Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of A Stake in the Land
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 30529

A Stake in the Land

by Peter A. Speek · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2009
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    FOREWORD

    This volume is the result of studies in methods of Americanization prepared through funds furnished by the Carnegie Corporation of New York. It arose out of the fact that constant applications were being made to the Corporation for contributions to the work of numerous agencies engaged in various forms of social activity intended to extend among the people of the United States the knowledge of their government and their obligations to it. The trustees felt that a study which should set forth, not theories of social betterment, but a description of the methods of the various agencies engaged in such work, would be of distinct value to the cause itself and to the public.

    The outcome of the study is contained in eleven volumes on the following subjects: Schooling of the Immigrant; The Press; Adjustment of Homes and Family Life; Legal Protection and Correction; Health Standards and Care;

    Naturalization and Political Life; Industrial and Economic Amalgamation;

    Treatment of Immigrant Heritages; Neighborhood Agencies and Organization; Rural Developments; and Summary. The entire study has been carried out under the general direction of Mr. Allen T. Burns. Each volume appears in the name of the author who had immediate charge of the particular field it is intended to cover.

    Upon the invitation of the Carnegie Corporation a committee consisting of the late Theodore Roosevelt, Prof. John Graham Brooks, Dr. John M.

    Glenn, and Mr. John A. Voll has acted in an advisory capacity to the director. An editorial committee consisting of Dr. Talcott Williams, Dr.

    Raymond B. Fosdick, and Dr. Edwin F. Gay has read and criticized the manuscripts. To both of these committees the trustees of the Carnegie Corporation are much indebted.

    The purpose of the report is to give as clear a notion as possible of the methods of the agencies actually at work in this field and not to propose theories for dealing with the complicated questions involved.

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    PAGE

    Publisher's Note v

    Foreword vii

    Table of Contents ix

    List of Tables xii

    List of Illustrations xiii

    Introduction xv

    Author's Note xxvii

    PART I

    CHAPTER

    I. NEED OF A LAND POLICY 3

    Strength of Home Ties 3
    Immigrants' Love of Land 5
    Need for Land Regulation 10

    II. LEARNING OF LAND OPPORTUNITIES 14

    Friends, Agents, and Advertisements 14
    Federal and State Immigration Offices 18
    Policies in California and Wisconsin 19

    III. EXPERIENCES IN ACQUIRING LAND 24

    Russian Sectarian Peasants in the West 24
    The Successful Colony at Glendale 30
    Other California Cases 31
    An Oklahoma Settlement 33

    IV. INDIVIDUAL LAND DEALERS 36

    Land Sharks 37
    Lower Type of Land Dealer 39
    The Public-spirited Land Dealer 42
    "Realtors" 45

    V. PRIVATE LAND COLONIZATION COMPANIES 49

    A Typical Company 52
    The Adviser 62
    Children Overworked 65
    Securing Credit 66
    Conservation of Wooded Land 68
    The Size of a Colony 69
    Learning American Ways 70
    Two Points of View 72
    Colony Snapshots 78

    VI. PUBLIC LAND COLONIZATION 86

    The California Experiment 86
    State Provisions for Soldier Settlements 91
    The Reclamation Act 95
    Proposed Federal Legislation 98
    Provision in Other Countries 105

    VII. A LAND POLICY 107

    Wide Range in Programs 107
    Plenty of Land 111
    Public Regulation of Land Dealing 112
    A Public Land Exchange 122
    Reclamation a Separate Function 124
    A Colonization Board 127
    Extension of Public Credit 135
    Co-operation Indispensable 135

    PART II

    VIII. RURAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCIES 145

    Importance of Education 145
    Bridging Differences 150
    Parochial Schools 153

    IX. PRIVATE SCHOOLS 156

    Nebraska 158
    North Dakota 161
    Minnesota 164
    Michigan 167
    Wisconsin 172
    South Dakota 174
    California 175
    Hebrew School in New Jersey 176
    Opinions on Both Sides 176
    Temporary Usefulness 179
    Need for Regulation 180

    X. IMMIGRANT CHURCHES 182

    Bilingual Services 186
    English Favored by Members 188
    Opposition to "Interfaith" Marriages 189
    Immigrant Pastors 192
    Potential Powers for Good 193

    XI. THE PUBLIC SCHOOL 195

    Limitations of the One-teacher School 195
    Growth of the Consolidated School 199
    The Rural School-teacher 203
    Irregular School Attendance 211
    Practical Curriculum Needed 217
    Need for Expert Administration 219
    Proposed Measures 222

    XII. EDUCATION OF ADULT IMMIGRANT SETTLERS 226

    Importance of Reaching Women 226
    The Home Teacher 228
    Organization of Immigrant Women 231
    The Public Evening School 233
    Education Made Interesting 241

    XIII. LIBRARY AND COMMUNITY WORK 244

    Place of the Printed Word 244
    Rural Needs for Books 246
    Package Libraries in Wisconsin 248
    Selection of Books 250
    A Community Hall 252
    Amateur Theatricals 254
    Community Teamwork 256

    INDEX 259

    LIST OF TABLES

    TABLE PAGE

    I. Number (by sex) of foreign-born white persons
    engaged as farm laborers in the United
    States, 1900 and 1910 6

    II. State legislation to promote land settlement
    for soldiers up to June, 1919 92-93

    III. Soldier settlement plans for United Kingdom
    and provinces Facing 106

    IV. Per cent unable to speak English, of total foreign
    born, ten years of age and over, in urban
    and rural communities 147

    V. Enrollment and language used in parochial and
    private schools in Minnesota, 1918 165

    VI. Enrollment and teaching force of private and
    parochial schools in Wisconsin, 1914-15
    and 1915-16 173

    VII. Length of teaching service in Wisconsin rural
    schools, 1915-16 204

    VIII. Percentage of population in Arizona, six to
    twenty-one years of age, in schools and not
    attending school, 1915-16 213

    ILLUSTRATIONS

    Long, Hard Months of Work Separate the
    Rough Shanty from White Clapboards and
    an Automobile Frontispiece

    Land Is Not the Only Stake in America for
    These Polish Parents Facing p. 4

    The Owner of this Farm, Settled in 1917, Has
    Persuaded Six Members of His Family to
    Buy Farms in the Neighborhood " 14

    Friendly Assistance Makes Pioneering Less
    Baffling " 44

    The Wisconsin Colonization Company Sees the
    Need of Community Centers " 54

    This Two-year-old Wisconsin Farm Is Just
    Ready to Care for Its Newly Acquired
    Shropshire Ewes " 64

    This Settler Started Ten Years Ago with No
    Money " 136

    These Children and Teachers in New Mexico
    Join Forces to Wipe Out Illiteracy " 146

    The Largest Girl Won a Prize for Scholarship " 146

    Immediate Returns from Child Labor Do Not
    Make Up for Loss of Schooling " 214

    The Arrival of an Immigrant Settler in 1883
    Was Shown in a Community Pageant " 242

    The Same Man Is Working for Land and Community
    Development " 242

    A Rural Community Center Plan Was Developed
    by the Wisconsin Colonization
    Company for Southern Sawyer County " 252

    INTRODUCTION

    Students of economics know that the roundabout methods of capitalistic production are far more fruitful than the direct methods of the primitive economy. As we advance, we introduce new intermediaries between the beginning and the end of production. This thought occurs to one in the study of Americanization. If we would Americanize the immigrant we must seek him out in his daily economic life and see to it that the influences under which he works are calculated to give him the right feeling toward his new home. A large part of our waking life is spent in gaining a livelihood, and our work brings with it most of our associations.

    School and church have their place for young and old, and they likewise must be considered. Their effect is direct and immediate and is more likely to attract attention than are the elements making up the economic life.

    Doctor Speek has done well in taking up the immigrant as a settler in the newer and developing parts of our country. The settlers are very largely immigrants who are trying to acquire a home and livelihood on the land. The writer of this Introduction has been studying this same subject for many years, and has done so in many different parts of the United States. The conclusion which we might reach deductively is confirmed by observation--namely, that the man who settles on the land in the right way is, with the rarest exceptions, likely to become a good American, as are also his children.

    But what do we mean by the right way? We mean that he must be on a farm of suitable size, of good productivity, with needed help in learning how to farm in the new country and with sufficient time in which to pay for his farm. These are not the only considerations, but they are the main ones, and to these Doctor Speek has given his attention.

    One of the outstanding features of every study of land settlement is that the first great cause of failure is poor selection of land. The second chief cause of failure is insufficient length of time in which to pay for the land. While this is of very great importance, it stands far behind the first as a cause of failure. The third cause of failure is closely connected with the second. It is inadequate credit and capital.

    We are dealing here with the results which are universal. The selection of land is extremely difficult, even for unusually intelligent farmers who have had long experience in our country. To select land wisely is quite beyond the capacity of the ordinary settler. The present writer could give unlimited illustrations of this truth.

    The man who has lived in the corn belt of Illinois is very apt to think that black soil is necessarily good soil, and, going to another state, may perhaps select some black peat land, underlain with sand, which is almost worthless. He is sure to be prejudiced against red soil, which may, after all, be good land.

    Once, when the writer was being shown citrous-fruit land in California, the wise friend who was his host would point to one orchard, which was "planted for oranges," and another "ranch" which "was planted to sell to suckers"; yet the ordinary man, even if he spent many years in the study of land values, could not tell the difference.

    John Stuart Mill presents, in his Principles of Political Economy, strong arguments for non-intervention of public authority in "the business of the community." He says that those who stand for intervention must make out a strong case. When, however, he turns to the consumer or buyer, he finds he is obliged to make many exceptions to the rule of non-intervention.

    To use his own words,[1] "The proposition that the consumer is a competent judge of the commodity can be admitted only with numerous abatements and exceptions." He uses also these words:[2] "Is the buyer always qualified to judge of the commodity?

    If not, the presumption in favor of the competition of the market does not apply to the case; and if the commodity be one in the quality of which society has much at stake, the balance of advantages may be in favor of some mode and degree of intervention by the authorized representatives of the collective interest of the state."

    We have, then, ample justification for some kind of help to the settler in the selection of land. What Doctor Speek presents to us simply confirms what is known to every thoughtful person who has given attention to the subject of land settlement. If we want to bring it about that our settlers should understand our institutions and become good American citizens, we must abandon all ideas of laissez-faire with respect to land selection.

    Generally the selection is made for the settler by the land agent. Doctor Speek gives attention to the real-estate business, and finds that it is not in a satisfactory condition. About this there can be no question. At the same time the present writer, as a result of careful observation, affirms without hesitation that probably no business has made greater progress toward a true professional level than has the land business during the last five years. Real-estate agents or brokers are forming associations and are doing a great deal to eliminate dishonest practices and to put into their business the idea of service.

    There are two lines of progress especially noteworthy. One is the development of Blue Sky laws, and the other is the requirement that those who engage in the real-estate business should have licenses. Blue Sky laws do not as yet afford anything like adequate protection, but certainly they may not be disregarded with impunity in Wisconsin. Licensing an occupation has been very generally one of the first steps toward putting it upon a professional basis. Doctor Speek relates what was attempted unsuccessfully in California. In Wisconsin we are just beginning the system of licenses, and so far it promises to be extremely helpful.

    Much more needs to be done, however, to help the settler make a good selection of a farm.

    Two outstanding movements are mentioned. One is the public-land settlement of California, under the direction of Dr. Elwood Mead, and the other is the work of the Director of Immigration of Wisconsin, Mr.

    B. G. Packer. Mr. Packer has been in the habit of meeting settlers in Chicago, the chief doorway into Wisconsin, and giving them advice of a general character in regard to the purchase of a farm in Wisconsin.

    While he is not in a position to recommend the purchase of a specific piece of land, the advice is pretty concrete and definite. His one thought very properly is the welfare of the settler, and he believes that it is in the interest of Wisconsin not to get as many settlers as possible, but to get settlers who, in his own words, "stick"--in other words, who will succeed. He does not for a moment hesitate to discourage a man from coming to Wisconsin if he is not likely to prove successful, and he does not for a moment hesitate to direct the attention of a settler away from a selection which would prove disastrous to him.

    The writer has visited many settlers in Wisconsin who have been brought to the state by Mr. Packer, and has found them almost universally prosperous.

    However, attention should be directed particularly to an important point made by Doctor Speek in his report. At present irresponsible and dishonest people often get hold of the settler first. Mr. Packer's work is being rapidly developed and it should have still larger funds for expansion. How is it going to be possible, however, to bring to the knowledge of all the settlers the helpful agencies that exist? These helpful agencies include not only the work of Mr. Packer, but of the county agents, and the different departments of the agricultural college, especially that department concerned with soil surveys, as well as with many others.

    In other states as well there are many helpful agencies for the settler.

    If the settler could only get hold of the men who are glad to help him he could make a wise selection of the land. Federal and state authorities must co-operate in efforts to bring to the settler a knowledge of the help that may be his.

    The City and Suburban Homes Company, of New York City, affords a suggestion. This company was formed in order to give the best homes possible to people in and about New York City compatible with very modest return on capital. The idea is that of serving the urban dweller.

    Vast as is the field of operation, it has accomplished appreciable results in New York City. Could not companies be formed to begin where the City and Suburban Homes Company leaves off? Two possibilities suggest themselves. One is the purchase and sale of land, and the other is disinterested advice.

    In this imperfect world perfection can never be attained, and with the best efforts mistakes will be made. With a strange perversity men often turn from those who are their true friends and give their confidence to the unscrupulous. A typical case is this: A man sold his small farm at a fair price. Those to whom he sold it were apprehensive lest he should waste the money and tried to help him make a wise investment. He had every reason for confidence in those who were trying to help him and who had never misled him, yet he was evidently suspicious that they were trying to serve their own ends.

    Shortly after receiving the money he took a journey into Canada, fell into the hands of land sharks, and lost every dollar he had received in the purchase of worthless lands.

    As a business becomes professional in character, connections are established with educational institutions. Medicine and law both occur to one as illustrations. Our universities are now developing courses in land economics, and these are going to be helpful in solving the problems of land settlement, as well as other land problems.

    Mention has been made of the length of time needed to pay for a farm. No mistake is more frequent than the mistake made in underestimating the length of time needed to buy a farm and to pay for it under the amortization plan--that is to say, by yearly installments, which include, with interest, a portion of the capital. Ireland affords a good illustration. As one great Land Act has followed another, the length of time for the payment of the farm has been increased, until now the amortization period is about sixty-eight years.

    With the higher return to labor in this country the writer thinks twenty-five to thirty years is about right. When we have this period for payment the annual payments of principal are small and the farmer has the sense of ownership and is able to bring up his family, giving the children a good education, and enjoying life as he goes on. All plans for land settlement should include long credit payments for land purchase; also provision of shorter periods for purchase of equipment.

    We are making progress in the provision of rural credit, but we still have a long way to go.

    A plan that should be emphasized is that we need the help of the many private agencies that have been developed. While splendid experiments are being conducted in California, so far the land settlement of that state cannot be regarded as anything more than experimental. The first purchase consisted of ten thousand acres. On the other hand, a single company in one part of the country visited by Doctor Speek is making a fine settlement of sixty thousand acres. Land settlement is extremely complex and thousands of honest men have developed skill and knowledge in the solution of its problems.

    We need their services and we must use every effort to protect them, as well as the settler, against dishonest and incompetent individuals, agents and companies.

    The district attorney's office of New York City has achieved noteworthy success in ferreting out land frauds and affording certain protection to land buyers. Our criminal laws need further development. In every state there should be those to whom the settler can turn with his grievance.

    This is required for the protection of the honest land company, as well as for the protection of the settler.

    When the Wisconsin Railroad Commission was established, the idea was that one should be able to write on a post card his complaint against any railroad company, and that the commission should take up and investigate the case. As Doctor Speek says, we need Federal and state commissions. These should prosecute relentlessly cases of fraud, and at the same time encourage right practices.

    We hear much about unused land which ought to be brought into use.

    Investigations made by Mr. O. E. Baker, of the Office of Farm Management, U. S. Department of Agriculture, and others, show that the idea that there are vast stretches of really good land which are not being utilized is fallacious. It stands to reason it should be so. If I have land that is worth a dollar an acre per annum I am not likely to allow it to be unused. I have to pay taxes on the land, and I have the interest charge, which is still more important. We do have, however, a great and crying evil in the mistaken, as well as the dishonest, attempt to bring into use land which is not susceptible of profitable use by settlers, or by any private individuals, for that matter.

    Probably somewhat less than half of the land of the United States can at present be profitably cultivated, and a large proportion of it has no value for the individual. Nevertheless, a large proportion of this inferior land is privately owned, and the owner is under a constant temptation to sell it to the settler. One of the chief problems we have is to take out of the market this submarginal land, which is responsible for so many ruined and embittered lives. Dishonest sale of poor land to unsuspecting settlers is a cause of Bolshevism, which we ought to fight in every possible way.

    Another point made by Doctor Speek relates to access to the land. How much utter nonsense has been talked about access to the land. As Doctor Speek points out, access to the land means a great many different things. If it is to amount to anything, it means knowledge based upon experience and it means capital. There is no magic about access to the land any more than there is about access to any other occupation than farming. A man who goes into any occupation, if he is going to be successful, must have the requisite tools, the requisite experience, and the requisite capital.

    The writer would like to touch upon many other points suggested by Doctor Speek's excellent report. One only, however, will be mentioned.

    We have spoken about the selection of land. We must also remember that those who are settling the land are those who are going to make up our rural population. Every state in the Union, as well as the Federal government, should consider the qualifications of those who are settling the land. We are going to have the experience of every European country. That is, by no possibility can everyone who would like to own a farm have one, any more than can everyone who would like to own some other business obtain it. No better illustration could be taken than that of Ireland, when visited by the writer in 1913. There was not land enough to afford farms to all those who wanted farms.

