
Gutenberg · ebook 43472
English Poor Law Policy
by Sidney Webb · English · public domain in the US
PREFACE
Nothing of to-day, it may be suggested, can be really understood
without its history. This, at any rate, is true of the complicated
policy of the English Poor Law, which is now (1910) costing the
public (for the United Kingdom) close upon twenty millions sterling
every year; and which is producing, on the whole, results which
led the Royal Commissioners of 1905-1909, without distinction
of political or economic party or creed, to their unanimous and
emphatic condemnatory verdict.
That policy is embodied in a
bewildering chaos of Statutes and Orders, Circulars and Minutes,
general reports and official letters, the specific provisions of
which, so far as they are contemporaneously in force, and so far
as they are publicly known, the legal text-books and elementary
manuals seek to re-arrange in such a way that the Poor Law Guardian
or Workhouse Master may learn, at any rate, what is legally
prescribed.
But though a precise statement of what is to-day
prescribed, in alphabetical or other order, may suffice for the
practical work of the administrator, it does not afford us any
idea of the general policy that lies behind the prescriptions, and
fails even to enable the ordinary citizen to understand what is
being done. We suggest, in short, that the English Poor Law policy
of to-day cannot be correctly appreciated, or even intelligently
comprehended, without some knowledge of the stages through which,
in the course of the past seventy-five years, it has gradually
been moulded into its present form.
To any one who compares the
contents of the Annual Report of the Local Government Board of
to-day with those of the slim little volume in which the Poor Law
Commissioners of 1835 described their activity, it will be evident
that, throughout the whole range of the Poor Law, the Policy of
the Central Authority has undergone great changes. What these
changes have actually been, and at what dates and in what order
they occurred, the following chronological analysis of the action
of the Poor Law Commissioners, the Poor Law Board, and the Local
Government Board for England and Wales attempts to set forth.
The extent, the complication, and what may be thought the aridity
of this analysis may probably daunt many who ought to read it. But
if they will persevere, they will find that the severe and exact
chronological record through which they are taken with regard to
each class of paupers--the Able-bodied, the Vagrants, the Sick,
the Women, the Children, the Aged, etc.--will presently reveal to
them the current in which they are themselves moving, the stream
of tendencies down which we are all floating, with a clearness
of comprehension not otherwise to be obtained.
It is here not a
question of whether we approve of this evolution of policy, or of
whether we should seek to promote or to resist it, but merely of
what exactly it has been, and therefore now is.
In view of the attention given to the Poor Law by many writers,
it is, perhaps, a matter for surprise, that no such chronological
analysis of policy has before been undertaken. Except in regard to
a few special matters, it is impossible, in any published work, to
trace the exact course of development of English Poor Law policy
since the great revolution of 1834. The most systematic books upon
the English Poor Law System, such as those by Dr.
Aschrott and
Monsieur Émile Chevalier,[1] have confined themselves, in the main,
to a description of the contemporary state of things, with only
comparatively brief and general accounts of how it came about. The
popular manuals, such as the admirable little book of the Rev. T.
W. Fowle, can naturally only give such scraps of history as are
current.[2] Even Mr.
Mackay, in adding a third volume to Sir George
Nicholls' History of the English Poor Law,[3] has limited himself
to a series of essays on particular points, without attempting
any but the briefest chronological analysis of the evolution of
policy of the Central Authority since 1834, upon which the whole
administration of the Boards of Guardians depends.
[1] See, for instance, The English Poor Law System, by Paul
Felix Aschrott, translated by H. Preston Thomas, 1888 and 1902;
La Loi des pauvres et la société anglaise, par E. Chevalier,
1895; The Better Administration of the Poor Law, by Sir William
Chance, Bart., 1895; The Public Relief of the Poor, by T.
Mackay, 1901; L'Assistance légale et la lutte contre le
pauperisme en Angleterre, par G. E. de Froment, 1905.
[2] The Poor Law, by the Rev. T. W. Fowle, 1881; The English
Poor Laws, by Miss Sophia Lonsdale, 1897 and 1902; Our Treatment
of the Poor, by Sir Wm. Chance, Bart, 1899; The Public Relief of
the Poor, by T. Mackay, 1901.
[3] History of the English Poor Law, vol. iii., from 1834 to the
present time, by T. Mackay, 1899.
It is easy to understand this general reluctance to work out,
from the materials themselves, the Poor Law history of the last
three-quarters of a century. As with all nineteenth-century
history, the extent, the variety, and the intricacy of the
various sources are simply overwhelming.
The number of official
records--Statutes, Orders, Circulars, Minutes, Reports, Letters,
etc.--dealt with for the present small volume (although we have
confined ourselves in the main to the publications of the Central
Authority itself, and have not been able to consult the manuscript
records and letter-books of more than a score of the Boards of
Guardians) runs into, literally, tens of thousands.
So great a mass of documentary material, without arrangement,
unclassified, unindexed, formless, and void of any obvious
significance, could be dealt with only by a systematic exploration.
We may here describe, as an instance of sociological method, the
plan that we adopted. What obscured the history was the manner in
which masses of heterogeneous facts were heaped together. To read,
one after another, these complicated Orders and lengthy Reports,
each dealing with all kinds of paupers and various methods of
relief, was but to accumulate confusion.
They resembled a heap of
geological conglomerates which could not be assayed until they had
been broken up in such a way as to sort the different materials
into separate homogeneous parcels. We discarded all idea of making
précis, summaries, or analyses of particular statutes or orders,
believing that in this way brevity is gained only at the expense
of omitting important qualifications.
After the choice of a
provisional scheme of classification, to which careful thought was
given, the expressions of policy embodied in each document were all
severally copied on loose sheets of paper of even size and shape.
Every prescription or dictum conveying an expression of policy with
regard to a particular class of paupers was placed upon a separate
sheet. Thus, a single Order or Circular might yield items relating
to women, to children, to persons on Outdoor Relief, to the sick,
to the aged, and so on.
However many and however closely related
were the classes to which the same prescription applied, it was
noted on a separate sheet for each of them, with the date and place
and exact source. To deal in this way, with scrupulous accuracy
and exhaustiveness, with all the Statutes, all the General Orders,
all the Special Orders, all the Circulars, all the published
Minutes, all the official reports, and all the letters of the
Central Authority to which we could gain access absorbed something
like nine months' continuous work. But for the first time order
was evolved out of chaos.
It was easy to sort the loose sheets by
subjects, and to arrange each series chronologically. This done, we
had before us, separated out from the mass, every prescription or
dictum as to the policy to be pursued, or the action to be taken
with regard to each particular class. The series of prescriptions
and suggestions with regard to children, for instance, could be
read in chronological sequence. At this stage it needed little
ingenuity to seize the salient points. The development of policy
leaped to the eyes.
Another three months' work enabled the record
to be put into a series of continuous narratives, with precise
references to the original authorities.
The reader who wants merely to know what it all amounts to should
turn to the last four chapters. Here he will find, succinctly set
forth, first "The Principles of 1907," being the principles on
which, as a matter of fact, the Local Government Board was (and
still is) proceeding, in contrast with "The Principles of 1834,"
from which seventy-five years of experience have reluctantly driven
it.
In subsequent chapters will be found a critical examination
of both the Majority and the Minority Reports of the Poor Law
Commission of 1905-1909, in the light of these "Principles of 1834"
and "Principles of 1907," with an attempt to appreciate what is
novel in those Reports, and to estimate how far they are severally
consistent with a due enforcement of personal responsibility.[4]
If the reader or reviewer is still more impatient he will probably
content himself with the final summary and conclusion.
[4] The Minority Report has been separately published in book
form, in two volumes, The Break Up of The Poor Law, and The
Public Organization of the Labour Market, each edited, with an
introduction, by S. and B. Webb (Longmans. 1909).
It remains for us to acknowledge the help without which this work
could not have been accomplished. The task was undertaken at the
suggestion of the Royal Commission on the Poor Law; and it formed
the subject of a report circulated to the Commission in July
1907. No printed document has been quoted which is not published
to the world; and (with trifling exceptions of ancient date) no
unprinted Minute or Letter has been used which has not been issued
as a public document, or is not freely accessible in the official
archives.
But we owe to the officials of the Local Government Board
and of the Boards of Guardians concerned--and among so many it
would be invidious to particularise--not only various facilities
for consulting these public documents, but also many helpful
suggestions, criticisms, and corrections of errors of fact.
Above
all we are indebted to Miss Mary Longman, of Girton College,
Cambridge, and of the London School of Economics and Political
Science, for the whole of the laborious service of effecting, under
our direction, the preliminary breaking-up of the conglomerates,
and much help in the more interesting work of making the final
assay. Without this zealous, unsparing, and devoted assistance, we
could not have found time to execute the work. Mrs. F. H.
Spencer,
D.Sc. (Econ.), investigated for us the records of various Boards
of Guardians up and down the country, in order to trace their
official correspondence with the Poor Law Commissioners, the Poor
Law Board, and the Local Government Board. To Miss Mildred Bulkley,
B.Sc. (Econ.), also of the London School of Economics and Political
Science, we owe not only many suggestions of value, but also the
checking of all the references, the correcting of the proofs, and
the preparing of the index.
SIDNEY AND BEATRICE WEBB.
41 GROSVENOR ROAD, WESTMINSTER.
January, 1910.
CONTENTS PAGE
PREFACE v
CHAPTER I
THE REVOLUTION OF 1834 1
The 1834 Report--National Uniformity--The
Able-bodied--Vagrants--Women--The Children--The Sick--The Aged and
Impotent (or Infirm)--The Workhouse--Emigration--Relief on
Loan--The Principles of 1834.
The Act of 1834 and its Amendments--National Uniformity--The
Able-bodied--Vagrants--Women--Children--The Sick--The Aged and
Impotent--The Workhouse--Emigration--Relief on Loan.
CHAPTER II
THE POOR LAW COMMISSIONERS 21
The Able-bodied (i.) on Outdoor Relief, (ii.) in the
Workhouse--Vagrants--Women--Children--The Sick--Persons of Unsound
Mind--Defectives--The Aged and Infirm--Non-Residents--The
Workhouse--Admission--Segregation--Service--Diet--Cleanliness and
Sanitation--Discipline--Employment--Sanctions--Discharge and
Detention--The Workhouse of the General Consolidated Order of
1847--The position in 1847 compared with the Principles of 1834.
CHAPTER III
THE POOR LAW BOARD 88
The Able-bodied--National Uniformity--Municipal Work for the
Unemployed--Vagrants--Women--Children--The Sick--Persons of
Unsound Mind--Defectives--The Aged and Infirm--Non-Residents--The
Workhouse--Emigration--Relief on Loan--Co-operation with Voluntary
Agencies--The Position in 1871.
CHAPTER IV
THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT BOARD 147
The Able-bodied--National Uniformity--The Workhouse Test--The Labour
Test--The modified Workhouse Test Order--The Test Workhouse--The
Provision of Employment--The Farm
Colony--Vagrants--Women--Children (i.) on Outdoor Relief; (ii.) in
Poor Law Schools; (iii.) the Workhouse Children; (iv.) The
Education of the Indoor Pauper Child; (v.) Boarding-out; (vi.)
Apprenticeship; (vii.) Adoption--The Sick--Domiciliary
Treatment--Institutional Treatment--The Municipal Medical
Service--Persons of Unsound Mind--Defectives--The Aged and
Infirm--Outdoor Relief--Indoor Relief--Non-Residents--The
Workhouse--Emigration--Relief on Loan--Co-operation with Voluntary
Agencies.
CHAPTER V
THE PRINCIPLES OF 1907 257
The Departures from the Principles of 1834--The Principle of National
Uniformity--The Principle of Less Eligibility--The Workhouse
System--New Principles unknown in 1834--The Principle of Curative
Treatment--The Principle of Universal Provision--The Principle of
Compulsion--The Contrast between 1834 and 1907--No Man's Land.
CHAPTER VI
THE MAJORITY REPORT OF THE ROYAL COMMISSION OF 1905-1909 274
The Principles of 1907--The Plea for a Single Destitution Authority--
The Reversion to 1834--The mutual Incompatibility of the Proposals
of the Majority Report--The Principle of Curative Treatment and a
Destitution Authority--The Principle of Compulsion and a
Destitution Authority--The Principle of Universal Provision and a
Destitution Authority.
CHAPTER VII
THE MINORITY REPORT OF THE ROYAL COMMISSION OF 1905-1909 296
The Principle of Prevention--The "Moral Factor" in the Problem of
Destitution--The Sphere of Voluntary Agencies in the Prevention of
Destitution.
CHAPTER VIII
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION 312
APPENDIX A 321
Memorandum by the Local Government Board as to the Local Authorities
for Poor Law purposes and the Out-relief Orders in force at the
end of the years 1847, 1871, 1906.
APPENDIX B 343
Extract from the Minority Report for Scotland giving the reasons in
favour of the Complete Supersession of the Poor Law.
INDEX OF UNIONS AND OTHER PLACES MENTIONED 365
INDEX OF SUBJECTS 371
ENGLISH POOR LAW POLICY
The English Poor Law Policy, of which we present an analysis, is that which has been from time to time promulgated for the authoritative guidance of local authorities in the relief of the destitute, whether laid down by Parliament or by Departments of the National Government.
This policy is to be found principally in (1) Orders, whether "General" or "Special"; (2) circulars and other instructional communications to officials and to local authorities, and (3) reports to Parliament. These documents fall into three periods, 1834-1847, 1847-1871, and 1871-1907, corresponding respectively with the Poor Law Commissioners, the Poor Law Board, and the Local Government Board.
But these are themselves governed by (4) the Act of 1834 and subsequent amending statutes; and the Act of 1834 itself lays down no policy, and having regard to its origin, and to its immediate connection with the recent Royal Commission, it cannot be understood without (5) the Report of the Royal Commission of 1834. Hence it is convenient, if not indispensable, in order to render the subsequent analysis intelligible, to begin with an exact statement of the proposals of the Report of 1834.[5]
[5] This analysis is confined to relief in all its various forms,
excluding all questions of chargeability (or the recovery from
other persons of the amount expended on relief), settlement,
removal, assessment, rating, and mere administrative procedure.
CHAPTER I
THE REVOLUTION OF 1834
It is unnecessary for us even to refer to the disastrous chaos into which the Poor Law and its local administration had in 1832 fallen, or to the events which led up to the celebrated Royal Commission appointed in that year. Their report, presented in 1834, and the Poor Law Amendment Act of the same year, together form the starting-point of all subsequent legislation and administration.
THE 1834 REPORT
The proposals of the Commissioners of 1834 were either formal "recommendations," exceptionally displayed in prominent type, or suggestions scattered among the pages which purport to summarise the evidence. For instance, the famous "principle" that the situation of the pauper should not be made "really or apparently so eligible as the situation of the independent labourer of the lowest class" is not a "recommendation," but occurs only as an assertion in the course of an argument.[6] We have therefore included, in the following statement of "the principles of 1834," all dogmatic assertions of this nature, as well as the formal recommendations.
[6] p. 228 of the Report of 1834. The references are to the latest
reprint (1905).
A.--National Uniformity
The most revolutionary principle of the Report of 1834--the fundamental basis alike of the Act of 1834 and of the policy of the Central Authority--was that of national uniformity in the treatment of each class of destitute persons. It was this principle that was in most marked contrast with the previous practice, under which each parish or union had pursued its own Poor Law policy. It was this principle that furnished the ground for the very existence of a Central Authority. The Commissioners recommended that there should be uniformity in the administration of relief in the different parts of the country, in order--
(a) To reduce the "perpetual shifting" from parish to parish;
(b) To prevent discontent among paupers; and
(c) To bring the management more effectually under the control of
Parliament.[7]
[7] pp. 279-280 of the Report of 1834.
For this among other reasons the recommendation seemed to the Commissioners to follow, "as a necessary consequence, that the Legislature should divest the local authorities of all discretionary power in the administration of relief."[8] But they did not put this recommendation into large type. What they put into large type was the recommendation that there should be a Central Authority to control the administration, directed to frame and enforce regulations, "as far as may be practicable ... uniform throughout the country."[9]
[8] p. 294 of the Report of 1834.
[9] p. 297 of the Report of 1834.
It is to be noted that the uniformity proposed by the Commissioners was a geographical uniformity in the treatment of particular classes of paupers, both indoor and outdoor, in different places, not an identical treatment of all paupers, or of all the paupers in any one place. We shall deal presently with their varying recommendations with regard to particular classes. But in two categories they proposed a further uniformity, a uniformity in the treatment of different individuals in a class.
They emphatically pointed out that any attempt to discriminate according to merit, in the award of outdoor relief, is dangerous and likely to lead to fraud.[10] This proposed further uniformity of treatment among individuals in a class, it will be seen, is expressly limited to the amount to be given as outdoor relief. It is not repeated in that part of the Report which deals with classification in institutions, nor does it apply to the decision as to whether or not outdoor relief should be given at all.
A further uniformity recommended by the Commissioners was that of identity of treatment of the able-bodied, whether deserving or undeserving. To this we shall refer in connection with the able-bodied. It is to be noted that the Commissioners do not explicitly apply it to any but the able-bodied.[11]
[10] p. 47 of the Report of 1834.
[11] pp. 263-264 of the Report of 1834.
B.--The Able-Bodied
Apart from a few stray suggestions, it might almost be said that the Report of 1834 was entirely directed to the treatment of the adult able-bodied labourer, with the family dependent on him.
Let us take, for example, the famous principle, already referred to, that the situation of "the individual relieved shall not," on the whole, "be made really or apparently so eligible as the situation of the independent labourer of the lowest class." This proposal, characterised as "the first and most essential of all conditions," occurs, as a dogmatic assertion, in the discussion of the remedial measures to be applied to the able-bodied.[12] It cannot be said to be clear from the Report whether the Commissioners wished this principle to be understood as applicable to the relief of any persons other than adult able-bodied wage-earners and their families.
It is followed by forty-four pages of argument and illustration relating exclusively to the able-bodied wage-earner. These are summed up in a sentence at p. 279 ("If the vital evil of the system, relief to the able-bodied on terms more eligible than regular industry"), which points to the same limitation. The principle is not reasserted when the Commissioners, in quite other parts of their Report, make their few recommendations with regard to the aged, the sick, and the orphan poor.
We have failed, indeed, even to satisfy ourselves from the context whether the Commissioners had in their minds the case of the adult able-bodied woman without a husband. Though there is no phrase or definition excluding the independent female wage-earner from the term "able-bodied," the Commissioners frequently use this term as applicable to men only; and nowhere do they mention, in recommendation or by way of illustration, under the category of able-bodied, the independent woman worker.
[12] p. 228 of the Report of 1834.
When we pass to recommendations explicitly restricted to the able-bodied, we are left in the same uncertainty as to what the term includes. No definition of able-bodied occurs in the Report. From the course of the argument throughout and all the illustrations from the evidence, we infer that the Commissioners had exclusively in view the adult man capable of obtaining employment in the labour market at any wage whatsoever, together with his wife and children under sixteen dependent on him. It is important to notice this ambiguity in the Report of 1834, because it explains a similar ambiguity in the subsequent policy of Parliament and the Central Authority.
