Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Trial of Theodore Parker
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 31298

The Trial of Theodore Parker

by Theodore Parker · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2010
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    The Trial of Theodore Parker by Theodore Parker is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #31298). [Transcriber's Note: A table of contents has been added for the reader's convenience. Errors listed in the Errata section have been noted with a [Transcriber's Note]; other obvious printer errors have been corrected without note.]

    PREFACE.

    TO THE PEOPLE OF THE FREE STATES OF AMERICA.

    FELLOW-CITIZENS AND FRIENDS,--

    If it were a merely personal matter for which I was arraigned before the United States Court, after the trial was over I should trouble the public no further with that matter; and hitherto indeed, though often attacked, nay, almost continually for the last fourteen years, I have never returned a word in defence. But now, as this case is one of such vast and far-reaching importance, involving the great Human Right to Freedom of Speech, and as the actual question before the court was never brought to trial, I cannot let the occasion pass by without making further use of it.

    When Judge Curtis delivered his charge to the Grand-Jury, June 7th, 1854, I made ready for trial, and in three or four days my line of defence was marked out--the fortifications sketched, the place of the batteries determined; I began to collect arms, and was soon ready for his attack.

    When that Grand-Jury, summoned with no special reference to me, refused to find a bill and were discharged, I took public notice of the conduct of Judge Curtis, in a Sermon for the Fourth of July.[1] But I knew the friends of the fugitive slave bill at Boston and Washington too well to think they would let the matter sleep; I knew what arts could be used to pack a jury and procure a bill. So I was not at all surprised when I heard of the efforts making by the Slave Power in Boston to obtain an indictment by another grand-jury summoned for that purpose.

    It need not be supposed that I was wholly ignorant of their doings from day to day. The arrest was no astonishment to me. I knew how much the reputation of this Court and of its Attorney depended on the success of this prosecution. I knew what private malignity was at work.

    [Footnote 1: 2 Parker's Additional Speeches, 178-283.]

    After my arraignment I made elaborate preparation for my defence. I procured able counsel, men needing no commendation, to manage the technical details which I knew nothing about and so could not meddle with, while I took charge of other matters lying more level to my own capacity. I thought it best to take an active part in my own defence,--for the matter at issue belonged to my previous studies and general business; my personal friends and the People in general, seemed to expect me to defend myself as well as I could.

    A great political revolution took place between the Judge's charge and my arraignment, June 7th, and November 29th, 1854, and I thought the Court would not allow the case to come to open argument. For certainly, it would not be a very pleasant thing for Judge Sprague and Judge Curtis, who have taken such pains to establish slavery in Massachusetts, to sit there--each like a travestied Prometheus, chained up in a silk gown because they had brought to earth fire from the quarter opposite to Heaven--and listen to Mr. Hale, and Mr.

    Phillips and other anti-slavery lawyers, day after day: there were facts, sure to come to light, not honorable to the Court and not pleasant to look at in the presence of a New England community then getting indignant at the outrages of the Slave Power. I never thought the case would come to the jury.

    I looked over the indictment, and to my unlearned eye it seemed so looped and windowed with breaches that a skilful lawyer might drive a cart and six oxen through it in various directions; and so the Court might easily quash the indictment and leave all the blame of the failure on the poor Attorney--whom they seemed to despise, though using him for their purposes--while they themselves should escape with a whole reputation, and ears which had not tingled under manly speech.

    Still, it was possible that the trial would come on. Of course, I knew the trial would not proceed on the day I was ordered to appear--the eighty-fifth anniversary of the Boston Massacre. It would be "unavoidably postponed," which came to pass accordingly. The Attorney, very politely, gave me all needed information from time to time.

    At the "trial," April 3d, it was optional with the defendant's counsel to beat the Government on the indictment before the Court; or on the merits of the case before the Jury. The latter would furnish the most piquant events, for some curious scenes were likely to take place in the examination of witnesses, as well as instruction to be offered in the Speeches delivered. But on the whole, it was thought best to blow up the enemy in his own fortress and with his own magazine, rather than to cut him to pieces with our shot in the open field.

    So the counsel rent the indictment into many pieces--apparently to the great comfort of the Judges, who thus escaped the battle, which then fell only on the head of the Attorney.

    At the time appointed I was ready with my defence--which I now print for the Country. It is a Minister's performance, not a lawyer's. Of course, I knew that the Court would not have allowed me to proceed with such a defence--and that I should be obliged to deliver it through the press. Had there been an actual jury trial, I should have had many other things to offer in reference to the Government's evidence, to the testimony given before the grand-jury, and to the conduct of some of the grand-jurors themselves. So the latter part of the defence is only the skeleton of what it otherwise might have been,--the geological material of the country, the Flora and Fauna left out.

    It would have been better to publish it immediately after the decision of the case: but my brief was not for the printer, and as many duties occurred at that time, it was not till now, in a little vacation from severer toils, that I have found leisure to write out my defence in full. Fellow-Citizens and Friends, I present it to you in hopes that it may serve the great cause of Human Freedom in America and the world; surely, it has seldom been in more danger.

    THEODORE PARKER.

    BOSTON, 24th August, 1855.

    INTRODUCTION.

    On Tuesday, the 23d of May, 1854, Charles F. Suttle of Virginia, presented to Edward Greeley Loring, Esquire, of Boston, Commissioner, a complaint under the fugitive slave bill--Act of September 18th, 1850--praying for the seizure and enslavement of Anthony Burns.

    The next day, Wednesday, May 24th, Commissioner Loring issued the warrant: Mr. Burns was seized in the course of the evening of that day, on the false pretext of burglary, and carried to the Suffolk County Court House in which he was confined by the Marshal, under the above-named warrant, and there kept imprisoned under a strong and armed guard.

    On the 25th, at about nine o'clock in the morning, the Commissioner proceeded to hear and decide the case in the Circuit Court room, in which were stationed about sixty men serving as the Marshal's guard.

    Seth J. Thomas, Esquire, and Edward Griffin Parker, Esquire, members of the Suffolk Bar, appeared as counsel for Mr. Suttle to help him and Commissioner Loring make a man a Slave. Mr. Burns was kept in irons and surrounded by "the guard." The Slave-hunter's documents were immediately presented, and his witness was sworn and proceeded to testify.

    Wendell Phillips, Theodore Parker, Charles M. Ellis, and Richard H.

    Dana, with a few others, came into the Court room. Mr. Parker and some others, spoke with Mr. Burns, who sat in the dock ironed, between two of the Marshal's guard. After a little delay and conference among these four and others, Mr. Dana interrupted the proceedings and asked that counsel might be assigned to Mr. Burns, and so a defence allowed.

    To this Mr. Thomas, the senior counsel for the Slave-hunters, objected. But after repeated protests on the part of Mr. Dana and Mr.

    Ellis, the Commissioner adjourned the hearing until ten o'clock, Saturday, May 27th.

    On the evening of Friday, May 26th, there was a large and earnest meeting of men and women at Faneuil Hall. Mr. George R. Russell, of West Roxbury, presided; his name is a fair exponent of the character and purposes of the meeting, which Dr. Samuel G. Howe called to order.

    Speeches were made and Resolutions passed. Mr. Phillips and Mr.

    Parker, amongst others, addressed the meeting; Mr. Parker's speech, as reported and published in the newspapers, is reprinted in this volume, page 199. While this meeting was in session there was a gathering of a few persons about the Court House, the outer doors of which had been unlawfully closed by order of the Marshal; an attempt was made to break through them and enter the building, where the Supreme Court of Massachusetts was sitting engaged in a capital case; and the Courts of this State must always sit with open doors.

    In the strife one of the Marshal's guard, a man hired to aid in the Slave-hunt, was killed--but whether by one of the assailing party, or by the Marshal's guard, it is not yet quite clear. It does not appear from the evidence laid before the public or the three Grand-Juries, that there was any connection between the meeting at Faneuil Hall and the gathering at the Court House.

    Saturday, 27th, at ten o'clock, the Commissioner opened his Court again, his prisoner in irons before him. The other events are well known. Mr. Burns was taken away to Slavery on Friday, June 2d, by an armed body of soldiers with a cannon.

    The May Term of the Circuit Court at Boston began on the 15th of that month, and the Grand-Jury for that term had already been summoned.

    Here is the list:--

    UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT, }

    MASSACHUSETTS DISTRICT. }

    May Term, 1854. ss. May 15, 1854.

    GRAND-JURY.

    1 Sworn. Isaac Tower, Randolph, Foreman.

    2 " Elbridge G. Manning, Andover.

    3 " Asa Angier, "

    4 " Ballard Lovejoy, "

    5 " Levi Eldridge, Chatham.

    6 " Isaac B. Young, "

    7 " Josiah Peterson, Duxbury.

    8 " James Curtis, "

    9 Not Sworn. William Amory, Boston, Excused first day.
    Member of the bar.

    10 Sworn. James P. Bush, " Absent June 28th.

    11 " John Clark, "

    12 " Charles H. Mills, "

    13 " William N. Tyler, "

    14 " Samuel Weltch, "

    15 " Reuben Nichols, Reading.

    16 " Benjamin M. Boyce, "

    17 " Ephraim F. Belcher, Randolph.

    18 " Thomas S. Brimblecome, Fairhaven.

    19 " Obed F. Hitch, "

    20 " Lowell Claflin, Hopkinton.

    21 " William Durant, Leominster.

    22 " Charles Grant, "

    23 " Jeremiah B. Luther, Douglas.

    On the 7th of June, Judge Curtis gave to this Grand-Jury his charge.[2] In that he spoke of the enforcement of the fugitive slave bill; and he charged the Jury especially and minutely upon the Statute of the United States of 1790, in relation to resisting officers in service of process as follows.

    [Footnote 2: The charge is printed below, at page 170.]

    That not only those who are present and actually obstruct, resist, and oppose, and all who are present leagued in the common design, and so situated as to be able in case of need, to afford assistance to those actually engaged; but all who, though absent, did procure, counsel, command, or abet others to commit the offence; and all who, by indirect means, by evincing an express liking, approbation, or assent to the design, were liable as principals.

    And he added, "My instruction to you is, that language addressed to persons who immediately afterwards commit an offence, actually intended by the speaker to incite those addressed to commit it, and adapted thus to incite them, is such a counselling, or advising to the crime as the law contemplates, and the person so inciting others is liable to be indicted as a principal," and it is of no importance that his advice or directions were departed from in respect to the time, or place, or precise mode, or means of committing it.

    That Jury remained in session a few weeks: pains were taken to induce them to find bills against the speakers at Faneuil Hall; but they found no indictment under the law of 1790, or that of 1850; they were discharged.

    On the 22d of September, venires were issued by order of the Court for a new Grand-Jury; and, on the 16th of October, twenty-three were returned by Marshal Freeman, and impanelled. Here is the list of new Grand-Jurors:--

    UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT, }

    MASSACHUSETTS DISTRICT. }

    October Term, 1854. ss. October 16, 1854.

    GRAND-JURY.

    1 Sworn. Enoch Patterson, Jr., Boston, Foreman.

    2 " David Alden, "

    3 " Stephen D. Abbott, Andover.

    4 " Isaac Beal, Chatham.

    5 " John Burrill, Reading.

    6 " Mathew Cox, Boston.

    7 " Richard B. Chandler, Duxbury.

    8 " Charles L. Cummings, Douglas.

    9 " Charles Carter, Leominster.

    10 " Warren Davis, Reading.

    11 " William W. Greenough, Boston.

    12 " George O. Hovey, "

    13 " John M. Howland, Fairhaven.

    14 Sworn. Manson D. Haws, Leominster.

    15 " John Holbrook, Randolph.

    Excused. Nathaniel Johnson, Hopkinton, Excused first day,
    October 16th, for
    the term.

    16 Sworn. George Londen, Duxbury.

    17 " Nathan Moore, Andover.

    18 " Samuel P. Ridler, Boston.

    19 " Christopher Ryder, Chatham.

    20 " John Smith, Andover.

    21 " Appollos Wales, Randolph.

    22 " Samuel L. Ward, Fairhaven.

    This Grand-Jury was not charged by the Judge upon the statute of 1790, or 1850, but was referred to Mr. Hallett, the Attorney, for the instructions previously given to the Jury that had been discharged, namely, for his charge of June 7th, already referred to. Mr. William W. Greenough, brother-in-law of Judge Curtis, was one of the Jury.

    They found the following indictment against Mr. Parker:--

    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

    Circuit Court of the United States of America, for the
    District of Massachusetts.

    At a Circuit Court of the United States of America, for the
    District of Massachusetts, begun and holden at Boston, the
    aforesaid District, on the sixteenth day of October, in the
    year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-four
    (the fifteenth day of said October being Sunday).

    The Jurors of the United States within the aforesaid
    District, on their oath, present.

    1st. That heretofore to wit,--on the twenty-fourth day of
    May, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
    fifty-four, a certain warrant and legal process directed to
    the Marshal of the said District of Massachusetts, or either
    of his Deputies, was duly issued under the hand and seal of
    Edward G.

    Loring, Esquire, who was then and there a
    Commissioner of the Circuit Court of the United States, for
    said District, which said warrant and legal process was duly
    delivered to Watson Freeman, Esquire, who was then and there
    an officer of the United States, to wit, Marshal of the
    United States, for the said District of Massachusetts, at
    Boston, in the District aforesaid, on the said twenty-fourth
    day of May in the year aforesaid, and was of the purport and
    effect following, that is to say:--

    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.

    MASSACHUSETTS DISTRICT, SS.

    To the Marshal of our District of Massachusetts, or either
    of his Deputies, Greeting:

    In the name of the President of the United States of
    America, you are hereby commanded forthwith to apprehend
    Anthony Burns, a negro man, alleged now to be in your
    District, charged with being a fugitive from labor, and with
    having escaped from service in the State of Virginia, if he
    may be found in your precincts, and have him forthwith
    before me, Edward G.

    Loring, one of the Commissioners of the
    Circuit Court of the United States for the said District,
    then and there to answer to the complaint of Charles F.
    Suttle, of Alexandria, in the said State of Virginia,
    Merchant, alleging under oath that the said Anthony Burns on
    the twenty-fourth day of March last, did and for a long time
    prior thereto had, owed service and labor to him the said
    Suttle, in the said State of Virginia, under the laws
    thereof, and that, while held to service there by said
    Suttle, the said Burns escaped from the said State of
    Virginia, into the State of Massachusetts; and that the said
    Burns still owes service and labor to said Suttle in the
    said State of Virginia, and praying that said Burns may be
    restored to him said Suttle in said State of Virginia, and
    that such further proceedings may then and there be had in
    the premises as are by law in such cases provided.

    Hereof fail not, and make due return of this writ, with your
    doings therein before me.

    Witness my hand and seal at Boston, aforesaid, this
    twenty-fourth day of May, in the year one thousand eight
    hundred and fifty-four.

    EDWARD G. LORING, Commissioner. [L.S.]

    And the Jurors aforesaid do further present, that the said
    warrant and legal process, being duly issued and delivered
    as aforesaid, afterwards to wit, on the twenty-fifth day of
    May, in the year aforesaid, at Boston in said District, the
    said Watson Freeman then and there being an officer of the
    said United States, to wit Marshal of the District
    aforesaid, and in pursuance of said warrant and legal
    process, did then and there arrest the said Anthony Burns
    named therein, and had him before the said Edward G.

    Loring,
    Commissioner, for examination--and thereupon the hearing of
    the said case was adjourned by the said Commissioner until
    Saturday the twenty-seventh day of May, in the year
    aforesaid, at ten o'clock in the forenoon; and the said
    Marshal, who had so made return of the said Warrant, was
    duly ordered by the said Commissioner to retain the said
    Anthony Burns in his custody, and have him before the said
    Commissioner on the said twenty-seventh day of May in the
    year aforesaid, at the Court House in said Boston, which
    said last-mentioned legal process and order was duly issued
    under the hand of the said Edward G.

    Loring, Commissioner,
    and was of the purport and effect following, that is to say:

    U.S. OF AMERICA, DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS.

    Boston, May 25, 1854.

    And now the hearing of this case being adjourned to
    Saturday, May 27, 1854, 10 A.M., the said Marshal, who has
    made return of this warrant, is hereby ordered to retain the
    said Anthony Burns in his custody, and have him before me at
    the time last mentioned, at the Court House in Boston, for
    the further hearing of the Complaint on which the warrant
    was issued.

    EDWARD G. LORING, Commissioner.

    And the Jurors aforesaid do further present, that on the
    twenty-sixth day of May, in the year aforesaid, in pursuance
    of the warrant and legal process aforesaid, and of said
    further legal process and order last mentioned, the said
    Watson Freeman, Marshal as aforesaid, then and there, at the
    said Court House in said Boston, had in his custody the
    person of the said Anthony Burns, in the due and lawful
    execution of the said warrant and legal process, and of the
    said further legal process and order, in manner and form as
    he was therein commanded--and one Theodore Parker, of
    Boston, in said District, Clerk, then and there well knowing
    the premises, with force and arms did knowingly and wilfully
    obstruct, resist, and oppose the said Watson Freeman, then
    and there being an officer of the said United States, to
    wit, Marshal of the said District, in serving and attempting
    to serve and execute the said warrant and legal process, and
    the said further legal process and order in manner and form
    as he was therein commanded, to the great damage of the said
    Watson Freeman, to the great hinderance and obstruction of
    Justice, to the evil example of all others, in like case
    offending, against the peace and dignity of the said United
    States, and contrary to the form of the Statute in such case
    made and provided.

    2d.

    And the Jurors aforesaid, on their oath aforesaid, do
    further present, that on the twenty-sixth day of May, in the
    year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-four,
    at Boston, in said District, one Theodore Parker, of Boston,
    in said District, Clerk, with force and arms, did knowingly
    and wilfully obstruct, resist, and oppose one Watson
    Freeman, who was then and there the Marshal of the United
    States of America, for the District of Massachusetts, and an
    officer of the said United States, in serving and attempting
    to serve and execute a certain warrant and legal process,
    which before that time, to wit, on the twenty-fourth day of
    May, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
    fifty-four, had been duly issued under the hand and seal of
    Edward G.

    Loring, Esquire, a Commissioner of the Circuit
    Court of the United States, for said District of
    Massachusetts, and directed to the Marshal of the District
    of Massachusetts, or either of his deputies, which said
    warrant and legal process the said Freeman, in the due and
    lawful execution of his said office, had then and there in
    his hands and possession for service of the same, and which
    he was then and there serving and attempting to serve and
    execute; which said warrant commanded the said Freeman to
    apprehend one Anthony Burns and to have him forthwith before
    the said Commissioner, then and there to be dealt with
    according to law.

    Against the peace and dignity of the said
    United States, and contrary to the form of the Statute in
    such case made and provided.

    3d.

    And the Jurors aforesaid, on their oath aforesaid, do
    further present, that on the twenty-sixth day of May, in the
    year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-four,
    at Boston, in said District, the said Theodore Parker, with
    force and arms, did knowingly and wilfully obstruct, resist,
    and oppose one Watson Freeman, who was then and there an
    officer of the said United States, to wit, the Marshal of
    the United States for the said District of Massachusetts, in
    serving and attempting to serve and execute a certain legal
    process which before that time, to wit, on the 25th day of
    May, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
    fifty-four, had been duly issued under the hand of Edward G.
    Loring, who was then and there a Commissioner of the Circuit
    Court of the United States, for the said District of
    Massachusetts, and was then and there duly empowered to
    issue said legal process, and which said legal process was
    duly committed for obedience and execution to the said
    Freeman, Marshal as aforesaid, wherein and whereby and in
    pursuance of the command whereof the said Freeman was then
    and there lawfully retaining, detaining, and holding one
    Anthony Burns for the further hearing and determination of a
    certain complaint, upon which a warrant before that time, to
    wit, on the twenty-fourth day of said May, had been duly
    issued under the hand and seal of the said Commissioner, by
    force of which warrant the said Anthony Burns had been duly
    arrested and apprehended by the said Freeman, and in
    execution of the same, on the twenty-fifth day of said May
    had been brought by the said Freeman before the said
    Commissioner.

    4th.

    And the jurors aforesaid, on their oath aforesaid, do
    further present, that on the twenty-sixth day of May, in the
    year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-four,
    at Boston, in said district, the said Theodore Parker, with
    force and arms, did knowingly and wilfully obstruct, resist,
    and oppose one Watson Freeman, who was then and there an
    officer of the said United States, to wit, Marshal of the
    United States, for the District of Massachusetts, in serving
    and attempting to serve and execute a certain warrant and
    legal process, which before that time, to wit, on the
    twenty-fourth day of May, in the year of our Lord one
    thousand eight hundred and fifty-four, had been duly issued
    under the hand and seal of Edward G.

