
Gutenberg · ebook 28436
A Handbook of the English Language
by R. G. Latham · English · public domain in the US
SECTION PAGE
- English language not British 1
- Real origin German 1
- Accredited immigrations and settlements 2
4, 5. Criticism 4, 5
CHAPTER II.
GERMANIC ORIGIN OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--THE GERMANIC AREA OF THE
PARTICULAR GERMANS WHO INTRODUCED IT.--EXTRACT FROM BEDA.
6, 7. Jutes, Angles, and Saxons 6
8, 9. Extract from Beda 6, 7
10-13. Criticism 8-11
14, 15. Angles 11, 12
16. Saxons of Beda 12, 13
17. Anglo-Saxon area 13
18, 19. The Frisians 13, 14
20. Anglo-Saxon area 14
CHAPTER III.
OF THE DIALECTS OF THE SAXON AREA, AND OF THE SO-CALLED OLD SAXON.
21-29. Old Saxon and Anglo-Saxon 16, 17
CHAPTER IV.
AFFINITIES OF THE ENGLISH WITH THE LANGUAGES OF GERMANY AND SCANDINAVIA.
30, 31. Gothic languages 18
32-34. Divisions of the Gothic stock 18
35. Moeso-Gothic 19
36. Old High German 19
37. Low German 19
38. Frisian and Dutch 19
39. Platt-Deutsch 20
40, 41. Comparison 21-23
CHAPTER V.
ANALYSIS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--GERMANIC ELEMENTS.--THE ANGLES.
- Analysis 24
43-54. Angles--their relations 24-28
55, 56. The Frisians 29, 30
CHAPTER VI.
THE CELTIC STOCK OF LANGUAGES AND THEIR RELATIONS TO THE ENGLISH.
- Branches of the Celtic stock 31
58-60. Structure of Celtic tongues 31-33
61-63. The Picts 33-35
CHAPTER VII.
THE ANGLO-NORMAN, AND THE LANGUAGE OF THE CLASSICAL STOCK.
- The classical languages 36
65-67. Latin branch 36-40
68, 69. Norman French 40, 41
PART II.
HISTORY AND ANALYSIS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
CHAPTER I.
HISTORICAL AND LOGICAL ELEMENTS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- Celtic elements 45
- Latin of first period 46
- Anglo-Saxon 47
- Danish or Norse 47
- Roman of second period 49
- Anglo-Norman element 49
- Indirect Scandinavian elements 50
- Latin of third period 51
- Latin of fourth period 51
- Greek 52
80-82. Tables 53-55
83-90. Miscellaneous elements 55-60
91-94. Hybridism and new words 60-62
95. Historical and logical analysis 63
CHAPTER II.
THE RELATION OF THE ENGLISH TO THE ANGLO-SAXON, AND THE STAGES OF THE
ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- Ancient and modern tongues 64
- Details 65-68
- Stages of the English language 68
- Semi-Saxon 69
100-103. Old English, &c. 70-72
104. Present tendencies 73
PART III.
SOUNDS, LETTERS, PRONUNCIATION, SPELLING.
CHAPTER I.
GENERAL NATURE AND CERTAIN PROPERTIES OF ARTICULATE SOUNDS.
- Spelling and speaking 77
- Sounds and syllables 79
- Vowels 79
- Divisions 80
- Sharp and flat sounds 80
- Continuous and explosive 80
- General statements 81
- The sound of h 81
CHAPTER II.
SYSTEM OF ARTICULATE SOUNDS.
- Certain foreign sounds 82
- System of mutes 82
- Lenes and aspirates 83
- Fourfold character of mutes 84
- Y and w 84
118, 119. Diphthongs 84
120. Compound sounds 85
121. Ng 85
122, 123. Broad, slender; long, short;
dependent, independent vowels 85, 86
124-126. System of sounds 86, 87
CHAPTER III.
OF CERTAIN COMBINATIONS OF ARTICULATE SOUNDS.
- Sharp and flat mutes 88
- Unstable combinations 89
- Effect of y 89
130, 131. Double consonants rare 89
132. True aspirates rare 90
CHAPTER IV.
EUPHONY AND THE PERMUTATION OF LETTERS.
- Euphony 92
- Permutation 93
CHAPTER V.
ON THE FORMATION OF SYLLABLES.
- Syllabification 95-97
CHAPTER VI.
ON QUANTITY.
- Long and short sounds 98
- Quantity of vowels--of syllables 98
- Classical and English measurements 99
CHAPTER VII.
ON ACCENT.
- Place of accents 101
- Distinctive accents 101
- Emphasis 102
CHAPTER VIII.
ORTHOGRAPHY.
- Orthoepy 103
143-146. Principle of an alphabet 103-105
147. Violations of it 105
148. Rules 107
149-151. Details of English 107-109
152. Insufficiency 109
153. Inconsistency 109
154. Erroneousness 110
155. Redundancy 110
156. Unsteadiness 110
157. Other defects 111
158. Historical propriety 113
159. Conventional spelling 113
CHAPTER IX.
HISTORICAL SKETCH OF THE ENGLISH ALPHABET.
160-166. Phoenician, Greek, Roman stages 116-124
166-172. Anglo-Saxon alphabet 124-126
173. Anglo-Norman alphabet 126
174. Extract from Ormulum 127
175. Order of alphabet 128
PART IV.
ETYMOLOGY.
CHAPTER I.
ON THE PROVINCE OF ETYMOLOGY.
176-179. Meaning of term 131-133
CHAPTER II.
ON GENDER.
- Boy and girl 134
- Man-servant and maid-servant 134
182, 183. Forms like genitrix 135
184. Forms like domina 136
185-189. Genders in English 136, 137
190-192. _The sun in his glory; the moon
in her wane_ 138
193. Miscellaneous forms 139-142
CHAPTER III.
THE NUMBERS.
194-197. Numbers in English 143, 144
198. Rule 145
199. Remarks 145
200. Addition of -es 146
Pence, alms, &c. 147
Mathematics 147
201. Children 149
202. Form in -en 150
203. Men, feet, &c. 150
204. Brethren, &c. 150
205. Houses 152
206. Wives, &c. 152
CHAPTER IV.
ON THE CASES.
207-211. Nature of cases 154-156
212. Accusatives 156
213. Datives 157
214. Genitives 157
215. Instrumental 158
All the better 158, 159
216. Determination of cases 159
217. Analysis of cases 160
218. Form in -s 160
CHAPTER V.
THE PERSONAL PRONOUNS.
219, 220. I, we, us, &c. 162
221. You 162
222. Me 163
223-225. Cautions 163, 164
CHAPTER VI.
ON THE TRUE REFLECTIVE PRONOUN IN THE GOTHIC LANGUAGES, AND ON ITS
ABSENCE IN ENGLISH.
- How far found in English 165
CHAPTER VII.
THE DEMONSTRATIVE PRONOUNS, ETC.
- He, she, it 166
- She 166
- Her, him, his, its, &c. 167
- Theirs 167
- Table 168
- These 169
- Those 171
CHAPTER VIII.
THE RELATIVE, INTERROGATIVE, AND CERTAIN OTHER PRONOUNS.
- Who, what, &c. 173
- Same, &c. 173
- Other, whether 177
CHAPTER IX.
ON CERTAIN FORMS IN -ER.
237-239. Idea expressed by -er 179-181
CHAPTER X.
THE COMPARATIVE DEGREE.
- Form in -s 182
- Elder, &c. 183
- Rather 183
243, 244. Excess of expression 183
245-247. Better 183-185
248. Worse 185
249. More 185
250. Less 185
251-253. Near, &c. 186
254. Origin of superlative 186
CHAPTER XI.
THE SUPERLATIVE DEGREE.
255, 256. Former 188
257. Nearest 188
258. Next 188
259, 260. Upmost, &c. 189, 190
CHAPTER XII.
THE CARDINAL NUMBERS.
- How far undeclined 191
CHAPTER XIII.
THE ORDINAL NUMBERS.
262-264. Seven, nine, ten 192
265, 266. Thirteen, thirty 193
CHAPTER XIV.
THE ARTICLES.
- A, an, the 194
CHAPTER XV.
DIMINUTIVES, AUGMENTATIVES, AND PATRONYMICS.
268-270. Diminutives 197-199
271. Augmentatives 200
272. Patronymics 200, 201
CHAPTER XVI.
GENTILE FORMS.
- Wales 202
CHAPTER XVII.
ON THE CONNEXION BETWEEN THE NOUN AND VERB, AND ON THE INFLECTION OF THE
INFINITIVE MOOD.
274-281. The verb, how far a noun 203-206
CHAPTER XVIII.
ON DERIVED VERBS.
- Divisions of verbs 207
- Derivation 208, 209
CHAPTER XIX.
ON THE PERSONS.
- Persons in English 210
284, 285. Historical view 211
286. Form in -t 212
287. Thou spakest, &c. 212
288. We loves 213
CHAPTER XX.
ON THE NUMBERS OF VERBS.
- Numbers in English 214
- Ran, run, &c. 215
CHAPTER XXI.
ON MOODS.
291-292. Moods in English 216
CHAPTER XXII.
ON TENSES IN GENERAL.
- Strike, struck 217
294-296. [Greek: Etupton], &c. 217, 218
297. Reduplication 219
298. Weak or strong 220
CHAPTER XXIII.
THE STRONG TENSES.
- Sing, sang, sung 221
300-303. Tables 222-225
CHAPTER XXIV.
THE WEAK TENSES.
- Stabbed, &c. 226
305-307. Divisions 227, 228
309. Bought, sought 228
309. Forms in -te and -ode 229
310-312. Bred, beat, &c. 230
313. Leave, left 231
314. Made, had 231
314. Would, should, could 231
315. Aught 231
316. Durst, must, &c.
232
317. This will do 233
318. Mind 234
319. Yode 234
320. Did 234
CHAPTER XXV.
ON CONJUGATION.
321, 322. Weak and strong conjugations natural
235-237
CHAPTER XXVI.
DEFECTIVENESS AND IRREGULARITY.
323-325. Irregularity 238
326. Vital and obsolete processes 240
327. Processes of necessity, &c. 241
328. Ordinary processes 241
329. Positive 242
330. Normal 242
331. Could 243
332. Quoth 244
333. Real irregular verbs few 244
CHAPTER XXVII.
THE IMPERSONAL VERBS.
334, 335. Me-seems, me-listeth 246
CHAPTER XXVIII.
THE VERB SUBSTANTIVE.
- Not irregular 247
- Was 247
338-341. Be 248, 249
342. An 249
343. Worth 250
CHAPTER XXIX.
THE PRESENT PARTICIPLE.
- Forms in -ing 251
- Forms in -ung 252
CHAPTER XXX.
THE PAST PARTICIPLE.
- Forms in -en 254
347, 348. Drunken 254
349. Forlorn 255
350. Forms in -ed 255
351. The prefix Y 256
CHAPTER XXXI.
COMPOSITION.
352-357. Nature of compounds 258-261
358-361. Accent 261-266
362. Obscure compounds 266
363-365. Exceptions 266, 267, 268
366. Peacock, peahen 269
367. Nightingale 269
368. Improper compounds 270
369. Decomposites 270
370. Combinations 270, 271
CHAPTER XXXII.
ON DERIVATION AND INFLECTION.
371-373. Their nature 272-275
CHAPTER XXXIII.
ADVERBS.
374, 375. Their division 276
376-379. Adverbs of deflection 277
380. Darkling 278
CHAPTER XXXIV.
ON CERTAIN ADVERBS OF PLACE.
381-384. Hither, thither, &c 279
385. Hence, &c. 280
386. Yonder 280
387. Anon 281
CHAPTER XXXV.
ON WHEN, THEN, AND THAN.
388, 389. Their origin 282
CHAPTER XXXVI.
PREPOSITIONS AND CONJUNCTIONS.
- Prepositions 283
- Conjunctions 283
- Yes, No 283
- Particles 283
CHAPTER XXXVII.
ON THE GRAMMATICAL POSITION OF THE WORDS mine AND thine.
394-407. Equivalent to meus and tuus, rather than possessive
cases 284-290
CHAPTER XXXVIII.
ON THE CONSTITUTION OF THE WEAK PRÆTERITE.
- Grimm's view 291
409, 410. Remarks of Dr. Trithen 291-293
PART V.
SYNTAX.
CHAPTER I.
ON SYNTAX IN GENERAL.
411, 412. Syntax 294
413. Personification 294
414. Ellipsis 295
415. Pleonasm 295
416. Zeugma 295
417. Pros to semainomenon 296
418. Apposition 296
419. Collectiveness 297
420. Reduction 297
421. Determination of part of speech 298
422-424.
Convertibility 298, 299
425. The Blacks of Africa 299
426. None of your ifs 300
427. Convertible words numerous in English 300
CHAPTER II.
SYNTAX OF SUBSTANTIVES.
- Rundell and Bridge's 301
- Right and left 301
CHAPTER III.
SYNTAX OF ADJECTIVES.
- Pleonasm 302
- Collocation 302
- Government 302
- More wise, wiser 303
- _The better of the two_ 304
- Syntax of adjectives simple 304
CHAPTER IV.
SYNTAX OF PRONOUNS.
- Pleonasm 305
- Father's, not father his 305
- Pleonasm and ellipses allied 306
CHAPTER V.
THE TRUE PERSONAL PRONOUNS.
- Pronomen reverentiæ 307
- Dativus ethicus 307
- Reflected pronoun 307
- Reflected neuters 308
- Equivocal reflective 308
CHAPTER VI.
ON THE SYNTAX OF THE DEMONSTRATIVE PRONOUNS, AND THE PRONOUNS OF THE
THIRD PERSON.
444, 445. His and its 310, 311
CHAPTER VII.
ON THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE WORD self.
446, 447. Myself, himself, &c. 312, 313
CHAPTER VIII.
ON THE POSSESSIVE PRONOUNS.
448-451. My and mine 314-316
CHAPTER IX.
THE RELATIVE PRONOUNS.
452-456. Their concord 317, 318
457. Ellipsis 318
458. Equivocal antecedent 319
CHAPTER X.
ON THE INTERROGATIVE PRONOUN.
459, 460. Direct and oblique questions 320
CHAPTER XI.
THE RECIPROCAL PRONOUNS.
461, 462. Their construction 322, 323
CHAPTER XII.
THE INDETERMINATE PRONOUNS.
463-466. Use of it 324, 325
467, 468. Use of them 325
CHAPTER XX.
ON THE TENSES.
- Present 342
486, 487. Preterite 342
CHAPTER XXI.
SYNTAX OF THE PERSONS OF VERBS.
488, 489. Their concord 344
CHAPTER XXII.
ON THE VOICES OF VERBS.
- Hight 345
CHAPTER XXIII.
ON THE AUXILIARY VERBS.
- Their classification 346-348
- I have ridden 348
- I am to speak 351
- I am to blame 351
- I am beaten 351
CHAPTER XXIV.
OF ADVERBS.
496, 497. Their syntax simple 353
498. Termination -ly 354
499. To walk and ride 354
500. From whence, &c. 354, 355
CHAPTER XXV.
ON PREPOSITIONS.
- Climb up a tree 356
- Part of the body 356
CHAPTER XXVI.
ON CONJUNCTIONS.
503, 504. Their nature 357-359
505. Their government 359
506-511. The subjunctive mood 359-364
512. Use of that 364
513. Succession of tenses 364
514. Disjunctives 365
CHAPTER XXVII.
THE SYNTAX OF THE NEGATIVE.
- Its place 366
- Its distribution 366
- Two negatives 367
- Questions of appeal 367
CHAPTER XXVIII.
ON THE CASE ABSOLUTE.
- Its participial character 369
PART VI.
PROSODY.
- Derivation of the word 371
521, 522. Importance of accent 371
523-526. Measures 372, 373
527. Metrical notation 374
528-535. Rhyme 374-377
536. Blank verse 377
537, 538. Last syllable indifferent 378
539, 540. Names of common English metres 379-384
PART VII.
DIALECTS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- Saxons and Angles 385
542-544. Dialects not coincident 385, 386
545, 546. Traces of the Danes 386, 387
547 Mercian origin of the written English 387
NOTES 393
- * * * *
AN INTRODUCTION
TO THE STUDY OF
THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- * * * *
PART I.
GENERAL ETHNOLOGICAL RELATIONS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- * * * *
CHAPTER I.
GERMANIC ORIGIN OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--DATE.
§ 1. The first point to be remembered in the history of the English language, is that it was not the primitive and original tongue of any of the British Islands, nor yet of any portion of them. Indeed, of the whole of Great Britain it is not the language at the present moment. Welsh is spoken in Wales, Manks in the Isle of Man, and Scotch Gaelic in the Highlands of Scotland; besides which there is the Irish Gaelic in Ireland.
§ 2. The next point to be considered is the real origin and the real affinities of the English language.
Its real origin is on the continent of Europe, and its real affinities are with certain languages there spoken. To speak more specifically, the native country of the English language is Germany; and the Germanic languages are those that are the most closely connected with our own. In Germany, languages and dialects allied to each other and allied to the mother-tongue of the English have been spoken from times anterior to history; and these, for most purposes of philology, may be considered as the aboriginal languages and dialects of that country.
§ 3. Accredited details of the different immigrations from Germany into Britain.--Until lately the details of the different Germanic invasions of England, both in respect to the particular tribes by which they were made, and the order in which they succeeded each other, were received with but little doubt, and as little criticism.
Respecting the tribes by which they were made, the current opinion was, that they were chiefly, if not exclusively, those of the Jutes, the Saxons, and the Angles.
The particular chieftains that headed each descent were also supposed to be known, as well as the different localities upon which they descended.[1] These were as follows:--
First settlement of invaders from Germany.--The account of this gives us A.D. 449 for the first permanent Germanic tribes settled in Britain.
Ebbsfleet, in the Isle of Thanet, was the spot where they landed; and the particular name that these tribes gave themselves was that of Jutes.
Their leaders were Hengist and Horsa. Six years after their landing they had established the kingdom of Kent; so that the county of Kent was the first district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English, introduced from Germany.
Second settlement of invaders from Germany.--A.D. 477 invaders from Northern Germany made the second permanent settlement in Britain. The coast of Sussex was the spot whereon they landed. The particular name that these tribes gave themselves was that of Saxons. Their leader was Ella. They established the kingdom of the South Saxons (Sussex or Suð-Seaxe); so that the county of Sussex was the second district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English, introduced from Germany.
Third settlement of invaders from Germany.--A.D. 495 invaders from Northern Germany made the third permanent settlement in Britain. The coast of Hampshire was the spot whereon they landed. Like the invaders last mentioned, these tribes were Saxons. Their leader was Cerdic. They established the kingdom of the West Saxons (Wessex or West-Seaxe); so that the county of Hants was the third district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English, introduced from Germany.
Fourth settlement of invaders from Germany.--A.D. 530, certain Saxons landed in Essex, so that the county of Essex [East-Seaxe] was the fourth district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English, introduced from Northern Germany.
Fifth settlement of invaders from Germany.--These were Angles in Norfolk and Suffolk. The precise date of this settlement is not known. The fifth district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English was the counties of Norfolk and Suffolk; the particular dialect introduced being that of the Angles.
Sixth settlement of invaders from Germany.--A.D. 547 invaders from Northern Germany made the sixth permanent settlement in Britain. The southeastern counties of Scotland, between the rivers Tweed and Forth, were the districts where they landed. They were of the tribe of the Angles, and their leader was Ida. The south-eastern parts of Scotland constituted the sixth district where the original British was superseded by the mother-tongue of the present English, introduced from Northern Germany,
§ 4. It would be satisfactory if these details rested upon contemporary evidence. This, however, is far from being the case.
- The evidence to the details just given, is not historical, but
traditional.--a. Beda,[2] from whom it is chiefly taken, wrote nearly 300 years after the supposed event, i.e., the landing of Hengist and Horsa, in A.D. 449.
b. The nearest approach to a contemporary author is Gildas,[3] and he wrote full 100 years after it.
- The account of Hengist's and Horsa's landing, has elements which are
fictional rather than historical--a. Thus "when we find Hengist and Horsa approaching the coasts of Kent in three keels, and Ælli effecting a landing in Sussex with the same number, we are reminded of the Gothic tradition which carries a migration of Ostrogoths,[4] Visigoths, and Gepidæ, also in three vessels, to the mouth of the Vistula."--Kemble, "Saxons in England."
b. The murder of the British chieftains by Hengist is told totidem verbis, by Widukind[5] and others, of the Old Saxons in Thuringia.
c. Geoffry of Monmouth[6] relates also, how "Hengist obtained from the Britons as much land as could be enclosed by an ox-hide; then, cutting the hide into thongs, enclosed a much larger space than the granters intended, on which he erected Thong Castle--a tale too familiar to need illustration, and which runs throughout the mythus of many nations. Among the Old Saxons, the tradition is in reality the same, though recorded with a slight variety of detail.
