Needlework As Art
by Viscountess Marianne Margaret Compton Cust Alford · English · Gutenberg #30472 · 880,738 chars · public domain (US)
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Needlework As Art
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: Needlework As Art
Author: Viscountess Marianne Margaret Compton Cust Alford
Release date: November 14, 2009 [eBook #30472]
Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/30472
Credits: Produced by Julia Miller, jenniemuse, Sam W. and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This
file was produced from images generously made available
by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)
*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK NEEDLEWORK AS ART ***
Transcriber's Note
A carat (^) is used to indicate superscripted characters.
The original text contained an errata list. The corrections have been
made to this text, and the list moved to the end of the book for
reference purposes only.
Other notes may be found at the end of the book.
NEEDLEWORK AS ART
BY
LADY M. ALFORD
[Illustration]
London:
SAMPSON LOW, MARSTON, SEARLE, AND RIVINGTON,
CROWN BUILDINGS, 188, FLEET STREET.
1886.
[_All rights reserved._]
LONDON:
PRINTED BY GILBERT AND RIVINGTON, LIMITED,
ST. JOHN'S SQUARE.
[Illustration: TELEMACHUS PENELOPE]
DEDICATED BY PERMISSION
TO
THE QUEEN.
TO
THE QUEEN.
_Your Majesty's most gracious acceptance of the Dedication of my book
on "Needlework as Art" casts a light upon the subject that shows its
worthiness, and my inability to do it justice. Still, I hope I may
fill a gap in the artistic literature of our day, and I venture to lay
my work at your Majesty's feet with loyal devotion._
MARIAN M. ALFORD.
PREFACE.
In the Preface to the "Handbook of Art Needlework," which I edited for
the Royal School at South Kensington in 1880, I undertook to write a
second part, to be devoted to design, colour, and the common-sense
modes of treating decorative art, as applied especially to embroidered
hangings, furniture, dress, and the smaller objects of luxury.
Circumstances have, since then, obliged me to reconsider this
intention; and I have found it more practicable to cast the
information which I have collected from Eastern and Western sources
into the form of a separate work, which in no way supersedes or
interferes with the technical instruction supposed to be conveyed in a
handbook. I have found so much amusement in learning for myself the
history of the art of embroidery, and in tracing the beginnings and
the interchanges of national schools, that I cannot but hope that I
may excite a similar interest in some of my readers, and so induce
those who are capable, to help and lift it to a higher place than it
has been allowed in these latter days to occupy. If I have given too
important a position to the art of needlework, I would observe that
while I have been writing, decorative embroidery has come to the
front, and is at this moment one of the hobbies of the day; and I
would point out that it contains in itself all the necessary elements
of art; it may exercise the imagination and the fancy; it needs
education in form, colour, and composition, as well as the craft of a
practised hand, to express its language and perfect its beauty.
I confess that when I undertook this task, I did not anticipate the
time I have had to spend in collecting and epitomizing the many
notices to be found in German, French, and English authors, on what
has been considered among us, at least in this century, as merely a
secondary art, and therefore, as such, of little importance. Cursory
notices of needlework are scattered through almost every book on art;
and under the head of textiles it is usual to find embroidery
acknowledged as being worthy of notice, though not to be named in
company with sculpture, architecture, or painting, however beautifully
or thoughtfully its works may be carried out. I have tried to show
that it deserves higher estimation.
My first intention was simply to consider STYLE, good or bad, as it
influences our embroidery of to-day, and to find some rules by which
to guide that of the future in its next phase. But when we search into
the fluctuations of style, and their causes, we find they have an
historical succession, and that we must begin at the beginning and
trace them through the life of mankind.
This led me to attempt a sketch of consecutive styles, their overlap
and variations.
I then found that DESIGN, PATTERNS, STITCHES, MATERIALS, each require
a separate study.
COLOUR, as applied to dyes, claims to be regarded as differing from
pigments on the painter's palette.
HANGINGS, DRESS, and ECCLESIASTICAL EMBROIDERIES each require
different rules, and the study of the best examples of past centuries.
Finally, it seems natural to dwell on our own proficiency in
decorative work. ENGLISH EMBROIDERY has always excelled; and, as we
have again returned to this occupation, it is worth while to recollect
what we have done of old.
In writing chapters on these subjects, I have found it most convenient
to separate the historical and æsthetic questions from the technical
rules, and the instruction which naturally belongs to a handbook, of
which the purpose should be to teach the easiest and most orthodox
manner of executing the simplest, and elaborating the finest works.
Such questions ought not to be overlaid with archæological inquiries,
or with the information which only profits the designer; though of
course it is best that the knowledge of design should be part of the
education of the craft.
Perhaps I may be found to have written a book too shallow for the
learned, too deep for the frivolous, too technical for the general
public, and too diffuse for the specialist of the craft.[1]
I must deprecate these criticisms by saying that I have written it for
the benefit of those who know nothing of the art, and are too much
engaged to seek information here and there; who yet, being women, have
to select and to execute ornamental needlework; or, being artists, are
vexed at the incongruities and want of intention in the decorations in
daily domestic use; I have also sought to help the designer, that he
or she may know something of the history of patterns and stitches.
If my readers should be aware of repetitions, they must forgive them;
remembering that the same idea has to be looked at sometimes from a
different point of view, according to the use to which it is to be
fitted. The same material may be employed for wall-hangings and dress,
and then the principles which have been formulated have to be varied.
I do not shrink from repetitions if they make my meaning clear,
remembering the Duke of Wellington's direction to his private
secretary, "Never mind repetitions; and _dot_ your i's."
Portions of these chapters have been already published in No. 49 of
the _Nineteenth Century_,[2] in 1881; and more was delivered in three
unpublished lectures the same year.
I have acknowledged and noted on each page my authorities for the
facts I have quoted. The illustrations that are not original, have
been copied from other works by permission of authors and publishers.
To all of these I wish to express my obligations and thanks,
especially to Mr. Villiers Stuart, Dr. Anderson, Sir G. Birdwood, and
Sir H. Layard, for their courtesy in allowing me the use of their
plates. To my old and valued friend, Mr. Newton, I wish to express my
gratitude for his unstinted gifts of time and trouble, bestowed in
criticizing and correcting my book, encouraging me to give it to the
public, and making it more worthy of publication.
I have largely quoted Charles Blanc ("Ornament in Dress," English
translation), Von Bock ("Liturgische Gewänder"), Dr. Rock ("The Church
of our Fathers" and "Introduction to Textiles"), Semper ("Der Stil"),
Yates ("Textrinum Antiquorum"), and Yule ("Marco Polo"), besides many
others. But these authorities often differ, and, after weighing their
arguments, I have ventured to select for my use the facts and
theories which accord with my own views. Facts are often so
interdependent and closely linked, that it requires great care to
distinguish where they have been shaped or coloured (however
unintentionally) to fit each other or the writer's preconceived ideas.
Certain it is that facts are but useless heaps till the thread of a
theory is found on which to hang them. This process, like that of
stringing pearls, has to be often repeated, till each occupies its
right place. Only those who have adopted and cherished a theory can
appreciate the pain of cutting the thread, to displace what appeared
to be a pearl, but which, from its false position as to date or place,
or its doubtful origin, has proved only an empty manufactured glass
bead of error.
This has happened to me more than once; and since I read my lectures I
have had to change my opinions in several instances. If, therefore,
any of my readers should observe such changes, I hope they will give
me credit for trying to convey _now_ what appears to me on each
subject a correct impression.
FOOTNOTES:
[1] Besides the art, I have sought to give something of
the archæology of needlework. Now the qualifications for
being a teacher on such subjects are rarely to be met
with, all combined. Mr. Newton, in his "Essays on Art
and Archæology," p. 37, says that "the archæologist
should combine with the æsthetic culture of the artist,
and the trained judgment of the historian and the
philologist, that critical acumen, required for
classification and interpretation; nor should that
habitual suspicion which must ever attend the scrutiny
and precede the warranty of evidence, give too sceptical
a bias to his mind." Such authorities have been
interrogated on each part of my subject.
[2] Quoted by permission of the Editor.
CONTENTS.
PAGE
INTRODUCTION. 1
CHAPTER I.--STYLE.
Definition of style--Development of style--Primitive--
Archaic--Egyptian--Babylonian--Phœnician influences
on early Greek style--Decoration of hangings of the
Tabernacle in the wilderness--Aryan ideas--The Code of
Manu--Indian art--Celtic style--Greek art in dress and
embroideries--Homer's descriptions of embroideries--Pallas
Athene--Shield of Achilles--Roman art--Byzantine art--Art
of Central Asia--Its arrival in Europe--Art of China,
Japan, and Java--Christian art--Scandinavian art--The Dark
Ages--Sicilian textile art--Renaissance--Arabesque--
Grotesque--Spanish Plâteresque--Style of Queen Anne and the
Chippendales--Louis XV. style--Classical revival--Young
England's style--Nineteenth century style 14
CHAPTER II.--DESIGN.
Artist and artisan--Prehistoric design--Naturalistic
design--Egyptian immutability--Slow evolution of
design--Greek perfection--Necessity of following rules--M.
Blanc's laws of ornamentation--Laws of composition--
Repetition--Alternation--Symmetry--Progression--Confusion--
Designs for hangings and dress materials--Floral design--Design
for carpets--The conventional--First principles 54
CHAPTER III.--PATTERNS.
Ancestry of patterns--Classification--Their historical
value--Primitive patterns--The wave--Tartan--Prehistoric
African patterns--The naturalistic--Flowers--Shells--Indian
forms of naturalistic patterns--Egyptian--The lotus--
Sunflower--Celtic Zoomorphic patterns--The human figure on
Greek textiles--Animal forms in Oriental patterns--Symbolical
and conventional patterns--The wave patterns--The palm leaf--
The cone--Gothic--Arab--Moresque--The Sacred Hom--Egg and
tongue--The cross--Swastika--Fylfote--Gammadion--The
crenelated pattern--The Ninevite daisy--Emblematic
patterns--Bestiaria--Volucraria--Lapidaria--Byzantine
patterns--Gothic--Renaissance--The cloud pattern--The
fundata--Italian--French patterns--Radiated patterns--The
shell--Patterns by repetition--Balcony pattern--Chinese
wicker-work--Survival of a pattern--Opus
Alexandrinum--Quilting patterns 82
CHAPTER IV.--MATERIALS.
Raw materials--Revelations of the microscope--Hemp--Jute--
Honduras grass--Spartum--Pinna silk--Hair--Leather--
Feathers--Asbestos--Coral--Pearls--Beads--Wool--Classical
notices of wool--Careful improvement of wool by the
ancients--Tanaquil--Homeric woollen carpets--Crimson
textile fragments--Scandinavian woollen garments--Qualities
of wool--English wool--Goats' hair--Flax--Lake cities--
Byssus--Fine linen of Egypt--The Atrebates--Embroidery on
linen--Cotton--Indian origin--Carbasa--Buckram--Cotton
fabrics--Gold--Silver--Gold brocades--Jewish--Indian--
Chinese--Dress of Darius--Attalus--Attalic textiles--
Agrippina's golden garments--St. Cecilia's mantle--Roman
tombs--Gold wire--Anglo-Saxon tomb--Childeric's tomb--Proba's
gold thread--Golden wrappings from tombs of Henry I. and Henry
III.--Gold embroideries and jewellers' work of Middle
Ages--Spangles--Enamels--Purl--Modern schools of gold
embroidery--Silk--Pamphile of Cos--Early specimens of silk
stuffs--Chinese silks--The Seres--Mela--Seneca--M. Terrien
de la Couperie--Empress Si-ling-chi--Princess of
Khotan--Euripides--Lucan--Pliny--Silk in Rome--Ælius
Lampridius--Flavius Vopiscus--Tailor's bill--Justinian's
codex--Imperial monopoly--Paul the Silentiary--Bede--King
John's apparition--Greek and Sicilian manufactories of
silk--Distinctive marks of different periods--Lyons--Spain--
Italy--Flemish towns--Marco Polo--Satin--Welsh poem, "Lady of
the Fountain"--Chaucer--Velvet--Transference of work to new
materials 118
CHAPTER V.--COLOUR.
Harmony and dissonance--Names of tints--Authorities for
theories--Art of colouring--Expression of colouring--
Purple--Red--Crimson--Blue--Yellow--Pliny--Renouf--Chinese
colours--Indian dyes--Persian colours--Dyes of the
Gauls--Romans--Scotch--Scales of colour--MM. Charton and
Chevreul on tones of colour--Gas colours 175
CHAPTER VI.--STITCHES.
Stitches--Part I.: The needle--Gammer Gurton's needle--Art
of needlework--Lists of stitches--Part II.: Plain work--
The seam--Mrs. Floyer--White embroidery--Nuns' work--
Greek--German--Spanish--Italian white work--Semper's
rules for white work--Part III.: Opus Phrygium--Gold
embroideries--Part IV.: Opus pulvinarium--Cushion stitches--
Mosaic stitches--Traditional decorations from Chaldea and
Assyria--German and Italian pattern-books--Part V.: Opus
plumarium--The Plumarii--Feather-work of India--Islands of
the Pacific--African work--Mexican and Peruvian--Cluny
triptych--Mitre of St. Charles Borromeo--Essay by
Denis--Chinese and Japanese feather-stitches--Part VI.:
Opus consutum or cut work--Patchwork--Egyptian and Greek
examples--Irish cut work--Chaucer--Francis I.'s hangings
at Cluny--Lord Beauchamp's curtains--Spanish examples--
Remarks--Art of application--Part VII.: Lace--Opus
filatorium--Mrs. Palliser--M. Blanc--Guipure--Sir Gardiner
Wilkinson--Netted lace--Homer--Solomon's Temple--Bobbin
laces--Yak--Coloured laces--Venetian sumptuary laws--Golden
laces--Point d'Alençon--Mr. A. Cole's lectures--M. Urbani
de Gheltof on Venice laces--Lace stitches--Revival of lace
school at Burano--English laces--Part VIII.: Tapestry--Opus
pectineum--Modes of weaving tapestry--Its great antiquity--
Egyptian looms--Albert Castel on tapestries--Homeric
picture-weaving--Arachne--A paraphrase by Lord Houghton--
Nomenticum--Sidonius Apollinaris--Saracenic weaving--Arras--
Brussels--Italian tapestries from Florence, Milan, and
Mantua--French tapestries--Cluny Museum collection--Gobelins--
Beauvais--English tapestry--Comnenus--Matthew Paris--Early
trade with Arras--Coventry tapestries--Chaucer--Tapestry
"of verd"--Hatfield tapestries--Armada tapestries--Sir F.
Crane--Mortlake manufactory--Francis Cleyne--Raphael
cartoons--Percy tapestry from Lambeth 194
CHAPTER VII.--HANGINGS.
Classical hangings--Babylonian and Persian--Semper's
theory--Sanctuary in the wilderness--St. Peter's at
Rome--Abulfeda--Akbar's tent--Nadir Shah's tent--Tent
of Khan of Persia--Tents of Alexander the Great at
Alexandria--Roman hangings--Funeral pyres--Kosroes'
tent--Semper's rules for hanging decorations--Ancient
carpets--English and French hangings--Rules for designs
of hangings 260
CHAPTER VIII.--FURNITURE.
Penelope's couch--Chaldean furnished house--The bed--Earl
of Leicester's inventories--State apartment of Alessandri
Palace--Indian embroideries for furniture--The sofa and
chair--The footstool--Furniture stitches--The table
cover--The screen--Book covers--Morris on furniture 280
CHAPTER IX.--DRESS.
Art of dress--Ancient splendour--Persian, Greek, and
Roman--Indian--Homeric--Early Christian--Charlemagne's
mantle and robe--Objects of dress--Embroidered garments 294
CHAPTER X.--ECCLESIASTICAL EMBROIDERY.
Christian art--Dark ages--Greek and Roman ecclesiastical
dress--Northern influence--Continuity of ecclesiastical
art--Authorities--Anglo-Saxon orthodox colours--Veils of
the Temple--Hangings in Pagan temples and Christian
churches--Russian use of veils--Art in the early Church--
Rare examples--Destruction by the iconoclasts--Early
embroiderers--Empress Helena--Bertha, mother of
Charlemagne--His dalmatic--Pluvial of St. Silvester--Pluvial
of museum at Bologna--Daroca cope--Cope of Boniface VIII.--
Style of the twelfth century--Mantle of St. Stephen of
Hungary--Kunigunda's work for Henry II.--The Romanesque--
Movement perfecting Gothic art, thirteenth century--Opus
Anglicanum--Syon cope--Embroidery on the stamp--Pictures in
flat stitches--Flemish work--Renaissance--Work of some royal
ladies--French--Spanish--Sicilian and Neapolitan--German
work--Sacred symbolism--Melito's "The Key"--Mystical
colours--Prehistoric cross--Many forms of the cross--The
roës--The chrysoclavus--Modern decoration--Principles and
motives for church embroideries--The altar-cloth--The
reredos--The pulpit and reading-desk--The ancient
Paschal--The banner of St. Cuthbert--The fringe--Lay
heraldry of the Church--South Kensington Museum 303
CHAPTER XI.--ENGLISH EMBROIDERY.
First glimpse of art in England--Dyeing and weaving in
Britain in early times--Cæsar's invasion--Roman
civilization--Anglo-Saxon times and art--Adhelme's
poem--Icelandic Sagas--Saga or story of Thorgunna--English
work in the eighth century--The Benedictines--Durham
embroideries--Aelfled--St. Dunstan--Queen Emma's
work--William of Poitou--The Bayeux tapestry--Abbess of
Markgate--Gifts to Pope Adrian IV.--Robes of Thomas à
Becket at Sens--Innocent III.--English pre-eminence in
needlework from the Conquest to the Reformation--John
Garland on hand-looms--Blode-bendes and lacs d'amour--Opus
Anglicanum--English peculiarities in ecclesiastical
design--Penalties against luxury in dress--Protection the
bane of art--Dunstable pall--Stoneyhurst cope--Destruction
of fine works at the Reformation--Much on the Continent,
much collected in our old Catholic houses--Field of the
Cloth of Gold--Mary Tudor's Spanish stitches--Queen
Elizabeth's embroideries--Institution of Embroiderers'
Company--East India Company--Oriental taste discouraged on
Protectionist grounds--Decay of the art in England--Style
of James I.--Dutch style--Cushion stitches--Miss Linwood--
Miss Moritt--Mrs. Delany--Mrs. Pawsey--Postscript--Revival
of the art of needlework--"Royal School of Art Needlework" 356
APPENDIX
I. Charles T. Newton on Votive Dresses 400
II. The Moritzburg Feather Hangings 401
III. The Story of Arachne, translated by Earl Cowper 402
IV. Charlemagne's Dalmatic, by Lord Lindsay 405
V. Notices of various Mediæval Embroideries by the Hon.
and Rev. W. Ignatius Clifford 407
VI. Syon Cope, Rock's Introduction, "Textile Fabrics" 408
VII. Assyrian Fringes 412
VIII. Hrothgar's House Furniture: Poem of Beowulf 412
IX. Thorgunna, by Sir G. Dasent 413
X. Pedigree of Aelswith 414
XI. Statutes at Large 414
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.
CUTS.
Fig.|Page.|
----+-----+
1 | 20 | Egyptian corselet. Wilkinson's "Ancient Egyptians," p.
| | 332.
2 | 25 | Tabernacle of Balawat. Temp. Shalmaneser. British
| | Museum.
3 | 30 | Zoomorphic Celtic pattern.
4 | 32 | Pallas Athene attired in the sacred peplos. Panathenaic
| | vase, British Museum.
5 | 62 | Wave pattern.
6 | 63 | Key pattern.
7 | 63 | Metopes and triglyphs.
8 | 73 | Persian carpet. Egyptian symbolic patterns.
9 | 91 | Gothic sunflower. R. S. A. N.
10 | 98 | Wave.
11 | 104 | Egyptian ally and enemy. Temp. Rameses II. Wilkinson's
| | "Ancient Egyptians," iii. p. 364.
12 | 105 | Assyrian crenelated pattern.
13 | 107 | Gothic type of trees, Bayeux tapestry.
14 | 111 | Radiated pattern.
15 | 111 | Radiated sunflower.
16 | 112 | Shell pattern.
17 | 112 | Balcony pattern.
18 | 115 | Varied adjustments of square and circle.
19 | 146 | Spangles.
20 | 195 | Needles.
21 | 208 | Feather patterns. Egyptian.
22 | 216 | Application. Egyptian. Auberville's "Tissus."
23 | 217 | Embroidered border on mantle. Crimea. "Compte Rendu."
24 | 281 | Babylonian or Chaldean house and furniture.
25 | 311 | Italian fifteenth-century pattern. Celtic type.
26 | 377 | Barbed quatrefoil.
27 | 380 | Holbein pattern. Sampler.
28 | 388 | Arms of Embroiderers' Guild; given by Queen Elizabeth.
29 | 393 | Portion of James II.'s coronation dress; from an old
| | print.
PLATES.