    Loring, Esquire, a
    Commissioner of the Circuit Court of the United States, for
    the District of Massachusetts, and directed to the Marshal
    of the said District of Massachusetts or either of his
    Deputies, which the said Freeman, in the due and lawful
    execution of his said office, had then and there in his
    hands and possession for service of the same, and which he
    was then and there serving and attempting to serve and
    execute; which warrant commanded the said Freeman to
    apprehend one Anthony Burns, and to have him forthwith
    before the said commissioner and that such further
    proceedings might then and there be had in the premises, as
    are by law in such cases provided,--and also in serving and
    attempting to serve and execute a certain further legal
    process which before that time, to wit, on the twenty-fifth
    day of May, in the year aforesaid, had been duly issued
    under the hand of the said Commissioner, and duly committed
    for obedience and execution to the said Freeman, wherein and
    whereby, and in pursuance of the command whereof, the said
    Freeman was then and there lawfully retaining, detaining,
    and holding the said Anthony Burns for the further hearing
    and determination of a certain complaint upon which the
    warrant aforesaid had been issued by the said Commissioner.

    5th.

    And the Jurors aforesaid on their oath aforesaid, do
    further present that one Theodore Parker, of Boston, in said
    District, Clerk, on the 26th day of May, in the year of our
    Lord one thousand eight hundred and fifty-four, at Boston,
    in the said District of Massachusetts, with force and arms,
    in and upon one Watson Freeman, then and there in the peace
    of the said United States being, an assault did make, he the
    said Freeman also then and there being an officer of the
    said United States, to wit, Marshal of the United States,
    for the said District of Massachusetts, and then and there
    also being in the due and lawful discharge of his duties as
    such officer.

    And so the jurors aforesaid, on their oath
    aforesaid, do say and present that the said Theodore Parker,
    at Boston aforesaid, on the said twenty-sixth day of said
    May, with force and arms assaulted the said Freeman as such
    officer, and knowingly and wilfully obstructed, resisted,
    and opposed him in the discharge of his lawful duties in
    manner and form aforesaid, against the peace and dignity of
    the said United States, and contrary to the form of the
    Statute in such cases made and provided.

    And the Jurors
    aforesaid, on their oath aforesaid, do further present that
    the said Theodore Parker was first apprehended in said
    District of Massachusetts, after committing the aforesaid
    offence, against the peace and dignity of the said United
    States, and contrary to the form of the statute in such case
    made and provided. A true bill.

    ENOCH PATTERSON, JR., Foreman.

    B.F. HALLETT, United States Attorney for the District of
    Massachusetts
    .

    Similar indictments were found against Mr. Phillips, Mr. Stowell, Rev.

    T.W. Higginson, John Morrison, Samuel T. Proudman, and John C. Cluer.

    Mr. Parker was arraigned on Wednesday, November 29th, and ordered to recognize in bonds of $1,500 for his appearance at that Court, on the 5th of March, 1855. His bondsmen were Messrs. Samuel May, Francis Jackson, and John R. Manley; his counsel were Hon. John P. Hale, and Charles M. Ellis, Esq. The other gentlemen were arraigned afterwards at different times.

    After considerable uncertainty about the engagements of Hon. Justice Curtis, Tuesday, April 3d, was fixed for the commencement of the trials. At that time there appeared as counsel for the government, Hon. Benjamin F. Hallett, District Attorney, and Elias Merwin, Esq., formerly a law partner of Judge Curtis; on the other side were Hon.

    John P. Hale, and Charles M. Ellis, Esq., for Mr. Parker; Wm. L. Burt, Esq., John A. Andrew, Esq., and H.F. Durant, Esq., counsel for Messrs.

    Phillips, Higginson, Stowell, Bishop, Morrison, Proudman, and Cluer.

    Mr. Hale, as senior counsel, stated to the court that the counsel for the defendants in several of the cases had conferred, and concluded--on the supposition that the Court and Government would assent to the plan as most for their own convenience, as well as that of the defendants' counsel--to file the like motion on the different cases; and, instead of each counsel going over the whole ground for each case, to divide the matter presented for debate, and for each to discuss some particular positions on behalf of them all. This was assented to; and motions, of which the following is a copy, were filed in the several cases:--

    CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES, MASSACHUSETTS DISTRICT,

    SS.

    United States by Indictment v. Theodore Parker.

    And now said Theodore Parker comes and moves that the
    indictment against him be quashed, because,

    "1. The writ of venire for the jury that found said
    indictment was directed to and returned by Watson Freeman,
    the Marshal, who was not an indifferent person, and it was
    not served and returned as the law directs.

    "2. Because said Jury was not an impartial Jury of the
    District, designated as the laws require, but the jury
    Districts for this court embrace but a portion of the
    District and of the population, and said jury was in fact
    chosen and designated from but a fraction of the District
    and contrary to law.

    "3. Because the matters and things alleged in said
    indictment do not constitute any crime under the statute on
    which said indictment is framed, the said statute not
    embracing them, or being, so far as it might embrace them,
    repealed by the statute of eighteen hundred and fifty.

    "4.

    Because said indictment does not allege and set forth
    fully and sufficiently the authority and the proceedings
    whereon the alleged warrant and order were based, or facts
    sufficient to show that the alleged process and order were
    lawfully issued by any person duly authorized, and his
    authority and jurisdiction, and that the same were within
    such jurisdiction, and issued by the authority of the law,
    and originated, issued, and directed as the law prescribes;
    said warrant and order not being alleged to have issued from
    any court or tribunal of general or special jurisdiction,
    but by a person vested with certain specific statute
    authority.

    "5. Because said indictment and the several counts thereof
    are bad on the face of them, as follows, viz.:--

    "First, it nowhere appearing that the same were found by a
    grand-jury, because the second and third counts do not
    conclude, against the form of the statute, and have no
    conclusion, because the third and fourth counts do not set
    forth the estate, degree, or mystery of the person therein
    charged.

    "Because said indictment and the counts thereof are
    repugnant and inconsistent, the same being based on an
    alleged obstruction, resistance, and opposition to the
    service of an action, order, or warrant, which is therein
    averred to have been already served, executed, and returned.

    "Because the first and fifth counts are double.

    "Because the alleged order of May 25th, referred to therein,
    was a void and illegal, order.

    "Because, if the alleged warrant was served as therein
    alleged, said Watson Freeman did not, and by law could not
    thereafter, hold the person described therein, under any
    process or order.

    "And because the same do not set forth and allege fully and
    specifically the acts charged to be offences against the
    statute, so as to inform said party charged, of the nature
    and cause of the accusation.

    "6. Because the warrant set forth and referred to therein
    was void on its face, and issued from and ran into a
    jurisdiction not authorized by law, and directed the arrest
    of a person without legal cause, and because said indictment
    is otherwise bad, uncertain, and insufficient."

    Mr. Wm. L. Burt commenced the argument of the motions, and presented several of the points. He was followed by Mr. C.M. Ellis, J.A. Andrew, and H.F. Durant, who severally discussed some of the grounds of the motions.

    Elias Merwin, Esquire, and Mr. Attorney Hallett, replied.

    The Court stated that they did not wish to hear Hon. John P. Hale, who was about to rejoin and close in support of the motion, and decided that the allegation, on the indictment, that Edward G. Loring was a Commissioner of the Circuit Court of the United States for said District, was not a legal averment that he was such a Commissioner as is described in the bill of 1850, and therefore the indictments were bad.

    The Court said they supposed it to be true that Mr. Loring was such a Commissioner, and that his authority could be proved by producing the record of his appointment; that they did not suppose the absence of this averment could be of any practical consequence to the defendants, so far as respected the substantial merits of the cases; and it was true the objection to the indictment was "technical;" but they held it sufficient, notwithstanding the averment that the warrant was "duly issued," and ordered the indictment against Stowell to be quashed.

    On every other point, save that that the Court could properly construct the Jury roster and return the Jury from a portion of the District, the Judge said they would express no opinion.

    Mr. Hallett insisted on his right to enter a nolle prosequi in the other cases; and the Judges decided that, though all the cases had been heard upon the motion, yet as it could make no difference whether an entry were made that this indictment be quashed, or an entry of nolle prosequi, the Attorney might enter a nolle prosequi if he chose to do so then, before the Court passed any order on the motions.

    Mr. Hallett accordingly entered a nolle prosequi in all the other cases, and the whole affair was quashed.[3]

    [Footnote 3: See Law Reporter for June, 1855.]

    DEFENCE.

    MAY IT PLEASE THE COURT:

    GENTLEMEN OF THE JURY.--It is no trifling matter which comes before you this day. You may hereafter decide on millions of money, and on the lives of your fellow men; but it is not likely that a question of this magnitude will ever twice be brought before the same jurymen.

    Opportunities to extend a far-reaching and ghastly wickedness, or to do great service for mankind, come but seldom in any man's life. Your verdict concerns all the people of the United States; its influence will reach to ages far remote, blessing or cursing whole generations not yet born. The affair is national in its width of reach,--its consequences of immense duration.

    In addressing you, Gentlemen, my language will be more didactic than rhetorical, more like a lecture, less like a speech; for I am not a lawyer but a minister, and do not aim to carry a Measure, which with you will go of its own accord, so much as to set forth a Principle that will make such prosecutions as impossible hereafter, as a conviction now is to-day.

    Gentlemen, I address you provisionally, as Representatives of the People. To them, my words are ultimately addressed,--to the People of the Free States of America. I must examine many things minutely, not often touched upon in courts like this. For mine is a Political Trial;

    I shall treat it accordingly. I am charged with no immoral act--with none even of selfish ambition. It is not pretended that I have done a deed, or spoken a word, in the heat of passion, or vengeance, or with calculated covetousness, to bring money, office, or honor, to myself or any friend. I am not suspected of wishing to do harm to man or woman; or with disturbing any man's natural rights. Nay, I am not even charged with such an offence. The Attorney and the two Judges are of one heart and mind in this prosecution; Mr.

    Hallett's "Indictment" is only the beast of burthen to carry to its own place Mr. Curtis's "Charge to the Grand-Jury," fit passenger for fitting carriage! The same tree bore the Judge's blossom in June, and the Attorney's fruit in October,--both reeking out the effluvia of the same substance. But neither Attorney nor Judge dares accuse me of ill-will which would harm another man, or of selfishness that seeks my own private advantage.

    No, Gentlemen of the Jury, I am on trial for my love of Justice; for my respect to the natural Rights of Man; for speaking a word in behalf of what the Declaration of Independence calls the "self-evident" Truth,--that all men have a natural, equal, and unalienable Right to Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness. I am charged with words against what John Wesley named, the "Sum of all Villanies," against a national crime so great, that it made freethinking Mr.

    Jefferson, with all his "French Infidelity," "tremble" when he remembered "that God is just." I am on trial for my manly virtue,--a Minister of the Christian Religion on trial for keeping the Golden Rule!

    It is alleged that I have spoken in Boston against kidnapping in Boston; that in my own pulpit, as a minister, I have denounced Boston men for stealing my own parishioners; that as a man, in Faneuil Hall, the spirit of James Otis, of John Hancock, and three Adams's about me, with a word I "obstructed" the Marshal of Boston and a Boston Judge of Probate, in their confederated attempts to enslave a Boston man.

    When the Government of the United States has turned kidnapper, I am charged with the "misdemeanor" of appealing from the Atheism of purchased officials to the Conscience of the People; and with rousing up Christians to keep the golden rule, when the Rulers declared Religion had nothing to do with politics and there was no Law of God above the fugitive slave bill!

    Such are the acts charged. Gentlemen of the Jury, you are summoned here to declare them a Crime, and then to punish me for this "offence!" You are the Axe which the Government grasps with red hand to cleave my head asunder. It is a trial where Franklin Pierce, transiently President of the United States, and his official coadjutors,--Mr. Caleb Cushing, Mr. Benj. R. Curtis, and Mr. Benj. F.

    Hallett,--are on one side, and the People of the United States on the other. As a Measure, your decision may send me to jail for twelve months; may also fine me three hundred dollars. To me personally it is of very small consequence what your verdict shall be. The fine is nothing; the imprisonment for twelve months--Gentlemen, I laugh at it!

    Nay, were it death, I should smile at the official gibbet. A verdict of guilty would affix no stain to my reputation. I am sure to come out of this trial with honor--it is the Court that is sure to suffer loss--at least shame. I do not mean the Court will ever feel remorse, or even shame, for this conduct; I am no young man now, I know these men,--but the People are sure to burn the brand of shame deep into this tribunal. The blow of that axe, if not parried, will do me no harm.

    But it is not I, merely, now put to trial. Nay, it is the unalienable Rights of Humanity, it is truths self-evident. For on the back of that compliant Measure, unseen, there rides a Principle. The verdict expected of you condemns liberal institutions: all Religion but priestcraft--the abnegation of religion itself; all Rights but that to bondage--the denial of all rights. The word which fines me, puts your own purse in the hands of your worst enemies; the many-warded key which shuts me in jail, locks your lips forever--your children's lips forever.

    No complaint against oppression hereafter! Kidnapping will go on in silence, but at noonday, not a minister stirring. Meeting-houses will be shut; all court houses have a loaded cannon at their door, chains all round them, be stuffed with foreign soldiers inside, while commissioners swear away the life, the liberty, and even the Estate of the subjected "citizens." All Probate Judges will belong to the family of man-stealers.

    Faneuil Hall will be shut, or open only for a "Union Meeting," where the ruler calls together his menials to indorse some new act of injustice,--only creatures of the Government, men like the marshal's guard last June, allowed to speak words paid for by the People's coward sweat and miserable blood. The blow which smites my head will also cleave you asunder from crown to groin.

    Your verdict is to vindicate Religion with Freedom of Speech, and condemn the stealing of men; or else to confirm Kidnapping and condemn Religion with Freedom of Speech. You are to choose whether you will have such men as Wendell Phillips for your advisers, or such as Benjamin F. Hallett and Benjamin R. Curtis for your masters, with the marshal's guard, for their appropriate servants. Do you think I doubt how you will choose?

    Already a power of iniquity clutches at your children's throat; stabs at their life--at their soul's life. I stand between the living tyrant and his living victim; aye, betwixt him and expected victims not yet born,--your children, not mine. I have none to writhe under the successful lash which tyrants now so subtly braid therewith, one day, to scourge the flesh of well-descended men. I am to stand the champion of human Rights for generations yet unborn. It is a sad distinction!

    Hard duties have before been laid on me,--none so obviously demanding great powers as this. Whereto shall I look up for inspiring aid? Only to Him who gave words to the slow tongue of Moses and touched with fire Esaias' hesitating lips, and dawned into the soul of tent-makers and fishermen with such great wakening light, as shining through them, brought day to nations sitting in darkness, yet waiting for the consolation. May such Truth and Justice enable me also, to speak a testimony unto the Gentiles; He who chose the weak things, to bring to nought the mighty, may not despise such humble services as mine.

    • * * * *

    Gentlemen of the Jury, my ministry deals chiefly with the Laws of God, little with the statutes of men. My manhood has been mainly passed in studying absolute, universal truth, teaching it to men, and applying it to the various departments of life. I have little to do with courts of law. Yet I am not now altogether a stranger to the circuit court room of the United States, having been in it on five several occasions before.

    1. A Polish exile,--a man of famous family, ancient and patrician

    before Christendom had laid eyes on America, once also of great individual wealth, a man of high rank alike acquired and inherited, once holding a high place at the court of the Czar,--became a fugitive from Russian despotism, seeking an asylum here; he came to the circuit court room to lecture on the Roman Law. I came to contribute my two mites of money, and receive his wealth of learning.

    1. The next time, I came at the summons of Thomas Sims. For a creature

    of the slave-power had spontaneously seized that poor and friendless boy and thrust him into a dungeon, hastening to make him a slave,--a beast of burthen. He had been on his mock trial seven days, and had never seen a Judge, only a commissioner, nor a Jury; no Court but a solitary kidnapper. Some of his attendants had spoken of me as a minister not heedless of the welfare and unalienable rights of a black man fallen among a family of thieves. I went to the court house.

    Outside it was belted with chains. In despotic Europe I had seen no such spectacle, save once when the dull tyrant who oppressed Bavaria with his licentious flesh, in 1844 put his capital in a brief state of siege and chained the streets. The official servant of the kidnapper, club in hand, a policeman of this city, goaded to his task by Mayor Bigelow and Marshal Tukey,--men congenitally mingled in such appropriate work,--bade me "Get under the chain." I pressed it down and went over.

    The Judges of our own Supreme Court, they went under,--had gone out and in, beneath the chain! How poetry mingles with fact! The chain was a symbol, and until this day remaineth the same chain, untaken away in the reading of the fugitive slave bill; and when the law of Massachusetts is read, the chain is also upon the neck of that court! Within the court house was full of armed men. I found Mr. Sims in a private room, illegally, in defiance of Massachusetts law, converted into a jail to hold men charged with no crime.

    Ruffians mounted guard at the entrance, armed with swords, fire-arms, and bludgeons. The door was locked and doubly barred besides. Inside the watch was kept by a horrid looking fellow, without a coat, a naked cutlass in his hand, and some twenty others, their mouths nauseous with tobacco and reeking also with half-digested rum paid for by the city.

    In such company, I gave what consolation Religion could offer to the first man Boston ever kidnapped,--consolations which took hold only of eternity, where the servant is free from his master, for there the wicked cease from troubling. I could offer him no comfort this side the grave.

    1. I visited the United States court a third time. A poor young man

    had been seized by the same talons which subsequently griped Sims in their poison, deadly clutch. But that time, wickedness went off hungry, defeated of its prey; "for the Lord delivered him out of their hands," and Shadrach escaped from that Babylonish furnace, heated seven times hotter than its wont: no smell of fire had passed on him.

    But the rescue of Shadrach was telegraphed as "treason." The innocent lightning flashed out the premeditated and legal lie,--"it is levying war!" What offence it was in that Fourth One who walked with the Hebrew children, "making their good confession," and sustained the old Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, I know not. But the modern countrymen of the African Shadrach, charged with some great crime, were haled into this court to be punished for their humanity! I came to look on these modern Angels of the Deliverance, to hear counsel of Mr.

    Dana, then so wise and humane, and to listen to the masterly eloquence which broke out from the great human heart of my friend, Mr. Hale, and rolled like the Mississippi, in its width, its depth, its beauty, and its continuous and unconquerable strength.

    1. The fourth time, a poor man had been kidnapped, also at night, and

    forced into the same illegal jail. He sat in the dock--an innocent man, to be made into a beast. The metamorphosis had begun;--he was already in chains and his human heart seemed dead in him; sixty ruffians were about him, aiding in this drama, hired out of the brothels and rum-shops for a few days, the lust of kidnapping serving to vary the continual glut of those other and less brutal appetites of unbridled flesh. While that "trial" lasted, whoredom had a Sabbath day, and brawlers rested from their toil.

    Opposite sat the Boston Judge of Probate, and the Boston District Attorney,--the Moses and Elias of this inverted transfiguration; there sat the marshal, two "gentlemen" from Virginia, claiming that a Boston man was their beast of burthen, owing service and labor in Richmond; two "lawyers," "members of the Suffolk bar," pistols in their coats, came to support the allegation and enforce the claim. Honorable men stood up to defend him. There is one of them,--to defend me [Charles M.

    Ellis.] You know very well the rest of that sad story,--the mock trial of Anthony Burns lasted from May 25th till June 2d. I was here in all the acts of that Tragedy. My own life was threatened; friend and foe gave me public or anonymous warning. I sat between men who had newly sworn to kill me, my garments touching theirs. The malaria of their rum and tobacco was an offence in my face. I saw their weapons, and laughed as I looked those drunken rowdies in their coward eye. They touch me!

    1. The fifth time I came here at the summons of an officer of this

    court,--very politely delivered, let me say it to his credit,--indicted and arrested for a "misdemeanor." I gave bail and withdrew.

    1. The sixth time,--Gentlemen,--it is the present, whereof I shall

    erelong have much to say.

    • * * * *

    At the first visit I found only scholarly and philanthropic gentlemen, coming out of sympathy with a Polish exile, a defeated soldier of freedom, from his broken English to learn sound Roman Law. On each of the other visits I have been in quite different company. I have invariably met this Honorable Court, its kinsfolk and its most intimate friends,--some member of the family of the distinguished Judge, now fitly presiding over this trial.

    1. It was Mr. George T. Curtis, the only brother of the honorable

    Justice now on the bench,--born of the same mother and father,--who had the glory of kidnapping Mr. Sims; it was he who seized Shadrach, and gave such witness against one of the Angels of the Deliverance, and then came back and enlarged his testimony; it was he who declared the rescue an act of "treason;" he who hung the court house in chains, and brought down the pliant neck of the Massachusetts Judges beneath that symbolic line of linked fetters long drawn out. To what weak forces will such necks bow when slavery commands!

    1. It was the honorable Judge now on the distinguished bench who tried

    men for the rescue of Shadrach. How he tried them is well known.

