Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 40058

The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2

by Sir Edward Tyas Cook · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2012
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2 by Sir Edward Tyas Cook is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #40058). NEW YORK · BOSTON · CHICAGO · DALLAS · SAN FRANCISCO

    NEW YORK · BOSTON · CHICAGO · DALLAS · SAN FRANCISCO

    THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, LTD.
    TORONTO

    • * * * *

    [Illustration: Florence Nightingale
    1887
    from the picture by Sir William Richmond at Claydon
    ]

    • * * * *

    THE LIFE

    OF

    FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE

    BY

    SIR EDWARD COOK

    IN TWO VOLUMES

    VOL. II

    (1862-1910)

    MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED

    ST. MARTIN'S STREET, LONDON

    1913

    COPYRIGHT

    • * * * *

    CONTENTS

    PART V

    FOR THE HEALTH OF THE ARMY IN INDIA

    (1862-1865)

    CHAPTER I

    PRELIMINARY. THE LOSS OF FRIENDS

    (AUGUST-DECEMBER 1861)

    PAGE

    Despondency after the death of Sidney Herbert--Sir George Lewis and
    the War Office--Lord de Grey reappointed under-secretary. II.
    "Saving things from the wreck"--The Herbert Hospital at Woolwich--
    Captain Galton at the War Office--Barracks inquiry extended to the
    Mediterranean--Miss Nightingale and the Volunteers. III. The
    American Civil War--Miss Nightingale and the nursing--British
    reinforcements to Canada--Miss Nightingale "working as in the times
    of Sidney Herbert." IV. Miss Nightingale and Arthur Hugh Clough--
    His assistance to her--His death (Nov.

    1861)--Her grief--Letters of
    condolence--Her yearning for sympathy--Illness 3

    CHAPTER II

    THE PROVIDENCE OF THE INDIAN ARMY

    (1862, 1863)

    High rate of mortality among the British army in India: Miss
    Nightingale as a "saviour" of the army. Her determination to obtain
    a Royal Commission for India on the lines of the Commission of 1857
    for the home army--Lord Stanley approves the idea: Sidney Herbert,
    chairman, succeeded by Lord Stanley--Selection of Commissioners.
    II. Miss Nightingale's work for the Commission (1859-1862)--
    Collection of evidence from India: her circular of inquiry--
    Preparation of statistical evidence at home: Miss Nightingale and
    Dr. Farr--Miss Nightingale and the witnesses. III.

    Her analysis of
    the written reports from India: "Observations by Miss Nightingale"
    thereon (1862)--Circulation of the "Observations"--Account of them
    --Abstract of the evidence by Miss Nightingale and Dr. Sutherland.
    IV. Death of Sir George Lewis--Her desire to see Lord de Grey
    appointed to the War Office--Press notices: letter to Lord
    Palmerston. V. Preparation of the Report of the Commission--Miss
    Nightingale's part in it--The recommendations--Her suggested
    machinery: (1) sanitary commissions in India, (2) supervision in
    England--Adoption of her policy--The Report signed (May 1863).
    VI.

    Miss Nightingale's "publicity campaign"--Distribution of early
    copies--Press notices--Omission of her "Observations" and Indian
    evidence from the cheaper official issue of the Report--Separate
    publication by her--Re-issue of the Report with her "Observations":
    circulation of the re-issue by the War Office. VII. Physical
    disabilities under which Miss Nightingale worked 18

    CHAPTER III

    SETTING REFORMERS TO WORK

    (1863-1865)

    "Reports not self-executive": Miss Nightingale's determination to
    put the Indian Report into execution. Correspondence with Lord
    Stanley--His interview with Sir Charles Wood--Miss Nightingale
    asked to draft "Suggestions" to be sent out to India--Departmental
    criticism of the Report: delay. II. Death of Lord Elgin, the
    Viceroy--Question of his successor--Miss Nightingale's admiration
    for Sir John Lawrence--His appointment--Her interview with him.
    III.

    Sir John Lawrence announces the appointment of sanitary
    commissions in India and begs her to expedite the dispatch of the
    "Suggestions."--More departmental delay--Miss Nightingale's
    impatience--Lord Stanley's intervention--The "Suggestions" approved
    and printed--Delay in sending them: circumvented by Miss
    Nightingale. IV.

    Sir John Lawrence's prompt action in India--
    Correspondence with Miss Nightingale--Reforms by Sir Hugh Rose
    (Lord Strathnairn)--Miss Nightingale's paper, How People may Live
    and not Die in India
    --Criticism of the Royal Commission's Report
    from India--Miss Nightingale's reply--Progress of sanitary reform
    in the army in India. V. Miss Nightingale as consultant and
    inspirer in Indian sanitary reform--Sir John Lawrence's
    difficulties--Lord Stanley's tribute to her--Importance of the
    co-operation between her and Sir John Lawrence 40

    CHAPTER IV

    ADVISORY COUNCIL TO THE WAR OFFICE

    (1862-1866)

    Miss Nightingale and the War Office: her position as consultant.
    Explanation of the position--Her expert authority on certain
    questions--Official legatee of Sidney Herbert--Correspondence with
    Sir George Lewis--Her friends at the War Office. II. Death of the
    permanent under-secretary--Miss Nightingale and Captain Galton's
    appointment--Her hopes of re-organization in the War Office.
    III. The Army Sanitary Commission--Miss Nightingale and
    improvements in barracks--Nursing in military hospitals. IV.

    The
    Army Medical School, and position of army doctors--Miss Nightingale
    as the doctors' champion--Lord Panmure's attack on the Herbert
    Hospital--Miss Nightingale's case for the defence. V. Wide range of
    subjects referred to her advice--The Geneva Convention (1864)--
    Suggestions about soldiers' and sailors' pay--Miss Nightingale's
    methods. VI. The State regulation of vice--Miss Nightingale's
    efforts on behalf of soldiers' clubs, recreation-rooms, etc. VII.
    Her researches into the disappearance of aboriginal races. VIII.
    Spiritual comfort--Memories of heroism in the Crimea 59

    CHAPTER V

    HELPERS, VISITORS, AND FRIENDS

    (1862-1866)

    The years of Miss Nightingale's most trying work. Her helpers--The
    indispensable Dr. Sutherland--His constant service--Miss
    Nightingale as task-mistress--Her method of "conversation" by
    written notes. II. Seclusion from her friends--Her strict rule of
    life--Letters to Madame Mohl--Visit from Garibaldi (1864)--Her
    account of the interview--Appreciation of Abraham Lincoln--Death of
    Lord Palmerston. III. Miss Nightingale's scheme for investments by
    the working-classes in small freeholds--Correspondence with
    Mr. Villiers and Mr. Gladstone. IV. Sympathetic letters to friends
    --Literary correspondence with M. Mohl. V.

    Friendship with
    Mr. Jowett--Their correspondence--Miss Nightingale's work for the
    army and for India an accidental "call"--Her yearnings for hospital
    work 84

    CHAPTER VI

    NEW MASTERS

    (1866)

    Public events in 1866 in relation to Miss Nightingale's work.
    Letters on those events. II. The story of a lost dispatch. Sir John
    Lawrence's scheme for sanitary organization in India--Miss
    Nightingale's anxiety to have it revised before the Liberal
    Government fell--The Dispatch lost at the India Office: found by
    Lord Ripon--His reply to it drafted, when the government fell.
    III. Miss Nightingale's vexation--Dr. Sutherland's absence--Visit
    from Lord Napier on his appointment to the governorship of Madras.
    IV.

    The Conservative Government--Miss Nightingale's desire to come
    in touch with the new ministers--Correspondence with Lord Cranborne
    (India Office) and Mr. Gathorne Hardy (Poor Law Board). V. The
    Austro-Prussian War--Miss Nightingale and war-nursing--
    Correspondence with the Princess Alice and the Crown Princess of
    Prussia. VI. A holiday at Embley with her mother--Private
    meditations 104

    PART VI

    MANY THREADS (1867-1872)

    CHAPTER I

    WORKHOUSE REFORM

    (1864-1867)

    State of the workhouse infirmaries--Report on the Metropolitan
    workhouses in 1866--Miss Nightingale a prime mover in the remedial
    legislation of 1867. II. Her friendship with Mr. William
    Rathbone--His scheme for introducing trained nurses into the
    Workhouse Infirmary at Liverpool--Negotiations with Miss
    Nightingale--Her friend, Miss Agnes Jones, appointed Lady
    Superintendent--Reforms effected by her (1865). III. Miss
    Nightingale's resolve to use the Liverpool experiment as a lever for
    reform in London--Workhouse scandals in London--Correspondence and
    interviews with Mr. Villiers--Friendship with Mr.

    Farnall, Poor Law
    Inspector--Miss Nightingale's scheme of Poor Law reform
    (1865)--Approved by Mr. Villiers--Articles in the Times--Defeat of
    the Government. IV. Mr. Gathorne Hardy succeeds Mr. Villiers--Removal
    of Mr. Farnall from London--Miss Nightingale's communications with
    Mr. Villiers--Committee appointed by Mr. Hardy--Miss Nightingale
    invited to express her views: outlines her scheme in a Memorandum.
    V. Mr. Hardy's Bill (1867)--Various views of it--Miss Nightingale's
    efforts for its extension--Importance of the reforms included in
    the Bill: the starting-point of workhouse reform. VI.

    Success of
    Miss Agnes Jones's pioneer work--Her death (1868)--Miss
    Nightingale's account of her in Good Words--Selection of a
    successor--Effect of the article 123

    CHAPTER II

    ALLIANCE WITH SIR BARTLE FRERE

    (1867-1868)

    Miss Nightingale's concern for a better organization of the public
    health service in India. Approaching retirement of Sir John
    Lawrence: her anxiety to insert "the main-spring"--Points for which
    she contended. II. Lord Cranborne succeeded at the India Office by
    Sir Stafford Northcote--Miss Nightingale's friendship with
    Sir Bartle Frere--She determines to advance--The "Doors versus
    Windows" controversy. III. Her communications with Sir S. Northcote
    --Interviews with him--Her scheme of organization adopted--Dispatch
    and other sanitary papers drafted by her. IV.

    Attitude of the
    Government of India--Letters from Sir John Lawrence--Abandonment of
    a female nursing scheme--Miss Nightingale's vexation. V. Continued
    correspondence with Sir John Lawrence--His return to England--Visit
    to Miss Nightingale 144

    CHAPTER III

    PUBLIC HEALTH MISSIONARY FOR INDIA

    (1868-1872)

    Miss Nightingale's "little Indian Department all to herself," a
    main pre-occupation. Rest-cure at Malvern (Dec. 1867)--Visit to her
    mother at Lea Hurst (July-Oct. 1868)--Miss Nightingale's movements
    in following years. II. Mr. Jowett's plea for less official
    drudgery, and more literary work--Her "Note on Pauperism" in
    Fraser's Magazine--Interest in colonization--Interview with
    Mr. Goschen. III. Health work for India: (1) correspondence and
    interviews with Indian officials--Interviews with Lord Mayo--
    Correspondence with Lord Napier (Madras)--"Special cholera
    inquiry." IV.

    An episode: Miss Nightingale's intervention to save
    the Army Sanitary Commission and the Army Medical School from being
    retrenched out of existence--Statistical evidence of sanitary
    reform. V. Interviews with Lord Napier of Magdala--Further
    correspondence with Lord Mayo--Other interviews and correspondence.
    VI. Health work for India: (2) acquaintance and correspondence
    with native Indian gentlemen--Sanitary appeal to village elders.
    VII. Health work for India: (3) work in connection with the Sanitary
    Department at the India Office--Contributions to and revision of
    the Indian Health Annual. VIII.

    Ten years' progress: How some
    People have Lived, not Died, in India
    --How much, and yet how
    little! 161

    CHAPTER IV

    ADVISER-GENERAL ON HOSPITALS AND NURSING

    (1868-1872)

    Miss Nightingale as a central department relating to hospitals and
    nurses. Criticism of hospital plans--"Suggestions" for nursing
    organization in public institutions. II. Visits on such subjects
    from great personages--Interviews and correspondence with the Crown
    Princess of Prussia. III. Supervision of the Nightingale Training
    School--Personal influence--Miss Nightingale's reception of lady
    superintendents and nurses going out from the School to other
    posts. IV. Closing of the Midwifery School at King's College
    Hospital--Miss Nightingale's Notes on Lying-in Institutions.
    V.

    The Franco-German War--Miss Nightingale and the "National
    Society for Aid to the Sick and Wounded"--Communications with the
    Crown Princess of Germany--Red Cross Societies. VI. Miss
    Nightingale's continued ill-health--Dr. Sutherland's constant help 185

    PART VII

    WORK OF LATER YEARS (1872-1910)

    CHAPTER I

    "OUT OF OFFICE." LITERARY WORK

    (1872-1874)

    Miss Nightingale's thought of entering St. Thomas's Hospital (1872)
    --Dissuaded by Mr. Jowett--"This year I go out of office"--Meaning
    of her statement--Her connection with the War Office closed--Lord
    Northbrook did not come to her. II. Unsettlement and depression--
    Mr. Jowett's plea for literary work--Mr. Mill's plea that she
    should speak out recalled. III. Articles in Fraser's Magazine
    (1873): embodying some of her Suggestions for Thought--Froude's
    and Carlyle's opinions of the articles--Miss Nightingale and her
    critics. IV. Death of Mr. Mill--Appreciation of him by Miss
    Nightingale.

    V. Theological essays written at Mr. Jowett's
    suggestion--Discussions with him--Contributions to the revised
    edition of his Plato--Suggestions for his sermons--Collaboration
    in The Children's Bible--Remarks on such literary work 211

    CHAPTER II

    THE MYSTICAL WAY

    Miss Nightingale's fondness for Catholic books of devotion--Idea of
    making a selection--Mr. Jowett's views of mysticism. II. Miss
    Nightingale's Preface to her Notes from Devotional Authors of the
    Middle Ages
    . III. Interruption of work by the death of her father
    (1874)--His character--Death of Mrs. Bracebridge: Miss
    Nightingale's tributes to her and her husband--Family worries.
    IV. Her book on the Mystics never finished--Her own mystical life
    --Her private meditations--The path to perfection 231

    CHAPTER III

    MISS NIGHTINGALE'S SCHOOL

    (1872-1879)

    Miss Nightingale's increased attention to the Nightingale Training
    School. Opening of the new buildings of St. Thomas's Hospital--
    Appointment of a new Medical Instructor of the Probationers, and of
    a "Home Sister." II. Miss Nightingale's interviews with the
    probationers--Her character-sketches and other records--Her sense
    of humour. III.

    District nursing in London--Miss Florence Lees--
    Selections and promotions--Some favourite pupils--Wide influence of
    the Nightingale nurses--Miss Nightingale's close relations with her
    old pupils in their new posts--Her affectionate solicitude for them
    --Typical letters--Extent of her correspondence. IV. Her "Addresses
    to Probationers"--Leading ideas in them--Style of address,
    reminiscent of school sermons. V. Her ideal of the nurse's calling
    --Her belief in individual influence, not in organization--Miss
    Nightingale as a "Founder" 246

    CHAPTER IV

    AN INDIAN REFORMER

    (1874-1879)

    Miss Nightingale's work on Indian questions. Her sources of
    information and industrious study: her opportunities of effective
    action less than in earlier years. II. Continued interest in army
    sanitation--Letter from Lord Napier of Magdala--Correspondence with
    Lord Salisbury and Lord Northbrook. III. Correspondence with Lord
    Salisbury and the Duke of Buckingham on the drainage of Madras.
    IV. Indian famines and an extension of Miss Nightingale's interests
    --Correspondence with Sir Arthur Cotton. V.

    An irrigation campaign
    --Miss Nightingale's appeal to Lord Salisbury for a Return of
    irrigation-results--Lord Salisbury on the experts--Miss
    Nightingale's continued advocacy of irrigation--Her article in the
    Nineteenth Century on "The People of India" (1878)--
    Correspondence with Lord Cranbrook. VI. Correspondence and
    interview with Mr. Gladstone--The death of Lord Lawrence. VII. Miss
    Nightingale's unpublished book on Indian Land Tenures and
    Irrigation--Her Irrigation maps. VIII.

    Her impatience at the slow
    rate of Indian reforms--Lord Salisbury's Philosophic Defence of the
    Policy of Draft 273

    CHAPTER V

    HOME LIFE IN SOUTH STREET AND THE COUNTRY

    Miss Nightingale's house in South Street--Sir Harry Verney's house
    in the same street. II. Her servants--Housekeeping. III. Miss
    Nightingale as a hostess--Reminiscences by a nursing friend.
    IV. Miss Nightingale's room--Personal appearance--Rarely out of
    doors--Love of birds--Note on London sky-effects. V. Sojourns out
    of London--A "lobster-like villa" at Norwood (1875)--Annual visits
    with her mother at Lea Hurst--Miss Nightingale's interest in her
    poorer neighbours--Mother and daughter--Impression made by Miss
    Nightingale on her friends--Mr. Jowett--The Grand Duchess of Baden
    --Lady Ashburton. VI.

    Letters to M. and Mme. Mohl--Death of M. Mohl
    (1876)--Death of Dr. Parkes--Miss Nightingale's intervention once
    more to save the Army Medical School--The Eastern Question--Miss
    Paulina Irby. VII. Was Miss Nightingale's a happy life?--Letters
    from Mr. Jowett 300

    CHAPTER VI

    LORD RIPON AND GENERAL GORDON

    (1880-1885)

    Death of Miss Nightingale's mother--Illness--Visits to the seaside
    and Claydon. II. The elections of 1880--Her special preoccupations
    and general work at this period--Visit to St. Thomas's Hospital.
    III. Friendship with General Gordon and his cousin, Mrs.
    Hawthorn--Inquiry into nursing by Orderlies in military
    hospitals--Letters from General Gordon. IV.

    Lord Ripon's Indian
    policy--Miss Nightingale's enthusiasm--Her efforts to support Lord
    Ripon--Interviews with Indian officials and politicians--Her
    interest in Indian agriculture and education--The Indian Civil
    servants at Oxford: suggestions to Arnold Toynbee--Her paper on Lord
    Ripon's Bengal Land Tenure Bill. V. The Egyptian campaign of
    1882--Miss Nightingale and the return of the Guards--Her appearances
    in public--Defects in hospital arrangements in South Africa and
    Egypt (1880-82)--Miss Nightingale's representations--Committee of
    Inquiry--Miss Nightingale and Lord Wantage. VI.

    Royal Red Cross
    conferred on her (1883)--Correspondence with the Queen--The Ilbert
    Bill--The hospital corps--Reforms in accordance with the Committee's
    recommendations--Lord Wolseley and the female nurses. VII. Progress
    of Lord Ripon's reforms--His resignation--Miss Nightingale's
    interview with his successor, Lord Dufferin--Mr. Gladstone and
    India--Lord Ripon's return. VIII. The Soudan expedition--Miss
    Nightingale and the war nurses--Reminiscences of Sister
    Philippa--Letters to Miss Williams--Miss Nightingale's
    meditations--Death of old friends 323

    CHAPTER VII

    "THE NURSES' BATTLE"; AND HEALTH IN THE VILLAGE

    (1885-1893)

    Miss Nightingale's "Jubilee Year"--A retrospect (1837-1887).
    Selection of a new matron at St. Thomas's Hospital. II. Queen
    Victoria's "Jubilee Institute for Nurses"--Misgivings--"The Nurses'
    Battle": for and against Registration--Therival forces--Miss
    Nightingale's leadership of the "Anti's"--Course of the battle--The
    hearing by the Privy Council--The result--Miss Nightingale's
    standpoint. III.

    Her work for Indian sanitation--Political
    unsettlement at home--Miss Nightingale's interviews with Lord
    Roberts and others--Lord Roberts's introduction of female nurses
    into Indian military hospitals--Lady Dufferin's Association.
    IV. "The Sutherland Succession"--Threatened dissolution of the Army
    Sanitary Committee--Proposed abolition of the Sanitary
    Commissioners in India--Miss Nightingale's campaign in
    defence--Appeal to Lord Dufferin--Communications with Lord Cross
    and Mr. W. H. Smith--Resignation of Lord Randolph Churchill--Mr.
    Smith succeeded at the War Office by Mr. Stanhope--Resignation of
    Dr.

