Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 40812

The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration

by Thomas Wilson · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2012
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration by Thomas Wilson is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #40812). Text enclosed by underscores is in italics (_italics_).

    THE SWASTIKA,

    The Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migrations; with Observations on the Migration of Certain Industries in Prehistoric Times.

    by

    THOMAS WILSON,

    Curator, Department of Prehistoric Anthropology, U. S. National Museum.

    From the Report of the U. S. National Museum for 1894, pages 757-1011, with plates 1-25 and Figures 1-374.

    Washington:

    Government Printing Office. 1896.

    TABLE OF CONTENTS.

    Page.

    Preface 763

    I.--DEFINITIONS, DESCRIPTION, AND ORIGIN.

    Different forms of the cross 765

    Names and definitions of the Swastika 768

    Symbolism and interpretation 770

    Origin and habitat 791

    II.--DISPERSION OF THE SWASTIKA.

    Extreme Orient 799
    Japan 799
    Korea 799
    China 799
    Tibet 802
    India 802

    Classical Orient 806
    Babylonia, Assyria, Chaldea, and Persia 806
    Phenicia 807
    Lycaonia 807
    Armenia 807
    Caucasus 808
    Asia Minor--Troy (Hissarlik) 809
    First and Second Cities 810
    The Third or Burnt City 811
    The Fourth City 813
    The Fifth City 818
    The Sixth and Seventh Cities 819
    Leaden idol of Hissarlik 829
    Owl-shaped vases 830
    The age of Trojan cities 832

    Africa 833
    Egypt 833
    Naukratis 834
    Coptos (Achmim-Panopolis) 834
    Algeria 838
    Ashantee 838

    Classical Occident--Mediterranean 839
    Greece, Cyprus, Rhodes, Melos, and Thera 839
    Greek fret and Egyptian meander not the same as the
    Swastika 839
    Swastika in panels 845
    Swastikas with four arms crossing at right angles,
    ends bent to the right 846
    Swastikas with four arms crossing at right angles,
    ends bent to the left 847
    Swastikas with four arms crossing at other than right
    angles, the ends ogee and to the left 848
    Meander pattern, with ends bent to the right and left 849
    Swastikas of different kinds on the same object 849

    Europe 854
    Bronze age 854
    Etruria and Italy 855
    Swiss lake dwellings 861
    Germany and Austria 862
    Belgium 863
    Scandinavia 864
    Scotland and Ireland 867
    Gallo-Roman period 869
    France 869
    Anglo-Saxon period 870
    Britain 870
    Swastika on ancient coins 871
    Triskelion, Lycia 871
    Triskelion, Sicily 873
    Triskelion, Isle of Man 874
    Punch marks on Corinthian coins mistaken for Swastikas 875
    Swastika on ancient Hindu coins 877
    Swastika on coins in Mesembria and Gaza 878
    Swastika on Danish gold bracteates 878

    United States of America 879
    Pre-Columbian times 879
    Fains Island and Toco mounds, Tennessee 879
    Hopewell Mound, Chillicothe, Ross County, Ohio 888
    Mounds in Arkansas 893
    North American Indians 894
    Kansas 894
    Sacs 895
    Pueblos 896
    Navajoes 897
    Pimas 901
    Colonial patchwork 901

    Central America 902
    Nicaragua 902
    Yucatan 902
    Costa Rica 903

    South America 903
    Brazil 903
    Paraguay 905

    III.--FORMS ALLIED TO THE SWASTIKA.

    Meanders, ogees, and spirals, bent to the left as well as
    to the right 905
    Aboriginal American engravings and paintings 906
    Designs on shell 906
    Ivory-billed woodpecker 907
    The triskele, triskelion, or triquetrum 908
    The spider 913
    The rattlesnake 914
    The human face and form 914
    Designs on pottery 920
    Designs on basketry 924

    IV.--THE CROSS AMONG THE AMERICAN INDIANS.

    Different forms 926
    The cross on objects of shell and copper 926
    The cross on pottery 931

    Symbolic meanings of the cross 933
    The four winds 934
    Sun and star symbols 936
    Dwellings 936
    Dragon fly (Susbeca) 936
    Mide', or Shamans 937
    Flocks of birds 937
    Human forms 938
    Maidenhood 939
    Shaman's spirit 939
    Divers significations 939

    Introduction of the cross into America 944

    Decorative forms not of the cross, but allied to the
    Swastika 946
    Color stamps from Mexico and Venezuela 946

    V.--SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SWASTIKA. 948

    VI.--THE MIGRATION OF SYMBOLS.

    Migration of the Swastika 952

    Migration of classic symbols 960
    The sacred tree of the Assyrians 960
    The sacred cone of Mesopotamia 960
    The Crux ansata, the key of life 961
    The winged globe 961
    The caduceus 962
    The trisula 963
    The double-headed eagle on the escutcheon of Austria
    and Russia 963
    The lion rampant of Belgium 963
    Greek art and architecture 964
    The Greek fret 965

    VII.--PREHISTORIC OBJECTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE SWASTIKA, FOUND

    IN BOTH HEMISPHERES, AND BELIEVED TO HAVE PASSED BY

    MIGRATION.

    Spindle whorls 966
    Europe 967
    Switzerland--Lake dwellings 967
    Italy 968
    Wurtemburg 968
    France 968
    North America--pre-Columbian times 969
    Mexico 970
    Central America 971
    Nicaragua 971
    South America 972
    Chiriqui 972
    Colombia 972
    Peru 972

    Bobbins 975
    Europe 975
    United States 975

    VIII.--SIMILAR PREHISTORIC ARTS, INDUSTRIES, AND IMPLEMENTS IN

    EUROPE AND AMERICA AS EVIDENCE OF THE MIGRATION OF

    CULTURE. 977

    CONCLUSION 981

    BIBLIOGRAPHY 984

    LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS 997

    THE SWASTIKA,

    THE EARLIEST KNOWN SYMBOL, AND ITS MIGRATIONS; WITH OBSERVATIONS ON THE

    MIGRATION OF CERTAIN INDUSTRIES IN PREHISTORIC TIMES.

    [Illustration]

    By THOMAS WILSON, Curator, Department of Prehistoric Anthropology, U. S.

    National Museum.

    PREFACE.

    An English gentleman, versed in prehistoric archæology, visited me in the summer of 1894, and during our conversation asked if we had the Swastika in America. I answered, "Yes," and showed him two or three specimens of it. He demanded if we had any literature on the subject.

    I cited him De Mortillet, De Morgan, and Zmigrodzki, and he said, "No, I mean English or American." I began a search which proved almost futile, as even the word Swastika did not appear in such works as Worcester's or Webster's dictionaries, the Encyclopædic Dictionary, the Encyclopædia Britannica, Johnson's Universal Cyclopædia, the People's Cyclopædia, nor Smith's Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities, his Greek and Roman Biography and Mythology, or his Classical Dictionary.

    I also searched, with the same results, Mollett's Dictionary of Art and Archæology, Fairholt's Dictionary of Terms in Art, "L'Art Gothique," by Gonza, Perrot and Chipiez's extensive histories of Art in Egypt, in Chaldea and Assyria, and in Phenicia; also "The Cross, Ancient and Modern," by W. W. Blake, "The History of the Cross," by John Ashton; and a reprint of a Dutch work by Wildener.

    In the American Encyclopædia the description is erroneous, while all the Century Dictionary says is, "Same as fylfot," and "Compare Crux Ansata and Gammadion." I thereupon concluded that this would be a good subject for presentation to the Smithsonian Institution for "diffusion of knowledge among men."

    The principal object of this paper has been to gather and put in a compact form such information as is obtainable concerning the Swastika, leaving to others the task of adjustment of these facts and their arrangement into an harmonious theory. The only conclusion sought to be deduced from the facts stated is as to the possible migration in prehistoric times of the Swastika and similar objects.

    No conclusion is attempted as to the time or place of origin, or the primitive meaning of the Swastika, because these are considered to be lost in antiquity. The straight line, the circle, the cross, the triangle, are simple forms, easily made, and might have been invented and re-invented in every age of primitive man and in every quarter of the globe, each time being an independent invention, meaning much or little, meaning different things among different peoples or at different times among the same people; or they may have had no settled or definite meaning.

    But the Swastika was probably the first to be made with a definite intention and a continuous or consecutive meaning, the knowledge of which passed from person to person, from tribe to tribe, from people to people, and from nation to nation, until, with possibly changed meanings, it has finally circled the globe.

    There are many disputable questions broached in this paper. The author is aware of the differences of opinion thereon among learned men, and he has not attempted to dispose of these questions in the few sentences employed in their announcement. He has been conservative and has sought to avoid dogmatic decisions of controverted questions. The antiquity of man, the locality of his origin, the time of his dispersion and the course of his migration, the origin of bronze and the course of its migration, all of which may be more or less involved in a discussion of the Swastika, are questions not to be settled by the dogmatic assertions of any individual.

    Much of the information in this paper is original, and relates to prehistoric more than to modern times, and extends to nearly all the countries of the globe. It is evident that the author must depend on other discoverers; therefore, all books, travels, writers, and students have been laid under contribution without scruple. Due acknowledgment is hereby made for all quotations of text or figures wherever they occur.

    Quotations have been freely made, instead of sifting the evidence and giving the substance. The justification is that there has never been any sufficient marshaling of the evidence on the subject, and that the former deductions have been inconclusive; therefore, quotations of authors are given in their own words, to the end that the philosophers who propose to deal with the origin, meaning, and cause of migration of the Swastika will have all the evidence before them.

    Assumptions may appear as to antiquity, origin, and migration of the Swastika, but it is explained that many times these only reflect the opinion of the writers who are quoted, or are put forth as working hypotheses.

    The indulgence of the reader is asked, and it is hoped that he will endeavor to harmonize conflicting statements upon these disputed questions rather than antagonize them.

    I.--DEFINITIONS, DESCRIPTION, AND ORIGIN.

    DIFFERENT FORMS OF THE CROSS.

    The simple cross made with two sticks or marks belongs to prehistoric times. Its first appearance among men is lost in antiquity. One may theorize as to its origin, but there is no historical identification of it either in epoch or by country or people. The sign is itself so simple that it might have originated among any people, however primitive, and in any age, however remote. The meaning given to the earliest cross is equally unknown. Everything concerning its beginning is in the realm of speculation. But a differentiation grew up in early times among nations by which certain forms of the cross have been known under certain names and with specific significations.

    Some of these, such as the Maltese cross, are historic and can be well identified.

    The principal forms of the cross, known as symbols or ornaments, can be reduced to a few classes, though when combined with heraldry its use extends to 385 varieties.[1]

    [Illustration: Fig. 1. LATIN CROSS (Crux immissa).]

    [Illustration: Fig. 2. GREEK CROSS.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 3. ST. ANDREW'S CROSS (Crux decussata).]

    It is not the purpose of this paper to give a history of the cross, but the principal forms are shown by way of introduction to a study of the Swastika.

    The Latin cross, Crux immissa, (fig. 1) is found on coins, medals, and ornaments anterior to the Christian era. It was on this cross that Christ is said to have been crucified, and thus it became accepted as the Christian cross.

    The Greek cross (fig. 2) with arms of equal length crossing at right angles, is found on Assyrian and Persian monuments and tablets, Greek coins and statues.

    The St. Andrew's cross, Crux decussata, (fig. 3) is the same as the Greek cross, but turned to stand on two legs.

    The Crux ansata (fig. 4) according to Egyptian mythology, was Ankh, the emblem of Ka, the spiritual double of man. It was also said to indicate a union of Osiris and Isis, and was regarded as a symbol of the generative principle of nature.

    [Illustration: Fig. 4. EGYPTIAN CROSS. (Crux ansata). The Key of Life.]

    The Tau cross (fig. 5), so called from its resemblance to the Greek letter of that name, is of uncertain, though ancient, origin. In Scandinavian mythology it passed under the name of "Thor's hammer," being therein confounded with the Swastika. It was also called St. Anthony's cross for the Egyptian hermit of that name, and was always colored blue. Clarkson says this mark was received by the Mithracists on their foreheads at the time of their initiation. C. W. King, in his work entitled "Early Christian Numismatics" (p.

    214), expresses the opinion that the Tau cross was placed on the foreheads of men who cry after abominations. (Ezekiel ix, 4.) It is spoken of as a phallic emblem.

    Another variety of the cross appeared about the second century, composed of a union of the St. Andrew's cross and the letter P (fig. 6), being the first two letters of the Greek word [Greek: CHRISTOS] (Christus). This, with another variety containing all the foregoing letters, passed as the monogram of Christ (fig. 6).

    [Illustration: Fig. 5. TAU CROSS, THOR'S HAMMER, OR ST. ANTHONY'S CROSS.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 6. MONOGRAM OF CHRIST. Labarum of Constantine.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 7. MALTESE CROSS.]

    As an instrument of execution, the cross, besides being the intersection of two beams with four projecting arms, was frequently of compound forms as [Y], on which the convicted person was fastened by the feet and hung head downward. Another form [symbol], whereon he was fastened by one foot and one hand at each upper corner; still another form [symbol], whereon his body was suspended on the central upright with his arms outstretched upon the cross beams.

    Fig. 7 represents the sign of the military order of the Knights of Malta.

    It is of medieval origin.

    Fig. 8 (a and b) represents two styles of Celtic crosses. These belong chiefly to Ireland and Scotland, are usually of stone, and frequently set up at marked places on the road side.

    Higgins, in his "Anacalypsis," a rare and costly work, almost an encyclopedia of knowledge,[2] says, concerning the origin of the cross, that the official name of the governor of Tibet, Lama, comes from the ancient Tibetan word for the cross. The original spelling was L-a-m-h.

    This is cited with approval in Davenport's "Aphrodisiacs" (p. 13).

    [Illustration: Fig. 8. CELTIC CROSSES.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 9. NORMAL SWASTIKA.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 10. SUAVASTIKA.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 11. SWASTIKA. Meander.]

    Of the many forms of the cross, the Swastika is the most ancient. Despite the theories and speculations of students, its origin is unknown. It began before history, and is properly classed as prehistoric. Its description is as follows: The bars of the normal Swastika (frontispiece and fig. 9) are straight, of equal thickness throughout, and cross each other at right angles, making four arms of equal size, length, and style. Their peculiarity is that all the ends are bent at right angles and in the same direction, right or left. Prof.

    Max Müller makes the symbol different according as the arms are bent to the right or to the left. That bent to the right he denominates the true Swastika, that bent to the left he calls Suavastika (fig. 10), but he gives no authority for the statement, and the author has been unable to find, except in Burnouf, any justification for a difference of names. Professor Goodyear gives the title of "Meander" to that form of Swastika which bends two or more times (fig. 11).

    The Swastika is sometimes represented with dots or points in the corners of the intersections (fig. 12_a_), and occasionally the same when without bent ends (fig. 12_b_), to which Zmigrodzki gives the name of Croix Swasticale. Some Swastikas have three dots placed equidistant around each of the four ends (fig. 12_c_).

    [Illustration: Fig. 12. CROIX SWASTICALE (ZMIGRODZKI).]

    There are several varieties possibly related to the Swastika which have been found in almost every part of the globe, and though the relation may appear slight, and at first sight difficult to trace, yet it will appear more or less intimate as the examination is pursued through its ramifications. As this paper is an investigation into and report upon facts rather than conclusions to be drawn from them, it is deemed wise to give those forms bearing even possible relations to the Swastika.

    Certain of them have been accepted by the author as related to the Swastika, while others have been rejected; but this rejection has been confined to cases where the known facts seemed to justify another origin for the symbol.

    Speculation has been avoided.

    [Illustration: PECULIAR FORMS OF SWASTIKA.

    Fig. 13_a_. OGEE AND SPIRAL SWASTIKAS. Tetraskelion (four-armed).

    Fig. 13_b_. SPIRAL AND VOLUTE. Triskelion (three-armed).

    Fig. 13_c_. SPIRAL AND VOLUTE. (Five or many armed.)

    Fig. 13_d_. OGEE SWASTIKA, WITH CIRCLE.]

    NAMES AND DEFINITIONS OF THE SWASTIKA.

    The Swastika has been called by different names in different countries, though nearly all countries have in later years accepted the ancient Sanskrit name of Swastika; and this name is recommended as the most definite and certain, being now the most general and, indeed, almost universal. It was formerly spelled s-v-a-s-t-i-c-a and s-u-a-s-t-i-k-a, but the later spelling, both English and French, is s-w-a-s-t-i-k-a. The definition and etymology of the word is thus given in Littre's French Dictionary:

    Svastika, or Swastika, a mystic figure used by several (East)
    Indian sects. It was equally well known to the Brahmins as to the
    Buddhists. Most of the rock inscriptions in the Buddhist caverns in
    the west of India are preceded or followed by the holy
    (sacramentelle) sign of the Swastika. (Eug. Burnouf, "Le Lotus de la
    bonne loi." Paris, 1852, p. 625.) It was seen on the vases and pottery
    of Rhodes (Cyprus) and Etruria. (F. Delaunay, Jour. Off., Nov. 18,
    1873, p. 7024, 3d Col.)

    Etymology: A Sanskrit word signifying happiness, pleasure, good luck.
    It is composed of Su (equivalent of Greek [Greek: eu]), "good," and
    asti, "being," "good being," with the suffix ka (Greek [Greek:
    ka], Latin co).

    In the "Revue d'Ethnographie" (IV, 1885, p. 329), Mr. Dumoutier gives the following analysis of the Sanskrit swastika:

    Su, radical, signifying good, well, excellent, or suvidas,
    prosperity.

    Asti, third person, singular, indicative present of the verb as,
    to be, which is sum in Latin.

    Ka, suffix forming the substantive.

    Professor Whitney in the Century Dictionary says, Swastika--[Sanskrit, lit., "of good fortune." Svasti (Su, well, + asti, being), welfare.]

    Same as fylfot. Compare Crux ansata and gammadion.

    In "Ilios" (p. 347), Max Müller says:

    Ethnologically, svastika is derived from svasti, and svasti from
    su, "well," and as, "to be." Svasti occurs frequently in the
    Veda, both as a noun in a sense of happiness, and as an adverb in the
    sense of "well" or "hail!" It corresponds to the Greek [Greek:
    euestô]. The derivation Svasti-ka is of later date, and it always
    means an auspicious sign, such as are found most frequently among
    Buddhists and Jainas.

    M. Eugene Burnouf[3] defines the mark Swastika as follows:

    A monogrammatic sign of four branches, of which the ends are curved at
    right angles, the name signifying, literally, the sign of benediction
    or good augury.

    The foregoing explanations relate only to the present accepted name "Swastika." The sign Swastika must have existed long before the name was given to it. It must have been in existence long before the Buddhist religion or the Sanskrit language.

    In Great Britain the common name given to the Swastika, from Anglo-Saxon times by those who apparently had no knowledge whence it came, or that it came from any other than their own country, was Fylfot, said to have been derived from the Anglo-Saxon fower fot, meaning four-footed, or many-footed.[4]

    George Waring, in his work entitled "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages" (p. 10), says:

    The word [Fylfot] is Scandinavian and is compounded of Old Norse
    fiël, equivalent to the Anglo-Saxon fela, German viel, many, and
    fotr, foot, the many-footed figure. * * * It is desirable to have
    some settled name by which to describe it; we will take the simplest
    and most descriptive, the "Fylfot."

    He thus transgresses one of the oldest and soundest rules of scientific nomenclature, and ignores the fact that the name Swastika has been employed for this sign in the Sanskrit language (the etymology of the word naturally gave it the name Svastika, sv--good or well, asti--to be or being, or it is) and that two thousand and more years of use in Asia and Europe had sanctioned and sanctified that as its name. The use of Fylfot is confined to comparatively few persons in Great Britain and, possibly, Scandinavia. Outside of these countries it is scarcely known, used, or understood.

    The Swastika was occasionally called in the French language, in earlier times, Croix gammée or Gammadion, from its resemblance to a combination of four of the Greek letters of that name, and it is so named by Count Goblet d'Alviella in his late work, "La Migration des Symboles."

    It was also called Croix cramponnée, Croix pattée, Croix à crochet.

    But the consensus even of French etymologists favors the name Swastika.

    Some foreign authors have called it Thor's hammer, or Thor's hammer-mark, but the correctness of this has been disputed.[5] Waring, in his elaborate work, "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages,"[6] says:

    The [Z] used to be vulgarly called in Scandinavia the hammer of Thor,
    and Thor's hammer-mark, or the hammer-mark, but this name properly
    belongs to the mark [Y].

    Ludwig Müller gives it as his opinion that the Swastika has no connection with the Thor hammer. The best Scandinavian authors report the "Thor hammer" to be the same as the Greek tau (fig. 5), the same form as the Roman and English capital T. The Scandinavian name is Miölner or Mjolner, the crusher or mallet.

    The Greek, Latin, and Tau crosses are represented in Egyptian hieroglyphics by a hammer or mallet, giving the idea of crushing, pounding, or striking, and so an instrument of justice, an avenger of wrong,[7] hence standing for Horus and other gods.[8] Similar symbolic meanings have been given to these crosses in ancient classic countries of the Orient.[9]

    SYMBOLISM AND INTERPRETATION.