    1. It was Edward G. Loring, another of this family so distinguished,

    who kidnapped Mr. Burns and held him in irons; he whose broom swept up together the marshal's guard; he who advised Mr. Burns's counsel to make no defence,--"put no obstructions in the way of his going back, as he probably will;" he who, in the darkness of midnight, sought to sell his victim, before he had examined the evidence which might prove him a free man; he who delivered him up as a slave, against evidence as against law.

    1. Another of the same family, William W. Greenough, brother-in-law of

    Hon. Judge Curtis, was one of the grand-jury which found the indictment against me, and "the most active of all in that work."

    1. When I came here on the 29th of last November, the Hon. Judge

    Curtis sat on the bench and determined the amount of my bail, and the same eye which had frowned with such baleful aspect on the rescuers of Shadrach, quailed down underneath my look and sought the ground.

    • * * * *

    In thus mentioning my former visits to the court, I but relate the exploits of the Hon. Justice Curtis, of his kinsfolk and friends, adding to their glory and their renown. Their chief title to distinction rests on their devotion to the fugitive slave bill.

    It and their honor are "one and inseparable." Once only humanity and good letters brought me here, I met only scholars and philanthropists; on five other occasions, when assaults on freedom compelled my attendance, I have been confronted and surrounded with the loyalty of the distinguished Judge and his kinsfolk and friends, valiantly and disinterestedly obeying the fugitive slave bill "with alacrity;" patriotically conquering their prejudices against man-stealing--if such they ever had;--and earning for themselves an undying reputation by "saving the Union" from Justice, Domestic Tranquillity, general Welfare, and the Blessings of Liberty.

    If I am to be arraigned for any act, I regard it as a special good fortune that I am charged with such deeds, with seeking to arouse the noblest emotions of Human Nature; and by means of the grandest Ideas which Human History has brought to light. I could not have chosen nobler deeds in a life now stretching over nearly half a hundred years. I count it an honor to be tried for them. Nay, it adds to my happiness to look at the Court which is to try me--for if I were to search all Christendom through, nay, throughout all Heathendom, I know of no tribunal fitter to try a man for such deeds as I have done.

    I am fortunate in the charges brought; thrice fortunate in the judges and the attorney,--the Court which is to decide;--its history and character are already a judgment.

    1. For my sixth visit, I was recognized to appear on the fifth of

    March, 1855--the eighty-fifth anniversary of the Boston Massacre. I might have been bound over to any other of the great days of American history--22d of December, 19th of April, 17th of June, or the 4th of July. But as I am the first American ever brought to trial for a speech in Faneuil Hall against kidnapping; as I am the first to be tried under the act of 1790 for "obstructing an officer" with an argument, committing a "misdemeanor" by a word which appeals to the natural justice of mankind, so there could not perhaps be a fitter time chosen.

    For on the fifth of March, 1770, British despotism also delivered its first shot into the American bosom. Not far from this place the hand of George III. wounded to death five innocent citizens of Boston,--one of them a negro. It was the first shot Britain ever fired into the body of the American people, then colonial subjects of the king-power. That day the fire was not returned,--only with ringing of bells and tumult of the public, with words and resolutions. The next day that American blood lay frozen in the street.

    Soon after the British government passed a law exempting all who should aid an officer in his tyranny from trial for murder in the place where they should commit their crime. Mr. Toucey has humbly copied that precedent of despotism. It was very proper that the new tyranny growing up here, should select that anniversary to shoot down freedom of thought and speech among the subjects of the slave-power. I welcomed the omen. The Fifth of March is a red-letter day in the calendar of Boston.

    The Court could hardly have chosen a better to punish a man for a thought and a word, especially a Boston man, for such a word in Faneuil Hall--a word against man-stealing. But I knew the case would never come to trial on that day--of course it was put off.

    Mr. Sims and Mr. Burns were accused of no crime but birth from a mother whom some one had stolen. They had only a mock trial, without due process of law, with no judge, no jury, no judicial officer. But I, accused of a grave offence, am to enjoy a trial with due process of law. It is an actual judge before me and another judge at his side, both judicial officers known to the constitution. I know beforehand the decision of the court--its history is my judgment.

    Justice Curtis's Charge of last June, would make my daily talk a "misdemeanor," my public preaching and my private prayers a "crime," nay, my very existence is constructively an "obstruction" to the marshal. On that side my condemnation is already sure.

    But there is another element.

    Gentlemen of the Jury, the judges and attorney cannot lay their hand on me until you twelve men with one voice say, "Yes! put him in jail." In the mock trial of Sims and Burns it was necessary to convince only a single official of the United States Court, a "ministerial" officer selected and appointed to do its inferior business, a man who needed no conviction, no evidence but the oath of a slave-hunter and the extorted "admission" of his victim, an official who was to have ten dollars for making a slave, five only for setting free a man!

    But you are a Massachusetts Jury, not of purchased officials, but of honest men. I think you have some "prejudices" to conquer in favor of justice. It has not appeared that you are to be paid twice as much for sending me to jail, as for acquitting me of the charge. I doubt that you have yet advised my counsel to make no defence, "put no obstructions in the way" of my being sent to jail as "he probably will."

    Gentlemen, a United States Commissioner has his place on condition that he performs such services as his masters "require." These United States Judges have their seat in consequence of services rendered to the ruling power of America, and for others of like sort yet to be paid to the stealers of men. Other rewards shine before them alluring to new service,--additional salary can pay additional alacrity. But you, Gentlemen, are not office-holders nor seekers of office, not hoping to gain money, or power, or honor, by any wickedness. You are to represent the unsophisticated Conscience of the People,--not the slave-power, but the power of Freedom.

    It is to you I shall address my defence! MY defence? No, Gentlemen, YOUR defence, the defence of your own Rights, inherent in your national Institutions as Americans, ay, in your Nature as Men. It is a singular good fortune that to you, as judges, I am pleading your own cause. You have more interest at stake than I. For at death my name will perish, while children and children's children, I trust, will gently mingle your memories in that fair tide of human life which never ends.

    • * * * *

    So much have I said by way of introduction, treating only of the accidents pertaining to this case. I will now come to the Primary Qualities and Substance thereof.

    This is a Political Trial. In form, I am charged with violating a certain statute never before applied to actions like mine; never meant to apply to such actions; not legally capable of such application. But in fact, my offence is very different from what the indictment attempts to set forth. The judges know this; the attorney knows it, and "never expected to procure a conviction." It is your cause, even more than mine, that I plead. So it concerns you to understand the whole matter thoroughly, that you may justly judge our common cause.

    To make the whole case clear, I will land it out into four great parcels of matter, which your mind can command at once, and then come to the details of each, ploughing it all over before your face, furrow by furrow. I shall speak,

    I. Of the State of Affairs in America which has led to this prosecution,--the Encroachments of a Power hostile to Democratic Institutions.

    II. Of the Mode of Operation pursued by this Encroaching Power, in other times and in our own,--of Systematic Corruption of the Judiciary.

    III. Of the great Safeguard which has been found serviceable in protecting Democratic Institutions and the Rights of Man they are designed to defend,--of the Trial by Jury.

    IV. Of the Circumstances of this special case, UNITED STATES versus THEODORE PARKER.

    I shall speak of each in its order, and begin at the head.

    I. OF THE STATE OF AFFAIRS IN AMERICA, WHICH HAS LED TO THIS

    PROSECUTION--THE ENCROACHMENTS OF A POWER HOSTILE TO DEMOCRATIC

    INSTITUTIONS.

    In a republic where all emanates from the People, political institutions must have a Basis of Idea in the Nation's Thought, before they can acquire a Basis of Fact in the Force of the Nation. Now in America there are two diverse Ideas recognized as principles of Action--the Idea of Freedom and the Idea of Slavery. Allow me to read my analysis and description of each.

    The Idea of Freedom first got a national expression on the
    Fourth of July, 1776. Here it is. I put it in a philosophic
    form. There are five points to it.

    First, All men are endowed by their Creator with certain
    natural rights, amongst which is the right to life, liberty,
    and the pursuit of happiness.

    Second, These rights are unalienable; they can be alienated
    only by the possessor thereof; the father cannot alienate
    them for the son, nor the son for the father; nor the
    husband for the wife, nor the wife for the husband; nor the
    strong for the weak, nor the weak for the strong; nor the
    few for the many, nor the many for the few; and so on.

    Third, In respect to these, all men are equal; the rich man
    has not more, and the poor less; the strong man has not
    more, and the weak man less:--all are exactly equal in these
    rights, however unequal in their powers.

    Fourth, It is the function of government to secure these
    natural, unalienable, and equal rights to every man.

    Fifth, Government derives all its divine right from its
    conformity with these ideas, all its human sanction from the
    consent of the governed.

    That is the Idea of Freedom. I used to call it "the American
    Idea;" that was when I was younger than I am to-day. It is
    derived from human nature; it rests on the immutable Laws of
    God; it is part of the natural religion of mankind. It
    demands a government after natural Justice, which is the
    point common between the conscience of God and the
    conscience of mankind; it is the point common also between
    the interests of one man and of all men.

    Now this government, just in its substance, in its form must
    be democratic: that is to say, the government of all, by
    all, and for all. You see what consequences must follow from
    such an idea, and the attempt to reënact the Law of God into
    political institutions. There will follow the freedom of the
    people, respect for every natural right of all men, the
    rights of their body and of their spirit--the rights of mind
    and conscience, heart and soul.

    There must be some
    restraint--as of children by their parents, as of bad men by
    good men; but it will be restraint for the joint good of all
    parties concerned; not restraint for the exclusive benefit
    of the restrainer. The ultimate consequence of this will be
    the material and spiritual welfare of all--riches, comfort,
    noble manhood, all desirable things.

    That is the Idea of Freedom. It appears in the Declaration
    of Independence; it reappears in the Preamble to the
    American Constitution, which aims "to establish Justice,
    insure domestic tranquillity, provide for the common
    defence, promote the general welfare, and secure the
    blessings of Liberty." That is a religious idea; and when
    men pray for the "Reign of Justice" and the "Kingdom of
    Heaven" to come on earth politically, I suppose they mean
    that there may be a Commonwealth where every man has his
    natural rights of mind, body, and estate.

    • * * * *

    Next is the Idea of Slavery. Here it is. I put it also in a
    philosophic form. There are three points which I make.

    First, There are no natural, unalienable, and equal rights,
    wherewith men are endowed by their Creator; no natural,
    unalienable, and equal right to life, liberty, and the
    pursuit of happiness.

    Second, There is a great diversity of powers, and in virtue
    thereof the strong man may rule and oppress, enslave and
    ruin the weak, for his interest and against theirs.

    Third, There is no natural law of God to forbid the strong
    to oppress the weak, and enslave and ruin the weak.

    That is the Idea of Slavery. It has never got a national
    expression in America; it has never been laid down as a
    Principle in any act of the American people, nor in any
    single State, so far as I know. All profess the opposite;
    but it is involved in the Measures of both State and Nation.
    This Idea is founded in the selfishness of man; it is
    atheistic.

    The idea must lead to a corresponding government; that will
    be unjust in its substance,--for it will depend not on
    natural right, but on personal force; not on the
    Constitution of the Universe, but on the compact of men. It
    is the abnegation of God in the universe and of conscience
    in man. Its form will be despotism,--the government of all,
    by a part, for the sake of a part.

    It may be a single-headed
    despotism, or a despotism of many heads; but whether a
    Cyclops or a Hydra, it is alike "the abomination which
    maketh desolate." Its ultimate consequence is plain to
    foresee--poverty to a nation, misery, ruin.

    • * * * *

    These two Ideas are now fairly on foot. They are hostile;
    they are both mutually invasive and destructive. They are in
    exact opposition to each other, and the nation which
    embodies these two is not a figure of equilibrium.

    As both
    are active forces in the minds of men, and as each idea
    tends to become a fact--a universal and exclusive fact,--as
    men with these ideas organize into parties as a means to
    make their idea into a fact,--it follows that there must not
    only be strife amongst philosophical men about these
    antagonistic Principles and Ideas, but a strife of practical
    men about corresponding Facts and Measures. So the quarrel,
    if not otherwise ended, will pass from words to what seems
    more serious; and one will overcome the other.

    So long as these two Ideas exist in the nation as two
    political forces, there is no national unity of Idea, of
    course no unity of action. For there is no centre of gravity
    common to Freedom and Slavery. They will not compose an
    equilibrious figure. You may cry "Peace! Peace!" but so long
    as these two antagonistic Ideas remain, each seeking to
    organize itself and get exclusive power, there is no peace;
    there can be none.

    The question before the nation to-day is, Which shall
    prevail--the Idea and Fact of Freedom, or the Idea and the
    Fact of Slavery; Freedom, exclusive and universal, or
    Slavery, exclusive and universal? The question is not
    merely, Shall the African be bond or free? but, Shall
    America be a Democracy or a Despotism? For nothing is so
    remorseless as an idea, and no logic is so strong as the
    historical development of a national idea by millions of
    men. A measure is nothing without its Principle. The Idea
    which allows Slavery in South Carolina will establish it
    also in New England.

    The bondage of a black man in
    Alexandria imperils every white woman's daughter in Boston.
    You cannot escape the consequences of a first Principle more
    than you can "take the leap of Niagara and stop when
    half-way down." The Principle which recognizes Slavery in
    the Constitution of the United States would make all America
    a Despotism, while the Principle which made John Quincy
    Adams a free man would extirpate Slavery from Louisiana and
    Texas. It is plain America cannot long hold these two
    contradictions in the national consciousness. Equilibrium
    must come.[4]

    [Footnote 4: See this statement in Mr. Parker's Additional Speeches, Addresses, and Occasional Sermons. Boston, 1855, vol. ii. p. 250, et seq.]

    These two ideas are represented by two parties which aim at the ultimate organization of their respective doctrines, the party indicating the special tendency towards Democracy or Despotism. The Party of Freedom is not yet well organized; that of Slavery is in admirable order and discipline. These two parties are continually at war attended with various success.

    1. In the individual States of the North, since the Revolution, the

    Party of Freedom has gained some great victories; it has abolished Personal Slavery in every northern State, and on a deep-laid foundation has built up Democratic Institutions with well proportioned beauty. The Idea of Freedom, so genial to the Anglo-Saxon, so welcome to all of Puritanic birth and breeding, has taken deep root in the consciousness of the great mass of the People at the North. In the severe simplicity of national deduction they will carry it to logical conclusions not yet foreseen by human providence. The free States are progressively democratic.

    But in all the Northern States, and more especially in its cities,--and here chiefly among the men of exclusive intellectual culture and the votaries of commerce and its riches,--there are exceptional men who embrace the Idea of Slavery and belong to its Party. They know no law higher than the transient interest of their politics or their commerce, their ease or ambition. They may not theoretically hate the People, but they so love their own money, their own ease or pleasure, that practically they oppose what promotes the welfare of mankind, and seek their own personal advancement to the injury of the human race.

    These are Northern men with Southern "Principles." They have their Journals too well known in Boston to need mention here.

    1. In the individual States of the South, the Idea and Party of

    Slavery has also gained great victories and been uniformly successful; it has extended and strengthened personal slavery, which has now a firmer hold in the minds of the controlling classes of Southern men,--the rich and "educated,"--than in 1776, or ever before. The Southern States are progressively despotic.

    Still, in all the Southern States there are exceptional men, hostile to slavery,--the intelligent and religious from conviction, others from mere personal interest. These are Southern men with Northern Principles. They are much oppressed at home--kept from political advancement or social respectability, as much as democrats would be at Rome or Naples,--have no journals and little influence.

    1. In the Federal Government, the warfare goes on, each party seeking

    for mastery over the whole United States--the contest is carried on in Congress, in all the local legislatures; newspapers, speeches, even sermons, resound with the din of battle. See what forces contend and with what results.

    The nation lives by its productive industry, whereof there are these five chief departments:--Hunting and Fishing, the appropriation of the spontaneous live products of the land and sea; Agriculture, the use of the productive forces of the earth's surface; Mining, the appropriation of the metallic products of her bosom; Manufactures, the application of toil and thought to the products of Hunting and Fishing, Mining and Agriculture; Commerce, the exchange of value, distribution of the products of these four departments of industry, directly productive.

    Hunting and Fishing, Mining, Manufactures, Commerce, are mainly in the hands of Northern men--the South is almost wholly Agricultural. Her wealth consists of land and slaves. In 1850 the fifteen slave States had not fourteen hundred millions of other property. In the South property, with its consequent influence, is in few hands--in the North it is wide spread.

    Now the few controlling men of the South, the holders of land and slaves, have Unity of pecuniary Interest--the support of Slavery as a local measure,--for it is the source of their material wealth, and also a consequent Unity of political Idea, the support of Slavery as a universal Principle, for it is the source likewise of their political power. Accordingly the South presents against the North an even and well-disciplined front of veteran soldiers, is always hostile to Freedom, and as her "best educated" men devote much time to politics, making it the profession of their whole lives, it is plain they become formidable antagonists.

    But the North has a great variety of conflicting interests, a great amount of intellectual activity, where education and its consequent habits of reading and thinking are so wide spread, and therefore a great variety of opinion. Accordingly there is not the same Unity of pecuniary Interest and of political Idea, which distinguishes the South. Besides, in the North the ablest and best educated men do not devote their time to the thankless and stormy calling of politics;

    Virginia cares for nothing but Negroes and Politics, her loins and her brains gender but this twofold product: Massachusetts and New York care for much beside. So the North does not present against the South an even and well-disciplined front of veteran soldiers, but a ragged, discordant line of raw recruits, enlisting for a short time with some special or even personal local interest to serve.

    What makes the matter yet worse for us, Gentlemen of the Jury, is this: While the great mass of the people at the North, engrossed in direct productive industry, are really hostile to slavery, those absorbed in the large operations of commerce, taken as a whole class, feel little interest in the Idea of Freedom; nay, they are positively opposed to it.

    Before the African Slave-trade was treated like other kindred forms of piracy, as a capital crime, they had their ships in that felonious traffic; and now their vessels engage in the American Slave-trade and their hand still deals in the bodies of their fellow men.

    In all the great commercial cities, like Philadelphia, New York and Boston these men prevail, and are the "eminent citizens," overslaughing the press, the pulpit, the bar, and the court, with the Ideas of their lower law, and sweeping along all metropolitan and suburban fashion and respectability in their slimy flood. Hence the great cities of the North, governed by the low maxims of this class, have become the asylum of Northern men with Southern "Principles," and so the strong-hold of Slavery.

    And hitherto these great cities have controlled the politics of the Northern States, crowding the Apostles of Freedom out from the national board, and helping the party of slavery to triumph in all great battles.

    Thus aided, for many years the South has always elected her candidate for the Presidency by the vote of the people. But the American Executive is twofold,--part Presidential, part Senatorial. Sometimes these two Executives are concordant, sometimes discordant. The Senatorial Executive has always carried the day against the less permanent Presidential power, except in the solitary case where General Jackson's unconquerable will and matchless popularity enabled him to master the senate itself, who "registered" his decrees, or "expunged" their own censure, just as the iron ruler gave orders.

    Now by means of the control which the Northern Cities have over the Northern States, and such Commercial Men over those cities, it has come to pass that not only the Presidential, but also the Senatorial Executive, has long been hostile to the Idea of Freedom.

    Gentlemen of the Jury, the direct consequence is obvious,--the Party of Slavery has long been the conqueror in the field of Federal politics. In the numerous and great conflicts between the two, Freedom has prevailed against Slavery only twice since the close of the Revolutionary War,--in prohibiting involuntary servitude in the North-west Territory in 1787, and in the abolition of the African Slave-trade in 1808. Her last triumph was forty-seven years ago,--nay, even that victory was really achieved twenty years before at the adoption of the constitution. In this warfare we have not gained a battle for freedom since 1788!

    For a time it seemed doubtful which would triumph, though Slavery gained Kentucky and Tennessee, and Louisiana was purchased as slave soil in 1803.

    But in 1820 slavery became the obvious and acknowledged master in the Federal Territory, marched victorious over the Mississippi, planted itself in Missouri, and has subsequently taken possession of Mississippi, Alabama and Arkansas, all slave States; has purchased Florida; "reannexed" Texas; conquered Utah, New Mexico and California, all slave soil; and from Freedom and the North has just now reconquered Kansas and Nebraska. Ever since the Missouri Compromise in 1820 Slavery has been really the master, obviously so since the annexation of Texas in 1845.

    The slave-power appoints all the great national officers, executive, diplomatic, judicial, naval and military,--it controls the legislative departments. Look at this Honorable Court, Gentlemen, and recognize its power!

    The idea of Slavery must be carried out to its logical consequence, so our masters now meditate two series of Measures, both necessary to the development of Slavery as a Principle.

