Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 30136

A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer

by William Reed Huntington · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2009
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    II. REVISION OF THE AMERICAN COMMON PRAYER.[1]

    The revision of long established formularies of public worship is, as it ought to be, a matter compassed about with obstacles many and great. A wise doubtfulness prompts conservative minds to throw every mover for change upon the defensive, when liturgical interests are at stake.

    So many men are born into the world with a native disposition to tamper with and tinker all settled things, and so many more become persuaded, as time goes on, of a personal "mission" to pull down and remake whatever has been once built up, esteeming life a failure unless they have contrived to build each his own monument upon a clearing, that lovers of the old ways are sometimes compelled in sheer self-defence to put on the appearance of being more obstinately set against change than they really are.

    It ought not to be absolutely impossible to alter a national hand-book of worship (which is what any manual calling itself a Common Prayer must aspire to become), but it is well that it should be all but impossible to do so. Logically it might seem as if the possession of a power to make involved a continuance of power to remake; and so it does, to a certain extent, but only to a certain extent.

    Living organisms cannot be remodelled with the same freedom as dead matter. A solemnity hangs about the moment of birth that attaches to no other crisis in a man's life until death comes. Similarly there are certain features which the founders of institutions, the first makers of organic law, imprint lastingly upon their work. We may destroy the living thing so brought to birth; to kill is always possible; but only by very gradual and plastic methods can we hope in any measure to reconstruct the actual embodiment of life once achieved. The men of 1789 had us in their power, even as the men of 1549 had had both them and us.

    In every creative epoch many things are settled by which unborn generations will be bound.[2]

    It may be urged that this is an argument against adopting liturgies in the first instance as vehicles of worship; and such undoubtedly it is in so far forth as immobility ought in such matters to be reckoned a disadvantage. But we are bound to take into account the gain which comes with immobility as well as the drawbacks. We must consider how large a proportion of the reverence which the great institutes of human life exact from us is due to the fixity of the things themselves. Mont Blanc loses nothing of its hold upon our admiration because we always find it in the same place.

    Men like to feel that there is something in the world stronger than the individual will, stronger simply because it expresses the settled common-sense of many as to what is fitting and right in contrast with the whim of one. Lawyers, as a class, are almost as conservative as ecclesiastics, and for the very reason that they also are charged with the custody of established forms which it is important that men should reverence.

    Laws affecting the tenure of property, the binding force of contracts, the stability of the marriage relation, not only cannot be lightly altered, the very phraseology in which they are couched must be carefully handled, for fear lest with the passing away of the form something of the substance go also.

    Moreover, the affections of men fasten themselves very tenaciously to such a trellis as a liturgy affords. The love for "the old words and the old tunes" against which all innovators in hymnody, however deserving, have to do battle, asserts itself under the form of love for the old prayers with ten-fold vehemence. An immense fund of latent heat smoulders beneath the maxim, "Let the ancient customs prevail"; and few of the victories achieved by the papacy are so startling as those that have resulted in the displacement of the liturgical uses of local Churches, that of Paris, for example, by the Roman rite.

    But true principles, as we are often reminded, become falsehoods when shoved across the line of proper measure. The very cycles of the astronomers have an end, and the clock-work of the most ancient heavens, or at least our reading of it, calls, from time to time, for readjustment. So long as man continues fallible his best intended workmanship will occasionally demand such alteration for the better as, within the limits already pointed out, may be possible.

    Many signs of the times suggest that the hour for a fresh review of the Anglican formularies of worship is nigh at hand. Some of these tokens are written on a sky broad enough to cover the whole English-speaking race, others of them are visible chiefly within our own national horizon. With respect to the English book, Cardwell [3] writing in 1840 and Freeman[4] in 1855, considered revision, however desirable in the abstract, to be a thing utterly out of reach, not within the circle, as the parliamentary phrase now runs, of "practical politics."

    But it may be fairly questioned whether these high authorities, were they living to-day, would not concur in the judgment of a more recent writer when he says--in language which, mutatis mutandis, applies to our own case: "The most weighty plea in favor of timely inquiry into the subject is that the process of revision is actually going on piecemeal, and with no very intelligent survey of the bearings as a preliminary to any one instalment.

    The New Lectionary of 1871, the Shortened Services Act, the debates in the Convocation of Canterbury on rubrical amendments, none of them marked by any sufficient care or knowledge, and all fraught with at least the possibility of serious consequence, are examples of formal and recognized inroads on the Act of Uniformity; while such practical though unauthorized additions to the scanty group of Anglican formularies as the Three Hours' Devotion, Harvest Thanksgivings, Public Institution of Incumbents, Ordination of Readers and Deaconesses, and Children's Services prove incontestably that the narrow limits of the Common Prayer Book are no longer adequate for the spiritual needs of the Church of England . . .

    "It is evident, then, that contented acquiescence with the old state of things already belongs to the past, and that a return to it is impossible. We must perforce advance, for good or ill, in the path of revision, and cannot even materially slacken the pace nor defer the crisis. One choice, however, is left in our power, and that is the most important of all, namely, the direction which revision shall take--that of conservative and recuperative addition, or that of further evisceration, ceremonial or devotional." [5]

    A measure looking in the direction towards which this reviewer points was actually passed by the General Convention of our own Church at its late session in October, 1880.

    The wording of the Resolution referred to was as follows:

    "Resolved: That a Joint Committee, to consist of seven bishops, seven presbyters, and seven laymen be appointed to consider and report to the next General Convention whether, in view of the fact that this Church is soon to enter upon the second century of its organized existence in this country, the changed conditions of the national life do not demand certain alterations in the Book of Common Prayer in the direction of liturgical enrichment and increased flexibility of use."[6]

    In the present article the writer proposes to inquire, in connection with this measure:

    (1) What motives may fairly be supposed to have actuated the Convention in allowing so important an initiatory step to be taken?

    (2) What measure of authority was conferred on and what scope given to the Joint Committee then constituted?

    (3) What reasons exist for considering the present a happy moment to attempt liturgical revision, within certain limits, should such a thing be determined upon?

    (4) What serious difficulties and obstacles are likely to be encountered in Committee, in Convention, and in the Church at large?

    (5) What particular improvements and adjustments of our existing system would be, in point of fact, best worth the effort necessary to secure them?

    I. The interpretation of motives, difficult enough in the case of individuals, becomes mere guess-work when the action under analysis is that of a large body of men. Which one of many considerations urged upon the Convention carried with it the supreme weight of persuasion in this particular instance it is impossible to say.

    Two or three arguments, however, from their frequent reappearance in the debate may fairly be judged to have exercised a controlling influence.

    One of these was hinted at in the language of the resolution itself, namely, the call for revision that has grown out of "the changed conditions of the national life." Shrewd and far-seeing as were William White and his coadjutors in their forecast of nineteenth century needs made from the standpoint of the Peace of Versailles, they would have been more than human had they succeeded in anticipating all the civil and ecclesiastical consequences destined to flow from that memorable event.

    Certainly it ought not to be held strange that this "new America" of ours, with its enormously multiplied territory, its conglomerate of races, its novel forms of association, its multiplicity of industries not dreamed of a generation ago, should have demands to make in respect to a better adaptation of ancient formularies to present wants, such as thoughtful people count both reasonable and cogent.

    That a Prayer Book revised primarily for the use of a half-proscribed Church planted here and there along a sparsely inhabited sea-coast, should serve as amply as it does the purposes of a population now swollen from four millions to fifty, and covering the whole breadth of the continent, is marvel enough; to assert for the book entire adequacy to meet these altered circumstances is a mistake.

    "New time, new favors, and new joys," so a familiar hymn affirms, "do a new song require." We have conceded the principle so far as psalmody is concerned, why not apply it to the service of prayer as well as to that of praise, and in addition to our new hymns secure also such new intercessions and new thanksgivings as the needs of to-day suggest?

    The reference in the resolution to the approaching completion of the century has since been playfully characterized as a bit of "sentimentalism."[7] The criticism would be entirely just if the mere recurrence of the centennial anniversary were the point chiefly emphasized.

    But when a century closes as this one of ours has done with a great social revolution whereby "all estates of men" have been more or less affected, the proposal to signalize entrance upon a fresh stretch of national life by making devotional preparation for it is something better than a pretty conceit; there is a serious reasonableness in it.[8]

    Every revision of the Common Prayer of the Church of England, and there have been four of them since Edward's First Book was put in print, has taken place at some important era of transition in the national life: and conversely it may be said that every civil crisis, with a single exception, has left its mark upon the formularies.

    To one who argues that because we in this country are evidently entering upon a new phase of the national life we ought similarly to re-enforce and readjust our service-book, it is no sufficient reply to urge the severance effected here between Church and State.

    The fact that ours is a non-established Church does not make her wholly unresponsive to the shocks of change that touch the civil fabric. In so far as a political renewal alters the social grading of society, bringing in education, for instance, where before it was not, or suddenly developing new forms of industrial activity, the Church, whether established or not, is in duty bound to take cognizance of the fresh field of duty thus suddenly thrust upon her, and to prepare herself accordingly.

    In the Preface added to the English Prayer Book at the Restoration, and commonly attributed to Sanderson, "that staid and well weighed man," as Hammond called him, there occurs a sentence which, both on account of its embodying in a few words the whole philosophy of liturgical revision and because of a certain practical bearing presently to be pointed out, it is worth while, in spite of its familiarity, to quote:

    "The particular forms of Divine worship, and the rites and ceremonies appointed to be used therein, being things in their own nature indifferent and alterable and so acknowledged, it is but reasonable, that upon weighty and important considerations, according to the various exigency of times and occasions, such changes and alterations should be made therein, as to those that are in place of authority should from time to time seem either necessary or expedient."

    Contemporaneously with this utterance there came into the Prayer Book, as a direct consequence of the enormous enlargement of the naval and commercial marine that had taken place under the Commonwealth, the "Forms of Prayer to be used at Sea." Here was a wise and right-minded recognition of a new want that had sprung up with a new time, a want which jealousy of the Puritans who had built up the naval supremacy did not prevent the Caroline bishops from meeting.

    But the change that passed on England during five years of Cromwell was as nothing compared with the transformation of America under ninety-five years of the federal constitution. Take a single illustration. The year 1789, the date of the Ratification of the American Prayer Book, saw sea-island cotton first planted in the United States, and it was about that time that upland cotton also began to be cultivated for home and foreign use.

    As the effect of this scarcely noticed experiment there straightway sprang up an industry, North and South, which has been to our country almost what her shipping interest is to Great Britain. Bishop White and his associates were not to blame for failure to provide bread that all this unanticipated multitude of toilers should eat. And yet a failure there has been.

    No one who has not labored at the task of trying to commend the Church of the Prayer Book to the working class, as it is represented in our large manufacturing towns, can know how lamentable that failure is. We gather in the rich and the poor, but the great middle class that makes the staple and the strength of American society stands aloof.

    Nowhere in this country, for instance, has the Church had a better opportunity to show what it could do for American people than in the city of Lowell, where cotton spinning had its first large development. It was a virgin soil: the Episcopal Church, as rarely happens, was earliest on the ground: and not only so, but it enjoyed for some years the friendly protection of the proprietors of the new settlement, almost a religious monopoly--was, in fact, an ecclesiastical preserve.

    Moreover, this beginning antedated the Irish occupation by many years, at least so far as skilled labor was concerned, for during a considerable period the operatives in the mills were of native New England stock, the best possible material to be made over into churchmen and churchwomen.

    And yet notwithstanding all this, and notwithstanding the patient and unintermitted toil through more than fifty years of perhaps the most laborious parish priest on the American clergy list, the Episcopal Church has to-day but a comparatively slender hold upon the affections and loyalty of the people of this largest of the manufacturing cities of New England.

    A similar failure to "reach the masses" betrays itself in Worcester and Fall River, the two cities of like character that come next in order of population, for in the former of these last named places only about two per cent, of the inhabitants have affiliations of any sort with the Episcopal Church.

    It was considerations of this sort, backed perhaps by memories of the ringing appeal sounded three years before at Boston by the Bishop of Connecticut, that moved the Convention to interpret as something better than a bit of sentimentalism the invitation to look the times in the face, and give the new century its infant baptism.

    But besides all this there pressed upon the mind of bishops and deputies a cumulative argument of a wholly different sort. The demand for revision seemed to be closing in upon the Church on converging lines. It was plain that, before long, hands of change must necessarily be laid upon certain semi-detached portions of the Prayer Book. There was the New Lectionary, for example, that would presently be knocking for hospitable reception within the covers, and the old Easter Tables, as they now stand, could not, it was observed, last very much longer.

    A new book, in the publisher's sense of that term, would soon have to be made. The sanctity of stereotype plates must be disturbed. Moreover, here was an admirable opportunity to settle the wrangle, now of nine years' standing, over the best way of bringing to pass shortened services for week-day use.

    Add to this the fact that the intrinsic weakness of the driblet method of revision[9] had been made so abundantly plain that even its former friends wisely refrained from all attempt to urge it, and our summing up of probable motives becomes approximately complete.

    II. As to the measure of authority conferred on, and scope allowed to the Committee of Twenty-one, it is possible to speak with more definiteness.

    A precisian might of course, were he so disposed, take up the ground that the report of the Committee when made ought to be monosyllabic, "Yes" or "No." The wording of the resolution admits of such a construction beyond a doubt; the Joint Committee was requested to consider and report whether, etc., etc. But no one who listened to the debate on the resolution could have been left in uncertainty as to the real animus of the measure. The thing intended to be authorized was an experimental review, with implied reference to a limited revision at some time future, in case the fruits of the review should commend themselves to the mind of the Church.

    A distinction must be drawn between revision and review. Revision implies review as an antecedent step, but review is by no means necessarily followed by revision. The English book was reviewed and revised in 1662; it was reviewed but not revised in 1689. Review is tentative and advisory; revision is authoritative and final. In the present instance not an atom of power to effect binding change has been conveyed. No authority has been given to anybody to touch a line or a letter of the Prayer Book save in the way of suggestion and recommendation. Responsible action has been held wholly in reserve.

    Moreover, even the pathway of review was most scrupulously hedged.

    Applying to the resolution the legal maxim, expressio unius est exclusio alterius, one sees at a glance that doctrinal change is a matter left wholly on one side. The two points to which the Committee is instructed to bend all its studies are "liturgical enrichment" and "increased flexibility of use." Whatsoever is more than these is irrelevant. Accurate distinguishment between such "enrichments" as have and such as have not a doctrinal bearing is, no doubt, a delicate point, and must be set down among the difficulties to be encountered.

    As such it will be considered further on. For the present the fact to be noted is that the authorized reviewers are both in honor and in duty bound to keep themselves absolutely clear of controversial bias.

    The movement is not a movement to alter in any slightest respect the dogmatic teaching of the Church, not a movement to unsettle foundations, not a movement toward disowning or repudiating our past, but simply and only an endeavor to make the Common Prayer, if possible (and we are far from being sure, as yet, that it is possible), a better thing of its kind, more comprehensive, more elastic, more readily responsive to the demands of all occasions and the needs of "all sorts and conditions of men." Some who are deeply persuaded that only by doctrinal revision in one direction or another can the Prayer Book be made thoroughly to commend itself to the heart and mind of the American people will esteem the measure of change above indicated not worth the effort indispensable to the attainment of it.

    Be it so; other some there are who do think the attempt well advised and who are willing to waive their own pet notions as to possible doctrinal improvements of the book for the sake of securing a consensus upon certain great practical improvements which come within the range of things attainable.

    Certain it is that any attempt of a body of reviewers like this to disturb, even by "shadowed hint," the existing doctrinal settlement under which we are living together, would be resented by the whole Church.

    There are divines among us who in the interest of a more sharply defined orthodoxy are conscientiously bent upon securing the reintroduction among our formularies of the so-called Athanasian Creed.

    There are others who consider that a more damaging blow at the catholicity of our dogmatic position as a Church could scarcely be dealt.

    Again, there are theologians who account the Prayer Book to be so thoroughly saturated in all its parts with the sacramental idea, that they would account it not only a piece of far-seeing statesmanship, but also a perfectly safe procedure to allow those who chose to do so to thank God after a child's baptism for the simple fact that he had thereby been "grafted into the body of Christ's Church."

    But over against these stand a much larger number who think nothing of the sort, and who would put up with the liturgical shortcomings of the Prayer Book, go without "enrichments" for a thousand years, rather than see the single word "regenerate" dropped out of the post-baptismal office.

    Sensible men not a few are to be found who hold that the incoming tide of host-worship with which, as they conceive, our reformed Church is threatened can never be stayed unless some carefully contrived definition inserted in the Prayer Book shall make impossible this subtile and refined species of idolatry. But men no whit less sensible laugh them in the face, pointing to the "black rubric" and its history as evidence that between the admitted doctrine of the real presence and the disallowed tenet of transubstantiation no impervious barrier of words can possibly be run.

    These illustrations of probable divergence in opinion, in case the field of doctrine were once entered, might be multiplied.

    The retranslation of the Nicene Creed and the more accurate punctuation of its sentences; the rendering of the word Sabbath in the Fourth Commandment into its English equivalent of Rest; the abolition of the curious misnomer under which we go on calling XXXVIII Articles XXXIX; the removal from the Catechism, or else the conversion into mother English of that sad crux infantum, the answer to the question, "What desirest thou of God in this prayer?" are a few examples of less importance than those previously cited; and yet, in the case of the least of them, it is most unlikely that the advocates of change would have the show of hands in their favor, so sensitive is the mind of the Church to anything that looks in the least degree like tampering with the standards of weight and measure, the shekels of the sanctuary.

    On the other hand, there are certain manifest and palpable instances of inaccuracy and, more rarely, infelicity of diction which the reviewers might very properly take occasion to amend even though such alterations could not be classified by a strict constructionist under either of the two heads "enrichment" and "flexibility." In the masterly Report of the Rev. Dr. T. W.

    Coit to the Joint Committee appointed by the Convention of 1841 to prepare a Standard Prayer Book,[10] a document of classical rank, there is more than one intimation of the hope that future reviewers would be given a larger liberty in this direction than he had himself enjoyed. He chafed, and naturally enough, under the necessity of reprinting in a "standard" book, evident and acknowledged solecisms and blunders. "We wanted," he says, "to correct one ungrammatical clause in the Consecration Prayer of the Communion Service.

    It is in the last sentence but one, at its close. It should be, not that he may dwell in them and they in him; but, that he may dwell in us and we in him.

    The prayer is made up out of two or three others; and anyone who will examine the parts put together will easily see how the thing was overlooked. A much greater error was overlooked elsewhere, showing that our American compilers were not sufficiently aware of the necessity which requires that the Prayer Book should always be consistent with itself. I allude to something in the office for the Private Baptism of Children. Suppose a clergyman to avail himself of the license given in the Rubric after the certification. He will then be made to talk thus: 'As the Holy Gospel doth witness to our comfort, on this wise--Dost thou in the name of this child,'" etc.[11]

    Other cases of evident inaccuracy, besides those referred to by this eminent critic, might be cited, even from the latest Standard Prayer Book, that of 1871. It is hard, for instance, to imagine even the veriest martinet in such matters objecting to the redress of a great wrong done on page 36 of the volume mentioned, where the prayer "to be used at the meetings of Convention" is entered under the general heading, "For malefactors after condemnation." Our ecclesiastical legislators have doubtless, like the rest of us, "erred and strayed" more than once, but to deal out to them such harsh measure as this is cruel.

    A strange uncertainty would seem from the Rubric to exist with reference to the limits of the Litany. On page 554 of the Standard Prayer Book, the words, "Here endeth the Litany," occur immediately after the prayer, "We humbly beseech thee, O Father," while on page 31 the same statement is placed immediately after the minor benediction.

    These are not faults for which it could ever be worth while to revise a Prayer Book, but they are blemishes of which the revisers of a Prayer Book ought to take note.

