Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 32533

The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin

by Henry M. Hunt · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2010
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin by Henry M. Hunt is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #32533). Note: Project Gutenberg also has an HTML version of this file which includes the original illustrations. See 32533-h.htm or 32533-h.zip: (https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/32533/pg32533-images.html) (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/32533/32533-h.zip)

    PREFACE

    This volume is not intended as an addition to the criminal literature of the country. It has not been published solely for the pleasure of those who delight in devouring morbid tales of crime and criminals. It rather owes its existence to a general demand from all parts of the United States, from the Canadas, from Great Britain, and from many points on the continent of Europe, for a complete, concise, and accurate story of one of the greatest of modern crimes and the events connected therewith.

    The reports of the public press, while of the most searching and elaborate character, have nevertheless been of necessity so disjointed, fragmentary and confusing, covering a period of over seven months, each day and week replete with new discoveries and new sensations, as to make it well-nigh impossible for even the most careful reader, with unlimited time at his disposal, to grasp or comprehend anything more than the barest outline of this remarkable case.

    The object of this volume therefore, is to present in consecutive form and as a complete narrative all the facts which have been brought to light from the day of the disappearance of Dr. Cronin, to the close of the trial of those accused of his murder.

    Many circumstances have combined to make the task a difficult and laborious one, but the results are submitted in the belief that as the only effort of its kind, it will prove not only a story of thrilling interest to the general reader, but also valuable, by its accuracy and continuity, as an historical work.

    THE AUTHOR.

    CONTENTS.

    PAGE.
    CHAPTER I.

    A Crime That Shocked the Civilized World--The Mysterious Stranger--A Sudden Summons--The Instincts of Humanity Triumph over Personal Considerations--Last Moments at Home--Parting Words with a Friend--Dr. Cronin's Eventful Life--How He Worked His Way Upward on the Ladder of Honor and Fame, 15

    CHAPTER II.

    Dr. Cronin Fails to Return Home--Anxiety of His Friends-- The Early Morning Ride to the Ice House--O'Sullivan's Surprise and Ignorance--The Mysterious Wagon and Its Occupants--A Bloody Trunk is Found--The Search Commenced-- "It is His Hair," 27

    CHAPTER III.

    An Accidental Clue--Frank Woodruff's Arrest--How He Was Hired to Get a Wagon to Carry the Mysterious Trunk to Lake View--A Corpse is Dumped Out--He Thinks It was That of a Woman--His Sensational Confession--The Police on a Wild-Goose Chase, 46

    CHAPTER IV.

    "It is a Conspiracy"--Dr. Cronin's Friends Claim the Murder was a Political Assassination--The Public Skeptical until Startling Developments Are Made--The Physician in Danger of His Life for Years--Previous Attempts to Remove Him--The Trouble in the Clan-na-Gael--Charges and Counter Charges--The Buffalo Convention--Why His "Removal" became a Necessity to Certain People, 57

    CHAPTER V.

    Strange Influences at Work--Miss Anna Murphy Thinks She Saw the Doctor on a Street Car--His Long and Mysterious Ride with Conductor Dwyer--Reporter Long also Encounters Him, This Time in Toronto--The Police and Public Satisfied, but His Friends Still Anxious--Efforts to Prove Him a British Spy--A Big Reward Offered 101

    CHAPTER VI.

    Hoping against Hope--The Stench in the Sewer--"Murder Will Out"--A Ghastly Discovery--Where the Body was Found--The Recognition by Captain Wing--Its Horrible Appearance--Evidences of a Foul Crime--The Corpse at the Morgue--Pitiable Scenes of Grief--The Official Autopsy--The Brutal Way in Which the Physician had been Done to Death 126

    CHAPTER VII.

    The Crime Creates An International Sensation--Discovery of the Lonely Cottage Where the Irish Nationalist Met His Death--Evidences of a Terrible Struggle--The Tell-Tale Blood Stains and Broken Furniture--The Mysterious Tenants and Their Movements--The Furniture Bought and Carted to the Assassins' Den--What Milkman Mertes Saw--The Plot as Outlined by the Surroundings--Iceman O'Sullivan Under Surveillance 154

    CHAPTER VIII.

    The White Horse and Buggy--Detective Coughlin Hires It for a "Friend"--The Trouble in the Stable--Dinan Goes to Schaack--The Captain's Peculiar Movements--Scanlan Identifies the Horse--The Detective and O'Sullivan are Jailed--The Grand Jury Indicts Them with Woodruff--The Accused Arraigned in Court 195

    CHAPTER IX.

    The Lying in State--An Impressive Scene--The Imposing Procession--At the Cathedral--An Eloquent Voice from the Pulpit--Clerical Denunciation of the Crime--Laid to Rest in Calvary Cemetery 220

    CHAPTER X.

    The Coroner's Inquest Opens--A Model Jury--Visiting the Scene of the Tragedy--Taking the Evidence--Captain Schaack's Compromising Admissions--Prominent Clan-na-Gael Men put on the Stand--Alexander Sullivan's Threats--Luke Dillon Tells What He Knows--The Documents Left by the Murdered Man Read by the Coroner--A Sensational Inquiry 236

    CHAPTER XI.

    Closing Scenes of the Inquest--The Verdict--Alexander Sullivan's Arrest Ordered--Midnight Visit to His Residence-- His Cool Demeanor and Cheerful Acquiescence--Taken to the County Jail--Incidents of the Arrest 259

    CHAPTER XII.

    At the Toronto End of the Conspiracy--Investigating Long's Circumstantial Stories, and His Interviews with Dr. Cronin-- A Chicago Fugitive Concerned--His Suspicious Movements--A Chapter of Startling Coincidences--Long on the Rack--Makes Damaging Admissions but will not Retract--The Object to Distract Attention from the Scene of the Crime--Another Confession from Woodruff 275

    CHAPTER XIII.

    Sullivan's Arrest Creates a Sensation--His Friends Stand by Him--The Noted ex-Irish Leader in Court--Efforts to Secure His Release--Judge Tuley Gives Him His Liberty--Arrest of Maroney and McDonald in New York--Their Extradition Refused 292

    CHAPTER XIV.

    Officer Collin's Suspicions--Martin Burke and His Record-- Fortunate Discovery of the Photograph of a Clan-na-Gael Group--The Carlsons and Others Identify Burke--His Peculiar Movements and His Flight--An Indictment against Him--The Capture in Winnipeg, when En Route to England--Stubborn Fight to Prevent His Extradition to American Soil--The Law Triumphant--A Memorable Journey Home--Preliminaries of the Trial--A Separate Trial Granted Woodruff 303

    CHAPTER XV.

    Theories Regarding the Disappearance of the Murdered Man's Clothing--The Hand of Providence Manifests Itself--Fortunate Discovery of the Last Bloody Evidences of the Crime--Dr.

    Cronin's Apparel is Found--It had been Secreted, with His Case of Surgical Instruments, in a Catch-basin, Adjacent to the One in Which the Body was Discovered--Shoes, Jewelry and Purse Missing--Complete Identification by His Friends--The Search Continued--A Piece of Carpet Found--The Conspirators' Plans Thwarted 333

    CHAPTER XVI.

    Special Grand Jury Summoned--Personnel of Its Members-- Judge Shepard's Vigorous Charge--The Testimony Taken-- Seventeen Days' Investigation Results in the Indictment of Seven Men--Full Text of the Indictment--Arrest of Beggs and Kunze--The Alleged Trial of Dr. Cronin in Camp 20 351

    CHAPTER XVII.

    Public Abhorrence at the Crime--A Great Out-pouring of the People--Cosmopolitan Assemblage at Central Music Hall--A Judge's Vigorous Speech--Congressmen Denounce the Crime-- The Rival Demonstrations at Cheltenham Beach and Ogden's Grove 369

    CHAPTER XVIII.

    In Court at Last--The State's Attorney Points Out the Accused, Man by Man--A Formidable Array of Legal Talent-- Objections to Luther Laflin Mills and his Associates-- Over-ruled by the Court--Weeks consumed in the Wearisome Task of Securing a Jury--Scenes and Incidents 384

    CHAPTER XIX.

    Startling Interruption to the Trial--Villainous Attempt to Frustrate the Ends of Justice--Bold Efforts to Bribe the Special Veniresmen in the Interest of the Prisoners--A "Hung" Jury Wanted--Fortunate Discovery of the Plot--The "Wheels Within Wheels" of the Conspiracy--Prompt Action of the Prosecuting Authorities--Speedy Arrest and Indictment of the Guilty Parties--Crime Added to Crime 399

    CHAPTER XX.

    A Jury Secured at Last--Names and Sketches of the Twelve Men Selected to Determine the Guilt of the Accused--The Trial Under Way--Opening Speeches for the State--Scenes in the Court Room 414

    CHAPTER XXI.

    Evidence for the State--The Story of the Crime Retold--A Long Line of Witnesses--Sensational Disclosures and Missing Links Supplied--Mrs. Hoertel's Graphic Story--Dr. Cronin's Knives are Found and Produced in Court--A Masterly Grouping of the Testimony Against the Prisoners 430

    CHAPTER XXII.

    The Defense Takes its Turn--Unsuccessful Efforts to Exclude the Bulk of the Evidence Given for the State--Alibis for the Prisoners and the White Horse--A General Denial of Complicity in the Tragedy--Rebuttal Evidence for the Prosecution 457

    CHAPTER XXIII.

    Opening for the State--The Evidence Reviewed--A Masterly Argument by State's Attorney Longenecker--Tracing the Plot from its Inception to the Murder--An Appeal for Justice-- Arguments for the Defense--Donahoe, Wing, Foster and Forrest make Their Final Pleas for the Prisoners, and Ingham, Hynes and Longenecker Close for the State 470

    CHAPTER XXIV.

    All the Testimony Before the Jury--Judge McConnell's Lucid Charge--The Jury Retires--A Period of Anxiety--Popular Excitement at its Height--Demeanor of the Prisoners-- Suspense at Last Ended--The Verdict 563

    LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.

    PAGE.

    PORTRAIT OF DR. PATRICK HENRY CRONIN, THE MURDERED

    PHYSICIAN Frontispiece.

    PORTRAIT OF PATRICK O'SULLIVAN, THE ICE MAN, ONE

    OF THE DEFENDANTS 28

    PORTRAIT OF DANIEL COUGHLIN, THE DETECTIVE, ONE

    OF THE DEFENDANTS 197

    PORTRAIT OF MARTIN BURKE, ONE OF THE DEFENDANTS 315

    PORTRAIT OF JOHN F. BEGGS, ONE OF THE DEFENDANTS 360

    PORTRAIT OF JOHN KUNZE, ONE OF THE DEFENDANTS 367

    O'SULLIVAN AND KUNZE, FROM PHOTOGRAPH TAKEN DURING TRIAL 392

    PORTRAIT OF PATRICK COONEY, "THE FOX" 452

    PORTRAIT OF SUPT. OF POLICE HUBBARD 210

    PORTRAIT OF OFFICER DANIEL BROWN 354

    PORTRAITS OF MR. AND MRS. T. T. CONKLIN 39

    PORTRAIT OF ALEXANDER SULLIVAN 263

    PORTRAIT OF MERTES, THE MILKMAN 187

    PORTRAITS OF FIVE DEFENDANTS ON TRIAL 429

    PORTRAITS OF THE SIX PRISONERS IN COURT 332

    PORTRAITS OF THE TWELVE JURYMEN 416-417

    PORTRAIT OF JUDGE MCCONNELL, PRESIDING AT THE MEMORABLE

    TRIAL 456

    PORTRAIT OF JOEL M. LONGENECKER, THE STATE'S ATTORNEY 469

    PORTRAIT OF LUTHER LAFLIN MILLS (THE NOTED CRIMINAL LAWYER),

    FOR THE PROSECUTION 550

    PORTRAIT OF GEORGE C. INGHAM, ATTORNEY FOR THE PROSECUTION 514

    PORTRAIT OF W. J. HYNES, ATTORNEY FOR THE PROSECUTION 521

    PORTRAIT OF W. S. FORREST, LEADING ATTORNEY FOR THE DEFENSE 536

    PORTRAIT OF JUDGE WING, ATTORNEY FOR THE DEFENSE 512

    PORTRAITS OF THREE OF THE CARLSON FAMILY 168

    PORTRAITS OF PRINCIPAL WITNESSES BEFORE THE CORONER'S INQUEST 254

    PORTRAIT OF DETECTIVE MICHAEL WHALEN 206

    PORTRAIT OF DETECTIVE BARNEY FLYNN 464

    PORTRAIT OF LAWRENCE R. BUCKLEY 242

    PORTRAIT OF T. P. O'CONNOR 244

    PORTRAIT OF P. M'GEHAN 247

    THE COURT ROOM, SHOWING THE GREAT TRIAL IN PROGRESS 413

    THE CARD OF SULLIVAN ICE CO., THAT LURED DR. CRONIN FROM

    HIS HOME ON THE NIGHT OF THE MURDER 20

    THE MYSTERIOUS WAGON 31

    DETECTIVES INSPECTING THE SPOT WHERE THE TRUNK WAS FOUND 42

    THE BLOODY TRUNK AND ITS CONTENTS 35

    PICTURE OF DR. CRONIN TAKEN AFTER HE WAS FOUND IN THE

    CATCH-BASIN WITH THE "AGNUS DEI" ON BREAST 135

    SCENE AT THE MORGUE, SHOWING THE BODY LYING ON SLAB AND

    BEING IDENTIFIED BY SCANLAN AND CONKLIN 140

    THE SPOT WHERE THE TRUNK WAS FOUND 33

    THE SKULL OF DR. CRONIN, SHOWING THE WOUNDS 143

    THE BROKEN ROCKER ON WHICH DR. CRONIN PROBABLY SAT WHEN KILLED 161

    BLOOD-STAINED PIECE OF BRASS 161

    THE SOLITARY LAMP 161

    THE CATCH-BASIN--SOUTH VIEW 127

    THE CATCH-BASIN, SHOWING FIRE-PLUG AND DITCH 129

    THE DISCOVERY OF THE BODY IN THE CATCH-BASIN 131

    ALEXANDER SULLIVAN'S RESIDENCE 264

    THE ASSASSINS' DEN, SHOWING THE CARLSON COTTAGE IN REAR 157

    DIAGRAM OF THE LOCALITY OF THE MURDER 156

    FOOTPRINT FOUND IN HOUSE 160

    THE CORONER'S JURY 239

    JURORS EXAMINING FINGER MARKS IN PAINT ON WINDOW BLIND 245

    JURORS EXAMINING BLOOD STAINS IN PARLOR OF COTTAGE 238

    THE WHITE HORSE AND BUGGY THAT TOOK DR. CRONIN AWAY FROM

    HIS HOME 199

    LIVERYMAN DINAN'S STABLE 198

    THE FUNERAL PROCESSION 223

    DR. CRONIN'S APARTMENTS IN WINDSOR THEATRE BUILDING 18

    DR. CRONIN'S RECEPTION ROOM IN CHICAGO OPERA HOUSE BUILDING 184

    DR. CRONIN'S OFFICE IN CHICAGO OPERA HOUSE BUILDING 181

    DR. CRONIN'S MAIN OFFICE IN CHICAGO OPERA HOUSE BUILDING 183

    STATE'S ATTORNEY LONGENECKER ADDRESSING THE COURT 296

    DR. CRONIN'S BOX AND ITS CONTENTS 337

    THE LOAD ON THE STRETCHER 338

    SOME OF DR. CRONIN'S CLOTHES 340

    TWO VIEWS OF DR. CRONIN'S HAT 341

    DR. CRONIN'S POCKET INSTRUMENT CASE 342

    DR. CRONIN'S SLEEVE BUTTON, COMB, R. A. BUTTON, CASE, ETC. 343

    DR. CRONIN'S POCKET CASE 345

    REMAINS OF THE MURDERER'S VALISE 346

    THE SILVER HYPODERMIC SYRINGE CASE 347

    DR. CRONIN'S SURGICAL INSTRUMENT CASE 348

    THE ENGLISH PRESCRIPTION BOOK 349

    THE JUDGE HEARS OF THE JURY-BRIBING PLOT 401

    THE KNIVES 466

    CHAPTER I.

    A CRIME THAT SHOCKED THE CIVILIZED WORLD--THE MYSTERIOUS STRANGER--A

    SUDDEN SUMMONS--THE INSTINCTS OF HUMANITY TRIUMPH OVER PERSONAL

    CONSIDERATIONS--LAST MOMENTS AT HOME--PARTING WORDS WITH A FRIEND--

    DR. CRONIN'S EVENTFUL LIFE--HOW HE WORKED HIS WAY UPWARD ON THE

    LADDER OF HONOR AND FAME.

    Little introduction to this volume is needed. It is the story--told in plain unvarnished words, so that everyone who reads may understand--of a crime that has shocked the people of the United States, and astounded the civilized world. Back of that crime was a conspiracy so wide in its ramifications, so cunningly contrived, so successfully executed, as to rival the diabolical plots and outgrowing tragedies that have been placed at the doors of the secret societies of France, Italy and Spain, by the historians of the Dark Ages.

    In the United States, as an event of national importance, the crime may be said to rank with the assassinations of Presidents Lincoln and Garfield. In the case of the former, as of the latter, the perpetrator of the crime was a half crazed enthusiast, who imagined that he had a mission to perform in taking the life of the Chief Magistrate of the Republic.

    An effort was made, it is true, to demonstrate the fact that the assassin of Abraham Lincoln was but the tool of a band of conspirators, but, despite the fact that five of his alleged accomplices suffered an ignominious death upon the scaffold upon conviction for complicity in the appalling crime, the question as to the actual existence of a conspiracy has remained to this day a mooted one. In the case of President Garfield there was not even a suggestion that the assassin acted upon other than his own insane impulse.

    So far as concerns the Haymarket horror in Chicago, the point as to whether the throwing of the bomb that echoed around the world was the outcome of a conspiracy, or the act of an individual who had inbibed anarchistic principles and doctrines until reason had been dethroned, and a desire for vengeance upon the supposed enemies of the proletaire had generated into an uncontrollable determination, is still unsettled in the minds of many people eminently well versed in the law; as well as in those of a goodly proportion of the masses.

    So far, however, as the tragic fate of Dr Cronin is concerned, no such doubt may be said to exist. That he fell a victim to a plot, remarkable in its conception and execution; conceived in shrewdness and forethought, and executed by the aid of far-reaching and elaborate machinery; and with remorseless precision, is beyond peradventure. But it serves no purpose to anticipate.

    The following chapters tell their own story of the manner and methods by which the murder of a law-abiding American citizen, prominent in his profession and of national reputation, was decreed and carried out. It was the first crime of its character in the history of the United States. It will probably be the last.

    THE DISAPPEARANCE.

    The locality was Chicago. The date Saturday, May 4th, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eighty-nine. The time eight o'clock of the evening. Philip Patrick Henry Cronin--for this was the full name of the physician--was closeted with a patient in the most spacious of the front suite of rooms attached to a handsomely furnished flat directly over the Windsor Theatre on North Clark Street. The tenants of the flat, T. T.

    Conklin, a well-known saloon keeper, and his wife, were among his most intimate and confidential friends, and with them the physician, who was a confirmed bachelor, had resided so long that he was regarded, to all intents and purposes, as one of the family. They nursed him in sickness, studied his every requirement when in health, and in a great measure, shared with him his personal and political knowledge. It was a happy, congenial family in every sense of the term. Dr.

    Cronin was on the point of dismissing the patient, for an important meeting of the Celto-American Society, which published a paper of which he was the political editor, necessitated his hurrying away to the other side of the city, when the door-bell rang violently. Mrs. Conklin responded. A man pale and breathless, stood on the landing.

    [Illustration: DR. CRONIN'S APARTMENTS IN WINDSOR THEATRE BUILDING.]

    "Is Dr. Cronin in?" he demanded, in a hurried, nervous manner.

    "Yes," was the reply, "but he is busy with a patient."

    "Well," responded the stranger with increasing nervousness. "I want to see him. It is a matter of life or death."

    Some fragments of the conversation had penetrated to the office where the physician was giving a final injunction to his patient. He threw open the door and came out into the vestibule.

    "What is the matter?" he asked.

    "Doctor" said the strange visitor as he presented a card, "one of the workmen at P. O'Sullivan's ice house at Lake View, has met with an accident and been terribly injured about here" (indicating the abdomen by a wave of his hand). "Unless a doctor sees him at once," he went on in his hurried, nervous, manner, "he will die. O'Sullivan is out of town, but he has spoken so often of you and said that you should be called in case of an accident that I thought I'd better come to you."