Plate|Page.| Ref.|
-----+-----+-----|
| | | TITLE-PAGE. Penelope at her loom, reproached by her
| | | son Telemachus. From vase found at Chiusi, in
| | | Etruria. "Monum. d. Inst. Arch. Rom." ix. Pl. 42.
1 | 22 | 93 | ASSURBANIPAL (Sardanapalus). Sculptures from Nineveh.
| | | British Museum.
2 | 22 | 93 | Portion of royal Babylonian mantle. From Layard's
| | | "Monuments," Series i. pl. 9.
3 | 29 | | ST. JOHN. From King Alfred's Celtic Book of the
| | | Gospels. Lambeth Palace Library.
4 | 30 | | A PAGE of the Book of St. Cuthbert, or Book of
| | | Lindisfarne.
5 | 33 | | SILVER BOWL from Palestrina. From Clermont Ganneau's
| | | "Journal Asiatique, Syro-Egyptien-Phœnicien."
6 | 40 | 93 | EMPRESS THEODORA. Ravenna Mosaic.
7 | 42 | | ITALIAN EMBROIDERY, fifteenth century. South
| | | Kensington Museum.
8 | 43 | | ITALIAN and SPANISH orphrey, sixteenth century.
9 | 45 | | PLÂTERESQUE DESIGN. Spanish coverlet, green velvet
| | | and gold, sixteenth century. Goa work.
10 | 87 | | WAVE PATTERN. 1, 4, 9, 12, 13. Greek wave pattern.
| | | 2. Key or Mæander Greek wave. 3. Greek broken wave.
| | | 5, 6, 7. Egyptian smooth and rippling wave pattern.
| | | 8. Mediæval wave. 10, 11, 14. Babylonian and
| | | Chaldean. 15. Persian or Greek, from glass bowl,
| | | British Museum. 16. English wave (or cloud). Durham
| | | embroideries, tenth century.
11 | 88 | | SIMPLE PATTERNS. 1. Persian. 2. Lotus border,
| | | Egyptian.
12 | 90 | | LOTUS BORDERS. 1. Indian. 2, 3. Egyptian. 4, 5, Greek.
| | | 6. Indian.
13 | 95 | 102 | INDIAN LOTUS. 1. With Assyrian daisy. 2. Lotus. 3. The
| | | egg and tongue, or Vitruvian scroll from Vignola.
| | | "Regole di Ordine di Architettura."
14 | 91 | | SUNFLOWER PATTERN. R. S. A. N. Nineteenth century.
15 | 92 | | PORTION OF A PAGE of the Book of Kells. Dublin
| | | University Library.
16 | 93 | 114 | DEMETER. Greek fictile vase. British Museum.
17 | 93 | 217 | 1. GREEK EMBROIDERY, 300 B.C. From tomb of the Seven
| | | Brothers, Crimea.
| | | 2. EGYPTIAN painted or embroidered linen. The cone,
| | | bead, daisy, wave. Lotus-under-water patterns are
| | | represented on this fragment.
18 | 93 | | EGYPTIAN Tapestry weaving finished with the needle.
| | | British Museum.
19 | 97 | 114 | EGYPTIAN key patterns. Wilkinson's "Ancient
| | | Egyptians," p. 125.
20 | 99 | 101 | TREES OF LIFE. 1, 2, 3. Assyrian. 4. Sicilian silk.
| | | 5. Mediæval. Birdwood's "Indian Arts."
21 | 101 | | TREES OF LIFE. 1. Sculpture over gate of Mycenæ.
| | | 2. Sicilian silks; Persian type.
22 | 101 | | LOTUS MERGED INTO TREE OF LIFE. 1. Split Chinese
| | | Lotus. 2. Split Persian Lotus, from a frieze by
| | | Benozzo Gozzoli. Ricardi Palace, Florence. 3. Petal
| | | of flower. Greek glass bowl from tomb in Southern
| | | Italy.
23 | 101 | | TREES OF LIFE. Sicilian silks. Auberville. 1, 2, 3,
| | | 4, 5, 10. Persian type. 6, 7, 8, 9, 11. Indian type.
24 | 101 | | TREE OF LIFE transformed into vine. Modern pattern of
| | | work from the Principalities.
25 | 103 | | TYPICAL CROSSES. 1. Swastika fire-stick cross. 2.
| | | From Greek vase, British Museum, 765 B.C. 3.
| | | Sectarial mark of Sakti race. India. 4. Sectarial
| | | mark of Buddhists and Jainis. 5. On early Rhodian
| | | pottery. 6. Egyptian prehistoric cross. 7. Tau
| | | cross. 8. Mark of land, Egyptian and Ninevite.
| | | 9. Mark of land, Egyptian and Ninevite. 10. Clavus,
| | | "nail" or "button," or sun-cross. 11, 12, 13.
| | | Scandinavian sun and moon crosses. 14, 15, 16.
| | | Celtic. 17. Chrysoclavus. 18, 19. Stauracin
| | | patterns. 20. Norwegian. 21. Runic. 22. Cross in
| | | Temple of the Sun, Palenque. 23. Scotch Celtic
| | | cross. 24. Cross at Iona. 25, 26. Runic and
| | | Scandinavian crosses. 27. Cross diapered on
| | | Charlemagne's dalmatic. 28. From mantle of Henry
| | | II., Emperor of Germany.
26 | 103 | | PREHISTORIC CROSSES. 1. Greek. Pallas, with plaited
| | | tunic worked with Swastika. 2. Greek. Ajax playing
| | | at dice with Achilles. Cloak embroidered with
| | | Swastika and other prehistoric patterns. Fictile
| | | vase, Vatican Museum.
27 | 105 | | ASSYRIAN CARPET carved in stone, British Museum.
28 | 107 | | GOTHIC. 1. Dress patterns from old MS. 2, 3. Old
| | | English tiles.
29 | 109 | | CLOUD PATTERNS. 1, 2, 3, 7. Japanese. 5, 8, 9.
| | | Mediæval. 4. Chinese. 6. Badge of Richard II.
30 | 109 | | INDO-CHINESE COVERLET. Hatfield. Supposed to have
| | | belonged to Oliver Cromwell.
31 | 109 | | FUNDATA PATTERNS. 1. On Phœnician silver bowl.
| | | ("L'Imagerie Phénicienne.") 2, 3. From tomb at
| | | Essiout, Egypt. Wilkinson's "Ancient Egyptians,"
| | | ii. p. 125. 1600 B.C.
32 | 124 | | PART OF BORDER of silk, gold, and pearls. Worked by
| | | Blanche, wife of Charles IV. of Bohemia. Bock's
| | | "Lit. Gew." ii. p. 246.
33 | 147 | | EMBROIDERED WINDOW HANGING from portrait of Mahomet
| | | II., by Gentil Bellini; belonging to Sir Henry
| | | Layard.
34 | 153 | 110 | CLASSICAL SILKS. 1. Greek. 2. Roman.
35 | 163 | | DURHAM RELICS. Persian type of silk weaving.
36 | 164 | | DURHAM RELICS. Norman and Persian types mixed.
37 | 164 | | DURHAM RELICS. Græco-Egyptian type.
38 | 164 | | EGYPTIAN BOAT with embroidered and fringed sails,
| | | and floating scarves. Wilkinson's "Ancient
| | | Egyptians," iii. p. 211.
39 | 200 | | WHITE EMBROIDERY from sculptured tomb of a knight,
| | | fifteenth century. Ara Cœli, Rome.
40 | 201 | | PROCESSIONAL CLOAK, Spanish work, temp. Henry VIII.,
| | | belonging to Lord Arundel of Wardour.
41 | 204 | | OPUS PULVINARIUM. Counted stitches. 1. Italian. 2.
| | | Scandinavian. 3. Ancient Egyptian. Turin Museum.
42 | 206 | | ITALIAN MOSAIC STITCH work, sixteenth century.
| | | Alford House.
43 | 214 | | JAPANESE OPUS PLUMARIUM. White silk.
44 | 216 | 25 | OPUS CONSUTUM. Funeral tent of an Egyptian queen.
45 | 219 | 123 | OPUS CONSUTUM. "Inlaid" and "onlaid." Italian,
| | | seventeenth century.
46 | 235 | | EGYPTIAN GOBELINS finished with the needle.
47 | 236 | | RHEIMS CATHEDRAL TAPESTRY. The Virgin weaving and
| | | embroidering on frame a "basse-lisse."
48 | 243 | | TENT OF CHARLES THE BOLD, taken at Grandson, now in
| | | museum at Berne. The badge is that of the Golden
| | | Fleece.
49 | 252 | | ENGLISH TAPESTRY belonging to Lord Salisbury, at
| | | Hatfield House, temp. Henry VIII.
50 | 294 | | ITALIAN KNIGHT of fifteenth century armed for
| | | conquest. Gentile da Fabriano. Academia, Florence.
51 | 309 | | ST. MARK. Anglo-Saxon Book of the Gospels. York
| | | Minster Library.
52 | 312 | | CLASSICAL PATTERN adapted into Christian art.
53 | 318 | | CHARLEMAGNE'S DALMATIC. Vatican Treasury.
54 | 318 | | CHARLEMAGNE'S DALMATIC. Vatican Treasury.
55 | 318 | | PORTION OF CHARLEMAGNE'S DALMATIC. Half-size.
56 | 319 | | ST. SILVESTER'S PLUVIAL. Treasury of St. John
| | | Lateran, Rome. Opus Anglicanum, thirteenth
| | | century.
57 | 319 | | PORTION OF ST. SILVESTER'S PLUVIAL, showing its
| | | condition.
58 | 319 | | BOLOGNA COPE. Museo del Municipio. Opus Anglicanum.
59 | 319 | | DAROCA COPE. Archæological Museum at Madrid. Opus
| | | Anglicanum.
60 | 319 | | BONIFACE VIII.'S COPE from Anagni, his native place;
| | | now in Vatican Treasury; twelfth century.
61 | 319 | | ALTAR FRONTAL at Anagni, Italy. Italian work,
| | | fourteenth century.
62 | 320 | | WORCESTER RELICS of the tenth century. 1. From tomb
| | | of Walter de Cantilupe. 2. From Aix, in Switzerland.
| | | Same type.
63 | 320 | | 1. MITRE OF THOMAS À BECKET. 2. The cross with twelve
| | | leaves, "for the healing of the nations." Coronation
| | | vestments at Rheims.
64 | 321 | | ANGLO-SAXON WORK, purple and gold, from tomb of
| | | William de Blois, Worcester. He died Bishop in 1236.
65 | 321 | | A PORTION OF ST. STEPHEN OF HUNGARY'S MANTLE, worked
| | | by his Queen Gisela. From Bock's "Kleinodien."
66 | 322 | | PORTION OF MANTLE OF HENRY II., worked by his Empress
| | | Kunigunda. From Bock's "Kleinodien."
67 | 325 | | THE SYON COPE. South Kensington Museum.
68 | 329 | | ITALIAN EMBROIDERIES designed by Pollaiolo; worked by
| | | Paolo da Verona. Sixteenth century.
69 | 330 | | SPANISH ALTAR FRONTAL. THE ARMS OF CASTILE embroidered
| | | in gold with pearls. Ashridge. Plâteresque style,
| | | seventeenth century.
70 | 337 | 113 | CONSULAR IVORIES. Two diptychs. 1. Zurich,
| | | Wasser-Kirche. Inscribed to Consul Areobindus,
| | | A.D. 434. 2. At Halberstadt. No date. From Bock's
| | | "Lit. Gew."
71 | 363 | | AELFLED'S ORPHREY, signed by her. Durham Cathedral
| | | Library.
72 | 363 | | ST. GREGORY AND ST. JOHN (PROPHET), from Aelfled's
| | | orphrey. Durham. English work, tenth century.
73 | 365 | | ST. DUNSTAN in adoration, drawn by himself. Bodleian
| | | Library, Oxford. Tenth century.
74 | 369 | | SMALL PARSEMÉ PATTERNS from Strutt's "Royal and
| | | Ecclesiastical Antiquities of the English from
| | | 1100 to 1530."
75 | 369 | | ENGLISH PATTERNS of embroidery. 1. Panel of a screen
| | | in Hornby Church, Yorkshire. 2. Dress on a painted
| | | window in St. Michael's Church, York. 3. Woven
| | | material of the Towneley Copes.
76 | 375 | | OPUS ANGLICANUM, twelfth century. British Museum.
77 | 376 | | TYPICAL ENGLISH ORNAMENTS for ecclesiastical
| | | embroideries, twelfth century.
78 | 377 | | DUNSTABLE PALL. Temp. Henry VII.
79 | 378 | | VINTNERS' COMPANY PALL. Henry VII.
80 | 378 | | HENRY VII.'S COPE, from Stoneyhurst; designed by
| | | Torrigiano, the sculptor of his tomb.
81 | 382 | | SPANISH WORK. Temp. Henry VIII.
82 | 383 | | ENGLISH "SPANISH WORK." Temp. Henry VIII.
83 | 389 | | CUSHION COVER, Hatfield House. Temp. Elizabeth.
84 | 390 | | ORIENTAL "TREE AND BEAST" PATTERN. Cockayne-Hatley.
| | | Temp. James I.
85 | 391 | | ENGLISH CREWEL WORK. Indian design. Temp. James I.
NEEDLEWORK AS ART.
INTRODUCTION.
The book of the Science of Art has yet to be written. Art has been
called the Flower of Life, and also the Consoler;--adorning the
existence of the strong and bright,--sheltering and comforting the sad
and solitary ones of the earth. But, rather, it resembles a
wide-spreading tree, covered with varied blossoms--bearing many
fruits.
To point out the history and the possibilities in the future of each
branch that shades, refreshes, and gives wholesome fruit to the world,
would be a task worthy of a master-hand and a pen of gold. But less
ambitious labourers in the field of investigation which is only as yet
partly cultivated, may each assist, by carefully collecting a little
heap of ascertained facts; and it is, indeed, the duty of each as he
passes to add his pebble to the slowly accumulating cairn of recorded
human knowledge.
Some one has said, "Build your house of little bricks of facts, and
you will soon find it inhabited by a body of truth; and that truth
will ally itself with other houses of facts, and in time a
well-ordered, cosmical city will arise."
My pebble is not yet polished. It is neither a diamond nor a ruby, but
I think there are a few streaks of golden light in it, which I may
venture to add to the daily accumulating treasure in the house of
human artistic knowledge.
My object in writing this volume is to fill up an empty space in the
English library of art.
The great exponents of poetic thought--verse, sculpture, painting, and
architecture--have long since been well interpreted and appreciated.
Men and women have written much and well on these large subjects, and
we may hope for more ere long. The secondary or smaller arts have been
hitherto neglected by us,--either treated merely as crafts, to which
artistic education may give help, or as the natural or inferior
outcome of the primal arts, having no claim to the possession of
special laws and history. And yet, when Moses wrote and Homer sang,
needlework was no new thing. It was already consecrated by legendary
and traditionary custom to the highest uses. The gods themselves were
honoured by its service, and it preceded written history in recording
heroic deeds and national triumphs.
It may be said that ivory carving is sculpture, and illuminated
manuscripts and coloured glass windows are painting. But for metal
work, whether in iron or gold, a place must be kept apart; and the
same privileges are due to embroidery and to metallurgy. All arts must
of necessity have their own laws and rules, which ensure their beauty
of execution and their special forms of design; these two last, from
the nature of their materials, and the modes of working them, must be
studied independently of any connection with painting, architecture,
or sculpture.
Yet, if the unity of nature is an accepted fact,[3] then the
acceptance of the unity of art must follow. Art must be considered as
the selection of natural phenomena by individual minds capable of
assimilating and reproducing them in certain forms and with certain
materials adapted to the national taste, needs, and power of
appreciation. If man cannot originate materials, he can invent
combinations;--and this is Art.
If proportion, colour, and sound alike depend on certain mathematical
measurements, and on rhythmical vibrations, there must be a real and
tangible relation between these elements, though applied to obtain
different results. In music, as in all art, harmony is, or ought to
be, a first consideration. We have seen by experiment how a note of
our scale can by touch form geometrical figures with sand on a sheet
of glass,--here form obeys the force of harmony. But what is harmony?
By analogy we may argue from the art of music. We who believe that we
have acquired the knowledge of music as a science, beyond all
preceding knowledge of the subject, have in Europe been able to enjoy
only our own musical scales; whereas throughout the East, those
accepted by the human ear are very various, and appear to depart from
what to our senses is harmony. Those Oriental musics have either been
adapted to the Oriental ear, or the ear has been adapted to appreciate
the forms and laws of harmony with which it came in contact.
The same questions occur to us while examining into the different
forms of decorative art; and we are constantly reminded that the laws
which should govern them, are perhaps, infinitely larger and wider
than we with our limited human capacities and experience, have
hitherto been able to appreciate.
"Ars longa--vita brevis" has been so often said, that from a proverb
it has become a truism; but it must continue to be the refrain of
those who write upon art. The subject is so long, and its
ramifications are so intricate, that it is difficult to include them
all under one category.
My furthest aim here is to trace back the art of needlework to its
beginning, without turning my eyes to the right or the left, though I
cannot help feeling myself drawn aside almost irresistibly by casual
glimpses of architecture, sculpture, and painting, which here and
there touch very nearly the history of needlework.
Except where they visibly influence each other, I avoid dealing with
the greater arts, leaving them to the study of the learned in each
special branch.
All art, however, throws reflected lights, and gleaning in the track
of those authors who have preceded us, we often pick up valuable hints
which we accept, and make use of them gladly.
Some writers have thought it incumbent on them to give a local
habitation and an abiding place to needlework, and they have regarded
it as a branch of painting. But I cannot endorse this classification.
According to Semper, indeed, it is the mother-art of sculpture and
painting, instead of being the offspring of either or both, as others
have maintained.[4] They have, indeed, such distinct functions that
each may justly boast its own original sources. Painting is the art of
colour; sculpture is that of form; embroidery is the art of clothing
forms. They are all so ancient, that in seeking to ascertain their
beginnings and dates. It is difficult to fix the precedence of one
over another. We may compare, distinguish, and yet again change our
opinions as fresh facts come under our observation.
The art of needlework reached its climax long ago, and is now very
old. History and faded rags are the only witnesses to its fabulous
glories, in Classical, Oriental, and early Mediæval days. It would
appear that nothing new remains to be invented. Copies of past styles,
and selections from the scraps we retain and value as models, are all
that we can boast of now.
Dr. Rock truly says that few persons of the present day have the
faintest idea of the labour, the money, the time, often bestowed of
old upon embroideries which had been designed as well as wrought by
the hands of men and women, each in their own craft the best and
ablest of their day.
Time is too short, our life too densely crowded, to allow leisure for
the extravagance of what is, after all, only a luxury of art--no
longer a civilizer, as of old, but just an efflorescence of our
culture.
Embroidery is now essentially "decoration," and nothing more. It is
intended to appeal to the sense of beauty of the eye, rather than to
the imagination. The designer for needlework should be an artist, but
he need not be a poet. You may omit this art altogether, and you need
be none the less sumptuously clothed and lodged. Yet it is worthy of
careful study as historical evidence, and that in the present and
future, as in the past, it may be an _art_, and not merely a _craft_.
For the great web of history is composed of many threads of divers
colours, and the warp and the woof are often exchanged, yet so
connected and knotted together that the continuity is never broken. On
this web, Time has drawn the picture of the past--sometimes faintly,
sometimes with indelible tints and pronounced forms. By poetry; by
architecture and its decorations; by dress, which represents and
distinguishes nationalities; by customs, such as the different forms
of burial; or even by such details as painting the eyes; also by the
tradition and outcome of the laws of the tribes that flowed
consecutively over Europe from the East; by the institutions which
remained immutably fixed on their native soil, such as those of the
Code of Manu, and those of Babylon, inscribed on bricks or clay; or by
the words, their form and lettering, in which these are handed down to
us;--out of all these the history of man is being reconstructed.
How valuable is every witness to the ancient records, which were
fading into myths in the memories of men. How joyfully is each little
fact hailed as a landmark, in the general fog of doubt!
Now embroidery may boast that it is a source of landmarks for all
time.
Without presuming to fix a date for its first beginning, that which I
wish to impress on the mind of the reader is the long continuity of
the art of needlework.
The sense of antiquity induces reverence, and I claim for the needle
an older and more illustrious age than can be accorded to the brush.
While the great pendulum of Time has swung art in sculpture, painting,
and architecture, from its cradle as in Mycenæ, to its throne in
Athens in the days of Pericles, and then back again to the basest
poverty of decaying Rome--needle work, continually refreshed from
Eastern inspiration, never has fallen so low, though it had never
aspired as high as its greater sister arts.
The stuffs and fabrics of various materials of the Egyptians, Chinese,
Assyrians, and Chaldeans are named in the earliest records of the
human race. How much these decorations depended on weaving, and how
much on embroidery with the needle, may in each case be disputed. The
products of the Babylonian looms are alluded to in the Book of Joshua.
Their beauty tempted Achan to rescue them when Jericho fell;[5] and
Ezekiel speaks of the embroideries of Canneh, Haran, and Eden, as well
as of their cloths of purple and blue, and their chests of garments of
divers colours[6].