    A selection had to be made. As we should have agencies to help select land, we should also make a wise selection of those who are to become our land owners and cultivators in our rural communities.

    RICHARD T. ELY,

    January, 1921. UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN.

    [1] John Stuart Mill, Principles of Political Economy, p. 11.

    [2] Ibid.

    AUTHOR'S NOTE

    This report summarizes the results of a preliminary survey of rural developments in the United States from the viewpoint of the Americanization of immigrant settlers conducted by the writer for the Study of Methods of Americanization.

    The field study covered a period of about four months, from June to September, 1918, inclusive, during which time the writer with his wife, Frances Valiant Speek, as his assistant, visited fifty-four cities and rural immigrant colonies in New England, the North Middle Western, the Western, and the Southwestern states. The cities and colonies visited and the nationalities involved are given in the order followed in the field study:

    1. New York, N. Y.
    2. Vineland, N. J. Italians
    3. " Jews
    4. " Russian co-operative farm
    5. Alliance, N. J. Jews
    6. Norma, N. J. Jews
    7. Woodbine, N. J. Jews
    8. Willington, Conn. Bohemians
    9. " Slovaks
    10. Portsmouth, R. I. Portuguese
    11. Fall River, Mass. Portuguese
    12. South Deerfield, Mass. Poles
    13. " Lithuanians
    14. Oneida, N. Y. Italians
    15. Canastota, N. Y. Italians
    16. Detroit, Mich.
    17. Lansing, Mich.
    18. Holland, Mich. Dutch
    19. Au Gres, Mich. Germans from Russia
    20. " Germans from Germany
    21. Posen, Mich. Poles
    22. Rudyard, Mich. Finns
    23. " Canadian French
    24. Madison, Wis.
    25. Radisson, Wis. Poles
    26. Exeland, Wis. Mixed
    27. Conrath, Wis. Poles
    28. Weyerhauser, Wis. Poles
    29. Holcombe, Wis. Mixed
    30. Wausau, Wis. Mixed, Germans and native-born predominating
    31. Three Lakes, Wis. Poles
    32. Jennings, Wis. Poles
    33. New Rhinelander, Wis. Italians
    34. Roxbury, Wis. Germans
    35. Walworth County, Wis. Germans
    36. St. Paul, Minn.
    37. St. Cloud, Minn. Slovenians
    38. " Germans
    39. Fargo, N. D. Scandinavians, Swedes, Norwegians
    40. Bismarck, N. D.
    41. Dickinson, N. D. Russians
    42. " Germans
    43. San Francisco, Cal. Russian Sectarians
    44. " Japanese
    45. Sacramento, Cal.
    46. Fresno, Cal.
    47. Los Angeles, Cal. Russian Sectarians
    48. Glendale, Ariz. Russian Sectarians
    49. Phoenix, Ariz.
    50. Globe, Ariz.
    51. Austin, Tex.
    52. Lincoln, Neb. Germans
    53. Milford, Neb. Germans (Mennonites)
    54. Chicago, Ill.

    In addition to observation of the conditions in the colonies, numbers of the immigrant settlers, their leaders, native neighbors, and local public officials were interviewed on the subject of the survey. This was later supplemented by research, conducted mainly by the writer's assistant in the Library of Congress. No attempt was made to collect facts and material in a quantitative sense, attention being concentrated on what seemed to be outstanding facts, conditions, and cases.

    In the writing of this summary the writer, as an immigrant himself, has also used his own experiences and earlier observations beginning in 1909, and his observations during his field investigation of the conditions of floating laborers in this country for the United States Commission on Industrial Relations during 1913-15.

    The fundamental conclusion at which the writer has arrived in this summary is as follows:

    The establishment of a home may involve direct material assistance, but requires protection, direction, and instruction given to the home-seeking and home-building immigrants. These aspects of the problem are discussed in Part I.

    In the question of education the instruction of adult immigrants as well as immigrant children is important. Among all educational agencies the public school is the foremost. The parochial school and Catholic and Lutheran churches are, in many of the districts studied. Part II discusses the relative efficacy of public and private educational agencies in tying the immigrant into American life and loyalties.

    P. A. S.

    A STAKE IN THE LAND

    PART I

    A STAKE IN THE LAND

    I

    NEED OF A LAND POLICY

    One of the strongest ties uniting human beings is found among the members of a family, the unit which is the foundation of the structure of organized society. Each family requires a home for its normal life and development.

    A normal home, especially in rural districts, means a piece of land and a suitable house for the family; it implies also an opportunity to earn the family living either on the same land--if it is large enough, as in the case of truck gardens or farms--or in a near-by industrial establishment; it implies acquaintances and friends in the same neighborhood, and certain minimum necessities of modern civilized life, such as roads, post office, newspaper, church, school, physician.

    STRENGTH OF HOME TIES

    When an immigrant has succeeded in establishing such a home in America he invariably answers, when questioned as to whether he considers America or the land of his birth to be his country, that America is his country. And he goes on to explain, saying that America is a free country, with better chances for everybody; that he has made his home here; that his children have been born here; that they have better schooling and much brighter hope for the future. For all these reasons, he explains, he does not want to return to his native country except perhaps on a visit, and he repeats again and again that America, not his old country, is now his homeland.

    There is no other tie that binds a man so closely to a country as his home.

    No wonder, for home is everybody's center of the world, lookout tower, refuge, and resting place. With it are associated the most intimate and tender feelings a human being ever experiences, and naturally the same fine feelings extend to the place in which one's home is located. So we speak of fatherland, motherland, homeland, expressing in these words the close intimacy between family, home, country, and ourselves.

    [Illustration: LAND IS NOT THE ONLY STAKE IN AMERICA FOR THESE POLISH

    PARENTS]

    In direct distinction, the word "homeless" has implications of aimless drifting, of destitution and misery, and of the indifference of a "homeless" man to "his" country. Certain advocates of cosmopolitanism in their agitation against patriotism often take advantage of the importance of home in the relation of a man to his country when they appeal to the "proletarians": "Do you own anything? Do you have even a home in this country? If not, why then should you love it?"

    Although a home means a little world by itself--much more than a piece of land with a shelter on it--the establishment of a home, nevertheless, involves, first of all, the acquisition of a piece of land, even though it be the smallest suburban building lot with a twenty-five-foot frontage. If the piece of land is large enough so that its owner, if he is inclined to land cultivation, can make a living by working on it as either gardener or farmer, so much the better.

    IMMIGRANTS' LOVE OF THE LAND

    It so happens that a large number of immigrants who come to our shores with the intention of remaining here desire to establish a home, to acquire land, and to become land cultivators in America. Most of them have had farming experience in Europe. But what actually has happened and is happening year after year is that these immigrants, saturated with farm life and experience, drift to the cities, to work in mines and factories and at pick-and-shovel jobs.

    This fact was confirmed so clearly by the investigation of the United States Immigration Commission that its report has been the basis of the following statement:

    From one third to three fifths of these newcomers, the proportion
    varying according to race, had been engaged in agricultural
    pursuits before coming to the United States, but not one in ten has
    settled on farms in this country.[3]

    In the year 1900, as is shown in Table I, there were 276,745 foreign-born white persons of both sexes employed as farm laborers in this country. In 1910 the number of immigrant agricultural laborers was 336,753, an increase of 60,008, or about 22 per cent.

    TABLE I

    NUMBER (BY SEX) OF FOREIGN-BORN WHITE PERSONS ENGAGED AS FARM LABORERS

    IN THE UNITED STATES, 1900 AND 1910[4]

    SEX | 1910 | 1900

    -----------+-----------+-----------
    Males | 308,360 | 253,895
    Females | 28,393 | 22,850
    -----------+-----------+-----------
    Total | 336,753 | 276,745
    ===================================

    According to the reports of the Commissioner General of Immigration, 1,602,748 immigrant agricultural laborers, male and female, arrived in the United States between 1901 and 1910, both years inclusive. If all of these incoming agricultural laborers had found employment on farms in this country, the increase of immigrant agricultural laborers in 1910 over the number of 1900 would have been 579 per cent instead of 22 per cent.

    The United States Immigration Commission made a detailed study of 17,141 households, the heads of which were miners or wage earners in manufacturing establishments. Of the persons of these households for whom complete data were secured, 62 per cent of the males and 24 per cent of the females were employed as farm laborers or as farmers before coming to the United States. The Immigration Commission also secured detailed information from 181,330 male and 12,968 female employees in mines and manufacturing establishments. Of these, 54 per cent of the males and 44 per cent of the females were employed in the old country in farming or as farm laborers.[5]

    The transformation of European peasants into mill hands and miners in America is to be ascribed partially to the fact that land was not available to them when they arrived in this country. Either they did not know where the land which awaited a cultivator was located, or they had not enough money to buy such land, or they lacked credit needed to undertake operations in clearing and preparing new land, or they were ignorant of American farming conditions. Some seemingly insurmountable reason prevented them from following their desires and calling.

    This occupational change has resulted in loss to this country. The experience in agriculture of these large numbers of men, coupled with their ability for the hard manual labor required in truck gardening, in intensive farming, and especially in the opening up of new land, has been wastefully cast aside. The significance of such loss is clear in view of the fundamental importance of agriculture in the nation's life.

    About two thirds of the area of our country is uncultivated as yet, and the one third that is cultivated is worked extensively rather than intensively. Furthermore, native Americans and even old-time immigrants avoid hard pioneering work in the wilderness since they can find opportunities of lighter work and better returns elsewhere, on already established and "paying" farms.

    Aside from economic loss there has also been a loss in social values.

    The desire of a large number of immigrants to establish permanent rural homes and to become citizens here has gone to the winds. Instead of scattering over the country and mingling with the native population, they have been driven to the congested cities and have formed there Little Polands, Little Italies, ghettos, etc., remaining almost untouched by American influences. Both the economic and the social loss might have been averted to a considerable degree if the nation had had an effective land policy and if it had come to the aid of the immigrants in distributing and settling them on the land.

    The certainty in the mind of an immigrant that there is a stake in the land for him, and his confidence that in the acquirement of his stake he gets a square deal from all concerned, are more important from the viewpoint of Americanization than the actual acquirement of any settlement on land; for not all immigrants desire to own a piece of land and work on it, and not all who desire to can actually do so. Other considerations--for instance, family conditions, industrial opportunities, city attractions, etc.--prevent a number of such immigrants from becoming farmers. Many come to America only to make money so as to return and buy land at home. For land ownership is to them the goal in life.

    What a change in this transient attitude might be made by a policy of having land available and usable for such birds of passage.

    Certainty and confidence as purely psychological factors in the process of Americanization can be cultivated in the immigrants by affording effective public guidance and protection to those who actually attempt to settle on land.

    As the land settlement conditions now are, a large number of the land-seeking immigrants are disappointed in the acquirement of land; they have no confidence in the land sellers and dealers, and they have even become suspicious of the country's laws and public institutions connected with land transfer by purchase. To illustrate: An old-time Italian immigrant, a skilled truck gardener, working for another Italian near a small Eastern town, explained to the writer:

    I have saved a small sum of money for the purpose of buying a piece
    of land. But after years of search I have not succeeded in
    acquiring a piece of land suitable for gardening. All land seems to
    have been already "grabbed." The price asked is so high that one
    hardly is able to work it out of the soil. Last year a "Yankee"
    sold me some land, but he did not give it to me; he wanted only my
    money. I had to take a lawyer, but he did not get the land that I
    had bought for me. Only my money was returned, half of which the
    lawyer kept for himself as a fee for his services.

    There is no help
    from lawyers or courts. I lost my savings of years. The
    land-selling business in this country is a big humbug. Too bad!

    NEED FOR LAND REGULATION

    It is an astonishing, almost unbelievable fact that, although nearly all industrial and trade pursuits have come under some sort of public regulation, licensing, or supervision--even such minor trades as shoeblacking, fruit peddling, and mere popcorn and peanut selling--land dealing, one of the most basic of all trades, has been practically overlooked by our lawmakers.

    The regulation of a trade requires a definite policy toward the present and future of the trade in relation to the public safety and welfare, and especially is this true in regard to the regulation of land dealing.

    The United States needs acutely regulation of land dealing within its boundaries, and as a natural antecedent to regulation it should have and must have a definite land policy. To go one step farther, no efficient policy is possible unless it is founded on certain sound principles.

    What are the guiding principles for a practical land policy?

    First of all, there is the economic principle. It is the increase of food production, on which the very life of the nation, its development and future strength, depend. The war demonstrated this in a most convincing way. The increase of productivity of the land must be continuous and permanent. The 1920 Census reports city population increases five times as rapidly as rural. Aside from conservation of the soil--that is, saving what we have--there must go on constant improvement of the soil by fertilizing and by the introduction of more efficient methods of cultivation, intensive as well as extensive.

    Then comes the social principle of an efficient land policy, with the end in view of affording more opportunities for the establishment of family homes. Among other results, this would closely bind the foreign-born elements of the population to the country and in this way materially assist the assimilation process. It would make for better public health and for greater happiness of the people.

    The political goal is the stability of democracy and the strength of the country in domestic and international relations, in peace and in war.

    The agrarian disorders of Europe, its varied turmoils, revolutions, and war, accompanied by starvation and epidemics, are to a large degree due to the old prevailing out-of-date forms of land tenure inherited from mediaeval times.

    Toward these ends certain changes and reforms in the distribution and colonization of land should be undertaken. The existing conditions are such as require prompt attention, not only in the interests of the general public and for the sake of the general good of the country, but especially for the sake of the immigrant. Because of his greater ignorance and helplessness and his usually strong desire to settle on land, he suffers more often and more severely than the native-born American from the unscrupulousness and dishonesty and laissez-faire methods that flourish in the absence of a public land policy and public land regulation.

    The partial or utter misfortune which the immigrant so often experiences molds his entire opinion of and attitude toward the United States. From the viewpoint of the Americanization of the immigrant, therefore, the questions of land policy, land colonization, and land dealing are of the utmost importance. Before a discussion of reforms is begun, a general description of present conditions, from this point of view of Americanization, is necessary.

    [3] Jenks and Lauck, The Immigration Problem, p. 100.

    [4] The figures for 1910 are taken from the Census of 1910, vol. iv, p.

    1. The Census of 1900 does not give occupations by nativity. The figures

    for 1900 are taken from the Reports of the Immigration Commission, vol. xxviii, pp. 66, 71-79, prepared from original and unpublished data of the Census Bureau. Since the figures for immigrant female agricultural laborers are incomplete, it has been here assumed that they were in the same proportion to that of the males in 1910--namely, about 9 per cent.

    Therefore the figure 22,850 for the immigrant female agricultural laborers for 1900 represents an estimate of 9 per cent of the number of immigrant male agricultural laborers for 1900.

    [5] Reports of the United States Immigration Commission, 1911, vol. xix, pp. 89-102.

    II

    LEARNING OF LAND OPPORTUNITIES

    The immigrant desiring to settle on land is constantly on the lookout for an opportunity to acquire land. The most general way of learning of such opportunity is through personal acquaintance or through correspondence with relatives and friends of the immigrant's own nationality who have previously settled on land. These sources of information are considered by the immigrant to be the most reliable, although they have certain drawbacks.

    FRIENDS, AGENTS, AND ADVERTISEMENTS

    First, immigrants on the land are always desirous of increasing the number of people of their own race or nationality in their particular locality, for the sake of their own advantage; for the larger their community the better their social and business opportunities. Therefore they are often prone to exaggerate the advantages of land and farming in their section and to be silent as to the disadvantages, so as to induce more people of their race to join the community.

    [Illustration]

    [Illustration]

    [Illustration: THE OWNER OF THIS FARM, SETTLED IN 1917, HAS PERSUADED

    SIX MEMBERS OF HIS FAMILY TO BUY FARMS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD]

    Second, it is quite a common practice among immigrant settlers to receive from land companies certain commissions for bringing in further settlers, which induce them to exaggerate the good qualities of the land. The usual commission in the North Middle states is fifty cents per acre. The prospective buyers of land do not usually know about this.

    There are also cases where a settler has secretly become a regular agent of the land company, receiving from the latter a salary in addition to a commission on each piece of land sold through him. In such cases the agent, known to the prospective buyer only as an ordinary settler, is in a position to get much higher prices for the land than a regular agent.

    Still more danger for the immigrant lurks in the scheme whereby immigrant settlers already on the land, or their native-born neighbors, seeing that new people are coming in rapidly, take options on valuable land in certain desirable localities and resell it to the newcomers at a much higher price. Near Willington, Connecticut, there is a Bohemian colony, and in the days when this colony was growing rapidly a Bohemian settler looked up land available there and took a number of options on farms for which he already had would-be buyers.

    He took an option on one farm for its purchase at the price of $500; to the buyer he charged $1,500, and made a clear profit of $1,000. According to a report of the Immigration Commission relating to the same colony, a man who paid $1,000 in cash for a farm found that the land "agent" who sold it to him had bought the option from the original owner for $400 a few weeks before the bargain was closed.

    Quite a number of land companies are employing immigrant agents, especially of those nationalities and races with which they expect to do business on a large scale. Usually these agents are sent out to the immigrant centers in industrial towns. They bring the prospective immigrant settlers to see the land and they conduct the business in cases where the immigrants do not know English. The companies consider this the most effective way of reaching immigrants who desire to settle on land.

