Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay)
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 2751

Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay)

by Alexandre Dumas · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2004
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay) by Alexandre Dumas is an English public-domain text held from Project Gutenberg (ebook #2751). *THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK [An Essay]*

    "'NARRATIVE OF THE BIRTH AND EDUCATION OF THE UNFORTUNATE PRINCE WHO WAS

    SEPARATED FROM THE WORLD BY CARDINALS RICHELIEU AND MAZARIN AND

    IMPRISONED BY ORDER OF LOUIS XIV.

    "'Drawn up by the Governor of this Prince on his deathbed.

    "'The unfortunate prince whom I brought up and had in charge till almost the end of my life was born on the 5th September 1638 at 8.30 o'clock in the evening, while the king was at supper. His brother, who is now on the throne, was born at noon while the king was at dinner, but whereas his birth was splendid and public, that of his brother was sad and secret; for the king being informed by the midwife that the queen was about to give birth to a second child, ordered the chancellor, the midwife, the chief almoner, the queen's confessor, and myself to stay in her room to be witnesses of whatever happened, and of his course of action should a second child be born.

    "'For a long time already it had been foretold to the king that his wife would give birth to two sons, and some days before, certain shepherds had arrived in Paris, saying they were divinely inspired, so that it was said in Paris that if two dauphins were born it would be the greatest misfortune which could happen to the State.

    The Archbishop of Paris summoned these soothsayers before him, and ordered them to be imprisoned in Saint-Lazare, because the populace was becoming excited about them--a circumstance which filled the king with care, as he foresaw much trouble to his kingdom. What had been predicted by the soothsayers happened, whether they had really been warned by the constellations, or whether Providence by whom His Majesty had been warned of the calamities which might happen to France interposed.

    The king had sent a messenger to the cardinal to tell him of this prophecy, and the cardinal had replied that the matter, must be considered, that the birth of two dauphins was not impossible, and should such a case arrive, the second must be carefully hidden away, lest in the future desiring to be king he should fight against his brother in support of a new branch of the royal house, and come at last to reign.

    "'The king in his suspense felt very uncomfortable, and as the queen began to utter cries we feared a second confinement. We sent to inform the king, who was almost overcome by the thought that he was about to become the father of two dauphins. He said to the Bishop of Meaux, whom he had sent for to minister to the queen, "Do not quit my wife till she is safe; I am in mortal terror." Immediately after he summoned us all, the Bishop of Meaux, the chancellor M.

    Honorat, Dame Peronete the midwife, and myself, and said to us in presence of the queen, so that she could hear, that we would answer to him with our heads if we made known the birth of a second dauphin; that it was his will that the fact should remain a state secret, to prevent the misfortunes which would else happen, the Salic Law not having declared to whom the inheritance of the kingdom should come in case two eldest sons were born to any of the kings.

    "'What had been foretold happened: the queen, while the king was at supper, gave birth to a second dauphin, more dainty and more beautiful than the first, but who wept and wailed unceasingly, as if he regretted to take up that life in which he was afterwards to endure such suffering. The chancellor drew up the report of this wonderful birth, without parallel in our history; but His Majesty not being pleased with its form, burned it in our presence, and the chancellor had to write and rewrite till His Majesty was satisfied. The almoner remonstrated, saying it would be impossible to hide the birth of a prince, but the king returned that he had reasons of state for all he did.

    "'Afterwards the king made us register our oath, the chancellor signing it first, then the queen's confessor, and I last. The oath was also signed by the surgeon and midwife who attended on the queen, and the king attached this document to the report, taking both away with him, and I never heard any more of either.

    I remember that His Majesty consulted with the chancellor as to the form of the oath, and that he spoke for a long time in an undertone to the cardinal: after which the last-born child was given into the charge of the midwife, and as they were always afraid she would babble about his birth, she has told me that they often threatened her with death should she ever mention it: we were also forbidden to speak, even to each other, of the child whose birth we had witnessed.

    "'Not one of us has as yet violated his oath; for His Majesty dreaded nothing so much as a civil war brought about by the two children born together, and the cardinal, who afterwards got the care of the second child into his hands, kept that fear alive.

    The king also commanded us to examine the unfortunate prince minutely; he had a wart above the left elbow, a mole on the right side of his neck, and a tiny wart on his right thigh; for His Majesty was determined, and rightly so, that in case of the decease of the first-born, the royal infant whom he was entrusting to our care should take his place; wherefore he required our signmanual to the report of the birth, to which a small royal seal was attached in our presence, and we all signed it after His Majesty, according as he commanded.

    As to the shepherds who had foretold the double birth, never did I hear another word of them, but neither did I inquire. The cardinal who took the mysterious infant in charge probably got them out of the country.

    "'All through the infancy of the second prince Dame Peronete treated him as if he were her own child, giving out that his father was a great nobleman; for everyone saw by the care she lavished on him and the expense she went to, that although unacknowledged he was the cherished son of rich parents, and well cared for.

    "'When the prince began to grow up, Cardinal Mazarin, who succeeded Cardinal Richelieu in the charge of the prince's education, gave him into my hands to bring up in a manner worthy of a king's son, but in secret. Dame Peronete continued in his service till her death, and was very much attached to him, and he still more to her. The prince was instructed in my house in Burgundy, with all the care due to the son and brother of a king.

    "'I had several conversations with the queen mother during the troubles in France, and Her Majesty always seemed to fear that if the existence of the prince should be discovered during the lifetime of his brother, the young king, malcontents would make it a pretext for rebellion, because many medical men hold that the last-born of twins is in reality the elder, and if so, he was king by right, while many others have a different opinion.

    "'In spite of this dread, the queen could never bring herself to destroy the written evidence of his birth, because in case of the death of the young king she intended to have his twin-brother proclaimed. She told me often that the written proofs were in her strong box.

    "'I gave the ill-starred prince such an education as I should have liked to receive myself, and no acknowledged son of a king ever had a better.

    The only thing for which I have to reproach myself is that, without intending it, I caused him great unhappiness; for when he was nineteen years old he had a burning desire to know who he was, and as he saw that I was determined to be silent, growing more firm the more he tormented me with questions, he made up his mind henceforward to disguise his curiosity and to make me think that he believed himself a love-child of my own.

    He began to call me 'father,' although when we were alone I often assured him that he was mistaken; but at length I gave up combating this belief, which he perhaps only feigned to make me speak, and allowed him to think he was my son, contradicting him no more; but while he continued to dwell on this subject he was meantime making every effort to find out who he really was. Two years passed thus, when, through an unfortunate piece of forgetfulness on my part, for which I greatly blame myself, he became acquainted with the truth.

    He knew that the king had lately sent me several messengers, and once having carelessly forgotten to lock up a casket containing letters from the queen and the cardinals, he read part and divined the rest through his natural intelligence; and later confessed to me that he had carried off the letter which told most explicitly of his birth.

    "'I can recall that from this time on, his manner to me showed no longer that respect for me in which I had brought him up, but became hectoring and rude, and that I could not imagine the reason of the change, for I never found out that he had searched my papers, and he never revealed to me how he got at the casket, whether he was aided by some workmen whom he did not wish to betray, or had employed other means.

    "'One day, however, he unguardedly asked me to show him the portraits of the late and the present king. I answered that those that existed were so poor that I was waiting till better ones were taken before having them in my house.

    "'This answer, which did not satisfy him, called forth the request to be allowed to go to Dijon. I found out afterwards that he wanted to see a portrait of the king which was there, and to get to the court, which was just then at Saint-Jean-de-Luz, because of the approaching marriage with the infanta; so that he might compare himself with his brother and see if there were any resemblance between them. Having knowledge of his plan, I never let him out of my sight.

    "'The young prince was at this time as beautiful as Cupid, and through the intervention of Cupid himself he succeeded in getting hold of a portrait of his brother. One of the upper servants of the house, a young girl, had taken his fancy, and he lavished such caresses on her and inspired her with so much love, that although the whole household was strictly forbidden to give him anything without my permission, she procured him a portrait of the king.

    The unhappy prince saw the likeness at once, indeed no one could help seeing it, for the one portrait would serve equally well for either brother, and the sight produced such a fit of fury that he came to me crying out, "There is my brother, and this tells me who I am!" holding out a letter from Cardinal Mazarin which he had stolen from me, and making a great commotion in my house.

    "'The dread lest the prince should escape and succeed in appearing at the marriage of his brother made me so uneasy, that I sent off a messenger to the king to tell him that my casket had been opened, and asking for instructions. The king sent back word through the cardinal that we were both to be shut up till further orders, and that the prince was to be made to understand that the cause of our common misfortune was his absurd claim.

    I have since shared his prison, but I believe that a decree of release has arrived from my heavenly judge, and for my soul's health and for my ward's sake I make this declaration, that he may know what measures to take in order to put an end to his ignominious estate should the king die without children. Can any oath imposed under threats oblige one to be silent about such incredible events, which it is nevertheless necessary that posterity should know?'"

    Such were the contents of the historical document given by the regent to the princess, and it suggests a crowd of questions. Who was the prince's governor? Was he a Burgundian? Was he simply a landed proprietor, with some property and a country house in Burgundy? How far was his estate from Dijon? He must have been a man of note, for he enjoyed the most intimate confidence at the court of Louis XIII, either by virtue of his office or because he was a favourite of the king, the queen, and Cardinal Richelieu.

    Can we learn from the list of the nobles of Burgundy what member of their body disappeared from public life along with a young ward whom he had brought up in his own house just after the marriage of Louis XIV? Why did he not attach his signature to the declaration, which appears to be a hundred years old? Did he dictate it when so near death that he had not strength to sign it? How did it find its way out of prison? And so forth.

    There is no answer to all these questions, and I, for my part, cannot undertake to affirm that the document is genuine. Abbe Soulavie relates that he one day "pressed the marshal for an answer to some questions on the matter, asking, amongst other things, if it were not true that the prisoner was an elder brother of Louis XIV born without the knowledge of Louis XIII. The marshal appeared very much embarrassed, and although he did not entirely refuse to answer, what he said was not very explanatory.

    He averred that this important personage was neither the illegitimate brother of Louis XIV, nor the Duke of Monmouth, nor the Comte de Vermandois, nor the Duc de Beaufort, and so on, as so many writers had asserted." He called all their writings mere inventions, but added that almost every one of them had got hold of some true incidents, as for instance the order to kill the prisoner should he make himself known.

    Finally he acknowledged that he knew the state secret, and used the following words: "All that I can tell you, abbe, is, that when the prisoner died at the beginning of the century, at a very advanced age, he had ceased to be of such importance as when, at the beginning of his reign, Louis XIV shut him up for weighty reasons of state."

    The above was written down under the eyes of the marshal, and when Abbe Soulavie entreated him to say something further which, while not actually revealing the secret, would yet satisfy his questioner's curiosity, the marshal answered, "Read M. de Voltaire's latest writings on the subject, especially his concluding words, and reflect on them."

    With the exception of Dulaure, all the critics have treated Soulavie's narrative with the most profound contempt, and we must confess that if it was an invention it was a monstrous one, and that the concoction of the famous note in cipher was abominable.

    "Such was the great secret; in order to find it out, I had to allow myself 5, 12, 17, 15, 14, 1, three times by 8, 3." But unfortunately for those who would defend the morals of Mademoiselle de Valois, it would be difficult to traduce the character of herself, her lover, and her father, for what one knows of the trio justifies one in believing that the more infamous the conduct imputed to them, the more likely it is to be true.