All these fabrics are named as merchandise, and were carried to the
sea-coast, and thence over the ancient world, by the Phœnicians,
the great shipowners and dealers of the East.
Indian needlework and design is 4000 years old; and the long
perspective of Egyptian art, while leading us still further back into
unlimited periods, shows it changing so slowly, that we feel as if it
had been all but stationary from the beginning.
The Chinese claim 5000 years as the life of their history; but if, as
is now suggested, their civilization is Accadian or Proto-Babylonian,
their wonderful artistic and scientific knowledge may have been
fragments of the great dispersal, secreted and preserved behind the
wonderful wall[7] of stone, silence, and law, where it has lain
fossilized ever since. One cannot but wonder at the perfection of the
textile manufactures of the Chinese, their marvellous embroideries,
and the peculiar modes of construction and design throughout their
arts, which have shown but few moments of change in growth--scarcely a
sign of evolution. And we may fairly surmise that this Accadian
culture (if such it be) is reflected from antediluvian tradition.
The archæology of Oriental art is most interesting. We contemplate
with awe the vast splendours of the consecutive civilizations of the
East; the ancient richness and fertility of the whole of the Asiatic
continent; the genius for empire and for commerce; the creative power
which seemed to pour itself forth, unchecked by wars and conquests;
the great dynasties which rose and fell, leaving behind them gigantic
works, and the records of fabulous luxury in the empires of China,
Assyria, India, and Persia, of which the remains have been of late
years excavated, deciphered, and confronted with the historical texts
which we have inherited, and had only partly believed. And studying
these new aspects of history, we are saddened, thinking that the
sunrise comes to us from shining over desert sands or the mounds of
empty cities, where the lion and the jackal "reassert their primeval
possession," or where the European and the Tartar, from the West and
from the East, dispute their rights to suzerainty. We are dazzled and
confused when we look back to those great days when the over-peopled
kingdoms sent forth whole tribes, eastward to the confines of Asia,
southward over India, and westward over Europe; and we bow reverently
before the mighty Power that led the Jews, by a promise and a hope,
across the seething nationalities, through the long passage of time
from Abraham to Solomon; and which is again giving into the hands of
those Oriental-looking men, so much power in shaping the destiny of
mankind through their great riches.
Moses commanded the Hebrew people to lend and never to borrow. They
have obeyed his precept, except in art; to that they have lent or
given nothing. There is no national Jewish art. For music only do they
show artistic genius, and that is European and not Oriental. As
illustrating their lack of intuitive decorative art, one need only
refer to the architecture of the first, second, and third Temple
buildings, which apparently reflected Babylonian and Semitic
influences on an early Chaldean type. The embroideries mentioned by
different writers, from Moses to Josephus, appear to have had always a
Babylonian, or later a Persian inspiration.
This absence of artistic genius is very remarkable in a people that
had its origin in the Eastern centre from whence all art has radiated.
The reason that so little survives of ancient embroidery is evident.
Woollen stuffs and threads decay quickly--the moth and rust do corrupt
them--and the very few ancient bits that remain, have been preserved
by the embalming process, which has kept the contents of tombs from
becoming dust.
As to more modern embroideries, we ought to be thankful that the art
has had its fashions; otherwise, the world would be overwhelmed with
shabby rags. Human nature has a tendency to dislike the
"old-fashioned"--i.e. the fashion of the last generation. That which
our mothers worked or wore, is an object for affectionate sentiment,
and the best specimens alone are preserved. That which belonged to our
grandfathers and grandmothers has receded into the rococo; and a few
more generations take us back to the antique, of which so little
survives, from wear and tear, carelessness and theft, that we put away
and preserve it as being curious and precious. We may hope that the
general law of the survival of the fittest has guarded what is most
remarkable.
Certain works have been consecrated by the hands that executed them,
or by that of the donor, or by the purpose for which they were
bestowed, and are mostly preserved in churches or national museums. Of
these there are vestments and altar decorations worked by royal and
noble ladies; and coronation garments given by Queens and Empresses,
such as Queen Gisela's and the Empress Kunigunda's at Prague and
Bamberg, and Charlemagne's dalmatic at the Vatican, described in the
chapter on ecclesiastical embroideries. Sculptured effigies help us as
to embroidered patterns; for our forefathers often actually copied in
bronze or stone the patterns of the garments in which the body was
buried, or at any rate, those the man had worn in his life. Of these,
King John's monument at Worcester, and the surcoat of the Black Prince
at Canterbury, are remarkable examples.[8]
The succeeding chapters will contain sketches of the history of the
different stitches, and of the best examples of stitch and style
remaining to us; and I shall try to extract from both the best
suggestions for guidance in design and handicraft.
Embroidery from its nature is essentially the woman's art.[9] It needs
a sedentary life, industry and patience. It does not require a room to
itself, and the worker may leave it at any moment between two stitches
when called to other duties. Nunneries produced the finest work of the
dark and middle ages; and their teaching inaugurated the workrooms in
the palaces and castles, where young girls, whether royal, noble, or
gentle, were trained in embroidery as an accomplishment and a
household duty.
The history of domestic embroidery ought to be looked upon as that of
an important factor in the humanizing effect of æsthetic culture.
The woman of the house has always been strong to fulfil her part in
this civilizing influence with the implement which custom has awarded
to her. Every man in the ancient East began his life under the tent or
in the palace adorned by the hands of his mother and her maidens, and
his home was made beautiful by his wife and his sisters and their
slaves. There, as in mediæval homes, lessons of morality and religion,
and the love and fame of noble deeds, were taught by the painting of
the needle to the minds of the young men, who would have scorned more
direct teaching; and the children felt the influence, as the women
wove what the bards sang.
Alas! we have but few specimens of embroideries of which we know the
history, earlier than the tenth and eleventh centuries.[10] Yet from
the days of the books of the Old Testament and the song of the siege
of Troy, down to the present time, the woman of the house has adorned
not only herself and her dear lord, but she has hung the walls, the
seats, the bed, and the tables with her beautiful creations.
Homer's women were all artists with the needle. Venus seeking Helen,--
"Like fair Laodice in form and face,
The loveliest nymph of Priam's royal race,
Here in the palace at her loom she found:
The golden web her own sad story crown'd.
The Trojan wars she weaved (herself the prize),
And the dire triumph of her fatal eyes."[11]
This must have been intended for hangings.
Hecuba's wardrobe is thus described:--
"The Phrygian queen to her rich wardrobe went,
Where treasured odours breathed a costly scent;
There lay the vestures of no vulgar art,
Sidonian maids embroider'd every part.
Here, as the queen revolved with careful eyes
The various textures and the various dyes
She chose a web that shone superior far,
And glow'd refulgent as the morning star."[12]
The women of the Middle Ages were great at the loom and frame. From
the Kleine Heldenbuch of the thirteenth century, Rock quotes these
lines:--
"Who taught me to embroider in a frame with silk,
And to sketch and design the wild and tame
Beasts of the forest and field?
Also to picture on plain surfaces;
Round about to place golden borders--
narrow and a broad one--
With stags and hinds, lifelike."
Gudrun, like the women of Homer, embroidered history--that of the
ancestors of Siegfried.
But in the Middle Ages the embroiderers were ambitious artists. The
deeds of Roland and the siege of Troy, all romantic and classical
lore, provided subjects for the needle.
Shakespeare gives a pretty picture of the graceful weaver and
embroiderer:--
* * * "Would ever with Marina be:--
Be't when she weaves the sleided silk,
With fingers long, small, white as milk;
Or when she would with sharp neeld wound
The cambric, which she makes more sound
By hurting it....
Deep clerks she dumbs; and with her neeld composes
Nature's own shape, of bud, bird, branch, or berry,
That even her art sisters the natural roses."[13]
Before closing this Introduction, I will take the opportunity to
protest against the abuse of the phrase "High Art." It is generally
appropriated by that which is the lowest and most feeble.
An old design for a chair or table, by no means remarkable originally,
but cheaply copied, and covered with a quaint and dismal cretonne or
poorly worked pattern, of which the design is neither new nor
artistic, is introduced by the upholsterer as belonging to "High Art
furniture." The epithet has succeeded to what was once "fashionable"
and "elegant." To get rid of carpets, and put down rugs, to hang up
rows of plates instead of family portraits--this also is "high art."
Likewise gowns lumped upon the shoulders, with all the folds drawn
across, instead of hanging draperies. The term is never used when we
speak of the great arts--painting, sculpture, and architecture. It is,
in fact, only the slang of the cabinet-maker, the upholsterer, and
milliner.
All true Art is very high indeed and apparent; and needs not to be
introduced with a puff. It sits enthroned between Poetry and History.
Even those who are ignorant of its laws feel its influence, and the
soothing grace which it sheds, falling like the rain, equally upon the
just and the unjust. Man's nature always responds to the truly high
and beautiful; only the most degraded are deprived of this source of
happiness. And there are but few women, till debased by cruelty,
misery, or drink, that do not try in some humble way (but especially
with their needle) to adorn their own persons, their children, and
their homes; and if their art is not high, it yet has the power to
elevate them.[14] While the most ambitious women try a higher flight,
into the regions of poetry, literature, painting, and even sculpture
(why has no woman ever been an architect?), millions have enjoyed the
art of the needle for thousands of years, and it will continue to be a
solace and a delight as long as the world lasts, for, like all art, it
gives the ever new joy of creation.
FOOTNOTES:
[3] See Duke of Argyll's "Unity of Nature."
[4] Walls, pillars, and roofs were certainly hung with
textile ornament before they were carved or painted.
This is Semper's theory, and though Woltmann and
Woermann ("History of Painting," Eng. Trans., Sidney
Colvin, p. 38) hardly accept this view, they do not
gainsay it. The women who wove hangings for the grove,
or more literally, "coverings for the houses" of the
grove, were probably the priestesses of Astarte, and
wove and worked the hangings of various colours. 2 Kings
xxii.; Ezek. xvi. 16-18.
"It is probable that the earliest kind of pictures were
either woven or embroidered upon figured stuffs of
various colours; and that in these decorations the
Greeks in the first instance imitated the Semitic races,
who had practised them from time immemorial." See
Woltmann and Woermann's "History of Painting" (Eng.
Trans.), p. 38.
[5] Joshua vii.
[6] Ezek. xxvii. 23.
[7] The wall of China, which, both figuratively and
literally, enclosed its civilization, and fenced off
that of the outer world, for thousands of years.
[8] When the tomb of King John was opened, the body was
found wrapped in the same dress as that sculptured on
his effigy. The surcoat of the Black Prince, of
embroidered velvet, still hangs above his monument, on
which it is exactly reproduced.
[9] Yet men, too, have wielded the embroidering needle.
[10] These remnants are not, like the straws in amber,
only precious because they are curious; they are most
suggestive as works of art.
[11] Pope's Homer, Iliad, book iii.
[12] Ibid. book vi.
[13] Shakespeare, "Pericles, Prince of Tyre," act iv.
20; v. 5.
[14] Surely it is a humanizing and Christian principle
which in Italy permits artistic work to be done in the
prisons where criminals are confined for life. Sisters
of Mercy teach lace-making to the wretched women who,
having committed great crimes, may never be seen again.
The produce of the work helps to pay the expense of the
prison, and at the same time a very small percentage is
given to the prisoners to send to their friends, or to
spend on little comforts, thus encouraging the poor
human creatures to exercise their best powers. We
believe this is sometimes allowed also in England and
France.
CHAPTER I.
STYLE.
In venturing to approach so great a subject as the history of style, I
would beg my readers to believe how well I am aware that on each point
much more has been already carefully treated by previous writers, than
will fall within the limits of a chapter that is intended only to
throw light on textile art, and especially on embroidery.
I suppose it is the same in all subjects of human speculation which
are worthy of serious study; and therefore I ought not to have been
surprised to find how much has already been written on needlework and
embroidery, and how unconsciously I, at least, have passed by and
ignored these notices, till it struck me that I ought to know
something of the history and principles of the art which with others,
I was striving to revive and improve.
Then new and old facts crowded round me, and became significant and
interesting. I longed to know something of the first worker and the
first needle; and behold the needle has been found!--among the débris
of the life of the Neolithic cave-man, made of bone and very neatly
fashioned.
Alas! the workwoman and her work are gone to dust; but _there_ is the
needle!--proof positive that the craft existed before the last glacial
period in Britain.[15] How long ago this was, we may conjecture, but
can never finally ascertain. Then I find embroidery named by the
earliest historians, by every poet of antiquity, and by the first
travellers in the East; and it has been the subject of laws and
enactments from the date of the Code of Manu in India, to the present
century. One becomes eager to systematize all this information, and to
share with the workers and thinkers of the craft, the pleasure found
in its study.
Perhaps what is here collected may appear somewhat bald and
disjointed; but antiquity, both human and historical, is apt to be
bald; and its dislocation and disjointed condition are owing to the
frequent cataclysms, physical, political, and social, which needlework
has survived, bringing down to us the same stitches which served the
same purposes for decoration under the Code of Manu, and adorned the
Sanctuary in the wilderness; and those stitches probably were not new
then.
I propose to give a slight sketch of the origin of the styles[16] that
have followed each other, noting the national influences that have
displaced or altered them, and the overlap of style caused by outside
events.
First, I would define what "STYLE" means.
Style is the mark impressed on art by a national period, short or
long. It fades, it wanes, and then some historical element enters on
the scene, which carries with it new materials, needs, and tastes
(either imported or springing up under the new conditions). The style
of the day in art and literature alters so perceptibly, that all who
have had any artistic training are at once aware of the difference.
Of late years, the science of history has been greatly assisted by the
science of language. When the mute language of art shall have been
patiently deciphered, the historian will be furnished with new powers
in his researches after truth.
The first "ineffaceable" is a _word_; the second a _pattern_. This is
proved by the history of needlework.
As the world grows old, its youth becomes more interesting. Alas! the
childhood of mankind is so distant, and it was so long before it
learned its letters, that but few facts have come down to us, on which
we may firmly build our theories; yet we must acknowledge the great
stride that has been made in the last few years, in the scientific
mode of extracting history from the ruins and tombs, and even the
dust-heaps, of the past. Whole epochs, which fifty years ago were as
blank as the then maps of Central Africa, are being now gradually
covered with landmarks.
Layard, Rawlinson, C. T. Newton, Botta, Rassam, Schliemann, Birch, G.
Smith, and a crowd of archæologists, and even unscientific explorers,
are collecting the materials from which the history of mankind is
being reconstructed.
From them I have sought information about the art of embroidery, and I
find that Semper gives it a high pre-eminence as to its antiquity,
making it the foundation and starting-point of all art. He clothes not
only man, but architecture, with the products of the loom and the
needle; and derives from them in succession, painting, bas-relief, and
sculpture.[17]
* * * * *
Style has to be considered in two different aspects, from two
different standpoints. First, historically and archæologically,
distinguishing and dating the forms which follow upon each other; and
tracing them back in the order of their natural sequence; so as to
guide us to the root, nay, to the seed[18] of each and all art.
The subsidiary art of embroidery, in its highest form the handmaid of
architecture, is full of suggestion, and may assist us greatly in the
search which culminates in the text of "In the beginning."
The other point of view from which style should be considered is the
æsthetic. This enables us to criticize the works of different periods;
extracting, as far as we may, rules for the beautiful and the
commendable, and seeking to find the "why?" also observing the
operation of the law by which decay follows too soon after the best
and highest efforts of genius, thought, and invention in art.
My present object is the history of consecutive styles, in so far as
they concern needlework.
Alas! nothing endures. This law is acknowledged by Goethe, when he
makes Jove answer Venus, who bewailed that all that is beautiful must
die,--that he had only bestowed beauty on the evanescent.
It seems as if the moment the best is attained, men, ceasing to
struggle for the better, fall back at once hopelessly and become mere
imitators. They no longer follow a type, but copy a model, and then
copy the copy. Imitation is a precipice, a swift descent through
poverty of thought into the chaos of mannerism, in the place of style.
The imitative tendency, as existing in all human minds, cannot be
ignored or despised. In individuals it accompanies enthusiasm for the
beautiful, and the graceful charm of sympathy. It maintains continuity
between specimen and specimen, between artist and artist, between
century and century; and it is this which enables an adept to say with
certainty of consecutive styles, "This is Spanish work of the
sixteenth century; that is Flemish or German work of the seventeenth
century."
The theory of development and of the survival of the fittest has been
worked so hard, that it sometimes breaks down under the task imposed
upon it. It would need to include Death in its procedure. In our
creed, Death, means the moment of entrance into a higher existence;
but in art it means extinction, leaving behind neither a history nor
an artisan--only, perhaps, an infinitely small tradition, like the
grain of corn preserved in the wrappings of a mummy, from which at
first accident, and then care and culture, may evoke a future life.
The various ways in which art has appeared at the beginning cannot
here be discussed; nor how the Chinese and Hindu may have leapt into a
perfection which has stood still for thousands of years, protected
alike from expansion as from destruction, by the swaddling bands of
codified custom; while Greek art rose like the sun, shone over the
civilized world, and set--never again to see another epoch of glory.
These subjects must be left for the study of the anthropological
philosopher, who is working for the assistance and guidance of the
future historian of art.
Style in needlework has passed through many phases since the
aboriginal, prehistoric woman, with the bone needle, drew together the
edges of the skins of the animals she had prepared for food.
For absolute necessity, in forming the garments and covering the tent,
needlework need go no further than the seam. This, however, in the
woven or plaited material, must fray where it is shaped, and become
fringed at the edges. Every long seam is a suggestion, and every
shaped edge a snare.
The fringe lends itself to the tassel, and the shaped seam suggests a
pattern; up-stitches are needed for binding the web, and before she is
aware of it, the worker finds herself adorning, _embroidering_; and
the craft enters the outskirts of the region of art.
The humble early efforts at decoration, called by the French
"primitif," are the first we know and class, and are found in all
savage attempts at ornament. This style consists mainly of straight
lines, zigzags, wavy lines, dots, and little discs.[19]
Gold discs of many sizes, and worked with a variety of patterns, are
found equally in the tomb of the warrior at Mycenæ, and in Ashantee,
accompanied in both cases with gold masks covering the faces of the
dead. The discs or buttons remind us of those found in Etruscan tombs,
though the execution of these last is more advanced. They appear to be
the origin of the "clavus" or nail-headed pattern woven into silks in
the Palace of the Cæsars. The last recorded survival of this pattern
is in woven materials for ecclesiastical purposes in the Middle Ages.
Of very early needlework we only find here and there a fragment,
illustrated occasionally by passing allusions in poetry and history.
The ornamental art of Hissarlik[20] is so primitive that we cannot
feel that it has any resemblance to that described as Trojan by Homer,
who probably adorned his song with the art he had known elsewhere.[21]
We know not what the actual heroes of the Iliad and Odyssey wore; but
we do know that what Homer describes, he must have seen. Was Homer,
therefore, the contemporary of the siege of Troy?--or does he not
rather speak of the customs and costumes of his own time, and apply
them to the traditions of the heroic ages of Greece? Whatever be the
date of Homer himself, we can, with the help of contemporary
survivals, reconstruct the house and the hall, and even furnish them,
and clothe the women and the princes, the beggars and the herdsmen.
From the remains of Egyptian, Babylonian, and Assyrian art we can
perceive their differences and their affinities. It is from textile
fragments, found mostly in tombs, that we obtain dates, and can
suggest them for other specimens.
The funeral tent of Shishak's mother-in-law, at Boulac, is most
valuable as showing what was the textile art of that early period.[22]
[Illustration: Fig. 1.
Egyptian corselet. (Wilkinson's "Ancient Egyptians.")]
The corselet which, according to Herodotus, was given by Amasis, King
of Egypt, to the Temple of Minerva at Lindos, in Rhodes, was possibly
worked in this style; for Babylonian embroidery was greatly prized in
Egypt, and imitated.
The second corselet given by Amasis to the Lacædemonians was worked in
gold and colours, with animals and other decorations. This was of the
seventh century B.C.[23]
Amongst the arms painted on the wall of the tomb of Rameses, at Thebes
(in Egypt), is a corselet, apparently of rich stuff,[24] embroidered
with lions and other devices. (Fig. 1.)
The Phœnicians imbibed and reproduced the styles they met with in
their voyages. The bowls found in Cyprus described and engraved in the
September number of the "Magazine of Art" (1883), are most interesting
illustrations of the meeting of two national styles, the Assyrian and
the Egyptian.[25]
Homer's "Shield of Achilles"[26] must, in general design, have
resembled these bowls (see Pl. 5). They also recall the description by
Josephus of the Temple veils at Jerusalem, which were Babylonian.[27]
Phœnicia, which was the carrier of all art, dropped specimens here
and there, for many hundred years, along the borders of the
Mediterranean and the coasts of Spain. We fancy we can trace her
ocean-path by the western shores of Africa, and even to America;
otherwise, how could it happen that a mummy-wrapping in Peru should so
nearly resemble some of those wrappings found at Saccarah,[28] in
Egypt, woven in precisely the same tapestry fashion?