    It is a graver matter to speak of infelicities of diction in a book so justly famous as the Prayer Book for its pure and wholesome English. Wordsworth's curse on

    One who would peep and botanize
    Upon his mother's grave

    seems, in the judgment of many, fairly earned by the critic, whoever he may be, who ventures to suggest that in any slightest instance the language of the formularies might have been more happily phrased. But there are spots on the sun. In the prayer already referred to, that for use "at the meetings of Convention," the petition, "We beseech thee to be present with the council of thy Church here assembled in thy name and presence" does seem open to the charge of tautology if nothing worse.

    It would be well if wherever the word occurs in the Prayer Book in connection with Deity the anthropomorphic plural "ears" could be replaced by the symbolic singular "ear."

    Considering also the great evil of having in a formulary of worship too many things that have to be laboriously explained, it might be well if in the Litany the adjective "sudden," which ever since Hooker's day has given perpetual occasion for cavil, were to yield to "untimely," or some like word more suggestive than "sudden" of the thought clumsily expressed in the "Chapel Liturgy" by the awkward phrase, "death unprepared for."[12]

    It must be again remarked that these are not points for the sake of which word-fanciers would be justified in disturbing an existing order of things; they are simply instances of lesser improvements that might very properly accompany larger ones, should larger ones ever be seriously undertaken.

    With so many pegs upon which controversies might be hung staring us in the face, can we think of it as at all likely that any considerable number of Churchmen assembled in committee (to say nothing of Convention) will be able to agree upon a common line of action with reference to an amendment of the formularies?

    That is the very point at issue, and how it is to be decided only the event can show. Certainly in the roll of the victories of charity, a favorable result, were it achieved, would stand exceeding high.

    This reflection naturally leads up to the inquiry whether there is any special reason to consider the present a happy moment to attempt within the limits already defined a revision of the Prayer Book.

    III. The argument for timeliness has been, in part, already stated.

    A revision will be timely, if the times imperatively demand it; and the main reasons for thinking that they do are before the reader. Something, however, is still left to be said in evidence that the movement now begun is opportune--not rudely thrust upon the Church. "To everything," saith the preacher, "there is a season, and a time to every purpose under heaven," and among the categories that follow this statement we find reckoned what answers to liturgical enrichment, for "there is," he observes, "a time to build up."

    Fifty years ago a persuasive argument against attempting to amend the Prayer Book, either in text or rubrics, might have been based upon the lack of hands competent to undertake so delicate a task.

    Raw material, well adapted to edification, was lying about in blocks, but skilled workmen were scarce. This can hardly be said to-day. Simultaneously with the beginning of the Oxford movement, there naturally sprang up a fresh interest in liturgical studies, an interest which has gone on deepening and widening until in volume and momentum the stream has now probably reached its outer limit.

    The convincing citation, "There were giants in those days," with which a late bishop of one of the New England dioceses used to enforce his major premise that wisdom died with Cranmer and his colleagues, no longer satisfies.

    Probably no period of corresponding length in the whole range of English Church history has shown itself so rich in the fruits of liturgical study as the fifty years that have elapsed since the introduction into the English Parliament of the first Reform Bill.[13] This particular historical landmark is mentioned on account of the close connection of cause and effect between it and the remarkable movement set on foot by Newman, Pusey, Keble, and Froude.

    To be sure, one of the earliest utterances in the Tracts ran in these words: "Attempts are making to get the Liturgy altered. My dear brethren, I beseech you consider with me whether you ought not resist the alteration of even one jot or tittle of it."[14]

    And yet, notwithstanding this disclaimer, one of the main impulses that lay behind the whole movement represented by the Tracts was an earnest desire to quicken the life of the Church of England in the region of worship. In the Table of the Tracts, showing their arrangement according to Subjects, the "Liturgical" section comes first.

    The present writer acknowledges but a very limited sympathy with the doctrinal motives and aims of either the earlier or the later Tractarians. But let us, above all things, be fair. With whatever prepossessions one looks back upon it, the ground traversed by the Church of England during the past fifty years cannot be otherwise regarded than as a field sown with mingled tares and wheat.

    Individuals will differ in judgment as to the proportion in which these two products of a common soil have coexisted, but even those who have most stoutly opposed themselves to the Oxford movement, as a whole, are fain to credit it with, at least, this one good result, the rescue of the usages of worship from slovenliness and torpor, and the establishment of a better standard of what is seemly, reverent, and beautiful in the public service of Almighty God.

    Not that there have not been, even in this respect, grave errors in the direction of excess; the statement ventured is simply this, that, up to a certain point, all Churchmen agree in admitting a genuine and wholesome improvement in the popular estimate of what public worship, as such, ought to be.

    An immense amount of devout study has been given, during the period mentioned, by many able men to liturgical subjects, and it would be strange indeed if fifty years of searching criticism had not resulted in the detection of some few points in which formularies originally compiled to meet the needs of the sixteenth century might be better adapted to the requirements of the twentieth.

    Or, to put the same point in another way, has not all this searching into the mines of buried treasure, all this getting together of quarried stone (with possibly a certain surplusage of stubble) been so much labor lost, if there is never to come the recognition of a ripe moment for the Church to avail itself of the results achieved? Are the studious toils of a Palmer, a Maskell, a Neale, a Scudamore, and a Bright to go for nothing except in so far as they have been contributory to our fund of ecclesiological lore?

    If so, the contempt often expressed for ritual and liturgical studies by students busy with other lines of research would seem to be not wholly undeserved.

    A good opportunity is now before the Church to give answer as to whether this form of investigation is or is not anything better than a species of sacred antiquarianism. Liturgiology as an aspirant for recognition among the useful sciences may be said at the present moment to be waiting for the verdict. To be sure, it can be asserted for liturgiology that to those who love it it is a study that proves itself, like poetry, "its own exceeding great reward." It is not worth while to dispute this point.

    Liturgiology pursued for its own sake may not be the loftiest of studies, but this, at least, can be said for it, that it is a not less respectable object of pursuit than many another specialty the devotees of which look down upon the liturgiologist with self-complacent scorn as a mere chiffonier. The forms which Christian worship has taken on in successive generations and among peoples of various blood are certainly as well worthy of analysis and classification as are the flora and fauna of Patagonia or New Zealand.

    But while the Patagonian naturalist secures recognition and is decorated, every jaunty man of letters feels at liberty to scoff at the liturgiologist as a laborious trifler.

    Moreover, remembering that in favorite studies, as in crops, there rules a principle of rotation, fashion affecting even staid divines with its subtle influence, we may look to see presently a decline of interest in this particular department of inquiry. Especially may serious men be expected to turn their attention in other directions, should it be found that a Non possumus awaits every effort to make the fruits of their labor available for the nourishment of the Church's daily life.

    So then, instead of deferring action until liturgical knowledge shall have become more widely spread, and available liturgical material more abundant, we shall, if we are wise, perceive that only by moving promptly will it be possible in this case to take the tide at the full.

    Never again will opportunity be more ripe.

    Another evidence of timeliness is supplied by the present pacific condition of the Church. Previous movements toward liturgical revision have been of a more or less partisan and acrimonious temper. Now for the first time we seem to be taking up this subject without the expression of a fear from any quarter that if changes are made this or that party will get the advantage of some other.

    The peculiar conditions that ensure this unwonted truce of God are not likely to last forever, nor is it perhaps wholly desirable that they should do so; what is desirable, and very desirable, is that we should avail ourselves of the lull to accomplish certain changes for the better, which in ordinary times the prevalent heat of friction makes impossible.

    The Joint Committee of Twenty-one is confidently believed to contain within itself every shade of color known to belong to the Anglican spectrum; if white light should be found to emerge, three years hence, as a result of the Committee's labors, it will be said, and truly, that never before in our history could such a blending of the rays possibly have taken place.

    Still another consideration properly included under the general head of timeliness is said to have been urged with much force in the House of Bishops when the "enrichment" resolution was under discussion.

    Up to the present time the Episcopal Church of this country has stood easily at the head in the matter of providing for the people a dignified and beautiful order of divine service. In fact, there has been, until lately, no one to compete. But all this is changing.

    Ours are no longer the only congregations in which common prayer is to be found. It is true that thus far the attempts at imitation have been rather grotesque than formidable, but such, until recently, have also been, in the judgment of foreign critics, all of our American endeavors after art.

    We are to consider what apt learners our quick-witted countrymen have shown themselves to be, in so much that even Christmas Day, once the bete noire of Puritan legislators, has come to be accounted almost a national festival, and we shall be convinced that our primacy in the field of liturgies is not an absolutely assured position.

    This argument is open to the criticism that it seems to lower and cheapen the whole subject by representing Anglican religion in a mendicant attitude bidding for the favor of the great American public, and vexed that others, fellow-suppliants, have stolen a good formula of appeal. Nevertheless there is a certain amount of reasonableness in this way of putting the thing.

    Certainly with those who reckon the liturgical mode of worship among the notes of the Church, the argument is one that ought to have marked influence; while with those who, not so persuaded, nevertheless view with pleased interest the general spread of a liturgical taste among the people of this country, seeing in it a token of better things to come, a harbinger of larger agreements than we have yet attained to, and of an approaching "consolation of Israel" once not thought possible--even with such the argument ought not to be wholly powerless.[15]

    The fact that the Convocations of Canterbury and York have taken in hand and carried through a revision of the rubrics of the Prayer Book will seem to those who hold that our Church ought to advance pari passu with the Church of England, and no faster, another evidence of the timeliness of the American movement. Under the title of The Convocation Prayer Book there has lately appeared in England an edition of the Prayer Book so printed as to show how the book would read were the recommendations of York and Canterbury to go into effect.

    It is true that the consent of Parliament must be secured before the altered rubrics can have the force of law; but whatever may come of the rubrics recommended, the existence of the book containing them is evidence enough of a wide-spread conviction among the English clergy that change is needed.

    Indeed never has this point been more powerfully put in the fewest possible words than by the brilliant, and no less logical than brilliant Bishop of Peterborough in a recent speech in the Upper House of Convocation.[16] "If the Church of England wants absolute peace, she should have definite rubrics."

    It is true he goes on to say that in his judgment the dangers of carrying the question of rubrical revision into Parliament are greater than the evil of letting it alone, but it is to be remembered that we in this country are hampered with no Parliamentary entanglements and are free to do of our own motion, and in a quiet, orderly way, that which the Church of England can only do at the risk of something very like revolution.

    But this matter of the rubrics and their susceptibility of improvement will come up later on. It seemed proper to refer to it, if no more, under the head of timeliness. If nothing else in the way of change be opportune at the present moment, it is an easy task to show that the rubrics, as they stand, cry aloud for a revision.

    IV. The obstacles to be encountered by any Committee undertaking so to carry forward a review of the Prayer Book that revision may eventually result, are of two sorts; there are the inherent difficulties of the work itself, such, for instance, as that of matching the literary style of the sixteenth century writers, and there is the wholesome dread of a change for the worse which is sure to assert itself in many quarters the moment definite propositions shall have reached a point at which the "yeas and nays" are likely to be called.

    Beginning, then, with the inherent difficulties, and taking them in the inverse order of arduousness, we see at once how hard it must be to secure unity and self-consistency in the revision of a book so complicated as the Common Prayer. It is like remodelling an old house.

    We think it a very easy matter, something that can be done in one's head, but the mistake is discovered when the new door designed to give symmetry to this room is found to have spoiled the looks of that, when the enlargement of the library turns out to have overtaxed the heating energy of the fireplace, and the ingenious staircase, instead of ending where it was expected to end, brings up against an intractable brick wall. Just such perils as these will beset anybody who ventures to disturb the adjustments of the "Prayer Book as it is" and to introduce desirable additions.

    But domestic architecture is not given up on account of the patient carefulness the practice of it demands, neither need Liturgical Revision be despaired of because it requires of the men who undertake it a like wisdom in looking before and after.

    The really formidable barrier to revision, so far as what have been called the "inherent difficulties" are concerned, is reached when we touch style. How to handle without harming the sentences in which English religion phrased itself when English language was fresher and more fluent than it can ever be again is a serious question.

    The hands that seek to "enrich" may well be cautioned to take heed lest they despoil. It is to be remembered, however, in the way of reassurance that the alterations most likely to find favor with the reviewers are such as will enrich by restoring lost excellencies, rather than by introducing forms fashioned on a modern anvil.

    The most sensitive critic could not, on the score of taste, find fault with the replacement in the Evening Prayer of the Magnificat and the Nunc dimittis, nor of bringing back a few of the Versicles that in the English book follow the Lord's Prayer, nor yet of our being allowed to say, "Lighten our darkness, we beseech thee, Lord," rather than "O Lord, our Heavenly Father, by whose Almighty power we have been preserved this day." Objections to these alterations may be readily imagined, but it would be necessary to base them on other grounds than those of literary fastidiousness.

    In the case of enrichments like these no one could raise the cry that the faultless English of the Prayer Book had been marred.

    But what shall be said of the composition of entirely new services and offices, if it should be judged expedient to give admission to any such? How can we be sure that such modern additions to the edifice would be sufficiently in keeping with the general tone of the elder architecture? It might be held to be an adequate answer to these questions to reply that if the living Church cannot now trust herself to speak out through her formularies in her natural voice as she did venture to do in the seventeenth century and the eighteenth, it must be that she has fallen into that stage of decrepitude where the natural voice is uncertain.

    But, really, what ought to be said is this--that if the same canons of style that ruled the sixteenth century writers are studied and obeyed, there is no reason in the world why a result equally satisfactory with the one then attained should not be reached now.

    There is nothing supernatural about the English of the Prayer Book.

    Cranmer and his associates were not inspired. The prose style of the nineteenth century may not be as good as that of the sixteenth, but, at its best, it is vastly superior to eighteenth century style, and of this last there are already no inconsiderable specimens in the American Book of Common Prayer. The Office for the Visitation of Prisoners, for example, is so redolent of the times of the Georges, when it was composed, that it might be appropriately enough interleaved with prints out of Hogarth. A bit of Palladian architecture in a Gothic church is not more easily recognized.

    Many worse things might happen to the Prayer Book than that the nineteenth century should leave its impress upon the pages.

    In fact, it is just as possible, if men will only think so, to use our language with effect for any good purpose to-day as it was three hundred years ago. All that is necessary is a willingness to submit to the same restrictions, and those mostly moral, that controlled the old writers; and our work, though not identical with theirs, will have the proper similarity. True, a modern author may not be able to reproduce, without a palpable betrayal of affectation and mannerism, the precise characteristics of a bygone style. Chattertons are not numerous.

    It is easier to secure for the brass andirons and mahogany dining chairs of our own manufacture the look of those that belonged to our grandfathers than it is to catch the tones of voices long dead; and just as good judgment dictates the wisdom of repeating the honest and thorough workmanship of the old cabinet-makers in place of slavishly imitating their patterns, so it will be well if the compilers of devotional forms for modern use seek to say what they have to say with sixteenth century simplicity rather than in sixteenth century speech.

    In letters, as in conduct, the supreme charm of style is the absence of self-consciousness. "Say in plain words the thing you mean, and say it as if you meant it," is good advice to any seeker after rhetorical excellence, be he young or old. The Reformers, that is to say, the men who Englished the Prayer Book, in seeking to meet the devotional needs of the people of their own time do not seem to have been at pains to tie themselves to the diction of a previous generation.

    They dared to "call a spade a spade" whenever and wherever the tool came into use, and they have their reward in the permanence of their work. Sweetnesses and prettinesses they banished altogether. Indeed, in those days it seems not to have occurred to people that such things had anything to do with religion. It was not that they did not know how to talk in the sweet way--never has sentimentalism been more rife in general literature than then, but they would not talk in that way; the stern traditions of Holy Church throughout all the world forbade.

    Religion was a most serious thing to their minds, and they would speak of it most seriously or not at all.

    Never since language began to be used have severity and tenderness been more marvellously blended than in the older portions of the English Prayer Book.

    This effect is largely due to an almost entire abstention on the part of the writers from figurative language, or at least from all imagery that is not readily recognized as Scriptural. Bread and beef are what men demand for a steady diet. Sweetmeats are well enough, now and then, but only now and then.

    It is the failure to observe this plain canon of style that has made shipwreck of many an attempt to construct liturgies de novo.

    Ambitious framers of forms of worship seem almost invariably to forget that there may be such a thing as a too exquisite prayer, an altogether too "eloquent address to the throne of grace." The longest and fullest supplicatory portion of the Prayer Book, the Litany, does not contain, from the first sentence to the last,[17] one single figurative expression, it is literally plain English from beginning to end; but could language be framed more intense, more satisfying, more likely to endure?

    Scriptural metaphor, whether because it comes to us with the stamp of authority or on account of some subtle intrinsic excellence, it may be difficult to say, does not pall upon the taste. And yet even this is used sparingly in the Prayer Book, some of the most striking exceptions to the general rule being afforded by the collects for the first and third Sundays in Advent, the collects for the Epiphany and Easter Even, and the opening prayer in the Baptismal Office.

    All these are instances of strictly Scriptural metaphor, and moreover it is to be kept in mind that they are designed for occasional, not constant use. In the orders for daily Morning and Evening Prayer, the "lost sheep" of the General Confession and the "dew" of God's blessing in the Collect for Clergy and People are almost the sole, if not the sole cases of evident metaphor, and these again are Scriptural.

    When in Jeremy Taylor's prayer, introduced by the American revisers into the Order for the Visitation of the Sick, we come upon the comparison of human life to a "vale of misery" we feel that somehow we have struck a new current in the atmosphere; for the moment it is the rhetorician who speaks, and no longer the earnest seeker after God.

    Besides this freedom from figures of speech, we notice in the style of Prayer Book English a careful avoidance of whatever looks like a metaphysical abstraction. The aim is ever to present God and divine things as realities rather than as mere concepts or notions of the mind.

    So far as the writer remembers, not a single prayer in the whole book begins with that formula so dear to the makers of extemporary forms of devotion, "O Thou." On the contrary, the approach to the Divine Majesty is almost always made with a reference to some attribute or characteristic that links Deity to man and man's affairs; it is "O God, the Protector of all that trust in thee," or "Almighty and everlasting God who of thy tender love toward mankind," or "Lord of all power and might who art the author and giver of all good things."

    Cardinal Newman in one of his theological works written before his departure from the Church of England, has a powerful passage bearing upon this point. He is criticising the evangelicals for their one-sided way of setting forth what it must mean to "preach the Gospel." No less a person than Legh Richmond is the object of his strictures.

    "A remarkable contrast between our Church's and this false view of religion," he says, "is afforded in the respective modes of treating a death-bed in the Visitation of the Sick, and a popular modern work, the Dairyman's Daughter. The latter runs thus: My dear friend, do you not FEEL that you are supported? The Lord deals very gently with me, she replied. Are not his promises very precious to you? They are all yea and amen in Christ Jesus.. . Do you experience any doubts or temptations on the subject of your eternal safety?

    No, sir; the Lord deals very gently with me and gives me peace. What are your views of the dark valley of death now that you are passing through it? It is not dark. Now, if it be said that such questions and answers are not only in their place innocent but natural and beautiful, I answer that this is not the point, but this, viz., they are evidently intended, whatever their merits, as a pattern of what death-bed examinations should be. Such is the Visitation of the Sick in the nineteenth century.

    Now let us listen to the nervous and stern tone of the sixteenth. In the Prayer Book the minister is instructed to say to the person visited:

    Forasmuch as after this life there is an account to be given to the Righteous Judge . . . I require you to examine yourself and your estate both toward God and man.

    Therefore I shall rehearse to you the Articles of our Faith, that you may know whether you do believe as a Christian man should or no . . . 'Then shall the minister examine whether he repent him truly of his sins, and be in charity with all the world: exhorting him to forgive from the bottom of his heart all persons who have offended him, and if he hath offended any other to ask their forgiveness, and where he hath done injury or wrong to any man that he make amends to the utmost of his power.' . . . Such is the contrast between the dreamy talk of modern Protestantism, and 'holy fear's stern glow' in the Church Catholic."[18]

    In this striking, though perhaps somewhat unnecessarily harsh way, Newman brings out a point which is unquestionably true, namely, that the language of the Prayer Book is of the sort which it is just now the fashion to call realistic, that is, a language conversant with great facts rather than with phases of feeling and moods of mind; which after all is only another way of saying that it is a Book of Common Prayer and not a manual for the furtherance of spiritual introspection.

