Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of The Works of Mr. George Gillespie (Vol. 1 of 2)
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 26849

The Works of Mr. George Gillespie (Vol. 1 of 2)

by George Gillespie · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2008
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    CHAPTER I.

    THAT OUR OPPOSITES DO URGE THE CEREMONIES AS THINGS NECESSARY.

    Sect. 1. This I prove, 1. From their practice; 2. From their pleading.

    In their practice, who seeth not that they would tie the people of God to a necessity of submitting their necks to this heavy yoke of human ceremonies? which are with more vehemency, forwardness, and strictness urged, than the weighty matters of the law of God, and the refusing whereof is far more inhibited, menaced, espied, delated, aggravated, censured, and punished, than idolatry, Popery, blasphemy, swearing, profanation of the Sabbath, murder, adultery, &c.

    Both preachers and people have been, and are, fined, confined, imprisoned, banished, censured, and punished so severely, that he may well say of them that which our divines say of the Papists, Hoec sua inventa Decalago anteponunt, et gravius eos-multarent qui ea violarent, quam qui divina praecepta transgrederentur.(45) Wherefore, seeing they make not only as much, but more ado, about the controverted ceremonies than about the most necessary things in religion, their practice herein makes it too, too apparent what necessity they annex to them.

    Sect. 2. And if we will hearken to their pleading it tells no less; for howbeit they plead for their ceremonies, as things indifferent in their own nature, yet, when the ceremonies are considered as the ordinances of the church, they plead for them as things necessary. M. G. Powel, in the Consideration of the Arguments directed to the High Court of Parliament in behalf of the Ministers suspended and deprived (ans. 3 to arg.

    16), hath these words, yea, these particulars: “Subscription, ceremonies, &c., being imposed by the church, and commanded by the magistrate, are necessary to be observed under the pain of sin.” The Bishop of Edinburgh resolves us concerning the necessity of giving obedience to the laws of the church, enacted anent the ceremonies, thus: “Where a man hath not a law, his judgment is the rule of his conscience, but where there is a law, the law must be the rule.

    As, for example, before that apostolical canon that forbade to eat blood or strangled things, every man might have done that which in his conscience he thought most expedient, &c., but after the making and the publication of the canon that enjoined abstinence, the same was to rule their consciences.

    And, therefore, after that time, albeit a man had thought in his own private judgment that to abstain from these things was not expedient, &c. yet, in that case, he ought not to have eaten, because now the will of the law, and not the judgment of his own mind, was the rule of his conscience.”(46) The Archbishop of St Andrews, to the same purpose saith, “In things indifferent we must always esteem that to be best and most seemly which seemeth so in the eye of public authority, neither is it for private men to control public judgment, as they cannot make public constitutions, so they may not control nor disobey them, being once made, indeed authority ought to look well to this, that it prescribe nothing but rightly, appoint no rights nor orders in the church but such as may set forward godliness and piety, yet, put the case, that some be otherwise established, they must be obeyed by such as are members of that church, as long as they have the force of a constitution, &c.

    But thou wilt say, My conscience suffers me not to obey, for I am persuaded that such things are not right, nor appointed.

    I answer thee, In matters of this nature and quality the sentence of thy superiors ought to direct thee, and that is a sufficient ground to thy conscience for obeying.”(47) Thus we see that they urge the ceremonies, not only with a necessity of practice upon the outward man, but also with a necessity of opinion upon the conscience, and that merely because of the church’s determination and appointment; yea, Dr Mortoune maketh kneeling in the act of receiving the communion to be in some sort necessary in itself, for he maintaineth,(48) that though it be not essentially necessary as food, yet it is accidentally necessary as physic.

    Nay, some of them are yet more absurd, who plainly call the ceremonies necessary in themselves,(49) beside the constitution of the church. Others of them, who confess the ceremonies to be not only unnecessary,(50) but also inconvenient, do, notwithstanding, plead for them as things necessary.

    Dr Burges tells us,(51) that some of his side think that ceremonies are inconvenient, but withal he discovers to us a strange mystery brought out of the unsearchable deepness of his piercing conception, holding that such things as not only are not at all necessary in themselves,(52) but are inconvenient too, may yet be urged as necessary.

    Sect. 3. The urging of these ceremonies as necessary, if there were no more, is a sufficient reason for our refusing them. “To the precepts of God (saith Balduine) nothing is to be added,(53) Deut. xii. Now God hath commanded these things which are necessary. The rites of the church are not necessary, wherefore, if the abrogation or usurpation of any rite be urged as necessary, then is an addition made to the commandment of God, which is forbidden in the word, and, by consequence, it cannot oblige me, neither should anything herein be yielded unto.” Who can purge these ceremonies in controversy among us of gross superstition, since they are urged as things necessary?

    But of this superstition we shall hear afterward in its proper place.

    CHAPTER II.

    THE REASON TAKEN OUT OF ACTS XV. TO PROVE THE NECESSITY OF THE CEREMONIES,

    BECAUSE OF THE CHURCH’S APPOINTMENT, CONFUTED.

    The Bishop of Edinburgh, to prove that of necessity our consciences must be ruled by the will of the law, and that it is necessary that we give obedience to the same, albeit our consciences gainsay, allegeth that apostolical canon,(54) Acts xv., for an example, just as Bellarmine maintaineth, Festorum observationem ex se indifferentem esse sed posita lege fieri necessariam(55). Hospinian, answering him, will acknowledge no necessity of the observation of feasts, except divine law could be showed for it.(56) So say we, that the ceremonies which are acknowledged by formalists to be indifferent in themselves, cannot be made necessary by the law of the church, neither doth that example of the apostolical canon make anything against us, for, according to Mr Sprint’s confession,(57) it was not the force or authority of the canon, but the reason and ground whereupon the canon was made, which caused the necessity of abstaining, and to abstain was necessary for eschewing of scandal, whether the apostles and elders had enjoined abstinence or not.(58) The reason, then, why the things prescribed in that canon are called necessary, ver.

    28, is not because, being indifferent before the making and publication of the canon, they became necessary by virtue of the canon after it was made, as the Bishop teacheth, but _quia tunc __ charitas exigebat, ut illa sua libertate qui ex gentibus conversi erant, propter proximi edificationem inter judeos non uterentur, sed ab ea abstinerent,_ saith Chemnitius.(59) This law, saith Tilen,(60) was propter charitatem et vitandi offendiculi necessitatem ad tempus sancita. So that these things were necessary before the canon was made. Necessaria fuerunt, saith Ames,(61) antequam Apostoli quidquam de iis statuerant, non absolute, sed quatenus in iis charitas jubebat morem gerere infirmis, ut cajetanus notat.

    Quamobrem, saith Tilen,(62) cum charitas semper sit colenda, semper vitanda sandala. “Charity is necessary (saith Beza), even in things which are in themselves indifferent.”(63) What they can allege for the necessity of the ceremonies, from the authority and obligatory power of ecclesiastical laws, shall be answered by and by.

    CHAPTER III.

    THAT THE CEREMONIES THUS IMPOSED AND URGED AS THINGS NECESSARY, DO BEREAVE

    US OF OUR CHRISTIAN LIBERTY, FIRST, BECAUSE OUR PRACTICE IS ADSTRICTED.

    Sect. 1. Who can blame us for standing to the defence of our Christian liberty, which we ought to defend and pretend in rebus quibusvis? saith Bucer.(64) Shall we bear the name of Christians, and yet make no great account of the liberty which hath been bought to us by the dearest drops of the precious blood of the Son of God? Sumus empti, saith Parcus:(65) non igitur nostri juris ut nos mancipemus hominum servitio: id enim manifesta cum injuria redemptoris Christi fieret: sumus liberti Christi.

    Magistratui autem, saith Tilen,(66) et ecclesioe proepositis, non nisi usque ad aras obtemperandum, neque ullum certamen aut periculum pro libertatis per Christum nobis partæ defensione defugiendum, siquidem mortem ipsius irritam fieri, Paulus asserit, si spiritualis servitutis jugo, nos implicari patiamur. Gal. v. 1, “Let us stand fast, therefore, in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and not be entangled again with the yoke of bondage.” But that the urging of the ceremonies as necessary doth take away our Christian liberty, I will make it evident in four points.

    Sect. 2. First, They are imposed with a necessity of practice.

    Spotswood tells us,(67) that public constitutions must be obeyed, and that private men may not disobey them, and thus is our practice adstricted in the use of things which are not at all necessary, and acknowledged gratis by the urgers to be indifferent, adstricted (I say) to one part without liberty to the other, and that by the mere authority of a human constitution, whereas Christian liberty gives us freedom both for the omission and for the observation of a thing indifferent, except some other reason do adstrict and restrain it than a bare human constitution.

    Chrysostome, speaking of such as are subject to bishops,(68) saith, In potestate positum est obedire vel non. Liberty in things indifferent,(69) saith Amandus Polanus, est per quam Christiani sunt liberi in usu vel abstinentia rerum adiaphorarom. Calvin, speaking of our liberty in things indifferent,(70) saith, We may eas nunc usurpare nunc omittere indifferenter, and places this liberty,(71) tam in abstinendo quam in utendo. It is marked of the rites of the ancient church,(72) that liberae fuerunt horum rituum observationes in ecclesia. And what meaneth the Apostle while he saith, “If ye be dead with Christ from the rudiments of the world, why, as though living in the world, are ye subject to ordinances, (touch not, taste not, handle not, which all are to perish with the using,) after the commandments and doctrines of men?” Col. ii.

    20-22. Surely he condemneth not only humana decreta de ritibus, but also subjection and obedience to such ordinances of men as take from us liberty of practice in the use of things indifferent,(73) obedience (I say) for conscience of their ordinances merely. What meaneth also that place, 1 Cor. vii.

    23, “Be not ye the servants of men?” “It forbids us, (saith Paybody) to be the servants of men, that is, in wicked or superstitious actions, according to their perverse commandments or desires.”(74) If he mean of actions that are wicked or superstitious in themselves, then it followeth, that to be subject unto those ordinances, “Touch not, taste not, handle not,” is not to be the servants of men, because these actions are not wicked and superstitious in themselves. Not touching, not tasting, not handling, are in themselves indifferent.

    But if he mean of actions which are wicked and superstitious, in respect of circumstances, then is his restrictive gloss senseless; for we can never be the servants of men, but in such wicked and superstitious actions, if there were no more but giving obedience to such ordinances as are imposed with a necessity upon us, and that merely for conscience of the ordinance, it is enough to infect the actions with superstition, Sunt hominum servi, saith Bullinqer,(75) qui aliquid in gratiam hominum faciunt.

    This is nearer the truth; for to tie ourselves to the doing of anything for the will or pleasure of men, when our conscience can find no other reason for the doing of it, were indeed to make ourselves the servants of men. Far be it then from us to submit our necks to such a heavy yoke of human precepts, as would overload and undo us. Nay, we will stedfastly resist such unchristian tyranny as goeth about to spoil us of Christian liberty, taking that for certain which we find in Cyprian,(76) periculosum est in divinis rebus ut quis cedat jure suo.

    Sect. 3. Two things are here replied, 1. That there is reason for adstricting of our practice in these things, because we are commanded to obey them that have the rule over us, and to submit ourselves, Heb. xiii. 17,(77) and to submit ourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord’s sake, 1 Pet. ii. 16, and that except public constitutions must needs be obeyed, there can be no order,(78) but all shall be filled with strife and contention. Ans. 1.

    As touching obedience to those that are set over us, if they mean not to tyrannise over the Lord’s inheritance, 1 Pet. v. 3; and to make the commandments of God of no effect by their traditions, Mark vii. 9, they must give us leave to try their precepts by the sure will of God’s word; and when we find that they require of us anything in the worship of God which is either against or beside his written word, then modestly to refuse obedience, which is the only way for order, and shunning of strife and contention.

    It will be said again, that except we prove the things commanded by those who are set over us to be unlawful in themselves, we cannot be allowed to refuse obedience to their ordinances. Ans. This unlawfulness of the ceremonies in themselves hath been proved by us already, and shall yet again be proved in this dispute.

    But put the case, they were lawful in themselves, yet have we good reason for refusing them: “David thought the feeding of his body was cause sufficient to break the law of the shew-bread; Christ thought the satisfying of the disciples’ hunger to be cause sufficient to break the ceremony of the Sabbath.

    He thought, also, that the healing of the lepers’ bodies was a just excuse to break the law that forbade the touching of them; much more, then, may we think now in our estimation, that the feeding of other men’s souls, the satisfying of our own consciences, together with the consciences of other men, and the healing of men’s superstition and spiritual leprosy, are causes sufficient to break the law of the ceremonies and of the cross, which are not God’s but men’s,” saith Parker.(79) 2.

    As touching submission or subjection, we say with Dr Field,(80) that subjection is generally and absolutely required where obedience is not, and even when our consciences suffer us not to obey, yet still we submit and subject ourselves, and neither do nor shall (I trust) show any the least contempt of authority.

    Sect. 4. Secondly, It is replied, that our Christian liberty is not taken away when practice is restrained, because conscience is still left free. “The Christian liberty (saith Paybody(81)), is not taken away by the necessity of doing a thing indifferent, or not doing, but only by that necessity which takes away the opinion or persuasion of its indifferency,” So saith Dr Burges,(82) “That the ceremonies in question are ordained to be used necessarily, though the judgment concerning them, and immediate conscience to God, be left free.” Ans. 1. Who doubts of this, that liberty of practice may be restrained in the use of things which are in themselves indifferent?

    But, yet, if the bare authority of an ecclesiastical law, without any other reason than the will and pleasure of men, be made to restrain practice, then is Christian liberty taken away.

    Junius saith,(83) that externum opus ligatur from the use of things indifferent, when the conscience is not bound; but in that same place he showeth, that the outward action is bound and restrained only quo usque circumstantiae ob quas necessitas imperata est, se extendunt. So that it is not the authority of an ecclesiastical law, but the occasion and ground of it, which adstricts the practice when the conscience is left free. 2.

    When the authority of the church’s constitution is obtruded to bind and restrain the practice of Christians in the use of things indifferent, they are bereaved of their liberty, as well as if an opinion of necessity were borne in upon their consciences. Therefore we see when the Apostle, 1 Cor. vii., gives liberty of marriage, he doth not only leave the conscience free in its judgment of the lawfulness of marriage, but also give liberty of practice to marry or not to marry. And Col. ii.

    21, when he giveth instances of such human ordinances as take away Christian liberty, he saith not, you must think that you may not touch, &c., but “touch not,” &c., telling us, that when the practice is restrained from touching, tasting, handling, by the ordinances of men, then is Christian liberty spoiled, though the conscience be left free. Camero, speaking of the servitude which is opposed to Christian liberty, saith,(84) that it is either animi servitus, or corporis servitus.

    Then if the outward man be brought in bondage, this makes up spiritual thraldom, though there be no more. But, 3. The ceremonies are imposed with an opinion of necessity upon the conscience itself, for proof whereof I proceed to the next point.

    CHAPTER IV.

    THAT THE CEREMONIES TAKE AWAY OUR CHRISTIAN LIBERTY PROVED BY A SECOND

    REASON, NAMELY, BECAUSE CONSCIENCE ITSELF IS BOUND AND ADSTRICTED.

    Sect. 1. Bishop Lindsey hath told us,(85) that the will of the law must be the rule of our conscience, so that conscience may not judge other ways than the law determines. Bishop Spotswood will have the sentence of superiors to direct the conscience,(86) and will have us to esteem that to be best and most seemly which seemeth so to them.

    Bishop Andrews, speaking of ceremonies,(87) not only will have every person inviolably to observe the rites and customs of his own church, but also will have the ordinances about those rites to be urged under pain of the anathema. I know not what the binding of the conscience is, if this be not it: Apostolus gemendi partes relinquit, non cogendi auctoritatem tribuit ministris quibus plebs non auscultat.(88) And shall they who call themselves the apostles’ successors, compel, constrain and enthral, the consciences of the people of God?

    Charles V., as popish as he was, did promise to the Protestants,(89) Nullam vim ipsorum conscientiis illatum iri. And shall a popish prince speak more reasonable than protestant prelates? But to make it yet more and plentifully to appear how miserably our opposites would enthral our consciences, I will here show, 1. What the binding of the conscience is. 2. How the laws of the church may be said to bind. 3.

    What is the judgment of formalists touching the binding-power of ecclesiastical laws.

    Sect. 2. Concerning the first of these we will hear what Dr Field saith:(90) “To bind the conscience (saith he) is to bind the soul and spirit of man, with the fear of such punishments (to be inflicted by him that so bindeth) as the conscience feareth; that is, as men fear, though none but God and themselves be privy to their doings; now these are only such as God only inflicteth,” &c. This description is too imperfect, and deserves to be corrected.

    To bind the conscience is illam auctoritatem habere, ut conscientia illi subjicere sese debeat, ita ut peccatum sit, si contra illam quidquam fiat, saith Ames.(91) “The binder (saith Perkins(92)) is that thing whatsoever which hath power and authority over conscience to order it.

    To bind is to urge, cause, and constrain it in every action, either to accuse for sin, or to excuse for well-doing; or to say, this may be done, or it may not be done.” “To bind the conscience (saith Alsted(93)) est illam urgere et adigere, ut vel excuset et accuset, vel indicet quid fieri aut non fieri possit.” Upon these descriptions, which have more truth and reason in them, I infer that whatsoever urges, or forces conscience to assent to a thing as lawful, or a thing that ought to be done, or dissent from a thing as unlawful, or a thing which ought not to be done, that is a binder of conscience, though it did not bind the spirit of a man with the fear of such punishments as God alone inflicteth.

    For secluding all respect of punishment, and not considering what will follow, the very obliging of the conscience for the time, ad assensum, is a binding of it.(94)

    Sect. 3.

    Touching the second, it is certain that human laws, as they come from men, and in respect of any force or authority which men can give them, have no power to bind the conscience. Neque enim cum hominibus, sed cum uno Deo negotium est conscientis nostris, saith Calvin.(95) Over our souls and consciences, nemini quicquam juris nisi Deo, saith Tilen.(96) From Jerome’s distinction, that a king praeest nolentibus but a bishop volentibus, Marcus Antonius de Dominis well concludeth: Volentibus gregi praeesso, excludit omnem jurisdictionem et potestatem imperativam ac coactivam et solam significat directivam, ubi, viz., in libertate subditi est et parere et non parere, ita ut qui praeest nihil habeat quo nolentem parere adigat ad parendum.(97) This point he proveth in that chapter at length, where he disputeth both against temporal and spiritual coactive jurisdiction in the church.

    If it be demanded to what purpose serveth then the enacting of ecclesiastical laws, since they have not in them any power to bind the conscience, I answer, The use and end for which ecclesiastical laws do serve is, 1. For the plain discovery of such things as the law of God or nature do require of us, so that law which of itself hath power to bind, cometh from the priests and ministers of the Lord neither ἀντοκρατορικῶς nor νομοθετικῶς, but declarativè, Mal. ii. 7. 2.

    For declaring to us what is fittest in such things as are, in their own nature, indifferent, and neither enforced by the law of God nor nature, and which part should be followed in these things as most convenient. The laws of the church, then, are appointed to let us see the necessity of the first kind of things, and what is expedient in the other kind of things, and therefore they are more properly called directions, instructions, admonitions, than laws.

    For I speak of ecclesiastical laws qua tales, that is, as they are the constitutions of men who are set over us; thus considered, they have only vim dirigendi et monendi.(98) It is said of the apostles, that they were constituted doctrinae Christi testes, non novae doctrinae legist tores.(99) And the same may be said of all the ministers of the gospel, when discipline is taken in with doctrine.

    He is no nonconformist who holdeth ecclesiam in terris agere partes oratoris, seu legati obsecrantis et suadentis.(100) And we may hitherto apply that which Gerson, the chancellor of Paris, saith:(101) “The wisest and best among the guides of God’s church had not so ill a meaning as to have all their constitutions and ordinances taken for laws properly so named, much less strictly binding the conscience, but for threatenings, admonitions, counsels, and directions only, and when there groweth a general neglect, they seem to consent to the abolishing of them again;” for seeing, lex instituitur, cum promulgatur, vigorem habet, cum moribus utentium approbatur.

    Sect. 4. But as we have seen in what respect the laws of the church do not bind, let us now see how they may be said to bind. That which bindeth is not the authority of the church, nor any force which the church can give to her laws. It must be then somewhat else which maketh them able to bind, when they bind at all, and that is ratio legis, “the reason of the law,” without which the law itself cannot bind, and which hath the chiefest and most principal power of binding.

    An ecclesiastical law, saith Junius,(102) διαταξις sive depositio, non vere lex est, sed διατυπωσις aut canon, ac proindedirigit quidem ut canon agentem voluntarie: non autem necessitate cogit, ut lex etiam involuntarium quod si forte ante accedit coactio, ea non est de natura canonis sed altunde pervenit.

    An ecclesiastical canon, saith Tilen,(103) ducit volentem, non trahit nolentem: quod si accedat coactio, ea ecclesiastici canonis natura est prorsus aliena, Calvin’s judgment is,(104) that an ecclesiastical canon binds, when manifestam utilitatem prae se fert, and when either tu prepon or charitatis ratio doth require, that we impose a necessity on our liberty. It binds not, then, by its own authority in his mind.

    And what saith the canon law itself?(105) Sed sciendum est quod ecclesiasticae prohibitiones proprias habent causas quibus cessantibus, cessant et ipsae. Hence Junius saith,(106) that the law binds not per se, but only propter ordinem charitatem, et cautionem scandali.

    Hence Ames,(107) quamvis ad justas leges humanas, justo modo observandas, obligentur homines in conscientiis suis a Deo; ipsae tamen leges humanae, qua sunt leges hominum, non obligant conscientiam. Hence Alsted:(108) “Laws made by men of things indifferent, whether they be civil or ecclesiastical, do bind the conscience, in so far as they agree with God’s word, serve for the public good, maintain order, and finally, take not away liberty of conscience.” Hence the professors of Leyden say,(109) that laws bind not primo et per se, sed secundario, et per accidens; that is,(110) quatenus in illis lex aliqua Dei violator.

    Hence I may compare the constitutions of the church with responsa juris consultorum among the Romans, which obliged no man, nisi ex aequo et bono, saith Daneus.(111) Hence it may be said, that the laws of the church do not only bind scandali et contemptus ratione, as Hospinian,(112) and in case libertas fiat cum scandalo, as Parcus;(113) for it were scandal not to give obedience to the laws of the church, when they prescribe things necessary or expedient for the eschewing of scandal, and it were contempt to refuse obedience to them, when we are not certainly persuaded of the unlawfulness or inexpediency of the things prescribed.