Among the puzzling phenomena due probably to Phœnician commerce, is
the complete suite of the sacerdotal ornaments of a High Priest, found
in his tomb,[29] now in the Vatican Museum. This reminds us of other
specimens of archaic art from distant sources, that our attention is
forcibly arrested, and we wonder whence they came, and whether they
were collected from alien civilizations by the Phœnicians before
they dispersed them.[30]
Certain Egyptian sculptures of deformed and repulsive
divinities--idols of the baser sort--are most interesting and puzzling
by their affinity in style to the Indo-Dravidian and the art of
Mexico, while they are entirely unlike that of Egypt. If Atlantis and
its arts never existed, it may be suggested that it was the eastern
coast of America that was spoken of under that name by the Egyptian
priest with whom Herodotus conversed.
The Babylonian and Ninevite embroideries, carefully executed on their
bas-reliefs, have a masculine look, which suggests the design of an
artist and the work of slaves. There is no following out of graceful
fancies; one set of selected forms (each probably with a symbolical
intention) following another. The effect, as seen on the sculptures in
the British Museum, is royally gorgeous; and one feels that creatures
inferior to monarchs or satraps could never have aspired to such
splendours. Probably the embroidery on their corselets was executed in
gold wire, treated as thread, and taken through the material; and the
same system was carried out in adorning the trappings of the horses
and the chariots. The solid masses of embroidery may have been
afterwards subjected to the action of the hammer, which would account
for their appearing like jeweller's work in the bas-reliefs (Pl. 1 and
2).
[Illustration: Pl. 1.
Assurbanipal fighting lions.
British Museum.]
[Illustration: Pl. 2.
Portion of a Babylonian Royal Mantle. Layard's "Monuments," series
i., pl. 9.]
The style of the Babylonian embroideries appears to have been
naturalistic though conventionalized. We may judge of their styles for
different purposes by the reliefs in the British Museum. From their
veils and curtains at a later date, when they had crossed their
art with that of India, we may imagine the mystical design of the
Temple curtain as described by Josephus; in fact, as much as possible
embracing all things on the earth and above it, excepting the images
of the heavenly bodies.[31]
Small carpets from Persia of the Middle Ages, as well as those woven
and embroidered even to the present day, are echoes of the ancient
Babylonian style, and most interesting as historical records of the
traditions of human taste. Our artistic interests are stirred when we
read in Ezekiel lists of the fabrics and materials of which Tyre had
become the central depôt, and we enjoy tracing them to the various
looms, named in verse and history, where they were adorned with
embroidery, and then either became articles of commerce, or were
stored away to be kept religiously as heirlooms, or presented as gifts
to the temples or to honoured guests.
Mr. G. Smith, after saying that the Babylonian is without doubt the
oldest of civilizations, continues thus:--"To us the history of
Babylonia has an interest beyond that of Egypt, on account of its more
intimate connection with our own civilization.[32] Babylon was the
centre from which it spread into Assyria, thence to Asia Minor and
Phœnicia, then to Greece and Rome, and so to all Europe. The Jews
brought the traditions of the creation and of early religion from Ur
of the Chaldees,[33] and thus preserved they became the heritage of
all mankind; while the science and civilization of that wonderful
people (the Babylonians) became the basis of modern research and
advancement."[34]
The hangings of the Tabernacle are so carefully described in the book
of Exodus, that we can see in fancy the linen curtains, blue or white,
embroidered in scarlet, purple, blue, and gold; the cherubim in the
woven material; the fringes enriched with flowers, buds, fruit, and
golden bells: and we can appreciate how little of Egyptian art and
style the children of Israel brought back from their long captivity,
and how soon they reverted to their ancient Chaldean proclivities,
after returning to their wandering life of the tent.
On the bronze gates from the mound of Balawat, near Nimroud, set up by
Shalmaneser to celebrate his conquest of Tyre and Sidon,[35] we find a
portable tabernacle, evidently meant to accompany the army on a march.
It is not much larger than a four-post bed, with transverse poles for
drawing the curtains, all fringed with bells and fruit. This is an
illustration of the motive for the Tabernacle of the forty years'
wandering in the desert. (Fig. 2.)
[Illustration: Fig. 2.
Tabernacle on gates of Balawat, time of Shalmaneser II. (British
Museum).]
Egyptian textile art is, perhaps, that of which we have the most early
specimens. These are to be seen at Boulac, at Vienna, Turin, and the
British Museum.[36] The Hieroglyphic, the Archaic, and the
Græco-Egyptian are all unmistakably the consecutive outcome of the
national original style, which had totally disappeared in the
beginning of our era. Few of the embroideries are more than two
thousand five hundred years old. But the great piece of patchwork in
leather, "the funeral tent of an Egyptian queen," as it covered the
remains of a contemporary of Solomon,[37] absolutely exhibits the
proficiency of the designer and the needlework of the eleventh century
B.C. (Pl. 44.)
The connection between Indian and Egyptian early art appears to have
existed only in their use of the lotus as an emblem and a constant
decoration; but their manner of employing it was characteristically
different. (Pl. 12 and 13.)
The Phœnicians carried with them the seeds of the Egyptian style
over the ancient world; but these seeds only took root and flourished
on the soil of Greece. The imitations of Egyptian style reappeared in
Rome, and again in France "under the two Empires." In both cases they
were only imitations, and neither had any permanent influence on the
art of their day.
I shall have to allude very often to our Eastern sources of artistic
culture.
Our own Aryan ancestors were so impregnated with beautiful ideas, that
we must believe that we inherit from them all our graceful
appreciation of naturalistic ornament. But even Aryan art met with
reverses on its Eastern soil, from which it constantly rose again and
renewed itself.
The Mongols crushed for a time the element of beauty in India. They
introduced a barbarous and hideous style which has its only
counterpart in that of Central America. It was the produce of a
religion, superstitious, cruel, and devilish.
The Aryan art of India, which was elegant and spiritual, was revived
by the kindred influence of Persia, and by the Renaissance in Europe.
Italian and other artists were employed in India, and "the spirit of
aerial grace, and the delicate sense of beauty in natural forms,
blossomed afresh and flourished for 300 years. Birds, flowers, fruit,
butterflies, became once more the legitimate ornament of every
material."[38]
I continue to quote from Sir G. Birdwood's "Arts of India." "The Code
of Manu, from 900 to 300 B.C., has secured to the village system of
India a permanent class of hereditary artistic workmen and artisans,
who have through these 2500 years, at least, been trained to the same
manipulations, and who therefore translate any foreign work which is
placed before them to copy, into something characteristically
Indian."[39] Indian art has borrowed freely from all sources without
losing its own individuality. It has been said, "There is nothing
newer in it than of the sixteenth century; and even then nothing was
original, especially in the minor arts." But this is owing to the
Hindu being equally endowed with assimilative and receptive
capacity,[40] so that in the hands of the Indian craftsman everything
assumes the distinctive expression of ancient Indian art.
In India everything is hand-wrought; but as the spirit of its
decorative art "is that of a crystallized tradition, its type has
remained almost unaltered since the Aryan genius culminated in the
Ramâyana and Mahabhârata--and yet each artisan in India is a true
artist."[41] In art, unfortunately, "the letter killeth;" and true
artists as they are, the ancient traditions bind and cramp them,
while the ancient materials, the dyes, and the absolute command of
time are failing: so that the beauty of Indian embroideries and other
decorations is gradually reducing itself to mannerism, which is more
dangerous to art than even had been the vicissitudes of war; for when
peaceful days returned, and the waves of conquest had subsided, the
ancient arts were found again deeply embedded in the traditions of the
people. They gradually returned to their old ways, which are so
indelible in the Hindu mind, that they will perhaps survive even the
fashions of to-day.[42]
From Yates' account it would appear that Europe had been fertilized
with taste in art and manufactures from the East by three different
routes.
The Egyptian civilization, with all its Eastern antecedents and
traditions, came to us by the Mediterranean and the Adriatic; the
Phœnicians being the merchants who brought it through those
channels. The Etruscans, who were the pedlars of Europe, travelled
north, conveying golden ornaments and coral, and bringing back jet and
amber. Their commercial track is to be traced by the contents of tombs
on their path.[43]
[Illustration: Pl. 3.
St. John. From King Alfred's Celtic Book of the Gospels. Lambeth
Palace Library.]
Secondly, there was also a Slavonian route from Eastern Asia, which
conveyed Oriental art to the north of Europe. Celtic art, which
certainly has something of the Indo-Chinese style, came to us probably
by this route. Another branch of the Celtic family was settled on the
north-eastern shores of the Adriatic. Celtic ideas and forms in art
probably crossed Europe from this point,[44] and came to us meeting a
cognate influence,[45] arriving from the north.[46] (Pl. 3.)
Thirdly, Oriental taste and textiles came from the Byzantine Empire in
the early days of Christianity, spreading to Sicily, Italy, Spain, and
finally to France, Germany, and Britain.
Runic art, whether Scandinavian or our own purer Celtic, is so
remarkable for its independence of all other European national and
traditional design, that I cannot omit a brief notice of it, though we
have no ascertained relics of any of its embroideries.[47] It appears
to have received, in addition to its own universal stamp--evidently
derived from one original source--certain influences impressed on it
like a seal by each country through which it flowed.[48] Wherever the
Runes are carved in stone, or worked on bronze, gold, silver, ivory,
or wood, or painted in their splendid illuminations (pl. 4), the
involved serpent, which was the sign of their faith, appears,
sometimes covered with Runic inscriptions; and this inscribed serpent,
later, is twined round or heaped at the foot of the peculiar
Scandinavian-shaped cross, the type of conversion. The serpent was
sometimes altered into the partial semblance of a four-footed animal,
the body and tail being lengthened and twined, and sometimes split, to
give a new turn to the pattern. (Fig. 3.) All these zoomorphic
patterns, as well as the human figures seen in the Book of Kells, the
missal at Lambeth, and the Lindisfarne Book (which is, however, more
English in its style), are yet of an Indo-Chinese type; the
wicker-work motives often replacing the involved serpent design.
[Illustration: Fig. 3.
Celtic Zoomorphic pattern.]
The Paganism of our own Celtic art, when it appears, is an
interpolation between our first and second Christian conversions, and
was brought to us in the incursions of the Vikings over Scotland and
into England.
[Illustration: Page from the Lindisfarne MSS. British Museum]
[Illustration: Pl. 5.
Silver bowl from Palestrina. Ganneau. "Journal Asiatique, Coupe de
Palestrina." 1880.]
Our knowledge of their advanced and most singular art comes out
of their tombs, in which the warrior was laid with all his arms and
his horse and his precious possessions, splendidly clothed according
to his degree--in the belief that he would need them again in a future
world.
This northern tradition was so long-lived, that Frederick Casimir, a
knight of the Teutonic Order, was buried with his sword and his horse
at Treves, in 1781.[49]
Greek embroideries we can perfectly appreciate, by studying Hope's
"Costumes of the Ancients," and the works of Millingen and others;
also the fictile vases in the British Museum and elsewhere. On these
are depicted the Hellenic gods, the wars, and the home life of the
Greeks. The worked or woven patterns on their draperies are infinitely
varied, and range over many centuries of design, and they are almost
always beautiful. It is melancholy to have to confess that in this, as
in all their art, the Greek taste is inimitable; yet we may profit by
the lessons it teaches us. These are: variety without redundancy;
grace without affectation; simplicity without poverty; the
appropriate, the harmonious, and the serene, rather than that which is
astonishing, painful, or awe-inspiring. These principles were carried
into the smallest arts, and we can trace them in the shaping of a cup
or the decoration of a mantle, as in the frieze of the Parthenon.
Homer makes constant mention of the women's work. Penelope's web is
oftenest quoted. This was a shroud for her Father-in-law. Ulysses
brought home a large collection of fine embroidered garments,
contributed by his fair hostesses during his travels.
Pallas Athene patronized the craft of the embroiderers; and the sacred
peplos which robed her statue, and was renewed every year, was
embroidered by noble maidens, under the superintendence of a
priestess of her temple. It represented the battles of the gods and
the giants (fig. 4), till the portraits of living men were profanely
introduced into the design. The new peplos was carried to the temple,
floating like a flag, in procession through the city.
The goddess to whom the Greeks gave the protection of this art was
wise as well as accomplished, and knew that it was good for women
reverently to approach art by painting with their needles. She always
was seen in embroidered garments, and worked as well as wove them
herself. She appeared to Ulysses in the steading of Eumœus, the
swineherd, as a "woman tall and fair, and skilful in splendid
handiwork."[50]
[Illustration: Fig. 4.
Pallas Athene attired in the sacred peplos.
(Panathenaic Vase, British Museum.)]
Homer never tires of praising the women's work, and the chests of
splendid garments laid up in the treasure-houses.[51] Helen gave of
her work to Telemachus: "Helen, the fair lady, stood by the coffer
wherein were her robes of curious needlework which she herself had
wrought. Then Helen, the fair lady, lifted it out, the widest and most
beautifully embroidered of all--and it shone like a star; and this she
sent as a gift to his future wife."[52]
Semper's theory is, that the one chief import of Oriental style being
embroideries, therefore the hangings and dresses arriving from Asia
gave the poetic Greek the motives for his art, his civilization, his
legends, and his gods.[53] This may or may not be; there is no doubt
that they influenced them.[54]
Böttiger accordingly believes that Homer's descriptions of beautiful
dress and furnishings are derived from, or at least influenced by,
what he had learnt of the Babylonian and Chaldean embroideries. This
is very probable, and would account for his poetical design on the
shield of Achilles, in which his own inspiration dictated the
possibilities of the then practised arts of Asia, of which the fame
and occasional glimpses were already drifting westward. (Plate 5.)
The description of the shield of Achilles is as follows: Hephaistos,
"the lame god," "threw bronze that weareth not, into the fire; and
tin, and precious gold and silver." "He fashioned the shield great and
strong, with five folds (or circles) in the shield itself." "Then
wrought he the earth and the sea, and the unwearying sun, and the moon
waxing to its full, and the signs, every one wherewith the heavens are
crowned." "Also he fashioned therein two cities of mortal men; and
here were marriage feasts, and brides led home by the blaze of
torches--young men whirling in the dance, and the women standing each
at her door marvelling." Then a street fight, and the elders sitting
in judgment. The other city was being besieged; and there is a
wonderful description of the battle fought on the river banks, and
"Strife, Tumult, and Death" personified, and mingling in the fight.
Then he set in the shield the labours of the husbandman. This is so
exquisitely beautiful that with difficulty I refrain from quoting it
all. "He wrought thereon a herd of kine with upright horns, and the
kine were fashioned of gold and tin," "and herdsmen of gold were
following after them." "Also did the glorious lame god devise a
dancing-place like unto that which once, in wide Knosos, Daidalos
wrought for Ariadne of the lovely tresses. There were youths dancing
and maidens of costly wooing, their hands upon their waists." "And now
would they run round with deft feet exceedingly lightly"--"and now
would they run in lines to meet each other." "And a great company
stood round the lovely dance in joy; and among them a divine minstrel
was making music on his lyre; and through the midst of them, as he
began his strain, two tumblers whirled. Also he set therein the great
might of the River of Ocean, around the utmost rim of the
cunningly-fashioned shield."[55]
There is, indeed, every proof that Greek art was the joint product of
the Egyptian and Assyrian civilizations. Their amalgamation gave birth
to the archaic style, struggling to express the strength and the
beauty of man--half heroic, half divine. Gradually, all the
surrounding decorations of life assumed as a governing principle and
motive, the worth of noble beauty.
The Greeks were the first artists. They broke away from the ancient
trammels of customary forms, and replaced law with liberty of thought,
and tradition with poetry.
They destroyed no old ideas, but they selected, appropriated, and
evoked beauty from every source. From the great days of Athens we may
date the moment when materials became entirely subservient to art, and
the minds of individual men were stamped on their works and dated
them. Phases indeed followed each other, showing the links of
tradition which still bound men's minds together to a certain extent,
and formed the general style of the day. Yet there was in art from
that time--life, sometimes death,--but then a resurrection.
It appears from classical writers that about 300 B.C. Greek art had
thrown itself into many new forms. Painting, for example, had tried
all themes excepting landscapes. We are told that within the space of
150 years the art had passed through every technical stage; from the
tinted profile system of Polygnotus to the proper pictorial system of
natural scenes, composed with natural backgrounds; and Peiraiïkos is
named as an artist of genre--a painter of barbers and cobblers,
booths, asses, eatables, and such-like realistic subjects.[56]
I suppose there is no doubt that all the Romans knew or felt of art
was borrowed directly or indirectly from Greece,[57] first through
Phœnician and perhaps Etruscan sources, and finally by conquest.
Everything we have of their art shows their imitation of Grecian
models. Their embroideries would certainly have shown the same
impress.
Greece--herself crushed and demoralized--even as late as the Eastern
Empire gave to Rome the fashion of the Byzantine taste, which she at
once adopted, and it was called the Romanesque. This style, which was
partly Arab, still prevails in Eastern Europe, having clung to the
Greek Church. In her best days, Roman poetry, architecture, and
decorative arts were Greek of Greece, imitating its highest types, but
never creating.
It is surely allowable to quote here one of Virgil's Homeric echoes,
which touches upon our especial subject,--
"Mournful at heart at that supreme farewell,
Andromache brings robes of border'd gold;
A Phrygian cloak, too, for Ascanius.
And yielding not the palm in courtesy,
Loads him with woven treasures, and thus speaks:
'Take these gifts, too, to serve as monuments
Of my hand-labour, boy; so may they bear
Their witness to Andromache's long love,
The wife of Hector:--take them, these last gifts
Thy kindred can bestow; in this sad world
Sole image left of my Astyanax!'"[58]
It is sad to mark how not only the refinements of taste, but even the
guiding principles of art, were gradually lost in the humiliation of a
conquered people, the dulness and discouragement which followed on the
expatriation or destruction of their accumulated treasures, and the
deterioration of the Greek artist and artisan, carried prisoners to
Rome, and settled there because it was the seat of luxury and empire.
As the captive Jews hung their harps on the willow-trees by the waters
of Babylon, and refused to sing, so Greek genius succumbed, weighed
down by Roman chains. It sickened and died in exile.
Late Roman art reminds us of the art of Etruria in its archaic days,
except that the freshness and promise are wanting, and that the one
was in its first, the other its second childhood.
Before entering on the subject of Christian art, I must again refer,
however briefly, to the Eastern origin of all art. It is evident that
this had always flowed in streams of many types from that high
watershed of Central Asia, where our human race is said to have been
created, and whence all wisdom and knowledge have emanated. In the
image of the Creator, man issued from thence, endowed with the gift of
the creative power. Wave after wave of fresh and apparently differing
nationalities followed each other; partially submerging those that had
gone before, and spreading till it had reached the furthest shores of
the Northern seas and the Atlantic, and encircled the Mediterranean.
They all followed the same course from east to west. The Greek
civilization was indeed so dazzling and strong, that it lighted the
world all around; and India, Persia, and Assyria felt its influence
reflected back on its old Asian cradle.
But from the same high watershed[59] flowed other tribal types towards
China, Java, and Japan, that had no affinity with any western
civilization; and while the Assyrian, Persian, Indian, and Mongolian
styles mixed and overlapped so near their sources, that it is
sometimes hardly possible to reason out and classify their
resemblances and their differences, the tribes flowing Eastward turned
aside and went their own way, and have remained till now perfectly
distinct.[60]
In spite of their matchless dexterity in the manipulation of their
materials, the infinite variety of their stitches, and exquisite
finish in execution, carrying out to the utmost point the intended
effect, yet Chinese and Japanese textile art differs in its inner
principles from all our accepted canons of taste; so that their want
of harmony, and sometimes their absurdity, is a puzzle of which we
cannot find the key. This I have already alluded to (p. 3).
I purposely avoid the questions suggested by Chinese art. The immense
antiquity it claims cannot be allowed without hesitation. M. Terrien
de la Couperie, however, believes that he has found the actual point
of departure of Chinese civilization, and he considers it to be an
early offshoot from Babylon.[61] He supports his theory on linguistic
grounds, and we must anxiously wait to see if it is corroborated by
further researches into the earliest records of the archaic Chinese
literature. But immobility in art is a Chinese characteristic, and no
national cataclysms seem to have disturbed it. The oldest specimens
known are very like the most modern. Yet an adept, learned in Chinese
art, can detect the signs which mark its different epochs.
In this they differ from the Japanese, who, added to their inherited
exquisite appreciation of natural beauty, have a power of assimilation
that might lead in time to their possessing a school of art which,
being really original, might become the style of the future. The
civilization of Japan is not older than the fifth century A.D., and
was probably then imported from Corea. Some of the earliest specimens
we know of their art are embroidered religious pictures by the son of
a Mikado Sholokutaiski, who was in the seventh century the great
apostle of Buddhism in Japan; and the next earliest works are by the
first nun, Honi, in the eighth century. We have European work as old,
and it is most interesting to compare the differences of their styles
and stitches.
We must now return to the beginning of our era, when we find Greek
taste, such as it was, still influencing and colouring art in Italy,
and throughout Europe, Asia, and Africa, wherever Roman colonies were
founded, till the eighth century. It died hard; but by that time the
barbarians had poured from the east and north in successive waves, and
conquered and suppressed the classical civilization.