    (I.) African Slavery is to be declared a Federal Institution, national and sectional, and so extended into all the Territories of the United States.

    New soil is to be bought or plundered from Hayti, Spain, Mexico, South America "and the rest of mankind," that slavery may be planted there; that is the purpose of all the Official Fillibustering of the Government, and the Extra-official Fillibustering which it starts, or allows; Quitman "Enterprises," Kinney "Expeditions," Black Warrior and El Dorado "difficulties," all point to this; the "Ostend Conference" is a step in that direction; Slavery is to be restored to the so called "Free States," reëstablished in all the North.

    That is the design of the fugitive slave bill in 1850, and the kidnapping of northern men consequent thereon for the last five years; of President Pierce's inaugural declarations in behalf of slavery in 1853; of Mr.

    Toombs's threat in 1854, that "soon the master with his slaves will sit down at the foot of Bunker Hill Monument;" of Mr. Toucey's Bill in 1855, providing that when a kidnapper violates the local laws of any State, he shall be tried by the fugitive slave bill court. Then the African Slave-trade is to be restored by federal enactments, or judicial decisions of the "Supreme Court of the United States." All these steps belong to Measure number One. The Supreme Court is ready to execute the commands of its lord. Soon you will see more "decisions" adverse to humanity.

    (II.) The next movement is progressively to weaken and ultimately to destroy the Democratic Institutions of the North,--yes, also of the South. This design is indicated and sustained by some of the measures already mentioned as connected with the first purpose.

    To this point tend the words of President Pierce addressed to the soldiers of 1812 on the 8th of January 1855, in which he speaks of such as "disseminate political heresies," that is, the Idea of Freedom; "revile the government,"--expose its hostility against the unalienable Rights of man; "deride our institutions,"--to wit, the patriarchal institution of Slavery; "sow political dissensions,"--advise men not to vote for corrupt tools of the government; "set at defiance the laws of the land,"--meaning the fugitive slave bill which commands kidnapping.

    There belong the attempts of the Federal courts to enlarge their jurisdiction at the expense of State Rights; the cry, "Union first and Liberty afterwards;" the shout "No higher law," "Religion nothing to do with Politics."

    Thence come the attacks made on the freedom of the pulpit, of the press, and all freedom of speech. The Individual State which preserves freedom must be put down,--the individual person who protests against it must be silenced. No man must hold a federal office,--executive, diplomatic, judicial, or "ministerial,"--unless he has so far conquered his "prejudices" in favor of the natural Rights of man that he is ready to enslave a brother with alacrity. All these steps belong to Measure number Two.

    This latter Measure advances to its execution, realizing the Idea of Slavery, with subtle steps, yet creeps on rapid-moving feet. See how it has gained ground latterly. Obviously the fugitive slave bill struck only at the natural Rights of Colored men--as valuable as those of white men, but the colored are few and the white many,--the experiment must be made on the feebler body. But this despotism cannot enslave a black girl without thereby putting in peril the liberty of every white man.

    At first our masters only asked of Boston a little piece of chain, but just long enough to shackle the virtuous hands of Ellen Craft, a wife and mother, whom her Georgian "owner" wished to sell as a harlot at New Orleans! A meeting was summoned at Faneuil Hall, and Boston answered, "Yes, here is the chain. Let the woman-hunter capture Ellen Craft, make her a Prostitute at New Orleans. She is a virtuous wife and mother,--but no matter. Slavery is king and commands it. Let the 'owner' have his chain."

    There is no escaping the consequence of a first Principle. Soon that little chain lengthened itself out, and coiled itself all round the court house, and how greedily your judges stooped to go under!

    This Anaconda of the Dismal Swamp wound its constricting twists about the neck of all your courts, and the Judges turned black in the face, and when questioned of law, they could not pronounce "Habeas Corpus," "Trial by Jury," nor utter a syllable for the Bible or the Massachusetts Constitution, but only wheeze and gurgle and squeak and gibber out their defences of Slavery!

    No, Boston could not bewray a woman wandering towards freedom, without chaining the court house and its judges, putting the town in a state of siege,--insolent soldiers striking at the people's neck. Now the attempt is making by this Honorable Court to put the same chain round Faneuil Hall, so that the old Cradle of Liberty shall no more rock to manhood the noble sons of freedom, but only serve as a nest that the spawn of Bondage may hibernate therein.

    I am on trial because I hate Slavery, because I love freedom for the black man, for the white man, and for all the human Race. I am not arraigned because I have violated the statute on which the indictment is framed--no child could think it--but because I am an advocate of Freedom, because my Word, my Thoughts, my Feelings, my Actions, nay, all my Life, my very Existence itself, are a protest against Slavery.

    Despotism cannot happily advance unless I am silenced. It is very clear logic which indicts me. Private personal malice, deep, long cherished, rancorous, has doubtless jagged and notched and poisoned too the public sword which smites at my neck. Still it is the public sword of Slavery which is wielded against me. Against ME? Against YOU quite as much--against your children.

    For as Boston could not venture to kidnap a negro woman, without bringing down that avalanche of consequences connected with the Principle of Slavery,--without chains on her Judges, falsehood in her officers, blood in her courts, and drunken soldiers in her streets, and hypocrisy in her man-hunting ministers,--no more can she put me to silence alone. The thread which is to sew my lips together, will make your mouths but a silent and ugly seam in your faces. Slavery is Plaintiff in this case; Freedom Defendant.

    Before you as Judges, I plead your own cause--for you as defendant. I will not insult you by the belief or the fear that you can do other than right, in a matter where the law is so plain, and the Justice clear as noonday light. But should you decide as the wicked wish, as the court longs to instruct you, you doom your mouths to silence; you bow your manly faces to the ground, destine your memories to shame, and your children to bondage worse than negro slavery.

    • * * * *

    Such, Gentlemen of the Jury, is the state of affairs leading to this Prosecution--such the past, present, and prospective Encroachments of a Power hostile to Democratic Institutions and the unalienable Rights they were designed to protect. Such also are the two Measures now in contemplation,--the Extension of African Bondage, and the Destruction of American Freedom.

    II. LOOK NEXT AT THE MODE OF OPERATION HITHERTO PURSUED BY THIS

    ENCROACHING POWER, IN OTHER TIMES AND NATIONS, AND IN OUR OWN,

    SYSTEMATIC CORRUPTION OF THE JUDICIARY.

    Here I shall show the process by which that Principle of Slavery becomes a Measure of political ruin to the People.

    In substance Despotism is always the same, Spanish or Carolinian, but the form varies to suit the ethnologic nature and historical customs of different people. I shall mention two forms--one to illustrate, the other to warn.

    (I.) The open Assumption of Power by military violence. This method is followed in countries where love of Individual Liberty is not much developed in the consciousness of the people, and where democratic institutions are not fixed facts in their history; where the nation is not accustomed to local self-government, but wonted to a strong central power directed by a single will. This form prevails in Russia, Turkey, and among all the Romanic tribes in Europe, and their descendants in America. Military usurpation, military rule is indigenous in France,--where two Napoleons succeed thereby,--in Italy, in Spain, and most eminently in Spanish America.

    But no people of the Teutonic family for any length of time ever tolerated a usurping soldier at the head of affairs, or submitted to martial arbitrary rule, or military violence in the chief magistrate. It is against our habit and disposition.

    Neither Cromwell nor William of Orange could do with the Anglo-Saxon what it would have been impossible not to do with Spaniards or Italians. Even warlike Swiss--Teutonic tribes--will have a government with due process of law, not by the abrupt violence of the soldier.

    Washington could not have established a military monarchy in America had he been so wickedly disposed. Even William the Conqueror must rule the Saxons by Saxon law.

    (II.) The corruption of the acknowledged safeguards of public security. This is attempted in nations who have a well-known love of individual liberty, and institutional defences thereof, the habit of Local Self-government by Democratic Law-making and Law-administering.

    For example, this experiment has been repeatedly made in England. The monarch seeking to destroy the liberty of the people, accomplishes his violent measure by the forms of peaceful law, by getting the judicial class of men on the side of despotism. Then all the wickedness can be done in the name, with the forms, and by "due process" of law, by regular officers thereof--done solemnly with the assistance of slow and public deliberation.

    Gentlemen of the Jury, this is a matter of such importance to the People of America just now, that I must beg you to bear with me while I explain this subtle operation. I will select examples from the history of England which are easy to understand, because her blood is kindred to our own, and the institutions of the two countries are related as parent and child. And besides, her past history affords alike warning and guidance in our present peril.

    • * * * *

    (I.) The first step in this process of political iniquity is, to appoint men for judges and other officers of the court, who know no law higher than the selfish will of the hand that feeds them, mere creatures of the rest [Transcriber's Note: for 'rest' read 'government'; see Errata].

    I will select instances of this from the reign of the Stuart kings and one of their successors, from a period full of melancholy warning to America.

    I will begin with James I. (1603-1625), the first King of New England.

    At his very accession he had high notions of his royal Prerogative, and maintained that all the privileges of the House of Commons were derived from his royal grant. "I am your King," said he, "I am placed to govern you, and I shall [must] answer for your errors." It was quite enough to answer for his own,--poor man. "Let me make the Judges," said he, "and I care not who makes the laws."

    Accordingly for judicial officers he appointed such men as would execute his unlawful schemes for the destruction of public liberty. To such considerations was Francis Bacon mainly indebted for his elevation from one legal rank to another, until he reached the seat of the Lord Chancellor.

    A man whom Villers declared, "of excellent parts, but withal of a base and ungrateful temper, and an arrant knave, yet a fit instrument for the purposes of the government." He did not receive his appointment for that vast, hard-working genius which makes his name the ornament of many an age, but only for his sycophantic devotion to the royal will.

    Sir Edward Coke was promoted rapidly enough, whilst wholly subservient to the despotic court, but afterwards, though a miracle of legal knowledge, not equalled yet perhaps, he must not be appointed Lord Chancellor on account of "his occasional fits of independence." Chief Justice Ley was one of the right stamp, but it was thought "his subserviency might prove more valuable by retaining him to preside over the Court of King's Bench." "For in making the highest judicial appointments the only question was, what would suit the arbitrary schemes of governing the country."[5] Hobart had resisted some illegal monopolies of the all-powerful Buckingham, and he was "unfit for promotion."

    [Footnote 5: 2 Campbell, 372, 374.]

    James thought the Prerogative would be strengthened by the appointment of clergymen of the national church, perhaps the only class of men not then getting fired with love of liberty,--and made Williams, Bishop of Lincoln, Lord Keeper, a "man of rash and insolent, though servile temper, and of selfish, temporizing, and trimming political conduct," who at that time had never acted as "a judge except at the Waldegrave Petty Sessions in making an order of bastardy or allowing a rate for the Parish poor," and was "as ignorant of the questions coming before him as the door-keepers of his court." But he was subservient, and had pleased the King by preaching the courtly doctrine that "subjects hold their liberties and their property at the will of the Sovereign whom they are bound in every extremity passively to obey."[6] Men like Fleming and other creatures of the throne, sanctioning the King's abundant claim to absolute power, were sure of judicial distinction; while it was only the force of public opinion which gave the humblest place of honor to such able and well-studied lawyers as would respect the constitutional Rights of the People and the just construction of the laws, and at all hazards maintain their judicial independence.

    Ecclesiastics who taught that the King "is above the laws by his absolute power," and "may quash any law passed by Parliament," were sure of rapid preferment. Thus Bancroft was promoted; thus Abbot was pushed aside; and for his mean, tyrannical and subservient disposition Rev. William Laud was continually promoted in expectation of the services which, as Archbishop, he subsequently performed in the overthrow of the Liberty of the People. But time would fail me to read over the long dark list of men whose personal shame secured them "official glory."

    [Footnote 6: 2 Campbell, 368, 374; 3 Howell State Trials, 824.]

    In his address to the Judges in the Star-Chamber in 1616 James gave them this charge, "If there falls out a question which concerns any Prerogative or mysterie of State, deale not with it till you consult with the King or his Council, or both; for they are Transcendent Matters, and must not be slibberly carried with over rash wilfullnesse." "And this I commend unto your special care, as some of you of late have done very much, to blunt the edge and vaine popular humor of some lawyers at the Barre, that think they are not eloquent and bold-spirited enough, except they meddle with the King's Prerogative." "That which concerns the mysterie of the King's Power is not lawful to be disputed."[7] Gentlemen, that was worthy of some judicial charges which you and I have heard.

    [Footnote 7: Speache in the Starre-Chamber, London, 1616.]

    • * * * *

    Charles I. (1625-1659,) pursued the same course of tyranny by the same steps. Coventry could be implicitly relied on to do as commanded, and was made Lord Keeper in 1625.

    When the question of Ship-money was to be brought forward in 1636, Chief Justice Heath was thought not fit to be trusted with wielding the instrument of tyranny, and accordingly removed; "and Finch, well known to be ready to go all lengths, was appointed in his place." For he had steadfastly maintained that the King was absolute, and could dispense with law and parliament,--a fit person to be a Chief Justice, or a Lord Chancellor, in a tyrant's court, ready to enact iniquity into law.

    His compliance with the King's desire to violate the first principle of Magna Charta, "endeared him to the Court, and secured him further preferment as soon as any opportunity should occur." So he was soon made Lord Chancellor and raised to the peerage. Littleton had once been on the popular side, but deserted and went over to the Court--he was sure of preferment; and as he became more and more ready to destroy the liberties of the People, he was made Chief Justice, and finally Lord Chancellor in 1641.

    Lane was a "steady friend of the prerogative," and so was made Attorney-General to the Prince of Wales, and thence gradually elevated to the highest station.

    Other Judicial appointments were continually made in the same spirit.

    Thus when Sir Randolf Crewe was Chief Justice of the King's Bench, the government questioned him to ascertain if he were "sound," and were shocked to hear him declare that the King had no right to levy taxes without consent of Parliament, or imprison his subjects without due process of law. He was "immediately dismissed from his office," (1626,) and Sir Nicolas Hyde appointed in his place. By such means the courts were filled with tools of the King or his favorites, and the pit digged for the liberties of the People, into which at last there fell--the head of the King!

    • * * * *

    Charles II. and James II., (1655-1686,) did not mend the evil, but appointed for judges "such a pack as had never before sat in Westminster Hall." Shaftesbury and Guildford had the highest judicial honors. Lord Chancellor Finch, mentioned already, had been accused by the Commons of High Treason and other misdemeanors, but escaped to the continent, and returned after the Restoration. He was appointed one of the Judges to try the Regicides.

    Thus he "who had been accused of high treason twenty years before by a full parliament, and who by flying from their justice saved his life, was appointed to judge some of those who should have been his Judges."[8] He declared in Parliament that Milton, for services rendered to the cause of liberty while Latin Secretary to Cromwell, "deserved hanging."[9]

    [Footnote 8: Ludlow, quoted in 2 Campbell, 470.]

    [Footnote 9: 4 Parl. Hist. 162.]

    In these reigns such men as Saunders, Wright, and Scroggs, were made Judges, men of the vilest character, with the meanest appetites, licentious, brutal, greedy of power and money, idiotic in the moral sense, appointed solely that they might serve as tools for the oppression of the People.

    Among these infamous men was George Jeffreys, of whom Lord Campbell says,--"He has been so much abused that I began my critical examination of his history in the hope and belief that I should find that his misdeeds had been exaggerated, and that I might be able to rescue his memory from some portion of the obloquy under which it labors; but I am sorry to say that in my matured opinion his cruelty and his political profligacy have not been sufficiently exposed or reprobated; and that he was not redeemed from his vices by one single solid virtue."[10] But in consequence of his having such a character, though not well-grounded in law, he was made a Judge, a Peer, and a Lord Chancellor!

    Wright, nearly as infamous, miraculously stupid and ignorant, "a detected swindler, knighted and clothed in ermine, took his place among the twelve judges of England."[11] He also was made Chief Justice successively of the Common Pleas and the King's Bench!

    Lord Campbell, himself a judge, at the end of his history of the reign of Charles and James, complains of "the irksome task of relating the actions of so many men devoid of political principle and ready to suggest or to support any measures, however arbitrary or mischievous, for the purpose of procuring their own advancement."[12] It was the practice of the Stuarts "to dismiss judges without seeking any other pretence, who showed any disposition to thwart government in political prosecutions."[13] Nor was this dismissal confined to cases where the judge would obey the law in merely Political trials.

    In 1686 four of the judges denied that the king had power to dispense with the laws of the land and change the form of religion: the next morning they were all driven from their posts, and four others, more compliant, were appointed and the judicial "opinion was unanimous." Hereupon Roger Coke says well,--"the king ... will make the judges in Westminster Hall to murder the common law, as well as the king and his brother desired to murder the parliament by itself; and to this end the king, when he would make any judges would make a bargain with them, that they should declare the king's power of dispensing with the penal laws and tests made against recusants, out of parliament."[14]

    [Footnote 10: 3 Campbell, 394.]

    [Footnote 11: 2 Campbell Chief Justices, 86.]

    [Footnote 12: 3 Campbell, 473.]

    [Footnote 13: 3 Hallam, 142.]

    [Footnote 14: 8 St. Tr. 195, note.]

    • * * * *

    Here, Gentlemen of the Jury, I must mention three obscure judges who received their appointments under Stuart kings. Before long I shall speak of their law and its application, and now only introduce them to you as a measure preliminary to a more intimate acquaintance hereafter.

    1. The first is Sir William Jones, by far the least ignoble of the

    three. He was descended from one of the Barons who wrung the Great Charter from the hands of King John in 1618 [Transcriber's Note: for '1618' read '1215'; see Errata], and in 1628 dwelt in the same house which sheltered the more venerable head of his Welsh ancestor. In 1628 he was made judge by Charles I.

    He broke down the laws of the realm to enable the king to make forced loans on his subjects, and by his special mandate (Lettre de Cachet) to imprison whom he would, as long as it pleased him, and without showing any reason for the commitment or the detention! Yes, he supported the king in his attempt to shut up members of parliament for words spoken in debate in the house of commons itself; to levy duties on imports, and a tax of ship-money on the land.

    He was summoned before parliament for his offences against public justice, and finally deprived of office, though ungratefully, by the king himself.[15]

    [Footnote 15: Account of him in Preface to his Reports, (1675); 3 St.

    Tr. 162, 293, 844, 1181; 2 Parl. Hist. 869; 1 Rushworth, 661, et al.; Whitlocke, 14, et al.]

    1. Thomas Twysden was counsel for George Coney in 1655, a London

    merchant who refused to pay an illegal tax levied on him by Cromwell--who followed in the tyrannical footsteps of the king he slew. Twysden was thrown into the Tower for defending his client--as Mr. Sloane, at Sandusky, has just been punished by the honorable court of the United States for a similar offence,--but after a few days made a confession of his "error," defending the just laws of the land, promised to offend no more, and was set at liberty, ignominiously leaving his client to defend himself and be defeated. This Twysden was made judge by Charles II.

    The reporters recording his decisions put down "Twysden in furore," thinly veiling the judicial wrath in modest Latin. He was specially cruel against Quakers and other dissenters, treating George Fox, Margarett Fell, and John Bunyan with brutal violence.[16]

    [Footnote 16: 6 St. Tr. 634; 1 Campbell Justices, 442.]

    1. Sir John Kelyng is another obscure judge of those times. In the

    civil war he was a violent cavalier, and "however fit he might be to charge the Roundheads under Prince Rupert, he was very unfit to charge a jury in Westminster Hall." In 1660 he took part in the trial of the Regicides and led in the prosecution of Colonel Hacker, who in 1649 had charge of the execution of Charles I.

    In 1662 he took part in the prosecution of Sir Henry Vane, and by his cruel subtlety in constructing law, that former governor of Massachusetts,--one of the most illustrious minds of England, innocent of every crime, was convicted of high treason and put to death.[17] For this service, in 1663 Kelyng was made a judge; and then, by loyal zeal and judicial subserviency, he made up "for his want of learning and sound sense."

    But he was so incompetent that even the court of Charles II. hesitated to make him more than a puny judge. But he had been a "valiant cavalier," and had done good service already in making way with such as the king hated, and so after the death of Sir Nicolas Hyde, he was made Lord Chief Justice in his place. "In this office," says Judge Campbell, he "exceeded public expectation by the violent, fantastical, and ludicrous manner in which he conducted himself."[18] But I will not now anticipate what I have to say of him in a subsequent part of this defence.

    [Footnote 17: 6 St. Tr. 161.]

    [Footnote 18: 1 Campbell Justices, 401.]

    Gentlemen of the Jury, we shall meet these three together again before long, and I shall also speak of them "singly or in pairs." In the mean time I will mention one similar appointment in the reign of George the III.--the last king of New England.

