
Gutenberg · ebook 28556
History of Woman Suffrage, Volume III
by unknown · English · public domain in the US
History of Woman Suffrage, Volume III is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #28556). [Transcriber's Note: Every effort has been made to replicate this text as faithfully as possible, including obsolete and variant spellings and other inconsistencies. Text that has been changed to correct an obvious error is noted at the end of this ebook.
PREFACE.
The labors of those who have edited these volumes are not only finished as far as this work extends, but if three-score years and ten be the usual limit of human life, all our earthly endeavors must end in the near future. After faithfully collecting material for several years, and making the best selections our judgment has dictated, we are painfully conscious of many imperfections the critical reader will perceive.
But since stereotype plates will not reflect our growing sense of perfection, the lavish praise of friends as to the merits of these pages will have its antidote in the defects we ourselves discover. We may however without egotism express the belief that this volume will prove specially interesting in having a large number of contributors from England, France, Canada and the United States, giving personal experiences and the progress of legislation in their respective localities.
Into younger hands we must soon resign our work; but as long as health and vigor remain, we hope to publish a pamphlet report at the close of each congressional term, containing whatever may be accomplished by State and National legislation, which can be readily bound in volumes similar to these, thus keeping a full record of the prolonged battle until the final victory shall be achieved. To what extent these publications may be multiplied depends on when the day of woman's emancipation shall dawn.
For the completion of this work we are indebted to Eliza Jackson Eddy, the worthy daughter of that noble philanthropist, Francis Jackson. He and Charles F. Hovey are the only men who have ever left a generous bequest to the woman suffrage movement. To Mrs.
Eddy, who bequeathed to our cause two-thirds of her large fortune, belong all honor and praise as the first woman who has given alike her sympathy and her wealth to this momentous and far-reaching reform. This heralds a turn in the tide of benevolence, when, instead of building churches and monuments to great men, and endowing colleges for boys, women will make the education and enfranchisement of their own sex the chief object of their lives.
The three volumes now completed we leave as a precious heritage to coming generations; precious, because they so clearly illustrate--in her ability to reason, her deeds of heroism and her sublime self-sacrifice--that woman preeminently possesses the three essential elements of sovereignty as defined by Blackstone: "wisdom, goodness and power." This has been to us a work of love, written without recompense and given without price to a large circle of friends.
A thousand copies have thus far been distributed among our coadjutors in the old world and the new. Another thousand have found an honored place in the leading libraries, colleges and universities of Europe and America, from which we have received numerous testimonies of their value as a standard work of reference for those who are investigating this question. Extracts from these pages are being translated into every living language, and, like so many missionaries, are bearing the glad gospel of woman's emancipation to all civilized nations.
Since the inauguration of this reform, propositions to extend the right of suffrage to women have been submitted to the popular vote in Kansas, Michigan, Colorado, Nebraska and Oregon, and lost by large majorities in all; while, by a simple act of legislature, Wyoming, Utah and Washington territories have enfranchised their women without going through the slow process of a constitutional amendment.
In New York, the State that has led this movement, and in which there has been a more continued agitation than in any other, we are now pressing on the legislature the consideration that it has the same power to extend the right of suffrage to women that it has so often exercised in enfranchising different classes of men.
Eminent publicists have long conceded this power to State legislatures as well as to congress, declaring that women as citizens of the United States have the right to vote, and that a simple enabling act is all that is needed. The constitutionality of such an act was never questioned until the legislative power was invoked for the enfranchisement of women.
We who have studied our republican institutions and understand the limits of the executive, judicial and legislative branches of the government, are aware that the legislature, directly representing the people, is the primary source of power, above all courts and constitutions. Research into the early history of this country shows that in line with English precedent, women did vote in the old colonial days and in the original thirteen States of the Union.
Hence we are fully awake to the fact that our struggle is not for the attainment of a new right, but for the restitution of one our fore-mothers possessed and exercised.
All thoughtful readers must close these volumes with a deeper sense of the superior dignity, self-reliance and independence that belong by nature to woman, enabling her to rise above such multifarious persecutions as she has encountered, and with persistent self-assertion to maintain her rights. In the history of the race there has been no struggle for liberty like this. Whenever the interest of the ruling classes has induced them to confer new rights on a subject class, it has been done with no effort on the part of the latter.
Neither the American slave nor the English laborer demanded the right of suffrage. It was given in both cases to strengthen the liberal party. The philanthropy of the few may have entered into those reforms, but political expediency carried both measures. Women, on the contrary, have fought their own battles; and in their rebellion against existing conditions have inaugurated the most fundamental revolution the world has ever witnessed.
The magnitude and multiplicity of the changes involved make the obstacles in the way of success seem almost insurmountable.
The narrow self-interest of all classes is opposed to the sovereignty of woman. The rulers in the State are not willing to share their power with a class equal if not superior to themselves, over which they could never hope for absolute control, and whose methods of government might in many respects differ from their own.
The annointed leaders in the Church are equally hostile to freedom for a sex supposed for wise purposes to have been subordinated by divine decree. The capitalist in the world of work holds the key to the trades and professions, and undermines the power of labor unions in their struggles for shorter hours and fairer wages, by substituting the cheap labor of a disfranchised class, that cannot organize its forces, thus making wife and sister rivals of husband and brother in the industries, to the detriment of both classes.
Of the autocrat in the home, John Stuart Mill has well said: "No ordinary man is willing to find at his own fireside an equal in the person he calls wife." Thus society is based on this fourfold bondage of woman, making liberty and equality for her antagonistic to every organized institution. Where, then, can we rest the lever with which to lift one-half of humanity from these depths of degradation but on "that columbiad of our political life--the ballot--which makes every citizen who holds it a full-armed monitor"?
LIST OF ENGRAVINGS.
VOL. III.
PHOEBE W. COUZINS Frontispiece.
MARILLA M. RICKER page 112
FRANCES E. WILLARD 129
JANE H. SPOFFORD 192
HARRIET H. ROBINSON 273
PHEBE A. HANAFORD 337
ARMENIA S. WHITE 369
LILLIE DEVEREUX BLAKE 417
RACHEL G. FOSTER 465
CORNELIA C. HUSSEY 481
MAY WRIGHT SEWALL 545
ELIZABETH BOYNTON HARBERT 592
SARAH BURGER STEARNS 656
CLARA BEWICK COLBY 689
HELEN M.
GOUGAR 704
LAURA DEFORCE GORDON 753
ABIGAIL SCOTT DUNIWAY 769
CAROLINE E. MERRICK 801
MARY B. CLAY 817
MENTIA TAYLOR 833
PRISCILLA BRIGHT MCLAREN 864
## GEORGE SAND 896
CONTENTS.
PAGE
CHAPTER XXVII.
THE CENTENNIAL YEAR--1876.
The Dawn of the New Century--Washington Convention--Congressional Hearing--Woman's Protest--May Anniversary--Centennial Parlors in Philadelphia--Letters and Delegates to Presidential Conventions--50,000 Documents sent out--The Centennial Autograph Book--The Fourth of July--Independence Square--Susan B. Anthony reads the Declaration of Rights--Convention in Dr. Furness' Church, Lucretia Mott, Presiding--The Hutchinson Family, John and Asa--The Twenty-eighth Anniversary, July 19, Edward M. Davis, Presiding--Letters, Ernestine L. Rose, Clarina I. H. Nichols--The Ballot-Box--Retrospect--The Woman's Pavilion 1
CHAPTER XXVIII.
NATIONAL CONVENTIONS, HEARINGS AND REPORTS.
1877-1878-1879.
Renewed Appeal for a Sixteenth Amendment--Mrs. Gage Petitions for a Removal of Political Disabilities--Ninth Washington Convention, 1877--Jane Grey Swisshelm--Letters, Robert Purvis, Wendell Phillips, Francis E. Abbott--10,000 Petitions Referred to the Committee on Privileges and Elections by Special Request of the Chairman, Hon. O. P. Morton, of Indiana--May Anniversary in New York--Tenth Washington Convention, 1878--Frances E.
Willard and 30,000 Temperance Women Petition Congress--40,000 Petition for a Sixteenth Amendment--Hearing before the Committee on Privileges and Elections--Madam Dahlgren's Protest--Mrs. Hooker's Hearing on Washington's Birthday--Mary Clemmer's Letter to Senator Wadleigh--His Adverse Report--Thirtieth Anniversary, Unitarian Church, Rochester, N. Y., July 19, 1878--The Last Convention Attended by Lucretia Mott--Letters, William Lloyd Garrison, Wendell Phillips--Church Resolution Criticised by Rev. Dr.
Strong--International Women's Congress in Paris--Washington Convention, 1879--Favorable Minority Report by Senator Hoar--U. S.
Supreme Court Opened to Women--May Anniversary at St.
Louis--Address of Welcome by Phoebe Couzins--Women in Council Alone--Letter from Josephine Butler, of England--Mrs. Stanton's Letter to The National Citizen and Ballot-Box 57
CHAPTER XXIX.
CONGRESSIONAL REPORTS AND CONVENTIONS.
1880-1881.
Why we Hold Conventions in Washington--Lincoln Hall Demonstration--Sixty-six Thousand Appeals--Petitions Presented in Congress--Hon. T. W. Ferry of Michigan in the Senate--Hon. Geo. B.
Loring of Massachusetts in the House--Hon. J. J. Davis of North Carolina Objected--Twelfth Washington Convention--Hearings before the Judiciary Committee of both Houses, 1880--May Anniversary at Indianapolis--Series of Western Conventions--Presidential Nominating Conventions--Delegates and Addresses to each--Mass-Meeting at Chicago--Washington Convention, 1881--Memorial Service to Lucretia Mott--Mrs. Stanton's Eulogy--Discussion in the Senate on a Standing Committee--Senator McDonald of Indiana Champions the Measure--May Anniversary in Boston--Conventions in the chief cities of New England 150
CHAPTER XXX.
CONGRESSIONAL DEBATES AND CONVENTIONS.
1882-1883.
Prolonged Discussions in the Senate on a Special Committee to Look After the Rights of Women, Messrs. Bayard, Morgan and Vest in Opposition--Mr. Hoar Champions the Measure in the Senate, Mr. Reed in the House--Washington Convention--Representative Orth and Senator Saunders on the Woman Suffrage Platform--Hearings Before Select Committees of Senate and House--Reception Given by Mrs.
Spofford at the Riggs House--Philadelphia Convention--Mrs. Hannah Whitehall Smith's Dinner--Congratulations from the Central Committee of Great Britain--Majority and Minority Reports in the Senate--E. G. Lapham, J. Z. George--Nebraska Campaign--Conventions in Omaha--Joint Resolution Introduced by Hon. John D. White of Kentucky, Referred to the Select Committee--Washington Convention, January 24, 25, 26, 1883--Majority Report in the House. 198
CHAPTER XXXI.
MASSACHUSETTS.
The Woman's Hour--Lydia Maria Child Petitions Congress--First New England Convention--The New England, American and Massachusetts Associations--Woman's Journal--Bishop Gilbert Haven--The Centennial Tea-Party--County Societies--Concord Convention--Thirtieth Anniversary of the Worcester Convention--School Suffrage Association--Legislative Hearing--First Petitions--The Remonstrants Appear--Women in Politics--Campaign of 1872--Great Meeting in Tremont Temple--Women at the Polls--Provisions of Former State Constitutions--Petitions, 1853--School-Committee Suffrage, 1879,--Women Threatened with Arrest--Changes in the Laws--Woman Now Owns her own Clothing--Harvard Annex--Woman in the Professions--Samuel E.
Sewall and William I. Bowditch--Supreme-Court Decisions--Sarah E.
Wall--Francis Jackson--Julia Ward Howe--Mary E. Stevens--Lucia M.
Peabody--Lelia Josephine Robinson--Eliza (Jackson) Eddy's Will 265
CHAPTER XXXII.
CONNECTICUT.
Prudence Crandall--Eloquent Reformers--Petitions for Suffrage--The Committee's Report--Frances Ellen Burr--Isabella Beecher Hooker's Reminiscences--Anna Dickinson in the Republican Campaign--State Society Formed October 28, 29, 1869--Enthusiastic Convention in Hartford--Governor Marshall Jewell--He recommends More Liberal Laws for Women--Society Formed in New Haven, 1871--Governor Hubbard's Inaugural, 1877--Samuel Bowles of the Springfield Republican--Rev. Phebe A.
Hanaford, Chaplain, 1870--John Hooker, Esq., Champions the Suffrage Movement--The Smith Sisters--Mary Hall--Chief-Justice Park--Frances Ellen Burr--Hartford Equal Rights Club 316
CHAPTER XXXIII.
RHODE ISLAND.
Senator Anthony in North American Review--Convention in Providence--State Association organized, Paulina Wright Davis, President--Report of Elizabeth B. Chase--Women on School Boards--Women's Board of Visitors to the Penal and Correctional Institutions--Dr. Wm. F. Channing--Miss Ida Lewis--Letter of Frederick A. Hinckley--Last Words of Senator Anthony 339
CHAPTER XXXIV.
MAINE.
Women on School Committees--Elvira C. Thorndyke--First Suffrage Society organized, 1868, Rockland--Portland Meeting, 1870--John Neal--Judge Goddard--Colby University Open to Girls, August 12, 1871--Mrs. Clara Hapgood Nash Admitted to the Bar, October 26, 1872--Tax-Payers Protest--Ann F. Greeley, 1872--March, 1872, Bill for Woman Suffrage Lost in the House, Passed in the Senate by Seven Votes--Miss Frank Charles, Register of Deeds--Judge Reddington--Mr.
Randall's Motion--Moral Eminence of Maine--Convention in Granite Hall, Augusta, January, 1873, Hon. Joshua Nye, President--Delia A.
Curtis--Opinions of the Supreme Court in Regard to Women Holding Offices--Governor Dingley's Message, 1875--Convention, Representatives Hall, Portland, Judge Kingsbury, President, Feb. 12, '76--The two Snow Families--Hon. T. B. Reed 351
CHAPTER XXXV.
NEW HAMPSHIRE.
Nathaniel P. Rogers--Parker Pillsbury--Galen Foster--The Hutchinson Family--First Organized Action, 1868--Concord Convention--William Lloyd Garrison's Letter--Rev. S. L. Blake Opposed--Rev. Mr. Sanborn in Favor--Concord Monitor--Armenia S. White--A Bill to Protect the Rights of Married Men--Minority and Majority Reports--Women too Ignorant to Vote--Republican State Convention--Women on School Committees, 1870--Voting at School District Meetings, 1878--Mrs.
White's Address--Mrs. Ricker on Prison Reform--Judicial Decision in Regard to Married Women, 1882--Letter from Senator Blair 367
CHAPTER XXXVI.
VERMONT.
Clarina Howard Nichols--Council of Censors--Amending the Constitution--St. Andrew's Letter--Mr. Reed's Report--Convention Called--H. B. Blackwell on the Vermont Watchman--Mary A.
Livermore in the Woman's Journal--Sarah A. Gibbs' Reply to Rev.
Mr. Holmes--School Suffrage, 1880 383
CHAPTER XXXVII.
NEW YORK--1860-1885.
Saratoga Convention, July 13, 14, 1869--State Society Formed, Martha C. Wright, President--The Revolution Established, 1868--Educational Movement--New York City Society, 1870, Charlotte B.
Wilbour, President--Presidential Campaign, 1872--Hearings at Albany, 1873--Constitutional Commission--An Effort to Open Columbia College, President Barnard in Favor--Centennial Celebration, 1876--School Officers--Senator Emerson of Monroe, 1877--Governor Robinson's Veto--School Suffrage, 1880--Governor Cornell Recommended it in his Message--Stewart's Home for Working Women--Women as Police--An Act to Prohibit Disfranchisement--Attorney-General Russell's Adverse Opinion--The Power of the Legislature to Extend Suffrage--Great Demonstration in Chickering Hall, March 7, 1884--Hearing at Albany, 1885--Mrs.
Blake, Mrs. Stanton, Mrs. Rogers, Mrs. Howell, Gov. Hoyt of Wyoming
395
CHAPTER XXXVIII.
PENNSYLVANIA.
Carrie Burnham--The Canon and Civil Law the Source of Woman's Degradation--Women Sold with Cattle in 1768--Women Arrested in Pittsburg--Mrs. McManus--Opposition to Women in Colleges and Hospitals; John W. Forney Vindicates their Rights--Ann Preston--Women in Dentistry--James Truman's Letter--Swarthmore College--Suffrage Association Formed in 1866, in Philadelphia--John K. Wildman's Letter--Judge William S. Pierce--The Citizens' Suffrage Association, 333 Walnut Street, Edward M.
Davis, President--Petitions to the Legislature--Constitutional Convention, 1873--Bishop Simpson, Mary Grew, Sarah C. Hallowell, Matilda Hindman, Mrs. Stanton, Address the Convention--Messrs. Broomall and Campbell Debate with the Opposition--Amendment Making Women Eligible to School Offices--Two Women Elected to Philadelphia School Board, 1874--The Wages of Married Women Protected--J. Edgar Thomson's Will--Literary Women as Editors--The Rev. Knox Little--Anne E.
McDowell--Women as Physicians in Insane Asylums--The Fourteenth Amendment Resolution, 1881--Ex-Gov. Hoyt's Lecture on Wyoming 444
CHAPTER XXXIX.
NEW JERSEY.
Women Voted in the Early Days--Deprived of the Right by Legislative Enactment in 1807--Women Demand the Restoration of Their Rights in 1868--At the Polls in Vineland and Roseville Park--Lucy Stone Agitates the Question--State Suffrage Society Organized in 1867--Conventions--A Memorial to the Legislature--Mary F.
Davis--Rev. Phebe A. Hanaford--Political Science Club-- Mrs.
Cornelia C. Hussey--Orange Club, 1870--Mrs. Devereux Blake gives the Oration, July 4, 1884--Dr. Elizabeth Blackwell's Letter--The Laws of New Jersey in Regard to Property and Divorce--Constitutional Commission, 1873--Trial of Rev. Isaac M.
See--Women Preaching in his Pulpit--The Case Appealed--Mrs. Jones, Jailoress--Legislative Hearings 476
CHAPTER XL.
OHIO.
The First Soldiers' Aid Society--Mrs. Mendenhall--Cincinnati Equal Rights Association, 1868--Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital--Hon. J. M. Ashley--State Society, 1869--Murat Halstead's
Letter--Dayton Convention, 1870--Women Protest Against
Enfranchisement--Sarah Knowles Bolton--Statistics on Coeducation by Thomas Wentworth Higginson--Woman's Crusade, 1874--Miriam M.
Cole--Ladies' Health Association--Professor Curtis--Hospital for Women and Children, 1879--Letter from J. D. Buck, M. D.--March, 1881, Degrees Conferred on Women--Toledo Association, 1869--Sarah Langdon Williams--The Sunday Journal--The Ballot-Box--Constitutional Convention--Judge Waite--Amendment Making Women Eligible to Office--Mr. Voris, Chairman Special Committee on Woman Suffrage--State Convention, 1873--Rev. Robert McCune--Centennial Celebration--Women Decline to Take
Part--Correspondence--Newbury Association--Women Voting,
1871--Sophia Ober Allen--Annual Meeting, Painesville, 1885--State Society, Mrs. Frances M. Casement, President--Adelbert College 491
CHAPTER XLI.
MICHIGAN.
Women's Literary Clubs and Libraries--Mrs. Lucinda H.