Assuming that we understand what classes of persons were intended by the Commissioners to be included under the term able-bodied, the proposals of the Report of 1834 are clear and peremptory:
I. That outdoor relief to the able-bodied and their families should be discontinued; except--
(a) As to medical relief; and
(b) Apprenticeship of children.
No other exceptions should be made. "Where cases of real hardship occur, the remedy must be applied by individual charity, a virtue for which no system of compulsory relief can or ought to be a substitute."[13] "It appears to us that this prohibition" (of outdoor relief to the able-bodied) "should come into universal operation at the end of two years,"[14] Meanwhile, it was suggested--
(a) That there should be a gradual substitution of relief in kind
for money doles;[15]
(b) "That all who receive relief from the parish should work for
the parish exclusively, as hard and for less wages than independent
labourers work for individual employers."[16]
(c) That the able-bodied, even "of the best character," should
not be offered "more than a simple subsistence. The person of bad
character, if he be allowed anything, could not be allowed
less."[17]
[13] p. 263 of Report of 1834.
[14] p. 297 of Report of 1834.
[15] p. 298 of Report of 1834.
[16] p. 262 of Report of 1834, made by way of comment as to the
temporary policy.
[17] p. 264 of Report of 1834.
That these recommendations had in view only the adult able-bodied person, capable of obtaining employment for wages, is supported by the explicit statement of the Commissioners that "the outdoor relief of which we have recommended the abolition is, in general, partial relief ... at variance with the spirit of the 43rd of Elizabeth, for the framers of that Act could scarcely have intended that the overseers should 'take order for setting to work' those who have work and are engaged in work; nor could they by the words 'all persons using no ordinary and daily trade of life to get their living by' have intended to describe persons 'who do use an ordinary and daily trade of life.'"[18]
[18] p. 262 of Report of 1834.
II. That the able-bodied should be offered maintenance in a workhouse.
It is important to notice exactly what the Commissioners here proposed, with all the emphasis of large type. Relief to the able-bodied and their families was to be "in well-regulated workhouses (i.e. places where they may be set to work according to the spirit and intention of the 43rd of Elizabeth)."[19]
[19] Ibid.
These workhouses for the able-bodied were to be separate from the buildings in which the aged and the children were accommodated; they were to be under separate officers; and were expressly not to form part of one great establishment containing other classes of paupers.[20] The character of the employment to be found for the able-bodied must also be noted, as the Commissioners made this a cardinal point.
It will be remembered that the 43rd of Elizabeth directed that the overseers should obtain "a convenient stock of flax, hemp, wool, and other necessaries for the poor to work upon," i.e. that they should "set the poor to work" on a normal productive enterprise. This principle is repeated and emphasised by the Commissioners. The employment to be found for the able-bodied "ought to be useful employment." Fictitious, artificial, or useless labour was "pernicious," and "ought to be carefully prevented....
The association of the utility of labour to both parties, the employer as well as the employed, is one which we consider it most important to preserve and strengthen; and we deem everything mischievous which unnecessarily gives to it a repulsive aspect. At the same time we believe that in extended districts the requisite sources of employment will be easily found.
The supply of the articles consumed in workhouses and prisons would afford a large outlet for the manufactures carried on in the House."[21] They even refer with approval to outdoor employment as possible in most districts.
[20] pp. 306-307 of Report of 1834.
[21] p. 324 of Report of 1834.
C.--Vagrants
With regard to vagrants, the Commissioners were convinced that they would "cease to be a burden," if they were treated like the ordinary able-bodied pauper. The difficulty was to enforce this, and they therefore recommended that the Central Authority should "be empowered and directed to frame and enforce regulations as to the relief to be afforded to vagrants and discharged prisoners."[22]
[22] p. 340 of Report of 1834.
D.--Women
With regard to the treatment of women, it cannot be said that the Report of 1834 afforded much guidance to the Central Authority. Whether or not the Commissioners meant to propose the abolition of outdoor relief to the legally independent able-bodied woman is, as we have shown, indeterminate. In this Report the single independent woman is nowhere mentioned.
The wife is throughout treated exactly as is the child; and it is assumed that she follows her husband, both with regard to the continuance of outdoor relief to the aged, the impotent, and the sick; and with regard to its abolition in the case of the able-bodied.
Such women as entered the workhouse were apparently to be regarded as divided into only two classes; they were to be accommodated either in the building for "the aged and really impotent," or else in the House for the "able-bodied females."[23] With regard to the really baffling problems presented by the widow, the deserted wife, the wife of the absentee soldier or sailor, the wife of a husband resident in another parish or another country--in each case whether with or without dependent children--the Report is silent.
[23] p. 306 of Report of 1834.
To the class of mothers of illegitimate children the Commissioners devoted much attention. The almost universal practice had been for such mothers to receive outdoor relief, the amount of which the parish was supposed to attempt to recover from the putative fathers. We do not find that the Report recommended any change in the method of relief of such paupers. Its proposal was, in effect, to put the mothers of illegitimate children in the same position as the widows with legitimate children.
As already mentioned, the Commissioners nowhere state whether they recommend any change in the method of relief of such widows--unless, indeed, it could be argued that these women were to be included under the class of able-bodied. The revolutionary change which the Report proposed with regard to bastardy dealt with chargeability, not methods of relief. The Commissioners strongly recommended the exemption of the putative father from any legal obligation to reimburse the parish.
"If," say the Commissioners, "our previous recommendations are adopted, a bastard will be, what Providence appears to have ordained that it should be, a burden on its mother, and where she cannot maintain it, on her parents."[24]
[24] p. 350 of Report of 1834.
E.--The Children
Apart from apprenticeship, the Report deals only incidentally with children. It is assumed throughout that children go with their parents, both with regard to the continuance of outdoor relief to the aged, impotent and sick, and with regard to its abolition in the case of the able-bodied.
On one point the Report is emphatic and clear, namely, that, where children do enter the workhouse, they are to be accommodated in a separate building, under a separate superintendent, in order that they may "be educated" by "a person properly qualified to act as a schoolmaster."[25]
[25] p. 307 of Report of 1834.
With regard to apprenticeship, all that the Report is--
(1) Expressly to except relief by way of apprenticeship from its
proposal to abolish outdoor relief to the able-bodied parent.[26]
(2) To recommend that the Central Authority should "be empowered to
make such regulations" as it might think fit; and subsequently "to
make a special inquiry" into the subject.[27]
[26] p. 262 of Report of 1834.
[27] p. 338 of Report of 1834.
F.--The Sick
In contradistinction to the revolutionary proposals of the Report of 1834 with regard to the able-bodied, it is extraordinary that it suggested absolutely no change with regard to the sick. The current practice was, in nearly every case, to deal with the sick by outdoor relief, with or without medical attendance.[28] The Report contains no suggestion for any alteration in this respect. When the Commissioners came to sketch out the classification of their proposed workhouse institutions, they did not include anything in the nature of a hospital.[29] This explains why the Report of 1834 does not mention any provision for indoor medical officers.
Even when dealing with the able-bodied and their families, the Commissioners explicitly except medical attendance from their proposed abolition of outdoor relief.[30]
[28] p. 43 of Report of 1834.
[29] pp. 306-307 of Report of 1834.
[30] p. 262 of Report of 1834.
This omission of anything in the nature of proposals for indoor relief for the sick becomes the more significant when we notice that the Commissioners do allude with approval to a possible extension of institutional treatment for certain classes of defectives, such as lunatics and the blind.[31]
[31] p. 307 of Report of 1834.
G.--The Aged and Impotent (or Infirm)
An almost similar absence of proposals is to be noted with regard to the aged and impotent. The current practice was to deal with these cases, as a rule, by outdoor relief. On this the Commissioners observe merely that "the outdoor relief to the impotent (using that word as comprehending all except the able-bodied and their families) is subject to less abuse.... No use can be made of the labour of the aged and sick, and there is little room for jobbing if their pensions are paid in money.
Accordingly, we find that even in places distinguished in general by the most wanton parochial profusion, the allowances to the aged and infirm are moderate."[32] The Commissioners made no proposal that outdoor relief to the aged or impotent (or infirm) should be abolished, or even curtailed.
[32] pp. 42-43 of Report of 1834.
Such "aged and really impotent" persons as were accommodated in the workhouse were to have a separate building to themselves, under a separate superintendent; expressly in order that "the old might enjoy their indulgences."[33]
[33] p. 307 of Report of 1834.
Passing now to those proposals of the Report which affected paupers generally, these concern the organisation of the workhouse, emigration and relief on loan.
H.--The Workhouse
With regard to the workhouse, the whole emphasis of the Report is upon classification of the inmates according to their needs; and classification, not in separate parts of one building, but by the allocation to separate classes of entirely distinct buildings in order that there might be separate and differing treatment under distinct management.
The Commissioners state that "at least four classes are necessary:--
- The aged and really impotent.
- The children.
- The able-bodied females.
- The able-bodied males.
"Of whom we trust the two latter will be the least numerous classes.
It appears to us that both the requisite classification and the requisite superintendence may be better obtained in separate buildings than under a single roof."[34] The Commissioners were insistent that the treatment measured out to each class should differ according to its requirements, and "each class might thus receive an appropriate treatment; the old might enjoy their indulgences without torment from the boisterous; the children be educated; and the able-bodied subjected to such courses of labour and discipline as will repel the indolent and vicious."[35] The need for separate buildings, under entirely different kinds of officers, with different qualifications, at different rates of payments--in contradistinction to one large building under a single officer--is emphasised again and again at different parts of the Report.[36] It was, indeed, largely in order to provide these specialised institutions that the Commissioners recommended the formation of unions, it being made a cardinal principle that the Central Authority should "assign" to the various existing workhouses thus coming under one board of guardians "separate classes of poor."[37]
[34] p. 306 of Report of 1834.
[35] p. 307 of Report of 1834.
[36] See pp. 305, 306, 307, 313-314 of Report of 1834.
[37] p. 314 of Report of 1834.
It is interesting to notice that, apart from this cardinal principle of classification by separate and specialised buildings, practically the only recommendations relating to the organisation of the workhouse, which are to be found in the Report, relate either to the character of the employment to be provided in the buildings set aside for the able-bodied--which, as we have seen, was expressly to be of a normal productive character, free from repellent characteristics--or to the enactment of a maximum diet (and no minimum). "The Commissioners should be empowered to fix a maximum of the consumption per head within the workhouses, leaving to the local officers the liberty of reducing it below the maximum if they can safely do so."[38]
[38] p. 298 of Report of 1834.
I.--Emigration
Without laying much stress upon emigration, the Report recommends that any vestry should be empowered to pay for it out of the poor rate, in the case of persons (apparently whether paupers or not) having settlements in the parish and willing to emigrate.[39]
[39] p. 357 of Report of 1834.
J.--Relief on Loan
The Commissioners recommended "that under regulations to be framed... parishes be empowered to treat any relief afforded to the able-bodied, or to their families, and any expenditure in the workhouses, or otherwise incurred on their account, as a loan," to be legally recoverable. It is to be noted that this proposal is expressly limited to the "able-bodied or to their families." No definition, as usual, is given of the term able-bodied.[40]
[40] p. 337 of Report of 1834.
K.--The Principles of 1834
To sum up the principles of administration recommended for adoption in the Report of 1834, omitting minor recommendations and incidental qualifications, they resolve themselves into three. The Principle of National Uniformity required that the relief afforded to each class of paupers should be uniform throughout the kingdom. The Principle of Less Eligibility demanded that the conditions of existence afforded by the relief should be less eligible to the applicant than those of the lowest grade of independent labourers. The Workhouse System was recommended on the assumption that it was the only means by which the Principle of Less Eligibility could be in practice enforced.
The two latter principles were applied explicitly only to the able-bodied and their families. To them (but to them only) any other form of relief ought, it was urged, to be made unlawful.
THE ACT OF 1834 AND ITS AMENDMENTS
The marked feature of this period is the paucity of statutory enactment affecting relief. Only four statutes[41] contain any provisions on the subject (apart from administrative detail), and these provisions are almost entirely mere enabling clauses, permitting the Central Authority to make such rules as it thinks fit, subject to a few specified exceptions. We can extract from these exiguous provisions nothing in the nature of a policy imposed by Parliament on the Central Authority. As already mentioned, it was assumed that the Central Authority would put into execution the proposals of the Report of 1834.
Parliament contented itself with giving the Central Authority wide powers and almost unfettered discretion in the use of them.
[41] 4 & 5 Will. IV. c. 76, quoted as the Act of 1834; 5
& 6 Vic. c. 57, quoted as the Act of 1842; 7 & 8 Vic. c. 101,
quoted as the Act of 1844; 10 and 11 Vic. c. 109, quoted as the
Act of 1847.
A.--National Uniformity
Prior to 1834 there were many authorities legally entitled to order relief from the rates. The Act of 1834 made for national uniformity by confining this power, subject to certain exceptions as regards special classes, to the boards of guardians when formed; and until these were formed, to the select vestries or bodies formed under local Acts; to the exclusion, in these places, of the Justices of the Peace and the overseers. The new relief-giving local authorities were made subject to the control of a Central Authority, to be exercised by rules having the force of law.
Two of the great classes of relief were singled out for special reference in the Act.
The Central Authority was expressly empowered to make "rules, orders and regulations to be observed and enforced at every workhouse."[42] The Central Authority was also expressly empowered to make "rules, etc., to regulate the relief of the able-bodied and their families."[43] With regard to all other classes of paupers (e.g. the aged and impotent; orphan and deserted children; widows and deserted wives, with their children; and the sick--unless any of these can be supposed to have been included by Parliament under the term able-bodied) the Central Authority had general powers only; the administration of all poor relief was made subject to its direction and control; and it was empowered and directed "to make rules for the management of the poor, the government of workhouses and the education of the children therein ... for the apprenticing the children of poor persons; and for the guidance and control of all guardians, vestries and parish officers so far as relates to the management or relief of the poor."[44]
[42] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 42.
[43] Ibid. sec. 52.
[44] Ibid. sec. 15.
B.--The Able-Bodied
It was expressly provided that relief to the able-bodied should be given only in accordance with the rules of the Central Authority. These rules might be of any kind, including (subject to exceptions) a total prohibition, then or at any future time. In the special preamble to this section, Parliament pointed to the difficulty of "an immediate and universal remedy"--doubtless referring to the proposal of the Report of 1834 that all such relief should be prohibited within two years.
But Parliament gave no direction for prohibition, nor did it expressly limit the discretion of the Central Authority on the subject, beyond certain specified exceptions.
These exceptions were (1) that complete discretion was reserved to the board of guardians so far as regarded the grant of food, temporary lodging or medicine "in cases of emergency," subject only to reporting their action to the Central Authority; and also, subject to the approval of the Central Authority, so far as regarded the grant of money or other relief in such cases;[45] (2) that in cases of "sudden and urgent necessity" the overseer was required to give "such temporary relief as each case shall require in articles of absolute necessity but not in money";[46] and (3) that any Justice might order medical relief in case of "sudden and dangerous illness" and relief in certain cases to non-parishioners.[47]
As in the Report itself, no definition is given in the Act of what was meant by "able-bodied persons." In the special preamble, however, prefixed to this section, it is recited that it is enacted in consequence of the prevalent practice of giving relief "to persons or their families who, at the time of applying for or receiving such relief, were wholly or partially in the employment of individuals."[48]
[45] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 52.
[46] Ibid. sec. 54.
[47] Ibid.
[48] Ibid. sec. 52.
C.--Vagrants
The Act of 1834 is silent with regard to vagrants, in accordance with the proposal of the Report of 1834 that those destitute persons who had hitherto been deemed vagrants should be dealt with simply as other destitute persons. It may, however, be noted that express provision was made to enable any one Justice to order temporary relief in kind to persons not settled in nor usually residing in the parish, in cases of urgent necessity, in which the overseer had refused relief.[49]
In 1842, however, it was enacted that the local authority might "prescribe a task of work to be done by any person relieved in any workhouse in return for the food and lodging afforded to such person," and (implicitly) might detain such person until the task was done; but such detention was not to exceed four hours after breakfast on the day following admission. Refusal or neglect to perform such task, or wilful damage to property, subjected the person to be deemed an idle and disorderly person within the meaning of the Vagrancy Act of 1824. This section is not expressly confined to wandering persons, but the marginal note confines it to the "occasional poor."[50]
[49] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 54.
[50] 5 & 6 Vic. c. 57, sec. 5.
In 1844 the Central Authority was empowered to combine parishes, in London and five other large towns, into districts for the provision of Asylums for Houseless Poor, that is to say, "asylums for the temporary relief and setting to work therein of destitute houseless poor"; to constitute Boards for such districts; with the consent of such Boards, to direct the establishment of such asylums, at the expense of the poor rates of such districts, up to a maximum of one-fifth of their whole Poor Law expenditure; and to make rules, etc., for such asylums, subject to a conscience clause and to facilities for entry by ministers of different denominations.[51] These Asylums for Houseless Poor were to be mildly penal establishments, supplementary to the workhouses, and involving detention for a term not exceeding four hours after breakfast on the day after admission; or, in the case of a person subjected to punishment for an offence committed during his stay, for any period up to twenty-four hours.[52]
[51] 7 & 8 Vic. c. 101, secs. 41 to 56.
[52] Ibid. sec. 53.
D.--Women
As in the Report of 1834, so in the Act of 1834, women do not appear as a class. It is assumed that married women follow their husbands, either with regard to the continuance of outdoor relief to the aged, the impotent and the sick; or with regard to its regulation or prohibition in the case of the able-bodied.
It is, as we have shown, difficult to infer that the term "able-bodied" was meant to include any but persons ordinarily in employment at wages, or capable of such employment. Whether or not Parliament had in contemplation under this term even the adult independent woman without encumbrances seems to us doubtful.
It is practically clear that the term was not intended by Parliament to apply to the widow, however able-bodied in the ordinary sense, nor to the deserted wife, the wife of the absentee sailor or soldier, or the wife of a husband resident in another parish or another country, if any of these were encumbered with young children, and so did not fall under the class of persons actually or potentially in employment at wages, cited in the preamble to the section dealing with the able-bodied.[53] If this is so, we can only infer from the Act, as from the Report, that no change in practice was then suggested.
With regard to such women, at least, the discretion of the Central Authority in its "direction and control" of poor relief, and its "management of the poor," and its power to make rules "for the guidance and control of" the local authority "so far as relates to the management or relief of the poor," was unfettered.[54]
[53] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 52.
[54] Ibid. sec. 15.
The fact that widows were not considered by Parliament to be included within the term "able-bodied persons and their families" may further be inferred from a section in the 1844 Act. This provided that the wife of a husband either (a) beyond the seas, (b) in the custody of the law, or (c) confined as a lunatic or idiot, should, notwithstanding her coverture, be treated for purposes of relief, as if she were a widow.[55] This implies that a widow was not regarded as subject to the conditions of relief to "able-bodied persons and their families."
[55] 7 & 8 Vic. c. 101, sec. 25.
It may be noted that relief to the child under sixteen of a widow was to be deemed relief to the mother;[56] and relief to an illegitimate child under sixteen was to be deemed relief to the mother so long as she remained unmarried or a widow.[57] Another section of the 1844 Act allowed a widow having a legitimate child dependent on her, and no illegitimate children, who at her husband's death was residing with him in a place where she had no settlement, to be granted non-resident relief.[58]
[56] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 56.