In their story, a lapfull of earth is purchased at a dear rate from a Thuringian; the companions of the Saxon jeer him for his imprudent bargain; but he sows the purchased earth upon a large space of ground, which he claims, and, by the aid of his comrades, ultimately wrests it from the Thuringians."--Kemble, "Saxons in England."
- There is direct evidence in favour of their having been German tribes
in England anterior to A.D. 447.--a. At the close of the Marcomannic war,[7] Marcus Antoninus transplanted a number of Germans into Britain.
b. Alemannic auxiliaries served along with Roman legions under Valentinian.[8]
c. The Notitia utriusque Imperii,[9] of which the latest date is half a century earlier than the epoch of Hengist, mentions, as an officer of state, the Comes littoris Saxonici per Britannias; his government extending along the coast from Portsmouth to the Wash.
§ 5. Inference.--As it is nearly certain, that 449 A.D. is not the date of the first introduction of German tribes into Britain, we must consider that the displacement of the original British began at an earlier period than the one usually admitted, and, consequently, that it was more gradual than is usually supposed.
Perhaps, if we substitute the middle of the fourth, instead of the middle of the fifth century, as the epoch of the Germanic immigrations into Britain, we shall not be far from the truth.
- * * * *
CHAPTER II.
GERMANIC ORIGIN OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--THE GERMANIC AREA OF THE
PARTICULAR GERMANS WHO INTRODUCED IT.--EXTRACT FROM BEDA.
§ 6. Out of the numerous tribes and nations of Germany, three have been more especially mentioned as the chief, if not the exclusive, sources of the present English population of Great Britain. These are the Jutes, the Saxons, and the Angles.
§ 7. Now, it is by no means certain that this was the case. On the contrary, good reasons can be given for believing that the Angles and Saxons were the same people, and that no such nation as the Jutes ever left Germany to settle in Great Britain.
§ 8. The chief authority for the division of the German invaders into the three nations just mentioned is Beda; and the chief text is the following extract from his "Ecclesiastical History." It requires particular attention, and will form the basis of much criticism, and frequently be referred to.
"Advenerunt autem de tribus Germaniæ populis fortioribus, id est Saxonibus, Anglis, Jutis. De Jutarum origine sunt Cantuarii, et Victuarii, hoc est ea gens quæ Vectam tenet insulam et ea quæ usque hodie in provincia Occidentalium Saxonum Jutarum natio nominatur, posita contra ipsam insulam Vectam. De Saxonibus, id est, ea regione quæ nunc Antiquorum Saxonum cognominatur, venere Orientales Saxones, Meridiani Saxones, Occidui Saxones.
Porro de Anglis hoc est de illa patria quæ Angulus dicitur, et ab illo tempore usque hodie manere desertus inter provincias Jutarum et Saxonum perhibetur, Orientales Angli, Mediterranei Angli, Merci, tota Northanhymbrorum progenies, id est illarum gentium quæ ad Boream Humbri fluminis inhabitant, cæterique Anglorum populi sunt orti"--"Historia Ecclesiastica," i. 15.
§ 9. This was written about A.D. 731, 131 years after the introduction of Christianity, and nearly 300 after the supposed landing of Hengist and Horsa in A.D. 449.
It is the first passage which contains the names of either the Angles or the Jutes. Gildas, who wrote more than 150 years earlier, mentions only the Saxons--"ferocissimi illi nefandi nominis Saxones."
It is, also, the passage which all subsequent writers have either translated or adopted. Thus it re-appears in Alfred, and again in the Saxon Chronicle.[10]
"Of Jotum comon Cantware and Wihtware, þæt is seo mæiað þe nú eardaþ on
Wiht, and þæt cynn on West-Sexum ðe man gyt hæt Iútnacyun. Of
Eald-Seaxum comon Eást-Seaxan, and Suð-Seaxan and West-Seaxan. Of Angle
comon (se á siððan stód westig betwix Iútum and Seaxum) Eást-Engle,
Middel-Angle, Mearce, and ealle Norðymbra."
From the Jutes came the inhabitants of Kent and of Wight, that is, the
race that now dwells in Wight, and that tribe amongst the West-Saxons
which is yet called the Jute tribe. From the Old-Saxons came the
East-Saxons, and South-Saxons, and West-Saxons. From the Angles, land
(which has since always stood waste betwixt the Jutes and Saxons) came
the East-Angles, Middle-Angles, Mercians, and all the Northumbrians.
§ 10. A portion of these extracts will now be submitted to criticism; that portion being the statement concerning the Jutes.
The words usque hodie--Jutarum natio nominatur constitute contemporary and unexceptionable evidence to the existence of a people with a name like that of the Jutes in the time of Beda--or A.D. 731.
The exact name is not so certain. The term Jutnacyn from the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle is in favour of the notion that it began with the sounds of j and u, in other words that it was Jut.
But the term Geatum, which we find in Alfred, favours the form in g followed by ea.
Thirdly, the forms Wihtware, and Wihttan, suggest the likelihood of the name being Wiht.
Lastly, there is a passage in Asserius[11] which gives us the form Gwith--"Mater" (of Alfred the Great) "quoque ejusdem Osburgh nominabatur, religiosa nimium foemina, nobilis ingenio, nobilis et genere; quæ erat filia Oslac famosi pincernæ Æthelwulf regis; qui Oslac Gothus erat natione, ortus enim erat de Gothis et Jutis; de semine scilicet Stuf et Wihtgur, duorum fratrum et etiam comitum, qui acceptâ potestate Vectis insulæ ab avunculo suo Cerdic rege et Cynric filio suo, consobrino eorum, paucos Britones ejusdem insulæ accolas, quos in eâ invenire potuerant, in loco qui dicitur, Gwithgaraburgh occiderunt, cæteri enim accolæ ejusdem insulæ ante sunt occisi aut exules aufugerant."--Asserius, "De Gestis Alfredi Regis."
Now, Gwith-gara-burgh means the burg or town of the With-ware;[12] these being, undoubtedly, no Germans at all, but the native Britons of the Isle of Wight (Vectis), whose designation in Latin would be Vecticolæ or Vectienses.
This being the case, how can they be descended from German or Danish Jutes? and how can we reconcile the statement of Beda with that of Asser?
§ 11. The answer to this will be given after another fact has been considered.
Precisely the same confusion between the sounds of w, j, g, io, eæ, u, and i, which occurs with the so-called Jutes of the Isle of Wight, occurs with the Jutlanders of the peninsula of Jutland. The common forms are Jutland, Jute, Jutones, and Jutenses, but they are not the only ones. In A.D. 952, we find "Dania cismarina quam Vitland incolæ appellant."--"Annales Saxonici."[13]
§ 12. Putting these facts together I adopt the evidence of Asser as to the Gwithware being British, and consider them as simple Vecti-colæ, or inhabitants of the Isle of Wight. They are also the Vectuarii of Beda, the Wihtware of the Saxon Chronicle, and the Wihtsætan of Alfred.
The Jutes of Hampshire--i.e., the "Jutarum natio--posita contra ipsam insulam Vectam," and the Jutnacyn, I consider to have been the same; except that they had left the Isle of Wight to settle on the opposite coast; probably flying before their German conquerors, in which case they would be the exules of Asser.
The statement of Beda, so opposed to that of Asser, I explain by supposing that it arose out of an inaccurate inference drawn from the similarity of the names of the Isle of Wight and the peninsula of Jutland, since we have seen that in both cases, there was a similar confusion between the syllables Jut- and Vit-. This is an error into which even a careful writer might fall.
That Beda had no authentic historical accounts of the conquest of Britain, we know from his own statements in the Preface to his Ecclesiastical History,[14] and that he partially tried to make up for the want of them by inference is exceedingly likely. If so, what would be more natural than for him to conclude that Jutes as well as Angles helped to subdue the country.
The fact itself was probable; besides which he saw at one and the same time, in England Vitæ (called also Jutæ), in immediate contact with Saxons,[26] and on the continent Jutæ (called also Vitæ) in the neighborhood of Angles[27] and Saxons. Is it surprising that he should connect them?
§ 13. If the inhabitants of the Isle of Wight were really Jutes from Jutland, it is strange that there should be no traces of the difference which existed, then as now, between them and the proper Anglo-Saxons--a difference which was neither inconsiderable nor of a fleeting nature.
The present Jutlanders are not Germans but Danes, and the Jutes of the time of Beda were most probably the same. Those of the 11th century were certainly so, "Primi ad ostium Baltici Sinus in australi ripa versus nos Dani, quos Juthas appellant, usque ad Sliam lacum habitant." Adamus Bremensis,[15] "De Situ Daniæ" c. 221. Also, "Et prima pars Daniæ, quæ Jutland dicitur, ad Egdoram[28] in Boream longitudine pretenditur ... in eum angulum qui Windila dicitur, ubi Jutland finem habet," c. 208.
At the time of Beda they must, according to the received traditions, have been nearly 300 years in possession of the Isle of Wight, a locality as favourable for the preservation of their peculiar manners and customs as any in Great Britain, and a locality wherein we have no evidence of their ever having been disturbed. Nevertheless, neither trace nor shadow of a trace, either in early or modern times, has ever been discovered of their separate nationality and language; a fact which stands in remarkable contrast with the very numerous traces which the Danes of the 9th and 10th century left behind them as evidence of their occupancy.
§ 14. The words England and English are derived from the Angles of Beda. The words Sussex, Essex, Middlesex and Wessex, from his Saxons. No objection lies against this; indeed to deny that populations called Angle and Saxon occupied England and spoke the Anglo-Saxon language would display an unnecessary and unhealthy scepticism. The real question concerning these two words consists in the relation which the populations to which they were applied bore to each other. And this question is a difficult one.
Did the Angles speak one language, whilst the Saxons spoke another? or did they both speak dialects of the same tongue?
Were these dialects slightly or widely different? Can we find traces of the difference in any of the present provincial dialects? Are the idioms of one country of Angle, whilst those of another are of Saxon origin? Was the Angle more like the Danish language, whilst the Saxon approached the Dutch?
None of these questions can be answered at present. They have, however, been asked for the sake of exhibiting the nature of the subject.
§ 15. The extract from Beda requires further remarks.
The Angles of Beda.--The statement of Beda respecting the Angles, like his statement concerning the Jutes, reappears in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, and in Alfred.
Ethelweard[16] also adopts it:--"Anglia vetus sita est inter Saxones et Giotos, habens oppidum capitale quod sermone Saxonico Sleswic nuncupatur, secundum vero Danos Hathaby."
Nevertheless, it is exceptionable and unsatisfactory; and like the previous one, in all probability, an incorrect inference founded upon the misinterpretation of a name.
In the eighth century there was, and at the present moment there is, a portion of the duchy of Sleswick called Anglen or the corner. It is really what its name denotes, a triangle of irregular shape, formed by the Slie, the firth of Flensborg, and a line drawn from Flensborg to Sleswick.
It is just as Danish as the rest of the peninsula, and cannot be shown to have been occupied by a Germanic population at all. Its area is less than that of the county of Rutland, and by no means likely to have supplied such a population as that of the Angles of England. The fact of its being a desert at the time of Beda is credible; since it formed a sort of March or Debatable Ground between the Saxons and Slavonians of Holstein, and the Danes of Jutland.
Now if we suppose that the real Angles of Germany were either so reduced in numbers as to have become an obscure tribe, or so incorporated with other populations as to have lost their independent existence, we can easily see how the similarity of name, combined with the geographical contiguity of Anglen to the Saxon frontier, might mislead even so good a writer as Beda, into the notion that he had found the country of the Angles in the Angulus (Anglen) of Sleswick.
The true Angles were the descendants of the Angli of Tacitus. Who these were will be investigated in §§ 47-54.
§ 16. The Saxons of Beda.--The Saxons of Beda reached from the country of the Old Saxons[29] on the Lippe, in Westphalia, to that of the Nordalbingian[30] Saxons between the Elbe and Eyder; and nearly, but not quite, coincided with the present countries of Hanover, Oldenburg, Westphalia, and part of Holstein. This we may call the Saxon, or (as reasons will be given for considering that it nearly coincided with the country of the Angles) the Anglo-Saxon area.
§ 17. River-system and sea-board of the Anglo-Saxon area.--As the invasion of England took place by sea, we must expect to find in the invaders a maritime population. This leads to the consideration of the physical character of that part of Germany which they occupied. And here comes a remarkable and unexpected fact. The line of coast between the Rhine and Elbe, the line which in reasoning a priori, we should fix upon as the most likely tract for the bold seamen who wrested so large an island as Great Britain from its original occupants (changing it from Britain to England), to have proceeded from, is not the country of the Anglo-Saxons.
On the contrary, it is the country of a similar but different section of the Germanic population, a section which has not received the attention from the English historian which it deserves. The country in question is the area of--
§ 18. The Frisians.--At the present moment the language of the Dutch province of Friesland is materially different from that of the other parts of the kingdom of Holland. In other words it is not Dutch. Neither is it German--although, of course, it resembles both languages. On the other hand, it is more like the English than any other language or dialect in Germany is.
It is a language of considerable antiquity, and although at present it is spoken by the country-people only, it possesses a considerable literature.
There is the Middle Frisian of Gysbert Japicx,[17] and the Old Frisian of the Frisian Laws.[18] The older the specimen of the Frisian language the more closely does it show its affinity to the English; hence the earliest Frisian and the Anglo-Saxon are exceedingly alike. Nevertheless they differ.
§ 19. The Frisian was once spoken over a far greater area than at present.
It was the original language of almost all Holland. It was the language of East Friesland to a late period. It was, probably, the language of the ancient Chauci. At the present time (besides Friesland) it survives in Heligoland, in the islands between the Ems and Weser, in part of Sleswick, and in a few localities in Oldenburg and Westphalia.
Hence it is probable that the original Frisian, extending to an uncertain and irregular distance inland, lay between the Saxons and the sea, and stretched from the Zuyder Zee to the Elbe; a fact which would leave to the latter nation the lower Elbe and the Weser as their water-system: the extent to which they were in direct contact with the ocean being less than we are prepared to expect from their subsequent history.
On the other hand the a priori probabilities of there being Frisians as well as Anglo-Saxons amongst the conquerors of Great Britain are considerable.--See §§ 55, 56.
§ 20. The Anglo-Saxon area coincided--
- Politically.--With the kingdom of Hanover, the duchy of Oldenburg, and
parts of Westphalia and Holstein.
- Physically.--With the basin of the Weser.
It was certainly from the Anglo-Saxon, and probably from a part of the Frisian area that Great Britain was first invaded.
This is as much as it is safe to say at present. The preceding chapter investigated the date of the Germanic migration into Britain; the present has determined the area from which it went forth.
- * * * *
CHAPTER III.
OF THE DIALECTS OF THE SAXON AREA, AND OF THE SO-CALLED OLD SAXON.
§ 21. The area occupied by the Saxons of Germany has been investigated; and it now remains to ask, how far the language of the occupants was absolutely identical throughout, or how far it fell into dialects or sub-dialects.
There were at least two divisions of the Saxon; (1st) the Saxon of which the extant specimens are of English origin, and (2nd), the Saxon of which the extant specimens are of Continental origin. We will call these at present the Saxon of England, and the Saxon of the Continent.
§ 22. Respecting the Saxon of England and the Saxon of the Continent, there is good reason for believing that the first was spoken in the northern, the second in the southern portion of the Saxon area, i.e., the one in Hanover and the other in Westphalia, the probable boundaries between them being the line of highlands between Osnaburg and Paderborn.
§ 23. Respecting the Saxon of England and the Saxon of the Continent, there is good reason for believing that, whilst the former was the mother-tongue of the Angles and the conquerors of England, the latter was that of the Cherusci of Arminius, the conquerors and the annihilators of the legions of Varus.[19]
§ 24. Respecting the Saxon of England and the Saxon of the Continent, it is a fact that, whilst we have a full literature in the former, we have but fragmentary specimens of the latter--these being chiefly the following: (1) the Heliand,[20] (2) Hildubrand and Hathubrant,[21] (3) the Carolinian Psalms.[22]
§ 25. The preceding points have been predicated respecting the difference between the two ascertained Saxon dialects, for the sake of preparing the reader for the names by which they are known.
THE SAXON OF THE CONTINENT THE SAXON OF ENGLAND
MAY BE CALLED MAY BE CALLED
- Continental Saxon. Insular Saxon.
- German Saxon. English Saxon.
- Westphalian Saxon. Hanoverian Saxon.
- South Saxon. North Saxon.
- Cheruscan Saxon. Angle Saxon.
- Saxon of the Heliand. Saxon of Beowulf.[23]
§ 26. The Saxon of England is called Anglo-Saxon; a term against which no exception can be raised.
§ 27. The Saxon of the Continent used to be called Dano-Saxon, and is called Old Saxon.
§ 28. Why called Dano-Saxon.--When the poem called Heliand was first discovered in an English library, the difference in language between it and the common Anglo-Saxon composition was accounted for by the assumption of a Danish intermixture.
§ 29. _Why called Old Saxon._ When the Continental origin of the Heliand was recognised, the language was called Old Saxon, because it represented the Saxon of the mother-country, the natives of which were called Old Saxons by the Anglo-Saxons themselves. Still the term is exceptionable; as the Saxon of the Heliand is probably a sister-dialect of the Anglo-Saxon, rather than the Anglo-Saxon itself in a Continental locality. Exceptionable, however, as it is, it will be employed.
- * * * *
CHAPTER IV.
AFFINITIES OF THE ENGLISH WITH THE LANGUAGES OF GERMANY AND SCANDINAVIA.
§ 30. Over and above those languages of Germany and Holland which were akin to the dialects of the Anglo-Saxons, cognate languages were spoken in Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Iceland, and the Feroe isles, i.e., in Scandinavia.
§ 31. The general collective designation for the Germanic tongues of Germany and Holland, and for the Scandinavian languages of Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Iceland, and the Feroe Isles, is taken from the name of those German tribes who, during the decline of the Roman Empire, were best known to the Romans as the Goths; the term Gothic for the Scandinavian and Germanic languages, collectively, being both current and convenient.
§ 32. Of this great stock of languages the Scandinavian is one branch; the Germanic, called also Teutonic, another.
§ 33. The Scandinavian branch of the Gothic stock comprehends, 1. The dialects of Scandinavia Proper, i.e., of Norway and Sweden; 2. of the Danish isles and Jutland; 3. of Iceland; 4. of the Feroe Isles.
§ 34. The Teutonic branch falls into three divisions:--
- The Moeso-Gothic.
- The High Germanic.
- The Low Germanic.
§ 35. It is in the Moeso-Gothic that the most ancient specimen of any Gothic tongue has been preserved. It is also the Moeso-Gothic that was spoken by the conquerors of ancient Rome; by the subjects of Hermanric, Alaric, Theodoric, Euric, Athanaric, and Totila.
In the reign of Valens, when pressed by intestine wars, and by the movements of the Huns, the Goths were assisted by that emperor, and settled in the Roman province of Moesia.
Furthermore, they were converted to Christianity; and the Bible was translated into their language by their Bishop Ulphilas.
Fragments of this translation, chiefly from the Gospels, have come down to the present time; and the Bible translation of the Arian Bishop Ulphilas, in the language of the Goths of Moesia, during the reign of Valens, exhibits the earliest sample of any Gothic tongue.
§ 36. The Old High German, called also Francic[24] and Alemannic,[25] was spoken in the ninth, tenth, and eleventh centuries, in Suabia, Bavaria, and Franconia.
The Middle High German ranges from the thirteenth century to the Reformation.
§ 37. The low Germanic division, to which the Anglo-Saxon belongs, is currently said to comprise six languages, or rather four languages in different stages.
I. II.--The Anglo-Saxon and Modern English.
III. The Old Saxon.
IV. V.--The Old Frisian and Modern Dutch.
VI.--The Platt-Deutsch, or Low German.
§ 38. The Frisian and Dutch.--It is a current statement that the Old Frisian bears the same relation to the Modern Dutch of Holland that the Anglo-Saxon does to the English.
The truer view of the question is as follows:--
- That a single language, spoken in two dialects, was originally common to
both Holland and Friesland.
- That from the northern of these dialects we have the Modern Frisian of
Friesland.
- From the southern, the Modern Dutch of Holland.