Nothing is so puzzling in textile art as the mixture of styles during
the first 1000 years A.D. The Græco-Roman, the Byzantine, and the
Egyptian, crossed by the Arabian, Persian, and Indian styles, were
reproduced in the Sicilian looms. Certain stock patterns, such as the
reclining hares or fawns, as we find them on the Shishak pall, or that
of the Tree of Life, approached by worshipping men or animals,
originating in Assyrian art, are employed as borders, and fill up
vacant spaces. The information collected from the tombs in the Crimea
immediately preceding our era, is supplemented by the variety in style
and materials from the Fayoum, now placed by Herr Graf'schen in the
Museum at Vienna.
Christian art, which began in Byzantium, gradually grew, and formed
itself into the Gothic,[62] which in time overcame the general chaos
of style.
Eastern art continued to flow westward, modifying and suggesting.
When the Phœnicians and Carthaginians had laid down their ancient
commercial sceptre, it was taken up by the Greeks, and later by the
Venetians and Genoese, always trading with Asiatic goods. Then the
arts of the Scandinavians[63] and of the Celts (who were the weavers),
though barbaric, still retained and spread certain Oriental
traditions. Luxury was born in Babylon, and Persia became its nurse,
whence all its glories and refinements spread over the world. But if
luxury was Babylonian, art was Greek. Alas! the love of luxury
survived in Rome the taste for art.
[Illustration: Pl. 6.
The Empress Theodora. Mosaic at Ravenna. Church of San. Vitale.]
At Ravenna we learn much of the early Christian period from the
mosaics in the churches. The Empress Theodora and her ladies appear to
be clothed in Indian shawl stuffs. (Plate 6.) These, of course, had
drifted into Rome, as they had long done into the Greek islands, by
the Red Sea or by land through Tyre. Ezekiel (590 B.C.) mentions the
Indian trade through Aden. Theodora's dress has a deep border of gold,
embroidered with classical warriors pursuing each other with
swords.[64] Works enriched with precious stones and pearls now appear
for the first time in European art, and testify to its Oriental
impress.
The Byzantine Christian style was essentially the art of mosaic. Its
patterns for architecture or dress, easily square themselves into
little compartments, suggesting the stitches of "counted" embroideries
("opus pulvinarium").
In the beginning of the fourth century, when Greek influence was still
languishing, we may date the commencement of ecclesiastical art. It
was a new birth, and had to struggle through an infancy of nearly 800
years, ignoring, or unconscious of all rules of drawing, colouring,
and design. Outlines filled in with flat surfaces of colours
represented again the art of painting, which had returned to archaic
types, and in no way differed from the essential properties of the art
of "acu pingere" or needlework, which was in the same phase--being,
fortunately for it, that to which it was best suited.
Therefore fine works of art were then executed by the needle, of which
a very few survive, either in description or copied into more lasting
materials; and showing that, with the minor arts of mosaic and
illumination, it was in a state of higher perfection than the greater
arts, which till the twelfth century were all but in abeyance.
In discussing textile art, I am obliged to pass over a part of the
dark ages, and to approach the period when it must be studied chiefly
in Sicily, which became the half-way house on the high road to the
East, and later the resting-place of the Crusaders to and from the
Holy Land.
Sicily, which had succeeded to Constantinople as being the great
manufacturing mart during the Middle Ages, was in the hands of the
Moors, the origin and source of all European Gothic textile art. Yet
even at Palermo and Messina this art was long controlled by the
traditions of Greece, ancient and modern, while fertilized by Persian
and Indian forms and traditional symbolisms.
The next European phase was the Gothic.[65] This was Arab and Moresque
steeped in northern ideas; and finding its congenial soil, it grew
into the most splendid, thoughtful, and finished style, far
transcending anything that it had borrowed from eastern or southern
sources.
All its traditions were carried out in the smaller decorative
arts--mosaics, ivories, and metal works; and, last and not least,
beautiful embroideries, to adorn the altars and the dresses of
monarchs and nobles. (Plate 7.)
When taste was imperfect or declined, then the decorations were all
rude, and the embroideries shared in the general rudeness or poverty;
but as these crafts rose again, adding to themselves grace and beauty
by study and experience, then needlework in England, Germany, France,
Italy, and Spain grew and flourished.[66]
[Illustration: Italian embroidery XV. Century
Kensington Museum]
[Illustration: Italian orphreys XVI. Century
South Kensington Museum]
[Illustration: Orphreys French and Spanish
XVI. Century]
Then came the Reformation, which, in Germany and England especially,
gave a blow to the arts which had reserved their best efforts for the
Church; and the change of style effected by the Renaissance was not
suited to the solemnity of ecclesiastical decoration.
The styles of the fifteenth and sixteenth century embroideries are
better adapted for secular purposes; though their extreme beauty as
architectural ornament in Italy, reconciles one to their want of
religious character, on the principle that it was allowable to
dedicate to the Church all that in its day was brightest and best.
(Plate 8.)
We possess much domestic embroidery of the Renaissance which is
exceedingly beautiful--Italian, Spanish, and German. English
needlework had lost its prestige from the time of the Reformation.[67]
The best efforts of the German schools of embroidery preceded the
Reformation, while those of Belgium never lost their excellence,[68]
and still hold their high position among the workers of golden
orphreys. In Italy they always retained much of the classical element.
Probably the ancient frescoes which served as models were originally
painted by Greek artists and their Roman imitators. This style
flourished for a hundred years. The French adopted and modified it.
The decorative style of that period is sometimes called the Arabesque,
and sometimes the Grotesque. The fashion was really copied from the
excavated palaces and tombs of the best Roman era. Raphael admired,
and caused his pupils to imitate and copy them; and they influenced
all decorative art for a considerable period. As long as beautiful
forms of flowers, fruit, birds, and animals were adhered to, the
Arabesque was a charming decoration, gay and brilliant; but when the
beautiful was set aside, and the ugly ideas were reproduced, the style
became the Grotesque, which word only means the grotto, cave, or tomb
style, and is as undescriptive to us as the word Arabesque, which has
nothing to do with the Arabs or their arts.
It would appear that if the beautiful only is permissible in
decorative art, and that if without beauty there is no reason that it
should exist at all, then the Grotesque should not be allowed, except
as a scherzo of the pencil; to be relegated, like all other
caricatures, to the portfolio.
A grotesque is something startling, laughable, perhaps ridiculous. A
woman with the head of a goose and a flowery tail may be a symbolical,
but it never can be an agreeable object. When the idea conveyed is a
great one, then it is excusable. The Ninevite bull, with a human head
and five legs, is a grotesque, but it is also a symbol of majesty and
might. A Satyr is a grotesque, but he has been so long recorded and
accepted that he has ceased to surprise us; and the Greeks spent so
much genius in making him a graceful creature, that he has become
picturesque, if not beautiful.
Arabesques and Grotesques have now so long prevailed in decoration,
that we have ceased to criticize them on principle, and accept them
gratefully, in proportion to the gay fancy and reticent genius of the
designer. Most Arabesques are, in fact, only graceful nonsense.
[Illustration: Pl. 9.
Spanish Coverlet, from Goa. Velvet and gold, Plâteresque style,
seventeenth century.]
Vitruvius (writing first century B.C.) says, that "in his time, on the
covering of the walls were painted rather monstrosities than images
of known things. Thus, instead of columns you will see reeds with
crisp foliage, and candlesticks supporting temples; and on the top of
these there are rods and twisted ornaments, and in the volutes
senseless little figures sitting there; likewise flowers with figures
growing out of their calyxes. Here a human head, there an
animal's."[69] Evidently Vitruvius did not approve of grotesques, and
his contemporary criticism is most valuable and amusing.
In the Louis Quatorze period, a species of vegetable grotesque was the
fashion, from which we suffer even now, and it deserves censure.
Leaves and flowers of different plants were made to grow from the same
stem, as only artificial flowers could do. The Greeks introduced into
their decorations sprays and wreaths of bay, olive, oak, ivy, and
vine, with their fruits; which are exquisitely composed and carefully
studied from nature. It is true that they sometimes invented flowers
of different shapes, following each other on the same stem, and
untrammelled by any natural laws. These classical freaks of fancy are
so graceful that their want of truth does not shock us, but they are
more safely copied than imitated.
The Renaissance was particularly marked in Spain and Portugal by the
embroideries which the latter drew from their Indian possessions in
Goa, whilst we in England were sedulously thrusting from our shores
any beautiful Indian textiles that we imagined could injure our own
home manufactures. It was, consequently, the worst phase of needlework
with us, while Spanish and Portuguese embroideries of the sixteenth
and seventeenth centuries are especially fine, their designs being
European, and their needlework Oriental. Their Renaissance, which went
by the name of the Plâteresque, is a style apart. (Pl. 9.) The reason
of its name is that it seems to have been originally intended for, and
is best suited to, the shapes and decorations of gold and silver
plate. It is extremely rich and ornate; not so appropriate to
architecture as to the smaller arts, and wanting, perhaps, the
simplicity which gives dignity. The style called Louis Quatorze
following on the Renaissance in Germany, England, Spain, Italy, and
France, assumed in each of these countries distinguishing
characteristics, into which we have not time to enter now. In this
style France took the lead and appropriated it, and rightly named it
after the magnificent monarch who fostered it. This was a splendid
era; and its furniture and wall decorations, dress, plate, and books
shine in all the fertile richness and grace of French artistic
ingenuity.[70] The new style asserted itself everywhere, and
remodelled every art; but the long reign of Louis Quatorze gave the
fashion time to wane and change. Under Louis XV. the defects increased
and the beauties diminished. The fine heavy borders were broken up
into fragmentary forms; all flow and strength were eliminated; and
what remained of the Louis Quatorze style became, under its next
phase, only remarkable for the sparkling prettiness which is inherent
in all French art.
In Italy this very ornate style was distinguished as the
"Sette-cento," and was a chastened imitation or appropriation of the
Spanish Plâteresque and the French Louis Quatorze. In Germany it was a
decided heavy copy of both, of which there are splendid examples in
the adornment of the German palaces, royal and episcopal. In England
the Continental taste was faintly reflected during the reign of Queen
Anne and the first Georges; but except in the characteristic
upholstery of the Chippendales, and one or two palaces, such as
Blenheim and Castle Howard, we did not produce much that was original
in the style of that day.
Under Louis XV., Boucher and Watteau, in France, produced designs that
were well suited to tapestries and embroideries. All the heathen gods,
with Cupids, garlands, floating ribbons, crowns, and cyphers were
everywhere carved, gilded, and worked. It was the visible tide of the
frivolity in which poor Marie Antoinette was drowned; though before
the Revolution she had somewhat simplified the forms of decoration,
and straight lines instead of curves, and delicacy rather than
splendour, had superseded, at least at court, the extravagant richness
of palatial furniture.
This was followed by the Revolution; and then came the attempt at
classical severity (so contrary to the French nature) which the
Republic affected.[71] Dress was adorned with embroidered spots and
Etruscan borders, and the ladies wore diadems, and tried to be as like
as possible to the Greek women painted in fictile art. Napoleon
attempted a dress which was supposed to be Roman at his coronation.
Trophies were woven and embroidered, and the "honeysuckle," "key," and
"egg and anchor" patterns were everywhere. With the fall of the Empire
the classical taste collapsed, and the Egyptian, Greek, and Roman
furniture were handed over to hotels and lodging-houses. In most of
the palaces on the Continent an apartment is still to be seen,
furnished in this style. It was the necessary tribute of flattery to
the great conqueror, who in that character inhabited so many of them
for a short time. But there was no sign of the style being taken up
enthusiastically anywhere out of France.
After the fall of the Empire, all pretence of style was in abeyance,
and it was then gradually replaced by a general craving for the
"antique," the "rococo," and finally the "baroc," as the outcome of
that part of a gentleman's education called the "grand tour." Every
one bought up old furniture; Italy and Spain were ransacked; and
foreign works of all ages were added to the hereditary house
furnishings. Every wealthy home became a museum. Now the numerous
exhibitions of the last few years, bringing together the works of all
Europe and other continents, have enabled us to continue to collect
and compare and furnish, without any reference to a particular style.
Meantime "Young England" had become æsthetic. Bohemianism was the
fashion, and the studio had to be furnished as a picturesque
lounge:--ragged tapestries for backgrounds; antique chairs and bits of
colour as cushions and draperies; shiny earthenware pots to hold a
flower and to catch a high light. All these bridged the space between
the new æstheticism and the old family museums; and from their
combination arose the style called by courtesy the "Queen Anne"--a
style which can be brought within the reach of the most moderate
fortunes. In humble mansions you will be aware of the grouping of the
old pieces of furniture, culminating perhaps in "my grandmother's
cabinet," and her portrait by Hogarth; or "my great-grandfather's
sword and pistols, which he carried at Culloden;" and his father's
clock, a relic perhaps of the Scotch Dutch.
The English style of to-day is really a conglomerate of the preceding
two hundred years, and it is formed from the débris of our family
life. It belongs mostly to the period of the pigtail; but it
stretches back, and includes all that followed the Protectorate, and
is therefore coeval with the wig. The name of "Queen Anne" would
really do as well as any other, only that the style of her reign,
which was heavy Louis Quatorze, is looked upon with suspicion, and
never admitted for imitation. The "Nineteenth Century" would be a
better name, for it has formed itself only within the last thirty
years, in the very heart of the century, and is, in fact, a fortunate
result of preceding conditions. It owes its existence, as I have said,
partly to the archæological tendencies of the day.
The maimed tables and chairs, which had painfully ascended from saloon
to bedroom, nursery, and attic, till they reposed in the garret (the
Bedlam of crazy furniture), now have descended in all the prestige of
antiquarian and family interest. Their history is recorded; the old
embroideries are restored, named, and honoured. What is not beautiful,
is credited with being "quaint"--the "quaint" is more easily imitated
than the beautiful; and we have elected this for the characteristic of
our new decorations. To be quaint, is really to be funny without
intending it, and its claim to prettiness is its _naïveté_, which is
sometimes touching as well as amusing: this was the special
characteristic of the revival in the Middle Ages. To imitate
quaintness must be a mistake in art; as in life it is absurd to
imitate innocence.
The nineteenth century "Queen Anne" has its merits.[72] It combines
simplicity, roominess and comfort, colour, light and shade. Soft
colouring to harmonize the new furniture with the tender tints of the
faded quaintnesses just restored to society; care in grouping even the
commonest objects, so as to give pleasure to the eye; a revived taste
for embroidered instead of woven materials, giving scope to the
talents of the women of the house;--all these are so much gained in
every-day domestic decoration. The poorest and most trivial
arrangements are striving to attain to a something artistic and
agreeable. This is still confined to the educated classes; but as good
and bad alike have to begin on the surface, and gradually filter
through to the dregs of society, we may hope that the women who wore
the last chignon and the last crinoline may yet solace their sordid
lives in flowing or tight woollen garments, adorned with their own
needlework; and that the dark-stained floor of the cottage or humble
lodging will set off the shining brass kettle, and the flower in a
brown or blue pot, consciously selected with a view to the
picturesque, and enjoyed accordingly.
From what we know, it would seem that a vital change in a national
style is never produced by the inspiration of one individual genius or
great original inventor. It invariably evolves itself slowly, by the
patient, persistent efforts of generations, polishing and touching up
the same motive, and at last reaching human perfection.
The annihilation of a style is oftenest caused by war passing over the
land, or revolution breaking up the fountains of social life, and
swamping the art and the artist.
But another cause of such an extinction--perhaps the saddest--is that
having reached perfection as far as it may, it deteriorates, sickens,
corrupts, and finally is thrown aside--superseded, hidden, and
overlapped by a newer fashion; and the worst and latest effort
discredits in the eyes of men, the splendid successes that preceded
its fall. Though the next succeeding phase may be less worthy to live
than the last, yet, carrying with it the freshness of a new spring, it
is acceptable for the time being.
The moral I should draw from this is, that you cannot force style; you
may prune, direct, and polish it, but you must accept that of your
day, and only in accordance with that taste can your work be useful.
Not accepting it idly or wearily, but cheerfully, on principle,
seeking to raise it; refusing by word or deed to truckle to the false,
the base, or the lawless in your art, or to act against the
acknowledged canons of good taste. Not for a moment should ambition be
checked, but it should always be accompanied by the grace of modesty.
To the young decorator or artist who feels the glow of original design
prompting him to reject old lines, and follow his own new and perhaps
crude ideas, a few words of warning, and encouragement also, may be of
use.
In art, as in poetry, we may recognize the Psalmist's experience: "My
heart burned within me, and at the last I spake with my tongue."
In small as in great things, crude ideas should not be brought to the
front. No one should give his thoughts to the world till his heart has
_burned_ within him, and he has been _forced_ to express himself.
Another wise saying, "Read yourself full, and then write yourself
empty," also applies to art. Knowledge must first be accumulated
before you can originate.
Wait till your experience and your thoughts insist on expression;
then subject the expressed idea to cultivated criticism, and profit by
the opinion you would respect if another's work, and not your own,
were under discussion.
It is true that taste is surprisingly various. Some will dislike your
design, because its style is a reflection of the Gothic; another may
be objected to as being frivolously Oriental-looking and brilliant,
whereas the critic likes only the sober and the dull. Few are
sufficiently educated to appreciate style: and we cannot rule our own
by anybody's opinion; but we can generalize and find something that
shall be agreeable to all--something approaching to a golden mean. The
artist for decoration should be sensitively alive to any suggestion
from the style of that which he is to adorn, remembering the
antecedent motives of its form, its history, and its date. He should
try to make his new work harmonize with the old; but of one thing he
may be certain--unless he absolutely copies an old design, his own
will carry the visible and unmistakable stamp of his day.
Even while suggesting copies this difficulty arises--how can a perfect
facsimile be obtained? No reproduction is ever really exact, unless
cast off by the hundred, stamped or printed by a machine.
It has been said that the translator of a poem adds to, or takes from
the original, that which he has or has not of the same poetical power;
and in art the copy requires the same qualities to guide the hand that
transmits the original motive to another material. An artist usually
carries out his own ideas from the first sketch blocked out on the
canvas, or scribbled on the bit of waste paper, to the last finishing
touch. It is, as far as it can be in human art, the visible transcript
of his own thought. In needlework this can hardly ever be. The
designer, whether he be St. Dunstan, Pollaiolo, Torrigiano, or Walter
Crane, only executes a drawing which leaves his hands for good, and is
translated into embroidery by the patient needlewoman who simply fills
in an outline, ignorant of art, unappreciative of its subtleties, and
incapable of giving life and expression, even when she is aware that
they are indicated in the original design. This is almost always the
case; but there are exceptions. Charlemagne's dalmatic, for instance,
shows signs of having been either the work of the artist himself, or
else carried out under his immediate supervision.
FOOTNOTES:
[15] Boyd Dawkins' "Early Man in Britain," p. 285. See
also chapter on stitches (_post_), p. 195.
[16] Some of these styles survive; some are still
perceptible as traditions or echoes; some have totally
disappeared in our modern art, such as the Primitive or
the Egyptian.
[17] See Semper, "Der Stil."
[18] The history of Gaul begins in the 7th, and that of
Britain in the 1st century B.C., while the civilization
of Egypt dates back to more than 4000 B.C.; therefore
the historical overlap is very great. It is probable
that a large portion of Europe was in its neolithic age,
while the scribes were composing their records of war
and commerce in the great cities on the Nile, and that
the neolithic civilization lingered in remote regions
while the voice of Pericles was heard in Athens, and the
name of Hannibal was a terror in Italy.--See Boyd
Dawkins' "Early Man in Britain," p. 481.
[19] See chapter on patterns.
[20] In the Troad.
[21] Some of the Egyptian arts we know are pre-Homeric
(if Homer really sang 800 B.C.), and Asiatic art was
then in its highest development.
[22] See chapter on stitches, cut work (_post_). This
funeral tent is a monumental work, inasmuch as the
inscription inwrought on it gives us the name and title
of her in whose honour it was made, and whose remains it
covered. See Villiers Stewart's "Funeral Tent of an
Egyptian Queen."
[23] Herodotus, book ii. c. 182; book iii. c. 47
(Rawlinson's Trans.). See Rock's Introduction, p. xiv.
[24] Homer mentions "Sidonian stuffs and Phœnician
skill" (Iliad, v. 170); also "Sidonian Embroidery."
Ibid. vi. 287-295.
[25] The Assyrian designs are such as are now still
worked at Benares, and being full of animals, they are
called Shikurgah, or "happy hunting-grounds." See Sir G.
Birdwood's "Industrial Arts of India," p. 236. See also
Plate 4.
[26] See Perrot and Chipiez (pp. 737-757); also Clermont
Ganneau's Histoire de l'Art, "L'Imagerie Phénicienne,"
Plate 1, pt. 1. Coupe de Palestrina. He says that
certain scenes from the "Shield of Achilles" are
literally to be found on Phœnician vases that have
come down to us--vases of which Homer himself must have
seen some of analogous design.
[27] Homer speaks of Sidonian embroideries, "Iliad,"
vi., 287-295.
[28] See Egyptian fragments in the British Museum, and
the specimens of Peruvian textiles; and Reiss and
Stübel's "Necropolis of Ancon in Peru."