[57] Ibid. sec. 71.
[58] 7 & 8 Vic. c. 101, sec. 26.
E.--Children
With certain insignificant exceptions hereinafter noticed, the only provisions with regard to children as such in the 1834 Act relate to children in the workhouse. The Central Authority was directed to make rules, etc., "for the education of the children" in the workhouse.[59] It was specially enacted that no child in a workhouse was to be educated in any creed other than that of his parent, or, if orphaned, "to which his godparents may object." Facilities for free entry of ministers of the child's own persuasion were to be accorded.[60]
[59] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 15.
[60] Ibid. sec. 19.
In 1844 the Central Authority was expressly empowered at its discretion to combine parishes (within fifteen miles) into school districts, and to constitute boards for such school districts; and, subject to the consent of a majority of such a board, to direct the establishment of district schools at the cost of the poor rates of the district, up to a maximum of one-fifth of the total Poor Law expenditure of the district.[61]
[61] 7 & 8 Vic. c. 101, secs. 40, 42-44.
The Central Authority was empowered to make rules for such schools, it being, however, expressly enacted: (1) that an Anglican chaplain was always to be appointed; (2) that facilities for visits by ministers of other denominations were to be given; and (3) a conscience clause was inserted.[62] Such district schools were to be for the accommodation of pauper children under sixteen, either orphans, deserted, or having parents who consented,[63] including such children from parishes outside the district.[64]
[62] Ibid. sec. 43.
[63] Ibid. sec. 40.
[64] Ibid. sec. 51.
With regard to apprenticeship the law remained at first unchanged, except that the Act of 1834 empowered the Central Authority to make regulations (in significant phrase) "for the apprenticing the children of poor persons"[65] in the execution of the then existing law. This applied, not to those who were destitute or who applied for relief, but to "the children of all such whose parents shall not, by the ... churchwardens and overseers, or the greater part of them, be thought able to keep and maintain their children."[66]
[65] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, secs. 15 and 61.
[66] 43 Eliz. c. 2, sec. 1; 18 George III. c. 47,
preamble; 56 George III. c. 139.
In 1835, the Merchant Shipping Act incidentally authorised local authorities to apprentice boys over thirteen, with their own consent, to the mercantile marine, whatever the distance of the port or address of the shipmaster; to pay a premium of £5; and to convey the boy to his new master by a constable.[67]
In 1842 the Parish Apprentices Act made it clear that all the previous Acts applied also to cases in which no premium had been paid.[68]
[67] 5 & 6 William IV. c. 19, secs. 26, 29.
[68] 5 & 6 Vict. c. 7.
But the first substantive alteration of the law was made in 1844, when the Central Authority was expressly empowered to make regulations prescribing the duties of masters and the other conditions of apprenticeship; the power of apprenticing was confined to the boards of guardians; and the former compulsory obligation on householders to receive apprentices was abolished.[69] The class of children to be apprenticed remained unchanged.[70]
[69] 7 & 8 Vict. c. 101, secs. 12, 13.
[70] There was a provision (since repealed), in sec. 15 of the Act of 1834, which we need not notice, as to making rules for the management of parish poor children under Hanway's Act (7 George III. c. 39), since repealed.
F.--The Sick
Parliament made no enactment with regard to the sick as a class; did not therefore seek to interfere with the existing practice under which the sick usually received outdoor relief; and did not even empower the Central Authority to make any regulations for the relief of the sick as such, except in so far as they were either inmates of workhouses or belonged to the indeterminate class of the "able-bodied and their families." Its only power in this connection lay in the general words placing the administration of all relief under its direction and control, and in the general authority to make rules, etc., for the guidance and control of local officers as far as related to the management or relief of the poor.[71]
[71] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 15.
The only provision relating to the sick as such was an express sanction of the existing power of any Justice to order medical relief in cases of sudden and dangerous illness without any restriction whatever.[72]
[72] Ibid. c. 54.
With regard to lunatics, the only provision was one in 1838, that the Justices might commit a dangerous or criminal lunatic to an asylum, at the cost of the Poor Rate.[73]
[73] Criminal Lunatics Act, 1838, 1 & 2 Vict. c. 14, sec. 2.
We may note a provision, declaring that relief to a blind or deaf and dumb wife or child under sixteen should not be deemed relief to the husband or the parent.[74] This apparently prevented these (together with their husbands or parents), from falling into the class of the "able-bodied and their families."
[74] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 56.
G.--The Aged and Impotent
The only provision relating to the aged and impotent as such was the express retention of the Justices' power to order outdoor relief without limit of amount or period. This was made subject to the conditions that the person should be (1) wholly unable to work, (2) entitled to relief in the union, and (3) desirous of outdoor relief; and that (4) the order should be given by two Justices "usually acting for the district," one of whom had satisfied himself of his own knowledge that the conditions were fulfilled.[75]
[75] Ibid. sec. 27.
H.--The Workhouse
The conditions and character of the relief to be afforded by admission to the workhouse were to be subject to rules etc., which the Central Authority was empowered and directed to make.[76] The power of the Central Authority was subject to an important limitation.
Any order for the building of a new workhouse was made conditional on obtaining the consent either of a majority of the guardians or of a majority of the ratepayers and owners.[77] The Central Authority could, however, without such consent, order the local authority "to enlarge or alter" any existing workhouse or building capable of being converted into a workhouse up to a limit of £50 or one-tenth of the average Poor Rate for the past three years.[78] Moreover, the local authority was not to expend on the building, alteration or enlargement of any particular workhouse (whether by way of loan or out of rate) more than the annual average of the poor rate during the three preceding years.[79] These limitations were removed, so far as regards the cost of sites in the Metropolitan Police District and the parish of Liverpool, in 1844.[80] It was also expressly provided that no person was to introduce alcoholic liquor into a workhouse without the written order of the master, under penalty of a fine not exceeding £10; nor was the master to do so save for domestic use of the officers, except in conformity with the rules.[81] Confinement beyond twenty-four hours, and the corporal punishment of adults, were expressly forbidden.[82] Notices of the law on these subjects were to be publicly displayed.[83] A conscience clause protected workhouse inmates, and they had also the right to receive visits by religious ministers of their own persuasions.[84]
[76] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, secs. 15, 42.
[77] Ibid. sec. 23.
[78] Ibid. sec. 25.
[79] Ibid. sec. 24.
[80] 7 & 8 Vict. c. 101, sec. 30.
[81] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, secs. 92, 93.
[82] Ibid. sec. 93.
[83] Ibid. sec. 94.
[84] Ibid. sec. 19.
I.--Emigration
The Act carried out the proposal of the Report, by enabling the ratepayers (including rated owners) to emigrate, at the expense of the poor rates, with the approval of the Central Authority, "poor persons" having settlements in the parish whether paupers or not.[85]
[85] Ibid. sec. 62.
J.--Relief on Loan
It was enacted that any relief that the Central Authority might declare or direct to be by way of loan should be legally recoverable by the local authority, even by attachment of wages.[86]
[86] 4 & 5 William IV. secs. 58, 59.
Five years later the local authority was given power to attach Army and Navy pensions, in repayment of the cost of relief, even without such relief having been declared to be on loan.[87]
[87] Pensions Act, 1839, 2 & 3 Vict. c. 51, sec. 2.
CHAPTER II
THE POOR LAW COMMISSIONERS
It had, as we have seen, been left to the Poor Law Commissioners to formulate their own policy, with the guidance of the Report of 1834.
This policy is, during the ensuing thirteen years, to be found in (1) the orders issued under the Act of 1834 and subsequent statutes; (2) the circulars and other explanatory or instructional communications to the local authorities, inspectors, auditors, etc., and (3) the reports to Parliament.
Under the term "order," we include, as is customary, all the "rules, orders, and regulations" issued in pursuance of statutory powers.
With whatever parts of poor relief these dealt, they had the force of law; either under the specific powers relating to workhouses,[88] or relief to the able-bodied,[89] or under the general powers authorising the Poor Law Commissioners to make "rules, orders, and regulations ... for the guidance and control of all guardians, vestries, and parish officers so far as relates to the management or relief of the poor."[90] According to the Act of 1834 some of these orders were to be "General Rules," and were not to take effect until they had been submitted to a Secretary of State, and by him laid before Parliament for forty days; and they were disallowable by the Privy Council.[91] A "General Rule" was to be "any rule ... which shall, at the time of issuing the same, be addressed ... to more than one union or to more parishes and places than one."[92] Other orders, known first as "Particular Orders," and subsequently as "Special Orders," and now simply as "Orders," were subject to no such conditions.
There was, however, no distinction between them as to validity, force of law, or sanction. It was therefore open to the Poor Law Commissioners to issue all its orders as particular or special orders by addressing them successively to separate unions or parishes, even if they were identical in their terms. For reasons explained in the Poor Law Commissioners' Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, this was the course adopted.[93] No general order was issued prior to 1841.
[88] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 42.
[89] Ibid. sec. 52.
[90] Ibid. sec. 15.
[91] Ibid. secs. 16, 17.
[92] Ibid. sec. 109.
[93] Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, pp.
32-34.
With circulars so-called we include all explanatory or instructional communications to local authorities or to the officers of central or local authorities, or to Parliament. These, though embodying the policy of the Central Authority, had not the force of law. Moreover, as they were issued for particular emergencies, and were never withdrawn or expressly abrogated, they--unlike any unrepealed orders--must not be considered as necessarily laying down general policy for all time.
Subject to consideration of this limitation, we propose to include the circulars, letters, etc., along with the general and special orders, in our analysis of the policy laid down for each of the several classes of destitute persons.
A.--The Able-Bodied
(i.) On Outdoor Relief
The ambiguity that existed, alike in the Report and in the Act of 1834, as to the meaning intended to be given to the term "the able-bodied" was, to a large extent, reflected in those documents of the Central Authority which expounded its policy with regard to the kind and conditions of relief to be given to this class. Once more there is no definition of the term able-bodied, which is used sometimes as an adjective and sometimes as a substantive.
From the context it must be inferred, as we shall presently show, that the term is used in different senses in the orders relating respectively to outdoor relief and to the management of the workhouse. What proved in the event more inimical to the principle of National Uniformity was the fact that in the orders relating to outdoor relief to the able-bodied, there was no consistency as to whether any class of women was or was not to be included among the able-bodied.
There are, as we shall presently describe, two distinct streams of regulations affecting outdoor relief to the able-bodied, one permitting such relief under conditions, culminating in the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order of 14th December, 1852 (still in force), and the other prohibiting it subject to exceptions, culminating in the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 21st December, 1844 (still in force).
In the former series of regulations, beginning with the first orders issued in the autumn of 1834 to particular unions, the term "able-bodied" is expressly qualified by the adjective "male" ("able-bodied male persons").[94] In the other series, beginning in 1836 with the Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town Unions, the category of the "able-bodied," if we are to go by the actual wording of the orders, clearly comprises both sexes; at first by excepting widows only from a universal rule, and presently by specifically including "every able-bodied" person, "male or female."[95] That this differing interpretation of the category of the "able-bodied and their families" was actually intended by the Central Authority in 1840, and 1844, and that it was not merely accidental, is shown by cases in which it was decided that outdoor relief to single women having illegitimate children was illegal, as being in contravention of the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order in force in those unions;[96] thus proving that, under this order, the category of "the able-bodied and their families" included independent women with children; although in the other kind of orders, contemporaneous in date, the same category included men only (and their families).
This is the more puzzling, in that we find the Central Authority, in 1839 at least, regarding these very outdoor relief prohibitory orders as practically, if not literally, applicable only to able-bodied males.
In the comprehensive defence of its action, when pleading for a renewal of the Act, the Central Authority expressly describes these orders as "prohibiting outdoor relief to able-bodied male paupers"; and as having attained the object aimed at, that of destroying the allowance system or relief in aid of wages, "so far as respects able-bodied male paupers and their families."[97]
[94] See for instance the Order of 31st December, 1834, issued to
Sutton Courtney Parish, now included in Abingdon Union, and the
Outdoor Relief Regulation Order, 14th December 1852, art. 1.
[95] See Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in
Town Unions, 7th March 1836, in Second Annual Report, 1836, p. 92;
the Order of 26th April 1839, to Aston Union; and Outdoor Relief
Prohibitory Order, 21st December 1844, art. 1.
[96] Official Circular, No. 1, p. 8, 8th January 1840; Ibid.
No. 34, p. 79, 30th April 1844.
[97] p. 62 of Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law,
1839.
To sum up this question of definition, in one series of outdoor relief regulations applicable to the able-bodied, in force in certain unions, the category of "the able-bodied" expressly excludes independent women; in another series of regulations, in force in other unions, the category of "the able-bodied" includes such women.
There is actual evidence that the Central Authority enforced these differing determinations so far as to include as among "the able-bodied" unmarried women having illegitimate children in those unions in which one set of Orders was in force. Whether it ever actually enforced this interpretation as regards single women without children is not apparent in the published documents, but would be seen from its records.
The fact of variance between the two interpretations of the category of "the able-bodied" becomes important when the two series of regulations are consolidated into two orders embodying distinct policies, one or other of which is made applicable to every union in the country.
Once having determined what was included in the category of "the able-bodied," the ground becomes more clear. With regard to outdoor relief, there are the two streams of contemporaneous regulations already alluded to--the one permitting it subject to conditions, the other prohibiting it subject to exceptions.
The first series was, it is clear, regarded (at any rate down to 1842) as temporary, only "to be sanctioned as a palliative for a time, and until adequate and efficient workhouse accommodation shall be provided."[98] These regulations were, in the autumn of 1834, issued separately to certain unions pending the introduction of "proper regulations";[99] but we also find them, between 1835 and 1842, included as a matter of course in orders prohibiting outdoor relief, by way of exception, but still only as providing a temporary alternative, until accommodation can be obtained for the reception of such persons in the workhouse.[100]
[98] See the "Suggestions as to the most eligible modes of
Providing Outdoor Employment ... in cases where there is not an
efficient workhouse, and preparatory to the establishment of the
Workhouse System," p. 45 of Second Annual Report, 1836.
[99] Circular, 8th November 1834, p. 73 of First Annual Report,
1835.
[100] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v., art. 27, p. 92 of Second Annual
Report, 1836.
There was even a third series of Orders, which may perhaps be regarded as even more provisional and temporary than the first series. To various local authorities in large towns (such as Norwich), and in the Metropolitan parishes, Orders were issued from 1835 onwards, simply requiring that any outdoor relief to the able-bodied should be, to the extent of one-third[101]--sometimes to the extent of one-half[102]--"relief in kind," that is to say, in loaves of bread.[103]
[101] Poor Law Commissioners to Norwich Court of Guardians, 25th
July 1835; Special Order to Norwich, 29th July 1835; MS. Minutes,
Norwich Court of Guardians, July and August 1835.
[102] Special Order to Norwich, 21st October 1835; Poor Law
Commissioners to Norwich Court of Guardians, 21st October 1835;
MS. Minutes, Norwich Court of Guardians, October 1835.
[103] This term, Relief in Kind, has always been limited to food,
though the character of the food has been varied. Medicine and
"medical extras" supplied to the paupers in their homes have been
included in the term Outdoor Medical Relief. The provision of
clothing and bedding to the outdoor poor--classed as ordinary
Outdoor Relief--though permitted, has never been encouraged by the
Central Authority. (Official Circular, 10th November 1840, No.
9, p. 117; Ibid., July 1850, No. 39 N.S., p. 108; see also
Selections from the Correspondence of the Local Government Board,
vol. ii., 1880, p.
71.) The provision of tools or implements of
trade was considered not to be of the nature of relief, and
therefore not legal. It was expressly prohibited by the Outdoor
Relief Regulation Order of 1852 (art. 3). Payment of rent (except
the provision of temporary lodging in urgent and sudden necessity,
or for housing a lunatic) was from the outset strictly prohibited.
(See Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844, art. 5, and
Outdoor Relief Regulation Order of 1852, art. 3.) This prohibition
of payment of rent seems to have been considered of importance by
the Poor Law Commissioners.
The impracticability of preventing
ordinary outdoor relief from being applied in payment of the
pauper's rent seems only gradually to have dawned upon the Poor
Law Board.
In 1852 it was explained that although the Order
"prohibits the Guardians from paying the rent for a pauper either
directly or indirectly, it does not prevent them from allowing him
such relief as under all the circumstances of the case his
necessities may require; it will rest with the pauper to dispose
of the relief afforded to him in such manner as he may think fit."
(Poor Law Board to Hemsworth Union, 19th October 1852; in House of
Commons, No. 111 of 1852-3, p.
96.) A similar decision was given
in 1902. (See Local Government Chronicle, 9th August 1902, p.
805.) The prohibition still remains in force, but is accordingly
not now regarded as of importance.
It has been assumed that it was the intention of the Central Authority from the outset to replace these temporary orders permitting outdoor relief to the able-bodied by some permanent injunction substituting relief in the workhouse as the only method. But the documentary evidence indicates that the Central Authority either never entertained the idea--or else very quickly abandoned it--of issuing the Prohibitory Order to the manufacturing towns of the north.
Thus, in October 1836, after nearly two years' experience, the Poor Law Commissioners, as their Assistant Commissioner reported, were disposed to leave "the contemplated workhouse system ... very much to the board of guardians, and they did not feel it necessary to lay down those strict rules that they had in some instances laid down for the government of unions in the south of England."[104]
[104] MS. Minutes, Newcastle Board of Guardians, 7th October 1836.
In 1842 the Central Authority, perhaps unwittingly, took a new departure. In the northern counties there were districts for which no orders "concerning the outdoor relief of the able-bodied" had been issued.
The Central Authority had failed to induce the Local Authorities to provide "adequate workhouse accommodation," and it was found that "large numbers of able-bodied persons are often suddenly thrown out of employment by the fluctuations of manufacturers" (sic).[105] To meet this situation, a new General Order was issued (the Outdoor Labour Test Order, 13th April 1842); on the ground that it was impracticable "to issue the Order prohibiting outdoor relief to able-bodied persons."[106] This order is historically of two-fold significance.
It has had, as will subsequently appear, a long and continuous career of its own, in force in combination with the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order in particular unions.[107] But between 1842 and 1852, standing by itself in other unions,[108] it was the temporary embodiment of an alternative policy of the Central Authority. This alternative policy was, in 1852, definitely adopted by the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order (still in force), as the one permanently appropriate for the circumstances of many unions, covering a large part of England and Wales.
[105] Circular of 30th April 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842,
p. 179.
[106] Minute of Commissioners respecting the means of enforcing an
Outdoor Labour Test, 31st October 1842, p. 381 of Ninth Annual
Report, 1843.
[107] For such Special Labour Test Orders, issued in supplement to
the Out-relief Prohibitory Order, see those to Boston Union, of
3rd February 1847; Crediton Union, 21st May 1847; and Catherington
Union, 2nd June 1847, which are in the most usual form; or those
to Foleshill Union, 13th December 1847; Maldon Union, 7th December
1847; and Nuneaton Union, 13th December 1847, which are in a much
shorter form, omitting the authority for the appointment of a
superintendent of pauper labour.
