Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 30065

Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type

by August Hoch · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2009
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type by August Hoch is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #30065). THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, Ltd.

    EDITOR’S PREFACE

    A word should be said as to the origin and history of this book. When the late Dr. Hoch became Director of the Psychiatric Institute of the New York State Hospitals in 1910, he found there an interest in just the kind of psychiatric research which it was his ambition to further. His predecessor, Adolf Meyer, had developed the conception that the psychoses should be looked on as psychobiological reactions rather than rigid nosological entities and had inculcated the habit of scrupulously thorough examination and record of what the patient said and did.

    Meyer had broken away from the sterile habit of making diagnoses in accordance with the set terms used to label symptoms; and his work and that of his assistants thus led to a collection of valuable material which could serve as a useful starting point for the keen clinical investigation of Hoch. Specifically, attention had already been fixed on the study of the so-called functional psychoses, comprising what are generally termed Dementia Præcox and Manic-Depressive Insanity.

    An urgent problem in this field was to separate different reaction types in order to discover which were recoverable and which chronic or progressive. In order to understand psychological reactions, interrelation rather than mere coincidence of symptoms must be studied and, to aid in this, free use was made of the fundamental principles of unconscious mentation as exposed in the theories of Freud and his followers.

    Almost at the outset it had been discovered that many patients presented clinical pictures that would not fit into existing diagnostic pigeon holes. Dr. George H. Kirby, whose skill and industry had made the most valuable contributions to the archives of the Institute, published in 1913 a brief paper in which he pointed out, not only that many cases with “catatonic” symptoms recovered, but also that clinically the behavior of stupor showed it to be related to manic-depressive insanity as well as dementia præcox. Dr. Hoch took up the problem at this point.

    Using Dr. Kirby’s material and adding to it his earlier observations as well as current cases, he endeavored to work out the essentials of the stupor reaction. It was his ambition to describe stupor not only in its psychiatric bearing but also as a life reaction.

    The significance of this task is to be realized only when one considers the general import of the functional psychoses. They are, biologically, failures of adaptation. The chronic and deteriorating cases give up the struggle permanently, while the temporary insanities lay bare the soul of man as he catches a glimpse of unreality but turns back to face the world as it is. When one realizes that emotional disturbances are characteristic of the benign psychoses, it is easy to imagine how much such studies may ultimately illuminate the problems of normal life.

    The technical value of this work to psychiatry is more immediate.

    Kraepelin laid the foundations for systematic classification with his dementia præcox and manic-depressive groups. But the rigidity of the latter, allegedly descriptive, term has confused the problem of classifying many benign psychoses. It was Hoch’s ambition to prove that, although elation and depression were the commonest mood anomalies in this group, they had no more theoretic importance than anxiety, distressed perplexity or apathy. These other moods, although less frequent, are just as characteristic of the psychoses in this group.

    In other words, the name “Anxiety-Apathy Insanity” would be as appropriate, theoretically, as Kraepelin’s term. In 1919 Hoch and Kirby published a report on the perplexity cases. This present book was designed to show that the symptom complex centering around apathy is as distinct as that which is recognized by all psychiatrists as mania with its predominant characteristic of elation.

    In 1917 ill health forced Dr. Hoch to resign from his official duties.

    He retired to California with the purpose of adding to psychiatric literature the fruits of his long experience and unrivaled judgment. His first task was this book. In the midst of this work came a sudden collapse. As I had been in close touch with his researches, coöperating in psychological speculations, and was free to devote some time to it, he asked shortly before his death that I complete the book. This obligation is incommensurate with the debt I owe for years of inspiration, tuition and criticism.

    The task has been mainly literary. I found the first five chapters practically completed, while it has not been difficult, as a rule, to discover from his copious notes what his intentions were as to the details of the following chapters. I have been greatly aided by the assistance of Dr. Adolf Meyer and of Dr. Kirby. The latter has been good enough to read the entire manuscript, making invaluable suggestions and criticisms.

    John T. MacCurdy.

    New York.

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    CHAPTER PAGE

    EDITOR’S PREFACE vii

    I. INTRODUCTION AND TYPICAL CASES OF DEEP

    STUPOR 1

    II. THE PARTIAL STUPOR REACTIONS 34

    III. SUICIDAL CASES 50

    IV. THE INTERFERENCES WITH THE INTELLECTUAL

    PROCESSES 67

    V. THE IDEATIONAL CONTENT OF THE STUPOR 82

    VI. AFFECT 123

    VII. INACTIVITY, NEGATIVISM AND CATALEPSY 132

    VIII. SPECIAL CASES: RELATIONSHIP OF STUPOR TO

    OTHER REACTIONS 149

    IX. THE PHYSICAL MANIFESTATIONS OF STUPOR 174

    X. PSYCHOLOGICAL EXPLANATION OF THE STUPOR

    REACTION 186

    XI. MALIGNANT STUPORS 205

    XII. DIAGNOSIS OF STUPOR 223

    XIII. TREATMENT OF STUPOR 229

    XIV. SUMMARY OF THE STUPOR REACTION 234

    XV. THE LITERATURE OF STUPOR 249

    INDEX 279

    BENIGN STUPORS

    CHAPTER I

    INTRODUCTION AND TYPICAL CASES OF DEEP STUPOR

    The fact that psychiatry lags in development and recognition behind other branches of medicine is due in part to the crudity of its clinical methods. The evolution of interest in science is from simple, obvious and tangible problems to more intricate and impalpable researches.

    Refined laboratory work has been done in psychiatric clinics, particularly along histopathological lines, but clinical studies follow antiquated methods. The internist does not say, “The patient has sugar in his urine, therefore he has diabetes and therefore he will die.” He finds a glycosuria and looks for its cause. If this symptom is found to be related to others in such a way as to justify the diagnosis of diabetes, a therapeutic problem arises, that of adjusting the chemistry of the body. The prognosis depends not on the disease but the interreaction of the organism and the morbid process.

    Both in diagnosis and treatment an individual factor, the patient’s metabolism, is of prime importance. Now in psychiatry, although the personality is diseased, this personal factor has been almost entirely neglected.

    Text-books furnish us with composite pictures which are called diseases, not with descriptions of reactions brought about by the interplay of personal and environmental factors. Educated people are not satisfied with novels that fail to depict real characters. Clinical psychiatry, however, has been content with the dime-novel type of character delineation. This is all the more disappointing, inasmuch as the study of insanity should contribute largely to our knowledge of everyday life.

    This defect can only be remedied by looking on every case as a problem in which the origin of each symptom is to be studied and its relation traced to all other symptoms and to the personality as a whole. This is an ambitious task and we do not pretend to any great achievement, merely to a beginning.

    No better psychoses could be chosen for a preliminary effort than benign stupors. Every psychiatrist has seen them, although they are wrongly diagnosed as a rule, and they play no small rôle in the world’s history.

    Euripides represents Orestes as having a stupor which is pictured as accurately as any modern psychiatrist could describe an actual case.[1] St. Paul is chronicled as falling to the ground, being thereafter blind and going without food or drink for three days. While apparently unconscious he had a religious vision. St. Catherine of Siena had several unquestionable stupors, which are fairly well described. In fact the mystics in general seem to have had communion with God and the saints most often when they seemed unconscious to bystanders.[2] The obsession with death, which seems so intimate a part of the stupor reaction, is a fundamental theme in poetry, religion and philosophy.

    The psychology of this interest is, speaking broadly, the psychology of stupor. So, from a general standpoint, our problem is related to the study of one of the most potent ideas which move the soul of man.

    Psychiatrically, stupors have long remained an unsolved riddle. In the century prior to 1872 (See the digest of Dagonet’s publication in

    Chapter XV) French psychiatrists wrote some good descriptions of stupor

    and offered brilliant, though sketchy generalizations about the condition. Two years later an English psychiatrist (Newington, See

    Chapter XV) improved on the French work. Little light has been thrown on

    the subject since then. The researches of the later French School showed that stupor often occurs in the course of major hysteria, but this left many of these episodes obviously not hysterical. When serious attempts were made at classification, this ubiquitous symptom complex was hard to handle. Wernicke wisely refrained from attempting more than a loose descriptive grouping. He called all conditions with marked inactivity and apathy “akinetic psychoses” and said that some recovered, some did not.

    Taxonomic zeal began to blind vision when Kahlbaum formulated his “Catatonia” and included stupor in the symptom complex. The condition which we call stupor occurs in the course of many different types of mental disease. It is true that it is frequent in catatonia but is not exclusively there. Mongols have black hair and straight hair, but one cannot therefore say that any black and straight haired man is a Mongol.

    Fortunately Kahlbaum prevented serious error by leaving the prognosis of his catatonia open. When Kraepelin included it in his large group of Dementia præcox, however, it implied that stupor could not be an acute, recoverable condition.[3] He unquestionably advanced psychiatry greatly but his scheme was too ambitious to be accurate. Many observers saw patients, classified as dements according to Kraepelin’s formulæ, return, apparently normal, to normal life. Finally Kirby[4] published a series of cases which showed decisively that this classification was too rigid.

    Since his paper is the foundation for this present study, it should be reviewed carefully. He first points out that Kraepelin’s “Dementia præcox” includes much more than it should with its inevitably bad prognosis. He shows how others have found patients with catatonic symptom complexes proceed to recovery and speaks of these symptoms occurring in epilepsy and even in frankly organic conditions, such as brain tumor, general paralysis, trauma and infections.

    Kirby’s first claim is that there are probably fundamentally different catatonic processes, deteriorating and non-deteriorating. Lack of knowledge has prevented us from understanding the meaning of the symptoms and hence making the discrimination. He points out that stupor seems to represent an attitude of defense, similar to feigned death in animals, and that in a number of his cases it was clear that the stupor symbolized the death of the patient.

    Apparent negativism, he found to be often a consciously assumed attitude of aversion towards an unpleasant emotional situation.

    In cases where there had been no prodromal symptoms pointing definitely to dementia præcox the outcome was almost always good. To discriminate the cases with good outlook from those with bad, he discerned no difference in the stupors themselves, but observed that the mental make-up and initial symptoms differed sufficiently for diagnosis to be made. His most important point is, perhaps, that these benign stupors showed a definite relationship to manic-depressive insanity in that some patients passed directly from stupor to typical manic excitement, while in others a “catatonic” attack replaced a depression in a circular psychosis.

    Kirby introduces, then, the idea of stupor being a type of reaction which can occur either in dementia præcox or in manic-depressive insanity. The matter cannot be left there, in fact it raises new problems: what constitutes the reaction? how are the various symptoms interrelated? are they different in deteriorating and acute cases? what is the teleological significance of the reaction? if it be an integral part of the manic-depressive group, how does it affect our conceptions of what manic-depressive insanity is? More than five years have been spent in endeavors to answer these questions and the results of the study are now presented.

    Naturally the first point to be settled is: what constitutes the stupor reaction itself. We can say at the outset that it is seen in the purest form in benign cases, hence they make up the material of this book. To discover the symptoms of the disorder one cannot do better than to study them in their most glaring form in deep stupors, where consistently recurring phenomena may be assumed to be essential to the reaction.

    CASE 1.--Anna G. Age: 15. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute July 25, 1907.

    F. H. The mother and two brothers were living and said to
    be normal. The father died of apoplexy when the patient was
    seven.

    P. H. The patient was sickly up to the age of seven, but
    stronger after that. It is stated that she got on well at
    school, though she was somewhat slow in her work. She was
    inclined to be rather quiet, even when a child, a bit shy,
    but she had friends and was well liked by others. After
    recovery she made a frank, natural impression. She was
    always rather sensitive about her red hair. She began to
    work a year before admission and had two positions. The
    last one she did not like very well, because, she alleged,
    the girls were “too tough.”

    Three weeks before admission she came home from work and
    said a girl in the shop had made remarks about her red
    hair. She wanted to change her position, but she kept on
    working until six days before admission. At that time her
    mother kept her at home as she seemed so quiet, and when
    the mother took her out for a walk she wanted to return,
    because “everybody was looking” at her. For the next two
    days she cried at times, and repeatedly said, “Oh, I wish I
    were dead--nobody likes me--I wish I were dead and with my
    father” (dead).

    She also called to various members of the
    family, saying she wanted to tell them something, but when
    they came she would only stare blankly. For a day she
    followed her mother around, clung to her, said once she
    wanted to say something to her, but only stared and said
    nothing.

    Four days before admission she became quite immobile, lay
    in bed, did not speak, eat or drink. She also had some
    fever.

    The patient herself, when well, described the onset of her
    psychosis as follows: She knew of no cause except that her
    brother, some time before the onset (not clear how long),
    was run over by an automobile and had his foot hurt. She
    claimed that while still working she lost her ambition,
    lost her appetite, did not feel like talking to any one;
    that when she went out with her mother it merely seemed to
    her that people stared at her. The day before she went to
    the Observation Pavilion her cousin came to see her, and
    she thought she saw, standing beside this cousin, the
    latter’s dead mother.

    She also thought there was a fire,
    and that her sister was sweeping little babies out of the
    room. Then, she claimed, she felt afraid (this still on the
    day before going to the Observation Pavilion) because she
    had repeated visions of an old woman, a witch. This woman
    said, “I am your mother, and I gave you to this woman
    (i.e., patient’s real mother) when you were a baby.” She
    also was afraid her mother was “going away.”

    At the Observation Pavilion she was described as
    constrained, staring fixedly into space, mute, requiring to
    be dressed and fed.

    Under Observation: 1. For five months the patient
    presented a marked stupor. She was for the most part very
    inactive, totally mute, staring vacantly, often not even
    blinking, so that for a time the conjunctivæ were dry. She
    did not swallow, but held her saliva; did not react to pin
    pricks or feinting motions before her eyes. Sometimes she
    retained her urine, again wet and soiled the bed. Often
    there was marked catalepsy, and the retention of very
    awkward positions. As a rule she was quite stiff, offering
    passive resistance towards any interference. She had to be
    tube-fed at first.

    Later she was spoon-fed, and then would
    swallow, in spite of the fact that during the interval
    between her feeding she would let saliva collect in her
    mouth. For a time she had a tendency to hold one leg out of
    bed, and when it was put back would stick the other out.
    Sometimes she walked of her own accord to the toilet chair,
    but on one occasion wet the floor before she got there.

    During the first month after admission, this stupor was
    interrupted for two short periods by a little freer action:
    she walked to a chair, sat down, smiled a little, fanned
    herself very naturally when a fan was given to her, though
    even then did not speak.

    There was, as a rule, no emotional reaction, but after some
    months she several times wept when her mother came, though
    without speaking. Once when taken to the tub she yelled.

    Her physical condition during this stupor was as follows:
    She menstruated freely on admission, then not again until
    she was well. Several times she had rises of temperature to
    102° or 103° with a high pulse and respiration; again a
    respiration of 40, with but slight rise of temperature,
    though the pulse had a tendency to go to 130 and over. She
    was apt to show marked skin hyperæmia wherever touched.
    With the fever there was found a leucocytosis of from
    11,900 to 15,000, with marked increase of polynuclear
    leucocytes (89%).

    She got very emaciated, so that four
    months after admission she weighed 68 lbs. (height 5′ 2″).

    1. About five months after admission she was often seen

    smiling, and again weeping, and she began to talk a little
    to the nurses, though not to the doctors. She also began to
    eat excessively of her own accord, and rapidly gained
    weight, so that by January she weighed 98½ lbs., a gain
    of 30 lbs. in two months. Yet she continued to be sluggish.

    1. For two more months she was apathetic and appeared

    disinterested, often would not reply, again, at the same
    interview, she would do so promptly and with natural voice.
    This condition may be illustrated by the summary of a note
    made on January 29, 1908, which is representative of that
    period. It is stated that she sat about apathetically all
    day, appeared sluggish, but was fairly neat about her
    appearance and cleanly in her habits. There was at no time
    any evidence of affect, except when asked by the examiner
    to put out her tongue so that he could stick a pin in it
    she blushed and hid her face.

    When asked whether she
    worried about anything, she denied this. When questions
    were asked, she sometimes answered promptly and in normal
    voice, again simply remained silent in spite of repeated
    urging. On the whole, it seemed that simple impersonal
    questions were answered promptly; whereas difficult
    impersonal questions or questions which referred to her
    condition were not answered at all. She proved to be
    oriented. Thus she gave the day of the week, month, year,
    the name of the hospital, names of the doctors and nurses
    promptly.

    She also counted quickly and did a few simple
    multiplications quickly. But she was silent when asked
    where the hospital was located, how long she had been here,
    whether she was here one or six months, how she felt.
    Questions in regard to the condition she had passed
    through, or involving difficult calculations, she did not
    answer. However, some questions regarding her condition
    asked in such a way that they could be answered by “yes” or
    “no” were again answered quite promptly.

    Thus when asked
    whether her head felt all right she said, “Yes, sir.” (Is
    your memory good?) “Yes.” (Have you been sick?) “No, sir.”
    (Are you worried?) “No.”

    1. This apathy cleared up too, so that by the middle of

    March she was bright, active and smiled freely. With the
    nurses she was rather talkative and pleased, though this
    was not marked. Towards the physician only was she natural
    and free. She then gave the retrospective account of the
    onset detailed above. When questioned about her condition
    she claimed not to remember the Observation Pavilion,
    although recalling vaguely going there in a carriage. She
    was almost completely amnesic for a considerable part of
    her stay in the Institute. She claimed it was only in
    November or December that she began to know where she was
    (five months after admission).

    In harmony with this is the
    fact that she did not recall the tube- and spoon-feeding
    which had to be resorted to for about four months of this
    period. No ideas or visions were remembered. As to her
    mutism she said, “I don’t think I could speak,” “I made no
    effort,” again “I did not care to speak.” She claimed that
    she remembered being pricked with a pin but that she did
    not feel it. She remembered yelling when taken to the tub
    (towards end of the marked stupor) and claimed she thought
    she was to be drowned.

    When she went home (March 24, 1908) she got into a more
    elated condition. She was talkative, conversed with
    strangers on the street, said to her mother that she was
    now sixteen years old and wanted “a fellow.” When the
    mother would not allow her to go out, she said it would be
    better if they both would jump out of the window and kill
    themselves. She then was sent back to the hospital. In the
    first part of this period after her return, she was
    somewhat elated and overtalkative, though she did not
    present a flight of ideas, and was well behaved.

    She soon
    got well, however, and was discharged, four months after
    her readmission, fully recovered.

    After that, it is claimed, she was perfectly well and
    worked successfully most of the time with the exception of
    a short period in the spring of 1909, when she was slightly
    elated.

    In 1910 she had a subsequent attack, during which she was
    treated at another hospital. From the description this
    again seems to have been a typical stupor (immobility,
    mutism, tendency to catalepsy, rigidity). According to the
    account of the onset sent by that hospital (it was obtained
    from the mother), this attack began some months before
    admission, with complaints of being out of sorts, not being
    able to concentrate and fearing that another attack would
    come on. Finally the stupor was said to have been
    immediately preceded by a seizure in which the whole body
    jerked.

    She made again an excellent recovery.

    The patient was seen about two years after this attack, and
    described the development of the psychosis as follows: She
    claimed she began to feel “queer,” “nervous,” “depressed,”
    got sleepless. Then (this was given spontaneously) she
    suddenly thought she was dying and that her father’s
    picture was talking to her and calling her. “Then I lost my
    speech.” As after the first attack, she claimed not to have
    any recollection of what went on during a considerable part
    of the stupor but recalled that she began to talk after her
    brother visited her.