    • * * * *

    In 1770 Sergeant Glynn, in Parliament, moved for an inquiry into the administration of criminal justice. Edmund Thurlow, a rough venal man, then recently appointed solicitor-general, proposed that a severe censure should be passed on him for the motion. Thurlow wanted the trial by jury abolished in all cases of libel, so that the liberty of the people should be in the exclusive care of government attorneys and judges appointed by the crown. Hear him speak on the 6th of December, 1770.

    "In my opinion no man should be allowed with impunity to
    make a wanton attack upon such venerable characters as the
    judges of the land. We award costs and damages to the
    aggrieved party in the most trifling actions. By what
    analogy, then, can we refuse the same justice in the most
    important cases, to the most important personages? If we
    allow every pitiful patriot thus to insult us with
    ridiculous accusations, without making him pay forfeit for
    his temerity, we shall be eternally pestered with the
    humming and buzzing of these stingless wasps. Though they
    cannot wound or poison, they will tease and vex.

    They will
    divert our attention from the important affairs of State to
    their own mean antipathies, and passions, and prejudices.
    Did they not count upon the spirit of the times and imagine
    that the same latitude which is taken by the libellers is
    here allowable, they would not have dared to offer so gross
    an outrage. I hope we shall now handle them so roughly as to
    make this the last of such audacious attempts. They are
    already ridiculous and contemptible. To crown their
    disgrace, let us inflict some exemplary punishment. Else
    none of us is safe.

    Virtue and honor, you see from this
    instance, are no safeguard from their attacks."

    "The nature, the direct effect, and the remote consequences
    of a State libel, are so complicated and involved with
    various considerations of great pith and moment, that few
    juries can be adequate judges. So many circumstances are at
    once to be kept in view, so many ponderous interests are to
    be weighed, so many comparisons to be made, and so many
    judgments formed, that the mind of an ordinary man is
    distracted and confounded, and rendered incapable of coming
    to any regular conclusion.

    None but a judge, a man that has
    from his infancy been accustomed to decide intricate cases,
    is equal to such a difficult task. If we even suppose the
    jury sufficiently enlightened to unravel those knotty
    points, yet there remains an insuperable objection. In State
    libels, their passions are frequently so much engaged, that
    they may be justly considered as parties concerned against
    the crown."

    "In order, therefore, to preserve the balance of our
    constitution, let us leave to the judges, as the most
    indifferent persons, the right of determining the malice or
    innocence of the intention
    ."

    "It is not that I think the intention a matter of fact; no,
    in the sense put upon it by the judges, it is a matter of
    law."

    "Much dust has been raised about civil and criminal actions.
    But to what purpose? Is not reparation to be made to the
    public for any injury which it may have sustained, as much
    as to an individual? Is the welfare of the nation in
    general, of less consequence than that of a single person?
    Where then is the propriety of making such a bustle about
    the malice or innocence of the intention? The injury done is
    the only proper measure of the punishment to be inflicted,
    as well as of the damage to be assessed.

    Since you cannot
    plead the intention as a mitigation in the latter case,
    neither can you in the former."[19]

    [Footnote 19: 16 Parl. Hist. 1291, 1292, 1293.]

    What followed? On the 23d of July, 1771, he was made Attorney-General.

    His subsequent history did not disappoint the prophecy uttered above by his former conduct and his notorious character.

    "In truth his success was certain, with the respectable share he possessed of real talents and of valuable requirements--strongly marked features, piercing eyes, bushy eyebrows, and a sonorous voice, all worked to the best effect by an immeasurable share of self-confidence--he could not fail."[20] He hated America with the intense malignity of a low but strong and despotic nature, and "took a most zealous part and uttered very violent language against the colonists.

    He scorned the very notion of concession or conciliation; he considered 'sedition' and 'treason,' (like tobacco and potatoes,) the peculiar plants of the American soil. The natives of these regions he thought were born to be taxed."[21] He favored the Stamp Act, the Coercion Bill,--quartering soldiers upon us, sending Americans beyond seas for trial,--the Boston Port Bill, and all the measures against the colonies.

    "To say that we have a right to tax America and never exercise that right, is ridiculous, and a man must abuse his understanding very much not to allow of that right;" "the right of taxing was never in the least given up to the Americans."[22] On another occasion he said, that "as attorney-general he had a right to set aside every charter in America."[23] What followed?

    Notwithstanding his youthful profligacy, the open profanity of his public and private speech, and his living in public and notorious contempt of matrimony,--he was made Lord Chancellor and elevated to the peerage in 1778! Him also we shall meet again.

    [Footnote 20: 5 Campbell, 398.]

    [Footnote 21: 5 Campbell, 410.]

    [Footnote 22: 17 Parl. Hist. 1313.]

    [Footnote 23: 18 St. Tr. 999.]

    Gentlemen of the Jury, I might as well try to bale all the salt water out of the sea as to mention every glaring and notorious instance where an oppressive government has appointed some discarder of all Higher Law for its servant in crushing the People. Come therefore to the next point.

    • * * * *

    (II.) The next step is by means of such Judges to punish and destroy or silence men who oppose the wickedness of the party in power, and the encroachments of despotism. Let me describe the general mode of procedure, and then illustrate it by special examples.

    1. In the Privy Council, or elsewhere, it is resolved to punish the

    obnoxious men,--and the business is intrusted to the law-officers of the crown, appointed for such functions.

    1. They consult and agree to pervert and twist the law--statute or

    common--for that purpose. By this means they gratify their master, and prepare future advancement for themselves.

    1. The precedent thus established becomes the basis for new operations

    in the future, and may be twisted and perverted to serve other cases as they occur.

    Now, Gentlemen, look at some examples taken from British history, in times of the same Kings mentioned before.

    1. In 1610 two Puritans for refusing the ex officio oath, were

    clapped in Jail by the commissioners. They were brought on habeas corpus before a court, and Mr. Fuller, their counsel, a learned lawyer, insisted that they were imprisoned without due process of law.

    For this "contempt of court" he was thrown into jail by Archbishop Bancroft, whence he was rescued only by death.[24]

    [Footnote 24: Peirce's Vindication, (1717,) 174.]

    1. In 1613 there were many murmurs among the People of England at the

    tyranny of James. Fine and imprisonment did not quell the disturbance; so a more dreadful example was thought needful. The officials of Government broke into the study of Rev. Edmund Peacham, a Protestant minister, sixty or seventy years old. In an uncovered cask they found a manuscript sermon, never preached, nor designed for the pulpit or the press, never shown to any one. It contained some passages which might excite men to resist tyranny. He was arrested, and thrown into Jail, all his papers seized. The Government resolved to prosecute him for high treason. Francis Bacon, the powerful and corrupt Attorney-General, managed the prosecution.

    Before trial was ventured upon, he procured an extrajudicial opinion of the Judges appointed for such services,--irregularly given, out of court, that they would declare such an act high treason.

    But a manuscript sermon, neither preached nor designed for the public, was hardly evidence enough of treason even for such Judges--so purchased, for such an Attorney--so greedy of preferment, with such a Cabinet and such a King. For all those, like the Pharisees of old, "feared the People." So their victim was tortured on the rack, and twelve leading questions prepared by the Government officials, were put to him there.

    I quote Secretary Winwood's record--still extant in his own handwriting--"He was this day examined before torture, in torture, between torture, and after torture; notwithstanding nothing could be drawn from him, he still persisting in his obstinate and insensible denials and former answers." Bacon was present at the torture, which took place in the Tower, Jan. 19, 1614, O.S. (30th Jan. 1615, N.S.). In August he was tried for high treason--"compassing and imagining the King's death"--before a packed jury; against law, and without legal evidence.

    He was of course found guilty under the ruling of the Court! But public opinion, even then making tyrants "tremble in their capitals," was so indignant at the outrage that the execution was not ventured on, and he was left to languish in Jail, till on the 27th of March, 1616, a King more merciful took the old minister where the wicked cease from troubling.[25]

    [Footnote 25: 2 St. Tr. 869; 16 Montagu's Bacon, clxvi.; 2 Campbell, 291.]

    In this case, Gentlemen of the Jury, you will notice three violations of the law.

    (1.) The opinion of the Judges before the trial was extrajudicial and illegal.

    (2.) The application of torture was contrary to law.

    (3.) The statute of Treason was wrested to apply to this case--and a crime was constructed by the servants of the court.

    It is curious to read the opinion of James himself. "The British Solomon" thus wrote:--

    "So the only thing the Judges can doubt of is of the
    delinquent's intention, on his bare denial to clear him
    [himself], since nature teaches every man to defend his life
    as he may; and whether in case there was a doubt herein, the
    Judges should not rather incline to that side [namely, the
    side of the Government,] wherein all probability lies: but
    if Judges will needs trust rather the bare negative of an
    infamous delinquent--then all the probabilities, or rather
    infallible consequences upon the other part, caring more for
    the safety of such a monster than the preservation of a
    crown in all ages following, whereupon depend the lives of
    many millions, happy then are all desperate and seditious
    knaves
    , but the fortune of this crown is more than
    miserable.

    Which God forefend."[26]

    [Footnote 26: 2 St. Tr. 879.]

    1. In 1633, Laud, a tyrannical, ambitious man, and a servile creature

    of the King, mentioned before, was made Archbishop of Canterbury, continuing Bishop of London at the same time. Charles I. was strongly inclined to Romanism, Laud also leaned that way, aiming to come as near as possible to the Papal and not be shut out of the English Church. He made some new regulations in regard to the Communion Table and the Lord's Supper.

    John Williams, before mentioned, Dean of Westminster and Bishop of Lincoln, who had been Lord Keeper under King James, wrote a book against those innovations; besides, in his episcopal court he had once spoken of the Puritans as "good subjects," and of his knowing "that the King did not wish them to be harshly dealt with." In 1637 Laud directed that he should be prosecuted in the Star-Chamber for "publishing false news and tales to the scandal of his Majesty's government;" and "for revealing counsels of State contrary to his oath of a Privy Counsellor." He was sentenced to pay a fine of £10,000,--equal to $50,000, or thrice the sum in these times; to be suspended from all offices, and kept a close prisoner in the Tower during the King's pleasure--whence the Revolution set him at liberty.

    Besides he wrote private letters to Mr. Osbalderston, and called Laud "the little great man," for this he, in 1639, was fined £5,000 to the King, and £3,000 to the Archbishop. Osbalderston in his letters had spoken of the "great Leviathan" and the "little Urchin," and was fined £5,000, to the King, and the same to the Archbishop, and sentenced also to stand in the pillory with his ears nailed to it![27]

    [Footnote 27: 3 St. Tr. 769; 2 Campbell, 400.]

    1. In 1629 Richard Chambers, a merchant of London, complained to the

    Privy Council of some illegal and unjust treatment, and declared "that the merchants in no part of the world are so screwed and wrung as in England; that in Turkey they have more encouragement." Laud, who hated freedom of speech and liberal comments on the government as much as "eminent citizens" nowadays, is said to have told the king, "If your majesty had many such Chambers, you would soon have no Chamber left to rest in." The merchant was tried before the "commissioners" at the Star-Chamber, and fined £2,000, and condemned to make a "submission for his great offence,"[28] which the stout Puritan refused to do, and was kept in prison till the Court of King's Bench, faithful to the law, on Habeas Corpus, admitted him to bail: for which they were reprimanded.

    Laud and all the ecclesiastical members of the "commission" wished his fine £3,000.

    [Footnote 28: 3 St. Tr. 373; Franklyn, 361; 2 Hallam (Paris, 1841), 6 ac etiam 13; 2 Mrs. Macaulay, 16, 45, 65.]

    1. In his place in Parliament in 1629, Sir John Eliot, one of the

    noblest men in England's noblest age, declared that "the Council and Judges had all conspired to trample underfoot the liberties of the subject." Gentlemen, the fact was as notorious as the advance of the Slave Power now is in America. But a few days after the king (Charles I.) had dismissed his refractory Parliament, Eliot, with Hollis, Long, Selden, Strode, and Valentine, most eminent members of the commons, and zealous for liberty and law, was seized by the king's command and thrown into prison.

    The Habeas Corpus was demanded--it was all in vain, for Laud and Strafford were at the head of affairs, and the priests and pliant Judges in Westminster Hall--Jones was one of them--clove down the law of the land just as their subcatenated successors did in Boston in 1851. The court decreed that they should be imprisoned during the king's pleasure, and not released until making submission and giving security for good behavior. Eliot was fined £2,000, Hollis and Valentine in smaller sums. Eliot--the brave man--refused submission, and died in the Tower.

    Thus was the attack made on all freedom of speech in Parliament![29]

    [Footnote 29: 3 St. Tr. 293; 1 Rushworth; 2 Hallam, 2; 2 Parl. Hist. 488, 504; Foster's Eliot, 100; 2 Mrs. Macaulay, ch. i. ii.]

    1. In 1630, the very year of the first settlement of Boston, on the

    4th of June, Rev. Dr. Alexander Leighton was brought before the Court of High Commission, in the Star-Chamber, to be tried for a seditious libel.

    He had published "An Appeal to the Parliament, or a Plea against Prelacy," a work still well known, remonstrating against certain notorious grievances in church and State, "to the end the Parliament might take them into consideration and give such redress as might be for the honor of the king, the quiet of the people, and the peace of the church," the court of commissions accounted it "a most odious and heinous offence, deserving the most serious punishment the court could inflict, for framing a book so full of such pestilent, devilish, and dangerous assertions." The two Chief Justices declared if the case had been brought to their courts, they would have proceeded against him for Treason, and it was only "his majesty's exceeding great mercy and goodness" which selected the milder tribunal.

    His sentence was a fine of £10,000, to be set in the pillory, whipped, have one ear cut off; one side of his nose slit, one cheek branded with S.S., Sower of Sedition, and then at some convenient time be whipped again, branded, and mutilated on the other side, and confined in the Fleet during life! Before the punishment could be inflicted he escaped out of prison, but was recaptured and the odious sentence fully executed.

    Those who "obstructed" the officer in the execution of that "process" were fined £500 a piece.[30] Gentlemen of the Jury, which do you think would most have astonished the Founders of Massachusetts, then drawing near to Boston, that trial on the 4th of June, 1630, or this trial, two hundred and twenty-five years later? At the court of Charles it was a great honor to mutilate the body of a Puritan minister.

    [Footnote 30: 3 St. Tr. 383; Laud's Diary, 4th November; 2 Hallam, 28.]

    But not only did such judges thus punish the most noble men who wrote on political matters, there was no freedom of speech allowed--so logical is despotism!

    1. William Prynn, a zealous Puritan and a very learned lawyer, wrote a

    folio against theatres called "a Scourge for Stage-Players," dull, learned, unreadable and uncommon thick. He was brought to the Star-Chamber in 1632-3, and Chief Justice Richardson--who had even then "but an indifferent reputation for honesty and veracity"--gave this sentence: "Mr. Prynn, I do declare you to be a Schism-Maker in the Church, a Sedition-Sower in the Commonwealth, a wolf in sheep's clothing; in a word 'omnium malorum nequissimus'--[the wickedest of all scoundrels].

    I shall fine him £10,000, which is more than he is worth, yet less than he deserveth; I will not set him at liberty, no more than a plagued man or a mad dog, who though he cannot bite, yet will he foam; he is so far from being a sociable soul that he is not a rational soul; he is fit to live in dens with such beasts of prey as wolves and tygers like himself; therefore I do condemn him to perpetual Imprisonment, as those monsters that are no longer fit to live among men nor to see light." "I would have him branded in the forehead, slit in the nose, and his ears cropped too." The sentence was executed the 7th and 10th of May, 1633.[31] But nothing intimidated, the sturdy man committed other offences of like nature, "obstructing" other "officers," and was punished again, and banished.

    But on the summoning of Parliament returned to England, and became powerful in that Revolution which crushed the tyrants of the time.

    [Footnote 31: 3 St. Tr. 561; 2 Hallam, 28, and his authorities. See also 2 Echard, 109, et seq., 124, et seq., 202, 368, 510; the remarks of Hume, Hist. ch. lii., remind me of the tone of the fugitive slave bill Journals of Boston in 1850-54.]

    1. In 1685, James II. was in reality a Catholic. He wished to restore

    Romanism to England and abolish the work of the Reformation, the better to establish the despotism which all of his family had sought to plant. He was determined to punish such as spoke against the Papal Church, though no law prohibited such speaking. Judge Jeffreys, a member of the cabinet and favorite of the king, was at that time chief justice--abundantly fit for the work demanded of him. The pious and venerable Richard Baxter was selected for the victim. Let Mr. Macaulay tell the story.

    "In a Commentary on the New Testament, he had complained,
    with some bitterness, of the persecution which the
    Dissenters suffered. That men, who, for not using the
    Prayerbook, had been driven from their homes, stripped of
    their property, and locked up in dungeons, should dare to
    utter a murmur, was then thought a high crime against the
    State and Church. Roger Lestrange, the champion of the
    government, and the oracle of the clergy, sounded the note
    of war in the Observator. An information was filed. Baxter
    begged that he might be allowed some time to prepare for his
    defence.

    It was on the day on which Oates was pilloried in
    Palace Yard that the illustrious chief of the Puritans,
    oppressed by age and infirmities, came to Westminster Hall
    to make this request. Jeffreys burst into a storm of rage.
    'Not a minute,' he cried, 'to save his life. I can deal with
    saints as well as with sinners. There stands Oates on one
    side of the pillory; and if Baxter stood on the other, the
    two greatest rogues in the kingdom would stand together.'"

    "When the trial came on at Guildhall, a crowd of those who
    loved and honored Baxter, filled the court. At his side
    stood Doctor William Bates, one of the most eminent
    Non-conformist divines. Two Whig barristers of great note,
    Pollexfen and Wallop, appeared for the defendant."

    "Pollexfen had scarce begun his address to the jury, when
    the chief justice broke forth: 'Pollexfen, I know you well.
    I will set a mark on you. You are the patron of the faction.
    This is an old rogue, a schismatical knave, a hypocritical
    villain. He hates the Liturgy.

    He would have nothing but
    longwinded cant without book;' and then his lordship turned
    up his eyes, clasped his hands, and began to sing through
    his nose in imitation of what he supposed to be Baxter's
    style of praying, 'Lord, we are thy people, thy peculiar
    people, thy dear people.' Pollexfen gently reminded the
    court that his late majesty had thought Baxter deserving of
    a bishopric. 'And what ailed the old blockhead then,' cried
    Jeffreys, 'that he did not take it?' His fury now rose
    almost to madness.

    He called Baxter a dog, and swore that it
    would be no more than justice to whip such a villain through
    the whole city."

    "Wallop interposed, but fared no better than his leader.
    'You are in all these dirty causes, Mr. Wallop,' said the
    judge. 'Gentlemen of the long robe ought to be ashamed to
    assist such factious knaves.' The advocate made another
    attempt to obtain a hearing, but to no purpose. 'If you do
    not know your duty,' said Jeffreys, 'I will teach it you.'

    "Wallop sat down, and Baxter himself attempted to put in a
    word; but the chief justice drowned all expostulation in a
    torrent of ribaldry and invective, mingled with scraps of
    Hudibras. 'My lord,' said the old man, 'I have been much
    blamed by Dissenters for speaking respectfully of bishops.'

    "'Baxter for bishops!' cried the judge; 'that's a merry
    conceit indeed. I know what you mean by bishops--rascals
    like yourself, Kidderminster bishops, factious, snivelling
    Presbyterians!'

    "Again Baxter essayed to speak, and again Jeffreys bellowed,
    'Richard, Richard, dost thou think we will let thee poison
    the court? Richard, thou art an old knave. Thou hast written
    books enough to load a cart, and every book as full of
    sedition as an egg is full of meat. By the grace of God,
    I'll look after thee. I see a great many of your brotherhood
    waiting to know what will befall their mighty Don. And
    there,' he continued, fixing his savage eye on Bates, 'there
    is a doctor of the party at your elbow. But, by the grace of
    God Almighty, I will crush you all!'

    "Baxter held his peace. But one of the junior counsel for
    the defence made a last effort, and undertook to show that
    the words of which complaint was made, would not bear the
    construction put on them by the information. With this view
    he began to read the context. In a moment he was roared
    down. 'You sha'n't turn the court into a conventicle!' The
    noise of weeping was heard from some of those who surrounded
    Baxter. 'Snivelling calves!' said the judge."[32]

    [Footnote 32: 1 Macaulay, (Harper's Ed.) 456-8.]

    He was sentenced to pay a fine of 500 marks, to lie in prison till he paid it, and be bound to good behavior for seven years. Jeffreys, it is said, wished him also to be whipped at the tail of a cart.[33] But the King remitted his fine.

    [Footnote 33: 1 Macaulay, 456; 11 St. Tr. 493.]

    Throughout the reign of James II. the courts of law became more and more contemptible in the eyes of the people. "All the three common law courts were filled by incompetent and corrupt Judges."[34] But their power to do evil never diminished.

    [Footnote 34: 2 Campbell's Justices, 87.]