    These, then, are the characteristics of the Prayer Book style: it is simple, straightforward, unmetaphorical, realistic. Seriously it looks almost like a studied insult alike to the scholarship and to the religion of our day, to say that these are excellencies attainable no longer. That revisers venturing upon additions to the Prayer Book would be bound to set the face as a flint against any slightest approach to sentimentality is true. But why assume that the men do not exist who are capable of such a measure of self-control?

    Grant that there are whole volumes of devotional matter, original and compiled, which one may ransack without finding a single form that is not either prolix, wishy-washy, or superstitious--it does not follow that if the Prayer Book is to be enriched, the enrichments must necessarily come from such sources. Moreover it is to be remembered that there is another vice of style to be shunned in liturgical composition quite as carefully as sentimentality, namely, jejuneness. We cannot escape being sentimental simply by being dull.

    Feeling must not be denied its place in prayer for fear that it may not prove itself a duly chastened feeling. There ought to be a heart of fire underneath the calm surface of every formulary of worship. Flame and smoke are out of place; but a liturgy should glow throughout. Coldness, pure and simple, has no place in devotion.

    Over and above the intrinsic difficulties in the way of revision growing out of the delicate nature of the work itself, obstacles of a different sort are certain to be encountered. In so large a body of men as the Joint Committee of the two Houses, entire and cordial agreement is almost too much to be expected; and then even supposing a unanimous report submitted, what is likely to follow?

    Why this--if the changes proposed are few, the cry will be raised, It surely is not worth while to alter the Prayer Book for the sake of so insignificant a gain; whereas if the changes proposed are considerable, the counter cry will be sounded, This is revolution.

    Then there is the anxious question, How will it look to the English?

    What will be the effect on the Concordat if we touch the Prayer Book? To be sure, the Concordat does not seem to weigh very heavily on the shoulders of the other party, as indeed there is no reason why it should. Convocation does not much disturb itself as to the view General Convention is likely to take of its sayings and doings, and even disestablishment might proceed without our being called into consultation.

    And yet the Concordat difficulty will have to be reckoned with; and the dire spectre of a possible disowning of us by our mother the Church of England will have to be laid, before any alterations in the Book of Common Prayer will be accounted by some among us perfectly safe.

    But it is scarcely worth while to go on gratuitously suggesting opposition arguments. They will be sure to present themselves unsolicited in due time. For the present it is enough to add that if the movement for liturgical revision has not in it enough toughness of fibre to enable it to survive vigorous attack, it does not deserve success.

    V. Under the head of liturgical enrichment ought to be classed whatever alteration would really serve to enhance the beauty, majesty, or fitness, of accepted formularies of worship. Excision may, under conceivable circumstances, be enrichment. James Wyatt undoubtedly imagined that he was improving the English cathedrals when he whitewashed their interiors, added composition pinnacles to the west towers of Durham, and rearranged the ancient monuments of Salisbury; but an important part of the enrichment accomplished by our nineteenth century restorers has lain simply in the undoing of what Wyatt did.

    Again, substitution may be enrichment, as in the case where a wooden spire built upon a stone tower is taken down to be replaced by honest work. It would be an enrichment if in St. George's Chapel, the central shrine of British royalty, the sham insignia now overhanging the stalls of the knights of the garter were to give room to genuine armor. Not merely then by addition, but possibly, in some instances, by both subtraction and substitution, we may find the "Prayer-book as it is" open to improvement.

    Before, however, entering upon any criticism of the formularies in detail, it is important to draw a distinction between two very different things, namely, the structure of a liturgical office and the contents of it. By structure should be understood the skeleton or frame that makes the groundwork of any given office, by contents the actual liturgical material employed in filling out the office to its proper contour.

    The offices of the Roman Breviary, for example, continue, for the most part, identical in structure from day to day, the year through; but they vary in contents. For an illustration nearer home take our own Order for Daily Morning Prayer. The structure of it is as follows: 1. Sentences, 2. Exhortation, 3. Confession, 4.

    Absolution, 5. Lord's Prayer, 6. Versicles, 7. Invitatory Psalm,

    1. The Psalms for the day, 9. Lection, 10. Anthem or Canticle, 11.

    Lection, 12. Anthem or Canticle, 13. Creed, 14. Versicles,

    1. Collect for the day, 16. Stated Collects and Prayers, 17.

    Benediction.

    Now it is evident that without departing by a hair's breadth from the lines of this framework, an indefinite number of services might by a process of substitution be put together, each one of which would in outward appearance differ widely from every other one.

    The identical skeleton, that is to say, might be so variously clothed upon that no two of its embodiments would be alike. But is it desirable to run very much after variety of such a sort in a book of prayer designed for common use? Most assuredly, No. To jeopard the supreme desideratum in a people's manual of worship, simplicity: to make it any harder than it now is for the average "stranger in the Church" to find the places, would be on the part of revisionists an unpardonable blunder.

    There are, however, a few points at which the Morning Prayer might advantageously be enriched, and no risk run. It would surely add nothing to the difficulty of finding the places if for one-half of the present opening sentences there were to be substituted sentences appropriate to special days and seasons of the ecclesiastical year. We should in this way be enabled to give the key-note of the morning's worship at the very outset.

    Having once departed, as in the case of our first two sentences, from the English precedent of putting only penitential verses of Scripture to this use, there is no reason why we should not carry out still more fully in our selection the principle of appropriateness. The sentences displaced need not be lost, for they might still stand, as now, at the opening of the Evening Prayer.

    Passing on to the declarations of absolution there is an opportunity to simplify the arrangement by omitting the alternate form borrowed from the Order for the Administration of the Lord's Supper, where only it properly belongs. This, however, is a change likely to be resisted on doctrinal grounds, and need not be urged.

    Coming to the Venite, we find another opportunity to accentuate the Christian Year. It may be said that the rubric, as it is already written, allows for the substitution of special anthems on the greater festivals and fasts. This is true; but by giving the anthem for Easter a place of honor, while relegating anthems for the other great days to an unnoticed spot between the Selections and the Psalter, the American compilers did practically discriminate in favor of Easter and against the rest.

    The real needs of the case would be more wisely met if the permission to omit Venite now attached to "the nineteenth day of the month" were to be extended to Ash-Wednesday and Good Friday, and special New Testament anthems analagous to the Easter one were to be inserted along with the respective Collects, Epistles, and Gospels, for Christmas-day and Whitsunday.

    By this change we should put each of the three great festivals of the year into possession of an invitatory anthem of its own; and we should obviate on the fasting days, by the simple expedient of omission, the futile efforts of choir-master and organist to transform Venite from a cry of joy into a moan of grief.

    This brings us to the Psalter.

    Here we have an opportunity to correct the palpable blunder by which it has come about that the greatest of the penitential psalms, the fifty-first, has no place assigned it among the proper psalms either for Ash-Wednesday or for Good Friday.[19] It would also be well to make optional, if not obligatory, the use of "proper psalms" on days other than those already provided with them; e. g., Advent Sunday, the Epiphany, Easter Even, Trinity Sunday, and All Saints' Day.[20] There would be a still larger gain in the direction of "flexibility of use," as well as a great economy of valuable space, if instead of reprinting some thirty of the Psalms of David under the name of Selections, we were to provide for allowing "select" psalms to be announced by number in the same manner that "proper" psalms are now announced.

    Instead of only the ten selections we now have, there might then be made available twenty or thirty groups of psalms at absolutely no sacrifice of room.

    It has been objected to this proposal that the same difficulty which now attaches to the finding of the "proper psalms" on great days would embarrass congregations whenever "select psalms" were given out; but this is fairly met by the counter consideration that if our people were to be educated by the use of select psalms into a more facile handling of the Psalter it would be just so much gained for days when the "proper psalms" must of necessity be found and read.

    The services, that is to say, would run all the more smoothly on the great days, after congregations had become habituated, on ordinary days, to picking out the psalms by number.

    Another step in the line of simplification, and one which it is in order to mention here, would be the removal from the Morning Prayer of Gloria in Excelsis, seeing that it is never, or almost never, sung at the end of the psalms unless at Evening Prayer. As to the expediency of restoring what has been lost of Benedictus after the second lesson, the present writer offers no opinion.

    There are some who warmly advocate the replacement, and there is, unquestionably, much to be said in favor of it. It is unlikely that any doctrinal motive dictated the abbreviation.

    Pausing a moment at the Creeds for the insertion of a better title than "Or this" before the confession of Nicaea, we pass to the versicles that follow.

    Here again it would be enrichment to restore the words of the English book, although the task of finding an equally melodious equivalent for O Lord, save the Queen might not be easy.

    Happily the other versicles are such as no civil revolution can make obsolete. It will never be amiss to pray,

    Endue thy ministers with righteousness.

    Answer. And make thy chosen people joyful.

    These are all the alterations for which the present Morning Prayer considered as a form of Divine Service for Sundays would seem to call. It will be observed that they are far from being of a radical character, that they affect the structure of the office not at all, and touch the contents of it but slightly.

    The case is altered when we come to the Order for Evening Prayer.

    Here there is a demand, not indeed for any structural change, but for very decided enrichment by substitution. The wording of the office is altogether too exact an echo of what has been said only a few hours before in Morning Prayer. It betokens a poverty of resources that does not really exist, when we allow ourselves thus to exhort, confess, absolve, intercede, and give thanks in the very same phrases at three in the afternoon that were on our lips at eleven in the morning.

    Doubtless liturgical worship owes a good measure of its charm to the subtle power of repetition; but the principle is one that must be handled and applied with the most delicate tact, or virtue goes out of it. We must distinguish between similarity and sameness.

    The ordered recurrence of accents is what makes the rhythm of verse; but for all that, there is a difference between poetry and sing-song, just as there is a difference between melody and monotony.

    Moreover, the taste of mankind undergoes change as to the sorts of repetition which it is disposed to tolerate. No modern poet of standing would venture, for instance, to employ identical epithets to the extent that Homer does, making Aurora "rosy-fingered" every time she appears upon the scene, and Juno as invariably "ox-eyed." People were pleased with it then, they would not be pleased with it now.

    It is possible in liturgies so to employ the principle of repetition that no wearying sense of sameness will be conveyed, and again it is possible so to mismanage it as to transform worship into something little better than a "slow mechanic exercise." Mere iteration, as such, is barren of spiritual power; witness the endless sayings over of Kyrie Eleison in the Oriental service-books, a species of vain repetition which a liturgical writer of high intelligence rightly characterizes as "unmeaning, if not profane."[21] Now the common popular criticism upon the Evening Prayer of the Church is that it repeats too slavishly the wording of the Morning Prayer.

    If this is an unjust criticism we ought not to let ourselves be troubled by it.

    On the other hand, if it is a just criticism it will be much wiser of us to heed than to stifle the voice that tells us the truth.

    It might seem to be straining a point were one to venture to explain the present very noticeable disinclination of Churchmen to attend a second service on Sunday, by connecting it with the particular infelicity in question; but that the excuse, We have said all this once to-day; why say it again? may possibly have something, even if not much, to do with the staying at home is certainly a fair conjecture.

    Without altering at all the structure of the Evening Prayer, it would be perfectly possible so to refill or reclothe that formulary as to give it the one thing needful which now it lacks--freshness.

    In such a process the Magnificat and the Nunc dimittis would play an important part; as would also certain "ancient collects" of which we have heard much of late. Failing this, the next best thing (and the thing, it may be added, much more likely to be done, considering what a tough resistant is old usage) would be the provision of an alternate and optional form of Evening Prayer, to be used either in lieu of, or as supplementary to the existing office. In the framing of such a Later Evensong a larger freedom would be possible than in the refilling of a form the main lines of which were already fixed.

    Still, the first plan would be better, if only it could be brought within the range of things possible.

    Next to Evening Prayer in the order of the Table of Contents comes the Litany. Here there is no call for enrichment,[22] though increased flexibility of use might be secured for this venerable form of intercessory prayer by prefixing to it the following rubric abridged from a similar one proposed in The Convocation Prayer Book:

    "A General Supplication, to be sung or said on Sundays, Wednesdays, and Fridays, and on the Rogation Days, after the third collect at Morning or Evening Prayer, or before the Administration of the Holy Communion; or as a separate Service.

    "NOTE.--The Litany may be omitted altogether on Christmas Day, Easter Day, and Whitsunday"

    In connection with the Morning and Evening Service there is another important question that imperatively demands discussion, namely, a week-day worship. The movement for "shortened services," so-called, has shared the usual fate of all efforts at bettering the life of the Church, in being at the outset of its course widely and seriously misunderstood.

    The impression has gone abroad, and to-day holds possession of many otherwise well-informed people, that a large and growing party in the Episcopal Church has openly declared itself wearied out with overmuch prayer and praise. Were such indeed the fact, the scandal would be grave; but the real truth about the matter is that the promoters of shortened services, instead of seeking to diminish, are really eager to see multiplied the amount of worship rendered in our churches.

    "Shortened services" is a phrase of English, not American origin, and has won its way here by dint of euphony rather than of fitness. Readjusted services, though a more clumsy, would be a less misdirecting term. In the matter of Sunday worship, the liberty now generally conceded of using separately the Morning Prayer, the Litany, and the Holy Communion is all that need be asked.

    Whether these services, or at least two of them, do not in themselves admit of a certain measure of improvement is a point that has already been considered, but there certainly is no need of shortening them, whatever else it may be thought well to do.

    When what a Boston worthy once termed "a holy alacrity" is observed, on the part of both minister and singers, even the aggregated services of Morning Prayer, Litany, and "Ante-Communion," together with a sermon five-and-twenty minutes long, can easily be brought within the compass of an hour and a half--a measure of time not unreasonably large to be given to the principal occasion of worship on the Lord's Day.

    As for the Evening Prayer--there certainty ought to be no call for the shortening of that on Sundays; for it would be scarcely decent or proper to devote to such a service anything less than the half hour the existing office demands.

    What the advocates of shortened services really desire to see furthered is an increase in the frequency of opportunities for worship during the week, their conviction being that if the Church were to authorize brief services for morning and evening use, such as would not occupy much more time than family prayers ordinarily do, the attendance might be secured of many who, at present, put aside the whole question of going to church on week-days as impracticable.

    Supposing it could be proved that such a provision would work to the discouragement of family prayer, it would plainly be wrong to advocate it; no priesthood is more sacred than that which comes with fatherhood. But we must face the fact that in our modern American life family prayer, like sundry other wholesome habits, has fallen largely into disuse.

    If the Church can, in any measure, supplement the deficiencies of the household, and help to supply to individuals a blessing they would gladly enjoy at their own homes, if they might, it is her plain duty to do so.

    Moreover, many a minister who single-handed cannot now prudently undertake a daily service, as that is commonly understood, would acknowledge himself equal to the less extended requirement.

    Not a few careful and friendly observers of the practical working of Anglican religion have been reluctantly led to consider the daily service, as an institution, only meagrely successful. Looking at the matter historically we find no reason to wonder at such a conclusion.

    Our existing usage (or more correctly, perhaps, non-user) dates from the Reformation period. The English Church and nation of that day had grown up familiar with the spectacle of a very large body of clerics, secular and regular, whose daily occupation may be said to have been the pursuit of religion.[23] The religion pursued consisted chiefly in the saying of prayers, and very thoroughly, so far at least as the consumption of time was concerned, were the prayers said.

    What more natural than that, under such circumstances, and with such associations, the compilers of a common Prayer Book for the people should have failed to see any good reason for discriminating between the amount of service proper to the Lord's Day and the amount that might be reasonably expected on other days?

    Theoretically they were right, all time belongs to God and he is as appropriately worshipped on Tuesdays and Thursdays as on Sundays.

    And yet as a result of their making no such discrimination, we have the daily service on our hands--a comparative, even if not an utter failure. We may lament the fact, but a fact it is, that In spite of all its improved appliances for securing leisure, the world is busier than ever it was; and there will always be those who will insist that the command to labor on six days is as imperative as the injunction to rest upon the seventh. As a consequence of all this accelerated business, and of the diminution in the number of persons officially set apart for prayer, the unabridged service of the Church fails to command a week-day attendance.

    We have no "clerks" nowadays to fill the choir. The only clerks known to modern times are busy at their desks.

    It may be urged in reply to this that the practical working of the daily service ought to be kept a secondary consideration, and that its main purpose is symbolical, or representative; the priest kneeling in his place, day by day, as a witness that the people, though unable personally to be present, do, in heart and mind, approve of a daily morning and evening sacrifice of prayer. This conception of the daily service as a vicarious thing has a certain mystical beauty about it, but if it is to be adopted as the Church's own let us, at least, clear ourselves of inconsistency by striking out the word "common" from before the word "prayer" in characterizing our book.

    What is really needed for daily use in our parishes is a short form of worship specially framed for the purpose. If they could be employed without offence to the Protestant ear (and they are good English Reformation words) Week-Day Matins and Week-Day Evensong would not be ill chosen names for such services.

    The framework of these Lesser Orders for Morning and Evening Prayer, as they might also be called, were the other titles found obnoxious, ought to be modelled upon the lines of the existing daily offices, though with a careful avoidance of identity in contents. There should be, for instance, as unvarying elements, the reading of the lessons for the day, the use of the collect for the day, and the saying or singing of the psalms for the day.

    Another constant would be the Lord's Prayer; but aside from these the Lesser Order need have nothing in common with the Order as we have it now. There might be, for example, after the manner of the old service-books, an invitatory opening with versicles and responses, or if the present mode of opening by sentences were preferred, specially chosen sentences, different from those with which the Sunday worship has made us familiar, could be employed.

    Moreover, the anthems or canticles and the prayers, with the exception of the two just mentioned, ought also to be distinctive, and, in the technical sense of the word, proper to the week-day use.

    Again, it would serve very powerfully and appropriately to emphasize the pivot points in the ritual year if this same principle were to be applied to saints' days, and we were to have special Holyday Matins and Holy-day Evensong, there still being required, on the greater festivals and fasts, the normal Morning and Evening Prayer proper to the Lord's Day.[24]

    The argument in favor of thus specializing the services for week-days and holydays, in preference to following the only method heretofore thought possible, namely, that of shortening the Lord's Day Order, rests on two grounds. In the first place permissions to skip and omit are of themselves objectionable in a book of devotions. They have an uncomely look. Our American Common Prayer boasts too many disfigurements of this sort already.

    Such a rubric as The minister may, at his discretion, omit all that follows to, etc. , puts one in mind of the finger-post pointing out a short cut to weary travellers. It is inopportune thus to hint at exhaustion as the probable concomitant of worship.

    That each form should have an integrity of its own, should as a separate whole be either said complete or left unsaid, is better liturgical philosophy than any "shortened services act" can show.

    In the second place, a certain amount of variety would be secured by the proposed method which under the existing system we miss.

    There is, of course, such a danger as that of providing too much liturgical variety. Amateur makers of Prayer Books almost invariably fall into this slough. Hymn-books, as is well known, often destroy their own usefulness by including too many hymns; and Prayer Books may do the same by having too many prayers.[25]

    To transgress in the compiling of formularies the line of average memory, to provide more material than the mind of an habitual worshipper is likely to assimilate, is to misread human nature.

    But here, as elsewhere, there is a just mean. Cranmer and his colleagues in the work of revision jumped at one bound from a scheme which provided a distinctive set of services for every day in the year to a scheme that assigned one stereotyped form to all days.

    Now nothing could be more unwise than any attempt to restore the methods of the Breviary, with its complicated and artificial forms of devotion; but so far to imitate the Breviary as to provide within limits for a recognition of man's innate love of change would be wisdom. By having a distinctive service for week-days, and a distinctive service for holydays, Ave might add just that little increment to the Church's power of traction that in many instances would avail to change "I cannot go to church this morning" into "I cannot stay away."

