Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Rise of the Mediaeval Church
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 41910

The Rise of the Mediaeval Church

by Alexander Clarence Flick · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2013
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    The Rise of the Mediaeval Church by Alexander Clarence Flick is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #41910). A few typographical errors have been corrected. A complete list as well as other notes follows the text.

    PREFACE

    The educational value of any subject depends primarily upon its own intrinsic value. The teaching of Church history for ten years as a regular course in liberal arts, side by side with the "orthodox" courses in history, has demonstrated beyond question that this subject can be made at once very popular and very valuable. It has proved its right to exist as a cultural subject. Yet the lack of intelligent information, even among educated people, concerning the history of the Christian Church, both in early and modern days, is simply appalling.

    The comparatively recent revival of interest in Church history has given birth to many general Church histories from English and American scholars. Numerous translations of discriminating and painstaking German authors are also available. A large number of intensive monographs has likewise appeared. But all these texts are written for classes in theological schools. Not a single Church history suitable either for regular college work, or for popular reading, is available; and yet all the standard courses in history are provided with up-to-date texts and illustrative material.

    This work is intended to meet the need I have felt in my own classes, and have heard expressed from fellow teachers and laymen, for a simple account of the evolution of the old Church minus all theological and dogmatic discussions. The purpose has been to show the origin of the Christian Church, its development in organisation, the forces which produced the Papacy, and the marvellous, formative influence of the Roman Church upon the civilisation of Western Europe. To that end the principal lines of development are emphasised at every point, while the subordinate influences have been minimised. Causes and results, continuity and differentiation, and unity have been constantly kept in mind.

    The subject-matter of this volume was worked out during a prolonged residence in Europe. Most of that time was spent in Germany under the inspiration of the foremost authorities in Church history, among whom may be mentioned Professor Nippold of Jena, Professor Loofs of Halle, Professor Hauck of Leipzig, and particularly Professor Harnack of Berlin. The work of the lecture-room and seminar was supplemented by investigation in the Royal Library of Berlin, the Vatican Library at Rome, the National Library at Paris, and the Library of the British Museum. The materials thus gathered were further organised and elaborated in a course of lectures on Church history given in Syracuse University.

    The references in the text and the bibliographies at the end of chapters are given, so far as possible, to English sources. It is believed that the exclusion of a pedantic list of foreign works will make the work more useful. It is hoped that the student will be induced to go to the library, the laboratory of the historian, and there by extensive and intensive reading supplement the text.

    Should this volume prove to be of service, it will be followed by two companion volumes--one on the Reformation and another on the modern Church. It is further planned to publish a source-book on Church history to supplement the texts.

    My indebtedness to books and men is so great that it would be impossible to enumerate them here. While all sources have been laid under tribute, special obligation is felt to many monographs and intensive studies.

    ALEXANDER C. FLICK.

    SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY.

    CONTENTS

    PAGE

    CHAPTER I

    THE STUDY OF CHURCH HISTORY 1

    OUTLINE: I.--Present status of history in college work.
    II.--Ecclesiastical history excluded since the Reformation by
    political history. III.--New view of the Mediæval Church and
    its influence. IV.--Renaissance of interest in Church history.
    V.--Pedagogical value and treatment of Church history.
    VI.--Sources.

    CHAPTER II

    GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY ON CHURCH HISTORY 12

    OUTLINE: I.--Primary materials. II.--Secondary materials.
    III.--Sketch of the writing of Church history. IV.--Most
    important collections of primary sources. V.--Most important
    general Church histories. VI.--Dictionaries and encyclopedias.
    VII.--Atlases and chronologies. VIII.--Text-books.
    IX.--Sources.

    CHAPTER III

    PREPARATION OF THE CIVILISED WORLD FOR THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH 40

    OUTLINE: I.--The ancient world. II.--Condition of the
    civilised world at the time Jesus came. III.--How the
    condition of the world prepared the way for Christianity.
    IV.--Sources.

    CHAPTER IV

    ORIGIN, SPREAD, AND ORGANISATION OF THE CHURCH DURING THE

    APOSTOLIC AGE 52

    OUTLINE: I.--Origin of the Christian Church. II.--Spread of
    the Apostolic Church. III.--Organisation of the Early Church.
    IV.--Conclusions. V.--Sources.

    CHAPTER V

    THE ROMAN CHURCH AND PETER'S PRIMACY 71

    OUTLINE: I.--Planting of the Church in Rome and its
    organisation there. II.--The two opposing views of the Petrine
    theory. III.--Proofs advanced for the Petrine theory.
    IV.--Evidence given against the Petrine theory. V.--Historical
    conclusions. VI.--Sources.

    CHAPTER VI

    THE ROMAN GOVERNMENT'S TREATMENT OF THE CHRISTIANS 91

    OUTLINE: I.--Religious persecutions before the Christian era.
    II.--Christians first persecuted by the Jews. III.--Causes and
    motives of persecution by the Roman government. IV.--Number
    and general character of the persecutions. V.--Results of
    persecutions. VI.--Sources.

    CHAPTER VII

    TRANSITION OF THE CHURCH UNDER CONSTANTINE 112

    OUTLINE: I.--Condition of the Empire in 300. II.--How
    Constantine became Emperor. III.--Constantine's conversion to
    Christianity. IV.--Constantine's favours to Christianity.
    V.--Constantine's character. VI.--Constantine's historical
    significance. VII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER VIII

    THE COUNCIL OF NICÆA AND ITS RESULTS 131

    OUTLINE: I.--Diversion of Christian thought in the early
    Church. II.--The Arian controversy. III.--The Council of Nicæa
    and its actions. IV.--Later history of Arianism. V.--Sources.

    CHAPTER IX

    RISE OF THE PAPACY 148

    OUTLINE: I.--Favourable conditions when the Christian era
    began. II.--Forces at work up to 313. III.--Description of the
    Roman Church in 313. IV.--Growth of the Papacy from 313 to
    604. V.--Condition of the Papacy at the close of this period,
    604. VI.--Sources.

    CHAPTER X

    RISE OF THE PAPACY (Continued) 164

    CHAPTER XI

    MONASTICISM 198

    OUTLINE: I.--Importance of the institution of monasticism.
    II.--Antecedents and analogies. III.--Causes of the origin of
    Christian monasticism. IV.--Evolution of Christian
    monasticism. V.--Spread of group monasticism from the East to
    the West. VI.--Development of monasticism in Western Europe.
    VII.--Opposition to monasticism. VIII.--Results and influences
    of monasticism. IX.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XII

    SPREAD OF THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH OVER EUROPE 229

    OUTLINE: I.--Extent of Christianity under Gregory the Great.
    II.--Character of missionary work from the sixth to the tenth
    century. III.--Conversion of the British Isles.
    IV.--Conversion of the Franks. V.--Conversion of the Germans.
    VI.--Conversion of Scandinavia. VII.--Planting of the Church
    among the Slavs. VIII.--Efforts to convert the Mohammedans.
    IX.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XIII

    SEPARATION OF THE ROMAN AND GREEK CHURCHES 265

    OUTLINE: I.--Relation of the Greek and Roman Churches before
    325. II.--Effect of the Arian Controversy on the situation.
    III.--The history of image worship. IV.--Character and results
    of the Iconoclastic Controversy. V.--Final separation.
    VI.--Resemblances and differences between the two churches.
    VII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XIV

    RELATION OF THE CHURCH AND STATE UP TO THE DISSOLUTION OF THE

    CAROLINGIAN EMPIRE 289

    OUTLINE: I.--Church and state before Constantine. II.--Church
    and state from Constantine to 476. III.--Period of the
    Ostrogothic rule (476-552). IV.--Reunion of Italy with the
    Eastern Empire. V.--Alliance between the Papacy and the
    Franks. VI.--Restoration of the Empire in the West in 800.
    VII.--Effect of the rise of national states on the Church.
    VIII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XV

    THE PSEUDO-ISIDORIAN DECRETALS AND THE PAPAL CONSTITUTION 326

    OUTLINE: I.--What were the Pseudo-Isidorian Decretals?
    II.--Condition of Europe when the Decretals appeared.
    III.--Purpose of the forgery. IV.--Character and composition.
    V.--Time, place, and personality of authorship.
    VI.--Significance and results. VII.--Nicholas I. and papal
    supremacy. VIII.--Decline of spirituality in the Church.
    IX.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XVI

    ORGANISATION, LIFE, AND INSTITUTIONS OF THE CHURCH, SIXTH TO

    NINTH CENTURY 347

    OUTLINE: I.--Organisation of the papal hierarchy. II.--Moral
    condition of the clergy and laity. III.--Great activity and
    wide influence of the Church. IV.--The ordeals and the Church.
    V.--Church discipline: excommunication and interdict, and
    penance. VI.--Worship; the mass; preaching; hymns. VII.--The
    sacraments. VIII.--Relics and saints. IX.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XVII

    THE HOLY ROMAN EMPIRE AND THE PAPACY 384

    OUTLINE: I.--Decline of the Empire under the later Carolingians.
    II.--Preparations to restore the Empire on a German basis.
    III.--Otto the Great creates the Holy Roman Empire. IV.--Holy
    Roman Empire attains its height under Henry III. V.--Results
    of the creation of the Holy Roman Empire. VI.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XVIII

    PREPARATIONS FOR THE HILDEBRANDINE REFORMATION 418

    OUTLINE: I.--Decline of the Papacy after Nicholas I.
    (858-867). II.--Reform efforts before the time of Hildebrand.
    III.--The youth and education of Hildebrand. IV.--The
    Hildebrandine Popes. V.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XIX

    GREGORY VII. AND HIS WORK 445

    OUTLINE: I.--Condition of the Church in 1073. II.--Election of
    Hildebrand as Pope. III.--Gregory VII.'s matured papal theory
    and reform ideas. IV.--His efforts to realise his ideals.
    V.--The investiture strife. VI.--Conclusions. VII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XX

    THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE CRUSADES 476

    OUTLINE: I.--The rise and spread of Mohammedanism.
    II.--Positive and negative causes of the Crusades.
    III.--Character and description of the Crusades. IV.--Results
    and influences of the Crusades. V.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XXI

    RISE OF THE MENDICANT ORDERS IN THE CHURCH 510

    OUTLINE: I.--Monasticism before the Crusades. II.--Effect of
    the Crusades on monasticism. III.--Origin of the begging
    orders. IV.--Rise and influence of the Dominicans. V.--Origin
    and power of the Franciscans. VI.--Wide-spread results of
    mediæval monasticism. VII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XXII

    INNOCENT III. AND THE CHURCH AT ITS HEIGHT 544

    OUTLINE: I.--Antecedent preparation for this period.
    II.--Career of Innocent III. up to 1198. III.--Innocent III.'s
    plans and ideals as Pope. IV.--Condition of Europe at the
    close of the twelfth century. V.--Innocent III. makes himself
    the political head of Europe. VI.--Innocent III.'s efforts to
    root out heresy and reform the Church. VII.--Innocent III.'s
    character and the general results of his pontificate.
    VIII.--Sources.

    CHAPTER XXIII

    THE MEDIÆVAL CHURCH AT ITS HEIGHT 569

    OUTLINE: I.--Characteristics of the thirteenth century.
    II.--Territorial extent and wealth of the Church.
    III.--Organisation of the papal hierarchy completed. IV.--The
    legal system of the Church. V.--The official language and
    ritual of the Church. VI.--The sacramental system. VII.--The
    employment of art. VIII.--The Church moulded the civilisation
    of Europe. IX.--Sources.

    INDEX 607

    THE RISE OF THE MEDIÆVAL CHURCH

    CHAPTER I

    THE STUDY OF CHURCH HISTORY[1:1]

    OUTLINE: I.--Present status of history in college work.
    II.--Ecclesiastical history excluded since the Reformation by
    political history. III.--New view of the mediæval Church and
    its influence. IV.--Renaissance of interest in Church history.
    V.--Pedagogical value and treatment of Church history.
    VI.--Sources.

    Half a century ago a prominent educator observed: "There is something remarkable in the actual condition of the study of Church history. While it seems to be receiving more and more cultivation from a few of us, it fails to command the attention of the educated public in the same proportion.

    We are strongly of the opinion that beyond the requisitions of academical and professional examination there is very little reading of Church history in any way."[1:2] Only twenty-five years ago Professor Emerton, upon taking the chair of ecclesiastical history in Harvard University, could say with truth: "There are to-day not more than half a dozen colleges in the country where any adequate provision for an independent department of history has been made."[2:1] At the present time, happily, the condition so much deplored in the last quotation has been remedied to a very large degree.

    Every great university in America has a well-organised faculty of history and allied subjects, while a large majority of the smaller institutions of higher education have regularly organised departments of history with instructors, well-trained at home or abroad, who devote all their time to the subject.

    But, notwithstanding these facts, the statement made about Church history still remains essentially true. The political, industrial, educational, and social sides of history have been emphasised by the creation of new departments with new courses of study, and by the writing of many text-books, monographs, and general treatises.

    Professorships of sociology, political economy, political science, constitutional law, education, and literature have been created in unprecedented numbers. Ecclesiastical history, on the contrary, has been all but ignored. Even in Germany, where the greatest strides have been made in the subject, it is still relegated to the theological faculty, though the number of philosophical students selecting it often exceeds that of the theological--a very significant fact. In America it would be difficult to point out more than a very few universities or colleges where a chair in Church history is put on an equality with chairs of other branches of history or of correlated subjects.

    Its proper place, in both scholastic and popular estimation, is in the theological seminary, and there it has always remained as a "professional" study.

    Even in this restricted sense, however, its intrinsic worth has placed it among the most important courses in the curriculum, and has given it a standing beyond "professional" circles. Some of America's greatest scholars have contributed powerfully, through the class-room, lectures, and books, to give Church history its rightful place both as a "professional" and as a "liberal" branch of learning.

    Until Luther led the great reformatory schism in the sixteenth century, all historians, crude and unscientific though much of their work was, recognised the necessary union of political and ecclesiastical history.

    The Venerable Bede began his celebrated history not with the coming of Abbot Augustine and his monks, but with the landing of Cæsar and his Roman cohorts. As modern civilisation crept over western Europe and crossed the mighty deep to Columbia's shores, carrying with it the revolutionising Teutonic conception of the national state with its new duties and relationships, the tendency was to magnify the political and social sides of history at the expense of the religious.

    The hatreds and misunderstandings of the Reformation, though doing something to rectify the "orthodox" history of the old Church, really put members of the old organisation wholly on the defensive, and checked for centuries anything like a genuinely sympathetic and scientific study of the old Church by Protestant historians. With Neander, that sympathetic Christian of Jewish descent, and the scholarly Gieseler, a new era opened. The growing doctrine of the separation of Church and state accentuated the breach between political and religious history.

    The early crude conception of specialisation also separated sacred from profane history, and turned the former over wholly to the theologian. Secular historians took the position of Napoleon when invited to enter the Holy City: "Jerusalem does not enter into the line of my operations."

    At last the Church historian and the civic historian have joined hands, and look each other in the face. They see that their aim is essentially common: to know the truth about the past. This search for truth for its own sake is purely modern--almost contemporaneous. Formerly, history was written to justify or disprove some theory of political or ecclesiastical polity, or to glorify some dynasty, sect, party, or hero, or to vindicate some hypothesis or set of ideas. The historian was not a searcher for truth, but a lawyer with a cause to plead.

    It is generally realised now that the historian, whether he deals with the state, the Church, society, education, or industry, is working an important part of the field of general history. A knowledge of each one of these institutions is necessary to supplement and explain any or all of the others.

    This institutional interdependence seems to be generally recognised now. "The web of history," said Professor Hatch in beginning his great work at Oxford, "is woven of one piece; it reflects the unity of human life, of which it is the record. We cannot isolate any group of facts and consider that no links of causation connect them with their predecessors or their contemporaries.

    Just as Professor Freeman insists on the continuity of history, so I wish to insist on its solidarity."[4:1] The mutual labours of scholars in correlating fields have revolutionised our historical knowledge of the early and later Middle Ages. A multitude of controverted points have vanished like ghosts. We see the old Church now as we never saw it before. The Catholic Church and the mediæval papacy were the greatest of the creations of the first fifteen centuries of the Christian era. The mediæval Church was not exclusively a religious organisation.

    It was more of an ecclesiastical state. It had laws, lawyers, courts, and prisons. If not born into it, all the people of western Europe were at least baptised into it. It levied taxes on its subjects. Standards of patriotism and treason were more sharply defined than in the modern state.[5:1] The evolution of this great organisation is the central fact of the first thirteen centuries after Christ. It aimed to control the whole life of its subjects here and to determine their destiny hereafter. Well may our greatest American Church historian, Henry C.

    Lea, ask: "What would have been the condition of the world if that organisation had not succeeded in bearing the ark of Christianity through the wilderness of the first fifteen centuries?"[5:2]

    The history of Europe, then, after the Roman period must be looked at through the eyes of the Church. The character and works of that great institution must first be studied, not pathologically but sympathetically.

    The historian, if honest, dare not show a "lack of appreciation of the service rendered to humanity by the organisation which in all ages has assumed for itself the monopoly of the heritage of Christ."[5:3] He must recognise the fact that "ecclesiastical history is simply the spiritual side of universal history."[6:1] "The value of a science depends on its own intrinsic merits," says Alzog.[6:2] When the great Teacher commanded from the Mount of Olives, "Go ye into all the world and preach the gospel," that mount became the pivot on which the whole world's history has turned.

    If the Christian religion be a matter, not of mint, anise, and
    cummin, but of justice, mercy, and truth; if the Christian
    religion be not a priestly caste, or a monastic order, or a
    little sect, or a handful of opinions, but the whole
    congregation of faithful men dispersed throughout the world;
    if the very word which of old represented the chosen "people"
    is now to be found in the "laity"; if the biblical usage of
    the phrase "ecclesia" literally justifies Tertullian's
    definition: Ubi tres sunt laici, ibi est ecclesia; then the
    range of the history of the Church is as wide as the range of
    the world which it was designed to penetrate.[6:3]

    The great difficulty with the study of Church history in the past has been that teachers treated it wholly from a theological standpoint. That may have been proper when the subject was viewed as a narrow "professional" study only. A new and better conception of the subject, however, as a part of the pregnant history of humanity, has brought with it a higher estimation of its value as a cultural study.

    All that can be claimed for historical studies in general can be claimed for it: mental discipline, broad culture, a view of practical life, enlarged sympathies and lessened prejudices, a truer conception of duty, and a saner estimate of the significance of current events. In addition it may be ventured that no subject can be of greater vital importance to the student for the very reason that it deals with the most important of all subjects.

    In order to do the most good as a liberal branch of learning, Church history must be taught not as theology or dogma, but as a powerful civilising institution like the state or the school.

    Then it will be true that "neither can the profane historian, the jurist, the statesman, the man of letters, the artist, nor the philosopher safely neglect the study of Church history."[7:1] For each one of these persons, as well as the minister, needs that "pragmatic view" of all the changes and developments of the Christian Church and the influence it has exerted on all other human relations.[7:2]

    Within the last few years, however, there has been a noticeable awakening of interest in Church history both within and without college walls. The indefatigable labours of a few men like Henry C. Lea, who has given us a series of invaluable monographs on the history of the old Church, have had much to do with the new status of Church history.

    Universities are already recognising courses in Church history offered by divinity schools as "liberal arts" electives for undergraduate and postgraduate study.

    The writers of recent text-books on general history, as well as in particular fields, recognise the revolution and try to make amends for the sin of omission by giving the Church a prominence never recognised before by secular historians.[7:3] Publishers have felt the popular pulse and, consequently, "Studies" and "Epochs" covering the whole range of Church history have appeared in cheap and popular form from the pen of scholar and compiler. Foreign works have been translated. Journals devoted to the study of Church history have been established.

    Lectureships have been created and endowed. Societies have been organised to further the work. Convenient editions of the "sources" are appearing. Everywhere there seems to be a reaction in favour of this misunderstood and neglected subject. An army of scholars is at work digging valuable material out of old monasteries, royal archives, private libraries, cemeteries and churches, catacombs, and every conceivable place of concealment.

    These labours are being rewarded by rich discoveries of valuable materials, which are immediately critically edited by competent hands and printed in translations suitable for all students. Huge collections of these sources are appearing in most of the European countries.[8:1]

    The most significant evidence of reaction, however, lies in the fact that the most recent courses offered on the Middle Ages in our leading universities are essentially courses in Church history. The name matters little so long as students approach the instructive history of western Europe from the right standpoint. Thus, at length, has come the fulfilment of the prophecy of Professor Koethe (d. 1850), made many years ago: "It is reserved to future ages, and in a special sense to the institutions of learning, to give to Church history its proper place in the curriculum of studies.

    When its nature and importance come to be fully known and appreciated it will be no longer limited to one faculty."

    The best pedagogical methods must be applied to Church history in order to obtain the best results. To that end these practical suggestions are offered:

    1. Emphasis ought to be laid on ideas back of events rather than on the

    events themselves.

    1. The important ought to be distinguished from the unimportant at every

    step. Athanasius and Augustine are worthier subjects of study than Flavian and Optatus. The invasion and conversion of the Teutons are more important than disputes over Easter or the shape of the tonsure.

    1. Original sources ought to be used so far as possible. History should

    be studied "from the sources of friend and foe, in the spirit of truth and love, sine ira et studio."[9:1]

    1. Both Protestant and Catholic secondary authorities ought to be read

    on every important controverted point.

    1. Origins ought to be studied with special care.
    1. Transition periods rather than crises ought to be given the most

    time.

    1. Biographies of epoch-making men like Constantine, Gregory the Great,

    Charlemagne, Hildebrand, St. Francis, Innocent III., etc., ought to be carefully considered.

    1. Causes and results ought to be closely worked out and

    classified.[9:2]

    1. The continuity of the Church as a great force in the world ought to

    be ever kept in mind.[9:3]

    1. Differentiation ought to be thoughtfully noted through the ages.
    1. The unity of history--the influence of the Church upon every other

    institution--ought to be followed from one transitional period to another.

    1. The sympathetic attitude ought to be taken at all times in judging

    men and movements. The student ought to stand in the centre of the circle so that he may see all points of the circumference--all persons, all events, all parties, all creeds, all sects, all shades of opinion--and see their true historical relations.

    SOURCES

    1.--Bright, W., The Study of Church History. In Waymarks of
    Church History
    . N. Y., 1894.

    2.--Cave, A., Introduction to the Study of Theology. Edinb.,
    1885, 421 ff.

    3.--Collins, W. E., The Study of Ecclesiastical History. N.
    Y., 1903.

    4.--Coxe, A. C., Institutes of Christian History. Chicago,
    1887.

    5.--De Witt, J., Church History as a Science, as a Theological
    Discipline, and as a Mode of the Gospel
    . Cinc., 1883.

    6.--Foster, F. H., The Seminary Method of Original Study in the
    Historical Sciences
    . N. Y., 1888.

    7.--Gwatkin, H. M., The Meaning of Ecclesiastical History.
    Camb., 1891.

    8.--Hatch, E., An Introductory Lecture on the Study of
    Ecclesiastical History
    . Lond., 1885.

    9.--Hitchcock, R. D. The True Idea and Uses of Church History.
    N. Y., 1856.

    10.--Jortin, J., The Use and Importance of Ecclesiastical
    History
    . Works, vii., 405-454. Lond., 1772.

    11.--Lea, H. C., Studies in Church History. Introd. Phil.,
    1869.

    12.--McGiffert, A. C., "The Historical Study of Christianity."
    Bibliotheca Sacra, Jan., 1893, 150-171.

    13.--Robinson, J. H., Sacred and Profane History. In An. Rep.
    Am. Hist. Assn.
    1899, i., 527.

    14.--Smith, H. B., "Nature and Worth of the Science of Church
    History." Bibliotheca Sacra, vol. vii., 1851, 412. See
    Faith and Philosophy, Edinb. and N. Y., 1877, 49-86.

    15.--Smyth, E. C., Value of the Study of Church History in
    Ministerial Education
    . Andover, 1874.

    16.--Stanley, A. P., Three Introductory Lectures on the Study of
    Ecclesiastical History
    . In History of the Eastern
    Church
    . Lond. and N. Y., 1884, 17-76.

