Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Round Towers of Ireland; or, The History of the Tuath-De-Danaans
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 42538

The Round Towers of Ireland; or, The History of the Tuath-De-Danaans

by Henry O'Brien · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2013
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    CHAPTER III

    (PP. 33-47)

    Continuing his attack upon Montmorency, the author points out that the towers erected elsewhere by Cœnobite associations are always square, not round, and that any argument based upon the elevated position of the entrances to both classes of edifices would apply equally to the pyramids.

    He shows that the round towers could not have been intended as places of refuge, or as depositories of ecclesiastical treasures, and adduces historical proof that the structures known as “belfries” were wholly different.

    Alluding to the supposed band of voluntary Cœnobite workmen under Saint Abban, he points out that their building operations must necessarily have been carried on in the midst of a raging war; that although they must have availed themselves of native assistance in the work, yet the Irish of the early Christian period betray not the slightest knowledge of the art of building; that the building of round towers ceased quite suddenly, almost immediately after the introduction of Christianity; that the native Irish have never attributed these towers to such an origin; that, so far from being, as Montmorency alleges, assisted by the munificence of native princes, the Cœnobite monks must have had to deal with absolute pagans, who would regard their labour with anything but approval; and that the fact of “kills,” or remains of Christian churches, being found in the vicinity of Cromleachs, Mithratic caves, and round towers is simply the result of the reverence felt by the pagan converts for the scenes and associations of their old belief, and affords no ground for supposing that the churches were coeval with the latter.

    Subsequently (at p. 514) he cites the instance of a round tower without any church near it.

    CHAPTER IV

    (PP. 48-62)

    In tracing the origin and purpose of the round towers, our author is led to consider the names given them in ancient records and Irish folk-lore.

    The stunted ruin of Bally-Carbery Round Tower, near his own birthplace, was, he found, known to the peasantry as the “Cathoir ghall,” i.e. “the temple of brightness or delight,” whilst both in the Annals of the Four Masters, the Ulster Annals, and the Annals of Innisfallen these towers are included in the generic name Fiadh-Neimhedh, as contrasted with the names Cloic teacha and Erdam applied to “belfries,” thus showing that the two kinds of structures are perfectly distinct.

    He finds that Fiadh-Nemeadth in all preceding writers on the subject is held to apply specifically to the round towers, though some of these writers (e.g. Colgan and O’Connor) have wrested its meaning to support their own particular views, and the true import of this term he subsequently explains to be “consecrated Lingams” (p. 105), or phallic temples. The “belfry” and the gnomon, or “celestial index,” theories are thus exploded.

    From historical evidence he is further led to assume that Ireland is identical with the Insula Hyperboreorum of the ancients, and that the legendary mission of the Boreadan Abaris[27] to Delos took place during the Scythian occupation of Ireland.

    This friendly communication between the ancient Irish and the Greeks he attributes to their having sprung from a common stock--the Pelasgi and the Tuath-de-danaans belonging to “the same time as the Indo-Scythæ, or Chaldean Magi.” He traces briefly the relations between the Tuath-de-danaan settlers in Ireland and their Scythian (or Milesian) conquerors, and shows that to the former is due the high state of civilisation and learning for which ancient Ireland was distinguished, and which degenerated under Scythian rule; and concludes with a general statement as to the prevalence of Sabaic worship therein, and the phallic configuration of the round towers.

    CHAPTER V

    (PP. 63-76)

    Being now fairly launched on the subject of Sabaism, or worship of natural manifestations of the divine energy, he traces its origin, development, and decadence into idolatry. Amid the heterogeneous confusion of beliefs that seem to have sprung up among the descendants of Noah, Nimrod introduced the worship of the sun as a deity, but only as a part of that general Sabaism which included the whole “host of heaven” as objects of worship, and recognised the Godhead, of which they were simply manifestations, under the names of Baal and Moloch.

    Gradually, the creature was substituted for the Creator, and their names, especially the former (Bolati), were applied to the sun, “as the source and dispenser of all earthly favours,” while to the moon was attributed a corresponding reverence under the name Baaltis, though in both cases the object of internal regard was intended to be Nature, or “the fructifying germ of universal generativeness.” From the tendency of man to the concrete, this central idea was soon lost sight of, and the material element put in its place--hence came Fire-worship.

    Originating in Chaldea, this degenerated form of Sabaism in course of time spread eastward until it reached Persia, where eventually there seems to have been a reversion to the principle which underlay it, i.e. that of generation and nutrition, in which form it afterwards extended to India.

    Though fire was the ostensible object of worship, the sun and moon, from which that worship originated, were regarded and reverenced as “the procreative causes of general fecundity,” with which was coupled the notion of regeneration after dissolution of the body. Hence when, as will appear hereafter, Eastern Sabaism was introduced into Ireland by the Tuath-de-danaans, the round towers created by them as temples of their worship had both a phallic and sepulchral meaning.

    CHAPTER VI

    (PP. 77-90)

    That purer form of Sabaism in which the central idea of “the All-good and All-great One” predominated over materialism, seems to have prevailed in ancient Egypt, and to a more definite extent in India, whilst in both these countries, and also in Ireland, its material side led to the cultivation of astronomy. Hence the pyramids of Egypt, the pagodas of India, and the round towers of Ireland had both a religious and a scientific purpose.

    There is no ground, however, for supposing that the round towers were “fire-temples.” Though temples of the latter kind undoubtedly exist in Ireland, their structure is altogether different, and they evidently belong to a later period, showing, in fact, traces of an Italian origin. Fire-worship was probably introduced into Italy from Greece, where it had been practised by the old Pelasgic stock, who, on their expulsion from Thessaly, settled in Etruria, bringing their worship with them.

    CHAPTER VIII

    (PP. 91-106)

    From a careful study of Eastern records and Sabaism, the author is led to take up the position that the round towers were constructed by early Indian colonists of Ireland (the Tuath-de-danaans), in honour of “the fructifying principle of nature,” of which the sun and moon are representative. The emblem of this principle was the phallus in the case of the sun, and the crescent in that of the moon.

    The round tower was simply a monumental phallus, which fact is taken to explain the terms “Cathoir ghall” and “Fidh-Nemphed” to which he alludes in chap. iv.; whilst the crescent ornament by which many of these towers were surmounted is symbolical of the female nature.

    A corroboration of this theory is found in the circumstance that the name Budh, by which these towers are “critically and accurately designated, signifies in Irish, first, the sun, and secondly, what φαλλός, phallus, does in Greek and Latin,” a view which is supported by the analogy of Egyptian sun and moon worship.

    CHAPTER IX

    (PP. 107-126)

    Having thus committed himself to the view that the paganism which founded the Irish Round Towers was a religion of which Budh (i.e. the sun and the phallus) was the central idea, and which, therefore, resembled in its essence the faiths of India and Egypt, the author proceeds to trace the origin of this religion.

    In India the latter is known as Buddhism, or that form of Sabaism taught by Buddha; but the author is persuaded that there never was such a person as Buddha--at least, when the religion first shot into life, which was almost as early as the creation of man--though in later times several enthusiasts assumed that name.

    The origin of the religion was, in fact, “an abstract thought,” which cannot easily be expressed in words until it is reduced to the materialised forms of that practical Sabaism which each nation framed for itself, and which consisted in the worship of generative and productive power under its various manifestations. Hence the objects of worship ranged from the sun and moon even to agricultural operations, and, of course, included sexual physiology.

    Indian Buddhism worshipped the Lingam (or phallus) as the emblem of_Budh_ (i.e. the Sun), but without any sensual alloy in such reverence, which, in fact, necessitated the observance of a strict moral code. Among other requirements of this code was the performance of works of charity, Dana (i.e. the giving of alms), and the religionists were hence called Danaans or Almoners.

    The bearing of all this upon Irish paganism is explained by referring to the intimate connection that in early times existed between Ireland and the East, from whence its Tuath-de-danaan colonists were derived.

    The name Erin, together with its Greek form Ierne, and its Latin transmutation Hibernia, is shown to be identical with Iran, the ancient name of Persia, which, modified into Irin, was applied by the Greek historians to the “Sacred Island” of the West, and recognised by Gildas and Ordericus Vitalis as the established designation of Ireland in their time.

    CHAPTER X

    (PP. 127-141)

    Developing this last argument, our author shows that, while Iran (or “the sacred land”) was a name applied to both Persia and Ireland, the form Irin (Sacred Island) is exclusively applied to Ireland, and that Irc, Eri, Ere, and Erin are but modifications of the latter.

    The Greeks commuted this name of Irin into Ierne, which is merely a translation (ἱερός + νῆσος); and the Latins, by putting an H for the rough breathing of ἱερός, and interpolating a b for sound’s sake, transformed the latter into Hibernia, the meaning “Sacred Island” being preserved.

    But by its own inhabitants it continued to be known as Fuodhla, Fudh-Inis, and Inis-na-Bhfiodhbhadh, names associating the worship which prevailed therein with the profession of the worshippers, for they respectively denote the land or island of Fuodh or Budh and Budhism. The Budh here mentioned was identical with the phallic deity worshipped by the Tuath-de-danaans under the name of Buodh (known also as Moriagan and Fareagh or Phearagh), which name the Scythian invaders afterwards adopted as their war-cry (Boo or A-boo).

    The peculiar tenets of Irish Budhism were embodied in a mass of literature committed to the flames by Saint Patrick; but the history of pagan Ireland still survives in MSS. scattered over Europe, whilst an image of Buodh, or Fareagh, bearing a close resemblance to those of the Eastern Buddha, and to the idols of Matambo “whose priests are sorcerers or magicians” (afterwards shown to be the meaning of Tuath-de-danaans), has been unearthed at Roscommon, and is now in the Museum of Trinity College, Dublin.

    CHAPTER XI

    (PP. 142-156)

    From India our author now diverges to Egypt. The similarity between the regal title “Pharaoh” and Phearagh or Fareagh just mentioned is accounted for by the invasion of Egypt by the Uksi, or Hyksos (Royal Shepherds or Shepherd Kings), who, according to Manetho, came “from the East.” The Indian Vedas, which corroborate his account, term them Pali, or “shepherds”; and the rigorous nature of their sway accounts for the dislike manifested by the Egyptians towards the Israelites, who were a pastoral people.

    That they introduced their form of worship into Egypt, is shown by the description which Herodotus gives of the rites, ceremonies, and usages of the Egyptian priests, resembling those practised by the Brahmins. Historical evidence points to the erection by them of the greater pyramids, also to their introduction of those magical arts for which the Egyptians became notorious.

    This latter fact brings the Uksi into connection with the Tuath-de-danaans (whose name is indicative of proficiency in magic), and serves to strengthen the author’s opinion that both belonged to the same Chaldean stock.

    CHAPTER XII

    (PP. 157-166)

    The pyramids of Egypt may be said to correspond, with one significant difference, to the round towers of Ireland. Both are characterised by the highest architectural skill; both are constructed with an evident reference to astronomical purposes; both afford indications that they were inter alia appropriated to sepulture; and both are distinctively of phallic or, more strictly, Sabaic import. But in this last feature a divergence becomes evident. The symbolism of the principle of “generative production” common to both is in the form of the pyramid more emblematic of the female nature (see pp.

    267-269), whilst the round towers typify the male--a divergence which the author subsequently treats in more detail. To it may be due the circumstance that these excavations or “wells” which exist beneath the pyramids have not hitherto been found under round towers.

    CHAPTER XIII

    (PP. 167-176)

    In connection with the last paragraph, attention is, however, drawn to the fact that round towers have usually been erected in the vicinity of water; and that this may have been owing to a real, though less dominant, veneration of the female principle, is probable from the extensive use of bathing in the worship of Astarte, the representative of that principle whose peculiar emblemism is apparent in the ornamentation of the round towers. Traces of the apparatus for a bell found on the summit of one of the latter edifices affords no proof of its original purpose as a belfry.

    For though bells were used in pagan ceremonials, they were not rung to summon worshippers; and the fact may have been that, after their conversion to Christianity, the Irish applied round towers occasionally to the only purpose for which they could then be used in connection with public worship.

    CHAPTER XIV

    (PP. 177-192)

    Recurring to the affinity of Ireland with ancient Persia (Iran), the history of the latter country is traced from its settlement by the Aryans. According to tradition preserved in the collection of sacred books known as the Zendavesta, the original seat of that people was the Eriene-Veedjo, a district situated in the north-western highlands of Asia, of great fertility, and enjoying a singularly mild climate, having seven months of summer and five of winter.

    Then “the death-dealing Ahriman smote it with the plague of cold, so that it came to have ten months of winter and only two of summer”; and was in consequence deserted by its inhabitants, who gradually overspread the low-lying countries, as far south as the Indus, including Fars, as Persia was then termed.

    They were a vigorous and energetic race these Aryans, who soon became dominant in their new quarters, substituting the name of their own country (Iran, or the sacred land, formed from the ancient Zend Eriene) for that of Fars, and founding a dynasty, or rather succession of dynasties, which superseded the government formerly in existence. The mixture of races led to a certain diversity of language, and thus originated the Zend and Pahlavi or Sanskrit dialects, which bear a remarkable affinity to Irish (cf. Palaver).

    There was further a diversity of religions, the old religion of Hushang, a predecessor of Zoroaster, being professed by many long after fire-worship became the dominant faith of Persia.

    CHAPTER XV

    (PP. 193-210)

    This ancient religion of Hushang, which was doubtless that of the Aryans, seems to have been of that Sabaic order practised by the Chaldeans, which, as we have seen, recognised the heavenly bodies as the most imposing representatives of a divine power, and cannot therefore be fairly described as idolatry. It was idealistic, in so far as it regarded the different energies of nature simply as manifestations of a great creative power, whereas the idolatrous stage did not supervene until this purer faith degenerated into materialism.

    With this religion that of the ancient Irish harmonized. The dominance of sun and moon worship in the latter is shown by the way in which the various titles of these luminaries are interwoven with the language; most of the Irish local names, as well as the names of traditional festivals, consisting of variants of different epithets applied to the sun and moon, which the pagan Irish considered to be united in matrimony, just as the Egyptians did Osiris and Isis, their equivalents.

    CHAPTER XVI

    (PP. 211-226)

    A faith thus compounded of love, religion, and astrology has necessarily a triple aspect; and, according to the particular component kept in view, or the etymology professed, may be termed Sabaism, Buddhism, or Phallism. It constitutes the most primitive form of worship, and is the source from whence all the faiths of the world have been derived. Hence the corresponding features in distinct mythologies.

    Brahminism, for example, is an offshoot from Buddhism, owing to the apostasy of Paramon, the son of Budh-dearg; and the essential notions of Christianity, the doctrines of a virginal conception, a vicarious sacrifice, and a resurrection, have their counterparts in both these faiths. The phallic element, ignored by Christianity, maintained its place in Oriental and Irish paganism. The adjuncts of Lingam worship occur in the worship of Budh. The pagodas of India have their counterparts in the round towers.

    The symbolism expressed in the sculptures of Elephanta, Ellora, and Salsette is reflected in the carvings at Clonmacnoise, Kilcullen, and Knockmoy. The Cross is universal, not distinctive; and the purposely mutilated cryptograms of the Crescent and the Serpent belong to a paganism long antecedent to the Christianity which partially effaced them.

    CHAPTER XVII

    (PP. 227-239)

    Researches into the distinctive character of Irish paganism show that its main element was the phallic type of Sabaism, the Irish language affording remarkable evidence of this fact. Many of its words and all its letters embody a twofold meaning, denoting in the first place some passion, quality, or virtue, and in the next its sensible index.

    For example, Budh or Fiodh means primarily a lingam, or phallus, and secondarily a tree; and this peculiarity of an esoteric meaning known only to the learned, and an esoteric one understood by the masses, it shares with Hebrew, which belongs to the same linguistic family. Of this we have an example in the scriptural allegory of “Eve and the tree of knowledge,” wherein the esoteric import of “tree” is phallus. We thus arrive, as it were, at the fount of Buddhism.

    Eve may be regarded as the first Buddhist, and her son Cain, who offered the fruits of the earth to “the God of nature and of increase” (Budh), as the first priest of that order. This allegory is found repeated in different forms among the various populations of the world--in Egypt, India, Persia, and elsewhere.

    It gave rise to many typical commemorations in various countries, such as the “Maypole festivals” of Eastern lands, whence the custom emanated to Ireland (with the Tuath-de-danaan settlers), where it is still practised.

    CHAPTER XVIII

    (PP. 240-251)

    The scriptural allegory of the “Fall of Man,” involving, as it does, the history of Cain, has an intimate bearing upon the ancestry of the Tuath-de-danaans. Cain had a son, Enoch, whose name connotes as usual a twofold meaning, signifying first, Initiation in sacred rites; secondly, an assembly of congregated multitudes.

    The son of Enoch was named Irad, i.e. consecrated to God (Budh); hence the region where he dwelt was called Iran, meaning the land of those so consecrated; from which it is argued that in that precise region the Budhists first established the insignia of their empire.

    Now, the Dabistan records declare that although Kaimours was generally regarded as the first king of Persia (Iran), he had many predecessors; and that long before the time of Zoroaster the Persians venerated a prophet called Mahabad or Maghabad (the Great, or Good, Abad), whom they considered as “the Father of men,” and who had thirteen successors of his own family, all styled Abad. This Abad, or Maghabadean, dynasty eventually became so corrupt that it was banished to the woods and mountains, when Kaimours was called to the throne.

    For various reasons the author is persuaded that the Maghabadeans were the direct descendants of Cain. Their name had the usual twofold signification: first, The unity of the Godhead; secondly, a sacerdotal institution; and Tuath-de-danaan is simply a translation or ampliative rendering of the latter--Tuath being a modification of Budh, and also signifying magic; De, the vernacular term for the Deity; and Danaan signifying Almoners--the whole thus meaning Magician-god-almoners, or the Almoner-magicians of the Deity.

    CHAPTER XIX

    (PP. 252-263)

    Assuming that the Tuath-de-danaans originally occupied Iran, or Persia, their migration to Ireland is thus explained. An internecine variance, arising out of a purely religious question, sprang up among them. They became divided into two sects--one maintaining that the male influence was dominant in the production of offspring; the other that female influence was more effective. Each adopted a distinguishing title, emblematic of the sex whose virtues it proclaimed.

    The former did not find it necessary to change the name Tuath-de-danaan, since the esoteric meaning of Tuath (i.e. Budh) was the emblem of masculinity; but the others adopted the title of Pish-de-danaans, because Pish, or Pith (synonymous with Yoni), denoted that of femininity. The war which resulted from this variance of opinion was waged with all the bitterness which usually marks polemic differences; and the Pish-de-danaans, proving completely victorious, expelled their rivals from the sacred soil of Iran.

    The Tuath-de-danaans, or at least a portion of them (cf. p. 443), fled westward, and after many vicissitudes reached Europe, where traces of them are found in parts of Greece, Italy, and Spain; and from the country last named (by help of the Phœnicians, who were the great sea-carriers of those days), they made their way to Ireland. It is remarkable that a parallel account appears in Hindu records of the severance which took place between the Lingajas and the Yonijas on a precisely similar question.

    CHAPTER XX

    (PP. 264-284)

    Although the Persian historians maintain silence, the evidence of other authorities in support of this episode is not wanting. For instance, when referring to Buddha, Oriental writers agree that he was born in Maghada; also that he was the son of Suad-de-dana--Suad being convertible with Tuath, and both resolvable into Budh. Without professing to map out the exact route by which the Tuath-de-danaans made their way to Ireland, the author maintains that the fact of their having occupied that country for a considerable time is incontrovertible.

    As for their rivals, the Pish-de-danaans, it has already been stated that they, in their turn, had to leave Persia when Kaimours was called to the throne; and the presumption is that they were identical with those Uksi, or Shepherd Kings, who overran Egypt, and to whom the erection of pyramids emblematical of the female nature is ascribed.

    Their distinctive views may, it is pointed out, have prevailed among them from the time when they formed a portion of the Noachidæ; for the “Ark” was typical of the dominant idea in their belief, and the same idea was typified under another form in the pyramids. A variant symbol of this idea is the crescent (or lunar boat), of which certain Irish ornaments are representative.

    It is further possible that the Pish-de-danaan tradition of the deluge may have been communicated to Moses during his stay in Egypt, and that the narrative is more figurative than historical.

    CHAPTER XXI

    (PP. 285-304)

    Among the sculptured symbols of the faith held by the ancient Irish, that of the Cross stands pre-eminent; but it would be a mistake to infer from this circumstance the existence of Christianity in Ireland at the time when these sculptures were wrought. The cryptogram of the Cross is found everywhere, both in the Old and New World, among the relics of nations whose paganism does not admit of doubt, and it dates from a period long antecedent to Christianity.