    Sutherland--Reconstitution of the Army Sanitary Committee.
    V. Draft dispatch at the India Office advocating
    a "forward" sanitary policy--The Indian Government's resolution for
    the appointment of Provincial Sanitary Boards--Lord Lansdowne
    succeeds Lord Dufferin. VI. Miss Nightingale and village sanitation
    in India--Scheme for providing funds submitted to Lord Cross--Her
    letter circulated to the Local Governments in India--Final reply
    from the Government of India (1894)--Her retrospect of her Indian
    work. VII.

    Miss Nightingale and village sanitation in England--
    Death of her sister--Sir Harry Verney and Miss Nightingale--Her
    visits to Claydon--Her scheme of Health Missioners adopted by the
    Bucks County Council 353

    CHAPTER VIII

    MR. JOWETT AND OTHER FRIENDS

    Miss Nightingale's public acquaintances and private friends. Her
    sympathetic nature--Acquaintances made on public business passing
    into friendships--Sir Henry Yule. II. Affectionate sympathy with
    her relations--Death of her "Aunt Mai" (1889)--Letters to her
    younger relations--A burglary in South Street. III. Last years with
    Mr. Jowett--His illness in South Street (1887)--Their scheme for a
    "Nightingale Professorship of Statistics"--Mr. Jowett's illnesses
    and death (1892)--Death of Sir Harry Verney and of Mr. Shore Smith
    (1894). IV. Miss Nightingale on Mr. Jowett's death--Correspondence
    with Lord Lansdowne--Mr.

    Jowett's precepts on old age 385

    CHAPTER IX

    OLD AGE. DEATH

    (1894-1910)

    The spirit of Rabbi Ben Ezra. The latter years to be the best--Miss
    Nightingale's letters in this sense--Her own fullness of work.
    II. Continual interest in India--Lord Elgin's village sanitary
    inspection. III. Interest in army affairs--Letter to the Duke of
    Cambridge (1895)--The Hongkong barracks (1896)--Indian cantonments
    (1896-97)--The Victorian Era Exhibition (1897): Crimean
    "relics"--Note on Waterloo Day (1898)--The South African War (1899).
    IV. Interest in nursing--The "Nurses' Battle" again--The true
    "angels"--Correspondence with the Grand Duchess of Baden and
    Mr.

    Rathbone--Death of old friends and fellow-workers. V. Gradual
    failure of Miss Nightingale's powers--Loss of sight--Her
    companions--Her favourite reading--Visitors. VI. Honours--The Order
    of Merit (1907)--Freedom of the City (1908)--Her fame--Renewed cult
    of "The Popular Heroine." VII. Death and funeral--Memorials 402

    CONCLUSION 424

    APPENDICES

    A. Chronological List of Writings by Miss Nightingale 437

    B. List of Some Writings about Miss Nightingale 459

    C. List of Portraits 467

    INDEX 471

    ILLUSTRATIONS

    FACE PAGE

    Florence Nightingale: 1887. (From the portrait by Sir William
    Richmond, K.C.B., R.A.
    ) Frontispiece

    Florence Nightingale in her Room at South Street. (From a
    photograph by Miss E. F. Bosanquet, 1906
    ) 306

    Florence Nightingale: 1907. (From a water-colour drawing by Miss
    F. Amicia de Biden Footner
    ) 418

    • * * * *

    Florence Nightingale's Handwriting: facsimile of part of a letter
    to John Stuart Mill, August 11, 1867 216

    PART V

    FOR THE HEALTH OF THE ARMY IN INDIA

    (1862-1865)

    The question is no less an one than this: How to create a public
    health department for India; how to bring a higher civilization
    into India. What a work, what a noble task for a Government--no
    "inglorious period of our dominion" that, but a most glorious one!
    That would be creating India anew. For God places His own power,
    His own life-giving laws in the hands of man. He permits man to
    create mankind by those laws, even as He permits man to destroy
    mankind by neglect of those laws.--FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE: How
    People may live and not die in India
    , 1864.

    CHAPTER I

    PRELIMINARY--THE LOSS OF FRIENDS

    But tasks in hours of insight will'd
    Can be through hours of gloom fulfill'd.
    MATTHEW ARNOLD.

    The years immediately after Sidney Herbert's death were among the busiest and most useful in Miss Nightingale's life. She was engaged during them in carrying their "joint work unfinished" into a new field.

    In the previous volume we saw Miss Nightingale using her position as the heroine of the Crimean War in order to become the founder of modern nursing, and to initiate reforms for the welfare of the British soldier.

    Among those who know, it is recognized that the services which she rendered to the British army at home were hardly greater than those which she was able to render to British India, and it was this Indian work which after Sidney Herbert's death became one of the main interests of her life. She threw herself into it, as we shall hear, with full fire, and brought to it abundant energy and resource. But first she had the memory of her friend to honour and protect; and then the hours of gloom were to be deepened by the loss of another friend hardly less dear to her.

    • * * * *

    Having finished her Paper upon Sidney Herbert, Miss Nightingale left the Burlington Hotel, never to return, and took lodgings in Hampstead (Aug.-Oct. 1861). Her mood was of deep despondency. She was inclined to shut herself off from most of her former fellow-workers. Against the outside world she double-barred her shutters. Her uncle was strictly enjoined to give no one her address; she asked that all her letters might be addressed to and from his care in London.

    The formula was to be that "a great and overwhelming affliction entirely precludes Miss Nightingale" from seeing or writing to anybody. "For her sake it is most earnestly to be wished," wrote her cousin Beatrice to Mr. Chadwick (Sept. 18), "that you may come into some immediate communication with her. It is your faith that her working days are not yet over, that she may work in another field, her own being now closed against her.

    I cannot find that any of those who have been with her lately would share this hope, less on account of her health, than of her state of extreme discouragement." It was a case not only, perhaps not chiefly, of personal loss, but also of public vexation; it was not only that the Minister had died, it was that his work seemed like to die also. The point of view appears in her letters to Dr. Farr:--

    Sept. 10. We are grateful to you for the memorial of my dear
    Master which you have raised to him in the hearts of the nation.[1]
    Indeed it is in the hearts of the nation that he will live--not in
    the hearts of Ministers. There he is dead already, if indeed they
    have any. And before he was cold in his grave, Gladstone attends
    his funeral and then writes to me that he cannot pledge himself to
    give any assistance in carrying out his friend's reforms. The reign
    of intelligence at the War Office is over. The reign of muffs has
    begun.

    The only rule of conduct in the bureaucracy there and in the
    Horse Guards is to reverse his decision, his judgment, and (if
    they can do nothing more) his words.

    [1] An eloquent address delivered to the British Association at
    Manchester (Times, Sept. 9, 1861).

    October 2.... My poor Master has been dead two months to-day, too
    long a time for him not to be forgotten.... The dogs have trampled
    on his dead body. Alas! seven years this month I have fought the
    good fight with the War Office and lost it!

    November 2. My dear Master has been dead three months to-day.
    Poor Lady Herbert goes abroad this next week with the children and
    shuts up Wilton, the eldest boy going to school. It is as if the
    earth had opened and swallowed up even the Name which filled my
    whole life these five years.

    But there were things to be done in her friend's name, and she turned to do them. The power of the bureaucracy to resist was strong, because the new Secretary of State was a novice at his task, and Lord Herbert, by failing to carry through any radical reorganization of the War Office, had as she said, failed to put in "the mainspring to his works." "The Commander-in-Chief rides over the learned Secretary of State as if he were straw." But there was one hopeful and helpful factor in the case.

    Now that the Secretary for War was in the Commons, Lord de Grey was reappointed Under-Secretary. He was a genuine reformer. He knew the mind of his former Chief. He was most sympathetic to Lady Herbert. He was acquainted with Miss Nightingale. The power of an Under-Secretary is very small, but what he could do, he would. A letter which she received from a friend, both of Lord de Grey and of herself, gave her encouragement:--

    (R. Monckton Milnes to Miss Nightingale.) October 21. I knew how
    irreparable a loss you and your objects in life had in Herbert's
    death, but I should like you to know how you will find Ld. de Grey
    willing to do all in his power to forward your great and wise
    designs. I say "in his power," for that, you know, is extremely
    limited, but he may do something for you in an indirect way and,
    without much originality, he has considerable tact and adroitness.
    You won't like Sir G.

    Lewis, but somewhere or other you ought to do
    so; for in his sincere way of looking at things and in his critical
    and curious spirit he is by no means unlike yourself. He makes up
    his mind, no doubt, far better to the damnabilities of the work
    than you would do,--tho' one does not know what you would have been
    if you had been corrupted by public life. I write this about de
    Grey because I was staying with him not long ago, and he expressed
    himself on the subject with much earnestness.

    II

    So, then, there were some things perhaps which might yet, as she put it, be "saved from the wreck." Lord de Grey had already given earnest both of his good will and of his courage. He had seen Lady Herbert and asked about her husband's intentions. She knew them generally, but referred for details to Miss Nightingale, who was thus able to be of some use in carrying through Lord Herbert's scheme for a Soldiers' Home at Aldershot. Then there was the question of the General Hospital to be built at Woolwich.

    The Commander-in-Chief was opposed to the scheme, and asked Sir George Lewis to cancel it. Economy was, perhaps, behind the Minister tempting him. But Lord de Grey, who was present at the interview, stood firm. "Sir," he said, "it is impossible. Lord Herbert decided it, and the House of Commons voted it."[2] In the end, the Horse Guards and the War Office accepted the inevitable with a good grace; the order was given for the building to proceed, and Miss Nightingale's suggestion was adopted that it should be christened "The Herbert Hospital."

    [2] Miss Nightingale related this incident in two letters--to Dr. Farr
    (Sept. 10), and to Harriet Martineau (Sept. 24).

    Lord de Grey was also influential in securing a redefinition of Captain Galton's duties at the War Office. Lady Herbert told Lord de Grey that this was one of the last official matters on which she had heard her husband speak. Miss Nightingale again supplied the details, and to her ally was committed responsibility (under the Secretary of State) for new barrack works. On some other questions Miss Nightingale had the bitterness of seeing projects abandoned which she and Lord Herbert had almost matured.

    "It is really melancholy now," wrote Captain Galton to her (Aug. 19), "to see the attempts made on all hands to pull down all that Sidney Herbert laboured to build up." She recounted some of the disappointments in a letter to Harriet Martineau, and that lady, whose genuine sympathy in the cause was perhaps heightened by a journalist's scent for "copy," was eager to go on the war-path. "No harm can come," she wrote to Miss Nightingale (Oct. 4), "of an attempt to shame the Horse Guards.

    I have consulted my editor [of the Daily News], and if I can obtain a sufficiency of clear facts, I will gladly harass the Commander-in-Chief as he was never harassed before--that is, I will write a leader against him every Saturday for as many weeks as there are heads of accusation against him and his Department. We don't want to mince matters." Miss Nightingale was to supply the powder and shot; Miss Martineau was to fire the guns. The partnership was declined by Miss Nightingale.

    The reason she gave was that she was no longer in the way of obtaining much inside information. But she doubtless had other reasons. There were things which she had just managed to carry through.

    There were other possibilities of usefulness before her. She was playing a difficult game. She did not think that her hand would be strengthened by newspaper polemics, for the form of which she would not be responsible, but the information in which would be traced back to her.

    Among the points which she had just managed to score was the appointment of the Commission already mentioned,[3] for extending the Barracks Inquiry to the Mediterranean stations. Headquarters tried to stop it. "And I defeated them," she had told Miss Martineau (Sept. 24), "by a trick which they were too stupid to find out." Her papers do not disclose the nature of the "trick" by which this excellent piece of work was carried through.

    [3] See Vol. I. p. 405.

    And there was another thing which she did in order to forward Sidney Herbert's work, though in a field outside that of their collaboration: she wrote a stirring letter (Oct. 8) on the Volunteer Movement, which he had organized in 1859. It brought her several "offers," as we have heard already[4]; and, displayed in large print on a card, must have attracted many recruits.

    She wrote it as one who had experience of war and its lessons; as one, too, who had worked for the Army, "seven years this very month, without the intermission of one single waking hour." She made eloquent appeal to the patriotic spirit of the British people; and she included this piece of personal feeling: "On the saddest night of all my life, two months ago, when my dear chief Sidney Herbert lay dying, and I knew that with him died much of the welfare of the British Army--he was, too, so proud, so justly proud, of his Volunteers--on that night I lay listening to the bands of the Volunteers as they came marching in successively--it had been a review-day--and I said to myself, 'The nation can never go back which is capable of such a movement as this; not the spirit of an hour; these are men who have all something to give up; all men whose time is valuable for money, which is not their god, as other nations say of us.'" I do not know if the name of Florence Nightingale be still--as it ought to be--a name of power with the people.

    If it is, then her letter of 1861 might well be reprinted in connection with recruiting for the Territorial Force. She laid stress upon the voluntary spirit, as opposed to compulsion. But she laid stress also on the supreme importance of efficient training: "Garibaldi's Volunteers did excellently in guerilla movements; they failed before a fourth-rate regular army."

    [4] Vol. I. p. 496.

    III

    Presently some old work in a new form came in Miss Nightingale's way.

    She had returned to London in November, chiefly in order to be on the spot for consultation and suggestion in connection with the Memorial to Sidney Herbert. It was her suggestion, for one thing, that the Memorial should include a Prize Medal at the Army Medical School. For this sojourn in London, Sir Harry Verney lent his house in South Street[5] to Miss Nightingale. The American Civil War now kept her busy. "Did I tell you," she wrote to Dr. Farr (Oct.

    8), "that I had forwarded to the War Secretary at Washington, upon application, all our War Office Forms and Reports, statistical and other, taking the occasion to tell them that, as the U.S. had adopted our Registrar-General's nomenclature, it would be easier for them to adopt our Army Statistics Forms. It appears that they, the Northern States, are quite puzzled by their own want of any Army organization.

    I also took occasion to tell them of our Chinese success in reducing the Army mortality to one-tenth of what it was, and the Constantly Sick to one-seventh of what they were during the first winter of the Crimean War, due to my dear master." When the Civil War broke out, Miss Nightingale's example in the Crimea had produced an immediate effect. A "Woman's Central Association of Relief" was formed in New York. In co-operation with other bodies they petitioned the Secretary of War to appoint a Sanitary Commission, and after some delay this was done.

    Camps were inspected; female nurses were sent to the hospitals; contrivances for improved cooking were supplied, and in short, much of Miss Nightingale's Crimean work was reproduced.[6] Presently she became more directly concerned. At the end of the year (1861) England was on the verge of being embroiled in the conflict, and, whilst the agitation over the Trent affair was at its height, the British Government decided to send reinforcements to Canada. Lord de Grey was charged with many of the preparations. He asked Miss Nightingale (Dec.

    3) if he might consult her personally "as to sanitary arrangements generally." He wished to profit by her experience and judgment in relation to transports, hospitals, clothing of the troops, supplies, comforts for the sick, and generally upon "the defects and dangers to be feared," and how best to prevent them. He also asked for the names of suitable men for the position of Principal Medical Officer, and he consulted her again before making the appointment. Without a moment's loss of time, she set to work in conjunction with Dr.

    Sutherland, and sent in her suggestions. The draft instructions to the officers in charge of the expedition were sent to her on December 8. On December 10 Lord de Grey wrote: "I have got all your suggestions inserted in the Instructions, and am greatly obliged to you for them." "We are shipping off the Expedition to Canada as fast as we can," she wrote to Madame Mohl (Dec. 13). "I have been working just as I did in the times of Sidney Herbert. Alas! he left no organization, my dear master!

    But the Horse Guards were so terrified at the idea of the national indignation if they lost another army, that they have consented to everything." A few days later another draft of instructions was sent to her through Captain Galton. "We have gone over your draft very carefully," she wrote (Dec.

    18), "and find that although it includes almost everything necessary, it does not define with sufficient precision the manner in which the meat is to get from the Commissariat into the soldier's kettle, or the clothing from the Army Medical General store on to the soldier's back. You must define all this. Otherwise you will have men, as you had in the Crimea, shirking the responsibility." Memoranda among Miss Nightingale's papers show the grasp of detail with which she worked out the problems. Her mind envisaged the scene of operations.

    She calculated the distances which might have to be covered by sledges; she counted the relays and depots; she compared the relative weights and warming capacities of blankets and buffalo robes. A great Commander was lost to her country when Florence Nightingale was born a woman. Her suggestions in the case of the Canadian reinforcements were happily not put to the test of war. The Trent affair was smoothed over, largely, as is now well known, owing to the moderating counsels of the Prince Consort. It was his last service to his adopted country.

    Miss Nightingale felt his death to be a national loss. "He neither liked," she said of him, "nor was liked. But what he has done for our country no one knows."

    [5] No. 32 at that time; now renumbered, No. 4.

    [6] See on this subject Bibliography B, No. 23. The Secretary of another
    body, the United States Christian Communion, in sending reports and
    papers to Miss Nightingale (July 26, 1865) wrote: "Your influence and
    our indebtedness to you can never be known.

    Only this is true that
    everywhere throughout our broad country during these years of
    inventive and earnest benevolence in the constant endeavour to
    succour and sustain our heroic defenders, the name and work of
    Florence Nightingale have been an encouragement and inspiration." In
    the same year the plans of an Emigrant Hospital on Ward Island were
    sent to her.

    In return she sent engravings of the Departure and the
    Arrival of the Pilgrim Fathers: "Presented to the Commissioners of
    Emigration of New York for the new Emigrant Hospital on Ward Island
    by Florence Nightingale as a slight sign of her deepest reverence and
    her warmest sympathy for the noble act by which they have so
    magnificently provided for--not their own sick, but--those of the Old
    Country."

    IV

    Miss Nightingale's work in connection with the Canadian expedition was done in the midst of a personal sorrow of her own, second only in poignancy, if second at all, to that caused by the death of Sidney Herbert. This was the death of Arthur Hugh Clough. He had broken down in health and been ordered abroad in April 1861, and she had urged him to go. He died, however, at Florence on November 12. They had been close friends since her return to England from the Crimea. His sweetness of disposition, his humour, his lofty moral feeling, alike attracted her.

    He on his side had deep admiration for her, and he devoted such strength--alas! but little--as remained to him from work in the Privy Council Office to her service. He fetched and carried for her. He made arrangements for her journeys, as we have heard, and escorted her. He saw her printers, he corrected her proofs. He became, at a modest salary, secretary to the Nightingale Fund. It was poor work to set a poet to, but he did it with cheerful modesty.

    He was intent, he told Miss Nightingale, upon "doing plain work"; he had "studied and taught," he said, "too much for a man's own moral good." In 1860 his health began to fail. Miss Nightingale was sometimes a little impatient. His loyalty and zeal she could never have doubted; but she was inclined to think him lacking in initiative and energy. She was always inclined to drive willing horses a little hardly. In the case of Clough, as in that of Sidney Herbert, she sometimes attributed to infirmity of will what was in fact due to infirmity of body.

    And in each case her grief, when the end came, was not free, I think, from some element of self-reproach. "I have always felt," she had written to her uncle (Dec. 7, 1860), "that I have been a great drag on Arthur's health and spirits, a much greater one than I should have chosen to be, if I had not promised him to die sooner." "She saw my father," wrote her cousin Beatrice to Mr. Nightingale (Dec. 4), "to speak only of Arthur, as only she can speak. She was quite natural, very affectionate, very, very much moved."

    But in her state of loneliness and nervous exhaustion her feeling for lost friends was sometimes morbid. She said that for months after the death of Sidney Herbert, and again after that of Clough, she could not bear to open a newspaper for dread of seeing some mention of a beloved name. Some years later she was sent a book by Mrs. Clough. "I like very much," she replied (Nov. 13, 1865)--"how much I cannot say--to receive that book from you. But it would be impossible to me to read it or look at it, not from want of time or strength, but from too much of both spent on his memory, from thinking, not too little, but too much on him.

    But I don't say this for others. I believe it is a morbid peculiarity of long illness, of the loss of power of resistance to morbid thoughts. I cannot bear to see a portrait of those who are gone." The depth of her grief at the death of Mr. Clough is expressed or reflected in letters which she wrote or received at the time:--

    (Benjamin Jowett to Miss Nightingale.) BALLIOL, Nov. 19 [1861].
    Thank you for writing to me. I am very much grieved at the tidings
    which your letter brought me. I agree entirely in your estimate of
    our dear friend's character. It was in 1836 (the anniversary is
    next week) that I first saw him when he was elected to the Balliol
    Scholarship. No one who only knew him in later life would imagine
    what a noble, striking-looking youth he was before he got worried
    with false views of religion and the world.