    See the introductions of the Church histories of Schaff, Gieseler, Alzog, Moeller, Kurtz, Hase, Döllinger, and Hergenröther.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [1:1] Reprinted from The Methodist Review, Jan., 1905.

    [1:2] Bib. Rep., vol. xxvi.

    [2:1] Unit. Rev., vol. xix.

    [4:1] Hatch, An Introductory Lecture on the Study of Ecclesiastical History, London, 1885. Comp. Gwatkin, The Meaning of Ecclesiastical History, Cambridge, 1891.

    [5:1] Maitland, Canon Law in the Church of England, London, 1898, 100, 101.

    [5:2] Lea, Studies in Church History, p. iii.

    [5:3] Ibid.

    [6:1] Gwatkin, The Meaning of Ecclesiastical History, 8.

    [6:2] Alzog, Universal Church History, i., § 13.

    [6:3] Stanley, Eastern Church, Introduction, 25.

    [7:1] Alzog, i., 32.

    [7:2] Gieseler, Ecclesiastical History, sec. 3 and 7.

    [7:3] Examine recently published texts like Emerton, Mediæval Europe, Robinson, History of Western Europe, Munro, A History of the Middle Ages, etc.

    [8:1] The Monumenta in Germany, the Rolls Series in England, etc.

    [9:1] Schaff, Church History, preface.

    [9:2] Mace, Method in History, 27-39.

    [9:3] Freeman, Methods of Historical Study, Lond. and N. Y., 1886.

    CHAPTER II

    GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY ON CHURCH HISTORY

    OUTLINE: I.--Primary materials. II.--Secondary materials.
    III.--Sketch of the writing of Church history. IV.--Most
    important collections of primary sources. V.--Most important
    general Church histories. VI.--Dictionaries and encyclopedias.
    VII.--Atlases and chronologies. VIII.--Text-books.
    IX.--Sources.

    All our information about the origin, life, and growth of the Christian Church comes from the revelation of evidence which is termed sources.

    These sources are partly original, or primary, and partly secondary. For the student of history both kinds of sources have a definite character and value, and are, therefore, of peculiar interest. Some knowledge about the scope and nature of the sources is necessary for an intelligent view of any field of history. At the same time it is clear that any person presuming to pose as an authority on a given phase of history must not only be thoroughly acquainted with the varied contributions of all secondary works, but must also be a master of the character and worth of all first-hand materials.

    The primary sources are simply the records and remains left by the people who lived at any given time. Such materials, it will be readily seen, give the nearest and truest account of the ideas, feelings, motives, and beliefs, as well as of the deeds and actions, of man. An original source is, therefore, merely a source back of which one cannot go for historical information. It is apparent, consequently, that the primary sources are the more important because they are the very foundations of history. "No documents, no history," tersely declared Langlois.

    The primary sources put us in vital connection with the thoughts, doings, and institutions of past times. In them one sees reflected the spirit of the age. Every line, every word, is a revelation. The student is led to feel history, to actually know men and women of the past, and thus to comprehend our own civilisation in the earlier periods of its evolution. The primary sources cannot be accepted and assigned their true value, however, until their authenticity and genuineness are determined, and the element of personal equation is taken into account.

    Even then final judgment can never be absolute.

    For the sake of giving a clear conception of the range of the primary sources the following classification may be of assistance:

    A.--Written sources of the subjoined kind:

    I.--Public official documents:

    1. Acts of councils and synods.
    1. Letters, bulls, briefs, rescripts, and regests of popes,

    patriarchs, and bishops.

    1. Confessions of faith.
    1. Liturgies, hymns, etc.
    1. Church canons and laws, and monastic rules.
    1. Decrees and letters of kings, nobles, and civic assemblies.
    1. Laws of states.

    II.--Private writings of personal actors and observers:

    1. The Apostles.
    1. Church fathers.
    1. Heretics and reformers.
    1. Heathen.
    1. Chroniclers and historians.
    1. Missionaries.
    1. Clergy and laity.

    III.--Inscriptions on churches, public buildings, tombs,
    monuments, coins, seals, etc.

    B.--Unwritten sources of the following character:

    I.--Buildings:

    1. Churches and baptisteries.
    1. Tombs and monuments.
    1. Civic edifices.
    1. Private dwellings.

    II.--Art:

    1. Sculpture--images and emblems.
    1. Painting and fresco.
    1. Mosaics.
    1. Ecclesiastical vestments and ornaments.
    1. Church furniture and vessels.

    III.--Rites and ceremonies.

    IV.--Oral traditions.

    The secondary sources are those that are compiled from a study of the original sources, or from other secondary works, or from both, as is more likely to be the case. This class of material is very abundant, and varies greatly in character and value because of the striking difference in authorship, style, and purpose. It is always necessary, therefore, carefully to discriminate the wheat from the chaff and to be able easily to recognise the "earmarks" of a reliable authority. Many of the works produced by modern scientific scholarship are excellent in every respect, and, in many fields of historical study, absolutely indispensable. Secondary sources may be divided as follows:

    A.--Written works:

    I.--History:

    1. General treatises based upon either primary sources, or

    secondary materials, or both.

    1. Encyclopedias and dictionaries.
    1. Monographs, essays, and articles.

    II.--Fiction:

    1. Novels.
    1. Poetry.
    1. Drama.

    B.--Unwritten:

    I.--Oral traditions and reports.

    II.--Transmitted rites and ceremonies.

    III.--Works of art copied from originals.

    The earliest account of the history of the Christian Church extant is the New Testament. The "Memoirs" of Hegesippus, a converted Jew of the second century, is the first known effort to record the growth of the Church, but all his books are lost.[15:1] Eusebius, the Greek bishop, called the "Father of Church history," wrote a comprehensive Ecclesiastical History to 324. Socrates, Sozomen, and Theodoret, each after his own ideal, continued the narrative of Eusebius. Rufinus translated the work of Eusebius into Latin and continued it to 395, while Epiphanius translated Socrates, Sozomen, and Theodoret into Latin and brought the record to 518.

    Theodorus and Evagrius were also continuators of these early works. Sulpicius Severus, a Gallic monk of noble birth, penned a fabulous chronicle of little worth.

    The Middle Ages produced little of real value in the field of Church history. The chronicles represent the best output. A few scholars of the Eastern Church, the Byzantine historians, the annalists of the Latin Church, and several specialists like Gregory of Tours and the Venerable Bede, complete the list. The lives of saints, however, abound.

    The fierce controversial spirit of the Reformation produced two monumental works. Matthias Flacius, aided by other Protestant scholars, in the Magdeburg Centuries, sought to reveal the whole disreputable career of the old Church. This keen voluminous work of the Reformers called forth from the learned Italian, Baronius, a powerful defence of the Roman Church in his Ecclesiastical Annals. Bossuet, a Frenchman, in his Discourse on Universal History, made a severe attack on Protestantism, while Tillemont, a Gallic nobleman of Jansenist faith, wrote critically and with more moderation. In Germany, Hottinger, Spanheim, and Arnold vindicated the Reformation.

    Following the earlier age of fierce theological controversy, Semler, Henke, Schmidt, Hume, and Gibbon wrote in a very rationalistic style and spirit.

    During the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, German scholars have led the world in their contributions to Church history. The great Mosheim made a pronounced improvement in the writing of Church history and introduced the modern scientific method. He was not alone the most learned theologian of his age in Germany, but was critical in the best sense, honest and impartial. His disciple, Schroeckh, wrote a work of forty-five volumes of considerable value.

    Gieseler improved on Mosheim's method and wrote an ideal outline of Church history with full citations to all the known sources. Neander, "a giant in learning, and a saint in piety," gave the world an epoch-making General History of the Christian Religion and Church (1825-52). His writings and his ideals have influenced nearly every Church historian since his death, when it was said, "The last of the Church Fathers has gone." Among his immediate pupils are Hagenbach, Kurtz, Guericke, Niedner, and Semisch.

    Baur founded the celebrated "Tübingen School" and did some excellent work in the Ante-Nicene period. Strauss, Zeller, Schenkel, Rothe, and Nippold are the most prominent among his followers.

    The names of other German historians who have laboured in this domain of knowledge are so numerous that only a few of the most prominent will be mentioned. Chief among the Protestants are Hase, Gfroerer, Ebrard, Herzog, Moeller, Müller, Loofs, Hauck, and Harnack; among the Roman Catholic writers are Stolberg, Katerkamp, Döllinger, Alzog, Pastor, Hefele, Hergenröther and Janssen.

    Although British scholarship has not devoted itself so zealously to the writing of Church history, yet some excellent contributions have been made by such men as Pusey, Keble, Newman, Waddington, Milman, Stanley, Stubbs, Robertson, Greenwood, Vaughan, Perry, Lingard, Creighton, Gwatkin, Tozer, Hatch, and Orr.

    American interest in the field of Church history is largely the product of the last thirty years. Most conspicuous among the contributors are Smith, Lanson, Shedd, Schaff, Fisher, Sheldon, Dryer, Hurst, Newman, McGiffert, and Henry C. Lea.

    At the present time in every Christian country a corps of well-trained scholars are devoting their lives to nearly every phase of Church history, and the outlook is most gratifying.

    The literature on Church history, taken as a whole, is perhaps more voluminous than that on any other phase of history. The use of the sources is, in consequence, at the very outset a problem of selection.

    It is apparent, therefore, that the following brief lists are not meant to be exhaustive. Only the most valuable collections of original documents, and also the most reliable books of a secondary character are included. Special care has been taken to mention all useful collections of sources in the English language. At the conclusion of each chapter will be found references to the sources on special topics.

    THE MOST IMPORTANT COLLECTIONS OF PRIMARY SOURCES ARE:

    A.--Official Documents:

    I.--In English:

    1.--Brett, T., Collection of the Principal Liturgies.
    Lond., 1838.

    2.--Fulton, J., Index Canonum. N. Y., 1892.

    3.--Gee, H., and Hardy, W. J., Documents Illustrative of
    English Church History
    . N. Y., 1896.

    4.--Hammond, C. E., Liturgies, Eastern and Western. Lond.,
    1878.

    5.--Henderson, E. F., Select Historical Documents of the
    Middle Ages
    . Lond. and N. Y., 1892.

    6.--Neale, J. M., The Liturgies of St. Mark, St. James, St.
    Clement, St. Chrysostom, and St. Basil
    . 2 vols. Lond.,
    1859.

    7.--Neale, J. M., and Webb, B., The Symbolism of Churches
    and Church Ornaments
    . Lond. and N. Y., 1893.

    8.--Ogg, F. A., Source-Book of Mediæval History. N. Y.,
    1908.

    9.--Palmer, W., Origines Liturgicæ. 2 vols. Lond., 1845.

    10.--Roberts and Donaldson, Ante-Nicene Christian Library.
    Vol. xxiv. Edinb., 1872.

    11.--Robinson, J. H., Readings in European History. Vol. i.
    Boston, 1906.

    12.--Schaff, P., The Creeds of Christendom. 3 vols. N. Y.,
    1878.

    13.--Swainson, C. A., The Greek Liturgies. Lond. and N. Y.,
    1884.

    14.--Thatcher and McNeal, A Source Book for Mediæval History.
    N. Y., 1907.

    15.--University of Penn., Translations and Reprints of
    Original Sources of European History
    . Phil., 1894 to
    present.

    16.--Winer, G. B., Comparative View of the Doctrines and
    Confessions of Christendom
    . Edinb., 1887.

    II.--In Foreign Languages:

    1.--Councils and Synods:

    (1).--Binius, S., Concilia Generalia et Provincialia Græca
    et Latina
    . 4 vols. Best ed., Cologne, 1606.

    (2).--Labbé, P., Concilia. 18 vols. Paris, 1671. Carried
    by others to 1727.

    (3).--Hardouin, J., Conciliorum Collectio. 12 vols. Paris,
    1715.

    (4).--Mansi, G. D., Sacrorum Conciliorum Nova et Amplissima
    Collectio
    . 31 vols. Flor., 1759-98. Most complete
    collection to 1509. New edition now out.

    2.--Bulls, Acts, Briefs, Rescripts, and Regests:

    (1).--Bullæ Diversorum Pontificum a Joanne XXII. ad
    Julium III. ex Bibliotheca Ludovici Gomes.
    Rome, 1550.
    This is the oldest collection, but it contains only
    fifty documents.

    (2).--Cherubini made the first comprehensive collection of
    bulls and briefs from Leo I. to 1585. It is known as the
    Magnum Bullarium Romanum.

    (3).--Maynardus, Bullarium Magnum. 19 vols. Luxemb.,
    1739-68. Contains bulls from Leo I. to Benedict XIV.

    (4).--Coquelines made a similar collection at Rome in 14
    vols., 1733-48. Barbarini added 6 more vols. Rome, 1835.

    (5).--Tomassetti has made the latest collection of bulls
    from Leo I. to the nineteenth century. 25 vols. Turin,
    1857-72.

    (6).--The best collections of early papal briefs were made
    by Coustant, Paris, 1721; Schoenemann, Götting., 1796;
    Thiel, Braunsberg, 1867-8.

    (7).--Jaffé, P., Regesta Pontificum Romanorum (to 1198).
    Ber., 1881-88. 2 vols.

    (8).--Potthast, A., Regesta Pontificum. (1198 to 1304).
    Ber., 1873. 2 vols.

    (9).--Kehr, Regesta Pontificum Romanorum (to 1198).
    Berlin, 1906-7. 2 vols.

    (10).--The Liber Pontificalis gives the history of the
    popes down to the end of the ninth century. Duchesne's
    ed. the most complete. Rome, 1886-92. Mommsen's ed.
    excellent.

    (11).--Mirbt, C., Quellen zur Geschichte des Papsttums. 2d
    ed., 1903.

    3.--Creeds, Liturgies, and Hymns:

    (1).--Walch, C. W. F., Bibliotheca Symbolum Vetus.
    Lemgo., 1770.

    (2).--Niemeyer, A. H., Collectio Confessionum in Ecclesiis
    Reformatis Publicatarum
    . Leipz., 1840.

    (3).--Kimmel, E. J., Monumenta Fidei Ecclesiæ Orientalis.
    Jena, 1843-50. 2 vols.

    (4).--Heurtley, C. A., Harmonia Symbolica. Oxf., 1858.

    (5).--Denzinger, H. J. D., Enchiridion Symbolorum et
    Definitionum
    . Wurzb., 1888. 6th ed.

    (6).--Caspari, C. P., Quellen zur Geschichte des
    Taufsymbols und der Glaubensregel
    . Christiania, 1866-75.
    3 vols. Revised in 1879.

    (7).--Hahn, A., Bibliothek der Symbole und Glaubensregeln.
    Berlin, 1877. 2d ed.

    (8).--Durandus, W., Rationale Divinorum Officiorum. (About
    1290). Many eds. Last at Naples, 1866.

    (10).--Renaudot, E., Liturgiarum Orientalium Collectio.
    New ed., Paris, 1847. 2 vols.

    (11).--Muratori, L. A., Liturgia Romana Vetus. Venice,
    1748.

    (12).--Assemani, J. A., Codex Liturgicus Ecclesiæ Universæ.
    Rome, 1749-66. 13 vols.

    (13).--Weale, W. J. H., Bibliotheca Liturgica. Lond., 1886.

    (14).--Delisle, L., Mémoire sur d'anciens Sacramentaires.
    Paris, 1886.

    4.--Laws and Canons:

    (1).--Richter, L. A., Corpus Juris Canonici. Leipz.,
    1833. 2 vols.

    (2).--Friedberg, E., Corpus Juris Canonici. Leipz.,
    1876-82. Best ed.

    (3).--Migne, Patrologia Latina. Contains many ancient
    laws.

    (4).--Haenel, Theodosian Code. Bonn, 1842. 6 vols.

    (5).--Krueger, Justinian Code. Ber., 1877.

    (6).--Moser, J. J., Corpus Juris Evang. Ecclesiæ. Zur.,
    1737. 2 vols.

    5.--Decrees and Acts of Civic Authorities:

    (1).--Pertz, et al., Monumenta Germaniæ Historica. Ber.,
    1819 to present.

    (2).--Muratori, Scriptores Rerum Italicarum. Milan,
    1723-57. 25 vols. From 500 to 1500.

    (3).--Thesaurus Veterum Inscriptionum. Milan, 1739-42. 4
    vols.

    (4).--Corpus Juris Civilis. Good ed. by Kriegel Brothers,
    Leipz., 1833-40. Best ed. by Mommsen, Ber., 1895. 3 vols.

    B.--Private Writings of Contemporaries:

    I.--In English:

    1.--Roberts and Donaldson, Ante-Nicene Christian Library.
    25 vols. Edinb., 1864-72, 1897.

    2.--Coxe, A. C., Ante-Nicene Fathers. 10 vols. Buf.,
    1886-88.

    3.--Pusey, et al., A Library of the Fathers of the Holy
    Catholic Church
    . 48 vols. Oxf., 1839-85.

    4.--The Publications of the Parker Society. 53 vols. Camb.,
    1840-55. For English Church.

    5.--Schaff, et al., Select Library of the Nicene and
    Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church
    . 14 vols.
    Buf., 1886-90. First series.

    6.--Schaff and Wace, Select Library of the Nicene and
    Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church
    . 14 vols.
    Lond. and N. Y., 1890-94.

    7.--Bohn, Antiquarian Library. 36 vols. Lond., 1847, etc.

    Classical Library. 107 vols. Lond., 1848, etc.

    Ecclesiastical Library. 15 vols. Lond., 1851, etc.

    8.--Foxe, Acts and Monuments. Townsend ed. Lond., 1843.

    9.--Lightfoot, The Apostolic Fathers. Lond., 1889.

    II.--In Foreign Languages:

    1.--Canisius, H., Antiquæ Lectiones. 2d ed., 1725. 7 vols.

    2.--Combefis, F., Græco-Lat. Patrum Bibliotheca Auctarium
    Novum
    . 2 vols. Paris, 1648.

    Bibliotheca Græcorum Patrum Auctarium Novissimum. 2 vols.
    Paris, 1672.

    Bibliotheca Patrum Concoinatoria. 8 vols. New ed. Paris,
    1859.

    3.--D'Achery, J. L., Veterum aliquot Scriptorum qui in Galliæ
    Bibliothecis delituerant, maxime Benedictinorum
    Spicilegium
    . 13 vols. Paris, 1655-77. New ed., 1723.

    4.--Du Pin, L. E., Bibliothèque Universelle des Auteurs
    Ecclésiastiques
    . 47 vols. Paris, 1686-1704. Several
    later editions.

    5.--Martène, E., Veterum Scriptorum et Monumentorum Collectio
    Nova
    . Rouen, 1700.

    6.--Montfauçon, B. de, Collectio Nova Patrum et Scriptorum
    Græcorum
    . Paris, 1706. 2 vols.

    7.--Muratori, L. A., Rerum Italicarum Scriptores. Mil.,
    1723-51. 25 vols. New ed. now being published, ed. by
    Carducci.

    8.--Ceillier, R., Histoire Générale des Auteurs Sacrés et
    Ecclésiastiques
    . New ed., Paris, 1858-69. 16 vols.

    9.--Bouquet, M., Scriptores Rerum Gallicarum et Francilarum.
    New ed., Paris, 1869-77. To date 23 vols.

    10.--Gallandi, A., Bibliotheca Veterum Patrum Antiquorumque
    Scriptorum Ecclesiasticorum
    . 14 vols. Venice, 1765-81.
    380 authors.

    11.--Routh, M. J., Reliquiæ Sacræ. 5 vols. Oxf., 2d ed.,
    1846-1848.

    12.--Pertz, et al., Monumenta Germaniæ Historica. Ber., 1819
    to present.

    13.--Niebuhr, et al., Scriptores Historiæ Byzantinæ. Bonn,
    1828-55. 48 vols.

    14.--Migne, J. P., Patrologiæ Cursus Completus. Paris,
    1844-66. 222 vols. of Latin Fathers and 166 vols. of
    Greek Fathers.

    15.--Chronicles and Memorials of Great Britain and Ireland from
    the Roman Invasion to Henry VIII. Lond., 1858-90. 210
    vols. (Rolls series).

    16.--Academy of Vienna, Corpus Scriptorum Ecclesiæ Latinæ. 17
    vols. Vienna, 1867-95.

    17.--Jaffé, P., Bibliotheca Rerum Germanicarum. 1864-73. 6
    vols.

    18.--Graffin, P., Patrologia Syriaca. Paris, 1895. 2 vols.

    (19).--Die Griechischen christlichen Schriftsteller der ersten
    drei Jahrhunderte.

    (20).--Bibliothèque de Théologie Historique. Paris, 1906
    ff. (To be completed in 60 vols.)

    C.--Inscriptions:

    I.--In English:

    1.--Northcote, J. S., Epitaphs of the Catacombs. Lond.,
    1898.

    2.--Bingham, J., Antiquities of the Christian Church. Oxf.,
    1855. 10 vols. Very valuable.

    3.--Guericke, H. E. F., Manual of the Antiquities of the
    Church
    . Lond., 1851.

    4.--Bennett, C. W., Christian Archæology. N. Y., 1888.

    5.--Rushforth, G. McN., Latin Historical Inscriptions. Oxf.,
    1893.

    II.--In Latin:

    1.--See Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum. Best ed. by Mommsen
    under Berlin Academy. 1862 to date 11 vols.

    2.--Boeckh, P. A., Corpus Inscriptionum Græcarum. Ber.,
    1824.

    3.--Le Blant, E., Inscriptions chrét. de la Gaule. Paris,
    1856-65. 2 vols.

    4.--Hübner, E., Inscriptions Hispan. Christ. Ber., 1871.

    Inscrip. Brit. Christ. Ber., 1876.

    5.--De Rossi, J. B., Inscriptiones Christianæ Urbis Romæ
    Septimo Sæculo Antiquiores
    . Rome, 1861.

    6.--Fabretti, A., Corpus Inscriptionum Italicarum. Turin,
    1867-77. 2 vols. Three supplements. Flor., 1800.

    7.--L'Epigraphie Chrestienne en Gaule et dans l'Afrique.
    Paris, 1890.

    MOST IMPORTANT GENERAL CHURCH HISTORIANS:

    A.--Before the Reformation:

    I.--Greek:

    1.--Hegesippus, a Christian Jew in Asia Minor (2d cent.),
    wrote a Church history in five books. Based on
    traditions. Only fragments preserved. See Ante-Nic.
    Lib.
    , viii., 762-5. See Eusebius.

    2.--Eusebius (d. 340), "Father of Church History," wrote a
    history of Church to 324. Valuable storehouse. Various
    Eng. translations. That by McGiffert, N. Y., 1890, in
    Nic. and Post-Nic. Fathers, i., is the best.

    3.--Socrates (d. 408), a lawyer, continued Eusebius to 439.
    Bohn. Nic. and Post-Nic. Fathers, ii.

    4.--Sozomen (d. 400), a lawyer, continued Eusebius to 423.
    Ibid. Bohn.

    5.--Theodoret (d. 457), a bishop, aimed to complete Socrates
    and Sozomen. Ibid. Bohn.

    6.--Evagrius (d. 537), a lawyer, continued Theodoret. Bohn.
    Bagster, Eccles. Historians.

    For other Greek historians, lost or not in English, see Alzog,
    i., § 17; Schaff, i., 29.

    II.--Latin--to the Reformation:

    1.--Rufinus (b. 345), a priest, translated Eusebius and added
    an inaccurate history of the Arians (318-395). Preface
    only in Eng. Nic. and Post-Nic. Fathers, iii., 565.

    2.--Severus (b. 363), a Gallic priest, wrote the history of
    the world to 400. Good for Gaul. Ib., xi., 71-122.

    3.--Orosius (5th cent.), a Spanish priest, wrote a world
    history to 416. Used as a text-book in Middle Ages. Bohn.

    4.--Cassiodorus (d. 562), a statesman and abbot, compiled a
    Church history from Socrates, Sozomen, and Theodoret.
    This is the famous "Tripartite History." It served as a
    text-book throughout the Middle Ages. Not in Eng. See
    Migne, Patrologia, lxix., and Hodgkin, The Letters of
    Cassiodorus
    .