    It will be urged as a counter-argument to these considerations that the thing is impossible, that such a measure of enrichment is entirely in excess of anything the Church has expressed a wish to have, and that for reviewers to propose a plan so sweeping would be suicide. Doubtless this might be a sufficient answer to anybody who imagined that by a bare majority vote of two successive General Conventions new formularies of daily worship could be forced upon the Church.

    But suppose such formularies were to be made optional; suppose there were to be given to parishes the choice between these three things, viz.: (a) the normal Morning Prayer; (b) a shortened form of the normal Morning Prayer; and (c) such a special order as has been sketched--what then? Would the Church's liberty be impaired! On the contrary, would not the borders of that liberty have been most wisely and safely widened by the steady hand of law?

    This is perhaps the right point at which to call attention to the present state of the "shortened services" controversy, for wearisome as the story has become by frequent repetition, the nexus between it and the subject in hand is too important to be left out of sight.

    In the General Convention of 1877, where the topic under its American aspects was for the first time thoroughly discussed, the two Houses came to a deadlock. The deputies on the one hand, almost to a man, voted in favor of giving the desired relief by rubric, thus postponing for three years' time the fruition of their wish; while the bishops with a unanimity understood to have been equally striking insisted that a simple canon, such as could be passed at once, would suffice. And so the subject dropped.

    At the late Convention of 1880 an eirenicon was discovered. The quick eye of one of the legal members of the House of Deputies detected on the fourth page of the Prayer Book, just opposite the Preface, a loophole of escape, to wit, The Ratification of the Book of Common Prayer. Here was the very tertium quid whereby the common wish of both parties to the dispute might be effected without injury to the sensibilities of either.

    The Ratification certainly did not look like a canon; neither could anybody with his eyes open call it a rubric--why not amend that, and say no more about it? The suggestion prevailed, and by a vote of both Houses, the following extraordinary document is hereafter to stand (the next General Convention consenting) in the very fore-front of the Prayer Book:

    THE RATIFICATION OF THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER. By the Bishops,
    the Clergy, and the Laity of the Protestant Episcopal Church in
    General Convention assembled
    .

    The General Convention of the Church having heretofore, to wit: on the sixteenth day of October in the year A. D. 1789, set forth a Book of Common Prayer and Administration of the Sacraments and other Rites and Ceremonies of the Church, and thereby established the said book, and declared it to be the Liturgy of said Church, and required that it be received as such by all the members of the same and be in use from and after the first day of October in the year of our Lord 1790; the same book is hereby ratified and confirmed, and ordered to be the use of this Church from this time forth.

    "But note, however, that on days other than Sundays, Christmas-day, the Epiphany, Ash-Wednesday, Good Friday, and Ascension Day, it shall suffice if the Minister begins Morning or Evening Prayer at the General Confession or the Lord's Prayer preceded by one or more of the Sentences appointed at the beginning of Morning and Evening Prayer, and end after the Collect for Grace or the Collect for Aid against Perils, with 2 Cor. xiii. 14, using so much of the Lessons appointed for the day and so much of the Psalter as he shall judge to be for edification.

    "And note also that on any day when Morning and Evening Prayer shall have been duly said or are to be said, and on days other than those first aforementioned, it shall suffice, when need may require, if a sermon or lecture be preceded by at least the Lord's Prayer and one or more Collects found in this book, provided that no prayers not set forth in said book, or otherwise authorized by this Church, shall be used before or after such sermon or lecture.[26]

    "And note further also that on any day the Morning Prayer, the Litany, or the Order for the Administration of the Lord's Supper may be used as a separate and independent service, provided that no one of these services shall be disused habitually."

    It may seem harsh to characterize this act as the mutilation of a monument; but really it does seem to be little else. The old Ratification of 1789 is an historic landmark; it is the sign-manual of the Church of White's and Seabury's day, and ought never to be disturbed or tampered with while the Prayer Book stands.

    The year 1889 might very properly see a supplemental Ratification written under it; and testifying to the fact of Revision; but to write into that venerable text special directions as to what may be done on days other than Ash-Wednesday, and what must not be done without 2 Cor. xiii.

    14, is very much as if the City Government of Cambridge should cause to be cut upon the stone under the Washington elm which now records the fact that there the commander of the American armies first drew his sword, divers and sundry additional items of information, such as the distance to Watertown, the shortest path across the common, etc., etc.

    Why the Convention after having entrusted to a Joint Committee, by a decisive vote, the task of devising means for securing for the Prayer Book "increased flexibility of use," should have thought it necessary subsequently to take up with this compromise of a compromise (for such the proposal to amend the Ratification really is) it is difficult to say. Perhaps it was with the determination to have, at any rate, something to fall back upon in case the larger and more comprehensive measure should come to naught.

    The rubric is confessedly the proper place for directions as to how to use the services, and but for the very natural and defensible objection on the part of some to touching the Prayer Book at all, there never would have been any question about it.[27] This objection having been at last waived, a straight path is now open to the end desired, and it ought to be followed even at the cost of three years more of delay.

    Returning to the general subject, and still following the order of the Table of Contents, we come to Prayers and Thanksgivings upon several Occasions.

    Here it would be well to note more intelligibly than is done by the present rubric the proper places for the introduction of the Prayers and the Thanksgivings, providing for the use of the former before, and of the latter after the General Thanksgiving.

    As to the deficiencies in this department let the late Dr. Muhlenberg speak.

    "The Prayer Book," he says, "is not undervalued as to its treasures in asserting its wants. The latter cannot be denied. Witness the meagre amount of New Testament prayer and praise for the round of festivals and fasts; the absence of any forms suited to the peculiar circumstances of our own Church and country and to the times we live in; or for our benevolent and educational institutions.

    There are no prayers for the increase of Ministers, for Missions, or Missionaries, for the Christian teaching of the young; for sponsors on occasions of Baptism; for persons setting out on long journeys by land, quite as perilous as voyages by sea; for the sick desiring the prayers of the Church when there is no prospect of or desire for recovery; for the bereaved at funerals, and many other occasions for which there might as well be provision as for those few for which we already have the occasional prayers."[28]

    After the Prayers and Thanksgivings come The Collects, Epistles, and Gospels . Here again there is some room for enrichment.

    Distinctive collects for the first four days of Holy Week, for Monday and Tuesday in Easter Week, and for Monday and Tuesday in Whitsun Week, would add very materially to our liturgical wealth, while there would seem to be no reason whatever why they should not be had. It would also serve to enhance the symmetry of the Christian Year if the old feast of the Transfiguration[29] (August

    1. were to be restored to its place among the recognized holy days

    of the Church and given its proper collect, epistle, and gospel.

    There are some liturgists who desire the restoration of the introits of the First Book of Edward VI. The introit (so called from being the psalm sung when the priest goes within the altar-rails) has been in modern usage replaced by a metrical hymn. A sufficient reason for not printing the introit for each day in full, just before the collect, as was the mode in Edward's Book, is that to do so would involve a costly sacrifice of room.

    A compromise course would be to insert between the title of each Sunday or holyday and the collect proper to it, a simple numerical reference stating whereabouts in the Psalter the introit for the day is to be found, and adding perhaps the Latin catchwords. Any attempt to make the use of the introit obligatory in our times would meet with deserved failure; the metrical hymn has gained too firm a hold upon the affections of the Church at large ever to be willingly surrendered.

    Coming, next, to the orders for the administration of the two sacraments, we find ourselves on delicate ground, where serious change of any sort is out of the question. Permission, under certain circumstances, still further to abbreviate the Office of the Communion of the Sick might, however, be sought without giving reasonable cause of alarm to any, and general consent might perhaps also be had for a provision with respect to the Exhortation, "Dearly beloved in the Lord," that in "Churches where there is frequent Communion it shall suffice to read the Exhortation above written once in a month on the Lord's Day."[30]

    There are three liturgical features of the Scottish Communion Office which some have thought might be advantageously transferred to our own service. They are (a) the inserting after Christ's summary of the Law a response, Lord, have mercy upon us and write these thy laws in our hearts, we beseech thee; (b) the repeating by the people, after the reading of the Gospel, of a formula of thanks corresponding to the Glory be to thee, O Lord, that precedes it; and (c) the saying or singing of an Offertory sentence at the presentation of the alms. Upon these suggested enrichments the present writer offers no opinion.

    In the Order of Confirmation a substitution for the present preface[31] of a responsive opening, in which the bishop should charge the minister to present none but such as he has found by personal inquiry "apt and meet" for the reception of the rite would be a marked improvement.

    The remaining Occasional Offices would seem to demand no change either in structure or contents, although in some, perhaps in all of them, additional rubrics would be helpful to worshippers.

    Some addition to the number of Occasional Offices would be a real gain. We need, for instance, a short Office for the Burial of Infants and Young Children; a Daybreak Office for Great Festivals; an Office for Midday Prayer; an Office of Prayer in behalf of Missions and Missionaries; an Office for the Setting apart of a Layman as a Reader, or as a Missionary; a Form of Prayer at the Laying of a Corner-stone; and possibly some others. It is evident that these new formularies might give opportunity for the introduction of hitherto unused collects, anthems, and benedictions of a sort that would greatly enhance the general usefulness of the Prayer Book.

    This completes the survey of the field of "liturgical enrichment."

    A full discussion of the allied topic, "flexibility of use," would involve the examination in detail of all the rubrics of the Prayer Book, and for this there is no room. It is enough to say that unless the rubrics, the hinges and joints of a service-book, are kept well oiled, much creaking is a necessary result. There are turning-points in our public worship where congregations almost invariably betray an awkward embarrassment, simply because there is nothing to tell them whether they are expected to stand or to sit or to kneel.

    It is easy to sneer at such points as trifles and to make sport of those who call attention to them; but if it is worth our while to have ritual worship at all it is also worth our while to make the directions as to how people are to behave adequate, explicit, plain. A lofty contempt for detail is not the token of good administration either in Church or State.

    To the list of defective rubrics add those that are confessedly obsolete and such as are palpably contradictory and we have a bill of particulars that would amply justify a rubrical revision of the Prayer Book even if nothing more were to be attempted.

    There is another reason. Far more rapidly than many people imagine, we are drifting away from the position of a Church that worships by liturgy to that of a Church worshipping by directory.

    The multiplicity of "uses" that vexed the Anglican Reformers is in our day multiplied four-fold. To those who honestly consider a directory a better thing than a liturgy this process of relaxation is most welcome, but for others who hold that, until the binding clauses of a Book of Common Prayer have been formally rescinded, they ought to be observed, the spectacle is the reverse of edifying.

    They would much prefer seeing the channels of liberty opened at the touch of law, and this is one of their chief reasons for advocating revision.

    Two questions remain untouched, both of them of great practical importance. Could the Prayer Book be enriched to the extent suggested in this paper without a serious and most undesirable increase in its bulk as a volume?

    Even supposing this were possible, is it at all likely that the Church could be persuaded to accept the amended book?

    Unless the first of these two eminently proper questions can be met, there is, or ought to be, an end to all talk about revision.

    The advantage to a Church of being able to keep all its authoritative formularies of worship within the compass of a single volume is inestimable. Even the present enforced severance of the Hymnal from the Prayer Book is a misfortune.[32]

    Those were good days when "Bible and Prayer Book" was the Churchman's all sufficient formula so far as volumes were concerned.

    Rome boasts a much larger ritual variety than ours, but she secures it by multiplying books. The Missal is in one volume, the Breviary in four, the Pontifical, the Ritual, and the Ceremonial in one each, making eight in all.[33] This is an evil, and one from which we Anglicans have had a happy escape. It was evidently with a great groan of relief that the Church of England shook herself free from the whole host of service-books, and established her one only volume. It behooves us to be watchful how we take a single step towards becoming entangled in the old meshes.[34]

    But need the enrichment of the Prayer Book--such enrichment as has been described, necessarily involve an unwieldiness in the volume, or, what would be still worse, an overflow into a supplement?

    Certainly not; for by judicious management every change advocated in this paper, and more besides, might be accomplished without transgressing by so much as a page or a paragraph the limits of the present standard book. All the space needed could be secured by the simple expedient of omitting matter that has been found by actual experience to be superfluous. Redundancy and unnecessary repetition are to the discredit of a book that enjoys such an unrivalled reputation as the Common Prayer. They are blemishes upon the face of its literary perfectness.

    Who has not marvelled at the strange duplication of the Litany and the Office of the Holy Communion in the Ordinal, when the special petitions proper to those services when used in that connection might easily have been printed by themselves with a direction that they be inserted in the appointed place?

    Scholars, of course, know perfectly well how this came about. The Ordinal does not belong to the Prayer Book proper, but has a separate identity of its own. When printed as a book by itself it is all very well that it should include the Litany and the Holy Communion in full, but why allow these superfluous pages to crowd out others that are really needed?[35]

    It has already been explained how the room now occupied by the "Selections" might be economized, and by the same simple device the space engrossed by divers psalms here and there in the Occasional Offices, e. g., Psalm li in the Visitation of Prisoners, and Psalm cxxx in the Visitation of the Sick could be made available for other use.

    Again, why continue to devote a quarter of a page of precious space to the "Prayer for imprisoned debtors," seeing that now, for a long time past, there has been no such thing in the United States as imprisonment for debt? By availing ourselves of only a portion of these possible methods of garnering space, all that is desired might be accomplished, without making the Prayer Book bulkier by a single leaf than it is to-day.

    But would a Prayer Book thus enriched be accepted by the Church at large? Is there any reason to think that the inertia which inheres in all large bodies, and to a singularly marked degree in our own Communion, could be overcome? The General Convention can give an approximate answer to these questions; it cannot settle them decisively, for it is a body which mirrors only to a certain extent the real mind and temper of the constituencies represented in it.

    One thing is certain, that only by allowing fullest possible play to the principle of "local option" could any wholly new piece of work on the part of revisionists, however excellent it might be in itself considered, find acceptance. To allow features introduced into the body of an existing service to be accounted optional, would indeed be impossible, without gendering the very wildest confusion. Upon such points the Church would have to decide outright, for or against, and stand by her decisions.

    But as respects every additional and novel Office proposed, the greatest care ought to be taken to have the indefinite An rather than the definite The prefixed to it. Before such new uses are made binding on all, they must have met and endured the test of thorough trial by some. This is only fair.

    But there is a limit, it must be remembered, in the Church's case to the binding power of precedent and prescription. The social order changes, and of these tides that ebb and flow it is our bounden duty to take note. Had mere aversion to change, dogged unwillingness to venture an experiment always carried the day, instead of having the "Prayer Book as it is," we should still be drearily debating the rival merits of Hereford and Sarum.

    The great question to be settled is, Does an emergency exist serious enough to warrant an attempt on our part to make better what we know already to be good? Is the Republic expecting of us, and reasonably expecting of us, greater things than with our present equipment we are quite able to accomplish? There are eyes that think they see a great future before this Church--are they right, or is it only mirage? At any rate ours is no return trip--we are outward bound.

    The ship is cutting new and untried waters with her keel at every moment. There is no occasion to question the sufficiency of either compass or helm, but in certain matters of a practical sort there is a demand upon us to use judgment, we are bound to give a place in our seamanship to present common-sense as well as to respect for ancient usage, and along with it all to feel some confidence that if the ship is what we think her to be, "the winds of God" may be trusted to bring her safely into port.

    THE BOOK ANNEXED: ITS CRITICS AND ITS PROSPECTS.

    THE BOOK ANNEXED: ITS CRITICS AND ITS PROSPECTS.[36]

    First, last, and always this is to be said with respect to the revision of the American Common Prayer, that unless we can accomplish it with hearty good feeling the attempt at improvement ought to be abandoned altogether.

    The day has gone by when new formularies of worship could be imposed on an unwilling Church by edict, and although under our carefully guarded system of ecclesiastical legislation there is little danger of either haste or unfairness, we must bear it well in mind that something more than "a constitutional majority of both houses" is needful if we would see liturgical revision crowned with real success. Of course, absolute unanimity is not to be expected.

    Every improvement that the world has seen was greeted at its birth by a chorus of select voices sounding the familiar anthem, "The old is better"; and the generation of those, who, in the sturdy phrase of King James's revisers, "give liking unto nothing but what is framed by themselves, and hammered on their anvil," will be always with us. But substantial unanimity may exist, even when absolute unanimity is impossible, and if anything like as general a consent can be secured for revision in 1886 as was given to it in 1883, the friends of the movement will have good reason to be satisfied.

    That there has been, since the publication of The Book Annexed as Modified, a certain measure of reaction against the spirit of change must be evident to all who watch carefully the pulse of public opinion in the Church. Whether this reaction be as serious as some imagine, whether it have good reasons to allege, and whether it be not already giving tokens of spent force, are points which in the present paper will be touched only incidentally, for the writer's purpose is rather irenic than polemical, and he is more concerned to remove misapprehensions and allay fears than to seek the fading leaf of a controversial victory.

    LIMITATIONS.

    No estimate of the merits and demerits of The Book Annexed can be a just one that leaves out of account the limitations under which the framers of it did their work. These limitations were not unreasonable ones. It was right and proper that they should be imposed. There is no good ground for a belief that the time will ever come when a "blank cheque," to borrow Mr. Goschen's mercantile figure, will be given to any company of liturgical revisers to fill out as they may see fit.

    But the moulders of forms, in whatever department of plastic art their specialty lies, when challenged to show cause why their work is deficient in symmetry or completeness, have an undoubted right to plead in reply the character of the conditions under which they labored. The present instance offers no exception to the general rule.

    In the first place, a distinct pledge was given in the House of Deputies, in 1880, before consent to the appointment of the Joint Committee was secured, that in case such permission to launch a movement in favor of revision as was asked for were to be granted, no attempt would be made seriously to change the Liturgy proper, namely, the Office of the Holy Communion.

    The question was distinctly asked by a clerical deputy from the diocese of Maryland,[37] Do you desire to modify the Office of the Holy Communion? and it was as distinctly answered by the mover of the resolution under which the Joint Committee was finally appointed, No, we do not. It is true that such a pledge, made by a single member of one House, could only measurably control the action of a Joint Committee in which both Houses were to be represented; but it is equally plain that the maker of the pledge was in honor bound to do all in his power to secure the observance of its terms.

    Let this historical fact be noted by those who are disposed to complain that the Joint Committee did not pull to pieces and entirely rearrange the Anglo-Scoto-American Office, which now for a long time, and until quite recently, we have been taught to esteem the nearest possible approach to liturgical perfection.

    Under this same head of "limitations" must be set down the following resolutions passed by the Joint Committee itself, at its first regular meeting:

    Resolved, That this Committee asserts, at the outset, its conviction that no alteration should be made touching either statements or standards of doctrine in the Book of Common Prayer.

    Resolved, That this Committee, in all its suggestions and acts, be guided by those principles of liturgical construction and ritual use which have guided the compilation and amendments of the Book of Common Prayer, and have made it what it is.

    It was manifestly impossible, under resolutions like these, to depart very widely from established precedent, or in any serious measure to disturb the foundations of things.

    The first of them shut out wholly the consideration of such questions as the reinstatement of the Athanasian Creed or the proposal to make optional the use of the word "regenerate" in the Baptismal Offices; while the other forbade the introduction of such sentimental and grotesque conceits as "An Office for the Blessing of Candles," "An Office for the Benediction of a Lifeboat," and "An Office for the Reconciliation of a Lapsed Cleric."[38]

    Still another very serious limitation, and one especially unfriendly to that perfectness of contour which we naturally look to see in a liturgical formulary, grew out of the tender solicitude of the Committee for what may be called the vested rights of congregations. There was a strong reluctance to the cutting away even of what might seem to be dead wood, lest there should ensue, or be thought to ensue, the loss of something really valuable.

    It was only as the result of much painstaking effort, and only at some sacrifice of literary fastidiousness, that the Committee was enabled to report a book of which it could be said that, while it added much of possible enrichment, it took away almost nothing that had been in actual possession.[39] There could be no better illustration of this point than is afforded by certain of the alterations proposed to be made in the Order for Evening Prayer.