    Dr. Cronin glanced at the card. It was a fac-simile of this.

    [Illustration]

    For a moment he twirled it between his finger and thumb. Then he looked at his watch. It was near the hour for the meeting, in the proceedings of which he was liable to take a prominent part. But the humane instincts of the profession quickly overcame all other considerations.

    "One moment" he ejaculated, "and I will be with you."

    "I have a buggy and fast horse down stairs" called out the stranger.

    Dr. Cronin darted into his office. Hastily gathering up his surgical instruments, he packed them into their case. A package of lint and absorbent cotton was pushed down into his pocket. Then he reappeared and with the remark "I am ready," made for the stairs. The unknown went down in advance and the doctor followed. At the curb, with a white horse in the shafts, was the buggy that was to take the physician on his supposed errand of mercy. As he reached the street, he came vis-a-vis with Frank T. Scanlan, Jr., a prominent young Irish-American, who had previously arranged to call for and accompany him to the meeting.

    "Are you ready" the latter asked.

    "No," was Dr. Cronin's reply. "I'm called away on an accident case."

    The stranger was already in the buggy. "There's no time to lose," he called out, and the ejaculation caused Scanlan to turn his head in that direction. He was startled for a moment by the look of fiendish rage with which the fellow was regarding him. Before he could say a word, however, Dr. Cronin had taken his seat in the vehicle. A whip cut through the air and descended on the animal's back, and as it started off the physician called out to his friend, who still stood on the sidewalk:

    "I may get down town in an hour, but don't wait for me. I really don't know how long this case may occupy me."

    Man proposes, but God disposes. It was the physician's last farewell to his home and his friends. The white horse sped into the darkness and each revolution of the wheels of the vehicle carried one of its occupants nearer his doom.

    THE STORY OF HIS LIFE.

    It is necessary to digress a moment at this point in order that something may be said regarding the previous history of the man whose name was soon to be on millions of tongues. Born on August 7th, 1846, on Erin's soil, near the town of Mallow, in the famed county of Cork, he was brought to the United States when yet a babe in his mother's arms.

    For five years thereafter he was numbered among the population of New York City. Thence the family moved to Baltimore, and thence again to the province of Ontario. When ten years of age he was placed in the care of the Christian Brothers at the Academy of St. Catherines. He graduated with honors in 1863, and, a boy of seventeen, started out to battle with the world. His first wages were earned at Petroleum City, Pa., where he taught school. From here he went to Titusville and thence to Clearfield, in the same state, where in 1866 he held a good position in a store. But he was restless and ambitious.

    There was no charm--from his point of view--in the plodding life of a country school teacher or store keeper. He wanted to make his way in the world and he realized that in order to accomplish this it would be necessary to take the historic advice of Horace Greeley and "go west."

    Accordingly, late in the fall of 1867 he bade farewell to the many friends and acquaintances he had made in the oil regions and departed for Missouri. He first located in a country town, but after a short stay removed again to St. Louis. Here he secured a position in the store of Michael Dougherty, a grocer. Those who came in contact with him at that time remembered him in after years as a young man of pleasing presence, fine attainments and a remarkably good musician.

    He was especially a fine tenor singer, and soon after his arrival he became a member of the choir of the Catholic Church of St. John's. The numerous services and consequent rehearsals, however, conflicted materially with his work at the store, and as a result he secured another position as superintendent of omnibuses for a local transfer concern.

    Meanwhile he had been industriously engaged in the study of pharmacy, and so well did he combine this craving after knowledge with commendable prudence and economy, that after awhile he was enabled to become a full fledged druggist with a store of his own on Garrison street, adjacent to Easton avenue. Even then, however, he was not satisfied. He aimed still higher, and immediately begun the study of medicine at the Missouri College.

    From this institution he graduated in 1878, and, relinquishing the drug business, entered upon the practice of his newly chosen profession.

    Meanwhile he had identified himself with the local militia, and held the rank of captain at the time of the strike in 1877. Shortly after his graduation he was appointed a commissioner to the Paris exposition. The next twelve months were passed abroad, a goodly portion of that period being spent in Dublin and other parts of Ireland. Returning home, he accepted the professorship of materia medica and therapeutics in the St. Louis College of Physicians and Surgeons.

    Even with the onerous duties of this responsible position he found time and opportunity to study for two years--'80 and '81, at the Jesuit University, and received as his reward the degrees of A. M., and Ph. D. In 1882, by the advice of friends, he left St. Louis for Chicago, and almost immediately upon his arrival in the Garden City was appointed one of the staff of physicians at the Cook County Hospital. From this he drifted into private practice, and gradually became identified with a large number of political and secret societies.

    Among the latter were the Royal League, the Legion of Honor, Ancient Order of Hibernians, Ancient Order of United Workmen, and Independent Order of Foresters. He was at one time or another a Deputy Grand Regent of the Royal Arcanum, Past Commander of the Knights of Pythias and Chief Ranger of the Catholic Order of Foresters. Of many of these societies, as well as of the Plasterers' Union, he was the medical examiner. His practice necessarily was a lucrative one.

    He took an active interest in various Irish movements calculated to elevate his race and to promote the cause of Irish independence, and, at the time of his taking off, he was president of the Celto-American Club of Chicago.

    Dr. Cronin never married. When rallied on one occasion on his apparent determination to live and die a bachelor, he tersely rejoined that "he had no desire to make widows." His only surviving immediate relatives were a sister, Mrs. Carroll, living at St. Catherines, Ont., and a brother John, who, just before the tragedy, had removed from Pawnee Rock, Kan., to Arkansas. He also had two nieces who were Mother Superiors in Canadian convents.

    In appearance he was a fine looking man, five feet ten and one-half inches tall, weighing 180 pounds and well proportioned. His hair was black and his luxuriant mustache was generally worn long and wavy at the ends. Personally he was courteous and warm-hearted. At the same time his impulses were quick and strong, and, while he would go to any extreme to serve a friend, he would follow up an enemy with relentless determination and vindictiveness.

    Wherever he went he enjoyed great popularity, and he could always boast of an extensive acquaintance and a host of close friends. He always retained the fine tenor voice of his youth and almost his last public appearance in Chicago was at the Washington centennial celebration at the Cavalry Armory, on which occasion he sang a specially composed "Hymn to Washington," with such telling effect as not only to elicit an encore but to rouse the vast audience to unwonted enthusiasm.

    CHAPTER II.

    DR. CRONIN FAILS TO RETURN HOME--ANXIETY OF HIS FRIENDS--THE EARLY

    MORNING RIDE TO THE ICE HOUSE--O'SULLIVAN'S SURPRISE AND IGNORANCE--THE

    MYSTERIOUS WAGON AND ITS OCCUPANTS--A BLOODY TRUNK IS FOUND--THE SEARCH

    COMMENCED--"IT IS HIS HAIR."

    Dr. Cronin did not join his friends at the meeting of the Celto-American Society that memorable Saturday night. Nor, although the Conklins waited for him until long past midnight, were the familiar footsteps heard upon the stairs. The Sabbath dawned, and the first streaks of grey penetrated through the curtains into his apartments, but he was still absent.

    Naturally the Conklins became alarmed. During all the years that the physician had lived with them he had been a model of punctuality in his habits. It was the first occasion that he had remained so long from home without reason. If his business affairs happened to keep him away even an hour longer than usual it was his invariable practice to in some way contrive to advise his friends, so that they might notify any patients that came in his absence.

    Moreover, he was not a drinking man and such a thing as staying out all night with boon companions was foreign to his practice. Yet, eight hours had sped by, the morning had broken, and he had not returned. No wonder, then, that the family was alarmed, or that Mr. Conklin, without waiting for breakfast, determined to procure a buggy and drive to P. O'Sullivan's residence, which adjoined his ice house, at the corner of Seminary Avenue and Lake View. A startling surprise awaited him at the end of his six mile ride.

    O'Sullivan, when aroused from bed, was, to all appearances, considerably surprised when asked if the doctor was in the house.

    [Illustration: P. O'SULLIVAN, THE ICE MAN.]

    "This is all news to me," he said, with an apparent air of frankness. "I have not been out of town and I know nothing of the man in a buggy."

    "Was there not an accident in your ice house?" he was asked. "No," was the reply. "I have only four men in my employ and none of them have been injured."

    "Then you did not call on Dr. Cronin, or send for him?"

    "No, the man who did call used my name without authority. You say he used one of my cards, leaving it at the office. Well, I can understand how that happened. My cards are scattered all over Lake View and the city, and anybody could have used one in the same way."

    "Do you know Dr. Cronin?" the ice man was asked.

    "Yes," was his reply, "I have met him several times, and we were quite friendly."

    "How did you come to engage him as physician to your family and workmen, when you live six miles from his office?"

    This pointed query seemed to stagger the ice man for a moment, but at last he replied:

    "He was recommended to me by Justice Mahoney." The latter, who had been elected a Lake View Magistrate but a few weeks before, had been regarded as one of Dr. Cronin's friends.

    "Then you do not know how it happened that he was summoned to your ice house?" was the final query.

    "I do not," emphatically replied O'Sullivan, "I cannot understand what were the motives of the man who went for him."

    This was all that the ice man had to say. In the light of subsequent events, however, it was of importance. Mr. Conklin's worst fears were intensified. Driving rapidly home, he learned from his wife that the physician had not taken his revolver, as was his practice when going on a long trip; that he had only a small amount of money with him, and that he wore no jewelry of value except a watch. Without delay, Conklin proceeded to notify Frank J. Scanlan, his brother John, and two or three other Irish-Americans of prominence.

    "This is the work of political enemies," they said without hesitation, "it has been skillfully planned and executed. It will take time and money to find him, if it is not intended to murder him."

    Significant words. At that very hour the blood of the murdered man was calling aloud for vengeance.

    A hue and cry was at once raised. The Chicago police were notified, and the most experienced detectives of the department started out on the case. Pinkerton's Detective Agency was retained, and Detective Frank Murray went out to Lake View as fast as a swift horse could take him.

    Captain Schaack of the Chicago Avenue Station, and officers of the Lake View police, were waited on and urged to turn loose all the officers they could spare to solve the mystery. Last, but not least, the newspaper offices were advised of the disappearance, and a score or more of sleuth reporters were soon in the suburb. By sundown of Sunday nearly sixty people were engaged in the search.

    A STARTLING DISCOVERY.

    Meanwhile there had been startling developments in another direction.

    Somewhere in the neighborhood of two o'clock on the morning of the same day (Sunday) and about six hours after the physician had been decoyed from his residence, Officers Smith and Hayden, of the Lake View police force, were on duty at the corner of Clark and Diversey Streets, when they saw a carpenter's wagon, drawn by a bay horse, rumbling at a furious rate toward the north. The Lake View police were under instructions to hail passing vehicles and pedestrians after midnight, and accordingly, Officer Smith stepped out on the pavement to look at the two men who sat upon the driver's seat.

    [Illustration: THE MYSTERIOUS WAGON.]

    The wagon was driven at such speed, however, that the officer did not have time to look into the faces of the two mysterious men or command them to stop. There was a large trunk in the wagon. Both officers saw this receptacle. When the wagon had disappeared Officer Smith became suspicious of the two drivers, and told Officer Hayden so. The two policemen patrolled their beats until about 3.30 o'clock when they again met at Clark and Diversey Streets. They had been there but a few moments when they again heard a vehicle rumbling over the pavement. It proved to be the same old carpenter's wagon with its mysterious occupants and its old bay horse.

    But the trunk was no longer in the wagon. This time Hayden walked out upon the pavement to look at the men in the driver's seat. One of them wore a black derby hat. His companion wore a soft hat.

    Both were young and muscular. There was no name on the wagon. Officer Hayden saw all this, but he could not get a good view of the men on the seat. He did not hail them because he thought the movement of a trunk at that time of year was not extraordinary. The wagon rolled back toward Chicago and Officer Hayden dismissed the incident from his mind; but Officer Smith was greatly disturbed, and told his companion so several times during the early morning hours.

    FINDING THE BLOODY TRUNK.

    The officers returned to the station at the usual hour, but neither made any report of the mysterious wagon or its still more mysterious occupants. At half past seven o'clock, Alderman Chapman, of Lake View, was driving along Evanston Avenue, between Graceland and the Roman Catholic Cemetery. He had reached a point five hundred yards from Sultzer Street, when he saw three men standing around a trunk which stood back of a bush, with one end thrust into the ditch which runs near the thoroughfare. Alderman Chapman alighted and went to the spot.

    The cover of the trunk had been forced open. The interior was bespattered with blood and partially filled with absorbent cotton which was saturated with gore. Chapman drove hurriedly to the Lake View Police Station and gave the alarm. Captain Villiers and a detachment of officers leaped into the patrol wagon and made a furious run to the lonely spot. When they got there they found a large crowd of gaping men and boys who had trampled the grass in every direction. The trunk was taken to the station house. The first thing Captain Villiers did after he cleared his private room of the curiosity seekers who had swarmed into the station house, was to make a careful examination of the trunk.

    He found enough evidence to satisfy him that a grown person had been murdered, thrust into it, and then carted to the spot between the two cemeteries. The trunk was new and large. A man six feet tall could be cramped into it. A trunk dealer who was summoned to the station house by Captain Villiers, said at once that it had been made either in Racine or Milwaukee. It was of cheap pattern and had evidently been purchased for the purpose for which it was used.

    The trunk had been locked after the body had been placed in it and the cotton had been packed about the wounds in order to stanch the flow of blood and thus insure greater safety in its transmission from place to place. Before the body was removed the lock of the trunk had been broken by two sharp blows with a blunt instrument. The marks of these blows were on both sides of the lock. In their haste to remove the body the murderers had thrown the cover back with such force that one of the sheet-iron hinges was broken.

    Captain Villiers picked the cotton out and placed it upon his table. He had formerly been a doctor and his examination of the cotton led him to the belief that the murder must have been committed some time after midnight. Some of the absorbent material was still soft with blood and there was a pool of fresh blood in one corner of the trunk. Careful examination of the cotton revealed other things to the officer. He found a lock of dark-brown hair, which was almost as fine as a woman's but not so glossy.

    [Illustration: THE SPOT WHERE THE TRUNK WAS FOUND.]

    [Illustration: THE BLOODY TRUNK AND ITS CONTENTS.]

    This was the only possible tangible clue to the identity of the victim.

    The lock of hair was placed under a microscope. It was found to be filled with blood and particles of cotton.

    More closely examined; it looked as though it had been chopped off with a blunt instrument. It had not been pulled out of the scalp but the hairs were all of uneven length and looked as though they might have come off the cranium near the forehead. The inside of the cover of the trunk was bespattered with blood. Some of the life fluid had trickled down the exterior; presumably when the body was dragged out upon the ground. There were no marks on the trunk and aside from the lock of hair there was absolutely nothing left for the officers to hold for identification.

    SEARCHING FOR CLUES.

    Captain Villiers had not yet heard of the disappearance of Dr. Cronin.

    He was quickly satisfied, however, that a diabolical murder had been committed and at once issued orders to his subordinates to institute a thorough search for the body, which he believed to be somewhere in the neighborhood of the spot where the trunk was found. A patrol wagon filled with officers was out the entire afternoon. The men searched all the brush, prairie and vacant houses for a mile around, but could find no trace of the corpse.

    So many persons had trampled the grass at the spot where the trunk was found that the officers could not discover tracks of any vehicle. Evanston Avenue is so well paved that search along this much travelled highway would have been useless. The officers scoured the grass, examined the fences and went even so far as to invade the cemeteries. Not a drop of blood nor a particle of cotton could be found anywhere.

    Three boards of a fence were down at Argyle Street, but there was no evidence that they had been removed for the purpose of assisting men in the removal of a body. Efforts were made to find the men who first discovered the trunk but without result. One man that drove along the Evanston road an hour ahead of Alderman Chapman was positive that it was not there at that time, while on the other hand the alderman insisted that there were men at the spot for some time before he happened along in his buggy.

    It was six o'clock on Sunday evening when Officers Smith and Hayden entered the station to report for their night's work. The instant Smith entered the Captain's private room he declared that the bloody trunk lying before him was the one he had seen in the carpenter's wagon when he stood with his brother-officer at Clark and Diversey Streets in the early morning.

    Officer Hayden, when called in, was equally positive. At this moment the news of Dr. Cronin's disappearance was received, and Captain Villiers became intensely excited. The report that Dr. Cronin was missing under the most alarming circumstances and the gory evidences of a murder lying before him seemed to inspire the Captain with the belief that perhaps the mystery surrounding the well-known doctor's disappearance had been solved. He at once issued orders for a search for the mysterious wagon and its occupants. He hurriedly drove over to O'Sullivan's and put the ice man through a sharp examination. The latter, however, stuck to the story he had told earlier in the day.

    He knew nothing but what he had been told, he said; and his manner was so earnest, and his distress of mind--to outward appearances--so intense, that the official took him at his word.

    "JUST LIKE HIS HAIR."

    From the icehouse Captain Villiers drove to the home of the missing physician. For hours the apartments had been thronged with visitors, some waiting hour after hour, others coming and going, to hear the latest intelligence of the search. Without apprising them of his conjectures regarding the trunk the captain enquired as to the length of Dr. Cronin's hair.

    "He wore his hair much longer than men usually do," said Mrs. Conklin, "and lately it had been quite long."

    "Had he plenty of hair on the top of his head" the captain went on.

    "Yes" replied some one in the room "and it was quite long."

    [Illustration: MR. AND MRS. CONKLIN.]

    The Chief then took from his pocket the scrap of paper containing the lock of hair he had found in the trunk, and those present crowded around and examined it closely. Some were inclined to believe that it resembled that of the missing man, but were fearful of expressing a positive opinion. At this juncture F. T. Scanlan, Jr., came into the room. He took the lock of hair and fingered it for a moment, his face blanched, and as he laid it down upon the table he ejaculated:

    "That is just like his hair, yes, just like it."

    There was a scream and a fall. One of the ladies present had fainted away.

    By this time Captain Villiers was fully convinced that the lock of hair was destined to play an important part in the solution of the mystery.

    At the same time he was desirous that the identification should be more complete, or that the resemblance between the lock and the hair of the missing man should be established by the testimony of those best qualified to speak on the subject. Accordingly, bright and early on the following morning he visited the tonsorial establishment one door north of the Windsor theatre, where for years the physician had been in the habit of getting shaved three or four times weekly. Here, however, his theory encountered a set back. The proprietor, H. F.

    Wisch, was positive that the hair had come from some other head than that of Dr. Cronin. In this opinion he was supported by two of his employes. They had cut his hair time and again, and they insisted that there could be no possibility of their being mistaken when they said that the hair could not have come from Dr. Cronin's head. The lock that they were asked to identify was fully four inches long, and fine, while, so they contended, the physician's hair was exceptionally coarse.

    Moreover--and this appeared to be conclusive--his hair had been cut three days prior to his disappearance and it would have been impossible that a lock four inches in length could have been left on his head. So far as could be remembered his head was trimmed to an average length of two inches. As to color, there was something of a resemblance, although there was enough apparent difference in shade to be noticeable when compared with a few hairs taken from a hair brush that was kept for the doctor's exclusive use. Mr. and Mrs.

    Conklin, however, took issue with Barber Wisch on almost every point. The hair of their friend and tenant they asserted, was long, soft and remarkably silky, while, moreover, it was precisely of the same shade as the lock held by Captain Villiers. In the face of these conflicting statements the latter very wisely concluded that it would be useless to push this particular branch of the investigation at that time, and the clue was consigned to a drawer of the safe in the Lake View Station.

    WAGON TRACKS LEAD TO THE WATER'S EDGE.

    Meanwhile every available officer of the police force of the suburb, reinforced by Captain Schaack and a number of city detectives and officers, were searching high and low to discover the whereabouts of the physician and to solve the mystery surrounding the bloody trunk. Captain Schaack and his associates, after examining the locality of the find, tramped over the ground for a mile around.

    [Illustration: DETECTIVES INSPECTING THE SPOT WHERE THE TRUNK WAS FOUND.]

    While thus engaged a discovery was made that in the light of subsequent events was of considerable importance. It was the tracks of a wagon in the sandy road leading to the lake. Commencing at a point but a few yards from the place where the trunk was dumped, the trail went northwardly some three hundred yards, then turned to the side road and went east to the water's edge. Here in the wet sand the indications of a halt were quite plain.