Stone--Classes of Girls in Europe--Ernestine L. Rose--Legislative Action, 1849-1885--State Woman Suffrage Society, 1870--Annual Conventions--Northwestern Association--Wendell Phillips'
Letter--Nannette Gardner votes--Catharine A. F. Stebbins
Refused--Legislative Action--Amendments Submitted--An Active Canvas of the State by Women--Election Day--The Amendment Lost, 40,000 Men Voted in Favor--University at Ann Arbor Opened to Girls, 1869--Kalamazoo Institute--J. A. B. Stone--Miss Madeline Stockwell and Miss Sarah Burger Applied for Admission to the University in 1857--Episcopal Church Bill--Local Societies--Quincy--Lansing--St.
Johns--Manistee--Grand Rapids--Sojourner Truth--Laura C.
Haviland--Sybil Lawrence 513
CHAPTER XLII.
INDIANA.
The First Woman Suffrage Convention After the War, 1869--Amanda M.
Way--Annual Meetings, 1870-85, in the Larger Cities--Indianapolis Equal Suffrage Society, 1878--A Course of Lectures--In May, 1880, National Convention in Indianapolis--Zerelda G. Wallace--Social Entertainment--Governor Albert G. Porter--Susan B. Anthony's Birthday--Schuyler Colfax--Legislative Hearings--Temperance Women of Indiana--Helen M. Gougar--General Assembly--Delegates to Political Conventions--Women Address Political Meetings--Important Changes in the Laws for Women, from 1860 to 1884--Colleges Open to Women--Demia Butler--Professors--Lawyers--Doctors--Ministers--Miss Catharine Merrill--Miss Elizabeth Eaglesfield--Rev. Prudence Le Clerc--Dr. Mary F.
Thomas--Prominent Men and Women--George W.
Julian--The Journals--Gertrude Garrison 533
CHAPTER XLIII.
ILLINOIS.
Chicago a Great Commercial Centre--First Woman Suffrage Agitation, 1855--A. J. Grover--Society at Earlville--Prudence Crandall--Sanitary Movement--Woman in Journalism--Myra Bradwell--Excitement in Elmwood Church, 1868--Mrs. Huldah Joy--Pulpit Utterances--Convention, 1869, Library Hall, Chicago--Anna Dickinson, Robert Laird Collier Debate--Manhood Suffrage Denounced by Mrs. Stanton and Miss Anthony--Judge Charles B. Waite on the Constitutional Convention--Hearing before the Legislature--Western Suffrage Convention, Mrs.
Livermore, President--Annual Meeting at Bloomington--Women Eligible to School Offices--Evanston College--Miss Alta Hulett Medical Association--Dr. Sarah Hackett Stevenson--"Woman's Kingdom" in the Inter-Ocean--Mrs. Harbert--Centennial Celebration at Evanston--Temperance Petition, 180,000--Frances E. Willard--Social Science Association--Art Union--Jane Graham Jones at International Congress in Paris--Moline Association 559
CHAPTER XLIV.
MISSOURI.
Missouri the first State to Open Colleges of Law and Medicine to Woman--Liberal Legislation--Harriet Hosmer--Wayman Crow--Dr. Joseph N. McDowell--Works of Art--Women in the War--Adeline Couzins--Virginia L. Minor--Petitions--Woman Suffrage Association, May 8, 1867--First Woman Suffrage Convention, Oct. 6, 1869--Able Resolutions by Francis Minor--Action Asked for in the Methodist Church--Constitutional Convention--Mrs. Hazard's Report--National Suffrage Association, 1879--Virginia L. Minor Before the Committee on Constitutional Amendments--Mrs. Minor Tries to Vote--Her Case in the Supreme Court--Mrs. Annie R.
Irvine--"Oregon Woman's Union"--Miss Phoebe Couzins Graduates From the Law School, 1871--Reception by Members of the Bar--Speeches--Dr. Walker--Judge Krum--Hon. Albert Todd--Ex-Governor E. O. Stanard--Ex-Senator Henderson--Judge Reber--George M. Stewart--Mrs. Minor--Miss Couzins 594
CHAPTER XLV.
IOWA.
Beautiful Scenery--Liberal in Politics and Reforms--Legislation for Women--No Right yet to Joint Earnings--Early Agitation--Frances Dana Gage, 1854--Mrs. Amelia Bloomer Lectures in Council Bluffs, 1856--Mrs. Martha H. Brinkerhoff--Mrs. Annie Savery, 1868--County Associations Formed in 1869--State Society Organized at Mt.
Pleasant, 1870, Henry O'Connor, President--Mrs. Cutler Answers Judge Palmer--First Annual Meeting, Des Moines--Letter from Bishop Simpson--The State Register Complimentary--Mass-Meeting at the Capitol--Mrs. Savery and Mrs. Harbert--Legislative Action--Methodist and Universalist Churches Indorse Woman Suffrage--Republican Plank, 1874--Governor Carpenter's Message, 1876--Annual Meeting, 1882, Many Clergymen Present--Five Hundred Editors Interviewed--Miss Hindman and Mrs. Campbell--Mrs. Callanan Interviews Governor Sherman, 1884--Lawyers--Governor Kirkwood Appoints Women to Office--County Superintendents--Elizabeth S.
Cook--Journalism--Literature-- Medicine--Ministry--Inventions--President of a National Bank-- The Heroic Kate Shelly--Temperance--Improvement in the Laws 612
CHAPTER XLVI.
WISCONSIN.
Progressive Legislation--The Rights of Married Women--The Constitution Shows Four Classes Having the Right to Vote--Woman Suffrage Agitation--C. L. Sholes' Minority Report, 1856--Judge David Noggle and J. T. Mills' Minority Report, 1859--State Association Formed, 1869--Milwaukee Convention--Dr. Laura Ross--Hearing Before the Legislature--Convention in Janesville, 1870--State University--Elizabeth R. Wentworth--Suffrage Amendment, 1880, '81, '82--Rev. Olympia Brown, Racine, 1877--Madam Anneke--Judge Ryan--Three Days' Convention at Racine, 1883--Eveleen L. Mason--Dr. Sarah Munro--Rev. Dr.
Corwin--Lavinia Godell, Lawyer--Angie King--Kate Kane 638
CHAPTER XLVII.
MINNESOTA.
Girls in State University--Sarah Burger Stearns--Harriet E. Bishop, the First Teacher in St. Paul--Mary J. Colburn Won the Prize--Mrs.
Jane Grey Swisshelm, St. Cloud--Fourth of July Oration, 1866--First Legislative Hearing, 1867--Governor Austin's Veto--First Society at Rochester--Kasson--Almira W. Anthony--Mary P. Wheeler--Harriet M.
White--The W. C. T. U.--Harriet A. Hobart--Literary and Art Clubs--School Suffrage, 1876--Charlotte O. Van Cleve and Mrs. C. S.
Winchell Elected to School Board--Mrs. Governor Pillsbury--Temperance Vote, 1877--Property Rights of Married Women--Women as Officers, Teachers, Editors, Ministers, Doctors, Lawyers 649
CHAPTER XLVIII.
DAKOTA.
Influences of Climate and Scenery--Legislative Action, 1872--Mrs.
Marietta Bones--In February, 1879, School Suffrage Granted Women--Constitutional Convention, 1883--Matilda Joslyn Gage Addressed a Letter to the Convention and an Appeal to the Women of the State--Mrs. Bones Addressed the Convention in Person--The Effort to get the Word "Male" out of the Constitution Failed--Legislature of 1885--Major Pickler Presents the Bill--Carried Through Both Houses--Governor Pierce's Veto--Major Pickler's Letter 662
CHAPTER XLIX.
NEBRASKA.
Clara Bewick Colby--Nebraska Came into the Possession of the United States, 1803--The Home of the Dakotas--Organized as a Territory, 1854--Territorial Legislature--Mrs. Amelia Bloomer Addresses the House--Gen. Wm. Larimer, 1856--A Bill to Confer Suffrage on Women--Passed the House--Lost in the Senate--Constitution Harmonized with the Fourteenth Amendment--Admitted as a State March 1, 1867--Mrs. Stanton, Miss Anthony Lecture in the State, 1867--Mrs. Tracy Cutler, 1870--Mrs. Esther L. Warner's
Letter--Constitutional Convention, 1871--Woman Suffrage Amendment
Submitted--Lost by 12,676 against, 3,502 for--Prolonged Discussion--Constitutional Convention, 1875--Grasshoppers Devastate the Country--Inter-Ocean, Mrs. Harbert--Omaha Republican, 1876--Woman's Column Edited by Mrs. Harriet S. Brooks--"Woman's Kingdom"--State Society Formed, January 19, 1881, Mrs. Brooks President--Mrs. Dinsmoor, Mrs. Colby, Mrs. Brooks, before the Legislature--Amendment again Submitted--Active Canvass of the State, 1882--First Convention of the State Association--Charles F.
Manderson--Unreliable Politicians--An Unfair Count of Votes for Woman Suffrage--Amendment Defeated--Conventions in Omaha--Notable Women in the State--Conventions--Woman's Tribune Established in 1883 670
CHAPTER L.
KANSAS.
Effect of the Popular Vote on Woman Suffrage--Anna C. Wait--Hannah Wilson--Miss Kate Stephens, Professor of Greek in State University--Lincoln Centre Society, 1879--The Press--The Lincoln Beacon--Election, 1880--Sarah A. Brown, Democratic Candidate--Fourth of July Celebration--Women Voting on the School Question--State Society, 1884--Helen M. Gougar--Clara Bewick Colby--Bertha H. Ellsworth--Radical Reform Association--Mrs. A. G.
Lord--Prudence Crandall--Clarina Howard Nichols--Laws--Women in the Professions--Schools--Political Parties--Petitions to the Legislature--Col. F. G. Adams' Letter 696
CHAPTER LI.
COLORADO.
Great American Desert--Organized as a Territory, February 28, 1860--Gov. McCook's Message Recommending Woman Suffrage, 1870--Adverse Legislation--Hon. Amos Steck--Admitted to the Union, 1876--Constitutional Convention--Efforts to Strike Out the Word "Male"--Convention to Discuss Woman Suffrage--School Suffrage Accorded--State Association Formed, Alida C. Avery, President--Proposition for Full Suffrage Submitted to the Popular Vote--A Vigorous Campaign--Mrs. Campbell and Mrs. Patterson of Denver--Opposition by the Clergy--Their Arguments Ably Answered--D.
M. Richards--The Amendment Lost--The Rocky Mountain News 712
CHAPTER LII.
WYOMING.
The Dawn of the New Day, December, 1869--The Goal Reached in England and America--Territory Organized, May, 1869--Legislative Action--Bill for Woman Suffrage--William H. Bright--Gov. Campbell Signs the Bill--Appoints Esther Morris, Justice of the Peace, March, 1870--Women on the Jury, Chief-Justice Howe, Presiding--J.
W. Kingman, Associate-Justice, Addresses the Jury--Women Promptly Take Their Places--Sunday Laws Enforced--Comments of the Press--Judge Howe's Letter--Laramie Sentinel--J. H.
Hayford--Women Voting, 1870--Grandma Swain the First to Cast her Ballot--Effort to Repeal the Law, 1871--Gov. Campbell's Veto--Mr.
Corlett--Rapid Growth of Public Opinion in Favor of Woman Suffrage
726
CHAPTER LIII.
CALIFORNIA.
Liberal Provisions in the Constitution--Elizabeth T. Schenck--Eliza W. Farnham--Mrs. Mills' Seminary, now a State Institution--Jeannie Carr, State Superintendent of Schools--First Awakening--The Revolution--Anna Dickinson--Mrs. Gordon Addresses the Legislature, 1868--Mrs. Pitts Stevens Edits The Pioneer--First Suffrage Society on the Pacific Coast, 1869--State Convention, January 26, 1870, Mrs. Wallis, President--State Association Formed, Mrs.
Haskell of Petaluma, President--Mrs. Gordon Nominated for Senator--In 1871, Mrs. Stanton and Miss Anthony Visit California--Hon. A. A. Sargent Speaks in Favor of Suffrage for Women--Ellen Clark Sargent Active in the Movement--Legislation Making Women Eligible to Hold School Offices, 1873--July 10, 1873, State Society Incorporated, Sarah Wallis, President--Mrs. Clara Foltz--A Bill Giving Women the Right to Practice Law--The Bill Passed and Signed by the Governor--Contest Over Admitting Women into the Law Department of the University--Supreme Court Decision Favorable--Hon. A. A. Sargent on the Constitution and Laws--Journalists and Printers Silk Culture--Legislative Appropriation--Mrs.
Knox Goodrich Celebrates July 4, 1876--Imposing Demonstration--Ladies in the Procession 749
CHAPTER LIV.
THE PACIFIC NORTHWEST.
The Long Marches Westward--Abigail Scott Duniway--Mary Olney Brown--The First Steps in Oregon--Col. C. A. Reed--Judge G. W.
Lawson--1870--The New Northwest, 1871--Campaign, Mrs. Duniway and Miss Anthony--They Address the Legislature in Washington Territory--Hon. Elwood Evans--Suffrage Societies Organized at Olympia and Portland--Before the Oregon Legislature--Donation Land
Act--Hon. Samuel Corwin's Suffrage Bill--Married Woman's Sole
Traders' Bill--Temperance Alliance--Women Rejected--Major Williams Fights Their Battles and Triumphs--Mrs. H. A. Loughary--Progressive Legislation, 1874--Mob-Law in Jacksonville, 1879--Dr. Mary A.
Thompson--Constitutional Convention, 1878--Woman Suffrage Bill, 1880--Hon. W. C. Fulton--Women Enfranchised in Washington Territory, Nov. 15, 1883--Great Rejoicing, Bonfires, Ratification Meetings--Constitutional Amendment Submitted in Oregon and Lost, June, 1884--Suffrage by Legislative Enactment Lost--Fourth of July Celebrated at Vancouvers--Benjamin and Mary Olney Brown--Washington Territory--Legislation in 1867-68 Favorable to Women--Mrs. Brown Attempts to Vote and is Refused--Charlotte Olney French--Women Vote at Grand Mound and Black River Precincts, 1870--Retrogressive Legislation, 1871--Abby H. Stuart in Land-Office--Hon. William H.
White--Idaho and Montana 767
CHAPTER LV.
LOUISIANA--TEXAS--ARKANSAS--MISSISSIPPI.
St. Anna's Asylum, Managed by Women--Constitutional Convention, 1879--Women Petition--Clara Merrick Guthrie--Petition Referred to Committee on Suffrage--A Hearing Granted--Mrs. Keating--Mrs.
Saxon--Mrs. Merrick--Col. John M. Sandige--Efforts of the Women all in Vain--Action in 1885--Gov. McEnery--The Daily Picayune--Women as Members of the School Board--Physiology in the Schools--Miss Eliza Rudolph--Mrs. E. J. Nicholson--Judge Merrick's Digest of Laws--Texas--Arkansas--Mississippi--Sarah A. Dorsey 789
CHAPTER LV. (CONTINUED).
DISTRICT OF
COLUMBIA--MARYLAND--DELAWARE--KENTUCKY--TENNESSEE--VIRGINIA--WEST
VIRGINIA--NORTH CAROLINA--SOUTH
CAROLINA--FLORIDA--ALABAMA--GEORGIA.
Secretary Chase--Women in the Government Departments--Myrtilla Miner--Mrs. O'Connor's Tribute--District of Columbia Suffrage Bill--The Universal Franchise Association, 1867--Bill for a Prohibitory Law Presented by Hon. S. C. Pomeroy, 1869--A Bill for Equal Wages for the Women in the Departments, Introduced by Hon. S.
M. Arnell, 1870--In 1871 Congress Passed the Organic Act for the District Confining the Right of Suffrage to Males--In 1875 it Withdrew all Legislative Power from the People--Women in Law, Medicine, Journalism and the Charities--Dental College Opened to Women--Mary A. Stewart--The Clay Sisters--The School of Pharmacy--Elizabeth Avery Meriwether--Judge Underwood--Mary Bayard Clarke--Dr. Susan Dimock--Governor Chamberlain--Coffee-Growing--Priscilla Holmes Drake--Alexander H.
Stephens 808
CHAPTER LV. (CONCLUDED).
CANADA.
Miss Phelps of St. Catharines--The Revolt of the Thirteen Colonies--First Parliament--Property Rights of Married Women--School Suffrage Thirty Years--Municipal Suffrage, 1882, 1884--Women Voting in Toronto, 1886--Mrs. Curzon--Dr. Emily H.
Stone--Woman's Literary Club of Toronto--Nova Scotia--New Brunswick--Miss Harriet Stewart 831
CHAPTER LVI.
GREAT BRITAIN.
Women Send Members to Parliament--Sidney Smith, Sir Robert Peel, Richard Cobden--The Ladies of Oldham--Jeremy Bentham--Anne Knight--Northern Reform Society, 1858--Mrs.
Matilda Biggs--Unmarried Women and Widows Petition Parliament--Associations Formed in London, Manchester, Edinburgh, 1867--John Stuart Mill in Parliament--Seventy-three Votes for his Bill--John Bright's Vote--Women Register and Vote--Lord-Chief-Justice of England Declares their Constitutional Right--The Courts Give Adverse Decisions--Jacob Bright Secures the Municipal Franchise--First Public Meeting--Division on Jacob Bright's Bill to Remove Political Disabilities--Mr.
Gladstone's Speech--Work of 1871-72--Fourth Vote on the Suffrage Bill--Jacob Bright Fails of Reelection--Efforts of Mr. Forsyth--Memorial of the National Society--Some Account of the Workers--Vote of the New Parliament, 1875--Organized Opposition--Diminished Adverse Vote of 1878--Mr. Courtney's Resolution--Letters--Great Demonstrations at Manchester--London--Bristol--Nottingham--Birmingham--Sheffield-- Glasgow--Victory in the Isle of Man--Passage of the Municipal Franchise Bill for Scotland--Mr.
Mason's Resolution--Reduction of Adverse Majority to 16--Liberal Conference at Leeds--Mr.
Woodall's Amendment to Reform Bill of 1884--Meeting at Edinburgh--Other Meetings--Estimated Number of Women Householders--Circulars to Members of Parliament--Debate on the Amendment--Resolutions of the Society--Further Debate--Defeat of the Amendment--Meeting at St. James Hall--Conclusion 833
CHAPTER LVII.
CONTINENTAL EUROPE.
The Woman Question in the Back-ground--In France the Agitation Dates from the Upheaval of 1789;--International Women's Rights Convention in Paris, 1878--Mlle. Hubertine Auclert Leads the Demand for Suffrage--Agitation Began in Italy with the Kingdom--Concepcion Arenal in Spain--Coeducation in Portugal--Germany: Leipsic and Berlin--Austria in Advance of Germany Caroline Svetla of Bohemia--Austria Unsurpassed in Contradictions--Marriage Emancipates from Tutelage in Hungary--Dr. Henrietta Jacobs of Holland--Dr.
Isala Van Diest of Belgium--In Switzerland the Catholic Cantons Lag Behind--Marie Goegg, the Leader--Sweden Stands First--Universities Open to Women in Norway--Associations in Denmark--Liberality of Russia toward Women--Poland--The Orient--Turkey--Jewish Wives--The Greek Woman in Turkey--The Greek Woman in Greece--An Unique Episode--Woman's Rights in the American Sense not Known 895
CHAPTER LVIII.
REMINISCENCES.
BY E. C. S. 922
Appendix 955
INDEX 985
CHAPTER XXVII.
THE CENTENNIAL YEAR--1876.
The Dawn of the New Century--Washington Convention--Congressional
Hearing--Woman's Protest--May Anniversary--Centennial Parlors in
Philadelphia--Letters and Delegates to Presidential
Conventions--50,000 Documents sent out--The Centennial Autograph
Book--The Fourth of July--Independence Square--Susan B. Anthony
reads the Declaration of Rights--Convention in Dr. Furness'
Church, Lucretia Mott, Presiding--The Hutchinson Family, John and
Asa--The Twenty-eighth Anniversary, July 19, Edward M. Davis,
Presiding--Letters, Ernestine L. Rose, Clarina I. H.
