsequent discoveries of Arrhenius, Nernst, Ostwald and others, have advanced every branch of chemistry, but perhaps no branch has profited quite so much as the theory of analytical chemistry, which, as a result of these discoveries, for the first time, received a clear, precise and satisfying scientific formulation of its empirical processes.[2] [p007]

    On account of the fundamental importance of this modern scientific formulation of the principles of analytical chemistry for the proper understanding of our subject, we shall consider first (in Part I) the modern theories of solution, with their experimental foundations, and we shall then develop the simpler fundamental laws governing chemical action and physical changes in solution. The analytical reactions themselves will be utilized as far as possible as the material for developing these general principles, so that this study may lead to the desired grasp of the theory of analysis and yet, at the same time, advance the student's knowledge of the practice of analysis.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [1] On account of the poisonous character of this and other vapors,
    the vessel containing a substance whose odor one wishes to test is
    not brought to the nose, but a little of the vapor is carefully
    wafted towards one by a motion of the hand, the vapor being thus
    greatly diluted with air.

    [2] We owe the first modern scientific treatment of the principles
    of Analytical Chemistry to Ostwald's ‹Wissenschaftliche Grundlagen
    der analytischen Chemie›, 1894.

    [p008]

    CHAPTER II

    «OSMOTIC PRESSURE AND THE THEORY OF SOLUTION I»

    If a concentrated solution of a substance like sugar or cupric nitrate is allowed to flow into a cylinder of water (‹exp.› with cupric nitrate), we find that the outside forces—gravity—tend to draw the solution, whose specific gravity is greater than that of water, to the bottom of the cylinder. In this method of proceeding there is some inevitable mixing of the solution with the solvent, as the result of friction, but the main portion of the deep blue solution is drawn to the bottom of the vessel and forms a blue layer under the colorless water.

    A much sharper line of separation may be obtained by allowing the cupric nitrate solution to enter a cylinder of water from under the water (see Fig. 1), the great density of the nitrate solution causing it to displace the water without perceptible mixing of the two liquids (‹exp.›). If these vessels are left at rest, it may be noted, from day to day, that the copper nitrate diffuses further and further into the pure solvent, and careful examination would show that the solvent, in turn, diffuses also into the copper nitrate solution.

    The process is a very slow one, but it will continue until a solution of ‹uniform concentration› is reached, and this will be the case, whatever the shape of the vessel may be.

    If, for the moment, only the copper nitrate be considered—and what we are developing for the copper nitrate may be applied equally well, ‹mutatis mutandis›, to the diffusion of water into the copper nitrate solution—it is obvious then that copper nitrate in solution ‹diffuses in all directions›, even against the force of gravity, and it is plain also, that any object, resisting or arresting such a motion of material particles, must have a force or pressure exerted upon it.

    Whatever the ultimate [p009] cause of the motion, whether it is the result of inherent molecular velocities of the dissolved copper nitrate, or of an attraction between the solute and the solvent, or both, it is inevitable that a pressure must result from the impact of the moving solute against the solvent.[3]

    [Illustration: FIG. 1.]

    We have thus phenomena of diffusion of solutes through solvents, exactly as we have the well-known diffusion of gases, and the two phenomena are unquestionably very much alike, the solute, like the gas, tending to diffuse from the place of higher, to that of lower concentration.[4] Likewise, if a solution of uniform concentration is heated in one part and not in another, the solute,[4] like a gas under similar conditions, will move from the warmer to the colder part of the solution, as was demonstrated by Soret.[5] Without committing ourselves for the present to any given reason for the diffusion, we note that the tendency to diffusion is a fact, and we must accept the conclusion that every obstacle to such diffusion must have a ‹pressure› exerted upon it.

    Now, if a solution is separated from the pure solvent by means of a so-called ‹semipermeable membrane›, some of the results of this tendency to diffusion may be demonstrated.

    EXP. A concentrated solution of cane sugar in water, colored with some aniline dye, is enclosed in a thimble of parchment paper firmly fastened to a long narrow glass tube (see Fig. 2) and the cell is placed in a vessel of pure water. The parchment is not absolutely semipermeable, but it is approximately so, allowing the solvent, water, to pass, but being practically impervious to the solute sugar. A Schleicher and Schüll diffusion-thimble, No. 579, may be used, with advantage, as the thimble. (‹Cf.› Smith's ‹Introduction to Inorganic Chemistry›, p. 284.) [p010]

    We observe, presently, that the system is not in a condition of equilibrium; water passes through the thimble into the sugar solution and the latter expands, producing a decided difference of level, and consequently a hydrostatic pressure, between the liquid in the cell and the solvent outside of it. We may note two facts: first, that the change includes an expansion of the solute,[6] the sugar, in the solution—that is, the tendency of the solute to expand into larger volumes of the solvent is satisfied exactly as in the experiment (Fig.

    1) described above. In the second place, like all natural phenomena which proceed spontaneously, ‹the change is in the direction of equilibrium›; for when the hydrostatic pressure on the solution in the cell becomes sufficiently great, or if it is made sufficiently great at once by the application of some outside pressure, ‹a point of equilibrium is reached, at which water will pass neither into the cell nor out of it›.

    At that point, the tendency to expansion, both of the solute and of the solvent in the solution, is just overcome by the pressure on the solution.

    [Illustration: FIG. 2.]

    «Definition of Osmotic Pressure.»—‹The hydrostatic pressure which is necessary to bring the solution into equilibrium with the pure solvent, when the two are separated by a semipermeable membrane, may be defined, according to van 't Hoff, as the measure of› what is called the ‹osmotic pressure of the solution›. We note that this definition still does not commit us to any theory as to the origin of the pressure, but merely ‹formulates› an ‹experimental relation›.

    «Measurement of Osmotic Pressure.»—More perfect semipermeable membranes can be produced. These make possible quantitative measurements of the hydrostatic pressure on a solution, when equilibrium between the solution and the pure solvent [p011] has been reached. Such membranes were first used by Pfeffer. They consist of certain gelatinous precipitates, notably copper ferrocyanide.

    Films of these precipitates may be formed, under proper conditions, which are permeable to water but not to certain solutes, such as cane sugar, glucose and galactose.

    [Illustration: FIG. 3.]

    By precipitating these membranes in the pores of unglazed clay cells, especially by the process devised by Morse,[7] we may make them sufficiently strong to resist enormous pressures—some used by the Earl of Berkeley were found to withstand a pressure of 130 atmospheres. The hydrostatic pressure required to produce equilibrium may then be measured in either of two ways.

    The first method, used originally by Pfeffer and more recently by Morse and Frazer[8] and their collaborators in a wonderfully conscientious study of osmotic pressures, consists in allowing the hydrostatic pressure to establish itself by the passage of very small quantities of the solvent, through the membrane, into the tightly closed cell containing the solution. When the resulting pressure produces a condition of equilibrium, it is measured[9] by a manometer connected with the solution, much as a gas pressure may be measured (Fig.

    3).[10] This process requires considerable time for exact measurements—weeks, during which the cell must be kept at a constant temperature. The second method, which has been used by Berkeley and Hartley,[11] is very much more rapid and requires only a few hours for the measurement.

    It consists in having the pure solvent within the cell, instead of outside of it, and in [p012] exerting an external pressure on the solution outside of the cell, until a delicate manometer, communicating with the pure solvent, shows that water does not pass through the membrane in either direction—equilibrium having been reached.

    «Osmotic Pressure and the Laws of Gases.»—The work of van 't Hoff, which has proved of inestimable value to the development of chemistry, succeeded in demonstrating that, ‹for dilute solutions, the osmotic pressure›, as defined above, ‹obeys the common laws of gases›,[12]—‹that, in fact, a substance in a dilute solution has an osmotic pressure equal to the gas pressure which it would exert if it were a gas of the same volume and at the same temperature›.[13]

    Space does not permit the presentation of all the details of the evidence confirming this conclusion, but some of the most direct experimental proofs[14] will be considered. [p013]

    «Boyle's Law.»—Boyle's law for gases states that, at a constant temperature, the pressure of a gas changes inversely as its volume, or directly as its concentration. Mathematically we have ‹P› : ‹P′› = ‹V′› : ‹V› or ‹P› ‹V› = ‹P′› ‹V′› = a constant, and ‹P› : ‹P′› = ‹C› : ‹C′› or ‹P› : ‹C› = ‹P′› : ‹C′› = a constant.

    When van 't Hoff published his first paper on the subject, Pfeffer's results from the direct measurement of the osmotic pressures of cane-sugar solutions were available, and even these, although experimentally not as exact as more recent determinations, showed plainly that, at a given temperature, the osmotic pressure of a sugar solution varies directly as the concentration, or inversely as the volume containing a given weight of the sugar. At 13–16° we have:

    Concentration. Osmotic Pressure. Pressure/
    mm. Mercury. Concentration.
    1.00% 535 535
    2.00% 1016 508
    2.74% 1518 554
    4.00% 2082 521
    6.00% 3075 513

    The ratio of pressure to concentration varies irregularly round a mean value of 526, and is approximately constant. The more recent, exceedingly careful measurements of Morse and Frazer confirm the conclusion, that Boyle's law holds for the osmotic [p014] pressures of dilute solutions; they find that the osmotic pressures of glucose and of cane-sugar solutions vary directly as the concentrations of the solutions, at a constant temperature.[15]

    «Gay-Lussac's Law.»—Gay-Lussac's law for gases states that, if the volume of gas is kept constant, its pressure increases by 1 / 273 of its value for every degree above 0° C., or ‹P›{‹t›} = ‹P›{0} (1 + ‹t› / 273).

    Expressing the temperature in absolute degrees, we have more simply:

    ‹P›{‹t›} = ‹P›{0} (‹T› / 273) or P_{t} / T = ‹P›_{0} / 273 = a constant.[16]

    That is, the pressure of a gas varies directly as its absolute temperature, if the volume is kept constant.

    Pfeffer's results, on the osmotic pressure of sugar solutions at different temperatures, were not sufficiently accurate to enable van 't Hoff to use them to confirm positively the rigorous thermodynamic proof (footnote 3, p. 12), that the osmotic pressure must increase proportionally to the absolute temperature, as required by Gay-Lussac's law. But the data did show, uniformly, a marked increase of the osmotic pressure with the temperature and, frequently, excellent agreement between theory and experiment.

    More striking were the results obtained by van 't Hoff in testing the correctness of this extension of Gay-Lussac's law by means of Soret's results on the diffusion of a solute from a warmer to a colder place. It was found that the concentrations, obtained by Soret when equilibrium was reached, agreed closely with the demand that the osmotic pressures in the colder and the warmer parts of the solution should be equal, and that the osmotic pressure of a given weight of solute in a given volume should increase proportionally to the absolute temperature.

    An elevation of temperature, in a portion of a uniform solution, will increase the osmotic pressure of this part. Diffusion will follow, until the loss in concentration of the solute, and therefore the loss of osmotic pressure (Boyle's law), of the warmer part, and the increased concentration and increased pressure of the colder portion result in all parts of the solution having the same osmotic pressure. [p015] As an example, a concentration of 17.33% copper sulphate at 20° was found to be in equilibrium with a concentration of 14.03% at 80°.

    Now, if the 17.33% solution had an osmotic pressure of ‹P› mm. at 20°, a 14.03% solution at the same temperature would have a pressure of (14.03 / 17.33) × ‹P› mm. (Boyle's law), and this would increase to (14.03 / 17.33) × ‹P› × (353 / 293) mm. at 80° C., or 0.975 ‹P› mm.—a result showing that the osmotic pressure in the hot part was practically the same as that, (‹P›), in the cold part of the solution.[17]

    It is a source of great satisfaction, that the recent very exact and painstaking work of Morse and Frazer,[18] in measuring osmotic pressures directly, completely confirms this fundamentally important conclusion, that the osmotic pressure of a solution does increase proportionally to its absolute temperature.

    «The Avogadro-van 't Hoff Hypothesis.»—For chemists, the most important part of van 't Hoff's work lies in the extension of ‹the Avogadro Hypothesis› to solutions. As van 't Hoff expresses it, "equal volumes of the most different solutions, having the same osmotic pressure and the same temperature, contain the same number of dissolved molecules,—that number, namely, which would be found in the same volume of a gas at the same gas pressure and temperature."[19] [p016]

    Pfeffer's measurements, with solutions of 1 g. of sugar in 100 c.c. of water (the volume of the solution is 100.6 c.c.), were shown to prove, that the observed osmotic pressures agreed excellently with the gas pressures, calculated for the equimolar weight of hydrogen, in the same volume and at the same temperature:

    Osmotic Pressure
    Temperature. ──────────────────────────

    Found. Calculated.[20]
    Atmosphere. Atmosphere.
    6.8 0.664 0.665
    13.7 0.691 0.681
    14.2 0.671 0.682
    15.5 0.684 0.686
    22 0.721 0.701
    32 0.716 0.725
    36 0.746 0.735

    Morse's more recent and more exact results show, that the osmotic pressure of solutions of cane sugar and of glucose (corrected for the volume occupied by the sugar, see footnote, p. 15) agrees within 6% with the values demanded by van 't Hoff's theory, being about 6% larger for concentrations ranging from 0.1 to 1.0 molar. The difference of 6% is noteworthy and is probably due to secondary causes, but suggests extended investigation of its source.

    «Indirect Determinations of Osmotic Pressure.»—The experimental results given have been obtained by direct measurements of osmotic pressures with the aid of semipermeable membranes. [p017] Perfect membranes are very difficult to prepare, and membranes of this kind can be used only with a few solutes. Nature offers us, however, forms of semipermeable "walls" between solutions and pure solvents, which in many instances are perfect.

    The atmosphere, above a volatile pure solvent and a solution of a nonvolatile substance in that solvent, when both liquids are placed side by side in a closed space, would serve as a semipermeable wall: the solvent vaporizes and may pass freely from solvent to solution and ‹vice versa›, but the solute, in the case under consideration, is nonvolatile and therefore cannot pass through the atmosphere.

    The vapor pressure of a pure solvent being always found to be higher than that of a solution in this solvent, at the same temperature, the solvent would pass in such a closed space as vapor ‹from the pure solvent› and would ‹condense› in the solution; it thereby dilutes the solution and the solute, and the solvent in the solution, expand, exactly as in the absorption of a solvent by a solution through a semipermeable membrane.

    Again, the vapor pressure of a solution being lower than that of the pure solvent, the solution (of a nonvolatile solute) must be heated higher than the pure solvent, to bring both to the boiling-point; that is, there is an ‹elevation of the boiling-point›, when a nonvolatile solute is dissolved in a solvent. The solute being nonvolatile, only the solvent passes off in the process of boiling, the solute becomes ‹more concentrated›, and, according to van 't Hoff's extension of Boyle's law, the ‹osmotic pressure of the solution increases›.

    Similarly, when a solution is cooled until freezing occurs, provided the solute does not crystallize out with the solvent, the concentration of the solute is again increased, and therefore the ‹osmotic pressure› of the solution is also increased. Van 't Hoff recognized the relations existing between the freezing, boiling and vaporization of solutions, on the one hand, and the changes of their osmotic pressures on the other.

    By developing rigorously the ‹relations between the lowering of the vapor tension, the raising of the boiling-point, the lowering of the freezing-point› of a solvent by a solute ‹and the osmotic pressure of the solution›, he made it possible[21] to use [p018] extensive experimental material,[22] on the elevation of boiling-points and the lowering of freezing-points and of vapor tensions, to determine the osmotic pressures of solutions.

    The theory of the relation of osmotic pressure to gas pressure is fully confirmed by these measurements, for those cases to which it may properly be applied, namely, to sufficiently dilute solutions and such as have only negligible heats of dilution, ‹i.e.› in which dilution does not involve chemical changes.

    «Apparent Exceptions.»—Instead of discussing the vast amount of material of this kind, which agrees with van 't Hoff's theory, we may consider, more profitably, typical cases of ‹apparent exceptions›. The most important instance of this kind, the case of solutions of compounds which undergo ‹electrolytic dissociation or ionization›, will be separately discussed in the next chapter, and we shall find that van 't Hoff's great generalization is a vital element in the evidence of this important form of dissociation.

    Of other apparent exceptions, we may note the fact that some solutes seem to give "abnormally" ‹low› osmotic pressures[23] in certain solutions. For instance, benzoic acid, in benzene solutions, gives only a little more than half as great an osmotic pressure as it does in aqueous solutions of the same concentration and temperature, and as would be calculated on the basis of the Avogadro-van 't Hoff Hypothesis for a compound of the formula C_{6}H_{5}COOH and the molecular weight 122.

    But a rigorous study[24] of the distribution of benzoic acid between water and benzene, when solutions of the acid in the two solvents are shaken together until equilibrium is established (Chapter VIII), has proved that the distribution is strictly in accord with the assumption that benzoic acid, in aqueous solution, has the molecular weight 122 and the composition C_{6}H_{5}COOH, and that, in benzene solution, it has the molecular weight 244 and the composition (C_{6}H_{5}COOH){2}; only a ‹small part› of the acid (C{6}H_{5}COOH){2} is decomposed in benzene solution into the simpler molecules, of the composition C{6}H_{5}COOH.

    In other words, the simpler molecules C_{6}H_{5}COOH are ‹polymerized› or ‹associated› to form larger molecules in benzene solution, much as the gas nitrogen dioxide NO_{2} goes over more or less into the gas N_{2}O_{4}, especially at low temperatures, and as hydrogen fluoride at low temperatures has the composition H_{2}F_{2}, while at higher temperatures it is HF.

    The divergence of the benzene solutions of benzoic acid from the Avogadro-van 't Hoff principle is therefore only an ‹apparent one›, not a real one, inasmuch as the osmotic pressure of the solutions agrees perfectly with that calculated for solutions of a substance (C_{6}H_{5}COOH){2}, of molecular weight 244.

    Such associated molecules (of organic acids, alcohols, phenols, etc.) occur [p019] particularly readily in liquids of small dissociating power, like benzene, and such solutions show marked ‹absorption of heat on dilution›,[25] the dilution being accompanied by a ‹chemical change›. The associated molecules are dissociated more and more completely [(C{6}H_{5}COOH){2} ⇄ 2 C{6}H_{5}COOH], even in these solvents, as the solutions are diluted.

    Since dilution results in a ‹chemical increase› in the number of molecules, the osmotic pressure cannot decrease proportionally with the increase of volume in such a case as this. Nor does gas pressure, it must be remembered, decrease proportionally to the volume in the case of gases which show ‹chemical changes› with change of volume, ‹e.g.› in the case of nitrogen tetroxide, for which we have N_{2}O_{4} ⇄ 2 NO_{2}.

    In still other instances, apparently too high osmotic pressures, or too low molecular weights, have been found by the application of the Avogadro-van 't Hoff Hypothesis to solutions: for instance, the molecular weight of sodium, when dissolved in mercury, was found by Ramsay to vary from 21.6, in dilute, to 15.1 in concentrated solutions.

    But Cady found that the heat of dilution of sodium in mercury solution is considerable, and by taking this properly into account, Bancroft was able to show that the molecular weight, correctly calculated in a given experiment, is 22.7 (agreeing well with the theoretical weight 23), in place of 16.5, as calculated without making the required allowance for the heat of dilution.[26] These determinations are most instructive in showing that the sources of some of the most important deviations from the van 't Hoff-Avogadro principle, deviations which have been brought forward as arguments against its assumptions, are due, not to any untrustworthiness of the general principle, but to the error of neglecting to observe the limiting conditions of the formulation, or of neglecting to make corresponding corrections for the non-observance thereof.