    I never met with any
    one who was more thoroughly high-minded: I believe he acted all
    through life simply from the feeling of what was right. He
    certainly had great genius, but some want of will or some want of
    harmony with things around him prevented his creating anything
    worthy of himself. I am glad he was married: life was dark to him,
    and his wife and children made him as happy as he was capable of
    being made. He was naturally very religious, and I think that he
    never recovered the rude shock which his religion received during
    his first years at Oxford.

    He did not see and yet he believed in
    the great belief of all--to do rightly. Did I quote to you ever an
    expression which Neander used to me of Blanco White: einer Christ
    mehr in Unbewusstseyn als in Bewusstseyn
    ? It grieves me that you
    should have lost so invaluable a friend. No earthly trial can be
    greater than to pursue without friends the work that you began with
    them. And yet it is the more needed because it rests on one only.
    If there be any way in this world to be like Christ it must be by
    pursuing in solitude and illness, without the support of sympathy
    or public opinion, works for the good of mankind.

    I hope you will
    sometimes let me hear from you. Let me assure you that I shall
    never cease to take an interest in your objects and writings.--Ever
    yours sincerely, B. JOWETT.

    (Miss Nightingale to Sir John McNeill.) SOUTH STREET, Nov. 18....
    He was a man of rare mind and temper. The more so because he
    would gladly do "plain work." To me, seeing the blundering harasses
    which were the uses to which we put him, he seemed like a
    race-horse harnessed to a coal truck. This not because he did
    "plain work" and did it so well. For the best of us can be put to
    no better use than that.

    He helped me immensely, though not
    officially, by his sound judgment and constant sympathy. "Oh,
    Jonathan, my brother Jonathan, my love to thee was very great,
    passing the love of woman." Now, not one man remains (that I can
    call a man) of all those whom these five years I have worked with.
    But, as you say, "we are all dying."

    (Sir John McNeill to Miss Nightingale.) EDINBURGH, November 19.
    I should find it difficult to tell you how much your letter has
    distressed me. I do not know that I have ever cared so much for any
    man of whom I had seen so little as I did for Clough. Perhaps it
    may not have been all on his own account, for to know that he was
    near you was a comfort, but if he had not been altogether estimable
    in head and heart this mixed feeling could not have arisen. His
    death leaves you dreadfully alone in the midst of your work, but
    that work is your life and you can do it alone.

    There is no feeling
    more sustaining than that of being alone--at least I have ever
    found it so. To mount my horse and ride over the desert alone with
    the sky closing the circle in which my horse and I were the only
    living things, I have always found intensely elating. To work out
    views in which no one helped me has all my life been to me a source
    of vitality and strength. So I doubt not it will be to you, for you
    have a strength and a power for good to which I never could
    pretend.

    It is a small matter to die a few days sooner than usual.
    It is a great matter to work while it is day, and so to husband
    one's power as to make the most of the days that are given us. This
    you will do. Herbert and Clough and many more may fall around you,
    but you are destined to do a great work and you cannot die till it
    is substantially, if not apparently, done. You are leaving your
    impress on the age in which you live, and the print of your foot
    will be traced by generations yet unborn. Go on--to you the
    accidents of mortality ought to be as the falling of the leaves in
    autumn.

    Ever respectfully and sincerely yours, JOHN MCNEILL.

    Miss Nightingale was able, as her friends predicted, to pursue in hours of gloom the tasks which in hours of insight she had willed; and to continue, without the same sympathy from close friends as before, the kind of work which she had once done with Sidney Herbert's co-operation or with Clough's advice. But she yearned for sympathy none the less; in a noble, though an exacting, way. For by "sympathy" she understood not such feeling as would be expressed merely in affectionate behaviour or personal consideration for herself, but a fellow-feeling for her objects expressed in readiness to follow her in serving them with something of her own practical devotion.

    She did not think of herself apart from her mission.

    (Miss Nightingale to Madame Mohl.) 32 SOUTH STREET, LONDON,
    Dec. 13 [1861]. I have read half your book thro' [Madame
    Récamier
    ], and am immensely charmed by it. But some things I
    disagree with and more I do not understand. This does not apply to
    the characters, but to your conclusions, e.g. you say "women are
    more sympathetic than men." Now if I were to write a book out of my
    experience, I should begin Women have no sympathy. Yours is the
    tradition. Mine is the conviction of experience.

    I have never found
    one woman who has altered her life by one iota for me or my
    opinions. Now look at my experience of men. A statesman, past
    middle age, absorbed in politics for a quarter of a century, out of
    sympathy with me, remodels his whole life and policy--learns a
    science the driest, the most technical, the most difficult, that of
    administration, as far as it concerns the lives of men,--not, as I
    learnt it, in the field from stirring experience, but by writing
    dry regulations in a London room by my sofa with me. This is what I
    call real sympathy.

    Another (Alexander, whom I made
    Director-General) does very nearly the same thing. He is dead too.
    Clough, a poet born if ever there was one, takes to
    nursing-administration in the same way, for me. I only mention
    three whose whole lives were remodelled by sympathy for me. But I
    could mention very many others--Farr, McNeill, Tulloch, Storks,
    Martin, who in a lesser degree have altered their work by my
    opinions. And, the most wonderful of all, a man born without a
    soul, like Undine--all these elderly men.

    Now just look at the degree in which women have sympathy--as far as
    my experience is concerned. And my experience of women is almost as
    large as Europe. And it is so intimate too. I have lived and slept
    in the same bed with English Countesses and Prussian Bäuerinnen.
    No Roman Catholic Supérieure has ever had charge of women of the
    different creeds that I have had. No woman has excited "passions"
    among women more than I have. Yet I leave no school behind me. My
    doctrines have taken no hold among women.

    Not one of my Crimean
    following learnt anything from me, or gave herself for one moment
    after she came home to carry out the lesson of that war or of those
    hospitals.... No woman that I know has ever appris à apprendre. And
    I attribute this to want of sympathy. You say somewhere that women
    have no attention. Yes. And I attribute this to want of sympathy.
    Nothing makes me so impatient as people complaining of their want of
    memory. How can you remember what you have never heard?...

    It makes
    me mad, the Women's Rights talk about "the want of a field" for
    them--when I know that I would gladly give £500 a year for a Woman
    Secretary. And two English Lady Superintendents have told me the same
    thing. And we can't get one.... They don't know the names of the
    Cabinet Ministers. They don't know the offices at the Horse Guards.
    They don't know who of the men of the day is dead and who is alive.
    They don't know which of the Churches has Bishops and which not. Now
    I'm sure I did not know these things.

    When I went to the Crimea I did
    not know a Colonel from a Corporal. But there are such things as Army
    Lists and Almanacs. Yet I never could find a woman who, out of
    sympathy, would consult one--for my work. The only woman I ever
    influenced by sympathy was one of those Lady Superintendents I have
    named. Yet she is like me, overwhelmed with her own business.... In
    one sense, I do believe I am "like a man," as Parthe says. But how?
    In having sympathy. I am sure I have nothing else. I am sure I have
    no genius.

    I am sure that my contemporaries, Parthe, Hilary, Marianne,
    Lady Dunsany, were all cleverer than I was, and several of them
    more unselfish. But not one had a bit of sympathy. Now Sidney
    Herbert's wife just did the Secretary's work for her husband (which
    I have had to do without) out of pure sympathy. She did not
    understand his policy. Yet she could write his letters for him
    "like a man." I should think M^{me} Récamier was another specimen
    of pure sympathy....

    Women crave for being loved, not for loving.
    They scream out at you for sympathy all day long, they are
    incapable of giving any in return, for they cannot remember your
    affairs long enough to do so.... They cannot state a fact
    accurately to another, nor can that other attend to it accurately
    enough for it to become information. Now is not all this the result
    of want of sympathy?...

    You say of M^{me} Récamier that her existence was "empty but
    brilliant." And you attribute it to want of family. Oh, dear
    friend, don't give in to that sort of tradition. People often say
    to me, You don't know what a wife and mother feels. No, I say, I
    don't and I'm very glad I don't. And they don't know what I
    feel.... I am sick with indignation at what wives and mothers
    will do of the most egregious selfishness. And people call it all
    maternal or conjugal affection, and think it pretty to say so. No,
    no, let each person tell the truth from his own experience.

    Ezekiel
    went running about naked, "for a sign." I can't run about naked
    because it is not the custom of the country. But I would mount
    three widows' caps on my head, "for a sign." And I would cry, This
    is for Sidney Herbert, This is for Arthur Clough, and This, the
    biggest widow's cap of all, is for the loss of all sympathy on the
    part of my dearest and nearest.[7] ...

    I cannot understand how M^{me} Récamier could give "advice and
    sympathy" to such opposite people as, e.g. M^{me} Salvage and
    Chateaubriand. Neither can I understand how she could give
    "support" without recommending a distinct line of policy,--by
    merely keeping up the tone to a high one. It is as if I had said to
    Sidney Herbert, Be a statesman, be a statesman--instead of
    indicating to him a definite course of statesmanship to follow.
    Also I am sure I never could have given "advice and sympathy" to
    Gladstone and S.

    Herbert--men pursuing opposite lines of policy.
    Also I am sure I never could have been the friend and adviser of
    Sidney Herbert, of Alexander, and of others, by simply keeping up
    the tone of general conversation on promiscuous matters. We debated
    and settled measures together. That is the way we did it. Adieu,
    dear friend.... I have had two consultations. They say that all
    this worry has brought on congestion of the spine which leads
    straight to paralysis....

    [7] The reference here is to the Aunt who, in earlier years, had been in
    close companionship with her. At this time there was some
    misunderstanding between them. Mrs. Smith's advancing age and home
    claims brought a cessation of her constant activity in Miss
    Nightingale's service; but in later years aunt and niece took much
    counsel together in a resumed study of the religious subjects upon
    which they had formerly held intimate converse: see below, pp. 353,
    387.

    (Miss Nightingale to her Mother.) 9 CHESTERFIELD ST., W., March
    7 [1862]. DEAREST MOTHER--So far from your letters being a "bore,"
    you are the only person who tells me any news. I have never been
    able to get over the morbid feeling at seeing my lost two's names
    in the paper, so that I see no paper. I did not know of the deaths
    you mention.... But they and others do not know how much they are
    spared by having no bitterness mingled with their grief. Such
    unspeakable bitterness has been connected with each one of my
    losses--far, far greater than the grief....

    Sometimes I wonder that
    I should be so impatient for death. Had I only to stand and wait, I
    think it would be nothing, though the pain is so great that I
    wonder how anybody can dread an operation.... I think what I have
    felt most (during my last three months of extreme weakness) is the
    not having one single person to give me one inspiring word or even
    one correct fact. I am glad to end a day which never can come back,
    gladder to end a night, gladdest to end a month.

    I have felt this
    much more in setting up (for the first time in my life) a
    fashionable old maid's house in a fashionable quarter (tho'
    grateful to Papa's liberality for enabling me to do so), because it
    is, as it were, deciding upon a new and independent course in my
    broken old age.... Thank you very much for the weekly box. I could
    not help sending the game, chicken, vegetables and flowers to
    King's College Hospital. I never see the spring without thinking of
    my Clough.

    He used to tell me how the leaves were coming
    out--always remembering that, without his eyes, I should never see
    the spring again. Thank God! my lost two are in brighter springs
    than ours. Poor Mrs. Herbert told me that her chief comfort was in
    a little Chinese dog of his, which he was not very fond of either
    (he always said he liked Christians better than beasts), but which
    used to come and kiss her eyelids and lick the tears from her
    cheeks. I remember thinking this childish. But now I don't. My cat
    does just the same to me.

    Dumb beasts observe you so much more than
    talking beings; and know so much better what you are thinking
    of.... Ever, dear Mama, your loving child, F.

    At the turn of the year, 1861-62, Miss Nightingale had been very ill; and two physicians, Dr. Williams and Dr. Sutherland, were in daily attendance. Happily, however, the case was by no means so serious as she had reported to Madame Mohl, and in 1862 she was able to devote unremitting labour to one of the heaviest, and most useful, pieces of work which she ever did.

    CHAPTER II

    THE PROVIDENCE OF THE INDIAN ARMY

    (1862, 1863)

    In this case you are doing much more than providing for the health
    of the Troops; for, to be effectual, the improvement must extend to
    the civil population, and thus another great element of
    Civilization will be introduced.--SIR CHARLES TREVELYAN (Letter to
    Florence Nightingale
    , Aug. 11, 1862).

    It is a commonplace that the British Empire in India was won and is held by British arms. And this, though not the whole truth of the tenure by which the Empire is held, is true. What is also true, but less generally known, is that there have been heavier sacrifices than those demanded in war and rendered glorious by British valour. The greater part of the British lives that were shed in India were lost, not in battle, but by disease. Burke said of British rule in India in his time: "England has built no bridges, made no high roads, cut no navigations.

    Were we driven out of India this day, nothing would remain to tell that it had been possessed, during the inglorious period of our dominion, by anything better than the ourang-outang or the tiger."[8] That was no longer true at the time with which we are here concerned. The era had begun in which it has been a song of the English to "drive the road and bridge the ford." But the land was not yet "cleared of evil." The British soldier was still sent out to India to die ingloriously by the neglect of sanitary laws.

    In 1859 it was found that the average annual death-rate among the British soldiers in India since the year 1817 had been 69 per 1000.

    To-day it is little over 5 per 1000. The changes in barracks and military sanitation in India, which are primarily accountable for this great saving of life, are directly traceable to the recommendations of the Royal Commission which was appointed by Lord Stanley in 1859, and which reported in 1863. Thus much the reader may find stated in any trustworthy book of reference or other standard authority.

    What he will not find generally stated is that the appointment of the Royal Commission is directly traceable to Miss Nightingale, that by her the greater part of its Report was written, and that the suggestions for reform founded upon it were also her work. At an International Congress held in London in 1860 a French delegate, as already related, spoke of Florence Nightingale as "the Providence of the English Army." She was no less the Providence of the Indian Army.

    To the British soldier in India, as at home, she was "a saviour." In introducing this subject, we must go back a little in point of time, for the Indian work had begun a few years before the death of Sidney Herbert.

    [8] Speech on Fox's East India Bill, Dec. 1, 1783 (Burke's Speeches,
    1816, vol. ii. p. 430).

    • * * * *

    "I must tell you a secret," wrote Miss Nightingale to Harriet Martineau in 1859 (May 19), "because I think it will please you. For eight long months I have been 'importunate-widowing' my 'unjust judge,' viz. Lord Stanley, to give us a Royal Sanitary Commission to do exactly the same thing for the Armies in India which the last did for the Army at home.

    We have just won it. The Queen has signed the Warrant. So it is safe.

    Mr. Sidney Herbert is Chairman of course. Drs. Sutherland, Martin, Farr, and Alexander, whose names will be known to you, and Sir R. Vivian and Sir P. Cautley, of the India Council, are on it."

    Miss Nightingale had made up her mind two years before to do this thing.

    The Indian Mutiny, which filled some minds only with thoughts of vengeance and repression against the native soldiers, filled hers rather with thoughts of pity and reform on behalf of the British soldiers. She had gone into the figures of mortality in the Indian army at the time when she was analysing those in the army at home. There was "murder" committed not only by the Sepoys. It was murder also to doom British soldiers to death by neglect of sanitary precautions. At the end of her Notes on the Army (1857), she inserted a fly-leaf, which foreshadowed her Indian campaign:--

    While the sheets were passing through the press, those lamentable
    occurrences took place in India which have led to an universal
    conviction that this vast Empire must henceforth be held by British
    troops. If we were to be led by past experience of the presumed
    effect of Indian climates on European constitutions, our country
    might almost despair of being able to supply men enough.... The
    British race has carried with it into those regions of the sun its
    habits, its customs, and its vices, without considering that under
    a low temperature man may do with impunity what under a higher one
    is death.

    Our vast Indian Empire consists of many zones, of many
    regions, of many climates. On the mere question of climate, it is
    surely within human possibility, even in the great majority of
    instances, so to arrange the stations, and so to connect them, by
    railroads and telegraphs, that the troops would hardly be required
    to occupy unhealthy districts. Even with regard to such districts
    the question arises to what extent the unhealthiness is inevitable,
    and to what extent it would be remediable....

    As an illustration of
    the necessity of Government interference in this matter, it may be
    stated, on the very first authority, that, after a campaign perhaps
    one of the most arduous and successful on record, and when the
    smallness of the British force and the season of the year required
    every sanitary precaution to be taken for the preservation of the
    force, a certain earnest, energetic Officer appointed a sanitary
    inspector to attend to the cleansing of a captured city, and to the
    burial of some thousand dead bodies of men, horses, asses,
    bullocks, camels, and elephants, which were poisoning the air.

    The
    Bombay Government, to which the appointment was referred, "would
    not sanction it," "because there was no precedent for it"! In
    future, it ought to be the duty of the Indian Government to require
    no precedents for such procedure. The observance of Sanitary laws
    should be as much part of the future régime of India as the
    holding of Military positions or as Civil government itself. It
    would be a noble beginning of the new order of things to use
    hygiene as the handmaid of civilization.

    Everything that Miss Nightingale thus said should be done, was done; and to the doing of it, she supplied, first, the propelling force, and, then, much of the detailed direction.

    First came the movement for getting the appointment of a Royal Commission agreed to in principle. Miss Nightingale's reference to Lord Stanley as her "unjust judge" need not be taken too seriously. He was her very good friend, as we know;[9] and it was when he was transferred from the Colonial to the India Office (1858) that she felt her time to have come. And Lord Stanley agreed at once to her suggestion of appointing a Commission. It was when the consideration of the Commission was reached that the delay began.

    Who should approach Lord Stanley on the details? And how should it be done? Miss Nightingale and what I have called her cabinet of reformers were equally interested in the Sub-Commissions still sitting on Army Sanitation at home. Lord Stanley wanted Mr. Herbert to undertake the chairmanship of the India Commission. Should he accept it, at risk of diverting some of his attention from these other reforms? Miss Nightingale and her friends hit upon a plan, as she hoped, for killing two birds with one stone. It was intimated to Lord Stanley that Mr.

    Herbert would accept the chairmanship on condition that the pending reforms at home were hastened. I do not know if the Indian Secretary came to terms with the War Secretary in that sense; if he did, I fear that General Peel interpreted "haste" as festina lente. Anyhow, Mr. Herbert accepted the chairmanship, and then some months were spent in arranging the membership and the terms of reference. There were to be three sanitary experts, a statistician, and two members of the India Council. Of the two latter, one (Sir R.

    Vivian) was a friend of Miss Nightingale's uncle, Mr. Smith; and of Sir Proby Cautley she had heard good reports. The sanitarians--Drs. Sutherland, Martin, and Alexander--and Dr. Farr, the statistician, were all of her inner circle. At the last moment there was a fresh delay. The list was submitted for the royal approval, and Her Majesty required that "a Queen's officer of acknowledged experience in India" should be added to the Commission. Mr.

    Herbert asked Miss Nightingale to supply a suitable man, by which he meant a man whose acknowledged experience included some belief in sanitary science. She took great pains, and employed some wile in obtaining the best opinions. She wrote, for one thing, to her uncle, telling him (May 19, 1859) to get at Sir John Lawrence, through his friend Sir R. Vivian, and ask for suggestions.

    "Vivian must be soaped," she added, "so as not to let him think that we undervalue his opinion." Sir John Lawrence did not, however, on this occasion prove very resourceful; Miss Nightingale sent in the name of an officer, Colonel E. H. Greathed, who had been commended to her through another channel, and he was duly added to the Commission. At an earlier stage she had thrown out the interesting suggestion that John Stuart Mill, lately retired from the East India House, should be asked to serve, but this did not meet with favour.

    "Our business," wrote one of her circle, "is with spades and wheelbarrows," and he doubted whether "Compte" [sic] could be put to such purposes. Miss Nightingale always thought that this ally of hers, though invaluable in many ways, was a little wanting in soul. So then the Commission was appointed. The Warrant was issued on May 31, 1859. The Commission reported on May 19, 1863. There were some changes in its personnel from death and other causes. On the overthrow of the Derby Government, Mr.

    Herbert went to the War Office, and he presently resigned the chairmanship. Lord Stanley succeeded him. The members of the Commission on whom both Mr. Herbert and Lord Stanley most relied were Dr. Sutherland and Dr. Farr, and a third, who was yet not a member--Miss Nightingale. And among these three the lion's share of the work was done by her.

    [9] See Vol. I. p. 339.