Nichols--The
Ballot-Box--Retrospect--The Woman's Pavilion.
During the sessions of 1871-72 congress enacted laws providing for the celebration of the one-hundredth anniversary of American independence, to be held July 4, 1876, in Philadelphia, the historic city from whence was issued the famous declaration of 1776.
The first act provided for the appointment by the president of a "Centennial Commission," consisting of two members from each State and territory in the Union; the second incorporated the Centennial Board of Finance and provided for the issue of stock to the amount of $10,000,000, in 1,000,000 shares of $10 each. It was at first proposed to distribute the stock among the people of the different States and territories according to the ratio of their population, but subscriptions were afterward received without regard to States.
The stockholders organized a board of directors, April 1, 1873. The design of the exhibition was to make it a comprehensive display of the industrial, intellectual and moral progress of the nation during the first century of its existence; but by the earnest invitation of our government foreign nations so generally participated that it was truly, as its name implied, an "International and World's Exposition."
The centennial year opened amid the wildest rejoicing. In honor of the nation's birthday extensive preparations were made for the great event. Crowds of people eager to participate in the celebration, everywhere flocked from the adjacent country to the nearest village or city, filling the streets and adding to the general gala look, all through the day and evening of December 31,
- From early gas-light upon every side the blowing of horns,
throwing of torpedos, explosion of fire-crackers, gave premonition of more enthusiastic exultation. As the clock struck twelve every house suddenly blossomed with red, white and blue; public and private buildings burst into a blaze of light that rivaled the noon-day sun, while screaming whistles, booming cannon, pealing bells, joyous music and brilliant fire-works made the midnight which ushered in the centennial 1876, a never-to-be-forgotten hour.
Portraits of the presidents from Washington and Lincoln laurel-crowned, to Grant, sword in hand, met the eye on every side.
Stars in flames of fire lighted the foreign flags of welcome to other nations. Every window, door and roof-top was filled with gay and joyous people. Carriages laden with men, women and children in holiday attire enthusiastically waving the national flag and singing its songs of freedom. Battalions of soldiers marched through the streets; Roman candles, whizzing rockets, and gaily-colored balloons shot upward, filling the sky with trails of fire and adding to the brilliancy of the scene, while all minor sounds were drowned in the martial music. Thus did the old world and the new commemorate the birth of a nation founded on the principle of self-government.
The prolonged preparations for the centennial celebration naturally roused the women of the nation to new thought as to their status as citizens of a republic, as well as to their rightful share in the progress of the century.
The oft-repeated declarations of the fathers had a deeper significance for those who realized the degradation of disfranchisement, and they queried with each other as to what part, with becoming self-respect, they could take in the coming festivities.[1] Woman's achievements in art, science and industry would necessarily be recognized in the Exposition; but with the dawn of a new era, after a hundred years of education in a republic, she asked more than a simple recognition of the products of her hand and brain; with her growing intelligence, virtue and patriotism, she demanded the higher ideal of womanhood that should welcome her as an equal factor in government, with all the rights and honors of citizenship fully accorded.
During the entire century, women who understood the genius of free institutions had ever and anon made their indignant protests in both public and private before State legislatures, congressional committees and statesmen at their own firesides; and now, after discussing the right of self-government so exhaustively in the late anti-slavery conflict, it seemed to them that the time had come to make some application of these principles to the women of the nation.
Hence it was with a deeper sense of injustice than ever before that the National Suffrage Association issued the call for the annual Washington Convention of 1876:
CALL FOR THE EIGHTH ANNUAL WASHINGTON CONVENTION.--The National
Woman Suffrage Association will hold its Eighth Annual Convention
in Tallmadge Hall, Washington, D. C., January 27, 28, 1876. In
this one-hundredth year of the Republic, the women of the United
States will once more assemble under the shadow of the national
capitol to press their claims to self-government.
That property has its rights, was acknowledged in England long
before the revolutionary war, and this recognized right made "no
taxation without representation" the most effective battle-cry of
that period. But the question of property representation fades
from view beside the greater question of the right of each
individual, millionaire or pauper, to personal representation. In
the progress of the war our fathers grew in wisdom, and the
Declaration of Independence was the first national assertion of
the right of individual representation.
That "governments derive
their just powers from the consent of the governed,"
thenceforward became the watchword of the world. Our flag, which
beckons the emigrant from every foreign shore, means to him
self-government.
But while in theory our government recognizes the rights of all
people, in practice it is far behind the Declaration of
Independence and the national constitution. On what just ground
is discrimination made between men and women? Why should women,
more than men, be governed without their own consent? Why should
women, more than men, be denied trial by a jury of their peers?
On what authority are women taxed while unrepresented? By what
right do men declare themselves invested with power to legislate
for women? For the discussion of these vital questions friends
are invited to take part in the convention.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, President, Fayetteville, N. Y.
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, Ch'n Ex. Com., Rochester, N. Y.
At the opening session of this convention the president, Matilda Joslyn Gage, said:
I would remind you, fellow-citizens, that this is our first
convention in the dawn of the new century. In 1776 we inaugurated
our experiment of self-government. Unbelief in man's capacity to
govern himself was freely expressed by every European monarchy
except France.
When John Adams was Minister to England, the
newspapers of that country were filled with prophecies that the
new-born republic would soon gladly return to British allegiance.
But these hundred years have taught them the worth of liberty;
the Declaration of Independence has become the alphabet of
nations; Europe, Asia, Africa, South America and the isles of the
sea, will unite this year to do our nation honor. Our flag is
everywhere on sea and land.
It has searched the North Pole,
explored every desert, upheld religious liberty of every faith
and protected political refugees from every nation, but it has
not yet secured equal rights to women.
This year is to be one of general discussion upon the science of
government; its origin, its powers, its history. If our present
declaration cannot be so interpreted as to cover the rights of
women, we must issue one that will. I have received letters from
many of the Western States and from this District, urging us to
prepare a woman's declaration, and to celebrate the coming Fourth
of July with our own chosen orators and in our own way. I notice
a general awakening among women at this time. But a day or two
since the women of this District demanded suffrage for themselves
in a petition of 25,000 names.
The men are quiet under their
disfranchisement, making no attempt for their rights--fit slaves
of a powerful ring.
The following protest was presented by Mrs. Gage, adopted by the convention, printed and extensively circulated:
To the Political Sovereigns of the United States in Independence
Hall assembled:
We, the undersigned women of the United States, asserting our
faith in the principles of the Declaration of Independence and in
the constitution of the United States, proclaiming it as the best
form of government in the world, declare ourselves a part of the
people of the nation unjustly deprived of the guaranteed and
reserved rights belonging to citizens of the United States;
because we have never given our consent to this government;
because we have never delegated our rights to others; because
this government is false to its underlying principles; because it
has refused to one-half its citizens the only means of
self-government--the ballot; because it has been deaf to our
appeals, our petitions and our prayers;
Therefore, in presence of the assembled nations of all the world,
we protest against this government of the United States as an
oligarchy of sex, and not a true republic; and we protest against
calling this a centennial celebration of the independence of the
people of the United States.
Letters[2] were read and a series of resolutions were discussed and adopted:
Resolved, That the demand for woman suffrage is but the
next step in the great movement which began with Magna
Charta, and which has ever since tended toward vesting
government in the whole body of the people.
Resolved, That we demand of the forty-fourth congress, in
order that it may adequately celebrate the centennial year,
the admission to the polls of the women of all the
territories, and a submission to the legislatures of the
several States of an amendment securing to women the
elective franchise.
Resolved, That the enfranchisement of women means wiser
and truer wedlock, purer and happier homes, healthier and
better children, and strikes, as nothing else does, at the
very roots of pauperism and crime.
Resolved, That if Colorado would come into the Union in a
befitting manner for the celebration of the centennial of
the Declaration of Independence, she should give the ballot
to brothers and sisters, husbands and wives, and thus
present to the nation a truly free State.
Resolved, That the right of suffrage being vested in the
women of Utah by their constitutional and lawful
enfranchisement, and by six years of use, we denounce the
proposition about to be again presented to congress for the
disfranchisement of the women in that territory, as an
outrage on the freedom of thousands of legal voters and a
gross innovation of vested rights; we demand the abolition
of the system of numbering the ballots, in order that the
women may be thoroughly free to vote as they choose, without
supervision or dictation, and that the chair appoint a
committee of three persons, with power to add to their
number, to memorialize congress, and otherwise to watch over
the rights of the women of Utah in this regard during the
next twelve months.
BELVA A. LOCKWOOD presented the annual report: The question of
woman suffrage is to be submitted to the people of Iowa during
the present centennial year, if this legislature ratifies the
action of the previous one. Colorado has not embodied the word
"male" in her constitution, and a vigorous effort is being made
to introduce woman suffrage there. In Minnesota women are allowed
to vote on school questions and to hold office by a recent
constitutional amendment. In Michigan, in 1874, the vote for
woman suffrage was 40,000, about 1,000 more votes than were
polled for the new constitution.
The Connecticut legislature,
during the past year appointed a committee to consider and report
the expediency of making women eligible to the position of
electors for president and vice-president. The committee made a
unanimous report in its favor, and secured for its passage 82
votes, while 101 votes were cast against it. In Massachusetts,
Governor Rice, in his inaugural address, recommended to the
legislature to secure to women the right to vote for presidential
electors.
An address to the legislature of New York by Mesdames
Gage, Blake and Lozier upon this question, was favorably received
and extensively quoted by the press. At an agricultural fair in
Illinois the Hon. James R. Doolittle advocated household
suffrage. In the Senate of the thirteenth legislature of the
State of Texas, Senator Dohoney, Chairman of the Judiciary
Committee, made a report strongly advocating woman suffrage; and
in 1875, when a member of the Constitutional Convention, he
advocated the same doctrine, and was ably assisted by Hon. W. G.
L. Weaver.
The governor of that State, in his message,
recommended that women school teachers should receive equal pay
for equal work. The word "male" does not occur in the new
constitution. In the territories of Wyoming and Utah, woman
suffrage still continues after five years' experiment, and we
have not learned that households have been broken up or that
babies have ceased to be rocked.
Women physicians, women journalists and women editors have come
to be a feature of our institutions. Laura De Force Gordon, a
member of our association, is editing a popular daily--the
Leader--in Sacramento, Cal. Women are now admitted to the bar
in Kansas, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, Missouri, Utah, Wyoming and
the District of Columbia. They are eligible and are serving as
school superintendents in Kansas, Nebraska, Illinois, Iowa and
Wisconsin. Illinois allows them to be notaries public. As
postmasters they have proved competent, and one woman, Miss Ada
Sweet, is pension agent at Chicago. Julia K.
Sutherland has been
appointed commissioner of deeds for the State of California. In
England women vote on the same terms as men on municipal,
parochial and educational matters. In Holland, Austria and
Sweden, women vote on a property qualification. The Peruvian
Minister of Justice has declared that Peru places women on the
same footing as men. Thus all over the world is the idea of human
rights taking root and cropping out in a healthful rather than a
spasmodic outgrowth.
The grand-daughter of Paley, true to her ancestral blood, has
excelled all the young men in Cambridge in moral science. Julia
J. Thomas, of Cornell University, daughter of Dr. Mary F. Thomas,
of Indiana, in the recent inter-collegiate contest, took the
first prize of $300, over eight male competitors, in Greek. The
recent decision in the United States Supreme Court, of Minor
vs. Happersett, will have as much force in suppressing the
individuality and self-assertion of women as had the opinion of
Judge Taney, in the Dred-Scott case, in suppressing the
emancipation of slavery.
The day has come when precedents are
made rather than blindly followed. The refusal of the Superior
Court of Philadelphia to allow Carrie S. Burnham to practice law,
because there was no precedent, was a weak evasion of common law
and common sense. One hundred years ago there was no precedent
for a man practicing law in the State of Pennsylvania, and yet we
have not learned that there was any difficulty in establishing a
precedent. I do not now remember any precedent for the
Declaration of Independence of the United Colonies, and yet
during a century it has not been overturned.
The rebellion of the
South had no precedent, and yet, if I remember, there was an
issue joined, and the United States found that she had
jurisdiction of the case.
The admission of women to Cornell University; their reception on
equal footing in Syracuse University, receiving in both equal
honorary degrees; the establishment of Wellesley College, with
full professorships and capable women to fill them; the agitation
of the question in Washington of the establishment of a
university for women, all show a mental awakening in the popular
mind not hitherto known. A new era is opening in the history of
the world. The seed sown twenty-five years ago by Mrs. Stanton
and other brave women is bearing fruit.
SARA ANDREWS SPENCER said it was interesting to pair off the
objections and let them answer each other like paradoxes. Women
will be influenced by their husbands and will vote for bad men to
please them. Women have too much influence now, and if we give
them any more latitude they will make men all vote their way.
Owing to the composition and structure of the female brain, women
are incapable of understanding political affairs. If women are
allowed to vote they will crowd all the men out of office, and
men will be obliged to stay at home and take care of the
children.
That is, owing to the composition and structure of the
female brain, women are so exactly adapted to political affairs
that men wouldn't stand any chance if women were allowed to enter
into competition with them. Women don't want it. Women shouldn't
have it, for they don't know how to use it. Grace Greenwood (who
was one of the seventy-two women who tried to vote) said men were
like the stingy boy at school with a cake. "Now," said he, "all
you that don't ask for it don't want it, and all you that do ask
for it sha'n't have it."
REV. OLYMPIA BROWN, pastor of the Universalist church in
Bridgeport, Conn., gave her views on the rights of women under
the constitution, and believed that they were entitled to the
ballot as an inalienable right. In this country, under existing
rulings of the courts as to the meaning of the constitution, no
one appeared likely to enjoy the ballot for all time except the
colored men, unless the clause, "previous condition of
servitude," as a congressman expressed it, referred to widows.
That being true, the constitution paid a premium only on colored
men, and widows.
If the constitution did not guarantee suffrage,
and congress did not bestow it, then the republic was of no
account and its boast devoid of significance and meaning. Its
life had been in vain--dead to the interests for which it was
created. She wanted congress to pass a sixteenth amendment,
declaring all its citizens enfranchised, or a declaratory act
setting forth that the constitution already guaranteed to them
that right.
Hon. FREDERICK DOUGLASS said he was not quite in accord with all
the sentiments that had been uttered during the afternoon, yet he
was willing that the largest latitude should be taken by the
advocates of the cause. He was not afraid that at some distant
period the blacks of the South would rise and disfranchise the
whites. While he was not willing to be addressed as the ignorant,
besotted creature that the negro is sometimes called, he was
willing to be a part of the bridge over which women should march
to the full enjoyment of their rights.
Miss PHOEBE COUZINS of St. Louis reviewed in an able manner the
decision of the Supreme Court in the case of Virginia L. Minor.
Mrs. DEVEREUX BLAKE spoke on the rights and duties of
citizenship.
She cited a number of authorities, including a
recent decision of the Supreme Court, to prove that women are
citizens, although deprived of the privileges of citizenship.
Taking up the three duties of citizenship--paying taxes, serving
on jury, and military service--she said woman had done her share
of the first for a hundred years; that the women of the country
now contributed, directly and indirectly, one-third of its
revenues, and that the House of Representatives had just robbed
them of $500,000 to pay for a centennial celebration in which
they had no part.
As for serving on jury, they did not claim that
as a privilege, as it was usually regarded as a most disagreeable
duty; but they did claim the right of women, when arraigned in
court, to be tried by a jury of their peers, which was not
accorded when the jury was composed wholly of men. Lastly, as to
serving their country in time of war, it was a fact that women
had actually enlisted and fought in our late war, until their sex
was discovered, when they were summarily dismissed without being
paid for their services.
Hon. Aaron A. Sargent, of California, in the United States Senate, and Hon. Samuel S. Cox, of New York, in the House of Representatives, presented the memorial asking the enfranchisement of the women of the District of Columbia, as follows:
IN THE SENATE, Tuesday, January 25, 1876.
Mr. SARGENT: I present a memorial asking for the establishment of
a government in the District of Columbia which shall secure to
its women the right to vote. This petition is signed by many
eminent ladies of the country: Mrs. Matilda Joslyn Gage,
President of the National Woman Suffrage Association, and the
following officers of that society: Lucretia Mott, Elizabeth Cady
Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, Henrietta Payne Westbrook, Isabella
Beecher Hooker, Mathilde F. Wendt, Ellen Clark Sargent; also by
Mary F. Foster, President of the District of Columbia Woman's
Franchise Association; Susan A. Edson, M. D.; Mrs. E. D. E.
N.
Southworth, the distinguished authoress; Mrs. Dr. Caroline B.
Winslow; Belva A. Lockwood, a practicing lawyer in this District;
Sara Andrews Spencer, and Mrs. A. E. Wood.
These intelligent ladies set forth their petition in language and
with facts and arguments which I think should meet the ear of the
Senate, and I ask that it be read by the secretary in order that
their desires may be known.
The PRESIDENT pro tempore: Is there objection? The chair hears
none, and the secretary will report the petition. The secretary
read:
To the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States in Congress assembled:
Whereas the Supreme Court of the United States has affirmed
the decision of the Supreme Court of the District of
Columbia in the cases of Spencer vs. The Board of
Registration, and Webster vs. The Judges of Election, and
has decided that "by the operation of the first section of
the fourteenth amendment to the Constitution of the United
States, women have been advanced to full citizenship and
clothed with the capacity to become voters; and further,
that this first section of the fourteenth amendment does not
execute itself, but requires the supervision of legislative
power in the exercise of legislative discretion to give it
effect"; and whereas the congress of the United States is
the legislative body having exclusive jurisdiction over the
District of Columbia, and in enfranchising the colored men
and refusing to enfranchise women, white or colored, made an
unjust discrimination against sex, and did not give the
intelligence and moral power of the citizens of said
District a fair opportunity for expression at the polls; and
whereas woman suffrage is not an experiment, but has had a
fair trial in Wyoming, where women hold office, where they
vote, where they have the most orderly society of any of the
territories, where the experiment is approved by the
executive officers of the United States, by their courts, by
their press and by the people generally, and where it has
"rescued that territory from a state of comparative
lawlessness" and rendered it "one of the most orderly in the
Union"; and whereas upon the woman suffrage amendment to
Senate bill number 44 of the second session of the
forty-third congress, votes were recorded in favor of woman
suffrage by the two senators from Indiana, the two from
Florida, the two from Michigan, the two from Rhode Island,
one from Kansas, one from Louisiana, one from Massachusetts,
one from Minnesota, one from Nebraska, one from Nevada, one
from Oregon, one from South Carolina, one from Texas, and
one from Wisconsin; and whereas a fair trial of equal
suffrage for men and women in the District of Columbia,
under the immediate supervision of congress, would
demonstrate to the people of the whole country that justice
to women is policy for men; and whereas the women of the
United States are governed without their own consent, are
denied trial by a jury of their peers, are taxed without
representation, and are subject to manifold wrongs resulting
from unjust and arbitrary exercise of power over an
unrepresented class; and whereas in this centennial year of
the republic the spirit of 1776 is breathing its influence
upon the people, melting away prejudices and animosities and
infusing into our national councils a finer sense of justice
and a clearer perception of individual rights; therefore,
We pray your honorable body to establish a government for
the District of Columbia which shall secure to its women the
right to vote.
Mr. SARGEANT: Even if this document were not accompanied by the
signatures of eminent ladies known throughout the land for their
virtues, intelligence and high character, the considerations
which it presents would be worthy of the attention of the senate.