    It is not clear how she was during the
    period immediately following the stupor.

    She made a very natural impression and came willingly to
    the hospital in response to a letter and was quite open
    about giving information.

    CASE 2.--Caroline DeS. Age: 21. Admitted to the
    Psychiatric Institute June 10, 1909.

    F. H. The father died of apoplexy when patient was nine.
    The mother had diabetes. A paternal uncle was queer,
    visionary.

    P. H. The patient was always considered natural, bright,
    had many friends, and was efficient.

    Some months before admission the patient’s favorite
    brother, who is a Catholic, became engaged to a Protestant
    girl, and spoke of changing his religion. The family and
    the patient were annoyed at this, and the patient is said
    to have worried about it, but was otherwise quite natural
    until seven days before admission. Then, at the engagement
    dinner of the brother, the psychosis broke out.

    She refused
    to sit down to the table, and then suddenly began to sing
    and dance, cry and laugh and talk in a disconnected manner.
    Among other things, she said “I hate her,” “I love you,
    papa” (father is dead), “Don’t kill me.” She struck her
    brother. She was in a few days taken to the Observation
    Pavilion.

    The patient stated after recovery that what worried her was
    that the brother would marry a Protestant and that he would
    leave home (favorite brother).

    At the Observation Pavilion she was excited, shouted,
    screamed, laughed, called out “Don’t kill me,” again
    “Brother, brother,” “You are my brother” (to doctor).

    Under Observation: 1. On admission, and for two weeks,
    the patient presented a marked excitement, during most of
    which she was treated in the continuous bath. She tossed
    about, threw the sheets off, beat her breasts and abdomen,
    put her fingers into her mouth, bit the back of her hands,
    waved her arms about, sometimes with peculiar gyration,
    etc., at the same time shouting, singing, again praying,
    laughing or crying, sometimes fighting the nurses and
    resisting them. She also talked quite a little as a rule,
    but there were periods when, although excited, she would
    not talk or answer questions.

    She was very little
    influenced in her talk by the environment.

    When on one
    occasion asked if she had any trouble, she said: “No--I
    don’t want, somebody else gave me a book--all right I love
    myself, Uncle Mike too--all right too--all right I am in
    Bellevue--I love everybody except the Jews all right, all
    right--give me water, give me milk, give me seltzer--white
    horse uncle--Holy Father, he is killing me, I want my
    mother,” or “Wait a minute, say, that’s a lie--oh no, Holy
    water--no I didn’t wash the water away--oh, she forgets, I
    am sick--mother why don’t you come--look at the baby, they
    knocked my head against the wall--wait a minute, isn’t that
    terrible?--I was married--I was so--I forgot--April fool--I
    kiss you seven kisses and one more--I love papa and mamma,
    I like others too--I am papa’s angel child--yes I confess I
    love him, but I don’t want to die myself.” On another
    occasion, when asked where she was, she said: “I am at the
    ball--I am going to Heaven--don’t shoot me” (affectless).
    (Why are you afraid?) “Because you see--high water (in the
    tub)--white horse.” (What about the water?) “My name is
    Caroline--if you love me, father, tickle me under my feet,”
    or, rolling her eyes up, “Oh, isn’t that awful, that ring,
    that diamond, that is the key to Heaven.”

    1. For about ten days she was somewhat different. She

    became quieter and at first lay muttering unintelligibly,
    saying some things about being killed, but speaking little,
    often restlessly tossing about and tremulous. She had to be
    tube-fed. On one day (July 1) she smiled more and talked
    more, said to the physician “You have been arrested for
    me--you arrested the first man that I ever--New York
    State--let me see that book” (note pad).

    Then she went on:
    “Oh, I am all apart--diamonds--they didn’t know--must I
    keep them clean?--what is your name?--that is another thing
    I would like to know.” But when asked what house she was in
    she said: “This is the same Ward’s Island” and then added,
    “How long have I been here?--there is my picture up there
    (register), who is that? (listening) it’s Ida ...” She
    began to sing softly.

    Then again she whined. “O mamma,
    mamma!” When asked how long she had been here, she said:
    “Since Decoration Day, when my father went in my sister’s
    house, nobody could catch up with me--somebody blackened
    her eyes.” When asked whether she was sick, she said “No,
    insane.”

    Although, as was stated, she said at one time, “This is the
    same Ward’s Island,” usually questions regarding
    orientation were not answered, as she gave few relevant
    replies, but she repeatedly said spontaneously that she was
    in “Hoboken or Bellevue,” and called the nurse by the name
    of a former teacher. A few days after this state had
    developed she had a fever. Once this rose to 104°. The
    fever lasted two weeks, coming down gradually. It was
    associated with a leucocytosis of 15,000 on June 29 (no
    differential count) and with coated tongue. No Widal (two
    examinations). No diazo (July 1).

    1. Then while the temperature still lasted she developed a

    stupor which persisted for about a year. During this time
    her temperature rose to 100° without ascertainable cause.
    She lay for the most part motionless, changing her position
    but rarely; her expression was stolid; she retained and
    drooled saliva, wet and soiled herself. She never answered
    any questions; showed no interest whatever. At times she
    was quite stiff and very resistive but never cataleptic.
    Her extremities were cold and cyanotic. She had to be
    tube-fed throughout. During this time she lost much hair.

    After some months she occasionally gazed about furtively,
    or later watched everything when unaware of being observed;
    at this time she also smiled occasionally at amusing
    things, or perhaps said “yes” or “no” to questions, but
    usually was stolid when interrogated.

    Then about nine months after admission, while in the
    condition just described, she developed a lobar pneumonia.
    During it she remained the same. But during convalescence
    she began to speak and eat.

    1. A period followed lasting six months during which she

    was up and about, but sat or stood around a good deal. On
    the other hand, she helped the nurses a little when urged.
    Her face was often stolid, again she looked about. At times
    (even nearly to the end) she drooled and soiled. She said
    little. At no time was she resistive. On other occasions
    she smiled or laughed, not always on provocation, or she
    showed little playful tendencies, such as throwing a pillow
    about the room, tearing leaves from the plants, taking the
    doctor’s arm and walking down the hall, asking him to kiss
    her. At such times she often looked quite bright, keen,
    alert and amused.

    Towards the end she would give at times
    playful answers, such as “I came to-day,” or “This is the
    Hall of Fame.” This tapered off, so that by December, 1910,
    she was perfectly well.

    Retrospectively, the patient claimed not to remember the
    upset at the dinner, or what happened afterward, although
    recalling the trip to the Observation Pavilion. She denied
    any memory of the journey to the hospital, but could tell
    what ward she came to. How well the condition after that
    was recalled, was not inquired into, except that she could
    or would not explain further the utterances during the
    first period. For the stupor period it is stated that she
    remembered many external facts, but it is not clear in
    which period they occurred.

    Catamnestic Note. May, 1913: She has worked efficiently,
    and is said to have been perfectly well.

    CASE 3.--Mary F. Age: 21. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute June 28, 1902.

    F. H. The mother died when the patient was five. The
    father was living, an alcoholic and reckless man. Four
    brothers and sisters died in infancy.

    P. H. The patient was the only surviving child. She was
    brought up in a convent and orphan asylum until 11, when
    her father remarried. At 12 she had to go to work, hence
    she had but little education. She was bright, efficient,
    well liked by her employers (in one position five years).
    As to her peculiarities, she was thought to be, perhaps, a
    little headstrong, and was also described as always very
    exact, rather quick-tempered and inclined to be irritable
    when crossed.

    She was married six months before admission and had a baby
    three weeks before admission
    . The husband stated that when
    the father found out she was pregnant, he spoke of killing
    him. He frequently upbraided both husband and wife, though
    he lived with them. Even after the child was born he
    continued to be disagreeable.

    The patient was rather low spirited and quieter after her
    marriage. She worried over her illegitimate pregnancy and
    the scolding from her father. But nothing was thought of
    all this, and it did not interfere with her activity. The
    birth was normal. She had no flow, no unfavorable symptoms,
    and sat up on the twelfth day. She is said to have appeared
    natural mentally.

    A week before admission the family returned from the
    christening, having left the patient apparently well. They
    now found her sitting in her chair, limp, with closed eyes,
    giving no answer to questions. Only after about twenty
    minutes could she be aroused. After her father had given
    her milk with whiskey in it, she claimed he had poisoned
    her. In the evening she was bright and lively, singing and
    dancing with the others, but in the night she woke up her
    husband, seemed frightened, said somebody was in the room
    and that he should get a priest as she was going to die.
    The husband went to sleep again.

    The next forenoon the
    patient claimed she had been frightened all night and
    thought her father was going to kill her husband.

    On the second day, while sitting at breakfast, she groped
    about for the bread plate for some time and then said she
    had been blind for a short time. During the day she had
    frequent spells in which she would close her eyes, become
    perfectly quiet and difficult to rouse. Sometimes at the
    beginning of these spells she would say “I am going.” She
    was then taken to her aunt and walked there, a distance of
    a few blocks. She was there for two days before going to
    the Observation Pavilion. In this time she is said to have
    been quiet for the most part, often apparently sleeping or
    staring.

    Once she said she was “rather dirty, filthy.” Once
    she tried to get out of the window, said it was a door and
    that she wanted to get out and take a walk. Above all, she
    had, in these two days, repeated peculiar seizures which
    the aunt and the husband described as follows: When sitting
    on a chair she would close her eyes, clench her fists,
    pound the side of the chair, get stiff, slide on the floor,
    then thrash her arms and legs about and move the head to
    and fro. She frothed at the mouth.

    After the attack, which
    lasted a few minutes, she breathed heavily for a while.
    Once she wiped off the froth with a handkerchief and gave
    the latter to the aunt, saying “Burn that, it is poison.”
    Before the attack she sometimes said that it got dark over
    her eyes and that her face felt funny, again that she had a
    pain in the stomach which worked towards her right
    shoulder. There was no cry in the beginning of the attack,
    but once she wet herself.

    After recovery the patient herself told the development of
    her psychosis thus:

    There was trouble between the father and the husband, and
    she was afraid of her father. On the day of the christening
    she took sick: a queer feeling came over her and she
    wondered whether she was going to die, “Then I seemed to
    lose myself, and when I came to I found my family standing
    around me.” Her father gave her whiskey and she thought it
    was poison. “That night I had spells of dancing and
    singing, it must have been something I took, perhaps the
    liquor.” The same night she was frightened, thought her
    father might do some harm, and had a vision of a person in
    white standing at her bed.

    After that she had repeated
    spells in which she knew nothing until “I came to again.”
    “It was a queer trembling.”

    At the Observation Pavilion she was described as in a
    state of “intense mental depression,” taking no interest in
    things going on about her. She spoke, however; said she
    wanted to die, that she had imagined her father had given
    her poison, that every one was against her, and that people
    were talking about her.

    1. On admission the patient had a slightly elevated

    temperature, which soon subsided, full breasts but without
    inflammation. Sordes were not mentioned.

    For a few days she was essentially somewhat restless,
    getting out of bed, disarranging her clothes, wandering
    about--all in a rather deliberate, aimless way, sometimes
    vaguely resistive, again with free movements. She looked,
    dazed, sometimes stared straight ahead and looked “dreamy.”
    Occasionally there was a tendency to close her eyes. With
    the restlessness she looked at times “a little
    apprehensive,” or shrank away when approached. She spoke
    slowly, with initial difficulty, but answered quite a
    number of questions.

    The mental content of this period was
    displayed in the following utterances: She would ask for a
    priest, or say “Have I done something?” or “Do people want
    something?” or, when asked why she was here, she said “I
    have done damage to the city, didn’t I?” (What have you
    done?) “I don’t know.” Or she spoke of people watching her.
    When asked the day, she said “Judgment Day,” yet she knew
    the month.

    Once when asked what the place was she said,
    “This is the hereafter.” When asked what had happened at
    home, she said: “Voices told me I was to be killed.” She
    was not clearly oriented, called the place Bellevue, asked
    “Isn’t this a hospital?” yet again said, “Ward’s Island,
    where they work.” On the day of admission she thought she
    came “the day before,” but knew she had come in a boat.
    When asked her address, she said slowly, “Didn’t I live at,
    etc.,” giving the address correctly. To the physician she
    said, “Are you my brother?” And on another occasion, “My
    God! You are Charlie” (brother).

    It was difficult to get
    her to eat, and she had to be spoon-fed.

    1. Then she became more preoccupied, the restlessness was

    much less in evidence, it became necessary to tube-feed
    her, she retained her urine, answered a few questions, and
    when asked where she was, she said, “Calvary, ain’t it?”
    (What house?) “Heaven, ain’t it?” She still called the
    physician by the name of her brother. After a few days this
    gave way to a more marked stupor which lasted nearly two
    years. This was characterized most frequently by a complete
    inactivity.

    She usually lay or sat motionless, sometimes
    with mouth partly open, letting the flies crawl over her
    face, gazing in one direction, soiling, wetting, resisting
    moderately or markedly any interference, and had to be
    tube-fed. But this was not the invariable state. The most
    constant feature was her mutism, but even that was a few
    times interrupted. Thus, when after a visit from her uncle
    (towards the end of July, 1902) she tried to get out of the
    window and was prevented, she swore at the nurse.

    Or in
    August, 1902, when she got into another patient’s bed and
    was taken out, she resisted and said promptly: “I think it
    is a damned shame I can’t get into my own bed.” But this
    was the extent of her talk for a year and a half. Nor was
    she always totally inactive. In the middle of July, 1902,
    she sometimes tried to get out of bed, wandered about, got
    into other patients’ beds. It was on such an occasion that
    the above incident happened.

    In August, 1902, she sometimes
    tried to get out when the door was opened, and we have
    seen that she tried to get out of the window, but she did
    not change her placid expression at such times. Her motive
    was not known.

    On two occasions towards the end of 1902,
    when she was taken to a dance and was made to take part,
    she waltzed with considerable animation but did not speak.
    This was quite striking in that these incidents occurred in
    a setting of marked inactivity (i.e., a condition in which
    she had to be pushed to the table, pushed to the closet).
    She did not soil any more, but she sometimes drooled and
    had to be spoon-fed. However, on a third occasion when this
    was tried, she had to be dragged around.

    Finally, though
    her facial expression showed at times a preoccupied
    staring, she more often looked around, sometimes quite
    freely and often looked up promptly enough when accosted.
    But there was very little evidence of any affect at any
    time. We have seen that twice she swore a little when
    opposed. On another occasion she slapped a patient when the
    latter helped her. Twice she was seen crying a little
    without apparent provocation, but she did not laugh, and
    the only suggestion of pleasurable emotion was that at the
    two dances mentioned she could be led into a certain
    animation.

    Usually, even when she got less resistive
    towards the end, she was essentially apathetic.

    Once in January, 1903, she could be made to write her name
    but wrote her maiden name. In the end of 1903 she improved
    gradually (a condition not well observed), so that by
    December she answered some questions in a low tone. Even in
    April, 1904, she was still described as apathetic, though
    she had begun to do some work.

    1. Then she improved markedly and began to work, looked

    after herself in a natural way, spoke freely, was entirely
    oriented and her mood generally presented nothing striking.
    But her mental attitude was still peculiar when she was
    questioned. She seemed somewhat inattentive, sulky,
    sneering. Thus, when asked why she was here, she said, “You
    will have to ask those who brought me here.”

    She denied ever having been pregnant, said the nurses on
    the ward had spoken of her having had a child and that they
    had showed her a child (one was born on that ward about
    August, 1903) but that it was not hers. She thought it was
    wrong for the nurses to speak on the ward of her having
    been pregnant. Again questioned about her marriage, she
    first said she had not been married, again that she was
    married “a year ago” (was in the hospital then).

    Again she
    spoke of her husband as her “gentleman friend,” claimed she
    called herself Mary M. (maiden name) until a girl friend
    wrote her a letter addressed to Mrs. F. From then on, she
    called herself by her married name. But she thought that
    probably they sometimes spoke of her marriage in fun. If
    she were Mrs. F. she would be living in Mr. F.’s house.

    On June 29, when again asked about her marriage, she said
    she was to have been married in December (correct date).
    (Were you?) “So they say.” (Do you remember it?) “In a
    way.” (When was the baby born?) “You will have to ask
    somebody more superior to me, more experienced.” Then, when
    further questioned about the age of the baby, she said,
    “The baby I saw in the ward was about a year old,” and she
    claimed not to remember ever having a baby.

    When asked why
    she had come here she said, “Well, I don’t know, perhaps
    you know better, through sickness I guess,” and later:
    “Well, don’t you ever get a cold and want doctors to
    examine you?” (What kind of a place?) “This is a nice place
    for sensible people who have enough knowledge to know and
    realize what they come for.” But she knew the name of the
    place, the date, the names of persons.

    Questioned about the trouble with her father or her
    husband’s trouble with him, she denied it, “If he did (sc.
    have any trouble), I don’t remember.” About her not
    speaking, she said, in answer to questions, “I didn’t know
    what I was here for, what was the object in keeping me
    here”; and to other questions about her condition, “I don’t
    know, those who examined me can tell you more about that.”
    Finally, she said in reply to the question, why she came
    here, “I don’t remember unless it was through fire,” but
    would not explain what she meant.

    In the beginning of July, she again said that she had no
    recollection of her marriage.

    She then improved a great deal and finally appeared very
    natural, gave the retrospective account noted in the
    history, had a clear appreciation of the fact that she was
    married and had a child. She claimed that she had
    previously forgotten about her marriage and thought she was
    still merely keeping company with Mr. F. She claimed not to
    remember coming to the hospital, did not know what ward
    she came to, who the doctor and nurses were, in fact
    claimed that it was about a year before she knew where she
    was. But she remembered having been tube-fed. She could not
    say why she did not speak.

    But she appreciated that she had
    been ill.

    Ten years after discharge the husband, in answer to an
    inquiry, stated that she had been perfectly well and had
    had no trouble at three successive childbirths.

    CASE 4.--Mary D. Age: 20. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute September 17, 1907.

    F. H. The grandfather and the father of the patient were
    alcoholics. The father died three years before the
    patient’s admission; he was killed in an accident. The
    mother stated that she herself was nervous, but she made a
    normal impression.

    P. H. The patient was described as bright at school and
    efficient in her work as a dressmaker, but she was rather
    quiet, inclined to stay at home and had not much
    inclination to consort with the other sex. She was rather
    proud. As an example of this is stated the fact that she
    was always somewhat sensitive, because the family lived in
    the basement of the house in which her mother was
    janitress. She did not menstruate until 16. It was about
    this time that her father was killed in an accident.

    She
    was considerably upset by this, talked a good deal about
    the way he was killed, but did not break down. The patient
    on recovery stated that it worried her because the father
    died without having any chance to get a priest.

    Six weeks before admission the patient was given a
    vacation, as there was not work enough in the shop, but she
    worked at home.

    Two or three weeks before admission her appetite failed
    somewhat, and ten days before admission, without any
    appreciable cause, she began to sleep badly, seemed
    somewhat nervous, became a little “fidgety” and said she
    worried because her mother had to work so hard. Later she
    began to speak about people saying that the ambulance would
    come for her and she heard voices saying “You will be
    dead.” It is not known in what emotional setting these
    remarks were made. Her mother took her to a dispensary.