    We cannot see the force of the objection that Louvois would not have written in the following terms to Saint-Mars in 1687 about a bastard son of Anne of Austria: "I see no objection to your removing Chevalier de Thezut from the prison in which he is confined, and putting your prisoner there till the one you are preparing for him is ready to receive him." And we cannot understand those who ask if Saint-Mars, following the example of the minister, would have said of a prince "Until he is installed in the prison which is being prepared for him here, which has a chapel adjoining"?

    Why should he have expressed himself otherwise? Does it evidence an abatement of consideration to call a prisoner a prisoner, and his prison a prison?

    A certain M. de Saint-Mihiel published an 8vo volume in 1791, at Strasbourg and Paris, entitled 'Le veritable homme, dit au MASQUE DE FER, ouvrage dans lequel on fait connaitre, sur preuves incontestables, a qui le celebre infortune dut le jour, quand et ou il naquit'. The wording of the title will give an idea of the bizarre and barbarous jargon in which the whole book is written. It would be difficult to imagine the vanity and self-satisfaction which inspire this new reader of riddles.

    If he had found the philosopher's stone, or made a discovery which would transform the world, he could not exhibit more pride and pleasure. All things considered, the "incontestable proofs" of his theory do not decide the question definitely, or place it above all attempts at refutation, any more than does the evidence on which the other theories which preceded and followed his rest. But what he lacks before all other things is the talent for arranging and using his materials.

    With the most ordinary skill he might have evolved a theory which would have defied criticism at least as successfully, as the others, and he might have supported it by proofs, which if not incontestable (for no one has produced such), had at least moral presumption in their favour, which has great weight in such a mysterious and obscure affair, in trying to explain, which one can never leave on one side, the respect shown by Louvois to the prisoner, to whom he always spoke standing and with uncovered head.

    According to M. de Saint-Mihiel, the 'Man in the Iron Mask was a legitimate son of Anne of Austria and Mazarin'.

    He avers that Mazarin was only a deacon, and not a priest, when he became cardinal, having never taken priest's orders, according to the testimony of the Princess Palatine, consort of Philip I, Duc d'Orleans, and that it was therefore possible for him to marry, and that he did marry, Anne of Austria in secret.

    "Old Madame Beauvais, principal woman of the bed-chamber to the queen mother, knew of this ridiculous marriage, and as the price of her secrecy obliged the queen to comply with all her whims. To this circumstance the principal bed-chamber women owe the extensive privileges accorded them ever since in this country" (Letter of the Duchesse d'Orleans, 13th September 1713).

    "The queen mother, consort of Louis XIII, had done worse than simply to fall in love with Mazarin, she had married him, for he had never been an ordained priest, he had only taken deacon's orders. If he had been a priest his marriage would have been impossible. He grew terribly tired of the good queen mother, and did not live happily with her, which was only what he deserved for making such a marriage" (Letter of the Duchesse d'Orleans, 2nd November 1717).

    "She (the queen mother) was quite easy in her conscience about Cardinal Mazarin; he was not in priest's orders, and so could marry. The secret passage by which he reached the queen's rooms every evening still exists in the Palais Royal" (Letter of the Duchesse d'Orleans, 2nd July 1719)

    "The queen's, manner of conducting affairs is influenced by the passion which dominates her. When she and the cardinal converse together, their ardent love for each other is betrayed by their looks and gestures; it is plain to see that when obliged to part for a time they do it with great reluctance. If what people say is true, that they are properly married, and that their union has been blessed by Pere Vincent the missioner, there is no harm in all that goes on between them, either in public or in private" ['Requete civile contre la Conclusion de la Paix, 1649).

    The Man in the Iron Mask told the apothecary in the Bastille that he thought he was about sixty years of age ['Questions sur d'Encyclopedie'). Thus he must have been born in 1644, just at the time when Anne of Austria was invested with the royal power, though it was really exercised by Mazarin.

    Can we find any incident recorded in history which lends support to the supposition that Anne of Austria had a son whose birth was kept as secret as her marriage to Mazarin?

    "In 1644, Anne of Austria being dissatisfied with her apartments in the Louvre, moved to the Palais Royal, which had been left to the king by Richelieu. Shortly after taking up residence there she was very ill with a severe attack of jaundice, which was caused, in the opinion of the doctors, by worry, anxiety, and overwork, and which pulled her down greatly" ['Memoire de Madame de Motteville, 4 vols. 12mo, Vol i. p. 194).

    "This anxiety, caused by the pressure of public business, was most probably only dwelt on as a pretext for a pretended attack of illness.

    Anne of Austria had no cause for worry and anxiety till 1649. She did not begin to complain of the despotism of Mazarin till towards the end of 1645" (Ibid., viol. i. pp. 272, 273).

    "She went frequently to the theatre during her first year of widowhood, but took care to hide herself from view in her box." (Ibid., vol. i. p. 342).

    Abbe Soulavie, in vol. vi. of the 'Memoires de Richelieu', published in 1793, controverted the opinions of M. de Saint-Mihiel, and again advanced those which he had published some time before, supporting them by a new array of reasons.

    The fruitlessness of research in the archives of the Bastille, and the importance of the political events which were happening, diverted the attention of the public for some years from this subject. In the year 1800, however, the 'Magazin encyclopedique' published (vol. vi. p. 472) an article entitled 'Memoires sur les Problemes historiques, et la methode de les resoudre appliquee a celui qui concerne l'Homme au Masque de Fer', signed C. D. O., in which the author maintained that the prisoner was the first minister of the Duke of Mantua, and says his name was Girolamo Magni.

    In the same year an octavo volume of 142 pages was produced by M.

    Roux-Fazillac. It bore the title 'Recherches historiques et critiques sur l'Homme au Masque de Fer, d'ou resultent des Notions certaines sur ce prisonnier'. These researches brought to light a secret correspondence relative to certain negotiations and intrigues, and to the abduction of a secretary of the Duke of Mantua whose name was Matthioli, and not Girolamo Magni.

    In 1802 an octavo pamphlet containing 11 pages, of which the author was perhaps Baron Lerviere, but which was signed Reth, was published. It took the form of a letter to General Jourdan, and was dated from Turin, and gave many details about Matthioli and his family. It was entitled 'Veritable Clef de l'Histoire de l'Homme au Masque de Fer'. It proved that the secretary of the Duke of Mantua was carried off, masked, and imprisoned, by order of Louis XIV in 1679, but it did not succeed in establishing as an undoubted fact that the secretary and the Man in the Iron Mask were one and the same person.

    It may be remembered that M. Crawfurd writing in 1798 had said in his 'Histoire de la Bastille' (8vo, 474 pages), "I cannot doubt that the Man in the Iron Mask was the son of Anne of Austria, but am unable to decide whether he was a twin-brother of Louis XIV or was born while the king and queen lived apart, or during her widowhood." M. Crawfurd, in his 'Melanges d'Histoire et de Litterature tires dun Portefeuille' (quarto 1809, octavo 1817), demolished the theory advanced by Roux-Fazillac.

    In 1825, M. Delort discovered in the archives several letters relating to Matthioli, and published his Histoire de l'Homme au Masque de Fer (8vo). This work was translated into English by George Agar-Ellis, and retranslated into French in 1830, under the title 'Histoire authentique du Prisonnier d'Etat, connu sons le Nom de Masque de Fer'. It is in this work that the suggestion is made that the captive was the second son of Oliver Cromwell.

    In 1826, M. de Taules wrote that, in his opinion, the masked prisoner was none other than the Armenian Patriarch. But six years later the great success of my drama at the Odeon converted nearly everyone to the version of which Soulavie was the chief exponent.

    The bibliophile Jacob is mistaken in asserting that I followed a tradition preserved in the family of the Duc de Choiseul; M. le Duc de Bassano sent me a copy made under his personal supervision of a document drawn up for Napoleon, containing the results of some researches made by his orders on the subject of the Man in the Iron Mask. The original MS., as well as that of the Memoires du Duc de Richelieu, were, the duke told me, kept at the Foreign Office. In 1834 the journal of the Institut historique published a letter from M.

    Auguste Billiard, who stated that he had also made a copy of this document for the late Comte de Montalivet, Home Secretary under the Empire.

    M. Dufey (de l'Yonne) gave his 'Histoire de la Bastille' to the world
    in the same year, and was inclined to believe that the prisoner was
    a son of Buckingham.

    Besides the many important personages on whom the famous mask had been placed, there was one whom everyone had forgotten, although his name had been put forward by the minister Chamillart: this was the celebrated Superintendent of Finance, Nicolas Fouquet. In 1837, Jacob, armed with documents and extracts, once more occupied himself with this Chinese puzzle on which so much ingenuity had been lavished, but of which no one had as yet got all the pieces into their places. Let us see if he succeeded better than his forerunners.

    The first feeling he awakes is one of surprise. It seems odd that he should again bring up the case of Fouquet, who was condemned to imprisonment for life in 1664, confined in Pignerol under the care of Saint-Mars, and whose death was announced (falsely according to Jacob) on March 23rd, 1680.

    The first thing to look for in trying to get at the true history of the Mask is a sufficient reason of state to account for the persistent concealment of the prisoner's features till his death; and next, an explanation of the respect shown him by Louvois, whose attitude towards him would have been extraordinary in any age, but was doubly so during the reign of Louis XIV, whose courtiers would have been the last persons in the world to render homage to the misfortunes of a man in disgrace with their master.

    Whatever the real motive of the king's anger against Fouquet may have been, whether Louis thought he arrogated to himself too much power, or aspired to rival his master in the hearts of some of the king's mistresses, or even presumed to raise his eyes higher still, was not the utter ruin, the lifelong captivity, of his enemy enough to satiate the vengeance of the king? What could he desire more? Why should his anger, which seemed slaked in 1664, burst forth into hotter flames seventeen years later, and lead him to inflict a new punishment?

    According to the bibliophile, the king being wearied by the continual petitions for pardon addressed to him by the superintendent's family, ordered them to be told that he was dead, to rid himself of their supplications. Colbert's hatred, says he, was the immediate cause of Fouquet's fall; but even if this hatred hastened the catastrophe, are we to suppose that it pursued the delinquent beyond the sentence, through the long years of captivity, and, renewing its energy, infected the minds of the king and his councillors?

    If that were so, how shall we explain the respect shown by Louvois? Colbert would not have stood uncovered before Fouquet in prison. Why should Colbert's colleague have done so?

    It must, however, be confessed that of all existing theories, this one, thanks to the unlimited learning and research of the bibliophile, has the greatest number of documents with the various interpretations thereof, the greatest profusion of dates, on its side.

    For it is certain--

    1st, that the precautions taken when Fouquet was sent to Pignerol resembled in every respect those employed later by the custodians of the Iron Mask, both at the Iles Sainte-Marguerite and at the Bastille;

    2nd, that the majority of the traditions relative to the masked prisoner might apply to Fouquet;

    3rd, that the Iron Mask was first heard of immediately after the announcement of the death of Fouquet in 1680;

    4th, that there exists no irrefragable proof that Fouquet's death really occurred in the above year.