    II

    She had not waited for the actual appointment of the Commission to begin collecting, preparing, and digesting evidence for it. Her first concern was to draft a circular of inquiry which should be sent to all the Stations in India. It lacked nothing, as will be supposed, in requiring fulness of statistical detail. When she had prepared it, she sent it in proof to Sir John McNeill for his suggestions, asking him also (May 9,

    1. "kindly to give an opinion as to the general direction which the

    Enquiry should take." In cases where she was personally acquainted with Governors or high military or medical officers in India, she wrote soliciting their good offices. Sir Charles Trevelyan, then Governor of Madras, promised cordial co-operation. Then she and Dr. Farr set to work on such statistical records as were obtainable from the East India House. There is a bundle of correspondence amongst her Papers relating to the difficulties she encountered, and surmounted, in obtaining official sanction for clerical work in this regard. Dr. Farr's appetite for statistics was as insatiable as hers, and she had taken means to lay in ample supplies:--

    (Miss Nightingale to Dr. Farr.) HIGHGATE, June 2, [1859]. Your
    Commission was gazetted on May 31 and Mr. Herbert is in town. As it
    will be necessary to obtain the Statistics of Sickness, Mortality,
    and Invaliding of the Indian Army from the Medical Boards there,
    would not some of the proposed forms for the Army Medical Dep. be
    better than any other, filled up for each station with the Diseases
    annually for a period say of 10 years? Or would it be necessary to
    provide others?

    We must, of course, have the most minute
    Statistics--both for Soldiers and Officers in the Queen's,
    Company's and native troops. And these we should get by this method
    for 10 years. I suppose the Medical Boards have the Presidency
    Medical Book Records. Would it be necessary to get the Returns for
    each Corps separately? Would it not be important to get the
    ages--age and time of service at Death or Invaliding?

    HAMPSTEAD, Dec. 6 [1859]. In consequence of your intemperate
    desire to have the Indian Medical Service Regulations, we have
    applied at the Great House for copies. And the answer is that they
    have only one Office copy, and if we want any we must send to
    India. Knowing their weakness, we had (in our "Queries") previously
    sent to two hundred Stations in India for copies of all
    "Regulations," and we hope the result will satisfy your literary
    appetite.

    Dr. Farr, then, was being fed with statistics. Officials in India were being kept busy with forms to be filled up, and with the preparation of other written evidence. In November 1859 the Commission began taking oral evidence in London, but this was a comparatively minor part of its labours, and during 1860 no public sittings were held. They were resumed in 1861. Lord Stanley had then succeeded Mr. Herbert in the chair, but Miss Nightingale's grip upon the Commission was not relaxed. Two of the Commissioners, Dr. Sutherland and Dr.

    Farr, were in close touch with her. The former was with her almost every day; the latter asked her to send him questions which he should put to witnesses. As in the case of the former Royal Commission, so now Miss Nightingale saw some of the witnesses before they gave their evidence. Among her visitors in this sort was Sir John Lawrence, as already mentioned, and a friendship began which had important consequences.

    Seeing that everything was thus in good train, Miss Nightingale was able during the years 1859-60-61 to devote her main work to those other matters with which we have been concerned in preceding Parts. In 1862, her main interest was in the Indian Commission, and the amount of work which she gave to it during 1862-1863 was enormous.

    Her manner of life during these years was similar to that described in a previous chapter. Work for the Commission required her constant attendance in London or within easy distance of it. In 1862 she lived either in a hotel (Peary's, 31 Dover Street), a hired house (9 Chesterfield Street), or Sir Harry Verney's house in South Street.

    During August and September she took a house in Oak Hill Park, Hampstead. In 1863 she divided her time between Hampstead, hired houses in Cleveland Row, and Sir Harry Verney's. Her affectionate friend, Mrs. Sutherland, did all the house-hunting for her. Cleveland Row was selected for its nearness to the War Office; and the convenience of the site so far constrained Dr. Sutherland's sanitary conscience that he declared Cleveland Row to be "the airiest place in London."

    III

    Few of my readers have come to close quarters, I suppose, with the Indian Sanitary Commission's Report. It is a very formidable thing, consisting of two bulky volumes, containing respectively 1069 and 959 pages--in all 2028 pages, mostly in small print. Of this mountainous mass, the greater part bears in one way or another the impress of Miss Nightingale. It was she, in the first place, as already stated, who drafted the questions which were sent to every military station in India.

    The replies, signed in each case by the commanding officer, the engineer officer, and the medical officer, occupy the whole of the second volume. The replies, as they came in from India, were sent to her to analyse. There were van-loads of them, she said, which cost her £4:10s. to move whenever she changed houses. With the analysis made by her and Dr. Sutherland, these replies anticipated, as she afterwards noted,[10] the Statistical Survey of India which Lord Mayo ordered ten years later.

    It was said at the time that such a complete picture of life in India, both British and native, was contained in no other book in existence. In October 1861 she was formally requested by the Commission to submit remarks on these Stational Reports. She had completed the task by August 1862. The "Observations by Miss Nightingale," which occupy twenty-three pages of the Report, are among the most remarkable of her Works, and in their results among the most beneficent.

    They are also extremely readable; and to make them more instructive, she included a number of woodcuts illustrating, not only Indian hospitals and barracks, but native customs in connection with water-supply and drainage.[11] The Treasury--horrified perhaps at the idea of popularizing a Blue-book--made some demur to the cost, but Miss Nightingale was allowed to solve the difficulty by paying for the printing, as well as for the illustrations, out of her private purse.

    [10] In her marginalia to Sir William Hunter's Earl of Mayo (1891).

    [11] Indian officers (and especially Colonel Young) supplied her with
    sketches, some of which were touched up by her cousin, Miss Hilary
    Bonham Carter.

    She made full use of the opening which the niggardliness of the Treasury gave her. She hurried the printers, and had a large number of her "Observations" struck off for private use. "I have looked once more," wrote Lord Stanley (Nov. 21), "through your Remarks, and like them better the oftener I read them. The style alone (apart from the authority which your name carries with it) will ensure their being studied by many who know nothing of the subject. They will admirably relieve the dryness of our official Report.

    I hope every Indian and English newspaper will reprint them, in extracts at least. They must be circulated with our Report, separately from the too voluminous mass of evidence which we can't help appending. You have added one more to your many and invaluable services in the cause." "Miss Nightingale's Paper," wrote Dr. Farr to Dr. Sutherland (Dec. 1), "is a masterpiece, in her best style; and will rile the enemy very considerable--all for his good, poor creature."[12] But it was not only among the Commissioners that she circulated her Paper.

    She sent it confidentially to many of her influential friends. "The picture is terrible," wrote Sir John McNeill (Aug. 9), "but it is all true.

    There is no one statement from beginning to end that I feel disposed to question, and there are many which my own observation and experience enable me to confirm." A copy went to John Stuart Mill, who was much pleased with the "Observations," and was certain that "the publication of them would do vast good." Miss Nightingale had a copy bound for the Queen, and sent it--as also a copy of her Paper on Sidney Herbert--through Sir James Clark, who marked passages for the Queen to read.

    Her Majesty, he found from conversation, had not confined her reading to those passages. The Queen in return sent a copy of her Collection of Prince Albert's Speeches. "The Queen," wrote Miss Nightingale to M. Mohl (Feb. 14, 1863), "has sent me her book with such a touching inscription. She always reminds me of the Greek chorus with her hands clasped above her head wailing out her irrepressible despair."[13] Miss Nightingale sent her "Observations" also to Sir John Lawrence, who studied them closely, and corresponded with her on the subject.

    Another copy went to Sir Charles Trevelyan.[14] "Having," he wrote (Oct. 31, 1862), "undertaken the duties of Financial Member of the Council of India, I may now be able to give some help in carrying the recommendations of your Commission into practical effect. You must not expect from me as much as Sidney Herbert did, for my power will not be the same. The Governor-General and the local Governors will alone be in that position. But I shall do what I can.

    Perhaps you will send me a copy of your Abstract of the Evidence, and direct my attention to the points of more immediate importance. I shall be obliged for any hints."

    Miss Nightingale responded by sending him papers enough to occupy all his time on the voyage. She seems at this time to have entertained some hope that her health would permit her, when the Report was out, to visit India in person; for one of Sir Charles's letters refers to such a visit, and expresses the pleasure which it would give to Lady Trevelyan and himself to receive her as their guest, and in every way to assist her mission. But this was not to be. Her knowledge of India and Indian questions was already great, and presently it became so minute as to encourage a legend that she herself had once been there.[15] But she never saw the country.

    It is not always either the "life-long resident," or, on the other hand, "Padgett, M.P.," who is better qualified than the student to perceive and serve a country's need.

    [12] A true prediction: see Sir Bartle Frere's saying, below, p. 158.

    [13] The inscription is: "To Miss Florence Nightingale in recollection
    of the greatest and best of Princes from the beloved Prince's
    broken-hearted Widow, Victoria R. Osborne, Jan. 13, 1863."

    [14] He had been recalled from Madras in 1860.

    [15] "It will be remembered that Miss Florence Nightingale came to this
    country and was impressed with the idea that if India needed
    anything it was village sanitation. She collected a mass of facts
    and has since been agitating in England": Amrita Bazar Patrika
    (Calcutta), June 29, 1892, reprinted in the Indian Spectator,
    July 10.

    Miss Nightingale's "Observations" form a synopsis of the whole subject.

    Giving chapter and verse from the Stational reports for each of her statements, she shows, first, that the prevailing diseases were camp diseases such as she had seen in the Crimean War--largely due to the selection of unsuitable sites. Among the causes were Bad Water, Bad Drainage, Filthy Bazaars, Want of Ventilation, and Surface Overcrowding in barrack-huts and sick-wards. Her remarks under these several heads are often characteristically racy.

    "Where tests have been used, the composition of the water reads like a very intricate prescription, containing nearly all the chlorides, sulphates, nitrates, and carbonates in the pharmacopoeia, besides silica and quantities of animal and vegetable matter, which the reports apparently consider nutritive." "If the facilities for washing were as great as those for drink, our Indian army would be the cleanest body of men in the world." "There is no drainage, in any sense in which we understand the word.

    The reports speak of cesspits as if they were dressingrooms." "Except where the two Lawrences have been--there one can always recognize their traces--the bazaars are simply in the first savage stage of social savage life."

    Under the head of "Overcrowding," she brings together various instances with figures and woodcuts; she quotes one report which said that the men (300 men per room!) "are generally accommodated in the barrack without inconvenient overcrowding," and she asks, "What is convenient overcrowding?" "At some stations the floors are of earth, varnished over periodically with cow-dung: a practice borrowed from the natives.

    Like Mahomet and the mountain, if men won't go to the dunghill, the dunghill, it appears, comes to them." Her next section, on "Intemperance," is scathing. In India, as at home,[16] it was a current opinion of the time that the soldier is by nature a drunken animal; the only question seemed to be as to how he had better get drunk. At one station, though the men were reported as "mostly temperate," she found that on a ten years' average one man in three was admitted into hospital directly from drink.

    "The men are killed by liver disease on canteen spirits to save them from being killed by liver disease on bazaar spirits. May there not be some middle course whereby the men may be killed by neither?" Under "Diet," she notes the absurdity of a uniform ration, in amount and quality, in all seasons and climates; and ventures to doubt whether cesspits are desirable adjuncts of kitchens. Her next head is "Want of Occupation and Exercise"--a fruitful source of vice and disease.

    It is a most interesting chapter, full of valuable hints and illustrated by an amusing drawing, sent to her by Colonel Young, of "Daily Means of Occupation and Amusement passim." Here, as in much else of Miss Nightingale's work, she collected all the better opinions; she picked out from the returns before her any hopeful experiments; enlarged upon them, and drove the moral home. Her chapter on "Indian Hospitals" is naturally very full and detailed.

    She discusses the prevalent structural defects; suggests improvements in the internal arrangements; and notes that there were "neither trained orderlies nor female nurses." On the subject of "Hill Stations," Miss Nightingale's "Observations" show a fear lest too much reliance should be placed upon their superior salubrity.

    She quotes instances of terrible sanitary defects on hill stations, and enforces the moral that "the salvation of the Indian army must be brought about by sanitary measures everywhere." After discussing "Native Towns," "Soldiers' Wives," and "Statistics," Miss Nightingale insisted generally on the importance of instituting a proper system of sanitary service in India. Henceforth, to the end almost of her long life, she regarded herself, and in large measure was able to act, as a sanitary servant to the army and peoples of India.

    [16] See Vol. I. p. 277.

    Miss Nightingale's "Observations" were only part of her share in the labours of the Commission. They were followed in the Report by an Abstract, arranged under Presidencies, of the Returns on which the "Observations" were founded. This analysis, occupying nearly a hundred pages, was drawn up, as already stated, by Miss Nightingale and Dr.

    Sutherland. The manuscript of it, preserved amongst her papers, is mainly in her handwriting. And she did much more, as will presently be related.

    IV

    When the Commission of the Army in India was nearing the end of its labours, an event happened which seemed to Miss Nightingale of crucial importance. On April 14, 1863, she heard from Sir Harry Verney that Sir George Lewis, the Secretary for War, had died suddenly on the previous day. Sir Harry added that at the Service Clubs, Lord de Grey was talked of as a probable successor, but that Lord Panmure's name was also mentioned.

    From another and a better-informed source she heard that Lord de Grey hoped to get the appointment, but that there were believed to be two difficulties in the way. The Queen might object to the War Office being given to a Minister who had not yet been in the Cabinet, and pressure might be put upon Lord Palmerston from other quarters not to appoint a Peer. Should either or both of these factors prevail, Mr. Cardwell was believed to be the most probable successor.

    Now it seemed to Miss Nightingale all-important that, when the Report on the health of the army in India came out, the Secretary of State for War should be a proved sanitarian. She did not want to have once more to "bully the Bison," and she did not know much of Mr. Cardwell. She did know Lord de Grey, and she knew him as a sympathiser in her cause.

    Without a moment's delay she set herself to bring to bear in his favour such influence as she might possess, either on her own account or as the public legatee, as it were, of Sidney Herbert. A telegram written en clair and preserved by the recipient shows how a good press was secured for Lord de Grey's appointment:--

    From Florence Nightingale to Harriet Martineau.--Agitate,
    agitate, for Lord de Grey to succeed Sir George Lewis.

    The world was duly informed next day (April 17) through the columns of the Daily News that public opinion expected the appointment of Lord de Grey. But Miss Nightingale took other measures. She wrote a letter to Lord Palmerston, and to his principal colleague, Mr. Gladstone, she sent a copy of it. Mr. Gladstone, in reply, did not doubt that Lord Palmerston had a very high opinion of Lord de Grey, but added on his own part that he saw great difficulty in not having the head of the War Office, with its vast expenditure, in the House of Commons.

    The letter to Lord Palmerston, meanwhile, was delivered by a special messenger, who had been strictly charged to make sure that the Minister read it at once. The sequel, describing a somewhat curious scene, had better be given in Sir Harry Verney's own words:--

    CLEVELAND ROW, Ap. 15 [2.30]. From Hampstead I returned to South
    Street, and found your letter. Thence to Cambridge House. Lord
    Palmerston was so good as to admit me. I said that I had seen you
    this morning, and that by your desire I requested him to allow me
    to read a letter to him from you. He said, "Certainly"; and I read
    it to him rather slowly. Having read it, I said that you had
    mentioned this morning that within a fortnight of Lord Herbert's
    death, he had said to you more than once that he hoped Lord de Grey
    might be his successor.

    I then added, "I have not to request any
    reply or observations on Miss Nightingale's letter. I have only to
    thank you for your kindness in allowing me to read it." He took
    the letter and put it in his pocket. He then asked how you are,
    and where, and I told him. There is a Cabinet at 5.30 this
    afternoon. I think that if Gladstone has your note before going to
    it, it might be well.

    She had anticipated Sir Harry's suggestion, as we have seen. The Prime Minister put her letter into his pocket, but it did not stay there. He took it with him to Windsor and read it to the Queen. On April 22 it was announced that Her Majesty had been pleased to approve the appointment of Lord de Grey as Secretary of State for War.

    V

    Miss Nightingale thus felt assured that when the Indian Report came out she would have a sympathetic chief at the War Office, and she turned with the greater zest to the next stage in her labours; namely, the preparation of the Report by the Commissioners. The manuscript of the first page or two (explaining the delay in issuing the Report and the procedure of the Commission) is in Lord Stanley's handwriting (preserved among Miss Nightingale's papers). He entrusted the preparation of the first draft of the rest of the Report, for statistics to Dr.

    Farr, and for the rest to Miss Nightingale and Dr. Sutherland. She had written a first draft of the greater part of her sections of the Report as early as April 1862. By August it was in type and corrected by Lord Stanley, who "pledged himself to carry it through the Commission next month."[17] But Dr. Farr's section was not so far advanced, and there were other delays at which Miss Nightingale chafed not a little. In May 1863 the last stage was reached.

    "I have done and shall do all in my power," Lord Stanley wrote to her (July 10), "to make it public that to Dr.

    Sutherland and you we mainly owe it that the Report has assumed its present shape." Among her papers is a collection of proofs of the Report in various stages; some corrected by Dr. Farr and Dr. Sutherland, others corrected and re-corrected by her. The descriptive portion of the Report is in substance a repetition of her "Observations," in the colder language which is held to add weight and dignity to such documents; though here and there Miss Nightingale's touch may be felt.

    The magnitude of the evils which needed to be remedied is put in an arresting way. "Besides deaths from natural causes [9 per 1000], 60 head per 1000 of our troops perish annually in India. It is at that expense that we have held dominion there for a century; a company out of every regiment has been sacrificed every twenty months.

    These companies fade away in the prime of life; leave few children; and have to be replaced, at great cost, by successive shiploads of recruits." The cost of preventable sickness in the Indian army was calculated at £388,000 a year. The list of Recommendations with which the Report concludes may be described as a Sanitary Charter for the Army in India--a Charter which during many successive years was gradually put into force.

    [17] Letter to Sir J. McNeill, Aug. 8, 1862.

    Last of all came what Miss Nightingale considered the most vital point of all--namely, the suggestion of practical machinery by which, if the Government adopted it, the recommendations of the Commission might be carried out. At this crucial point, she had a very stiff fight. The machinery, as she had devised it, was to be twofold. First, there were to be Sanitary Commissions appointed for each Presidency in India. On this point, all the Commissioners seem to have been agreed; but it was different with Miss Nightingale's second point.

    The reports which she had read and marked from the Indian stations filled her with a fear that if the whole of the initiative were left to India the work would in some cases be negligently or unintelligently done. There had not yet been in that country the same education of public opinion amongst the governing class in the science of sanitation that had been in progress in England.

    She deemed it essential that the machinery recommended by the Commission should in one way or another include provision to secure for India the experience already obtained in dealing with all kinds of sanitary questions in England. She had formulated her own plans to this end at an early stage of the Commission. What she first suggested was a Sanitary Department at the India Office, and this, as we shall hear in a later chapter (p. 153), was ultimately established.

    It had been well if the suggestion had been accepted from the beginning, for the compromise which was substituted led to some confused friction between the War Office and the India Office. As the second-best plan, Miss Nightingale wanted the standing Sanitary Committee at the War Office,[18] reinforced by one or two representatives of India, to be invested with authority over Indian sanitation, and she wanted, secondly, a Sanitary Code to be issued for India by the Home Government. She had named the two Indian officials, and had urged the addition of Mr.

    Rawlinson, at that time the leading sanitary engineer in England.[19] But on all this there was some difference of opinion. She was kept informed from day to day of the currents of thought among the Commissioners, and of the course of the discussions. The letters, minutes, memoranda in which she urged her views are many. She had first to persuade Lord Stanley, and this in personal interviews she succeeded in doing. She begged him to open the subject to Sir Charles Wood, the Secretary for India, who did not take the suggestion amiss.

    There were still, however, some contrary opinions, but ultimately her policy prevailed. "I cannot help telling you, in the joy of my heart," she wrote to Harriet Martineau (May 19), "that the final meeting of the Indian Sanitary Commission was held to-day--that the Report was signed--and that after a very tough battle, lasting three days, to convince these people that a Report was not self-executive, our Working Commission was carried, not quite in the original form proposed, but in what may prove a better working form because grafted on what exists.

    This is the dawn of a new day for India in sanitary things, not only as regards our Army, but as regards the native population." But Miss Nightingale was never content to let the light steal in gradually; she wanted to secure for the Report of the Commission the fullest possible glare of publicity.

    [18] The Barrack and Hospital Commission, re-named the Army Sanitary
    Committee in 1865; see p. 65.

    [19] Her nominations were, in the end, all approved. The Indian
    representatives were Sir Proby Cautley and Sir James Ranald Martin.