    Another way in which immigrants learn of land opportunities is through the land companies' advertisements in the foreign-language newspapers. The immigrant newspapers, depending on a nation-wide constituency, are, as a rule, careful in accepting trade advertisements. Often the editor, before accepting the advertisement from the land company, makes a personal visit to the company's main office to find out whether the advertisement is honest or put out by schemers and crooks. According to the testimony of the land companies the editors of the foreign-language newspapers, in the vast majority of cases, are honest men who refuse to be bribed.

    Only in a very few cases have the editors agreed to accept commissions.

    Finally comes the usual method of all land companies, that of sending out agents among the immigrants, sending them folders, etc. As a rule the advertisements and folders exaggerate the good points of the land and gloss over the bad points. Quite often the exaggerations know no bounds; the land is described as the most fertile on the surface of the earth--photographs show corn, for instance, growing like a forest; a record of the yield is given, showing it to bring hundreds and even thousands of dollars a year per acre.

    Such exaggerations may be illustrated by the literature sent out by the New South Farm and Home Company, advertising ten-acre farms in Florida.

    The representations were that the farms were not swampy, were near direct water connections with New York; that every month in the year was a growing month; that the farms were surrounded by orange and citrous-fruit farms; that there were fine roads, wells, homes, schools, hotels, etc.; that the titles were perfect; that neighboring farms were doubling, trebling, and quadrupling in price; that the settlements were rapidly growing; that there was every convenience and comfort, such as Pullman cars, long-distance telephone, etc., etc.

    It is needless to say that many of these advantages were nonexistent. The decision of the Supreme Court of the United States in regard to this case was that when a proposed seller goes beyond mere exaggeration of the qualities of an article and assigns to it qualities which it does not possess, "does not simply magnify in opinion the advantages which it has, but invents advantages and falsely asserts their existence, he transcends the limit of 'puffing' and engages in false representations and pretenses."

    By this decision it was established that to invent advantages and falsely assert their existence in a transaction of sale is a fraud.

    FEDERAL AND STATE IMMIGRATION OFFICES

    The information given to immigrants by the Federal and state immigration offices is of value, because it presents certain facts needed by settlers, as, for instance, information on climatic conditions, general soil and market conditions, and so on. But these information bulletins often do not reach the immigrants because the immigrants do not know enough to ask for them; and, even supposing that they did reach the prospective settler, the bulletins are too general.

    They describe the conditions of large districts and sections of the country or state, while what the immigrant needs is exact, detailed knowledge about a particular piece of land in which he is interested. The government officials claim that they have not sufficient forces to undertake a detailed investigation of individual land holdings, and also that they must try to avoid any appearance of discriminating between various land companies in the sense of encouraging or discouraging the sale of land belonging to given companies.

    In general, one might say that the ways open to immigrants for learning of land opportunities are defective. Misrepresentation of land conditions and actual money frauds have made them suspicious of any land dealer, so that the best land companies experience, in the immigrants' suspicion, a handicap in the development of their business. This in part explains why the various real-estate associations are trying to get some sort of public regulation for their business and why a number of states which are interested in the development of their lands have begun to talk of regulation.

    They reason that such regulation would be a good advertisement for the state and would increase the confidence of people in the chances of successfully settling on land in that state.

    POLICIES IN CALIFORNIA AND WISCONSIN

    In the states of California and Wisconsin the state departments and colleges of agriculture, through their extension service and the state immigration offices, are doing highly valuable work in disseminating correct information in regard to land opportunities among prospective settlers and in defending the latter against unscrupulous land dealers.

    The writer was especially impressed by the methods used by the Director of Immigration of the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Mr. B. G.

    Packer. The following statement dictated by Mr. Packer serves as the best description of his work and methods:

    Four years ago, at the invitation of the Department of Labor, in
    Chicago, I began going down and meeting people by appointment
    there--immigrants who wanted to come to Wisconsin. In order to
    reach them, we advertised in Chicago papers. We ran classified
    notices in the metropolitan papers, in addition inviting
    correspondence from home seekers. We ran articles in
    foreign-language papers, showing what the crops are and how to open
    up the land, how to pull up the stumps, etc. We have had pamphlets
    on Wisconsin, and methods of cultivation of its land, published in
    foreign languages.

    I find that the home seekers do not know where to go or whom to
    believe, but by meeting them in conferences I have been able to
    protect them against exploitation and direct them to localities
    where they stand a good show of making good. The average capital of
    immigrants will run a little over fifteen hundred dollars. The
    average capital of native-born Americans who come to see me is
    considerably less. A man going on the land should have not less
    than twelve hundred dollars after making his first payment on forty
    acres. We have schedules showing approximately what his living
    expenses will be for the first couple of years.

    Our work is largely protective. The leading Chicago papers
    co-operate with us by refusing the advertising of real-estate men
    who misrepresent their properties. The state attorney's office
    co-operates with us by enforcing the confidence-game statute. Every
    inquirer is furnished with a certificate (see p. 22), and I find
    that dishonest dealers refuse to sell to home seekers who present
    this certificate to them.

    One point I should like to emphasize is that the back-to-the-farm
    movement will be successful in proportion to each state's activity
    in supplying home seekers with information that will insure their
    success on the land.

    First, those coming into the new land region in our state, must
    have enough capital to carry them through the first two years for
    the purchase of clothing and food and farm equipment.

    Second, they should have had some experience in farming. The
    city-bred man who wishes to get out into the country, not because
    of love of the country, but because of dislike of the city, is a
    poor investment. Those visiting us who have not had farm experience
    are urged to get it before locating or before investing their
    money.

    Third, the wife must be satisfied and willing to undergo some
    pioneering. Right here is where a good many fall down. The man is
    willing to go and his wife goes unwillingly.

    Fourth, the immigrants should not be flimflammed into paying
    excessive prices for undeveloped land. So far as Wisconsin is
    concerned, competition takes care of this, provided the home seeker
    gets into communication with our department. To illustrate: One
    concern in Chicago, operating in Bayfield County, Wisconsin, is
    asking forty and forty-five dollars an acre for cut-over land no
    better than may be obtained from lumber and railroad companies for
    half this figure.

    Fifth, there is a tendency on the part of land salesmen to load up
    the immigrant with more land than he can use, or sometimes pay for.
    Eighty acres makes a good-sized farm for one family to develop and
    handle, and this is the size of tract recommended.

    Sixth, the back-to-the-lander should be a man in good physical
    condition. I believe that it is a mistake to put men on the land
    who are not heavy enough for farm work. The man should weigh not
    less than two pounds for every inch of his height, which is the
    army standard.

    Seventh, it is a mistake to encourage people to go on the land
    after the time for the spring work has passed. I mean by this that
    under our conditions the settler has to construct a small house and
    do some brushing and clearing in order to grow vegetables for
    himself and a small amount of winter feed for his stock.

    Eighth, the back-to-the-lander has too many fake ideas about the
    amount of money to be made in farming. Under our conditions the
    settler is putting money into his land and not taking very much out
    the first two or three years, unless he has merchantable timber
    that can be worked up into cordwood or bolts, or unless he locates
    in a region having little timber to be removed, and is able to
    specialize in potatoes. The men who have become wealthy from
    strictly farming operations are not numerous in Wisconsin or
    anywhere else.

    I should like to call your attention to the following form of
    certificate furnished inquirers in communication with this
    department:

    THE STATE OF WISCONSIN

    DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

    IMMIGRATION DIVISION

    Directing Certificate

    TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:

    The bearer ......................................... of
    ........................ is in communication with this department,
    and looking for a farm home in ............. County, Wisconsin. It
    is our purpose to keep in touch with him after his removal to this
    state, to note his progress, and learn if he is fully satisfied
    with the business relations he may have with any person or firm
    selling him land.

    Any courtesies extended him will be appreciated.

    .......................... 191......
    ....................................

    Director of Immigration.

    C. P. Norgord, Commissioner.

    In a bulletin of information for immigrants, issued by the Commission of Immigration and Housing of California, 1920, the commission offers its assistance to the seekers of land in the state of California, in the following words:

    Immigrants who are thinking of buying farm lands should call upon
    or write to the office of the Commission of Immigration and Housing
    for free information and advice.

    (a) The commission co-operating with the Agricultural
    Department of the State University will furnish without charge
    general information regarding agricultural lands; and

    (b) It will make an investigation and free report to any
    immigrant concerning any particular tract of land which he may
    have visited, and which he contemplates buying. This report will
    cover the agricultural possibilities of the land and its
    accessibility to markets. If the immigrant states his previous
    experience, his financial condition, and gives other information
    which may be requested by the commission, the report will also
    give advice as to the wisdom of buying the proposed land.

    No purchase or contract to purchase land should be made or entered
    into until the immigrant knows the nature of the land, its true
    money value, and that the land belongs to the one who proposes to
    sell it.

    This is the kind of public assistance which the land seekers, especially the immigrants, most urgently need, and to which they are entitled. The only questions are, will the other states follow, and how can the opportunity of such reliable public assistance be made known to the land-seeking masses?

    III

    EXPERIENCES IN ACQUIRING LAND

    The experiences of the Russian sectarian peasants in America in their attempts to settle on land are illuminating in regard to existing conditions of land dealing and colonization as they affect the immigrant.

    There are in the Western states about a thousand families (or six thousand individuals) of Russian peasant sectarians--Molokans, Holy Jumpers, Wet and Dry Baptists, and others. They were all engaged in agriculture while they lived in Russia. As a result of persecution by the Russian monarchy they left their country and came to America about ten years ago.

    RUSSIAN SECTARIAN PEASANTS IN THE WEST

    From the beginning of their American adventure they have had a keen desire to settle on land. They have made repeated attempts to acquire farms, but so far failure has been the rule, with few exceptions.

    The facts regarding most of the unsuccessful attempts outlined below were obtained at a meeting of Russian sectarians in Los Angeles attended by about one hundred family heads. Each one told his own experience. The men had great difficulty in indicating American names--the names of companies, counties, etc.--so that in the following account names are omitted.

    When questioned as to how they could secure so much money, they explained that they all work whenever it is possible to find work, that they live moderately, that their men and women dress cheaply, that they do not drink or smoke or go to any places of amusement, as all that is prohibited by their religion, and that they save.

    They stated that their land-seeking attempts are backed financially by the entire colony; the losses are shared by all its members, although the individual families who are on the firing line lose more than the families who remain in Los Angeles and back these scouting parties.

    These peasants believe that their difficulty in finding and settling on land has been due to several causes. First, they have not enough money to buy immediately a large tract of land, irrigate and improve it, and give the families a good start. Second, they do not know the country and conditions well enough, especially the agricultural possibilities.

    Third, the private land dealers are mostly crooks who cheat them, either by misrepresenting the quality of the land, or by not fulfilling their contract promises, or by making contracts so complicated and so filled with catches that they afterward prove the ruin of the settler. The following are some of the most important of the attempts to find land.

    From thirty to thirty-three families made a land-purchase contract with a company of ---- County, Washington. One hundred and sixty acres were sold to each family, at a price of from $40 to $50 an acre. Each family pays down $400 and should pay to the company 60 per cent a year of the first, second, and third years' crops, it being understood that the remaining 40 per cent would remain in the hands of the settler for the support of his family. But during the first year it developed that the company took out of that 40 per cent the interest on the mortgages and the taxes on the land, so that very little was left for the cultivator.

    The next year the settlers left the land, worked on neighboring farms for another year, and then returned to Los Angeles. Some families had lost $400, some $700--practically all the money they had saved or borrowed.

    Again, fifteen families made a contract with a company near Fresno, California. Forty acres were sold to each family at $115 per acre, with the privilege of water for irrigation on the stipulation that the company would receive half of the market value of the crops. The company promised to lend seeds and implements. Several of the families had come from Mexico to escape revolutionary disturbances there, bringing implements, horses, cattle, etc. When they arrived they had to borrow seeds and provisions for the support of the families. The company furnished these on a chattel mortgage at 7 per cent.

    But the company was not able to provide irrigating water, so the settlers, after two years of fruitless effort, had to leave the land, losing all their mortgaged personal property. Some families lost $700 in cash, some lost $1,000, and some even more.

    Later, twenty families made a contract with a land company for the purchase of farms varying in size from twenty to forty acres, at a price of $120 per acre. To be cautious, the peasants sent out only seven families. The company promised to provide either a tractor or horses, implements, seeds, and water, and was to receive one fourth of the crops. But it turned out that the company was not able to furnish water.

    During two years the settlers tried to make good, but did not succeed, the lack of water being the main cause of failure. One family lost $700, another $820, and the others lost about the same amount each.

    Another group of twenty families made a contract with a company in the same neighborhood. Fifty acres were sold to each family at $120 per acre. The company agreed to provide two horses for each family and all necessary implements, and for its part was to receive half of all the crops. It also promised to give water. But when the time came the company supplied only thirty horses instead of forty, and only three plows for the whole colony; it also failed to furnish water. The land was good, but without water it was of no use. The settlers battled for two years and then left the land. Each lost from $500 to $1,000.

    About two years ago a farmer owning lands in the San Joaquin Valley got in touch with Russian peasants in Los Angeles. He agreed to sell these people land, with houses, stock, etc., at what seemed a nominal first payment--$200. It looked like a wonderful opportunity to the simple peasants, who, by their industry, had saved up two or three hundred dollars or more. About 120 families were induced to make the first deposit ($10 or $20). Then Prof. W. T.

    Clarke of the agricultural extension service of the University of California was asked by the Immigration Commission to visit this tract and report on it. He found that it was the poorest kind of alkali land--land that a grasshopper would starve on. The farmer who was selling the land raised strenuous objections to the investigation and the resulting report, but the commission succeeded in shutting off the entire deal, except in the cases of four or five peasants who insisted on taking the farms and who are now making a failure of it.

    On an attempt of the peasants to settle in Utah, twenty families contracted to buy farms at $100 per acre, 130 acres to a family. One fourth of the crops were to be paid to the company, which promised to provide water; but the company failed to find water and all the settlers and the company itself went to pieces. The settlers' losses were very heavy, some losing $1,000, some $2,000. They were again compelled to return to Los Angeles.

    In 1907 certain agents of a German sugar company in Honolulu appeared and promised to sell the peasants good land in Honolulu. Thirty families made contracts to buy farms of forty acres, with the stipulation that they would pay the price gradually out of their income from the farms.

    When the families arrived in Honolulu there was no land for them. The company explained that they had been merely hired for work on its plantation. Under the conditions of labor there they were half slaves and the life became unendurable. After six months of trial and hardship they returned to Los Angeles, each family having lost from $600 to $700.

    In another instance seven families bought farms at Elmira, California, varying in size from twenty to seventy acres. The price was $117 an acre, and they paid down $10 an acre, the balance being covered by a mortgage at 6 per cent. This land is rather poor, but the settlers have stayed on.

    THE SUCCESSFUL COLONY AT GLENDALE

    Aside from a few families who have succeeded in settling on land here and there through the Western states and who are making ends meet, there is only one group of these peasants which has succeeded in establishing a well-to-do colony; that colony is at Glendale, Arizona, below the Roosevelt Dam.

    The first colonists arrived in Glendale seven years ago from Los Angeles, while others came later from San Francisco and from Mexico. The development of the colony has been steady. There are four groups of colonists located a few miles from one another, but they communicate freely and consider themselves one colony. There are at present about seven hundred persons in the colony, with an average of five or six children in each family. The settlers paid down little money at the beginning.

    Some families did not pay anything; some paid $100, some $500, and a few paid $1,000. The price of the land was originally $125 per acre, but it has now doubled. Almost all the land is under cultivation. The men have acquired the necessary machinery, stock, plants, and seeds; they have plenty to eat, and a large number of families have Ford automobiles, while a few are considering the purchase of higher-priced cars.

    The success of the peasants in Glendale is to be explained by the fertility of the new desert land, the adequate irrigation provided by the Roosevelt Dam system, reasonable conditions of land purchase, the capacity of the men for hard labor, and their love of the land. The main money crop is cotton of the highest grade and of exceptionally heavy yield. There is no difficulty in marketing farm products, for the colony is within a few miles of Phoenix.

    OTHER CALIFORNIA CASES

    The report of the Commission on Land Colonization and Rural Credits of the state of California presents some interesting cases.[6]

    A tract of wheat land was bought at $7 per acre. The buyer organized a syndicate composed of himself and his stenographer and sold the land to the syndicate at $100 per acre. The syndicate sold the land at $200 per acre. No settler was able to earn either the purchase price or the interest on it out of the soil.

    Another colonization company bought 150,000 acres at an average of less than $40 per acre. The average selling price at the start was $75 per acre, but was soon increased to $175 per acre. The agents commission on the higher price was 30 per cent--i.e., considerably more than the cost of the land.

    In another case an agent made a contract for selling a tract of land at 20 per cent of the selling price, which he was free to fix himself. He raised the price from $150 to $400 per acre, so that he received commissions of $80 per acre instead of $30. As the terms were one fifth cash, the balance in four yearly installments, the agent induced the settlers to buy as much land as would absorb all their capital for the first payments, and then he pocketed as his commission the total amount paid down. When the tract was all sold, the owner held the contracts of the moneyless settlers, the latter had the use of the land, and the agent had the coin.

    Some colonization companies, in searching for a tract of land, have regarded price as the only consideration, saying that any land that could be bought for $25 an acre could be colonized. Only hardpan and alkali land could be bought in California at that price. Nevertheless, one company bought such an area, subdivided it, and traded it for houses and lots in Los Angeles. Some time later only three of the purchasers were found to be still in the colony, and probably not one of them intended to remain.

    In one district a tract of "goose" land, after selling for $5 and then $15 an acre, was subdivided and sold as garden soil for $125 an acre.

    Three brothers who were market gardeners bought farms and settled there with their families. They found the soil, when wet, to be a quagmire and when dry to be possible of cultivation only with dynamite. After three years of utter failure they were forced to abandon their homes, having lost their money, time, and labor, and having reaped a bitter feeling of injustice and wrong.