    On
    the way she asked the mother where she was going and said
    “I can’t tell the number and I don’t know where I am going.
    I think I am losing my mind.” She also said she could not
    understand any more what she read. She was put to bed. She
    then talked less, appeared stupid, and was inclined to
    refuse food.

    Four days before admission she claimed that she could see
    her dead father beckoning to her, again she said a certain
    young man was God. She was sent to the Observation
    Pavilion. On the day she went there she was reported to
    have shown a slight jaundice.

    The patient, after her recovery, added to the above account
    of the mother, that about two weeks before admission, for
    no reason which she could state, she began to feel quiet,
    and that after that her father’s death began to prey on her
    mind, and that later she had a vision of her father. She
    claimed that in this period she had no fear but that her
    head felt dizzy and her vision seemed dim.

    At the Observation Pavilion the patient was described as
    constrained, refusing food, mute, resistive of attention,
    sometimes muttering to herself and having the appearance of
    uneasiness.

    Under Observation: 1. On admission the patient had a
    slight jaundice, which disappeared in a few days, and the
    bile test in the urine was negative on admission. She was
    rather thin, but otherwise in good physical condition. Her
    temperature was 99.2°.

    For three months the patient was very inactive, moving very
    little. She had to be dressed and undressed, when taken out
    of bed. She often was markedly constrained, either lying
    with her head raised from the pillow, or for long periods
    of time holding her arms or hands in rather constrained
    positions on her body. But there was at no time any
    catalepsy when tested by moving her arms. In the beginning,
    however, before she lay so persistently with her head
    raised, she was found holding it up from the pillow after
    her hair had been fixed.

    Again, she did not correct other,
    rather uncomfortable, positions in which she had been left.
    There was also at times a slight or occasionally a somewhat
    more marked resistance in her arms and neck, but this never
    amounted to a pronounced resistance. She sometimes did not
    react to pin pricks, sometimes flinched a little, never
    warded off the pin, indeed she would put out her tongue
    repeatedly when asked to do so in order to have a pin stuck
    into it. She very often wet and soiled, once even
    immediately after she had been taken to the closet, on
    which occasion she did not urinate.

    Her face was usually
    dull, vacant and immobile, but sometimes, when questioned
    or when something obtrusive happened, a little puzzled.
    Occasionally she looked slowly about or followed people
    with her eyes. There was no evidence of any affect as a
    rule, but not infrequently she smiled, even quite freely at
    times, when the physician came to her or on other
    appropriate occasions. For example, once when a nurse came
    into the ward whom she had known outside she flushed and
    smiled a little. Once when the mother came to see her a few
    tears appeared, the only time this occurred.

    Although for the most part immobile, when she did move, she
    was distinctly slow. When asked to do certain things, she
    usually did not comply, but now and then, after urging,
    would show her tongue after delay, or merely open her
    mouth; or she would bring the hand forward slowly when the
    physician offered his hand in greeting. Once she fumbled
    with her braids slowly. When out of bed, she stood about
    aimlessly or sometimes walked somewhat slowly.

    She was almost entirely mute, but a few times she returned
    a greeting quite promptly, or on another occasion
    (September 23) she said quite promptly, when asked how she
    felt, “I feel better. I took off my clothes” (correct--she
    had been up and put to bed again). Again she sometimes
    answered simple questions by “yes” or “no,” though
    sometimes in a contradictory and rather aimless manner, but
    promptly enough. Once she said to her mother, “I can’t, I
    have to remain here.” There were some other replies which
    we shall presently take up. Several times it was possible
    to make her write.

    On these occasions she wrote her name
    promptly, or might write only after much delay or stopping
    in the middle of a word.

    This leads us to her capacity to think, the defect of which
    was perhaps most clear in her writing. Thus, though having
    been told to write her name, and having written it quickly
    enough, when, immediately after it, she was asked to write
    her address or the name of the hospital, she had to be
    urged much, and then wrote each time merely a repetition of
    her name, this time much more slowly.

    On October 13, when
    she was asked to write her name, she wrote it correctly;
    then for the address she wrote the house number correctly,
    but for 90th street she wrote “90theath”; and, urged again
    for the address, she added “Dr.

    Wyeth.” Again when asked to
    write the word “watch” she was slow, and finally put down
    “10.” When on October 23 she was asked to write “Manhattan
    State Hospital,” she wrote “Manhatt Hhospshosh,” and for
    “Ward’s Island” (which she was told), “Ww Iland.” Then she
    was asked to write “I wish to go home.” She wrote “I wish
    to go home, go West.” Here again the first part was written
    promptly.

    We now can add some of the other replies which she gave.
    Once she was asked “Do you know where you are?” She
    promptly said, “Yes.” (Where?) No reply. On another
    occasion, at the initial examination, she said she was home
    or “in papa’s house.” Once when asked “Do you know me?” she
    said “Yes.” (What is my name?) “Miss D.” (her name). On the
    occasion on which she had stated that she had taken off her
    clothes, she was asked “Where have you taken off your
    clothes?” She made the irrelevant reply, “That was the girl
    the one I had.”

    1. Then she improved somewhat. On January 5 she walked

    about a little more, though slowly, and still looked
    slightly puzzled when questioned. She spoke more readily,
    counted promptly though once stopped in the middle of the
    exercise. In calculation she multiplied correctly 3 × 7,
    but for 4 × 9 repeated the 21, and when given 9 × 9 she did
    not answer. A few days later, though she lay again
    motionless with her head raised as before, and, as she had
    sometimes done, smiled brightly when accosted, she gave few
    replies, but when asked to write down the month she slowly
    wrote “December.” Asked to write it the second time, she
    did it promptly.

    She also replied promptly by saying “Yes”
    when asked whether Christmas, and again whether New Year’s,
    had passed, but did not reply to the questions how long ago
    Christmas, or how long ago New Year’s, had occurred. On
    January 23 she was decidedly more free and prompt in her
    replies, yet she still wet and soiled (in fact this did not
    cease until the end of the month, when great improvement
    occurred). At this time she gave quite a number of
    calculations promptly, about an equal number wrongly.

    She
    knew where she was, knew the names of a number of people
    about her, but thought she had been here about two weeks
    (four months), and gave the year and the date, the latter
    as the 28th of January. When then told that it was
    Thursday, January 23, and that she must remember it, and
    asked five minutes later what she had been told, she again
    said “January 28” and left out Thursday. To some questions
    to which she did not know the answers, since she had an
    amnesia for the time of their occurrence (the incidents of
    coming here), she simply remained silent.

    Even on February
    7, when she was much freer, helped the nurses, and said
    herself she was “smarter,” she had difficulty in thinking,
    said she was 17 (21), gave the date of her birth correctly,
    but the current year as 1909 (1908) and still insisted she
    was 17. She then did the calculations on paper, and with
    considerable difficulty got correctly “22.” But she could
    not straighten out the discrepancy.

    At that time, also, she
    still wrote “Hospitital,” calculated even simple
    multiplications with some mistakes, could not get the point
    of a story, and to retention tests gave poor results.
    Indeed, even seven days later, when she wrote a very
    rational letter and appeared quite natural, she made some
    omissions in her writing, and a few mistakes in spelling.

    However, she now improved rapidly, and by March 31 she made
    a very natural impression, was frank, free, had good
    insight, calculated well, etc., understood a story,
    retention was good.

    She then gave the retrospective account embodied in the
    history, and in addition told that she had no recollection
    of going to the Observation Pavilion, the coming here, or
    the first part of her stay, including presentation of the
    case at a staff meeting, a physical examination and a blood
    examination, and she claimed for a long time not to know
    where she was, “I was in a kind of dazed condition.” She
    also said she could not understand the questions which were
    asked her. This probably refers, however, to the second
    part, i.e., the partial stupor lasting for two months.

    She
    did not “feel like talking,” the limbs “felt stiff-like.”

    CASE 5.--Annie K. Age: 22. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute January 7, 1907.

    F. H. The father was an alcoholic, who died when patient
    was a child. A paternal aunt had a nervous breakdown, with
    recovery. The mother appeared to be normal.

    P. H. The mother stated that the patient was a rather
    delicate child. She attended school irregularly, never felt
    much interest in it, and was always glad to be at home and
    help the mother take care of the other children. On the
    other hand, she is said to have been quite lively, rather a
    tomboy, with a temper. She left school at 14; learned
    dressmaking for a year, but did not get along well. Then
    she took several other positions, which she held for about
    a year, getting on pretty well.

    She married at 20. Her husband never supported her well and
    often beat her. She had to borrow money to get along and
    worried much. During pregnancy she seemed to worry more,
    had crying spells, and often seemed absorbed in thought.

    Three weeks before admission she gave birth to a child. The
    labor was somewhat difficult, but she had no fever. She got
    up on the tenth day, and then seemed to lose all interest,
    did not attend to the baby, said she was not strong enough.
    She sat about, appearing depressed. The mother then took
    her and the baby to her house. There she sat or walked
    about, said very little. But she repeatedly came to her
    mother, said she had something to tell her, or that she had
    “done something,” although she could never be induced to
    say what. Once she came to her and said, “You are not going
    to die.” She often moaned.

    Finally, she claimed a neighbor
    had been saying she was poisoning the baby.

    The patient herself gave, after recovery, the onset as
    follows: When she married she knew her husband was not what
    he should be, but not that he was so bad as he proved to
    be. He was a gambler, did not support her, and this caused
    her much worry.

    When she became pregnant, eight months
    after marriage, this increased her worry, and throughout
    the pregnancy she spoke much to a neighbor about her
    worries, and said she did not know how she could manage,
    pay the doctor, and the like, but she did not say much
    about it to her mother (because the latter would have made
    such a fuss about it, or would have said, “It serves you
    right”). Then the childbirth came. This further accentuated
    her worries. She felt her difficult circumstances, wondered
    how she could get the necessary money, “I lay there
    worrying.” And she claimed she did not sleep at all.

    About
    her statement, mentioned by the mother, that she had done
    something, she said that she thought she had poisoned the
    child by giving it fennel tea, and that she thought a
    neighbor who visited her said she had poisoned it. She was
    then put to bed again, and one night she had a vision of
    her father. This frightened her. She thought this meant he
    had come for her and she wanted to die.

    At the Observation Pavilion she was dull, staring,
    resisting attempts at passive motions.

    Under Observation: 1. There was nothing noteworthy in her
    physical condition, except for a rise of temperature to
    100° occasionally during the first month of her admission.
    For the first four months she was often found lying in bed
    with her head half raised from the pillow, or standing or
    sitting about in constrained positions, immobile,
    frequently she let saliva collect in her mouth. She usually
    wet and sometimes soiled the bed. Sometimes, when sitting
    in a constrained position, she let herself gradually slide
    on the floor.

    She often began to feed herself when urged,
    but would not finish, and had to be spoon-fed, as a rule.
    She was never tube-fed. She was often quite stiff and
    showed marked resistance. This was manifested either when
    passive motions were tried, at which times she usually
    resisted passively, i.e., she became more tense; or when
    there broke through a more active aggression and she would
    strike.

    Above all, the opposition showed itself towards the
    nurses’ attention; in this she also showed either a
    passive, aimless opposition and stiffness, or a more active
    one; but even in the latter an open show of angry affect,
    or plain irritation, though present at times, was by no
    means constant. When it was present, she would strike quite
    aimfully; once she struck the nurse and said, “You are the
    cause of it all,” and once, when the nurse tried to give
    her some milk, she said, in an irritated tone, “I wonder
    people would not let me alone some time.” Again, she bit a
    patient who tried to hold her.

    On another occasion she
    quickly jumped up and pulled the hair of a patient who
    evidently disturbed her by her noisy shouting. As was
    stated, she usually wet the bed, resisted being taken to
    the toilet, or when taken there, would not urinate or
    defecate, but would do so as soon as she was returned to
    bed; or she urinated while standing. The same perverse
    opposition was seen when she would refuse a glass of milk,
    but grab it when it was taken away and then refuse to let
    go. She often would grasp the bedclothes or other things
    and hold on aimlessly.

    She rarely spoke, answered almost no questions, complied,
    as a rule, not even with the simplest commands. To pin
    pricks she did not react except at times by flushing. But
    she did not stare, rather looked about, and was at times
    easily attracted by noises or happenings about her, and
    would then look in that direction not without some
    interest. Often there was then an expression of
    bewilderment. Her mood, however, was, as a rule, apathetic,
    but at times, as stated, she showed some anger. Once she
    wept, and a few times she smiled or snickered. As a rule,
    this happened without appreciable cause.

    But once, when a
    cheering remark was made, she smiled; or, when her picture
    was taken (to show the peculiar constrained attitude with
    the head raised from the pillow), she laughed loudly.

    Although she spoke rarely, she made a few utterances in the
    first few days. Thus she suddenly said: “I want to see Mr.
    N.--what I said to him was not right,” or “Listen! there
    are the priests calling,” or “You are all faking--it is me
    that done it--they are all dressing up downstairs,” or “I
    told you she was not able to nurse the baby,” or “I have
    nobody, I am lost--I want to know the truth--my mamma,” or
    she called her sister, “They are dead since last night.”

    Even during the more stuporous state she could, a few
    times, be made to write a little. Then she either wrote
    very slowly and not more than a letter, or if she wrote
    more, it was remarkably mixed up. Thus when asked to write
    the date, she wrote, “Jane (mother’s name) to me to
    Chrichst,” or when asked to write her name: “Annie take you
    ktusto.”

    As to her orientation, nothing could be made out as a rule.
    At first, however, a few weeks after admission, she spoke
    correctly of the month as January and spoke of the Island.
    When at that time she was asked if she had a baby, she
    said, in an annoyed tone, “I don’t know.”

    1. In the beginning of May, i.e., four months after

    entrance, her condition changed somewhat, and for two
    months she presented the following state: She stood about,
    or walked around slowly, usually with her arms folded. She
    had a tendency to stand near the door. She had to be
    assisted in dressing, pushed rather than led to her meals,
    and urged to eat. For the most part, she would not answer
    questions, but would either smile in a sneering way, or
    just walk away, or say, “Oh, don’t bother me,” or “I don’t
    want to talk,” and generally her attitude was rather sulky.
    Nor was this only towards the physicians but towards the
    husband, sister and child as well.

    When on May 17 the
    sister came, she would not speak to her but said “Go away.”
    The baby she simply pushed away sulkily when it was brought
    to her. To the husband she said on May 31, “Go away, you
    stink.” In the first part of this period, she presented
    some bursts of elation, on one occasion turned somersaults,
    indulged in a few pranks with laughter, or once, when a
    knock at the door was heard, she called out “Holy gee,
    cheese it, the cop.” But these occurred only in the first
    part of the period.

    On June 1 she spoke to the nurse, said,
    “What is the matter with these people, they must be crazy,”
    asked to go home, and was then by the nurse found to be
    oriented, and to know the names of people around her. But
    when she was asked about the baby she would not answer, and
    questioned whether she was not married, she said “I don’t
    know.” Yet when the physician desired to talk to her, she
    was just the same as before and remained so for two more
    weeks.

    Another somewhat isolated occurrence was when on
    June 18 she spoke a little to the physician, but she sat in
    a constrained position when taken into the office and
    answered many questions by “I don’t know,” namely, those
    regarding her condition and feelings, the questions about
    orientation, about her mother’s address, and her child’s
    age; but when asked how long she had been married she said
    correctly “Two years.”

    At the beginning of July she improved quite rapidly, and on
    July 5 appeared fairly free and gave a fair retrospective
    account, with some urging, and it was thought that she
    smiled somewhat too freely. However, on July 27, she seemed
    perfectly well, had normal insight, and then gave the
    second retrospective account, which, together with the
    first, will now be taken up.

    Retrospectively: She claimed to remember things at home,
    and at both interviews said she recalled being taken to the
    Observation Pavilion. While there she thought she knew
    where she was, remembered that she did not talk. She had a
    feeling she was going to die and said “I thought I would
    die if I kept still.” However, the transfer to this
    hospital was vague in her mind, as was the entrance on the
    ward, and she claimed not to have known for quite a while
    where she was.

    She added that she used to wonder where she
    was, how she had gotten here, and how she could get out,
    and thought the questions which were asked were queer.
    Individual occurrences, too, specifically inquired into
    were not recollected, such as an examination in a special
    room. Of the mixed-up writing at the end of the second
    week, she had no recollection even when it was shown to
    her. She did not recall having her picture taken (with eyes
    open) two months after entrance. Yet a sudden angry
    outburst ten weeks after admission was remembered.

    She
    stated that she struck the patient because the latter
    annoyed her by her shouting. She had a general recollection
    of being stiff, having her head raised, and of soiling and
    drooling, but could not account for it. She felt stubborn.
    She also claimed not to have been hungry and not to have
    felt pin pricks.

    In regard to ideas which she had, she claimed to be afraid
    at first that she would be cut up. She remembered repeated
    visions of her father at night, also once of her dead aunt,
    who said “Come to me.” She thought she was in a cemetery,
    all the family were dead, the baby dead. In the beginning,
    too, she sometimes heard a priest whom she had known, say
    “Be good and God will look after you.”

    In regard to the later period, she recalled that she got up
    in May and felt cross. She did not answer because she did
    not want to be bothered. She pushed the baby away because
    she did not think it belonged to her, the husband because
    she did not like him. (She did not think she was not
    married.) She evidently remembered the visits, thought she
    knew where she was, knew she stood near the door “because I
    wanted to go home.” Besides the idea that the baby was not
    hers, she recalled none, and thought she had no
    hallucinations.

    She was discharged perfectly well six months after
    admission to the hospital. Soon after that, she left the
    husband, once had him arrested in 1908 and sent to the
    workhouse. She was again examined in 1913, and was found to
    be perfectly well, and she stated she had been well since
    the discharge.

    These five cases will have to suffice for the present. They were given in full in spite of the fact that we shall leave out of our present considerations the history of the cases and certain of the stages, and confine ourselves to that stage of each case which is best qualified to give us a good general survey of the essential features of the stupor reaction.

    These phases are: stage 1 of Case 1, lasting five months; stage 3 of Case 2, lasting one year; stage 2 of Case 3, lasting two years; stage 1 of Case 4, lasting three months; stage 1 of Case 5, lasting four months.

    We gather from these descriptions that the essentials of the stupor reaction are (1) more or less marked interference with activity, often to the point of complete cessation of spontaneous and reactive motions and speech; (2) interference with the intellectual processes; (3) affectlessness; (4) negativism.

    Inactivity: There is a complete cessation or more or less marked diminution of all spontaneous or reactive movements. This includes such voluntary muscle reflexes as contain a psychic component. For instance, there is, often, an interference with swallowing (letting saliva collect and drooling), winking, and even with the inhibitory processes used in holding urine and feces (soiling and wetting). Often there is no reaction to pin pricks or feinting motions. The inactivity also often interferes with the taking of food so that spoon-feeding or tube-feeding has to be resorted to.

    The patient may keep his eyes covered or stare vacantly, the face often presenting a remarkably immobile wooden, or stolid, expression. Complete mutism is the rule. When activity is not totally interfered with, those movements which are present may be slow.

    The patient may have to be pushed around and be able to take a few steps, but soon relapses. More often they are of normal rapidity. Speech then may also be slow and low, but usually shows no change except for the fact that it is diminished in amount. Sometimes awkward positions are assumed and retained, and there may be catalepsy.