    5.--Gregory of Tours (d. 594), a bishop, wrote a valuable
    history of the Frankish Church. Not in Eng.

    6.--Venerable Bede (d. 735), "Father of English Church
    History," wrote a history of the English Church to 731.
    Many Eng. eds.

    7.--Paul Warnefried (d. 799), a Lombard monk wrote a History
    of the Langobards. Tr. by Foulke, U. of Pa. Transl. and
    Rep.
    Phil. 1907.

    8.--Haymo (d. 853), bishop of Halberstädt, abridged Rufinus
    and added notes of his own. Not in Eng.

    9.--Anastasius (d. 886), abbot and papal librarian at Rome,
    compiled a Church history from the Greek writers. Not in
    Eng.

    10.--Flodoard (d. 966), a bishop, wrote a history of the
    Church of Rheims to 948. Not in Eng.

    11.--Luitprand (d. 972), bishop of Cremona, wrote a chronicle
    and a report of his embassy to Constantinople. See Pertz,
    Mon. Ger., iii., 264; Henderson, Hist. Docs. of the M.
    A.
    , 441.

    12.--Adam of Bremen (d. 1076), a canon, wrote the only reliable
    history of the Scandinavian Church from 788 to 1076. Not
    in Eng.

    13.--Orderic Vital (d. 1142), abbot in Normandy, wrote a Church
    history to 1142. Best work of the Middle Ages. In Eng.,
    Bohn. Vols. 27, 28, 30, 36.

    14.--Ptolemy of Lucca (d. 1312), a Dominican, and papal
    librarian, wrote a Church history to 1312. Not in Eng.

    15.--St. Antoninus (d. 1459), archbishop of Florence, wrote the
    largest mediæval work from the creation to 1457. Not in
    Eng.

    16.--Laurentius Valla (d. 1457), an Italian critic and scholar,
    wrote a history of the Church. Denounced the "Donation of
    Constantine" as a forgery. Work full of doubt. Not in
    Eng.

    17.--Nicholas of Cusa (d. 1464), a cardinal, was a radical
    critic in his early days but temperate in later life. His
    works not in Eng.

    18.--John of Tritenheim (d. 1516) was among the first
    historians to write from the sources. Not in Eng.

    19.--Albert Cranz (d. 1517), a canon of Hamburg, wrote "The
    Metropolis," a critical history of the Church in northern
    Germany from 780 to 1504. Not in Eng.

    B.--Roman Catholic historians after the Reformation:

    I.--Italian:

    1.--Baronius (d. 1607), a cardinal, wrote Annales
    Ecclesiastici
    in 12 fol. vols. The work of 30 years.
    Invaluable. Not in Eng. Written to refute the Protestant
    Magdeburg Centuries. Continued from 1198 to 1566 by
    Raynaldus, to 1571 by Laderchi, to 1584 by Theiner. Pagi
    made valuable corrections. Best defence of the mediæval
    papacy.

    2.--Caspar Saccarelli wrote Historia Ecclesiastica to 1185.
    Pub. in Rome, 1771-96, in 25 quarto vols.

    3.--Muratori (d. 1750) made a valuable collection of Italian
    historians and original documents from 500 to 1500. Not
    in Eng.

    4.--Mansi (d. 1769) edited a valuable and very complete
    edition of the councils. Not in Eng.

    5.--Orsi (1761), a Dominican cardinal, wrote a Church history
    for the first six centuries. Continued by others to the
    Council of Trent. Not in Eng.

    For other Italian historians see Alzog, i., 49.

    II.--French:

    1.--Natalis Alexander (d. 1724) wrote a clear, deep Church
    history to 1600. Its Gallican spirit put it in the Index
    till corrected.

    2.--Abbé Fleury (d. 1723) wrote a Church history to 1414 in 20
    vols. from the sources. Continued to 1595 by Fabre. First
    3 vols. pub. in Eng. at Oxf., in 1842.

    3.--Bossuet (d. 1704), the bishop of Meaux, wrote a
    "Discourse on Universal History." In Eng. Continued by
    Cramer, a German Protestant.

    4.--Tillemont (d. 1698), a nobleman and priest, wrote fine
    biographies to 516 from the sources. An excellent piece
    of work in 16 vols.

    5.--Du Pin (d. 1719) furnished a biographical and
    bibliographical Church history to the 17th century.

    6.--Ceillier (d. 1763) wrote a similar work but more complete
    and valuable.

    7.--Darras (d. 1872). A General History of the Catholic
    Church.
    Transl. by Spaulding. 4 vols. Not reliable.

    III.--German:

    1.--Count Leopold von Stolberg (d. 1819), an ex-Protestant,
    wrote a Church history to 430 in 15 vols. Kerz continued
    it in 30 more vols. to 1192 and Brischar in 9 more vols.
    to 1245.

    2.--Theodore Katerkamp (d. 1834), a professor at Munster, and
    a friend of Stolberg, wrote a history to 1153.

    3.--Locherer (d. 1837), a professor at Giessen, produced a
    very liberal work up to 1073.

    4.--Döllinger (d. 1890), a professor in Munich, was the most
    learned historian of the Catholic Church in the 19th
    cent. Was excommunicated for refusing to accept the
    Vatican decrees (1871). Most of his many works have been
    translated into Eng.

    5.--Hefele (d. 1893), a professor at Tübingen and a bishop,
    wrote History of the Councils to 1447. An excellent
    piece of work. Completed by Hergenröther. In Eng.

    6.--Gfrörer (d. 1861) began his learned Church history as a
    rationalist (1841) and continued it from 1056 on as a
    Catholic.

    7.--Hergenröther (d. 1890), cardinal and keeper of the papal
    archives at Rome, wrote a general history of the Church
    which is very partisan.

    IV.--English and American:

    1.--Newman (d. 1890), an English cardinal, wrote The Arians
    of the Fourth Century
    (1883), Church of the Fathers,
    and many other historical works.

    2.--Allies, The Formation of Christendom. Lond., 1882-91. 7
    vols.

    3.--Spalding (1872), an American prelate, wrote The History
    of the Protestant Reformation
    , 2 vols., 1860, and edited
    Darras's General History of the Catholic Church. (1868)

    4.--Gibbons (b. 1834), cardinal in the U. S., wrote Faith of
    Our Fathers
    and other historical works.

    C.--Protestant Church Historians:

    I.--German:

    1.--Matthias Flacius Illyricus (d. 1575), with ten educated
    Protestant scholars, produced the Centuriæ
    Magdeburgenses
    , covering 13 centuries in 13 vols., to
    justify the Reformation. Controversial.

    2.--Hottinger (d. 1664) wrote a partisan history to 16th cent.
    in 9 vols. Not original.

    3.--Spanheim (d. 1649) worked out a history from the sources
    to 16th cent. Aimed at Baronius. Eng. transl.

    4.--Arnold (d. 1714) wrote an Impartial History of the Church
    and of Heretics
    to 1688. "Learned, but fanatical."

    5.--Mosheim (d. 1755) wrote Institutes of Ecclesiastical
    History
    . Marks an epoch in the writing of Church
    history. Several Eng. transls.

    6.--Schröckh (d. 1808) wrote large work in 45 vols. on epoch
    plan, to end of 18th cent. Rich in historical material.

    7.--Henke (d. 1809) wrote a general history in a very
    rationalistic style.

    8.--Neander (d. 1850), professor in Berlin, the "Father of
    Modern Church History," wrote A General History of the
    Christian Religion and Church
    to 1430. Based on the
    sources. Several Eng. transls. Torrey's the best.

    9.--Gieseler (d. 1854), professor in Göttingen, wrote a
    history from the sources to 1648. Various Eng. transls.
    Excellent.

    10.--Baur (d. 1860), professor in Tübingen, produced a
    History of the Christian Church in 5 vols. In Eng.

    11.--Hagenbach (d. 1874), professor in Basle, wrote a general
    history of the Church in 7 vols. In Eng.

    II.--French:

    1.--Chastel (d. 1886), professor at Geneva, wrote a complete
    history of the Church in 5 vols.

    2.--D'Aubigné (d. 1872), professor at Geneva, wrote a general
    history of the Reformation in 13 vols. In Eng.

    3.--Renan, E. (d. 1892), was educated for the Catholic
    priesthood, but he early gave up that calling and devoted
    himself to history and literature. He produced many works
    of great value on early Church history.

    III.--English:

    1.--Gibbon (d. 1794) devoted twenty years to his history of
    the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. To 1453.
    Still very valuable. Best ed. by Bury. Lond., 1896.

    2.--Milner (d. 1797) wrote a History of the Church of Christ
    in popular form.

    3.--Dean Waddington (d. 1869) penned six "high and dry" vols.
    on the Church.

    4.--Robertson (d. 1882), professor in King's College, London,
    wrote a History of the Christian Church to 1517. Fairly
    well done from the sources.

    5.--Milman (d. 1868), among other works, wrote the History
    of Latin Christianity
    to 1455 in 8 vols. Excellent.

    6.--Dean Stanley (d. 1881) has given us histories of the
    Eastern Church and Jewish Church in a pure, plain style.

    7.--Creighton (d. 1901), has written the best History of the
    Papacy from the Great Schism to the Sack of Rome
    . 6
    vols. Invaluable.

    IV.--American:

    1.--Smith (d. 1877), professor in Union Theological Seminary,
    worked out the history of Christianity in 16
    chronological tables, (1860).

    2.--Shedd (d. 1894), professor in Union Theological Seminary,
    wrote a History of Christian Doctrine in 2 vols. 1863.

    3.--Schaff (d. 1893), professor in Union Theological Seminary,
    a disciple of Neander, wrote, in addition to other works
    of value, a History of the Christian Church. To the
    Reformation. 7 vols. Excellent. Vol. 5, by D. S. Schaff.

    4.--Sheldon (b. 1845) has written an excellent history of
    doctrine and also of the Church. 5 vols. 1896.

    5.--Allen (d. 1908) wrote Christian History in Three Great
    Decades
    in 3 vols. 1883.

    6.--Fisher (b. 1827), professor in Yale, has produced several
    valuable books on Church history.

    7.--White (d. 1885) wrote Eighteen Christian Centuries.

    8.--Lea (b. 1825) has written invaluable monographs on the
    Inquisition, Indulgences, Celibacy, etc., which
    have given him a world-wide reputation.

    9.--Other Americans who are doing good work in Church history
    are: Jackson, Hurst, Baird, Thompson, Mombert, Gillett,
    Storrs, Taylor, Clark, Emerton, Bigelow, West, Fulton,
    Jacobs, Newman, Zenos, Dexter, McGiffert, Dryer,
    Faulkner, etc.

    DICTIONARIES AND ENCYCLOPEDIAS

    A.--English:

    I.--Protestant:

    1.--Abbott and Conant, Dictionary of Religious Knowledge.
    N. Y., 1875.

    2.--Benham, Dictionary of Religion. Lond. and N. Y., 1887.

    3.--Blunt, A Dictionary of Doctrinal and Historical
    Theology
    . Lond. and Phil., 2d ed., 1891.

    4.--Blunt, A Dictionary of Sects, Heresies, Ecclesiastical
    Parties, and Schools of Religious Thought
    . Lond. and
    Phil., 2d ed., 1886.

    5.--Buck, A Theological Dictionary. Lond., 1847.

    6.--Cheyne and Black, Encyclopædia Biblica. 4 vols. N. Y.,
    1905.

    7.--Eadie, The Ecclesiastical Cyclopædia. Lond., 1847.

    8.--Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge. Phil., 1870.

    9.--Farrar, An Ecclesiastical Dictionary. Lond., 1853.

    10.--Gardner, The Christian Cyclopedia. Lond., 1854.

    11.--Hastings, A Dictionary of the Bible. N. Y. and
    Edinburgh.

    12.--Herzog, A Protestant, Theological, and Ecclesiastical
    Encyclopædia
    . 2 vols. Phil., 1858-60.

    13.--Hook, A Church Dictionary. N. Y., 1875.

    14.--Hook, Ecclesiastical Biography. 4 vols. Lond., 1845.

    15.--Jackson, Concise Dictionary of Religious Knowledge and
    Gazetteer
    . N. Y., 1893.

    16.--McClintock and Strong, Cyclopædia of Biblical,
    Theological, and Ecclesiastical Literature
    . 10 vols. N.
    Y., 1867-81. 2 sup. vols. 1884-86.

    17.--Marsden, A Dictionary of Christian Churches and Sects. 2
    vols. Lond., 1891.

    18.--Sanford, A Concise Encyclopædia of Religious Knowledge.
    N. Y., 1891.

    19.--Schaff-Herzog, Encyclopædia of Religious Knowledge. 3
    vols. N. Y., 1891.

    The New Schaff-Herzog Encyclopædia of Religious Knowledge.
    Revised by S. M. Jackson. N. Y. and Lond., 1908 ff. In
    12 vols.

    20.--Shipley, A Glossary of Ecclesiastical Forms. Lond.,
    1871.

    21.--Smith and Cheetham, A Dictionary of Christian
    Antiquities
    . 2 vols. Bost., 1875-80.

    22.--Smith and Wace, A Dictionary of Christian Biography,
    Literature, Sects, and Doctrines
    . 4 vols. Bost.,
    1877-87.

    23.--Stanton, An Ecclesiastical Dictionary. N. Y., 1861.

    24.--Wolcott, Sacred Archeology. Lond., 1868.

    II.--Catholic:

    1.--Addis and Arnold, A Catholic Dictionary. N. Y., 1884.

    2.--Gillow, Dictionary of English Catholic Biography and
    Bibliography
    . (1534-1884.) 6 vols. Lond., 1887-94.

    3.--Gibbings, Index Expurgatoris. Lond., 1837.

    4.--Butler, Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs and Other Saints.
    12 vols. Lond., 1866.

    5.--Berington, The Faith of Catholics. 3 vols. Lond., 1846.

    6.--The Catholic Encyclopedia. N. Y., 1907 ff. (To be
    completed in 15 vols.)

    7.--Thein, Ecclesiastical Dictionary, 1905.

    III.--Jewish and Mohammedan:

    1.--The Jewish Encyclopedia. 12 vols. N. Y., 1902-5.

    2.--Encyclopedia Islam. 3 vols. 1908.

    B.--Foreign:

    I.--Protestant:

    1.--Hauck, Herzog's Real-Encyklopädie für protestantische
    Theologie und Kirche
    . 1896 ff.

    2.--Lichtenberger, Encyclopédie des Sciences Religieuses.
    Paris, 1872-82. 13 vols.

    II.--Catholic:

    1.--Aschbach, Allgemeines Kirchen-Lexicon. Frankf.,
    1846-50. 4 vols.

    2.--Wetzer und Welte, Kirchen Lexicon. Freib., 1847-56. 12
    vols.

    3.--Hergenröther und Kauler. Kirchenlexikon oder Encyklopädie
    der Katholischen Theologie und ihrer
    Hilfswissenschaften.
    Freib., 1880-1895. 10 vols.

    C.--Consult standard secular encyclopædias like Britannica, Johnson, International, etc.

    ATLASES AND CHRONOLOGIES

    I.--English:

    1.--Koeppen, A. L., The World in the Middle Ages. N. Y.,
    1854.

    2.--Sprüner, Historico-Geographical Hand Atlas. Lond., 1861.

    3.--Wiltsch, J. E. F., Handbook of the Geography and
    Statistics of the Church
    . 2 vols. Lond., 1859-69.

    4.--McClure, C. E., Ecclesiastical Atlas. Lond., 1888.

    5.--Freeman, E. A., Historical Geography of Europe. Lond.,
    1881. 2 vols. New ed. 1904.

    6.--Labberton, R. H., New Historical Atlas and General
    History
    . N. Y., 1890.

    7.--Riddle, J. E., Ecclesiastical Chronology. Lond., 1840.

    8.--Tarner, G. E., Concise Tabular View of the Outlines of
    Christian History
    . Lond., 1890.

    9.--Smith, H. B., History of the Church in Chronological
    Tables
    . N. Y., 1875.

    10.--Woodward and Gates, Encyclopædia of Chronology. N. Y.,
    1872.

    11.--Dow, E. W., Atlas of European History. N. Y., 1907.

    II.--Foreign:

    1.--Putzger, F. W., Historischer Schul-Atlas. Leipz., 1903.
    Anglicised now. Excellent.

    2.--Droysen, H., Allgemeine historische Handatlas. Leipz.,
    1886.

    3.--Weidenbach, Calendarium Hist. Chron. Medii et Novi Ævi.
    Reg., 1855.

    4.--Grotefend, G. A., Handbuch des Hist. Chr. des
    Mittel-Alters
    . Hanov., 1872.

    TEXT-BOOKS ON CHURCH HISTORY

    I.--Protestant:

    1.--Allen, Outlines of Christian History. Bost., 1885. 3
    vols.

    2.--Blackburn, History of the Christian Church. Cin., 1879.
    (Presb.).

    3.--Butler, An Ecclesiastical History. Phil., 1868-72. 2
    vols.

    4.--Fisher, History of the Christian Church. N. Y., 1887.

    5.--Foulkes, A Manual of Ecclesiastical History. Oxf., 1851.

    6.--Gieseler, A Text-Book of Church History. N. Y., 1868-79.
    5 vols.

    7.--Green. Handbook of Church History. N. Y., 1904.

    8.--Guericke, A Manual of Church History (to 1073). And.,
    1872. 2 vols.

    9.--Hardwick, A History of the Christian Church. Lond.,
    1861-65. 2 vols.

    10.--Hase, A History of the Christian Church. N. Y., 1870.

    11.--Hurst, A History of the Christian Church. N. Y., 1897. 2
    vols.

    12.--Jennings, A Manual of Church History. N. Y., 1887-8. 2
    vols.

    13.--Knight, A Concise History of the Church. Lond., 1888.

    14.--Kurtz, Church History. N. Y., 1888. 3 vols.

    15.--Moeller, History of the Christian Church. Lond., 1902. 3
    vols.

    16.--Moncrief, A Short History of the Christian Church.
    Chicago and N. Y., 1902.

    17.--Mosheim, Institutes of Ecclesiastical History. Last ed.,
    Bost., 1902. 3 vols.

    18.--Newman, A Manual of Church History. Phil., 1902-3. 2
    vols.

    19.--Schaff, History of the Christian Church. N. Y., 1884-92.
    7 vols.

    Vol. v., by D. S. Schaff, N. Y., 1908.

    20.--Smith, The Student's Manual of Ecclesiastical History.
    N. Y., 1879.

    21.--Schubert, Outlines of Church History. Lond., 1907.

    22.--Sohm, Outlines of Church History. Lond., 1895.

    23.--Waddington, A History of the Church. Lond., 1835. 3
    vols.

    24.--Zenos, Compendium of Church History. Phil., 1900.

    II.--Catholic:

    1.--Alzog, A Manual of Universal Church History. Lond.,
    1888-90. 3 vols.

    2.--Birkheuser, History of the Catholic Church from its First
    Establishment to our own Times
    . 7th ed., 1905.

    3.--Brueck, History of the Catholic Church. N. Y., 1886.

    4.--Döllinger, Manual of Church History. Lond., 1840-42. 4
    vols.

    5.--Gilmartin, Manual of Church History. Lond., 1890-2. 2
    vols.

    It is a matter of deep regret that such excellent books by Catholic writers like Hergenröther, Kraus, Möhler, Funk, etc., have not yet been translated into English.

    SOURCES

    1.--Adams, C. K., A Manual of Historical Literature. N. Y.,
    1888.

    2.--Cave, A., Introduction to Theology. Edinb., 1886.

    3.--Crooks, G. R., and Hurst, J. F., Literature of Theology.
    N. Y., 1896. Pt. iii.

    4.--Darling, J., Cyclopædia Bibliographica. 3 vols. Lond.,
    1854-9.

    5.--Donaldson, J., A Critical History of Christian Literature.
    3 vols. Lond., 1864-6.

    6.--Dowling, J. G., An Introduction to the Critical Study of
    Ecclesiastical History
    . London, 1832.

    7.--Fisher, J. A., A Select Bibliography of Ecclesiastical
    History
    . Bost., 1885.

    8.--Fortescue, G. K., Subject Index of the Modern Works Added
    to the Library of the British Museum in the Years
    1881-1900
    . 3 vols. 1902-1904.

    9.--Hurst, J. F., Literature of Theology. N. Y., 1896. Pt.
    iii., p. 186.

    10.--Kruger, G., History of Early Christian Literature in the
    First Three Centuries
    . N. Y., 1897.

    11.--Malcom, H., Theological Index. Phil., 1870.

    12.--Poole, W. F., Index to Periodical Literature (1802 to
    date).

    13.--Schaff, P., Theological Propædeutics. N. Y., 1893.

    14.--Sonnenschein, W. S., The Best Books. Lond., 1896.

    15.--Tibbals, C. F., Thesaurus of the Best Theological,
    Historical, and Biographical Literature
    . N. Y., 1891.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [15:1] Extracts in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History and in Ante-Nic.

    Ch. Fathers (Chr. Lit. ed.), viii., 762.

    CHAPTER III

    PREPARATION OF THE CIVILISED WORLD FOR THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH

    OUTLINE: I.--The ancient world. II.--Condition of the
    civilised world at the time Jesus came. III.--How the
    condition of the world prepared the way for Christianity.
    IV.--Sources.

    The ancient world included the many independent tribes surrounding the Mediterranean Sea and spreading into the interior. This independence was institutional. Each tribe had its own government, laws, and customs; its own religion and gods; its own ideals of education; its own commercial and industrial methods. But all these diversities of life and thought were broken down by the ascendancy of Rome. The independent laws, gods, and institutions fell before the onward march of those of the Mistress of the World.

    When Jesus was born, the Roman Empire extended from the Euphrates to the Atlantic, and from the African desert to the Danube, Rhine, and Weser.

    It formed a wide fringe around the Mediterranean Sea, included the best parts of three continents, and had a population of 100,000,000.[40:1] The Empire was called "the world." Roman law was predominant throughout the provinces as well as at Rome, but local usages were tolerated.

    Citizenship had become so widely extended that the different peoples began to feel themselves a single race, bound together by one Emperor, one government, and one code of laws.

    The era of the boyhood of Jesus was one of comparative peace, since there was no important war after the naval battle of Actium (31 B.C.).[41:1] Hence the industries of the Empire prospered greatly.

    Across the Mediterranean as the great highway, up and down the rivers, and along the incomparable Roman roads, an enormous trade was carried on between the colonies and the capital, Rome.[41:2] Factories thrived in every direction and commerce flourished. Showers of wealth fairly fell upon the Eternal City.

    The trade of the Empire was carried on in Latin, the official language of the Empire for law and war. Greek was also a universal tongue, but used more especially for art, science, philosophy, education, and religion.[41:3] Cicero complained: "Greek is read in almost all nations.

    Latin is confined by its own natural boundaries." Hebrew and other tongues were sectional. The literature of the opening century of the Christian era, however, was largely in Latin,[41:4] which had been fertilised by Greek culture.

    Education had made far greater progress in this old world than is generally thought. Judea,[41:5] Greece,[41:6] and Rome[42:1] had excellent systems of education, though differing much in purpose and in subjects studied. Pronounced schools of philosophy grew up. Art, comparatively little developed among the Jews, culminated with the Greeks, and from them was transplanted to Rome. Travel, always liberalising and educational, was widespread among scholars, tradesmen, soldiers, and public officials. All these factors had produced a superior intelligence and general culture throughout the Empire.

    The religious condition of the Empire was very significant. The Roman religion, a mixture of Grecian and Etrurian religions[42:2]--of licentiousness and puritanism--was alone legal over the whole Empire.[42:3] The Emperor, as Pontifex Maximus, was head of the religion. Worship, however, had become mere form--even priests ridiculed the gods.

    Cicero declared: "One soothsayer could not look another in the face without laughing," and "even old women would no longer believe either in the fables of Tartarus or the joys of Elysium." This loss of faith engendered skepticism and superstition, and gave magicians and necromancers a wide patronage. The best men in Rome were demanding reformation, and were longing for and predicting a new era.