    It appears from the report that a certain class of land speculators, when buying land for reselling in plots, do not pay so much attention to the qualities of the land as to its advertising possibilities. If land in a widely known valley is alkali land, so much the better, for the buying price is lower. The speculator in his advertisement makes it appear as fruit land with a great future. It seems also to have been by no means uncommon for the agent's commission to be higher than the price paid by the owner for the land.

    AN OKLAHOMA SETTLEMENT

    On February 12, 1919, in Cincinnati, Ohio, sixteen land swindlers of the McAlester Real Estate Exchange, of McAlester, Oklahoma, were found guilty by a jury in Federal court. The company's land-advertisement literature was so worded as to convey the impression that the McAlester company was acting as an agent of the government in the sale of Indian lands. The prosecution was largely centered on the distribution among the customers of a tract of 41,000 acres in Oklahoma. It was charged that the president of the company secured an option on these lands when he found that he was unable to buy sufficient land at the government sale of Indian lands to fill his contracts.

    It was also charged that the company perpetrated a fraud on its customers when it took $135 as a fee for locating and purchasing land, agreeing to act as attorney and agent for the customer, and then sold the land that it had bought privately at a profit. These contracts were, in the opinion of the government, so worded as to convey the impression that in paying for the locating and bidding the "party of the second part" was also making a payment on the land and was encouraged in the belief that his land would be in the midst of areas yielding oil and other mineral products as well as timber. Timber-right frauds also were alleged.

    The company had during 1917 collected from its victims, who lived in all parts of the country, nearly $1,000,000. It was revealed also that given plots of land had been sold to more than one buyer.

    The foregoing instances indicate that companies formed for the purpose of exploiting and deceiving land settlers have succeeded. With the increasing tide of new immigration, it may be possible to ensnare even more unwary persons. But there have been a sufficient number of exposes, as well as court decisions, to make the business of fraudulent land promotion a dangerous one. All types of real-estate dealers are increasingly realizing the need for making their transactions aboveboard and honest. Steps to this end are being taken by the better class of dealer.

    [6] California Commission on Land Colonization and Rural Credits,

    1. pp. 50-53.

    IV

    INDIVIDUAL LAND DEALERS

    Except for government land grants and homestead acts, land dealing and colonization in the United States have, up to very recent times, been entirely in private hands. Land is one of the necessities of life; land dealing, consequently, is one of the most important features in social and economic relations. Yet it has been left unregulated, with the result that land dealing is now the most chaotic sort of business, one which has not worked out its own definite methods, rules, and traditions, as banking and other branches of commerce and business have done. It may even be said that people who deal in land have fallen, in the eyes of the public, into the ranks of those open to suspicion.

    In the field investigation for this study, land dealing was considered to be an important phase of the problem of Americanization in rural districts. Based upon the experiences and facts collected, the picture may be drawn as follows:

    According to their methods, private land dealers may be classified as follows:

    (1) Land "sharks," divided between those acting outside the law and
    those acting within the law; (2) the ordinary real-estate
    dealer--of two types--the lower, selfish, narrow-minded, the
    higher, public-spirited; (3) "realtors"; (4) land-colonizing
    companies.

    LAND SHARKS

    Land sharks are of two distinct varieties. One type is composed of men of a criminal character. The words "lawful" and "unlawful" have no meaning for them. They often sell land as their own which they do not own, or sell land other than they have promised or even shown to the buyer. Their only aim is to cheat the latter out of his money and to escape the penalty of the law.

    These pirates injure both land seekers and legitimate real-estate men.

    They hang about the trains, railroad stations, and all points where there is a chance of attracting the land seekers. They are sometimes able to entice those who are being brought in by reputable land men.

    Often the pirates are of the same nationality as the immigrants and by clever emphasis on this common bond and by skillful manipulation of truth and lies they steal the men away to look at land which they call their own. The land pirates do not advertise, but live on the advertising that the reputable land men do. As a result the latter curtail their advertising and do a comparatively small amount of it, since they are prevented from realizing the full profits due on the investment. This is a situation that forces the land men to realize the need of a licensed real-estate profession.

    The president of a land company in Wisconsin gives this description of the operations of the land sharks and of the effects of their activity:

    Relative to the land pirates, it is hard to estimate how much land
    they sell, but we find that for every customer they do sell to they
    queer deals for this country of from ten to twenty-four which the
    other land men might have landed.... I estimate that within the
    last two years the city of ---- has lost from fifty to one hundred
    customers for land though these pirates, who infest the depot and
    meet all trains....

    Their first act is to find that the man is
    looking for land and to find out whom he is expecting to see, for
    they usually come up with some definite proposition to look over.
    The pirate then proceeds to throw cold water on the locality that
    he is to look over, and very often challenges the integrity of the
    party whom he is going to see. He does this preparatory to starting
    in to taking the man off and showing him something of his own.
    Frequently these men do not own a foot of land, but have a few
    pieces for sale on commission.

    They are usually irresponsible men
    and often put through some rocky deals, and it is through them more
    than anything else that the real-estate men have often got very bad
    names for the way they have handled customers who come up to buy
    land. When the customer's mind has been poisoned against the party
    whom he was coming to see, and against the particular piece of land
    or locality where he had formerly planned to buy, he is often ready
    to quit and go back, and it is very hard for anyone thereafter to
    deal with him, because his confidence has been shaken in the people
    and the country.

    The other type of land shark is composed of men who act within the law, but, for their own gain, apply methods which are mildly called "sharp" or "unethical." They either misrepresent the qualities of the land they offer, or charge a higher price than the land is worth, or make in the contract such stipulations as will afterward ruin the settler. They profit by the settlers' failures, for each settler adds something to the improvement of the land before the conditions of the land-purchase contract which he is unable to meet compel him to leave the land.

    The land shark sells the land to a new settler for a still higher price, capitalizing the improvements made by the former settler. With the new settler the process is repeated, and so it goes, like an endless chain.

    It is similar to the method of splitting fees practiced by private employment offices and foremen who keep men coming and going.

    There are no data collected to show the actual extent of the activities of the land sharks, but, judging by the stories told by the immigrants, by records of court proceedings, by suspicious land advertisements in newspapers, especially in the smaller, less reliable foreign-language papers, and by the number of cases brought to the attention of the state immigration commissioners, it is safe to state that the immigrants suffer very greatly from the land-shark evil.

    LOWER TYPE OF LAND DEALER

    One group of the ordinary type of land dealer might be characterized as being composed of narrow-minded, hard, and even heartless business men, working solely for their own interests. Their business consists merely in buying and selling land as rapidly as possible. In making prices for land and in making contract stipulations with the buyers, they do not "monkey," as some of them say. As a rule they do not charge a higher price than the land is worth--that is, not higher than the prevailing market price in a particular locality.

    They also avoid unreasonable or impossible contract stipulations. When land is sold, when the contract has been signed by both sides, then their care and interest in regard to the land and its owner end. If the buyer later fails to meet the contract stipulations in any particular the land dealer sees to it that he leaves the land at once. The dealer then advertises and sells the land again. Usually, no compensation for improvements made by the settler, in case of his failure, is stipulated in the contract.

    If there is any gain to the land dealer from the failure of a settler, the dealer often claims that such gain is more than offset by heavy expenses, such as for advertising, agents' commissions, and the like, in finding a new buyer.

    The land dealer gives little or no consideration to the causes of the failure of the settler. According to the observation of the writer, a large number of failures in settling on land are not due to the personal defects or weakness of the settlers, but are due to external causes, such as lack of capital and credit, lack of market, poor roads, etc. The settlers who have failed owing to such causes might be criticized for their poor judgment in selecting the land, but the land dealers might equally be criticized for not warning the settlers of the difficulties before they buy the land.

    The land dealers ought to know the market facilities, the extent of capital and credit required for success on a particular piece of land and in a particular locality. As a matter of fact, dealers of the type under discussion do not warn the settlers. They give advice of an optimistic character and they apply to the settler the Darwinian theory of survival of the fittest. A number of these land dealers said to the writer:

    Well, it is up to the settler himself, either to succeed or to
    fail. If he fails, he has himself alone to blame, and he must give
    place to the settler who is able to succeed. There is no room for
    weaklings on my land or anywhere else in this world.

    The results which follow in the wake of such land-settlement policies are described in the following extract from the letter of a county agent. He writes from a locality where many of the settlers are immigrants:

    In some parts of this country ... the statistics show that there is
    a complete change in the farmers every seven years. That means that
    several farmers are coming and going all the time. Several farmers
    are paying out taxes and interest on something they will never
    own.... As to the land companies doing things for the settler, in
    the most part they take care of the new man for a time, but I
    notice that they close them out, too, if taxes and interest are not
    kept up pretty well.

    A similar condition is described in the letter below from a county agent in the same state:

    The land companies in this county are not putting forth any special
    effort to make it easier for the new settlers to succeed. As far as
    I know, all the land companies in this county are reliable. They
    live up to their agreements with the settlers. However, I can also
    vouch for the statement that many of our farms, with very little
    clearing, are continuously changing hands.

    The importance of advice and warning from the land company to the settler, and the deplorable infrequency with which it is given, are spoken of in this statement by a county agent:

    So far the ... settler's only means of protection has been the
    county agent. From the county agent the settler gets the true
    condition of the land, climate, and possibilities in general, of
    the particular region into which he is going. Too often, though,
    the settler is met at the train by the real-estate agent, and this
    agent does not let his prospective buyer get in touch with anyone
    else until after he has been sold a piece of land.

    After the
    settler has bought his land the real-estate man thinks that his
    connection with him has ceased, and he is no longer interested in
    him other than to see that the promised payments are paid when due.

    THE PUBLIC-SPIRITED LAND DEALER

    The second group of the ordinary type of land dealer, though not so large as the first group, consists of men who have a broader outlook upon their business and work. While they also are after personal profit, they understand that they are rendering, in return for their profit, a service not only to the land buyer, but also to the public.

    Accordingly, they are considerate of the settler, try to make him successful, and, having the social point of view, they promote education, welfare work, and other community interests among the settlers.

    The writer has met a number of such broad-minded and public-spirited land dealers. Some of them were so modest as to deny that they were interested in or were keeping in mind any public or social end in their business.

    Well, I am after profit, nothing more. By helping the settler to
    make a success through extension of credit to him, through
    demonstrations, through finding a market for his products, and
    through organizing community work, I am only advertising my land
    and attracting new settlers. That is, I am applying a little bit of
    Henry Ford's methods to the land-settlement business, that's all!

    This explanation was given by a large land dealer in one of the Middle Western states. Further conversation with him showed that he took great pride in the fact that the settlers on his land esteemed him highly and had confidence in him.

    It is land men of this type that a county agent from the North Middle West speaks of in these words:

    The land men in this county all believe that it is to their own
    interests to have every settler a satisfied settler. They are
    getting away from the idea that they are done with the settler as
    soon as they sell him a piece of land. They now believe that they
    are just starting their relations with the settler when he buys
    from them.

    Another county agent writes that he believes that

    the real-estate men are beginning to try to see that the settlers
    to whom they sell land make good. They are doing this by being
    lenient with their conditions and by picking only the better types
    of land for settlement.

    One of the real-estate men who have this more public-spirited view of their work describes his relations with the settlers as follows:

    I try to assist the settler by giving him all the moral support and
    encouragement possible, by keeping friendly with him so he feels
    free to come to me with his every problem. I stand ready to finance
    any deserving settler for the full purchase price of good milk
    cows, or to buy a pig or two, or for any other thing that is sure
    to help him over the hill. Especially, I go among them organizing
    farm loan associations and community-center gatherings, thereby
    bringing the whole family the general social opportunities that
    every normal family craves and has the right to expect.

    [Illustration]

    [Illustration: FRIENDLY ASSISTANCE MAKES PIONEERING LESS BAFFLING]

    A real-estate company with offices in Chicago states that it assists the individual settler in many ways:

    1. We sell him horses and cows on liberal terms.
    1. We help him buy on credit building materials and other

    necessaries, such as feed for his stock, small tools, etc. We O.K.
    many small bills.

    1. We many times indorse settlers' notes at banks in order to help

    them get credit, and thus get the money with which to make progress.

    1. Our organization keeps in touch with parties to whom we have

    sold. Our men see them occasionally and give them advice. Often we
    are able to be of material assistance in helping them to buy the
    right stock at the right prices.

    1. We keep hammering away at the importance of their keeping in

    touch with the county adviser and getting the free literature that
    is sent out by the state and Federal authorities.

    1. We try to be of aid in everything which promotes the general

    social and economic welfare of the community. For example:

    a. Our Mr. ---- was chairman of the Liberty Loan Committee in
    ---- County.

    b. Any proposition for new roads, new schools, or new churches
    gets our hearty and immediate support.

    c. In all cases where we have been asked to donate an acre or
    half acre for church purposes, we have done so.

    d. We have been instrumental in helping a number of incipient
    business men to start cheese factories.

    "REALTORS"

    Certain phases of the real-estate business requiring concerted action, and especially the desire of the higher type of land dealers to put their trade or profession on a higher level, and thus to prevent it from falling into disrepute in the public eye, have led the better type of real-estate men to organize themselves into local real-estate boards with an associate membership of leading local merchants, bankers, lawyers, and others particularly interested in real-estate developments.

    The "realtors" prefer to speak of their trade as a "profession" or "calling," not a business or trade, for they claim that an up-to-date real-estate dealer is a community builder and leader whose preparation requires a good general education and a special training, pointing out that a number of the best colleges in the country are giving courses in the real-estate business.

    Nineteen local boards from thirteen states formed a national association in 1908. At present the association comprises 130 local boards in this country and Canada, with a total membership of about 8,500 persons.

    The aims of the National Association of Real Estate Boards are to promote efficiency among its members, to be a clearing house for the exchange of information and ideas, to publish an organ of the association, to broaden the sphere of influence of the local real-estate men, to assist in organizing local boards, to fight the land "sharks" and "curbstone brokers," and to maintain a high standard of professional ethics.

    The members of the associated local boards call themselves "realtors," as distinct from "real-estate men" or "land dealers"--names which, they feel, are tainted by the unscrupulous methods of the "sharks."

    The association has published a code of ethics for its members, in which paragraph 13 is especially noteworthy. It reads:

    As a duty to the public and each other, members should report to
    the board misrepresentations or any fraudulent, criminal, or
    illegal act pertaining to real estate, which may entrap and injure
    innocent or ignorant persons; and the board owes it to members and
    the community to take steps to stop such practices and to punish
    parties guilty thereof.

    The local boards often render certain services to the community. The valuation committees are often called upon to give their expert advice in land matters even to the courts and government administrative offices.

    But how far the association is successful in combating the underhand business methods of the unscrupulous real-estate men is very difficult to say. The fact is this, that the association favors public registry and regulation of the real-estate trade and at present is working toward that end, supporting bills of this nature that are introduced in the state legislatures.

    A number of the realtors are not in favor of the words "license" and "licensing." They prefer instead the words "certificate," "registry," and "regulation," believing that the word "license" is associated in the popular mind with saloon-keeping and similar trades of a lower order.

    The desire of these men to separate from ordinary real-estate men by calling themselves "realtors" and their business a "profession," and their advocacy of public regulation, show that the land "shark" is still very much alive and that the real-estate men themselves by their own private efforts are not able successfully to combat the "shark."

    In the field of private land dealing there is appearing a substitute for the individual dealer. The modern colonization company has recently grown up, and out of this new project have grown broader policies and methods.

    V

    PRIVATE LAND COLONIZATION COMPANIES

    The earlier so-called city and empire builders were in most cases nothing more than dealers in land. When a lot or farm was sold, there the company's interest ended. The modern colonization company goes much farther. When a man settles on land, the company of the better type usually looks out for him, backs him with credit, affords him the service of an expert agricultural adviser, cares for his health, and promotes his social interests and activities through a salaried community worker.

    All this is done by the company not only for the sake of the settler himself, but mainly for the sake of the business interests of the company, since the success of the settlers on the company's land is the best advertisement of the company's business. It creates confidence in the company among the searchers for land and helps to increase the volume of business and the profits. Such companies are of rather recent origin and as yet are comparatively few in number. Their appearance means specialization in the land-development business.

    In the North Middle Western states the wilderness land has been for the most part owned by the lumber companies. The lumber companies attempted to dispose of their cut-over and burnt-over land in the easiest way by selling to individuals. As a rule this retail selling was unsuccessful.

    They found that it was more profitable for them to stick to their lumber business and sell their land in large tracts to the land dealers and to land-development and colonization companies.

    In this connection it is interesting to note that in the wilds of our north one may still see the following stages of frontier life as they exist side by side, sometimes overlapping and crosscutting one another.

    1. The earliest stage known to American civilization was that of virgin

    wilderness inhabited by animals and roamed over by Indians. As remnants of that time there are found some animals, now driven into the swamps and rocks, and a few Indians settled on reservations.

    1. The next stage was when the white missionaries, traders, adventurers,

    followed by professional trappers, began penetrating the wilderness.

    This white men's hunting stage is still represented by the present-day "shackers" and trappers, though they are mostly of an amateur character, and, so to speak, domesticated.

    1. The following stage was when lumbermen began being heard throughout the

    forests. They are still there, though in considerably reduced numbers. They are hurriedly attacking the remaining woods, leaving in their wake a dreary, sorrowful-looking expanse of cut-over and burnt-over lands.

