Fifty Years of Public Service
by Shelby M. Cullom · English · Gutenberg #23097 · 857,076 chars · public domain (US)
The Project Gutenberg eBook of Fifty Years of Public Service
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.
Title: Fifty Years of Public Service
Author: Shelby M. Cullom
Release date: October 20, 2007 [eBook #23097]
Language: English
Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/23097
Credits: Produced by Ed Ferris
*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK FIFTY YEARS OF PUBLIC SERVICE ***
Produced by Ed Ferris
Transcriber's notes:
The dieresis is transcribed by a preceding hyphen. Caps and small
caps have been set as upper and lower case. Names have been corrected
Chapter VIII: "La Fayette", Indiana, kept as a contemporary
variant spelling. McPherson, "clerk of the house" changed to "Clerk
of the House" (of Representatives).
LoC call number: E661.C9
FIFTY YEARS OF PUBLIC SERVICE
[Frontispiece]
_Photo, by Prince Tota, Washington, D. C._
[Facsimile signature]
SMCullom
FIFTY YEARS
OF
PUBLIC SERVICE
_PERSONAL RECOLLECTIONS OF_
SHELBY M. CULLOM
_SENIOR UNITED STATES SENATOR FROM ILLINOIS_
WITH PORTRAITS
_SECOND EDITION_
CHICAGO
A. C. McCLURG & CO.
1911
Copyright
A. C. McCLURG & Co.
1911
Published October, 1911
Second Edition, December, 1911
PRESS OF THE VAIL COMPANY
COSHOCTON, U. S. A.
CONTENTS
CHAPTER
I Birth to Admission to the Bar, 1829 to 1855
II Service as City Attorney at Springfield, 1855 and 1856
III Election to the Illinois Legislature: Lincoln-Douglas
Debates, 1856 to 1858
IV Other Distinguished Characters of that Day, 1858 and 1859
V Nomination of Lincoln and Douglas for the Presidency, 1859
and 1860
VI Speaker of the Illinois Legislature, and a Member of
Congress, 1860 to 1865
VII Lincoln, 1860 to 1864
VIII Notables in the Thirty-ninth Congress, 1864 to 1870
IX The Impeachment of President Johnson
X Speaker of the Legislature, and Governor, 1871 to 1883
XI Grant
XII General John A. Logan
XIII General John M. Palmer
XIV Governor Richard J. Oglesby
XV Senatorial Career, 1883 to 1911
XVI Cleveland's First Term, 1884 to 1887
XVII Cleveland's Defeat and Harrison's First Term, 1888 to 1891
XVIII Cleveland's Second Term, 1892 to 1896
XIX McKinley's Presidency, 1896 to 1901
XX Roosevelt's Presidency, 1901 to 1909
XXI Interstate Commerce
XXII John Marshall Harlan
XXIII Members of the Committee on Foreign Relations
XXIV Work of the Committee on Foreign Relations
XXV The Interoceanic Canal
XXVI Santo Domingo's Fiscal Affairs
XXVII Diplomatic Agreements by Protocol
XXVIII Arbitration
XXIX Titles and Decorations from Foreign Powers
XXX Isle of Pines, Danish West Indies, and Algeciras
XXXI Congress under the Taft Administration
XXXII Lincoln Centennial: Lincoln Library
XXXIII Consecutive Elections to United States Senate
XXXIV Conclusion
Index
LIST OF PORTRAITS
S. M. Cullom
Shelby M. Cullom, while a Law Student
Richard Yates
Stephen A. Douglas
Abraham Lincoln
James G. Blaine
Andrew Johnson
Shelby M. Cullom, while Governor of Illinois
Ulysses S. Grant
John A. Logan
John M. Palmer
Richard J. Oglesby
Grover Cleveland
James A. Garfield
William McKinley
William Howard Taft
Cushman K. Davis
William P. Frye
John C. Spooner
Theodore Roosevelt
Elihu Root
FOREWORD
"Oh, that mine adversary had written a book!"
Such was the exclamation of one who, through the centuries, has
been held up to the world as the symbol of patience and long
suffering endurance, and who believed that he thus expressed the surest
method of confounding an enemy.
I have come to that age in life where I feel somewhat indifferent
as to consequences, and, yielding to the suggestions and insistence
of friends, I determined that I would undertake to write some
recollections, as they occurred to me, of the men and events of my
time.
Naturally, to me the history of the period covered by my life since
1829 is particularly interesting. I do not think that I am prejudiced
when I assert that while this period has not been great in Art and
Letters, from a material, scientific, and industrial standpoint it
has been the most wonderful epoch in all the world's history.
About the period of my birth General Andrew Jackson was first
elected President of the United States. Jackson to me has always
been an interesting character. Theodore Roosevelt has declared
very little respect for him, and has written deprecatingly--I might
say, even abusively--of him. But the truth is, there were never
two Presidents in the White House who, in many respects, resembled
each other more nearly than Jackson and Roosevelt.
Jackson was sixty-one years old when elected President--an unusually
old man to be elected to that high office; and he had served his
country during the War of the Revolution. When I consider this
the thought occurs to me, How young as a Nation we are, after all.
Why, I date almost back to the Revolution! President Taft jocularly
remarked to me recently: "Here's my old friend, Uncle Shelby. He
comes nearer connecting the present with the days of Washington
than any one whom I know." And I suppose there are few men in
public life whose careers extend farther into the past than mine.
During my early life the survivors of the Revolutionary War, to
say nothing of the War of 1812, were very numerous and abundantly
in evidence. Up to that time, no man who had not served his country
in some capacity in the Revolutionary War had been elevated to the
Presidency, and this was the case until the year 1843.
During the year 1829 the crown of Great Britain descended from King
George IV to King William IV. That reign passed away, and I have
lived to see the long reign of Victoria come and go, the reign of
Edward VII come and go, and the accession of King George V. Charles
X ruled in France, Francis I in Austria (the reign of Francis Joseph
had not yet begun), Frederick William III in Prussia, Nicholas I
in Russia; while Leo XII governed the Papal States, the Kingdom of
Italy not yet having come into existence. The United Kingdom of
Great Britain and Ireland had not yet a population of 24,000,000,
all told.
From the dawn of this epoch may well date the practical beginning
of a long cycle of political and intellectual upheaval, and the
readjustment of relations which go to make up world-history, arriving
at a culmination in our great Civil War.
In the last half-century--nay, I might say, within the last two
decades--there has been a mighty impulse in the direction of
scientific investigation, of mechanical invention, of preventive
medicine, of economic improvement, and the like. Germany, in some
respects, has led, but our own country has not been far behind.
Independent research has been wonderfully productive, and rivalry
has been keen. Often the mere suggestion of one scientist has been
taken up and elaborated (or discredited) by other scientists; the
idea of one inventor has been seized upon and bettered, or possibly
proved valueless, by other inventors. The paths to the remote and
inaccessible have been toiled over by rival explorers; new records
have been made by rival aviators; while competitive and co-operative
activities in every line have known a phenomenal growth. New names
have been placed in the Pantheon of the immortals, new planets
discovered in the solar system, new stars added to the clear skies
of our nightly vision. Out of all the striving has come a sweeping
advance in lingual requirements. In most departments of Science,
Art, and Manufacture, the processes and methods of to-day are not
those of yesterday, and the doers of new things have freely coined
new words or given new meaning to old ones. The most complete and
exhaustive encyclopaedia of yesterday is to-day found not entirely
adequate to the already increased wants. Upon all these momentous
factors must these "Recollections," in one way or another, touch
from time to time.
Shelby M. Cullom.
Washington, D. C.
_July, 1911_.
FIFTY YEARS OF PUBLIC SERVICE
CHAPTER I
BIRTH TO ADMISSION TO THE BAR
1829 to 1855
Tides of migration set in about the close of the Revolutionary War,
originating in the most populous of the late Colonies (now States),
debouching from the western slopes of the mountain border-passes
into the headwaters of Kentucky's rivers, and mingling at last in
the fertile valley through which those rivers, in their lower
reaches, find an outlet into the Ohio.
The westward flowing current brought with it two families--the
Culloms of Maryland, and the Coffeys of North Carolina--who settled
in a beautiful valley, not far from the banks of the Cumberland,
which bore the euphonious name of Elk Spring Valley. Richard
Northcraft Cullom, of the first-named family, married Elizabeth
Coffey. They remained in Kentucky until seven children had been
born to them, I being the seventh, the date of my birth occurring
on the twenty-second day of November, 1829. We were a large family,
but not extraordinarily numerous for those times, there being five
brothers and seven sisters.
Kentucky was a Slave State, and my father did not believe in slavery.
He was fairly well to do, and after considering the situation he
determined to seek a home in a Free State and live there to the
end of his days.
A treaty with the Indians in 1784, at Fort Stanwix, had secured
from the Iroquois all claims to the lands which now make up the
States of Ohio, Indiana, and Illinois. At the time of our removal
the State of Illinois was only eleven years old, and but a small
portion of it had any considerable settlements. These were mainly
in the south half of the State. Chicago was then a small village,
Fort Dearborn being at that time of more consequence than the
village. Now Chicago is the second greatest city in the Union in
population and business.
My father, together with Alfred Phillips and William Brown, his
two brothers-in-law, entered land in the same portion of the County
of Tazewell, and at once, on their arrival from Kentucky, pitched
their tents and began the erection of log cabins, in preparation
for winter. Phillips was a large, vigorous man, both in body and
mind. He was a man of the highest integrity, and soon became one
of the leading citizens of Tazewell County, continuing so until
his death. William Brown was a Methodist preacher and was a worthy
example of the consistent minister of the Gospel of Christ. He
was called upon by the people for many miles around to perform
ceremonies on wedding occasions and, in time of sorrow, to preach
at the funerals of departed friends.
My father lived longer than either Phillips or Brown. They both
raised large families, and to-day the youngest son of Phillips--
the Hon. Isaac N. Phillips--is recognized as one of the able lawyers
of the State, and is the reporter of the Supreme Court of Illinois.
My father was a farmer, but he always took great interest in the
affairs of the country, and especially of the State in which he
lived. He was a Whig, and believed in Henry Clay. He took an
active part in political campaigns, and was several times a member
of the House of Representatives of the State Legislature, and once
of the State Senate.