[108] For such Special Labour Test Orders, issued to unions not
under the Out-relief Prohibitory Order, see that to
Ashton-under-Lyne Union, 29th March 1847; or that, in a shorter
form, omitting the authority for the appointment of a
superintendent of pauper labour, to Chertsey Union, 17th December
1847.
This policy of leaving to the discretion of the local authorities the grant of outdoor relief to the able-bodied on certain conditions was, as already mentioned, confined to men. We can find no explanation of, or reason for, the entire absence of any provision for independent women who were able-bodied. It can only be inferred that, in those districts, the Central Authority meant the unlimited discretion of the local authorities with regard to outdoor relief to able-bodied independent women to continue.
The outdoor relief sanctioned for able-bodied men was strictly limited to persons who were not in employment for hire.
This limitation was expressly intended to prevent the old "Rate in Aid of Wages." But it was subsequently expressly allowed that outdoor relief might be given, in respect of the particular days in a week or the particular weeks in a month during which persons were unemployed, whilst they were in remunerative employment on other days of that week, or other weeks of that month.[109] In the case of persons partially disabled, and able to earn only partial maintenance, the Poor Law Commissioners recommended that they "should be entirely supported by the guardians"--not, be it noted, by being admitted to the workhouse--but either by their being "set to work by the guardians in such manner as may be suitable to their condition," or else by their being prohibited from doing any work on their own account.[110]
[109] Circular Letter, 14th December 1852, in Fifth Annual Report
of Poor Law Board, 1852, p. 31.
[110] Special Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law,
1839, p. 72.
It should be said that (with an exception to be hereafter noted in the case of women) the Central Authority stood rigidly on the position taken up by the 1834 Report that no regard was to be paid to character, in judging applications for relief. "If a person," said the Poor Law Commissioners in 1840, "be in a state of destitution, such person is to be relieved, without reference to the moral character of such person.
Relief from the poor rates can only lawfully be given in cases where persons are destitute of the means of support. And the fact that the destitution may have been caused by the immorality or improvidence of the party who seeks to be relieved does not alter or vary the duty of guardians to administer relief proportional to the necessity of the case."[111]
[111] Poor Law Commissioners to Plymouth Board of Guardians, 25th
April 1840.
The outdoor relief, where given, had to be subject to two conditions. It was to be at least half in kind, and conditional on the recipient being set to work by the local authority, the time, mode and conditions of work being fixed by the Central Authority.
With regard to the kinds and conditions of "parish work," it was repeatedly laid down by the Central Authority that none would be sanctioned unless (a) the work was "hard," not of a kind usually performed by independent labourers or competing with them, nor "much regarded as to profitable results," strictly supervised, "of a laborious and undesirable nature in itself," and "of such a nature as to discourage applications from all who are not really necessitous"; (b) paid "less than would be paid for work of equal quantity if performed by independent labourers";[112] or as it was later stated, the payment "ought to assume the form of relief, not of wages....
A single man or a man with a wife and one child ought not to receive as much as a man with a wife and eight children."[113]
[112] p. 45 of Second Annual Report, 1836; Official Circular,
No. 29, p. 151, 30th November 1843.
It is not explained how payment on the last principle could be made consistent with the former principles. But the intention of the Central Authority is clear. In the words quoted with approval in the circular of 1835, the parish was to be "the hardest taskmaster and the worst pay-master."[114]
[113] Minute, 31st October 1842, p. 383 of Ninth Annual Report,
1843.
[114] p. 46 of Second Annual Report, 1836.
An important exception was made by a separate clause in the Order providing that the guardians might depart from any of these regulations in particular instances, and thus give outdoor relief to able-bodied males on any conditions, subject to their reporting each such instance within fifteen days to the Central Authority, and obtaining its subsequent approval. With that approval, outdoor relief to able-bodied men, without any conditions, was lawful.
The records of the Central Authority between 1842 and 1847, which have not been published, would show how frequently application was made for this approval, and whether the Central Authority pursued any definite policy in approving or disapproving the cases, or merely approved all that were reported to it.
The second series of outdoor relief regulations, beginning with the Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town Unions of 1836, and culminating in the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844 (still in force), proceeds on the basis of forbidding outdoor relief to the "able-bodied and their families." But from the outset we find a series of express exceptions made in particular Orders, gradually increasing in number and definiteness.
The most numerous and the most important of these exceptions relate to women, and will be subsequently dealt with. For the male able-bodied person himself (and his family) only three exceptions were to be made. The local authority had discretion to allow him outdoor relief (a) in case of sudden and urgent necessity; (b) in case of sickness, accident, or mental infirmity in his family; or (c) for the burial of any member of his family.[115]
[115] See Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order, 1844, art. 1.
Another series of exceptions allowed outdoor relief to the families of able-bodied persons (a) in gaol, or otherwise in custody; (b) absent as soldiers, sailors or marines; or (c) otherwise residing outside the union.[116]
[116] Ibid.
A third exception empowered the local authorities (as in the analogous case of the Outdoor Labour Test Order) to depart from these regulations in any particular instance, and thus to give outdoor relief to the able-bodied, whether men, women, or their families, on any conditions, subject to their reporting each such instance within fifteen days to the Central Authority and obtaining its subsequent approval. With that approval outdoor relief to the able-bodied, without any conditions, was lawful.
The records of the Central Authority between 1842 and 1847 would show what policy it pursued in approving or disapproving the cases of unconditional outdoor relief to the able-bodied, which were reported by those local authorities to which this Order had been issued. What appears from the published documents is that the Central Authority, between 1835 and 1842, "in cases where this Order had been issued ... had been obliged to sanction large exceptions to its provisions."[117]
[117] Minute of Commissioners, 31st October 1842, p. 381 of Ninth
Annual Report, 1843.
On this, among other grounds, the Central Authority in 1843 took to modifying the operation of the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Orders by supplementing them, in certain of the unions in which they were in force, by an Outdoor Labour Order, practically identical in terms with the Outdoor Labour Test Order of 1842, which we have already mentioned as being alone in force in other unions.[118] Similar Orders--in effect modifying the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order--have ever since continued to be issued to particular unions; but, from 1852 onward, in the form of applying to the particular unions concerned the Outdoor Labour Test Order of 1842, which had theretofore been issued alone.
[118] p. 379 of Ninth Annual Report, 1843.
We are now in a position to sum up the policy of the Central Authority, with regard to outdoor relief to the able-bodied, as it stood in 1847, embodied in documents applicable to three different parts of England and Wales. In thirty-two unions the Labour Test Order of 1842 was alone in force, whilst in twenty-nine others the regulations were essentially similar to this.
In this part of the country the discretion of the local authorities to give outdoor relief to able-bodied independent women (as to other independent women) was unfettered by any regulation, and not directed by any instructions. Outdoor relief to able-bodied men and their families was within the discretion of the local authorities, if it was accompanied by test work by the man and subject to certain conditions.
In other parts of the country, comprising 396 unions, the Prohibitory Order was alone in force, and outdoor relief to the able-bodied, whether men or women, and their families, was, with limited and precise exceptions, prohibited; unless, in particular instances, the local authority subsequently reported it to, and got it sanctioned by, the Central Authority.
In yet other parts of the country, comprising eighty-one unions, the Prohibitory Order and an Outdoor Labour Test Order were jointly in force, and outdoor relief to the able-bodied, whether men or women, and their families, was, so far as general rules went, prohibited.
But such outdoor relief was lawful if it was in each case subsequently reported to, and approved by, the Central Authority; with this difference between that given to able-bodied men (and their families) and that given to independent women (and their families) that the former had to be, and the latter had not to be, accompanied by test work.
This requirement of test work by the man, in certain unions, as a condition of the outdoor relief to be thus sanctioned by the Central Authority, appears at first sight to impose on those unions an additional restriction on the grant of outdoor relief, as compared with those unions in which outdoor relief could be sanctioned by the Central Authority without test work. The practical result may have been exactly the opposite.
The records of the Central Authority between 1843 and 1847 would show to what extent and in what kind of cases its sanction to these cases of outdoor relief was given or refused; and whether, according to the statistics, it was not given more frequently and even as a matter of course, where test work was obligatory as a condition, as compared with cases in which test work was not required.
If this was so, not only did union differ from union in the extent to which outdoor relief to the able-bodied was sanctioned by the Central Authority, but it may be that the statistics would show that in this respect, sex differed from sex--such outdoor relief being freely granted and lightly sanctioned to able-bodied men from whom test work was exacted; and sanctioned with greater stringency in the case of the able-bodied independent women from whom no such test was exacted.
(ii.) In the Workhouse
When "the able-bodied and their families" entered the workhouse, we find the Central Authority prescribing a classification altogether different from that applied to outdoor paupers. The very category of the "able-bodied and their families" disappears. It was, of course, inevitable that this should happen. In any institution, infants, boys, girls, sick and healthy adults, male and female, required different treatments.
But, to the confusion of every one concerned, the Central Authority retained, for its workhouse classification, as for the entirely different classification of outdoor paupers, the same adjective of "able-bodied," without even explaining that it was here used in an altogether different sense. As usual in the documents of this period, there is no definition of the term.
But whenever it occurs in the regulations affecting the workhouse, the term "able-bodied" was apparently intended by the Central Authority to denote all persons not being either children, "the aged and infirm," or "the sick." If the draughtsman of the General Consolidated Order of 1847 had been aware of the need for a definition clause, he would presumably have said that in that Order the term "able-bodied" should denote those persons above the age of childhood, and below that of "the aged," who for the time being were in the enjoyment of normal health.
This class, it will be seen, differs considerably from that referred to in the preamble of the section in the 1834 Act under which outdoor relief to the able-bodied was to have been abolished; namely, persons (with their families) "who at the time of applying for or receiving such relief were wholly or partially in the employment of individuals."[119] The Act thus pointed to the capacity to obtain employment for hire, at any wages whatsoever, whatever may have been the state of health, as the essential characteristic of being "able-bodied." This, too, was the construction placed on the term when used in the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order, 1844, where the Central Authority expressly held that "poor persons who have frequent ailments, who are ruptured and are generally of weak constitutions" but who are "in receipt of wages"--however low such wages might be--must be treated, for outdoor relief, as being "able-bodied persons."[120] When such persons entered the workhouse, not merely would the several members of their families pass into different categories, but they themselves, if the doctor so decided, would, in the view of the Central Authority, on crossing the threshold, cease to be "able-bodied persons,"--and become members of the diametrically opposite category of "the sick." If such persons, without being cured, subsequently left the workhouse, we must infer that, according to the policy of the Central Authority, their characteristic of physical or mental infirmity ceased to be relevant, as they passed, on crossing the threshold, into the ranks of "able-bodied persons."
[119] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 52.
[120] Official Circular, April and May 1848, Nos. 14 and 15,
N.S., pp. 227-8.
Inside the workhouse, the "able-bodied" (in the workhouse sense) are divided simply into male and female. We can find no regulations specially affecting relief to them, as apart from other inmates of the establishment, except some modifications in the amount of food allowed, or of labour exacted. As even these modifications are inextricably mixed up with the general regulations affecting all inmates, and are contained in the same long series of Orders, culminating in the General Consolidated Order of 1847, we relegate them to the subsequent section on the workhouse.
B.--Vagrants
We have seen that the policy of the Report and Act of 1834, with regard to vagrants, was to ignore them as a class, to relieve them only in the workhouse, and to deal with them exactly as with other workhouse inmates. What the Central Authority seems to have contemplated was that the strict application of the "workhouse test" would not only prevent vagrants coming on the rates at all, but that it could be used to prevent almsgiving.
It was apparently with this view that the Central Authority, in 1837, sanctioned a code of regulations for the admission to the workhouse of the "casual poor," meaning "wayfarers" or homeless "persons in a state of destitution ... who ... belonged to distant parishes."[121] These regulations included admission by tickets distributed by any ratepayer, and the performance of a task of work before the grant of a meal.[122] In diet, discipline, and other treatment, they were to be dealt with "as the other paupers in the workhouse."[123] In other unions the regulations included the establishment of a separate vagrant ward, which was equally sanctioned by the Central Authority.
A similar plan was strongly pressed on the local authorities of the Metropolis in 1838 and 1839.[124] Such vagrants must, however, if destitute, not be refused relief.[125] The Central Authority hoped that "if these arrangements be adopted ... casual almsgiving in the streets, by which vagrancy and imposture are encouraged, will be materially checked."[126]
[121] Letter, 6th September 1837, in Fourth Annual Report, 1838,
p. 154.
[122] pp. 135-141 of Third Annual Report, 1837.
[123] p. 89 of Fifth Annual Report, 1839.
[124] Instructional Circular, 12th December 1838; in Fifth Annual
Report, 1839, p. 87; ditto, 7th December 1839, in Sixth Annual
Report, 1840, p. 103.
[125] Letter, 2nd August 1841, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p.
77.
[126] Circular, 7th December 1839; in Sixth Annual Report, 1840,
p. 104.
The first sign of discontent with this policy that we find is in 1841, when the Central Authority is asked by the local authorities of Lambeth and Colchester "whether the workhouse is to be a lodging house and to be inundated with these trampers" who habitually "make the union house a lodging house," greatly to the annoyance of the establishment.
The Central Authority admits that its policy of a mere application of the "workhouse test" to vagrants has proved unsatisfactory, and declares the only effectual remedy to be a separate semi-penal establishment.[127] In the absence of adequate statutory powers, the Central Authority pours out, between 1841 and 1844, a stream of regulations and suggestions to local authorities, based on the idea of making the night's stay of the vagrant more unpleasant to him.
There was to be everywhere a separate vagrant ward; without a fire; smoking and card playing were to be strictly prohibited; they were to be bathed; their bedding was to be inferior to that of other inmates, and so on. Above all, they were to be prosecuted under the Vagrant Act on the slightest provocation.[128]
[127] Official Circular, No. 12, 14th October 1841, p. 170;
Letter, 15th February 1841, to Newcastle Board of Guardians;
Letter, 12th September 1844, to Bradford Board of Guardians.
[128] Official Circular, No. 12, 14th October 1841, p. 170;
General Order, 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842,
p. 81; Letter, 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842,
p. 110.
Yet the Central Authority was not yet convinced of the need for a vagrant ward in every union. When the Bradford Board of Guardians pointed out in 1844 that the average number of their vagrants was only twelve a week, the Central Authority at once acquiesced in the abandonment of the proposed vagrant ward, and said that arrangements should be made to set the vagrants a task of work in the workhouse itself.[129]
[129] Letter to Bradford Board of Guardians, 3rd October 1844.
In 1842 and 1844, as we have seen, slightly increased powers over vagrants were obtained (including, but only by implication, statutory authority for the four hours' detention in the morning), together with powers to establish district asylums for the houseless poor in certain large towns.
The Central Authority "framed a scheme for division of the whole of the Metropolitan district" into areas corresponding "to the great lines of roads along which mendicants and vagrants" entered London,[130] which were to have separate establishments for vagrants, and so entirely relieve the Metropolitan workhouses of their care.[131] What Orders were issued to this effect is not clear. Meanwhile the House of Commons appointed a Select Committee to consider the whole conduct of the Central Authority; and no further action was taken.
Orders were issued to the boards of management of the newly created vagrant districts, telling them that they need not meet.[132] How far these vagrancy districts ever came into existence we have not yet discovered. One of them, the North Eastern Metropolitan District, had got so far as to enter into a contract for the purchase of a site and to borrow £3500 to pay for it.
"Owing to various causes, the chief of which was a want of co-operation on the part of several of the boards of guardians, that scheme, after an inquiry by a Committee of the House of Commons, was abandoned."[133] Beyond this somewhat obscure episode, all that happened was that when the General Consolidated Order of 1847 systematically codified the regulations affecting workhouses, it included, scattered among its various sections, a few provisions relating to the treatment of the "casual poor wayfarers," such as the requirement of a separate ward, and the express regulation of their diet and employment.[134]
[130] p. 19 of Eleventh Annual Report, 1845.
[131] p. 19 of Twelfth Annual Report, 1846; Official Circular,
No. 5, N.S., p. 69, 1st May 1847.
[132] p. 11 of Thirteenth Annual Report, 1847.
[133] Minute of Poor Law Board on the Houseless Poor in the
Metropolis, 23rd December 1863, in Sixteenth Annual Report, 1863,
p. 31.
[134] General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847, see arts.
97, 99 and 104.
C.--Women
We have shown, in the preceding analysis of the Report and Act of 1834, that neither the "principles of 1834" nor the enactment of Parliament had prescribed the policy to be pursued with regard to women; except that it was implied or assumed that wives were to follow their husbands exactly as if they were infants. With regard to the widow, the deserted wife, the wife of the absentee soldier or sailor, the wife of a husband resident in another parish or another country--above all, with regard to the independent able-bodied woman--the Central Authority had either to let the existing practice of outdoor relief continue, or to discover a policy for itself.
With regard to the able-bodied independent woman, we have shown that the Central Authority developed, between 1834 and 1847, two distinct policies which became applicable to two different geographical areas. In the thirty-two unions in which the Outdoor Labour Test Order was alone in force, the discretion of the local authorities to give outdoor relief to able-bodied independent women was left unfettered by any rule, instruction or advice of the Central Authority.[135]
[135] We ought to state that in one of the early Orders (intended
to be temporary) the Central Authority did expressly prescribe a
policy for "single women not being aged or infirm." It was
evidently contemplated that they were to be dealt with quite
differently from the "able-bodied male pauper," who was to be put
to "parish work." The outdoor relief to be granted to them was to
be at least half in kind (p. 85 of First Annual Report, 1835). No
such clause appears in the General Orders subsequently issued.
In the 477 unions in which the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order was in force (either with or without an Outdoor Labour Test Order), outdoor relief to able-bodied independent women was prohibited, with certain exceptions, which, between 1835 and 1844, steadily increased in number.
As crystallised in the Out Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844 (still in force) outdoor relief was allowed to such able-bodied independent women,
(1) On account of sudden and urgent necessity;
(2) On account of the sickness, accident, or bodily or mental
infirmity of any member of their families (unlike a father in like case,
the independent mother was not required to produce a medical
certificate);
(3) For defraying the expenses of burial of any of their families;
(4) If a widow, for the first six months of widowhood or, without
limit of time, if, unable to earn a livelihood, and having one or more
children dependent on her, she had had no illegitimate child since her
widowhood.[136]
[136] Amended Forms of Order prohibiting Outdoor Relief to the
Able-bodied, 1839 and 1840, in Report on the Further Amendment of
the Poor Law, 1839, p. 105, and Seventh Annual Report, 1841, pp.
99-100; Out Relief Prohibitory Order, 1844, art. 1.
In the Circulars issued with these Orders, the only instructions with regard to any class of able-bodied independent women relate to widows.
In these instructions the grant of outdoor relief during the first six months of widowhood, without any mention of its being considered whether they had children or not, or whether they were employed for wages or not, is specially and repeatedly brought to the notice of the local authorities as laudable.[137]
[137] Instructional Letter, December 1839, p. 107 of Report on the
Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839; ditto, August 1840, p.
102 of Seventh Annual Report, 1841.
It was, indeed, insisted by the House of Commons Committee in 1838 "that a power should be continued to the board of guardians, taking into consideration the character of the parties, to relieve, out of the workhouse, widows with young children left dependent upon them."[138]
[138] Report of House of Commons Committee on Poor Law
Administration, 1837-8, p. 39.