    Cicero prophesied: "There shall no longer be one law at Rome, and another at Athens; nor shall it decree one thing to-day, and another to-morrow; but one and the same law, eternal and immutable, shall be prescribed for all nations and all times, and the God who shall prescribe, introduce, and promulgate this law shall be the one common Lord and Supreme Ruler of all."[43:1]

    The Grecian religion,[43:2] so closely resembling the Roman, was of course tolerated in the Empire. The gods were ideal Greeks with virtues and vices magnified. They were born, had passions, senses, and bodies like men, but never died.

    They committed crimes, had troubles, and were given to wrath, hatred, lust, cruelty, perjury, deception, and adultery, yet were omnipotent and omniscient.[43:3] While the conception of Zeus, as the father of the gods, ruled by fate, had a vague idea of monotheism in it, still the Greek religion lacked the Christian conception of sin and righteousness, for with the Greeks sin was only a folly of the understanding--even the gods sinned.

    Small wonder then that Plato banished the gods from his ideal republic.[43:4] Pindar, Eschylus, and Sophocles also urged loftier views of the gods, and preached a higher morality.[43:5] With the Roman conquest national honour and patriotism died out, and superstition, infidelity, refined materialism, and outright atheism came in. The best hearts were longing for a new and purer religion, and were ready to accept it when it came.

    The Jews,[44:1] intensely religious, with several thousand years of spiritual history back of them, divided the known world into the followers of the true God and the heathen idolaters. Even they were separated into factions:

    (1) The Pharisees,[44:2] numbering 6000, stoical casuists, rigidly orthodox, prone to analyse the Mosaic law to death, intensely patriotic, and bitter against all non-Jewish tendencies, were very popular, guided public worship, and controlled the Jews in politics.

    (2) The Sadducees,[44:3] rationalistic and skeptical, were aristocratic Epicureans who rejected oral traditions, and denied resurrection,[44:4] angels,[44:5] and an all-ruling, foreknowing Providence. They formed a smaller political party in opposition to the Pharisees, held many priestly offices, were in league with the Romans, and therefore had less influence with the people.[44:6]

    (3) The Essenes,[44:7] a mystic brotherhood of 4000 whose purpose was to attain holiness, received their ideas from eastern Theosophists; lived communal lives on the shores of the Dead Sea; took the Old Testament allegorically; wore a white dress; were over-scrupulously clean for the purpose of purification; and rejected animal food, bloody sacrifices, oaths, slavery, and marriage. They had little to do with politics; were forerunners of Christian monasticism; and may have influenced the ideas of Jesus.[45:1]

    (4) The Samaritans,[45:2] in origin half Jewish and half heathen Babylonian, practised their reformed Judaism about Gerizim under an established Levitical priesthood. They rejected all Scriptures but the Pentateuch, held pure Messianic expectations, looked with favour upon Christianity, and were bitterly hated by the orthodox Jews.[45:3]

    (5) The Zealots, led by Judas of Galilee, a sort of a nationalistic party, were imbued by a very materialistic conception of the hope of Israel. They sprang from the Pharisees and followed them in religious things. They confidently expected the realisation of the kingdom of God, the Messiah, and a new Israel. In their patriotic zeal they did not hesitate to use the sword and dagger to drive out their Roman foes in order to realise their dreams for a purely Jewish kingdom. Their followers came mostly from the lowest classes.[45:4]

    (6) The common people accepted the Pharisees, in a general way, as leaders. They believed in tradition and in the resurrection, but they were prone to neglect the law and formalism so stoutly insisted upon by the scribes. This class of Jews had a vital, living fellowship with God, and might be called pietists. Such characters as Simeon and Anna, Zachariah and Elizabeth, Joseph and Mary, and most of those influenced by John's call to repentance were of this class.

    They stood for the pure religion of the early prophets, and in a way opposed the sacerdotalism of the Jewish Church. They were in a spiritual and ethical mood to accept the great teachings of Jesus of Nazareth, and were consequently his first converts. While they constituted the majority of the Jews, and were scattered all over the Roman Empire yet they were not organised as a political party. To these Christianity meant a great and much needed reformation.[46:1]

    The moral condition of the Empire, east and west, makes a dark picture as drawn by such men as Paul,[46:2] Seneca,[46:3] Tacitus,[46:4] Juvenal, Persius, and Sallust. "The world is full of crimes and vices" moaned Seneca. Foreign conquest and plunder brought in their wake luxury, sensuality, cruelty, and licentiousness. Slavery was fostered; infanticide tolerated; marriage lax, and divorce shamefully common.

    Amusements became bloody and brutal; 20,000 lives were sacrificed in one month to appease the populace, who cared only for "panem et circenses."

    The stern virtue and morality of old Greece and Rome were dead. The huge Empire was a giant body without a soul going to final destruction.

    It is evident, then, that forces both positive and negative were at work to prepare the civilised world for the reception of Christianity:

    (1) The universal Empire of Rome was a positive groundwork for the universal empire of the Gospel. The imperial organisation suggested a form of organisation for the Church, so that Latin Christianity was simply Rome baptised. The unity of the Empire afforded concrete illustration of God's spiritual kingdom, and implied fatherhood and brotherhood.[47:1] Imperial toleration of harmless provincial religions protected Christianity, and thus enabled it to get a foothold before persecution came. Universal peace also was a boon to the Christian crusade.

    The flourishing commerce, the good roads uniting the Empire, the extensive travel, and the various military expeditions all made the spread of new ideas easier and quicker.

    (2) Pagan theology became a stepping-stone to Christian theology.[47:2] The decay of polytheism, because of its unspiritual and unsatisfying character, made spiritual monotheism acceptable. Pagan temples, priests, and rites made the conception of, and the transition to, Christianity easier. Even the low moral condition and widespread skepticism strongly emphasised the need of a better religion.

    (3) The schools of the Empire prepared men's minds for an intellectual consideration of the new faith, though not necessarily for its adoption.

    The Greek and Latin tongues were excellent mediums for propagating the new doctrines. Greek particularly was excellent for the expression of abstract and lofty truth, and the Old Testament had been translated into it more than two centuries before Jesus.[48:1] Grecian eloquence became the model for sacred oratory. The philosophy of Plato and Aristotle formed the scientific basis for Christian theology. The spiritual flights of Plato,[48:2] the religious reflections of Plutarch, and the moral precepts of Seneca were all used as arguments of revealed religion. Even pagan art, with its love for the beautiful, was early employed to give material expression to Christian ideas.

    (4) The Jews, scattered over the world,[48:3] befriended by Julius Cæsar, given legal status as a sect by Augustus, expelled in vain by Tiberius and Claudius, spread a knowledge of the living God over the whole Empire before Christ appeared. Synagogues were numerous, and many Gentiles became converts to monotheism.[48:4] These converts were the first to accept the teachings of Jesus, and in this way formed the nuclei of the Christian Church.

    Thus Jerusalem the Holy City, Athens the city of culture, and Rome the city of power, combined to prepare the world so that the matchless ethical and religious teaching of Jesus of Nazareth could capture the hearts and heads of men, replace the national religions, and become realised in the outward forms and inward beliefs of the Christian Church, which was soon to exercise a controlling power in the civilised world.

    SOURCES

    A.--PRIMARY:

    I.--JEWISH:

    1.--Old Testament.

    2.--Old Testament Apocrypha. Transl. by E. C. Bissell, N.
    Y., 1865-80.

    3.--Josephus (37-103 A.D.), Antiquities, and The Jewish
    War
    . Various eds. Whiston the standard.

    4.--Philo Judæus (20 B.C.-40 A.D.), Works. Transl. by C. D.
    Yonge. In Bohn, Lond., 1854-5. 4 vols.

    5.--The Talmud. Transl. by Bodkinson and revised by Wise, N.
    Y., 1896.

    6.--Lardner, Jewish and Heathen Testimonies. Works, vii.,
    Lond., 1788.

    II.--PAGAN:

    =1.--Greek:=

    1.--The classics. Bohn Lib. Excellent. Fine transl. by W.
    H. Appleton, Bost., 1893.

    2.--Polybius (204-122 B.C.), Histories. Transl. by E. S.
    Schuckburgh. 2 vols. Lond., 1889.

    3.--Strabo (62 B.C.-24 A.D.), Geography. Transl. by
    Falconer and Hamilton, Lond., 1890. 2 vols. Bohn Lib.

    =2.--Latin:=

    1.--Virgil (70-19 B.C.), Works. Bohn Lib., 1894; Morley
    Univ. Lib., 1884.

    2.--Horace (65-8 B.C.), Works. Transl. by Lonsdale and
    Lee, Lond., 1873. Best complete Eng. ed. is by Wickham. 2
    vols. Oxf., 1887, 1892.

    3.--Livy (59 B.C.-17 A.D.), Works. Bohn Lib., 1850.
    Transl. by Stephenson, Lond., 1883-90.

    4.--Ovid (43 B.C.-17 A.D.), Works. Bohn Lib. Transl. by H.
    T. Riley, Lond., 1852.

    5.--Lucan (39-65 A.D.), Pharsalia. Transl. by H. T. Riley,
    Lond., 1853. Bohn Lib.

    6.--Seneca (3-65 A.D.), Works. Transl. by T. Lodge, Lond.,
    1620. Bohn Lib. has partial list.

    7.--Pliny (61-115 A.D.), Works. Transl. by Milmoth and
    Bosauquet, Lond., 1878.

    8.--Tacitus (54-119 A.D.), Works. Bohn Lib., 1848. 2 vols.
    Transl. by Church and Brodribb, Lond., 1877.

    9.--Juvenal (47-130 A.D.), Works. Bohn Lib. Transl. by
    Strong and Leeper, Lond., 1882.

    10.--Suetonius (75-160 A.D.), Lives of the Twelve Cæsars.
    Bohn Lib., 1855. Transl. by C. Whibley, Lond., 1899. 2
    vols.

    III.--CHRISTIAN:

    1.--New Testament. (27 canonical books).

    2.--New Testament Apocrypha. In Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib.,
    vol. 16.

    3.--Justin Martyr (103-164 A.D.), Apologies. Ib., vol.
    ii., 1-84; Am. ed., vol. i.

    4.--Tertullian (104-216 A.D.), Apology. Ante-Nic. Christ.
    Lib.
    , xi., 53-140. Several other transls.

    5.--Minicius Felix (?), Octavius. Ibid., xiii.

    6.--Eusebius (d. 340), The Evangelical Preparation. Transl.
    by H. Street, Lond., 1842.

    7.--St. Augustine (d. 430), The City of God. Nic. and
    Post-Nic. Fathers.
    Buf., 1886-90. ii., 16-621. Other
    transls.

    B.--SECONDARY:

    I.--SPECIAL:

    1.--Breed, D. R., A History of the Preparation of the World
    for Christ
    . N. Y., 1893.

    2.--Döllinger, J. J. I., The Gentile and the Jew. Lond.,
    1862. 2 vols.

    3.--Fisher, G. P., Beginnings of Christianity. N. Y., 1877.

    4.--Hardwick, C., Christ and Other Masters. Lond., 1875. 2
    vols.

    5.--Hausrath, A., History of the New Testament Times. Lond.,
    1895. 4 vols.

    6.--Maurice, F. D., Religions of the World. Lond. and Bost.,
    1854.

    7.--Pressensé, De E., Religions before Christ. Edinb., 1862.

    8.--Shahan, J. T., The Beginnings of Christianity. N. Y.,
    1904.

    9.--Trench, R. C., Christ the Desire of all Nations. Camb.,
    1846.

    10.--Uhlhorn, G., Conflict of Christianity with Heathenism.
    Lond., 1880.

    11.--Wernle, P., The Beginnings of Christianity. Lond., 1908.
    2 vols.

    II.--GENERAL:

    Alzog, i., § 24-31. Backhouse, E., Early Ch. Hist., ch. 1.
    Baur, i., 1-43. Blunt, J. H., Key to Ch. Hist., ch. 1.
    Bouzique, i., Intr. Burton, E., Lects. on Eccles. Hist. (to
    3d cent.). Catterille, H., Genesis of the Ch., ch. 1.
    Cheetham, ch. 1. Cox, H., First Cent. of Christianity, i.,
    chs. 1-10. Darras, i., ch. 1. Döllinger, Hist. of the Ch.,
    i., ch. 1, sec. 1-2. Duff, ch. 1-6. Farrar, F. W., Early Days
    of Christianity
    , bk. i., ch. 1. Fisher, pd. i., ch. 1.
    Gibbon, i.-ii. Gieseler, i., sec. 8-19. Gilmartin, i., sec.
    2-3. Guericke, pp. 21-28. Hase, 13-23.

    Hurst, i., 61-87.
    Jackson, F. J. F., Hist. of the Christ. Ch. (to 461), ch. 2.
    Janes, L. G., A Study of Prim. Christ., chs. 1-2. Killen,
    ch. 1. Kurtz, i., sec. 6-12. Milman, Hist. of Christ. (to
    4th cent.), ch. 1. Milner, i., cent. i. Moeller, i., 26-48.
    Mosheim, 11-30. Neander, i., 1-69. Robertson, bk. i., ch. 1.
    Schaff, i., ch. 1. Waddington, ch. 1.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [40:1] Mommsen, v., chs. 11-12; Merivale, i., ch. 1; iv., ch. 39;

    Liddell, ii., ch. 71; Bury's Gibbon, i., chs. 1-3; Finlay, i., ch. 1.

    [41:1] 1 Tim. ii., 2. Epictetus wrote: "Cæsar has promised us a profound peace; there are neither wars, nor battles, nor great robberies, nor piracy."--Dis., iii., 13.

    [41:2] Lewin, Life and Epistles of St. Paul. Lond., 1878. Bergier, Histoire des Grands Chemins de l'Empire Romain.

    [41:3] Merivale, iv., ch. 41.

    [41:4] The chief writers were: Ovid, d. 17; Livy, d. 17; Lucan, d. 65;

    Seneca, d. 65; Pliny, d. 115; Tacitus, d. 119; Juvenal, d. 130.

    [41:5] Schürer, ii., § 22; Graetz, i., ch. 20.

    [41:6] Plato, Protagoras, tr. by Jowett; Aristotle, Politics, bk. 8, tr. by Jowett; Mahaffy, Old Greek Ed.; St. John, The Hellenes, bk. 2, ch. 4; Davidson, Aristotle, bk. 1, ch. 4; The Nation, March 24, 1892, pp. 230-231; Zeller, Socrates and the Socratic Schools, ch. 3;

    Capes, University Life in Ancient Athens, ch. 1; Newman, Hist.

    Sketches, ch. 4; Thirlwell, Hist. of Greece, i., ch. 8.

    [42:1] Döllinger, Gentile and Jew, ii., 294-296; Kirkpatrick, Hist.

    Develop. of Super. Instr.; Am. Jour. of Ed., xxiv., 468-470.

    [42:2] Gieseler, i., § 11.

    [42:3] Döllinger, Gentile and Jew, i., bk. 7.

    [43:1] About the Republic, iii., 6; Virgil, Eclogues, iv., 4-10; 13, 14; Lactantius, Divine Inst., vi., 8; Suetonius, Life of Vesp., ch. 4; Tacitus, Histories, v., 13.

    [43:2] Gladstone, Gods and Men of the Heroic Age; Tyler, Theol. of the Greeks; Cocker, Christ and Greek Philos.; Niebuhr, Stories of Gr. Heroes; Berens, Myths and Legends of Anc. Gr.; Taylor, Anc.

    Ideals; Parnell, Cults of the Gr. States; Ely, Olympus; Francillon, Gods and Heroes; Grote; Curtius; Thirlwell.

    [43:3] Read Iliad, Odyssey and Hesiod, Theogeny.

    [43:4] Concerning the Republic, ii.

    [43:5] Adam, The Religious Teachers of Greece, Edinb., 1908. Baur, The Christian Element in Plato, Edinb., 1861; Hatch, The Greek Influence on Christianity. Hibbert Lectures, 1888.

    [44:1] Schürer, Hist. of Jewish People; Milman, Hist. of the Jews;

    Stanley Lect. on Hist. of Jewish Ch.; Ewald, Hist. of Jewish People;

    Edersheim, Prophecy and Hist. in Rel. to the Messiah; Kent, Hist. of Heb. People; Graetz, Hist. of Jews; Newman, Christianity in its Cradle. See Josephus for full account.

    [44:2] Jewish Encyc. See Josephus, Antiq., XIII., x., 5, 6; v., 9;

    XVII., ii., 4; XVIII., i., 2.

    [44:3] Jewish Encyc. See Josephus, Antiq., XIII., v., 9; x., 6;

    XVIII., i., 3; Wars, II., viii., 14.

    [44:4] Matt. xxii., 23; Mark xii., 18; Luke xx., 27; Josephus, Antiq., XVIII., i., 4.

    [44:5] Acts xxiii., 8.

    [44:6] It must be remembered that Nicodemus, Gamaliel, and others came from this class.

    [44:7] Jewish Encyc.

    [45:1] Josephus; Philo; Pliny; Lightfoot, Ep. to Gal.; Schürer, ii., 188; Jewish Encyc.

    [45:2] Jewish Encyc.

    [45:3] John iv., 4; viii., 48; Luke ix., 52, 53; x., 25-37.

    [45:4] Josephus, Antiq., XVIII., i., 1-6; Rhees, Life of Jesus; Jewish Encyc. Hastings, Dict. of the Bible.

    [46:1] Schürer, Jewish People, div. II., ii., 154-187; Wendt, Teachings of Jesus, i., 33-89; Graetz, Hist. of the Jews, ii., 122-123, 140-147; Edersheim, Life and Times of Jesus, i., 160-179;

    Rhees, Life of Jesus, sec. 13; Mathews, Hist. of N. T. Times, ch. 13.

    [46:2] Rom. i., 18-32.

    [46:3] De Ira, I., ii., c. 8.

    [46:4] Politica, I., ii., c. 2-18.

    [47:1] Tacitus felt a common humanity when he wrote: "Homo sum; humani nihil a me alienum puto." Cicero and Virgil expressed like ideas. In the Middle Ages it was even said that Virgil in the Fourth Eclogue prophesied the advent of Jesus. See Princeton Rev., Sept. 1879, 403 ff.

    [47:2] Ackerman, The Christian Element in Plato; Cocker, Christianity and Greek Philosophy; Hatch, Influence of Greek Ideas and Usages upon the Christian Church; Addis, Christianity and the Roman Empire, 22-25; Farrar, Seekers after God; Davidson, The Stoic Creed, N. Y. 1907.

    [48:1] The Septuagint version, 284-247 B.C.

    [48:2] Ackerman, The Christian Element in Plato.

    [48:3] Josephus and Strabo. Gieseler, i., § 17.

    [48:4] Apion, ii., 10, 39.

    CHAPTER IV

    ORIGIN, SPREAD, AND ORGANISATION OF THE CHURCH DURING THE APOSTOLIC AGE

    OUTLINE: I.--Origin of the Christian Church. II.--Spread of
    the Apostolic Church. III.--Organisation of the Early Church.
    IV.--Conclusions. V.--Sources.

    The Christian Church has both an internal and an external side--a soul and a body. Thoughts, feelings, and beliefs constitute the inner Church, the creed. These, in turn, aided by physical conditions, determine the outward organisation of the Church. In a broad sense the Church was a product of certain forces already in the world at the opening of the Christian era, which were utilised by the believers in the teachings of Jesus. From pagan and Jewish sources contributions were made to both the form and content of the Christian Church in the following ways:

    1. The Jews[52:1] gave in ideas: (a) a belief in Jehovah as God, (b) the

    conception of sin, (c) a consciousness of the need of repentance and reconciliation, (d) the doctrine of immortality, (e) the conception of Heaven and Hell, (f) angels and the devil, (g) miracles, (h) the Old Testament as God's word, and (i) the Sabbath. To the form of the Christian Church they suggested: (a) the synagogue, (b) officials like the elders, (c) ceremonies, (d) feasts,[53:1] and (e) organisation.[53:2]

    1. The pagans contributed in ideas: (a) Greek philosophy and

    culture,[53:3] (b) concepts of morality,[53:4] (c) the idea of absolute sovereignty, and (d) universality.[53:5] In form they gave: (a) local organisations like the democratic Hellenistic guild or municipality,[53:6] or the numerous Roman social or religious associations known as collegia and sodalitia (especially the collegia funeraticia), and the general organisation of the Empire[53:7]; (b) rites and ceremonies; (c) the evening meal,[53:8] (d) festivals like Easter and Christmas; (e) the use of images, and (f) architecture, painting, and ornamentation.

    1. The real founder of the Church, however, was Jesus Christ. He

    supplied the fundamental ideas of: (a) the universal fatherhood of God, (b) the divine sonship of the Saviour of the world, (c) the brotherhood of man, and (d) the ethical law of self-sacrifice. He created the Church: (a) by choosing twelve Apostles, by teaching them and by commissioning them to continue the work; (b) by winning a number of converts to His doctrines; (c) by leaving certain sacraments for His followers--Catholics say seven; most Protestants, two. But He left no written Church constitution giving the details of organisation. The work of Jesus and His immediate followers in founding the Church is described in the New Testament.

    Broadly, then, the Church of Jesus Christ is composed of all the believers in the teachings of Jesus, although differing greatly in interpretation and in organisation.[54:1]

    From Jerusalem the Apostles and disciples of Jesus spread his teachings to Syria, Asia Minor, Africa, Greece, and Rome. From these fields the propagation was continued until by the time of Constantine every point within and some places without the Empire were reached.

    "Throughout every city and village," enthusiastically exclaimed Eusebius, "churches were quickly established and filled with members from every people."[54:2] The fruitful labours of Paul and Timothy were explained thus: "And so were the churches established in the faith, and increased in numbers daily."[54:3] Other Apostles were, no doubt, equally active in various parts of the Empire.

    The "Christians"--a term of derision first used by the heathen of Antioch,[54:4]--numbering 500 in 30 A.D.,[54:5] grew to 500,000 by 100 A.D.,[54:6] and increased to 30,000,000 by 311 A.D.[54:7]--a growth almost unparalleled in the world's religious history. They included all the social classes in the Empire from slave to Emperor, though the great middle class was in all probability most numerously represented.[55:1]

    The causes for this marvellous growth[55:2] are found in: (a) the revolutionary teachings of Jesus, particularly the idea of immortality, which was very vague in heathen minds, and the law of love and self-sacrifice; (b) the miraculous powers attributed to the first Christians; (c) the purer and austerer morality of the early Christians; (d) the unity and discipline of the Church, making it a powerful organisation within the Empire; (e) the preparation and ripeness of the Empire for Christianity, and (f) the subjective vividness of the constant presence of Jesus with the early Christians, as explained by Paul, and their zealous propagandism.

    The results of this new life, brought into the world so dramatically, must be measured in terms of all subsequent history.[55:3] Every institution in the Empire was modified by this new spiritual force[55:4] so that as old pagan imperial Rome gradually fell, new Christian Rome took its place to rule all western Europe for more than a thousand years in every sphere of human activity and endeavour.

    The exact form of the organisation of the early Christian Church is extremely difficult to determine, because of the lack of sufficient positive authority in the New Testament and in patristic literature. The Acts of the Apostles and the letters of Paul and others to the first Christian communities tell nearly all any one can know about the origin and organisation of the Apostolic Church. From these sources it is clear that Jesus left certain great teachings, and many devoted believers in those truths.

    After His departure, the Apostles, not limited to twelve,[56:1] receiving authority directly from the Master,[56:2] like the prophets of old, spread the new pregnant faith over the world, organised their converts according to individual ideas and local needs,[56:3] and practically monopolised all direction of the Church.[56:4] With the increase of these Christian societies in size and numbers, came the necessity of appointing local officers, or of having them elected by the "brethren." In this way, at an early date, began the outward organisation of the Church.

    The development of the Jewish Kingdom of God into the Ecclesia of the Christians was a comparatively easy transition, especially for the Jewish converts.

    Next to the Apostles in point of time, but not authority, in the Biblical account, came the deacons. At Jerusalem the Apostles had the "brethren" select "seven men of honest report" to minister to the poor and unfortunate, and to wait on the table in the daily love-feasts.[56:5] They were installed by "laying on of hands." This democratic example apparently was followed elsewhere.[56:6] Both sexes were eligible.[56:7] The high qualifications for the office suggest its importance.[56:8]

    St. Paul tells us that the earliest Christian communities found it necessary to have some organisation, hence they chose bishops, or overseers, and presbyters, or elders. But throughout the New Testament the words elder, presbyter, and bishop seem to be used interchangeably.[57:1] The qualifications for the offices were the same.