    Buildings of cruciform structure, and evidently devoted to religious uses, exist all over the East and West; and both they and the Mithratic caves, for which no one has ever claimed any but a pagan origin, partake of the same character.

    To aver that the Cross was emblematical of a vicarious sacrifice by which the redemption of mankind was accomplished, is merely to say that it expresses a belief common to many Sabaic faiths of the pagan world--a belief of which it was the recognised emblem in Egypt, India, Greece, Rome, Scandinavia, and America, as well as in Ireland.

    CHAPTER XXII

    (PP. 305-324)

    The argument as to the pagan origin of Irish cross-symbolism is pursued and developed, and the connection of the symbol in question with the Irish Budh-gaye (corresponding to the Hindu Budha-gaya), or representative of generative power (gaye-phallus), demonstrated. The symbolism of which it forms a type is ubiquitous, being found in archaic sculpture all over the Eastern and Western World: nor did Plato exaggerate when he said--‘The letter X is stamped upon the universe.’

    CHAPTER XXIII

    (PP. 325-340)

    A remarkable instance of this widely prevalent doctrine of the vicarious sacrifice of some incarnation of the Deity accomplished by a purely virginal conception is afforded in the Hindu Puranas, which recount the incarnation of Vishnu (or Crishna) in the White Island, and the subsequent crucifixion of the fruit of this conception, under the name of Sulivahana (cf. the Irish patronymic Sulivan), called also Dhanandhara, i.e. the Sacred Almoner (cf. Danaan and its meaning).

    Curiously enough, the mystic, or esoteric, name of ancient Ireland was Muc Inis, meaning White Island; and the details of a similar crucifixion are, with strictly pagan accompaniments, reproduced in the sculptures at Knockmoy, in Galway, which further closely resemble not only a sculptured portrayal on the temple of Kalabche, in Nubia, but a distinctly Eastern Buddhist group on the Tuath-de-danaan cross at Old Kilcullen, County Kildare.

    CHAPTER XXIV

    (PP. 341-355)

    A striking instance of the resemblance between the Nubian and Knockmoy sculptures consists in the attire of the principal figures. In both the philibeg, or kilt, is worn; and this peculiarity is reproduced in idols of the Irish pagan god, Phearagh, or Farragh, or Budh, which have been from time to time exhumed. The headdresses and collars also correspond. In Buddhist Indian mythology Deva Thot is represented as crucified; in fact, the expectation of salvation through the atonement of a crucified Mediator characterises the whole system of pagan (Sabaic) beliefs as thoroughly as it did Hebraism.

    It is expressed in one of the names of Ireland, namely, Criach-na-Fuineadhach (meaning the asylum of the expectants, or the retreat of those looking forward), which was given to that country long before the advent of Christianity.

    CHAPTER XXV

    (PP. 356-367)

    The round towers and crosses at Clonmacnoise, Clondalkin, and elsewhere, abound in sculptured devices of a similar character, there being in all a manifest reference to Buddhist, or Eastern, ceremonial; whilst the representation of a dog (an animal esteemed sacred by the Tuath-de-danaans) on one of the crosses at Clonmacnoise seems to exclude the possibility of its relation to Christianity. But perhaps the most significant feature of these sculptures is the profusion of snake ornamentation, pointing to a time when that form of Sabaism known as “serpent-worship” was in the ascendant.

    The frequency of this emblemism was so obnoxious to the early Christian missionaries, on account of the evident reverence with which it was regarded by the Irish, that St.

    Patrick thought it advisable to efface it when practicable; and in this sense he may be entitled to the credit of having banished snakes from Ireland.

    CHAPTER XXVI

    (PP. 368-395)

    Reverting to his proper subject of the origin and purpose of the round towers, our author examines the evidence bearing on the date of their erection. The Ulster Annals record the destruction of fifty-seven of these towers by an earthquake in A.D. 448, the natural inference being that they must have existed before the fifth century, but how long before is matter of conjecture.

    Tradition connects them with a personage styled the Goban Saer (Freemason Sage); but this title being the name of a class, not of an individual, and having no settled place in chronology, does not further the solution of the difficulty. A better clue is found in the name of the place whereon was fought the first decisive battle between the Tuath-de-danaan invaders and the Celtic (Firbolg) inhabitants, which gave the supremacy of the island to the former.

    From the number of commemorative towers erected there by the conquerors, this came to be known as Moytura (in Irish, Moye-tureadh, i.e. “the field of the towers”); and as the date of the second battle, fought centuries later, is approximately B.C. 600 (p. 449), there is reason for assigning the erection of round towers to a period long preceding that of Christianity.

    The ascription of these towers to the Tuath-de-danaans is in a degree warranted by the fact that the word “Tuathan-Tower” is a well-known Irish expression, and that there seems to be no other word in the language which conveys the same idea.

    CHAPTER XXVII

    (PP. 396-411)

    The identity of Ireland with the Insula Hyperboreorum is deduced from a description of the latter, copied by Diodorus Siculus from the writings of Hecatæus and from a compendium by Marcianus Herocleotes of the works of Artemidorus.

    Both Hecatæus and Artemidorus lived before the Christian era, and an allusion in the latter author to certain “round temples,” of which the officiating priests were called Boreades, that existed in “Juvernia, a British isle, bounded on the north by the ocean called the Hyperborean, but on the east by the ocean called the Hibernian,” coupled with the fact that (with the exception of those at Brechin and Abernethy) no remains of round temples are found in any of the British Isles save Ireland,[28] goes far to prove the identity in question, also the pre-Christian antiquity of the round towers, together with the existence of an exceptional, and therefore by natural inference an imported, civilisation in that island.

    The latter inference is strengthened by continually-recurring traces of the great proficiency of its inhabitants in the fine, or useful, arts at an era when the adjacent islands were still plunged in barbarism.

    CHAPTER XXVIII

    (PP. 412-431)

    These proofs of an adventitious civilisation bearing the marks, not of gradual growth, but of full development, point to the colonisation of the island by a highly-cultured race, such as were the ancient people of Iran (Persia). The round towers, for instance, could not well have been the work of the Phœnicians, who were a maritime and mercantile race, by no means prone to arts and letters, and in none of whose admitted settlements is any trace of similar buildings to be found.

    Neither the Firbolgs (or Celtic inhabitants of Ireland), nor the Fomorians, nor the Scythians, Scoto-Milesians, nor Danish invaders, were at all given to the refinements of civilisation, and simply regarded the construction of permanent buildings as unworthy of a race of warriors. Everything, in fact, goes to show that the Tuath-de-danaan settlers alone could have erected these towers, introduced the Boreadan ceremonial, and given to the country of their adoption a name taken from that of their native land.

    With the Scythian conquest, it became, of course, inevitable that this name (Irin or Eirin) should be changed into Scuitte or Scotia (the land of the Scythians), and that there should have been a partial exodus of the vanquished Tuath-de-danaans--some of whom, settling in what is now Scotland, gave it the name of Iran or Eran (which survives in Erne or Erse), which was afterwards changed into Scoitte or Scotia, out of compliment to the Scythian rulers of the adjacent island, with whom its Pictish inhabitants had formed alliance.

    CHAPTER XXIX

    (PP. 432-444)

    As for the unfounded theory,--that Ireland was colonised by Phœnicians arriving from Spain, whose last settlement in the island was established by Heber and Heremon, sons of Milesius, and descendants of Feni an fear soid, “the Phœnician wise man,”--it is pointed out that Heber and Heremon (brothers of Amergin, the bard) were in reality the sons of Gallamh, and invaded Ireland at the head of a Scythian, not Phœnician, colony (p. 393).

    Upon historical evidence, the date of this invasion is fixed at B.C. 1002; while it is agreed on all hands that the Tuath-de-danaans had landed about two hundred years before, or B.C. 1202, which latter date exactly corresponds with that given by most Oriental authorities for the exodus of the Buddhists from India.

    About this time, indeed, Ireland seems to have borne the character of an Oriental asylum--a circumstance to which may be attributed the Eastern costumes and aspect of the figures depicted in its ancient sculptures, the Eastern character of traditional religious and ceremonial usages, and the national reverence for the shamrock, corresponding with that shown to the trefoil (or trisula) in Persia (Iran).

    CHAPTER XXX

    (PP. 445-474)

    The duration of Tuath-de-danaan supremacy may have been some six centuries, dating from the first battle of Moytura, in B.C. 1202 (p. 435), to the second battle, in or about B.C. 600, between the Firbolgs, or Celts (who had been gradually reasserting themselves), and a reinforcement of Tuath-de-danaans, coming this time, not from Persia, but from India, whence they had been expelled by the Brahmins (p. 443).

    Although this second invasion proved successful, the power of the Tuath-de-danaans was now on the wane, and the height of civilisation to which they had raised the island rapidly declined before the inroads of the Scythians. Their ritual became merged in that of the Druids, and their taste for letters vitiated.

    Possibly, with a view to arrest this decadence, they began to cultivate intercourse with Greece, the result being a strong reciprocal influence, exercised by the languages of the two countries on each other, and more especially by Irish upon Greek. A corresponding influence resulted from the migration of discontented Tuath-de-danaans into Scotland.

    Nor was it confined to language; for certain peculiarities of ancient Irish architecture are found reproduced in Mycenian and Caledonian structures, as, for example, in the Treasury of Atreus (Mycenæ) and the Dune of Dornadilla (Scotland); and that religion was not wholly unaffected is proved by the discovery of Irish relics showing that the oracular superstitions of Dodona had their counterpart in Ireland.

    CHAPTER XXXI

    (PP. 475-497)

    The relics of Tuath-de-danaan occupation, which exist in the shape of gigantic crosses, and of sculptured ornamentation in which cross-symbolism is prominent, point to a mystery far more esoteric than that involved in the Christian emblem. The cross had become representative of the number ten, because in Irish the same word, lambh, denoted equally a cross and the human hand, or the number of fingers on both hands; whilst the “triangle of ten” (p. 268) embraced “all that was solemn in religion and in thought,” being, in fact, “the index of male and female united,” and the prototype of the ark and pyramid.

    This Sabaic, and only intelligible, explanation of these highly figurative sculptures disposes of the theory that they are the product of a Christianity with which they have nothing in common but a shape which is not peculiar to any one religion in any part of the world.

    CHAPTER XXXIII

    (PP. 498-524)

    Serpent-worship is perhaps the most significant form of Sabaism, involving, as it does, the expression of its source. For in the sacred language of Iran, whereof Irish is the leading type, the word Sabh (the root of Sabaism) has three distinct, yet connected, meanings--(1) Voluptuousness, or the Yoni; (2) a Snake, or sinuosity; (3) Death.

    Through all these runs the central idea of sexual relation, which, as the most elementary part of social life, has been symbolised all over the world in connection with religion. The scriptural reproach, “generation of vipers,” is probably equivalent to offspring of concupiscence, as will appear from the indignant repudiation of those to whom it was addressed--“We were not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.” The part which the serpent plays in Brahminism is well known.

    In Mexico a widespread faith called Nagualism had the Culebra, or snake, for one of its principal deities; whilst the Gadelglas of the ancient Irish (Gadelians) meant simply the green snake-god, from which latter, and not from the verdure of its soil, Ireland may have obtained the designation of the Emerald Isle. In fact, Sabaism, Ophiolatry, and Gadelianism were one and the same; and, while purporting to be the worship of the serpent, or of the stars (vide p.

    505), were in reality the worship of Sabh or Yoni, the representative of female nature. It was, however, masculinity (Budh) that was typified in the phallic form of those round towers, which the author now proceeds to describe with more minuteness of detail than heretofore. Incidentally, he disposes of the argument in favour of the Christian origin of these towers, which is based upon the assumption that remains of Christian churches are invariably found in their vicinity, by adducing an instance to the contrary (at Giant’s Ring, County Down).[29]

    W. H. C.

    DEDICATION OF THE FIRST EDITION

    TO

    THE LEARNED OF EUROPE

    TO THE HEADS OF ITS SEVERAL UNIVERSITIES

    TO THE TEACHERS OF RELIGION AND THE LOVERS OF HISTORY

    MORE ESPECIALLY

    TO THE ALIBENISTIC ORDER OF FREEMASONS

    TO THE FELLOWS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY

    TO THE MEMBERS OF THE ROYAL ASIATIC SOCIETY

    TO THE FELLOWS OF THE SOCIETY OF ANTIQUARIES

    TO THE EDITORS OF THE ARCHÆOLOGIA SCOTICA

    TO THE COMMITTEES OF THE SOCIETIES FOR THE PROPAGATION OF THE

    GOSPEL AND THE DIFFUSION OF USEFUL KNOWLEDGE

    AND

    TO THE COURT OF THE HONOURABLE THE EAST INDIA COMPANY

    THIS VOLUME IS INSCRIBED

    AS A NOVEL EXPOSITION OF LITERARY INQUIRIES IN WHICH

    THEY ARE SEVERALLY INTERESTED

    AND AS AN INTIMATION OF RESPECT FROM

    THE AUTHOR

    PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION

    In Fraser’s Magazine for the month just expired, there has appeared an article headed the “Arcana of Freemasonry,” which will save me the trouble of an introductory dissertation. The style is quaint, but that will be overlooked; its author is evidently a true mason and a good man; and, initiated as he is in all the fundamentals of his fraternity, he will be the more ready to recognise the truth of my disclosures, as well as to admit the originality of the proofs which I adduce. To him, therefore, whoever he is, do I with confidence refer.

    “In the spirit of the mighty dead,” says he, “the great ones of the earth, that seem ever and anon to look down through the clouds of this murky atmosphere and to beckon us heavenward, nothing strikes more keenly, in our conviction, than that passion for divine truth which burned unquenchably within them. With what hallowed devotion they worshipped it, with what intense aspirations they loved it, we must remember but too painfully, when we converse with men as they are, and read the writings they applaud.

    “Yes--it must be so! The first and noblest object to which the ambition of man can aspire is the discovery and propagation of truth, on which the felicity of all created thinkers absolutely depends; and, fortunately, the glory of its discovery is nothing superior to the joy of its communication. And therefore have the finest and freest souls, that have caught the brightest glimpses of truth’s eternal radiation, ever most earnestly sought to lead their brethren and kindred to the same difficult and solitary height from which they themselves first witnessed the dawnings of the prophetic dayspring.

    “How many illustrious names, however venerable, have from time’s eldest records sought out with indefatigable assiduity the relics of divinest Wisdom! How often beneath her charmed inspirations they wandered forth, exulting over the boundless fields of metaphysical and physical science--endeavouring by the things that are manifest to retrace the hidden Divinity--to look through nature up to nature’s God!

    And if happily they discover some strange and stirring indications of the Almighty’s elaborating hand, or some bright testimony of His vivifying though impalpable Spirit, have they not hastened with glowing hearts, and souls overcharged with adoration, to whisper the mystery in secret, or to proclaim the marvel to the world?

    “The history of Freemasonry being in fact the history of the gradual progression of devotion and philosophy in the youth, maturity, and declension of our planet’s millenary circle, is intensely interesting to the philosophic mind, as the ages of the one have a thousand mystic correspondences with the ages of the other. After taking a luminous survey of the advances of human intelligence as revealed in Scripture, it traces the perpetual tradition of divine wisdom among the hierophantic academies of classic memorial. None understood so well the essential truth of their theo-astrological mythologies and their symbolical mysteries.

    They track every subtle declension of lofty and bright-souled truth into the shadowy circumference of hostile error; and thus, establishing their minds on the deepest foundations of history, they continually build up superstructures of all that is precious in literature or elegant in art.

    “In thus eulogising Freemasons, we of course allude to Freemasons initiated into the deep spirit of divine philosophy, and not mere nominal professors. True masons,--those who are made free by their free devotion to God’s spiritual service, and accepted by emulating the self-immolation of their celestial prototype of heaven and earth for just and disciplined worthies,--we would discourse of these, and these alone.

    It would be as unfair to judge of Freemasonry in its hidden sanctuary within the veil, by its irregular members, as to judge of its religious illustration without the veil by merely nominal Christians.

    “But for true, or free, or speculative masons. These are the men who, attached to their celestial Saviour with filial enthusiasm incommunicable, and to each other by fraternal sympathies that melt them into beautiful unanimity of immortal emulation, these are the men who feel a more especial and endearing interest in the whole history of mankind.

    To them, whatever is “wisest, virtuousest, discreetest, best,” in all the records of humanity, hath a kind of kindred familiarity of association unknown to others; for in all true men they recognise their ancestry or their brotherhood, and they watch the broad line of their genealogical descent with the reverent fondness of a lineal and loyal progeny. In their history they love to contemplate the magnificent economy of Providence for the gradual perfectionising of all lapsed intelligences.

    In this they view every variation of Churches and States with tranquil and unbroken satisfaction, and from it they look forward to the future with that fine, free, and fearless confidence which Christian philosophy alone inspires.

    “In the present times, these relations to society have assumed a somewhat deeper and still more thrilling intensity; they know well enough that old age hath come upon the earth, and that the latter day is at hand; and that the prophecies relating to her dissolution and bright regeneration are, ere long, to be accomplished in their fulness.

    “They confess, with rejoicing, the vast spread of intellectual light and freedom that now gilds the concluding pages of our planet’s history. They believe that the true and venerable principles of Church and State will be confirmed and illustrated in their breadth and length, and height and depth, by the last and prophetic experience of pious and patriot sages, ere the kindling judgment breaks out upon the astonished world.

    “Such is the position of Freemasons in society at present. And when we consider the extent of this chosen band of good and wise men, bound together by the fellowship of indissoluble benevolence, and scattered over every kingdom and republic, we cannot but observe their influences with peculiar scrutiny of attention; for, by keeping fast their own counsel, and preserving mutual good faith, they ever possess a strong, though secret domination of philanthropy over all the affairs of Church and State.

    In her peaceful and inviolable retirement, Masonry is, as it were, the primum mobile and mainspring of society,--unseen herself, but urging the whole visible mechanism into harmonious and musical action.

    “In the present time, Freemasons cannot but feel that a terrible responsibility is committed to their charge. The ancient interests and ambitions of Churches and States are coming into perpetual and jarring collision with the new. The ebb-tides of bigotry and despotism are clashing with the advancing currents of enthusiasm and dissolute passion.

    The spray of the whirling eddies already whitens the deep, and the roar of the conflicting breakers is heard far away upon the wind. God saith, ‘I will overturn, overturn, overturn, until He shall come whose right the kingdom is’; and the sea and the waves are roaring upon every shore, and men’s hearts fail them for fear, and for looking on those things which are coming on the earth. To true masons is entrusted the hazardous charge of piloting the vessel athwart the boiling whirlpools.

    They will save, if they can, earth’s latest age from indecent strife and confusion, and struggle hard against the unfilial and disloyal apostates, that would bring down her grey hairs with sorrow to the grave.”[30]

    Here I would willingly close my Introduction; but as it may seem strange that a work which bears upon its title-page the character of “Prize Essay” should not have been published by the Society that have awarded it the prize, I am obliged to open up a statement of facts which I had rather have concealed; yet, in doing so, I shall take care, now that all vexation has passed over, that no symptoms of asperity shall escape my pen; all the colouring of language I shall equally avoid; nay, even inferences, however obvious, I shall not press into observation, but confine myself strictly to a matter-of-fact detail as to the conduct of the party in the case in question.

    In December 1830, the Royal Irish Academy, after many fruitless efforts to obtain information on the subject of the Round Towers, proposed a premium of a gold medal and fifty pounds to the author of an approved Essay, in which all particulars respecting them were expected to be explained. This intimation I never saw. The stipulated time for the composition of treatises--namely, a full twelvemonth--expired, and the several candidates sent in their works.

    After a perusal of two or three months, the Council agreed upon giving the premium to one of them; but his work being deficient in some of the conditions required,[31] it was furthermore resolved that he should be allowed some additional interval for the supplying of these defects, and this determination they put into practice by the following advertisement:--

    “ROYAL IRISH ACADEMY HOUSE, DUBLIN,

    “21st February 1832.

    “It having appeared to the Royal Irish Academy that none of the Essays
    given in on the subject of the ‘Round Towers,’ as advertised in
    December 1830, have satisfied the conditions of the question, they
    have come to the following resolutions:--

    “1st. That the question be advertised again as follows:--

    “‘The Royal Irish Academy hereby give notice that they will give a
    Premium of Fifty Pounds and the Gold Medal to the author of an
    approved Essay on the Round Towers of Ireland, in which it is expected
    that the characteristic architectural peculiarities belonging to all
    those ancient buildings now existing shall be noticed
    , and the
    uncertainty in which their origin and uses are involved be
    satisfactorily removed.’

