
Gutenberg · ebook 38655
Principles of Political Economy, Vol. 2
by Wilhelm Roscher · English · public domain in the US
SECTION CXLIV.
RECEIPTS.--INCOME.--PRODUCE.
The idea covered by the word receipts (Einnahme) embraces all the new additions successively made to one's resources within a given period of time.[144-1] Income, on the other hand, embraces only such receipts as are the results of economic activity. (See §§ 2, 11.) Produce (Ertrag, produit) is income, but not from the point of view of the person or subject engaged in a business of any kind, but from that of the business itself, or of the object with which the business is concerned, and on which it, so to speak, acts.
Income is made up of products, the results of labor and of the employment and use of resources. These products, the producer may either consume himself or exchange against other products, to satisfy a more urgent want.[144-2] Hence, spite of the frequency with which we hear such expressions as these: "the laborer eats the bread of his employer;" "the capitalist lives by the sweat of the brow of labor;" or, again, a manufacturer or business man "lives from the income of his customers,"[144-3] they are entirely unwarranted.
No man who manages his own affairs well, or those of a household, lives on the capital or income of another man; but every one lives on his own income, by the things he has himself produced; although with every further development of the division of labor, it becomes rarer that any one puts the finishing stroke to his own products, and can satisfy himself by their immediate consumption alone. Hence we should call nothing diverted or derived income except that which has been gratuitously obtained from another.[144-4]
[Footnote 144-1: Including of course, gifts, inheritances,
lottery prizes, etc.]
[Footnote 144-2: Thus the original income of the peasant
consists in his corn, of the miller in his flour, of the
baker in his bread, of the shoemaker in his shoes. The money
which circulates among all these and the purchaser, is only
the means of exchanging that part of their products which
they cannot themselves use, for other goods. Money, on the
other hand, was the original income of the producers of the
gold or silver it contains. Compare Mirabeau, Philosophie
rurale, 1763, ch. 3. Adam Smith, II, ch. 2. But
especially, see J. B. Say, Traité II, ch. 1, 5; and
Sismondi, N.
P., I, 90, 376, in which it is correctly
said, that the quality which constitutes anything capital or
income does not inhere in the thing itself, but depends on
the person. Compare, however, I, 148; Hermann, Staatsw.
Untersuch. 297 ff., 33 seq.]
[Footnote 144-3: A fundamental thought in St. Chamans, Du
Système d'Impôt, 1820. Nouvel Essai sur la Richesse des
Nations, 1824.]
[Footnote 144-4: Thus, for instance, the support given by
the head of a family to the members thereof; also gifts,
alms, thefts. Even A. L. Schlözer, St. A., II, 487, will
allow that no one "eats the bread of another," but the
person who has received it from the latter by way of favor
and for nothing. In the case of a rented house, there is
only an exchange of objects of income. The person to whom it
is rented gives up a portion of his, and the renting party
the use of his house. Similarly, in the case of personal
services.
Writers who maintain that only certain kinds of
useful labor are productive, must of course extend the
limits of diverted income much farther. See Lotz,
Handbuch, III, § 133; Rau, Lehrbuch, I, §§ 248, 251.
Cantillon thinks that if no landowner spent more than his
income, it would be scarcely possible for any one else to
grow rich. (Nature du Commerce, 75.) According to Stein,
Lehrbuch, 347, every one gets his income from the income of
other people!]
SECTION CXLV.
INCOME.--GROSS, FREE AND NET.
In all income, we may distinguish a gross amount, a net amount and a free amount.[145-1] The gross income of a year, for instance, consists of all the goods which have been newly produced within that time. The net[145-2] income is that portion of the former which remains after deducting the cost of production (§ 106), and which may therefore be consumed without diminishing the original resources. Only the new values incorporated in the new commodities make up the net income.
Evidently, a great portion of what is considered in one business the cost of production is net income in a great many others; as for instance, what the person engaged in one enterprise in production has paid out in wages and interest on capital. By means of this outlay, a portion of his circulating capital is drawn by others as income, and, on the other hand, a portion of their original income is turned into a portion of his circulating capital.[145-3] Free income, I call that portion of net income which remains available to the producer after his indispensable wants have been satisfied.
An accurate kind of book-keeping which keeps these three elements of income separate is more generally practicable as civilization advances.
We might call it the economic balance. Where commerce is very thriving it is even customary to provide by law that those classes who need it especially should have this species of book-keeping. People in a lower stage of cultivation, with their poetical nature, are unfriendly to such calculations.[145-4] [145-5] And where natural-economy (Naturalwirthschaft) or barter prevails, a book-keeping of this kind of any accuracy is scarcely practicable.
The ratio which net income bears to gross income is a very important element to enable us to judge of the advantageousness of any method of production. If every producer should succeed in consequence of keeping his books in this manner, in determining exactly the cost to him of each of his products, this would be an economic progress similar to that of general spread of good chemical knowledge in the arts.
On the amount of free income, on the other hand, depends all the higher enjoyment of life, all rational beneficence, and the progressive enrichment of mankind.[145-6]
[Footnote 145-1: Similarly in Sismondi, N. P., II, 330,
and Rau, Lehrbuch, I, § 71, a.]
[Footnote 145-2: Called by Hermann, loc. cit., simply
income.]
[Footnote 145-3: This truth J. B. Say has exaggerated to
the extent of claiming that gross and net income are one and
the same so far as entire nations are concerned. (Traité,
II, ch. 5; Cours pratique, III, 14; IV, 74.) But the gross
profit of the entire production of any one year is much
greater than the simultaneous net income of all the
individuals engaged in it. This is accounted for by the fact
that in such production an amount of circulating capital is
invested which was saved from the net profit of previous
economic times.
Compare Storch, Nationaleinkommen, 90 ff.
Kermann, loc. cit., 323 ff.]
[Footnote 145-4: In the East, a valuation by one's self of
his property is considered a guilty kind of pride, usually
punished by the loss of one's possessions. (Burckhardt,
Travels in Arabia, I, 72 ff.) See Samuel, 24, on the
census made by David. The Egyptians, however, as may be
inferred from their monuments, must have very early and very
extensively felt the want of some kind of book-keeping such
as we have mentioned.
A very accurate sort of book-keeping
among the more highly cultured Romans, with a daily
memorandum and a monthly book with entries from the former
(adversaria-tabula expensi et accepti). Compare Cicero,
pro Roscio, com. 2, 3; pro Cluent, 30; Verr., II, 1, 23,
36. The Latin putare, from putus, pure, means: to make
an account clear, and therefore corresponds to the American
provincialism, "I reckon," i. e., I believe; and is a
remarkable proof of a rigid method of keeping accounts.
The
Italian, or so-called double-entry method of book-keeping,
which gives the most accurate information on the profit from
every separate branch of business, became usual among the
nations of modern Europe whose civilization was the first to
ripen, about the end of the fifteenth century. Its invention
is ascribed to the monk Luca Paciolo di Borgo S. Sepolcro.
In England, this kind of book-keeping is very gradually
coming into use even among farmers, while Simond, Voyage
en Angleterre, 2 ed., II, 64, Dunoyer, Liberté du Travail,
VIII, 5, say, "it would in France be considered as
ridiculous as the book-keeping of an apple vendor." In
Germany, there have been for some time past, manufactories
of commercial books.
Besides, the remarkable difference
brought out by the income tax in England between the exact
statements made by large manufacturers, etc., and by those
engaged in industry on a medium or small scale, bears
evidence of the better way in which the former keep their
accounts, the cause and effect of their better business in
general. Compare Knies, in the Tübing. Zeitschr., 1854,
513. On the best mode of determining income, see Cazaux,
Eléments d'Économie publique et privée, Livre, II.
It is
especially necessary to keep an account of the increase or
diminution, even when accidental, of the value of the fixed
capital employed.]
[Footnote 145-5: The Code de Commerce, I, art. 8, requires
that every merchant should keep a journal, paged and
approved by the authorities, showing the receipts and
disbursements of each day, on whatever account, and also the
monthly expenditures of his family. Besides, he is required
to make a yearly inventory of his debits and credits,
subscribe to it and preserve it. That such books were
excellent judicial evidence may be shown by Italian statutes
of the fourteenth century. (Martens, Ursprung des
Wechschrechts, 23.) Those of Germany even in 1449.
(Hirsch, Danziger Handelsgeschichte, 232.)]
[Footnote 145-6: Importance of the so-called "transferring
to credit," where a business man considers his business as
an independent entity and as distinct from himself.]
SECTION CXLVI.
NATIONAL INCOME.--ITS STATISTICAL IMPORTANCE.
Among the most important[146-1] but also the most difficult objects of statistics, that book-keeping of nations, is national income. In estimating it, we may take our starting point from the goods which are elements of income, or from the persons who receive them as income.[146-2]
In the former case the gross national income consists:
A. Of the raw material newly obtained in the country.
B. Of imports from foreign countries, including that which is secured by piracy, as war-booty, contributions, etc.
C. The increase of values which industry[146-3] and commerce add to the first two classes up to the time of their final consumption.
D. Services in the narrower sense and the produce (Nutzungen) of capital in use.
All these several elements, estimated at their average price in money, which supposes that all purchases, especially those under the head D, are made voluntarily[146-4] and at their natural price.
To find the national net income, we must deduct the following items:
A. All the material employed in production which yields no immediate satisfaction to any personal want.[146-5]
B. The exports which pay for the imports.
C. The wear and tear of productive capital and capital in use.
In the second case the net national income is to be calculated from the following items:
A. From the net income of all independent private businesses etc.[146-6]
B. From the net income of the state, of municipalities, corporations and institutions, derived from their own resources.
C. Under the former heads must be taken into the account such parts of property as have been immediately consumed and enjoyed.[146-7]
D. Interest on debt must be added only on the side of the creditor, and deducted from the income of the debtor; otherwise, error dupli. This does not apply to taxes or church dues because the subjects of a good state and members of a good church purchase thereby things which are really new and of at least equal value to the outlay. Besides, in both instances, it is necessary to calculate the number of men who live from the national income, the average amount of their indispensable wants, and the average price in money of the same, in order to determine the free national income by deducting the sum total of these average wants, estimated at this average price.[146-8] [146-9]
[Footnote 146-1: Not only to compare the happiness and power
of different nations with one another, but also for purposes
of taxation, the profitableness and innocuousness of which
suppose the most perfect adaptation to the income of the
whole people.]
[Footnote 146-2: The former, in Rau, Lehrbuch, I, § 247;
the latter in Hermann, 308 ff. The former mode of
calculation gives us a means of judging of the comfort of
the people, their control of natural forces, etc.; the
second, of the relation of classes among the people. (v.
Mangoldt, Grundriss, 99. V. W. L., 316 ff.) Each member of
the nation produces his income only in the whole of the
nation's economy.
Hence Held, Die Einkommensteuer, 1872,
70, 77, would, but indeed only under very abstract fictions,
construct private income from the national, and not vice
versa.]
[Footnote 146-3: On the average degree of this increase of
values in different industries, see Chaptal, De
l'Industrie française, II, passim. Bolz, Gewerbekalender
für, 1833, 111. No such scale can be lastingly valid,
because, for instance, almost all technic progress decreases
the appreciation of values through industry, and every
advance made by luxury raises the claims to refined quality
etc. See Hildebrand, Jahrbücher für Nat-Oek., 1863, 248
ff.]
[Footnote 146-4: Many items in Class D evade all
calculation. Thus, for instance, the numberless cases of
personal services which are enjoyed only by the doer
himself; also the greater number of products
(Nutzungen=usufruct) of capital in use for the consumption
of the owner himself. (Latent income.) Only, it may be, in
the case of dwelling houses, equipages, etc., that the
consumption by use can be estimated in accordance with the
analogy of similarly rented goods.]
[Footnote 146-5: The principal materials consumed in
manufactures are of course not to be deducted here, because
the increase in their value was taken into account above.]
[Footnote 146-6: When an artist who earns $10,000 per annum
appears in a country, the gross national income increases in
a way similar to that in which it increases when a new
commodity is found which would have a yearly increase of
value equal to $10,000 over and above that of the raw
material. Cost of production in the case of such a virtuoso
is scarcely to be alluded to. Nearly his entire income, with
the exception of his traveling expenses, etc., is net, and
the greater portion of it free.
An income tax would affect
his hearers after as it did before, and in his income, find
a completely new object. Per contra, see Saggi economici,
I, 176 f.]
[Footnote 146-7: For purposes of taxation, where a relative
valuation is more the question than an absolute one, it
would be sufficient to assume that every household consumed
clothing, utensils, etc., in proportion to the rest of their
income. Hence, these items might, unhesitatingly, be omitted
altogether.]
[Footnote 146-8: Mathematically demonstrated by Fuoco,
Saggi economici, II, 102 ff.]
[Footnote 146-9: The gross income of British Europe is
estimated by Pebrer, Histoire financière et statistique
générale de l'Empire Br., 1834, II, 90, at £514,823,059,
viz.: agriculture, £246,600,000; mining, 21,400,000;
manufactures, after deduction made of the raw material,
£148,050,000; internal and coast trade, £51,975,060; foreign
commerce and navigation, £34,398,059; banking, £4,500,000;
interest from foreign countries, £4,500,000. By Moreau de
Jonnés, Statist de la Gr.
Br., 1837, I, 312, it is
estimated at 18,000,000,000 francs, from which, however, the
raw material used in industry is not deducted.
The net
income of Great Britain was estimated by Pitt, in 1799, at
£135,000,000, of which £25,000,000 were received by
landowners for rent, £25,000,000 by farmers, £5,000,000 were
tithes, £3,000,000 from forests, canals, and mines,
£6,000,000 from houses, £15,000,000 from state funds,
£12,000,000 from foreign commerce, £28,000,000 from inland
commerce and manufactures, £3,000,000 from fine arts,
£80,000,000 from Scotland, £5,000,000 from foreign
countries. (Gentz, Histor. Journ., 1799, I, 183 ff.)
Lowe, England in its present Situation, 1822, p. 246,
speaks of 255,000,000.
About 1860, the incomes subject to
taxation alone, that is, all above £100, amounted to
335,000,000. The remainder was certainly worth one-half of
this. (Statist. Journ., 1864, 121.) Baxter, in 1867,
assumed it to be £825,000,000. Compare L. Levi, on
Taxation, 6.
In France, about forty years ago, according to Chaptal,
Doudeauville, Balbi and others, about 6,500,000,000 francs
gross national income could be counted on. Schnitzler
speaks of 7,000,000,000 francs (Creation de la Richesse en
France, 1842, I, 392), after deduction made of the raw
material of manufacture. According to Wolowski,
Statistique de la Fr., 1847, it was more than 12,000,000,000
francs. M. Chevalier, Revue des deux Mondes, March 15,
1848, has it 10,000,000,000 at most. In these four
estimates, only material products are taken into account.
Ch.
Dupin thinks the income per capita was, in 1730, = 108
francs; in 1780, = 169; in 1830, = 269. Cazeaux, Eléments,
163, estimated the net national income, in 1825, at
5,000,000,000 francs; Cochut, in 1861, at 16,000,000,000.
(Revue des deux Mondes, XXXVII, 703.)
In Spain, Borrego, Nationalreichthum, etc. Spaniens, 1834,
33, estimated the income from agriculture at 2,284,000,000
francs; from industry, etc., 361,000,000; commerce,
124,000,000; from houses, 186,000,000; canals, streets etc.,
8,500,000; personal services, 75,000,000; money in
circulation (probably loaned capital), 85,000,000.
In the United States, in 1840, the national income was
estimated at over $1,063,000,000; from agriculture, over
$654,000,000; from manufactures, nearly $240,000,000;
commerce, almost $80,000,000; mining, over $42,000,000; from
lumber (Wäldern), almost $17,000,000; and from the
fisheries, almost $12,000,000. The per capita amount of
income was $62. It was largest in Rhode Island--$110; in
Massachusetts it was $103; in Louisiana, $99; and in Iowa,
smallest, $27; in Michigan, it was $33. Compare Tucker,
Progress of the United States, 195 ff.
The census of 1860
assumes the national wealth, slaves not included, at
$14,183,000,000, that is $451 per capita, with a per capita
annual income of $112. According to Czörnig, the gross
income of Austria, from agriculture, the chase and
fisheries, in 1861, was 2,119,000,000 florins; from mining,
41,000,000; from the industries, 1,200,000,000.
In Prussia,
the net national income, not including the revenue from
state property, nor the income of the royal household,
seems, from the returns of the income and class tax, to
have been about 2,458,000,000 thalers, in 1874. Engel,
Preuss. Statist. Ztschr., 1875, 133. The majority of the
above estimates are obviously unreliable.]
SECTION CXLVII.
NATIONAL INCOME.--ITS STATISTICAL IMPORTANCE. [CONTINUED.]
The question frequently discussed, whether it is more advantageous to increase the gross income or the net income[147-1] of a people, may be readily answered with the assistance of our tripartite division. Since economic production has no other object than the satisfaction of human wants, the mere increase of the gross income of a people is a matter of indifference. An increase of the net income puts a people in a condition to increase either their numbers or their enjoyments.
(See §§ 163 and 239.) The most desirable condition is where both these results are produced. It is fortunate for a people when the free income of the nation increases by reason of the absolute or relative decrease of the cost of production, which adds nothing to enjoyment. But it is politically and morally to be lamented when it increases at the expense of the satisfaction of man's necessary wants, especially if the majority of the people deny themselves in this respect to produce that end.
Sir Thomas More called the sheep of his time, to make place for which so many farm houses were razed to the ground, ravenous beasts, which devoured men and laid waste city and country.[147-2]
[Footnote 147-1: The greater number of writers, at bottom,
understand by this question only whether greater efforts
should be made to increase the wages of the lower classes or
the rent and rate of interest on capital paid to the higher.
(Schmoller, in the Tüb. Zeitschrift, 1863, 22.)]
[Footnote 147-2: The difference between gross and net income
was introduced into the science principally by the
Physiocrates. Vauban (1707) had no conception of it, and
thirty years later a French minister, in his instructions
concerning the levy of the vingtièmes, dimly seeing that
the aggregate amount of the harvest was not clear gain,
ordered, to obtain the latter, that the cost of reaping and
threshing should be deducted. (Dupont, Correspondence of
J. B. Say, 404, éd.
Daire.) By produit net, Quesnay
means the excess of original production over its cost,
considered from the personal point of view of the individual
landowner. This excess, it is claimed, can alone increase
the national wealth and alone support the "steril" class.
The political and military bearing of this very clearly
recognized. (102 ff., éd Daire.) Hence Quesnay, favors it
in every way; by large farming instead of small, by stock
raising on a large scale, supplanting home labor by cheaper
foreign labor, by machinery and the employment of manual
labor, etc.; 91 ff., 200 ff., 274 ff. The elder Mirabeau
teaches even that the goodness of a government or of a
constitution, and even national morality may be inferred
from the amount of the produit net. (Ph. rurale, ch. 5.)
Stewart, Principles, I, ch.
20. Adam Smith gives greater
prominence to the gross income, and grades the principal
branches of national labor according as they increase the
gross product of the nation's economy. (II, chs. 1, 5.)
Similarly, J. B. Say, Traité, ch. 8, § 3; Lauderdale,
Inquiry, 142.
Ricardo thoroughly reacts against this view, and considers
it a matter of indifference whether a net product (interest
on capital and rent) of a given amount be obtained by the
labor of five or seven million other men, so long as only
five million can live on it. (Principles, ch. 26.) Similarly
Ganilh, Systèmes, I, 218 ff.; Théorie, II, 96.
Controverted by Malthus, Principles, II, § 6. Buquoy,
Theorie der Nat.
Wirthsch., 1815, 310 ff. Sismondi has
ridiculed this predilection for the net product which in
Ricardo corresponds with what the Germans call free
product (freien Ertrage), and which, contrary to Ricardo's
own opinion, he calls Ricardo's ideal, saying that according
to him, nothing more was to be desired but that "the king
should remain alone on the island and, by turning a crank
forever, do all the work of England through the
instrumentality of automata." (N.
P., II, 330 ff.) An entire
people should value only gross product. (I, 183.) In his
Etudes, Essai, II: Du Revenu Social, Sismondi
distinguishes as elements of the gross national income: a,
pure capital, the return of outlay; b, that which is at once
both capital and income, and serves as family support
(capital as a necessarily remaining supply, income as the
product of the preceding year); c, net income, the excess of
production over consumption.
The Socialists of our day would prefer to see the whole net
income of a people employed in the satisfaction of the
necessary wants of an ever increasing population. By this
procedure, as a natural consequence, we should witness first
the curtailing of the taxing power, of the funds for the
satisfaction of the more refined wants and of the saving of
capital, nor would it be long before even the existing
generation would experience the bitterness of this "living
from hand to mouth." After a time, even the possibility of
progress and even of mere increase of population would
cease.