The reason of this refinement is as follows:--
The Modern Dutch has certain grammatical forms older than those of the old Frisian; e.g., the Dutch infinitives and the Dutch weak substantives, in their oblique cases, end in -en; those of the Old Frisian in -a: the form in -en being the older.
The true Frisian is spoken in few and isolated localities. There is--
- The Frisian of the Dutch state called Friesland.
- The Frisian of the parish of Saterland, in Westphalia.
- The Frisian of Heligoland.
- The North Frisian, spoken in a few villages of Sleswick. One of the
characters of the North Frisian is the possession of a dual number.
In respect to its stages, we have the Old Frisian of the Asega-bog, the Middle Frisian of Gysbert Japicx,[31] and the Modern Frisian of the present Frieslanders, Westphalians, and Heligolanders.
§ 39. The Low German and Platt-Deutsch.--The words Low-German are not only lax in their application, but they are equivocal; since the term has two meanings, a general meaning when it signifies a division of the Germanic languages, comprising English, Dutch, Anglo-Saxon, Old Saxon, and Frisian, and a limited one when it means the particular dialects of the Ems, the Weser, and the Elbe. To avoid this the dialects in question are conveniently called by their continental name of Platt-Deutsch, just as in England we say Broad Scotch.
§ 40. The most characteristic difference between the Saxon and Icelandic (indeed between the Teutonic and Scandinavian tongues) lies in the peculiar position of the definite article in the latter. In Saxon, the article corresponding with the modern word the, is þæt, se, seó, for the neuter, masculine, and feminine genders respectively; and these words, regularly declined, are prefixed to the words with which they agree, just as is the case with the English and with the majority of languages.
In Icelandic, however, the article instead of preceding, follows its noun, with which it coalesces, having previously suffered a change in form. The Icelandic article corresponding to þæt, se, seó, is hitt, hinn, hin: from this the h is ejected, so that, instead of the regular inflection (a), we have the forms (b).
a.
Neut. Masc. Fem.
Sing. Nom. Hitt Hinn Hin.
Acc. Hitt Hinn Hina.
Dat. Hinu Hinum Hinni.
Gen. Hins Hins Hinnar.
Plur. Nom. Hin Hinir Hinar.
Acc. Hin Hina Hinar.
Dat. Hinum Hinum Hinum.
Gen. Hinna Hinna Hinna.
b.
Sing. Nom. -it -inn -in.
Acc. -it -inn -ina (-na).
Dat. -nu -num -inni (-nni).
Gen. -ins -ins -innar (-nnar).
Plur. Nom. -in -nir -nar.
Acc. -in -na -nar.
Dat. -num -num -num.
Gen. -nna -nna -nna.
Whence, as an affix, in composition,
Neut. Masc. Fem.
Sing. Nom. Augat Boginn Túngan.
Acc. Augat Boginn Túnguna.
Dat. Auganu Boganum Túngunni.
Gen. Augans Bogans Túngunnar.
Plur. Nom. Augun Bogarnir Túngurnar.
Acc. Augun Bogana Túngurnar.
Dat. Augunum Bogunum Túngunum.
Gen. Augnanna Boganna Túngnanna.
In the Swedish, Norwegian, and Danish this peculiarity in the position of the definite article is preserved. Its origin, however, is concealed; and an accidental identity with the indefinite article has led to false notions respecting its nature. In the languages in point the i is changed into e, so that what in Icelandic is it and in, is in Danish et and en. En, however, as a separate word, is the numeral one, and also the indefinite article a; whilst in the neuter gender it is et--en sol, a sun; et bord, a table: solon, the sun; bordet, the table.
From modern forms like those just quoted, it has been imagined that the definite is merely the indefinite article transposed. This it is not.
To apply an expression of Mr. Cobbet's, en = a, and -en = the, are the same combination of letters, but not the same word.
§ 41. Another characteristic of the Scandinavian language is the possession of a passive form, or a passive voice, ending in -st:--ek, þu, hann brennist = I am, thou art, he is burnt; ver brennumst = we are burnt; þér brennizt = ye are burnt; þeir brennast = they are burnt. Past tense, ek, þu, hann brendist; ver brendumst, þér brenduzt, þeir brendust. Imperat.: brenstu = be thou burnt.
Infinit.: brennast = to be burnt.
In the modern Danish and Swedish, the passive is still preserved, but without the final t. In the older stages of Icelandic, on the other hand, the termination was not -st but -sc; which -sc grew out of the reflective pronoun sik.
With these phenomena the Scandinavian languages give us the evolution and development of a passive voice; wherein we have the following series of changes:--1. the reflective pronoun coalesces with the verb, whilst the sense changes from that of a reflective to that of a middle verb; 2. the c changes to t, whilst the middle sense passes into a passive one; 3. t is dropped from the end of the word, and the expression that was once reflective then becomes strictly passive.
Now the Saxons have no passive voice at all. That they should have one originating like that of the Scandinavians was impossible, inasmuch as they had no reflective pronoun, and, consequently, nothing to evolve it from.
- * * * *
CHAPTER V.
ANALYSIS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--GERMANIC ELEMENTS.--THE ANGLES.
§ 42. The language of England has been formed out of three elements.
a. Elements referable to the original British population, and derived from times anterior to the Anglo-Saxon invasion.
b. Anglo-Saxon, Germanic, or imported elements.
c. Elements introduced since the Anglo-Saxon conquest.
§ 43. Each of these requires a special analysis, but that of the second will be taken first, and form the contents of the present chapter.
All that we have at present learned concerning the Germanic invaders of England, is the geographical area which they originally occupied. How far, however, it was simple Saxons who conquered England single-handed, or how far the particular Saxon Germans were portions of a complex population, requires further investigation. Were the Saxons one division of the German population, whilst the Angles were another? or were the Angles a section of the Saxons, so that the latter was a generic term including the former?
Again, although the Saxon invasion may be the one which has had the greatest influence, and drawn the most attention, why may there not have been separate and independent migrations, the effects and record of which have, in the lapse of time, become fused with those of the more important divisions?
§ 44. The Angles; who were they? and what was their relation to the Saxons?--The first answer to this question embodies a great fact in the way of internal evidence, viz., that they were the people from whom England derives the name it bears = Angle land, i.e., land of the Angles. Our language too is English, i.e., Angle. Whatever, then, they may have been on the Continent, they were a leading section of the invaders here. Why then has their position in our inquiries been hitherto so subordinate to that of the Saxons?
It is because their importance and preponderance are not so manifest in Germany as we infer them to have been in Britain. Nay more, their historical place amongst the nations of Germany, is both insignificant and uncertain; indeed, it will be seen from the sequel, that in and of themselves we know next to nothing about them, knowing them only in their relations, i.e., to ourselves and to the Saxons.
§ 45. Although they are the section of the immigration which gave the name to England, and, as such, the preponderating element in the eyes of the present English, they were not so in the eyes of the original British; who neither knew at the time of the Conquest, nor know now, of any other name for their German enemies but Saxon. And Saxon is the name by which the present English are known to the Welsh, Armorican, and Gaelic Celts.
Welsh Saxon.
Armorican Soson.
Gaelic Sassenach.
§ 46. Although they are the section of the immigration which gave the name to England, &c., they were quite as little Angles as Saxons in the eyes of foreign cotemporary writers; since the expression Saxoniæ transmarinæ, occurs as applied to England.
§ 47. Who were the Angles?--Although they are the section of the immigration which gave the name to England, &c., the notices of them as Germans in Germany, are extremely limited.
Extract from Tacitus.--This merely connects them with certain other tribes, and affirms the existence of certain religious ordinances common to them:--
"Contra Langobardos paucitas nobilitat: plurimis ac valentissimis nationibus cincti, non per obsequium sed proeliis et periclitando tuti sunt. Reudigni deinde, et Aviones, et Angli, et Varini, et Eudoses, et Suardones, et Nuithones, fluminibus aut silvis muniuntur: nec quidquam notabile in singulis, nisi quod in commune Herthum, id est, Terram matrem colunt, eamque intervenire rebus hominum, invehi populis, arbitrantur. Est in insula Oceani Castum nemus, dicatumque in eo vehiculum, veste contectum, attingere uni sacerdoti concessum.
Is adesse penetrali deam intelligit, vectamque bobus feminis multâ cum veneratione prosequitur. Læti tunc dies, festa loca, quæcumque adventu hospitioque dignatur. Non bella ineunt, non arma sumunt, clausum omne ferrum; pax et quies tunc tantùm nota, tunc tantùm amata, donec idem sacerdos satiatam conversatione mortalium deam templo reddat; mox vehiculum et vestes, et, si credere velis, numen ipsum secreto lacu abluitur. Servi ministrant, quos statim idem lacus haurit.
Arcanus hinc terror, sanctaque ignorantia, quid sit id, quod tantùm perituri vident."[32]
Extract from Ptolemy.--This connects the Angles with the Suevi, and Langobardi, and places them on the Middle Elbe.--[Greek: Entos kai mesogeiôn ethnôn megista men esti to te tôn Souêbôn tôn Angeilôn, hoi eisin anatolikôteroi tôn Langobardôn, anateinontes pros tas arktous mechri tôn mesôn tou Albios potamou].
Extract from Procopius.--For this see § 55.
Heading of a law referred to the age of Charlemagne.--This connects them with the Werini (Varni) and the Thuringians--"Incipit lex Angliorum et Werinorum hoc est Thuringorum."
§ 48. These notices agree in giving the Angles a German locality, and in connecting them ethnologically, and philologically with the Germans of Germany. And such was, undoubtedly, the case. Nevertheless, it may be seen from § 15 that a Danish origin has been assigned to them.
The exact Germanic affinities of the Angles are, how ever, difficult to ascertain, since the tribes with which they are classed are differently classed. This we shall see by asking the following questions:--
§ 49. What were the Langobardi, with whom the Angles were connected by Tacitus? The most important fact to be known concerning them is, that the general opinion is in favour of their having belonged to either the High-German, or Moeso-Gothic division, rather than to the Low.
§ 50. What were the Suevi, with whom the Angles were connected by Tacitus? The most important fact to be known concerning them is, that the general opinion is in favour of their having belonged to either the High-German or Moeso-Gothic division rather than to the Low.
§ 51. What were the Werini, with whom the Angles were connected in the Leges Anglorum et Werinorum? Without having any particular data for connecting the Werini (Varni, [Greek: Ouarnoi]) with either the High-German, or the Moeso-Gothic divisions, there are certain facts in favour of their being Slavonic.
§ 52. What were the Thuringians, with whom the Angles are connected in the Leges Anglorum? Germanic in locality, and most probably allied to the Goths of Moesia in language. If not, High-Germans.
§ 53. Of the Reudigni, Eudoses, Nuithones, Suardones, and Aviones, too little is known in detail to make the details an inquiry of importance.
§ 54. The reader has now got a general view of the extent to which the position of the Angles, as a German tribe, is complicated by conflicting statements; statements which connect them with (probably) High-German Thuringians, Suevi, and Langobardi, and with (probably) Slavonic Werini, or Varni; whereas in England, they are scarcely distinguishable from the Low-German Saxons. In the present state of our knowledge, the only safe fact seems to be, that of the common relation of both Angles and Saxons to the present English of England.
This brings the two sections within a very close degree of affinity, and makes it probable, that, just as at present, descendants of the Saxons are English (Angle) in Britain, so, in the third and fourth centuries, ancestors of the Angles were Saxons in Germany. Why, however, the one name preponderated on the Continent, and the other in England is difficult to ascertain.
§ 55. The Frisians have been mentioned as a Germanic population likely to have joined in the invasion of Britain; the presumption in favor of their having done so arising from their geographical position.
There is, however, something more than mere presumption upon this point.
Archbishop Usher, amongst the earlier historians, and Mr. Kemble amongst those of the present day, as well as other intermediate investigators, have drawn attention to certain important notices of them.
The main facts bearing upon this question are the following:--
- Hengist, according to some traditions, was a Frisian hero.
- Procopius wrote as follows:--[Greek: Brittian de tên nêson ethnê tria
poluanthrôpotata echousi, basileus te eis autôn hekastôi ephestêken, onomata de keitai tois ethnesi toutois Angiloi te kai Phrissones kai hoi têi nêsôi homônumoi Brittônes. Tosautê de hê tônde tôn ethnôn poluanthrôpia phainetai ousa hôste ana pan etos kata pollous enthende metanistamenoi xun gunaixi kai paisin es Phrangous chôrousin].--Procop. B. G. iv. 20.
- In the Saxon Chronicle we find the following passage:--"That same year,
the armies from among the East-Anglians, and from among the North-Humbrians, harassed the land of the West-Saxons chiefly, most of all by their 'æscs,' which they had built many years before. Then king Alfred commanded long ships to be built to oppose the æscs; they were full-nigh twice as long as the others; some had sixty oars, and some had more; they were both swifter and steadier, and also higher than the others. They were shapen neither like the Frisian nor the Danish, but so as it seemed to him that they would be most efficient.
Then some time in the same year, there came six ships to Wight, and there did much harm, as well as in Devon, and elsewhere along the sea coast. Then the king commanded nine of the new ships to go thither, and they obstructed their passage from the port towards the outer sea. Then went they with three of their ships out against them; and three lay in the upper part of the port in the dry; the men were gone from them ashore.
Then took they two of the three ships at the outer part of the port, and killed the men, and the other ship escaped; in that also the men were killed except five; they got away because the other ships were aground. They also were aground very disadvantageously, three lay aground on that side of the deep on which the Danish ships were aground, and all the rest upon the other side, so that no one of them could get to the others.
But when, the water had ebbed many furlongs from the ships, then the Danish men went from their three ships to the other three which were left by the tide on their side, and then they there fought against them. There was slain Lucumon the king's reeve, and Wulfheard the Frisian, and Æbbe the Frisian, and Æthelhere the Frisian, and Æthelferth the king's 'geneat,' and of all the men, Frisians and English, seventy-two; and of the Danish men one hundred and twenty."
§ 56. I believe then, that, so far from the current accounts being absolutely correct, in respect to the Germanic elements of the English population, the Jutes, as mentioned by Beda, formed no part of it, whilst the Frisians, not so mentioned, were a real constituent therein; besides which, there may, very easily, have been other Germanic tribes, though in smaller proportions.
- * * * *
CHAPTER VI.
THE CELTIC STOCK OF LANGUAGES, AND THEIR RELATIONS TO THE ENGLISH.
§ 57. The languages of Great Britain at the invasion of Julius Cæsar were of the Celtic stock.
Of the Celtic stock there are two branches.
- The British or Cambrian branch, represented by the present Welsh, and
containing, besides, the Cornish of Cornwall (lately extinct), and the Armorican of the French province of Brittany. It is almost certain that the old British, the ancient language of Gaul, and the Pictish were of this branch.
- The Gaelic or Erse branch, represented by the present Irish Gaelic, and
containing, besides, the Gaelic of the Highlands of Scotland and the Manks of the Isle of Man.
§ 58. Taken altogether the Celtic tongues form a very remarkable class. As compared with those of the Gothic stock they are marked by the following characteristics:--
The scantiness of the declension of Celtic nouns.--In Irish there is a peculiar form for the dative plural, as cos = foot, cos-aibh = to feet (ped-ibus); and beyond this there is nothing else whatever in the way of case, as found in the German, Latin, Greek, and other tongues. Even the isolated form in question is not found in the Welsh and Breton. Hence the Celtic tongues are pre-eminently uninflected in the way of declension.
§ 59. The agglutinate character of their verbal inflections.--In Welsh the pronouns for we, ye, and they, are ni, chwyi, and hwynt respectively. In Welsh also the root = love is car. As conjugated in the plural number this is--
car-wn = am-amus.
car-ych = am-atis.
car-ant = am-ant.
Now the -wn, -ych, and -ant, of the persons of the verbs are the personal pronouns, so that the inflection is really a verb and a pronoun in a state of agglutination; i.e., in a state where the original separate existence of the two sorts of words is still manifest. This is probably the case with languages in general. The Celtic, however, has the peculiarity of exhibiting it in an unmistakable manner; showing, as it were, an inflection in the process of formation, and (as such) exhibiting an early stage of language.
§ 60. The system of initial mutations.--The Celtic, as has been seen, is deficient in the ordinary means of expressing case. How does it make up for this? Even thus. The noun changes its initial letter according to its relation to the other words of the sentence. Of course this is subject to rule. As, however, I am only writing for the sake of illustrating in a general way the peculiarities of the Celtic tongues, the following table, from Prichard's "Eastern Origin of the Celtic Nations," is sufficient.
Câr, a kinsman.
- form, Câr agos, a near kinsman.
- Ei gâr, his kinsman.
- Ei châr, her kinsman.
- Vy nghâr, my kinsman.
Tâd, a father.
- form, Tâd y plentyn, the child's father.
- Ei dâd, his father.
- Ei thâd, her father.
- Vy nhâd, my father.
Pen, a head.
- form, Pen gwr, the head of a man.
- Ei ben, his head.
- Ei phen, her head.
- Vy mhen, my head.
Gwas, a servant.
- form, Gwâs fydhlon, a faithful servant.
- Ei wâs, his servant.
- Vy ngwas, my servant.
Duw, a god.
- form, Duw trugarog, a merciful god.
- Ei dhuw, his god.
- Vy nuw, my god.
Bara, bread.
- form, Bara cann, white bread.
- Ei vara, his bread.
- Vy mara, my bread.
Lhaw, a hand.
- form, Lhaw wenn, a white hand.
- Ei law, his hand.
Mam, a mother.
- form, Mam dirion, a tender mother.
- Ei vam, his mother.
Rhwyd, a net.
- form, Rhwyd lawn, a full net.
- Ei rwyd, his net.
From the Erse.
Súil, an eye.
- form, Súil.
- A húil, his eye.
Sláinte, health.
- form, Do hláinte, your health.
§ 61. The Celtic tongues have lately received especial illustration from the researches of Mr. Garnett. Amongst others, the two following points are particularly investigated by him:--
- The affinities of the ancient language of Gaul.
- The affinities of the Pictish language or dialect.
§ 62. The ancient language of Gaul Cambrian.--The evidence in favour of the ancient language of Gaul being Cambrian rather than Gaelic, lies in the following facts:--
The old Gallic glosses are more Welsh than Gaelic.
a. Petorritum = a four-wheeled carriage, from the Welsh, peder = four, and rhod = a wheel. The Gaelic for four is ceathair, and the Gaelic compound would have been different.
b. Pempedula, the cinque-foil, from the Welsh pump = five, and dalen = a leaf. The Gaelic for five is cuig, and the Gaelic compound would have been different.
c. Candetum = a measure of 100 feet, from the Welsh cant = 100. The Gaelic for a hundred is cead, and the Gaelic compound would have been different.
d. Epona = the goddess of horses. In the old Armorican the root ep = horse. The Gaelic for a horse is each.
e. The evidence from the names of geographical localities in Gaul, both ancient and modern, goes the same way: Nantuates, Nantouin, Nanteuil, are derived from the Welsh nant = a valley, a word unknown in Gaelic.
f. The evidence of certain French provincial words, which are Welsh and Armorican rather than Erse or Gaelic.
§ 63. The Pictish most probably Cambrian.--The evidence in favour of the Pictish being Cambrian rather than Gaelic lies in the following facts:
a. When St. Columbanus preached, whose mother-tongue was Irish Gaelic, he used an interpreter. This shows the difference between the Pict and Gaelic. What follows shows the affinity between the Pict and Welsh.
b. A manuscript in the Colbertine library contains a list of Pictish kings from the fifth century downwards. These names are more Welsh than Gaelic. Taran = thunder in Welsh. Uven is the Welsh Owen. The first syllable in Talorg ( = forehead) is the tal in Talhaiarn = iron forehead, Taliessin = splendid forehead, Welsh names. Wrgust is nearer to the Welsh Gwrgust than to the Irish Fergus.
Finally, Drust, Drostan, Wrad, Necton, closely resemble the Welsh Trwst, Trwstan, Gwriad, Nwython. Cineod and Domhnall (Kenneth and Donnell) are the only true Erse forms in the list.
c. The only Pictish common name extant is the well-known compound pen val, which is, in the oldest MS. of Beda, peann fahel. This means caput valli, and is the name for the eastern termination of the Vallum of Antoninus. Herein pen is unequivocally Welsh, meaning head. It is an impossible form in Gaelic. Fal, on the other hand, is apparently Gaelic, the Welsh for a rampart being gwall. Fal, however, occurs in Welsh also, and means inclosure.