    The decree of the Court of justice, dated 20th December 1664, banished Fouquet from the kingdom for life. "But the king was of the opinion that it would be dangerous to let the said Fouquet leave the country, in consideration of his intimate knowledge of the most important matters of state. Consequently the sentence of perpetual banishment was commuted into that of perpetual imprisonment." ['Receuil des defenses de M.

    Fouquet'). The instructions signed by the king and remitted to Saint-Mars forbid him to permit Fouquet to hold any spoken or written communication with anyone whatsoever, or to leave his apartments for any cause, not even for exercise. The great mistrust felt by Louvois pervades all his letters to Saint-Mars. The precautions which he ordered to be kept up were quite as stringent as in the case of the Iron Mask.

    The report of the discovery of a shirt covered with writing, by a friar, which Abbe Papon mentions, may perhaps be traced to the following extracts from two letters written by Louvois to Saint-Mars: "Your letter has come to hand with the new handkerchief on which M. Fouquet has written" (18th Dec. 1665 ); "You can tell him that if he continues too employ his table-linen as note-paper he must not be surprised if you refuse to supply him with any more" ( 21st Nov. 1667).

    Pere Papon asserts that a valet who served the masked prisoner died in his master's room. Now the man who waited on Fouquet, and who like him was sentenced to lifelong imprisonment, died in February 1680 (see letter of Louvois to Saint-Mars, 12th March 1680). Echoes of incidents which took place at Pignerol might have reached the Iles Sainte-Marguerite when Saint-Mars transferred his "former prisoner" from one fortress to the other. The fine clothes and linen, the books, all those luxuries in fact that were lavished on the masked prisoner, were not withheld from Fouquet. The furniture of a second room at Pignerol cost over 1200 livres (see letters of Louvois, 12th Dec.

    1665, and 22nd Feb, 1666).

    It is also known that until the year 1680 Saint-Mars had only two important prisoners at Pignerol, Fouquet and Lauzun. However, his "former prisoner of Pignerol," according to Du Junca's diary, must have reached the latter fortress before the end of August 1681, when Saint-Mars went to Exilles as governor. So that it was in the interval between the 23rd March 1680, the alleged date of Fouquet's death, and the 1st September 1681, that the Iron Mask appeared at Pignerol, and yet Saint-Mars took only two prisoners to Exilles.

    One of these was probably the Man in the Iron Mask; the other, who must have been Matthioli, died before the year 1687, for when Saint-Mars took over the governorship in the month of January of that year of the Iles Sainte-Marguerite he brought only ONE prisoner thither with him. "I have taken such good measures to guard my prisoner that I can answer to you for his safety" ['Lettres de Saint-Mars a Louvois', 20th January 1687).

    In the correspondence of Louvois with Saint-Mars we find, it is true, mention of the death of Fouquet on March 23rd, 1680, but in his later correspondence Louvois never says "the late M. Fouquet," but speaks of him, as usual, as "M. Fouquet" simply. Most historians have given as a fact that Fouquet was interred in the same vault as his father in the chapel of Saint-Francois de Sales in the convent church belonging to the Sisters of the Order of the Visitation-Sainte-Marie, founded in the beginning of the seventeenth century by Madame de Chantal.

    But proof to the contrary exists; for the subterranean portion of St. Francis's chapel was closed in 1786, the last person interred there being Adelaide Felicite Brulard, with whom ended the house of Sillery. The convent was shut up in 1790, and the church given over to the Protestants in 1802; who continued to respect the tombs. In 1836 the Cathedral chapter of Bourges claimed the remains of one of their archbishops buried there in the time of the Sisters of Sainte-Marie.

    On this occasion all the coffins were examined and all the inscriptions carefully copied, but the name of Nicolas Fouquet is absent.

    Voltaire says in his 'Dictionnaire philosophique', article "Ana," "It is most remarkable that no one knows where the celebrated Fouquet was buried."

    But in spite of all these coincidences, this carefully constructed theory was wrecked on the same point on which the theory that the prisoner was either the Duke of Monmouth or the Comte de Vermandois came to grief, viz. a letter from Barbezieux, dated 13th August 1691, in which occur the words, "THE PRISONER WHOM YOU HAVE HAD IN CHARGE FOR TWENTY YEARS." According to this testimony, which Jacob had successfully used against his predecessors, the prisoner referred to could not have been Fouquet, who completed his twenty-seventh year of captivity in 1691, if still alive.

    We have now impartially set before our readers all the opinions which have been held in regard to the solution of this formidable enigma. For ourselves, we hold the belief that the Man in the Iron Mask stood on the steps of the throne. Although the mystery cannot be said to be definitely cleared up, one thing stands out firmly established among the mass of conjecture we have collected together, and that is, that wherever the prisoner appeared he was ordered to wear a mask on pain of death.

    His features, therefore, might during half a century have brought about his recognition from one end of France to the other; consequently, during the same space of time there existed in France a face resembling the prisoner's known through all her provinces, even to her most secluded isle.

    Whose face could this be, if not that of Louis XVI, twin-brother of the Man in the Iron Mask?

    To nullify this simple and natural conclusion strong evidence will be required.

    Our task has been limited to that of an examining judge at a trial, and we feel sure that our readers will not be sorry that we have left them to choose amid all the conflicting explanations of the puzzle. No consistent narrative that we might have concocted would, it seems to us, have been half as interesting to them as to allow them to follow the devious paths opened up by those who entered on the search for the heart of the mystery. Everything connected with the masked prisoner arouses the most vivid curiosity. And what end had we in view? Was it not to denounce a crime and to brand the perpetrator thereof?

    The facts as they stand are sufficient for our object, and speak more eloquently than if used to adorn a tale or to prove an ingenious theory.

    ----

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay)
    Author
    Alexandre Dumas
    Release date
    September 22, 2004 [eBook #2751]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    Produced by David Widger
    Most recently updated
    November 28, 2016
    Transcriber and production notes
    Produced by David Widger.
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
                     *THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK [An Essay]*
    
                                      _By_
    
                            *Alexandre Dumas, Pere*
    
             _From the set of Eight Volumes of "Celebrated Crimes"_
    
    
                                      1910
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    
        *THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK [An Essay]*
    
    
    
    
    *THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK [An Essay]*
    
    
        (This is the essay entitled The Man in the Iron Mask, not the
                novel
        "The Man in the Iron Mask" [The Novel] Dumas
                #28[nmaskxxx.xxx]2759])
    
    For nearly one hundred years this curious problem has exercised the
    imagination of writers of fiction--and of drama, and the patience of the
    learned in history. No subject is more obscure and elusive, and none
    more attractive to the general mind. It is a legend to the meaning of
    which none can find the key and yet in which everyone believes.
    Involuntarily we feel pity at the thought of that long captivity
    surrounded by so many extraordinary precautions, and when we dwell on
    the mystery which enveloped the captive, that pity is not only deepened
    but a kind of terror takes possession of us. It is very likely that if
    the name of the hero of this gloomy tale had been known at the time, he
    would now be forgotten. To give him a name would be to relegate him at
    once to the ranks of those commonplace offenders who quickly exhaust our
    interest and our tears. But this being, cut off from the world without
    leaving any discoverable trace, and whose disappearance apparently
    caused no void--this captive, distinguished among captives by the
    unexampled nature of his punishment, a prison within a prison, as if the
    walls of a mere cell were not narrow enough, has come to typify for us
    the sum of all the human misery and suffering ever inflicted by unjust
    tyranny.
    
    Who was the Man in the Mask? Was he rapt away into this silent seclusion
    from the luxury of a court, from the intrigues of diplomacy, from the
    scaffold of a traitor, from the clash of battle? What did he leave
    behind? Love, glory, or a throne? What did he regret when hope had fled?
    Did he pour forth imprecations and curses on his tortures and blaspheme
    against high Heaven, or did he with a sigh possess his soul in patience?
    
    The blows of fortune are differently received according to the different
    characters of those on whom they fall; and each one of us who in
    imagination threads the subterranean passages leading to the cells of
    Pignerol and Exilles, and incarcerates himself in the Iles
    Sainte-Marguerite and in the Bastille, the successive scenes of that
    long-protracted agony will give the prisoner a form shaped by his own
    fancy and a grief proportioned to his own power of suffering. How we
    long to pierce the thoughts and feel the heart-beats and watch the
    trickling tears behind that machine-like exterior, that impassible mask!
    Our imagination is powerfully excited by the dumbness of that fate borne
    by one whose words never reached the outward air, whose thoughts could
    never be read on the hidden features; by the isolation of forty years
    secured by two-fold barriers of stone and iron, and she clothes the
    object of her contemplation in majestic splendour, connects the mystery
    which enveloped his existence with mighty interests, and persists in
    regarding the prisoner as sacrificed for the preservation of some
    dynastic secret involving the peace of the world and the stability of a
    throne.
    
    And when we calmly reflect on the whole case, do we feel that our first
    impulsively adopted opinion was wrong? Do we regard our belief as a
    poetical illusion? I do not think so; on the contrary, it seems to me
    that our good sense approves our fancy's flight. For what can be more
    natural than the conviction that the secret of the name, age, and
    features of the captive, which was so perseveringly kept through long
    years at the cost of so much care, was of vital importance to the
    Government? No ordinary human passion, such as anger, hate, or
    vengeance, has so dogged and enduring a character; we feel that the
    measures taken were not the expression of a love of cruelty, for even
    supposing that Louis XIV were the most cruel of princes, would he not
    have chosen one of the thousand methods of torture ready to his hand
    before inventing a new and strange one? Moreover, why did he voluntarily
    burden himself with the obligation of surrounding a prisoner with such
    numberless precautions and such sleepless vigilance? Must he not have
    feared that in spite of it all the walls behind which he concealed the
    dread mystery would one day let in the light? Was it not through his
    entire reign a source of unceasing anxiety? And yet he respected the
    life of the captive whom it was so difficult to hide, and the discovery
    of whose identity would have been so dangerous. It would have been so
    easy to bury the secret in an obscure grave, and yet the order was never
    given. Was this an expression of hate, anger, or any other passion?
    Certainly not; the conclusion we must come to in regard to the conduct
    of the king is that all the measures he took against the prisoner were
    dictated by purely political motives; that his conscience, while
    allowing him to do everything necessary to guard the secret, did not
    permit him to take the further step of putting an end to the days of an
    unfortunate man, who in all probability was guilty of no crime.
    
    Courtiers are seldom obsequious to the enemies of their master, so that
    we may regard the respect and consideration shown to the Man in the Mask
    by the governor Saint-Mars, and the minister Louvois, as a testimony,
    not only to his high rank, but also to his innocence.
    
    For my part, I make no pretensions to the erudition of the bookworm, and
    I cannot read the history of the Man in the Iron Mask without feeling my
    blood boil at the abominable abuse of power--the heinous crime of which
    he was the victim.
    