Hermann, Staatsw. Untersuch., 297 ff., has better than
almost any one else developed the theory of income, and he
lays most stress on the satisfaction of wants as the chief
aim of public economy. Kröncke, Das Steuerwesen, 1804, 381
ff.; Grundsätze einer gerechten Besteuerung, 1819, 93 f.,
may be considered the predecessor who prepared the way for
him. Compare the profound work of Bernhardi, Versuch einer
Kritik der Gründe die für grosses und kleines Grundeigenthum
angeführt werden, St. Petersburg, 1848.
Many controversies
on this subject may be closed by a more accurate
understanding as to terms. Thus, for instance, when Rau,
Handbuch, embraces in the cost of production the necessary
maintenance of material-workmen, and of those engaged in the
labor of commerce; or when Jacob, Staatswissenschaft, §
496, and Storch, Einkommen, 116 ff., even the necessary
support of every class useful to society, their valuation of
the gross national income is in only apparent conflict with
our doctrine on the subject.]
SECTION CXLVIII.
THE TWO PHASES OF INCOME.
In every income which has anything to do with other incomes, it is necessary to distinguish its immediately productive side, and its profit or acquisition side. It is necessary, in the first place, that all the products made by private parties should, so to speak, be put into the common treasury of the national economy, and that each should thence draw his own private revenue. Justice requires that there should be a perfect correlation between the two; that each should enjoy precisely the quota of the national income to the production of which his person or his property contributed.
A just appreciation of the relative productive power of the divers branches of labor constitutes one of the chief bulwarks against the inroads of destructive socialistic theories.
The person who calls a good doctor or a good judge unproductive should, to be consistent, call those who by their greater intelligence are fitted to superintend agricultural and industrial enterprises unproductive, also, as is done by the coarser socialists with their apotheosis of mere manual labor. Unfortunately, such a settlement as is above contemplated among the different factors of production, whose owners are desirous to divide the common product among them, is possible only where the factors of production are either of the same kind, or can be reduced to a common denominator.[148-1] But if justice pure and simple were meted out, no man could subsist.
Love or charity must supplement justice in order to assist those (and especially such as without any fault of theirs) who are not able to produce anything, or enough to supply those wants, for instance, children and the poor.
As the net national income, following the three great factors of all economic production, is divided into three great branches, rent, wages and interest on capital, the net income from any private business may be reduced to one or more of these branches.[148-2] The three great branches of income may be considered with advantage from a great many different points of view.
We may inquire in the case of each of them: concerning its absolute magnitude, its relation to the aggregate national income, to the magnitude of the factor of production, of which it constitutes the remuneration; by what number of men it is shared, and what number of wants it satisfies.[148-3] Lastly, the difference between the amount stipulated for, and the original amount of both rent and wages, as well as the interest of capital, is of special importance.
The former consists in the price paid by the borrower for the use of the factor of production to the owner; the latter in the immediate products which the employment of the same productive power brings on one's own account. Evidently, the original amount is, in the long run, the chief element in the determination of the stipulated amount.
While the former depends more on the deeper and more durably effective elements of price, especially the cost of production, the value in use and the paying capacity of purchasers; the latter is conditioned more by the superficial variations of supply and demand, and even by custom. For our purposes, the former is by far the more important, but, at the same time, by far the more difficult to perceive.
[Footnote 148-1: This is possible between labor and capital,
at least in so far as a comparison can be instituted between
the sacrifice of human rest there is in labor and the
sacrifice of enjoyment in the building up of capital.
But
the person who introduces an entirely unimproved piece of
land into the service of production, stands to the laborer
as well as to the capitalist in a relation which is entirely
incomparable with any other. (See § 156.) The doctrine of
former agriculturists, that one-half of the harvest was to
be ascribed to the soil and the other to the manure, would
not suffice here, even if it were correct. Compare Fraas,
Gesch. der Landbau- und Forstwissenschaft, 257. But in the
production of a calf, the coöperation of a bull and cow are
necessary.
Yet no one is in condition to determine what
portion of the calf is to be accounted as belonging to
either. If the bull and cow belong to different owners, the
relation of supply and demand, and the deeper causes that
determine them, decide in what proportion the value of the
calf is to be divided among them.]
[Footnote 148-2: Among the greatest services rendered by
Adam Smith is, his complete demonstration, that any income
may be resolved into one or more of the three great branches
of the national income. (I, ch. 6.)]
[Footnote 148-3: Ricardo has not unfrequently bewildered
uncritical readers, by his habit--in which he is by no means
always consistent--of using the expressions higher and lower
wages, higher and lower profit of capital, to designate not
the absolute greatness of these branches of income, either
in money or in the wants of life, nor their greatness from a
personal point of view, but only their relative greatness as
compared with the aggregate income, the measure of the quota
of the aggregate product which is divided among workmen,
capitalists, etc.
And yet, in the case of most economic
questions, this is without doubt the less interesting side.
Compare the polemic of R. Jones, On the Distribution of
Wealth, 1831, I, 288 ff.; Senior, Outlines, 142 seq.;
Carey, On the Rate of Wages, 1834, 24.
Thus, according to
Ricardo, the increase of one branch is possible only at
the expense of another, while in the case of flourishing
nations, the three branches increase absolutely and
together. Ricardo, himself, was by no means unacquainted
with this, as may be seen from Baumstark's German
translation of his work, pp. 37, 108 ff.]
CHAPTER II.
THE RENT OF LAND.
SECTION CXLIX.
THEORY OF RENT.
Rent is that portion of the regular net product of a piece of land which remains after deducting the wages of labor and the interest on the capital usual in the country, incorporated into it.[149-1] Hence it is the price paid for the using of the land itself, or for what Ricardo calls the original inexhaustible forces of the soil which are capable of being appropriated.[149-2] This price also depends, of course, on the relation between demand and supply; the demand in turn, on the wants and means of payment of buyers, but the supply by no means on cost of production, which, from the definitions above given, is here unthinkable.
However, land has this in common with other means of production, that its price is mainly determined by that of its products.
[Footnote 149-1: According to von Thünen, Der isolirte
Staat. in Beziehung auf Landwirthschaft und Nat. Oek, 1850,
I, 14: "what remains of the revenue of an estate after
deducting the interest on all the objects of value which may
be separated from the soil." According to Whately, it is
surplus profit. The expression "regular product" supposes,
among other things, an average skillfulness of the economic
individual.
Thus, for instance, the farm-rent of a piece of
land generally includes besides the real rent of the land,
interest on much capital which is more or less firmly fixed
in the soil. The importance of the latter may be
approximately determined from the fact that in the
electorate of Hesse, for instance, the value of all meadow
lands, woods, and agricultural lands is estimated at from
205 to 206 millions of thalers, and the value of all the
houses at 100 millions. (Hildebrand, Statist.
Mittheil.
über die volkswirthschaftlichen Zustände Kurhessens, 1852,
37.) In the English income tax of 1843, the annual value of
all lands in Great Britain was estimated at over 45 millions
sterling, that of all houses at over 38 millions. However
the farm-rent of a piece of land does not by any means
always embrace the entire rent. A part of the rent is paid
to the state in the form of taxes, and another portion to
the payment of tithes.
Short leasehold terms, frequent land
sales, the comparatively great difficulty of disengaging
capital invested in the cultivation of land, the union of
landed proprietor, capitalist and laborer in one person
easily obscure the law of rent.]
[Footnote 149-2: The stores of immediate plant food in a
piece of land, of minerals in a mine, of salt in a salt
mine, etc., are subject to the law of rent only in so far as
they may be considered inexhaustible; that is, they are not,
strictly speaking, subject to it. Our definition applies all
the more to the capacity for cultivation, and of support or
bearing capacity mentioned in § 35; and hence it is easier
to follow the law of rent in the case of land used for
building purposes than for agriculture. When v.
Mangoldt
claims that the exhaustibility or inexhaustibility of the
soil has nothing to do with rent so long as it flows evenly
(so lange sie eben fliesst) he is in harmony with his own
general conception of rarity-premiums
(Seltenheitsprämien).]
SECTION CL.
THEORY OF RENT. (CONTINUED.)
Agricultural products of equal quantity and quality are produced on pieces of land of unequal fertility, even when the same amount of skill is displayed by the husbandman, with very different outlays of capital and labor.[150-1] And yet the price of these products in the same market is uniformly the same.
This price must, on the supposition of free and intelligent competition, be, in the long run, at least high enough to cover the cost of production on even the worst soil (the margin of cultivation according to Fawcett), which must be brought under cultivation in order to satisfy the aggregate want.
(See § 110.) This worst land need yield no rent.[150-2] The better land which, with an equal outlay of labor and capital, produces a greater yield, furnishes an excess over the cost of production.[150-3] This excess is rent, which, as a rule, is obviously higher in proportion as the difference in fertility between the worst and the better land is greater.
The person who cultivates the land of a stranger may unhesitatingly turn this rent over to the owner; since, notwithstanding his so doing, all that he has himself contributed to production in labor and capital of his own, returns to him entire in the product.[150-4]
According to § 34, a continual increase in the amount of labor and capital lavished on the fertilization of land, agricultural science remaining the same, leads, sooner or later to this, that every new addition of capital or labor becomes relatively less remunerative than the preceding.[150-5] The worse the land is, the sooner is this point reached.
Hence, it necessarily happens that, with an increase in the aggregate want of agricultural products, greater and greater amounts of labor and capital are employed in the further fertilization of land, and that there comes to be a greater difference between the fertility of the worst and better lands, in consequence of which the rent of the latter rises.[150-6]
[Footnote 150-1: Flotow, Anleitung zur Abschätzung der
Grundstücke nach Klassen, 1820, 50 ff., estimates the cost
of production of a scheffel of rye on land of the first
class, at scarcely 1½ thalers; on land of the tenth class,
at 3 thalers. In Hanover, it is estimated that about 60 per
cent. of the land devoted to gardening and agricultural
products produces only from 2 to 4 times the quantity of
seed sown; over 35 per cent. from 5 to 8 times, and 4.5 per
cent. from 9 to 12 times. (Marcard, Zur Beurtheilung des
Nat. Wohlstandes im Königreich Hanover, Tab.
3.) In Prussia,
the rates of net produce adopted by the central commission
in 1862 vary from 3 to 420 silver groschens per morgen, in
the case of agricultural land; from 6 to 420 in the case of
meadow land; in the case of pasturage, from 1 to 360. (v.
Viebahn, Statist. des Zollvereins, II, 966.) In England,
parliamentary investigations (1821) have shown that the best
land produces from 32 to 40, and the worst from 8 to 12
bushels per acre of wheat. (Edinburgh Review, XL, 21.) As to
the influence of the elevation of land, the royal Saxon
commission for the assessment of the value of land,
estimated that the net product of an acre of land at a
height above the level of the sea,
In the case of 2d class land--
Of 500 feet, 55 per cent.
Of 800 " 52-1/2 "
Of 1600 " 48 "
Of 2400 " 43.8 "
In the case of 11th class land--
42.9 per cent. of the gross yield.
39-1/2 " " " "
34 " " " "
26 " " " "]
[Footnote 150-2: The English are very fond of assuming that
the worst land for the time being under cultivation pays no
rent. (Ricardo, Principles, II, 2.) This fact is
frequently obscured by the aggregation into one economic
whole of land that pays no rent and land that is able to pay
rent. (John Stuart Mill, Principles, II, ch. 16, § 3.)
True it is that there is a great deal of land which cannot
be farmed out, but which can be used only by its owners.
Compare Salfeld, in the Landwirthsch. Centralb., 1871, II,
182 ff.
On land near Wetzlar which, notwithstanding the high
price of land in the neighborhood, could not be farmed out
at auction, because no one was desirous to lease it, and
which was therefore turned over to the highest bidder for
the preceding piece, see Stöckhardt, Zeitschr. für
deutsche Landwirthe, 1861, 237. Where, however, all the land
has its own proprietors, the competition of farmers may
easily produce a rent for the worst land.
It is a matter of
complete indifference to the theory of rent, whether the
worst land when possessed only by right of occupation or
used as pasturage for cattle previous to its cultivation,
had value or not. Compare Nebenius, Oeff. Credit, I, 29;
Hermann, Staatswirthsch. Unters., 170 seq.]
[Footnote 150-3: The analogous gradation in mining may make
this clearer.]
[Footnote 150-4: Ricardo illustrated this by the following
example. An uncultivated tract of country is settled by a
small colony. As long as there is here an excess of land of
the best quality, and everyone may take possession of it
without paying anything therefor, no rent of the land which
is merely occupied is possible.
But if all the first class
land is under cultivation--land which perhaps with the
employment of a small amount of capital yields 5 quarters an
acre per annum; and the increasing population necessitates
the cultivation of land of the second class, which with the
same outlay of capital yields only 4 quarters an acre per
annum, there arises a rent of 1 quarter an acre per annum
for land of the first class.
For the price, 4 quarters is
now high enough to cover the cost of production per acre,
and it must be a matter of complete indifference (complete
indifference?) to a new comer whether he obtains 5 quarters
from land of the first class as a farmer and pays out 1
quarter, or whether he harvests 4 quarters from second class
land as proprietor.
If there is a further increase of
population, so that land of the third class also, which
yields only 3 quarters per acre per annum, must be brought
under cultivation, the price of corn rises again because the
cost of production has now to be covered by three quarters.
Land of the first class now pays a rent of 2 quarters and
second class land of 1 quarter. (Ch. 2.)]
[Footnote 150-5: von Thünen, der isolirte Staat, II, I,
179, estimates that a bed of manure 1/3 of an inch thick on
an acre of ground, increases the production by 1/2; that a
second 1/2 inch of manure increases the yield only by a + of
5/8 corn; the third of 1/4 corn, etc. Geyer is of opinion
that, in Saxony, land of the average quality will yield a
gross product of 60 thalers per acre, and 14 thalers net
product per acre, in case it is managed with the greatest
intelligence and the employment of a large amount of
capital; when managed in a very ordinary way, it would yield
20 thalers gross, and 7-1/2 thalers net product. Thünen
gives the following formula determining when it is more
advantageous to cultivate the old land with more
intensiveness (higher farming) than to begin the
cultivation of new: As long as p - _a_q is less than
sqrt(ap), so long is an increase of the outlay of capital on
the same land more profitable than the cultivation of new
land, and vice versa.
Here p = aggregate product obtained
by a workman in a year from the amount of capital used by
him; a = sum of his necessary yearly wants; a = the
interest per annum of a capital = p; q = the amount of
capital given to assist the individual workman.]
[Footnote 150-6: Ricardo had, in every case in which
outlay of capital and labor of different degrees of
productiveness had to be used on the same land, to suppose a
price of the products = the cost of the least productive
outlay.
See the tables in Ricardo's work, On the Influence
of a low Price of Corn on the Profits of Stock, 1815, 14
seq. Schmoller, on the other hand, rightly applies the
principle of united costs of production in as far as the
usual amount of profit of the producer is added to the cost
of the commodity with the highest cost of production.
Mittheilungen des Landwirthsch. Instituts zu Halle, 1865,
128. Compare supra, §§ 106, 110.]
SECTION CLI.
THEORY OF RENT.--LAND FAVORABLY SITUATED.
The favorable situation of a piece of land operates, in almost every politico-economical respect, in the same manner as its fertility.[151-1] If a market, to be fully supplied, needs to be fed from a circuit of ten miles, the price must be sufficient to make good not only the other cost of production but the freight over ten miles. Here, therefore, all producers living nearer to the market, who have to make a smaller outlay for transportation and yet obtain the same market price for their produce, make a profit exactly corresponding to the advantage of their situation.[151-2]
The situation of individual pieces of land relatively to farm buildings, etc., operates in a similar way.[151-3]
[Footnote 151-1: L'éloignement équivaut à la stérilité.
(J. B. Say.) If we imagine with A. Walker an entirely
uncultivated country, equally fertile in every part, settled
only on the coast, and divided into shares of equal breadth,
equally accessible at all points, so that every settler has
unlimited space to extend his possessions from the coast
into the interior, the shares situated in the middle of the
coast strip would be most eagerly sought after; since in its
vicinity, prospectively, all the institutions of the country
would come together.
The colonist, therefore, who should
obtain that share as his, would, unquestionably, be in a
condition to pay a price for this preference, that is a
rent. (Science of Wealth, 296.)]
[Footnote 151-2: It is a consequence both of their
difference of situation and of their fertility that in the
Himalaya the farmers low down on the sides pay 50 per cent.
of the gross product as farm-rent, and higher up, 20 per
cent. less. (Ritter, Erdkunde, III, 878.) Both influences
may be traced most accurately in East Friesland, and in
similar places: marsh land, sandy land, heath land, and high
moorland.
Its situation influences especially the money rent of land,
and its quality the amount of produce. (McCulloch,
Principles, III, 5.)]
[Footnote 151-3: We need only mention the hauling of the
crops and of manure. According to the instructions of the
royal Saxon commission, above mentioned, the cost is assumed
to be 10 per cent. higher for a distance of 250 rods, and 20
per cent. higher for a distance of 500 rods.]
SECTION CLII.
THE THEORY OF RENT. [CONTINUED.]
From what we have said, it follows that the rent of the land of a country is equal at least to the sum of all the differences between the product of the least productive portions of capital which have been necessarily laid out in the cultivation of the soil and the product of the other portions more productively laid out by other husbandmen.
It may rise higher than this on account of a coalition among landowners or immoderate competition among farmers, who may thereby be forced to surrender a portion of their wages and interest on capital to the former; but it can never lastingly fall below this amount.
If the landowners themselves were to surrender all claim to rent, the price of agricultural products would not sink if the market was kept fully supplied; and the excess obtained from the better land over and above the cost of production would go, but only in the nature of a gift, to the farmers, corn dealers and individual consumers.[152-1] Normal rent is not to be explained by any mysterious or peculiar productiveness[152-2] of the land that yields it, but on the contrary, by the fact that even material forces unexhaustible in themselves, but which can be productive only in combination with given parcels of land, uniformly oppose even successively greater difficulties to every successive and additional improvement.[152-3]
Moreover, the capital which becomes a part of the land to such an extent that it cannot be separated from it, and perhaps not even distinguished from it at sight, such for instance as has been laid out for purposes of drainage or in the purchase of material intended to modify the nature of the soil, partakes of the character of the land itself, and its yield obeys the laws of rent. How frequently it happens that such improvements made by the farmer without the least assistance from the owner of the land permanently contribute to an increase of the rent. (§ 181.)[152-4]
[Footnote 152-1: Compare J. Anderson, An Inquiry into the
Nature of the Corn Laws, 1777. Extracts from the same in the
Edinburgh Review, LIV, 91 ff. On the other hand, Buchanan,
on Adam Smith, IV, 134, thinks that rent arises exclusively
from the monopoly of the owners, and that without it the
price of corn would be lower.
It is certain, however, that
if the land of a country be considered as one great piece of
property, and under one great system of husbandry, the
products of the soil might be offered permanently at a price
corresponding to the average cost of production, on the
better and worse pieces of land. (Umpfenback, N. Oek.,
191.)]
[Footnote 152-2: Malthus, On the Policy of restricting the
Importation of foreign Corn, 1815. Additions, 1817, to the
Essay on the Principle of Population, III, ch. 8-12;
Principles, 217 ff.]
[Footnote 152-3: Ricardo says that if air, water,
elasticity and steam were of different qualities, and might
be made objects of exclusive possession; and that if each
kind could be had only in a moderate supply, they would,
like land, produce a rent, according as they were brought
into use, one kind after another. In the class of natural
forces, also, the possession of a secret of production or of
inimitable skill, or a legal right to its exclusive use, may
produce something similar to rent. (Senior, Outlines, 91.)
Hermann, Staatswirthsch.
Unters., 163 ff., had already
laid the foundation of this doctrine, and earlier yet,
Canard, 17 seq., and Hufeland. I, 303 ff. See supra, §
120. Hence v. Mangoldt uses the word rent to designate all
rarity-premiums. John Stuart Mill, III, ch. 5, 4.
Schäffle speaks of the universal existence of a surplus;
that is, of the factor of rent (Nat. Oek., I, Aufl., 140
ff.), and has recently developed this into a theory
thoroughly systematic and detailed. (Nationalökonomische
Theorie der ausschliessenden Absatzverhältnisse, 1867.)
According to him, rent is "the premium paid for the most
economic course taken in the interest of society in
general;" and hence he finds rent as much in superior labor
and in a very advantageous outlay of capital.
Yet he grants,
that "exclusive custom (Kundschaft) on the basis of
natural advantages occurs only in the case of land-rent."
(59.) And even granting that he is right, that no rent is by
itself forever secure (74 seq.), and that much rent is a
premium paid for a search after and the appropriation of the
best land, divination of the best situations, etc. (60 ff.,
74 ff.), there still remains the great difference between
rent and the extra income from labor and capital; that here
the very transitory nature of the substratum, or basis, and
the personal merit of the recipient, is the rule, while in
the former case it is a rare exception.