Tazewell County, in which he resided, became a very strong Whig
county, the Whigs having their own way until the Free-soil party,
which soon became the Republican party, took its place as against
the Democratic party. When that time came, Tazewell, like Sangamon,
became Democratic. Sangamon County, in which I live, and Tazewell
County, in which I was raised, were both strong Whig counties while
the Whig party survived; but when it died, the population being
largely from Kentucky and other Southern States, naturally sympathized
with the South on the question of slavery. They drifted into the
Democratic party in large numbers, and gave the control to the
Democracy for a time; and the two parties still struggle for control
in both counties.
My father became well acquainted with Abraham Lincoln while the
latter was a young man. The first time I ever heard of Lincoln,
was when two men came to my father's house to consult with him on
the question of employing an attorney to attend to a law case for
them at the approaching term of the Circuit Court. I remember
hearing my father say to them that if Judge Stephen T. Logan should
be in attendance at court, they should employ him; but if he were
not, a young man named Lincoln would be there, who would do just
about as well. Readers will see by this that while Lincoln was
yet a young man he was ranked among the foremost lawyers at the
Bar. At that time Stephen A. Douglas was beginning to be heard
from.
Judge Logan was one of the best lawyers of the Mississippi Valley.
He was a Kentuckian by birth, and, as a lawyer, was a very great
man. Douglas was a great statesman and a leader of men; a great
debater, but, in my opinion, not a great lawyer. The law is a
jealous mistress; there are no great lawyers who do not give
undivided attention to its study, and Douglas devoted much time to
public affairs.
On the arrival of my father at the grove where he had previously
determined to locate his family, he pitched his tent near a little
stream, then called Mud Creek, afterwards called Deer Creek, because
it was a great resort for wild deer. He soon erected a log cabin
and moved into it with his family. I was less than one year old
when the family located in Illinois. We lived in the cabin for
several years. It was not a single cabin, but there were two cabins
connected together by a covered porch; which was a very pleasant
arrangement in both summer and winter.
Finally, my father built a frame house. During all this time the
wild deer were numerous, and often I have counted from the door
from five to twenty deer feeding in a slough not a quarter of a
mile away.
I never killed a deer. The beautiful animals always seemed to me
so innocent that I had not the heart to shoot them.
The Winter of 1830-31 was long remembered by the early settlers of
Illinois, and of all the now so-called Middle States, as the "winter
of the deep snow." For months it was impossible to pass from one
community to another in the country.
My education was obtained at the local schools and at the seminary
at Mount Morris two hundred miles distant from my father's home.
In my boyhood years there were no common schools. There were only
such schools in the country as the people by subscription saw proper
to provide. The schoolhouse in the neighborhood in which I lived
was built of logs, covered with thick boards, and supplied with
rude benches on its puncheon floor for the scholars to sit upon.
We sat bolt upright, there being nothing to lean against. There
were no desks for our books; and had desks been obtainable there
were but few books to use or care for. We boys whispered to the
girls at our peril; but we took the risk occasionally.
It was my duty as a school-boy, after doing the chores and work
inseparable from farm life, to walk every morning a long distance
over rough country roads to school. After I had attained to a fair
common-school education, I concluded that I could teach a country
school, and was employed to teach in the neighborhood; first for
three months at eighteen dollars per month, and then for a second
term of three months at twenty. I think I have a right to assume
that I did well as a teacher, since the patrons raised my wages
for the second term two dollars per month.
My efforts in teaching school did not secure sufficient funds to
enable me to remain at school away from home very long, and I
determined to try another plan. My father had five yoke of oxen.
I prevailed on him to lend them to me. I obtained a plough which
cut a furrow eighteen to twenty inches wide, and with the oxen and
plough I broke prairie for some months. I thereby secured sufficient
money, with the additional sums which I made from the institution
at Mount Morris at odd times, to enable me to remain at the Mount
Morris Seminary for two years.
I never shall forget the journey from my home in Tazewell County
to Mount Morris, when I first left home to enter the school. As
it well illustrates the difficulties and hardships of travel in
those early days in Illinois, I may be pardoned for giving it
somewhat in detail.
It was in the Spring of the year. My father started with me on
horseback from my home in Tazewell County to Peoria, a distance of
fifteen miles. A sudden freeze had taken place after the frost
had gone out of the ground, and this had caused an icy crust to
form over the mud, but not of sufficient strength to bear the weight
of a horse, whose hoofs would constantly break through. Whereupon
I dismounted and told father that he had better take the horses
back home, and that I would go to Peoria on foot, which I did.
The weather was cold, and I was certainly used up when I arrived
in Peoria. I went to bed, departing early the following morning,
by steamer, for Peru, a distance of twenty-five miles. From there
I took the stage-coach to Dixon, a distance of twelve miles.
There came up another storm during the journey from Peru to Dixon,
and the driver of the stage-coach lost his way and could not keep
in the road. I ran along in front of the coach most of the way,
in order to keep it in the road, the horses following me. From
Dixon I crossed the river, proceeding to Mount Morris by private
conveyance. I never had a more severe trip, and I felt its effects
for very many years afterwards.
The days I spent in old Mount Morris Seminary were the pleasantest
of my life. I was just at the age which might be termed the
formative period of a young man's career. Had I been surrounded
then by other companions, by other environment, my whole future
might have been entirely different. Judged by the standard of the
great Eastern institutions, Mount Morris was not even a third-class
college; but it was a good school, attended by young men of an
unusually high order. In those early days it was the leading
institution of higher learning in Northern Illinois. I enjoyed
Mount Morris, and the friendships formed there continued throughout
my life.
I do not know whether I was a popular student or not, but I was
president of the Amphictyon Society, and, according to the usual
custom, was to deliver the address on retiring from the presidency.
During the course of the address I fainted and was carried from
the chapel, which was very hot and very crowded. I was rolled
around in the snow a while and speedily revived. I was immediately
asked to let one of the boys read the remainder of the address,
but the heroic treatment to which I had been subjected stirred me
to profane indifference respecting its fate. Later I was selected
to deliver the valedictory. So I suppose I must have enjoyed a
reasonable degree of popularity among my fellow students.
It was at Mount Morris that I first became intimate with the late
Robert R. Hitt. He and his brother John, who recently died, were
classmates of mine, their father being the resident Methodist
preacher at Mount Morris. Robert R. Hitt remained my friend from
our school days until his death. He was a candidate for the Senate
against me at one time, but he was no politician, and I defeated
him so easily that he could not harbor a bitter feeling against
me. He was quite a character, and enjoyed a long and distinguished
public career in Illinois. One of the early shorthand reporters
of the State, the reporter of the Lincoln-Douglas debates, he became
intimate with Lincoln, and Lincoln was very fond of him. He filled
numerous important positions at home and abroad, and married a most
beautiful lady, who still survives. He was later appointed Secretary
of Legation at Paris.
Bob Hitt told me that he asked President Grant for the appointment,
and the President at once said that he would give it to him.
Washburne, who had been Secretary of State for a few days, and who
was then minister at Paris, was much astonished when Hitt appeared
and said that he had been appointed Secretary of Legation. Mr.
Washburne denounced both President Grant and Secretary of State
Fish for appointing anybody to fill such an intimate position
without his consent.
Ambassadors and ministers, however, are not consulted as to who
shall be appointed secretaries. These appointments are made by
the President, by and with the advice and consent of the Senate;
but Mr. Washburne, as usual, though that he was a bigger man than
any one else, and that an exception should have been made in his
case. But, when officially informed of the appointment, he submitted
gracefully, and they got along together quite amicably. Strange
to say, Hitt represented Washburne's old district in Congress for
a number of years--many more years than Washburne himself represented
it.
It was as a member of Congress that Mr. Hitt distinguished himself.
He did what every man should do who expects to make a reputation
as a national legislator; and that is to specialize, to become an
expert in some particular branch. He was peculiarly fitted for
foreign affairs. He was a man of education and culture, a student
always, had served abroad for years, had mingled in the highest
society, and it is not strange than in a comparatively few years
he was recognized as the leading authority on all matters coming
before the House pertaining to our foreign relations.
The Foreign Affairs Committee of the House is not nearly so important
a committee as the Foreign Relations Committee of the Senate, and
I may be pardoned for saying that I am chairman of the latter
committee myself.
The reason is this: the Constitution provides that treaties shall
be made only with the advice and consent of the Senate; hence it
is that all such treaties, and consequently the foreign policy of
the general Government, must pass the scrutiny of the Foreign
Relations Committee of the Senate while the House and its committees
have nothing whatever to do with them.
But nevertheless of all the House committees, that of Foreign
Affairs is at times the foremost, and it never had an abler chairman
than Robert R. Hitt. He was certainly in the most remarkable degree
what might be termed a specialist in legislation. He gave but
scant attention to any other branch of legislation. He had little
time or liking for the tariff, finance, appropriations, or for any
branch of legislation that failed to come within his own especial
province. He was, in fact, so indifferent to the general business
of the House that he told me one day that he did not even take the
trouble to select a regular seat; that when any question came up
in which he was interested he would talk from the seat of some
absent colleague. Hence it was that he was seldom seen on the
floor of the House except when some question was raised concerning
our foreign relations; at which time he was immediately sent for.
And it is only justice to him to say that he was the only man in
the House in his time, and no one has since appeared there, who
could so successfully defend or attack the policy of an administration
concerning its foreign affairs.
The late Senator Morgan of Alabama, a most extraordinary character,
of whom I shall have something to say later, and Robert R. Hitt
and myself were appointed members of a commission to frame a form
of government for the Territory of Hawaii, which we had just
acquired. We travelled to Hawaii together. No two more delightful,
entertaining, or interesting men could be found. They are both
dead, and it was my sad privilege to eulogize their public achievements
in the Senate.
In what I am writing from time to time, now, as the months and
years go by, when I have the leisure from my public duties to devote
to it, and without knowing whether what I am writing will ever be
published, I do not want to eulogize any one. If what I say about
men and events shall offend their friends living, I can not help
it. I want only to give my own estimate of the men whom I have
known. Robert R. Hitt was a good man; his honesty and uprightness
were never questioned; he never did a great deal for his district
but he was one of the most useful legislators in his own line--
foreign affairs--whom I have ever known during my service in
Congress. I think this is a fair and just estimate of him.
But to return to Mount Morris, Professor D. J. Pinckney was president
of the Seminary when I was a student there. He knew my father
intimately, and naturally took more than ordinary interest in me.