    The Committee felt assured that upon no point was the judgment of the Church likely to be more unanimous than in approving the restoration to their time-honored home in the Evening Office of Magnificat and Nunc dimittis, and yet so unwilling were they to displace Bonum est confiteri and Benedic anima mea from positions they have only occupied since 1789 that they authorized the unquestionably clumsy expedient of printing three responds to each Lesson.

    Probably a large majority of the Committee would have preferred to drop Bonum est confiteri and Benedic anima mea altogether, retaining Cantate Domino and Deus miser eatur as the sole alternates to the two Gospel canticles, as in the English Book, but rather than have a thousand voices cry out, as it was believed they would cry out, "You have robbed us," the device of a second alternate was adopted, to the sad defacement of the printed page.

    In may be charged that, in thus choosing, the Committee betrayed timidity, and that a wise boldness would have been the better course; but if account be taken of the attitude consistently maintained by General Convention towards any proposition for the change of so much as a comma in the Prayer Book, during a period of fifty years prior to the introduction of The Book Annexed, it will perhaps be concluded that for the characterization of the Committee's policy timidity is scarcely so proper a word as caution.

    SPECIAL CRITICISMS.

    (a) Foreign.

    As there is reason to believe that opinion at home has been very considerably affected by foreign criticism of The Book Annexed, it will be well at this point to give some attention to what has been said in English journals in review of the work thus far accomplished. The more note

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer
    Author
    William Reed Huntington
    Release date
    September 30, 2009 [eBook #30136]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Elaine Laizure
    Most recently updated
    October 24, 2024
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    [Transcriber's Note: The footnotes have been numbered and moved to
    the end of the document.]
    
    This file was produced from images generously made available by
    The Internet Archive/American Libraries.
    
    
    A SHORT HISTORY OF THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER
    
    TOGETHER WITH
    
    CERTAIN PAPERS ILLUSTRATIVE OF LITURGICAL REVISION 1878-1892
    
    
    
    
    BY
    
    
    
    WILLIAM REED HUNTINGTON D. D. D. C. L.
    
    _Rector of Grace Church New York_
    
    
    
    
    NEW YORK THOMAS WHITTAKER
    
    2 and 3 Bible House
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    Copyright, 1893,
    
    by
    
    THOMAS WHITTAKER,
    
    
    
    THE MERSHON COMPANY PRESS, RAHWAY, N. J.
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    
    I. A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer:
    
    I. Origins,
    
    II. Vicissitudes,
    
    II. Revision of the American Common Prayer,
    
    III. _The Book Annexed_: Its Critics and its Prospects,
    
    Appendix:
    
    I. Permanent and Variable Characteristics of the Prayer Book--A
    Sermon Before Revision, 1878
    
    II. The Outcome of Revision, 1892
    
    III. Tabular View of Additions Made at the Successive Revisions,
    1552-1892
    
    
    
    
    INTRODUCTORY NOTE.
    
    
    The opening paper of this collection was originally read as a
    lecture before a liturgical class, and is now published for the
    first time. The others have appeared in print from time to time
    during the movement for revision. If they have any permanent
    value, it is because of their showing, so far as the writer's part
    in the matter is concerned, what things were attempted and what
    things failed of accomplishment. Should they serve as contributory
    to some future narrative of the revision, the object of their
    publication will have been accomplished. So much has been said as
    to the poverty of our gains on the side of "enrichment," as
    compared with what has been secured in the line of "flexibility,"
    that it has seemed proper to append to the volume a Comparative
    Table detailing the additions of liturgical matter made to the
    Common Prayer at the successive revisions.
    
    W. R. H. New York, Christmas, 1892.
    
    
    
    A SHORT HISTORY OF THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER.
    
    
    
    
    A SHORT HISTORY OF THE BOOK OF COMMON PRAYER.
    
    
    I. ORIGINS.
    
    
    Liturgical worship, understood in the largest sense the phrase can
    bear, means divine service rendered in accordance with an established
    form. Of late years there has been an attempt made among purists to
    confine the word "liturgy" to the office entitled in the Prayer
    Book, _The Order for the Administration of the Lord's Supper or
    Holy Communion_.
    
    This restricted and specialized interpretation of a familiar word
    may serve the purposes of technical scholarship, for undoubtedly
    there is much to be said in favor of the narrowed signification as
    we shall see; but unless English literature can be rewritten, plain
    people who draw their vocabulary from standard authors will go on
    calling service-books "liturgies" regardless of the fact that they
    contain many things other than that one office which is entitled
    to be named by eminence _the_ Liturgy. "This Convention," write the
    fathers of the American Episcopal Church in the Ratification printed
    on the fourth page of the Prayer Book, "having in their present
    session set forth a Book of Common Prayer and other rites and
    ceremonies of the Church, do hereby establish the said book; and
    they declare it to be the _Liturgy_ of this Church."
    
    For the origin of liturgy thus broadly defined we have to go a long
    way back; beyond the Prayer Book, beyond the Mass-book, beyond the
    ancient Sacramentaries, yes, beyond the synagogue worship, beyond
    the temple worship, beyond the tabernacle worship; in fact I am
    disposed to think that, logically, we should be unable to stop
    short until we had reached the very heart of man itself, that
    dimly discerned groundwork we call human nature, and had discovered
    there those two instincts, the one of worship and the other of
    gregariousness, from whence all forms of common prayer have sprung.
    Where three or two assemble for the purposes of supplication, some
    form must necessarily be accepted if they are to pray in unison.
    When the disciples came to Jesus begging him that he would teach
    them how to pray, he gave them, not twelve several forms, though
    doubtless James's special needs differed from John's and Simon's
    from Jude's--he gave them, not twelve, but one. "When ye pray,"
    was his answer, "say Our Father." That was the beginning of
    Christian Common Prayer. Because we are men we worship, because
    we are fellow-men our worship must have form.
    
    But waiving this last analysis of all which carries us across the
    whole field of history at a leap, it becomes necessary to seek
    for liturgical beginnings by a more plodding process.
    
    If we take that manual of worship with which as English-speaking
    Christians we are ourselves the most familiar, the Book of Common
    Prayer, and allow it to fall naturally apart, as a bunch of
    flowers would do if the string were cut, we discover that in
    point of fact we have, as in the case of the Bible, many books
    in one. We have scarcely turned the title-page, for instance,
    before we come upon a ritual of daily worship, an order for
    Morning Prayer and an order for Evening Prayer, consisting in
    the main of Psalms, Scripture Lessons, Antiphonal Versicles,
    and Collects. Appended to this we find a Litany or General
    Supplication and a collection of special prayers.
    
    Mark an interval here, and note that we have completed the first
    volume of our liturgical library. Next, we have a sacramental
    ritual, entitled, _The Order for the Administration of the Lord's
    Supper or Holy Communion_, ingeniously interwoven by a system of
    appropriate prayers and New Testament readings with the Sundays
    and holydays of the year. This gives us our second volume.
    Then follow numerous offices which we shall find it convenient
    to classify under two heads, namely: those which may be said by
    a bishop or by a presbyter, and those that may be said by a
    bishop only. Under the former head come the baptismal offices,
    the Order for the Burial of the Dead, and the like; under the
    latter, the services of Ordination and Confirmation and the Form
    of Consecration of a Church or Chapel.
    
    In the Church of England as it existed before the Reformation,
    these four volumes, as I have called them, were distinct and
    recognized realities. Each had its title and each its separate
    use. The name of the book of daily services was _The Breviary_.
    The name of the book used in the celebration of the Holy Communion
    was _The Missal_. The name of the book of Special Offices was
    _The Ritual_. The name of the book of such offices as could be
    used by a bishop only was _The Pontifical_. It was one of the
    greatest of the achievements of the English reformers that they
    succeeded in condensing, after a practical fashion, these four
    books, or, to speak more accurately, the first three of them,
    Breviary, Missal, and Ritual, into one. The Pontifical, or
    Ordinal, they continued as a separate book, although it soon for
    the sake of convenience became customary in England, as it has
    always been customary here, for Prayer Book and Ordinal to be
    stitched together by the binders into a single volume. Popularly
    speaking the Prayer Book is the entire volume one purchases under
    that name from the bookseller, but accurately speaking the Book
    of Common Prayer ends where _The Form and Manner of Making,
    Ordaining, and Consecrating Bishops, Priests, and Deacons_
    begins. "Finis" should be written after the Psalter, as indeed
    from the Prayer Book's Table of Contents plainly appears.
    
    Setting aside now, for the present, that portion of the formularies
    which corresponds to the Ritual and Pontifical of the mediaeval
    Church, I proceed to speak rapidly of the antecedents of Breviary
    and Missal. Whence came they? And how are we to account for
    their being sundered so distinctly as they are?
    
    They came, so some of the most thoughtful of liturgical students
    are agreed, from a source no less remote than the Temple of
    Solomon, and they are severed, to speak figuratively, by a valley
    not unlike that which in our thoughts divides the Mount of
    Beatitudes from the Hill of Calvary.
    
    In that memorable building to which reference was just made,
    influential over the destinies of our race as no other house of
    man's making ever was, there went on from day to day these two
    things, psalmody and sacrifice. Peace-offering, burnt-offering,
    sin-offering, the morning oblation, and the evening oblation--these
    with other ceremonies of a like character went to make what we
    know as the sacrificial ritual of the temple.
    
    But this was not all. It would appear that there were other
    services in the temple over and above those that could strictly
    be called sacrificial. The Hebrew Psalter, the hymn-book of that
    early day, contains much that was evidently intended by the
    writers for temple use, and even more that could be easily
    adapted to such use. And although there is no direct evidence
    that in Solomon's time forms of prayer other than those associated
    with sacrificial rites were in use, yet when we find mention in
    the New Testament of people going up to the temple of those later
    days "at the hour of prayer," it seems reasonable to infer that
    the custom was an ancient one, and that from the beginning of the
    temple's history forms of worship not strictly speaking sacrificial
    had been a stated feature of the ritual. But whether in the temple
    or not, certainly in the synagogues, which after the return from
    the captivity sprang up all over the Jewish world, services
    composed of prayers, of psalms, and of readings from the law and
    the prophets were of continual occurrence. Therefore we may safely
    say that with these two forms of divine service, the sacrificial
    and the simply devotional and didactic, the apostles, the founders
    of the Christian Church, had been familiar from their childhood.
    They were at home in both synagogue and temple. They knew by sight
    the ritual of the altar, and by ear the ritual of the choir. They
    were accustomed to the spectacle of the priest offering the victim;
    they were used to hearing the singers chant the psalms.
    
    We see thus why it is that the public worship of the Church should
    have come down to us in two great lines, why there should be a
    tradition of eucharistic worship and, parallel to this, a tradition
    of daily prayer; for as the one usage links itself, in a sense,
    to the sacrificial system of God's ancient people and has in it a
    suggestion of the temple worship, so the other seems to show a
    continuity with what went on in those less pretentious sanctuaries
    which had place in all the cities and villages of Judea, and indeed
    wherever, throughout the Roman world, Jewish colonists were to be
    found. The earliest Christian disciples having been themselves
    Hebrews, nothing could have been more natural than their moulding
    the worship of the new Church in general accordance with the
    models that had stood before their eyes from childhood in the
    old. The Psalms were sung in the synagogues according to a settled
    principle. We cannot wonder, then, that the Psalter should have
    continued to be what in fact it had always been, the hymn-book of
    the Church. Moreover, they had in the synagogue besides their
    psalmody a system of Bible readings, confined, of course, to the
    Old Testament Scriptures. This is noted in the observation that
    fell from Simon Peter, at the first Council of the Church, "Moses
    of old time hath in every city them that preach him, being read in
    the synagogue every Sabbath day." Scripture lessons, therefore,
    would be no novelty.
    
    We gather also from the New Testament, not to speak of other
    authorities, that in the apostolic days people were familiar with
    what were known as "hours of prayer." There were particular times
    in the day, that is to say, which were held to be especially
    appropriate for worship. "Peter and John went up together into
    the temple at the hour of prayer, being the ninth hour." Again,
    at Joppa, we find the former of these two apostles going up upon
    the house-top to pray at "the sixth hour." Long before this David
    had mentioned morning and evening and noon as fitting hours of
    prayer, and one psalmist, in his enthusiasm, had even gone so far
    as to declare seven times a day to be not too often for giving
    God thanks. There was also the precedent of Daniel opening his
    windows toward Jerusalem three times a day. As the love for order
    and system grew year by year stronger in the Christian Church,
    the laws that govern ritual would be likely to become more
    stringent, and so very probably it came to pass. For aught we
    know to the contrary, the observance of fixed hours of prayer
    was a matter of voluntary action with the Christians of the first
    age. There was, as we say, no "shall" about it. But when the
    founders of the monastic orders came upon the scene a fixed rule
    took the place of simple custom, and what had been optional
    became mandatory. By the time we reach the mediaeval period
    evolution has had its perfect work, and we find in existence
    a scheme of daily service curiously and painfully elaborate.
    The mediaeval theologians were very fond of classifying things
    by sevens. In the symbolism of Holy Scripture seven appears as
    the number of perfection, it being the aggregate of three, the
    number of Deity, and four, the number of the earth. Accordingly
    we find in the theology of those times seven sacraments, seven
    deadly sins, seven contrary virtues, seven works of mercy, and
    also seven hours of prayer. These seven hours were known as
    Matins, Prime, Tierce, Sext, Nones, Vespers, and Complene. The
    theory of the hours of prayer was that at each one of them a
    special office of devotion was to be said. Beginning before
    sunrise with matins there was to be daily a round of services at
    stated intervals culminating at bedtime in that which, as its
    name indicated, filled out the series, Complene. To what extent
    this ideal scheme of devotion was ever carried out in practice it
    is difficult positively to say.
    
    Probably in the monastic and conventual life of the severer orders
    there was an approximation to a punctual observance of the hours
    as they successively arrived. Possibly the modern mind fails to
    do full justice to the conception of worship on which this system
    was based. Those principles of devotion of which the rosary is the
    visible symbol do not easily commend themselves to us. They have
    about them a suggestion of mechanism. They remind us of the
    Buddhist praying wheel, and seem to put the Church in the attitude
    of expecting to be heard for her "much speaking."
    
    Doubtless many a pure, courageous spirit fought the good fight
    of faith successfully in spite of all this weight of outward
    observances; but in the judgment of the wiser heads among English
    churchmen, the time had come, by the middle of the sixteenth
    century, when this complicated armor must either be greatly
    lightened or else run the risk of being cast aside altogether.
    Let Cranmer tell his own story. This is what he says in the
    Preface to the First Book of Edward VI. as to the ritual grievances
    of the times. The passage is worth listening to if only for the
    quaintness of its strong and wholesome English:
    
    "There was never anything by the wit of man so well devised or so
    surely established which, in continuance of time, hath not been
    corrupted, as, among other things, it may plainly appear by the
    common prayer, in the Church, commonly called divine service. The
    first original and ground whereof, if a man would search out by
    the ancient fathers, he shall find that the same was not ordained
    but of a good purpose, and for a great advancement of godliness, for
    they so ordered the matter that all the whole Bible, or the greatest
    part thereof, should be read over once in the year . . . But these
    many years past this godly and decent order of the ancient fathers
    hath been so altered, broken, and neglected by planting in
    uncertain stories, legends, responds, verses, vain repetitions,
    commemorations, and synodals that commonly, when any book of the
    Bible was begun, before three or four chapters were read out all
    the rest were unread. And in this sort the Book of Esaie was begun
    in Advent, and the Book of Genesis in Septuagesima, but they were
    only begun and never read through . . . And moreover, whereas St.
    Paul would have such language spoken to the people in the Church
    as they might understand and have profit by hearing the same, the
    service in this Church of England (these many years) hath been
    read in Latin to the people, which they understood not, so that
    they have heard with their ears only, and their hearts, spirit,
    and mind have not been edified thereby . . . Moreover, the number
    and hardness of the rules called the Pie, and the manifold
    changings of the service was the cause that to turn the Book
    only was so hard and intricate a matter that many times there was
    more business to find out what should be read than it was to read
    it when it was found out. These inconveniences therefore considered,
    here is set forth such an order whereby the same shall be
    redressed."
    
    As an illustration of what Cranmer meant by his curious phrase,
    "planting in uncertain stories," take the following Lessons quoted
    by Dr. Neale in his _Essays on Liturgiology_:
    
    "Besides the commemoration of saints," writes this distinguished
    antiquarian, "there are in certain local calenders notices of
    national events connected with the well-being of the Church. Thus,
    in the _Parisian Breviary_, we have on the eighteenth of August a
    commemoration of the victory of Philip the Fair in Flanders, A.D.
    1304." Here is the fourth of the appointed lessons: "Philip the
    Fair, King of the French, in the year 1304, about the feast of St.
    Mary Magdalene, having set forth with his brothers Charles and
    Louis and a large army into Flanders, pitched his tent near Mons,
    where was a camp of the rebel Flemings. But when, on the eighteenth
    of August, which was the Tuesday after the Assumption of St. Mary,
    the French had from morning till evening stood on the defence, and
    were resting themselves at nightfall, the enemy, by a sudden
    attack, rushed on the camp with such fury that the body-guard had
    scarce time to defend him.
    
    "_Response_. Come from Lebanon, my spouse; come, and thou shalt be
    crowned, The odor of thy sweet ointments is above all perfumes.
    _Versicle_. The righteous judge shall give a crown of righteousness."
    
    Then, after this short interlude of snatches from Holy Scripture,
    there follows the Fifth Lesson: "At the beginning of the fight the
    life of the king was in great danger, but shortly after, his
    troops crowding together from all quarters to his tent, where the
    battle was sharpest, obtained an illustrious victory over the
    enemy"--and more of this sort until all of a sudden we come upon
    the Song of Solomon again. "_V_. Thou art all fair, my love; come
    from Lebanon. _R_. They that have not defiled their garments,
    they shall walk with me in white, for they are worthy."
    
    Is not Cranmer's contemptuous mention of these uncertain legends
    and vain repetitions amply justified? And can we be too thankful
    to the sturdy champions of the Reformation, who in the face of no
    little opposition and by efforts scarcely appreciated to-day, cut
    us loose from all responsibility for such solemn nonsense?
    
    There are some who feel aggrieved that chapters from the Apocrypha
    should have found admission to our new lectionary, and there are
    even those who think that of the canonical Scriptures, passages
    more edifying than certain of those appointed to be read might
    have been chosen, but what would they think if they were compelled
    to hear the minister at the lecturn say: "Here beginneth the first
    chapter of the Adventures of Philip the Fair"?
    
    But the reformers, happily, were not discouraged by the portentous
    front of wood, hay, and stubble which the liturgical edifice of
    their day presented to the eye. They felt convinced that there
    were also to be found mixed in with the building material gold,
    silver, and precious stones, and for these they determined to make
    diligent search, resolved most of all that the foundation laid
    should be Jesus Christ. This system of canonical hours, they
    argued, this seven-fold office of daily prayer is all very
    beautiful in theory, but it never can be made what in fact it
    never in the past has been, a practicable thing. Let us be content
    if we can do so much as win people to their devotions at morning
    and at night. With this object in view Cranmer and his associates
    subjected the services of the hours to a process of combination
    and condensation. The Offices for the first three hours they
    compressed into _An Order for Daily Morning Prayer_, or, as it was
    called in Edward's first Book, _An Order for Matins_, and the
    Offices for the last two hours, namely, Vespers and Complene,
    they made over into _An Order for Daily Evening Prayer_, or, as
    it was named in Edward's first Book, _An Order for Evensong_.
    
    These two formularies, the _Order for Matins_ and the _Order for
    Evensong_, make the core and substance of our present daily
    offices. But the tradition of daily prayer is only one of the
    two great devotional heritages of the Church. With the destruction
    of the temple by the Roman soldiery, the sacrificial ritual of
    the Jewish Church came to a sudden end; but it was not God's
    purpose that the memory of sacrifice should fade out of men's
    minds or that the thought of sacrifice should be banished from
    the field of worship. Years before the day when the legionaries
    of Titus marched amid flame and smoke, into the falling sanctuary
    of an out-worn faith, one who was presently to die upon a cross
    had taken bread, had blessed it and broken it, and giving it to
    certain followers gathered about him, had said, "Take, eat; this
    is my body, which is given for you: this do in remembrance of me."
    Likewise also he had taken the cup after supper, saying, "This cup
    is the New Testament in my blood which is shed for you."
    