Willingly,
therefore, as I recognize the possibility and fruitfulness
of Schäffle's way of conceiving this subject (the latter,
especially, for monographic purposes), I prefer, so far as
the entire system is concerned, the keeping apart of the
three branches of income corresponding to the three factors
of production as has been usual since Adam Smith's time.]
[Footnote 152-4: John Stuart Mill, ch. 16, § 5. An example
in Fawcett, Manual, 149 seq. This explains many objections
to Ricardo's laws, which are the result of misconception.
Thus, for instance, in Schmalz, Staatswirthschaftslehre,
I, 81, Quarterly Review, XXXVI, 412 ff. Bastiat, Harmonies
économiques, ch. 9, where rent is considered the interest on
the capital laid out in bringing land under cultivation and
improving it.
If, however, we imagine an island to emerge
suddenly from the waves in the vicinity of Naples, in
consequence of an earthquake, no one can doubt that its land
would sell at a very high rate and pay a very good rent. And
yet no capital or labor has been laid out on it. A similar
lesson is taught by the fact, that, in Scotland, rocks which
are covered twice a day by the waves are leased for the sake
of the sea-weed left on them. (Adam Smith, Wealth of
Nations, I, ch. 11.) Also by the fact, that in Poulopinang,
a cavity in which many edible swallows' nests are found,
pays £500 a year rent. (Geogr.
Ephemeriden, Oct., 1805,
134.) However, Bastiat, abstractly speaking, is right when
he says, that every one by the importation of agricultural
products from quarters which pay no rent, and still more by
emigrating thither, may deprive the owners of land of the
tribute imminent in rent.
But how would it be if the cost of transportation and
emigration amounted to more than the rent? The case
theoretically so important, in which all the land in the
world is supposed to have been appropriated as private
property, this writer, generally so lucid, treats in a
surprisingly blind way (275 ff). It is remarkable that A.
Walker, Science of Wealth, spite of his prejudices in favor
of Bastiat's doctrines on the gratuitous nature of all
natural forces, nevertheless follows, essentially,
Ricardo's theory of rent, 294 ff.
A much more vulgar error yet is, that rent is the result of
the capacity of the capital employed in the purchase of the
land to produce some interest Thus Hamilton, Reports to
the Congress on the Manufactures of the United States, 1793,
and Canard, Principes, sec. 5. Per contra, compare
Turgot's view, supra, § 42, note 1.
Even Locke,
Considerations on the Lowering of Interest, Works, II, 17
ff., maintained the closest parallel between rent and
interest to be possible, with this difference only, that
money was all of a kind but pieces of land of different
degrees of fertility. Similarly Sir D. North, Discourse
upon Trade, 1791, with his parallel of landlord and
stocklord.]
SECTION CLIII.
THEORY OF RENT. (CONTINUED.)
Ricardo says that rent can never, not even in the slightest degree, constitute an element in the price of corn. This is certainly not a very happy way of expressing the truth, that a high rent is not the cause, but the effect, of a relatively high price of corn.[153-1] Ricardo would have been nearer right had he said that rent was not a component part of the price of every portion of the supply of corn brought to market.
Is rent an addition to national income? Ricardo (ch. 31) answers this question in the negative, and says that it takes from the consumers what it gives to the owners of the land, and that it increases only the value in exchange of the national wealth.[153-2] It is evident that as thus stated, the question is not properly put. Neither interest on capital nor wages are any addition to a nation's income, but, like rent, only forms of trade, by means of which that income is distributed among the individuals constituting the nation. (§ 201.)
The special kind of product obtained from a piece of land influences its rent only in so far as the growth of that kind of product is exclusively confined either by nature, privilege or prejudice to certain land.[153-3] Adam Smith is of opinion that the rent of agricultural land is ordinarily (!) one-third of the gross product; that of coal mines, from one tenth to a maximum of one-fifth; of good lead and tin mines, one sixth (with the dues paid the state of twenty-one and two-thirds per cent.); of Peruvian silver mines, scarcely one-tenth; of gold mines, one-twentieth. And he thinks that rent grows less certain for every succeeding article.[153-4]
So far as this is based on facts, it may be explained as follows: The greater capacity an article has for transportation from one place to another, the less important is advantage of situation, which is generally one of the chief elements of rent. The more indispensable the commodity is, the more readily is the consumer induced to pay a price for it greater than the cost of production; that is, to pay a rent. This again is enhanced by the difficulty of the preservation of the commodity. Lastly, the more it is a mere product of nature,[153-5] the more difficult it is to simultaneously employ several portions of capital of different grades of productiveness in its production.
[Footnote 153-1: To be met with in this form even in Adam Smith,
Wealth of Nations, I, ch. 11, pr. John Stuart Mill, Principles
II, ch. 16, § 6, thus states the matter: "Whoever cultivates land,
paying a rent for it, gets in return for his rent an instrument of
superior power to other instruments of the same kind for which no
rent is paid. The superiority of the instrument is in exact
proportion to the rent paid for it." According to v. Jacob,
Grundsätze der Nat.
Oek., I, 187, rent constitutes a much larger
portion of the price of commodities than is generally supposed, in
as much as wages depend so largely on the price of the means of
subsistence. Per contra, Baudrillart, Manuel, 391 ff., who
maintains that rent is practically insignificant.]
[Footnote 153-2: Similarly Buchanan, loc. cit., and Sismondi,
Richesse commerciale, I, 49. Compare contra, Malthus, Inquiry
into the Nature and Progress of Rent, 15. I would call attention
en passant to the absurdity that there may be an increase in the
value in exchange of a nation's entire resources without any
increase in its value in use. (Supra, § 8.)]
[Footnote 153-3: Thus Adam Smith remarks that corn fields and
rice fields pay very different rents, because it is not always
possible to convert one into the other. (Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 11,
1.) Compare the tabular statistical view of the rent of land used
for vineyards, gardens, meadows, pasturages, wood and farming
purposes, in Rau, Lehrbuch, I, § 218. For a general theory of the
rent of wooded land, see Hermann, Staatsw. Unters., 177 ff.; of
vineyards, 181 seq.]
[Footnote 153-4: Adam Smith, Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 11, 3.]
[Footnote 153-5: It is hereby rendered akin to those low stages of
civilization in which no rent is paid.]
SECTION CLIV.
THEORY OF RENT. (CONTINUED.)
As the purchase of a piece of land[154-1] is no more and no less than its exchange against a portion of capital in the shape of money,[154-2] its purchase price depends generally on the amount it will rent for as compared with the interest on the capital to be given in exchange for it. The rate of interest remaining the same, it rises and falls with its rent. And vice versa, the rent remaining the same it rises and falls inversely as the rate of interest.[154-3] A rise in the price of land is not always a proof of the growing wealth of a people.
It may proceed from a depreciation of the value of money, or from a decrease of the rate of interest caused by a decline in the number of loans which can be advantageously placed.
It is frequently said, that the price paid for land is greater than the money-capital which yields an equal revenue.[154-4] This, abstraction made of proletarian distress prices for small parcels of land and of the political and social privileges of landowners, is accounted for by the assumed greater security of the latter,[154-5] which, however, fares ill enough in war times, and times of political disturbance. The fact itself is found to exist, I think, only in economically progressive times, when confidence prevails, and it is based on the pretty certain prospect that the rate of interest will decline, while rents will rise.[154-6]
It has been observed in Belgium, that the medium farm rent of land, in quarters remarkable for any economic peculiarity whatever, pays an interest lower, as compared with the purchase money, in proportion as the country about is more thickly populated, and as its husbandry is carried on by farmers instead of by owners.[154-7] This phenomenon is doubtless correlated with these others, that the conditions just named are pretty regularly attendant on a high state of civilization, and that advanced civilization is attended uniformly by a decline in the rate of interest. (175).[154-8]
[Footnote 154-1: In every day language, people say of a man
who has purchased a piece of land, that he "put" as much
capital as is equal to the purchase price "into his land;"
or "laid out on it" as much. But this mode of expression is
as inaccurate as is this other: "the sun is rising," or "the
sun has gone down."]
[Footnote 154-2: Macleod, who is not fond of the natural
mode of expression, maintains that the purchase price of a
piece of land is equal to the discounted value of the sum of
the values of all the future products to be obtained from
the land. (Elements, 75.)]
[Footnote 154-3: C:i::L:r in which C = the capital, i = its
interest, L = the piece of land, and r = its rent.]
[Footnote 154-4: There are traces to be found of the fact
among the ancient Greeks, that the farm-rent of landed
estates paid a smaller interest on the purchase money than
was otherwise usual in the country. Isaeus de Hagn., 42;
Salmasius, De Modo Usur., 848.]
[Footnote 154-5: Thus even North and Locke, loc. cit.;
Cantillon, Nature du Commerce, 294.]
[Footnote 154-6: Compare List, Werke II, 173. In Belgium,
farm-rent per hectare was, in 1830 = 57.25 francs, in 1835
= 62.78, in 1840 = 70.44, in 1846 = 74.50, on an average.
This was at the rate of from 2.62 to 2.80, or an average of
2.67 per cent. on the purchase money.
If to this we add the
increase in the rise of land between 1830 and 1846, divided
by 16, the yearly revenue rises from 2.67 to 3.91 per cent.,
that is pretty nearly the rate of interest on hypothecation,
and is higher or lower in the different provinces, as the
former is higher or lower. (Heuschling, Résumé du
Récensement général de 1846, 89.) In France, land paid but
from 2 to 3 per cent. on the purchase money; but both rents
and the price of land have doubled between 1794 and 1844.
(Journal des Econ., IX, 208.)]
[Footnote 154-7: Moreover, whole countries may, because of
their great natural advantages, possess, so far as the
commerce of the entire world is concerned, something
analogous to rent. Thus, for instance, North America,
although here, this world-rent finds expression in the
national height of the wages of labor and of the rate of
interest, (v. Bernhardi, Versuch einer Kritik der Gründe
welche für grosses und kleines Grundeigenthum angeführt
werden, 1848, 294.)]
[Footnote 154-8: Writers as old as Culpeper, A Tract
against the high Rate of Usurie, 1623, and Sir J. Child,
Discourse of Trade, p. 22 of the French translation,
observed the connection existing between a low rate of
interest, national wealth and a flourishing state of
commerce on the one hand, and a high price of the
necessaries of life and of land in the other. Sir W.
Petty
would estimate the rent of land as follows: If a calf
pasturing in an open meadow gains as much flesh in a given
time as is equal to the cost of the food of 50 men for a
day, and a workman, on the same land, in the same time,
produces food for 60 men, the rent of the land must be 50,
and the rate of wages 10. (Political Anatomy of Ireland, 62
seq.; compare 54.) Besides, he accounts for the height of
rents by the density of the population exclusively, and he
would prefer to see both increase ad infinitum. (Several
Essays on Political Arithmetic, 147 ff.)
The germs of the Ricardo law of rent, in Boisguillebert:
the price of corn determines how far the cultivation may be
extended; by manuring the land, as much corn as desired may
be obtained, provided the cost of production is covered.
(Traité des Grains, II, ch. 2 ff.) There is a foreshowing of
the same law in the Physiocratic view that only in the
production of raw material is there a real excess over and
above the cost--produit net. Compare Quesnay, Probl.,
économique, 177 ff.
Sur les travaux des artisans. (Daire.)
Auxiron, Principes de tout Gouvernement, 1776, I, 126.
Adam Smith came very near to the true principle in the
case of coal mines, but was hindered reaching it in other
cases by the false assumption that certain kinds of
agricultural production always yield a rent, while others do
so only under certain circumstances. Besides he always
considered the interest of capital fixed in the soil;
buildings, for instance, as part of the rent. (Wealth of
Nat., I, ch.
11.) Compare Hume's Letter to Adam Smith;
Burton's Life and Correspondence of Hume, II, 486; von
Thünen, Isolirter Staat., I, 15 ff.
The most immediate predecessors of Ricardo, Principles, 2,
3, 24, 31, are Anderson (§ 152); West, Essay on the
Application of Capital to Land, 1815, and Malthus, Inquiry
into the Nature and Progress of Rent, 1815. See § 152. It is
wonderful how a theory which, in 1777, remained almost
untouched, was in 1815 etc., attacked and defended with the
greatest zeal, because it then affected the differences
between the moneyed and landed interest.
Yet Ricardo did
not take into account at all the rent-creating influence of
the situation of land in relation to the market, as well as
to the "farm-office" (dem Wirthschaftshofe). The influence
of the system of husbandry on rent, first thoroughly treated
by von Thünen, loc. cit. What has recently been urged
against Ricardo by, for instance, J. B. Say, Traité, II,
ch. 9; Sismondi, N. P., III, ch.
12; Jones, Essay on the
Distribution of Wealth, 1831 (see Edinburg Review, LIV),
bears evidence either of a misunderstanding of the great
thinker, or else contains only modifications of some
individual abstract propositions of his, stated perhaps too
strictly. In judging Ricardo, it must not be forgotten,
that it was not his intention to write a text-book on the
science of Political Economy, but only to communicate to
those versed in it the result of his researches, in as brief
a manner as possible.
Hence he writes so frequently making
certain assumptions; and his words are to be extended to
other cases only after due consideration, or rather
re-written to suit the changed case.
Baumstark very correctly says: "Rent rises, not because
new capital has been invested, but when the circumstances of
trade make a new addition to capital possible."
(Volkswirthschaftliche Erläuterungen über Ricardo's System,
1838, 567.) Fuoco's Nuova Teoria della Rendita, Saggi
economici, No. 1, is nothing but an Italian version of the
doctrines of Malthus and Ricardo. The greater number of
anti-Ricardo theories of rent have originated from the rapid
and apparently unlimited growth of national husbandry in
recent times.
Thus it is a fundamental thought in
Rodbertus, Sociale Briefe, 1851, No. 3, that an increase
of the price of corn need not attend an increase of
population, either uniformly or necessarily. According to
Carey, The Past, the Present and the Future, ch. 1, 1848,
the most fertile land is last brought under cultivation,
because it is covered with swamps, forests, etc.; and
because it offers greater resistance to the work of the
agriculturist, by reason of its luxurious vegetation.
The
more elevated lands are first cultivated which present fewer
obstacles to cultivation on account of their dryness, their
thinner crust, etc. Carey generalizes this and thinks he has
reversed the Ricardo law of rent! He overlooks entirely
that Ricardo speaks only of the original powers of the
soil. Now a swampy land which must be dried at the expense
of a great deal of labor, possesses less of these original
powers than a sandy soil which may be sown immediately.
See
Carey, Essay on the Rate of Wages, 232 ff., and the
lengthy exposition of the same doctrine rank with inexact
natural science and unhistorical history in the same
author's Principles of Social Science, 1858, vol. I.
There is this much truth, however, in Carey's error that,
with increasing economic progress, the superiority not only
of situation, relatively to the market, but also of natural
fertility, may of itself go over to other lands. Thus, for
instance, the ancient Slaves used clay soil everywhere as
pasturage, and cultivated the sandy soil, because their
pick-axes could overcome the resistance only of the latter.
Langethal, Geschicte der deutschen Landw., II, 66;
Waitz, Schlesw. Holstein, Gesch., I, 17. Similarly in
Australia: Hearne, Plutology, 1864.
Compare, Roscher,
Nationalökonomik des Ackerbaues, § 34. The word fertility
should not be taken too exclusively in its present
agricultural sense. In a lower stage of civilization, the
facility of military defense or the ut fons, ut nemus
placuit--Tacit., Germ., 16--may have more weight.
The chief difference in the theories of rent consists in
this: whether rent is considered a result of production or
only of distribution, and an equalization of gain. Compare
Behrens, Krit. Dogmengeschichte der Grundrente, 1868, 48.]
SECTION CLV.
HISTORY OF RENT.
In poor nations, and in those in a low stage of civilization, especially where the population is sparse, rent is wont to be low. In Turkistan, land is valued according to the capital invested in its irrigation.[155-1] In the interior of Buenos Ayres, at the beginning of the nineteenth century, landed estates were paid for in proportion to the magnitude of the live stock on them, so that it seemed, at least, as if the land was given for nothing, or simply thrown in with the purchase.
And only a short time since, an English acre in the same country, fifteen leguas from the capital, was worth from three to four pence, and at a distance of fifty leguas, only two pence.[155-2] In Russia, also, not long since, the valuation of landed estates was made, not in proportion to the superficies, but according to the number of souls, that is, of male serfs, a remnant suggestive of the previous situation when no rent was paid.[155-3] Where, in relatively uncivilized medieval times, instances of the farming out or leasing of land occur, farm-rents are so small that their payment can only be considered as a mere recognition of the owner's continuing right of property.
Under these circumstances, it is natural that great landowners, especially in the lower stages of civilization, should exert an especially great influence; and that their low tenants (Hintersassen) are more dependent in proportion to the want of capital and the absence of trade.
Hence, these are wont to make up for the smallness of their rent by great honors paid to their landlords, and great services, especially military service.[155-4] Besides, the lords of the manor, in almost every medieval period, have used their influence with the government to cut down the wages of labor by serfdom and other similar institutions, and the rate of interest on capital by prohibiting interest, by usury laws, etc.; and thus, in both ways, to artificially increase their own share of the national income.
[Footnote 155-1: A. Burnes, Reise nach Bukhara, II, 238.]
[Footnote 155-2: W. Maccann, Two Thousand Miles Ride
through the Argentine Provinces, London, 1853, I, 20; II,
143. Ausland, 1843, No. 140. Frisian ancient documents in
which parcels of land are described as terræ 20 animalium,
48 animalium, etc. Lacomblet, Urkundenbuch, I, 27.
Kindlinger, Münster Beitr., I, Urkundenbuch, 24.]
[Footnote 155-3: The custom began to be more usual in Russia
also to say "so many dessjatines and the peasantry
belonging thereto." This was especially so in the case of
very fertile land, as for instance in Orel. See v.
Haxthausen, Studien, II, 510. Formerly the bank loaned only
250 per soul, afterwards up to 300 R. Bco. (II, 81). Spite
of this v.
Haxthausen thinks that rent would be illusory,
in Russia, in case agriculture was carried on with hired
workmen. (I, Vorrede, XIII.) Carey's remark, "every one is
familiar with the fact that farms sell for little more than
the value of the improvements," may be true of the United
States (The Past, Present and Future, 60.)]
[Footnote 155-4: This condition of things continued in the
highlands of Scotland until the suppression of the revolt of
1745. The celebrated Cameron of Lochiel took the field with
800 tenants, although the rent of the land was scarcely
£500. (Senior, Three Lectures on the Rate of Wages, 45.)
"Poor 12,000 pound sterling per annum nearly subverted the
constitution of these kingdoms!" (Pennant.)]
SECTION CLVI.
INFLUENCE OF ADVANCING CIVILIZATION ON RENT.
Advancing civilization contributes in three different ways to raise rents.[156-1] The growth of population necessitates either a more intensive agriculture (higher farming), or causes it to extend over less fertile parcels of land, or parcels less advantageously situated.[156-2] If the growth of population be attended by an increase of capital, this happens in a still higher degree. The people now consume, if not more, at least wheat of finer quality, more and better fed live stock; the consequence of which is, that the demands made on the land are increased.
Lastly, if the population be gradually concentrated in large cities, this fact also must contribute to raise rents, because it requires a multitude of costly transportations of agricultural produce and so increases the cost of production (up to the time of consumption) on the less advantageously situated land.[156-3] [156-4]
As most of the symptoms of a higher civilization become apparent earliest, and in the most striking manner, in large cities, so also a rise in rents is first felt in them. The building of houses may be considered as the most intensive of all cultivation of land and that which is most firmly fixed to the soil.[156-5] Rent has nowhere an unsurpassable maximum any more than a necessary minimum.
[Footnote 156-1: Jung, Lehrbuch der Cameralpraxis, 1790,
182, has so little idea of this that he is of opinion that
farm-rent must grow ever smaller.]
[Footnote 156-2: According to Schmoller, in the
Mittheilungen des landwirthschaftlich. Instituts zu Halle,
1865, 112 seq., the average farm-rent of the Prussian
domains per morgen, and the population to the square mile,
amounted:
+============+============+============+
District. | 1849. | 1864. | 1849. | 1858.