    Sect. 5.

    But out of the case of scandal or contempt, divines teach that conscience is not bound by the canon of the church made about order and policy. Extra casum scandali et destinatae rebellionis, propter commune bonum, non peccat qui contra constitutiones istas fecerit, saith Junius.(114) “If a law (saith Perkins)(115) concerning some external right or thing indifferent, be at some time or upon some occasion omitted, no offence given, nor contempt showed to ecclesiastical authority, there is no breach made in the conscience.” Alsted’s rule is,(116) Leges humanae non obligant quando omitti possunt sine impedimento finis ob quem feruntur sine scandalo aliorum, et sine contemptu legislatoris. And Tilen teacheth us,(117) that when the church hath determined the mutable circumstances, in the worship of God, for public edification, privatorum conscientiis liberum est quandoque ista omittere, modo offendicula vitentur, nihil que ex contemptu ecclesiae ac ministerii publici petulanti καινοτομια vel κειοδοξια facere videantur.

    Sect. 6. We deny not, then, that the church’s canons about rites, which serve for public order and edification, do bind. We say only, that it is not the authority of the church framing the canon that binds, but the matter of the canon chiefly warranted by God’s word.(118) Scimus enim quaecunque ad decorum et ordinem pertinent, non habenda esse pro humanis placitas, quia divinitus approbantur. Therefore we think concerning such canons, “that they are necessary to be observed so far forth only, as the keeping of them maintaineth decent order, and preventeth open offence.”(119)

    Sect. 7. If any say that I derogate much from the authority of the church when I do nothing which she prescribeth, except I see it lawful and expedient, because I should do this much for the exhortation and admonition of a brother. Ans. 1. I give far more reverence to the direction of the church than to the admonition of a brother, because that is ministerial, this fraternal, that comes from authority, this only from charity, that is public, this private, that is given by many, this by one.

    And, finally, the church hath a calling to direct me in some things wherein a brother hath not. 2. If it be still instanced that, in the point of obedience, I do no more for the church than for any brother, because I am bound to do that which is made evident to be lawful and expedient, though a private Christian do but exhort me to it, or whether I be exhorted to it or not.

    For answer to this I say, that I will obey the directions of the church in many things rather than the directions of a brother; for in two things which are in themselves indifferent, and none of them inexpedient, I will do that which the church requireth, though my brother should exhort me to the contrary. But always I hold me at this sure ground, that I am never bound in conscience to obey the ordinances of the church, except they be evidently lawful and expedient.

    This is that, sine quo non obligant, and also that which doth chiefly bind, though it be not the only thing which bindeth. Now, for making the matter more plain, we must consider that the constitutions of the church are either lawful or unlawful. If unlawful, they bind not at all; if lawful, they are either concerning things necessary, as Acts xv.

    28, and then the necessity of the things doth bind, whether the church ordain them or not; or else concerning things indifferent, as when the church ordaineth, that in great towns there shall be sermon on such a day of the week, and public prayers every day at such an hour.

    Here it is not the bare authority of the church that bindeth, without respect to the lawfulness or expediency of the thing itself which is ordained (else we were bound to do every thing which the church ordains, were it never so unlawful, for quod competit alicui qua tali, competit omni tali: we behold the authority of the church making laws, as well in unlawful ordinances as in lawful), nor yet is it the lawfulness or expediency of the thing itself, without respect to the ordinance of the church (for possibly other times and diets were as lawful, and expedient too, for such exercises, as those ordained by the church); but it is the authority of the church prescribing a thing lawful or expedient.

    In such a case, then neither doth the authority of the church bind, except the thing be lawful and expedient, nor doth the lawfulness and expediency of the thing bind, except the church ordain it; but both these jointly do bind.

    Sect. 8. I come now to examine what is the judgment of formalists touching the binding of the conscience by ecclesiastical laws. Dr Field saith, that the question should not be proposed, whether human laws do bind the conscience, but “whether binding the outward man to the performance of outward things by force and fear of outward punishment to be inflicted by men, the non-performance of such things, or the non-performance of them with such affections as were fit, be not a sin against God, of which the conscience will accuse us,”(120) &c.

    Unto this question thus proposed and understood of human laws, and where no more is considered as giving them power to bind, but only the authority of those who make them; some formalists do give (as I will show), and all of them (being well advised) must give an affirmative answer.

    And, I pray, what did Bellarmine say more,(121) when, expressing how conscience is subject to human authority, he taught that conscience belongeth ad humanum forum, quatenus homo ex praecepto ita obligator ad opus externum faciendum, ut si non faciat, judicat ipse in conscientia sua se male facere, et hoc sufficit ad conscientiam obligandam? But to proceed particularly.

    Sect. 9. I begin with Field himself, whose resolution of the question proposed is,(122) that we are bound only to give obedience to such human laws as prescribe things profitable, not for that human laws have power to bind the conscience, but because the things they command are of that nature, that not to perform them is contrary to justice or charity.

    Whereupon he concludeth out of Stapleton, that we are bound to the performance of things prescribed by human laws, in such sort, that the non-performance of them is sin, not ex sola legislatoris voluntate, sed ex ipsa legum utilitate. Let all such as be of this man’s mind not blame us for denying of obedience to the constitutions about the ceremonies, since we find (for certain) no utility, but, by the contrary, much inconveniency in them.

    If they say that we must think those laws to be profitable or convenient, which they, who are set over us, think to be so, then they know not what they say. For, exempting conscience from being bound by human laws in one thing, they would have it bound by them in another thing.

    If conscience must needs judge that to be profitable, which seemeth so to those that are set over us, then, sure, is power given to them for binding the conscience so straitly, that it may not judge otherwise than they judge, and force is placed in their bare authority for necessitating and constraining the assenting judgment of conscience.

    Sect. 10. Some man perhaps will say that we are bound to obey the laws made about the ceremonies, though not for the sole will of the law-makers, nor yet for any utility of the laws themselves, yet for this reason, that scandal and contempt would follow in case we do otherwise. Ans. We know that human laws do bind in the case of scandal or contempt.

    But that nonconformity is neither scandal nor contempt, Parker hath made it most evident.(123) For, as touching contempt, he showeth out of fathers, councils, canon law, schoolmen, and modern divines, that non obedire is not contempt, but nolle obedire, or superbiendo repugnare. Yea, out of Formalists themselves, he showeth the difference betwixt subjection and obedience. Thereafter he pleadeth thus, and we with him: “What signs see men in us of pride and contempt? What be our cetera opera that bewray such an humour?

    Let it be named wherein we go not two miles, when we are commanded to go but one, yea, wherein we go not as many miles as any shoe of the preparation of the gospel will bear us. What payment, what pain, what labour, what taxation made us ever to murmur? Survey our charges where we have laboured, if they be n

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    The Works of Mr. George Gillespie (Vol. 1 of 2)
    Author
    George Gillespie
    Release date
    October 8, 2008 [eBook #26849]
    Language
    English
    Most recently updated
    June 20, 2020
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
                                   THE WORKS OF
    
                               MR. GEORGE GILLESPIE
    
                              MINISTER OF EDINBURGH,
    
                    AND ONE OF THE COMMISSIONERS FROM SCOTLAND
    
                        TO THE WESTMINSTER ASSEMBLY, 1644
    
                               NOW FIRST COLLECTED.
    
                      WITH MEMOIR OF HIS LIFE AND WRITINGS,
    
                           BY M. W. HETHERINGTON, LL.D.
    
                                 IN TWO VOLUMES.
    
                                     VOL. I.
    
                                    EDINBURGH:
    
                         ROBERT OGLE AND OLIVER AND BOYD.
    
                   M. OGLE & SON AND WILLIAM COLLINS, GLASGOW.
    
                           HAMILTON, ADAMS & CO, LONDON
    
                                      1846.
    
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    
    ADVERTISEMENT.
    MEMOIR OF THE REV. GEORGE GILLESPIE.
    APPENDIX. EXTRACTS FROM WODROW’S ANALECTA (MAITLAND CLUB EDITION)
    DISPUTE AGAINST THE ENGLISH POPISH CEREMONIES OBTRUDED ON THE CHURCH OF
    SCOTLAND.
       DEDICATION
       AUTHOR’S PREFACE
       PROLOGUE.
       ORDER.
       THE FIRST PART. AGAINST THE NECESSITY OF THE CEREMONIES.
          CHAPTER I. THAT OUR OPPOSITES DO URGE THE CEREMONIES AS THINGS
          NECESSARY.
          CHAPTER II. THE REASON TAKEN OUT OF ACTS XV. TO PROVE THE NECESSITY
          OF THE CEREMONIES, BECAUSE OF THE CHURCH’S APPOINTMENT, CONFUTED.
          CHAPTER III. THAT THE CEREMONIES THUS IMPOSED AND URGED AS THINGS
          NECESSARY, DO BEREAVE US OF OUR CHRISTIAN LIBERTY, FIRST, BECAUSE
          OUR PRACTICE IS ADSTRICTED.
          CHAPTER IV. THAT THE CEREMONIES TAKE AWAY OUR CHRISTIAN LIBERTY
          PROVED BY A SECOND REASON, NAMELY, BECAUSE CONSCIENCE ITSELF IS
          BOUND AND ADSTRICTED.
          CHAPTER V. THAT THE CEREMONIES TAKE AWAY CHRISTIAN LIBERTY, PROVED
          BY A THIRD REASON, VIZ., BECAUSE THEY ARE URGED UPON SUCH AS, IN
          THEIR CONSCIENCES, DO CONDEMN THEM.
          CHAPTER VI. THAT THE CEREMONIES TAKE AWAY CHRISTIAN LIBERTY PROVED
          BY A FOURTH REASON, VIZ., BECAUSE THEY ARE PRESSED UPON US BY NAKED
          WILL AND AUTHORITY, WITHOUT GIVING ANY REASON TO SATISFY OUR
          CONSCIENCES.
          CHAPTER VII. THAT FESTIVAL DAYS TAKE AWAY OUR LIBERTY, WHICH GOD
          HATH GIVEN US, PROVED; AND FIRST OUT OF THE LAW.
          CHAPTER VIII. THAT FESTIVAL DAYS TAKE AWAY OUR CHRISTIAN LIBERTY,
          PROVED OUT OF THE GOSPEL.
          CHAPTER IX. SHOWING THE WEAKNESS OF SOME PRETENCES WHICH OUR
          OPPOSITES USE FOR HOLIDAYS.
       THE SECOND PART. AGAINST THE EXPEDIENCY OF THE CEREMONIES.
          CHAPTER I. AGAINST SOME OF OUR OPPOSITES, WHO ACKNOWLEDGE THE
          INCONVENIENCY OF THE CEREMONIES, AND YET WOULD HAVE US YIELD TO
          THEM.
          CHAPTER II. AGAINST THOSE OF OUR OPPOSITES WHO PLEAD FOR THE
          CEREMONIES AS THINGS EXPEDIENT.
          CHAPTER III. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE INEXPEDIENT, BECAUSE THEY ARE
          PREPARATIVES FOR GREATER EVILS.
          CHAPTER IV. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE INEXPEDIENT, BECAUSE THEY HINDER
          EDIFICATION.
          CHAPTER V. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE INEXPEDIENT, BECAUSE THEY ARE
          OCCASIONS OF INJURY AND CRUELTY.
          CHAPTER VI. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE INEXPEDIENT, BECAUSE THEY HARDEN
          AND CONFIRM THE PAPISTS.
          CHAPTER VII. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE INEXPEDIENT, BECAUSE THEY
          DISTURB THE PEACE OF THE CHURCH.
          CHAPTER VIII. THAT THE INEXPEDIENCY OF THE CEREMONIES, IN RESPECT OF
          THE SCANDAL OF THE WEAK, MAY BE PLAINLY PERCEIVED. TWELVE
          PROPOSITIONS TOUCHING SCANDAL ARE PREMITTED.
          CHAPTER IX. ALL THE DEFENCES OF THE CEREMONIES, USED TO JUSTIFY THEM
          AGAINST THE SCANDAL IMPUTED TO THEM, ARE CONFUTED.
       THE THIRD PART. AGAINST THE LAWFULNESS OF THE CEREMONIES.
          CHAPTER I. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE UNLAWFUL, BECAUSE SUPERSTITIOUS,
          WHICH IS PARTICULARLY INSTANCED IN HOLIDAYS, AND MINISTERING THE
          SACRAMENTS IN PRIVATE PLACES.
          CHAPTER II. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE UNLAWFUL BECAUSE THEY ARE
          MONUMENTS OF BY-PAST IDOLATRY, WHICH NOT BEING NECESSARY TO BE
          RETAINED, SHOULD BE UTTERLY ABOLISHED, BECAUSE OF THEIR IDOLATROUS
          ABUSES: ALL WHICH IS PARTICULARLY MADE GOOD OF KNEELING.
          CHAPTER III. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE UNLAWFUL, BECAUSE THEY SORT US
          WITH IDOLATERS, BEING THE BADGES OF PRESENT IDOLATRY AMONG THE
          PAPISTS.
          CHAPTER IV. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE IDOLS AMONG THE FORMALISTS
          THEMSELVES; AND THAT KNEELING IN THE LORD’S SUPPER BEFORE THE BREAD
          AND WINE, IN THE ACT OF RECEIVING THEM, IS FORMALLY IDOLATRY.
          CHAPTER V. THE FIFTH ARGUMENT AGAINST THE LAWFULNESS OF THE
          CEREMONIES TAKEN FROM THE MYSTICAL AND SIGNIFICANT NATURE OF THEM.
          CHAPTER VI. THAT THE LAWFULNESS OF THE CEREMONIES IS FALSELY
          GROUNDED UPON THE HOLY SCRIPTURE; WHERE SUCH PLACES AS ARE ALLEGED
          BY OUR OPPOSITES, EITHER FOR ALL THE CEREMONIES IN GENERAL, OR FOR
          ANY ONE OF THEM IN PARTICULAR, ARE VINDICATED FROM THEM.
          CHAPTER VII. THAT THE LAWFULNESS OF THE CEREMONIES CANNOT BE
          WARRANTED BY ANY ECCLESIASTICAL LAW, NOR BY ANY POWER WHICH THE
          CHURCH HATH TO PUT ORDER TO THINGS BELONGING TO DIVINE WORSHIP.
          CHAPTER VIII. THAT THE LAWFULNESS OF THE CEREMONIES CANNOT BE
          WARRANTED BY ANY ORDINANCE OF THE CIVIL MAGISTRATE; WHOSE POWER IN
          THINGS SPIRITUAL OR ECCLESIASTICAL IS EXPLAINED.
          DIGRESSION I. OF THE VOCATION OF MEN OF ECCLESIASTICAL ORDER.
          DIGRESSION II. OF THE CONVOCATION AND MODERATION OF SYNODS.
          DIGRESSION III. OF THE JUDGING OF CONTROVERSIES AND QUESTIONS OF
          FAITH.
          DIGRESSION IV. OF THE POWER OF THE KEYS, AND ECCLESIASTICAL
          CENSURES.
          CHAPTER IX. THAT THE LAWFULNESS OF THE CEREMONIES CANNOT BE
          WARRANTED BY THE LAW OF NATURE.
       THE FOURTH PART. AGAINST THE INDIFFERENCY OF THE CEREMONIES.
          CHAPTER I. OF OUR OPPOSITES’ PLEADING FOR THE INDIFFERENCY OF THE
          CEREMONIES.
          CHAPTER II. OF THE NATURE OF THINGS INDIFFERENT.
          CHAPTER III. WHETHER THERE BE ANYTHING INDIFFERENT IN ACTU EXERCITO.
          CHAPTER IV. OF THE RULE BY WHICH WE ARE TO MEASURE AND TRY WHAT
          THINGS ARE INDIFFERENT.
          CHAPTER V. THE FIRST POSITION WHICH WE BUILD UPON THE GROUND
          CONFIRMED IN THE FORMER CHAPTER.
          CHAPTER VI. ANOTHER POSITION BUILT UPON THE SAME GROUND.
          CHAPTER VII. OTHER POSITIONS BUILT UPON THE FORMER GROUND.
          CHAPTER VIII. THAT THE CEREMONIES ARE NOT THINGS INDIFFERENT TO THE
          CHURCH OF SCOTLAND; BECAUSE SHE DID ABJURE AND REPUDIATE THEM BY A
          MOST SOLEMN AND GENERAL OATH.
          CHAPTER IX. A RECAPITULATION OF SUNDRY OTHER REASONS AGAINST THE
          INDIFFERENCY OF THE CEREMONIES.
    A BROTHERLY EXAMINATION OF SOME PASSAGES OF MR COLEMAN’S LATE SERMON UPON
    JOB XI. 20.
       NOTICE.
       EXTRACT FROM COLEMAN’S SERMON.
       A BROTHERLY EXAMINATION, &c.
    NIHIL RESPONDES: OR A DISCOVERY OF THE EXTREME UNSATISFACTORINESS OF MR
    COLEMAN’S PIECE.
       THAT MR COLEMAN DOTH NOT ONLY PREVARICATE, BUT CONTRADICT HIMSELF,
       CONCERNING THE STATE OF THE QUESTION.
       THE PARTICULARS IN MY BRIEF EXAMINATION, WHICH MR COLEMAN EITHER
       GRANTETH EXPRESSLY, OR ELSE DOTH NOT REPLY UNTO.
       HIS ABUSING OF THE SCRIPTURES.
       HIS ERRORS IN DIVINITY.
       HIS ABUSING OF THE HONOURABLE HOUSES OF PARLIAMENT.
       HIS ABUSING THE REVEREND ASSEMBLY OF DIVINES.
       HIS CALUMNIES.
       THE REPUGNANCY OF HIS DOCTRINE TO THE SOLEMN LEAGUE AND COVENANT.
    MALE AUDIS; OR, AN ANSWER TO MR COLEMAN’S MALE DICIS.
       PREFACE TO THE READER.
       CHAPTER I. THAT MR COLEMAN DOTH STILL CONTRADICT HIMSELF IN THE STATING
       OF THIS PRESENT CONTROVERSY ABOUT CHURCH GOVERNMENT.
       CHAPTER II. A CONFUTATION OF THAT WHICH MR COLEMAN HATH SAID AGAINST
       CHURCH GOVERNMENT; SHOWING ALSO THAT HIS LAST REPLY IS NOT MORE, BUT
       LESS SATISFACTORY THAN THE FORMER, AND FOR THE MOST PART IS BUT A
       TERGIVERSATION AND FLEEING FROM ARGUMENTS BROUGHT AGAINST HIM, AND FROM
       MAKING GOOD HIS OWN ASSERTIONS AND ARGUMENTS CONCERNING THE DISTINCTION
       OF CIVIL AND CHURCH GOVERNMENT.
       CHAPTER III. THAT MR COLEMAN’S AND MR HUSSEY’S OPPOSING OF CHURCH
       GOVERNMENT NEITHER IS NOR CAN BE RECONCILED WITH THE SOLEMN LEAGUE AND
       COVENANT.
       CHAPTER IV. MR COLEMAN AND MR HUSSEY’S ERRORS IN DIVINITY.
       CHAPTER V. THE PRELATICAL WAY AND TENETS OF MR COLEMAN AND MR HUSSEY,
       REPUGNANT ALSO, IN DIVERS PARTICULARS, TO THE VOTES AND ORDINANCES OF
       PARLIAMENT.
       CHAPTER VI. MR COLEMAN’S WRONGING OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND.
       CHAPTER VII. CALUMNIES CONFUTED, AND THAT QUESTION BRIEFLY CLEARED,
       WHETHER THE MAGISTRATE BE CHRIST’S VICEGERENT.
       CHAPTER VIII. THAT MR COLEMAN DOTH GREAT VIOLENCE, BOTH TO HIS OWN
       WORDS AND TO THE WORDS OF OTHERS WHOM HE CITETH.
    ONE HUNDRED AND ELEVEN PROPOSITIONS CONCERNING THE MINISTRY AND GOVERNMENT
    OF THE CHURCH.
       PROPOSITIONS.
    A SERMON PREACHED BEFORE THE HONOURABLE HOUSE OF COMMONS AT THEIR LATE
    SOLEMN FAST
       PREFACE TO THE READER.
       SERMON.
    A SERMON PREACHED BEFORE THE RIGHT HONOURABLE THE HOUSE OF LORDS, IN THE
    ABBEY CHURCH AT WESTMINSTER.
       PREFACE TO THE READER.
       SERMON.
    Footnotes
    
    
    
    
    
    
    ADVERTISEMENT.
    
    
    (Transcriber’s Note: This book is an 1846 reprint of George Gillespie’s
    books, which were originally published separately.  Each is reprinted here
    with its original title page and other front matter.  The paper book had
    no page numbers; each book is transcribed here with its own page
    numbering, which may have no correspondence with the publisher’s idea of
    the page numbers.)
    
    In presenting to the public, for the first time, a Complete Edition of the
    Works of Mr GEORGE GILLESPIE, there are two or three points to which the
    Publisher begs to direct special attention.
    
    Although the great value of Gillespie’s various works was well known to
    many, yet there had been no recent reprints of them, and they had become
    so very scarce that it was with great difficulty any of them could be
    obtained. Recent controversies had brought forward the very subjects which
    had been so ably treated by Gillespie; and it was felt, that justice to
    the Church of which he was so great an ornament, and to the cause which he
    so strenuously supported, demanded the republication of his whole works,
    in a form, and at a price, which should render them generally accessible.
    
    In prosecuting this task the idea was suggested, that it would be
    desirable to publish what remained of those Notes on the Proceedings of
    the Westminster Assembly of Divines, which Gillespie was known to have
    written, if the permission of the Advocates, in whose Library they were,
    could be obtained. That permission was most readily granted. The
    manuscript volumes, of what purported to be Gillespie’s Notes, form part
    of the large collection entitled, the Wodrow MSS. They appear, however,
    not to be Gillespie’s own Notes, but copies separately taken from the
    original. The fact that they are manifestly separate and independent
    transcriptions, furnishes good evidence of the genuineness and
    authenticity of the original manuscripts, though it is not now known where
    they are, if still in existence. In making a new copy for the press every
    facility was granted by the Librarians of the Advocates’ Library, with
    their well-known courtesy and liberality; and much aid was rendered by
    David Laing, Esq., a gentleman thoroughly conversant with Scottish
    ecclesiastical literature, and generously ready to communicate to others
    the benefit of his own extensive and accurate knowledge.
    