The evidence just indicated is rendered nearly conclusive by an interpolation, apparently of the twelfth century, of the Durham MS. of Nennius, whereby it is stated that the spot in question was called in Gaelic Cenail. Now Cenail is the modern name Kinneil, and it is also a Gaelic translation of the Pict pen val, since cean is the Gaelic for head, and fhail for rampart or wall. If the older form were Gaelic, the substitution, or translation, would have been superfluous.
d. The name of the Ochil Hills in Perthshire is better explained from the Pict uchel = high, than from the Gaelic uasal.
e. Bryneich, the British form of the province Bernicia, is better explained by the Welsh bryn = ridge (hilly country), than by any word in Gaelic.--Garnett, in "Transactions of Philological Society."
- * * * *
CHAPTER VII.
THE ANGLO-NORMAN, AND THE LANGUAGES OF THE CLASSICAL STOCK.
§ 64. The languages of Greece and Rome belong to one and the same stock.
The Greek and its dialects, both ancient and modern, constitute the Greek of the Classical stock.
The Latin in all its dialects, the old Italian languages allied to it, and the modern tongues derived from the Roman, constitute the Latin branch of the Classical stock.
Now, although the Greek dialects are of only secondary importance in the illustration of the history of the English language, the Latin elements require a special consideration.
This is because the Norman French, introduced into England by the battle of Hastings, is a language derived from the Roman, and consequently a language of the Latin branch of the Classical stock.
§ 65. The Latin language overspread the greater part of the Roman empire.
It supplanted a multiplicity of aboriginal languages; just as the English of North America has supplanted the aboriginal tongues of the native Indians, and just as the Russian is supplanting those of Siberia and Kamskatka.
Sometimes the war that the Romans carried on against the old inhabitants was a war of extermination. In this case the original language was superseded at once. In other cases their influence was introduced gradually. In this case the influence of the original language was greater and more permanent.
Just as in the United States the English came in contact with an American, whilst in New Holland it comes in contact with an Australian language, so was the Latin language of Rome engrafted, sometimes on a Celtic, sometimes on a Gothic, and sometimes on some other stock. The nature of the original language must always be borne in mind.
From Italy, its original seat, the Latin was extended in the following chronological order:--
- To the Spanish Peninsula; where it overlaid or was engrafted on
languages allied to the present Biscayan.
- To Gaul, or France, where it overlaid or was engrafted on languages of
the Celtic stock.
- To Dacia and Pannonia where it overlaid or was engrafted on a language
the stock whereof is undetermined, but which was, probably, Sarmatian. The introduction of the Latin into Dacia and Pannonia took place in the time of Trajan.
§ 66. From these different introductions of the Latin into different countries we have the following modern languages--1st Italian, 2nd Spanish and Portuguese, 3rd French, 4th Wallachian; to which must be added a 5th, the Romanese of part of Switzerland.
Specimen of the Romanese.
Luke xv. 11.
- Ün Hum veva dus Filgs:
- Ad ilg juveu da quels schet alg Bab, "Bab mi dai la Part de la
Rauba c' aud' à mi:" ad el parchè or ad els la Rauba.
- A bucca bears Gis suenter, cur ilg Filg juven vet tut mess ansemel,
scha tilà 'l navent en ünna Terra dalunsch: a lou sfiget el tut sia
Rauba cun viver senza spargn.
- A cur el vet tut sfaig, scha vangit ei en quella Terra ün grond
Fumaz: ad el antschavet a ver basengs.
- Ad el mà, à: sa plidè enn ün Burgeis da quella Terra; a quel ilg
tarmatet or sin sês Beins a parchirar ils Porcs.
- Ad el grigiava dad amplanir sieu Venter cun las Criscas ch' ils
Porcs malgiavan; mo nagin lgi deva.
- Mo el mà en sasez a schet: "Quonts Fumelgs da mieu Bab han budonza
da Pann, a jou miei d' fom!"
- "Jou vi lavar si, ad ir tier mieu Bab, e vi gir a lgi: 'Bab, jou
hai faig puccau ancunter ilg Tschiel ad avont tei;
- "'A sunt bucca pli vangonts da vangir numnaus tieu Filg; fai mei
esser sco ün da tes Fumelgs.'"
Specimen of the Wallachian.
Luke xv. 11.
- Un om evea do[)i] fec or[)i].
- Shi a zis c'el ma[)i] tinr din e[)i] tatlu[)i] su: tat, dm[)i]
partea c'e mi se kade de avucie: shi de a imprcit lor avuciea.
- Shi nu dup multe zile, adunint toate fec orul c el ma[)i] tinr, s'a
dus intr 'o car departe, shi akolo a rsipit toat avuciea ca, viecuind
intr dezm[)i]erdr[)i].
- Shi keltuind el toate, c'a fkut foamete mare intr' ac'ea car: shi
el a inc'eput a se lipsi.
- Shi mergina c'a lipit de unul din lkuitori[)i] cri[)i] ac'eia: si
'l a trimis pre el la earinide sale c pask porc'i[)i].
- Shi doria c 'sh[)i] sature pinctec'ele s[)u] de roshkobele c'e
minka porc'i[)i]! shi nimin[)i] nu [)i] da lu[)i].
- Iar viind intru sine, a zis; kic[)i] argac[)i] a[)i] tatlu[)i]
mie[)u] sint indestulac[)i] de pi[)i]ne, iar e[)u] p[)i]ei[)u] de
foame.
- Skula-m-vio[)u], shi m' voi[)u] duc'e la tata mie[)u], shi vio[)u]
zic'e lui:
- Tat, greshit-am la c'er shi inaintea ta, shi nu mai sint vrednik a
m kema fiul t[)u]; fm ka pre unul din argaci[)i] ti.
§ 67. Such is the general view of the languages derived from the Latin, i.e., of the languages of the Latin branch of the Classical stock.
The French requires to be more minutely exhibited.
Between the provincial French of the north and the provincial French of the south, there is a difference, at the present day, at least of dialect, and perhaps of language. This is shown by the following specimens: the first from the canton of Arras, on the confines of Flanders; the second from the department of Var, in Provence. The date of each is A.D. 1807.
I.
Luke xv. 11.
- Ain homme avoüait deeux garchéons.
- L'pus jone dit a sain père, "Main père, baillé m'cheu quî doüo me
'r v'nir ed vous bien," et lue père leu partit sain bien.
- Ain n'sais yur, tro, quate, chéon jours après l'pus tiò d'cnés
déeux éféans ôyant r'cuéllé tout s'n' héritt'main, s'ot' ainvoye dains
nâin pahis gramain loüon, dú qu'il échilla tout s'n' argint ain fageant
l'braingand dains chés cabarets.
- Abord qu'il o eu tout bu, tout mié et tout drélé, il o v'nu adonc
dains ch' pahis lo ainn' famaine cruüelle, et i c'mainchonait d'avoir
fon-ye d' pon-ye (i.e. faim de pain).
II.
THE SAME.
- Un homé avié dous enfans.
- Lou plus pichoun diguét a son päiré, "Moun päiré, dounas mi ce què
mi reven de vouastré ben;" lou pairé faguet lou partagé de tout ce que
poussédavo.
- Paou do jours après, lou pichoun vendét tout se què soun päiré li
avié desamparat, et s'en anét díns un päis fourco luench, ounté
dissipét tout soun ben en debaucho.
- Quand aguét tou arcaba, uno grosso famino arribet dins aqueou päis
et, leou, si veguét reduech à la derniero misèro.
Practically speaking, although in the central parts of France the northern and southern dialects melt into each other, the Loire may be considered as a line of demarcation between two languages; the term language being employed because, in the Middle Ages, whatever may be their real difference, their northern tongue and the southern tongue were dealt with not as separate dialects, but as distinct languages--the southern being called Provençal, the northern Norman-French.
Of these two languages (for so they will in the following pages be called, for the sake of convenience) the southern, or Provençal, approaches the dialects of Spain; the Valencian of Spain and the Catalonian of Spain being Provençal rather than standard Spanish or Castilian.
The southern French is sometimes called the Langue d'Oc, and sometimes the Limousin.
§ 68. The Norman-French, spoken from the Loire to the confines of Flanders, and called also the Langue d'Oyl, differed from the Provençal in (amongst others) the following circumstances.
- It was of later origin; the southern parts of Gaul having been colonized
at an early period by the Romans.
- It was in geographical contact, not with the allied languages of Spain,
but with the Gothic tongues of Germany and Holland.
§ 69. It is the Norman-French that most especially bears upon the history of the English language.
Specimen from the Anglo-Norman poem of Charlemagne.
Un jur fu Karléun al Seint-Denis muster,
Reout prise sa corune, en croiz seignat sun chef;
E ad ceinte sa espée: li pons fud d'or mer.
Dux i out e dermeines e baruns e chevalers.
Li emperères reguardet la reine sa muillers.
Ele fut ben corunée al plus bel e as meuz.
Il la prist par le poin desuz un oliver,
De sa pleine parole la prist à reisuner:
"Dame, véistes unkes hume nul de desuz ceil
Tant ben séist espée no la corone el chef!
Uncore cunquerrei-jo citez ot mun espeez."
Cele ne fud pas sage, folement respondeit:
"Emperere," dist-ele, trop vus poez preiser.
"Uncore en sa-jo un ki plus se fait léger,
Quant il porte corune entre ses chevalers;
Kaunt il met sur sa teste, plus belement lui set"
In the northern French we must recognise not only a Celtic and a Classical, but also a Gothic element: since Clovis and Charlemagne were no Frenchmen, but Germans. The Germanic element in French has still to be determined.
In the northern French of Normandy there is a second Gothic element, viz., a Scandinavian element. See § 76.
- * * * *
QUESTIONS.
- What are the present languages of Wales, the Isle of Man, the Scotch
Highlands, and Ireland?
- What are the present languages of Germany and Holland? How are they
related to the present language of England? How to the original language of England?
- Enumerate the chief supposed migrations from Germany to England,
giving (when possible) the date of each, the particular German tribe by which each was undertaken, and the parts of Great Britain where the different landings were made. Why do I say supposed migrations?
Criticise, in detail, the evidence by which they are supported, and state the extent to which it is exceptionable. Who was Beda? What were the sources of his information?
- Give reasons for believing the existence of Germans in England anterior
to A.D. 447.
- Who are the present Jutlanders of Jutland? Who the inhabitants of the
district called Anglen in Sleswick? What are the reasons for connecting these with the Jutes and Angles of Beda? What those for denying such a connection?
- What is the meaning of the termination -uarii in Cant-uarii and
Vect-uarii? What was the Anglo-Saxon translation of Antiqui Saxones, Occidentales Saxones, Orientates Saxones, Meridionales Saxones? What are the known variations in the form of the word Vectis, meaning the Isle of Wight? What those of the root Jut- as the name of the inhabitants of the peninsula of Jutland?
- Translate Cantware, Wihtware, into Latin. How does Alfred translate
Jutæ? How does the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle? What is the derivation of the name Carisbrook, a town in the Isle of Wight?
- Take exception to the opinions that Jutes, from Jutland, formed part
of the Germanic invasion of England; or, rather, take exceptions to the evidence upon which that opinion is based.
- From what part of Germany were the Angles derived? What is Beda's?
what Ethelweard's statement concerning them? Who were the Angli of Tacitus?
- What is the derivation of the word Mercia?
- Give the localities of the Old Saxons, and the Northalbingians.
Investigate the area occupied by the Anglo-Saxons.
- What is the present population of the Dutch province of Friesland? What
its language? What the dialects and stages of that language?
- What was the language of the Asega-bog, the Heliand, Beowulf,
Hildubrand and Hathubrant, the Carolinian Psalms, the Gospels of Ulphilas, and the poems of Gysbert Japicx?
- Make a map of Ancient Germany and Scandinavia according to languages
and dialects of those two areas. Exhibit, in a tabular form, the languages of the Gothic stock. Explain the meaning of the words Gothic, and Moeso-Gothic, and Platt-Deutsch.
- Analyze the Scandinavian forms Solen, Bordet, and brennast.
- Exhibit the difference between the logical and the historical
analysis of a language.
- What are the Celtic names for the English language?
- Enumerate the chief Germanic populations connected by ancient writers
with the Angles, stating the Ethnological relations of each, and noticing the extent to which they coincide with those of the Angles.
- What are the reasons for believing that there is a Frisian element in
the population of England?
- Exhibit, in a tabular form, the languages and dialects of the Celtic
stock. To which division did the Gallic of ancient Gaul, and the Pict belong? Support the answer by reasons. What were the relations of the Picts to the Gaelic inhabitants of Scotland? What to the Lowland Scotch? What to the Belgæ?
- Explain the following words--petorritum, pempedula, candetum,
Epona, Nantuates, peann fahel and Bernicia. What inferences do you draw from the derivation of them?
- Exhibit, in a tabular form, the languages and dialects of the Classical
stock.
- What is the bearing of the statements of Tacitus and other ancient
writers respecting the following Germanic populations upon the ethnological relations of the Angles,--Aviones, Reudigni, Suevi, Langobardi, Frisii, Varini?
- What is meant by the following terms, Provençal, Langue d'Oc, Langue
d'Oyl, Limousin, and Norman-French?
- What languages, besides the Celtic and Latin, enter into the
composition of the French?
- * * * *
PART II.
HISTORY AND ANALYSIS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
- * * * *
CHAPTER I.
HISTORICAL AND LOGICAL ELEMENTS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
§ 70. The Celtic elements of the present English fall into five classes.
- Those that are of late introduction, and cannot be called original and
constituent parts of the language. Some of such are the words flannel, crowd (a fiddle), from the Cambrian; and kerne (an Irish foot-soldier), galore (enough), tartan, plaid, &c., from the Gaelic branch.
- Those that are originally common to both the Celtic and Gothic stocks.
Some of such are brother, mother, in Celtic brathair, mathair; the numerals, &c.
- Those that have come to us from the Celtic, but have come to us through
the medium of another language. Some of such are druid and bard, whose immediate source is, not the Celtic but the Latin.
- Celtic elements of the Anglo-Norman, introduced into England after the
Conquest, and occurring in that language as remains of the original Celtic of Gaul.
- Those that have been retained from the original Celtic of the island,
and which form genuine constituents of our language. These fall into three subdivisions.
a. Proper names--generally of geographical localities; as the Thames, Kent, &c.
b. Common names retained in the provincial dialects of England, but not retained in the current language; as gwethall = household stuff, and gwlanen = flannel in Herefordshire.
c. Common names retained in the current language.--The following list is Mr. Garnett's:--
Welsh. English.
Basgawd Basket.
Berfa Barrow.
Botwm Button.
Bràn Bran.
Clwt Clout, Rag.
Crochan Crockery.
Crog Crook, Hook.
Cwch Cock, in Cock-boat.
Cwysed Gusset.
Cyl, Cyln Kiln (Kill, provinc.).
Dantaeth Dainty.
Darn Darn.
Deentur Tenter, in Tenterhook.
Fflaim Fleam, Cattle-lancet.
Fflaw Flaw.
Ffynnell (air-hole) Funnel.
Gefyn (fetter) Gyve.
Greidell Grid in Gridiron.
Grual Gruel.
Gwald (hem, border) Welt.
Gwiced (little door) Wicket.
Gwn Gown.
Gwyfr Wire.
Masg (stitch in netting) Mesh.
Mattog Mattock.
Mop Mop.
Rhail (fence) Rail.
Rhashg (slice) Rasher.
Rhuwch Rug.
Sawduriaw Solder.
Syth (glue) Size.
Tacl Tackle.
§ 71. Latin of the first period.--Of the Latin introduced by Cæsar and his successors, the few words remaining are those that relate to military affairs; viz. street (strata); -coln (as in Lincoln = Lindi colonia); -cest- (as in Gloucester = glevæ castra) from castra. The Latin words introduced between the time of Cæsar and Hengist may be called the Latin of the first period, or the Latin of the Celtic period.
§ 72. The Anglo-Saxon.--This is not noticed here, because, from being the staple of the present language, it is more or less the subject of the book throughout.
§ 73. The Danish, or Norse.--The pirates that pillaged Britain, under the name of Danes, were not exclusively the inhabitants of Denmark. Of the three Scandinavian nations, the Swedes took the least share, the Norwegians the greatest, in these invasions.
The language of the three nations was the same; the differences being differences of dialect. It was that which is now spoken in Iceland, having been once common to Scandinavia and Denmark.
The Danish that became incorporated with our language, under the reign of Canute and his sons, may be called the direct Danish element, in contradistinction to the indirect Danish of § 76.
The determination of the amount of Danish in English is difficult. It is not difficult to prove a word Scandinavian; but, then, we must also show that it is not German as well. A few years back the current opinion was against the doctrine that there was much Danish in England. At present, the tendency is rather the other way. The following facts are from Mr.
Garnett.--"Phil. Trans." vol. i.
- The Saxon name of the present town of Whitby in Yorkshire was
Streoneshalch. The present name Whitby, Hvitby, or Whitetown, is Danish.
- The Saxon name of the capital of Derbyshire was Northweortheg. The
present name is Danish.
- The termination -by = town is Norse.
- On a monument in Aldburgh church, Holdernesse, in the East Riding of
Yorkshire, referred to the age of Edward the Confessor, is found the following inscription:--
Ulf het aræran cyrice for hanum and for Gunthara saula.
"Ulf bid rear the church for him and for the soul of Gunthar."
Now, in this inscription, Ulf, in opposition to the Anglo-Saxon Wulf, is a Norse form; whilst hanum is a Norse dative, and by no means an Anglo-Saxon one.--Old Norse hanum, Swedish honom.
- The use of at for to as the sign of the infinitive mood is Norse,
not Saxon. It is the regular prefix in Icelandic, Danish, Swedish, and Feroic. It is also found in the northern dialects of the Old English, and in the particular dialect of Westmoreland at the present day.
- The use of sum for as; e.g.,--swa sum we forgive oure detturs.
- Isolated words in the northern dialects are Norse rather than Saxon.
Provincial. Common Dialect. Norse.
Braid Resemble Braas, Swed.
Eldin Firing Eld, Dan.
Force Waterfall Fors, D.
Swed.
Gar Make Göra, Swed.
Gill Ravine Gil, Iceland.
Greet Weep Grata, Iceland.
Ket Carrion Kiöd--flesh, Dan.
Lait Seek Lede, Dan.
Lathe Barn Lade, Dan.
Lile Little Lille, Dan.
§ 74. Roman of the second period.--Of the Latin introduced under the Christianised Saxon sovereigns, many words are extant.
They relate chiefly to ecclesiastical matters, just as the Latin of the Celtic period bore upon military affairs. Mynster, a minster, monasterium; portic, a porch, porticus; cluster, a cloister, claustrum; munuc, a monk, monachus; bisceop, a bishop, episcopus; arcebisceop, archbishop, archiepiscopus; sanct, a saint, sanctus; profost, a provost, propositus; pall, a pall, pallium; calic, a chalice, calix; candel, a candle, candela; psalter, a psalter, psalterium; mæsse, a mass, missa; pistel, an epistle, epistola; prædic-ian, to preach, prædicare; prof-ian, to prove, probare.
The following are the names of foreign plants and animals:--camell, a camel, camelus; ylp, elephant, elephas; ficbeam, fig-tree, ficus; feferfuge, feverfew, febrifuga; peterselige, parsley, petroselinum.
Others are the names of articles of foreign origin, as pipor, pepper, piper; purpur, purple, purpura; pumicstan, pumicestone, pumex.
This is the Latin of the second, or Saxon period.
§ 75. The Anglo-Norman element.--For practical purposes we may say that the French or Anglo-Norman element appeared in our language after the battle of Hastings, A.D. 1066.
Previous, however, to that period we find notices of intercourse between the two countries.
- The residence in England of Louis Outremer.
- Ethelred II. married Emma, daughter of Richard Duke of Normandy, and the
two children were sent to Normandy for education.
- Edward the Confessor is particularly stated to have encouraged French
manners and the French language in England.
- Ingulphus of Croydon speaks of his own knowledge of French.
- Harold passed some time in Normandy.
- The French article la, in the term la Drove, occurs in a deed of
A.D. 975.
The chief Anglo-Norman elements of our language are the terms connected with the feudal system, the terms relating to war and chivalry, and a great portion of the law terms--duke, count, baron, villain, service, chivalry, warrant, esquire, challenge, domain, &c.
§ 76. When we remember that the word Norman means man of the north, that it is a Scandinavian, and not a French word, that it originated in the invasions of the followers of Rollo and and other Norwegians, and that just as part of England was overrun by Pagan buccaneers called Danes, part of France was occupied by similar Northmen, we see the likelihood of certain Norse words finding their way into the French language, where they would be superadded to its original Celtic and Roman elements.