---------------+------------+------------+------------+----------
| Thalers. | Population
| | per square mile
Königsberg, | 0.73 | 1.16 | 2076 | 2298
Gumbinnen, | 0.59 | 0.76 | 2059 | 2249
Danzig, | 1.02 | 1.51 | 2656 | 2926
Marienwerder, | 0.63 | 1.06 | 1944 | 2135
Posen, | 0.69 | 1.07 | 2789 | 2857
Bromberg, | 0.69 | 1.10 | 2116 | 2322
Stettin, | 1.07 | 1.73 | 2355 | 2614
Cöslin, | 0.83 | 1.30 | 1735 | 1940
Stralsund, | 0.95 | 1.50 | 2347 | 2549
Breslau, | 1.19 | 1.45 | 4733 | 5034
Liegnitz, | 1.17 | 1.75 | 3676 | 3763
Oppeln, | 0.86 | 1.20 | 3973 | 4433
Potsdam, | 1.08 | 1.59 | 3317 | 3640
Frankfort, | 1.29 | 2.00 | 2446 | 2660
Magdeburg, | 2.31 | 2.98 | 3290 | 3508
Werseburg, | 2.35 | 3.03 | 3934 | 4270
Erfurt, | 2.04 | 2.55 | 5621 | 5735
Münster, | .... | 2.03 | 3192 | 3299
Minden, | 2.48 | 2.62 | 4841 | 4808
## +============+============+============+
Compare the review of rents in the states of the Zollverein,
in v. Viehbahn, Statistik, II, 979. It is difficult to
compare different countries with one another in this
respect, because it is seldom certain whether the word rent
means exactly the same thing in them. Besides, it should not
be overlooked, how difficult it is to ascertain what rent,
in the strict sense of the term, as used by Ricardo, is.]
[Footnote 156-3: Moreover, the rise of rents, in so far as
it depends on the greater cost of transportation to a
growing market, becomes progressively slower. The concentric
circles about that point increase in a greater ratio than
the radii.]
[Footnote 156-4: As to the history of rents in England, a
comparison of the years from 1480 to 1484, with the most
recent times, shows that the amount of rent estimated in
money in agricultural districts, where no very great
"improvements" have been made, have increased as 1 to
80-100, while the price of wheat has increased 12-fold and
wages 10-fold. (Rogers, in the Statist. Journal, 1864,
77.) According to Hume, History of England, ch.
33, it
seems that rents under Henry VIII. were only 1/10 of those
usually paid in his time, while the price of commodities was
only 1/4 of the modern. Davenant, Works, II, 217, 221,
estimates the aggregate rent of land, houses and mines, at
the beginning of the seventeenth century, at £6,000,000;
about 1698, at £14,000,000; capitalized respectively at
£72,000,000 and £252,000,000. About 1714, J. Bellers,
Proposals for Employing the Poor, puts it at £15,000,000;
about 1726, Erasm.
Phillips, State of the Nation in
Respect to Commerce etc., at £20,000,000; about 1771, A.
Young, at £16,000,000; about 1800, Beeke, Observations on
the Income-Tax, at £20,000,000; about 1804, Wakefield,
Essay on Political Economy, at £28,000,000; about 1838,
McCulloch, Statist., I, 535, at £29,500,000. The poor tax
in England and Wales, in 1841, was on a valuation of
£32,655,000. (Porter, Progress, VI, 2, 614); 1864-5, the
annual value of lands, £46,403,853 (Stat.
Journal, 1869.)
Moreover, the income from houses, railroads, etc. (real
property other than lands), increased very much more than
that received from pieces of farming land; between 1845 and
1864-5, the former by 392.8 per cent., and the latter by
27.9 per cent. (Hildebrand's Jahrbb., 1869, II, 383 seq.);
and the income tax of 1857 on £47,109,000. There was a still
more rapid growth of rent in Scotland.
In 1770, it was only
£1,000,000-1,200,000: in 1795, £2,000,000; in 1842,
£5,586,000. (McCulloch, I, 576, ff.) In Ireland, about
1776, it was only $900,000, according to Petty. (Political
Anatomy of Ireland, I, 113.) A. Young assumed it to be
£6,000,000 in 1778; Newenham, View of Ireland, about 1808,
£15,000,000. In many parts of the Rosendale Forest in
Lancashire, the land is leased by the ell, at £121, and even
at £131 per acre; i. e., more than the whole forest of
15,300 acres was rented for in the time of James I.
In many
of the moorland portions of Lancashire, rent has risen in
150 years, 1,500 and even 3,000 per cent. (Edinburg Rev.,
1843, Febr., 223.)
The amount of rents in Prussia, Krug assumed to be in
1804, 50,000,000 thalers, and von Viebahn, Zollverein
Statistik, II, 974, in 1862, 116,500,000 thalers. Lavergne
assumed the rents of France after 1850 to be 1,600,000,000
francs (Revue des deux Mondes, Mars, 1868); and Dutot,
Journal des Economistes, Juin, 1870, in 1870, at
2,000,000,000. In Norway, the capitalized value of all the
land was assessed at 13,000,000,000 thalers in specie, in
1665; in 1802, at 25,500,000; in 1839, at 64,000,000
thalers. Blom, Statistik von Norwegen, I, 145.
The older
such estimates are, the more unreliable they are.]
[Footnote 156-5: In Paris, in 1834, the square toise = 37
sq. feet, in the Rue Richelieu and Rue St.
Honoré, cost
1,500 to 2,000 francs; in Rue neuve Vivienne, 2,500 to 3,500
francs; in 1857, from 200 to 500 francs per square meter, =
10 sq. feet, was very usual. (Wolowski.) Before the gates
of Paris, the rent amounted to as high as 250 francs per
hectare; at Fontainebleau, to only from 30 to 40. (Journal
des Economistes, Mars, 1856, 337.) In Market Square,
Philadelphia, land was worth from 3,000 to 4,000 francs per
sq. toise, and in Wall Street, New York, about 4,000
francs. (M. Chevalier, Letters sur l'Amérique, 1836, I,
355.) In St.
Petersburg, after 6 years, the house frequently
falls to the owner of the area. (Storch. by Rau, I, 248
f.) In Manchester, the Custom House area cost from 10 to 12
pounds sterling per square yard; in the center of the city,
as high of £40, that is, nearly £200,000 per acre. In
Liverpool, in the neighborhood of the Exchange and of Town
Hall, the cost is from 30 to 40 pounds sterling. (Athenæum,
Dec. 4, 1852.) In London, a corner building on London
street, erected for £70,000, with only three front windows,
pays a rental of £22,000. (Allg.
Zeitung, 1 Febr., 1866.)
The villa at Misenum--a very beautiful location--which the
mother of the Gracchi bought for about 5,000 thalers, came
into the possession of L. Lucullus, consul in the year B. C.
74, for about 33 times as much. Mommsen, Römisch. Gesch.,
II, 382.]
SECTION CLVII.
HISTORY OF RENT.--IMPROVEMENTS IN THE ART OF AGRICULTURE.
Improvements in the art of agriculture which are confined to individual husbandmen leave rent unaffected. They do not perceptibly lower the price of agricultural products, and only effect an increase of the reward of enterprise which is entirely personal to the more skillful producers and does not attach to the ground itself.
But how is it when these improvements become general throughout the country? If population and consumption remain unchanged, the supply of agricultural products will exceed the demand. This would compel farmers, if there be no avenue open to exports, to curtail their production. The least fertile and most disadvantageously situated parcels of land will be abandoned to a greater or less extent, and the least productive capital devoted to agriculture, withdrawn.
In this way, rent goes down both relatively and absolutely, although the owners of land may be able to partially cover their loss by the gain which results to them as consumers and capitalists.[157-1] (§ 186). After a time, however, and as a consequence of the diminished price of corn, population and consumption will increase, and entail an extension of agriculture and a consequent rise in rents.[157-2] If it, relatively speaking, reaches the same point as before, it still is absolutely much greater than before.
Let us suppose that there are three classes of land of equal extent in a country, which for an equal outlay of capital produce 100,000, 80,000 and 70,000 bushels yearly. The rent of the land here would be equal to at least 40,000 bushels. If the yield of production now doubles, while the demand for agricultural products also doubles, the aggregate harvest will be 200,000 + 160,000 + 140,000 bushels, and consequently rent will have risen to at least 80,000 bushels. But this increase of rent has injured no one.
If the population increases in a less degree than the productiveness of the land, the consumer may, to a certain extent, gain largely, and the landowner better his condition. However, great agricultural improvements spread so gradually over a country, that, as a rule, the demand for agricultural products can keep pace with the increased supply.
But even in this case, that transitory absolute decline of rent may be avoided; and it cannot be claimed universally, as it is by many who are satisfied with mumbling Ricardo's words after him, that an increase of rent is possible only by an enhancement of the price of the products of the soil. Where the development of a people's economy is a normal one, the rent of land is wont to increase gradually, but at the same time to constitute a diminishing quota of the entire national income.[157-3]
Improvements in milling,[157-4] and in the instruments of transportation[157-5] adapted to agricultural products, and the introduction of cheaper[157-6] food, have the same effect as improvements of agricultural production. All such steps in advance render an increase in population, or in the nation's resources, possible without any corresponding increase in the amount paid to landowners as tribute money.[157-7]
The foregoing facts furnish us the data necessary to decide what influence permanent soil improvements have on the rent of land.[157-8] The improved parcels of land now grow more fertile. Their rentability also increases, while that of the others becomes not only relatively but absolutely less, if the demand remains unaltered. The whole is as if capital had been transformed into fertile land, and this added to the improved land.
[Footnote 157-1: Since it has seemed absurd to many writers
to say that an improvement in the art of agriculture may
cause rents to decline (compare Malthus, Principles, I,
ch. 3, 8), John Stuart Mill, Principles, IV, ch. 3, § 4,
prefers to put the question thus: whether the landowner is
not injured by the improvement of the estates of other
people, although his own is included in the improvement.
Compare Davenant, Works, I, 361.
And so the long
agricultural crisis through which Germany passed at the
beginning of the third decade of this century was produced
mainly by the great impulse given to agriculture (Thaer,
Schuerz etc.), while population did not keep pace with it.
Similarly, at the same time, in England, McCulloch, Stat.,
I, 557 ff. Of course, the less fertile pieces of land
declined even relatively most in price.
From 1654 to 1663,
Switzerland experienced a severe agricultural crisis,
attended with oppressive cheapness of corn, a great decline
in the price of land, innumerable cases of insolvency,
revolts of the peasantry, emigration, etc. (Meyer von
Knonau, Handbuch d. schweiz. Gesch., II, 43.) The Swiss
had, precisely during the Thirty Years' War which spared
them, so extensively developed their agricultural interests,
that now that other countries began to compete with them,
they could not find a market large enough for their
products.
For English instances of similar "agricultural
distress" in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, see
Child, Discourse on Trade, 73, 124 seq.; Temple,
Observations upon the U. P., ch. 6; Tooke, History of
Prices, I, 23 seq., 42. Even where there have been no
technic improvements, a series of unusually good harvests
may have the same results, of which there are many instances
scattered through Tooke's first volume.
There is great importance attached in England to the
difference between those agricultural reforms which save
land and those which effect a saving in capital and labor.
The latter, it is said, decrease the money rent of the
landowner by depreciating the price of corn, but leave the
corn-rent unaltered. The former, on the other hand, decrease
the rent both in money and corn, but the money rent in a
higher degree. (Ricardo, Principles, ch. 2; J. S. Mill,
Principles, IV, ch. 3, 4.)]
[Footnote 157-2: When the demand for products of the soil
which minister to luxury, such as fat meat, milk,
vegetables, is increasing, a greater cheapness of the
necessary wheat may raise rent, for the reason that lands
are now cultivated which were not formerly tillable. Thus,
there is now land in Lancashire which could not formerly be
planted with corn, because the laborers would have consumed
more than the harvest yielded.
Since the large imports of
the means of subsistence from Ireland these lands have been
transformed into artificial meadows, gardens, etc.
(Torrens, The Budget, 180 ff.) Compare Adam Smith, I,
257, ed. Bas. Banfield would misuse these facts to
overturn the theory of Ricardo. (Organization of Industry,
1848, 49 ff.)]
[Footnote 157-3: The French testamentary tax was on an
amount,
In 1835, of 552 mill. francs moveable property
and 984 " immoveable.
In 1853, of 820 " francs moveable property
and 1,176 " immoveable.
In 1860, of 1,179 " francs moveable property
and 1,545 " immoveable.
so that the preponderance of immoveable property constituted
a converging series of 78, 43, and 31 per cent. (Parieu.)
In North America, with its great unoccupied territory, the
reverse is the case.
The census of 1850 gave a moveable
property of 36 per cent.; that of 1860 of only 30 per cent.
According to Dubost, the rent of land in Algeria was 80
per cent., a gross product of only 10-15 francs per
hectare; in Corsica, 66 per cent., a gross yield of from
30-35 per cent.; in the Department du Nord, 17.5-24 per
cent., a gross yield of from 500-740 francs. (Journal des
Economistes, Juin, 1870, 336 ff.)]
[Footnote 157-4: The repeated sifting of the bran (mouture
économique) had great influence in this respect. In France,
in the sixteenth century, a setier of wheat gave only 144
pounds of bread. In 1767, according to Malouin, L'Art du
Bonlanger, it gave 192 pounds. It now gives from 223 to 240
pounds. The gain in barley is still greater; the setier
gives 115 pounds of flour, formerly only 58. (Roquefort,
Histoire de la Vie Privée des Français, I, 72 ff.
Beckmann, Beitr. zur Gesch. der Erfind., II, 54.)]
[Footnote 157-5: In the beginning of the eighteenth century,
the counties in the neighborhood of London addressed a
petition to Parliament against the extension of the building
of turnpike roads which caused their rents to decline, from
the competition of distant districts. (Adam Smith, Wealth
of Nat., I, ch. 11, 1.) Compare Sir J. Stewart,
Principles, I, ch. 10. Improvements in transportation which
affect the longest and shortest roads to a market in an
absolutely equal degree, as, for instance, the bridging of a
river very near the market, leave rent unaffected. (von
Mangoldt, V. W.
L., 480.)]
[Footnote 157-6: Malthus, Principles, 231 ff. If the
laboring class were to become satisfied with living on
potatoes instead of meat and bread as hitherto, rents would
immediately and greatly fall, since the necessities of the
people might then be obtained from a much smaller
superficies. But after a time, the consequent increase in
population might lead to a much higher rent than before;
since a great deal of land too unfertile for the cultivation
of corn might be sown with potatoes, and thus the limits of
cultivation be reached much later.]
[Footnote 157-7: In France, between 1797 and 1847, the
average price of wheat did not rise at all. Hipp.
Passy
mentions pieces of land which produced scarcely 12
hectolitres of wheat, but which now produce 20--an increased
yield of 170 francs, attended by an increase in the cost of
only 75 francs. (Journal des Economistes, 15 Oct., 1848.)
Moreover, it may be that a not unimportant part of modern
rises in the price of corn may be accounted for by the
better quality of the corn caused by higher farming. (Inama
Sternbeg, Gesch. der Preise, 10 seq.) Such facts, readily
explainable by Ricardo's theory, remove the objection of
Carey, Banfield and others, that the condition of the
classes who own no land has, since the middle ages,
unquestionably improved.
Political Economy would be simply a
theory of human degradation and impoverishment, if the law
of rent was not counteracted by opposing causes. (Roesler,
Grundsätze, 210.) According to Berens, Krit.
Dogmengeschichte, 213, the actual highness of rent is to be
accounted for by the antagonism between the "soil-law
(Bodengesetz) of the limited power of vegetation," and the
"progress of civilization" (but surely only to the extent
that the latter improves the art of agriculture). Thus, too,
John Stuart Mill, Principles, I, ch. 12; II, ch. 11, 15
seq.; III, ch.
4 seq.; IV, ch. 2 ff.]
[Footnote 157-8: Thus, for instance, drainage works which,
where properly directed, have paid an interest of from 25 to
70 per cent. per annum in England and Belgium on the capital
invested.]
SECTION CLVIII.
HISTORY OF RENT.--IN PERIODS OF DECLINE.
If a nation's economy be declining, in consequence of war for instance, the disastrous influence hereof on rent may be retarded by a still greater fall in wages or in the profit on capital. But it can be hardly retarded beyond a certain point.[158-1] As a rule, the decline of rents begins to be felt by the least fertile and least advantageously situated land.[158-2] [158-3]
[Footnote 158-1: "The falling of rents an infallible sign of
the decay of wealth." (Locke.) In England, in 1450, land
was bought at "14 years' purchase;" i. e., with a capital =
14 times the yearly rent paid, in 1470, at only "10 years'
purchase." (Eden, State of the Poor, III, App., I, XXXV.)
This was, doubtless, a consequence of the civil war raging
in the meantime. The American war (1775-82) depressed the
price of land in England to "23-1/4 years' purchase,"
whereas it had previously stood at 32. (A.
Young.) The
rent of land, in many places in France, declined from 10,000
to 2,000 livres, on account of the many wars during Louis
XIV.'s reign. (Madame de Sévigné's Lettres, 25 Dec, 1689.)
Even in 1677, it was only one-half of its former amount
(King, Life of Locke, I, 129.) The whole Bekes county
(comitat) in Hungary was sold for 150,000 florins under
Charles VI.; after the unfortunate war with France.
(Mailath, Oesterreich, Gesch., IV, 523.) Compare
Cantillon, Nature du Commerce, 248.
In Cologne, a new
house was sold in the spring of 1848 for 1,000 thalers, the
site of which alone had cost 3,000 thalers; and there are
six building lots which formerly cost over 3,000 thalers,
now valued at only 100 thalers. (von Reden, Statist.
Zeitschr., 1848, 366.) On the other hand, Napoleon's war
very much enhanced English rents (Porter, Progress of the
Nation, II, 1, 150 ff.), because it affected England's
national husbandry principally by hindering the importation
of the means of subsistence. (Passy, Journal des
Economistes, X, 354.)]
[Footnote 158-2: Thus the price of lands, in Mecklenburg,
between 1817 and 1827, fell 30 to 40 per cent. in the least
fertile quarters; in the better, from 15 to 20 per cent.
(von Thünen, in Jacob, Tracts relating to the Corn
Trade, 40, 187.) Per contra, see Hundeshagen Landwirthsch.
Gewerbelehre, 1839, 64 seq., and Carey, Principles, I,
354.]
[Footnote 158-3: The average rent in England was, in 1815,
17s. 3d. In the counties, it was highest in Middlesex, 38s.
9d.; in Rutland, 38s. 2d.; Leicester, 27s. 3d.; lowest in
Westmoreland, 9s. 1d. In Wales, the average was 7s. 10d.;
highest in Anglesea, 19s.; lowest in Merioneth, 4s. 8d. In
Scotland the average was 5s. 1-1/2d.; highest, Midlothian,
24s. 6-1/2d.; lowest, Highland Caithness, Cromarthy,
Inverness and Rosse, from 1s. 1d. to 1s. 5d.; Orkneys,
8-1/2d.; Sutherland, 6d.; Shetlands, 3d. In Ireland, the
average was 12s. 9d.; highest in Dublin, 20s.
1-1/2d.;
lowest, Donegal, 6s. (McCulloch, Stat., I, 544 ff.;
Yearbook of general Information, 1843, 193.) In France,
Chaptal, De l'Industrie Fr., 1819, I, 209 ff., estimates
the average yield per hectare at 28 francs; in the
Department of the Seine, 216; Nord, 69.56; Lower Seine,
67.85; in the upper Alps, 6.2; in the lower Alps, 5.99: in
the Landes, 6.25. While in the Landes, only 20 francs a
hectare are frequently paid, the purchase price in the
neighboring Medoc is sometimes 25,000 francs. (Journal des
Economistes, Jan.
15, 1851.) In Belgium, the average price
of agricultural land is 52.46; in East Flanders, 53.19; in
Namur, 29.24. (Heuschling, Statistique, 77.)]
SECTION CLIX.
HISTORY OF RENT.--RENT AND THE GENERAL GOOD.
We so frequently hear rent called the result of the monopoly[159-1] of land, and an undeserved tribute paid by the whole people to landowners, that it is high time we should call attention to the common advantage it is to all.
There is evidently danger that, with the rapid growth of population, the mass of mankind should yield to the temptation of gradually confining themselves to the satisfaction of coarse, palpable wants; that all refined leisure, which makes life and the troubles that attend it worth enduring, and which is the indispensable foundation of all permanent progress and all higher activity, should be gradually surrendered.
(See § 145.) Here rent constitutes a species of reserve fund, which grows greater in proportion as these dangers impend by reason of the decline of wages and of the profit of capital, or interest.[159-2] Besides, precisely in times when rent is high, the sale and divisibility of landed estates act as a beneficent reaction against the monopoly of land, which is always akin to the condition of things created by rent.
But it is of immeasurably greater importance that high rents deter the people from abusing the soil in an anti-economic way; that they compel men to settle about the centers of commerce, to improve the means of transportation, and under certain circumstances to engage in the work of colonization; while, otherwise, idleness would soon reconcile itself to the heaping together of large swarms of men.[159-3] The anticipation of rent may render possible the construction of railroads, which enable the land to yield that very anticipated rent.
[Footnote 159-1: "Rent is a tax levied by the landowners as
monopolists." (Hopkins, Great Britain for the last forty
Years, 1834.) For a very remarkable armed and successful
resistance of farmers in the state of New York to the claims
for rent of the Rensselaer family, represented by the
government, see Wappäus Nord Amerika, 734.]