    «Summary.»—Van 't Hoff's theory of solution—that the osmotic pressure of substances in solution obeys the laws of gases, and that equal volumes of the most varied dilute solutions, having the same temperature and osmotic pressure, contain the same number of dissolved molecules, that number, namely, which would be found in the same volume of a gas at the same temperature and gas pressure,—accords thus, not only with the demands of thermodynamics,[27] but is also, within the limits demanded by the theory itself, in agreement with the best experimental measurements of osmotic pressures that have been made in recent years.

    The apparent exceptions, as in the cases just described and, as we shall find, in the case of electrolytic dissociation, are found to be no exceptions, when the conclusions, reached on the assumption that [p020] the theory is correct, are tested rigorously by independent methods of investigation.[28]

    The fundamental laws of gases and the Avogadro Hypothesis may be condensed into the following general equation, expressing all of the laws, viz.: ‹P› ‹V› = ‹n› ‹R› ‹T›. This equation applies equally to the osmotic pressures of dilute solutions, the osmotic pressure being substituted for the gas pressure.

    In the equation, ‹T› is the absolute temperature of the gas or solution, ‹P› the gaseous or osmotic pressure, ‹V› the free space of the gas volume, ‹i.e.› the volume of the gas less the volume occupied by the gas molecules, or the volume of the pure solvent in the solution used, ‹i.e.› the volume of the solution less the volume of the solute. ‹R› is the so-called ‹gas-constant›, and represents ‹the work› done against the external pressure when one gram molecule, or mole, of the gas is heated one degree and allowed to expand, say at constant pressure ‹P›, against an external pressure ‹P›; ‹n› represents the number of gram molecules or moles of gas or solute used (the total weight of solute or gas, divided by the average weight of a mole in the gas or solute).

    If a given weight of a gas or solute is taken, and no dissociation or association occurs (such as would involve appreciable heats of dilution), then ‹n› is a given number; and, therefore, at a given temperature ‹T›, all the factors on the right side of the general equation being given numbers, ‹P› ‹V› ‹is a constant› (Boyle's law). For a given quantity of gas or solute (‹n› is a given number), kept at ‹constant volume› ‹V›, the pressure must vary as the absolute temperature (Gay-Lussac's law); ‹P› / ‹T› = ‹n› ‹R› / ‹V› = ‹a constant›.

    When the pressure, volume and temperature of two gases, or two dilute solutions, are equal, ‹n›, the number of gas or solute molecules present, must be the same (Avogadro-van 't Hoff Hypothesis); ‹n› = ‹P› ‹V› / (‹R› ‹T›), and all the factors of the right side are the same for the gases and solutions which we are comparing.

    Finally, if the pressure is expressed in atmospheres, the volume in litres, and the temperature in absolute degrees, the ‹gas-constant› ‹R› = ‹P› ‹V› / ‹T› = 1 × 22.4 / 273 = 0.082.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [3] Even after a solution of uniform concentration of the solute is
    formed, the tendency toward diffusion, and the diffusion itself,
    and the resulting pressure must still persist. But a state of
    ‹dynamic› (or flowing) ‹equilibrium› must be considered now to
    exist, the loss caused by the moving away of the solute, from a
    given part of the solution, being balanced by the diffusion (into
    that part) of the solute from the neighboring parts.

    Whether
    one ascribes the diffusion to inherent molecular velocities of
    the solute, or to an attraction between solvent and solute,
    the discrete particles of the solute in a solution of uniform
    concentration will continue to have such inherent velocities (Chap.
    III), and will also continue to be surrounded by pure solvent,
    exactly as in solutions of unequal concentrations, where the
    diffusion may be observed, because the net result, in such a case,
    is a one-sided action.

    [4] This again holds equally for the solvent.

    [5] See below.

    [6] At the same time, the change is also in the direction of an
    expansion of the ‹solvent in the solution›. The two changes are not
    opposed to each other, but supplementary.

    [7] ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «28», 1 (1902); «40», 266, 325 (1908) («Stud.»).

    [8] ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «34», 1 (1905); «36», 39 (1906); «37», 324,
    425, 558 (1907); «38», 175 (1907).

    [9] The exact concentration of the solution at the point of
    equilibrium is determined by subsequent analysis.

    [10] ‹Cf.› Smith's ‹Inorganic Chemistry›, p. 287.

    [11] Berkeley and Hartley, ‹Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc.› A, «206», 481
    (1906).

    [12] When appreciable ‹heat of dilution› is shown by a solution,
    some chemical change, resulting from dilution, is indicated (such
    as, dissociation of the solute, hydration, hydrolysis, etc.). In
    such a case, the Avogadro-van 't Hoff principle holds for each
    concentration for its actual composition, and the principle may
    often be used to determine the extent of the chemical change
    produced by dilution. But then the osmotic pressure will not obey
    Boyle's and Gay-Lussac's laws. The same exception applies also to
    gases which undergo chemical changes, as the result of dilution
    or change of temperature.

    In the case, for instance, of nitrogen
    tetroxide, which dissociates according to N_{2}O_{4} ⇄ 2 NO_{2},
    the extent of the dissociation varies with changes of concentration
    (pressure) and of temperature, and the gas does not obey the laws
    of Gay-Lussac and of Boyle. In regard to the rôle of heat of
    dilution in connection with osmotic pressure, see Bancroft, ‹J.
    Phys. Chem.›, «10», 319 (1906).

    [13] See p. «15» for a more rigorous statement concerning the
    volume. ‹Cf.› Morse and Frazer, ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «34», 1 (1905).

    [14] As a result of numerous vain endeavors, as well as of much
    direct evidence of a positive character, the scientific world has,
    for many years, held the opinion that any sort of "perpetual motion
    machine" is impossible. Every one now admits that a machine which
    would be able to work continuously, without consuming energy, is
    an impossibility—that is, that a "‹perpetuum mobile of the first
    class›," as it is called, is impossible (law of the conservation of
    energy or ‹first law› of thermodynamics).

    From this law it does not
    of necessity follow, however, that it would be impossible to make a
    machine or device that would convert ‹continuously› into available
    energy or work, say, the enormous amounts of heat energy of the
    earth or of large bodies of water ("dissipated energy") which would
    thereby be ‹cooled below› the temperatures of their surroundings.
    Such a hypothetical process has been termed a "‹perpetuum mobile of
    the second class›"; it has never been realized and is universally
    conceded to be an impossibility; the so-called "‹second law› of
    thermodynamics" gives expression to this fact.

    Now van 't Hoff [‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «1», 481 (1887)] showed, first,
    that a gas like oxygen, nitrogen, hydrogen, etc., which is soluble
    in proportion to its gas pressure (Henry's law), must exert, in
    solution, an osmotic pressure equal to the gas pressure, which it
    would have, if present in the same quantity as a gas in the same
    volume at the same temperature; for, if such were not the case,
    the solution and gas could be used to produce a ‹perpetuum mobile
    of the second class›, which, according to the above law, is an
    impossibility. Similar proofs were given by Rayleigh [‹Nature›,
    «55», 253 (1897)] and by Larmor [‹Phil.

    Trans.›, «190», 266 (1897),
    ‹Nature›, «55», 545 (1897)] that the principle applies to solutions
    of other solutes.

    Provided, then, that we have (1) perfect semipermeable membranes,
    (2) sufficiently dilute solutions, and (3) none but negligible
    heats of dilution (p. 12), van 't Hoff's generalization, concerning
    the relation of osmotic pressure and the laws of gases, must hold,
    if the ‹perpetuum mobile of the second class› is impossible, as is
    demanded by the second law of thermodynamics.

    [15] See p. 15 in regard to the relation for concentrated solutions.

    [16] The pressure ‹P›{0} of a given quantity (weight) of a gas
    at 0° C., in a given constant volume, is also a given number and
    consequently ‹P›
    {0}/273 is a constant under these conditions.

    [17] The slight differences in the ionization of copper sulphate
    solutions of 14% and 17% and at 20° and 80° are not included in the
    calculation, ionization being unknown, when van 't Hoff made his
    calculations.

    [18] ‹Am. Chem. J.›, 41, 258 (1909).

    [19] In the light of recent work, especially by Morse and Frazer,
    the law would state, more exactly, that a substance in solution
    produces the osmotic pressure, at a given temperature, which
    it would exert, if it were contained as a gas, at the same
    temperature, ‹in the volume occupied by the pure solvent› of the
    solution.

    For sufficiently dilute solutions, the volume of the
    solution and the volume of the solvent may be considered identical;
    for more concentrated solutions, there is a decided difference,
    and the correct volume to use in calculation is the volume of the
    solvent alone, ‹i.e.› the volume of the solution reduced by the
    volume of the pure solute.

    This corresponds to the correction of
    the volume in the more accurate expression for the behavior of
    gases, developed by van der Waals; in place of ‹v›, the total
    gas volume, (‹v› − ‹b›), the total volume of the gas less the
    volume of the spheres of action of the gas particles, is used,
    especially for strongly compressed or concentrated gases. It may
    be added that van 't Hoff's thermodynamic proof involves the same
    correct definition of the volume that Morse and Frazer subsequently
    developed experimentally. ‹Cf.› Bancroft, ‹J. Phys. Chem.›, «10»,
    319 (1906).

    [20] One gram of cane sugar, C_{12}H_{22}O_{11} (the mol.
    wt. is 342) corresponds to 1 / 342 gram molecule or mole
    and, therefore, to 2.02 / 342 gram of hydrogen. The volume
    containing this quantity of hydrogen is 100.6 c.c.; a liter
    would contain 2.02 / 342 × 1000 / 100.6 gram of hydrogen.
    The pressure of a mole or 2.02 grams of hydrogen, contained
    in a liter at 0°, is 22.4 atmospheres, and the pressure of
    the quantity of hydrogen given above, in a liter, would be
    (2.02 × 1000) / (342 × 100.6) × (22.4 / 2.02) at 0°.

    At 36°
    C., for instance, the pressure would be 309 / 273 times as
    great, or ‹P›_{calculated} = (2.02 × 1000 × 22.4 × 309) /
    (342 × 100.6 × 2.02 × 273) = 0.735 atmosphere.

    [21] The exact relations are discussed in van 't Hoff's ‹Lectures
    on Physical Chemistry›, Part II, pp. 42–59, Nernst's ‹Theoretical
    Chemistry› (1904), pp. 142 and 148, and H. C. Jones's ‹The Elements
    of Physical Chemistry› (1909), pp. 252, 271.

    [22] ‹Vide› Raoult, ‹Scientific Memoir Series›, «4», 71, 127.

    [23] ‹I.e.› abnormally small depressions of freezing-points or
    elevations of boiling-points.

    [24] Nernst, ‹Theoretical Chemistry›, p. 486; Hendrixson, ‹Z.
    anorg. Chem.›, «13», 73 (1897).

    [25] ‹Cf.› Bancroft, ‹J. Phys. Chem.›, «10», 319 (1906).

    [26] For the discussion of other instances, ‹vide› Bancroft, ‹loc.
    cit.›

    [27] Footnote 3, p. 12.

    [28] For example, determinations of distribution coefficients
    (p. 18), heats of dilution (p. 19), conductivities and chemical
    activity (Chapters IV–VI).

    [p021]

    CHAPTER III

    «OSMOTIC PRESSURE AND THE THEORY OF SOLUTION II»

    Accepting van 't Hoff's theory of solutions, then, as based on experimental evidence as well as on sound thermodynamic reasoning, we find a number of interesting questions still confronting us.

    Most insistent is the question as to the source of the remarkable agreement between the osmotic pressure of a solute and the gas pressure, which it would exert in the same volume, as a gas, at the same temperature, and as to the identity of the laws governing the two forms of pressure. Then, we may also ask, what is the mechanism of the process by which osmotic pressure reveals itself, especially in the case of cells with semipermeable membranes. And, finally, we may ask what is the cause of the semipermeability of the membranes.

    «Semipermeability.»—Taking up the last question first, as the simplest one, we find that it was long ago recognized that permeability depends on the power of membranes to dissolve certain substances, or to form unstable combinations with them. A membrane is semipermeable if it will dissolve one component only of a solution, the solute or the solvent, and not the other.[29]

    We find the simplest evidence of the cause of semipermeability in the case of gases. Palladium, especially when heated, dissolves hydrogen readily, but not nitrogen or oxygen, and a wall of palladium may be used as a semipermeable membrane to separate a mixture of hydrogen and nitrogen from pure hydrogen, just as copper ferrocyanide membranes are used with aqueous sugar solutions and water. The results with the gases duplicate in every particular the observations made on the solutions (see below, p. 24).

    Certain gases, such as ammonia and hydrogen chloride, are easily soluble in water, while others, like oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen, are very difficultly soluble, and a film of [p022] water may be used as a semipermeable membrane for such gases.[30]

    EXP. If the moist membrane of a cell (Fig. 4), containing air, is covered with an atmosphere of hydrogen, there is no increase of pressure produced in the cell, as indicated by the column of colored oil in the manometer in which the cell ends: hydrogen, being very little soluble in water, cannot pass through the film of water in the few minutes it is allowed to act. If now an atmosphere of ammonia is substituted for the hydrogen, the gas passes through the film into the cell. It turns the color of a piece of litmus paper placed in the cell and produces an increased pressure in the cell, the air remaining in the latter, because oxygen and nitrogen are very little soluble in water.

    [Illustration: FIG. 4.]

    Membranes will be, similarly, semipermeable to solvent or solute, when only one of these is soluble in the membrane, or is capable of forming an unstable compound with it. For instance, salts, holding water of crystallization which is readily lost and recovered, may easily be conceived of as assuming the rôle of semipermeable membranes, allowing the passage of water say from a wet atmosphere to a dry one, or from pure water to a solution; and Tammann[31] has realized such membranes by the use of zeolites—silicates, which hold water of crystallization but are insoluble in water.

    Kahlenberg[32] has recently used rubber membranes, that are permeable for solvents like benzene, pyridine, etc., which are soluble in rubber, but not permeable for water, which is insoluble in rubber.

    [Illustration: FIG. 5.]

    «Osmosis.»—The recognition of this rôle of the semipermeable membrane leads to the second question raised, namely as to the mechanism of the process by means of which osmotic pressures are measured directly with the aid of such membranes (p. 11).

    [p023] The answer hinges on the question of the mechanism of the diffusion of the solvent into the cell, a diffusion which is called its osmosis.[33] If we consider the pure solvent, say water, on one side of a semipermeable membrane, and a solution (‹e.g.› of sugar in water) on the other side, it is obvious that the ‹solvent› itself has a ‹higher concentration› on the side where it is pure, than on the side of the solution, where it is diluted—distended by the solute in it.

    The solvent is soluble in the membrane, and its solubility will be proportional[34] to its own (the solvent's) concentration; it will, consequently, be more soluble in the membrane on the side of the pure solvent than on the side of the solution. If we bring such a membrane first into contact with the pure solvent (Fig. 5), the membrane will take up the solvent (from the side ‹A›) until it is ‹saturated› with it. Let the solubility, which represents the concentration of the solvent in the membrane at this stage, be called ‹c›.

    The membrane may then be considered to be taking up in unit time just as many molecules from the solvent as it gives up to it (dynamic equilibrium), exactly as, when water is in equilibrium with water vapor, we consider the water to be vaporizing just as fast as vapor is condensing to form water. Now, if a solution of sugar is placed on the other side of the membrane, the solvent will pass out of the membrane into the solution just as fast as it passes back into the pure solvent.

    At first the concentration of the solvent on the surface ‹B› of the membrane is just as great (‹c›) as on the surface ‹A›; but ‹the membrane will here receive the solvent more slowly from the solution, which is less concentrated as to the solvent›; and consequently the membrane ‹will lose water to the solution›.

    The solubility (‹c′›) of the solvent at this surface ‹B› of the membrane, corresponding to the smaller concentration of the solvent in the solution, will be less than the solubility (‹c›) at ‹A›, where the membrane is in contact with the pure solvent, and water will pass into the solution at ‹B›, until the concentration of the water in the membrane at ‹B› has fallen [p024] from (‹c›) to (‹c′›).

    In such a membrane, as in every solution or gas, there must be a tendency towards the establishing of uniform concentration by diffusion from points of higher concentration to those of lower, and the solvent will, therefore, ‹diffuse from points along the surface A of the membrane to points along the surface B›; the surface ‹A› will become ‹unsaturated› and will take up solvent from the pure liquid bathing it, and the surface ‹B› will be kept continuously supersaturated and will lose solvent continually to the solution.

    Consequently, the solvent will pass continuously through the membrane from the pure solvent to the solution. Equilibrium will be reached, and the flow will cease, only ‹when the solution has become infinitely dilute›, equal hydrostatic pressure obtaining on solution and solvent, or ‹when the disturbing influence of the solute, which dilutes the solvent in the solution, is exactly counterbalanced by an external hydrostatic pressure, exerted on the solution›.

    When such a pressure on the surface of the solution balances the force exerted against the solvent by the solute we shall have equilibrium. It is clear, then, that the ‹osmosis›, or passage of the solvent through the membrane, is brought about by the unequal concentrations (or, more exactly, the resulting ‹unequal partial pressures›) ‹of the solvent itself.

    But this inequality is produced by the presence of the solute, and it is a characteristic and significant fact, that the effect of the latter, in dilute solutions, may be overcome by a hydrostatic pressure, corresponding to the gas pressure which the same number of molecules of a gas in the same volume at the same temperature would exert against this hydrostatic pressure›.

    [Illustration: FIG. 6.]

    «Osmosis and Gas Pressure.»—The legitimacy of the interpretation given is most strikingly shown by experiments with a membrane, semipermeable for gases, which enables us to measure gas pressures, that may be unknown, by exactly the same process as is used to measure the unknown osmotic pressure of a solute in solution. Van 't Hoff[35] and Arrhenius[36] predicted such a result, and Ramsay[37] proved by experiment the correctness of their assumptions.

    A mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen may be enclosed in a palladium vessel connected with a manometer (see Fig. 6).[38] The partial pressure ‹P›{‹N›} of the nitrogen may be [p025] determined by surrounding the palladium vessel with pure hydrogen, at a pressure which is known and is greater than the partial pressure of the hydrogen in the vessel, and by observing the final total gas pressure which is obtained in the vessel.

    The hydrogen diffuses from the point of higher concentration, outside of the vessel, through the palladium, into the interior where the concentration of the hydrogen is lower. The experiment may be carried out at 280°, a temperature at which palladium readily dissolves hydrogen and is permeable to it. The metal does not dissolve nitrogen and is not permeable to it.

    The volume of the enclosed gas is kept constant by raising the mercury level in the outside arm of the manometer, and the total pressure of the enclosed gas is measured when equilibrium is reached. If this total pressure is ‹P›{final} and the known pressure of the hydrogen outside of the vessel is ‹P›{‹H›}, then, if equilibrium is reached when the hydrogen on both sides of the semipermeable palladium membrane has the same concentration (pressure), ‹P›{‹H›} + ‹P›{‹N›} = ‹P›{final} and ‹P›{‹N›} = ‹P›{final} − ‹P›_{‹H›}.

    In other words, the excess of the final combined pressure inside, over the outside pressure of the hydrogen, ‹is equal to the pressure of the nitrogen in the vessel›.