    Many theories have been presented concerning the symbolism of the Swastika, its relation to ancient deities and its representation of certain qualities. In the estimation of certain writers it has been respectively the emblem of Zeus, of Baal, of the sun, of the sun-god, of the sun-chariot of Agni the fire-god, of Indra the rain-god, of the sky, the sky-god, and finally the deity of all deities, the great God, the Maker and Ruler of the Universe. It has also been held to symbolize light or the god of light, of the forked lightning, and of water.

    It is believed by some to have been the oldest Aryan symbol. In the estimation of others it represents Brahma, Vishnu, and Siva, Creator, Preserver, Destroyer. It appears in the footprints of Buddha, engraved upon the solid rock on the mountains of India (fig. 32). It stood for the Jupiter Tonans and Pluvius of the Latins, and the Thor of the Scandinavians. In the latter case it has been considered--erroneously, however--a variety of the Thor hammer.

    In the opinion of at least one author it had an intimate relation to the Lotus sign of Egypt and Persia. Some authors have attributed a phallic meaning to it. Others have recognized it as representing the generative principle of mankind, making it the symbol of the female. Its appearance on the person of certain goddesses, Artemis, Hera, Demeter, Astarte, and the Chaldean Nana, the leaden goddess from Hissarlik (fig. 125), has caused it to be claimed as a sign of fecundity.

    In forming the foregoing theories their authors have been largely controlled by the alleged fact of the substitution and permutation of the Swastika sign on various objects with recognized symbols of these different deities. The claims of these theorists are somewhat clouded in obscurity and lost in the antiquity of the subject. What seems to have been at all times an attribute of the Swastika is its character as a charm or amulet, as a sign of benediction, blessing, long life, good fortune, good luck.

    This character has continued into modern times, and while the Swastika is recognized as a holy and sacred symbol by at least one Buddhistic religious sect, it is still used by the common people of India, China, and Japan as a sign of long life, good wishes, and good fortune.

    Whatever else the sign Swastika may have stood for, and however many meanings it may have had, it was always ornamental. It may have been used with any or all the above significations, but it was always ornamental as well.

    The Swastika sign had great extension and spread itself practically over the world, largely, if not entirely, in prehistoric times, though its use in some countries has continued into modern times.

    The elaboration of the meanings of the Swastika indicated above and its dispersion or migrations form the subject of this paper.

    Dr. Schliemann found many specimens of Swastika in his excavations at the site of ancient Troy on the hill of Hissarlik. They were mostly on spindle whorls, and will be described in due course. He appealed to Prof. Max Müller for an explanation, who, in reply, wrote an elaborate description, which Dr. Schliemann published in "Ilios.[10]"

    He commences with a protest against the word Swastika being applied generally to the sign Swastika, because it may prejudice the reader or the public in favor of its Indian origin. He says:

    I do not like the use of the word svastika outside of India. It is a
    word of Indian origin and has its history and definite meaning in
    India. * * * The occurrence of such crosses in different parts of the
    world may or may not point to a common origin, but if they are once
    called Svastika the vulgus profanum will at once jump to the
    conclusion that they all come from India, and it will take some time
    to weed out such prejudice.

    Very little is known of Indian art before the third century B. C., the
    period when the Buddhist sovereigns began their public buildings.[11]

    The name Svastika, however, can be traced (in India) a little farther
    back. It occurs as the name of a particular sign in the old grammar of
    Pânani, about a century earlier. Certain compounds are mentioned there
    in which the last word is karna, "ear." * * * One of the signs for
    marking cattle was the Svastika [fig.

    41], and what Pânani teaches in
    his grammar is that when the compound is formed, svastika-karna, i.
    e., "having the ear marked with the sign of a Svastika," the final a
    of Svastika is not to be lengthened, while it is lengthened in other
    compounds, such as datra-karna, i. e., "having the ear marked with
    the sign of a sickle."

    D'Alviella[12] reinforces Max Müller's statement that Panini lived during the middle of the fourth century, B. C. Thus it is shown that the word Swastika had been in use at that early period long enough to form an integral part of the Sanskrit language and that it was employed to illustrate the particular sounds of the letter a in its grammar.

    Max Müller continues his explanation:[13]

    It [the Swastika] occurs often at the beginning of the Buddhist
    inscriptions, on Buddhist coins, and in Buddhist manuscripts.
    Historically, the Svastika is first attested on a coin of Krananda,
    supposing Krananda to be the same king as Xandrames, the predecessor
    of Sandrokyptos, whose reign came to an end in 315 B. C. (See Thomas
    on the Identity of Xandrames and Krananda.) The paleographic evidence,
    however, seems rather against so early a date. In the footprints of
    Buddha the Buddhists recognize no less that sixty-five auspicious
    signs, the first of them being the Svastika [see fig.

    32], (Eugene
    Burnouf, "Lotus de la bonne loi," p. 625); the fourth is the
    Suavastika, or that with the arms turned to the left [see fig. 10];
    the third, the Nandyâvarta [see fig. 14], is a mere development of
    the Svastika. Among the Jainas the Svastika was the sign of their
    seventh Jina, Supârsva (Colebrooke "Miscellaneous Essays," II, p. 188;
    Indian Antiquary, vol. 2, p. 135).

    In the later Sanskrit literature, Svastika retains the meaning of an
    auspicious mark; thus we see in the Râmâyana (ed. Gorresio, II, p.
    318) that Bharata selects a ship marked with the sign of the Svastika.
    Varâhamihira in the Brihat-samhitâ (Mod. Sæc., VI, p. Ch.) mentions
    certain buildings called Svastika and Nandyâvarta (53.34, seq.), but
    their outline does not correspond very exactly with the form of the
    signs. Some Sthûpas, however, are said to have been built on the plan
    of the Svastika. * * * Originally, svastika may have been intended
    for no more than two lines crossing each other, or a cross.

    Thus we
    find it used in later times referring to a woman covering her breast
    with crossed arms (Bâlarâm, 75.16), svahastas-vastika-stani, and
    likewise with reference to persons sitting crosslegged.

    Dr. Max Ohnefalsch-Richter[14] speaking of the Swastika position, either of crossed legs or arms, among the Hindus,[15] suggests as a possible explanation that these women bore the Swastikas upon their arms as did the goddess Aphrodite, in fig. 8 of his writings, (see fig. 180 in the present paper), and when they assumed the position of arms crossed over their breast, the Swastikas being brought into prominent view, possibly gave the name to the position as being a representative of the sign.

    Max Müller continues:[16]

    Quite another question is, why the sign [S] should have had an
    auspicious meaning, and why in Sanskrit it should have been called
    Svastika. The similarity between the group of letters sv in the
    ancient Indian alphabet and the sign of Svastika is not very striking,
    and seems purely accidental.

    A remark of yours [Schliemann] (Troy, p. 38.) that the Svastika
    resembles a wheel in motion, the direction of the motion being
    indicated by the crampons, contains a useful hint, which has been
    confirmed by some important observations of Mr. Thomas, the
    distinguished Oriental numismatist, who has called attention to the
    fact that in the long list of the recognized devices of the
    twenty-four Jaina Tirthankaras the sun is absent, but that while the
    eighth Tirthankara has the sign of the half-moon, the seventh
    Tirthankara is marked with the Svastika, i. e., the sun.

    Here, then,
    we have clear indications that the Svastika, with the hands pointing
    in the right direction, was originally a symbol of the sun, perhaps of
    the vernal sun as opposed to the autumnal sun, the Suavastika, and,
    therefore, a natural symbol of light, life, health, and wealth.

    But, while from these indications we are justified in supposing that
    among the Aryan nations the Svastika may have been an old emblem of
    the sun, there are other indications to show that in other parts of
    the world the same or a similar emblem was used to indicate the earth.
    Mr. Beal * * * has shown * * * that the simple cross ([cross]) occurs
    as a sign for earth in certain ideographic groups. It was probably
    intended to indicate the four quarters--north, south, east, west--or,
    it may be, more generally, extension in length and breadth.

    That the cross is used as a sign for "four" in the Bactro-Pali
    inscriptions (Max Müller, "Chips from a German Workshop," Vol. II, p.
    298) is well known; but the fact that the same sign has the same power
    elsewhere, as, for instance, in the Hieratic numerals, does not prove
    by any means that the one figure was derived from the other. We forget
    too easily that what was possible in one place was possible also in
    other places; and the more we extend our researches, the more we shall
    learn that the chapter of accidents is larger than we imagine.

    The "Suavastika" which Max Müller names and believes was applied to the Swastika sign, with the ends bent to the left (fig. 10), seems not to be reported with that meaning by any other author except Burnouf.[17] Therefore the normal Swastika would seem to be that with the ends bent to the right. Burnouf says the word Suavastika may be a derivative or development of the Svastikaya, and ought to signify "he who, or, that which, bears or carries the Swastika or a species of Swastika." Greg,[18] under the title Sôvastikaya, gives it as his opinion that there is no difference between it and the Swastika.

    Colonel Low[19] mentions the word Sawattheko, which, according to Burnouf[20] is only a variation of the Pali word Sotthika or Suvatthika, the Pali translation of the Sanskrit Swastika. Burnouf translates it as Svastikaya.

    M. Eugene Burnouf[21] speaks of a third sign of the footprint of Çakya, called Nandâvartaya, a good augury, the meaning being the "circle of fortune," which is the Swastika inclosed within a square with avenues radiating from the corners (fig. 14). Burnouf says the above sign has many significations. It is a sacred temple or edifice, a species of labyrinth, a garden of diamonds, a chain, a golden waist or shoulder belt, and a conique with spires turning to the right.

    Colonel Sykes[22] concludes that, according to the Chinese authorities Fa-hian, Soung Young, Hiuan thsang, the "Doctors of reason," Tao-sse, or followers of the mystic cross [S] were diffused in China and India before the advent of Sakya in the sixth century B. C. (according to Chinese, Japanese, and Buddhist authorities, the eleventh century B. C.), continuing until Fa-hian's time; and that they were professors of a qualified Buddhism, which, it is stated, was the universal religion of Tibet before Sakya's advent,[23] and continued until the introduction of orthodox Buddhism in the ninth century A. D.[24]

    [Illustration: Fig. 14. NANDÂVARTAYA, A THIRD SIGN OF THE FOOTPRINT OF BUDDHA. Burnouf, "Lotus de la Bonne Loi," Paris, 1852, p. 696.]

    Klaproth[25] calls attention to the frequent mention by Fa-hian, of the Tao-sse, sectaries of the mystic cross [S] (Sanskrit Swastika), and to their existence in Central Asia and India; while he says they were diffused over the countries to the west and southwest of China, and came annually from all kingdoms and countries to adore Kassapo, Buddha's predecessor.[26] Mr. James Burgess[27] mentions the Tirthankaras or Jainas as being sectarians of the Mystic Cross, the Swastika.

    The Cyclopædia of India (title Swastika), coinciding with Prof. Max Müller, says:

    The Swastika symbol is not to be confounded with the Swastika sect in
    Tibet which took the symbol for its name as typical of the belief of
    its members. They render the Sanskrit Swastika as composed of su
    "well" and asti "it is," meaning, as Professor Wilson expresses it,
    "so be it," and implying complete resignation under all circumstances.
    They claimed the Swastika of Sanskrit as the suti of Pali, and that
    the Swastika cross was a combination of the two symbols sutti-suti.
    They are rationalists, holding that contentment and peace of mind
    should be the only objects of life.

    The sect has preserved its
    existence in different localities and under different names,
    Thirthankara, Tor, Musteg, Pon, the last name meaning purity, under
    which a remnant are still in the farthest parts of the most eastern
    province of Tibet.

    General Cunningham[28] adds his assertion of the Swastika being the symbol used by the Buddhist sect of that name. He says in a note:

    The founder of this sect flourished about the year 604 to 523 B. C.,
    and that the mystic cross is a symbol formed by the combination of the
    two Sanskrit syllables su and ti-suti.

    Waring[29] proceeds to demolish these statements of a sect named Swastika as pure inventions, and "consulting Professor Wilson's invaluable work on the Hindoo religious sects in the 'Asiatic Researches,' we find no account of any sect named Swastika."

    Mr. V. R. Gandhi, a learned legal gentleman of Bombay, a representative of the Jain sect of Buddhists to the World's Parliament of Religions at Chicago, 1893, denies that there is in either India or Tibet a sect of Buddhists named "Swastika." He suggests that these gentlemen probably mean the sects of Jains (of which Mr. Gandhi is a member), because this sect uses the Swastika as a sign of benediction and blessing. This will be treated further on. (See p. 804.)

    Zmigrodzki, commenting on the frequency of the Swastika on the objects found by Dr. Schliemann at Hissarlik, gives it as his opinion[30] that these representations of the Swastika have relation to a human cult indicating a supreme being filled with goodness toward man. The sun, stars, etc., indicate him as a god of light. This, in connection with the idol of Venus, with its triangular shield engraved with a Swastika (fig. 125), and the growing trees and palms, with their increasing and multiplying branches and leaves, represent to him the idea of fecundity, multiplication, increase, and hence the god of life as well as of light.

    The Swastika sign on funeral vases indicates to him a belief in a divine spirit in man which lives after death, and hence he concludes that the people of Hissarlik, in the "Burnt City" (the third of Schliemann), adored a supreme being, the god of light and of life, and believed in the immortality of the soul.

    R. P. Greg says:[31]

    Originally it [the Swastika] would appear to have been an early Aryan
    atmospheric device or symbol indicative of both rain and lightning,
    phenomena appertaining to the god Indra, subsequently or collaterally
    developing, possibly, into the Suastika, or sacred fire churn in
    India, and at a still later period in Greece, adopted rather as a
    solar symbol, or converted about B. C. 650 into the meander or key
    pattern.

    Waring, while he testifies to the extension of the Swastika both in time and area, says:[32]

    But neither in the hideous jumble of Pantheism--the wild speculative
    thought, mystic fables, and perverted philosophy of life among the
    Buddhists--nor in the equally wild and false theosophy of the
    Brahmins, to whom this symbol, as distinctive of the Vishnavas,
    sectarian devotees of Vishnu, is ascribed by Moor in his "Indian
    Pantheon," nor yet in the tenets of the Jains,[33] do we find any
    decisive explanation of the meaning attached to this symbol, although
    its allegorical intention is indubitable.

    He mentions the Swastika of the Buddhists, the cross, the circle, their combination, the three-foot [Y] and adds: "They exhibit forms of those olden and widely spread pagan symbols of Deity and sanctity, eternal life and blessing."

    Professor Sayce says:[34]

    The Cyprian vase figured in Di Cesnola's "Cyprus," pl. XLV, fig. 36
    [see fig. 156], which associates the Swastika with the figure of an
    animal, is a striking analogue of the Trojan whorls on which it is
    associated with the figures of stags. The fact that it is drawn within
    the vulva of the leaden image of the Asiatic goddess [see fig. 125]
    seems to show that it was a symbol of generation. I believe that it is
    identical with the Cyprian character [symbol] or [symbol] (ne), which
    has the form [symbol] in the inscription of Golgi, and also with the
    Hittite [symbol] or [symbol] which Dr.

    Hyde Clarke once suggested to
    me was intended to represent the organs of generation.

    Mr. Waller, in his work entitled "Monumental Crosses," describes the Swastika as having been known in India as a sacred symbol many centuries before our Lord, and used as the distinguishing badge of a religious sect calling themselves "Followers of the Mystic Cross." Subsequently, he says, it was adopted by the followers of Buddha and was still later used by Christians at a very early period, being first introduced on Christian monuments in the sixth century. But Mr. Waring says that in this he is not correct, as it was found in some of the early paintings in the Roman catacombs, particularly on the habit of a Fossor, or gravedigger, given by D'Agincourt.

    Pugin, in his "Glossary of Ornament," under the title "Fylfot," says that in Tibet the Swastika was used as a representation of God crucified for the human race, citing as his authority F. Augustini Antonii Georgii.[35] He remarks:

    From these accounts it would appear that the fylfot is a mystical
    ornament, not only adopted among Christians from primitive times, but
    used, as if prophetically, for centuries before the coming of our
    Lord. To descend to later times, we find it constantly introduced in
    ecclesiastical vestments, * * * till the end of the fifteenth century,
    a period marked by great departure from traditional symbolism.

    Its use was continued in Tibet into modern times, though its meaning is not given.[36] (See p. 802.)

    The Rev. G. Cox, in his "Aryan Mythology," says:

    We recognize the male and the female symbol in the trident of
    Poseidon, and in the fylfot or hammer of Thor, which assumes the form
    of a cross-pattèe in the various legends which turn on the rings of
    Freya, Holda, Venus, or Aphrodite.

    Here again we find the fylfot and cross-pattèe spoken of as the same symbol, and as being emblematic of the reproductive principles, in which view of its meaning Dr. Inman, in his "Ancient Faiths Embodied in Ancient Names," concurs.

    Burnouf[37] recounts the myth of Agni (from which comes, through the Latin ignis, the English word igneous), the god of Sacred Fire, as told in the Veda:[38]

    The young queen, the mother of Fire, carried the royal infant
    mysteriously concealed in her bosom. She was a woman of the people,
    whose common name was "Arani"--that is, the instrument of wood (the
    Swastika) from which fire was made or brought by rubbing. * * * The
    origin of the sign [Swastika] is now easy to recognize. It represents
    the two pieces of wood which compose l'arani, of which the
    extremities were bent to be retained by the four nails.

    At the
    junction of the two pieces of wood was a fossette or cup-like hole,
    and there they placed a piece of wood upright, in form of a lance (the
    Pramantha), violent rotation of which, by whipping (after the fashion
    of top-whipping), produced fire, as did Prometheus, the porteur du
    feu
    , in Greece.

    And this myth was made, as have been others, probably by the priests and poets of succeeding times, to do duty for different philosophies. The Swastika was made to represent Arani (the female principle); the Pramantha or upright fire stake representing Agni, the fire god (the male); and so the myth served its part to account for the birth of fire. Burnouf hints that the myth grew out of the production of holy fire for the sacred altars by the use of the Pramantha and Swastika, after the manner of savages in all times. Zmigrodzki accepts this myth, and claims all specimens with dots or points--supposed nail holes--as Swastikas.

    The Count Goblet d'Alviella[39] argues in opposition to the theory announced by Burnouf and by Zmigrodzki, that the Swastika or croix swasticale, when presenting dots or points, had relation to fire making.

    He denies that the points represent nails, or that nails were made or necessary either for the Swastika or the Arani, and concludes that there is no evidence to support the theory, and nothing to show the Swastika to have been used as a fire-making apparatus, whether with or without the dots or points.

    Mr. Greg[40] opposes this entire theory, saying:

    The difficulty about the Swastika and its supposed connection with
    fire appears to me to be in not knowing precisely what the old fire
    drill and chark were like. * * * I much doubt whether the Swastika had
    originally any connection either with the fire-chark or with the sun.
    * * * The best authorities consider Burnouf is in error as to the
    earlier use of the two lower cross pieces of wood and the four nails
    said to have been used to fix or steady the framework.

    He quotes from Tylor's description[41] of the old fire drill used in India for kindling the sacrificial fire by the process called "churning," as it resembles that in India by which butter is separated from milk. It consists in drilling one piece of Arani wood by pulling a cord with one hand while the other is slackened, and so, alternately (the strap drill), till the wood takes fire. Mr. Greg states that the Eskimos use similar means, and the ancient Greeks used the drill and cord, and he adds his conclusions: "There is nothing of the Swastika and four nails in connection with the fire-churn."

    Burton[42] also criticises Burnouf's theory:

    If used on sacrificial altars to reproduce the holy fire, the practice
    is peculiar and not derived from everyday life; for as early as Pliny
    they know that the savages used two, and never three, fire sticks.

    Burnouf continues his discussion of myths concerning the origin of fire:

    According to Hymnes, the discoverer of fire was Atharan, whoso name
    signifies fire, but Bhrigon it was who made the sacred fire, producing
    resplendent flames on the earthen altar. In theory of physics, Agni,
    who was the fire residing within the "onction," (?) came from the milk
    of the cow, which, in its turn, came from the plants that had
    nourished her; and these plants in their turn grew by receiving and
    appropriating the heat or fire of the sun. Therefore, the virtue of
    the "onction" came from the god.