    “2nd. That the time be extended to the 1st of June next, for receiving
    other Essays on said subject, and for allowing the authors of the
    Essays already given in to enlarge and improve them; for which purpose
    they will be returned, on application at the Academy House.

    “All Essays, as usual, to be sent post free to the Rev. J. H. Singer,
    D.D., Secretary, at the Academy House, 114 Grafton Street, Dublin;
    each Essay being inscribed with some motto, and accompanied with a
    sealed billet, superscribed with same motto, in which shall be written
    the author’s name and address.”

    A few days before this appeared, I heard, for the first time, of the subject having been for competition. Wishing to ascertain whether it was decided or not, I availed myself of a pretext for calling upon Dr.

    M’Donnell, one of the Secretaries to the Academy, when the following conversation took place between us:--

    “I wish to know, sir,” said I, “whether the Council would patronise a translation of Ibernia Phœnicia, which I have just embarked in, with Dr.

    Villanueva’s consent?”

    “The Council have already subscribed to the original, and I believe they feel no difficulty in understanding it in that form,” was the reply.

    “I do not at all question their competency,” I rejoined; “but to the public, Doctor, it is a sealed volume; and I cannot think it foreign from the spirit of your institution to countenance such an idea. Besides, it is not a mere echo of the original that I intend to give. I purpose to enlarge it by many additions of my own, accompanying it all through with notes and illustrations.”

    “To what points in particular will those additions refer?”

    “To the development of the mystery which overhangs the Round Towers.”

    “Oh! On that head the Academy have already made up their minds. What is your theory about them?”

    “Surely, Doctor, if the Academy have already made up their minds upon the subject, my information can be to you of no value! Good-morning.”

    If my disappointment at this interview was great, my delight, a few mornings after, was incomparably greater, on beholding the advertisement above introduced; and though the shortness of the time allowed, with the positiveness of the assertion so recently and reluctantly extorted, made me suspect at once that there was some management in the business, yet, having thoroughly assured myself, from the wording of that manifesto, that I was entitled to enter the lists, I plunged into the discussion without further delay, and day and night, in sorrow and in difficulties, I laboured, until I finished my Essay against the appointed day, when I sent it in accordingly to await its chance.

    Four days, however, had only passed over, when the Council, having perceived that they had been taken at their word, by the appearance of a new candidate, allowed their friend to take back his Essay for one month more, to render it more perfect! And in the exercise of their discretion, they had the modesty to advertise, by a document precisely similar to that already inserted, that their object in so doing was to “obtain new Essays on said subject.”

    This last advertisement was not published for some days after their friend had removed his work from the Council Board; so that there were no more than about three weeks remaining, for the inditing of new works upon a subject for which lives have been found inadequate, and for which their friend had already been allowed a period nearly approaching to two years!

    Soon as informed of this manœuvre, I called upon Dr. Singer, as the Secretary, and entreated of him, with much ardour, that he would put a stop to those proceedings; stated that I was myself the author of one of the Essays, which I would not further particularise; and that, as I had reason to apprehend something wrong was in contemplation, I would feel obliged if he exerted himself to have the Essays detained, and determined upon by their merits as they then stood. He asked me to explain the ground of my apprehensions.

    I complied; whereupon he assured me that I was mistaken in that quarter, as “the individual,” says he, “at whose request we have extended the time is one for whom we all have a regard, and is by no means the person on whom your suspicions light!”

    It was but little consolation to me that the person in whose favour all this partiality was exerted was “not the person on whom my suspicions lighted”! I remonstrated, but in vain. Every syllable that transpired afterwards tended only to show that the decision was already pronounced--that the premium was already awarded. I then hinted at the injustice of seducing me into the competition, at the very risk of my life, upon so short a notice, and not vouchsafing now so much as to examine my production. This had some effect, and I left the Doctor with an assurance that I “should, at all events, get a hearing.”

    The day for the reception of the amended Essays again came, and mine again made its appearance. In the interim was started a periodical, under the direction of some members of the Council, the most prominent of whom was the favoured individual himself. In the second number of this periodical, on the Saturday after the last sending in of the Essays, there appeared an article, written by the Rev.

    Cæsar Otway, a member of the Council, under the assumed name of Terence O’Toole, in which half playfully and half mysteriously, he lets the cat out of the bag, and actually asserts, as the event verified, that the premium was already determined to a member of their own body!

    Here are his words:--

    “The Round Tower, to the right, is a prodigious puzzler to antiquarians.

    Quires of paper, as tall as a tower, have been covered with as much ink as might form a Liffey, in accounting for their origin and use. But all these clever and recondite conjectures are shortly, as I understand, to be completely overthrown, and the real nature of these Round Towers clearly explained, for the first time, in a Prize Essay presented to the Royal Irish Academy by an accomplished antiquarian of our city.”[32]

    Notwithstanding the disguise here assumed of “as I understand,” and so forth, the writer of this announcement had, at this moment, not only perused his colleague’s Essay, but actually registered his vote in its favour! And as to his pretending that the development was a discovery, by saying “for the first time,” he betrays therein the extreme either of untruth or of ignorance, as the theory alluded to is but the echo, in all particulars, of Montmorency’s book, every sentence in which I prove erroneous in the early chapters of the present volume!

    I could no longer, however, be ignorant as to the identity of the person in whose favour Dr. M’Donnell had told me the Council had “made up their minds”;--casually corroborated afterwards by Dr. Singer!--I saw at once that the “accomplished antiquarian of our city” was Mr. Petrie, the antiquarian artist of the Royal Irish Academy--himself a member of their Council!

    However, Dr. Singer had promised that I “should get, at all events, a hearing.” And this was performed with a vengeance. Three months was the time devoted to the examination of all the former Essays. It remained, therefore, only publicly to announce what was privately resolved upon.

    But as my Essay, the only new one, was at all taken in, it was indispensable but that they must read it, and six long months did they appropriate thereto. At the end of this period they saw that the position assumed was right, and that I was entitled to the premium. But they had already pledged themselves to give it to their friend, whose theory was the direct opposite of mine; and, consequently, every sentence in it, or in mine, must be wrong--a discrepancy, however, which they thought to reconcile by leaving the original prize undisturbed, and voting me a separate one.

    Had they had the candour to avow that this was their dilemma, I should never have murmured, but quietly submitted to the issue; instead of which, however, they worded their resolution in such a form as led the public to think that there were two premiums all along intended, and that the first of these was given to the best composition, and the second to that which approached it in quality.

    It was as follows:--

    “ROYAL IRISH ACADEMY HOUSE.

    “On Monday, December 17, a meeting of the Council of the Royal Irish
    Academy was held, for the purpose of deciding on the merits of essays
    received, pursuant to advertisement, on The Origin and Use of the
    Round Towers of Ireland
    , when the following premiums were adjudged,
    viz.:--

    “Fifty pounds and the gold medal to George Petrie.

    “Twenty pounds to Henry O’Brien, Esq.”

    Now, be it observed that it was not only of the gold medal and fifty pounds that I was deprived by this manœuvre, but of the one hundred additional pounds which Lord Cloncurry had offered upon the same subject.

    Of this the Academy were also the dispensers, on the understanding that whoever should get their gold medal and fifty pounds--the only premium which they had offered--should also get his lordship’s hundred; so that by this stratagem they assigned to their friend not only their own, but his lordship’s patronage!

    I was in London at the time, and signified my dissatisfaction by letter.

    Several were interchanged, in one of which I gave them to understand that I would submit to the injustice if they would but publish my work in their Transactions simultaneously with Mr. Petrie’s. This they declined, assuring me that they would publish it, but not simultaneously, and not until after. No comment is necessary for this.

    Meanwhile, their periodical, which, from the first moment of its starting, whenever reference was made to the Round Towers, unqualifiedly asserted that they were Christian, and only coeval with the monasteries,[33] thought proper now to change its tone; but as an open acknowledgment of error would be too self-abasing for Academicians, they only put forth a feeler, as if implying doubt on the matter, which would have the twofold effect of screening the “Council’s” verdict--as the result of doubt or ambiguity--and of preparing the public mind for the altered and novel conclusion to which all, I trust, will ere long, as well as themselves, have arrived.

    My eye, however, was on their plans, though separated by “a roaring sea.”

    I knew that where there were so many windings to mature the plot, there must be as many to prevent its detection; and, accordingly, the very first move they made in these, their new tactics, I checkmated at once by the following letter:--

    (No. 1.)

    “LONDON, March 16, 1833.

    “DEAR DR. SINGER,--The Dublin Penny Journal of February 23rd, on the
    article, ‘Devenish Island,’ contains this sentence, viz.: ‘Whether the
    towers are the accompaniment to the churches, or the churches to the
    towers, is a question not yet decided.’

    “Now this--coupled with the circumstance of the Committee having
    awarded two premiums to two, as I understand, conflicting
    ascriptions
    , and that when only one was originally
    proposed
    --induces me, with all deference, to offer this memorial,
    through you, to the Academy.

    “As the development of truth in the elucidation of history is the
    object of the antiquarian, and, as the ‘labourer is worthy of his
    hire,’ I take the liberty respectfully to ask whether, if I make my
    ascription
    of the Round Towers a mathematical demonstration, with
    every other incident relating to their founders, comprehending all
    the antiquities of Ireland, as connected therewith--and this by all
    the varieties and modes of proof--whether, I say, in that event,
    will the Academy award me the gold medal and premium? or, if that
    cannot be recalled, an equivalent gold medal and premium.

    “My intercalary work, substantiating all the above, is now finished,
    and can be forwarded to the Committee by return of the same post which
    will favour me with your answer.--I have the honour to be, dear sir,
    your obedient, etc.

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.

    “To the Rev. Dr. J. H. Singer,
    “Secretary to the Academy.”

    By the above proposal I must not be understood as admitting that my original essay “was not sufficiently conclusive”; but as I had more arguments still in reserve, I wanted to elicit from the Academy the admission that it was truth they sought after. After waiting, however, more than three weeks, and getting no reply, I forwarded some other proofs, accompanied by a letter, of which the following was the conclusion, viz.:--

    (No. 2.)

    “These are but items in the great body of discoveries which this
    intercalary work will exhibit. In truth, I may without vanity assert
    that the whole ancient history of Ireland, etc., is therein
    rectified and elucidated--which it never was before. Am I, therefore,
    presumptuous in appealing to the Royal Irish Academy--the heads of
    Irish literature and the avowed patrons of its development--for the
    reward of my labours?

    “I shall with confidence rely upon their justice.--I have the honour
    to be, with sincere regard, etc.

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.

    “To the Rev. Dr. J. H. Singer,
    “Secretary to the Academy.”

    (No. 3.)

    “ROYAL IRISH ACADEMY HOUSE,

    “April 16, 1833.

    “SIR,--Your improved essay and letter were yesterday laid before
    Council, and as Dr Singer is at present confined with the gout, it
    devolves on me to communicate to you the following extract from the
    minutes:--

    “‘Resolved, that the Secretary be directed to reply to Mr. O’Brien,
    and to state that any alteration or revocation of their award cannot
    be made, whatever may be the merits of any additional matter
    supplied to them after the day appointed by advertisement; but if Mr.
    O’Brien be willing that the new matter be printed along with the
    original Essay, the Council will have the same perused, in order to
    ascertain the expediency of so enlarging their publication.’--By
    order.

    “RICH. ROW, Clerk to the Academy.

    “To H. O’Brien, Esq.”

    (No. 4.)

    “LONDON, April 18, 1833.

    “SIR,--Had I a notion that the Academy’s reply would be such as your
    letter has this day imparted, I would never have sat down to indite
    those additions, much less have forwarded them for their perusal.
    For why did I write to the Secretary three weeks ago, but to
    ascertain whether or not, in the event of my doing so and
    so, would the Academy act so and so, and thus repair that
    injury which they had before inflicted? What could be more easy than
    to give me a categorical answer, one way or the other?

    Instead of
    which, however, they left me to my own conclusions, which, as usual in
    such circumstances, leading me to construe silence into acquiescence,
    I transmitted my documents on the tacit faith that though the Academy
    would not pledge themselves by a written promise, they would,
    notwithstanding, if my researches proved adequate, reward my industry
    by a suitable remuneration.

    “Now, however, when my papers have been received, and my developments
    communicated, I am told that, be their merits what they may, the
    award is irrevocable; and I have no alternative, in the writhings
    of my mortification, but the consolation of being injured and
    duped at the same time.

    “You will say, perhaps, that my new evidences have not yet been read,
    and that therefore my property is secure and sacred. But has not the
    accompanying letter been read? And what was that but a programme
    of their contents?

    “I had thought that the Royal Irish Academy were not only a
    learned, but a just and a patriotic Society. I had thought
    that having marshalled themselves into an institution, with the
    avowed object of resuscitating from death the almost despaired-of
    evidences
    of our national history, they would not alone foster
    every advance toward that desirable consummation, but shower
    honours, and acclamations, and triumphs upon him who has not
    only infused a vital soul into those moribund remains, but made
    the history of Ireland, at this moment, the clearest, the most
    irrefragable, and withal the most interestingly comprehensive
    chain
    of demonstrational proofs in the whole circle of universal
    literature
    .[34]

    “But it is not alone the being deprived of my reward that I complain
    of, and the transferring of that reward to another, every sentiment
    of whose production must inevitably be wrong
    , but it is the
    suppression of my labours, and the keeping them back from the public
    eye, in deference to my opponent’s work, lest that the discernment
    of the public should bestow upon me those honours which the
    discretion of the Academy has thought proper to alienate, that
    affects me as most severe.

    “Indeed, it has been stated from more quarters than one, that the
    withholding of the medal from me, in the first instance, and the
    substituting thereinstead a nominal premium of twenty pounds,
    originated from a personal pique against me individually.

    Such a
    report I would fain disbelieve, and yet it is hard not to give it some
    credence, seeing that the irresistible cogency of my truths and
    the indubitable value of my literary discoveries are not only not
    rewarded, but kept back from publication, until someone else more
    fortunate, or rather more favoured, shall run away with the credit
    of my cherished disclosures.[35] I wish--I desire--I most intensely
    covet--that the Academy would convince me that this is not an act of
    the most aggravated injustice
    .

    “You will please lay this before the Council, and tell them from me,
    respectfully, that I do not want them either to ‘alter’ or ‘revoke’
    their award, but simply to vote me ‘an equivalent gold medal and
    premium
    ’ for my combined essay, or, if they prefer, the new
    portion
    of it. Should this be refused, I will put my cause, etc.
    etc.--I have the honour to be, etc. etc.

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.

    “To the Rev. Richard Row,
    “Clerk to the Academy.”

    They bestowed some days in consultation upon the above; meanwhile, the transmission of the Dublin Penny Journal to London was countermanded, and not a copy of it was allowed, for some months afterwards, to come within hundreds of miles of the place of my residence. In the interim the ingenious author of the Celtic Druids, and who had been partly in possession of my development of the “Towers” for some time previously, favoured me with a visit, during which we conversed principally on historical questions.

    The next day I addressed him a note, a copy of which, with its answer, I take leave to subjoin, for the sake of the terminating clause of the latter, being the self-convicting acknowledgment of the “Academy’s” disingenuousness.

    (No. 5.)

    “May 2, 1833.

    “DEAR SIR,--I hope you will not feel displeased at the frankness of
    this question which I am about to propose to you, viz. have you any
    objection to show me in manuscript, before you send to print, the
    terms in which you speak of me, in reference to those points of
    information which I entrusted to your confidence--such as the ancient
    names of Ireland and their derivation, the towers and founders, dates,
    etc.?

    “Should you think proper to consent to this feeling of anxiety on my
    part, I shall be most willing to share with you those other ‘points’
    which I exclusively retain.

    “To the full extent you shall have them. The only condition I require
    is, the credit of originality, which I have laboriously earned. Please
    to drop me a line in reply to this, and allow me to subscribe myself,
    with great respect,--Dear sir, your obedient,

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.

    “Godfrey Higgins, Esq.”

    (No. 6.)

    “May 3, 1833.

    “MY DEAR O’BRIEN,--You may be perfectly assured I shall print nothing
    which I have learned from you without acknowledging it. But I have
    really forgotten what you told me, because I considered that I should
    see it in print in a few days. Anything I shall write on the subject
    will not be printed for years after your books have been before the
    public. You did not tell me the name of Buddha, but I told it you,
    that it was Saca, or Saca-sa,[36] which I have already printed a
    hundred times, and can show you in my great quarto, when you take your
    tea with me, as I hope you will to-morrow. Sir W.

    Betham told me of
    the fire-towers being Phalluses last night at the Antiquarian
    Society.--Yours truly,

    “G. HIGGINS.”

    Who, now, can pretend to think that the neutralising award of the “Council” was the effect of scepticism or legitimate doubt? Here Sir William Betham, the Ulster King-at-Arms! the Goliath of antiquaries!--as he is, undoubtedly, of pedigrees,--being himself a member of the “deciding tribunal,”--proclaims, in the midst of a venerable literary assembly, that my solution of the Round Tower enigma is accurate; and yet in the teeth of this confession, and of the conviction which extorted it, he joins in voting away my medal to a compilation of errors, and in substituting thereinstead twenty pounds!

    (No. 7.)

    “LONDON, May 2, 1833.

    “DEAR DR. SINGER,--I exceedingly grieve to hear of your ill-health.
    Its announcement, I assure you, made me look within myself, and for a
    moment lose sight of my own hardships. I hope, however, that you are
    now so far recovered as to send me a favourable answer to this my
    last appeal.

    “Taking it for certain that the Academy’s having not replied to the
    tenor of my late intimation arose from the circumstance of there
    having been no ‘Council day’ since; and, as I anticipate, that on
    Monday next my question will be finally disposed of, I am anxious,
    for the good of all parties, and for the triumph of truth, to
    show you in one view how I have amputated the last supports of
    error, and covered its advocates with ignominy and shame.

    • * * * *

    “Thus every leaf unfolds evidences to the realisation of my
    victory
    . I took my stand at the outset on the pedestal of truth;
    and I challenge scrutiny to insinuate that, in the multiplied
    developments
    which I have since revealed, I have deviated from my
    grand position one single iota.

    “Let it not be supposed, in the observation with which I am now about
    to conclude, that I mean anything disrespectful to the Council of the
    Academy. Many years have not passed since I knew several of them in a
    different relation; and however little effect college associations may
    produce on other minds, I find not their influence so fleeting or
    transient. It is with extreme reluctance, therefore, that I would
    split with a body who have lectured me as tutors. But time has
    advanced; I am now right, and they are wrong, and the cause which
    they patronise will not do them much credit
    .

    “I do not, however, yet give up my hopes but that the Academy will
    wisely retrace their steps. Revocation of the former medal I do
    not require--much less the exercise of a single grain of partiality.
    My demand merely is, as my former letters have indicated, the
    substitution of justice.

    “Please receive the assurance of my consideration, and in confident
    reliance that you will use your influence in this matter, and favour
    me with the upshot instantly after Monday’s Board,--I remain, ever
    sincerely yours,

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.”

    (No. 8.)

    “LONDON, May 9, 1833.

    “DEAR DR. SINGER,--My appeals are over; and I regret to say that they
    have not been attended to. The virtuous and enlightened part of
    the Academy, therefore, cannot blame me, if, in the assertion of my
    honest right, I try the effect of a public remonstrance.

    “In the interim, I transmit to you by this night’s post some
    additional leaves, which, in the anxiety of despatch, as well, indeed,
    as from fear that they would not be inserted because they overwhelm
    for ever the antiquarian pretensions of the Dublin Penny Journal
    ,[37]
    have omitted to copy. However, I will now forward them, and claim
    that they may be printed along with those already sent in the original
    Essay.

    “... I have exhausted all the forms of blandness and conciliation, in
    the vain hope of inducing the Council to redeem themselves from
    disgrace, by doing me common justice. I have strove in the
    mildest terms of conscious rectitude, invigorated by a phalanx of
    overwhelming proofs, to make them reconsider their course, and spare
    me the unpleasant task of exposing a deed which I am loth to
    characterise by its proper designation.

    But the ‘heart of Pharaoh’ was
    hardened; the ‘voice of the charmer’ not listened to; and to my soft
    importunities nothing was returned but the coldness of obduracy and
    disregard.

    “The Rubicon, therefore, is crossed; my patience feels insulted; and
    the only consideration I value, in the resolve to which I have at last
    been driven, is, that you had nothing to do with the ‘job’ of the
    Round Towers.