    A few years ago, M. Fournier and I, thinking the subject suitable for
    representation on the stage, undertook to read, before dramatising it,
    all the different versions of the affair which had been published up to
    that time. Since our piece was successfully performed at the Odeon two
    other versions have appeared: one was in the form of a letter addressed
    to the Historical Institute by M. Billiard, who upheld the conclusions
    arrived at by Soulavie, on whose narrative our play was founded; the
    other was a work by the bibliophile Jacob, who followed a new system of
    inquiry, and whose book displayed the results of deep research and
    extensive reading. It did not, however, cause me to change my opinion.
    Even had it been published before I had written my drama, I should still
    have adhered to the idea as to the most probable solution of the problem
    which I had arrived at in 1831, not only because it was incontestably
    the most dramatic, but also because it is supported by those moral
    presumptions which have such weight with us when considering a dark and
    doubtful question like the one before us. It will, be objected, perhaps,
    that dramatic writers, in their love of the marvellous and the pathetic,
    neglect logic and strain after effect, their aim being to obtain the
    applause of the gallery rather than the approbation of the learned. But
    to this it may be replied that the learned on their part sacrifice a
    great deal to their love of dates, more or less exact; to their desire
    to elucidate some point which had hitherto been considered obscure, and
    which their explanations do not always clear up; to the temptation to
    display their proficiency in the ingenious art of manipulating facts and
    figures culled from a dozen musty volumes into one consistent whole.
    
    Our interest in this strange case of imprisonment arises, not alone from
    its completeness and duration, but also from our uncertainty as to the
    motives from which it was inflicted. Where erudition alone cannot
    suffice; where bookworm after bookworm, disdaining the conjectures of
    his predecessors, comes forward with a new theory founded on some
    forgotten document he has hunted out, only to find himself in his turn
    pushed into oblivion by some follower in his track, we must turn for
    guidance to some other light than that of scholarship; especially if, on
    strict investigation, we find that not one learned solution rests on a
    sound basis of fact.
    
    In the question before us, which, as we said before, is a double one,
    asking not only who was the Man in the Iron Mask, but why he was
    relentlessly subjected to this torture till the moment of his death,
    what we need in order to restrain our fancy is mathematical
    demonstration, and not philosophical induction.
    
    While I do not go so far as to assert positively that Abbe Soulavie has
    once for all lifted the veil which hid the truth, I am yet persuaded
    that no other system of research is superior to his, and that no other
    suggested solution has so many presumptions in its favour. I have not
    reached this firm conviction on account of the great and prolonged
    success of our drama, but because of the ease with which all the
    opinions adverse to those of the abbe may be annihilated by pitting them
    one against the other.
    
    The qualities that make for success being quite different in a novel and
    in a drama, I could easily have founded a romance on the fictitious
    loves of Buckingham and the queen, or on a supposed secret marriage
    between her and Cardinal Mazarin, calling to my aid a work by
    Saint-Mihiel which the bibliophile declares he has never read, although
    it is assuredly neither rare nor difficult of access. I might also have
    merely expanded my drama, restoring to the personages therein their true
    names and relative positions, both of which the exigencies of the stage
    had sometimes obliged me to alter, and while allowing them to fill the
    same parts, making them act more in accordance with historical fact. No
    fable however far-fetched, no grouping of characters however improbable,
    can, however, destroy the interest which the innumerable writings about
    the Iron Mask excite, although no two agree in details, and although
    each author and each witness declares himself in possession of complete
    knowledge. No work, however mediocre, however worthless even, which has
    appeared on this subject has ever failed of success, not even, for
    example, the strange jumble of Chevalier de Mouhy, a kind of literary
    braggart, who was in the pay of Voltaire, and whose work was published
    anonymously in 1746 by Pierre de Hondt of The Hague. It is divided into
    six short parts, and bears the title, 'Le Masque de Fer, ou les
    Aventures admirables du Prre et du Fils'. An absurd romance by Regnault
    Warin, and one at least equally absurd by Madame Guenard, met with a
    like favourable reception. In writing for the theatre, an author must
    choose one view of a dramatic situation to the exclusion of all others,
    and in following out this central idea is obliged by the inexorable laws
    of logic to push aside everything that interferes with its development.
    A book, on the contrary, is written to be discussed; it brings under the
    notice of the reader all the evidence produced at a trial which has as
    yet not reached a definite conclusion, and which in the case before us
    will never reach it, unless, which is most improbable, some lucky chance
    should lead to some new discovery.
    
    The first mention of the prisoner is to be found in the 'Memoires
    secrets pour servir a l'Histoire de Perse' in one 12mo volume, by an
    anonymous author, published by the 'Compagnie des Libraires Associes
    d'Amsterdam' in 1745.
    
    "Not having any other purpose," says the author (page 20, 2nd edit.),
    "than to relate facts which are not known, or about which no one has
    written, or about which it is impossible to be silent, we refer at once
    to a fact which has hitherto almost escaped notice concerning Prince
    Giafer (Louis de Bourbon, Comte de Vermandois, son of Louis XIV and
    Mademoiselle de la Valliere), who was visited by Ali-Momajou (the Duc
    d'Orleans, the regent) in the fortress of Ispahan (the Bastille), in
    which he had been imprisoned for several years. This visit had probably
    no other motive than to make sure that this prince was really alive, he
    having been reputed dead of the plague for over thirty years, and his
    obsequies having been celebrated in presence of an entire army.
    
    "Cha-Abas (Louis XIV) had a legitimate son, Sephi-Mirza (Louis, Dauphin
    of France), and a natural son, Giafer. These two princes, as dissimilar
    in character as in birth, were always rivals and always at enmity with
    each other. One day Giafer so far forgot himself as to strike
    Sephi-Mirza. Cha-Abas having heard of the insult offered to the heir to
    the throne, assembled his most trusted councillors, and laid the conduct
    of the culprit before them--conduct which, according to the law of the
    country, was punishable with death, an opinion in which they all agreed.
    One of the councillors, however, sympathising more than the others with
    the distress of Cha-Abas, suggested that Giafer should be sent to the
    army, which was then on the frontiers of Feidrun (Flanders), and that
    his death from plague should be given out a few days after his arrival.
    Then, while the whole army was celebrating his obsequies, he should be
    carried off by night, in the greatest secrecy, to the stronghold on the
    isle of Ormus (Sainte-Marguerite), and there imprisoned for life.
    
    "This course was adopted, and carried out by faithful and discreet
    agents. The prince, whose premature death was mourned by the army, being
    carried by unfrequented roads to the isle of Ormus, was placed in the
    custody of the commandant of the island, who, had received orders
    beforehand not to allow any person whatever to see the prisoner. A
    single servant who was in possession of the secret was killed by the
    escort on the journey, and his face so disfigured by dagger thrusts that
    he could not be recognised.
    
    "The commandant treated his prisoner with the most profound respect; he
    waited on him at meals himself, taking the dishes from the cooks at the
    door of the apartment, none of whom ever looked on the face of Giafer.
    One day it occurred to the prince to scratch, his name on the back of a
    plate with his knife. One of the servants into whose hands the plate
    fell ran with it at once to the commandant, hoping he would be pleased
    and reward the bearer; but the unfortunate man was greatly mistaken, for
    he was at once made away with, that his knowledge of such an important
    secret might be buried with himself.
    
    "Giafer remained several years in the castle Ormus, and was then
    transported to the fortress of Ispahan; the commandant of Ormus having
    received the governorship of Ispahan as a reward for faithful service.
    
    "At Ispahan, as at Ormus, whenever it was necessary on account of
    illness or any other cause to allow anyone to approach the prince, he
    was always masked; and several trustworthy persons have asserted that
    they had seen the masked prisoner often, and had noticed that he used
    the familiar 'tu' when addressing the governor, while the latter showed
    his charge the greatest respect. As Giafer survived Cha-Abas and
    Sephi-Mirza by many years, it may be asked why he was never set at
    liberty; but it must be remembered it would have been impossible to
    restore a prince to his rank and dignities whose tomb actually existed,
    and of whose burial there were not only living witnesses but documentary
    proofs, the authenticity of which it would have been useless to deny, so
    firm was the belief, which has lasted down to the present day, that
    Giafer died of the plague in camp when with the army on the frontiers of
    Flanders. Ali-Homajou died shortly after the visit he paid to Giafer."
    
    This version of the story, which is the original source of all the
    controversy on the subject, was at first generally received as true. On
    a critical examination it fitted in very well with certain events which
    took place in the reign of Louis XIV.
    
    The Comte de Vermandois had in fact left the court for the camp very
    soon after his reappearance there, for he had been banished by the king
    from his presence some time before for having, in company with several
    young nobles, indulged in the most reprehensible excesses.
    
    "The king," says Mademoiselle de Montpensier ['Memoires de Mademoiselle
    de Montpensier', vol. xliii. p. 474., of 'Memoires Relatifs d'Histoire
    de France', Second Series, published by Petitot), "had not been
    satisfied with his conduct and refused to see him. The young prince had
    caused his mother much sorrow, but had been so well lectured that it was
    believed that he had at last turned over a new leaf." He only remained
    four days at court, reached the camp before Courtrai early in November
    1683, was taken ill on the evening of the 12th, and died on the 19th of
    the same month of a malignant fever. Mademoiselle de Montpensier says
    that the Comte de Vermandois "fell ill from drink."
    
    There are, of course, objections of all kinds to this theory.
    
    For if, during the four days the comte was at court, he had struck the
    dauphin, everyone would have heard of the monstrous crime, and yet it is
    nowhere spoken of, except in the 'Memoires de Perse'. What renders the
    story of the blow still more improbable is the difference in age between
    the two princes. The dauphin, who already had a son, the Duc de
    Bourgogne, more than a year old, was born the 1st November 1661, and was
    therefore six years older than the Comte de Vermandois. But the most
    complete answer to the tale is to be found in a letter written by
    Barbezieux to Saint-Mars, dated the 13th August 1691:--
    
    "When you have any information to send me relative to the prisoner who
    has been in your charge for twenty years, I most earnestly enjoin on you
    to take the same precautions as when you write to M. de Louvois."
    
    The Comte de Vermandois, the official registration of whose death bears
    the date 1685, cannot have been twenty years a prisoner in 1691.
    
    Six years after the Man in the Mask had been thus delivered over to the
    curiosity of the public, the 'Siecle de Louis XIV' (2 vols. octavo,
    Berlin, 1751) was published by Voltaire under the pseudonym of M. de
    Francheville. Everyone turned to this work, which had been long
    expected, for details relating to the mysterious prisoner about whom
    everyone was talking.
    
    Voltaire ventured at length to speak more openly of the prisoner than
    anyone had hitherto done, and to treat as a matter of history "an event
    long ignored by all historians." (vol. ii. p. 11, 1st edition, chap.
    xxv.). He assigned an approximate date to the beginning of this
    captivity, "some months after the death of Cardinal Mazarin" (1661); he
    gave a description of the prisoner, who according to him was "young and
    dark-complexioned; his figure was above the middle height and well
    proportioned; his features were exceedingly handsome, and his bearing
    was noble. When he spoke his voice inspired interest; he never
    complained of his lot, and gave no hint as to his rank." Nor was the
    mask forgotten: "The part which covered the chin was furnished with
    steel springs, which allowed the prisoner to eat without uncovering his
    face." And, lastly, he fixed the date of the death of the nameless
    captive; who "was buried," he says, "in 1704., by night, in the parish
    church of Saint-Paul."
    
    Voltaire's narrative coincided with the account given in the 'Memoires
    de Peyse', save for the omission of the incident which, according to the
    'Memoires', led in the first instance to the imprisonment of Giafer.
    "The prisoner," says Voltaire, "was sent to the Iles Sainte-Marguerite,
    and afterwards to the Bastille, in charge of a trusty official; he wore
    his mask on the journey, and his escort had orders to shoot him if he
    took it off. The Marquis de Louvois visited him while he was on the
    islands, and when speaking to him stood all the time in a respectful
    attitude. The prisoner was removed to the Bastille in 1690, where he was
    lodged as comfortably as could be managed in that building; he was
    supplied with everything he asked for, especially with the finest linen
    and the costliest lace, in both of which his taste was perfect; he had a
    guitar to play on, his table was excellent, and the governor rarely sat
    in his presence."
    