    One of the Vedas says of Agni, the god of fire:[43]

    Agni, thou art a sage, a priest, a king,
    Protector, father of the sacrifice;
    Commissioned by our men thou dost ascend
    A messenger, conveying to the sky
    Our hymns and offerings, though thy origin
    Be three fold, now from air and now from water,
    Now from the mystic double Arani.[44]

    Count Goblet d'Alviella combats the hypothesis of Burnouf that the Swastika when turned to right or left, passed, the one for the male and the other for the female principle, and declares, on the authority of Sir George Birdwood, that it is, in modern India, a popular custom to name objects which appear in couples as having different sexes, so that to say "the male Swastika" and the "female Swastika," indicating them by the pronouns "he" or "she," would be expressed in the same manner when speaking of the hammer and the anvil or of any other objects used in pairs.[45]

    Ludwig Müller, in his elaborate treatise, gives it as his opinion that the Swastika had no connection with the Tau cross or with the Crux ansata, or with the fire wheel, or with arani, or agni, or with the mystic or alphabetic letters, nor with the so-called spokes of the solar wheel, nor the forked lightning, nor the hammer of Thor. He considers that the triskelion might throw light on its origin, as indicating perpetual whirling or circular movement, which, in certain parts of southern Asia as the emblem of Zeus, was assimilated to that of Baal, an inference which he draws from certain Asiatic coins of 400 B. C.

    Mr. R. P. Greg[46] opposes this theory and expresses the opinion that the Swastika is far older and wider spread as a symbol than the triskelion, as well as being a more purely Aryan symbol. Greg says that Ludwig Müller attaches quite too much importance to the sun in connection with the early Aryans, and lays too great stress upon the supposed relation of the Swastika as a solar symbol.

    The Aryans, he says, were a race not given to sun worship; and, while he may agree with Müller that the Swastika is an emblem of Zeus and Jupiter merely as the Supreme God, yet he believes that the origin of the Swastika had no reference to a movement of the sun through the heavens; and he prefers his own theory that it was a device suggested by the forked lightning as the chief weapon of the air god.

    Mr. Greg's paper is of great elaboration, and highly complicated. He devotes an entire page or plate (21) to a chart showing the older Aryan fire, water, and sun gods, according to the Brahmin or Buddhist system.

    The earliest was Dyaus, the bright sky or the air god; Adyti, the infinite expanse, mother of bright gods; Varuna, the covering of the shining firmament. Out of this trinity came another, Zeus, being the descendant of Dyaus, the sky god; Agni, the fire; Sulya, the sun, and Indra, the rain god. These in their turn formed the great Hindu trinity, Brahma, Vishnu, and Siva--creator, preserver, and destroyer; and, in his opinion, the Swastika was the symbol or ordinary device of Indra as well as of Zeus.

    He continues his table of descent from these gods, with their accompanying devices, to the sun, lightning, fire, and water, and makes almost a complete scheme of the mythology of that period, into which it is not possible to follow him. However, he declines to accept the theory of Max Müller of any difference of form or meaning between the Suavastika and the Swastika because the ends or arms turned to the right or to the left, and he thinks the two symbols to be substantially the same.

    He considers it to have been, in the first instance, exclusively of early Aryan origin and use, and that down to about 600 B. C. it was the emblem or symbol of the supreme Aryan god; that it so continued down through the various steps of descent (according to the chart mentioned) until it became the device and symbol of Brahma, and finally of Buddha. He thinks that it may have been the origin of the Greek fret or meander pattern.

    Later still it was adopted even by the early Christians as a suitable variety of their cross, and became variously modified in form and was used as a charm.

    D'Alviella[47] expresses his doubts concerning the theory advanced by Greg[48] to the effect that the Swastika is to be interpreted as a symbol of the air or of the god who dwells in the air, operating sometimes to produce light, other times rain, then water, and so on, as is represented by the god Indra among the Hindus, Thor among the Germans and Scandinavians, Perkun among the Slavs, Zeus among the Pelasgi and Greeks, Jupiter Tonans, and Pluvius among the Latins.

    He disputes the theory that the association of the Swastika sign with various others on the same object proves its relationship with that object or sign. That it appears on vases or similar objects associated with what is evidently a solar disk is no evidence to him that the Swastika belongs to the sun, or when associated with the zigzags of lightning that it represents the god of lightning, nor the same with the god of heaven.

    The fact of its appearing either above or below any one of these is, in his opinion, of no importance and has no signification, either general or special.

    D'Alviella says[49] that the only example known to him of a Swastika upon a monument consecrated to Zeus or Jupiter is on a Celto-Roman altar, erected, according to all appearances, by the Daci during the time they were garrisoned at Ambloganna, in Britain. The altar bears the letters I.

    O. M., which have been thought to stand for Jupiter Optimus Maximus. The Swastika thereon is flanked by two disks or rouelles, with four rays, a sign which M. Gaidoz believes to have been a representative of the sun among the Gaulois.[50]

    Dr. Brinton[51] considers the Swastika as being related to the cross and not to the circle, and asserts that the Ta Ki or Triskeles, the Swastika and the Cross, were originally of the same signification, or at least closely allied in meaning.

    Waring,[52] after citing his authorities, sums up his opinion thus:

    We have given remarks of the various writers on this symbol, and it
    will be seen that, though they are more or less vague, uncertain, and
    confused in their description of it, still, with one exception, they
    all agree that it is a mystic symbol, peculiar to some deity or other,
    bearing a special signification, and generally believed to have some
    connection with one of the elements--water.

    Burton says:[53]

    The Svastika is apparently the simplest form of the Guilloche [scroll
    pattern or spiral]. According to Wilkinson (11, Chap. IX), the most
    complicated form of the Guilloche covered an Egyptian ceiling upward
    of a thousand years older than the objects found at Nineveh. The
    Svastika spread far and wide, everywhere assuming some fresh
    mythological and mysterious significance. In the north of Europe it
    became the Fylfot or Crutched cross.

    Count Goblet d'Alviella is of the opinion (p. 57) that the Swastika was "above all an amulet, talisman, or phylactere," while (p. 56) "it is incontestable that a great number of the Swastikas were simply motifs of ornamentation, of coin marks, and marks of fabrics," but he agrees (p. 57) that there is no symbol that has given rise to so many interpretations, not even the tricula of the Buddhists, and "this is a great deal to say." Ludwig Müller believes the Swastika to have been used as an ornament and as a charm and amulet, as well as a sacred symbol.

    Dr. H. Colley March, in his learned paper on the "Fylfot and the Futhore Tir,"[54] thinks the Swastika had no relation to fire or fire making or the fire god. His theory is that it symbolized axial motion and not merely gyration; that it represented the celestial pole, the axis of the heavens around which revolve the stars of the firmament. This appearance of rotation is most impressive in the constellation of the Great Bear.

    About four thousand years ago the apparent pivot of rotation was at [Greek: a] Draconis, much nearer the Great Bear than now, and at that time the rapid circular sweep must have been far more striking than at present. In addition to the name Ursa Major the Latins called this constellation Septentriones, "the seven plowing oxen," that dragged the stars around the pole, and the Greeks called it [Greek: elikê], from its vast spiral movement.[55] In the opinion of Dr. March all these are represented or symbolized by the Swastika.

    Prof. W. H. Goodyear, of New York, has lately (1891) published an elaborate quarto work entitled "The Grammar of the Lotus: A New History of Classic Ornament as a Development of Sun Worship."[56] It comprises 408 pages, with 76 plates, and nearly a thousand figures. His theory develops the sun symbol from the lotus by a series of ingenious and complicated evolutions passing through the Ionic style of architecture, the volutes and spirals forming meanders or Greek frets, and from this to the Swastika. The result is attained by the following line of argument and illustrations:

    The lotus was a "fetish of immemorial antiquity and has been worshiped in many countries from Japan to the Straits of Gibraltar;" it was a symbol of "fecundity," "life," "immortality," and of "resurrection," and has a mortuary significance and use. But its elementary and most important signification was as a solar symbol.[57]

    He describes the Egyptian lotus and traces it through an innumerable number of specimens and with great variety of form.

    He mentions many of the sacred animals of Egypt and seeks to maintain their relationship by or through the lotus, not only with each other but with solar circles and the sun worship.[58] Direct association of the solar disk and lotus are, according to him, common on the monuments and on Phenician and Assyrian seals; while the lotus and the sacred animals, as in cases cited of the goose representing Seb (solar god, and father of Osiris), also Osiris himself and Horus, the hawk and lotus, bull and lotus, the asp and lotus, the lion and lotus, the sphinx and lotus, the gryphon and lotus, the serpent and lotus, the ram and lotus--all of which animals, and with them the lotus, have, in his opinion, some related signification to the sun or some of his deities.[59] He is of the opinion that the lotus motif was the foundation of the Egyptian style of architecture, and that it appeared at an early date, say, the fourteenth century B.

    C. By intercommunication with the Greeks it formed the foundation of the Greek Ionic capital, which, he says,[60] "offers no dated example of the earlier time than the sixth century B. C." He supports this contention by authority, argument, and illustration.

    [Illustration: From figures in Goodyear's "Grammar of the Lotus," p. 27.

    Fig. 15. TYPICAL LOTUS ON CYPRIAN VASES.

    Fig. 16. TYPICAL LOTUS ON RHODIAN VASES.

    Fig. 17. TYPICAL LOTUS ON MELIAN VASES.]

    He shows[61] the transfer of the lotus motif to Greece, and its use as an ornament on the painted vases and on those from Cyprus, Rhodes, and Melos (figs. 15, 16, 17).

    [Illustration: Fig. 18. DETAIL OF CYPRIAN VASE SHOWING LOTUSES WITH CURLING SEPALS. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 47, fig. 1.]

    Chantre[62] notes the presence of spirals similar to those of fig. 17, in the terramares of northern Italy and up and down the Danube, and his fig. 186 (fig. 17) he says represents the decorating motif, the most frequent in all that part of prehistoric Europe. He cites "Notes sur les torques ou ornaments spirals."[63]

    That the lotus had a foundation deep and wide in Egyptian mythology is not to be denied; that it was allied to and associated on the monuments and other objects with many sacred and mythologic characters in Egypt and afterwards in Greece is accepted. How far it extends in the direction contended for by Professor Goodyear, is no part of this investigation. It appears well established that in both countries it became highly conventionalized, and it is quite sufficient for the purpose of this argument that it became thus associated with the Swastika. Figs.

    18 and 19 represent details of Cyprian vases and amphora belonging to the Cesnola collection in the New York Metropolitan Museum of Art, showing the lotus with curling sepals among which are interspersed Swastikas of different forms.

    [Illustration: Fig. 19. DETAIL OF CYPRIAN AMPHORA IN METROPOLITAN MUSEUM OF ART, NEW YORK CITY. Lotus with curling sepals and different Swastikas.

    Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 47, figs. 2, 3.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 20. THEORY OF THE EVOLUTION OF THE SPIRAL SCROLL FROM LOTUS. One Volute. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," fig. 21.]

    According to Professor Goodyear,[64] these bent sepals of the lotus were exaggerated and finally became spirals,[65] which, being projected at a tangent, made volutes, and, continuing one after the other, as shown in fig. 20, formed bands of ornament; or,[66] being connected to right and left, spread the ornament over an extended surface as in fig. 21. One of his paths of evolution closed these volutes and dropped the connecting tangent, when they formed the concentric rings of which we see so much.

    Several forms of Egyptian scarabæi, showing the evolution of concentric rings, are shown in figs. 22, 23, and 24.

    [Illustration: Fig. 21. THEORY OF LOTUS RUDIMENTS IN SPIRAL. Tomb 33, Abd-el Kourneh, Thebes. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," p. 96.]

    By another path of the evolution of his theory, one has only to square the spiral volutes, and the result is the Greek fret shown in fig. 25.[67] The Greek fret has only to be doubled, when it produces the Swastika shown in fig. 26.[68] Thus we have, according to him, the origin of the Swastika, as shown in figs. 27 and 28.[69]

    Professor Goodyear is authority for the statement that the earliest dated instances of the isolated scroll is in the fifth dynasty of Egypt, and of the lotus and spiral is in the eleventh dynasty. The spiral of fig. 19 (above) belongs to the twelfth dynasty.[70]

    [Illustration: EGYPTIAN SCARABÆI SHOWING EVOLUTION OF CONCENTRIC RINGS.

    Fig. 22. CONCENTRIC RINGS CONNECTED BY TANGENTS. From a figure in Petrie's "History of Scarabs."

    Fig. 23. CONCENTRIC RINGS WITH DISCONNECTED TANGENTS. Barringer collection, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 8, fig. 93.

    Fig. 24. CONCENTRIC RINGS WITHOUT CONNECTION. Farman collection, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 8, fig. 95.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 25. SPECIAL EGYPTIAN MEANDER. An illustration of the theory of derivation from the spiral. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 10, fig. 9.]

    Professor Goodyear devotes an entire chapter to the Swastika. On pages 352, 353 he says:

    There is no proposition in archæology which can be so easily
    demonstrated as the assertion that the Swastika was originally a
    fragment of the Egyptian meander, provided Greek geometric vases are
    called in evidence. The connection between the meander and the
    Swastika has been long since suggested by Prof. A. S. Murray.[71]
    Hindu specialists have suggested that the Swastika produced the
    meander.

    Birdwood[72] says: "I believe the Swastika to be the origin
    of the key pattern ornament of Greek and Chinese decorative art."
    Zmigrodzki, in a recent publication,[73] has not only reproposed this
    derivation of the meander, but has even connected the Mycenæ spirals
    with this supposed development, and has proposed to change the name of
    the spiral ornament accordingly. * * * The equivalence of the Swastika
    with the meander pattern is suggested, in the first instance, by its
    appearance in the shape of the meander on the Rhodian (pl. 28, fig.
    7), Melian (pl. 60, fig. 8), archæic Greek (pl. 60, fig. 9, and pl.
    61, fig.

    12), and Greek geometric vases (pl. 56). The appearance, in
    shape of the meander may be verified in the British Museum on one
    geometric vase of the oldest type, and it also occurs in the Louvre.

    On page 354, Goodyear says:

    The solar significance of the Swastika is proven by the Hindu coins of
    the Jains. Its generative significance is proven by a leaden statuette
    from Troy. It is an equivalent of the lotus (pl. 47, figs. 1, 2, 3),
    of the solar diagram (pl. 57, fig. 12, and pl. 60, fig. 8), of the
    rosette (pl. 20, fig. 8), of concentric rings (pl. 47, fig. 11), of
    the spiral scroll (pl. 34, fig. 8, and pl. 39, fig. 2), of the
    geometric boss (pl. 48, fig. 12), of the triangle (pl. 46, fig. 5),
    and of the anthemion (pl. 28, fig. 7, and pl. 30, fig. 4). It appears
    with the solar deer (pl. 60, figs. 1 and 2), with the solar antelope
    (pl. 37, fig.

    9), with the symbolic fish (pl. 42, fig. 1), with the
    ibex (pl. 37, fig. 4), with the solar sphinx (pl. 34, fig. 8), with
    the solar lion (pl. 30, fig. 4), the solar ram (pl. 28, fig. 7), and
    the solar horse (pl. 61, figs. 1, 4, 5, and 12). Its most emphatic and
    constant association is with the solar bird (pl. 60, fig. 15; fig.
    173).

    [Illustration: Fig. 26. DETAIL OF GREEK VASE. Meander and Swastika.

    Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," fig. 171.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 27. DETAIL OF GREEK GEOMETRIC VASE IN THE BRITISH MUSEUM. Swastika, right, with solar geese. Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 353, fig. 173.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 28. GREEK GEOMETRIC VASE. Swastika with solar geese.

    Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 353, fig. 172.]

    Count Goblet d'Alviella, following Ludwig Müller, Percy Gardner, S. Beal, Edward Thomas, Max Müller, H. Gaidoz, and other authors, accepts their theory that the Swastika was a symbolic representation of the sun or of a sun god, and argues it fully.[74] He starts with the proposition that most of the nations of the earth have represented the sun by a circle, although some of them, notably the Assyrians, Hindus, Greeks, and Celts, have represented it by signs more or less cruciform. Examining his fig.

    2, wherein signs of the various people are set forth, it is to be remarked that there is no similarity or apparent relationship between the six symbols given, either with themselves or with the sun. Only one of them, that of Assyria, pretends to be a circle; and it may or may not stand for the sun. It has no exterior rays. All the rest are crosses of different kinds. Each of the six symbols is represented as being from a single nation of people.

    They are prehistoric or of high antiquity, and most of them appear to have no other evidence of their representation of the sun than is contained in the sign itself, so that the first objection is to the premises, to wit, that while his symbols may have sometimes represented the sun, it is far from certain that they are used constantly or steadily as such.

    An objection is made to the theory or hypothesis presented by Count d'Alviella[75] that it is not the cross part of the Swastika which represents the sun, but its bent arms, which show the revolving motion, by which he says is evolved the tetraskelion or what in this paper is named the "Ogee Swastika." The author is more in accord with Dr. Brinton and others that the Swastika is derived from the cross and not from the wheel, that the bent arms do not represent rotary or gyratory motion, and that it had no association with, or relation to, the circle.

    This, if true, relieves the Swastika from all relation with the circle as a symbol of the sun. Besides, it is not believed that the symbol of the sun is one which required rotary or gyratory motion or was represented by it, but, as will be explained, in speaking of the Assyrian sun-god Shamash (p. 789), it is rather by a circle with pointed rays extending outward.

    D'Alviella[76] presents several figures in support of his contention. The first (a) is on a fibula from Etruria (fig. 190 of this paper). His explanation is that the small circle of rays, bent at right angles, on the broad shield of the pin, represents graphically the rotary movement of the sun, and that the bent arms in the Swastikas on the same object are taken from them.

    It seems curious that so momentous a subject as the existence of a symbol of a great god, the god of light, heat, and thus of life, should be made to depend upon an object of so small importance. This specimen (fig. 190) is a fibula or pin, one of the commonest objects of Etruscan, Greek, or Roman dress. The decorations invoked are on the broad end, which has been flattened to protect the point of the pin, where appears a semicircle of so-called rays, the two Swastikas and two possible crosses.

    There is nothing about this pin, nor indeed any of the other objects, to indicate any holy or sacred character, nor that any of them were used in any ceremony having relation to the sun, to any god, or to anything holy or sacred. His fig. b is fig. 88 in this paper. It shows a quadrant of the sphere found by Schliemann at Hissarlik. There is a slightly indefinite circle with rays from the outside, which are bent and crooked in many directions. The sphere is of terra cotta; the marks that have been made on it are rough and ill formed.

    They were made by incision while the clay was soft and were done in the rudest manner. There are dozens more marks upon the same sphere, none of which seem to have received any consideration in this regard. There is a Swastika upon the sphere, and it is the only mark or sign upon the entire object that seems to have been made with care or precision. His third figure (c) is taken from a reliquaire of the thirteenth century A. D. It has a greater resemblance to the acanthus plant than it has to any solar disk imaginable.

    The other two figures (d and e) are tetraskelions or ogee Swastikas from ancient coins.

    D'Alviella's next argument[77] is that the triskelion, formed by the same process as the tetraskelion, is an "incontestable" representation of solar movement. No evidence is submitted in support of this assertion, and the investigator of the present day is required, as in prehistoric objects, to depend entirely upon the object itself. The bent arms contain no innate evidence (even though they should be held to represent rotary or gyratory motion) representing the sun or sun gods.

    It is respectfully suggested that in times of antiquity, as in modern times, the sun is not represented as having a rotary motion, but is rather represented by a circle with diminishing rays projecting from the center or exterior. It seems unjustifiable, almost ridiculous, to transform the three flexed human legs, first appearing on the coins of Lycia, into a sun symbol, to make it the reliable evidence of sun worship, and give it a holy or sacred character as representing a god.

    It is surely pushing the argument too far to say that this is an "incontestable" representation of the solar movement. The illustrations by d'Alviella on his page 71 are practically the same as figs. 224 to 226 of this paper.

    Count d'Alviella's further argument[78] is that symbols of the sun god being frequently associated, alternated with, and sometimes replaced by, the Swastika, proves it to have been a sun symbol. But this is doubted, and evidence to sustain the proposition is wanting. Undoubtedly the Swastika was a symbol, was intentional, had a meaning and a degree of importance, and, while it may have been intended to represent the sun and have a higher and holier character, yet these mere associations are not evidence of the fact.

    D'Alviella's plate 2, page 80, while divided into sections a and b, is filled only with illustrations of Swastika associated with circles, dots, etc., introduced for the purpose of showing the association of the Swastika therewith, and that the permutation and replacing of these signs by the Swastika is evidence that the Swastika represented the sun. Most of the same illustrations are presented in this paper, and it is respectfully submitted that the evidence does not bear out his conclusion.

    If it be established that these other symbols are representatives of the sun, how does that prove that the Swastika was itself a representative of the sun or the sun god? D'Alviella himself argues[79] against the proposition of equivalence of meaning because of association when applied to the Crux ansata, the circle, the crescent, the triskelion, the lightning sign, and other symbolic figures.

    He denies that because the Swastika is found on objects associated with these signs therefore they became interchangeable in meaning, or that the Swastika stood for any of them. The Count[79] says that more likely the engraver added the Swastika to these in the character of a talisman or phylactery. On page 56 he argues in the same line, that because it is found on an object of sacred character does not necessarily give it the signification of a sacred or holy symbol.

    He regards the Swastika as a symbol of good fortune, and sees no reason why it may not be employed as an invocation to a god of any name or kind on the principle, "Good Lord, good devil," quoting the Neapolitan proverb, that it will do no harm, and possibly may do good.