    Certainly there must be a relation of cause and effect between this
    scene and the fact, which is a fact, that the most ancient
    fragments of primitive Christian worship now discoverable are
    forms for the due commemoration of the sacrifice of the death of
    Christ.
    
    These venerable monuments seem to exclaim as we decipher them:
    "Even so, Lord, it is done as thou didst say." "Thy name, O Lord,
    endureth forever and so doth thy memorial from generation to
    generation." Of the references to Christian worship discoverable
    in documents later than the New Testament Scriptures there are
    three that stand out with peculiar prominence, namely, the lately
    discovered _Teaching of the Twelve Apostles_, placed by some
    authorities as early as the first half of the second century;
    the famous letter of Pliny to the Emperor Trajan, a writing of
    the same period; and the Apology or Defence addressed by Justin
    Martyr to Antoninus Pius about the year 140 after Christ. The
    noteworthy fact in connection with these passages is that of the
    three, two certainly, and probably the third also, refer directly
    to the Holy Communion. In the _Teaching_ we have a distinct sketch
    of a eucharistic service with three of the prescribed prayers
    apparently given in full. In Justin Martyr's account, the evidence
    of a definitely established liturgical form is perhaps less plain,
    but nothing that he says would appear to be irreconcilable with
    the existence of a more or less elastic ritual order. Whether he
    does or does not intend to describe extemporaneous prayer as
    forming one feature of the eucharistic worship of the Christians
    of his time depends upon the translation we give to a single word
    in his narrative. Later on in the life of the Church, though by
    just how much later is a difficult point of scholarship, we are
    brought in contact with a number of formularies, all of them
    framed for the uses of eucharistical worship, all of them, that
    is to say, designed to perpetuate the commandment, "This do in
    remembrance of me," and all of them preserving, no matter in what
    part of the world they may be found, a certain structural
    uniformity. These are the primitive liturgies, as they are
    called, the study of which has in late years attained almost to
    the dignity of a science. As to the exact measure of antiquity
    that ought to be accorded to these venerable documents the
    authorities differ and probably will always differ. Dr. Neale's
    enthusiasm carried him so far that he was persuaded and sought
    to persuade others of the existence of liturgical quotations in
    the writings of St. Paul. This hypothesis is at the present time
    generally rejected by sober-minded scholars. Perhaps "the personal
    equation" enters equally into the conclusions of those who assign
    a very late origin to the liturgies, pushing them along as far as
    the sixth or seventh century. If one happens to have a rooted
    dislike for prescribed forms of worship, and believes them in his
    heart to be both unscriptural and unspiritual, it will be the
    most natural thing in the world for him to disparage whatever
    evidence makes in favor of the early origin of liturgies. Hammond
    is sensible when he says in the Preface to his valuable work
    entitled _Liturgies Eastern and Western_, "I have assumed an
    intermediate position between the views of those on the one hand
    who hold that the liturgies had assumed a recognized and fixed
    form so early as to be quoted in the Epistles to the Corinthians
    and Hebrews . . . and of those, on the other, who because there are
    some palpable interpolations and marks of comparatively late date
    in some of the texts, assert broadly that they are all untrustworthy
    and valueless as evidence. This view I venture to think," he adds,
    "equally uncritical and groundless with the former."
    
    To sum up, the argument in behalf of an apostolic origin for the
    Christian Liturgy may be compactly stated thus: The very earliest
    monuments of Christian worship that we possess are rituals of
    thanksgiving, having direct reference to the sacrifice of the
    death of Christ. Going back from these to the New Testament we
    find there the narrative of the institution of the Holy Communion
    by Christ himself, and in connection with it the command, "This
    do in remembrance of me." It is, I submit, a reasonable inference
    that the liturgies in the main fairly represent what it was in
    the mind of the apostle to recognize and establish as proper
    Christian worship. I do not call it demonstration, I call it
    reasonable inference. There is a striking parallelism between the
    argument for liturgical worship and the argument for episcopacy.
    In both cases we take the ground that continuity existed between
    the life of the Church as we find it a hundred years after the
    last of the apostles had gone to his rest and the life of the
    Church as it is pictured in the New Testament.
    
    That there were many changes during the interval must no doubt be
    granted, but we say that if those changes were serious ones
    affecting great principles of belief or order, those who maintain
    that such a hidden revolution took place are bound to bring
    positive evidence to the fact. This history of the Church during
    the second century has been likened with more of ingenuity than
    of poetical beauty to the passing of a train through a railway
    tunnel.
    
    We see the train enter, we see it emerge, but its movement while
    inside the tunnel is concealed from us. Similarly we may say that
    we see with comparative distinctness the Christian Church of the
    Apostolic Age, and we see with comparative distinctness the Church
    of the Age of Cyprian and Origen, but with respect to the interval
    separating the two periods we are not indeed wholly, but, we are,
    it must be confessed, very largely ignorant. And yet as in the
    case of the tunnel we confidently affirm an identity between what
    we saw go in and what we see coming out, so with the doctrine,
    discipline, and worship of the Church, the usages of the third
    century, we argue, are probably in their leading features what the
    usages of the first century were. If reason to the contrary can
    be given, well and good; but in the absence of countervailing
    testimony we abide by our inference, holding it to be sound.
    
    I am far from wishing to maintain that these considerations bind
    liturgical worship upon the Christian Church as a matter of
    obligation for all time. It might be argued, and I think with
    great force, that liturgical worship having been universal
    throughout the ancient world, heathen as well as Jewish, the
    apostles and fathers of the Christian Church judged it unwise
    to make any departure at the outset from a custom so invariable,
    trusting it to the spirit of the new religion to work out freer and
    less formal methods of approaching God through Christ in the times
    to come. This, I confess, strikes me as a perfectly legitimate line
    of reasoning and one which is strengthened rather than weakened by
    what we have seen happen in Christendom since the sixteenth
    century. Great bodies of Christians have for a period of some
    three hundred years been worshipping Almighty God in non-liturgical
    ways, and have not been left without witness that their service
    was acceptable to the Divine Majesty. Moreover, the fact that
    absolute rigidity in liturgical use never was insisted upon in
    any age of the Church until the English passed their Act of
    Uniformity, makes in the same direction. And yet even after these
    allowances have been made, there remains a considerable amount
    of solid satisfaction for those who do adhere to the liturgical
    method, in the thought that they are in the line which is apparently
    the line of continuity, and that their interpretation of the
    apostolic purpose with respect to worship is the interpretation
    that has been generally received in Christendom as far back as we
    can go.
    
    
    
    
    II.
    
    VICISSITUDES.
    
    
    Certain of the necromancers of the far East are said to have the
    power of causing a tree to spring up, spread its branches, blossom,
    and bear fruit before the eyes of the lookers-on within the space
    of a few moments.
    
    Modern liturgies have sometimes been brought into being by a process
    as extemporaneous as this, but not such was the genesis of the
    Book of Common Prayer.
    
    There are at least eight forms under which the Prayer Book has
    been from time to time authoritatively set forth--five English,
    one Scottish, one Irish, and one American; so that, if we would
    be accurate, we are bound to specify, when we speak of "The Prayer
    Book," which of several Prayer Books we have in mind.
    
    The truth is, there exists in connection with everything that grows,
    whether it be plant, animal, or building, a certain mystery like
    that which attaches to what, in the case of a man, we call personal
    identity. Which is the true, the actual Napoleon? Is it the
    Napoleon of the Directory, or the Napoleon of the Consulate, or the
    Napoleon of the Empire? At each epoch we discern a different phase
    of the man's character, and yet we are compelled to acknowledge,
    in the face of all the variations, that we have to do with one and
    the same man.
    
    But just as a ship acquires, as we may say, her personal identity
    when she is launched and named, even though there may be a great
    deal yet to be done in the way of finishing and furnishing before
    she can be pronounced seaworthy, so it is with a book that is
    destined to undergo repeated revision and reconstruction, it does
    acquire, on the day when it is first published, and first given a
    distinctive title, a certain character the losing of which would be
    the loss of personal identity. There is many an old cathedral that
    might properly enough be called a re-edited book in stone. Norman
    architecture, Early English, Decorated, and Perpendicular, all are
    there, and yet one dominant thought pervades the building.
    Notwithstanding the many times it has been retouched, the fabric
    still expresses to the eye the original creative purpose of the
    designer; there is no possibility of our mistaking Salisbury for
    York or Peterborough for London.
    
    The first Book of Common Prayer was built up of blocks that for the
    most part had been previously used in other buildings, but the
    resulting structure exhibited, from the very moment it received a
    name, such distinct and unmistakable characteristics as have
    guaranteed it personal identity through more than three hundred
    years. Hence, while it is in one sense true that there are no
    fewer than eight Books of Common Prayer, it is in another sense
    equally true that the Book of Common Prayer is one.
    
    An identity of purpose, of scope, and of spirit shows itself
    in all its various forms under which the book exists, so that
    whether we are speaking of the First Prayer Book of King Edward
    the Sixth, or of the book adopted by the Church of Ireland after
    its disestablishment, or of the American Book of Common Prayer,
    what we have in mind is, in a very real and deep sense, one and
    the same thing.
    
    Let us proceed now to a rapid survey of the facts connected with
    the first issue of the Common Prayer.
    
    For a period long anterior to the Reformation there had been in
    use among the English brief books of devotion known as "primers,"
    written in the language of the people. The fact that the public
    services of the Church were invariably conducted in the Latin
    tongue made a resort to such expedients as this necessary, unless
    religion was to be reserved as the private property of ecclesiastics.
    
    By a curious process of evolution the primer, from having been
    in mediaeval times a book wholly religious and devotional, has
    come to be in our day a book wholly secular and educational. We
    associate it with Noah Webster and the Harper Brothers. The New
    England Primer of the Puritans, with its odd jumble of piety and
    the three R's, marks a point of transition from the ancient to the
    modern type.
    
    But this by the way. The primer we are now concerned with is the
    devotional primer of the times just previous to the Reformation.
    This, as a rule, contained prayers, the Belief, the Ave Maria, a
    litany of some sort, the Ten Commandments, and whatever else there
    might be that in the mind of the compiler came under the head of
    "things which a Christian ought to know." There were three of
    these primers set forth during the reign of Henry the Eighth, one
    in 1535, one in 1539, and one in 1545. During the space that
    intervened between the publication of the second and that of the
    third of these primers, appeared "The Litany and Suffrages," a
    formulary compiled, as is generally believed, by Cranmer, the then
    Archbishop of Canterbury, and in substance identical with the Litany
    we use to-day. This Litany of 1544 has been properly described as
    "the precursor and first instalment of the English Book of Common
    Prayer." It was the nucleus or centre of crystallization about
    which the other constituent portions of our manual of worship
    were destined to be grouped. A quaint exhortation was prefixed to
    this Litany, in which it was said to have been set forth "because
    the not understanding the prayers and suffrages formerly used
    caused that the people came but slackly to the processions."
    Besides the primers and the Litany, there were printed in Henry's
    reign various editions of a book of Epistles and Gospels in English.
    There was also published a Psalter in Latin and English.
    
    All this looked rather to the edification of individual Christians
    in their private devotional life than to the public worship of the
    Church, but we are not to suppose that meanwhile the larger
    interests of the whole body were forgotten. So early as in the
    year 1542, Convocation, which according to the Anglican theory
    stands toward the Church in the same attitude that Parliament holds
    to the State, appointed a Committee of Eight to review and correct
    the existing service-books. We know very little as to the proceedings
    of this committee, but that something was done, and a real impulse
    given to liturgical revision, is evidenced by the fact that at a
    meeting of Convocation held soon after King Henry's death a
    resolution prevailed "That the books of the Bishops and others who
    by the command of the Convocation have labored in examining,
    reforming, and publishing the divine service, may be produced
    and laid before the examination of this house."
    
    The next important step in the process we are studying was the
    publication by authority in the early spring of 1548, of an Order
    of the Communion, as it was called, a formulary prepared by Cranmer
    to enable the priest, after having consecrated the elements in
    the usual manner, to distribute them to the people with the
    sentences of delivery spoken in English. The priest, that is to
    say, was to proceed with the service of the Mass as usual in the
    Latin tongue, but after he had himself received the bread and
    the wine, he was to proceed to a service of Communion for the
    people in a speech they could understand.
    
    Almost everything in this tentative document, as we may call it,
    was subsequently incorporated in the Office of the Holy Communion
    as we are using it to-day.
    
    We have, then, as an abiding result of the liturgical experiments
    made in anticipation of the actual setting forth of an authoritative
    Prayer Book, the Litany and this Order of the Communion.
    
    The time was now ripe for something better and more complete; a
    new king was upon the throne, and one whose counsellors were
    better disposed toward change than ever Henry had been. The great
    movement we know under the name of the Reformation touched the
    life of the Christian Church in every one of its three great
    departments--doctrine, discipline, and worship. In Henry's mind,
    however, the question appears to have been almost exclusively one
    of discipline or polity. His quarrel was not with the accepted
    theological errors of his day, for as Defender of the Faith he
    covered some of the worst of them with his shield. Neither was
    he ill-disposed toward the methods and usages of public worship
    so far as we can judge. His quarrel first, last, and always was
    with a certain rival claimant of power, whose pretended authority
    he was determined to drive out of the realm, to wit, the Pope.
    But while it was thus with Henry, it was far otherwise with many
    of the more thoughtful and devout among his theologians, and
    when the restraint that had been laid on them was removed by
    the king's death, they welcomed the opportunity to apply to
    doctrine and worship the same reforming touch that had already
    remoulded polity.
    
    An enlarged Committee of Convocation sat at Windsor in the summer
    of 1548, and as a result there was finally set forth, and ordered
    to be put into use on Whitsunday, 1549, what has become known in
    history as the "First Prayer Book of Edward VI."
    
    To dwell on those features of the First Book that have remained
    unaltered to the present day would be superfluous; I shall
    therefore, in speaking of it, confine myself to the distinctive
    and characteristic points in which it differs from the Prayer
    Books that have succeeded it.
    
    It is worthy of note that in the title page of the First Book
    there is a clear distinction drawn between the Church Universal,
    or what we call in the _Te Deum_ "the holy Church throughout all
    the world," and that particular Church to which King Edward's
    subjects, in virtue of their being Englishmen, belonged. The book
    is said to be "the Book of the Common Prayer and administration of
    the Sacraments and other Rites and Ceremonies of _The Church_,
    after the use of the Church of England." "_The Church_" is
    recognized as being a larger and, perhaps, older thing than the
    _Church of England_, while at the same time it is intimated that
    only through such use of these same prayers and sacraments as the
    English Church ordains and authorizes can English folk come into
    communion with the great family of believers spread over the whole
    earth.
    
    The Preface is a singularly racy piece of English, in which with
    the utmost plainness of speech the compilers give their reasons
    for having dealt with the old services as they have done. This
    reappears in the English Prayer Book of the present day under the
    title "Concerning the Service of The Church," and so described is
    placed after the Preface written in 1662 by the Revisers of the
    Restoration.
    
    The Order for Daily Morning Prayer, as we name it, is called in
    Edward's First Book "An Order for Matins daily through the year."
    Similarly, what we call the Order for Daily Evening Prayer was
    styled "An Order for Evensong." These beautiful names, "Matins"
    and "Evensong," which it is a great pity to have lost, for surely
    there is nothing superstitious about them, disappeared from the
    book as subsequently revised, and save in the Lectionary of the
    Church of England have no present recognition. One of them,
    however, Evensong, seems to be coming very generally into colloquial
    use. The Order for Matins began with the Lord's Prayer. Then, after
    the familiar versicles still in use, including two that have no
    place in our American book, "O God, make speed to save me. O Lord,
    make haste to help me," there followed in full the 95th Psalm, a
    portion of which is known to us as the _Venite_. From this point
    the service proceeded, as in the English Prayer Book of to-day,
    through the Collect for Grace, where it came to an end. The
    structure of Evensong was similar, beginning with the Lord's
    Prayer and ending, as our shortened Evening Prayer now does, with
    the Collect for Aid against Perils. Then followed the Athanasian
    Creed, and immediately afterward came the Introits, Collects,
    Epistles, and Gospels.
    
    These Introits, so-called, were psalms appointed to be sung when
    the priest was about to begin the Holy Communion. They had been
    an ancient feature of divine service, but were dropped from the
    subsequent books as a required feature of the Church's worship.
    
    The title of the Communion Service in Edward's First Book is as
    follows: "The Supper of the Lord and the Holy Communion commonly
    called the Mass." Immediately after the Prayer for Purity--_i_.
    _e_., in the place where we have the Ten Commandments, comes the
    _Gloria in Excelsis_. The service then proceeds very much as with
    us, except that the Prayer for the Church Militant and the
    Consecration Prayer are welded into one, and the Prayer of Humble
    Access given a place immediately before the reception of the
    elements. I note, in passing, certain phrases and sentences that
    are peculiar to the Communion Office of the First Book, as, for
    instance, this from the Prayer for the whole state of Christ's
    Church: "And here we do give unto thee most high praise and hearty
    thanks for the wonderful grace and virtue declared in all thy
    saints from the beginning of the world, and chiefly in the most
    glorious and blessed Virgin Mary, Mother of thy Son Jesus Christ
    our Lord and God, and in the holy patriarchs, prophets, apostles,
    and martyrs, whose examples, O Lord, and steadfastness in thy
    faith and keeping thy holy commandments grant us to follow. We
    commend unto thy mercy, O Lord, all other thy servants which are
    departed hence from us with the sign of faith and do now rest in
    the sleep of peace. Grant unto them, we beseech thee, thy mercy and
    everlasting peace, and that at the day of the general resurrection
    we and all they which be of the mystical body of thy Son may
    altogether be set on his right hand."
    
    And this from the closing portion of the Consecration: "Yet we
    beseech thee to accept this our bounden duty and service, and
    command these our prayers and supplications by the ministry of thy
    holy angels to be brought up into thy holy tabernacle before the
    sight of thy divine majesty."
    
    Following close upon the Communion Service came the Litany, differing
    very little from what we have to-day, save in the memorable petition,
    "From the tyranny of the Bishop of Rome and all his detestable
    enormities, good Lord deliver us."
    
    The Baptismal Offices of the First Book contain certain unique
    features. The sign of the cross is ordered to be made on the child's
    breast as well as on his forehead. There is a form of exorcism said
    over the infant in which the unclean spirit is commanded to come
    out and to depart. There is also the giving of the "Crisome" or
    white vesture as a symbol of innocence. "Take this white vesture
    for a token of the innocency which by God's grace in this holy
    sacrament of Baptism is given unto thee, and for a sign whereby
    thou art admonished, so long as thou livest, to give thyself to
    innocency of living, that after this transitory life thou mayest
    be partaker of the life everlasting."
    
    The Catechism in Edward VI. First Book, as in the subsequent books
    down to 1662, is made a part of the Confirmation Office, although
    it does not clearly appear that the children were expected to say
    it as a preliminary to the service.
    
    The Office for the Visitation of the Sick contains provision for
    private confession and absolution, and also directs that the priest
    shall anoint the sick man with oil if he be desired to do so.
    
    The Office for the Communion of the Sick allows the practice of what
    is called the reservation of the elements, but contains also, be it
    observed, that rubric which has held its place through all the
    changes the Prayer Book has undergone, where we are taught that if
    the sick man by any "just impediment fail to receive the sacrament
    of Christ's body and blood, the curate shall instruct him that if
    he do truly repent him of his sins and steadfastly believe that
    Jesus Christ hath suffered death upon the cross for him . . . he
    doth eat and drink the body and blood of our Saviour Christ,
    profitably to his soul's health although he do not receive the
    sacrament with his mouth."
    