When I became ill at school, he took me into his own home and kept
me there for a month or more, treating me with the greatest kindness
and consideration.
Years after I left the institution he became interested in politics,
and ran as an independent for Congress against Horatio C. Burchard,
Republican (who was, by the way, a very excellent man and my friend).
Burchard defeated him. When the campaign was on I was invited to
go to Galena and make a speech for Mr. Burchard. It never occurred
to me at the time that I was going into Pinckney's district; but
when I discovered the truth, I could not very well back out. I
made my speech, but was careful not to say a word against Professor
Pinckney, simply advocating the election of Mr. Burchard as a good
Republican. Professor Pinckney, however, took great offense, and
was very cold toward me from that time until his death. I felt
that he had been misled, that it would all come right, and that
some day I would have a plain talk with him; but he died before we
ever got together. He has a son now living in Chicago, a prominent
circuit judge of Cook County.
Among other classmates of mine at Mount Morris, was the late General
John A. Rawlins, who became a distinguished officer and was General
Grant's chief of staff. No better, no truer, man ever lived than
General Rawlins. He was essentially a good man and never had a
bad habit.
Rawlins was a Democrat, and a strong one, during his school days,
and I believe that he remained one until the Civil War. Robert
Hitt and his brother John, together with Rawlins and myself, formed
a sort of four-in-hand, and we were very intimate. We would take
part in the discussions in our society, and Rawlins was especially
strong when a political question was raised. I have heard him,
during his school days, make speeches that would have done credit
to a statesman. He would have done himself and country credit in
any civil office. He served as Secretary of War a few months.
Like so many others who entered the war without the slightest
military training, he came out of it with a brilliant record as an
officer and soldier.
Judge Moses Hallett, a United States judge, retired, of Colorado,
was another classmate of mine. He was an exceptionally good man,
and developed into a very able lawyer and judge. He is still
living, and has become quite wealthy through fortunate real-estate
investments in the vicinity of Denver.
But I fear I might tire the reader by dwelling longer on my school
life at Mount Morris. To look back over those happy early days is
interesting to me; but it is sad to think how few, how very few,
of my schoolmates, then just beginning the journey of life, with
all the enthusiasm and hope of youth, are living to-day. They soon
scattered, some to one vocation, some to another; some to achieve
distinction and fame, some failure; but certain it is that I know
of very few who are now living.
My health was impaired when I left school, and I returned home to
work on the farm. Soon I became strong again, but the labor was
so arduous and uncongenial that I determined upon a change: if
there was any other way of making a honest living, I would try to
find it.
In the meantime I had leased a farm of one hundred and sixty acres
from my father. When Spring came I told him that I wanted to be
released from my contract; that I had deliberately come to the
conclusion that I could make my living some other way--that I
intended to study law. My father did not hesitate to relieve me
of my obligations, and the succeeding October, 1853, I started for
Springfield to enter upon the study of law. I consulted with
Abraham Lincoln, and on his advice I entered the law offices of
Stuart and Edwards, both of whom were Whigs and friends of my
father. They were both very good men and distinguished lawyers.
At that time Abraham Lincoln and Stephen T. Logan and Stuart and
Edwards were the four ablest lawyers of the capital city. I studied
two years in the offices of Stuart and Edwards, pursuing the usual
life of a law student in a country law office, and was admitted to
the Bar in 1855, and elected City Attorney the same year.
Meanwhile, however, I had been ill of typhoid fever for several
months. During the period of my convalescence, I was advised to
return to my home in the country and spend much time riding horseback.
I did so, but the time seemed to drag, and finally I went to the
city of Peoria to learn whether I could direct my restorative
exercise to an additional profitable end. The result was that for
several ensuing weeks I rode about the countryside, buying hogs
for Ting & Brotherson; at the expiration of which time I had regained
my health, was richer by about five hundred dollars, and was thus
enabled to return at once to Springfield and take up again my
interrupted studies.
Having been inducted into the office of City Attorney, I was fairly
launched upon a political career, exceeding in length of unbroken
service that of any other public man in the country's history. In
fact I never accepted but two executive appointments: the first
was an unsought appointment by Abraham Lincoln, after he had become
the central figure of his time, if not of all time; and, second,
an appointment from President McKinley as chairman of the Hawaiian
Commission.
CHAPTER II
SERVICE AS CITY ATTORNEY AT SPRINGFIELD
1855 and 1856
My election as City Attorney of Springfield signalized at once my
active interest in politics at the very moment when the war cloud
was beginning to take shape in the political heavens--a portentous
cloud, but recognized as such at that time by comparatively few of
the thinking people. It had seemed certain for years that a struggle
was sure to come. Being a very young man, I suppose I did not
realize the horrors of a civil war, but I watched with keen interest
the signs of dissolution in political parties, and realignments in
party ties.
In 1854 the country seemed on the verge of a war with Spain over
Cuba which happily was averted. The _Black Warrior_ had been seized
in Havana Harbor, and the excitement throughout the country when
Congress prepared to suspend the neutrality laws between the United
States and Spain was intense.
It was about this time also that the famous Ostend manifesto was
issued without authority from any one. The American representatives
at the Courts of England, France, and Spain met at Ostend to confer
on the best method of settling the difficulties concerning Cuba
and obtaining possession of the island. They issued a manifesto in
which they recommended that Cuba should be purchased if possible,
failing which that it should be taken by force:
"If Spain, actuated by stubborn pride and a false sense of honor,
should refuse to sell Cuba to the United States, then by every law,
human and divine, we shall be justified in wresting it from Spain,
if we possess the power."
The Ostend manifesto was repudiated; but it is certain that we
would have then intervened in favor of freeing Cuba, had it not
been for the dark war clouds which were so quickly gathering over
our own country.
Among the other vital conditions which helped to keep the country's
interest and attention divided at this critical time was the Missouri
Compromise repeal, May 30, 1855. This repealing act early began
to bear political fruit. Already treaties had been made with half
a score of the Indian Nations in Kansas, by which the greater part
of the soil for two hundred miles west was opened. Settlers,
principally from Missouri, immediately began to flock in, and with
the first attempt to hold an election a bloody epoch set in for
that region between the pro-slavery and anti-slavery factions,
fanned by attempts in Massachusetts and other Eastern States to
make of Kansas a Free State.
By methods of intimidation, Whitfield, a slave-holder, was elected
the first delegate to Congress. At a second election thirteen
State Senators and twenty-six members of a Lower House were declared
elected. For this purpose 6,320 votes were cast--more than twice
the number of legal voters.
Foreign affairs other than Spain's unfriendly activities also had
a share in distracting attention. The United States paid Mexico
ten million dollars to be free of the Guadalupe Hidalgo obligation
to defend the Mexican frontier against the Indians.
My first experience after I was elected City Attorney, was to
prosecute persons charged with violating the ordinances prohibiting
the sale of intoxicating liquors. One of my preceptors, the Hon.
Benjamin S. Edwards, was a strong and earnest temperance man. He
volunteered to assist me in the prosecution of what we called
"liquor cases." The fact is that for a time he took charge of the
cases, and I assisted him. Life was made a burden to violators of
liquor ordinances that year in Springfield.
The following year, 1856, was a Presidential year. I was chosen
as an elector on what was called the "Fillmore Ticket." I did not
at that time believe very strongly in Fremont for President. During
the same year, I was nominated as a candidate for the House of
Representatives of the Illinois Legislature, and was supported by
both the Fillmore party and the Free-soil party and thus elected.
The House of Representatives of the Legislature of 1856 was so
close that if all the members who had not been elected as Democrats
united, they had one majority. If any one of them went to the
Democrats, the Democrats would have the control. One of the men
elected on the Fillmore ticket went over, thus giving the Democracy
the coveted one necessary. The Republicans, or as they were then
called, Free-soilers, attempted to organize the House by recognizing
the clerk of the previous House, who was a Free-soiler, it then
being the custom to have the clerk call the House to order and
preside until a temporary organization was perfected. The Democrats
refused to recognize the clerk whom the opposition recognized.
The Democrats declared by vote the election of a temporary chairman,
nominated and elected a sergeant-at-arms and a deputy, and ordered
the two latter officers to carry the clerk out of the hall; which
was promptly done at the expense of a good suit of clothes to the
clerk who departed reluctantly. This was my first experience in
legislation.
A careful reading of the annals of the State of Illinois will show
that this incident is by no means unique in its history.
To go back a few years, when Edward Coles, who had been private
secretary to President Madison, was elected Governor, it was by a
mere plurality vote over his highest competitor, and--to use the
language of former Governor Ford--he was so unfortunate as to have
a majority of the Legislature against him during his whole term of
service. The election had taken place soon after the settlement
of the Missouri question. The Illinois Senators had voted for the
admission of Missouri as a Slave State, while her only Representative
in the Lower House voted against it. This all helped to keep alive
some questions for or against the introduction of slavery.
About this time, also, a tide of immigrants was pouring into Missouri
through Illinois, from Virginia and Kentucky. In the Fall of the
year, every great road was crowded with them, all bound for Missouri,
with their money and long trains of teams and negroes. These were
the most wealthy and best educated immigrants from the Slave States.
Many people who had land and farms to sell, looked upon the good
fortune of Missouri with envy; whilst the lordly immigrant, as he
passed along with his money and droves of negroes, took a malicious
pleasure in increasing it by pretending to regret the short-sighted
policy of Illinois, which excluded him from settlement, and from
purchasing and holding lands.
In this mode a desire to make Illinois a Slave State became quite
prevalent. Many persons had voted for Brown or Phillips with this
view, whilst the friends of a Free State had rallied almost in a
body for Coles.
Notwithstanding the defeat of the Democrats at this election, they
were not annihilated. They had been beaten for Governor only by
a division in their own ranks, whilst they had elected a large
majority of each House of the Assembly, and were determined to make
a vigorous effort to carry their measure at the session of the
Legislature to be held in 1822-23. Governor Coles, in his first
message, recommended the emancipation of the French slaves. This
served as the spark to kindle into activity all the elements in
favor of slavery.
Slavery could not be introduced, nor was it believed that the French
slaves could be emancipated, without an amendment to the Constitution;
the Constitution could not be amended without a new convention, to
obtain which two thirds of each branch of the Legislature had to
concur in recommending it to the people; and the voters, at the
next election, had to sanction it by a majority of all the votes
given for members of the Legislature.