    Prof. Max Müller[80] refers to the discovery by Prof. Percy Gardner of one of the coins of Mesembria, whereon the Swastika replaces the last two syllables of the word, and he regards this as decisive that in Greece the meaning of the Swastika was equivalent to the sun. This word, Mesembria, being translated ville de midi, means town or city of the south, or the sun. He cites from Mr.

    Thomas's paper on the "Indian Swastika and its Western Counterparts"[81] what he considers an equally decisive discovery made some years ago, wherein it was shown that the wheel, the emblem of the sun in motion, was replaced by the Swastika on certain coins; likewise on some of the Andhra coins and some punched gold coins noted by Sir Walter Elliott.[82] In these cases the circle or wheel alleged to symbolize the sun was replaced by the Swastika.

    The Swastika has been sometimes inscribed within the rings or normal circles representing what is said to be the four suns on Ujain patterns or coins (fig. 230). Other authorities have adopted the same view, and have extended it to include the lightning, the storm, the fire wheel, the sun chariot, etc. (See Ohnefalsch-Richter, p. 790.) This appears to be a non sequitur. All these speculations may be correct, and all these meanings may have been given to the Swastika, but the evidence submitted does not prove the fact.

    There is in the case of the foregoing coins no evidence yet presented as to which sign, the wheel or the Swastika, preceded and which followed in point of time. The Swastika may have appeared first instead of last, and may not have been a substitution for the disk, but an original design. The disk employed, while possibly representing the sun in some places, may not have done so always nor in this particular case.

    It assumes too much to say that every time a small circle appears on an ancient object it represented the sun, and the same observation can be made with regard to symbols of the other elements.

    Until it shall have been satisfactorily established that the symbols represented these elements with practical unanimity, and that the Swastika actually and intentionally replaced it as such, the theory remains undemonstrated, the burden rests on those who take the affirmative side; and until these points shall have been settled with some degree of probability the conclusion is not warranted.

    As an illustration of the various significations possible, one has but to turn to Chapter IV, on the various meanings given to the cross among American Indians, where it is shown that among these Indians the cross represented the four winds, the sun, stars, dwellings, the dragon fly, mide' society, flocks of birds, human form, maidenhood, evil spirit, and divers others.

    Mr. Edward Thomas, in his work entitled "The Indian Swastika and its Western Counterparts,"[83] says:

    As far as I have been able to trace or connect the various
    manifestations of this emblem [the Swastika], they one and all resolve
    themselves into the primitive conception of solar motion, which was
    intuitively associated with the rolling or wheel-like projection of
    the sun through the upper or visible arc of the heavens, as understood
    and accepted in the crude astronomy of the ancients.

    The earliest
    phase of astronomical science we are at present in position to refer
    to, with the still extant aid of indigenous diagrams, is the Chaldean.
    The representation of the sun in this system commences with a simple
    ring or outline circle, which is speedily advanced toward the
    impression of onward revolving motion by the insertion of a cross or
    four wheel-like spokes within the circumference of the normal ring.

    As
    the original Chaldean emblem of the sun was typified by a single ring,
    so the Indian mind adopted a similar definition, which remains to this
    day as the ostensible device or cast-mark of the modern Sauras or sun
    worshipers.

    The same remarks are made in "Ilios" (pp. 353, 354).

    The author will not presume to question, much less deny, the facts stated by this learned gentleman, but it is to be remarked that, on the theory of presumption, the circle might represent many other things than the sun, and unless the evidence in favor of the foregoing statement is susceptible of verification, the theory can hardly be accepted as conclusive. Why should not the circle represent other things than the sun?

    In modern astronomy the full moon is represented by the plain circle, while the sun, at least in heraldry, is always represented as a circle with rays. It is believed that the "cross or four wheel-like spokes" in the Chaldean emblem of the sun will be found to be rays rather than cross or spokes. A cast is in the U. S. National Museum (Cat. No. 154766) of an original specimen from Niffer, now in the Royal Museum, Berlin, of Shamash, the Assyrian god of the sun.

    He is represented on this monument by a solar disk, 4 inches in diameter, with eight rays similar to those of stars, their bases on a faint circle at the center, and tapering outwards to a point, the whole surrounded by another faint circle. This is evidence that the sun symbol of Assyria required rays as well as a circle. A similar representation of the sun god is found on a tablet discovered in the temple of the Sun God at Abu-Habba.[84]

    Perrot and Chipiez[85] show a tablet from Sippara, of a king, Nabu-abal-iddin, 900 B. C., doing homage to the sun god (identified by the inscription), who is represented by bas-relief of a small circle in the center, with rays and lightning zigzags extending to an outer circle.

    In view of these authorities and others which might be cited, it is questionable whether the plain circle was continuously a representation of the sun in the Chaldean or Assyrian astronomy. It is also doubtful whether, if the circle did represent the sun, the insertion of the cross or the four wheel-like spokes necessarily gave the impression of "onward revolving motion;" or whether any or all of the foregoing afford a satisfactory basis for the origin of the Swastika or for its relation to, or representation of, the sun or the sun god.

    Dr. Max Ohnefalsch-Richter[86] announces as his opinion that the Swastika in Cyprus had nearly always a signification more or less religious and sacred, though it may have been used as an ornament to fill empty spaces.

    He attributes to the Croix swasticale--or, as he calls it, Croix cantonnée--the equivalence of the solar disk, zigzag lightning, and double hatchet; while to the Swastika proper he attributes the signification of rain, storm, lightning, sun, light, seasons, and also that it lends itself easily to the solar disk, the fire wheel, and the sun chariot.

    Greg[87] says:

    Considered finally, it may be asked if the fylfot or gammadion was an
    early symbol of the sun, or, if only an emblem of the solar
    revolutions or in movements across the heavens, why it was drawn
    square rather than curved: The [Z], even if used in a solar sense,
    must have implied something more than, or something distinct from, the
    sun, whose proper and almost universal symbol was the circle. It was
    evidently more connected with the cross [cross] than with the circle
    [circle] or solar disk.

    Dr. Brinton[88] considers the Swastika as derived from the cross rather than from the circle, and the author agrees that this is probable, although it may be impossible of demonstration either way.

    Several authors, among the rest d'Alviella, Greg, and Thomas, have announced the theory of the evolution of the Swastika, beginning with the triskelion, thence to the tetraskelion, and so to the Swastika. A slight examination is sufficient to overturn this hypothesis. In the first place, the triskelion, which is the foundation of this hypothesis, made its first appearance on the coins of Lycia. But this appearance was within what is called the first period of coinage, to wit, between 700 and 480 B.

    C., and it did not become settled until the second, and even the third period, 280 to 240 B. C., when it migrated to Sicily. But the Swastika had already appeared in Armenia, on the hill of Hissarlik, in the terramares of northern Italy, and on the hut-urns of southern Italy many hundred, possibly a thousand or more, years prior to that time. Count d'Alviella, in his plate 3 (see Chart I, p. 794), assigns it to a period of the fourteenth or thirteenth century B. C., with an unknown and indefinite past behind it.

    It is impossible that a symbol which first appeared in 480 B. C. could have been the ancestor of one which appeared in 1400 or 1300 B. C., nearly a thousand years before.

    William Simpson[89] makes observations upon the latest discoveries regarding the Swastika and gives his conclusion:

    • * * The finding of the Swastika in America gives a very wide

    geographical space that is included by the problem connected with it,
    but it is wider still, for the Swastika is found over the most of the
    habitable world, almost literally "from China to Peru," and it can be
    traced back to a very early period. The latest idea formed regarding
    the Swastika is that it may be a form of the old wheel symbolism and
    that it represents a solar movement, or perhaps, in a wider sense, the
    whole celestial movement of the stars.

    The Dharmachakra, or Buddhist
    wheel, of which the so-called "praying wheel" of the Lamas of Thibet
    is only a variant, can now be shown to have represented the solar
    motion. It did not originate with the Buddhists; they borrowed it from
    the Brahminical system to the Veda, where it is called "the wheel of
    the sun." I have lately collected a large amount of evidence on this
    subject, being engaged in writing upon it, and the numerous passages
    from the old Brahminical authorities leave no doubt in the matter. The
    late Mr. Edward Thomas * * * and Prof.

    Percy Gardner * * * declared
    that on some Andhra gold coins and one from Mesembria, Greece, the
    part of the word which means day, or when the sun shines, is
    represented by the Swastika. These details will be found in a letter
    published in the "Athenæum" of August 20, 1892, written by Prof. Max
    Müller, who affirms that it "is decisive" as to the meaning of the
    symbol in Greece. This evidence may be "decisive" for India and
    Greece, but it does not make us quite certain about other parts of the
    world.

    Still it raises a strong presumption that its meaning is likely
    to be somewhat similar wherever the symbol is found.

    It is now assumed that the Triskelion or Three Legs of the Isle of Man
    is only a variant of the Swastika. * * * There are many variants
    besides this in which the legs, or limbs, differ in number, and they
    may all be classed as whorls, and were possibly all, more or less,
    forms intended originally to express circular motion. As the subject
    is too extensive to be fully treated here, and many illustrations
    would be necessary, to those wishing for further details I would
    recommend a work just published entitled "The Migration of Symbols,"
    by Count Goblet d'Alviella, with an introduction by Sir George
    Birdwood.

    The frontispiece of the book is a representation of Apollo,
    from a vase in the Kunsthistorisches Museum of Vienna, and on the
    middle of Apollo's breast there is a large and prominent Swastika. In
    this we have another instance going far to show its solar
    significance. While accepting these new interpretations of the symbol,
    I am still inclined to the notion that the Swastika may, at the same
    time, have been looked upon in some cases as a cross--that is, a
    pre-Christian cross, which now finds acceptance by some authorities as
    representing the four cardinal points.

    The importance of the cardinal
    points in primitive symbolism appears to me to have been very great,
    and has not as yet been fully realized. This is too large a matter to
    deal with here. All I can state is, that the wheel in India was
    connected with the title of a Chakravartin--from Chakra, a
    wheel--the title meaning a supreme ruler, or a universal monarch, who
    ruled the four quarters of the world, and on his coronation he had to
    drive his chariot, or wheel, to the four cardinal points to signify
    his conquest of them. Evidence of other ceremonies of the same kind in
    Europe can be produced.

    From instances such as these, I am inclined to
    assume that the Swastika, as a cross, represented the four quarters
    over which the solar power by its revolving motion carried its
    influence.

    ORIGIN AND HABITAT.

    Prehistoric archæologists have found in Europe many specimens of ornamental sculpture and engraving belonging to the Paleolithic age, but the cross is not known in any form, Swastika or other. In the Neolithic age, which spread itself over nearly the entire world, with many geometric forms of decoration, no form of the cross appears in times of high antiquity as a symbol or as indicating any other than an ornamental purpose. In the age of bronze, however, the Swastika appears, intentionally used, as a symbol as well as an ornament.

    Whether its first appearance was in the Orient, and its spread thence throughout prehistoric Europe, or whether the reverse was true, may not now be determined with certainty. It is believed by some to be involved in that other warmly disputed and much-discussed question as to the locality of origin and the mode and routes of dispersion of Aryan peoples. There is evidence to show that it belongs to an earlier epoch than this, and relates to the similar problem concerning the locality of origin and the mode and routes of the dispersion of bronze.

    Was bronze discovered in eastern Asia and was its migration westward through Europe, or was it discovered on the Mediterranean, and its spread thence? The Swastika spread through the same countries as did the bronze, and there is every reason to believe them to have proceeded contemporaneously--whether at their beginning or not, is undeterminable.

    The first appearance of the Swastika was apparently in the Orient, precisely in what country it is impossible to say, but probably in central and southeastern Asia among the forerunners or predecessors of the Bramins and Buddhists. At all events, a religious and symbolic signification was attributed to it by the earliest known peoples of these localities.

    M. Michael Zmigrodzki, a Polish scholar, public librarian at Sucha, near Cracow, prepared and sent to the World's Columbian Exposition at Chicago a manuscript chart in French, showing his opinion of the migration of the Swastika, which was displayed in the Woman's Building. It was arranged in groups: The prehistoric (or Pagan) and Christian. These were divided geographically and with an attempt at chronology, as follows:

    I. Prehistoric:
    1. India and Bactria.
    2. Cyprus, Rhodes.
    3. North Europe.
    4. Central Europe.
    5. South Europe.
    6. Asia Minor.
    7. Greek and Roman epoch--Numismatics.
    II. Christian:
    8. Gaul--Numismatics.
    9. Byzantine.
    10. Merovingian and Carlovingian.
    11. Germany.
    12. Poland and Sweden.
    13. Great Britain.

    Lastly he introduces a group of the Swastika in the nineteenth century. He presented figures of Swastikas from these localities and representing these epochs. He had a similar display at the Paris Exposition of 1889, which at its close was deposited in the St. Germain Prehistoric Museum. I met M. Zmigrodzki at the Tenth International Congress of Anthropology and Prehistoric Archæology in Paris, and heard him present the results of his investigations on the Swastika.

    I have since corresponded with him, and he has kindly sent me separates of his paper published in the Archives für Ethnographie, with 266 illustrations of the Swastika; but on asking his permission to use some of the information in the chart at Chicago, he informed me he had already given the manuscript chart and the right to reproduce it to the Chicago Folk-Lore Society. The secretary of this society declined to permit it to pass out of its possession, though proffering inspection of it in Chicago.

    In his elaborate dissertation Count Goblet d'Alviella[90] shows an earlier and prehistoric existence of the Swastika before its appearance on the hill of Hissarlik. From this earlier place of origin it, according to him, spread to the Bronze age terramares of northern Italy. All this was prior to the thirteenth century B. C. From the hill of Hissarlik it spread east and west; to the east into Lycaonia and Caucasus, to the west into Mycenæ and Greece; first on the pottery and then on the coins.

    From Greece it also spread east and west; east to Asia Minor and west to Thrace and Macedonia. From the terramares he follows it through the Villanova epoch, through Etruria and Grand Greece, to Sicily, Gaul, Britain, Germany, Scandinavia, to all of which migration he assigns various dates down to the second century B. C. It developed westward from Asia Minor to northern Africa and to Rome, with evidence in the Catacombs; on the eastward it goes into India, Persia, China, Tibet, and Japan.

    All this can be made apparent upon examination of the plate itself. It is introduced as Chart I, p. 794.

    The author enters into no discussion with Count d'Alviella over the correctness or completeness of the migrations set forth in his chart. It will be conceded, even by its author, to be largely theoretical and impossible to verify by positive proof. He will only contend that there is a probability of its correctness.

    It is doubted whether he can maintain his proposition of the constant presence or continued appearance of the Swastika on altars, idols, priestly vestments, and sepulchral urns, and that this demonstrates the Swastika to have always possessed the attributes of a religious symbol.

    It appears to have been used more frequently upon the smaller and more insignificant things of everyday life--the household utensils, the arms, weapons, the dress, the fibulæ, and the pottery; and while this may be consonant with the attributes of the talisman or amulet or charm, it is still compatible with the theory of the Swastika being a sign or symbol for benediction, blessing, good fortune, or good luck; and that it was rather this than a religious symbol.

    [Illustration: CHART I.--Probable introduction of the Swastika into different countries, according to Count Goblet d'Alviella.

    ["La Migration des Symboles," pl. 3.]]

    Count Goblet d'Alviella, in the fourth section of the second chapter[91] relating to the country of its origin, argues that the Swastika sign was employed by all the Aryans except the Persians. This omission he explains by showing that the Swastika in all other lands stood for the sun or for the sun-god, while the Aryans of Persia had other signs for the same thing--the Crux ansata and the winged globe.

    His conclusion is[92] that there were two zones occupied with different symbols, the frontier between them being from Persia, through Cyprus, Rhodes, and Asia Minor, to Libya; that the first belonged to the Greek civilization, which employed the Swastika as a sun symbol; the second to the Egypto-Babylonian, which employed the Crux ansata and the winged globe as sun symbols.

    Professor Sayce, in his preface to "Troja," says:[93]

    The same symbol [the Swastika], as is well known, occurs on the
    Archaic pottery of Cyprus * * * as well as upon the prehistoric
    antiquities of Athens and Mykênæ [same, "Ilios," p. 353], but it was
    entirely unknown to Babylonia, to Assyria, to Phoenicia, and to Egypt.
    It must therefore either have originated in Europe and spread eastward
    through Asia Minor or have been disseminated westward from the
    primitive home of the Hittites.

    The latter alternative is the more
    probable; but whether it is so or not, the presence of the symbol in
    the land of the Ægean indicates a particular epoch and the influence
    of a pre-Phoenician culture.

    Dr. Schliemann[94] reports that "Rev. W. Brown Keer observed the Swastika innumerable times in the most ancient Hindu temples, especially those of the Jainas."

    Max Müller cites the following paragraph by Professor Sayce:[95]

    It is evident to me that the sign found at Hissarlik is identical with
    that found at Mycenæ and Athens, as well as on the prehistoric pottery
    of Cyprus (Di Cesnola, Cyprus, pls. 44 and 47), since the general
    artistic character of the objects with which this sign is associated
    in Cyprus and Greece agrees with that of the objects discovered in
    Troy. The Cyprian vase [fig. 156, this paper] figured in Di Cesnola's
    "Cyprus," pl. 45, which associates the Swastika with the figure of an
    animal, is a striking analogue of the Trojan whorls, on which it is
    associated with the figure of the stags.

    The fact that it is drawn
    within the vulva of the leaden image on the Asiatic goddess shown in
    fig. 226 ("Ilios," fig. 125 this paper) seems to show that it was a
    symbol of generation.

    Count Goblet d'Alviella,[96] citing Albert Dumont[97] and Perrot and Chipiez,[98] says:

    The Swastika appears in Greece, as well as in Cyprus and Rhodes, first
    on the pottery, with geometric decorations, which form the second
    period in Greek ceramics. From that it passes to a later period, where
    the decoration is more artistic and the appearance of which coincides
    with the development of the Phoenician influences on the coasts of
    Greece.

    Dr. Ohnefalsch-Richter, in a paper devoted to the consideration of the Swastika in Cyprus,[99] expresses the opinion that the emigrant or commercial Phenicians traveling in far eastern countries brought the Swastika by the sea route of the Persian Gulf to Asia Minor and Cyprus, while, possibly, other people, brought it by the overland route from central Asia, Asia Minor, and Hissarlik, and afterwards by migration to Cyprus, Carthage, and the north of Africa.

    Professor Goodyear says:[100]

    The true home of the Swastika is the Greek geometric style, as will be
    immediately obvious to every expert who examines the question through
    the study of that style. In seeking the home of a symbol, we should
    consider where it appears in the largest dimension and where it
    appears in the most formal and prominent way. The Greek geometric
    vases are the only monuments on which the Swastika systematically
    appears in panels exclusively assigned to it (pl. 60, fig. 13; and pl.
    56, fig. 4). There are no other monuments on which the Swastika can be
    found in a dimension taking up one-half the height of the entire
    object (pl. 56, fig. 4).

    The ordinary size of the Swastika, in very
    primitive times, is under a third of an inch in diameter. They are
    found in Greek geometric pottery 2 or 3 inches in diameter, but they
    also appear in the informal scattering way (pl. 61, fig. 4) which
    characterizes the Swastika in other styles.

    • * * * *

    The Swastika dates from the earliest diffusion of the Egyptian meander
    in the basin of the Mediterranean, and it is a profound remark of De
    Morgan (Mission Scientifique au Caucase) that the area of the Swastika
    appears to be coextensive with the area of bronze. In northern
    prehistoric Europe, where the Swastika has attracted considerable
    attention, it is distinctly connected with the bronze culture derived
    from the south. When found on prehistoric pottery of the north, the
    southern home of its beginnings is equally clear.

    In seeking the home of a symbol, we should consider not only the
    nature of its appearance, but also where it is found in the largest
    amount, for this shows the center of vogue and power--that is to say,
    the center of diffusion. The vogue of the Swastika at Troy is not as
    great as its vogue in Cyprian Greek pottery (pl. 60, fig. 15) and
    Rhodian pottery (pl. 60, fig. 2). * * * It is well known to Melian
    vases (pl. 60, fig. 8) and to archaic Greek vases (pl. 61, fig. 12),
    but its greatest prominence is on the pottery of the Greek geometric
    style (pl. 60, fig. 13; pl. 56, fig. 4; pl. 61, figs. 1 and 4; and
    figs. 173 and 171). * * *

    Aside from the Greek geometric style, our earliest reference for the
    Swastika, and very possibly an earlier reference than the first, is
    its appearance on the "hut urns" of Italy. On such it appears rather
    as a fragment of the more complicated meander patterns, from which it
    is derived. My precise view is that the earliest and, consequently,
    imperfect, forms of the Swastika are on the hut urns of Italy, but
    that, as an independent and definitely shaped pattern, it first
    belongs to the Greek geometric style.