    “Little did the Academy know what arguments I could adduce in
    elucidation of certain mysteries. As little do they now dream what
    proofs I can summon, though you cannot have forgotten one of them,
    while I promise I shall make Dr. M’Donnell recollect another; and
    would not the Rev. Cæsar Otway, with whom I have never so much as
    exchanged a look, be surprised at my quoting him as a reluctant third
    witness, to show that the gold medal and premium were predetermined to
    Mr.

    Petrie before ever I became a candidate; and that, consequently,
    the advertisement under which I was invited to contend, but from
    which the Council never expected an intruder, was but a specious
    delusion.

    “In this determination I violate no act of private regard, nor set
    light by the claims of individual acquaintance. You know yourself how
    earnestly I struggled, before the consummation of this nefarious
    proceeding, to stem the agency of that despicable under-current which
    I had just detected.

    I knew that fraud of some kind was at work; and
    though unable at the moment to fix upon the person in whose favour it
    was set agoing,--nay, though mentally fastening the blame thereof
    upon another, whose name, however, I never let slip, and to whom, I
    rejoice to say I have since made more than recompense for this ideal
    injury,--yet could I not be persuaded but that something sinister
    was designated; and to frustrate the influence of such prominent
    deceit, you know how vehement was my address.

    I implored you, I
    besought you, and all but upon my knees, and with tears, I invoked
    you, by your regard to justice and your fear of a Creator, to check
    this trickery
    , and allow merit alone and anonymous to decide the
    issue.

    “I now, in the same spirit of solemn self-composure, adjure the
    ‘Council’ through you, in the name of that God before whom they and I
    shall one day appear, that they will have my cause redressed, and make
    me reparation, not only for the substantial injury, but for the mental
    disquietude and agony which this ‘business’ has occasioned. If they do
    not, rest satisfied that my path is already chalked.

    All the
    evolutions of the Council, as displayed upon the Towers, and with
    which I am but too familiar, shall be immortalised in letterpress; and
    I do not yet despair of the hereditary fairness of my country but
    that it shall register its dissent from the decision of that
    tribunal, which could have had at once the obtuseness of intellect
    and the perverseness of conduct to stultify their own verdict by a
    contradictory award; and, after inveigling me into a competition
    which they never meant to remunerate, deprive
    me of the fruits of my
    indubitable triumph, in the pursuit of which I had almost lost my
    life, and cut short my existence in the very spring of my manhood.

    “I mean no offence, individually or collectively, to the Academy or
    its members; but as they have been deaf to the justice of my private
    ‘appeals,’ I shall try the effect of a public ‘remonstrance’; and as
    to ulterior consequences I greatly err, else the upshot will show
    that the motto[38] adopted as my fictitious signature in the ‘Essay’
    was not the random assumption of inconsiderateness or accident, but
    the true index to the author’s resources.

    “My proposal is this--my unshaken position from which I will not
    swerve or retract--a gold medal and premium equivalent to those
    originally advertised
    .--I am, dear sir, yours sincerely,

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.

    “To the Rev. Dr. J. H. Singer,
    “Secretary to the Academy.”

    (No. 10.)

    “GRAFTON STREET, DUBLIN,

    “May 13, 1833.

    “DEAR SIR,--I have been directed by the Council of the Royal Irish
    Academy to reply to your last letters on the subject of your Essay,
    and the additional matter recently sent over.

    As to the latter, I am
    directed to say that the Council had engaged to examine and publish,
    if approved, some small additions to your former Essay; but the papers
    you have sent are so large as to be nearly equal in bulk to the
    original dissertation; under these circumstances the Council cannot
    publish them as additional to, or incorporated with, the Essay to
    which they awarded twenty pounds prize, as thereby its character
    might be so altered that it would not appear in print the same Essay
    on which they had formed their opinion
    . The Council, therefore, wish
    to know how they may transmit to you the papers you have sent.

    When
    the gentlemen to whom your Essay has been submitted for examination
    report, you shall be made aware of the extent of alteration they
    suggest; and if you think that your paper requires the additions you
    have sent, and would therefore wish to publish it with them yourself,
    I have no doubt the Council will entertain any notice to that
    effect.--I am, dear sir, your most obedient,

    “J. H. SINGER.

    “H. O’Brien, Esq.”

    (No. 11.)

    “LONDON, May 20, 1833.

    “DEAR DR. SINGER,--I do not quite understand the closing observation
    of your last letter. If the Academy mean me a kindness, I should trust
    that my nature is too sensible of such advances not suitably to
    acknowledge it; and I should be sorry that, either from obscurity in
    the diction, or want of quickness in my perception, I were to lose the
    opportunity of making a grateful return. Let me, therefore, put the
    following interrogatory to set myself right, viz.:--

    “Will the Academy procure me a publisher for my enlarged work? And
    will they advertise that, having previously done me injustice, by the
    transfer of my medal, they now, on being convinced of their error,
    adopt this as the only mode of reparation, the award itself not being
    to be recalled?

    “Without some such course as this, it is obvious that the offer which
    they make, instead of being a kindness, would be a mockery; and,
    instead of making amends for oppression, would be adding insult to
    persecution!

    For who, let me ask, would publish a work which a jury
    have branded with the stamp of inferior, doling out their
    surreptitious twenty pounds as an eleemosynary deodand, while the
    darling of their adoption, though disfigured by all the
    imperfections of blindness, lameness, and untruth, and
    recommended only by a few painted gew-gaws, which never entered into
    the requisites of the original advertisement, will pass current in
    Dublin amongst the creatures
    of party!

    “I have already applied to Mr. ----, and he, intimidated by the
    vicious state of society in Ireland, declined my proposal; but though
    his apprehensions were sufficient to deter him from the speculation,
    they were totally unfounded; for, despite of all corruption, all
    chicanery, and all cabals, the etc. etc. etc.

    “This complaint, observe, does not refer to the new papers only, but
    extends itself equally to the original Essay. Why do the Academy keep
    it back? Believe me, it is in vain for them to defer ‘the evil day’ of
    their exposure. Their doom was sealed the very moment they did me
    injustice!

    I have watchfully reconnoitred their course, and have
    proofs of the intricacies of their internal machinery, ample as those
    before adduced for the solution of the Round Tower enigma, to effect
    their overthrow; and if the present generation be not virtuous enough
    to redress my cause, it shall be no fault of mine if any future age
    shall be ignorant of the names of the individuals who constitute the
    present Council; and in what light they shall be considered, their
    own conscience can furnish them with a tolerable foretaste!

    “Was it not a cruelly perverse thing of them, after determining
    beforehand to award the medal to Mr. Petrie, to inveigle me into the
    competition by a deceptious advertisement? And then, after signally
    beating them under all disadvantages, to manœuvre me off by a
    beggarly cheat
    ? Shame, foul shame for ever upon the Academy!

    “Why, sir, the very terms of your letter show their
    self-convictedness, though they have not honesty enough to avow it
    overboard! What do they mean by saying that the new matter would ‘make
    my Essay not appear in print the same as that on which they formed
    their opinion’? Are they afraid that it would make it appear worse?
    Not at all; they would rejoice at the pretext, and publish it
    instanter as a cloak to their verdict! But as they have, in spite of
    them, admitted those additions to be an improvement,[39] why do they,
    I ask, who have advertised for truth, again repress its effulgence
    ?

    “It is now easy to see what they designed by the clauses of
    ‘expediency,’ ‘if approved,’ and ‘subject to revisal’; viz., if false,
    we will insert them in self-vindication; but if true, we will not,
    as being too great a victory over our own ignorance and favouritism!

    “My Essay, however, does not want those new papers: the Council,
    therefore, will please have them sealed and handed over to the custody
    of Mr. Tims, my bookseller, in Grafton Street. The only additions
    which I shall insist upon being inserted are those contained in my
    letters in appropriate places, as I shall point out.

    “I conclude by giving notice that I shall claim Lord Cloncurry’s
    premium; nor do I despair of recovering that, as I should think that
    his lordship is too honest a man to sacrifice the interests of
    literature to the intrigues of a faction
    !--I have the honour to be,
    etc.,

    “HENRY O’BRIEN.”

    (No. 12.)

    “ROYAL IRISH ACADEMY HOUSE, DUBLIN,

    “May 27, 1833.

    “SIR,--I am directed by the Council of the Royal Irish Academy to
    inform you that they feel themselves compelled, in consequence of your
    late letters, to decline the publication of your Essay, or the
    maintaining any further correspondence with you on the subject.

    “Your Essay and the additional matter will be sent, as you desire, to
    Mr. Tims, Grafton Street, as soon as a copy of the former can be
    taken.--I am, sir, your most obedient,

    “J. H. SINGER, Secretary.

    “H. O’Brien, Esq.”

    The discontinuance of the correspondence was to be expected, but their declining the publication of my Essay in their Transactions, merely because of my giving utterance to some unpalatable truths, was an excess of magnanimity which I did not think that even the “Council” would personify.

    However, you suppose that they, at all events, returned me my Essay, as promised? Far from it! In violation of all honour, and of the written engagements of their Secretary, they have detained it ever since in their hands, thereby putting me to the vast expense of procuring new plates, instead of those which the original contained--an inconvenience, I must affirm, which they had hoped I could never have surmounted; while, in the interim, they should push out their bantling upon the public, secure in the consciousness of having cushioned my work, that they should ride over the market without a rival.

    They should have known, however, that the person who, at three months’ notice, undertook to solve the Towers, and then kept them at bay for six months before they could chouse him out of his prize, was not to be deterred by such an obstacle as the above. And the reader may be satisfied that, though it has occasioned me some hardship, he is in no respect thereby a loser.

    I have stated that the effect of my Letter No. 1 was to interrupt the transmission of the Dublin Penny Journal to London. I have now to point out the result of the menace conveyed in Letter 8 of my determining to expose--as I enclosed the proofs that I could refute--the antiquarian errors of their organ. It was that they instantly took the hint, and sold their interest in the concern! And its new proprietor, edified no doubt by a friendly lesson at their hands, very wisely intimates, in his opening number, that he shall forego antiquities, and make literary jobbing no part of it.

    Here are his words: “From the concluding paragraph of the last number of this little publication, its readers will be aware that it is now in the hands of a new editor and proprietor, and they will naturally expect that in the present number something should be said relative to its future management.

    ‘Deeds, not words,’ has ever been the motto of its (present) conductor, and he will therefore merely say that it is his intention to give his readers good value for their money; that the Dublin Penny Journal shall not be a mere ‘catchpenny,’ depending upon the number and excellence of its woodcuts for extensive circulation, but containing, as he considers a publication of the kind should do, such a variety of interesting and useful matter as shall render it really valuable.

    In future, therefore, while the antiquities of the country will not be neglected, the work shall exhibit a more general character in the subjects of its contents.”[40]

    • * * * *

    N.B.--As I am a member of no club, belong to no literary society, and have no facilities otherwise for watching periodicals, whether newspapers, magazines, or reviews, I shall feel obliged if any gentleman who, in the exercise of a free judgment, should think proper to dissent from me, and to express such dissent in offensive language, would be pleased to forward me a copy of the work wherein his strictures may appear, and I promise that I shall reply to them with deference, and perhaps satisfaction.

    I also trust that, from the singularity of my position, I do not expect too much when I express a hope that any publication which speaks against me will allow me to reply through the same medium--a request certainly which cannot be refused, unless the design be hostile and factiously malicious.

    Any suggestions for improvement, with a view to a second edition, I very cheerfully court.

    All communications addressed to me, to the care of my publisher, Mr.

    Whittaker, Ave Maria Lane, St. Paul’s, London, will reach me, and be attended to.

    THE ROUND TOWERS OF IRELAND;

    OR

    THE HISTORY OF THE TUATH-DE-DANAANS

    FOR THE FIRST TIME UNVEILED.

    BY HENRY O’BRIEN, ESQ., A.B.

    [Illustration]

    “Hic sacra, hic genus, hic majorum multa vestigia.”
    CICERO.

    ... “were of fame,
    And had been glorious in another day.”
    BYRON.

    SECOND EDITION.

    LONDON:
    PARBURY AND ALLEN, LEADENHALL STREET;
    DUBLIN:
    J. CUMMING, LOWER ORMOND QUAY.
    MDCCCXXXIV.

    TO THE MOST NOBLE THE MARQUIS OF LANSDOWNE, ETC. ETC. ETC.

    MY LORD MARQUIS,

    Many reasons concur why I should feel ambitious to associate your name with the following production. To enumerate these would neither become my humility, nor be acceptable to your good taste.

    But there is one motive which, as it is the offspring of the heart, implanted there at a period when adulation was not dreamt of, I may be allowed to particularise,--I was born upon your estates--you are the landlord of that spot which imparted my earliest images--the first soarings of my fancy were derived from that scene--and to the native notes which I have lisped in that primitive and retired region, more than to the vaunted advantages of a subsequent collegiate career, am I beholden for the clue with which I have traversed the ancient world; and of which Envy herself must yet acknowledge, that I have here rectified the history in its very widest amplitude--as well sacred as profane.

    It is to do honour to this clue in the eyes of the Mecænas of his age, and, under the auspices of his approval, to promote its revival, that I give utterance to this sentiment; and so, hoping that you will view it in this light, and not as the empty chaunt of a reprehensible egotism, I beg leave to subscribe myself, with the most profound consideration and respect,

    My Lord Marquis,
    Your Lordship’s most devoted
    And most faithful, humble Servant,
    HENRY O’BRIEN.

    LONDON, September 1834.

    LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.

    PAGE

    PORTRAIT OF HENRY O'BRIEN, BY MACLISE Frontispiece

    DEVENISH ROUND TOWER 38

    ARDMORE " " 71

    CLONDALKIN " " 101

    EFFIGY OF FARRAGH, OR MORIAGAN 138

    SAMONA OF BUDDHA 140

    ROUND TOWER, WITH DEVOTEE ON SUMMIT 169

    SYMBOLIC SCULPTURE FOUND AT VINDOLANA 223

    PALENCIAN SCULPTURE OF THE SYMBOLIC “TREE,” WITH FIGURES 229

    PYTHAGOREAN TRIANGLE OF TEN 268

    SYMBOLIC CRESCENT-ORNAMENTS 273, 274

    EFFIGY OF CRUCIFIED BUDDHA, SACA, OR MACHA 296

    BRECHIN ROUND TOWER (SCOTLAND), WITH DOUBLE-ARCH AND EFFIGIES 299

    OBELISK AT SANDWICK (ROSS-SHIRE) 306

    PHOENICIAN MEDALS, STAMPED WITH CROSS, LAMB, AND ROSARY 314

    SHAFT OF CROSS AT FORRES (SCOTLAND) 316

    " " " REVERSE SIDE OF SAME 319

    MONOLITH AT CARNAC (EGYPT) 322

    SCULPTURE IN KNOCKMOY ABBEY 329, 330

    SCULPTURE ON TEMPLE AT KALABCHE (NUBIA) 341, 342

    KILCULLEN, CROSS AT 338

    CLONMACNOISE, " 358

    FINGLAS " 366

    KELLS " 491

    FACSIMILE OF MS. DISCOVERED AT ICOLMKILL 419

    PHEELEAS, OR ORACLE-TUBE, FOUND AT BALLYMONEY 460

    GLENDALOUGH, CURIOUS SYMBOLIC SCULPTURE ON RUINS OF 467

    THE MAGI--WOODCUT FROM AN ANCIENT BLOCK-BOOK 482

    MEDALS OF CHRIST, FOUND AT ISLAND OF ANGLESEA AND AT CORK 509

    THE ROUND TOWERS, &c.

    CHAPTER I.

    “A lively desire of knowing and recording our ancestors so generally
    prevails, that it must depend on the influence of some common
    principle in the minds of men. We seem to have lived in the persons of
    our forefathers; our calmer judgment will rather tend to moderate than
    suppress the pride of an ancient and worthy race. The satirist may
    laugh; the philosopher may preach; but reason herself will respect the
    prejudices and habits which have been consecrated by the experience of
    mankind.”[41]

    Of all nations on the globe, the Irish, as a people, are universally admitted to possess, in a pre-eminent degree, those finer sensibilities of the human heart, which, were they but wisely controlled, would exalt man above the level of ordinary humanity, and make him, as it were, a being of another species. The numerous instances adduced in all periods of their history, of ardent and enterprising zeal, in every case wherein personal honour or national glory may be involved, are in themselves sufficient to establish this assertion.

    But while granting their pre-eminence as to the possession of those feelings, and the capability of the feelings themselves to be refined and sublimated to the very acme of cultivation, we may still doubt whether the mere possession of them be not less a blessing than a curse--whether, in fact, their quick perception of disquietudes and pains be not more than a counterpoise to their keen enjoyment of delight or pleasure.

    Foremost, however, in the train of the many virtues which flow therefrom, is that “amor patriæ,” or love of country, which, unsubdued often by the most galling miseries and the most hopeless wants, throws a halo round the loneliness of their present despair in the proud retrospection of their former buoyancy. This spirit it is which, despite of obvious advantages to be derived from emigration, has riveted the Irish peasant so immutably to his home, that any effort on his part to dissolve those local fetters would be equivalent to the disruption of all the ties and attachments which nature or habit had implanted within him.

    “The lofty scenes around their sires recall,
    Fierce in the field and generous in the hall;
    The mountain crag, the stream and waving tree,
    Breathe forth some proud and glorious history--
    Urges their steps where patriot virtue leads,
    And fires the kindred souls to kindred deeds.
    They tread elate the soil their fathers trod,
    The same their country, and the same their God.”

    But it may be said that this is a day-dream of youth--the hereditary vanity of one of Iran’s sons, arrogating antiquity and renown for an inconsiderable little island, without a particle of proof to substantiate their assumption, or a shadow of authority to give colour to their claims.

    Why, sir, cast your eye over the fair face of the land itself, and does not the scene abound with the superfluity of its evidences?

    What are those high aspiring edifices which rise with towering elevation towards the canopy of the “Most High”?[42] What are those stupendous and awful structures of another form--the study at once and admiration of the antiquarian and the philosopher, to be found on the summits of our various hills[43] as well as in the bowels[44] of the earth itself?--what are they but the historical monuments of splendour departed--surviving the ravages of time and decay, not as London’s column, to “lift their heads and lie,” but to give the lie and discomfiture to those, who, from the interested suggestions of an illiberal policy, or the more pardonable delusions of a beclouded judgment, would deny the authenticity of our historic records, and question the truth of our primeval civilisation?

    It is true, the magnificence which those memorials demonstrate is but the unenviable grandeur of druidical, as it is called, idolatry and unenlightened paganism,--when man, relinquishing that supremacy consigned to him at his creation, or rather divested thereof in punishment for the transgression of his degenerate disposition, lost sight of that Being to whom he owed his safety and his life, and bent himself in homage before perishable creatures that crawl their ephemeral pilgrimage through the same scene with himself.

    Granted; yet that cannot well be objected to us as a disgrace, which, co-extensive in its adoption with the amplitude of the earth’s extension, equally characterised the illiterate and the sage; and if, amidst this lamentable prostration of the human understanding, anything like redemption or feature of superiority may be allowed, it must be, unquestionably, to the adherents of that system, which, excluding the objects of matter and clay, recognised, in its worship of the bright luminaries of the firmament, the purity and omnipotence of that Spirit who brought all into existence, and who guides and preserves them in their respective spheres;--and when I shall have proved that the intent and application of those Sabian[45] Towers,--or, to speak more correctly, those primitive Budhist Temples,--which decorate our landscape and commemorate our past renown, appertained to this species of purified idolatry, which worshipped only the host of heaven, the moon and the solar body, which gives vigour to all things, I shall, methinks, have removed one obstacle from the elucidation of our antiquities, and facilitated the road to further adventure in this interesting inquiry.

    Let me not be supposed, however, by the preceding remarks to restrict their destination to one single purpose. All I require of my readers is a patient perusal of my details; and I deceive myself very much, and overrate my powers of enunciation, else I shall establish in their minds as thorough a conviction of the development of the “Towers” as I am myself satisfied with the accuracy of my conclusions.

    I shall only entreat, then, of their courtesy that I be not anticipated in my course, or definitively judged of by isolated scraps, but that, as my notice for this competition has been limited and recent, allowing but little time for the observance of tactique or rules, in the utterance of the novel views which I now venture to put forward, the proofs of which, however, have been long registered in my thoughts, and additionally confirmed by every new research, the merits of the production may not be estimated by parcels, but by the combined tendency of the parts altogether.