When the Legislature assembled, it was found that the Senate
contained the requisite two-thirds majority; but in the House of
Representatives, by deciding a contested election in favor of one
of the candidates, the Slave party would have one more than two-
thirds, while by deciding in favor of the other, they would lack
one vote of having the majority. These two candidates were John
Shaw and Nicholas Hanson, who claimed to represent the County of
Pike, which then included all the military tract and all the country
north of the Illinois River to the northern limits of the State.
The leaders of the Slave party were anxious to re-elect Jesse B.
Thomas to the United States Senate. Hanson would vote for him,
but Shaw would not; Shaw would vote for the convention, but Hanson
would not. The party had use for both of them, and they determined
to use them both, one after the other. For this purpose, they
first decided in favor of Hanson, admitted him to a seat, and with
his vote elected their United States Senator; and then, toward the
close of the session, with mere brute force, and in the most
barefaced manner, they reconsidered their former vote, turned Hanson
out of his seat, and decided in favor of Shaw, and with his vote
carried their resolution for a convention.
There immediately resulted a very fierce contest before the people,
characterized by lavish detraction and personal abuse--one of the
most bitter, prolonged, and memorable in the history of the State
--and the question of making Illinois permanently a Slave State
was put to rest by a majority of about two thousand votes. The
census of 1850 was the first that enumerated no slaves in our State.
In this connection I cannot avoid giving a little account of
Frederick Adolphus Hubbard, who was Lieutenant-Governor when Coles
was Governor. Hubbard seemed to be a very ignorant man, but
ambitious to become Governor of the State, or to attain some other
position that would give him reputation.
"It is related of him that while engaged in the trial of a lawsuit,
involving the title to a certain mill owned by Joseph Duncan [who
afterwards became Governor], the opposing counsel, David J. Baker,
then recently from New England, had quoted from Johnson's New York
reports a case strongly against Hubbard's side. Reading reports
of the decisions of courts before juries was a new thing in those
days; and Hubbard, to evade the force of the authority as a precedent,
coolly informed the jury that Johnson was a Yankee clock-peddler,
who had been perambulating up and down the country gathering up
rumors and floating stories against the people of the West, and
had them published in a book under the name of 'Johnson's Reports.'
He indignantly repudiated the book as authority in Illinois, and
clinched the argument by adding: 'Gentlemen of the jury, I am sure
you will not believe anything that comes from that source; and
besides that, what did Johnson know about Duncan's mill anyhow?'"( 1)
Hubbard, in 1826, became a candidate for Governor of Illinois. He
canvassed the State, and the following is a sample of his speeches,
recorded by Ford:
"Fellow-citizens, I offer myself as a candidate before you for the
office of Governor. I do not pretend to be a man of extraordinary
talents, nor do I claim to be equal to Julius Caesar or Napoleon
Bonaparte, nor yet to be as great a man as my opponent, Governor
Edwards. Nevertheless I think I can govern you pretty well. I do
not think it will require a very extraordinary smart man to govern
you; for to tell you the truth, fellow-citizens, I do not believe
you will be very hard to govern, nohow."( 2)
In 1825, Governor Coles notified Lieutenant-Governor Hubbard that
he had occasion to leave the State for a time and required the
latter to take charge of affairs. Hubbard did so, and when Governor
Coles returned Hubbard declined to give up the office, asserting
that the Governor had vacated it. He based his contention upon
that clause of the Constitution that provided that the Lieutenant-
Governor should exercise all the power and authority appertaining
to the office of Governor, in case of the latter's absence from
the State, until the time provided by the Constitution for the
election of Governor should arrive. He claimed that the Governor
had vacated the office until the time of the election of a new
Governor, and declined to surrender. The result was, the Governor
had to get a decision of the Supreme Court, which was to the effect
that there was no ground on which to award the writ. Coles was
obliged to submit, but not until he had appealed to the Legislature,
where his contention was equally unsuccessful.
At one time, after repeated and annoying application, Hubbard
obtained from Governor Edwards what he had reason to believe was
a recommendation for a certain office. He became a little suspicious
that the letter was not very strong in his behalf, and in speaking
of it afterwards, in his lisping manner, said: "Contrary to the
uthage amongst gentlemen, he thealed it up; and contrary to the
uthage amongst gentlemen, I broke it open; and what do you think
I found? Instead of recommending me, the old rathcal abuthed me
like a pickpocket."
( 1) Moses, page 334.
( 2) Ford, page 61.
CHAPTER III
ELECTION TO THE ILLINOIS LEGISLATURE: LINCOLN-DOUGLAS DEBATES
1856 to 1858
In the year 1856 I had rather unusual experiences of both victory
and defeat in one and the same political campaign. As candidate
for the Legislature I won out, being elected; as the chosen elector
on the Fillmore ticket, I went down in the party's defeat. The
Whig party was in its expiring days, and what was called the "Know-
Nothing" party was apparently a temporary substitute for it.
Fillmore carried one solitary state--Maryland. Buchanan was elected
by quite a large majority over both Fremont and Fillmore combined.
The administration of President Buchanan has been so frequently
and fully described that there is little, if anything, new to say
about it; but such were the fearful responsibilities incurred by
it for the subsequent bloodshed, that its shortcomings cannot be
entirely ignored in the intelligible presentation of the course of
events which gave direction to my observations and activities.
The campaign of 1856 had been one of the most exiting and hotly
contested ever fought in the State. The only hope the Democrats
had of success was in the division of their opponents and in
preventing their fusion. Their denunciations of abolitionists and
"Black Republicans," as they termed their antagonists, were without
bounds. But here and there some one would be called to account,
as in the case of the late John M. Palmer, since distinguished in
war and peace, and some years ago candidate of the Gold Democrats
for the Presidency.
Between him and Major Harris, then running for Congress in his
district, there had been considerable ill-feeling. The major had
written a letter to be read at a Democratic meeting at which Palmer
was present. It was very abusive of the Republicans, and Palmer
rising, remarked the fact that the author would not dare make such
charges to the face of any honest man. Harris, as related by the
historian Moses, hearing of this, announced that he would resent
it at the first opportunity. This Palmer soon gave him by attending
one of his meetings. The major in the course of his remarks indulged
in the most vituperative language against abolitionists, calling
them disturbers of the peace, incendiaries, and falsifiers; and at
length, turning to Palmer and pointing his finger at him, said, "I
mean you, sir!" Palmer rising to his feet, instantly replied,
"Well, sir, if you apply that language to me you are a dastardly
liar!" And drawing a pistol, he started toward the speaker's stand.
"Now, sir," he continued, "when you get through, I propose to reply
to you." The major had not anticipated this turn of affairs, but
prudently kept his temper and finished his speech. Then Palmer
arose and, laying his weapon before him, cocked, proceeded to give
the Democratic party such a castigation as none of those present
had ever heard before.
It was in the campaign of 1856 that I first began to make political
speeches. James H. Matheny, who was then our circuit clerk,
accompanied me to several meetings where we both delivered addresses.
He was an old Whig inclined toward Democracy, and I was a Whig
inclined toward Republicanism. The result was I made Republican
speeches, while Judge Matheny made Democratic speeches.
Our first meeting away from home was at Petersburg, Menard County.
Being a candidate for elector on the Fillmore ticket, I made my
first away-from-home speech, which I thought was a pretty good
Republican speech. Matheny followed me with a hot Democratic
speech, attacking especially Judge Trumbull, then our United States
Senator. I remained pretty steadily in the campaign of that year,
making about the same character of speech wherever I went.
Fillmore was very popular in Central Illinois, where the Whig party
also had quite a large following during its palmy days, but he did
not receive votes enough to come anywhere near carrying the State.
Sangamon, my home county, and Tazewell County, where I was brought
up, both gave their majority votes for Fillmore.
The Hon. John T. Stuart and his partner, the Hon. B. S. Edwards,
with whom I studied law, besides being able lawyers and first-class
men, were both Whigs; Mr. Stuart especially took an active part in
the campaign. The latter was invited to attend what was called a
Fillmore meeting at Shelbyville, several counties away from Sangamon.
It so happened that he could not go, and the people of Shelbyville
telegraphed for me. I went, and it turned out to be a combined
Fremont, Buchanan, and Fillmore meeting--at least the three meetings
there were held all on the same day.
The Fillmore camp gathered its forces out in the woods until about
two o'clock in the afternoon. The Buchanan and Fremont crowds then
marched in, informing the first-comers that they regarded their
right to have the first meeting pre-eminent. An agreement was
arrived at after some little wrangling, and old General Thornton
was chosen to preside. He determined that, as I was not only a
young man but the farthest from home, I should make the first speech
--an arrangement that suited me very well.
I made my speech, as good a one as I could, and in closing, somewhat
hurriedly announced that I was obliged to leave for home, much as
I might wish to remain with them to the close of the meeting. The
result was that most of the Fillmore people followed me away and
came nearly breaking up the whole performance. I urged them to go
back and listen to the other speakers; but they declined to do so
until I had gotten off for home. It was my first venture at speech-
making away from home on national issues.
I worked and voted for Fillmore because I had a very high opinion
of him as a good man, and did not then think very much of Fremont
as a proper candidate for the Presidency. Subsequently Fremont
became better known, and occupied a high place in the estimation
of the people of the United States, as a gallant soldier and a
statesman, enjoying the unique honor of having been the first
candidate of the Republican party for President.
I have taken an active part in every campaign since 1856, excepting
when poor health prevented a regular speaking campaign.
The animosities of the campaign of 1856 were carried into the
Legislature and kept alive in the House during the entire session.
Governor Bissell's inaugural address was a dignified State paper
in which he referred to the administration of his predecessor in
highly complimentary terms. He concurred in all his recommendations,
but suggested no measures of his own. Although he had commented
briefly upon the Kansas-Nebraska controversy, and in mild terms,
his remarks stirred the ire of the Democrats. Upon the motion to
print the address, a virulent attack was made upon him, led, strange
to say, by John A. Logan, afterwards the foremost volunteer general
of the Union, and a Republican of Republicans. The rancor of the
Democrats against Governor Bissell, who at that time was a physical
wreck from a stroke of paralysis, though mentally sound, was largely
due to their recollection of the fearless manner in which he had
responded, some years before, to a challenge given him by Jefferson
Davis to a duel. That episode has long since become historic, and
I need not enlarge upon it here.