I have no doubt that the great movement of which this is a part
will prevail. It is working its progress day by day throughout
the country. It is making itself felt both in social and
political life.
The petitioners here well say that there has been
a successful experiment of the exercise of female suffrage in one
of our territories; that a territory has been redeemed from
lawlessness; that the judges, the press, the people generally of
Wyoming approve the results of this great experiment. I know of
no better place than the capital of a nation where a more
decisive trial can be made, if such is needed, to establish the
expediency of woman suffrage. As to its justice, who shall deny
it?
I ask, for the purpose of due consideration, that this
petition be referred to the Committee on the District of
Columbia, so that in preparing any scheme for the government of
the District which is likely to come before this congress, due
weight may be given to the considerations presented.
The PRESIDENT pro tempore: The petition will be referred to the
Committee on the District of Columbia.
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES, Friday, March 31, 1876.
Mr. COX: Mr. Speaker, I am requested to present a memorial,
asking for a form of government in the District of Columbia which
shall secure to its women the right to vote; and I ask the grace
and favor to have this memorial printed in the Record.
Mr. BANKS: Mr. Speaker, I beg the privilege of saying a few words
in favor of the request made by the gentleman from New York who
presents this memorial. It is a hundred years this day since Mrs.
Abigail Adams, of Massachusetts, wrote to her husband, John
Adams, then a member of the continental convention, entreating
him to give to women the power to protect their own rights and
predicting a general revolution if justice was denied them. Mrs.
Adams was one of the noblest women of that period, distinguished
by heroism and patriotism never surpassed in any age.
She was
wife of the second and mother of the sixth president of the
United States, and her beneficent influence was felt in political
as well as in social circles. It was perhaps the first demand for
the recognition of the rights of her sex made in this country,
and is one of the centennial incidents that should be remembered.
It came from a good quarter. This memorial represents half a
million of American women. They ask for the organization of a
government in the District of Columbia that will recognize their
political rights.
I voted some years ago to give women the right
to vote in this District, and recalling the course of its
government I think it would have done no harm if they had enjoyed
political rights.
Mr. KASSON: I suggest that the memorial be printed without the
names.
Mr. COX: There are no names appended except those of the officers
of the National Woman Suffrage Association; and I hope they will
be printed with the memorial.
Mr. HENDEE: I trust the gentleman will allow this petition to be
referred to the committee of which I am a member: the Committee
for the District of Columbia. There being no objection, the
memorial was read and referred to the Committee for the District
of Columbia, and ordered to be printed in the Record.
At the close of the convention a hearing was granted to the ladies before the committees of the Senate and House of Representatives on the District of Columbia.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, of New York, said: Mr. Chairman and
Gentlemen of the Committee: On behalf of the National
Association, which has its officers in every State and territory
of the Union, and which numbers many thousands of members, and on
behalf of the Woman's Franchise Association of the District of
Columbia, we appear before you, asking that the right of suffrage
be secured equally to the men and women of this District. Art. 1,
sec. 8, clauses 17, 18 of the Constitution of the United States
reads:
Congress shall have power to exercise exclusive legislation
in all cases whatsoever over such district as may become the
seat of government of the United States, * * * * * to make
all laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying
into execution the foregoing powers.
Congress is therefore constitutionally the special guardian of
the rights of the people of the District of Columbia. It
possesses peculiar rights, peculiar duties, peculiar powers in
regard to this District. At the present time the men and women
are alike disfranchised. Our memorial asks that in forming a new
government they may be alike enfranchised. It is often said as
an argument against granting suffrage to women that they do not
wish to vote; do not ask for the ballot.
This association,
numbering thousands in the United States, through its
representatives, now asks you, in this memorial, for suffrage in
this District. Petitions from every State in the Union have been
sent to your honorable body. One of these, signed by thirty-five
thousand women, was sent to congress in one large roll; but what
is the value of a petition signed by even a million of an
unrepresented class?
The city papers of the national capital, once bitterly opposed to
all effort in this direction, now fully recognize the dignity of
the demand, and have ceased to oppose it. One of these said,
editorially, to-day, that the vast audiences assembling at our
conventions, the large majority being women, and evidently in
sympathy with the movement, were proof of the great interest
women take in this subject, though many are too timid to openly
make the demand.
The woman's temperance movement began two years
ago as a crusade of prayer and song, and the women engaged
therein have now resolved themselves into a national
organization, whose second convention, held in October last,
numbering delegates from twenty-two States, almost unanimously
passed a resolution demanding the ballot to aid them in their
temperance work. We who make our constant demand for suffrage,
knew that these women were in process of education, and would
soon be forced to ask for the key to all reform.
The ballot says yes or no to all questions. Without it women are
prohibited from practically expressing their opinions. The very
fact that the women of this District make this demand of you more
urgently than men proves that they desire it more and see its
uses better. The men of this District who quietly remain
disfranchised have the spirit of slaves, and if asking for the
ballot is any proof of fitness for its use, then the women who do
ask for it here prove themselves in this respect superior to men,
more alive to the interests of this District, and better fitted
to administer the government.
Women who are not interested in
questions of reform would soon become so if they possessed the
ballot. They are now in the condition we were when we heard of
the famine in Persia two years ago. Our sympathies were aroused
for a brief while, but Persia was far away, we could render it no
certain aid, and the sufferings of the people soon passed from
our minds.
Our approaching centennial celebration is to commemorate the
Declaration of Independence, which was based on individual
rights. For ages it was a question where the governing power
rightfully belonged; patriarch, priest, and monarch each claimed
it by divine right. Our country declared it vested in the
individual. Not only was this clearly stated in the Declaration
of Independence, but the same ground was maintained in the secret
proceedings upon framing the constitution. The old confederation
was abandoned because it did not secure the independence and
safety of the people.
It has recently been asked in congressional
debates, "What is the grand idea of the centennial?" The answer
was, "It is the illustration in spirit and truth of the
principles of the Declaration of Independence and of the
constitution."
These principles are:
First--The natural rights of each individual.
Second--The exact equality of these rights.
Third--That rights not delegated are retained by the
individual.
Fourth--That no person shall exercise the rights of others
without delegated authority.
Fifth--That non-use of rights does not destroy them.
Rights did not come new-born into the world with the revolution.
Our fathers were men of middle age before they understood their
own rights, but when they did they compelled the recognition of
the world, and now the nations of the earth are this year invited
to join you in the celebration of these principles of free
government.
We have special reasons for asking you to secure suffrage to the
women of the District of Columbia. Woman Suffrage has been tried
in Wyoming, and ample testimony of its beneficial results has
been furnished, but it is a far distant territory, and those not
especially interested will not examine the evidence. It has been
tried in Utah, but with great opposition on account of the
peculiar religious belief and customs of the people. But the
District of Columbia is directly under the eye of congress. It is
the capital of the nation, and three-fifths of the property of
the District belongs to the United States.
The people of the
whole country would therefore be interested in observing the
practical workings of this system on national soil. With 7,316
more women than men in this District, we call your special
attention to the inconsistency and injustice of granting suffrage
to a minority and withholding it from a majority, as you have
done in the past. If the District is your special ward, then
women, being in the majority here, have peculiar claims upon you
for a consideration of their rights. The freedom of this country
is only half won.
The women of to-day have less freedom than our
fathers of the revolution, for they were permitted local
self-government, while women have no share in local, State, or
general government.
Our memorial calls your attention to the Pembina debate in 1874,
when senators from eighteen States recognized the right of
self-government as inhering in women. One senator said: "I
believe women never will enjoy equality with men in taking care
of themselves until they have the right to vote." Another, "that
the question was being considered by a large portion of the
people of the United States." When the discussion was concluded
and the vote taken, twenty-two senators recorded their votes for
woman suffrage in that distant territory.
During the debate
several senators publicly declared their intention of voting for
woman suffrage in the District of Columbia whenever the
opportunity was presented. These senators recognize the fact that
the ballot is not only a right, but that it is opportunity for
woman; that it is the one means of helping her to help herself.
In asking you to secure the ballot to the women of the District
we do not ask you to create a right. That is beyond your power.
We ask you to protect them in the exercise of a right.
Mrs. SARA ANDREWS SPENCER, Secretary of the District of Columbia
Woman's Franchise Association, said: For no legal or political
right I have ever claimed in the District of Columbia do I ask a
stronger, clearer charter than the Declaration of Independence,
and the constitution of the United States as it stood before the
fourteenth amendment had entered the minds of men. A judicial
decision, rendered by nine men, upon the rights of ten millions
of women of this republic, need not, does not, change the
convictions of one woman in regard to her own heaven-endowed
rights, duties, and responsibilities.
We have resorted to all the measures dictated by those who rule
over us for securing the freedom to exercise rights which are
sacredly our own, rights which are ours by Divine inheritance,
and which men can neither confer nor take away. We are not only
daughters of our Father in heaven, and joint heirs with you
there; but we are daughters of this republic, and joint heirs
with you here.
Every act of legislation which has been placed as
a bar in our way as citizens has been an act of injustice, and
every expedient to which we have resorted for securing
recognition of citizenship has been with protest against the
existence of these acts of unauthorized power.
When any man expresses doubt to me as to the use that I or any
other woman might make of the ballot if we had it, my answer is,
What is that to you? If you have for years defrauded me of my
rightful inheritance, and then, as a stroke of policy, or from
late conviction, concluded to restore to me my own domain, must I
ask you whether I may make of it a garden of flowers, or a field
of wheat, or a pasture for kine? If I choose I may counsel with
you. If experience has given you wisdom, even of this world, in
managing your property and mine, I should be wise to learn from
you.
But injustice is not wont to yield wisdom; grapes do not
grow of thorns, nor figs of thistles.
Born of the unjust and cruel subjection of woman to man, we have
in these United States a harvest of 116,000 paupers, 36,000
criminals, and such a mighty host of blind, deaf and dumb,
idiotic, insane, feeble-minded, and children with tendencies to
crime, as almost to lead one to hope for the extinction of the
human race rather than for its perpetuation after its own kind.
The wisdom of man licenses the dram-shop, and then rears
station-houses, jails, and gibbets to provide for the victims.
In
this District we have 135 teachers of public schools and 238
police officers, and the last report shows that public safety
demands a police force of 900. We have 31,671 children of school
age; 31,671 reasons why I want to vote. We have here 7,000 more
children of school age than there are seats in all the public
schools, and from the swarm of poor, ignorant, and vagrant
children, the lists of criminals and paupers are constantly
supplied. To provide for these evils there is an annual
expenditure of $350,000, not including expenses of courts, while
for education the annual expenditure is $280,000.
Will you say that the wives and the mothers, the house and
homekeepers of this small territory, have no interest in all
these things? If dram-shops are licensed and brothels protected,
are not our sons, our brothers, tempted and ruined, our daughters
lured from their homes, and lost to earth and heaven? Long and
patiently women have borne wrongs too deep to be put into words;
wrongs for which men have provided no redress and have found no
remedy.
When five years ago, with our social atmosphere poisoned
with vices which as women we had no power to remove, men in
authority began a series of attempts to fasten upon us by law the
huge typical vice of all the ages--the social evil--in a form so
degrading to all womanhood that no man, though he were the prince
of profligates, would submit to its regulations for a day; then
we cried out so that the world heard us. We know the plague is
only stayed for a brief while. The hydra-headed monster every now
and then lifts a new front, and must be smitten again.
Four times
in four successive years a little company of women of the
District have appeared before committees and compelled the
discussion and defeat of bills designed to fasten these measures
upon the community under the guise of security for public health
and morality. The last annual report of the board of health
speaks tenderly of the need of protecting vicious men by these
regulations, and says:
The legalization of houses of ill-fame for so humane a
purpose, startling as it may be to the moral sense, has many
powerful advocates among the thoughtful, wise, and
philanthropic of communities.
The report quotes approvingly Dr. Gross, of Philadelphia, who
says in behalf of laws to license the social evil:
The prejudices which surround the subject must be swept
away, and men must march to the front and discharge their
duty, however much they may be reproached and abused by the
ignorant and foolish.
Aside from the higher ground of our inherent right to
self-government, we declare here and now that the women of this
District are not safe without the ballot. Our firesides, our
liberties are in constant peril, while men who have no concern
for our welfare may legislate against our dearest interests. If
we would inaugurate any measure of protection for our own sex, we
are bound hand and foot by man. The law is his, the treasury is
his, the power is his, and he need not even hear our cry, except
at his good will and pleasure.
If man had legislated justly and wisely for the interests of this
District, if its financial condition was sound, its social and
moral atmosphere pure, and all was well, there would be some show
of reason in your refusing to hazard a new experiment, even
though we could demonstrate it to be founded upon eternal
justice. But the history of the successive forms of government in
the District of Columbia is a history of failures. So will it
continue to be until you adopt a plan founded upon truly
republican principles.
When, a few years ago, you put the ballot
into the hands of the swarming masses of freedmen who had
gathered here with the ignorance and vices of slaves, and refused
to enfranchise women, white or colored, you gave this District no
fair trial of a republican form of government. You did not even
protect the interests of the colored race. You admitted that the
colored man was not really free until he held the ballot in his
hand, and therefore you enfranchised him and left the woman twice
his slave.
I know colored women in Washington far the superiors,
intellectually and morally, of the masses of men, who declare
that they now endure wrongs and abuses unknown in slavery.
There is not an interest in this District that is not as vital to
me as to any man in Washington--that is not more vital to me than
it can be to any member of this honorable body. As a citizen,
seeking the welfare of this community, as a wife and mother
desiring the safety of my children, which of you can claim a
deeper interest than I in questions of markets, taxes, finance,
banks, railroads, highways, the public debt and interest thereon,
boards of health, sanitary and police regulations, station-houses
(wherein I find many a wreck of womanhood, ruined in her youth
and beauty), schools, asylums, and charities?
Why deny me a voice
in any or all of these? Do you doubt that I would use the ballot
in the interests of order, retrenchment, and reform? Do you deny
a right of mine, which you will admit I know how to prize,
because there are women who do not appreciate its value, do not
demand it, possibly might not (any better than men) know how to
use it? What a mockery of justice! What a flagrant violation of
individual rights! I would cry out against it if no other woman
in the land felt the wrong.
But among the 10,000,000 of mothers
of 14,000,000 of children in this country, vast numbers of
thoughtful, philanthropic, and pure women have come to see this
truth, and desire to express their mother love and home love at
the ballot-box!
Frederick Douglass once said: "Whole nations have been bathed in
blood to establish the simplest possible propositions. For
instance, that a man's head is his head; his body is his
body; his feet are his feet, and if he chooses to run away with
them it is nobody's business"; and all honor to him, he added,
"Now, these propositions have been established for the colored
man. Why does not man establish them for woman, his wife, his
mother?"
Determined to surround the colored man with every possible
guarantee of protection in the possession of his freedom,
congress stopped the wheels of legislation, and made the whole
country wait, while day after day and night after night his
friends fought inch by inch the ground for the civil rights bill.
During that debate Senator Frelinghuysen said:
When I took the oath as senator, I took the oath to support
the Constitution of the United States, which declares
equality for all: and in advocating this bill I am doing my
sworn duty in endeavoring to secure equal rights for every
citizen of the United States.
But where slept his "sworn duty" when he recorded his vote in the
Senate against woman suffrage? With marvelous inconsistency, as a
reason for opposing woman suffrage, during the Pembina debate,
May 27, 1874, Senator Merrimon said of the relation of women to
the Constitution of the United States:
They have sustained it under all circumstances with their
love, their hands, and their hearts; with their smiles and
their tears they have educated their children to live for
it, and to die for it.
Therefore the honorable gentleman denies them the right to vote.
Upon the civil rights bill, Senator Howe said:
I do not know but what the passage of this bill will break
up the common schools. I admit that I have some fear on that
point. Every step of this terrible march has been met with a
threat; but let justice be done although the common schools
and the heavens do fall.
In reply to the point made by Mr. Stockton that the people of the
United States would not accept this bill, Mr. Howe said:
I would not turn back if I knew that of the forty million
people of the United States not one million would sustain
it. If this generation does not accept it there is a
generation to come that will accept it. What does this
provide? Not that the black man should be helped on his way;
not at all; but only that, as he staggers along, he shall
not be retarded, shall not be tripped up and made to fall.
Brave and tender words these for our black brother; but see how
prone men are to invert truth, justice, and mercy in dealing with
women. During the Pembina debate, Senator Merrimon said:
I know there are a few women in the country who complain;
but those who complain, compared with those who do not
complain, are as one to a million.
As a literal fact, the women who have complained, have
petitioned, sued, reasoned, plead, have knocked at the doors of
your legislatures and courts, are as one to fifty in this
country, as we who watch the record know; and even that is a
small proportion of those who would, but dare not; who are bound
hand and foot, and will be bound until you make them free.
But if
no others feel the wrong but those who have dared to complain; if
the poor, the ignorant, the betrayed, the ruined do not
understand the question, and the well-fed and comfortable "have
all the rights they want," do you give that for answer to our
just demand? What do we ask? Not that poor woman "shall be helped
on her way"--not at all; but only that, "as she staggers along,
she shall not be retarded, shall not be tripped up, shall not be
made to fall."
And here on this national soil, for the women of this District of
Columbia--your peculiar wards--I ask you to try the experiment of
exact, even-handed justice; to give us a voice in the laws under
which we must live, by which we are tried, judged and condemned.
I ask it for myself, that I may the better help other women. I
ask it for other women, that they may the better help themselves.
As you hope for justice and mercy in your hour of need, may you
hear and answer.
Rev. Olympia Brown, of Connecticut; Belva A. Lockwood, of Washington; and Phoebe Couzins, of St. Louis, also addressed the committees; enforcing their arguments with wit, humor, pathos and eloquence.
On her way home from Washington, Mrs. Gage stopped in Philadelphia to secure rooms for the National Association during the centennial summer, and decided upon Carpenter Hall, in case it could be obtained. This hall belongs to the Carpenter Company of Philadelphia, perhaps the oldest existing association of that city, it having maintained an uninterrupted organization from the year 1724, about forty years after the establishment of the colonial government by William Penn, and was much in use during the early days of the revolution.
The doors of the State House, where the continental congress intended to meet, were found closed against it; but the Carpenter Company, numbering many eminent patriots, offered its hall for their use; and here met the first continental congress, September 5, 1774. John Adams, describing its opening ceremonies, said:
Here was a scene worthy of the painter's art. Washington was
kneeling there, and Randolph, Rutledge, Lee and Jay; and by their
side there stood, bowed in reverence, the Puritan patriots of New
England, who at that moment had reason to believe that an armed
soldiery was wasting their humble households. It was believed
that Boston had been bombarded and destroyed.[3] They prayed
fervently for America, for the congress, for the province of
Massachusetts Bay, and especially for the town of Boston. Who can
realize the emotions with which in that hour of danger they
turned imploringly to heaven for Divine interposition.
It was
enough to melt a heart of stone. I saw the tears gush into the
eyes of old, gray, pacific Quakers of Philadelphia.
The action of this congress, which sat but seven weeks, was momentous in the history of the world. "From the moment of their first debate," said De Tocqueville, "Europe was moved." The convention which in 1781 framed the constitution of the United States, also met in Carpenter Hall in secret session for four months before agreeing upon its provisions. This hall seemed the most appropriate place for establishing the centennial rooms of the National Woman Suffrage Association, but the effort to obtain it proved unavailing[4] as will be seen by the following correspondence:
To the President and Officers of the Carpenter Company of
Philadelphia:
The National Woman Suffrage Association will hold its
headquarters in Philadelphia the centennial season of 1876, and
desires to secure your historic hall for that purpose. We know
your habit and custom of denying its use to all societies, yet we
make our request because our objects are in accord with the
principles which emanated from within its walls a hundred years
ago, and we shall use it in carrying out those principles of
liberty and equality upon which our government is based.