    1. These cut-over lands are now invaded by the land development and

    colonization companies, with their armies of new settlers, attempting to transform the last remnants of wilderness into fertile gardens, fields, and meadows. This is the last decisive war of man upon the wilderness--a picturesque and difficult struggle. A settler gives this vivid description, printed in the Radisson, Wisconsin, Courier:

    Everywhere we go we see men, women, and children cutting and piling
    the brush and logs that have covered the ground since the days of
    the logger. Everyone seems to be trying to clear more land than his
    neighbor, and get it ready to produce the crops that are so badly
    needed all over the world, and as we stop a minute to take a better
    view of what each one has done, we hear the boom of dynamite that
    is following the brush lines as they are being pushed back.

    In the north the land-clearing line is called the firing line, a term which can be taken literally, for the land-clearing front is continually under fire and clouds of smoke from burning debris.

    1. The sturdy new settlers, the last pioneers and frontiersmen in the

    country, are followed, especially along rivers where water power is at hand, by industrial workers. Here and there are appearing thriving manufacturing and commercial towns--the last stage in the opening up of a new country to civilization.

    But the most important work in the wilderness at present is that of the modern land colonization companies. To give an idea of their work and methods it is necessary to describe one of these companies in detail.

    A TYPICAL COMPANY

    The particular company investigated with special attention is located in the wilderness of one of the North Middle Western states. In general the company is applying the same business methods to land colonization as Mr. Ford is applying to automobile production--production of new farms on a large scale so as to diminish the overhead expense, and standardization of various colonization methods. The guiding test is the success of the new settlers on the company's land.

    Failures among the settlers are avoided and fought against by the company as though they were a dangerous epidemic. "Each failure among our settlers is a bad advertisement for our company, a loss to us, and an evidence of defects in our business methods," stated the company's head.

    To insure the success of the settlers and the settlement, the company proceeds as follows: The most careful study is made of the tract of land which the company intends to acquire for colonization purposes. Not only is the tract of land closely looked over by the company's officials, but land experts, such as soil surveyors, are engaged to examine the land from the viewpoint of its agricultural possibilities. Federal and state surveyors' reports are also used in considering the possibilities of the land.

    When the land has been acquired, a plan for a colony is worked out, with provision for necessary roads, town sites, irrigation or drainage systems, utilization of water power, social centers, experimental farms, etc. The accompanying map shows the plan of one such colony.

    The tract is then surveyed and cut up into farms according to the plan adopted. A number of farm lots are selected by the company. On each of these lots there is designated a place for the farm buildings and the garden. A simple, inexpensive house and a barn are built by the company on a small clearing, usually facing the main road. At present the company has ceased to clear any land for agricultural use for the reason that if there is a piece of cleared land the new settler is apt to expend his main efforts on cultivation of this cleared land, neglecting the clearing of more land.

    Our experience has shown that it is much better when a new settler
    begins his settlement enterprise with clearing. He at once acquires
    the needed experience in clearing, and develops the confidence
    that he is able to overcome the difficulties of clearing. As a
    result, his ambition grows to clear more land each year,

    explained a company official. This again shows with what fineness the company has to adjust its methods to the psychological peculiarities of the settlers.

    At the same time the company equips the experimental farm and puts it into operation under the supervision of a trained agriculturist. For the community work a hall is provided and a community worker engaged.

    Meanwhile the company's agents and advertisers have been busy in making the land opportunities known to people who are intending to settle on land. The new settlers are of two distinct types. One type consists either of native Americans or immigrants who have previously been on land in the United States either as landowners or as tenants. The second class consists of immigrants who have been living in the cities and who desire to settle on land. In most cases they have been engaged in agricultural work in their old countries.

    [Illustration: THE WISCONSIN COLONIZATION COMPANY SEES THE NEED OF

    COMMUNITY CENTERS]

    The company itself takes into consideration racial and national factors. In the year of the investigation the company was doing its main business in the one section with Polish immigrants, and preferred them even to the native settlers. The reason given was that immigrants, especially Slavs, are easy to get along with and readily follow the company's directions and advice. They are hard workers and are satisfied with a small return at the beginning. In contrast, the natives commonly pay little attention to the company's directions and advice, being anxious to make a quick success.

    In case they do not succeed as rapidly as they expected, they get discouraged, leave the place, and give the company a "black eye."

    The land is sold in plots of forty acres each, either as "made-to-order" farms or without farming improvements--"land only." The purchaser may buy as many plots as he desires and is able to pay for. However, the company discourages the buying of more land than the settler is able actually to improve and cultivate, which usually is about forty acres.

    The company offers in its folder the following three land sale plans:

    PLAN NO. 1

    LAND ONLY, WITHOUT IMPROVEMENTS

    First payment, $200 for each 40 acres. Total cost, $750 to $1,000
    for each 40 acres.

    If you buy under Plan No. 1 you pay for the land only. Should you
    want lumber or building supplies, we will furnish them to you at
    cost, and add on to your contract. The same is true in case you
    want live stock. In other words, we will furnish supplies equal to
    the amount of the first payment. Prices vary according to location
    and quality of land.

    PLAN NO. 2

    FORTY ACRES OF LAND WITH HOUSE AND LIVE STOCK

    House 14x20 feet, 1 story,
    1 cow,
    1 small pig,
    4 chickens,
    Complete assortment of vegetable and flower seeds,
    1 bushel mixed clover and timothy seed.

    Cash payment, $250.
    Total cost, $1,100 to $1,350.

    These plans cover only 40 acres. If you wish larger acreage add to
    these plans what land you require, at $750 to $1,000 per 40-acre unit.

    PLAN NO. 3

    FORTY ACRES OF LAND WITH HOUSE, BARN, LIVE STOCK, AND TOOLS

    House 14x20 feet, 1-1/2 story,
    Barn 12x14 feet,
    1 cow,
    4 chickens,
    2 small pigs,
    Complete assortment of vegetable and flower seeds,
    1 bushel mixed clover and timothy seed,
    1 garden cultivator,
    1 crosscut saw,
    1 ax,
    1 brush scythe,
    1 mattock.

    Cash payment, $400.
    Total cost, $1,250 to $1,500.

    These plans cover only 40 acres. If you wish larger acreage add to
    these plans what land you require, at $750 to $1,000 per 40-acre
    unit.

    As experience has shown, a settler on new land which he has to clear has no opportunity for using a horse to its fullest capacity during the first two years. Therefore the company does not include a horse in the preliminary equipment of a "made-to-order" farm. When a new settler needs horse power either for plowing or hauling he hires a horse from his older neighbors or from the company's demonstration farm at a reasonable price.

    One of the company's special efforts consists in securing a market for the settler's produce. With this end in view, co-operative creameries are favored and promoted by the company.

    It is the policy of the company to encourage the organization of local state banks wherever it does any colonizing work, for the company realizes that the short-time credit needs of the settlers must be taken care of. It always encourages the local merchants and people in the near-by towns to take some stock in the bank. Whatever stock is left over, different members connected with the company usually take, upon an understanding with the local people that as soon as any of them wish some of this stock the company will sell it to them at 6 per cent interest on its money.

    A number of years ago the company organized a bank in one of its colonies in order that the settlers might get proper credit. The company found it necessary to do something, as heretofore the settlers had had no opportunity to secure short-time credit. After the bank had been organized for three years the people in the colony desired to take the bank stock, and the men connected with the colonization company sold all their stock with the exception of one or two hundred dollars each, which the local people desired that they retain, so that out of $10,000 capital stock $1,000 is held by men interested in the company.

    In another colony some of the local people spoke for some stock and were offered the stock held by men interested in the colonization company at exactly what they paid for it, plus 6 per cent interest on their money.

    This has been true in the different sections where the company has promoted the organization of a bank.

    As the company's business methods are based upon the principle of the settler's success, the company is keeping in very close touch with its settlers. For each settler a "Progress Record" card is filed in the company's local office. The following reproduction of the main features of the card indicates the items that show the economic progress of the settler. Although it is not possible to have all the items filled up to date, a beginning is always made. As visits are made to the settlers' farms by the company's representatives, or the settlers come to the company office for advice or help, information is collected and added to the cards.

    Eventually an invaluable record of salient facts in regard to the settler and his progress is accumulated in this way.

    SETTLER'S PROGRESS RECORD

    Name ....................... Address .......................

    DESCRIPTION

    Acres
    .............Sec............Tp..........R........ .........
    .............Sec............Tp..........R........ .........
    .............Sec............Tp..........R........ .........
    County..............State...............Total acres.........
    Soil...............Distance from school................miles
    From town..........miles. Name...........................
    Nationality........Age..............Children................
    Previous farming experience.................................
    Bought........acres..........from...........................
    (year and month)
    Moved on land in..............191....

    From..................
    I had in cash.................In stock......................
    Tools and machinery.........................................
    Total net worth (when I moved on land) $................

    improved
    Price paid for unimproved land, $...........................
    _____________

    Paid in cash........................................
    Balance due.........................................

    Improvements, Equipment, and Live Stock included in purchase
    price.......................................................
    ............................................................
    Terms of contract...........................................
    Interest rate 6 per cent.

    RECORD OF PROGRESS

    1st 2d 3d 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th
    yr. yr. yr. yr. yr. yr. yr. yr.

    Built.......................................................
    Cleared (plowed)............................................
    Cleared (stumps in).........................................
    Fenced......................................................
    No. of cows.................................................
    No. of calves...............................................
    No. of horses...............................................
    No. of colts................................................
    No. of pigs.................................................
    Days worked out.............................................
    Owed on chattel.............................................
    Owed bank...................................................
    Paid on land (prin.)........................................
    Paid on land (int.).........................................

    PRESENT VALUE OF PROPERTY

    LAND

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    Acres Classification Acres Acre Total
    Fenced Value
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    .........Cultivated.........................................
    .........Cultivated (stumps in).............................
    .........Meadow (wild hay)..................................
    .........Unimproved.........................................
    -------------
    Total value of land..............$.............

    BUILDINGS

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    Size Material Insured For Total
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    House.......................................................
    Barn........................................................
    Silo........................................................
    -------------
    Total value of buildings..........$............

    LIVE STOCK

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    No.

    Value, Total
    Each
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    .........Dairy cows.........................................
    .........Dairy heifers......................................
    .........Dairy calves.......................................
    .........Beef cattle........................................
    .........Horses.............................................
    .........Colts..............................................
    .........Hogs...............................................
    .........Sheep..............................................
    ----------
    Total value of live stock.....$..........

    MACHINERY

    ..................................................
    ..................................................
    ----------
    Total value of machinery.......$..........

    Assets Liabilities
    Value of land.......$...... Due on land........$......
    Value of buildings............ Due on live stock.........
    Value of live stock........... Due on machinery..........
    Value of machinery............ Other debts...............
    Value of other property....... -------
    -------- Total..........$......
    Total.......$.......
    Present net worth......$.......

    These progress records are valuable to the company for a number of purposes. They help in considering extension of credit, in giving advice to the settlers, and in finding out what general business methods are the best for the company to follow in the way of assisting the settler to make a success.

    As the settler's future well-being depends to a certain degree upon his progress in Americanization, it would be advisable for the company to include in the record cards items concerning the date of the settler's arrival in America, his naturalization status, and the degree of his knowledge of English at the time of his settlement on land. These few additional items would hardly complicate or burden the recording work of the company's local office.

    THE ADVISER

    The company's officials stated that the immigrant family when first arriving in the colony is shy and helpless. The introduction of the family to the new conditions and surroundings has to be made gradually.

    A representative of the company meets the family at the station and directs it to a hotel, where it stays a few days before it is taken to the farm. During these several days the company's adviser calls often upon the family, talks with its members, takes them through the colony and introduces them to their future neighbors, and explains the local conditions. When the family is transferred to the farm the company's adviser still has to call almost daily, for there are numerous matters upon which the settler needs advice and encouragement.

    The majority of the new settlers are quite ignorant of the methods of land clearing. This the adviser has to teach them. How to feed cows, what and when to plant, how to cultivate, and how to handle the products--in all such questions the new settlers need constant direction. They themselves give two reasons for their need of advice in farming operations. First, the European methods of farm work are different from the American methods, especially because in Europe they were not engaged in opening up new land. Secondly, having been engaged in industrial work in America, often for long years, they have forgotten the European farm experience to a certain degree.

    While the writer was in the office of the adviser the settlers were constantly calling upon the latter for advice in all sorts of matters.

    One woman came, crying, and said, through her boy as interpreter, that her cow was sick and perhaps dying. Another woman sought advice as to her sick baby. A man came to ask that a certain road be extended to his place. Still another man wanted to do some stumping on his land in co-operation with his neighbors, provided the company lent a machine and the adviser came to direct the work. Another man asked advice in regard to the extension of credit to him. So the stream of inquiries went on continually. The adviser needed to be, as he was, an extremely capable man to deal with the extraordinary list of demands.

    He was an expert agriculturist, energetic, and in love with the game of helping the immigrant settlers.

    [Illustration]

    [Illustration: THIS TWO-YEAR-OLD WISCONSIN FARM IS JUST READY TO CARE

    FOR ITS NEWLY ACQUIRED SHROPSHIRE EWES]

    In regard to the need of a trained adviser for the new settlers the president of the company explained as follows:

    The greatest need for instruction is in land clearing, for the
    modern land-clearing methods--methods of just how to "brush," and
    at what time of year to conduct the operations--are entirely new to
    almost every settler arriving in the colony. No wonder we ourselves
    are studying, experimenting, and improving on land-clearing methods
    each month.

    In general, our immigrant colonists are efficient workers. The fact
    is that some of the buildings in our new town site are being built
    by our settlers. A large number of them were contractors. Many of
    the foreigners worked in the shipyards on the coast. Some of them
    worked on big farms. We find them very intelligent and capable, and
    some of them very good business men. We have built over twenty
    miles of road this year, every bit of it being done under contract,
    and the contracts were all taken by our new settlers. During the
    past year about two hundred houses were built, and these were all
    contracted to the new settlers.

    It is true they have many things to learn, just as we have. We are
    not really teaching them, but we are working with them, studying
    with them, learning much from them, just as they learn from us. We
    are opening up our demonstration farms, studying the problems just
    as they are.

    Our adviser's main work is to assist them in choosing
    the kind of seed best adapted to that country, to act as a kind of
    leader for the community, for they are all strangers, and until
    they have become accustomed to the country, and until leaders
    have sprung up among them, it is necessary that an outside leader,
    such as our agricultural adviser, should be employed, but not
    because of the ignorance or inefficiency of the foreigners.

    Observing the actual operations of such advisers in a number of cases, the writer has been convinced that in every new rural immigrant colony an intelligent, sympathetic, and efficient adviser is needed, and that the private colonization companies are to be commended for employing such advisers.

    CHILDREN OVERWORKED

    In one of the colonies the writer observed that the settlers' children worked a great deal. On one farm three children--two boys and one girl--of ages varying from nine to thirteen or fourteen, were clearing land of stones and the debris of brush and stumps. On another farm, the settler's wife, with her two tiny and delicate girls, was cultivating potatoes, each one using a rake. On a third farm, two boys, one of ten and the other of twelve, were cutting hay with scythes. The boys were thin and pale. In talk they appeared serious and somewhat cheerless, although in a measure enthusiastic about their new farm.

    The company's local officials and also the settlers themselves admitted that their children work considerably, even to the extent that they are often kept home from school. The settlers said that they understood the harm being done their children both by working too hard and by being withdrawn from school. But they are very eager to put their new farms on a paying basis in the shortest possible time. The company's officials said that they had so far not interfered with the use of child labor, but that in the future they would try to exercise some supervision over the work of children in the colony.

    The president of the company stated in regard to the labor of the settlers' children that "in some cases in the cities, on the farms, and everywhere, there is an indiscreet use of child labor, as also there is a practice in many communities of letting the children run wild. I believe I would rather trust future America to those brought up in pioneer regions than I would trust future America to those brought up under conditions where no hardship, no pioneering, no work whatever is expected of them."

    While this is quite true, nevertheless the writer's impression was that a number of the settlers overwork their children and keep them out of school at times.

    SECURING CREDIT

    As the company's overhead expenses for the maintenance of a number of offices, for the employment of a large number of agents and for commissions and extensive advertising, are heavy, the company is able to do successful business only on a very large scale. The head of this particular company believed that, in view of this fact, the tract of good farming land on which a company operates must be not less than 50,000 acres.

    He also stated that in view of the fact that the company's outlay of money, and especially its extension of credit to settlers, is very large, the reliable land development and colonization companies ought to be assisted in the way of credit by the public through the government.

    During the war the company had great difficulty in borrowing money on the settlers' mortgages. They had to pay a high rate of interest. Since the end of the war, however, the company has been able through the banks of the financial centers of the North Middle West to float a large number of collateral bonds on mortgages. These bonds at the present time sell to the general public at 6 per cent. The company, its president stated, must pay the cost of trusteeship commission on sale of bonds, etc., which brings the rate which the company pays to a fair amount above the 6 per cent which the ultimate investor receives.

    At the present time there is no difficulty in financing the organization, although it would be very desirable to have state and Federal assistance.

    Bills providing for such assistance have been introduced in the state legislatures of all of the northwest states. Congressman Knutson at Washington has introduced a land credit bill to provide capital for the development by land colonization of the agricultural resources of the nation, providing for certain privileges to soldier settlers, and creating a National Colonization Board.[7]

    CONSERVATION OF WOODED LAND

    While the company has made provision for the conservation of riparian rights, for roads, and even for town sites, it has done little for the conservation of wooded land. It has preserved the woodland on river banks and 160 acres of timber in one colony, and it has planted about 15,000 small pine trees. Moreover, the company encourages the conservation of woodland by the settlers, advising them to keep in timber from five to ten acres for each farm.