This is the more significant in that the Central Authority, in one case at least, had tried a harsher expedient. In the Bradfield Union, which, under Mr.
Stevens' chairmanship, had adopted an ultra-rigorous policy, the board of guardians itself passed a rule forbidding outdoor relief "to any widow or single woman, not being aged or infirm, who is of ability to work," except in sickness, accident or urgent necessity.[139] This was much criticised but was maintained by the majority, who asked the Central Authority to support them by issuing an Order prohibiting all outdoor relief to able-bodied women not being aged or infirm.
The Poor Law Commissioners in reply said that they "most willingly confirm the resolution, and in so doing they desire to state that they consider the workhouse to be the best description of relief for all cases, and they are always glad to perceive that the guardians of any union view outdoor relief as the exception to the general rule, to be administered, with caution, in cases of sickness, infirmity and particular distress only."[140] But even the Bradfield Guardians found this Order, for which they had themselves asked, quite unworkable; and they were reduced to asking sanction for successive departures from it.
They generally granted outdoor relief to widows for the first few weeks of their widowhood, and were often driven to extend it. They then asked for an alteration permitting outdoor relief to able-bodied "widows of good character with more than one child under eleven, if a boy, and under thirteen if a girl." The Central Authority was loath to let go, but had eventually to issue another Special Order as desired.[141]
[139] MS. Minutes, Bradfield Board of Guardians, 12th October
1835.
[140] MS. Minutes, Bradfield Board of Guardians, 8th, 15th and
27th February 1836; Special Order to Bradfield Union, 26th
February 1836.
[141] Ibid. 4th March and 31st October 1836; February, June,
July and November 1839; Poor Law Board to Bradfield Union, 17th
July and 7th November 1839; Special Order to Bradfield Union,
November 1839.
The grant of outdoor relief to widows having children, apart from this six months' term, is, "so far as it relates to able-bodied women in employment," regarded as of doubtful policy, to be made with circumspection, as likely to excuse contributions from relatives, to discourage insurance, and to have all the evils of the rate in aid of wages.
It is suggested, moreover, that a widow can usually earn enough to support one child.[142] It may be understood from a bare reference in the Instructional Letter of 1839 to "able-bodied women themselves" as well as to widows, that the Central Authority was alive to the effect upon women's wages of the grant of outdoor relief to single independent women in employment.[143] But in the revision of this Instructional Letter in 1841--though its terms remained almost identical--the slight reference to the single able-bodied woman wage-earner was silently omitted.[144]
[142] See note 1.
[143] p. 108 of Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law,
1839.
[144] p. 102 of Seventh Annual Report, 1841.
With regard to married women, the policy laid down by the Central Authority differed according to the particular kind of Order in force, and thus according to the locality in which they resided. In all but specially excepted cases, relief to a woman under coverture was deemed to be relief to her husband, and came thus within all the various regulations and conditions limiting outdoor relief to the able-bodied man.
In the thirty-two unions to which Outdoor Labour Test Orders were applied by themselves--these culminating in the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order 1852 (still in force)--the policy of the Central Authority was to leave the discretion of the local authorities unfettered, with regard to the grant of outdoor relief to married women, except the wives of those men ("the able-bodied and their families") to whom outdoor relief was only to be granted in return for labour. In these latter cases the measure of the relief was to be the needs of the family, not the work done by the husband.
In 1835 the Central Authority had even urged that, where the families were large, they "should be furnished with provisions according to their numbers and necessities in the same way as other paupers" by way of "additional relief" to the man for the "wives and children, as far as shall be actually necessary."[145]
[145] Circular, 21st September 1836, p. 48 of Second Annual
Report, 1836.
As the policy became settled, the phrase "additional relief" was dropped; but the amount given to the husband was to depend, not on the amount or value of the work that he did, but was to be "proportioned to the wants of the applicant and his family, and should not be deemed remuneration for the work done."[146] In these cases half, at least, of the relief given to the husband was to be in kind; whilst, according to the Orders, no labour was required from the wife.[147] In spite of the absence from the Orders of any requirement that the wife should render any task of labour, we find the Central Authority in 1842--concerned at the earning of money by the wives (and children) of men at "parish work"--making an inconsistent suggestion.
In the Minute of 31st October 1842, it is suggested that, "if it be practicable, some employment, such as picking up or carrying stones, should be provided for the wives and children. The latter precaution is peculiarly important in the manufacturing districts."[148] This requirement of labour from the wife had, up to 1847, found no embodiment in any Order.
[146] Minute on Outdoor Labour Test, 31st October 1842, p. 383 of
Ninth Annual Report, 1843.
[147] Outdoor Labour Test Order, 30th April 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 175.
[148] p. 385 of Ninth Annual Report, 1843.
In the 477 unions to which the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844 applied, three extensive classes of wives were, by the policy of the Central Authority, to be treated as if they were widows.
(a) A wife deserted by her husband and having only legitimate children dependent on her could, under the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order, 1844, be given Outdoor Relief as a widow having a child dependent on her. As a matter of fact, the position of any wife living apart from her husband was better than that of a widow.
The wife living apart from her husband (whether technically deserted by him or not, and whether or not he was within the union) could insist on the relief of her children, without applying for relief for herself; and if the child was below the age of seven, it could not be separated from her, even with her own consent; and thus the relief had to be outdoor relief. She could, moreover, send her children over seven into the workhouse without herself accompanying them, or herself becoming a pauper.
On the other hand, though the local authority might, if it chose, grant outdoor relief to a widow having a child dependent on her (if she had had no illegitimate child born since her widowhood), it need not do so, and it could not relieve her dependent children, whether under seven or over, without making her a pauper.
(b) The wife of a husband--
(i.) Beyond the seas;
(ii.) In custody of the law; or
(iii.) Confined in an asylum as a lunatic or idiot was to be
treated, for indoor and outdoor relief alike, as if she were a widow (a
widow beyond the six months' term, though this is not so stated). By
"beyond the seas," the Central Authority understood "out of Great
Britain."[149]
[149] Instructional Letter, 17th October 1844; in Eleventh Annual
Report, 1845, p. 137.
(c) In the case of the wife of an able-bodied soldier, sailor, or marine in His Majesty's service (wherever he might be situated), the Central Authority expressly stated that it felt it to be "desirable to give great latitude" to the local authorities.[150]
[150] Instructional Letter, 21st December 1844; in Eleventh Annual
Report, 1845, p. 59.
In all other cases, within those parts of the country to which this Order applied, wives residing with their husbands had to follow them, and were not to be relieved, either in or out of the workhouse, without them. A more difficult question was whether a man could continue to receive relief in the workhouse if his wife insisted on leaving it. The Central Authority, on being appealed to by a local authority actually confronted with such a case, decided that the wife could not be prevented from leaving the workhouse.
It hazarded the opinion (of which we do not admit the legal validity), "that a woman may be restrained by the control of her husband from leaving the workhouse, and if he declines to use his marital control, it is in the power of the guardians to dismiss the husband. But whether it is expedient or judicious to pursue such a course must depend on the peculiar circumstances which each individual case presents.
One consideration is particularly important in dealing with any case of this description, that is, whether the husband is in a condition practically to exercise his control over his wife. Where he is not, it would be very unadvisable, in the opinion of the Commissioners, to make it a condition of the relief of the husband or of his children (if he have any) that he should exercise an authority over his wife which practically he cannot exercise."[151]
[151] Official Circular, 1st June 1845, No. 48, p. 90.
It is interesting at this point to sum up the policy of the Central Authority, so far as embodied in its published documents between 1834 and 1847, with regard to outdoor relief to women, especially as affecting the "Rate in Aid of Wages." The policy differed fundamentally in the two different areas of the country governed respectively by the two kinds of Orders.
Where the Outdoor Labour Test Order (continued, after 1852, by the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order, which is still in force) was alone applied, the discretion of the local authority to give outdoor relief to women of any status, married or unmarried, with children or without, was unfettered by any Order. The only rule made by the Central Authority in the matter was that if the woman was the wife of an able-bodied man who was himself employed on "parish work," and residing with him, at least one-half of his relief should be in kind.
No rule was made or Order issued by the Central Authority against the grant of outdoor relief to women employed for wages, even in respect of the very days on which they were earning wages.
We have mentioned that the Central Authority, so far as men were concerned, stood rigidly to the position of the 1834 Report that the moral character of the applicant was to be absolutely disregarded in considering the relief to be granted to him. With regard to women, however, it took up a different position. We find it advising that the mothers of illegitimate children should, on this ground alone, not be granted outdoor relief.[152]
[152] Poor Law Commissioners to Plymouth Court of Guardians, 25th
April 1840.
Where the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order was in force, neither spinsters nor wives residing with able-bodied husbands[153] could, apart from sudden and urgent necessity, receive outdoor relief, unless they were sick. But with regard to widows and wives living apart from their husbands, the exceptions to the prohibition were so numerous that both these classes may almost be said to have been expressly allowed to receive outdoor relief.
The fact that such women were in employment for wages was not regarded by the Orders of the Central Authority as relevant: nor was it prescribed that any task of labour should be exacted in return for the relief.
And although if we look closely, it is possible to find, in the circulars, instructional letters and published decisions of these thirteen years (1834-1847), two or three bare incidental allusions to the possibility of outdoor relief to women having the effect of a "Rate in Aid of Wages," even these occur only in the earlier years, and presently die away entirely. It is, therefore, not incorrect to say that an objection to outdoor relief to women in employment formed during these years no part of the declared policy of the Central Authority.
[153] Not being soldiers, sailors, or marines.
When women entered the workhouse, the policy of the Central Authority (as in the analogous case of "the able-bodied") was to classify them in quite other categories than those which governed their outdoor relief.
The woman's status, with regard to a man, so fundamental as long as she remained outside, was, in the workhouse, entirely irrelevant. What became important was whether or not she was sick, "able-bodied" (in the workhouse sense), or "aged and infirm"; whether or not she was a nursing mother, or a mother of children under seven years old; whether or not she was of "good character" or of "dissolute and disorderly habits" or the mother of an illegitimate child.
These considerations--leading to classifications inconsistent with each other--affected the women's segregation in the workhouse, the employment provided for them, the dietary and the amount of their freedom. With all this we deal in subsequent sections.
D.--Children
The policy of the Central Authority with regard to the relief of children rested on the general rule that children, residing with their parents (or surviving parent) and dependent on them for support, had to follow them for relief. This was not limited by any condition as to the age of the child, the essential fact being the dependence of the child for support. Looked at from the standpoint of the child, this involved a great and complex difference in policy in the two different areas of the country to which we have had so often to refer.
In unions governed by the Outdoor Labour Test Order (afterwards the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order, 1852), all such children might be relieved in their homes, the only limitation placed on the discretion of the local authority being that, if they were the children of able-bodied men, at least half the relief granted to the father for their necessities had to be in kind.
In unions in which the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order was in force, the children (although not sick) of certain classes of parents might be relieved in their own homes, whilst those of certain other classes of parents could be relieved only by admission to the workhouse (unless, in particular instances, the grant of outdoor relief was specially sanctioned by the Central Authority). This determination by the Central Authority of the method of relief of such children did not depend on their age, their sex, their characteristics, or their needs, but on the artificial categories in which their fathers (or mothers) were placed.
We need not follow these intricacies once more in detail. They can easily be unravelled from the foregoing sections on "The Able-bodied" and on "Women."
Whatever outdoor relief was given to the parent in respect of the child, the policy of the Central Authority was one of absolute non-intervention with regard to its treatment. No directions were given, either for its education or for any other of its needs. The only direction that we find is a decision that the local authority must not pay the school fees for any such child; and must not even add with this view 2d. per week per child to the outdoor relief granted to the parent.[154]
[154] Official Circular, 31st January 1844, No. 31, pp. 178-9.
When the child entered the workhouse it passed out of its former classification and entered into an entirely different one. For outdoor relief, as we have seen, the policy of the Central Authority was to distinguish among children only according to the kind of parents they had. Inside the workhouse, the policy of the Central Authority was to regard this classification as irrelevant, and to place all children, of whatever parentage, in categories, dependent on their own age, sex and health. They were either sick or well; and also either (1) Children under seven; (2) Boys between seven and fifteen; or (3) Girls between seven and fifteen.
The treatment of these categories is so inextricably mixed up with that of the other inmates of the workhouse that we relegate the matter to our subsequent sections.
The Central Authority gave no direction to change the system under which some local authorities sent their pauper children to establishments kept for private profit. In 1838, this system was implicitly sanctioned by a long instructional letter, dealing with "Mr. Aubin's establishment for pauper children at Norwood," where the children were employed in the workshop on alternate days, and were under the special care of a chaplain.[155]
[155] Instructional Letter, 1838, in Fifth Annual Report, 1839, p.
76.
But the Central Authority was evidently uneasy about the quarter of a million pauper children, of whom it was gradually getting some tens of thousands in the great general workhouses on which it had insisted.[156] Reports on the training of the workhouse children were called for, and a valuable series was published in 1841, in which the establishment of separate boarding schools was suggested, where the children could receive both elementary schooling and industrial training.
This proposal united the opposition of the boards of guardians, who objected to a new authority, to that of those who demurred to giving the pauper children any better education than the children of the lowest independent labourer.[157]
[156] At Midsummer, 1838, the children under sixteen in the
workhouses of the 478 unions then making returns numbered no fewer
than 42,767, out of a total workhouse population of 97,510.
(Special Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, p.
56.) In 1840 the Poor Law Commissioners estimated the total number
under 16 to be 64,570, of whom 56,835 were between 2 and 16
(Report on the Training of Pauper Children, 1841, p. iii.).
[157] "It would be said that we should be giving the pauper
children a better education than that obtainable by the
independent labourer's child. While I allow and lament this truth,
I wholly deny its force. Because the schooling of children out of
the workhouse is neglected, is this a valid reason and excuse for
equally neglecting those who are within it? According to this
argument, not a single ray of moral or religious knowledge should
be allowed to illumine the mind of a pauper child; he should be
brought up a perfect brute, since it is certain that this is the
lot of innumerable independent children" (E.
Carleton Tufnell, in
Report on the Training of Pauper Children, 1841, p. 355).
In 1844, as we have seen, the Central Authority obtained statutory power to direct the establishment of district schools; but no Order on the subject appears to have been issued prior to 1847.
We pass now to the children of an age to be started in life. Though the Central Authority had been expressly empowered to issue regulations as to apprenticeship, it did not, during its first decade, issue any Order on the subject. The only indication which we can find of the policy which it wished pursued during this decade with regard to such children is a comment on the proposed Bill for the Amendment of the Poor Law in
- This comment is strongly adverse to the payment of apprenticeship
premiums, and suggests that premiums are only needed in "occasional" cases of lame or blind children.[158] Not until 1845 does the Central Authority issue any directions on the subject.
By the Apprenticeship Orders of December 1844, and January 1845, amended in August 1845, and included and amplified in the General Consolidated Order of 1847, elaborate conditions of apprenticeship were prescribed for the protection of the apprentice; limits of age were fixed; the duties of the masters were made more onerous and definite; and the payment of premiums, whilst still allowed for children between nine and sixteen, was expressly prohibited, at first for all over fourteen, but subsequently for all over sixteen, unless physically deformed or defective, except in the form of clothing.[159] But the Central Authority does not advocate apprenticeship.
On the contrary, in issuing the Order of 1845, it wrote a special letter to accompany it in which the local authorities were pointedly reminded that it had hitherto refrained from issuing any regulations on the subject; that as Parliament had not abolished the system of apprenticeship it would "doubtless continue to be practised in those districts where it has hitherto prevailed"; that "there are not wanting authorities of weight against the system"; and that local authorities were not to infer that the Central Authority entertained "any desire to promote its introduction."[160]
[158] Official Circular, No. 5, 16th June 1840, p. 56.
[159] General Order, 31st December 1844, and 29th January 1845, in
Eleventh Annual Report, 1845, pp. 72-96; 15th and 22nd August
1845, in Twelfth Annual Report, 1846, pp. 60-71; and Arts. 52-74
of General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847.
[160] Circular, 1st January 1845, in Eleventh Annual Report, 1845,
pp. 96-7.
Apart from this severe discouragement of apprenticeship we can discover no indication of the policy of the Central Authority as to starting the children in life. No advice was given to the local authorities on the subject.
E.--The Sick
We have seen that neither the Report nor the Act of 1834 laid down any policy for the sick--suggesting, in fact, no change in the existing practice under which they were both maintained and medically attended in their homes. During the whole of the period, 1834-47, there is nothing in the Orders laying down any other policy so far as the maintenance of the sick is concerned.
Both the two streams of regulations, the Outdoor Labour Test Orders (culminating in the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order of 1852) and the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844, expressly excepted, from all their prohibitions or restrictions on the grant of outdoor relief, cases of "sickness, accident, or bodily or mental infirmity." In all these cases the policy of the Central Authority was to leave the local authorities the same absolutely unfettered discretion with regard to the grant of outdoor relief that they had before possessed.
In the Instructional Letter of 1836 as to medical attendance the practice of granting outdoor relief to the sick in "food or clothing" is mentioned, without criticism.[161] So much was this the accepted policy that, when the Central Authority referred to the sick, in the comprehensive defence of its action in 1839, it only mentioned the steps that it had in view with regard to the better organisation of medical attendance, which did not seem to call "for any immediate general change"--without even alluding to the almost universal practice under which the sick received also outdoor relief in money.[162] In a Minute of 1840 it is pointed out that members of friendly societies in receipt of a money allowance whilst sick were only to be granted such amount of outdoor relief as, together with their allowances, would make up the sums which the local authority would have granted if they had had nothing.
It is not even hinted that the grant of outdoor relief at all was against the policy of the Central Authority, although it is suggested that in these cases it should be granted on loan.[163]
[161] Instructional Letter, 6th May 1836, in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 50.
[162] Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, pp.
73-81.
[163] Minute, 27th March 1840, in Sixth Annual Report, 1840, pp.
95-96.
The first suggestion that we have found of this policy not being wholly satisfactory occurs in 1840, in the Central Authority's comments on the case of a boy who had died, it was asserted, from privation whilst his father was actually in receipt of outdoor relief.
No blame was imputed to the local authority, which, it was said, had been "acting under a recognised mode of relief"; but it was suggested that the case showed the dangers of "partial relief"; that illness was likely to be more quickly cured "with the advantages of the superior cleanliness and the better regulated warmth and ventilation of the appropriate rooms or a sick ward" of the workhouse together with the superior nursing, dietary, and doctoring there possible; and that, especially where there was likelihood of the outdoor relief or other family income being unwisely applied, it was better to relieve by admission to the workhouse.[164] But this first suggestion of an alternative policy stands alone; and it was not embodied in any Order.
[164] Official Circular, No. 9, 10th November 1840, pp. 113-118.
What the Central Authority was concerned about, with regard to the sick poor, was not their outdoor relief, but the extent to which they took advantage of the services of the parish doctor. Already in 1836 it was laid down by an Instructional Letter (which expressed no criticism on the practice of granting relief "in food or clothing") that medical attendance could be allowed only in cases of destitution.