    Bishops and elders are never joined together like bishops and deacons as if they were two distinct classes of officers. Timothy, for example, appoints bishops and deacons; Titus, elders and deacons.

    Paul sends greetings to bishops and deacons at Philippi, but omits all mention of elders and presbyters because, presumably, they were included in the conception of bishops.[57:2] In his pastoral epistles he describes all Church officers, but mentions only two classes, bishops or elders, and deacons.[57:3] Peter, who calls himself "also an elder," urges the elders to "tend the flock of God" and to "fulfil the office of bishop."[57:4] Even Clement of Rome uses bishop and presbyter interchangeably as late as 95 A.D.[57:5] Irenæus (d. 190) and Tertullian (d. 220), however, were conscious of a distinct division and differentiation.

    That the official titles, bishop and presbyter or elder, were used from early apostolic days, all must admit, for the New Testament evidence is unmistakable. But perplexity and doubt arise at once when an attempt is made to determine the resemblances and differences in their duties and powers. The term elder, or presbyter, may have been used merely to designate the personal relation of the most highly respected members to the congregation, while the name bishop, or overseer, may have been the official designation of leadership.

    Indeed some scholars, like Hatch and Harnack, believe that the functions of presbyters and bishops were distinct and different from the beginning. They assert that the college of presbyters assumed the leadership, or government proper, of the Christian community, with jurisdiction and disciplinary power, while the bishops had charge of the administration of the Church, including worship and finance, and were also largely occupied with charitable work, in co-operation with the deacons, such as care for the sick, the poor, and strangers.

    According to this view each congregation was organised with three sets of officers, namely, deacons, presbyters, and bishops, from the very outset. Gradually, however, an amalgamation took place. The bishops, with their practical information, received seats and votes in the presbytery and finally came to fill the office of presidency.

    It seems more probable, on the contrary, that these two titles simply signify the twofold origin of the early Christians, namely, from the Jews and the pagans. The word presbyter is of Hebraic derivation, while bishop is a pure Greek term. Consequently the tendency developed to use presbyter wherever the Hebrew element predominated, and, on the other hand, to employ bishop for Greek communities. It was but natural, too, that these two terms should come to signify the same thing and should come to be used interchangeably.

    The derivation of these terms is not clear.[59:1] Both presbyter and bishop appear to have been in use in Syria and Asia Minor to designate officers of municipal and private corporations. In Grecian civic organisations, the word bishop or superintendent was likewise commonly used. Then there were the well-known elders of the Jewish synagogue,[59:2] and the senators of Roman municipalities--in fact a universal respect for seniority existed in the old world.

    It was very natural, therefore, that the Christians should adopt the known forms, names, and offices of those organisations with which they were familiar.[59:3] This method of procedure is precisely the one followed over the world to-day in propagating any idea through organised effort.

    These elders were apparently organised into boards, or councils, for the purpose of better furthering the interests of the Church. They were not teachers at first so much as the administrators, or business managers, of the general concerns of the Church.[59:4] They helped to enact ordinances[59:5]; discussed important questions with the Apostles and assisted them in every possible way; enforced discipline[59:6]; settled disputes between Christians; and prayed for the sick and anointed them.[59:7]

    The first Christians, eagerly awaiting the literal second coming of Christ, and imbued with great enthusiasm for the Gospel, did not feel the need of an elaborate constitution. But in time, as numbers increased, as severe persecution fell upon the Christians, and as the original fervour and spirituality decreased with the conversion of so many pagans, it became necessary to develop a regular system of Church government, which would more effectively meet the new conditions. The fact of differentiation in organisation is easily established, because the earliest and later forms may be determined with reasonable accuracy, but the transitional process is much more difficult of comprehension.

    This evolution, however, appears to have taken this course:

    1. The board of presbyters, at least in the larger congregations,

    naturally and logically developed a head with a priority in rank. The office of president was universal in contemporary Jewish associations, and in Roman and Greek organisations. The creation of a chairman of the administrative body became a political necessity to expedite business, and to enforce discipline in the Christian societies.

    Moreover there was the example of the Apostles, who actually designated officers to continue their work (a) of teaching the true doctrines,[60:1] (b) of organising new churches, (c) of ordaining deacons and elders, and (d) in acting as head of the whole congregation.[60:2] Hence this change was natural, imperative, and easy; but the transition must have been gradual and must have lacked uniformity.

    1. The president of the board of presbyters came, in course of time, to

    have a recognised supremacy in power as well as in rank, and the title of bishop was gradually restricted to his high office. After the death of the Apostles more duties devolved upon the president of the council, and it was in the course of things that the special word bishop, i. e., overseer or superintendent, should be applied to him. By the second century, at least, if not indeed before, the differentiation had begun and from that time on it can be plainly traced in the Church Fathers.

    Jerome states that at Alexandria until the middle of the third century the presbyters elected one of their number as president and called him bishop.[61:1] Hilarius says: "Every bishop is a presbyter, but not every presbyter a bishop; for he only is bishop who is the primate among the presbyters."[61:2] Examples, secular and ecclesiastical, were not lacking to warrant the change: (a) the Old Testament priesthood, (b) Christ and his Apostles, (c) the Apostles and their appointees, (d) the Emperor and his officials.

    The bishop soon professed to occupy the place of an Apostle instead of Christ as earlier, hence arose the idea of an "Apostolic seat" and "Apostolic succession."[61:3] He represented Christian unity of doctrine and discipline, and ruled over a recognised territory--first a single church, then a city, then a province. From the bishop it was only another step to the archbishop, the metropolitan, the patriarch, and the Pope.

    1. The position of the presbyter changes, likewise, from that of the

    highest officer in the Church to one subordinate (a) to the board of elders and then (b) to the bishop. This distinction once made between bishop and presbyter, there was a tendency for the bishops to usurp more and more power, while the presbyters opposed it. The third century is full of these quarrels.[62:1] Here began the conflict between the principles of monarchy and aristocracy in the Church. Soon, from acting as a member of a council, the presbyter came to act alone under the bishop--i. e., the presbyter became a priest, just as the president became a bishop.

    Presbyters also assumed new functions: (a) "ministry of the word" and (b) "ministry of the sacraments." New detached communities were ruled not infrequently by single presbyters under the city bishop.

    Indeed it seems that from the outset the smaller and weaker Christian communities were ruled by single elders.

    1. The status and functions of the deacon likewise were altered. At

    first he visited the sick and unfortunate, collected and disbursed alms, and reported on discipline. Stephen taught; Philip baptised. With the growth of Christian civilisation, however, institutions of relief--hospitals, orphanages, infant asylums, almshouses, poorhouses, guest-houses, etc.--took the place of the earlier personal ministrations of the deacons. Each institution had its own head, not necessarily a deacon. From being distributors of alms, therefore, the deacon first became an assistant of the bishop,[62:2] and later the chief helper of the priest in the administration of the sacraments. With the multiplication of the duties of this office came the archdeacons and subdeacons.

    1. The many duties incident to a complex organisation gradually produced

    a new set of subordinate officials--the minor orders: (a) lectors to read the Scriptures in public and to keep the books, (b) acolytes to assist the bishops, (c) exorcists to pray for those possessed of evil spirits, (d) janitors to care for the buildings and preserve order, (e) precentors to conduct public praise service, (f) catechists to instruct the catechumens, (g) interpreters to translate the Scripture lesson.[63:1]

    1. The clergy came to be distinct from the laity--a sacerdotal class was

    developed. In the early Church the priesthood was universal, i. e., laymen as well as Church officers could preach, baptise, administer the sacraments, and exercise discipline. The relation of clergy to laity was merely that of leadership as in non-Christian organisations. "Ordination" simply meant appointment, and was used in civic installations, while "laying on of hands" was only a symbol of prayer and even used by the Jews for secular affairs.

    Gradually, however, the tendency to put the Church officials above the laity grew stronger until something akin to the Old Testament idea of the priesthood was revived. By the fourth century the Church officers had lost their primitive character and had become a separate class mediating between God and man.

    The causes of this separation are not difficult to see, namely: (a) the peculiar duties of the Church officials tended to give them a distinct character; (b) the persecutions to which the Roman government subjected them threw them into conspicuous relief; (c) the legalisation of Christianity bestowed upon them a distinct civil status, made them immune from public burdens like taxes and military service, exempted them from civil courts, and permitted them to acquire property; and (d) the rise of asceticism forced the clergy to observe a code of morals different from that of the laity, demanded celibacy, originated the badge of the tonsure, and created clergy-houses.

    The laity were early organised in congregations. Membership in the Church was open to all believers in Jesus. The election of officers was, for the most part, democratic. The life of each congregation was socialistic and communistic.

    All possessions were sold for the common good and to create a common fund for the needy.[64:1] The members enjoyed a common evening meal and their common love-feast which was to them the highest act of worship.[64:2] Disobedience, or infidelity, might be punished by private admonition, public correction, and in stubborn cases excommunication.[64:3] But after the first century these communistic-democratic societies were gradually replaced by a hierarchical organisation with new or modified institutions.

    The monarchio-episcopal principle of church government was gradually evolved but, nevertheless, much of the primitive democracy remained. This evolution in the government of the Church may be clearly seen by the end of the second century.

    From this discussion these conclusions may be drawn:

    1. The New Testament does not furnish a satisfactory model for any one

    distinct organisation of the Christian Church.

    1. In the New Testament, however, are found the germs from which sprang

    deacons, priests, bishops, metropolitans, patriarchs, and popes.

    1. The elements from which the Church was organised already existed in

    large measure in human society. Hence the Church, in its outward form, had a natural historical growth and was influenced by (a) the Jewish synagogue, (b) Greek municipalities, (c) the Roman government, (d) local needs, and (e) the conditions of the times. The animating principle and causal inspiration was Christianity.

    1. Christian society, like human society, was subject to constant change

    which is easily detected. The form of organisation, originally democratic, was gradually changed by the force of circumstances until it became monarchial and at the same time the officers underwent a similar transformation.

    SOURCES

    A.--PRIMARY:

    I.--JEWISH:

    1.--Josephus, Jewish War, Against Apion, Autobiography,
    Whiston ed.

    2.--Philo Judæus. Works. 4 vols. Bohn Lib., 1854-55.

    3--Talmud. Transl. by Rodkinson; rev. by Wise, N. Y., 1896.

    II.--HEATHEN:

    1.--Lucan, Pliny, Tacitus, Suetonius. See Chap. III. of this
    work.

    2.--Celsus (c. 178 A.D.), Against the Christians. Transl. by
    Lardner, Lond., 1830.

    3.--Porphyry (d. 306), Against the Christians. Ib.

    4.--Julian (d. 363), Against the Christians. Ib. Also
    Transl. by Nevins, Lond., 1873. Works. Bohn Lib., 1888.
    Transl. by Duncombe, Lond., 1784. Public Letters.
    Transl. by Chinnock, Lond., 1901.

    III.--CHRISTIAN:

    =1.--New Testament= (27 canonical books).

    =2.--New Testament Apocrypha.= Schaff, i., 188. Transl. in
    Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib., vol. xvi.

    1.--Acts. Transl. by Phillips, Lond., 1876.

    2.--Epistles--6 by Paul and 8 by Seneca.

    3.--Apocalypses--of the Apostles.

    =3.--Apostolic Fathers:=

    1.--Clement of Rome (97?), Epist. to the Ch. of Corinth.
    Best ed. by Lightfoot, Apost. Fathers, N. Y. 1891.

    2.--Ignatius (d. 70-115), Epistles (7). Ib. See Killen.

    3.--Barnabas(?), Epistle. Lightfoot; Cunningham.

    4.--Polycarp (d. 156), Epistle. Lightfoot; Jackson.

    5.--Papias (d. 153?), Fragments. Lightfoot; Hall.

    6.--Shepherd of Hermas(?). Lightfoot; Hoole.

    7.--Didache(?). Hoole; Hitchcock.

    =4.--Post-Apostolic Fathers:=

    1.--Justin Martyr (d. 164?), Works. Ante-Nic. Christ.
    Lib.
    , ii.; Am. ed., i.

    2.--Irenæus (d. 202?), Works. Ib., v., ix.; Am. ed., i.;
    Fathers of the Holy Cath. Ch., ch. 42.

    3.--Hippolytus(?), Works. Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib., ii.,
    130; vi., 15-403.

    4.--Victor (d. 200?), Works. Ib., xviii., 388-434.

    5.--Tertullian (d. 230?), Works. Ib., i., 408; ii., 25;
    iii., 118; xi., 53-140; xviii.; Am. ed., iii.-iv.

    6.--Origen (d. 254?), Works. Ib., ii., 1-3; x.; Am. ed.,
    iv.

    7.--Cyprian (d. 258?), Works. Ib., viii.; xiii., 1-264;
    Am. ed., v.

    8.--Dionysius of Alexandria (d. 264?), Works. Ib., xx.,
    157-265.

    9.--Tatian (d. 166?), Works. Ib., iii., 1-46; Am. ed.,
    ii.

    10.--Eusebius, Eccl. Hist. in Nic. and Post-Nic.
    Fathers
    . 1. Other translations.

    =5.--Collections:=

    1.--Apostolic Constitutions. Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib.,
    xvii. Am. ed., vii.

    2.--O'Leary, L. E., Apostol. Const. and Cognate Documents,
    N. Y., 1906.

    3.--Apostolical Canons. Tr. by R. C. Jenkins. Lond., 1856.
    See Harnack, Sources of the Apostolic Canons. Lond.,
    1895.

    4.--Conybeare, F. C., The Apology and Acts of Apollonius
    and other Monuments of early Christianity
    . N. Y., 1894.

    5.--Lardner, N. Jewish and Heathen Testimonials. In his
    Works, vii.-ix.

    B.--SECONDARY:

    I.--SPECIAL:

    1.--Allies, T. W., The Formation of Christendom, 4 vols.
    Lond., 1895.

    2.--Anderdon, W. H., Fasti Apostolici. Lond., 1884.

    3.--Anson, A. J. R., The Church: its Organisation in the Time
    of the Apostles
    . Lond., 1886.

    4.--Barnes, A., Organisation and Government of the Apostolic
    Church
    . Phila., 1854.

    5.--Bartlett, J. V., The Apostolic Age. N. Y., 1900.

    6.--Baumgarten, M., The Acts of the Apostles. 3 vols. N. Y.,
    1854.

    7.--Capes, J. M., The Church of the Apostles. Lond., 1886.

    8.--Catterille, H., The Genesis of the Church. Edinb., 1872.

    9.--Colman, L., Ancient Christianity. Phila., 1853.

    10.--Cox, H., The First Century of Christianity. Lond.,
    1892.

    11.--Cutts, E. L., Notes of Lessons on the Church in the New
    Testament
    . N. Y., 1892.

    12.--Davidson, S., The Ecclesiastical Polity of the New
    Testament
    . Lond., 1855.

    13.--Dobschütz, E. von, The Early Christian Communities. N.
    Y., 1903. Christian Life in the Primitive Church. N.
    Y., 1904.

    14.--Döllinger, J. J. I., The First Age of Christianity and
    the Church
    . 2 vols. Lond., 1877.

    15.--Fairbairn, A. M., Christianity in the First Century.
    Lond., 1883.

    16.--Falconer, J. W., From Apostle to Priest. Edinb., 1900.

    17.--Farrar, F. W., The Early Days of Christianity. N. Y.,
    1882.

    18.--Fisher, G. P., Beginnings of Christianity. N. Y., 1888.

    19.--Giles, J. A., Apostolical Records of Early Christianity.
    Lond., 1886.

    20.--Harnack, A., The Expansion of Christianity in the First
    Three Centuries
    . Lond., 1904-1905. 2 vols.

    21.--Hatch, E., Growth of Church Institutions. Lond., 1887.
    Influence of Greek Ideas and Usages upon the Church.
    Lond., 1890. Organisation of the Early Churches. Lond.,
    1888.

    22.--Hausrath, A., The Time of the Apostles. 4 vols. Lond.,
    1895.

    23.--Hinds, S., and Newman, J. H., History of the Christian
    Church in the First Century
    . Lond., 1862.

    24.--Hort, F. J. A., The Christian Ecclesia. Lond., 1897.

    25.--Jacob, G. A., Ecclesiastical Polity of the New
    Testament
    . N. Y., 1874.

    26.--Janes, L. G., Study of the Primitive Church. Bost.,
    1886.

    27.--Lightfoot, J. B., Apostolic Fathers. N. Y., 1891.
    Dissertations on the Apostolic Age. N. Y., 1892.

    28.--Maurice, J. F. D., Lectures on Ecclesiastical History.
    Camb., 1854.

    29.--McGiffert, A. C., History of Christianity in the
    Apostolic Age
    . N. Y., 1891.

    30.--Merivale, L. A., Christian Records. Lond., 1857.

    31.--Miller, E., The Priesthood in the Light of the New
    Testament
    . Lond., 1876.

    32.--Neander, A., Planting and Training of the Christian
    Church by the Apostles
    . N. Y., 1856.

    33.--Orr, J., Neglected Factors in the Study of the Progress
    of Christianity
    . N. Y., 1899. The Early Church: its
    History and Literature.
    N. Y., 1901.

    34.--Palmer, R., The Catholic and Apostolic Church. Lond.,
    1899.

    35.--Pressensé, E. De, Early Days of Christianity. 4 vols. N.
    Y., 1873-8.

    36.--Pryce, J., Notes on the History of the Early Church.
    Lond., 1892.

    37.--Ramsay, W. M., The Church in the Roman Empire. N. Y.,
    1893.

    38.--Reichel, C. P., The Origins of the Church. Dub., 1882.

    39.--Renan, E., Origins of Christianity. Lond., 1888.

    40.--Ropes, J. H., The Apostolic Age in the Light of Modern
    Criticism
    . N. Y., 1906.

    41.--Row, C. A., Apostolical Christianity. Lond., 1881.

    42.--Schaff, P., History of the Apostolic Church. N. Y.,
    1874.

    43.--Simcox, W. H., The Beginnings of the Christian Church.
    Lond., 1881.

    44.--Slater, W. F., Faith and Life of the Early Church.
    Lond., 1892.

    45.--Stanley, A. P., Apostolic Age. Oxf., 1874.

    46.--Tarrant, W. G., Beginnings of Christendom. Lond., 1893.

    47.--Taylor, I., Ancient Christianity. Lond., 1844.

    48.--Thatcher, O. J., History of the Apostolical Church. N.
    Y., 1893.

    49.--Thiersch, H. W. J., History of the Christian Church in
    the Apostolic Age
    . Lond., 1852.

    50.--Vaughan, C. S., The Church of the First Days. 3 vols.
    Lond., 1864.

    51.--Vedder, H. C., Dawn of Christianity. Phila., 1894.

    52.--Watson, R. A., Apostolic Age. Lond., 1894.

    53.--Weizsacker, C., The Apostolic Age. 2 vols. N. Y., 1894.
    Antiqua Mater. Lond., 1887.

    54.--Wernle, P., The Beginnings of Christianity. N. Y., 1902.

    II.--GENERAL:

    Alzog, i., 117-160. Backhouse, pt. i., ch. 1, 2. Baur, ii.,
    16-61. Blunt, i., ch. 2-5. Bouzique, i., ch. 1, 2. Bright, W.,
    ch. 1. Burton, ch. 8. Butler, ch. 2, 4, 5. Chantrel, ch. 1, 2.
    Cheetham, ch. 2, 4, 7, 8. Coxe, ch. 2. Crooks, ch. 3, 10, 18.
    Cunningham, lect. 1, 2. Dehorbe, ch. 28-32. Döllinger, J. J.
    I., i., ch. 1, sec. 4, 5; ch. 3, sec. 1-4. Duff, 79, 105, 108,
    110, 120, 139, 157, 226, 260, 304, 396. Fisher, pd. i., ch. 2;
    pd. ii., ch. 1, 2. Fitzgerald, i., 63-75, 118-129. Foulkes,
    ch. 1, 2. Gieseler, sec. 25-30. Gilmartin, i., ch. 4.
    Guericke, 106-139. Hase, 24-41. Hore, ch. 1, 2. Hurst, i.,
    61-149. Jackson, ch.

    3, 10. Jennings, i., ch. 1, 2. Killen,
    sec. 3, ch. 3. Kurtz, i., 22-36, 52-64. Mahan, bk. i., ch. 11;
    bk. ii., ch. 48. Milman, bk. i., ch. 1. Moeller, i., 62-68.
    Neander, i., sec. 2, 3. Newman, A. H., pd. i., ch. 1-3.
    Robertson, bk. i., ch. 8. Schaff, i., 187-217, 432-506. Sikes,
    ch. 2.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [52:1] Jewish Encyc.; Sorley, Jewish Christians and Judaism, London, 1881; Bettany, History of Judaism and Christianity, London, 1892; A History of Jews in Rome, B.C. 160-A.D. 604, London, 1882; Toy, C. H., Judaism and Christianity, Boston, 1891.

    [53:1] Moeller, i., 69.

    [53:2] Moeller, i., 55, 66.

    [53:3] Kurtz, Sec. 7, No. 4.

    [53:4] See Cicero, Seneca, Epictetus, and Marcus Aurelius. Read Baur, i., 10-17, Kurtz, Sec. 7, No. 2; cf. Foucard, Les associations relig. chez les Grecs, Paris, 1873.

    [53:5] Kurtz, Sec. 7, No. 5.

    [53:6] Hatch, 26-39; Kurtz, Sec. 17, Nos. 2, 3; Moeller, i., 66.

    [53:7] Tertullian, Apol., ch. 38, 39; cf. Mommsen, De collegiis et sodal. Rom., Kil., 1843.

    [53:8] Xenophon, Memorabil., iii., 14; Athenæus, Deipnos, vii., 7, 68, p. 365a; Fouard, St. Peter, 363.

    [54:1] 1 Cor. i., 2. Illustration of this variation is found in the fact that Calvinists and most Protestants believe the Church to be an invisible organisation, while Catholics, Lutherans, Anglicans, and oriental Christians hold it to be visible.

    [54:2] Euseb., bk. ii., ch. 3.

    [54:3] Acts xvi., 5; cf. Acts ii., 47.

    [54:4] Euseb., bk. ii., ch. 3; cf. Acts xi., 26.

    [54:5] Gieseler, i., 72.

    [54:6] Schaff, i., 196.

    [54:7] Orr, Neglected Factors, 23-91. Schaff, 197, gives only 12,000,000.

    [55:1] Orr, Neglected Factors, 95-163.

    [55:2] See Gibbon's "famous infamous," ch. 15.

    [55:3] Church, R. W., Civilisation before and after Christianity, N.

    Y., 1872.

    [55:4] See the works of Troplong, Schmidt, Uhlhorn, Lecky, Brace, Milman, Pressensé, etc.

    [56:1] 1 Cor. ix., 1, 5; xii., 28, 29; xv., 5, 7; Rom. xvi., 7.

    [56:2] 1 Cor. xi., 23; xii., 3-8; 2 Cor. x., 8; xiii., 10; Gal. i., 8, 9, 12; Eph. iv., 11.

    [56:3] Acts xiv., 23; Tit. i., 5.

    [56:4] Acts ii., 42; iv., 35, 37; v., 2.

    [56:5] Acts vi., 1-6.

    [56:6] Phil. i., 1; 1 Tim. iii., 8; iv. 14.

    [56:7] Rom. xvi., 1.

    [56:8] Acts vi., 1-6; 1 Tim. iii., 8-13.

    [57:1] Acts xv., 23; xvi., 4; xx., 17, 28; Phil. i., 1; 1 Tim. iii.; iv., 14; v., 17-19; Tit. i., 5-7; James v., 14; Clement, To Corinth, xlii., 44. Cf. Rev. iv., 4; v., 5, 6; vii., 11, 13.

    [57:2] Phil. i., 1.

    [57:3] 1 Tim. iii., 1-13; v., 17-19; Tit. i., 5-7; Heb. xi., 2.

    [57:4] 1 Pet. v., 1-2.