    The Burial Office contains a recognition of prayer for the dead,
    but except in the matter of the arrangement of the parts differs
    but little from the service still in use. A special Introit,
    Collect, Epistle, and Gospel are appointed "for the Celebration of
    the Holy Communion when there is a Burial of the Dead."
    
    A Commination Office for Ash-Wednesday, substantially identical
    with that still in use in the Church of England, concludes the book.
    
    The First Prayer Book of King Edward the Sixth, memorable as it was
    destined to become, proved, so far as actual use was concerned, but
    short-lived. It became operative, as we have seen, on Whitsunday,
    1549, but it was soon evident that while the new services went too
    far in the direction of reform to please the friends of the ancient
    order of things, they did not go far enough to meet the wishes of
    the reforming party.
    
    Before the year was out no fewer than three translations of the
    Liturgy into Latin had been undertaken with a view to informing
    the Protestant divines of the Continent as to what their English
    colleagues were doing. "There was already within the Church" (of
    England), writes Cardwell, in his comparison of Edward's two books,
    "a party, though probably not numerous, which espoused the peculiar
    sentiments of Calvin; there were others, and Cranmer, it appears,
    had recently been one of them, adhering strictly to the opinions
    of Luther; there were many, and those among the most active and the
    most learned, who adopted the views of Bullinger and the theologians
    of Zurich; there was a still larger body anxious to combine all
    classes of Protestants under one general confession, and all these,
    though with distinct objects and different degrees of impatience,
    looked forward to a revision of the Liturgy, to bring it more
    completely into accordance with their own sentiments."
    
    As a result of the agitation thus vividly pictured by Cardwell,
    there came forth in 1552 the book known as the Second Prayer Book
    of King Edward VI., a work of the very greatest interest, for the
    reason that it was destined to become the basis of all future
    revisions. Whitsunday, 1549, was the day when the First Book began
    to be used. The Feast of All Saints, 1552, was the date officially
    appointed for the introduction of the Second Book. Presently King
    Edward died, and by an act of Mary passed in October, 1553, the use
    of his Book became illegal on and after December 20th of that year.
    It thus appears that the First Book was in use for two years and
    about four months, and the Second Book one year and about two
    months. A memorable three years and a half for the English-speaking
    peoples of all time to come, for it is not too much to say that
    while the language of Tyndale and of Cranmer continues to be heard
    on earth, the devotions then put into form will keep on moulding
    the religious thought and firing the spiritual imagination of this
    race.
    
    The points in which the second of King Edward's two books differs
    from the first are of such serious moment and the general complexion
    of the later work has in it such an access of Protestant coloring,
    that high Anglican writers have been in the habit of attributing the
    main features of the revision to the interference of the Continental
    Reformers. "If it had not been for the impertinent meddling," they
    have been accustomed to say, "of such foreigners as Bucer, Peter
    Martyr, and John a-Lasco, we might have been enjoying at the present
    day the admirable and truly Catholic devotions set forth in the
    fresh morning of the Reformation, before the earth-born vapors of
    theological controversy and ecclesiastical partisanship had
    beclouded an otherwise fair sky." But it does not appear that there
    is any solid foundation in fact for these complaints.
    
    The natural spread of the spirit of reform among the people of the
    realm, taken in connection with the changes of opinion which the
    swift movement of the times necessarily engendered in the minds of
    the leading divines, are of themselves quite sufficient to account
    for what took place. Certainly, if the English of that day were at
    all like their descendants in our time, it is in the highest degree
    unlikely that they would have allowed a handful of learned refugees
    to force upon them changes which their own sober judgment did not
    approve.
    
    The truth is, very little is certainly known as to the details of
    what was done in the making of Edward's Second Book. Even the names
    of the members of the committee intrusted with the revision are
    matter of conjecture, and of the proceedings of that body no
    authentic record survives. What we do possess and are in a position
    to criticise is the book itself, and to a brief review of the
    points in which it differs from its predecessor we will now pass.
    
    Upon taking up the Second Book after laying down the First, one is
    struck immediately with the changed look of Morning Prayer. This
    is no longer called Matins, and no longer begins as before with the
    Lord's Prayer. An Introduction has been prefixed to the office
    consisting of a collection of sentences from Holy Scripture, all of
    them of a penitential character, and besides these of an Exhortation,
    a Confession, and an Absolution. There can be little doubt that this
    opportunity for making public acknowledgment of sin and hearing
    the declaration of God's willingness to forgive, was meant to
    counterbalance the removal from the book of all reference, save
    in one instance, to private confession and absolution. The Church
    of England has always retained in her Visitation Office a permission
    to the priest to pronounce absolution privately to the sick man.
    This was a feature of the First Book that was not disturbed in the
    Second. But wherever else they found anything that seemed to look
    toward the continuance of the system familiarly known to us under
    the name of "the Confessional," they expunged it. Between the
    Exhortation and the Confession there is, in point of literary merit,
    a noticeable contrast, and it is scarcely to be believed that both
    formularies can have proceeded from one and the same pen. Another
    step in the Protestant direction was the prohibition of certain
    vestments that in the First Book had been allowed, as the alb and
    cope. The Introit Psalms were taken away. The word "table" was
    everywhere substituted for the word "altar." The changes in the
    Office of the Holy Communion were numerous and significant. The
    Ten Commandments, for instance, were inserted in the place where
    we now have them. The _Gloria in Excelsis_ was transferred from
    the beginning of the service to the end. The Exhortations were
    re-written. The supplication for the dead was taken out of the
    Prayer for the whole state of Christ's Church, and the words
    "militant here on earth" were added to the title with a view to
    confining the scope of the intercession to the circle of people
    still alive. The Confession, Absolution, Comfortable Words, and
    Prayer of Humble Access were placed before the Consecration instead
    of after it. Most important of all was the change of the words
    appointed to be said in delivering the elements to the communicants.
    In the First Book these had been, "The body of our Lord Jesus Christ
    which was given for thee, preserve thy body and soul unto everlasting
    life," and in the case of the cup, "The blood of our Lord Jesus
    Christ, which was shed for thee, preserve thy body and soul unto
    everlasting life." For these were now substituted in the one
    instance the words, "Take and eat this in remembrance that Christ
    died for thee, and feed on him in thy heart by faith, with
    thanksgiving," and in the other, "Drink this in remembrance that
    Christ's blood was shed for thee, and be thankful."
    
    From the Office for the Communion of the Sick the direction to
    reserve the elements was omitted, as was also the permission to
    anoint the sick man with oil. The Service of Baptism was no longer
    suffered to retain the exorcism of the evil spirit, or the white
    vesture, or the unction; and there were other items of less
    important change. Those mentioned reveal plainly enough what was
    the animus of the revisers. Most evidently the intention was to
    produce a liturgy more thoroughly reformed, more in harmony with
    the new tone and temper which the religious thought of the times
    was taking on.
    
    We come to the Third Book of Common Prayer. Bloody Mary was dead,
    and Elizabeth had succeeded to the throne.
    
    During the Roman reaction proclamation had been made that all the
    Reformed service-books should be given up to the ecclesiastical
    authorities within fifteen days to be burned. This is doubtless
    the reason why copies of the liturgical books of Edward's reign
    are now so exceedingly rare. Reprints of them abound, but the
    originals exist only as costly curiosities.
    
    Soon after Elizabeth's accession a committee of divines assembled
    under her authority for the purpose of again revising the
    formularies.
    
    The queen was personally a High-Churchwoman, and her own judgment
    is said to have been favorable to taking the first of Edward's two
    books as the basis of the revision, but a contrary preference
    swayed the committee, and the lines followed were those of 1552
    and not those of 1549.
    
    The new features distinctive of the Prayer Book of Elizabeth,
    otherwise known as the Prayer Book of 1559, are not numerous.
    A table of Proper Lessons for Sundays was introduced. The old
    vestments recognized in the earlier part of King Edward's reign
    were again legalized. The petition for deliverance from the tyranny
    of the Pope was struck out of the Litany, and by a compromise
    peculiarly English in its character, and, as experience has shown,
    exceedingly well judged, the two forms of words that had been used
    in the delivery of the elements in the Holy Communion were welded
    together into the shape in which we have them still.
    
    Queen Elizabeth's Prayer Book continued in use for five-and-forty
    years. Nothing was more natural than that when she died there should
    come with the accession of a new dynasty a demand for fresh revision.
    King James, who was not afflicted with any want of confidence in
    his own judgment, invited certain representatives of the disaffected
    party to meet, under his presidency, the Churchmen in council with
    a view to the settlement of differences. The Puritans had been
    gaining in strength during Elizabeth's reign, and they felt that
    they were now in position to demand a larger measure of liturgical
    reform than that monarch and her advisers had been willing to
    concede to them.
    
    King James convened his conference at Hampton Court, near London,
    and he himself was good enough to preside. Very little came of the
    debate. The Puritans had demanded the discontinuance of the sign of
    the cross in Baptism, of bowing at the name of Jesus, of the ring
    in marriage, and of the rite of confirmation. The words "priest"
    and "absolution" they sought to have expunged from the Prayer Book,
    and they desired that the wearing of the surplice should be made
    optional.
    
    Almost nothing was conceded to them. The words "or Remission of
    Sins" were added to the title of the Absolution, certain Prayers
    and Thanksgivings were introduced, and that portion of the Catechism
    which deals with the Sacraments was for the first time set forth.
    And thus the English Prayer Book started out upon its fourth lease
    of life destined in this form to endure unchanged, though by no
    means unassailed, for more than half a century.
    
    A stirring half century it was. The Puritan defeat at Hampton Court
    was redressed at Naseby. With the coming in of the Long Parliament
    the Book of Common Prayer went out, and to all appearances the
    triumph of the Commonwealth meant the final extinction of the usage
    of liturgical worship on English soil. The book, under its various
    forms, had lasted just a hundred years when he who
    
      Nothing common did or mean
      Upon that memorable scene
    
    suffered at Whitehall.
    
    They buried him in St. George's Chapel, Windsor, and no single word
    of the Prayer Book he had loved and for which he had fought was
    said over his grave.
    
    On January 3, 1645, Parliament repealed the statutes of Edward VI.
    and of Elizabeth that had enjoined the use of the Book of Common
    Prayer, and took order that thereafter only such divine service
    should be lawful as accorded with what was called the _Directory_,
    a manual of suggestions with respect to public worship adopted by
    the Presbyterian party as a substitute for the ancient liturgy.
    
    With the restoration of the Stuarts in 1660 came naturally the
    restoration of the Prayer Book, and with equal naturalness a
    revision of it. But of what sort should the revision be, and under
    whose auspices conducted? This was an anxious question for the
    advisers, civil and ecclesiastical, of the restored king. Should
    the second Charles take up the book just as it had fallen from the
    hands of the first Charles, unchanged in line or letter, or should
    he seek by judicious alterations and timely concessions to win
    back for the national Church the good-will and loyalty of those
    who, eighteen years before, had broken down her hedge? The situation
    may be described as triangular.
    
    The king's secret and personal sympathies were probably all along
    with the Roman Church; his official allegiance was plainly due to
    the Church of England; and yet, at the same time, he owed much
    to the forbearance of the men who had been dominant under the
    Commonwealth. The mind of the nation had, indeed, reacted toward
    monarchy, but not with such an absolute and hardy renunciation of
    the doctrines of popular sovereignty as to make it safe for the
    returning king to do precisely as he chose. The glorious Revolution
    that was destined so soon to follow upon the heels of the gracious
    Restoration gave evidence, when it came, that there were some
    things the people of England prized even more highly than an
    hereditary throne. Misgivings as to the amount there might still
    be of this sort of electricity in the atmosphere suggested to the
    king and his counsellors the expediency of holding a conference,
    at which the leaders on either side might bring forward their strong
    reasons in favor of this or that method of dealing with the
    ecclesiastical question in general, and more especially with the
    vexed problem of worship.
    
    Accordingly, early in the spring of 1661 the King issued a
    royal warrant summoning to meet at the Savoy Palace in the
    Strand an equal number of representatives of both parties--namely,
    one-and-twenty Churchmen and one-and-twenty Presbyterians.
    
    The Episcopal deputation consisted of twelve bishops and nine other
    divines called coadjutors. The Presbyterians had also their twelve
    principal men and their nine coadjutors.
    
    Conspicuous among the Episcopalians for weight of learning were
    Bishops Sanderson, Cosin, and Walton, and Doctors Pearson, Sparrow,
    and Heylin. Baxter, Reynolds, Calamy, and Lightfoot were the most
    notable of the Presbyterians.
    
    The conference, which has ever since been known from its place of
    meeting (an old palace of the Piedmontese Ambassadors) as the Savoy
    Conference, convened on April 15, 1661. For various reasons, it
    was evident from the outset that the Churchmen were in a position
    of great advantage. In the first place, signs and tokens of a
    renewed confidence in monarchy and of a revived attachment to the
    reigning House were becoming daily more numerous.
    
    Before he had had a chance to test the strength of the existing
    political parties and to know how things really stood, Charles had
    borne himself very discreetly toward the Presbyterians, and had
    held out hopes to them which, as the event proved, were destined
    never to be realized. In a declaration put forth in the autumn of
    1660, after he had been for some months on English soil, he had even
    gone so far as to say: "When we were in Holland we were attended
    by many grave and learned ministers from hence, who were looked
    upon as the most able and principal asserters of the Presbyterian
    opinions; with whom we had as much conference as the multitude of
    affairs which were then upon us would permit us to have, and to
    our great satisfaction and comfort found them persons full of
    affection to us, of zeal for the peace of the Church and State, and
    neither enemies, as they have been given out to be, to episcopacy
    or liturgy, but modestly to desire such alterations in either,
    as without shaking foundations might best allay the present
    distempers."
    
    By the time the conference met it had become evident, from votes
    taken in Parliament and otherwise, that the Churchmen could sustain
    toward their opponents a somewhat stiffer attitude than this without
    imperilling their cause. Another great advantage enjoyed by the
    Episcopalians grew out of the fact that they were the party in
    possession. They had only to profess themselves satisfied with the
    Prayer Book as it stood, in order to throw the Presbyterians into
    the position of assailants, and defense is always easier than
    attack. Sheldon, the Bishop of London, was not slow to perceive
    this. At the very first meeting of the conference, he is reported
    to have said that "as the Non-conformists, and not the bishops, had
    sought for the conference, nothing could be done till the former
    had delivered their exceptions in writing, together with the
    additional forms and alterations which they desired." Upon which
    Bishop Burnet in his _History of his own Times_ remarks: "Sheldon
    saw well what the effect would be of putting them to make all their
    demands at once. The number of them raised a mighty outcry against
    them, as people that could never be satisfied."
    
    The Presbyterians, however, took up the challenge, set to work at
    formulating their objections, and appointed Richard Baxter, the most
    famous of their number, to show what could be done in the way of
    making a better manual of worship than the Book of Common Prayer.
    
    Baxter, a truly great man and wise in a way, though scarcely in the
    liturgical way, was guilty of the incredible folly of undertaking
    to construct a Prayer Book within a fortnight.
    
    Of this liturgy it is probably safe to say that no denomination of
    Christians, however anti-prelatical or eccentric, would for a
    moment dream of adopting it, if, indeed, there be a single local
    congregation anywhere that could be persuaded to employ it. The
    characteristic of the devotions is lengthiness. The opening sentence
    of the prayer with which the book begins contains by actual count
    eighty-three words. It is probable that Baxter by his rash act did
    more to injure the cause of intelligent and reverential liturgical
    revision than any ten men have done before or since. In every
    discussion of the subject he is almost sure to be brought forward
    as "the awful example."
    
    A document much more to the point than Baxter's Liturgy was the
    formal catalogue of faults and blemishes alleged against the Prayer
    Book, which the Puritan members of the conference in due time
    brought in. This indictment, for it may fairly be called such,
    since it was drawn up in separate counts, is very interesting
    reading. Of the "exceptions against the Book of Common Prayer,"
    as the Puritans named their list of liturgical grievances, some
    must strike almost any reader of the present day as trivial and
    unworthy. Others again there are that draw a sympathetic Amen from
    many quarters to-day. To an American Episcopalian the catalogue
    is chiefly interesting as showing how ready and even eager were
    our colonial ancestors of a hundred years ago to remove out of the
    way such known rocks of offence as they could. An attentive student
    of the American Prayer Book cannot fail to be struck with the number
    of instances in which the text gives evidence of the influence
    exerted over the minds of our revisers by what had been urged, more
    than a hundred years before, by the Puritan members of the Savoy
    Conference. The defeat of 1661 was, in a measure at least, avenged
    in 1789. It is encouraging to those who cast their bread upon
    liturgical waters to notice after how many days the return may come.
    But the conference, to all outward seeming, was a failure. Baxter's
    unhappy Prayer Book was its own sufficient refutation, and as for
    the list of special grievances it was met by the bishops with an
    "Answer" that was full of hard raps and conceded almost nothing.
    
    A few detached paragraphs may serve to illustrate the general tone
    of this reply. Here, for instance, is the comment of the bishops
    upon the request of the Puritans to be allowed occasionally to
    substitute extemporaneous for liturgical devotions. "The gift or
    rather spirit of prayer consists in the inward graces of the spirit,
    not in extempore expressions which any man of natural parts having
    a voluble tongue and audacity may attain to without any special
    gift." Nothing very conciliatory in that. To the complaint that
    the Collects are too short, the bishops reply that they cannot
    for that reason be accounted faulty, being like those "short but
    prevalent prayers in Scripture, Lord, be merciful to me a sinner.
    Lord, increase our faith." The Puritans had objected to the
    antiphonal element in the Prayer-Book services, and desired to
    have nothing of a responsive character allowed beyond the single
    word Amen. "But," rejoin the bishops, "they directly practise the
    contrary in one of their principal parts of worship, singing of
    psalms, where the people bear as great a part as the minister. If
    this way be done in Hopkin's why not in David's Psalms; if in metre,
    why not in prose; if in a psalm, why not in a litany?" Sharp, but
    not winning.
    
    The Puritans had objected to the people's kneeling while the
    Commandments were read on the score that ignorant worshippers
    might mistake the Decalogue for a form of prayer. With some asperity
    the bishops reply that "why Christian people should not upon their
    knees ask their pardon for their life forfeited for the breach of
    every commandment and pray for grace to keep them for the time to
    come they must be more than 'ignorant' that can scruple."
    
    The time during which the conference at the Savoy should continue
    its sessions had been limited to four months. This period expired
    on July 24, 1661, and the apparently fruitless disputation was at
    an end. Meanwhile, however, Convocation, the recognized legislature
    of the Church of England, had begun to sit, and the bishops had
    undertaken a revision of the Prayer Book after their own mind, and
    with slight regard to what they had been hearing from their critics
    at the Savoy. The bulk of their work, which included, it is said,
    more than six hundred alterations, most of them of a verbal
    character and of no great importance, was accomplished within the
    compass of a single month. It is consoling to those who within our
    own memory have been charged with indecent haste for seeking to
    effect a revision of the American Book of Common Prayer within a
    period of nine years, to find this precedent in ecclesiastical
    history for their so great rashness.
    
    Since Charles the Second's day there has been no formal revision of
    the Prayer Book of the Church of England by the Church of England.
    
    Some slight relaxations of liturgical use on Sundays have been made
    legal by Act of Parliament, but in all important respects the Prayer
    Book of Victoria is identical with the book set forth by Convocation
    and sanctioned by Parliament shortly after the collapse of the Savoy
    Conference. Under no previous lease of life did the book enjoy
    anything like so long a period of continued existence. Elizabeth's
    book was the longest lived of all that preceded the Restoration,
    but that only continued in use five-and-forty years. But the Prayer
    Book of 1661 has now held its own in England for two centuries and
    a quarter. When, therefore, we are asked to accept the first
    Edwardian Book as the only just exponent of the religious mind of
    England, it is open to us to reply, "Why should we, seeing that
    the Caroline Book has served as the vehicle of English devotion for
    a period seventy-five times as long?" The most voluminous of the
    additions made to the Prayer Book, in 1661, were the Office for the
    Baptism of Adults and the Forms of Prayer to be used at Sea. The
    wide diffusion, under the Commonwealth, of what were then called
    Anabaptist opinions, had brought it to pass that throughout the
    kingdom there were thousands of men and women who had grown up
    unbaptized. At the time of the Reformation such a thing as an
    unchristened Christendom seems not to have been thought possible.
    At any rate no provision was made for the contingency. But upon
    the spread of liberty of religious thought there followed, logically
    enough, the spread of liberty of religious action, and it was not
    strange that after a whole generation had spent its life in
    controversy of the warmest sort over this very point of Baptism,
    there were found to be in England multitudes of the unbaptized.
    