We design to advertise our headquarters to the world, and old
Carpenter Hall, if used by us, would become more widely
celebrated as the birth-place of liberty. Our work in it would
cause it to be more than ever held in reverence by future ages,
and pilgrimages by men and women would be made to it as to
another Mecca shrine.
We propose to place a person in charge, with pamphlets, speeches,
tracts, etc., and to hold public meetings for the enunciation of
our principles and the furtherance of our demands. Hoping you
will grant this request,
I am respectfully yours, MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE,
President of the National Woman Suffrage Association.
Two months afterward, the following reply was received:
HALL, CARPENTER COURT, 322 Chestnut St.,}
PHILADELPHIA, April 24, 1876.}
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, President of the Woman Suffrage
Association:
Your communication asking permission to occupy Carpenter Hall for
your convention was duly received, and presented to the company
at a stated meeting held the 16th instant, when on motion it was
unanimously resolved to postpone the subject indefinitely.
[Extract of minutes]. GEORGE WATSON, Secretary.
It was a matter of no moment to those men that women were soon to assemble in Philadelphia, whose love of liberty was as deep, whose patriotism was as pure as that of the fathers who met within its walls in 1774, and whose deliberations had given that hall its historic interest.
In the midst of these preparations the usual May anniversary was held:
CALL FOR THE MAY ANNIVERSARY, 1876.--The National Woman Suffrage
Association will hold its Ninth Annual Convention in Masonic
Hall, New York, corner of Sixth avenue and Twenty-third street,
May 10, 11, 1876.
This convention occuring in the centennial year of the republic,
will be a most important one. The underlying principles of
government will this year be discussed as never before; both
foreigners and citizens will query as to how closely this country
has lived up to its own principles.
The long-debated question as
to the source of the governing power was answered a century ago
by the famous Declaration of Independence which shook to the
foundation all recognized power and proclaimed the right of the
individual as above all forms of government; but while thus
declaring itself, it has held the women of the nation accountable
to laws they have had no share in making, and taught as their one
duty, that doctrine of tyrants, unquestioning obedience.
Liberty
to-day is, therefore, but the heritage of one-half the people,
and the centennial will be but the celebration of the
independence of one-half the nation. The men alone of this
country live in a republic, the women enter the second hundred
years of national life as political slaves.
That no structure is stronger than its weakest point is a law of
mechanics that will apply equally to government. In so far as
this government has denied justice to woman, it is weak, and
preparing for its own downfall. All the insurrections,
rebellions, and martyrdoms of history have grown out of the
desire for liberty, and in woman's heart this desire is as strong
as in man's.
At every vital time in the nation's life, men and
women have worked together; everywhere has woman stood by the
side of father, brother, husband, son in defense of liberty;
without her aid the republic could never have been established;
and yet women are still suffering under all the oppressions
complained of in 1776; which can only be remedied by securing
impartial suffrage to all citizens without distinction of sex.
All persons who believe republican principles should be carried
out in spirit and in truth, are invited to be present at the May
convention.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, President.
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, Chairman Executive Committee.
This May anniversary, commencing on the same day with the opening of the centennial exhibition, was marked with more than usual earnestness. As popular thought naturally turned with increasing interest at such an hour to the underlying principles of government, woman's demand for political equality received a new impulse. The famous Smith sisters, of Glastonbury, Connecticut, attended this convention, and were most cordially welcomed. The officers[5] for the centennial year were chosen and a campaign[6] and congressional[7] committee appointed to take charge of affairs at Philadelphia and Washington. The resolutions show the general drift of the discussions:[8]
WHEREAS, The right of self-government inheres in the individual
before governments are founded, constitutions framed, or courts
created; and
WHEREAS, Governments exist to protect the people in the enjoyment
of their natural rights, and when any government becomes
destructive of this end, it is the right of the people to resist
and abolish it; and
WHEREAS, The women of the United States, for one hundred years,
have been denied the exercise of their natural right of
self-government and self-protection; therefore,
Resolved, That it is the natural right and most sacred duty of
the women of these United States to rebel against the injustice,
usurpation and tyranny of our present government.
WHEREAS, The men of 1776 rebelled against a government which did
not claim to be of the people, but, on the contrary, upheld the
"divine right of kings"; and
WHEREAS, The women of this nation to-day, under a government
which claims to be based upon individual rights, to be "of the
people, by the people, and for the people," in an infinitely
greater degree are suffering all the wrongs which led to the war
of the revolution; and WHEREAS, The oppression is all the more
keenly felt because our masters, instead of dwelling in a foreign
land, are our husbands, our fathers, our brothers and our sons;
therefore,
Resolved, That the women of this nation, in 1876, have greater
cause for discontent, rebellion and revolution, than the men of
1776.
Resolved, That with Abigail Adams, in 1776, we believe that
"the passion for liberty cannot be strong in the breasts of those
who are accustomed to deprive their fellow-creatures of liberty";
that, as Abigail Adams predicted, "We are determined to foment a
rebellion, and will not hold ourselves bound by laws in which we
have no voice or representation."
WHEREAS, We believe in the principles of the Declaration of
Independence and of the Constitution of the United States, and
believe a true republic is the best form of government in the
world; and
WHEREAS, This government is false to its underlying principles in
denying to women the only means of self-government, the ballot;
and
WHEREAS, One-half of the citizens of this nation, after a century
of boasted liberty, are still political slaves; therefore,
Resolved, That we protest against calling the present
centennial celebration a celebration of the independence of the
people of the United States.
Resolved, That we meet in our respective towns and districts on
the Fourth of July, 1876, and declare ourselves no longer bound
to obey laws in whose making we have had no voice, and, in
presence of the assembled nations of the world gathered on this
soil to celebrate our nation's centennial, demand justice for the
women of this land.
WHEREAS, The men of this nation have established for men of all
nations, races and color, on this soil, at the cost of countless
lives, the proposition (in the language of Frederick Douglass)
"that a man's head is his head, his body is his body, his feet
are his feet"; therefore,
Resolved, That justice, equity and chivalry demand that man at
once establish for his wife and mother the corresponding
proposition, that a woman's head is her head, her body is her
body, her feet are her feet, and that all ownership and mastery
over her person, property, conscience, and liberty of speech and
action, are in violation of the supreme law of the land.
Resolved, That we rejoice in the resistance of Julia and Abby
Smith, Abby Kelly Foster, Sarah E. Wall and many more resolute
women in various parts of the country, to taxation without
representation.
Resolved, That the thanks of the National Woman Suffrage
Association are hereby tendered to Hon. A. A. Sargent, of
California, for his earnest words in behalf of woman suffrage on
the floor of the United States Senate, Jan. 25, 1876; and to Hon.
N. P. Banks, of Massachusetts, for his appeal in behalf of the
centennial woman suffrage memorial in the United States House of
Representatives, March 31, 1876.
Resolved, That the repeated attempts to license the social evil
are a practical confession of the weakness, profligacy and
general unfitness of men to legislate for women, and should be
regarded with alarm as a proof that their firesides and liberties
are in constant peril while men alone make and execute the laws
of this country.
WHEREAS, There are 7,000 more women than men in the District of
Columbia, and no form of government for said District has allowed
women any voice in making the laws under which they live;
therefore,
Resolved, That in this centennial year the congress of the
United States having exclusive jurisdiction over that territory
should establish a truly republican form of government by
granting equal suffrage to the men and women of the District of
Columbia.
Immediately at the close of the May convention Mrs. Gage again went to Philadelphia to complete the arrangements in regard to the centennial headquarters. Large and convenient rooms were soon found upon Arch street, terms agreed upon and a lease drawn, when it transpired that a husband's consent and signature must be obtained, although the property was owned by a woman, as by the laws of Pennsylvania a married woman's property is under her husband's control.
Although arrangements for this room had been made with the real owner, the terms being perfectly satisfactory to her, the husband refused his ratification, tearing up the lease, with abuse of the women who claimed control of their own property, and a general defiance of all women who dared work for the enfranchisement of their sex. Thus again were women refused rooms in Philadelphia in which to enter their protest against the tyranny of this republic, and for the same reason--they were slaves.
Had the patriots of the revolutionary period asked rooms of King George, in which to foster their treason to his government, the refusal could have been no more positive than in these cases.
The quarters finally obtained were very desirable; fine large parlors on the first floor, on Chestnut street, at the fashionable west end, directly opposite the Young Men's Christian Association.
The other members of the committee being married ladies, Miss Anthony, as a feme sole, was alone held capable of making a contract, and was therefore obliged to assume the pecuniary responsibility of the rooms. Thus it is ever the married women who are more especially classed with lunatics, idiots and criminals, and held incapable of managing their own business. It has always been part of the code of slavery, that the slave had no right to property; all his earnings and gifts belonging by law, to the master. Married women come under this same civil code. The following letter was extensively circulated and published in all the leading journals:
NATIONAL WOMAN SUFFRAGE PARLORS, }
1,431 Chestnut Street, PHILADELPHIA, PA. }
The National Woman Suffrage Association has established its
centennial headquarters in Philadelphia, at 1,431 Chestnut
street. The parlors, in charge of the officers of the
association, are devoted to the special work of the year,
pertaining to the centennial celebration and the political party
conventions; also to calls, receptions, conversazioni, etc. On
the table a centennial autograph book receives the names of
visitors.
Friends at a distance, both men and women, who cannot
call, are invited to send their names, with date and residence,
accompanied by a short expressive sentiment and a contribution
toward expenses. In the rooms are books, papers, reports and
decisions, speeches, tracts, and photographs of distinguished
women; also mottoes and pictures expressive of woman's
condition. In addition to the parlor gatherings, meetings and
conventions will be held during the season in various halls and
churches throughout the city.
On July Fourth, while the men of this nation and the world are
rejoicing that "All men are free and equal" in the United States,
a declaration of rights for women will be issued from these
headquarters, and a protest against calling this centennial a
celebration of the independence of the people, while one-half are
still political slaves.
Let the women of the whole land, on that day, in meetings, in
parlors, in kitchens, wherever they may be, unite with us in this
declaration and protest. And, immediately thereafter, send full
reports, in manuscript or print, of their resolutions, speeches
and action, for record in our centennial book, that the world may
see that the women of 1876 know and feel their political
degradation no less than did the men of 1776.
The first woman's rights convention the world ever knew, called
by Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, met at Seneca Falls,
N. Y., July 19, 20, 1848. In commemoration of the twenty-eighth
anniversary of that event, the National Woman Suffrage
Association will hold in ---- hall, Philadelphia, July 19, 20, of
the present year, a grand mass convention, in which eminent
reformers from the new and old world will take part. Friends are
especially invited to be present on this historic occasion.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, Chairman Executive Committee.
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, Corresponding Secretary.
From these headquarters numberless documents were issued during the month of June. As the presidential nominating conventions were soon to meet, letters were addressed to both the Republican and Democratic parties, urging them to recognize the political rights of women in their platforms. Thousands of copies of these letters were scattered throughout the nation:
To the President and Members of the National Republican
Convention, Cincinnati, O., June 14, 1876.
GENTLEMEN: The National Woman Suffrage Association asks you to
place in your platform the following plank:
Resolved, That the right to the use of the ballot inheres
in every citizen of the United States; and we pledge
ourselves to secure the exercise of this right to all
citizens, irrespective of sex.
In asking the insertion of this plank, we propose no change of
fundamental principles. Our question is as old as the nation. Our
government was framed on the political basis of the consent of
the governed. And from July 4, 1776, until the present year,
1876, the nation has constantly advanced toward a fuller practice
of our fundamental theory, that the governed are the source of
all power. Your nominating convention, occurring in this
centennial year of the republic, presents a good opportunity for
the complete recognition of these first principles.
Our
government has not yet answered the end for which it was framed,
while one-half the people of the United States are deprived of
the right of self-government. Before the Revolution, Great
Britain claimed the right to legislate for the colonies in all
cases whatsoever; the men of this nation now as unjustly claim
the right to legislate for women in all cases whatsoever.
The call for your nominating convention invites the cooeperation
of "all voters who desire to inaugurate and enforce the rights of
every citizen, including the full and free exercise of the right
of suffrage." Women are citizens; declared to be by the highest
legislative and judicial authorities; but they are citizens
deprived of "the full and free exercise of the right of
suffrage." Your platform of 1872 declared "the Republican party
mindful of its obligations to the loyal women of the nation for
their noble devotion to the cause of freedom." Devotion to
freedom is no new thing for the women of this nation.
From the
earliest history of our country, woman has shown herself as
patriotic as man in every great emergency in the nation's life.
From the Revolution to the present hour, woman has stood by the
side of father, husband, son and brother in defense of liberty.
The heroic and self-sacrificing deeds of the women of this
republic, both in peace and war, must not be forgotten. Together
men and women have made this country what it is. And to-day, in
this one-hundredth year of our existence, the women--as members
of the nation--as citizens of the United States--ask national
recognition of their right of suffrage.
The Declaration of Independence struck a blow at every existent
form of government, by declaring the individual the source of all
power. Upon this one newly proclaimed truth our nation arose. But
if States may deny suffrage to any class of citizens, or confer
it at will upon any class--as according to the Minor-Happersett
decision of the Supreme Court--a decision rendered under the
auspices of the Republican party against suffrage as a
constituent element of United States citizenship--we then possess
no true national life.
If States can deny suffrage to citizens of
the United States, then States possess more power than the United
States, and are more truly national in the character of their
governments. National supremacy does not chiefly mean power "to
levy war, conclude peace, contract alliances, establish
commerce"; it means national protection and security in the
exercise of the right of self-government, which comes alone, by
and through the use of the ballot.
Even granting the premise of the Supreme-Court decision that "the
Constitution of the United States does not confer suffrage on any
one"; our national life does not date from that instrument. The
constitution is not the original declaration of rights. It was
not framed until eleven years after our existence as a nation,
nor fully ratified until nearly fourteen years after the
commencement of our national life. This centennial celebration of
our nation's birth does not date from the constitution, but from
the Declaration of Independence.
The declared purpose of the
civil war was the settlement of the question of supremacy between
the States and the United States. The documents sent out by the
Republican party in this present campaign, warn the people that
the Democrats intend another battle for State sovereignty, to be
fought this year at the ballot-box.
The National Woman Suffrage Association calls your attention to
the fact that the Republican party has itself reopened this
battle, and now holds the anomalous position of having settled
the question of State sovereignty in the case of black men, and
again opened it, through the Minor-Happersett decision, not only
in the case of women citizens, but also in the case of men
citizens, for all other causes save those specified in the
fifteenth amendment. Your party has yet one opportunity to
retrieve its position.
The political power of this country has
always shown itself superior to the judicial power--the latter
ever shaping and basing its decisions on the policy of the
dominant party. A pledge, therefore, by your convention to secure
national protection in the enjoyment of perfect equality of
rights, civil and political, to all citizens, will so define the
policy of the Republican party as to open the way to a full and
final adjustment of this question on the basis of United States
supremacy.
Aside from the higher motive of justice, we suggest your adoption
of this principle of equal rights to women, as a means of
securing your own future existence. The party of reform in this
country is the party that lives. The party that ceases to
represent the vital principles of truth and justice dies. If you
would save the life of the Republican party you should now take
broad national ground on this question of suffrage.
By this act you will do most to promote the general welfare,
secure the blessings of liberty to yourselves and your posterity,
and establish on this continent a genuine republic that shall
know no class, caste, race, or sex--where all the people are
citizens, and all citizens are equal before the law.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, Chairman Executive Committee.
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, Corresponding Secretary.
Centennial Headquarters,
1,431 Chestnut street, Philadelphia, June 10, 1876.
To the President and Members of the National Democratic
Convention assembled at St. Louis, June 27, 1876:
GENTLEMEN: In reading the call for your convention, the National
Woman Suffrage Association was gratified to find that your
invitation was not limited to voters, but cordially extended to
all citizens of the United States. We accordingly send delegates
from our association, asking for them a voice in your
proceedings, and also a plank in your platform declaring the
political rights of women.
Women are the only class of citizens still wholly unrepresented
in the government, and yet we possess every qualification
requisite for voters in the several States. Women possess
property and education; we take out naturalization papers and
passports; we preempt lands, pay taxes, and suffer for our own
violation of the laws.
We are neither idiots, lunatics, nor
criminals; and, according to your State constitutions, lack but
one qualification for voters, namely, sex, which is an
insurmountable qualification, and therefore equivalent to a bill
of attainder against one-half the people; a power no State nor
congress can legally exercise, being forbidden in article 1,
sections 9, 10, of our constitution.
Our rulers may have the
right to regulate the suffrage, but they can not abolish it
altogether for any class of citizens, as has been done in the
case of the women of this republic, without a direct violation of
the fundamental law of the land.
As you hold the constitution of the fathers to be a sacred legacy
to us and our children forever, we ask you to so interpret that
Magna Charta of human rights as to secure justice and equality
to all United States citizens irrespective of sex.
We desire to
call your attention to the violation of the essential principle
of self-government in the disfranchisement of the women of the
several States, and we appeal to you, not only because as a
minority you are in a position to consider principles, but
because you were the party first to extend suffrage by removing
the property qualification from all white men, and thus making
the political status of the richest and poorest citizen the same.
That act of justice to the laboring masses insured your power,
with but few interruptions, until the war.
When the District of Columbia suffrage bill was under discussion
in 1866, it was a Democratic senator (Mr. Cowan, of Pennsylvania)
who proposed an amendment to strike out the word "male," and thus
extend the right of suffrage to the women, as well as the black
men of the District. That amendment gave us a splendid discussion
on woman suffrage that lasted three days in the Senate of the
United States.
It was a Democratic legislature that secured the
right of suffrage to the women of Wyoming, and we now ask you in
national convention to pledge the Democratic party to extend this
act of justice to the women throughout the nation, and thus call
to your side a new political force that will restore and
perpetuate your power for years to come.
The Republican party gave us a plank in their platform in 1872,
pledging themselves to a "respectful consideration" of our
demands. But by their constitutional interpretations, legislative
enactments, and judicial decisions, so far from redeeming their
pledge, they have buried our petitions and appeals under laws in
direct opposition to their high-sounding promises and
professions.
And now (1876) they give us another plank in their
platform, approving the "substantial advance made toward the
establishment of equal rights for women"; cunningly reminding us
that the privileges and immunities we now enjoy are all due to
Republican legislation--although, under a Republican dynasty,
inspectors of election have been arrested and imprisoned for
taking the votes of women; temperance women arrested and
imprisoned for praying in the streets; houses, lands, bonds, and
stock of women seized and sold for their refusal to pay unjust
taxation--and, more than all, we have this singular spectacle: a
Republican woman, who had spoken for the Republican party
throughout the last presidential campaign, arrested by Republican
officers for voting the Republican ticket, denied the right of
trial by jury by a Republican judge, convicted and sentenced to a
fine of one hundred dollars and costs of prosecution; and all
this for asserting at the polls the most sacred of all the rights
of American citizenship--the right of suffrage--specifically
secured by recent Republican amendments to the federal
constitution.
Again, the Supreme Court of the United States, by its recent
decision in the Minor-Happersett case, has stultified its own
interpretation of constitutional law. A negro, by virtue of his
United States citizenship, is declared under recent amendments a
voter in every State in the Union; but when a woman, by virtue of
her United States citizenship, applies to the Supreme Court for
protection in the exercise of this same right, she is remanded to
the State by the unanimous decision of the nine judges on the
bench, that "the Constitution of the United States does not
confer the right of suffrage upon any one."