    Negativism: A common symptom is perverse resistiveness. It may consist in a marked stiffening of the body which is assumed spontaneously or appears only when attempts at interference are made, or there may be a more active turning away or even a direct warding off, sometimes with scowling or anger or even swearing and striking. Retention of urine, which is seen at times, should, perhaps, be mentioned here. Now and then we find that a patient is put on the toilet and cannot be induced to urinate or defecate, while soiling and wetting occur at once on returning to bed.

    The intellectual processes: Little is known about the intellectual processes from direct observation in these more pronounced cases, except for the fact that in Case 5 questions or obtrusive occurrences sometimes produced a somewhat puzzled facial expression. Moreover, the patient retrospectively stated that she was unable to understand the questions, which points to marked difficulty in apprehension. We also find that occasionally there is evidence of an interference with the intellectual processes which showed itself in what may be called “paragraphic” writing when the patient could be induced to write.

    Above all, we see that retrospectively very little is remembered of what took place during the stupor, even of such obtrusive events as the moving from one ward to another, tube-feeding, physical examination, the presentation at a staff meeting, and the like.

    Affect: Complete affectlessness is an integral part of the stupor reaction. Modification of the statement will later be mentioned. The patient is indifferent so far as his basic condition is concerned, and it is only by certain stimuli that at times emotional reactions can be elicitated, some tears at a visit of a relative, an appropriate smile at a joke or a comical situation when the stupor is not too deep or an angry reaction called forth by interference.

    Catalepsy: Waxy flexibility or merely a tendency to maintain artificial positions is a frequent but not an essential symptom.

    Physical Condition: Not infrequently we find in the beginning or in the course of the stupor an elevation of temperature to 101°, 102° or even 103°. In one case we found a marked cyanosis in the extremities.

    Case 2 showed marked loss of hair. Gain in weight is never observed and marked emaciation is the rule. This we may attribute to the refusal of food.

    A perusal of these cases, then, shows that the dominant (and well-nigh exclusive) symptoms of the stupor are inactivity, apathy, negativism and disturbance of the intellectual functions. Benign stupor can be defined as a recoverable psychosis characterized by these four symptoms. The meaning of such vague physical manifestations as the low fever is not clear.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [1] MacCurdy has discussed the psychological phenomenon of a dramatist depicting a psychosis correctly in “Concerning Hamlet and Orestes.” Journal of Abnormal Psychology, Vol. XIII, No. 5.

    [2] Many of these states seem to be hysterical rather than manic-depressive stupors, but so far as the unconsciousness goes, there is probably as much psychological as symptomatic resemblance between the two types of reaction.

    [3] Kraepelin recognizes, of course, the occurrence of stupor symptoms or states in the course of manic-depressive psychoses. It is stupor as a clinical entity, as a separate psychosis, that he regards as one form of the catatonic, and therefore of the dementia præcox, reaction.

    [4] Kirby, George H.: “The Catatonic Syndrome and Its Relation to Manic-Depressive Insanity.” Jour. of Nervous and Mental Disease, Vol. 40, No. 11, 1913.

    CHAPTER II

    THE PARTIAL STUPOR REACTIONS

    The cases thus far considered, namely, those of marked stupor, are fairly well known and have been studied by others. Less well known and formulated, but even more important from a practical as well as from a theoretical point of view, are what may be called partial stupors.

    The reader has noted that the states of deep stupor described in the last chapter, did not end abruptly with a sudden return to health or a sudden change to another type of psychosis. They all gradually passed away, not by the disappearance of one symptom after another, but by the attenuation of all. Sometimes a more or less stable condition persisted for months, in which there was no stupor in a literal, clinical sense but when apathy, inactivity, interference with the intellectual functions and negativism all existed.

    Had these been the only states observed in these patients, there might have been some ground for doubt as to the diagnosis. As it was, it was clear that we were dealing with mild stages of stupor. When a psychiatrist meets with an undeveloped manic state, he calls it a hypomania and does not hesitate to make this diagnosis in the absence of complete development into a florid excitement. This procedure is not questioned, because the manic reaction as distinguished from a mania is well recognized.

    We believe that there is just as distinctive a stupor reaction which may be exhibited either in deep stupors or what we may term partial stupors.

    Theoretically, complete apathy, inactivity, etc., make up the clinical picture of a deep stupor. When these symptoms appear rather as tendencies than as perfect states, a partial stupor is the product. That partial stupors occur as well-defined psychoses, developing and disappearing without the appearance of deep stupor, we shall attempt to show in the following three typical cases:

    CASE 6.--Rose Sch. Age: 30. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute August 22, 1907.

    F. H. Both parents were living (father 74, mother 68), as
    were two brothers and two sisters. All were said to be
    normal.

    P. H. Nothing was known of the patient’s early
    characteristics, except that she herself said she was slow
    at learning in school and did not have much of an
    education. But when well she made by no means the
    impression of a weak-minded person. The husband had known
    her for ten years. He married her eight years before
    admission, by civil process, keeping this from his own
    family because he was a Jew and she a Christian.

    He said
    that this undoubtedly worried the patient at times and that
    she often asked him when he would take her to his family.
    The patient herself later also said that this used to worry
    her. Finally, one and a half years before admission she
    agreed, on account of the children, to accept the Hebrew
    faith, and they were then married in the synagogue. But he
    still did not take her to his family.

    There were four pregnancies: the first child died; of the
    survivors one was 8, a second 5 years old. Finally, a year
    before admission, she became again pregnant. During the
    pregnancy one of the children had whooping cough and she
    herself was thought to have caught it. The baby was born
    three months before admission. It was a blue baby which
    died two days after birth. The patient flowed heavily for
    three weeks and was taken to a hospital, where she
    continued to flow intermittently for some weeks more.

    Finally, three weeks before admission, a hysterectomy was
    performed. Several days after this, when the sister-in-law
    visited her, the patient begged her to take her home, said
    the doctor wished to shoot her and to give her poison.
    Later the patient confirmed this, saying that she thought
    they wanted to give her saltpeter, and that she heard them
    say they wanted to shoot her.

    When taken home she refused food; gazed about, was
    absorbed, seemed obstinate, and several times tried to jump
    out of the window. Retrospectively the patient stated that
    she heard children on the street call “Katie.” She thought
    they meant her child, heard that it was to be taken away
    from her, and a similar idea again came out later in her
    psychosis, namely, that somebody was going to harm her
    children.

    At the Observation Pavilion she appeared stupid, rather
    immobile, her attention difficult to attract.

    Under Observation: On admission the patient appeared
    sober, impassive, moved very little, was markedly
    cataleptic, though not resistive. On the other hand, her
    eyes were wide open and she looked about freely, following
    the movements of those around her not unnaturally. When
    questioned, she looked at the questioner rather intently,
    and was apt to breathe a little more rapidly, and made some
    ineffectual lip motions but no reply. To simple commands
    she made slow and inadequate responses. She flinched when
    pricked with a pin, but made no attempt at protecting
    herself. She had to be spoon-fed.

    The catalepsy persisted
    only for two days.

    After this she continued to show a marked reduction of
    activity, moved very little, said nothing spontaneously,
    had at first to be spoon-fed (later ate naturally enough).
    But she never soiled herself and went to the closet of her
    own accord.

    Emotionally she seemed dormant for the most part, though
    for the first few days she appeared somewhat puzzled, and
    one night when a patient screamed she seemed afraid and
    did not sleep, whereas other nights she slept well. She
    answered only after repeated questions and in a low tone.
    Very often, though her attention was attracted easily
    enough, her answers were remarkably shallow and also showed
    a striking off-hand profession of incapacity or lack of
    knowledge. This was often without any admission of
    depression or concern about her incapacity.

    She would
    usually say “What?” or “Hm?” or repeat the question, but
    most often would say, “I don’t know,” this even to very
    simple questions. For instance, when asked, “What is your
    name?” she answered, “My name? I don’t know myself” (but
    she did give her husband’s name), or when asked to write
    her name, she said, “I don’t know how to write,” or “Call
    Annie, she will write my name.” When requested to read or
    write (even when asked for single letters), she would make
    such statements as “I can’t read.” However, she finally
    named some objects in pictures.

    This condition was
    characteristic of her for two weeks.

    Then her condition changed a little. She spoke a little
    more freely but was similarly vague.

    The following
    interview of September 9, is characteristic: When asked how
    she was, she said, “Belle.” (Are you sick?) “No.” (Is your
    head all right?) “Yes.” (Is your memory all right?) “Yes.”
    (Do you know everything?) “Yes.” (Understand everything?)
    “Yes.” (Are you mixed up?) “No.” (Do you feel sick?) “No.”
    But when asked where she was, how long she had been here,
    what the name of the place was, what was the occupation of
    those about her, she said, “I don’t know.” (How did you
    come here?) “I couldn’t tell how I came up here.” (What are
    you here for?) “I am walking around and sitting on
    benches,” but finally, when again asked what she was here
    for, she said, “To get cured.” She now gave and wrote her
    name and address correctly when requested, also gave the
    names of her children.

    Yet when asked about the age of the
    girl, said, “I don’t know, my head is upside down.” When an
    attempt was made to make her repeat the name of the
    hospital, or the date, or the name of the examiner, she did
    so all right, but even if this was done repeatedly and she
    was asked a few minutes later, she would say “I couldn’t
    say,” or “I forget things,” or “I have a short memory,” or
    she would give it very imperfectly, as “Manhattan Island,”
    or “Rhode Island” for “Manhattan State Hospital, Ward’s
    Island.” (How is your memory?) “All right.” But when at
    this point the difficulty was pointed out, she cried.
    (Why?) “Because I forget so easily.” All this was while her
    general activity was much reduced, and she seemed to take
    very little interest in her surroundings.

    Then she improved somewhat, asked the husband some
    questions about home, and on one occasion cried much and
    clung to him and did not want to let him go without taking
    her. She also began to work quite well, but still said very
    little spontaneously. During this period when asked
    questions, she spoke freely enough, but seemed somewhat
    embarrassed. What was still quite marked were striking
    discrepancies in giving dates, and her utter inability to
    straighten them out when attention was called to them, as
    well as to her inability to supply such simple data as the
    ages of her children.

    Her capacity was later not gone into
    fully but it was certainly less defective on recovery than
    at this time. She was rather shallow in giving a
    retrospective account during this period. Even later, when
    she had developed a clear insight and made, in respect to
    her activity and behavior, a natural impression, she was
    not able to give much information about her psychosis,
    although she apparently tried to do so.

    She was discharged recovered four months after admission,
    her weight having risen from 93 lbs. on admission to 133
    lbs. on discharge. For the first two weeks of her stay in
    the hospital, her temperature varied between 99° and 100°.

    Retrospectively: She said in answer to questions about
    her inactivity and difficulty in answering that she did not
    feel like talking, felt mixed up, could not remember well,
    did not want to write.

    Before she was quite well she knew of her entrance to the
    Observation Pavilion and her transfer to Ward’s Island, of
    which she could give some details, but thought she had been
    in the Observation Pavilion two weeks instead of three days
    and in the admission ward one month instead of a few hours.
    As to the precipitating cause of the attack, she spoke of
    her flowing so much after childbirth and of her operation.

    She was seen again in March, 1913, when she seemed quite
    normal mentally and claimed that she had been well ever
    since leaving the hospital.

    With the exception of negativism, which appears only in the anamnesis, all the cardinal stupor symptoms are found in this history. Particularly noteworthy is her intellectual deficiency which seemed to be made up of a real incapacity plus a remarkable disinclination for any mental effort whatever. It is important to note that her attitude towards this disability was usually one of indifference and that, in general, there was no show of affect whatever. Freedom of speech was the last thing for her to regain.

    CASE 7.--Mary C. Age 26. Single. Admitted to the
    Psychiatric Institute April 7, 1907.

    F. H. The father had repeated attacks of insanity, from
    which he recovered, but he died in an attack at the age of
    60. A sister also had a psychosis, from which she
    recovered.

    P. H. The patient was rather quiet and easily worried.
    When 14 she had some dizzy spells, with momentary loss of
    consciousness. After that time she had no such attacks,
    except after a tooth extraction when about 24.

    The patient came to the United States six months before
    admission. She went to live with a cousin who died a week
    after she arrived at his house. She worried and said that
    she brought bad luck. Then she took a position, where she
    was well liked, but she was not particularly efficient. In
    this situation she often felt homesick and lonely.

    Two weeks before admission an uncle died, which affected
    her considerably. She spoke of his leaving three children,
    and would not go to the funeral. Then she thought she was
    going to die. She felt dizzy, weak, walked with a stooped
    position, was sleepless. In the midst of this she suddenly
    felt frightened and walked into her mistress’ room, to
    whom she complained that some one was talking outside but
    could not tell what was said. She heard shooting.
    Retrospectively, after recovery the patient said that at
    that time she suddenly got “mixed up,” and that her “memory
    got bad.”

    She was taken to a general hospital, where she thought
    there was a fire, and screamed “Fire!” She was soon
    transferred to the Observation Pavilion, where she
    appeared dazed, moving slowly, yet showing a certain
    restlessness. She spoke of “the boat” being shut up so that
    no one could go out.

    Again, she said “The boat went down
    and all the people keep turning up.” Retrospectively the
    patient stated about this condition that she remembered
    going to the general hospital but not her stay at the
    Observation Pavilion. (The trip to the Manhattan State
    Hospital was again clearer to her.) About the ideas she had
    at the time, she remembered only that the room seemed to go
    around, and that after she had come to the Manhattan State
    Hospital and was clearer, she thought she was in Belfast,
    was on a ship, and that people were drowning.

    Under Observation: On admission she had a temperature of
    100°, a coated tongue, suffused conjunctivæ. There were
    herpes of the lower lip, a general appearance of weariness
    and exhaustion, a flushed face, trace of albumen in the
    urine, which was absent on the third day, no leucocytosis,
    but 41 per cent. lymphocytes.

    Then and henceforth she was inactive and very slow in all
    her movements; she never stirred spontaneously, and had to
    be pushed to the toilet and to the table; she ate slowly.
    She did not speak spontaneously, and her replies were very
    slow in coming. She had to be urged considerably before she
    would speak and, as a rule, she did not answer. On one
    occasion she was for a day totally inactive and looked
    duller. That day and on a few other occasions she wet the
    bed.

    There was at times an appearance of dull bewilderment.
    When, soon after admission, asked whether she felt cheerful
    or downhearted, she said “downhearted,” but this was the
    only time. Often she answered “I don’t know,” when asked
    whether she was worried, and she could never say what she
    was worried about.

    Again she directly denied worry.
    Sometimes she smiled appropriately, and repeatedly, when
    asked how she felt, said, “I feel better.” In answer to
    questions as to how her head was, she replied several
    times, “My memory is gone,” also “I can’t take in my
    surroundings,” or “I don’t know where I am,” or “I cannot
    realize where I am.” Again, she spoke of being dizzy and
    once said it was as though the room went round. Sometimes
    she knew where she was or knew names, again said “I
    forget,” but she always was approximately oriented as to
    time.

    There were no special ideas expressed and no
    hallucinations, except in the very beginning when she still
    thought at night, when she heard the boats on the East
    River, that people were being drowned. She later, as stated
    above, said she thought she was on a boat and people were
    being drowned.

    By June, i.e., two months after admission, she began
    rhythmical swaying of the body, twisting of the fingers, or
    pulling out some of her hair. She ascribed this behavior
    simply to “nervousness.”

    On July 16, after a visit from her cousin, who said to her
    that if she worked she would soon get better, she began
    spontaneously to occupy herself somewhat. She became more
    active, said she felt stronger and brighter, and that her
    memory was better. By the beginning of August she was
    fairly free, but still spoke in a rather low voice,
    although answering well. Her capacity to calculate also
    remained poor.

    When asked about the more inactive state,
    she said she had been afraid to stir. (What afraid of?) “I
    didn’t know where to go or what to do.” Further, she
    recalled that she had had a numb feeling in her tongue,
    could not speak quickly, and that her mind had felt
    confused and “she could not take in things.” Further review
    with her of the earlier period of her psychosis showed that
    there was a blank for external events and most of the
    internal events during this time.

    She made a perfect recovery and was discharged August 7,
    1907, four months after admission.

    This case, although very like the last, differs from it in two particulars. For one day her symptoms were sufficiently marked to suggest a deep stupor. Secondly, her intellectual incapacity was not so marked (always approximately oriented for time) and with this there was some subjective appreciation of her defect. Apparently, however, this insight did not cause her any worry. The affectlessness was equally prominent in both of the foregoing cases, the fact that Mary C. (Case 7) once admitted feeling downhearted in response to leading questions, having little significance in the face of her expression, actions and usual denial of worry.

    It is interesting to note that, during the bulk of her psychosis, her only complaints were of mental hebetude and dizziness. Possibly the latter was merely an expression of her subjective confusion.

    CASE 8.--Henrietta H. Age: 22. Admitted to the
    Psychiatric Institute March 6, 1903.

    F. H. The father stated that both parents were living and
    well, also eight brothers and sisters.

    P. H. The patient came to this country when she was a
    baby. She was bright at school and industrious. From the
    age of 17 on, she worked in a drygoods store and gave
    satisfaction. About her mental make-up no data were
    available, except for the statement that she always made a
    natural impression.

    When 21 (February, 1902), without known cause, she broke
    down and was sent to the Manhattan State Hospital, but was
    not observed in the Institute ward. She remained in the
    hospital for three months. It was claimed that the attack
    came on suddenly two days before she was sent away. She
    suddenly appeared anxious, said something had happened and
    became excited. This lasted for about a week, and then she
    was, as the description says, “depressed and cataleptic.”
    She remained in this condition for about a month, during
    which time there was a slight rise of temperature.

    Then she
    improved gradually and was discharged three months after
    admission. After recovery from the present attack the
    patient stated that during the first sickness she had
    visions of dead friends.

    She was perfectly well in the interval.

    Six days before admission she suddenly became excited,
    refused to eat, and began to talk, repeating phrases over
    and over. Then she became elated and excited.

    After recovery the patient described the onset of her
    psychosis as follows: Six days before admission, after
    having been perfectly well and without any known cause, she
    was feverish and vomited, but slept well. Next day she felt
    nervous, and her thoughts were clear. She constantly
    thought of dead friends, heard them talking, when she tried
    to do anything the voices said, “Don’t do that.” She also
    thought somebody wanted to harm her people. Soon she
    started singing and felt happy.

    Then she was sent to the Observation Pavilion, where she
    appeared to be in the same condition which was observed in
    the Institute.

    Under Observation: 1. On admission she was in good
    physical condition, except for her skin seeming greasy. She
    presented for nine days the following picture: She was
    essentially elated, laughing, singing, jumping out of bed,
    good-natured and tractable, and very talkative. Her
    productions showed a good deal of sameness and a certain
    lack of progression. She spoke at times in a rather
    monotonous voice, but again often in very theatrical tones,
    with much, rather slow, gesturing. The following are very
    representative samples:

    “I have been suffering from my own blood, my own blood sent
    all away from home. I just came from Bellevue. I left here
    last May (correct) a healthy girl.