    Ramsay's results showed that the amount of hydrogen actually entering the vessel was 90–97% of the amount predicted by the theory on the basis of the assumption that equilibrium will be reached, when the hydrogen has the same concentration (pressure) on both sides of the palladium membrane.

    The experiment is particularly instructive, in the first place, because it illustrates with a gas, subject to the laws of gases, why and how osmosis takes place through a semipermeable membrane—namely as a result of the solubility of the diffusing substance in the membrane, and through the flow of the diffusing substance [p026] from higher to lower concentrations.

    In the second place, while the increase in total pressure in the inner chamber undoubtedly is ‹brought about› by the ‹osmosis› of ‹hydrogen› into the chamber, the excess pressure when equilibrium has been reached, necessarily measures accurately the partial pressure of the ‹nitrogen›.

    In other words, the semipermeable membrane is merely a means or ‹device for measuring› the partial pressure of the nitrogen—the membrane is not the ‹cause› of the pressure; the latter is a definite one, whether we know what it is or not, and the osmosis of the hydrogen through the palladium merely gives us a means of ascertaining it.

    Similarly, it would be wrong to consider that the osmotic pressure of a solution is caused, or brought about, by the flow of the solvent through a semipermeable membrane (osmosis); the latter simply is a ‹device› which enables us to recognize and ‹measure› the pressure that exists in the solution, both in the presence and the absence of such a membrane.

    We may consider, then, that the osmosis, or migration of the solvent through a semipermeable membrane into a solution, is the result of the reduced concentration (or ‹partial pressure›) of the solvent in the solution, resulting from the presence of the solute.

    Inasmuch as the ‹effect› of the ‹solute› on the solvent can be overcome by a ‹pressure› on the surface of the solution, one is led to the conclusion that the solute acts by exerting, in turn, ‹a force or pressure› against the surfaces of the solvent, in the directions opposite to the hydrostatic pressure required to overcome it.

    The significant identity of the value of this pressure, as thus measured, with the gas pressure that would be exerted by a gas of the same number of molecules, in the same volume and at the same temperature, leads us to the last of the three questions which have been raised, namely, the question concerning the theory of the intimate relations between gas and osmotic pressures (p. 21).

    «The Kinetic Theory and Osmotic Pressure.»—For an answer to this fundamentally interesting theoretical question one turns, naturally, to the kinetic theory, which, in the hands of Clausius, Joule, van der Waals and others, has given us a very satisfactory and essentially complete theoretical interpretation of the behavior of gases, and of the liquids to which they may be compressed.

    The laws of gases, it is known, are in accord with the two simple assumptions of the kinetic theory. The first assumption is that [p027] gases consist of ultimate discrete particles (molecules), which move in all directions through the space filled by the gas and, at ordinary pressures, are so far apart, that the forces of molecular attraction between them are negligible; the ‹pressure› of the gas is simply the net result of the impacts of these flying particles upon the walls of the containing vessel.

    The second assumption of the kinetic theory is that ‹temperature› is a function of the mean kinetic energy of the moving molecules, and that the molecules of gases of the same temperature have the same mean kinetic energy. The kinetic energy of particles is a function of their mass ‹m› and their velocity ‹u› (K.E. = ½ ‹m› ‹u›^2). When a gas is heated, the kinetic energy of its molecules is increased, and, since their masses remain unchanged, their velocity must increase.

    As a result, the number and the force of their impacts against the walls of a given space increase, and thus the pressure is increased.

    We may ask, whether this theory cannot be used to explain the connection between osmotic and gaseous pressure.

    If temperature is a function of the kinetic energy of the molecules of which a substance consists,—and the whole behavior of gases confirms such a conception,—then one must conclude, that the mean kinetic energy of molecules, at a given temperature, must always be the same, irrespective of whether they are present in gaseous, or liquid, or solid form, or even in solution.[39] The tendency of the molecules to move, resulting from the kinetic energy inherent at a given temperature, may be largely balanced (liquids), or overcome (solids), by molecular attractions of surrounding particles, but such conditions are altogether in harmony with the conception of a definite mean molecular kinetic energy, persisting at a given temperature, irrespective of the physical surroundings of the molecule.

    According to the kinetic theory, then, when we have a dilute solution, say of alcohol in water, the molecules of alcohol, at a given temperature, would have a given mean kinetic energy, [p028] and would be tending to move in all directions with a mass[40] and velocity, the same as if the alcohol were present as a gas or vapor at the same temperature. If the solution is sufficiently dilute, the dissolved alcohol molecules are sufficiently far apart, for average time, to make the molecular attractions between them negligible, just as is assumed for gases.

    As far as the alcohol (solute) molecules alone are concerned, they may, evidently, be assumed to be present in the solution, in the same condition, as to number, mean kinetic energy and mean velocity, as they would be in alcohol vapor of the same concentration and temperature. We may ask, now, whether the osmotic pressure of the solution may not result from the pressure on the solvent, growing out of its bombardment by the solute molecules.

    And we may ask, further, what numerical relation would subsist between such a pressure and the pressure of the solute, if the latter were present as a gas, under the same conditions of temperature and concentration. In order to be prepared to answer these questions, we must consider, in what way the presence of the solvent must modify the motions and the forces of impact of solute molecules.

    One great difference between the dissolved substance and the gas would be, that, in the solution, the solute is in intimate contact with the ‹solvent›. A decided attraction must exist between the solute molecules and the solvent molecules, since we could not otherwise understand how a solvent, like water, in dissolving a nonvolatile substance like sugar, could overcome those molecular attractions between the sugar molecules, which make sugar a solid.

    But we note, that all the solute molecules in a solution, except those at the surface, are surrounded on all sides equally by the solvent. The attractive forces, exerted upon the single molecules of the solute by the solvent molecules, thus sum up to ‹zero›, and need not be considered further. Only the small number of solute molecules, which are at the surface of the liquid, would involve a minor correction in the application of the kinetic theory, and this need not be considered here.

    A second point of difference between a substance in solution, and the same substance as a gas or vapor at the same temperature [p029] in the same volume, lies in the fact that a gas molecule will go a much greater distance without colliding with some second molecule and changing its path, than would a solute molecule, the latter molecule being closely surrounded by the molecules of the solvent.

    The mean ‹free path›, as it is called, will be very much shorter for a solute molecule than for a gas molecule, and we note, as a matter of fact, how slow is the diffusion through a solvent (see ‹exp.› p. 8). But the shortness of the previous path ‹does not affect the force of a blow resulting from the impact of a moving mass›, the force of the impact being dependent only on the mass and the change in speed of the striking particle, at the moment of impact.

    Thus the short free mean path of a dissolved molecule does not affect the mean ‹force› of the blow, ‹delivered when it strikes the resisting medium›.

    The slow diffusion of a dissolved substance represents a difference in degree, not in kind, between gases and dissolved substances. Even in gases, we have such frequent collisions that the mean free path of an oxygen molecule at 0° and atmospheric pressure is only 0.00001 cm., whereas the velocity, the total path covered in one second, is 42,500 cm.

    EXP. If a bulb containing a few drops of bromine is broken at the bottom of a tall cylinder, the bromine vapor is seen to diffuse rather slowly into the upper part of the cylinder, the bromine molecules, in their passage upward, rebounding from the air molecules, with which the cylinder is filled. If a second cylinder is first evacuated, and the bromine bulb is broken ‹in vacuo›, the vapor is seen to fill the cylinder instantly, the high velocity of the bromine molecules being thus revealed.

    But a third question, of fundamental importance in the comparison of the condition of a substance existing as a gas and its condition in a solution of the same concentration and temperature, results from a consideration of the ‹frequency of the impacts› of the solute molecules against the solvent, growing out of the reduction of the lengths of the mean free paths of the solute molecules.[41] In order to be able to take this fact properly into account, it will be necessary to consider somewhat more precisely the manner in which, according to the kinetic theory, gas pressure is produced.

    We may consider that we have in a cube of unit volume (1 c.c.) ‹n› molecules of a gas, each of mass ‹m› and average velocity ‹u› cm. per second. We may assume that one-third of the total number [p030] of molecules moves in each of the three dimensional directions.[42] A single molecule of mass ‹m›, striking the surface with a velocity ‹u› and rebounding with the same velocity in the opposite direction, will exert on the surface a force of 2 ‹m› ‹u› units.

    But, with a velocity of ‹u› cm. per second, it will reach the opposite wall and return to the surface we are considering, ‹u› / 2 times in one second. A single molecule will consequently exert a force 2 ‹m› ‹u› × ‹u› / 2 or ‹m› ‹u›^2 on the surface, and the ‹n› / 3 molecules moving in the same direction will exert a force ‹n› / 3 × ‹m› ‹u›^2 on the unit surface. This represents, therefore, the pressure of such a gas, as calculated on the basis of the assumptions of the kinetic theory.

    Now, when a gas is so strongly compressed, that the bulk of the molecules is not negligible in comparison with the total volume of the gas, the number of impacts on unit surface in unit time becomes sensibly greater than ‹n› / 3 × ‹u› / 2, since the distance to be covered between successive blows on the surface will be sensibly less than 2 cm., in a cube of unit volume. If we imagine, for the sake of a rough illustration, that one-third of the molecules in 1 c.c. are united into one spherical mass (indicated by A in Fig.

    7), moving upwards and downwards, it is obvious that the distance covered between two successive blows on a surface is not 2 cm., but that distance diminished by twice the diameter of the sphere. For strongly compressed gases, the total number of impacts on unit surface is therefore sensibly greater than ‹n› / 3 × ‹u› / 2, and the pressure is proportionately greater. According to van der Waal's correction for this effect, ‹P› = ‹n› / 3 × ‹m› ‹u›^2 / (1 − ‹b›), where ‹b› represents the volume actually occupied by the molecules in 1 c.c. of the gas.[43]

    [Illustration: FIG. 7.]

    Now, for solute molecules, the "free space" of movement, as we may call it, is, similarly, very considerably reduced by the presence [p031] of the solvent, and the reduction of this free space, as Nernst has shown, will have the same effect on the pressure produced against unit surface of the solvent by the bombardment of the solvent by the solute, as the reduction of the free space has on the gas pressure when a gas is strongly compressed.

    The resulting pressure on unit surface of the solution must thus be increased, from the pressure ‹P›{gas}, which would be exerted by the solute against the walls of a vessel, if it were present as a gas of the same concentration, at the same temperature, to ‹P›{gas} / (1 − ‹v›), where ‹v› represents the real volume occupied by the solvent and (1 − ‹v›) the ‹free space› for the solute molecules ‹in unit volume› of solution.[44] If osmotic pressure is the result of such a bombardment of the solvent by the molecules of the solute, one might, therefore, expect to find the osmotic pressure ‹very much greater› than the gas pressure of the same substance in the same volume at the same temperature.

    However, in all the ‹experimental determinations› (by means of semipermeable membrane, vapor pressure, boiling-point and freezing-point measurements) of the osmotic pressure as defined on p. 10, this ‹corrective factor cancels› out again.[45] ‹According to the kinetic theory›, the osmotic pressure of a substance in ‹dilute solution should, consequently, be found by experiment to be equal to the gas pressure which a gas, of the same molecular concentration, would exert at the same temperature›.[46]

    We find thus that the significant coincidence between the osmotic pressure of a substance in dilute solution, as defined and measured according to van 't Hoff, and the gas pressure which the substance would exert, if it were present as a gas in the same volume and at the same temperature, is in agreement with the fundamental assumptions of the kinetic theory. This theory, consequently, gives us an adequate theoretical explanation of [p032] osmotic pressure, as it does of gas pressure.

    As van 't Hoff says,[47] "if the osmotic pressure follows Gay-Lussac's law and is proportional to the absolute temperature, then, like gas pressure, it will become zero at 0° absolute temperature and will vanish when molecular movements come to rest. It is therefore natural to look for the cause of osmotic pressure in kinetic phenomena and not in attractions."[48]

    FOOTNOTES:

    [29] L'Hermite, ‹Compt. rend.›, «39», 1177 (1854); van 't Hoff,
    ‹Lectures on Physical Chemistry›, ‹Part II›, p. 37.

    [30] Nernst, ‹Theoretical Chemistry›, p. 103.

    [31] Van 't Hoff, ‹Lectures on Physical Chemistry, Part II›, p. 37.

    [32] ‹J. Phys. Chem.›, «10», 141 (1906).

    [33] This term ‹must not be confounded with the term osmotic
    pressure›, which has been defined on p. 10.

    [34] See Chapter VII on the law of physical or heterogeneous
    equilibrium, where the relations are discussed in detail.

    [35] ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «5», 175 (1890).

    [36] ‹Ibid.›, «3», 119 (1889).

    [37] ‹Phil. Mag.›, «38», 206 (1894).

    [38] ‹Cf.› van 't Hoff's ‹Lectures on Physical Chemistry›, Vol. II,
    40 (1899).

    [39] The molecules may have different masses in the different
    conditions, and the principle of the mean kinetic energy would
    always apply to them as ‹they are›, in the condition under
    observation, and not as they are in some other condition; any
    change in mass, in solution, for instance, would show itself in
    the osmotic pressure measurements (see p. 18), just as it is
    shown in the measurements of gases, when the gas molecules show
    a change in composition, as is the case with hydrogen fluoride
    (H_{2}F_{2} ⇄ 2 HF), nitrogen tetroxide (N_{2}O_{4} ⇄ 2 NO_{2}),
    phosphorus pentachloride (PCl_{5} ⇄ PCl_{3} + Cl_{2}) and other
    compounds.

    [40] The molecular weight of alcohol in dilute aqueous solution is
    the same (46) as in vapor form. Raoult, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «27»,
    656; Loomis, ‹ibid.›, «32», 592.

    [41] Nernst, ‹Theoretical Chemistry›, p. 245.

    [42] This assumption is not made in the rigorous development of the
    above relations on the basis of the kinetic theory, but it leads to
    the same net result.

    [43] Even for gases of ordinary concentration, the introduction
    of the same correction gives an expression for the relation of
    pressure and volume, which is more exact than Boyle's law and is
    used in all exact calculations with gases.

    [44] One may imagine, first, ‹n› molecules of the solute as
    a ‹gas›, with the pressure ‹P›{gas}, in 1 c.c. Then, one
    may imagine, crudely, the ‹n› molecules of solute, in a free
    (gas) space of (1 − ‹v›) c.c., in the center of 1 c.c. of the
    solvent, and exerting by their impacts a pressure ‹P›
    {osm.},
    against the solvent. According to Boyle's law, we should then
    have, ‹P›{gas} × 1 = ‹P›{osm.} × (1 − ‹v›), and therefore
    ‹P›{osm.} = ‹P›{gas} / (1 − ‹v›).

    [45] ‹Vide› Nernst, ‹Theoretical Chemistry›, p. 245, for the
    detailed discussion of this relation.

    [46] This conclusion is reached more rigorously and more simply by
    thermodynamic analysis.

    [47] ‹Lectures on Physical Chemistry›, Part II, p. 35.

    [48] Rigorous developments of the relations between solute and
    solvent, for dilute and concentrated solutions, have been made
    by van der Waals, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «5», 133 (1890); van Laar,
    ‹ibid.›, «15», 457 (1894); G. N. Lewis, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «30»,
    675 (1908), and Washburn, ‹ibid.›, «32», 653 (1910). An admirable
    review of the theories of osmotic pressure, by Lovelace, will be
    found in the ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «39», 546 (1908) («Stud.»).

    [p033]

    CHAPTER IV

    «THE THEORY OF IONIZATION; IONIZATION AND ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITY»

    Of the laws and hypotheses concerning gases, the one that is perhaps of most importance to chemistry is Avogadro's hypothesis. With the aid of this hypothesis, we are able to determine the relative molecular weights[49] of such elements and compounds as are gases, or are volatile at higher temperatures. If equal volumes of gases, under the same conditions of temperature and pressure, contain the same number of molecules, then the weights of such equal volumes also represent the relative weights of the molecules composing the gases.

    As a standard, for expressing the relative molecular weights in definite numbers, the molecular weight of oxygen is taken by convention to be 32, and all other molecular weights are expressed in terms of this standard. The density, or weight of one liter of oxygen at 0° and 760 mm., is 1.429 grams, and the ‹molecular weight expressed in grams (molar weight)› of oxygen, 32 grams, occupies, therefore, 32 / 1.429, or 22.4 liters.

    The weights of ‹this same volume›, 22.4 liters, of gases and vapors, calculated for 0° and 760 mm. pressure,[50] express then directly, in terms of the oxygen standard, the relative molecular weights of the elements or compounds forming the gases. The weights themselves give us directly their gram-molecular or molar weights.

    When molecular weights are determined in this way, with the aid of Avogadro's hypothesis, results are obtained which agree [p034] perfectly with the chemical behavior of the compounds or elements in question. The molecular weights of hydrogen chloride, water, ammonia, and marsh gas, for instance, are found to be 36.5, 18, 17 and 16, respectively, corresponding to the formulæ[51] HCl, H_{2}O, NH_{3} and CH_{4}, and in confirmation of these results we find, by methods used especially in organic chemistry, that these compounds show a chemical behavior agreeing perfectly with the presence of one, two, three and four hydrogen atoms, respectively, in their molecules.

    Marsh gas, for instance, by treatment with chlorine, yields a monochloride, CH_{3}Cl, a dichloride, CH_{2}Cl_{2}, a trichloride (chloroform), CHCl_{3}, and a tetrachloride, CCl_{4}. Water, by proper treatment, may be converted in successive stages into alcohol, (C_{2}H_{5})OH, and then into ether, (C_{2}H_{5})O(C_{2}H_{5}), or into sodium hydroxide, NaOH, and sodium oxide, Na_{2}O.

    It is this perfect agreement between the chemical behavior and the formulæ (as based on these molecular weights and on the analysis of compounds), which forms the strongest ‹experimental evidence› of the correctness of the fundamental assumption of Avogadro's hypothesis.

    The agreement has been shown to hold for innumerable compounds, even for those of greatest complexity, and it was such agreement which finally led to the general acceptance of the hypothesis. The experimental evidence of this nature is so strong, so extensive and so completely corroborative of the hypothesis, that many chemists, rather justly, consider the hypothesis to have been established as a law, although the evidence is circumstantial rather than direct.

    While the application of Avogadro's hypothesis thus gives results agreeing well with the observed chemical behavior of very many important compounds, observations have been made which, at first sight, do not appear to agree with the requirements of the hypothesis and which seem to raise a doubt as to the ‹universal truth› of its fundamental assumption. Thus, if equal volumes of hydrogen chloride and ammonia, of the same temperature and pressure, are brought together, ammonium chloride is formed, both gases being totally consumed.

    Since, according to the hypothesis, equal volumes, under the conditions obtaining, contain the same numbers of molecules, the formation of ammonium chloride takes place according to the equation NH_{3} + HCl → NH_{4}Cl, and we should anticipate that the molecular weight of [p035] ammonium chloride would be 17 + 36.5 or 53.5.

    However, when the molecular weight is determined by obtaining the weight of a measured volume of ammonium chloride vapor, at a temperature sufficiently high to vaporize the salt, and the observations are reduced to standard conditions of temperature and pressure, 26.75 grams is found as the calculated weight of 22.4 liters, and this weight, according to this hypothesis, should be the molecular weight of the chloride.

    This contradiction in two conclusions, each reached by the application of Avogadro's hypothesis to experimental observations, would, at the first glance, make one hesitate to accept the hypothesis as representing a universal truth; it might seem as if in some gases, such as ammonium chloride vapor, there might be only half as many molecules in a given volume as in the same volume of the majority of gases.

