Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of War Letters of a Public-School Boy
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 29333

War Letters of a Public-School Boy

by Henry Paul Mainwaring Jones · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2009
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    War Letters of a Public-School Boy by Henry Paul Mainwaring Jones is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #29333). [Transcriber's note: Obvious printer's errors have been corrected. Hyphenation and accentuation have been standardised, all other inconsistencies are as in the original. The author's spelling

    HARRY JONES

    He was the very embodiment in himself of all that is best in the
    public-school spirit, the very incarnation of self-sacrifice and
    devotion.

    A DULWICH MASTER.

    WITH EIGHT PLATES

    CASSELL AND COMPANY, LTD

    London, New York, Toronto and Melbourne
    1918

    CONTENTS

    Page
    Introductory 1

    PART I. MEMOIR

    Chapter

    1. Childhood 9
    2. At Dulwich College 14
    3. Football 28
    4. Cricket 37
    5. Editor of The Alleynian 41
    6. Public Schools and the War 47
    7. Tastes and Hobbies 52
    8. Music 59
    9. Literature and Ethics 72
    10. History and Politics 85
    11. In the Army 98
    12. Personal Characteristics 110

    PART II. WAR LETTERS

    At a Home Port 121
    With the 9th Cavalry Brigade 131
    With a Supply Column 186
    In the Somme Battlefield 202
    With the 2nd Cavalry Brigade 212
    With the Tank Corps 229

    PART III

    Epilogue 257

    INDEX 277

    LIST OF PLATES

    H. P. M. Jones as 2nd Lieut. A.S.C. Frontispiece

    To face page
    Paul as an Infant 8
    In his 6th Year 12
    Winning the Mile, March 27, 1915 22
    Dulwich College First XV, 1914-15 28
    Dulwich Modern Side XV, 1914-15 32
    Paul Jones in his 19th Year 110
    As a Subaltern in the A.S.C. 120

    WAR LETTERS

    OF A

    PUBLIC-SCHOOL BOY

    INTRODUCTORY

    These laid the world away; poured out the red
    Sweet wine of youth; gave up the years to be
    Of work and joy ...
    And those who would have been,
    Their sons, they gave, their immortality.

    RUPERT BROOKE.

    In deciding to publish some of the letters written by the late Lieutenant H. P. M. Jones during his twenty-seven months' service with the British Army, accompanying them with a memoir, I was actuated by a desire, first, to enshrine the memory of a singularly noble and attractive personality; secondly, to describe a career which, though tragically cut short, was yet rich in honourable achievement; thirdly, to show the influence of the Great War on the mind of a public-school boy of high intellectual gifts and sensitive honour, who had shone with equal lustre as a scholar and as an athlete.

    My choice of the title of this book was determined by the frequent allusions made by my son in his war letters to his old school. He spent six and a half years at Dulwich College. His career there was gloriously happy and very distinguished. On the scholastic side, it culminated in December, 1914, in the winning of a scholarship in History and Modern Languages at Balliol College, Oxford; on the athletic side, in his carrying off four silver cups at the Athletic Sports in March, 1915, and tieing for the "Victor Ludorum" shield.

    As a merry, light-hearted boy in his early years at Dulwich, his love for the College was marked. It waxed with every term he spent within its walls. After he left it, that love became a passion, sustained, coloured and glorified by happy memories. Everybody and everything connected with it shared in his glowing affection. Its welfare and reputation were infinitely precious to him. Like a leitmotif in a musical composition, this love of Dulwich College recurs again and again in his war letters.

    Every honour won by a Dulwich boy on the battlefield, in scholarship or in athletics gave him exquisite pleasure. The very last letter he wrote is irradiated with love of the old school. When he joined the Tank Corps, stripping, as it were, for the deadly combat, he sent to the depôt at Boulogne all his impedimenta. But among the few cherished personal possessions that he took with him into the zone of death were two photographs--one of the College buildings, the other of the Playing Fields, this latter depicting the cricket matches on Founder's Day.

    In death as in life Dulwich was close to his heart.

    Paul Jones was a young man of herculean strength--tall, muscular, deep-chested and broad-shouldered. But he had one grave physical defect. He was extremely short-sighted, had worn spectacles habitually from his sixth year and was almost helpless without them. In fact, his vision was not one-twelfth of normal. Much to his chagrin, his myopia excluded him from the Infantry which he tried to enter in the spring of 1915, and he had to put up with a Commission as a subaltern in the Army Service Corps.

    His first three months in the Army were spent at a home port, one of the chief depôts of supply for the British Army in the field. Eagerly embracing the first chance to go abroad, he left Southampton for Havre in the last week of July, 1915. A few days after his arrival in France, he was appointed requisitioning officer to the 9th Cavalry Brigade--a post for the duties of which he was specially qualified by his excellent knowledge of the French language.

    After 11 months in this employment, he was appointed to a Supply Column, and subsequently, during the protracted battles on the Somme, was in command of an ammunition working party. In October, 1916, he was again appointed requisitioning officer, this time to the 2nd Cavalry Brigade.

    Though his duties were often laborious and exacting, his relative freedom from peril and hardship while other men were facing death every day in the trenches sorely troubled his conscience. Feeling that he was not pulling his weight in the war and seeing no prospect of the Cavalry going into action he resolved, at all hazards, to get into the fighting line. After two abortive efforts to transfer from the A.S.C., he succeeded on the third attempt, and was appointed Lieutenant in the Tank Corps, which he joined on 13th February, 1917. His elation at the change was unbounded, and thenceforth his letters home sang with joy.

    He took part as a Tank officer in the battle of Arras in April, and when the great offensive was planned in Flanders he was shifted to that sector. In the battle of 31st July, when advancing with his tank north-east of Ypres, he was killed by a sniper's bullet. He seemed to have had a premonition some days before that death might soon claim him. In a letter to his brother, a Dulwich school boy, dated 27th July, he wrote:

    Have you ever reflected on the fact that, despite the horrors of
    the war, it is at least a big thing? I mean to say that in it one
    is brought face to face with realities. The follies, selfishness,
    luxury and general pettiness of the vile commercial sort of
    existence led by nine-tenths of the people of the world in peace
    time are replaced in war by a savagery that is at least more
    honest and outspoken.

    Look at it this way: in peace time one just
    lives one's own little life, engaged in trivialities, worrying
    about one's own comfort, about money matters, and all that sort
    of thing--just living for one's own self. What a sordid life it
    is! In war, on the other hand, even if you do get killed, you
    only anticipate the inevitable by a few years in any case, and
    you have the satisfaction of knowing that you have "pegged out"
    in the attempt to help your country. You have, in fact, realised
    an ideal, which, as far as I can see, you very rarely do in
    ordinary life.

    The reason is that ordinary life runs on a
    commercial and selfish basis; if you want to "get on," as the
    saying is, you can't keep your hands clean.

    Personally, I often rejoice that the war has come my way. It has
    made me realise what a petty thing life is. I think that the war
    has given to everyone a chance to "get out of himself," as I
    might say. Of course, the other side of the picture is bound to
    occur to the imagination. But there! I have never been one to
    take the more melancholy point of view when there's a silver
    lining to the cloud.

    The eagerness to subordinate self displayed in this letter was very characteristic of its author. He was by nature altruistic, and this propensity was intensified by his career at Dulwich and his experience of athletics, both influences tending to merge the individual in the whole and to subordinate self to the side. Death he had never feared, and he dreaded it less than ever after his experience of campaigning.

    His last letter shows with what serenity of mind he faced the ultimate realities. He greeted the Unseen with a cheer.

    His Commanding Officer, in a letter to us after Paul's death, wrote:

    "No officer of mine was more popular. He was efficient, very keen, and a most gallant gentleman. His crew loved him and would follow him anywhere. He did not know what fear was."

    From the crew of his Tank we received a very sympathetic letter which among other things said:

    "We all loved your son. He was the best officer in our company and never will be replaced by one like him."

    A gunner who served in the same Tank company testified his love and admiration for our son and said that all the men would do anything for him; even the roughest came under his spell.

    A brother officer who served with Paul in the 2nd Cavalry Brigade, in paying homage to his character, wrote: "He was a most interesting and lovable companion and friend. He never seemed to think of himself at all."

    Among the many tributes that reached us were several from the masters, old boys, and present boys at Dulwich College. Several of the writers express the opinion that Paul Jones would, if he had lived, have done great things. Mr. Gilkes, late headmaster of Dulwich, in a touching letter, spoke of the nobility of his character and his high gifts; Mr.

    Smith, the present headmaster, testified to his intellectual power, energy and keenness; Mr. Joerg, master of the Modern Sixth, to his sense of justice, loyalty and truth; Mr. Hope, master of the Classical Sixth, to his high conception of duty, "his sterling qualities and great ability." From the young man who was captain of the school when Paul was head of the Modern Side came this testimony: "He was one of the finest characters of my time at school; in me he inspired all the highest feelings." One of his contemporaries in the Modern Sixth wrote: "I owe more than I can express to your son's influence over me.

    As long as I live I shall never forget him. His spirit is with me always; for it is to him that I owe my first real insight into life."

    A well-known Professor wrote: "I felt sure he was destined to do great things; but he has done greater things; he has done the greatest thing of all." Some of these letters are set forth in full in the Epilogue.

    Appended is a list of events in this rich and strenuous, albeit brief life:

    Born at 6 Cloudesdale Road, Balham, May 18th, 1896.
    Entered Dulwich College, September, 1908.
    Junior Scholarship, Dulwich College, June, 1909.
    Senior Scholarship, Dulwich College, June, 1912.
    Matriculated, with honours, London University, 1911.
    Appointed Prefect at Dulwich, September, 1912.
    Secretary and Treasurer of the College Magazine, 1913-14.
    Editor of The Alleynian, 1914-15.
    Head of the Modern Side, 1913-15.
    Member of 1st XV, 1912-13, 1913-14, 1914-15.
    Hon.

    Secretary 1st XV, 1913-14.
    Captain of Football, 1914-15.
    Won a Balliol Scholarship, December, 1914.
    Tied for "Victor Ludorum" Shield, March, 1915.
    Joined the Army, April, 1915.
    Killed in Action, July 31st, 1917.

    All that was mortal of Paul Jones is buried at a point west of Zonnebeke, north-east of Ypres.

    PART I

    MEMOIR

    [Illustration: Paul Jones as an Infant.]

    CHAPTER I

    CHILDHOOD

    Our birth is but a sleep and a forgetting:
    The Soul that rises with us, our life's Star
    Hath had elsewhere its setting,
    And cometh from afar;
    Not in entire forgetfulness,
    And not in utter nakedness.
    But trailing clouds of glory do we come
    From God, Who is our home.

    WORDSWORTH: "INTIMATIONS OF IMMORTALITY."

    Henry Paul Mainwaring Jones, born in London on May 18, 1896, was the first child of Henry and Emily Margaret Jones. His grandfather, the late Thomas Mainwaring, was in his day a leading figure in literary and political circles in Carmarthenshire. My own people have been associated with that county for centuries. For our son's christening a vessel containing water drawn from the Pool of Bethesda was sent to us by my old friend Sir John Foster Fraser, who in the spring of that year passed through Palestine on his journey by bicycle round the world.

    At this time I was acting editor of The Weekly Sun, a journal then in high repute. Later, at Mr. T. P. O'Connor's request, I took charge of his evening newspaper, The Sun. After the purchase of The Sun by a Conservative proprietary I severed my connection with it, and in January, 1897, went to reside in Plymouth, having undertaken the managing editorship of the Western Daily Mercury.

    We remained at Plymouth more than seven years. Paul received his early education at the Hoe Preparatory School in that town. He was a lively and vigorous child overflowing with health. When he was in his sixth year we discovered that he was shortsighted--a physical defect inherited from me. The discovery caused us acute distress. I knew from personal experience what a handicap and an embarrassment it is to be afflicted with myopia. Regularly thenceforward his eyes had to be examined by oculists.

    For several years, in fact until he was 16, the myopia increased in degree, but we were comforted by successive reports of different oculists that though myopic his eyes were very strong, and that there was not a trace of disease in them, the defect being solely one of structure which glasses would correct.

    To Paul as a boy the habitual wearing of spectacles was at first very irksome, but in time he adapted himself to them. Even defects have their compensations. He was naturally rash and daring, and his short sight undoubtedly acted as a check on an impetuous temperament. He early gave signs of unusual intelligence. His activity of body was as remarkable as his quickness of mind. At play and at work, with his toys as with his books, he displayed the same intensity; he could do nothing by halves. There never was a merrier boy. His vivacity and energy and the gaiety of his spirit brightened everybody around him.

    When he bounded or raced into a room he seemed to bring with him a flood of sunshine.

    From his childhood he gave evidences of an unselfish nature and a desire to avoid giving trouble. He had his share of childish ailments, but always made light of them and bore discomfort with a sunny cheerfulness; his invariable reply, if he were ill and one asked how he fared, was "Much better; I'm all right, thanks." Marked traits in him as a small boy were truthfulness, generosity and sensitiveness. In a varied experience of the world I have never met anyone in whom love of truth was more deeply ingrained.

    On one occasion in his twelfth year, when he was wrestling with an arithmetical problem--the only branch of learning that ever gave him trouble was mathematics--and I offered to help in its solution, he rejected my proffered aid with the indignant remark: "Dad, how could I hand this prep. in as my own if you had helped me to do it?" His generosity of spirit was displayed in his eagerness to share his toys and books with other children; his sensitiveness by his acute self-reproaches if he had been unkind to anyone or had caused pain to his mother or his nurse.

    Plymouth is a fine old city, beautifully situated and steeped in historic memories. Our home was in Carlisle Avenue, just off the Hoe, and on that spacious front Paul spent many happy hours as a small boy.

    His young eyes gazed with fascination on the warships passing in and out of Plymouth Sound, on the great passenger steamers lying at anchor inside the Breakwater, or steaming up or down the Channel; on the fishing fleet, with its brown sails, setting out to reap the harvest of the sea; and when daylight faded in the short winter days he would watch the Eddystone light--that diamond set in the forehead of England--flashing its warning and greeting to "those who go down to the sea in ships and do business in great waters." Always from the Hoe there is something to captivate the eye--the wonder and beauty of the unresting ocean; on the Cornish side the wooded slopes and green sward of Mount Edgcumbe; on the Devon side Staddon Height, rising bold and sheer from the water; looking landward the picturesque mass of houses, towers, spires, turrets that is Plymouth, and far behind the outline of the Dartmoor Hills.

    On the Hoe itself one's historic memories are stirred by the Armada memorial and the Drake statue; close at hand is the Citadel, the snout of guns showing through its embrasures; and near by is Sutton Pool, whence the Pilgrim Fathers set forth in the little Mayflower, carrying the English language and the principles of civil and religious liberty across the stormy Atlantic.

    All these sights and scenes and historical associations had their influence on a bright and ardent boy in these impressionable years. He soon got to be keenly interested in the Navy, amassed a surprising amount of information about the types, engine strength and gun-power of the principal warships, and found delight in making models of cruisers and torpedo-boats.

    The Army in those days made no appeal to him, though he was familiar with military sights and sounds--the ceremonious displays that take place from time to time in a garrison town, bugles blowing, the crunch of feet on the gravel in the barrack square, and the tramp, tramp of marching men. It was to the Navy that his heart went out. The natural set of his mind to the Navy was encouraged by the accident that his first school prize was Southey's "Life of Nelson"--a book that inspired him with hero-worship for the illustrious admiral.

    [Illustration: Paul in his 6th Year.]

    On Saturday afternoons, whenever weather permitted, it was my custom to roam with Paul over the pleasant environs of Plymouth. We would visit Plympton or Plym Bridge, Roborough Down or Ivybridge, Tavistock or Princetown, for a tramp on Dartmoor. Or we would go by water to Newton, Yealmpton, Salcombe, or Calstock, or cross by the ferry to Mount Edgcumbe for Penlee Point, with its marvellous seaward view. He was an excellent walker and a most delightful little companion, keenly interested in all he saw, and absorbing eagerly the beauty of earth and sea and sky.

    No wonder he had happy memories of the West country and that his mind retained clear images of Plymouth, the sea, and gracious, beautiful Devon!

    In the summer of 1904 I returned to London, having accepted an appointment on the editorial staff of the Daily Chronicle. Paul, who had left his first school with high commendation, was entered in September at Brightlands Preparatory School, Dulwich Common. There he remained four years, during which he made rapid strides in knowledge.

    His first report said: "Is very keen and has brains above the average; conduct and work excellent; extremely quick and a splendid worker.

    Doing very well in Classics, and making marvellous progress in French." From later reports the following expressions are taken: "Keen in the extreme, and a hard worker; a marvellously retentive memory." "His work has been superlatively good; conduct excellent; drawing poor; written work marred by blots and smudges." "Developing very much; thoroughly deserves his prizes; his work is neater; composition and geography excellent; and even in mathematics no boy has improved more; now plays very keenly in games." "He is making splendid progress with his Greek; gets flustered in Mathematics when difficulties appear." Paul won numerous prizes at Brightlands for Classics, English, French, General Knowledge, Reading, Athletics, and was almost invariably top of his form.

    He left the Preparatory School after the summer term, 1908.

    CHAPTER II

    AT DULWICH COLLEGE

    Ah! happy years! once more who would not be a boy?

    BYRON: "CHILDE HAROLD."

    Our son entered Dulwich College in September, 1908, when he was twelve years of age, and remained a member of it until March, 1915. These six and a half years had a powerful influence on the development of his character, which flowered beautifully in this congenial atmosphere.

    The most famous school in South London, Dulwich College has a notable history. It was founded through the munificence of Edward Alleyn, theatre-proprietor and actor, a contemporary, an acquaintance, and probably a friend of Shakespeare.

    At the inaugural dinner in September, 1619, to celebrate the foundation of Alleyn's "College of God's gift," an illustrious company was present, including the Lord Chancellor, Francis Bacon, "the greatest and the meanest of mankind," then at the summit of his fame but soon to fall in disgrace from his high eminence; Inigo Jones, the famous architect, who in that year was superintending the erection of the new Banqueting Hall in Whitehall; and other distinguished men.

    Since its foundation the College has passed through many vicissitudes.

    With the development of building on the estate the income rapidly expanded in the nineteenth century. In 1857 the charity was reorganised and the trust varied by Act of Parliament. The present school buildings were opened in 1870. The old college--including the chapel (containing the pious founder's tomb), almshouses and the offices of the estate governors--remains in Dulwich Village, a very picturesque and well-preserved structure embowered in trees.

    At its rear is the celebrated Picture Gallery, the nucleus of which was a collection of pictures originally intended to grace the palace of Stanislaus, the last King of Poland. The new college buildings have a delightful situation. All around them are wide stretches of green fields; here and there pleasant hedgerows; on the slopes of Sydenham Hill charming woodlands, some of them a veritable sanctuary for bird-life.

    In the spring-time the whole neighbourhood is musical with the song of birds, and one is often thrilled by the rich haunting note of the cuckoo. On the fringes of the playing-fields and round about the boarding-houses are magnificent trees--chiefly elm, beech, birch and chestnut, more rarely oak. In short, the surroundings of the college have a thoroughly rural aspect. It is an ideal environment for the training of boys. There is nothing in this sylvan and pastoral beauty to suggest that we are in a great city.

    Dulwich College is both a boarding school and a day school, the boarders numbering about 120 and the day-boys about 550. When Paul Jones entered the college as a day-boy in 1908 the Headmaster was Mr.

    A. H. Gilkes, who retired after the summer term of 1914. Our son, therefore, had the good fortune to come under the influence for six years of one of the greatest public-school masters of our generation.

    A former colleague of mine, Mr. Henry W. Nevinson, used to speak to me in glowing terms of Mr. Gilkes, who was a master at Shrewsbury School when he was a boy there, and I note that the Rev. Dr. Horton in his "Autobiography" alludes to him as "the master at Shrewsbury to whom I owed most." Undoubtedly Mr. Gilkes's best work was done as Headmaster of Dulwich. The College has never known a greater head. Under him the whole place was revivified. During his reign not only did a fine moral tone characterise the school, but there was equal enthusiasm for work and games.

    Thanks to a commanding personality, in which strength, dignity and graciousness were subtly mingled, the influence of Mr.

    Gilkes pervaded the whole school from the highest to the lowest forms.

    Paul quickly recognised the nobility of the "Old Man," as he was universally known to the boys. His affection for him amounted to veneration, and however brief the leave he had from the Army he always found time to pay his old headmaster a visit. On his part Mr. Gilkes had a great regard for our son, whom with sure perception he described as "fearless, strong and capable, with a heart as soft and kind as a heart can be."