    How far the settlers will follow this good advice remains to be seen, while the conservation of wooded land by the company is inadequate. This the company's local officials admitted, but they reasoned that it would hardly be advisable for a single company, or even a number of companies, to attempt to conserve wooded land or other natural resources the return from which would be in the far distant future. It would be advisable for the state, or even for the Federal government, to make provisions and necessary regulations for the conservation of wooded land and other natural resources upon which the well-being of the public at large depends.

    THE SIZE OF A COLONY

    A number of Polish settlers in one of the colonies visited expressed the desire to have a Polish church and school. They believed that if the national Catholic Church organization would help them, they themselves would be able to maintain their church and school.

    This fact led the writer to a discussion with the company's officials as to the advisable size of a compact colony of the same nationality. They stated that if an immigrant family is established among settlers of another nationality, the family becomes lonely and desperate and after a year or two of such loneliness is apt to leave the farm, no matter how successful it has been in buying and cultivating the land. Therefore the company's policy is to settle the people of the same nationality together.

    The writer asked whether, if a colony of one nationality is large, having a hundred or several hundred families, the resulting conditions would not make for separation and isolation. They would have intimate intercourse only with one another, would establish a church and school of their own nationality, and would even develop their own town and elect their own local government officials. The company's officers admitted that this would possibly happen; they said that the company had not yet decided how large a colony of one nationality, in the same locality or neighborhood, it would develop.

    The personal opinion of one of the officials was that from fifteen to twenty-five families of one nationality in the same neighborhood would not be a source of danger because of becoming clannish and remaining un-Americanized for a generation or a number of generations. A colony of such size would not be able to maintain a church and school of its own nationality. As to the danger of inbreeding, the officials pointed out that the church rules and state laws would prohibit it, and said that, furthermore, the immigrants, having friends and acquaintances elsewhere in the country, would marry into other groups of immigrants.

    LEARNING AMERICAN WAYS

    The writer, while visiting the company's colonies, was struck by the fact that the settlers who said they had been in this country from eight to ten years understood and spoke very little English, seemed to be rather shy, and in general appearance lacked signs of American influence. Overalls and the tools in their hands were almost the only betraying marks of the American environment.

    The investigation developed the fact that most of the settlers had lived previously in the congested "Little Polands" in Chicago, Detroit, and Milwaukee. The settlers explained that they lived there as in the old country, having their own Polish church, Polish schools, Polish banks, Polish stores, Polish books and papers, speaking Polish in their homes, in the streets, and in social gatherings. Even in the factories where they worked, their fellow workers were often Poles; sometimes even the foreman was a Pole. There was almost no opportunity for coming in contact with the American ways of life and with the country's language.

    Several settlers declared that they had learned more about America and had used English more during the last two years in the northern wilderness than during the previous seven or eight years in the city of Chicago. Settling on land, they came in contact with the American land agents, other company officials, government authorities, American banks and stores, and with American neighbors at the community meetings. Here in the wilderness they first found how badly they needed English and a knowledge of American ways. A number of parents started to learn English by taking lessons from their children, who themselves were learning English in the local public schools.

    The company's officials stated, in confirmation, that the Polish settlers in their colonies were growing in dignity and self-reliance, that they were assuming American characteristics and an American bearing.

    TWO POINTS OF VIEW

    As the colonies of the company are comparatively young, it is impossible to foresee their future with certainty. So far they seem to be on a sound basis, and their success rather than their failure is to be expected. The soil is good and the settlers stick hard to their work on the land. The first colony founded seems to be over the danger line already. It is no longer under the financial control of the company, the settlers have secured loans outside, and their farms are progressing from the experimental stage to that of established security.

    However, a settler expressed the following apprehension to the writer:

    You see us, men and women, old and young, working here in the
    wilderness like beavers, clearing and digging, scraping and
    building. All are pressed hard by a strong hope of establishing a
    permanent home and of earning future independence. But we still
    live in makeshift houses, and so far only a few families are able
    to make a living, bare and meager, out of their clearings,
    diggings, and cows. The vast majority--almost all of us--have, at
    times, to leave the farm in care of women and children and look for
    work elsewhere--in Duluth, Chicago, Detroit--for the purpose of
    earning bread for the family on the farm.

    A number temporarily hire
    out to the company, but the latter's wages are considerably less
    than we get in the industrial centers.

    You have heard the company's officials and seen their doings, and
    everything might seem to you to work smoothly for the benefit of
    the settlers. Is it not so?

    For instance, the company claims that
    it sells us tools at cost, but we already have found out in regard
    to a number of things that the company makes a fair profit on them.
    Again, the company claims that it runs the demonstration farms only
    for our benefit, but as a matter of fact the company's aim is, as
    we understand it, to build up a large farm estate on the best land
    of the tract, and to sell us its products, seeds, breeding stock,
    etc.; in other words, to make money out of demonstration.

    One
    hardly can object to this, except that the company claims that it
    is doing business with us "at cost," which is not so.

    Almost in everything, even in our home life, we depend upon the
    good will of the company, and so far we have not much complaint to
    make against it. In general, it has treated us well under the
    existing circumstances, but we are a little apprehensive about our
    future. Suppose we, as settlers, finally succeed in making good,
    clear our land, and build up our farms, as expected by the company
    and hoped by ourselves. Will we then be free and independent of the
    company's control? We are afraid not.

    We will still have to
    transact our financial matters through the bank in which the
    company is interested, sell our products through the company's
    agency, etc., not because any law or stipulation would require
    this, but solely because the company, with all its business
    establishments, is here among us. The company is retaining river
    shores, town sites connected with certain business privileges, and
    the best pieces of land, as its demonstration farms. This means
    that the company, with its fatherly care for us, is going to remain
    with us for a long time to come.

    The field notes of the writer on the above statements of the settler were later shown to the company's head, who answered them as follows:

    The expression "makeshift houses" is not fitting at all, for the
    buildings are warm and comfortable--hardwood floors, painted wall
    board inside. They are small, it is true. You can travel the
    country over, where pioneers are located, and I defy anyone to find
    a better-looking set of houses than those in any one of our colonies.

    This man states that so far only a few families are able to make a
    living. In our older colonies I could show a list of cream checks
    which the different settlers are receiving from their cows; they
    will range all the way from $50 to $400 a month. This does not take
    into consideration the surplus live stock, potatoes, and other
    grains, which they sell from their farms. It is not expected that
    these new settlers will make money out of their crops for the first
    few years. It is expected that they will go away to the cities and
    work part of the time, while their families remain on the land.

    We
    state in our literature, as does all state literature, that the
    first two or three years contain hardships, and mean some working
    out to earn money, provided the settler comes without any funds
    whatever. The survey of all our settlers shows that while they have
    worked in the city ten to fifteen years, their entire savings have
    amounted to from $200 to $1,000. In the colonies, due to clearing,
    increased value of land, and earnings on their new farms, they have
    made from $500 to $1,000 a year. Surely this entails some hardship
    and some hard work.

    The statement that some of them hired out to the company at less
    wages than are paid in industrial centers I'll agree was true
    during war times. We could not hope to compete with the wages paid
    in the munition factories of the East. The company does, however,
    pay standard wages, as high as are paid anywhere for the same class
    of labor.

    The statement that the company claims that it sells the necessities
    at cost is not correct, for the company sells nothing. We have an
    iron-bound practice that in no case do we enter into the store or
    sales business. We furnish the original house, barn, tools, live
    stock, with the land. After that we sell nothing.

    We have often
    stated that if we would enter into the store business or selling
    business, it would drive others out, and it was poor practice for
    the company to engage in any business outside of colonization, for
    it involved too much detail and was a separate business.
    Colonization is a game all of itself, and if we divided our
    energies with other industries we could not succeed.

    Some time ago a charge similar to this was made by some of the
    settlers, stating that the company was making profits on buildings.
    We immediately offered to have any lumber company agree to put up
    those buildings for the same price that we did. We asked for a
    large number of bids, and the nearest bid was one hundred and
    twenty-five dollars more than the price we were charging the
    settlers. We did not ask them to bid on only one house, but on one
    hundred houses a year.

    The reason we have been able to construct
    these buildings at such a low rate is that we have our own timber.
    When the price of lumber went up during war times, we did not
    increase our price one dollar. By building hundreds of houses each
    year, by eight or ten years of experiment, and keeping the same
    foreman and crew, we have been able to develop an efficiency that
    will allow us to put these buildings up at one hundred dollars less
    than the best bid we could get from anyone.

    We would gladly give up
    this detail work if some one else could do it, for we make no money
    on it and barely take care of costs and our necessary overhead.

    As to furnishing cattle, we made an offer to one of the local
    Holstein and Guernsey associations, asking them if they would be
    willing to furnish all of our settlers cows at the same price we
    were asking, and deliver them at the same time we were delivering
    them; we could not get anyone to accept our offer. We have lost
    money right along on our live stock--not a great deal, but a small
    amount. So when your informer tells you that they purchase goods
    from the company at a fair profit to the company, the statement is
    not correct, for we sell no goods to them at all except what goes
    with the land.

    In no case do we buy anything from the settlers, and
    in no case do we sell anything to them, except the original
    equipment which goes with the original purchase.

    The statement that the company's purpose is to reserve large
    demonstration farms is laughable, for we only have two
    demonstration farms reserved in our entire tract of 60,000 acres.
    Those two demonstration farms cover 2,500 acres. Already one
    demonstration farm in a colony where we sold practically all the
    land has been cut up into small farms and offered for general sale.
    The other demonstration farm is in the vicinity of our present
    settlement and is not now broken up.

    In our oldest colony we reserve not a foot of land there. The
    cheese factory which we started we turned over to the co-operative
    organization. The warehouse which we constructed we turned over to
    a Co-operative Shippers' Association.

    There is one thing that your informant is correct on, and that is
    that we retain the river shores. We have retained the riparian
    rights for the reason that some day we hope to turn this over to a
    water-power company and develop hydroelectric power for the benefit
    of that whole community. If these river shores were in the hands of
    different settlers, it would be impossible for a hydroelectric
    company ever to go in there and purchase each farm separately at a
    price that would enable it to develop the power.

    The contradictions in the above interviews are to be explained by the settlers' misunderstanding of the company's general policy and methods.

    In their eyes everything in the colony belongs to and is managed by the company, which is quite true at the beginning of the colony, and which cannot be otherwise at that time. The new settlers know little of one another, and are ignorant of the local conditions. They lack both business experience and capital. Therefore, as a rule they are not able to conduct, either individually or on a co-operative basis, commercial or industrial establishments at the start. It is therefore up to the company to see that there is a town, a hotel, a grocery store, a bank, a creamery, or cheese factory, a shipping office, etc., in the colony.

    The fact that the company has interests in, and even controls, these concerns at the beginning, and that all these business branches work together, conducting their financial transactions through the same bank, has led the settlers to believe that everything is permanently owned and controlled by the company. The settlers in a new colony do not know that as soon as the success of these business organizations is secure and the settlers have been assisted to a firmer footing the company will turn the organizations over to the settlers themselves on a co-operative basis, as has already been done in the company's oldest colony.

    It is the company's policy, as above stated by its head, to specialize in the land colonization work only, leaving banking, commerce, and manufactures to others.

    COLONY SNAPSHOTS

    The writer visited and investigated two colonies of new settlers founded by the colonization company within a distance of about twenty to thirty miles from one another. The following field notes taken during interviews with the company's local officials and the settlers themselves give a general picture of the conditions of the colonies.

    In the first colony, the first families settled about twelve to fifteen years ago. At that time a logging camp was operating and the country was covered with standing timber. As fast as the loggers cleared the timber the land was opened for settlement by the colonization company. Land buyers were taken into the logging camp, were given meals and sleeping quarters there, and were taken out and shown their land. About five years after the first settlers came most of the timber had been cut. The company then established the village and began settling from that point. The colony has steadily increased and at present contains about fifty families.

    The settlers were Polish. About ten families came from Russia, twenty from Germany, and twenty from Austria. They left their old country on account of poverty, political oppression, and compulsory military service there. Almost all of them had been engaged in agriculture in the old country. About forty families had been employed in shops and factories in America before they succeeded in settling on land here; only about ten families came from Europe directly to the colony, of which they learned through the company's advertisements in the American-Polish newspapers and also through the letters of their friends and acquaintances.

    The largest farm is 120 acres, the smallest 20 acres, and the average 80 acres. Most of the farms are still under mortgage, only a few being cleared of debt.

    In the colony and its vicinity are seven schools: six with one room and one with three rooms. All teachers are native born and all teaching is in English. The settlers appreciate education. Most of the children are inclined to farming and will remain in the colony. One fourth of the adults do not speak English, one half only speak English, and one fourth speak and write English.

    Only a few of the adult male settlers have second papers; about nine tenths have first papers, while the rest are totally unnaturalized. In explanation of this fact the company's president stated that it is only the older men who have not secured even their first papers.

    A large proportion of the foreign settlers [he said] secure their
    second papers just as rapidly as they can after they locate on the
    land. They desire to take part in local politics; they find that
    they must become interested in local political affairs if they wish
    to have a good system of schools, roads, and gain the other
    advantages which both the county and town can give them. They are
    also interested in the state politics.

    All this brings the question
    of second papers forcibly to their minds, and in an accurate survey
    of the different colonies we are interested in, you will find that
    a large per cent of those who have been on the land five years or
    more have already secured their second papers. One of the
    difficulties which hinder them from getting their second papers
    sooner is the fact that they must have some one certify that he has
    actually known them for a period of five years.

    Coming as they do,
    strangers from another state, it is necessary that they live among
    us for a five-year period before such an affidavit can be secured.
    I have had many of the settlers speak to me, desiring second
    papers, but they were forced to wait their period before they could
    secure them.

    Most of the settlers read the Polish newspapers published in America.

    Quite a number of families take books from the school libraries; among these are a few Polish books--stories and histories.

    The settlers are of the Roman Catholic faith. They attend a local church. Their Catholic neighbors of other nationalities attend the same church. The priest is of the Polish nationality; he cannot speak English well. He is appointed by the bishop. The settlers would prefer to elect their priest themselves.

    While the houses are of the American type, the interior arrangement of the living rooms remains that of the European Slavic peasantry--the bedcover is often fancy handiwork, the walls are profusely covered with family photographs, pictures of Polish heroes, and magazine illustrations. However, an honored place is given to the picture of the President and the American flag. Furniture is placed against the wall around the room. The premises are kept comparatively clean and in order.

    Diet is rather mixed, though the Polish meals and the Polish ways of cooking predominate. The settlers claim that their housewives are more frugal than the American housewives in their neighborhood.

    There are very few intermarriages; nationality alone is considered a drawback for intermarriage between a Pole and non-Pole. In cases where the two people are of different faith, the Church is another drawback.

    Family discipline, in respect to the authority of the husband as the family head, is less strict than in the old country. The settlers believe that this is due to the American influence. Here the husband has to consult his wife in every important question and the children are not so often punished.

    The relations between the colonists and the national groups in the neighborhood are generally friendly and help is given mutually in cases of need. But there is very little social visiting between the groups, the difference in nationality being a bar.

    The settlers secure agricultural advice from two sources--the company's adviser and the county agent. They raise wheat, rye, oats, potatoes, grasses--clover and timothy--while their main income is derived from milk production.

    The products are sold to the local agents; there is no discrimination in prices. Necessities are bought in the near-by towns, prices being too high and goods not always suited to the needs of the settlers.

    Money is loaned by the local banks at 7 to 8 per cent. This rate, the company stated, was on short-time, unsecured paper. The settlers, it maintained, have always been able to secure money on farm mortgages at 6 and 7 per cent.

    Economically stronger families compel their children to do chores and work in the field outside of school time, while poorer and weaker families, especially those of more recent settlers, often let their children work even during school time.

    The settlers are satisfied with their conditions and they all desire to remain permanently in America. The only thing they want is an increase in the number of settlers and further development of their locality.

    The second colony[8] visited by the writer was started by the company the year before (1917). There are now about sixty Polish families in the colony. Half of the adult male population were deserters from the compulsory military service in Russia, Germany, and Austria. "Why should we have served in the armies by which Poland was oppressed!" exclaimed a settler when asked as to their justification for desertion.

    Before settling on the land they all had worked in steel mills, factories, mines, etc., some five to six years, some longer, but their experience in Europe had been on farms. While in America they had learned of the land from the company's advertisements in the Polish papers. In regard to the settlers' previous farming experience the company's head said that

    our company will not sell land to any settler who has not had some
    farm experience. We advise them first to work on a farm
    somewhere--either rent it or hire out--until they have gained the
    necessary experience to make them successful on their farms. These
    people here are not factory workers, but are primarily farmers,
    land hungry, who came to this country for the purpose of owning a
    home, and only temporarily worked in steel mills, factories, and
    mines, in order to secure sufficient money to get the start that
    they so much desire.

    About ten settlers had gone, at the time of the writer's visit, to work in Duluth and Chicago. Their families and other settlers were busily engaged in land clearing. The smallest clearing was 6 acres, the largest 20 acres, and the average clearing for each farm was 10 acres--that is, about one sixth of the land was already cleared, but most of the cleared land was not yet turned. The size of the largest farm was 120 acres, that of the smallest 40 acres, and of the average 60 acres.

    In May the company organized a land-clearing contest among the settlers of its colonies, providing rewards for the winners. "This was a big event in our colony--the men pushed the brush for all they were worth," said the company's agent.

    The settlers estimated that all of the adult males understand English, and that about 70 per cent can also speak English, though not well, while not one can intelligibly write English. Most of the adult women do not even understand English.

    There is no Polish church. Once in two or three weeks a Polish priest comes. The majority of the settlers do not care about having a Polish church and school. They claim that their religious sentiment is weaker in America than it was in Europe.