    «Gaseous Dissociation.»—The discrepancy between the two conclusions and any doubt as to the universal soundness of the great generalization expressed in Avogadro's hypothesis disappear, however, in the light of a closer study of the composition of ammonium chloride vapor.

    It was suggested simultaneously by Cannizzaro, by Kopp and by Kékulé[52] that the abnormally low result, obtained for the molecular weight of ammonium chloride from a study of its vapor density, is due to the ‹dissociation› of the salt at high temperatures into its components, ammonia and hydrogen chloride, the ‹average› of whose ‹molecular weights› is, in fact, (17 + 36.5) / 2, or 26.75, the value found experimentally for the vapor of ammonium chloride.

    Proof of the correctness of this interpretation was furnished by Pébal,[53] who showed that ammonium chloride vapor does consist of the two gases, the lighter of which, ammonia, diffuses more rapidly through porous walls (Pébal used an asbestos stopper) than does the heavier, hydrogen chloride.

    The dissociation may be easily demonstrated by using an air cushion as a porous wall.[54] From the mixture produced by vaporizing ammonium chloride,[55] the ammonia will diffuse more rapidly through the layer of air than will the hydrogen [p036] chloride, and the gases may be recognized in succession by their action on litmus paper (‹exp.›).

    The ‹gaseous dissociation› of other ammonium salts, of phosphorus pentachloride and pentabromide (PX_{5} ⇄ PX_{3} + X_{2}), and of a number of less common compounds, has been demonstrated in similar ways. As a result of the study of each case, the important conclusion has been reached that, as far as our knowledge goes, there are no exceptions to Avogadro's hypothesis, and this hypothesis seems therefore to represent a universal truth.[56]

    «Molecular Weight Determinations in Solution.»—Van 't Hoff's extension of the Avogadro Hypothesis, so that it shall apply to solutes in dilute solutions, is the basis of another general method of greatest value for determining molecular weights. Equal volumes of dilute solutions of the same osmotic pressure and the same temperature contain, according to van 't Hoff, the same numbers of dissolved molecules, irrespective of the solvent used.

    Furthermore, the number of dissolved molecules is identical with that which a gas of the same pressure and at the same temperature would contain in the same volume. To determine the molecular weight of a solute, therefore, we may calculate, from the osmotic pressure, the temperature and the concentration of the solution,[57] that weight of the solute which, in 22.4 liters of the solution, at 0° would give 760 mm. osmotic pressure; the weight found represents, in grams, the ‹molecular weight› of the solute ‹in the solution used›. [p037]

    The fact that ‹all solvents› and ‹all solutes› are included in this hypothesis, with the sole limiting condition that the solution must be dilute, is one of great significance and of greatest practical importance, as we may use any suitable solvent for determinations.

    When molecular weights are determined in this way, a very large number of compounds give the same molecular weight by the solution method as by the gas method. For instance we have:

    Substance. Mol. Wt. Mol. Wt. Solvent.
    Gas Method. Sol. Method.
    Chloroform, CHCl_{3} 119.5 119.5 Benzene
    Carbon bisulphide, CS_{2} 76 76 Benzene
    Methyl (wood) alcohol, CH_{4}O 32 32 Water
    Ethyl (ordinary) alcohol,
    C_{2}H_{6}O 46 46 Water
    Ether, C_{4}H_{10}O 74 74 Acet. Acid

    Further, the molecular weight of glucose is found in aqueous solutions to be 180, conforming to the formula C_{6}H_{12}O_{6}, and agreeing with the molecular weight as obtained by a chemical study of compounds derived from glucose.

    While there are, then, very many agreements in the molecular weights determined by the solution and by the older methods, it was recognized, at the outset,[58] that there is also a large number of apparently ‹abnormal› cases, in which, in particular, ‹much lower molecular weights› are obtained by the solution methods than by the gas method,—lower even than the weights consistent with the accepted atomic weights of the elements in the compounds in question.[59] For instance, we find 36.5 to be the molecular weight of hydrogen chloride in the gas form, but in ‹aqueous› solution its apparent molecular weight, as determined on the basis of van 't Hoff's hypothesis, is not even a constant; it is found to be less than 36.5 and approaches the limit 18.25, the more dilute the solution, [p038] the lower being the apparent molecular weight.[60] For sodium chloride, the formula weight, corresponding to the formula NaCl, is 58.5.

    This would also represent its smallest molecular weight in gas form, consistent with the accepted atomic weights for sodium and chlorine. In ‹aqueous› solution, again, the apparent molecular weight of sodium chloride is found to be less than 58.5, and more than 29.25, the value found depending on the concentration of the solution used. For zinc chloride we have, likewise, in aqueous solution values much less than 136 and tending toward the limit 45, whereas the formula weight for ZnCl_{2} is 136.

    These are instances of a very large class of apparent gross discrepancies between the requirements of the Avogadro-van 't Hoff principle and the generally accepted molecular weights of common compounds. There are three ways, in particular, in which one might be inclined to regard such results: in the first place, one might be tempted to consider that van 't Hoff's extension of Avogadro's hypothesis to solutions is justified in a considerable number of cases, but not as a ‹universal› expression, applicable to ‹all› dilute solutions. This seems, indeed, to have been van 't Hoff's own attitude originally.

    Such a view, since it does not throw new light on the matter, but simply shelves the question of the source of the discrepancy, would be tenable only after all other explanations had been found unsatisfactory.

    In the second place, we might be inclined to consider whether a molecule like hydrogen chloride is not dissociated in aqueous solution into two smaller molecules, ‹h›‹cl›, in which hydrogen and chlorine would appear as atoms with the weights ‹h› = 0.5 and ‹cl› = 17.75, which are half as large as the atomic weights determined from a study of volatile compounds of hydrogen and chlorine.

    If we remember that our atomic weights are confessedly maximum weights, and not minimum weights—although they are almost certainly also the true atomic weights—such a view would be, at least, worthy of some consideration.

    But, in the first place, it would be extraordinary that we should never have found, in the thousands of [p039] hydrogen derivatives that have been investigated, any compound, the molecule of which, in the gaseous condition, contained a ‹single› such atom of hydrogen, with the weight 0.5, or an ‹uneven› multiple of it: that only ‹even› multiples or pairs ‹h›_{2}, corresponding to the atom H, should always have been found.

    In the second place, such an explanation of the results of the molecular weight determinations in aqueous solutions given above, would soon lead to difficulties, which make the view altogether untenable. For instance, the molecule of zinc chloride, according to the data given, would have to break down into three molecules and, if these were of uniform composition, we would have to assume chlorine atoms two-thirds or one-third as large as Cl.

    Since a moment ago we had to assume chlorine atoms one-half as large as Cl, we would have to conclude that the atomic weight of chlorine could be, at most, Cl / 6, which is the largest common divisor of Cl / 2 and Cl / 3. No chemist would seriously consider an atomic weight for chlorine one-sixth as large as the accepted weight, for that would mean that, in all the chlorine compounds investigated in the condition of gases, we have always at least six such atoms occurring together, and otherwise always multiples of six.

    Consequently such an interpretation of the so-called "abnormal" behavior of solutions of hydrogen chloride, sodium and zinc chlorides, etc., although at one time advanced by some chemists, must be considered as altogether untenable.

    A third explanation of the "abnormally" low molecular weights, which certain substances in aqueous solutions possess, is, that the molecules of these compounds are ‹capable of dissociation into smaller molecules of unlike composition›, somewhat like ammonium chloride when it is heated, and that the substances in question are dissociated more or less considerably in this fashion in the solutions under consideration.

    Hydrogen chloride, for instance, besides existing as such (as HCl), in aqueous solutions, might be capable of dissociating, and actually be dissociated, to a considerable degree into molecules containing either only hydrogen or only chlorine (HCl ⇄ H + Cl); the ‹average› of the weights of the molecules in a mixture of molecules, HCl, H, and Cl, would be ‹less› than 36.5, and, according to the proportion of dissociated and undissociated molecules of hydrogen chloride, the average would lie between the limits 36.5 and (1 + 35.5) / 2, or 18.25.

    Such an [p040] explanation,[61] made with ‹certain additions and restrictions›, was advanced in 1885 by Arrhenius, a Swedish chemist and physicist, when he learned of the exceptional behavior of these solutions, as noted by van 't Hoff. Although at first this interpretation occasioned considerable criticism, it has maintained itself successfully for twenty years, on the basis of a wide range of accumulated facts, and it has been of remarkable value and benefit in the development of all branches of chemistry and the allied sciences.

    «The Theory of Ionization.»—Arrhenius[2] made the simple observation that all those solutions, in which the dissolved compounds seem to have abnormally low molecular weights, are solutions through which an ‹electric current› may be readily passed, they are ‹electrolytes›, whereas the solutions which give normal results (see, for instance, the table on p. 37) do not allow the ready passage of a current, they are ‹nonelectrolytes›.

    EXP. The fundamental difference between the two classes of solutions may readily be demonstrated. To water contained in an electrolytic cell, which is connected with a lighting circuit and with an electric lamp, first some alcohol, and later a small quantity of hydrochloric acid are added. The lamp is seen to glow, instantly, when the acid is added.

    This simple fact, that the very solutions which give abnormally low molecular weights for the dissolved compounds are also good conductors of electricity, was explained by a theory of ‹electrolytic dissociation› or of ‹ionization›, which Arrhenius had developed[62] from a study of the conductivity of electrolytes. The same fact has aided in establishing this theory which has led to the elucidation of vital problems of ‹electrical conductivity› and to a successful [p041] explanation of the problem of the apparently abnormal ‹osmotic pressures› (and ‹molecular weights›) of electrolyte solutes.

    It has thus removed the last difficulty in the way of accepting the van 't Hoff-Avogadro Hypothesis (p. 15) as true for all dilute solutions, exactly as the discovery of ‹gaseous dissociation› made it possible to recognize in the original Avogadro Hypothesis a universal truth (p. 36) about gases. And to these results was added, chiefly as the fruit of the work of Ostwald, with the aid of the theory of Arrhenius, the most successful and accurate formulation of the problem of the ‹chemical activity› of electrolytes, known in the history of chemistry.

    «Main Assumptions of Arrhenius's Theory of Ionization.»—The main assumptions of the theory of electrolytic dissociation or ionization are the following: (1) When an ionogen is dissolved in water, its molecules are immediately, more or less completely, ‹dissociated by the water› into smaller fragments or molecules of unlike composition.

    (2) These new molecules are charged with ‹electricity›; the molecules of the one product are charged with ‹positive›, the molecules of the other product[63] with ‹negative electricity›, the unit positive charge being equal in quantity, but opposite in kind, to the unit negative charge; the sum of all the positive charges in a solution is equal to the sum of all the negative charges, and the whole solution is electrically neutral.

    (3) The dissociation is a reversible reaction, and all electrolytes must be considered to be ‹completely ionized at infinite dilution›. (4) Except for the dependence resulting from the electrical charges and the consequent attractions and repulsions between ions, the ions must be considered independent molecules with their own ‹specific chemical› and ‹physical› properties.

    When a current is passed through the solution of an ionogen, the electrified particles carry their charges to the electrodes (see [p042] below). They are called the ‹ions›[64] of the electrolyte; the positively charged ions are distinguished as ‹cations› from the negatively charged ‹anions›, and the electrode toward which the cations move is called the cathode (negative electrode), and the electrode to which the anions move is called the ‹anode› (positive electrode).

    The dissociation of hydrogen chloride may be expressed, in the terms of the assumptions made, in the following equation:

    HCl ⇄ H^{+} + Cl^{−}; that is, hydrogen chloride is dissociated, to a greater or smaller extent and in reversible fashion, into positively charged hydrogen ions H^{+}, and negatively charged chloride ions Cl^{−}, and the charge on each chloride ion is equal in quantity to the positive charge on each hydrogen ion.

    Zinc chloride is dissociated according to the equation ZnCl_{2} ⇄ Zn^{2+} + 2 Cl^{−}, and, according to (2), the charge on each zinc ion is twice as great in quantity as the charge on each chloride ion, and therefore twice as great also as the charge on each hydrogen ion (see below, p. 58).

    It is practically certain, according to more recent results, that the ions are combined with water to form hydrates, such as H^{+}(H_{2}O){‹x›} and Cl^{−}(H{2}O)_{‹y›}.[65] This does not modify, essentially, the fundamental assumptions of the theory, but contributes rather to a satisfactory explanation of the rôle of water as an ionizing agent, a question to which we shall return later.

    «The Theory of Ionization and the Electron Theory of Electricity and of Matter.»[66]—According to the views held by many leading physicists at the present time, ‹negative electricity› consists of ultimate particles of matter called electrons or corpuscles.

    The mass of an electron is about 1 / 1000 the mass of an atom of hydrogen, and the electric charge of the electron is equal to that carried by a chloride ion in solution.[67] The atoms of the elements are considered to consist of aggregations of large numbers of electrons in a kind of "shell" or "body" of positive electricity.

    This positive electricity, in a given atom, is equal in quantity to the total negative charge of the electrons in the atom, the atoms as such [p043] containing no excess of either positive or negative electricity. The number of electrons in the atom of an element is considered to be definite and constant for that element, but the number varies as we go from the atoms of one element to those of a second element, the number increasing with the atomic weight of the element.

    One of the most fundamental and most characteristic properties of elements is considered to be the ‹affinity which their atoms show for electrons›; thus, the atoms of metals like sodium and potassium, which are generally called "electropositive" elements,[68] show an enormous tendency ‹to lose one electron› each and to form positively charged particles[69] Na^{-ε} (= Na^{+}) and K^{-ε} (= K^{+}).[70] The atoms of strongly electronegative elements, like chlorine, have a tremendous tendency for ‹gaining› and ‹holding electrons› beyond the number originally in such atoms.

    Thus, chlorine atoms tend to ‹assume an electron› each; they thereby become ‹negatively charged› particles, Cl^{+ε} ( = Cl^{−}).

    On the basis of these views, we have in sodium chloride NaCl a substance, whose molecules contain an atom, Na, with a tremendous ‹tendency to lose an electron›, and an atom, Cl, which has a tremendous ‹affinity for an electron›. It is natural to suppose, then, that ‹both tendencies will be satisfied by the passage of an electron from the sodium to the chlorine atom›, NaCl → Na^{-ε}Cl^{+ε}.

    Or, if we use the sign + to designate the positive charge produced on an atom by the loss of an electron and the sign − to indicate the charge gained through the assumption of an electron, we have[71]: NaCl is Na^{+}Cl^{−}. Similarly we have in hydrogen chloride H^{-ε}Cl^{+ε} or H^{+}Cl^{−}. It is altogether likely, therefore, that the atoms in a molecule of sodium chloride or of hydrogen chloride already possess electric charges,[72] so that, even while combined, [p044] their tendencies to lose or gain electrons are satisfied.

    It is also possible that the atoms are held together in the molecule by the electrical attraction of the opposite charges.[73] The force with which opposite electrical charges attract each other depends, as is well known, on the nature of the ‹surrounding medium›. Now, when molecular sodium chloride or hydrogen chloride is dissolved in water (a favorable medium), a decided decrease in the attraction (see p. 62), between the charged atoms within the molecules is brought about, and a process of ‹ionization› results: H^{+}Cl^{−} ⇄ H^{+} + Cl^{−}.

    The charged particles are called ‹ions› only after they have separated from one another and have become independent molecules, capable, for example, of moving in ‹opposite› directions.

    While the atoms of some metallic elements tend to lose a single electron and form ions Me^{+} (‹e.g.› Na^{+}, K^{+}), the atoms of other elements tend to lose two or more electrons, forming bivalent ions, Me^{2+} (‹e.g.› Zn^{2+}, Fe^{2+}, etc.), or trivalent ions, Me^{3+} (‹e.g.› Bi^{3+}, Fe^{3+}), and so forth. Similarly, atoms of the so-called negative elements may assume two or more electrons, forming bivalent ions, X^{2−} (‹e.g.› S^{2−}), and so forth.

    «The Validity of the Theory of Ionization.»—In determining the validity of the theory of ionization, we may consider, first, the sufficiency of the explanations which it offers for observed facts and important phenomena. We may then weigh, more critically, by any evidence offering itself, the facts which will enable us to decide between this theory and the older theory of ionization, that of Clausius (p. 51). The latter, although displaced, is still often revived by opponents of the modern theory.

    Such facts as we will consider are found, first, in the domain of ‹conductivity phenomena›, next, in the ‹osmotic pressure› and related properties of solutions, and, finally, in the study of the ‹chemical activity› of electrolytes (see Chapter V).

    «Ionization and Electrical Conductivity.»—Turning our attention first to the field of electrical phenomena, and developing the theory for the present descriptively, we find that the conductivity of a solution depends, according to this theory, on the fact that when two oppositely charged poles are placed in a solution, the [p045] positive charge on the anode attracts all the negative particles within its field of action, and repels all the positive particles, exactly as a positive static charge of electricity would attract a negatively charged pith-ball and repel a positively charged one.

    In the case of a solution of hydrochloric acid, the negative charge on the cathode would attract the hydrogen ions and repel the chloride ions, and the positive charge of the anode would attract the chloride ions and repel the hydrogen ions. The net result would be a migration of all the chloride ions with their negative charges toward the anode, and of the positively charged hydrogen ions toward the cathode,—a flow or ‹current of electricity› being thus produced.

    The fact, then, that a current of electricity does readily pass through such a solution of an ionogen, is easily understood on the basis of these views.

    [Illustration: FIG. 8.]

    EXP. The migration of the ions throughout the whole solution may be demonstrated by the passage of a current through a large U-tube containing a mixture of a cupric salt and a permanganate,[74] placed under some dilute sulphuric acid. The cupric-ion is blue, all ionized solutions of cupric salts, with a colorless negative ion, being blue, while the permanganate-ion is of an intense purple color. In the limb of the U-tube, in which the cathode is placed, a blue zone, containing cupric ions, is soon seen emerging from the purple liquid and rising toward the cathode (see Fig. 8). It will take some time for any cupric ions actually to reach the electrode and be deposited as metallic copper.

    On the anode side, purple permanganate ions are seen rising toward the positive electrode.

    The movement of the electrically charged particles in opposite directions through the solution constitutes an electric current, and such a current has the properties of a current through a [p046] wire—producing, for instance, heat, or being capable of deflecting a magnet placed in its field of action.[75]

    «Electrolysis.»—When ions touch an electrode, they are discharged, and with the discharge, are changed chemically, and, according to the electron theory, also materially. Cupric ions, Cu^{2+} or Cu^{−2 ε}, receiving two electrons at the cathode, are precipitated as metallic copper. When a current is passed through a solution of hydrochloric acid, the hydrogen ions, by the pairing of the discharged ions, yield hydrogen gas consisting of molecules, H_{2}; the chloride ions are converted at the anode into chlorine Cl_{2}.

    The formation of these molecules, X_{2}, may be variously interpreted, as resulting either from the union of two discharged or neutral atoms, or as consisting, for instance in the case of hydrogen, in the discharge of a hydrogen ion H^{+}, at the negative electrode, ‹followed by the assumption of a negative charge or electron by the neutral atom›, the new ion H^{−} combining at once with the positive ion H^{+} to form the molecule H^{+}H^{−}.

    At the positive pole, by an analogous recharging of a discharged negative chloride-ion Cl^{−}, we should obtain a positive ion,[76] Cl^{+}, and immediately the formation of Cl_{2} or Cl^{+}Cl^{−} would follow. Helmholtz advocated the latter conception of the action at the electrodes, and, more recently, J. J.