    A sister is a sister--I
    wonder why shorthand is shorthand, a stenographer is a
    stenographer (seeing stenographer write)--a kind brother,
    Bill H.--why H. his wife is a sister-in-law to us, she has
    four children--four beautiful children--sister-in-laws and
    brother-in-laws--telephone ringing (telephone did
    ring)--dear Lord, such a remembrance--remembrance was
    remembrance, truth was truth--honesty is honesty--policy is
    policy--if she married him, she is my sister-in-law and he
    is my brother-in-law--Max knows me--she changed her name to
    Mrs.

    R.--two children who are Rosie and Maud, if names were
    given, names should not be mistaken--they are Julia,
    Lillian--Rosie and Maud--why should wonders wonder and
    wonders cease to wonder, why should blunders blunder and
    blunders still blunder; sleep is one dream and dream means
    sleep--if move is moving, why not move?” When she
    accidentally heard the word wine, she said “Guilty wine is
    not in our house--wine is red and women are women, and
    women and wine and wine and women and wine and song.”
    Again, “You are not Mr. Kratzberger, Mr. Steinberger, Mr.
    Einberger--you are not Mr. Horrid or Mr.

    Storrid--perhaps
    you are Mr. Johnson or Mr. Thompson--no, you are Dr. C.”
    (correct).

    She was quite clear about her environment.

    Although the mood was throughout one of elation, on the
    ninth day in the forenoon she cried at times, wanted to see
    her mother, and spoke in a depressed strain (content not
    known). A few hours after that she suddenly became quiet.

    1. Then for four days (March 14-17) she was markedly

    inactive, though at times got out of bed. She looked about
    in a bewildered manner, did not speak spontaneously, but
    could with urging be induced to make some replies. She did
    this now fairly promptly, now quite slowly. Questions were
    apt to bring on the bewilderment. Thus, when asked where
    she was, she merely looked more bewildered, finally said
    “Bellevue--I don’t know,” and questioned who the doctor was
    whom she had called by name in her manic state, she said,
    with some bewilderment, “Your face looks familiar.” (Where
    have you seen me?) “In New York.” She claimed to feel all
    right.

    There was no real affect. She made the statement
    that at home she heard voices saying “You will be killed.”

    1. Henceforth this bewilderment ceased, and for 16 or 17

    days she was essentially inactive for the most part, for a
    short time with a tendency to catalepsy and some
    resistiveness, and at that time lying with eyes partly
    closed. As a rule she said nothing spontaneously, but
    replied to some questions, usually with marked retardation,
    again more promptly. She constantly denied feeling sad or
    worried, repeatedly said she felt “better,” only on one
    occasion did she cry a little. When asked to calculate she
    sometimes did it very slowly, again fairly promptly. The
    simple calculations were usually done without error, the
    others with some mistakes.

    As to her orientation the few
    answers obtained showed that at times she knew the name of
    the place and the day, again she gave wrong answers
    (Bellevue). Once asked on March 23 for the day, she said
    April. She wrote her name promptly on one occasion, again
    a sentence slowly but without mistakes. Once during the
    period she sang at night. Once she suddenly ran down the
    hall but quickly lapsed into the dull condition.

    On April 4, at the end of this period, she suddenly
    laughed, again ran down the hall, said she had done nothing
    to be kept on Ward’s Island. But she quickly lapsed again
    into the dull state.

    Later, on the same day, when the
    doctor was near, she said, in a natural tone, “Thank God,
    the truth is coming out.” (What do you mean?) “That I have
    been trusting in a false name and that Miss S. (the nurse)
    should not nurse me.” Then she got suddenly duller,
    calculated slowly and with some mistakes, 3×17=41, 4×19=56,
    and when asked to write Manhattan State Hospital she wrote
    (not very slowly) “Mannahaton Hotspalne.”

    1. Next day it was noted that she was more stuporous, and

    she remained so for two weeks, now showing a decided
    tendency to catalepsy and more resistance than before,
    though not marked, except in the jaw. She lay often with
    head raised, sometimes with eyes partly open, or staring in
    a dull, dreamy way, neither soiling nor drooling, however;
    a few times she looked up when spoken to sharply. There was
    no spontaneous speech. Usually she did not answer at all,
    but a few times a short low response was obtained. Once she
    wrote slowly a simple addition, put down on paper. When, on
    one occasion, asked how she felt, she, as before, said, “I
    feel better.”

    1. Then, with the exception of a day at the end of the

    month, when the more stuporous state was again in evidence,
    she returned to her former condition without catalepsy or
    resistiveness and without staring, but essentially with
    inactivity or slowness. She now even dressed herself,
    answered slowly though not consistently, but she again
    denied feeling troubled or sad, “I feel better.”

    On July 7 she got brighter but was still rather slow. She
    then even began to do some work. She again denied feeling
    sad.

    In a few weeks, while having a temperature of 102° with
    vomiting and diarrhea, she suddenly got freer. She then
    said, in answer to questions, that she did not speak
    because she was not sure whether it would be right, again
    because she seemed to lose her speech. She did not move
    because she was tired, had a numb feeling. She said she
    had not been sad, “but I had different thoughts,” “saw
    shadows on the walls of animals, living people and dead
    people.” She was not frightened, “I just looked at them.”
    People moved so quickly that she thought everything was
    moved by electricity.

    She thought her head had been all
    right.

    After a few days she relapsed into a duller state again,
    but then got quite free and natural in her behavior. On
    August 28 she gave a retrospective account of her
    psychosis, a part of which has been embodied in the
    history. She had insight in so far as she knew she had been
    mentally ill. She claimed to remember the Observation
    Pavilion and her coming to the hospital, also the incidents
    during the manic state, when she heard cannon and thought a
    war was on, and voices she could not recognize nor
    understand. Then she became stupid, although neither sad
    nor happy.

    Then, she claimed, she got stupid, but neither sad nor
    happy. She claimed to have known all along where she was,
    but felt mixed up at times, her thoughts wandered and she
    felt confused about the people.

    She thought she was in
    everybody’s way, thought others wanted to get ahead of her,
    did not speak because she did not know if it were right or
    wrong, felt she might cause disturbance if she answered.
    (It is not clear whether she had complete insight into the
    morbid nature of these statements.) She also claimed again
    that all along she “saw shadows on the wall,” “scenes from
    Heaven and Earth,” “shadows of dead friends laid out for
    burial.” She had insight into the hallucinatory nature of
    these visions. Sometimes she thought she was dead also.

    She
    claimed that she began to feel better when these shadows
    stopped appearing in June (the actual time of her
    improvement).

    She was discharged recovered a month later, after having
    been sent to another ward.

    In this case, then, we find that the two months of stupor were ushered in by a brief state in which, in addition to the usual inactivity, there was a certain bewilderment, increased by questions, while the orientation which in the preceding manic state had been good became seriously interfered with. The psychosis bordered on deep stupor for brief periods when the inactivity seemed to be complete or she lay in bed with her head raised from the pillow. On the other hand, there were occasional sudden spells of free activity even with a certain elation.

    She could often be persuaded to answer questions or to write, the slowness of this spoken or written speech varying considerably. Her replies revealed the fact that she was essentially affectless and that her intellectual processes were interfered with, even to the extent of paragraphic writing. We have, therefore, here again features similar to those of the preceding cases. In addition we must add as important that this patient said retrospectively that she thought she was dead, that she saw “shadows from Heaven and Earth,” “shadows of dead friends laid out for burial,” all this without any fear. We shall see later that this is a typical stupor content.

    We will here include state 3 of Anna G. (See Chapter I, Case 1) who after the pronounced stupor was for two months merely dull, somewhat slowed and markedly apathetic. Although her orientation was not seriously affected, there was considerable interference with her intellectual processes, as shown in her wrong answers or her lack of answers when more difficult questions were asked.

    A similar picture was presented in state 2 of Mary D. (See Chapter I, Case 4.) Here, to be sure, there were more marked stupor features in that the patient wet and soiled, in addition to occasional spells when she lay with her head raised. But she spoke and acted fairly freely (even while soiling). By her replies she showed a considerable intellectual inefficiency, although, like Anna G., her orientation was not seriously disturbed. Here again there was complete affectlessness.

    This gives us, therefore, five states which may be analyzed for the symptoms of partial stupor. The pictures of all five are unusually consistent. There is inactivity, marked but not complete; poverty of affect without perfect apathy; and a marked interference with the intellectual processes. The last can be studied better than in the deep stupors because these partial cases are more or less accessible to examination. There is a tendency for the patient to think much of death either in the onset or during the psychosis. Negativism seems much less prominent than in the deep stupors.

    A natural criticism is that these cases merely had retarded depressions.

    Although this topic will be discussed fully in a later chapter, two differential characteristics should be mentioned now. First, depression is a highly emotional state in which the sadness of the patient is as evident from his facial and vocal expression as from what he says, while these stupor reactions are by observation and confession states of indifference. Secondly, there is no such disturbance of the intellectual processes in depression as is here chronicled. Let the retardation once be overcome so that the will is exercised and no real defect is demonstrable.

    In our experience the cases of apparent depression with intellectual incapacity are found on closer study to be really stupors as other symptoms show.

    CHAPTER III

    SUICIDAL CASES

    An important “catatonic” symptom is a tendency to sudden, impulsive, unexplainable acts. Such actions occur occasionally in benign stupors and, since we attempt an understanding of the reaction as a whole, an effort should be made to study these phenomena as well. The cases chosen showed persistent, quite affectless, yet very impulsive attempts at self-injury. They characterized the first of the three cases throughout, were present in one stage (the second) of the second patient, while in the last for one day there was behavior which can be similarly interpreted.

    Mention has been made of the prominence, approaching universality, of the death idea in stupor. This is a subject to be discussed in length presently, but for the present we may say that there may be a delusion of death with dramatization of that state or a mere abandonment of the mental activities of life. It is but a step from corpse-like behavior to suicidal attempts, psychologically speaking, yet this transition necessarily modifies the clinical picture, since one necessitates inactivity and the other activity. Secondarily, other atypical clinical features appear, as will be seen.

    CASE 9.--Pearl F. Age: 24. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute July 26, 1913.

    F. H. A paternal aunt was insane. Both parents died long
    ago; the mother when the patient was a baby; the father
    when she was a girl. She came to this country when 17. In
    this country she had generally been a domestic. An older
    brother and sister were also in America.

    P. H. She was described as sociable, good-natured, bright
    enough, not inclined to be depressed. She had little
    education. There was no former attack.

    Four months before admission, the patient did not
    menstruate but was said not to have worried about this. A
    month later she began to show symptoms. She said she did
    not want to live, had done something wrong but could not or
    would not say what it was. Again she said a young man was
    going to sue her, a young Jewish fellow whom she had seen
    only a few times. She talked of turning on the gas. She
    also complained that people were looking at her and that
    the food was poisoned.

    The patient after recovery gave the following version of
    the onset: She had a position on 99th St. for 2½ years.
    She liked the people there and often went to see them
    later. Her next position was in the Bronx. She was there
    for nine months. In the same house lived “Harry.” After the
    work she used to talk to him in the yard and, after she
    left, she used to think of him and long for him. But she
    denied, with a very natural attitude, that she worried
    about him at the beginning of her psychosis. After the
    position in the Bronx she went to one on 96th St., where
    she was for four months.

    In the same house was a girl whom
    she liked and who was lively. When she left, the patient
    left too. This was a month before the psychosis began. When
    she left there, she got word that her employer on 99th St.
    had developed consumption and had to go out West, but did
    not worry over this news, she claimed. She looked for
    another position and had one for two weeks, but felt
    lonely, did not care to live. Then her sister took her to
    her home. She thought people were looking at her and were
    making remarks because she was not working.

    During this
    time she had a dream one night in which her dead mother
    appeared to her (in ordinary street clothes) and said to
    her that she (the patient) “was going away.” She woke up
    frightened. She was worried, thought she had not prayed
    enough for her mother, and asked her sister to pray also
    and to give money to the poor. She did not recall, or at
    any rate denied, speaking of the young man suing her.

    She was then taken to a private sanatorium, where she was
    for two months preceding her admission to this hospital.
    There she was described as quiet, mute, tube-fed,
    resistive.

    When well, the patient said that in this sanatorium she was
    first spoon-fed, cup-fed, later tube-fed, “I used to be
    scared of them, they used to put a spoon way down my throat
    and I had no appetite--I did not like them around me, they
    were mean to me. They used to let me stand without clothes,
    used to spite me.” “If I did not want to dress myself, they
    used to hit me.” “I used to feel lonesome for home and I
    imagined my people were there and that my sister passed the
    place without stopping.” She was afraid of the nurses,
    thinking they wanted to kill her.

    At the Observation Pavilion the patient was described as
    dull, but brightening up under examination. She made few
    spontaneous remarks, but in answer to questions said she
    was melancholy, tired of life, because she was in love with
    a Gentile fellow who refused to marry her. She also said “I
    get peculiar thoughts that I am going to die.”

    Under Observation: The patient’s condition lasted for
    about two years. Much of the time she lay in bed, often
    with the covers pulled over her, sometimes with her legs
    drawn up, again in a more natural, comfortable position, or
    she sat up with her head bowed. She obeyed almost no
    commands. For months she soiled and wet herself, but never
    drooled. For a time she refused food consistently, lost
    flesh and had to be tube-fed. For the most part she said
    very little and, when one accosted her, she was apt to turn
    away. A few times, when further urged, she swore at the
    examiner.

    There was also persistent marked resistance
    towards any interference, sometimes merely passive or quite
    often, especially at first, with wriggling or severe
    scratching of her own body. There was often with this
    evidence of irritation or she moaned. Again she was
    described as quite affectless. One of the most striking
    features throughout a large part of the course were her
    suicidal attempts.

    She would try to strike her head against
    the iron bedpost, throw herself out of bed, throw herself
    about generally, try to strangle herself with the sheets,
    try to pull out her tongue, all of which seemed to be done
    with great impulsiveness. Almost her only utterances had to
    do with death. She said she wanted to die, wanted to drop
    dead, did not want to live, wanted to kill herself, that
    she did not eat because she wanted to die. When once she
    was found tossing about and was asked whether she worried,
    she said “I know I am going to die.” (You mean you will be
    killed?) “I don’t care.”

    There were a few episodes which still have to be mentioned.
    Quite early in the course of the stupor, when she was
    restless, scratching herself and moaning, she once spoke
    quite freely. She said “Give me that fellow (Harry), I
    don’t care, I can’t help it. I must have him, even if it
    costs me my life.” “I would feel happy if I could get him.
    O God, I love him--I will never get him even if I drop
    dead, I know I won’t get him, the darling” (cries). (What
    if you did get him?) “I know I would lose him again.” Then
    with shame she claimed she had had sexual relations with
    him (when well, denied).

    At the same interview, when the
    doctor sneezed, she said “Gesundheit.” In June, 1914, she
    was seen smiling at times. But the first was the only
    episode when she spoke more freely, and the two occasions
    the only ones when she showed a frank affect.

    The improvement commenced in April, 1915. Although still
    very inactive, she sometimes began to laugh and sing and
    talk a little to other patients. She also answered a few
    questions on April 22, 1915. Thus, when asked whether she
    wanted to go home, she said “No, I want to stay here.” (Do
    you like it here?) “Yes” (smiles), “I can’t get no other
    place; I have got to like it here.” She smiled freely. To
    orientation questions, she knew the place, month, but not
    the year.

    She continued inactive and above all diffident, but
    improved steadily and, when examined by the writer on
    November 15, she made a very natural impression and gave
    the retrospective account of the onset embodied in the
    history. She was quite frank, thanked the doctor for the
    interest he took in her case, and said for example, “You
    know I never thought I would get well. I quite gave up--I
    am very glad I am well now.”

    When questioned about her stay here, the patient evidently
    remembered much. She was able to say which wards she had
    been in and approximately how long she had been in each
    one. She claimed that at first it “seemed strange.” “I did
    not eat, I did not want to eat, I used to tell them to
    poison me and that I wanted to die, I was disgusted, I
    thought I would never go home.” She also says she felt
    angry, wanted to kill herself.

    She bit and scratched
    “because I was nervous.” She remembered talking about
    Harry, “I said I was in love with him, I thought I wanted
    to die because I could not have him.” She also talked of
    having been stubborn. Sometimes she felt like running to
    the river. She also claimed she imagined people were false
    to her.

    In one of the wards she said she thought people were there
    on her account, were waiting for her death. She did not
    care for a time whether she died or not. She knew she tried
    to choke herself occasionally. Asked how she behaved, she
    first said she was quiet. (Were you not restless?) “I used
    to get tired and have backache and roll around in bed.” She
    also felt like running away sometimes, wanted to get out of
    bed and wanted to walk about. (What about going to the
    river?) “I used to say that.” She claimed not to have been
    mixed up at any time and to remember everything.

    Remarkable
    is the fact that she claimed she did not worry at all,
    “I felt I was lost and would not worry. I used to worry
    at home and at Dr. M.’s (the private sanatorium) but not
    here. Here I never worried, I did not care where I went.”
    She said she did not talk because she was bashful in the
    presence of doctors, sometimes she felt afraid of them,
    afraid they would kill her, put poison in her food when
    they fed her. “When my people came, I said I did not want
    to live, wanted to kill myself.

    I used to cry.” Again asked
    why she did not talk, she admitted she really did not know.
    Once she said she was bashful because she soiled her bed.
    She did not want to go to the closet because she was afraid
    of the nurse. She denied hearing voices.

    In addition to the activity incidental to her attempts at self-injury, this patient showed an unusual degree of resistiveness and with this some affect, for she appeared to be irritated and at times moaned. Still more unusual were the appearances of delusions not associated with death but with a vivid form of life, namely, a love affair. Occasionally she spoke of her imaginary lover “Harry.” Another atypical feature was a fair memory for the period when she was in stupor. She claimed to remember much of her movements and this claim was substantiated by her answers to questions after recovery.

    CASE 10.--Margaret C. Age: 23. Single. Admitted to the
    Psychiatric Institute November 13, 1913.

    F. H. Heredity was absolutely denied. The mother is
    living and made a natural impression. The father died at
    65, nine months before patient’s admission, of cardio-renal
    disease. Two brothers and one sister died of acute
    diseases. One sister died in childbirth. Three brothers and
    one sister were said to be well.

    P. H. The patient was bright and passed successfully
    through high school. For seven years prior to the psychosis
    she worked for the same company as clerk. She was described
    as efficient, conscientious, systematic, though sometimes
    upset by her work; as lively, talkative, cheerful, with
    somewhat of a temper and easily hurt, also as quite
    religious. She was more attached to her mother than to her
    father, but still more to her older sister, whose death
    precipitated her psychosis. She never had any love affair
    and was said not to have cared for men.

    Two months before
    admission, when her favorite sister was confined, the
    patient was quite worried about her, but relieved when she
    heard good news. A few hours later, however, the sister
    died suddenly. When the patient learned of the sister’s
    death, she screamed, and screamed several times at the
    funeral. She did not cry, said she could not. After this
    she slept poorly, seemed nervous, went to church more, but
    there was no other change. She continued to work and,
    according to the employer, worked well.

    Nine days before admission she would not get out of bed in
    the morning, said little and refused food. A few days later
    she was induced to take a walk, but she seemed to have no
    interest in anything. When she talked at all it was about
    her sister and of wanting to go to a convent. When asked
    to do anything she said she would if it were God’s will.
    She did not menstruate after her sister’s death. When
    practically recovered, the patient attributed her breakdown
    to this tragedy.