As was the political temper in the State of Illinois, so was it,
to a greater or less degree, throughout the entire Nation.
Buchanan's first message repeated the assurance that the discussion
of slavery had come to an end. The clergy were criticised for
fomenting prevalent disturbances. The President declared in favor
of the admission of Kansas, with a Constitution agreeable to a
majority of the settlers. He also referred to an impending decision
of the Supreme Court, with which he had been made acquainted, and
asked acquiescence in it. This was Judge Taney's decision in the
Dred Scott case, rendered two days after Buchanan's inauguration.
An action had been begun in the Circuit Court in Missouri by Scott,
a negro, for the freedom of himself and children. He claimed that
he had been removed by his master in 1834 to Illinois, a Free State,
and afterwards taken into territory north of the compromise line.
Sanford, his master, replied that Scott was not a citizen of
Missouri, and could not bring an action, and that he and his children
were Sanford's slaves. The lower courts differed, and the case
was twice argued. The decision nullified the Missouri restriction,
or, indeed, any restriction by Congress on slavery in the Territories.
Chief-Justice Taney said:
"The question is whether the class of persons (negroes) compose a
portion of the people, and are constituent members of this sovereignty.
We think they are not included under the word 'citizen' in the
Constitution, and can therefore claim none of the rights and
privileges of that instrument."
Negroes, as a race, were at that time considered as a subordinate
and inferior class who had been subjugated by the dominant whites,
and had no rights or privileges except such as those who held the
power and the government might choose to grant them. They had for
more than a century been regarded as beings of an inferior grade--
so far inferior that they possessed no rights which the white man
was bound to respect; and the negro might justly and lawfully be
reduced to slavery for his (the white man's) benefit. The negro
race by common consent had been excluded from civilized governments
and the family of nations, and doomed to slavery. The unhappy
black race was separated from the whites by indelible marks long
before established, and was never thought of or spoken of except
as property.
The Chief-Justice further annulled the Missouri restriction, by
asserting that "the act of Congress which prohibited a citizen from
holding property of this kind north of the line therein mentioned
is not warranted by the Constitution, and is therefore void."
Benton said that it was "no longer the exception, with freedom the
rule; but slavery was the rule, with freedom the exception."
It was a year of financial distress in America, which recalled the
hard times of twenty years before. The United States treasury was
empty.
Early in this year (1856) a Legislature had met at Topeka, Kansas,
and was immediately dissolved by the United States marshals. A
Territorial Legislature also met at Lecompton and provided for a
State Constitution. The people of Kansas utterly refused to
recognize the latter body which had been chosen by the Missouri
invaders, and both parties continued to hold their elections.
Thus it may be seen that these episodes were the culmination of a
long series of events leading to a new alignment of the country's
political forces. The Republican party was the child of this
ferment of unrest. The formation of a new political party, or the
regeneration of an old one, is always due to events, and not to
the schemes and purposes of men except as events sometimes originate
in such purposes and schemes. In this case the steps in the course
of events which had rendered the formation of an anti-slavery party
inevitable were: The pro-slavery provisions of the Constitution,
the foreign slave trade, the acquisition of the Territory of
Louisiana, the invention of the cotton-gin and its effects, the
Missouri Compromise, the nullification schemes of South Carolina,
the colonization and annexation of Texas, the Mexican War, the
contest over the admission of California, the Compromise Measure
of 1850, and finally the repeal of the Missouri Compromise in 1854.
The name of the party was an incident only, and not an essential
or very important incident; its principles and purposes were the
vital facts. When events demand a new party, or the reorganization
of an old one, all resistance is usually borne down speedily. On
the other hand, it is a wasteful exhibition of human power to
attempt the creation of a new party by the force of combined will
and resolutions formulated in public meetings. Abraham Lincoln's
great experience or keener penetration, or both, guided him at the
outset of the realignments on political issues, and at the opening
of the Congressional campaign of 1858, I followed him firmly and
without mental reservation into the ranks of the Republican party.
Hence it was that I was present on that historic occasion when the
Republican party of the State of Illinois held a convention at
Springfield, June 17 of the year named, and nominated Lincoln for
the seat in the United States Senate, then held by Stephen A.
Douglas, who at that time was usually affectionately referred to
by his partisan followers as "The Little Giant." This nomination
was anticipated, and Mr. Lincoln had prepared a speech, which he
then delivered, in which he set forth, in a manner now universally
recognized as masterly, the doctrines of the Republican party. He
arraigned the administration of Mr. Buchanan and denounced the
repeal of the Missouri Compromise under the lead of Senator Douglas.
In that speech he made the declaration, which I remember as clearly
as though an event of yesterday, then characterized as extravagant
but long since accepted as prophetic: "I believe this Government
cannot endure permanently, half slave and half free."
That address inaugurated a discussion which has no exact parallel
in history--certainly no equal in American political history. It
introduced Mr. Lincoln to the country at large, and prepared the
way for his nomination to the Presidency two years later. On the
declaration above quoted Mr. Douglas based many arguments, in vain
attempts to prove that Mr. Lincoln was a disunionist.
During this period Douglas addressed an enthusiastic assemblage at
Chicago, and in the course of his speech adverted to the arraignment
of himself by Mr. Lincoln. He took direct issue with that gentleman
on his proposition that, as to Freedom and Slavery, "the Union will
become _all_ one thing or _all_ the other," and maintained strenuously
that "it is neither desirable nor possible that there should be
uniformity in the local institutions and domestic regulations of
the different States of this Union."
An announcement that Mr. Lincoln would reply to Mr. Douglas on the
following evening brought out another assemblage, July 10, which
was awakened, before the speaker had concluded, to an enthusiasm
at least equal to that which the eloquence of Douglas had aroused.
The issues involved in this famous series of debates are too familiar
to all students of our Nation's political history to be considered
at length in these pages. Mr. Lincoln analyzed and answered the
various arguments advanced by Mr. Douglas the evening before; and
the closing paragraphs of his reply to the insistent reminders
"that this Government was made for white men," were memorable:
"Those arguments that are made, that the inferior race are to be
treated with as much allowance as they are capable of enjoying;
that as much is to be done for them as their conditions will allow.
What are these arguments? They are the arguments that kings have
made for enslaving the people in all ages of the world. You will
find that all the arguments in favor of kingcraft were of this
class; they always bestrode the necks of the people, not that they
wanted to do it, but because the people were better off for being
ridden. That is their argument, and this argument of the Judge is
the same old serpent that says: 'You work, and I eat; you toil,
and I will enjoy the fruits of it.'"
Six days thereafter, July 16, Senator Douglas in a great speech
again tried to break the force of his opponent's facts and logic.
This was at Bloomington, and Mr. Lincoln was again a careful
listener. On the evening following, July 17, at Springfield, before
an enthusiastic audience, he proceeded to dissect the matters so
plausibly presented.
At the same hour Douglas was addressing a Springfield audience of
his own, ridiculing especially Mr. Lincoln's alleged attitude toward
the Supreme Court.
Contrasting the disadvantages under which, by reason of an unfair
apportionment of State Legislature representation and otherwise,
the Republicans labored in that campaign, Mr. Lincoln on that
occasion said in the course of his talk:
"Senator Douglas is of world-wide renown. All the anxious politicians
of his party, or who have been of his party for years past, have
been looking upon him as certainly, at no distant day, to be the
President of the United States. They have seen in his round, jolly,
fruitful face, post-offices, land-offices, marshalships, and cabinet
appointments, _chargé_-ships and foreign missions, bursting and
sprouting out in wonderful exuberance, ready to be laid hold of by
their greedy hands. And as they have been gazing upon this attractive
picture so long, they cannot, in the little distraction that has
taken place in the party, bring themselves to give up the charming
hope; but with greedier anxiety they rush about him, sustain him,
and give him marches, triumphal entries, and receptions, beyond
what even in the days of his highest prosperity they could have
brought about in his favor. On the contrary, nobody has ever
expected me to be President. In my poor, lean, lank face, nobody
has ever seen that any cabbages were sprouting out."
He affirmed that Popular Sovereignty, "the great staple" of the
Douglas campaign, was "the most arrant Quixotism that was ever
enacted before a community."
As a result of these preliminary speeches of the Congressional
campaign it was generally conceded that, at last, the "Little Giant"
had met his match, and the intellectual and political appetites of
the public called for more. In recognition of this demand, Mr.
Lincoln opened a correspondence which led to an agreement with Mr.
Douglas for a series of joint discussions, seven in number, on fixed
dates in August, September, and October. Alternately they were,
in succession, to open the discussion and speak for an hour, with
another half-hour at the close after the other had spoken for an
hour and a half continuously. My friend and schoolmate, the late
Mr. R. R. Hitt, an efficient stenographer, was employed to report
the whole series, and thus we have a full record of the most
remarkable debate, viewed from all points, that has ever occurred
in American history--possibly without a parallel in the world's
history. Vast assemblages gathered from far and near and listened
with breathless attention to these absorbingly interesting
discussions.
Notwithstanding the intense partisan feeling that was evoked, the
discussion proceeded amidst surroundings characterized by the utmost
decorum. The people evidently felt that the greatest of all
political principles, that of human liberty itself, was hanging on
the issue of this great political contest between intellectual
giants, thus openly waged before the world. They accordingly rose
to the dignity and solemnity of the occasion, as has been well said
by one who was then a zealous follower of Douglas, vindicating by
their very example the sacredness with which the right of free
speech should be regarded at all times and everywhere.
I have elsewhere described the disappointment I personally felt at
the result, when the election returns came in. Although the popular
vote stood 125,698 for Lincoln to 121,130 for Douglas--showing a
victory for Lincoln among the people--yet enough Douglas Democrats
were elected to the Legislature, when added to those of his friends
in the Illinois Senate elected two years before and held over, to
give him fifty-four members of both branches of the Legislature on
joint ballot, against forty-six for Mr. Lincoln.
CHAPTER IV
OTHER DISTINGUISHED CHARACTERS OF THAT DAY
1858 and 1859
More than four months had elapsed since Lincoln's epoch-marking
speech at Springfield had brought on his great discussion with
Douglas, when on October 20, 1858, Governor Seward at Rochester,
New York, intensified the political inflammation of the times by
saying in a notable speech:
"These antagonistic systems (free labor and slave labor) are
continually coming close in contact. It is an irrepressible conflict
between opposing and enduring forces; and it means that the United
States must and will, sooner or later, become either an entirely
slave-holding or entirely a free-labor nation."