As, however, sickness quickly involved destitution, it was suggested that provident sick clubs should be promoted, to provide for medical attendance when needed.[165] Four years later it is pointed out that members of friendly societies, entitled as such to medical attendance, must not be allowed the services of the parish doctor.[166] This was repeated in 1844.[167] "Medical extras," such as "meat, milk, wine, and porter," could not be ordered by the doctor, but could be granted, on his recommendation, by the local authority; and it is to be noted that the Central Authority adds no words in any way discouraging such grant.[168] The Central Authority became even more concerned about the organisation of the medical attendance, the area of each medical officer's district, the method of selecting him, his qualification, and above all the mode of his remuneration, so that he might not be tempted to increase the number of cases.[169] Its views on this subject were embodied in the General Medical Order of 12th March 1842, and explained in the accompanying letter of the same date.[170] We omit this, along with other administrative questions; but it must be noted that the whole policy of the Central Authority in the matter rested on the assumption, on which no criticism was expressed, that the sick would, as a matter of fact, be relieved in their homes.
[165] Instructional Letter, 6th May 1836, in Second Annual Report,
1836, pp. 50-51.
[166] Minute, 27th March 1840; in Sixth Annual Report, 1840, p.
95.
[167] Official Circular, No. 34, 30th April 1844, p. 76.
[168] Ibid. p. 74.
[169] Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, pp.
73-81.
[170] pp. 129-142 of Eighth Annual Report, 1842.
When the sick entered the workhouse they were dealt with as a class by themselves, in the general establishment which alone was then in existence. We shall deal with the policy with regard to them in a subsequent section.
It may be noted that in 1840 the Central Authority supported the proposal of the Government Bill of that year for the establishment of district infirmaries, but these were not for the sick, but for the infirm.[171] The proposal was never proceeded with. In 1842 the local authorities are incidentally reminded that they have power to send sick persons to hospitals outside the union.[172]
[171] Official Circular, No. 5, 16th June 1840, pp. 51-53.
[172] Letter, 2nd August 1841, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p.
77.
F.--Persons of Unsound Mind
A separation of lunatics from the other inmates of the workhouses had been suggested in the Report of 1834. But it was in the course of this period 1834-47 that persons of unsound mind became recognised as a distinct class. It was, however, long before any settled term was used.
We read of "idiots" (1), dangerous (2), or not dangerous (3), curable (4), or not curable; "the insane" (5), "persons of weak intellect" (6), or suffering from "mental infirmity" (7), or from "mental imbecility" (8), or from "disease of mind" (9), or merely "persons of unsound mind" (10).[173]
[173] (1) (3) Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief
in Town Unions, 7th March 1836, in Second Annual Report, 1836, p.
89. (2) General Order, 24th July 1847, art. 101. (4) Letter of 5th
February 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 111. (5) (10)
General Order, 3rd December 1841, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842,
p. 183. (7) Form of Order, 1839, in Report on the Further
Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, p. 106. (8) General Order, 30th
April 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 177. (9) General
Order, 5th February, 1842, in ibid. p. 80.
Persons suffering from "mental infirmity" (explained to mean "insane") were repeatedly excepted from the prohibition of the grant of outdoor relief.[174] In the Outdoor Labour Test Order a similar exception allows outdoor relief, without work, and even if the applicant is in employment, on account of the mental infirmity of a member of his family.[175] Finally, a similar exception was definitely incorporated in the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844 (still in force) and the Outdoor Relief Regulation Order of 1852 (still in force).
[174] Amended Form of Order prohibiting Outdoor Relief to the
able-bodied; Instructional Letter, 1839, in Report on the Further
Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, pp. 106-107.
[175] p. 177 of Eighth Annual Report, 1842.
We are not here concerned with the increasing statutory powers, and the practical application of them, for the compulsory removal to asylums or other licensed houses of persons certified to be dangerous; or with the question of their chargeability. When persons of unsound mind found their way to the workhouse they were to be detained. It should be noted that the Central Authority supported the Government proposal to enable unions to combine for the establishment of district asylums for the insane poor, a proposal which was not proceeded with.[176]
[176] Official Circular, No. 5, 16th June 1840, supplement, p.
9.
G.--Defectives
We must note the beginning of a new class, only just mentioned in the Report and Act of 1834, viz. that of the physically defective, at first only those who were blind, or deaf and dumb. The Act of 1834 had implicitly sanctioned the grant of outdoor relief to such of these defective persons as were either wives or children, by regarding such relief as not made to the husbands or fathers, even if these were able-bodied and in employment. Within the period 1834-47 we find no hint of a new policy.
The Central Authority issues no Order dealing with the suggestion, made in the Report of 1834, of institutional treatment for the blind. In 1842, however, the local authorities are incidentally reminded that they have power to send the blind or deaf and dumb to such voluntary institutions as existed for them even if they were outside the union.[177] Beyond this there is no suggestion of policy, either for the blind or for the deaf and dumb, except as regards apprenticeship.
The deaf and dumb did not need to be taught to read and write before being eligible for apprenticeship.[178] Premiums were admitted to be necessary in binding as apprentices lame or blind children;[4] and might be given even for children over fourteen or even over sixteen, if they were unfitted for the trade by permanent bodily infirmity.[179]
[177] Letter, 2nd August 1841, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p.
77.
[178] General Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847, art. 52.
[179] Minute, 13th June 1840, in Official Circular, No. 5, 16th
June 1840, p. 56.
[180] General Order, 31st December 1844, art. 2, in Eleventh
Annual Report, 1845, pp. 16, 72; General Consolidated Order, 24th
July 1847, art. 54.
H.--The Aged and Infirm
As with the sick, so with the aged and infirm, neither the Report nor the Act of 1834 had suggested any change in the current policy of outdoor relief. Nor did the Central Authority prescribe any new policy with regard to this class.
It is to be noted that there is the usual absence of definition. The aged and the infirm are always referred to as forming one and the same class. (The word "impotent," used in the Report of 1834, seems to have been silently dropped.) It should be noted also that the class of the "aged and infirm" was not restricted to the infirm aged. The question of age did not enter in at all. What was meant was the class of persons permanently incapacitated, whether from old age, physical defect, or chronic debility, from obtaining any paid employment.
The essential characteristic of "the aged and infirm" (like that of "children") was indeed the precise opposite of that of "the able-bodied." The latter always meant (for outdoor relief) those who were actually or potentially in employment for hire. The "aged and infirm" were those (not being children) who could not possibly get employment for any hire, however small; and together with the "children" and "the able-bodied" they made up in the eyes of the Central Authority the whole pauper universe.
It was, as we have seen, universally assumed that the various prohibitions or regulations of outdoor relief to the able-bodied did not apply to "aged and infirm persons." These persons were, indeed, expressly made exceptions from the first universal rule prohibiting outdoor relief to any one, in the "Form of Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town Unions."[181] In the succeeding Orders prohibiting or regulating outdoor relief, all mention of them is omitted, as not falling within the class of "the able-bodied and their families" to which alone these orders applied.
In 1839 the Central Authority definitely laid it down "that we do not require aged and infirm paupers to be relieved only in the workhouse," and that "it is not our intention to issue any such rule."[182] The discretion of the local authorities in the matter of outdoor relief to this class was thus left as absolutely unfettered as before; and we can find in the published documents of this period of 1834-47 no direction or advice by the Central Authority on the subject, and no indication that it had any new policy.
[181] p. 92 of Second Annual Report, 1836.
[182] Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, pp.
53, 61.
When the aged and infirm entered the workhouse they (like the able-bodied) were put into entirely new categories, though without a new terminology. Those who, whilst in receipt of outdoor relief were merely "aged and infirm," found themselves classified in the workhouse according to sex, age and bodily health. Those who were under sixty, and were not ordered by the doctor to be put on special diet, found themselves classed as "able-bodied" (in the workhouse sense).
These varieties of treatment in the general workhouse will be dealt with in a subsequent section. It is to be noted that in 1840 the Central Authority supported the Government proposal to enable "district infirmaries" to be established apart from the general workhouse for such of the aged and infirm as received indoor relief.
The class to be therein accommodated was to include "every person applying for or receiving relief who shall, by reason of any bodily defect, or of any permanent ailment, or of the permanent effects of any ailment or bodily accident, be incapable of supporting himself."[183] The proposal was never proceeded with.
[183] Official Circular, No. 5, 16th June 1840, p. 53.
It is clear that, although there is no indication of this policy in the Report of 1834, or in any of the statutes, the Poor Law Commissioners, between 1834 and 1847, had it occasionally in their minds to apply the "deterrent" workhouse test to the aged and infirm, as well as to the able-bodied. In 1839, indeed, they expressed this intention. It will be remembered that the 1834 Report had talked of the aged enjoying "their indulgences" in workhouses set apart for them.
"With regard to the aged and infirm," say the Commissioners of 1839, "there is a strong disposition on the part of a portion of the public so to modify the arrangements [of the workhouses] as to place them on the footing of almshouses. The consequences which would flow from this change have only to be pointed out to show its inexpediency and its danger.
If the condition of the inmates of a workhouse were to be so regulated as to invite the aged and infirm of the labouring classes to take refuge in it, it would immediately be useless as a test between indigence and indolence and fraud, it would no longer operate as an inducement to the young and healthy to provide support for their later years, or as a stimulus to them whilst they have the means to support their aged parents and relatives.
The frugality and forethought of a young labourer would be useless if he foresaw the certainty of a better asylum for his old age than he could possibly provide by his own exertions, and the industrious efforts of a son to provide a maintenance for his parents in his own dwelling would be thrown away and would cease to be called forth, if the almshouse of the district offered a refuge for their declining years, in which they might obtain comforts and indulgences which even the most successful of the labouring classes cannot always obtain by their own exertions."[184]
[184] Special Report of Poor Law Commissioners on the Further
Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, p. 47.
I.--Non-Residents
A new class of persons arises in the documents after 1834, namely those who are not residing in the parish or union to which they apply for relief. There had grown up a custom under the old Poor Law by which, in order to save the expense and hardships of removal, parishes agreed to grant outdoor relief to persons belonging to them by settlement, who were residing elsewhere. The Central Authority set itself to restrict this practice.
By various of its early Orders it prohibited it altogether, and at once (with the usual exceptions of sickness, accident, and urgent necessity) in the case of able-bodied male persons between sixteen and sixty. It prohibited it as regards all new cases for all other persons with the same exceptions.[185] Between this date and 1844 we find the same series of exceptions allowed to this general prohibition as in the case of outdoor relief to the able-bodied and their families; and these exceptions became stereotyped in Art.
3 of the Outdoor Relief Prohibitory Order of 1844 (still in force).
[185] p. 85 of First Annual Report, 1835.
J.--The Workhouse
As we have shown, the Act of 1834 and the subsequent legislation left to the Central Authority complete discretion as to the kind of indoor maintenance to be provided for the destitute by the local authority. In view of the fact that the action taken between 1834 and 1847--culminating in the General Consolidated Order of 1847, which is still in force--determined, in the main, the character of the modern workhouse, it is necessary to analyse in some detail exactly what the policy was which the Central Authority in these years imposed from one end of England to another. The common understanding at the time was, we believe, that the policy to be carried out was that of the 1834 Report.
Two limitations only were imposed on the power of the Central Authority in this respect.
The building of entirely new workhouses--which the Report had thought would not be requisite in many instances[186]--was dependent on the assent either of a majority of the board of guardians or of a majority of the rated owners and occupiers.[187] The Central Authority was, however, empowered, without any local consent, peremptorily to order a local authority to enlarge or alter any existing workhouse or building capable of being converted into a workhouse; subject to the limitation that the principal sum to be raised on any parish could not exceed £50, or one-tenth of the average Poor Rate of the last three years.[188] As every board of guardians in the United Kingdom found itself in possession of several parish workhouses--sometimes of a large number of such buildings--it was within the statutory power of the Central Authority, even without local consent, to have given directions for the moderate enlargement and adaptation of any or all of these, which Parliament seems to have contemplated.
The second limitation seems at first sight more serious.
The Central Authority could not order any greater expenditure, on building or enlarging any workhouse, or sanction the borrowing for this purpose of any larger sum, than the average amount of the last three years' Poor Rate[189]--a limitation which, as we have seen, was, in 1844, repealed so far as the purchase of sites in the Metropolitan Police District and the parish of Liverpool was concerned.[190] But there was at no time any limitation to the aggregate amount of the expenditure out of Poor Rate that might be incurred by the local authority, or that might, with or without its consent, be ordered by the Central Authority to be spent, on the enlargement or adaptation of its various existing workhouses, provided that not more than the statutory maximum was spent on any one of them.
In view of the strong objection expressed in the 1834 Report to the mixing of different kinds of paupers in a single institution,[191] and the positive recommendation, in preference, of distinct institutions, in separate buildings, with specialised rules and under different managements, for the several kinds of paupers[192]--for which it was expressly pointed out that the existing buildings were to be adapted[193]--these sections of the Act of 1834 indicate an intention of Parliament (as it certainly was the intention of the authors of the Report of 1834) that each union should have several small institutions, and should assign to those workhouses "separate classes of poor."[194]
[186] p. 313 of Report of 1834 (reprint of 1905).
[187] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 23.
[188] Ibid. sec. 25.
[189] 4 & 5 William IV. c. 76, sec. 24.
[190] See ante, p. 19.
[191] pp. 306, 307, 313 of Report of 1834.
[192] Ibid. pp. 306, 307.
[193] Ibid. p. 313.
[194] Ibid. p. 314.
It is startling to find that the Central Authority, between 1834 and 1847, pursued an entirely different policy. The published documents for this period do not afford any explanation of this difference. They do not show, for instance, whether it meant the deliberate adoption of a new policy, or whether it resulted merely from a discovery that the recommendations of the Report were impracticable in the rural unions.
The documents simply assume the necessity for the establishment in each union, not of a group of specialised workhouses for the different classes, but of one institution, to be called "The Union Workhouse," for the paupers as a whole.
In no Special or General Order, in no Circular or published Minute, can we find any recommendation that a board of guardians should carry out the emphatic recommendations of the 1834 Report in favour of classification by institutions, and the adaptation of the existing buildings into specialised workhouses, "assigning one class of paupers to each of the houses comprehended within each incorporation."[195] Nor was the unity introduced and insisted on by the Central Authority one of structure only.
That the policy was to have, under the one roof, for all the various kinds of paupers, only one institution and one régime, is revealed in every part of the workhouse code.
In the elaborate series of Special Orders and General Orders which culminated in the General Consolidated Order of 1847 (still in force), we find a minutely particular body of rules, referring always to "the" workhouse of the Union, applied with practical identity to all unions, providing for the reception under a single roof and subject to a single officer of every kind of pauper, applying to all the inmates, and (with quite insignificant variations, presently to be noted, for the aged, the sick and the infants), treating all the kinds of paupers alike.[196]
[195] p. 313 of Report of 1834.
[196] See the first of such "Orders and Regulations," in First
Annual Report, 1835, pp. 96-110; the Consolidated Order for the
Administration of Relief in Town Unions, in Second Annual Report,
1836, pp. 81-89; the General Order, Workhouse Rules, 5th February
1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, pp. 79-104; and the General
Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847.
It was possibly connected with this policy of one general workhouse for each union that we find the Central Authority assuming that the grouping together of a score or more of parishes almost inevitably involved building a new workhouse.
At first, indeed, the Assistant Commissioners were directed to examine to what extent existing poorhouses or workhouses could be "made useful for only one class of paupers."[197] In August 1835, the Central Authority could write of its year's experience that "it has also been proved that the expense and loss of time in building new workhouses may, in many cases, be saved, by a union of parishes and the combination of their existing workhouses and poorhouses, by assigning one or two classes of the paupers to one of the separate workhouses within the district."[198] But already by that time the contrary policy was being carried out by the most energetic subordinate of the Central Authority, who (as his private reports show) had quickly satisfied himself, and was rapidly convincing his superiors, that the policy of utilising as specialised institutions the existing parish workhouses was, with the boards of guardians of that time, administratively impossible.
Already by August 1835, Sir Francis B. Head was reporting that "with the exception of Romney Marsh, the whole of East Kent, comprehending an area of 590 square miles, is now grouped into compact unions of parishes; these unions are all very nearly of the same size--all contain very nearly the same population--all have voluntarily adopted for their workhouse the same low, cheap, homely building--all have agreed in placing it in the centre of their respective unions."[199]
[197] First Annual Report, 1835, p. 29.
[198] First Annual Report, 1835, p. 16.
[199] Ibid. p. 166.
It is interesting to see the arguments by which this flagrant departure from the policy of the 1834 Report was attacked and defended. In 1835 we have a magistrate of Kent, belonging to a union where they had so far adhered to the recommendations of the Report, writing very graphically on the subject to Sir Francis Head. "There is one point," he said, "upon which our practice differs materially from most of our neighbours, and it is one upon which I entertain a strong opinion that ours is the correct system.
It is the adaptation of existing workhouses to different classes, instead of building new ones.... In the first place upon our system there is a great saving of expense; our homes altogether have cost us under £300.... I dislike the appearance of these new houses all over the country.... I dislike the outward and visible sign of the change that is being operated. I am alarmed at the irritation. I fear the consequences.
When we have eight workhouses there is hardly an inducement to pull down one only, and to pull them all down is next to impossible, from the wide surface over which they are spread. Our system, I might almost say, eludes the grasp of insurrection. Besides this, how much more perfect is the classification! How secure are our separate schools from all contamination. How small are the masses of pauperism which we bring together, compared with the congestion of one vast House.
With us, our Houses are not like prisons, for we require no high wall to separate the classes; eight or ten miles distance is far more effectual than the highest walls."
To this Sir Francis Head seems to have replied to the following effect.
He did not at all agree with his correspondent that eight classified workhouses were better than one general establishment. "The very sight," he said, "of a well-built efficient establishment would give confidence to the board of guardians; the sight and weekly assemblage of all servants of their union would make them proud of their office; the appointment of a chaplain would give dignity to the whole arrangement, while the pauper would feel it was utterly impossible to contend against it.
In visiting such a series of unions, the Assistant Commissioner could with great facility perform his duty, whereas if he had eight establishments to search for in each union, it would be almost impracticable to attend to them.
I would, moreover, beg to observe that in one establishment there would always be a proper governor, ready to receive and govern any able-bodied applicants, whereas in separate establishments this most important arrangement (the Able-bodied House) during harvest, etc., would constantly be empty, and consequently would become inefficient in moments of emergency."[200]
[200] MS. correspondence of Sir Francis Head.
Sir Francis Head, as we have seen, had his way. In writing a farewell letter to the Kentish boards of guardians at the end of 1835, he urges them to stick to the dietary, and to appoint a chaplain "to your central house, which will shortly be the sole establishment in your union....
As soon as this important object has been gained--as soon as you find that the whole of your indoor poor are concentrated in one respectable establishment--under your own weekly superintendence--when you see yourselves surrounded by a band of resolute, sensible, well-educated men faithfully devoted to your service--you will then, I believe, fully appreciate the advantage which you, as well as your successors, will ever derive from possessing one strong, efficient building, instead of having, from false economy, frittered away your resources among your old existing houses."[201]
[201] Ibid.