    To begin, therefore. The origins I have heard assigned to those records of antiquity,--however invidious it may appear, at this the outset of my labours, to assume so self-sufficient a tone, yet can I not avoid saying that, whether I consider their multiplicity or their extravagance, they have not more frequently excited my ridicule than my commiseration.

    That specimens of architecture, so costly and so elegant, should be designed for the paltry purposes of purgatorial columns or penitential heights, to which criminals should be elevated for the ablution of their enormities--while the honest citizen, virtuous and unstained, should be content to grovel amongst lowly terrestrials ’mid the dense exhalations of forests and bogs, in a mud-wall hut, or at best a conglomeration of wattles and hurdles--is, I conceive, an outrage upon human reason too palpable to be listened to.

    Not less ridiculous is the idea of their having been intended for beacons; for, were such their destination, a hill or rising ground would have been the proper site for their erection, and not a valley or low land, where it happens that we generally meet them.

    The belfry theory alone, unfounded in one sense though it really be, and when confined to that application equally contemptible with the others, is, notwithstanding, free from the objection that would lie against the place, as it is well known that the sound of bells which hang in plains and valleys is heard much farther than that of such as hang upon elevations or hills: for, air being the medium of sound, the higher the sonorous body is placed, the more rarefied is that medium, and consequently the less proper vehicle to convey the sound to a distance.

    The objection of situation, therefore, does not apply to this theory; and, accordingly, we shall find that the exercising of bells--though in a way and for an object little contemplated by our theorists--constituted part of the machinery of the complicated ceremonial of those mysterious edifices.

    The truth is, the “Round Towers” of Ireland were not all intended for one and the same use, nor any one of them limited to one single purpose; and this, I presume, will account for the variety in their construction, not less perceptible in their diameters and altitudes than in other characteristic bearings. For I am not to be told that those varieties we observe were nothing more than the capriciousness of taste, when I find that the indulgence of that caprice, in one way, would defeat the very object to which one party would ascribe them, whilst its extension, in a different way, would frustrate the hopes of another set of speculators.

    But what must strike the most cursory as irresistibly convincing that they were not erected all with one view, is the fact of our sometimes finding two of them together in one and the same locality.

    Now, if they were intended as beacons or belfries, would it not be the most wasteful expenditure of time and wealth to erect two of them together on almost the same spot? And when I mention expenditure, perhaps I may be allowed, incidentally, to observe, that, of all species of architecture, this particular form, as it is the most durable, so is it also the most difficult and the most costly.

    Need I name the sum of money which Nelson’s monument has cost in modern times? or that imperfect testimonial in the Phœnix Park which commemorates the glories of the hero of Waterloo.

    No; but I will mention what Herodotus tells us was the purport of an inscription upon one of the pyramids of Egypt, the form of some of which, be it known, was not very dissimilar to our Irish pyramids, while their intent and object were more congenial; viz. that no less a sum than 1600 talents of silver, or about £400,000 of our money, had been expended upon radishes, onions, and garlic alone, for 360,000 men, occupied for twenty years in bringing that stupendous fabric, that combined instrument of religion and science, to completion!

    Our Round Towers, we may well conceive, must have been attended, at the early period of their erection, with comparatively similar expense: and assuredly, the motive which could suggest such an outlay must have been one of corresponding import, of the most vital, paramount, and absorbing consideration.

    Would the receptacles for a bell be of such moment? And that, too, whilst the churches, to which, of course, they must have appertained, were thought worthy of no better materials than temporary hurdles, and so leave behind them no vestiges of their local site,--no evidence or trace of their ever having existed! And, indeed, how could they?--for existence they never had, except in the creative imagination of our hypothetical antiquaries.

    Ruins, it is true, of chapels and dilapidated cathedrals are frequently found in the vicinity of our Round Towers; but these betray in their materials and architecture the stamp of a later age, having been founded by missionaries of the early Christian Church, and purposely thus collocated--contiguous to edifices long before hallowed by a religious use--to at once conciliate the prejudices of those whom they would fain persuade, and divert their adoration to a more purified worship.

    And yet, upon this single circumstance of proximity to ecclesiastical dilapidations--coupled with the bas-relief of a crucifix which presents itself over the door of the Budhist temple of Donoghmore in Ireland, and that of Brechin in Scotland--have the deniers of the antiquity of those venerable memorials raised that superstructure of historical imposture, which, please God, I promise them, will soon crumble round their ears before the indignant effulgence of regenerated veracity.

    It might be sufficient for this purpose, perhaps, to tell them that similar ruins of early Christian churches are to be met with abundantly in the neighbourhood of Cromleachs and Mithratic caves all through the island; and that they might as well, from this vicinity, infer that those two other vestiges of heathenish adoration were contrived by our early Christians as appendages to the chapels, as they would fain make out--by precisely the same mode of inference--that the Round Towers had been!

    But this would not suit; they could find no ascription associated with Christianity which cave or cromleach could subserve; and thus have the poor missionaries escaped the cumbrous imputation of having those colossal pagan slabs and those astounding gentile excavations affiliated upon them.

    Not so fortunate the Towers. After ransacking the whole catalogue of available applications appertaining to the order of monastic institutions with which to Siamise those temples, Montmorency has at last hit upon the noble and dignified department of a “dungeon-keep” or “lock-up!” as the sole use and intention of their original erection!

    As I intend, however, to unravel this fallacy in its proper quarter, I shall resume, for the present, the thread of my discourse.

    Besides the absurdity, then, of bestowing such magnificence upon so really inconsiderable a thing as a belfry, while the supposed churches were doomed to dwindle and moulder in decay, is it not astonishing that we find no vestiges of the like fashion, or structures of the like form, in any of those countries where the people to whom the advocates of this theory ascribe their erection have since and before exercised sway?

    The Danes had dominion in Britain longer and more extensively than they ever had in this island; and yet, in the whole compass of England, from one extremity to the other, is there not one fragment of architecture remaining to sanction the idea of identity or resemblance!

    Nay, in all Denmark and Scandinavia, the original residence of the Ostmen and Danes, there is not a single parallel to be found to those columnar edifices!

    Ireland, on the contrary, exhibits them in every quarter; in districts and baronies where Danish authority was never felt; and surely our forefathers were not so much in love with the usages and habits of their barbarian intruders, as to multiply the number of those stately piles, solely in imitation of such detested taskmasters.

    But what renders it demonstrative that those professional pirates had no manner of connection with the Irish Round Towers, is the glaring fact, that in the two cities of Wexford and Waterford--where their power was absolute, their influence uncontrolled--there is not a solitary structure that could possibly be ascribed to the class of those which we now discuss!

    In Scotland alone, of all European countries besides Ireland, do we meet with two of them,--one at Brechin, and the other at Abernethy;--but they are smaller than the Irish, and, with other characteristics, seem to have been built, after their model, at a comparatively recent period, by a colony from this country, “as if marking the fact,” to use Dalton’s accidentally[46] appropriate phrase, “of that colonisation having taken place when the rites, for which the Round Towers were erected, in the mother-country, were on the decline.”

    But, forsooth, they are called “cloghachd” by the peasantry, and that, without further dispute, fixes their destination as belfries! Oh! seri studiorum quîne difficile putetis?

    That some of them had been appropriated in latter times, nay, and still are, to this purpose, I very readily concede; but, “toto cœlo,” I deny that such had ever entered into the contemplation of their constructors, as I do, also, the universality of the very name, which I myself know, by popular converse, to be but partial in its adoption, extending only to such as had been converted by the moderns to the purpose described, or such as may, originally, have had a clogh, or bell, of which I admit there were some, as part of their apparatus.

    The first bells of which we have any mention are those described by Moses, as attached to the garments of the high-priest. From these, the Gentiles, as they affected to rival the Israelites in all their ceremonies, borrowed the idea, and introduced its exercise into the celebration of their own ritual.

    By “Israelites,” however, I deem it necessary to explain that I do not understand those who, in strictness of speech, are so denominated as the descendants of Israel, i.e. Jacob, who, in fact, were a comparatively modern people; but I particularise that old stock of patriarchal believers which existed from the Creation, and upon which the Israelites, rigidly so called, were afterwards engrafted.

    Our Irish history abounds with proofs of the “ceol,” and “ceolan,” the bell and the little bell, having been used by the pagan priests in the ministry of their religious ordinances; and to the fictitious sanctity which they attributed to this instrument may we ascribe that superstitious regard which the illiterate and uneducated still continue to entertain for the music of its sound.

    From the Sabian ceremonial--succeeded by the Druidical--it unquestionably was that the Christian missionaries in Ireland first adopted the use of bells, wishing, wisely, therein to conform as much as possible to the prejudices of the natives, when they did not essentially interfere with the spirit of their divine mission.

    I shall hereafter relate the astonishment excited in England, at the appearance of one of those bells, brought there in the beginning of the sixth century by Gildas, who had just returned after finishing his education in Ireland; and this, in itself, should satisfy the most incredulous that the Britons, as well pagan as Christian, were ever before strangers to such a sight; and no wonder, for they were strangers also to such things as Round Towers, to which I shall prove those implements properly and exclusively belonged.

    “Clogad” is the name, and which literally signifies a “pyramid,” that has led people into this “belfry” mistake. To conclude, therefore, this portion of our investigation, I shall observe, in Dr.

    Milner’s words, “that none of these towers are large enough for a single bell of a moderate size to swing about in it; that, from the whole of their form and dimensions, and from the smallness of the apertures in them, they are rather calculated to stifle than to transmit to a distance any sound that is made in them; lastly, that though possibly a small bell may have been accidentally put up in one or two of them at some late period, yet we constantly find other belfries, or contrivances for hanging bells, in the churches adjoining to them.”

    I fear greatly I may have bestowed too much pains in dispelling the delusion of this preposterous opinion.

    But as it had been put forward with so much confidence by a much-celebrated “antiquarian,”--though how he merited the designation I confess myself at a loss to know,--I thought it my duty not to content myself with the mere exposure of the fallacy, without following it up with proofs, which must evermore, I trust, encumber its advocates with shame; and the rather, as this great champion of Danish civilisation and proclaimer of his country’s barbarism is at no ordinary trouble to affect ridicule and contempt for a most enlightened and meritorious English officer, who, from the sole suggestion of truth, promoted by observation and antiquarian research, stood forward as the advocate of our ancestral renown, to make amends, as it were, for the aspersions of domestic calumniators.

    Both parties are, however, now appreciated as they ought; and though Vallancey, certainly, did not understand the purport of our Round Towers, his view of them, after all, was not far from being correct; and the laborious industry with which he prosecuted his inquiries, and the disinterested warmth with which he ushered them into light, should shield his memory from every ill-natured sneer, and make every child of Iran feel his grateful debtor.

    Having given Milner a little while ago the opportunity of tolling the death-knell of the belfry hypothesis, I think I could not do better now than give Ledwich, in return, a triumph, by demolishing the symmetry of the anchorite vagary.

    “It must require a warm imagination,” says this writer,--after quoting the account given by Evagrius of Simeon Stylites’ pillar, upon which Richardson, Harris, and Milner after them had founded the anchorite vagary,--“to point out the similarity between this pillar and our ‘tower’: the one was solid, and the other hollow--the one square, and the other circular: the ascetic there was placed without on the pillar; with us enclosed in the tower.

    He adds, these habitations of anchorites were called inclusoria, or arcti inclusorii ergastula, but these were very different from our round towers; for he mistakes Raderus, on whom he depends, and who says, ‘The house of the recluse ought to be of stone, the length and breadth twelve feet, with three windows, one facing the choir, the other opposite, through which food is conveyed to him, and the third for the admission of light--the latter to be always covered with glass or horn.’

    “Harris, speaking of Donchad O’Brien, Abbot of Clonmacnois, who shut himself up in one of these cells, adds, ‘I will not take upon me to affirm that it was in one of these towers of Clonmacnois he was enclosed.’ It must have been the strangest perversion of words and ideas to have attempted it. Is it not astonishing that a reverie thus destitute of truth, and founded on wilful mistakes of the plainest passages, should have been attended to, and even be, for some time, believed?”

    Thus have I allowed him to retaliate in his own words; but in order to render his victory complete, by involving a greater number within his closing denunciation, he should have waited until he had seen a note appended to the fourteenth of Dr. Milner’s Letters, which, unquestionably, would deserve a similar rebuke for its gross perversion of a “cell” into a “tower.”

    It is this: “We learn from St. Bernard, that St. Malachy, afterwards Archbishop of Armagh, in the twelfth century, applied for religious instruction, when a youth, to a holy solitary by name Imarus, who was shut up in a ‘cell,’ near the cathedral of the said city, probably in a Round Tower.” Risum teneatis?

    But I am tired of fencing with shadows and special pleading with casuists.

    And yet, as I would wish to render this Essay systematically complete, I am forced, however reluctant, to notice the conjecture, which others have hazarded, of those Round Towers having been places of retreat and security in the event of invasion from an enemy; or depositories and reservoirs for the records of State, the Church utensils and national treasures!

    To the former, I shall reply, that Stanihurst’s description of the “excubias in castelli vertice,” upon which it would seem to have been founded, does not at all apply to the case; because, while the “castella” have vanished, the Round Towers--which never belonged to them--do, many of them still firmly, maintain their post; and as to the latter, the boldness with which it has been put forward, by its author before named,[47] requires a more lengthened examination than its utter instability could otherwise justify.

    CHAPTER II.

    This chivalrous son of Mars, more conversant, I should hope, with tactics than with literary disquisitions, has started with a position which he is himself, shortly after, the most industrious to contradict; namely, “that the gods, to punish so much vanity and presumption, had consigned to everlasting oblivion the founders, names, dates, periods, and all records relating to them.”[48]

    Surely, if they were intended for the despicable dungeons which the Colonel would persuade us was their origin, there existed neither “vanity” nor “presumption” in that humble design; and when to this we add the nature of that security, which he tells us they were to establish, one would think that this should be a ground for the perpetuity of their registration, rather than for consigning their history to “everlasting oblivion.”

    But secure in the consciousness of the whole history of those structures, and satisfied that truth will never suffer anything by condescending to investigation, I will, to put the reader in full possession of this adversary’s statement, here capitulate his arguments with all the fidelity of an honourable rival.

    His object, then, being to affix the Round Towers to the Christian era, he begins by insisting that, as “the architects of those buildings were consummate masters in masonic art,” it follows, that “a people so admirably skilled in masonry never could have experienced any impediments in building substantial dwellings, strong castles, palaces, or any other structures of public or private conveniency, some fragments of which, however partial and insignificant, would still be likely to appear, in despite of the corroding breath of time or the torch of devastation.”

    His next argument is, “that the busy and fantastic bard, whose occupation led him to interfere in private and public concerns,--who, in truth (he adds) is our oldest and most circumstantial annalist,--on the subject of the Pillar Tower is dumb and silent as the dead”; whence he infers the “non-existence of those Towers during the remote ages of bardic influence,”--“and of their being utterly unknown to them, and to our ancestors, anterior to the reception of the Christian faith.”

    His third proposition is, that as “Strabo, Pomponius Mela, Solinus, Diodorus Siculus, and other writers of antiquity, have represented the condition of Ireland and its inhabitants to be barbarous in their days,--in common with their neighbours the Britons, Gauls, and Germans, to whom the art systematically to manufacture stone had been unknown,--ergo, those barbarians could not be set up as the authors of the Pillar Tower.”

    His fourth premise is, that “wherever we chance to light upon a cromleach, we seldom fail to find near it one of those miserable caves”--and which he has described before as “surpassing in dreariness everything in the imagination of man”;--whereas in the vicinity of the Pillar Tower no such thing is seen, unless some natural or accidental excavation may happen to exist unaccountably in that direction. His inference from which is, that “although the cromleach and the cave do claim, the first a Celtic, the second a Phœnician origin, and happen here to be united, the Pillar Tower, nevertheless, disavows even the most distant connection with either of them.”

    His fifth is a continuation of the foregoing, with an erroneous parallelism, viz. “at Bael Heremon, in India, not far from Mount Lebanon, there stood a temple dedicated to Bael, near to which were many caves, of which one was roomy enough to admit into it four thousand persons.” “The size of those temples,” he adds, “was regulated according to the extent or amount of the local population, being spacious and magnificent in large cities, and small and simple in the inferior towns and villages; but nowhere, nor in any case, do we meet an example of a lofty spiral tower, internally too confined to admit into it at once a dozen bulky persons, denominated a temple.”

    “An edifice,” he resumes, “like the Pillar Tower, might easily serve for a belfry; and there are instances where it has been converted, in modern times, to that use; on the other hand, a temple, properly speaking, gives an idea of a spacious edifice, or of one calculated to accommodate, withinside its walls, a certain congregation of devout people, met to pray.

    Should the building, to answer any partial or private use, be constructed upon a diminutive scale, like the little round temple at Athens,[49] called Demosthenes’, the edifice,” he continues, “in that case, obtains its appropriate shape, yet differing in plan, size, and elevation from the Irish Pillar Tower, to which it cannot, in any one respect, be assimilated.”

    “Moreover,” he says, “the ancients had hardly any round temples.

    Vitruvius barely speaks of two kinds, neither of which bears the slightest resemblance to a tower. Upon the whole,” concludes he, “if we will but bestow a moment’s reflection on the geographical and political condition of primitive Ireland, and the avowed tardy progress towards civilisation and an acquaintance with the fine arts then common to those nations not conveniently placed within the enlightened and enlivening pale of Attic and Roman instruction, it will be impossible not to pronounce Vallancey’s conjectures respecting the Pillar Towers as receptacles for the sacred fire altogether chimerical and fabulous.”

    Before I proceed to demolish, seriatim, this tissue of cobwebs, I wish it to be emphatically laid down that I do not tread in General Vallancey’s footsteps. To his undoubted services, when temperately guarded, I have already paid the tribute of my national gratitude; but, pitying his mistakes, while sick of his contradictions, I have taken the liberty to chalk out my own road.

    Now for Montmorency.

    As to the first, then, of those objections against the antiquity of our Round Towers, it is readily repelled by explaining that, in the early ages of the world, masonic edifices, of architectural precision, were exclusively appropriated, as a mark of deferential homage, to the worship of the Great Architect of the universe; and with this view it was that the science was, at first, studied as a sort of religious mystery, of which there can be required no greater possible corroboration than the circumstance of that ancient and mysterious society who date the existence of their institution from Noah himself--and it is incomparably older--still retaining, amid the thousand changes which the world has since undergone, and the thousand attempts that have been made to explore and explode their secrets, the mystic denominational ligature of “Free and Accepted Masons.”[50]

    The absence, therefore, of any vestiges of other coeval structures, for private abode or public exhibition, should excite in us no surprise; more especially when we recollect that in the East also--whence all our early customs have been derived--their mud-built houses present the greatest possible contrast between the simplicity of their domestic residences and the magnificence and grandeur of their religious conventicles--Verum illi delubra deorum pietate, domos sua gloria decorabant.[51]

    But though this my reply is triumphantly subversive of the Colonel’s first position, I shall dwell upon it a little longer, to hold forth, with merited retaliation, either his disingenuousness or his forgetfulness; because the same inference which he deduced from the non-appearance of coeval architecture of any other class, would apply as well to the period which he wishes to establish as the era of the erection of the Towers,--and of which era, he admits, no other architectural monuments do remain,--as to that which I shall incontrovertibly prove was their proper epoch.

    Then, without having recourse to the impossibility--of which all travellers complain--to ascertain even the situation of those gigantic cities which in other parts of the globe, at equally remote periods of time, were cried up as the wonders of the age--the masterpieces of human genius, making their domes almost kiss the stars; without betaking myself, I say, to those, the only memorials of which are now to be found in that of the echo, which, to your affrighted fancy, asking inquisitively and incredulously, “Where are they?” only repeats responsively, “Where are they?”--passing over this, I tell him that, more highly favoured than other countries, we possess, in Ireland, ample evidences of those remnants which he so vauntingly challenges.

    Traverse the isle in its inviting richness, over its romantic mountains and its fertile valleys, and there is scarcely an old wall you meet, or an old hedge you encounter, that you will not find, embedded among the mass, some solitary specimens of chiselled execution, which, in their proud, aristocratic bearing, afford ocular and eloquent demonstration of their having once occupied a more respectable post.

    Not less futile than the foregoing is his second objection, arising from what he represents as the silence of “the busy and fantastic bard.”

    Doubtless he reckoned upon this as his most impregnable battery; and I readily believe that most of his readers anticipate the same result: but this little book will soon shiver the fallacy of such calculations, and adduce, in its proper place, from the very head and principal of the bardic order--no less a personage than Amergin himself--its towering refutation; as well as the final, incontrovertible appropriation of those structures to their actual founders.