All concessions of privileges or redress of grievances are but
mockery for any class that has no voice in the laws and
lawmakers. Hence we demand the ballot--that scepter of power--in
our own hands, as the only sure protection for our rights of
person and property under all conditions. If the few may grant or
withhold rights at their own pleasure, the many cannot be said to
enjoy the blessings of self-government. Jefferson said, "The God
who gave us life gave us liberty at the same time.
The hand of
force may destroy, but cannot disjoin them." While the first and
highest motive we would urge on you is the recognition in all
your action of the great principles of justice and equality that
underlie our form of government, it is not unworthy to remind you
that the party that takes this onward step will reap its just
reward.
Had you heeded our appeals made to you in Tammany Hall, New York,
in 1868, and again in Baltimore, in 1872, your party might now
have been in power, as you would have had, what neither party can
boast to-day, a live issue on which to rouse the enthusiasm of
the people. Reform is the watchword of the hour; but how can we
hope for honor and honesty in either party in minor matters, so
long as both consent to rob one-half the people--their own
mothers, sisters, wives and daughters--of their most sacred
rights?
As a party you defended the right of self-government in
Louisiana ably and eloquently during the last session of
congress. Are the rights of women in all the Southern States,
whose slaves are now their rulers, less sacred than those of the
men of Louisiana? "The whole art of government," says Jefferson,
"consists in being honest."
It needs but little observation to see that the tide of progress,
in all countries, is setting toward the emancipation and
enfranchisement of women; and this step in civilization is to be
taken in our day and generation. Whether the Democratic party
will take the initiative in this reform, and reap the glory of
crowning fifteen million women with the rights of American
citizenship, and thereby vindicate our theory of self-government,
is the momentous question we ask you to decide in this eventful
hour, as we round out the first century of our national life.
ELIZABETH CADY STANTON, President.
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE, Chairman Executive Committee.
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, Corresponding Secretary.
Centennial Headquarters,
1,431 Chestnut street, Philadelphia, June 20, 1876.
In addition to these letters delegates were sent to both the Republican and Democratic conventions. Sara Andrews Spencer and Elizabeth Boynton Harbert were present at the Republican convention at Cincinnati; both addressed the committee on platform and resolutions, and Mrs. Spencer, on motion of Hon. George F. Hoar, was permitted to address the convention. Mrs. Virginia L. Minor and Miss Phoebe W. Couzins were the delegates to the Democratic convention at St. Louis, and the latter addressed that vast assembly.[9]
For a long time there had been a growing demand for a woman's declaration to be issued on July Fourth, 1876. "Let us then protest against the falsehood of the nation"; "If the old Declaration does not include women, let us have one that will"; "Let our rulers be arraigned"; "A declaration of independence for women must be issued on the Fourth of July, 1876," were demands that came from all parts of the country.
The officers of the association had long had such action in view, having, at the Washington convention, early in 1875, announced their intention of working in Philadelphia during the centennial season, and were strengthened in their determination by the hearty indorsement they received. At the May convention in New York, Matilda Joslyn Gage, in her opening speech, announced that a declaration of independence for women would be issued on the Fourth of July, 1876.
In response to this general feeling, the officers of the National Association prepared a declaration of rights of the women of the United States, and articles of impeachment against the government.
Application was made by the secretary, Miss Anthony, to General Hawley, president of the centennial commission, for seats for fifty officers of the association. General Hawley replied that "only officials were invited"--that even his own wife had no place--that merely representatives and officers of the government had seats assigned them. "Then" said she, "as women have no share in the government, they are to have no seats on the platform," to which General Hawley assented; adding, however, that Mrs.
Gillespie, of the woman's centennial commission, had fifty seats placed at her disposal, thus showing it to be in his power to grant places to women whenever he so chose to do.
Miss Anthony said: "I ask seats for the officers of the National Woman Suffrage Association; we represent one-half the people, and why should we be denied all part in this centennial celebration?" Miss Anthony, however, secured a reporter's ticket by virtue of representing her brother's paper, The Leavenworth Times, and, ultimately, cards of invitation were sent to four others,[10] representing the 20,000,000 disfranchised citizens of the nation.
Mrs. Stanton, as president of the association, wrote General Hawley, asking the opportunity to present the woman's protest and bill of rights at the close of the reading of the Declaration of Independence. Just its simple presentation and nothing more. She wrote:
We do not ask to read our declaration, only to present it to the
president of the United States, that it may become an historical
part of the proceedings.
Mrs. Spencer, bearer of this letter, in presenting it to General Hawley, said:
The women of the United States make a slight request on the
occasion of the centennial celebration of the birth of the
nation; we only ask that we may silently present our declaration
of rights.
General HAWLEY replied: It seems a very slight request, but our
programme is published, our speakers engaged, our arrangements
for the day decided upon, and we can not make even so slight a
change as that you ask.
Mrs. SPENCER replied: We are aware that your programme is
published, your speakers engaged, your entire arrangements
decided upon, without consulting with the women of the United
States; for that very reason we desire to enter our protest. We
are aware that this government has been conducted for one hundred
years without consulting the women of the United States; for this
reason we desire to enter our protest.
General HAWLEY replied: Undoubtedly we have not lived up to our
own original Declaration of Independence in many respects. I
express no opinion upon your question. It is a proper subject of
discussion at the Cincinnati convention, at the St. Louis
convention,, in the Senate of the United States, in the State
legislatures, in the courts, wherever you can obtain a hearing.
But to-morrow we propose to celebrate what we have done the last
hundred years; not what we have failed to do. We have much to do
in the future. I understand the full significance of your very
slight request.
If granted, it would be the event of the day--the
topic of discussion to the exclusion of all others. I am sorry to
refuse so slight a demand; we cannot grant it.
General Hawley also addressed a letter to Mrs. Stanton:
DEAR MADAM: I regret to say it is impossible for us to make any
change in our programme, or make any addition to it at this late
hour.
Yours very respectfully,
JOS. R. HAWLEY, President U. S. C. C.
As General Grant was not to attend the celebration, the acting vice-president, Thomas W. Ferry, representing the government, was to officiate in his place, and he, too, was addressed by note, and courteously requested to make time for the reception of this declaration. As Mr. Ferry was a well-known sympathizer with the demands of woman for political rights, it was presumable that he would render his aid.
Yet he was forgetful that in his position that day he represented, not the exposition, but the government of a hundred years, and he too refused; thus this simple request of woman for a half moment's recognition on the nation's centennial birthday was denied by all in authority.[11] While the women of the nation were thus absolutely forbidden the right of public protest, lavish preparations were made for the reception and entertainment of foreign potentates and the myrmidons of monarchial institutions.
Dom Pedro, emperor of Brazil, a representative of that form of government against which the United States is a perpetual defiance and protest, was welcomed with fulsome adulation, and given a seat of honor near the officers of the day;
Prince Oscar of Sweden, a stripling of sixteen, on whose shoulder rests the promise of a future kingship, was seated near. Count Rochambeau of France, the Japanese commissioners, high officials from Russia and Prussia, from Austria, Spain, England, Turkey, representing the barbarism and semi-civilization of the day, found no difficulty in securing recognition and places of honor upon that platform, where representative womanhood was denied.
Though refused by their own countrymen a place and part in the centennial celebration, the women who had taken this presentation in hand were not to be conquered. They had respectfully asked for recognition; now that it had been denied, they determined to seize upon the moment when the reading of the Declaration of Independence closed, to proclaim to the world the tyranny and injustice of the nation toward one-half its people.
Five officers of the National Woman Suffrage Association, with that heroic spirit which has ever animated lovers of liberty in resistance to tyranny, determined, whatever the result, to present the woman's declaration of rights at the chosen hour. They would not, they dared not sacrifice the golden opportunity to which they had so long looked forward; their work was not for themselves alone, nor for the present generation, but for all women of all time.
The hopes of posterity were in their hands and they determined to place on record for the daughters of 1976, the fact that their mothers of 1876 had asserted their equality of rights, and impeached the government of that day for its injustice toward woman. Thus, in taking a grander step toward freedom than ever before, they would leave one bright remembrance for the women of the next centennial.
That historic Fourth of July dawned at last, one of the most oppressive days of that terribly heated season. Susan B. Anthony, Matilda Joslyn Gage, Sara Andrews Spencer, Lillie Devereux Blake and Phoebe W. Couzins made their way through the crowds under the broiling sun to Independence Square, carrying the Woman's Declaration of Rights. This declaration had been handsomely engrossed by one of their number, and signed by the oldest and most prominent advocates of woman's enfranchisement.
Their tickets of admission proved open sesame through the military and all other barriers, and a few moments before the opening of the ceremonies, these women found themselves within the precincts from which most of their sex were excluded.
The declaration of 1776 was read by Richard Henry Lee, of Virginia, about whose family clusters so much of historic fame. The close of his reading was deemed the appropriate moment for the presentation of the woman's declaration. Not quite sure how their approach might be met--not quite certain if at this final moment they would be permitted to reach the presiding officer--those ladies arose and made their way down the aisle. The bustle of preparation for the Brazilian hymn covered their advance.
The foreign guests, the military and civil officers who filled the space directly in front of the speaker's stand, courteously made way, while Miss Anthony in fitting words presented the declaration. Mr. Ferry's face paled, as bowing low, with no word, he received the declaration, which thus became part of the day's proceedings; the ladies turned, scattering printed copies, as they deliberately walked down the platform.
On every side eager hands were stretched; men stood on seats and asked for them, while General Hawley, thus defied and beaten in his audacious denial to women the right to present their declaration, shouted, "Order, order!"
Passing out, these ladies made their way to a platform erected for the musicians in front of Independence Hall. Here on this old historic ground, under the shadow of Washington's statue, back of them the old bell that proclaimed "liberty to all the land, and all the inhabitants thereof," they took their places, and to a listening, applauding crowd, Miss Anthony read[12] the Declaration of Rights for Women by the National Woman Suffrage Association, July 4, 1876:
While the nation is buoyant with patriotism, and all hearts are
attuned to praise, it is with sorrow we come to strike the one
discordant note, on this one-hundredth anniversary of our
country's birth. When subjects of kings, emperors, and czars,
from the old world join in our national jubilee, shall the women
of the republic refuse to lay their hands with benedictions on
the nation's head? Surveying America's exposition, surpassing in
magnificence those of London, Paris, and Vienna, shall we not
rejoice at the success of the youngest rival among the nations of
the earth?
May not our hearts, in unison with all, swell with
pride at our great achievements as a people; our free speech,
free press, free schools, free church, and the rapid progress we
have made in material wealth, trade, commerce and the inventive
arts? And we do rejoice in the success, thus far, of our
experiment of self-government.
Our faith is firm and unwavering
in the broad principles of human rights proclaimed in 1776, not
only as abstract truths, but as the corner stones of a republic.
Yet we cannot forget, even in this glad hour, that while all men
of every race, and clime, and condition, have been invested with
the full rights of citizenship under our hospitable flag, all
women still suffer the degradation of disfranchisement.
The history of our country the past hundred years has been a
series of assumptions and usurpations of power over woman, in
direct opposition to the principles of just government,
acknowledged by the United States as its foundation, which are:
First--The natural rights of each individual.
Second--The equality of these rights.
Third--That rights not delegated are retained by the
individual.
Fourth--That no person can exercise the rights of others
without delegated authority.
Fifth--That the non-use of rights does not destroy them.
And for the violation of these fundamental principles of our
government, we arraign our rulers on this Fourth day of July,
1876,--and these are our articles of impeachment:
Bills of attainder have been passed by the introduction of
the word "male" into all the State constitutions, denying to
women the right of suffrage, and thereby making sex a
crime--an exercise of power clearly forbidden in article I,
sections 9, 10, of the United States constitution.
The writ of habeas corpus, the only protection against
lettres de cachet and all forms of unjust imprisonment,
which the constitution declares "shall not be suspended,
except when in cases of rebellion or invasion the public
safety demands it," is held inoperative in every State of
the Union, in case of a married woman against her
husband--the marital rights of the husband being in all
cases primary, and the rights of the wife secondary.
The right of trial by a jury of one's peers was so
jealously guarded that States refused to ratify the original
constitution until it was guaranteed by the sixth amendment.
And yet the women of this nation have never been allowed a
jury of their peers--being tried in all cases by men, native
and foreign, educated and ignorant, virtuous and vicious.
Young girls have been arraigned in our courts for the crime
of infanticide; tried, convicted, hanged--victims,
perchance, of judge, jurors, advocates--while no woman's
voice could be heard in their defense.
And not only are
women denied a jury of their peers, but in some cases, jury
trial altogether.
During the war, a woman was tried and
hanged by military law, in defiance of the fifth amendment,
which specifically declares: "No person shall be held to
answer for a capital or otherwise infamous crime, unless on
a presentment or indictment of a grand jury, except in cases
... of persons in actual service in time of war." During the
last presidential campaign, a woman, arrested for voting,
was denied the protection of a jury, tried, convicted, and
sentenced to a fine and costs of prosecution, by the
absolute power of a judge of the Supreme Court of the United
States.
Taxation without representation, the immediate cause of
the rebellion of the colonies against Great Britain, is one
of the grievous wrongs the women of this country have
suffered during the century. Deploring war, with all the
demoralization that follows in its train, we have been taxed
to support standing armies, with their waste of life and
wealth.
Believing in temperance, we have been taxed to
support the vice, crime and pauperism of the liquor traffic.
While we suffer its wrongs and abuses infinitely more than
man, we have no power to protect our sons against this giant
evil. During the temperance crusade, mothers were arrested,
fined, imprisoned, for even praying and singing in the
streets, while men blockade the sidewalks with impunity,
even on Sunday, with their military parades and political
processions.
Believing in honesty, we are taxed to support a
dangerous army of civilians, buying and selling the offices
of government and sacrificing the best interests of the
people. And, moreover, we are taxed to support the very
legislators and judges who make laws, and render decisions
adverse to woman.
And for refusing to pay such unjust
taxation, the houses, lands, bonds, and stock of women have
been seized and sold within the present year, thus proving
Lord Coke's assertion, that "The very act of taxing a man's
property without his consent is, in effect, disfranchising
him of every civil right."
Unequal codes for men and women. Held by law a perpetual
minor, deemed incapable of self-protection, even in the
industries of the world, woman is denied equality of rights.
The fact of sex, not the quantity or quality of work, in
most cases, decides the pay and position; and because of
this injustice thousands of fatherless girls are compelled
to choose between a life of shame and starvation. Laws
catering to man's vices have created two codes of morals in
which penalties are graded according to the political status
of the offender.
Under such laws, women are fined and
imprisoned if found alone in the streets, or in public
places of resort, at certain hours. Under the pretense of
regulating public morals, police officers seizing the
occupants of disreputable houses, march the women in
platoons to prison, while the men, partners in their guilt,
go free.
While making a show of virtue in forbidding the
importation of Chinese women on the Pacific coast for
immoral purposes, our rulers, in many States, and even under
the shadow of the national capitol, are now proposing to
legalize the sale of American womanhood for the same vile
purposes.
Special legislation for woman has placed us in a most
anomalous position. Women invested with the rights of
citizens in one section--voters, jurors,
office-holders--crossing an imaginary line, are subjects in
the next. In some States, a married woman may hold property
and transact business in her own name; in others, her
earnings belong to her husband. In some States, a woman may
testify against her husband, sue and be sued in the courts;
in others, she has no redress in case of damage to person,
property, or character.
In case of divorce on account of
adultery in the husband, the innocent wife is held to
possess no right to children or property, unless by special
decree of the court. But in no State of the Union has the
wife the right to her own person, or to any part of the
joint earnings of the co-partnership during the life of her
husband. In some States women may enter the law schools and
practice in the courts; in others they are forbidden.
In
some universities girls enjoy equal educational advantages
with boys, while many of the proudest institutions in the
land deny them admittance, though the sons of China, Japan
and Africa are welcomed there. But the privileges already
granted in the several States are by no means secure. The
right of suffrage once exercised by women in certain States
and territories has been denied by subsequent legislation.
A
bill is now pending in congress to disfranchise the women of
Utah, thus interfering to deprive United States citizens of
the same rights which the Supreme Court has declared the
national government powerless to protect anywhere. Laws
passed after years of untiring effort, guaranteeing married
women certain rights of property, and mothers the custody of
their children, have been repealed in States where we
supposed all was safe.
Thus have our most sacred rights been
made the football of legislative caprice, proving that a
power which grants as a privilege what by nature is a right,
may withhold the same as a penalty when deeming it necessary
for its own perpetuation.
Representation of woman has had no place in the nation's
thought. Since the incorporation of the thirteen original
States, twenty-four have been admitted to the Union, not one
of which has recognized woman's right of self-government. On
this birthday of our national liberties, July Fourth, 1876,
Colorado, like all her elder sisters, comes into the Union
with the invidious word "male" in her constitution.
Universal manhood suffrage, by establishing an aristocracy
of sex, imposes upon the women of this nation a more
absolute and cruel depotism than monarchy; in that, woman
finds a political master in her father, husband, brother,
son. The aristocracies of the old world are based upon
birth, wealth, refinement, education, nobility, brave deeds
of chivalry; in this nation, on sex alone; exalting brute
force above moral power, vice above virtue, ignorance above
education, and the son above the mother who bore him.
The judiciary above the nation has proved itself but the
echo of the party in power, by upholding and enforcing laws
that are opposed to the spirit and letter of the
constitution. When the slave power was dominant, the Supreme
Court decided that a black man was not a citizen, because he
had not the right to vote; and when the constitution was so
amended as to make all persons citizens, the same high
tribunal decided that a woman, though a citizen, had not the
right to vote.
Such vacillating interpretations of
constitutional law unsettle our faith in judicial authority,
and undermine the liberties of the whole people.
These articles of impeachment against our rulers we now submit to
the impartial judgment of the people. To all these wrongs and
oppressions woman has not submitted in silence and resignation.
From the beginning of the century, when Abigail Adams, the wife
of one president and mother of another, said, "We will not hold
ourselves bound to obey laws in which we have no voice or
representation," until now, woman's discontent has been steadily
increasing, culminating nearly thirty years ago in a simultaneous
movement among the women of the nation, demanding the right of
suffrage.
In making our just demands, a higher motive than the
pride of sex inspires us; we feel that national safety and
stability depend on the complete recognition of the broad
principles of our government. Woman's degraded, helpless position
is the weak point in our institutions to-day; a disturbing force
everywhere, severing family ties, filling our asylums with the
deaf, the dumb, the blind; our prisons with criminals, our cities
with drunkenness and prostitution; our homes with disease and
death.
It was the boast of the founders of the republic, that the
rights for which they contended were the rights of human nature.
If these rights are ignored in the case of one-half the people,
the nation is surely preparing for its downfall. Governments try
themselves. The recognition of a governing and a governed class
is incompatible with the first principles of freedom. Woman has
not been a heedless spectator of the events of this century, nor
a dull listener to the grand arguments for the equal rights of
humanity.
From the earliest history of our country woman has
shown equal devotion with man to the cause of freedom, and has
stood firmly by his side in its defense. Together, they have made
this country what it is. Woman's wealth, thought and labor have
cemented the stones of every monument man has reared to liberty.
And now, at the close of a hundred years, as the hour-hand of the
great clock that marks the centuries points to 1876, we declare
our faith in the principles of self-government; our full equality
with man in natural rights; that woman was made first for her own
happiness, with the absolute right to herself--to all the
opportunities and advantages life affords for her complete
development; and we deny that dogma of the centuries,
incorporated in the codes of all nations--that woman was made for
man--her best interests, in all cases, to be sacrificed to his
will.