    A new boy's early days in a public school are often trying. He is in a strange world with its own laws and customs; and at the outset he has to endure the scrutiny of curious and often hostile eyes. Our son's marked idiosyncrasies, sturdy independence, fastidious refinement and passion for work, singled him out from his fellows as an original. As boys resent any deviation from the normal, he had a rough time until he found his feet, and the experience was repeated as he moved up to new forms.

    Not a word about all this escaped his lips at home; I have ascertained it from others. Stories reached me of personal combats from which he usually emerged the victor, and of one prolonged fight with an older boy that had at last to be drawn. In the end Paul won through; his pluck and strength compelled a respect that would have been refused to his intellectual gifts. His tormentors realised that he was not a mere "swot," that he had fists and knew how to use them.

    Animosity was also disarmed by his chivalric spirit. He began his career at Dulwich in the Classical Lower IV. In June, 1909, he won a Junior Scholarship, which freed him from school fees for three years, and in 1912 a Senior Scholarship of the same nature. When he was in the Classical Lower Fifth (1909), his form master, Mr. H. V. Doulton reported:

    "He is a boy of great promise and will make an excellent scholar. He has marked aptitude for classical work, and success in the great public examinations may be predicted for him with absolute confidence." "Painstaking and anxious to do well, but rather slow," was the verdict of his mathematical teacher.

    In the summer term, 1910, Paul changed over from the Classical to the Modern side of the school. I was averse to the change, and his Classical form-master dissuaded him against it. But once Paul's mind was made up nothing would break his resolution: he had a strong and tenacious will. His main desire in transferring to the Modern side was to study English literature and modern languages thoroughly. He never regretted the change. As he grew older the firmer became his conviction that Classics were overdone in the public schools.

    Even in a school responsive to the spirit of the age like Dulwich, which has Modern, Science, and Engineering sides, the primacy still belongs to Classics, and the captaincy of the school is rigidly confined to boys on the Classical side. My son believed that this bias for Classics was bad educationally. He thought the prestige given to Greek and Latin as compared with English Literature, Science, Modern Languages and History was simply the outcome of a pedantic scholastic tradition, which made for narrowness not for broad culture.

    With him it was not a case of making a virtue of necessity, as he had real aptitude for Greek and Latin. But he wanted the windows of our public schools to be cleared of mediæval cobwebs and flung wide open to the fresh breezes of the modern world.

    In the report for the last term of 1910, when he was in the Modern Upper V, he was described as "a very capable boy with great abilities." The next report, when he was in the Remove, complained of his "frivolous attitude" in the Physics classes, but "otherwise he has worked well and made good progress." In June, 1911, he passed the Senior School Examination with honours, winning distinction in English, French and Latin--a remarkable achievement for a boy who had only just turned fifteen.

    Owing to his being under age, the London Matriculation certificate in respect of this examination was not forwarded until he had reached sixteen. "Considering that he is only fifteen," wrote Mr. J. A. Joerg, his form-master, "it should be deemed a great honour for him to have passed in the First Division; it does him much credit." Mr. Boon, who prepared him in mathematics, testified that Paul had "worked with interest and energy" at what was for him an uncongenial subject.

    He entered the Sixth Form in September, 1911, being then fifteen and a half years old; the form average was seventeen years. In 1912 his reports showed that he was making all-round progress, and was applying himself with zest to a new subject, Logic. In the summer term, 1913, he was first in form order--1st in English, 2nd in Latin, 3rd in French, 4th in German.

    Though specialising in History, he retained his position as head of the Modern side until he left school, with one interval in the summer term of 1914, when he had to take second place, recovering the headship next term. In order to have a clear road to Oxford University, he qualified in Greek at the London Matriculation Examination, January, 1914. During his Dulwich career he won many prizes, most of which took the form of historical works. As will appear later, he played as whole-heartedly in games as he worked at his books.

    History was a subject to which he was instinctively drawn, and in 1913 he began preparing definitely for an Oxford University scholarship. He read thoroughly and covered a wide field. In addition to the systematic study of History, he touched the fringes of philosophy and political economy. He was helped in his studies by a very retentive memory.

    One of his schoolfellows said to me, "Paul has only to read a book once and it is for ever imprinted on his mind." Among the historical writers whom he read during his eighteen months' preparation were: Gibbon, Carlyle, Macaulay, Hallam, Guizot, Michelet, Thiers, Bluntschli, Maine, Froude, Bagehot, Seeley, Maitland, Stubbs, Gardiner, Acton, John Morley, Bryce, Dicey, Tout, Mahan, Holland Rose, G. M. Trevelyan, Hilaire Belloc and H. W. C. Davis. Two recent books that gave him special pleasure were Mr. G. P. Gooch's masterly "History of Historians" and Mr.

    F. S. Marvin's entrancing little work "The Living Past."

    His hard reading was crowned in December, 1914, by a considerable achievement, for he won the coveted Brakenbury Scholarship in History and Modern Languages at Balliol College, Oxford. This scholarship, worth £80 per annum, is tenable for four years; to it subsequently Dulwich College added an exhibition of the annual value of £20. He was the first Balliol scholar in history from Dulwich. Not at all confident that he had won the Brakenbury, he went up to Oxford a second time, while the result of the Balliol examination was still unknown, to try for a less exacting scholarship.

    Happily there was no necessity for him to undergo this second test, as he found on his arrival at Oxford that his name had just been posted as a Brakenbury scholar.

    When he went up, in the last week in November, 1914, for examination at Balliol College, it was his first visit to Oxford. Short as was his stay within its precincts, it was long enough for the glamour and beauty of the venerable university to steal into his soul; and the spell of it remained with him as a permanent possession. In spite of examination anxieties he had a pleasant time at Oxford, as the following letter shows:

    THE OLD PARSONAGE,

    OXFORD,

    December 1st, 1914.

    Everything going as well as could be anticipated. But I don't
    expect to win the Brakenbury, so there can't be much of a
    disappointment. I have done one paper already, the
    essay--subject, "A Nation's character as expressed in its Art and
    Literature." I think I got on fairly well. The papers end by
    Thursday afternoon. I was round with all the Dulwich fellows in
    Wetenhall's rooms at Worcester College last night, and had a
    great time.

    Cartwright came across, and a lot of other O.A.'s.
    To-night I am dining with Gover, an old friend of mine, in hall
    at Balliol, and going on to his rooms afterwards. I am booked for
    brekker and dinner to-morrow. Dulwich is a magic name here; if
    you add "captain of football" all doors fly open to you.
    Altogether I don't feel I am up for a scholarship at all--a good
    thing, for it prevents my getting nervous.

    Of the many congratulations on his success in winning a Balliol scholarship, none granted him more than a letter from an "Old Alleynian," who wrote:

    My very best congratters on the fresh laurel with which you have
    adorned your crown of victory. A Balliol scholarship for four
    years, and this to have been secured by the captain of a public
    school 1st XV that has won four out of its five great school
    matches! My dear Paul, you have done splendidly. I don't remember
    during my time such a happy combination of work and play.

    Mr. Llewelyn Williams, K.C., M.P., himself an Oxford history scholar, wrote: "Paul's brilliant success warmed even my old heart. Tell him from me I hope when he is a Don he will write the History of Wales."

    Paul was appointed a prefect at Dulwich in 1912. He participated in every phase of school life and was devoted to athletics. In cricket he was quick and adroit as a fielder, but he had no skill either as a batsman--doubtless owing to his visual defect--or as a bowler. Very fond of swimming, he was a regular visitor to the college swimming bath. He had great endurance in the water, but lacked speed, and much to his disappointment failed to get his swimming colours. His love of swimming never waned, and in the sea he would swim long distances.

    Swimming brought him an ecstasy of physical and moral exhilaration. He could say with Byron:

    I have loved thee, Ocean! and my joy
    Of youthful sports was on thy breast to be
    Borne, like thy bubbles, onward.

    Lawn tennis is discouraged at Dulwich, but Paul became adept in this pastime, thanks to games on the lawn attached to our house. In the whole range of athletics nothing gave him so much pleasure and satisfaction as Rugby football. Too massive in build to be a swift runner, and unable owing to his defective vision to give or take "passes" with quick precision, he was not suited to the three-quarter line; but as a forward he made a reputation second to none of his contemporaries in public-school football. He played for the College 1st XV in three successive seasons, during which he was not once "crocked," nor did he miss a single match.

    His success in football was an illustration of how a resolute will can triumph over a hampering physical defect.

    In the autumn of 1913 he was offered a house scholarship, which would have meant residence in one of the boarding-houses. Without hesitation he declined what was at once an honour and a privilege, preferring to remain a day-boy. He dearly loved his home, and his opinion was that the advantages of public-school training were much enhanced when combined with home life. His custom was to ride to the College on his bicycle in the morning, stay there for dinner and return home in the evening between 6 and 7 o'clock, the hours following afternoon school being devoted to games, the gymnasium, or some other form of physical training.

    In 1914 he was elected Captain of the 1st XV. No distinction he ever won--and there were many--gratified him more. In a great public school the duties that devolve on a captain of football are laborious and responsible. They entail many hours of work weekly, the careful compilation of lists of players for the numerous school teams, a vigilant oversight of training and a watchful eye for budding talent.

    But Paul loved the work, and love lightens labour. He threw himself into the duties with all the enthusiasm of his nature. The amount of time he was devoting to football in September and October made me doubtful of his ability to carry off a Balliol scholarship in December. Accordingly I suggested that he might relinquish the captaincy temporarily, say for a month, so as to allow him freedom to concentrate on his history reading before the examination. He would not listen to the suggestion. He said he meant to fulfil the duties of captain to the uttermost.

    If this jeopardised his chances for a scholarship he would be sorry, but whatever the cost he was not going to fall short in his work as captain of football. In the result he brought off the double event, winning the scholarship and leading his team with shining success.

    [Illustration: Winning the Mile, March 27, 1915.]

    His athletic career culminated at the school sports on March 27, 1915, when he won the mile flat race, the half-mile, and the steeplechase, and was awarded the silver cup for the best forward in the 1st XV. He tied for the "Victor Ludorum" shield with his friend S. J. Hannaford (a versatile athlete reported missing in France, September, 1917). These successes at the sports were a dazzling finish to Paul's school days. He bore them, like his scholastic triumphs, very modestly, but in his heart he was proud and happy.

    It was not his nature to plume himself on any achievement. Only once do I remember his betraying pride in what he had accomplished. It is the custom in Dulwich to inscribe on the walls of the great hall the names of boys who distinguish themselves on entering or leaving the Universities and the Army. In due time the ten Oxford scholars of 1914 were walled. During his first leave from the Army Paul revisited the old school, and I recollect his telling me that the names of those who had won scholarships at Oxford had been duly painted in hall.

    "My name is placed first," he said with a smile; adding with emphasis, "and so it ought to be."

    It was his hope that his own success would give a stimulus to the study of history at Dulwich. In 1916, when he learnt that another Dulwich boy was thinking of preparing for a Balliol scholarship in history, he wrote to me from France, requesting that his notes, memoranda, essays and books should be placed at the student's disposal. He added in reference to a matter on which I had asked his opinion:

    The education you get from a correspondence course is of a kind
    which, while useful for acquiring a knowledge of facts, is of
    very little value in the development of that culture which is the
    first and essential element in obtaining a 'Varsity--above all, a
    Balliol--scholarship. If a boy decides to go in for a history
    scholarship, the Dulwich authorities ought to provide him with
    adequate tutorship as part of his school training. Were the boy
    to go to an outside institution, the school would lose part of
    the honour gained by the winning of the scholarship.

    But
    remember that no one would have the ghost of a chance for an
    Oxford scholarship on the knowledge gained from a correspondence
    course taken by itself. Finally, any honour gained by a Dulwich
    boy ought to redound to the credit of Dulwich; the school alone
    should have the credit of the achievements of its members.

    From masters and boys I learnt that my son's influence was specially marked in his last two years at the College. It was an influence that was always thrown on the side of what was lovely, pure and of good report. Frank, free-spirited, open-hearted, his buoyancy and his rich capacity for laughter diffused an atmosphere of cheerfulness; his unflagging enthusiasm stimulated interest in athletics; his love of learning and passion for work were contagious; his high ideals of conduct helped to set the tone in morals and manners.

    The qualities he most prized in boys were courage, purity, veracity. No one loved books more, but book-learning by itself he placed low on the list. To use his own words: "It is character and personality that tell." Purity in deed and thought was with him a constant aspiration. He reverenced the body as the temple of the Holy Spirit. From the ordeal of the difficult years between 14 and 16 he emerged like refined gold. A boy he was

    With rosy cheeks
    Angelical, keen eye, courageous look,
    And conscious step of purity and pride.

    His serene and radiant air was witness to a soul at peace with itself.

    Things coarse and impure fled from his presence. It was the union in him of moral elevation with physical courage that explained the secret of his remarkable influence in school.

    At Dulwich the school year is full and various. In addition to the acquisition of knowledge there is much else to engage a boy's interest--cricket, football, fives, swimming, the gymnasium, athletic competitions, the choir; and then those red-letter days--Founder's Day, with its Greek, French or German play, the Prize Distribution and the Concerts. Our son bore his share in every phase of this varied life.

    He had a warm corner in his heart for the College Mission, which maintains a home in Walworth for boys without friends or relatives and enables them to be trained as skilled artisans. The home has accommodation for twenty-one boys; a married couple look after the house work, and two old Alleynians are in residence. He never failed after he left the College to send an annual subscription anonymously to the Mission funds. An enthusiastic lover of music, he was for years in the College Choir, singing latterly with the basses.

    At the 1913 Founder's Day celebration Paul took a subsidiary part, that of Fitzwater, in a scene from Shakespeare's Richard II, on which occasion the King was brilliantly impersonated by E. F. Clarke (killed in action, April, 1917). On the same occasion Paul was one of the voyageurs in the scenes from Le Voyage de Monsieur Perrichon, his amusing by-play in that modest rôle sending the junior school into roars of laughter. At the 1914 celebration of Founder's Day he took the part of Fluellen in a scene from Henry V, and sustained a very different rôle, that of Karl der Sieberite, in a scene from Schiller's Jungfrau von Orleans.

    Reviewing the performances, The Alleynian said of the former: "In this piece Jones was the comedian. He was clumsy and not quite at home on the boards, but his Welsh was delightful."

    Of his performances as Charles VII in Schiller's play the critic wrote:

    The scene chosen is one of the most powerful scenes in the play.
    It is that in which the King, sceptical of the divine
    inspiration of the Maid, determines to test her by substituting a
    courtier upon his throne.... When she is not only not deceived,
    but proceeds also to interpret many of the King's innermost
    thoughts, the surprise of the monarch, passing into hushed
    reverence, calls for a studied piece of careful acting. H. P. M.
    Jones sustained this part, and sustained it well.

    He gave it the
    dignity which it needed, and if his natural gift of physical
    stature helped him somewhat, so also did the smooth diction and
    easy repose which he had evidently been at pains to acquire.

    Of the performance as a whole: "It says a very great deal for the German in the upper part of the school, that a scene can be enacted in which both accent and acting can reach so high a level."

    The school year at Dulwich always closes with a concert at which the music, thanks to the competent leadership of Mr. H. V. Doulton, is of a high order. The solos of the two school songs on 19th December, 1914, were sung by H. P. M. Jones and H. Edkins, both of them Oxford scholars who have since been killed in action. Edkins, who had a rich baritone voice, sang the song in praise of Edward Alleyn, the pious founder. My son, as captain of football, sang the football song, the first and last verses of which are appended:

    Rain and wind and hidden sun,
    Wild November weather,
    Muddy field and leafless tree
    Bare of fur or feather.
    Sweeps there be who scorn the game,
    On them tons of soot fall!
    All Alleynians here declare
    Nought like Rugby football.

    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    Broken heads and bleeding shins!
    What's the cause for sorrow?
    Shut your mouth and grin the more,
    Plaster-time to-morrow.
    Young or old this shall remain
    Still your favourite story:
    Fifteen fellows fighting-full,
    Out for death or glory.

    After each stanza the choir and the whole school rolled in with the chorus, proclaiming in stentorian voices that "the Blue and Black" (these being the Dulwich football colours) shall win the day. My wife and I were present at this concert, and there is a vivid image before us of our son, a tall, powerful figure in evening dress, standing on the platform in front of the choir, his eager face now following the conductor's bâton, now glancing at the music-score, now looking in his forthright way at the audience.

    The reception that greeted him when he stepped on to the platform must have thrilled every fibre of his being; another rapturous outburst of cheers acclaimed him as he retired to his place in the choir. Those cheers, loud, shrill and clear, with that poignant note that there often is in boyish voices, still resound in our ears. We had heard that Paul was popular at Dulwich: we had ocular and audible testimony of it on this unforgettable night. Those had not exaggerated who told us that he was the hero of the school.

    CHAPTER III

    FOOTBALL

    Play it long and play it hard
    Till the game is ended.

    DULWICH FOOTBALL SONG.

    The earliest reference to Paul as a footballer appears in The Alleynian's report of a match, "Boarders v. School," played on September 25, 1912, when the School won by 32 points to 21. "Jones," says the reporter, "presented an awesome sight." His first appearance in the 1st XV was against London Hospitals "A" in October. Singling him out for honourable mention, the critic says: "Jones displayed any amount of go." He was awarded his 1st XV colours after the match against Bedford School at Bedford in November.

    In this hard-fought game Bedford led at half-time by 15 points to 5, and 25 minutes before the close of play the score was in Bedford's favour by 28 to 5. Then, by a wonderful rally, Dulwich scored 23 points in almost as many minutes, the match finally being drawn 28-28. In The Alleynian for February, 1913, Paul is thus described in the article, "First XV Characters":

    A young, heavy and extremely energetic forward. Puts all he knows
    into his play, and is a great worker in the scrum. In the loose,
    however, a lot of his energy is somewhat misdirected, and he has
    an alarming tendency for getting off-side.

    [Illustration: Dulwich College 1st XV, 1914-15, of which Paul Jones was Captain.

    From left to right, top Row: H. C. Jensen, M. Z. Ariffin, E. A. F.

    Hawke, R. L. Paton, J. Paget, J. F. G. Schlund, J. M. Cat, G. H.

    Gilkes. Middle Row: A. H. H. Gilligan, L. W. Franklin, H. P. M.

    Jones, L. Minot, R. S. Hellier. On Ground: C. A. R. Hoggan, S. H.

    Killick.]

    In the 1913-14 season, a daily newspaper, describing the hard-fought Sherborne v. Dulwich match, said: "H. P. M. Jones worked like a Trojan for the losers, his Pillmanesque hair being seen in the thick of everything." That season Paul had charge of the Junior games.

    He had a way with small boys, and soon fired them with his own zeal.

    In an article in The Alleynian for December, 1913, giving counsel to the juniors, he wrote:

    You must not gas so much on the field, but play the game as hard
    as it can be played. Except in rare circumstances, the only
    players who are to shout are the captain, the scrum-half, and the
    leader of the forwards. Forwards must learn to pack low and shove
    straight and hard. Three-quarters must remember not to run across
    too much, and never to pass the ball when standing still.

    There are other useful hints. Looking upon the junior games as the seed-bed for future crops of 1st XV players, he devoted a great deal of time and patience to teaching the youngsters how to play. In addition to matches with other schools and clubs, a feature of the football season at Dulwich are the side-games. Paul played in three seasons for the Modern Sixth and Remove, and was captain of the victorious team in the side-contests, 1914-15. House matches of which he was only a spectator he often reported for The Alleynian.

    It was at a meeting of the Field Sports Board on July 28, 1914, that Paul Jones was elected captain of the 1st XV, being proposed by A. W.

    Fischer and seconded by A. E. R. Gilligan. At the same meeting R. B.

    B. Jones was elected captain of the gymnasium. Fischer, Basil Jones and my son have been killed in the War. In a report of a meeting of the Field Sports Board held on September 29 appears the following: "H.

    P. M. Jones then submitted a code of rules to regulate the management of the school games. These were unanimously approved." In a survey of the prospects of the 1914-15 football season which appeared in the October Alleynian, Paul paid tribute to the magnificent work done for football in Dulwich by one of the masters, Mr. W. D. Gibbon, an old International, who joined the Army shortly after the outbreak of war and is now Lieutenant-Colonel. Paul wrote:

    The loss of Mr. Gibbon is a staggering-blow. He it is who, more
    than anyone, has given us the very high place we hold among
    Rugby-playing schools. To lose his services is disastrous. Still,
    it would be shameful to grouse over his departure considering
    that he goes to serve his country. Rather let us congratulate him
    on his captaincy in the Worcestershires.