    She added to the description above given
    that, soon after losing her sister, she had a fright at
    home. “It was the house in which my father died and one day
    when I was in bed I thought somebody came in.” But she
    denied a vision and could not further explain.

    At the Observation Pavilion she was very inactive, so
    that she had to be fed and cared for in every way, mute,
    often covering her head with a sheet, turning away when
    questioned and resistive when the physical examination was
    attempted. But at times she smiled or laughed.

    Under Observation: 1. For two months the patient was
    generally inactive, sometimes lying in bed with her eyes
    tightly closed, or with her face covered by the sheets or
    buried in the pillow; or she sat inactive, staring, or with
    eyes closed, or her head buried in her arms. On one visit
    she had to be brought into the examining room in a wheel
    chair and lifted into another seat. A few times she was
    observed holding herself very tense with her head pressed
    against the end of the bed.

    But this inactivity was often
    interrupted by her going quickly into various rooms to
    kneel down, though she was never heard praying. Or she ran
    down the hall for no obvious reason. Or, again, she was
    found lying on the floor face down. She ate very poorly and
    had to be tube-fed a considerable part of the time. When
    this was done, she sometimes resisted severely, as she did
    in fact most nursing attentions. Thus she soon began to
    struggle when her hair was combed. She also resisted being
    taken to the toilet or being brought back.

    She did not soil
    or drool, however, but sometimes seemed to be in
    considerable distress before she finally literally ran to
    the closet. This resistance just spoken of consisted
    chiefly in making herself stiff and tense. Sometimes at the
    feeding she pulled up the cover when preparations were made
    and held to it tightly.

    Quite striking was the fact that
    with such resistance she sometimes, though by no means
    always, laughed loudly, as she did occasionally when she
    was talked to, or even without any external stimulation.
    This laughter always was one of genuine merriment and quite
    contagious, and by no means shallow or silly.

    Usually the patient was totally mute. The exceptions
    occurred mostly when her resistance was called forth. Thus
    one day when fed she said, “I wish you people would have
    more to do,” or on another occasion, when she had resisted
    being brought into the examining room, she said, “I will
    get out of here if I break a leg.” But once when the nurse
    accidentally tickled her, she said, “Since I am ticklish, I
    must be jealous--I should worry.” She also answered very
    few questions and such responses as she made were chiefly
    expressions of resentment.

    Thus, when one kept urging her,
    she finally would say “stop,” or after much urging “I am
    going to hurt you pretty quick.” Sometimes she said “Go
    away,” or “Let me alone.” She was just as silent with the
    mother and the priest as with the physicians.

    On one
    occasion she told the nurse that the priest had told her to
    talk to the doctors, but that she had nothing to say.
    Sometimes she did not even look at the visitors, but turned
    away from them, as she did from the physicians, but at one
    visit from a priest, though she scarcely said anything, she
    held on to him when he was about to depart and would not
    let him go. Throughout this period, since scarcely any
    answers were given, nothing was known about her
    orientation, except when on admission she gave a few
    answers.

    She then thought she was at the Observation
    Pavilion, seemed unable to tell even that the physician was
    a doctor, but knew the date. When asked how she came to
    Ward’s Island, she said “By ambulance.” The physical
    condition presented nothing of note, except for a certain
    sluggishness of the skin with marked comedones.

    1. By January, 1914, the picture changed somewhat and she

    then presented the following state for an entire year: The
    mutism persisted and indeed became even more absolute, and
    she began to wet and soil constantly. This commenced as
    what seemed to be an act of spite as a part of her
    resistiveness, for the first time she soiled she seemed to
    do it deliberately when the nurses insisted that she allow
    them to put on a dress. Later this explanation no longer
    held. Tube-feeding too was for the most part necessary, the
    resistiveness continuing as before.

    But the inactivity was
    broken into much more than before by constant impulsive
    attempts to hurt herself in every conceivable way--by
    bumping her head against the wall, putting her head under
    the hot water faucet, trying to pound the leg of the
    bedstead on her foot, striking herself, pinching her
    eyelids, pulling out her hair, trying to pick her radial
    artery, throwing herself out of bed, knocking her head
    against the bed rail, etc. This was done in silence but
    with what appeared a great determination that occasionally
    showed itself in her face. She also sometimes scowled and
    frowned.

    With the difficulty in feeding her and the
    constant impulsive excitement in which bruises could not
    always be avoided (once an extensive cellulitis developed
    in the arm which had to be lanced), the patient got weak,
    emaciated and exhausted; much of her hair fell out,
    although some she pulled out. It should be stated that
    during this entire impulsive state she could not be taken
    care of in the Institute ward, but was sent to a special
    ward in the Manhattan State Hospital, where suicidal
    patients are under constant watch.

    These impulsive attempts
    at self-injury lessened only towards the end of the period.
    Her laughter, which had been such a prominent trait,
    disappeared almost entirely during this entire phase. With
    all this, the general resistiveness, as has been stated,
    remained towards feeding or any other interference. It was
    only in the beginning associated with laughter as in the
    previous stage.

    Although there were, as a rule, no spontaneous remarks and
    no replies, she on one occasion said spontaneously,
    probably referring to her unsuccessful attempts to kill
    herself: “I can’t do it, I have no will.” During the same
    period she once said: “I don’t want to eat, I don’t want to
    get well, I want to do penance and die.”

    By January, 1915 (i.e., a year after the second phase had
    commenced), she began to dress herself and eat, and also
    became clean. But she remained for the most part very
    inactive, sitting stolidly about all day and still without
    interest in her environment. The impulsive attempts at
    killing herself disappeared. Although she remained for
    months to come still inactive, she gradually began to talk
    a little, began to play a little on the piano, but said
    little to any one.

    By August, 1915, she still was inactive, shy, standing
    about, or sitting picking her fingers, occasionally going
    to the piano, but evidently unable to finish anything. She
    had to be coaxed to come to the examining room and talked
    in a low tone. Often she commenced vaguely to speak and
    then stopped and could not be made to repeat what she had
    been saying. Affectively she was remarkably frank,
    sometimes a little surly, or she showed a slight empty
    uneasiness. She could, however, be made to laugh heartily
    at times, or did so spontaneously on very slight
    provocation.

    Some of her utterances were in harmony with her apparent
    indifference. It was difficult to get her to say how she
    felt even when thorough inquiries were made.

    Once she said,
    when asked about worrying, “I don’t worry,” or again “I get
    angry sometimes,” or “I used to worry about my health, I
    don’t now,” or, when asked what her plans were, she said
    directly: “I don’t care what happens.” Again she said “I
    guess I am disagreeable,” or “I guess I am a crank.”
    Another interesting indication of her state was expressed
    in her repeated statement, “I don’t know what I want.” But
    she was oriented in a way, though not sure of her data.

    She
    would give most of her answers with a questioning
    inflection, “This is the Manhattan State Hospital, isn’t
    it?” or she would say, “I don’t know exactly where I am,
    it’s Ward’s Island, isn’t it?” and in the same way she gave
    the day, date and year correctly. But she did not know the
    names of the physicians. At that time she could give many
    data about her family correctly, but was slow, even if
    correct, in calculation, and, though she got the gist of a
    test story, she left out some important details.

    A retrospective account at that time showed she was
    uncertain about the Observation Pavilion, that she was not
    certain how she came to Ward’s Island, “On a boat, I
    believe.” It was clear that she did not remember the
    admission ward, about the Institute ward (in which she had
    been for the first two and a half months and in which she
    was again examined); she said it was familiar to her, but
    she was not certain that she had been in it.

    About the
    physician who saw most of her in these first two and a half
    months, she said that his voice seemed familiar, and she
    asked him whether he had tube-fed her (she had been
    tube-fed by him many times), but she again said, “No, you
    are not the one,” and described as the man who had fed her
    the one who did it on the second ward where she was for a
    year. But she knew that she had been sent to the second
    ward, because she constantly tried to injure herself.

    These
    injuries she recalled but was unable to say why she
    attempted them, “I suppose I didn’t know what I was doing.”
    She claimed she heard voices and had “all sorts” of
    imaginations, but could not be gotten to tell about them.
    When it was difficult for her to give an answer, she was
    apt to keep silent and then could be prodded without much
    success.

    In October, 1915, there was further improvement, inasmuch
    as she began to converse some with other patients, played
    the piano and seemed able to carry a piece through. She was
    put in the occupation class and did quite well. At the
    interview with the physician she was still apt to laugh
    boisterously at slight provocation. Even now she had great
    difficulty in describing her condition and at the
    examination was often still quite vague.

    Thus, when asked
    how she felt, she said, “I do know I feel
    ridiculous--sometimes I feel kind of angry--I don’t
    know--they say I am crazy but I am not, but I am hungry--I
    don’t know whether I am or not, I don’t know what I can do
    well,” etc. This is quite characteristic.

    When asked
    whether she was worried, she said: “I don’t know, am I
    worried?--yes, a little sometimes, I am to-day--I am so
    untidy--don’t know what is the matter with me.” Again:
    “Sometimes I lose my speech--I can’t say what I feel, I
    don’t know what it was.” Later, half to herself: “I don’t
    know what is the matter with me--I don’t care anyway.”

    In December, 1915, there was still further improvement,
    and on the ward and in superficial conversation she made,
    towards the end of the month, in many ways a natural
    impression, though the laughter before described was still
    somewhat in evidence. It usually came not without occasion,
    but was, as a rule, quite out of proportion to the
    stimulus. She again said she could not explain why she
    tried to injure herself, claimed she did not feel it, and
    even claimed she did not remember doing it in the Institute
    but only in the second ward.

    The defect in thinking which still remained is very
    difficult to formulate. She was now entirely oriented, no
    longer with any hesitation about the correctness of her
    information. She subtracted 7 from 100 very quickly and
    could from memory write a long poem, but there was a
    certain vagueness about her which partly may have been due
    to a still existing indifference. This vagueness consisted
    chiefly in a difficulty of attention or in her capacity to
    grasp fully what was wanted.

    It is best illustrated by a
    few examples: After she had been asked about the onset of
    her sickness and she had said that what was on her mind
    then were prayers for the salvation of her relatives, she
    was asked exactly when it was that she thought of this; she
    answered “Now?” (What period were we talking of, the
    present or past?) “The present.” (What did I ask you?)
    “About this period of my sickness.” (Which one?) “What
    sickness?” She said herself at this point, “I am rather
    stupid” (quite placidly).

    Or again she said she did not
    know why she pounded her head, but finally said, “To get
    better and go home.” (Do you think if you pounded your head
    against the wall you would go home sooner?) “I don’t
    know--maybe.” (How would it help you?) “You mean to go to
    the city?” (Yes.) “I don’t know.” Again when asked how her
    mind worked, she said, “Pretty quickly sometimes--I don’t
    know.” (As good as it used to?) “No, I don’t think so.”
    (What is the difference?) This had to be repeated several
    times, at which she said, “There is no difference.” (What
    did I ask you?) “The difference.” (The difference between
    what?) “You did not say.” Equally striking was the fact
    that when she was jokingly told “If it snows to-night, we
    shall have a black Christmas,” she did not grasp the
    absurdity at once, but in a rather puzzled way asked,
    “Why?”

    She was then discharged on parole, two years and one month
    after admission. Soon after discharge her menstruation,
    which had been absent throughout her psychosis, returned.
    On her discharge she had regained her normal weight, and
    during the two subsequent months gained fifteen pounds.

    She then recovered completely, so that three months after
    discharge she made a very natural impression. She said, on
    looking back over her state with impulsive excitement, that
    she constantly had the idea that she wanted to punish
    herself, but that she did not know why, and did not think
    she was sad or worried.

    Considering only the second phase of the psychosis, this deep stupor showed many interruptions, due not merely to her suicidal efforts but also to her resistiveness. The condition, too, was not so completely affectless as one expects a deep stupor to be. In the first stage there was much sudden laughter, reminding one of dementia præcox (except for its never being shallow or silly) and this persisted into the first part of the second phase. The actual attempts at self-injury brought out emotion, for with them she scowled and frowned as well as showing considerable energy.

    To these may be added the following case. It is not unlike the ordinary stupor in the fact that there was intense inactivity and mutism with great tenseness. The remarkable trait was, however, that for a whole day she forcibly held her breath until she got blue in the face. The case in detail is as follows:

    CASE 11.--Rosie K. Age: 18. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute January 24, 1907.

    F. H. Both parents were living. The father was a loafer.
    Nine brothers and sisters were said to be well, with the
    exceptions of one brother who had an irritable temper, and
    of a markedly inferior sister.

    P. H. The patient was a Galician Hebrew, a shirtwaist
    operator. Not much was known about her make-up, but it is
    certain that she was a bright girl. The patient herself
    said after recovery that her father was nagging her
    constantly with complaints that she was not making enough
    money, although he himself did not work and she contributed
    much to the support of her family. She disliked him very
    much and claimed that all her relatives worried her, except
    her mother.

    Nine weeks before admission a messenger came into the shop
    where she worked and said, “Rosie, your father is dead”
    (the message was intended for a fellow worker). In spite of
    the fact that the matter was explained, she was upset and
    nervous enough to be taken home. Though she continued to
    work for over two weeks, she worried over many trivial
    matters and talked much about this. She also said that
    everything looked queer at her home and complained of
    having difficulty in concentrating her mind. Finally she
    became elated and talkative. Nothing is known of any
    special ideas.

    At the Observation Pavilion she appeared to be typically
    manic.

    Then she was sent to an institution where she remained for
    six weeks. The report from there stated that she was for
    ten days “elated, excited, talkative, with flight of
    ideas.” Then her condition suddenly changed to a marked
    reduction of activity, in which she neither spoke
    spontaneously nor answered questions. She “appeared to
    sleep,” but was said to have talked to her people. When
    interfered with, she was resistive and sometimes let
    herself fall out of bed. On the other hand, she
    occasionally wandered about at night.

    It should be added
    that during the stupor an alveolar abscess developed which
    discharged pus. It was washed out and healed.

    Then she was sent to the Manhattan State Hospital and
    admitted to the service of the Psychiatric Institute.

    Under Observation: 1. On the first day she lay in bed
    with cyanotic extremities, weak pulse, grunting, moaning
    and not responding in any way when examined. After this the
    moaning and grunting ceased and she was essentially
    indifferent, and for the most part kept her eyes closed.
    Often she wet and soiled herself. She was resistive to any
    care or examination. She would not eat, as a rule, but
    again gulped down milk offered her. For a considerable time
    she had to be tube-fed.

    During the early part of this
    stupor she once took a paper from the doctor, examined it,
    and then gave it back without saying anything, or again she
    peered around silently, or asked to go home, or again, on a
    few occasions, answered a question or two or spoke some
    unintelligible words. Orientation could not be established.

    1. After a few weeks she became more rigid, a condition

    which continued for six months. She let saliva collect in
    her mouth, and drooled. She had to be tube-fed. She lay
    very rigid, with very pronounced general tension, with her
    lips puckered, hands clenched, sometimes holding her eyes
    tightly closed, and often with marked perspiration. For one
    day she held her breath until she was blue in the face. On
    the same day she was extremely rigid, so that she could be
    raised by her head with only her heels resting on the bed.
    Her eyes were tightly shut and she was in profuse
    perspiration.

    Sometimes she interrupted this by a deep
    breath, only again to resume the forcible holding of her
    breath. On another day towards the end of the period, while
    quite stiff, she kept grunting and screaming “murder.” The
    soiling continued. She never spoke.

    Physical condition during the stupor: At first she had a
    coated tongue, foul breath and a fetid diarrhea. The latter
    was treated with high colonic flushing and mild diet. Urine
    normal--gynecologically normal. General neurological and
    physical examination not possible. At the same time she had
    for two weeks a temperature which often reached 100° or a
    little above, a weak, irregular but not rapid pulse, a
    leucocytosis of 17,500 and 80% hemoglobin.

    When she began
    to refuse food and before she was tube-fed regularly, she
    twice had syncopal attacks and lost considerable flesh
    which was gradually regained under tube-feeding. After the
    diarrhea she was habitually constipated. Cyanosis of the
    extremities seemed to have been present only at first.

    1. Six months after admission she began to make very free

    facial movements--winking, raising the eyebrows--and soon
    developed an excitement with marked elation. She had to be
    kept in the continuous bath, talked continuously, whistled,
    sang, was markedly erotic towards the physician, careless
    in exposing herself and often obscene in her talk. Most of
    her productions were determined by the environment. She was
    therefore quite distractible, very alert; sometimes she was
    meddlesome, again irritable, irascible. The following
    illustrates her productions: “Send for my husband, S.--He
    had one sister as big as that. She likes candy....

    My
    father is underneath and my mother is on top because she is
    fat and he is skinny.... Wait till the sun shines,
    Nellie--we will be happy, Nellie--don’t you sigh,
    sweetheart, you and I--wait till the sun shines by and
    by.... Come in (as noise is heard)--I bet that is my
    husband--my name is Regina K. (mother’s name)--my mother’s
    name is the same--I got a little sister named Regina--she
    is my husband.” When she heard the word pain, she said,
    “Who says paint, Pauline used paint, I used paint,” etc.

    Towards the end of August she had pneumonia, which did not
    change her condition.

    By October she was well, having gradually settled down. She
    had good insight.

    Retrospectively: She laid very little stress on the false
    report of the father’s death. She claimed to remember being
    at the Observation Pavilion, but to recall very little of
    the other hospital. Unfortunately an inquiry was not made
    regarding her memory during the stupor period under
    observation with the exception of the fact that she said
    she wanted to die and therefore refused food.

    She was seen in March, 1913, appeared perfectly well, and
    stated she had been well during the entire interval.

    If this forced holding of the breath had been the only anomaly, one would, perhaps, not be justified in drawing any conclusions as to its significance. But the deep stupor was interrupted again for a day by grunting and screaming of “murder.” This is certainly indicative of a compulsive death idea and retrospectively she spoke of having refused food in order to die. The latter seems to indicate some connection between her negativism and death. Consequently, even if we regard the breath holding as resistiveness, it would still be related to her idea of dissolution. Her negativism went beyond ordinary limits in that it affected the expression of the face.

    When we consider these three cases together, we see that what would otherwise have been deep stupors with profound inactivity, were modified by activity in two directions: suicidal and resistive. Presuming that the symptoms of stupor are all interrelated, we can see a reason why the affect should also have been altered. When one is modified, this should influence the other. When the activity is increased, the emotional concomitants of impulsive acts tend to break through as well. Hence the changes observed in these cases in facial expression and tone of voice.

    It is noteworthy, too, that all three showed a tendency for laughter to appear, as if, the emotions once stirred, it was possible for them to be exhibited in other than unpleasant forms. So, too, it was possible for ideas unrelated to the stupor picture, such as those of lovers, to occur sporadically. Finally, since activity must imply some contact with environment, the first of these cases at least showed less interference with the intelligence than is usual. In general, one may conclude that any aberration from the pure type of stupor tends to allow other impurities to appear.

    CHAPTER IV

    THE INTERFERENCES WITH THE INTELLECTUAL PROCESSES

    This is one of the most interesting and important of the stupor symptoms. We are accustomed to think of the functional psychoses having symptoms to do with emotions and ideas in the main, and, conversely, that disorientation, etc., observed in such cases is merely the result of distraction, poor attention or coöperation. But in stupor the deficit in understanding, incapacity to solve simple problems and failure of memory seem deep-rooted and fundamental symptoms.