A book written by a young Southerner, "The Impending Crisis in the
South--How to Meet It," was recommended in a circular signed by a
large number of the Republican Congressmen, and thus given a vogue
and weight out of all proportion to the standing of the author,
whose recent death under tragic circumstances at an advanced age
has drawn the name of Hinton Rowan Helper for a brief hour from
its long obscurity.
"Dred, a Tale of the Dismal Swamp," by the author of "Uncle Tom's
Cabin," served, if such service were at all needed, to keep fresh
in all civilized lands the name of Harriet Elizabeth Beecher Stowe.
The British Museum has a long shelf filled with different translations,
editions, and versions of her greatest literary work.
In the month of September Mr. Lincoln delivered a speech at
Cincinnati, in reply to Mr. Douglas. In that speech he addressed
himself to the citizens of Kentucky, and advocated the nomination
of Mr. Douglas to the Presidency, upon the ground that he was more
devoted to the South than were the Southern leaders themselves,
and that he was wiser in methods for defending their rights.
This was a form of attack which Douglas had not anticipated, and
which he could neither resent nor answer. As the event proved,
the seed thus sown was to bear fruit abundantly in results at the
ensuing National Democratic conventions, and at the Presidential
election two years later. Until June, Mr. Lincoln was unknown
outside of Illinois and Indiana. Judge Douglas had already taken
a high place among the able men of his time of national and
international reputation. In September, Lincoln's character was
understood and his ability was recognized in all the non-slaveholding
States of the Union. His mastery over Douglas had been complete.
His logic was unanswerable, his ridicule fatal; every position
taken by him was defended successfully. At the end Douglas had
but one recourse. He misstated Lincoln's positions, and then
assailed them.
But Lincoln was ever on the alert to expose his opponent's fallacies,
and to hold up the author to the derision or condemnation of his
hearers.
Mr. Lincoln's first fame rests, therefore, on that great debate.
Judge Douglas had long been famous as an experienced politician
and an exceptionally skilful debater. As lawyers both ranked high
in their State at a time when the bar of Illinois could boast of
exceptionally brilliant and able forensic talent.
As it is my purpose to treat of both these great men in some detail
in subsequent pages of this work, devoting at least a full chapter
to Mr. Lincoln, so long my admired and never failing friend, I
shall now proceed to give some personal recollections concerning
certain other of the distinguished characters of that day, chiefly
those connected with the bar.
I knew Judge David Davis very well. He was Circuit Judge on our
State circuit for a number of years, and until Mr. Lincoln became
President, when he was made Associate Justice of the Supreme Court
of the United States. When a young lawyer Davis was a Whig; and
my father, being also a Whig, took a great interest in him, as he
did in every young lawyer he knew who became affiliated with that
party. My father thought himself justified in believing that Davis
would become a power in the land. Hence he took up the young man
soon after he had settled in the practice of the law at Bloomington;
and I have heard him state that he gave Davis the first case he
ever had in Tazewell County, by advising another to employ him.
But he re-enacted, on the less conspicuous forum, the distressing
experience of failure of Disraeli in his first attempt to address
the English House of Commons. Davis broke down in the speech he
had prepared to make, to the great mortification of my father, who
had exhibited such unusual pride and confidence as to counsel his
employment in the case. Subsequently Davis redeemed himself, as
did Disraeli, and became a most prominent and successful lawyer.
Among other interesting circumstances of his career was that of a
little claim he had for a client in Boston against a merchant in
Chicago. He could not collect the debt, except by levying on a
tract of land in Chicago--eighty acres, I think. Davis reported
what he had done, and his client manifested dissatisfaction with
the result. He so vigorously stated his disappointment to Davis,
that the latter immediately redeemed the land by taking it himself
and paying the amount of money due the client. This tract grew in
value with the growth of Chicago until it became worth a million
dollars or more.
Judge Davis was a remarkably popular man on his circuit. He was
thoroughly honest, and could not endure a dishonest man on the
witness-stand or anywhere else. I remember a man in Chicago who
on one occasion filed a bill of discovery for the purpose of finding
real estate that he seemed once to have had an interest in, and
which also involved the insertion of Judge Davis's own name, since
he had himself at one time owned the tract of land involved. The
man had lost his voice to a considerable extent, so that he had
come to be called "Whispering Smith." He became notorious as a
successful collector of debts, where persons had failed and were
unable to pay their debts. He had filed in this case a bill of
discovery consisting of thirty or forty printed pages which included
the names of many persons who had been found to have owned the real
estate at one time or another, among them being Judge Davis.
Discovering this, and being entirely innocent of any complicity
with the party who had failed, the Judge denounced Smith in open
court for the outrage of swearing to something he did not know
anything about, and practically threw him out of court.
There was an incident characteristic of his fidelity to friendships
which I think well worth relating. It occurred when I was Governor
of Illinois. I was invited by the Agricultural Society of McLean
County to deliver an address, and went to Bloomington on the day
designated. I was called upon by Judge Davis, who resided there.
He was a very polite man, and asked me if he could not take me out
to the fair-ground. I told him I would be delighted if he would
do so. He came for me with his carriage, and on our arrival at
the grounds took me to the stand, disregarding the prearrangements
of the officials of the fair, and introduced me to the audience.
In doing so he made a speech, very complimentary to my father, but
scarcely mentioning me at all--not more than to introduce me at
the end of his eulogistic remarks. Many of the lawyers of the town
were present. I knew them all, and they were much amused at this
unusual style of introduction. And so was I. I knew, of course,
that he was a great friend of my father, and a great friend of mine
as well.
Judge Davis was elected to the Senate in 1877 to succeed General
Logan, and resigned his seat on the bench to accept the position.
He became quite fond of the Senate, and during his one term there
he was elected president _pro tempore_ of the body under somewhat
unusual conditions. The Senate at that time was almost evenly
divided between the two parties. The two senators from New York,
however (both Republicans), and Mr. Aldrich, of Rhode Island, had
been elected by their respective Legislatures, but had not taken
their seats. This gave the Democrats a temporary majority, and
the Senate proceeded to elect Senator Bayard, of Delaware, as its
president _pro tempore_. Within the next day or two, however, the
two New York senators and Senator Aldrich were admitted to their
seats; this left a majority of two for the Republicans if Davis
acted with them, and the two parties tied if Davis acted with the
Democrats. Under these circumstances, General Logan, who after
being out for two years had been re-elected to the Senate, moved
in the caucus that David Davis be the Republican candidate for
president _pro tempore_. Later he made the nomination in the Senate
itself, and Senator Davis was elected, Senator Bayard descending,
amid general laughter, from the chair which he had occupied for
but a short time.
Senator Davis was very proud of the position of president _pro
tempore_, which he retained to the end of his Senate term. He had
been acting quite independently, but seemed to incline a little
toward the Democrats. After he became president _pro tempore_,
while he never announced himself a Republican, he generally acted
with the Republicans.
I was in the Senate the day before Senator Davis's term expired.
He was soliloquizing to himself in the intervals of putting motions
and attending to the routine of his office. He was very fond of
Senator Isham G. Harris of Tennessee, and when he had occasion to
call a senator to the chair, generally it would be Harris. He
called Harris to him while I was there, and I heard him say as his
friend came up: "Harris, Harris! When I get out of here I won't
have to listen to old Bayard any more!"
He was a very remarkable man and a friend of Lincoln, and Lincoln
was a friend of his. I suppose that Davis did as much to secure
Lincoln's nomination over Seward as any one man, although Judge
Logan worked with equal zeal. But Davis knew more people than did
Judge Logan, although the latter was, in my opinion, the better
lawyer.
In the days of Davis's judicial life on the State bench, the judge
and the lawyer had a pretty large circuit. Davis's circuit was
composed of several large counties. It was the custom to travel
the circuit, judge, lawyers, and all, together. At that period
there were no railway facilities worth mentioning, and they had to
go by private conveyance--wagon or carriage or on horseback as the
case might be. Probably a dozen lawyers might go together, all
putting up at the same hotel, and generally having a good time at
night, spinning yarns. Lincoln was a good story-teller, and so
was Davis; and the evenings were made exceedingly agreeable to all
concerned.
In no small measure as a result of the influences thus put into
operation, the lawyers of the period were better qualified to get
along in life than those of later days; that is to say, for the
rough-and-tumble life they were better able to take care of themselves
than the lawyers of a more recent date have been, as a general rule.
Judge Stephen T. Logan was, I think, the best lawyer that I have
ever known in Illinois. He went to Illinois at an early age and
lived there until his death; he had attained the age of a little
more than eighty years before he died. He was purely a lawyer.
I think I never knew another lawyer who could so everlastingly ruin
a man who undertook to misrepresent the truth. He seemed to
understand intuitively whether a man was trying to tell the truth
or was lying; if the latter, his words would so effectually be torn
to pieces that they could be of no earthly value. But he was not
an adept as a politician. He ran for Congress at one time against
a man named Thomas L. Harris, and was beaten. He also ran later
for Judge of the Supreme Court, and was beaten. This defeat was
not his fault, however, as the community was a strongly Democratic
one. I recall a story current in those days, to the effect that
some man who had recently come from the east inquired, while talking
with him, "By the way, Judge, didn't you run for the Supreme Court
last year?" In his squeaky voice, the judge replied, "No; I hardly
walked."
But the judge was a true man in every respect,--honest, faithful
to his friends, and fearless in doing whatever he believed to be
right. He felt, I think, a little bit disappointed that President
Lincoln did not appoint him instead of Davis a Judge of the Supreme
Court.
I came to Washington and saw Mr. Lincoln in Judge Logan's behalf
without any suggestion that I do so from Logan or any one else,
but simply because I believed that the President ought to appoint
him on the Supreme Bench in preference to any other man in the
State.
Logan was a better lawyer than Davis; but Davis was an abler
politician than Logan. I have always felt that in view of the fact
that Lincoln and Logan had been partners earlier, and also neighbors
and close friends, he ought to have nominated Logan instead of
Davis. Davis, Logan, and Browning were all well qualified for the
Supreme Court, all of them friends of Lincoln, and all Whigs.
Lincoln had to make the choice, and I think the selection was
influenced by Davis's great assistance in securing his nomination.