We ask of our rulers, at this hour, no special favors, no
special privileges, no special legislation. We ask justice, we
ask equality, we ask that all the civil and political rights that
belong to citizens of the United States, be guaranteed to us and
our daughters forever.[13]
The declaration was warmly applauded at many points, and after scattering another large number of printed copies, the delegation hastened to the convention of the National Association. A meeting had been appointed for twelve, in the old historic First Unitarian church, where Rev. Wm. H. Furness preached for fifty years, but whose pulpit was then filled by Joseph May, a son of Rev. Samuel J.
May. To this place the ladies made their way to find the church crowded with an expectant audience, which greeted them with thanks for what they had just done; the first act of this historic day taking place on the old centennial platform in Independence Square, the last in a church so long devoted to equality and justice. The venerable Lucretia Mott, then in her eighty-fourth year, presided.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton read the Declaration of Rights. Its reception by the listening audience proclaimed its need and its justice. The reading was followed by speeches upon the various points of the declaration.
Belva A. Lockwood took up the judiciary, showing the way that body lends itself to party politics. Matilda Joslyn Gage spoke upon the writ of habeas corpus, showing what a mockery to married women was that constitutional guarantee. Lucretia Mott reviewed the progress of the reform from the first convention. Sara Andrews Spencer illustrated the evils arising from two codes of morality.
Mrs. Devereux Blake spoke upon trial by jury; Susan B. Anthony upon taxation without representation, illustrating her remarks by incidents of unjust taxation of women during the present year.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton spoke upon the aristocracy of sex, and the evils arising from manhood suffrage. Judge Esther Morris, of Wyoming, said a few words in regard to suffrage in that territory.
Mrs. Margaret Parker, president of the woman suffrage club of Dundee, Scotland, and of the newly-formed Christian Woman's International Temperance Union, said she had seen nothing like this in Great Britain--it was worth the journey across the Atlantic. Mr.
J. H. Raper, of Manchester, England, characterized it as the historic meeting of the day, and said the patriot of a hundred years hence would seek for every incident connected with it, and the next centennial would be adorned by the portraits of the women who sat upon that platform.
The Hutchinsons, themselves of historic fame, were present. They were in their happiest vein, interspersing the speeches with appropriate and felicitous songs. Lucretia Mott did not confine herself to a single speech, but, in Quaker style, whenever the spirit moved made many happy points. When she first arose to speak, a call came from the audience for her to ascend the pulpit in order that she might be seen.
As she complied with this request, ascending the long winding staircase into the old-fashioned octagon pulpit, she said, "I am somewhat like Zaccheus of old who climbed the sycamore tree his Lord to see; I climb this pulpit, not because I am of lofty mind, but because I am short of stature that you may see me." As her sweet and placid countenance appeared above the pulpit, the Hutchinsons, by happy inspiration, burst into "Nearer, my God, to Thee." The effect was marvelous; the audience at once arose, and spontaneously joined in the hymn.
Phoebe W. Couzins, with great pathos, referred to woman's work in the war, and the parade of the Grand Army of the Republic the preceding evening; she said:
In such an hour as this, with my soul stirred to its deepest
depths, I feel unequal to the task of uttering words befitting
the occasion, and to follow the dear saint who has just spoken;
how can I? I am but a beginner, and to-day I feel that to sit at
the feet of these dear women who have borne the heat and burden
of this contest, and to learn of them is the attitude I should
assume. It is not the time for argument or rhetoric. It is the
time for introspection and prayer. We have come from Independence
Square, where the nation is celebrating its centennial birthday
of a masculine freedom. You have just heard from Mrs.
Stanton the
reading of Woman's Declaration of Rights; that document has
already been presented in engrossed form, tied with the symbolic
red, white and blue, to the presiding officer of the day, Senator
Thomas W. Ferry, on their platform in yonder square; and the John
Hampden of our cause, the immortal Susan B.
Anthony, rendered it
historic, by reading it from the steps of Independence Hall, to
an immense audience there gathered, that could not gain access to
the square or platform. [Great applause.] I cannot express to you
in fitting language the thoughts and feelings which stirred me as
I sat on the platform, awaiting the presentation of that
document.
We were about to commit an overt act. Gen. Hawley, president of
the centennial commission and manager of the programme, had
peremptorily forbidden its presentation.
Yet in the face of
this--in the face of the assembled nation and representatives
from the crowned heads of Europe, a handful of women actuated by
the same high principles as our fathers, stirred by the same
desire for freedom, moved by the same impulse for liberty, were
to again proclaim the right of self-government; were again to
impeach the spirit of King George manifested in our rulers, and
declare that taxation without representation is tyranny, that the
divine right of one-half of the people to rule the other half is
also despotism.
As I followed the reading of Richard Henry Lee,
and marked the wild enthusiasm of its reception, and remembered
that at its close, a document, as noble, as divine, as grand, as
historic as that, was to be presented in silence; an act, as
heroic, as worthy, as sublime, was to be performed in the face of
the contemptuous amazement of the assembled world, I trembled
with suppressed emotion.
When Susan Anthony arose, with a look of
intense pain, yet heroic determination in her face, I silently
committed her to the Great Father who seeth not in part, to
strengthen and comfort her heroic heart, and then she was lost to
view in the sudden uprising caused by the burst of applause
instituted by General Hawley in behalf of the Brazilian emperor.
And thus at the close of the reading of a document which
repudiated kings and declared the right of every person to life,
to liberty and the pursuit of individual happiness, the American
people, applauding a crowned monarch, received in silence the
immortal document and protest of its discrowned queens!
Shall I recount the emotion that swayed me, as I thought of all
that woman had done to build up this country; to sustain its
unity, to perpetuate its principles; of its self-denying and
heroic Pilgrim and revolutionary mothers; of the work of woman in
the anti-slavery cause; the agony and death of her travail in its
second birth for freedom; sustaining the nation by prayers, by
self-sacrificing contributions, by patriotic endeavors, by
encouraging words; and, reviewing the programme, and all the
attendant pageants, remembered that in these grand centennial
celebrations, when the nation rounded out its first century, not
a tribute, not a recognition in any shape, form or manner was
paid to woman; that upon the platform, as honored guests, sat
those who had been false in the hour of our country's peril; that
upon this historic soil, stood the now freeman, once a slave,
whose liberty and life were given him at the hands of woman; that
the inhabitants of the far off isles of the sea, India, Asia,
Africa, Europe, were gladly welcomed as free citizens, while
woman, a suppliant beggar, pleaded of one man, invested with
autocratic power, for the simple boon of presenting a protest in
silence, against her degradation, and was denied!
I stood yesterday on the corner of Broad and Chestnut streets,
watching the march of the Grand Army of the Republic. As the torn
and tattered battle flags came by, all the terrors of that war
tragedy suddenly rushed over me, and I sat down and wept. Looking
again, I saw the car of wounded, soldiers; as in thought I was
suddenly transported to the banks of the Mississippi I felt the
air full of the horrors of the battle of Shiloh, and saw two
young girls waiting the landing of a steamer that had been
dispatched to succor the wounded on that terrible field.
They
were watching for "mother"--who for the first time had left her
home charge, and hushing her own heart's pleadings, heard only
her country's call, and gone down to that field of carnage to
tenderly care for the soldier. As they boarded the steamer; what
a sight met their eyes! Maimed, bleeding, dying soldiers by the
hundreds, were on cots on deck, on boxes filled with amputated
limbs, and the dead were awaiting the last sad rites.
Like
ministering angels walked two women, their mother and the now
sainted Margaret Breckenridge of Kentucky, amid these rows of
sufferers, with strong nerve and steady arm, comforting the
soldier boy, so far from friends and home; binding up the ghastly
wound, bathing the feverish brow, smoothing the dying pillow, and
with tender mother's prayer and tear, closing the eyes of the
dead. The first revelation of war; how it burned our youthful
brain!
How it moved us to divine compassion, how it stirred us to
even give up our mother to the work for years, as we heard the
piteous pleading, "Don't leave us, mother"--"Oh, mother, we can
never forget." But alas they did forget!
This scene repeated
again, and again, during that long conflict, with hundreds of
women offering a like service in camp and floating hospital,
leaving sweet homes, without money, price or thought of
emolument, going to these battle-fields and tenderly nursing the
army of the republic to life again; while back of them were tens
of thousands other women of the great sanitary army, who, in
self-sacrifice at home, were sending lint, bandages, clothing,
delicacies of food and raiment of all kinds, by car-load and
ship-load, to comfort and ameliorate the sufferings of the grand
army of the republic, and yet as I watched its march in this
centennial year, its gala day--not a tribute marked its
gratitude to her who had proved its savior and friend, in the
hour of peril.
Again, came the colored man in rank and file--and in thought I
saw the fifteenth-amendment jubilee, which proclaimed his
emancipation. As banner after banner passed me, with the name of
Garrison, of Phillips, of Douglass, I looked in vain for the name
of Harriet Beecher Stowe, whose one book, "Uncle Tom's
Cabin"--did more to arouse the whole world to the horrors of
slavery, than did the words or works of any ten men. I searched
for a tribute to Lucretia Mott and other women of that conflict,
but none appeared.
And so to-day, standing here with heart and
brain convulsed with all these memories and scenes, can you
wonder that we are stirred to profoundest depths, as we review
the base ingratitude of this nation to its women? It has taxed
its women, and asked the women, in whose veins flows the blood of
their Pilgrim and Revolutionary mothers, to assist by money,
individual effort and presence, to make it a year of jubilee for
the proclamation of a ransomed male nationality.
Zenobia, in
gilded chains it may be, but chains nevertheless, marches through
the streets of Philadelphia to-day, an appendage of the chariot
wheels which proclaim the coming of her king, her lord, her
master, whether he be white or black, native or foreign-born,
virtuous or vile, lettered or unlettered.
As the state-house
bell, with its inscription, "Proclaim liberty--throughout the
land, unto all the inhabitants thereof," pealed forth its
jubilant reiteration,--the daughters of Jefferson, of Hancock, of
Adams, and Patrick Henry, who have been politically outlawed and
ostracized by their own countrymen, here had no liberty
proclaimed for them; they are not inhabitants, only sojourners in
the land of their fathers, and as the slaves in meek subjection
to the will of the master placed the crown of sovereignty on the
alien from Europe, Asia, Africa, she is asked to sing in dulcet
strains: "The king is dead--long live the king!"
And thus to-day we round out the first century of a professed
republic,--with woman figuratively representing freedom--and yet
all free, save woman.
For five long hours of that hot mid-summer's day, that crowded audience listened earnestly to woman's demand for equality of rights before the law. When the convention at last adjourned, the Hutchinsons singing, "A Hundred Years Hence,"[14] it was slowly and reluctantly that the great audience left the house. Judged by its immediate influence, it was a wonderful meeting. No elaborate preparations had been made, for not until late on Friday evening had it been decided upon, hoping still, as we did, for a recognition in the general celebration on Independence Square.
Speakers were not prepared, hardly a moment of thought had been given as to what should be said, but words fitting for the hour came to lips rendered eloquent by the pressure of intense emotion.
Day after day visitors to the woman suffrage parlors referred to this meeting in glowing terms. Ladies from distant States, in Philadelphia to visit the exposition, said that meeting was worth the whole expense of the journey. Young women with all the attractions of the day and the exposition enticing them, yet said, "The best of all I have seen in Philadelphia was that meeting."
Women to whom a dollar was of great value, said, "As much as I need money, I would not have missed that meeting for a hundred dollars"; while in the midst of conversation visitors would burst forth, "Was there ever such a meeting as that in Dr. Furness' church?" and thus was Woman's Declaration of Rights joyously received.
The day was also celebrated by women in convocations of their own all over the country.[15]
An interesting feature of the centennial parlors was an immense autograph book, in which the names of friends to the movement were registered by the thousands, some penned on that historic day and sent from the old world and the new, and others written on the spot during these eventful months. From the tidings of all these enthusiastic assemblies and immense number of letters[16] received in Philadelphia, unitedly demanding an extension of their rights, it was evident that the thinking women of the nation were hopefully waiting in the dawn of the new century for greater liberties to themselves.
From "Aunt Lottie's Centennial Letters to her Nieces and Nephews," we give the one describing this occasion:
MY DEARS: I suppose I had best tell you in this letter about the
Fourth of July celebration at the centennial city--at least that
portion of it that I know about, and which I would not have
missed for the exhibition itself, and which I would not have you
miss for all the rest of my letters. I cannot expect you to be as
much interested in it as was I, but it is time you were becoming
interested in the subject; and, if you live a half century from
this time (in less than that, I hope,) you will see that what I
am about to relate was, as General Hawley admitted it would be,
"the event of the occasion."
At the commencement of the exhibition, Miss Susan B. Anthony and
Mrs. Matilda Joslyn Gage came to Philadelphia and procured the
parlors of 1,431 Chestnut street for the accommodation of the
National Woman Suffrage Association. These rooms were open to the
friends of the association, and public receptions were held and
well attended every Tuesday and Friday evening. During these
months these two ladies--assisted the latter part of the time by
Mrs.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton--were engaged in preparing a history
of the suffrage movement and a declaration of rights to be
presented at the great centennial celebration of the Fourth of
July, 1876. This document is in form like the first declaration
of a hundred years ago, handsomely engrossed by Mrs. Sara Andrews
Spencer, of Washington--a lady delegate to the Cincinnati
Republican convention, June 12.
The celebration was held in Independence Square, just back of the
old state-house where the first declaration was signed. There was
a great crowd of people collected; a poem was read by Bayard
Taylor and a speech delivered by William M. Evarts. But I knew it
was useless to go there expecting to hear any portion of either;
so I waited until twelve o'clock and then rode down in the cars
to Dr. Furness' church, corner of Broad and Locust streets, where
these ladies were to hold their meeting. The church was full, and
the exercises were opened by Mrs.
Mott--the venerable and
venerated president--a Quaker lady of slight form, attired in a
plain, light-silk gown, white muslin neckerchief and cap, after
that exquisitely neat and quaint fashion. Then the Hutchinsons
sang a hymn, in which all were requested to join. Afterward Mrs.
Stanton came to the front of the pulpit, the house was hushed, to
a reverential stillness, and I never yet heard anything so solemn
and impressive as her reading of the Declaration of Rights of the
Women of the United States.
A printed copy had been given me the day before, when between the
sessions of the New England American Association in the Academy
of Music, where were Lucy Stone, Julia Ward Howe, Rev. Antoinette
Brown Blackwell, Elizabeth K. Churchill and other pleasant-faced,
sweet-voiced ladies, I had called at the rooms on Chestnut street
and folded declarations, for half an hour with Mrs. Stanton,
which they were distributing by post and in every way all over
the land.
When I read it at home that night I realized its
importance, but as the next day (the Fourth) was excessively
warm, I very nearly gave up going, and then I should have missed
the impressiveness of her reading. When she first commenced, her
voice seemed choked with emotion. She must have realized what she
was doing, as we all knew it was the grandest thing that had been
done in a hundred years. Thrill after thrill went through my
veins, and the whole scene formed a picture that will yet be the
subject of artists' pencils and poets' pens.
I should have been
contented to have had the meeting closed then with that best song
of the Hutchinsons upon the progress of reform, where the young
gentleman was so much applauded for his solo, "When Women Shall
be Free." Still we were all interested in Mrs.
Spencer's account
of her interview with General Hawley, and his refusal to permit
the silent handing-in of the declaration, which, after her
persistence, assuring him "it would not take three minutes," he
was obliged to confess was because he was "very well aware it
would be the event of the occasion." "Immediately," said Mrs.
Spencer, "you cannot imagine what an inspiration we all had to do
it; for," added the slight, fair-haired, fluent lady, in a
humorous manner that called forth laughter and applause, "I never
yet was forbidden by a man to do a thing, but that I resolved to
do it."
We were also pleased to hear from that earnest woman, Susan B.
Anthony, inspired by the immutable abstract truths of justice and
equity. Reports say that she has the air of a Catholic devotee.
She said that in defiance of "the powers that be" she took a
place on that platform in Independence square, and at the proper
time delivered the engrossed copy of the declaration to the Hon.
T. W. Ferry, who received it with a courteous bow; and afterward
on the steps of Independence Hall she read it to an assembled
multitude.
She had done her centennial day's work for all time;
and small wonder that mind and body craved rest after such
tension. She is yet under a hundred dollars fine for voting at
Rochester, and although from her lectures the last six years she
has paid $10,000 indebtedness on The Revolution, she said she
never would have paid that fine had she been imprisoned till now.
Mrs. Lucretia Mott, whom the younger Hutchinson[17] assisted into
the pulpit--a beautiful sight to see cultured youth supporting
refined old age--stated that she went up there, "not because she
was higher-minded than the rest, but so that her enfeebled voice
might be better heard." The dear old soul is so much stronger
than her body, that it would seem that she must have greatly
overtasked herself; though an inspired soul has wonderful
recuperative forces at command for the temple it inhabits.
A
goodly number of gentlemen were present at this meeting and that
of the day before--three or four of them making short speeches. A
Mr. Raper of England, strongly interested in the temperance and
woman suffrage cause, told us that in his country "all women
tax-payers voted for guardians of the poor, upon all educational
matters, and also upon all municipal affairs. In that respect she
was in advance of this professed republic.
In England there is an
hereditary aristocracy, here, an aristocracy of sex"; or, as the
spirited Lillie Devereux Blake who was present once amusingly
termed it, of "the bifurcated garment." And now perhaps some
materially-minded person will ask, "What are you going to do
about it? You can't fight!" forgetting that we are now fighting
the greatest of all battles, and that the weapons of woman's
warfare, like her nature at its best development, are moral and
spiritual.
LEWISE OLIVER.
Philadelphia, July 13, 1876.
The press of the country commented extensively upon the action of the women:
At noon to-day, in the First Unitarian church, corner Tenth and
South, the National Woman Suffrage Association will present the
Woman's Declaration of Rights. The association will hold a
convention at the same time and place, at which Lucretia Mott is
announced to preside, and several ladies to make speeches. Most
of the ladies are known as women of ability and earnest apostles
of the creed they have espoused for the political enfranchisement
of women. Their declaration of rights, we do not doubt, will be
strongly enforced.
These ladies, or some of them, have been
assigned places upon the platform at the grand celebration
ceremonies to take place in Independence Square to-day; and they
have requested leave to present their declaration of rights in
form on that occasion. They do not ask to have it read, we
believe, but simply that the statement of their case shall go on
file with the general archives of the day, so that the women of
1976 may see that their predecessors of 1876 did not let the
centennial year of independence pass without
protest.--[Philadelphia Ledger, July 4.
There was yet another incident of the Fourth, in Independence
Square. Immediately after the Declaration of Independence had
been read by Richard Henry Lee, and while the strains of the
"Greeting from Brazil" were rising upon the air, two ladies
pushed their way vigorously through the crowd and appeared upon
the speaker's platform. They were Susan B. Anthony and Matilda
Joslyn Gage. Hustling generals aside, elbowing governors, and
almost upsetting Dom Pedro in their charge, they reached
Vice-President Ferry, and handed him a scroll about three feet
long, tied with ribbons of various colors.
He was seen to bow and
look bewildered; but they had retreated in the same vigorous
manner before the explanation was whispered about. It appears
that they demanded a change of programme for the sake of reading
their address; but if so, this was probably a mere form intended
for future effect. More than six months ago some of the advocates
of female suffrage began in this city their crusade against
celebrating the centennial anniversary of a nation wherein women
are not permitted to vote.
The demand of Miss Anthony and Mrs.
Gage to be allowed to take part in a commemoration which many of
their associates discouraged and denounced, would have been a
cool proceeding had it been made in advance. Made, as it was,
through a very discourteous interruption, it pre-figures new
forms of violence and disregard of order which may accompany the
participation of women in active partisan politics.--[New York
Tribune.