    I do not assert that the
    Swastika is very common on hut urns, which are often undecorated. * *
    * Our present intermediate link with India for the Swastika lies in
    the Caucasus and in the adjacent territory of Koban. This last ancient
    center of the arts in metal has lately attracted attention through the
    publication of Virchow (Das Gräberfeld von Koban). In the original
    Coban bronzes of the Prehistoric Museum of St. Germain there is
    abundant matter for study (p. 351).

    Mr. R. P. Greg, in "Fret or Key Ornamentation in Mexico and Peru,"[101] says:

    Both the Greek fret and the fylfot appear to have been unknown to the
    Semitic nations as an ornament or as a symbol.

    In Egypt the fylfot does not occur. It is, I believe, generally
    admitted or supposed that the fylfot is of early Aryan origin.
    Eastward toward India, Tibet, and China it was adopted, in all
    probability, as a sacred symbol of Buddha; westward it may have spread
    in one form or another to Greece, Asia Minor, and even to North
    Germany.

    Cartailhac says:[102]

    Modern Christian archæologists have obstinately contended that the
    Swastika was composed of four gamma, and so have called it the Croix
    Gammée. But the Ramâyana placed it on the boat of the Rama long before
    they had any knowledge of Greek. It is found on a number of Buddhist
    edifices; the Sectarians of Vishnu placed it as a sign upon their
    foreheads. Burnouf says it is the Aryan sign par excellence. It was
    surely a religious emblem in use in India fifteen centuries before the
    Christian era, and thence it spread to every part.

    In Europe it
    appeared about the middle of the civilization of the bronze age, and
    we find it, pure or transformed into a cross, on a mass of objects in
    metal or pottery during the first age of iron. Sometimes its lines
    were rounded and given a graceful curve instead of straight and square
    at its ends and angles. [See letter by Gandhi, pp. 803, 805.]

    M. Cartailhac notes[103] several facts concerning the associations of the Swastika found by him in Spain and Portugal and belonging to the first (prehistoric) age of iron: (1) The Swastika was associated with the silhouettes of the duck, or bird, similar to those in Greece, noted by Goodyear; (2) the association (in his fig.

    41) on a slab from the lake dwellings, of the Maltese cross and reproduction of the triskelion; (3) a tetraskelion, which he calls a Swastika "flamboyant," being the triskelion, but with four arms, the same shown on Lycian coins as being ancestors of the true triskelion (his fig. 412); (4) those objects were principally found in the ancient lake dwellings of Sambroso and Briteiros, supposedly dating from the eighth and ninth centuries B. C.

    With them were found many ornaments, borders representing cords, spirals, meanders, etc., which had the same appearance as those found by Schliemann at Mycenæ.

    Cartailhac says:[104]

    Without doubt Asiatic influences are evident in both cases; first
    appearing in the Troad, then in Greece, they were spread through
    Iberia and, possibly, who can tell, finally planted in a far-away
    Occident.

    A writer in the Edinburgh Review, in an extended discussion on "The pre-Christian cross," treats of the Swastika under the local name of "Fylfot," but in such an enigmatical and uncertain manner that it is difficult to distinguish it from other and commoner forms of the cross.

    Mr. Waring[105] criticises him somewhat severely for his errors:

    He states that it is found * * * in the sculptured stones of Scotland
    (but after careful search we can find only one or two imperfect
    representations of it, putting aside the Newton stone inscription,
    where it is probably a letter or numeral only); that it is carved on
    the temples and other edifices of Mexico and Central America (where
    again we have sought for it in vain); that it is found on the cinerary
    urns of the terramare of Parma and Vicenza, the date of which has been
    assigned by Italian antiquaries to 1000 B.

    C. (but there again we have
    found only the plain cross, and not the fylfot), and, finally, he
    asserts that "it was the emblem of Libitina or Persephone, the awful
    Queen of the Shades, and is therefore commonly found on the dress of
    the tumulorum fossor in the Roman catacombs," but we have only found
    one such example. "It is noteworthy, too," he continues, "in reference
    to its extreme popularity, or the superstitious veneration in which it
    has been also universally held, that the cross pattée, or cruciform
    hammer (but we shall show these are different symbols), was among the
    very last of purely pagan symbols which was religiously preserved in
    Europe long after the establishment of Christianity (not in Europe,
    but in Scandinavia and wherever the Scandinavians had penetrated). * *
    * It may be seen upon the bells of many of our parish churches, as at
    Appleby, Mexborough, Haythersaye, Waddington, Bishop's Norton, West
    Barkwith, and other places, where it was placed as a magical sign to
    subdue the vicious spirit of the tempest;" and he subsequently points
    out its constant use in relation to water or rain.

    Mr. Waring continues:

    The Rev. C. Boutell, in "Notes and Queries," points out that it is to
    be found on many mediæval monuments and bells, and occurs--e. g., at
    Appleby in Lincolnshire (peopled by Northmen)--as an initial cross to
    the formula on the bell "Sta. Maria, o. p. n. and c." In these cases
    it has clearly been adopted as a Christian symbol. In the same
    author's "Heraldry," he merely describes it as a mystic cross.

    Mr. Waring makes one statement which, being within his jurisdiction, should be given full credit. He says, on page 15:

    It [the Swastika] appears in Scotland and England only in those parts
    where Scandinavians penetrated and settled, but is not once found in
    any works of purely Irish or Franco-Celtic art.

    He qualifies this, however, by a note:

    I believe it occurs twice on an "Ogam" stone in the Museum of the
    Royal Irish Academy, figured in Wilde's Catalogue (p. 136), but the
    fylfots are omitted in the wood cut. [See fig. 215.]

    Dr. Brinton,[106] describing the normal Swastika, "with four arms of equal length, the hook usually pointing from left to right," says: "In this form it occurs in India and on very early (Neolithic) Grecian, Italic, and Iberian remains." Dr. Brinton is the only author who, writing at length or in a critical manner, attributes the Swastika to the Neolithic period in Europe, and in this, more than likely, he is correct. Professor Virchow's opinion as to the antiquity of the hill of Hissarlik, wherein Dr.

    Schliemann found so many Swastikas, should be considered in this connection. (See p. 832, 833 of this paper.) Of course, its appearance among the aborigines of America, we can imagine, must have been within the Neolithic period.

    II.--DISPERSION OF THE SWASTIKA.

    EXTREME ORIENT.

    JAPAN.

    [Illustration: Fig. 29. BRONZE STATUE OF BUDDHA. Japan. Eight swastikas on pedestal. Cane tintinnabulum with six movable rings or bells.

    One-fifteenth natural size.]

    The Swastika was in use in Japan in ancient as well as modern times. Fig. 29 represents a bronze statue of Buddha, one-fifteenth natural size, from Japan, in the collection of M. Cernuschi, Paris. It has eight Swastikas on the pedestal, the ends all turned at right angles to the right. This specimen is shown by De Mortillet[107] because it relates to prehistoric man. The image or statue holds a cane in the form of a "tintinnabulum," with movable rings arranged to make a jingling noise, and De Mortillet inserted it in his volume to show the likeness of this work in Japan with a number of similar objects found in the Swiss lake dwellings in the prehistoric age of bronze (p. 806).

    The Swastika mark was employed by the Japanese on their porcelain. Sir Augustus W. Franks[108] shows one of these marks, a small Swastika turned to the left and inclosed in a circle (fig. 30). Fig. 9 also represents a mark on Japanese bronzes.[109]

    [Illustration: Fig. 30. JAPANESE POTTER'S MARK ON PORCELAIN. De Mortillet, "Musée Préhistorique," Fig. 1248.]

    KOREA.

    The U. S. National Museum has a ladies' sedan or carrying chair from Korea. It bears eight Swastika marks, cut by stencil in the brass-bound corners, two on each corner, one looking each way. The Swastika is normal, with arms crossing at right angles, the ends bent at right angles and to the right. It is quite plain; the lines are all straight, heavy, of equal thickness, and the angles all at 90 degrees. In appearance it resembles the Swastika in fig. 9.

    CHINA.

    In the Chinese language the sign of the Swastika is pronounced wan (p. 801), and stands for "many," "a great number," "ten thousand," "infinity," and by a synecdoche is construed to mean "long life, a multitude of blessings, great happiness," etc.; as is said in French, "mille pardons," "mille remercîments," a thousand thanks, etc. During a visit to the Chinese legation in the city of Washington, while this paper was in progress, the author met one of the attachés, Mr. Chung, dressed in his robes of state; his outer garment was of moiré silk.

    The pattern woven in the fabric consisted of a large circle with certain marks therein, prominent among which were two Swastikas, one turned to the right, the other to the left. The name given to the sign was as reported above, wan, and the signification was "longevity," "long life," "many years." Thus was shown that in far as well as near countries, in modern as well as ancient times, this sign stood for blessing, good wishes, and, by a slight extension, for good luck.

    The author conferred with the Chinese minister, Yang Yu, with the request that he should furnish any appropriate information concerning the Swastika in China. In due course the author received the following letter and accompanying notes with drawings:

    • * * I have the pleasure to submit abstracts from historical and

    literary works on the origin of the Swastika in China and the
    circumstances connected with it in Chinese ancient history. I have had
    this paper translated into English and illustrated by india-ink
    drawings. The Chinese copy is made by Mr. Ho Yen-Shing, the first
    secretary of the legation, translation by Mr. Chung, and drawings by
    Mr. Li.

    With assurance of my high esteem, I am,
    Very cordially,
    YANG YU.

    Buddhist philosophers consider simple characters as half or incomplete
    characters and compound characters as complete characters, while the
    Swastika [Z] is regarded as a natural formation. A Buddhist priest of
    the Tang Dynasty, Tao Shih by name, in a chapter of his work entitled
    Fa Yuen Chu Lin, on the original Buddha, describes him as having this
    [Z] mark on his breast and sitting on a high lily of innumerable
    petals. [Pl. 1.]

    Empress Wu (684-704 A. D.), of the Tang Dynasty, invented a number of
    new forms for characters already in existence, amongst which [Z
    circle] was the word for sun, [symbol] for moon, [circle] for star,
    and so on. These characters were once very extensively used in
    ornamental writing, and even now the word [Z circle] sun may be found
    in many of the famous stone inscriptions of that age, which have been
    preserved to us up to the present day. [Pl. 2.]

    The history of the Tang Dynasty (620-906 A. D.), by Lui Hsu and others
    of the Tsin Dynasty, records a decree issued by Emperor Tai Tsung
    (763-779 A. D.) forbidding the use of the Swastika on silk fabrics
    manufactured for any purpose. [Pl. 3.]

    Fung Tse, of the Tang Dynasty, records a practice among the people of
    Loh-yang to endeavor, on the 7th of the 7th month of each year, to
    obtain spiders to weave the Swastika on their web. Kung Ping-Chung, of
    the Sung Dynasty, says that the people of Loh-yang believe it to be
    good luck to find the Swastika woven by spiders over fruits or melons.
    [Pl. 4.]

    Sung Pai, of the Sung Dynasty, records an offering made to the Emperor
    by Li Yuen-su, a high official of the Tang Dynasty, of a buffalo with
    a Swastika on the forehead, in return for which offering he was given
    a horse by the Emperor. [Pl. 5.]

    The Ts'ing-I-Luh, by Tao Kuh, of the Sung Dynasty, records that an
    Empress in the time of the South Tang Dynasty had an incense burner
    the external decoration of which had the Swastika design on it. [Pl.
    6.]

    Chu I-Tsu, in his work entitled Ming Shih Tsung, says Wu Tsung-Chih, a
    learned man of Sin Shui, built a residence outside of the north gate
    of that town, which he named "Wan-Chai," from the Swastika decoration
    of the railings about the exterior of the house. [Pl. 7.]

    An anonymous work, entitled the Tung Hsi Yang K'ao, described a fruit
    called shan-tsao-tse (mountain or wild date), whose leaves resemble
    those of the plum. The seed resembles the lichee, and the fruit, which
    ripens in the ninth month of the year, suggests a resemblance to the
    Swastika. [Pl. 8.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 1. ORIGIN OF BUDDHA ACCORDING TO TAO SHIH, WITH SWASTIKA SIGN. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S. National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 2. SWASTIKA DECREED BY EMPRESS WU (684-704 A. D.) AS A SIGN FOR SUN IN CHINA. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S.

    National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 3. SWASTIKA DESIGN ON SILK FABRICS. This use of the Swastika was forbidden in China by Emperor Tai Tsung (763-779 A. D.). From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S. National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 4. SWASTIKA IN SPIDER WEB OVER FRUIT. (A good omen in China.) From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S. National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 5. BUFFALO WITH SWASTIKA ON FOREHEAD. Presented to Emperor of Sung Dynasty. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S.

    National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 6. INCENSE BURNER WITH SWASTIKA DECORATION. South Tang Dynasty. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S National Museum Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 7. HOUSE OF WU TSUNG-CHIH OF SIN SHUI, WITH SWASTIKA IN RAILING. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S. National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: PLATE 8. MOUNTAIN OR WILD DATE.--FRUIT RESEMBLING THE SWASTIKA. From a drawing by Mr. Li, presented to the U. S. National Museum by Mr. Yang Yü, Chinese Minister, Washington, D. C.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 31. POTTER'S MARK ON PORCELAIN. China. Tablet of honor, with Swastika. Prime, "Pottery and Porcelain," p. 254.]

    The Swastika is one of the symbolic marks of the Chinese porcelain.

    Prime[110] shows what he calls a "tablet of honor," which represents a Swastika inclosed in a lozenge with loops at the corners (fig. 31). This mark on a piece of porcelain signifies that it is an imperial gift.

    Major-General Gordon, controller of the Royal Arsenal at Woolwich, England, writes to Dr. Schliemann:[111] "The Swastika is Chinese. On the breech chasing of a large gun lying outside my office, captured in the Taku fort, you will find this same sign." But Dumoutier[112] says this sign is nothing else than the ancient Chinese character c h e, which, according to D'Alviella,[113] carries the idea of perfection or excellence, and signifies the renewal and perpetuity of life. And again,[111] "Dr. Lockyer, formerly medical missionary to China, says the sign [Z] is thoroughly Chinese."

    The Swastika is found on Chinese musical instruments. The U. S. National Museum possesses a Hu-Ch'in, a violin with four strings, the body of which is a section of bamboo about 3-1/2 inches in diameter. The septum of the joint has been cut away so as to leave a Swastika of normal form, the four arms of which are connected with the outer walls of the bamboo. Another, a Ti-Ch'in, a two-stringed violin, with a body of cocoanut, has a carving which is believed to have been a Swastika; but the central part has been broken out, so that the actual form is undetermined.

    Prof. George Frederick Wright, in an article entitled "Swastika,"[114] quotes Rev. F. H. Chalfont, missionary at Chanting, China, as saying: "Same symbol in Chinese characters 'ouan,' or 'wan,' and is a favorite ornament with the Chinese."

    TIBET.

    Mr. William Woodville Rockhill,[115] speaking of the fair at Kumbum, says:

    I found there a number of Lh'asa Tibetans (they call them Gopa here)
    selling pulo, beads of various colors, saffron, medicines, peacock
    feathers, incense sticks, etc. I had a talk with these traders,
    several of whom I had met here before in 1889. * * * One of them had a
    Swastika (yung-drung) tattooed on his hand, and I learned from this
    man that this is not an uncommon mode of ornamentation in his
    country.

    Count D'Alviella says that the Swastika is continued among the Buddhists of Tibet; that the women ornament their petticoats with it, and that it is also placed upon the breasts of their dead.[116]

    He also reports[117] a Buddhist statue at the Musée Guimet with Swastikas about the base. He does not state to what country it belongs, so the author has no means of determining if it is the same statue as is represented in fig. 29.

    INDIA.

    Burnouf[118] says approvingly of the Swastika:

    Christian archæologists believe this was the most ancient sign of the
    cross. * * * It was used among the Brahmins from all antiquity. (Voyez
    mot "Swastika" dans notre dictionnaire sanskrit.) Swastika, or Swasta,
    in India corresponds to "benediction" among Christians.

    [Illustration: Fig. 32. FOOTPRINT OF BUDDHA WITH SWASTIKA, FROM AMARAVATI TOPE. From a figure by Fergusson and Schliemann.]

    The same author, in his translation of the "Lotus de la Bonne Loi," one of the nine Dharmas or Canonical books of the Buddhists of the North, of 280 pages, adds an appendix of his own writing of 583 pages; and in one (No.

    1. devoted to an enumeration and description of the sixty-five figures

    traced on the footprint of Çakya (fig. 32) commences as follows:

    1. Svastikaya: This is the familiar mystic figure of many Indian

    sects, represented thus, [S], and whose name signifies, literally,
    "sign of benediction or of good augury." (Rgya tch'er rol pa, Vol. 11,
    p. 110.)

    • * * The sign of the Swastika was not less known to the Brahmins than

    to the Buddhists. "Ramayana," Vol. II, p. 348, ed. Gor., Chap. XCVII,
    st. 17, tells of vessels on the sea bearing this sign of fortune. This
    mark, of which the name and usage are certainly ancient, because it is
    found on the oldest Buddhist medals, may have been used as frequently
    among the Brahmins as among the Buddhists. Most of the inscriptions on
    the Buddhist caverns in western India are either preceded or followed
    by the holy (sacramentelle) sign of the Swastika. It appears less
    common on the Brahmin monuments.

    Mr. W. Crooke (Bengal Civil Service, director of Eth. Survey, Northwest Provinces and Oudh), says:[119]

    The mystical emblem of the Swastika, which appears to represent the
    sun in his journey through the heavens, is of constant occurrence. The
    trader paints it on the flyleaf of his ledger, he who has young
    children or animals liable to the evil eye makes a representation of
    it on the wall beside his doorpost. It holds first place among the
    lucky marks of the Jainas. It is drawn on the shaven heads of children
    on the marriage day in Gujarat. A red circle with Swastika in the
    center is depicted on the place where the family gods are kept
    (Campbell, Notes, p. 70).

    In the Meerut division the worshiper of the
    village god Bhumiya constructs a rude model of it in the shrine by
    fixing up two crossed straws with a daub of plaster. It often occurs
    in folklore. In the drama of the Toy Cart the thief hesitates whether
    he shall make a hole in the wall of Charudatta's house in the form of
    a Swastika or of a water jar (Manning, Ancient India, 11, 100).

    Village shrines.--The outside (of the shrines) is often covered with
    rude representations of the mystical Swastika.

    On page 250 he continues thus:

    Charms.--The bazar merchant writes the words "Ram Ram" over his
    door, or makes an image of Genesa, the god of luck, or draws the
    mystical Swastika. The jand tree is reverenced as sacred by Khattris
    and Brahmins to avoid the evil eye in children. The child is brought
    at 3 years of age before a jand tree; a bough is cut with a sickle and
    planted at the foot of the tree. A Swastika symbol is made before it
    with the rice flour and sugar brought as an offering to the tree.
    Threads of string, used by women to tie up their hair, are cut in
    lengths and some deposited on the Swastika.

    Mr. Virchand R. Gandhi, a Hindu and Jain disciple from Bombay, India, a delegate to the World's Parliament of Religions at Chicago in 1893, remained for some time in Washington, D. C., proselyting among the Christians. He is a cultivated gentleman, devoted to the spread of his religion. I asked his advice and assistance, which he kindly gave, supervising my manuscript for the Swastika in the extreme Orient, and furnishing me the following additional information relative to the Swastika in India, and especially among the Jains:

    The Swastika is misinterpreted by so-called Western expounders of our
    ancient Jain philosophy. The original idea was very high, but later on
    some persons thought the cross represented only the combination of the
    male and the female principles. While we are on the physical plane and
    our propensities on the material line, we think it necessary to unite
    these (sexual) principles for our spiritual growth. On the higher
    plane the soul is sexless, and those who wish to rise higher than the
    physical plane must eliminate the idea of sex.

    I explain the Jain Swastika by the following illustration [fig. 33]:
    The horizontal and vertical lines crossing each other at right angles
    form the Greek cross. They represent spirit and matter. We add four
    other lines by bending to the right each arm of the cross, then three
    circles and the crescent, and a circle within the crescent. The idea
    thus symbolized is that there are four grades of existence of souls in
    the material universe. The first is the lowest state--Archaic or
    protoplasmic life. The soul evolves from that state to the next--the
    earth with its plant and animal life.

    Then follows the third
    stage--the human; then the fourth stage--the celestial. The word
    "celestial" is here held to mean life in other worlds than our own.
    All these graduations are combinations of matter and soul on different
    scales. The spiritual plane is that in which the soul is entirely
    freed from the bonds of matter. In order to reach that plane, one must
    strive to possess the three jewels (represented by the three circles),
    right belief, right knowledge, right conduct. When a person has those,
    he will certainly go higher until he reaches the state of liberation,
    which is represented by the crescent.

    The crescent has the form of the
    rising moon and is always growing larger. The circle in the crescent
    represents the omniscient state of the soul when it has attained full
    consciousness, is liberated, and lives apart from matter.

    The interpretation, according to the Jain view of the cross, has
    nothing to do with the combination of the male and female principle.
    Worship of the male and female principles, ideas based upon sex,
    lowest even of the emotional plane, can never rise higher than the
    male and female.