    Being desirous to render this Edition of Gillespie’s works as full and
    complete as possible, several small and comparatively unimportant papers
    have been copied from the Wodrow Manuscript, some account of which will be
    found at the close of the Memoir. An appendix to the Memoir contains all
    that could be gleaned from Wodrow’s Analecta, as printed by the Maitland
    Club.
    
    The Memoir itself has been drawn up with considerable care, and is as
    extensive as the paucity of materials for its composition would admit. It
    might, indeed, have been enlarged by a more full account of the great
    events which occurred during the period in which Gillespie lived; but this
    would have been an unfair changing of biography into history, and would
    not have been suited to the object in view.
    
    As the parts of the Collected Edition of Gillespie’s Works were issued
    successively, they have been paged separately; and may be arranged in
    volumes according to the taste of their purchasers. It will, however, be
    found most expedient to adopt a chronological arrangement, such as is
    indicated in the closing pages of the Memoir.
    
    
    
    
    
    MEMOIR OF THE REV. GEORGE GILLESPIE.
    
    
    George Gillespie was one of the most remarkable men of the period in which
    he lived, singularly fertile as that period was in men of great abilities.
    He seems to have been almost unknown, till the publication of his first
    work, which dazzled and astonished his countrymen by the rare combination
    it displayed of learning and genius of the highest order. From that time
    forward, he held an undisputed position among the foremost of the
    distinguished men by whose talents and energy the Church of Scotland was
    delivered from prelatic despotism. Yet, although greatly admired by all
    his compeers during his brilliant career, so very little has been recorded
    respecting him, that we can but glean a scanty supply of materials, from a
    variety of sources, out of which to construct a brief memoir of his life
    
    We have not met with any particular reference to the family from which
    George Gillespie was descended, except a very brief notice of his father,
    the Rev. John Gillespie, in Livingston’s “Memorable Characteristics.” From
    this we learn that he was minister at Kirkcaldy, and that he was, to use
    Livingston’s language, “a thundering preacher.” In that town George
    Gillespie was born; but, as the earlier volumes of the Session Register of
    Births and Baptisms have been lost, the precise year of his birth cannot
    be ascertained from that source. It could not, however, have been earlier
    than 1612, in which year his father was chosen to the second charge in
    Kirkcaldy, as appears from the town records, nor later than 1613, as the
    existing Register commences January, 1614, and, in the end of that year,
    the birth of a daughter of Mr John Gillespie is registered, and again in
    1610, of a son, baptised Patrick. It may be assumed, therefore, with
    tolerable certainty, that George Gillespie was born early in the year
    1613, a date which agrees with that engraven on his tombstone. Wodrow,
    indeed, states, on the authority of Mr Simpson, that Gillespie was born on
    the 21st of January, 1613.
    
    Nothing has been recorded respecting the youthful period of Gillespie’s
    life. The earliest notice of him which appears, is merely sufficient to
    intimate that his mind must have been carefully cultivated from his
    boyhood, as it relates to the time of his being sent to the University of
    St Andrews, to prosecute his studies, in 1629, when he was, of course, in
    his 16th year. It appears to have been the custom of the Presbytery of
    Kirkcaldy, as of many others at that time, to support young men of merit
    at the University, as Presbytery Bursars, by means of the contributions of
    the parishes within its bounds. In the Session Record of Kirkcaldy the
    following statement occurs, dated November, 1629:—“The Session are content
    that Mr George Gillespie shall have as much money of our Session, for his
    interteynment, as Dysart gives, viz. 20 merks, being our Presbytery
    Bursar.” In some of the brief biographical notices of him which have been
    given, we are informed that during the course of his attendance at the
    University, he gave ample evidence of both genius and industry, by the
    rapid growth and development of mental power, and the equally rapid
    acquirement of extensive learning, in both of which respects he surpassed
    his fellow-students. That this must have been the case, his future
    eminence, so early achieved, sufficiently proves; but nothing of a very
    definite nature, relating to that period, has been preserved.
    
    When he had completed his academic career, and was ready to enter into the
    office of the ministry, his progress was obstructed by a difficulty which,
    for a time, proved insurmountable. Being conscientiously convinced that
    the prelatic system of church government is of human invention, and not of
    Divine institution, and having seen the bitter fruits it bore in Scotland,
    he would not submit to receive ordination from a bishop, and could not, at
    that juncture, obtain admission into the ministerial office without it.
    Though thus excluded from the object of his pursuit, he found congenial
    employment for his pious and active mind in the household of Lord Kenmure,
    where he resided as domestic chaplain, till the death of that nobleman in
    September, 1634. Soon afterwards we find him discharging a similar duty in
    the family of the Earl of Cassilis, and, at the same time, acting as tutor
    to Lord Kennedy, the Earl’s eldest son. This latter employment furnished
    him with both leisure and inducement to prosecute his studies, and that,
    too, in the very direction to which his mind had been already predisposed.
    But, in order to obtain an intelligible view of the state of matters in
    Scotland at that period, we must take a brief survey of the events which
    had been moulding the aspect of both church and kingdom for some time
    before.
    
    It may be assumed as a point which no person of competent knowledge and
    candid mind will deny or dispute, that the Reformed Church of Scotland
    was, from its very origin, Presbyterian; equally opposed to the prelatic
    superiority of one minister over others, and to the authority of the civil
    power in spiritual matters. This point, therefore, we need not occupy
    space in proving; but we may suggest, that there is a much closer and more
    important connexion between the two elements here specified, than is
    generally remarked. For, as a little reflection will show, without the
    pre-eminence of some small number of ministers over the rest, the civil
    power cannot obtain the means of directly exercising an authoritative
    control in spiritual matters. Even the indirect methods of corruption
    which may be employed can be but partially successful, and may at any time
    be defeated, whenever the general body shall be restored to purity and put
    forth its inherent power. A truly presbyterian church, therefore, never
    can be thoroughly depended on by civil rulers who wish to use it as a mere
    engine of state for political purposes; consequently, a truly presbyterian
    church has never found much favour in the estimation of the civil
    power,—and, it may be added, never will, till the civil power itself
    become truly Christian. Thus viewed, it was not strange that the civil
    power in Scotland, whether wielded by a regent such as Morton, or a king
    like James VI., should strenuously and perseveringly seek the subversion
    of the Presbyterian Church. In the earlier stage of the struggle, first
    Morton, and then James, attempted force, but found the attempt to be in
    vain. At length the King seemed inclined to leave off the hopeless and
    pernicious contest; and, in the year 1592, an Act of Parliament was
    passed, ratifying all the essential elements of the Presbyterian Church,
    in doctrine, government, discipline, and worship. But this proved to be
    merely a cessation of hostilities on the part of the King, preparatory to
    their resumption in a more insidious and dangerous manner, and by the dark
    instrumentality of his boasted “king-craft.”
    
    The first indication of the crafty monarch’s designs was in the year 1597,
    when he, “of his great zeal and singular affection which he always has to
    the advancement of the true religion, presently professed within this
    realm,” to use his own words, enacted that all who should be appointed to
    the prelatic dignity, should enjoy the privilege of sitting and voting in
    Parliament. The pretence was, that these persons would attend better to
    the interests of the Church than could be done by laymen; the intention
    was, to introduce the prelatic order and subvert the Presbyterian Church.
    And, that this might be done quietly and imperceptibly, the question
    respecting the influence which these parliamentary representatives of the
    Church should have in the government of the Church itself, was left to be
    determined by the King and the General Assembly. Many of the most
    judicious and clear-sighted of the ministers perceived the dangerous
    tendency of this measure, and gave it their decided and strenuous
    opposition; but others, wearied out by their conflict with the avaricious
    and tyrannical conduct of the nobility, which they hoped thus more
    effectually to resist, or gained over by the persuasions of the King and
    the court party, supported the proposal. The result was, that the measure
    was carried in the Assembly of 1598, by a majority of ten, and that
    majority formed chiefly by the votes of the elders, whom the King had
    induced to support his views. Scarcely had even this step been taken, when
    the Church became alarmed at the possible consequences; and, in order to
    avoid increasing that alarm, all further consideration of the measure,
    with reference to its subordinate details, was postponed till the meeting
    of the next Assembly. Nor was this enough. As the time for the next
    Assembly drew near, the King felt so uncertain of success, that he
    prorogued the appointed meeting, and betook himself to those private
    artifices by which his previous conquest had been gained.
    
    When the Assembly of 1600 met, the most intense interest was felt by the
    whole kingdom in its proceedings, all men perceiving that upon its
    decision would depend the continuation or the overthrow of the
    presbyterian form of church government in Scotland. The King’s first step
    was the arbitrary exclusion from the Assembly of the celebrated Andrew
    Melville. The discussion commenced respecting the propriety of ministers
    voting in Parliament. But when those who favoured the measure could not
    meet the argument of its opponents, the King again interposed, and
    authoritatively declared that the preceding General Assembly had already
    decided the general question in the affirmative; and that they had now
    only to determine subordinate arrangements. The measure was thus saved
    from defeat. The next question, whether the parliamentary ministers should
    hold their place for life, or be annually elected, was decided in favour
    of annual election. Yet James prevailed upon the cleric to frame an
    ambiguous statement in the minute of proceedings, virtually granting what
    the Assembly had rejected. Even then, though thus both overborne and
    tricked by the King, the Church framed a number of carefully expressed
    “caveats,” or cautions, for protecting her liberties, and guarding against
    the introduction of Prelacy. It was not, however, the intention of the
    King to pay any regard to these “caveats,” so soon as he might think it
    convenient to set them aside; and, accordingly, within a few months he
    appointed three bishops to the vacant sees of Ross, Aberdeen, and
    Caithness, directly in violation of all the “caveats” by which he had
    agreed that the appointment of ecclesiastical commissioners to Parliament
    should be regulated.
    
    That mysterious event, the Gowry conspiracy, and the views taken of it by
    some of the best and most influential of the ministers, tended to alter
    the aspect of the struggle between the King and the Church; and though the
    King twice interposed to change the Assembly’s time and place of meeting
    by his own authority, contrary to the provisions of the act, 1592, yet the
    church succeeded in maintaining a large measure of its primitive freedom
    and purity, against the encroachments of the crafty and perfidious monarch
    and his “creatures,” to use their own phrase, the bishops.
    
    The Assembly of 1602, however, was the last that retained anything like
    presbyterian liberty, and ventured to act on its own convictions of duty.
    But, the death of Queen Elizabeth, and the accession of James to the
    English throne, directed his main attention for a time to other matters,
    and gave occasion to a temporary pause in his violations of all the laws
    which he had repeatedly sworn to maintain. The pause was brief. The
    flattering servility of the English bishops inflated his vanity to an
    extravagant degree, and rendered him the more determined to subvert wholly
    the Presbyterian Church of Scotland, and to erect Prelacy on its ruins. He
    had already presumed more than once to postpone meetings of the General
    Assembly, by his own arbitrary authority; he resumed this course,
    postponed the Assembly for one year, naming another,—then prorogued it
    again, without naming another day of meeting, which was nearly equivalent
    to an intimation, that it should entirely depend upon his pleasure whether
    it should ever meet again,—directly contrary to the act, 1592, in which it
    was expressly stipulated that the Assembly should meet at least once a
    year. The most zealous and faithful of the ministers were now fully aware
    of the imminent peril to which spiritual liberty was exposed. On the 2d of
    July, 1605, the day on which the General Assembly had been appointed to
    meet at Aberdeen, nineteen ministers met, constituted the Assembly in the
    usual form, and while engaged in reading a letter presented by the King’s
    Commissioner, a messenger-at-arms entered, and in the King’s name, charged
    them to dismiss, on pain of being held guilty of rebellion. The moderator
    appointed another day of meeting, and dissolved the Assembly in the usual
    manner. This bold and independent, though perfectly legal and
    constitutional conduct, roused the wrath of the King to fury. Six of the
    most eminent of the ministers, one of whom was John Welsh of Ayr,
    son-in-law of Knox, were confined in a miserable dungeon in the castle of
    Blackness, for a period of fourteen months, and then banished to France.
    Eight others were imprisoned for a time, and banished to the remotest
    parts of Scotland. The severity of Robert Bruce’s treatment was increased;
    and six other ministers, who had not been directly involved in the
    resistance to the King’s authority, by the suppressed Assembly of
    Aberdeen, were called to London, and engaged in captious disputations by
    the crafty monarch, and his sycophantic prelates, in order to find
    occasion against them also. The result was, the confinement in the Tower
    of Andrew Melville, and his subsequent banishment to France; and the
    prohibition of his nephew, James Melville, to return to Scotland.
    
    Having thus succeeded, by fraud and force, in cutting off the leading
    ministers, James next summoned an Assembly to meet at Linlithgow, in
    December 1606, naming the persons who were to be sent by the presbyteries.
    In this packed Assembly he succeeded in his design of introducing more
    generally the prelatic element, by the appointment of constant moderators
    in each presbytery. Advancing now with greater rapidity, he instituted, in
    1610, the Court of High Commission, which may be well termed the Scottish
    Inquisition; and in the same year, in an Assembly held at Glasgow, both
    nominated by the King, and corrupted by lavish bribery, the whole prelatic
    system of church government was introduced; the right of calling and
    dismissing Assemblies was declared to belong to the royal prerogative, the
    bishops were declared moderators of diocesan synods; and the power of
    excommunicating and absolving offenders was conferred on them.
    
    The government of the Church was thus completely subverted in its external
    aspect. Its forms indeed remained. There were still presbyteries and
    synods, and there might be a General Assembly, if the King pleased; but
    the power of presbyteries or synods was vested in the Prelates, and the
    King could prevent any Assembly from being held, as long as he thought
    proper. But the Presbyterian Church, though overborne, was not destroyed,
    nor was its free spirit wholly subdued. When, in 1617, the King attempted
    to arrogate to himself and his prelatic council the power of enacting
    ecclesiastical laws, he was immediately met by a protestation against a
    measure so despotic. By an arbitrary stretch of power, he banished the
    historian Calderwood, the person who presented to him the protestation;
    but he felt it necessary to have recourse once more to his previously
    employed scheme, of a packed and bribed Assembly, in which to enact his
    innovations. This was accordingly done in the Assembly of 1618, held in
    Perth, in which, by the joint influence of bribery and intimidation, he
    succeeded in obtaining a majority of votes in favour of _the five articles
    of Perth_, as they are usually called. These _five articles_
    were,—_kneeling at the communion_,—_the observance of
    holidays_,—_episcopal confirmation_,—_private baptism_,—_and the private
    dispensation of the Lord’s Supper_. It will at once be seen that these
    innovations were directly contrary to the presbyterian principle, which
    holds that human inventions ought not to be added to divine institutions.
    
    This was the last attempt made by King James for the overthrow of the
    Presbyterian Church. It was but partially successful. Not less than
    forty-five, even of the ministers summoned to Perth by the King, voted
    against the _five articles_; and in defiance of the authority of the King,
    and the Prelates, and the terrors of the Court of High Commission, a large
    proportion of the ministers, and a much larger proportion of the people
    throughout the kingdom, never conformed to these articles. Various
    attempts were made by the prelatic faction to suppress the resistance of
    the faithful ministers and people. At one time a minister who would not
    yield was suspended from his ministry; at another, he was banished from
    his flock, and confined to some remote district of the country. But all
    was ineffectual, although much suffering and distress of mind was caused
    by these harrassing persecutions. Very gladly would the ministers and
    people have abandoned the prelatised church, and maintained the government
    and ritual of the Church of their fathers by their own unaided exertions,
    had they been permitted. But no such permission could be obtained. They
    were compelled either to abstain from preaching altogether, or to remain
    in connection with the Church. And even this alternative was not always
    left to their choice. They were frequently kept in a species of
    imprisonment in their own houses, not permitted to leave the Church, and
    yet forbidden to preach, or even to expound the word of God to the members
    of their own households. Such was the monstrous and intolerable tyranny
    exercised by Prelacy in Scotland, in its desperate attempts to destroy the
    Presbyterian Church.
    
    But the Presbyterian Church has always proved to be not easily destroyed.
    At the very time when Prelacy and king-craft were uniting for its
    destruction, its Divine Head was graciously supporting it under its
    trials, giving it life to endure them, and preparing for its deliverance.
    The sufferings endured by the faithful ministers in many parts of the
    country, tended to make them objects of admiration, love, and respect to
    the people, who could not but draw a very striking contrast between their
    conduct, and that of the haughty and irreligious prelates. But mighty as
    was this influence in the hearts of the people, one infinitely more mighty
    began to be felt in many districts of the kingdom. God was pleased to
    grant a time of religious revival. The power of vital godliness aroused
    the land, shining in its strength, like living fire. At Stewarton, at
    Shotts, and in many others quarters, great numbers were converted, and the
    faith of still greater numbers was increased. A time of refreshing from
    the presence of God had evidently come; and it soon became equally
    evident, that the enemies of spiritual freedom were under the blinding
    influence of infatuation.
    
    The younger bishops, inflated with vanity, acted towards the Scottish
    nobility in a manner so insolent, as to rouse the pride of these stern and
    haughty barons. But the prelates had learned from Laud, what measures
    would be agreeable to Charles I., who, to all his father’s despotic ideas
    of royal prerogative, and love of Prelacy, and to at least equal
    dissimulation, added the formidable elements of a temper dark and
    relentless, and a proud and inflexible will. The consequences soon
    appeared. Charles resolved, that the Church of Scotland should not only be
    episcopalian in its form of government, but also in all its discipline,
    and in its form of worship. In order to accomplish this long wished for
    purpose, it was resolved that a Book of Canons, and a Liturgy, should be
    prepared by the Scottish bishops, and transmitted to those of England, for
    their revision and approval. The book of Canons appeared in 1635, and was
    regarded by the nation with the utmost abhorrence, both on its own
    account, and as intended to introduce innovations still more detested.
    What was dreaded soon took place. The Liturgy was prepared, sent to
    England, and revised, several of the corrections being written by Laud
    himself, all tending to give it a decidedly popish character. Some copies
    of this production appeared early in the year 1637, and were immediately
    subjected to the examination of acute and powerful minds, well able to
    detect and expose their errors, and to resist this tyrannical attempt to
    do violence to the conscience of a free and religious people.
    
    The crisis came. A letter from his Majesty was procured, requiring the
    Liturgy to be used in all the churches of Edinburgh, and an act of the
    Privy Council was passed, to enforce obedience to the royal mandate.
    Archbishop Spotswood summoned the ministers together, announced to them
    the King’s pleasure, and commanded them to give intimation from their
    pulpits, that on the following Sabbath the public use of the Liturgy was
    to be commenced. The 23d day of July, 1637, was that on which the perilous
    attempt was to be made. In the cathedral church of St. Giles, the Dean of
    Edinburgh, attired in his surplice, began to read the service of the day.
    At that moment, an old woman, named Jenny Geddes, unable longer to
    restrain her indignation, exclaimed, “Villain, dost thou say mass at my
    lug!” and seizing the stool on which she had been sitting, threw it at the
    Dean’s head. Instantly all was uproar and confusion. Threatened or
    assailed on all sides, the Dean, terrified by this sudden outburst of
    popular fury, tore himself out of their hands and fled, glad to escape,
    though with the loss of his priestly vestments. In vain did the magistracy
    interfere. It was impossible to restore sufficient quiet to allow the
    service to be resumed; and the defeated prelatic party were compelled to
    abandon the Liturgy, thus dashed out of their trembling grasp by a woman’s
    hand.
    
    Such was the state of affairs in both church and kingdom, when George
    Gillespie first appeared in public life. He had already refused to receive
    ordination at the hands of a bishop; he had marked well the pernicious
    effects of their conduct on the most sacred interests of the community;
    and his strong and active intellect was directed to the prosecution of
    such studies as might the better enable him to assail the wrong and defend
    the right. His residence in the household of the Earl of Cassilis, while
    it furnished the means of continuing his learned researches, was not
    likely to change their direction; for the Earl was one of those
    high-hearted and independent noblemen, who could not brook prelatic
    insolence, even when supported by the Sovereign’s favour. The first
    production from the pen of Gillespie, the fruit, doubtless, of his
    previous studies, was a work entitled “A Dispute against the English
    Popish Ceremonies obtruded upon the Church of Scotland.” Its publication
    was remarkably well timed, being in the summer of 1637, at the very time
    when the whole kingdom was in a state of intense excitement, in the
    immediate expectation that the Liturgy would be forced upon the Church.
    Nothing could have been more suited to the emergency. It encountered every
    kind of argument employed by the prelatic party; and, as the defenders of
    the ceremonies argued that they were either necessary, or expedient, or
    lawful, or indifferent, so Gillespie divided his work into four parts,
    arguing against their _necessity_, their _expediency_, their _lawfulness_,
    and their _indifferency_, with such extensiveness of learning and
    acuteness and power of reasoning, as completely to demolish all the
    arguments of all his prelatical antagonists. The effect produced by this
    singularly able work may be conjectured from the fact, that within a few
    months after its publication, a proclamation was issued by the Privy
    Council, at the instigation of the bishops, commanding all the copies of
    it that could be found to be called in and burned. Such was the only
    answer that all the learned Scottish prelates could give to a treatise,
    written by a youth who was only in his twenty-fifth year when it appeared.
    The language of Baillie shows the estimation in which that learned, but
    timid and cautious man, held Gillespie’s youthful work. “This same youth
    is now given out also, by those that should know, for the author of the
    ‘English Popish Ceremonies,’ whereof we all do marvel; for, though he had
    gotten the papers, and help of the chief of that side, yet the very
    composition would seem to be far above such an age. But, if that book be
    truly of his making, I admire the man, though I mislike much of his
    matter; yea, I think he may prove amongst the best wits of this isle.”
    