The letter of a correspondent, printed in another column,
describing the presentation of a woman's bill of rights, in
Independence Square on the Fourth of July, will interest all
readers, whether or not they think with the correspondent, that
this little affair was the most important of the day's
proceedings. We have not a doubt that the persons who were
concerned in the affair enjoyed it heartily. Those of them who
made speeches naturally regarded their eloquence as a thing to
stir the nation. All persons who make speeches do. The day was a
warm one, and imagination, like the fire-cracker, was on fire.
In
the heat of the occasion, of course, the women who want to vote
and who desire the protection of the writ of habeas corpus
against the tyranny of actual or possible husbands, felt that
they were making great folios of history; but the sagacity of the
press agents and reporters was not at fault. The gatherers of
news know very well what they are about; and when they decided to
omit this part of the proceedings from their reports, they simply
obeyed that instinct upon which their livelihood depends--the
instinct, namely, to write only of matters in which the public is
interested.
The good women who wrote and published this declaration, fancying
that they were throwing a bombshell into the gathered crowds of
American (male) citizens, are very much in earnest, doubtless,
and are entitled--we have platform authority for saying it--to
"respectful consideration"; but their movement scarcely rises, as
yet at least, to the dignity of a great historical event. There
is a prevailing indifference to their cause which is against it.
The public is not aroused to a fever heat of indignation over the
wrongs which women are everywhere suffering at the hands of the
tyrants called husbands.
The popular mind is not yet awake to the
fact that men usually imprison their wives in back parlors and
maltreat them shamefully. The witnesses, wives to wit, refuse to
bear testimony to this effect, and the public placidly accepts
appearance for reality and believes that the gentlewomen who ride
about in their carriages or haunt the shops of our cities in gay
apparel are reasonably well contented with their lot in life.
In
a word, it is not hostility so much as calm indifference with
which the advocates of woman suffrage have to contend, and
unluckily for them the indifference is very largely
feminine.--[New York Evening Post.
There is something awful in the thought that should the woman
suffragists be continually refused a voice in the affairs of the
nation they might at last in a fit of desperation, do what our
fathers did, and frame a declaration of independence, No, 2. Just
think of an army of crinolines willing to take arms against the
tyrant man, and sacrifice their lives, if need be, to carry out
their principles! It is easier to ridicule the woman suffrage
movement than to answer the arguments advanced by some of the
leading advocates of that question.
It is only the innate
mildness of the position of women in general that has prevented a
revolution on this same subject long ago. One hundred thousand
such fire-eaters as Susan B. Anthony or Elizabeth Cady Stanton in
the land, could raise a rumpus which would cause the late
unpleasantness to pale into insignificance. Armed and equipped,
what a sight would be presented by an army of strong-minded
women! There would be no considering the question of whether the
cavalry should ride side-saddle, or a la clothes-pin.
Such
detail would be of too small importance to receive the slightest
attention; the more vital questions would be, "How can we
slaughter the most men?" "How can we soonest convince the demons
that we have rights which must be respected?" The fact is, that
if these down-trodden women would take a firm stand in any thing
like respectable numbers, and assert their claims to suffrage at
the point of the bayonet, they would be allowed everything they
asked for. There is not a man in the land who would dare to take
up arms against a woman.
Such a dernier resort on the part of the
women would be truly laughable, but the matter would cease to be
a joke, if General Susan B. Anthony, in command of a bloomer
regiment, should march into the halls of congress, armed
cap-a-pie, and demand the passage of a law in behalf of woman
suffrage, or the alternative of the general cleaning out of the
whole body. There is no immediate prospect of such an event, but
"hell hath no furies like a woman scorned." Long and loud have
been the appeals of the fair sex for recognition at the
ballot-box.
With that faithful zeal so truly characteristic of
her sex, she has each time, for many years in the history of this
country, presented herself before the curious gaze of our
national conventions, asking, with no little stress of argument,
for a woman's plank in the platforms. If she has been heard at
all in the framed resolutions of the parties, the feeling
prevailing in the conventions has been rather to pacify and put
her off, than to grant her request through motives of political
policy. If perseverance is to be awarded, the agitators of the
woman question will yet carry off the prize they seek.
Death
alone can silence such women as Susan B. Anthony and Cady
Stanton, and their teachings will live after them and unite
others of their sex into strong bands of sisterhood in a common
cause. It is safe to say, if events march on in the same
direction they have since the calling of the first National
Woman's Convention, another centennial will see woman in the
halls of legislation throughout the land, and so far as we are
concerned we have no objection, so long as she behaves
herself.--[St. Louis Dispatch, July 13.
It is a curious anomaly that the movement for national woman
suffrage in our country is most obstructed by women, and that
even where the men have doubts, their natural admiration for the
gentler sex almost converts them into champions. Certain it is
that the Declaration of Rights of the Women of the United States
that the National Woman Suffrage Association presented to the
vice-president, Mr.
Ferry, while he was surrounded by foreign
princes and potentates and by the governors of most of the States
of the union, faced at the same time by a countless mass of
American and foreign visitors--certain it is, we repeat, that
when this altogether unique paper was presented by Miss Susan B.
Anthony and her sisters, it became a record in the minds and
memory of all who witnessed the strange proceeding.
And it is a
very well written statement, and no doubt one hundred years hence
it will be read with an interest not less ecstatic than the
enthusiasm of its present pioneers; for, in the interval, these
advanced women may have won for their withholding sisters the
entire list of male prerogatives. What adds to the force of the
present woman suffrage party is the dignity, intelligence and
purity of its participants. The venerable Lucretia Mott; the
honest, straightforward Susan B.
Anthony; the cultivated Ellen
Clark Sargent (wife of the California senator); the beloved
Elizabeth Cady Stanton, and indeed all the names attached to the
declaration command our respect.
Whatever we may think of the
points of the declaration itself, with all our sincere admiration
of these gentlewomen, increased by the knowledge everywhere that
they are ardent republicans, we fear that their weakness, to
employ a paradox, consists in their strength, or, in other words,
that it is difficult to induce even the most benevolent and
sympathetic observer to believe that they are really as much
persecuted and oppressed as they claim to be.
When the colored
man demanded his rights they were given to him because these
rights in republican constitutions were regarded as inherent, and
also because he had reciprocal duties to discharge, and heavy
burdens to carry, and when the Southern confederate demanded
restitution of his rights, he rested his claim upon the double
basis that he had earned forgiveness by his bravery, and that
political disfranchisement did not belong to a republican
example.
Fortunately or unfortunately, it is very different with
the ladies; and so when they come forward insisting upon rights
heretofore accorded to men alone, they must encounter all the
differences created by the delicacy of their own sisters and the
reverence and love of the men, and the hard fact that these two
influences have made it heretofore impossible for women to
descend to the arena of politics.
Having said this much, we
present a few of the cardinal points of the woman's declaration
of rights laid before the august memorial centennial celebration
last Tuesday, July 4, 1876.--[Philadelphia Press, July 15.
On July 19, the Citizens' Suffrage Association, of Philadelphia, joined with the National Association in commemorating the first woman's rights convention called by Lucretia Mott and Elizabeth Cady Stanton, at Seneca Falls, N. Y., July 19, 1848--thus celebrating the twenty-eighth anniversary of that historic event.
The meeting was presided over by Edward M. Davis, president of the association, son-in-law of Lucretia Mott, and one of the most untiring workers in the cause. The venerable Lucretia Mott addressed the meeting, and Miss Anthony read letters from several of the earliest and most valued pioneers of the movement:
TENAFLY, New Jersey, July 19, 1876.
LUCRETIA MOTT--Esteemed Friend: It is twenty-eight years ago
to-day since the first woman's rights convention ever held
assembled in the Wesleyan chapel at Seneca Falls, N. Y.
Could we
have foreseen, when we called that convention, the ridicule,
persecution, and misrepresentation that the demand for woman's
political, religious and social equality would involve; the long,
weary years of waiting and hoping without success; I fear we
should not have had the courage and conscience to begin such a
protracted struggle, nor the faith and hope to continue the work.
Fortunately for all reforms, the leaders, not seeing the
obstacles which block the way, start with the hope of a speedy
success.
Our demands at the first seemed so rational that I
thought the mere statement of woman's wrongs would bring
immediate redress. I thought an appeal to the reason and
conscience of men against the unjust and unequal laws for women
that disgraced our statute books, must settle the question. But I
soon found, while no attempt was made to answer our arguments,
that an opposition, bitter, malignant, and persevering, rooted in
custom and prejudice, grew stronger with every new demand made,
with every new privilege granted.
How well I remember that July day when the leading ladies and
gentlemen of the busy town crowded into the little church;
lawyers loaded with books, to expound to us the laws; ladies with
their essays, and we who had called the convention, with our
declaration of rights, speeches, and resolutions. With what
dignity James Mott, your sainted husband, tall and stately, in
Quaker costume, presided over our novel proceedings. And your
noble sister, Martha C. Wright, was there.
Her wit and wisdom
contributed much to the interest of our proceedings, and her
counsel in a large measure to what success we claimed for our
first convention. While so many of those early friends fell off
through indifference, fear of ridicule and growing conservatism,
she remained through these long years of trial steadfast to the
close of a brave, true life. She has been present at nearly every
convention, with her encouraging words and generous
contributions, and being well versed in Cushing's Manual, has
been one of our chief presiding officers.
And my heart is filled
with gratitude, even at this late day, as I recall the
earnestness and eloquence with which Frederick Douglass advocated
our cause, though at that time he had no rights himself that any
white man was bound to respect. I marvel now, that in our
inexperience the interest was so well sustained through two
entire days, and that when the meeting adjourned everybody signed
the declaration and went home feeling that a new era had dawned
for woman. What had been done and said seemed so preeminently
wise and proper that none of us thought of being ridiculed,
ostracised, or suspected of evil.
But what was our surprise and
chagrin to find ourselves, in a few days, the target for the
press of the nation; the New York Tribune being our only strong
arm of defense.
Looking over these twenty-eight years, I feel that what we have
achieved, as yet, bears no proportion to what we have suffered in
the daily humiliation of spirit from the cruel distinctions based
on sex. Though our State laws have been essentially changed, and
positions in the schools, professions, and world of work secured
to woman, unthought of thirty years ago, yet the undercurrent of
popular thought, as seen in our social habits, theological
dogmas, and political theories, still reflects the same customs,
creeds, and codes that degrade women in the effete civilizations
of the old world.
Educated in the best schools to logical
reasoning, trained to liberal thought in politics, religion and
social ethics under republican institutions, American women
cannot brook the discriminations in regard to sex that were
patiently accepted by the ignorant in barbarous ages as divine
law. And yet subjects of emperors in the old world, with their
narrow ideas of individual rights, their contempt of all
womankind, come here to teach the mothers of this republic their
true work and sphere.
Such men as Carl Schurz, breathing for the
first time the free air of our free land, object to what we
consider the higher education of women, fitting them for the
trades and professions, for the sciences and arts, and
self-complacently point Lucretia Mott, Maria Mitchell, Harriet
Beecher Stowe, Susan B. Anthony, to their appropriate sphere, as
housekeepers with a string of keys, like Madam Bismark, dangling
around their waists.
The Rev. J. G. Holland, the Tupper of our American literature,
thanks his Creator that woman has no specialty. She was called
into being for man's happiness and interest--his helpmeet--to
wait and watch his movements, to second his endeavors, to fight
the hard battle of life behind him whose brain may be dizzy with
excess, whose limbs may be paralyzed, or if sound in body, may be
without aim or ambition, without plans or projects, destitute of
executive ability or good judgment in the business affairs of
life.
And such sentimentalists, after demoralizing women with
their twaddle, discourage our demand for the right of suffrage by
pointing us to the fact that the majority of women are
indifferent to this movement in their behalf. Suppose they are;
have not the masses of all oppressed classes been apathetic and
indifferent until partial success crowned the enthusiasm of the
few? Carl Schurz would not have been exiled from his native land
could he have roused the majority of his countrymen to the same
love of liberty which burned in his own soul.
Were his dreams of
freedom less real because the stolid masses were not awake to
their significance? Shall a soul that accepts martyrdom for a
principle be told he is sacrificing himself to a shadow because
the multitude can neither see nor appreciate the idea?
I do not feel like rejoicing over any privileges already granted
to my sex, until all our rights are conceded and secured and the
principle of equality recognized and proclaimed, for every step
that brings us to a more equal plane with man but makes us more
keenly feel the loss of those rights we are still denied--more
susceptible to the insults of his assumptions and usurpations of
power.
As I sum up the indignities toward women, as illustrated
by recent judicial decisions--denied the right to vote, denied
the right to practice in the Supreme Court, denied jury trial--I
feel the degradation of sex more bitterly than I did on that July
19, 1848, and never more than in listening to your speech in
Philadelphia on the Fourth of July, our nation's centennial
birthday, remembering that neither years nor wisdom, brave words
nor noble deeds, could secure political honor or call forth
national homage for women.
Let it be remembered by our daughters
in future generations that Lucretia Mott, in the eighty-fourth
year of her age, asked permission, as the representative woman of
this great movement for the enfranchisement of her sex, to
present at the centennial celebration of our national liberties,
Woman's Declaration of Rights, and was refused! This was the
"respectful consideration" vouchsafed American women at the close
of the first century of our national life.
May we now safely prophesy justice, liberty, equality for our
daughters ere another centennial birthday shall dawn upon us!
Sincerely yours, ELIZABETH CADY STANTON.
DETROIT, July 17, 1876.
To Lucretia Mott, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Mary Ann McClintock
and daughters, Amy Post, and all associated with them and myself
in the first Woman's Rights Convention, held in Seneca Falls, N.
Y., July 19, 1848, as well as to our later and present
associates, Greeting:
Not able to be with you in your celebration of the nineteenth, I
will yet give evidence that I prize your remembrance of our first
assemblage and of our earliest work. That is, and will ever be as
the present is a memorable year; and may this be memorable too
for the same reason, a brave step in advance for human freedom. I
would that it could be a conclusive step in legislation for the
political freedom of the women of the nation.
For it is only in
harmony with reason and experience to predict that the men as
well as the women of the near future will rejoice if this
centennial year is thus marked and glorified by so grand a deed.
We may well congratulate each other and have satisfaction in
knowing that we have changed the public sentiment and the laws of
many States by our advocacy and labors. We also know that while
helping the growth of our own souls, we have set many women
thinking and reading on this vital question, who in turn have
discussed it in private and public, and thus inspired others. So
that at this present time few who have examined can deny our
claim.
But we are grateful to remember many women who needed no
arguments, whose clear insight and reason, pronounced in the
outset that a woman's soul was as well worth saving as a man's;
that her independence and free choice are as necessary and as
valuable to the public virtue and welfare; who saw and still see
in both, equal children of a Father who loves and protects all.
Men do not need to be convinced of the righteousness of entire
freedom for us; they have long been convinced of its justice;
they confess that it is only expediency which makes them withhold
that which they profess is precious to them. We await only an
awakened conscience and an enlarged statesmanship.
I bid you and the women of the republic God-speed, and close in
the language of one who went before us, Mary Wollstonecraft, who
did so much in a thoughtless age to bring both men and women back
to virtue and religion. She says: "Contending for the rights of
woman, my main argument is built on this simple principle, that
if she be not prepared by education to become the companion of
man, she will stop the progress of knowledge and virtue; for
truth must be common to all or it will be inefficacious with
respect to its influence in general practice.
And how can woman
be expected to cooeperate unless she know why she ought to be
virtuous; unless freedom strengthen her reason till she
comprehends her duty and sees in what manner it is connected with
her real good? If children are to be educated to understand the
true principle of patriotism, their mother must be a patriot; and
the love of mankind from which an orderly train of virtues
spring, can only be produced by considering the moral and civil
interests of mankind; but the education and situation of woman at
present, shuts her out from such investigations."
With the greatest possible interest in your celebration and
deliberations, and assuring you that I shall be with you in
thought and spirit, I am most earnestly and cordially yours,
CATHARINE A. F. STEBBINS.
ROCHESTER, N. Y., June 27, 1876.
MY DEAR SUSAN ANTHONY: I thank thee most deeply for the assurance
of a welcome to your deliberative councils in our country's
centennial year, to reannounce our oft-repeated protest against
bondage to tyrant law. Most holy cause! Woman's equality, why so
long denied?... I was ready at the first tap of the drum that
sounded from that hub of our country, Seneca Falls, in 1848,
calling for an assembly of men and women to set forth and
remonstrate against the legal usurpation of our rights.... I
cannot think of anything that would give me as much pleasure as
to be able to meet with you at this time.
I am exceedingly glad
that you appreciate the blessings of frequent visits and wise
counsel from our beloved and venerated pioneer, Lucretia Mott. I
hope her health and strength will enable her to see and enjoy the
triumphant victory of this work, and I wish you all the blessings
of happiness that belong to all good workers, and my love to them
all as if named.
AMY POST.
POMO, Mendocino Co., California, June 26, 1876.
July 4, 1776, our revolutionary fathers--in convention
assembled--declared their independence of the mother country;
solemnly asserted the divine right of self-government and its
relation to constituted authority. With liberty their shibboleth,
the colonies triumphed in their long and fierce struggle with the
mother country, and established an independent government. They
adopted a "bill of rights" embodying their ideal of a free
government.
With singular inconsistency almost their first act, while it
secured to one-half the people of the body politic the right to
tax and govern thems
Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence
The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.
Transcriber and production notes
Produced by Richard J. Shiffer and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net
Front matter as received (title page, contents)
[Transcriber's Note: Every effort has been made to replicate this
text as faithfully as possible, including obsolete and variant
spellings and other inconsistencies. Text that has been changed to
correct an obvious error is noted at the end of this ebook.
Also, many occurrences of mismatched single and double quotes
remain as they were in the original.]
[Illustration: Phoebe W. Couzins.]
HISTORY
of
WOMAN SUFFRAGE.
EDITED BY
ELIZABETH CADY STANTON,
SUSAN B. ANTHONY, AND
MATILDA JOSLYN GAGE.
ILLUSTRATED WITH STEEL ENGRAVINGS.
_IN THREE VOLUMES._
VOL. III.
1876-1885.
"WOMEN ARE CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES, ENTITLED TO ALL
THE RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES GUARANTEED
TO CITIZENS BY THE NATIONAL CONSTITUTION."
SUSAN B. ANTHONY,
17 MADISON ST., ROCHESTER, N. Y.
Copyright, 1886, by SUSAN B. ANTHONY.Header as received
The Project Gutenberg eBook of History of Woman Suffrage, Volume III
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: History of Woman Suffrage, Volume III
Editor: Elizabeth Cady Stanton
Susan B. Anthony
Matilda Joslyn Gage
Release date: April 11, 2009 [eBook #28556]
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/28556
Credits: Produced by Richard J. Shiffer and the Online Distributed
Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.netFull Project Gutenberg licence
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
States without permission and without paying copyright
royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
license, especially commercial redistribution.
START: FULL LICENSE
THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
www.gutenberg.org/license.
Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
electronic works
1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
you share it without charge with others.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
country other than the United States.
1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
beginning of this work.
1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
Gutenberg License.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
provided that:
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation.”
• You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
works.
• You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
receipt of the work.
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
forth in Section 3 below.
1.F.
1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
cannot be read by your equipment.
1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
DAMAGE.
1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
without further opportunities to fix the problem.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
remaining provisions.
1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
Defect you cause.
Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
from people in all walks of life.
Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation
Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
public support and donations to carry out its mission of
increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
status with the IRS.
The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
approach us with offers to donate.
International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
volunteer support.
Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
edition.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.
This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #28556. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.