Judge Logan was also a close Whig friend of my father, and earnest
in his friendship for me on that account. When I was a candidate
for the nomination for Governor I had a pretty stiff fight for the
first term. There were rumors that men were going to attack my
personal character. I did not know about the judge's action in
the premises, but when the convention met, Judge Logan went to it
as a private citizen and crowded himself into the hall, remaining
here until I was nominated. Then he went home. I was told afterwards
that he had gone there for the purpose of defending me in case of
an attack against my personal character.
Of course, I could not but greatly appreciate a friendship so
manifest.
He had a son, David Logan, who went to Oregon as a young lawyer,
and became very eminent there. In later years the judge wrote to
him, proposing that if he would come back home he would take him
into partnership. To this the father received a reply from David,
proposing that if he would come out there a partnership with the
son was subject to his acceptance or refusal. The judge died after
attaining full four-score years, and the son at an age less
advanced.
I think Judge Logan also felt a bit sour toward Mr. Lincoln because
the latter, he thought, ought to have been more helpful than he
was to his son in his effort to be elected to the United States
Senate from Oregon, at the time Baker was elected.
Speaking of Judges Logan and Davis, I am reminded of the exceptionally
high character of the lawyers of Illinois of that day, and more
especially of Springfield. I think there has never been a time
when it had another such splendid bar. It must be that high personal
character in leaders has a direct and marked influence in elevating
the general characters of the followers. The young lawyers,
especially, are impelled by a force implanted by nature to admire
and to strive to imitate or attain to the great qualities manifested
in life of those to whom leadership is conceded by common consent.
Colonel E. D. Baker was a very good lawyer. Also Orville H.
Browning, of Quincy, who was in Springfield attending the various
courts whose sittings were at the State capital much of the time.
Then there was Archibald Williams; and Stephen A. Douglas, a great
man in every way, was on the bench a part of the time. Abraham
Lincoln was, of course, the equal of any man, on the bench or off
of it. Such men prominently in the lead as lawyers, and as men
among men, could not but stimulate the ambitions and loftier
aspirations of other lawyers, especially the younger ones. In
striving to pay the tributes--imitation, etc.,--that can be accorded
to greatness, they become great themselves; and perhaps here may
be found the real or chief cause of the very large numbers of
conspicuously eminent men congregated at the capital of Illinois
in those days.
Judge Lyman Trumbull I always regarded as one of the exceptional
lawyers of the country. I came to know him well while I was a
member of the House and he a United States Senator. During those
days I saw very much of him. When Trumbull came to the Senate
there was some prejudice against him, growing out of circumstances
(related elsewhere in these pages) which prevented the election of
Mr. Lincoln, and which seemed to be plainly within Mr. Trumbull's
control. But the feeling soon vanished, and Trumbull's course in
the Senate was so true to the principles of the party which Mr.
Lincoln had championed, that the manner in which he had secured
the election was soon forgotten, or at least condoned, and the
judge remained there for a long period of service--three terms.
While he was there I came to the House of Representatives, and came
to be, as our association grew more and more intimate, very fond
of Senator Trumbull. I also admired his ability. He was one of
the few in that body who could hold his own with Judge Douglas in
debate, and when he came into the Senate he at once took issue with
Douglas, they being in controversy with each other very frequently
on slavery and other political questions, until Douglas's career
ended, about the beginning of the Civil War.
I was, perhaps, as intimate personally with Judge Trumbull during
my stay in the House as any other member. Barton C. Cook and Norman
B. Judd also were as intimate with the judge, as any other members
of the Illinois delegation. Nothing ever happened to change these
conditions, until the vote which Trumbull cast against the impeachment
of Andrew Johnson. Mr. Cook and Mr. Judd, especially the latter,
seemed to be almost bitterly angry against Judge Trumbull.
As a result of that vote opposition to him began to grow in the
party. However, almost immediately after the impeachment he was
re-elected, although at the time not a candidate. He was subsequently
nominated by the Democratic party for Governor of Illinois. I ran
against him as the candidate of the Republican party, and was
elected over him by a majority of about thirty-eight thousand. He
imagined, so I have heard, that he was going to beat me, and was
considerably surprised at his failure to do so.
He died only a few years ago, at an advanced age. His first wife
was a sister of Dr. Jayne, an excellent man, and, I am glad to add,
he and I are warm personal friends. I am very sorry to say, though,
that his children, I believe, are all gone, as are mine.
There were other men who had risen to prominence in Illinois, of
whom I wish to write, and some who were then new upon the stage of
public life, whom I knew and who subsequently achieved distinction.
I have already postponed my reminiscences of Mr. Lincoln to a later
chapter than I could wish, but in point of time we have now come
to the year of his nomination and election to the Presidency of
the United States, and the beginning of a career which was to be
finished in the course of only a little over four years.
The reference to my old friend Doctor William Jayne reminds me that
I should say something of my Springfield friends,--some living,
but many dead. It is to these friends that I am indebted for my
success in public life, and they have generally loyally supported
me, although friends in other parts of the State have been quite
as loyal and devoted to my interests when I have been a candidate
for high public office.
In the days of Lincoln, I do not believe that there ever was a
community that contained so many really splendid men, men who were
so well fitted to fill any place in the State or Nation, as did
Springfield. I can refer to only a few of those of State and
National renown. If I have overlooked some whom I should have
mentioned, I hope I shall be pardoned.
First of all comes Lincoln. From time to time, as I have written
these recollections, I have spoken of him. I will later give my
estimate of Douglas, who, while not a citizen of Springfield, spent
a great deal of time there as a member of the Supreme Court, as a
member of the Legislature, and on legal, political, and social
affairs. In the last-mentioned connection he at one time was a
rival for the hand of Mary Todd, afterwards Mrs. Abraham Lincoln.
I have thought and written something of Stephen T. Logan, and to
my own old law partner, Milton Hay, I refer in other parts of these
recollections. There were no better lawyers in their day.
William H. Herndon, Lincoln's law partner, was a capable lawyer
also. He wrote an excellent life of his distinguished partner.
Herndon was one of the earliest Republicans of his State. While
Lincoln believed in the principles of the party from the very
beginning, the truth is, he was a little slow in becoming a member
of it; and Herndon always claimed that he had much to do with making
Abraham Lincoln an active member of the Republican party. Herndon
believed that he was qualified to fill almost any office, and I
think he was a little dissatisfied that Lincoln did not give him
some high position.
William Butler, belonging to this same period, was one of the
leading citizens and a devoted friend of Lincoln and an excellent
man. Nor can I forget Antram Campbell, one of my first law partners.
We were always warm friends. I saw him on his death-bed when I
returned home from Washington, where I was serving as a Member of
Congress. He recognized me, but could not speak, and I can see
now the tears falling from his eyes.
Of the State officers of that day, Richard Yates was Governor.
The State, under the lead of its War Governor, did not waste time
or spare money in putting the troops in readiness for the field,
and perhaps there was no governor of any State more watchful of
the State's interests, or more devoted to the interests of the
Union, or more loved by the people of his own State, including the
troops in the field, than was Governor Yates. He was loyalty
itself, and for many years was an apostle of liberty. He retired
from the office of governor, to take his place as a senator from
Illinois in the United States Senate. His fame, however, rests on
being the great War Governor of the State of Illinois, the compeer
of Morton, Andrews, and Curtin.
His son, Richard Yates, many years later succeeded to the office
of governor, and is one of the prominent men of Springfield to-day.
O. M. Hatch was Secretary of State. He was among my early influential
friends in Springfield. Uncle Jesse K. Dubois, for whom I had high
regard, and who was quite well known in and out of Illinois, was
one of the State officers. O. H. Miner was Auditor of the State
at one time. He was a very good man. His son, Louis Miner, and
Harry Dorwin, a nephew of my deceased wife, are joint owners of
the Springfield _Journal_, one of the oldest Republican organs of
the State.
Colonel John Williams could not be said to be a National or State
character, but he was a good business man, and one of the best
friends I ever had, so I cannot refrain from a passing tribute to
his memory.
When I was elected to Congress the first time, in 1864, my friends
knew that I had spent a considerable sum of money for election
expenses. It being Lincoln's district, and Lincoln being a candidate
for re-election as President, the National Committee helped some;
but I was naturally compelled to spend a great deal myself. I
considered to whom I should apply for assistance, and thought of
Colonel Williams. I went to him, candidly explaining that I should
be unable to make the race without financial assistance; he told
me to draw on him for whatever funds I might want, and at the end
to let him know the total amount, and that he would take care of
it. I did so. He gave me what I asked for, and I gave him my
note, which I paid as soon as I could; but he never bothered me
about it. I always had a warm spot for him in my heart.
Nicholas H. Ridgely, the grandfather of the Hon. William Barret
Ridgely, who married one of my daughters, and who served as United
States Comptroller of the Currency for a number of years, was one
of the leading bankers of the State, and was reputed to be one of
the first millionaires of Illinois. He was a very careful banker,
and was probably too careful to be popular among the people generally;
but every one knew that there was no sounder institution in the
State than the Ridgely National Bank. His son, Charles Ridgely,
whom I always regarded as one of the most interesting men in
Springfield, has passed away just about the time that I am writing
these lines. Mr. Charles Ridgely was a man of great reading and
great cultivation, and a man whom any one would like to meet. His
death was a loss to Springfield of one of its most interesting and
enterprising characters.
S. H. Jones ("Sam" Jones, as he was known) was another well-known
character in Springfield, as well as throughout Illinois. He was
a warm friend and supporter of mine in the early days.
James C. Robinson was twice elected to Congress. He and Governor
Oglesby were opponents for State Senator from the district. A
little story in this connection occurs to me, which Oglesby used
to tell.
When running for the Senate, before the Civil War, Oglesby and
Robinson travelled together over the district. The settlements in
those days were very scattering, and as the rivals were good friends
personally they agreed to go together and hold joint discussions.
They held one every day, the understanding being that if either
desired to talk anywhere else aside from the joint debate he had
a right to do so.
At one place Robinson announced that he would make a speech in the
courthouse. A large crowd greeted him, which he captured with one
of his characteristic speeches. Oglesby was sitting in front of
the hotel across the way by himself, and listening to the cheering.
He became very uneasy lest Robinson should get the best of it.