[Footnote 159-2: Malthus, Additions to the Essay on
Population, 1817, III, ch. 10; compare also Verri,
Meditazioni, XXIV, 3. The Physiocrates call the landowners
classe disponible, since, as they may live without labor,
they are best adapted to military service, the civil
service, etc., either in person or by defraying the expenses
of those engaged in them. (Turgot, Sur la Formation etc.,
§ 15; Questions sur la Chine, 5.)]
[Footnote 159-3: Well discussed by Schäffle, Theorie, 65,
72, 83. Malthus considers the capital and labor expended
in agriculture more productive than any other, because they
produce not only the usual interest and wages, but also
rent.
If, therefore, the manufacturing and commercial profit
of a country = 12 per cent., and the profit of capital
employed in agriculture = 10 per cent., a corn law which
compelled the capital engaged in manufactures and commerce
to be devoted to agriculture would be productive of
advantage to the national husbandry in general, if the
increase in rent should amount to about 3 per cent. (On the
Effects of the Corn Laws and of a Rise or Fall in the Price
of Corn on the Agriculture and the general Wealth of the
Country, 1815.
The Grounds of an Opinion on the Policy of
Restricting the Importation of Foreign Corn, 1815.) Compare
supra, § 55, and the detailed rectification in Roscher,
Nationalökonomik des Ackerbaues, etc., § 159 ff.]
CHAPTER III.
WAGES.
SECTION CLX.
THE PRICE OF COMMON LABOR.
Like the price of every commodity, the immediate wages of common labor is determined by the relation of the demand and supply of labor.
Other circumstances being the same, every great plague[160-1] or emigration[160-2] is wont, by decreasing the supply, to increase the wage's of labor; and a plague, the wages of the lowest kind of labor most.[160-3] And so, the increased demand, in harvest time, is wont to increase wages; and even day board during harvest time is wont to be better.[160-4] [160-5] In winter the diminished demand lowers wages again.[160-6] Among the most effective tricks of socialistic sophistry is, unfortunately, to caricature the correct principle: "labor is a commodity," into this other: "the laborer is a commodity."
Moreover, common labor has this peculiarity, that those who have it to supply are generally much more numerous than those who want it; while the reverse is the case with most other commodities. Another important peculiarity of the "commodity" labor, is, that it can seldom be bought, without at the same time reducing the person of the seller to a species of dependence. Thus, for instance, the seller cannot be in a place different from that in which his commodity is.
Hence a change in the person, etc. of the buyer very readily necessitates in the workman a radical change of life, and that the levelling adjustment of local excess and want is rendered so difficult in the case of this commodity.[160-7] Hence, it is that, if in the long run the exchange of labor against wages is to be an equitable one (§ 110), the master of labor must, so to speak, incorporate part of his own personality into it, have a heart for faithful workmen and thus attach them to himself.[160-8]
[Footnote 160-1: High rate of Italian wages after the plague
in 1348, but also many complaints of the indolence and
dissoluteness of workmen. (M. Villani, I, 2 ff., 57 seq.
Sismondi, Gesch. der ital. Republiken in Mittelalter, VI,
39.) In England, the same plague increased the wages of
threshers from an average of 1.7 d. in 1348, to 3.3 d. in
1349. Mowers received, during the 90 years previous, 1/12 of
a quarter of wheat per acre; in 1371-1390, from 1/7 to 1/6.
The price of most of their wants was then from 1/8 to 1/12
as high as in A.
Young's time, and wages 1/4 as high.
(Rogers, I, 306, 271, 691.) The great earthquake in
Calabria, in 1783, produced similar effects. (Galanti, N.
Beschreiburg von Neapel, I, 450.) Compare Jesaias, 13, 12.
On the other hand, depopulation caused by unfortunate wars
is not very favorable to the rate of wages; instance,
Prussia in 1453 ff., after the Polish struggle, and Germany,
after the Thirty Years' War.]
[Footnote 160-2: How much it contributes to raise wages that
workmen can, in a credible way, threaten to move to other
places, is illustrated by the early high wages and personal
freedom of sailors. Compare Eden, State of the Poor, I,
36. In consequence of the recent great emigration from
Ireland, the weekly wages of farm hands in that country was
57.4 per cent. higher than in 1843-4. In Connaught, where
the emigration was largest, it was 87 per cent. higher.
(London Statist. Journ., 1862, 454.)]
[Footnote 160-3: Compare Rogers, I, 276, and passim.]
[Footnote 160-4: And this in proportion as the uncertainty
of the weather causes haste. In England, the harvest doubles
wages. (Eden.) In East Friesland, it raises it from 8-10
ggr. to 2 thalers sometimes (Steltzner); in the steppes of
southern Russia, from 12-15, to frequently 40-50 kopeks.
This explains why the country people who come into the
weekly market are anxious, during harvest time, to get rid
of their stocks as fast as possible. According to the
Statist. Journal, 1862, 434, 448, the average wages in
harvest and other times, amounted to:
In harvest time. Other times.
In Scotland for males, 18s. 7d. 12s. 11-1/2d.
" " females, 11s. 4d. 5s. 7d.
In Ireland " males, 12s. 9d. 6s. 11-1/2d.
" " females, 8s. 3d. 3s. 9d.
" " males, 15s. 4d. 7s. 1-1/4d.
" " females, 7s. 1-3/4d. 3s. 11d.
The reason why the wages of females rises more in harvest
time than the wages of males may be the same that in many
places in Ireland has made emigration more largely increase
the wages of women. (l. c., 454.) Every excess of workmen
depresses, and every scarcity of workmen enhances the wages
of the lowest strata relatively most.]
[Footnote 160-5: The wages of English sailors was usually
40-50 shillings a month. During the last naval war, it rose
to from 100 to 120, on account of the great demand created
by the English fleet. (McCulloch, On Taxation, 40.)]
[Footnote 160-6: The winter wages of German agricultural
laborers varies between 6.1 and 20 silver groschens; summer
wages between 7.9 and 27.5 silver groschens. Emminghaus,
Allg. Gewerbelehre, 81, therefore, advises that in winter
the meal time of workmen in the fields should be postponed
to the end of the day, and winter wages then made less low
than at present.]
[Footnote 160-7: W. Thornton, On Labour, its wrongful
Claims and rightful Dues, its actual, Present and possible
Future, 1869, II, ch. 1. Harrison, Fortnightly Review,
III, 50.]
[Footnote 160-8: Just as the husband binds himself in
marriage. While in concubinage there is apparent equality,
it costs the woman a much greater sacrifice than the man.]
SECTION CLXI.
WAGES OF LABOR.--THE MINIMUM OF WAGES.
Human labor cannot, any more than any other commodity, be supplied, in the long run, at a price below the cost of production.[161-1] [161-2] The cost of production here embraces not only the necessary or customary means of subsistence of the workman himself, but also of his family; that is, of the coming generation of workmen. The number of the latter depends essentially on the demand for labor.
If this demand be such that it may be satisfied by an average of six children to a family, the rate of wages must be such as to support the workman himself and to cover the cost of bringing up six children.[161-3] Where it is customary for the wife and child, as well as for the father, to work for wages, the father does not need to earn the entire support of the family, and hence individual wages may be smaller.[161-4] But if it were to fall below the cost mentioned above, it would not be long before increased mortality and emigration, and a diminution of marriages and births would produce a diminution of the supply; the result of which would be, if the demand remained the same, a renewed rise of wages.
Conversely, it would be more difficult for the rate of wages to be maintained long much above that same cost, in proportion as the gratification of the sexual appetite was more generally considered the highest pleasure of sense, and the love of parents for their children as the most natural human duty. As Adam Smith says, where there is a great demand for men, there will always be a large supply of them.[161-5]
[Footnote 161-1: Compare Engel's beautiful lecture on the
cost of labor to itself (Selbstkosten = self-cost),
Berlin, 1866.]
[Footnote 161-2: Wolkoff zealously and rightly argues,
that the minimum wages is not the taux naturel of wages.
(Lectures, 118 ff., 284.) von Thünen also divides wages
into two component parts--that which the workman must lay
out in his support in order to continue able to work, and
that which he receives for his actual exertion. (Isolirter
Staat., II, 1, 92 seq.)]
[Footnote 161-3: Gasparin distinguishes five periods in
the career of a workman generally: a, he is supported by his
parents; b, he supports himself and is in a condition to
save something; c, he marries, and supports his children
with trouble; d, the children are able to work, and the
father lives more comfortably; e, his strength and resources
decline. (Villermé, Tableau de l'État physique et moral
des Ouvriers, 1840, II, 387.)]
[Footnote 161-4: Cantillon, Nature du Commerce, etc.,
1755, is of opinion that a day laborer, to bring up two
children until they are grown, needs about as much as he
does for his own support; and that his wife may, as a rule,
support herself by her own work. (42 ff.) In Germany, it is
estimated that, in the case of day laborers, a woman can
earn only from 1/3 to 1/2 of what her husband does; mainly
because she is so frequently incapacitated for work by
pregnancy, nursing, etc. (Rau, Lehrbuch, I, § 190.) In
France, in 1832, a man working in the fields earned, on an
average, 1-1/4 francs a day, the wife 3/4 of a franc (200
days to the year), the three children 38/100 francs (250
days to the year), an aggregate of 650 francs per annum.
(Morogues.) In England, the average amount earned in the
country was for males, per annum, £27 17s.; (munications
relative to the Support and Maintenance of the Poor, 1834,
p.
LXXXVIII.) The wife of an English field hand, without
children, earns 1/3 more than one with children. In the case
of mothers, a difference of fewer or more children is
unnoticeable in the effects on wages. (London Statist.
Journal, 1838, 182.) In the spinning factories in
Manchester, in 1834, children between 9 and 10 years of age
were paid, weekly, from 2s. 9d. to 2s. 10d.; between 10 and
12, from 3s. 6d. to 3s. 7d.; between 12 and 14, from 5s. 8d.
to 5s. 9d.; between 14 and 16, from 7s. 5d. to 7s.
6d.
(Report of the Poor Commissioners, 204.) Those manufactures
which require great physical strength, like carpet and
sail-cloth weaving, and those carried on in the open air and
in all kinds of weather, allow of no such family competition
and debasement of wages. (Senior in the Report of the
parliamentary Committee on Hand Weavers, 1841.)]
[Footnote 161-5: Similarly, J. Möser, Patriot. Phant., I,
40. Adam Smith infers from the following symptoms in a
country that wages are higher there than the indispensable
minimum, viz.: if wages in summer are higher than in winter,
since it is seldom that enough is saved in summer to satisfy
the more numerous wants of winter; if wages vary less from
year to year and more from place to place than the means of
subsistence, it they are high even where the means of
subsistence are cheapest. (Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 8.)]
SECTION CLXII.
COST OF PRODUCTION OF LABOR.
The idea conveyed by the expression necessaries of life is, within certain limits, a relative one. In warm countries, a workman's family needs less clothing, shelter, fuel and even food[162-1] than in cold countries. This difference becomes still more striking when the warm countries possess absolutely cheaper food as, for instance, rice, Turkish wheat, bananas etc.
Here, evidently, other circumstances being the same, the rate of wages may be lower.[162-2] The cultivation of the potato has operated in the same direction; since an acre of land planted with potatoes yields, on an average, twice as much food as the same acre planted with rye.[162-3] In France, two-thirds of the population lived almost without animal food, on chestnuts, Indian corn, and potatoes (Dupin), while in England, malt, hops, sugar, brandy, tea, coffee, tobacco, soap, newspapers, etc. are described as "articles chiefly used by the laboring classes." (Carey.)
The standard of decency of the working class also has great influence here. The use of blouses in Paris has nothing repulsive, nor that of wooden shoes in many of the provinces of France, nor the absence of shoes in lower Italy; while the English workman considers leather shoes indispensable, as he did only a short time ago a cloth coat. Compare infra, § 214.[162-4]
[Footnote 162-1: Explained since Liebig's time by the fact
that a part of food is consumed to preserve animal heat:
means of respiration in contradistinction to means of
nutrition. Recent research has shown that in cold weather
more urea and also more carbonic acid are given off; hence
the means of supplying this deficit should be greater in
cold weather than in warm. This more rapid transformation is
wont, when nutrition is sufficient, to be accompanied by
more energetic activity. (Moleschott, Physiologie der
Nahrungsmittel, 1850, 47, 50, 83.)]
[Footnote 162-2: This is opposed in part by the fact that a
hot climate induces indolence, and that therefore he needs a
greater incentive to overcome his disposition to idleness.
Thus, in the cooler parts of Mexico, the rate of wages was
26 sous a day, in the warmer, 32 sous. (Humboldt, N.
Espagne, III, 103.)]
[Footnote 162-3: According to Engel, Jahrbuch für Sachsen,
I, 419, on acres similarly situated and under similar
conditions, the lowest yielded:
_Watery contents Watery contents
included. excluded._
Of wheat, 1,881 lbs. 1,680 lbs.
" rye, 1,549 " 1,404 "
" pease, 1,217 " 1,095 "
" potatoes, 21,029 " 5,257 "
The dry substance of these products yielded:
_Azotized Mineral
Substance. Fecula. Matter._
Wheat, 282 lbs. 879 lbs. 49 lbs.
Rye, 243 " 661 " 34 lbs.
Pease, 309 " 431 " 33 lbs.
Potatoes, 525 " 3,785 " 178 lbs.
In Saxony, from 1838 to 1852, the average prices stood as
follows:
Of Rye. Of Wheat. Of Potatoes.
One lb. of dry substance, 1 1.28 .95
One lb. of protein substance, 1 1.11 1.78
One lb. of fecula, 1 1.14 0.72
(loc. cit.) The high price of protein in wheat depends
probably on the more agreeable appearance and pleasanter
taste of wheat flour; the still higher price of potato
protein on the exceedingly easy mode of its preparation.]
[Footnote 162-4: As regards food alone, the cost of the
support of a plowman on Count Podewil's estate, reduced by
Rau, Lehrbuch, § 191, to the unit of rye, is annually
1,655 lbs. of rye. According to Koppe, it is 1,952 lbs.;
to Block, 2,300 lbs.; to Kleemann, from 1,888 to 2,552
lbs.; to Möllenger, 2,171 lbs. The first three estimate
the cost in meat at 78, 160 and 60 pounds. Compare Block,
Beitr. Z. Landgüterschätzungskunde, 1840, 6.
Exhaustive
estimates for all Prussian governmental districts in von
Reden, Preussische Erwerbs, und Verkehrsstatistik, 1853, I,
177 ff., according to which the requirement, per family,
varies between 71 thalers in Gumbinnen and 204 thalers in
Coblenz, the average being 105 thalers. According to more
recent accounts, a laborer's family in East Prussia, gangmen
not included, get along very well on 177 thalers per annum.
(von der Goltz, Ländl. Arbeiterfrage, 1872, 9 ff.) In
Mecklenburg, omitting Hofgänger, on 183 thalers. (Ann.
des. patr. Vereins, 1865, No. 26.)
The necessary outlay of the family of an agricultural day
laborer in England, in 1762, was estimated as follows: for
bread and flour, £6 10s. per annum; for vegetables and
fruit, £1 1-2/3s.; for fuel, light and soap, 2-9-5/6s.; for
milk, butter and cheese, £1 1-6-5/6s.; for meat, £1 6s.; for
house-rent, 1-6s.; for clothing, bedding, etc., 2-16-1/3s.;
for salt, beer and colonial wares, 1-16-5/6s.; for medicine,
expenses attending confinement of wife, etc., 1-6-1/2s. (J.
Wade, History of the middle and working Classes, 1853,
545.) Concerning 1796, compare Sir F. M.
Eden, State of
the Poor, I, 660, 1823; Lowe, on the present Condition of
England. Compare on the receipts and expenses of ten working
families in and about Mühlhausen, the tables in the Journal
des Economistes, October, 1861, 50; and further
Ducpétiaux, Budgets économiques des Classes ouvrières en
Belgique, 1855. According to Playfair in Knop,
Agriculturchemie, I, 810, ff., different classes of grown
men need daily food.
+=========+========+========+========+
GRAMMES. | 1. | 2. | 3. | 4. | 5.
------------------+---------+--------+--------+--------+--------
Plastic material, | 56.70 | 70.87 | 119.07 | 155.92 | 184.27
Fat, | 14.70 | 28.35 | 51.03 | 70.87 | 70.87
Starch, | 340.20 | 340.20 | 530.15 | 567.00 | 567.00
## +=========+========+========+========+
Here 1 stands for a convalescent who can bear only enough to
preserve life; 2, the condition of rest; 3, moderate motion
of from 5 to 6 English miles' walk daily; 4, severe labor =
a walk of 20 English miles daily; 5, very severe labor = to
a day's walk of 14 English miles, with a load weighing 60
lbs. If the fat be given in terms of starch, the aggregate
need of both substances in the case of 1 is 6.6 times as
great as the need of plastic substance; in the case of 2, 3,
4, and 5, respectively 5.7, 5.2, 4.8 and 4.0 times as much.
A Dutch soldier doing garrison duty receives daily, in times
of peace, 0.333 kilogrammes of wheat flour, 0.125 of meat,
0.850 of potatoes, 0.250 of vegetables, containing in the
aggregate 60 grammes of albumen. In forts, where the service
is more severe, he receives 0.50 kilogrammes of wheat flour,
0.06 of rice or groats, with an aggregate amount of 116
grammes of albumen. (Mulder, Die Ernährung in ihrem
Zusammenhange mit dem Volksgeiste, übersetzt von
Molecshott, 1847, 58 seq.) According to the researches of
Dr.
Smith, in order to avoid the diseases caused by hunger,
a man needs, on an average, to take 4,300 grains of carbon
and 200 grains of nitrogen in his daily food; a woman 3,900
grains of carbon and 180 grains of nitrogen.
In 1862, the
workmen in the famishing cotton industries of Lancashire
were actually reduced to just about this minimum. (Marx,
Kapital, I, 642.) Death from starvation occurs in all
vertebrates when the loss of weight of the body, produced by
a want of food, amounts to between two-fifths and one-half
of what it was at the beginning of the experiment.
(Chossat, Recherches expérimentales sur l'Inanition, 184,
3.)]
SECTION CLXIII.
WAGES OF LABOR.--POWER OF THE WORKING CLASSES
OVER THE RATE OF WAGES.
In this way, the working classes hold in their own hands one of the principal elements which determine the rate of wages; and it is wrong to speak of an "iron law" which, under the control of supply and demand, always reduces the average wages down to the means of subsistence.[163-1] For the moment, indeed, not only individual workmen, but the whole working class is master of the supply of its commodity only to a very small extent; since, as a rule, the care for existence compels it to carry, and that without interruption, its whole labor-power to market.
But it is true that the future supply depends on its own will; since, with an increase or decrease in the size of the families of workingmen, that supply increases or diminishes. If, therefore, by a favorable combination of circumstances, wages have risen above the height of urgent necessity, there are two ways open to the working class to take advantage of that condition of things.
The workman either raises his standard of living, which means not only that his necessary wants are better satisfied, his decencies increased and refined, but also and chiefly, that the intellectual want of a good prospect in the future, which so particularly distinguishes the honorable artisan from the proletarian is taken into consideration. And it is just here that a permanent workingmen's union, which should govern the whole class, might exert the greatest influence.
Their improved economic state can be maintained only on condition that the laboring class shall create families no larger than they hope to be able to support consistently with their new wants.[163-2]
Or, the laboring class continues to live on as before, from hand to mouth, and employ their increased resources to gratify their sexual appetite earlier and longer than before, thus soon leading to an increase of population.
The English took the former course in the second quarter of the last century, when English national economy received a powerful impetus, and the large demand for labor rapidly enhanced the rate of wages. The Scotch did in like manner a generation later. The second alternative was taken by the Irish, when the simultaneous spread of the cultivation of the potato[163-3] and the union with England, at the beginning of the nineteenth century, gave an extraordinary extension to their resources of food. While the population of Great Britain, between 1720 and 1821, did little more than double, the population of Ireland increased from 2,000,000 to nearly 7,000,000 between 1731 and 1821.
No wonder, therefore, that the average wages of labor was twenty to twenty-four pence per day in the former, and in the latter only five pence. (MCCulloch.)[163-4]
Naturally enough, this difference of choice by the two peoples is to be explained by the difference in their previous circumstances. The Irish people, robbed by violence of their own higher classes, and, therefore, and on this account precisely, almost entirely destitute of a middle class, had lost the check on increase they possessed in the middle ages, without having as yet assimilated to themselves the checks which come with a higher stage of culture.
Their political, ecclesiastical and social oppression allowed them no hope of rising by temporary sacrifices and energetic efforts permanently to a better condition as citizens or gentlemen. Only the free man cares for the future. Hence, the sexual thoughtlessness and blind good nature, the original tendencies of the Irish people, necessarily remained without anything to counterbalance them.
It always supposes a high degree of intelligence and self-restraint among the lower classes, when an increase in the thing-value, or the real value of wages, does not produce an increase in the number of workmen, but in their well-being. The individual is too apt to think that it matters little to the whole community whether he brings children into the world or not, a species of egotism which has done most injury to the interests in common of mankind.