    Voltaire added a few further details which had been given him by M. de
    Bernaville, the successor of M. de Saint-Mars, and by an old physician
    of the Bastille who had attended the prisoner whenever his health
    required a doctor, but who had never seen his face, although he had
    "often seen his tongue and his body." He also asserted that M. de
    Chamillart was the last minister who was in the secret, and that when
    his son-in-law, Marshal de la Feuillade, besought him on his knees, de
    Chamillart being on his deathbed, to tell him the name of the Man in the
    Iron Mask, the minister replied that he was under a solemn oath never to
    reveal the secret, it being an affair of state. To all these details,
    which the marshal acknowledges to be correct, Voltaire adds a remarkable
    note: "What increases our wonder is, that when the unknown captive was
    sent to the Iles Sainte-Marguerite no personage of note disappeared from
    the European stage."
    
    The story of the Comte de Vermandois and the blow was treated as an
    absurd and romantic invention, which does not even attempt to keep
    within the bounds of the possible, by Baron C. (according to P.
    Marchand, Baron Crunyngen) in a letter inserted in the 'Bibliotheque
    raisonnee des Ouvrages des Savants de d'Europe', June 1745. The
    discussion was revived somewhat later, however, and a few Dutch scholars
    were supposed to be responsible for a new theory founded on history; the
    foundations proving somewhat shaky, however,--a quality which it shares,
    we must say, with all the other theories which have ever been advanced.
    
    According to this new theory, the masked prisoner was a young foreign
    nobleman, groom of the chambers to Anne of Austria, and the real father
    of Louis XIV. This anecdote appears first in a duodecimo volume printed
    by Pierre Marteau at Cologne in 1692, and which bears the title, 'The
    Loves of Anne of Austria, Consort of Louis XIII, with M. le C. D. R.,
    the Real Father of Louis XIV, King of France; being a Minute Account of
    the Measures taken to give an Heir to the Throne of France, the
    Influences at Work to bring this to pass, and the Denoument of the
    Comedy'.
    
    This libel ran through five editions, bearing date successively, 1692,
    1693, 1696, 1722, and 1738. In the title of the edition of 1696 the
    words "Cardinal de Richelieu" are inserted in place of the initials "C.
    D. R.," but that this is only a printer's error everyone who reads the
    work will perceive. Some have thought the three letters stood for Comte
    de Riviere, others for Comte de Rochefort, whose 'Memoires' compiled by
    Sandras de Courtilz supply these initials. The author of the book was an
    Orange writer in the pay of William III, and its object was, he says,
    "to unveil the great mystery of iniquity which hid the true origin of
    Louis XIV." He goes on to remark that "the knowledge of this fraud,
    although comparatively rare outside France, was widely spread within her
    borders. The well-known coldness of Louis XIII; the extraordinary birth
    of Louis-Dieudonne, so called because he was born in the twenty-third
    year of a childless marriage, and several other remarkable circumstances
    connected with the birth, all point clearly to a father other than the
    prince, who with great effrontery is passed off by his adherents as
    such. The famous barricades of Paris, and the organised revolt led by
    distinguished men against Louis XIV on his accession to the throne,
    proclaimed aloud the king's illegitimacy, so that it rang through the
    country; and as the accusation had reason on its side, hardly anyone
    doubted its truth."
    
    We give below a short abstract of the narrative, the plot of which is
    rather skilfully constructed:--
    
    "Cardinal Richelieu, looking with satisfied pride at the love of Gaston,
    Duc d'Orleans, brother of the king, for his niece Parisiatis (Madame de
    Combalet), formed the plan of uniting the young couple in marriage.
    Gaston taking the suggestion as an insult, struck the cardinal. Pere
    Joseph then tried to gain the cardinal's consent and that of his niece
    to an attempt to deprive Gaston of the throne, which the childless
    marriage of Louis XIII seemed to assure him. A young man, the C. D. R.
    of the book, was introduced into Anne of Austria's room, who though a
    wife in name had long been a widow in reality. She defended herself but
    feebly, and on seeing the cardinal next day said to him, 'Well, you have
    had your wicked will; but take good care, sir cardinal, that I may find
    above the mercy and goodness which you have tried by many pious
    sophistries to convince me is awaiting me. Watch over my soul, I charge
    you, for I have yielded!' The queen having given herself up to love for
    some time, the joyful news that she would soon become a mother began to
    spread over the kingdom. In this manner was born Louis XIV, the putative
    son of Louis XIII. If this instalment of the tale be favourably
    received, says the pamphleteer, the sequel will soon follow, in which
    the sad fate of C. D. R. will be related, who was made to pay dearly for
    his short-lived pleasure."
    
    Although the first part was a great success, the promised sequel never
    appeared. It must be admitted that such a story, though it never
    convinced a single person of the illegitimacy of Louis XIV, was an
    excellent prologue to the tale of the unfortunate lot of the Man in the
    Iron Mask, and increased the interest and curiosity with which that
    singular historical mystery was regarded. But the views of the Dutch
    scholars thus set forth met with little credence, and were soon
    forgotten in a new solution.
    
    The third historian to write about the prisoner of the Iles
    Sainte-Marguerite was Lagrange-Chancel. He was just twenty-nine years of
    age when, excited by Freron's hatred of Voltaire, he addressed a letter
    from his country place, Antoniat, in Perigord, to the 'Annee Litteraire'
    (vol. iii. p. 188), demolishing the theory advanced in the 'Siecle de
    Louis XIV', and giving facts which he had collected whilst himself
    imprisoned in the same place as the unknown prisoner twenty years later.
    
    "My detention in the Iles-Saint-Marguerite," says Lagrange-Chancel,"
    brought many things to my knowledge which a more painstaking historian
    than M. de Voltaire would have taken the trouble to find out; for at the
    time when I was taken to the islands the imprisonment of the Man in the
    Iron Mask was no longer regarded as a state secret. This extraordinary
    event, which M. de Voltaire places in 1662, a few months after the death
    of Cardinal Mazarin, did not take place till 1669, eight years after the
    death of His Eminence. M. de La Motte-Guerin, commandant of the islands
    in my time, assured me that the prisoner was the Duc de Beaufort, who
    was reported killed at the siege of Candia, but whose body had never
    been recovered, as all the narratives of that event agree in stating. He
    also told me that M. de Saint-Mars, who succeeded Pignerol as governor
    of the islands, showed great consideration for the prisoner, that he
    waited on him at table, that the service was of silver, and that the
    clothes supplied to the prisoner were as costly as he desired; that when
    he was ill and in need of a physician or surgeon, he was obliged under
    pain of death to wear his mask in their presence, but that when he was
    alone he was permitted to pull out the hairs of his beard with steel
    tweezers, which were kept bright and polished. I saw a pair of these
    which had been actually used for this purpose in the possession of M. de
    Formanoir, nephew of Saint-Mars, and lieutenant of a Free Company raised
    for the purpose of guarding the prisoners. Several persons told me that
    when Saint-Mars, who had been placed over the Bastille, conducted his
    charge thither, the latter was heard to say behind his iron mask, 'Has
    the king designs on my life?' To which Saint-Mars replied, 'No, my
    prince; your life is safe: you must only let yourself be guided.'
    
    "I also learned from a man called Dubuisson, cashier to the well-known
    Samuel Bernard, who, having been imprisoned for some years in the
    Bastile, was removed to the Iles Sainte-Marguerite, where he was
    confined along with some others in a room exactly over the one occupied
    by the unknown prisoner. He told me that they were able to communicate
    with him by means of the flue of the chimney, but on asking him why he
    persisted in not revealing his name and the cause of his imprisonment,
    he replied that such an avowal would be fatal not only to him but to
    those to whom he made it.
    
    "Whether it were so or not, to-day the name and rank of this political
    victim are secrets the preservation of which is no longer necessary to
    the State; and I have thought that to tell the public what I know would
    cut short the long chain of circumstances which everyone was forging
    according to his fancy, instigated thereto by an author whose gift of
    relating the most impossible events in such a manner as to make them
    seem true has won for all his writings such success--even for his Vie de
    Charles XII"
    
    This theory, according to Jacob, is more probable than any of the
    others.
    
    "Beginning with the year 1664.," he says, "the Duc de Beaufort had by
    his insubordination and levity endangered the success of several
    maritime expeditions. In October 1666 Louis XIV remonstrated with him
    with much tact, begging him to try to make himself more and more capable
    in the service of his king by cultivating the talents with which he was
    endowed, and ridding himself of the faults which spoilt his conduct. 'I
    do not doubt,' he concludes, 'that you will be all the more grateful to
    me for this mark of my benevolence towards you, when you reflect how few
    kings have ever shown their goodwill in a similar manner.'" ( 'Oeuvres
    de Louis XIV', vol. v. p. 388). Several calamities in the royal navy are
    known to have been brought about by the Duc de Beaufort. M. Eugene Sue,
    in his 'Histoire de la Marine', which is full of new and curious
    information, has drawn a very good picture of the position of the "roi
    des halles," the "king of the markets," in regard to Colbert and Louis
    XIV. Colbert wished to direct all the manoeuvres of the fleet from his
    study, while it was commanded by the naval grandmaster in the capricious
    manner which might be expected from his factious character and love of
    bluster (Eugene Sue, vol. i., 'Pieces Justificatives'). In 1699 Louis
    XIV sent the Duc de Beaufort to the relief of Candia, which the Turks
    were besieging. Seven hours after his arrival Beaufort was killed in a
    sortie. The Duc de Navailles, who shared with him the command of the
    French squadron, simply reported his death as follows: "He met a body of
    Turks who were pressing our troops hard: placing himself at the head of
    the latter, he fought valiantly, but at length his soldiers abandoned
    him, and we have not been able to learn his fate" ['Memoires du Duc de
    Navailles', book iv. P. 243)
    
    The report of his death spread rapidly through France and Italy;
    magnificent funeral services were held in Paris, Rome, and Venice, and
    funeral orations delivered. Nevertheless, many believed that he would
    one day reappear, as his body had never been recovered.
    
    Guy Patin mentions this belief, which he did not share, in two of his
    letters:--
    
    "Several wagers have been laid that M. de Beaufort is not dead! 'O
    utinam'!" (Guy Patin, September 26, 1669).
    
    "It is said that M. de Vivonne has been granted by commission the post
    of vice-admiral of France for twenty years; but there are many who
    believe that the Duc de Beaufort is not dead, but imprisoned in some
    Turkish island. Believe this who may, I don't; he is really dead, and
    the last thing I should desire would be to be as dead as he",(Ibid.,
    January 14, 1670).
    