    Thence, after following the beach about a hundred yards, the tracks turned into what was known as the Wilson road, and apparently proceeded southward to the city. It was impossible to determine from appearances whether the ruts were a day or a week old, for the high wind had blown the fine sand across the level beach in great clouds.

    At this juncture, however, a special officer of the village of Edgewater, and a watchman at the station, Wade by name, and who had learned that the officers were inclined to connect the wagon tracks with the trunk, told an interesting story.

    "Early on Sunday morning," he said, "I was standing on Hollywood avenue, just north of Bryn Mawr avenue, when I saw a team standing near the edge of the lake. It was about 1:05, and I went to the team and asked a fellow who stood near what he was doing there at that hour of the night."

    "We're looking for the Lake Shore drive," said he, "we want to get back to town."

    "The Lake Shore drive, man, is two miles from here," I said, "can't you see there is no roadway here?"

    "While I was talking a couple of fellows who had been walking along the beach came up."

    "Boys," said the first man, "this officer says we're away off the road."

    "At this they all got into the wagon and drove west on Bryn Mawr avenue until they reached the Evanston road. Then they started down Evanston avenue at a rapid gait and I lost sight of them. I noticed a long square box in the wagon, but it was very dark and I could not see plainly what it was. The fellow I talked to, however, I'll recognize and identify anywhere."

    From a study of the surroundings, taken in connection with this story, the conclusion was arrived at by the police authorities that the trunk had been first taken to the lake, its contents thrown into the surf, and that it was then brought back into the road and dumped into the ditch.

    This, as was developed later, was the original intention of the murderers. The point on the beach where the tracks showed that the vehicle had made a halt was about as dreary and desolate a spot as could be found in the country. Sandy, covered with heavy timber, and removed nearly half a mile from a house or a shelter of any kind, it was just the place that a man or a party of men with a murderous job on their hands would have naturally selected.

    To empty a trunk into the lake, or to dig a hole in the sand and drop a human body in it, would have been the work of but a few minutes, and all traces of the bloody crime might thus have been obliterated forever.

    THE SEARCH REVEALS NOTHING.

    For the next forty-eight hours the efforts of the authorities were re-doubled. All the livery stables on the north side of the city were visited for the purpose of ascertaining if a white horse and vehicle, as described by Mrs. Conklin and Frank Scanlan, had been rented out on the previous Saturday. Several white horses were owned by the liverymen in that section, but all, apparently, were satisfactorily accounted for.

    The one man, who, had he so chosen, could, by answering the question in the affirmative, have solved at least this portion of the mystery, preferred to hold his peace for the time being. Scores of men and boys waded through the pond in the German Catholic Cemetery, the river in the vicinity was dragged, nearly every sewer and sluice box in the city of Lake View was examined, and even the clay holes--which were as plentiful thereabouts as reefs in Lake Michigan--were hunted from end to end.

    As a last resort, and at the earnest solicitation of friends of Dr. Cronin, the Chicago River was dredged for a distance of six hundred feet at Fullerton avenue bridge, over which the wagon with the trunk was supposed to have crossed. This task, conducted by Captain Schaack and eight officers, occupied two days. Like the search in every other direction, however, it was utterly without result.

    The physician had disappeared as completely as though the earth had opened and swallowed him up, and the mystery of the trunk and its gory contents remained a mystery still.

    CHAPTER III.

    AN ACCIDENTAL CLUE--FRANK WOODRUFF'S ARREST--HOW HE WAS HIRED TO GET A

    WAGON TO CARRY THE MYSTERIOUS TRUNK TO LAKE VIEW--A CORPSE IS DUMPED

    OUT--HE THINKS IT WAS THAT OF A WOMAN--HIS SENSATIONAL CONFESSION--THE

    POLICE ON A WILD GOOSE CHASE.

    Despite the small army of professional and amateur detectives at work on the case and the untiring labors of the missing man's friends, it was an accident rather than a clue that brought about the first important development of this sensational tragedy.

    On Thursday morning, May 9th, five days after the physician had disappeared as completely as though the ground had opened and swallowed him up, a stable owner named Foley, having barns on Fifteenth Street near Centre Avenue, entered the Twelfth Street Police Court while the hearing of a case was in progress, and informed Lieutenant Beck that a young man had been trying to sell him a horse and wagon and that he had agreed to purchase the rig for $10, in order that he might detain the supposed horse-thief until the police could be notified.

    Two officers, O'Malley and Halle, were at once sent to the barn. The man, upon being placed under arrest, at once fainted.

    Upon regaining consciousness, he was started for the station. His peculiar agitation was noticed by the officers, and one of them, in joking about a horse-thief having such a nervous temperament, made a slight remark in which he mentioned the name of Dr. Cronin. The prisoner evinced a strong tendency to faint again, and gasped:

    "I'll tell you all when I get to the station."

    The officers laughed. Their dull comprehensions failed to connect the remark with the trunk mystery. When the station was reached, however, and the attention of Lieutenant Beck had been called to what the man had said, he at once jumped to the conclusion that the horse was the one attached to the wagon that had hauled the mysterious trunk. He ordered the man into his private office and at once began to put him in what is known in police parlance as "the sweat box," or in other words, to put him through a rapid course of questioning.

    At first the man--a mild mannered young fellow, attired in clothes of cheap material, with bad complexion, square features, heavy jaws, and a pronounced squint in one eye--gave his name as Frank J. Black, although he afterwards admitted that it was Woodruff. He was, he said, 26 years of age, a Canadian by birth, and a railroad laborer by occupation.

    "I want to make a confession," he remarked, after the preliminaries had been completed. He was warned that it would have to be entirely voluntary, and that no immunity could be promised. To this understanding he gave his assent, and Sergeant Cosgrove, having been called in as a witness, the prisoner commenced his story:

    "A week ago last Wednesday," (May 1) he said, "I was in Sol Van Praag's gambling house, at 392 South State Street, playing poker. I lost $8, and, just before 11 o'clock, I got up from the table saying: I ought not to gamble, I can't afford to lose any money. Just then William H. King, an old friend of mine, who was standing by, said to me: 'I'll put you on the road to make a few dollars if you want to.' I told him I was willing," went on Woodruff, "and that I could be found at D. G. Dean's livery stable, at 406 Webster Avenue, where I was working.

    We had several drinks, and then went down State Street to Madison, where King left me. He did not say how I was to make the money. But last Sunday he came up to the stable in the afternoon, and called me out. We went into a saloon near by, and King said to me: 'I want you to get a horse and some light rig in which to carry a trunk, about 2 o'clock to-morrow morning, if you can. I want you to do it quietly, and be sure to come out before three or four o'clock. If you can't get out as early as that, I don't want you at all.'"

    Woodruff had been talking rapidly. He paused a moment for breath, and then went on.

    WOODRUFF'S LURID STORY.

    "The wagon was to be brought to a corner a few blocks from our stable, where King was to be in waiting. At three o'clock in the morning I hitched a white horse to a light wagon and drove to the corner, where I found King. He told me it was all right, and that there was $25 in it for me. King got into the wagon and told me to drive to the rear of 528 North State Street. When we got there, we met a man that I supposed was Dr. Cronin, also a sporting man named Dick Fairburn, who I knew to be a desperate character.

    They went into the barn and hauled out a trunk. The man I supposed was Cronin was extremely impatient and nervous, and urged the others to hurry up. They called him 'Doc.' and when he was inclined to get mad, Fairburn said, 'all right, Doc., we'll hurry.' When the trunk was put into the wagon, King and Fairburn got in and the rig started north, 'Doc.' being left behind. The horse was guided up the Lake Shore drive to the north end of Lincoln Park.

    Here a strange man in a high cart, driving a buckskin-colored horse, approached the wagon from behind, and the men told me to hurry out of the way. I turned off the road into a parallel driveway and went up about a quarter of a mile.

    Then King told me to stop. While going up the driveway, King gave me $25, and I heard him say:

    'If we'd have let Tom alone, we'd have had the Doc. in here too.'

    When the wagon stopped, King remarked as he jumped off:

    "Here's where we drop Alice."

    "Then the trunk was opened and a stench came out. The horse became restless and I had to get out and attend to him. What I saw led me to believe that the body removed from the box was that of a woman in a mutilated condition. I saw a leg that had been cut off at the thigh. The corpse was wrapped in cotton batting. After the remains had been dumped near a clump of bushes, the batting was placed in the trunk, which was then thrown into the wagon. Then King said: "Leave us here. You drive on a piece and hide the trunk some way or another, and then go home."

    "I drove on for about fifteen minutes," the fellow resumed, "and then I stopped at a hole and threw the trunk into it. Then I made straight for the barn, driving as fast as I could. I reached there at five o'clock, and managed to get in without any one seeing me."

    "How was it possible for you to get the rig out without being detected," Woodruff was asked.

    "O, that's easy enough," he replied, with a laugh. "You could go there yourself, almost any night, and do the same thing. Howard (one of the employes) is usually out, seeing his girl, and as for Charlie (another employe), you might fire a sixteen-pound cannon under his ears, and he'd never wake up. I went to bed as usual that night, just about eleven o'clock, in the room near the stable. I lay quiet until I knew that the boys were asleep, and then I slipped out and went down the stairway to the floor where the horses were, carrying my shoes in my hand. I had left the wagon in the alley outside, so as to be sure of it."

    "What kind of a rig was it," asked the Lieutenant.

    "It was a red gear wagon, with a black box and a high dashboard in front. The doors leading to the barn are folding doors, which open easily, and the floor is sprinkled with sawdust. I got the horse out all right, after muffling its hoofs, and led it to the wagon in the alley, where I hitched it up. I am sure nobody saw me when I got back. Somebody used the mare later in the day (Sunday), and said when she came out, 'It doesn't seem to me she's fresh, to-day.' I heard it all, but I didn't say a word."

    Woodruff was sharply questioned, with the view of testing his veracity, but he stuck closely to his statements. He admitted that he had taken the horse and wagon that he was charged with stealing from Dean's stable two days before, and inquiry by telephone developed the fact that Dean had reported his loss at the nearest police station. The prisoner admitted that he had made up his mind to leave the city just before being arrested, because he was afraid of Fairburn, who had told him to say nothing about the midnight ride, and had warned him that if he "peached" he would kill him (Woodruff), if he had to wait twenty years to do it.

    Fairburn, he described as being short, heavy-set, with gray hair and moustache. He was a desperate man, and one not afraid to commit murder. King was about thirty-two, six feet tall, stout, dark-complexioned, and of gentlemanly appearance.

    No time was lost by Lieutenant Beck in communicating the developments of the day to his superiors, and Captains Schaack and O'Donnell were at the station as fast as horseflesh could bring them. The records of the two men mentioned by the horse-thief were first looked up, and both turned out to be hard cases. Fairburn was recognized from the description as a desperate thief, and who, under the alias of Neil White, had "done time" in the penitentiary. At one time he was a resident of Minneapolis.

    WOODRUFF GOES OVER THE ROUTE.

    As a result of the conference of the two police officials it was decided that, in order to test the truthfulness of the prisoner, he should be taken out and allowed to drive over the route that he claimed to have taken on that memorable Saturday night. Just as soon as darkness had set in this idea was carried into effect. Starting from Webster and Lincoln avenues, he proceeded directly to North State and Schiller streets, turned into the alley between State and Dearborn, and stopped in front of the barn in the rear of 528 North State street.

    This, he claimed, was the place from which the trunk was taken. From here the drive was north to North avenue, where he turned to the right, and struck the Lake Shore drive. Woodruff stopped the horse directly opposite the artesian well, and, pointing to a clump of bushes, told the officers that that was the place where the trunk had been emptied and the mutilated body taken out and left with Fairburn and King. This spot was directly below the sand-hills, and a little while before had been planted with evergreens and shrubbery.

    Resuming the trip, Woodruff drove straight and without prompting or hesitation to the spot where the empty trunk was found, on the Evanston road, north of Sulzer street. His course was along the Lake Shore drive to Belmont avenue, thence to Evanston avenue, and from thence north until the spot was reached. At the ditch he stopped long enough to explain how the trunk fell sideways on the ground, and in doing so burst open, the lid breaking off at one end.

    His description of the trunk corresponded in every detail with the one that at that time was locked away in the Lake View Station.

    What between the story and the trip, the police were considerably mystified. It seemed impossible that, even with the newspaper accounts of the disappearance and the details as material to work upon, a man of only average intelligence could invent such a story and strike the localities with such accuracy. At the same time outside investigation failed to substantiate what he had said.

    The keeper of the gambling house denied that any men answering to the description of King and Fairburn had ever frequented his place, or been seen in conversation with Woodruff, although he recognized the latter as an occasional visitor to the den. Liveryman Dean and his employes were equally positive that it would have been impossible for the horse and wagon to have been taken from the stable and returned without detection.

    Finally, the occupier of the barn scouted the idea that the trunk had been taken from that place as ridiculous, in view of the fact that it was always kept well locked and provided in addition with burglar alarms communicating with the house. Diligent inquiry in a dozen different directions failed to locate either of the two men named by the prisoner, or to corroborate any other portion of the story. But Woodruff, when confronted with these contradictions, held his ground well, even in the face of a vigorous cross-examination.

    His description of the mysterious "Doc" tallied with that of Dr. Cronin to the life. He was positive, moreover, that the corpse was that of a woman, not only because the men had referred to "Alice," or "Allie," but also because the hand that was exposed was soft and white and slender. This afforded ground for the theory that the remains might have been those of a woman who had fallen a victim to a criminal operation, but a little reasoning showed that this was untenable.

    It was hardly likely that King would have arranged with Woodruff to haul the trunk three days before the nefarious job was to be done, for he could not very well have known that the operation would result in the death of the victim and that, consequently, there would be a corpse to dispose of. Nor could the crime have been committed on the Wednesday, the day upon which Woodruff claimed to have been first approached, without the decomposing body attracting suspicion.

    The only effect, therefore, of Woodruff's first confession--for several more were to follow at later stages of the case--was to deepen the mystery and, incidentally, to start the authorities and friends of Dr. Cronin on another wild goose chase. The ponds and river were dragged a second time, sand hills and prairie trudged over for miles, until the weary and dispirited men were ready to drop the work as well as the idea that any connection existed between the blood-stained trunk and the disappearance of the physician.

    Twenty-four hours later, as an outcome of sinister influences that emanated from Canada, and which are dealt with at length in another chapter, the search was practically abandoned by almost every one concerned.

    CHAPTER IV.

    "IT IS A CONSPIRACY"--DR. CRONIN'S FRIENDS CLAIM THE MURDER WAS A

    POLITICAL ASSASSINATION--THE PUBLIC SCEPTICAL UNTIL STARTLING

    DEVELOPMENTS ARE MADE--THE PHYSICIAN IN DANGER OF HIS LIFE FOR

    YEARS--PREVIOUS ATTEMPTS TO "REMOVE" HIM--THE TROUBLE IN THE

    CLAN-NA-GAEL--CHARGES AND COUNTER CHARGES--THE BUFFALO CONVENTION--WHY

    HIS "REMOVAL" BECAME A NECESSITY TO CERTAIN PEOPLE.

    "He is dead I feel sure of it." So said Mrs. Conklin, when the news of the finding of the bloody trunk, the cotton batting, and the locks of matted hair, had been brought to her.

    "This is the work of political enemies" echoed Frank T. Scanlan.

    "Dr. Cronin has been the victim of a political assassination" was the immediate verdict of a number of prominent Irishmen of New York, Philadelphia and other places. And the developments soon to come showed that they knew whereof they spoke.

    But the general public, while it listened and eagerly discussed the mystery, was inclined to be sceptical.

    A political murder in the free, liberty loving United States. It could not be! Two Presidents had, it was true, been shot in cold blood by madmen; and in different parts of the country and on divers occasions men had been killed in scrimmages at the polls as a result of troubles growing out of election affairs.

    But these were not political murders in the general acceptation of the term, not the deliberate well planned taking of life; not the outgrowth of a conspiracy to "remove" some one whose particular political predelictions or position had rendered him obnoxious to those politically associated with him. "Such things might happen abroad it is true" said the sceptics, "but on American soil it would be an impossibility."

    DR. CRONIN AS A PROPHET.

    Dr. Cronin's friends were not among the sceptics. Very well they knew that there was more than ordinary ground for the fears they had expressed. There was abundant evidence that long before his death the physician had known that his life was threatened, and that any day might be his last. This knowledge, or belief,--it may be put in either way--was clearly outlined in a pamphlet which, under the title of "Is it a conspiracy," he caused to be printed and circulated among his friends a year before his taking off.

    In this document which, at the time was summed up by most of those that read it, as a mass of words and phrases without meaning to any one but the writer, Dr. Cronin clearly outlined the fact that he would meet his end by violent means. There was a key to the story which, when read between the lines after his disappearance, made its meaning clear to many of those to whom it had previously seemed but a jumble of incoherences.

    The closing paragraph, in particular, was an extraordinary indication of the prophetic spirit that had been generated in the physician by the dangers that he knew assailed him.

    "It strikes me that your funeral would be a largely attended one," was the question that he put into the mouth of the mythical reporter who was supposed to be interviewing him.

    "Yes," was the reply that followed "and the cause of death extensively inquired into."

    Prophetic words. How largely his funeral was attended; how extensively the cause of death was investigated; this volume itself is a record.

    The fact that his life was in danger had been the burden of Dr. Cronin's confidences to his friends for a year prior to that memorable night in May.

    More than once attempts had been made to lure him to isolated and unfrequented spots on the pretense that his professional services were required. On one of these occasions, so it is said,--although the doctor was always uncommunicative on this point--he barely escaped with his life from a house whither he had been summoned to attend a woman who was, in reality, feigning sickness. At another time he publicly denounced a man whom he believed had been sent from a distant city in the east to encompass his death.

    Still another time a local sport who had been hired by his enemies to "do him up" as the expression was used; inspired by feelings of gratitude from some indirect favor, had made a clean breast of the matter. Little wonder then that Dr. Cronin felt that he lived the life of a marked man, and that sooner or later, he would fall a victim to the machinations of those that were bent upon his removal. But why had he enemies? and why moreover was his death so greatly desired?

    CRONIN AND THE CLAN-NA-GAEL.

    The answer to these questions is given in the theory adopted by the officers of the law immediately upon the discovery of the body; which was subsequently endorsed by the coroner's jury, re-indorsed by the Grand jury; and in pursuance of which seven men were soon to be placed upon trial for actual participation or complicity in the crime.

    This theory was that the physician had fallen a victim of a conspiracy, covering two continents, its ramifications extending in numerous directions and involving people of high as well as low repute, and that this conspiracy had for its object his deliberate removal in order that certain secrets and information that he possessed, and which virtually affected the reputation, honor, and credit of certain Irishmen of international reputation, might not be given to the world.

    In order, however, that this theory may be made clear, it is necessary to go back to the beginning of the trouble. Almost from his boyhood days Dr. Cronin had taken an active interest in organizations that had for their object the liberation of Ireland from British domination. One of these organizations was the Clan-na-Gael. This was probably the most closely oath-bound of all the Irish Societies of this country or abroad. Its strength, moreover, was phenomenal.

    Although, owing to the secrecy which surrounded its annual conventions, no public reports of its total membership had ever appeared of record, it was generally believed and understood that it ran into many scores of thousands, and penetrated into almost, if not quite, every section of the North American continent. In age it dated back to 1869, its cardinal object being to establish in Ireland an Irish republic, to bring about fraternal feelings among Irishmen in the United States, and generally assist in the elevation of the Irish race.

    It affiliated with the old revolutionary organizations in Ireland, and moved on lines so nearly masonic in their secrecy, that in many parts of the country the clergy of the Catholic church either discouraged or altogether forbade the members of their flocks from becoming identified with it. Despite this fact, however, the order, almost from its inception, grew in strength, in wealth, and in influence.

    There was nothing in the obligation which would-be members were compelled to take, before being entrusted with the pass-words and other secret work that conflicted with their duties as citizens of the United States, except that the occasion might arise when it would be necessary for them to violate the neutrality laws.

    Every man, however, that joined the Clan-na-Gael, or, as it was more generally known to the outside world, the "United Brotherhood," knew that, as an Irishman or a man of Irish descent, his sworn duty was loyalty to Ireland, and that, were he called upon to take up arms in aid of any movement for the independence of Erin's Isle, it would be his duty to comply without question or demur.

    The membership of the organization was divided into districts, which again were subdivided into local lodges or "Camps." Each district had its general officer, to whose authority each local camp was subject, and the district officers in turn made up an Executive Board. This body possessed absolute and complete control of the organization in every particular.