As a rule, it requires a great and palpable enhancement of wages to make workmen, as a class, raise their standard of living.[163-5] [163-6]
[Footnote 163-1: Compare Lassalle, Antwortschreiben an das
Central Comite zur Berufung eines allg. deutschen
Arbeitercongresses, 1863, 15; also Turgot, sur la
Formation etc., § 6. When Lassalle says that when a varied
standard of living has become a national habit it ceases to
be felt as an improvement, he says what is in a certain
sense true. But is the man to be pitied who, absolutely
speaking, is getting on well enough; relatively speaking,
better off than before; but who is only not better off than
other men?]
[Footnote 163-2: A case in Holstein, in which, in the first
half of the eighteenth century, the serfs of a hard master
conspired together not to marry, and thus soon forced him to
sell his estate. (Büsch, Darstellung der Handlung, V, 3,
## II.)]
[Footnote 163-3: On the otherwise remarkable economic
advance in Ireland about 1750, see Orrey, Letters
concerning the Life and Writings of Swift, 1751, 127;
Anderson, Origin of Commerce, a., 1751.]
[Footnote 163-4: Compare especially Malthus, Principles,
ch. 4, sec. 2. How little Adam Smith dreamt of this may be
best seen in I, 115, Bas. Recently, the average wages per
week amounted in England to 22-1/2s., in Scotland to
20-1/2s., in Ireland to 14-3/4s. (Levi, Wages and Earnings
of the working Classes, 1866.)]
[Footnote 163-5: Thus the unheard of long series of
excellent harvests in England, between 1715 and 1765,
contributed very largely to this favorable transformation.
Day wages expressed in wheat, between 1660 and 1719,
amounted on an average to only about 2/3 of a peck; between
1720 and 1750, to an entire peck. In the fifteenth century,
a similar series of good harvests contributed very much to
the flourishing condition of the "yeomanry." Under Henry
VII., workmen earned from two to three times as much corn as
they did a century later.
And so in France, the great
Revolution at the end of the eighteenth century, by setting
free a vast quantity of hitherto bound-up force, enhanced
the productiveness of the entire economy of the nation, and
made the division of the national income more nearly equal.
There is an essential connection here between the rapidity
of the transition and the facts, that the habits of
consumption of the working class received a powerful
impulse, and that population increased much less rapidly
than the national income. Compare John Stuart Mill,
Principles, II, ch. 11, 2.
In our own days again, English
workmen had a splendid opportunity to raise their standard
of life. Emigration to Australia, etc. preponderated over
the natural increase of population to such an extent that,
in 1852, for instance, only 217,000 more human beings were
born in England and Wales than died, and 368,000 emigrated.
At the same time, exports increased: in 1849, they were
£63,000,000; in 1850 £71,000,000; about the end of 1853,
something like £90,000,000.
This golden opportunity was used by the English laboring
classes to both largely multiply marriages and to enhance
the rate of wages. The number of marriages contracted in
England yearly, from 1843 to 1847, was 136,200; from 1853 to
1857, 159,000. The number of births annually, from 1843 to
1847, was 544,800; from 1853 to 1857, 640,400. And wages, in
a number of industries, rose, between 1839 and 1859, from
about 18 to 24 per cent. (Quarterly Review, July, 1860, 86),
while the prices of most of the necessaries of life
declined.
That, in the same time, the condition of English
laborers was elevated, both intellectually and morally, is
proved by many facts cited in Jones' and Ludlow's work on
the social and political condition of the laboring classes
in England. In Germany, the recent establishment of peace on
a firm footing and the French war contributions have given
the country an impulse which might be taken advantage of by
the laboring class with the happiest results if they would
accustom themselves to more worthy wants and at the same
time preserve their accustomed industry.]
[Footnote 163-6: The cheapening of the necessaries of life,
experience shows, is more likely to lead to an increase of
population; that of luxuries, to a raising of the standard
of life or of comfort.]
SECTION CLXIV.
WAGES.--COST OF PRODUCTION OF LABOR.
As the cheapening of the means of subsistence, when the circle of wants of the laboring class has not correspondingly increased, leads to a decline of wages, so an enhancement of their price must, when wages are already so low as only to be able to satisfy indispensable wants, produce an increase in the rate of wages.
The transition in the former case is as pleasing as in the latter it is replete with the saddest crises.[164-1] The slower the rise in the price of the means of subsistence is, the more it is to be feared that the working classes will seek to meet it, not by emigration or by a diminished number of marriages, but by decreasing the measure of their wants, the introduction of a poorer quality of food, etc.[164-2]
However, all this is true only of permanent changes in the average price of the means of subsistence, such as are produced, for instance, by the development of agriculture, by taxation etc. Transitory fluctuations, such as result, for instance, from a single good or bad harvest, cannot have this result.[164-3] It is, in poor countries at least, one of the worst effects of a bad harvest, that it tends to positively lower the rate of wages.
A multitude of persons who would otherwise be able to purchase much labor are now deterred from doing so, by the enhancement of the price of food.[164-4] On the other hand, the supply increases: many men who before would not work even for money, see themselves now compelled to do so. Those who have been workmen hitherto are compelled by want to make still greater exertions.[164-5]
In very cheap years, all this is naturally reversed.[164-6]
[Footnote 164-1: According to McCulloch, Edition of Adam
Smith, 472, the food of a day laborer's family constitutes
between 40 and 60 per cent. of their entire support. In the
case of Prussian field hands, it is generally 54 per cent.
greatest in the province of Saxony, viz., 58 per cent. and
lowest in Posen, 43 per cent. Compare Rau, Lehrbuch, I, §
191. This may serve as a point of departure, from which to
measure the influence of a given enhancement of the price of
corn.
In opposition to Buchanan (Edition of Adam Smith,
1817, 59), who had denied the influence of the price of the
means of subsistence on the rate of wages, see Ricardo,
Principles, ch. 16.]
[Footnote 164-2: How easily English farmers have accustomed
themselves to the consequences of momentary calamities, may
be seen from John Stuart Mill, Principles, II, ch. 11, 5
seq.; Thornton, Population and its Remedy, 1846, passim.
Malthus, Principles, sec. 8, shows in opposition to
Ricardo, Principles, ch. 8, that it is not all one to the
laboring classes whether their wages rise while the price of
the means of subsistence remains the same, or whether the
rate of wages remaining nominally the same, the commodities
to be purchased decline in price.
If for instance,
potato-food, physiologically considered, was just as good as
flesh-food and wheat bread, yet an unmarried workman or a
father with a number of children below the average would be
able to save less from the former for the reason that it
possesses less value in exchange. (Edinburg Rev., XII, 341.)
Thus, e. g., in Ireland, between A.
Young and Newenham
(1778-1808), the rate of wages increased more than the price
of potatoes, but all other means of subsistence in a still
greater ratio. (Newenham, A view of Ireland, 1808.)
Compare Malthus, On the Policy of Restricting the
Importation of foreign Corn, 1815, 24 ff.; contra.
Torrens, on the Corn trade, 1820, 374 ff.]
[Footnote 164-3: Compare Garve in MacFarlan, On
Pauperism, 1785, 77. Thus, in the United States, the same
quantities of coffee, leather, pork, rice, salt, sugar,
cheese, tobacco, wool, etc., could be earned in 1836 by 23.5
days' labor; in 1840, by 20.75; in 1843, by 14.8; in 1864,
by 34.6. (Walker, Science of Wealth, 256.)]
[Footnote 164-4: The person who formerly consumed perhaps
four suits of clothes in a year now limits himself to two,
and forces the tailor to dismiss one journeyman. In Bavaria,
the dear times, 1846-47, and probably also the disturbances
of 1848-49, caused officials, pensioners, annuitants and
professional men to discharge one-tenth of the female
domestics they employed in 1840. (Hermann, Staatsw.
Unters, II, Aufl., 467.)]
[Footnote 164-5: The labor of digging during the time of
scarcity in England was paid one-third of the price usually
paid in good years. (Porter, Progress of the Nation, III,
14, 454.) On the Slavic portions of Silesia, see
Hildebrand's Jahrb., 1872, I, 292. According to Rogers,
I, 227 ff., 315 ff., and the table of prices in the appendix
to Eden, State of the Poor, the price in England of a
quarter of wheat and a day's wages was, in--
1287, 2s. 10-1/4d. 3d.
1315, 14s. 10-7/8d. 3d.
1316, 15s. 11-7/8d. 3-7/8d.
1392, 3s. 2-5/8d. 5d.
1407, 3s. 4d. 3d.
1439, 8s.-26s. 8d. 4-1/2d.
1466, 5s. 8d. 4-6d.
1505, 6s. 8d. 4d.
1575, 20s. 8d.
1590, 21s. 3-6d.
1600, 10d.]
[Footnote 164-6: Petty, Several Essays on Political
Arithmetic, 133 ff. Adam Smith, Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 8.
Ricardo, Principles, ch. 9. In Hesse, in consequence of a
series of many rich harvests from 1240 to 1247, no servants
could be had at all, so that the nobility and clergy were
obliged to till their own lands. (Anton, Gesch. der
deutschen Landwirthschaft, 111, 209.)]
SECTION CLXV.
WAGES.--THE DEMAND FOR LABOR.
The demand for labor, as for every other commodity, depends, on the one hand, on the value in use of it, and on the other, on the purchaser's capacity to pay for it (his solvability), These two elements determine the maximum limit of wages, as the means of support considered indispensable by the workmen determine the minimum. There are circumstances conceivable under which the rise in wages might entirely eat up rents; but there must always be a portion of the national income reserved to reward capital (its profit).
If wages were to absorb the latter also, the mere owner of capital would cease to have any interest in the progress of production. Capital would then be withdrawn from employment and consumed.[165-1] Obviously, no man engaged in any enterprise can give more as wages to his workmen than their work is worth to him.[165-2] Hence the additional product in any branch of industry, due to the labor of the workman last employed, has a controlling influence on the rate of the wages which can be paid to his fellow workmen.
If the additional products of the workmen successively last employed constitute a diverging series,[165-3] the last term in the series is the natural expression of the unsurpassable maximum of wages; if they constitute a converging series, men the employer can pay the last workman higher wages than the additional product due to him; provided, however, that the reduction which is to be expected in the case of the workmen previously employed to the same level still leaves him a sufficiently high rate of profit.[165-4] Hence the growing skill of a workman, in and of itself, makes an increase of his wages possible;[165-5] while, conversely, if he can be replaced by capital, which always relatively decreases the value in use of his labor, there is a consequent pressure on his wages.
[Footnote 165-1: Storch, Handbuch, I, 205 seq.]
[Footnote 165-2: Higher wages promised, for instance, as a
reward for saving a human life or some other very precious
thing in great danger of being destroyed. In the case of
material production, labor is worth to the party engaged in
the enterprise, at most, as much as the price of the product
after the remaining cost of reproducing it is deducted.]
[Footnote 165-3: Possibly in consequence of a better
division of labor or of some other advance made in the
technic arts.]
[Footnote 165-4: Thus, for instance, in harvesting potatoes,
if, after they have been ploughed up, only those nearest the
surface are collected, a laborer can gather over thirty
Prussian scheffels in a day. But the fuller and completer
the gathering of potatoes desired is, the smaller will be
the product of one workman and of one day's labor. If,
therefore, a man wants to gather even the last bushel in a
potato field of 100 square rods, so much labor would be
required to accomplish it that the workman would not gather
enough to feed him during his work, to say nothing of
supplying his other wants.
Supposing that 100 scheffels of
potatoes had grown on 100 square rods, and that of these
were harvested--
_When the number of Then the additional yield
men employed in obtained by the
gathering them was last workman employed is_
4, 80 scheffels,
5, 86.6 " 6.6 scheffels.
6, 91 " 4.4 "
7, 94 " 3 "
8, 96 " 2 "
(von Thünen, Der isolirte Staat, II, 174 ff.)]
[Footnote 165-5: In Manchester, in 1828, the wages paid for
spinning one pound of cotton yarn, No. 200, was 4s. 1d.; in
1831, only from 2s. 5d. to 2s. 8d. But, in the former year,
the spinner worked with only 312 spools; in the latter, with
648; so that his wages increased in the ratio of 1274 to
1566. (Senior, Outlines.)]
SECTION CLXVI.
WAGES.--PRICE OF COMMON LABOR.
In the case of a commodity as universally desired as human labor is, the idea of the purchasers' capacity to pay (solvability) must be nearly commensurate with the national income, or to speak more correctly, with the world's income.[166-1] In regard to the different kinds of labor, and especially to common labor, it is evident that the different kinds of consumption require very different quantities of them.
Here, therefore, we depend on the direction which national consumption takes, and this in turn is most intimately related to the distribution of the national income.[166-2] If all workmen were employed in nothing but the production of articles consumed by workmen, the rate of wages would be determined almost exclusively by the ratio between the number of the working population and the amount of the national income.
But, if this were the case, landowners and capitalists would be obliged to live just as workmen do, and their highest luxury would have to consist in feeding idlers. (§ 226).
The effect must be much the same, when the wealthy are exceedingly frugal and employ their savings as rapidly as possible in the employment of common home labor; while, on the other hand, the exportation of wheat, wood, and other articles, which the working classes consume, in exchange for diamonds, lace, champagne, diminishes the efficient demand for common labor in a country.[166-3]
The assumption frequently made, that the demand for labor depends on the size of the national capital, is far from exact.[166-4] Thus, for instance, every transformation of circulating into fixed capital, especially when the labor used in effecting this transformation is ended, diminishes the demand for other labor. That principle is not unconditionally true, even in the case of circulating capital.
Thus, for instance, the rate of wages is wont to be raised by the transfer of capital from such businesses as require little labor into such as require much.[166-5] Only that part of circulating capital can have any weight here which is intended, directly or indirectly, for the purchase of labor and for the purchase of each kind of labor in particular.[166-6] The capital of the employer is, by no means, the real source[166-7] of the wages of even the workmen employed by him, It is only the immediate reservoir through which wages are paid out, until the purchasers of the commodities produced by that labor make good the advance, and thereby encourage the undertaker to purchase additional labor.
Correlated to this is the fact, that other circumstances being the same, those workmen usually receive the highest wages who have to do most immediately with the consumer.[166-8]
[Footnote 166-1: Senior denies this. Let us suppose that
agriculture in Ireland employs on every 200 acres ten
working men's families, one-half of whom are used to satisfy
the aggregate wants of the working people, and the other
half in the production of wheat to be exported to England.
If now the English market requires meat and wool instead of
wheat, the Irish landowner will, perhaps, find it
advantageous, of the ten laboring families, to employ one in
stock raising, a second in obtaining food, etc. to support
the laborers, and to discharge all the others.
If, then, the
increased net product is employed in the purchase of other
Irish labor, all goes on well enough; but if, instead of
this, the landowners should import articles of English
manufacture, the demand for labor in Ireland would doubtless
decrease, notwithstanding the increase of its income.
(Outlines, I, 154.) Senior here overlooks two things:
first, that in the supposed case, if eight-ninths of Irish
laborers are thrown out of employment, spite of the
increased income of the owners of landed estates, Ireland's
national income is on the whole probably diminished (§ 146),
and secondly, that, possibly, the demand for labor in
England experiences a greater increase than the decrease in
Ireland; since, with the addition to the world-income, there
would be an increase in the world-demand for labor.]
[Footnote 166-2: Compare Hermann, Staatswirthsch.
Untersuch., 280 ff. Earlier yet, Malthus, Principle of
Population, II, ch. 13.]
[Footnote 166-3: Thus, Thomas More, Utopia, 96, 197,
thinks that if every one was industrious and engaged in only
really useful business, no one would need to fatigue himself
very much; while, as it is now, the few real laborers there
are wear themselves out in the service of the vanity of the
rich, are poorly fed and worked exceedingly hard.]
[Footnote 166-4: McCulloch, Principles, 104, seq. 2d ed.]
[Footnote 166-5: Thus, in France, during the continental
blockade, distant ocean commerce declined, and manufactures
flourished instead. (Lotz, Revision, III, 134.)]
[Footnote 166-6: Thus, Adam Smith divides "the funds
destined for the payment of wages" into two kinds: the
excess of employers' income over their own maintenance, and
the excess of their capital over the demands of their own
use of it. (Wealth of Nat, I, ch.
8.) Senior considers it
a self-evident principle, that the rate of wages depends on
the size of the "fund for the maintenance of laborers
compared with the number of laborers to be maintained."
(Three Lectures on the Rate of Wages, 1830, Outlines, 153,
ff.) But what determines the quota of the aggregate national
wealth and national income that is to constitute this fund?
Carey, Rate of Wages, 1835, has a very exhaustive
commentary on Senior.]
[Footnote 166-7: Watts, Statist. Journal, 1861, 500,
asserts altogether too generally that an "increase of profit
increases the future wages-fund, and consequently the demand
for laborers;" and that therefore every new machine useful
in manufactures must also be of use to the laboring class.
The employer engaged in any enterprise who has grown richer,
can pay more wages, but whether he will do it depends on
other causes, and even his ability to do it, in the long
run, on his customers. When John Stuart Mill, Principles,
I, ch.
5, 9, says that only the capital which comes into the
hands of labor before the completion of their work
contributes to their support, it is as if he were to explain
the phenomena of prices by demand and supply, and nothing
else, denying the influence of the cost of production, of
value in use, and of the deeper determining causes upon
them. (Supra, § 107, note 1.) Compare Roesler, Z. Kritik
der Lehre vom Arbeitslohn, 1861, 104 ff. In England, the
superstition which to a great extent attached to the idea
"wages-fund," was first questioned by F.
Longe, Refutation
of the Wages-Fund Theory of modern Political Economy, 1866.
See also Thornton, On Labour, II, ch. 1. Even John Stuart
Mill dropped his earlier erroneous views on this subject.
(Fortnightly Review, May and June, 1869.) Not, however,
without exaggeration, as is proved by his well-known saying,
that laborers needed capital but no capitalists. Still, even
here, he tenaciously holds that a rise in wages which
increases the price of some classes of commodities, must
decrease the aggregate demand for commodities.
But better
paid workmen may now increase their demand for commodities
to the same extent that the purchasers of labor who do not
gain as much as before, or the consumers of the goods whose
price has been enhanced diminish theirs. (Brentano, in
Hildebrand's Jahrbb., 1871, 374.) Only, this increase need
not affect the very commodities influenced by the decrease.]
[Footnote 166-8: Thus, the person who builds his own house
is wont to pay his workmen better than a contractor or
builder by profession; and the maker of the entire
manufactured article, as a rule, suffers less frequently
than the maker of only half of it. (Hermann, Staatsw.
Unters., II, Aufl., 471.)]
SECTION CLXVII.
DIFFERENCE OF WAGES IN DIFFERENT BRANCHES OF LABOR.
All the causes which make wages higher in some branches of labor; than in others, may be divided into three great categories.[167-1]
A. Rare personal acquirements. The supply of labor requiring rare personal ability will always be limited.[167-2] Such labor must, naturally, have great value in use, when a small supply of it is met by a great demand.[167-3] It sometimes happens that a species of labor can be utilized only by a small circle of persons who demand it. But the wages for it is raised very high by the great solvability of those who do demand it.
How frequently it happens, for instance, that a minister is paid a very high salary for the ability he possesses of making complicated and dry affairs of state attractive to the personal taste of his sovereign.[167-4] Here, particularly, the confidence which the workman inspires by his skill and fidelity enters as an element.
Without this confidence, there are many kinds of business which would be crushed out entirely by the control it would be necessary to subject them to, and others would not be possible at all.[167-5] When, for instance, in a large manufacturing establishment, understrappers, workmen, foremen, subordinate superintendents, directors, etc., draw different salaries, their pay, if equitably graduated, should be in harmony with the principles laid down in § 148, The head of a manufacturing establishment, for instance, who has organized a more perfect division and coöperation of labor, himself, and by means of which ten men are enabled to perform the work before performed by twenty, may equitably retain, as the reward of his organizing power, a considerable amount of what was previously paid out in wages.
Louis Blanc's proposition, that all should receive equal salaries is, as Bastiat remarks, equivalent to the assertion that a yard of cloth manufactured by a lazy or unskillful workman is worth as much as two yards manufactured by an industrious and skillful one.[167-6]
Such qualified labor, as is treated of here, may be most accurately estimated, the quality of which supposes a certain cost of acquisition.
This cost may be considered as the outlay of so much capital, which, with interest,[167-7] should come back to the workman in his wages.
Otherwise, others would be deterred from entering the same business by the example of his loss.