The extent to which this is actually the case has only been partially investigated. It is certain, however, that some French words are Norse or Scandinavian. Such, for instance, are several names of geographical localities either near the sea, or the river Seine, in other words, within that tract which was most especially occupied by the invaders. As is to be expected from the genius of the French language, these words are considerably altered in form. Thus,
NORSE. ENGLISH. FRENCH.
Toft Toft Tot.
Beck Beck Bec.
Flöt Fleet[33] Fleur, &c.
and in these shapes they appear in the Norman names Yvetot, Caudebec, and Harfleur, &c.
Now any words thus introduced from the Norse of Scandinavia into the French of Normandy, might, by the Norman Conquest of England, be carried further, and so find their way into the English.
In such a case, they would constitute its indirect Scandinavian element.
A list of these words has not been made; indeed the question requires far more investigation than it has met with. The names, however, of the islands Guerns-ey, Jers-ey, and Aldern-ey, are certainly of the kind in question--since the -ey, meaning island, is the same as the -ey in Orkn-ey, and is the Norse rather than the Saxon form.
§ 77. Latin of the third period.--This means the Latin which was introduced between the battle of Hastings and the revival of literature. It chiefly originated in the cloister, in the universities, and, to a certain extent, in the courts of law. It must be distinguished from the indirect Latin introduced as part and parcel of the Anglo-Norman. It has yet to be accurately analyzed.
§ 78. Latin of the fourth period.--This means the Latin which has been introduced between the revival of literature and the present time. It has originated in the writings of learned men in general, and is distinguished from that of the previous periods by:
- Being less altered in form:
- Preserving, with substantives, in many cases its original inflections;
axis, axes; basis, bases:
- Relating to objects and ideas for which the increase of the range of
science in general has required a nomenclature.
§ 79. Greek.--Words derived directly from the Greek are in the same predicament as the Latin of the third period--phænomenon, phænomena; criterion, criteria, &c.; words which are only indirectly of Greek origin, being considered to belong to the language from which they were immediately introduced into the English. Such are deacon, priest, &c., introduced through the Latin. Hence a word like church proves no more in regard to a Greek element in English, than the word abbot proves in respect to a Syrian one.
§ 80. The Latin of the fourth period and the Greek agree in retaining, in many cases, original inflexions rather than adopting the English ones; in other words, they agree in being but imperfectly incorporated. The phænomenon of imperfect incorporation is reducible to the following rules:--
- That it has a direct ratio to the date of the introduction, i.e., the
more recent the word the more likely it is to retain its original inflexion.
- That it has a relation to the number of meanings belonging to the words:
thus, when a single word has two meanings, the original inflexion expresses one, the English inflexion another--genius, genii, often (spirits), geniuses (men of genius).
- That it occurs with substantives only, and that only in the expression
of number. Thus, although the plural of substantives like axis and genius are Latin, the possessive cases are English. So also are the degrees of comparison for adjectives, like circular, and the tenses, &c. for verbs, like perambulate.
§ 81. The following is a list of the chief Latin substantives introduced during the latter part of the fourth period; and preserving the Latin plural forms--
FIRST CLASS.
Words wherein the Latin plural is the same as the Latin singular.
(a) Sing. Plur. | (b) Sing. Plur.
Apparatus apparat-us | Caries cari-es
Hiatus hiat-us | Congeries congeri-es
Impetus impet-us | Series seri-es
| Species speci-es
| Superficies superfici-es.
SECOND CLASS.
Words wherein the Latin plural is formed from the Latin singular by changing the last syllable.
(a).--Where the singular termination -a is changed in the plural into -æ:--
Sing. Plur. | Sing. Plur.
Formul-a formul-æ | Nebul-a nebul-æ
Lamin-a lamin-æ | Scori-a scori-æ.
Larv-a larv-æ |
(b).--Where the singular termination -us is changed in the plural into -i:--
Sing. Plur. | Sing. Plur.
Calcul-us calcul-i | Polyp-us polyp-i
Coloss-us coloss-i | Radi-us radi-i
Convolvul-us convolvul-i | Ranuncul-us ranuncul-i
Foc-us foc-i | Sarcophag-us sarcophag-i
Geni-us geni-i | Schirr-us schirrh-i
Mag-us mag-i | Stimul-us stimul-i
Nautil-us nautil-i | Tumul-us tumul-i.
Oesophag-us oesophag-i |
(c).--Where the singular termination -um is changed in the plural into -a:--
Sing. Plur. | Sing. Plur.
Animalcul-um animalcul-a | Mausole-um mausole-a
Arcan-um arcan-a | Medi-um medi-a
Collyri-um collyri-a | Memorand-um memorand-a
Dat-um dat-a | Menstru-um menstru-a
Desiderat-um desiderat-a | Moment-um moment-a
Effluvi-um effluvi-a | Premi-um premi-a
Empori-um empori-a | Scholi-um scholi-a
Encomi-um encomi-a | Spectr-um spectr-a
Errat-um errat-a | Specul-um specul-a
Gymnasi-um gymnasi-a | Strat-um strat-a
Lixivi-um lixivi-a | Succedane-um succedane-a.
Lustr-um lustr-a |
(d).--Where the singular termination -is is changed in the plural into -es:--
Sing. Plur. | Sing. Plur.
Amanuens-is amanuens-es | Ellips-is ellips-es
Analys-is analys-es | Emphas-is emphas-es
Antithes-is antithes-es | Hypothes-is hypothes-es
Ax-is ax-es | Oas-is oas-es
Bas-is bas-es | Parenthes-is parenthes-es
Cris-is cris-es | Synthes-is synthes-es
Diæres-is diæres-es | Thes-is thes-es.
THIRD CLASS.
Words wherein the plural is formed by inserting -e between the last two sounds of the singular, so that the former number always contains a syllable more than the latter:--
Sing. Plur.
Apex sounded apec-s apices
Appendix -- appendic-s appendices
Calix -- calic-s calices
Cicatrix -- cicatric-s cicatrices
Helix -- helic-s helices
Index -- indec-s indices
Radix -- radic-s radices
Vertex -- vertec-s vertices
Vortex -- vortec-s vortices.
In all these words the c of the singular number is sounded as k; of the plural, as s.
§ 82. The following is a list of the chief Greek substantives lately introduced, and preserving the Greek plural forms--
FIRST CLASS.
Words where the singular termination -on is changed in the plural into -a:--
Sing. Plur. Sing. Plur.
Apheli-on apheli-a Criteri-on criteri-a
Periheli-on periheli-a Ephemer-on ephemer-a
Automat-on automat-a Phænomen-on phænomen-a.
SECOND CLASS.
Words where the plural is formed from the original root by adding either -es or -a, but where the singular rejects the last letter of the original root.
Plurals in -es:--
Original root. Plur. Sing.
Apsid- apsid-es apsis
Cantharid- cantharid-es cantharis
Chrysalid- chrysalid-es chrysalis
Ephemerid- ephemerid-es ephemeris
Tripod- tripod-es tripos.
Plurals in -a:--
Original root. Plur. Sing.
Dogmat- dogmat-a dogma
Lemmat- lemmat-a lemma
Miasmat- miasmat-a miasma.[34]
§ 83. Miscellaneous elements.--Of miscellaneous elements we have two sorts; those that are incorporated in our language, and are currently understood (e.g., the Spanish word sherry, the Arabic word alkali, and the Persian word turban), and those that, even amongst the educated, are considered strangers. Of this latter kind (amongst many others) are the oriental words hummum, kaftan, gul, &c.
Of the currently understood miscellaneous elements of the English language, the most important are from the French; some of which agree with those of the Latin of the fourth period, and the Greek, in preserving the French plural forms--as beau, beaux, billets-doux.
Italian.--Some words of Italian origin do the same; as virtuoso, virtuosi.
Hebrew.--The Hebrew words, cherub and seraph do the same; the form cherub-im, and seraph-im being not only plurals but Hebrew plurals.
Beyond the words derived from these five languages, none form their plural other than after the English method, i.e., in -s, as waltzes, from the German word waltz.
§ 84. Hence we have a measure of the extent to which a language, which, like the English, at one and the same time requires names for many objects, comes in contact with the tongues of half the world, and has moreover, a great power of incorporating foreign elements, derives fresh words from varied sources; as may be seen from the following incomplete notice of the languages which have, in different degrees, supplied it with new terms.
Arabic.--Admiral, alchemist, alchemy, alcohol, alcove, alembic, algebra, alkali, assassin.
Persian.--Turban, caravan, dervise, &c.
Turkish.--Coffee, bashaw, divan, scimitar, janisary, &c.
Hindoo languages.--Calico, chintz, cowrie, curry, lac, muslin, toddy, &c.
Chinese.--Tea, bohea, congou, hyson, soy, nankin &c.
Malay.--Bantam (fowl), gamboge, rattan, sago, shaddock, &c.
Polynesian.--Taboo, tattoo.
Tungusian or some similar Siberian language.--Mammoth, the bones of which are chiefly from the banks of the Lena.
North American Indian.--Squaw, wigwam, pemmican.
Peruvian.--Charki = prepared meat; whence jerked beef.
Caribbean.--Hammock.
§ 85. A distinction is drawn between the direct and indirect, the latter leading to the ultimate origin of words.
Thus a word borrowed into the English from the French, might have been borrowed into the French from the Latin, into the Latin from the Greek, into the Greek from the Persian, &c., and so ad infinitum.
The investigation of this is a matter of literary curiosity rather than any important branch of philology.
The ultimate known origin of many common words sometimes goes back to a great date, and points to extinct languages--
Ancient Nubian.--Barbarous.
Ancient Egyptian.--Ammonia.
Ancient Syrian.--Cyder.
Ancient Lycian.--Pandar.
Ancient Lydian.--Mæander.
Ancient Persian.--Paradise.
§ 86. Again, a word from a given language may be introduced by more lines than one; or it may be introduced twice over; once at an earlier, and again at a later period. In such a case its form will, most probably, vary; and, what is more, its meaning as well. Words of this sort may be called di-morphic, their dimorphism having originated in one of two reasons--a difference of channel or a difference of date.
Instances of the first are, syrup, sherbet, and shrub, all originally from the Arabic, srb; but introduced differently, viz., the first through the Latin, the second through the Persian, and the third through the Hindoo. Instances of the second are words like minster, introduced during the Anglo-Saxon, as contrasted with monastery, introduced during the Anglo-Norman period.
By the proper application of these processes, we account for words so different in present form, yet so identical in origin, as priest and presbyter, episcopal and bishop, &c.
§ 87. Distinction.--The history of the languages that have been spoken in a particular country, is a different subject from the history of a particular language. The history of the languages that have been spoken in the United States of America, is the history of Indian languages. The history of the language of the United States is the history of a Germanic language.
§ 88. Words of foreign simulating a vernacular origin.--These may occur in any mixed language whatever; they occur, however, oftener in the English than in any other.
Let a word be introduced from a foreign language--let it have some resemblance in sound to a real English term: lastly, let the meanings of the two words be not absolutely incompatible. We may then have a word of foreign origin taking the appearance of an English one.
Such, amongst others, are beef-eater, from boeuffetier; sparrow-grass, asparagus; Shotover, Chateauvert;[35] Jerusalem, Girasole;[36] Spanish beefeater, spina bifida; periwig, peruke; runagate, renegade; lutestring, lustrino;[37] O yes, Oyez! ancient, ensign.[38]
Dog-cheap.--This has nothing to do with dogs. The first syllabic is god = good transposed, and the second the ch-p in chapman ( = merchant) cheap, and Eastcheap. In Sir J. Mandeville, we find god-kepe = good bargain.
Sky-larking.--Nothing to do with larks of any sort; still less the particular species, alauda arvensis. The word improperly spelt l-a-r-k, and banished to the slang regions of the English language, is the Anglo-Saxon lác = game, or sport; wherein the a is sounded as in father (not as in farther). Lek = game, in the present Scandinavian languages.
Zachary Macaulay = Zumalacarregui; Billy Ruffian = Bellerophon; Sir Roger Dowlas = Surajah Dowlah, although so limited to the common soldiers and sailors, who first used them, as to be exploded vulgarisms rather than integral parts of the language, are examples of the same tendency towards the irregular accommodation of misunderstood foreign terms.
Birdbolt.--An incorrect name for the gadus lota, or eel-pout, and a transformation of barbote.
Whistle-fish.--The same for gadus mustela, or weasel-fish.
Liquorice = glycyrrhiza.
Wormwood = weremuth, is an instance of a word from the same language, in an antiquated shape, being equally transformed with a word of really foreign origin.
§ 89. Sometimes the transformation of the name has engendered a change in the object to which it applies, or, at least, has evolved new ideas in connection with it. How easy for a person who used the words beef-eater, sparrow-grass, or Jerusalem, to believe that the officers designated by the former either eat or used to eat more beef than any other people, that the second word was the name for a grass or herb of which sparrows were fond; and that Jerusalem artichokes came from Palestine.
What has just been supposed has sometimes a real occurrence. To account for the name of Shotover-hill, I have heard that Little John shot over it.
Here the confusion, in order to set itself right, breeds a fiction. Again, in chess, the piece now called the queen, was originally the elephant.
This was in Persian, ferz. In French it became vierge, which, in time, came to be mistaken for a derivative, and virgo = the virgin, the lady, the queen.
§ 90. Sometimes, where the form of a word in respect to its sound is not affected, a false spirit of accommodation introduces an unetymological spelling; as frontispiece, from frontispecium, sovereign, from sovrano, colleague from collega, lanthorn (old orthography) from lanterna.
The value of forms like these consists in their showing that language is affected by false etymologies as well as by true ones.
- * * * *
§ 91. In lambkin and lancet, the final syllables (-kin and -et) have the same power. They both express the idea of smallness or diminutiveness.
These words are but two out of a multitude, the one (lamb) being of Saxon, the other (lance) of Norman origin. The same is the case with the superadded syllables: -kin being Saxon; -et Norman. Now to add a Saxon termination to a Norman word, or vice versâ, is to corrupt the English language.
This leads to some observation respecting the--
§ 92. Introduction of new words and Hybridism.--Hybridism is a term derived from hybrid-a, a mongrel; a Latin word of Greek extraction.
The terminations -ize (as in criticize), -ism (as in criticism), -ic (as in comic)--these, amongst many others, are Greek terminations. To add them to words not of Greek origin is to be guilty of hybridism. Hence, witticism is objectionable.
The terminations -ble (as in penetrable), -bility (as in penetrability), -al (as in parental)--these, amongst many others, are Latin terminations. To add them to words not of Latin origin is to be guilty of hybridism.
Hybridism is the commonest fault that accompanies the introduction of new words. The hybrid additions to the English language are most numerous in works on science.
It must not, however, be concealed that several well established words are hybrid; and that, even in the writings of the classical Roman authors, there is hybridism between the Latin and the Greek.
Nevertheless, the etymological view of every word of foreign origin is, not that it is put together in England, but that it is brought whole from the language to which it is vernacular. Now no derived word can be brought whole from a language unless, in that language, all its parts exist. The word penetrability is not derived from the English word penetrable, by the addition of -ty. It is the Latin word penetrabilitas imported.
In derived words all the parts must belong to one and the same language, or, changing the expression, every derived word must have a possible form in the language from which it is taken. Such is the rule against hybridism.
§ 93. A true word sometimes takes the appearance of a hybrid without really being so. The -icle, in icicle, is apparently the same as the -icle in radicle. Now, as ice is Gothic, and -icle classical, hybridism is simulated. Icicle, however, is not a derivative but a compound; its parts being is and gicel, both Anglo-Saxon words.[39]
§ 94. On incompletion of the radical.--Let there be in a given language a series of roots ending in -t, as sæmat. Let a euphonic influence eject the -t, as often as the word occurs in the nominative case. Let the nominative case be erroneously considered to represent the root, or radical, of the word. Let a derivative word be formed accordingly, i.e., on the notion that the nominative form and the radical form coincide. Such a derivative will exhibit only a part of the root; in other words, the radical will be incomplete.
Now all this is what actually takes place in words like hæmo-ptysis (spitting of blood), sema-phore (a sort of telegraph). The Greek imparisyllabics eject a part of the root in the nominative case; the radical forms being hæmat- and sæmat-, not _hæm-_and sæm-.
Incompletion of the radical is one of the commonest causes of words being coined faultily. It must not, however, be concealed, that even in the classical writers, we have in words like [Greek: distomos] examples of incompletion of the radical.
- * * * *
§ 95. The preceding chapters have paved the way for a distinction between the historical analysis of a language, and the logical analysis of one.
Let the present language of England (for illustration's sake only) consist of 40,000 words. Of these let 30,000 be Anglo-Saxon, 5,000 Anglo-Norman, 100 Celtic, 10 Latin of the first, 20 Latin of the second, and 30 Latin of the third period, 50 Scandinavian, and the rest miscellaneous. In this case the language is considered according to the historical origin of the words that compose it, and the analysis is an historical analysis.
But it is very evident that the English, or any other language, is capable of being contemplated in another view, and that the same number of words may be very differently classified. Instead of arranging them according to the languages whence they are derived, let them be disposed according to the meanings that they convey. Let it be said, for instance, that out of 40,000 words, 10,000 are the names of natural objects, that 1000 denote abstract ideas, that 1000 relate to warfare, 1000 to church matters, 500 to points of chivalry, 1000 to agriculture, and so on through the whole.
In this case the analysis is not historical but logical; the words being classed not according to their origin, but according to their meaning.
Now the logical and historical analyses of a language generally in some degree coincide; that is, terms for a certain set of ideas come from certain languages; just as in English a large proportion of our chemical terms are Arabic, whilst a still larger one of our legal ones are Anglo-Norman.
- * * * *
CHAPTER II.
THE RELATION OF THE ENGLISH TO THE ANGLO-SAXON, AND THE STAGES OF THE
ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
§ 96. The relation of the present English to the Anglo-Saxon is that of a modern language to an ancient one: the words modern and ancient being used in a defined and technical sense.
Let the word smiðum illustrate this. Smið-um, the dative plural of smið, is equivalent in meaning to the English to smiths; or to the Latin fabr-is. Smiðum, however, is a single Anglo-Saxon word (a substantive, and nothing more); whilst its English equivalent is two words (i.e., a substantive with the addition of a preposition). The letter s, in smiths, shows that the word is plural. The -um, in smiðum, does this and something more. It is the sign of the dative case plural. The -um in smiðum, is the part of a word.
The preposition to is a separate word with an independent existence. Smiðum is the radical syllable smið + the subordinate inflectional syllable -um, the sign of the dative case. The combination to smiths is the substantive smiths + the preposition to, equivalent in power to the sign of a dative case, but different from it in form.
As far, then, as the words just quoted is concerned, the Anglo-Saxon differs from the English by expressing an idea by a certain modification of the form of the root, whereas the modern English denotes the same idea by the addition of a preposition; in other words, the Saxon inflection is superseded by a combination of words.
The sentences in italics are mere variations of the same general statement.
- The earlier the stage of a given language the greater the amount of its
inflectional forms, and the later the stage of a given language, the smaller the amount of them. 2. As languages become modern they substitute prepositions and auxiliary verbs for cases and tenses. 3. The amount of inflection is in the inverse proportion to the amount of prepositions and auxiliary verbs. 4. In the course of time languages drop their inflections, and substitute in its stead circumlocutions by means of prepositions, &c.
The reverse never takes place. 5. Given two modes of expression, the one inflectional (smiðum), the other circumlocutional[40] (to smiths), we can state that the first belongs to an early, the second to a late, state of language.
The present chapter, then showing the relation of the English to the Anglo-Saxon, shows something more. It exhibits the general relation of a modern to an ancient language. As the English is to the Anglo-Saxon, so are the Danish, Swedish, and Norwegian, to the old Norse; and so are the French, Italian, Spanish, Portuguese, Romanese and Wallachian to the Latin, and the Romaic to the ancient Greek.
§ 97. Contrasted with the English, the Anglo-Saxon has (among others) the following differences.
NOUNS.
- Gender.--In Anglo-Saxon there were three genders, the masculine, the
feminine, and the neuter. With adjectives each gender had its peculiar declension. With substantives also there were appropriate terminations, though only to a certain degree.
- The definite article varied with the gender of its substantive; þæt
eage, the eye; se steorra, the star; seo tunge, the tongue.
- Number.--The plural form in -en (as in oxen), rare in English, was
common in Anglo-Saxon. It was the regular termination of a whole declension; e.g., eágan, eyes; steorran, stars; tungan, tongues.