    THE "TRIANGLE" IN POWER.

    It was not until 1881, when it had passed its first decade of existence, that the United Brotherhood first came prominently to the attention of people of all nationalities in the United States. In that year it held a national convention in Chicago. At this time its membership was at its height.

    Tens of thousands of men of Irish blood had become affiliated with it for motives of the purest patriotism, many others on account of the secret political influence which it was enabled to wield; and not a few because they thought they saw in it a source of livelihood and profit to themselves.

    Its treasury had swollen to large proportions, as a natural result of that section of the constitution which required every local camp to remit ten per cent. of its gross receipts to the Executive Board, and to faithfully keep the balance, save and except so much as might be required for running expenses, in its treasury for an emergency. It was from this convention that the troubles which afterward overwhelmed the order first dated.

    One of its actions was to so change the system of government as to confide the supreme control to an Executive Board of five men, of which number three formed a quorum.

    Alexander Sullivan of Chicago, Michael Boland of Louisville, and D. C.

    Feeley of Rochester, New York, were elected members of this Executive Board, and, working together, became both the majority and necessary quorum. This was the trio which was destined to become famous in after years as the "Triangle."

    Almost from the day and hour that the convention adjourned, the "Triangle" commenced to rule the order with a rod of iron. Despite the fact that when it came into power there was in the treasury funds, according to the best data that has been obtainable, aggregating a quarter million of dollars, a new rule was promulgated which required nearly the entire receipts of each Camp, instead of the former ten per cent., to be forwarded to the National Executive Committee.

    In justification of this remarkable step, it was quietly given out that matters connected with the objects of the organization indicated that an imperative demand was very shortly expected, which would allow of no delay, and in which much money would be required. As the funds had been raised for the sole purpose of assisting in revolutionary efforts, which, from their very nature had necessarily to be conducted with the utmost secrecy, no great objection came from any quarter to the transfer of the funds.

    The amount thus placed in the control of Alexander Sullivan, as chief of the Executive Committee, and of Feeley and Boland, his aids, was subsequently stated by men who knew, men of honor and integrity, men whose word in commercial transactions was considered as good as their bond, as being in the immediate neighborhood of the enormous total of one hundred thousand dollars.

    VICTIMS OF A "PHYSICAL FORCE" POLICY.

    What followed in the next few years is a matter of history. At irregular intervals the news of dynamite explosions in different parts of England, was flashed over the wires that spanned the two continents beneath the broad waters of the great Atlantic. So, too, was the news of the death, or capture and subsequent imprisonment, of those supposed to have been primarily concerned in these affairs. Oftentimes the arrests were made under circumstances which could lead to no other belief than that the victim had been deliberately betrayed.

    Between 1881 and 1885 twenty-nine Irish revolutionists were sent from America into English prisons, and in almost every instance the suspicion was so strong as to almost amount to a certainty that these victims were betrayed to the government, against which their attack was to be directed, before they had left the vessel which had carried them across the ocean. This is the record:

    ##
    Date of | | |
    Sentence.
    | Name. | Crime. |Sentence.
    -------------+--------------------+------------------------+------------
    1881. | | |
    May |James McGrath |Attempt to blow up |Life.
    |James McKevitt | Liverpool Town Hall. |20 years.
    1882. | | |
    Jan.

    31 |John Tobin |Illegal possession of |7 years.
    | | nitro-glycerine. |
    July 31 |Thomas Walsh |Illegal possession of | 7 years.
    | | nitro-glycerine. |
    1883. | | |
    May 28 |Thomas Gallagher |Illegal manufacture of |Life.
    |A. G. Whitehead | nitro-glycerine |Life.
    |H. H.

    Wilson | at Birmingham |Life.
    |John Curtin | and transfer of it to |Life.
    July |William Tansey | London Exposition at |14 yrs.
    |Pat Noughton | Weston House in Galway.|8 yrs.
    |Pat Rogerson | |12 yrs.
    |James Kelly | |2 yrs. H.

    L.
    July 30 |Timothy Featherstone|Illegal possession of |Life.
    |Dennis Deasy | infernal machines. |Life.
    |Pat Flannigan | |Life.
    |Henry Dalton | |Life.
    Dec.

    21 |James McCullough |Outrages in Glasgow in |Life.
    |Thomas Dewanney | January, 1883. |Life.
    |Peter Callahan | |Life.
    |Henry McCann | |Life.
    |Terrance McDermott | |Life.
    |Dennis Casey | |7 yrs.
    |Pat McCabe | |7 yrs.
    |James Kelly | |7 yrs.
    |James Donnelly | |7 yrs.
    |Patrick Drum | |5 yrs.
    1884. | | |
    July 29 |John Daly |Illegal possession of |Life.
    |J.

    F. Egan | infernal machines. |20 yrs.
    1885. | | |
    March |Patrick Levy |Explosion at Mill street|1 yr. H. L.
    | | barracks. |
    May 18 |J. G. Cunningham |Explosion at Tower of |Life.
    |H. Burton | London, etc. |Life.
    Nov. 18 |J. Wallace, alias |Murder at Solihall. |20 yrs.
    | Duff | |
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------

    This was a total of thirty-two men convicted of participation in dynamite explosions. The conviction of Wallace for murder grew out of his arrest on the charge of conspiracy. Two of the unfortunates died shortly after their conviction, one was pardoned, and of the remainder there were on October the 1st, 1889, twenty-two still confined in British convict prisons.

    Besides these, two other delegates from the United States, Captain Mackey Lomasney and a mysterious man, known only as Peter Malone, were supposed to have been killed in the explosion on London Bridge on the evening of December the 13th, 1884, while one more of the number, James Moorehead, better known as Thomas J. Mooney, who, with others, managed the explosion in Whitehall in 1883, was successful in escaping to New York.

    Some time after his return to the United State he made a full statement of the manner in which he was sent abroad for dynamite work, and furnished with money and methods of introduction to the agents of destruction on the other side of the Atlantic.

    CRONIN TO THE FRONT.

    For a time Irish fealty proved equal to the situation, and no outcry was raised because the treasure was wasted, the lives of brothers lost, and the sentiment of the whole world turned against the cause of the freedom of Ireland. Presently, however, a demand was made by the Executive Board upon the local Camps for more money, and dissatisfaction began to manifest itself. It seemed incredible that the immense sum which but a few years before had been at the disposal of the Triangle could have been absorbed, and that, as was claimed the order was thousands of dollars in debt. An investigation was demanded, and the Triangle responded with its rod of iron.

    It declared that opposition should be crushed out. Member after member, and then Camp after Camp was expelled.

    It was at this time that Dr. Cronin came to the front. He was a collossus. He insisted that the members of the organization had a right to know what was being done with their money, whether the immense amounts levied and wrung from patriotic Irishmen in America, had been well used, or whether it had found its way through other channels into the pockets of financial conspirators.

    The Triangle did not deign to notice him for a while, but his following increased from scores to hundreds and from hundreds to thousands, and it became evident that the bold, intrepid Irishman who had forged his way from poverty to an honorable position in the metropolis of the West was the man of all men of whom to be feared. The fiat went out that Cronin's expulsion from the order was necessary to the future safety of the organization. An opportunity was soon found. In his own Camp, Dr.

    Cronin had read a circular from one of the Camps that had been expelled, protesting against the action of the Executive Board. For doing this he was charged with treason. This was in 1885. He was brought to trial in Chicago before a committee consisting of Lawrence Buckley, Frank Murray, John O'Malley, Daniel Coughlin, the detective, who later was to be charged with participation in his murder, and Henry LeCaron, alias Beach, afterward a British spy, and who had been introduced into the order by Alexander Sullivan. The latter acted as prosecutor.

    With such a trial committee it was little wonder but that the physician should have been pronounced guilty of treason, and that his expulsion from the order should have been decreed.

    The "treasonable" letter was as follows:

    THE "TREASONABLE" LETTER.

    The initials used throughout represent the titles in this order:

    "V. C.," United Brotherhood; "F. C.," Executive Body; "U. S.," United Sons; "D.," Camps; "I. R. B.," Irish Republican Brotherhood; "R. D.," Revolutionary Directorate; "S. C.," Supreme Council.

    HEADQUARTERS F. C. OF V. C.,

    Sep. 15, 1885.

    To the Officers and Members of the V. C. and of the U. S.:

    BROTHERS: In accordance with the call of the Committee of Safety a
    general convention of the V. C. was held in New York City, Aug. 3
    and 4, for the purpose of taking the necessary measures to save the
    organization from the ruin which threatens it. A full account of
    its proceedings will be found in the printed report, to which we
    invite your attention.

    Having been chosen by the convention to fill a position of great
    difficulty and responsibility in the organization during this, the
    supreme crisis of its existence, we feel it to be our duty to lay
    before you the plain facts of the present situation, and to ask the
    assistance of every honest man in bringing about a remedy. We make
    this appeal without regard to the side you may have taken in the
    recent and present troubles, knowing full well that nine-tenths of
    the organization are in a state of utter ignorance as to the actual
    facts, and that honest men have been led to sustain wrong.

    We make
    it more particularly to those who are supporting and yielding blind
    obedience to men who have turned their backs on the I. R. B.,
    thereby ignoring the fundamental principal which is the cause and
    object of our organization. If that support is withdrawn an
    effective remedy can be at once applied. That there is trouble you
    will not now deny, and that it is serious enough to menace the
    existence of a once powerful organization, and to threaten the ruin
    of the hopes that have hitherto stimulated our efforts for Ireland,
    every day will make more clear to your understanding.

    The efforts
    at concealment made by the men who created this trouble, the
    withholding of information as to the wholesale suspension of D's,
    and the mendacious assertions made in recent circulars, have all
    failed of the desired effect; and in every D in the organization,
    to-day, there is gloom and discouragement and members are fast
    falling away. No official denials, a thousand times repeated, can
    any longer conceal this fact. Every member from Maine to California
    can see it for himself.

    The truth is beginning to filter through
    the barriers set up against its entrance to the D's, by desperate
    men, whose characters depend on its suppression. The frantic
    efforts and reckless statements of the army of paid organizers,
    sent around to counteract the progress of truth and avert the
    exposure of wrong doing, are useless and unavailing. Many of these
    are the men under accusation of complicity in the fraud, and they
    now use your money to deceive you and prolong the reign of
    dishonesty.

    Their prevarications, contradictions, and shuffling
    evasions are doing more to establish the truth of the charges,
    against which they are vainly struggling, than the strongest
    statement made in the interest of right and justice, and a spirit
    is gradually growing up in the organization which will produce one
    of two results--reform and punishment of the evildoers, or
    disruption of the organization and escape of the prisoners.

    One or other of these results is inevitable. And whichever it is,
    it will be the clear and logical result of your action. Your
    withdrawal from the organization, in despair or disgust, will no
    more enable you to shake off your responsibility than if you give
    an active support to the criminals. Which result shall it be? The
    decision rests with you.

    If the men responsible for this wretched
    state of things cannot succeed in stifling all investigation into
    their misdeeds, they would prefer to see the organization smashed.
    "Dead men tell no tales." They know that an honest investigation
    would overwhelm them, and they are fighting for existence.
    Therefore they are determined there shall be none, and every D that
    demands one is suspended or left without communication. This
    conduct is capable of but one explanation. They cannot stand
    investigation.

    The question with them is, shall their personal
    reputations be destroyed, or the organization be ruined? and they
    have chosen the latter. Men with true instincts, and whose records
    were clean, would scorn to force themselves on any organization, to
    handle its funds and direct its policy, while under such
    accusations as have been leveled against the Triangle. Men with the
    real good of Ireland and of the V. C. at heart, would refuse to
    hold office at the expense of the unity and the efficiency of the
    organization. Looked at from any stand-point their conduct is
    indefensible and unpatriotic.

    No man fit for the duties of the high
    office, these men hold, would acquire it by such means or hold on
    to it when acquired. No men who honestly intended to aid the men at
    home to free Ireland--which is the fundamental principle of the V.
    C.--would begin their official careers by deceiving their
    colleagues in Ireland and persisting in carrying on any policy
    against their protest.

    Since the disastrous gathering, miscalled a convention, which met
    in Boston twelve months ago, the organization has been going from
    bad to worse. The deceit and trickery by which three members of the
    F. C. were enabled to continue themselves in power, and so to
    change the whole form and object of the order, as to make it a
    convenient instrument for the furtherance of personal ambition, at
    the expense of the sacred cause of Ireland, have continued to play
    havoc in our ranks. The strength and vitality of the national
    movement have been shattered.

    The oldest and strongest D's are
    being driven out one by one, and a system of repression of free
    speech and sham trials, copied from the worst features of British
    tyranny in Ireland, is brought into requisition for the purpose of
    crushing all independence of thought, and stifling the voice of
    patriotism. No honest man in the V. C., who sees and hears what is
    going on around him, can fail to recognize that ruin and
    disintegration must speedily make shipwreck of our hopes, if a
    strong and vigorous remedy be not soon applied.

    No intelligent man
    can fail to see that every effort of the three men who have usurped
    the governing authority of the V. C., every dollar intrusted to
    them for the advancement of the cause is being devoted to the
    maintenance of their power, and to the work of driving from the
    organization every man who charges them with wrong-doing, or who
    advocates an investigation of the charges made.

    That the aims and objects of the organization, and also its money,
    are being sacrificed to the necessities of the war of self-defense,
    waged by three desperate men, must be plain to every intelligent
    man, and it must be equally plain that an honest, impartial
    investigation of the serious charges, made against these men, would
    put a speedy end to all this trouble, by either convicting them of
    wrong-doing or their accusers of falsehood. In either case the
    organization would be freed from evil-doers and restored to
    harmony. Why, then, is such an investigation refused?

    The men who
    make the charges are ready to substantiate them and take the
    consequences. The accused men shirk an investigation, drive their
    accusers out of the organization, so that their evidence may not be
    available, and hold on with the grip of desperation to the
    positions they are accused of disgracing.

    Can any organization of intelligent, self-respecting men tolerate
    such a state of affairs? You who submit to the scandalous methods
    by which it is kept up are making yourselves responsible for
    irreparable injury to the cause you are sworn to serve.

    Let us recapitulate the work of the Boston "Convention," the
    charges made against the Triangle, the disruptive policy they have
    since pursued, and the remedy we propose. We charge that the three
    members of the last F. C., who now constitute the Triangle, are
    solely responsible for the evils of the present situation, and that
    deceit and trickery have characterized their action at every step.
    There is no statement of theirs, now promulgated, that is not made
    for the purpose of misleading the organization in regard to vital
    facts.

    These facts cover the postponement and change of form of the
    convention, the proceedings of that body, the relations with the I.
    R. B., the disbursement of the largest sum of money ever handled by
    any F. C., the authority and responsibility of the R. D., and the
    policy pursued. In short, they embrace every question of vital
    importance to the organization and to their characters as officers
    and members of the V. C.

    First--The Postponement of the Convention--It is claimed that these
    men had nothing to do with it--that it was entirely the work of the
    organization. Here are the facts:

    Those who were delegates to the Philadelphia National Convention
    will remember, that the subject was first mooted there at the
    request of the three members of the F. C. in question
    , in a caucus
    of members of the V. C. It was proposed by a member of D. II, and
    seconded by a member of D. I, and passed as a recommendation to the
    D's that they favor a change in the constitution, by which each
    district should elect delegates in proportion to membership to the
    National Convention. It was recommended in that form to the F. C.
    for promulgation to the D's.

    When promulgated it had undergone a
    remarkable change, by which each district was allowed two
    delegates, irrespective of membership. This would give a district,
    having then less than 100 members in good standing, the same
    representation as others having 1,500 members.

    The proposition of the F. C. was passed in some D's, with an
    amendment providing for representation according to membership, and
    a request that the amendment be submitted to all D's. The reply of
    the F. C. was that there was no time to do so, and yet about a year
    elapsed before the convention was held.

    Thus they secured a
    postponement of the convention under pretense of submitting a
    constitutional question to the D's, but so altered the question
    itself as to deprive large districts of representation in
    proportion to their membership, reducing the number of delegates to
    the convention, thereby making the work of manipulation easier.
    Thus, you see, the proposition originated with the F. C. was
    supported by them in caucus, and they voted and worked for its
    passage, and yet they tell you they had nothing to do with it,
    "that it was the work of the organization."

    This was the first part of the program by which they sought to
    deceive and hoodwink the organization, escape a proper accounting
    of their trusts, and secure a continuance in office. Let us now
    examine the second part of the program, or farce, played at Boston.

    The Convention--Notwithstanding the long delay and the evidence of
    elaborate preparation for the convention on the part of the F. C.,
    the notice to the delegates was only given at the last moment. Both
    the first circular after the convention, and the so-called "report"
    of its proceedings, issued by the Triangle in the name of the
    delegates from each district, contained deliberate misstatements of
    facts. There was no Committee on Credentials, and the word of the
    Secretary of the F. C. was the only voucher for the genuineness of
    the delegates.

    There were three persons present who were not
    delegates, and one of the three presided. The composition of the
    committees appointed by the chairman, after dining with the men who
    controlled the F. C., and disbursed its funds, left every
    consideration of decency and bona fide investigation out of
    account. To investigate the work of these men, a Committee on
    Foreign Relations, consisting of two of them, and a man who was
    entirely dependent on them for information, was appointed. The
    Financial Committee consisted of three district members, two of
    whom were the agents of the F.

    C., in the "active policy," and
    notoriously their partizans. These committees, sitting jointly, and
    having out of the six members only two who were not previously
    concerned in the work of governing and spending the funds, had the
    coolness to report that "The Finance Committee are fully satisfied
    with the economy and prudence with which the expenditures have been
    made, and the Foreign Relations Committee find complete exactitude
    in the financial acknowledgments of the R. D., etc." That is, two
    members of the American part of the R.

    D., who had been receiving
    and spending, in the name of that body, vast sums of money, of
    which the three home members knew nothing, aided by two
    accommodating district members who had been helping them to spend
    the money, find "complete exactitude" in their own accounts.

    And
    then, on the plea that "lives of faithful and devoted men are in
    the keeping of each of us who have served on either of these
    committees," they appeal to be allowed to keep the knowledge to
    themselves, and assure the organization that they "individually and
    collectively agree that it is a misfortune that so many of us
    should have this knowledge." They describe their anxiety to "see in
    the flesh the officer in charge of the new policy"--a staunch
    confederate of theirs whom they appointed and who merely carried
    out their orders--so that they might, forsooth, determine whether
    economy characterized his work and their own.

    But the crowning
    hypocrisy of all was their desire to ascertain if the receipts
    "acknowledged by the Home Branch of the R. D., corresponded with
    those reported by the F. C., as having been paid out." That is,
    they wanted to see if moneys received and spent by the American
    Branch of the R. D., without the knowledge or consent of the Home
    Branch, were properly accounted for by men who knew nothing about
    them, and whose representative was kept away from the convention
    lest the truth should become known. And the men guilty of this
    shameless deceit and hypocrisy are running the U. S. to-day.

    Third--The Relations with the I. R. B.--Without the presence of an
    envoy from the I. R. B. the convention was dependent on the word of
    men, who admitted the receipt and expenditure of $266,000, and who
    are positively known to have received a much larger sum, for the
    genuineness of the account. They place $128,000 to the credit of
    the R. D., and $75,000 to that of the S. C. of the I. R. B., and
    they make it impossible for an envoy from Ireland to confirm or
    contradict the statement, by withholding information from him as to
    the time and place of the convention.

    They aver that they sent the information both by cable and mail,
    and yet there are letters at our disposal, dating from June to
    October, from a member of the S. C., complaining that they could
    not get the information they sought, and the last one affirming
    that the old address was still good for either cable or mail. No
    letter passing between the two organizations ever miscarried before
    that time, and others have reached the same address since. The F. C.
    were made aware of the non-receipt of the information, and if it was
    intended to reach the S. C. it would have been received.

    The true
    explanation for all this is found in the admission in the "report"
    of the convention of a radical difference of opinion between the
    F. C. and S. C., and of a determination to dictate to the latter body.
    There is not a shadow of doubt that three members of the F. C. who
    represent the V. C. or the R. D. usurped the functions of the whole
    body, and spent the money voted to it by the F. C., without the
    knowledge of the home members. By keeping away the one envoy of the
    I. R. B., and auditing their own accounts, and speaking in general
    terms of the R.