    So far as argument was concerned, the controversy was ended by Gillespie’s
    work, as no answer was ever attempted by the prelates. But the contest,
    which began as one of power against principle, ere long became one of
    power against power. In vain did the King attempt to overawe the firm
    minds of the Presbyterians. In vain did the bishops issue their commands
    to the ministers to use the Liturgy. These commands were universally
    disobeyed; for the spirit of Scotland was now fairly roused—a spirit which
    has often learned to conquer, but never to yield. It was to be expected
    that Gillespie would not be allowed to remain much longer in comparative
    obscurity, after his remarkable abilities had become known. The church and
    parish of Wemyss being at that time vacant, the congregation, to whom he
    had been known from his infancy, “made supplication” that he might be
    their minister. This request was granted, “maugre St Andrew’s beard,” as
    Baillie says; that is, in spite of the opposition made by Spotswood,
    Archbishop of St Andrews, who knew enough of the young man to regard him
    with equal fear and hatred. He was ordained by the Presbytery of Kirkcaldy
    on the 26th of April, 1638, the celebrated Robert Douglas, at that time
    minister of Kirkcaldy, presiding at the ordination; and was the first who
    was admitted by a presbytery, at that period, without regard to the
    authority of the bishops. This, indeed, soon ceased to be a singularity;
    but, it must be remembered, that though the attempt to impose the Liturgy
    upon the Church had been successfully resisted, the ostensible government
    of the Church was still held by the prelates, and continued to be held by
    them, till they were all deposed by the famous General Assembly which met
    in Glasgow on the 21st day of November, 1638. But their power had received
    a fatal blow, and it could not fail to be highly gratifying to George
    Gillespie, that the first free act of the Presbyterian Church, to the
    recovery of whose liberty he had so signally contributed, should be his
    own ordination to the ministerial office.
    
    From that time forward, the life of George Gillespie was devoted to the
    public service of the Church; and he was incessantly engaged in all the
    great measures of that momentous period. He, however, was not the man of
    the age. That man was Alexander Henderson, the acknowledged leader of the
    Church of Scotland’s Second Reformation. And, as it is not our purpose to
    write a history of that period, we must confine ourselves chiefly to those
    events in which Gillespie acted a prominent part.
    
    The next intimation that we receive of Gillespie is in Baillie’s account
    of the Glasgow Assembly. “After a sermon of Mr Gillespie,” says Baillie,
    “wherein the youth very learnedly and judiciously, as they say, handled
    the words, ‘The King’s heart is in the hand of the Lord,’ yet did too much
    encroach on the King’s actions: he (Argyle) gave us a grave admonition, to
    let authority alone, which the Moderator seconded, and we all religiously
    observed, so long as the Assembly lasted.” This proves, at least, that
    Gillespie was highly esteemed by his brethren, who had selected him as one
    to preach before that important Assembly, notwithstanding his youth. It
    should be added, that on consulting the records of that Assembly’s
    proceedings, we do indeed find Argyle’s grave admonition not to interfere
    with the authority due to the King in his own province, and the
    Moderator’s answer; but nothing to lead us to think that it had any
    reference to Gillespie’s sermon. Baillie had not, at that time, learned to
    know and appreciate Gillespie, as he did afterwards and, as he had been
    somewhat startled by the point and power of the “English Popish
    Ceremonies,” he might not unnaturally conclude, that Argyle’s caution
    against what might be, had been caused by what had already been beginning
    to appear in the language of the youthful preacher.
    
    The course of public affairs swept rapidly onward, though certainly not in
    such a channel as to gratify the lovers of arbitrary power and
    superstition. The King, enraged to find his beloved Prelacy overthrown at
    once and entirely, prepared to force it upon the Scottish Covenanted
    Church and people by force of arms. The Covenanters stood on the
    defensive, and met the invading host on the Border, prepared to die rather
    than submit to the loss of religious liberty. But the English army was
    little inclined to fight in such a cause. They had felt the king’s tyranny
    and the oppression of their own prelates, and were not disposed to destroy
    that liberty, so nobly won by Scotland, for which they were themselves
    most earnestly longing. A peace ensued. The King granted that spiritual
    liberty which he was unable to withhold; and the ministers who had
    accompanied the Scottish army, returned to the discharge of their more
    peaceful duties. But this peace proved of short duration. The King levied
    a new and more powerful army, and again declared war against his Scottish
    subjects. Again the Covenanters resumed their weapons of defence, and
    marched towards the Border, a number of the most eminent ministers, among
    whom was Gillespie, being required to accompany the army, and empowered to
    act as a presbytery. It was, however, judged necessary to anticipate the
    approach of the English by entering England. This bold movement changed
    the nature of the contest for the time, because the English parliament
    felt the utmost jealousy of the King’s despotic designs, and would not
    grant him the necessary support. Negotiations for peace were begun at
    Ripon, and transferred to London. This rendered it necessary for the
    Scottish Commissioners for the peace to reside at London. Henderson,
    Blair, Baillie and Gillespie accompanied the Commissioners to London,
    resided with them there in the capacity of chaplains, and availed
    themselves of the opportunity thus afforded, for proving to the people of
    England that presbyterian ministers were not such rude and ignorant men as
    their prelatic calumniators had asserted. The effect of their preaching
    was astonishing, as even Clarendon, their prejudiced and bitter reviler,
    admits. Wherever they preached, the people flocked in crowds to hear them,
    and even clustered round the doors and windows of the churches in which
    they were proclaiming the unsearchable riches of Christ. It soon became
    apparent that both the cause, and the men by whom it was defended, were
    too mighty to be despised. Courtly parasites might scoff, but the heart of
    England was compelled to know that living faith and true eloquence are
    equally powerful to move and guide the minds of men, whether on the bleak
    waste of a Scottish moor, or in the midst of a mighty city.
    
    Soon after the return of the Scottish Commissioners and ministers, in the
    Assembly of 1641, the town of Aberdeen gave a call to George Gillespie to
    be one of their pastors. This call, however, he strenuously and
    successfully resisted, and was permitted to remain at Wemyss. But next
    year, the town of Edinburgh applied to the General Assembly, to have him
    translated to one of the charges there, and this application was
    successful, so that he became one of the ministers of Edinburgh in the
    year 1642, and continued so during the remainder of his life.
    
    But although Edinburgh had succeeded in obtaining Gillespie, the citizens
    were not long permitted to enjoy the benefit of his ministry. Another
    class of duties awaited him, in a still more public and important sphere
    of action. It is impossible here to do more than refer to the great events
    which at that time agitated not only Scotland, but also England. The
    superstition, bigotry and intolerance of Archbishop Laud and his
    followers, combining with and urging on the despotism of the King, had at
    length completely exhausted the patience of the English people and
    parliament. Every pacific effort had proved fruitless; and it had become
    undeniably evident, to every English patriot, that Prelacy must be
    abolished and the royal prerogative limited, unless they were prepared to
    yield up every vestige of civil and religious liberty. They made the
    nobler choice, passed an act abolishing Prelacy, and summoned an Assembly
    of Divines to deliberate respecting the formation of such a Confession of
    Faith, Catechism, and Directory, as might lead to uniformity between the
    Churches of the two kingdoms, and thereby tend to secure the religious
    liberty of both. The Assembly of Divines met at Westminster, on the 1st
    day of July, 1643. Soon afterwards Commissioners from the English
    Parliament, and from the Westminster Assembly, were appointed to proceed
    to Edinburgh, to be present at the meeting of the General Assembly in
    August, and to seek a conference, respecting the best method of forming
    the basis of a religious and civil confederacy between the two kingdoms,
    in their time of mutual danger. These Commissioners, accordingly, attended
    the meeting of the Assembly in Edinburgh, and the result of their
    conferences was the framing of that well-known bond of union between the
    two countries, THE SOLEMN LEAGUE AND COVENANT—“a document which we may be
    pardoned for terming the noblest, in its essential nature and principles,
    of all that are recorded among the international transactions of the
    world.”
    
    As the main object for which the Solemn League and Covenant was framed,
    was to secure the utmost practicable degree of uniformity in the religious
    worship of both countries; and, as the English Divines had already met at
    Westminster to take the whole subject into consideration, and had
    requested the assistance of Commissioners from the Church of Scotland, the
    General Assembly named some of the most eminent of their ministers and
    elders as Commissioners to the Westminster Assembly. These were, Alexander
    Henderson, Robert Douglas, Robert Baillie, Samuel Rutherford, and George
    Gillespie, ministers; and the Earl of Cassilis, Lord Maitland, and Sir
    Archibald Johnston of Warriston, elders; but neither the Earl of Cassilis
    nor Robert Douglas went. Three of these, Lord Maitland, Henderson, and
    Gillespie, set off for London, along with the English Commissioners,
    immediately after the rising of the General Assembly; the other three,
    Warriston, Rutherford, and Baillie, followed about a month afterwards. On
    the 15th of September the Scottish Commissioners were received into the
    Westminster Assembly with great kindness and courtesy; and, on the 25th of
    the same month, the Solemn League and Covenant was publicly sworn and
    subscribed by both Parliament and Assembly, after addresses by Nyo and
    Henderson. It was not, however, till the 12th of October, that the
    Westminster Assembly commenced its serious deliberations concerning Church
    Government, Discipline, and a Directory of Worship, in the hope of
    arriving at such conclusions as might produce religious uniformity in the
    Churches of England, Scotland, and Ireland, if not also with the Reformed
    Churches of the Continent.
    
    Scarcely had the Westminster Assembly begun its deliberations, when it
    became abundantly apparent, that, however sincere its members might all be
    in the desire to promote the religious welfare of the community, they
    were, nevertheless, divided in their views as to how that could be best
    accomplished. There were three parties in the Assembly, the Presbyterians,
    the Independents, and the Erastians. Of these the Presbyterians(1) formed
    by far the most numerous, comprising at least nine-tenths of the entire
    body. There were at first only five Independent divines, commonly termed
    “the Five Dissenting Brethren;” but their number finally amounted to ten
    or eleven. Only two ministers were decided Erastians, but a considerable
    number of the parliamentary members, chiefly those who were professionally
    lawyers, advocated that secular policy. The Scottish Commissioners refused
    to exercise the right of voting, but were continually present in the
    Assembly, and took a very prominent part in all its deliberations and
    debates, supporting, as might be expected, the views of the Presbyterians.
    The chief strength of the Independents consisted in the tenacity with
    which they adhered to their own opinions, disputing every proposition
    brought forward by others, but cautiously abstaining from giving any
    definite statement of their own; and in the close intercourse which they
    contrived to keep with Cromwell and the military Independents. And the
    Erastian party, though few in numbers within the Assembly itself,
    possessed, nevertheless, considerable influence, arising out of their
    reputation for learning, having as their ornament and support, that
    distinguished man, emphatically called “the learned Selden.” But the true
    source of their power was the Parliament, which, having deprived the King
    of that ecclesiastical supremacy which he had so grievously abused, wished
    to retain it in its own possession, and therefore, supported the Erastian
    party in the Assembly.
    
    Numerous and protracted were the debates which arose in the Westminster
    Assembly, during the discussion of the various topics on which these three
    parties differed in opinion; and in all those debates no person took a
    more active part, or gained more distinction than George Gillespie. His
    previous course of studies had rendered him perfectly familiar with all
    that had been written on the subjects under discussion; his originally
    acute and powerful intellect had been thoroughly trained and exercised to
    its highest degree of clearness and vigour; and to a natural, perspicuous,
    and flowing readiness of language, the warmth and earnestness of his heart
    added the energy and elevation which form the very essence of true
    eloquence. We have already referred to the high expectations which Baillie
    entertained of his future career. But high as these had been, they were
    far surpassed by the reality, as he himself declares. “None in all the
    company did reason more, and more pertinently than Mr Gillespie. That is
    an excellent youth; my heart blesses God in his behalf!”—“Very learned and
    acute Mr Gillespie, a singular ornament of our church, than whom not one
    in the whole Assembly speaks to better purpose, and with better acceptance
    by all the hearers.”—“Mr George Gillespie, however I had a good opinion of
    his gifts, yet I profess he has much deceived me: Of a truth there is no
    man whose parts in a public dispute I do so admire. He has studied so
    accurately all the points that ever yet came to our Assembly, he has got
    so ready, so assured, so solid a way of public debating, that however
    there be in the Assembly divers very excellent men, yet, in my poor
    judgment, there is not one who speaks more rationally, and to the point,
    than that brave youth has done ever.”
    
    We cannot here follow the course of the prolonged deliberations in which
    Gillespie so greatly distinguished himself; but there is one instance of
    his eminence which has so often been related, and not always very
    accurately, that it would be unpardonable not to give it here,—especially
    as some pains have been taken to obtain as full and correct a version of
    it as is now practicable. After the Westminster Divines had agreed
    respecting the office-bearers whose permanent continuation in the church
    can be proved from scriptural authority; they proceeded to inquire
    concerning the subject of Church Discipline. In this the Presbyterians
    were constrained to encounter both the Independents and the Erastians; for
    the Independents, on the one hand, denied any authoritative
    excommunication or suspension, and the Erastians, on the other, admitted
    such a power, but placed it in the hands of the civil magistracy. For a
    considerable time the discussion was between the Presbyterians and the
    Independents; but when the arguments of the latter party had been
    conclusively met and answered by their antagonists, the Erastians hastened
    to the rescue, and their champion, “the learned Selden,” came to the
    Assembly, when the discussion drew near its close, prepared to pour forth
    all his learning for the discomfiture of the hitherto triumphant
    Presbyterians. His intention had been made known extensively, and even
    before the debate began, the house was crowded by all who could claim or
    obtain admission. Gillespie, who had been probably engaged in some
    Committee business as usual, was rather late in coming, and upon his
    arrival, not being recognised as a member by those who were standing about
    the door and in the passages, was told that it was impossible for him to
    get in, the throng was so dense. “Can ye not admit a _pinning_?” said he,
    using a word employed by masons, to indicate the thin slips of stone with
    which they pin, or fill up the chinks and inequalities that occur in the
    building of a plain wall. He did, however, work his way to the seat
    allotted to the Scottish Commissioners, and took his place beside his
    brethren. The subject under discussion was the text, Matt. xviii. 15-17,
    as bearing upon the question respecting excommunication. Selden arose, and
    in a long and elaborate speech, and with a great display of minute
    rabbinical lore, strove to demonstrate that the passage contained no
    warrant for ecclesiastical jurisdiction, but that it related to the
    ordinary practice of the Jews in their common civil courts, by whom, as he
    asserted, one sentence was excommunication, pronounced by their own
    authority. Somewhat confused, if not appalled, by the vast erudition
    displayed, even the most learned and able of the divines seemed in no
    haste to encounter their formidable opponent. At length both Herle and
    Marshall, two very distinguished men, attempted answers, but failed to
    counteract the effect of Selden’s speech. Gillespie had been observed by
    his Scottish brethren writing occasionally in his note-book, as if marking
    the heads of Selden’s argument; and one of them, some accounts say
    Rutherford, turning to him in this emergency, said, “Rise, George, rise
    up, man, and defend the right of the Lord Jesus Christ to govern, by his
    own laws, the church which he hath purchased with his blood.” Thus urged,
    Gillespie arose, gave first a summary of Selden’s argument, divesting it
    of all the confusion of that cumbrous learning in which it had been
    wrapped, and reducing it to its simple elements; then in a speech of
    singular acuteness and power, completely refuted it, proving that the
    passage could not be interpreted or explained away to mean a mere
    reference to a civil court. By seven distinct arguments he proved, that
    the whole subject was of a spiritual nature, not within the cognisance of
    civil courts; and he proved also, that the church of the Jews both
    possessed and exercised the power of spiritual censures. The effect of
    Gillespie’s speech was so great, as not only to convince the Assembly, but
    also to astonish and confound Seldon himself, who is reported to have
    exclaimed in a tone of bitter mortification, “That young man, by this
    single speech, has swept away the learning and labour of ten years of my
    life!” Those who were clustered together in the passage near the door,
    remembering Gillespie’s expression when he was attempting to enter, said
    one to another, “It was well that we admitted the _pinning_, otherwise the
    building would have fallen.” Even his Scottish brethren, although well
    acquainted with his great abilities, were surprised with his masterly
    analysis of Selden’s argument, and looked into his note-book, expecting
    there to find the outline of the summary which he had given. Their
    surprise was certainly not diminished when they found that he had written
    nothing but, _Da lucem, Domine_, Lord give light,—and similar brief
    petitions for the direction of that divine Head and King of the church,
    whose crown-rights he was about to defend.
    
    Various other anecdotes have been recorded respecting Gillespie’s singular
    skill and ability in debate; but the preceding is at once the most
    striking and the best authenticated, and may suffice to prove his
    eminence, both in learning and in power of argument, among the Westminster
    Divines.(2)
    
    The first part of the task in which the Westminster Assembly was engaged,
    was the framing of a Directory for Public Worship. This having been
    completed about the close of the year 1644, the General Assembly of the
    Church of Scotland met on the 23d of January, 1645, to take this Directory
    into consideration, and to give it their sanction, should it be found
    satisfactory. Baillie and Gillespie were sent to Scotland, to be present
    at the Assembly, that they might introduce the subject, and give any
    explanation that might appear necessary, and to do everything in their
    power to procure for it the desired approbation. In this they were
    completely successful, and the Assembly passed an act sanctioning the
    Directory,—that act having been written, as Baillie informs us, by
    Gillespie. Having accomplished the object of their mission, they returned
    to London, where Gillespie was speedily engaged in the Erastian
    Controversy, during which he produced his greatest work.
    
    We have already referred to the distinguished ability with which Gillespie
    encountered and defeated Selden, in the discussion which arose within the
    Westminster Assembly itself. But the principles of Erastianism were
    entertained by many who were not members of that Assembly, and were
    advocated in other quarters, so as to lead to a literary controversy. The
    Rev. Thomas Coleman, one of the Erastians divines, the other being
    Lightfoot, preached a sermon before the House of Commons, on the 30th of
    July, 1645, in which there was a peculiar display of Erastianism of the
    very strongest kind. This sermon was printed, as were all sermons preached
    before either House, and excited at once the disapprobation of all the
    friends of religious liberty. It did not remain long unanswered. On the
    27th of August, the same year, Gillespie preached before the House of
    Lords; and when his sermon was also published, he added to it an appendix
    entitled, “A Brotherly Examination of some passages of Mr Coleman’s late
    printed sermon.” In this appendix Gillespie not only answered and refuted
    Coleman, but turned his arguments completely against himself. Coleman soon
    afterwards published a pamphlet entitled, “A Brotherly Examination
    Re-examined.” To this Gillespie replied in another bearing the title,
    “Nihil Respondes,” in which he somewhat sharply exposed the weak and
    inconclusive character of his opponent’s argument. Irritated by the
    castigation he had received, Coleman published a bitter reply, to which he
    gave the somewhat unintelligible title of “Male Dicis
    Maledicis,”—intending, probably, to insinuate that Gillespie’s answer was
    of a railing character. This roused Gillespie, and induced him to put
    forth his controversial power in a singularly vigorous pamphlet, entitled,
    “Male Audis,” in which he took a rapid survey of the whole Erastian
    controversy, so far as Coleman and some of his friends had brought it
    forward, convicted him and them of numerous self-contradictions, of
    unsoundness in theology, of violating the covenant which they had sworn,
    and of inculcating opinions fatal to both civil and religious liberty. To
    this powerful production Coleman attempted no reply; nor have its
    arguments ever been answered by any subsequent advocate of Erastianism.
    
    But however able and well-timed these controversial pamphlets were, they
    were not enough to occupy even the few spare hours that Gillespie was able
    to snatch from his attendance on the business of the Assembly. He had
    planned, and was all the while prosecuting, a much larger work. That work
    appeared about the close of the year 1646, under the title of “Aaron’s Rod
    Blossoming: or, the Divine Ordinance of Church Government Vindicated.” In
    this remarkably able and elaborate production, Gillespie took up the
    Erastian controversy as stated and defended by its ablest advocates,
    fairly encountering their strongest arguments, and assailing their most
    formidable positions, in the frank and fearless manner of a man thoroughly
    sincere, and thoroughly convinced of the truth and goodness of his cause.
    As it may be presumed that the readers of this memoir are also in
    possession of “Aaron’s Rod,” we need not occupy space in giving even a
    brief outline of that admirable work; but as we are convinced that the
    Erastian conflict, which has been recently resumed, must still be fought,
    and will be ultimately won, we strenuously recommend the studious perusal
    of Gillespie’s masterly production to all who wish fully to comprehend the
    subject.(3) One or two points of general information, however, it may be
    expedient to give. In the “Aaron’s Rod,” while Gillespie intentionally
    traversed the whole ground of the Erastian controversy, he directed also
    special attention to the productions of the day. This he could not avoid;
    but this has tended unfortunately, to give to his work the appearance of
    being to some extent an ephemeral production, suited to the period when it
    appeared, but not so well suited to the present times. It addresses itself
    to answer the arguments of Selden, and Coleman, and Hussey, and Prynne;
    and as the writings of these men have sunk into oblivion, we are liable to
    regard the work which answered them as one which has done its deed, and
    may also be allowed to disappear. Let it be observed, that Erastianism
    never had abler advocates than the above-named men. Selden was so
    pre-eminent for learning that his distinguishing designation was “the
    learned Selden.” Coleman was so thoroughly conversant with Hebrew
    literature, that he was commonly termed “Rabbi Coleman.” Hussey, minister
    at Chessilhurst in Kent, was a man of great eloquence, both as a speaker
    and a writer, and possessed no small influence among the strong-minded men
    of that period. And Prynne had a double claim on public attention both
    then and still; for he had been so formidable an antagonist of the Laudean
    Prelacy, as to have been marked out by Laud as a special victim,—had been
    condemned to the pillory, and suffered the loss of both his ears by the
    sentence of that cruel prelate,—and had been rescued from his sufferings,
    and restored to political life and influence, by the Long Parliament. He
    was, moreover, both a learned man, an acute lawyer, and an able and subtle
    controversialist, and his writings exercised at the time no mean
    influence. When such men undertook the advocacy of the Erastian argument,
    encouraged as they were by the English Parliament, it may well be
    conceived that they would present it both in its ablest, and in its most
    plausible form. And it is doing no discredit to Erastians of the present
    day, to say that they are not likely to produce anything either more
    profound in learning, or more able and acute in reasoning than was done by
    their predecessors of the Long Parliament, and the Westminster Assembly.
    If, therefore, Gillespie’s Aaron’s Rod completely defeated the acute and
    able men of that day, we may well recommend it to the perusal of those
    whose duty it may be to engage in a similar controversy in the present
    age.
    