After this we hear no more of the policy of specialised institutions for particular kinds of paupers, as recommended in the Report of 1834. The policy of the Central Authority settles down definitely to that which provided each union with one general workhouse, almost invariably built for the purpose, near the centre of the union.[202]
[202] The possibility was once barely mentioned in 1837 of the one
"common workhouse establishment" consisting "of a selection of the
better workhouses now existing in each union," instead of
concentrating "all the necessary accommodation in one workhouse
situated in the centre of the union" (Third Annual Report, 1837,
p. 27.) See also the reference to this possibility in the
Instructional Letter sent in that year to each new Board of
Guardians (ibid. p. 82).
In June 1837, the Central Authority
said that it had always preferred one central workhouse, but had
sometimes allowed existing ones to remain. Its two years'
experience had now confirmed it in its belief that one central
workhouse was better (Letter to Newcastle Board of Guardians, 20th
June 1837).
Two years later, in describing, with praise, "the consolidation of workhouse establishments" which had been going on in Lancashire and Yorkshire, the Central Authority observes "that very few will ultimately find it desirable to retain more than one establishment" (Fifth Annual Report, 1839, p. 29). In the Special Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, it is pointed out, as evidence that the Central Authority had not yet had time to put its policy completely into execution, that there were "still about seventy unions in which a central workhouse" had "not yet been built." (Report on the Further Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, p. 7.)
It is not easy to discover what policy was laid down as to the site and character of the new general workhouse thus prescribed. There was no Special or General Order, and apparently no paper of rules or suggestions, giving any direction as to the position to be chosen, the surroundings to be preferred, or even the area to be obtained. Nothing was prescribed as to the character of the building, the cubic space to be provided for each inmate, the sanitary arrangements, or the structural provision for classification by sex, age, character or condition.
To some extent this lack of any statement of policy may have been supplied by oral explanations in the process of sanctioning the building plans. This hardly applies, however, to the choice of a site; and we cannot discover from any published document whether the Central Authority thought it preferable that the union workhouse should be located in the crowded streets of a populous city or in a pleasant rural district.
The only help that seems to have been afforded was the publication in 1835 of some pictures and diagrams of suggested workhouses.[203] From these we may infer that the Central Authority had adopted as its policy the erection of the same "low, cheap, homely (?) building"--bearing no little resemblance to the prison plans of the period--with which Sir Francis Head was covering East Kent.
[203] First Annual Report, 1835, p. 29, and end.
It was not until 1842, after illness due to serious over-crowding had occurred at the Sevenoaks Workhouse,[204] that the Central Authority began to incorporate in its policy some elementary sanitary regulations.
We have first the requirement that a maximum number to be accommodated in each workhouse should be fixed. Even then it was left to each board of guardians to suggest whatever number it chose, after consultation with its medical officer, subject to approval and to the final fixing of the number by the Central Authority.[205] In 1847 the phrase with regard to approval drops out, and the Central Authority merely fixes the number.
[204] Eighth Annual Report, 1842, pp. 13-15, 188-190, 194-198.
[205] General Order, 5th February 1842, art. 11, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 81; amended by General Consolidated Order, 24th
July 1847, art. 100; still in force.
In 1842 the medical officer of the union is required to report to his board any defects in drainage, ventilation, and warmth.[206] Beyond these somewhat exiguous forms no policy was even suggested to the local authorities with regard to the structural arrangements of the workhouse.
[206] Eighth Annual Report, 1842, pp. 14, 188-190.
We have now to consider how the Central Authority exercised its power to determine the character of the one general workhouse which it had imposed on each union. Let us take the policy laid down with regard to each phase of the indoor pauper's life.
(i.) Admission
The door was to be always open. In cases of "sudden or urgent necessity" any person in a state of destitution, applying at any hour, with or without an order or any other formality, was to be immediately relieved by admission, and by the supply of food, clothing, medicine, and other necessaries. Where the necessity was not urgent, the applicant had first to get an order for admission, which (unless some other mode of relief was adopted) could not be refused to any destitute person. The pauper admitted was to be cleansed, clothed, medically examined, and searched for prohibited articles, in a "probationary" or "receiving" ward.
The pauper was then, if free from disease, to be assigned to his particular section of the workhouse, according to a sevenfold classification by sex, age, and physical condition.
(ii.) Segregation
The character of the workhouse of 1835-1847 was principally determined by the practice as to the segregation of its inmates. To discover exactly what the Central Authority intended this segregation to be is surprisingly difficult. We have first a rigid and logical classificatory scheme, imposed with the force of law. To this there came both a series of exceptions to the classification and a series of directions as to the practical segregation in daily life, additional to or inconsistent with the classification; some of them permissive and others mandatory.
The seven classes insisted on by the classificatory scheme of the Central Authority were (i.) aged or infirm men; (ii). able-bodied males over thirteen; (iii.) boys between seven and thirteen; (iv.) aged or infirm women; (v.) able-bodied women and girls over sixteen; (vi.) girls between seven and sixteen; and (vii.) children under seven. This classification, imposed in 1836, was confirmed, with only the slightest of modifications, by the General Orders of 1842 and 1847 (the latter still in force).
As therein finally settled, it provided for "(i.) men infirm through age or any other cause; (ii.) able-bodied men and youths above the age of fifteen years; (iii.) boys above the age of seven years and under that of fifteen; (iv.) women infirm through age or any other cause; (v.) able-bodied women and girls above the age of fifteen years; (vi.) girls above the age of seven years and under that of fifteen; and (vii.) children under seven years of age." Explicit rules are made that each class is to remain in the separate apartments or buildings assigned to it, without communication with any other class.[207]
[207] General Order, 5th February 1842, art. 9, in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 80; General Consolidated Order, 24th July
1847, art. 98; still in force.
The modern student is struck at once by the omissions in this compulsory classificatory scheme. There is no class for the sick, either those suffering from infectious or contagious diseases, or from others. There is no class for the lying-in cases. There is no class for the lunatics, idiots, or imbeciles. There is no provision for infants at the breast, who, by the classificatory scheme, were ordered to be separated from their mothers. There was no class for the vagrant intending to stay only one night.
Finally, there was no provision made for any segregation by character--not merely none by past character, but not even for any by present character or conduct, which would have effected a separation between quiet and orderly inmates and the turbulent prostitute or semi-criminal.
Some of these omissions were partly remedied by new Orders or recommendations between 1836 and 1847, which were embodied in the General Consolidated Order of 1847, but never found their way into the classificatory scheme itself.
With regard to the sick, the Central Authority imposed no requirements at all. It was incidentally mentioned in the Order of 1836, and repeated in those of 1842 and 1847, that the sick were, on admission, to be placed in "the sick ward," or in such other ward as the medical officer might direct. We have incidental references during the ensuing decade to the existence of sick wards in workhouses.
But there was no provision in any Order requiring a "sick ward" to be provided, still less any provision requiring properly classified accommodation for the sick of different ages, sexes, conditions, or diseases. When these workhouse rules were issued in 1842 as a General Order to practically all the unions then in existence, they were still left without any mention even of infectious diseases.
The utmost that the Central Authority could bring itself to do was to declare, in the covering letter, but not in the rules themselves, that it was the duty of the master, under the direction of the medical officer, to isolate an infectious case in a separate apartment.[208]
[208] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, pp. 108-109. In 1845, after the deliberate sending
to the workhouse of a small-pox patient had led to an epidemic,
the Central Authority goes so far as to suggest to the board of
guardians concerned "that it is of the utmost consequence that
provision should be made at the workhouse by separate infectious
wards for the reception of cases of this description without
endangering the health of all in the house" (Letter of 25th
September 1845, in Official Circular, 1st January 1846, No. 55,
p. 15).
But even then there was no order made on the subject; no
alteration of the classificatory scheme; and no general
recommendation to all boards of guardians.
The explanation of the omission to provide for the sick will
become apparent at a later stage. It was no part of the policy of
the Central Authority that the sick should be received into the
workhouse at all. It was assumed that they would normally be
relieved in their own homes. The incidental scanty references to
the sick wards of the workhouses had reference only to the
accommodation of such of the inmates of the workhouse as happened
to fall sick. Even these were, in serious cases, to be transferred
to a voluntary hospital, where such an institution existed.
A
resolution of the Poplar Board of Guardians, in 1842, to send "all
cases requiring extraordinary surgical aid" to the London Hospital
was approved (Official Circular, No. 20, 30th July 1842, p.
297). "Any reasonable subscription to a hospital or similar
establishment by a Board of Guardians" would be sanctioned
(ibid. No. 17, 12th April 1842, p. 250.)
When the rules were finally consolidated in 1847, they still ignored the sick in their scheme of classification, and actually omitted all mention either of infectious diseases, or of lying-in cases, merely laying it down in general terms that it was the duty of the guardians, "after consulting the medical officer," to "make such arrangements as they may deem necessary, with regard to persons labouring under any disease of body or mind."[209]
[209] Art. 99 of General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847;
still in force.
No provision whatever was made for the segregation of paupers of unsound mind, whether lunatics, idiots, or imbeciles. In an Order of 1836 we do indeed find "the ward for lunatics and idiots" incidentally mentioned, as existing in some workhouses;[210] but such a ward was never required by the Central Authority, nor even suggested by it.
[210] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. 5; in Second Annual Report, 1836, p.
89.
In 1842, it was ordered that, if such paupers were dangerous, they were not to be retained in the workhouse, but sent to an asylum within fourteen days.[211] It was even suggested in an Instructional Letter in 1842 that curable cases, even if not dangerous, should be sent to asylums; and that even incurable, harmless idiots were inconvenient inmates of a workhouse. But no hint is given of the desirability of their segregation whilst they are there.[212]
[211] Art. 12 of General Order, 5th February 1842, in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 82; repeated in art. 101 of General
Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847.
[212] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 111.
With regard to infants at the breast, no special provision was ever made by rule. But it was allowed that children under seven might be placed (though only if the guardians thought fit) in any part of the female wards; and the mothers were at any rate "to have access to them at all reasonable times."[213] The Central Authority remarked, in a covering letter of 1842--which was not repeated when the rules were re-issued in 1847--"that so long as any mother is suckling her child, she ought to have access to it at all times except when she is at work, and that the child ought not, even then, to be completely beyond the mother's reach."[214]
[213] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 15, in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 90; art. 10 of General Order of 5th February 1842, in
Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 82; repeated in art. 99 of General
Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847.
[214] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 110.
In 1847, still without amendment of the classificatory scheme, the guardians were allowed to permit a mother and her infant children to occupy the same bed.[215]
[215] Art. 111 of General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847.
With regard to vagrants, the first departure from the policy of merely including them as able-bodied paupers came in 1842, in a rule requiring "casual poor wayfarers and vagrants" to be kept "in the Vagrant Ward," or other separate ward--presumably separate for each sex, though this was not explicitly required.[216]
[216] Art. 10 of General Order of 5th February 1842, and
Instructional Letter of the same date, in Eighth Annual Report,
1842, pp. 81, 110. In 1847 "casual poor wayfarers" were to be kept
in "a separate ward" (General Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847,
art. 99).
With regard to segregation by character, the first relaxation from the classificatory scheme is to be found in a letter of 1839, in which the Central Authority permits married women of good character to be placed with the aged women, in order that they may avoid the contamination of bad characters, but only provided that their daily employment is not interfered with.[217] We can find no contemporary document even allowing the guardians to protect from a like contamination unmarried women or young girls of good character.
[217] Letter, 1st April 1839, in Special Report on the Further
Amendment of the Poor Law, 1839, p. 293.
In 1840, however, the Official Circular referred to "the separation of certain abandoned persons from the other inmates," explaining that it rested "not on the consideration of their past conduct, but on that of their present habits and character."[218]
[218] Official Circular, 24th December 1840, No. 10, p. 143.
In 1842 the central authority incidentally observed in an instructional letter that the guardians were permitted to subdivide any of the seven classes of the scheme imposed on them, and that it was "very desirable that females of dissolute and disorderly habits should be separated from those of a better character."[219]
[219] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 108.
Not until 1847 do we find a rule providing that, "as far as circumstances will permit," the guardians were to "further subdivide any of the classes enumerated" in the classificatory scheme, "with reference to the moral character or behaviour or the previous habits of the inmates, or to such other grounds as may seem expedient."[220]
[220] General Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847, art. 99.
Meanwhile, however, the Central Authority was breaking down by inconsistent provisions the classificatory scheme which it left still figuring in the forefront of its Consolidated Orders. We may cite first the provision as to aged married couples. The Central Authority had for seven years eloquently justified its insistence on the strict separation of all married couples, however aged. In 1842, however, it made a rule "that, if for any special reason it shall at any time appear to the board of guardians to be desirable to depart from the regulations contained in Art.
9, in respect of any married couple," who were infirm through age or any other cause, "the guardians shall be at liberty to resolve that such couple shall have a sleeping apartment separate from those of the other paupers," subject to obtaining in each case the consent and approval of the Central Authority.[221]
[221] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 10; in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 80. It is, we think, not incorrect to
infer from the restricted terms of this rule, that the Central
Authority was clinging to its former policy in the face of public
pressure. Such an inference is supported by the terms in which the
covering letter of 5th February 1842 refers to the new proviso,
and by the broad hint therein conveyed that "the guardians can
allow outdoor relief to any aged couple whom it may be inexpedient
to separate" (Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 109).
In 1846, on the vehement objection and practical rebellion of the Norwich Court of Guardians, it went much further and agreed to sanction "an arrangement by which a separate room shall be assigned to each married couple of whatever class,"[222] that the guardians thought fit.
In 1847, however, Parliament swept the original policy away so far as legislation could do so, by enacting, unconditionally, that no married couple over sixty should be compelled in the workhouse to live separately and apart from each other.[223]
[222] Letter to Norwich Court of Guardians, 3rd February 1846.
[223] 10 & 11 Vic. c. 109, sec. 23.
A second inroad into the classificatory scheme was made by the provision that children under seven might be placed in any female ward, whether that of the sick women, that of the aged and infirm women, or even that of the able-bodied women.[224]
[224] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 15, in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 90; repeated in General Order of 5th February 1842, art.
10, proviso 5, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 81; and in
General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847, art. 99, proviso 7.
Yet another, and possibly a more important inroad into the scheme was made by a rule of 1842, which permitted the guardians in particular cases to classify boys and girls over ten in any way they thought fit.[225]
[225] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 10, and
Instructional Letter of the same date, in Eighth Annual Report,
1842, pp. 81, 109; repeated in 1847, in more guarded form,
maintaining at any rate segregation by sex (General Consolidated
Order of 24th July 1847, art. 99).
(iii.) Service
But it was in its rules as to the services to be rendered by the workhouse inmates that the Central Authority most effectually undermined its own classificatory scheme, and practically destroyed any real segregation.
That scheme, as we have shown, expressly forbade the paupers in any class to leave the particular "ward or separate building and yard" assigned to such class, or to hold any communication with any other class.[226] Nevertheless the Central Authority had, from the first, a policy of workhouse organisation inconsistent with any such segregation. Practically all the workhouse service was to be performed by the paupers themselves, and every pauper who was capable of work was to be incessantly occupied in that service.
The able-bodied women who formed Class V. might be supervised by the aged and infirm women of Class IV. The children under seven who formed Class VII. might be supervised either by the able-bodied women of Class V., or by the aged and infirm women of Class IV., or by the girls of Class VI. The boys over seven who formed Class III. might be supervised by the aged and infirm men of Class I. The girls over seven who formed Class VI. might be supervised by the aged and infirm women of Class IV.
These girls, so far from being confined to the premises assigned to their class, were to be employed in the able-bodied women's wards, in the aged and infirm women's wards, in the wards for the children under seven, and in household work generally, provided only that they were somehow kept from communicating with able-bodied men or boys. The sick, whether male or female, whether of good character or of bad, had necessarily to be waited on, and no paid nurses were required to be appointed.
Consequently the provision allowing all the sick wards to be attended by the able-bodied women, by the girls between seven and sixteen, by the aged women, or by any combination of these that the master might direct, in itself necessarily destroyed all real segregation.
By 1847 this permission had been so far restricted as to confine the attendance on the sick males to the aged and infirm men and the aged and infirm women; though such girls over seven, such able-bodied women, and such aged or infirm women as the master might deem fit might still be employed indiscriminately in the service of any of the wards except those for men and boys, and generally for household work throughout the workhouse.[227]
[226] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 9, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 80; General Consolidated Order, 24th July 1847,
art. 98.
[227] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v., arts. 9, 13-14, in Second Annual
Report, 1836, pp. 89-90; General Order of 5th February 1842, art.
10, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 81; General Consolidated
Order of 24th July 1847, art. 99.
(iv.) Diet
It is significant of the unity of régime insisted upon in the one general workhouse that the Central Authority laid constant stress on the uniformity to be observed in the dietaries of all the classes of paupers in the workhouse, except only by order or on the advice of the medical officer, which might be either for the sick, for those requiring a change of diet, for the nursing mothers, or for the infants.
Even to those paupers who were employed as servants only the common fare was "in general" to be given.[228] The first dietaries issued to the boards of guardians for them to choose from were drawn up avowedly for the able-bodied, with no other variation for other classes than were contained in a few footnotes referring (apart from the sick and children under nine) to extras which the guardians might, if they thought fit, allow to persons over sixty.
Thus, practically the only difference in the food to be allowed to the able-bodied males, the able-bodied females, and the children over nine, was one of quantity.
Even the aged and infirm had the same diet, with nothing else prescribed for them, and with no greater indulgence allowed, even if the guardians wished it, than an ounce of tea per week, with milk and sugar, and the possible addition, in one out of the six dietaries among which the boards of guardians might choose, of meat pudding once a week instead of bread and cheese; and, in four of these dietaries, also of butter for breakfast.[229] There was, of course, to be no alcoholic drink for any class of pauper except by written medical order.[230] No presents of food to individual paupers or classes of paupers were to be allowed, as they would produce inequality and discontent.[231] Even the sick, who were originally to be dieted case by case at the discretion of the medical officer, were, in 1842, to be fed with absolute uniformity as among the different classes of paupers and among the different individuals in a class, it being urged on the guardians that the medical officer should be restricted for his patients to a choice among four fixed dietaries which he was to draw up once for all, and hang up in the sick wards for permanent reference.
These were described as "high, middle, low, and fever"; and he was expressly to be instructed "that the quantity of articles to be allowed for each should be minutely specified."[232]
[228] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 109.
[229] Circular on Workhouse Dietaries, 1836; in Second Annual
Report, 1836, pp. 64-66.
[230] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 23; in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 91.
[231] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 113.
[232] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 113. This instruction was made mandatory on the
medical officer in 1847, but he was permitted to frame in advance,
not four only, but as many different dietaries as he chose. The
instructions of 1842 were not, however, superseded (General
Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847, art. 207, sec. 9; see also
under art. 108).
Finally, as it had been found that the old men and women who were allowed weekly ounces of tea and weekly allowances of butter would not take their teas simultaneously or consume their little pats of butter evenly, this distressing deviation from the dietetic uniformity led the Central Authority to suggest the withdrawal of the privilege, in favour of a simultaneous service of "a certain quantity of liquid tea" and of portions of bread and butter.[233]
[233] Official Circular, 30th July 1842, No. 20, p. 301.
With regard to the quantities of food to be supplied, the policy of the Central Authority passed through three phases.