    D. as if they spoke for the whole body, they hoped
    to conceal this fact and secure a continuance of the fraud. We now
    begin to see why it became necessary to impose silence, by oath on
    the delegates, for the first time in the history of the conventions
    of the V. C. The report of the convention issued by the Triangle,
    and the tone of circulars since issued, show a deliberate purpose to
    prepare the minds of the members of the V. C. for a break with our
    brothers at home. Are such men worthy of your confidence?

    Fourth--The R. D.--The R. D. is a fundamental law of the V. C.,
    protected and ratified by international treaty with the I. R. B. It
    cannot be altered or abolished without the consent of the I. R. B.,
    and the consent of the D's. It was adopted by the Philadelphia
    convention of the V. C., by a unanimous vote in 1876, with the
    proviso, that it should become a law only when approved by a
    two-thirds majority of the D's. It was submitted to the D's, and
    after being discussed at special meetings in every D, was approved
    by much more than the necessary majority. It was then submitted to
    the S.

    C., and having been agreed to by them the R. D. was elected,
    and by a solemn treaty invested with the supreme authority in all
    revolutionary matters.

    The R. D. could not be abolished without the consent of both the
    contracting parties, nor its functions assumed by a minority of
    that body, or their confederate "in flesh," without the consent of
    the S. C. or consulting the D's, who created it, and that most
    accommodating body called the Boston convention, has empowered the
    Triangle to elect an R. D. or not, as they see fit. That is, to
    elect the whole body and run a boat of their own, as did the
    Flannigans at the Flood, with the assistance of their confederate
    "in the flesh."

    The R. D. provided the means of adjusting all differences between
    the two organizations, of adopting a common policy, of auditing all
    expenditures, and made out of previously disjointed fragments, one
    united Irish revolutionary body throughout the world. Every
    intelligent man will now perceive that the assumption of power by
    the V. C. members of the R. D. and their "officer in the flesh," as
    well as the action taken at Boston, means broken faith with the I.
    R. B., means secession, disruption, divided counsels, is a direct
    blow at the integrity of the national movement.

    We cannot believe
    that you will continue to condone this offense on the part of the
    present Triangle, or indorse this breach of faith with the I. R. B.

    Fifth--The other work of the convention--The mode of electing the
    Triangle is inconsistent with honest intentions and gives the
    organization no protection against wrong doing. The oath of
    secrecy, as to the whole proceedings, is absolutely without
    justification or valid reason. Its evident intention was to cover
    up the farce enacted by the committees.

    No reasonable member of the V. C. wants information, involving
    danger to men, within the enemies reach. But every man should know,
    who audits accounts covering hundreds of thousands of dollars, and
    insist on having some guarantee that an honest inquiry is made into
    the most important work of the F. C., viz: their relations with
    the men at home.

    The change in the oath bodes evil to the cause.
    What intelligent man will bind himself to promote all measures
    adopted by the Triangle, "whether known or unknown?" Are we to
    follow these men blindly in every enterprise to which fancy or
    ambition leads them, including schemes of American politics?

    This, brothers, is the true situation of the Irish National
    movement in America to-day.

    The only possible remedy is in a general convention, which will
    pronounce final judgment, and calmly and impartially set aside all
    men who stand in the way of union. We have appealed to the
    triumvirate for such a convention, as have many of you, in vain.

    They will never call it, for the simple reason that they dare not.
    The only possible means of securing it, and thereby ending this
    trouble once for all, is by your shaking off the lethargy that has
    overtaken you and joining hands with us. Your appeals and protests
    to your leaders will be met by hollow pretenses and subterfuges,
    such as have met all such efforts for the last year.

    Waiting for the "regular" convention means submitting to another
    farce and allowing the work of disruption to go on with accelerated
    speed. Come, frankly and openly to our side, and the settlement of
    the trouble will be in your own hands. We are empowered to call a
    convention at any time, when we see the necessity for it, without
    waiting for the period fixed, and it shall be called as soon as you
    say the word. Then let the culprit suffer, whether it be accused or
    accuser, and the unfaithful, incompetent, and factious step to the
    rear.

    The cause of truth, justice and patriotism will triumph, the
    confidence now broken be restored, the gloom now hovering over the
    organization dispelled, and with brightening hopes we will march on
    to the accomplishment of our object--the restoration of national
    independence under a republican form of government to our native
    land.

    Fraternally yours,
    THE F. C. OF THE V. C.
    X. F. G. (W. E. F.), Chairman.
    Y. F. C. (X. E. B.), Sec.

    All communications should be addressed to John C. Phillips care of
    P. O. Box 2049, New York City.

    CHARGES AGAINST THE TRIANGLE.

    But these vigorous measures, instead of crushing the opposition, served only to give it new life and energy. An organization, antagonistic to the Triangle, composed of men bitterly hostile to Sullivan, Boland, Feeley and others high in power, was brought into existence, and rapidly grew until it was equal in strength to the original Clan-na-Gael. It had trusty spies and avowed adherents in the older organization, and the bitter quarrel was also brought into other Irish movements.

    Sullivan and his aids gradually dropped out of control, first seeing to it, however, that they were to be replaced by men to whom their word would be as law. Still Cronin and those with him kept up their warfare.

    Numerous efforts were made to silence him, and twice in 1887 he was called as an expert witness in trumped up cases before two Chicago police justices, in the hope that his persecutors, by putting him on the rack of cross examination, might find some flaw in his life that could be made use of in lessening his influence, or some disgraceful scrape which might be held over his head, to make him heed the behests of the man into whose possession the secrets had come.

    This effort failed of its object, and the physician returned to the charge with two new allegations.

    One was that the Triangle had allowed the family of Lomasney to suffer for the necessaries of life, while funds that had been appropriated by a local committee of the Clan-na-Gael, which labored under the belief that the missing brother was in an English dungeon, had been withheld, and another, that Sullivan had gone to Paris, while Patrick Egan was an exile in the French capital, and demanded the sum of $100,000 of Land League funds to carry out the aims of the physical force men in America.

    According to this charge, the money was demanded to meet certain expenditures that had been planned in a convention of representative members of the Clan. Mr. Egan, so it was claimed, after a good deal of consideration, refused to turn over the money, and then Sullivan threatened to disrupt every Irish society in America unless his demand was speedily complied with.

    He pointed to the fact that there was a large and growing element among Irish-Americans that was dissatisfied with the management of national affairs, and was ready to revolt as soon as a leader turned up to direct them. A whole week was consumed in discussing the demand of the American emissary, and in the end Mr. Egan was convinced that it would be wiser to take counsel with some of his confreres before rendering a final decision. He told Mr.

    Sullivan plainly that he was opposed to granting so large a sum of money for any purpose whatever, but he was willing to abide by the decision of other men who had as close a knowledge as himself of the needs of the order at home and abroad. He offered to submit Sullivan's proposition to Sheridan, the famous No. 1 of the Phoenix Park Invincibles, and the leader of the physical force men in Ireland. Mr.

    Sullivan agreed to this offer, and Sheridan was called to Paris from Ireland by telegraph. Within a week after all the facts had been laid before him, he decided that the money demanded by Sullivan had better be paid than withheld to conciliate all factions of the Clan-na-Gael in America. In result it was claimed that Egan paid Sullivan $100,000 in cash, from the funds of the Irish National League, of which he was treasurer, and that the then chief of the Triangle brought the full amount with him when he returned home.

    Instead, however, of turning it into the treasury of the Clan-na-Gael, it was contended that only $18,000 was accounted for, and the balance of $82,000 was deposited in the Traders' Bank, to the credit of "Alexander Sullivan, agent," the full amount being subsequently withdrawn on account of certain speculations by Sullivan on the Chicago Board of Trade. That such a deposit had been made was confirmed some time later, when the bank in question failed and its records, as the outcome of legal proceedings, became public property.

    SULLIVAN ON TRIAL.

    But the troubles of the warring factions could not last for ever. There were influential men on both sides who wanted harmony, and were determined to secure it. Finally, the two sides came together at a convention held in Chicago in 1888. Peace was restored, and the Camps and individuals that had been expelled by the Triangle were declared to be again in good standing. It was decided that the accounts and acts of the Clan-na-Gael society from 1881 should be investigated, and three men were chosen from each faction as a trial committee. They were as follows:

    Dr. P. H. Cronin, of Chicago.
    Dr. P. McCahey, of Philadelphia.
    John D. McMahon, of Rome, N. Y.
    P. A. O'Boyle, of Pittston, Pa.
    Christopher F. Byrne, of Saxonville, Mass.
    James J. Rogers, of Brooklyn, N. Y.

    The sessions of the committee commenced at Buffalo, in 1888, but the fact that there were a large number of witnesses from points adjacent to New York City, induced the body to make a change of base to that city, and the inquiry was resumed at the Westminster Hotel during the heat of the Harrison-Cleveland presidential campaign. It was soon found that the hotel was altogether too public a place for the inquiry and a hall was hired in another locality. Alexander Sullivan, who, with Boland and Feeley, was present in person, entered a formal protest against the participation of Dr. Cronin, couched in the most vituperative language.

    It read as follows:

    SULLIVAN'S CELEBRATED PROTEST.

    NEW YORK, SEPT. 15, 1888.
    P. O. BOYLE, Secretary.

    DEAR SIR:--At the opening of this investigation in Buffalo I
    protested against the presence of P. H. Cronin as a member of the
    committee to investigate any charges against me. The committee
    decided that it had no power to act in the matter, but, through its
    chairman, said that I could file my protest in writing. Therefore I
    formally and in writing renew said protest. My grounds are

    First, he is a personal enemy; second, he has expressed opinions in
    this case; third, he is a perjurer and scoundrel, unfit to be
    placed on any jury.

    To the first objection I cite the men of the United Brotherhood
    organization in Chicago, from which he was expelled in a case where
    I conducted the prosecution. There is no question in Chicago of his
    personal hostility. Before the National League convention in 1886,
    his was one of the signatures to a circular assailing me, and he
    was a regular attendant at meetings hostile to me. This is so
    notorious to me from all parts of the country that it is not
    necessary to enlarge upon it, but if substantiation is required it
    can be furnished to an overwhelming degree.

    In the support of the second objection it is only necessary to
    recite the now notorious fact that Cronin was a member of the
    executive body of the United Brotherhood, and as such he was one of
    those who circulated charges against my former associates and
    myself. He therefore not only expressed opinions, but in his
    official capacity caused those opinions to be published and
    circulated.

    Your committee is chosen from two bodies, whose members differ on
    many points, but who all agree, or profess to agree, in denouncing
    unfair trials, biased juries and prejudiced jurors in Ireland, and
    yet I am asked, after a period of four years has elapsed since I
    was a member or the organization, to come for trial before a
    committee chosen in my absence at a place where I was given no
    opportunity to be heard, although I was within a few hundred feet
    of the place.

    While you ask the world to believe that you want a fair trial on
    one side of the Atlantic, you ask me to accept as a juror one who
    would be excluded in any civil court from a jury in a trial of a
    case in which I had an interest however trivial.

    I am told that it has been declared that if I do not appear before
    this committee I shall be denounced as one unable to defend himself
    against the accusations filed. So I was left with the alternative
    of being tried before a jury, with at least one perjured member, or
    being abused and villified for my non-appearance. And this is what
    the men who selected Cronin were led to believe was fairness. They
    should never again be so indecently inconsistent as to criticise
    the position of juries or courts chosen to try men in England and
    Ireland.

    Had he as much decency as an ordinary dog he would not sit
    in a case in which I was interested.

    As to the third objection to Cronin, I charge that the brand of
    perjury is so burned into the scoundrel's brow that all the waters
    of the earth would not remove the brand. He was a delegate at the
    district convention held in Chicago, March 23, 1884, that being the
    first one held in this district. After the constitution was so
    amended as to provide for the elevation of two delegates from each
    district, two delegates were elected at the very same session, one
    being chosen immediately after the other.

    Yet Cronin, after first
    officially reporting to his club that two delegates were elected,
    circulated a report that only one was elected, and stated that he
    would not be permitted to speak or to present any suggestions from
    his camp. Every such delegate at the convention has been sworn, and
    every one, including those who were with Cronin in the U. B.
    organization, testified that two delegates were chosen, that Cronin
    was present when they were chosen, that every delegate not only
    could speak, but was actually called upon to speak, and that every
    delegate, including Cronin, did speak.

    Cronin was expelled, a convicted liar, who added perjury to his
    slander. I have further investigated his record, and I find that in
    several matters outside of this organization he is also a perjurer.
    A record obtained from Ireland by William J. Fitzgerald says that
    Cronin was born at Buttevante, April 13, 1844. Cronin swears that
    he lived at St. Catherines, Canada, until after the assassination
    of President Lincoln, April 14, 1865. Captain McDonald, of No. 2
    Company, Nineteenth Battalion of the Canadian militia, of which P.
    H. Cronin was a member, says that at its formation in 1862 or 1863
    he had P. H.

    Cronin in his company, or shortly after its formation.
    He was known as the "Singer Cronin," and at the time of joining he
    took the oath of allegiance as follows: "I swear that I will bear
    true and faithful allegiance to her majesty, the queen, her heirs
    and successors."

    About 1863 positive orders were sent by the government that every
    man had to take the oath of allegiance, and that there were none
    under his command who did not take it. The record shows that Dr.
    Cronin's father, J. G. Cronin, was a British subject and continued
    in Canada up to the time of his death, so that P. H. Cronin until
    1865 or 1866, when he left Canada, was a British subject, and if,
    as he claims, his father was naturalized in the United States
    before going to Canada, he voluntarily abandoned his American
    citizenship and resumed the position of a British subject.

    This P. H. Cronin voluntarily swore allegiance to her British
    majesty. Yet this creature swore in his name as a voter in St.
    Louis and voted in that city. He thought best not to come to
    Chicago and reside one year, but sneaked down to a county in
    Illinois, doubtless being afraid of attracting attention in
    Chicago, and swore that he arrived in the United States a minor,
    under the age of twenty-one years; that he resided in the United
    States three years preceding his arrival at the age of twenty-one
    years.

    He claimed to have been home in 1856, and not in 1844, and
    even if that were true, he was only nineteen years old when he left
    Canada, because he swore he was in Canada when President Lincoln
    was assassinated; that he came to the United States in 1865 or
    1866, and yet he swore he resided in the United States three years
    previous to arriving at the age of nineteen, and thus secured his
    papers on this minor petition falsely sworn to.

    This side of Cronin's character, I submit, should be considered in
    connection with any report his malice and prejudice may dictate. I
    have not made any formal protest against the presence of Dr.
    McCahey on the trial committee, but it is well known that he has
    been active in publishing documents and interviews hostile to me,
    and it is at least strange that one who has been so engaged should
    be willing to serve on such a committee.

    Very respectfully,

    ALEXANDER SULLIVAN.

    The protest was overruled. The charges, five in number, filed by John Devoy, of New York, and Luke Dillon, of Philadelphia, set forth that no active work had been performed by the "Triangle" or its agents; that there was nothing to substantiate its claim that it had expended over $87,000 in active work; that it had basely neglected the families of men sent on errands of the Brotherhood; that bogus transfers had been issued to members of the organization as coming from Ireland, and that a district convention had illegally instituted.

    The trial was a heated one. Each side went to the hall every night backed by desperate followers. Letters threatening them death if a verdict of guilty was rendered were received by Cronin and McCahey. Suspecting treachery; the former took the precaution of making full notes of the testimony for his private information. When the evidence was all in a vote was taken on a motion to acquit. It stood three to three. Next a vote was taken to find Sullivan, Boland and Feeley guilty.

    This time it stood four to two, one of Cronin's colleagues deserting to the other side, and leaving the Chicago and Philadelphia physicians alone in their opposition to the Triangle. The question then arose as to the disposition of the evidence and a resolution was adopted that every record of the trial should be destroyed. Dr. Cronin demanded that the evidence should be published with the report, and sent to every Camp, but again the majority was against him.

    Thereupon he refused to surrender his private notes, and after returning to Chicago and consulting his friends, he determined that every man in the Clan-na-Gael should hear the story, and that a statement on the subject should be made at the meeting of the Irish National League of America, which had been called to assemble in Philadelphia in 1889. From this time on to his death, the matter was uppermost in his mind. A minority report, signed by the physician and Dr.

    McCahey, was filed with the executive, and a demand was made that it should be made public in the order. This was not done, however, simply because the majority of the Executive was attached to the "Triangle element," and, this avenue closed against him, Dr. Cronin contented himself with reading the report in his own Camp. It was this act, according to the subsequent theory of the prosecution, that, more than any thing else, cost him his life.

    Meanwhile he was industriously engaged upon the preparation of his papers for the prospective conventions of the Clan-na-Gael and Irish National League, his report of the New York trial proving invaluable to him in this connection; while he continued at the same time to periodically insist upon the publication of the minority report of the trial.

    On the very day upon which he was decoyed from home, the Executive Board was called together; and on the following day, (Sunday) an order was issued that Alexander Sullivan's protest, which branded the physician as a perjurer and a traitor, should be sent to every Camp.

    It was hardly to be expected that the adherents and allies of the ex-head-centre of the Triangle would contemplate the vigorous assaults of Dr. Cronin upon the reputation and official conduct of their erstwhile leader with equanimity. The temporary calm that had settled over the organization with the close of the Chicago convention and its treaty of peace, vanished like a fog before the noon-day sun; and strife and bitterness once more reigned supreme. Every camp had its faction that championed the one side or the other.

    Under the banner of the physician, as well as under the colors of his adversary, were ranged scores and hundreds of men who had left their imprint upon the Irish-American history of the decade. The physician had his Rends, Dillons, Devoys, Hynes, Scanlans, McCaheys; the lawyer his Egans and Fitzgeralds, O'Briens and Bolands. Effort after effort was made to induce Dr. Cronin to abandon his policy. Arguments, pleading, cajolery, threats--all were employed in vain.

    To one and all he had but one reply: "That he had put his hand to the plow, and that, God helping him, he would never turn back." For months before his disappearance, he believed that he was a marked man, and that, at the first opportunity, he would pay forfeit with his life for what he regarded as his unselfish devotion to the cause of his native land.

    Little wonder then, that those of his intimate friends who were familiar with these facts declared, as with one voice, that he had met his death at the hands of his enemies.

    Dr. Cronin's report of the trial, and which for weeks prior to the night of his disappearance, he had carried with him for safe keeping, were found in one of his garments in his residence after his failure to return home. The record in full is as follows:

    TELEGRAM.

    MARCH 13, 1889.--Dr. P. H. Cronin, No. 468 N. Clark Street: Meet
    me at Westminster Hotel, New York, Tuesday evening, 15th, 8
    o'clock. Peremptorily required on account report of committee to
    read. J. D. MCMAHON.

    Telegram dated Jan. 19 or 18, 1889, New York:

    Dr. P. H. Cronin, Opera House, Chicago, Ill.: Ordered by the
    proper board that you send to me without delay your report on the
    trial. RONAINE.

    Dr. Cronin's reply as follows:

    CHICAGO, Jan. 17, 1889.

    T. H. Ronaine, Esq., New York.--

    DEAR SIR AND BROTHER: I am in receipt of telegram, and in reply
    would say that I vote as I did at last meeting of committee in New
    York; with the recommendation that vote be published and read to
    the clubs. McCahey has correct record of my vote. Or, if not,
    please inform me. Fraternally,

    P. H. CRONIN.

    PHILADELPHIA, PA., Jan. 15, 1889.

    To the F. C. of the U. S.--

    DEAR SIRS AND BROTHERS: The Trial Committee appointed at Chicago
    was unable to elicit all the facts connected with the charges
    placed before it, because of the refusal of several of the
    witnesses to answer many of the questions asked, and because of the
    inability of others to remember events and figures that might be
    supposed to be indelibly impressed on their memories. From the
    evidence presented I am obliged to report:

    1. That the family of one who lost his life in the service of the

    order was scandalously and shamefully neglected, and continued to
    be neglected for two years after their destitute condition was
    known, and that Alexander Sullivan, Michael Boland, and D. C.
    Feeley are responsible and censurable for that neglect.

    1. That Gen. C. H. McCarthy, of St. Paul, Minn., was unjustly and

    deliberately excluded from the Boston convention, and subsequently
    shamefully persecuted and driven from the order, and that Alexander
    Sullivan, Michael Boland, and D. C. Feeley are responsible and
    censurable for that series of reprehensible acts.

    1. That delegate from home organization was excluded from the

    Boston convention, and that the same three defendants are
    responsible and censurable for that exclusion.