    Thomson[77] brings forward, as a very important argument in favor of it, the fact that iodine, which according to vapor density determinations dissociates into monatomic molecules at high temperatures (I_{2} ⇄ 2 I), becomes, simultaneously with this dissociation, also an excellent ‹gaseous conductor of electricity›, as would be anticipated from a dissociation, I^{+}I^{−} ⇄ I^{+} + I^{−}.

    This fact is emphasized here, because in it we seem to have a case of ‹conductivity› coinciding with ‹gaseous dissociation›, the existence of which is recognized by the universally accepted laws of gases, and differing in no important respect from the dissociation assumed for conductors in solution.

    «Conductivity and Dilution.»—The passage of a current through an electrolyte consists, then, in a transfer of electricity by material particles, the ions. According to the theory of ionization only [p047] the ionized portion of an electrolyte can carry the current at any moment, and, consequently, a ‹given weight› of an ionogen should, under comparable conditions, be the more efficient as a conductor, the more completely it is dissociated into ions.

    If the conductivity of a given weight of hydrogen chloride, for instance, is measured under comparable conditions, it should be found to be greater, the more completely the acid is ionized. Now, in aqueous solutions, hydrogen chloride ionizes under the influence of the ‹solvent water› (pp. 41, 61), and the theory would lead us to anticipate that the greater the proportion of water used, the more extensively will it ionize the acid. Consequently, the addition of water to a given weight of acid should increase the latter's efficiency as a conductor.

    This conclusion has been fully verified by exact methods of measurement and may be readily demonstrated by the following series of experiments:

    EXP.[78] An electrolytic cell, having the shape of a parallelopipedon and a capacity of about one liter, is fitted with electrodes of copper, which reach from the bottom to the top of the cell and are connected with a storage cell and an ammeter. The cell is first filled with distilled water: no perceptible current passes through the water and the latter is therefore practically a nonconductor. The cell is then emptied by means of a siphon and 20 c.c. of 4-molar hydrochloric acid is brought into it.

    The ammeter shows that a definite current passes through the solution (0.17 ampere in an experiment[79] with a cell 4.6 cm. wide and 11.5 cm. long, with copper electrodes 4.6 cm. broad and 21 cm. high). (See Fig. 9, p. 48.) [p048]

    [Illustration: FIG. 9.]

    The conductivity of a solution, like that of a metal conductor, is the reciprocal of its resistance. Since, according to Ohm's law,[80] the current for a ‹given potential› is inversely proportional to the resistance, the current is also directly proportional to the conductivity. The resistances of the metal connections and of the ammeter in the experiment are very small compared with the resistance of the solution, and they may be considered negligible for our purpose. Thus, ‹the current indicated by the ammeter is a closely approximate measure of the conductivity of the solution›.

    Now, if a volume of water (20 c.c.) equal to the volume of acid, were to be added to the latter, the cross section through which the current flows from plate to plate would be ‹doubled›, and, since the conductivity of a liquid conductor, like that of a metal, increases proportionally to the cross section, the current should be doubled by the change in this one factor. On the other hand, the concentration of the conducting acid is now ‹one-half› of the original concentration, and this should in turn reduce the conductivity of the solution to one-half.

    Consequently, if there were no further change in the electrolyte, the original conductivity should be maintained when the acid is thus diluted. But, according to the theory of ionization, as has just been shown, the addition of [p049] water to a given weight of hydrochloric acid ‹should increase the proportion of ionized acid›, and since the ions are the carriers of the current, the ‹conductivity› of the solution should be ‹increased› because of this change in the ‹composition› of the electrolyte. Experiment shows that such is the case.

    EXP. 20 c.c. of water is added to the 20 c.c. of 4-molar acid in the cell, and the mixture is stirred. The current is decidedly increased (from 0.17 to 0.22 ampere in the experiment under discussion).

    If 40, 80, 160 and 320 c.c. of water are added in succession to the contents of the cell, the conductivity is ‹increased by every addition of water›. But, while each addition dilutes the acid to one-half the previous concentration, the ‹increase grows proportionally smaller and smaller with increasing dilution›. In the following table, "Ratios I" are the ratios of the observed conductivities ‹to the original conductivity›, "Ratios II" the ratio of each observed conductivity to the ‹preceding one›.

    ‹Concentration› ‹Observed› Ratios I. Ratios II.
    ‹of Acid.› ‹Conductivity.›[A]

    4-molar 0.17 1 1.
    2-molar 0.22 1.30 1.30
    1-molar 0.26 1.53 1.18
    0.5-molar 0.30 1.76 1.15
    0.25-molar 0.31 1.83 1.04
    0.125-molar 0.32 1.88[B] 1.03

    TABLE NOTES:

    A. This is an artificial scale (see text) of conductivities,
    and does not represent reciprocal ohms, the standard units of
    conductivity.

    B. In the exact data on the conductivities of 4-molar and
    1/8-molar HCl (Kohlrausch and Holborn, ‹Leitvermögen der
    Elektrolyte› (1898) p. 160), the ratio 348 / 181.5, or 1.92,
    is found, in place of 1.88 as observed.

    We should expect, further, that the increase in conductivity, being dependent on the increased dissociation of a finite quantity of electrolyte, should tend towards a ‹limit›, a maximum conductivity being reached when (practically) all the acid is ionized. As a matter of experience, the conductivity of a given quantity of an acid or other ionogen does tend toward a ‹limit›. In the experiment just made, the conductivity of the acid increases very rapidly at first, as the 4-molar acid is diluted by water; but the increase in conductivity with the succeeding dilutions grows ‹smaller› and ‹smaller› and the conductivity is plainly approaching [p050] a limit (see the ratios I and II in the table).

    For hydrochloric acid at 18°, the limit for one mole[81] (36.5 grams HCl) at infinite dilution, as deduced from the curve of conductivities at finite dilutions, is 384 reciprocal ohms.[82]

    «Degree of Ionization of an Electrolyte.»—The conductivity of a given weight of an electrolyte, for instance of its gram-equivalent weight, depends, then, at a given temperature on the extent to which it is ionized, the ions being the only carriers of the current in a solution of an electrolyte. The conductivity will also depend on the friction which the ions must overcome in moving through a solution, but, for sufficiently dilute solutions in a given solvent, the friction may be assumed to be approximately constant for given ions.

    For such solutions, then, the conductivity of a given weight of a given electrolyte at a given temperature may be said to depend wholly on the extent to which the electrolyte is ionized. Thus, the proportion of ionized electrolyte in a solution may be determined by measuring the conductivity. ‹The extreme limit of its conductivity, calculated for infinite dilution, represents complete ionization› of the electrolyte according to a fundamental postulate (§ 3, p.

    1. of the theory of Arrhenius, and the ratio of the conductivity

    in a given solution to the conductivity of the same weight of electrolyte at infinite dilution represents then the ‹proportion of ionized electrolyte to the total electrolyte› used. This proportion is called its ‹degree of ionization› (commonly designated by α).

    If we call Λ_{‹v›} the conductivity of a gram-equivalent weight of an electrolyte in a given solution, and Λ_{∞} the limit of its conductivity for infinite dilution, then the degree of ionization is found from α = Λ_{‹v›} / Λ_{∞}. [p051]

    The method of calculation of α in a specific case may be illustrated as follows: the resistance of a cube of 1 cm. edge of a solution of hydrochloric acid, which contains 1.825 grams hydrogen chloride in a liter, is found to be 55.55 ohms at 18°. Its conductivity then is 1 / 55.55 reciprocal ohms. Now, 1.825 grams of hydrogen chloride is 1.825 / 36.5 or 1 / 20 gram-equivalent of the acid; a whole gram-equivalent of the acid would be contained in 20 liters or 20,000 c.c. Then Λ_{‹v›} = (1 / 55.55) × 20,000, or 360 reciprocal ohms. If we use the value at infinite dilution given above, α = 360 / 384, or 93.75%.

    That is, 93.75% of the hydrochloric acid is present in the ionized condition in such a solution, and 6.25% is not ionized.

    By making the assumption that ‹at infinite dilution electrolytes are completely ionized›, and by taking the ratio which the equivalent conductivity of a given solution of an electrolyte bears to the maximum limit-value (calculated for the conductivity at infinite dilution) ‹to be the degree of ionization of the electrolyte›, as just explained, the theory of Arrhenius has thus made it appear possible ‹to determine experimentally the proportion of ionized electrolyte present›.

    It is a significant fact that the equivalent conductivity of hydrochloric acid is ‹close to its limit even at finite dilutions›, and that the same relation holds for the strong acids and the strong bases, in general, and for most salts. But the equivalent conductivity of weak acids, like acetic acid, and of weak bases, like ammonium hydroxide, in finite dilutions is still far removed from the limits which may be calculated for infinite dilutions.

    Arrhenius was led then to the further important conclusion that, in the case of the first electrolytes mentioned, a ‹very large proportion of the electrolyte must exist in the ionized form at finite concentrations›, their equivalent conductivities having almost reached the limit characteristic of infinite dilution.

    «Clausius's Theory of Ionization and the Modern Theory.»—It is in these conclusions—in particular that the proportion of ionized electrolyte ‹may be determined experimentally›, and that frequently a ‹large proportion is found to be ionized at finite concentrations›,—that the ‹modern theory of ionization differs from the older theory of Clausius›. The former is an elaboration of the latter, and some opponents[83] of the modern theory still uphold the latter as offering an adequate explanation of the phenomena of conductivity.

    All facts, then, in particular, which confirm the validity of the ‹conception of the degree of ionization›, as introduced by Arrhenius, [p052] must be considered as criteria favoring his theory, specifically. The development of chemistry in the last twenty years is replete with such evidence and we shall meet it in many connections throughout our work.

    Clausius[84] also assumed dissociated molecules or ions to be the real carriers of electricity in the passage of a current through the solution of an electrolyte, but he assumed only a ‹minute quantity of these molecular fragments or ions to be free at any moment›, their existence being supposed to be transitory and dependent in particular on exchanges of atoms between molecules.

    As a result of the oscillations of the atoms composing a molecule, oscillations comparable with the motions of molecules assumed in the kinetic theory of gases, molecules were considered by Clausius occasionally to reach such a condition of instability, that they dissociated into smaller particles; since the atoms were supposed to be held in a molecule by attractions of electrical charges on the atoms (theory of Berzelius), the fragments of the molecule would carry the charges, positive and negative respectively, which they possessed in the molecule.

    Such a breaking up or dissociation of molecules was, further, supposed to occur with particular ease during the collisions of molecules, the electrical attractions and repulsions of the charged atoms favoring, at such moments, an ‹exchange of atoms›. During the exchange, the atoms were considered to be free molecules, charged with electricity—essentially ions,—capable of moving under the influence of electrical forces and of thus carrying a current.

    Finally, such ions were supposed, in part, to escape recombination, and to remain free, until each ion either collided and combined with an ion of opposite charge, or collided with a molecule and displaced an atom of the same charge from that molecule, a new ion being thus liberated. The theory, as usually interpreted, assumed the existence of only a very small quantity of such free ions, that being all that was supposed to be required to explain the facts known at the time it was advanced.

    In what follows, we shall confine the discussion strictly to such contrasts between the two theories as grow out of a consideration of the phenomena of conductivity, and particularly consider some evidence which is directly concerned with the conductivity of solutions.

    In the first place, if the formation of ions occurs primarily during the exchange of atoms in ‹collisions of molecules›, then, as Whetham[85] has shown, the specific conductivity (of 1 cm.^3) of an electrolyte, like hydrochloric acid, must increase with the concentration and must increase, approximately, as a function of the ‹third› power of the concentration. The more concentrated the solution, the more frequent the collisions between the dissolved molecules must be.

    As a matter of fact, as shown in the following table, the conductivity [p053] increases a ‹little less› than proportionally to the ‹first› power of the concentration—‹which is in conflict with the assumption made in the hypothesis of Clausius›, but in perfect agreement with the hypothesis of Arrhenius. The small ‹decrease› with increasing concentration, in the simple ratio between conductivity and concentration, is due to the decreasing degree of ionization in the more concentrated solutions, as demanded by the hypothesis of Arrhenius.

    The table gives, in the first column, the specific conductivities of hydrochloric acid at 18°, and, in the second column, the concentrations; these concentrations are expressed in moles or gram-equivalents per cubic centimeter; the last column gives the ratio of conductivity to concentration.

    Conductivity Conductivity
    of 1 c.c. Concentration ─────────────
    Concentration.

    0.00370 0.00001 370
    0.00734 0.00002 367
    0.01092 0.00005 364
    0.01800 0.00005 360
    0.03510 0.00010 351

    Furthermore, facts admitted by Clausius to be inexplicable by his own assumptions receive, in the theory of Arrhenius, at least a quantitative formulation borne out by a mass of corroborative evidence. The difference in conductivity between pure water and sulphuric acid is such a fact, mentioned by Clausius. Determinations of the ionization of sulphuric acid and of water, by the conductivity methods which are based on the theory of Arrhenius, show that, while sulphuric acid is very considerably ionized (see p. 104), water is scarcely ionized at all.

    The ionization of water (see p. 104) has been determined quantitatively by at least four independent methods of examination,[86] and, minimal as the ionization is, the results agree so well with each other that van 't Hoff[87] was led to write: "If one is not previously convinced of the correctness of the theory of electrolytic dissociation, hardly any result won by means of it is so convincing, as the agreement between the conclusions reached in completely different ways as to the degree of dissociation of water itself.

    After such an agreement, it is hardly conceivable that the basis on which all these results rest should further be altered."

    «Mobilities or Partial Conductivities of Ions: Principle of Kohlrausch.»—If ions have a separate existence, each kind of ion would be expected to move through a solution under a given electrical force at a given temperature with its own specific speed, the speed being presumably dependent on the nature of the ion as well as on the weight of water combined with it and dragged with it through the solution (p. 42). [p054]

    Such relative speeds of ions may be demonstrated by means of an experiment: the motion of the hydrogen ions, formed by the ionization of hydrochloric and other acids, may be observed by their action on a reddened (alkaline) solution of phenolphthaleïn, which is decolorized by them; and the motion of the hydroxide ions, formed by the ionization of sodium hydroxide and other bases, may be followed by their action on colorless phenolphthaleïn, which turns red in their presence.

    The hydrogen and the hydroxide ions are the fastest, in aqueous solutions, and their speeds are compared in the next experiment with that of blue cupric ions, which have a speed roughly the same as that of many common ions. In this experiment the hydrogen ions are readily seen to move about twice as fast as the hydroxide ions and five to six times as fast as the cupric ions.

    [Illustration: FIG. 10]

    EXP.[88] Five grams of agar-agar are dissolved in 250 c.c. of boiling water. To 100 c.c. of the hot solution, 32 c.c. of a saturated solution of potassium chloride and about 1 c.c. of phenolphthaleïn solution are added, together with enough of a solution of potassium hydroxide, added drop by drop, to produce a deep red tint in the phenolphthaleïn.

    Of this mixture 50 c.c. is treated with dilute hydrochloric acid, added drop by drop, until the red color is just discharged, and then an excess of acid, equal in amount to the quantity used to neutralize the 50 c.c., is added to the mixture. This colorless solution and 50 c.c. of the red solution are poured, while still warm, into the two parts of a wide U-tube, slowly and at equal rates, so that the level on the two sides remains the same.

    In this way it is possible without difficulty to have the solution on one side red (alkaline) and on the other side colorless (acid). The agar-agar is allowed to congeal, and then a mixture of 0.5 c.c. of hydrochloric acid, (sp. g. 1.12), 6 c.c. of saturated cupric chloride solution and 20 c.c. of water is poured over the red half, and a mixture of 20 c.c. of saturated [p055] potassium chloride solution and 2 c.c. of 10% potassium hydroxide solution is poured over the colorless half.

    The U-tube is surrounded by ice water during the passage of the current, and the cathode is placed in the solution on the colorless side. In Fig. 10 the U-tube is shown when first charged (on the left), and after the current has been running for a short time (on the right).

    The conductivity of a solution must be made up, therefore, of the sum of the shares which the positive ions and the negative ions, respectively, take in carrying the current. This principle was first advanced by Kohlrausch. The share of each kind of ion in conducting a current may be determined, for hydrochloric acid for instance, in the following way: A porous diaphragm may be used to divide the solution in an electrolytic cell into two halves, the concentration of the acid being the same in both halves (represented, as indicated in Fig.

    11, by 15 molecules[89] of ionized acid in each half). A measured current is passed through the solution, say, sufficient to liberate 3 molecules of hydrogen H_{2}, and 3 of chlorine Cl_{2}, corresponding to 6 ‹ions› of each, and the concentration of the acid in each half is then again determined by analysis. Say it is found to correspond to 14 molecules of hydrochloric acid in the half of the solution on the side of the cathode and 10 molecules in the half on the side of the anode (see Fig. 12).

    Then the anode half has lost 5 ions of hydrogen, which must have passed through the diaphragm toward the cathode and taken the place of five of the six hydrogen ions discharged at the cathode. Similarly, the solution around the cathode has lost one chloride ion, which must have passed through the diaphragm toward the anode, and the hydrogen-ion corresponding to it, remaining on the right side without a compensating negative ion, must be the sixth hydrogen-ion discharged at the cathode.

    In other words, five hydrogen ions passed to the right, while one chloride ion passed to the left. The hydrogen ions then carried five-sixths of the current through the diaphragm, and consequently through the solution, and the chloride ions only one-sixth of the current. Since the solutions were of equal concentration to start with, the hydrogen ions have moved ‹five times as fast› toward the cathode as the chloride ions have moved toward the anode.

    [Illustration: FIG. 11.]

    [Illustration: FIG. 12.]

    The equivalent conductivity of 0.1-molar hydrochloric acid is 351 at 18°, and experiment shows that the hydrogen-ion carries 84% of the current, the chloride-ion only 16%. The conductivity may then be considered to be the [p056] sum of the share the hydrogen-ion has in carrying the current, ‹i.e.› 0.84 × 351, or 295, and of the share of the chloride-ion, 0.16 × 352.5, or 56. These values may be called the ‹equivalent partial conductivities› or ‹mobilities› of the ions in this solution.

    In a similar way, the conductivity of every solution of an electrolyte may be shown to represent the sum of the mobilities of the ions carrying the current (‹principle of Kohlrausch›). The limit of the conductivity of one equivalent of an electrolyte is the sum of the mobilities of the ions composing the electrolyte.

    The frictional forces being constant for infinitely dilute solutions, at a given temperature, an ion will always show the same mobility, irrespective of the nature of the ion of opposite charge, with which it forms the electrolyte. We may then put Λ_{∞} = (‹l›^{+}{∞} + ‹l›^{−}{∞}), if ‹l›^{+}{∞} and ‹l›^{−}{∞} are used to designate the limits of the mobilities of gram-equivalents of the positive and negative ions forming the electrolyte. The following table[90] gives the limits of the mobilities for gram equivalents of some of the most important ions at 18°.

    ‹Limits of Mobilities of Common Ions at› 18°.