    Her first concern was to get early notices of the Report in the newspapers. The daring, the celerity, the energy of her moves might excite the admiration even of the greatest experts in this sort of our own day. The gist of the Report, so far as its statement of the facts was concerned, was contained in her own "Observations"; and, as explained above, she had already circulated these both in India and at home. Having thus, as it were, salted the ground, she prepared for the official publication.

    As one of the principal authors of the Report, she was obviously entitled to some copies. She obtained a note from Lord Stanley, the Chairman, to that effect. The Queen's printer, Mr. Spottiswoode, was her very good friend, having been associated with her in more than one philanthropic enterprise, and, after seeing Lord Stanley's note, he promised to use every expedition and to let Miss Nightingale have some of the very earliest copies.

    She sent them off immediately; to various influential friends (Sir John Lawrence among the number), but principally to writers for the press; and with regard to these latter, there was no reason why she should tell each recipient of the special early copy that he was not the only individual so favoured.

    A Blue-book of 2028 pages is not mastered in a minute, and people wondered how so many of the newspapers and magazines were able to notice the Report so fully on the instant. "Mr. Baker [the Clerk to the Commission] has regained his equanimity," wrote the printer (July 23); "but for three days he could not recover the shock of your rapid action." Miss Nightingale's celerity may well have seemed indecent to the leisurely official mind; for six months were allowed to pass before the Government of India was officially provided with copies of the Report!

    This delay may seem incredible to those not well versed in such affairs, but it is recorded in a Government Dispatch,[20] and an investigation made by Miss Nightingale into another delay of a like kind may perhaps afford an explanation.[21] Meanwhile, in July 1863, she had, for some days previous to the issue of the Report, been arranging for reviews in newspapers and magazines, in Edinburgh and Dublin as well as in London. Mr. W. R.

    Greg was especially helpful; he contributed notices to three important periodicals--the Economist, the National Review, and the Spectator. Miss Nightingale was diligent also in coaching Harriet Martineau, writing at great length to explain the points on which public opinion might most usefully declare itself. Miss Martineau wrote on the Report in the Daily News, Macmillan's Magazine, and Once a Week; and on her own part she had a contribution to make to the cause. She was an old friend of Lord and Lady Elgin.

    Should she write to them? The indefatigable Miss Nightingale at once sent her the heads of a letter on the subject which should go immediately to the Viceroy.

    [20] "On the 5th February 1864, the Government of India informed the
    Secretary of State that, in consequence of the non-arrival of the
    Report of the Royal Commission, it had not been possible to carry
    out the measures indicated in the despatch of the 15th August, but
    that having just received a few copies, &c., &c." (Memorandum on
    Measures adopted for Sanitary Improvements in India up to the end
    of 1867
    , p. 2).

    [21] See below, p. 49 n.

    Though Miss Nightingale attached importance to notices in the press, she was equally eager that the Report itself should attract the attention of influential individuals in and out of Parliament. And here at the outset she met with a severe check which, however, by her energy and resource was turned to the greater advantage of the cause. The Blue-books were of enormous bulk, and a smaller edition had been prepared, apparently by the Clerk.

    Owing to what was officially described as "a mistake," it was this smaller edition that was "presented to both Houses of Parliament by command." It alone was placed on sale to the public; the 1000 copies of the complete work (of which the printer had been ordered to break up the type) were reserved for the press and for official purposes. They could be obtained (on application) by members of Parliament, but were not accessible to the public.

    The smaller edition, which the officials designed for public use, did not contain Miss Nightingale's "Observations" (though these were referred to in the Report) and did not contain the evidence from the Indian Stations. It gave instead a "précis of evidence" made by the Clerk. This, as Miss Nightingale thought, was badly done, and, moreover, referred in the margin to passages which again were not accessible to the public.

    Miss Nightingale was naturally and justly indignant at a proceeding which thus left the recommendations of the Commission unsupported, so far as the public were concerned, by the essential facts. She set herself with characteristic energy to rectify the official "mistake," or, as she suspected, to circumvent the design. If indeed there were any intention to withhold from the public eye the full extent of the terrible state of things in India, the authors of the design had counted without the formidable Lady-in-Chief.

    As for the partial suppression of her own "Observations," that was easily rectified. Dr. Sutherland and Dr. Farr, incensed at the treatment which she had received, promptly made arrangements with a publisher for the separate issue of her "Observations."[22] This little "red book" had a large sale, and was widely reviewed in the press.

    Thereby the subject received a second series of notices. "It is not a book," said one of the reviewers, "but a great action." But Miss Nightingale herself was more concerned with the wide circulation of the Blue-books themselves. First, she wrote round to every member of Parliament whom she knew, informing them of the facts and begging them to apply for the unmutilated edition. One of the answers she received was from Lord Shaftesbury (Aug.

    22): "I will immediately apply for the copy of evidence you mention, but ought we not to insist when Parliament meets that it be fully circulated like any other document? Sir C. Wood may have made a 'mistake,' but a far greater mistake would be to bury this important matter in the 'tomb of all the Capulets.' ... You have achieved very grand things; and you must thank God that He has called you to such a work, and has so blessed it.

    I have much to talk to you about."[23] Secondly, she extracted a promise that inquirers at Hansard's office should be informed that copies of the unmutilated edition could be obtained by the public on application at the Burial Board Office.[24] She took very good care that they should not be buried there. She prompted all sorts and conditions of persons among her acquaintances to apply, and there was a run on the book.

    Next, and chiefly, she was anxious that the essential parts of the Report should come under the notice of every officer and every official in India who was in any degree responsible for the health of the army and who might be brought by a knowledge of the facts to further the cause of sanitary reform. The way in which she achieved her purpose was characteristic.

    Miss Nightingale had a personal grievance in this matter; and she used it, as on a previous occasion she had used her personal prestige, to gain a public end. To an intimate friend in the War Office, she was downright: "Done in some way or other, I am determined it shall be." But to the great men above him, she was suave--insidiously and dangerously suave. She entirely agreed that it would be expensive to reprint, and absurd to circulate widely, two enormous Blue-books of 2028 pages.

    Nobody would read them. But on the other hand was it not a little unfair to her to circulate an abridged edition, from which was excluded all the material upon which, at the request of the Commission, she had spent years of labour? But what was to be done? She knew how busy all Government officials were; but she would willingly undertake the task of putting together an amended edition of the smaller issue. Would the Treasury object to the cost? If so, she would bear it.

    In one way and another, she said, she had spent £700 in connection with the former Report on the British Army; the cost of similar work in connection with India would be less, and she would gladly defray it. Lord de Grey authorized her to proceed on August 26, and for the next three months she was busy in preparing the Report in the form in which it was to be circulated among military and medical officers.[25] But she was not quite satisfied yet. She had provided means for bringing her horses to water, but who was to make them drink?

    Her amended report was to be circulated amongst the Army in India, but would it be read? She was afraid not, unless the Secretary of State specially commended it to the attention of his subordinates. Did the War Office shrink from taking initiative in a matter which also concerned the India Office?

    "But surely Sir Charles Wood will be very grateful to you for remedying his mistake." The Minister assented, and a preface was added to Miss Nightingale's edition of the Report, in which the Secretary for War explained that it was circulated "with a view of affording information on the subject to Commanding, Engineering, and Medical Officers." Of course there were official delays, and this edition of the Report was not issued till August 1864, but it gave Miss Nightingale opportunity of organizing yet another press crusade.

    Through Sidney Herbert's friend, Count Strzelechi, who was also a friend of Delane, she was able to secure a series of articles in the Times on the sanitary needs of India.[26] The Count was very proud of what he had been able to do for her. None of Miss Nightingale's official works obtained a wider circulation than the "Observations"; nor, I suppose, did any Blue-book on such a subject ever attain a greater amount of publicity.

    [22] Bibliography A, No. 34.

    [23] Miss Nightingale's letter to Lord Shaftesbury is printed in his
    Life, p. 581.

    [24] This was not designedly a practical joke. The Clerk to the
    Commission held a post in the Board.

    [25] See Bibliography A, No, 33 (3).

    [26] A leading article appeared on August 23, introducing a series of
    "special articles" which began on the following day.

    VI

    But all this was only a preliminary. Public attention had been aroused, and every one said vaguely that something must be done. It remained for Government to do it. The steps which Miss Nightingale took to this end, the obstacles which she encountered, the measure of success which she attained, will be described in the next chapter.

    The work, which has been described in foregoing pages and which Miss Nightingale continued during the following year, was very heavy, and it was all done under grievous physical disability. In 1857-58, when she was doing like work in connection with the Royal Commission on the Home Army, though she was in very delicate health, she had yet been able to move about. When Sidney Herbert could not come to see her, she could go to see him. But now in 1863, when work for the Commission on the Indian Army was at its height, she was bedridden.

    When she invited a nursing friend to her house, the formula was "Will you come and spend Saturday to Monday in bed with me?" She could only receive her visitors, if at all, in her own room, and all her writing was done in bed. She was sustained through these disabilities partly, it may be, by the consciousness of power and by satisfaction in its exercise, but principally by passionate devotion to her cause. And there was another feeling which gave her strength, as appears from many a passage in her private letters.

    She was carrying out, as best she could alone, the "joint work" which had been left "unfinished" at Sidney Herbert's death. "There is no feeling more sustaining," Sir John McNeill had said to her, when Arthur Clough was also taken from her, "than that of being alone."

    So, in some sort, I think, she found it. And sometimes, as to one who stretches out his hands in yearning for the further shore, there seemed to come to her voices of encouragement. "I heard the other day," she said in 1863, "of two Englishmen who were nearly lost by being caught by the tide on the coast of France, and a little French fisher-girl ran all along the wet sands to show them the only rock, half a mile from the shore, which the tide did not cover, where of course she was obliged to stay with them.

    It got quite dark, the water rose above their knees, but presently they heard a sound, faint and far off, and the little girl said, 'They think the tide is turning, they are shouting to cheer us!' I often think I hear those on the far-off shore who are shouting to cheer me."

    CHAPTER III

    SETTING REFORMERS TO WORK

    (1863-1865)

    I am more hopeful than you appear to be in regard to the good
    likely to be effected by the Report. Although our Indian
    administration has great difficulties to contend with owing to the
    nature of the country and the people, it is both honest and able;
    and I never knew a public measure, the advantage of which was
    generally admitted, which ultimately was not properly taken in
    hand.--SIR CHARLES TREVELYAN (Letter to Florence Nightingale,
    Aug. 24, 1862).

    In the last chapter we traced Miss Nightingale's hand throughout the famous Report of the Indian Sanitary Commission. We saw how she worked for the inclusion, in the Commissioners' recommendations, of machinery for getting the other recommendations adopted; we saw, too, how cleverly she man[oe]uvred to obtain wide publicity and discussion for the whole subject. But this was not enough for her.

    She had created a favourable atmosphere; she had provided suitable machinery; it remained to set the wheels going round. "Reports are not self-executive": she applied her words in this fresh direction; and, as in the case of the Home Commission five years before, so now she gave not a moment's rest to herself or to anybody else whom she could influence until reforms, recommended by the Report, were set on foot.

    Miss Nightingale was as eager, in as great a hurry to begin, as determined to have her way, as before; but the difficulties were now greater. In the case of the Home Army, only one department (though that, to be sure, was a dual one) was concerned; in the case of Sanitary measures for the Army in India, there were the India Office and the Government of India to be considered as well as the War Office. And everybody, who knows anything about public affairs, knows what it means to the cause of prompt efficiency if departments begin wrangling with each other. And then Miss Nightingale had no longer her "dear master."

    Lord Stanley, the Chairman of the Indian Commission, was friendly, and sincerely desirous to see things done; but he was not an enthusiast. His temperament was cool; his judgment, critical. But, as I have already said, he had a great belief in Miss Nightingale, and though she did not always find him an easy man to drive, she did it. The moment the Report was signed she was up and at him. He must do as Sidney Herbert did; that is, go at once to Ministers and insist on immediate steps being taken to put the recommendations of the Report into operation. Otherwise, all their labour might dissolve in air. Lord Stanley proposed to wait and see:--

    (Lord Stanley to Miss Nightingale.) July 10, 1863. ... Do not
    fear that Lord Herbert's work will be left unfinished: sanitary
    ideas have taken root in the public mind, and they cannot be
    treated as visionary. The test of experience is conclusive. The
    ground that has been gained cannot be lost again.----July 12....
    The first step is to ask what the War and India departments will
    do. If on consideration they consent to the appointment of the
    commissions recommended with or without modification of our plan,
    the thing is fairly started. I am inclined to believe that they
    will be found willing.

    But we must give them time to read the
    report. If they object to do anything, other methods may be tried.
    We have friends in the Indian Council, and Lord de Grey is a
    Sanitarist. I quite agree in what you say as to its being a duty to
    help the ministry of the day in working out their plans.
    Practically I have acted on this rule. Few matters pass in the
    India Office that do not come before me. But such help cannot be
    offered by an outsider--it must be asked by those who are
    responsible. If Sir C. Wood desires assistance in giving effect to
    the sanitary projects, I will not refuse it.

    There is ample time to
    consider all this.

    So Lord Stanley was waiting to be asked. Then it became Miss Nightingale's business to contrive that he should be asked. She saw Lord de Grey, begged him to go forthwith to the India Office, and to suggest to Sir Charles Wood that he should talk matters over with Lord Stanley.

    The thing was done:--

    (Lord Stanley to Miss Nightingale.) July 24. I have had several
    conversations with Sir C. Wood, and from the language he now holds,
    I consider it settled that the report of the commissioners will be
    acted upon--the W.O. Commission being enlarged for the purpose of
    dealing with Indian questions. I have also arranged with him for
    the settlement of all personal claims arising out of our
    enquiry.[27] I hope, therefore, that we may look on our work as
    done for the present.

    It is probable that difficulties will arise
    out of the conflicting claims of the Indian and home authorities:
    but these we must be prepared for, and deal with as they come
    up. So far, all has gone well.

    [27] Mr. Herbert had promised, but apparently only by word of mouth,
    that the services rendered by Dr. Farr and Dr. Sutherland to the
    Commission should be paid. Miss Nightingale was able to confirm the
    promise.

    The Duke of Newcastle wrote to her to like effect (Aug. 31): "The Report on the Indian Army is attracting much attention, and I have no doubt it will do a great deal of good, tho' there is supposed to be still a very strong obstructive power in the India Office." For a time, it seemed as if official measures would be taken with reasonable celerity. Two members, to represent India, were added to the Barrack and Hospital Improvement Commission. The Secretary for India sent a dispatch (Aug.

    1. suggesting the formation of Sanitary Commissions as recommended in

    the Report. Miss Nightingale was asked to draft a code of suggestions which might be sent out to India. But soon there was a hitch. The military element in the India Office quarrelled with the Report, and it was intimated that there might be similar criticism from the military element in the Government of India. The accuracy of Dr. Farr's statistics was to be impugned; and it was to be objected that Miss Nightingale's "Observations" did not in all cases reflect the present state of the Indian stations.

    As if reports, which had taken and must have taken months and months to collect, could possibly have been brought up to the last moment! And as if the mere fact that such reports had been called for was not likely to lead to some improvement! These things need not detain us. They were, as Miss Nightingale put it, "the Crimea over again," "these and those" protesting that things were not so bad as they had been painted, and that in any case it was not A who was to blame, but B. But meanwhile everything was hung up.

    Lord Stanley, the Chairman of the Commission, whose Report was impugned, was in the country. Miss Nightingale "urged and baited him" (so she described it) to come up to London and return to the charge. He came in November, and had an interview with her before seeing Sir Charles Wood.

    II

    And now an event occurred which was followed by results of consequence to her cause. Lord Elgin, the Viceroy, while travelling in the Himalayas, was stricken down by a heart complaint from which he was not expected to recover. The question of a successor became urgent. The minds of many turned to Sir John Lawrence, but, with one exception, no Indian civilian since Warren Hastings had permanently held the office of Viceroy. Miss Nightingale had unbounded admiration for him. The soldier's heart in her loved his heroic deeds.

    "What would Homer have been," she once said, "if he had had such heroes as the Lawrences to sing?"[28] Personal intercourse had filled her with closer admiration for what Lord Stanley called "a certain heroic simplicity" in the man, for his unaffected piety, his rugged honesty, his deep sympathy with human suffering. In later years a photograph of Watts's portrait of Lawrence always hung in Miss Nightingale's room.

    At the moment with which we are now concerned, she regarded him as the indispensable man for India, not more on account of the threatening border war on the north-west frontier (the consideration which doubtless most moved Lord Palmerston), than on account of his sympathy with the cause of sanitary reform. An opportunity came for putting in her word. Sir Charles Wood consulted his predecessor at the India Office, and Lord Stanley in turn talked matters over with Miss Nightingale.

    She urged him with fervent eagerness to do everything in his power to promote the appointment of Sir John Lawrence. Lord Elgin died on November 20. Lawrence was appointed on November 30, and was to start for India immediately:--

    (Lord Stanley to Miss Nightingale.) Dec. 1. I saw Sir C. Wood
    yesterday. The sanitary question was gone into, tho' not so fully
    as I could have wished. Sir J. Lawrence's appointment is a great
    step gained. He knows what is wanted, and has no prejudices in
    favour of the existing military administration. I shall see him
    to-night and shall probably be able to have some talk with him on
    the subject. But why should not he see you? The plans are in the
    main yours; no one can explain them better: you have been in
    frequent correspondence with him.

    I believe there will now be but
    little difficulty in India.... Let me repeat--you must manage to
    see Sir John Lawrence. He does not go till the 10th. Your position
    in respect of this whole subject is so peculiar that advice from
    you will come with greater weight than from anyone else.

    [28] Letter to Harriet Martineau (Feb. 2, 1865).

    Miss Nightingale was among the first to offer congratulations to the new Viceroy; the terms in which she addressed him expressed what she sincerely and intensely believed:--

    (Miss Nightingale to Sir John Lawrence.) Among the multitude of
    affairs and congratulations which will be pouring in upon you,
    there is no more fervent joy, there are no stronger good wishes,
    than those of one of the humblest of your servants. For there is no
    greater position for usefulness under heaven than that of the
    government of the vast Empire you saved for us. And you are the
    only man to fill it. So thought a statesman with whom I worked not
    daily, but hourly, for five years, Sidney Herbert--when the last
    appointment was made.

    In the midst of your pressure pray think of
    us, and of our sanitary things on which such millions of lives and
    health depend.[29]

    [29] From the Life of Lord Lawrence, by R. Bosworth Smith, 1885,
    vol. ii. p. 278.

    Prompted by Lord Stanley, Miss Nightingale asked the new Viceroy to call. He was the first of a succession of high Indian officials who made a point of coming to Miss Nightingale before leaving for their posts.

    The interview took place on December 4. Miss Nightingale never forgot either the interview itself or Lord Stanley's kindly anxiety that it should take place. Thirty years later (Feb. 17, 1893), in sending Aitchison's Memoir of Lord Lawrence to Sir Harry Verney, she wrote: "How many touches--short but sweet--I could add to the book! The real tale of Sir J. Lawrence's appointment as Viceroy will never be told. During the only ten days left to Lawrence before he started, he came to see me. How kind it was of Lord Stanley. He came like a footman to my door, and, without giving his name, sent up to ask whether Sir John Lawrence was coming.

    The interview was one never to be forgotten."

    Sir John Lawrence discussed the sanitary question with Miss Nightingale in all its bearings, and they exchanged views further by correspondence before he left London:--

    (Miss Nightingale to Dr. Farr.) Dec. 10. I have had the great joy
    of being in constant communication with Sir John Lawrence, and of
    receiving his commands to do what I had almost lost the hope of
    being allowed to do--viz. of sending out full statements and
    schemes of what we want the Presidency Commissions to do. I should
    be glad to submit to you copies of papers of mine which he desired
    me to write and which he took out with him, as to the constitution
    of the Presidency Commissions, if you care to see them. They are,
    of course, confidential.

    I have also seen Lord Stanley more than
    once during these busy days. And with Sir John Lawrence's command,
    we feel ourselves empowered to begin the Home Commission,[30] and
    to further our plans upon it. Sir John Lawrence, so far from
    considering our Report exaggerated, considers it under the mark.

    [30] That is the Barrack and Hospital Improvement Commission (Army
    Sanitary Committee), reinforced by India Office representatives,
    which was to issue Sanitary Suggestions for the Government of India.