    In the interim, I must not let the opportunity pass of vindicating our ancient bards from the false imputations of “busy and fantastic.”

    If pride of descent be a weakness of Irishmen, it is one in which they are countenanced by all the nations of the globe who have had anything like pretensions to support the claim; and I fearlessly affirm that the more sensitive a people prove themselves of their national renown, their hereditary honour, and ancestral splendour, the more tenacious will they show themselves, in support of that repute,--whether as individuals or a community,--in every cause involving the far higher interests of moral rectitude, of virtue, and of religion.

    In the legitimate indulgence of this honourable emotion the Irish have ever stood conspicuously high. No nation ever attended with more religious zeal to their acts and genealogies, their wars, alliances, and migrations, than they did; and while no people ever excelled them in enterprise or heroism, or the wisdom and administration of their legislative code, so were they surpassed by none in the number and capability of those who could delineate such events, and impart to reality the additional charm of imagery and verse.

    The bards were a set of men exclusively devoted, like the tribe of Levi amongst the Israelites, to the superintendence of those subjects. Their agency in this department was a legitimately recognised and graduate faculty; and, in accuracy of speech, the only one which merited the designation of learned, being attainable only after the most severe novitiate of preliminary study and rigid exercise of all the mental powers.

    The industry and patience bestowed on such a course were not, however, without their reward. In a classical point of view this exhibited itself in the high estimation in which they were held--both amongst foreigners and natives--as poets, as prophets, and as philosophers; while the dignity and emolument attached to their situation, and the distinguished rank assigned them, at the general triennial assemblies of the state at Tara--with the endowments conferred upon them by the monarch and the several provincial kings--were sure to render it, at all times, an object of ambition and pursuit to members of the noblest families throughout the various parts of the realm.

    The moral deportment and personal correctness of those literary sages contributed still further to add to their esteem; and, probably, I could not succeed better, in depicting the almost sanctity of their general behaviour, than by transcribing a stanza descriptive of the qualities which won to them, as a society, the mingled sentiments of veneration and of awe. It is taken from a very ancient Irish poem, and runs thus--

    “Iod na laimh lith gan ghuin,
    Iod na beorl gan ean neamhuib,
    Iod na foghlama gan ean ghes,
    Is iod na lanamh nas.”

    That is--

    “Theirs were the hands free from violence,
    Theirs the mouths free from calumny,
    Theirs the learning without pride,
    And theirs the love free from venery.”

    In later times I admit there was a lamentable degeneracy in the bardic class,--or rather the innumerable pretenders to the assumption of the name; and the “fescennine licentiousness” with which they violated the sanctity of domestic seclusion, in exposing the objects of their private spleen, tended not a little to bring their body into disrepute, and subject them additionally to the salutary restrictions of legislative severity. They were not less extravagant in the lavishment of their fulsome commendations; so that one can hardly avoid drawing a parallel between them and those poetasters, formerly, of Italy, whom Horace so happily describes in those remarkable hexameters, viz.:--

    “Fescinnina per hunc invecta licentia morem,
    Versibus alternis opprobria rustica fudit,
    ... quin etiam lex
    Pœnaque lata malo quæ mallet carmine quenquam,
    Describi.”[52]

    You would imagine the Roman poet was speaking of the Irish bards in the night of their decline; but the description by no means applies to the original institution, whose object it was to perpetuate the history and records of the nation, and preserve its history from the intrusions of barbarism. To this end it was that they met for revision at the senatorial synod; and the importance of this trust it was that procured to their body the many dignities before described, giving them precedence above the aggregate of the community at large, and investing them with an authority little short of royalty.

    Rhyme was the vehicle in which their lucubrations were presented; verse the medium selected for their thoughts. To gain perfection in this accomplishment their fancies were ever on the stretch; while the varieties of metre which they invented for the purpose, and the facility with which they bent them to each application and use, were not the least astonishing part of their arduous avocations, and leave the catalogue of modern measures far away in the shade.

    Music is the sister of poetry, and it is natural to suppose that they went hand in hand here. In all countries, the voice was the original organ of musical sounds. With this they accompanied their extemporaneous hymns; with this they chanted the honours of their heroes. The battle-shout and the solemnity of the hour of sacrifice were the usual scenes for the concerts of our ancestors. Singing the glory of former warriors, the combatant was himself inspired; and while the victim expired on the altar of immolation, the priest sang the praise of the deity he invoked.

    The introduction of the Christian truths gave a new and elevated scope to the genius of the bards. A new enthusiasm kindled up their ardour--a new vitality invigorated their frames; and they who, but the moment before, were most conspicuous in upholding the dogmas of the pagan creed, became now the most distinguished in proclaiming the blessings of the Christian dispensation. Fiech, Amergin, Columba, Finan, etc., are glorious examples of this transmuted zeal.

    About the twelfth or thirteenth centuries, however, a change burst forth for the destinies of this order. Verse ceased to be used in their historical announcements. Prose succeeded, as a more simple narrative; and from that moment the respectability of the bards progressively evaporated.

    The jealousy of the English Government at the martial feeling excited by their effusions, and the intrepid acts of heroism inculcated by their example, if not the actual cause of this national declension, preponderated very largely amongst its component ingredients.

    In the height of the battle, when the war-cry was most loud, and the carnage most severe, those poetic enthusiasts would fling themselves amongst the ranks of the enraged contenders, and determine the victory to whatever party they chose to befriend.

    When, too, under the pressure of an untoward fate, and the disheartening yoke of--what they deemed--a treacherous subjugation, the nobles would seem dispirited at the aspect of circumstances, and all but subscribe to the thraldom of slavery, the bards would rouse the energies of their slumbering patriotism, and, as Tyrtæus used the Spartans, enkindle in their bosoms a passion for war.

    We must not be surprised, therefore, to find in the preamble to some of the acts passed in those times for the suppression of this body of men, the following harsh and deprecating allusions, viz.:--“That those rymors do, by their ditties and rymes made to divers lords and gentlemen in Ireland, in the commendacyon and high praise of extortion, rebellyon, rape, raven, and outhere injustice, encourage those lords and gentlemen rather to follow those vices than to leave them.”

    For two centuries after the invasion of Henry II., the voice of the Muse was but faintly heard in Ireland. The arms of Cromwell and William III. completely swept away her feudal reminiscences. As it was their country’s lustre that inspired the enthusiasm of the bards, so, on the tarnishing of its honour, did they become mute and spiritless. They fell with its fall; and, like the captive Israelites, hanging their untuned harps on the willows, they may be supposed to exclaim in all the vehemence of the royal psalmist--

    “Now while our harps were hanged soe,
    The men whose captives there we lay
    Did on our griefs insulting goe,
    And more to grieve us thus did say:
    You that of musique make such show,
    Come,

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Round Towers of Ireland; or, The History of the Tuath-De-Danaans
    Author
    Henry O'Brien
    Release date
    April 15, 2013 [eBook #42538]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by The Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
    Most recently updated
    October 23, 2024
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    THE ROUND TOWERS OF IRELAND
    
    
    
    
    [Illustration: Henry O’Brien
    
    _Author of “The Round Towers of Ireland.”_]
    
    
    
    
      THE ROUND TOWERS OF IRELAND
      OR
      THE HISTORY OF THE TUATH-DE-DANAANS
    
    
      BY HENRY O’BRIEN
    
    
      A NEW EDITION
    
      _WITH INTRODUCTION, SYNOPSIS, INDEX, ETC._
    
    
      LONDON: W. THACKER & CO., 2 CREED LANE, E.C.
      CALCUTTA: THACKER, SPINK & CO.
      1898
      [_All Rights Reserved_]
    
    
    
    
    _750 Copies only of this Edition have been printed for Sale and the Type
    distributed, of which this is No. 324._
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    
                                                          PAGE
    
      INTRODUCTION                                         vii
    
      SYNOPSIS                                          xxxvii
    
      DEDICATION (FIRST EDITION)                           lxi
    
      PREFACE (FIRST EDITION)                            lxiii
    
      DEDICATION (SECOND EDITION)                        xciii
    
      LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS                                xcv
    
      AUTHOR’S TEXT (SECOND EDITION)                         1
    
      LIST OF THE PRINCIPAL IRISH TOWERS AND CROSSES       525
    
      INDEX                                                529
    
    
    
    
    INTRODUCTION
    
        “When all is dark, who would object to a ray of light, merely because
        of the faulty or flickering medium by which it is transmitted? And if
        those round towers have been hitherto a dark puzzle and a mystery,
        must we scare away O’Brien, because he approaches with a rude and
        unpolished but serviceable lantern?”--_Fraser’s Magazine_ for August
        1835.
    
    
    Henry O’Brien, the most daring and ingenious explorer of that recondite
    mystery, the origin and purpose of Irish Round Towers, was born in 1808.
    On both his father’s and his mother’s side he came of good descent,[1]
    being connected with two of the oldest and most influential families in
    the west of Ireland. At the time of his birth that branch of “the
    O’Briens” to which he belonged were settled in Kerry, where his father
    resided in a wild, mountainous district, known as Iveragh, forming a
    portion of the Marquis of Lansdowne’s Irish estates. That his family were
    in affluent circumstances is improbable, for up to the age of twelve the
    boy’s education seems to have been neglected in a way very uncommon with
    Irish people who are well off. “Though I could then tolerably well express
    myself in English,” he says,[2] referring to this portion of his life,
    “the train of my reflections always ran in Irish. From infancy I spoke
    that tongue; it was to me vernacular. I thought in Irish, I understood in
    Irish, and I composed in Irish”; and again, “I was twelve years of age
    before ever I saw a Testament in any language.” From this unusual neglect,
    coupled with the fact of his becoming a private tutor soon after he had
    settled in London, and an obscure reference to certain “difficulties” at
    the outset of his career as an author, we are probably justified in
    assuming that money was a rather scarce commodity in the paternal home.
    There is, however, reason to suppose that when he had reached the age of
    twelve, or thereabouts, his education was taken in hand, though how, or by
    whom, does not appear. Evidence of his having been sent to school and
    placed under systematic and qualified instruction is not forthcoming. In
    fact, circumstances go to negative that supposition. His acquaintance with
    Greek and Latin authors seems to have been more extensive than accurate,
    and his quotations from them are marked by solecisms which any properly
    taught schoolboy would avoid, but in which the self-educated are prone to
    indulge. It is true that (at p. 481) he describes in terms of unqualified
    praise a “tutor” with whom he commenced the study of the Greek Testament;
    but there is internal evidence in the same passage that such praise was
    not wholly deserved, and that the tutor in question was certainly not the
    person referred to in Father Prout’s statement that O’Brien had been
    “brought up at the feet of the Rev. Charles Boyton.”[3] Mr. Boyton was at
    the time a highly distinguished Fellow of Trinity College, Dublin, who, in
    addition to holding the position of Greek Lecturer at that University, was
    the most eminent mathematical “coach” of his day; and the only connection
    likely to have existed between him and young O’Brien was that of
    college-tutor and undergraduate _in statu pupillari_. The probability is,
    therefore, that any instruction which the boy received at this early
    period of his life was of a very elementary character, and that his
    education was mainly conducted by himself, a probability which is
    certainly not discounted by the wide and promiscuous character of his
    reading. From the outset of his introduction to letters he is known to
    have been an omnivorous reader of all books that came in his way, nor was
    his mode of studying classical authors that by which the scholastic
    proficiency essential to aspirants for success at college examinations is
    usually attained. O’Brien did not resemble the ordinary boy-student, to
    whom Roman or Greek classics represent merely a given quantity of “text”
    possessing certain peculiarities of diction or allusion which have to be
    nicely dissected, analysed, and mastered, but who regards the
    subject-matter of each work as being of very minor importance. On the
    contrary, he manifestly read them as authors, or rather authorities upon
    the subjects with which they respectively dealt, paying, so far as we can
    perceive, little or no attention to the diction or distinctive literary
    character of their writings. The result was what might be expected. If,
    whilst an undergraduate of Dublin University, it be true that he was
    regarded by many of his fellow-students as a prodigy of learning, their
    seniors appear to have been less enthusiastic about his scholarship, for
    we have not been able to discover his name in the college archives.[4]
    Still, from the fact of his having obtained, after he took his degree in
    1831, the appointment of private tutor to the sons of the then Master of
    the Rolls,[5] it is possible that he may have distinguished himself
    previously.
    
    What seems absolutely certain is, that during his stay at the University
    he must have availed himself to the full of opportunities presented by the
    library for which Trinity College is famous. Here, no doubt, he laid the
    foundation of that Oriental learning in which he was second to no Irishman
    of his day, and probably to few Englishmen. It is hardly too much to say
    that in the early part of the century Orientalism was comparatively
    untrodden ground. Sir William Jones had indeed, many years before,
    thoroughly explored this field of knowledge, but the results of his
    splendid labours had not as yet been properly assimilated by the general
    mass of readers, or supplemented to any remarkable extent by other workers
    in the same field. Hence the scope of European knowledge of the East was
    by no means so extensive then as now; and an enthusiastic student thereof,
    which O’Brien undoubtedly was, had it in his power to acquire an almost
    complete mastery of the subject, so far as it was then known. It was one
    peculiarly fitted to his ardent, dreamy, and speculative nature. He read,
    he pondered, he divined, he foresaw. Dark places in the history of his own
    country began to grow clear in the light of this Eastern dawn. Hitherto,
    like so many of his compatriots, he had found no way of accounting for the
    extraordinary contrast between the distinctive superiority of “the Ireland
    that _was_” and the relative obscurity of “the Ireland that _is_.” To
    what, he must apparently have asked himself, was the fact to be
    attributed, that a people who in days of old were admittedly pre-eminent
    in learning and civilisation, should have afterwards lost all claim to
    such distinction; or how was it that, in a land covered with the ruins of
    structures evincing the ripest skill and most fanciful artistic device,
    architecture should have sunk to a level that was almost barbarous? Why
    was it that this decadence did not take place gradually, as one would
    expect, but was plainly the result of a sudden check that stopped the
    erection of such edifices at once and for ever? Why were the materials,
    structure, and conformation of the edifices in question so different from
    those of other ancient buildings found in their immediate neighbourhood?
    Why had their sculptured ornamentation reference to what was unconnected
    with, nay even opposed to, the teachings of that religious faith to which
    its execution was attributed; and why did the peasantry, inheriting the
    tradition of bygone ages, not recognise them as identified with that
    religion? Questions like these are very stimulating to inquisitive young
    souls, which usually become fired with an ambition to solve them; and as
    O’Brien pored over Sir William Jones and _The Asiatic Researches_--not to
    mention his beloved, though decried, Herodotus--it was only natural that
    he should draw certain conclusions from the undoubted affinity that exists
    between the languages, folk-lore, customs, superstitions, and modes of
    thought of his own country and those of the Orient. Similar conclusions
    had forced themselves upon older people who did not possess a tithe of his
    Eastern lore. Moore, that versatile Anacreontic, in his ill-fitting
    disguise of an Edinburgh Reviewer, avowed “That there exist strong traces
    of an Oriental origin in the language, character, and movements of the
    Irish people, no fair inquirer into the subject will be inclined to deny;”
    and it is further instanced by the same reviewer how the famous traveller,
    Bishop Pococke, on visiting Ireland after his return from the East, was
    much struck with “the amazing conformity” he observed between the Irish
    and the Egyptians.[6] From early childhood the questions to which we have
    referred seem to have been present to O’Brien--even from the time when he
    gazed upon the stunted ruin of Bally-Carbery Round Tower, not far from his
    father’s house, and had been told by awestruck peasants that the real name
    of that desolate and unsightly object was _Cathoir Ghall_, or “The Temple
    of Delight” (p. 48). Since then he had seen other and complete round
    towers; had noticed that all were of the same peculiar shape, and possibly
    had detected for himself, or learned from other sources, the existence of
    that phallic analogy upon which he so strongly insists. He must have read
    in Sir William Jones and elsewhere how, in Eastern lands, the idea which
    lay beneath this same analogy formed the basis of a widespread religious
    faith, and was expressed in structures devoted to public worship. His next
    step was, almost inevitably, one of conjecture. If, as the voice of
    national tradition asserted, the round towers are “temples,” and if
    certain analogous associations are connected with them, might they not
    have been temples of a kindred religious belief? Having settled this to
    his own satisfaction, the speculation would naturally rise--How came that
    particular form of belief to prevail in Ireland? Was it native to the
    soil; or if not, by whom was it introduced, and when? His book being
    mainly an answer to these questions, we need not continue to follow the
    various stages by which conjecture may have passed into theory, and theory
    into conviction. With men of O’Brien’s temperament the hypothetical
    interval is rarely of long duration. Before he had assumed the _toga
    virilis_ of a full-fledged graduate, he probably felt confident that in an
    Eastern origin lay the true solution of the mystery of the round towers;
    and the more he studied the subject, the stronger grew his belief. Being
    an ambitious man, too, he had no intention to forego the honour which he
    was persuaded must accrue to the discoverer of this key to a problem that
    had baffled so many generations of inquirers, and longed for an
    opportunity to display his acquisition.
    
    That opportunity soon came. In December 1830, the Royal Irish Academy
    offered the prize of a gold medal and fifty pounds to “the author of an
    approved essay on the Round Towers, in which it is expected that the
    characteristic architectural peculiarities belonging to all those ancient
    buildings now existing shall be noticed, and the uncertainty in which
    their origin and uses are involved be satisfactorily removed.”
    Unfortunately, the advertisement of this offer escaped O’Brien’s notice,
    and he did not join in the competition which it evoked. But on the 21st
    February 1832 the advertisement was repeated, and this time it caught his
    attention. It declared that none of the essays which had been sent in
    “satisfied the conditions of the question,” and extended the period of
    competition for another three months (_i.e._ until 1st June 1832), in the
    alleged hope “of receiving other essays on said subject,” and also for
    allowing the authors of the essays already sent in “to enlarge and improve
    them.” Considering the task that was set, new competitors were thus placed
    at a singular disadvantage--being expected to do in three months what the
    others had been unable to accomplish in two years. With all due respect to
    the Royal Irish Academy, it is difficult to believe that its members can
    have fully realised the nature of their own conditions. There still exist
    some scores of round towers in a more or less perfect state; and they are
    scattered all over Ireland, being situated for the most part in remote and
    not easily accessible places. The work of visiting and inspecting
    these--which was, surely, a necessary preliminary to describing “the
    characteristic architectural peculiarities belonging to all”--would
    require much time, after which candidates must apply themselves to the by
    no means trifling task of dispelling “the uncertainty in which their
    origin and use are involved,” and all within three short months.[7]
    O’Brien was not, however, to be deterred by considerations of time or
    space when confronted with such a chance of winning deathless fame.
    Besides, he was, in one respect at any rate, well equipped for the
    enterprise, having already made up his mind as to the “origin and uses” of
    the Round Towers. That he had examined them all is not to be supposed, nor
    is it at all likely that at his age he could have possessed sufficient
    technical knowledge of architecture, in its historical and scientific
    aspects, to profit much by their inspection. Still, he was probably
    acquainted with whatever had been written on that branch of the subject,
    and had actually made an examination of some towers, which would give him
    a fair general idea of the whole. Moreover, he had a formidable quantity
    of Eastern learning to fall back upon, in which latter respect he would
    have enjoyed an immense advantage over all other possible competitors, if
    his judges had only been qualified to appreciate that learning as it
    deserved. Be his equipment for the enterprise what it might, the
    enthusiastic young Irishman saw no rocks ahead, felt no mistrust, and
    rushed into the fray. “I grappled with the question,” he assures us, “with
    all the ardour of my nature; and, _heaven_ and _earth_, _night_ and _day_,
    _in difficulties and in sorrow_, I laboured until I finished my ‘essay’
    against the appointed hour, when--a brain blow to their (_sc._ the
    Academy’s) expectation--I sent it in--fully satisfied, from the
    consciousness of its imperturbable axioms, that all the powers of error
    and wickedness combined could not withhold from it the suffrage of the
    advertised medal.”[8] The meaning of this passionate reference to malign
    influences in the background will appear later on; as yet, he had no cause
    for misgiving on the subject of fair play, and his overweening
    self-confidence precluded any anticipation of failure. Bad omens seem to
    have attended his venture from the very outset. The Academy had requested
    that each essay should be inscribed with some motto; and it would appear
    that the motto appended to O’Brien’s was “Φωνη εν τη ερεμω” (_sic_[9])--a
    sorry introduction to the notice of learned Academicians.
    