    1. That the same defendants issued a deceptive report to the Boston

    convention, leading the order to believe that its affairs had been
    examined by independent committees, and that the order was $13,000
    in debt; that, in fact, Alexander Sullivan and Michael Boland were
    on the committee of foreign affairs, and the Treasurer states that
    there was a balance in the treasury and not a debt.

    1. That prior to the Boston convention one hundred and eleven

    thousand ($111,000) dollars was expended without any direct or
    indirect benefit to the order, and most of it in a manner that
    could not in any way have benefited the order, and that the same
    three defendants are censurable and responsible for this enormous
    and wasteful expenditure.

    1. That this enormous sum was spent without the sanction or

    knowledge of the home portion of the R. D.

    1. That various persons sent abroad were not supplied with

    sufficient funds, and that the agent of the Triangle is responsible
    and censurable for that criminal neglect, and not the three
    defendants.

    1. That Michael Boland and the late Secretary of the I. N. B.

    issued fraudulent transfers, for the purpose of deceiving the order
    in Philadelphia into believing that the union with the home order
    had not been broken.

    1. That Michael Boland and D. C. Feeley, the former by acts and the

    latter by assent, are guilty of attempting to pack the Pittsburg
    convention by, first, excluding the delegate from the Pacific
    Slope; second, excluding Mr. McLaughlin, delegate from Dakota;
    third, excluding O'Sullivan and Delaney, rightful delegates from
    New York; fourth, admitting the Rev. Dr. Betts and John J. Maroney,
    on bogus credentials from the bogus districts; fifth, admitting
    Boland and Malone, illegal delegates from New York; sixth,
    admitting proxies from Iowa, Brooklyn, and Illinois; seventh,
    sitting as delegates themselves in direct violation of the
    constitution.

    1. That the $80,491, reported to the district convention as having

    been spent in active work was not spent for any such work, no such
    work having been done or contemplated during the eleven months
    within which this large amount was drawn from the treasury. The
    active work done between the Boston and other district conventions,
    was paid for out of the surplus held by the agent of the Triangle
    at the time of the Boston convention, and not out of the $87,491
    drawn from the treasury months after such active work had ceased.

    1. That Michael Boland and D. C. Feeley, the former by acts and

    the latter by silence, are responsible for the expenditure of this
    large amount of money, and censurable for deceiving the district
    convention as to the purpose for which it was spent.

    1. That Michael Boland, Alexander Sullivan, and D. C. Feeley, the

    former by acts and the two latter by assent, illegally suspended
    D's in January, 1885, and that Michael Boland and D. C. Feeley, the
    former by acts and the latter by assent, illegally suspended U.
    D.'s in New York, in January, 1886.

    Yours, respectfully, P. MCCAHEY.

    I concur in the within and foregoing report, and would recommend,
    in strict fairness to all concerned, and in justice to the entire
    organization, that the evidence, from which were deducted the
    foregoing, be printed by F. C. and sent to each D. O. and by him
    read at the general meeting or district over which he presides.

    P. H. CRONIN.

    Signed Jan. 19, 1889.

    NOTES OF TESTIMONY.

    First meeting, Westminster Hotel, New York, July 30.

    J. D. McMahon, of Rome, N. Y., in the chair.

    Committee met, and after some discussion as to choice of chairman
    and secretary the matter was arranged by electing anew J. D.
    McMahon as chairman, and P. A. O'Boyle as secretary. Members
    present: McMahon, O'Boyle, McCahey, Rogers, Burns and Cronin.

    Letters and telegrams were read showing that none of the defendants
    were ready, owing to brief notice. Accusers on hand.

    On motion, committee adjourned to meet at Buffalo, N. Y., Aug. 20,
    1888.

    Genesee House, Buffalo, N. Y., Aug. 20, 1888. Committee called to
    order. J. D. McMahon, President; P. A. O'Boyle, Secretary.

    Present: J. D. McMahon, P. A. O'Boyle, P. McCahey, J. J. Rogers, P.
    H. Cronin, C. F. Burns, Sullivan, Feeley, Boland, Ryan, Devoy,
    Trude, O'Neill, McCahey.

    On announcement by the Chair that the committee was ready for
    business, Mr. Sullivan stated that he had an objection to offer to
    the constitution of the committee. The chairman asked if it was to
    the committee as a whole, or to any particular person.

    Sullivan answered that it was to the personnel of the committee;
    that one of the committee was a malignant enemy of his
    (Sullivan's); that the same party was forever pursuing him with a
    design to injure him; that as an expelled member of the order, that
    party referred to ought not to sit in any committee. Continuing,
    Mr. Sullivan said that the party referred to was Dr.

    Cronin, who
    recently had made statements through a newspaper in regard to him
    that he knew to be false; that the newspaper editor (giving name of
    paper and editor) had sent him (Sullivan) a letter of explanation,
    and that for this and many other reasons he objected to being tried
    by the committee as constituted.

    Messrs. Feeley and Boland followed, both strongly objecting to Dr.
    Cronin. Boland said that though personally he had some objections
    to Dr. McCahey he would waive those objections and join with
    Messrs. Sullivan and Feeley in asking that Dr. Cronin retire from
    the committee, they being willing to accept any one in the room in
    preference.

    Dr. Cronin replied to this; said he thought it strange that Mr.
    Sullivan should speak of him as a malignant enemy. He (Cronin) had
    never characterized Sullivan personally as an enemy; anything said
    by him (Cronin) was directed toward the men whom he was given to
    understand had wrecked the organization. Sullivan was one of them,
    he understood, and only in connection with certain developments
    pertaining to the order did he say anything of Sullivan. If Mr.
    Sullivan believed everything told him by gossips he (the doctor)
    could not help it. "Indeed," the doctor continued, "why should I be
    the enemy of Mr.

    Sullivan? What has he done to me that I should, as
    he says, single him out for personal enmity?" As to the newspaper
    editor matter, the doctor said, that while not believing in
    introducing what savored of American politics, he could explain the
    newspaper affair by referring to the paper itself. Mr. Sullivan
    would certainly not make an affidavit to the statement that the
    paper had done what he said, for he (Dr. Cronin) had evidence that
    would readily disprove it.

    To this Mr. Sullivan replied that he did not want to make
    affidavits, but would say that the creature (referring to the
    doctor) should not sit as one of his judges; that he (Sullivan)
    could prove by a dozen men, who would not believe the doctor under
    oath, that he (the doctor) was an expelled member of the
    organization. [Then the paper mentions the names of three men.]

    Mr. Cronin said, interrupting Mr. Sullivan, that the gentleman
    evidently meant to irritate him or intimidate the committee.

    Mr. Sullivan said that he did not wish to intimidate the committee.

    Dr. Cronin then said: "Then you probably mean to intimidate me.
    That you cannot do, sir, and you ought to know it by this time. All
    the objections you urge were made at the convention, and by an
    almost unanimous vote, as the selection of that convention, I am
    the peer of any one here and doing my duty by the body that created
    me. I would not, if I could."

    Mr. Sullivan took his seat, overruled by that body.

    The Chairman asked all but the committee to retire, and, upon a
    vote being taken, the objections of the defendants to Dr. Cronin
    were overruled by the votes of the Chairman, Messrs. Burns, Rogers,
    McCahey, and Cronin, the Secretary not voting. This was announced
    to those making the objections, and the trial proceeded.

    Before the trial proceeded, Col. Boland said he had a witness whose
    expenses he wished to have guaranteed; that the witness resided at
    Leadville. On motion it was ordered that the expenses of witness be
    guaranteed.

    Col. Boland called attention to the fact that many persons present
    who were witnesses, etc., should not know what was going on. The
    Colonel said that matters of grave importance might come before the
    committee, and as it was common report that one witness had given
    information to the British Government, that John Devoy had given
    information to the British Government, he requested that none but
    the attorneys for prosecution and the defendants remain before the
    committee, each witness to be examined separately.

    Dr. Cronin objected to this, saying, that as Devoy had been singled
    out for animadversion by Col. Boland, it was not fair for the
    committee to extend support to Boland's unjust attack.

    On motion all but the committee retired. The committee then decided
    that each prosecutor should remain with the attorney and that
    witnesses be introduced separately; the defendants remaining also;
    the committee admitting all those entitled to be present, the
    charges were presented and specifications as follows:

    1. That no active work had been performed by F. C. that had been

    claimed by that body and its agents.

    1. The men on errands of the brotherhood had been basely neglected

    and their families left without support.

    1. That bogus transfers to members of the organization had been

    issued as coming from Ireland.

    1. That the district convention was falsely instituted, etc.
    1. That F. C. members sat as delegates in that convention in direct

    violation of the constitution.

    The proof of charges had shown:

    1. That they had claimed that $87,467 had been expended in active

    work. No vouchers were presented, no contracts, and no money, no
    account explained about.

    1. Proof that such explanation was never made.
    1. But little money given Mrs. McCahey; small sums given to men

    abroad; bogus transfers fabricated by X Y and others.

    1. Convention illegally constituted at Pittsburg; proxies present,

    Boland and Feeley sitting there. Boland offered position as R. D.
    and money sent him that he might make statement that active work
    was engaged in.

    A witness testifies: Witness called to stand, after being duly
    obligated, testified as follows:

    Some time previous to the Boston convention I was called on by
    certain members of the order in reference to an offer of services
    made by me some time previously. After conference in relation to
    details I agreed to go to the other side. I went by steerage on
    ticket procured for me and received _£20. After an absence of
    seven weeks I returned by steerage passage out of the amount
    received. Upon my arrival in America I met Donovan, who acted as
    agent for the body, and who paid me $50. Donovan was then in the
    employ of Gen. Kerwin. I complained of the small amount given me,
    but did not ask for more.

    Not enough was given me for the work
    expected to be done. Later in the same year I was again called on
    by Donovan, who asked me if in addition to myself I could furnish
    enough men to accomplish a certain amount of active work. He asked
    me would I go again I said yes. Looked up the men. It was almost
    impossible to find any. Got two men on steamer and one to accompany
    me to do work abroad. Everything being ready, I met Donovan at
    Green's Hotel, Philadelphia, in company with John J. Maroney.
    Donovan told me that Maroney would buy tickets for me by steerage.
    They cost $18 apiece and $100 was given me to carry on work.

    I told
    Donovan that on former occasions I had to go on vessel three days
    after work was done; that the sum now offered me was too little for
    the work looked for. I insisted on getting money enough for the
    purpose of safety, else I would not go. Donovan told me that
    sufficient funds would be furnished on the other side. He stated
    his reason for not giving me more before leaving was that men
    engaged in similar work had been arrested on landing on the other
    side; that my carrying a large sum might excite suspicion.

    That was
    satisfactory to me, especially as I was given the name of the agent
    on the other side who was to furnish funds as needed. I left the
    room and sent in ---- (another man), the one that was to accompany
    me. Maroney left the room with me. This other man told me he
    received the same amount that I did. Maroney then told me he was
    glad I refused to accept the sum offered me as total compensation
    for the work. He also said he did not believe it was the wish of
    the F. C. to do as the S. had said. He promised to see the F.

    C.
    and demand money from them, and should they not give it he would
    send me help on the next steamer by a trusty man. On the way over I
    had to pay over
    £2 for certain accommodations on steamer. After
    being on the other side nine days, taking care not to excite
    suspicion, I had but
    £10 left. I then went to Capital City, and
    met the man who I was told was the agent and would give me money,
    and I told him I wanted some help, as I was short of funds. I asked
    him for
    £_10.

    He denied having any money for any such purpose; he
    had no more than he required for actual expenses, and hardly that.
    He said all he had received upon leaving was $200.

    Objected to by Boland, who asked to know how witness knew the man
    was agent.

    Witness--I was told by Donovan in the presence of Maroney that upon
    my arrival on the other side I would get funds from the man
    mentioned. The man then went on to say, that owing to the
    circumstances he might be obliged to stay for a year. He had worked
    at his business for some time, but was doing nothing now. I then
    said I would return at once to America. He said he would at once
    ask something for me from Ex. I replied that if he did not get
    funds I would go back. Before leaving I asked him where would it be
    necessary to do the work.

    He said he did not know; things were
    looking queer; that he was sure he had been betrayed by some one.

    Question by Mr. Ryan--What became of this man?

    Witness--He is now in prison. His reason for thinking he was
    betrayed was that two men had called at his lodging asking for him
    under his assumed name. I told him to change his lodging. But soon
    after I was told he had been followed up by the same individuals,
    whom he had suspected were detectives. This alarmed him much. At
    his request work was delayed six weeks. I at last told him I would
    do the work. There were four of us. At various times I asked him if
    he had received any money from Ex. He said no. He seemed so careful
    that my men deemed it cowardice.

    I called his attention to this
    before the men, saying we looked for courage at this time. He
    repeated before us that he believed he had been betrayed, for,
    though he had changed his lodgings several times, the party he
    suspected as being a detective had called upon him at each place.

    Exception by defendant. To which was said:

    I finally induced him to give orders to do the work. This was
    Thursday. Saturday we did it. After the work was done I met him
    that same evening. He remained in Capital City seven days
    afterward. I was so reduced for funds that I prevailed upon him to
    give me _£4 of the £16 he had left. On landing in this country
    had
    £_3-1/2. Had no bed nor bedding on the ship; slept on the top
    side of a plank.

    This in answer to a question by Dr Cronin:

    I at once complained to Donovan and Maroney, and through them to
    the executive, or Gen. Kerwin, of the treatment I had received and
    the culpable neglect of the F C. About the last of February, 1885,
    Donovan furnished me $10 with which to reach home. The man in
    charge for the order made me take an oath before leaving to bring
    the matter before the order.

    I always supposed Kerwin was a member of the executive. Before
    leaving America I told Maroney I would take an alias known to me;
    my alias was the proper name of a man. The imprisoned one bore the
    alias given to me. This was the agent. He was four miles from the
    place we worked at. Only three of us did the work.

    Question by Mr. Ryan--How much money in all did you receive?

    A.--Four persons in all. $500; of this the agent got $200. We were
    two months in the country.

    Then the witness makes a statement that the other man who went with
    him, whose name I did not read the last time--this man came back
    six months after. At an expense for material, I should think, of
    $7,400 in all to cover the enterprise.

    Q.--How many operations did you perform? A.--Three. We always bade
    each other good by after each meeting, thinking it might be our
    last meeting on earth. I have learned that in order to get back,
    the other man who went over with me had to sell his clothes to get
    passage money. He came with a sprained ankle. In July or August,
    1885, he received $7 from Maroney. I took up Rossa's paper one day
    and in it I saw an announcement of a subscription to keep the
    mother of Cunningham. I went to Maroney, and after telling him it
    was shameful that she should be allowed to suffer so he said he
    would see to the matter.

    Spoke of Gen. Kerwin as being asked to
    send some help; said he would not. I said if they didn't I would.
    Kerwin then came to my home and said I ought to be expelled; I told
    him he ought to send help to the woman; he said he ought not as the
    man himself had abundant means; I finally induced Mr. Ryan to get
    F. C. to send something. One hundred dollars was sent through D.
    18, who sent it through F. C., and I was informed of S. G. of 18. A
    few months after I met a lady of Detroit who told me that Capt.
    Mackey's wife was in want; he was killed in London and was assured,
    I am told, that his family would never want.

    Lomasney, and his
    brother, accompanied by Fleming, went over in 1884. I wrote to
    Cochrane, and both assured me that Mrs. Mackey was in want. At once
    $1,025 was raised and sent to Detroit, where matters were found to
    be even worse than they had been represented.

    In the case of Dr. Gallagher, his people were in want. Mr. Delaney
    had recovered the money on the doctor's person, but that was only a
    small sum, and most of it was being used in his defense.

    On consultation, met D. in New York. One hundred dollars was raised
    and sent to Mrs. Gallagher. I requested that the men on trial on
    the other side should be defended. Gen. Kerwin said that friendless
    men were better off in such cases. I raised _£_50 to send to Jack
    Delaney's sister.

    Witness produced five forms of transfer, purporting to be in
    accordance with the rules of the combined order, but which were
    shown to be bogus. Witness said: I wrote in the early part of June,
    1886, for transfers for certain persons in Philadelphia, who had
    been clamoring for admission into D. I said it would do a great
    deal of good to be able to show that we were in opinion with the
    folks at home. Within four days I received six, of which those five
    are a part. McMahon, Burns, Henry, Gallagher, Henry, the witness
    testifying. Leonard stated to me--

    Objected to by the defendants.

    Some time before the Pittsburg convention, witness was called upon
    by P. O. Sullivan and J. J. Delaney, who had learned that he was a
    delegate to the convention. They said they represented eleven D's,
    and that in order to seat Boland and Miller, Sullivan and Delaney
    had been thrown out by the suspension of D.

    Mr. Boland objects to this.

    Mr. Ryan and I protested at the convention and asked that Delaney
    and Sullivan be seated. We stated that a good member of the
    executive should sit as a delegate in the convention; for the same
    objection, we objected to Mr. Feeley and Mr. Gleason. Each of these
    men voted to seat the other. We objected to the proxies from
    Chicago, Messrs. Tim Crane and Florence Sullivan, the latter proxy
    for Father Dorney. The other said he represented Alexander
    Sullivan.

    It having been stated that district S. represented or had been
    represented by virtue of a cablegram sent to Gleason and Sullivan,
    Boland requests them to act for Australia, and that John J. Maroney
    and Dr. Betts were admitted as proxies. We asked the secretary if
    any money had been sent by this district in any communication had
    before the receipt of this cablegram. Secretary said he hadn't had
    any communication with S. at all. The communication was with
    Alexander Sullivan and Michael Boland.

    We then asked how the Australian cablegram came here, by which
    route. The secretary didn't seem to know. Mr. Ryan then informed
    the convention that all cablegrams reaching here from Australia
    were recorded in the London post office. For this reason he thought
    it highly improbable that any such message came to the gentleman
    mentioned.

    Here Mr. Sullivan denied having been appointed delegate to the
    convention, or that his brother Florence represented him there.

    The Witness--I was R. D. at that time in place of Gen. Kerwin.
    Before my election as delegate I never acted as R. D. There was no
    connection with the home body. I received $500 from Mr. Ryan, which
    it was said I was to use as my judgment dictated. I asked Boland if
    I should do any active work outside and kept a lookout for it. I
    spent money afterwards in trying to right the order.

    CROSS-EXAMINED BY ALEXANDER SULLIVAN.

    Q--When and to whom did you complain on your return to this
    country? A--To Donovan.

    Q--You made no complaint to the executive directly. A--No.

    By Mr. Boland--How did you get the money, the $500. A--In cash.
    This was three months before the convention.

    Q--Did I ask you to get the amount right as representing R. D.?
    A.--I told you I had them on the ship.

    Q.--Has any difficulty since that made you say why you were on R.
    D.? A.--No.

    Q.--Were you a delegate at the time you got the money? A.--No.

    Q.--Were you appointed on foreign relations or finance committee?
    A.--No.

    Q.--Pending the discussion of the report you left the convention?
    A.--I left, claiming it was not a convention of the order.

    Q.--You don't know who I appointed? A.--No; I was not in on
    permanent organization.

    Q.--You don't know of operations outside of your own? A.--No.

    To Mr. Rogers--I voted at the convention under a vote taken on
    various motions.

    By Mr. Ryan--Do you know of any work having been done between Jan.
    20, 1885, and the district convention. A.--No.

    Q.--How much did it cost for Mackey's work? Objected to by Feeley.

    Q.--When did you get that $500. A.--The check sent by Boland and
    Ryan will show I got the money from Ryan, but he received it by
    check.

    Constitution of the order offered in evidence.

    Examination of another witness. Obligated, name, etc.

    My knowledge when I was elected D. M. to fill vacancy, caused by
    resignation of John J. Marony. In July, 1885, his resignation was
    demanded by the district. In October I went out as an organizer for
    the National League through the west. Nov. 23, I spoke at
    Philadelphia. Several seniors mentioned that Dillon was in
    straightened circumstances. I promised to see the executive. I saw
    Gen. Kerwin, D. M., of New York. He said when I mentioned the
    matter to him, that he had no power; that this was not an order to
    grant pensions. He would see Boland.

    I met Boland by arrangement.
    He listened to what I had to say, and at first refused to assist
    Dillon. Finally he said he would consider the matter. Then he
    authorized me to pay $200 of obligations maturing. I advanced this
    myself, and got it back in December, 1885, and I saw Gen. Kerwin,
    and told him he should send money to Mrs. Cunningham; that the lady
    was hurt on the subject of her being neglected by us. He said he
    would send it. In December, 1885, it was rumored that our
    convention would be held in January, 1886. I was told by Kerwin and
    Boland that Egan wanted to retire from the Presidency of the
    league.