    The Jains make the Swastika sign when we enter our temple of worship.
    This sign reminds us of the great principles represented by the three
    jewels and by which we are to reach the ultimate good. Those symbols
    intensify our thoughts and make them more permanent.

    [Illustration: Fig. 33. EXPLANATION OF THE JAIN SWASTIKA, ACCORDING TO GANDHI. (1) Archaic or protoplasmic life; (2) Plant and animal life; (3) Human life; (4) Celestial life.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 34_a_. THE FORMATION OF THE JAIN SWASTIKA--FIRST STAGE. Handful of rice or meal, in circular form, thinner in center.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 34_b_. THE FORMATION OF THE JAIN SWASTIKA--SECOND STAGE. Rice or meal, as shown in preceding figure, with finger marks, indicated at 1, 2, 3, 4.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 34_c_. THE FORMATION OF THE JAIN SWASTIKA--THIRD STAGE. Ends turned out, typifying animal, human, and celestial life, as shown in fig. 33.]

    Mr. Gandhi says the Jains make the sign of the Swastika as frequently and deftly as the Roman Catholics make the sign of the cross. It is not confined to the temple nor to the priests or monks. Whenever or wherever a benediction or blessing is given, the Swastika is used. Figs. 34 a, b, c form a series showing how it is made. A handful of rice, meal, flour, sugar, salt, or any similar substance, is spread over a circular space, say, 3 inches in diameter and one-eighth of an inch deep (fig. 34_a_), then commence at the outside of the circle (fig.

    34_b_), on its upper or farther left-hand corner, and draw the finger through the meal just to the left of the center, halfway or more to the opposite or near edge of the circle (1), then again to the right (2), then upward (3), finally to the left where it joins with the first mark (4). The ends are swept outward, the dots and crescent put in above, and the sign is complete (fig. 34_c_).

    The sign of the Swastika is reported in great numbers, by hundreds if not by thousands, in the inscriptions on the rock walls of the Buddhist caves in India. It is needless to copy them, but is enough to say that they are the same size as the letters forming the inscription; that they all have four arms and the ends turn at right angles, or nearly so, indifferently to the right or to the left. The following list of inscriptions, containing the Swastikas, is taken from the first book coming to hand--the "Report of Dr.

    James Burgess on the Buddhist Cave Temples and their Inscriptions, Being a Part of the Result of the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Seasons' Operations of the Archæological Survey of Western India, 1876, 1877, 1878, 1879:"[120]

    +--------------------------------------------------+
    | | |Inscription| Direction |
    | | Plate. | number. |in which ends|
    | | | | are bent. |
    |--------|---------------|-----------|-------------|
    | Bhaja | XLIV | 2 | To right. |
    | Kuda | XLVI | 26 | Do. |
    | Do | XLVI | 27 | To left. |
    | Kol | XLVI | 5 | To right. |
    | Karle | XLVII | 1 | Do. |
    | Do | XLVII | 3 | Do. |
    | Junnar | XLIX | 5 | Do. |
    | Do | XLIX | 6 | To left. |
    | Do | XLIX | 7 | To right. |
    | Do | XLIX | 8 | To left. |
    | Do | XLIX | 9 | To right. |
    | Do | XLIX | 10 | Do. |
    | Do | XLIX | 11 (?) | Do. |
    | Do | XLIX | 12 | Do. |
    | Do | XLIX | 13 (?) | Do. |
    | Do | XLIX | 13 (?) | To left. |
    | Do | XLIX | 14 | Do. |
    | Do | L | 17 | To right. |
    | Do | L | 19 | Do. |
    | Nasik | LII | 5 | Do. |
    | Do | LV (Nasik 21) | 5 (?) | Do. |
    | Do | LV (Nasik 24) | 8 (?) | Do. |
    +--------------------------------------------------+

    Chantre[121] says:

    I remind you that the (East) Indians, Chinese, and Japanese employ the
    Swastika, not only as a religious emblem but as a simple ornament in
    painting on pottery and elsewhere, the same as we employ the Greek
    fret, lozenges, and similar motifs in our ornamentation. Sistres
    [the staff with jingling bells, held in the hand of Buddha, on whose
    base is engraved a row of Swastikas, fig. 29 of present paper] of
    similar form and style have been found in prehistoric Swiss lake
    dwellings of the bronze age. Thus the sistres and the Swastika are
    brought into relation with each other.

    The sistres possibly relate
    to an ancient religion, as they did in the Orient; the Swastika may
    have had a similar distinction.

    De Mortillet and others hold the same opinion.[122]

    CLASSICAL ORIENT.

    BABYLONIA, ASSYRIA, CHALDEA, AND PERSIA.

    Waring[123] says, "In Babylonian and Assyrian remains we search for it [the Swastika] in vain." Max Müller and Count Goblet d'Alviella are of the same opinion.[124]

    Of Persia, D'Alviella (p. 51), citing Ludwig Müller,[125] says that the Swastika is manifested only by its presence on certain coins of the Arsacides and the Sassanides.

    PHENICIA.

    It is reported by various authors that the Swastika has never been found in Phenicia, e. g. Max Müller, J. B. Waring, Count Goblet d'Alviella.[126]

    Ohnefalsch-Richter[127] says that the Swastika is not found in Phenicia, yet he is of the opinion that their emigrant and commercial travelers brought it from the far east and introduced it into Cyprus, Carthage, and the north of Africa. (See p. 796.)

    LYCAONIA.

    Lempriere, in his Classical Dictionary, under the above title, gives the following:

    A district of Asia Minor forming the southwestern quarter of Phrygia.
    The origin of its name and inhabitants, the Lycaones, is lost in
    obscurity. * * * Our first acquaintance with this region is in the
    relation of the expedition of the younger Cyprus. Its limits varied at
    different times. At first it extended eastward from Iconium 23
    geographical miles, and was separated from Cilicia on the south by the
    range of Mount Taurus, comprehending a large portion of what in later
    times was termed Cataonia.

    Count Goblet d'Alviella,[128] quoting Perrot and Chipiez,[129] states that the Hittites introduced the Swastika on a bas-relief of Ibriz, Lycaonia, where it forms a border of the robe of a king or priest offering a sacrifice to a god.

    ARMENIA.

    [Illustration: Fig. 35. BRONZE PIN-HEAD FROM CHEITHAN-THAGH. De Morgan, "Au Caucase," fig. 177.]

    M. J. de Morgan (the present director of the Gizeh Museum at Cairo), under the direction of the French Government, made extensive excavations and studies into the prehistoric antiquities and archæology of Russian Armenia. His report is entitled "Le Premier Âge de Métaux dans l'Arménie Russe."[130] He excavated a number of prehistoric cemeteries, and found therein various forms of crosses engraved on ceintures, vases, and medallions. The Swastika, though present, was more rare. He found it on the heads of two large bronze pins (figs. 35 and 36) and on one piece of pottery (fig. 37) from the prehistoric tombs.

    The bent arms are all turned to the left, and would be the Suavastika of Prof. Max Müller.

    CAUCASUS.

    [Illustration: Fig. 36. BRONZE PIN-HEAD FROM AKTHALA. De Morgan, "Au Caucase," fig. 178.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 37. SWASTIKA MARK ON BLACK POTTERY. Cheithan-thagh. De Morgan, "Au Caucase," fig. 179.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 38. FRAGMENT OF BRONZE CEINTURE. Swastika repoussé.

    Necropolis of Koban, Caucasus. Chantre, "Le Caucase," pl. 11, fig. 3.]

    In Caucasus, M. E. Chantre[131] found the Swastika in great purity of form. Fig. 38 represents portions of a bronze plaque from that country, used on a ceinture or belt. Another of slightly different style, but with square cross and arms bent at right angles, is represented in his pl. 8, fig. 5. These belonged to the first age of iron, and much of the art was intricate.[132] It represented animals as well as all geometric forms, crosses, circles (concentric and otherwise), spirals, meanders, chevrons, herring bone, lozenges, etc.

    These were sometimes cast in the metal, at other times repoussé, and again were engraved, and occasionally these methods were employed together. Fig. 39 shows another form, frequently employed and suggested as a possible evolution of the Swastika, from the same locality and same plate. Fig. 40 represents signs reported by Waring[133] as from Asia Minor, which he credits, without explanation, to Ellis's "Antiquities of Heraldry."

    The specimen shown in fig. 41 is reported by Waring,[134] quoting Rzewusky,[135] as one of the several branding marks used on Circassian horses for identification.

    [Illustration: Fig. 39. BRONZE AGRAFE OR BELT PLATE. Triskelion in spiral.

    Koban, Caucasus. Chantre, "Le Caucase," pl. 11, fig. 4.]

    Mr. Frederick Remington, the celebrated artist and literateur, has an article, "Cracker Cowboy in Florida,"[136] wherein he discourses of the forgery of brands on cattle in that country. One of his genuine brands is a circle with a small cross in the center. The forgery consists in elongating each arm of the cross and turning it with a scroll, forming an ogee Swastika (fig. 13_d_), which, curiously enough, is practically the same brand used on Circassian horses (fig. 41).

    Max Ohnefalsch-Richter[137] says that instruments of copper (audumbaroasih) are recommended in the Atharva-Veda to make the Swastika, which represents the figure 8; and thus he attempts to account for the use of that mark branded on the cows in India (supra, p. 772), on the horses in Circassia (fig. 41), and said to have been used in Arabia.

    [Illustration: Fig. 40. SWASTIKA SIGNS FROM ASIA MINOR. Waring, "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages," pl. 41, figs. 5 and 6.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 41. BRAND FOR HORSES IN CIRCASSIA. Ogee Swastika, tetraskelion. Waring, "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages," pl. 42, fig. 20_c_.]

    ASIA MINOR--TROY (HISSARLIK).

    Many specimens of the Swastika were found by Dr. Schliemann in the ruins of Troy, principally on spindle whorls, vases, and bijoux of precious metal. Zmigrodzki[138] made from Dr. Schliemann's great atlas the following classification of the objects found at Troy, ornamented with the Swastika and its related forms:

    Fifty-five of pure form; 114 crosses with the four dots, points or alleged nail holes (Croix swasticale); 102 with three branches or arms (triskelion); 86 with five branches or arms; 63 with six branches or arms; total, 420.

    Zmigrodzki continues his classification by adding those which have relation to the Swastika thus: Eighty-two representing stars; 70 representing suns; 42 representing branches of trees or palms; 15 animals non-ferocious, deer, antelope, hare, swan, etc.; total, 209 objects. Many of these were spindle whorls.

    Dr. Schliemann, in his works, "Troja" and "Ilios," describes at length his excavations of these cities and his discoveries of the Swastika on many objects. His reports are grouped under titles of the various cities, first, second, third, etc., up to the seventh city, counting always from the bottom, the first being deepest and oldest. The same system will be here pursued.

    The first and second cities were 45 to 52 feet (13 to 16 meters) deep; the third, 23 to 33 feet (7 to 10 meters) deep; the fourth city, 13 to 17.6 feet (4 to 5-1/2 meters) deep; the fifth city, 7 to 13 feet (2 to 4 meters) deep; the sixth was the Lydian city of Troy, and the seventh city, the Greek Ilium, approached the surface.

    [Illustration: Fig. 42. FRAGMENT OF LUSTROUS BLACK POTTERY. Swastika, right. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 247.]

    First and Second Cities.--But few whorls were found in the first and second cities[139] and none of these bore the Swastika mark, while thousands were found in the third, fourth, and fifth cities, many of which bore the Swastika mark. Those of the first city, if unornamented, have a uniform lustrous black color and are the shape of a cone (fig. 55) or of two cones joined at the base (figs. 52 and 71). Both kinds were found at 33 feet and deeper. Others from the same city were ornamented by incised lines rubbed in with white chalk, in which case they were flat.[140] In the second city the whorls were smaller than in the first.

    They were all of a black color and their incised ornamentation was practically the same as those from the upper cities.[141]

    Zmigrodzki congratulated himself on having discovered among Schliemann's finds what he believed to be the oldest representation of the Swastika of which we had reliable knowledge. It was a fragment of a vase (fig. 42) of the lustrous black pottery peculiar to the whorls of the first and second cities. But Zmigrodzki was compelled to recede, which he did regretfully, when Schliemann, in a later edition, inserted the footnote (p. 350) saying, that while he had found this (with a companion piece) at a great depth in his excavations, and had attributed them to the first city, yet, on subsequent examination, he had become convinced that they belonged to the third city.

    The Swastika, turned both ways [S] and [Z], was frequent in the third, fourth, and fifth cities.

    The following specimens bearing the Swastika mark are chosen, out of the many specimens in Schliemann's great album, in order to make a fair representation of the various kinds, both of whorls and of Swastikas.

    They are arranged in the order of cities, the depth being indicated in feet.

    [Illustration: Fig. 43. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO SWASTIKAS AND TWO CROSSES.

    Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1858.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 44. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO SWASTIKAS. Depth, 23 feet.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1874.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 45. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO SWASTIKAS. Depth, 23 feet.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1919.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 46. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO SWASTIKAS. Depth, 28 feet.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1826.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 47. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE SWASTIKAS. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1851.]

    The Third, or Burnt, City (23 to 33 feet deep).--The spindle-whorl shown in fig. 43 contains two Swastikas and two crosses.[142] Of the one Swastika, two arms are bent to the right at right angles, while the other two are bent to the right in curves. The other Swastika has but two bends, one at right angles, the other curved, both to the right. The specimen shown in fig. 44 has two Swastikas, in one of which the four arms are bent at right angles to the left.

    The entire figure is traced in double lines, one heavy and one light, as though to represent edges or shadows. The second Swastika has its ends bent at an obtuse angle to the left, and at the extremities the lines taper to a point. The whorl shown in fig. 45 is nearly spherical, with two Swastikas in the upper part. The ends of the four arms in both are bent at right angles, one to the right, the other to the left. Fig.

    46 represents a spindle-whorl with two irregular Swastikas; but one arm is bent at right angles and all the arms and points are uncertain and of unequal lengths. The rest of the field is covered with indefinite and inexplicable marks, of which the only ones noteworthy are points or dots, seven in number. In fig. 47 the top is surrounded by a line of zigzag or dog-tooth ornaments. Within this field, on the upper part and equidistant from the central hole, are three Swastikas, the ends of all of which turn to the left, and but one at right angles.

    All three have one or more ends bent, not at any angle, but in a curve or hook, making an ogee. Fig. 48 shows a large whorl with two or three Swastikas on its upper surface in connection with several indefinite marks apparently without meaning. The dots are interspersed over the field, the Swastikas all bent to the right, but with uncertain lines and at indefinite angles.

    In one of them the main line forming the cross is curved toward the central hole; in another, the ends are both bent in the same direction--that is, pointing to the periphery of the whorl. Fig. 49 shows a sphere or globe (see figs. 75, 88) divided by longitudinal lines into four segments, which are again divided by an equatorial line. These segments contain marks or dots and circles, while one segment contains a normal Swastika turned to the left. This terra-cotta ball has figured in a peculiar degree in the symbolic representation of the Swastika. Greg says of it:[143]

    We see on one hemisphere the [Z] standing for Zeus (= Indra) the sky
    god, and on the other side a rude representation of a sacred (somma)
    tree; a very interesting and curious western perpetuation of the
    original idea and a strong indirect proof of the [Z] standing for the
    emblem of the sky god.

    [Illustration: Fig. 48. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH SWASTIKAS. Depth, 23 feet.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1982.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 49. SPHERE DIVIDED INTO EIGHT SEGMENTS, ONE OF WHICH CONTAINS A SWASTIKA. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1999.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 50. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH SWASTIKA. Schliemann, "Ilios," Fig. 1949.]

    Fig. 50 represents one of the biconical spindle-whorls with various decorations on the two sides, longitudinal lines interspersed with dots, arcs of concentric circles arranged in three parallels, etc. On one of these sides is a normal Swastika, the arms crossing at right angles, the ends bent at right angles to the left. The specimen shown in fig. 51 contains four perfect Swastikas and two inchoate and uncertain. Both of the latter have been damaged by breaking the surface.

    The four Swastikas all have their arms bent to the right; some are greater than at right angles, and one arm is curved. Several ends are tapered to a point. Fig. 52 shows a whorl of biconical form. It contains two Swastikas, the main arms of which are ogee forms, crossing each other at the center at nearly right angles, the ogee ends curving to the right. In fig.

    53 the entire field of the upper surface is filled with, or occupied by, a Greek cross, in the center of which is the central hole of the whorl, while on each of the four arms is represented a Swastika, the main arms all crossing at right angles, the ends all bent to the right at a slightly obtuse angle.

    Each of these bent ends tapers to a point, some with slight curves and a small flourish. (See figs. 33 and 34 for reference to this flourish.) The specimen shown in fig. 54 has a center field in its upper part, of which the decoration consists of incised parallel lines forming segments of circles, repeated in each one of the four quarters of the field. The center hole is surrounded by two concentric rings of incised lines. In one of these spaces is a single Swastika; its main arms crossing at right angles, two of its ends bent to the left at right angles, the other two in the same direction and curved.

    [Illustration: Fig. 51. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH SIX SWASTIKAS. Depth, 33 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1859.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 52. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO OGEE SWASTIKAS.

    Depth, 33 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1876.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 53. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FOUR SWASTIKAS. Depth, 33 feet.

    De Mortillet, "Musée Préhistorique," fig. 1240.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 54. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA. Depth, 33 feet.

    De Mortillet, "Musée Préhistorique," fig. 1241.]

    The Fourth City (13.2 to 17.6 feet deep).--Schliemann says:[144]

    We find among the successors of the burnt city the same triangular
    idols; the same primitive bronze battle-axes; the same terra-cotta
    vases, with or without tripod feet; the same double-handled goblets
    ([Greek: sepa amphikupella]); the same battle-axes of jade, porphyry,
    and diorite; the same rude stone hammers, and saddle querns of
    trachyte. * * * The number of rude stone hammers and polished stone
    axes are fully thrice as large as in the third city, while the masses
    of shells and cockles accumulated in the débris of the houses are so
    stupendous that they baffle all description.

    The pottery is coarser
    and of a ruder fabric than in the third city. * * * There were also
    found in the fourth city many needles of bone for female handiwork,
    boar tusks, spit rests of mica schist, whetstones of slate, porphyry,
    etc., of the usual form, hundreds of small silex saws, and some knives
    of obsidian. Stone whorls, which are so abundant at Mycenæ, are but
    rarely found here; all of those which occur are, according to Mr.
    Davis, of steatite.

    On the other hand, terra-cotta whorls, with or
    without incised ornamentation, are found by thousands; their forms
    hardly vary from those in the third (the burnt) city, and the same may
    be generally said of their incised ornamentation. * * * The same
    representation of specimens of whorls are given as in the third city,
    and the same observations apply.

    [Illustration: Fig. 55. CONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE OGEE SWASTIKAS.

    Depth 13-1/2 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1850.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 56. CONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FOUR SWASTIKAS OF VARIOUS KINDS. Depth 13-1/2 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1879.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 57. CONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH SWASTIKAS. Depth. 13-1/3 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1894.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 58. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA. Depth, 13-1/2 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1983.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 59. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE OGEE SWASTIKAS.

    Depth, 13-1/2 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1990.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 60. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH TWO SWASTIKAS. Depth, 16-1/2 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1863.]

    Fig. 55 shows a simple cone, the upper surface being flat and without other decoration than three Swastikas equidistant from the hole and from each other, all made by the two crossed ogee lines with ends curved to the right. This specimen is much like that of Fig. 71 (Madam Schliemann collection in the U. S. National Museum, Cat. No. 149704). Fig. 56 shows a remarkable spindle-whorl. Its marks greatly excited the interest of Dr.

    Schliemann, and he devoted much space to the discussion of these and similar characters. The whorl is in the form of a cone. It bears upon its conical surface four Swastikas, the ends of three of which bend to the right and one to the left. There are but two of these ends which bend at right angles. Most of them are at an obtuse angle, while the ends of two are curved. Some taper to a point and finish with a slight flourish. The other marks which so interested Dr.

    Schliemann were the chevron ornament (zigzag), drawn in parallel lines, which, he strongly argued, and fortified with many authorities, represented lightning. The second series of marks he called a "burning altar." This assertion he also fortified with authorities and with illustrations of a similar sign from different countries. (See fig.

    101.) The third series of marks represented an animal, name and character unknown, with a head or tusks with two large branching horns or ears, a straight back, a stiff but drooping tail, four legs, and two rows of the remarkable dots--seven in one, six in the other--placed over the back of the animal. (See figs. 99 and 100.) Fig.

    57 represents another cone-shaped whorl, the flat surface of which is engraved with one perfect Swastika, the two arms crossing each other at right angles and the two ends bending at right angles to the right; the other two are curved, also to the right. Two of the other figures Dr.