    The heartburnings of suspense, with which most young authors are familiar,
    soon began. Four days after his essay had been sent in, the Academy issued
    a _third_ advertisement, requiring all the essays to be taken back, and
    extending the period of preparation by an additional month, “so as to
    admit of the receiving of other essays on said subject, and for allowing
    the authors of essays already given in to improve and enlarge them.”
    O’Brien afterwards saw fit to attribute this fresh delay to a cause very
    different from that alleged; but just then, being persuaded that his
    triumph was merely postponed, he reconciled himself as best he could to
    the infliction, and calmly waited for apotheosis. Six months more passed
    by--wearily enough, we may be sure; and then, one direful morning, just at
    the close of 1832, came news that the premiums had been adjudged as
    follows:--“£50 and the gold medal to George Petrie, and £20 to Henry
    O’Brien, Esq.”
    
    It may be stated here that an additional premium of £100, which had been
    placed by Lord Cloncurry at the disposal of the Academy, was also awarded
    in its entirety to Mr. Petrie, and that the essay sent in by that
    gentleman was, by order of the Academy, printed in their _Transactions_.
    It further appears that O’Brien’s essay was at first accepted for
    publication in the _Transactions_, but afterwards rejected on the ground
    of having been made too lengthy by the insertion of additional matter,
    though in its most enlarged form it never attained to the dimensions of
    Mr. Petrie’s work, and, presumably, must have been smaller in its original
    than in its present shape. The true reason for its exclusion from the
    _Transactions_ (as will, we think, appear from what follows) was that the
    Academy took offence at the way in which O’Brien received their decision.
    Nor was such resentment to be wondered at. So confidently had our author
    reckoned upon an overwhelming triumph for the revelation which, as we have
    seen, he believed to be not only unprecedented, but given to the world
    with flawless perfection of statement, that the award seems to have almost
    maddened him. Belonging to a race which has never been remarkable for the
    silent endurance of wrongs, he lost no time in giving expression to his
    feelings of disappointment. At first came distant mutterings of the storm
    that was brewing. “On hearing of the decision,” he informs us, “I wrote
    off to the secretary, tendering, in indignant irony, my thanks for their
    adjudication, taking care, however, to tell them that I had expected an
    issue more flattering to my hopes.” This dignified attitude having
    apparently failed to imbue the Academy with a desire to remedy his
    grievance, he flung off the mask of satire, and rushed into downright,
    unmistakable personalities of a kind rarely addressed to august and
    learned associations. He declared that, from information which had come to
    his knowledge, he was prepared to prove “that the Royal Irish Academy, at
    the very moment in which they published their second invitation (_i.e._
    that by which the time for receiving essays was extended to 1st June
    1832), had actually determined to award the gold medal and premium to _one
    of their own Council_.”[10] He then went on to denounce the successful
    essay as “a farrago of anachronisms and historical falsehoods.” He
    prophesied that when both essays were published, and the public given an
    opportunity of seeing “the truth,” in the shape of his own essay, there
    would be a general acclamation of “This alone is right.” He warned the
    Academy that, “though separated from them by a roaring sea” (he was living
    in London at the time), his eye was on their plans, and he demanded from
    them an opportunity for making his _ascription_ of the Round Towers “a
    mathematical demonstration by all the varieties and modes of proof”; and
    further, that upon such demonstration they should at once award _him_ the
    gold medal and premium, “or, if that could not be recalled, an equivalent
    gold medal and premium”--not that, as he is careful to assure them, this
    offer was to be construed as an admission that his original essay was not
    “all-sufficient, all-conclusive, all-illustrative, and all-convincing.” As
    was only to be expected, the reply sent to this challenge ran to the
    effect that, “whatever might be the merits of any additional matter
    supplied to them after the day appointed by advertisement, the Academy
    could not make any alteration or revocation of their award.” Then came
    the rejoinder,--“I do not want them either to ‘alter’ or ‘revoke’ their
    award; but simply to vote me ‘an equivalent gold medal and premium’ for my
    _combined essay_, or, if they prefer, the _new portion_ of it. Should this
    be refused, I will put my cause into the hands of the great God who has
    enlightened me, and make Him the Umpire between me and the Academy.”[11]
    One is not surprised to learn that “no answer was received to this
    communication,” which, as already pointed out, may have afforded one of
    the reasons why the Academy declined to publish the essay in their
    _Transactions_. We may sympathise with O’Brien’s disappointment, and even
    go further in deprecation of the attitude assumed by the Academy; but it
    is impossible to deny that his conduct showed a want of dignity and common
    sense, excusable only on the ground of youth.
    
    As regards the Academy’s decision, assuming that the competition was
    conducted fairly,--and, _a priori_, everything seemed in favour of that
    assumption,--it is not easy to see how it could well have been other than
    it was. With all possible admiration for O’Brien’s talents and learning,
    candour obliges us to own that his essay--taken merely as a literary
    performance--was inferior to that of his rival. Apart from the question as
    to whether his theory was the true one, and that of Dr. Petrie the
    reverse, the Academy were in a manner bound by regard for their own
    dignity, and by the literary standard then prevailing, to withhold the
    meed of their unqualified approval from a composition which violated in so
    many respects the established precedents of literary “form,” not to
    mention the canons of good taste. Besides, O’Brien was, in archæological
    matters, so far in advance of his generation, that a body of elderly
    gentlemen, who simply represented the standard of knowledge prevalent at
    the time, might well be excused for declining to follow him. They had, in
    fact, to decide between the respective merits of two essays,--one of
    which was well put together, conforming, at least in appearance, to the
    stipulated conditions, expressing the most approved views, bearing the
    marks of careful and systematic investigation and of superior technical
    knowledge, also of literary skill much above the average; the other,
    daring, novel, incoherent, propounding views which were not only
    unfamiliar, but even shocking, to grave and reverend seignors, rambling in
    method, deficient in proof, and slipshod in language. Was it not, then,
    almost inevitable that they should have preferred the former? But if one
    has to pronounce upon the way in which the competition was started,
    carried on, and finally decided, we are by no means sure that O’Brien had
    not some reason to complain. First of all, with regard to his charge of
    the Academy having awarded the prize to a member of their own Council, the
    evidence to support it is _primâ facie_ strong. Upon turning to vol. xvi.
    of the _Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy_, we find the names of
    “The Committee of Antiquities of the Council” for the year 1830 (that in
    which the competition was first invited) given as follows:--“Isaac
    D’Olier, LL.D.; Thomas Herbert Orpen, M.D.; Hugh Ferguson, M.D.; Sir
    William Betham; John D’Alton, Esq.; _George Petrie, Esq._; and the Rev.
    Cæsar Otway.” In the next volume of the _Transactions_, extending to 1837,
    the above list is given without any alteration, except that Mr. D’Alton’s
    name is omitted, that of the Dean of St. Patrick’s being substituted. From
    this the inference seems only natural that “George Petrie, Esq.,” was a
    member of the Council (being likewise, as we find, “antiquarian artist to
    the Academy”) at the time when the idea of offering a prize for an essay
    on the Round Towers was first started; that he continued to be a member
    while the competition was in progress, and was actually one when the said
    prize was adjudicated. Next, as to the charge that the Academy had
    predetermined to award the prize to a member of its own Council, we have
    the very compromising letter of the Rev. Mr. Otway (himself a member of
    the Council) to the editor of the _Dublin Penny Journal_, which is cited
    in the Preface to the first edition of this work,[12] coupled with those
    repeated postponements of the date for sending in essays, which O’Brien
    assures us were inexplicable on any other ground than that of giving Mr.
    Petrie time to finish _his_ essay. We are far from contending that the
    reasons adduced in support of both these charges should weigh against the
    high repute which the Royal Irish Academy has always enjoyed from the time
    of its foundation; still, it is impossible to deny that, in the absence of
    all satisfactory explanation,--at least so far as we have been able to
    discover any,--they wear a rather ugly look.
    
    O’Brien was resolved that, as the Academy would not publish his essay, he
    must do so himself; but in the meantime he had been engaged upon a
    translation of Dr. Villanueva’s _Ibernia Phœnicia_, which appeared in
    1833. Personal liking for the author must have been his motive for
    undertaking this task, as his own views do not always harmonise with those
    of the Spanish _savant_; and certain letters which are quoted in the
    “Translator’s Preface” show that the two were very intimate. Having made
    this concession to friendship, he busied himself with the production of an
    enlarged and amended version of his essay. The first edition of this was
    published, early in 1834, by Whittaker & Co. of London, and J. Cumming of
    Dublin. It seems to have met with a ready sale, for a second edition
    appeared during the same year, bearing the imprint of Parbury & Allen,
    London, and J. Cumming, Dublin. Both editions are in octavo, and to
    outward appearance uniform, but differ in some respects. On the title-page
    of the first it is described as the “Prize Essay of the Royal Irish
    Academy, enlarged”--a description omitted in the second. Further, the
    title itself is given as “The Round Towers of Ireland (or the Mysteries of
    Freemasonry, of Sabaism, and of Budhism, for the first time unveiled)”;
    but the words within brackets are absent from the title-page of the
    second. A few corrections, too, appear in the latter edition; but, upon
    the whole, it is not much more carefully edited than the first--the
    curious omission of chapters vii. and xxxii. being common to both. What is
    known in the book-trade as “The Long Preface,” together with an amusingly
    comprehensive “Dedication,” is omitted from the second edition, a much
    more commonplace dedication to the Marquis of Lansdowne (described, of
    course, as “The Mæcenas of his age”) being substituted for the latter. As
    the second, and last, edition is that which had the author’s latest
    revisions, it has been thought advisable to reproduce it in the present
    issue. No interference with its text has been attempted--typography and
    pagination being alike preserved. Nor has anything in the shape of comment
    been inserted. A few supplementary additions to the original work will
    probably not be considered out of place. Together with this Introduction,
    they comprise a “Synopsis,” of which the object is to assist readers in
    following the track of the main argument--not always an easy task in the
    face of the author’s numerous divagations, annotated lists of the
    principal Round Towers and crosses, and an Index to the body of the work.
    
    The reception accorded to the book by those whose verdict was most
    important to its success, was decidedly hostile, and--what must have been
    especially galling to a man like O’Brien--took the shape of ridicule.
    Though it cannot be said that he had given no occasion for the latter, it
    is equally apparent that much of it was owing to ignorance; for there is
    not to be found among all the censorious judgments of those “irresponsible
    reviewers” a single attempt at sterling criticism. They attacked his
    style, and they laughed his theory out of court, but they never resorted
    to anything that deserved to be called refutation; and showed plainly by
    the character of their strictures that they were quite in the dark with
    respect to the nature of the evidence which he adduced in support of his
    statements. It was profanely said of the late Professor Jowett, that
    whatever he did not happen to know was held by him not to be _knowledge_;
    and such was the view which his critics seem to have taken of O’Brien’s
    dependence upon Eastern authorities, with which they themselves were
    unfamiliar. As occasionally happens in Irish affairs, a countryman of his
    own led the attack. In one of the weakest articles that ever appeared in
    the _Edinburgh Review_,[13] Moore, the poet, accused O’Brien of plagiarism
    and other misdeeds. Considering the extent of Moore’s acquaintance with
    Oriental literature, and the character of his mind, it is perhaps not
    surprising that he mistakes the whole drift of O’Brien’s argument, fails
    to perceive the force of those analogies upon which the latter chiefly
    relied, and, in fact, only succeeds in proving his own incapacity as a
    critic. But it is less conceivable that he should seek to overwhelm a
    young aspirant for literary honours, who was of his own nationality, and
    with whom he was on terms of at least nominal friendship, with unfounded
    charges and clumsy ridicule. The secret of this otherwise unaccountable
    severity is disclosed to us by “Father Prout,” in his article on “The
    Rogueries of Tom Moore.” From it we learn that Moore had endeavoured
    unsuccessfully to secure the co-operation of O’Brien in his forthcoming
    History of Ireland, and that, upon the negotiation falling through, a
    “coolness” ensued between the two. As “Father Prout” had the whole
    correspondence laid before him, the story does not rest upon O’Brien’s own
    version of what took place. But, be it reliable or not, there is no
    denying that the poet went out of his way--and out of his depth, too--in
    the effort to crush a young author, who might fairly be supposed to have
    some claim upon his sympathy. The scent which Moore thus struck was
    followed up by the whole critical pack. The _Gentleman’s Magazine_, for
    instance,[14] without attempting anything like serious criticism, quizzed
    O’Brien unmercifully. He committed the fatal indiscretion of sending a
    lengthy, but for him most temperate, reply, in which he is fain to cite
    the _Freemason’s Quarterly Review_ as his solitary backer. The
    _Gentleman’s Magazine_ reserved its answer until he was no more; when, in
    an obituary notice (November 1835), it flung back this retort: “Fondly
    imagining that he was the author of most profound discoveries, and as it
    were the discoverer of a new historical creed, Mr. O’Brien was always in a
    state of the highest excitement; and when his lucubrations were treated
    with ridicule instead of serious refutation, he was acutely
    irritated”--which last observation somehow reminds one of that fastidious
    man-o’-war’s man, who, whether the bo’sun “hit him high or hit him low,”
    took no pleasure in being flogged. In fact, there was no real scholarly
    criticism of the book from any quarter, though its eccentricities of style
    and treatment received due attention. Superficially regarded, indeed, it
    bristled with salient points for attack, and of these the gentlemen of the
    press naturally availed themselves. They described it as “wild and
    extravagant”--and no one could say them nay; but they failed to point out,
    probably because they failed to see, that under this same wildness and
    extravagance lay profound knowledge of a most unusual kind, powerful if
    somewhat erratic reasoning, and the only theory as to the genesis of
    ancient Irish proficiency in the arts of civilisation which is consistent
    with the traditions, customs, superstitions, folk-lore, and antiquities of
    the country.
    
    O’Brien had now settled in London, where such time as could be spared from
    his tutorial duties was spent in the study of his favourite literature. It
    appears that he had at least two works then in contemplation--one a
    Dissertation on the Pyramids, partly written, and the other a Celtic
    Dictionary--which latter project excited the ribaldry, altogether
    unfounded,[15] of certain critics. His health, never strong, was now such
    as to cause some apprehension to his friends; still he was able to share
    the pleasures which London life affords. He went into the fashionable
    world--which, by the way, does not appear to have taken him quite
    seriously, while acknowledging his talents and erudition. The Marquis of
    Lansdowne’s house was open to him; and mainly, no doubt, through the
    influence of that kindly nobleman, he was even presented at Court. The
    military career, for which, as he informs us (p. 130), he had a
    predilection second only to “his love for truth and the rectification of
    his country’s honour,” was no longer an object of ambition; and he may be
    regarded as having resigned himself contentedly to the peaceful avocations
    of a man of letters. Bad health, aggravated by his studious habits, seems
    indeed to have been the only drawback from which he suffered; but although
    this had previously excited the apprehension of his friends, it was
    without any immediate warning that the end came. He had been paying a
    visit to some acquaintances in the suburbs of London; had spent with them
    an evening, during which he displayed his usual cheerfulness and vivacity;
    had retired to rest without any symptoms of indisposition; and the next
    morning was found lifeless in his bed,--death having, to all appearance,
    taken place quite painlessly during sleep. By those who knew him he was
    mourned, and by none more sincerely than the genial “Father Prout,” who
    added the following postscript to his article on “The Rogueries of Tom
    Moore,” already in print when the news of his young friend’s death reached
    him:--
    
        “MEM.--On the 28th of June 1835, died, at The Hermitage, Hanwell,
        Henry O’Brien, author of _The Round Towers of Ireland_. His portrait
        was hung up in the gallery of Regina on the 1st August following; and
        the functionary who exhibits the ‘Literary Characters’ dwelt thus on
        his merits:--
    
        “In the village graveyard of Hanwell (_ad_ viii. _ab urbe lapidem_)
        sleeps the original of yonder sketch.... Some time back we had our
        misgivings that the oil in his flickering lamp of life would soon dry
        up; still we were not prepared to hear of his light being thus
        abruptly extinguished. “One morn we missed him” from the accustomed
        table at the library of the British Museum, where the page of
        antiquity awaited his perusal; “another came--nor yet” was he to be
        seen behind the pile of _Asiatic Researches_, poring over his
        favourite Herodotus, or deep in the Zendavesta. “The next” brought
        tidings of his death. His book on the Round Towers has thrown more
        light on the early history of Ireland, and on the freemasonry of those
        gigantic puzzles, than will ever shine from the cracked pitchers of
        the Royal Irish Academy, or the farthing candle of Tommy Moore.... No
        emblem will mark the sequestered spot where lies the Œdipus of the
        Round Towers riddle--no hieroglyphic.... But ye who wish for monuments
        to his memory, go to his native land, and
        there--_circumspicite!_--Glendalough, Devenish, Clondalkin,
        Inis-Scattery, rear their architectural cylinders; and each proclaims
        to the four winds of heaven ... the name of him who solved the problem
        of 3000 years, and who first disclosed the drift of these
        erections.... Suffice it to add that he fell a victim to the intense
        ardour with which he pursued the antiquarian researches that he
        loved.”
    
    One portion at least of the good Father’s prophecy was amply fulfilled. In
    _Irish Graves in England_, by Michael M’Donagh (_Evening Telegraph
    Reprints_: Dublin, 1888), a chapter on O’Brien contains these words:--
    
        “His grave cannot now be identified in Hanwell churchyard. It was
        never marked by even a rude stone. In the register of burials the
        entry is: ‘No. 526, Henry O’Brien, Hanwell, July 2, years 26. Charles
        Birch, officiating clergyman.’ Tho number of the grave did not help
        towards its identification, and an examination of every stone did not
        result in the discovery of the name of O’Brien.”
    
    So passed out of life a gifted young soul that had just begun to know the
    measure of its strength. Had O’Brien been spared, he might have taken the
    very highest rank among antiquarians and ethnologists; as it is, his fame
    must rest upon a single crude and imperfect work, written in haste, before
    his powers were fully ripe, or his learning properly assimilated. Beyond
    this, and his translation of Villanueva, he may be said to have left no
    trace behind. He had never married, though it is highly improbable that,
    with his ardent temperament, and that almost reverential admiration for
    the sex to which he gives frequent expression in _The Round Towers_, he
    could have reached the age of six-and-twenty heart-whole. From his
    portrait by Maclise (a copy of which forms the frontispiece to this
    volume), he must, one would think, have been a sufficiently personable
    man--though somewhat frail, and looking older than his years--not to have
    wooed in vain. But he has left no hint of a love affair, beyond occasional
    references to a mysterious “sorrow,” which may have been of this nature.
    No stain rests upon his memory; his habits were convivial, but not
    vicious; and he had a great reverence for his own religion, in no way
    weakened by his sympathy with other less perfect aspects of eternal truth.
    It may be said of him that he left the world without having done it any
    harm, and in the firm belief that he had nobly served the cause of human
    enlightenment,--which surely was no bad ending.
    
           *       *       *       *       *
    
    It is one thing to admit the ingenuity, or even the plausibility, of a
    writer’s views, and another to accept them as articles of belief. So far
    from claiming for O’Brien that he has completely solved the mystery of the
    Round Towers, we may even confess a doubt that the latter admits of any
    complete solution. Certain links in the chain of evidence are wanting,
    which, to all appearance, are not likely to be ever supplied. That, for
    instance, the _Tuath-de-danaans_ came from Persia, bringing with them to
    Ireland their arts and their religion, is quite possible; but the absence
    of any reference to such migration in the more ancient Persian historians,
    where we should expect to find it; the want of some adequate explanation
    of the motives which could have led a highly-civilised people, accustomed
    to a luxurious climate, to prefer as their final settlement the bleak
    shores of a remote Atlantic island to the more temperate and, to an
    Eastern eye, more beautiful countries through which they must have passed
    on their way; the all but complete failure to point out the route which
    they followed in their quest of an asylum--these are gaps which require to
    be filled up before most of us will be prepared to accept their Eastern
    genealogy. Still, it must be confessed that O’Brien’s theory rests upon
    other and surer foundations, so far as its essential probability is
    concerned; also, that it is entertaining and suggestive to a degree which
    renders it, if not a profitable, at least a pleasing mental exercise.
    