Besides this, the Anglo-Saxons had forms in -u and -a as ricu, kingdoms; gifa, gifts. The termination -s, current in the present English, was confined to a single gender and to a single declension, as endas, ends; dagas, days; smiðas, smiths.
- Case.--Of these the Saxons had, for their substantives, at least
three; viz., the nominative, dative, genitive. With the pronouns and adjectives there was a true accusative form; and with a few especial words an ablative or instrumental one. Smið, a smith; smiðe, to a smith; smiðes, of a smith. Plural, smiðas, smiths; smiðum, to smiths; smiða, of smiths: he, he; hine, him; him, to him; his, his; se, the; þa, the; þy, with the; þam, to the; þæs, of the.
- Declension.--In Anglo-Saxon it was necessary to determine the
declension of a substantive. There was the weak, or simple declension for words ending in a vowel (as, eage, steorra, tunga), and the strong declension for words ending in a consonant (smið, spræc, leáf). The letters i and u were dealt with as semivowels, semi-vowels being dealt with as consonants; so that words like sunu and gifu belonged to the same declension as smið and spræc.
- Definite and indefinite form of adjectives.--In Anglo-Saxon each
adjective had two forms, one definite and one indefinite. There is nothing of this kind in English. We say a good sword, and the good sword equally. In Anglo-Saxon, however, the first combination would be se gode sweord, the second án god sweord, the definite form being distinguished from the indefinite by the addition of a vowel.
- Pronouns personal.--The Anglo-Saxon language had for the first two
persons a dual number; inflected as follows:
1st Person. 2nd Person.
Nom. Wit We two Nom. Git Ye two
Acc. Unc Us two Acc. Ince You two
Gen. Uncer Of us two Gen. Incer Of you two.
Besides this, the demonstrative, possessive, and relative pronouns, as well as the numerals twa and þreo, had a fuller declension than they have at present.
VERBS.
- Mood.--The subjunctive mood that in the present English (with one
exception[41]) differs from the indicative only in the third person singular, was in Anglo-Saxon considerably different from the indicative.
Indicative Mood.
Pres. Sing. 1. Lufige. Plur. 1. }
2. Lufast. 2. } Lufiað.
3. Lufað. 3. }
Subjunctive Mood.
Pres. Sing. 1. } Plur. 1. }
2. } Lufige 2. } Lufion.
3. } 3. }
The Saxon infinitive ended in -an (lufian), and besides this there was a so-called gerundial form, to lufigenne.
Besides these there were considerable differences in respect to particular words; but of these no notice is taken; the object being to indicate the differences between the ancient and modern stages of a language in respect to grammatical structure.
- To bring about these changes a certain amount of time is, of course,
necessary; a condition which suggests the difficult question as to the rate at which languages change. This is different for different languages; but as the investigation belongs to general philology rather than to the particular history of the English language, it finds no place here.
§ 98. The extent, however, to which external causes may accelerate or retard philological changes, is not foreign to our subject; the influence of the Norman Conquest, upon the previous Anglo-Saxon foundation, being a problem of some difficulty.
At the first glance it seems to have been considerable, especially in the way of simplifying the grammar. Yet the accuracy of this view is by no means unequivocal. The reasons against it are as follows:
a. In Friesland no such conquest took place. Yet the modern Frisian, as compared with the ancient, is nearly as simple in its grammatical structure, as the English is when compared with the Anglo-Saxon.
b. In Norway, Sweden, and Denmark, no such conquest took place. Yet the modern Danish and Swedish, as compared with the Old Norse, are nearly as simple in their grammatical structure, as the English is, when compared with the Anglo-Saxon.
The question requires more investigation than it has met with.
An extract from Mr. Hallam's "History of Literature" closes the present section, and introduces the next.
"Nothing can be more difficult, except by an arbitrary line, than to
determine the commencement of the English language; not so much, as in
those on the Continent, because we are in want of materials, but rather
from an opposite reason, the possibility of showing a very gradual
succession of verbal changes that ended in a change of denomination. We
should probably experience a similar difficulty, if we knew equally
well the current idiom of France or Italy in the seventh and eighth
centuries.
For when we compare the earliest English of the thirteenth
century with the Anglo-Saxon of the twelfth, it seems hard to pronounce
why it should pass for a separate language, rather than a modification
or simplification of the former. We must conform, however, to usage,
and say that the Anglo-Saxon was converted into English:--1. By
contracting and otherwise modifying the pronunciation and orthography
of words. 2. By omitting many inflections, especially of the noun, and
consequently making more use of articles and auxiliaries. 3. By the
introduction of French derivatives. 4.
By using less inversion and
ellipsis, especially in poetry. Of these, the second alone, I think,
can be considered as sufficient to describe a new form of language; and
this was brought about so gradually, that we are not relieved from much
of our difficulty, as to whether some compositions shall pass for the
latest offspring of the mother, or the earlier fruits of the daughter's
fertility. It is a proof of this difficulty that the best masters of
our ancient language have lately introduced the word Semi-Saxon, which
is to cover everything from A.D. 1150 to A.D. 1250."--Chapter i. 47.
§ 99. This shows that by the middle of the 12th century, the Anglo-Saxon of the standard Anglo-Saxon authors, had undergone such a change as to induce the scholars of the present ago to denominate it, not Saxon, but Semi-Saxon. It had ceased to be genuine Saxon, but had not yet become English.
Some, amongst others, of the earlier changes of the standard Anglo-Saxon are,
- The substitution of -an for -as, in the plural of substantives,
munucan for munucas (monks); and, conversely, the substitution of -s for -n, as steorres for steorran (stars).
- The ejection or shortening of final vowels, þæt ylc for þæt ylce;
sone for sunu; name for nama; dages for dagas.
- The substitution of -n for -m in the dative case, hwilon for hwilum.
- The ejection of the -n of the infinitive mood, cumme for cuman (to
come), nemne for nemnen (to name).
- The ejection of -en in the participle passive, I-hote for gehaten
(called, hight).
- The gerundial termination -enne, superseded by the infinitive
termination -en; as to lufian for to lufienne, or lufigenne.
- The substitution of -en for -að in the persons plural of verbs; hi
clepen (they call) for hi clypiað, &c.
The preponderance (not the occasional occurrence) of forms like those above constitute Semi-Saxon in contradistinction to standard Saxon, classical Saxon, or Anglo-Saxon proper.
§ 100. Old English stage.--Further changes convert Semi-Saxon into Old English. Some, amongst others, are the following:--
- The ejection of the dative plural termination -um, and the substitution
of the preposition to and the plural sign -s; as to smiths for smiðum.
Of the dative singular the -e is retained (ende, worde); but it is by no means certain that, although recognized in writing, it was equally recognized in pronunciation also.
- The ejection of -es in the genitive singular whenever the preposition
of came before it; Godes love (God's love), but the love of God, and not the love of Godes.
- The syllable -es as a sign of the genitive case extended to all genders
and to all declensions; heart's for heortan; sun's for sunnan.
- The same in respect to the plural number; sterres for steorran;
sons for suna.
- The ejection of -na in the genitive plural; as of tunges for
tungena.
- The use of the word the, as an article, instead of se, &c.
The preponderance of the forms above (and not their mere occasional occurrence) constitutes Old English in contradistinction to Semi-Saxon.
§ 101. In the Old English the following forms predominate.
- A fuller inflection of the demonstrative pronoun, or definite article;
þan, þenne, þære, þam;--in contradistinction to the Middle English.
- The presence of the dative singular in -e; ende, smithe.
- The existence of a genitive plural in -r or -ra; heora, theirs;
aller, of all. This, with substantives and adjectives, is less common.
- The substitution of heo for they, of heora for their, of hem
for them.
- A more frequent use of min and thin, for my and thy;--in
contradistinction to both Middle and Modern English.
- The use of heo for she;--in contradistinction to Middle and Modern
English and Old Lowland Scotch.
- The use of broader vowels; as in iclepud or iclepod (for icleped
or yclept); geongost, youngest; ascode, asked; eldore, elder.
- The use of the strong preterits (see the chapter on the tenses of
verbs), where in the present English the weak form is found--wex, wop, dalf, for waxed, wept, delved.
- The omission not only of the gerundial termination -enne, but also of
the infinitive sign -en after to; to honte, to speke;--in contradistinction to Semi-Saxon.
- The substitution of -en for -eþ or -eð, in the first and second persons
plural of verbs; we wollen, we will: heo schullen, they should.
- The comparative absence of the articles se and seo.
- The substitution of ben and beeth, for synd and syndon = we,
ye, they are.
§ 102. Concerning the extent to which the Anglo-Norman was used, I retail the following statements and quotations.
- "Letters even of a private nature were written in Latin till the
beginning of the reign of Edward I., soon after 1270, when a sudden
change brought in the use of French."--Mr. Hallam, communicated by Mr.
Stevenson (Literature of Europe, i. 52, and note).
- Conversation between the members of the Universities was ordered to
be carried on either in Latin or French:--"Si qua inter se proferant,
colloquio Latino vel saltem Gallico perfruantur."--Statutes of Oriel
College, Oxford.--Hallam, ibid. from Warton.
- "The Minutes of the Corporation of London, recorded in the Town
Clerk's Office, were in French, as well as the Proceedings in
Parliament, and in the Courts of Justice."--Ibid.
- "In Grammar Schools, boys were made to construe their Latin into
French."--Ibid. "Pueri in scholis, contra morem cæterarum nationum,
et Normannorum adventu, derelicto proprio vulgari, construere Gallice
compelluntur. Item quod filii nobilium ab ipsis cunabulorum crepundiis
ad Gallicum idioma informantur. Quibus profecto rurales homines
assimulari volentes, ut per hoc spectabiliores videantur, Francigenari
satagunt omni nisu."--Higden (Ed. Gale, p. 210).
§ 103. The reigns of Edward III., and Richard II., may be said to form a transition from the Old to the Middle; those of Mary and Elizabeth from the Middle to the New, Recent or Modern English. No very definite line of demarcation, however, can be drawn.
§ 104. The present tendencies of the English may be determined by observation: and as most of them will be noticed in the etymological part of this volume, the few here indicated must be looked upon as illustrations only.
- The distinction between the subjunctive and indicative mood is likely to
pass away. We verify this by the very general tendency to say if it is, and if he speaks, rather than if it be, and if he speak.
- The distinction between the participle passive and the past tense is
likely to pass away. We verify this by the tendency to say it is broke, and he is smote, for it is broken and he is smitten.
- Of the double forms, sung and sang, drank and drunk, &c., one
only will be the permanent.
As stated above, these tendencies are but a few out of many, and have been adduced in order to indicate the subject rather than to exhaust it.
- * * * *
QUESTIONS.
- Classify the Celtic elements of the English language.
- Enumerate the chief periods during which words from the Latin were
introduced into English, and classify the Latin elements accordingly.
- What words were introduced directly by the Danes, Scandinavians,
or Norsemen? What indirectly? Through what language did these latter
come?
- Give the dates of the Battle of Hastings, and of the reigns of Louis
Outremer, Ethelred II, and Edward the Confessor. What was the amount of
Norman-French elements in England anterior to the Conquest?
- Give the languages from whence the following words were introduced
into the English--flannel, jerked (as to beef), hammock,
apparatus, waltz, Seraph, plaid, street, muslin.
- Distinguish between the direct, indirect, and ultimate origin
of introduced words. What words have we in English which are supposed
to have originated in the Ancient Ægyptian, the Syrian, and the
languages of Asia Minor?
- Under what different forms do the following words appear in
English--monasterium, [Greek: presbuteros], [Greek: episkopos].
Account for these differences. Syrup, shrub, and sherbet, all
originate from the same word. Explain the present difference.
- Give the direct origin (i.e., the languages from which they were
immediately introduced) of--Druid, epistle, chivalry, cyder,
mæander. Give the indirect origin of the same.
- Investigate the process by which a word like sparrow-grass,
apparently of English origin, is, in reality, derived from the Latin
word asparagus. Point out the incorrectness in the words
frontispiece, colleague, and lanthorn.
- To what extent may Norse, and to what extent may Celtic words,
not found in the current language of English, be found in the
provincial dialects?
- What were the original names of the towns Whitby and Derby?
From what language are the present names derived? Give the reason for
your answer.
- Show the extent to which the logical and historical analyses
coincide in respect to the words introduced from the Roman of the
second period, the Arabic, the Anglo-Norman, and the Celtic of the
current English.
- What are the plural forms of criterion, axis, genius,
index, dogma? When is a word introduced from a foreign language
perfectly, when imperfectly incorporated with the language into
which it is imported? Is the following expression correct--the
cherubim that singeth aloft? If not, why?
- What is there exceptionable in the words semaphore (meaning a
sort of telegraph), and witticism. Give the etymologies of the words
icicle, radicle, and radical.
- What are the singular forms of cantharides, phænomena, and
data?
- What are the stages of the English language? How does the present
differ from the older ones?
- Exhibit in detail the inflections of the Anglo-Saxon a) noun, and
b) verb, which are not found in the present English. What is the import
of the loss of inflections, and their replacement by separate words?
What is the nature of such words in nouns? What in verbs?
- Contrast the syntax of the Anglo-Saxon with the Modern English
adjective. What is the English for the Anglo-Saxon words wit, unc,
incer?
- Express, in general terms, the chief points wherein a modern
language differs from an ancient one: or, rather, the points wherein
the different stages of the same language differ.
- Investigate the influence of the Norman Conquest on the English.
Explain the terms Semi-Saxon, Old English, and Middle English. Compare
the stages of the English with those of the other Gothic tongues.
- Give the Modern English for the following forms and
expressions--munucas, steorran, to lufienne. What are the
Anglo-Saxon forms of munucan, steorres, i-hotte, clepen?
Translate the Latin word omnium (genitive plural of omnis) into
Old English. Translate the Greek [Greek: ho], [Greek: hê], [Greek:
to] into Anglo-Saxon, Old English, and Modern English.
- Investigate the extent to which the Anglo-Norman superseded the
Anglo-Saxon subsequent to the Conquest. Is any further change in the
grammatical structure of our language probable? If so, what do you
consider will be the nature of it?
- * * * *
PART III.
SOUNDS, LETTERS, PRONUNCIATION, SPELLING.
- * * * *
CHAPTER I.
GENERAL NATURE AND CERTAIN PROPERTIES OF ARTICULATE SOUNDS.
§ 105. To two points connected with the subject of the following chapter, the attention of the reader is requested.
a. In the comparison of sounds the ear is liable to be misled by the eye.
Thus--
The syllables ka and ga are similar syllables. The vowel is in each the same, and the consonant is but slightly different. Hence the words ka and ga are more allied to each other than the words ka and ba, ka and ta, &c., because the consonantal sounds of k and g are more allied than the consonantal sounds of k and b, k and t.
Comparing the syllables ga and ka, we see the affinity between the sounds, and we see it at the first glance. It lies on the surface, and strikes the ear at once.
It is, however, very evident that ways might be devised or might arise from accident, of concealing the likeness between the two sounds, or, at any rate, of making it less palpable. One of such ways would be a faulty mode of spelling. If instead of ga we wrote gha the following would be the effect: the syllable would appear less simple than it really was; it would look as if it consisted of three parts instead of two, and consequently its affinity to ka would seem less than it really was.
It is perfectly true that a little consideration would tell us that, as long as the sound remained the same, the relation of the two syllables remained the same also; and that, if the contrary appeared to be the case, the ear was misled by the eye. Still a little consideration would be required. Now in the English language we have (amongst others) the following modes of spelling that have a tendency to mislead;--
The sounds of ph and of f, in Philip and fillip, differ to the eye, but to the ear are identical. Here a difference is simulated.
The sounds of th in thin, and of th in thine, differ to the ear but to the eye seem the same. Here a difference is concealed.
Furthermore. These last sounds appear to the eye to be double or compound.
This is not the case; they are simple single sounds, and not the sounds of t followed by h, as the spelling leads us to imagine.
b. Besides improper modes of spelling, there is another way of concealing the true nature of sounds. If I say that ka and ga are allied, the alliance is manifest; since I compare the actual sounds. If I say ka and gee are allied, the alliance is concealed; since I compare, not the actual sounds, but only the names of the letters that express those sounds. Now in the English language we have (amongst others) the following names of letters that have a tendency to mislead:--
The sounds fa and va are allied. The names eff and vee conceal this alliance.
The sounds sa and za are allied. The names ess and zed conceal the alliance.
In comparing sounds it is advisable to have nothing to do either with letters or names of letters. Compare the sounds themselves.
§ 106. In many cases it is sufficient, in comparing consonants, to compare syllables that contain those consonants; e.g., in order to determine the relations of p, b, f, v, we say pa, ba, fa, va; or for those of s and z, we say sa, za. Here we compare syllables, each consonant being followed by a vowel. At times this is insufficient. We are often obliged to isolate the consonant from its vowel, and bring our organs to utter (or half utter) the imperfect sounds of p', b', t', d'.
§ 107. Let any of the vowels (for instance, the a in father) be sounded. The lips, the tongue, and the parts within the throat remain in the same position; and as long as these remain in the same position the sound is that of the vowel under consideration. Let, however, a change take place in the position of the organs of sound; let, for instance, the lips be closed, or the tongue be applied to the front part of the mouth: in that case the vowel sound is cut short. It undergoes a change.
It terminates in a sound that is different, according to the state of those organs whereof the position has been changed. If, on the vowel in question, the lips be closed, there then arises an imperfect sound of b or p. If on the other hand, the tongue be applied to the front teeth, or to the forepart of the palate, the sound is one (more or less imperfect) of t or d. This fact illustrates the difference between the vowels and the consonants. It may be verified by pronouncing the a in fate, ee in feet, oo in book, o in note, &c.
It is a further condition in the formation of a vowel sound, that the passage of the breath be uninterrupted. In the sound of the l' in lo (isolated from its vowel) the sound is as continuous as it is with the a in fate. Between, however, the consonant l and the vowel a there is this difference: with a, the passage of the breath is uninterrupted; with l, the tongue is applied to the palate, breaking or arresting the passage of the breath.
§ 108. The primary division of our articulate sounds is into vowels and consonants. The latter are again divided into liquids (l, m, n, r) and mutes (p, b, f, v, t, d, k, g, s, z, &c.).
§ 109. Sharp and flat.--Take the sounds of p, f, t, k, s. Isolate them from their vowels, and pronounce them. The sound is the sound of a whisper.
Let b, v, d, g, z, be similarly treated. The sound is no whisper, but one at the natural tone of our voice.
Now p, f, t, k, s (with some others that will be brought forward anon) are sharp, whilst b, v, &c., are flat. Instead of sharp, some say hard, and instead of flat, some say soft. The terms sonant and surd are, in a scientific point of view, the least exceptionable. They have, however, the disadvantage of being pedantic. The tenues of the classics (as far as they go) are sharp, the mediæ flat.
§ 110. Continuous and explosive.--Isolate the sounds of b, p, t, d, k, g.
Pronounce them. You have no power of prolonging the sounds, or of resting upon them. They escape with the breath, and they escape at once.
It is not so with f, v, sh, zh. Here the breath is transmitted by degrees, and the sound can be drawn out and prolonged for an indefinite space of time. Now b, p, t, &c., are explosive, f, v, &c., continuous.
§ 111. Concerning the vowels, we may predicate a) that they are all continuous, b) that they are all flat.
Concerning the liquids, we may predicate a) that they are all continuous, b) that they are all flat.
Concerning the mutes, we may predicate a) that one half of them is flat, and the other half sharp, and b) that some are continuous, and that others are explosive.
§ 112.--The letter h is no articulate sound, but only a breathing.
- * * * *
CHAPTER II.
SYSTEM OF ARTICULATE SOUNDS.
§ 113.--The attention of the reader is now directed to the following foreign vowel sounds.
- The é fermé, of the French.--This is a sound allied to, but different
from, the a in fate, and the ee in feet. It is intermediate to the two.
- The u of the French, ü of the Germans, y of the Danes.--This sound is
intermediate to the ee in feet, and the oo in book.
- The o chiuso, of the Italians.--Intermediate to the o in note, and
the oo in book.
For these sounds we have the following sequences: a in fate, é fermé, ee in feet, ü in übel (German), oo in book, o chiuso, o in note.
And this is the true order of alliance among the vowels; a in fate, and o in note, being the extremes; the other sounds being transitional or intermediate. As the English orthography is at once singular and faulty, it exhibits the relationship but imperfectly.
§ 114. The system of the mutes.--Preliminary to the consideration of the system of the mutes, let it be observed:--
- that the th in thin is a simple single sound, different from the
th in thine, and that it may be expressed by the sign þ.