    Thus was preparation made for putting the Report into execution in India. During Lawrence's Viceroyalty, Sir Bartle Frere was governor of Bombay. "Men used to say," he told Miss Nightingale, "that they always knew when the Viceroy had received a letter from Florence Nightingale: it was like the ringing of a bell to call for sanitary progress."

    III

    Within a month of his arrival in India, Sir John Lawrence had set the Sanitary Commissions on foot, and nothing was wanting except hints and instructions from home:--

    (Sir John Lawrence to Miss Nightingale.) CALCUTTA, Feb. 5
    [1864]. I write a line to say that we have commenced work by
    establishing our Sanitary Committees for Calcutta, Madras, and
    Bombay. They are composed of five members. A Civilian is at their
    head, and a Medical Officer as Secretary. I hope that you will
    expedite the transmission to India of the codes and rules and plans
    which have been approved of for home and the colonies. We shall
    then have an idea in a practical shape of the main features of the
    sanitary system, and can readily adapt it to the peculiar
    circumstances of the country.

    Without such a guide we shall often
    be perhaps working in direct opposition to your views. Where we
    differ, it will become our duty to set forth the grounds for so
    doing, in sending our plans and reports home. Pray excuse this
    hurried scrawl, and believe me, Sincerely yours, JOHN LAWRENCE.

    It was not Miss Nightingale's fault that this plea for expedition was necessary. In December 1863 Lord de Grey had again asked her to draft a letter to the India Office, as from the War Office, on the measures recommended by the Royal Commission, and she had done it. But days, weeks, months passed, and nothing happened. In January 1864 her "Suggestions in regard to Sanitary Works required for the Improvement of Indian Stations,"[31] written at the urgent request of the Governor-General, were ready, Dr. Sutherland, Dr. Farr, and Mr.

    Rawlinson collaborating with her. Again months passed and nothing happened. The Barrack and Hospital Improvement Committee had been officially informed in December of the appointment of the Indian members, and requested to report on any matters which might be referred to it by the Secretary for India or the Secretary for War; but as yet no Indian reference had been made. Miss Nightingale chafed sorely at the needless delay. The Governor-General wrote to her again and again pressing for the Suggestions.

    She had done her part long ago; the War Office had been in possession of her Draft for months. She tried plain pressure, and pressure barbed with sarcasm. "Poor man!" she wrote in forwarding to the War Office one of the Governor-General's letters (March 10); "he really expects despatch. He thinks we can write a letter in three months! He must be more fit for a Lunatic Asylum than for a Governor-Generalship." Or, when the Government had been having a close division in the House,[32] she tried to play the India Office against the War Office.

    "You will all be 'out' this session," she wrote to the War Office (March 7, 1864); "after which I shall be able to get what I like from Lord Stanley [I.O.], but you will not be able to get what you like from Gen. Peel [W.O.]. It is therefore very desirable that this letter should be written now at once while you are still 'in.'" It turned out that the reason of the delay was this: the War Office had sent a preliminary letter to the India Office, and the India Office resented it.

    Sir Charles Wood, it was explained to Miss Nightingale, had "snubbed" Lord de Grey. The War Office was sulking in its tents accordingly. The India Office, on its part, was standing on its dignity, and was not going to place itself in the humiliating position of taking action proposed to it by the War Office. And this was the reason why Miss Nightingale's Suggestions, for which the Governor-General was asking, were still pigeon-holed.

    As for minor recommendations in the Royal Commission's Report, it was quite true that many of them could be carried out by administrative order, and some of them were; but the difficulty in the case of others was that it had hitherto passed the wit of man to discover with whom the power, or the responsibility, of making the order lay. Well may Miss Nightingale have written, as she did in more than one letter of this time (Jan.

    1864): "No impression in all my life was ever 'borne in upon me' more strongly than this, that the Ministers have never considered the respective jurisdictions of the W.O. and the I.O., and that I.O., W.O., Horse Guards at home, Commander-in-Chief in India, Governor-General in India are as little defined as to the respective powers and duties as if India were the Sandwich Islands."

    [31] Bibliography A, No. 24.

    [32] On March 1, on a debate on the Yeomanry, the majority had been 1.

    On the major matter, the dispatch of sanitary suggestions to guide the Indian authorities, Miss Nightingale now resolved that the delay should come to an end. She had drafted an ultimatum to the War Office, threatening an attack in the House of Commons, when Lord Stanley, a prominent member of the Opposition, appeared on the scene.

    He had forewarned Miss Nightingale, as we have heard, that departmental jealousies would cause some delay; but seven months had now passed since the Report of his Commission had been issued, and he seems to have thought that this was time enough to allow for the two offices to let off steam between themselves. He wrote to Miss Nightingale suggesting that he should come to see her, and offering, if she approved, to put pressure either upon Lord de Grey or upon Sir Charles Wood.

    Miss Nightingale loyally gave her friends at the War Office a last chance, but they did not care to take it. Lord Stanley saw Sir Charles Wood accordingly, promised him parliamentary support in any action which he might take, and matters were at last arranged. Miss Nightingale's draft "Suggestions" were submitted to the Barrack and Hospital Improvement Commission, and with slight alterations were adopted by that body.

    It was a War Office Commission, but the dignity of the India Office was consulted by the statement on the title-page of the Blue-book, that the Suggestions had been prepared by the said Commission "in accordance with Letters from the Secretary of State for India in Council." The fact was that they were prepared by Miss Nightingale in accordance with the wishes of Sir John Lawrence.

    When once the "Suggestions" had been passed officially, it was within her power, by the simple expedient of laying in a stock of early copies, to prevent a moment's further delay. She used the power; and could not deny herself a few genial taunts at her official friends. "I beg to inform you," she wrote to Captain Galton at the War Office (Aug.

    8), "that by the first mail after signature I sent off by H.M.'s book-post, at an enormous expense (I have a good mind to charge it to you!), to Sir John Lawrence direct no end of copies of Suggestions (also to the Presidency Commissions); and that, as he is always more ready to hear than you are to pray (you sinners!), I have not the least doubt that they will have been put in execution long before the India Office has even begun to send them."[33] She was not far wrong; six or seven weeks elapsed before the official copies were sent,[34] and meanwhile Miss Nightingale was able to get in another gibe.

    She heard from Sir John Lawrence that he had ordered the Suggestions to be reprinted in India. "It might be as well," she wrote to the War Office, "to hurry your copies for the India Office, who will otherwise receive them first from India."

    [33] This was no idle taunt. The Government of India had already put in
    force some of the recommendations of the Royal Commission before it
    had officially received copies of the Report: see above, p. 34 and
    n.

    [34] Miss Nightingale conducted a secret inquiry, which would have done
    credit to a detective-inspector, into the causes of this delay.
    According to "information received," the first cause was that the
    final printing order was delayed while communications went to and
    fro between the War Office and the India Office upon the number of
    copies required. Then the supply ultimately ordered by the latter
    passed leisurely from one sub-department to another.

    Finally, the
    stock reposed a while at a warehouse across the water, until there
    were sufficient official papers to fill certain regulation cases of
    a regulation size.

    IV

    In India itself, advance, with Sir John Lawrence at the helm, was rapid.

    The President and the Secretary of each Sanitary Commission were required to devote their whole attention to the work. They were charged to "consider and afford advice and assistance in all matters relative to the health of the Army, and to supervise the gradual introduction of sanitary improvements in Barracks, Hospitals, and Stations, as well as in Towns in proximity to Military Stations." Of every step taken, Miss Nightingale was kept informed.

    Sir John wrote to her frequently to report progress; he described to her the condition of all the Stations he had inspected on his way up to Simla; he applied to her for information on special points. His private secretary, Dr. Hathaway, who also had seen Miss Nightingale before he left England, wrote yet more fully and frequently. The President of the Bengal Commission was Mr. Strachey.[35] He, too, had made Miss Nightingale's acquaintance, and they corresponded at great length. Dr. J. P.

    Walker, a surgeon in the Indian Army, was in England in December 1863. He wrote to Miss Nightingale, as a devoted follower of her school. He went out to India, was appointed Secretary of the Bengal Commission, and at every stage consulted her and reported to her. Mr. R. J. Ellis, President of the Madras Commission, and Dr. Leith, President of the Bombay one, also corresponded with her. To any official in India, from the Governor-General downwards, who was ready to listen, Miss Nightingale had much to say.

    The correspondence with Sir John Lawrence is the most interesting:--

    (Sir John Lawrence to Miss Nightingale.) SIMLEH, June 12
    [1864]. It was truly kind of you to write and give me so nice an
    account of my children.... What an exciting time must Garibaldi's
    visit to England have been. He is indeed a noble fellow, and fully
    worthy of all our sympathies. I only trust that he will be
    persuaded to keep quiet and bide his time. A good day for his
    country, if the people only deserve it, must surely come. I am
    doing what I can to put things in order out here; but it is a very
    uphill work, and many influences have to be managed and overcome.

    I
    often think of the last visit I paid you before leaving England and
    of your conversation on that occasion. You will recollect how much
    I dwelt on the difficulties which meet one on every side. These
    have been exemplified in a way I could scarcely understand or
    anticipate, by the good folks of England really believing that I
    had sanctioned an attack on the religion of the Hindoos, because I
    desired to improve the health of the people in Calcutta!

    [35] John Strachey (1823-1907); afterwards Chief Commissioner of
    Oudh, Lieut.-Governor of the N.W. Provinces, financial member of
    the Governor-General's Council; knighted, 1872; G.C.S.I., 1878; and
    member of the Secretary of State's Council.

    (Miss Nightingale to Sir John Lawrence.) 32 SOUTH STREET, Sept.
    26 [1864]. MY DEAR SIR JOHN LAWRENCE--I always feel it a kind of
    presumption in me to write to you--and a kind of wonder at your
    permitting it. I always feel that you are the greatest figure in
    history, and yours the greatest work in history, in modern times.
    But that is my very reason. We have but one Sir John Lawrence. Your
    Bengal Sanitary Commission is doing its work, like men--like
    martyrs, in fact,--and what a work it is! All we have in Europe is
    mere child's play to it.

    Health is the product of civilization,
    i.e. of real civilization. In Europe we have a kind of
    civilization to proceed upon. In India your work represents, not
    only diminished Mortality as with us, but increase of energy,
    increase of power of the populations. I always feel, as if God had
    said: mankind is to create mankind. In this sense you are the
    greatest creator of mankind in modern history....

    Would there be any impropriety in your Sanitary Commissions sending
    copies of their printed Minutes to the Barrack and Hospital
    Improvement Commission here, through the India Office--merely for
    information? As far as your Bengal Commission goes: these men don't
    want urging: they have not now to be taught. Anything which might
    even appear to interfere with the responsibilities of your
    Commissions, unless at their own request, is not only undesirable:
    but, as far as the Bengal Comm^n. is concerned, useless.

    But, if
    you saw no objection to sending the Minutes for information to the
    War Office Commission here, I am sure they would very much like it.
    Or, if that would be too formal and official (as regards the India
    Office here), if they, the Minutes, might be sent to me, with
    permission to shew them to one or two, such as Lord Stanley (our
    late Chairman of the Royal Commission), Dr. Sutherland, and Capt.
    Galton, of the War Office, &c., it would answer the same purpose.
    The India Office here does not shew now the least jealousy of the
    Barrack and Hosp^l. (War Office) Commission.

    On the contrary, one
    can scarcely help smiling at the small things it is glad to throw
    off its responsibility for upon said Commission.

    There are three glaring (tho' lesser) evils in Calcutta about which
    I know you have been employed--lesser tho' they are--and your
    attention and Dr. Hathaway's have been aroused by them. These are:
    (1) The Police Hospitals (or state of Hosp^l. accommodation) for
    sick poor at Calcutta. The Police establishments seem about as bad
    as possible. Indeed the poor wretches are brought in mostly to die.
    The Parisian system of relief is very good: every Police station at
    Paris has means of temporary help in cases of emergency until the
    sufferers can be removed to Hospital.

    Some such arrangement with a
    thorough reform of the Hospitals, and such additional accommodation
    as may be wanted, might meet Calcutta's case.

    (2) The condition of Jails and Lunatic Asylums in India. Certainly
    it is not for me to draw your attention or Dr. Hathaway's to this.
    Probably he knows more about them than any man living. The reports
    and recommendations of one or two of the Jail Inspectors shew that
    they want experience: as I am sure Dr. Hathaway will agree with me.
    Perhaps we might help you by sending out such Reports on the
    subject as may be useful.

    (3) The seamen at the great Ports. You have already done so much.
    But Rome can't be built in a day. Bad water, bad food bought in
    Bazaars, and bad drinks cause a vast amount of disease and death.
    Self-supporting Institutions, such as our Sailors' Homes (of which,
    indeed, I believe you have already founded more than one), would
    give the men wholesome food and drink, and lodgings and day-rooms
    at little cost. So many men perish for want of this kind of
    accommodation at Calcutta, where the evil seems greatest.

    It seems to me so base to be writing while you are doing. Oh that I
    could come out to Calcutta and organize at least the Hospital
    accommodation for the poor wretches in the streets. There is
    nothing I should like so much. But it is nonsense to wish for what
    is an impossibility. I am sure you will be glad to hear that one of
    my life-long wishes, viz. the nursing of Workhouse Infirmaries by
    proper Nurses, is about to be fulfilled.

    By the munificence of a
    Liverpool man (who actually gives £1200 a year for the object, but
    desires not to be named), we undertake next month the Liverpool
    Workhouse Infirmary (of 1000 beds)--the first Workhouse that ever
    has been nursed--with 15 Head Nurses, trained by ourselves, and a
    Lady (Volunteer) Matron (who underwent a most serious course of
    training at our Nurses' School at St. Thomas' Hospital), 15
    Assistants, and 52 ex-pauper women, whom we are to train as
    Nurses.[36] I am sure it is not for us to talk of Civilization.

    For
    I have seen, in our English Workhouse Infirmaries, neglect,
    cruelty, and malversation such as can scarcely be surpassed in
    semi-barbarous countries. And it was then I felt I must found a
    school for Nurses for Workhouses, &c. The opportunity has come too
    late for me to do the Workhouse Nursing myself. But, so it is well
    done, we care not how. I think with the greatest satisfaction upon
    your re-union with Lady Lawrence and (some of) your children. God
    bless you.--I am yours devotedly, FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE.

    P.S.--The Calcutta Municipality does not seem yet to have wakened
    up to a sense of its existence. It does not know that it exists:
    much less, what it exists for. Still, you are conquering India anew
    by civilization, taking possession of the Empire for the first time
    by knowledge instead of by the sword.--F. N.

    [36] On this subject, see below, p. 128.

    The Commander-in-Chief in India, Sir Hugh Rose (Lord Strathnairn) was hardly less helpful in the cause than the Governor-General. The War Office had sent to him, through the Horse Guards, a letter inviting his attention to the regimental recommendations in the Royal Commission's Report. His reply was most sympathetic, and his period of command was marked, amongst other things, by two reforms specially near to Miss Nightingale's desires: he introduced regimental workshops and soldiers' gardens in cantonments.

    The War Office forwarded his letter to Miss Nightingale. "It is quite worth while," she wrote in reply (Aug. 11, 1864), "all that has been suffered,--to have this letter from Sir Hugh Rose. And I forgive everybody everything." "I sing for joy every day," she had written previously (June 6), "at Sir John Lawrence's Government." She made public thanksgiving.

    To the Social Science Congress at Edinburgh in October 1863, she had contributed a paper, entitled, "How People may Live and not Die in India," in which she gave, in concise and popular form, a résumé of the Royal Commission's Report. The reading of her paper had been followed by "Three Cheers for Florence Nightingale." She now (Aug.

    1864) republished the Paper, with a Preface, in which, as it were, she gave "Three Cheers for Sir John Lawrence." She described how the Commissions of Health had been appointed in India, and how they had now been put in possession of all the more recent results of sanitary works and measures which had been of use at home.

    Then she turned to the military authorities, and described how "several of the worst personal causes of ill-health to which the soldier was in former times exposed have been, or are being, removed." "The men," she wrote, "have begun to find out that it is better to work than to sleep and drink, even during the heat of the day. One regiment marching into a Station, where cholera had been raging for two years, were chaffed by the regiments marching out, and told they would never come out of it alive.

    The men of the entering battalion answered, they would see; we won't have cholera, they think. And they made gardens with such good effect that they had the pleasure, not only of eating their own vegetables, but of being paid for them too by the Commissariat. And this in a soil which no regiment had been able to cultivate before. And not a man had cholera.

    These good soldiers fought against disease, too, by workshops and gymnasia."[37] She gave account of trades, savings' banks, games, libraries; noting what had been done and what yet remained to be done. "In the meantime the regulation two drams have been reduced to one. A Legislative Act imposes a heavy fine or imprisonment on the illicit sale of spirits near cantonments.

    Where there are recreation rooms, refreshments (prices all marked) are spread on a nice clean table." All these things, which in 1864 were new or exceptional, became in later years well-established and the rule. The main causes of disease among the Army in India were, however, as Miss Nightingale went on to say, want of drainage, want of proper water-supply, want of proper barracks and hospitals. But in these respects she had set the reformers to a work which has continued from that day to this.

    [37] This incident was told in Sir Hugh Rose's letter.

    There was, indeed, some criticism at the start, but this touched only the past, and did not seriously affect the future. Indian officials felt aggrieved, as I have already said, at the strictures contained in the Report of the Royal Commission, and this movement came to a head in two documents--one, a counter-Report by Dr. Leith, the Chairman of the Bombay Sanitary Commission (Oct. 1864); the other, a dispatch (Dec. 8) from the Government of India (Sir John Lawrence on an important point dissenting). Lord Stanley thought that Dr.

    Leith ought to be answered at once, and wrote to Miss Nightingale (Oct. 25) for her advice on the subject. She suggested that the answer should be sent in the form of a Report on Dr. Leith's letter by the Barrack and Hospital Improvement Commission--an ingenious plan, as it gave opportunity to that expert body for giving further advice to one of the Presidency Commissions.

    Miss Nightingale and Dr. Sutherland drafted the Report, which was adopted by the Commission on January 6, 1865. "I have pleasure," wrote Lord Stanley to her (Dec. 26), "in sending back the draft reply to Dr.

    Leith with only one or two verbal amendments suggested. It seems to me well done, moderate in tone, and conclusive in argument." A reply to the Indian Government's Dispatch, signed by Lord Stanley, Dr. Farr, and Dr.

    Sutherland, was sent on May 20. Miss Nightingale in her eagerness was much annoyed by these criticisms,[38] and Lord Stanley often told her that she made too much of what were only temporary ebullitions. "Don't be discouraged, dear Miss Nightingale," he wrote (Jan. 22) when the Government of India's dispatch arrived; "the practical work may go on while the controversy is proceeding.

    My idea of the matter is that the Indian authorities only want time to set things a little in order--that they are willing to mend, but not inclined to give us the credit of having first put them in the right way. That is human nature." Lord Stanley was a true prophet.

    The Indian authorities did mend; and so successfully has the work been carried out by a long line of Commanders, Administrators, and Engineers that the death-rate from preventable disease among the British Army in India has fallen far below the figure which the Royal Commission named as a counsel of perfection.[39]

    [38] If any reader should desire to follow up the criticisms and the
    replies, he will find the Reply to Dr. Leith in Parliamentary
    Papers, 1865, No. 329; and the Government of India's dispatch
    with the Reply, in Nos. 108 and 324. Dr. Leith's Report does not
    appear to have been reprinted as a Parliamentary Paper. A copy of
    it, printed at Bombay, 1864, is among Miss Nightingale's papers.

    [39] The Commission looked forward to a rate of not more than 10 per
    1000. The rate in 1911 was, as already stated, 5.04.

    V

    In this work of "salvation" Miss Nightingale was for many years to play a part as consultant, and sometimes as inspirer. In November 1864 the Governor-General in Council intimated his readiness to consider a scheme for the employment of nurses in Military Hospitals, and thereupon the Bengal Sanitary Commission requested Miss Nightingale to aid them by her advice. She wrote in collaboration with Sir John McNeill a comprehensive series of Suggestions in the following February.[40] Throughout the year (1865) Miss Nightingale was engaged from time to time in Indian sanitary business; and her house served as headquarters for the sanitary reformers. Mr.

    Ellis, the President of the Madras Commission, came home in the middle of the year in order to study sanitary reforms in this country. Miss Nightingale invited him to use her rooms; sent Dr.

    Sutherland to accompany him on visits of inspection to hospitals and barracks; arranged meetings between him and Lord Stanley; conferred with him on changes which Sir John Lawrence was proposing to make in the constitution of the Presidency Commissions. The Governor-General himself communicated with her freely on the same subject. The Secretary of the Bengal Commission applied to her for information on trustworthy tests for the discovery of organic matter in water. Being unable to obtain what was wanted from Dr. Parkes, she applied to Dr.