    A reformer by temperament, my son was determined to improve the forward play during his captaincy, as he believed that not enough attention had been given to the forwards for several seasons at Dulwich. It was inevitable that the War would derange the football programme, but though there would be few club matches, the new captain thought that the "school games" might benefit from this very lack.

    Anyhow it was "a unique chance to build them up on a sound basis." He believed in doing everything to encourage in-school football, meaning by that the half-holiday games, the side-matches, cup matches, and such games as Prefects v. School, Boarders v. School, the House matches, etc. He realised that the first three XV's only include 45 boys, and that there were 600 others whose claims to consideration were equally great. Moreover, good in-school football would produce a succession of players for the first XV.

    Having all this in mind, in his article in The Alleynian he exhorted the game captains to instil "a general keenness" and to do their duty unselfishly and enthusiastically. His survey then proceeds:

    Now as to the teams. In the first place, let it be said at once
    that the outsides are going to be fine this year. Franklin and A.
    H. H. Gilligan, the "star" wings of last year's team, and Minôt,
    undoubtedly the best of the centres, remain to us. Franklin is
    faster than of yore, and still goes down the right touch-line
    like a miniature thunderbolt, brushing aside the opposition like
    so many flies.

    If he is the thunderbolt, Gilligan, on the other
    wing, is undoubtedly the "greased lightning"; we have not seen so
    fast a school wing for years, and his newly acquired swerve makes
    him all the more dangerous. Minôt has quite mastered the art of
    passing; we have rarely seen "transfers" made so accurately and
    so artistically. He can cut through when required, and altogether
    should make Gilligan a splendid partner. All these three defend
    stoutly. We are also fortunate in retaining the services of Paton
    (2nd XV) for the other centre position; he only wants a little
    more judgment to be quite first-class.

    At half, Evans and A. E. R. Gilligan have left a terrible gap.
    But again fortune is on our side, as we have in Killick (2nd XV)
    a worthy successor to the latter--very quick off the mark, and an
    excellent giver and taker of passes; while Jensen (2nd XV) shows
    promise of becoming a really "class" scrum worker. At present his
    chief fault is inaccuracy of direction, but that will soon
    vanish. Both these halves are excellent in defence. Again, Hooker
    (3rd XV) is a very useful scrum half, but slow in attack.

    For the
    full-back position we have that wily old veteran Ariffin (2nd
    XV), whose kicking has distinctly improved since last year. He
    tackles as well as ever. Sellick (3rd XV) is a useful back, but
    weak in defence.

    So, gentlemen, outside the scrum all is well. But what of the
    scrum itself? This, we don't deny, is going to be a difficult
    problem. It is not that there isn't plenty of good stuff. Hellier
    and Gilkes (2nd XV), Hoggan, Schlund, Cat and Fischer (all 3rd
    XV)--here is the nucleus of a fine pack, not to mention a host of
    hefty and keen fellows as yet without colours. But the difficulty
    lies in the traditions of the past. Since 1912, our forwards have
    steadily deteriorated as our backs have got better and better.

    It
    was always the way last year that, if we had a ground wet to any
    degree, we were as good as beaten--look at the Easter term, for
    example. Also, the helplessness of the forwards threw a lot too
    much work on the outsides. This has got to be stopped. You can't
    always get weather to suit your team's outsides. We must learn
    how to play a forward game when it's necessary. We must learn
    to screw, to wheel, to shove and to rush. We repeat, the
    individuals are there, but they have to be trained into a
    combination.

    The outsides are so brilliant that they can be
    trusted faithfully to fulfil the work of passing and open-side
    attack.

    Our chief efforts this year must be directed to the training of
    the forwards: (1) to play a truer forward game; (2) and not to
    forget how to attack and adopt open-side tactics when necessary.
    Once the teams have re-learnt these lessons, the games will
    automatically do so. In the days of Jordan, Mackinnon and Green
    we won as many matches by our forwards as by our outsides. It is
    fatuous to develop one division at the expense of the other. The
    outsides are going this season to receive all possible attention,
    but so are the forwards.

    Paul carried out thoroughly the policy here foreshadowed. As a consequence forward play at Dulwich was absolutely transformed, and the impulse he gave to it survives to this day. Under his captaincy the 1st XV had a brilliantly successful season, winning four out of five of the great school matches, viz.:

    Dulwich v. Merchant Taylors; won 6 points to 5.
    " v. Sherborne, won 39 points to 9.
    " v. St. Paul's, lost 16 points to 28.
    " v. Bedford, won 30 points to 16.
    " v. Haileybury, won 36 points to 2.

    With the exception of 1909-10, when Dulwich won all its school matches, this 1914-15 record during Paul's captaincy was the best for a dozen years. Of the football in the school generally the captain, writing in the December Alleynian, said: "Such a uniform standard of keenness has rarely been witnessed. For this I have to thank the Games Captains most sincerely. They have done their part most loyally and unselfishly. The next few years will prove the value of their work."

    [Illustration: Dulwich Modern Side XV, 1914-15, Captained by Paul Jones.

    From left to right, Top Row: C. F. N. Ambrose, W. B. Jellett, B. A.

    J. Mills, G. Walker, C. R. Mountain. Second Row, J. C. Corrie, R. W.

    Mills, G. Roederwald, L. Paton, H. V. Morlock. Seated: R. L. Paton, A.

    H. H. Gilligan, H. P. M. Jones, C. A. R. Hoggan, J. F. G. Schlund. On Ground: L. A. Hotchkiss, R. A. Mayne.]

    In a review of the 1st XV characters in The Alleynian for February, 1915, appeared the following:

    H. P. M. Jones (captain) (1912-13-14-15) (12 st. 6 lb.).
    Forward.--One of the keenest captains Dulwich has ever produced.
    An untiring and zealous worker both in the game and organisation,
    from which he has produced one of the finest packs Dulwich has
    seen in recent years. He uses every ounce of his weight to
    advantage, and his knowledge of the game is beyond reproach. He
    is sound in defence, and in the open wherever the ball is you
    will find him. We shall all greatly miss him, but will remember
    that his valuable work for the forwards will mean much to the
    school in the future. (Forward Challenge Cup.)

    On February 6 he had the gratification of avenging the defeat by St.

    Paul's in the previous November, Dulwich this time being victorious over the Paulines by 39 to nil. With this victory he regarded his work as captain of football finished, though he played in the side-games until March. In spite of the difficulties caused by the war, the season had been a triumphant one. An old member of the 1st XV, Lieut. A. E. R. Gilligan, writing from his regiment, congratulated Paul on "the magnificent record of the team--a record which reflects the utmost credit on its captain. Without your keenness and energy the side would have been a poor one." Lieut. Gilligan added: "To have beaten St. Paul's was absolutely a crowning effort.

    All the 'O.A.'s' here are overjoyed at our victory. It is simply splendid, and makes up for the defeat of last term. Best congratulations to all the gallant team and to its victorious captain."

    Paul's football enthusiasm inspired him on one occasion to attempt a metrical description of a match between Bedford and Dulwich. The nature of this poetical effusion may be gauged by the following quotations:

    In November, month of drabness,
    Month of mud and month of wetness,
    Came the red-shirted Bedfordians,
    Came the lusty Midland schoolmen,
    Skilled in every wile of football,
    Swift to run, adept to collar,
    'Gainst the Blue-and-Blacks to battle.
    Know ye that this famous contest
    Has from age to age endured:
    Thirty years and more it's lasted
    'Twixt Bedfordians and Dulwich,
    'Twixt the Midlanders and Southrons.

    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    Behold the game now well in progress;
    See the dashing Dulwich outsides,
    Swift as leopards, brave as lions,
    Down the field come running strongly--
    See the fleet right-wing three-quarter
    Darting through the ranks of Bedford,
    Handing off his fierce opponents,
    Scoring now 'mid deaf'ning uproar,
    'Mid wild shouts of "Well played, Dulwich!"
    'Mid the sweetest of confusion.

    He followed with close attention the exploits of the chief Rugby clubs, especially those hailing from South Wales. His sympathies were with Wales in the international games. These international matches enthralled him, and he was a spectator whenever possible of those that were played in the vicinity of London. One of his ambitions was some day to don the scarlet jersey with the Prince of Wales's plume and play for Wales in international contests. To achieve that distinction and to win his football "blue" for Oxford--these were cherished ambitions which but for the War would doubtless have been realised.

    In the spring of 1915, interviewed by a London football editor, he explained how Dulwich had built up its great football reputation. Much of the success he attributed to the system of training.

    We do not divide the school into so many "houses," as they do
    elsewhere, but into "games." We have no fewer than eight senior
    games, which means eight groups of players, about thirty in each
    group; and these are selected so that boys of about the same age
    and weight will meet each other. When we have arranged our games,
    one of the Colours--1st XV men--is told off to coach. Sometimes
    we play as many as nine XV's in one day.

    With the first team we
    practise what are called "set-pieces." One day we will take the
    forwards, get the scrum properly formed, practise hooking,
    heeling and screwing. We have devoted a lot of attention to
    wheeling. We also practise hand-to-hand passing among the
    forwards.

    My son held that brain as well as muscle was needed in athletics. "Rugby football," he wrote, "tends more and more to become an ideal combination of scientific actions. Haphazard, clumsy battering is useless. Your footballer has to be a thinking and a reasoning factor."

    He believed that games properly played are invaluable as a training in character. "They make," he wrote, "not only for courage and unselfishness, but also for clean living: a sportsman dare not indulge in excesses."

    Nobody could have found greater happiness in a game of football than did Paul Jones. He revelled in a hard-fought match and seemed impervious to knocks and bruises. One of his merits as a captain was that he never lost heart; he would fight doggedly to the last, even against adverse conditions. He knew, too, how to adapt his tactics skilfully to varying conditions of play. It was an intoxicating moment after a victory, for the boys would sweep into the field of play and carry the captain in triumph shoulder-high from the arena.

    In public-school football no animosities are left, no matter how keenly contested the game. Victor and vanquished dine together after the match, the best of friends, and the home team escort their visitors to the railway station. How well I recollect Paul coming home on Saturday evenings about eight o'clock after a victorious match; his firm, quick step, and the eager joy that shone in his face! His mother and I often watched the games at Dulwich, and he would go over every phase of the play with us, inviting comments and contributing his own.

    He was always severe in his condemnation of anything in the shape of "gallery play," his constant maxim being that the player should subordinate himself entirely to the side. It was his conviction that unselfishness was stimulated by football. The amateur athlete, who forgot himself in the team of which he was a part, and who played and worked hard for the honour of the game, and without thought of personal advantage or reward, was the god of his idolatry.

    Fond as he was of sport, and highly as he appreciated it as a discipline for character, he held that the cult of athletics could be overdone, and that to make a business of what should only be a pastime was a grave blunder. In an essay which he wrote on "Sport," he characterises the professional athlete as a man who is engaged "in the vilest of trades." "Life," he wrote, "is made up of varied interests, and man has serious work to do in the world. Excess in sport--or in anything else--puts the notes of the great common chord of life out of harmony."

    CHAPTER IV

    CRICKET

    Your cricketer, right English to the core,
    Still loves the man best he has licked before.

    TOM TAYLOR in Punch.

    Though, as has been said, Paul had no skill in cricket, he was jealous of the cricket reputation of the College. He knew the game thoroughly.

    His cricket "Bible," if I may use the expression, was Prince Ranjitsinhji's excellent "Jubilee Book of Cricket." He often accompanied the 1st XI for out-of-town matches, to act as scorer or reporter. His cricket reports in The Alleynian make racy reading.

    The following is taken from a picturesquely-written account of a victory over Brighton at Brighton in May, 1914:

    When A. E. R. Gilligan appeared at the wicket things became more
    than merry. He was in fine fettle, and from the first made light
    of the bowling, hitting all round the wicket with immense vigour.
    The gem of the day was his treatment of D. S. Johnson's fifth
    over. We seem to recollect reading in our childhood a work of P.
    G. Wodehouse's, in which he remarks that "when a slow bowler
    begins to bowl fast, it is as well to be batting if you can
    manage it." Well, Johnson was--we think--originally a slow
    bowler, and he tried to bowl fast.

    The result was that traffic
    had to be suspended on the road running past the school. First
    Franklin--who had replaced Shirley, brilliantly caught at
    point--smote Johnson for a three. This brought Gilligan to the
    batting end, and a horse passing outside the ground nearly had
    its life cut short. The next ball just missed the railings, and
    the next almost smashed the fanlight in a house across the road.
    It was then that the police suspended the traffic. Gilligan
    finally played inside a good length ball, and was most
    unfortunately bowled when within two of his century.

    Hard luck!
    He had been missed twice--once, we admit, badly--but on the whole
    his smiting was admirably timed and placed. He hit three sixes
    and fifteen fours. Franklin had meanwhile been busy, and scored
    22, with three fours. Finally, Brown and Wood put on some 30
    runs, the former being not out for a useful 16, and the latter
    getting 13. Our score was 326 for eight when Gilligan declared.

    Appended is a passage from his account of the match with Bedford on June 6 (in which Dulwich were victorious by 81 runs), describing a record achievement by A. H. H. Gilligan, one of three brothers who distinguished themselves in athletics in Dulwich:

    A. H. H. Gilligan was now well over the 170 mark, and had
    therefore beaten the previous school record for the highest
    score. At 190, however, he just touched a short fast ball from
    Cameron, and put the ball into the hands of Dix at second slip:
    283-9-190. The innings closed for 284 in the next over, Paton
    being run out. To score 190 out of 284 is an almost superhuman
    performance. For a man who was only playing his second match this
    season it was a positively marvellous achievement.

    Gilligan's
    innings was a masterpiece, and at no time did he seem to be in
    the slightest degree troubled by the bowlers, yet the latter were
    distinctly good, as they proved by the fact that they got nine
    men out for 94 runs or less. Gilligan's innings included a six
    and thirty-two fours. The previous best score--against a weak
    scratch side in 1911--was 171 by C. V. Arnold. Gilligan was at
    the wickets in all only two and a quarter hours or so.

    The following is from his report of the Sherborne match, which Dulwich won handsomely:

    Had not the last few wickets been able to put on a few more runs
    all earlier efforts might have been wasted, and certainly all
    would have been altered had it not been for the amazing bowling
    of Paton. His analysis was five for 6--a wonderful achievement.
    The wicket was, indeed, to a certain extent favourable to him,
    but he was able to make the ball swing with his arm and break
    back in a fashion that was quite astounding. A. E. R. Gilligan
    worked with his usual energy and bore the brunt of the bowling.
    While he did not have the success of Paton, he bowled extremely
    well, taking four for 30.

    All our team fielded so well that to
    specify individuals would be unnecessary. The Sherborne team
    brought off some excellent catches, though their ground-fielding
    was not quite so good. Wheeler bowled very well, and Westlake was
    in splendid form behind the wicket. After the match there were
    the usual handshakings and so forth, and we started back for
    London at five-thirty, getting to Waterloo at about eight
    o'clock. Our visit was quite delightful, and we send our very
    best thanks to our Sherborne friends for their kindness and
    hospitality.

    Of the match with St. Paul's School in July, 1914, in which Dulwich were badly beaten, he wrote:

    We would have given much to win this match, in particular, but at
    least there is the consolation that we lost to a really great
    side which could hardly have been beaten by any school in the
    country. The St. Paul's batting was so splendidly balanced that
    every man could be sure of a 10 or 20, while Skeet and Gibb were
    always certain of really good knocks; and in bowling the wizardry
    of Pearson was in itself enough to conjure any team out.

    St. Paul's knocked up 188 in their first innings. Dulwich were disposed of for 67, largely owing to the bowling of Pearson.

    The Pauline "demon" had now got all our men into a terrible
    "funk," and the result was that wickets began to fall at both
    ends like ninepins: 44-9-3. Then came the best batting of the
    game. Gilkes joined Brown, and quickly showed that he was not the
    man to hide his head before foes, however strong. After smiting
    Roberts to the leg boundary, he did the same to the off, and with
    Brown playing his usually steady game--being particularly smart
    in short runs--the 50 and 60 soon went up.

    But it could not go
    on, for at 67 Brown, avoiding Scylla, fell into the jaws of
    Charybdis--in other words, keeping Pearson out, was bowled by
    Skeet: 67-10-11. His 11 was a most valuable piece of batting.
    Gilkes, with 12 not out, was top scorer on our side--except for
    Mr. Extras. He had really done extremely well, and played with a
    straight bat at everything--therefore he did not get out. A most
    plucky and useful bit of work this.

    But what of our innings as a whole? Let the heavens fall in
    confusion on us! We decline to discuss the matter. Pearson took
    five wickets for 17, Skeet three for 21, Roberts two for 13. St.
    Paul's fielded well, especially Skeet, Hayne and Gibb. It was
    Pearson's cakewalk-tango bowling that undid us. Note, however,
    that in a second innings we quite redeemed ourselves, Rowbotham
    (31 not out), Paton (29), and Brown (29 not out) playing really
    excellently. Why, oh, why! didn't we do it in the first innings?

    His detailed and graphic reports were greatly appreciated by the members of the 1st XI, and read with relish by the whole school.

    Whenever opportunity offered Paul would visit the Oval for a great cricket match. Lord's not being so accessible, he seldom went to the M.C.C. ground. Though a poor cricketer himself, he loved the great summer game and admired those who excelled in it.

    CHAPTER V

    EDITOR OF "THE ALLEYNIAN."

    True ease in writing comes from art, not chance.

    POPE: "ESSAY ON CRITICISM."

    To the school magazine, The Alleynian, which is published monthly, Paul began contributing in 1912. His success in essays having shown that he had facility in writing, he was asked by those in authority to report the lectures for the magazine and help to liven up its contents. His first contribution deals with a lantern lecture on the "Soudan," delivered before the Science and Photographic Society by Major Perceval on November 23, 1912. A summary of the lecture is enlivened by such observations as these:

    A large and very distinguished audience was present. On the back
    benches in particular was a great array of Dulwich "knuts." The
    lecturer was, however, undaunted, though there can be no doubt
    that he felt much awe at the number of mighty men in his
    audience.

    From the report of a lecture delivered on January 31, 1913, "The Land of the Maori," the following quotation is made because of its allusions to then topical events:

    The lecturer said that in New Zealand the interests of labour
    were so well safeguarded that the country is called "the
    working-man's paradise" (loud cheers), while the women there had
    votes. At this an unparalleled uproar broke out. Cheers and
    hisses were commingled in one tremendous cataclysm of sound.
    Certainly we heard shouts of "Bravo" countered by shrieks of
    "Shame." The lecturer seemed dazed by the dreadful din.

    A report of the "Servants' Concert" (28th July, 1913) is in rollicking vein:

    Success was in the air from the very start. The crush at the
    doors was like Twickenham on the day of the England v. Scotland
    match--we had almost said the Crystal Palace on Cup Final Day. It
    is evident that there is a tremendous amount of talent for the
    stage and the music-halls in the school. To hear Gill give the
    tragic history of "Tommy's Little Tube of Seccotine," or the duet
    on the touching story of "Two Little Sausages," by Savage and
    Livock, would have brought tears to the eyes of a prison warder.
    Then there were F. W. Gilligan to relate his horticultural, and
    brother A. E.

    R. his zoological reminiscences--works of great
    value to scientists and others. To hear Killick dilate upon the
    dangers of the new disease, the "Epidemic Rag" (which seems to be
    quite as catching as the mumps), Gill upon the risks of the
    piscatorial art, or Savage upon an original Polynesian theme,
    "Zulu Lulu," was to feel like Keats's watcher of the skies, "when
    a new planet swims into his ken." For the admirer of Spanish
    customs there was A. E. J.

    Inglis (O.A.) to sing, as only he can,
    the Toreador's song; while for the Cockney there was Killick to
    give, in his own inimitable fashion, that really touching little
    ballad "My Old Dutch," Ould Oireland being well catered for by
    Livock in "A Little Irish Girl." The pianoforte solos by Nalder,
    Jacob and Shirley were all excellent and thoroughly well
    appreciated, as was our old friend, "Let's have a Peal," by the
    First XI.

    And now for the "star" performance of the evening. Positively for
    one night only, the Dulwich College Dramatic Society were down to
    give us W. G. O. Gill's one-act farce, "The Lottery Ticket." This
    fairly brought down the house. It went "with a bang," as actors
    say, from the very start. The great point about it was that all
    the performers forgot that they were acting, and were so
    perfectly natural. There was not a hitch. Killick, as a withered
    old Shylock, gave a really masterly representation of ancient
    villainy.