    Another reason assigned in the Preface of the English Prayer Book
    for the addition of this office was that it might be used for the
    baptizing of "natives in the plantations and other converts." This
    is the first hint of any awakening of the conscience of the English
    Church to a sense of duty toward those strangers and foreigners who
    in the "Greater Britain" of these later days fill so large a place.
    The composition of the office, which differs very little, perhaps
    scarcely enough, from that appointed for the Baptism of Infants, is
    attributed to Griffith, the Bishop of St. Asaph. The compiler of
    the Forms of Prayer to be used at Sea was Bishop Sanderson, famous
    among English theologians as an authority on casuistry. He must have
    found it rather a nice case of conscience to decide whether a Stuart
    divine in preparing forms of prayer for a navy that had been the
    creation of Oliver Cromwell ought wholly to omit an acknowledgment
    of the nation's obligation to that stout-hearted, if non-Episcopal
    Christian. Other additions of importance made at this revision were
    the General Thanksgiving, in all probability the work of Reynolds,
    a conforming Presbyterian divine, the Collect, Epistle, and Gospel
    for the Sixth Sunday after the Epiphany, the Prayer for Parliament,
    upon the lines of which our own Prayer for Congress was afterward
    modelled, and the Prayer for All Sorts and Conditions of Men. In
    the Litany the words "rebellion" and "schism" were introduced into
    one of the suffrages, becoming tide-marks of the havoc wrought in
    Church and State by what the revisers, doubtless, looked back upon
    as "the flood of the ungodly." The words "Bishops, Priests, and
    Deacons" were substituted for "Bishops, Pastors, and Ministers of
    the Church." New Collects were appointed for the Third Sunday in
    Advent and for St. Stephen's Day. Both of these are distinct gains,
    albeit had the opinion then prevailed that to introduce into the
    Prayer Book anything from the pen of a living writer is an impiety,
    we should have gained neither of them.
    
    Another important change made in 1662 was the adoption for the
    Sentences, Epistles and Gospels of the language of King James's
    Bible in place of that of earlier versions. This principle was not
    applied to the Psalter, to the Decalogue, or, in fact, to any of
    the portions of Scripture contained in the Communion Service.
    
    It is also interesting to note that the Confession in the Holy
    Communion, which the earlier rubric had directed should be said
    by one of the congregation, or else by one of the ministers, or
    by the priest himself, "was now made general and enjoined upon all
    the worshippers."
    
    Most suggestive of all, however, was the reinsertion at the end of
    the Communion Service of a certain Declaration about the significance
    of the act of kneeling at the reception of the elements, which had,
    as some say, irregularly and without proper authority, found its way
    into the Second Book of Edward VI., but had been omitted from all
    subsequent books till now. This Declaration, which from its not
    being printed in red ink is known to those who dislike it under the
    name of "the black rubric," was undoubtedly intended to ease the
    consciences of those who scrupled to kneel at the altar-rail for
    fear of seeming to countenance that superstitious adoration of the
    elements known to and stigmatized by the Reformers as "host-worship."
    The language of the black rubric as it stood in Edward's Second
    Book was as follows: "Although no order can be so perfectly devised
    but it may be of some, either for their ignorance and infirmity,
    or else of malice and obstinacy, misconstrued, depraved, and
    interpreted in a wrong part; and yet because brotherly charity
    willeth that so much as conveniently may be offences should be
    taken away; therefore we willing to do the same: whereas, it is
    ordained in the Book of Common Prayer, in the Administration of
    the Lord's Supper, that the communicants kneeling should receive the
    Holy Communion, which thing being well meant for a signification
    of the humble and grateful acknowledging of the benefits of Christ
    given unto the worthy receiver, and to avoid the profanation and
    disorder, which about the Holy Communion might else ensue, lest
    yet the same kneeling might be thought or taken otherwise; we do
    declare that it is not meant thereby, that any adoration is done
    or ought to be done, either unto the sacramental bread or wine
    there bodily received or unto any real and essential presence there
    being of Christ's natural flesh and blood. For as concerning the
    sacramental bread and wine they remain still in their very natural
    substances, and therefore may not be adored, for that were idolatry
    to be abhorred of all faithful Christians: and as concerning the
    natural body and blood of our Saviour Christ, they are in heaven
    and not here, for it is against the truth of Christ's true natural
    body to be in more places than in one at one time."
    
    In restoring this significant Declaration, the revisers of 1662
    substituted the words "corporal presence" for the words "real and
    substantial presence," but probably with no intention other than
    that of making the original meaning more plain. The fact that in
    the teeth and eyes of the black rubric the practice known as
    Eucharistical adoration has become widely prevalent in the Church
    of England, only shows how little dependence can be placed on forms
    of words to keep even excellent and religious people from doing
    the things they have a mind to do.
    
    In taking leave of the Caroline revision, it may be permitted to
    dwell for a moment upon the serious character of the conclusion
    reached by the ecclesiastical leaders of that day. An opportunity
    was given them to conciliate dissent. Without going all lengths,
    without in any measure imperilling the great foundation principles
    of Anglican religion, they might, it would seem, have won back to
    the national church thousands of those whom their sternness not
    only repelled but permanently embittered. But it was the hour of
    victory with the Churchmen, and "Woe to the conquered" seems to
    have been their cry. They set their faces as a flint against
    concession; they passed their iron-clad act of uniformity, and
    now for more than two hundred years religion in Great Britain has
    been a household divided against itself. Perhaps nothing that the
    men of the Restoration could have done would have made it otherwise.
    Perhaps the familiar question of the cynical Dean of St. Patrick's,
    "What imports it how large a gate you open, if there be always left
    a number who place a pride and a merit in refusing to enter?" was
    a fair question, and fatal to any dream of unity. And yet one may
    be pardoned for believing that had a little of the oil of brotherly
    kindness been poured upon those troubled waters we whom the waves
    still buffet might to-day be sailing a smoother sea.
    
    As stated above, the Convocation of 1662 gave to the Prayer Book of
    the Church of England the form it has ever since retained. But it
    must not be supposed that no efforts have been made meanwhile to
    bring changes to pass. The books written upon the subject form a
    literature by themselves.
    
    The one really serious attempt to reconstruct the Liturgy in
    post-Caroline times was that which grew naturally enough out of the
    Revolution of 1688. In every previous crisis of political change,
    the Prayer Book had felt the tremor along with the statute-book.
    
    Church and State, like heart and brain, are sympathetically
    responsive to one another; revisions of rubrics go naturally
    along with revisions of codes. It was only what might have been
    anticipated, therefore, that when William and Mary came to the
    throne a Commission should issue for a new review. If Elizabeth
    had found it necessary to revise the book, if James had found it
    necessary, if Charles had found it necessary, why should not the
    strong hand of William of Orange be laid upon the pages? But this
    time the rule was destined to find its exception. The work of review
    was, indeed, undertaken by a Royal Commission, including among its
    members the great names of Stillingfleet, Tillotson, and Beveridge,
    but nothing came of their work. Convocation again showed itself
    unfriendly to anything like concessive measures, and so complete
    was the obscurity into which the doings of the Commission fell,
    that even as late as 1849, Cardwell, in the third edition of
    his _History of Conferences_, speaks as if he knew nothing of
    the whereabouts of the record. In 1854 the manuscript minutes
    of the Commission's proceedings were discovered in the Library
    of Lambeth Palace, and by order of Parliament printed as a
    Blue-book. The same document has also been published in a more
    readable form by Bagster. One rises from the perusal of this Broad
    Church Prayer Book--for such, perhaps, Tillotson's attempt may not
    unfairly be called--profoundly thankful that the promoters of it
    were not suffered to succeed. The Preface to our American Book of
    Common Prayer refers to this attempted review of 1689 "as a great
    and good work." But the greatness and the goodness must have lain
    in the motive, for one fails to discern them either in the matter
    or in the manner of what was recommended.
    
    Even Macaulay, Whig that he is, fails not to put on record his
    condemnation of the literary violence which the Prayer Book so
    narrowly escaped at the hands of the Royal Commission of 1689.
    Terseness was not the special excellency of Macaulay's own style,
    yet even he resented Bishop Patrick's notion that the Collects
    could be improved by amplification. One of the few really good
    suggestions made by the Commissioners was that of using the
    Beatitudes in the Office of the Holy Communion as an alternate
    for the Decalogue. There are certain festivals of the Christian
    year when such a substitution would be most timely and refreshing.
    
    We make a leap now of just a hundred years. From 1689 we pass to
    1789, and find ourselves in the city of Philadelphia, at a
    convention assembled for the purpose of framing a constitution
    and setting forth a liturgy for a body of Christians destined to
    be known as the Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States
    of America. During the interval between the issue of the Declaration
    of Independence and the Ratification of the Constitution of the
    United States, the people in this country who had been brought
    up in the communion of the Church of England found themselves
    ecclesiastically in a very delicate position indeed. As colonists
    they had been canonically under the spiritual jurisdiction of the
    Bishop of London, a somewhat remote diocesan. But with this
    Episcopal bond broken and no new one formed, they seemed to be
    in a peculiar sense adrift. It does not fall to me to narrate
    the steps that led to the final establishment of the episcopacy
    upon a sure foundation, nor yet to trace the process through which
    the Church's legislative system came gradually to its completion.
    Our interest is a liturgical one, and our subject matter the
    evolution of the Prayer Book. I say nothing, therefore, of other
    matters that were debated in the Convention of 1789, but shall
    propose instead that we confine ourselves to what was said and
    done about the Prayer Book. In order, however, fully to appreciate
    the situation we must go back a little. In a half-formal and
    half-informal fashion there had come into existence, four years
    before this Convention of 1789 assembled, an American Liturgy now
    known by the name of _The Proposed Book_. It had been compiled on
    the basis of the English Prayer Book by a Committee of three
    eminent clergymen, Dr. White of Pennsylvania, Dr. William Smith
    of Maryland, and Dr. Wharton of Delaware. Precisely what measure
    of acceptance this book enjoyed, or to what extent it came actually
    into use, are difficult, perhaps hopeless questions.
    
    What we know for certain is that the public opinion of the greater
    number of Churchmen rejected it as inadequate and unsatisfactory.
    In the Convention of 1789 The Proposed Book does not seem to have
    been seriously considered in open debate at all, though doubtless
    there was much talk about it, much controversy over its merits and
    demerits at Philadelphia dinner-tables and elsewhere while the
    session was in progress.
    
    The truth is, the changes set forth in _The Proposed Book_ were
    too sweeping to commend themselves to the sober second-thought of
    men whose blood still showed the tincture of English conservatism.
    Possibly also some old flames of Tory resentment were rekindled,
    here and there, by the prominence given in the book to a form of
    public thanksgiving for the Fourth of July. There were Churchmen
    doubtless at that day who failed duly to appreciate what were called
    in the title of the office, "the inestimable blessings of Religious
    and Civil Liberty." Others again may have been offended by the
    treatment measured out to the Psalter, which was portioned into
    thirty selections of two parts each, with the _Benedicite_ added
    at the end, to be used, if desired, on the thirty-first day of any
    month. Another somewhat crude and unliturgical device was the
    running together without break of the Morning Prayer and the
    Litany.
    
    I speak of blemishes, but _The Proposed Book_ had its excellences
    also. Just at present it is the fashion in Anglican circles to heap
    ridicule and contempt on _The Proposed Book_ out of all proportion
    to its real demerits. Somehow it is thought to compromise us with
    the English by showing up our ecclesiastical ancestors in an
    unfavorable light as unlearned and ignorant men. It is treated
    as people will sometimes treat an old family portrait of a forebear,
    who in his day was under a cloud, mismanaged trust funds, or made
    money in the slave trade. Thus a grave historiographer by way of
    speaking comfortably on this score, assures us that the volume
    "speedily sunk into obscurity," becoming one of the rarest of the
    books illustrative of our ecclesiastical annals.
    
    And yet, curiously enough, _The Proposed Book_ was in some points
    more "churchly," using the word in a sense expressive of liturgical
    accuracy, than the book finally adopted. In the Morning Prayer it
    has the _Venite_ in full and not abridged. The _Benedictus_ it also
    gives entire. A single form of Absolution is supplied. The versicles
    following upon the Creed are more numerous than ours. In the Evening
    Prayer the great Gospel Hymns, _the Magnificat_ and the _Nunc
    dimittis_, stand in the places to which we with tardy justice have
    only just restored them.
    
    Again, if we consider those features of _The Proposed Book_ that
    were retained and made part of the Liturgy in 1789, we shall have
    further reason to refrain from wholesale condemnation of this
    tentative work. For example, we owe the two opening sentences of
    Morning Prayer, "The Lord is in his holy temple" and "From the
    rising of the sun," to _The Proposed Book_, and also the special
    form for Thanksgiving Day. And yet, on the whole, the Convention
    of 1789 acted most wisely in determining that it would make the
    Prayer Book of the Church of England, rather than _The Proposed
    Book_, the real basis of revision. It did so, and as a result we
    have what has served us so well during the first century of our
    national life--the _Book of Common Prayer and Administration of
    the Sacraments and other rites and ceremonies of the Church
    according to the use of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the
    United States of America_. The points wherein the American Prayer
    Book differs from the Prayer Book of the Church of England are too
    numerous to be catalogued in full. "They will appear," says the
    Preface (a composition borrowed, by the way, almost wholly from
    _The Proposed Book_), "and, it is to be hoped, the reasons of them
    also, upon a comparison of this with the Book of Common Prayer of
    the Church of England."
    
    The most important differences are the following: The permissive
    use of "Selections of Psalms in place of the Psalms appointed for
    the day of the month." This was doubtless suggested by the wholesale
    transformation of the Psalter in _The Proposed Book_ into a series
    of selections.
    
    The permitted shortening of the Litany is an American feature.
    
    A number of the special prayers, as, for example, the prayer for a
    sick person, that for persons going to sea, the thanksgivings for a
    recovery and for a safe return, all these are peculiar to the
    American use. Extensive alterations were made in the Marriage
    Service and certain greatly needed ones in the Burial Office.
    The two most noteworthy differences, however, are the omission
    from our Prayer Book of the so-called Athanasian Creed, and the
    insertion in it of that part of the Consecration Prayer in the
    Communion Office known as the Invocation. The engrafting of this
    latter feature we owe to the influence of Bishop Seabury, who by
    this addition not only assimilated the language of our liturgy more
    closely to that of the ancient formularies of the Oriental Church,
    but also insured our being kept reminded of the truly spiritual
    character of Holy Communion. "It is the spirit that quickeneth,"
    this Invocation seems to say; "the flesh profiteth nothing." Quite
    in line with this was the alteration made at the same time in the
    language of the Catechism. "The Body and Blood of Christ," says the
    English Book, "which are verily and indeed taken and received by
    the faithful in the Lord's Supper."
    
    "The Body and Blood of Christ," says the American Book, "which are
    spiritually taken and received by the faithful in the Lord's
    Supper."
    
    Many verbal changes are to be found scattered here and there
    through the book, some of them for the better, some, perhaps,
    for the worse. The prevailing purpose seems to have been to
    expunge all obsolete words and phrases while dealing tenderly
    with obsolescent ones. In this course, however, the revisers
    were by no means always and everywhere consistent.
    
    "Prevent," in the sense of "anticipate," is altered in some places
    but left unchanged in others. In the _Visitation of Prisoners_, an
    office borrowed from the Irish Prayer Book, the thoroughly obsolete
    expression, "As you tender," in the sense of "as you value," the
    salvation of your soul, is retained.
    
    From the Psalter has disappeared in the American Book "Thou tellest
    my Sittings," although why this particular archaism should have
    been selected for banishment and a hundred others spared, it is
    not easy to understand.
    
    Perhaps some sudden impatience seized the reviser, like that which
    moved Bishop Wren, while annotating his Prayer Book, to write on
    the margin of the calendar for August, "Out with 'dog days' from
    among the saints."
    
    Considering what a bond of unity the Lord's Prayer appears to be
    becoming among all English-speaking worshippers, it is, perhaps,
    to be regretted that our revisers changed the wording of it in two
    or three places. The excision of "Lighten our darkness" must
    probably be attributed to the prosaic matter-of-fact temper which
    had possession of everybody and everything during the last quarter
    of the eighteenth century.
    
    The Ordinal, the Articles, the Consecration of Churches, and the
    Institution of Ministers made no part of the Prayer Book as it was
    set forth in 1789; nor do they, even now, strictly speaking, make
    a part of it, although in the matter of binding force and legal
    authority they are on the same footing.
    
    The Ordinal and Articles are substantially identical with the
    English Ordinal and Articles, save in the matter of a reference
    to the Athanasian Creed and several references to the connection of
    Church and State. The Consecration of Churches and the Institution
    of Ministers are offices distinctively American. If I add that the
    American Book drops out of the Visitation of the Sick a form
    of private absolution, and greatly modifies the service for
    Ash-Wednesday, we shall have made our survey of differences
    tolerably, though by no means exhaustively complete.
    
    And now what is the lesson taught us by the history of the Prayer
    Book? Homiletical as the question sounds, it is worth asking.
    
    We have reviewed rapidly, but not carelessly, the vicissitudes of
    the book's wonderful career, and we ought to be in a position to
    draw some sort of instructive inference from it all. Well, one
    thing taught us is this, the singular power of survival that lives
    in gracious words. They wondered at the "gracious words which
    proceeded out of His mouth," and because they wondered at them
    they treasured them up.
    
    Kind words, says the child's hymn, can never die; neither can
    kindly words, and kindly in the deepest sense are many, many of
    the words of the Common Prayer; they touch that which is most
    catholic in us, that which strongly links us to our kind. There
    is that in some of the Collects which as it has lasted since the
    days when Roman emperors were sitting on their thrones, so will
    it last while man continues what he is, a praying creature.
    
    Another thing taught us by the Prayer Book's history is the duty
    of being forever on our guard in the religious life against "the
    falsehood of extremes."
    
    The emancipated thinkers who account all standards of belief to
    be no better than dungeon walls, scoff at this feature of the
    Anglican character with much bitterness. "Your Church is a Church
    of compromises," they say, "and your boasted _Via media_ only a
    coward's path, the poor refuge of the man who dares not walk in
    the open." But when we see this Prayer Book condemned for being
    what it is by Bloody Mary, and then again condemned for being what
    it is by the Long Parliament, the thought occurs to us that
    possibly there is enshrined in this much-persecuted volume a truth
    larger than the Romanist is willing to tolerate, or the Puritan
    generous enough to apprehend.
    
    A third important lesson is that we are not to confound revision
    with ruin, or to suppose that because a book is marvellously good
    it cannot conceivably be bettered. Each accomplished revision of
    the Book of Common Prayer has been a distinct step in advance. If
    God in his wise providence suffered an excellent growth of devotion
    to spring up out of the soil of England in the days of Edward
    the Sixth, and, after many years, determined that like a vine
    out of Egypt it should be brought across the sea and given root
    on these shores, we need not fear that we are about to lose
    utterly our pleasant plant if we notice that the twigs and leaves
    are adapting themselves to the climate and the atmosphere of the
    new dwelling-place. The life within the vine remains what it always
    was. The growth means health. The power of adaptation is the
    guarantee of a perpetual youth.
    
    
    
    
    REVISION OF THE AMERICAN COMMON PRAYER.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: A Short History of the Book of Common Prayer
    
    Author: William Reed Huntington
    
    
            
    Release date: September 30, 2009 [eBook #30136]
                    Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/30136
    
    Credits: Produced by Elaine Laizure
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #30136. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 30136
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.