- That the th in thine is a simple single sound, different from the
th in thin, and that it may be expressed by the sign ð.
- That the sh in shine is a simple single sound, and that it may be
expressed by the sign [sigma][42] (Greek [Greek: sigma]).
- That the z in azure, glazier (French j) is a simple single
sound, and that it may be expressed by the sign [zeta][42] (Greek
[Greek: zêta]).
- That in the Laplandic, and possibly in many other languages, there
are two peculiar sounds, different from any in English, German, and
French, &c., and that they may respectively be expressed by the sign
[kappa] and the sign [gamma][42] (Greek [Greek: kappa] and [Greek:
gamma]).
§ 115. With these preliminary notices we may exhibit the system of the sixteen mutes; having previously determined the meaning of two fresh terms, and bearing in mind what was said concerning the words sharp and flat, continuous and explosive.
Lene and aspirate.--From the sound of p in pat, the sound of f in fat differs in a certain degree. This difference is not owing to a difference in their sharpness or flatness. Each is sharp. Neither is it owing to a difference in their continuity or explosiveness; although f is continuous, whilst p is explosive. This we may ascertain by considering the position of s. The sound of s is continuous; yet s, in respect to the difference under consideration, is classed not with f the continuous sound but with p the explosive one.
This difference, which has yet to be properly elucidated, is expressed by a particular term; and p is called lene, f is called aspirate.
As f is to p so is v to b.
As v is to b so is þ to t.
As þ is to t so is ð to d.
As ð is to d so is [kappa] to k.
As [kappa] is to k so is [gamma] to g.
As [gamma] is to g so is [sigma] to s.
As [sigma] is to s so is [zeta] to z.
Hence p, b, t, d, k, g, s, z, are lene; f, v, þ, ð, [kappa], [gamma], [sigma], [zeta], are aspirate. Also p, f, t, þ, k, [kappa], s, [sigma], are sharp, whilst b, v, d, ð, g, [gamma], z, [zeta], are flat; so that there is a double series of relationship capable of being expressed as follows:--
Lene. Aspirate. | Sharp. Flat.
Sharp. Flat. Sharp. Flat. | Lene. Aspirate. Lene. Aspirate.
p b f v | p f b v
t d þ ð | t þ d ð
k g [kappa] [gamma] | k [kappa] g [gamma]
s z [sigma] [zeta] | s [sigma] z [zeta]
All the so-called aspirates are continuous; and, with the exception of s and z, all the lenes are explosive.
§ 116. I believe that in the fact of each mute appearing in a four-fold form (i.e., sharp, or flat, lene, or aspirate), lies the essential character of the mutes as opposed to the liquids.
§ 117. Y and w.--These sounds, respectively intermediate to [gamma] and i (the ee in feet), and to v and u (oo in book), form a transition from the vowels to the consonants.
§ 118. The French word roi, and the English words oil, house, are specimens of a fresh class of articulations; viz., of compound vowel sounds or diphthongs. The diphthong oi is the vowel o + the semivowel y.
The diphthongal sound in roi is the vowel o + the semivowel w. In roi the semivowel element precedes, in oil it follows.
§ 119. The words quoted indicate the nature of the diphthongal system.
- Diphthongs with the semivowel w, a) preceding, as in the French word
roi, b) following, as in the English word new.
- Diphthongs with the semivowel y, a) preceding, as is common in the
languages of the Lithuanic and Slavonic stocks, b) following, as in the word oil.
- Triphthongs with a semivowel both preceding and following.
The diphthongs in English are four; ow as in house, ew as in new, oi as in oil, i as in bite, fight.
§ 120. Chest, jest.--Here we have compound consonantal sounds. The ch in chest = t + sh; the j in jest = d + zh. I believe that in these combinations one or both the elements, viz., t and sh, d and zh, are modified; but I am unable to state the exact nature of this modification.
§ 121. Ng.--The sound of the ng in sing, king, throng, when at the end of a word, or of singer, ringing, &c., in the middle of a word, is not the natural sound of the combination n and g, each letter retaining its natural power and sound; but a simple single sound, for which the combination ng is a conventional mode of expression.
§ 122. Compared with a in fate, and the o in note, a in father, and the aw in bawl, are broad; the vowels of note and fate being slender.
§ 123. In fat, the vowel is, according to common parlance, short; in fate, it is long. Here we have the introduction of two fresh terms. For the words long and short, I substitute independent and dependent.
If from the word fate I separate the final consonantal sound, the syllable fa remains. In this syllable the a has precisely the sound that it had before. It remains unaltered. The removal of the consonant has in nowise modified its sound or power. It is not so, however, with the vowel in the word fat. If from this I remove the consonant following, and so leave the a at the end of the syllable, instead of in the middle, I must do one of two things: I must sound it either as the a in fate, or else as the a in father. Its (so-called) short sound it cannot retain, unless it be supported by a consonant following. For this reason it is dependent.
The same is the case with all the so-called short sounds, viz., the e in bed, i in fit, u in bull, o in not, u in but.
§ 124. It is not every vowel that is susceptible of every modification. I (ee) and u (oo) are incapable of becoming broad. The e in bed, although both broad and slender, is incapable of becoming independent. For the u in but, and for the ö of certain foreign languages, I have no satisfactory systematic position.
§ 125. Vowel System.
Broad. Slender.
Independent. || Independent. | Dependent.
a, in father || a, in fate | a, in fat.
|| é in fermé, | é, in fermé,
|| long | short.
e, in meine, Germ. || | e, in bed.
|| ee, in feet | i, pit.
|| ü, of the German, | the same, short.
|| long |
|| oo, in book | ou, in could.
|| o in chiuso | the same, short.
aw, in bawl || o, in note | o, in not.
From these the semivowels w and y make a transition to the consonants v and the so-called aspirate of g, respectively.
§ 126. System of Consonants.
Liquids. Mutes. Semivowels.
|| Lene. | Aspirate. ||
|| Sharp. Flat. | Sharp. Flat. ||
|| | ||
m || p v | f v || w
n || t d | þ ð || .
l || k g |[kappa] [gamma] || y
r || s z |[sigma] [zeta] || .
n is doubled in unnatural, innate, oneness.
l -- soulless, civil-list, palely.
k -- book-case.
t -- seaport-town.
It must not, however, be concealed, that, in the mouths even of correct speakers, one of the doubled sounds is often dropped.
§ 132. True aspirates rare.--The criticism applied to words like pitted, &c., applies also to words like Philip, thin, thine, &c.
There is therein no sound of h. How the so-called aspirates differ from their corresponding lenes has not yet been determined. That it is not by the addition of h is evident. Ph and th are conventional modes of spelling simple single sounds, which might better be expressed by simple single signs.
In our own language the true aspirates, like the true reduplications, are found only in compound words; and there they are often slurred in the pronunciation.
We find p and h in the words haphazard, upholder.
-- b and h -- abhorrent, cub-hunting.
-- f and h -- knife-handle, off hand.
-- v and h -- stave-head.
-- d and h -- adhesive, childhood.
-- t and h -- nuthook.
-- th and h -- withhold.
-- k and h -- inkhorn, bakehouse.
-- g and h -- gig-horse.
-- s and h -- race-horse, falsehood.
-- z and h -- exhibit, exhort.
-- r and h -- perhaps.
-- l and h -- wellhead, foolhardy.
-- m and h -- Amherst.
-- n and h -- unhinge, inherent, unhappy.
- * * * *
CHAPTER IV.
EUPHONY AND THE PERMUTATION OF LETTERS.
§ 133. 1. Let there be two syllables of which the one ends in m, and the other begins with r, as we have in the syllables num- and -rus of the Latin word numerus.
- Let an ejection of the intervening letters bring these two syllables
into immediate contact, numrus. The m and r form an unstable combination.
To remedy this there is a tendency to insert an intervening sound.
In English, the form which the Latin word numerus takes is number; in Spanish, nombre. The b makes no part of the original word, but has been inserted for the sake of euphony; or, to speak more properly, by a euphonic process. The word euphony is derived from [Greek: eu] (well), and [Greek: phônê] (fônæ, a voice).
§ 134. In the words give and gave we have a change of tense expressed by a change of vowel. In the words price and prize a change of meaning is expressed by a change of consonant. In clothe and clad there is a change both of a vowel and of a consonant. In the words to use and a use there is a similar change, although it is not expressed by the spelling. To the ear the verb to use ends in z, although not to the eye.
All these are instances of the permutation of letters.
Permutation of Vowels.
a to [)e], as man, men.
a to oo, as stand, stood.
a to u, as dare, durst.
a to [=e], as was, were.
ea to o, as speak, spoken.
ea = [)e] to ea = [=e], as breath, breathe.
ee to [)e], as deep, depth.
ea to o, as bear, bore.
i to a, as spin, span.
i to u, as spin, spun.
[=i] = ei to o, as smite, smote.
i = ei to [)i], as smite, smitten.
i to a, as give, gave.
i = ei to a, as rise, raise.
[)i] to e, as sit, set.
ow to ew, as blow, blew.
o to e, as strong, strength.
oo to ee, as tooth, teeth.
o to i, as top, tip.
o to e, as old, elder; tell, told.
[)o] to e, as brother, brethren.
[=o] = oo to i, as do, did.
o = oo to o = [)u], as do, done.
oo to o, as choose, chose.
Permutation of Consonants.
f to v, life, live; calf, calves.
þ to ð, breath, to breathe.
þ to d, seethe, sod; clothe, clad.
d to t, build, built.
s to z, use, to use.
s to r, was, were; lose, forlorn.
In have and had we have the ejection of a sound; in work and wrought, the transposition of one.
Permutation of Combinations.
ie = i to ow, as grind, ground.
ow to i = ei, as mouse, mice;
cow, kine.
ink to augh, as drink, draught.
ing to ough, as bring, brought.
y (formerly g), to ough, as buy, bought.
igh = ei to ough, as fight, fought.
eek to ough, as seek, sought.
It must be noticed that the list above is far from being an exhaustive one.
The expression too of the changes undergone has been rendered difficult on account of the imperfection of our orthography. The whole section has been written in illustration of the meaning of the word permutation, rather than for any specific object in grammar.
- * * * *
CHAPTER V.
ON THE FORMATION OF SYLLABLES.
§ 135. In respect to the formation of syllables, I am aware of no more than one point that requires any especial consideration.
In certain words, of more than one syllable, it is difficult to say to which syllable an intervening consonant belongs. For instance, does the v in river, and the e in fever, belong to the first or the second syllable? Are the words to be divided thus, ri-ver, fe-ver? or thus, riv-er, feve-r?
The solution of the question lies by no means on the surface.
In the first place, the case is capable of being viewed in two points of view--an etymological and a phonetic one.
That the c and r in become, berhymed, &c., belong to the second syllable, we determine at once by taking the words to pieces; whereby we get the words come and rhymed in an isolated independent form. But this fact, although it settles the point in etymology, leaves it as it was in phonetics; since it in nowise follows, that, because the c in the simple word come is exclusively attached to the letter that succeeds, it is, in the compound word become, exclusively attached to it also.
To the following point of structure in the consonantal sounds the reader's attention is particularly directed.
- Let the vowel a (as in fate) be sounded.--2. Let it be followed by the
consonant p, so as to form the syllable [=a]p. To form the sound of p, it will be found that the lips close on the sound of a, and arrest it. Now, if the lips be left to themselves they will not remain closed on the sound, but will open again; in a slight degree indeed, but in a degree sufficient to cause a kind of vibration, or, at any rate, to allow an escape of the remainder of the current of breath by which the sound was originally formed. To re-open in a slight degree is the natural tendency of the lips in the case exhibited above.
Now, by an effort, let this tendency to re-open be counteracted. Let the remaining current of breath be cut short. We have, then, only this, viz., so much of the syllable [=a]p as can be formed by the closure of the lips. All that portion of it that is caused by their re-opening is deficient. The resulting sound seems truncated, cut short, or incomplete.
It is the sound of p, minus the remnant of breath. All of the sound p that is now left is formed, not by the escape of the breath, but by the arrest of it.
The p in [=a]p is a final sound. With initial sounds the case is different. Let the lips be closed, and let an attempt be made to form the syllable pa by suddenly opening them. The sound appears incomplete; but its incompleteness is at the beginning of the sound, and not at the end of it. In the natural course of things there would have been a current of breath preceding, and this current would have given a vibration, now wanting. All the sound that is formed here is formed, not by the arrest of breath, but by the escape of it.
I feel that this account of the mechanism of the apparently simple sound p, labours under all the difficulties that attend the description of a sound; and for this reason I again request the reader to satisfy himself either of its truth or of its inaccuracy, before he proceeds to the conclusions that will be drawn from it.
The account, however, being recognized, we have in the sound of p, two elements:--
- That formed by the current of air and the closure of the lips, as in ap.
This may be called the sound of breath arrested.
- That formed by the current of air, and the opening of the lips, as in
pa. This may be called the sound of breath escaping.
Now what may be said of p may be said of all the other consonants, the words tongue, teeth, &c., being used instead of lips, according to the case.
Let the sound of breath arrested be expressed by [pi], and that of breath escaping be expressed by [varpi], the two together form p ([pi] + [varpi] = p).
Thus ap (as quoted above) is p - [varpi], or [pi]; whilst pa (sounded similarly) is p - [pi], or [varpi].
In the formation of syllables, I consider that the sound of breath arrested belongs to the first, and the sound of breath escaping to the second syllable; that if each sound were expressed by a separate sign, the word happy would be divided thus, ha[pi]-[varpi]y; and that such would be the case with all consonants between two syllables. The whole consonant belongs neither to one syllable nor the other. Half of it belongs to each.
The reduplication of the p in happy, the t in pitted, &c., is a mere point of spelling.
- * * * *
CHAPTER VI.
ON QUANTITY.
§ 136. The dependent vowels, as the a in fat, i in fit, u in but, o in not, have the character of being uttered with rapidity, and they pass quickly in the enunciation, the voice not resting on them. This rapidity of utterance becomes more evident when we contrast with them the prolonged sounds of the a in fate, ee in feet, oo in book, or o in note; wherein the utterance is retarded, and wherein the voice rests, delays, or is prolonged. The f and t of fate are separated by a longer interval than the f and t of fat; and the same is the case with fit, feet, &c.
Let the n and the t of not be each as 1, the o also being as 1; then each letter, consonant or vowel, shall constitute 1/3 of the whole word.
Let, however, the n and the t of note be each as 1, the o being as 2.
Then, instead of each consonant constituting 1/3 of the whole word, it shall constitute but ¼.
Upon the comparative extent to which the voice is prolonged, the division of vowels and syllables into long and short has been established: the o in note being long, the o in not being short. And the longness or shortness of a vowel or syllable is said to be its quantity.
§ 137. Attention is directed to the word vowel. The longness or shortness of a vowel is one thing. The longness or shortness of a syllable another. This difference is important in prosody; especially in comparing the English with the classical metres.
The vowel in the syllable see is long; and long it remains, whether it stand as it is, or be followed by a consonant, as in see-n, or by a vowel, as in see-ing.
The vowel in the word sit is short. If followed by a vowel it becomes unpronounceable, except as the ea in seat or the i in sight. By a consonant, however, it may be followed. Such is the case in the word quoted--sit. Followed by a second consonant, it still retains its shortness, e.g., sits. Whatever the comparative length of the syllables, see and seen, sit and sits, may be, the length of their respective vowels is the same.
Now, if we determine the character of the syllable by the character of the vowel, all syllables are short wherein there is a short vowel, and all are long wherein there is a long one. Hence, measured by the quantity of the vowel, the word sits is short, and the syllable see- in seeing is long.
§ 138. But it is well known that this view is not the view commonly taken of the syllables see (in seeing) and sits. It is well known, that, in the eyes of a classical scholar, the see (in seeing) is short, and that in the word sits the i is long.
The classic differs from the Englishman thus,--He measures his quantity, not by the length of the vowel, but by the length of the syllable taken altogether. The perception of this distinction enables us to comprehend the following statements.
a. That vowels long by nature may appear to become short by position, and vice versâ.
b. That, by a laxity of language, the vowel may be said to have changed its quantity, whilst it is the syllable alone that has been altered.
c. That if one person measures his quantities by the vowels, and another by the syllables, what is short to the one, shall be long to the other, and vice versâ. The same is the case with nations.
d. That one of the most essential differences between the English and the classical languages is that the quantities (as far as they go) of the first are measured by the vowel, those of the latter by the syllable. To a Roman the word monument consists of two short syllables and one long one; to an Englishman it contains three short syllables.
- * * * *
CHAPTER VII.
ON ACCENT.
§ 139. In the word tyrant there is an emphasis, or stress, upon the first syllable. In the word presume there is an emphasis, or stress, on the second syllable. This emphasis, or stress, is called accent. The circumstance of a syllable bearing an accent is sometimes expressed by a mark ('); in which case the word is said to be accentuated, i.e., to have the accent signified in writing.
Words accented on the last syllable--Brigáde, preténce, harpoón, reliéve, detér, assúme, besóught, beréft, befóre, abroád, abóde, abstrúse, intermíx, superádd, cavaliér.
Words accented on the last syllable but one--An'chor, ar'gue, hásten, fáther, fóxes, smíting, húsband, márket, vápour, bárefoot, archángel, bespátter, disáble, terrífic.
Words accented on the last syllable but two--Reg'ular, an'tidote, for'tify, suscéptible, incontrovértible.
Words accented on the last syllable but three (rare)--Réceptacle, régulating, tálkativeness, ábsolutely, lúminary, inévitable, &c.
§ 140. A great number of words are distinguished by the difference of accent alone.
An áttribute. To attríbute.
The month Aúgust. An augúst person.
A com'pact. Compáct (close).
To con'jure (magically). Conjúre (enjoin).
Des'ert, wilderness. Desért, merit.
Inválid, not valid. Invalíd, a sickly person.
Mínute, 60 seconds. Minúte, small.
Súpine, part of speech. Supíne, careless, &c.
§ 141. In týrant and presúme, we deal with single words; and in each word we determine which syllable is accented. Contrasted with the sort of accent that follows, this may be called a verbal accent.
In the line,
Better for us, perhaps, it might appear,
(Pope's "Essay on Man," I. 169.)
the pronoun us is strongly brought forward. An especial stress or emphasis is laid upon it, denoting that there are other beings to whom it might not appear, &c. This is collected from the context. Here there is a logical accent. "When one word in a sentence is distinguished by a stress, as more important than the rest, we may say that it is emphatical, or that an emphasis is laid upon it. When one syllable in a word is distinguished by a stress, and more audible than the rest, we say that it is accented, or that an accent is put upon it.
Accent, therefore, is to syllables what emphasis is to sentences; it distinguishes one from the crowd, and brings it forward to observation."--Nares' "Orthoepy," part ii. chap. 1.
- * * * *
CHAPTER VIII.
ORTHOGRAPHY.
§ 142. Orthoepy, a word derived from the Greek orthon (upright), and epos (a word), signifies the right utterance of words. Orthoepy determines words, and deals with a language as it is spoken; orthography determines the correct spelling of words, and deals with a language as it is written. This latter term is derived from the Greek words orthos (upright), and graphé, or grafæ (writing).
Orthography is less essential to language than orthoepy; since all languages are spoken, whilst but a few languages are written. Orthography presupposes orthoepy. Orthography addresses itself to the eye, orthoepy to the ear. Orthoepy deals with the articulate sounds that constitute syllables and words; orthography treats of the signs by which such articulate sounds are expressed in writing. A letter is the sign of an articulate (and, in the case of h, of an inarticulate) sound.
§ 143. A full and perfect system of orthography consists in two things:--1.
The possession of a sufficient and consistent alphabet. 2. The right application of such an alphabet. This position may be illustrated more fully.
§ 144. First, in respect to a sufficient and consistent alphabet--Let there be in a certain language, simple single articulate sounds, to the number of forty, whilst the simple single signs, or letters, expressive of them, amount to no more than thirty. In this case the alphabet is insufficient.
It is not full enough: since ten of the simple single articulate sounds have no corresponding signs whereby they may be expressed. In our own language, the sounds (amongst others) of th in thin, and of th in thine, are simple and single, whilst there is no sign equally simple and single to spell them with.
§ 145. An alphabet, however, may be sufficient, and yet imperfect. It may err on the score of inconsistency. Let there be in a given language two simple single sounds, (for instance) the p in pate, and the f in fate.
Let these sounds stand in a given relation to each other. Let a given sign, for instance, [Hebrew: P] (as is actually the case in Hebrew), stand for the p in pate; and let a second sign be required for the f in fate.