    I was asked by them to accept the Secretaryship of the
    league. This I refused. It was said considerable trouble might be
    looked for in any case; about the last of December I was sent for
    to go to New York. I saw Boland and Kerwin together at this time,
    as well as in January and February. Had interviews with Kerwin and
    Boland on the subject of the convention and like matters. Mr.
    Boland asked me why I would not take the Secretaryship. He said the
    plan for holding a convention of the order had been abandoned, as
    the L. R. then did not take place. Men would get out and I would
    not be selected as President of the league.

    Some time after this I received the following letter from Kerwin:

    "My Dear Sir: (Giving the name.) The Chicago people have asked
    for you for the 4th of March. If you will take my advice you will
    take no office in the league."

    I was led to believe about this time that the organization intended
    opposing Parnell, owing to his recognition of others. Boland and
    Kerwin both said this.

    (Interrupted by Boland.) Is that your recollection of what took
    place? A.--Yes.

    Various letters were shown. (Exhibit B.)

    These exhibits were not found among the physician's papers.

    Q.--By Mr. Rogers--What did you give the money to Dillon for?
    A.--The money had been given me as a general resource. I did not
    want to go into active work, and suggested Dillon. I gave him the
    money. Boland authorized this by a letter to me. [Letter read.]
    Dillon had convinced me that the F. C. hadn't done fair; in fact, I
    felt that Boland was trying to play me, and I wished to return the
    compliment.

    Q.--Did you want to accept the Presidency of the league? A.--The
    slate was Baldwin, Minton and Carroll for F. C., and myself as
    President of the league. I knew that my age was a bar to my
    acceptance. Then I was going to attack the ones in authority. I
    attended the convention. Carroll was temporary Chairman; Reynolds
    was elected permanent Chairman.

    Convention went into Committee of the Whole. It was reported that
    Father Dorney could not come because he had trouble with the
    Bishop, and that Alexander Sullivan was absent because British
    detectives were shadowing him. I held that no member of the
    executive could sit as a delegate; quoted the constitution; no
    exception to my doing so; the fact was as stated by me. The last
    district called was Q. For R. we were directed to apply to the
    Secretary. District S. was named. I objected to this as no mention
    had been made of it in our report.

    I asked "Where is it?" I was
    answered, "Australia." Its representatives here are Maroney and
    Betts. They said they represented Boland and Sullivan. I asked if
    there was any organization in Australia? I was answered there is
    one in contemplation. The Secretary said Betts and Maroney were
    there by order of the executive and by order of a cablegram sent to
    Sullivan and Boland.

    Sullivan is said to be not a member of the order and Boland
    represents New York. They had earlier said that Sullivan was
    shadowed by detectives.

    I then showed how the cablegram had come from England. Letters had
    been left with the President by Boland. Districts H. and B.
    declared they would leave the convention. We refused to take any
    part. Did not return. Motion to expel seceding members carried by a
    vote of 20 to 5.

    Q.--By Mr. Boland--The conversations were in the presence of
    Kerwin, were they not? A.--Yes, many of them.

    Q.--Did the matter come up in relation to your treatment at
    Chicago? Some of it took place before you were elected? A.--Yes. At
    district meeting of S. J. Kerwin was present as the representative
    of F. C. The district requested me to accept. Had no conversation
    with you until months after.

    Q.--By Mr. Feeley--Did you present any objection at district
    convention as to your statement as to district? A.--No. Because I
    knew nothing of any other district.

    Q.--Did you present any evidence, other than your statement, in
    relation to any of the acts mentioned? A.--No. Because I was not
    aware of any man elected.

    Q.--Do you recollect that a vote was taken in regard to District
    A.? A.--Yes; if you have any doubt I can refer you to mem.

    Q.--Do you recollect my opposing the representation of Australia by
    any person in that body? A.--No; you spoke to me, however, and said
    to me that I should not oppose it; that you were as anxious as I,
    for you had been ignored or not consulted for eighteen months. You
    voted to seat Australia.

    Q.--You charged that the executive used the funds of the
    organization to pay Maroney's debts, did you? A.--No. In August,
    1884, Maroney was a porter in a store on Market street. Soon after
    he was D. M. of three counties surrounding Philadelphia. He went
    into the gents' furnishing goods at No. 2400 Kensington avenue. He
    got $400 from the executive; check on the Continental Bank,
    exchanged to his credit. Afterwards he went into debt $600 to
    McDermott (Black Jim). This amount the executive paid to McDermott.
    I saw the $600 paid him. I made the fact known to the convention.
    [Mr. O'Boyle interrupts.]

    Q.--What was the relation between Maroney and the executive? A.--I
    don't know.

    Mr. Rogers--What did Maroney say when you gave him the money?
    [There is no answer to that question.]

    Mr. O'Boyle--Upon whom was the check drawn? A.--All checks were
    signed by Kerwin for the executive.

    Mr. Rogers--Had this not been a prior date? A. No.

    Mr. Feeley--Was your charge denied by Maroney? A.--No, he said the
    money was furnished by the executive for work until he should earn
    enough to pay it back.

    Mr. Feeley--When was Maroney's debt paid? A.--Some time in
    December.

    Q.--Did Maroney do any work after that? A.--He acted as detective
    in Iowa. He went with Sullivan and Boland to St. Paul.

    Dr. Cronin--Did the term report show any loss to Maroney? A.--I
    could not say; the time was from August, 1885, to August, 1886.

    Examination of another witness, a member since the beginning of the
    old organization.

    Q.--Did you know Capt. Lomasney? A.--Yes.

    Q.--Do you know of his having left on a certain motive? A.--Yes,
    three or four times since his imprisonment as Mr. O'Sullivan in
    1867.

    Q.--Do you remember the last time he went? A.--Yes; in August,
    1884.

    Q.--What did he say to you on the subject of his work? A.--I was
    closer than a brother to him. Our families had constant
    intercourse. I offered him my hand the day he told me of his
    project; had little help. Wife saved a bed.

    Q.--What family had he? A.--A wife and four children and an aged
    father.

    Q.--Who were with him? A.--His brother Jim and Mr. So-and-so.

    Q.--Have they been seen since? [No answer to this.]

    Q.--What was Mrs. Lomasney's condition before his going? A.--A most
    outrageous case of neglect. Flemming's mother died in the
    poorhouse.

    Q.--Did you ask for help? A.--Yes; in 1885 I went to New Haven. We
    had no directors. I called upon Dr. Wallace. He was D. Saw Mulvaney
    and Condon. The latter went with me to Carroll. He professed utter
    ignorance of the whole affair. I said: "By God, you must see her;"
    her, Mrs. L. He decided to. Mulvaney said: "Why don't you see
    Boland?" Found him on Fifth avenue. He denied all responsibility.
    He would have nothing to do with it. Finally he claimed she had
    received much money. I said she did not. He was non-committal. His
    acknowledgment made him responsible.

    Q.--Did you see Carroll at New York? A.--Yes. We met him at Vesey
    street. He left me to go into the Herald building and brought me
    $100. I refused this. I told him I didn't come for money. I said:
    "You know how to send this, as you have the others; if you respect
    the memory of the dead and the widow and the orphan, made so by
    your act, do your duty by all."

    Q.--Until August, 1886, what was her condition?
    A.--Poverty-stricken; no coal, no clothing; nothing left her but
    misery and her pride. Our S. G. would not give the channel of
    communication. He read our resolutions; whether he ever forwarded
    them or not I did never know. He is dead. He told the committee of
    D. that the organization was not responsible.

    Mr. Rogers--You swear you called the attention of Boland and
    Carroll to her condition? A.--Yes; and not until somebody came to
    us with $1,025 did the poor woman have any adequate support.

    By Dr. Cronin--Did Lomasney attend the district convention held in
    Chicago in 1884? A.--No; he was not elected.

    Q.--Was any one elected from your D.? A.--No; we noticed it much.
    We could not account for our D. having no representation.

    Q.--Would Lomasney tell you if he had been selected a delegate by
    any one outside of D.? A.--Yes, and we would have been aware of his
    absence.

    Q.--Would he have gone there, if not elected a delegate?

    A.--No; he was the soul of honor, and despised trickery; he did not
    care for office; never held any in his life except in danger.

    Mr. Boland--Did you see him at Boston? A.--Walsh told me he had no
    control. S. G. contended that the organization had no
    responsibility. In 1885 John Maroney called; said he had been
    especially sent. They had come for a little money; gave $10;
    Lomasney had nothing. N. Y. D. S. raised and sent $150. More was
    raised and suppressed. In 1887 the sheriff put Mrs. L. out on the
    street. No home was ever bought for her.

    Question by Mr. Dillon--Do you know that Mrs. L. is an economical
    woman? A.--Yes. People began to talk of her and sent an
    organization to me to say that she was extravagant; talked of her
    husband's taking off, which prejudiced many, and her rent was
    raised. She had been paying $30 a month; no general increase; the
    landlord wanted her put out.

    Mrs. Lomasney examined. [Upon Alexander Sullivan's request not
    sworn.] Husband went away in August, 1884.

    Q.--How much money have you received from the organization since?
    A.--A thousand dollars altogether.

    Q.--How much since? A.--In the summer of 1885 I visited Alexander
    Sullivan. I went to inquire after my husband, as I was led to
    believe he was in possession of certain funds; he did not know my
    condition, nor did he relieve me. He did send for a ticket to
    Detroit with which I returned home.

    Q.--When again did you call upon Mr. Sullivan? A.--In August, 1886,
    I made known my condition, and after advising me to sell my little
    store, he asked me a schedule of my liabilities: $200; he would
    attend to the matter. He gave me no money, nor offered me any. He
    seemed anxious that I should not communicate with any one in the
    city. He asked me if I was acquainted with any one. I told him of
    James Q. Mr. S. said I should not mention his (Sullivan's) name to
    any one, etc. Called on Q. He talked to me about Father Dorney. No
    help.

    Met Col. Richard Burke, and he, with some friends, assisted me, I
    know that Mr. Sullivan was the one that had a right to attend to
    this. Was afterward amazed that he did not. The dress I wore was a
    borrowed one. John Hickey was S. G. Several weeks after I went to
    Mr. Sullivan and asked him a loan of $100; this he sent me; nothing
    since. I could not give up the store, as that would confirm the
    belief that husband was dead or in the business. Thomas Tuttle was
    the first to relieve my necessities.

    CROSS-EXAMINED BY ALEXANDER SULLIVAN.

    Q.--You saw me in 1886, was it not? A.--Yes, certain. Another $500
    came from Brooklyn. I had a letter sent by my husband when he was
    in Europe, inclosing one from Mr. Alexander Sullivan, in which he
    said, in my letter, he asked for money. I afterwards received a
    note from my husband saying he had received money from Mr.
    Sullivan; I don't know the amount.

    Here Mr. S. admitted that Lomasney was sent by the organization.

    The last letter from husband was in 1884; anxious to go home. His
    age 44.

    Examination of another witness. Evidence corroborates that of the
    first witness taken. Received _£_20 and one steerage passage six
    weeks after the first witness. No shoes. Sold clothes and trunk to
    get home. No bed.

    Here the notes abruptly ended.

    CHAPTER V.

    STRANGE INFLUENCES AT WORK--MISS ANNIE MURPHY THINKS SHE SAW THE DOCTOR

    ON A STREET CAR--HIS LONG AND MYSTERIOUS RIDE WITH CONDUCTOR DWYER--

    REPORTER LONG ALSO ENCOUNTERS HIM, THIS TIME IN TORONTO--THE POLICE

    AND PUBLIC SATISFIED BUT HIS FRIENDS STILL ANXIOUS--EFFORTS TO PROVE

    HIM A BRITISH SPY--A BIG REWARD OFFERED.

    Less than a week had elapsed from the events narrated in the first chapter when sinister rumors commenced to gain circulation. It was whispered about that the alleged "mysterious disappearance" was in reality no mystery at all, that the physician had not been decoyed from home; that he was alive; that he had left the city of his own free will, and that the whole affair had been concocted for sensational purposes, the motive for which would be brought to light so soon as the cardinal objects had been attained.

    It was further hinted that the physician was inclined to be extremely erratic at times, that his love of sensationalism bordered on a mania, and that such a performance as that of May 4 was entirely in a line with his methods.

    A STREET CAR "CLUE."

    On the heels of these rumors came positive statements of alleged facts.

    It was first claimed that Dr. Cronin was seen on a street car two hours after he had parted with Frank Scanlan outside of the Windsor Theatre Building. Miss Annie Murphy, an employe of the City Recorder's Office, was responsible for this story which was made public a few hours after the arrest and "confession" of Woodruff. A comely and talented young lady, with a reputation as an elocutionist of no mean ability, she had frequently figured on the programme with the physician at Irish demonstrations and Catholic entertainments.

    Consequently she knew him well, and what she had to say commanded general attention, and a large degree of confidence. It was not known at this time, however, that her father, Thomas Murphy, was a prominent member of the Clan-na-Gael, and an officer in one of the local camps to boot. Miss Murphy's statement made on May 9th, when the popular excitement was at its height, was to the effect that she had seen Dr. Cronin on a Clark Street car shortly after nine o'clock on the night of his disappearance.

    "I had been paying a visit to friends on Garfield Avenue," she said, "and left at nine o'clock, taking a Garfield Avenue car. At the corner of Clark Street this was attached to a cable train. When we reached Division Street, I looked into the cable car, and I am positive that I saw Dr. Cronin sitting in it, his arms folded and his head bowed as if in deep thought. He did not look at me, nor could he have recognized me if he had, as it was dark outside, while the car in which he rode was well lighted. He had an oblong bundle of some kind resting upon his knees, over which his arms were folded. When I read in the papers on Monday morning that Dr.

    Cronin had disappeared, I told father that I had seen him, and we both laughed at the idea that the doctor had been murdered. When I reached the office, I told the same story."

    "You are sure that the man was Dr. Cronin?"

    "Just as sure as I am about my own identity," was the reply.

    CONDUCTOR DWYER ADDS A "LINK."

    Equally positive was the statement of William Dwyer, the conductor that had charge of car 415, and it convinced a good many people who had been inclined to the belief that Miss Murphy had been mistaken. Two weeks later, when the body of the murdered physician had been brought to light, Dwyer suddenly became an invalid, resigned his position and went to Canada "for his health." This fact gives additional significance to the circumstantial story that he told at the time.

    "My regular run," he said, "is on the State Street horse line, but I was called up to the limits barn Saturday night to take the place of Conductor Humphrey who got suddenly sick. I was put aboard of car No. 415, one of the big, long ones. It was just 9:18 o'clock to a second when we left the barn. There was not a passenger aboard. When we reached Frederick Street a tall, good-looking man with a heavy mustache, and I think a plug hat, got on. I took particular notice of him, because he was a striking looking man."

    "Where did he sit down?"

    "In the middle of the car. He faced east."

    "Did he have any parcels?"

    "Yes. I remember that he carried a little box or case. I think it was black. It was made of highly polished wood."

    "What did he do with it when he sat down?"

    "Put it in his lap and leaned his arm on it."

    "Did you notice how he was dressed?"

    "No, not particularly, except that he was well dressed. I saw he had a kind of a round bundle in his lap, too. It was a queer color--a kind of light red or pink."

    "Are you sure about that?"

    "Yes, because I noticed it particularly as I passed through the car. My attention was first attracted to it by a kind of white stuff that stuck out of the ends. It looked like white cotton, and when I passed through the car I brushed against it and a small particle of cotton clung to my coat."

    "Do you think your solitary passenger was under the influence of liquor?"

    "No, I don't. He walked straight and seemed to be sober. He was only abstracted and preoccupied. I noticed when we were passing the Windsor Theatre that he looked through the open windows of the car at the building with more interest than he had shown in anything else."

    "How was it that you noticed him then?"

    "Because he leaned forward as far as he could, and I guess I hadn't much else to look at just then."

    "Did he get up as if he intended to leave the car?"

    "No, he didn't; he kept his seat."

    "How far did he ride?"

    "To Madison Street. He started to get off at Washington Street, though.

    He had been more preoccupied than ever going through the tunnel, and when he got up at Washington Street he seemed kind of dazed. He asked me if we were at Madison Street, saying that he wanted to go to the Union Depot. I told him we were a block from Madison Street, and he returned to his seat. When we got to Madison I stopped the car and he jumped off.

    He started toward the river at a fast gait, as if he had an important appointment to keep."

    "Do you know Dr. Cronin?"

    "No, sir; I think not."

    "Then you do not know, of your own knowledge, that your solitary passenger was Dr. Cronin?"

    "No. But now that you speak of Dr. Cronin," he said after a long interval, "I remember that I thought he was a doctor, and I got an impression somehow from his grave aspect that he had been attending to a very serious case."

    "Did you notice whether anybody was with him when he stepped out at Frederick Street to board your car?"

    "I didn't notice, but I don't think there was."

    "Did you see an undersized man with a heavy mustache and a slouch hat?"

    "No; I didn't--but hold on a minute. I did see a man on the sidewalk, standing in the shadow of the building, who I think wore a soft hat, but as I had only a fleeting glimpse at him I couldn't attempt to describe him."

    These two stories, the first so clear and direct, and the other so corroborative obtained general credence except among the immediate friends of the physician. These still insisted upon their theory of foul play. Numerous contradictions in the statements made by Dwyer to different people were pointed out. An inspection of the sheet upon which he had made out his report of the trip when he turned in his receipts showed that instead of one passenger on the nine o'clock car he had carried thirty-six.

    The story told by Miss Murphy was directly challenged, many of the physician's friends declared that it was manufactured for ulterior motives. It was also charged that her father and Dr. Cronin were bitter enemies. This was denied at the time, and it was added that Murphy, who resided on Oak Street near by Alexander Sullivan, had never taken an active part in Irish affairs.

    Subsequently, during the Coroner's investigation, it was developed that at that very time he was the financial secretary of a Clan-na-Gael camp hostile in its composition to the missing man.

    BOGUS "INTERVIEWS" FROM CANADA.

    But still more astounding developments in this phase of the case were soon to come. There resided in Toronto, Canada, at this time, one Charles T. Long, a young man whose father was the publisher and part proprietor of an influential newspaper. Some time before this Long had been employed as a reporter on one or two Chicago morning papers, and in the performance of his duties he had met Dr. Cronin on numerous occasions. He had, moreover, for a short period been a member of a secret beneficial society with which the physician was identified, and hence could claim something more than a passing acquaintance with him.

    When therefore on the night of Friday, May 10th, the morning papers of Chicago and several other cities received dispatches--the majority over the ex-reporter's own signature--to the effect that the physician was alive and in that city, and had actually been spoken to, it was taken for granted that the major portion of the mystery had been solved. No mere resume could do justice to what might well be termed the devilish ingenuity with which these dispatches were framed, and it is necessary to quote them at length. The one received by the Chicago Herald, and which was a fair type of all, ran in this wise:

    Dr. P. H. Cronin is in Canada. He was seen, recognized and spoken
    to here to-day by a former Chicagoan, and in return told of his
    troubles, bitterly denouncing a number of Garden City people,
    Alexander Sullivan particularly. The missing and
    supposed-to-be-murdered physician seemed to be slightly deranged.
    C. T. Long, who for three years was intimately acquainted with Dr.
    Cronin in Chicago, was walking down Yonge street shortly after 11
    o'clock this morning, and when opposite the Arcade came face to
    face with the missing Irish nationalist.

    He was accompanied by a
    man of shorter stature. "Hello, Doc; what are you doing here?" was
    Long's greeting. To this the doctor answered "Hello," and then
    pausing and drawing himself up in an injured manner, continued:
    "You have me at a disadvantage, sir. What do you want?"

    "Why, Cronin, is it possible that you don't remember me?"

    "I do not know you, sir, and shall have you handed over to the
    police in case you bother me further."

    Having delivered himself of this the doctor turned the corner of
    the Arcade and quickly followed the retreating footsteps of his
    friend, who turned down Victoria street, and together they were
    soon lost in the crowd. Long informed the Herald correspondent
    that for three years he had been intimately acquainted with Cronin
    while living in Chicago--in fact, employed him as his family
    physician and belonged to several organizations with him. He was
    completely dumbfounded, first at sight of him and then at his mode
    of treatment.