[29] At Cervetri, Dennis' "Etruria," ed. 1878, i. p.
268.
[30] The restless activity of the Phœnicians has
often helped to confuse our æsthetic knowledge, and has
caused the waste of much speculation in ascertaining how
certain objects of luxury, belonging to distant
civilizations, can possibly have arrived at the places
where we find them.
[31] "The Beautiful Gate of the Temple was covered all
over with gold. It had also golden vines above it, from
which hung clusters of grapes as tall as a man's
height.... It had golden doors of 55 cubits altitude,
and 16 in breadth: but before these doors there was a
veil of equal largeness with the doors. It was a
Babylonian curtain of blue, fine linen, and scarlet and
purple; of an admixture that was truly wonderful. Nor
was the mixture without its mystical interpretation; but
was a kind of image of the universe. For by the scarlet
was to be enigmatically signified fire; by the fine
flax, the earth; by the blue, the air, and by the
purple, the sea;--two of them having their colours for
the foundation of this resemblance; but the fine flax
and the purple have their own origin for this
foundation, the earth producing the one, and the sea the
other. This curtain had also embroidered upon it all
that was mystical in the heavens excepting the twelve
signs of the zodiac, representing living creatures."
Josephus (Trans. by Whiston), p. 895.
[32] See also M. E. Harkness and Stuart Poole, "Assyrian
Life and History," p. 66.
[33] The visions of Ezekiel and St. John remind us of
the composite figures and animals in Ninevite
sculptures, and the prophetic poetry helps us to
interpret their symbolism.
[34] G. Smith's "Ancient History of the Monuments,"
Babylonia, p. 33. Edited by Sayce.
[35] In the British Museum. See "Bronze Ornaments of
Palace Gates, Balawat," pl. E 5.
[36] See Auberville's "Ornement des Tissus," pl. 1.
[37] The Egyptian queen in question was mother-in-law to
Shishak, whose daughter married Solomon. After his
son-in-law's death, Shishak plundered the "King's
House," and carried to Egypt the golden shields or
panels (1 Kings xiv. 26). The golden vessels went to
Babylon later, and the golden candlesticks to Rome.
[38] Sir G. Birdwood repeatedly points out that the
Vedic was the art that worshipped and served nature. The
Puranic is the ideal and distorted. The Moguls, about
700 B.C., introduced their ugly Dravidian art. Through
the Sassanian art of Persia, that of India was
influenced. Possibly the very forms which in India are
copied from Assyrian temples and palaces, may have
travelled first to Assyria upon Indian stuffs and
jewellery (Sir G. Birdwood's "Industrial Arts of India,"
i. p. 236).
[39] Ibid., p. 130 (ed. 1884).
[40] Nearchus (Strabo, XV. i. 67) says that the people
of India had such a genius for imitation that they
counterfeited sponges, which they saw used by the
Macedonians, and produced perfect imitations of the real
object. See Sir G. Birdwood's "Industrial Arts of
India," ii. p. 133 (ed. 1884).
[41] Ibid., ii. p. 131 (ed. 1884).
[42] See Sir G. Birdwood, p. 129 (ed. 1884). If
Fergusson is right in suggesting that the art of Central
America was planted there in the third or fourth century
of our era, it would, perhaps, appear to have taken
refuge in America when it was driven out of India by the
Sassanians, and was really Dravidian. He gives to the
Turanian races all the mound buildings, as well as the
fylfot or mystic cross, and he looks in Central India
for the discovery of some remains that will give us the
secret of the origin of the Indo-Aryan style. He thinks
the Archaic Dravidian is allied with the Chinese. See
Fergusson's "Architecture."
[43] Etruscan and Indian golden ornaments, including the
"Bolla" and the "Trichinopoly" chains and coral, are to
be found throughout Scandinavia and in Ireland. See
"Atlas de l'Archéologie du Nord," par la Société Royale
des Antiquaires du Nord. Copenhagen, 1857.
[44] Arrian tells us of the Celts, "a people near the
Great Ionian Bay," who sent an embassy to Alexander
before the battle of the Granicus--"a people strong and
of a haughty spirit." Alexander asked them if they
feared anything. They answered that they feared the "sky
might fall upon their heads." He dismissed them,
observing that the Celts were an arrogant nation
(Arrian, i. 4, 10).
[45] According to Yates, the merchandise of Eastern Asia
passed through Slavonia to the north of Europe in the
Middle Ages, without the intervention of Greece or
Italy. This may account for certain terms of
nomenclature which evidently came with goods transported
straight to the north. Yates' "Textrinum Antiquorum,"
vol. i. p. 225-246.
[46] These northern ideas, spreading over Germany,
England, and France, flourished especially on German
soil; and Oriental-patterned embroideries for hangings
and dress were worked in every stitch, on every
material, as may be seen in the museums and printed
catalogues of Vienna, Berlin, Munich, &c.
[47] Except, perhaps, the Serpent and Tree cope in
Bock's Kleinodien.
[48] The different Celtic nationalities are always
recognizable. There was found in a grave-mound at Hof,
in Norway, a brooch, showing at a glance that it was
Christian and Celtic, though taken from the grave of a
pagan Viking. Another at Berdal, in Norway, was at once
recognized by M. Lorange as being undoubtedly Irish.
There are many other instances of evident Celtic
Christian art found on the west coast of Norway under
similar conditions--probably spoil from the British
Islands, which were subject to the descents of the pagan
Vikings for centuries after the time of St. Columba's
preaching of Christianity in Scotland. For information
on the subject, see G. Stephen's "Monuments of Runic
Art," and F. Anderson's "Pagan Art in Scotland."
[49] "Scotland in Pagan Times," by J. Anderson, pp. 3-7.
[50] On a vase in the British Museum, Minerva appears
with her ægis on her breast, and clothed in a petticoat
and upper tunic worked in sprays, and a border of
kneeling lions. On another Panathenaic vase she has a
gown bordered with fighting men, evidently the sacred
peplos. (Fig. 4.)
[51] See the account of the veil of Herè in the Iliad,
and that of the mantle of Ulysses in the Odyssey.
[52] See Butcher and Lang's Odyssey.
[53] "Der Stil."
[54] The Greeks collected into one focus all that they
found of beauty in art from many distant
sources--Egyptian, Indian, Assyrian--and thus fired
their inborn genius, which thenceforth radiated its
splendour over the whole civilized world.
[55] Homer's Iliad, xviii. 480-617 (Butcher and Lang).
[56] See "Woltmann and Woermann." Trans. Sidney Colvin,
p. 64.
[57] Except, perhaps, the keystone arch.
[58] Virg. Æneid iii. Trans. G.L.G.
[59] The Indian Cush.
[60] Except in the art of the Celts, whose Indo-Chinese
style shows evidence of Mongolian importation, and later
we find traces of a similar influence: for instance,
"Yarkand rugs are semi-Chinese, semi-Tartar, resembling
also the works of India and Persia. It is easy to
distinguish from what source each comes, as one
perceives the influence of the neighbouring native art"
("On Japan," by Dresser, p. 322).
[61] See a paper by M. Terrien de la Couperie in the
Journal of the Society of Arts, 1881.
[62] "Rome had to be overthrown that the new religion
and the new civilization might be established.
Christianity did its work in winning to it those
Teutonic conquerors, but how vast was the cost to the
world, occasioned by the necessity of casting into the
boiling cauldron of barbarous warfare, that noble
civilization and the treasures which Rome had gathered
in the spoil of a conquered universe! Had any old Roman,
or Christian father been gifted with Jeremiah's
prescience, he might have seen the fire blazing amidst
the forests of Germany, and the cauldron settling down
with its mouth turned towards the south, and would have
uttered his lamentation in plaintive tones, such as
Jeremiah's, and in the same melancholy key" ("Holy
Bible," with Commentary by Canon Cook, Introduction to
Jeremiah, vol. i. p. 319).
[63] Scandinavian art became strongly tinctured with
that of Byzantium. The Varangian Guards were, probably,
answerable for this, by their intercourse between Greece
and their native land, which lasted so many centuries.
There have come down to us, as witnesses of this
intercourse, many coins and much jewellery, in which all
that is Oriental in its style has been leavened by its
passage through Byzantine and Romanesque channels.
Gibbon, writing of this period, says: "The habits of
pilgrimage and piracy had approximated the countries of
the earth" (see Gibbon's "Decline and Fall," chap. lv.).
Greek embroidered patterns and Greek forms of dress
still linger in Iceland. There was lately brought to
England a bride's dress, which might have belonged to
the Greek wife of a Varangian guardsman. It is
embroidered with a border in gold of the classical
honeysuckle pattern; and the bridal wreath of gilt metal
flowers might, from its style, be supposed to have been
taken from a Greek tomb.
[64] Evidently an imitation of the peplos of Minerva
(see fig. 4, p. 32).
[65] The descent from the Persian of Arab or Moorish
art, as we generally call it when speaking of its
Spanish development, is to be accounted for by the
presence of a considerable colony of Persians in Spain
in the time of the Moors, as attested by numerous
documents still in existence. See Col. Murdoch Smith's
"Preface to Persian Art," Series of Art Handbooks of the
Kensington Museum.
[66] Ronsard, poet, politician, and diplomatist,
compares the Queen of Navarre to Pallas Athene:--
"Elle adonnait son courage
A mainte bel ouvrage
Dessus la toile, et encor
A joindre la soie et l'or.
Vous d'un pareil exercise
Mariez par artifice
Dessus la toile en mainte traits
L'or et la soie en pourtraict."
[67] Mary de Medici brought back with her from Italy
Federigo Vinciolo as her designer for embroideries.
[68] See "Art Needlework," by E. Maxse, and "Manuel de
la Broderie," by Madame E. F. Celnart.
[69] From the Italian translation by Signor Minghetti.
[70] Gaston, Duke of Orleans (died 1660), kept hothouses
on purpose to supply models for floral textile designs.
Le Brun often drew the embroideries for the hangings in
rooms he had himself designed and decorated.
[71] We have all seen the dining-room wine-coolers
modelled in imitation of Roman tombs; and there is a
drawing-room in a splendid mansion still furnished with
cinerary urns covering the walls, while curule chairs
most uncomfortably furnish the seats.
[72] In his designs for papers and textiles, Mr. Morris'
poetical and artistic feeling--his admiration and
sensitiveness for all that is beautiful and graceful (as
well as quaint)--his respect for precedent, added to his
own fanciful originality,--have given a colour and seal
to the whole decorative art of England of to-day. It is
a step towards a new school. The sobriety and tenderness
of his colouring gives a sense of harmony, and
reconciles us to his repetitions of large vegetable
forms, which remind us sometimes of a kitchen-garden in
a tornado. For domestic decoration we should, as far as
possible, adhere to reposing forms and colours. Our
flowers should lie in their allotted spaces, quiet and
undisturbed by elemental struggles, which have no
business in our windowed and glass-protected rooms.
CHAPTER II.
DESIGN.
_Gorgo._ Behold these 'broideries! Finer saw you never.
_Praxinoè._ Ye gods! What artists work'd these pictures in?
What kind of painter could these clear lines limn?
How true they stand! nay, lifelike, moving ever;
Not worked--_created!_ Woman, thou art clever!
(Scene at a Festival) _Theocritus_, Idyll xv. line 78.
The word design, as applied to needlework, includes the principles and
laws of the art: the motives and their hereditary outcome; the art
creating the principles; the laws controlling the art.
Design means intention, motive, and should as such be applied to the
smallest as to the greatest efforts of art. That which results from
it, either as picture or pattern, is a record of the thoughts which
produced it, and by its style fixes the date, of its production.
I will first consider the principles of design, and afterwards, in
another chapter, inquire into the origin of patterns; investigating
their motives, and using them as examples, and also as warnings.
The individual genius of the artist works first in design, though his
work is for the use of the craftsman or artisan, his collaborator; for
the two, head and hands, must work together, or else will render each
other inoperative or ineffective.
The artisan, by right of his title, claims a part in the art itself;
the craftsman, by his name, points out that he, too, has to work out
the craft, the mystery, the inner meaning, of the design or intention.
The designer himself is subject to the prejudices called the taste of
his day. He is necessarily under the influence which that taste has
imposed upon him, and from which no spontaneous efforts of genius can
entirely emancipate him. Whether he is conceiving a temple for the
worship of a national faith, or the edging for the robe of a fair
votaress, or the pattern on the border of a cup of gold or brass, he
cannot avoid the force of tradition and of custom, which comes from
afar, weighted with the power of long descent, and which crushes
individuality, unless it is of the most robust nature.
Of very early design we have most curious and mysterious glimpses. The
cave man was an artist. The few scratches on a bone, cleverly showing
the forms of a dog or a stag, a whale or a seal, nay, the figure of a
man, have enabled us to ascertain and to classify the Palæolithic cave
man; from whom his less civilized successor, the Neolithic man, may be
distinguished by his absence of all animal design.[73]
These fragmentary scraps of information, pieced together only in these
later years, teach us the value of very small facts which time and
care are now accumulating, and which, being the remains of lives and
nations passed away, still serve as the soil in which history can be
fertilized.
We have no means of judging whether the cave man was an artist on a
greater or more advanced scale than is actually shown by the
bone-scratchings; the only other relic of his handiwork is the
needle.[74]
It is evident that a direct imitation of nature, such as is seen in
these "graffiti," and at an immense distance in advance of them, in
the earliest known Egyptian sculptures, preceded all conventional art.
Some of the earliest portrait statues in the Museum at Boulac exhibit
a high degree of naturalistic design before it became subservient to
the expression of the faith of the people. As soon as art was found to
be the fittest conveyance of symbolism, it became the consecrated
medium for transmitting language, thought, and history, and was
reduced to forms in which it was contented to remain petrified for
many centuries, entirely foregoing the study or imitation of
nature.[75] It recorded customs, historical events, and religious
beliefs; receiving from the last the impress of the unchangeable and
the absolute, which it gave to the other subjects on which it touched.
It ceased to be a creative art (if it had ever aspired to such a
function), and was never the embodiment of individual thought. This
phase prevailed under different manifestations in Assyria and China.
Pictorial art had, in fact, become merely the nursing mother of the
alphabet, guiding its first steps--the hieroglyphic delineation or
expression of thoughts and facts.[76]
In Egypt, the change from the first period of actual imitation of
nature was succeeded by many centuries of the very slowest progress.
Renouf speaks,[77] however, of "the astonishing identity that is
visible through all the periods of Egyptian art" (for you could never
mistake anything Egyptian for the produce of any other country). "This
identity and slow movement," he says, "are not inconsistent with an
immense amount of change, which must exist if there is any real life."
In fact, there were periods of relative progress, repose, and decay,
and every age had its peculiar character. Birch, Lepsius, or Marriette
could at once tell you the age of a statue, inscription, or
manuscript, by the characteristic signs which actually fix[78] the
date.
Design, unconsciously has a slowly altering and persistently onward
movement, which but seldom repeats itself. It is one of the most
remarkable instances of evolution. But it also has its cataclysms
(however we may account for them), of which the Greek apotheosis of
all art is a shining example, and the total disappearance of classical
influence in Europe before the Renaissance is another.
I will instance one prevailing habit of Egyptian art.[79] In the long
processional subjects, and in individual separate figures, it was
usual to draw the head in perfect profile, the body facing you, but
not completely--a sort of compromise with a three-quarter view of
it--and the feet following each other, on the same line as the
profile. This mode of representing the human figure was only effaced
gradually by the introduction of Greek art, and continued to be the
conventional and decorative method even in the latest days of Egyptian
art; and it is curious to observe, that in the Dark ages European
design fell into the same habit. We cannot imagine that this distorted
way of drawing the human figure could have any intentional meaning,
and therefore may simply believe that it had become a custom; and that
when art has so stiffened and consolidated itself by precedent and
long tradition, as in Egypt and in India, certain errors as well as
certain truths become, as it were, ingrained into it. Plato remarked
of Egyptian art, that "the pictures and statues they made ten thousand
years ago were in no particular better than those they make now."[80]
One day, however, the Greek broke away from the ancient bonds of
custom. The body was made to accompany the head, and the feet followed
suit. But the strange fact remains that for several thousand years men
walked in profile, all out of drawing. Evidently originality was not
in much estimation among the Egyptian patrons of art. Design seemed to
have restricted itself to effective adaptations in a few permitted
forms in architecture and painting, and the illumination of the
papyrus MSS.
Egyptian elasticity of design found some scope in its domestic
ornamentation, in jewellery and hangings, but especially in its
embroideries for dress. Here much ingenuity was shown, and the
patterns on walls and the ceilings of tombs give us the designs which
Semper considers as having been originally intended for textile
purposes. He strains to a point to which I can hardly follow him, the
theory that all decorations were originally textile (except such as
proceeded in China from the lattice-work motive); though I willingly
accept the idea that textile decoration was one of the first and most
active promoters of design.
It is not possible for us to trace systematically the different points
at which Egyptian and Asiatic art touch, but we can see that they were
always acting and reacting on each other in the later centuries before
our era, and that Greece profited by them. The first efforts of both
to break through this chrysalis stage, resulted in the early Greek
archaic style. Its strongly marked, muscular humanity reminds one of
all the conflicting impressions struggling in the conception of the
great artist who first embodied them. They appear to be breaking out
from the trammels of Egyptian and Assyrian styles, which by meeting
had engendered life; and Greek art was the child of their union. Then
art, having shaken off symbolism as its only purpose, and seeking to
represent the forms of men, yet possessed by a guiding spirit, first
sought to convey the idea of expression. The worship of humanity,
mingling with that of their gods, produced the Heroic ideal; and all
the attributes of their heroes--majesty, beauty, grace, and
passion--had to be depicted; as well as rage, sorrow, despair, and
revenge. These were soon to be surrounded with all the splendours of
the arts of decoration.
Greece had prepared for this outburst of excellence and the perfect
science of art, by collecting the traditions, the symbols, the
experience in colouring, and the knowledge of beautiful forms, human
and ideal. All that was needed for the advent of the man who could
design and create types of beauty for all ages was thus accumulated,
and the man came, and his name was Pheidias. A crowd followed him, all
steeped in the same flood of poetry and art; and for several
centuries they filled the world with the sense and science of beauty.
Then the function of the designer--the artist--was changed and
elevated, and he became, through the great days of Greek and Roman
Pagan art, and afterwards through the rise of that of Christianity,
the exponent of all that was poetical and ennobling in the life of
man.
But though the Greek artist had broken the chains of prescribed form,
he still adhered to the "motive"--the inner symbolical thought--and
strove to express it as it had never been expressed before.[81] New
principles were evoked, and the artist, while revelling in the
"sweetness and light" of freedom, framed for himself standards of
taste and refinement, which he left as a heritage to all succeeding
generations.
I fear that I am repeating a platitude when insisting that freedom in
all design, but especially that employed in decoration, must be kept
within certain boundaries; otherwise it becomes lawless. Rules, like
all other controlling circumstances, are of the greatest service to
the artist, as they suggest what he can do, as well as decide what he
ought not to attempt. All boundaries are highly suggestive; the size
of a sheet of paper--the form of a panel--the colours in the box of
pigments--even the touch of the brush which comes to hand,--all these
help to shape the idea to our ends, and assist us in giving to the
original motive the form which is most suitable. These restrictions
are often regarded as impediments by the impatient artist; whereas he
ought to look on them as hints and suggestions, and claim their
assistance, instead of struggling against them. Let us accept the
principle that it is good for each of our efforts at decoration that
we are controlled by the space allotted to its composition. The
relative size (small, perhaps, for a table-cover, but large for that
of a book) and the shape to which we are limited, alter all the
conditions of a design. Whether it is square or oblong, or lengthened
into a frieze; whether it must be divided into parts, including more
than one motive, or be grouped round one centre; whether it is to be
repeated more than once within the range of the eye, or whether it is
to disappear into space upwards or horizontally; and whether it is to
stand alone, or be framed with lines or a border,--all these
restrictions must govern the design, or, in its highest phase, the
composition.
The composition must consist of supporting lines well balanced, and
"values" filling up the whole surface of the space, which is to
contain it, and beyond which it must not seek to extend. As we have in
embroidery no distances--only a foreground--the design must be placed
all on one plane. The title of "composition" cannot be granted to a
bouquet or a bird cast on one corner of a square of linen, however
gracefully it may be drawn. It does not cover the space allotted to
it.
If we carefully study the great and guiding principles that have been
distinctly formulated by some of the Continental authorities on
decorative art, we shall find much help in composing our designs.
Nothing is more interesting than to search for the foundation of the
structure which centuries have helped to raise, and to dig out, as it
were, the original plan or thought of the founder. So it is most
instructive to learn the fundamental rules by which such results are
secured.
M. Blanc[82] says of the general laws of ornamentation: "There can be
no nobler satisfaction to the mind, than to be able to unravel what is
beyond measure complicated, to diminish what is apparently immense,
and to reduce to a few clear points what has been till now involved in
a haze of obscurity. Just as the twenty-six letters of the alphabet
have been, and always will be sufficient to form the expression of the
words necessary for all human thought, so certain elements susceptible
of combination among themselves have sufficed, and will suffice, to
create ornament, whose variety may be indefinitely multiplied."