    So far is this true that Bleuler[5] looks on “schizophrenic” cases with this symptom of “Benommenheit” as organic in etiology. It may be said at the outset that we do not share this view for many reasons. One at least may now be stated as it seems to be final. In benign stupor purely mental stimuli may change the whole clinical picture abruptly and with this produce a change in the intellectual functioning such as we never see in organic dementias or clouded states.

    We find it more satisfactory to attempt a correlation of this with the other symptoms on a purely functional basis, as will be explained later.

    For the study of the interferences with the intellectual processes during stupor reaction, we have two sources of information: The first is derived from the account which the patient is able to give in regard to what he remembers as having taken place around him or in his mind during the stupor period; the second is the direct observation of partial stupor reactions.

    1. Information Derived from the Patient’s Retrospective Account

    We will start with the cases of marked stupor mentioned in Chapter I.

    Anna G.’s (Case 1) psychosis commenced at home, and under observation lasted with great intensity for five months. She remembered only vaguely the carriage going to the Observation Pavilion, had no recollection of the latter, nor of her transfer to the Manhattan State Hospital and of most of the stay at the Institute ward, including the tube- or spoon-feeding which had to be carried on for four months. She also claimed that she did not know where she was until four or five months after admission. She was amnesic for her delusions and hallucinations.

    Of Caroline DeS. (Case 2) we have no information. Of Mary F. (Case 3), whose stupor began at home and under observation lasted two years, we find that she had no recollection of coming to the hospital, what ward she came to, who the doctor and nurses were (with whom she became acquainted later), in fact she claimed that for about a year she did not know where she was. But she remembered having been tube-fed (this took place over a long period). Mary D.’s (Case 4) stupor also commenced at home, and under observation lasted for three months.

    She had no recollection of going to the Observation Pavilion, of the transfer to Manhattan State Hospital, and of a considerable part of her stay here, including such obtrusive facts as a presentation before a staff meeting, an extensive physical and a blood examination, and she claimed not to have known for a long time where she was. Annie K.’s (Case 5) stupor commenced at home.

    Although she recalled the last days there and some ideas and events at the Observation Pavilion, the memory of the journey to Ward’s Island was vague, as was that of entrance to the ward, and she claimed not to have known where she was for quite a while. Specific occurrences, such as the taking of her picture (with open eyes two months after admission), an examination in a special room, her own mixed-up writing (end of second week) were not remembered.

    But it is quite interesting that an angry outburst of another patient within this same period, which was evidently not recorded, is clearly remembered.

    We shall later show that when the patient comes out of a stupor the condition may be such that, for a time at least, retrospective accounts are difficult to obtain. It must also be remembered that not infrequently the more marked stupors may be followed by milder states, and it is important, if we wish to determine how much is remembered, not to confuse the two states or not to let the patient confuse them.

    For example, Mary D. (Case 4), who showed two separate phases, while she claimed not to know of many external facts, also added that she could not understand the questions which were asked. From observation in other cases it seems that in marked stupor any such recollection about the patient’s own mental processes would be quite inconsistent. We have to assume, therefore, that this remark referred in reality to the second milder phase, for which, as we shall see, it is indeed quite characteristic. It is not necessary to burden the reader with other cases, all of which consistently gave such accounts.

    We see, then, that in the marked stupor the intellectual processes are regularly interfered with, as evidenced by almost complete amnesia for external events and internal thoughts. In other words, this would indicate that the minds of these patients were blank. Inasmuch as direct observation during the stupor adduces little proof of mentation, we may assume that such mental processes as may exist in deepest stupor are of a primitive, larval order.

    Before we examine more carefully the milder grades of stupor, it will be necessary to say a few words about the retrospective account which the patient gives of intellectual difficulties during the incubation period of the psychosis. As a matter of fact, we find that these accounts are remarkably uniform. While some patients, to be sure, speak of a more or less sudden lack of interest or ambition which came over them, others of them speak plainly of a sudden mental loss. Mary. C. (Case 7) claimed she suddenly got mixed up and lost her memory.

    Laura A. spoke at any rate of suddenly having felt dazed and stunned. Mary D. (Case 4) said she felt she was losing her mind and that she could not understand what she was reading. Maggie H. (Case 14) began to say that her head was getting queer. We see from this that the interferences with the intellectual processes may in the beginning be quite sudden.

    In some instances a more detailed retrospective account was taken, which may throw some light upon the interferences with the intellectual processes with which we are now concerned. Emma K., whose case need not be taken up in detail, had a typical marked stupor which lasted for nine months, preceded by a bewildered, restless, resistive state for five days. She was in the Institute ward for the first four months, including the five days above mentioned; later in another ward.

    When asked what was the first ward which she remembered, she mentioned the one after the Institute ward, and when asked who the first physician was, she mentioned the one in charge of the second ward. However, when taken to the Institute ward, she said it looked familiar, and was able to point to the bed in which she lay, though somewhat tentatively. The same rousing of memory occurred when the first physician, who saw her daily, was pointed out to her.

    She remembered having seen him, and then even recalled the fact that he had thrown a light into her eyes, but remembered nothing else. This observation would seem to show that with some often repeated or very marked mental stimuli (throwing electric light into her eyes) a vague impression may be left, so that it may at least be possible to bring about a recollection with assistance, whereas spontaneous memory is impossible. In another instance, the patient was confronted with a physician who had seen a good deal of her.

    She said that he looked familiar to her, but she was unable to say where she had seen him. Here then again evidence that a certain vague impression was made by a repeated stimulus.

    Another feature should here be mentioned, namely, that isolated facts may be remembered when the rest is blank. We have seen above that Annie K. (Case 5), while very vague about most occurrences, recalled a sudden angry outburst in detail. Another patient, though the period of the stupor was a blank, recalled some visits of her mother. At these times, as she claimed, she thought she was to be electrocuted and told her mother so, “Then it would drop out of my mind again.” These facts are very interesting.

    We can scarcely account for such phenomena in any other way than by assuming that certain influences may temporarily lift the patient out of the deepest stupor. In spite of the fact that stupors often last for one or two years almost without change, a fact which would argue that the stupor reaction is a remarkably set, stable state, we see in sudden episodes of elation that this is not the case, and other experiences point in the same direction. A similar observation was made on a case of typical stupor with marked reduction of activity and dullness.

    A rather cumbersome electrical apparatus (for the purpose of getting a good light for pupil examination) was brought to her bedside.

    Whereas before, she had been totally unresponsive, she suddenly wakened up, asked whether “those things” would blow up the place, and whether she was to be electrocuted. During this anxious state she responded promptly to commands, but after a short time relapsed into her totally inactive condition. We have, of course, similar experiences when we try to get stuporous patients to eat, who, after much coaxing may, for a short time, be made to feed themselves, only to relapse into the state of inactivity.

    Such variations are paralleled, as we shall later show, by a suddenly pronounced deepening of the thinking disorder. We have already seen that the onset may be quite sudden. All this indicates that, in spite of a certain stability, sudden changes are not uncommon. Finally, we know that, in spite of the fact that stupor is an essentially affectless reaction, certain influences may produce smiles or tears, or, above all, angry outbursts, which again can hardly be interpreted otherwise than by assuming that those influences have temporarily produced a change in the clinical picture, in the sense of lifting the patient out of the depth of the stupor.

    All these facts suggest that inconsistencies in recollection are correlated with changes in the clinical picture.

    As is to be expected, the cases with partial stupors remember much more of what externally and internally happened during their psychoses. Rose Sch. (Case 6), who had a partial stupor during which she answered questions but showed a great difficulty in thinking, said retrospectively that she felt mixed up and could not remember. Although she recalled with details the Observation Pavilion and her transfer, she was not clear about their time relations (how long in the Observation Pavilion, how long in the first ward). Mary C.

    (Case 7), whose activity was not entirely interfered with and who showed some thinking disorder, said retrospectively that she could not take in things. Henrietta H. (Case 8), who had a partial stupor, claimed to have known all along where she was, but that she felt mixed up, that her thoughts wandered and that she felt confused about people. In the cases where a partial stupor was preceded by a marked one, such as in phase 2 of Anna G. (Case

    1. and phase 2 of Mary D. (Case 4), we have no retrospective account

    regarding the partial stupor, because emphasis in the analysis was naturally laid on the period comprising the most marked disorder.

    However, we can gather from the few cases at our disposal that the patients retrospectively lay stress chiefly on their inability to understand the situation.

    We finally have to consider the group of suicidal cases. We have information only in regard to two cases, namely, Margaret C. (Case 10) and Pearl F. (Case 9). In both of these, we find that a good many things that happened during the period under consideration were remembered, as were also the patients’ own actions. In Rosie K. (Case 11) we have at least the evidence that she remembered her own impulses, namely, that she refused food because she wanted to die. In other words, in these partial stupors with impulsive suicidal tendencies the interference with the intellectual processes seems to be moderate, and memory for external events not markedly affected.

    1. Information Derived from Direct Observation

    The evidence can best be presented by considering the details of some cases.

    Rose Sch. (Case 6) was remarkable, in connection with the present problem, in her unusually poor answers. She either merely repeated the questions, or made irrelevant superficial replies, or said she did not know, this even with very simple questions. When better, too, though not quite well, she showed striking discrepancies in time relations and incapacity to correct them. It would seem that in this case there was something more than an acute interference with the intellectual processes, such as we are here discussing.

    As a matter of fact, we have the statement in the history that the patient herself said she was slow at learning in school and had not much of an education. A congenital intellectual defect and the attitude which it creates may, however, as my experience has repeatedly shown me, very greatly exaggerate an acute thinking disorder. The case, therefore, while it shows us an unquestionably acute interference with the intellectual processes, does not give us useful information about its nature. More information can be gathered from Mary D. (Case 4).

    Even toward the end of her marked stupor some replies were obtained chiefly by making her write. When asked to write Manhattan State Hospital, she wrote Manhatt Hhospshosh, and for Ward’s Island, Ww. Iland. Again, instead of writing 90th Street, she wrote 90theath Street. These are plainly reactions of the path of least resistance or, in these instances, of perseveration. Of the same nature are some of her other replies in writing or speaking.

    After she had been asked to write her name, she was requested to add her address, or the name of the hospital; she merely repeated the name. Similarly, when asked whether she knew the examiner, she said “Yes,” but when urged to give his name, she gave her own. In the partial stupor at a time when she knew where she was, knew the names of some people about her, the year and approximately the date, she made mistakes in calculation and could not get the point of a test story.

    Moreover, she failed in retention tests without there being any evidence of anything like a marked fundamental retention disorder, such as we find in Korsakoff psychosis. It seems that these results are best termed defects in attention, which chiefly interfere with the apprehension of more difficult tasks. As we shall see later, this seems to be rather characteristic of these cases.

    Another point which should be mentioned is the fact that her reaction to questions which she was unable to answer (such as matters which referred to her amnesic periods) was peculiar, inasmuch as she did not only not try to think them out, but seemed indifferent to her incapacity, simply leaving the question unanswered. This too, as we shall see later, is characteristic. Laura A., at a time when she could be made to reply, merely repeated the question, again a reaction of least resistance. The same patient sometimes asked, “Where am I?” Mary C.

    (Case 7) made similar queries.

    Although she was at times approximately oriented, she would say, “I don’t know where I am,” or “I can’t realize where I am,” or more pointedly, “I can’t take in my surroundings.” She often did not answer and sometimes seemed bewildered by the questions. Henrietta H. (Case 8) again showed some defect of orientation and mistakes in calculation, and above all, marked mistakes in writing (for Manhattan State Hospital--Manhaton Hotspal).

    A special feature here is that this occurred immediately after she had been quite talkative, but suddenly had relapsed into a dull state. Anna G.

    (Case 1), during the third phase of her psychosis, showed the following: Although she was approximately oriented and answered promptly simple questions; e.g., about orientation or simple calculation, she, like these other patients, simply remained silent when more difficult intellectual tasks were required of her (more difficult calculations); or when she was asked how long she had been here (which involved data that could not be available to her, owing to her amnesia); or when questions were put to her regarding her feelings or the condition she had passed through.

    On the other hand, she sometimes gave appropriate replies in the words “yes” or “no,” but it was difficult to say whether these answers did not also represent the path of least resistance.

    We will finally take up the last phase of Margaret C. (Case 10).

    Although she was entirely oriented, there was a certain vagueness about her answers which is difficult to formulate. She was telling about the onset of her sickness and said that at that time her mind was taken up with prayers about the salvation of her relatives.

    She was asked exactly when it was that she thought of this and she answered “Now?” (What period are we talking about?) “The present.” (What did I ask you?) “About this period of my sickness.” (Which one?) “What sickness?” She said herself at this point, “I am rather stupid.” Again when asked how her mind worked, she said, “Pretty quickly sometimes--I don’t know.” (As good as it used to?) “No, I don’t think so.” (What is the difference?) “There is no difference.” (What did I ask you?) “The difference.” (The difference between what?) “You did not say.” In this the shallowness of her comprehension and thinking is well shown, and it seems here again perhaps justifiable to formulate the main defect as one of attention, which prevents completion of a complicated process of comprehension.

    A feature of further interest in this case is that automatic intellectual processes, such as those necessary for the writing of a long poem from memory, were not interfered with.

    Summary

    In the most pronounced stupor we have evidently a more or less complete standstill in thinking processes. Practically no impressions are registered and consequently nothing is remembered except events that occurred in some short periods when some affective stimulus, or a brief burst of elation, lifts the patient temporarily out of the deep stupor.

    It is impossible to say whether the statement of a complete standstill has to be qualified. In some stupors repeated environmental stimuli sometimes make at least a vague impression, so that while spontaneous recollection is impossible a feeling of familiarity is present when the patient is again confronted with this environment. This might be an exception to the dictum of complete mental vacuity, or it may be that there are somewhat less pronounced stupor reactions.

    When more is perceived, there is often a retrospective statement of having felt mixed up, being unable to take in things, or, directly under observation, the patient may say, “I cannot realize where I am,” “I cannot take in my surroundings.” In harmony with this is the fact that questions often produce a certain bewilderment.

    In quite pronounced states in which some replies can still be obtained, we find that the intellectual processes may be interfered with to the extent of a paragraphia, i.e., a remarkably mixed-up writing in which perseveration (one form of following the path of least resistance) plays a prominent part. This same principle is also seen in such reactions as the repetition of the question or the senseless repetition of a former answer.

    These phenomena remind us of what we see in epileptic confusions, in epileptic deterioration and in arteriosclerotic dementia.

    In milder cases difficulties in orientation may be more or less marked; or there may be incapacity to think out problems, although the orientation is perfect. The more automatic mental processes may run smoothly (memory and calculation may be excellent) and there may yet be a certain shallowness in thinking, a defect of attention (a purely descriptive term) which is most obvious in the patient’s inability to grasp clearly the drift of what is going on or the meaning of complicated questions.

    I am inclined to think that poor results in retention tests are entirely due to this attention disorder, for we have no evidence of any fundamental retention defect such as we find in the totally different organic stupors. From a practical point of view it is important at this place to call attention to the fact that such mild changes are particularly seen in end stages.

    Even when pronounced negativistic tendencies do not play a prominent rôle, the patient is then apt to be silent chiefly as a result of the residual disorder in the intellectual processes. Still more striking are the conditions which are on a somewhat higher level and in which the shallowness of the responses, due to the residual disorder of attention, together with the last traces of the affectlessness, are apt to create the impression of a dementia.

    In such cases the opinion is often held that the patient has reached a defect stage from which recovery is impossible, whereas a thorough knowledge of these end stages teaches us that they are not only recoverable but quite typical for the terminal phases of stupor.

    Considering these data, especially those gathered in the end stages, it would appear that there is no tendency in this intellectual disorder associated with the stupor reaction for any special side of mental activity to be most prominently affected. It looks rather as if it were a question of a general diminution of the capacity to make a mental effort which in its different intensities accounts for the symptoms.

    FOOTNOTES:

    [5] See Chapter XV.

    CHAPTER V

    THE IDEATIONAL CONTENT OF THE STUPOR

    Brief survey of the ideas associated with stupor: Having thus described the formal manifestations of the various stupor reactions, it will now be interesting to see what ideas seem to be associated with these reactions. It is, of course, impossible to obtain during a considerable part of the stupor any statement of the patients’ thoughts.

    We therefore have to depend on their utterances during periods when the inactivity temporarily ceases, or on the retrospective account which the patient gives after the stupor has completely disappeared; and as we shall see, we also may obtain considerable information by studying the ideas which occur in the period preceding the stupor. These last may be autogenous delusions or thoughts about actual events which precipitated the psychosis.

    It is not likely that many observers have a very clear conception about what sort of ideas to expect. We have, as a rule, not been in the habit of paying much attention to the content of delusions, hallucinations, and the like. So far as we could judge, therefore, the ideas expressed might be expected to be fairly multiform, and it was distinctly interesting to us when we found a marked tendency for the trends of ideas to remain within a certain small compass.[6] It was possible, to state this at once, to show that in by far the majority of cases the same set of ideas returned, and that these ideas had among themselves a definite inner relationship, being concerned with thoughts of “death.”

    In isolated instances other ideas were found as well, and they will have to be discussed later. For the present we shall take up more habitual content.

    In addition to the eleven cases already described, it may be well to cite four others which present material now of interest to us.

    CASE 12.--Charlotte W. Age: 30. Admitted to the
    Psychiatric Institute October 21, 1905.

    F. H. The father was alcoholic and quick-tempered; he
    died when the patient was a child. The mother was alcoholic
    and was insane at 40 (a state of excitement from which she
    recovered). A brother had an attack of insanity in 1915. A
    maternal uncle died insane.

    P. H. The patient was described as jolly, having many
    friends. She got on well in school and was efficient at her
    work.

    She was married at 23 and got on well with her husband. The
    latter stated, however, that she masturbated during the
    first year of her married life. The first child was born
    without trouble.

    First Attack at 25: Two or three days after giving birth
    to a second child, her mother burst into the room
    intoxicated. The patient immediately became much
    frightened, nervous, and developed a depressive condition
    with crying, slowness and inability to do things. During
    this state she spoke of being bad and told her husband
    that a man had tried to have intercourse with her before
    marriage. This attack lasted six months and ended with
    recovery.

    When 29, a year before her admission, she had an abortion
    performed, and four months later another. Her husband was
    against this, but she persisted in her intention. Seven
    months before admission she went to the priest, confessed
    and was reproved. It is not clear how she took this
    reproof, but at any rate no symptoms appeared until three
    weeks later, after burglars had broken into a nearby
    church.

    Then she became unduly frightened, would not stay
    at home, said she was afraid the burglars would come again
    and kill “some one in the house.” The patient herself
    stated later, during a faultfinding period, that at that
    time she was afraid somebody would take her honor away, and
    that she thought burglars had taken her “wedding dress.”
    “Then,” she added, “I thought I would run away and lead a
    bad life, but I did not want to bring disgrace to the
    family.”

    The general condition which she presented at this time is
    described as one of apprehensiveness when at home. For this
    reason she was for five weeks (it is not clear exactly at
    what period) sent to her sister, where she was better.
    About a month before the patient was admitted, the husband
    moved, whereupon she got depressed, complained of inability
    to apply herself to work, became slow and inactive, and
    blamed herself for having had the abortion performed. She
    began to speak of suicide and was committed because she
    bought carbolic acid.