    Cronin was dressed in a black coat and vest, light
    colored pants, black silk hat, and carried a small black hand-bag
    in one hand and a light spring overcoat thrown over his arm. The
    person with him appeared to be twenty-seven or thirty years of age,
    and while Long cannot place him, his face seemed quite familiar. At
    first sight he was taken for Jack Lynch, bailiff in Judge
    Clifford's court, and very strongly resembled him, but as far as
    Long knew Lynch was unknown to Cronin. Cronin's companion was
    dressed in a dark suit of clothes and slouch hat.

    He carried
    nothing but a newspaper, which was afterward picked up on Victoria
    street and proved to be a Chicago evening newspaper of the 7th
    inst.

    Long at once made for the Union Station in the hope that he might
    there run across the pair, but after waiting some thirty minutes
    concluded to notify the police and have them keep a sharp lookout
    for Cronin. While on the way to the Court street Station, police
    headquarters, and at the corner of King and Toronto streets, Long
    again caught sight of the pair walking rapidly down Toronto street.
    Slipping into a doorway at the receiver general's office he waited
    until they had passed, and then noticed that Cronin had adjusted a
    pair of goggles, but otherwise was attired precisely the same as on
    Yonge street.

    Stepping up to the doctor the point-blank question
    was put: "Cronin, what are you doing in Toronto when your friends
    in Chicago are hunting the earth for you?"

    "Now, look here, Long," he replied, "for God's sake let up on me. I
    have already had enough notoriety and don't want to be bothered.
    Why can't you let me go? You know I have always been your friend,
    and I shall expect that you will say nothing about having seen me."

    "Come in and let us talk the matter over," said Long, leading the
    pair into a convenient saloon. Cronin appeared to be a very sick
    man; in fact, the first impression conveyed was that he was out of
    his mind. He rambled away, talking about the Royal League and Mr.
    Warren, the secretary, and then, apparently getting frenzied,
    denounced in strong terms a number of St. Louis and Chicago
    gentlemen, among them Alexander Sullivan, John F. Scanlan, Dr.
    O'Reilly, M. F. Madden, Lawyer Berry, Harry Ballard, Judge
    Prendergast and Lawyer Wade. He mentioned several other names, but
    they were unknown to Long.

    Cronin went on to state that he had
    unearthed a great crime in Chicago during the past few months, but
    would give no details, and stated that his life had been settled as
    the penalty. "You know what kind of a man Sullivan is, don't you?"
    he said. "Well, he will never let up on me for what I have done,
    but I have a host of friends--yes, sir, a host of friends--in this
    country, and if harm comes to me all will not be well for him, I
    can assure you." All during the conversation his companion never
    opened his lips, and when he began talking of Sullivan he took him
    by the arm and whispered in his ear, after which Cronin refused to
    speak further.

    "Where are you stopping in town?" was met with a point-blank
    refusal to say more and an entreaty not to follow him. He was
    allowed to leave the saloon, and at once Cronin and his companion
    entered a cab and were driven rapidly west on King street. Long,
    too, summoned a cab, but through a mistake of the driver the wrong
    hack was followed. This brought up at the Union Station shortly
    after 12 o'clock. Long glanced at the time tables and found that
    the first train leaving the depot would be at 12:20 and concluded
    to wait and see if the case would further develop.

    At exactly
    12:18 a two-horse covered cab dashed up to the station and from it
    sprang Cronin, the unknown man, and a lady apparently about
    twenty-three years of age. They all three hurried into the train
    for Hamilton, not waiting to purchase tickets. Long boarded the
    train and asked Cronin for what point they were bound, and being
    refused a civil answer stated that he would stay with him and
    inform the police at the first station in case he refused to give
    up.

    He thereupon stated that they intended going to Niagara Falls.
    The lady was probably twenty to twenty-three or four years of age
    and wore a dark gray traveling dress and a turban hat. She carried
    a shawl-strap and a brown paper parcel. Cronin had nothing but his
    small bag and overcoat, while the stranger carried a large brown
    leather valise.

    Long has known Cronin for the past three years and intimately for
    the past two, belonged to a number of societies with him and had
    frequently visited his office on Clark street and received in
    return calls from the doctor at the house he used to live in, 271
    Huron street, and could not possibly be mistaken in the man.

    The
    only time Cronin ever made any remark to Long while in Chicago
    which would lead to the idea that he anticipated violence was one
    night while walking together up Clark street about 11:30 o'clock,
    and at Huron street the doctor requested Long to accompany him as
    far as Division street on a car, as he did not know what might
    happen to him. Passing Dillon's book store Frank Scanlan was met,
    and he went on home with the doctor.

    A CHAPTER OF INFAMY.

    Dr. Cronin's friends were dumbfounded when they opened their morning papers and found themselves confronted by these dispatches. His opponents, on the other hand, were in high glee, and quoted the news as vindicating their own acuteness of perception. But the Toronto end of the conspiracy had scarcely got into active operation. The initial dispatch of Friday was intended simply as a feeler. Long returned to the charge on Saturday with a second circumstantial story that completely eclipsed his first effort. It was as follows:

    After Cronin and his party--a man and woman--left Toronto yesterday
    on the Grand Trunk train moving west, your correspondent
    telegraphed a friend at Hamilton a description of the trio and
    requested that he should keep a sharp look-out for them; also that
    he should wire regarding all their movements and follow them, no
    matter where they went. In case they separated he was to put men on
    the track of the woman and strange man and to follow Cronin. This
    afternoon at 4:10 o'clock a message arrived stating that Cronin had
    left Hamilton alone, and was on the train scheduled to arrive at
    Toronto about 5:30 this evening.

    Dr. Cronin was not on that train.

    Shortly after 7 o'clock a telephone message announced that the
    Doctor was in this city at the Rossin House, King street, West.

    The correspondent sought out the fugitive and greatly surprised him
    when he answered his knock at the door.

    "Well, Doctor, back again?" was the greeting, to which the Doctor
    answered: "Well, ----," calling the correspondent by name, "it is
    really too bad that you should dog me round in this shape. What is
    your object in doing it? I have committed no crime and cannot see
    why you should thrust my name before the public as you did this
    morning in the Empire (a Toronto paper). You lied when you stated
    that Jim Lynch accompanied me. I don't even know the man."

    "Well, Cronin, you must certainly know that the people generally,
    and your Chicago friends particularly, are anxious to know where
    you are, why you left Chicago, and where you intend going."

    "I don't intend making statements," said the Doctor, "I guess I
    have some rights. Make a statement? I guess not! Now, please get
    out of my room, or I will kick you out."

    The correspondent mentioned that a number of detectives were
    searching for the missing man. This announcement appeared to annoy
    the Doctor, and he appeared willing to do anything rather than have
    detectives take him in charge. He seemed anxious to know all about
    the detectives, who they were, and what they were doing, and was
    especially desirous of knowing positively whether any of them were
    here. He was told that a rumor to that effect had gone the rounds
    to-day.

    Finally, Cronin requested that questions should be put to him, and
    the following conversation took place:

    "When did you leave Chicago?"

    "Just a week ago to-night."

    "Where did you go?"

    "I went to Montreal."

    "How did you leave Chicago?"

    "I refuse to answer."

    "Come, now, Cronin, remember the detectives."

    "Now, for God's sake, don't push that question! I can't answer it!"

    "When did you get to Montreal?"

    "I got there last Monday evening."

    "Where did you put up?"

    After considerable bickering the Doctor said he had taken a room at
    the St. Lawrence Hotel, got his meals at the house of a friend,
    whose name he would not give.

    "Why did you leave Montreal, and when did you do so?"

    "I received word that it was known in Chicago, or at least
    supposed, that I was down there, and got out so I could not be
    found."

    "Where did you then go?"

    "I came up to Ottawa."

    "When did you leave Montreal?"

    "I left there Thursday night."

    "Where did you put up in Ottawa?"

    "At the Russell Hotel."

    "Under your own name?"

    "No."

    "What name did you give?"

    "I don't remember."

    "Was it Parkhurst?"

    "No, that was not the name."

    "What address did you give?"

    "I think it was New York."

    "Don't you know?"

    "Yes."

    "Well, why did you leave Ottawa?"

    "Because the town was so small that I was afraid some one might
    know me."

    "When you got to Montreal where did you intend going?"

    "I intended taking a steamer for France, but found that no ship
    left that port which would take me there."

    "Why did you not then go on to New York?"

    "Because I am well known there and did not care to risk it."

    "After you left Ottawa where did you go?"

    "I took the Canadian Pacific train for Toronto and arrived here
    Friday morning at about 9 o'clock."

    "Where were you from 9 o'clock till the Empire reporter met you
    on Yonge street?"

    "I had been trying to find Starkey, the lawyer, who left Chicago
    last winter."

    "Why did you wish to see him?"

    "Simply to get the run of the town."

    "Did you not suspect that he might expose you?"

    "O, no! I am sure he would not do that. It would not be to his
    interest."

    "I thought Starkey was not friendly to you. Did he not at one time
    try to hurt your reputation?"

    "I don't know that he did. In any case he would not do so now."

    "Well, now, as to why you left Chicago?"

    "I have been declining in health for some time and thought it would
    do me good to take a trip."

    "Why should you have left Chicago without letting your friends
    know?"

    "Well, now, that is a long story and the telling of it would
    implicate a great number of my friends who are in no way
    responsible for any of my actions. I trust you will not press me on
    that point."

    Cronin was pressed, however, and told the following story:

    "While I lived in St. Louis I promptly identified myself with the
    Irish cause, then disturbing the public. I soon found that the
    great Irish movement was to be centered either at Chicago or New
    York, and after consulting my intimate friends, among whom was Dr.
    O'Reilly, I made up my mind to go to Chicago. I did so, armed with
    letters of introduction, and soon found myself prominent in Irish
    as well as other circles."

    He then went on to say that he soon discovered that the large
    quantities of money being received by certain persons for the Irish
    cause were not handled properly, and that not more than
    three-fourths of it ever reached Ireland.

    "I know," he stated, "that at least $85,000 was gobbled up by
    certain persons in Chicago, and when I began to 'call the turn' on
    them they tried to scare me off. Failing in this, they tried to
    bribe me. That would not work."

    "Their next move," said Dr. Cronin, "was to introduce me to Le
    Caron under the name of Beach, in order that he might pump me and
    damage me in any way that he could. Beach was introduced to me by a
    reporter named Conwell, a man whom I had always considered my
    friend, but since the recent developments in the London Times
    case I know he was against me and that Le Caron was introduced to
    me for no good purpose. He got little out of me, however, and that
    means failed. I have been warned several times to get out of the
    country, and assured that my life was in danger.

    But up to last
    Saturday I felt that I could hold my own. Last Saturday, however, I
    was put in possession of unquestionable proof that the Clan-na-Gael
    Society had decided that my life should be taken. A man was
    appointed as my executioner and preparations were in active
    progress to accomplish the deed. Enough to say I made up my mind at
    once to fly. You know the rest. The lady who accompanied me
    yesterday to Hamilton was quite unknown to me, as was also the
    gentleman, until I met them on the train between Ottawa and
    Toronto. Neither of them knew who I was until you met me on Yonge
    street Friday morning.

    They happened to be going to Buffalo on the
    train I took out of Toronto, and I left them at Hamilton."

    This part of the story proved to be true.

    "Did you plan for a man to call at your office and request you to
    go out to the ice-house and attend a patient?" he was asked.

    "That I will not answer."

    When asked what move he intended making next the Doctor stated that
    he would go to France as soon as possible. "I left some important
    documents behind in Chicago," he said, "and only hope that I can
    get to a country where I will be safe; then I will make some
    disclosures which will open the eyes of the public generally and
    make the hair stand on the heads of several Chicago and New York
    gentlemen. This talk about my having been seen in a cable-car
    Saturday night is entirely false. The Conklins have made fools of
    themselves over the whole matter.

    According to the instructions I
    left with them they should not have opened their mouths until I was
    safely out of the country; but it is the same old story--tell a
    woman anything and you are sure to get the worst of it."

    The Doctor intimated that a certain Methodist minister had caused
    all his trouble, but would not disclose his name.

    The woman who accompanied the Doctor from Toronto to Hamilton
    proved to be from Buffalo and had no knowledge of the company she
    was keeping until she read the paper. The Doctor says that the man
    who walked up Yonge street with him Friday afternoon was also
    unknown to him until Thursday night and that he was on his way to
    Winnipeg. This man has been located at Collingwood, a small town
    about 100 miles north of Toronto. He is unknown there, and may be
    waiting a steamer which would take him to Winnipeg.

    Cronin is still in town and a close watch is being kept on all his
    movements.

    CRONIN'S ENEMIES IN HIGH GLEE.

    In another dispatch it was stated that Dr. Cronin had, on Saturday night, accepted the hospitalities of W. J. Starkey, an ex-Chicago lawyer. On the following morning, so the same dispatch went on to say, the physician had actually been entertained by Long at his residence. To ninety-nine out of a hundred people, this was conclusive. Everything pointed to the fact that the hitherto missing man was alive and in the flesh. No chain of evidence could have been more complete. Had not Miss Murphy seen him on the car?

    Had he not ridden down town with Conductor Dwyer, to whom he said that he was on his way to the Union Depot, and had he not appeared in Toronto, broken bread with Starkey and Long, and admitted that he was on his way to cross the ocean? What more was wanted? At this point, too, his enemies in Chicago began to add leaven to the lump.

    The story told by Woodruff was recalled, and it was insidiously suggested in one quarter that the physician was the mysterious "Doc," and that having performed a criminal operation upon the equally mysterious "Alice," whose remains had been taken to the park in the trunk, he had fled the country to avoid the legal consequences of his crime. In another direction it was boldly charged that before many days the physician would turn up in London in the role of a second Le Caron. Said one of his most inveterate opponents:

    "Dr. Cronin is not dead; at least he wasn't assassinated at the end
    of his buggy ride with a strange man last Saturday night. Neither
    is he likely to be found in this city or State, and perhaps not in
    the United States. And there is much reason to suspect that he went
    at the beck and call of the English Government--in short, that he
    was a British spy, and has gone to join Le Caron, his friend and
    companion and near neighbor both here and in St. Louis. A startling
    communication in cipher has been received from the other side, and
    the information comes from a source whose accuracy cannot be
    doubted.

    It is to the effect that agents of the English Government
    have been arranging to place another American informer on the stand
    in the Parnell inquiry. It seems that the informer has offered to
    testify for a stated sum, which is said to be $100,000, and that
    the Government is only awaiting the report of its experts, who are
    inspecting his documentary proof before accepting his proposition.
    That is the way the matter stands now. I have been asked to find
    out who this new informer is. I have tried my best to do so, but I
    can't say I have been entirely successful. Dr.

    Cronin's mysterious
    disappearance has left a deep suspicion on my mind. I never liked
    that fellow, anyway, for I always considered him a contemptible
    rascal. I don't believe, either, that he has been assassinated,
    because I don't know of any good reason for killing him. I wouldn't
    be surprised if he turned up in London shortly. It wouldn't be at
    all strange. He was Le Caron's friend, as nearly as I can ascertain
    from Chicagoans, who knew them both, and what would be more natural
    than for him to cross the Atlantic to pay the druggist a friendly
    visit?"

    On the heels of this came an alleged dispatch from London:

    "Le Caron, the man who acted as a spy for the British Government on the movements of the Irish leaders in America, and who testified for the Times before the Parnell Commission, declares that he and Dr. Cronin were the closest friends. Le Caron believes that Dr. Cronin has been killed, and that the friendship of the murdered man may account for his removal."

    Naturally enough, these diabolical insinuations had their full effect on the public mind. The search for the body was practically abandoned by the police, and the theory that the physician had left the town of his own free will was generally accepted by the public.

    Even some of those who had been closely associated with him were inclined to the same view, except that they ascribed his possible trip to London to different purposes to those advanced by his enemies.

    "I believe Dr. Cronin is in New York on his way to London for the purpose of testifying before the Parnell Commission," said one of his friends.

    "Why do you think so?" he was asked.

    "Apart from certain things I cannot divulge," was the response, "Dr.

    Cronin has for several years been prepared to prove that not one-tenth of the amount of funds published in the American papers as having been collected for the Land League ever went across the water."

    "How would testimony to that effect benefit Parnell?"

    "It would show that his connection with certain extensive movements among the Irish factions in America has not been as close as was supposed. If, as a matter of fact, he has received no financial help from these factions, he cannot be held responsible for their statements of his advocacy of their advocacy."

    "Do any other persons entertain this theory?"

    "Yes, a number of Irish-Americans, who know of Dr. Cronin's possession of the information I speak of, have expressed the opinion I hold."

    And, as if to demonstrate the fact that the speaker was on the right track, a dispatch was received in Chicago, through the agency of The United Press, within the hour, that said:

    "New York: It is reported to-night that Dr. Cronin is in this city."

    STAUNCH FRIENDS TO THE FRONT.

    But, to their eternal honor and credit, be it said, there were many staunch friends of the missing man, who, undeterred by slander and suspicion on the one hand, and questionable reports on the other, were determined that the mystery should be probed to the bottom, and that, dead or alive, the physician should be found. Among them were John F.

    Scanlan, W. P. Rend, Frank Scanlan, P. McGarry, and T. T. Conklin. These and others came together and decided to send one of their number to Toronto to investigate the reports that had emanated from that city. An unlimited supply of money was pledged, and Pat McGarry was selected for the mission. Information regarding this action was telegraphed to Toronto and took the Canadian conspirators--who had not contemplated any such move--somewhat by surprise. Prompt action became necessary, and the only thing to be done was to make it appear that Dr. Cronin had disappeared from the city as suddenly as he entered it.

    Accordingly, dispatches to that effect were prepared and transmitted to the various papers that had received the previous reports. One of these was worded as follows:

    Dr. Cronin is a fugitive. He has not been seen in Toronto since 10
    o'clock this morning, when Long, his former Chicago friend, left
    him under the surveillance of an amateur detective, paid for the
    purpose. Cronin then was in a state bordering on terror, and begged
    frequently that detectives should not be put upon his track, and
    offered to give any additional particulars he knew about affairs
    generally. Dispatches from Chicago newspapers had given the story
    of suspicion against Cronin in respect to the trunk mystery. When
    asked about this mystery he denied that he knew anything.

    This
    morning, when the news contained in Chicago dispatches was
    communicated to him, he stuck to that statement, though once or
    twice threatened with exposure and the allegation that detectives
    were waiting in the vestibule of the hotel and had a warrant for
    his arrest on the charge of malpractice. He was next asked if there
    was any truth in the other story about his going to London to
    communicate with the British Government. His manner and evasive
    replies tended to create this impression rather than that he made
    his escape from Chicago over the trunk mystery.

    He said he intended
    in a day or two to return to Montreal, where he had been to get one
    of the Canada-French line boats to Paris. Then he said he might go
    to England.

    Cronin promised he did not intend to leave Toronto for a few days.
    He was not registered at the hotel, and the scores of reporters who
    called were informed that he was not staying there, and had not
    been there. This was arranged by Cronin's occupying a room engaged
    by another party, so the hotel clerk had no idea that the man was
    in the house. The information contained in the interview was no
    doubt intended by Cronin to mislead, and the interviewer was well
    aware of the fact at the time.

    He got his amateur detective at the
    end of the corridor and told him to keep his eyes open, and when
    Cronin was left alone in his apartment to see that he did not leave
    it. Some few minut

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin
    Author
    Henry M. Hunt
    Release date
    May 25, 2010 [eBook #32533]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland and the Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team
    Transcriber and production notes
    E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland and the Project Gutenberg Online
    Distributed Proofreading Team (http://www.pgdp.net)
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    Note: Project Gutenberg also has an HTML version of this
          file which includes the original illustrations.
          See 32533-h.htm or 32533-h.zip:
          (https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/32533/pg32533-images.html)
          or
          (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/32533/32533-h.zip)
    
    
    
    
    
    THE CRIME OF THE CENTURY
    
    Or,
    
    The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin.
    
    A Complete and Authentic History of the
    Greatest of Modern Conspiracies.
    
    by
    
    HENRY M. HUNT,
    The Noted Journalist.
    
    Profusely Illustrated with Original Engravings.
    
    Apart from Its Value As a History of a Celebrated Case,
    the Story Itself Is of Thrilling and
    Fascinating Interest.
    
    
    [Illustration: _From a Photograph taken just before the Murder._]
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    Copyright 1889,
    By
    H. L. & D. H. Kochersperger.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Crime of the Century; Or, The Assassination of Dr. Patrick Henry Cronin
    
    Author: Henry M. Hunt
    
    
            
    Release date: May 25, 2010 [eBook #32533]
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/32533
    
    Credits: E-text prepared by Juliet Sutherland and the Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #32533. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 32533
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.