    But while such were Gillespie’s labours in the field of controversy, the
    value of which could not be easily over-estimated, his memory would be
    grievously wronged were we to regard him only as a controversialist. For
    although the topics which first engaged the attention of the Westminster
    Assembly were those on which the greatest difference of opinion existed,
    and to which, almost of necessity, the public mind, both then and ever
    since, has been most strongly directed, there was a very large portion of
    their duty, and that, too, of the highest importance, and demanding the
    utmost care, in which a much greater degree of unanimity prevailed. For a
    considerable time after the Assembly commenced its deliberations, its
    attention was almost exclusively occupied with the framing of Directories
    for public worship and ordination, and with discussions respecting the
    form of Church government, including the power of Church censure. These
    topics involved both the Independent and the Erastian controversies; and
    till some satisfactory conclusions had been reached on these points, the
    Assembly abstained from entering upon the less agitating, but not less
    important work of framing a Confession of Faith. But having completed
    their task, so far as depended upon themselves, they then turned their
    attention to their doctrinal labours.
    
    The manner in which the Assembly entered upon this solemn duty deserves
    the utmost attention, as intimating the earnest and prudent spirit by
    which their whole deliberations were pervaded. They appointed a committee
    to prepare and arrange the main propositions which were to be examined and
    digested into a system by the Assembly. The members of this committee
    were, Dr Hoyle, Dr Gouge, Messrs Herle, Gataker, Tuckney, Reynolds, and
    Vines, with the Scottish Commissioners Henderson, Baillie, Rutherford, and
    Gillespie. Those learned and able divines began their labours by
    arranging, in the most systematic order, the various great and sacred
    truths which God has revealed to man; and then reduced these to thirty-two
    distinct heads or chapters, each having a title expressive of its subject.
    These were again subdivided into sections; and the committee formed
    themselves into several subcommittees, each of which took a specific topic
    for the sake of exact and concentrated deliberation. When these
    sub-committees had completed their respective tasks, the whole results
    were laid before the entire committee, and any alterations suggested and
    debated till all were of one mind. And when any title, or chapter, had
    been thus fully prepared by the committee, it was reported to the
    Assembly, and again subjected to the most minute and careful
    investigation, in every paragraph, sentence, and even word. All that
    learning the most profound, intellect the most searching, and piety the
    most sincere could accomplish, was thus concentrated in the Westminster
    Assembly’s Confession of Faith, which may be safely termed the most
    perfect statement of systematic Theology ever framed by the Christian
    Church.
    
    In the preliminary deliberations of the Committee the Scottish divines
    took a leading part, and none more than Gillespie. But no report of these
    deliberations either was or could be made public. The results alone
    appeared when the Committee, from time to time, laid its matured
    propositions before the Assembly. And it is gratifying to be able to add,
    that throughout the deliberations of the Assembly itself, when composing,
    or rather, formally sanctioning the Confession of Faith, there prevailed
    almost an entire and perfect harmony. There appears, indeed, to have been
    only _two_ subjects on which any difference of opinion existed among them.
    The one of these was the doctrine of Election, concerning which Baillie
    informs us they had “long and tough debates;” the other was concerning
    that which heads the chapter entitled “Of Church Censures,” as its
    fundamental proposition, viz. “The Lord Jesus Christ, as King and Head of
    his Church, has therein appointed a government in the hand of
    church-officers distinct from the civil magistrate.” This proposition the
    Assembly manifestly intended and understood to contain a principle
    directly and necessarily opposed to the very essence of Erastianism, and
    it was regarded in the same light by the Erastians themselves, hence it
    had to encounter their most strenuous opposition. It was, however,
    somewhat beyond the grasp of the lay-members of the Assembly, especially
    since their champion Selden had in a great measure withdrawn from the
    debates after his signal discomfiture by Gillespie, and consequently it
    was triumphantly carried, the single dissentient voice being that of
    Lightfoot, the other Erastian divine, Coleman, having died before the
    conclusion of the debate. The framing of the Confession occupied the
    Assembly nearly a year. After having been carefully transcribed, it was
    presented to the parliament on the 3d of December, 1646.
    
    A plan similar to that already described was also employed in preparing
    that admirable digest of Christian doctrine, the Shorter Catechism, and so
    far as can be ascertained, by the same Committee. For a time, indeed, they
    attempted to prosecute the framing of both Confession and Catechism at
    once; but after some progress had been made with both, the Assembly
    resolved to finish the Confession first, and then to construct the
    Catechism upon its model, so far at least as to have no proposition in the
    one which was not in the other. By this arrangement they wisely avoided
    the danger of subsequent debate and delay. Various obstacles, however,
    interposed, and so greatly impeded the progress of the Assembly, that the
    Catechism was not so speedily completed as had been expected. It was,
    however, presented to the House of Commons on the 5th of November 1647,
    and the Larger, in the spring of the following year.
    
    There is one anecdote connected with the formation of the Shorter
    Catechism both full of interest and so very beautiful, that it must not be
    omitted. In one of the earliest meetings of the Committee, the subject of
    deliberation was to frame an answer to the question “_What is God_?” Each
    man felt the unapproachable sublimity of the divine idea suggested by
    these words; but who could venture to give it expression in human
    language! All shrunk from the too sacred task in awe-struck reverential
    fear. At length it was resolved, as an expression of the Committee’s deep
    humility, that the youngest member should first make the attempt. He
    consented; but begged that the brethren would first unite with him in
    prayer for divine enlightenment. Then in slow and solemn accents he thus
    began his prayer:—“O God, Thou art a Spirit, infinite, eternal, and
    unchangeable, in Thy being, wisdom, power, holiness, justice, goodness and
    truth.”—When he ceased, the first sentence of his prayer was immediately
    written down and adopted, as the most perfect answer that could be
    conceived, as, indeed, in a very sacred sense, God’s own answer,
    descriptive of Himself.(4) Who, then, was the youngest member of the
    Committee? When we compare the birth-dates of the respective members of
    the Committee, we find that George Gillespie was the youngest by more than
    a dozen years. We may, therefore, safely conclude, that George Gillespie
    was the man who was thus guided to frame this marvellous answer.
    
    Without further enlarging on these points, we may, without hazard, affirm,
    that however eminent Gillespie was in the department of controversy, he
    was scarcely, if at all, less so in that of systematic theology, while his
    personal piety was of the most elevated and spiritual character. Rarely,
    indeed, have such qualities met in any one man, as were united in him; but
    when God requires such a man, he creates, endows and trains him, so as to
    meet the necessity.
    
    When the public labours of the Westminster Assembly drew near a close, the
    Scottish commissioners returned to their native country. Henderson had
    previously found the repose of the grave, Rutherford remained a short time
    behind. Baillie and Gillespie appeared at the General Assembly which met
    in August, 1647, and laid before that supreme ecclesiastical court the
    result of their protracted labours. The Confession of Faith was ratified
    by that Assembly. The same Assembly caused to be printed a series of
    propositions, or “Theses against Erastianism,” as Baillie terms them,
    amounting to one hundred and eleven, drawn up by George Gillespie,
    embodying eight of them in the act which authorised their publication. The
    perusal of these propositions would enable any person of unprejudiced and
    intelligent mind to master and refute the whole Erastian theory; and could
    not fail, at the same time, to draw forth sentiments of admiration towards
    the clear and strong mind by which they were framed.
    
    But the incessant toils in which Gillespie’s life had been spent had
    shattered his constitution beyond the power of recovery; and the state in
    which he found Scotland on his return was such as to permit no relaxation
    of these toils. The danger in which the obstinacy and duplicity of Charles
    I. had placed that unhappy monarch’s life, drew forth towards him the
    strong compassion of all who cherished sentiments of loyalty to the
    sovereign and pity for the man. But in many instances these generous
    feelings were allowed to bias the dictates of religious principle and
    sound judgment; and a party began to be formed for the purpose of
    attempting to save the King even at the hazard of entering into a war with
    England. This was, of course, eagerly encouraged by all who had previously
    adhered to the King’s party in the contest between him and the
    Covenanters; and a series of intrigues began and were carried on, breaking
    the harmony which had previously existed, and preparing for the disastrous
    consequences which soon afterwards ensued. Gillespie exerted himself to
    the utmost of his power to avert the coming calamities which he
    anticipated, by striving to prevent the commission of crimes which provoke
    judgment. His influence was sufficient to restrain the Church from
    consenting to countenance the weak and wicked movements of politicians.
    But his health continued to sink under these incessant toils and
    anxieties. He was chosen moderator of the General Assembly of 1648,
    though, as Baillie states, “he did much deprecate the burden, as he had
    great reason, both for his health’s sake, and other great causes.”
    
    This Assembly met on the 12th of July, 1648, and so arduous and difficult
    were the duties which it had to discharge, that it did not end its labours
    till the 12th of August. Although Gillespie was then rapidly sinking under
    the disease of which he died, which, from its symptoms, must have been
    consumption, he continued to take an active part in all its deliberations,
    and drew up the last public paper which it directed to be framed, in
    answer to a document, issued by the State, respecting the engagement that
    had been formed for the support of the King. The arduous labours of the
    Assembly being thus ended, Gillespie left Edinburgh and retired to
    Kirkcaldy, with the view of seeking, by change of scene and air, some
    renovation to his health. But the disease had taken too firm a hold of his
    enfeebled constitution, and he continued to suffer from increasing
    weakness. Still the cares of the distracted Church and country pressed
    heavily on his mind. He was now unable to attend the public meetings of
    Church courts; but on the 8th of September he addressed a letter to the
    Commission of Assembly, in which he stated clearly and strongly his
    opinion concerning the duties and the dangers of the time. Continuing to
    sink, and feeling death at hand, he partly wrote and partly dictated what
    may be termed his dying “Testimony against association with malignant
    enemies of the truth and godliness.”(5) At length, on the 17th day of
    December, 1648, his toils and sorrows ceased, and he fell asleep in Jesus.
    
    So passed away from this world one of those bright and powerful spirits
    which are sent in troublous times to carry forward God’s work among
    mankind. Incessant toil is the destiny of such highly-gifted men while
    here below; and not unfrequently is their memory assailed by those mean
    and little minds who shrunk with instinctive fear and hatred before the
    energetic movements which they could neither comprehend nor encounter. But
    their recompense is in heaven, when their work is done; and future
    generations delight to rescue their reputation from the feeble obloquy
    with which malevolence and folly had endeavoured to hide or defame it.
    Thus has it been with George Gillespie to a considerable extent already;
    and we entertain not the slightest shadow of doubt that his transcendent
    merit is but beginning to be known and appreciated as it deserves, and
    that ere very long his well-earned fame will shine too clearly and too
    strong to be approached by detractors.
    
                                    * * * * *
    
    We have but little more to relate respecting George Gillespie. His death
    was deeply lamented by all who loved their church and country at the time;
    and such was the feeling generally entertained of his great merit, that
    the Committee of Estates, or government of the kingdom, by an Act dated
    20th December, 1648, did, “as an acknowledgment for his faithfulness in
    all the public employments entrusted to him by this Church, both at home
    and abroad, his faithful labours, and indefatigable diligence in all the
    exercises of his ministerial calling, for his Master’s service, and his
    learned writings, published to the world, in which rare and profitable
    employments, both for Church and State, he truly spent himself and closed
    his days, ordain, That the sum of one thousand pounds sterling be given to
    his widow and children.” And though the Parliament did, by their Act,
    dated June 8th, 1650, unanimously ratify the preceding Act, and
    recommended to their Committee to make the same effectual, yet in
    consequence of Cromwell’s invasion, and the confusion into which the whole
    kingdom was thereby thrown, this benevolent design was frustrated, as his
    grandson, the Rev. George Gillespie, minister at Strathmiglo, afterwards
    declared.(6) So much for the trust to be placed in national gratitude and
    the promises of statesmen.
    
    George Gillespie was buried at Kirkcaldy, his birth-place, and the place
    also where he died. A tomb-stone, erected to his memory by his relatives
    and friends, bore an inscription in Latin, recording the chief actions of
    his life, and stating the leading elements of his character. But when
    Prelacy was re-imposed on Scotland, after the restoration of Charles II.,
    the mean malice of the Prelatists gratified itself by breaking the
    tomb-stone. This petty and spiteful act is thus recorded in the “Mercurius
    Caledonius,” one of the small quarto newspapers or periodicals of the
    time, of date January 16th to 25th, 1661. “The late Committee of Estates
    ordered the tomb-stone of Mr George Gillespie, whereon was engraven a
    scandalous inscription, should be fetched from the burial place, and upon
    a market-day, at the cross of Kirkcaldy, where he had formerly been
    minister, and there solemnly broken by the hands of the hangman; which was
    accordingly done,—a just indignity upon the memory of so dangerous a
    person.”
    
    The Committee of Estates by which this paltry deed was done was that of
    Middleton’s parliament, frequently called the “drunken parliament,” from
    the excesses of its leading men, and which on the following year
    signalised itself by the Glasgow act,—that act which emptied nearly four
    hundred pulpits in one day. The inaccuracy of the statement made by the
    prelatic newspaper, asserting that he had formerly been minister at
    Kirkcaldy, will not surprise any person who is acquainted with the
    writings of the Prelatists of that period, who seem not to have been able
    to write the truth when relating the most common and well-known facts. But
    one is somewhat surprised to find statements equally inaccurate made
    respecting George Gillespie, by reverend and learned historians. In Dr
    Cook’s History of the Church of Scotland, we find in one passage George
    Gillespie’s character and conduct completely misunderstood and
    misrepresented, (vol. iii. pages 160-162), and in a subsequent passage an
    assertion that the proceedings of that party in the church called the
    Protestors were, in the year 1650, “directed by Gillespie, a factious
    minister, whose name has been frequently mentioned,” (page 196). George
    Gillespie was the only person of whom mention was made, or could be made,
    in the previous portion of the history, as his brother had not then began
    to take any active part in public affairs; but he was dead nearly two
    years before the date to which the latter passage refers. It is plain that
    Dr Cook confounded George Gillespie with his brother Patrick, and ascribed
    to the former the actions of the latter, regarding them both as but one
    and the same person. He further asserts, that Gillespie was “suspected of
    corresponding with the Sectaries.” That Patrick Gillespie corresponded
    with the Sectaries, and was much trusted and countenanced by Cromwell, is
    perfectly true; but before that time George Gillespie had joined the One
    Church and family in heaven. In every period of his life, and in every
    transaction in which he was engaged, George Gillespie was far above all
    private or discreditable intriguing, which is the vice of weak, cunning,
    and selfish minds. And while we do not think it necessary further to
    prosecute this vindication of his memory, we yet think it our duty, when
    writing a memoir of him, thus briefly to set aside the groundless
    accusation, whether it be adduced by prelatic or Erastian writers,—his
    baffled antagonists when living, his impotent calumniators when dead.
    
    The tomb-stone, as has been related, was broken in 1661, but the
    inscription was preserved. A plain tablet was erected in 1745, by his
    grandson, the Rev. George Gillespie, minister of Strathmiglo, on which the
    inscription was re-produced, with a slight addition, mentioning both
    events. It is still to be seen in the south-east porch of the present
    church. The inscription is as follows:—
    
    
        MAGISTER GEORGIUS GILLESPIE, PASTOR EDINBURGENSIS, JUVENILIBUS
        ANNIS RITUUM ANGLORUM PONTIFICIORUM TURMAM PROSTRAVIT: GLISCENTE
        AETATE, DELEGATUS CUM MANDATIS IN SYNODO ANGLICANA, PRÆSULEM E
        ANGLIA ERADICANDUM, SINCERUM DEI CULTUM UNIFORMEM PROMOVENDUM,
        CURAVIT; ERASTUM AARONIS GERMINANTE VIRGA CASTIGAVIT. IN PATRIAM
        REVERSUS FOEDIFRAGOS ANGLIAM BELLO LACESSENTES LABEFACTAVIT:
        SYNODI NATIONALIS ANNO 1648, EDINBURGI HABITÆ PRÆSES ELECTUS,
        EXTREMAM PATIRÆ SUÆ OPERAM CUM LAUDE NAVAVIT: CUMQUE OCULATIS
        TESTIS VIDISSET MALIGNANTIUM QUAM PRÆDIXERAT RUINAM, EODEM QUO
        FOEDUS TRIUM GENTIUM SOLENNE RENOVATUM TUIT DIE DECEDENS IN PACE,
        ANNO ÆTATIS 36, IN GAUDIUM DOMINI INTRAVIT: INGENIO PROFUNDUS,
        GENIO MITIS, DISPUTATIONE ACUTUS, ELOQUIO FACUNDUS, ANIMO
        INVICTUS, BONOS IN AMOREM, MALOS IN INVIDIAM, OMNES IN SUI
        ADMIRATIONEM, RAPUIT: PATLÆ SUÆ ORNAMENTUM; TANTO PATRE DIGNA
        SOBOLES.
    
    
        THIS TOMB BEING PULLED DOWN BY THE MALIGNANT INFLUENCE OF
        ARCHBISHOP SHARP, AFTER THE INTRODUCTION OF PRELACY, MR GEORGE
        GILLESPIE, MINISTER OF THE GOSPEL AT STRATHMIGLO, CAUSED IT TO BE
        RE-ERECTED, IN HONOUR OF HIS SAID WORTHY GRANDFATHER, AND AS A
        STANDING MONUMENT OF DUTIFUL REGARD TO HIS BLESSED MEMORY; ANNO
        DOMINI, 1746.
    
    
    It may be expedient to give a translation:—
    
    
        “Master George Gillespie, minister at Edinburgh, in his youthful
        years overthrew a host of ‘English popish ceremonies;’ as he
        approached full manhood, having been sent as commissioner to the
        Westminster Assembly, his attention was directed to the task of
        extirpating Prelacy from England, and promoting purity and
        uniformity in the worship of God. He chastised Erastianism in his
        ‘Aaron’s Rod Blossoming.’ Having returned to his native country he
        weakened the violators of the covenant, who were bent on provoking
        a war with England.(7) Having been chosen moderator of the General
        Assembly which met at Edinburgh in the year 1648, he devoted his
        last exertions to the service of his country so as to draw forth
        public approbation: and having, as an eye-witness, seen that ruin
        of the malignants which he had foretold, departing in peace on the
        same day on which the League of the three kingdoms was solemnly
        renewed, in the 36th year of his age, he entered into the joy of
        the Lord. He was a man profound in genius, mild in disposition,
        acute in argument, flowing in eloquence, unconquered in mind. He
        drew to himself the love of the good, the envy of the bad, and the
        admiration of all. He was an ornament of his country,—a son worthy
        of such a father.”
    
    
    Such was the “scandalous inscription” which the peevish spleen, yet bitter
    malice of Scottish Prelacy, found gratification in attempting to destroy.
    But there is a righteous retribution even in this world. Men rear their
    own monuments, and write inscriptions on them which time cannot
    obliterate. Gillespie’s enduring monument is in his actions and his
    writings, which latest ages will admire. The monuments of Scottish Prelacy
    are equally imperishable, whether in the wantonly defaced tomb-stones of
    piety and patriotism, or in the moss-grown martyr-stones that stud the
    moors and glens of our native land; and the inscriptions thereupon are
    fearfully legible with records of indelible infamy.
    
    It remains but to offer a few remarks respecting Gillespie’s various
    works. The first production of his pen was his remarkable “Dispute against
    the English Popish Ceremonies.” It was published in 1637, when its author
    was only in the 25th year of his age; and it must have been completed some
    time previous to its publication, as it appears to have been printed
    abroad, most probably in Holland. This gives countenance to one statement
    which affirms it to have been written when Gillespie had scarcely passed
    his 22d year.
    
    His next work was published in London, in the year 1641, where he was
    during the progress of the treaty with the King. It is referred to by
    Baillie in the following terms:—“Think not we live any of us here to be
    idle; Mr Henderson has ready now a short treatise, much called for, of our
    church discipline; Mr Gillespie has the grounds of Presbyterial Government
    well Asserted; Mr Blair, a pertinent answer to Hall’s Remonstrance: all
    these are ready for the press.” The valuable treatise here referred to has
    not been so much noticed as several other of Gillespie’s writings, but is
    included in this collective edition.
    
    His Sermons and Controversial Pamphlets were produced in the years
    1641-5-6, during the sittings of the Westminster Assembly.
    
    Aaron’s Rod Blossoming was published at London also, about the close of
    the year 1646. This is his greatest work.
    
    The celebrated Hundred and Eleven Propositions were prepared before he
    left London, and laid before the General Assembly on his return to
    Scotland in the summer of 1647. Perhaps it is not possible to obtain a
    clear conception of Erastianism better than by the study of these
    propositions. They have been reprinted several times, yet were rarely to
    be obtained.
    
    The short, yet very able and high-principled papers which he prepared for
    the Assembly and its Commission in 1648, were his latest writings.
    
    A short time after his death, and during the year 1649, his brother
    Patrick published in one volume, entitled a “Treatise of Miscellany
    Questions,” a series of papers, twenty-two in number, on a variety of
    important topics, which appeared to be in a condition fit for the press.
    Though this is a posthumous production, and consequently without its
    author’s finishing corrections, it displays the same clearness, precision,
    and logical power, which characterise his other works. We are inclined to
    conjecture that these Essays, as we would now term them, were written at
    different times during the course of several years, and while he was
    studying the various topics to which they relate. Several of them are on
    subjects which were debated in the Westminster Assembly; and it is very
    probable that Gillespie wrote them while maturing his views on these
    points preparatory for those discussions in which he so greatly
    distinguished himself. This conjecture is strengthened by the curious and
    interesting fact, that a paper, which will be found beginning at page 109
    of the part now printed for the first time from the MS., is almost
    identical, both in argument and language, though somewhat different in
    arrangement, with chapter viii. pages 115 to 120, of Aaron’s Rod. The
    arrangement in the Aaron’s Rod is more succinct than in the paper referred
    to, but its principles, and very much of the language, are altogether the
    same. May not this indicate Gillespie’s mode of study and composition? May
    he not have been in the habit of concentrating his mind on the leading
    topics of the subjects which he was studying, writing out pretty fully and
    carefully his thoughts on these topics, and afterwards connecting and
    arranging them so as to form one complete work? If so, then we may
    conclude that the Miscellany Questions contain such of these masses of
    separate thinking as Gillespie found no opportunity of using in any other
    manner, and, therefore, consented to their publication in their present
    form.
    