    Their diet is almost entirely Polish. Some families keep their homes clean and in order; some continue to live in dirt as in Europe.

    Relations between the Polish and non-Polish settlers are good, though no social visiting takes place. Still, they meet and see one another at the community hall, about which the settlers seemed to be enthusiastic.

    In clearing land the settlers have so far applied hand labor almost exclusively, but in the coming year horse power will be needed. Near the houses small potato patches and vegetable gardens have been planted.

    Field crops have been started, in a small and primitive way, and among these oats and feed grasses predominate. The sale of milk is the most important item of income of the settlers. Dairy farming is the company's aim in the development of the colony.

    In regard to the clearing of land the company emphasized the point that the land does not all have to be cleared in order to produce.

    Cattle are immediately turned into the brushland, and can pasture
    upon the brush, the native grasses, and the clover which grows
    throughout the entire region. Land which is cleared is used for
    winter food products. Summer feed for the cattle, hogs, and horses
    comes almost exclusively from the uncleared land. By following
    dairying and live-stock raising, the entire land becomes productive
    at once, while grain or vegetable farming would mean that only the
    land under cultivation would be producing.

    The men of the colony seemed to be rather cheerful and hopeful, while their wives impressed the writer as being somewhat downcast and self-centered. Several of them said that they have to work much harder in the colony than in the cities or even in the old country.

    [7] H. R. 3274, 66th Congress, 1st Session.

    [8] Only those field notes are here quoted which vary from the description of the first colony.

    VI

    PUBLIC LAND COLONIZATION

    California is the first, and so far the only state in the Union to undertake the public colonization of land. Its first experiment is very recent and on a comparatively small scale. Its leaders are ably utilizing their knowledge of the experiences in public land colonization in foreign countries such as Australia, New Zealand, the Scandinavian states, and Great Britain. Although it is impossible to foresee the outcome, the writer is inclined to believe that the public land colonization in California will continue to be a success, giving impetus to similar projects in other states.

    THE CALIFORNIA EXPERIMENT

    The California experiment and its history may be outlined briefly as follows: A report of the California Commission on Land Colonization and Rural Credits made in 1916 revealed the fact that few settlers were coming to California and that many who had come were leaving because of hardships created by high prices of land, high interest rates, and short terms of payment given in colonization contracts. As a result, the California legislature passed the Land Settlement Act, approved June 1, 1917,[9] for the purpose of

    promoting closer agricultural settlement, assisting deserving and
    qualified persons to acquire small improved farms, providing homes
    for farm laborers, increasing opportunities under the Federal Farm
    Loan Act, and demonstrating the value of adequate capital and
    organized direction in sub-dividing and preparing agricultural land
    for settlement.

    The act appropriated $250,000 for a demonstration in state land colonization, fixing 10,000 acres as the limit which should be bought.

    The land might be situated in one or two localities, but not profitably in more, because of the increase in overhead expenses. To carry out the provisions of the act a state Land Settlement Board was appointed of which Prof. Elwood Mead was chairman. The board was organized at the end of August, 1917, and immediately began the search for a suitable tract of land. With the advice of technical experts of the University of California and of other authorities upon soil, irrigation, health, and various conditions which would affect the success of the colony, final selection was made of a tract at Durham, Butte County, California.

    On May 7, 1918, the land was finally transferred to the state. Prior to this, however, the land had been subdivided and had been prepared for farming, a large acreage having even been seeded. On May 15th, 3,421 acres were offered to settlers, consisting of 53 farms, ranging in size from 3-1/2 acres to 160 acres, and of 21 two-acre farm laborers allotments. The prices of the farms varied from $875 (above which the next price was $3,646) to $14,942. The price of the farm laborers' allotments was $400.

    The law provided that the value of the former, without improvements, should not exceed $15,000, and that of the latter, without improvements, should not exceed $400. The terms of sale were as follows:

    Settlers were to pay 5 per cent of the cost of the land and 40 per cent of the cost of the improvements at the time of purchase, the remainder of the purchase price to be paid over a period of twenty years with interest at the rate of 5 per cent per annum. Payments of principal and interest were to be made semiannually in accord with the amortization table of the Federal Farm Loan Board.

    All applicants for land were carefully considered as to their character and their fitness for farming. The minimum amount of capital a settler was required to have was fixed at $1,500 or a working equipment of equal value. A farm laborer was not required to have any capital, but had only to pay the initial deposit of $20 and semiannual payments of about $15.

    The board reserved the right of supervision of the methods of cultivation of each settler, of the state of repair of buildings, of fire-insurance policies, and of other details.

    Plans of houses and barns were prepared and the board offered to build these, or others, for the settler, on payment of 40 per cent of the cost.

    An engineer was employed to supervise the erection of buildings and to help settlers plan the grouping of buildings, orchard, garden, and field. The board bought material at wholesale and let contracts in groups and in this way each family was saved much money and valuable farming time.

    The board kept the following objects in view:

    1. That the settlement become widely and favorably known as the home of

    one breed of dairy cattle, one breed of beef cattle, one breed of hogs, and one or two breeds of sheep.

    1. The co-operation of the settlers in buying and selling.
    1. The establishment at Durham, or on the settlement, of a training

    school in agriculture.

    1. The erection in the near future of a social hall owned and paid for

    by settlers.

    Co-operative action among the farmers and farm laborers was particularly desired and encouraged. A co-operative stock breeders' association was formed. Twenty-two acres were reserved for community use, and here it is hoped that community buildings will be erected.

    When the farms were offered for sale there were from ten to fourteen applicants for each of the improved farms. Four of the unimproved farms were not applied for and these will be seeded and offered to settlers later at the opening of the next tract. Every one of the farm laborers' allotments was applied for. The settlement was made self-sustaining and productive within sixty days from the date the land was purchased.

    As to the racial composition of this colony and the way in which the method of colonization would affect the incorporation of the different racial elements in the life of the settlement, the superintendent, Mr.

    George C. Kreutzer, made the following statement:

    Five of the settlers on the colony are of German origin, two of
    Danish origin, two Italian, one French, and all the others are of
    either English, Irish, or Scotch origin.

    No policy of mixing nationalities was followed. These farmers put
    in either a first, second, or third choice for the allotments they
    desired, and the board then selected the man best suited
    agriculturally for the particular block he was allotted.

    Under our system of allotting blocks here the farmers are
    particularly concerned in making a success of their farms
    financially, rather than socially. We were never confronted with
    the problem of having too many of one nationality in the community,
    and as we have only fifty-three farms to offer for settlers, it is
    not large enough to involve the problem at all. Further than this,
    I do not think the problem will come up under this system of
    allotting blocks, for the reason first stated above.

    It will Americanize immigrants through co-operation and social
    intercourse, through the various settlers' organizations necessary
    to their social and financial welfare. We have a Stock Breeders'
    Association which meets at regular times to discuss live-stock
    problems at intervals during the year. They are all on equal terms,
    each one buying the land for himself, thus breaking down class
    distinction. There will not be the distinction between lessees and
    freeholders that we find in the Middle States. Their children will
    go to the same school.

    This undertaking of California is the only one in the field of public land colonization anywhere in the country, except for projects involving soldier settlements which some states have lately begun to undertake.

    STATE PROVISION FOR SOLDIER SETTLEMENTS

    With the close of the War there began to appear on the calendars of state legislatures the subject of land settlement provision for returning soldiers. Up to the time this report was written, twenty-three states had passed some legislation relative to this need. The following table indicates in a general way the extent and nature of this provision.

    TABLE II

    STATE LEGISLATION TO PROMOTE LAND SETTLEMENT FOR SOLDIERS UP TO JUNE,

    1919[11]
    ---------------------------------------------------------------+
    | | | Amount of
    State | Bill Number| Date Approved |Appropriation
    --------------+------------+---------------------+-------------+
    Arizona | Senate 89|March 26, 1919[10]|$ 100,000
    | | |
    California |{Senate 246|April, 1919 | 10,000,000
    |{Senate 221|April, 1919[10]| 1,000,000
    Colorado | Senate 262|April 9, 1919[10]|
    Delaware | House 182|April 2, 1919 | 25,000
    Florida | Senate 21|December 7, 1918[10]|
    Idaho | House 100|March 7, 1919[10]| 100,000
    Maine | Chapter 89|April 4, 1919[10]|
    | | |
    Missouri |{Senate 355|April, 1919[10]| 10,000
    |{Senate 15|April, 1919[10]| 1,000,000
    Montana |{House 130|March 11, 1919[10]| 50,000
    |{House 170|March 4, 1919[10]| 200,000
    Nevada | House 219|March 28, 1919 | 1,000,000
    New Jersey | Senate 5|March 26, 1919 |
    New Mexico | House 204|March, 1919[10]| 30,000
    North Carolina| Chapter 266|March 10, 1919[10]|
    North Dakota | House 128|March 6, 1919 |
    | | |
    Oklahoma | Number 249|March 28, 1919 | 250,000
    Oregon | Senate 147|March 4, 1919[10]| 50,000
    South Dakota | Senate 255|March, 1919[10]| 100,000
    | | | 1,000,000
    Tennessee | House 447|April 16, 1919[10]|
    Texas | |May 24, 1919 |
    Utah |{Senate 79|March 17, 1919[10]| 25,000
    |{Senate 80|March 17, 1919[10]| 1,000,000
    Vermont | Number 15|March 26, 1919 |
    Washington |{House 200|March 18, 1919 | 1,050,000
    |{Senate 184|March 20, 1919[10]| 160,000
    Wisconsin | Senate 8|February 23, 1919[10]|
    Wyoming | Senate 70|February 28, 1919[10]| 5,000
    | | | 200,000
    ---------------------------------------------------------------+

    TABLE II--Continued

    STATE LEGISLATION TO PROMOTE LAND SETTLEMENT FOR SOLDIERS UP TO JUNE,

    1919[11]
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    |
    State | Special Note
    --------------+---------------------------------------------
    Arizona |To aid Federal Reclamation Service in this
    | state.
    California |Referendum on bond issue.
    |
    Colorado |No appropriation indicated.
    Delaware |
    Florida |Appropriating state lands.
    Idaho |Conditional upon similar Federal legislation.
    Maine |Necessary amount out of remainder of
    | reserve land fund.
    Missouri |
    |Revolving fund submitted to popular vote.
    Montana |
    |To be drawn upon if necessary.
    Nevada |By bond sale.
    New Jersey |Appropriation for placement work.
    New Mexico |Plus half of certain state rentals and sales.
    North Carolina|Commission appointed to report.
    North Dakota |Twenty-five dollars per soldier per month
    | in service.
    Oklahoma |For loans to land settlers.
    Oregon |
    South Dakota |
    |Bond issue.
    Tennessee |No appropriation indicated.
    Texas |State credit for land settlers.
    Utah |
    |Bond issue.
    Vermont |
    Washington |Revolving fund for state Reclamation Act.
    |For land settlement.
    Wisconsin |Commission appointed to report.
    Wyoming |
    |For loans to land settlers.
    ------------------------------------------------------------

    In more than half the states the laws refer to Federal legislation, in a few cases specifying that the appropriation shall be contingent upon a national appropriation. Several states signify their approval of co-operation with Federal provision, but make no appropriation for the work. The largest appropriation in the form of a bond issue for popular approval of $10,000,000 was passed by the California legislature.

    Similar provision was made by Missouri, South Dakota, and Utah to the amount of $1,000,000. Nevada arranged for the borrowing of $1,000,000 for "reclamation, improvement, and equipment of lands ... for soldiers, sailors, marines, and other loyal citizens." Washington appropriated a revolving fund beginning with $1,050,000 and eventually reaching $3,000,000 to create a state Reclamation Service.

    In spite of this evidence of awakened interest in soldier settlements, many such projects have died before any real attempt could be made to put them into practical operation. This is to be explained as follows.

    The projects in a number of cases were products rather of sentiment than of logic based upon experience. War-time patriotism created a desire to give some sort of reward to men fighting for the country's cause. "Let us give to each returning soldier a farm--a ready-made farm!" was heard throughout the country. Whether we had enough land, or economically available land, for millions of farms was not always asked. Many of the project-makers turned to our swamps, deserts, and cut-over lands filled with stumps and debris.

    The easy-flowing imagination of these people, especially of the city type, made out of these lands new farms, flourishing gardens, meadows and fields burdened with crops waving in the winds. How much it would cost, whence would come the money and energy to create such a miracle, and how much time the prosecution of the plan would require was not asked. Would not our returned soldiers, who already are matured men, be in their graves before their desert and swamp farms gave a living to their cultivators? Still more strange was the common notion that all soldiers, even the crippled, were eager to settle on land--that all wanted land and all were fit to be farmers!

    As the product of mere fancy, such sweeping soldiers' settlement projects were bound to die a natural death. And yet they have not been without value. They created lively discussion, and called attention to our land problems, especially to the reclamation and colonization of unused lands by the people who want land and are fit to be farmers and to do hard land-pioneering work, be they returned soldiers, native farmers, or newly arrived immigrants.

    THE RECLAMATION ACT

    The Federal Reclamation Service was established by an act of June 17, 1902, ch. 1093, 32 Stat., 388.[12] This act provides that the moneys received from the sale of public lands in the Western states, with the exception of the 5 per centum reserved by law for educational and other purposes, shall be set aside in the Treasury as a reclamation fund to be used for the construction and maintenance of irrigation works for the purpose of reclaiming arid and semiarid lands in these states.

    Authority to conduct the reclamation work is placed in the hands of the Secretary of the Interior. He is given authority to withdraw from public entry the lands required for irrigation works and to restore the withdrawn lands to public entry when their use for such purpose is over.

    Under the authority conferred upon him by the act (Section 4, and Opinion Assistant Attorney General, April 16, 1906, 34 L. D., 567) he may enter into contracts for the construction of irrigation works or construct such works by labor employed and operated under the superintendence and direction of government officials.

    The Secretary is authorized to give public notice of the lands irrigable under such project, and limit of area per entry, which limit shall represent the acreage which, in the opinion of the Secretary, may be reasonably required for the support of a family upon the reclaimed lands; and of the charges which shall be made per acre upon the entries, and upon lands in private ownership which may be irrigated by the waters of the irrigation works. The charges shall be determined with a view to returning to the reclamation fund the cost of construction and shall be apportioned equitably.

    It is provided that in all construction work eight hours shall constitute a day's work and no Mongolian labor shall be employed (32 Stat., 389). No right to the use of water for land in private ownership shall be sold for a tract exceeding 160 acres to any one landowner. It is provided that the reclamation fund shall be used for the operation and maintenance of irrigation works and that when the payments required by the act are made for the major portion of the lands irrigated the management of these works shall pass to the landowners.

    The Secretary of the Interior is authorized to acquire any rights or property for reclamation purposes by purchase or by condemnation under judicial process, and to pay from the reclamation fund sums needed for that purpose. Within thirty days, upon application of the Secretary of the Interior, the Attorney General of the United States shall institute condemnation proceedings. The Secretary of the Interior is authorized to make rules and regulations for carrying the provisions of the act into full force and effect.

    In the seventeen years since the passage of the Reclamation Act the surveys, examinations, and construction authorized by it have proceeded, and to-day, according to the report of the Secretary of the Interior for 1919,[13]

    the service is in a position to deliver water to about 1,600,000
    acres of irrigable land, covered by crop census, of which about
    1,120,000 acres are now being irrigated. Besides this storage water
    is delivered from permanent reservoirs under special contracts to
    about 950,000 acres more. The projects that have been undertaken
    have been planned to provide for an area of about 3,200,000 acres.

    A number of bills have been proposed for enlarging and extending this work.

    PROPOSED FEDERAL LEGISLATION

    The Department of the Interior has prepared a draft of a bill providing rural homes for returning soldiers. Copies of the bill were sent to the Governors for consideration by various state legislatures.

    The bill is based on the principle of co-operation, according to which (1) the state provides land, acquiring it by purchase or by agreement with the present landowners whereby the latter turn their holdings over to the state for a reasonable price gradually paid to them out of the returns from the settlers, and (2) the Federal government advances money for reclamation through irrigation, drainage, and clearing, and for preparation of the land for immediate farming through the providing of buildings, implements, seeds, live stock, etc.

    The total cost of the land and improvements, with interest at 4 per cent on capital invested, will be repaid by the settlers during the course of, approximately, forty years by an annual payment of 5 per cent of the total cost.

    A bill was introduced in Congress by Senator Myers (S. 4947, 65th Congress, 2d Session) in October, 1918, and backed by the Department of the Interior, which provided for a survey and classification by this department of all unentered public lands and all privately owned unused lands for the purpose of finding out what lands can be reclaimed and put to productive use by returning soldiers who would like to settle on land and engage in agriculture. After such an investigation the Secretary of the Interior was required to report to Congress and to propose a plan for the settlement and cultivation of such lands.

    There were two bills (S. 5397 and H. 15672) introduced by Senator W. S.

    Kenyon of Iowa and Representative M. Clyde Kelly of Pennsylvania, respectively, which, among other features, made possible development of rural districts. Although differing in details, the bills both appropriated $100,000,000 to be expended in providing employment primarily for returning soldiers. This was to be done through the authorized public construction work, or through the organization and extension of useful public works, in the development of natural resources. Only in localities where the Secretary of Labor reports extraordinary unemployment to exist shall public works be carried on from this fund.

    The House bill provided for the building of new post roads; for the transfer of war material no longer needed by the army, the same to be used for the construction, improvement, and maintenance of the post roads; for supplementing the public school equipment where public school buildings are or shall be designated as postal stations, for the use of the construction service; and for other purposes.

    The bill provides for the establishment of motor transport and postal routes; for the organization of a system of marketing facilities for the collection and delivery, through the postal service and public school buildings, of farm products from producer to consumer; and for the construction of any authorized public work.