In 1836 the boards of guardians were expressly directed that the diet in the workhouse (which, as we have shown, was to be practically uniform for all classes of paupers) was not to be "equal"--that is to say, was actually to be inferior--"to the ordinary mode of subsistence of the labouring classes of the neighbourhood."[234] This was perhaps more tactfully expressed in the Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town Unions, in saying that the diet was "in no case to exceed in quantity and quality of food the ordinary diet of any class of able-bodied labourers living within the same district."[235] All the contemporary warnings of the Central Authority were against giving too much; and there was no provision for ensuring that each pauper got even the quantity prescribed in the dietary chosen by the local authority.
No extra dinner was allowed on Christmas or other feast days, unless, indeed, this was supplied by private individuals.[236] In 1842 a change was made.
The Central Authority fixed a separate dietary for each workhouse, and there was no longer any reference to these dietaries being inferior to the subsistence of the independent labourer; on the contrary the intention of the Central Authority was avowedly "to assimilate them as much as possible to the ordinary food of the working classes in the neighbourhood"[237]--in Kent and Sussex mainly bread and cheese, in the northern counties meat, potatoes, and porridge, and in Cornwall including fish.
Moreover, it was provided that any pauper might, on demand, have his prescribed portion weighed out to him.[238] Finally, by 1847, we gather that the principle had been silently adopted of fixing such a dietary as was calculated to keep the paupers in physical health, irrespective of the amount or kind of food that might ordinarily be obtained by the lowest class of non-pauper labourer in particular districts or at particular periods.
Even extra food on Christmas Day was allowed at the expense of the Poor Rate, at the unfettered discretion of the boards of guardians.[239]
[234] Circular on Workhouse Dietaries, 1836, in Second Annual
Report, 1836, p. 63.
[235] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 21; in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 91.
[236] Official Circular, 2nd July 1840, No. 6, pp. 73-74.
[237] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 112.
[238] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 18, and
Instructional Letter of the same date, in Eighth Annual Report,
1842, pp. 83, 113; repeated in General Consolidated Order of 24th
July 1847, art. 109.
[239] General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847, art. 107.
It should, however, be added that, although the policy of the Central Authority passed, as stated, through these three phases, the actual dietaries prescribed by it, even in the first phase, seem (in the light of modern physiology) to have been ample for health, if the paupers always got what was prescribed and knew how to eat it.
(v.) Cleanliness and Sanitation
It was part of the policy that the utmost cleanliness and good order should be maintained throughout the workhouse; and (to the limited extent of the hygienic knowledge of the time) that sanitary conditions should be insisted on.
It was expressly made the duty of the master and matron to enforce "industry, order, punctuality, and cleanliness" on all the inmates; every day to "see that each individual is clean and in a proper state"; daily to inspect and see that all the sleeping wards are "duly cleaned and properly ventilated," and "to take care that the wards, kitchen, larder, and other rooms and offices be kept clean and in good order." All paupers were compulsorily to be cleansed on admission.
All the workhouse inmates were to be supplied with clean linen and stockings every week, whilst their beds were to have clean sheets monthly.[240] This latter requirement was superseded in 1842 by the more general provision that the beds and bedding were to be kept in a clean and wholesome state.[241] Food was to be given out as required for each meal, not once for the day. It was to be eaten only in the dining-room, and not (except as ordered for the sick) elsewhere in the house.
All remnants were to be removed from the dining-room by the officers after each meal.[242] It was compulsory on each board of guardians to appoint a qualified medical officer, as part of the very first business.
It was expressly made part of his duty to attend regularly at the workhouse, and come whenever sent for; to examine all the sick and give all necessary directions for their care; to give all necessary directions for the meals of the aged and infirm, and the children; and (from 1842 onwards) "to report in writing to the board of guardians any defect in the diet, drainage, ventilation, warmth, or other arrangement of the workhouse, or any excess in the number of any class of inmates which he may deem to be detrimental to the health of the inmates."[243]
[240] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. iv. arts. 4, 5; in Second Annual
Report, 1836, pp. 85-86.
[241] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 75; in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 95.
[242] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in ibid. p.
112.
[243] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 78; in ibid. p.
97.
(vi.) Discipline
The same desire for uniformity of treatment for all workhouse inmates is seen in the Orders of the Central Authority with regard to the hours to be observed. A fixed time-table was imposed, to be rigidly observed by all classes of paupers, in all workhouses, at all seasons of the year.
The whole of the day from getting out of bed to retiring to rest was definitely allotted. All classes of paupers were to observe precisely the same hours, except (1) the sick, who were never recognised in the classificatory scheme; (2) the aged and infirm; and (3) the children under seven, all of whom had to rise, go to bed, take their meals, and work at whatever hours the master might appoint, subject to any directions of the board of guardians.
Thus, it was peremptorily ordered by the Central Authority that the able-bodied men, the able-bodied women, and the boys and girls over seven should, whatever their several strengths and conditions, all rise at five in summer and seven in winter; that they should all work for uniformly ten hours in summer and nine hours in winter; that they should all eat three simultaneous meals; that they should all have during the day exactly one hour of unallotted time and no more, and this between 7 and 8 p.m., winter and summer alike; and that all, whatever their ages or physical strength, should go to bed uniformly at 8 p.m. all the year round.
This remained unchanged in 1847, except that the hours of rising had been altered in 1842 to 5.45 in summer and 6.45 in winter, with corresponding breakfast times.[244] Besides the remarkable uniformity of this scheme of daily life, which was absolutely enforced on paupers of all ages from seven to sixty (or such other age-limit as might be adopted for "the aged"), one is struck by its omissions.
There was no provision for going out in the open air, and no time during which it was possible; unless the Central Authority meant that the several classes of paupers might be allowed in the various yards between 7 and 8 p.m., in summer and winter alike.
No pauper was to be allowed to go outside the workhouse walls except for "urgent or special reason," and it was expressly laid down that they were not to be permitted, whether their conduct was good or bad, to go out "at stated intervals."[245] A slight relaxation in this latter respect was permitted (though not prescribed) in 1842, in the case of children under fifteen, when the master was allowed, if he chose, to send any of them out for exercise under the charge of the schoolmaster or other officer.[246] There was equally no provision (at any rate for any but "boys and girls") for any exercise of the mental faculties, either in the form of recreation or in the form of education or training.
From 1836 to 1842 it was even ordered that the meals were to be taken in silence, even by the children.[247]
[244] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 17, in Second Annual Report,
1836, pp. 90, 99; General Order of 5th February 1842, arts. 13-16,
in Eighth Annual Report, 1842, pp. 82-83, 99; General Consolidated
Order of 24th July 1847, arts. 102-106, and Form (N).
[245] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, pp. 115-116.
[246] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 24, and
Instructional Letter of the same date, in Eighth Annual Report,
1842, pp. 84, 116. This was repeated in the General Consolidated
Order of 24th July 1847, art. 117.
[247] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 17; in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 90.
No provision was made for the supply of any books for the use of the inmates, whether sick or well--not even Bibles and prayer-books; and it was thus made unlawful for the boards of guardians to have provided these, even if they had wished to do so--unless, indeed, it would have been held by the Auditor that they were "reasonably necessary." The point seems never to have been raised. The education provided for the children was of the scantiest.
It was confined to "boys and girls," without definition of age, and it was thus left to the boards of guardians to begin it as late and to terminate it as early as they chose.
It was to consist of instruction for three hours a day "at least," in "reading, writing, and the principles of the Christian religion," together with "such other instructions" as were "calculated to train them to habits of usefulness, industry, and virtue."[248] Apparently arithmetic was thought not to come under this definition, as it was added in 1842.[249] Shoe making was approved in 1845 in the case of Poplar.[250] A schoolmaster or schoolmistress needed only to be appointed "if the guardians shall think fit"; and the Central Authority thus left it open to guardians to impose the task of instruction on the porter or matron--this being actually mentioned in the Instructional Letters[251]--or on an aged pauper--a course which was frequently adopted without rebuke.
If a schoolmaster or schoolmistress was appointed no qualification was required.[252] No provision was made for playrooms, playthings, or even playing time for children of any age.
[248] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 16, in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 90.
[249] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 22, in Eighth
Annual Report, 1842, p. 83.
[250] MS. Minutes, Poplar Board of Guardians, 15th January 1845.
[251] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 124.
[252] This remained so even in the General Consolidated Order of
24th July 1847, art. 167.
With regard to the adults, well or sick, it was apparently part of the policy to ignore, and even to prohibit, recreation. Playing at cards and all other games of chance were absolutely forbidden to all classes of inmates at all hours and seasons. Smoking was peremptorily prohibited in any room in the workhouse, except by the special direction of the medical officer, and the boards of guardians were told that they might prohibit it in the yards if they chose. No visitors were allowed (otherwise than to the sick) except at the will, and actually in the presence, of the master or matron.
It even required a special exception, not made until 1842, to enable parents to see their children who were in the same workhouse "at some one time in each day."[253]
[253] General Order of 5th February 1842, art. 10, proviso 6, in
Eighth Annual Report, 1842, p. 81.
(vii.) Employment
We may infer from the scheme of daily life just described, which the Central Authority imposed on all classes of workhouse inmates, that it laid great stress, as a matter of policy, on the ten hours of work which it exacted from all who were neither physically disabled nor below the age of seven. The bulk of the inmates, especially the aged and infirm, the women and children, and, we may add, the defectives, were evidently to be employed on the ordinary household service and attendance of the workhouse and its inmates.
It was expressly ordered that all the paupers so employed were to be under "the strictest superintendence," not to be given "offices of trust"; and confined to "offices of mere labour which can be performed under trustworthy superintendence."[254] But this household service did not suffice to find occupation for the able-bodied, especially the men.
The Report of 1834, it will be remembered, had been emphatic in recommending that all pauper employment should be in accordance with the spirit of the Act of Elizabeth, useful to "the employer as well as to the employed," and that everything which gave to labour a repulsive aspect was to be avoided as mischievous. The Central Authority did not adopt this policy, even at the beginning of its work, and by 1847 had adopted a contrary one.
From the outset the policy laid down was that the pauper was not to work on his own account, was not to be remunerated for his labour, and was not to obtain any personal advantage from working harder or more skilfully than the prescribed minimum. But the policy of the Central Authority, at first, was that the work should be useful, and for the benefit of the union.
Thus, in 1836 it was ordered that the clothing of all the paupers should, "as far as possible, be made by the paupers in the workhouse."[255] This project promptly disappears from the documents, presumably on the discovery that tailoring and bootmaking were skilled occupations, beyond the capacity of ordinary workhouse inmates.
[254] Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842; in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 109.
[255] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, in Second Annual Report, 1836, p. 91.
In 1842 the central authority declares itself unable to suggest for the able-bodied men in the workhouse "any kind of labour which is likely to be productive of profit"; and remarks that "stone-breaking under proper superintendence is generally found to answer." other occupations which are named to the guardians as being frequently adopted are grinding corn in hand mills, pounding or grinding bones for manure, and oakum-picking.[256] the horrors revealed in the inquiry into the andover workhouse scandal led to a summary prohibition of the employment of paupers in pounding, grinding, or otherwise breaking bones, or preparing bone dust.[257] this left practically only stone-breaking, hand-grinding, and oakum-picking at the disposal of the boards of guardians--occupations, as it seems to us, combining in the highest degree the characteristics of monotony, absence of initiative, toilsomeness, and inutility--giving, in fact, to labour, in flat contradiction of the recommendation of the report of 1834, an aspect as repulsive as could be devised.[258]
[256] Letter of 18th February 1842; in Official Circular, 13th
February 1843, No. 23, p. 43. See also the interesting letter of
5th March 1842, giving the reasons for grinding by stones rather
than by a steel mill (ibid. 30th July 1842, No. 20, p. 298).
[257] General Order of 8th November 1845, and Circular Letter of
the same date, in Twelfth Annual Report, 1846, pp. 72-77.
[258] The last instruction of the Central Authority during this
period with regard to employment is the Circular of 1st April
1846, stating that the task to be exacted in oakum-picking should
be 4 lb. per day for males and 2 to 3 lb. per day for females
(Official Circular, 1st April 1886, No. 58, p. 57).
(viii.) Sanctions
As the policy of the Central Authority was to exclude from the life of the workhouse inmates everything of the nature of reward, encouragement, stimulus, responsibility, or initiative, the question arises by what means the monotonous discipline was to be maintained. The documents indicate that the Central Authority relied on the two forces of punishment and religion.
The discipline of the workhouse was to rest primarily on the fact that the master, either with or without the prior sanction of the board of guardians, had summary powers of instant, though carefully limited, punishment of any pauper inmate. Any disobedience of the regulations or of any order of the master might be punished, sometimes at his sole discretion, sometimes by order of the board of guardians, by confinement not exceeding twenty-four hours in a separate room or cell, and by reduction to a diet of bread and water only for not more than two days.
Between 1840 and 1847 the disorderly or refractory pauper might also, by order of the guardians, be made to wear a special dress for not more than forty-eight hours.[259] But elaborate precautions were taken against abuse. The greatest care was to be taken that no injury to health was caused by any punishment.[260] Corporal punishment was strictly confined to boys under fourteen.
And, as some protection to the paupers against tyranny or oppression, the rules as to discipline and punishment were to be put up in the dining-halls, school-rooms, and board-room;[261] it was expressly provided that any pauper who had been punished or who was reported as refractory was (whether this was requested or not) to be brought before the board of guardians at its next meeting, and given an opportunity of complaining; and the visiting committee was to ascertain the truth of every complaint made to them.
Under no circumstances was the master to lay hands on a pauper. If force was absolutely needed, he should call in the porter or other officer.[262] For graver offences the pauper had to be proceeded against before the magistrates under the Vagrant Acts and the ordinary criminal law.
[259] Form of Order, 1840, art. 5; in Seventh Annual Report, 1841,
p. 115. This was repeated in the General Order of 5th February
1842, art. 38, and Instructional Letter of the same date, in
Eighth Annual Report, 1842, pp. 86, 121. But it was omitted from
the General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847.
And when a board
of guardians had made all the unchaste women wear a yellow gown,
this was in 1839 disallowed by the Central Authority, on the mixed
grounds that the Poor Law Amendment Act had removed all penal
consequences from incontinence, and that classification should be
by present habits and character, not by past conduct (Minute of
5th March 1839, in Sixth Annual Report, 1840, pp. 98-100; see
also Instructional Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual
Report, 1842, p. 121).
We are told that the slang term for
workhouse wards for immoral women was "Canary Wards," so that the
distinctive dress must have been widely known.
[260] Circular Letter of January 1841, in Seventh Annual Report,
1841, p. 121.
[261] Form of Order, 1840, art. 23; in Seventh Annual Report,
1841, p. 118.
[262] Circular Letter of January 1841, in Seventh Annual Report,
1841, p. 121.
Passing from punishment to religion, we may note that the main preoccupation of the Central Authority was, in accordance with the 1834 Act, to protect the pauper from proselytism or from being compelled to attend services contrary to his religious feelings. The basis of this protection was the compulsory creed register. No pauper was to be obliged to attend--or so placed that he could not avoid being present at--any religious service contrary to his principles. Children were not to be educated in any creed other than that of their parents.
On the other hand, it was expressly laid down that a chaplain should be appointed and prayers and services should be officially provided, although these were only to be those of the Established Church.[263] But provision was made for what promptly became the holding of Nonconformist services in the workhouse, by the permission that any pauper might be visited at any time of the day by a licensed minister of his own persuasion, for religious assistance or the instruction of children.[264] Those who were registered as members of the Established Church, whether adults or children, were not to be permitted, even with their own consent, to receive religious assistance or instruction from ministers of other denominations.[265] This, however, was altered in 1842, when the Central Authority, whilst still thinking it "objectionable," announced that it would not interfere to prevent the attendance of such persons as desired it at any Nonconformist service performed in the workhouse.[266] In one union (Royston), where the board of guardians refused to appoint a chaplain, and sought to induce the inmates to receive the voluntary ministrations of Nonconformists, the Central Authority was driven peremptorily to forbid, by three successive special orders, any pauper inmate, whether child or adult, belonging to the Established Church being even allowed to attend Nonconformist services in the workhouse.[267] Finally, the Central Authority reverted, for all unions, to its policy of 1839, restricting the ministrations of Nonconformist ministers to members of their own denomination only, except in so far as the guardians might choose to allow inmates belonging to any sect of Protestant Dissenters to receive, if they chose, the ministrations of any Protestant Dissenter.[268]
[263] Letter of 4th February 1836, in Second Annual Report, 1836,
pp. 66-67.
[264] Consolidated Order for the Administration of Relief in Town
Unions, 7th March 1836, sec. v. art. 17, in Second Annual Report,
1836, p. 91.
[265] Letter of 6th November 1839; in Seventh Annual Report, 1841,
pp. 230-2.
[266] Letter of 5th February 1842, in Eighth Annual Report, 1842,
p. 117.
[267] Special Orders, 1st February 1842, 20th April 1842, and 18th
January 1845; in Eleventh Annual Report, 1845, pp. 30-1, 132-3.
[268] General Consolidated Order of 24th July 1847, art. 122.
For all who did not conscientiously object, there were to be public prayers daily before breakfast and after supper; and Divine service within the workhouse every Sunday, at which attendance was compulsory on all members of the Church of England, not being children or sick. It was obligatory to appoint a chaplain, whose duty
Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence
The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.
Transcriber and production notes
Transcriber's Notes: The underscore markup indicates italics. The = markup indicates bold font. The oe ligature has been expanded. In order to make the index more clear, it has been displayed in a single column, rather than the double column of the original. Some formatting markup (such as italics markup) has been removed from the large table in order to improve readability. Other than obvious printing errors which have been corrected, the spelling and punctuation are as in the original publication. Some of the formatting markup in the large table have been removed in order to improve readability. Corrections in punctuation were made on pages 2, 12, and 192.
Front matter as received (title page, contents)
ENGLISH POOR LAW POLICY.
BY
SIDNEY AND BEATRICE WEBB
LONGMANS, GREEN AND CO.,
39 PATERNOSTER ROW, LONDON,
NEW YORK, BOMBAY AND CALCUTTA.
1910. (_Second Impression, 1913_)Header as received
The Project Gutenberg eBook of English Poor Law Policy
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: English Poor Law Policy
Author: Sidney Webb
Beatrice Webb
Release date: August 15, 2013 [eBook #43472]
Most recently updated: October 23, 2024
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/43472
Credits: Produced by Juliet Sutherland, Sue Fleming and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.netFull Project Gutenberg licence
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
States without permission and without paying copyright
royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
license, especially commercial redistribution.
START: FULL LICENSE
THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
www.gutenberg.org/license.
Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
electronic works
1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
you share it without charge with others.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
country other than the United States.
1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
beginning of this work.
1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
Gutenberg License.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
provided that:
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation.”
• You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
works.
• You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
receipt of the work.
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
forth in Section 3 below.
1.F.
1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
cannot be read by your equipment.
1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
DAMAGE.
1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
without further opportunities to fix the problem.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
remaining provisions.
1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
Defect you cause.
Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
from people in all walks of life.
Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation
Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
public support and donations to carry out its mission of
increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
status with the IRS.
The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
approach us with offers to donate.
International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
volunteer support.
Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
edition.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.
This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #43472. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.