    K: 65.3 ½ Ca: 53.0 I: 66.7
    Na: 44.4 H: 318.0 NO_{3}: 60.8
    (NH_{4}): 64.2 OH: 174.0 C_{2}H_{3}O_{2}: 33.7
    Ag: 55.7 Cl: 65.9 ½ SO_{4}: 69.7

    For quite dilute solutions, in which the friction may be assumed to be approximately constant, the conductivity will depend, not only on the mobilities of the ions, which may be taken to be the same as for solutions of extreme dilution, but also ‹on the proportion of electrolyte that is ionized›, ‹i.e.› on the degree of ionization, α. Then Λ_{‹v›} = α (‹l›^{+}{∞} + ‹l›^{−}{∞}), which is an elaboration of the original equation given on page 50.

    Now, Kohlrausch discovered the principle of the summation of the mobilities of ions a number of years before the theory of Arrhenius was advanced, and the proportion in which the ion is present in a given solution being unknown, the effect of what is here known as the degree of ionization was included empirically in the value of the mobility.

    It is not surprising, then, that an ion was found to have approximately the same mobility ‹only› in solutions of the same concentration ‹of strictly analogous and closely related salts›, which, according to present methods of investigation, are ‹now› found to have approximately the same degree of ionization. For instance, the mobility of the gram-equivalent of the chloride-ion was found to be approximately the same, 47.3 and 50.5 respectively, in molar solutions of sodium and potassium chloride at 18°, no account being taken of the degrees of ionization.

    However, the degrees of ionization of the two salts are approximately the same, 66.9% and 74.9% respectively, and might be ignored in a comparison of the conductivities, without affecting the result of the comparison in any marked way. [p057]

    When the conductivities of unlike electrolytes are compared, the ‹introduction of the conception of the degree of ionization› (by Arrhenius,) into Kohlrausch's principle of the independent conductivities of specific ions, shows most striking results and ‹demonstrates the value of the new conception›. For instance, the equivalent conductivity of potassium chloride at 18° in 0.075 molar solution is 113.8 reciprocal ohms and the partial conductivity of the chloride-ion in the solution is 57.4.

    But the conductivity of an equivalent solution of ‹mercuric chloride› at 18° is only 1.51, which is very much less than the conductivity of the chloride-ion alone in the potassium chloride solution. Now, mercuric chloride, according to investigations of its conductivities and of its effect in depressing the freezing-point of water,[91] is one of a very few salts that are difficultly ionizable (p.

    107); according to the data mentioned, it is ionized, at most, to the extent of 2.5 per cent in the solution in question, whereas 87.5 per cent of the potassium chloride is ionized in such a solution. When the difference in the degree of ionization is taken into account, the conductivity which mercuric chloride ‹should show› may be calculated, ‹on the assumption that the chloride-ion has the same mobility› in the two solutions, but that there is less of it in the mercuric solutions. We put Λ_{HgCl_{2}} = α (‹l›{Hg} + ‹l›{Cl}) = 0.025 (48 + 65.9) = 2.8.

    We thus find that the conductivity of the mercuric chloride should be, approximately, only 2.8 reciprocal ohms, which is of the same order as that found (1.51).[92]

    In the same way, when we compare the conductivity of a strong acid, like hydrochloric acid, with that of a weak acid, like acetic acid—the conductivity of 0.1 molar hydrochloric acid is 351, of 0.1 molar acetic acid only 4.6—the principle of the specific, characteristic mobility of the hydrogen-ion, which is present in both solutions, has significance only if we take into account the very different concentrations of the hydrogen-ion in the two solutions, ‹resulting from the different degrees of ionization of the two acids›—91% for the hydrochloric and only 1.7% for the acetic acid.

    The same relations hold in the comparison of the conductivity of a solution of a strong base like sodium hydroxide with that of an equivalent solution of a weak, i.e. much less ionized base like ammonium hydroxide, or in comparing the conductivity of a ‹weak acid› or a ‹weak base› with the conductivities of their ‹much more highly ionized salts›.

    ‹In all these cases the use of the conception of the degree of ionization of the electrolytes› makes possible a much broader and more general application of the principle of the independent migration or mobility of the ions than was possible before the theory of Arrhenius was proposed, and marks a distinct advance in the theory of conductivity, over what was possible on the basis of the theory of Clausius. [p058]

    «Faraday's Law.»—If a definite quantity of electricity, a faraday,[93] or 96,600 coulombs, is passed through a solution of hydrochloric acid, a definite quantity (36.5 grams, one mole) of the hydrogen chloride is decomposed, and one gram of hydrogen and 35.5 grams of chlorine are liberated by the discharge of one gram (‹i.e.› one gram-ion) of the hydrogen-ion and 35.5 grams or one gram-ion of the chloride-ion. In a solution of cupric chloride, the chloride-ion is identical in every respect with the chloride-ion found in a solution of hydrochloric acid.

    In the solution of cupric chloride, however, a molecule of the salt, when it is completely ionized, produces two chloride ions for every cupric ion (CuCl_{2} ⇄ Cu^{2+} + 2 Cl^{−}). Since the solution never shows the presence of an excess of either form of electricity, and the negative charge on each chloride ion is the same as on a chloride ion formed by the dissociation of hydrogen chloride, a cupric ion must hold ‹exactly› double the positive charge that a hydrogen ion does.

    In modern terms, each hydrogen atom, present as an ion, has lost one electron, and each copper atom present in the form of a cupric ion has lost two electrons. Our unit quantity of electricity, 96,600 coulombs, can discharge therefore ‹only half as many of the cupric› as of the hydrogen ions, and since each cupric ion is 63.6 times as heavy as the hydrogen-ion (Cu = 63.6, H = 1), 63.6 / 2 grams of copper, the ‹equivalent weight›, will be deposited in place of one gram of hydrogen.

    Similarly, from a solution of ferrous chloride FeCl_{2}, 55.9 / 2 grams of iron (Fe = 55.9) will be deposited, the ferrous ion being Fe^{2+}; while from a solution of ferric chloride FeCl_{3}, only 55.9 / 3 grams of iron will be deposited by 96,600 coulombs, the ferric ion, Fe^{3+}, holding three times the charge that a hydrogen ion does. In other words, a given quantity of current will decompose ‹equivalent› quantities of electrolytes and deposit ‹equivalent quantities› of metals. This is the well-known law of Faraday.

    The theory of Arrhenius agrees with it, as did the theory of Clausius. It cannot be considered as evidence bearing on the question of the preference to be given to either of the theories of ionization, since the degree of ionization of electrolytes is not involved in the relations covered by the law. But any other relation would have been incompatible with the theory of Arrhenius.

    The law is of particular importance in giving us [p059] the best clew that we have in regard to the ultimate nature of "valence" (as shown for instance in the difference between the ferrous, Fe^{2+}, and the ferric ions, Fe^{3+}). On the basis of this law, valence may be said to consist simply in the capacity of atoms to hold different multiples of the unit electrical charge (positive or negative).

    This conception will be of especial value to us when we come to consider the relation of the theory of ionization to oxidation and reduction (Chapters XIV and XV).

    «Diffusion of Ions and Concentration Cells.»—When the, apparently, abnormally low molecular weight of ammonium chloride was explained as being due to the dissociation of each molecule of ammonium chloride into a molecule of ammonia and one of hydrogen chloride, the evidence of the correctness of this interpretation was at once forthcoming—the vapor of ammonium chloride, by the unequal rates of diffusion of its components, was proved to be a mixture of the two gases (p. 35).

    Now, if an electrolyte like hydrochloric acid in aqueous solution is dissociated more or less into separate ions, H^{+} and Cl^{−}, then one may well ask, whether the dissociation cannot be demonstrated by the same kind of experiment, as, for instance, by showing that hydrogen and chloride ions ‹are molecules with unequal powers of diffusion› and ‹by separating them by virtue of such inequality›.

    Ions being, according to the theory under consideration, independent molecules, except for the attractive and repulsive forces of the electrical charges, they should have, like cane sugar, copper nitrate and other solutes, the capacity for diffusion from regions of higher to those of lower concentration. Further, if ions show different degrees of mobility (p. 53), one would expect the more mobile or faster moving one to diffuse more rapidly than a less mobile ion.

    Such a relation should hold for the ions in a solution of hydrochloric acid, the hydrogen-ion, according to the calculations of Kohlrausch[94] and the observation of Lodge,[95] moving at a rate about five times as great as that of the chloride-ion, at 18°.

    Thus, if a rather concentrated solution of hydrochloric acid were covered with a layer of water, or with a very dilute solution of the acid, one might expect the hydrogen ions to migrate faster than the chloride ions from the [p060] point of higher to that of lower concentration, ‹i.e.› from the more concentrated to the dilute acid. When the experiment is tried in this way, no separation of the hydrogen from the chloride ions seems to occur.

    The reason for the failure of the experiment is as follows: If any such separation did occur, even to the extent of say one milligram-equivalent of hydrogen and chloride ions, we would have a separation of electrostatic charges of 96 coulombs. These charges, on the small areas involved, would inevitably produce enormous potentials, that would operate against the separation.

    The hydrogen ions, which would tend to move from the concentrated to the dilute acid, would therefore be held back by the powerful attraction between their positive charges and the negative charges left in the concentrated acid (on the Cl^{−} ions). The separation of the electrical charges, incidental to a faster diffusion of hydrogen ions, if it occurred, would result, therefore, in the development of electrical forces of attraction, which would prevent a separation of the oppositely charged particles beyond any but distances too small to be measured.

    It would follow, however, that no difficulty whatever should be experienced in ‹observing such a separation›, as a result of unequal rates of migration of the ions in question, ‹if provision were made to preserve electrical neutrality in all zones› of the two solutions, ‹i.e.› if provision is made for the immediate discharge of the ions, as they separate by the unequal rates of diffusion.

    For instance, the part of the liquid into which the positive hydrogen ions move more rapidly, charging it with positive electricity, may be connected, by means of a wire, with the part of the liquid to which the chloride ions, left behind by their slower movements, are imparting a negative charge. In such a circuit, a current of electricity should be produced, the positive current flowing through the wire from the dilute to the concentrated acid. As a matter of fact, we find that a current is produced, when these conditions are observed.

    EXP. The lower plate in an Arrhenius cell is covered with concentrated hydrochloric acid. Very dilute acid is allowed to flow slowly on to the surface of the concentrated acid, from a pipette with a curved, narrow point, until the upper plate is submerged. The two plates are connected with a sensitive galvanometer. The current flows in the direction demanded by the observed mobilities of the ions, the positive current entering the galvanometer from the plate covered by the dilute solution, which is charged positively by the faster moving hydrogen ions coming from the concentrated solution.

    If the cell is [p061] connected with the electrodes of a very small cell containing copper sulphate, in the course of twenty-four hours quite a deposit of metallic copper is formed on the electrode connected with the concentrated solution of hydrochloric acid.

    The existence of the products of the electrolytic dissociation, of hydrochloric acid may therefore be demonstrated,[96] by the aid of the individual diffusion of the products of the dissociation, in the same way as was the coëxistence of the products of the gaseous dissociation of ammonium chloride, when the conditions for the experiment are adapted to the nature of the dissociation products. Cells of this type, depending for their current on unequal concentrations of given ions, are called "concentration cells."

    If it can be shown that the flow of electricity, resulting from such unequal diffusibility of ions, is a function not only of the difference in the total concentration of the electrolyte in the two solutions brought into contact with each other, but is also a function of the relative degrees of ionization of the electrolyte in the two solutions, as defined by the theory of Arrhenius, then this method of experimentation may be used as a further test of the validity of this theory as against that of Clausius.

    It is obvious that if such currents are the results of the diffusion of ‹ions› from higher to lower concentrations, then the essential concentrations do not embrace all of the electrolyte, but only the ionized part. W. K. Lewis[97] has rather recently shown that the degrees of dissociation of electrolytes may be measured by the use of concentration cells, and that the results agree well with the determinations of the degree of dissociation from conductivity measurements (p. 50).

    From calculations, based on Jahn's accurate measurements of the electromotive forces of concentration cells, A. A. Noyes[98] finds that "when the conductivity ratio is assumed to represent the degree of ionization of the salt, the calculated values of the electromotive force of concentration cells exceed the measured ones by only about one per cent, in the case of potassium and sodium chloride between the concentrations of 1 / 600 and 1 / 20 molar."

    «The Rôle of the Solvent in Ionization.»—A question that has profoundly interested chemists, particularly during the last few years, has been that of the rôle which the solvent plays in the [p062] dissociation of electrolytes into ions. The most important ionizing solvent is water and, of the common solvents which cause ionization, it is the most powerful in this particular. Alcohols have also ionizing power; methyl or wood alcohol, which stands nearest to water, has a higher ionizing power than ordinary ethyl alcohol.

    The exact work[99] of Franklin and Kraus, on the conductivity of solutions of salts in liquid ammonia, showed that the same general relations obtain for such solutions as for solutions in water, the differences being differences of degree rather than of kind. Salts are found to be less ionized in liquid ammonia than in equivalent aqueous solutions, but their conductivities are higher, the result of smaller friction in ammonia. Liquid hydrogen cyanide is also a very good ionizing medium.

    Solvents which cause ionization only to a minimal extent are benzene (C_{6}H_{6}), carbon bisulphide, ether, chloroform, petroleum ether (gasoline) and similar solvents. Hydrogen chloride dissolved in benzene has an extremely small conductivity, indicating only a trace of ionization.[100]

    The question may be raised, why the first solvents mentioned should have the power to cause ionization, while the second series of solvents named do not have this power, or have it only to a very slight extent. Without attempting to enter into an elaborate discussion of this important question, it may be said that J. J.

    Thomson[101] and Nernst[102] suggested that the ionizing powers of solvents must be intimately connected with their ‹dielectric behavior›, and this view has now been well established. It may be said, in simple terms, that the so-called dielectric constant of a solvent determines the force with which electrical charges will attract and repel each other; the higher the dielectric coefficient of a medium, the ‹smaller will be the attraction between opposite electrical charges›, other conditions being the same. In solvents, then, of high dielectric powers, the coëxistence of oppositely charged particles must be more favored than in solvents of low dielectric powers.

    The dielectric constants of a number of solvents are given in the following table: [p063]

    Hydrogen cyanide, HNC 95
    Hydrogen peroxide, H_{2}O_{2} 93
    Water, H_{2}O 81
    Methyl (wood) alcohol, CH_{4}O 32
    Ethyl (ordinary) alcohol, C_{2}H_{6}O 22
    Ammonia, H_{3}N 22
    Chloroform, CHCl_{3} 5
    Ether, (C_{2}H_{5}){2}O 4
    Benzene, C
    {6}H_{6} 2

    It is quite apparent that the good ionizing media have, as a matter of fact, the highest constants; those which cause ionization, at most minimally (‹e.g.› benzene), the lowest.

    Recent extended and exact investigations by Walden[103] have succeeded in bringing the ionizing power of solvents into definite quantitative relations to their dielectric constants, with the result that order has been brought out of a condition of chaos that, for a number of years, existed in this field, as the result of conclusions based on incomplete data.

    Conductivity being a function both of the proportion of dissociated electrolyte and of the mobility of the ions in a given solution, Walden determined, for a certain salt (an organic derivative of ammonium iodide, namely, tetraethyl ammonium iodide N(C_{2}H_{5}){4}I), for all solvents used, not only the conductivities for finite dilutions but also, by extrapolation, the limiting values for infinite dilution. He was thus able to determine the degree of ionization of the salt.

    Some of his results are particularly interesting; for instance, a ‹poorly conducting› solution, such as that of the salt in glycol, a solvent resembling glycerine in general character, may contain the dissolved electrolyte in a ‹highly ionized› state, while in a much better conducting solution the degree of ionization may be much smaller—the low conductivity of the first solution being the result of a very high friction and of the slow motion of the ions, while the well-conducting solution might show a very high degree of mobility of the ions.

    The mobility changes with the nature of the solvent, and the limit, Λ{∞}, of the equivalent conductivity of the salt, as found by Walden, ranges from 8 in glycol, which is a thick, viscous oil like glycerine, to 200 in acetonitrile, a thin mobile solvent.

    In the one solution, an observed conductivity of 4 represents 50% ionization of the salt, in the other only 2%.

    Now, for solutions of a given electrolyte—tetraethyl ammonium iodide was used—Walden[104] found the following exceedingly interesting relation between the ionizations in, and the dielectric constants of, various solvents:

    ‹e›{1} : ∛‹c›{1} = ‹e›{2} : ∛‹c›{2} = a constant,

    where ‹e›{1} and ‹e›{2} represent the dielectric constants of different solvents, and ‹c›{1} and ‹c›{2} represent the concentrations of the salt in the solvents when the salt is ‹ionized to the same degree[105] in the two solutions›.

    The bearing of the relation is apparent from the data in the following [p064] table.[106] The upper half of the table gives the dielectric constants (column two) of the solvents named in column one; the concentrations which show identical degrees of ionization—47%—are given in the third column, and the last column gives the value of the relation ‹e› : ∛‹c›. The lower half of the table presents the same kind of data, for the same salt, when its degree of ionization is 91%, in the different solutions examined. It is clear that the numbers in the third column of each part represent approximately constants.

    All solutions, including aqueous solutions, are thus brought into one general relation.

    Solvent. ‹e› ‹c› ‹e› : ∛‹c›
    Methyl alcohol 32.5 0.125 65
    Ethyl alcohol 21.7 0.020 80
    Acetyl bromide 16.2 0.010 75
    Benzaldehyde 16.9 0.016 78
    Acetonitril 35.8 0.100 77

    Water 80 0.00910 383
    Furfurol 39.4 0.00125 365
    Nitromethane 40 0.00125 371
    Acetonitril 36 0.00100 358
    Methyl alcohol 32.5 0.00050 365

    «The Ionizing Power of Solvents Related to the Unsaturated Condition of their Simple Molecules and to their Power of Association.»—A careful scrutiny of the group of highly-ionizing solvents (p. 62) brings out another interesting relation, to which attention is called because it is a chemical one, and which should always be considered in connection with reactions in such solvents. It is well known that ammonia is an ‹unsaturated› body, combining readily with all acids, and with many salts, such as copper sulphate.

    The fact may be recalled, that this unsaturated condition is ascribed to the unsaturated nitrogen atom in the molecule of ammonia, the nitrogen showing a valence of only 3 in ammonia, whereas in the derivatives it forms when it saturates itself with the compounds mentioned, ‹e.g.› in H_{4}NCl, it has five saturated valences. Assuming that a valence consists in a unit charge, positive or negative, on the atom (pp.

    42, 59), a view which has almost become a certainty, we should decide that the two free valences in ammonia must consist of a negative and a positive charge, as expressed in H_{3}N^{±}.

    (We may imagine such a double [p065] charge to be produced by the movement of one electron of the nitrogen atom to a position in that atom which would make one point of the atom negative and the other positive.) As a matter of fact, we find ammonia uniting with hydrogen chloride, by absorbing a positive and a negative fragment of it—producing H_{4}NCl from H_{3}N^{±} + H^{+} + Cl^{−}.

    It is also evident that, through these charges, ammonia could combine with itself to form larger complexes, ^{+}NH_{3}-NH_{3}^{−}, in which we would still have two opposite charges, presumably removed further from each other than in the simple molecule. The new molecule could, in turn, by virtue of its charges, combine with a further molecule to form a still larger or more ‹associated› molecule, ^{+}NH_{3}-NH_{3}-NH_{3}^{−}, and such ‹association› could evidently go still further.

    One can readily see that such molecules would be ‹electrically polarized›, and their charges might easily have the ‹power to cause[107] electrolytic dissociation or ionization›. The larger the associated molecule, the further apart might be the positive and negative charges upon it: the further apart the charges, the smaller would be their mutual attraction: and the smaller the mutual attraction, the stronger, presumably, would the dissociating power of such a molecule be.