    Evans was admirably suited with the rôle of a dashing
    young man-about-town. The way he took his gloves off was worth a
    fortune in itself. We felt that there must be many degrees of
    blue blood in his veins. His back-chat repartee was far better
    than that of Mr. F. E. Smith, K.C. If Gill and Waite are in the
    future ever in need of a berth they should, judging by their
    performances in this play, apply to Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree for
    parts as a dilapidated charwoman and unwashed office-boy
    respectively. The topical allusions in the play were all
    thoroughly well made and appreciated.

    We might suggest that it is
    not the custom "in polite circles" to open and read other
    people's telegrams, but for a hardened old reprobate like Mr.
    Grabbit we can feel no pity, while we can forgive anything to a
    Principal Boy like Mr. Knowall.

    It is an open secret that the concert was organised by Killick.
    We take this opportunity of congratulating him heartily. From
    what rumour says, we take it that the Powers-that-be are very
    pleased with the concert. So are we. It was a complete success
    from start to finish. It is to be hoped that it will become a
    regular institution, especially considering the object it has in
    view--to give pleasure to those who have not often the chance of
    it.

    In 1913 he was appointed secretary and treasurer of the magazine, and a few months later he became one of the editors. Throughout 1913 and 1914 he was the chief contributor to its pages. Reporting a lady's lecture on Tibet (October 17, 1913), he wrote:

    But, at least, the Tibetans can teach us something--simplicity in
    ceremonies. For when Miss Kemp went to see the palace of the King
    all the decoration she saw there was a simple table and chair. A
    Tibetan kitchen was a very popular slide. In that country they
    apparently use a golf-bag to brew tea in, and cast-off bicycle
    wheels for plates. There prevails in Tibet some element of
    democracy, for Miss Kemp's cook was also a J.P., a Civil Servant,
    and held other such offices of fame. One of her assistants was a
    positive marvel--a human carpet-sweeper.

    If the floor was to be
    brushed he would simply roll over and over on it and clean it
    with his clothes! The Tibetans have no motor-bikes and no S. F.
    Edges, their fastest conveyance being a yâk, a species of ox,
    which moves at an average speed of two miles an hour (with the
    high gear in), and can slow down to an infinite extent. However,
    the nature of the country would make high speeds rather
    dangerous, as constantly you find yourself in danger of falling
    over precipices, down crevasses, or of being overwhelmed by
    falling boulders, for the mountain lands are covered with great
    glaciers.

    It was these mountain views that were especially
    magnificent. They were, for the most part, taken with
    tele-photographic lenses at a distance of fifty or sixty miles.

    To the November Alleynian he contributed a racy and rattling parody of the modern sensational drama entitled Red Blood: a Western Drama in Two Acts, in which the dramatis personæ are an English cowboy (heir to a million dollars without knowing it), an Indian chief (his friend), a wicked uncle, a murderer, and a New York detective. His historical tastes peep out in his report of a lecture delivered 7th November, 1913, on the famous mediæval doctor, Pareil (1510-1590).

    From this report the following is extracted:

    Much interest attaches to the historic associations of Pareil's
    life. As a famous surgeon he was in constant attendance on
    figures renowned in history, personages like Coligny (who was
    murdered by the mob of Paris while recovering from an amputation
    of Pareil's), Erasmus, Servetus, Leonardo da Vinci, and Catherine
    de Medici. Like Chaucer's doctour of physik, Pareil knew well the
    works of "Olde Ypocras," Galen, Avycen, etc., the famous
    physicians whose names have come down from history, but he was no
    pedantic scholar, preferring to do his own thinking.

    A stout
    Protestant, his last act was to beseech the Catholic Archbishop
    of Lyons, who was holding Paris against the assaults of Henry of
    Navarre (with the result that the population of the city was
    perishing by thousands), to open the gates and save the
    inhabitants, but he beseeched in vain.

    Altogether a remarkable figure, this old Pareil. Looked at in
    perspective, and in his era, it is clear how great a man he was.
    For he, first of all men in medicine, freed the world from the
    influence of pedantic tradition, and paved the way for modern
    medical science. Then all honour to his name, for, as the Master
    put it in proposing the vote of thanks to Mr. Paget, the art of
    healing is the greatest boon which man can give to the world.

    The last lecture he reported was delivered by Mr. F. M. Oldham, chief Science Master at the College, on "Primitive Man," on 3rd April, 1914.

    From this report the following extract is taken:

    Our main knowledge of man in the earliest stages of his existence
    comes from the examination of river mud. Mr. Oldham showed how
    different strata are built up by the river on its bed, and how in
    the lowest of these strata there will be found the oldest relics
    of man. In this way we are able to declare that the difference
    between the earliest man and his immediate followers lay in the
    question of polishing his flint instruments. That is to say, the
    earliest or palæolithic man had his implements unpolished; his
    successors polished them, often to a beautifully smooth surface.
    This Mr.

    Oldham illustrated with a series of films--your pardon,
    slides--of the arrow-heads made by palæolithic and neolithic man.
    It was a natural step, once man had learned to polish his
    instruments, and when he was advanced enough to try to form
    conceptions of beauty for himself, that he should draw or scratch
    pictures on stone. Several of these Mr. Oldham showed on the
    screen; some of them are extraordinarily well executed and show
    real artistic feeling. We would particularly mention one such
    representation of a reindeer, and another of a man stalking a
    bison.

    After the cave-dwellers' epoch comes that of huts, wood and
    bronze. Man in this stage is really but little different from
    what he is to-day. He has even the wit to construct himself
    lake-dwellings, consisting of huts placed on rafts and secured
    temporarily with large stones sunk in the lake-bed.
    Characteristic of this period are the great tolmens and monoliths
    found all over the world.

    Neolithic man had, indeed, sometimes
    constructed for himself a hut of stone, as Dartmoor will testify,
    but the tolmens are of quite different origin, and indicate a
    distinctly greater mental development, in that they are usually
    put up as monuments to great men or events. Of the same nature
    are the great mounds or "barrows" that abound in Ireland; inside
    there was a sort of crypt in which chiefs were buried. The
    monoliths were constructed, as doubtless the Pyramids also were,
    by rolling the great stones up an inclined bank of earth
    previously built up.

    Throughout 1914 Paul was the mainstay of the magazine. The May number contains from his pen exhaustive reports of two house matches (football), a shrewd commentary on the Junior School Cup matches, and a long report of a lecture. For the July number he wrote ten pages of cricket reports, and an account of the swimming competition. He was also responsible for the finances of the magazine, continuing to act as secretary and treasurer. All this time he was preparing for his Oxford scholarship. If he owed much to Dulwich, the College also owed something to him. No boy ever worked harder for it, or consecrated himself with more entire devotion to its welfare.

    CHAPTER VI

    PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND THE WAR

    Now all the youth of England are on fire.
    SHAKESPEARE: "HENRY V."

    To The Alleynian for October, 1914, Paul contributed an editorial article on the War that had then begun to rage in its destructive fury. Taking the view that "this war had to come sooner or later," he wrote:

    When one nation has a world-wide Empire embracing a fifth of the
    globe, founded on principles of absolute liberty for all whom it
    contains, and when another, built up by the force of
    circumstances on a basis of military despotism, also aspires to a
    different sort of world-power, and challenges the first nation,
    whose principles it abhors as much as its own are abhorred--in
    these circumstances it is hopeless to talk of reconciliation till
    one or the other is down.

    Actually, Germany's monstrous conduct
    in violating the neutrality of a small, industrious and
    inoffensive Power--a neutrality to which, be it marked, Germany
    was as much a partner as England or France--has put her
    hopelessly in the wrong with the civilised world. But that does
    not alter the fact that the War is primarily one for political
    existence. Either the despotism of Potsdam or the constitutional
    government of Westminster must survive. We, more even than Russia
    or France, are fighting for our very existence.

    Things are, indeed, very favourable to us and to our Allies.
    Through the brutal but clumsy blundering of Prussian diplomats,
    Europe has been long awaiting the conflagration; every move in
    the game has been brought out long ago. Besides, Germany
    undoubtedly counted on our domestic troubles and our pacific
    tendencies to keep us out of this conflict. They imagined France
    could easily be wiped out while Russia's vast bulk was slowly
    mobilising, and that the Russians would then be held up by the
    victorious legions pouring back from Paris. Then in, say, ten
    years they would turn on England and wipe her from the map.

    Our
    entrance into the War now has not only braced the whole moral
    fibre of France, Russia, Belgium and Serbia, but has strangled
    German commerce and held up her food supply by means of our
    command of the seas. Thus all the enemy plans have been thrown
    into confusion. We would be indeed foolish if we did not realise
    our position--what it means to ourselves, to Europe, and to the
    world. Having won the toss on a hard wicket, we are not going to
    put Germany in. We must fight to the death. The law is "Eat or be
    eaten."

    In these circumstances we call on Dulwich College to realise its
    duties to the State. Nothing--not work nor games--must be allowed
    to stand before the Corps till the War is over. Special drills
    and parades, extra route marches, all these must be and ought to
    be looked forward to cheerfully and willingly. The splendid
    number of recruits shows that the school is not going to fail in
    its duty here. We are not going to indulge in theories and
    jingo-patriotism, but call on you with deadly seriousness--the
    British Empire, the British principles of liberty, all are at
    stake. If we go down now we go down for ever.

    Germany is said to
    have called up every male between the ages of fifteen and sixty.
    If they can do that, surely we ought to be able to reply. Let
    that voluntary system which is the glory of our armies and navies
    carry us through now! We call on every one in the School to join
    the Corps at once.

    Nothing was finer in the first months of the War than the rally of the manhood of Great Britain to the call of the country in its time of need. All classes, rich and poor, patrician and peasant, employer and workman, were uplifted by the great occasion.

    Through the influence of patriotism, the recognition by all sorts and conditions of our people of the honourable obligation of fidelity to the pledged word of Britain, combined with a chivalric desire to champion the cause of weak, unoffending Belgium against the Teutonic bully--there was released in this country a flood of noble idealism and pure emotion, the memory of which those who lived during that spiritual awakening will never forget.

    No section of the community rose more finely to the height of the occasion than the athletes and scholars from our public schools and universities. Nobly did they respond to the call voiced by one of their number, R. E. Vernède (an old Pauline, now sleeping in a soldier's grave in France):

    Lad, with the merry smile and the eyes
    Quick as the hawk's and clear as the day;
    You, who have counted the game the prize,
    Here is the game of games to play.
    Never a goal--the captains say--
    Matches the one that's needed now;
    Put the old blazer and cap away--
    England's colours await your brow.

    Man, with the square-set jaws and chin,
    Always, it seems, you have moved to your end
    Sure of yourself, intent to win
    Fame and wealth and the power to bend.
    All that you've made you're called to spend--
    All that you've sought you're asked to miss--
    What's ambition compared with this:
    That a man lay down his life for his friend?

    Exulting in the response of the athletes, Paul Jones found his faith in the value of games confirmed by this memorable rally to the Flag.

    His last contribution to The Alleynian was inspired by it. Shortly after he joined the Army he wrote to the magazine a letter (published anonymously in May, 1915) under the caption "Flannelled Fools and Muddied Oafs." In this contribution he sings a pæan in praise of the amateur athlete. After reminding his readers of pre-War denunciations of "the curse of athletics," he asks, "What of athletics now?"

    At present, we see that the poor, despised athlete or
    sportsman--call him what you will--is coming to the front,
    practically and metaphorically, in a way which makes one wonder
    if, for the higher purposes of duty, athletics are not really the
    very best of all systems of training. When we look at the matter
    in the broadest light, the explanation shines forth clearly. All
    learning and all business are in the end simply and solely
    selfish. For example, you work hard for a scholarship at Oxford
    or Cambridge--why? So that you can obtain for
    yourself
    --(underline these words, Mr.

    Printer, please!)--the
    advantages of 'Varsity life and culture, and to the ultimate end
    that you may be better fitted to make your own way in life. Of
    course, this is necessary, but life is always very sordid in its
    details, and the more civilised we become, the more apparent is
    that sordidity. In fact, it is only on our amateur playing-fields
    that we become really unselfish. For here we play for a team or a
    side; and for the success of that side--which success, by the
    way, is in no sense material or selfish--we are prepared to take
    all sorts of pains, to scorn delights and live laborious days.

    It
    is the clearest manifestation of the simple, unsophisticated man
    coming to the front and tearing aside for a brief moment the
    cloud of materialism with which civilisation has been enveloping
    him.

    Nothing but athletics has succeeded in doing this sort of work in
    England. Religion has failed, intellect has failed, art has
    failed, science has failed. It is clear why: because each of
    these has laid emphasis on man's selfish side; the saving of
    his own soul, the cultivation of his own mind, the pleasing
    of his own senses. But your sportsman joins the Colours because
    in his games he has felt the real spirit of unselfishness, and
    has become accustomed to give up all for a body to whose service
    he is sworn.

    Besides this, he has acquired the physical fitness
    necessary for a campaign. These facts explain the grand part
    played by sport in this War; they also explain why the amateur
    has done so enormously better than the professional.

    "Let us therefore," is his injunction, "take off our hats to the amateur athlete, who is one of the brightest figures in England to-day. Let us indeed not forget that it is not in any sense only the athletes who have gone, but let us remember that in proportion no class of men has seen its duty so clearly, and done it so promptly, in the present crisis. We suggest that this War has shown the training of the playing-fields of the Public Schools and the 'Varsities to be quite as good as that of the class-rooms; nay, as good? Why, far better, if training for the path of Duty is the ideal end of education."

    Here, as always, Paul distinguished between the amateur athlete and the professional athlete. For the latter his scorn was unmitigated, and he could not endure Association football with its paid players. He also loathed the betting element that defiled the Soccer game.

    This letter was his last contribution to The Alleynian. Its strictures are far too sweeping; it has the dogmatism and the note of certitude to which youth is prone. But it is animated by a fine spirit. Very characteristic is the emphasis placed in it on the ideas of duty and unselfishness. The passion for sacrifice was in his blood.

    CHAPTER VII

    TASTES AND HOBBIES

    Variety's the very spice of life.
    COWPER: "THE TASK."

    Many of our son's vacations were spent in Llanelly, South Wales, where his mother's and my own kindred dwell. Llanelly is not a beautiful town--industrial centres seldom are--but Paul loved every aspect of it--the busy works, the spacious bay with its great stretches of sandy beach, the green and hilly hinterland, dotted with snug farmhouses and cheerful-looking cottages. Accompanied by his cousin Tom, for whom he had an intense affection, and under the guidance of his uncle, Mr.

    Edwin Morgan, a consulting engineer of high repute, he visited in process of time every industrial establishment in the neighbourhood--steel works, foundries, engineering shops and tinplate works. His insatiable curiosity, his desire to know the reason for everything, his alert interest in all the processes of manufacture, were noted with smiling admiration by managers and workmen. His last visit to Llanelly was in the summer of 1914. We joined him there in the third week of August.

    Clear in recollection is an incident that took place during our stay there.

    One sunny afternoon we were out in Carmarthen Bay in a little tug-boat and hailed a large four-masted vessel that had dropped anchor and was awaiting a pilot. She had just arrived from Archangel with timber. Her crew, athirst for news about the War, were most grateful for a bundle of newspapers. Paul thrilled at this meeting at sea with a vessel that had come direct from Russia, and he followed with fascinated interest the conversation between the tugboatmen and the crew of the barque. Little did any of us think then that the War was destined to claim Paul's life!

    Celtic on his mother's side and mine, he was proud of the fact that he sprang from an "old and haughty nation, proud in arms." On many of his school books he wrote in bold lettering: "Cymru am byth!" ("Wales for ever!") His instinctive love of Wales was strengthened by his visits to Llanelly and by holidays on the Welsh countryside, where, amid romantic surroundings and far from the fret and fever of modern life, he obtained an insight into rural ways and things. Welsh love of music and Welsh prowess in football also appealed powerfully to him.

    Like most boys he went through the usual run of hobbies: silkworms, carpentry, stamp-collecting, photography, parlour railways.

    Thoroughness was his quality even in his hobbies. He had the note-taking habit in marked degree. Even as a small boy on a long railway journey he would carefully record in his notebook the name of every station through which the train passed, and then, on reaching his destination, would work out the distances by maps and books, and finally draw an outline showing the route with the principal stations and junctions marked. The same passion for classifying facts made him, as soon as he began to follow cricket closely, compile tables showing the batting and bowling averages of the leading players. Similarly with football.

    He was familiar with the record of the leading Rugby clubs and the characteristics of the principal players.

    Machinery had for him the fascination of life in motion. He would gaze with rapture at the rhythmic movement of a flywheel and was thrilled by the harmonious movement of cogs and eccentrics, pistons and connecting-rods, all "singing like the morning stars for joy that they are made." As a child visiting a printing office he used to clap his hands with delight at the sight of "the wheels all turning." For engines of all sorts he had a passion.

    At Plymouth he loved to watch the great G.W.R. locomotives steaming into Millbay terminus, and would often engage the driver or stoker in conversation. After our removal to London he spent part of one vacation in an engineering shop. When he was fifteen we bought for him a small gas-engine which was fixed in an upper room. Clad in overalls he spent many a happy hour with this engine, generating electricity which he used sometimes for lighting, sometimes for driving the engine and train on his miniature railway.

    Here are extracts from one of his vacation diaries:

    JANUARY, 1912

    January 1.--Went with Mother to first night of Nightbirds at
    the Lyric. Workman and Constance Driver excellent; Farkoa also
    very good.

    January 2-5.--Busy making switchboard at home. At the
    engineering workshop I am starting on a steel rod; cutting with
    hack saw, cutting 5/16 standard Whitworth thread; grooving it.
    All this on a Drummond 3-1/2-inch lathe.

    January 6.--Heard of 4 v. 20 a.h. accumulator for 10s. 6d. I
    must buy it. Splendid acc. it is. Finished switchboard; all
    correct; polished up meters and instruments. [Here is diagram of
    connections.]

    Evening.--At Tales of Hoffmann, Opera House, with Mother. Good
    performance. First and third acts excellent; second ("Barcarolle"
    act) poor. Orchestra superb. Felice Lyne, Pollock, Victoria
    Fer--artistes of great promise. Renaud a master.

    January 7.--Wrote Economic Electric for new dynamo. Received
    letter from "Humber" recommending motor bike. I will probably buy
    one later on, or a "Triumph."

    January 10.--Took my old accumulator to electrician. To my
    great pleasure he said there was nothing wrong, only wanted
    filling and charging.

    January 11.--Tried my acc. on the train, running through
    switchboard; a great success. Engine runs very well. All
    switchboard connections absolutely correct; the reading when
    running: volts 3.5 to 4.25, amps. 1 to 2.5.

    January 12.--To Bassett Lowke's and bought wagon; yellow
    colour, red lettering; splendid model.

    January 13.--At matinée Orpheus in the Underground, at His
    Majesty's. Exceedingly good show. Courtice Pounds, L. Mackinder
    and Lottie Venn--all first rate; good voices and not afraid to
    use them.

    January 15.--To Hippodrome. The feature two amazingly clever
    Chimpanzees. Leo Fall's Eternal Waltz a pretty operetta.

    January 16.--Final golf match between Dad and myself. Dad wins
    match and rubber by 1 up.

    January 17.--Got back my P.O. bank book. Total now £6 3s.
    Discovered slight leakage at joint between the cylinder and
    combustion head of the gas engine, owing to wearing away of
    asbestos washer, so causing a very small but appreciable
    diminution of compression. Made a temporary stopping with
    vaseline.

    Evening.--Dad and I to Tales of Hoffmann, at the Opera House.
    This time a magnificent performance.

    January 19.--Dynamo arrived. A beautiful machine.

    January 20.--Went with Dad to International football match,
    England v. Wales, at Twickenham. Score--England, 8 points;
    Wales, nil. A splendid game. Wales beaten chiefly owing to
    their very poor three-quarters. Little to choose between the
    packs.

    January 31.--Having re-started music with a good teacher, a
    pupil of Professor Hambourg, I have practised very hard on the
    piano these last few days.

    In his enthusiasm for engineering he devoured books like "Engineering Wonders of the World," "How it Works," "How it is Made," "Engineering of To-day," "Mechanical Inventions of To-day"; also books on wireless telegraphy and aviation. A great lover of books, he liked on off-days to visit London bookshops and rummage their shelves. Very proud he was of his purchases during these excursions. From time to time he would have a run round the museums and picture galleries of London or take a trip to Hampton Court--Wolsey's palace and William III's home--a spot dear to him for its links with history and for the beauty of its surroundings.