    In Wodrow’s Analecta it is stated that Gillespie had a manuscript volume
    of sermons prepared for the press, which were bought from the printer by
    the Sectaries, and probably destroyed. It is also stated, that there were
    six octavo volumes of notes written by Gillespie at the Westminster
    Assembly then extant, containing an abstract of its deliberations. Of
    these manuscript volumes there are two copies in the Wodrow MSS.,
    Advocates’ Library, but neither of them appears to be Gillespie’s own
    hand-writing; the quarto certainly is not, and the octavo seems to be an
    accurate copy of _two_ of the original volumes. These have been collated
    and transcribed by Mr Meek, with his well-known care and fidelity, and the
    result is now, for the first time, given to the public. What has become of
    the missing volumes is not known, and it is to be feared the loss is
    irrecoverable. There is one consideration, however, which mitigates our
    regret for the loss of these volumes. The one which has been preserved
    begins February 2d, 1644, and ends January 3d, 1645.(8) Lightfoot’s
    Journal continues till the end of 1644, and then terminates abruptly, as
    if he had not felt it necessary any longer to continue noting down the
    outline of the debates. Yet Lightfoot continued to attend the Assembly
    throughout the whole of its protracted deliberations. From other sources
    also, we learn that the whole of the points on which there existed any
    considerable difference of opinion in the Assembly, had been largely
    debated during the year 1644, so that little remained to be said on either
    side. The differences, indeed, continued; but they assumed the form of
    written controversy, the essence of which we have in the volume entitled,
    “The Grand Debate.” It is probable, therefore, that the lost volumes of
    Gillespie’s manuscript contained chiefly his own remarks on the writings
    of the Independents, and, not unlikely, the outlines of the answers
    returned by the Assembly. Supposing this to be the case, it would
    doubtless have been very interesting to have had Gillespie’s remarks and
    arguments, but they could not have given much information which we do not
    at present possess.
    
    A few brief notices respecting the papers now first published may both be
    interesting, and may conduce to rendering them intelligible to the general
    reader.
    
    There is _first_, an extract attested by the scribes, or clerks, of the
    Westminster Assembly, copied from the original, by Wodrow, and giving a
    statement of the Votes on Discipline and Government, from session 76, to
    session 186.
    
    _Second_, Notes of Proceedings from February 2, to May 14, 1644, to p. 64.
    
    _Third_, Notes of Proceedings from September 4, 1644, to January 3, 1645,
    to p. 100. (By consulting Lightfoot, we learn that the time between May
    and September was occupied chiefly in debates respecting Ordination, the
    mode of dispensing the Lord’s Supper, Excommunication, and Baptism, with
    some minor points.)
    
    _Fourth_, Debates in the Sub-committee respecting the Directory, 4th
    March, to 10th June, p. 101-2.
    
    _Fifth_, Notes of Proceedings in the Grand Committee, from September 20,
    to October 25, 1644, p. 103-7. This part of the manuscript, though short,
    is of very considerable importance, as giving us a specimen of the manner
    in which the Grand Committee acted. The Grand Committee was composed of
    some of the most influential persons of the Lords, of the Commons, and of
    the Assembly, together with the Scottish Commissioners. The duty of that
    Committee was to consult together respecting the subjects to be brought
    before the Assembly, and to prepare a formal statement of those subjects
    for the purpose of regular deliberation. By this process a large amount of
    debate was precluded, and the leading men were enabled to understand each
    other’s sentiments before the more public discussions began. And as the
    Scottish Commissioners were necessarily constituent members of this
    Committee, their influence in directing the whole proceedings was both
    very great, and in constant operation. Lightfoot’s journal gives no
    account of the proceedings of this Committee.
    
    _Sixth_, A paper on excommunication, &c. It has already been mentioned
    that this paper is nearly identical with part of a chapter in the Aaron’s
    Rod.
    
    _Seventh_, A short note on some discussions which took place in the
    Committee of the General Assembly at Edinburgh, on the 7th and 8th of
    February, 1645, at the time when Baillie and Gillespie laid before the
    Assembly the Directory which had been recently completed.
    
    _Eighth_, The Ordinance of the two Houses of the English Parliament, 12th
    June, 1643, summoning the Assembly of Divines. This is added chiefly for
    the purpose of shewing the intention of the Parliament in calling the
    Assembly.
    
    It has been already stated that there are two MS. volumes, purporting to
    be copies of Gillespie’s Notes. The one of these is in octavo, and seems
    to have been carefully taken; the other is in quarto, and appears to be
    partly a copy, partly an abstract. In it Gillespie is always spoken of in
    the third person, which has caused many variations. The transcriber has
    also made many omissions, not only of one, but of several paragraphs at a
    time, frequently passing over the remarks of the several speakers. It
    appears to have been his object to copy chiefly the argumentative part of
    the manuscript. This defective transcription had belonged to Mr William
    Veitch, as appears from his name written on the cover and first page, with
    the addition “minister at Peebles, 1691.” In the copy transcribed for the
    press, the octavo manuscript has been followed. The quarto, however, along
    with Lightfoot, has been found useful in correcting the Scripture
    references, which had all to be carefully examined and verified; but
    sometimes all three failed to give satisfaction, and a conjectural
    substitute has been given, enclosed in brackets, and with a point of
    interrogation. In concluding these remarks, we cannot help expressing
    great gratification to see for the first time a complete edition of the
    works of George Gillespie; and in order also to complete the memoir, we
    add, as an appendix, some very interesting extracts from the Maitland Club
    edition of Wodrow’s Analecta, chiefly relative to his last illness and
    death.
    
    
    
    
    
    APPENDIX. EXTRACTS FROM WODROW’S ANALECTA (MAITLAND CLUB EDITION)
    
    
    “MR GEORGE GILLESPIE.
    
    “Mr George Gillespie, first minister of Kirkcaldy, and afterward minister
    of Edinburgh; when he was a child, he seemed to be somewhat dull and soft
    like, so that his mother would have stricken and abused him, and she would
    have made much of Patrick, his younger brother. His father, Mr John
    Gillespie, minister of Kirkcaldy, was angry to see his wife carry so to
    his son George; and he would have said, ‘My heart, let alone; though
    Patrick may have some respect given him in the Church, yet my son George
    will be the great man in the Church of Scotland.’ And he said of him when
    he was a-dying, ‘George, George, I have gotten many a brave promise for
    thee.’ And indeed he was very soon a great man; for it’s reported, that
    before he was a preacher, he wrote the ‘English Popish Ceremonies.’ He
    was, of all ministers in his time, one of the greatest men for disputing
    and arguing; so that he was, being but a young man, much admired at the
    Assembly at Westminster, by all that heard him; he being one of the
    youngest members that was there. I heard old Mr Patrick Simson say, that
    he heard his cousin, Mr George Gillespie say, ‘Let no man who is called of
    God to any work, be it never so great and difficult, distrust God for
    assistance, as I clearly found at that great Assembly at Westminster. If I
    were to live a long time in the world, I would not desire a more noble
    life, than the life of pure and single dependence on God; for, said he,
    though I may have a claim to some gifts of learning and parts, yet I ever
    found more advantage by single looking to God for assistance than by all
    the parts and gifts that ever I could pretend to, at that time.’
    
    “When he was at London, he would be often on his knees; at another time,
    reading and writing. And when he was sitting in that great Assembly at
    Westminster, he was often observed to have a little book, and to be
    marking down something with his pen in that book, even when some of the
    most learned men, as Coleman and Selden, were delivering their long and
    learned orations, and all he was writing was for the most part his pithy
    ejaculations to God, writing these words; _Da lucem, Domine; Da lucem!_
    When these learned men had ended their oration, the Moderator proposed who
    should give an answer to their discourse; they all generally voted Mr
    Gillespie to be the person. He being a young man, seemed to blush, and
    desired to be excused, when so many old and learned divines were present,
    yet all the brethren, with one voice, determined he should be the person
    that should give an answer to that learned oration. Though he seemed to
    take little heed, yet being thus pressed, he rose up, and resumed all the
    particulars of that learned oration very distinctly, and answered every
    part of it so fully, that all that heard him were amazed and astonished;
    for he died in 1648, and was then but about thirty-six years of age. Mr
    Calamy, if I be not forgotten, said, we were ready to think more of Mr
    Gillespie than was truly meet; if he had not been stained by being against
    our way and judgment for the Engagement.
    
    “He was one of the great men that had a chief hand in penning our most
    excellent Confession of Faith and Catechisms. He was a most grave and bold
    man, and had a most wonderful gift given him for disputing and arguing. My
    father told me, he observed that when there was a considerable number of
    ministers met, there were several of our great nobles were strongly
    reasoning with our ministers about the engagement 1648. When Mr Gillespie
    was busy studying his sermon that he was to preach before the Parliament
    to-morrow, the ministers sent privately for Mr Gillespie, whom he observed
    to come in very quietly, and when Lauderdale, Glencairn, and some others,
    rose up and debated very strongly for the engagement, Mr Gillespie rose up
    and answered them so fully and distinctly, firstly, secondly, and thirdly,
    that he fully silenced them all; and Glencairn said, ‘There is no standing
    before this great and mighty man!’ I heard worthy Mr Rowat say, that Mr
    Gillespie said, ‘The more truly great a man is, he was really the more
    humble and low in his own eyes,’ as he instanced in the great man Daniel;
    and, said he, ‘God did not make choice of some of us as his instruments in
    the glorious work of Reformation, because we were more fit than others,
    but rather because we were more unfit than others.’ He was called _Malleus
    Mallignantium_, and Mr Baillie, writing to some in this church anent Mr
    George Gillespie, said, ‘He was truly an ornament to our church and
    nation.’ And Mr James Brown, late minister of Glasgow, told me that there
    was an English gentleman said to him, that he heard Mr Gillespie preach,
    and he said, he believed he was one of the greatest Presbyterians in the
    world. He was taken from the Greyfriars’ Church to the New Church. He has
    written several pieces, as ‘Aaron’s Rod Blossoming,’ and ‘Some Miscellany
    Questions,’ and his ‘Assertion of the Government of the Church of
    Scotland, about Ruling Elders.’ He had several little books wherein he set
    down his remarks upon the proceedings of the Assembly at
    Westminster.”—WODROW’S ANALECTA, vol. iii. pp. 109-18.
    
    “What follows here I have in conversation with Mr Patrick Simpson, whose
    memory was most exact. What concerns Mr Gillespie, and the Marquis of
    Montrose, I read over to him, and he corrected. The rest are hints I set
    down after conversation, when two or three days with him in his house at
    Renfrew, in the year 1707.
    
    (ACCOUNT OF THE LAST ILLNESS AND DEATH OF MR GEORGE GILLESPIE.)
    
    “Mr George Gillespie being moderator of the Assembly held at Edinburgh,
    July 12th, 1648, was all the time thereof, as also half a year before, in
    a greater weakness of body than ordinary; that being now come to a height,
    which long before had been gathering. He had a great hoasting and
    sweating, which in the time of the General Assembly began to grow worse;
    but being extraordinarily (so I may say) upheld, was not so sensible as
    when the Assembly dissolved it appeared to be. On occasion whereof, the
    next Wednesday after the rising of the Assembly, he went with his wife
    over to Kirkcaldy, there intending to tarry for a space, till it should
    please the Lord, by the use of means, to restore him to some more health
    to come over again. But when he was come there, his weakness and disease
    grew daily more and more, so that no application of any strength durst be
    used towards him. It came to that, he kept his chamber still to his death,
    wearing and wasting hoasting, and sweating. Ten days before his death his
    sweating went away, and his hoasting lessened, yet his weakness still
    encreased, and his flux still continued. On Wednesday morning, which day
    he began to keep his bed, his pain began to be very violent, his breath
    more obstructed, his heart oppressed; and that growing all the next night
    to a very great height, in the midst of the night there were letters
    written to his brother, and Mr Rutherford, and Mr John Row, his death
    approaching fast. On Friday all day, and Thursday all night, he was at
    some ease. Friday at night, till Saturday in the afternoon, in great
    violence, the greatness of pain causing want of sleep. Mr Rutherford and
    Lord Craigihall came to visit him. Thus much for his body. Now I’ll speak
    a little of what concerns his soul, and the exercise of his mind all the
    while.
    
    Monday, December 11, 1648, came my Lords Argyle, Cassils, Elcho, and
    Warriston to visit him. He did faithfully declare his mind to them, as
    public men, in that point whereof he hath left a testimony to the view of
    the world, as afterwards; and the speaking was very burdensome, yet he
    spared not very freely to fasten their duty upon them. The exercise of his
    mind all the time of his sickness was vary sad and constant, without
    comfortable manifestations, and sensible presence for the time, yet he
    continued in a constant faith of adherence, which ended in an adhering
    assurance, his grips growing still the stronger.
    
    “One day, a fortnight before his death, he had leaned down on a little
    bed, and taking a fit of faintness, and his mind being heavily exercised,
    and lifting up his eyes, this expression fell with great weight from his
    mouth, ‘O my dear Lord, forsake me not forever!’ His weariness of this
    life was very great, and his longing to be relieved, and to be where the
    veil would be taken away.
    
    “Tuesday, December 14, (1648) he was in heavy sickness, and three pastors
    came in the afternoon to visit him, of whom one said to him, ‘The Lord
    hath made you faithful in all he hath employed you in, and it’s likely we
    be put to the trial; therefore what encouragement give you us thereanent!’
    Whereto he answered in few words, ‘I have gotten more by the Lord’s
    immediate assistance than ever I had by study, in the disputes I had in
    the Assembly of Divines in England; therefore let never man distrust God
    for assistance that cast themselves on him, and follow his calling. For my
    own part, the time that I have had in the exercise of the ministry is but
    a moment.’ To which sentence another pastor answered, ‘But your moment
    hath exceeded the gray heads of others! This I may speak without
    flattery.’ To which he answered disclaiming it with a ‘no;’ for he desired
    still to have Christ exalted, as he said at the same time, and another.
    And at other times, when any such things were spoken to him, ‘What are all
    my righteousnesses but rotten rags? All that I have done cannot abide the
    touchstone of his justice. They are all but abominations, and as an
    unclean thing, when they are reckoned between my God and me. Christ is all
    things, and I am nothing!’ The other pastor when the rest were out, asked,
    ‘Whether he was enjoying the comforts of God’s presence, or if they were
    for a time suspended! He answered, Indeed they were suspended.’ Then
    within a little while he said, ‘Comforts! aye comforts!’ meaning, that
    they were not easily attained. His wife said, ‘What reck’d the comfort if
    believing is not suspended!’ He said, ‘No.’ Speaking farther to that his
    condition, he said, ‘Although that I should never see any more light of
    comfort than I do see, yet I shall adhere, and do believe that He is mine,
    and I am his!’
    
    “The next morrow being Friday, he not being able to write, did dictate out
    the rest of a paper, which he had been before writing himself, and did
    subscribe it before two witnesses, who also did subscribe; wherein he gave
    faithful and clear testimony to the work and cause of God, and against the
    enemies thereof, to stop the mouths of calumniators and to confirm his
    children.
    
    “In all his discourses this was mixed as one thing, that he longed for the
    time of relief, and rejoiced because it was so near. His breath being very
    short, he said, ‘Where the hallelujahs are sung to the Lamb, there is no
    shortness of breath!’ And being in very great pain all the Friday night,
    his mother said in the morning, ‘In all appearance you will not have
    another night.’ To which he said, ‘Think you that your word will hold
    good?’ She said, ‘I fear it will hold over good.’ He said, ‘Not over
    good.’ That day he blessed his children and some others, (Mr Patrick
    Simson, the writer of this) and said, ‘God bless you: and as you carry the
    name of your grandfather, so God grant you his graces.’ That afternoon,
    being Saturday, came Mr Samuel Rutherford, who, among other things, said,
    ‘The day, I hope, is dawning, and breaking in your soul, that shall never,
    have an end.’ He said, ‘It is not broken yet; but though I walk in
    darkness and see no light, yet I will trust in the name of the Lord and
    stay upon my God!’ Mr Samuel said, ‘Would not Christ be a welcome guest to
    you?’ He answered, ‘Welcome! the welcomest guest that ever I saw.’ He said
    further, ‘Doth not your soul love Christ above all things?’ He answered,
    ‘I love him heartily: who ever knew any thing of him but would love him!’
    
    “Mr James Wilson going to pray, asked ‘What petitions he would have him to
    put up for him?’ He said, ‘For more of himself, and strength to carry me
    through the dark valley.’
    
    “Saturday night he became weaker, and inclined to drowsiness and sleeping,
    and was discerned in his drowsiness a little to rave; yet being till the
    last half hour in his full and perfect senses, and having taken a little
    jelly and drink, about half an hour before his death he spake as sensibly
    betwixt as ever, and blessed some persons that morning with very spiritual
    and heavenly expressions. About seven or eight of the clock his drowsiness
    encreased, and he was overheard in it speaking (after he had spoken more
    imperfectly some words before) those words, ‘Glory! Glory! a seeing of
    God! a seeing of God! I hope it shall be for his glory!’ After he had
    taken a little refreshment of jelly, and a little drink through a reed, he
    said that the giving him these things made him drowsy; and a little
    afterwards, ‘There is a great drowsiness on me, I know not how it comes.’
    
    “His wife seeing the time draw near, spake to him and said, ‘The time of
    your relief is now near, and hard at hand.’ He answered, ‘I long for that
    time. O! happy they that are there.’ This was the last word he was heard
    sensibly to speak. Mr Frederick Carmichael being there, they went to
    prayer, expecting death so suddenly. In the midst of prayer he left his
    rattling(9) and the pangs and fetches of death begin thence, his senses
    went away. Whereupon they rose from prayer, and beheld till, in a very
    gentle manner, the pins of his tabernacle were loosed.
    
    “He said (_supra_) ‘Say not over good,’ because he thought she wronged him
    so far in wishing the contrary of what he longed for.
    
    “Mr Carmichael said, ‘You have been very faithful, and the Lord has
    honoured you to do him very much service, and now you are to get your
    reward.’ He answered ‘I think it reward enough, that ever I got leave to
    do him any service in truth and sincerity.’ ”
    
    This account was dictated to me by Mr Patrick Simson, Mr Gillespie’s
    cousin, who was with him to his last sickness, and at his death, and took
    minutes at the time of these his expressions. I read it over, after I had
    written it, to him. He corrected some words, and said to me, “This is all
    I mind about his expressions toward his close. They made some impression
    on me at the time, and I then set them down. I have not read the paper
    that I mind these forty years, but I am pretty positive these were his
    very words.” A day or two after, I went in with him to his closet to look
    for another paper, for now he had almost lost his sight, and in a bundle,
    I fell on the paper he wrote at the time, and told him of it. When we
    compared it with what I wrote, there was not the least variation betwixt
    the original and what I wrote, save an inconsiderable word or two, here
    altered; which is an instance of a strong memory, the greatest ever I
    knew.
    
    (Subscribed) R WODROW
    
    Sept. 8, 1707 WODROW’s ANALECTA, vol. I, pp. 154-159
    
                                    * * * * *
    
    _What follows about Mr Gillespie I wrote also from Mr Simson’s mouth._
    
    “George Gillespie was born January 21st, 1613. He was first minister at
    Weemyse, the first admitted under Presbytery 1638. He was minister at
    Weemyse about two years. He was very young when laureate, before he was
    seventeen. He was chaplain first to my lord Kenmure, then to the Lord of
    Cassilis. When he was with Cassilis, he wrote his ‘English Popish
    Ceremonies,’ which when printed, he was about twenty-two. He wrote a
    ‘Dialogue between a Civilian and Divine,’ a piece against Toleration,
    entitled ‘Wholesome Severity reconciled with Christian Liberty.’ He died
    in strong faith of adherence, though in darkness as to assurance, which
    faith of adherence he preached much. He died December seventeen, 1648. If
    he had lived to January 21, 1649, he had been thirty six years.
    
    “The last paper he wrote, was ‘The Commission of the Kirk’s Answer to the
    State’s Observations on the Declaration of the General Assembly anent the
    Unlawfulness of the Engagement.’ The Observations were penned, (as my
    relator supposes) by Mr William Colville, who wrote all these kind of
    papers for the Committee of Estates, and printed during the Assembly
    whereof he was moderator. They could not overtake it, but remitted it to
    the Commission to sit on Monday, and Mr Gillespie wrote the answer on
    Saturday and the Sabbath, when he (the thing requiring haste) staid from
    sermon, and my informer, Mr Patrick Simson, transcribed it against Monday
    at ten, when it passed without any alteration. And just the week after, he
    went over to Fife, where he died. He was not full ten years in the
    ministry. He had all his sermons in England, part polemical, part
    practical prepared for the press, and but one copy of them, which he told
    the printer’s wife he used to deal with, and bade her have a care of them.
    And she was prevailed on by some money from the Sectaries, who were mauled
    by him, to suppress them. He was very clear in all his notions, and the
    manner of expressing them. There are six volumes in 8vo manuscript which
    he wrote at the Assembly of Divines remaining.”—WODROW’S ANALECTA, vol. i.
    p. 159-160.
    
    
    
    
    
    DISPUTE AGAINST THE ENGLISH POPISH CEREMONIES OBTRUDED ON THE CHURCH OF
    SCOTLAND.
    
    
                  DISPUTE AGAINST THE ENGLISH POPISH CEREMONIES
    
                       OBTRUDED ON THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND;
    
         WHEREIN NOT ONLY OUR OWN ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE SAME ARE STRONGLY
    CONFIRMED, BUT LIKEWISE THE ANSWERS AND DEFENCES OF OUR OPPOSITES, SUCH AS
       HOOKER, MORTOUNE, BURGES, SPRINT, PAYBODY, ANDREWS, SARAVIA, TILEN,
            SPOTSWOOD, LINDSEY, FOSBESSE, ETC., PARTICULARLY CONFUTED
    
                               BY GEORGE GILLESPIE,
    
                              MINISTER AT EDINBURGH,
    
                                      1662.
    
                                 Jer. ix. 12-14.
    
    “Who is the wise man, that may understand this? and who is he to whom the
     mouth of the Lord hath spoken, that he may declare it, for what the land
    perisheth?” “And the Lord saith, Because they have forsaken my law which I
    set before them, and have not obeyed my voice, neither walked therein, but
     here walked after the imagination of their own heart, and after Baalim.”
    
                                    EDINBURGH:
    
                         ROBERT OGLE, AND OLIVER & BOYD.
    
                   M. OGLE & SON AND WILLIAM COLLINS, GLASGOW.
    
           D. DEWAR, PERTH. G. & R. KING, ABERDEEN. W. M’COMB, BELFAST.
    
              HAMILTON, ADAMS & CO., AND JAMES NISBET & CO., LONDON.
    
                                    MDCCCXLIV.
    
                         Reprinted from Edition of 1660.
    