    Angus Smith (inventor of an air-test also), who wrote a pamphlet for her on the subject. It was printed at her expense. She had it approved by the War Office Sanitary Committee, and a large number of copies was distributed throughout India. She had impressed upon the Governor-General the importance of stirring up the Indian municipalities.

    The Indian Towns Municipal Improvement Bill (1865) was submitted for her criticism, and she wrote a "Note on the relations which should exist between the powers of raising and spending taxes proposed to be granted to local authorities, and the proper execution of sanitary works and measures in India." Her friend, Sir Charles Trevelyan, retired from the post of Financial Minister in India in 1865, and she made the acquaintance of his successor, Mr. W. N. Massey.

    She was very jubilant when she "got a vote of seven millions for my Indian barracks." She was depressed when the Governor-General wrote to her from time to time saying that the great obstacle in the way of speedier reform was want of money; but she made excuses for her hero. "Sir John Lawrence," she wrote to Madame Mohl (March 20, 1865), "is just as much hampered with the Horse Guards out there as I am here. He is always writing to me to apologize for the little progress he makes.

    By the very last mail he says I shall think him 'timid and perhaps even time-serving.' I could not help laughing.

    Certainly Sir J. Lawrence is the only man who ever called Sir J.

    Lawrence a time-server,--except in the highest possible sense, of serving his country at her greatest time of need in the highest possible way." She was constantly corresponding with Lord Stanley, urging him to win points for her from the Indian Secretary. "I have just seen Sir Charles Wood," wrote Lord Stanley (Feb. 10).

    "He agrees as to the expediency of sending home a yearly report of the sanitary stations in each Presidency." "Pray never speak of being troublesome," he wrote again (May 15): "it is a real pleasure to me to help you a little in the great work: I know no other way in which my time can be made equally useful." He frequently saw Sir Charles Wood on matters which she urged, and he won what was almost her highest praise.

    "Lord Stanley," she said, "is a splendid worker." His cool common sense was perhaps a wholesome antidote sometimes to her almost feverish eagerness. "Publicity," he said (Aug. 17), "will in the long-run do what we want. People won't stand being poisoned when they know it." The annual Reports from the Presidencies, obtained by Miss Nightingale some years later (p.

    155), were submitted for her "Observations"; and in many other ways, as we shall hear, it was remarkable how close a touch upon the course of sanitary reform in India was maintained by this lady from a bedroom in Mayfair. But essentially Miss Nightingale's work was that of inspirer and pioneer. These chapters will have shown, I think, that a compliment paid to her by the Chairman of the Indian Sanitary Commission was no less true than graceful:--

    (Lord Stanley to Miss Nightingale.) ST. JAMES'S SQUARE, July 25
    [1864]. I don't wonder that the delays of the "savage tribe" should
    try your patience; and I admire the more the care and success with
    which you keep outward show of annoyance to yourself. I had rather
    be criticised by any one rather than you! I am only passing through
    town to-day, there being nothing left to do; but shall be again in
    this place on Thursday, and ready to wait upon you if any matters
    want settling.

    If not, I can only wish you health--success is sure
    to come--and beg that you will remember the value of your own
    public service, and not by overwork endanger its continuance. Pray
    excuse a caution which I am sure I am not the first to give. Every
    day convinces me more of two things: first, the vast influence on
    the public mind of the Sanitary Commissions of the last few
    years--I mean in the way of speeding ideas which otherwise would
    have been confined to a few persons; and next, that all this has
    been due to you, and to you almost alone.

    [40] Bibliography A, No. 44. For the subsequent fate of this scheme, see
    below, p. 157.

    In one of many moments of vexation at the delays of the "savages" in their red-tape, Miss Nightingale wrote thus to Captain Galton (June 23, 1864): "The Horse Guards say that they were quite aware of Sir John Lawrence's application and of the delay, but that 'it is Sir J.

    Lawrence's one and only object of interest, while it is one out of a thousand of the War Office's.' They ought to have the V.C. for their cool intrepidity in the face of truth. I have told Sir J. Lawrence of the opinion of these dining-out freliquets as to his hard work. And I think I shall publish it after my death." But "unlicked cubs," as she said at Scutari, "grow up into good old bears"[41]; and it is not in order to pay off a score against the "puppies" that I quote this letter.

    Behind the remark which excited Miss Nightingale's righteous anger there was an element of unconscious truth, and it is one which sums up this and the preceding chapter. It was, indeed, an ignorant untruth to say that Sir John Lawrence had no other work or interest than the promotion of sanitary improvements for the Army in India; and it would be untrue also, as later chapters will show, to say the same thing of Miss Nightingale.

    Yet it made all the difference for the promotion of that work in India that there was at the head of affairs a man whose heart and soul were in it. And at home, it made all the difference that there was one resolute will, combined with a clear head, determined to give impetus and direction to the work. It was probably quite true to say that to many, perhaps to most, of the men at the War Office and the Horse Guards this question of Army sanitation in India appeared as only "one out of a thousand" questions.

    To Miss Nightingale it was, in a very literal and instant sense, a matter of life and death; and it was her passionate conviction that supplied the initiating and driving force which compelled reform. If the Governor-General of the time had been hostile or apathetic, even her persistence might yet have been foiled.

    But, as things were, the co-operation between Sir John Lawrence and Florence Nightingale was as beneficent in its results upon the welfare of the British Army in India, as the co-operation between her and Sidney Herbert had been in the case of the Army at home.

    [41] See Vol. I. p. 184.

    CHAPTER IV

    ADVISORY COUNCIL TO THE WAR OFFICE

    (1862-1866)

    We are trying to reduce chaos into shape. It is three years to-day
    since I first felt what an awful wreck I had got myself into. I
    interfering with Government affairs; and the captain of my ship,
    without whom I should never have done it, dying and leaving me, a
    woman, in charge. What nonsense people do talk, to be sure, about
    people finding themselves in suitable positions and looking out for
    congenial work! I am sure if any body in all the world is most
    unsuited for writing and official work, it is I.

    And yet I have
    done nothing else for seven years but write Regulations.--FLORENCE
    NIGHTINGALE (Letter to Julius Mohl, Jan 1. 1864).

    Though Miss Nightingale's main work during these years was connected with the Army in India, she was also continuously engaged in work for the War Office in relation to the army at home. Indeed in some respects the work was as constant, and it was quite as varied, if not as far-reaching in range, as in the days when Sidney Herbert was Secretary of State.

    She was a kind of Advisory Council to the War Office on all subjects within her sphere, and on some outside it; but the references to her were far more frequent than is commonly the case with those somewhat shadowy bodies; and besides she was a privileged person, with the right of initiating suggestions. The picture of her relations to the War Office as it is disclosed in her papers is remarkable. There are scores of letters from the Ministers. There are hundreds from one of the (non-political) Under-Secretaries.

    Her own letters in reply are equally numerous. There is a large collection of Drafts, Minutes, Warrants, Regulations. Her private letters tell of frequent interviews with one of the Ministers. Was there ever another case in which nearly every vexed question in War Office administration (other than of a purely military kind) was referred almost as a matter of course to a private lady, and that lady an invalid in her bed?

    It is not likely that the situation will ever exist again; and it becomes of interest to trace "the Nightingale power" in this matter to its sources.

    • * * * *

    The primary explanation is simple. In a large class of questions which were occupying the attention of the War Office at this time Miss Nightingale was regarded as the first expert of the day. One sees this in the fact that she was consulted in connection with work, within her sphere, for other departments than the War Office. Thus in 1865 Mr. R.

    S. Wright (afterwards the judge) was appointed by the Colonial Office to prepare a Report on the condition of Colonial Prisons. He went to Miss Nightingale, asking (April 27) "to be allowed to submit to you for your criticism the conclusions at which I may arrive. Supposing them to be approved by you, it will be a great advantage if I may state that you approve them."[42] Then, in the second place,--to repeat a phrase which I have already applied to her, she was the official legatee of Sidney Herbert.

    Everyone who was behind the scenes knew that his work had also been her work, and Sidney Herbert's repute as a reformer stood very high. The official Army world at this time was divided into two camps--those who desired to complete Herbert's work, and those who tried to undo it. Miss Nightingale, as the repository of the Herbert tradition, was the indispensable ally of the former party against the latter.

    Her friend, Lady Herbert, put the case from her point of view, when she wrote (March 7, 1862), in reply to a letter telling of much weakness and weariness, "If you never wish to live for your own sake, yet bear to live, dearest, for a time to carry out his work, and to keep his memory fresh in the hearts of men." Some questions of reform arose to which Sir Benjamin Hawes had raised copious objections.

    "Would Miss Nightingale oblige the Political Under-Secretary by suggesting an answer to Hawes's points?" Sometimes she was the only person who possessed the necessary documents. "Have you got a copy of the Report of the Committee on the Organization of a Medical School? The War Office actually have no copy, and the Army Medical Department only a proof not signed and supposed to have been altered?"

    [42] Miss Nightingale must have enjoyed the correspondence that ensued;
    for not only was Mr. Wright sound on sanitary matters ("it is no
    part of a prisoner's sentence that he should be black-holed"), but
    he wrote to her in a racy style. "I send you (Oct. 23) a specimen
    of the materials sent home by colonial prison authorities with the
    endorsement of a colonial Governor:--Question: What is the mode
    of treating lunatic or maniacal prisoners? Answer: Maniacles is
    not nor ever has been in use in this prison."

    But besides all this there were personal factors in the case. Miss Nightingale had no longer, it is true, an intimate friend at the head of the War Office, and with Lord Herbert's successor, Sir George Lewis, she was not otherwise than by correspondence acquainted. Early in 1862 he had made overtures through Sir Harry Verney, desiring to be given the honour of making Miss Nightingale's personal acquaintance. She was, however, too ill to receive him, and knowing perhaps her proficiency in the classics he sent her some of his jeux d'esprit.

    The offering had anything but a propitiatory effect. Many of her letters express indignation that the Secretary for War should be writing trifles in Latin instead of reforming the War Office. She was equally indignant when he presently published learned works on Ancient Astronomy and Egyptology. Mr. Jowett was somewhat of the same mind: "I agree with you about Sir G. Lewis and his book.

    I felt the same disgust at Gladstone for writing nonsense about Homer while the East India Bill was passing through the House." It does not seem to follow, however, that Mr. Gladstone would have been the more interested in the East India Bill if he had not been engaged in finding the Trinity on Mount Olympus, or that Sir George Lewis would have been any more in the mood to reorganize the War Office if he had not been applying the Egyptological method to modern history, or turning "Hey diddle diddle" into Latin verse.

    There is a keener point in another of Miss Nightingale's reflections on the Minister (Feb.

    19, 1863): "If Sir George Lewis, instead of writing a 'Dialogue on the Best Forms of Government' would write (or rather silently act) a Monologue on the Dual Form being the Worst form of Government, the War Office would be much the gainer." But during his term of office the Under-Secretary was Lord de Grey; and with him she was on very friendly terms, and he, as is obvious from the correspondence, had the highest opinion of her knowledge, her ability, and her influence.

    The part she played in Lord de Grey's appointment as Secretary of State, after the death of Sir G. Lewis, has already been described. Then in Captain Galton she had throughout these years a standing ally within the War Office, and her daily attendant, Dr.

    Sutherland, was a member of the Army Sanitary Committee. And in the last resort, if a difficulty worthy of such adjustment arose, she had the ear of the Prime Minister.

    II

    Such occasion did arise when, on May 15, 1862, death removed from the War Office Miss Nightingale's old opponent Sir Benjamin Hawes, the Permanent Under-Secretary. She had tried to reorganize him into insignificance in 1861, but "Ben had beaten Sidney Herbert."[43] Now was a chance of carrying out the plan which Mr. Herbert and she had often discussed--of breaking the bureaucracy, and of dividing up the office.

    Hitherto the Departments had reported through the Permanent Under-Secretary; the reform scheme was that they should report direct to the Secretary of State. Sir E. Lugard, Military Under-Secretary, was already in part-possession. Let Captain Galton resign his commission, and take the other half, as a civilian (and, what was equally in her mind, a convinced and professional sanitarian). She carried the case to the Prime Minister, and convinced him. Lord Palmerston told her afterwards that when the appointment was first mentioned to the Horse Guards they said it was "simply impossible." But the Prime Minister advised Sir George Lewis to make the appointment nevertheless:--

    (Miss Nightingale to her Father.) 9 CHESTERFIELD STREET, Poor
    Queen's Birthday
    , 1862. I must tell you the first joy I have had
    since poor Sidney Herbert's death. Lord Palmerston has forced Sir
    G. Lewis to carry out Mr. Herbert's and my plan for the
    reorganization of the War Office in some measure. Hawes's place
    is not to be filled up. Galton is to do his work as Assistant
    Under-Secretary. This brings with it some other reforms. Lord de
    Grey says that he can reorganize the War Office with Captain
    Galton, because Sir G. Lewis will know nothing about it and never
    inquires.

    Sir G. Lewis wrote it (innocently) to the Queen
    yesterday, and Captain Galton was appointed to-day, resigning the
    Army of course. No, Sir Charles Trevelyan would not have done at
    all [in Hawes's place].

    It would have been perpetuating the
    principle (which I have been fighting against in all my official
    life, i.e., for eight years) of having a dictator, an autocrat,
    irresponsible to Parliament, quite unassailable from any quarter,
    immovable in the middle of a (so-called) constitutional government,
    and under a Secretary of State who is responsible to Parliament.
    And, inasmuch as Trevelyan is a better and abler man than Hawes, it
    would have been worse for any reform of principle. I don't mean
    to say that I am the first person who has laid down this.

    But I do
    believe I am the first person who has felt it so bitterly, keenly,
    constantly as to give up life, health, joy, congenial occupation
    for a thankless work like this.... It has come too late to give
    happiness to Galton, as it has come too late for me. He seems more
    depressed than pleased. And I do believe, if he feels any pleasure,
    it is that now he can carry out Sidney Herbert's plans in some
    measure. And it may seem to you some compensation for the enormous
    expense I cause you that, if I had not been here, it would not have
    been done. Would that Sidney Herbert could have lived to do it
    himself!

    Would that poor Clough could have lived to see it! He
    wished for it so much--for my sake....

    [43] See Vol. I. p. 405.

    The high hopes which Miss Nightingale entertained from this slight reorganization were doomed to disappointment. Neither as Under-Secretary, nor after April 1863, when he became Secretary of State, did Lord de Grey manage, and I do not know that he seriously attempted, to reform the War Office root and branch.[44] He and Captain Galton had, according to Miss Nightingale, "miscalculated their power."

    She preached the necessity of reform to them unceasingly--in season and, as they may sometimes have thought, out of season too, for she was a very persistent person; and, with Dr. Sutherland's assistance, she provided them with detailed schemes. Her principles were as admirable, as was her criticism scathing when any breach of them came under her notice.

    There must in all things, she said, be a clear definition of responsibility, with a logical differentiation of functions; and the business of the War Office was to prepare for war--not to jog along with an organization which might hold together in peace, but would break down in the field. Some papers were submitted to her criticism (June 1862). "What strikes me in them," she wrote, "is the black ignorance, the total want of imagination, as to a state of war in which the War Office seems to be.

    Really if it was a Joint Stock Company for the manufacture of skins, it could not, as far as appears, be less accustomed to contemplate or to imagine or to remember a state of war." I am afraid that most of us have lived through times when the same criticism could have been made. Let us hope that it is all a matter of ancient history now. Papers were sent to her dealing with the questions of Purveying and Commissariat. The Commissariat had hitherto been the bankers of the army, and some of the permanent officials saw no reason for a change.

    From her experience in the Crimea she gave them the reason. The confusion of functions worked badly in the field.[45] As it was bound to do, for it was absurd. "Is a man who buys bullocks the best man to be a banker? Would it not be better to have a separate Treasurer for the Army to receive all moneys and issue them to all departments? In private life nobody makes his steward or butler his banker. It would not be economical. Finance is as much a specialty as marketing, and as much so, to say the least of it, in the Army as in private life."

    [44] There is a succinct account of organizations and reorganizations
    between 1854 and 1868 in a Memorandum on the Organization of the
    War Office
    by Captain Galton, dated November 1868.

    [45] See Vol. I. p. 231.

    III

    Complete reform of the War Office was, then, to remain a task for the future; but Miss Nightingale thought that Lord de Grey and Captain Galton did the administrative work well. Much of it was done with her assistance. From Miss Nightingale's point of view, the most important thing done under the Lewis-De Grey régime was the placing on a permanent footing of the Barrack and Hospital Improvement Commission. It was important, first, as keeping sound sanitary principles to the forefront in the execution of new works at home.

    It also, as already explained, provided machinery for promoting sanitary improvements in India. The point, next to its permanence, on which she most insisted was that the Commission should not be under the Army Medical Department, but should be directly responsible to the Secretary of State. "Lord de Grey said," wrote Captain Galton (June 25, 1862), "that he had adopted exactly your Minute about the Instructions to the Commission." With its Secretary, Mr. J. J. Frederick, Miss Nightingale was on very friendly terms, and Dr.

    Sutherland was its most active member. Most of the plans for new barracks or hospitals were submitted to her, and her inspection and criticism of them were searching. Then in 1862 the Government was about to build a new Military General Hospital at Malta. With Dr. Sutherland's aid, she went into every detail, and her Report on the plans occupies twenty-four pages of manuscript.

    In 1865 Sir Hope Grant succeeded Sir Richard Airey as Quarter-master General, and in that capacity as chairman of the Barrack Commission, the name of which was now changed to the Army Sanitary Committee. He went to see Miss Nightingale, "proud to think that she remembered him"; and the conversation must have been satisfactory; for "our new President is a Trump," reported Dr.

    Sutherland to her.

    In examining plans, she always had a thought for the horses. When the plans for some cavalry barracks were sent for her criticism she put in a plea (June 4, 1863) for windows in the loose-boxes out of which the horses could see. "I do not speak from hearsay," she wrote to Captain Galton, "but from actual personal acquaintance with horses of an intimate kind. And I assure you they tell me it is of the utmost importance to their health and spirits when in the loose-box to have a window to look out at. A small bull's-eye will do. I have told Dr.

    Sutherland but he has no feeling." To which Dr. Sutherland added: "We have provided such a window and every horse can see out if he chooses to stand on his hind legs with his fore-feet against the wall. It is the least exertion he can put himself to, and if your doctrine is right, he will no doubt do it." Miss Nightingale had learnt to love the army horse in the Crimea. Many years later, some very bad barracks were closed in Ireland, and men and horses were moved to the Curragh. It was the horses, she wrote, who had done it.

    "If we are not moved, they said, we shall mutiny. Military horses are quite capable of organizing movements. Did you ever hear of Jack? Jack was a riderless horse (his master having been killed) at the Charge of Balaclava. And he was seen collecting about 30 riderless horses, and at the head of his troop leading them back to, I suppose, Cavalry Headquarters. I have failed to discover whether Jack allowed horseless men to mount some of his horses.

    These men certainly returned on horseback--but when they found that a comrade, or an officer, was missing, they rode back, one and another, mounted the wounded man, and fought their way out of the Russian melée, but many died in the attempt--a glorious death. And when I see in the hansom-cabs horses who by their beautiful legs must have been hunters or even racers, galloping up Park Lane as long as they can stand, I say too 'a glorious death'; and horses should teach us, not we them, duty--do you think."[46]

    [46] Letter of April 12, 1896, to Mrs. Henry Bonham Carter.

    All regulations for military hospitals and for their nursing staff were similarly submitted to Miss Nightingale. She had a poor opinion of the capacity of the male mind to frame rules for female nurses. "By the united skill," she wrote (Feb.

    16, 1863), of "Mess^{rs.} ---- and ----, the following Regulations for Female Hospitals were put together:--(1) Kennel your nurses and chain them up till wanted; (2) When the number of Patients does not exceed----, chain up the Nurses without food; (3) Let the number of Nurses vary every day as the number of Patients varies. I send you an amended copy which, if you approve, might be put into type." She was constantly appealed to in connection with disputes caused at Netley by the difficult temper of Mrs.

    Shaw Stewart, the Superintendent of the Female Nursing Staff. She and Miss Nightingale were no longer close friends, but Miss Nightingale's sense of justice was strong, and she continuously supported Mrs. Stewart's authority.