    He was always enthralled at the British Museum by the Rosetta Stone--that key by means of which Champollion unlocked for the modern world the long-hidden secret of Egypt's ancient civilisation.

    A subject which he pursued keenly for a couple of years--from fifteen to seventeen--and which held him in fascinated wonder, was Astronomy, a branch of knowledge that happens to be strongly represented among my books. Often on starry nights he would be a watcher of the heavens.

    Many a night from yonder ivied casement,
    Ere he went to rest,
    Did he look on great Orion, sloping
    Slowly to the west.
    Many a night he saw the Pleiads, rising
    Thro' the mellow shade,
    Glitter like a swarm of fireflies, tangled
    In a silver braid.

    It has been stated that most of Paul's vacations were spent in Wales, but in 1913 he went farther afield, accompanying his mother, his brother and myself on a tour in Germany. He was enraptured with this, his first visit to the Continent. On our outward journey we halted at Brussels, in those days a bright and happy city with nothing in its cheerful, prosperous air to suggest that in less than a year there would descend upon it the baleful shadow of the Great War.

    Much in the old Germany appealed powerfully to our son, and even of the new Germany, with its energy and its zeal for learning, he was something of an admirer. But he hated in modern Germany its brazen materialism and boastful arrogance. He attributed the change in the spirit of the German people to the hardness of their Prussian taskmasters, whose yoke was submissively borne because of the glamour of the military victories achieved since 1866, and the rapid growth in wealth that had followed the attainment of German unity.

    He read and spoke German and was familiar with the literature and history of the country. Two great Germans, Goethe and Wagner, he intensely admired. It so happened that we were at Frankfort on the centenary of Goethe's death. Paul visited the Goethe house and spent a couple of hours examining its souvenirs with loving interest. He liked to see the places and the houses associated with the names or lives of great men. On our homeward journey down the Rhine he left us at Bonn to visit the house where Beethoven was born, joining-us subsequently at Cologne.

    This holiday in the Rhineland and the Black Forest brought deep enjoyment to him. His enthusiasm at his first sight of the Rhine was unrestrained, and the morning after our arrival he plunged into its waters for a swim. Professor Cramb, writing of the love of Germans for the Rhine, quotes a letter from Treitschke, in which that fire-eating historian said on the eve of his leaving Bonn: "To-morrow I shall see the Rhine for the last time. The memory of that noble river will keep my heart pure and save me from sad or evil thoughts throughout all the days of my life." Paul in a marginal note writes: "Wonderful attraction of the Rhine.

    I have felt it myself, though not a German."

    He got on excellently with the German people. One Sunday afternoon, doing the famous walk from Triberg to Hornberg, he had a long and friendly talk with a German reservist in the latter's native tongue, about the relations of Germany and England. Both agreed that war between the two nations would be madness, and both dismissed it as to the last degree improbable, but the German said significantly that he feared the Crown Prince was a menace to peace.

    In the spring of the following year (1914) Paul spent Easter week with me in Paris. Never had I seen the French capital more beautiful or happier-seeming than in that bright and joyous springtime. Who could have dreamt then that war was only three months distant? Paris was a revelation to Paul. He crowded a lot of sight-seeing into half a dozen busy days. All that was noble or beautiful in Art as in Nature appealed instinctively to him. I can see him now at the Louvre gazing rapt from various angles at that glorious piece of statuary the Venus of Milo. His knowledge of history made his visit to the glittering palace of Louis XIV at Versailles an undiluted pleasure.

    Fascinated by the genius of Napoleon, he spent a long time at the Invalides gazing down on the sarcophagus within which the conqueror of Europe sleeps his last sleep.

    Later in the year he and two other Dulwich boys arranged to spend three weeks of the summer vacation in the house of a professor at Rouen. They were to have left London on the second week in August.

    This hopeful project was frustrated by the rude shock of war.

    CHAPTER VIII

    MUSIC

    Music is a kind of inarticulate, unfathomable speech, which leads us
    to the edge of the Infinite, and lets us for moments gaze into that.

    CARLYLE.

    Paul began the study of music at an early age. He had natural aptitude for it and an unerring ear. As a little boy he used to sing with much expression in a sweet, clear voice. He received great assistance from his mother in his musical studies. After he had turned fifteen, music became one of his main interests. Indeed, if we except football, it was his master passion, and, unlike football, it could be pursued throughout the year. Whenever his scholastic studies and his athletic activities permitted, he would spend his leisure at the piano.

    With characteristic thoroughness he studied the lives as well as the works of the great composers. During the Grand Opera season he was a frequent visitor to Covent Garden Theatre and the performances of the Nibelungen Ring were for him a fountain of pure delight. He was also a regular attendant with his mother at the Queen's Hall and Albert Hall concerts. Ballad singing did not appeal to him in the same degree as operatic and orchestral music. Thanks to instinctive gifts and assiduous practice he became a scholarly and an accomplished musician.

    A brilliant pianist, his playing was marked by power and passion, and the colour and glow of an intense and sensitive personality. He could memorise the most intricate composition, and would play for hours without a note. Music was almost a religion with him: he found in it solace, joy, inspiration.

    Above all other musicians, he reverenced Beethoven and Wagner. For Beethoven's music, with its spiritualised emotion and divine harmonies, his admiration knew no bounds. Of the famous symphonies he assigned first place to that in C minor, No. 5, which he thought stood alone in the art of musical expression, peerless and unapproachable, a unique emanation from the soul and mind of man.

    "It holds us in its grasp," wrote Wagner of this composition, "as one of the rarer conceptions of the master, in which Passion, aroused by Pain as its original ground-tone, raises itself upward on the stepping-stone of conciliation and exaltation to an outburst of Joy conscious of Victory." Paul loved to play the Fifth Symphony as well as to hear it performed by an orchestral band. When playing it he seemed to lose touch with earth and to be transported to celestial heights.

    In his marginalia he compares the methods of expression of Shakespeare with those of Beethoven. That able critic, the late Professor Dowden, in some penetrating observations on Shakespeare's works, wrote:

    In the earliest plays the idea is at times hardly sufficient to
    fill out the language; in the middle plays there seems a perfect
    balance and equality between the thought and its expression; in
    the latest plays this balance is disturbed by the preponderance,
    or excess, of ideas over the means of giving them utterance.

    After underlining this passage Paul made the comment: "An extraordinary coincidence occurs to me in that the same thing happens with Beethoven, the greatest of the absolute musicians. Anyone must see that in the last symphony (No. 9 in D minor) he seems often at a loss how to put his feelings into shape (or sound), as though musical style up to his time could not express the intensity of his ideas.

    Hence in this symphony there is a distinct lack of balance--a defect which is absent from the works of his middle period (e.g., Symphony No. 5 or No. 7)."

    Another Beethoven work that he loved was the Third Symphony in E Flat, with its epic opening; the mournful beauty of its funeral march, now sad, calm, solemn like a moonless, starless night, now shining with gleams of hope and faith; its crisp and lively scherzo; and the triumphant finale, a veritable ecstasy of divine joy.

    My son as an historical scholar found a peculiar attraction in this symphony by reason of its association with Napoleon Buonaparte, for it was inspired by Beethoven's belief--formed in those days when the soldier of the Revolution was regarded as the liberator of peoples and the enemy only of the old feudal order--that Napoleon was marked out by destiny to realise Plato's ideal of government.

    One recalls how the act of Napoleon in proclaiming himself Emperor shattered this illusion; how Beethoven erased the fallen hero's name from the title-page of his score, withheld the "Eroica" for a time, and then gave it to the world in 1805 as "An Heroic Symphony composed in memory of a great man." When Beethoven heard of Napoleon's death at St.

    Helena, he said he had already composed his funeral ode 17 years before. Of this marche funèbre M. Ballaique wrote: "It owes its incomparable grandeur to the beauty of the melodic idea and also to a peculiarity of rhythm. At the first half of each bar there is a halt, a pause, which seems to punctuate each station, each painful slip or descent on the way to the illustrious tomb."

    Of Wagner, Paul was a whole-hearted worshipper. He was familiar with the myths, legends and folk-poems from which Wagner drew his themes, and he exulted in the master's superb treatment of them.

    Never, he thought, had music and ideas been more felicitously blended than by Wagner, whatever the theme--the storm-tost soul of "the Flying Dutchman," to whom redemption came at last through loyalty and compassion; the conflict between sensuality and love fought out in the arena of Tannhäuser's mind; the cosmic glories of the Ring with the resplendent figures of Siegfried and Brunhilde; the self-dedication of Parsifal, the Sir Percival of our Arthurian legends, whom "The sweet vision of the Holy Grail drew from all vain-glories, rivalries and earthly heats." Into the glowing music of Wagner my son read lessons in renunciation, the sordidness of the lust for gold, the sublimity of pure human love, the redemptive power of self-sacrifice.

    The occasional voluptuousness of the music was so transmuted in the alembic of his temperament that for him the sensual element was eliminated. An incident illustrative of his devotion to Wagner is worth recording. In the summer of 1913, during our holiday tour in Germany, we had for part of the time our headquarters at Assmannshausen, a smiling village sheltering snugly at the foot of vine-clad hills on the right bank of the Rhine. That great river is at its best at Assmannshausen; the broad current here flows swiftly over a stony bed.

    Day and night one's ears are filled with the music of the rushing waters hastening impetuously to the distant sea as though eager to lose themselves in its infinite embrace. One evening the guests at the hotel arranged a concert, and to our surprise--for we knew how diffident he was--Paul, evidently moved by the genius loci, volunteered to take part in it. When the time came he advanced to the piano through the crowded room and, with an elbow resting on the instrument, astonished the audience by a few explanatory words.

    He said he was going to play the "Ride of the Valkyries," and explained what Wagner meant to convey by that wild, stormy music. Then seating himself at the instrument, he proceeded to play the "Ride" from memory. His execution had a verve whose charm was irresistible. It was a lovely summer night. Through the open windows of the concert-room one caught glimpses of the moonlight quivering on the waters of the swift-flowing Rhine.

    Nothing could be heard save the river's melodious roar softened by distance, and this enchanting music interpreted by one who was saturated with its spirit, both sounds blending harmoniously like the double pipe of an ancient Greek flute player. All of us felt the spell of the scene and the occasion.

    Everyone listened tense and silent until the descending chromatic passage at the end when the "Valkyries" vanish into space, the echo of their laughter dies away, and the "Ride" ends in a sound like the fluttering of wings in the distance. When Paul rose from the piano the pent-up feelings of the audience found expression in enthusiastic applause.

    In the spring of 1913, just after he had turned 17, he wrote the following appreciation of Wagner for the Llanelly Star:

    The 22nd of May, 1913, marks the centenary of an event of supreme
    importance in the annals of music. To-day just one hundred years
    ago was born at Leipzig Richard Wagner, king of the music-drama,
    who towers above all other operatic composers like some lofty
    mountain rising from the midst of a dull and featureless plain.
    Such a colossal revolution as was effected by Wagner in Art can
    hardly find a parallel in any walk of life. What, in brief, was
    the scope of Wagner's reforms? To answer this question it is
    necessary to glance at the state in which the opera stood in
    pre-Wagner days.

    From the days of Scarlatti the opera had
    consisted of a number of semi-detached solos, duets or choruses
    to which tunes were set. These pieces were joined up by any
    jumble of notes sung by the characters on the stage, usually with
    no artistic meaning whatsoever, known as the recitative. In a
    word, the opera was a mere ballad concert.

    The recitative was so
    utterly foolish and meaningless, as a rule, that men like
    Beethoven and Weber, when they composed music-dramas, abolished
    it altogether, and composed what is known as "Singspiel"--that
    is, a number of ballads connected simply by spoken words. (The
    well-known Gilbert and Sullivan operettas are really Singspiels
    in a lesser form.) Thus it is obvious that the meaning of the
    opera--that is, a drama whose significance is made more clear by
    the aid of music suitable to the situation in hand--had been
    entirely lost sight of.

    In the average French or Italian opera, or in the singspiels, all
    that matters is a number of songs, ballads or arias--call them
    what you will--entirely disconnected and quite destructive to the
    continuity that must be the essence of every drama. This
    continuity is an absolute necessity to every spoken play; imagine
    the effect if Shakespeare or Ibsen had written little pieces of
    rhyming verse joined up by any jumble of nonsensical prose!
    Neglect of this fact led every opera composer before Wagner
    astray.

    We can imagine a pre-Wagner composer telling his
    librettist, "Now, mind you arrange that in certain parts the
    words will allow me to put in arias or choruses." In short, the
    situation was summed up in Wagner's famous phrase, "The means of
    expression (music) has been made the end, while the end of
    expression (the drama) has been made the means." Now this state
    of affairs is clearly wrong. If there is no dramatic idea kept as
    end to work to, then what is the use of writing opera at all? Why
    not be content with song-cycles or ballads, or lieder like
    Brahms's and Schumann's?

    There are no divisions into aria and recitative in Wagner's
    operas, but dramatic continuity is retained by the voices of the
    characters singing music the succession of whose notes is
    determined by the emotional requirements of the moment.
    Meanwhile, the orchestra forms a sort of musical background by
    giving forth music which exactly suits the dramatic situation.
    The orchestra, in a word, as Wagner himself said of Tristan und
    Isolde
    , forms an emotional tide on which the voice floats like a
    boat on the waters.

    The essential relevance of the music to the
    dramatic situation is obtained, as a rule, by means of what are
    known as "leading motives." These form the basis of all Wagner's
    reforms. A leading motive is simply a musical phrase suggestive
    of a dramatic idea. Wagner's motives are marvellous in their
    descriptive and soul-stirring power. They seem to indicate not
    only the pith, but the utmost depths of the heart of the ideas
    which they represent. It is this that makes Wagner so very like
    Shakespeare. All can appreciate him, yet he is above all
    criticism, universal in his appeal.

    Who but Wagner could make us feel the awful tragedy of
    Siegfried's death, the calm of the primeval elements, the pompous
    yet somewhat venerable character of the Mastersingers, the agony
    of Tristan's delirium, the superb majesty of Valhalla, or the
    free, noble nature of Parsifal? Even when Wagner uses motives
    comparatively little, writing rather "freely," as in Tristan und
    Isolde
    , he always has the power of imprinting an idea with the
    utmost clearness upon our souls.

    He will sometimes make a slight
    change in a motive, or make a development of it, that gives us an
    entirely different psychological impression of the idea
    represented by the motive, as indicating some new aspect of it in
    which the motives are all dovetailed together into a compact
    whole that is simply marvellous. If one considers the "Ring,"
    that gigantic web of motives, and at the same time, in the words
    of that able critic, Mr.

    Ernest Newman, "beyond all comparison
    the biggest thing ever conceived by the mind of a musician,"
    colossal yet logical, gigantic yet compact, the power of the
    Bayreuth master will become even still more evident.

    Wagner's first work, Rienci, composed frankly in the blatant
    Meyerbeerian style, has no artistic significance. The Flying
    Dutchman
    marks a great advance. Tannhäuser and Lohengrin are
    milestones of progress, but in all these works Wagner's full
    ideal is, generally speaking, but little perceptible.

    The really
    great Wagner operas are his later works, Tristan und Isolde,
    Parsifal, Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, and, above all,
    that gigantic tetralogy (a complete musico-dramatic rendering of
    the Icelandic Saga put into English verse under the title of
    Sigurd the Volsung by William Morris) which consists of four
    stupendous operas, Das Rheingold, Die Walküre, Siegfried,
    and Gotterdämmerung.

    These marvellous works, the consummation
    of the Bayreuth master's principles, undoubtedly stand with
    Beethoven's symphonies as the greatest achievements in music.

    For the rest, it may be mentioned that Wagner was in private life
    a most kindly man, albeit at times quick-tempered, a great lover
    of children and animals. His philosophy was a somewhat variable
    quantity; he fell under the influence first of Feuerbach, then of
    Schopenhauer, and to some extent possibly of Nietzsche. But
    still, throughout all his works runs the doctrine of the Free
    Individual, of which Siegfried and Parsifal are perhaps the most
    striking impersonations.

    Like Browning, Wagner believed in redemption by means of
    sacrifice. In his richness and strength Wagner typified the
    abounding vitality of the new Germany. To the Fatherland he is
    what Shakespeare is to England. One may apply to him the noble
    words Milton wrote of Shakespeare:

    "Thou in our wonder and astonishment
    Hast built thyself a livelong monument.

    . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    And so sepulchred in such pomp dost lie
    That kings for such a tomb would wish to die."

    H. P. M. J.

    I found among my son's papers a sketch in manuscript of Wagner's life and work. It begins with some observations on Romanticism and Classicism.

    Whereas in the Classical style the spirit is held in restraint by
    certain forms, in the Romantic it refuses to acknowledge these
    forms and breaks away to give the soul entirely free play. It
    necessarily follows that the Romantic style makes the wider
    appeal, for it touches chords of the heart that the Classical
    cannot. Also the Romantic is rather more definite and less purely
    intellectual than the Classical, though the ideal may be equally
    high in the one as in the other. In short, the Romantic style is
    human in its appeal, while the Classical is superhuman.

    The best
    examples of men great in these two forms of art are Shakespeare
    in the Romance and Milton in the Classic.

    Returning to music, he thought that Bach, "immortal though many of his works are," was fettered by his servitude to rules.

    The Classical may become too cold, may lose all connection with
    the warmth of humanity. Such a fate does Haydn seem to have met
    in many of his works. Beethoven, the mightiest classicist, also
    to some extent Mozart, saw that the soul must not hold entirely
    aloof from humanity. Hence it is that Beethoven broke
    deliberately several, though not indeed very many, of Bach's more
    enchaining rules, while Mozart, in his operas at least, had a
    large amount of Romance worked into his music. On the other hand,
    by its very nature the Romance style is occasionally apt to slip
    into what is pre-eminently Classicism.

    He confutes the argument that because base things have to be expressed in the Romantic style therefore that style degrades Art, for "base things handled artistically excite pure emotions of anger or indignation."

    Wagner, though he broke every rule set up by Bach, though he
    abolished all the ideas of Classicism, produced with his later
    works (i.e., The Ring, Die Meistersinger, Tristan, and
    Parsifal) music which reveals infinitudes of art to quite as
    great an extent as any classicist has done.... Wagner gives us
    Nature's message, Beethoven the message of the incomprehensible
    Empyrean, and it is for no one to say that the one message is any
    greater or less than the other.

    Necessarily the opera must be more romantic than the symphony. "Composers who have given the world both opera and symphony such as Beethoven, Mozart, Weber, Spohr, Berlioz, always wrote Romantically in their operas and Classically in their symphonies." Of the development of opera he wrote:

    Opera was fast degenerating into a sort of collection of ballads,
    with hardly any orchestration at all, when a strong man rose to
    check these abuses. Gluck was the forerunner of the earlier
    German school of opera composers, which includes such men as
    Beethoven, Mozart, Weber and Schubert. Gluck had studied
    carefully the progress of non-operatic music since Bach's time,
    and seeing what vast strides the art had made in this direction,
    tried to bring into line with the opera its improvements. He was
    the first composer to show the immense and inestimable necessity
    of properly orchestrated music in opera.

    Gluck's rich scoring,
    beautiful melodies combined with dramatic connection between
    action, voice and orchestra, entirely revolutionised the opera.
    Fortunately, he had a still greater contemporary to carry on his
    reforms. Gluck has himself explained how he set out to avoid any
    concession of music to the vocal abilities of the singer; how he
    had tried to bring music to its proper function, i.e., to go
    side by side with the poetry of the drama--a clear forecasting of
    Wagner's own reforms.

    Whereas in Monteverde's operas the dramatic significance was
    kept, but only at the expense of the music, which had absolutely
    no signification at all, in the works of Gluck, Mozart and
    Scarlatti the musical part is elevated, but entirely at the
    expense of the dramatic idea, which is quite lost. A Mozart
    melody, rhythmic, square-cut, is as different as possible from a
    Wagner theme, for whereas the former suggests nothing the latter
    is very rich in suggestion.

    It is clear that Gluck and Mozart,
    though they performed an inestimable service to the musical art
    by the raising of the orchestra to its proper position with
    regard to the voice and the music, yet failed to keep in view the
    continuity of the drama in opera. Hence it was that Weber and
    Beethoven frankly abolished the recitative that joins the formal
    melodies of the arias and melodic passages and composed
    Singspiel, having their works built up of airs and melodies
    joined by spoken dialogue. Such is Weber's Der Freischütz and
    such Beethoven's Fidelio.