                   A. MURRAY, PRINTER, MILNE SQUARE, EDINBURGH.
    
    
    
    
    DEDICATION
    
    
    TO
    ALL AND EVERY ONE
    IN THE
    REFORMED CHURCHES
    OF
    SCOTLAND, ENGLAND, AND IRELAND,
    WHO
    LOVE THE LORD JESUS, AND MEAN TO ADHERE UNTO THE REFORMATION OF RELIGION.
    GRACE, MERCY, AND PEACE, FROM GOD OUR FATHER,
    AND FROM
    THE LORD JESUS CHRIST.
    
    
    
    
    AUTHOR’S PREFACE
    
    
    As Satan’s malice, and man’s wickedness, cease not to molest the thrice
    happy estate of the church of Christ, so hath the eternal council of the
    only wise God predetermined the coming of offences, persecutions,
    heresies, schisms and divisions, that professors may be proved before they
    be as approved and made manifest, 1 Cor. xi. 19. And hence “It must needs
    be that offences come,” Matt. xviii. 17; neither hath the church ever
    enjoyed both purity and peace any long time together. But whiles the
    church of God, thus disquieted, at well with dangerous alterations, as
    with doleful altercations, is presented in the theatre of this world, and
    crieth out to beholders, “Have ye no regard, all ye that pass by!” Lam. i.
    12. A pity it is to see the crooked and sinistrous courses of the greatest
    part, every man moving his period within the enormous confines of his own
    exorbitant desires; the atheistical nullisidian, nothing regardeth the
    assoiling of ecclesiastical controversies,—he is of Gallio’s humour, Acts
    xviii. 17, and cares for none of those things; the sensual Epicurean and
    riotous ruffian (go church matters as they will) eats and drinks, and
    takes his pleasure; the cynical critic spueth out bitter aspersions,
    gibeth and justleth at everything that can be said or done in the cause of
    religion; the acenical jester playeth fast and loose, and can utter
    anything in sport, but nothing in earnest; the avaricious worldling hath
    no tune but _Give_, _give_, and no anthem pleaseth him but _Have_, _have_;
    the aspiring Diotrephes puffeth down every course which cannot puff up;
    the lofty favourite taketh the pattern of his religion from the court
    iconography, and if the court swim, he cares not though the church sink;
    the subdulous Machiavillian accounteth the show of religion profitable,
    but the substance of it troublesome: he studieth not the oracles of God
    but the principles of Satanical guile, which be learneth so well that he
    may go to the devil to be bishopped; the turn-coat temporiser wags with
    every wind, and (like Diogenes turning about the mouth of his voluble
    hogshead, after the course of the sun) wheresoever the bright beams of
    coruscant authority do shine and cherish, thither followeth and sitteth
    he; the gnathonic parasite sweareth to all that his benefactor holdeth;
    the mercenary pensioner will bow before he break; he who only studieth to
    have the praise of some witty invention, cannot strike upon another anvil;
    the silly idiot (with Absolom’s two hundred, 2 Sam. xv. 11,) goeth, in the
    simplicity of his heart, after his perverse leaders; the lapped Nicodemite
    holds it enough to yield some secret assent to the truth, though neither
    his profession nor his practice testify so much; he whose mind is
    possessed with prejudicate opinions against the truth, when convincing
    light is holden forth to him, looketh asquint, and therefore goeth awry;
    the pragmatical adiaphorist, with his span-broad faith and ell-broad
    conscience, doth no small harm—the poor pandect of his plagiary profession
    in matters of faith reckoneth little for all, and in matters of practice
    all for little. Shortly, if an expurgatory index were compiled of those,
    and all other sorts of men, who either through their careless and neutral
    on looking, make no help to the troubled and disquieted church of Christ,
    or through their nocent accession and overthwart intermeddling, work out
    her greater harm, alas! how few feeling members were there to be found
    behind who truly lay to heart her estate and condition? Nevertheless, in
    the worst times, either of raging persecution or prevailing defection, as
    God Almighty hath ever hitherto, so both now, and to the end, he will
    reserve to himself a remnant according to the election of grace, who
    cleave to his blessed truth and to the purity of his holy worship, and are
    grieved for the affliction of Joseph, as being themselves also in the
    body, in confidence whereof I take boldness to stir you up at this time,
    by putting you in remembrance. If you would be rightly informed of the
    present estate of the reformed churches, you must not acquiesce in the
    pargetting verdict of those who are wealthy and well at ease, and mounted
    aloft upon the uncogged wheels of prosperous fortune (as they call it).
    Those whom the love of the world hath not enhanced to the serving of the
    time can give you the soundest judgment. It is noted of Dionysius
    Hallicarnasseus(10) (who was never advanced to magistracy in the Roman
    republic) that he hath written far more truly of the Romans than Fabius,
    Salustius, or Cato, who flourished among them with riches and honours.
    
    After that it pleased God, by the light of his glorious gospel, to dispel
    the more than cimmerian darkness of antichristianism, and, by the antidote
    of reformation, to avoid the poison of Popery; forasmuch as in England and
    Ireland, every noisome weed which God’s hand had never planted was not
    pulled up, therefore we now see the faces of those churches overgrown with
    the repullulating twigs and sprigs of popish superstition. Mr Sprint
    acknowledgeth the Reformation of England to have been defective, and
    saith, “It is easy to imagine of what difficulty it was to reform all
    things at the first, where the most part of the privy council, of the
    nobility, bishops, judges, gentry, and people, were open or close Papists,
    where few or none of any countenance stood for religion at the first, but
    the Protector and Cranmer.”(11) The church of Scotland was blessed with a
    more glorious and perfect reformation than any of our neighbour churches.
    The doctrine, discipline, regiment, and policy established here by
    ecclesiastical and civil laws, and sworn and subscribed unto by the king’s
    majesty and several presbyteries and parish churches of the land, as it
    had the applause of foreign divines; so was it in all points agreeable
    unto the word, neither could the most rigid Aristarchus of these times
    challenge any irregularity of the same. But now, alas! even this church,
    which was once so great a praise in the earth is deeply corrupted, and
    hath “turned aside quickly out of the way,” Exod. xxxii. 8. So that this
    is the Lord’s controversy against Scotland. “I had planted thee a noble
    vine, wholly a right seed? How then art thou turned into the degenerate
    plant of a strange vine unto me?” Jer. ii. 21.
    
    It is not this day feared, but felt, that the rotten dregs of Popery,
    which were never purged away from England and Ireland and having once been
    spued out with detestation, are licked up again in Scotland, prove to be
    the unhappy occasions of a woeful recidivation. Neither is there need of
    Lyncean eyes, for if we be not poreblind, it cannot be hid from us. What
    doleful and disastrous mutation (to be bewailed with tears of blood) hath
    happened to the church and spouse of Christ in these dominions? Her comely
    countenance is miscoloured with the fading lustre of the mother of
    harlots, her shamefaced forehead hath received the mark of the beast, her
    lovely locks are frizled with the crisping pins of antichristian fashions,
    her chaste ears are made to listen to the friends of the great whore, who
    bring the bewitching doctrine of enchanting traditions, her dove eyes look
    pleasantly upon the well attired harlot, her sweet voice is mumming and
    muttering some missal and magical liturgies, her fair neck beareth the
    halter like to kens of her former captivity, even a burdensome chain of
    superfluous and superstitious ceremonies, her undefiled garments are
    stained with the meritricious bravery of Babylonish ornaments, and with
    the symbolising badges of conformity with Rome, her harmless hands reach
    brick and mortar to the building of Babel, her beautiful feet with shoes
    are all besmeared, whilst they return apace in the way of Egypt, and wade
    the ingruent brooks of Popery. Oh! transformed virgin, whether is thy
    beauty gone from thee? Oh! forlorn prince’s daughter, how art thou not
    ashamed to look thy Lord in the face? Oh! thou best beloved among women,
    what hast thou to do with the inveigling appurtenances and habilement of
    Babylon the whore?—But among such things as have been the accursed means
    of the church’s desolation, which peradventure might seem to some of you
    to have least harm or evil in them, are the ceremonies of kneeling in the
    act of receiving the Lord’s supper, cross in baptism, bishopping,
    holidays, &c., which are pressed under the name of things indifferent; yet
    if you survey the sundry inconveniences and grievous consequences of the
    same, you will think far otherwise. The vain shows and shadows of these
    ceremonies have hid and obscured the substance of religion; the true life
    of godliness is smothered down and suppressed by the burden of these human
    inventions, for their sakes, many, who are both faithful servants to
    Christ and loyal subjects to the king, are evil spoken of, mocked,
    reproached, menanced, molested; for their sakes Christian brethren are
    offended, and the weak are greatly scandalised; for their sakes the most
    powerful and painful ministers in the land are either thrust out, or
    threatened to be thrust out from their callings; for their sakes the best
    qualified and most hopeful expectants are debarred from entering into the
    ministry; for their sakes the seminaries of learning are so corrupted,
    that few or no good plants can come forth from thence, for their sakes
    many are admitted into the sacred ministry, who are either popish and
    Arminianised, who minister to the flock poison instead of food; or silly
    ignorants, who can dispense no wholesome food to the hungry; or else
    vicious in their lives, who draw many with them into the dangerous
    precipice of soul perdition; or, lastly, so earthly minded, that they
    favour only the things of this earth, not the things of the Spirit of God,
    who feed themselves, but not the flock, and to whom the Great Shepherd of
    the sheep wilt say, “The diseased have ye not strengthened, neither have
    ye healed that which was sick, neither have ye bound up that which was
    broken, neither have ye brought again that which was driven away, neither
    have ye sought that which was lost,” Ezek. xxxiv. 4. Simple ones, who have
    some taste and relish of popish superstition (for many such there be in
    the land), do suck from the intoxicated drugs of conformity, the softer
    milk which makes them grow in error. And who can be ignorant what a large
    spread Popery, Arminianism and reconciliation with Rome, have taken among
    the arch urgers of the ceremonies? What marvel that Papists clap their
    hands! for they see the day coming which they wish for. Woe to thee, O
    land, which bears professed Papists and avouched Atheists, but cannot bear
    them who desire to “abstain from all appearance of evil,” 1 Thes. v. 22,
    for truth and equity are fallen in thee, and “he that departeth from evil
    maketh himself a prey,” Isa. lix. 14, 15.
    
    These are the best wares which the big hulk of conformity, favoured with
    the prosperous gale of mighty authority, hath imported amongst us, and
    whilst our opposites so quiverly go about to spread the bad wares of these
    encumbering inconveniences, is it time for as luskishly to sit still and
    to be silent? “Woe unto us, for the day goeth away, for the shadows of the
    evening are stretched out,” Jer. vi. 4.
    
    Moreover, besides the prevailing inconveniency of the controverted
    ceremonies, the unlawfulness of them is also plainly evinced in this
    ensuing dispute by such convincing arguments, as, being duly pondered in
    the equal balance of an attentive mind, shall, by God’s grace, afford
    satisfaction to so many as purpose to buy the truth, and not to sell it.
    Wherefore, referring to the dispute the points themselves which are
    questioned, I am in this place to beseech you all by the mercies of God,
    that, remembering the words of the Lord, “Them that honour me I will
    honour, and they that despise me shalt be lightly esteemed,” 1 Sam. ii.
    30, remembering, also, the curse and condemnation of Meroz, which came not
    to help the Lord against the mighty, Judg. v. 23, of the nobles of Tekoa,
    who put not their necks to the work of the Lord, Neh. iii. 5 and, shortly,
    of all such as have no courage for the truth, Jer. ix. 3, but seek their
    own things, not the things which are Jesus Christ’s, Phil. ii. 21, and,
    finally, taking to heart how the Lord Jesus, when he cometh in the glory
    of his Father with his holy angels, Mark viii. 38, will be ashamed of
    every one who hath been ashamed of him and his words in the midst of a
    sinful and crooked generation, you would, with a holy zeal and invincible
    courage, against all contrary error, superstition, and abuse whatsoever,
    set yourselves both to speak and do, and likewise (having a calling) to
    suffer for the truth of Christ and for the purity of his worship, being in
    nothing terrified by your adversaries, Phil. i. 28, 1 Pet. iii. 14, which,
    that ye may the better perform, I commend to your thoughts these wholesome
    admonitions which follow—
    
    I. When you see so much diversity both of opinion and practice in things
    pertaining to religion, the rather ye ought to give all diligence for
    trying the things which are different, Phil. i. 10. If you judge us before
    you hear us, then do you contrary to the very law of nature and nations,
    John vii. 51, Acts v. 16. Neither will it help you at your reckoning to
    say, We believed our spiritual guides, our prelates and preachers, whom
    God had set over us. Nay, what if your guides be blind? then they not only
    fall in the ditch themselves, but you with them, Matth. iv. 14. Our Master
    would not have the Jews to rest upon the testimony of John Baptist
    himself, but would have them to search the Scriptures, John v. 33, 34, 39,
    by which touch stone the Bereans tried the Apostle’s own doctrine, and are
    commended for so doing, Acts xvii. 11. But as we wish you not to condemn
    our cause without examining the same by the Word, so neither do we desire
    you blindly to follow us in adhering unto it, for what if your seeing
    guides be taken from you? How, then, shall you see to keep out of the
    ditch? We would neither have you to fight for us nor against us, like the
    blind sword players, Andabatæ, a people who were said to fight with their
    eyes closed. Consider, therefore, what we say, and the Lord give you
    understanding in all things, 2 Tim. ii. 7.
    
    II. Since the God of heaven is the greatest king, who is to rule and reign
    over you by his Word, which he hath published to the world, and, _tunc
    vere_, &c., then is God truly said to reign in us when no worldly thing is
    harboured and haunted in our souls, saith Theophylact,(12) since also the
    wisdom of the flesh is enmity against God, Rom. viii. 7, who hath made
    foolish the wisdom of this world, 1 Cor. i. 20, therefore never shall you
    rightly deprehend the truth of God, nor submit yourselves to be guided by
    the same, unless, laying aside all the high soaring fancies and
    presumptuous conceits of natural and worldly wisdom, you come in an
    unfeigned humility and babe-like simplicity to be edified by the word of
    righteousness. And far less shall you ever take up the cross and follow
    Christ (as you are required), except, first of all, you labour and learn
    to deny yourselves, Matth. xvi. 24, that is, to make no reckoning what
    come of yourselves, and of all that you have in the world, so that God
    have glory and yourselves a good conscience, in your doings or sufferings.
    
    III. If you would not be drawn away after the error of the wicked, neither
    fall from your own stedfastness, the apostle Peter teacheth you, that ye
    must grow both in grace and knowledge, 2 Pet. iii. 18, for, if either your
    minds be darkened through want of knowledge, or your affections frozen
    through want of the love of God, then are you naked, and not guarded
    against the tentations of the time. Wherefore, as the perverters of the
    truth and simplicity of religion do daily multiply errors, so must you
    (shunning those shelves and quicksands of deceiving errors which witty
    make-bates design for you), labour daily for increase of knowledge, and as
    they to their errors in opinion do add the overplus of a licentious
    practice and lewd conversation, so must you (having so much the more ado
    to flee from their impiety), labour still for a greature measure of the
    lively work of sanctifying grace; in which respects Augustine saith well,
    that the adversaries of the truth do this good to the true members of the
    church, that the fall of those makes these to take better hold upon
    God.(13)
    
    IV. Be not deceived, to think that they who so eagerly press this course
    of conformity have any such end as God’s glory, or the good of his church
    and profit of religion. When a violent urger of the ceremonies pretendeth
    religious respects for his proceedings, it may be well answered in
    Hillary’s(14) words. _Subrepis nomine blandienti, occidis specie
    religionis_—Thou privily creepest in with an enticing title, thou killest
    with the pretence of religion, for, 1. It is most evidently true of these
    ceremonies, which our divines(15) say of the gestures and rites used in
    the mass, “They are all frivolous and hypocritical, stealing away true
    devotion from the heart, and making men to rest in the outward gestures of
    the body.” There is more sound religion among them who refuse, than among
    them who receive the same, even our enemies themselves being judges, the
    reason whereof let me give in the words of one of our opposites(16)
    _Supervacua hoec occupatio circa traditiones humanas, gignit semper
    ignorantiam et contemptum proeceptorum divinorum_—This needless business
    about human traditions doth ever beget the ignorance and contempt of
    divine commandments. 2. Where read we that the servants of God have at any
    time sought to advance religion by such hideous courses of stern violence,
    as are intended and assayed against us by those who press the ceremonies
    upon us? The jirking and nibbling of their unformal huggermugger cometh
    nearer to sycophancy than to sincerity, and is sibber to appeaching
    hostility than fraternal charity, for just so they deal with us as the
    Arians did with the catholics of old. _Sinceros_, &c.(17) “The sincere
    teachers of the churches they delated and accused before magistrates, as
    if they alone did continually perturb the church’s peace and tranquillity,
    and did only labour that the divided churches might never again piously
    grow together, and by this calumny they persuaded politic and civil men
    (who did not well enough understand this business), that the godly
    teachers of the churches should be cast forth into exile, and the Arian
    wolves should be sent into the sheepfolds of Christ.” Now, forasmuch as
    God hath said, “They shall not hurt nor destroy in all my holy mountain,”
    Isa. ix. 11, and will not have his flock to be ruled with force and with
    cruelty, Ezek. xxxiv. 4. _Nec potest_ (saith Lactantius(18)) _aut veritas
    cum vi, aut justitia cum crudelitate conjungi_—Neither can either truth be
    conjoined with violence, or righteousness with cruelty therefore, if our
    opposites would make it evident that they are in very deed led by
    religious aims let them resile from their violent proceedings, and deal
    with us in the spirit of meekness showing us from God’s word and good
    reason the equity of their cause, and iniquity of ours, wherein we require
    no other thing of them, than that which Lactantius required of the
    adversaries of his profession, even that they would debate the matter
    _verbis pontius quam verberibus_—by words rather than by whips
    _Distringant aciem ingeniorem suorum: siratio eorum vera est, asseratur:
    parati sumus audire, si doceant_—Let them draw out the sharpness of their
    engines; if their reason be true let it be averred, we are ready to hear,
    if they teach us. 3. If their aims were truly for the advancement of
    religion, how comes it to pass, that whilst they make so much ado and move
    every stone against us for our modest refusing of obedience to certain
    ordinances of men, which in our consciences we are persuaded to be
    unlawful, they manumiss and set free the simony, lying, swearing,
    profanation of the Sabbath, drunkenness, whoredom, with other gross and
    scandalous vices of some of their own side, by which God’s own
    commandments are most fearfully violated? This just recrimination we may
    well use for our own most lawful defence. Neither do we hereby intend any
    man’s shame (God knows), but his reformation rather. We wish from our
    hearts we had no reason to challenge our opposites of that superstition
    taxed in the Pharisees, _Quod argubant &c._—that they accused the
    disciples of little things, and themselves were guilty in great things,
    saith Nicolaus Goranus.(19)
    
    V. Do not account ceremonies to be matters of so small importance that we
    need not stand much upon them, for, as Hooker(20) observeth, a ceremony,
    through custom, worketh very much with people. Dr Burges allegeth(21) for
    his writing about ceremonies, that the matter is important for the
    consequence of it. Camero(22) thinketh so much of ceremonies, that he
    holdeth our simplicity to notify that we have the true religion, and that
    the religion of Papists is superstitious because of their ceremonies. To
    say the truth, a church is in so far true or hypocritical as it mixeth or
    not mixeth human inventions with God’s holy worship, and hence the
    Magdeburgians profess,(23) that they write of the ceremonies for making a
    difference betwixt a true and a hypocritical church. _Vere enim ecclesia,
    &c._—for a true church, as it retains pure doctrine, so also it keeps
    simplicity of ceremonies, &c., but a hypocritical church, as it departs
    from pure doctrine, so for the most part it changeth and augmenteth the
    ceremonies instituted of God, and multiplieth its own traditions, &c. And
    as touching our controverted ceremonies in particular, if you consider
    what we have written against them, you shall easily perceive that they are
    matters of no small, but very great consequence. Howbeit these be but the
    beginnings of evils, and there is a worse gallimaufry gobber-wise
    prepared. It hath been observed of the warring Turks(24) that often they
    used this notable deceit—to send a lying rumour and a vain tumult of war
    to one place, but, in the meanwhile, to address their true forces to
    another place, that so they might surprise those who have been unwarily
    led by pernicious credulity. So have we manifest (alas too, too manifest)
    reasons to make us conceive, that whilst the chief urgers of the course of
    conformity are skirmishing with us about the trifling ceremonies (as some
    men count them), they are but labouring to hold our thoughts so bent and
    intent upon those smaller quarrels, that we may forget to distinguish
    betwixt evils immanent and evils imminent, and that we be not too much
    awake to espy their secret sleight in compassing further aims.
    
    VI. Neither let the pretence of peace and unity cool your fervour, or make
    you spare to oppose yourselves unto those idle and idolised ceremonies
    against which we dispute, for whilst our opposites make a vain show and
    pretence of peace, they do like the Romans,(25) who built the Temple of
    Concord just in the place where the seditious outrages of the two Gracchi,
    Tiberius and Caius, had been acted, which temple,(26) in the subsequent
    times, did not restrain, but, by the contrary, gave further scope unto
    more bloody seditions, so that they should have built _discord_ a temple
    in that place rather than _concord_, as Augustine pleasantly tickleth
    them. Do our opposites think that the bane of peace is never in yielding
    to the course of the time, but ever in refusing to yield? Or will they not
    rather acknowledge, that as a man is said to be made drunk by drinking the
    water of Lyncestus, a river of Macedonia,(27) no less than if he had
    filled himself with the strongest wine, so one may be inebriate with a
    contentious humour in standing stiffly for yielding, as well as in
    standing stedfastly for refusing? Peace is violated by the oppugners of
    the truth, but established by the possessors of the same, for (as was
    rightly said by Georgius Scolarius in the Council of Florence(28)) the
    church’s peace “can neither stay among men, the truth being unknown,
    neither can it but needs return, the truth being known.” _Nec veritate
    ignorata manere inter homines potest, nec illa agnita necessario non
    redire._ We must therefore be mortised together, not by the subscudines of
    error, but by the bands of truth and unity of faith. And we go the true
    way to regain peace whilst we sue for the removal of those popish
    ceremonies which have both occasioned and nourished the discord, we only
    refuse that peace (falsely so called) which will not permit us to brook
    purity, and that because (as Joseph Hall(29) noteth) St James’ (chap. iii.
    17,) describeth the wisdom which is from above to be “first pure, then
    peaceable,” whence it cometh that there can be no concord betwixt Christ
    and antichrist, nor any communion betwixt the temple of God and idols, 2
    Cor. vii. 15, 16. _Atque ut coelum_, &c.: “And though heaven and earth
    should happen to be mingled together, yet the sincere worship of God and
    his sacred truth, wherein eternal salvation is laid up for us, should
    worthily be unto us of more estimation than a hundred worlds,” saith
    Calvin.(30) John Fox(31) judgeth it better to contend against those who
    prefer their own traditions to the commandments of God, than to be at
    peace with them. True it is,—_Pax optima rerum, quas homini novisse datum
    est._—Yet I trust we may use the words of that great adiaphorist, Georgius
    Cassander—_Ea __ demion vera_, &c. “That alone (saith he) is true and
    solid Christian peace which is conjoined with the glory of God and the
    obedience of his will, and is rejoined from all depravation of the
    heavenly doctrine and divine worship.”
    