    1. James II. wished to restore the Catholic form of religion, rightly

    looking on Protestantism as hostile to his intended tyranny; so he claimed a right to dispense with the laws relating thereto, put a Jesuit into his Privy Council, expelled Protestants from their offices, and filled the vacancy thus illegally made with Papists; he appointed Catholic bishops.[35] In 1688 he published a proclamation.

    It was the second of the kind,--dispensing with all the laws of the realm against Catholicism; and ordered it to be read on two specified Sundays during the hours of service in all places of public worship.

    This measure seemed to be a special insult to the Protestants. The declaration of indulgence was against their conscience, and in violation of the undisputed laws of the land, but Chief Justice Wright declared from the bench his opinion that it was "legal and obligatory," and on the day appointed for reading the decree attended church "to give weight to the solemnity," and as it was not read--for the clerk "had forgot to bring a copy,"--he "indecently in the hearing of the congregation abused the priest, as disloyal, seditious, and irreligious."

    [Footnote 35: See 2 Brewster's Newton, 108.]

    But the clergy thought differently from the Chief Justice--Episcopalians and Dissenters agreeing on this point. Seven bishops petitioned the King that they might not be obliged to violate their conscience, the articles of their religion, and the laws of the realm, by reading the declaration. They presented their petition in person to the King, who treated it and them with insolence and wrath.

    "The king, says Kennet, was not contented to have this
    declaration published in the usual manner, but he was
    resolved to have it solemnly read in all churches as the
    political gospel of his reign.

    The bishops and clergy were,
    of all others the most averse to the subject-matter of the
    declaration, as being most sensible of the ill design and
    ill effects of it; and therefore the court seemed the more
    willing to mortify these their enemies, and make them become
    accessory to their own ruin; and even to eat their own dung,
    as father Petre proudly threatened, and therefore this order
    of council was made and published."[36]

    [Footnote 36: 12 St. Tr. 239.]

    The petition was printed and published with great rapidity, the bishops were seized, thrown into the Tower, and prosecuted in the court for a "false, feigned, malicious, pernicious, and seditious" libel.

    Judge Allybone thus addressed the Jury.

    "And I think, in the first place, that no man can take
    upon him to write against the actual exercise of the
    government, unless he have leave from the government
    , but
    he makes a libel, be what he writes true or false; for if
    once we come to impeach the government by way of argument,
    it is the argument that makes it the government, or not the
    government.

    So that I lay down that, in the first place,
    the government ought not to be impeached by argument, nor
    the exercise of the government shaken by argument; because I
    can manage a proposition, in itself doubtful, with a better
    pen than another man; this, say I, is a libel.

    "Then I lay down this for my next position, that no private
    man can take upon him to write concerning the government at
    all
    ; for what has any private man to do with the
    government
    , if his interest be not stirred or shaken? It is
    the business of the government to manage matters relating to
    the government; it is the business of subjects to mind only
    their own properties and interests
    . If my interest is not
    shaken, what have I to do with matters of government? They
    are not within my sphere.

    If the government does come to
    shake my particular interest, the law is open for me, and I
    may redress myself by law; and when I intrude myself into
    other men's business that does not concern my particular
    interest, I am a libeller.

    "These I have laid down for plain propositions; now, then,
    let us consider further, whether, if I will take upon me to
    contradict the government, any specious pretence that I
    shall put upon it, shall dress it up in another form and
    give it a better denomination?

    And truly I think it is the
    worse, because it comes in a better dress; for by that rule,
    every man that can put on a good vizard, may be as
    mischievous as he will, to the government at the bottom, so
    that, whether it be in the form of a supplication, or an
    address, or a petition, if it be what it ought not to be,
    let us call it by its true name, and give it its right
    denomination--it is a libel."

    "The government here has published such a declaration as
    this that has been read, relating to matters of government;
    and shall, or ought anybody to come and impeach that as
    illegal, which the government has done
    ? Truly, in my
    opinion, I do not think he should, or ought; for by this
    rule may every act of the government be shaken, when there
    is not a parliament de facto sitting.

    "When the house of lords and commons are in being, it is a
    proper way of applying to the king; there is all the
    openness in the world for those that are members of
    parliament, to make what addresses they please to the
    government, for the rectifying, altering, regulating, and
    making of what law they please; but if every private man
    shall come and interpose his advice, I think there can never
    be an end of advising the government.

    "We are not to measure things from any truth they have in
    themselves, but from that aspect they have upon the
    government; for there may be every tittle of a libel true,
    and yet it may be a libel still
    ; so that I put no great
    stress upon that objection, that the matter of it is not
    false; and for sedition, it is that which every libel
    carries in itself: and as every trespass implies vi and
    armis
    , so every libel against the government carries in it
    sedition, and all the other epithets that are in the
    information. This is my opinion as to law in general.

    I will
    not debate the prerogatives of the king, nor the privileges
    of the subject; but as this fact is, I think these venerable
    bishops did meddle with that which did not belong to them;
    they took upon them, in a petitionary, to contradict the
    actual exercise of the government, which I think no
    particular persons, or singular body, may do."[37]

    [Footnote 37: 12 St. Tr. 427, 428, 429.]

    Listen, Gentlemen of the Jury, to the words of Attorney-General Powis:--

    "And I cannot omit here to take notice, that there is not
    any one thing that the law is more jealous of
    , or does more
    carefully provide for the prevention and punishment of,
    than all accusations and arraignments of the government. No
    man is allowed to accuse even the most inferior magistrate
    of any misbehavior in his office
    , unless it be in a legal
    course, though the fact is true.

    No man may say of a
    justice of the peace, to his face, that he is unjust in his
    office. No man may tell a judge, either by word or
    petition, you have given an unjust, or an ill judgment
    , and
    I will not obey it; it is against the rules and laws of the
    kingdom, or the like
    .

    No man may say of the great men of
    the nation, much less of the great officers of the kingdom,
    that they do act unreasonably or unjustly, or the like;
    least of all may any man say any such thing of the king; for
    these matters tend to possess the people, that the
    government is ill administered; and the consequence of that
    is, to set them upon desiring a reformation; and what that
    tends to, and will end in, we have all had a sad and too
    dear bought experience."[38]

    [Footnote 38: 12 St. Tr. 281.]

    Hearken to the law of Solicitor-General Williams:--

    "If any person have slandered the government in writing, you
    are not to examine the truth of that fact in such writing,
    but the slander which it imports to the king or government;
    and be it never so true, yet if slanderous to the king or
    the government, it is a libel and to be punished; in that
    case, the right or wrong is not to be examined, or if
    what was done by the government be legal, or no
    ; but
    whether the party have done such an act.

    If the king have a
    power (for still I keep to that), to issue forth
    proclamations to his subjects, and to make orders and
    constitutions in matters ecclesiastical, if he do issue
    forth his proclamation, and make an order upon the matters
    within his power and prerogative; and if any one would come
    and bring that power in question otherwise than in
    parliament, that the matter of that proclamation be not
    legal, I say that is sedition, and you are not to examine
    the legality or illegality of the order or proclamation, but
    the slander and reflection upon the government."

    "If a person do a thing that is libellous, you shall not
    examine the fact, but the consequence of it; whether it
    tended to stir up sedition against the public, or to stir up
    strife between man and man, in the case of private persons;
    as if a man should say of a judge, he has taken a bribe, and
    I will prove it.

    "They tell the king it is inconsistent with their honor,
    prudence, and conscience, to do what he would have them to
    do. And if these things be not reflective upon the king and
    government, I know not what is.

    "I'll tell you what they should have done, Sir. If they were
    commanded to do any thing against their consciences, they
    should have acquiesced till the meeting of the parliament
    .
    [At which some people in the court hissed.]

    "If the king will impose upon a man what he cannot do, he
    must acquiesce
    ; but shall he come and fly in the face of
    his prince? Shall he say it is illegal? and the prince acts
    against prudence, honor, or conscience, and throw dirt in
    the king's face? Sure that is not permitted; that is
    libelling with a witness."[39]

    [Footnote 39: 12 St. Tr. 415, 416, 417.]

    Here, however, there was a JURY--the seven bishops were acquitted amid the tumultuous huzzas of the people, who crowded all the open spaces in the neighborhood of Westminster Hall, and rent the air with their shouts, which even the soldiers repeated.[40]

    [Footnote 40: See 2 Campbell's Justices, 95.]

    Two of the Judges--Sir John Powell and Sir Richard Holloway--stood out for law and justice, declaring such a petition to the King was not a libel. They were presently thrust from their offices.

    • * * * *

    Gentlemen of the Jury, the Stuarts soon filled up the measure of their time as of their iniquity, and were hustled from the throne of England. But, alas, I shall presently remind you of some examples of this tyranny in New England itself. Now I shall cite a few similar cases of oppression which happened in the reign of the last King of New England.

    I just now spoke of Edmund Thurlow, showing what his character was and by what means he gained his various offices, ministerial and judicial.

    I will next show you one instance more of the evil which comes from putting in office such men as are nothing but steps whereon despotism mounts up to its bad eminence.

    1. On the 8th of June, 1775,--it will be eighty years on the first

    anniversary of Judge Curtis's charge to the grand-jury,--John Horne, better known by his subsequent name John Horne Tooke, formerly a clergyman but then a scholarly man devoting himself to letters and politics--published the following notice in the Morning Chronicle and London Advertiser, as well as other newspapers:--

    "King's-Arms Tavern, Cornhill, June 7, 1775.

    At a special
    meeting this day of several members of the Constitutional
    Society, during an adjournment, a gentleman proposed that a
    subscription should be immediately entered into by such of
    the members present who might approve the purpose, for
    raising the sum of £100, to be applied to the relief of the
    widows, orphans, and aged parents of our beloved American
    fellow-subjects, who, faithful to the character of
    Englishmen, preferring death to slavery, were for that
    reason only inhumanly murdered by the king's troops at or
    near Lexington and Concord, in the province of
    Massachusetts, on the 19th of last April; which sum being
    immediately collected, it was thereupon resolved that Mr.
    Horne do pay to-morrow into the hands of Mess.

    Brownes and
    Collinson, on account of Dr. Franklin, the said sum of
    100_l._ and that Dr. Franklin be requested to apply the same
    to the above-mentioned purpose."

    At that time Thurlow, whom I introduced to you a little while ago, was Attorney-General, looking for further promotion from the Tory Government of Lord North. Mansfield was Chief Justice, a man of great ability, who has done so much to reform the English law, but whose hostility to America was only surpassed by the hatred which he bore to all freedom of speech and the rights of the Jury. The Government was eager to crush the liberty of the American Colonies. But this was a difficult matter, for in England itself there was a powerful party friendly to America, who took our side in the struggle for liberty.

    The city of London, however, was hostile to us, wishing to destroy our merchants and manufacturers, who disturbed the monopoly of that commercial metropolis. The government thought it necessary to punish any man who ventured to oppose their tyranny and sympathize with America. Accordingly it was determined that Mr. Horne should be brought to trial. But as public opinion, stimulated by Erskine, Camden and others, favored the rights of the Jury, it seems to have been thought dangerous to trust the case to a Grand-Jury.

    Perhaps the Judge had no brother-in-law to put on it, or the Attorney-General--though famous also for his profanity,--doubted that any swearing of his would insure a bill; nay, perhaps he did not venture to "bet ten dollars that I will get an indictment against him." Be that as it may, the Attorney-General dispensed with the services of the Grand-Jury and filed an information ex officio against Mr.

    Horne, therein styling him a "wicked, malicious, seditious, and ill-disposed person;" charging him, by that advertisement, with "wickedly, maliciously, and seditiously intending, designing, and venturing to stir up and excite discontents and sedition;" "to cause it to be believed that divers of his Majesty's innocent and deserving subjects had been inhumanly murdered by ... his Majesty's troops; and unlawfully and wickedly to encourage his Majesty's subjects in the said Province of Massachusetts to resist and oppose his Majesty's Government." He said the advertisement was "a false, wicked, malicious, scandalous, and seditious libel;" "full of ribaldry, Billingsgate, scurrility, balderdash, and impudence;" "wicked is a term too high for this advertisement;" "its impudence disarmed its wickedness." In short, Mr.

    Horne was accused of "resisting an officer," obstructing the execution of the "process" whereby the American Provinces were to be made the slave colonies of a metropolitan despotism. The usual charge of doing all this by "force and arms," was of course thrown in.

    The publication of the advertisement was declared a "crime of such heinousness and of such a size as fairly called for the highest resentment which any court of justice has thought proper to use with respect to crimes of this denomination;" "a libel such that it is impossible by any artifice to aggravate it;" "It will be totally impossible for the imagination of any man, however shrewd, to state a libel more scandalous and base in the fact imputed, more malignant and hostile to the country in which the libeller is born, more dangerous in the example if it were suffered to pass unpunished, than this:" "It is in language addressed to the lowest and most miserable mortals, ... it is addressed to the lowest of the mob, and the bulk of the people, who it is fit should be otherwise taught, who it is fit should be otherwise governed in this country."

    Mr. Horne was brought to trial on the 4th of July, 1777. He defended himself, but though a vigorous writer, he was not a good speaker, and was in a strange place, while "Thurlow fought on his own dunghill," says Lord Campbell, "and throughout the whole day had the advantage over him." There was a special jury packed for the purpose by the hireling sheriff,--a "London jury" famous for corruption,--a tyrannical and powerful judge, ready to turn every weapon of the court against the defendant and to construct law against the liberty of speech. Of course Mr. Horne was convicted.

    But how should he be punished? Thurlow determined.

    "My Lords, the punishments to be inflicted upon misdemeanors
    of this sort, have usually been of three different kinds;
    fine, corporal punishment by imprisonment, and infamy by the
    judgment of the pillory.

    With regard to the fine, it is
    impossible for justice to make this sort of punishment,
    however the infamy will always fall upon the offender;
    because it is well known, that men who have more wealth, who
    have better and more respectful situations and reputations
    to be watchful over, employ men in desperate situations both
    of circumstances and characters, in order to do that which
    serves their party purposes; and when the punishment comes
    to be inflicted, this court must have regard to the apparent
    situation and circumstances of the man employed, that is, of
    the man convicted, with regard to the punishment.

    "With regard to imprisonment, that is a species of
    punishment not to be considered alike in all cases, but ...,
    that it would be proper for the judgment of the court to
    state circumstances which will make the imprisonment fall
    lighter or heavier, ... that would be proper, if I had not
    been spared all trouble upon that account, by hearing it
    solemnly avowed ... by the defendant himself, that
    imprisonment was no kind of inconvenience to him; for that
    certain employments, ... would occasion his confinement in
    so close a way, that it was mere matter of circumstance
    whether it happened in one place or another; and that the
    longest imprisonment which this court could inflict for
    punishment, was not beyond the reach of accommodation which
    those occasions rendered necessary to him.

    In this respect,
    therefore, imprisonment is not only, ... not an adequate
    punishment to the offence, but the public are told, ... that
    it will be no punishment.

    "I stated in the third place to your Lordships, the pillory
    to have been the usual punishment for this species of
    offence
    .

    I apprehend it to have been so, in this case, for
    above two hundred years before the time when prosecutions
    grew rank in the Star-Chamber ... the punishment of the
    pillory was inflicted, not only during the time that such
    prosecutions were rank in the Star-Chamber, but it also
    continued to be inflicted upon this sort of crime, and that
    by the best authority, after the time of the abolishing the
    Star-Chamber, after the time of the Revolution, and while my
    Lord Chief Justice Holt sat in this court.

    "I would desire no better, no more pointed, nor any more
    applicable argument than what that great chief justice used,
    when it was contended before him that an abuse upon
    government, upon the administration of several parts of
    government, amounted to nothing, because there was no abuse
    upon any particular man. That great chief justice said, they
    amounted to much more; they are an abuse upon all men.
    Government cannot exist, if the law cannot restrain that
    sort of abuse.

    Government cannot exist, unless ... the full
    punishment is inflicted which the most approved times have
    given to offences of much less denomination than these, of
    much less. I am sure it cannot be shown, that in any one of
    the cases that were punished in that manner, the
    aggravations of any one of those offences were any degree
    adequate to those which are presented to your Lordship now.
    If offences were so punished then, which are not so punished
    now, they lose that expiation which the wisdom of those ages
    thought proper to hold out to the public, as a restraint
    from such offences being committed again.

    "I am to judge of crimes in order to the prosecution; your
    lordship is to judge of them ultimately for punishment.

    I
    should have been extremely sorry, if I had been induced by
    any consideration whatever, to have brought a crime of the
    magnitude which this was (of the magnitude which this was
    when I first stated it) into a court of justice, if I had
    not had it in my contemplation also that it would meet with
    an adequate restraint, which I never thought would be done
    without affixing to it the judgment of the pillory; I
    should have been very sorry to have brought this man here,
    after all the aggravations that he has superinduced upon the
    offence itself, if I had not been persuaded that those
    aggravations would have induced the judgment of the
    pillory
    ."[41]

    [Footnote 41: 20 St. Tr. 780-783.]

    But Mansfield thought otherwise, and punished him with a fine of £200 and imprisonment for twelve months.[42]

    [Footnote 42: 20 St. Tr. 651; 5 Campbell, 415.]

    "Thus," says Lord Brougham, "a bold and just denunciation of the attacks made upon our American Brethren, which nowadays would rank among the very mildest and tamest effusions of the periodical press, condemned him to prison for twelve months."[43]

    [Footnote 43: Statesmen, 2 Series, 109.]

    Thurlow was a man of low intellect, of a fierce countenance, a saucy, swaggering, insolent manner, debauched in his morals beyond the grossness of that indecent age,--ostentatiously living in public concubinage,--a notorious swearer in public and private. But he knew no law above the will of the hand that fed and could advance him, no justice which might check the insolence of power. And in less than a month after Mr. Horne was sent to jail, Thurlow was made Lord Chancellor of England, and sat on the woolsack in the House of Lords.

    His chief panegyrist can only say, "in worse times there have been worse chancellors." "But an age of comparative freedom and refinement has rarely exhibited one who so ill understood, or at least so ill discharged, the functions of a statesman and legislator."

    I will enrich this part of my argument with an example of the opinions of this Judge, which would endear him to the present administration in America, and entitle him to a high place among southern politicians. In 1788 a bill was brought into Parliament to mitigate the horrors of the African slave-trade. The Lord Chancellor, Thurlow, opposed it and said:--

    "It appears that the French have offered premiums to
    encourage the African [slave] trade, and that they have
    succeeded. The natural presumption therefore is, that we
    ought to do the same
    .

    For my part, my Lords, I have no
    scruple to say that if the 'five days' fit of philanthropy'
    [the attempt to abolish the slave-trade] which has just
    sprung up, and which has slept for twenty years together,
    were allowed to sleep one summer longer, it would appear to
    me rather more wise than thus to take up a subject
    piecemeal, which it has been publicly declared ought not to
    be agitated at all till next session of Parliament.

    Perhaps,
    by such imprudence, the slaves themselves may be prompted by
    their own authority, to proceed at once to a 'total and
    immediate abolition of the trade.' One witness has come to
    your Lordship's bar with a face of woe--his eyes full of
    tears, and his countenance fraught with horror, and said,
    'My Lords, I am ruined if you pass this bill! I have risked
    £30,000 on the trade this year!

    It is all I have been able
    to gain by my industry, and if I lose it I must go to the
    hospital!
    ' I desire of you to think of such things, my
    Lords, in your humane phrensy, and to show some humanity to
    the whites as well as to the negroes
    ."[44]

    [Footnote 44: 5 Campbell, 460; 27 Parl. Hist. 638.]

    One measure of tyranny in the hands of such Judges is Constructive Crime, a crime which the revengeful, or the purchased judge distils out of an honest or a doubtful deed, in the alembic he has made out of the law broken up and recast by him for that purpose, twisted, drawn out, and coiled up in serpentine and labyrinthine folds.

    For as the sweet juices of the grape, the peach, the apple, pear, or plumb may be fermented, and then distilled into the most deadly intoxicating draught to madden man and infuriate woman, so by the sophistry of a State's Attorney and a Court Judge, well trained for this work, out of innocent actions, and honest, manly speech, the most ghastly crimes can be extorted, and then the "leprous distilment" be poured upon the innocent victim,

    "And a most instant tetter barks about,
    Most lazar-like, with vile and loathsome crust,
    All his smooth body!"

    Here is an example. In 1668 some London apprentices committed a riot by pulling down some houses of ill-fame in Moorfields, which had become a nuisance to the neighborhood; they shouted "Down with Bawdy Houses." Judge Kelyng had them indicted for High Treason. He said it was "an accroachment of royal authority." It was "levying war." He thus laid down the law. "The prisoners are indicted for levying war against the King.