    [57:5] To Corinth, ch. xliii. The Didache and Shepherd of Hermas offer additional testimony on this point.

    [59:1] See various dictionaries of the Bible.

    [59:2] Ex. xxiv., 1; Num. xi., 16; Gen. l., 7-8; Lev. iv., 15; Deut. xxi., 19; 1 Sam. xvi., 4; Ezra v., 5; Psalm cvii., 32; Ezek. viii., 1;

    Acts iv., 8; Matt. xxi., 23; xxvii., 1; Luke xxii., 66.

    [59:3] Hatch, 62-66.

    [59:4] Hatch, 69-73; Acts xx., 28-31; 1 Pet. v., 1; 1 Tim. v., 17.

    [59:5] Acts xvi., 4.

    [59:6] Acts xx., 29-31, 35; Tertullian, Apol., 39.

    [59:7] James v., 14.

    [60:1] 1 Tim. i., 3.

    [60:2] Tit. i., 5.

    [61:1] Ep. 146, Ad Evangelum; cf. Ep. 82 and 84. Apost.

    Const., iii., c. 11.

    [61:2] 1 Ep. to Timoth., c. 3.

    [61:3] Hatch, 106-109.

    [62:1] Neander, i., 192, 193.

    [62:2] Hatch, 54.

    [63:1] Euseb., vi., 43; Neander, i., § 2; Kurtz, i., § 34; Alzog, i., § 83; Moeller, i., 234.

    [64:1] Acts ii., 44, 45.

    [64:2] Acts ii., 42, 46.

    [64:3] Mat. xviii., 15-18; Tit. iii., 10; 1 Cor. v., 5.

    CHAPTER V

    THE ROMAN CHURCH AND PETER'S PRIMACY

    OUTLINE: I.--Planting of the church in Rome and its
    organisation there. II.--The two opposing views of the Petrine
    theory. III.--Proofs advanced for the Petrine theory.
    IV.--Evidence given against the Petrine theory. V.--Historical
    conclusions. VI.--Sources.

    Reports concerning the teachings and labours of Jesus must have early reached Rome.[71:1] A perpetual stream of strangers and provincials flowed into Rome from every quarter of the Empire, hence every new creed, theory, and organisation was soon known in the capital.[71:2] Roman merchants, sailors, soldiers, or public officials, or the Jews, or the Greeks, might have carried news of the new sect to the heart of imperial power.

    Tertullian mentions the legend that Emperor Tiberius sought to include Jesus among the Roman gods, but his plan was frustrated by the Roman Senate.[71:3] Eusebius declared that this same ruler, "being obviously pleased with the doctrine," threatened "death to the accusers of the Christians."[71:4] It seems reasonable to conclude, then, that Christianity, soon after its birth, was introduced into the Eternal City.

    It appears clear, too, that Christian converts were early won in Rome, or else migrated thither from other parts of the Empire. It is not at all improbable that many of these early Christians in the capital were Jews.[72:1] Paul said that upon his arrival in Italy he "found brethren" at Puteoli and that a week later Christians came out of the city of Rome to greet him.[72:2] It is also quite probable that these various Christian communities in Italy had already created loose local organisations.

    Paul, during his prolonged stay in Rome, undoubtedly converted many to the new faith and laboured to perfect their Church organisation.[72:3] The magnificent work done by this Apostle in promulgating the new faith throughout western Europe was sealed by a martyr's death at Rome.[72:4]

    It appears, also, that the Apostle Peter laboured at Rome, probably after Paul, and completed the organisation of the Church. Tradition likewise gives him a martyr's crown. The Roman Church, therefore, founded by two Apostles and nourished by their heroic blood, was a double apostolic seat. This unusual origin, coupled with the fact of location in the heart of the world, together with a hundred other causes, made the Roman Church very conspicuous from the first and enabled it to become the determining factor in Western civilisation for fifteen hundred years.

    Under these circumstances it was but natural that the head of the Roman Church should come to have superior respect, primacy in rank, and leadership in power, first in Italy, and then throughout western Europe.

    The mother Church in Rome was imbued with great missionary zeal, and spread the new faith with extraordinary rapidity.

    In 64 A.D. the Christians in Rome, according to the heathen historian Tacitus, constituted a "huge multitude."[73:1] By 250 the Roman bishop ruled over forty-six presbyters, seven deacons, seven sub-deacons, forty-two acolytes, and fifty readers, exorcists, and porters.[73:2] The Christians in Rome, a city of possibly one million, numbered at least fifty thousand as estimated by Gibbon[73:3] and possibly three times that many as reckoned by later investigators.[73:4] Optatus, Bishop of Mileve in Numidia, asserted that in 300 there were forty churches in the Eternal City.

    While possibly a few churches may have been planted in western Europe independently, just as in Rome, still, in general, Christianity was disseminated throughout western Europe and the western part of northern Africa through the apostolic organisation in the capital city.

    Paul may have even made a visit to Spain.[73:5] Bede says that King Lucius asked the Roman bishop in 156 to send missionaries to Britain[73:6] and Tertullian confirmed the declaration.[73:7] In France a church was planted at Lyons in 177 and another at Vienne.[73:8] In the third century, asserts Gregory of Tours, seven Roman missionaries went to Gaul and there became seven bishops with subordinate churches. The famous St.

    Denis of Paris was one of these pioneers.[74:1] Christianity was likewise early carried into Germany (cis-Rhenana)[74:2] and across the Mediterranean to north-western Africa.[74:3] It is a matter of no great surprise, therefore, to see the Roman Church revered as the great mother Church of the West. Paul speaks of the faith of Rome as "proclaimed throughout the whole world."[74:4]

    The process of Church organisation at Rome was no doubt quite similar to that described in the preceding chapter, with this difference, however, that the episcopal system was either present from the time Peter and Paul appointed a successor, or at least began very early. Through his presbyters, or priests, the Bishop of Rome at first ruled over a number of separate communities in the city. As the faithful spread the gospel beyond the walls, churches were organised in the villages and jurisdiction over them became vested in priests sent out by the bishops.

    In time, however, the churches in the chief centres of population demanded bishops of their own; they were appointed, or elected, under influence from Rome, and, consequently, acknowledged allegiance to the Roman See. There is incontrovertible evidence that by the fourth century every city in Italy had a bishop. The village bishops naturally looked to the city bishops for assistance and advice. The city bishops similarly depended upon the bishop in the capital of the province, and the provincial bishop in like manner recognised the superiority of the bishop in the capital of the Empire. Thus the power of the Roman bishop was gradually extended first over Italy and then over western Europe.

    The consciousness of a unity of belief, unity of interest, and unity of purpose developed comparatively early among the churches. A name for this unity is first found in Ignatius and was the Universal or Catholic Church.[75:1] Before long the Bishop of Rome was to claim, by divine appointment and arrangement, sovereign jurisdiction over the great organisation.

    The classes won to the new faith in the city of Rome through the zeal of the Roman Christians included representatives from the slave to the imperial family. The earliest converts may have been the Jews, who were quite numerous in the Eternal City, and who best understood the significance of Christianity.

    The hope and faith and love of the new teaching appealed powerfully to the lowest social classes--the wretched slave and the impoverished freedman.[75:2] The need and the truth of this lofty, universal creed also won adherents from the great creative middle class--including not only the educated but also the soldiers, tradespeople, farmers, imperial officials, and skilled workmen.

    In fact the marvellous vitality and the unparalleled growth of Christianity in Rome can be explained satisfactorily only upon the supposition that the representation of this class was very great.[75:3] From the nobility converts were likewise secured and even in the Emperor's household followers were found.[76:1] In short, the whole social and moral structure of Rome was leavened by the new ideas.

    Along with this unparalleled growth of the power of the Roman bishop was created the Petrine theory destined to have a powerful effect on the history of the Church. Since an inquiry into this theory has a peculiar significance for the Roman Catholic, the Greek Catholic, and the Protestant, it is necessary to consider the subject rather carefully from the standpoint of both its advocates and opponents.

    The Roman Catholic belief is that Jesus came to organise His Church on earth; that He appointed Peter to be his successor and head of the Church; that Peter went to Rome, established the Church there in the great capital city, laboured as its head twenty-five years, and died there as a martyr; that Peter transmitted his leadership and primacy to the Bishop of Rome, whom he appointed as his successor, and who in turn transferred it to succeeding popes; that the Roman Church, therefore, is the only true Church, and that these contentions are conclusively proved from the Bible, the Church Fathers, traditions, and monuments.[76:2]

    The Greek Catholic view coincides with Rome in asserting the divine origin of the Church. A certain honourable primacy is conceded to the Apostle Peter; and to his successors at Rome, as patriarchs of the West, is granted a kind of supreme leadership in the Church. But the patriarchs of the East are put on an equality with the Pope of Rome, and thus the extreme claims of the Petrine theory are denied.

    Protestant opinion on the other hand takes two forms:

    1. The pro-Petrine view, held chiefly by the Episcopalians, maintains

    that Jesus turned His Church over to all His Apostles; that upon their death they transmitted their leadership to succeeding bishops; that Peter was in Rome and, with Paul, helped to organise the Church there, and appointed a successor through whom apostolic power has been transmitted to all bishops appointed by the Bishop of Rome, or by his appointees, where it now resides; that bishops and their successors appointed by Apostles other than Peter have just as much power as the Bishop of Rome, because the fruits of Peter's work are merely the most marked, but not necessarily the only divine or the most divine; that adequate proofs of this position are found in history, the Church Fathers, and the Scriptures.

    1. The anti-Petrine view, taken by most Protestants, asserts that Jesus

    left no Church organisation; that he did not appoint Peter as his successor; that whatever leadership Peter had, came from his temperament and natural ability; that there is no positive proof of Peter's being in Rome, consequently he could not have founded the Church there and named a successor; that therefore the Roman Catholic Church is not the only true Church, and that abundant proof of this position can be supplied.

    It may be well now to examine the proof offered in support of the Petrine theory under the four following heads:

    1. Peter's primacy. Jesus said to Peter, "Thou art Peter, and upon

    this rock I will build my Church; . . . And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven."[78:1] No such words were addressed to any other Apostle, hence Peter is the foundation-stone of the Church.

    Just as God changed Abram's name to Abraham, when he called him to be the father of a mighty nation, so Jesus gave Peter a new name.[78:2] Peter was chosen to be present with James and John on important occasions, like the healing of the daughter of Jairus[78:3]; the glorification of Jesus[78:4]; the struggle in Gethsemane[78:5]; and on all these occasions Peter is named first in the record.

    He likewise was the first to whom the risen Christ appeared.[78:6] Before His ascension Jesus gave Peter charge over His whole fold--laity, priests, and bishops,--when He commanded, "Feed my sheep," and twice repeated, "Feed my lambs."[78:7] These facts are sufficient, it is believed, to warrant the belief that Jesus appointed Peter to be the head of His Church.

    1. Peter's exercise of his primacy. Next to Jesus, he stands head and

    shoulders above all the other Apostles in his activity. The first twelve chapters of Acts are devoted to him.

    His name always comes first in the lists of Apostles, and Judas Iscariot's last.[79:1] He performed the first recorded miracle,[79:2] and was the first to address the Jews in Jerusalem, while the other Apostles stood around to see three thousand converted.[79:3] He was first to win converts from both the Jews[79:4] and from the Gentiles,--Cornelius and his friends.[79:5] He was the first to inflict ecclesiastical punishment on offenders.[79:6] He fought the first heretic in the Christian Church.[79:7] He made the earliest apostolic visitation of the churches.[79:8] When a successor to Judas was chosen, Peter alone spoke, and the other Apostles silently acted on his advice.[79:9] In the council of Jerusalem Peter first spoke, when the disputes ceased and "all the multitude kept silence"; even James obeyed.[79:10] James was beheaded by Herod, but no tumult resulted.

    Peter was imprisoned about the same time, and the whole Church was aroused about it.[79:11] St. Paul himself plainly admitted Peter's pre-eminence.[79:12] These deeds clearly indicate, it is contended, that Peter consciously exercised the primacy bestowed upon him, and that his fellow Apostles recognised it.

    1. Peter's visit to Rome, and martyrdom there. Peter's First Epistle,

    addressed from "Babylon," naturally interpreted, proves that he wrote it in Rome.[80:1] Clement of Rome (96 A.D.) said, "Let us set before our eyes the good Apostles,--Peter, who endured many labours, and having borne his witness, went to the appointed place of glory," etc.[80:2] Ignatius of Antioch (115), in a letter to the Romans, mentions Peter as having exhorted them.

    Papias (130) interpreted 1 Peter v., 13 to mean Rome.[80:3] Dionysius, Bishop of Corinth (170), wrote Soter, Bishop of Rome, about the common activity of Peter and Paul in Italy.[80:4] Irenæus (190) wrote, "Matthew . . . published his Gospel while Peter and Paul were preaching at Rome, and founding the Church there."[80:5] Clement of Alexandria (200) said that Peter, "the elect, the chosen one, the first of the disciples," preached at Rome.[80:6] Tertullian (200) positively asserted Peter's presence in Rome, and is the first to describe the manner of his death, in Nero's reign.[80:7] Origen (250) declared that Peter was the great foundation of the Church, and that "at last, having arrived in Rome, he was crucified, head downward, having himself requested that he might so suffer."[80:8] Commodion (250) named Peter and Paul as Neronian martyrs; and Caius, a Roman presbyter (250), makes a like assertion.[80:9] Cyprian (d.

    258) was the first to call Rome the locum Petri, while Hippolytus recorded Peter's conflict with Simon Magnus at Rome.[81:1] The Muratorian Canon referred to the "passion of Peter" in close connection with Paul's journey to Rome.[81:2] Peter of Alexandria (306) believed Peter was crucified there, and Lactantius accepted it as undoubted.[81:3] "The Doctrine of Addai" (fourth century) of the Syriac Church mentioned the "Epistles of Paul which Simon Peter sent us from the City of Rome."[81:4] Eusebius, using all previous testimony, made the most complete and convincing statement, which caps the climax of the overwhelming proof.[81:5] The "Deposito Martyrum" gave the report of the removal of the two Apostles' bodies in 258 to the catacombs.

    Jerome (d. 420) added the information that Peter laboured twenty-five years in Rome before his martyrdom.[81:6]

    1. Peter as the first Pope in Rome. With the establishment of Peter's

    primacy and his presence in Rome, it is certainly warrantable to conclude that he perfected the organisation of the Church there and served as its head until his death, when he appointed a successor.

    Clement (96) and Ignatius (115), Dionysius (170) and Irenæus (190), Commodion (250) and Lactantius (d. 330), all in speaking of Peter and Paul as founders of the Roman Church, always name Peter first. Ignatius spoke of the "presidency" of the Roman Church under Peter, and Tertullian (b. 160) asserted that Jesus gave the keys to Peter, the "Bishop of Bishops" at Rome, and through him to the Church. Origen (d.

    1. called Peter "the Prince of the Apostles" and "the great foundation

    of the Church." All the earliest lists of Popes began with Peter and indicate the transmission of his power.[82:1] Cyprian (d. 258) gave the complete statement of the primacy of the Roman bishop and the unity of the Church through Peter and Jesus.[82:2]

    This sums up, essentially, all the proofs offered in support of the Petrine theory, and constitutes, it must be confessed, a powerful and consistent case.

    It is necessary now, in the next place, to look at the evidence offered in opposition to the Petrine theory. For the sake of clearness, this evidence will be given under the four heads just employed:

    1. Peter's primacy. The famous passage, "Thou art Peter," etc.,

    correctly interpreted, does not warrant a belief in Peter's primacy. "Peter" may mean "rock" ("cephas"), but it here refers to Christ, not Peter, or to Peter's confession, just made,[82:3] or to Peter's faith, or to Peter merely as a type of all the Apostles.[82:4] Furthermore the commission to "bind" and to "loose" and the promise connected with it were not intended exclusively for Peter but for all the Apostles[83:1];

    Peter stood only for a type.[83:2] The change of Peter's name does not carry with it any special significance. Peter himself never mentioned his primacy in his speeches or writings,[83:3] and nowhere else in the New Testament is it distinctly stated or recognised by others. Whatever natural capacity for leadership Peter may have possessed, it cannot be proved that he received an official primacy. Such a position would have conflicted likewise with the supremacy of Jesus.

    1. Peter's exercise of his primacy. The numerous instances where Peter

    took the lead, or acted, or spoke first,[83:4] or where his name heads lists of Apostles,[83:5] merely show that he was a man of impulsive, aggressive character, who would and did naturally take the lead in powers common to all the Apostles.

    At the council of Jerusalem Peter did not preside, as he would have done if he was the recognised "Prince of the Apostles," but only made the first speech.[83:6] Paul would not have rebuked Peter to his face about some very important points had Peter been the recognised head of the Church.[83:7] Peter was a coward, braggart, and traitor, and was reproved again and again by Jesus Himself,[83:8] who would not have chosen such a person to be the head of the Church. There is not a single reference in the New Testament to show that Peter ever attempted to exercise a primacy over his companions. He called himself a fellow "elder."[84:1]

    1. Peter's presence in Rome. There is not a syllable in the New

    Testament to warrant the conclusion that Peter was in Rome. Inference alone makes "Babylon"[84:2] the Eternal City. On the contrary, there are implications in the Scriptures that he was not in Rome. Paul in his Epistle to the Romans greeted all his friends, but said not a word about Peter. This would clearly indicate that Peter had not been in Rome before this Epistle was written, nor at the time it was written. Again in letters written from Rome, Paul is strangely silent about Peter's presence.

    The claim rests wholly upon tradition, therefore, and that is far from conclusive. There is a significant silence from the time of 2 Peter until that of Clement (96). Clement, to be sure, mentions Peter's martyrdom; but it is only by inference that the place is Rome. Not until well on in the second century did the legend about Peter's connection with Rome begin to circulate, and not until the third century did Tertullian assert positively that Peter was martyred in Rome under Nero.

    After that the assertion was generally accepted over the Church as a truth.[84:3]

    1. Peter as the first Roman Pope. This, of course, is precluded by the

    want of adequate evidence of Peter's presence and labours in Rome.

    The evidence adduced here ends with the sweeping denial of every claim of the Petrine theory.

    Having now stated the two sides of the question here still remains the duty of making the historical summary from the sources available, namely, both the canonical and apocryphal books of the New Testament, and the traditional evidence in the Church Fathers.

    The New Testament, as the most important source of information, reveals Peter's birthplace,[85:1] occupation,[85:2] marriage,[85:3] call by Jesus,[85:4] and elevation to apostleship.[85:5] It shows the conspicuous leadership of Peter in the apostolic college--indeed, a primacy which Jesus Himself recognised,--yet leaves the character of that primacy and the power to transfer it to a successor open to question.

    The New Testament evidence does not give any clue to Peter's movements after Paul's notice of him in Galatians ii. except the reference in 1 Peter, which naturally, but not literally, interpreted might indicate that he was in Rome (Babylon).

    It likewise affords very scanty grounds, therefore, for believing that Peter first established the Church in Rome, or that he was the first Bishop of Rome, or that he conferred his power upon a successor.

    Traditional evidence, on the contrary, is more favourable to Peter's presence in Rome. No one can possibly doubt that the Petrine theory was generally believed in western Christendom at least after the third century. Prior to the third century, there are many streams of testimony which converge in positive support of at least a portion of the Petrine theory:

    1. The official lists and records of the Roman Church, some of which

    must rest upon earlier sources, accept the whole question as proved and recognised generally.

    1. The transference of Peter's remains to a new resting place in 258

    shows that the tradition was definite and unquestioned early in the third century.

    1. The writings of Caius, Origen, Clement of Alexandria, and Tertullian

    indicate that the theory was accepted in Asia, Alexandria, Carthage, and Rome at the same period.

    1. A passage from Irenæus, who probably used the official documents in

    Rome and who may have known St. John and his companions, carries the legend back to the second century.

    1. The testimony of Dionysius of Corinth (d. 165), Papias, and Ignatius

    (d. 114) carries the belief back through the second to the first century.

    1. The clear testimony of Clement of Rome makes a connecting link at the

    close of the first century.

    Hence when the various pieces of evidence--the official sources, the monumental testimony, and the writings of the early Fathers,--which are independent and consistent, are combined they form a solid body of proof, which is practically irresistible, that Peter was in Rome.

    Likewise the absolute absence of any rival tradition from other cities adds greatly to the probability.

    Peter's presence and death in Rome may be admitted as an established fact. If in Rome, whether one year or twenty-five years, Peter, with his aggressive nature, with his marked ability for leadership, and with his capacity for organisation, must have had a great deal to do with the establishment of the Roman Church, either jointly with Paul, or independently of him. Nor does it seem to be a misuse of the law of historical probabilities to assert that Peter, either with Paul or without him, appointed a bishop for the Church of Rome and transferred to that bishop his apostolic authority.

    From these facts, based almost entirely upon traditional evidence, coupled with the peculiar primacy conceded to Peter in the New Testament by his fellow Apostles, gradually developed the Petrine theory with all its sweeping claims.

    The admission of the belief that the Petrine theory is founded on certain established facts, and not merely on fancies and myths, does not carry with it the recognition of all the assertions which form a part of that theory. Peter's unique leadership in the apostolic college, his activity in founding the Roman Church, and his naming of a successor, who in time became the Pope, may all be granted without carrying with it the necessity of accepting the assertion that Christ chose Peter to be the head of a definite, divinely-planned Church and that Peter, conscious of that great mission, went to the capital of the Roman Empire, and there organised the only true Church on earth.

    SOURCES

    A.--PRIMARY:

    I.--CHRISTIAN:

    1.--=New Testament= (27 canonical books).

    2.--=New Testament Apocrypha= (see Chap. III).

    3.--=Church Fathers:=

    1.--Clement of Rome. Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib., i., ch. 5;
    iii., ch. 12 ff.; Am. ed., ix.

    2.--Ignatius. Ib., i., 137 ff., 449 ff.

    3.--Papias. Ib., i., 441 ff.

    4.--Dionysius of Corinth (d. 178?). Euseb., ii., 25.

    5.--Clement of Alexandria (d. 218?), Miscellanies.
    Ante-Nic. Christ. Lib., iv., 355; xii., 326, 379, 451,
    452; Am. ed., ii.

    6.--Irenæus. Ib., i., 261; Am. ed., i.

    7.--Tertullian. Ib., ii., 408; xv., 25; xviii., 118; Am.
    ed., iii., iv.

    8.--Origen. Ib., xxiii., 1-3; Am. ed., iv.

    9.--Hippolytus. Ib., ix., 130.

    10.--Peter of Alexandria (d. 311). Ib., xiv., 305, 318.

    11.--Caius of Rome (210?). Euseb., ii., 25; iii., 28; v., 28;
    vi., 20. Ante-Nic. Fathers, v.

    II. NON-CHRISTIAN:

    1.--Eusebius, Eccl. Hist. Many eds.

    2.--Socrates, Eccl. Hist. Nic. and Post-Nic. Fathers, ii.,
    109.

    3.--Theodoret, Letters. No. 86. Ib., iii., 282.

    4.--Josephus and Philo. See Chap. IV.

    5.--Heathen writers like Lucan, Pliny, Tacitus, Suetonius,
    Celsus, Porphyry, and Julian. See Chaps. III. and IV.

    B.--SECONDARY:

    I.--SPECIAL:

    1.--Allies, T. W., St. Peter: His Name and His Office.
    Lond., 1895.

    2.--Allmatt, C. F. B., Cathedra Petri. Lond., 1884. Was St.
    Peter Bishop of Rome?
    Lond., 1887.

    3.--Barnes, A. S., St. Peter in Rome and His Tomb in the
    Vatican Hill
    . Lond., 1900.

    4.--Berington and Kirk, Faith of the Catholics. 3 vols. N.
    Y., 1885.

    5.--Birks, H. A., Studies in the Life and Character of St.
    Peter
    . Lond., 1887.

    6.--Bright, W., The Roman See in the Early Church. Lond.,
    1896.

    7.--Brown, J. H., Peter the Apostle never in Rome. Lond.,
    1861.

    8.--Bruce, A. B., Training of the Twelve. N. Y., 1871.

    9.--Darby, W. A., St. Peter at Rome. Lond., 1872.