    The dissociation may be effected, possibly, by the ‹action of these intensified charges› upon ‹charges already existing›[108] within the molecule of the dissolved ionogen.

    In liquid ammonia we might well have, for instance, the action ^{+}NH_{3}-NH_{3}^{−} + HCl ⇄ ^{+}(NH_{3}-NH_{3})H + Cl^{−}, or ^{+}NH_{3}-NH_{3}^{−} + H^{+}Cl^{−} ⇄ ^{+}(NH_{3}-NH_{3})H + Cl^{−}.

    Now, in liquid ammonia, the salts NH_{4}Cl, NH_{4}NO_{3} [or, more probably, (NH_{3}){‹x›}HCl, (NH{3}){‹x›},HNO{3}] have the functions of the aqueous acids[109]; that is, the ‹hydrogen-ion› of the acids is found ‹combined with the solvent› ammonia. The ion ^{+}(NH_{3}-NH_{3})H, and similar ions in liquid ammonia, would correspond then to what is considered the hydrogen-ion in aqueous solutions[110] (formed according to HCl ⇄ H^{+} + Cl^{−}, as ordinarily written), and the ‹polarized charges on molecules› like ^{+}NH_{3}-NH_{3}^{−} appear thus as ‹possible active agents› in this dissociation of the hydrogen chloride molecules. [p066]

    Now, it is a significant fact that all the best ionizing solvents are compounds whose simple ‹molecules are unsaturated› exactly like those of ammonia; this is true for water H_{2}O, the unsaturated character of whose oxygen atom is now universally recognized. It is now a familiar fact that liquid water is not represented by the formula H_{2}O but consists of more complex molecules (H_{2}O){n}.

    According to the most recent investigations,[111] while steam is H{2}O, or monohydrol, ice is trihydrol (H_{2}O){3}, and liquid water, at ordinary temperatures, a mixture consisting chiefly of dihydrol (H{2}O)_{2}, some trihydrol, and very little monohydrol.

    The proportion of the last appears to increase with a rise of temperature; the proportion of trihydrol seems to increase with a fall in temperature. One can easily see how such aggregates would result from the saturation of the free charges on oxygen, by further molecules of water. One can also see that such an association of water molecules could leave a positive and a negative charge on the associated molecules, which would be ‹polarized› and more effective than the simple molecule would be.

    That the molecule of hydrogen cyanide contains a similarly unsaturated atom was demonstrated by Nef.[112] He proved that the behavior of hydrocyanic acid agrees with the structure expressed by the formula HN=C=, which we may well write HN=C^{±}. In sulphur dioxide, another good ionizing solvent, we have, similarly, unsaturated sulphur, the sulphur atom being here quadrivalent, whereas its maximum valence is six.

    Now, the ionizing power of solvents like water, ammonia, etc., has been ascribed, by various chemists, not only to their dielectric properties, but also to the ‹unsaturated condition of their molecules, and particularly to their powers of association into large molecules›. The relations developed suggest that ‹all three properties are most intimately related›, the dielectric properties and the powers of association being consequences, possibly, of the fundamental condition of unsaturation, and of the great tendency toward self-saturation,[113] of the simple molecules of the best ionizing solvents.

    From Walden's work it appears that the dielectric constant finally determines the quantitative ionizing effect of a solvent.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [49] From the molecular weights of elements and compounds, the
    atomic weights of elements may be determined, with the aid of
    analysis. (‹Cf.› Smith, ‹Inorganic Chemistry› (1909), p. 196, or
    ‹General Chemistry for Colleges› (1908), p. 130 («Stud.»), or
    Remsen, ‹Inorganic Chemistry, Advanced Course› (1904), pp. 71–80
    («Stud.»).)

    [50] The weight of a small volume of a gas or vapor, at any
    definite temperature and pressure, is determined. With the aid of
    Boyle's and Gay-Lussac's laws, this observed volume is then reduced
    to standard conditions. Finally, the weight of 22.4 liters, under
    standard conditions, is obtained by calculation.

    [51] For the deduction of formulæ see Smith, ‹Inorganic Chemistry›,
    196, 203; ‹College Chemistry›, 40; or Remsen, ‹ibid.›, p. 79
    («Stud.»).

    [52] Kopp, ‹Liebig's Ann.›, «105», 390 (1858); Kékulé, ‹ibid.›,
    «106», 143 (1858) («Stud.»).

    [53] ‹Liebig's Ann.›, «123», 199 (1862) («Stud.»).

    [54] Wanklyn and Robison, ‹Compt. rend.›, «52», 549 (1863)
    («Stud.»).

    [55] For instance in a test tube held in a horizontal position.

    [56] By applying the corrections demanded by the kinetic theory
    (van der Waals's equation) to gases even under ordinary pressures,
    Guye and D. Berthollet have obtained, with the aid of Avogadro's
    hypothesis, values for the molecular weights of gases and for the
    atomic weights of their components, which compare in accuracy with
    the best analytical work on solutions and solids.

    [57] The usual experimental methods consist in determining
    the elevation of the boiling-point, or the lowering of the
    freezing-point, or the lowering of the vapor tension of a solvent
    by a solute, methods which were discovered by Raoult and used
    empirically until van 't Hoff developed their relations to the
    Avogadro principle. The calculation of a molecular weight is
    much simplified by the use of the different specific constants
    expressing the lowering or elevation produced by one gram-molecule
    or mole, dissolved either in one liter or in 100 grams of each
    specific solvent.

    [58] See Arrhenius, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «1», 631 (1887).

    [59] Or, on the basis of the accepted molecular weights, abnormally
    high osmotic pressures, abnormally great lowerings of the
    freezing-point, raisings of the boiling-point, etc., were obtained.
    Van 't Hoff, originally, on account of these discrepancies,
    considered this extension of the Avogadro Hypothesis to hold
    only for the "majority" of substances in solution, not for all
    (Arrhenius, ‹loc. cit.›). It was considered to have ‹universal›
    application (for dilute solutions) only after Arrhenius had
    explained the exceptions with the aid of his theory of electrolytic
    dissociation.

    [60] That is, hydrogen chloride, in aqueous solution, depresses the
    vapor tension and the freezing-point and elevates the boiling-point
    considerably more than an ‹equimolecular› quantity, for instance,
    of glucose does, and gives a considerably higher osmotic pressure.
    The differences are relatively greater, the more dilute the
    solutions used.

    [61] A fourth interpretation advanced at one time in opposition to
    the theory of ionization is that salts like sodium chloride and
    zinc chloride are ‹hydrolyzed› and thereby produce more solute
    molecules, ‹e.g.› NaCl + H_{2}O → NaOH + HCl.

    Aside from the fact
    that such hydrolysis of salts, when it does occur (Chapter X.), is
    easily detected, and that it can be proved not to occur appreciably
    in the case of sodium chloride (‹loc. cit.›), this interpretation
    fails utterly to account for the results obtained with ‹acids,
    e.g.› HCl, HNO_{3}, H_{2}SO_{4}, and with ‹bases›, ‹e.g.› NaOH,
    Ba(OH)_{2}, which in aqueous solutions show an increase in the
    number of molecules as great as shown by salts. This explanation is
    therefore untenable.

    [62] ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «1», 631, (1887). Previous papers were
    published in the transactions of the Royal Academy of Sweden
    (Stockholm). For a history of the theory see Ostwald, ‹Z. phys.
    Chem.›, «69», p. 1 (1909), and Arrhenius, ‹The Willard Gibbs
    Address›, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, 1911 («Stud.»).

    [63] In the case of double salts, such as sodium-ammonium
    phosphate, and similar compounds, the dissociation leads to
    the formation of more than two products. The molecules of two
    or more different products may then be charged positively and,
    conversely, there may be two or more different products of
    dissociation carrying negative charges. We have, for instance,
    ## Na(NH_{4})HPO_{4} ⇄ Na^{+} + NH_{4}^{+} + H^{+} + PO_{4}^{3−}
    and Na(NH_{4})HPO_{4} ⇄ Na^{+} + NH_{4}^{+} + HPO_{4}^{2−}.

    In
    all cases the rule concerning the sum of all the charges, as
    expressed in (2), must be fulfilled, the charge on the phosphate
    ion, PO_{4}^{3−}, being three times as great as that on a sodium,
    ammonium, or hydrogen ion; that on the acid phosphate ion,
    HPO_{4}^{2−}, being twice as great.

    [64] Ion = the going or the migrating particle.

    [65] See Washburn, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «31», 322 (1909), in regard
    to the values of ‹x› and ‹y›, the quantities of water carried by
    certain ions.

    [66] ‹Vide› J. J. Thomson, ‹Electricity and Matter› (1905) and
    ‹Corpuscular Theory of Matter› (1907) («Stud.»). ‹Vide› R.
    A. Millikan, ‹Science›, «32», 436 (1910), on the discrete or
    "granular" nature of electricity («Stud.»).

    [67] See ‹Millikan›, ‹loc. cit.›, as to the exact value of this
    "unit charge."

    [68] ‹Cf.› McCoy, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «33», March, 1911, in regard
    to electropositive, composite (‹i.e.› nonelementary) "metals."

    [69] The symbol ε is used to designate an electron. The loss of one
    electron by an atom leaves a ‹unit positive charge› on the particle.

    [70] In Chapter XV (‹q. v.›) the affinity of the elements for
    electrons and the reactions, of the nature of oxidation and
    reduction, depending on this affinity, are discussed in detail.

    [71] J. J. Thomson, ‹Corpuscular Theory of Matter›, p. 120.

    [72] A. A. Noyes (‹Carnegie Institution Publications›, No. «63», p.
    351 (1907)), believes that we may have two ‹kinds of molecules›,
    HCl and H^{+}Cl^{−}, as well as the ions H^{+} and Cl^{−}.

    [73] Modern theory thus is reverting to the Berzelius theory
    of chemical affinity [‹Vide› Meyer's ‹History of Chemistry›
    (translated by M'Gowan) 1891, 220–265, or Ladenburg's ‹History of
    Chemistry› (translated by Dobbin) 1900, 86, 88, etc.]

    [74] To a saturated solution of cupric nitrate may be added a
    small amount of a saturated solution of potassium permanganate,
    sufficient to give a decided purple color to the mixture. Potassium
    chromate, as recommended by A. A. Noyes, may be used in place of
    the permanganate. (‹Cf.› Noyes and Blanchard, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›,
    «22», 726 (1900).)

    [75] ‹Exp.›; ‹cf.› Eckstein, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «27», 759 (1905)
    («Stud.»).

    [76] W. A. Noyes, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «23», 460 (1901); Stieglitz,
    ‹ibid.›, «23», 796 (1901); Walden, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «43», 385
    (1903).

    [77] ‹Corpuscular Theory of Matter›, p. 130 (1907).

    [78] The experiment is an adaptation of a similar one described by
    A. A. Noyes and Blanchard, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «22», 726 (1900).

    [79] The copper electrodes are polarized by the formation of
    hydrogen on the cathode, but, in the course of a few seconds, the
    current becomes rather constant and is then read. The polarization
    may be considered as simply reducing the potential of the cell, and
    since, within the range of concentrations of acid used,—4-molar
    to 1/8-molar—the polarization current does not vary markedly,
    as compared with the potential of the storage cell, the total
    potential used through the series of dilutions may be considered
    sufficiently constant for the purposes of the experiment.

    Readings
    are made three or four seconds after each dilution, when the
    polarization has been fully established. Polarization may be
    entirely avoided by the use of a silver nitrate solution and silver
    electrodes or of a cupric salt solution and copper electrodes
    (Noyes and Blanchard). Hydrochloric acid is used here in order
    to carry the discussion in the text as far as possible with this
    typical ionogen. If one takes care to make readings as described,
    the result is quite satisfactory, as is shown by the comparison
    of the ratios of the readings with the ratios calculated from the
    known conductivities of the various dilutions (see table below).

    [80] Current = (Potential Difference) / Resistance, or
    Current = (Potential Difference) × Conductivity. For a ‹constant
    potential difference›, then, Current ~ Conductivity.

    [81] The ‹specific conductivity› of a solution (commonly designated
    by κ) is the conductivity of a cube of 1 cm. edge; the ‹molecular
    conductivity› is the conductivity of a mole of the electrolyte; the
    ‹equivalent conductivity› (designated by Λ) is the conductivity
    of a ‹gram-equivalent› of the electrolyte. Λ = κ × ‹v›, where
    ‹v› is the volume, expressed in cubic centimeters, containing
    the gram-equivalent.

    For instance, the resistance of 0.1 molar
    hydrochloric acid in a cube of 1 cm. edge is 28.5 ohms and its
    conductivity (κ) therefore 1 / 28.5 or 0.0351 reciprocal ohms.
    Since 10 liters or 10,000 c.c. of 0.1-molar hydrochloric acid is
    the volume (‹v›) containing one mole of the acid (the molar and the
    equivalent conductivities, for a monobasic acid being the same)
    Λ = 0.0351 × 10,000, or 351.

    [82] Kohlrausch and Holborn, p. 200.

    [83] Cf. Kahlenberg, ‹Transactions of the Faraday Society›, «1», 42
    (1905).

    [84] Clausius, ‹Poggendorf's Ann.›, «101», 347 (1857) («Stud.»).
    His theory replaced the older one of Grotthuss.

    [85] ‹Phil. Mag.›, «5», 729 (1903), and‹ Transactions of the
    Faraday Society›, «1», 55, (1905).

    [86] ‹Vide›, Hudson, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «31», 1136 (1909), for a
    recent summary of results.

    [87] ‹Lectures on Physical Chemistry›, «1», p. 131.

    [88] ‹Vide› A. A. Noyes and Blanchard, ‹J. Am. Chem. Soc.›, «22»,
    726 (1900).

    [89] The concentrations are figurative, but may be taken to
    represent actual concentrations, such as 0.015 molar, etc.

    [90] Kohlrausch and Holborn, ‹loc. cit.›, p. 200.

    [91] Raoult, ‹Ann. de Chim. et de Phys.› (6), «2», 84 (1884).

    [92] The degree of ionization of mercuric chloride is based on
    Raoult's freezing-point measurements and is subject to revision,
    and the limit of the mobility of the mercuric-ion (½ Hg) is assumed
    to be 48, close to the values found for the ions of zinc and
    cadmium, elements in the same family as mercury.

    [93] Lehfeldt's ‹Electrochemistry›, 1904, p. 3.

    [94] See table, p. 56.

    [95] Report of the British Association for the Advancement of
    Science, 1886, p. 389.

    [96] With the aid of more elaborate apparatus rigorous
    demonstrations and measurements of such diffusion currents of
    so-called "concentration cells" are made.

    [97] ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «63», 174 (1908). The work was carried out
    in Abegg's laboratory.

    [98] ‹Report of the St. Louis Congress of Arts and Sciences›, «IV»,
    314 (1904).

    [99] ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «20», «21», «23» (1898–1900).

    [100] Kablukoff, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «4», 429 (1889).

    [101] ‹Phil. Mag.› (5), «36», 320 (1893).

    [102] ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «13», 531 (1893).

    [103] Walden, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «54», 129 (1906); McCoy, ‹J. Am.
    Chem. Soc.›, «30», 1074 (1908).

    [104] ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «54», 229 (1906).

    [105] The degrees of ionization were always determined from the
    relation α = Λ_{‹v›} / Λ_{∞} according to the method discussed on
    page 50.

    [106] Walden, ‹loc. cit.›

    [107] ‹Cf.› Arrhenius, ‹Theories of Chemistry›, p. 83 (1907).

    [108] In hydrogen chloride, the hydrogen and the chlorine atoms may
    be held in the molecules H^{+}Cl^{−} by the electric attraction of
    a positive charge on the hydrogen, and a negative charge on the
    chlorine atom (see p. 43).

    [109] Franklin and Kraus, ‹Am. Chem. J.›, «23», 305 (1900) (Stud.)

    [110] It is very likely that in aqueous acids, a large proportion,
    at least, of the hydrogen-ion is similarly combined with water.
    (Lapworth, ‹J. Chem. Soc.›, (London) «93», 2187 (1908). See Chapter
    XII.)

    [111] ‹Vide› the discussion on the "Constitution of Water," ‹and
    the summary› by J. Walker, ‹Transactions of the Faraday Society›,
    «VI», 71–123 (1910).

    [112] ‹Proc. Am. Acad.›, 1892; Liebig's Ann. «287», 263 (1895).

    [113] ‹Cf.› Walden, ‹Z. phys. Chem.›, «55», 683 (1906).

    [p067]

    CHAPTER V

    «THE THEORY OF IONIZATION. II»

    IONIZATION AND OSMOTIC PRESSURE. IONIZATION AND CHEMICAL ACTIVITY

    We will turn now to the consideration of evidence bearing on the theory of ionization, found in the data on osmotic pressure.

    The apparent molecular weight of hydrogen chloride is found to be smaller than 36.5, when determined in aqueous solution (p. 37), and it is found to approach the limit 18.25 as a more and more dilute acid is used.[114] The value found represents the average molecular weight of all the molecules in any solution, the osmotic pressure, freezing-point or boiling-point of which has been taken.

    It is evident that, if there is dissociation of hydrogen chloride into hydrogen and chloride ions, the average values found for the molecular weight must be lower than 36.5, ‹must be variable›, and must ‹approach› the ‹limit› 18.25, as the dissociation into the smaller molecules becomes more and more complete. Such a result is, therefore, what we would anticipate on the basis of the theory of ionization.

    For a salt like potassium chloride KCl, a similar tendency toward a minimum, average molecular weight of (K^{+} + Cl^{−}) / 2 or (39.1 + 35.5) / 2 = 37.3 would be anticipated, and, as a matter of fact, molecular weight determinations with potassium chloride in aqueous solution give results agreeing with such a tendency.[115] For a salt like calcium chloride, on the other hand, we would expect that its ionization into ‹three› ions, according to the equation CaCl_{2} ⇄ Ca^{2+} + 2 Cl^{−}, would give a minimum, not of one-half the formula weight, but of one-third, viz., (Ca^{2+} + 2 Cl^{−}) / 3 or (40 + 71) / 3 = 37, when the molecular weight determination is carried out in aqueous solution.

    As a matter of fact, with salts of this type, the determinations, by osmotic pressure methods, indicate a dissociation into ‹three› smaller components, as required by the theory. It may be added that, for [p068] a salt, sodium mellitate, Na_{6}(C_{12}O_{12}), the salt of a hexabasic acid, Taylor found average molecular weights tending to a minimum of ‹one-seventh› of the formula weight, as we should expect from the ionization of the salt into seven smaller molecules, (C_{12}O_{12})Na_{6} ⇄ 6 Na^{+} + (C_{12}O_{12})^{6−}.

    «Quantitative Evidence.»—Some of the most exact quantitative evidence bearing on these relations, such as the results of investigations, by Griffith and by Taylor, on the freezing-point depressions of solutions of electrolytes, may be briefly considered. The depression of the freezing-point of a given solvent by a solute is proportional to the concentration of the solute or proportional to its osmotic pressure. Further, according to the Van 't Hoff Hypothesis (p.