    After discussing Meyerbeer, Scarlatti, and Rossini, Bellini and Donizetti, my son comes to Wagner and the revolution in music he accomplished:

    Wagner was a man of ripe culture, who was equally familiar with
    Beethoven's symphonies, Shakespeare's dramas, Kant's philosophic
    writings and Homer's epics. All the great works of literature and
    philosophy were well known to him. Thus he brought to bear on his
    music a mind singularly well equipped in every direction. He was,
    too, essentially a Teuton, with all the German massiveness of
    conception and depth of soul. A lesser man must have fallen
    before the prospect of attempting such a colossal reform. What
    was that reform in its essentials?

    It was this--to compose opera
    in which the idea of the drama was made the ruling conception; to
    attain this end by a wedding of suitable poetry to music of such
    a kind as should reflect by its themes what was happening on the
    stage or in the minds of the characters. There was to be no aria
    or fixed form of ballad, but continuous melody, in which the
    voices of the characters are regarded as extra instruments of the
    orchestra, with just that element of personality included....

    To have succeeded entirely in this bold design he would have had
    to be a Shakespeare in poetry and knowledge of human nature, as
    well as a musician of equal ability. How could any one man fulfil
    both of these rôles? In the matter of the music Wagner is a very
    Shakespeare. But if we take his own writings as evidences of what
    he meant to do, then his librettos must necessarily be
    unsatisfactory. They keep the dramatic idea in sight so much as
    almost entirely to lose sight of poetic beauty. Wagner was
    pre-eminently a musician; he was not a poet, as he wished also to
    be.

    Whatever his poetical achievements, the main fact is
    unaltered. The dramatic idea and the musical expression are kept
    so indissolubly close by Wagner as to be one for all intents and
    purposes.

    Of Wagner's treatment of the vocalist he says:

    The melody sung is modelled upon the way in which the speaking
    voice rises and falls in accordance with the feelings of the
    moment. With marvellous skill the master of Bayreuth has made the
    music sung reflect as clearly as any oration what are the
    thoughts and feelings of the character. The orchestra makes, as
    it were, a tide or ocean, over which the voice, in this manner,
    floats, now rising high on the crest of the wave, now sinking
    into the trough of the seas. Sometimes for added poignancy,
    Wagner makes the voice sing the leitmotif of some idea
    connected with the idea of the moment.

    This is constantly
    occurring in Die Meistersinger.

    After scornful allusions to French and Italian opera, he shows how Wagner re-fashioned opera on new and nobler lines. Replying to those who say "You must have lightness sometimes," he wrote:

    Yes, but never triviality. If we want lightness of touch and
    wittiness, have we not Die Meistersinger, the greatest comedy
    in the world, or a merry piece like Mozart's Nozze di Figaro?
    Here is all the wit that one wants, yet the level is kept high
    throughout. It is the same in literature. We have absurd, banal
    pieces, said to be humorous, such as The Glad Eye, which really
    contain not one-millionth the humour that there is in a noble
    comedy like Shakespeare's Twelfth Night, or As You Like It,
    or a Shavian play like John Bull's Other Island.

    Man is too
    great a thing ever to be of his nature low and banal. We have in
    life farce sometimes, comedy very often indeed, but never
    banality.

    The essay thus concludes:

    If we have been flooded with rag-times and musical comedies, the
    fault lies in the first place with the French and Italian
    composers of the period 1790-1850. Pre-Wagner opera is as low a
    concoction as can possibly be conceived. It took all the genius
    of the great Bayreuth master to turn things back into their
    proper channel. But he has succeeded, and the old style is
    moribund. Anyone who glances over the list of living composers
    must see that they are all enormously influenced by Wagner's
    principle. The last of the old style was Massenet, and he is
    dead.

    We see Richard Strauss, an extreme Wagnerian, only without
    the master's full powers; Engelbert Humperdinck, who is a user of
    the leitmotif and a most skilled orchestrator, though his
    motifs are not so powerful as Wagner's or even Strauss's; Pietro
    Mascagni, a Mozartean composer; Bruneau, an extreme Wagnerian;
    Glazounov and Mossourgsky have combined Wagner's ideas with
    Tschaikovsky's; Puccini at least is a very strong supporter and
    admirer of Wagner.

    It will thus be seen that, with the exception
    of Mascagni, Wagnerian ideas have been paid tribute to by all the
    leading opera composers of the day. In a word, the Man is here.
    Opera, as represented by Richard Wagner's music-dramas, takes its
    place on a level with the absolute music of which Beethoven's
    work is the noblest example.

    Paul found keen pleasure in the Gilbert and Sullivan operas, liking the witty libretto as much as the bright, tuneful melodies. For the work of Cæsar Franck, a gifted Belgian musician who died on the threshold of manhood, he had profound admiration, and was of opinion that had he lived Franck would have taken rank with the great masters.

    As was to be expected, my son had for Welsh music a strong natural sympathy. He held that "Men of Harlech" was one of the greatest of all battle hymns, and that "Morfa Rhuddlan," the ancient Cymric dirge, had never been surpassed as a piece of funereal music. Some of the old Welsh hymn tunes he regarded as unique in their wistfulness and devout aspiration; and as for Welsh choral singing, he thought it was matchless for richness, fire and harmony.

    CHAPTER IX

    LITERATURE AND ETHICS

    Without the blessing of reading the burden of life would be
    intolerable and the riches of life reduced to the merest penury.

    GLADSTONE.

    The taste for reading stores the mind with pleasant thoughts,
    banishes ennui, fills up the unoccupied interstices and enforced
    leisures of an active life; and if it is judiciously managed it is
    one of the most powerful means of training character and
    disciplining and elevating thought. To acquire this taste in early
    life is one of the best fruits of education.

    LECKY: "THE MAP OF LIFE."

    From his childhood Paul Jones had been a voracious and an omnivorous reader. He read with amazing rapidity. The first book he enjoyed whole-heartedly was Mabel Dearmer's "Noah's Ark Geography," one of the best children's books written in the past twenty years. He read and re-read this book as a little boy and used to talk lovingly of Kit and his friends, Jum-Jum and the Cockyolly Bird. Alas! Kit (Mrs. Dearmer's son Christopher) and his gifted mother have been claimed as victims by the World War.

    Paul revelled in "Æsop's Fables," "Robinson Crusoe," "The Swiss Family Robinson," "Don Quixote," "Treasure Island," "The Arabian Nights," "Gulliver's Travels," and classical legends. As he grew older he passed on to "The Mabinogion," "The Pilgrim's Progress," Lamb's "Tales of Shakespeare," and writers like Henty, Manville Fenn, Clark Russell, W. H. Fitchett and P. G. Wodehouse. He followed with delight the adventures of Sherlock Holmes, whose charm never faded for him. He made a point of reading everything written by Conan Doyle.

    But he gave first place among living writers to George Bernard Shaw, and next place to H. G. Wells. He would never miss a Shaw play. His delight at the first performance he saw of John Bull's Other Island was boisterous. He loved to read that play as well as to see it performed. The glimpses of Ireland and the portraits of Irish character enchanted him.

    Broadbent--typifying the self-complacency of the well-meaning but Philistine Victorian who had solved to his own satisfaction all mysteries in earth and heaven--he regarded as a masterpiece of creative art. For Kipling his admiration was qualified; but he loved "M'Andrews' Hymn," and often recited lines from the "Recessional." Of the great novelists Dickens was easily his first favourite; a long way behind came Scott, Stevenson and Jules Verne.

    Dickens he knew and loved in every mood. Pickwick like Falstaff was to him a source of perennial delight. He loved and honoured Dickens for his rich and tender humanity, the passion of pity that suffused his soul, the lively play of his comic fancy. Endowed with a keen sense of humour, he read Mark Twain and W. W. Jacobs with gusto. As a relaxation from historical studies he would sometimes devour a bluggy story, and as he read would shout with laughter at its grotesque out-topping of probabilities. He tried his own hand at sensational yarns. I recall one of them, rich in gory incidents, with a villain who is constantly leaping from a G.W.R. express to elude his pursuers.

    Among his papers I found the manuscript of a detective story, vivaciously written after the Sherlock Holmes and Watson manner.

    At one time Paul liked to read Homer and Thucydides, Virgil and Tacitus; but as soon as he was at home in the wide realm of English literature he thrust the old classics from him, and subsequently his hard historical reading gave him no opportunity, even if he had felt the desire, to revert to Greek and Latin writers. But he was fully conscious of the world's debt in culture to Greece and in law and government to Rome. He wrote: "The influence of Greek thought, Greek form, Greek art, is universal and eternal."

    Of all names in literature he reverenced most that of Shakespeare, in whom he saw "the spirit of the Renaissance personified," and whom he described "as romantic, philosophic, realistic, and as varied and impersonal as Nature." He was never weary of reading the tragedies and historical plays. He resented any word in disparagement of Shakespeare, and could not understand the inability of a supreme artist like Tolstoy to appreciate his greatness.

    Though he has written a noble sonnet in homage to Shakespeare's genius, Matthew Arnold once permitted himself to say that "Homer leaves Shakespeare as far behind as perfection leaves imperfection." Paul wrote in a marginal note, "Bosh! to put it bluntly." He would say with Goethe, "The first page of Shakespeare made me his for life, and when I had perused an entire play I stood like one born blind, to whom sight by some miraculous power had been restored in a moment." Paul and I often exchanged ideas on Shakespeare.

    He was lost in wonder at Shakespeare's creative power, his inexhaustible fertility, the universality of his range, the perfection of his portraiture, his mastery over all moods, his cunning artistry in the use of words, his exuberant imagery and effortless ease. He made a pilgrimage to Stratford-on-Avon to see with his own eyes the spots and scenes amid which Shakespeare's youth and declining years were spent. The smiling beauty of Stratford and the rich rural charm of its surroundings left on his mind a delightful impression that was never erased.

    Next to Shakespeare his admiration flowed out to Milton. When he went into the battle-line he took with him only two books--his Shakespeare and his Milton.

    With Milton's character he had some marked affinities--the virginal purity of Milton's youth, his love of learning, his hatred of all tyrannies, secular and spiritual, making a strong appeal to the sympathies of my son. "Milton," he wrote, "is perhaps the very grandest figure in English history." "In Milton the spirit of Puritanism is combined with a purely Hellenic love of beauty." "'Paradise Lost' may be regarded (1) as a reflection of the Puritan point of view; (2) as a poem pure and simple; (3) as an epic of the classical school."

    Profound as was his admiration for "Paradise Lost," he could not forbear smiling at Taine's quip that the Miltonic Adam is "your true Paterfamilias, a member of the Opposition, a Whig, a Puritan, who entered Paradise via England."

    Paul extolled Pope's ingenuity and metrical felicity--he has thoroughly annotated the "Essay on Man"--but was acutely conscious of aridity and the absence of rapture and vision in Pope as in Dryden. He singled out as "the finest passage in the 'Essay on Man'" the eight lines in which Pope contrasts the majesty of the Universe with the insignificance of man, beginning:

    Let earth unbalanced from her orbit fly,
    Planets and suns run lawless through the sky.

    He had not much respect for Pope's philosophy, and, commenting on one passage in the same poem, writes: "Pope, like many other unsound reasoners, when his position becomes dangerous, seeks to vindicate himself by insults."

    Above all nineteenth-century poets he loved Wordsworth, the revelation of whose richness and glory only came to him after he was seventeen.

    There were no bounds to his admiration for the Wordsworth sonnets.

    Many a time since the War he would recite the glorious sonnet which proclaims that

    We must be free or die, who speak the tongue
    That Shakespeare spake, the faith and morals hold
    Which Milton held. In every thing we are sprung
    Of Earth's first blood, have titles manifest.

    The magic of Keats and his adoration of beauty struck a responsive chord in Paul's nature. Tennyson did not stir him to the depths of his being like Wordsworth. "Ulysses," "The Revenge," and "Crossing the Bar" were the only Tennyson poems that he cared for. In an essay written when he was eighteen he defined poetry as "the soul of man put into untrammelled speech, the voice of angels, the music of the spheres." He read with critical discernment, sometimes agreeing, sometimes disagreeing, with the author. It was his habit when reading a book to mark passages that impressed him and make comments in the margin.

    Some of his obiter dicta shall be given. In judging them it should be remembered that they were all pronounced before he was nineteen.

    How aptly said that Dante seems to have tried to write a poem
    with a sculptor's chisel or a painter's brush.

    Froissart observes clearly, but his observation is limited to the
    world of nobles and chivalry; he ignores the life, the sufferings
    and the joys of the people.

    Ben Jonson, master of dignified declamatory drama, was the
    greatest of the post-Shakespeare school. We may justly say
    post-Shakespeare, though Jonson was nearly contemporaneous with
    the Bard of Avon, because the influence of such a man clearly
    belongs to an age in which the freedom and romantic magnificence
    of Shakespeare have been forgotten.

    Gibbon is the first of historians. The "Decline and Fall of the
    Roman Empire" runs its course like some majestic river.

    Burns is a microcosm of Scotland.

    Burke--a stainless and beautiful character. A theorist in
    practice; a practical man in theory.

    Burke's view of Rousseau was biased and unjust.

    Though contemptuous of Wordsworth, Byron himself is a romantic of
    the romanticists. He was the guiding star of rebels the world
    over.

    In the calm purity of his verse, Shelley is more classic than
    romantic. What ecstatic melody in his lyrics!

    Dickens is often mawkish and often portrays oddities; but these
    oddities do exist, especially in London (e.g., Sam Weller, Mrs.
    Todgers, Jo, etc.), and Dickens unearthed them for the first
    time. How his heart warms for the poor and the wretched! He is
    the great poet of London life.

    Macaulay is not a philosophic writer; but then the English genius
    is certainly non-philosophic.

    Froude in his essay on Homer says: "The authors of the Iliad and
    the Odyssey stand alone with Shakespeare far away above mankind."
    Paul's marginal note: "Add to them Milton, Goethe, the author of
    the Nibelungen-lied, Browning."

    Froude, I think, has misunderstood the Nibelungen-lied entirely.
    There is really much savagery and much glory in both the German
    and the Greek epic.

    How strange that men like Rabelais and Swift, Goldsmith and
    Dickens, who have done so much to make the world laugh,
    experienced in their own lives great unhappiness.

    Browning is always an optimist. His manliness and vigour are
    unfailing:

    I find earth not grey but rosy,
    Heaven not grim but fair of hue.
    Do I stoop? I pluck a posy.
    Do I stand and stare? All's blue.

    Paul considered that Macaulay lacked ideas and vision. He liked the lilt and swing of the Lays and Ballads, and enjoyed the Essays with their superb colouring. Disputing Macaulay's dictum that neither painters nor poets are helped by the advances in civilisation, science and refinement, he wrote: "This argument disproved by the examples of men like Shakespeare and Goethe, like Browning and Kipling. And did not Leonardo da Vinci become a student of anatomy in order to learn how to depict the human body properly on his canvas?"

    Macaulay in his Essay on Mackintosh's "History of The Revolution" describes the condition of England in 1678, after eighteen years of Charles the Second's reign, in graphic words, beginning "Such was the nation which, awaking from its rapturous trance, found itself sold to a foreign, a despotic, a Popish court, defeated on its own seas and rivers by a State of far inferior resources, and placed under the rule of pandars and buffoons."

    Paul's comment reads: "This superb passage is one of the most inspired of Macaulay's utterances. Contrast with it in the same Essay the vivid sentence beginning 'In the course of seven centuries,' in which he pronounces a magnificent panegyric on the greatness of Britain."

    He thought the music of Macaulay's prose had often a metallic sound, and that it suffered from excess of epithet and addiction to antithetical phrases. In pithiness of style, sureness of touch and dispassionate judgment, he contrasted Acton as an historical writer with Macaulay, to the latter's disadvantage. He found every page of Acton packed with thought, every essay richly freighted with ideas.

    Moreover, Acton was sternly impartial and impersonal in his judgment of persons and in his estimate of influences. Paul wrote:

    There has never been in historical writing such inexorable logic,
    such compact phraseology, so much pith and point, as are to be
    found in Acton's Essays.

    His view of Carlyle was thus expressed: "Take away his style and half his greatness vanishes. Carlyle's works are not English in spirit, nor have they any point of resemblance to those of any other English writer." As for his views: "he has, alas! no love for democracy."

    Carlyle's habit of apotheosising heroes and his worship of the Strong Man made Paul pose the familiar problem: "Is the great man the fashioner of his age, or its product?" He thought something was to be said on both sides, and that it was impossible to lay down a positive proposition on what he called "this terribly difficult question." But he agreed with Guizot that "great events and great men are fixed points and summits of historical survey." He emphasises the fact that in his "French Revolution" Carlyle, in spite of his hero-worship, accepts the evolutionary view of history.

    Among essayists he had a special liking for Froude, Matthew Arnold and Edmund Gosse.

    He often turned for refreshment to Froude's "Short Studies," and felt the fascination of his "Erasmus." In his essay on the Book of Job, Froude writes: "Happiness is not what we are to look for; our place is to be true to the best which we know; to seek that and do that." On this my son comments: "I don't hold with this idea; for, while happiness is not the end, yet it always in its purest and brightest form comes to the really good or great man in the consciousness of the work he has done." Froude in his essay on "Representative Men" enlarges on the importance of educating boys by holding up before them the pattern of noble lives.

    By picturing the career of a noble man rising above temptation and "following life victoriously and beautifully forward," Froude thinks you will kindle a boy's heart as no threat of punishment here or hereafter will kindle it. On this Paul writes: "A noble plea for an education of youth far more effective than the cursed nonsense of forbidding this or that on penalty of hell-fire."

    Matthew Arnold, whom in some moods he admired, occasionally got on his nerves. I find this footnote on a page of "Culture and Anarchy": "This is self-satisfied swank." On another page: "Matthew Arnold himself often wanting in sweetness and light." On another: "Admirably put; here I do agree with M. A." He liked Arnold's essay on "The Function of Criticism," although he differed from some of the author's judgments.

    "The French Revolution took a political, practical character," wrote Arnold; on which my son's comment is: "Surely the French Revolution was only one aspect of a great world-movement of liberation! One side of it is Romanticism; another the Revolution itself; yet another, the Industrial Revolution. No movement has ever a character sui generis." On Joubert's remark: "Force and Right are the governors of this world, Force till Right is ready," his comment is: "A regular German theory." Paul's final note on "The Function of Criticism" reads:

    I consider that Matthew Arnold insists too much on the
    non-practical element of criticism. After all, it is the lesson
    of life that the practical man wins in the end. When we are
    brought face to face with the realities of things--as in a war
    like the present one--all thought of art and letters simply
    vanishes. How is it that the mass of the world is always
    inartistic? How is it that the one people in the world--the
    Greeks--who built up their State on what Arnold regards as ideal
    conditions, collapsed in headlong ruin before the inartistic but
    practical Romans?

    This comment illustrates one effect of the War on Paul's mind: he was becoming less of an idealist and more of a realist.

    For Mr. W. H. Hudson's "Introduction to the Study of Literature" he had high esteem. This book he has carefully annotated. Of Mr. Hudson's remarks on the contrast between the style of Milton and that of Dryden, between Hooker and Defoe, he writes: "A comparison of remarkable discernment.

    The difference between the Miltonic and Drydenic styles, i.e., pre-1660 and post-1660, was simply due to the change in ideas caused by the reaction against Puritanism." Agreeing with Hudson that there is much poetry which is prosaic and much prose which is poetical, he cites as examples: "Prose in Poetry: Pope, Dryden, Walt Whitman.

    Poetry in Prose: Carlyle, Macaulay, Goethe." He did not concur with Hudson's remark that the "full significance of poetry can be appreciated only when it addresses us through the ear," and that "the silent perusal of the printed page will leave one of its principal secrets unsurprised." Paul's comment on this:

    Too sweeping a statement. Take, for example, poets like Milton
    and Browning, where every line is fraught with some deep
    philosophic meaning and must be pondered over for some time
    before the whole of the greatness of the poetry is realised. In
    these cases reading aloud is not nearly so good as private,
    silent study.

    He demurred to the proposition that while the function of Ethics is to instruct, that of Art is to delight. "I hold," he writes, "that Art's duty is to instruct as much as, if not more than, that of Ethics. Art to be great must elevate and edify." Hudson wrote: "The common view that the primitive ages of the world were ages of colossal individualism is grotesquely unhistorical; they were, on the contrary, ages in which group-life and group-consciousness were in the ascendant." "Quite true," notes Paul.