    In addition to these more indirect ways of opening up the country the bill carried specific provision for promoting and conducting land-settlement colonies, as well as provision for logging or milling operations, contingent upon a continuous yield of timber, so that the forest communities would be permanent. The provisions of the bill were to be carried out by an interdepartmental National Board of Public Construction, which would organize a body of workers, known as the United States Construction Service.

    Since the bill carried the reclamation and technical land-improvement work, the only question might be, is there any need for this to be carried on by a special Construction Service? Would it not be a duplication of the work of the already existing Reclamation Service of the Department of the Interior? Would it not be economical and otherwise proper to increase the staff and other working forces of the Reclamation Service to the extent of the proposed reclamation duties of the Construction Service?

    Representative E. T. Taylor of Colorado introduced in the House, February 15, 1919, a bill (H. R. 15993) providing for employment and the securing of rural homes for returned soldiers and for the promotion of the reclamation of land for cultivation under the direction of the Secretary of the Interior. Short-term loans to settlers were provided for. This bill contains a good land-development plan, except that the Reclamation Service, Department of the Interior, ought not to be burdened with colonization work and with loans to settlers.

    Colonization work ought to be the duty of a separate body, and the extension of credit to settlers naturally belongs to the Farm Loan Board, Department of the Treasury.

    Representative Mondell of Wyoming introduced in the House, May 19, 1919, a bill (H. R. 487) providing employment and rural homes for returned soldiers through the reclamation of lands under the direction of the Secretary of the Interior, who may, for this purpose, acquire by gift, purchase, deed in trust, or otherwise, the necessary lands for soldier settlement projects and, for the same purpose, may withdraw, utilize, and dispose of by contract and deed suitable public lands. An appropriation of $500,000 is proposed.

    The plan in this bill for the acquisition and reclamation of unused land is a strong one. Equally commendable is the provision for safeguarding the settlers' holdings against speculation, for the selling, leasing, or mortgaging of the land by settlers requires the approval of the Secretary of the Interior. The bill requires that the Interior Department, through its Reclamation Service, acquire and improve lands, colonize them, and make loans to settlers. It would seem a more efficient plan to make a division of these various duties.

    The Reclamation Service should acquire and improve lands for settlement, while the colonization work and the extension of loans to settlers would be made the duties of other public authorities, as pointed out below.

    House Bill No. 3274, introduced by Representative Knutson, May 27, 1919, proposes to create, in the Treasury Department, a National Colonization Board with local colonization commissions, for the purpose of providing capital for the development by land colonization of the agricultural resources of the nation, affording certain privileges to soldier settlers. The commissions approve and charter private colonization companies and recommend applications for loans after seeing all the provisions of the act have been complied with. The commissions are to include the directors of the district land bank.

    The main aim of the bill is to standardize private land colonization companies to a certain degree, to facilitate the extension of credit to them, and to make loans to soldier settlers. The Knutson bill in meeting these needs is a comprehensive one. It deserves the closest attention of Congress. Would it not be advisable, however, to attach the administrative machinery for credit extension outlined in the bill to a division to be created in the Farm Loan Board, with separate colonization credit funds, and to leave the regulation and licensing of the private colonization companies to a separate body as outlined below?

    Senator Thomas J. Walsh of Montana introduced in the Senate, August 20, 1917, a bill (S. 2812) which was passed by both Houses and reported from conference for passage in February, 1919. The bill provides for the sale or lease of coal, oil, and other mineral lands on the public domain. The leasing clause of the bill is weakened by the provision, "unless previously entered under Section 2 of this act." The public coal lands would be "entered," sold into private ownership, which means the loss of public control over these lands and the methods of their exploitation.

    However, the bill if passed would be a step forward in the sense that it would increase opportunities for investment of capital and employment of labor, which would result in the increase of the coal output so much needed.

    The only step so far undertaken by Congress in the direction of land colonization is the appropriation of $200,000 for an investigation by the Reclamation Service, Department of the Interior, of lands outside of the existing reclamation projects. The measures needed are waiting for action.

    In regard to the available land for acquisition, reclamation, and colonization, several projects are proposed by the above-quoted bills and by various Federal departments. The principal projects are as follows:

    1. Agricultural:

    a. Logged-off lands in the North Middle Western
    and Northwestern states.

    b. Irrigation of desert lands in the Southwestern
    states.

    c. Drainage of swamp lands in the Southern states.

    1. Forestry projects; permanent colonies for logging,

    milling, and reforestation of logged-off lands in the
    Northwestern states.

    1. Colonization projects for an intensive cultivation of

    lands around smaller growing towns.

    1. Colonization projects in Alaska for developing various

    extractive industries.

    Action of some sort is eminently desirable in this country, especially in view of the fact that other countries have already taken steps to these ends.

    PROVISION IN OTHER COUNTRIES

    The settlement of soldiers on land has been a problem much considered in all of the warring nations. Although the plans are just only being tried out for the first time in many cases, they are suggestive of the trend that land-settlement laws are taking.

    In 1918 a law was enacted in France "providing for the acquisition of small rural properties by soldier and civilian victims of the war. It provides in part for 'individual mortgage loans to facilitate acquisition, parceling out, transformation, and reconstitution of small rural properties of which the value does not exceed 10,000 francs.' The loans are to be made from the agricultural lending societies at a rate of 1 per cent, with a term of twenty-five years. Advances for improvements are provided for and a special commission is appointed to administer the law."[14]

    In the United Kingdom, as well as in the majority of its dominions and states, acts providing for land settlement for ex-soldiers have been passed or formulated. Large sums of money have already been appropriated for the purchase, improvement, and development of land. In some cases the crown lands are to be used and in other private lands are to be bought. Table III indicates some of the general provisions of the legislation.

    Over $133,000,000 has been appropriated and in two Australian states alone 2,060,000 acres have been set aside. The size of the individual holdings varies from 10 to 160 acres.

    In some cases the land is given outright, in others the settler must help bear the cost of surveys and improvement. The third plan is that of a lease, usually with an option to buy, varying in different states.

    Whatever the terms of settlement are, in most cases the ex-soldier can meet his obligations because of the easy terms by which he can borrow money from the government. Although the maximum amount is limited, the rate of interest is low in most cases and the term of years, with one exception, twenty years or more. Although some farming experience is required, in almost every law, there is provision for a demonstration farm. Here the prospective farmers can learn scientific farming, usually getting paid for their work in the interval.

    TABLE III

    SOLDIER SETTLEMENT PLANS FOR UNITED KINGDOM AND PROVINCES[15]

    ------------------------------------------+
    |
    |
    |
    |
    Country Act |
    ------------------------------------------+
    Dominion of Canada[16]| August 29, 1917 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Ontario | No. 150, 1916 |
    | |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    British Columbia |6 Geo. V.

    59, 1916 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    New Brunswick |6 Geo. V. 9, 1916 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Australia | 1917 Conference |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    New South Wales | No.

    21, 1916; |
    | amended, 1917 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Victoria | October 22, 1917 |
    | |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Queensland | 1917 |
    | |
    | |
    | |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    South Australia | 1916, 7, Geo. V. |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    New Zealand |6 Geo. V.

    45, 1916;|
    | amended, 1917 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Tasmania |Geo. V. 20; 1916-17|
    | |
    | |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    United Kingdom |6 and 7 Geo. V., c |
    | 38 |
    ----------------------+-------------------+
    Union of South | 1912; amended |
    Africa | 1917 |
    | |
    | |
    ------------------------------------------+

    TABLE III--Continued

    SOLDIER SETTLEMENT PLANS FOR UNITED KINGDOM AND PROVINCES[15]

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------+
    | Aid Given |
    |-------------------------------------------------+
    | | | |
    | Maximum | | Interest |
    Country | Amount | Time | Per Cent |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Dominion of Canada[16]| $2,500[A] |20 equal payments| 5 |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Ontario | $500[B] | 20 years | 6 |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    British Columbia | [C] [B] | 20 years | 5 |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    New Brunswick |$500 to $1,500[B]| 20 years | 5 |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Australia | [C] | [C] | [C] |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    New South Wales | $2,500 | Lease | 2-1/2 on |
    | | | capital |
    | | | value |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Victoria | $2,500 | 31-1/2 years | 6 |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Queensland |$2,500 buildings;| 40 years; 25 | 3-1/2 to 5; |
    | $3,500 | years; 10 | 1-1/2 on |
    | equipment |years; perpetual | capital |
    | | | value |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    South Australia | $2,400 | 21 years | 4 |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    New Zealand | [D] | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Tasmania | $2,500 | 21 years | 3-1/2 to 5 |
    | | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    United Kingdom | | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+-----------------+-------------+
    Union of South | $1,250; $25 a | 3-1/2 years to | 4-1/2 |
    Africa | month to | 7 years. | |
    | families | | |
    | | | |
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------+

    TABLE III--Continued

    SOLDIER SETTLEMENT PLANS FOR UNITED KINGDOM AND PROVINCES[15]

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------+
    | | Acres Assigned |
    | |---------------------------------+
    | | | |
    | | |Individual|
    Country | Appropriation | Total | Holdings |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Dominion of Canada[16]| $2,910,000 |Certain dominion lands| 160 |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Ontario | $5,000,000 | | 100 |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    British Columbia | $500,000 | | |
    | annually | | 160 |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    New Brunswick | | 20,000 | 10-100 |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Australia | $100,000,000 | | |
    ----------------------|---------------+----------------------+----------+
    New South Wales | | 1,500,000 | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Victoria | $11,250,000 |500,000 wheat-growing | |
    | | plus irrigated lands | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Queensland | $50,000 | 560,000 | |
    | | | |
    | | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    South Australia | $220,000 | 10,000 | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    New Zealand | $3,000,000 | 270,000 | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Tasmania | $750,000 | | 100 |
    | | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    United Kingdom | $10,000,000 | | |
    | asked for | 60,000 | |
    ----------------------+---------------+----------------------+----------+
    Union of South | [C] |Lands purchased not to| |
    Africa | |exceed $7,500 for each| |
    | | settler who provides | |
    | | one fifth of price | |
    ------------------------------------------------------------------------+

    TABLE III--Continued

    SOLDIER SETTLEMENT PLANS FOR UNITED KINGDOM AND PROVINCES[15]

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    | | | |
    | | | |
    | | |Demonstration|
    | |Training| Farm |Capital
    Country | Tenure | Needed | Provided |Desirable
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Dominion of Canada[16]| Free grant | Yes | Yes | Yes
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------|---------
    Ontario | Patent given in | Yes | Yes | Yes
    | 5 years | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    British Columbia | Free grant | No | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    New Brunswick | Free grant | | Yes | Yes
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Australia | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    New South Wales | Perpetual lease | Yes | Yes | Yes
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Victoria | Purchase in | Yes | | Yes
    | 31-1/2 Years | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Queensland | Perpetual lease | | Yes | Yes
    | only | | |
    | | | |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    South Australia | Perpetual lease | | Yes | Yes
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    New Zealand | Lease 66 years, | | Yes | Yes
    | or freehold | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Tasmania | 99-year lease; | Yes | Yes |
    | or purchase | Yes | Yes |
    | after 10 years | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    United Kingdom | Lease | Yes | Yes |
    | | | |
    ----------------------+-----------------+--------+-------------+---------
    Union of South | Lease for 5 | | Yes |
    Africa |years and option | | |
    | of purchase, | | |
    | with 20 years | | |
    | to pay | | |
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------

    [9] Senate Bill No. 584, chap. 755.

    [10] In co-operation with the Federal government.

    [11] Compiled from manuscript given to the author by the Department of the Interior.

    [12] Federal Reclamation Laws of the United States. House Committee on Irrigation of Arid Lands, 66th Congress, 2d Session, Washington, D. C., 1920; chap. v, pp. 13-50.

    [13] Reports of the Department of the Interior for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1919. Washington, Government Printing Office, 1920; vol. 1, p. 96.

    [14] Work and Homes for Our Fighting Men, U. S. Reclamation Service, 1919 (pamphlet).

    [15] Tabulated from table compiled by United States Reclamation Service, Work and Homes for Our Fighting Men, 1919, p. 20-21 (pamphlet).

    [16] From Canada comes the news that at the end of January, 1921, 20,000 soldiers have taken farms, and that 42,000 of 59,000 applicants for land grants have been declared qualified and will soon get the land. Although the men have 25 years to pay off their land debt, several hundred have already paid in full. The Canadian soldiers have received 2,000,000 acres of farming land in government soldiers grants.

    [A] Security required.

    [B] In addition to Dominion advance.

    [C] Amount not specified.

    [D] Sufficient for clearing.

    VII

    A LAND POLICY

    Most of the land-reform programs, beginning with those of the extreme conservatives, laissez-faire theorists of various schools, and ending with those of the extreme radicals, anarchists, and socialists of various leanings, are primarily concerned with the question of land ownership.

    WIDE RANGE IN PROGRAMS

    These programs might be, in the main, classified as follows:

    I. Private land ownership:

    A. Large-scale ownership, subject to no public interference.

    B. Small-scale ownership, limited and regulated by
    public authority.

    II. Public land ownership:

    A. Secured by

    1. Confiscation, by revolutionary action.
    1. Purchase, by land bond issues.
    1. Taxation, by the single tax.

    B. Forms of public ownership:

    1. Nationalization; national ownership. In the

    United States it would be Federal ownership.

    1. Provincial ownership. In the United States it would be

    state ownership, and in Switzerland canton ownership.

    1. Municipalization or communalization; land

    owned by cities and communities in the rural districts.

    1. Nobody's ownership; free to all, except that the

    public takes the ground value (irrespective of
    improvements) through the single tax, from the land users,
    which practically means a disguised form of public
    ownership, or at least a condition very near it.

    C. Methods of use:

    1. Parceling the public land into homesteads of

    one-family size, and reselling these to the
    cultivators on the basis of individual fee simple.

    1. Giving the homesteads to cultivators on the

    basis of perpetual leasehold.

    1. Public cultivation, either direct or through

    communes or co-operative associations.

    Comparing these programs one with another and with the existing conditions, one reaches the following conclusions: All the programs tend to treat the land problem merely as a question of ownership. Each favors a specific form of ownership almost as an all-inclusive remedy for defects in social relations so far as they depend upon land cultivation and land use. The argument is based upon reasoning, a mere logical calculation, and on what the authors of the program desire. The existing conditions and tendencies are much more varied and complex than they seem to appear to the land reformers.

    First, there is nothing new or untried in these programs, for almost all the advocated forms of land ownership are already existing side by side.

    It seems that no one single form is able to remedy the defects in the land situation. We have in this country national (Federal), provincial (state), and municipal or communal ownership, with small-scale private ownership predominating. We also have special land taxation, as, for instance, in certain cities that tax unimproved land higher than improved land. These existing forms of land ownership are competing with one another. The forms which allow more efficient cultivation, result in greater social stability, and are based on social justice will be the winners in the march of the economic and social progress of the country.

    The bold claim of Marxian or German Socialism that large private land ownership, erroneously identified with cultivation on a large scale, is going to prevail through absorption of small private land ownership is rapidly losing ground. The small landowners are able to enjoy, through co-operation, all the technical advantages of large-scale cultivation, retaining as well the advantages resulting from individual initiative and efficiency. There is a marked movement t

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    A Stake in the Land
    Author
    Peter A. Speek
    Release date
    November 23, 2009 [eBook #30529]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Tom Roch, Larry B. Harrison and the Online
    Most recently updated
    January 5, 2021
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by Tom Roch, Larry B. Harrison and the Online
    Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This
    file was produced from images produced by Core Historical
    Literature in Agriculture (CHLA), Cornell University)
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    A STAKE IN THE LAND
    
    
    
    
    [Illustration]
    
    [Illustration: LONG, HARD MONTHS OF WORK SEPARATE THE ROUGH SHANTY FROM
    WHITE CLAPBOARDS AND AN AUTOMOBILE]
    
    
    
    
      AMERICANIZATION STUDIES
      ALLEN T. BURNS, DIRECTOR
    
      A STAKE
      IN THE LAND
    
      BY
      PETER A. SPEEK
    
      IN CHARGE, SLAVIC SECTION
      LIBRARY OF CONGRESS
    
      HARPER & BROTHERS PUBLISHERS
      NEW YORK AND LONDON
      1921
    
    
    
    
      A STAKE IN THE LAND
    
      Copyright, 1921, by Harper & Brothers
      Printed in the United States of America
    
    
    
    
    PUBLISHER'S NOTE
    
    
    The material in this volume was gathered by the Division of
    Rural Developments of Studies in Methods of Americanization.
    
    Americanization in this study has been considered as the union of native
    and foreign born in all the most fundamental relationships and
    activities of our national life. For Americanization is the uniting of
    new with native-born Americans in fuller common understanding and
    appreciation to secure by means of self-government the highest welfare
    of all. Such Americanization should perpetuate no unchangeable
    political, domestic, and economic regime delivered once for all to the
    fathers, but a growing and broadening national life, inclusive of the
    best wherever found. With all our rich heritages, Americanism will
    develop best through a mutual giving and taking of contributions from
    both newer and older Americans in the interest of the commonweal. This
    study has followed such an understanding of Americanization.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of A Stake in the Land
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: A Stake in the Land
    
    Author: Peter A. Speek
    
    
            
    Release date: November 23, 2009 [eBook #30529]
                    Most recently updated: January 5, 2021
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/30529
    
    Credits: Produced by Tom Roch, Larry B. Harrison and the Online
            Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This
            file was produced from images produced by Core Historical
            Literature in Agriculture (CHLA), Cornell University)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #30529. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 30529
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.