    _The Origin of the Round Towers_ (the first branch of the question
    proposed by the Royal Irish Academy) is really only part of a much wider
    problem which had long engaged the attention of earnest, capable, and
    industrious archæologists, with whose names the reader of this work is
    likely to become only too familiar. The Round Towers are merely one class
    of more or less elaborate architectural or monumental remains, scattered
    all over Ireland, and bearing unmistakable signs of a very remote
    antiquity.[16] That these remains are inseparably connected in time and
    origin, seems to be proved by the fact that no writer upon the subject of
    the Round Towers had hitherto been able to treat of the latter
    exclusively, without taking into consideration the “crosses” or “temples,”
    or other subdivisions of the whole, and that neither Dr. Petrie nor his
    rival claimed exemption from the same necessity. A great portion of their
    respective works on the Round Towers is devoted, for instance, to a
    consideration of other antiquities; and what is perhaps the most valuable
    part of O’Brien’s,--namely, that upon which his assumption of a _pagan_
    origin chiefly rests,--is the result of investigation into the nature of
    that symbolism for which the sculptured crosses are so remarkable. It
    seemed, in fact, impossible for those who studied the subject carefully to
    resist the conclusion that all these remains belong to a period when
    Ireland was inhabited by a race which differed in many respects from the
    Irish of a later date. In Dr. Petrie’s opinion, that race consisted of the
    early Christian missionaries and their proselytes; in O’Brien’s, it
    belonged to an era far antecedent to Christianity itself; and so far, he
    is at one with the leading authorities who preceded him. Limiting his
    statement to the Round Towers, Dr. Petrie informs us[17] that, up to the
    time at which he undertook to decide the matter, two theories prevailed as
    to the “origin” of these structures: (1) That they were erected by the
    Danes; (2) that they were of Phœnician origin. But O’Brien discards the
    Danes altogether, and only allows a very subordinate part indeed to the
    Phœnicians, namely, that of having, as sea-carriers, assisted to convey
    the _Tuath-de-danaans_ to Ireland. For the grounds upon which Dr. Petrie
    attributes an exclusively Christian origin to the Round Towers inquirers
    must be referred to the body of his work, where they will find it most
    ingeniously, if not quite ingenuously, argued at much length that these
    structures were erected between the fifth and thirteenth centuries of our
    era by Christian founders. An outline of his rival’s argument to the
    contrary is given in the annexed “Synopsis.” The difference between the
    respective methods of the two theorists is very marked, and here the
    advantage does not rest with O’Brien. Petrie is calm, precise,
    authoritative; O’Brien fervid, rambling, and passionately expostulative.
    That the former has failed to prove his case, and that the latter has to
    some extent succeeded in doing so, may, or may not, be the fact; but it
    must be admitted that, if O’Brien was the more successful, he was not the
    more dexterous combatant. It has been frequently, and perhaps not without
    justice, remarked that “Irishmen have a way of _blundering_ upon the
    truth”; and from the eccentric fashion in which he sets about proving his
    contention, some may argue that O’Brien’s success merely affords an
    instance of this national peculiarity. But it would be hardly fair to do
    so in the case of an author who is acknowledged to have prepared himself
    for his task by careful study of the authorities bearing upon its subject,
    and whose “discovery,” as he calls it, is expressly founded on the results
    of that preparation. In this latter respect he presents a marked contrast
    to his somewhat dictatorial rival, who is wont to treat the exercise of
    private judgment by those who happen to differ from himself as a species
    of _lèse-majesté_.[18] On the other hand, O’Brien is always imploring the
    reader to follow his argument step by step. “Here,” he ever seems to be
    urging, “are the plain, unvarnished facts; here, the incontestable
    authorities; with these staring you in the face, surely you cannot think
    of denying that such and such an inference is unavoidable?” His reasons
    may not be always of the best; but, such as they are, he gives them
    freely. Of the two methods, the public, who are usually impressed by
    self-assertion, preferred the former; and “Dr. Petrie’s epoch-making book”
    was by general consent allowed to have “settled the question of the Round
    Towers for ever.” This comforting belief remained undisturbed for more
    than a quarter of a century, when, in the year 1867, a book appeared which
    challenged its infallibility. The author, a Mr. Marcus Keane, seems to
    have started upon an investigation of Irish ruins from sheer curiosity,
    and with a dispassionate intention to see and judge for himself. He was
    certainly not actuated by any wish to decry the merits of Petrie’s work,
    to which he confesses his great obligations, and which he appears to have
    taken at first as his guide. But, having carefully examined bit by bit the
    ancient architecture still remaining in most of the Irish counties, and
    having tested Petrie’s statements by personal investigation on the spot,
    he reluctantly confessed that he had lost faith in the latter. “After much
    consideration,” he declares,[19] “I have been forced to the conclusion ...
    that the generally received theory is not supported by sufficient
    evidence. My conviction of the heathen origin of these ruins has been
    strengthened in proportion to the increased knowledge which I have
    acquired by examination of the ruins themselves.... Not only the Round
    Towers, but also the crosses and stone-roofed churches are entirely of
    heathen origin.” Further, on all essential points he found himself in
    agreement with O’Brien, the difference between them, in respect of the
    particular form of paganism to which those remains owe their existence,
    being so trifling as hardly to merit notice. Of course, we do not
    undertake to say that he is right: the question is one upon which people
    have always differed hitherto, and which will probably be a subject of
    variance until the end of time. But it seems to us that the dispassionate,
    almost reluctant, judgment of this competent, methodical, and eminently
    fair observer, who approached his subject, not when controversy was
    raging, but after a sufficient number of years had elapsed to admit of
    prejudice dying out, is entitled to carry more than ordinary weight, where
    the object is to arrive at a conclusion based upon a study of unvarnished
    facts.
    
    Up to this point the question may be said to have been regarded solely
    from the architectural point of view, which is not the most favourable for
    O’Brien; though, considering his necessarily limited knowledge in that
    respect, he must be admitted to have made out a fairly strong case. It is
    where the argument hinges upon analogies between Irish and Eastern
    symbolism that we have him at his best. Here all the resources of his
    great Oriental learning come into play, and may be said fairly to have
    turned the scale in his favour. Indeed, it is perfectly astonishing,
    considering that his book was written more than sixty years ago, when he
    was himself a mere youth, how nearly it reaches the level attained by
    modern research. In proof of this, it may be as well to refer, by way of
    example, to one of the latest authoritative treatises on the subject of
    Symbolism, that written by Count Goblet D’Alviella[20] (_Hibbert
    Lecturer_ for 1891, and member of the Royal Academy of Belgium), together
    with its learned “Introduction” by Sir George Birdwood, K.C.I.E.; and we
    do so with the less hesitation because, as neither of these writers
    indulges in more than a passing reference to Ireland, no suspicion of a
    wish to strengthen their inferences by making out a pagan origin for Irish
    antiquities can attach to them. The reader who consults these authorities
    will find that they go far to support O’Brien’s interpretation of the
    symbolic ornamentation of Irish towers and crosses; that they perfectly
    coincide with his views on the nature of Sabaic paganism; and generally
    with his theory, that where symbolism of this character is found existing
    in Western lands, it must have been introduced there from an Eastern
    source. A few sentences taken almost at random from the Introduction to
    Count D’Alviella’s work, as well as from the book itself, may be adduced
    in support of this assertion. Thus, having stated that “the religious
    symbols common to the different historical races of mankind have not
    originated independently among them, but have, for the most part, been
    carried from the one to the other in the course of their migrations of
    conquests and commerce”; that “the more notable of these symbols were
    carried over the world in the footsteps of Buddhism”; that they were at
    first but “the obvious ideograph of the phenomena of nature that made the
    deepest impression on Asiatic man”; that the Sabæans were “the Chaldæan
    worshippers of the Host (_Saba_) of Heaven,”[21] it goes on to say:
    “Without doubt, the symbols that have attracted in the highest degree the
    veneration of the multitude have been the representative signs of gods,
    often uncouth and indecent; but what have the gods themselves ever been,
    except the more or less imperfect symbols of the Being transcending all
    definition whom the human conscience has more and more clearly divined
    through and above all these gods?” How, it may be asked, does this differ
    from O’Brien’s description of the nature of that “Budh” who forms the
    central idea around which he groups the minor significances of Irish
    Sabaism? Again we read: “It is sentiment, and, above all, religious
    sentiment, that resorts largely to symbolism; and in order to place itself
    in more intimate communication with the being or abstraction it desires to
    approach. To that end men are everywhere seen either choosing natural or
    artificial objects to remind them of the Great Hidden One.[22]... There
    exists a symbolism so natural that ... it constitutes a feature of
    humanity in a certain phase of development; ... for example, the
    representations of the sun by a disc or radiating face, of the moon by a
    crescent; ... of the generative forces of nature by phallic emblems.”[23]
    Might we not fancy that this was written by O’Brien? Again: “What theories
    have not been built upon the existence of the equilateral cross as an
    object of veneration?... Orthodox writers have protested against the claim
    of attributing a pagan origin to the cross of the Christians, because
    earlier creeds had included cruciform signs in their symbolism. And the
    same objection might be urged against those who seek for Christian
    infiltrations in certain other religions under the pretext that they
    possess the sign of the Redemption.” Is not this O’Brien’s argument in a
    nutshell? Then we have an entire chapter (iv.), entitled “Symbolism and
    Mythology of the Tree,” the substance of which he may be said to have
    anticipated; and so on, all through the book. It is needless to multiply
    quotations; those already given suffice to show that, in its essential
    character, O’Brien’s argument, so far as it relies upon symbolism, is
    corroborated by those in the front rank of modern archæologists.
    
           *       *       *       *       *
    
    It must, however, be confessed that O’Brien is not always so much in
    harmony with modern thought, and that his reasoning from analogies of
    language appears to us, occasionally, neither sound nor ingenuous. Perhaps
    it would be more correct to say that he sometimes, without meaning
    deception, allows enthusiasm to entice him across the line between fact
    and fiction. In this respect he is not, perhaps, less scrupulous than the
    average etymologist; but even admitting the veniality of his offence, it
    seems to us that the philological is the weakest portion of his book. In
    his hands Grimm’s then recently discovered “law of the mutation of
    consonants” was, as we think, too often strained to cover most
    questionable derivations, nor did he shrink, apparently, from coining
    forms of words to suit his purpose. As instances of this we may point to
    his otherwise skilful treatment of the name _Hibernia_ at p. 128, where,
    without any authority that we are aware of, he employs the form νηος for
    υῆσος, evidently with a view to strengthen his case; also, to his
    wonderful evolution of the word _Lingam_, at p. 284. But whilst the reader
    will probably accept his statements on this head with caution, admiration
    of his skill in detecting analogies which only require pointing out to
    secure our assent, cannot be withheld. That he had in him the making of a
    great philologist, is beyond question; and that in course of time, had his
    life been spared, he would have made this branch of his argument really
    formidable, is very probable. Even as it stands, we may be undervaluing
    its merit: philology is not an exact science, and one can rarely be sure
    of one’s ground therein from day to day. But, judging the matter by such
    light as we possess, it seems to us that the least valuable part of
    O’Brien’s book is that upon which he evidently prided himself most: others
    may, possibly on better grounds, be of a different opinion, and we gladly
    leave this portion of the book to speak for itself.
    
           *       *       *       *       *
    
    It may, we think, be said without injustice, that when dealing with that
    part of the question which related to the _uses_ of the Round Towers,
    O’Brien was more successful in upsetting the theories of other people than
    in establishing his own. The purposes for which preceding antiquarians had
    severally claimed that the towers were built are almost endless; but Dr.
    Petrie has summarised the most prominent of them as follows:[24]--(1)
    Fire-temples; (2) places from which to proclaim the Druidical festivals;
    (3) Gnomons, or astronomical observatories; (4) Phallic emblems, or
    Buddhist temples; (5) Anchorite towers, or Stylite columns; (6)
    Penitential prisons; (7) Belfries; (8) Keeps, or Monastic Castles; (9)
    Beacons and Watch-towers. Both he and O’Brien agree in holding that the
    Round Towers were not appropriated to any one of these purposes
    exclusively, though they might have been used for two or more of them. It
    is with regard to the selection of these latter that the authors
    differ--Petrie adopting views (7), (8), (9); O’Brien, view (3), but with
    much reservation; view (4) absolutely, and adding another view of his own,
    namely, that they were sometimes devoted to memorial or sepulchral uses.
    It has been mentioned already that Moore charged him with plagiarism in
    respect of his adoption of view (4); but, like other charges from the same
    quarter, the assertion rests upon unstable grounds. O’Brien made no secret
    of the fact that on many points he shared the views of General Vallancey,
    for whom he invariably expresses respect, and even admiration; but he is
    careful to explain that, where their judgments happen to coincide, it is
    for very different reasons. “I wish it to be emphatically laid down,” he
    says in one place, “that I do not tread in General Vallancey’s
    footsteps.... I have taken the liberty to _chalk out my own road_”; and,
    in another, “Though his perseverance had rendered him (Vallancey) the best
    _Irishian_ of his age, and of many ages before him, yet he has committed
    innumerable blunders.” This goes to show that he was unlikely to adopt any
    theory merely because Vallancey held it; and to have arrived at the same
    conclusion by a wholly different road was surely not “plagiarism.” What is
    more, a reference to the published works of General Vallancey,[25] or even
    to such extracts from them as may be found in Dr. Petrie’s book, will, if
    we are not mistaken, give rise to some doubt of that author having ever
    distinctly maintained the Eastern, or pagan, origin of the Round Towers.
    His views are, however, so nebulous and shifting, that it is difficult to
    say whether he committed himself to any positive theory on the subject.
    Starting with the conjecture that the Round Towers may have been the work
    of “Phœnicians or Indo-Scythians,” he is soon found attributing them to
    certain “African sea-champions,” who, in his opinion, were the “Pheni,”
    being likewise, as he goes on to inform us, “a _Pelasgic_ tribe.” Next, he
    declares that it was the _Fomorians_ who, having conquered Ireland,
    “taught the inhabitants to build Round Towers”; but he afterwards seems to
    discard this theory in favour of a “Danish” origin, and ends, to all
    appearance, by resigning himself to the notion that they may, after all,
    have been built by “Christian” settlers. Nor are his speculations as to
    the _purpose_ of those structures less varied and conflicting. At one time
    he maintains that they were undoubtedly “fire-temples”; at another, that
    they were “belfries”; and yet again, that they were “beacons.” But--what
    is especially remarkable in connection with the charge of plagiarism--he
    never, so far as we can discover, attributes to them a “phallic”
    significance. Upon the whole, then, it seems rather unreasonable to accuse
    anybody of having borrowed theories from an author who practically had
    none; and the probability is that, without having read General Vallancey’s
    works, Moore had, from hearsay, formed a vague general notion of their
    contents, which notion he, in the capacity of an irresponsible and not
    over-scrupulous reviewer, ventured to utilise for paying off old scores.
    Be that as it may, we are not prepared to urge that, upon the evidence,
    O’Brien’s theory as to the phallic emblemism of the Round Towers--whether
    he borrowed it from Vallancey or not[26]--absolutely deserves credence.
    Like his ascription of an Eastern origin to the _Tuath-de-danaans_, it is
    one of those things which, so far as we can see, are incapable of proof.
    Still, it cannot be said that there is any inherent impossibility in the
    notion; in fact, assuming that the Round Towers were built by an Eastern
    colony, there is much in its favour. For, as all who are acquainted with
    our Indian Empire must be well aware, phallic symbols are there regarded
    with a veneration which in its character is entirely free from
    associations that appear to be inseparable from them elsewhere. The East
    and West have taken different views as to the light in which the physical
    agency by which divine creative power has chosen to perpetuate life should
    be regarded; and to the Hindoo mind, for instance, there is nothing
    inconsistent with the highest moral purity in worshipping an idealised
    representation of the generative principle. A similar belief, on O’Brien’s
    showing, prevailed in ancient Persia,--indeed, but for its existence
    there, the Tuath-de-danaans’ immigration into Ireland could hardly have
    taken place,--so that colonisers from that country, if any such
    colonisation ever took place, were likely to have introduced corresponding
    typical representations wherever they settled. Hence the theory of the
    Eastern origin of the Round Towers and that of their phallic significance
    are mutually interdependent. Further than this it is useless to go. The
    probability of either theory is a matter that, if we are not mistaken,
    most readers will determine for themselves, without much respect to
    authority; nor has any author who tries to establish a hypothesis on
    evidence the bearing of which upon the subject is in itself hypothetical,
    a right to complain that this should be so. O’Brien has been in a manner
    forced to rely upon such evidence all through his book, and the latter
    suffers in consequence. To our thinking, those portions of it are usually
    the most convincing where, discarding authority for the most part, he
    relies upon his own native shrewdness. His attack upon the “belfry” theory
    is one instance of this. Another is the way in which he combats
    Montmorency’s notion, that the towers may have been intended as places of
    shelter, for persons or property, from hostile invasion. Almost equally
    effective is his refutation of the hackneyed argument, that because Round
    Towers are usually (not invariably, as some assert) found in the vicinity
    of ecclesiastical buildings, they must necessarily be of Christian origin;
    though here, as in the case of the “belfry” theory, he might, we think,
    have insisted more upon the curious circumstance that Christians should
    have discontinued building them as soon as Christianity was firmly
    established in Ireland, but before the country had been reduced to a
    peaceful or settled condition. If such adjuncts to churches were needed up
    to the thirteenth century, there is nothing in the history of Ireland for
    the next three centuries, at least, which shows that they might have been
    dispensed with. To account for their disappearance by representing it as a
    consequence of the transition from Romanesque to Gothic architecture,
    which took place about the twelfth century, is to beg the whole question;
    for it assumes that the Round Towers are Romanesque--a point on which we
    take leave to think that opinions are much divided, as indeed they appear
    to be upon almost every topic connected with the subject-matter of this
    very remarkable book.
    
    W. H. C.
    
    LONDON, 1897.
    
    
    
    
    SYNOPSIS
    
    
    CHAPTER I
    
    (PP. 1-15)
    
    
    The book opens with a preliminary statement, in general terms, of the
    object which its author has in view. It is to prove that the round towers
    date from a more remote antiquity than that usually assigned to them; that
    they were, in fact, erected long before Christianity reached these
    islands, and even before the date of the Milesian and Scandinavian
    invasions. In support of this view, he contrasts the materials,
    architecture, and costliness of their construction with those of the early
    Christian churches usually found in their vicinity (cf. p. 514), and
    accounts for the contiguity of the latter by stating that the Christian
    missionaries selected, as the sites of their churches, localities
    previously consecrated to religious use, in order that they might thereby
    “conciliate the prejudices of those whom they would fain persuade”; whilst
    he points out that a Christian origin has not been claimed for Cromleachs
    and Mithratic caves, in the vicinity of which ecclesiastical remains
    likewise abound. On the other hand, he insists that the general structure
    and decorative symbolism of the round towers is clearly indicative of
    pagan times and a pagan origin, more especially of that primitive form of
    paganism which, originating in Chaldea, diffused itself eastward until it
    overspread a considerable part of Asia, and which is known as _Sabaism_.
    Dissenting from the theories of his predecessors in the same field of
    inquiry, he rejects the various theories that the round towers were
    intended as “purgatorial columns,” or “beacons,” or “belfries,” or
    “dungeons,” or “anchorite-cells,” or “places of retreat” in the case of
    hostile invasion, or “depositories” for State records, Church utensils, or
    national treasures; and he states as his conviction, based on examination
    of their structure, that it was not the intention of their founders to
    limit their use to any one specific purpose.
    
    
    CHAPTER II
    
    (PP. 16-32)
    
    Following up this line of argument, he attacks Montmorency, who had
    maintained that the founders of the round towers were “primitive Cœnobites
    and bishops, munificently supported in the undertaking by the
    newly-converted kings and toparchs; the builders and architects being
    those monks and pilgrims who, from Greece and Rome, either preceded or
    accompanied the early missionaries of the fifth and sixth centuries.”
    Reserving a detailed refutation of this theory for subsequent chapters, he
    contents himself for the present with showing that it rests upon mere
    assumption, which is not borne out by the evidence adduced in
    corroboration thereof; and exposes the fallacy of Montmorency’s argument,
    that pre-Christian Ireland was in a state of barbarism which precluded the
    possibility of such structures as the round towers being erected by its
    inhabitants. He further deals with the objections, that the bards do not
    allude to these towers as existent in their time, that those undoubtedly
    ancient excavations, the Mithratic caves, are never found in the vicinity
    of round towers, and that the limited nature of their accommodation made
    them serviceable only for some such purpose as that of a belfry or
    dungeon. With Vallancey’s views he finds himself more in sympathy, but is
    unable to adopt them unreservedly--preferring, as he puts it, to chalk out
    his own road.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Round Towers of Ireland; or, The History of the Tuath-De-Danaans
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Round Towers of Ireland; or, The History of the Tuath-De-Danaans
    
    Author: Henry O'Brien
    
    
            
    Release date: April 15, 2013 [eBook #42538]
                    Most recently updated: October 23, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42538
    
    Credits: Produced by The Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
            http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images
            generously made available by The Internet Archive.)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #42538. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 42538
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.