    Schliemann calls Swastikas, although they are uncertain in some of their arms and angles. The fourth character he imagined to be an inchoate or attempted Swastika. Fig. 58 shows a biconical whorl with curious and inexplicable characters. One of them forms a crude Swastika, which, while the main arms cross at right angles the ends are bent at uncertain angles, three to the left and one to the right. These characters are so undetermined that it is doubtful if they could have had any signification, either ornamental or otherwise. Fig.

    59 is almost conical, the flat surface thereof being only slightly raised at the center. It is much the same form as the whorls shown in figs. 55 and 71. The nearly flat surface is the top, and on it, equidistant from the center hole and from each other, are three ogee Swastikas of double lines, with their ends all curved to the right. In the alternate spaces are small incised circles, with dots in the centers. In fig. 60 a biconical whorl is shown.

    It has three of the circle segments marked in equilateral positions, with three or four parallel lines, after the style shown in Fig. 54. In the spaces are two Swastikas, in both of which the two main arms cross at right angles. Some of the ends bend at a right, and others at an obtuse, angle.

    In one of the Swastikas the bent ends turn toward each other, forming a rude figure 8. The specimen shown in fig. 61 is biconical, but much flattened; it contains five ogee Swastikas, of which the ends of four bend to the right and one to the left. In an interval between them is one of the burning altars. Fig. 62 shows three Swastikas with double parallel lines. The main arms cross each other at right angles; the ends are bent at nearly right angles, one to the left, one to the right, and the other both ways. Fig.

    63 represents a spindle-whorl with a cup-shaped depression around the central hole, which is surrounded by three lines in concentric circles, while on the field, at 90 degrees from each other, are four ogee Swastikas (tetraskelions), the arms all turning to the left and spirally each upon itself. The specimen shown in fig. 64 is biconical, though, as usual, the upper cone is the smallest.

    There are parallel lines, three in a set, forming the segments of three circles, in one space of which appears a Swastika of a curious and unique form, similar to that shown in fig. 60. The two main arms cross each other at very nearly right angles and the ends also bend at right angles toward and approaching each other, so that if continued slightly farther they would close and form a decorative figure 8. The specimen shown in fig.

    65 is decorated with parallel lines, three in number, arranged in segments of three circles, the periphery of which is toward the center, as in figs. 60 and 64. In one of the spaces is a Swastika of curious form; the main arms cross each other at right angles, but the four ends represent different styles--two are bent square to the left, one square to the right, and the fourth curves to the left at no angle. Fig. 66 shows a biconical whorl, and its top is decorated to represent three Swastikas and three burning altars.

    The ends of the arms of the Swastikas all bend to the left, some are at right angles and some at obtuse angles, while two or three are curved; two of them show corrections, the marks at the ends having been changed in one case at a different angle and in another from a straight line to a curve.

    Fig. 67 shows four specimens of Swastika, the main arms of all of which cross at right angles. The ends all bend to the right, at nearly right angles, tapering to a point and finishing with the slight flourish noted in the Jain Swastika (fig. 34_c_). They are alternated with a chevron decoration. Fig. 68 shows three Swastikas, the ends of the arms of which are all bent to the left. One Swastika is composed of two ogee lines.

    Two arms of another are curved, but all others are bent at right angles, some of them tapering to points, finishing with a little flourish (figs. 67 and 34_c_). One of these ends, like that in fig. 66, has been corrected by the maker. Fig. 69 represents one Swastika in which the main arms cross at nearly right angles. Both ends of one arm turn to the left and those of the other arm turn to the right in figure 8 style. One of the ends is curved, the others bent at different angles. Fig.

    70 shows the parallel lines representing segments of a circle similar to figs. 60, 64, 65, and 69, except that it has four instead of three. It has one Swastika; the main arms (of double lines) cross at right angles, the ends all curving to the left with a slight ogee.

    [Illustration: Fig. 61. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FIVE OGEE SWASTIKAS.

    Depth, 18 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1905.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 62. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE SWASTIKAS. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1855.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 63. SPINDLE-WHORL HAVING FOUR OGEE SWASTIKAS WITH SPIRAL VOLUTES. Depth, 18 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1868.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 64. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1865.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 65. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios", fig. 1866.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 66. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE SWASTIKAS AND THREE BURNING ALTARS. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios", fig. 1872.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 67. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FOUR SWASTIKAS.

    Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1873.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 68. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE SWASTIKAS OF DIFFERENT STYLES. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1911.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 69. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA OF THE FIGURE-8 STYLE. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1861.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 70. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA, SLIGHT OGEE. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1864.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 71. CONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH THREE OGEE SWASTIKAS.

    Depth, 13.5 feet. Gift of Madame Schliemann, Cat. No. 149704, U. S. N. M.]

    The U. S. National Museum was, during 1893, the fortunate recipient of a collection of objects from Madame Schliemann, which her husband, before his death, had signified should be given to the United States as a token of his remembrance of and regard for his adopted country. He never forgot that he was an American citizen, and, preparing for death, made his acknowledgments in the manner mentioned. The collection consisted of 178 objects, all from ancient Troy, and they made a fair representation of his general finds. This collection is in the Department of Prehistoric Anthropology. In this collection is a spindle-whorl, found at 13-1/2 feet (4 meters) depth and belonging to the fourth city.

    It had three Swastikas upon its face, and is here shown as fig. 71.[145]

    The Fifth City.--Schliemann says:[146]

    The rude stone hammers found in enormous quantities in the fourth city
    are no longer found in this stratum, nor did the stone axes, which are
    so very abundant there, occur again here. Instead of the hundreds of
    axes I gathered in the fourth city, I collected in all only two here.
    * * * The forms of the terra-cotta whorls, too, are in innumerable
    instances different here. These objects are of a much inferior fabric,
    and become elongated and pointed. Forms of whorls like Nos. 1801,
    1802, and 1803 [see figs. 72, 73, and 74], which were never found
    before, are here plentiful.

    The Sixth and Seventh Cities.--The sixth city is described in "Ilios," page 587, and the seventh on pages 608 and 618. Both cities contained occasional whorls of clay, all thoroughly baked, without incised or painted ornamentation, and shed no further light on the Swastika.

    [Illustration: Figs. 72, 73, 74. FORMS OF WHORLS FROM THE FIFTH BURIED CITY OF HISSARLIK, FOR COMPARISON. Schliemann, "Ilios," figs. 1801, 1802, 1803.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 75. TERRA-COTTA SPHERE WITH THIRTEEN SWASTIKAS. Third city. Depth, 26 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," figs. 245, 246.]

    Fig. 75 represents the opposite hemispheres of a terra-cotta ball, found at a depth of 26 feet, divided by incised lines into fifteen zones, of which two are ornamented with points and the middle zone, the largest of all, with thirteen specimens of [S] and [Z].

    Zmigrodzki says[147] that there were found by Schliemann, at Hissarlik, fifty-five specimens of the Swastika "pure and simple" (pp. 809, 826).

    It will be perceived by examination that the Swastika "pure and simple" comprised Swastikas of several forms; those in which the four arms of the cross were at other angles besides right angles; those in which the ends bent at square and other angles to the right; then those to the left (Burnouf and Max Müller's Suavastika); those in which the bends were, some to the right and some to the left, in the same design; where the points tapered off and turned outward with a flourish; where the arms bent at no angle, but were in spirals each upon itself, and turned, some to the right, some to the left.

    We shall see other related forms, as where the arms turn spirally upon each other instead of upon themselves. These will sometimes have three, five, six, or more arms, instead of four (p. 768).

    The cross and the circle will also appear in connection with the Swastika; and other designs, as zigzags (lightning), burning altars, men, animals, and similar representations will be found associated with the Swastika, and are only related to it by the association of similar objects from the same locality. A description of their patterns will include those already figured, together with Schliemann's comments as to signification and frequency.

    They become more important because these related forms will be found in distant countries and among distant peoples, notably among the prehistoric peoples of America. Possibly these designs have a signification, possibly not. Dr. Schliemann thought that in many cases they had. Professor Sayce supported him, strongly inclining toward an alphabetic or linguistic, perhaps ideographic, signification.

    No opinion is advanced by the author on these theories, but the designs are given in considerable numbers, to the end that the evidence may be fully reported, and future investigators, radical and conservative, imaginative and unimaginative, theorists and agnostics, may have a fair knowledge of this mysterious sign, and an opportunity to indulge their respective talents at length. Possibly these associated designs may throw some light upon the origin or history of the Swastika or of some of its related forms.

    [Illustration: Fig. 76. TERRA-COTTA DISK WITH ONE SWASTIKA. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1849.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 77. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH OGEE SWASTIKA. Third city.

    Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1822.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 78. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH IRREGULAR SWASTIKAS AND CROSSES. Fourth city. Depth, 13.6 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1871.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 79. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH UNCERTAIN AND MALFORMED SWASTIKAS. Third city. Depth, 33 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1870.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 80. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH IRREGULAR AND PARTLY FORMED SWASTIKAS HAVING LARGE DOT IN CENTER. Fourth city. Depth, 23 feet.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1875.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 81. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL, FLATTENED, WITH TWO SWASTIKAS AND INDEFINITE DECORATION. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1947.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 82. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH ONE SWASTIKA AND FOUR SEGMENTS OF CIRCLES. Third city. Depth, 33 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1989.]

    The specimen represented in fig. 76 is not a spindle-whorl, as shown by the number and location of the holes. It bears a good representation of a Swastika the form of which has been noticed several times. The two main arms cross each other at nearly right angles. The ends of the arms all bend to the right at a slightly obtuse angle and turn outward with a flourish somewhat after the style of the Jain Swastika (fig. 34_c_). Fig. 77 represents a spindle-whorl with a Swastika of the ogee style curved to the right. The center hole of the whorl forms the center of the sign. The figure is of double lines, and in the interspaces are four dots, similar to those in figs. 96-98, and others which Dr.

    Schliemann reports as common, and to which he attributes some special but unknown meaning.

    Swastikas and crosses of irregular shape and style are shown in the field of fig. 78. Two fairly well formed Swastikas appear, both of the ogee style, with the ends curved to the right. One is of the style resembling the figure 8 (see figs. 60 and 64). Two others are crudely and irregularly formed, and would scarcely be recognized as Swastikas except for their association. Fig. 79 represents uncertain and malformed Swastikas. The arms are bent in different directions in the same line. Two of the main arms are not bent.

    The inexplicable dots are present, and the field is more or less covered with unmeaning or, at least, unexplained marks. Fig. 80 also illustrates the indefinite and inchoate style of decoration. One unfinished Swastika appears which, unlike anything we have yet seen, has a circle with a dot in the center for the body of the Swastika at the crossing of the main arms. Fig. 81 shows two Swastikas, both crossing their main arms at right angles and the ends bending also at right angles--one to the right, the other to the left.

    This specimen is inserted here because of the numerous decorations of apparently unmeaning, or, at least, unexplained, lines. Fig. 82 shows four segmented circles with an indefinite Swastika in one of the spaces. The ends are not well turned, only one being well attached to the main arms. One of the ends is not joined, one overruns and forms a sort of cross; the other has no bend.

    Fig. 83 contains an unmistakable Swastika, the main arms of which cross at right angles, turning to the left with an ogee curve. The peculiarity of this specimen is that the center of the sign is inclosed in a circle, thus showing the indifference of the Swastika sign to other signs, whether cross or circle. The outer parts of the field are occupied with the parallel lines of the circle segment, as shown in many other specimens.

    The specimen shown in fig. 84 is similar in style to the last. The bodies of six Swastikas are formed by a circle and dot, while the arms of the cross start from the outside of the circle, extending themselves in curves, all of them to the right. (See fig. 13_d_.) It has no other ornamentation. The same remark is to be made about the indifferent use of the Swastika in association with cross or circle. We have seen many Swastikas composed of the crossed ogee lines or curves. Figs. 85 and 86 show the same ogee lines and curves not crossed; and thus, while it may be that neither of them are Swastikas, yet they show a relationship of form from which the derivation of a Swastika would be easy.

    [Illustration: Fig. 83. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL, FLATTENED. Ogee Swastika with central circle. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1987.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 84. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH SIX OGEE SWASTIKAS HAVING CENTRAL CIRCLE AND DOT. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1862.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 85. SPHERICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FLATTENED TOP AND OGEE LINES WHICH DO NOT FORM SWASTIKAS. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1890.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 86. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL WITH OGEE CURVES WHICH ARE NOT CROSSED TO FORM SWASTIKAS. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1889.]

    Attention has been called to decorations comprising segments of the circles incised in these whorls, the periphery of which is toward their centers (figs. 60, 64, 65, 69, 70, 82 and 83). Also to the mysterious dots (figs. 46, 56, 75, 76, 77, 79, 84, 92, 96 and 97). Fig. 87 shows a combination of the segments of three circles, the dots within each, and two Swastikas. Of the Swastikas, one is normal, turning to the right; the other turns to the right, but at an obtuse angle, with one end straight and the other irregularly curved. Fig.

    88 represents two sections of a terra-cotta sphere divided similar to fig. 49. Each of these sections contains a figure like unto a Swastika and which may be related to it. It is a circle with arms springing from the periphery, which arms turn all to the left, as they do in the ogee Swastika. One has seven, the other nine, arms. One has regular, the other irregular, lines and intervals. Fig.

    89 represents a spindle-whorl of terra cotta nearly spherical, with decoration of a large central dot and lines springing thereout, almost like the spokes of a wheel, then all turning to the left as volutes. In some countries this has been called the sun symbol, but there is nothing to indicate that it had any signification at Hissarlik. One of the marks resembles the long-backed, four-legged animal (figs. 99 and 100).[148] Figs.

    90, 91, 92, and 93 show a further adaptation of the ogee curve developed into a Swastika, in which many arms start from the center circle around the central hole in the whorl, finally taking a spiral form. The relation of this to a sun symbol is only mentioned and not specified or declared. The inexplicable and constantly recurring dots are seen in fig. 90.

    [Illustration: Fig. 87. SPHERICAL SPINDLE-WHORL, FLATTENED. Two Swastikas combined with segments and dots. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1988.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 88. SECTIONS OF TERRA-COTTA SPHERE.[149] Central circles with extended arms turning to the left, ogee and zigzag.

    Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1993.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 89. SPHERICAL SPINDLE-WHORL. Large central dot with twelve arms, similar in form to the ogee Swastika. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1946.]

    It is not contended that these are necessarily evolutions of the Swastika.

    We will see farther on many lines and forms of decoration by incised lines on these Trojan whorls, which may have had no relation to the Swastika, but are inserted here because persons rich in theories and brilliant in imagination have declared that they could see a resemblance, a relation, in this or some other decoration. As objects belonging to the same culture, from the same locality, and intimately associated with unmistakable Swastikas, they were part of the res gestæ, and as such entitled to admission as evidence in the case. The effect of their evidence is a legitimate subject for discussion and argument.

    To refuse these figures admission would be to decide the case against this contention without giving the opposing party an opportunity to see the evidence or to be heard in argument. Therefore the objects are inserted.

    [Illustration: Fig. 90. SPINDLE-WHORL. Central dot with ogee arms radiating therefrom in different directions, but in the form of a Swastika. Third City. Depth, 29 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1830.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 91. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH CENTRAL HOLE AND RADIATING ARMS. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1842.]

    Specimens of other crosses are presented because the Swastika is considered to be a form of the cross. There may have been no evolution or relationship between them; but no person is competent to decide from a mere inspection or by reason of dissimilarity that there was not. We have to plead ignoramus as to the growth and evolution of both cross and Swastika, because the origin of both is lost in antiquity. But all are fair subjects for discussion. There certainly is nothing improbable in the relationship and evolution between the Swastika and the cross. It may be almost assumed.

    [Illustration: Fig. 92. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH CENTRAL CIRCLE AND MANY ARMS.

    Fourth city. Depth, 19.8 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1837.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 93. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH CENTRAL HOLE, LARGE CIRCLE, AND MANY CURVED ARMS. Third city. Depth, 29 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1833.]

    Evidence leading to conviction may be found in associated contemporaneous specimens. M. Montelius, an archæologist of repute in the National Museum at Stockholm, discovered eight stages of culture in the bronze age of that country, which discovery was based solely upon the foregoing principle applied to the fibulæ found in prehistoric graves. In assorting his stock of fibulæ, he was enabled to lay out a series of eight styles, each different, but with many presentations. He arranged them seriatim, according to certain differences in size, style, elegance of workmanship, etc., No. 1 being the smallest, and No. 8 the largest and most elaborate.

    They were then classified according to locality and association, and he discovered that Nos. 1 and 2 belonged together, on the same body or in the same grave, and the same with Nos. 2 and 3, 3 and 4, and so on to No. 8, but that there was no general or indefinite intermixture; Nos. 1 and 3 or 2 and 4 were not found together and were not associated, and so on. Nos. 7 and 8 were associated, but not 6 and 8, nor 5 and 7, nor was there any association beyond adjoining numbers in the series.

    Thus Montelius was able to determine that each one or each two of the series formed a stage in the culture of these peoples. While the numbers of the series separated from each other, as 1, 5, 8, were never found associated, yet it was conclusively shown that they were related, were the same object, all served a similar purpose, and together formed an evolutionary series showing their common origin, derivative growth and continuous improvement in art, always by communication between their makers or owners.

    [Illustration: Fig. 94. LARGE BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL. Four crosses with bifurcated arms. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1855.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 95. SPINDLE-WHORL. Hole and large circle in center with broad arms of Greek cross. Third city. Depth, 26.4 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1820.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 96. SPINDLE-WHORL. Hole and large circle in center.

    Extended parallel arms with dots, forming a Greek Cross. Third city.

    Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1817.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 97. SPINDLE-WHORL. Greek cross. Tapering arms with dots. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1818.]

    Thus it may be with the other forms of crosses, and thus it appears to be with the circle and spiral Swastikas and those with ends bent in opposite and different directions. Just what their relations are and at which end of the series the evolution began, is not argued. This is left for the theorists and imaginists, protesting, however, that they must not run wild nor push their theories beyond bounds. Fig.

    94 represents four crosses, the main arms of which are at right angles, and each and all ends, instead of being turned at an angle which would make them Swastikas, are bifurcated and turn both ways, thus forming a foliated cross similar to the Maya cross, the "Tree of life." Figs. 95, 96, and 97 show Greek crosses. The centers of the crosses are occupied by the central hole of the whorl, while the arms extend to the periphery. In the centers of the respective arms are the ubiquitous dots.

    The question might here be asked whether these holes, which represented circles, stood for the sun symbol or solar disk. The question carries its own answer and is a refutation of those who fancy they can see mythology in everything. Fig. 98 is the same style of figure with the same dots, save that it has three instead of four arms. Figs. 99 and 100 each show four of the curious animals heretofore represented (fig. 56) in connection with the Swastika. They are here inserted for comparison. They are all of the same form, and one description will serve.

    Back straight, tail drooping, four legs, round head showing eye on one side, and long ears resembling those of a rabbit or hare, which, in fig. 56, are called horns. The general remarks in respect to the propriety of inserting crosses and burning altars (p. 824) apply with equal pertinency to these animals and to the unexplained dots seen on so many specimens. Fig. 101 shows both ends of a spindle-whorl, and is here inserted because it represents one of the "burning altars" of Dr. Schliemann, associated with a Swastika, as in figs.

    61, 66, and 68, and even those of figure-8 style (figs. 64 and 69).

    [Illustration: Fig. 98. SPINDLE-WHORL. Central hole and three arms with dots. Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1819.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 99. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL. Four animals are shown similar to those found associated with the Swastika. Third city. Depth, 33 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1877.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 100. BICONICAL SPINDLE-WHORL. Four animals are shown similar to those found associated with the Swastika. Fourth city. Depth, 19.6 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1867.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 101. SPINDLE-WHORL WITH FIGURE-8 SWASTIKA (?) AND SIX "BURNING ALTARS." Fourth city. Depth, 19.6 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 1838.]

    Dr. Schliemann found, during his excavations on the hill of Hissarlik, no less than 1,800 spindle-whorls. A few were from the first and second cities; they were of somewhat peculiar form (figs. 72 and 74), but the greatest number were from the third city, thence upward in decreasing numbers. The Swastika pure and simple was found on 55 specimens, while its related or suggested forms were on 420 (pp. 809, 819).

    Many of the other whorls were decorated with almost every imaginable form of dot, dash, circle, star, lozenge, zigzag, with many indefinite and undescribable forms. In presenting the claims of the Swastika as an intentional sign, with intentional, though perhaps different, meanings, it might be unsatisfactory to the student to omit descriptions of these associated decorative forms.

    This description is impossible in words; therefore the author has deemed it wiser to insert figures of these decorations as they appeared on the spindle-whorls found at Troy, and associated with those heretofore given with the Swastika.

    It is not decided, however, that these have any relation to the Swastika, or that they had any connection with its manufacture or existence, either by evolution or otherwise, but they are here inserted to the end that the student and reader may take due account of the association and make such comparison as will satisfy him. (Figs. 102 to 124.)

    [Illustration: Figs. 102-113. TROJAN SPINDLE-WHORLS. Schliemann, "Ilios."]