    By levying war is not only meant when a body is gathered together as an army, but if a company of people will go about any public reformation, this is high treason. These people do pretend their design was against brothels; now let men to go about to pull down brothels, with a captain [an apprentice "walked about with a green apron on a pole"] and an ensign and weapons,--if this thing be endured, who is safe?

    It is high treason because it doth betray the peace of the nation, and every subject is as much wronged as the King; for if every man may reform what he will, no man is safe; therefore the thing is of desperate consequence, and we must make this for a public example.

    There is reason why we should be very cautious; we are but recently delivered from rebellion [Charles I. had been executed nineteen years before, and his son had been in peaceable possession of the throne for eight years], and we know that that rebellion first began under the pretence of religion and the law; for the Devil hath always this vizard upon it. We have great reason to be very wary that we fall not again into the same error. Apprentices for the future shall not go on in this manner.

    It proved that Beasly went as their captain with his sword, and flourished it over his head [this was the "weapons,"] and that Messenger walked about Moorfields with a green apron on the top of a pole [this was the "ensign"]. What was done by one, was done by all; in high treason all concerned are principals."[45]

    [Footnote 45: 1 Campbell's Justices, 404-5; Kelyng's Reports, 70.]

    Thereupon thirteen apprentices who had been concerned in a riot were found guilty of high treason, sentenced, and four hanged. All of the eleven Judges--Twysden was one of them--concurred in the sentence, except Sir Matthew Hale. He declared there was no treason committed; there was "but an unruly company of apprentices."[46]

    [Footnote 46: 6 St. Tr. 879, note 911.]

    This same Judge Kelyng, singularly thick-headed and ridiculous, loved to construct crimes where the law made none. Thus he declares, "in cases of high treason, if any one do any thing by which he showeth his liking and approbation to the Traitorous Design, this is in him High Treason.

    For all are Principals in High Treason, who contribute towards it by Action or Approbation."[47] He held it was an overt act of treason to print a "treasonable proposition," such as this, "The execution of Judgment and Justice is as well the people's as the magistrates' duty, and if the magistrates pervert Judgment, the people are bound by the law of God to execute judgment without them and upon them."[48] So the printer of the book, containing the "treasonable proposition," was executed.

    A man, by name Axtell, who commanded the guards which attended at the trial and execution of Charles I., was brought to trial for treason. He contended that he acted as a soldier by the command of his superior officer, whom he must obey, or die. But it was resolved that "that was no excuse, for his superior was a Traitor and all that joined with him in that act were Traitors, and did by that approve the Treason, and when the command is Traitorous, then the Obedience to that Command is also Traitorous." So Axtell must die.

    The same rule of course smote at the head of any private soldier who served in the ranks![49]

    [Footnote 47: Kelyng's Reports, 12.]

    [Footnote 48: Ibid. 22.]

    [Footnote 49: Kelyng's Reports, 13.]

    These wicked constructions of treason by the court, out of small offences or honest actions, continued until Mr. Erskine attacked them with his Justice, and with his eloquence exposed them to the indignation of mankind, and so shamed the courts into humanity and common sense.[50] Yet still the same weapon lies hid under the Judicial bench as well of England as of America, whence any malignant or purchased Judge, when it suits his personal whim or public ambition, may draw it forth, and smite at the fortune, the reputation, or the life of any innocent man he has a private grudge against, but dares not meet in open day. Of this, Gentlemen of the Jury, in due time.

    [Footnote 50: See his Defence of Hardy, 24 St. Tr. 877.]

    • * * * *

    The mass of men, busy with their honest work, are not aware what power is left in the hands of judges--wholly irresponsible to the people; few men know how they often violate the laws they are nominally set to administer. Let me take but a single form of this judicial iniquity--the Use of Torture, borrowing my examples from the history of our mother country.

    In England the use of torture has never been conformable either to common or to statute law; but how often has it been practised by a corrupt administration and wicked judges!

    In 1549 Lord Seymour of Sudley, Admiral of England, was put to the torture;[51] in 1604 Guy Fawkes was "horribly racked."[52] Peacham was repeatedly put to torture as you have just now heard, and that in the presence of Lord Bacon himself in 1614.[53] Peacock was racked in 1620, Bacon and Coke both signing the warrant for this illegal wickedness,--"he deserveth it as well as Peacham did," said the Lord Chancellor, making his own "ungodly custom" stand for law.[54] In 1627 the Lord Deputy of Ireland wanted to torture two priests, and Charles I. gave him license, the privy council consenting--"all of one mind that he might rack the priests if he saw fit, and hang them if he found reason!"[55] In 1628 the judges of England solemnly decided that torture was unlawful; but it had always been so,--and Yelverton, one of the judges, was a member of the commission which stretched Peacham on the rack.[56] Yet, spite of this decision, torture still held its old place, and a warrant from the year 1610 still exists for inflicting this illegal atrocity on a victim of the court.[57] Yet even so late as 1804, when Thomas Pictou, governor of Trinidad, put a woman to tortures of the most cruel character, by the connivance of the court he entirely escaped from all judicial punishment.[58] Yes, torture was long continued in England itself, though not always by means of thumbscrews and Scottish boots and Spanish racks; the monstrous chains, the damp cells, the perpetual irritation which corrupt servants of a despotic court tormented their victims withal, was the old demon under another name.[59] Nay, within a few months the newspapers furnish us with examples of Americans being put to the torture of the lash to force a confession of their alleged crime--and this has been done by the power which this court has long been so zealous to support--the Slave Power of America.

    [Footnote 51: See 2 St. Tr. 774, note.]

    [Footnote 52: 1 Jardine, Crim. Tr. 16.]

    [Footnote 53: 2 St. Tr. 871.]

    [Footnote 54: 1 Jardine, 19.]

    [Footnote 55: Ibid.]

    [Footnote 56: 3 St. Tr. 371. See 30 St. Tr. 892.]

    [Footnote 57: 1 Jardine, 20. See Emlyn, Preface to St. Tr. in 1 Hargrave, p. iii.]

    [Footnote 58: 30 St. Tr. 225.]

    [Footnote 59: See case of Huggins in 17 St. Tr. 297, 309.]

    It has been well said:--

    "It must be owned that the Guards and Fences of the law have
    not always proved an effectual security for the subject. The
    Reader will ... find many Instances wherein they who hold
    the sword of Justice did not employ it as they ought to in
    punishment of Evil-Doers, but to the Oppression and
    Destruction of Men more righteous than themselves. Indeed it
    is scarce possible to frame a Body of Laws which a
    tyrannical Prince, influenced by wicked Counsellors and
    corrupt Judges, may not be able to break through.... The Law
    itself is a dead letter.

    Judges are the interpreters of it,
    and if they prove men of no Conscience nor Integrity, they
    will give what sense they will to it, however different from
    the true one; and when they are supported by superior
    authority, will for a while prevail, till by repeated
    iniquities they grow intolerable and throw the State into
    convulsions which may at last end in their own ruin. This
    shows how valuable a Blessing is an upright and learned
    Judge, and of what great concern it is to the public that
    none be preferred to that office but such whose Ability and
    Integrity may be safely depended on."[60]

    [Footnote 60: 1 Hargrave's St. Tr. 6.]

    Thus, Gentlemen of the Jury, is it that judges who know no law but the will of "the hand that feeds them," appointed for services rendered to the enemies of mankind and looking for yet higher rewards, have sought to establish the despotism of their masters on the ruin of the People.

    But the destruction of obnoxious individuals is not the whole of their enormity; so I come to the next part of the subject.

    (III.) The next step is for such judges to interpret, wrest, and pervert the laws so as to prepare for prospective Acts of Tyranny.

    Here, Gentlemen of the Jury, I shall have only too many examples to warn you with.

    Early in his reign James I. sought to lay burthensome taxes on the people without any act of Parliament; this practice was continued by his successors.

    1. In 1606 came "the great Case of Impositions," not mentioned in the

    ordinary histories of England. The king assumed the right to tax the nation by his own prerogative. He ordered a duty of five shillings on every hundred pounds of currants imported into the kingdom to be levied in addition to the regular duty affixed by Act of Parliament.

    This was contrary to law, nay, to the Constitution of England, her Magna Charta itself provided against unparliamentary taxation. Sir John Bates, a London merchant, refused to pay the unlawful duty, and was prosecuted by information in the Star-Chamber. "The courts of justice," says Mr.

    Hallam, "did not consist of men conscientiously impartial between the king and the subject; some corrupt with hopes of promotion, many more fearful of removal, or awe-struck by the fear of power." On the "trial" it was abundantly shown that the king had no right to levy such a duty.

    "The accomplished but too pliant judges, and those indefatigable hunters of precedents for violations of constitutional government, the great law-officers of the crown," decided against the laws, and Chief Justice Fleming maintained that the king might lay what tax he pleased on imported goods!

    The corrupt decision settled the law for years--and gave the king absolute power over this branch of the revenue, involving a complete destruction of the liberty of the people,--for the Principle would carry a thousand measures on its back.[61] The king declared Fleming a judge to his "heart's content." Bacon's subserviency did not pass unrewarded.

    Soon after James issued a decree under the great seal, imposing heavy duties on almost all merchandise "to be for ever hereafter paid to the king and his successors, on pain of his displeasure."[62] Thus the Measure became a Principle.

    [Footnote 61: 2 St. Tr. 371, and 11 Hargrave, 29; 1 Campbell's Justices, 204.]

    [Footnote 62: 1 Hallam, 231. See 1 Parl. Hist. 1030, 1132, 1150;

    Baker's Chronicle, 430.]

    1. James, wanting funds, demanded of his subjects forced contributions

    of money,--strangely called "Benevolences," though there was no "good-will" on either side. It was clearly against the fundamental laws of the kingdom. Sir Oliver St. John refused to pay what was demanded of him, and wrote a letter to the mayor of Marlborough against the illegal exaction. For this he was prosecuted in the Star-Chamber in 1615 by Attorney-General Bacon. The court, with Lord Chancellor Ellesmere at its head, of course decided that the king had a right to levy Benevolences at pleasure. St. John was fined five thousand pounds, and punished by imprisonment during the king's pleasure.

    This decision gave the king absolute power over all property in the realm,--every private purse was in his hands![63] With such a court the king might well say, "Wheare any controversyes arise, my Lordes the Judges chosene betwixte me and my people shall discide and rulle me."[64]

    [Footnote 63: 2 St. Tr. 899; 1 Hallam, 251; 2 Campbell, 291.]

    [Footnote 64: 1 Parl. Hist. 1156.]

    1. Charles I. proceeded in the steps of his father: he levied forced

    loans. Thomas Darnel and others refused to pay, and were put in prison on a General Warrant from the king which did not specify the cause of commitment. They brought their writs of habeas corpus, contending that their confinement was illegal. The matter came to trial in 1627.

    Sir Randolf Crewe, a man too just to be trusted to do the iniquity desired, was thrust out of office, and Sir Nicolas Hyde appointed chief justice in his place. The actual question was, Has the king a right to imprison any subject forever without process of law? It was abundantly shown that he had no such right. But the new chief justice, put in power to oppress the people, remembering the hand that fed him, thus decreed,--"Mr.

    Attorney hath told you that the king hath done it, and we trust him in great matters, and he is bound by law, and he bids us proceed by law; ... and we make no doubt but the king, if you look to him, he knowing the cause why you are imprisoned, he will have mercy; but that we believe that ... he cannot deliver you, but you must be remanded." Thus the judges gave the king absolute power over the liberties of any subject.[65]

    [Footnote 65: 3 St. Tr. 1. See also 2 Parl. Hist. 288; 1 Rushworth and 1 Mrs. Macaulay, 341.]

    But the matter was brought up in Parliament and discussed by men of a different temper, who frightened the judge by threats of impeachment, and forced the king to agree to the PETITION OF RIGHT designed to put an end to all such illegal cruelty.

    Before Charles I. would sign that famous bill, he asked Judge Hyde if it would restrain the king "from committing or restraining a subject without showing cause." The crafty judge answered, "Every law, after it is made, hath its exposition, which is to be left to the courts of justice to determine; and although the Petition be granted there is no fear of [such a] conclusion as is intimated in the question!" That is, the court will interpret the plain law so as to oppress the subject and please the king!

    As the judges had promised to annul the law, the king signed it.[66] Charles dissolved Parliament and threw into jail its most noble and powerful members--one of whom, Eliot, never left the prison till death set him free.[67] The same chief justice gave an extrajudicial opinion justifying the illegal seizure of the members,--"that a parliament man committing an offence against the King in Parliament not in a parliamentary course, may be punished after the Parliament is ended;" "that by false slanders to bring the Lords of the Council and the Judges, not in a parliamentary way, into the hatred of the people and the government into contempt, was punishable out of Parliament, in the Star-Chamber, as an offence committed in Parliament beyond the office, and beside the duty of a parliament man."[68] Thus the judges struck down freedom of speech in Parliament.

    [Footnote 66: 1 Campbell, Justices, 311; 2 Parl. Hist. 245, 350, 373, 408, et al.; 3 St. Tr. 59.]

    [Footnote 67: See above, p. 29.]

    [Footnote 68: 1 Campbell's Justices, 315.]

    1. In 1634 Charles I. issued a writ levying ship-money, so called, on

    some seaport towns, without act of Parliament. London and some towns remonstrated, but were forced to submit, all the courts being against them. Chief Justice Finch, "a servile tool of the despotic court," generalized this unlawful tax, extending it to inland towns as well as seaboard, to all the kingdom. All landholders were to be assessed in proportion to their property, and the tax, if not voluntarily paid, collected by force. The tax was unpopular, and clearly against the fundamental law of the kingdom.

    But if the government could not get the law on its side it could control its interpreters, for "every law hath its exposition." So the Judges of Assize were ordered in their circuits to tell the people to comply with the order and pay the money! The King got all extrajudicial opinion of the twelve Judges delivered irregularly, out of court, in which they unanimously declared that in time of danger the King might levy such tax as he saw fit, and compel men to pay it. He was the sole judge of the danger, and of the amount of the tax.[69]

    [Footnote 69: 3 St. Tr. 825. See the opinion of the Judges with their twelve names, 844, and note [dagger symbol].]

    John Hampden was taxed twenty shillings--he refused to pay, though he knew well the fate of Richard Chambers a few years before. The case came to trial in 1637, in the Court of Exchequer before Lord Chancellor Coventry, a base creature, mentioned before. It was "the great case of Ship-money." The ablest lawyers in England showed that the tax was contrary to Magna Charta, to the fundamental laws of the realm, to the Petition of Right and to the practice of the kingdom.

    Hampden was defeated. Ten out of the twelve Judges sided with the King. Croke as the eleventh had made up his mind to do the same, but his noble wife implored him not to sacrifice his conscience for fear of danger, and the Woman, as it so often happens, saved the man.[70] Attorney-General Banks thus set forth the opinion of the Government, and the consequent "decision" of the Judges. He rested the right of levying Ship-money on the "intrinsic, absolute authority of the King."

    There was no Higher Law in Old England in 1634! Banks said, "this power [of arbitrary and irresponsible taxation] is innate in the person of an absolute King, and in the persons of the Kings of England. All-magistracy it is of nature; and obedience and subjection [to] it is of nature. This power is not anyways derived from the people, but reserved unto the King when positive laws first began. For the King of England, he is an absolute monarch; nothing can be given to an absolute prince but what is inherent in his person. He can do no wrong.

    He is the sole judge and we ought not to question him, whom the law trusts we ought not to distrust." "The Acts of Parliament contain no express words to take away so high a prerogative; and the King's prerogative, even in lesser matters, is always saved, where express words do not restrain it."[71]

    [Footnote 70: Whitelocke, Memor. 25.]

    [Footnote 71: 2 Hallam, 16.]

    It required six months of judicial labor to bring forth this result, which was of "infinite disservice to the crown." Thereupon Mr. Hallam says:--

    "Those who had trusted to the faith of the judges were
    undeceived by the honest repentance of some, and looked with
    indignation on so prostituted a crew. That respect for
    courts of justice which the happy structure of our Judicial
    administration has in general kept inviolate, was exchanged
    for distrust, contempt, and a desire of vengeance. They
    heard the speeches of some of the Judges with more
    displeasure than even their final decision.

    Ship-money was
    held lawful by Finch and several other Judges, not on the
    authority of precedents which must in their nature have some
    bounds, but on principles subversive of every property or
    privilege in the subject. Those paramount rights of
    monarchy, to which they appealed to-day in justification of
    Ship-money, might to-morrow serve to supersede other laws,
    and maintain more exertions of despotic power. It was
    manifest by the whole strain of the court lawyers that no
    limitations on the King's authority could exist but by the
    King's sufferance.

    This alarming tenet, long bruited among
    the churchmen and courtiers, now resounded in the halls of
    justice."[72]

    [Footnote 72: 2 Hallam, 18.]

    Thus by the purchased vote of a corrupt Judiciary all the laws of Parliament, all the customs of the Anglo-Saxon tribe, Magna Charta itself with its noble attendant charters, were at once swept away, and all the property of the kingdom put into the hands of the enemy of the People. These four decisions would make the King of England as absolute as the Sultan of Turkey, or the Russian Czar.

    If the opinion of the Judges in the case of Impositions and Ship-money were accepted in law,--then all the Property of the People was the King's; if the courts were correct in their judgments giving the King the power by his mere will to imprison any subject, during pleasure, and also to do the same even with members of Parliament and punish them for debates in the House of Commons, then all liberty was at an end, and the King's Prerogative extended over all acts of Parliament, all property, all persons.

    1. One step more must be taken to make the logic of despotism perfect,

    and complete the chain. That work was delegated to clergymen purchased for the purpose--Rev. Dr. Robert Sibthorpe and Rev. Dr. Roger Mainwaring.

    The first in a sermon "of rendering all their dues," preached and printed in 1627, says, "the Prince who is the Head, and makes his Court and Council, it is his duty to direct and make laws. 'He doth whatsoever pleaseth him;' 'where the word of the King is there is power, and who may say unto him, What doest thou?'" And again, "If Princes command any thing which subjects may not perform, because it is against the Laws of God, or of Nature, or impossible; yet Subjects are bound to undergo the punishment, without either resisting, or railing, or reviling, and are to yield a Passive Obedience where they cannot exhibit an Active one, ... but in all others he is bound to active obedience."[73]

    [Footnote 73: Cited in Franklyn, 208; 1 Rushworth, 422, 436, 444.]

    Mainwaring went further, and in two famous sermons--preached, one on the 4th of July, 1628, the other on the 29th of the same month--declared that "the King is not bound to observe the Laws of the Realm concerning the Subject's Rights and Liberties, but that his Royal will and Command, in imposing Loans, and Taxes, without consent of Parliament, doth oblige the subject's conscience upon pain of eternal damnation.

    That those who refused to pay this Loan offended against the Law of God and the King's Supreme Authority, and became guilty of Impiety, Disloyalty, and Rebellion. And that the authority of Parliament is not necessary for the raising of Aid and Subsidies; and that the slow proceedings of such great Assemblies were not fitted for the Supply of the State's urgent necessities, but would rather produce sundry impediments to the just designs of Princes." "That Kings partake of omnipotence with God."[74]

    [Footnote 74: Franklyn, 208, 592. These two Sermons were published in a volume with the title "Religion and Allegiance."... "Published by his Majesty's special command." (London, 1628.) Prof. Stuart seems inspired by this title in giving a name to his remarkable publication--written with the same spirit as Dr. Mainwaring's--"Conscience and the Constitution." (Andover, 1851.) See 3 St. Tr. 335; 1 Rushworth, 422, 436, 585, et al.; 1 Hallam, 307; 2 Parl. Hist. 388, 410.]

    The nation was enraged. Mainwaring was brought before Parliament, punished with fine and imprisonment and temporary suspension from office and perpetual disability for ecclesiastical preferment. But the King who ordered the publication of the sermons, and who doubtless had induced him to preach them, immediately made him Rector of Stamford Parish, soon appointed him Dean of Worcester, and finally in 1645 made him Bishop of St. David's. A few years ago such clerical apostasy would seem astonishing to an American.

    But now, Gentlemen of the Jury, so rapid has been the downfall of public virtue, that men filling the pulpits once graced and dignified by noblest puritanic piety, now publicly declare there is no law of God above the fugitive slave bill.

    Nay, a distinguished American minister boldly proclaimed his readiness to send his own Mother (or "Brother") into eternal bondage! Thus modern history explains the old; and the cheap bait of a republican bribe can seduce American dissenters, as the wealthy lure of royal gifts once drew British churchmen into the same pit of infamy. Alas, hypocrisy is of no sect or nation.

    Gentlemen, the Government of England once decreed "that every clergyman, four times in the year, should instruct his parishioners in the Divine right of Kings, and the damnable sin of resistance."[75] No Higher Law! America has ministers who need no act of Parliament to teach them to do the same; they run before they are sent.

    [Footnote 75: 2 Campbell, 460; 1 Rushworth, 1205.]