    "See Maine's 'Ancient Law,' where he points out that ancient history has nothing to do with the individual but only with groups." Another annotated book is Maeterlinck's "Wisdom and Destiny." To Maeterlinck's remark, "It is often of better avail from the start to seek that which is highest," he adds: "Always, not often." He heartily subscribed to Maeterlinck's doctrine that our attitude to life ought to be one of "gladsome, enlightened acceptance, not a hostile, gloomy submission."

    His philosophy of life was expressed in that beautiful passage in Carlyle's essay on "Characteristics":

    Here on earth we are as soldiers fighting in a foreign land; that
    understand not the plan of the campaign and have no need to
    understand it; seeing well what is at our hand to be done, let us
    do it like soldiers, with submission, with courage, with a heroic
    joy. "Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with all thy
    might." Behind us, behind each one of us, lie 6,000 years of
    human effort, human conquest.

    Before us is the boundless Time,
    with its as yet uncreated and unconquered continents and
    Eldorados, which we, even we, have to conquer, to create; and
    from the bosom of Eternity there shine for us celestial guiding
    stars.

    My inheritance, how wide and fair!
    Time is my fair seed-field, of Time I'm heir.

    The ethical side of Paul's character is reflected in the appended quotations from some of his essays:

    Sacrifice is always the lot of the divine man.

    What is "to do good"? It is to think of other people.

    Joy only comes to Faust when at last he is labouring for others.
    As Wolsey puts it in Henry VIII: "Love thyself last," and "bear
    peace in thy right hand."

    The Epicurean idea is vile and detestable. If everyone thinks
    only of his own indulgence, how can the wherewithal for that
    indulgence be forthcoming? What is the use of man having all his
    glorious gifts of character and intellect if he does not use
    them? Why is man made so different from the animals if he is to
    be the mere slave of his passions?

    Stoicism finally degenerates into mere pessimism.

    The great defect of Puritanism was its hostility to Art; for Art
    glorifies and ennobles Life.

    "What is the final cause of the Universe?" This is the old
    problem of the philosophers. Goethe's lines leap to the mind:

    "How, when and where?
    The Gods make no reply;
    To causes give thy care,
    And cease to question why."

    Carlyle in "Heroes and Hero Worship" shows the folly of
    condemning a man for the faults noted down by the world about
    him--by those blind to the true inner secret of his life. "Who
    art thou that judgest thy fellow?"

    Naturalism is illogical because it postulates Nature without
    mind.

    If you do not place faith in humanity, what really is the use of
    any philosophy of life?

    Let us remember St. Paul's injunction, "Bear ye one another's
    burdens."

    It is a thought to make one ponder, that by far the finest Life
    of Christ was written by an agnostic, Renan.

    Action is a great joy in life.

    When prehistoric man took up a flint and laboriously beat it into
    a shape that his brain told him would be of use to him, he laid
    the foundations of all civilisation. Man's progress is the story
    of brute force laid low by Thought--which is the one really
    irresistible influence in the Universe:

    "In the world there is nothing great but Man;
    In Man there is nothing great but Mind."

    It is a perplexing reflection that there is no absolute moral
    standard. The moral law appears to vary with environment and
    according to conditions of time and place. I am reminded of
    Pope's lines:

    "Where the extreme of vice was ne'er agreed.
    Ask where's the North? At York 'tis on the Tweed;
    In Scotland, at the Orcades; and there
    At Greenland, Zembla, or the Lord knows where."

    The greater a man is in one direction, the more prone he usually
    is to weakness in another: that is why we must never condemn
    indiscriminately.

    The laws governing the Universe, so far from being mechanical
    and dead, are elements filled with Truth and Beauty.

    Materialism is fatal to the higher instincts, because it
    introduces that most sordid element--earthly pomp, circumstance
    and recompense.

    The Universe, History, Life are before us. Why should they not be
    investigated? It is not true that science leads to Atheism or
    Fatalism. What science does is to destroy that fabric of
    Aberglaube or superstition which chokes and asphyxiates the
    best parts of religion. What science does is to set up a new,
    purer creed based on certainty and truth.

    Of French writers Paul liked most Taine, Sainte-Beuve, and Victor Hugo. His love of reading he took with him into the War. A box of books returned to us with his other effects from France included "The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius," Kant's "Critique of Pure Reason," Macaulay's "Essays," Saint-Simon's "Memoirs," Sainte-Beuve's "Causeries," "The Imitation of Christ," Lecky's "History of European Morals," and works by Goethe, Victor Hugo, Dumas the elder, Flaubert, Maurice Barrès, and Mrs. Humphry Ward.

    CHAPTER X

    HISTORY AND POLITICS

    History is philosophy teaching by examples.

    BOLINGBROKE.

    The science of Politics is the one science that is deposited by the
    stream of history, like grains of gold in the sand of a river.

    ACTON.

    Reared in the home of a political journalist, it was natural that Paul Jones should be attracted to public affairs. He followed with lively curiosity the progress of the two general elections of 1910, and from that year was an interested observer of political events. As he grew older his bent towards politics became more pronounced. A youth familiar with Roman, mediæval and modern history could not fail to be fascinated by the political drama unfolding before his eyes. He watched history in the making with the same eagerness that he read the history of the past. The prevailing tone at Dulwich, as at most public schools, is Conservative. Paul was a perfervid Liberal.

    In school and out of school, not only did he not disguise, he gloried in his advanced opinions. The extent of his political knowledge and the ripeness of his views were astonishing in one so young.

    From the moment he began to think for himself his sympathies flowed out to the wage-earning classes. What he remembered and what he had heard of his Puritan grandfather, William Jones, a grand specimen of the Victorian artisan, who died in December, 1905, on the verge of 80, deepened his regard for them. But his own broad and sympathetic nature would have drawn him instinctively to their side. In his judgment it was on and by the working-classes that the wheels of the world moved forward.

    He had nothing but contempt for the sparrow-like frivolity of fashionable Society, and was repelled from the middle classes by their servitude to conventions, their prejudices social and political, and their non-receptivity to ideas. He for his part must breathe an ampler air. He was wont to speak disdainfully of the Victorian era, because, in spite of all the advances it witnessed in the physical sciences and of Britain's rapid growth in wealth between 1850 and 1890, it did so little for social welfare.

    For feudal magnates and the nouveaux riches he had scant respect, holding that both the aristocracy and the plutocracy had used their political power for selfish ends. Old feudalism in some respects he regarded as better than new Capital, for the landed aristocracy did at least recognise some obligations to those under their sway, whereas Capital was so concerned with its rights that it forgot altogether its reciprocal duties.

    His view was that, under shelter of the laissez-faire system, with its false presumption that employers and employed were on a parity in bargaining power, Capital had scandalously evaded its obligations to Labour. He regarded the conditions of life in some of our industrial districts as a grave reproach to the nation. The lust for wealth and other unlovely aspects of competitive commercialism were most repugnant to him. He knew that Nature cares not a rap for equality and lavishes her gifts with a strange caprice.

    But though there is inequality of natural gifts, he thought it was the duty of the State to ensure equality of opportunity to all its citizens. His ideal was a co-operative commonwealth, in which the competitive spirit would be held in check by communal needs and aims, and where every career would be opened freely to talent.

    In one of his essays he deplores the fact that political economists had fallen into the delusion of applying the laws that govern the exchange of commodities without any variation to Labour, and leaving out of account intangibles and imponderables like moral forces and other expressions of the delicate and mysterious human spirit.

    Political economy, he thought, would have to be recast and humanised. "The economists," he said, "have entirely ignored the human factor."

    Paul's conviction was that when the rule of enlightened democracy was established wars would cease. "The peoples never want wars," he wrote; "under a pure democracy wars would be impossible." Because of the associations clustering around it the word "Imperialism" jarred on him, but he took pride in the greatness of the free and liberal British Empire, with its rule of law, its love of peace, its humane ideals. He had the historical sense in highly developed degree.

    The story of human progress stretched before the eye of his mind in a series of vivid pictures. Surveying the immense and imposing fabric of recorded events woven by the ceaseless loom of Time, he had an unerring instinct for the shining figures, the salient characteristic, the determining factor. Away from a library he could have written a quite tolerable essay on any century of the Christian era.

    Historical characters in whom he was specially interested were Julius Cæsar, Octavius, Charlemagne, the Emperor Charles V, Queen Elizabeth, Cromwell, Louis XIV, the elder Pitt, Frederick the Great, and Napoleon; and among the non-political Roger Bacon, Erasmus, Luther, Sir Thomas More, Isaac Newton, Faraday, and Darwin.

    The Elizabethan age had for him a magnetic attraction, because of the Queen with her enigmatical personality, marvellous statecraft and capacity for inspiring devotion, and of the brilliant galaxy of great men, statesmen and sailors, poets and scholars, who enriched her reign with so much glory. Another epoch he loved to study was that of the French Revolution. I have already referred to his habit of annotating the books he read. From notes he made on political books and from some of his essays I have culled the following:

    Man's tool-using power is simply a symbol of man's unique
    reasoning gifts. Its connotations may be extended to mean the
    entire intellect.

    The savage using his language with joy like a child, gives us the
    wealth of beautiful mythology about all natural objects.

    It is wonderful to think that Julius Cæsar's imperial system was
    handed right down to the nineteenth century, until one not unlike
    Cæsar himself set his foot upon its neck in 1806. But long before
    it fell the Holy Roman Empire had really ceased, in Voltaire's
    words, to be holy, or Roman, or an empire.

    Froude holds up to admiration the "serene calmness" of Tacitus,
    and says he took no side. But I ask anyone who has read the
    sarcastic remarks about Domitian and the Emperors in the
    "Agricola" whether he thinks Tacitus took no side in writing
    history.

    Nothing can alter the fact that Mohammedanism has done a vast
    amount of good. Compare Carlyle's appreciation of Mahomet with
    Gibbon's acrimonious insinuations.

    Much that is strange in human history is explained if we remember
    that aristocracies in the West were political, while in the East
    they were religious.

    Hildebrand, who boldly declared that the Church compared to the
    State was as the sun to the moon--the State only shining by light
    borrowed from the greater orb--was now on the papal throne. His
    giant intellect and tremendous personality had overawed Henry IV
    into ignominious capitulation at Canossa. With Europe at his feet
    Hildebrand cannot but have desired to assert his authority over
    the island-State across the Channel.

    William the Conqueror and
    Hildebrand were rarely-matched antagonists--the one determined to
    set bounds to the Pope's scheme of world-domination; the Pope
    equally determined to bend the stubborn Norman to his will. It
    was the Conqueror who won.

    The conception of the Norman Conquest has shifted from the
    grotesque over-estimate of Thierry to the under-estimate of
    Freeman and Maitland. To the moderns the Conquest is now little
    more than a change of dynasty. A juster estimate would be that
    the very change of dynasty gave the Conquest its vital
    importance.... The effects were really immense. The Conquest
    substituted for the degenerate race of Anglo-Saxon kings a virile
    dynasty able to give to England what it needed--a vigorous
    central administration--and brought the English people into the
    stream of European civilisation.

    It was the hope of Erasmus that Catholic forms could be blended
    with the Greek spirit.

    Luther's songs express the very soul of old Germany; above all,
    the great hymn "Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott."

    Though the Reformation in freeing the mind of man from
    ecclesiastical tyranny made eventually for political liberty, its
    whole tendency in England for the time being was in favour of
    absolute monarchy. Its first outcome here was to set up a secular
    monarchy, supreme in Church and State, founded on the theory of
    the divine right of kings, based on an aristocracy made loyal by
    the instinct of self-interest.

    Commerce and national wealth were at stake in the war between
    England and Spain in the sixteenth century, and not merely,
    perhaps not even mainly, religion.

    Drake was a very great sailor, but he was undoubtedly a
    buccaneer.

    Many Ministers had been sent to the block for offences far less
    rank than those of Charles I; nevertheless, his execution was
    absolutely illegal and a fatal mistake in policy.

    Few men experienced such hard treatment at the hands of fortune
    as Cromwell. In every case, save the rule of the major-generals,
    his constitutional experiments were wise, far-seeing and
    well-conceived. It was the perverse conduct of those who
    professed to be his followers that ruined all.

    There has never been a shrewder king on a throne than Charles II.

    In the popular view, James II will always be regarded as the
    tyrannical despot, the subverter of the religious and political
    institutions of England, while his brother, Charles II, will be
    looked upon as a kindly and amiable gentleman, who oppressed no
    one and treated everyone kindly. Yet in the view of the student
    of history Charles becomes the tyrant and James an honest though
    bigoted fool.

    To compare the age of Cromwell with that of Charles II is to see
    the Dorian and Lydian spirits respectively in their most
    contrasted lights.

    The difference between Richelieu and Mazarin is the difference
    between the creator and the developer.

    The political revolution of 1688 was contemporaneous with a
    revolution in physics, shown by Harvey's discovery of the
    circulation of the blood; with a revolution in astronomical
    thought, shown by Newton's "Principia"; with a small revolution
    in literature, shown by the rise of English prose; with a
    revolution in popular feeling all over the world, as shown by the
    riots against excessive taxation in France and the ejection of de
    Witt in Holland. All the different threads of life seem to run
    interwoven, and one cannot be disturbed without disturbing the
    others.

    The character of Frederick the Great was stained by many infamous
    deeds; he was in many ways unscrupulous, yet he was never petty,
    and he was devoted to his country. He was the greatest genius in
    practical reforms and in the art of war that the eighteenth
    century produced.

    Frederick the Great has had a far stronger and better influence
    on history than a selfish, callous person like Louis XIV.

    Of all the benevolent despots there is only one, Frederick the
    Great, to whom can be fitly applied what Johnson said of
    Goldsmith: "Let not his faults be remembered: he was a very great
    man."

    Under a despotism the aristocracy loses all its powers, and,
    except for the bureaucracy and "King's friends," there is no
    privileged class unless the King is a weak man and under the
    thumb of his court (e.g., contrast the France of Louis XIV with
    that of Louis XV).

    Carlyle in his "French Revolution" paints a wonderfully vivid
    picture of the idle, voluptuous noblesse of the eighteenth
    century: compare the views of de Tocqueville.

    Carlyle in his grim account of the death-bed of Louis XV writes:
    "We will pry no further into the horrors of a sinner's
    death-bed." Paul's comment: "cf. the episode of the death of
    Front-de-Boeuf in 'Ivanhoe.'"

    Lord Chesterfield saw clearly the symptoms of the coming
    Revolution in France. Only two other men in Europe foresaw that
    immense event: Goldsmith and Arthur Young. Note Gibbon's
    complacent attitude in re France to illustrate the general lack
    of vision on the subject.

    Voltaire's summing up of the consequences of Turgot's fall may be
    expressed in Sir Edward Grey's phrase: "Death, disaster and
    damnation."

    If Louis XVI had been wiser and more capable, would he have
    averted the French Revolution? I think not. It is to be doubted
    whether even a strong king, after so many years of tyranny which
    had generated such hatred of the ancient regime, could have
    checked the flow of forces making for the Revolution. Apart from
    the effect of the old tyranny, new ideas of democracy were
    arising. Witness the contemporary failure of a great benevolent
    despot in Joseph II.

    There was no idea of nationality in the foreign policy of the
    younger Pitt.

    Hilaire Belloc's description of the guillotining of the
    Dantonists forms a picture among the most thrilling, enthralling
    and agonising that I know.

    Fox stands out as one of the most brilliant failures and one of
    the most ineffective geniuses in history.

    Before war broke out in 1870 the world believed in the military
    superiority of France. Only that grim trio, Bismarck, Moltke and
    Roon, knew the contrary.

    William the First, grandfather of the present Kaiser, was an
    absurdly overestimated character. He owed all his success to his
    great Ministers.

    Treitschke writes: "The territories drained by great rivers are
    usually centres of civilisation.... Our Rhine remains the king of
    all rivers, but what great thing has ever happened on the
    Danube?" Paul's comment on this:

    "I know of only three great events on the Danube. One, the
    capture of Vienna by the Turks; two, the Battle of Blenheim;
    three, the Battle of Ulm."

    The Jews are a truly extraordinary race. Though they have for
    centuries been persecuted, despised, outcast, so far from being
    crushed by their sufferings, they seem actually to have been
    toughened in fibre, and to-day they exercise a commanding
    influence in the world.

    England's geographical position does not fit her for the rôle of
    a Continental Power. Her home is on the sea; her empire
    world-wide.

    Each race, each nation, has its own characteristics, its own
    peculiar type of civilisation. Attempts to destroy these inherent
    qualities have time and time again been baffled--as the examples
    of the Jews, Poland and Alsace-Lorraine clearly demonstrate....
    As Treitschke puts it: "The idea of a world-State is odious. The
    whole content of civilisation cannot be realised in a single
    State. Every people has the right to believe that certain powers
    of the Divine Reason display themselves in it at their highest."

    Patriotism may indeed be but a larger form of selfishness, but it
    is a larger form. It does involve devotion to others. As long as
    men are men, it is so unlikely as almost to be impossible that
    patriotism will ever be replaced by cosmopolitanism.

    A great point in favour of the rule of democracy is its
    character-building power.

    It is customary in a certain class of society to abuse
    trade-unionism. People talk of the tyranny of trade-unionism; it
    would be as easy, perhaps more justifiable, to talk of the
    tyranny of Capital. The trade union has its counterpart in what
    are termed the "upper classes." For example, the British Medical
    Association is nothing but a trade union under another name. The
    trade union is an absolute necessity to the worker in modern
    society.

    Laissez-faire has advantages up to a point; State control has
    advantages up to a point. The most successful nation will be that
    one which succeeds in making a judicious mixture of the two
    systems.

    The Englishman in his devil-may-care way does not trouble to
    persecute or oppress; his tolerant spirit, aided by the splendid
    devotion of a few great men, has, in the words of Seeley, built
    up a glorious free Empire "in a fit of absence of mind."

    You will never make the English people idealistic, but you will
    never conquer them on that very account.

    While the German talks and dreams of world-Empire, the Englishman
    smiles, puts his pipe in his mouth and goes off to found it by
    accident.

    The modern system of diplomacy is as vile as anything can be.
    Even in England it is the negation of popular government.

    Man's duty to his neighbour ought to be observed as well as the
    harsh and pitiless laws of trade and competition.

    The social conditions of our industrial towns to-day are a
    standing indictment of the laissez-faire system.

    The great warrior is no more important than the humble toiler.

    Gladstone's finance was governed by the determination to spend as
    little as possible. It does not seem to be so good as that of
    Lloyd George, viz., to be prepared to spend a great deal provided
    you are sure it is for the benefit of the people.

    On a remark of Dr. Sarolea's in re the alleged inherent
    antagonism between Europe and America on the one side and Asia
    and Africa on the other: "Absurd! If we are to be good Europeans
    we must first of all be good world citizens. The Asiatic is as
    much our brother as is the Belgian or the American."

    It is not the case that England has checked Germany's Colonial
    development. Germany has herself to blame--herself and destiny.
    But I must say that Germany had to some extent right on her side
    in the Morocco dispute.

    The Germans ignore the fact that wherever we British go we throw
    our ports open to the commerce of the world.

    In the autumn of 1914 my son read General von Bernhardi's book, "Germany and the Next War." In his notes on this book he drew attention to Bernhardi's frequent self-contradictions and his false philosophy. From these notes the following excerpts are taken:

    Here Bernhardi flatly contradicts the biological argument he uses
    earlier in the chapter. Biology knows nothing of States; it sees
    only human beings.

    Look at the intimate connection between Darwinism and the
    political and economic views of the Individualist Radicals of the
    mid-Victorian era.

    Bernhardi assumes that mere material existence is always to be
    man's destiny. But the perpetuation of existence beyond the
    immediate present cannot be guided by the instinct of grabbing.

    The modern theory is that good and bad as abstract considerations
    do not exist, but that they are what experience shows to be best
    for us in the end. The animal knows this subconsciously; man
    consciously to a certain extent.

    Emphatically No; mere brute force is not the law of the universe.

    Bernhardi may as well talk of conquering the moon as of
    conquering the U.S.A.

    Man's true development consists above all in the negation of his
    selfish elements for the good of humanity.

    Bernhardi's proposition, "Only the State which strives after an
    enlarged sphere of influence can create the conditions under
    which mankind develops into the most splendid perfection," Paul
    counters by asking: "How does this theory fit in with the case of
    the Greeks, who, politically so weak, were yet intellectually so
    great that to-day, after 2,000 years, their influence in Europe
    is as great as ever? Which would you rather have been, tiny
    Greece or vast Persia?"