    15), the osmotic pressure at a constant temperature is dependent only on the number of molecules present in unit volume, and not on the nature or composition of the molecules: the freezing-point of the solvent is depressed, likewise, proportionally to the total concentration of the solute, irrespective of the fact whether the solution contains only one, or more than one molecular species. ‹The ratio, observed depression / concentration›,[116] or ‹Δ› / ‹C›, ‹should be constant›,[117] therefore, in a given solvent, for dilute solutions of all kinds of solutes, simple or mixed.

    Griffith[118] found, for a solution of cane sugar, a non-electrolyte, in water, the ratio of the freezing-point depression to the concentration to be 1.858°. For instance, the freezing-point of a 0.01 molar solution of cane sugar (3.42 grams of cane sugar per liter; C_{12}H_{22}O_{11} = 342) is found to be −0.01858°, and 0.01858 / 0.01 = 1.858. This ratio should be the same, as stated above, according to van 't Hoff's theory of solutions, for dilute aqueous solutions of all solutes.

    But the ratio ‹Δ› / ‹C› for an aqueous solution of potassium chloride, an electrolyte, ‹was found to increase slowly› and ‹continuously› until in 0.0003 molar solution the ratio 3.72 was found, which is exactly twice the value obtained with cane sugar. The result indicates, therefore, a ‹gradual dissociation› of the potassium chloride with ‹increasing› dilution, and a ‹dissociation, ultimately, of each molecule› of the salt into ‹two› new molecules, in all respects exactly as demanded by the theory of Arrhenius.

    Loomis[119] found in a similar way a ratio of 3.61 for HCl, 3.71 [p069] for KOH, 3.60 for KCl, 3.67 for NaCl, 3.73 for HNO_{3}, etc., when 0.01 molar aqueous solutions were used. For similar solutions of calcium chloride CaCl_{2}, magnesium chloride MgCl_{2}, and sodium sulphate Na_{2}SO_{4}, the value 5.07 was found as the ratio between the depressions of the freezing-point and the concentration of the salts in extremely dilute solutions—a result showing, plainly, a dissociation of each salt into ‹three smaller molecules›.

    The limit 5.67 for such a dissociation is not quite reached in these cases, because salts of the types Me″X_{2} and Me_{2}′Y″ ionize less readily than do the electrolytes Me′X′, a fact also shown by their conductivities.

    We thus find that the most exact work on molecular weight determinations in ‹dilute› aqueous solutions agrees excellently, as does the conductivity of such solutions, with the demands of the theory of ionization, a fact which is particularly impressive because osmotic pressure and electrical conductivity are in no wise fundamentally related phenomena, and yet each, as a measure of ionization or electrolytic dissociation, leads independently to the same conclusion.[120]

    «The Chemical Composition of the Ions of Electrolytes.»—Accepting the theory of Arrhenius, we may now inquire more closely than heretofore, first, what compounds are subject to electrolytic dissociation, and then, what the chemical composition of their ions is and how it is determined.

    The compounds which are dissociated into ions, by solvents which cause ionization (p. 62), comprise the ‹salts›, the ‹acids› and the ‹bases›; chemists are, in fact, more inclined now to invert the statement and say that those substances which have long been known as salts, acids and bases, owe the essential characteristics, which led to their classification, to the fact that they are ionizable (see pp. 72–82).

    The composition of the ions, formed from the simpler of these compounds,[121] may be expressed by saying that the metal component or metal-like component (hydrogen, ammonium) forms the positive ion (cation, metal ion) and all the rest of the [p070] molecule forms the negative ion (anion, acid ion[122]).

    Thus, sodium chloride, nitrate, sulphate, phosphate yield the sodium-ion, Na^{+}, and the chloride (Cl^{−}), nitrate (NO_{3}^{−}), sulphate (SO_{4}^{2−}), or phosphate (PO_{4}^{3−}) ions; cupric nitrate Cu(NO_{3}){2} dissociates into the cupric ion (Cu^{2+}) and the nitrate ion, calcium sulphate CaSO{4} into the calcium-ion (Ca^{2+}) and the sulphate-ion, aluminium sulphate Al_{2}(SO_{4})_{3} into the aluminium-ion (Al^{3+}) and the sulphate-ion.

    But the question arises, as to how we know that the salts mentioned produce ions of the given composition; why, for instance, should sodium nitrate be considered to dissociate into sodium, Na^{+}, and nitrate ions, NO_{3}^{−}, the nitrogen atom carrying all of the oxygen atoms with it in the negative ion?

    [Illustration: FIG. 13.]

    The composition of the ions of a salt can be determined experimentally[123] by devices of which the U-tube experiment (p.

    1. may be considered to be a simple type. For instance, if we wish

    to determine the composition of the ions of sodium nitrate, we could cover a solution of sodium nitrate with a solution, say, of hydrochloric acid, pass a current through the liquids, and determine the composition of the components that have moved to the negative and positive poles, respectively. In practice, the device could be elaborated for the sake of convenience. Stopcocks, for instance, might be placed in the U-tube, at the points of separation of the nitrate solution and the hydrochloric acid (see Fig.

    13), the stopcocks being opened only during the passage of the current. Or porous plates or cells might be used, in place of stopcocks, at these [p071] points.

    Now, if we assume sodium nitrate to be dissociated, not into Na^{+} and NO_{3}^{−}, but let us say into positive ions NaO^{+} and negative ions NO_{2}^{−}, the changes which would result from the passage of a current would be as follows: starting with the action at the positive pole, we should find chloride ions discharged and chlorine evolved at the pole (the evolution of chlorine could be avoided, if considered desirable, by the use of a silver anode, which would absorb the liberated chloride-ion to form insoluble silver chloride on the electrode).

    At the same time, hydrogen ions would move out of the space ‹P›, being repelled by the positive pole, and attracted by the negative. At the boundary between the sodium nitrate solution and the hydrochloric acid, the negative ions of sodium nitrate, which we are supposing to have the composition NO_{2}^{−}, would move up from ‹B› toward the positive pole (‹cf.› exp., p.

    45), being attracted by its charge; at any moment we should have in any part of ‹P› as many negative ions (Cl^{−} and NO_{2}^{−}), as there are hydrogen ions, the solution showing no excess of free electricity at any point. Now, if NO_{2}^{−} were the ion that moved up into the space ‹P›, then we should presently find ‹nitrous› acid ‹around› the ‹positive pole› in space ‹P›, H^{+} and NO_{2}^{−} combining to form nitrous acid, HNO_{2}.

    But, as a matter of experiment, although the tests for nitrous acid belong to the most sensitive ones in chemistry, no trace of this acid is found there; what we do find is ‹nitric acid›, HNO_{3}, resulting obviously from the presence in space ‹P› of both hydrogen ions and ‹nitrate ions›, NO_{3}^{−}, which have moved up from space ‹B›.

    It is clear, that the presence of nitric acid in the region around the positive pole means that the nitrogen atoms must have carried with them all three of the oxygen atoms of the nitrate—in a word, that the composition of the negative ion of sodium nitrate is NO_{3}^{−} and not, say, NO_{2}^{−}.

    Similarly, considering what happens in space ‹N›, round the negative pole, we have here an evolution of hydrogen, a migration of some chloride ions out of ‹N› into the space ‹C›, and, at the same time, a migration of the positive ions of space ‹C› into the division ‹N›.

    On examining the solution in ‹N›, we now find sodium chloride, with unchanged hydrochloric acid, exactly what we should expect from the migration of the ion Na^{+} toward the negative electrode.[124] If the positive ion were, say, [p072] NaO^{+}, we should expect to obtain either some of the hypochlorite NaOCl (NaO^{+} + Cl^{−}), or, at least, an evolution of oxygen in this place, since sodium chloride is formed.

    As a matter of experiment, no oxygen is evolved here, and no trace of hypochlorite is found in ‹N› round the negative pole, although the tests for hypochlorites are extremely sensitive.

    Comparatively simple methods, in principle of the nature outlined, enable us, then, to ‹determine experimentally› the composition of the ions into which ionizable compounds, salts, acids and bases, dissociate. Whenever any doubt may exist about the composition of the ions of a given electrolyte, this device may be employed to settle the matter, and there will presently be occasion to employ the U-tube for such a purpose.

    ‹Ionization and Chemical Activity.›—The fact that the theory of ionization gives us adequate explanations of the conductivity shown by dissolved electrolytes and of their abnormally high osmotic pressures, would have been in itself of interest to chemists; but, if its applications were limited to these phenomena, we should not be considering it in connection with qualitative chemical analysis, nor would the theory, presumably, have greatly affected the development of chemistry, as it has done.

    It is the fact that the electrolytic dissociation of an electrolyte into its ions involves ‹chemical› changes of the most profound nature, and most intimately affects ‹chemical› reactivity, that has made it play, in the last two decades, such a leading rôle in the development of chemistry, and that makes it necessary to include its consequences in the consideration of analytical problems, if one would understand, as far as present knowledge permits, the reactions involved in chemical analysis.

    Hydrogen chloride, as a perfectly dry gas, is a non-conductor of electricity and, at the same time, it is found to be chemically ‹inactive›—it does not combine, for instance, with dry ammonia[125] or act upon dry calcium carbonate[126] or on dry litmus. Hydrogen chloride, subjected to great pressure at a low temperature, is liquefied. The liquid is also a very poor conductor of [p073] electricity[127] and does not show the chemical activity of ordinary, aqueous hydrochloric acid; it does not combine with calcium oxide or attack marble, zinc, iron or even magnesium.[127]

    A solution of hydrogen chloride in a poorly ionizing medium, like benzene or toluene, is an extremely poor conductor. There is an extremely small conductivity indicating only a trace of ionization.[128]

    EXP. A solution of hydrogen chloride, prepared by passing the dried gas into benzene or toluene (thiophene-free benzene will not become discolored), and kept anhydrous by means of fused calcium chloride, is tested for its conductivity, by dipping into it electrodes connected with a lighting circuit and a galvanometer.

    Such a solution behaves chemically, also, quite differently from the aqueous solutions of hydrogen chloride with which we are familiar: dry steel nails,[129] dropped into it, will remain almost unchanged—there is no marked evolution of hydrogen (‹exp.›).

    Perfectly dried marble, added to it, will not give rise to the evolution of carbon dioxide[129] (‹exp.›). We find thus, in all the cases discussed—the nonconducting dry gas, the anhydrous liquefied hydrogen chloride and the anhydrous benzene solution—an absence of ionization,[130] as indicated by the lack of conductivity, and, along with this, a lack of the familiar action of hydrochloric acid as an acid.

    If we dissolve the gas in water, we obtain a well-conducting solution (‹exp.›), in which, according to molecular weight determinations, the [p074] hydrogen chloride is more or less largely ionized, and this same solution has all the well-known chemical properties of hydrochloric acid—it evolves hydrogen liberally when given an opportunity to act upon zinc or iron (‹exp.›), it evolves carbon dioxide copiously when marble is brought into contact with it (‹exp.›).

    In such an aqueous solution we have both the ions of the acid and the more or less non-ionized hydrogen chloride, the action (HCl ⇄ H^{+} + Cl^{−}) being reversible.

    Now, since in those cases in which we have admittedly only non-ionized hydrogen chloride, there is no vigorous chemical action, we are bound to conclude that, in the aqueous solution where we have both the non-ionized and the ionized substance, it must be the new components, the ions of the acid, which give this solution its new qualities, the well-known properties of a pronounced acid.[131] This conclusion, that the acid properties of hydrogen chloride in aqueous solution are due to the ionized hydrogen chloride, rather than to the hydrogen chloride itself, is one of fundamental importance.

    «Dry Salts and their Aqueous Solutions.»—If the study of the relation of ionization to chemical activity be extended, it is found that a dry salt, such as, for example, silver nitrate, in crystals or finely pulverized, is not perceptibly ionized, for it is a non-conductor (‹exp.›). The same result is obtained with potassium chromate. If the dry powders are intimately mixed, there is no chemical action between them, no perceptible change occurs.

    The aqueous solutions of the salts are excellent conductors (‹exp.›), as are the aqueous solutions of almost all salts; the dissolved salts are therefore largely ionized. As soon as the ionizing medium, water, is added to the dry, yellow mixture of silver nitrate and potassium chromate, instantly a chemical change results—red silver chromate, Ag_{2}CrO_{4}, is precipitated (‹exp.›). Now, in the aqueous solution of these salts we have both non-ionized molecules and their ions:

    AgNO_{3} ⇄ Ag^{+} + NO_{3}^{−},

    K_{2}CrO_{4} ⇄ 2 K^{+} + CrO_{4}^{2−}.

    Since there is no interaction when the dry salts, containing only the non-ionized substances, are mixed, and since there is interaction [p075] when the solutions are mixed, in which both the non-ionized and the ionized salts are present, one must conclude again that the formation of silver chromate is the result of the action of the silver ions on the chromate ions in the solution. In point of fact, there could hardly fail to be an action, since the positive silver ions and the negative chromate ions, moving in all directions through the solution, must collide and be discharged, or combine, to form molecular silver chromate.

    This salt happens to be very difficultly soluble, and to be colored red, as well, so that silver chromate is precipitated and is immediately recognizable.

    The two dry powders in the experiment were allowed to be in contact for only a few moments. It is important to note, therefore, that dry sodium acid carbonate and dry potassium acid tartrate are also nonconductors (‹exp.›), and that the intimate mixture of these two powders is kept for years in the well-known form of baking powders without appreciable decomposition—yet best in tin vessels, to exclude moisture. The aqueous solutions, however, are good conductors (‹exp.›), and, when dissolved, these salts are more or less ionized.

    The addition of water to the mixed salts (‹exp.›) leads at once to the well-known action, carbon dioxide being liberated and sodium-potassium tartrate or Rochelle salt being formed.

    «Behavior of Fused Salts.»—It may be objected that there are common cases, where dry salts are known to act upon each other; barium sulphate is fused with sodium carbonate to convert the former into the carbonate, BaSO_{4} + Na_{2}CO_{3} ⇄ Na_{2}SO_{4} + BaCO_{3}.

    Before one decides that this must be an instance of the action of non-ionized salts on each other, the conductivity of dry salts under the conditions of the experiment, namely at an elevated temperature, must be examined. There is no difficulty in recognizing that while dry sodium carbonate or potassium nitrate at ordinary temperatures does not conduct a current, and is not perceptibly ionized, each salt, when fused, becomes an excellent conductor (‹exp.›,[132] with potassium nitrate). It is, in fact, well known that, in many electrolytic operations, fused salts[133] are used in place [p076] of solutions.

    It must be added that the heat, not the change of state, causes the ionization, careful work having shown that conductivity begins to be appreciable below the point of fusion.

    EXP. Two platinum wires, fused, one inch apart, into a glass rod, are connected with a sensitive galvanometer and the lighting circuit. When the glass is warmed, a current is found to pass.

    The action between barium sulphate and sodium carbonate at a high temperature does not mean, then, that the non-ionized salts interact; on the contrary, we find that, under such conditions, coincident with the evidence of reactivity, we have also decided conductivity—again indicating decided ionization.

    «Dry Salts at Ordinary Temperatures.»—Inasmuch as ordinary temperatures are still far removed from the absolute zero, one must suppose that dry salts must be ionized, minimally at least, even at room temperature, and should therefore react with each other. Presumably they do, only so slowly, as a result of the minimal degrees of ionization, and of the few chances of collision between ions of opposite charges, owing to the restricted range of the molecular motions, that the total change is imperceptible.

    Critical work on the question is most desirable. In this connection it maybe said that Spring[134] found that dry salts do interact at ordinary temperature, when ‹subjected to great pressures›, provided the volume of the products is smaller than the volume of the initial substances. Whether this action is due to the ionization of the salts, minimal as it is, or whether we have here a case of interaction of non-ionized molecules, has not, it seems, been determined; it would require difficult quantitative work to settle the question.

    «Influence of Light and Heat.»—It is apparent that heat, a form of energy, contributes to the dissociation of ionogens, and it is natural that we should consider other forms of energy, ‹e.g.› light, to have the same power. One may speculate about the possibility of light inducing chemical action (‹e.g.› in starting the combination of hydrogen and chlorine, or in photography) by its ionizing power, and about the possibility that rapid combination of oxygen and hydrogen follows the application of a flame to the mixture, as the result of increased ionization of the components at the elevated temperature of the flame and of the burning gases.

    The experimental evidence shows that, in some actions of this nature, ionization is an important factor, while in other instances it appears to be negligible.[135] [p077]

    «Conclusions.»—It appears that we must accept the conclusion, that the ‹reactions of salts›, ‹acids› and ‹bases› (ionogens) ‹in aqueous solution› (the so-called "salt reactions") ‹are the reactions of the ions and not of the non-ionized molecules.› This conclusion is of the greatest and most practical importance in our science. It is the natural inference from the results of the qualitative experiments described in the three preceding sections. Its final adoption, however, is based on the existence of a great mass of ‹quantitative evidence›, and to the consideration of some of this we now turn.

    «Quantitative Relations.»—If the active components in aqueous solutions of acids, bases and salts are the ions, rather than the undissociated compounds, then quantitative data supporting such a conclusion should be found. Such quantitative confirmation, from the point of view of chemical activity, is not lacking. Only a small part of the data can be considered here.

    Conductivity measurements, and the lowering of freezing-points and the elevation of boiling-points, show that there are very decided differences ‹in the degrees of ionization of different acids and bases› in solutions of equivalent concentration. For instance, potassium hydroxide is somewhat more ionized than is barium hydroxide, and decidedly more so than ammonium hydroxide, a fact that can readily be demonstrated by the conductivities of the solutions[136]:

    EXP. Equivalent solutions (1 / 10 normal) of the three bases are introduced into three vertical tubes, containing electrodes connected, in parallel, with a lighting circuit and with small electric lamps. When the two electrodes in each of the three tubes are at equal distances from each other, the lamp connected with the potassium hydroxide solution glows most brightly, that connected with the barium hydroxide solution a little less brightly, and the lamp connected with the ammonium hydroxide solution does not glow at all—not enough current is

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis, vol. 1, parts 1 and 2.
    Author
    Julius Stieglitz
    Release date
    February 23, 2014 [eBook #44986]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Juliet Sutherland, RichardW, and the Online
    Most recently updated
    October 24, 2024
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
     THE ELEMENTS OF QUALITATIVE CHEMICAL ANALYSIS
    
     WITH
    
     SPECIAL CONSIDERATION OF THE APPLICATION OF
     THE LAWS OF EQUILIBRIUM AND OF THE
     MODERN THEORIES OF SOLUTION
    
     BY
     JULIUS STIEGLITZ
     ‹Professor of Chemistry in the University of Chicago›
    
     VOLUME I
     PARTS I AND II
     FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES AND THEIR APPLICATION
    
     [Illustration]
    
     NEW YORK
     THE CENTURY CO.
     1920
    
    
    
    
     COPYRIGHT, 1911,
     BY
     THE CENTURY CO.
    
     ‹Printed, October, 1911›
     ‹Reprinted, August, 1912›
     ‹Reprinted, October, 1913›
     ‹Reprinted, October, 1915›
     ‹Reprinted, August, 1917›
     ‹Reprinted, January, 1919›
     ‹Reprinted, August, 1919›
     ‹Reprinted, November, 1919›
     ‹Reprinted, July, 1920›
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis, vol. 1, parts 1 and 2.
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Elements of Qualitative Chemical Analysis, vol. 1, parts 1 and 2.
    
    Author: Julius Stieglitz
    
    
            
    Release date: February 23, 2014 [eBook #44986]
                    Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/44986
    
    Credits: Produced by Juliet Sutherland, RichardW, and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #44986. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 44986
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.