    1. After the head of one Stuart was shorn off and his son had

    returned, no wiser nor better than his father, the old progress of despotism began anew. I pass over what would but repeat the former history, and take two new examples to warn the nation with, differing from the old only in form.

    In 1672, Charles II. published a proclamation denouncing rigorous penalties against all such as should speak disrespectfully of his acts, or hearing others thus speak should not immediately inform the magistrates! Nay, in 1675, after he had sold himself to the French king, and was in receipt of an annual pension therefrom, he had this test-oath published for all to sign: "I do solemnly declare that it is not lawful upon any pretence whatever to take up arms against the king, ... and that I will not, at any time to come, endeavor the alteration of the government, either in Church or State."[76]

    [Footnote 76: Carroll's Counter Revolution (Lond. 1846), 99, et seq.]

    An oath yet more stringent was enforced in Scotland with the edge of the sword, namely, to defend all the prerogatives of the crown, "never without the king's permission to take part in any deliberations upon ecclesiastical or civil affairs; and never to seek any reform in Church or State."

    Notwithstanding all that the Charleses had done to break down the liberty of Englishmen, still the great corporate towns held out, intrenched behind their charters, and from that bulwark both annoyed the despot and defended the civil rights of the citizen. They also must be destroyed. So summons of quo warranto were served upon them, which frightened the smaller corporations and brought down their charters.

    Jeffreys was serviceable in this wicked work, and on his return from his Northern Circuit, rich with these infamous spoils, as a reward for destroying the liberties of his countrymen, the king publicly presented him with a ring, in token of "acceptance of his most eminent services." This fact was duly blazoned in the Gazette, and Jeffreys was "esteemed a mighty favorite," which, "together with his lofty airs, made all the charters, like the walls of Jericho, fall down before him, and he returned, laden with surrenders, the spoil of towns."[77]

    [Footnote 77: 8 St. Tr. 1038, and the quotations from North (Examen.)

    Sprat, and Roger Coke, in note on p. 1041, et seq. See, too, Fox, James II. p. 48, 54, and Appendix, Barillon's Letter of Dec. 7th, 1684.]

    London still remained the strong-hold of commerce, of the Protestant Religion, and of liberal Ideas in domestic Government; for though subsequently corrupted by lust of gain, which sought a monopoly, the great commercial estates and families of England were not then on the side of Despotism, as now strangely happens in America.

    When the king sought to ruin Shaftesbury,--a corrupt man doubtless, but then on the side of liberty, the enemy of encroaching despotism,--a London Grand-Jury refused to find a bill, and was warmly applauded by the city. Their verdict of IGNORAMUS was a "personal liberty bill" for that time, and therefore was the king's wrath exceeding hot, for "Ignoramus was mounted in Cathedra," and there was a stop put to such wickedness. So London must be brought down. She refused to surrender her Charter.

    In 1682 the king proceeded to wrest it from her by the purchased hand of the courts of law. But even they were not quite adequate to the work. So Chief Justice Pemberton was displaced, and Saunders,--a man as offensive in his personal habit of body as he was corrupt in conduct and character--was put in his office. Dolbin, too just for the crime demanded of him, was turned out, and Withins made to succeed him. For "so great a weight was there at stake as could not be trusted to men of doubtful principles," says North.

    Saunders, who had plotted this whole matter, was struck with an apoplexy when sentence was to be given, but sent his opinion in writing. Thus on the judgment given by only two judges, who assigned no reasons for their decision, it was declared that the Charter of London was forfeit, and the liberties and franchises of the city should "be seized into the king's hands."[78]

    [Footnote 78: 2 Hallam, 333; Burnet, Own Times (London, 1838), 350; 8 St. Tr. 1039, 1081 note, 1267, et seq.; 2 Campbell, Justices, 63;

    North's Examen. 626; Fox, 54.]

    Thus fell the charter of London! Gentlemen of the Jury, the same sword was soon to strike at the neck of New England; the charter of Massachusetts could not be safe in such a time.

    In 1686 James II. wished to destroy Protestantism,--not that he loved the Roman form of religion, but that tyranny which it would help him get and keep. So he claimed the right by his royal prerogative to dispense with any laws of the land. Of the twelve Judges of England eight were found on his side, and the four unexpectedly proven faithful were at once dismissed from office and their places filled with courtiers of the king, and the court was unanimous that the king had a constitutional right to destroy the constitution.

    Then he had not only command of the purses of his subjects and their bodies, but also of their mind and conscience, and could dictate the actual Religion of the People as well as the official "religion" of the priests.[79]

    [Footnote 79: 11 St. Tr. 1165; 12 Ibid. 358.]

    One State-secret lay at the bottom of the Stuarts' plans,--to appoint base men for judges, and if by accident a just man came upon the bench, to keep him in obscurity or to hustle him from his post. What names they offer us--Kelyng, Finch, Saunders, Wright, Jeffreys, Scroggs![80] infamous creatures, but admirable instruments to destroy generous men withal and devise means for the annihilation of the liberties of the people.

    Historians commonly dwell on the fields of battle, recording the victories of humanity, whereof the pike and gun were instruments; but pass idly over the more important warfare which goes on in the court house, only a few looking on, where lawyers are the champions of mankind, and the battle turns on a sentence; nay, on a word which determines the welfare of a nation for ages to come. On such little hinges of law do the great gates hang, and open or shut to let in the happiness or the ruin of millions of men!

    Naseby and Worcester are important places truly, venerable for great deeds.

    Cromwell and Blake are names not likely to perish while men can appreciate the heroism which sheds blood. But Westminster Hall has rung with more important thunder than cannon ever spoke, and Pym and Selden, St. John and Hampden--nay, Penn, Bunyan, Fox, Lilburne--have done great service for mankind. Gentlemen of the Jury, it is a matter of great magnitude which hinges on the small question of fact and law to-day. You are to open or shut for Humanity. If the People make themselves sheep there will be wolves enough to eat you up.

    [Footnote 80: This last name is thought to be extinct in Great Britain, but I find one Thomas Scruggs in Massachusetts in 1635 et post, 1 Mass. Records (1628-1641), index.]

    It is difficult to calculate the amount of evil wrought by such corrupt judges as I have spoken of; they poison the fountains of society. I need not speak of monsters like Scroggs and Jeffreys, whose names rot in perpetual infamy, but creatures less ignoble, like Wright, Saunders, Finch, Kelyng, Thurlow, Loughborough, and their coadjutors, must be regarded as far more dangerous than thieves, murderers, or pirates. A cruel, insolent Judge selecting the worst customs, the most oppressive statutes, and decisions which outrage human nature--what an amount of evil he can inflict on groaning humanity!

    • * * * *

    Gentlemen of the Jury, in this long sad history of judicial tyranny in England there is one thing particularly plain: such judges hate freedom of speech, they would restrict the Press, the Tongue, yes, the Thought of mankind. Especially do they hate any man who examines the actions of the government and its servile courts, and their violation of justice and the laws. They wish to take exemplary and malignant vengeance on all such. Let me freshen your knowledge of some examples.

    1. In 1410 the government made a decree "that whatsoever they were

    that should rede the Scriptures in the mother tongue, they should forfeit land, catel, body, lif, and godes from their heyres forever, and so be condempned for heretykes to God, enemies to the crowne, and most errant traiters to the land." The next year, in one day thirty-nine persons were first hanged and then burned for this "crime."[81]

    [Footnote 81: 1 St. Tr. 252.]

    1. In 1590, Mr. Udall, a Puritan minister, published a book,

    "Demonstrations of Discipline," not agreeable to the authorities. He was brought to a trial for a Felony,--not merely a "misdemeanor." The jury were ordered by the judge to find him guilty of that crime if they were satisfied that he published the book,--for the court were to judge whether the deed amounted to that crime! He was found "guilty," and died in jail after nearly three years of cruel confinement.[82]

    [Footnote 82: 1 St. Tr. 1271; 1 Neal's Puritans (N.Y. 1844), 190. See 16 Parl. Hist. 1276, where Mr. Dunning says this is the first example of such a charge to a jury.]

    1. In 1619 one Williams of Essex wrote a book explaining a passage in

    the book of Daniel as foretelling the death of James I. in 1621. He inclosed the manuscript in a box, sealed it, and secretly conveyed it to the king. For this he was tried for high treason, and of course executed. "Punitur Affectus, licet non sequatur Effectus," said the court, for "Scribere est agere," "Punish the wish though the object be not reached," for "writing is doing!"[83]

    [Footnote 83: 2 St. Tr. 1085.]

    1. In 1664 Mr. Keach, a Baptist, published a "Childs' Instructer, or a

    New and Easy Primmer," in which he taught the doctrines of his sect, "that children ought not to be baptized" but only adults; "that laymen may preach the gospel." He was brought before Lord Chief Justice Hyde, who after insulting the prisoner, thus charged the grand-jury:--"He is a base and dangerous fellow; and if this be suffered, children by learning of it will become such as he is, and therefore I hope you will do your duty." Of course such a jury indicted him. The "trial" took place before Judge Scroggs; the Jury were at first divided in opinion. "But," said the Judge, "you must agree!" So they found him guilty.

    He was fined "£20, twice set in the pillory, and bound to make public submission."[84]

    [Footnote 84: 7 St. Tr. 687.]

    1. In 1679 George Wakeman and others were tried for high treason

    before Scroggs, whose conduct was atrocious, and several pamphlets were published commenting on the ridiculous and absurd conduct of this functionary, "Lord Chief Justice Scroggs." One Richard Radley in a bantering talk had bid another man "Go to Weal Hall, to my Lord Scroggs, for he has received money enough of Dr. Wakeman!" Radley was indicted for "speaking scandalous words of Chief Justice Scroggs."

    Whereupon at the opening of the court that eminent officer, who did not disdain to wreak public and judicial vengeance on heads that wrought his private and personal grief, made a speech setting forth his magisterial opinions on the liberty of the press. Doubtless this court knows original authority for the opinions they follow; but for your instruction, Gentlemen of the Jury, I will give you the chief things in the judicial speech of Scroggs, Lord Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of England in 1679.[85]

    [Footnote 85: 6 St. Tr. 701; see Dunning in 16 Parl. Hist. 1276, et seq.]

    "For these hireling scribblers who traduce it [the fairness
    and equality of the trial in which he had been notoriously
    unfair and unequal], who write to eat, and lie for bread, I
    intend to meet with them another way; for they are only safe
    while they can be secret; but so are vermin, so long as they
    can hide themselves.... They shall know that the law wants
    not the power to punish a libellous and licentious press,
    nor I a resolution to exact it.

    And this is all the answer
    is fit to be given (besides a whip) to these hackney
    writers." "However, in the mean time, the extravagant
    boldness of men's pens and tongues is not to be endured, but
    shall be severely punished
    ; for if once causes come to be
    tried with complacency to particular opinions, and shall be
    innocently censured if they go otherwise, public causes
    shall all receive the doom as the multitude happen to be
    possessed; and at length any cause shall become public ...
    at every session the Judges shall be arraigned, the Jury
    condemned, and the verdicts overawed to comply with popular
    wish and indecent shouts."

    "There are a set of men ... that too much approve and
    countenance such vulgar ways, ... that embrace all sorts of
    informations, true or false, likely or impossible, nay
    though never so silly and ridiculous, they refuse none; so
    shall all addresses be made to them, and they be looked on
    as the only patrons of religion and government!"

    His associates chimed in with accordant howl. Puny Judge Jones declared,--

    "We have a particular case here before us, as a matter of
    scandal against a great Judge, the greatest Judge in the
    kingdom
    , in criminal causes [the Lord Chancellor Nottingham
    was greater in civil causes]; and it is a great and an
    high charge upon him.

    And certainly there was never any age,
    I think, more licentious than this in aspersing governors,
    scattering of libels and scandalous speeches against those
    that are in authority
    : and without all doubt it doth
    become the court to show their zeal in suppressing it
    ." [It
    was 'resisting an officer.'] "That trial [of Dr. Wakeman]
    was managed with exact justice and perfect integrity.

    And
    therefore I do think it very fit that this person be
    proceeded against by an information, that he may be made a
    public example
    to all such as shall presume to scandalize
    the government, and the governors, with any false aspersions
    and accusations."

    Accordingly Mr. Radley, for that act, was convicted of speaking "scandalous words against the Lord Chief Justice Scroggs" and fined £200.[86]

    [Footnote 86: 7 St. Tr. 701.]

    Mr. Hudson says of the Star-Chamber, "So tender the court is of upholding the honor of the sentence, as they will punish them who speak against it with great severity."[87]

    [Footnote 87: In 2 Collectanea Juridica, 228.]

    1. In 1680 Benjamin Harris, a bookseller, sold a work called "An

    Appeal from the country to the city for the Preservation of his Majesty's Person, Liberty, Property, and the Protestant Religion." He was brought to trial for a libel, before Recorder Jeffreys and Chief Justice Scroggs who instructed the jury they were only to inquire if Harris sold the book, and if so, find him "guilty." It was for the court to determine what was a libel. He was fined five hundred pounds and placed in the pillory; the Chief Justice wished that he might be also whipped.[88]

    [Footnote 88: 7 St. Tr. 925.]

    1. The same year Henry Carr was brought to trial. He published a

    periodical--"the Weekly Packet of advice from Rome, or the History of Popery"--hostile to Romanism. Before the case came to court, Scroggs prohibited the publication on his own authority. Mr. Carr was prosecuted for a libel before the same authority, and of course found guilty. The character of that court also was judgment against natural right. Jane Curtis and other women were in like manner punished for speaking or publishing words against the same "great judge."[89] And it was held to be a "misdemeanor" to publish a book reflecting on the justice of the nation--the truer the book the worse the libel!

    It was "obstructing an officer," and of course it was a greater offence to "obstruct" him with Justice and Truth than with wrong and lies. The greater the justice of the act the more dangerous the "crime!" If the language did not hit any one person it was "malice against all mankind."

    [Footnote 89: 7 St. Tr. 1111, 959; 4 Parl. Hist. 1274.]

    1. In 1684 Sir Samuel Barnardiston was brought to trial charged with a

    "High Misdemeanor." He had written three private letters to be sent--it was alleged--by post to his friend, also a private man. The letters do not appear designed for any further publication or use; they related to matters of news, the events of the day and comments thereon, and spoke in praise of Algernon Sidney and Lord Russell who were so wickedly beheaded about the time the letters were written. It would require a microscopic eye to detect any evil lurking there.

    Jeffreys presided at the trial, and told the jury:--

    "The letters are factious, seditious, and malicious
    letters, and as base as the worst of mankind could ever have
    invented
    ." "And if he be guilty of it--the greater the man
    is the greater the crime, and the more understanding he has,
    the more malicious he seems to be; for your little ordinary
    sort of people, that are of common mean understanding, they
    may be wheedled and drawn in, and surprised into such
    things; but men of a public figure and of some value in the
    world that have been taken to be men of the greatest
    interest and reputation in a party, it cannot be thought a
    hidden surprise upon them; no, it is a work of time and
    thought, it is a thing fixed in his very nature, and it
    shows so much venom as would make one think the whole mass
    of his blood were corrupt
    ." "Here is the matter he is now
    accused of, and here is in it malice against the king,
    malice against the government, malice against both Church
    and State, malice against any man that bears any share in
    the government, indeed malice against all mankind that are
    not of the same persuasion with these bloody miscreants."
    "Here is ... the sainting of two horrid conspirators!

    Here
    is the Lord Russell sainted, that blessed martyr; Lord
    Russell, that good man, that excellent Protestant, he is
    lamented! And here is Mr. Sidney sainted, what an
    extraordinary man he was! Yes, surely he was a very good
    man--and it is a shame to think that such bloody miscreants
    should be sainted and lamented who had any hand in that
    horrid murder [the execution of Charles I.] and treason ...
    who could confidently bless God for their being engaged in
    that good cause (as they call it) which was the rebellion
    which brought that blessed martyr to his death.

    It is high
    time for all mankind that have any Christianity, or fear of
    Heaven or Hell, to bestir themselves, to rid the nation of
    such caterpillars, such monsters of villany as those are!"

    Of course the packed jury found him guilty; he was fined £10,000.[90]

    [Footnote 90: 7 St. Tr. 1333.]

    Gentlemen of the Jury, such judges, with such kings and cabinets, have repeatedly brought the dearest rights of mankind into imminent peril.

    Sad indeed is the condition of a nation where Thought is not free, where the lips are sewed together, and the press is chained! Yet the evil which has ruined Spain and made an Asia Minor of Papal Italy, once threatened England. Nay, Gentlemen of the Jury, it required the greatest efforts of her noblest sons to vindicate for you and me the right to print, to speak, to think. Milton's "Speech for the Liberty of unlicensed Printing" is one monument of the warfare which lasted from Wicliffe to Thomas Carlyle.

    But other monuments are the fines and imprisonment, the exile and the beheading of men and women! Words are "sedition," "rebellion," "treason;" nay, even now at least in New England, a true word is a "Misdemeanor," it is "obstructing an officer." At how great cost has our modern liberty of speech been purchased! Answer John Lilburne, answer William Prynn, and Selden, and Eliot, and Hampden, and the other noble men who

    ----"in the public breach devoted stood,
    And for their country's cause were prodigal of blood."

    Answer Fox and Bunyan, and Penn and all the host of Baptists, Puritans, Quakers, martyrs, and confessors--it is by your stripes that we are healed! Healed! are we healed? Ask the court if it be not a "misdemeanor" to say so!

    A despotic government hates implacably the freedom of the press. In 1680 the Lord Chief Justice of England declared the opinion of the twelve judges "indeed all subscribe that to print or publish any news-books, or pamphlets of news whatsoever, is illegal; that it is a manifest intent to the breach of the peace, and they may be proceeded against by law for an illegal thing." "And that is for a public notice to all people, and especially printers and booksellers, that _they ought to print no book or pamphlet of news whatsoever without autho

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Trial of Theodore Parker
    Author
    Theodore Parker
    Release date
    February 17, 2010 [eBook #31298]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Meredith Bach, Linda Cantoni, and the Online
    Most recently updated
    January 6, 2021
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by Meredith Bach, Linda Cantoni, and the Online
    Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This
    file was produced from images generously made available
    by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    [Transcriber's Note: A table of contents has been added for the
    reader's convenience. Errors listed in the Errata section have been
    noted with a [Transcriber's Note]; other obvious printer errors have
    been corrected without note.]
    
    
    
    
    THE TRIAL
    
    OF
    
    THEODORE PARKER,
    
    FOR THE
    
    "MISDEMEANOR"
    
    OF
    
    A Speech in Faneuil Hall against Kidnapping,
    
    BEFORE THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
    
    AT BOSTON, APRIL 3, 1855.
    
    WITH
    
    THE DEFENCE,
    
    
    BY
    
    THEODORE PARKER,
    
    MINISTER OF THE TWENTY-EIGHTH CONGREGATIONAL SOCIETY IN BOSTON.
    
    
    BOSTON:
    PUBLISHED FOR THE AUTHOR.
    1855.
    
    Entered according to Act of Congress, in the year 1855, by
    
    THEODORE PARKER,
    
    In the Clerk's Office of the District Court of the District of
      Massachusetts.
    
    CAMBRIDGE:
    ALLEN AND FARNHAM, PRINTERS.
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    
    PREFACE
    INTRODUCTION
    DEFENCE
    ERRATA
    OTHER WORKS BY THE SAME AUTHOR
    
    
    
    
    TO
    
    JOHN PARKER HALE
    
    AND
    
    CHARLES MAYO ELLIS,
    
    MAGNANIMOUS LAWYERS,
    
    FOR THEIR LABORS IN A NOBLE PROFESSION,
    
    WHICH HAVING ONCE IN ENGLAND ITS KELYNG, ITS SAUNDERS, ITS JEFFREYS,
    AND ITS SCROGGS, AS NOW IN AMERICA ITS SHARKEY, ITS GRIER, ITS CURTIS,
    AND ITS KANE, HAS YET ALSO SUCH GENEROUS ADVOCATES OF HUMANITY AS
    EQUAL THE GLORIES OF HOLT AND ERSKINE, OF MACKINTOSH AND ROMILLY,
    
    FOR THEIR ELOQUENT AND FEARLESS DEFENCE OF TRUTH, RIGHT, AND LOVE,
    
    THIS VOLUME IS DEDICATED,
    
    BY THEIR CLIENT AND FRIEND,
    
    THEODORE PARKER.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Trial of Theodore Parker
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Trial of Theodore Parker
    
    Author: Theodore Parker
    
    
            
    Release date: February 17, 2010 [eBook #31298]
                    Most recently updated: January 6, 2021
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/31298
    
    Credits: Produced by Meredith Bach, Linda Cantoni, and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This
            file was produced from images generously made available
            by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #31298. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 31298
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-22
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.