    IV

    Another large batch of the semi-official correspondence is concerned with Miss Nightingale's favourite child, the Army Medical School, and with the position of the Army doctors generally. The troubles of the professors were still many; the relation of the School to the Secretary of State on the one hand, and to the Army Medical Department on the other, was much vexed; and, when the School was moved to Netley (1863), a fresh set of difficulties cropped up.

    Miss Nightingale was constantly appealed to, sometimes by the staff, sometimes by the War Office, to smooth over difficulties, to suggest ways out, to settle disputed questions. She was recognized by the War Office as a kind of super-professor. One of the staff sought official sanction for a book on the work of the School: "Lord de Grey wants to know whether he is capable; also whether his proposed syllabus is good. Also to have any critical suggestions upon it which Miss Nightingale could kindly communicate." Her verdict was favourable.

    I have been told that some Army doctors of to-day, knowing little about Miss Nightingale except that she found fault with medical arrangements in the Crimea, suppose her not to have been their friend. Nothing could be further from the truth. What she blamed was not the doctors (for most of whom she had the greatest admiration), but the system. From first to last, she was the most efficient friend that the Army Medical Service ever had.

    In 1862-63 there is a long series of letters from her to the War Office, in which she persistently pleaded for improvement in their status and emoluments.

    It was in connection with this matter that she wrote to Captain Galton (Dec. 24, 1863): "In re Medical Warrant, I am meek and humble, but 'I cut up rough.' I am the animal of whom Buffon spoke, Cet animal féroce mord tous ceux qui veulent le tuer. You must do something for these doctors; or they will do for you, simply by not coming to you." A series of letters to Sir James Clark in the following year shows with what pertinacity she fought the battle of the Army doctors, and how indignant she was at any slights cast upon them:--

    April 6 [1864].

    I have written threatening letters both to Lord
    de Grey and to Captain Galton about the [Medical Officers']
    Warrant; and after pointing out that both restoration of Warrant
    and increase of pay are now necessary, I have shown how, when we
    are exacting duties from the Medical Officer, such as sanitary
    recommendations to his Commanding Officer, which essentially
    require him to have the standing of a gentleman with his Commanding
    Officer,--we are doing things, such as dismounting him at parade,
    depriving him of presidency at Boards, etc., which in military
    life, to a degree we have no idea of in civil life, deprive him of
    the weight of a gentleman among gentlemen.

    April 7. The W.O. seem now willing to listen to some kind of
    terms. They are frightened. They sent me your letter. It was very
    good, very firm. Don't be conciliatory.

    April 9. I wrote for the tenth time a statement of eight pages,
    with permission to make any use of it they pleased, with my
    signature, as to Lord Herbert's intentions. But I positively
    refused to write to Mr. Gladstone, who certainly ought not to grant
    me what the Secretary of State of War does not urge.

    April 11. What is wanted is to put a muzzle on the Duke of
    Cambridge, and to tell him that he must not alter a Royal
    Warrant.

    April 15. You may think I am not wise in being so angry. But I
    assure you, when I write civilly, I have a civil answer--and
    nothing is done
    . When I write furiously, I have a rude
    letter--and something is done (not even then always, but only
    then
    ).

    In the following year there was a debate in the House of Lords upon the Military Hospitals which greatly interested, and personally affected, Miss Nightingale. Early in March Lord Dalhousie (the Lord Panmure of earlier days)[47] gave notice of a motion to call attention to the expenditure on the Netley Hospital and the Herbert Hospital respectively, and it was rumoured that the ex-Minister intended to deliver a set attack upon two of his successors, the late Lord Herbert and Lord de Grey.

    The War Office, in order to be fully prepared, sent to Miss Nightingale for a brief. She gladly supplied it, and she entered into the fray with great spirit. She was very angry that the memory of her "dear master" should be assailed, but I think that she enjoyed not a little the prospect of yet another encounter with "the Bison." She had beaten him before, and was determined that he should be beaten now. She advised Lord de Grey to avoid giving an advantage to the enemy by withholding any credit to which he was justly entitled.

    She recalled that at the last time they met, Lord Panmure had complained to her that she ascribed every sanitary reform in the Army to Sidney Herbert, though some of the reforms had been started by himself. She admitted, and advised Lord de Grey to admit, that Lord Panmure had deserved well of the Army by the measures which he took in the Crimea, and by initiating some steps for reducing the mortality at home. These things being admitted, the defence of Lord Herbert would carry the more weight.

    Having armed the Secretary of State with materials to meet any attack that might be made, Miss Nightingale turned to organize a second line of defence. Sir Harry Verney was dispatched to ask Mr. Gladstone's advice.

    Mr. Gladstone thought that Lord Harrowby should be retained for the defence, and he was approached. Miss Nightingale sent watching briefs also to her own friends, Lord Shaftesbury and Lord Houghton.[48] When Lord Dalhousie's motion was taken, the rumours turned out to be well founded.

    He extolled his Netley (the non-"pavilion" hospital) as perfect, and criticized the Herbert Hospital ("pavilion") as a costly toy in the "glass-and-glare" style, and in a long speech attacked the "wasteful" system which Lord Herbert had introduced by paying attention to "hygienists who had carried their opinions too far." He had, I suppose, "that turbulent fellow," Miss Nightingale, in his mind when "he could not help thinking that all these unnecessary knick-knacks in hospitals were introduced partly from the habit, which prevailed at the War Office, of consulting hygienists not connected with the army." The personal animus in the attack was thought so obvious that the speech fell very flat.

    And Lord de Grey's reply--"quite admirable" according to Miss Nightingale--was so courteous, yet so conclusive, that her "counsel" were unanimously of opinion that not another word was necessary. Apart from any personal question, Lord Dalhousie's speech[49] has a certain historical interest as embodying some of the prejudices against which Miss Nightingale as a Hospital Reformer had to contend.

    A little later in the year a military attack on the sanitarians was threatened in the House of Commons, but this only took the form of questions about the vote under which payment by the War Office to Dr.

    Sutherland appeared.[50] Miss Nightingale sent a note to the War Office, setting forth the facts and emphasizing the value of his services in the cause of sanitary improvement.

    [47] He had succeeded to the earldom of Dalhousie on the death of his
    cousin, the 10th earl and first marquis, in Dec. 1860.

    [48] Mr. R. Monckton Milnes had been created Baron Houghton in 1863.

    [49] It is in Hansard on March 6, 1865.

    [50] Hansard, June 19 and 30, 1865.

    V

    These were subjects in which Miss Nightingale was directly concerned, but questions of many other kinds were referred to her.

    I find in the correspondence with the War Office during these years that, in addition to matters otherwise mentioned in this chapter, her advice was asked upon such subjects as an Apothecaries' Warrant, barracks for Ceylon, "Fever Tinctures," Instructions for Cholera, fittings for Military Hospitals, the proposed amalgamation of the Home and Indian Medical Services, the organization of Hospitals for Soldiers' Wives, Sanitary Instructions for New Zealand, revision of soldiers' rations, staff appointments at Netley, appointment of West Indian staff surgeons, an outbreak of Yellow Fever in Bermuda, the relation of Commissariat Barracks and Purveying at Foreign Stations, victualling on transports and the Mhow court-martial.[51] On one occasion she was asked to send hints for a speech in the House of Commons.

    Lord Hartington, then Under-Secretary for War, would have to defend a large increase in the votes for Hospital and Medical Service. The Crimean War and Miss Nightingale's crusade had raised the expenditure from £97,000 in 1853-54 to £295,000 in 1864-65. "Could you send me a paragraph for Lord Hartington's speech," she was asked, "to show the salient points of what the nation gets for its money? Something pithy, put in your best manner." "There is nothing in the world I should like so much," she replied (Feb.

    29, 1864), "as to have to do Lord Hartington's speech and stand in his shoes on such an occasion." She sent some pithy comparisons; and, in case the Minister wanted something heavier, a detailed memorandum. I suppose Lord Hartington chose the heaviness and rejected the pith; for when Miss Nightingale read the parliamentary report, she thought the speech a poor performance.[52] The same kind of references to Miss Nightingale went on when in 1866, on Lord de Grey's transference to the India Office,[53] Lord Hartington became Secretary of State for War.

    "Can you throw light," she was asked (June 21, 1866), "on the position of the medical officers of the Guards? This is very pressing. The whole matter is an awful mess, and Lord Hartington is anxious to leave it in some way of settlement." On the following day a lucid and exhaustive Memorandum on the subject went in from her.

    [51] The history of this affair, which excited a prodigious interest in
    Parliament and the press, may be read by the curious in vol. xxxiii.
    of the Parliamentary Papers of 1863, and vol. xxxv. of those of
    1864. Miss Nightingale's good offices were asked by the War Office
    to parry an attack by "Jacob Omnium," for whose part in the affair
    see Essays on Social Subjects, by Matthew John Higgins, 1875,
    pp. lvi.-lx.

    [52] It certainly was dull: see Hansard, March 3, 1864.

    [53] See below, p. 108.

    In July 1864 Miss Nightingale was engaged on a piece of work for the War Office which was closely associated with her Crimean experiences and with her European repute. It was in August of that year that the international congress was held which framed the famous Geneva Convention. The British delegates were Miss Nightingale's friend, Dr.

    Longmore, and Dr. Rutherford, and she drafted their Instructions. The principle of the Convention was the neutralization of the wounded under the Red Cross. Societies formed under the Red Cross were soon organized throughout Europe, and the movement led to a great development of volunteer-nursing in war time.

    Sometimes Miss Nightingale sent in suggestions on her own account. She was in close touch with soldiers and sailors, and a woman's sympathetic insight appears in this letter:--

    (Miss Nightingale to Captain Galton.) Sept. 21 [1863]. People
    are complaining that when a Regiment sails, many of their wives and
    children are left behind, and the soldiers are unable to make any
    provision for their support until they have reached their
    destination, say China or Calcutta (after a four months' voyage
    round the Cape), and have been able to send money through their
    Captains to their families at home. Meanwhile the families have
    gone through five or six months of distress.

    For sailors leaving a
    port in England or Ireland, the Admiralty provides power to leave a
    standing order that a certain amount of pay is to be sent regularly
    to their families. The W.O. objects that a similar arrangement
    would "involve a change in their book-keeping." It would involve no
    change. It would involve a small addition. I am willing to go the
    length of 6d. to furnish an account-book to the W.O., which would
    enable them to keep these additional accounts. The W.O. also
    objects that it would deprive the Captain of the chance of fining
    the soldiers for any military offence.

    But they can learn the
    Admiralty system; and whilst there are other ways of "doing" the
    soldiers, their pay is the only means of providing bread for their
    families starving (or doing worse) at home. Surely the soldiers
    might be allowed to leave, for the probable duration of their
    voyage, and for a month or two beyond it, a sum to be paid weekly
    to their representatives at home. Sir E. Lugard has been tried and
    failed. Pray set this right. But the W.O. would not be the W.O., if
    such things as these were not. And when they have ceased to be, the
    War Office will have ceased to be.

    Satire was not the only weapon which Miss Nightingale employed in order to get things done. Sometimes she appealed to the motive of rivalry. Was the Minister hanging back? Well, all she could say was that Sidney Herbert would have done the thing in a moment. There were difficulties in the way, were there? The subordinate officials were piling up what they were pleased to call "reasons" to the contrary, were they?

    Well, "on this day many years ago," she wrote (June 18, 1862), "the French guns kept coming up again and again to get us out of the yard at Hougomont, and we answered in strong language, often repeated, till we kept the ground that we had won. I never heard the French guns called reasons. And I advise you to answer in the same way, because there is no other way of answering. Lord de Grey's Minute is the gun which just has to be fired over again." And sometimes she resorted, as of old, to a little bullying.

    "I send you," she wrote (March 26, 1863), "my protest about the Medical School. Make what use of it you like. But, if we fail, I shall refer it to Lord Palmerston who, as you know, befriended us on a former occasion (after Hawes's death)"--a home thrust, this, as it was by a personal reference to Lord Palmerston that she had secured Captain Galton's appointment.

    There was one occasion when, for a wonder, the pressure to be prompt and decided came not from her, but from the War Office. The Governorship of the Woolwich Hospital fell vacant; she had been sent a list of names with a request to advise upon them, and she had not immediately replied. "I wrote," she explained (Feb. 11, 1863), "to various authorities the very moment your and Lord de Grey's letters were put into my hands. The answers cannot be long delayed. But what would you think of my opinion if I volunteered it about men whom I know only by name?

    Had you asked me about Lord William Paulet or Colonel Storks or Sir Richard Airey, I could have given you an opinion off-hand with the utmost want of modesty. The very moment I have any reliable information you shall have it. But it takes some time to make such an inquiry, or what would it be worth? And Woolwich, I suppose, is not on fire, or with the enemy at the gates?" But for some reason or other, the War Office was in a hurry, and the appointment was made before her inquiries were completed.

    Her conscientiousness thus lost her the chance of deciding a piece of patronage. Not, indeed, that she felt any loss in such a case. She was nothing of a jobber. She pulled wires, as I have told, in some special appointments where she believed that a high public cause was at stake; but she was never actuated by personal favouritism, or by the love of personal influence on behalf of individuals. For this very post, she had received fifty letters of application, she said, but she had taken no action upon them.

    Only once, she said on another occasion, had she solicited anything as a personal favour from the War Office. It was an appointment for a Presbyterian Chaplain, who was not personally known to her, but whose hard and deserving case (as she thought it) had been brought to her notice. She was once sent a list of the Army Medical Service, and asked by a Minister to mark the names, for his private and confidential use, with her approbation or otherwise. This she respectfully declined to do.

    When she was asked a specific question about an officer whom she had known in the Crimea or elsewhere, she gave an opinion freely, and generally managed to put it pointedly; as of a certain Commandant: "As you often see in those round-headed, red-faced men, he has a great deal of conscience and very little judgment."

    VI

    A subject, in which Miss Nightingale took great and painful interest during these years, was the State regulation of vice. The legislation of 1864, 1866, and 1869 was already being promoted and considered in 1862.

    The subject was odious to Miss Nightingale, but her experiences in foreign hospitals and at Scutari had made her peculiarly familiar with it. Her private correspondence with doctors and military officers shows that for some years before 1862 she had given much thought and study to the question, and had carefully tested conclusions drawn from her personal observations by statistics and by the opinions of other persons.

    She hated the system of regulation on moral grounds, but she was equally convinced that the case for it had not been satisfactorily established by statistical evidence on hygienic grounds. On this point, two of the medical men, upon whose judgment she placed most reliance--Dr. Sutherland and Dr. Graham Balfour (the head of the Army Statistical Department)--agreed with her.

    With their assistance she worked up the case against the continental system, and at the request of Sir George Lewis, who was considering the matter in 1862, she wrote a private paper, which was circulated among some members of the Government and others. "Your facts," wrote Captain Galton to her (April 29, 1862), "have shaken Lord de Grey's views on the subject of police inspection."

    With Mr. Gladstone, she was less successful. He found her Paper "of deep interest and full of important fact and argument," and said that, as a result of reading it and her letters, he should approach the subject "with much of circumspection as well as of anxiety"; but he "doubted the possibility of making a standing army a moral institution."

    Therein she profoundly differed, and she urged, in rejoinder, that nothing should be done on his assumption, at least until the other had been given a fair trial--by increasing the soldiers' facilities for marriage, by giving them better opportunities for instruction and recreation, by encouraging physical exercise and manual handicrafts.

    Official opinion steadily hardened, however, in the direction of regulation; and presently public opinion was tested by a series of articles in the Times in favour of the continental system. Miss Nightingale thereupon supplied Harriet Martineau with facts and figures, and the Times was answered by the Daily News. Miss Nightingale also printed her own Paper for a more extended, though still "private and confidential," circulation. Dr.

    Sutherland chivalrously assumed the sole authorship, and was acrimoniously attacked by some of his professional brethren. The Army Medical Department was working hard for regulation, and some person therein, suspecting Miss Nightingale as the real leader of the opposition, disgraced himself by sending her an anonymous letter of vulgar abuse. This of course did not deter her, and, when legislation was proposed, she lobbied indefatigably (through correspondence) against it. The opinion of the House of Commons was, however, overwhelmingly in its favour.

    When the legislation was passed, the War Office invited her assistance in the selection of medical officers under the Act; but she refused to touch what she regarded as an accursed thing. It was left to another of the remarkable women of the nineteenth century, to secure, after a struggle of sixteen years, the repeal of the Acts; but though Miss Nightingale shrank from taking a public part in that crusade, she gave support privately to Mrs. Josephine Butler. At a later time, however, Miss Nightingale somewhat modified her views.[54]

    [54] Below, p. 408.

    Miss Nightingale's failure during the years 1862-64 to arrest the movement of public opinion in the direction which she detested, increased her eagerness to promote what she considered the more excellent way. She was the life and soul at headquarters of the movement for increasing the supply of Reading-rooms, Soldiers' Clubs, Recreation-rooms, and facilities for useful employment. "I will tell you," she wrote to the Reverend Mother of the Bermondsey Convent (Jan.

    3, 1864), "how I spent my Christmas Day and the Sunday after, those being two holidays: in preparing a scheme, by desire of Lord de Grey, for employing soldiers in trades." She wrote a Memorandum on "Methods of Starting an Exhibition (Soldiers' Trades)," and such an exhibition was held at Aldershot in the summer of 1864.[55] Whenever there was a difficulty to be overcome, or an opportunity to be seized, Miss Nightingale was appealed to. For instance, there was a fight for a certain disused Iron House at Aldershot.

    Miss Nightingale's party (supported at the War Office) wanted it for a Men's Recreation Room; the Horse Guards wanted it for an Officers' Club. A promise had already been given in favour of the former, but Sir George Lewis was wavering. "Lord de Grey thinks," wrote Captain Galton (April 29, 1862), "that the best course for the Iron House is for Sir H. Verney to ask Sir G. L. in the House about it, alluding to his former promise, and if it could be arranged that Monckton Milnes, Gen.

    Lindsay, or any other persons could cheer or support the proposals, it would pledge Sir G. L. to act at once." Miss Nightingale set her parliamentary friends to work, and the fight for the Iron House was won. Lord de Grey succeeded in getting a vote on the Estimates for the encouragement of such places. Miss Nightingale revised for him a set of Regulations for Reading-Rooms. She also, at his request, drew up (in concert with Captain Pilkington Jackson) an inventory of the appropriate furniture and other fitments.

    Her zeal in this matter was known abroad; at Montreal and Halifax and Gibraltar commanding-officers who were trying to start or develop instructions of the kind applied to her. She often succeeded in obtaining War Office grants for them, and these she supplemented by gifts of her own. No inconsiderable portion of her resources at this time went in subscriptions of this sort, either in money or in kind (carpentering equipment, bagatelle boards, books, prints, and the like).

    It is pleasant to read the letters in which the non-commissioned officers and men of regiments, which had been served by Miss Nightingale in the Crimea, sent thanks, through their commanding officers, to "that noble lady for her continued interest in the welfare of the British soldiers."

    [55] Attention was called to it, and the moral was pointed, by a leading
    article in the Daily News (July 8), doubtless written by Harriet
    Martineau.

    It was a cause of great pleasure to Miss Nightingale that in 1864 her old friend of the Scutari days, General Storks, who had encouraged her there in work of this kind,[56] was appointed to the command at Malta. "I am very grateful to you," he wrote (Nov. 10), "for seeing me the other day, and can only express the great gratification I experienced on that occasion. I can never forget the time when I was associated with you in the great work which has produced such satisfactory results, and for which the whole army will ever thank you. When one reflects on the condition of the soldier ten years ago

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2
    Author
    Sir Edward Tyas Cook
    Release date
    July 16, 2012 [eBook #40058]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Jeannie Howse, Jens Nordmann, Bryan Ness and
    Most recently updated
    November 27, 2024
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by Jeannie Howse, Jens Nordmann, Bryan Ness and
    the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
    http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images
    generously made available by The Internet Archive/Canadian
    Libraries)
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
                         THE LIFE OF FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE
    
    
                            MACMILLAN AND CO., LIMITED
                      LONDON · BOMBAY · CALCUTTA · MELBOURNE
    
                               THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Life of Florence Nightingale, vol. 2 of 2
    
    Author: Sir Edward Tyas Cook
    
    
            
    Release date: July 16, 2012 [eBook #40058]
                    Most recently updated: November 27, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/40058
    
    Credits: Produced by Jeannie Howse, Jens Nordmann, Bryan Ness and
            the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
            http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images
            generously made available by The Internet Archive/Canadian
            Libraries)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #40058. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 40058
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.