Here, especially, it is necessary to take into account the long period of apprenticeship or tuition, and the large fees paid for the same; and this, whether they depend on the natural difficulties in the way of acquirement or on artificial obstacles opposed to freedom of competition.[167-8] The influence of these circumstances is particularly great in those kinds of labor which require a "liberal" education.[167-9] Among the costs of production proper, peculiar to this labor-force, must be included, also, the necessary support of the workman, during the interval between the completion of his studies and the beginning of his full reward.[167-10]
When a species of work requires special current expenses to be made in order to its proper performance, these also should of course be made good to the workman in his wages. Most intellectual labor, for instance, requires quiet surroundings. The brain-worker cannot share his study with his family, and, therefore should receive wages or remuneration large enough in amount to enable him to arrange his dwelling accordingly. A similar circumstance, only in a much higher degree, enhances the price paid for diplomatic service.
[Footnote 167-1: Excellent germs thereof in Adam Smith,
Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 10, 1. Earlier yet, in Galiani,
Della Moneta, I, 2. Cantillon, Nature du Commerce, 24 ff.]
[Footnote 167-2: Even in the case of mere manual labor, for
instance, a skillful packer of goods is paid higher wages
than a mere day laborer; a sower better than a plowman or a
digger; a vintner, in general, better than an agricultural
laborer: in the Palatinate of the Rhine, in the ratio of
36:24. Thus, almost anyone can paint a door or a house,
while an artist possesses a species of natural monopoly.]
[Footnote 167-3: Thus, the Greek juggler, who understood how
to throw lintels from a certain distance through the eye of
a needle, was very appropriately rewarded by his king with a
bushel of lintels. On the other hand, the high fee paid for
an operation for cataract depends both on the great
importance of the eye which cannot be replaced in any way,
and on the rarity of the courage among doctors to pierce the
eye of a living man. Very remarkable achievements, which it
requires great education to understand, are generally paid
for at a very low rate. (Stein, Lehrbuch, 123.)]
[Footnote 167-4: I need only recall Richelieu and
Mazarin, the last of whom left an estate worth 200,000,000
livres. (Voltaire, Siècle de Louis XIV., ch. 6.) In
Parisian industries, few workmen are as well paid as those
who are skilled in rapidly effecting changes of form. The
so-called premières de modes frequently received more than
1,800 francs a year, while the apprêteuses received only
from 15 to 20 sous a day. (Revue des deux Mondes, Sept.
15,
1850.) There are women there paid very well for making
pin-cushions, pen-wipers, etc., each one of a different
form; but as soon as any one form ceases to be a novelty,
the wages paid for making it sinks to a minimum. (M. Mohl,
Gewerbswissenschaftliche Reise durch Frankreich, 87.)]
[Footnote 167-5: Jewelers, lawyers, statesmen, generals.
Senior says that of the income of £4,000 which a lawyer or
a doctor draws, only £40 are wages for his labor; £3,000 are
a rent paid for the possession of extraordinary talent, or
for his good luck, and £960 as the interest on his
intellectual capital, which is also the chief element of
wealth. (Outline, 134.)]
[Footnote 167-6: On the sad experience of the tailors'
association founded by Louis Blanc himself, at Clichy, and
in consequence of which they soon gave up paying equal wages
and returned to piece wages, see Journal des Economistes,
Mars, 1850, 349.]
[Footnote 167-7: As the interest on land improvements
assumes the character of rent, so also does that of the
education of labor the character of wages. The rate of
interest usual in a country, and the average duration of the
life of the workman affect the capital thus invested as a
species of annuity.]
[Footnote 167-8: Wages in the country are generally lower
than in the cities.
In the electorate of Hesse, for
instance, on the supposition of steady employment, males, in
the country, received 69 thalers, 23 silver groschens a
year; females, 55 thalers, 9 silver groschens; in the
cities, on the other hand, males, 88 thalers, 23 silver
groschens, and females 61 thalers, 28 silver groschens.
(Hildebrand, statistische Mittheilungen, 101, 137.) And
so, according to Colquhoun, Treatise on Indigence, 1806,
the English agricultural laborers received, on an average,
£31 per annum, and manufacturing workmen, £55.
The reason of
this is, besides the greater facility of learning how to
perform agricultural labor, the greater dearness of living
in cities, and in England also, because industry has
developed much more rapidly than agriculture.]
[Footnote 167-9: The cost of bringing up a common laborer,
in England, according to Senior, is £40; a gentleman,
£2,040. (Outlines, 205.) The more expensive an education
which one acquires for its own sake and without any special
object beyond this in view, is, the less can the capital
laid out in it affect wages. (von Mangoldt, V. W. L.,
382.)]
[Footnote 167-10: If the salaries of clergymen are, on an
average, lower than the income of a lawyer or a doctor, it
is partly because theological candidates are provided for
much earlier, and partly because of the lesser cost
attending the study of theology.
Thus, at the end of the
eighteenth century, there were 350 students at the
University of Tubingen who are maintained gratis, on
foundation-money, and who had previously attended monastery
schools, free of charge. (Nicolai, Reisebescreibungen, XI,
73.) The remarkable contrast between the high wages of the
Athenian sophists and the low wages of modern abbés, Adam
Smith accounts for principally by the many scholarships of
modern times. In Saxony, in 1850 etc., the outlay by the
state and of foundation-funds for the education of a student
amounted to an average of nearly 140 thalers. (Engel.)]
SECTION CLXVIII.
DIFFERENCE OF WAGES IN DIFFERENT BRANCHES OF LABOR. (CONTINUED.)
B. The great economic risk of the work. When a branch of labor necessary to a country is, notwithstanding, attended by many chances of failure to the individual who devotes himself to it, a sufficient supply of the labor can be relied on only in case that the danger attending it is compensated for by a corresponding premium paid to success.[168-1] The choice of a profession or avocation, Adam Smith has compared to a lottery, in which the fortunate winners gain only what the unfortunate have lost.
The greater the prizes, the greater also the number of blanks.[168-2] However, the surplus wages in risky kinds of labor are not sufficient to constitute a full insurance premium. This is connected with the vanity of men who, as a rule, over-estimate not only their talent but their good fortune,[168-3] and especially in youth, when they decide on the choice of a profession, etc. According to this, wages must be specially low where even complete failure does not endanger the living or the social position of the workman.
Partly on this account are the industries carried on by women so poorly remunerated;[168-4] as also such work as is done by a large class of people to fill up their leisure hours.[168-5]
The prospect of frequent interruptions in any kind of labor must have the same effect on the wages paid for it as its economic or business risk.[168-6] Thus, for instance, a mason or roofer must earn at least enough, during the days he can work, to enable him to live during the time he is prevented working by bad weather. Hence, the highness of his wages may, in some respects, be called an apparent one.[168-7] Wages paid by the week more generally tend to equality than wages paid by the day, and more so yet wages paid by the year, for then winter and summer compensate the one for the other.
When the workman must be ever ready to perform his task, account must be taken not only of the number of hours he is engaged, but also of fractions of his waiting hours, which must be paid for likewise.[168-8] Two half days cost almost everywhere more than one whole one.
The number of holidays plays a very important part here. In Protestant countries, the workman must, in about three hundred work days, earn enough to live on for about sixty holidays as well. In Catholic countries, before the time of Clement XIV., he had to earn enough in addition to support himself for about one hundred and fifty holidays, on ninety of which he performed no work whatever.[168-9] So large a number of holidays produces a higher rate of wages or necessitates a low standard of life among the working classes.[168-10] Something similar is true of evening leisure and rest;[168-11] i. e., of the time when labor ceases.
[Footnote 168-1: The greater the preparatory cost of labor
is, the more difficult it is for workmen to go from one kind
of labor to another; but, at the same time, the more certain
it is that, without the inducement of a premium paid, there
will be no after increase or recruiting of labor-force.]
[Footnote 168-2: Thus, for instance, in the country, where
doctors generally get along well enough, the most skillful
never obtains any very distinguished position. But, in large
cities, on the other hand, there is the greatest difference
between first-class physicians and obscure practitioners.
Great generals usually obtain a larger income and greater
influence than great admirals; and so it is that prizes in
the military lottery are greater, and there are therefore
more blanks than in the naval lottery.
The common soldier is
almost everywhere worse paid than the common sailor. (Adam
Smith.) To some extent, this depends on the prison-like
life of the seaman in times of service, and in the absence
of an attractive uniform. As to the extent that the lottery
comparison is defective, see Macleod, Elements, 215.]
[Footnote 168-3: Who, otherwise, would have anything to do
with a lottery in which the mass of players were certain to
lose, and the keeper of it to gain?
And this accounts for
the fact well known to all financiers, that the amount of
the budget remaining the same, a greater eagerness to enter
the military service of the country is inspired by endowing
the higher positions munificently--provided they are
attainable by all--and paying the lower ones in a very
niggardly way, than when the pay is made more uniform.
Something similar is to be observed in the ecclesiastical
service of the Roman and Protestant churches, inasmuch as
the former, considered from an economic point of view,
offers more magnificent prizes, but also more blanks, while
the latter divides its emoluments more equally.]
[Footnote 168-4: As most seamstresses are, when the worst
comes to the worst, supported by their parents, connections
by marriage, brothers, etc., the condition of those who have
to live by their needle must be a pretty hard one. Who is
not familiar with the refrain to Hood's celebrated song of
the shirt: "Oh God, that bread should be so dear, and flesh
and blood so cheap!" There is a "distressed needlewoman's
society" in London.
They undoubtedly suffer from an
overcrowding of their avocation, yet their chief desire is
that the competition of all who do not live exclusively by
the labor of their hands should be prohibited; for instance,
that of seamstresses who are paid for their work outside of
factories. (Edinb. Rev., 1851, 24.) In Paris, in 1845, the
yearly earnings of women workers averaged 375 francs, their
yearly wants 500 francs. (Journal des Economistes, X, 250.)
This does not apply to female servants whose wages,
especially in highly cultured localities as the vicinity of
large cities (Holstein, Brandenburg), is very high.
In
England, the wages of female domestics is frequently higher
than in the United States; and hence nearly two-thirds of
all English girls between fifteen and twenty-five years of
age serve as maids. Browning, Political and Domestic
Condition of Great Britain, 413; Carey, Rate of Wages, 92.
A remarkable indication that women thrive only in the
family. (Compare § 250.)]
[Footnote 168-5: Thus, the darning of stockings in the sandy
parts of North Germany, in the Highlands of Scotland, in the
Faroe Islands, and formerly, even in the ante-rooms of the
Russian nobility. (Schlözer, Anfangsgründe der
Staatswirthsch, I, 126.) Flax spinning and linen weaving in
Westphalia and Ireland, and wool weaving in the East Indies.
Manufacturing industries must be in a very highly developed
condition, and machinery carried to a high degree of
perfection to compete in price with these accessory
industries. Cheapness of many products manufactured in
convents and monasteries.]
[Footnote 168-6: Among these interruptions, may also be
reckoned the prospect the laborer has of being early
incapacitated for work, and thus of seeing himself cut off
from every other source of support. This is one of the
principal reasons why opera singers are generally better
paid than actors.]
[Footnote 168-7: In Leipzig, in 1863, mason and carpenter
journeymen earned during the summer, from twenty silver
groschens to one thaler, ordinary garden workmen, 20 silver
groschens, while shoemaker journeymen did not make much more
than 3-1/2 thalers a week, and manual laborers, only from 10
to 15 silver groschens a day.
The masons of Paris have the
reputation of being the best patrons of the savings banks,
and, on that account, are more exposed to being attacked by
thieves than any other class. (Frégier, Des Classes
dangereuses, II, 3, 1.) High wages paid for threshing in
East Prussia, because, the workman during the winter can be
employed in very few different kinds of labor, and therefore
must earn his entire support by threshing.
In Paris, of
101,000 persons engaged in industry in 1860, 6,400 had to
calculate on no interruption of their work, the remaining
number, however, lost with a certain degree of regularity,
from 2 to 4 months a year. (Revue des deux Mondes, 15 Fév.,
1865.) If the interruption can be so accurately estimated in
advance that the workman may engage in some business for
himself during the interval, as for instance when the
workmen in the Bavarian breweries work during the summer as
masons, its influence on wages decreases. (Storch,
Handbuch, I, 192.) As to how, in Switzerland, since 1850,
the guaranty of full employment to masons in winter is
considered as an addition to the wages of summer, see
Böhmert, Arbeiterverhältnisse, I, 141.]
[Footnote 168-8: Commissionaires, hack-drivers,
Extraposthalter in Germany, porters, nurses, guides,
servants in watering places and countries visited by
tourists. A London porter gets at least a shilling an hour.
If employed by the day, he of course gets smaller wages.
Image venders, who travel from house to house, sell their
wares much lower at their own houses. The person who calls
them in from the street is obliged to pay them not only for
this one journey, but for several others which yielded them
no profit.]
[Footnote 168-9: If we call the minimum daily need or the
absolute requirement of the workman = m, the rate of daily
wages in the former case must amount to at least m + m/6; in
the latter, on the other hand, to m + m/4. A Bavarian
holiday estimated at a minus of much more than 1,000,000
florins. (Hermann, II, Anfl., 192.)]
[Footnote 168-10: Von Sonnenfels, Polit. Abhandlungen,
1777, 332 ff.]
[Footnote 168-11: In a part of Lower Bavaria, in which there
were 204 holidays in a year, among them the anniversaries of
the consecration of 40 churches in the country about, and a
feast day following each such anniversary, as well as
target-shooting festivals, the celebration begins at 4
o'clock P. M. of the preceding day. (Rau, Lehrbuch, I, §
193.)]
SECTION CLXIX.
THE DISAGREEABLENESS OF CERTAIN CLASSES OF LABOR.--ITS EFFECT ON WAGES.
C. Lastly, the personal disagreeableness of the work, which must be compensated for by higher wages. The uncleanness of a coal-worker's task, that of the chimney-sweep, and the repulsive labor of the butcher, demand high compensation, while other branches of business, themselves productive of pleasure, and therefore engaged in by many for pleasure's sake only, yield relatively little to those who engage in them as a regular industry.[169-1]
To this category belong the kinds of labor which require extraordinary effort,[169-2] or which put life or health in unusual jeopardy.[169-3] But, indeed, when the danger attending any kind of work is made glorious by the romantic light of honor, or by still higher motives, it ceases to have any influence on wages.[169-4] On the other hand, the disreputableness of a business in itself raises wages;[169-5] whereas, scholars, poets, etc., leaving the charm inherent in their occupations out of account, are for the most part remunerated only by the honor paid them, and, not unfrequently, only by fame after they have gone hence.[169-6] And yet their talents are so rare, the preparation so laborious, the economic risk so great!
Nor is there for the really creative workman any such thing as evening rest. (Riehl.) Common intellectual labor is worse paid in our days than it was, comparatively speaking, a generation ago; because the increased average education makes it less burthensome to most people, and even seem positively agreeable to many. It would, indeed, be a dangerous retrogressive step towards barbarism, if it should come to such a pass, that labor preponderantly intellectual should be permanently more poorly remunerated than mere muscular labor.[169-7] [169-8]
[Footnote 169-1: Thus the chase, fishing in rivers (compare
Theocrit., Idyll., 21), gardening, fine female manual
labor, and literature.]
[Footnote 169-2: The high wages paid to mowers and threshers
may be accounted for on this ground (§ 160). In countries
that have a strong heavy soil, wages are frequently 20 per
cent. higher than under circumstances otherwise similar
where it is sandy or light. In Mexico, a digger gets about
twice the wages of an agricultural laborer. (Senior, On
the Value of Money, 56.)]
[Footnote 169-3: Almost every trade predisposes to some
special disease. Compare Halfort, Enstehung, Verlauf und
Behandlung der Krankheiten der Künstler und
Gewerbetreibenden, 1845. Livy, Traité d'Hygiène publique
et privée, 1850, II, 755. It has been noticed, in Sheffield,
that thoughtless steel polishers look unfavorably on certain
new inventions intended to protect workmen against inhaling
small particles of stone and iron dust.
They dread that if
these inventions come into general use, their wages would be
lowered in consequence; and prefer a short and merry life to
one longer and more quiet.
In places in which nearly all kinds of work are dangerous,
the danger cannot of course relatively raise the wages of
anyone. Thus, in the Thuringian forest, the wages of the
haulers of wood are very low. (Lotz, Revision, III, 151.)]
[Footnote 169-4: Missionaries! Besides the extremely small
wages paid to common soldiers (in the German infantry only
36.5 thalers cash per annum, to which in Leipzig, for
instance, rations, etc., add about 34 thalers more) is an
outlay made by the government principally to effect a levy
of the tax of the compulsory labor that lies in
conscription. (Knies.) In the volunteer system, the
difference between officers and men is wont to be much
smaller.
Thus, Gustav Wasa paid his German mercenaries as
follows: 6 marks a month to captains, five to lieutenants
and 4 to common soldiers. (Geijer, Schwed. Gesch., II, 125
seq.) Similarly in the case of the Greek hired troops.
(Böckh, Staatshaushalt der Athener, I, 165 ff.) As to how
little at the outbreak of a war, soldier earnest money is
increased, and positions as officers most sought after, see
Hermann, II, Aufl., 479.]
[Footnote 169-5: Thus, for instance, the skinning or flaying
of dead animals is comparatively well paid, to which the
rarity of the application of the work of executioners
contributes. (J. Moser, Patr. Ph., I, No.
34.) The high
wages of actors, singers, dancers, and especially of the
female members of the stage, depends principally on the
contempt with which they were formerly looked upon;
excommunicated by the Catholic church, and a scarcely milder
sentence passed upon them by the Protestant, until about the
middle of the eighteenth century. (Schleiermacher,
Christliche Sitte, 681.) Compare even J. J. Rousseau,
Lettre sur les Spectacles à Mr. d'Alembert sur son Article
Genève.]
[Footnote 169-6: Schiller's "Theilung der Erde." Blanqui
says of the learned: "They are most frequently satisfied
with a citizen-crown, and think themselves remunerated when
justice has been done to their genius. Their magnanimity
impels them, to their own injury, to diffuse their knowledge
as rapidly as possible. Thus they are like the light of day
which no one pays for, but which all enjoy, without thanking
the giver as they ought." The reward of intellectual labor
is called an honorarium. (Riehl, Die Deutsche Arbeit,
1861, 232.) According to J. B.
Say, Traité, II, ch. 7, the
poor wages of savants depends on the fact that they take to
market, and all at once, a great quantity of what they
produce, which cannot even be used up.]
[Footnote 169-7: In Switzerland, journeymen are often better
paid than the clerks kept by the greater tradesmen.
(Böhmert, Arbeiterverhältnisse, II, 168.) In England,
also, since 1850, the wages for "unskilled labor" has risen,
relatively, most. (Tooke, Hist. of Prices, VI, 177.) It
would be a frightful peril to our whole civilization if
school teachers and subordinate officials should be turned
into enemies of the entire existing state of things by
want.]
[Footnote 169-8: The high wages paid to engineers on
railroads is accounted for by the wear, physical and mental,
their employment entails, and also by their unavoidable
expenses away from home; further, by the importance of the
interests confided to their trust. On the Leipzig-Dresden
Railway, locomotive engineers, for the most part previously
journeymen blacksmiths, earned 900 thalers a year.
Similarly, in the case of pilots.
The high wages paid on
board ships engaged in the slave-trade arose from the
unhealthiness of the African coast, where formerly
one-sixteenth of the crew died yearly (Edinburg Rev., 480),
from the moral turpitude of the business, and from the
severe penalties under which it was afterwards prohibited.
On the other hand, the low wages paid to European mining
laborers is largely the consequence of the certainty of
being cared for in old age, of those so employed.
Weavers'
wages are low because the facility of learning the trade
makes it possible for the business to be carried on at home;
and hence there is a comparatively great pressure to engage
in it. (Baines, History of the Cotton Manufacture, 485
ff.)
According to the first annual report of the poor law
commissioners (202), the weekly wages in Manchester of
hod-carriers was 12s.; of hand-weavers, 7-15s.; of diggers,
10-15s.,; of pack-carriers, 14-15s.; of shoemakers, 15-16s.;
of machine-weavers, 13-16-5/6s.; of white-washers, 18s.; of
tailors, 18s.; of dyers, 15-20s.; of plasterers, 19-21s.; of
masons, 18-22s.; of tinsmiths, 22-24s.; of carpenters, 24s.;
of spinners, 20-25s.; of machinists, 26-30s.; of iron
founders and power-loom tenders, 28-30s.
In Belgium, the
average daily wages for male labor was 1.18 francs for
agricultural laborers; for those engaged in industry, 1.48
francs; in the manufacture of linen, 0.80 francs; of cotton,
1.55; of woolens, 1.62; of silk, 1.25; of stockings, 1.14;
of glass, 2.58; of coal, 1.33. All according to the
Statistique générale de la B. In Athens, in the time of
Aristophanes, a pack-carrier earned 4 oboli a day; a street
sweeper, 3; a stone cutter on the public works, 6; a
carpenter, 5; for roofing houses and taking down
scaffoldings, each man, 6.
The architects who superintended
the building of the temple of Polias, on the other hand, got
only 6 oboli per day, and the contractor 5. (Böckh, I, 165
ff.)