Concerning the nature of this latter sign, two views may be taken. One framer of the alphabet, perceiving that the two sounds are mere modifications of each other, may argue that no new sign (or letter) is at all necessary, but that the sound of f in fate may be expressed by a mere modification of the sign (or letter) [Hebrew: P], and may be written thus [Hebrew: P·], or thus [Hebrew: P'] or [Hebrew: P`], &c.; upon the principle that like sounds should be expressed by like signs. The other framer of the alphabet, contemplating the difference between the two sounds, rather than the likeness, may propose, not a mere modification of the sign [Hebrew:
P], but a letter altogether new, such as f, or [Greek: ph], &c., upon the principle that sounds of a given degree of dissimilitude should be expressed by signs of a different degree of dissimilitude.
Hitherto the expression of the sounds in point is a matter of convenience only. No question has been raised as to its consistency or inconsistency.
This begins under conditions like the following:--Let there be in the language in point the sounds of the t in tin, and of the th in thin; which (it may be remembered) are precisely in the same relation to each other as the p in pate and the f in fate. Let each of these sounds have a sign or letter expressive of it. Upon the nature of these signs, or letters, will depend the nature of the sign or letter required for the f in fate.
If the letter expressing the th in thin be a mere modification of the letter expressing the t in tin, then must the letter expressive of the f in fate be a mere modification of the letter expressing the p in pate, and vice versâ. If this be not the case, the alphabet is inconsistent.
In the English alphabet we have (amongst others) the following inconsistency:--The sound of the f in fate, in a certain relation to the sound of the p in pate, is expressed by a totally distinct sign; whereas, the sound of the th in thin (similarly related to the t in tin) is expressed by no new sign, but by a mere modification of t; viz., th.
§ 146. A third element in the faultiness of an alphabet is the fault of erroneous representation. The best illustration of this we get from the Hebrew alphabet, where the sounds of [Hebrew: T] and [Hebrew: T`], mere varieties of each other, are represented by distinct and dissimilar signs, whilst [Hebrew: T] and [Hebrew: T], sounds specifically distinct, are expressed by a mere modification of the same sign, or letter.
§ 147. The right application of an alphabet.--An alphabet may be both sufficient and consistent, accurate in its representation of the alliances between articulate sounds, and in no wise redundant; and yet, withal, it may be so wrongly applied as to be defective. Of defect in the use or application of the letters of an alphabet, the three main causes are the following:--
a. Unsteadiness in the power of letters.--Of this there are two kinds. In the first, there is one sound with two (or more) ways of expressing it.
Such is the sound of the letter f in English. In words of Anglo-Saxon origin it is spelt with a single simple sign, as in fill; whilst in Greek words it is denoted by a combination, as in Philip. The reverse of this takes place with the letter g; here a single sign has a double power; in gibbet it is sounded as j, and in gibberish as g in got.
b. The aim at secondary objects.--The natural aim of orthography, of spelling, or of writing, is to express the sounds of a language.
Syllables and words it takes as they meet the ear, it translates them by appropriate signs, and so paints them, as it were, to the eye. That this is the natural and primary object is self-evident; but beyond this natural and primary object there is, with the orthographical systems of most languages, a secondary one, viz., the attempt to combine with the representation of the sound of a given word, the representation of its history and origin.
The sound of the c, in city, is the sound that we naturally spell with the letter s, and if the expression of this sound was the only object of our orthographists, the word would be spelt accordingly (sity). The following facts, however, traverse this simple view of the matter. The word is a derived word; it is transplanted into our own language from the Latin, where it is spelt with a c (civitas); and to change this c into s conceals the origin and history of the word. For this reason the c is retained, although, as far as the mere expression of sounds (the primary object in orthography) is concerned, the letter is a superfluity.
In cases like the one adduced the orthography is bent to a secondary end, and is traversed by the etymology.
c. Obsoleteness.--It is very evident that modes of spelling which at one time may have been correct, may, by a change of pronunciation, become incorrect; so that orthography becomes obsolete whenever there takes place a change of speech without a correspondent change of spelling.
§ 148. From the foregoing sections we arrive at the theory of a full and perfect alphabet and orthography, of which a few (amongst many others) of the chief conditions are as follow:--
- That for every simple single sound, incapable of being represented by a
combination of letters, there be a simple single sign.
- That sounds within a determined degree of likeness be represented by
signs within a determined degree of likeness; whilst sounds beyond a certain degree of likeness be represented by distinct and different signs, and that uniformly.
- That no sound have more than one sign to express it.
- That no sign express more than one sound.
- That the primary aim of orthography be to express the sounds of words,
and not their histories.
- That changes of speech be followed by corresponding changes of spelling.
With these principles in our mind we may measure the imperfections of our own and of other alphabets.
§ 149. Previous to considering the sufficiency or insufficiency of the English alphabet, it is necessary to enumerate the elementary articulate sounds of the language. The vowels belonging to the English language are the following twelve:--
- That of a in father. 7. That of e -- bed.
- -- a -- fat. 8. -- i -- pit.
- -- a -- fate. 9. -- ee -- feet.
- -- aw -- bawl. 10. -- u -- bull.
- -- o -- not. 11. -- oo -- fool.
- -- o -- note. 12. -- u -- duck.
The diphthongal sounds are four.
- That of ou in house.
- -- ew -- new.
- -- oi -- oil.
- -- i -- bite.
This last sound being most incorrectly expressed by the single letter i.
The consonantal sounds are, 1. the two semivowels; 2. the four liquids; 3. fourteen out of the sixteen mutes; 4. ch in chest, and j in jest, compound sibilants; 5. ng, as in king; 6. the aspirate h. In all, twenty-four.
- w as in wet. 13. th as in thin.
- y -- yet. 14. th -- thine.
- m -- man. 15. g -- gun.
- n -- not. 16. k -- kind.
- l -- let. 17. s -- sin.
- r -- run. 18. z -- zeal.
- p -- pate. 19. sh -- shine.
- b -- ban. 20. z -- azure, glazier.
- f -- fan. 21. ch -- chest.
- v -- van. 22. j -- jest.
- t -- tin. 23. ng -- king.
- d -- din. 24. h -- hot.
§ 150. Some writers would add to these the additional sound of the é fermé of the French; believing that the vowel in words like their and vein has a different sound from the vowel in words like there and vain. For my own part I cannot detect such a difference either in my own speech or that of my neighbours; although I am far from denying that in certain dialects of our language such may have been the case.
The following is an extract from the "Danish Grammar for Englishmen," by Professor Rask, whose eye, in the matter in question, seems to have misled his ear; "The é fermé, or close é, is very frequent in Danish, but scarcely perceptible in English; unless in such words as their, vein, veil, which appear to sound a little different from there, vain, vale."
§ 151. The vowels being twelve, the diphthongs four, and the consonantal sounds twenty-four, we have altogether as many as forty sounds, some being so closely allied to each other as to be mere modifications, and others being combinations rather than simple sounds; all, however, agreeing in requiring to be expressed by letters or by combinations of letters, and to be distinguished from each other. This enables us to appreciate--
§ 152. The insufficiency of the English alphabet.--
a. In respect to the vowels.--Notwithstanding the fact that the sounds of the a in father, fate, and fat, and of the o and the aw in note, not, and bawl, are modifications of a and o respectively, we have still six vowel sounds specifically distinct, for which (y being a consonant rather than a vowel) we have but five signs. The u in duck, specifically distinct from the u in bull, has no specifically distinct sign to represent it.
b. In respect to the consonants.--The th in thin, the th in thine, the sh in shine, the z in azure, and the ng in king, five sounds specifically distinct, and five sounds perfectly simple require corresponding signs, which they have not.
§ 153. Its inconsistency.--The f in fan, and the v in van, sounds in a certain degree of relationship to p and b, are expressed by sounds as unlike as f is unlike p, and as v is unlike b. The sound of the th in thin, the th in thine, the sh in shine, similarly related to t, d, and s, are expressed by signs as like t, d, and s, respectively, as th and sh.
The compound sibilant sound of j in jest is spelt with the single sign j, whilst the compound sibilant sound in chest is spelt with the combination ch.
§ 154. Erroneousness.--The sound of the ee in feet is considered the long (independent) sound of the e in bed; whereas it is the long (independent) sound of the i in pit.
The i in bite is considered as the long (independent) sound of the i in pit; whereas it is a diphthongal sound.
The u in duck is looked upon as a modification of the u in bull; whereas it is a specifically distinct sound.
The ou in house and the oi in oil are looked upon as the compounds of o and i and of o and u respectively; whereas the latter element of them is not i and u, but y and w.
The th in thin and the th in thine are dealt with as one and the same sound; whereas they are sounds specifically distinct.
The ch in chest is dealt with as a modification of c (either with the power of k or of s); whereas its elements are t and sh.
§ 155. Redundancy.--As far as the representation of sounds is concerned the letter c is superfluous. In words like citizen it may be replaced by s; in words like cat by k. In ch, as in chest, it has no proper place.
In ch, as in mechanical, it may be replaced by k.
Q is superfluous, cw or kw being its equivalent.
X also is superfluous, ks, gz, or z, being equivalent to it.
The diphthongal forms æ and oe, as in Æneas and Croesus, except in the way of etymology, are superfluous and redundant.
§ 156. Unsteadiness.--Here we have (amongst many other examples), 1. The consonant c with the double power of s and k; 2. g with its sound in gun and also with its sound in gin; 3. x with its sounds in Alexander, apoplexy, Xenophon.
In the foregoing examples a single sign has a double power; in the words Philip and filip, &c.; a single sound has a double sign.
In respect to the degree wherein the English orthography is made subservient to etymology, it is sufficient to repeat the statement that as many as three letters c, æ, and oe are retained in the alphabet for etymological purposes only.
§ 157. The defects noticed in the preceding sections are absolute defects, and would exist, as they do at present, were there no language in the world except the English. This is not the case with those that are now about to be noticed; for them, indeed, the word defect is somewhat too strong a term. They may more properly be termed inconveniences.
Compared with the languages of the rest of the world the use of many letters in the English alphabet is singular. The letter i (when long or independent) is, with the exception of England, generally sounded as ee.
With Englishmen it has a diphthongal power. The inconvenience of this is the necessity that it imposes upon us, in studying foreign languages, of unlearning the sound which we give it in our own, and of learning the sound which it bears in the language studied. So it is (amongst many others) with the letter j. In English this has the sound of dzh, in French of zh, and in German of y. From singularity in the use of letters arises inconvenience in the study of foreign tongues.
In using j as dzh there is a second objection. It is not only inconvenient, but it is theoretically incorrect. The letter j was originally a modification of the vowel i. The Germans, who used it as the semivowel y, have perverted it from its original power less than the English have done, who sound it dzh.
With these views we may appreciate in the English alphabet and orthography--
Its convenience or inconvenience in respect to learning foreign tongues.--The sound given to the a in fate is singular. Other nations sound it as a in father.
The sound given to the e, long (or independent), is singular. Other nations sound it either as a in fate, or as é fermé.
The sound given to the i in bite is singular. Other nations sound it as ee in feet.
The sound given to the oo in fool is singular. Other nations sound it as the o in note, or as the ó chiuso.
The sound given to the u in duck is singular. Other nations sound it as the u in bull.
The sound given to the ou in house is singular. Other nations, more correctly, represent it by au or aw.
The sound given to the w in wet is somewhat singular, but is also correct and convenient. With many nations it is not found at all, whilst with those where it occurs it has the sound (there or thereabouts) of v.
The sound given to y is somewhat singular. In Danish it has a vowel power.
In German the semivowel sound is spelt with j.
The sound given to z is not the sound which it has in German and Italian, but its power in English is convenient and correct.
The sound given to ch in chest is singular. In other languages it has generally a guttural sound; in French that of sh. The English usage is more correct than the French, but less correct than the German.
The sound given to j (as said before) is singular.
§ 158. The historical propriety or impropriety of certain letters.--The use of i with a diphthongal power is not only singular and inconvenient, but also historically incorrect. The Greek iota, from whence it originates, has the sound of i and ee, as in pit and feet.
The y, sounded as in yet, is historically incorrect. It grew out of the Greek [upsilon], a vowel, and no semivowel. The Danes still use it as such, that is, with the power of the German ü.
The use of j for dzh is historically incorrect.
The use of c for k in words derived from the Greek as mechanical, ascetic, &c., is historically incorrect. The form c is the representative of [gamma] and [sigma] and not of the Greek kappa.
§ 159. On certain conventional modes of spelling.--In the Greek language the sounds of o in not and of o in note (although allied) are expressed by the unlike signs (or letters) [omicron] and [omega], respectively. In most other languages the difference between the sounds is considered too slight to require for its expression signs so distinct and dissimilar. In some languages the difference is neglected altogether. In many, however, it is expressed, and that by some modification of the original letter.
Let the sign (-) denote that the vowel over which it stands is long, or independent, whilst the sign (U) indicates shortness, or dependence. In such a case, instead of writing not and n[omega]t, like the Greeks, we may write n[)o]t and n[=o]t, the sign serving for a fresh letter.
Herein the expression of the nature of the sound is natural, because the natural use of (-) and (U) is to express length or shortness, dependence or independence. Now, supposing the broad sound of o to be already represented, it is very evident that, of the other two sounds of o, the one must be long (independent), and the other short (dependent); and as it is only necessary to express one of these conditions, we may, if we choose, use the sign (-) alone; its presence denoting length, and its absence shortness (independence or dependence).
As signs of this kind, one mark is as good as another; and instead of (-) we may, if we chose, substitute such a mark as (') and write nót = n[=o]t = n[omega]t = n[=o]te; provided only that the sign (') expresses no other condition or affection of a sound. This use of the mark ('), as a sign that the vowel over which it is placed is long (independent), is common in many languages. But is this use of (') natural?
For a reason that the reader has anticipated, it is not natural, but conventional. Neither is it convenient. It is used elsewhere not as the sign of quantity, but as the sign of accent; consequently, being placed over a letter, and being interpreted according to its natural meaning, it gives the idea, not that the syllable is long, but that it is emphatic or accented. Its use as a sign of quantity then, would be an orthographical expedient, or an inconvenient conventional mode of spelling.
The English language abounds in orthographical expedients; the modes of expressing the quantity of the vowels being particularly numerous. To begin with these:--
The reduplication of a vowel where there is but one syllable (as in feet, cool), is an orthographical expedient. It merely means that the syllable is long (or independent).
The juxtaposition of two different vowels, where there is but one syllable (as in plain, moan), is an orthographical expedient. It generally means the same as the reduplication of a vowel, i.e., that the syllable is long (independent).
The addition of the e mute, as in plane, whale (whatever may have been its origin), is, at present, but an orthographical expedient. It denotes the lengthening of the syllable.
The reduplication of the consonant after a vowel, as in spotted, torrent, is in most cases but an orthographical expedient. It merely denotes that the preceding vowel is short (dependent).
The use of ph for f in Philip, is an orthographical expedient, founded upon etymological reasons.
The use of th for the simple sound of the first consonant in thin and thine, is an orthographical expedient. The combination must be dealt with as a single letter.
Caution.--The letters x and q are not orthographical expedients. They are orthographical compendiums, x = ks, and q = kw.
- * * * *
CHAPTER IX.
HISTORICAL SKETCH OF THE ENGLISH ALPHABET.
§ 160. The preceding chapter has exhibited the theory of a full and perfect alphabet; it has shown how far the English alphabet falls short of such a standard; and, above all, it has exhibited some of the conventional modes of spelling which the insufficiency of alphabets, combined with other causes, has engendered. The present chapter gives a history of our alphabet, whereby many of its defects are accounted for. These defects, it may be said, once for all, the English alphabet shares with those of the rest of the world; although, with the doubtful exception of the French, it possesses them in a higher degree than any.
With few, if any exceptions, all the modes of writing in the world originate, directly or indirectly, from the Phoenician.
At a certain period the alphabet of Palestine, Phoenicia, and the neighboring languages of the Semitic tribes, consisted of twenty-two separate and distinct letters.
Now the chances are, that, let a language possess as few elementary articulate sounds as possible, an alphabet of only twenty-two letters will be insufficient.
Hence it may safely be asserted, that the original Semitic alphabet was insufficient for even the Semitic languages.
§ 161. In this state it was imported into Greece. Now, as it rarely happens that any two languages have precisely the same elementary articulate sounds, so it rarely happens that an alphabet can be transplanted from one tongue to another, and be found to suit. When such is the case, alterations are required. The extent to which these alterations are made at all, or (if made) made on a right principle varies with different languages. Some adapt an introduced alphabet well: others badly.
Of the twenty-two Phoenician letters the Greeks took but twenty-one.
The eighteenth letter, tsadi [Hebrew: TS] was never imported into Europe.
Compared with the Semitic, the Old Greek alphabet ran thus:--
Hebrew. Greek.
- [Hebrew: '] [Alpha].
- [Hebrew: B] [Beta].
- [Hebrew: G] [Gamma].
- [Hebrew: D] [Delta].
- [Hebrew: H] [Epsilon].
- [Hebrew: W] Digamma.
- [Hebrew: Z] [Zeta].
- [Hebrew: CH] [Eta].
- [Hebrew: T`] [Theta].
- [Hebrew: Y] [Iota].
- [Hebrew: K] [Kappa].
- [Hebrew: L] [Lambda].
- [Hebrew: M] [Mu].
- [Hebrew: N] [Nu].
- [Hebrew: S] [Sigma]?
- [Hebrew: `] [Omicron].
- [Hebrew: P] [Pi].
- [Hebrew: TS] --
A letter called
19. [Hebrew: Q] koppa, afterwards
ejected.
20. [Hebrew: R] [Rho].
21. [Hebrew: SH] M afterwards [Sigma]?
22. [Hebrew: T] [Tau].
The names of the letters were as follows:
Hebrew. Greek.
- Aleph Alpha.
- Beth Bæta.
- Gimel Gamma.
- Daleth Delta.
- He E, psilon.
- Vaw Digamma.
- Zayn Zæta.
- Heth Hæta.
- Teth Thæta.
- Yod Iôta.
- Kaph Kappa.
- Lamed Lambda.
- Mem Mu.
- Nun Nu.
- Samech Sigma?
- Ayn O.
- Pe Pi.
- Tsadi ----
- Kof Koppa, Archaic.
- Resh Rho.
- Sin San, Doric.
- Tau Tau.
The alphabet of Phoenicia and Palestine being adapted to the language of Greece, the first change took place in the manner of writing. The Phoenicians wrote from right to left; the Greeks from left to right.
Besides
Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence
The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.
Transcriber and production notes
Produced by Colin Bell, Keith Edkins and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images generously made available by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.) Transcriber's note: A few typographical errors have been corrected: they are listed at the end of the text.
Front matter as received (title page, contents)
[=a] signifies "a with macron"; [)e] "e with breve"; and so forth.
* * * * *
A HAND-BOOK
OF
THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE,
FOR THE USE OF
STUDENTS OF THE UNIVERSITIES AND
HIGHER CLASSES OF SCHOOLS.
BY
R. G. LATHAM, M.D., F.R.S.,
LATE PROFESSOR OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE,
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE, LONDON.
NEW-YORK: D. APPLETON & COMPANY, 443 & 445 BROADWAY. M.DCCC.LXIV.
* * * * *
CONTENTS.
* * * * *
PART I.
GENERAL ETHNOLOGICAL RELATIONS OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.
CHAPTER I.
GERMANIC ORIGIN OF THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE.--DATE.Header as received
The Project Gutenberg eBook of A Handbook of the English Language
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: A Handbook of the English Language
Author: R. G. Latham
Release date: March 29, 2009 [eBook #28436]
Most recently updated: January 4, 2021
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/28436
Credits: Produced by Colin Bell, Keith Edkins and the Online
Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net (This
file was produced from images generously made available
by The Internet Archive/American Libraries.)Full Project Gutenberg licence
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
States without permission and without paying copyright
royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
license, especially commercial redistribution.
START: FULL LICENSE
THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
www.gutenberg.org/license.
Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
electronic works
1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
you share it without charge with others.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
country other than the United States.
1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you
are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
beginning of this work.
1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
Gutenberg License.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
provided that:
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation.”
• You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
works.
• You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
receipt of the work.
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
forth in Section 3 below.
1.F.
1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
cannot be read by your equipment.
1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
DAMAGE.
1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
without further opportunities to fix the problem.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
remaining provisions.
1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
Defect you cause.
Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
from people in all walks of life.
Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
Literary Archive Foundation
Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
public support and donations to carry out its mission of
increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
status with the IRS.
The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
approach us with offers to donate.
International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
volunteer support.
Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
edition.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.
This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #28436. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.