    The following are the objections to this theory:
    
    "In several narratives written by eye-witnesses of the siege of Candia,"
    says Jacob, "it is related that the Turks, according to their custom,
    despoiled the body and cut off the head of the Duc de Beaufort on the
    field of battle, and that the latter was afterwards exhibited at
    Constantinople; and this may account for some of the details given by
    Sandras de Courtilz in his 'Memoires du Marquis de Montbrun' and his
    'Memoires d'Artagnan', for one can easily imagine that the naked,
    headless body might escape recognition. M. Eugene Sue, in his 'Histoire
    de la Marine' (vol. ii, chap. 6), had adopted this view, which coincides
    with the accounts left by Philibert de Jarry and the Marquis de Ville,
    the MSS. of whose letters and 'Memoires' are to be found in the
    Bibliotheque du Roi.
    
    "In the first volume of the 'Histoire de la Detention des Philosophes et
    des Gens de Lettres a la Bastille, etc.', we find the following
    passage:--
    
    "Without dwelling on the difficulty and danger of an abduction, which an
    Ottoman scimitar might any day during this memorable siege render
    unnecessary, we shall restrict ourselves to declaring positively that
    the correspondence of Saint-Mars from 1669 to 1680 gives us no ground
    for supposing that the governor of Pignerol had any great prisoner of
    state in his charge during that period of time, except Fouquet and
    Lauzun.'"
    
    While we profess no blind faith in the conclusions arrived at by the
    learned critic, we would yet add to the considerations on which he
    relies another, viz. that it is most improbable that Louis XIV should
    ever have considered it necessary to take such rigorous measures against
    the Duc de Beaufort. Truculent and self-confident as he was, he never
    acted against the royal authority in such a manner as to oblige the king
    to strike him down in secret; and it is difficult to believe that Louis
    XIV, peaceably seated on his throne, with all the enemies of his
    minority under his feet, should have revenged himself on the duke as an
    old Frondeur.
    
    The critic calls our attention to another fact also adverse to the
    theory under consideration. The Man in the Iron Mask loved fine linen
    and rich lace, he was reserved in character and possessed of extreme
    refinement, and none of this suits the portraits of the 'roi des halles'
    which contemporary historians have drawn.
    
    Regarding the anagram of the name Marchiali (the name under which the
    death of the prisoner was registered), 'hic amiral', as a proof, we
    cannot think that the gaolers of Pignerol amused themselves in
    propounding conundrums to exercise the keen intellect of their
    contemporaries; and moreover the same anagram would apply equally well
    to the Count of Vermandois, who was made admiral when only twenty-two
    months old. Abbe Papon, in his roamings through Provence, paid a visit
    to the prison in which the Iron Mask was confined, and thus speaks:--
    
    "It was to the Iles Sainte-Marguerite that the famous prisoner with the
    iron mask whose name has never been discovered, was transported at the
    end of the last century; very few of those attached to his service were
    allowed to speak to him. One day, as M. de Saint-Mars was conversing
    with him, standing outside his door, in a kind of corridor, so as to be
    able to see from a distance everyone who approached, the son of one of
    the governor's friends, hearing the voices, came up; Saint-Mars quickly
    closed the door of the room, and, rushing to meet the young man, asked
    him with an air of great anxiety if he had overheard anything that was
    said. Having convinced himself that he had heard nothing, the governor
    sent the young man away the same day, and wrote to the father that the
    adventure was like to have cost the son dear, and that he had sent him
    back to his home to prevent any further imprudence.
    
    "I was curious enough to visit the room in which the unfortunate man was
    imprisoned, on the 2nd of February 1778. It is lighted by one window to
    the north, overlooking the sea, about fifteen feet above the terrace
    where the sentries paced to and fro. This window was pierced through a
    very thick wall and the embrasure barricaded by three iron bars, thus
    separating the prisoner from the sentries by a distance of over two
    fathoms. I found an officer of the Free Company in the fortress who was
    nigh on fourscore years old; he told me that his father, who had
    belonged to the same Company, had often related to him how a friar had
    seen something white floating on the water under the prisoner's window.
    On being fished out and carried to M. de Saint-Mars, it proved to be a
    shirt of very fine material, loosely folded together, and covered with
    writing from end to end. M. de Saint-Mars spread it out and read a few
    words, then turning to the friar who had brought it he asked him in an
    embarrassed manner if he had been led by curiosity to read any of the,
    writing. The friar protested repeatedly that he had not read a line, but
    nevertheless he was found dead in bed two days later. This incident was
    told so often to my informant by his father and by the chaplain of the
    fort of that time that he regarded it as incontestably true. The
    following fact also appears to me to be equally well established by the
    testimony of many witnesses. I collected all the evidence I could on the
    spot, and also in the Lerins monastery, where the tradition is
    preserved.
    
    "A female attendant being wanted for the prisoner, a woman of the
    village of Mongin offered herself for the place, being under the
    impression that she would thus be able to make her children's fortune;
    but on being told that she would not only never be allowed to see her
    children again, but would be cut off from the rest of the world as well,
    she refused to be shut up with a prisoner whom it cost so much to serve.
    I may mention here that at the two outer angles of the wall of the fort
    which faced the sea two sentries were placed, with orders to fire on any
    boat which approached within a certain distance.
    
    "The prisoner's personal attendant died in the Iles Sainte-Marguerite.
    The brother of the officer whom I mentioned above was partly in the
    confidence of M. de Saint-Mars, and he often told how he was summoned to
    the prison once at midnight and ordered to remove a corpse, and that he
    carried it on his shoulders to the burial-place, feeling certain it was
    the prisoner who was dead; but it was only his servant, and it was then
    that an effort was made to supply his place by a female attendant."
    
    Abbe Papon gives some curious details, hitherto unknown to the public,
    but as he mentions no names his narrative cannot be considered as
    evidence. Voltaire never replied to Lagrange-Chancel, who died the same
    year in which his letter was published. Freron desiring to revenge
    himself for the scathing portrait which Voltaire had drawn of him in the
    'Ecossaise', called to his assistance a more redoubtable adversary than
    Lagrange-Chancel. Sainte-Foix had brought to the front a brand new
    theory, founded on a passage by Hume in an article in the 'Annee
    Litteraire (1768, vol. iv.), in which he maintained that the Man in the
    Iron Mask was the Duke of Monmouth, a natural son of Charles II, who was
    found guilty of high treason and beheaded in London on the 15th July
    1685.
    
    This is what the English historian says:
    
    "It was commonly reported in London that the Duke of Monmouth's life had
    been saved, one of his adherents who bore a striking resemblance to the
    duke having consented to die in his stead, while the real culprit was
    secretly carried off to France, there to undergo a lifelong
    imprisonment."
    
    The great affection which the English felt for the Duke of Monmouth, and
    his own conviction that the people only needed a leader to induce them
    to shake off the yoke of James II, led him to undertake an enterprise
    which might possibly have succeeded had it been carried out with
    prudence. He landed at Lyme, in Dorset, with only one hundred and twenty
    men; six thousand soon gathered round his standard; a few towns declared
    in his favour; he caused himself to be proclaimed king, affirming that
    he was born in wedlock, and that he possessed the proofs of the secret
    marriage of Charles II and Lucy Waiters, his mother. He met the
    Royalists on the battlefield, and victory seemed to be on his side, when
    just at the decisive moment his ammunition ran short. Lord Gray, who
    commanded the cavalry, beat a cowardly retreat, the unfortunate Monmouth
    was taken prisoner, brought to London, and beheaded.
    
    The details published in the 'Siecle de Louis XIV' as to the personal
    appearance of the masked prisoner might have been taken as a description
    of Monmouth, who possessed great physical beauty. Sainte-Foix had
    collected every scrap of evidence in favour of his solution of the
    mystery, making use even of the following passage from an anonymous
    romance called 'The Loves of Charles II and James II, Kings of
    England':--
    
    "The night of the pretended execution of the Duke of Monmouth, the king,
    attended by three men, came to the Tower and summoned the duke to his
    presence. A kind of loose cowl was thrown over his head, and he was put
    into a carriage, into which the king and his attendants also got, and
    was driven away."
    
    Sainte-Foix also referred to the alleged visit of Saunders, confessor to
    James II, paid to the Duchess of Portsmouth after the death of that
    monarch, when the duchess took occasion to say that she could never
    forgive King James for consenting to Monmouth's execution, in spite of
    the oath he had taken on the sacred elements at the deathbed of Charles
    II that he would never take his natural brother's life, even in case of
    rebellion. To this the priest replied quickly, "The king kept his oath."
    
    Hume also records this solemn oath, but we cannot say that all the
    historians agree on this point. 'The Universal History' by Guthrie and
    Gray, and the 'Histoire d'Angleterre' by Rapin, Thoyras and de Barrow,
    do not mention it.
    
    "Further," wrote Sainte-Foix, "an English surgeon called Nelaton, who
    frequented the Cafe Procope, much affected by men of letters, often
    related that during the time he was senior apprentice to a surgeon who
    lived near the Porte Saint-Antoine, he was once taken to the Bastille to
    bleed a prisoner. He was conducted to this prisoner's room by the
    governor himself, and found the patient suffering from violent headache.
    He spoke with an English accent, wore a gold-flowered dressing-gown of
    black and orange, and had his face covered by a napkin knotted behind
    his head."
    
    This story does not hold water: it would be difficult to form a mask out
    of a napkin; the Bastille had a resident surgeon of its own as well as a
    physician and apothecary; no one could gain access to a prisoner without
    a written order from a minister, even the Viaticum could only be
    introduced by the express permission of the lieutenant of police.
    
    This theory met at first with no objections, and seemed to be going to
    oust all the others, thanks, perhaps, to the combative and restive
    character of its promulgator, who bore criticism badly, and whom no one
    cared to incense, his sword being even more redoubtable than his pen.
    
    It was known that when Saint-Mars journeyed with his prisoner to the
    Bastille, they had put up on the way at Palteau, in Champagne, a
    property belonging to the governor. Freron therefore addressed himself
    to a grand-nephew of Saint-Mars, who had inherited this estate, asking
    if he could give him any information about this visit. The following
    reply appeared in the 'Annee Litteraire (June 1768):--
    
    "As it appears from the letter of M. de Sainte-Foix from which you quote
    that the Man in the Iron Mask still exercises the fancy of your
    journalists, I am willing to tell you all I know about the prisoner. He
    was known in the islands of Sainte-Marguerite and at the Bastille as 'La
    Tour.' The governor and all the other officials showed him great
    respect, and supplied him with everything he asked for that could be
    granted to a prisoner. He often took exercise in the yard of the prison,
    but never without his mask on. It was not till the 'Siecle' of M. de
    Voltaire appeared that I learned that the mask was of iron and furnished
    with springs; it may be that the circumstance was overlooked, but he
    never wore it except when taking the air, or when he had to appear
    before a stranger.
    
    "M. de Blainvilliers, an infantry officer who was acquainted with M. de
    Saint-Mars both at Pignerol and Sainte-Marguerite, has often told me
    that the lot of 'La Tour' greatly excited his curiosity, and that he had
    once borrowed the clothes and arms of a soldier whose turn it was to be
    sentry on the terrace under the prisoner's window at Sainte-Marguerite,
    and undertaken the duty himself; that he had seen the prisoner
    distinctly, without his mask; that his face was white, that he was tall
    and well proportioned, except that his ankles were too thick, and that
    his hair was white, although he appeared to be still in the prime of
    life. He passed the whole of the night in question pacing to and fro in
    his room. Blainvilliers added that he was always dressed in brown, that
    he had plenty of fine linen and books, that the governor and the other
    officers always stood uncovered in his presence till he gave them leave
    to cover and sit down, and that they often bore him company at table.
    