    [Illustration: Figs. 114-124. TROJAN SPINDLE-WHORLS. Schliemann, "Ilios."]

    Leaden idol of Hissarlik.--Dr. Schliemann, in his explorations on the hill of Hissarlik, at a depth of 23 feet, in the third, the burnt city, found a metal idol (fig. 125), which was determined on an analysis to be lead.[150] It was submitted to Professor Sayce who made the following report:[151]

    It is the Artemis Nana of Chaldea, who became the chief deity of
    Carchemish, the Hittite capital, and passed through Asia Minor to the
    shores and islands of the Ægean Sea. Characteristic figures of the
    goddess have been discovered at Mycenæ as well as in Cyprus.

    In "Troja" Professor Sayce says:

    Precisely the same figure, with ringlets on either side of the head,
    but with a different ornament (dots instead of Swastika) sculptured on
    a piece of serpentine was recently found in Mæonia, and published by
    M. Salmon Reinach in Revue Archæologique. By the side of the goddess
    stands the Babylonian Bel, and among the Babylonian symbols that
    surround them is the representation of one of the terra-cotta whorls,
    of which Dr. Schliemann found such multitudes at Troy.

    The chief interest to us of Dr. Schliemann's description of the idol lies in the last paragraph:[152]

    The vulva is represented by a large triangle, in the upper side of
    which we see three globular dots; we also see two lines of dots to the
    right and left of the vulva. The most curious ornament of the figure
    is a Swastika, which we see in the middle of the vulva. * * * So far
    as we know, the only figures to which the idol before us has any
    resemblance are the female figures of white marble found in tombs in
    Attica and in the Cyclades.

    Six of them, which are in the museum at
    Athens, * * * represent naked women. * * * The vulva is represented on
    the six figures by a large triangle. * * * Similar white Parian marble
    figures, found in the Cyclades, whereon the vulva is represented by a
    decorated triangle, are preserved in the British Museum. Lenorment, in
    "Les Antiquités de la Troade" (p.

    46), says: "The statuettes of the
    Cyclades, in the form of a naked woman, appear to be rude copies made
    by the natives, at the dawn of their civilization, from the images of
    the Asiatic goddess which had been brought by Phoenician merchants.
    They were found in the most ancient sepulchers of the Cyclades, in
    company with stone weapons, principally arrowheads of obsidian from
    Milo, and with polished pottery without paintings.

    We recognize in
    them the figures of the Asiatic Venus found in such large numbers from
    the banks of the Tigris to the island of Cyprus, through the whole
    extent of the Chaldeo-Assyrian, Aramæan, and Phoenician world. Their
    prototype is the Babylonian Zarpanit, or Zirbanit, so frequently
    represented on the cylinders and by terra-cotta idols, the fabrication
    of which begins in the most primitive time of Chaldea and continues
    among the Assyrians.

    [Illustration: Fig. 125. LEADEN IDOL OF ARTEMIS NANA OF CHALDEA, WITH SWASTIKA.[153] Third city. Depth, 23 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 126. 1-1/3 natural size.]

    It is to be remarked that this mark is not on the vulva, as declared by Schliemann, but rather on a triangle shield which covers the mons veneris.

    Professor Sayce is of the opinion, from the evidence of this leaden idol, that the Swastika was, among the Trojans, a symbol of the generative power of man.

    An added interest centers in these specimens from the fact that terra-cotta shields of similar triangular form, fitted to the curvature of the body, were worn in the same way in prehistoric times by the aboriginal women of Brazil. These pieces have small holes at the angles, apparently for suspension by cords. The U. S. National Museum has some of these, and they will be figured in the chapter relating to Brazil. The similarity between these distant objects is remarkable, whether they were related or not, and whether the knowledge or custom came over by migration or not.

    [Illustration: Fig. 126. TERRA-COTTA VASE WITH MAMELON. Fourth city.

    Depth, 16.5 feet. Cat. No. 149676, U. S. N. M. 1/3 natural size.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 127. TERRA-COTTA VASE WITH CIRCLE OR RING. Fourth city. Depth, 20 feet. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 988. 1/3 natural size.]

    Owl-shaped vases.--It is also remarkable to note in this connection the series of owl-shaped terra-cotta vases of the ruined cities of Hissarlik and their relation to the Swastika as a possible symbol of the generative power. These vases have rounded bottoms, wide bellies, high shoulders (the height of which is emphasized by the form and position of the handles), the mouth narrow and somewhat bottle-shaped, but not entirely so.

    What would be the neck is much larger than usual for a bottle, and more like the neck of a human figure, which the object in its entirety represents in a rude, but, nevertheless, definite, manner. At the top of the vase are the eyes, eyebrows, and the nose. It is true that the round eyes, the arched eyebrows, and the pointed nose give it somewhat an owlish face, but if we look at fig.

    127, the human appearance of which is emphasized by the cover of the vase, which serves as a cap for the head and has the effect of enlarging it to respectable dimensions, we will see how nearly it represents a human being. The U. S. National Museum possesses one of these vases in the Schliemann collection (fig. 126). It has the face as described, while the other human organs are only indicated by small knobs.

    It and the three figures, 127, 128, and 129, form a series of which the one in the Museum would be the first, the others following in the order named. No. 2 in the series has the female attributes indefinitely and rudely indicated, the lower organ being represented by a concentric ring.

    In No. 3 the mammæ are well shown, while the other organ has the concentric ring, the center of which is filled with a Greek cross with four dots, one in each angle, the Croix swasticale of Zmigrodzki (fig. 12). No. 4 of the series is more perfect as a human, for the mouth is represented by a circle, the mammæ are present, while in the other locality appears a well-defined Swastika. The first three of these were found in the fourth city at 20 to 22 feet depth, respectively; the last was found in the fifth city at a depth of 10 feet.

    The leaden idol (fig. 125), with its Swastika mark on the triangle covering the private parts, may properly be considered as part of the series. When to this series is added the folium vitus of Brazil (pl. 18), the similarity becomes significant, if not mysterious. But, with all this significance and mystery, it appears to the author that this sign, in its peculiar position, has an equal claim as a symbol of blessing, happiness, good fortune, as that it represents the generative power.

    [Illustration: Fig. 128. TERRA-COTTA VASE WITH CIRCLE OR RING AND CROIX SWASTICALE. Schliemann, "Ilios," fig. 986. 1/6 natural size.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 129. TERRA-COTTA VASE WITH CIRCLE OR RING INCLOSING SWASTIKA. Schliemann, "Troja," fig. 101. 2/5 natural size.]

    From the earliest time of which we have knowledge of the thoughts or desires of man we know that the raising up "heirs of his body" constituted his greatest blessing and happiness, and their failure his greatest misery.

    The first and greatest command of God to man, as set forth in the Holy Bible, is to "Be fruitful, and multiply, and replenish the earth."[154] This was repeated after the Deluge,[155] and when He pronounced the curse in the Garden, that upon the woman[156] was, "In sorrow thou shalt bring forth children." God's greatest blessing to Abraham, when He gave to him and his seed the land as far as he could see, was that his seed should be as the dust of the earth, "so that if a man can number the dust of the earth, then shall thy seed also be numbered."[157] "Tell the stars, if thou be able to number them * * * so shall thy seed be. * * * As the father of many nations," etc.

    We all know the story of Sarai, how, when she and Abraham had all riches and power on earth, it was as naught while they were childless, and how their greatest blessing was the Divine promise of an heir, and that their greatest happiness was over the birth of Isaac.

    This may be no proof of the symbolism of the Swastika, but it shows how, in high antiquity, man's happiness in his children was such as makes the Swastika mark, in the position indicated, equally a symbol of good fortune and blessing as it was when put on the spindle-whorls of Hissarlik, the vases of Greece, or the fibulæ of Etruria.

    The age of the Trojan cities.--It may be well to consider for a moment the age or epoch of these prehistoric Trojan cities on the hill of Hissarlik. Professor Virchow was appealed to by Schliemann for his opinion. He says:[158]

    Other scholars have been inclined to ascribe the oldest cities of
    Hissarlik to the Neolithic age, because remarkable weapons and
    utensils of polished stone are found in them. * * * This conception is
    unjustified and inadmissible. To the third century A. D. belongs the
    surface of the fortress hill of Hissarlik, which still lies above the
    Macedonian wall; and the oldest "cities"--although not only polished
    stones but also chipped flakes of chalcedony and obsidian occur in
    them--nevertheless fall within the age of metals, for even in the
    first city utensils of copper, gold, and even silver were dug up.

    No
    stone people, properly so called, dwelt upon the fortress hill of
    Hissarlik, so far as it has been uncovered.

    Virchow's opinion that none of the cities of Hissarlik were in the stone age may be correct, but the reason he gave is certainly doubtful. He says they come within the age of metals, for, or because, "utensils of copper, gold, and even silver were dug up among the ruins of the first city."

    That the metals, gold, silver, or copper, were used by the aborigines, is no evidence that they were in a metal age, as it has been assigned and understood by prehistoric archæologists. The great principle upon which the names of the respective prehistoric ages--stone, bronze, and iron--were given, was that these materials were used for cutting and similar implements. The use of gold and silver or any metal for ornamental purposes has never been considered by archæologists as synchronous with a metal age.

    Indeed, in the United States there are great numbers of aboriginal cutting implements of copper, of which the U. S. National Museum possesses a collection of five or six hundred; yet they were not in sufficient number to, and they did not, supersede the use of stone as the principal material for cutting implements, and so do not establish a copper age in America. In Paleolithic times bone was largely used as material for utensils and ornaments.

    Bone was habitually in use for one purpose or another, yet no one ever pretended that this establishes a bone age. In countries and localities where stone is scarce and shell abundant, cutting implements were, in prehistoric times, made of shell; and chisels or hatchets of shell, corresponding to the polished stone hatchet, were prevalent wherever the conditions were favorable, yet nobody ever called it an age of shell.

    So, in the ruined cities of Hissarlik, the first five of them abounded in stone implements peculiar to the Neolithic age, and while there may have been large numbers of implements and utensils of other materials, yet this did not change it from the polished stone age.

    In any event, the reason given by Virchow--i. e., that the use, undisputed, of copper, gold, and silver by the inhabitants of these cities--is not evidence to change their culture status from that denominated as the polished stone age or period.

    Professor Virchow subsequently does sufficient justice to the antiquity of Schliemann's discoveries and says[159] while "it is impossible to assign these strata to the stone age, yet they are indications of what is the oldest known settlement in Asia Minor of a people of prehistoric times of some advance in civilization," and[160] that "no place in Europe is known which could be put in direct connection with any one of the six lower cities of Hissarlik."

    Professor Sayce also gives his opinion on the age of these ruins:[161]

    The antiquities, therefore, unearthed by Dr. Schliemann at Troy,
    acquire for us a double interest. They carry us back to the later
    stone ages of the Aryan race.

    AFRICA.

    EGYPT.

    A consensus of the opinions of antiquarians is that the Swastika had no foothold among the Egyptians. Prof. Max Müller is of this opinion, as is also Count Goblet d'Alviella.[162]

    Waring[163] says:

    The only sign approaching the fylfot in Egyptian hieroglyphics that we
    have met is shown in fig. 3, pl. 41, where it forms one of the
    hieroglyphs of Isis, but is not very similar to our fylfot.

    Mr. Greg says:[164] "In Egypt the fylfot does not occur." Many other authors say the same. Yet many specimens of the Swastika have been found in Egypt (figs. 130 to 136). Professor Goodyear[165] says:

    The earliest dated Swastikas are of the third millenium B. C., and
    occur on the foreign Cyprian and Carian (?) pottery fragments of the
    time of the twelfth dynasty (in Egypt), discovered by Mr. Flinders
    Petrie in 1889. (Kahun, Gurob, and Hawara, pl. 27, Nos. 162 and 173.)

    [Illustration: Fig. 130. GREEK VASE SHOWING DEER, GEESE, AND SWASTIKAS.

    Naukratis, Ancient Egypt. Sixth and fifth centuries, B. C. Petrie, Third Memoir, Egypt Exploration Fund, part 1, pl. 4, fig. 3, and Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 60, fig. 2.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 130_a_. DETAIL OF VASE SHOWN IN THE PRECEDING FIGURE.]

    Naukratis.--Figs. 130 to 135, made after illustrations in Mr. W.

    Flinders Petrie's Third Memoir of the Egypt Exploration Fund (Pt. 1), found by him in Naukratis, all show unmistakable Swastikas. It should be explained that these are said to be Greek vases which have been imported into Egypt. So that, while found in Egypt and so classed geographically, they are not Egyptian, but Greek.

    Coptos (Achmim-Panopolis).--Within the past few years great discoveries have been made in Upper Egypt, in Sakkarah, Fayum, and Achmim, the last of which was the ancient city of Panopolis. The inhabitants of Coptos and the surrounding or neighboring cities were Christian Greeks, who migrated from their country during the first centuries of our era and settled in this land of Egypt. Strabo mentions these people and their ability as weavers and embroiderers. Discoveries have been made of their cemeteries, winding sheets, and grave clothes. These clothes have been subjected to analytic investigation, and it is the conclusion of M.

    Gerspach, the administrator of the national manufactory of the Gobelin tapestry, Paris,[166] that they were woven in the same way as the Gobelins, and that, except being smaller, they did not differ essentially from them. He adds:

    These Egyptian tapestries and those of the Gobelins are the result of
    work which is identical except in some secondary details, so that I
    have been able, without difficulty, to reproduce these Coptic
    tapestries in the Gobelin manufactory.

    [Illustration: Fig. 131. POTTERY FRAGMENTS WITH TWO MEANDER SWASTIKAS.

    Naukratis, Ancient Egypt. Petrie, Third Memoir of the Egyptian Exploration Fund, part 1, pl. 5, figs. 15, 24.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 132. FRAGMENT OF GREEK VASE WITH LION AND THREE MEANDER SWASTIKAS. Naukratis, Ancient Egypt. Petrie, Sixth Memoir of the Egypt Exploration Fund, part 2, fig. 7, and Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 30, fig. 2.]

    On one of these Coptic cloths, made of linen, reproduced in "Die Gräber- und Textilfunde von Achmim-Panopolis," by R. Forrer, occurs a normal Swastika embroidered or woven, tapestry fashion, with woolen thread (fig. 136). It belongs to the first epoch, which includes portions of the first and second centuries A. D. There were on these cloths an enormous amount of decoration, representing many figures, both natural and geometric. Among them was the Swastika variously applied and in different sizes, sometimes inserted in borders, and sometimes adorning the corners of the tunics and togas as a large medallion, as shown in the figure.[167]

    [Illustration: Fig. 133. FRAGMENT OF GREEK VASE DECORATED WITH FIGURES OF

    SACRED ANIMALS AND SWASTIKAS, ASSOCIATED WITH GREEK FRET. Naukratis,

    Ancient Egypt. Petrie, Sixth Memoir of the Egypt Exploration Fund, part 2, pl. 6, fig. 1.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 134. FRAGMENT OF GREEK VASE WITH FIGURES OF ANIMALS, TWO MEANDER SWASTIKAS, AND GREEK FRET. Naukratis, Ancient Egypt. Petrie, Sixth Memoir of the Egypt Exploration Fund, part 2, pl. 8, fig. 1, and Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 30, fig. 10.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 135. GREEK VASE WITH DEER, AND MEANDER AND FIGURE-8 SWASTIKAS. Naukratis, Ancient Egypt. Petrie, Sixth Memoir of the Egypt Exploration Fund, part 2, pl. 5, fig. 1.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 136. GREEK TAPESTRY. Coptos, Egypt. First and second centuries, A. D. Forrer, "Die Gräber- und Textilfunde von Achmin-Panopolis."]

    ALGERIA.

    [Illustration: Fig. 137. TORUS OF COLUMN WITH SWASTIKAS. Roman ruins, Algeria. Waring, "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages," pl. 43, fig. 2, quoting from Delamare.]

    Waring, in his "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages," discoursing upon the Swastika, which he calls fylfot, shows in pl. 43, fig. 2 (quoting from Delamare), the base of a column from a ruined Roman building in Algeria (fig. 137), on the torus of which are engraved two Swastikas, the arms crossing at right angles, all ends bent at right angles to the left. There are other figures (five and six on the same plate) of Swastikas from a Roman mosaic pavement in Algeria. Instead of being square, however, or at right angles, as might ordinarily be expected from mosaic, they are ogee.

    In one of the specimens the ogee ends finish in a point; in the other they finish in a spiral volute turning upon itself. The Swastika has been found on a tombstone in Algeria.[168]

    ASHANTEE.

    [Illustration: Fig. 138. BRONZE INGOTS BEARING SWASTIKAS. Coomassee, Ashantee.]

    Mr. R. B. Æneas McLeod, of Invergordon Castle, Ross-shire, Scotland, reported[169] that, on looking over some curious bronze ingots captured at Coomassee in 1874, during the late Ashantee war, by Captain Eden, in whose possession they were at Inverness, he had found some marked with the Swastika sign (fig. 138). These specimens were claimed to be aboriginal, but whether the marks were cast or stamped in the ingot is not stated.

    CLASSICAL OCCIDENT--MEDITERRANEAN.

    GREECE AND THE ISLANDS OF CYPRUS, RHODES, MELOS, AND THERA.

    The Swastika has been discovered in Greece and in the islands of the Archipelago on objects of bronze and gold, but the principal vehicle was pottery; and of these the greatest number were the painted vases. It is remarkable that the vases on which the Swastika appears in the largest proportion should be the oldest, those belonging to the Archaic period.

    Those already shown as having been found at Naukratis, in Egypt, are assigned by Mr. Flinders Petrie to the sixth and fifth centuries B. C., and their presence is accounted for by migrations from Greece.

    [Illustration: Fig. 139. VARIATION OF THE GREEK FRET. Continuous lines crossing each other at right angles forming figures resembling the Swastikas.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 140. GREEK GEOMETRIC VASE IN THE LEYDEN MUSEUM, WITH FIGURES OF GEESE AND SWASTIKA IN PANEL.[170] Smyrna. Conze, "Anfänge," etc., Vienna, 1870, and Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 56, fig. 4.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 141. GREEK VASE WITH FIGURES OF HORSES, GEOMETRIC ORNAMENTS AND SWASTIKAS IN PANELS. Athens. Dennis, "Etruria," 1, p. cxiii.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 142. GREEK VASE WITH SWASTIKAS IN PANELS. Conze, "Anfänge," etc., and Goodyear, "Grammar of the Lotus," pl. 60, fig. 13.]

    The Greek fret and Egyptian meander not the same as the Swastika.--Professor Goodyear says:[171] "There is no proposition in archæology which can be so easily demonstrated as the assertion that the Swastika is originally a fragment of the Egyptian meander, provided Greek geometric vases are called in evidence."

    Egyptian meander here means the Greek fret. Despite the ease with which he says it can be demonstrated that the Swastika was originally a fragment of the Egyptian meander, and with all respect for the opinion of so profound a student of classic ornament, doubts must arise as to the existence of the evidence necessary to prove his proposition.

    [Illustration: Fig. 143. DETAIL OF ARCHAIC GREEK VASE WITH FIGURE OF SOLAR GOOSE AND SWASTIKAS IN PANELS. British Museum. Waring, "Ceramic Art in Remote Ages," pl. 41, fig. 15.]

    [Illustration: Fig. 144. CYPRIAN POTTERY PLAQUE WITH SWASTIKA IN PANEL.

    Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York City. Cesnola, "Cyprus, its Ancient Cities,

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration
    Author
    Thomas Wilson
    Release date
    September 21, 2012 [eBook #40812]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Marilynda Fraser-Cunliffe and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team
    Most recently updated
    October 23, 2024
    Transcriber and production notes
    Transcriber's note:
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
          Text enclosed by underscores is in italics (_italics_).
    
          Text enclosed by curly braces is in superscript
          (example: 7{me}).
    
          The original text contains a few letters with diacritical
          marks that are not represented in this text version.
    
          The original text includes Greek characters. For this
          text version these letters have been replaced with
          transliterations.
    
          The following symbols are used in this text version to
          represent symbols that can not be presented in any other
          way.
    
            [S] represents a Swastika with left-bar facing up.
            [Z] represents a Swastika with left-bar facing down.
            [Z circle] represents a Swastika inside a circle.
            [cross] represents a simple cross (plus-sign form).
            [circle] represents a circle.
            [U] represents a large U.
            [V] represents a large V.
            [Y] represents a large Y.
            [symbol] represents various symbols.
    
          In the Bibliography section the reader will encounter
          numerous vertical bars or "pipes" ( | ).  These were
          present in the original book. The reason for their
          presence is uncertain.
    
          Mismatched/unmatched quotation marks are as in the
          original.
    
    
    
    
    
    Smithsonian Institution.
    United States National Museum.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Swastika, the Earliest Known Symbol, and Its Migration
    
    Author: Thomas Wilson
    
    
            
    Release date: September 21, 2012 [eBook #40812]
                    Most recently updated: October 23, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/40812
    
    Credits: Marilynda Fraser-Cunliffe and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #40812. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 40812
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-22
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.