He reduces ornamental design to five principles, Repetition,
Alternation, Symmetry, Progression, and Confusion.
[Illustration: Fig. 5.
Wave Pattern.]
First, Repetition. "You may act on the mind, through sight, by the
same means as those that will excite physical sensations. A single
prick of a pin is nothing, but a hundred such will be intolerably
painful. Repetition produces pleasurable sensations, as well as
painful ones." An insignificant form can become interesting by
repetition, and by the suggestion which, singly, it could not
originate. For example, the rolling of the Greek scroll or wave
pattern awakens in us the idea of one object following another. "It
also suggests the waves of the ocean; or the poet may see in it a
troop of maidens pursuing each other in space, not frivolously, but in
cadence, as if executing a mystic dance." Change the curves into
angular forms, as making the key pattern, and it will no longer flow,
but become as severe as the other was graceful. No principle gives
greater pleasure than repetition, and next to it, _alternation_.
[Illustration: Fig. 6.
Key Pattern.]
Variety is here added to the law of repetition. "There can be
repetition without alternation, but no alternation without
repetition." Alternation is, then, a succession of two objects
recurring regularly in turn; and the cadence of appearance and
disappearance gives pleasure to the senses, whether it be addressed to
taste, hearing, or sight. Alternate rhymes, and even short and long
lines, soothe the ear in verse. In form, the alternations are the more
agreeable, the more they differ. Such are, in architecture, a
succession of metopes and triglyphs on a Doric frieze, where the
circle and the straight lines relieve each other.
[Illustration: Fig. 7.
Metopes and Triglyphs.]
Symmetry. The correspondence of two parts opposite to each other is
symmetrical. "A living being, man or animal, is composed of two parts,
which appear to have been united down one central line. Without being
identical, if you folded them down the line, they would overlap and
perfectly cover each other. Man is born with the sense of symmetry, to
match his outward form; and he appreciates its existence, and
instinctively feels the want of it. Symmetry is another word for
justness of proportion. The Greeks understood by symmetry, the
condition of a body of which the members have a common measure among
themselves. We expect the two sides of a living being to correspond,
and we look for these proportions in the living body to balance each
other, which we do not expect to find in any other natural object. A
large leaf at the end of a slender stem may be as appropriate, and
give as much pleasure, as a small leaf in the same position; but a
huge hand at the end of an arm is not so agreeable to our sense of
symmetry as one of the size and outline which we naturally expect to
see.
"The mind of man expects to find, outside of himself and his own
proportions, something which he feels is proportionate and
symmetrical; in fact, he at once detects the want of it. The Japanese,
with delicacy and taste, often substitute for symmetry its
corollary--balance. The Chinese or Japanese vase will often have an
appreciable affinity and resemblance to a Greek one, each preserving a
secret balance, even in the extremest whimsicality of its composition.
Proportion is another corollary to symmetry, if it is not another word
for some of its qualities."
"Progression. In this principle are included long perspectives,
pyramidal forms in architecture, and certain processional
compositions."
"For pyramidal surfaces, such as pediments, a progressive ornament is
the fittest. All the buildings in the East, and in the ancient cities
of Central America, which are raised on pyramids of steps, show the
tendency to this species of effect in giving dignity to the buildings
placed on such platforms."
"Perspectives are highly attractive specimens of progression, which,
when made use of in the decorations of a theatre, produce delightful
illusions."
M. Blanc quotes Bernardin de St. Pierre, who says: "When the
branches of a plant are disposed in a uniform plan of diminishing
size, as in the pyramidal shape of a pine, there is progression; and
if these trees be planted in long avenues, diminishing in height and
colour, as each tree does in itself, our pleasure is redoubled,
because progression here becomes infinite. It is owing to this
feeling of infinity that we take pleasure in looking at anything that
presents progression, such as nurseries in different stages of
growth, the slopes of hills retreating to the horizon at different
levels--interminable perspectives."
All floral compositions which give the effect or impression of growth
may be included in the progressive principle. A composition which,
beginning as it were with a stem, spreads and floreates equally on
each side; thrusting outwards and upwards, and ending in a topmost
twig or bud, is governed by this principle.
Confusion. Boileau is quoted by M. Blanc as saying, "A fine disorder
is often the effect of art;" and he adds, "But before he said it,
nature had shown it." Here we must observe that the confusions or
disorders of nature are all subject to certain laws; and it is in
adopting this idea, that an artistic confusion may give us the sense
of its being ordered by, and subject to definite rules. These rules
act as the frame affects the picture, circumscribing its
irregularities, and restricting them to a certain area. "The
artist-painter is, in a small space, permitted to employ confusion,
because the art of the cabinet-maker will keep the geometrical effect
in view." When the Japanese throw their ornaments, apparently without
rule, here and there on the japanned box, they reckon on the square
shape being sufficiently marked to the eye by its shining surface and
sharp corners.
The confusion in a Japanese landscape is so beautiful that one
appreciates the innate sense of balance, which modifies the
confusion--rules and orders it.
"In the hands of the designer, confusion is only a method of rendering
order visible in a happy disorder. Here contraries meet and touch....
Admit these as the principles of all decoration, and you will find
that, by following and combining them, you may produce varieties as
numberless as the sands of the sea, and that a latent equilibrium will
reduce nearly every complication and confusion to perfect harmony."
Each of the five principles we have discussed has its corollary, which
adds to the resources of the decorative artist. These are as
follows:--To Repetition belongs harmony, or consonance; to
Alternation, contrast; to Symmetry, radiation; to Progression,
gradation; to balanced Confusion, deliberate complication.[83]
_Harmonies_ in form and in colour are produced in different
ways--sometimes by repetition with variation; sometimes by the
different parts being rather reflected on each than repeated. This
explains the harmony that may be called consonance, if I rightly
understand M. Blanc's theory.
_Contrast_ is most generally understood as a common resource in the
hands of the artist for producing strong effects; but M. Blanc
cleverly expresses the reticence needed to ensure contrast being
pleasurable, not painful. "To adorn persons or things," he says, "is
not simply for the purpose of causing them to be conspicuous; it is
that they may be admired. It is not simply to draw attention to them,
but that they may be regarded with feelings of pleasure.... If
contrast be needed, let it be used as the means of rendering the whole
more powerful, brilliant, and striking. For instance, if orange is
intended to predominate in a decoration, let blue be mingled with it,
but sparingly. Let the complementary colour be its auxiliary, and not
its rival." Contrasts are always unpleasant, if the two forces
struggle with each other for pre-eminence, whether it be in form or in
colour. The rule to be observed in all ornamental design is this:
"that contrasting objects, instead of disturbing unity, should assist
it by giving most effect to that we wish to bring forward and
display."
_Radiation_ belongs to the principle of symmetry, starting from a
centre from which all lines diverge, and to which all lines point.
This is to be found throughout nature, from the rays of the sun to the
petals of the daisy. All decorative art employs and illustrates it.
"_Gradation_ in colour, as in form, is not quite synonymous with
progression, but expresses a series of adroitly managed transitions.
The English intermingle in their decoration, colours very finely
blended; nor do they find any transition too delicate. This, as in all
principles of ornament, has to be employed according to the feelings
intended to be produced on the mind of the spectator--whether for
absolute contrast or for imperceptible progression, when the tenderest
colours are needed."
_Complication_ is illustrated by M. Blanc, by a quotation from
"Ziegler."[84] "Complication is another aspect of the art which owns
the same sentiment as that expressed by Dædalus in his labyrinth,
Solomon in his mysterious seal, the Greeks in their interlacing and
winding ornaments, the Byzantines, the Moors, and the architects of
our cathedrals in their finest works. Intertwined mosaics, and
intersection of arches and ribs, all spring from complication."
To follow the interlacing line of an ornament, gives the mind the
pleasure of untying the Gordian knot, without cutting it. It gives the
excitement of curiosity, pursuit, and discovery. "When we see these
traceries so skilfully plaited, in which straight lines and curves
intermingle, cross, branch out, disappear and recur, we experience a
high pleasure in unravelling a puzzle which at first, perhaps,
appeared to be undecipherable; and in acknowledging that a latent
arrangement may be recognized in what at first, and at a distance,
seems an inextricable confusion." The Celtic, Moorish, and Gothic
styles illustrate and are explained by these remarks; and they are
well worthy the attention of the designer.
Having so freely borrowed from M. Blanc's chapter on the general laws
of ornamentation, I will finish my quotations with the words with
which he concludes: "There is no decoration in the works of nature or
the inventions of men which does not owe its birth to one of the
original principles here enumerated, viz. Repetition, Alternation,
Symmetry, Progression, and Balanced Confusion; or else to one of their
secondary causes, consonance, contrast, radiation, gradation, and
complication; or lastly, to a combination of these different elements,
which all finally lose themselves in a primordial cause--the origin of
the movements of the universe--ORDER."[85]
The extracts from M. Blanc's works I have carefully placed between
commas, being most anxious to express my obligation to him for his
carefully formulated epitome of the laws of design. But though I have
largely quoted, there remains still much most interesting and
suggestive matter, which I recommend the reader to seek in his book.
Though we should call to our aid the general laws of design for all
art, we must select from them what is specially appropriate for the
needs of our craft. From the art of needlework we should eliminate
as much as possible all ideas of _roundness_, all variety of surface
and effects of light and shadow and contrasting colours. Unity,
softness, grace, refinement, brightness, cheerfulness, pleasant
suggestions,--these should be the objects in view when we design the
panels for the drawing-room or boudoir, the hangings for the bed, or
the cover for the table--harmony which will satisfy the eye, thoughts
that shall please the mind.
The objects in nature that give us the most unalloyed pleasure--birds
and flowers--are those that from all time have served as the materials
for decorative design, and therefore have been moulded into the
traditional patterns which have descended to us from the earliest
times. Design must follow the scientific laws of art, and shape the
variations of traditional forms from which we cannot escape. In our
present search after these inner truths, I repeat that we have nothing
to do with the rules of painting, sculpture, and architecture, or any
other of the secondary arts, such as wood carving, metal work, &c.;
these having each their own intrinsic principles, which must be worked
out as corollaries from the general laws of composition which govern
all Aryan art.[86]
It is curious that in drawing on the flat, in ancient frescoes, there
appear to be no acknowledged rules of perspective--hardly more in
Pompeii, than on early Chinese screens and plates; or than later in
the Bayeux tapestries. And yet the Greeks, with their unerring
instinct, actually made use of false architectural perspectives to add
to the effects of height and depth in their colonnaded buildings.[87]
They sensibly diminished the circumference of the columns, and used
other means in their designs for this purpose. They understood the
principle, but they did not carry it into flat decorative art. They
did not attempt, when they painted a landscape on the wall, to do more
than recall the idea they were sketching; and never thought of vying
in scientific or naturalistic imitation with the real landscape they
saw through the window; they did not wish to interfere with the effect
of the statue, or the human figures grouped in front of it, to which
the wall served as a background. Those threw shadows and cast lights;
but in the flat there were no shadows, no perspective--all was
flat.[88] We must draw from this the deduction that the Greeks held
that flatness was an essential quality of wall decoration (except in
friezes) as well as of all textile ornament; and for every reason we
must accept this flatness as a general law for designs in embroidery.
In hangings and dress materials, flatness is more agreeable than a
complicated shaded design, especially when it is further confused by
folds, disturbing and interrupting the flow of the lines of the
pattern.
The reader will perceive that the laws of composition for textiles
quoted from M. Blanc, apply perfectly to designs on the flat, and to
outlined sketches in black and white, as well as to the most
elaborate compositions for pictures, either historical or "genre."
They are rules which should be understood and employed by the man who
draws for a wall-paper or an area railing; and certainly by him who
makes patterns for our schools of design.
It may therefore be laid down as a general rule, that all designs for
embroidery should be considered first as outlined drawings, covering a
flat surface, and then filled in with colour. The outlines should as
little as possible overlap one another, as flatness is one of the
first objects to be remembered; and this, of course, will be disturbed
by the parts passing over or under each other. Indian designs in
flowers have invariably a wonderful flatness, in the absence of all
light and shadow; joined to a naturalistic suggestion of detail, which
is accounted for by their traditional mode of copying from nature. The
branch or blossom to be copied, is laid on the ground and pegged down
with care, to eliminate every variety of surface, and every branch and
twig so arranged that they may not cross or touch each other. This
conventional composition is then drawn, and every natural distinction
in the form carefully copied. I would suggest that this idea should be
accepted as useful for imitation among ourselves in certain
conventional compositions of vegetable forms. Perhaps it is our Aryan
ancestry that has given us a prevailing taste for such decorations;
and it is worth while to consider how best to manipulate them.[89]
Clinging as we do to these floral designs, we can see that they are
the only ones that bear repetition, whether covering the surface of
the material in the rich irregularity of the flowers in a field, or
conventionalized into a form or a pattern.
The eye is never shocked or fatigued by such repetitions in orderly
confusion, or trained by the hand into artistic shapes or meanderings
of tracery. But when embroidery or weaving attempts to represent
animals or typical human figures, repetition immediately becomes
tiresome. A Madonna surrounded by angels, comes in badly, repeated
over and over again as a pattern, broken up by folds, cut up by a
seam, dislocated in the joining, and repeated in tiers. Such a design
is figured in Auberville's book.[90] The drawing is beautiful, but by
repetition it becomes ridiculous. I therefore deprecate this kind of
ornament in textile work. For this reason embroidery, which can be
fitted to each space that is to be covered, is preferable to woven
designs, however richly or perfectly they may be carried out.
Another class of design, which must be considered apart, is the
conventional-geometrical, of which the special distinction appears to
be that it consists of echoes or fragments of what we have seen
elsewhere. These conventional patterns are often merely the _detritus_
of past styles or motives crushed and placed by time in a sort of
kaleidoscope. They remind one of the little wreaths of broken shells
and coloured sea-weeds left on the sands by the retiring waves after a
storm, and are sometimes full of beauty and suggestion. (Pl. 17.) We
trace in these fragmentary patterns forgotten links with different
civilizations; and we ponder on the historical events which have
brought them into juxtaposition. These kaleidoscope patterns are to be
seen in Persian and Turkish carpets of the present day, and we find,
on examination, little bits which can only be the remnants of a
broken-up motive, probably as much lost now to the designer who
inherits the traditional form, as to us who can only see the vague
results.
I illustrate this remark by giving the border of a modern Persian
carpet which has certainly had Egyptian ancestry. The boat, the
beetle, and the prehistoric cross are to be found in it.
[Illustration: Fig. 8.
Persian Carpet.]
Many conventional patterns of to-day are descendants of the
lattice-work of Chinese art, and of the zigzags, lines, and discs of
barbarous primitive ornamentation.
The traceries in Indian stone windows show some of the most charming
geometrical forms, and are akin to the Persian and Russian modes of
composing conventional patterns. They appear on very ancient metal
work, and are the motives of all the embroideries in the Greek islands
and the principalities, and of the linen embroideries of Russia. Their
Byzantine origin gave its impress to the European schools of the
Middle Ages, and the pattern-books of Germany and Venice of the
sixteenth century are full of them. They are best suited for the
mosaic stitches, and, kept in their places as decoration, they are
useful for carpets and borders.
It should be impressed on our young artists, that, in composing their
designs, they must be influenced by the materials to be employed, and
the purpose for which the decoration is intended. Thus in textile
design for dress and hangings (excepting for tapestries) the fact must
never be lost sight of that they will be subject to disturbance by
crossing folds and crumplings, which will break up the lines of the
pattern. It is therefore evident that a design fitted for a rigid
material in a fixed place, such as an architectural decoration in
wood, stone, or stucco, must be subject to a treatment different from
that which befits an embroidered curtain or panel.
Stone and wood, being materials of uniform colour, require all the
help of recessed shadows and projections to catch the light; whereas
in textiles, form is assisted by colour, and smoothness of surface is
a primary consideration. The strongly accentuated design for
wood-carving becomes poor and lifeless when deprived of its essential
conditions and _raison d'être_, and the pattern which looks charming,
outlined and filled in with colour, could be hardly seen incised on a
flat stone surface. This seems a truism, but the neglect of these
plain axioms causes many mistakes in decorative art. Mr. Redgrave
says: "A design must be bad which applies the same treatment to
different materials." He further says: "The position of the ornament
requires special consideration. The varied quantities, bolder relief,
and coarser execution are not only allowable, but absolutely
necessary, at heights considerably above the eye. Moreover, each
fabric has its own peculiar lustre, texture, &c. Thus, in the use of
hangings, curtains, &c., the design might be suitable in silk, and
coarse or dull in woollen."[91]
Here I venture to differ from Mr. Redgrave. Perspective is as much to
be respected in decoration as in pictures, near to the eye; and the
gradation in size and colour, as the ornament travels up into height
or fades into distance, is a phase of pleasure which should not be
checked by enlargement of form or reinforcement of colouring.
It is hardly necessary to warn our artists against a sort of design
which is conventional, yet had its own meaning in the beginning. This
is to be found in Indian carvings and embroideries of a certain date,
or imitating the works of that distant period. It proceeded from a
hideous worship of monstrous Dravidian divinities. Their statues are
to be found, surrounded by coarsely designed patterns, in the temple
architecture of the first and second centuries. Its characteristics
are idols in niches or shrines, distorted in form or attitude; foliage
of unnatural, twisted plants, added to the recurring of the lotus and
tree of life; or animals destroying each other, or kneeling in worship
to the idols. These ugly designs are purely conventional. Fergusson
suggests that they were introduced into Mexico in the fourth or fifth
centuries A.D. by Buddhism.[92]
Those many-armed, sometimes many-faced divinities drove out the
beautiful Aryan types, which, however, resumed their sway when the
wave of the Renaissance flowed back to India, and was remodelled by
Oriental taste to the lovely designs we find in the Taj Mahal.
In M. Blanc's classification of ornament, he has placed Gothic design
under the head of deliberate complication. The whole of the Gothic
decorations, which are a gradual growth in one direction, arose from
the study of interlacing boughs and stems, employed as the enrichment
of the newly-grown forms of the vaulted roofs. The possibilities of
great size and height covered these designs and inspired all their
decoration; and the effect of reiteration and long recurring lines in
perspective was essentially the motive of these avenues in stone.[93]
Here enter the principles of repetition and progression, and you will
find how carefully the designers of the twelfth, thirteenth, and
fourteenth centuries worked up to these ideas. You will see in their
embroideries, shining figures or pictures in gold, silver, and
coloured silks, shimmering on dark velvet backgrounds, each design
terminating a perspective of architectural forms which enhances their
brilliancy. The most effective, probably, were generally employed for
the adornment of the high altar, so as to be seen from a great
distance. The smaller and less distinct and more delicate ornaments
were reserved for the side chapels or for smaller churches, where such
distant effects were inappropriate. But the motives of ecclesiastical
embroidery will be discussed in a future chapter.
All attempts at pictorial art are a mistake in textiles. It does not
enter into such designs; and when by chance it is allowed to be so
used, it is an error of judgment, and only exhibits a laborious and
useless ingenuity. It is no longer an artistic delineation of a
natural object, but becomes an imitation of another way of rendering
such objects.
Mr. Redgrave says that pictorial art in our manufactures is one of our
great mistakes. "The picture must be independent of the material, the
thought alone should govern it; whereas in decoration the material
must be one of the suggestors of the thought, its use must govern the
design."
Perhaps it will appear to my readers that here I repeat, in different
forms, what has been said in a previous chapter on the history of
style. I think that it is better to do so, than to omit to show where
style and design must accompany each other. Style, without any
reference to design, would be but a barren subject; and design,
without reference to style, would become lawless, and soon be lost in
the mazes of bad taste and mannerism. Both subjects are of so large
and important a nature that I do not attempt to do more than point out
how, in their history and their influence, they belong to the craft of
embroidery.
Such influences belong to all art; and though I am anxious to confine
myself to only one section of it, I find it difficult to resist the
temptation to generalize and stray from the prescribed path, when
large and important views are opened on every side, as I travel on
from point to point.
In sketching the history of design, as well as I may in so short a
space, it is only considered in the light in which it illustrates our
craft.
I repeat that the design should be informed by the motive which
suggested it, and by the need which has called it forth; and it must
be moulded to the space it has to fill, and the position it will
occupy. The design must be modified into different outward forms,
according to whether it is to be fitted to the edge of a building
against the sky; to a high panelled wall; to be applied as a frieze,
or round the capital of a pillar; to the embroidered cover of an
altar, or the silken hangings of a bed, or the framed flat spaces on
the walls of a saloon. In fact, "intention," "place," and "shape" are
necessary motives and limits to a flat design.
Leaving aside all architectural ornamentation, and adhering only to my
own subject, embroidery, I will limit my observations to the three
purposes here suggested. Firstly, as the central effect of the holiest
part of a church; secondly, in the domestic and comfortable room, to
be adorned and made cheerful; and thirdly, as decking the refined and
gay saloon or banqueting-hall.
To the church we should devote the most splendid and effective
contrasts, to blaze unframed against dark empty backgrounds, or amidst
stone and marble decorations; something set apart from its
surroundings, and asserting that separation, is the desirable effect
to be attained.