    10.--Ellendorf, J., St. Peter: Was He ever at Rome and a
    Bishop of the Church of Rome?
    Lond., 1887.

    11.--Fouard, C., St. Peter and the First Years of
    Christianity
    . N. Y., 1892.

    12.--Gallagher, M., Was the Apostle Peter ever at Rome? N.
    Y., 1894.

    13.--Green, S. G., The Apostle Peter: His Life and Letters.
    Lond., 1873.

    14.--Hatch, E., "Peter," Encyc. Brit.

    15.--Hodder, E., Simon Peter: His Life. Lond., 1893.

    16.--Kenrick, F. P., The Primacy of the Apostolic See
    Vindicated
    . Phil., 1855.

    17.--Lightfoot, J. B., St. Peter in Rome. Clement, ii.,
    481. Lond., 1890.

    18.--Littledale, R. F., The Petrine Claims. N. Y., 1889.

    19.--Livius, T., St. Peter, Bishop of Rome. Lond., 1902.

    20.--Murphy, J. N., The Chair of St. Peter. Lond., 1888.

    21.--Puller, F. W., The Primitive Saints and the See of Rome.
    Lond., 1900.

    22.--Ramsay, W. M., The Church in the Roman Empire. Lond.,
    1893.

    23.--Rivington, L., The Primitive Church and the See of St.
    Peter
    . N. Y., 1894.

    24.--Robins, S., Against the Claims of the Roman Church.
    Lond., 1853.

    25.--Robinson, C. S., Simon Peter: His Life and Times. 2
    vols. Lond., 1890-5.

    26.--Ryberg, A. V., Roman Legends about the Apostles Paul and
    Peter
    . Lond., 1898.

    27.--Simon, T. C., The Mission and Martyrdom of St Peter.
    Lond., 1852.

    II.--GENERAL:

    Alzog, i., 117-133. Backhouse, 76, 229. Bartlett, 297 ff., 364
    ff. Blunt, i., 10, 24, 28, 43, 45. Bouzique, i., ch. 1. Brock,
    ch. 2, 3. Cheetham, ch. 2, § 5; ch. 4, § 5. Cox, i., ch. 10,
    11. Darras, i., ch. 1-3. Döllinger, First Age, i., 71-83;
    ii., 115, 145; Hist. of Ch., i., ch. 3, § 4. Duff, ch. 7.
    Farrar, bk. ii., ch. 5-11. Fisher, 18, 20, 23, 26, 43, 57,
    106. Gibbon, ch. 9, 10. Gieseler, i., § 27. Giles, ch. 16.
    Gilmartin, i., ch. 2, pp. 28, 29. Greenwood, i., ch. 1-3.
    Hase, 30. Hurst, i., 104-106, 325. Jackson, ch. 3, 11.
    Jennings, i., ch. 1. Killen, § 1, ch. 10. Kurtz, i., 45.
    Mahan, bk. i., ch. 8.

    Milman, i., ch. 1. Milner, i., cent. 1,
    ch. 12. Moeller, i., 345. Neander, Planting, etc., i., bk.
    iv., ch. 2; Ch. Hist., i., 84, 203, 211. Pressensé, Early
    Years of Christ.
    10 ff., 64, 176. Renan, The Apostles, ch.
    6. Robertson, bk. i., ch. 8, p. 160. Schaff, Apost. Age, bk.
    i., ch. 4; Ch. Hist., pd. i., ch. 4. Stanley, Apost. Age,
    1-5, 56-114. Walpole, ch. 1-3.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [71:1] Moeller, i., 67, 75; cf. Acts xviii., 1-3.

    [71:2] Gibbon, i., 579.

    [71:3] Apol., 5; Suetonius, Life of Claudius, 25.

    [71:4] Euseb., ii., c. 2.

    [72:1] Shortly before the Christian era the Jews were so numerous that 8000 could sign a petition to the Emperor.--Josephus, Antiq., xvii., c. 11.

    [72:2] Acts xxviii., 14-16; Ramsay, St. Paul, ch. 15.

    [72:3] Acts xxviii., 24, 30, 31.

    [72:4] Euseb., ii., c. 22.

    [73:1] Annals, xv., 44.

    [73:2] Euseb., vi., c. 43.

    [73:3] Gibbon, i., ch. 15.

    [73:4] Orr, Neglected Factors, 39.

    [73:5] Rom. xv., 24; Muratorian Fragment; Clement of Rome, To Corinth, c. 5; Alzog, i. 125; Kurtz, i., 44.

    [73:6] Eccl. Hist., c. 4.

    [73:7] Against Jud., c. 7.

    [73:8] Euseb., v., c. 1.

    [74:1] Annales Francorum.

    [74:2] Irenæus, Against Her., i., c. 10.

    [74:3] Tertullian, Apol., c. 37; Cyprian, Ep., 71, 73; Augustine, On Bap., ii., c. 13.

    [74:4] Rom. i., 8.

    [75:1] The pagan writer Celsus was familiar with this idea as early as 161 A.D.

    [75:2] But nothing could be farther from the truth than Gibbon's statement that the Christians were won "almost entirely" from the "dregs of the populace." See Orr, Neglected Factors.

    [75:3] Ramsay in his Church in the Roman Empire, 57, goes so far as to say that the new faith "spread at first among the educated more rapidly than among the uneducated." This statement, however, is probably an exaggeration. See an excellent discussion in Orr, Neglected Factors, 95-163; Merivale, The Romans under the Empire, ch. 54.

    [76:1] Phil. iv., 22; Lightfoot, Philippians, 171 ff.; Howson, St.

    Paul, ch. 26; Weizäcker, Apost. Age, ii., 132; Harnack, Princeton Rev., 1878, p. 257; Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iii., c. 18.

    [76:2] Alzog, i., §§ 48, 52, 53; Berington and Kirk, ii., 1-113;

    Gibbons, Faith of Our Fathers; Cath. Encyc.

    [78:1] Matt. xvi., 18, 19. In Syro-Chaldaic, the tongue probably used by Jesus, "Peter" means "rock" or "cephas." The only parallel in modern languages is in French: "Tu es Pierre, et sur cette pierre," etc. Cf. John i., 42.

    [78:2] John i., 42.

    [78:3] Mark v., 37; Luke viii., 51.

    [78:4] Matt. xvii., 1; Mark ix., 2; Luke ix., 28.

    [78:5] Matt. xxvi., 37; Mark xiv., 33.

    [78:6] Luke xxiv., 12, 34; cf. John xx., 2-10; Weizäcker, i., § 3.

    [78:7] Luke xxii., 31-32; John xxi., 15-18.

    [79:1] Matt. x., 2-4; Mark iii., 16-19; Luke vi., 14-16; Acts i., 13.

    [79:2] Acts iii., 1-12.

    [79:3] Acts ii., 14-41.

    [79:4] Acts ii., 41.

    [79:5] Acts x.

    [79:6] Acts v., 1 ff.

    [79:7] Acts viii., 21.

    [79:8] Acts ix., 32.

    [79:9] Acts i., 13-26.

    [79:10] Acts xv., 6-12.

    [79:11] Acts xii.

    [79:12] Gal. i., 18; ii., 11.

    [80:1] 1 Peter v., 13. St. John everywhere in his Apocalypse calls Rome Babylon: xiv., 8; xvii., 18.

    [80:2] 1 Ep. to Corinth, Sec. 5.

    [80:3] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., ii., c. 15; iii., c. 39.

    [80:4] Ib., ii., c. 25.

    [80:5] Against Heresy, iii., 3, No. 2.

    [80:6] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vi., c. 14.

    [80:7] De Præsc. Hæret. c. 36.

    [80:8] Cf. Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iii., c. 1.

    [80:9] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., ii., c. 25.

    [81:1] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., ii., c. 13, 14.

    [81:2] James, Apocr. Anecdota, ii., p. x.

    [81:3] Inst. Div., iv., 21.

    [81:4] Cureton, Ancient Syriac Docs., 33.

    [81:5] Eccl. Hist., ii., c. 14, 15, 17, 25; iii., 21, 31; v., 6.

    [81:6] For passages from later writers consult Lipsius, 236, Ramsay, Harnack, Farrar, Lightfoot, McGiffert, Schaff, Renan, Neander, Lea, Kurtz, Hase, Moeller, etc.

    [82:1] Hegesippus made a list of bishops in Rome in the time of Anicetus (155-168) but it is now lost (Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iv., c. 22).

    Eusebius used that list, and also gave two lists of his own in Greek with Peter as the first (Chronicon, ii.; Eccl. Hist., v., c. 6). The first Latin list is the Catalogus Liberianus (352?), based upon earlier lists. St. Augustine (Ep. 53) and Optatus (Donatist Schism, ii., 3) both give Latin lists. These lists show how early the whole Church recognised the importance of the succession of Roman bishops. The list made out by Irenæus in the time of Bishop Eleutherus (174-189) gives Peter and Paul as the joint founders of the Church.

    [82:2] Epistles 43, 5; 55; 59, 7 and 14; 71, 3; 73, 7; 75, 17; Ante-Nic. Fathers, v., 263-596; Robinson, Readings, i., ch. 4.

    [82:3] Matt. xvi., 16.

    [82:4] Lightfoot, Clement, ii., 481-490; Hort, Ecclesia, 16.

    [83:1] Matt. xviii., 18.

    [83:2] John xxi., 15-18; Luke xxii., 31, 32.

    [83:3] Cf. Acts; 1 Pet. 1-3; 2 Pet.

    [83:4] Acts i., 13-26; ii., 14-41; iii., 1-12; x.; xv., 7-12, etc.

    [83:5] Matt. x., 2; xvii., 1; xxvi., 37; Mark iii., 16; v., 37; ix., 2; xiv., 33; Luke vi., 14; viii., 51; ix., 28; Acts i., 13.

    [83:6] Acts xv., 1-11.

    [83:7] Gal. ii., 11-14.

    [83:8] Luke xxii., 31; John xiii., 36-38; Matt. xvi., 23, etc.

    [84:1] 1 Pet. v., 1. See 2 John i., 1; 3 John i., 1.

    [84:2] 1 Pet. v., 13.

    [84:3] Cf. Lipsius for a full discussion of the so-called "Simonian theory."

    [85:1] John i., 44.

    [85:2] Matt. iv., 18; Mark i., 16-20.

    [85:3] Matt. viii., 14; Mark i., 29-31; Luke iv., 38.

    [85:4] Matt. iv., 18; xix., 27; Mark i., 16; John i., 35, 40, 51; Luke v.; xviii., 28.

    [85:5] Mark iii., 13-19; Luke vi., 12-16.

    CHAPTER VI

    THE ROMAN GOVERNMENT'S TREATMENT OF THE CHRISTIANS

    OUTLINE: I.--Religious persecutions before the Christian era.
    II.--Christians first persecuted by the Jews. III.--Causes and
    motives of persecution by the Roman government. IV.--Number
    and general character of the persecutions. V.--Results of
    persecutions. VI.--Sources.

    Religious persecution originated long before the Christian era began--in fact it runs through the whole history of religion. In Rome all citizens were required by law to conform to the Roman religion so that the gods would protect the state. Refusal brought punishment, but always on political grounds.[91:1] Foreign religions which were either harmless or helpful were often adopted, or at least tolerated.[91:2] Those, however, which were dangerous to public morality, social order, or political security, and which were not tolerant of other religions, were severely treated by the Roman government.

    This was the Roman legal principle of procedure in the case of every such religion,[91:3] hence when Christianity appeared, Rome had already developed a distinct policy which first tolerated and then persecuted it.

    Persecution came to the Christians first from the Jews. Had not these deserters of their fathers' faith precipitated Roman hatred upon the Jews which resulted in persecution, expulsion, and loss of freedom and independence?[92:1] Might not the Jewish religion be greatly weakened if this proselyting continued? Hence the Christians were persecuted individually and in masses.[92:2] The Jews sought in every possible way to incite the Roman authorities against the hated Christians.[92:3] This resulted in an irreparable breach between the two sects.

    The Christians were brought into greater prominence, and the Romans even sought to protect them from the Jewish fanatics.[92:4] At the same time a greater Christian zeal was aroused, and thus the spread of the new faith was promoted.

    The Roman government tolerated the Christians at the outset, because they were regarded as a harmless sect of Jews, whose work was quiet and unobtrusive.[92:5] The significance of Christianity was not understood, nor the marvellous spread of the faith noticed. Indeed Roman hostility to the Jews led at first to personal and official protection of the supporters of the new faith, until the Jewish War in 70 A.D.

    The Roman policy soon changed, however, from that of indifference, or protection, to persecution. The causes for this change are: (1) The political science of the Roman Empire, and (2) the inherent character of Christianity.

    Ethically the Roman state embodied the highest good, hence all human good depended upon the integrity and security of the state. That principle subordinated the religious to the political, and made the Emperor the head of all recognised religions.

    Roman law upheld this theory, as clearly stated by Cicero: "No man shall have for himself particular gods of his own; no man shall worship by himself new or foreign gods, unless they are recognised by the public laws."[93:1] Julius Paulus, a Roman citizen, stated the idea thus: "Whoever introduces new religions, the tendency and character of which are unknown, whereby the minds of men might be disturbed, should, if belonging to the higher rank, be banished; if to the lower, punished with death." Gaius said of forbidden associations: "Neither a society, nor a college, nor any body of this kind, is conceded to all persons promiscuously; for this thing is regulated by laws, or codes of the Senate, and by imperial constitutions."[93:2] Hence from a legal standpoint Christianity was illegal, because it introduced a new religion not admitted into the class of religiones licitæ.

    "You are not permitted by the law," was the taunt of pagans.[93:3] To organise churches and to hold unlicensed meetings were violations of Roman law.

    Might they not easily serve as covers for political plots? Mæcenas advised Augustus: "Worship the gods in all respects in accordance with the laws of your country, and compel all others to do the same.

    But hate and punish those who would introduce anything whatever alien to our customs in this particular . . . because such persons, by introducing new divinities, mislead many to adopt foreign laws. Hence conspiracies and secret combinations--the last things to be borne in a monarchy."[94:1] Roman citizens, therefore, who turned Christian were criminals, outlaws, bandits, and traitors; consequently the best Emperors, those who felt called upon to enforce the law for the weal of the Empire, those who wished to restore the vigour and power of old Rome, sought to exterminate them, while the worst rulers were mostly indifferent, and in some instances tolerant.

    Christianity, inherently, was opposed to the whole governmental, social, and religious systems of Rome in the most offensive and uncompromising manner. It advocated one God for all men, one universal kingdom, one brotherhood of all men, and one plan of salvation. It was world-wide, above the Emperor, and advocated a non-Roman unity.

    The Christians were subjects of God's kingdom first, and the Emperor's next; and when Rome spurned this secondary allegiance they ceased to feel themselves Romans at all.[94:2] They refused the duties of loyal citizens, held no offices, objected to military service,[94:3] and refused to sacrifice to the honour of the Emperor.[95:1] "Does not the Emperor punish you justly?" asked Celsus. "Should all do like you he would be left alone--there would be none to defend him.

    The rudest barbarians would make themselves masters of the world." Furthermore the Christians claimed the exclusive possession of divine knowledge and called all forms of pagan worship idolatrous.[95:2] Christianity itself was intolerant of all other religions. Was not Christianity the only true faith?

    How then could the Christians compromise with false faiths, or concede to them any truth, or any right to exist?[95:3] Hence it was inevitable, and Christians were keenly conscious of the fact, that a conflict should arise between Christianity and the Roman Empire, before the universal dominion of the world could come. The efforts of imperial officers to compromise matters, by insisting on mere outward conformity, met with little success.

    The attack made by paganism on Christianity came first from Roman philosophers, scholars, and statesmen for all sorts of motives. Some desired popular favour, others were sincere, still others sought to win imperial approval. Many, no doubt, even though they had no longer any heart for the ancient faith, yet could not bear to see it abolished.

    They would agree with Cæcilius that "Since all nations agree to recognise the immortal gods, although their nature or their origin may be uncertain, I cannot endure that any one swelling with audacity and such irreligious knowledge should strive to dissolve or weaken a religion so old, so useful, so salutary."[96:1] Tacitus called Christians "haters of mankind," and assailed their religion as a "destructive superstition."[96:2] Suetonius denounced the new faith as a "poisonous or malignant superstition." Others scoffed at these odd devotees as "dangerous infidels," "enemies of Cæsar and of the Roman people," and "a reprobate, unlawful, desperate faction." Priests, driven on by duty and possibly fearing the loss of their offices, added their sacred voices to the popular clamour.[96:3] Merchants and artists, whose livelihood depended upon the sale of their products and wares to pagan temples and worshippers, raised their voices against the new sect "without altars, without temples, without images, and without sacrifices."[96:4] Then the populace, incited by the above-named classes, took up the opposition and soon spread the wildest reports.[96:5]

    Christians were also declared to be responsible for every disaster like war, famine, fire, pestilence, flood, earthquakes, death of prominent persons, etc. The gods, angered at the presence of such persons, sent these dire calamities[96:6] on the atheists, who denied the many gods and worshipped but one, and who discarded all images--even that of the Emperor.[96:7] Did they not adore the wood of a cross and worship the head of an ass?[97:1] Did they not refuse to conform to all religious observances and festivals?

    Who but dangerous conspirators would hold their meetings in secret at night? These anarchists who refused all civic service[97:2]; these social revolutionists who broke up family ties,[97:3] set slave against master, taught robbery under the guise of equality, refused to enjoy the social games and festivals, and interfered with business; these cannibals who ate the flesh and drank the blood of their infants, the offspring of their incestuous and adulterous carousals--what punishment could be too severe for such degenerates?

    Were they not a Jewish sect which had deserted the faith of their fathers, and which could command respect neither for age nor legality?[97:4]

    The occasion for the inevitable war between the Roman sword and the Christian cross was popular hatred and ridicule, and the frequent outbreaks of the mobs. The fundamental cause was political necessity, for the Christians were guilty of crimen læsæ majestatis, high treason. Christianity in the Roman Empire was somewhat like anarchy to-day in the United States in its relation to the state.

    The technical charges made against the Christians were: (1) introducing a religio illicita, for which the penalty was death or banishment; (2) committing læsa majestas, for which the penalty was loss of social rank, outlawry, or death by sword, fire, or wild beasts; (3) being guilty of sacrilegium, for which the penalty was death by crucifixion, the ax, or wild beasts; (4) practising magic, for which the penalty was crucifixion, or exposure to wild beasts in the circus.

    Both the number and character of the persecutions seem to be misunderstood. The Church Fathers and many later historians magnify the number, fierceness, and duration of the persecutions, and the number killed.[98:1] On the contrary it seems that considerable time elapsed before the Christians were noticed by the government, which then proceeded against them with caution and reluctance and punished them in comparative moderation.[98:2] The Church enjoyed many seasons of rest and peace.

    The number of Christians killed during the entire period of persecution was comparatively small.[98:3] The persecutions varied with the whims and feelings of each Emperor--the best rulers like Trajan, Marcus Aurelius, Decius, and Diocletian, feeling the necessity of upholding the law, were the most energetic persecutors, while the worst Emperors were indifferent, or even favourable. The early persecutions were only spasmodic outbreaks and limited; the later ones were general.

    There is no reason for giving ten as the number of the persecutions--nor for comparing them with the ten plagues of Egypt.

    The first persecution occurred in Rome under Nero in 64 A.D.[99:1] Some historians contend that the Neronian persecution fell upon the Jews, whom Tacitus, writing fifty years after the event, erroneously calls Christians.[99:2] Others maintain that the Jews, through court influence, shifted the punishment from themselves to the Christians.[99:3] Recent scholars, however, are inclined to accept the literal narrative of Tacitus.[99:4] According to his version of the situation, the persecution was accidental--a device of Nero to divert the suspicion directed against himself of having burned Rome--and local, that is, it did not extend to the provinces.

    A few Christians were tortured and compelled to confess themselves guilty of incendiarism and to give the names of others, and that led to the punishment of an "ingens multitudo" as Nero's scapegoats.[99:5] As a punishment for their alleged crime of incendiarism and "hatred for the human race," they were covered with the skins of wild beasts and torn to pieces by the dogs in the circus, crucified by day, and burned as torches by night.[100:1] Paul, in all likelihood, fell a victim to this persecution and the Roman Church has always believed that Peter also perished at this time.[100:2]

    As a result, the attention of the Roman government was directed to these "haters of the human race," and they became branded as outlaws and brigands. Popular fury ran riot. A precedent was established, both in Rome and the provinces, for punishing Christians for the name alone.[100:3] Nevertheless sympathy was won for them, they secretly increased in numbers, and were compelled to adopt a better organisation in order to resist oppression. Above everything else the striking difference between the Kingdom of God and the Empire of Cæsar was strongly marked on the Christian conscience.

    After Nero's persecution, under the Flavian Emperors (68-96), there was a standing law against Christianity, like that against brigandage, but it was only occasionally enforced.[100:4] There is no positive proof of persecution under Vespasian (69-79). Titus (79-81), however, continued the policy of Nero.[100:5] Under Domitian (81-96) there was increased severity in both Rome and the provinces. This may have been occasioned in part by the fact that as a result of the Jewish War all toleration for the Jews was withdrawn.

    Christians were now classed with the hated Jews. Flavius Clemens, the Emperor's cousin, was executed and his beautiful wife Domitilla was banished.[101:1] Many others were killed, compelled to fight wild beasts in the arena, or at least lost their property.[101:2] It was even reported that Domitian planned to have all the relatives of Jesus slain in order to prevent the rise of a possible rival in the east.[101:3]

    Of "the Five Good Emperors" (96-180) who succeeded the Flavian rulers, three continued the policy of persecution. The first, Nerva (96-98), was tolerant to the Christians. The next Emperor, Trajan (98-117), one of the best Emperors, was not a wanton persecutor,[101:4] but felt it to be his duty to uphold the laws and religion of the Empire.[101:5] He was really the first Emperor to proceed against Christianity from a purely legal point of view. By this time Christianity was clearly recognised as a distinct sect and its real significance appreciated.

    His policy may be clearly seen in his correspondence with Pliny, the governor of Bithynia (112).[101:6] No doubt his views were influenced by Tacitus and Pliny, who regarded Christianity as a "bad and immoderate superstition." Still under Trajan persecution was limited to Bithynia, Jerusalem, and Antioch, although Christianity had been formally proscribed everywhere, together with all secret societies. His attitude was the model for persecutions of the second century and later.[102:1]

    Hadrian (117-138), who apparently judged Christianity rather trivially, issued the famous rescript which forbade riotous proceedings, on the one hand, and malicious information against the Christians on the other: "If any one, therefore, accuses them and shows that they are doing anything contrary to the laws, do you pass judgment according to the crime.

    But, by Hercules! if any one bring an accusation through mere calumny, decide in regard to his criminality and see to it that you inflict punishment."[102:2] Hadrian's adopted son and successor, Antoninus Pius (138-161), a wise, upright ruler, interfered to protect Christians at Athens and Thessalonica.

    His edict, given in Eusebius, is probably spurious, though the spirit may be correct.[102:3] Marcus Aurelius (161-180), an educated Stoic and an excellent Emperor, encouraged persecution against those guilty of "sheer obstinacy." Public calamities had again aroused the mob against the Christians. The imperial decree, "not fit to be executed even against barbarous enemies," authorised the use of torture to discover Christians and to compel them to recant, and also ordered the confiscation of property.

    This order to seek out Christians, and not await formal complaints, seems to mark a new step in imperial legislation. Still persecution was not general, but confined to Lyons and Vienne in southern Gaul, and to Asia Minor.[103:1]

    The period from 180 to 249 saw no essential changes.[103:2] Persecutions were merely local, and depended more upon provincial feeling and the character of the governor, than on the Emperor. Some of the Emperors were friendly to the new religion, others quite hostile.

    Commodus (180-193), dissolute, timid, and cruel, was friendly to the Christians owing, probably, to the influence of his favourite concubine, Marcia, who may have been a Christian.[103:3] Septimus Severus (193-211), an able soldier, was indifferent to the new faith up to 202, when he issued a rescript forbidding pagans from becoming Christians, and enforced the old Trajan law with considerable severity.[103:4] Caracalla (211-217) and Heliogabalus (218-222), two of the most contemptible Roman rulers, both tolerated Christianity.