    "In 1698 M. de Saint-Mars was promoted from the governorship of the Iles
    Sainte-Marguerite to that of the Bastille. In moving thither,
    accompanied by his prisoner, he made his estate of Palteau a
    halting-place. The masked man arrived in a litter which preceded that of
    M. de Saint-Mars, and several mounted men rode beside it. The peasants
    were assembled to greet their liege lord. M. de Saint-Mars dined with
    his prisoner, who sat with his back to the dining-room windows, which
    looked out on the court. None of the peasants whom I have questioned
    were able to see whether the man kept his mask on while eating, but they
    all noticed that M. de Saint-Mars, who sat opposite to his charge, laid
    two pistols beside his plate; that only one footman waited at table, who
    went into the antechamber to change the plates and dishes, always
    carefully closing the dining-room door behind him. When the prisoner
    crossed the courtyard his face was covered with a black mask, but the
    peasants could see his lips and teeth, and remarked that he was tall,
    and had white hair. M. de Saint-Mars slept in a bed placed beside the
    prisoner's. M. de Blainvilliers told me also that 'as soon as he was
    dead, which happened in 1704, he was buried at Saint-Paul's,' and that
    'the coffin was filled with substances which would rapidly consume the
    body.' He added, 'I never heard that the masked man spoke with an
    English accent.'"
    
    Sainte-Foix proved the story related by M. de Blainvilliers to be little
    worthy of belief, showing by a circumstance mentioned in the letter that
    the imprisoned man could not be the Duc de Beaufort; witness the epigram
    of Madame de Choisy, "M. de Beaufort longs to bite and can't," whereas
    the peasants had seen the prisoner's teeth through his mask. It appeared
    as if the theory of Sainte-Foix were going to stand, when a Jesuit
    father, named Griffet, who was confessor at the Bastille, devoted
    chapter xiii, of his 'Traite des differentes Sortes de Preuves qui
    servent a etablir la Verite dans l'Histoire' (12mo, Liege, 1769) to the
    consideration of the Iron Mask. He was the first to quote an authentic
    document which certifies that the Man in the Iron Mask about whom there
    was so much disputing really existed. This was the written journal of M.
    du Jonca, King's Lieutenant in the Bastille in 1698, from which Pere
    Griffet took the following passage:--
    
    "On Thursday, September the 8th, 1698, at three o'clock in the
    afternoon, M. de Saint-Mars, the new governor of the Bastille, entered
    upon his duties. He arrived from the islands of Sainte-Marguerite,
    bringing with him in a litter a prisoner whose name is a secret, and
    whom he had had under his charge there, and at Pignerol. This prisoner,
    who was always masked, was at first placed in the Bassiniere tower,
    where he remained until the evening. At nine o'clock p.m. I took him to
    the third room of the Bertaudiere tower, which I had had already
    furnished before his arrival with all needful articles, having received
    orders to do so from M. de Saint-Mars. While I was showing him the way
    to his room, I was accompanied by M. Rosarges, who had also arrived
    along with M. de Saint-Mars, and whose office it was to wait on the said
    prisoner, whose table is to be supplied by the governor."
    
    Du Jonca's diary records the death of the prisoner in the following
    terms:--
    
    "Monday, 19th November 1703. The unknown prisoner, who always wore a
    black velvet mask, and whom M. de Saint-Mars brought with him from the
    Iles Sainte-Marguerite, and whom he had so long in charge, felt slightly
    unwell yesterday on coming back from mass. He died to-day at 10 p.m.
    without having a serious illness, indeed it could not have been
    slighter. M. Guiraut, our chaplain, confessed him yesterday, but as his
    death was quite unexpected he did not receive the last sacraments,
    although the chaplain was able to exhort him up to the moment of his
    death. He was buried on Tuesday the 20th November at 4 P.M. in the
    burial-ground of St. Paul's, our parish church. The funeral expenses
    amounted to 40 livres."
    
    His name and age were withheld from the priests of the parish. The entry
    made in the parish register, which Pere Griffet also gives, is in the
    following words:--
    
    "On the 19th November 1703, Marchiali, aged about forty-five, died in
    the Bastille, whose body was buried in the graveyard of Saint-Paul's,
    his parish, on the 20th instant, in the presence of M. Rosarges and of
    M. Reilh, Surgeon-Major of the Bastille.
    
    "(Signed) ROSARGES.
    
    "REILH."
    
    As soon as he was dead everything belonging to him, without exception,
    was burned; such as his linen, clothes, bed and bedding, rugs, chairs,
    and even the doors of the room he occupied. His service of plate was
    melted down, the walls of his room were scoured and whitewashed, the
    very floor was renewed, from fear of his having hidden a note under it,
    or left some mark by which he could be recognised.
    
    Pere Griffet did not agree with the opinions of either Lagrange-Chancel
    or Sainte-Foix, but seemed to incline towards the theory set forth in
    the 'Memoires de Perse', against which no irrefutable objections had
    been advanced. He concluded by saying that before arriving at any
    decision as to who the prisoner really was, it would be necessary to
    ascertain the exact date of his arrival at Pignerol.
    
    Sainte-Foix hastened to reply, upholding the soundness of the views he
    had advanced. He procured from Arras a copy of an entry in the registers
    of the Cathedral Chapter, stating that Louis XIV had written with his
    own hand to the said Chapter that they were to admit to burial the body
    of the Comte de Vermandois, who had died in the city of Courtrai; that
    he desired that the deceased should be interred in the centre of the
    choir, in the vault in which lay the remains of Elisabeth, Comtesse de
    Vermandois, wife of Philip of Alsace, Comte de Flanders, who had died in
    1182. It is not to be supposed that Louis XIV would have chosen a family
    vault in which to bury a log of wood.
    
    Sainte-Foix was, however, not acquainted with the letter of Barbezieux,
    dated the 13th August 1691, to which we have already referred, as a
    proof that the prisoner was not the Comte de Vermandois; it is equally a
    proof that he was not the Duke of Monmouth, as Sainte-Foix maintained;
    for sentence was passed on the Duke of Monmouth in 1685, so that it
    could not be of him either that Barbezieux wrote in 1691, "The prisoner
    whom you have had in charge for twenty years."
    
    In the very year in which Sainte-Foix began to flatter himself that his
    theory was successfully established, Baron Heiss brought a new one
    forward, in a letter dated "Phalsburg, 28th June 1770," and addressed to
    the 'Journal Enclycopedique'. It was accompanied by a letter translated
    from the Italian which appeared in the 'Histoire Abregee de l'Europe' by
    Jacques Bernard, published by Claude Jordan, Leyden, 1685-87, in
    detached sheets. This letter stated (August 1687, article 'Mantoue')
    that the Duke of Mantua being desirous to sell his capital, Casale, to
    the King of France, had been dissuaded therefrom by his secretary, and
    induced to join the other princes of Italy in their endeavours to thwart
    the ambitious schemes of Louis XVI. The Marquis d'Arcy, French
    ambassador to the court of Savoy, having been informed of the
    secretary's influence, distinguished him by all kinds of civilities,
    asked him frequently to table, and at last invited him to join a large
    hunting party two or three leagues outside Turin. They set out together,
    but at a short distance from the city were surrounded by a dozen
    horsemen, who carried off the secretary, 'disguised him, put a mask on
    him, and took him to Pignerol.' He was not kept long in this fortress,
    as it was 'too near the Italian frontier, and although he was carefully
    guarded it was feared that the walls would speak'; so he was transferred
    to the Iles Sainte-Marguerite, where he is at present in the custody of
    M. de Saint-Mars.
    
    This theory, of which much was heard later, did not at first excite much
    attention. What is certain is that the Duke of Mantua's secretary, by
    name Matthioli, was arrested in 1679 through the agency of Abbe
    d'Estrade and M. de Catinat, and taken with the utmost secrecy to
    Pignerol, where he was imprisoned and placed in charge of M. de
    Saint-Mars. He must not, however, be confounded with the Man in the Iron
    Mask.
    
    Catinat says of Matthioli in a letter to Louvois "No one knows the name
    of this knave."
    
    Louvois writes to Saint-Mars: "I admire your patience in waiting for an
    order to treat such a rogue as he deserves, when he treats you with
    disrespect."
    
    Saint-Mars replies to the minister: "I have charged Blainvilliers to
    show him a cudgel and tell him that with its aid we can make the froward
    meek."
    
    Again Louvois writes: "The clothes of such people must be made to last
    three or four years."
    
    This cannot have been the nameless prisoner who was treated with such
    consideration, before whom Louvois stood bare-headed, who was supplied
    with fine linen and lace, and so on.
    
    Altogether, we gather from the correspondence of Saint-Mars that the
    unhappy man alluded to above was confined along with a mad Jacobin, and
    at last became mad himself, and succumbed to his misery in 1686.
    
    Voltaire, who was probably the first to supply such inexhaustible food
    for controversy, kept silence and took no part in the discussions. But
    when all the theories had been presented to the public, he set about
    refuting them. He made himself very merry, in the seventh edition of
    'Questions sur l'Encyclopedie distibuees en forme de Dictionnaire
    (Geneva, 1791), over the complaisance attributed to Louis XIV in acting
    as police-sergeant and gaoler for James II, William III, and Anne, with
    all of whom he was at war. Persisting still in taking 1661 or 1662 as
    the date when the incarceration of the masked prisoner began, he attacks
    the opinions advanced by Lagrange-Chancel and Pere Griffet, which they
    had drawn from the anonymous 'Memoires secrets pour servir a l'Histoire
    de Perse'. "Having thus dissipated all these illusions," he says, "let
    us now consider who the masked prisoner was, and how old he was when he
    died. It is evident that if he was never allowed to walk in the
    courtyard of the Bastille or to see a physician without his mask, it
    must have been lest his too striking resemblance to someone should be
    remarked; he could show his tongue but not his face. As regards his age,
    he himself told the apothecary at the Bastille, a few days before his
    death, that he thought he was about sixty; this I have often heard from
    a son-in-law to this apothecary, M. Marsoban, surgeon to Marshal
    Richelieu, and afterwards to the regent, the Duc d'Orleans. The writer
    of this article knows perhaps more on this subject than Pere Griffet.
    But he has said his say."
    
    This article in the 'Questions on the Encyclopaedia' was followed by
    some remarks from the pen of the publisher, which are also, however,
    attributed by the publishers of Kelh to Voltaire himself. The publisher,
    who sometimes calls himself the author, puts aside without refutation
    all the theories advanced, including that of Baron Heiss, and says he
    has come to the conclusion that the Iron Mask was, without doubt, a
    brother and an elder brother of Louis XIV, by a lover of the queen. Anne
    of Austria had come to persuade herself that hers alone was the fault
    which had deprived Louis XIII [the publisher of this edition overlooked
    the obvious typographical error of "XIV" here when he meant, and it only
    makes sense, that it was XIII. D.W.] of an heir, but the birth of the
    Iron Mask undeceived her. The cardinal, to whom she confided her secret,
    cleverly arranged to bring the king and queen, who had long lived apart,
    together again. A second son was the result of this reconciliation; and
    the first child being removed in secret, Louis XIV remained in ignorance
    of the existence of his half-brother till after his majority. It was the
    policy of Louis XIV to affect a great respect for the royal house, so he
    avoided much embarrassment to himself and a scandal affecting the memory
    of Anne of Austria by adopting the wise and just measure of burying
    alive the pledge of an adulterous love. He was thus enabled to avoid
    committing an act of cruelty, which a sovereign less conscientious and
    less magnanimous would have considered a necessity.
    