    She later said that while in the
    Observation Pavilion she imagined her children were cut
    up.

    Under Observation the condition was as follows:

    1. For the first three days the patient, though for the

    most part not showing any marked mood reaction, was
    inclined at times to cry, and at such times complained
    essentially that this was a terrible place for a person who
    was not insane.

    1. On the fourth day the condition changed, and it will be

    advisable to describe her state in the form of abstracts of
    each day.

    On October 24 the patient began to be preoccupied and to
    answer slowly. A few days later she became distinctly dull,
    walked about in an indifferent way or lay in bed immobile.
    Twice on October 27 she said in a low tone and with
    slight distress, “Give me one more chance, let me go to
    him.” But she would not answer questions. At times she
    lapsed into complete immobility, lying on her back and
    staring at the ceiling.

    When the husband came in the
    afternoon, she clung to him and said: “Say good-by forever,
    O my God, save me.” Again, very slowly with long pauses and
    with moaning, she said: “You are going to put me in a big
    hole where I will stay for the rest of my life.” On
    October 28
    she was found with depressed expression and
    spoke in a rather low tone, but not with decided slowness
    as had been the case on the day before.

    She pleaded about
    having her soul saved; “Don’t kill me”; “Make me true to my
    husband”; once, “I have confessed to the wrong man the
    shame of my life.” Later she said she did not tell the
    truth about her life before marriage. Again she wanted to
    be saved from the electric chair. At times she showed a
    tendency to stare into space and to leave questions
    unanswered.

    1. From now on a more definite stupor occurred, which is

    also best described in summaries of the individual notes.

    Oct. 29. Lies in bed with fixed gaze, pointing upward
    with her finger and is very resistive towards any
    interference. She has to be catheterized.

    Oct. 30. Can be spoon-fed but is still catheterized.
    During the morning she knelt by the bed and would not
    answer. At the visit she was found in a rather natural
    position, smiling as the physician approached, saying “I
    don’t know how long I have been here.” Then she looked out
    of the window fixedly. At first she did not answer, but,
    when the physician asked whether she knew his name, she
    laughed and said, “I know your name--I know my name.” Then
    she would not answer any more questions but remained
    immobile, with fixed gaze.

    When her going home was
    mentioned, however, she flushed and tears ran down her
    cheek, though no change in the fixedness of her attitude or
    in her facial expression was seen.

    Nov. 1. Lies flat on her back with her hands elevated.
    She is markedly resistive.

    Nov. 2. Free from muscular tension and more responsive.
    When asked whether she felt like talking, she said in a
    whining tone, “No, go away--I have to go through enough.”
    Then she spoke of not knowing how long the nights and days
    were, of not having known which way she was going. When
    asked who the physician was she whimpered and said, “You
    came to tell me what was right.” She called him “Christ”
    and another physician “Jim” (husband’s name), though, later
    in the interview, she gave their correct names.

    When asked
    about the name of another physician, she said: “He looks
    like my cousin, he was here, they all came the first night.
    I did not take notice who it was till I went through these
    spirits, then I knew it was right.”--She paused and added:
    “My God--mother it was; she is here on Earth, somewhere in
    a convent--Sister C. (who actually is in a convent) she was
    here, too, I could hear her.” She said they all came to try
    to save her.

    When asked whether she had been asleep, she
    said: “No, I wasn’t asleep, I was mesmerized, but I am
    awake now--sometimes I thought I was dead.” (When?) “The
    time I was going to Heaven.” Again: “I went to Heaven in
    spirit, I came back again--the wedding ring kept me on
    Earth--I will have to be crucified now.” (Tell me about
    it.) “Jim will have to pick my eyes out--I think it is him.
    Oh, it is my little girl.” (Who told you?) “The spirits
    told me.” Again: “Little birds my children--I can’t see
    them any more--I must stay here till I die.” (Why?) “The
    spirits told me--till I pick every one of my eyes out and
    my brains too.” When asked what day it was, she said, “It
    must be Good Friday.” (Why?) “Because God told me I must
    die on the cross as he did.” When asked why she had not
    spoken the day before, she said that “Jesus Christ in
    Heaven” had told her she should not tell anything, “till
    all of you had gone, then I could go home with him, because
    that is the way we came in and it was Jim too all the
    time.” Finally she said crossly, “Go away now, you are all
    trying to keep me from Jim” (crying).

    Nov. 3. Knelt by bed during the night. This morning lies
    in bed staring, resistive, again she is markedly
    cataleptic. She has to be spoon-fed, and is totally
    unresponsive. In the afternoon she was found staring and
    resistive. Presently she said with tears: “I am waiting to
    be put on the cross.”

    Nov. 4. Still has to be catheterized. She sits up,
    staring, with expressionless face, but when asked how she
    felt she responded and said feebly: “I don’t know how I
    feel or how I look or how long I have been here or
    anything.” (What is wrong?) “Oh, I only want to go to a
    convent the rest of my days.” (Why?) “Oh, I have only said
    wrong things, I thought I would be better dead, I could not
    do anything right.” Later she again began to stare.

    Nov. 5. During the night she is said to have been
    restless and wanted to go to church. To-day she is found
    staring, but not resistive. When questioned she sometimes
    does not answer. She said to the physician, “I should have
    gone up to Heaven to you and not brought me down here.” She
    called the physician “Uncle James.” Again she said, “I want
    to go up to see Jim.” Sometimes she looks indifferent,
    again somewhat bewildered.

    Nov. 6. She eats better, catheterizing is no longer
    necessary. She is found lying in bed, rigid, staring,
    resistive, does not answer at first, later appears somewhat
    distressed, says “I want to go and see Jim.” (Where?) “In
    Heaven.” She gave the name of the place and of the
    physician, also the date.

    Nov. 8. In the forenoon, after she had presented a rather
    immobile expression and had answered a few orientation
    questions correctly, she suddenly beckoned into space, then
    shook her fist in a threatening manner. When later asked
    about this, she said: “Jim was down there and I wanted to
    get him in.” (And?) “You was up here first.” (And?) “I
    thought we was going down down, up up--the boat-- --you
    came in here for--to lock Jim out so we wouldn’t let him
    in.” Later she said, when asked whether anything worried
    her, “Yes, you are taking Jim’s place.”

    Nov. 9. During the night she is reported to have varied
    between stiffness with mutism and a more relaxed state.
    Once, the nurse found her with tears, saying “I want to go
    down the hall to my sister--to the river,” and a short time
    later with fright: “Is that my mother?” Again she said: “Oh
    dear, I wish this boat would stop--stop it--where are we
    going?” In the forenoon she was quiet and unresponsive.

    In
    the afternoon she said in a somewhat perplexed way, “We
    were in a ship and we were ’most drowned.” (When was that?)
    “Day before yesterday it must have been”--Again she said in
    the same manner: “It was like water. I was going down.

    I
    could hear a lot of things.” She claimed this happened
    “to-day.” “I saw all the people in here, it was all full
    of water,” “I have been lying here a long time--do you
    remember the time I was under the ground and it seemed full
    of water and every one got drowned and a sharp thing struck
    me?” “I was out in a ship and I went down there in a
    coffin.” When asked whether she had been frightened at such
    times, she said: “No, I didn’t seem to be, I just lay
    there.” She also said: “the water rushed in,” and when
    asked why she put up her arms, she said, “I did it to save
    the ship.”

    Nov. 10. She is still fairly free. She said that when she
    was on the ship things looked changed, “the picture over
    there looked like a saint, the beds looked queer.” (How do
    things look now?) “All right.” (The picture too?) “The same
    as when I was going down into a dark hole.” When asked
    later in the day where she was, she said, “In the Pope’s
    house, Uncle Edward is it?” but after a short time she
    added, “It is Ward’s Island, isn’t it?”

    Nov. 11. Inactive, inaccessible, but for the most part
    not rigid.

    Nov. 14. Varies between mutism with resistance and more
    relaxed inactivity. To-day lies in a position repeatedly
    assumed by her, namely, on her stomach with head raised,
    resistive towards any interference, immobile face, totally
    inaccessible.

    Nov. 15. Freer. She said: “One day I was in a coffin,
    that’s the day I went to Heaven.” She also said she used to
    see “the crucifix hanging there” (on the ceiling)--“not now
    but when I was going to Heaven.” (When was that?) “Over in
    that bed” (her former bed). Later she added, “The place
    changed so ... things used to be coming up and down
    (dreamily)--that was the day I was coming up on the ship or
    going down.” She is quite oriented.

    Nov. 17. Usually stands about with immobile face,
    preoccupied, but she eats voluntarily.

    Nov. 24. When the husband and sister came a few days ago
    she said she was glad to see them, embraced them, cried and
    is said to have spoken quite freely. To-day she speaks more
    freely than usually.

    When asked why she had answered so
    little, she said she could not bring herself to say
    anything, though she added spontaneously, “I knew what was
    said to me.” When shown a picture of her cataleptic
    attitude with hands raised, she said dreamily, “I guess
    that must have been the day I went to Heaven, everything
    seemed strange, things seemed to be going up and down.”
    (Did you know where you were?) “I guess that was the day I
    thought I was on the ship.” When the sister spoke to her,
    she seemed depressed and said, “If only I had not done
    those things I might be saved, if I had only gone to church
    more.”

    Dec. 3. Seems depressed. She weeps some, says she is sad,
    “There seems to be something over my heart, so I can’t see
    my little girls.” Again: “I should have told you about it
    first--I should not have bought it”--(refers to buying
    carbolic acid). She wrote a natural letter but very slowly.

    1. There followed then a state lasting for six months,

    during which the patient was rather inactive, preoccupied,
    even a little tense at times. Sometimes she did not answer,
    again at the same interview spoke quite promptly. For the
    most part the affect was reduced, at other times she
    appeared a little uneasy, bewildered, or again depressed.
    She said that sometimes a mist seemed to be over her.

    Now
    and then spoke of things looking queer and she asked, when
    the room was cleaned, “Why do they move things about?” and
    she added irrelevantly: “I thought the robbers broke into
    my house and stole my wedding dress and my children’s
    dresses” (refers to the condition during the onset of her
    psychosis). In the beginning of this state, when asked
    about the stupor, she spoke again of the “ship” and about
    going “down, down,” but also said that on one occasion she
    heard beautiful music, was waiting for the last trumpet and
    was afraid to move.

    Moreover, she had some ideas referring
    to the actual situation which were akin to those in the
    more marked stupor period. Although she admitted she was
    better, she said on December 8 that she still had queer
    ideas at times, “I sometimes think the doctor is Uncle Jim”
    (long dead). She also spoke of other patients looking like
    dead relatives, and added, “Are all the spirits that are
    dead over here?” “We never die here, the spirits are here.”
    But after that date no such ideas recurred, in fact this
    whole period seems to have been remarkably barren of
    delusions. Exceptionally isolated ones were noted.

    Thus, on
    January 28 it is mentioned that she stated she sometimes
    felt so lonely, and as though people were against her; and
    on February 13 she said she felt as though the chair knew
    what she was talking about. It is also mentioned in January
    that she wept at times, but this seems not to have been a
    leading feature at all. In March, when asked why she was
    not more active and cheerful, her lips began to quiver and
    she said, “Oh, I thought my children would be cut up in
    Bellevue.” “I don’t know why I feel that way about them.”
    She sometimes cried when her friends left her.

    1. Then followed a week of a rather faultfinding,

    self-assertive state, during which she demanded to be
    allowed to go home, saying indignantly that she was not a
    wicked woman, had done nothing to be kept a prisoner here;
    she wanted justice because another patient had called her
    crazy. But in this period also she said that after the
    robbery (at home) she felt afraid that her honor would be
    taken away.

    When told that her husband had been with her,
    she said “Yes, but I was afraid they would get into a
    fight.” (You mean you were afraid the other man would kill
    him?) “No, he is not dead.” She further talked of a
    disagreement she had at that time with her husband, and
    that she felt then like running away and leading a bad
    life, but thought of the children. With tears she added: “I
    would not do anything that is wrong. I have my children to
    live for.” Quite remarkable was the fact that she then told
    of various erotic experiences in her life, though with a
    distinctly moral attitude and minimizing them.

    1. On June 16 another state was initiated with peculiar

    ideas, the setting of which is not known, as she told them
    only to the nurses. She said that she was not Mrs. W. but
    the Queen of England, again that she was an actress, or
    again the wife of a wealthy Mr. B., and that she was going
    to have a baby. But at night she is said to have been
    agitated and afraid she was to be executed. She asked to be
    allowed to go to bed again, then stopped talking, and
    remained in this mute condition for about a week. She often
    left her bed and went back again, remained much with a
    perplexed expression. On one occasion she put tinsel in her
    hair saying it was a golden crown.

    1. At the end of that time she became freer and more

    natural, and remained so for three weeks. She occupied
    herself somewhat. When asked what had happened in the
    condition preceding, said she thought she was a queen or
    was to be a queen.

    1. Towards the end of this period she had again three more

    absorbed days, but when examined on the third of these days
    got rather talkative and somewhat drifting in her talk on
    superficial topics.

    1. Two days later she began to sing at night, kissed

    everybody, said it was the anniversary of her meeting her
    husband, again cried a little, and on the following morning
    began to sing love songs, with a rather ecstatic mood, and
    at times stood in an attitude of adoration with her hands
    raised. This passed over to a more elated state, during
    which she smiled a good deal, often quite coquettishly; she
    sang love songs softly; on one occasion put a mosquito
    netting over her head like a bridal veil; or she held her
    fingers in the shape of a ring over a flower pinned to her
    breast.

    But even during this state she said little, only
    once spoke of waiting for her wedding ring, and again, when
    asked why she had been singing, said “I was singing to the
    man I love.” (Why are you so happy?) “Because I am with
    you” (coquettishly).

    This, however, represented the end of the psychosis. She
    improved rapidly. At first she smiled rather readily, but
    soon began to occupy herself and made a perfect recovery.

    She gave a rather shallow retrospective account about the
    last phase: at first she said it was natural for people to
    feel happy at times, and that she did not talk more because
    the inclination was not there. The only point she added
    later was that she held her fingers in the shape of a ring
    because she was thinking of her wedding ring.

    She was discharged on October 11.

    The patient was seen again in September, 1915. She then
    stated that she had been perfectly well until 1912, when
    she had a breakdown after childbirth. (A childbirth in 1910
    had led to no disorder.) The attack lasted six months. She
    slept poorly, lost weight, and felt weak, depressed, “my
    strength seemed all gone.” In July, 1915, following again
    a childbirth, she was for about six weeks “despondent, weak
    and tired out.”

    At the interview she made a very natural, frank impression,
    and displayed excellent insight.

    CASE 13.--Johanna S. Age: 47. Admitted to the Psychiatric
    Institute January 23, 1904.

    F. H. It was claimed that there was no insanity in the
    family.

    P. H. The patient was said to have been bright and rather
    quick-tempered. She came to the United States from Ireland
    at the age of 20, worked as a servant, was well liked, and
    retained her position well.

    She was married at 24. After a second confinement, at the
    age of 26, the patient had her first attack of manic
    excitement, from which she recovered in four months. She
    had, subsequently, at the ages of 28, 30, 32, 35, 43, and
    45, other attacks of the same nature, each one lasting
    about four months. No precipitating cause was known for any
    of them. Only one of the attacks, the fifth, (none were
    well observed) seems to have shown features different from
    an elated excitement with irritability. At the end of this
    attack she was said to have been “dull” for a month.

    Her husband died four years before the present admission,
    evidently soon after her sixth attack.

    The present attack:

    About two months before admission the patient began,
    without appreciable cause, to be sleepless, complained of
    headaches and appeared downhearted and sad. She sat about.

    After a week she would not get out of bed and remained in
    bed until she was sent to the Observation Pavilion, getting
    up only to go to the closet. She said very little and would
    not eat much. About a month before admission she began to
    say that she did not want to live, begged her daughter to
    throw her out of the window. About two weeks before
    admission she began to insist that she heard the voice of
    her brother (living in Ireland) calling her. She got out of
    bed to look for him.

    At the Observation Pavilion she was described as slow,
    looking about in an apprehensive manner, bewildered, dazed,
    saying “I am dead--there is poison in it (not clear in
    what)--I am dead, you are dead.”

    Under Observation: 1. On admission the patient had a
    coated tongue, foul breath, constipation, lively knee-jerks
    and a pulse of 110. She appeared dull, inactive, lay in bed
    with her eyes closed. She would open them when urged but
    appeared drowsy and her face was strikingly immobile. At
    times she moaned a little. She could be made to respond in
    various ways such as shaking her head, or making some
    motions as though to indicate that she could not give any
    explanations. All movements were slow. She also responded
    to a few questions by “I don’t know.”

    Two days after admission the condition was not essentially
    different except that she was a little uneasy when urged to
    speak, corrugated her forehead, said “Everything is dark,”
    again “I am very sick,” or she turned away her head.

    On the fourth day, i.e., January 26, the picture altered,
    inasmuch as she was much more responsive. She was found
    sitting up in bed and, at times, a little uneasy. She was
    slow in her movements and answers, speaking in a whisper
    and sometimes a little fretfully. The answers, though slow,
    were, however, by no means given in the shortest possible
    manner, but with variations,

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
    Author
    August Hoch
    Release date
    September 22, 2009 [eBook #30065]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Bryan Ness, S.D., and the Online Distributed
    Most recently updated
    October 24, 2024
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
      BENIGN STUPORS
    
    
      THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
    
      NEW YORK · BOSTON · CHICAGO · DALLAS
      ATLANTA · SAN FRANCISCO
    
      MACMILLAN & CO., Limited
    
      LONDON · BOMBAY · CALCUTTA
      MELBOURNE
    
      THE MACMILLAN CO. OF CANADA, Ltd.
    
      TORONTO
    
    
    
    
      BENIGN STUPORS
    
      _A STUDY OF
      A NEW MANIC-DEPRESSIVE REACTION TYPE_
    
      BY
    
      AUGUST HOCH, M.D.
    
      LATE DIRECTOR OF THE PSYCHIATRIC INSTITUTE OF THE
      NEW YORK STATE HOSPITALS, WARD’S ISLAND, NEW
      YORK. LATE PROFESSOR OF PSYCHIATRY, CORNELL
      UNIVERSITY MEDICAL COLLEGE, NEW YORK
    
      New York
      THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
      1921
    
      _All rights reserved_
    
    
      PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
    
    
      Copyright, 1921,
      By THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
      Set up and printed. Published July, 1921.
    
    
      Press of
      J. J. Little & Ives Company
      New York, U. S. A.
    
    
      TO
      MY FORMER COLLEAGUES
      IN THE
      NEW YORK STATE HOSPITAL SERVICE
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Benign Stupors: A Study of a New Manic-Depressive Reaction Type
    
    Author: August Hoch
    
    Editor: John T. MacCurdy
    
    
            
    Release date: September 22, 2009 [eBook #30065]
                    Most recently updated: October 24, 2024
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/30065
    
    Credits: Produced by Bryan Ness, S.D., and the Online Distributed
            Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net (This book was
            produced from scanned images of public domain material
            from the Google Print project.)
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #30065. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 30065
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.