A totally different set of rules come into play when we have to select
the decorations of a bedroom. Here a background does not exist. We are
surrounded by four walls very near to the eye, so that perspectives
are a secondary interest, if indeed they can claim any consideration;
severe and magnificent ornamentation is out of place, except perhaps
in that time-honoured institution--to be found in every great house
possessing a suite of reception-rooms--the State bedroom, where the
display of hangings and embroideries was the first motive of the
decoration of the past, clothing and garnishing the bare spaces on the
lofty walls. Space and separateness are not the object or aim of the
bedroom of to-day; but lightness, snugness, and cheerful comfort, with
which the design of the textile ornaments have much to do. This will
in a later chapter come under the head of furniture.
For the saloon we may accept any splendour of rich and costly design,
and the variously shaped panels assist in suggesting the form of the
decoration. The plain or moulded panels, called in Italian "targhe,"
or shields, seem to be descended from the actual shields of gold which
Solomon hung on the walls of the king's house in the Forest of
Lebanon.[94] The motive was apparently Tyrian, and traces of it are
also to be found in Assyrian sculpture.[95]
The practice of framing the design gives opportunities for change of
materials, colour, and pattern, permitting the employment of different
flat surfaces laid on each other, and scope for endless enrichment;
the framed picture being, perhaps, the central culminating attraction,
crowning, as it were, the textile ornamentation.
I merely give these instances as illustrating the rule that we have
more than once laid down, that a design cannot fitly be employed
except in the position for which the artist has composed it. I will,
however, add that though it is right to give due consideration to the
preparation of each work for its intended use, yet we often have
charming suggestions offered to us, by the chance acquisition of a
beautiful artistic specimen, which finds its own place and
accommodates itself to the surrounding colours and forms. These are
the happy accidents of which the cultivated artistic eye takes
advantage, adding them to the experience which may help those who are
seeking for the rules of harmony and contrast in design.
Research into the mysteries and principles of design applies to woven
arabesques and patterns, and must include machine-made textile
ornament, and all decorative needlework. It is, in fact, the fabric
for the million which most especially needs the careful study of
guiding rules. When a plant sends forth hundreds of winged, wind-blown
seeds, like the thistle, it spreads itself over wide fields, and is
more mischievous than a more noxious growth, such as the deadly
nightshade, which only drops an occasional berry into the earth. So a
common cheap chintz or carpet, with a poor, gaudy, motiveless design,
carries a bad style into thousands of homes wherever our commerce
extends; disgracing us, while it corrupts the taste of other nations.
In addressing our young designers, I would remind them that in art the
race is not always to the strong. Prudence and educated powers,
thoughtfulness and study, often carry us where unassisted and
uncultivated genius has signally failed. Even such facilities as are
afforded by the acquirement of freehand drawing, as taught in our
schools of art, are not to be despised. The workman should thoroughly
master his tools, or they will hamper him. The first step towards
design is that you should learn to draw. After this, appreciation and
observation are necessary, and due balance in outline and colour
should be studied; and all this is as much needed in drawing a
pattern as in composing a picture. The difference lies in our art
being only decorative, wherein beauty and fitness are to be
remembered, and nothing else; whereas the picture may have to record
historical facts, or to inspire poetical thoughts--to awe or to touch
the beholder. A decorative design is only asked to delight him.
Intelligent delight, however, can only be evoked by intelligent art,
and to this, decoration must be subjected.
FOOTNOTES:
[73] The earliest art we know (the bone-scratching) is
naturalistic and imitative. We are unaware of any
attempt at a pattern of the prehistoric period. The lake
cities are of so vague a date that their ornaments on
pottery are puzzling rather than instructive. The
earliest Hellenic pottery was scratched or painted.
Cuttle-fish, repeated over and over again, are among the
earliest attempts at a pattern, by repetition of a
natural object. Naturalism soon fell into symbolism,
which appropriated it and all art, and the upheaval of a
new culture was needed to lift it once more into the
region of individual creation. See Boyd Dawkins' "Early
Man in Britain;" also General Pitt Rivers's Museum of
Prehistoric Art, lately presented to the University of
Oxford.
[74] See Boyd Dawkins' "Early Man in Britain."
[75] "I hope, indeed, to enable them" (the members of
his class) "to read, above all, the minds of
semi-barbarous nations in the only language by which
their feelings were capable of expression; and those
whose temper inclines them to take a pleasure in mythic
symbols, will not probably be induced to quit the
profound fields of investigation which early art will
open to them, and which belong to it alone. For this is
a general law, that supposing the intellect of the
workman the same, the more imitatively complete his art,
the less he will mean by it, and the ruder the symbol,
the deeper the intention."--Ruskin's "Oxford Lectures on
Art," 1870, p. 19.
[76] See Isaac Taylor's "History of the Alphabet."
[77] Renouf's Hibbert Lectures, 1879, p. 67.
[78] Now there is a point of view in which we may regard
the imitative art of all races, the most civilized as
well as the most barbarous--in reference to the power of
correctly representing animal and vegetable forms, such
as they exist in nature. The perfection of such
imitation depends not so much on the manual dexterity of
the artist as on his intelligence and comprehension of
the type of the essential qualities of the form he
desires to represent. See Ch. T. Newton's "Essays on Art
and Archæology," p. 17.
[79] See Wilkinson's "Ancient Egyptians."
[80] Plato's Second Book of Laws, p. 656.
[81] "The religion of the Greeks penetrated into their
institutions and daily life. The myth was not only
embodied in the sculptures of Pheidias on the Parthenon,
and portrayed in the paintings of Polygnotus in the Stoa
Poikile; it was repeated in a more compendious and
abbreviated form on the fictile vase of the Athenian
household, on the coin circulated in the market-place,
on the mirror in which the Aspasia of the day beheld her
charms. Every domestic implement was made the vehicle of
figurative language, or fashioned into a
symbol."--Newton's "Essays on Art and Archæology," p.
23.
[82] "Art in Ornament and Dress," by M. Charles Blanc,
formerly Director of the French Institute. Eng. Trans.,
Chapman and Hall, London.
[83] See Charles Blanc's "Art in Ornament and Dress," p.
31.
[84] Charles Blanc's "Art in Ornament and Dress," p. 43.
[85] Charles Blanc's "Art in Ornament and Dress," pp.
43, 45, 46.
[86] Chinese design shows naturalistic art arrested and
perpetuated on totally different principles. Their
representations are all equally allied to their art of
picture-painting, whether on china with the brush, or on
textiles with the needle. The flatness of the picture is
still preserved by their ignorance of perspective. When
they attempted to express different distances, they did
so by placing them one above another, so that in reading
the composition the eye first takes in the distant
horizon; next below it, the middle distance; and being
thus prepared, it comes down to the actual living
foreground, on which rests the dramatic action and
interest addressed to the spectator. The Chinese
understood many of the secrets of art, yet never
achieved perspective.
[87] See Mr. Penrose's work on the measurements of the
Parthenon at Athens. Published by the Society of the
Dilettanti.
[88] Marked outlines in embroidery add to the flatness,
and enable us to omit cast shadows. In this it differs
entirely from pictorial art, where one of the great
objects is to avoid flatness.
[89] Semper's theory, already mentioned, is that textile
design was certainly flat; that it was the first form of
decoration, and was followed by bas-relief, which could
not at once rid itself of the original motive.
[90] Auberville's "Ornamentation des Tissus" (eleventh
century).
[91] Redgrave's "Manual of Design," pp. 43-45.
[92] This idolatrous type was introduced into England by
the Buccaneers, and reflected on our carvings and
embroideries of the time of James I., slightly modified
by the Italian Renaissance of that period. As this sort
of vulgar ornamentation has once prevailed, let us
protect ourselves against its possible recurrence.
[93] While making this passing allusion to the theory
that the origin of all Gothic decoration is mainly
founded on the motive of interlacing stems and foliage,
I wish to guard myself against being supposed in any way
to argue against other beginnings, whenever they can be
proved. I have said before that most decorations have a
mixed ancestry. But when I see single or clustered
columns starting from the ground--spreading at the base
like the gnarled root, and growing till they culminate
in crowns of foliage, forming symmetrical capitals, like
the first clusters of leaves on a strong young
sapling--then the branches spreading and interlacing,
only checked at equal intervals by a lovely leaf or
burgeon, till they meet in blossoms on the highest point
of the arch,--I cannot but adhere to the old idea that
rows of trees meeting overhead suggested Gothic ornament
as well as Gothic Architecture. The Spanish or Moresque
Gothic was overloaded with leaves and flowers, and the
German Gothic was enriched with fantastic trees and
flowers, each according to its national taste and
fashion. A Gothic tree is a very conventional plant; and
generally carries only one leaf on each branch. I have
given a specimen of archaic trees from the Bayeux
tapestry. They are typical of the Gothic botanical idea
and style down to the fourteenth century. (Fig. 13.)
Nor is this interpretation of Gothic design other than a
result of its descent from the Egyptian ancestral
motive, where the temple columns represented the single
stem of the lotus with one large blossom for its
capital, or else a bundle of stems of the lotus, palm,
and convolvulus flowering together into a beautiful
cluster. Even the gigantic columns of the great
hypæthral hall at Karnac are only a stupendous
exaggeration of the same stalk and flower motive. From
these were derived the forms of the early Greek
column--soon enriched by substituting the Acanthus for
the Lotus, but often retaining the convolvulus.
[94] 1 Kings x.; Ezek. xxvii. 10, 11. See Stanley's
"Lectures on the Jewish Church."
[95] Layard's "Nineveh and its Remains," vol. ii. p.
388; Rawlinson's "Ancient Monarchies," vol. ii. p. 2.
CHAPTER III.
PATTERNS.
In the last chapter on design I have described patterns as the
examples or illustrations of the art of decoration, and as being the
records of the motives which produced them in different eras. My
present object is to class and define patterns as decorative art.
It is argued by some archæologists that the recurrence of a pattern,
for instance the "wave," over the whole world, proves that it really
came from many sources, under the same conditions of life and art;
showing also that a pattern is a thing that, like a flower, must grow,
if the culture of the race be equal. I do not believe this. We can
nearly always trace the family history of a pattern to its original
motive; and in the very few cases where we are unable to do so, it is
hardly necessary to cover our ignorance by stretching the fashionable
theory of development over the few instances that are as yet
unaccountable.
I have been repeatedly asked to procure or to invent a new pattern.
Such is my respect for the decorative achievement called a "pattern,"
that I cannot hope for the moment of inspiration in which I might
create such a thing. If any one has in his lifetime invented a
pattern, he has done something truly remarkable, and as rare as is a
really original thought on any subject. Patterns are commonly, like
men, the result of many centuries of long descent from ancestors of
remote antiquity.
Individuals differ from their ancestors through inherited and
surrounding conditions, and through the modifying powers of evolution,
climate, and education. So also a pattern has, besides its ancestry
and descent, the unconscious mark or seal of its day; and it is easy
to trace whence it comes, if we set ourselves to examine the style of
it seriously.
The patterns of which we can nearly always name at once the
nationality, are the Assyrian, the Chinese, the Egyptian, the Hindu
(Aryan and Turanian), the Persian, the Archaic and the highly
developed Grecian; the Roman, the Celtic, the Byzantine, the Arabian,
the Gothic, the Renaissance, the Spanish Plâteresque, the Louis
Quatorze, and those of the art of Central America.
The pattern cannot exist without design. Design means intention and
motive. Many of the motives in Oriental textile decorations are
suggestive of intention, as is shown by their names. Among Indian
patterns we meet with "ripples of silver," "sunshine and shade,"
"pigeon's eye," "peacock's neck," &c.[96]
Patterns must be classed either by their dates, when ascertained, or
according to their style, which must generally be allowed to cover
vast areas and periods irregularly drifting down, overlapping, or
being absorbed or effaced by the circumstances they have encountered.
Only when a national style has been obstinately fixed, as in China,
and bound down by strict laws and religious formulas, suited exactly
to the people for whom they were evolved out of the national life, and
imprinted on it by their own lawgivers, philosophers, and priests; and
neither imposed by conquerors, nor swept over by the waves of a new
civilization;--only in such cases can we find a continuity of
decorative art which leads us far back on its traces. Then, on this
long track, we learn how little, man, the decorating animal, has
really advanced in his powers of creation. He has gone more than once
to a certain point, and has then either been petrified by law and
custom--turned into a pillar of salt, like Lot's wife, because he has
looked back instead of striving to advance, or else through poverty or
satiety has fallen into the last stage of the Seven Ages, "_sans_
eyes, _sans_ teeth--_sans_ everything." When what is good is neither
perceived nor desired, then the arts, small and great, dwindle and
disappear, and nothing remains to show that they have been, but a
name, and perhaps a pattern.
Chinese design is the most striking example of the first of these
phases; and the extinction of all classical art with the fall of
Paganism in Rome is an instance of the second.
In the chapter on style it is said that a pattern is as ineffaceable
as a word. But one will occasionally disappear for a time, till the
ruin that covers it is cleared away, and the lost design recovered and
employed simply as a decoration, if it is beautiful; or perhaps fitted
with a new meaning, and so it makes a fresh start.
The importance of patterns, when traceable to their origin, as a means
of investigating historical influences cannot be too much insisted on,
and their history is full of suggestion as a guide to the decorator.
Much has been argued and much ascertained from the evidence of these
fragments of national civilizations, showing how an idea or a myth has
been, as it were, engrafted into the essence of another national idea,
partly altering what it finds, and changing to fit itself to its new
surroundings. Eastern patterns have travelled far, and lasted long;
and continue still to hold the fancy, and exercise the ingenuity, of
the artist and decorator. When we find a pattern of which the
nationality is strongly marked, it is worth our while to ascertain its
date and history, which will help us to recognize cognate design
wherever we may meet it. However, this is often not to be done; and
then it is best to set these puzzling examples aside, and to await
patiently the elucidation, which may come from some source of which we
are as yet ignorant.
In very early art we have little remaining but patterns, on which we
may found theories by tracing them home to their original source. The
oldest patterns had each a meaning and an intention. When a pattern
has been enduring and far spread, it is because it was originally the
expression of an idea or a symbol.
In the earliest dawn of civilization, the arts were the repositories
of the myths and mysteries of national faiths. Embroidery was one of
these arts, and the border which edged the garment of a divinity, the
veil which covered the grave of a loved one, or the flower-buds and
fruit which fringed the hangings and curtains in the sanctuary, each
had a meaning, and therefore a use. These symbolical designs and forms
were constantly reproduced; and all human ingenuity was exercised in
reforming, remodelling, and adding perfect grace to the expression of
the same idea.
* * * * *
Patterns may be ranged under four heads--the Primitive, the
Naturalistic, the Conventional, and the Geometrical.
The primitive are those of which we know not the ancestry, and rarely
can guess the motive. To us they are, in general, simply rude
decorations. The naturalistic are those which are borrowed from
natural forms, and are either only imitative, or else convey some
hidden meaning. The conventional are those which, by long descent,
have come to be accepted simply as ornamental art, with or without
reference to an original motive, now lost. The geometrical or
symmetrical are founded on form only, and in so far resemble our
experience of the primitive; they express no meaning, and only serve
to satisfy the eye by their balance and their ingenuity.
PRIMITIVE.
The first patterned forms with which we are acquainted are the
primitive. They are found in all parts of the inhabited world. In our
present ignorance as to the beginnings of the scattered tribes of men,
we cannot judge if these are the remains of an earlier art or the
first germs of a new one. Of one thing there is no doubt: this
primitive decoration consists entirely of pattern; that is to say, of
the repetition of certain (to us) inexpressive forms, which by
reiteration assume importance and in some degree express beauty--the
beauty of what Monsieur Blanc calls "cadence."
After these first unintelligible forms, which simply by repetition
become accepted patterns, come those called the Prehistoric, of which
we know or guess something as to their original meaning, and which,
having been reduced from the hieroglyphic-symbolical to the
conventional, have thus crystallized themselves, by constant use, into
a pattern. Such, for instance, is the simplest form of the "wave"
pattern, which in very early art was a representation of water.
The prehistoric water or wave patterns had other forms; for instance,
zigzags, upright or horizontal, and undulating lines which are
intelligible as expressing smooth or rough water. In general, however,
the primitive and prehistoric patterns convey no idea, and consist, as
we have said elsewhere, of lines, straight or wavy, sometimes
intersected; of angles, zigzags, groups of dots, rings and little
discs, and crosses of the Swastika shape. (Plate 10.)
[Illustration: Pl. 10.
WAVE PATTERNS.
1, 4, 9, 12, 13. Greek Wave Patterns. 2. Key or Mæander, Greek
Wave. 3. Greek Broken Wave. 5, 6, 7. Egyptian Smooth and
Rippling Water Patterns. 8. Mediæval Wave. 10, 11, 14.
Assyrian. 15. Persian or Greek (from Glass Bowl, British
Museum). 16. English Waves (Durham Embroideries.)]
Where shall the tartan be placed? It is certainly primitive, and
apparently had no intention beyond that of employing as many coloured
threads as there were dyes, so as to form the brightest contrasts, or
else to be as invisible as possible either in the sunshine or in the
shade. The Gauls brought this kind of weaving with them from the East,
and probably invented the pattern, if such a motiveless design can be
so called. It had its classical name, "Polymita," and was admired in
Rome when newly imported, as being something original and barbaric.
The Romans found it in Britain, and Boadicea wore a tartan dress on
the day of her defeat. Perhaps even then fashions came from France,
and it may have been her best tunic from across the Channel. This
fabric may have been imported by the Belgic Gauls, and was so easily
woven on house looms, that it became in time the feudal dress of the
Scottish tribes and clans, and the colours were ingeniously arranged
to show the most different effects. The tartan has always been a
resource for the woollen trade, and the fashion constantly recurs in
France, either from sentiment or the actually inherited Gallic taste;
but it remains a primitive pattern, and nothing can make it artistic.
No embroidery can soften the constantly recurring angles, and only
fringes can be employed to decorate a tartan costume. Pliny tells us
of the ingenuity of Zeuxis, who, to show his wealth, had his name
embroidered in gold in the squared compartments of his outer
garment.[97]
Primitive patterns still linger in many savage nations, but especially
throughout uncivilized Africa. Curious to say, the very ancient
fossilized early art of Egypt does not assist us to trace it back to
a prehistoric style, though it may lead us into prehistoric times.
NATURALISTIC.
The phases of the naturalistic patterns are constantly recurring. Art
is always tending to realism, in the laudable effort to reach the
motive without the shackles of rules. Each phase has fallen a prey to
symbolism, to conventionalism, or to mannerism, which last symptom
marks the decline and fall of art. We shall find these phases
everywhere in the design of patterns.
Naturalism has always striven, by simple repetition, to reduce to
patterns the forms of flowers, fruits, animals, birds, insects,
reptiles, and other natural objects.
In flower patterns the simplest forms by repetition make sometimes the
richest patterns, and the most effective. (Plate 11, Nos. 1 and 2.)
It is remarkable that one very beautiful class of natural objects is
rarely employed in ancient decoration[98]--shells and corals. The
barbarous tribes of the West Coast of Africa alone seem to have
appreciated their forms, and added them to their small repertory of
naturalistic patterns. They do not appear in any European or Asiatic
textiles till the seventeenth century, when shells were much used in
the decorations of the reigns of Queen Anne and Louis Quatorze.
The first change from naturalism into the conventional was through
symbolism, and belonged to the time when unwritten thought was first
recorded by pictured signs, which then ceased to be merely decoration.
We find that the naturalism of the earliest Egyptians and Asiatics was
soon entirely absorbed by the effort to express some hidden meaning or
mystery, and then to fit the representation to a special place and
purpose, and to restore it, as it were, to decorative art.
[Illustration: Pl. 11.
1. Persian Flower Border.
2. Egyptian Border, composed of Head-dress of the god Nile
(Wilkinson's "Ancient Egyptians").
3. Assyrian.
4. Assyrian.]
The lotus and the patterns founded on its forms, and the many
emblematic meanings attached to them, are notable examples of these
transmutations in style and intention, and of the value given to their
intention and use in Egypt and India, where each development was
immediately crystallized into a recognized pattern, and given its
place and language. It received its "_mot d'ordre_," and continued to
act upon it long after the meaning was forgotten or out of date.
The rolling pattern which had so long represented only the "wave," was
given to the really straight stem of the lotus, and its blossom,
substituted for the wave's crest, now filled many a frieze in Indian
temple architecture; whereas the lotus stems in Egypt were still bound
in sheaves to form columns, and the flowers, buds, and leaves spread
and blossomed into capitals. Here we have symbolism and
conventionalized naturalism, all combined, showing how their
principles, though quite distinct, can mix and unite. The conventional
form often superseded and effaced the naturalistic, and became the
sign of an idea, or the hieroglyphic picture of a thing; immovable and
unalterable in Egypt, where every effort was made to secure eternity
on earth, but continually returning to naturalism in India, where the
Aryan tendency, with the assistance of the "Code of Manu," always
recur
Showing first 200,000 characters. Full text: gutenberg.org/ebooks/30472