    After this declaration Voltaire made no further reference to the Iron
    Mask. This last version of the story upset that of Sainte-Foix. Voltaire
    having been initiated into the state secret by the Marquis de Richelieu,
    we may be permitted to suspect that being naturally indiscreet he
    published the truth from behind the shelter of a pseudonym, or at least
    gave a version which approached the truth, but later on realising the
    dangerous significance of his words, he preserved for the future
    complete silence.
    
    We now approach the question whether the prince who thus became the Iron
    Mask was an illegitimate brother or a twin-brother of Louis XIV. The
    first was maintained by M. Quentin-Crawfurd; the second by Abbe Soulavie
    in his 'Memoires du Marechal Duc de Richelieu' (London, 1790). In 1783
    the Marquis de Luchet, in the 'Journal des Gens du Monde' (vol. iv. No.
    23, p. 282, et seq.), awarded to Buckingham the honour of the paternity
    in dispute. In support of this, he quoted the testimony of a lady of the
    house of Saint-Quentin who had been a mistress of the minister
    Barbezieux, and who died at Chartres about the middle of the eighteenth
    century. She had declared publicly that Louis XIV had consigned his
    elder brother to perpetual imprisonment, and that the mask was
    necessitated by the close resemblance of the two brothers to each other.
    
    The Duke of Buckingham, who came to France in 1625, in order to escort
    Henrietta Maria, sister of Louis XIII, to England, where she was to
    marry the Prince of Wales, made no secret of his ardent love for the
    queen, and it is almost certain that she was not insensible to his
    passion. An anonymous pamphlet, 'La Conference du Cardinal Mazarin avec
    le Gazetier' (Brussels, 1649), says that she was infatuated about him,
    and allowed him to visit her in her room. She even permitted him to take
    off and keep one of her gloves, and his vanity leading him to show his
    spoil, the king heard of it, and was vastly offended. An anecdote, the
    truth of which no one has ever denied, relates that one day Buckingham
    spoke to the queen with such passion in the presence of her
    lady-in-waiting, the Marquise de Senecey, that the latter exclaimed, "Be
    silent, sir, you cannot speak thus to the Queen of France!" According to
    this version, the Man in the Iron Mask must have been born at latest in
    1637, but the mention of any such date would destroy the possibility of
    Buckingham's paternity; for he was assassinated at Portsmouth on
    September 2nd, 1628.
    
    After the taking of the Bastille the masked prisoner became the
    fashionable topic of discussion, and one heard of nothing else. On the
    13th of August 1789 it was announced in an article in a journal called
    'Loisirs d'un Patriote francais', which was afterwards published
    anonymously as a pamphlet, that the publisher had seen, among other
    documents found in the Bastille, a card bearing the unintelligible
    number "64389000," and the following note: "Fouquet, arriving from Les
    Iles Sainte-Marguerite in an iron mask." To this there was, it was said,
    a double signature, viz. "XXX," superimposed on the name "Kersadion."
    The journalist was of opinion that Fouquet had succeeded in making his
    escape, but had been retaken and condemned to pass for dead, and to wear
    a mask henceforward, as a punishment for his attempted evasion. This
    tale made some impression, for it was remembered that in the Supplement
    to the 'Siecle de Louis XIV' it was stated that Chamillart had said that
    "the Iron Mask was a man who knew all the secrets of M. Fouquet." But
    the existence of this card was never proved, and we cannot accept the
    story on the unsupported word of an anonymous writer.
    
    From the time that restrictions on the press were removed, hardly a day
    passed without the appearance of some new pamphlet on the Iron Mask.
    Louis Dutens, in 'Correspondence interceptee' (12mo, 1789), revived the
    theory of Baron Heiss, supporting it by new and curious facts. He proved
    that Louis XIV had really ordered one of the Duke of Mantua's ministers
    to be carried off and imprisoned in Pignerol. Dutens gave the name of
    the victim as Girolamo Magni. He also quoted from a memorandum which by
    the wish of the Marquis de Castellane was drawn up by a certain Souchon,
    probably the man whom Papon questioned in 1778. This Souchon was the son
    of a man who had belonged to the Free Company maintained in the islands
    in the time of Saint-Mars, and was seventy-nine years old. This
    memorandum gives a detailed account of the abduction of a minister in
    1679, who is styled a "minister of the Empire," and his arrival as a
    masked prisoner at the islands, and states that he died there in
    captivity nine years after he was carried off.
    
    Dutens thus divests the episode of the element of the marvellous with
    which Voltaire had surrounded it. He called to his aid the testimony of
    the Duc de Choiseul, who, having in vain attempted to worm the secret of
    the Iron Mask out of Louis XV, begged Madame de Pompadour to try her
    hand, and was told by her that the prisoner was the minister of an
    Italian prince. At the same time that Dutens wrote, "There is no fact in
    history better established than the fact that the Man in the Iron Mask
    was a minister of the Duke of Mantua who was carried off from Turin," M.
    Quentin-Crawfurd was maintaining that the prisoner was a son of Anne of
    Austria; while a few years earlier Bouche, a lawyer, in his 'Essai sur
    l'Histoire de Provence' (2 vols. 4to, 1785), had regarded this story as
    a fable invented by Voltaire, and had convinced himself that the
    prisoner was a woman. As we see, discussion threw no light on the
    subject, and instead of being dissipated, the confusion became ever
    "worse confounded."
    
    In 1790 the 'Memoires du Marechal de Richelieu' appeared. He had left
    his note-books, his library, and his correspondence to Soulavie. The
    'Memoires' are undoubtedly authentic, and have, if not certainty, at
    least a strong moral presumption in their favour, and gained the belief
    of men holding diverse opinions. But before placing under the eyes of
    our readers extracts from them relating to the Iron Mask, let us refresh
    our memory by recalling two theories which had not stood the test of
    thorough investigation.
    
    According to some MS. notes left by M. de Bonac, French ambassador at
    Constantinople in 1724, the Armenian Patriarch Arwedicks, a mortal enemy
    of our Church and the instigator of the terrible persecutions to which
    the Roman Catholics were subjected, was carried off into exile at the
    request of the Jesuits by a French vessel, and confined in a prison
    whence there was no escape. This prison was the fortress of
    Sainte-Marguerite, and from there he was taken to the Bastille, where he
    died. The Turkish Government continually clamoured for his release till
    1723, but the French Government persistently denied having taken any
    part in the abduction.
    
    Even if it were not a matter of history that Arwedicks went over to the
    Roman Catholic Church and died a free man in Paris, as may be seen by an
    inspection of the certificate of his death preserved among the archives
    in the Foreign Office, one sentence from the note-book of M. de Bonac
    would be sufficient to annihilate this theory. M. de Bonac says that the
    Patriarch was carried off, while M. de Feriol, who succeeded M. de
    Chateauneuf in 1699, was ambassador at Constantinople. Now it was in
    1698 that Saint-Mars arrived at the Bastille with his masked prisoner.
    
    Several English scholars have sided with Gibbon in thinking that the Man
    in the Iron Mask might possibly have been Henry, the second son of
    Oliver Cromwell, who was held as a hostage by Louis XIV.
    
    By an odd coincidence the second son of the Lord Protector does entirely
    disappear from the page of history in 1659; we know nothing of where he
    afterwards lived nor when he died. But why should he be a prisoner of
    state in France, while his elder brother Richard was permitted to live
    there quite openly? In the absence of all proof, we cannot attach the
    least importance to this explanation of the mystery.
    
    We now come to the promised extracts from the 'Memoires du Marechal de
    Richelieu':
    
    "Under the late king there was a time when every class of society was
    asking who the famous personage really was who went by the name of the
    Iron Mask, but I noticed that this curiosity abated somewhat after his
    arrival at the Bastille with Saint-Mars, when it began to be reported
    that orders had been given to kill him should he let his name be known.
    Saint-Mars also let it be understood that whoever found out the secret
    would share the same fate. This threat to murder both the prisoner and
    those who showed too much curiosity about him made such an impression,
    that during the lifetime of the late king people only spoke of the
    mystery below their breath. The anonymous author of 'Les Memoires de
    Perse', which were published in Holland fifteen years after the death of
    Louis XIV, was the first who dared to speak publicly of the prisoner and
    relate some anecdotes about him.
    
    "Since the publication of that work, liberty of speech and the freedom
    of the press have made great strides, and the shade of Louis XIV having
    lost its terrors, the case of the Iron Mask is freely discussed, and yet
    even now, at the end of my life and seventy years after the death of the
    king, people are still asking who the Man in the Iron Mask really was.
    
    "This question was one I put to the adorable princess, beloved of the
    regent, who inspired in return only aversion and respect, all her love
    being given to me. As everyone was persuaded that the regent knew the
    name, the course of life, and the cause of the imprisonment of the
    masked prisoner, I, being more venturesome in my curiosity than others,
    tried through my princess to fathom the secret. She had hitherto
    constantly repulsed the advances of the Duc d' Orleans, but as the
    ardour of his passion was thereby in no wise abated, the least glimpse
    of hope would be sufficient to induce him to grant her everything she
    asked; I persuaded her, therefore, to let him understand that if he
    would allow her to read the 'Memoires du Masque' which were in his
    possession his dearest desires would be fulfilled.
    
    "The Duc d'Orleans had never been known to reveal any secret of state,
    being unspeakably circumspect, and having been trained to keep every
    confidence inviolable by his preceptor Dubois, so I felt quite certain
    that even the princess would fail in her efforts to get a sight of the
    memoranda in his possession relative to the birth and rank of the masked
    prisoner; but what cannot love, and such an ardent love, induce a man to
    do?
    
    "To reward her goodness the regent gave the documents into her hands,
    and she forwarded them to me next day, enclosed in a note written in
    cipher, which, according to the laws of historical writing, I reproduce
    in its entirety, vouching for its authenticity; for the princess always
    employed a cipher when she used the language of gallantry, and this note
    told me what treaty she had had to sign in order that she might obtain
    the documents, and the duke the desire of his heart. The details are not
    admissible in serious history, but, borrowing the modest language of the
    patriarchal time, I may say that if Jacob, before he obtained possession
    of the best beloved of Laban's daughters, was obliged to pay the price
    twice over, the regent drove a better bargain than the patriarch. The
    note and the memorandum were as follows: "'2. 1. 17. 12. 9. 2. 20. 2. 1.
    7. 14 20. 10. 3. 21. 1. 11. 14. 1. 15. 16. 12. 17. 14. 2. 1. 21. 11. 20.
    17. 12. 9. 14. 9. 2. 8. 20. 5. 20. 2. 2. 17. 8. 1. 2. 20. 9. 21. 21. 1.
    5. 12. 17. 15. 00. 14. 1. 15. 14. 12. 9. 21. 5. 12. 9. 21. 16. 20. 14.
    8. 3.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay)
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Man in the Iron Mask (an Essay)
    
    Author: Alexandre Dumas
    
    
            
    Release date: September 22, 2004 [eBook #2751]
                    Most recently updated: November 28, 2016
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2751
    
    Credits: Produced by David Widger
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #2751. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 2751
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-22
    Completeness
    Complete held text.