    On Bernhardi's remark: "No excuse for revolutionary agitation in Germany now exists."

    No excuse? When the people have no power at all, and can at any
    moment be led to the slaughter by a pack of Junkers--"all for the
    good of the State"; in other words, to give the military caste
    more wealth and dignity. In a few years Bernhardi will see
    whether the people have any cause for revolution or not.

    The Germany of philosophy, poetry and song will rescue the German
    people from the abyss into which the War Lords have plunged them.

    Germany was indeed unfortunate in entering the world as a great
    Power so late. But she will not make any progress by perpetually
    brandishing a sword before Europe.

    I do think that Prussia's policy in the past was largely
    determined by her geographical situation.

    The Entente with France was the price we paid for Egypt. Germany
    never entered our thoughts at all.

    On Bernhardi's allusion to India, Paul wrote: "Curiously enough,
    the very day I read this I heard in the House of Commons the
    wonderful story of the gifts presented to the British Government
    for war purposes by the Indian princes. Such a passionate
    outburst of loyalty has never been equalled. This gratitude and
    devotion we have won not by the rule of force, but by that of
    justice and kindness."

    In regard to Bernhardi's prediction that our self-governing Dominions would separate from the British Empire:

    Our policy toward them nobly justified. Now in our time of need
    the Colonies have flown to our side.

    God help civilisation when the Bernhardis set to work on it!

    Strange that people so far apart as Bernhardi and we Socialists
    should yet be at one on this question of checking selfish
    individualism by measures of State Socialism.

    A frequent visitor to the Lobby and Press Gallery of the House of Commons, my son was known to many members of Parliament and political journalists. Thanks to his free, affable manner, he was on terms of cordial regard with several of the attendants and police-constables on duty in and about the House of Commons. His last visit to the Press Gallery was in May, 1916. He was stirred by the life and movement of the House and enjoyed a good Parliamentary debate, but he had a feeling that politicians were apt to mistake illusions for realities and to think that words could take the place of deeds.

    In the last three years of his life, though his democratic sympathies never waned, some of his opinions underwent a change. He was disappointed at the indifference of the masses of the people to their own interests, at their low standard of taste, at the ease with which they could be exploited by charlatans. I remember his telling me once, in 1915, apropos of the blatancy of some noisy patriots: "I now realise for the first time what Dr.

    Johnson meant when he wrote, 'Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel.'" He disliked the squalor of the political game and the glibness of tongue and tenuity of thought of the mere politician. A generous-minded youth of high ideals, he had not learnt to make allowances for political human nature, or for the fact that the mass of mankind are necessarily occupied with petits soins and apt to be dulled by the mechanical routine of their daily lives.

    Latterly he often told me that, after all, there was a great deal to be said for the rule of the enlightened autocrat. "But," he said, "the mischief is that you can't guarantee a succession of enlightened autocrats; so we must make the best of the rule of the majority." The backwardness of England in education used to make him wring his hands. To lack of education he attributed the tawdriness and vulgarity of popular taste. I thought my own political and social views were advanced: to Paul I was little better than a Whig with a veneration for Mr.

    Gladstone. He had a bold, forward-looking mind, and was in favour of root-and-branch changes. He was only 21 when he died, and his views on social and political questions would doubtless have been modified in one direction or another had he lived. But his passion for liberty of thought and action and his deep sympathy with the unprivileged multitude would have remained, for these things were inherent in his character.

    He would have said with Ibsen: "I want to awaken the democracy to its true task--of making all the people noblemen by freeing their wills and purifying their minds."

    Literature, athletics, music, politics did not exhaust the interests of this strong and eager mind. He was a good chess-player, and followed with lively curiosity the new developments in mechanics and aviation. Very fond of dogs, between him and our little fox-terrier there was a tie of deep affection. As indicative of the catholicity of his tastes I may mention that, going over his papers after his death, I discovered in the same drawer a manuscript appreciation of Wagner, "Football Hints," memoranda on "Pascal and Descartes on Method," and the outline of an essay on "The Norman Conquest and its Effects."

    CHAPTER XI

    IN THE ARMY

    Ever the faith endures,
    England, my England:
    "Take and break us, we are yours,"
    England, my own.

    W. E. HENLEY.

    In the first flush of enthusiasm for the War in 1914 Paul wanted to join the Public Schools Battalion, but I induced him to postpone doing so, pointing out that he had been preparing hard for an Oxford Scholarship, and that there would be ample time for him to join the Army after the examination early in December. My reasons were reinforced by his own desire to carry out his duties as Captain of Football.

    After winning the Balliol Scholarship, and with the knowledge that the number of recruits for the Army at that time was far in excess of the provision of equipment, he was persuaded to stay at Dulwich College till the end of the football season. But he became very restless in the early months of 1915. He had never cared for military exercises, much preferring free athletics, but in 1914 he had joined the O.T.C. at the College. He assiduously applied himself to drill and took part in many marches and several field-days.

    Meanwhile he followed every phase of the War with fascinated interest. He read all the War books he could get and began a War diary, which he entered up every week-end, giving a succinct account of the War's progress on land and sea and in the air. This diary he continued until he entered the Army, and at his request I have kept it up since.

    From copious entries by my son under the dates named the appended excerpts are taken. They indicate with what intelligence and comprehension he followed every phase of the War.

    August 18, 1914.--The British Expeditionary Force has landed
    safely in France: embarkation, transportation and debarkation
    carried out with great precision and without a single casualty.
    Our men have made a magnificent impression on the French people
    by their athletic demeanour, cheerfulness and orderly discipline.
    Their arrival a source of great moral strength to France.

    The Belgian King and Staff have left Brussels for Antwerp.

    August 30.--News filtering through of the retreat from Mons.
    After the battle of Charleroi and the collapse of the French on
    our right, the British troops fought stubbornly, but had to fall
    back before enormous forces of the enemy, which sought to
    annihilate them by sheer weight of numbers. In most difficult
    circumstances the ten days' retreat was carried out with
    wonderful skill.

    September 3 and 4.--The Germans now within forty miles of
    Paris. Note, however, these important considerations: (1) The
    German losses are terrific; (2) the whole Allied forces are
    absolutely intact and in good order. The situation is very
    different from that of 1870, when the French field armies were
    destroyed before the war had been in progress a month.

    The French Government has quitted Paris for Bordeaux.

    September 14-16.--It is now evident that the battle of the
    Marne was a great victory for the Franco-British forces. On
    September 6 the German advance southwards reached its extreme
    points at Coulommiers and Provins. This movement was covered by a
    large flanking force west of the Ourcq watching the outer Paris
    defences. The southward movement left the enemy's right wing in a
    dangerous position, as the Creil-Senlis-Compiègne line, by which
    the Germans had advanced, had been evacuated.

    The Allies attacked
    this wing in front and flank on September 8, and a French Army
    was hurried from Paris to attend to the flanking force. The
    frontal attack carried out by French and British. The enemy
    retreated skilfully to the line of the Ourcq, and from here tried
    to crush the French by a counter-attack. This failed utterly,
    and the enemy right wing-fell back over the Marne on September
    10, pursued by the French and the British. Large captures of
    German prisoners and guns.

    September 16.--Official report of the Belgian Commission on
    German atrocities too awful to read. The horrible things done by
    the Kaiser's brutal soldiery in Belgium must remove every vestige
    of respect for the Germans.

    September 19-21.--Conflict on the Aisne continues. No decisive
    advantage to either side: both armies now strongly entrenched.

    September 29-Oct. 2.--The pater came in very gloomy one night
    this week saying he had got information that could not be
    published to the effect that Antwerp must fall in a few days, and
    that the military situation in Belgium is as bad as it can be.

    October 12-15.--Ostend evacuated by the Belgian Government,
    which has moved to Havre. Germans have occupied Ghent and Bruges
    and are attempting a sweeping cavalry movement to and along the
    coast. This coincident with an infantry advance on Calais, which
    was skilfully checked by a British force that had lain concealed
    near Ypres.

    October 18.--German troops in Belgium are now in contact with
    von Kluck's army; that is, they are on the right of the force
    that invaded France, roughly on a line drawn from a point a few
    miles north of Lille to Ostend. The Allies still occupy part of
    Belgium including Fleurbaix, Ypres and the surrounding portion of
    the right bank of the Lys. It was feared that the German force
    liberated by the fall of Antwerp would be able to combine with
    von Kluck, so as to effect a great turning movement on the
    Allies' left.

    Thanks, however, to the excellent railways in
    north-east France, skilful disposition of British and French
    forces, and the stubborn courage of our troops, this danger was
    averted. We have not only checked the movement, but have
    ourselves advanced, and the Allies' line to the sea is secure.

    November 15-22.--Lord Roberts died of pneumonia. He breathed
    his last at St. Omer in sound of the guns. He had gone to France
    to greet his beloved Indian soldiers. A fitting end for this
    really great man.

    December 13-20.--On Wednesday morning, December 16, German
    warships bombarded Scarborough and Hartlepool. This incident of
    no military value, but (1) it is a distinct "buck-up" for the
    Germans, as no hostile shots had struck any part of English soil
    before since the days of de Ruyter; (2) it may arouse unpleasant
    misgivings among unthinking people as to the functions and
    efficiency of our Navy. A tip-and-run bombardment only possible
    because the Germans can concentrate on any selected point of our
    coast, whereas we have to guard its whole length.

    Scarborough an
    undefended town, and the bombardment a gross breach of
    international law; but we are getting used now to that sort of
    thing.

    England has formally taken over Egypt, which hitherto had only
    been in our occupation, Turkey's suzerainty being recognised. The
    old Khedive, who is absent from the country and intriguing with
    the enemy, deposed, and Hussein Ali appointed Sultan.

    December 20-27.--Full story of the Falkland Islands victory now
    published. This swift, clean and sure naval stroke appears to
    have been planned from London by Sir John Fisher, the First Sea
    Lord. Von Spee, the German Admiral, with his two sons and other
    officers, went down on the Scharnhorst, refusing to surrender.

    January 3, 1915.--A rather blunt note from the U.S.A.
    complaining that American merchant vessels have been stopped and
    searched by our warships without justification, that serious
    delays have been caused, and that American commercial interests
    have suffered. Specific instances quoted, and freedom of American
    ships from molestation in the future demanded. It is the old
    question of the right of search come up again.

    January 17-24.--On Tuesday the famous Zeppelins made their
    first appearance on the English scene. Several of the airships
    appeared over Yarmouth, King's Lynn, Sheringham, and Sandringham.
    Many bombs dropped, but absolutely no military damage; total
    result, a number of innocent people killed and injured. This
    marvellous achievement said to have given vast joy to Berlin.
    Well, they are easily pleased. The destructive power of the Zepps
    has been greatly overrated.

    February, 1-8.--Early in the week von Tirpitz avowed Germany's
    intention to torpedo or otherwise destroy every British ship on
    the sea, whether a vessel of war or a merchant trader--this to
    be done without warning. Our Admiralty countered this declaration
    by announcing their intention of using neutral flags for
    non-combatant British vessels--a permissible ruse de guerre.
    Thus the Lusitania has set sail from New York flying the
    American flag. "Diamond cut diamond" with a vengeance!

    February 8-14.--U.S.A. warn Germany that any attack on a vessel
    flying the American flag before it is ascertained whether the
    flag is or is not fictitious will be "viewed as a serious
    matter."

    February 14-21.--The Germans have gained an immense victory
    over the Russians along a front extending from the Niemen to the
    Bzura, and Warsaw is as much in danger of capture as Paris was
    last September. With marvellous accuracy and skill Hindenburg
    seized the opportunity of using his railways in East Prussia to
    outflank the Russians on both sides. One fact stands out clear in
    the war--the British are the only troops who have as yet held
    their ground against the Germans. Of what use are our Allies?

    March 14-20.--Neuve Chapelle battle not the success for us that
    the first reports suggested. I fear some disagreeable facts are
    being concealed. The reticence imposed by the Censor is
    deplorable. We have suffered heavy casualties in winning a sector
    of two miles wide by one mile long: our gains disproportionate to
    our losses. We ought to have shaken the German position right up
    to Lille.

    March 21-28.--Fall of Przemysl to the Russians after a siege of
    203 days. The garrison that surrendered comprised nine Generals,
    ninety-three superior officers, 2,500 subalterns and officials,
    117,000 rank and file. This great success frees a large Russian
    force for active work elsewhere.

    Our Commander-in-Chief in France, Sir John French, in his last
    communiqué talks of a protracted war and warns us against
    over-sanguineness. "The protraction of the war depends entirely
    upon the supply of men and munitions. Should these be
    unsatisfactory the war will be accordingly prolonged."

    In Alsace the French have captured the position of
    Hartmannsweilerkopf; they have penetrated twelve miles into
    German territory.

    March 29-April 4.--The Dardanelles operations are fizzling out
    in melancholy fashion. Owing to the fact that we began the naval
    bombardment before our land forces had arrived, the Turks have
    been able to repair nearly all the damage. However, now that Ian
    Hamilton has arrived to direct operations in Gallipoli, things
    ought to begin to move.

    April 5-12.--The French have gained a position which overlooks
    and commands the whole of the Woevre Plain; they are now fighting
    like demons. This district (Lorraine) is very near to the French
    heart. The first substantial advance that the French have made
    since the battle of the Marne.

    No official news of any value from the British front (the Censor
    is hard at work), but for the last six days our casualties have
    been terrible. It is maddening to see this long catalogue of
    brave men killed or wounded and yet to have all information
    withheld.

    The Americans, having fallen out for a short time with us, are
    now quarrelling with the Germans, the cause being a very insolent
    message to the White House from the German Ambassador. In frantic
    tones Count Bernstorff demands that America shall cease to supply
    munitions of war to England and her Allies, his object being to
    neutralise the effect of our sea-power.

    Paul joined the Army on April 15, 1915, within a month of his 19th birthday. His application for a commission in the Infantry was refused point-blank because of his defective vision.

    The War Office authorities, much impressed by his school and athletic record, had requested him to undergo a special examination by an oculist; and on receipt of the oculist's report showing how extreme was his short sight, wrote to me on March 26, "It is quite impossible to think of passing him for a commission, as his sight is so very much below the necessary standard." Subsequently at an interview at the War Office he admitted that if his spectacles were lost or broken he would be helpless; but he said he would equip himself with several pairs to provide against such emergencies.

    It was pointed out to him that in wet weather rain-spots on the lenses of his glasses would obscure his vision.

    "I am willing to take the risk," was his reply.

    "Yes," came the rejoinder, "but as an officer you would be jeopardising other lives and not merely your own."

    He was constrained to admit the force of this reasoning. Nevertheless, his rejection for the Infantry was a grievous disappointment to him.

    Eventually he obtained a commission in the Army Service Corps. He was very proud to don the King's uniform. On April 15 he reported himself for duty at a home port which is the principal centre of supply for our armies abroad. There he remained for over three months. As his nature was in taking up any work, he got absorbed in his new duties, and, I am informed, executed them with the utmost efficiency. To keep himself physically fit he gave some of his leisure to golf and to long walks, some days tramping twenty miles and more.

    Looking forward impatiently to the prospect of going abroad, he used to worry himself by the thought that he, an athlete, had no more useful work to do than to superintend the unloading of railway trucks and the loading of vessels and seeing that supplies were up to specification. At Whitsuntide his mother, brother and I spent a week-end in the vicinity of the port where he was employed. One day we visited a little country town, where he had arranged to join us after his duty was done.

    Near to the town was a huge camp, also a hospital for wounded soldiers. We met Paul on his arrival by train and walked with him to the hotel. On the way he was kept busy acknowledging the salutes of soldiers who passed us. At tea he was grave and preoccupied--for him a most unusual mood. I rallied him on it, and asked whether he was in trouble with his C.O.

    "Certainly not," was his reply, "I get on excellently with the Colonel."

    Then a moment or two later he exclaimed with emotion, "Dad, I simply can't stand it."

    "Stand what!" I exclaimed.

    "I can't stand receiving the salutes of men who have fought or are going out to fight while I spend my time about wharves and warehouses."

    As he spoke his eyes filled with tears. To appease him was not easy.

    This outburst was indicative of something more than a fugitive mood.

    To his intense delight he received orders to go abroad a couple of months later. On July 27, 1915, he left England for France, in which country and Flanders the next two years of his life were to be spent.

    His first appointment abroad was that of Requisitioning Officer to the 9th Cavalry Brigade of the 1st Cavalry Division--a Brigade that took part in the severe fighting of the early months of the War and was now waiting eagerly for a fresh opportunity to display its prowess. Our Cavalry officers are a distinct type, with traditions and modes of life and thought of their own. Paul, to whom nothing human was alien, studied them with keen curiosity. He found them gay-hearted, chivalrous gentlemen, and soon shared their enthusiasm for horses.

    His experiences with the 9th Brigade are described in his letters. The psychology of the French peasantry and tradespeople with whom he came into contact also vastly interested him. It was very responsible work he had to do for a lad of 19, but he did it ably and zealously. He liked the work for its variety; it involved a great deal of riding on horseback and much motoring, and gave opportunities for practising his French.

    Yet from time to time he heard voices from the trenches calling him.

    He was always contrasting his lot with the hardships that were being patiently endured in the front line by, as he would say, "better men than myself." He received his promotion to lieutenant in the spring of 1916. His pleasure at that step upward was soon dashed by his appointment to a Supply Column. This "grocery work," as he characterised it, was most distasteful to him; he thought of throwing up his commission and trying to enlist as a private, but finally decided to seek a commission in the Royal Field Artillery.

    After two unhappy months in the Supply Column he was appointed in command of an ammunition working-party at an advanced railhead in the Somme battlefield. How he enjoyed this work his letters will show. It involved, however, the hanging up of his application for transfer to the R.F.A. In October, 1916, he was appointed Requisitioning Officer to the 2nd Cavalry Brigade. He rejoiced at his escape from the inglorious, albeit necessary, work of the Supply Column, and was soon at home with his new comrades.

    As time went on, it became more and more evident that our cavalry would not have much opportunity in the War. The enforced inaction preyed upon Paul's spirits, and in December he determined to do his utmost to exchange into a unit in the front line. In his application for transfer he put his preferences in this order: 1st, Infantry; 2nd, M.G.C., heavies; 3rd, Artillery. The authorities, realising that his extreme short sight disqualified him for the Infantry, assigned him to the Tank Corps, which he joined on February 13, 1917.

    Paul's delight at the change of employment was unbounded. His letters from the time he joined the Tank Corps sing with happiness. Having pushed all obstacles aside in order to walk the sacrificial road, he found great gladness in breasting its steeps. A singular change is discernible in his letters in the last seven months of his life. No longer was there any reference in them to political affairs at home or to international events.

    He who used to follow the progress of the world with so much intentness had not a word to say about the change in the Premiership of Great Britain, or any comment to offer on such momentous events as the overthrow of the Tsardom in Russia, and the entry into the war of

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    War Letters of a Public-School Boy
    Author
    Henry Paul Mainwaring Jones
    Release date
    July 6, 2009 [eBook #29333]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by Geetu Melwani, Sigal Alon, Christine P. Travers
    Most recently updated
    January 5, 2021
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by Geetu Melwani, Sigal Alon, Christine P. Travers
    and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
    https://www.pgdp.net
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
    [Transcriber's note: Obvious printer's errors have been corrected.
    Hyphenation and accentuation have been standardised, all
    other inconsistencies are as in the original. The author's spelling
    has been maintained.]
    
    
    
    
    WAR LETTERS
    
    OF A
    
    PUBLIC-SCHOOL BOY
    
    
    
    
    [Illustration: Lieut. Paul Jones.
    
    (_From a Photograph by his Brother._)]
    
    
    
    
    WAR LETTERS
    
    OF A
    
    PUBLIC-SCHOOL BOY
    
    BY
    
    PAUL JONES
    
    Lieutenant of the Tank Corps
    
    Scholar-Elect of Balliol College, Oxford: Head of the Modern Side
    and Captain of Football, Dulwich College, 1914
    
    
    WITH A MEMOIR BY HIS FATHER
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of War Letters of a Public-School Boy
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: War Letters of a Public-School Boy
    
    Author: Henry Paul Mainwaring Jones
    
    
            
    Release date: July 6, 2009 [eBook #29333]
                    Most recently updated: January 5, 2021
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/29333
    
    Credits: Produced by Geetu Melwani, Sigal Alon, Christine P. Travers
            and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at
            https://www.pgdp.net
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #29333. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 29333
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-22
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.