    VII. Beware, also, you be not deceived with the pretence of the church’s
    consent, and of uniformity as well with the ancient church as with the now
    reformed churches, in the forms and customs of both, for, 1. Our opposites
    cannot show that the sign of the cross was received and used in the church
    before Tertullian, except they allege either the Montanists or the
    Valentian heretics for it. Neither yet can they show, that apparel proper
    for divine service, and distinguished from the common, is more ancient
    than the days of Pope Cœlestinus, nor lastly, that kneeling in the act of
    receiving the communion was ever used before the time of Pope Honorious
    III. They cannot prove any one of the controverted ceremonies to have been
    in the church the first two hundred years after Christ, except the feast
    of Easter (which yet can neither be proved to have been observed in the
    apostles’ own age, nor yet to have been established in the after age by
    any law, but only to have crept in by a certain private custom), and for
    some of them they cannot find any clear testimony for a long time
    thereafter. Now, in the third century,(32) historiographers observe, that
    _Paulatum ceremoniæ auctæ sunt, hominum superstitionorum opinionibus: unde
    in baptismo unctionem olei, cruces signaculum, et osculum
    addiderunt_—Ceremonies were by little and little augmented by the opinions
    of superstitious men, whence it was that they added the unction of oil,
    the sign of the cross, and a kiss in baptism. And in the fourth century
    they say, _Subinde magis magisque, traditiones humanæ cumulatæ
    sunt_—Forthwith human traditions were more and more augmented. And so from
    that time forward vain and idle ceremonies were still added to the worship
    of God, till the same was, under Popery, wholly corrupted with
    superstitious rites, yes, and Mr Sprint hath told us, even of the first
    two hundred years after Christ, that the “devil, in those days, began to
    sow his tares (as the watchmen began to sleep), both of false doctrine and
    corrupt ceremonies.” And now, though some of the controverted ceremonies
    have been kept and reserved in many (not all), the reformed churches, yet
    they are not therefore to be the better liked of. For the reason of the
    reservation was, because some reverend divines who dealt and laboured in
    the reformation of those churches, perceiving the occurring lets and
    oppositions which were caused by most dangerous schisms and seditions, and
    by the raging of bloody wars, scarcely expected to effectuate so much as
    the purging of the church from fundamental errors and gross idolatry,
    which wrought them to be content, that lesser abuses in discipline and
    church policy should be then tolerated, because they saw not how to
    overtake them all at that time. In the meanwhile, they were so far from
    desiring any of the churches to retain these popish ceremonies, which
    might have convenient occasion of ejecting them (far less to recal them,
    being once ejected), that they testified plainly their dislike of the
    same, and wished that those churches wherein they lived, might have some
    blessed opportunity to be rid of all such rotten relics, riven rags and
    rotten remainders of Popery. All which, since they were once purged away
    from the church of Scotland and cast forth as things accursed into the
    jakes of eternal detestation, how vile and abominable may we now call the
    resuming of them? Or what a piacular prevarication is it to borrow from
    any other church which was less reformed, a pattern of policy for this
    church which was more reformed. But, 2. Though there could be more alleged
    for the ceremonies than truly there can be, either from the customs of the
    ancient or reformed churches, yet do our opposites themselves profess,
    that they will not justify all the ceremonies either of the ancient or
    reformed churches. And, indeed, who dare take this for a sure rule, that
    we ought to follow every ancient and universally received custom? For as
    Casaubon showeth, though the church’s consent ought not to be contemned,
    yet we are not always to hold it for a law or a right rule. And do not our
    divines teach, that _nihil faciendum est ad ahorum exemplum, sed juxta
    verbum_—Nothing is to be done according to the example of others, but
    according to the word _Ut autem_, &c. “As the multitude of them who err
    (saith Osiander), so long prescription of time purchaseth no patrociny to
    error.”
    
    VIII. Moreover, because the foredeck and hind deck of all our opposites’
    probations do resolve and rest finally into the authority of a law, and
    authority they use as a sharp knife to cut every Gordian knot which they
    cannot unloose, and as a dreadful peal to sound so loud in all ears that
    reason cannot be heard, therefore we certiorate you with Calvin, that _a
    acquievistis imperio, pessimo laqueo vos in duistis_—If you have
    acquiesced in authority, you have wrapped yourselves in a very evil snare.
    As touching any ordinance of the church we say with Whittaker, _Obediendum
    ecclesioe est sed jubents ac docenti recta_—We are to obey the church but
    commanding and teaching right things. Surely, if we have not proved the
    controverted ceremonies to be such things as are not right to be done we
    shall straight obey all the ceremonial laws made thereanent, and as for
    the civil magistrate’s part, is it not holden that he may not enjoin us
    “to do that whereof we have not good ground to do it of faith?” and that,
    “although all thy external condition is in the power of the magistrate,
    yet internal things, as the keeping of faith, and obedience, and a good
    conscience, are not in his power.” For every one of us “shall give account
    of himself to God,” Rom. xiv. 12, but until you hear more in the dispute
    of the power which either the church or the magistrate hath to enact laws
    anent things belonging to the worship of God, and of the binding power of
    the same, let me add here touching human laws in general, that where we
    have no other reason to warrant unto us the doing of that which a human
    law prescribeth, beside the bare will and authority of the law maker, in
    this case a human law cannot bind us to obedience. Aquinas holdeth with
    Isidore, that a human law (among other conditions of it) must both be
    necessary for removing of some evil, and likewise profitable for guiding
    us to some good. Gregorius Sayrus following them herein, saith, _Debet lex
    homines a malo retrahere, et idio dicatur necessaria debet __ etiam
    promovere in bonum, et ideo dicitur utilis_—A law ought to draw back men
    from evil, and therefore is called necessary, it ought also to promove
    them unto good, and therefore is called profitable. Human laws, in Mr
    Hooker’s judgment,(33) must teach what is good, and be made for the
    benefit of men. Demosthenes(34) describeth a law to be such a thing _cui
    convenit omnibus parere_ which it is convenient for every one to obey.
    Camero(35) not only alloweth us to seek a reason of the church’s laws
    (_Non enim_ saith he, _verae ecclesiae libet leges ferre quarum non reddat
    rationem_—It pleaseth not the true church to make and publish laws,
    whereof she giveth not a reason), but he(36) will likewise have us, in
    such things as concern the glory and honour of God, not to obey the laws
    of any magistrate blindly and without a reason. “There was one (saith the
    Bishop of Winchester(37)), that would not have his will stand for reason,
    and was there none such among the people of God? Yes, we find, 1 Sam. ii,
    one of whom it is said, Thus it must be, for Hophni will not have it so,
    but thus his reason is, For he will not. And God grant none such may be
    found among Christians.” From Scripture we learn, that neither hath the
    magistrate any power, but for our good only, Rom. xiii. 4, nor yet hath
    the church any power, but for our edification only, Ephes. iv. 12. Law
    makers, therefore, may not enjoin _quod libet_, that which liketh them,
    nay, nor always _quod licet_, that which is in itself lawful, but only
    _quod expedit_, that which is expedient and good to the use of edifying.
    And to them we may well say with Tertullian,(38) _Iniquam exercetis
    dominationem si ideo negatis licere quia vultis, non quia debuit non
    licere_—You exercise an unjust dominion, if, therefore, you deny anything
    to be free, because you will so, not because it ought not to be free.
    Besides all this, there is nothing which any way pertaineth to the worship
    of God left to the determination of human laws, beside the mere
    circumstances, which neither have any holiness in them, forasmuch as they
    have no other use and praise in sacred than they have in civil things, nor
    yet were particularly determinable in Scripture, because they are
    infinite, but sacred, significant ceremonies, such as cross, kneeling,
    surplice, holidays, bishopping, &c., which have no use and praise except
    in religion only, and which, also, were most easily determinate (yet not
    determined) within those bounds which the wisdom of God did set to his
    written word, are such things as God never left to the determination of
    any human law. Neither have men any power to burden us with those or such
    like ordinances, “For (saith not our Lord himself to the churches), I will
    put upon you none other burden, but that which ye have already, hold fast
    till I come,” Rev. ii. 24, 25. Wherefore, _pro hac_, &c., for this liberty
    we ought stoutly to fight against false teachers.(39) Finally, it is to be
    noted, that though in some things we may and do commendably refuse
    obedience to the laws of them whom God hath set over us, yet are we ever
    obliged (and accordingly intend) still to subject ourselves onto them, for
    to be subject doth signify (as Zanchius showeth(40)), to be placed under,
    to be subordinate, and so to give honour and reverence to him who is
    above, which may well stand without obedience to every one of his laws.
    Yea, and Dr Field(41) also tells us, that “subjection is generally and
    absolutely required where obedience is not.”
    
    IX. Forasmuch as some ignorant ones are of opinion, that when they
    practise the ceremonies, neither perceiving any unlawfulness in them (but,
    by the contrary, being persuaded in their consciences of the lawfulness of
    the same), nor yet having any evil meaning (but intending God’s glory and
    the peace of the church), therefore they practise them with a good
    conscience. Be not ye also deceived, but rather advert unto this, that a
    peaceable conscience, allowing that which a man doth, is not ever a good
    conscience, but oftentimes an erring, bold, presuming, secure, yea,
    perhaps, a seared conscience. A good conscience, the testimony whereof
    giveth a man true peace in his doings, is, and is only, such a one as is
    rightly informed out of the word of God. Neither doth a good meaning
    excuse any evil action, or else they who killed the apostles were to be
    excused, because in so doing they thought they did God good service, John
    xiv. 2. It is the observation even of Papists, that men may commit many a
    soul-ruining scandal, though they intend no such thing as the ruin of
    souls.(42)
    
    X. If once you yield to these English ceremonies, think not that
    thereafter you can keep yourselves back from any greater evils, or grosser
    corruptions which they draw after them; for as it is just with God to give
    such men over to strong delusions as have not received the love of the
    truth, nor taken pleasure in the sincerity of his worship, 2 Thess. ii.
    10, 11; so there is not a more deceitful and dangerous temptation than in
    yielding to the beginnings of evil. “He that is unjust in the least, is
    also unjust in much” saith he who could not lie, Luke xvi. 20. When Uriah
    the priest had once pleased king Ahaz, in making an altar like unto that
    at Damascus, he was afterwards led on to please him in a greater matter,
    even in forsaking the altar of the Lord, and in offering all the
    sacrifices upon the altar of Damascus, 2 Kings xvi. 10-16. All your
    winning or losing of a good conscience, is in your first buying; for such
    is the deceitfulness of sin, and the cunning conveyance of that old
    serpent, that if his head be once entering in, his whole body will easily
    follow after; and if he make you handsomely to swallow gnats at first, he
    will make you swallow camels ere all be done. Oh, happy they who dash the
    little ones of Babylon against the stones! Psal. cxxxvii. 9.
    
    XI. Do not reckon it enough to bear within the inclosure of your secret
    thoughts a certain dislike of the ceremonies and other abuses now set
    afoot, except both by profession and action you evidence the same, and so
    show your faith by your fact. We are constrained to say to some among you,
    with Elijah, “How long halt ye between two opinions?” 1 Kings xviii. 21;
    and to call unto you, with Moses, “Who is on the Lord’s side?” Exod.
    xxxii. 26. Who? “Be not deceived; God is not mocked;” Gal. vi. 7; and, “No
    man can serve two masters,” Mat. vi. 24. However, he that is not against
    us, _pro tanto_, is with us, Mark ix. 40, that is, in so far he so
    obligeth himself unto us as that he cannot speak lightly evil of our
    cause, and we therein rejoice, and will rejoice, Phil. i. 18; yet,
    _simpliciter_, he that is not with us is against us, Matt. xii. 30; that
    is, he who by profession and practice showeth not himself to be on our
    side, is accounted before God to be our enemy.
    
    XII. Think not the wounds which the church hath received by means of these
    nocent ceremonies to be so deadly and desperate, as if there were no balm
    in Gilead; neither suffer your minds so far to miscarry as to think that
    ye wish well to the church, and are heartily sorry that matters frame with
    her as they do, whilst, in the meantime, you essay no means, you take no
    pains and travail for her help. When king Ahasuerus had given forth a
    decree for the utter extirpation of the Jews, Mordecai feared not to tell
    Esther, that if she should then hold her peace enlargement and deliverance
    should arise unto the Jews from another place, but she and her father’s
    house should be destroyed; whereupon she, after three days’ humiliation
    and prayer to God, put her very life in hazard by going in to supplicate
    the king, which was not according to the law, Esth. iv. But now, alas!
    there are too many professors who detract themselves from undergoing
    lesser hazards for the church’s liberty, yea, from using those very
    defences which are according to the laws of the kingdom. Yet most certain
    it is, that without giving diligence in the use of the means, you shall
    neither convince your adversaries, nor yet exonerate your own consciences,
    nor, lastly, have such comfort in the day of your suffering as otherwise
    you should. I know that principally, and, above all, we are to offer up to
    God prayers and supplications, with strong crying and tears, which are the
    weapons of our spiritual warfare, Heb. v. 7; but as this ought to be done,
    so the achieving of other secondary means ought not to be left undone.
    
    If you disregard these things whereof, in the name of God, I have
    admonished you, and draw back your helping hands from the reproached and
    afflicted cause of Christ, for which we plead, then do not put evil far
    from you, for wrath is determined against you. And as for you, my dear
    brethren and countrymen of Scotland, as it is long since first
    Christianity was preached and professed in this land, as also it was
    blessed with a most glorious and much-renowned Reformation:(43) and,
    further, as the gospel hath been longer continued in purity and peace with
    us than with any church in Europe: moreover, as the Church of Scotland
    hath treacherously broken her bonds of oath and subscription wherewith
    other churches about us were not so tied; and, finally, as Almighty God,
    though he hath almost consumed other churches by his dreadful judgments,
    yet hath showed far greater long-suffering kindness towards us, to reclaim
    us to repentance, though, notwithstanding all this, we go on in a most
    doleful security, induration, blindness, and backsliding: so now, in the
    most ordinary course of God’s justice, we are certainly to expect, that
    after so many mercies, so great long-suffering, and such a long day of
    grace, all despised, he is to send upon us such judgments as should not be
    believed though they were told. O Scotland! understand and turn again, or
    else, as God lives, most terrible judgments are abiding thee.
    
    But if you lay these things to heart,—if you be humbled before God for the
    provocation of your defection, and turn back from the same,—if with all
    your hearts and according to all your power, you bestow your best
    endeavours for making help to the wounded church of Christ, and for
    vindicating the cause of pure religion, yea, though it were with the loss
    of all that you have in the world, (_augetur enim religio Dei, quo magis
    premitur_(_44_)—God’s true religion is enlarged the more it is pressed
    down), then shall you not only escape the evils which shall come upon this
    generation, but likewise be recompensed a hundred fold with the sweet
    consolations of God’s Spirit here, and with the immortal crown of never
    fading glory hence. Now, our Lord Jesus Christ himself, and God, even our
    Father, which hath loved us, and hath given us everlasting consolation and
    good hope through grace, stablish you and keep you from evil, that ye may
    be presented before his throne. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with
    you all, Amen.
    
    
    
    
    PROLOGUE.
    
    
    How good reason those wise men had for them who did not allow of the
    English popish ceremonies at the first introducing of these novations into
    the Church of Scotland, foreseeing the bad effects and dangerous evils
    which might ensue thereupon, and how greatly the other sort were mistaken
    who did then yield to the same, apprehending no danger in them, it is this
    day too too apparent to us whose thoughts concerning the event of this
    course cannot be holden in suspense betwixt the apprehensions of fear and
    expectations of hope, because doleful experience hath made us feel that
    which the wiser sort before did fear. Since, then, this church, which was
    once a praise in the earth, is now brought to a most deplorable and daily
    increasing desolation by the means of these ceremonies, which have been
    both the sparkles to kindle, and the bellows to blow up, the consuming
    fire of intestine dissensions among us, it concerneth all her children,
    not only to cry out Ah! and Alas! and to “bewail with the weeping of
    Jazer,” Isa. xvi. 9, but also to bethink themselves most seriously how to
    succour their dear, though distressed mother, in such a calamitous case.
    Our best endeavours which we are to employ for this end, next unto praying
    earnestly “for the peace of Jerusalem,” Psal. cxxii. 6, are these: 1. So
    far as we have attained “to walk by the same rule, to mind the same
    thing,” Phil. iii. 19, and to labour as much as is possible that the
    course of the gospel, the doctrine of godliness, the practice of piety lie
    not behind, because of our differing one from another about the
    ceremonies, lest otherwise τὸ ἔργον grow to be πάρεργον. 2. In such things
    whereabout we agree not, to make diligent search and inquiry for the
    truth. For to have our judgments in our heels, and so blindly to follow
    every opinion which is broached, and squarely to conform unto every custom
    which is set afoot, becometh not men who are endued with reason for
    discerning of things beseeming from things not beseeming, far less
    Christians, who should have their senses exercised to discern both good
    and evil. Heb. v. 14, and who have received a commandment “to prove all
    things,” 1 Thess. v. 21, before they hold fast anything; and least of all
    doth it become us who live in these most dangerous days, wherein error and
    defection so much abound. 3. When we have attained to the acknowledging of
    the truth, then to give a testimony unto the same, according to our
    vocation, contending for the truth of God against the errors of men, for
    the purity of Christ against the corruptions of Antichrist: For to
    understand the truth, and yet not contend for it, argueth cowardliness,
    not courage; fainting, not fervour; lukewarmness, not love; weakness, not
    valour. Wherefore, since we cannot impetrate from the troublers of our
    Israel that true peace which derogateth not from the truth, we may not, we
    dare not, leave off to debate with them. Among the laws of Solon, there
    was one which pronounced him defamed and unhonest who, in a civil uproar
    among the citizens, sitteth still a looker-on and a neuter (_Plut. in
    Vita. Solon_); much more deserve they to be so accounted of who shun to
    meddle with any controversy which disquieted the church, whereas they
    should labour to win the adversaries of the truth, and, if they prove
    obstinate, to defend and propugn the truth against them. In things of this
    life (as Calvin noteth in _Epist. ad Protect. Angl._) we may remit so much
    of the right as the love of peace requireth, but as for the regiment of
    the church which is spiritual, and wherein everything ought to be ordered
    according to the word of God, it is not in the power of any mortal man
    _quidquam hic aliis dare, aut in illorum gratiam deflectere_. These
    considerations have induced me to bestow some time, and to take some pains
    in the study of the controversies which are agitated in this church about
    the ceremonies, and (after due examination and discussion of the writings
    of such as have played the proctors for them) to compile this ensuing
    dispute against them, both for exonering myself, and for provoking of
    others to contend yet more for the truth, and for Zion’s sake not to hold
    their peace, nor be at rest, until the amiable light of long-wished-for
    peace break forth out of all these confusions, Isa. lxii. 1; which, O
    Prince of Peace! hasten, who “wilt ordain peace for us: for thou also hast
    wrought all our works in us,” Isa. xxvi. 12.
    
    
    
    
    ORDER.
    
    
    Because polemic and eristic discourses must follow the adversaries at the
    heels whithersoever they go, finding them out in all the lurking-places of
    their elaborate subterfuges, and conflicting with them wheresoever they
    pitch, until not only all their blows be awarded, but themselves also all
    derouted, therefore, perceiving the informality of the Formalists to be
    such that sometimes they plead for the controverted ceremonies as
    necessary, sometimes as expedient, sometimes as lawful, and sometimes as
    indifferent, I resolve to follow the trace, and to evince, by force of
    reason, that there is none of all those respects to justify either the
    urging or the using of them. And albeit the Archbishop of Spalato (_Pref.
    Libror. de Rep. Eccl._) cometh forth like an Olympic champion, stoutly
    brandishing and bravading, and making his account that no antagonist can
    match him except a prelate, albeit likewise the Bishop of Edinburgh
    (_Proc. in Perth, Assembly_, part iii. p. 55) would have us to think that
    we are not well advised to enter into combat with such Achillean strength
    as they have on their side, yet must our opposites know, that we have more
    daring minds than to be dashed with the vain flourish of their great
    words. Wherefore, in all these four ways wherein I am to draw the line of
    my dispute, I will not shun to encounter and handle strokes with the most
    valiant champions of that faction, knowing that—_Trophoeum ferre me à
    forti viro, pulchrum est: sin autem et vincar, vinci à tali nullum est
    probrum_—But what? Shall I speak doubtfully of the victory, or fear the
    foil? Nay, I consider that there is none of them so strong as he was who
    said, “We can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth,” 2 Cor.
    xxiii. 8. I will therefore boldly adventure to combat with them even where
    they seem to be strongest, and to discuss their best arguments,
    allegations, answers, assertions, and distinctions. And my dispute shall
    consist of four parts, according to those four pretences which are given
    out for the ceremonies, which, being so different one from another, must
    be severally examined. The lawfulness of a thing is in that it may be
    done; the indifferency of it in that it may either be done or left undone,
    the expediency of it in that it is done profitably; and the necessity of
    it in that it may not be left undone. I will begin with the last respect
    first, as that which is the weightiest.
    
    
    
    
                                 THE FIRST PART.
    
    
    AGAINST THE NECESSITY OF THE CEREMONIES.
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Works of Mr. George Gillespie (Vol. 1 of 2)
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: The Works of Mr. George Gillespie (Vol. 1 of 2)
    
    Author: George Gillespie
    
    Contributor: W. M. Hetherington
    
    
            
    Release date: October 8, 2008 [eBook #26849]
                    Most recently updated: June 20, 2020
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/26849
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #26849. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 26849
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.