The Edictum Diocletiani of the year 301 after Christ
contains the following provisions in relation to wages,
besides "board:" shepherds, camel-drivers and muleteers, 20
denarii; agricultural laborers, water-carriers, scavengers,
25; bakers, masons, roofers, house-finishers and repairers
of the inside, lime burners, wheelwrights and common clay
moulders, 50; boatsmen, sailors, makers of marble or mosaic
floors, 60; wall painters, 70; clay moulders for statues,
75; artistic painters, 150. (ed. Mommsen, cap.
7.) In
slave countries, the price of different slaves is to be
judged, mainly, by the above rules. Concerning the Greeks,
see Böckh, I, 95 ff. St. John, The Hellenes, III, 23 ff.
It is a characteristic fact that the Romans, after the
Syrian war, began to pay high prices for the hitherto much
despised kitchen slaves. (Livy, XXXIX, 6.) Remarkable
fixed prices for slaves by Justinian: Cod. VI, 43, 3; VII,
7, 1, 5. Thus, in the Lex Burgundionum, tit.
10, the
compensation for the murder of a common laborer is fixed at
30 solidi; of a carpenter, at 40; of a smith, at 50; of a
silversmith, at 100; of a goldsmith, at 150. Advanced
civilization is wont to raise the price of slaves who
perform work of a higher quality, just as it raises the
wages of labor of a higher quality.]
SECTION CLXX.
RATE OF WAGES.--INFLUENCE OF CUSTOM.
Custom always exerts a great influence where there is question of choosing an avocation with the intention of devoting one's self to it entirely and exclusively. There is a public opinion which fixes the gradation of the different classes of labor and their appropriate reward, which is slow to change, and which both determines, and is determined by the relation of supply and demand. There is an equilibrium between the pleasantness of work and the rate of wages only in the case of such kinds of labor as are on the same social footing.
It frequently happens, however, that the most repulsive work has to be performed by those who are forced to accept any pay and to be satisfied with it.[170-1] There are many branches of labor those engaged in which still form a kind of exclusive caste; and the pay of the higher branches is maintained at a high rate, especially by the fact that the members of the castes to which they belong are provident in their marriages.
The lower classes are not in a condition to meet the preparation necessary to engage in such professions, even if they were certain of being afterwards reimbursed with interest for the outlay.[170-2] One of the chief causes of the lowness of wages paid to women is, that so few branches of labor are traditionally open to them, that the few that are, are intended to supply luxuries, and are, besides, for the most part, over-crowded.
The distribution of the aggregate wages earned by any industry, among the higher and lower classes of workmen who coöperate in it, depends very largely on their social position relatively to one another.[170-3] [170-4] Here political forms and changes may exert the greatest influence.[170-5]
Thus, the artificial increase of the wages of masters effected by the former guild-system was produced, to say the least, as much at the cost of the journeymen and apprentices as of the public. And if, on the other hand, it cannot be said that the most recent marked rise in wages, in so many countries, is merely the consequence of the extension of the parliamentary right of suffrage, certain it is that the two phenomena are very closely related, and that both are at once the effect and the cause of the intensified feeling of individuality and of the consciousness of constituting a class in the community of the lower strata of society.
[Footnote 170-1: At least where the supply of labor in
general surpasses the demand. Compare J. S. Mill,
Principles, II, ch. 14, 3d ed. The dangerous industries in
which lead, quicksilver, arsenic, etc. are manipulated or
employed, should be and can be better paid than they
actually are. In the Bavarian Palatinate, stone-cutters
rarely reach their 45th year; and yet their wages are very
low, because of the comparative over-population of the
country. (Rau, Haussen's Archiv., N. T.
X., 228.) But
the lowness of wages here is certainly and mainly caused by
the little thought the workmen themselves give to
considerations of health.]
[Footnote 170-2: The lower the rate of wages of any class
sinks, the more difficult it becomes for parents to devote
their children to another career.]
[Footnote 170-3: In Paris, 24,463 workmen with less than 3
francs daily; 157,216, with from 3 to 5; 10,393, with from 5
to 20 and even 3 to 5 francs.
It is remarkable, however, how
uniform the average wages in the different trades is:
vêtements, 3.33 francs; fils et tissus, 3.42;
boisellerie, vannerie, 3.44; garçons boulangers,
bouchers 3.50; arts chimiques et céramiques 3.71;
bâtiments, 3.81; carosserie, 3.86; peaux et cuirs,
3.87; ameublement, 3.90; articles de Paris, 3.94;
métaux communs, 3.98; métaux précieux, 4.17;
imprimerie, 4.18. (Journal des Economistes, Janv. 1853,
111.)]
[Footnote 170-4: How the Roman advocates were given to all
sorts of ostentation, and even borrowed costly rings in
order to raise their honoraria, see Juvenal, VII, 105,
ff.]
[Footnote 170-5: The salaries paid to the employees in the
office of the minister of finance in France and the United
States were as follows: to the porter, 1,500 and 3,734
francs; the lowest clerk, 1,000 to 1,800, and 5,420 francs;
to the head clerk, 3,200 to 3,600, and 8,672 francs; the
secretary general, 20,000 and 10,840 francs; to the
minister, 80,000 and 32,520 francs. (Tocqueville,
Démocratie aux États-Unis, II, 74.) In the treasury
department, at Washington, of 158 employees, only 6 received
less than $1,000 salary, but only 2 over $2,000. (M.
Chevalier, Lettres sur l'Amérique du Nord, II, 151, 456.)
Compare Büsch, Geldumlauf, IV, 34.
In Russia, the wages of
the higher classes of laborers as compared with those paid
the commoner class is much higher than in Germany.
(Kosegarten, in Haxthausen, Studien, III, 583.) On the
other hand, in England, since 1850, the rate of wages for
unskilled labor has risen relatively more than any other.
(Tooke, Hist. of Prices, VI, 177.)]
SECTION CLXXI.
HISTORY OF THE WAGES OF COMMON LABOR.--IN THE LOWER STAGES OF
CIVILIZATION.
In very low stages of civilization, where there is scarcely any such thing as rent, and where capital is extremely rare, the wages of labor, notwithstanding its small amount absolutely speaking, must eat up the greatest part of the product.[171-1] With every further advance, the condition of the laboring class is modified, according as the natural decline in this relative amount of their wages is outweighed or counterbalanced, or neither outweighed nor counterbalanced, by the increase in the aggregate product; in other words, in the national income in general as compared with the number of workmen.
[Footnote 171-1: Adam Smith, Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 8.
Thus in the case of nations of hunters.
The wages of free
laborers in Russia, at the beginning of this century, were
so high that mowers, in the vicinity of Moscow, received a
good half of the corn mowed by them, (von Schlözer,
Aufangsgründe, I, 65.) As a rule, the natural relation of
the three branches of income is here postponed by the
intervention of slavery. (§ 76, 155.) But, for instance,
since the negroes have been emancipated, in the southern
states of the American Union, it has become necessary to
promise them one-half of the cotton crop as wages, and for
the employer to run all the risk of a bad harvest. (R.
Somers, The Southern States since the War, 1871.) On the
wretched pay of domestic servants in the middle ages, see
Grimm, D.
Rechtsalterth., 357.]
SECTION CLXXII.
HISTORY OF THE WAGES OF COMMON LABOR.--IN FLOURISHING TIMES.
When, where a nation's economy[172-1] is growing and flourishing, capital increases more rapidly than population, there is a search for employment by capital still greater than the search for employment by labor. The consequence is, of course, a decline in the rate of interest, and a rise in the rate of the wages of labor, although the latter may be compelled to surrender a part of its increase to rent, which also rises.
If simultaneously with these phenomena, there have been great advances made in national productive skill, especially in the cultivation of land; if, therefore, labor and the capital consumed have become more prolific, the condition of the laboring class is improved in a two-fold manner; the condition of capitalists needs, to say the least, grow no worse, and the increase of rent paid to landowners may be avoided.[172-2]
This favorable development is most striking in the colonies of rich and highly civilized parent countries, where the labor, capital and social customs of an old and ripe civilization are found together with the overflowing natural forces inherent in a virgin soil, engaged in the work of economic production. Here the growth of national wealth is most rapid; and the rate of wages is here wont to be highest.[172-3] With the high rate of interest that obtains where capital is rapidly saved, and with the low price of land, it is not a matter of difficulty for good workmen to enter into the ranks of landowners and capitalists.
In North America, and especially in the western part,[172-4] it is very frequently in the normal course of economic development for young people to begin to work on wages, then to work on their own account, and finally to become themselves employers of labor.
[Footnote 172-1: Compare Hermann, Staatswirths. Unters.,
241 ff.; J. S. Mill, Principles, ch. 3. As to how Carey
confounds the rise and fall of the productiveness of labor
with the rise and fall of wages, see J. S. Mill's views in
Lange, 1866, 218 ff.]
[Footnote 172-2: In England, wages from 1400 to 1420,
estimated in produce, were much higher than from 1500 to
1533. (Statist. Journal, 1861, 544 ff.) Later, a quarter of
wheat was earned by day labor as follows: under Elizabeth,
in about 48 days; during the seventeenth century, in 43
days; between 1700 and 1766, in 32 days; between 1815 and
1848, in from 19 to at most 28-3/4 days. (Hildebrand, Nat.
Oek. der Gegenwart und Zukunft.) Since 1860, it has been
earned in about 14 days. About 1668, the wages paid to
English laborers and servants was one-third higher than
twenty years before. (Sir J.
Child, Discourse on Trade, p.
43 of the French translation.) D. Defoe, Giving Alms no
Charity, 1704, draws a much more favorable picture of the
time next succeeding. Adam Smith, Wealth of Nat., I, ch.
8, shows how money-wages, in the eighteenth century, were
higher and the price of corn lower than in the seventeenth
century.
Between 1737 and 1797, wages in most parts of
England, except in the immediate neighborhood of the great
cities, doubled. (Eden, I, 385.) In Scotland, about the
year 1817, the wages of married farm servants, expressed in
corn, were about 60 per cent. higher than in 1792.
(Sinclair, Grundgesetze des Ackerbaues, 105.)
Boisguillebert, Traité des Grains, I, 2, estimates the
wages in France, for agricultural laborers, at least from 7
to 8 sous, of present money, and at twice that amount in
harvest time. In 1697, laborers in Paris received from 40 to
50 sous. (Détail de la France, I, ch. 1, ch. 7.) Vauban
estimates wages in large cities at 22-1/2-45 sous; for
country manual laborers, at 18 sous; for agricultural
laborers, 12-13-1/5 sous. (Project d'une Dime royale, 89
Daire.) On the other hand, Chaptal, De l'Industrie, Fr.
I,
245, 1819, speaks of an average wage--25 sous. Dureau de la
Malle, Economie polit. des Romains, I, 151, allows
agricultural laborers, in 80 departments of France, only
20-25 sous. According to Moreau de Joannés, Journal des
Econ., Oct. 1850, the average wages of a French agricultural
family amounted per annum, in 1700, to 135 francs; in 1760,
to 126; in 1788, to 161; in 1813, to 400; in 1840, to 500
francs. While A.
Young, Travels in France, 1787-89, speaks
of wages of 20 sous a day; Peuchet, Statist. élémentaire,
1805, 361, assumes it to be 30 sous, although the price of
corn was not much higher. Compare Birkbeck, Agricultural
Tour of France, 13, who is of opinion even, that French
laborers are better situated than the English (?). From 1830
to 1848, wages decreased about 30 per cent. (L. Faucher,
Revue des deux Mondes, Avril, 1848.) Levasseur, Histoire
des Classes ouvrières en France, II, 1858.
General data for whole countries are obviously very
doubtful. In Germany, for instance, economically active
places have witnessed an undoubted elevation of the
condition of the laboring classes. Thus, in Hamburg and
Lower Saxony, about the end of the eighteenth century
(Büsch, Geldumlauf, II, 56 ff.); while in Thuringia, in
1556, a sümmer of rye was earned by 7 summer days' labor,
and in 1830 ff. by 8. (Lotz, Handbuch, I, 404.) In Hessen,
also, there has been but a very small increase in wages.
(Hildebrand, Nat.
Oek., I, 190.) According to von der
Goltz, Ländliche Arbeiterfrage, 1872, 84 seq., wages in the
country during the last twenty or thirty years have
increased on an average, 50 per cent. at least; in Bavaria
about 100 per cent.; in the Rhine province, male wages,
about 100; female wages, from about 75 to 100 per cent. The
masterly investigations of the wages of typesetters in Jena
and Halle by Strasburger in Hildebrand's Jahrb., 1872, I
ff., show that from 1717 to 1848, there was scarcely any
change in them.
A million m's was paid for in 1717-40 with
26.93 Prussian sheffels of rye; 1804-47 with from 24.80 to
28.80. Since then, a remarkable rise; so that in 1871, up to
November, 76.26 was reached. The prices of food, dwellings,
fuel, clothing, such as is in demand by such laborers, rose
between 1850 and 1860, 16.7 per cent., and the wages for
1,000 m's in the same period of time rose about 14.3 and
43.7 per cent. In the industrious manufacturing vicinity of
Moscow, wages in 1815 were four times as high as in 1670,
while the means of subsistence rose relatively much less.
(Storch, I, 203.)]
[Footnote 172-3: In the United States, the wages of
carpenters and masons, about the end of the last century,
were $0.62 and $0.75; in 1835, of the former from $1.12 to
$1.25, and for the latter from $1.37 to $1.50. In 1848, the
general wage was $0.75.
The price of corn, in the meantime,
did not rise, and the price of manufactured articles was
much smaller. (Carey, Rate of Wages, 26 seq.; Past,
Present and Future, 154.) In New York, as far back as 1790,
wages were much higher (Ebeling, Geschichte und
Erdbeschreibung von Nordamerika, II, 917); and between 40
and 50 years ago, a journeyman mason might earn over 700
thalers per annum. Agricultural laborers, in 1835, got $9 a
month and their board, valued at $65 for the whole year.
In
the vicinity of large cities, both were higher. (Carey,
91.) The condition of the factory hands, in Lowell, is a
very good one. In 1839, more than 100 of them had over
$1,000 each in the savings banks, and pianos at their mess
places. (Boz, Notes on America, 1842.) Most of them could
save $1.50 a week. Colton, in his Public Economy (1849),
says that a workman would consider himself in a bad way if
he could not save half of his wages. Compare Chevalier,
Lettres sur l'Amérique, II, 174, 122, 19; I, 221 ff.
Apprentices in the United States, in almost every instance,
begin to be paid wages as soon as their work begins to prove
useful. The work of half-grown children, who had not yet
left the parental roof, was so well paid that it was
estimated that a child earned for his parents, on the whole,
£100 more than he cost them. What an incentive to marriage!
(Adam Smith, Wealth of Nat., I, ch. 8.) In Canada,
agricultural laborers earn between £24 and £30 per annum and
their board.
In and around Melbourne, agricultural laborers
got from 15 to 20 shillings a week and lodging; herdsmen,
£35 to £40 a year; girls, from £20 to £45 (Statist. Journal,
1872, 387 ff.); female cooks, from £35 to £40; male cooks,
from £52 to £156. In hotels, girls, from £30 to £35; female
cooks, from £50 to £100; domestic servants, £39 to £52;
carpenters, masons, etc., 10 shillings a day; the best
tailors, from 60 to 75 shillings a week; shoemakers, from 40
to 55 shillings; bakers, from 40 to 60 shillings a week.
(Statist.
Journal, 1871, 396 seq.) In San Francisco, a short
time since, servant girls got $25 a month; Chinese, $1 a
day; common laborers, $2; skilled artisans, from $3 to $5.
(Whymper, Alaska, 299, 326.) The wages of a European
tradesman, in Rio Janeiro, was from I to 2 Spanish piasters
a day. (Martius, Reise, I, 131.) In the English West
Indies, a new-born negro was formerly worth £5. (B.
Edwards, History of the West Indies, II, 128.) The high
wages paid in young colonies are frequently made temporarily
still higher, by a large influx of capital in the shape of
money, brought by emigrants, and by government outlays.
Thus, in Van Diemen's land, for instance, in 1824,
carpenters, masons, etc. got 12 shillings a day; in 1830,
10; in 1838, only from 6 to 7, although between 1830 and
1838, the export trade of the island trebled while the
population scarcely doubled. (Merivale, On Colonies, II,
225.)]
[Footnote 172-4: As to how many workmen in the eastern part
of North America buy land in the west, and so threaten their
employers with immediate emigration, see Brentano,
Arbeitergilden, II, 131. However, in Massachusetts, women's
wages are in many instances so low that, considering the
dearness of the means of subsistence, it is almost
impossible to understand how they exist. (Statist. Journal,
1872, 236 ff.)]
SECTION CLXXIII.
HISTORY OF THE WAGES OF COMMON LABOR.--IN FLOURISHING NATIONS.
A permanently[173-1] high rate of wages[173-2] is, both as cause and effect, very intimately connected with a flourishing condition of national life.
It proves on the one hand, great productiveness of the public economy of the people generally: prudence, self-respect and self-control, even of the lowest classes, virtues, which, however, are found, on the whole, only where political liberty exists, and where the lowest classes are rightly valued by the higher.[173-3] On the other hand, it produces a condition of the great majority of that portion of the population who have to support themselves on the wages they receive, worthy of human beings, a condition in which they can educate their children, enjoy the present and provide for the future.
Equality before the law and participation in the affairs of government are empty phrases, and even tend to inflame the passions, where the rate of wages is not high. When the lower classes are dissatisfied, in highly civilized countries, with the sensitiveness and mobility of the whole national life, there can be no certainty of the freedom of the middle classes or of the rule of the upper. Here, in other respects, also, the philanthropy of employers harmonizes remarkably well with their reasonable self-interest. According to § 40, on
Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence
The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.
Transcriber and production notes
Produced by Frank van Drogen, Carol Brown, Gwen Adams, Elizabeth Oscanyan, and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net. Transcriber's Note: A monospaced font will display the tables in this book better than a variable-spaced font.
Front matter as received (title page, contents)
PRINCIPLES
OF
POLITICAL ECONOMY
BY
WILLIAM ROSCHER,
PROFESSOR OF POLITICAL ECONOMY AT THE UNIVERSITY OF LEIPZIG,
CORRESPONDING MEMBER OF THE INSTITUTE OF FRANCE, PRIVY
COUNSELLOR TO HIS MAJESTY, THE KING OF SAXONY.
FROM THE THIRTEENTH (1877) GERMAN EDITION.
WITH ADDITIONAL CHAPTERS, FURNISHED BY THE AUTHOR, FOR THIS FIRST
ENGLISH AND AMERICAN EDITION, ON
PAPER MONEY, INTERNATIONAL TRADE, AND THE
PROTECTIVE SYSTEM;
AND A PRELIMINARY
ESSAY ON THE HISTORICAL METHOD IN POLITICAL ECONOMY
(From the French)
BY L. WOLOWSKI,
THE WHOLE TRANSLATED BY
JOHN J. LALOR, A. M.
VOL. II.
[Illustration: Printer's Logo]
NEW YORK:
HENRY HOLT & CO.
1878.
Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year eighteen hundred
and seventy-eight,
BY CALLAGHAN & CO.,
In the office of the Librarian of Congress, at Washington, D. C.
DAVID ATWOOD, STEREOTYPER AND PRINTER, MADISON, WIS.
TO
WILLIAM H. GAYLORD, ESQ.,
_COUNSELOR AT LAW_,
OF CLEVELAND, OHIO,
TO WHOSE BROTHERLY CARE IT IS LARGELY DUE THAT I LIVED TO
TRANSLATE THEM,
THESE VOLUMES
ARE AFFECTIONATELY INSCRIBED.
BOOK III.
DISTRIBUTION OF GOODS.
CHAPTER 1.
INCOME IN GENERAL.Header as received
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Principles of Political Economy, Vol. 2
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: Principles of Political Economy, Vol. 2
Author: Wilhelm Roscher
Translator: John J. Lalor
Release date: January 23, 2012 [eBook #38655]
Most recently updated: January 8, 2021
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/38655
Credits: Produced by Frank van Drogen, Carol Brown, Gwen Adams,
Elizabeth Oscanyan, and the Online Distributed Proofreading
Team at https://www.pgdp.net.Full Project Gutenberg licence
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
States without permission and without paying copyright
royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
license, especially commercial redistribution.
START: FULL LICENSE
THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
www.gutenberg.org/license.
Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
electronic works
1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
you share it without charge with others.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
country other than the United States.
1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
beginning of this work.
1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
Gutenberg License.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
provided that:
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation.”
• You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
works.
• You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
receipt of the work.
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
forth in Section 3 below.
1.F.
1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
cannot be read by your equipment.
1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
DAMAGE.
1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
without further opportunities to fix the problem.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
remaining provisions.
1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
Defect you cause.
Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
from people in all walks of life.
Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation
Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
public support and donations to carry out its mission of
increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
status with the IRS.
The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
approach us with offers to donate.
International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
volunteer support.
Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
edition.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.
This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #38655. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.