    The former recalled banished Christians; the latter sought to merge Christianity into his own elective system of religion. Alexander Severus (222-235) actually gave Christianity a place in his cosmopolitan faith, had a bust of Jesus set up in his private chapel, allowed churches to be built, and protected the Christians.

    But Christianity was not legalised. On the contrary, Ulpian, the great jurist, collected for public use in case of need all the imperial laws against the new faith.[104:1] Maximinus the Thracian (235-238), a coarse, brutal, military leader, ordered that all officers of the churches should be "put to death as responsible for the gospel teaching."[104:2] Philip the Arabian (244-248) was reported to be a Christian--at all events Christians were not punished during his rule.[104:3]

    The last period of persecution (249-311) was characterised by civil and moral decline in the Empire and by the amazing growth of Christianity, which had become bold and aggressive. It must either be exterminated, or else adopted as the state religion. Hence the Emperors, who sought to restore the old power and splendour of ancient Rome, showed the greatest severity.

    Decius (249-251) issued the first edict of universal persecution (250) as a political necessity.[104:4] Local officials, under the threat of severe penalties, were required to compel all Christians to conform to the state religion. Christians might flee, but their property was confiscated and their return meant death.

    The inquisitorial process was employed and penalties were severe, especially for the leaders.[104:5] Decius declared that he would rather hear of the rise of a rival Emperor than of the appointment of a Roman bishop.[105:1] Valerian (253-260) was said at first to be "mild and friendly toward the men of God,"[105:2] but public disasters and the advice of his friends led him to renew the persecutions, so he issued an edict in 257 commanding Christians to conform to the state religion on pain of banishment.

    The assembly of Christians was forbidden,[105:3] and the bishops were banished. The next year he promulgated a second decree more sanguinary than that of Decius, because it condemned all bishops, priests, and deacons to death.[105:4] Gallienus (260-268) recalled the exiled Christians, restored their church property, and forbade further persecution,[105:5] but Aurelian (270-275) ordered the old laws enforced with renewed vigour.[105:6] His death, however, prevented the execution of the order; and thus the Christians had about forty years of peace.

    Under Diocletian (284-305), a warrior statesman, occurred the last, longest, and harshest persecution.[105:7] It was mildest in the West and worst in Syria and Egypt, and endured ten years. This Emperor, apparently, took up the sword very reluctantly. In 287 he issued a decree against the Manichæans in Egypt which was a general condemnation of Christianity. In 295 all soldiers were ordered to sacrifice on pain of expulsion, or, in obstinate cases, execution.

    In 303 Christians were accused of burning the imperial palace at Nicomedia and suffered accordingly.

    An imperial edict commanded the churches to "be razed to the ground, the Scriptures destroyed by fire," Christian officials degraded, Christian servants enslaved, bishops imprisoned and forced to sacrifice, and torture employed to compel Christians to conform.[106:1] Everywhere these laws were executed, Eusebius says, with great severity until checked by the edict of limited toleration by Galerius and his co-regents in 311,[106:2] and stopped by the decree of complete toleration granted by Constantine in 313[106:3] after a glorious struggle of 250 years.

    The results of the persecutions were very marked and have been both exaggerated and ignored:

    1. The growth of Christianity was helped rather than hindered.

    Persecution advertised the new belief and won sympathy. It created an intense devotion to the cause, proved the truth of the religion, and made a martyr's crown desirable. Tertullian exclaimed: "Go on! rack, torture, grind us to powder; our members increase in proportion as you mow us down. The blood of Christians is their harvest seed. Your very obstinacy is a teacher. For who is not incited by a consideration of it to enquire what there is in the core of the matter? And who, after having joined us, does not long to suffer?" The period of persecution ended with a conquest of the Emperor and a large part of the Empire. The victory was thus a double one.

    1. The organisation of the Church was effected. Persecution forced the

    Church to organise itself more efficiently, produced responsible leaders, who were forced to direct the struggle against Rome and who, as a result, were given pre-eminence by special punishment, and developed the monarchio-episcopal system. The extraordinary development of the power of the Bishop of Rome, in particular, was influenced to a far greater degree than is ordinarily taken into account. Much emphasis has been laid on the fact that that epoch of outlawry ended by the adoption of Christianity by the Empire. A much more important result, however, is found in the fact that Christianity, for weal or woe, adopted the Roman Empire.

    1. The Church was kept purer in belief and more united in form. The

    spiritual was magnified over the temporal. Common oppression joined Christians in common sympathy. The differences between Christianity and paganism were emphasised. With death over their heads the Christians thought little of life here but much of that hereafter and regulated their lives accordingly. Still the growing consciousness that the Church was a world-wide institution must have been powerfully stimulated. With the evolution of the idea of Christian unity appeared the conspicuous leadership of the Roman Church. Irenæus (d.

    202) could declare that it was "a matter of necessity that every church should agree with this church, on account of its pre-eminent authority." Tertullian (c. 220) also recognised the distinction of the Roman Church, though later he questioned the validity of the Petrine claim. It was left to Cyprian (d.

    1. to give the first complete account of the Universal or Catholic

    Church in his work on the Unity of the Church.

    1. Persecution produced a group of extraordinary literary defenders like

    the apologists, controversialists, and letter writers, and helped to develop the fundamental, orthodox Christian doctrine. It also produced much legendary poetry; and out of this baptism of blood was created the heroic age of the Church, based partly on fact and partly on fiction.

    1. The forms of worship were modified, the worship of saints and relics

    was originated, and the priesthood was sanctified and set above the laity.

    1. An example was furnished for later persecutions of the pagans,

    Mohammedans, Jews, and heretics.

    SOURCES

    A.--PRIMARY:

    I.--CHRISTIAN.

    1.--=New Testament.=

    2.--=Church Fathers.=

    1.--Clement, Ep. to Cor., ch. 5-7. Lightfoot, Lond.,
    1891.

    2.--Justin Martyr, 1 Apol., ch. 5, 24, 31, 52. 2 Apol.,
    ch. 2, 8. Dialog. with Trypho, ch. 110. Ante-Nic.
    Lib.
    , ii., 1, 2, 79.

    3.--Athenagoras, Plea for the Christians, ch. 1-4, 12, 31.
    Ib., ii., 375.

    4.--Minucius Felix, The Octavius. Ib., 451-571.

    5.--Severus, Sacred Hist., ii., ch. 28-33. Nic. and
    Post-Nic. Fathers
    xi.

    6.--Tertullian, To Scapulam, ch. 4. Ib., ii., 49-51.
    Apology, ch. 2-16. Ib., 55-84.

    7.--Lactantius, Divine Institutes, v., ch. 1, 9, 11.
    Ib., xxii., 92, 93, 98, 99. About the Death of
    Persecutors
    , ch. 4, 7. Ib., xxii., 167, 168, 170.

    8.--Origen, Against Celsus, i., ch. 3. Ib., x., 400.

    9.--Cyprian, Epistle 80; To Demetrianus, ch. 17. Ib.,
    viii., 436.

    10.--Irenæus, Fragments, ch. 13. Ib., x., 164, 165.

    11.--Hippolytus, Christ and Antichrist, ch. 56, 60. Ib.,
    ix., 34, 35.

    12.--Eusebius, Eccl. Hist. Various eds.

    II.--HEATHEN WRITERS.

    1.--Tacitus, Annals, xi., 15; xv., 38-44.

    2.--Juvenal, First Satire, verse 155 ff.

    3.--Suetonius, Hist. of the Twelve Cæsars. Tiberius, ch. 36;
    Claudius, ch. 25, 5; Nero, ch. 16, 38; Domitian, ch. 12.
    Bohn.

    4.--Dion Cassius, Hist. of Rome. Xiphilin's Abridgment in
    Eng. 2 vols. 1704.

    5.--Pliny, Letters, x., 96, 97. Transl. by Lewis, Lond.,
    1879.

    6.--Aurelius, Meditations, xi., 3. Bohn, 1869.

    7.--Celsus, Against the Christians. Eng. transl., Lond.,
    1869.

    8.--Lucian, The Death of Perigrinus. Transl. by Tooke.
    Lond., 1820.

    3.--=Collections.=

    1.--Univ. of Penn., Translations and Reprints, iv., No.
    1.

    2.--Foxe, Acts and Monuments, i.

    B.--SECONDARY:

    I.--SPECIAL:

    1.--Addis, W. E., Christianity in the Roman Empire. Lond.,
    1893.

    2.--Baring-Gould, Lives of the Saints. N. Y., 1873-7.

    3.--Bigg, The Church's Task under the Roman Empire. Lond.,
    1903.

    4.--Butler, A., Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Saints.
    Dub., 1866.

    5.--Carr, A., The Church and the Roman Empire. Lond., 1886.

    6.--Casy, J., Trials and Triumphs of the Church. Dub., 1899.

    7.--Castelloe, B. F. C., The Church and the Catacombs.
    Lond., 1894.

    8.--Croke, A. D., The Church and the Roman Empire. Lond.,
    1890.

    9.--Döllinger, J. J. I., Hippolytus and Callistus. Edinb.,
    1876. First Age of Christianity. Lond., 1877.

    10.--Gregg, J. A. F., The Decian Persecutions. Edinb., 1897.

    11.--Hardy, E. G., Christianity and the Roman Government.
    Lond., 1894.

    12.--Healy, P. J., The Valerian Persecution. N. Y., 1905.

    13.--Lightfoot, J. B., St. Clement of Rome, i., 69-81.
    Ignatius, i., 69.

    14.--Mason, A. J., The Diocletian Persecution. Lond., 1876.

    15.--Newton, R., Heroes of the Early Church. Lond., 1889.

    16.--Oxenham, H. N., Studies in Ecclesiastical History and
    Biography
    . Lond., 1884. 27-56.

    17.--Perram, A. F., Stories about the Early Christians.
    Lond., 1887.

    18.--Pressensé, E. de, The Martyrs and Apologists. N. Y.,
    1873. i., ch. 2-14.

    19.--Ramsay, W. M., The Church in the Roman Empire. N. Y.,
    1893.

    20.--Rankin, J., The First Saints. Lond., 1893.

    21.--Renan, E., Marcus Aurelius. Antichrist.

    22.--Spence, H. D. M., Early Christianity and Paganism. N. Y.
    and Lond., 1902.

    23.--Steere, E., Persecutions of the Early Church. Lond.,
    1880.

    24.--Uhlhorn, G., The Conflict of Christianity with
    Heathenism
    . N. Y., 1879.

    25.--Watson, F., Defenders of the Faith. Lond., 1888.

    26.--Workman, H. B., Persecution in the Early Church. Lond.,
    1906.

    II.--GENERAL:

    Alzog, i., sec. 48, 64-70. Backhouse, pt. 2, ch. 2-8.
    Bartlett, ch. 2. Baur, ii., 215-221. Bouzique, i., ch. 3.
    Burton, ch. 2, 5, 7-11, 13, 16, 17. Butler, ch. 6-8. Chantrel,
    ch. 3. Cheetham, ch. 3, sec. 1. Clarke, ch. 1, 2. Coxe, ch. 2,
    sec. 27. Croke, ch. 1-10. Crooks, ch. 14. Darras, i., ch.
    1-14. Döllinger, i., ch. 1, sec. 9, 10. Duff, ch. 11, 13, 15,
    16, 22-25, 30. Fisher, pd. 2, ch. 1. Foulkes, ch. 1-3.
    Gieseler, i., 119. Gilmartin, i., ch. 5. Guericke, 77-102.
    Hase, 42-55. Hore, ch. 3. Hurst, i., 161-179. Jackson, ch.
    2-3. Jennings, i., ch. 2-3. Knight, ch. 2-5. Kurtz, i., sec.
    21, 22. Merivale, 6-8.

    Milman, bk. i., ch. 1. Milner, i.,
    cent. 2-4. Moeller, i., 74, 82, 159, 190. Neander, i., 86.
    Newman, i., 147. Robertson, bk. i., ch. 1-3, 5-7. Schaff, ii.,
    31 ff.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [91:1] Hardy, 1-18.

    [91:2] Examples: Cybele, Bellona, Magna Mater.

    [91:3] Examples: Cult of Isis excluded from Rome 58 B.C. (Tertullian, Apol.). Temples of Isis and Serapis destroyed 50 B.C. (Dion Cassius, xi., 47). Repeated measures later. Jews expelled from Rome.

    [92:1] Neander, i., 89; Fisher, 30. Caligula, it seems, expelled the Jews from Rome; Claudius (41-54) first forbade their assembling (Dion Cassius, 60, 6) and then sought to drive them out of the capital (Orosius, Hist., 7, 6.)

    [92:2] For individuals like Stephen, Acts vii., 58; James, Acts xii., 2;

    Peter, Acts iv.; xii., 3; Paul, Acts ix., 23, 24; xiv., 5, 19; xvii., 13; xxiii., 12; xvi., 23; xxii., 24. For masses see Acts viii., 1-4;

    Acts xxvi., 10-12; Clement, Recognitions, i., ch. 53, 71; Justin Martyr, 1 Apol., ch. 36; Dialogue with Trypho, ch. 16, 39, 96, 115.

    [92:3] Hurst, i., 153.

    [92:4] Acts, xviii., 14, 15; xxi., 31, 32; xxiv., 1-27; xxv., 14; xxvi., 32; Uhlhorn, 238.

    [92:5] Origen, Against Celsus, iii., 1-3.

    [93:1] Concerning Laws, i., pt. 2, ch. 8. This was also the ancient principle of the XII. Tables.

    [93:2] Bk. iii., ch. 4, par. 1.

    [93:3] See Tertullian and Celsus.

    [94:1] Address reported by Dion Cassius.

    [94:2] Ramsay, 356.

    [94:3] Uhlhorn, Conflict of Christ. with Heathenism, 231.

    [95:1] Uhlhorn, Conflict of Christ. with Heathenism, 234.

    [95:2] Gibbon, ii., bk. 3, ch. 16.

    [95:3] Uhlhorn, 224; Moeller, i., 81.

    [96:1] Octav., c. 8.

    [96:2] Annales, xv., c. 44.

    [96:3] Alzog, i., 257.

    [96:4] Acts xix., 24 ff.; Pliny, Ep., x., 97; Neander, i., 92.

    [96:5] For a detailed statement of the accusations read the apologies of Justin Martyr, Athenagoras, Tertullian, and Origen.

    [96:6] Cyprian, To Demetrianus, 1; Origen, Against Celsus, iii., ch. 16; Tertullian, Apol., ch. 40; To Nations, 9; Alzog, i., 261.

    [96:7] Justin Martyr, Apol., i., ch. 6, 13, 17; Arnobius, Against Gentes, iii., ch. 28.

    [97:1] A crucifix with the head of an ass and body of a man was actually dug up in Rome and is now exhibited in a museum there. In Tertullian's day there was circulated a picture of a man with the ears of an ass, clothed in a toga, holding a book, and with these words beneath: "The God of the Christians" (Apol., 16; Ad. Nat., 11, 14; Tacitus, Hist., v., 3). In the Palace of the Cæsars a rough sketch of a crucified man with an ass's head was found (Hist. Photographs, No. 107, Oxf., 1870; Univ. Quart., July, 1879, p. 338).

    [97:2] Origen, Against Celsus, viii., ch. 75; Apol., ch. 29, 35, and 39; Tertullian, Concerning Idol., ch. 17; De Cor. Mil., i., c. 15.

    [97:3] Cf. Luke, xxi., 16.

    [97:4] Hence all the hatred and prejudice of the Romans for the Jews were turned against the Christians. Gibbon, ii., 6; Gieseler, i., p. 101.

    [98:1] Origen declared that the number of Christian martyrs was small and easily counted. Celsum, c. 3.

    [98:2] Gibbon, ii., ch. 16; Uhlhorn, 234, 235.

    [98:3] Moeller, i., 193.

    [99:1] Tacitus, Ann., xv., 44. It seems to be very probable that persecutions by the Roman government occurred earlier than this. 1 Pet.;

    Rev. ii., 13; xx., 4.

    [99:2] Schiller, Lipsius, and Hausrath.

    [99:3] Notably Merivale.

    [99:4] Hardy, Uhlhorn, Ramsay, Allard, and Harnack.

    [99:5] E. Th. Klette, Nero and the Christians, who relies for his conclusions on sources prior to Tacitus, repudiates the scapegoat theory. He contends that Nero, influenced by Jewish intrigue, publicly punished the Christians as Christians and because of the popular suspicions against them, so as to make it appear that the burning of Rome was due to the wrath of the gods.

    [100:1] Juvenal, Sat., i., 155 ff.; Seneca, Ep., 14; Clement, To Corinth, 6; Euseb., ii., c. 25; Orosius, vii., c. 7. Cf. Ramsay, Ch. in Rom. Emp. 226 ff.

    [100:2] Sulp. Severus, Chron. ii., c. 29; Transl. and Rep., iv., 6.

    [100:3] Mommsen, Sandy, Hardy, Ramsay.

    [100:4] Mommsen, v., 523 n.

    [100:5] Sulp. Severus, Chron., ii., c. 30, 6; Transl. and Rep., iv., 6-8.

    [101:1] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iii., c. 18; Dion Cass., lxvii., c. 14.;

    Suet., Dom., c. 15; Transl. and Rep., iv., 6.

    [101:2] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iv., 26.

    [101:3] Hegesippus, quoted in Eusebius, Eccl. Hist., iii., c. 20;

    Tertullian; Clement of Rome, 1st Epistle.

    [101:4] Melito of Sardica (c. 170), Lactantius, Eusebius, and the mediæval writers generally held that he was rather favourable to Christians.

    [101:5] Gieseler, Aubé, Overbeek, Uhlhorn, Keim and Renan held that Trajan began a new era unfavourable to Christians but Lightfoot, Hardy, and Ramsay explain it on the ground of political expediency.

    [101:6] Pliny wrote sixty letters to Trajan and Trajan made forty-eight replies. These have all been translated into English. Read letters 96 and 97. See Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 8.

    [102:1] For an excellent discussion of the significance of the Trajan prosecutions, see Ramsay, Ch. in Rom. Emp., 190-225.

    [102:2] Authenticity of this document is doubted by Baur, Klein, Lipsius, Overbeek, Aubé, McGiffert, etc., but defended by Ramsay, Lightfoot, Mommsen, Allard, Funk, Ranke, Uhlhorn, Moeller, etc. See Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 10.

    [102:3] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., iv., c. 13, 26; Tertullian; Harnack, article on Pius in Herzog-Hauck, Real Encyc.

    [103:1] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., v., c. 1; Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 11.

    [103:2] This period saw seventeen different Emperors.

    [103:3] See Eusebius on this reign, Eccl. Hist., v., c. 9-24.

    [103:4] Clement of Alexandria wrote: "Many martyrs are daily burned, crucified, and beheaded before our eyes." Origen's father was among them. At Scillite in Numidia 200 suffered. Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 20. At Carthage two young women were given to wild beasts.

    Tertullian refers to other persecutions. Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vi., c. 1, 7.

    [104:1] Moeller, i., 191.

    [104:2] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vi., c. 28; Origen, On Martyrdom.

    [104:3] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vi., c. 34.

    [104:4] The text of this decree has been lost. Two later decrees were issued--the first exiling Church officers, the second condemning them to death. See Gregg, The Decian Persecution.

    [104:5] Read Cyprian, Concerning the Lapsed, iii., c. 8, for the most vivid account; Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 21.

    [105:1] Cyprian, Ep. to Antonian.

    [105:2] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vii., c. 10; Gregg, The Decian Persecution.

    [105:3] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vii., c. 11.

    [105:4] Cyprian, Ep., 81; Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, 20, 22, 23.

    [105:5] Euseb., Eccl. Hist., vii., c. 13 ff.

    [105:6] Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 26.

    [105:7] Mason, The Persecution of Diocletian.

    [106:1] Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 26; Euseb., Eccl. Hist., viii.-x.; Uhlhorn, 407.

    [106:2] Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 28; Euseb., Eccl. Hist., viii., 17.

    [106:3] Transl. and Rep., iv., No. 1, p. 29.

    CHAPTER VII

    TRANSITION OF THE CHURCH UNDER CONSTANTINE

    OUTLINE: I.--Condition of the Empire in 300. II.--How
    Constantine became Emperor. III.--Constantine's conversion to
    Christianity. IV.--Constantine's favours to Christianity.
    V.--Constantine's character. VI.--Constantine's historical
    significance. VII.--Sources.

    To understand the great changes that took place in the Christian Church under Constantine, it is necessary to keep distinctly in mind both the status of Christianity, on the one hand, and the general conditions of the Empire, on the other.

    In territorial extent the Empire still formed a huge fringe around the Mediterranean Sea and had lost but little of its vastness under Trajan (98-117). Under Diocletian (284-305) the Empire became an undisguised oriental despotism. The administration was divided between two Augusti, each of whom had an associate, called Cæsar. This division of rule, with its increased expense, aroused much jealousy and discontent, and greatly weakened the Empire. As many as six rival Emperors appeared at once, and out of the rivalry emerged Constantine the Great as the sole ruler of the Empire.

    Wars with the Persians in the east and with the barbarians on the north accelerated the declining political morality. At the same time social classes became more marked, and moral standards lower.

    Schools were neglected, literature became superficial, poetry lost its voice, and oratory declined. Paganism, largely a form of patriotism and national festivity, still numbered many adherents, but it was not deeply rooted in their hearts.

    Christianity, in the face of outlawry and severe persecution, had spread steadily and marvellously, and particularly among the substantial people of the Empire.[113:1] It is difficult to estimate the number of Christians because few records were left and the number of real believers was much larger than the professed adherents. The earlier estimates are probably too low. After more careful investigation, 30,000,000 may be safely given as indicating the numerical strength of the new creed.[113:2] When Constantine the Great appeared, therefore, old pagan Rome was declining, while a new Christian Rome was rapidly rising.

    Christianity would undoubtedly have gained the victory sooner or later had Constantine not appeared as its champion.

    Constantine was born about 274 at Naïssus, in Upper Moesia. His father was Constantius Chlorus, a nephew of Emperor Claudius, the conqueror of the Goths, who was selected as Cæsar of the West possibly because of his imperial connection. His mother was Helena, the daughter of an innkeeper, and not the fabled English princess. She was only a concubine, who, however

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Rise of the Mediaeval Church
    Author
    Alexander Clarence Flick
    Release date
    January 24, 2013 [eBook #41910]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Chuck Greif, Lisa Reigel, and the Online
    Most recently updated
    October 23, 2024
    Transcriber and production notes
    Transcriber's Notes: Variations in spelling and hyphenation have been
    left as in the original. Words in italics in the original are surrounded
    by _underscores_. Words in bold in the original are surrounded by =equal
    signs=. A row of asterisks represents a thought break. Ellipses match
    the original.
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    A few typographical errors have been corrected. A complete list as well
    as other notes follows the text.
    
    
    
    
                               THE RISE OF THE
    
                               MEDIAEVAL CHURCH
    
                   AND ITS INFLUENCE ON THE CIVILISATION OF
    
                     WESTERN EUROPE FROM THE FIRST TO THE
    
                              THIRTEENTH CENTURY
    
    
                                      BY
    
                  ALEXANDER CLARENCE FLICK, PH. D., LITT. D.
    
    
                                [Illustration]
    
                                BURT FRANKLIN
                               New York, N. Y.
    
    
    
    
      TO
    
      HENRY C. LEA
    
      Who through his numerous scholarly monographs has earned the foremost
      place among American Church historians, both at home and abroad,
    
      AND TO
    
      PROFESSOR DOCTOR ADOLPH HARNACK
    
      To whom both the Old and the New World are profoundly indebted for his
      scholarly labours, and from whose inspiration in public lectures and
      private conferences this work derived much that is best in it,
    
      THIS BOOK IS GRATEFULLY DEDICATED.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Rise of the Mediaeval Church
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Rise of the Mediaeval Church
    
    Author: Alexander Clarence Flick
    
    
            
    Release date: January 24, 2013 [eBook #41910]
                    Most recently updated: October 23, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/41910
    
    Credits: Produced by Chuck Greif, Lisa Reigel, and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #41910. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 41910
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.