Now it chanced that Oglesby could play a violin splendidly. A man
came along with one in his hands, and Oglesby asked if he might
borrow it for the evening, to which the man consented. He commenced
playing in order to attract the crowd from Robinson, and in order
to break up his meeting. He succeeded; one by one they came out
of the courthouse, and when Oglesby swung into a stirring dance
measure the crowd at once responded with an impromptu hoe-down.
Robinson, seeing his audience dwindling, quit speaking and came
out himself. Taking in the situation at a glance, he pulled off
his shoes and became the most enthusiastic participant, dancing
first with one and then with another of his late hearers, winning
them all back again and completely turning the tables against his
adroit opponent.
This is a good illustration of early campaigning in the country
districts of Illinois. There was the utmost good feeling, and a
disposition to let the best man win.
Among the early men and incidents connected with the practice of
the law in Springfield, in the sixties, and before and during the
time I was Speaker of the House, the Rev. Peter Cartwright must
not be forgotten. He was one of the prominent figures in the
pioneer educational and religious life of the Western country, more
particularly of Illinois. He was a wonderful type of the times--
a man of great courage, of considerable ability, and most remarkable
in his capacity as a minister of the Gospel. He believed in camp-
meetings; and when Peter Cartwright conducted a camp-meeting the
loafers and rowdies inclined to interrupt the worship knew they
would invite trouble if they ventured to interfere with or annoy
the meeting. He was ready, not only to preach the Gospel but to
fight, as sometimes he felt it his duty to do. No man dared in
the presence of Cartwright to interrupt the meeting, as in those
times irresponsible parties hanging about such gatherings frequently
attempted to do in his absence.
Cartwright was not only an able pioneer preacher, but he was a
loyal Democrat, too. He believed in Democracy, and was ready to
run on the Democratic ticket, or to advance the party's cause in
any other way. He was nominated for Congress as against Mr. Lincoln,
the only time Lincoln ever ran for Congress.
Some persons disapproved of Cartwright's activity in politics,
questioning the propriety of it on the part of a minister. Among
these was Judge Treat, then our Federal Judge in the Springfield
district. The story goes that the Judge signified to Mr. Lincoln
his dislike of Cartwright, and his willingness to lend a helping
hand in case Lincoln should need help and would let him know the
fact. He thought he could get a good many votes for Lincoln, and
the latter thanked him and told him if he found need of his help
he would let him know. On one occasion during the campaign Lincoln
was walking along one side of the street when he saw Treat on the
farther side, proceeding in the opposite direction, toward his
home. Lincoln called out to him: "Judge, I won't need your help.
I have got the better of the old Methodist preacher, and I will
beat him; so I will not have to call upon you for help." This so
embarrassed the judge, lest some one should hear what was being
said, that he almost ran, in his hurry to get into his house.
It so happened that some of Peter Cartwright's grandchildren were
somewhat reckless boys, and one of them killed another young man.
Mr. Peyton Harrison, the father of the slayer, was a friend of Mr.
Lincoln and also of Judge Logan, and had grown to be a good friend
of mine, I being a young lawyer. The two and I were employed in
the defence of the young man. I did the running about, and other
things necessary to be done until the time arrived for the trial.
I had the accused man in my house part of the intervening time.
When the Circuit Court convened he, having been previously indicted,
was delivered up and the trial came on. It lasted some ten or
twelve days. In the meantime, Peter Cartwright, and his daughter
Mrs. Harrison, the mother of the young man on trial, were at my
house most of the time. They drove into town from where they lived,
some ten or twelve miles out, every day, and remained until nearly
night, going back and forth as long as the trial lasted. Cartwright
became somewhat attached to me on account of my efforts in the
young man's behalf.
The trial resulted in the acquittal of young Harrison, in whose
behalf Mr. Lincoln and Judge Logan exerted themselves very
earnestly.
Springfield seems changed to me since my old friend, David T.
Littler, passed away. If I visited Springfield during the heat of
Summer, when every one else was gone, I was always sure that Dave
Littler would be there to greet me. Littler was a unique character.
His manners and speech were bluff and frank; he never was afraid
of any one, and never was afraid to speak just exactly what he
thought. Senator Littler, Colonel Bluford Wilson, a particularly
devoted friend, and I travelled through Europe together, and we
had a great time.
Littler was for many years a member of the State Senate of Illinois,
and was a very useful member in securing favors for his district;
and there is no district in the State more dependent upon the
Legislature than the Springfield district. He was very ambitious,
and when many of my friends in Illinois believed that President
McKinley would honor me with an appointment to his cabinet, he
thought he was pretty sure to succeed me in the United States
Senate. My secret opinion was that the politicians who were running
State affairs at that time were fooling him; but it never came to
a test, as I did not enter the cabinet.
It is a pleasure to record that I was able to show a substantial
token of friendship when, through my influence, Senator Littler
was appointed by President Cleveland one of the Pacific Railroad
Commissioners.
Speaking of Colonel Littler reminds me of our mutual friend, Mr.
Rheuna Lawrence, an estimable citizen of Springfield in his day.
When I was re-elected to the Senate in the Winter of 1901, Rheuna
Lawrence and David Littler were both desperately ill. I visited
them both before leaving for Washington. Lawrence died soon after,
but Littler recovered and lived for a year or two.
Rheuna Lawrence was intensely interested in my campaign in 1900.
He attended the Peoria convention as one of the Springfield delegates.
There was a contesting delegation from Sangamon County, and my
friends, among whom were Lawrence and Littler, were seated. My
friends won out all along the line, and the excitement was too much
for Rheuna, who was not a drinking man at all; but he and Dave got
in their cups, and it was very amusing to those who knew Mr. Lawrence
as one of the cleanest and most estimable of our citizens to hear
Littler refer to him as "my drunken friend, Rheuna." All of which,
of course, was only a little pleasantry which I repeat for the
benefit of those who attended that convention, and knew Lawrence
and Littler well.
James C. Conkling was a prominent lawyer at home, in the days of
Lincoln. He was a zealous Republican and a stanch supporter of
Lincoln; also a lawyer and a business man; but for some reason or
other, I do not know why, he became involved and failed, and the
people, especially the older citizens, insisted that he be appointed
postmaster. I recommended him, and the appointment was made. He
served a term and passed away. His son, Mr. Clinton Conkling, is
now one of the leading attorneys of the city.
Henry Green was noted as a great lawyer. He came to Illinois from
Canada and studied law in Clinton County with the Hon. Lawrence
Weldon, who was a prominent lawyer himself, and for years served
as a member of the Court of Claims at Washington. Weldon was a
lovable character. Green was for some years the partner of Milton
Hay, the firm being Hay, Green, and Littler; it changed later to
Green and Humphrey. While I always believed that Hay was the best
lawyer in the State, many lawyers believed that Green was the ablest
in connection with railroad litigation.
The Hon. O. H. Browning was one of the most prominent men of Illinois
in the early times, and was about Springfield, the capital, a great
deal, attending the Federal Court, and also the Supreme Court of
the State. Browning, Archibald Williams, and Jack Grimshaw were
all three very excellent lawyers, quite prominent in their profession,
as well as associates in the Whig party. Browning was probably
the most prominent of the three. He was appointed by Governor
Yates to succeed Douglas, after the death of the latter, in the
United States Senate. Of course he did not remain there long,
being succeeded, I think, by William A. Richardson, a strong Democrat
of Quincy, and a man of considerable ability. After he went out
of the Senate, Browning was appointed by Andrew Johnson as Secretary
of the Interior. He became a follower of Mr. Johnson, who had
broken with the Republican party, and when he got out of office,
I think he ceased to take any part in politics. He had been talked
about a good deal at one time as the proper man for the Supreme
bench, but as between him and Logan and Davis, Mr. Lincoln decided
in favor of Davis.
It is impossible to mention all the many friends and supporters
loyal and devoted to me who are now living, but I shall be pardoned,
I am sure, for saying a few words in reference to some of them at
present in Springfield, who are especially esteemed.
I have been away from Springfield most of the time for nearly thirty
years, and as I go back there during the vacations for brief periods,
I feel lonely, because so many of the familiar faces of earlier
days have passed away. As I walk the streets now it seems that I
know comparatively few people; but I have the best of reasons for
knowing that among them are many splendid men.
I like to feel, on the eve of visiting Springfield, that I shall
see my friend, Judge J. Otis Humphrey, United States District Judge
for the Southern District of Illinois. I have all the affection
and interest in Judge Humphrey that one could entertain for a
brother, and I know that he has the same feeling for me. He is an
able man, and is regarded by the Bar as the ablest judge who has
ever occupied the United States District Bench at Springfield. I
have known him from his boyhood, and knew his father before him.
It was one of the great pleasures of my public career to have been
able to secure from the late President McKinley his appointment as
United States Attorney for the Southern District of Illinois, and
later to have secured his promotion to the position of United States
District Judge. He is now the senior United States District Judge
of the seventh circuit, and I regard him as the ablest judge of
them all. I sincerely hope that higher honors, which he so well
deserves in his chosen career, are still in store for him.
In connection with Judge Humphrey I am reminded of the late Judge
Solomon H. Bethea, who was appointed United States Attorney for
the Northern District of Illinois, and who was later promoted to
the Federal Bench. Humphrey and Bethea I have always regarded as
my two judges, as they were both appointed on my recommendation.
Bethea was a man of very strong and positive character. These
traits were so conspicuous that his manners were, by some, regarded
as extremely dictatorial. He was highly educated, a student all
his life, and a very cultivated man. At the same time he was a
first-rate politician. I do not know of two more useful men to
lead a floor fight in a convention than Bethea and Humphrey. Judge
Bethea was my friend and supporter from the time I was elected to
the United States Senate, in 1883, until his death. He made a
splendid record as United States Attorney, and am informed that
during his incumbency of that office, he never lost a case before
a jury. Very unfortunately, just when he reached the goal of his
highest ambition, a Federal judgeship, his health failed. I have
never for a moment doubted that had he lived and retained his health
he would have made an enviable record on the bench.
There is no better man in Springfield than John W. Bunn. He has
been my friend ever since I first went to Springfield. He was a
friend of Lincoln, and there was no one in Springfield in whom
Lincoln placed more confidence. I believe that one of the first
appointments he made, after entering the office of President, was
that of John W. Bunn as Pension Agent at Springfield. He was the
trusted friend of the War Governor, Yates, and performed many
important duties for him during the Civil War. From those early
days down to the present, every one has had confidence in John W.
Bunn and in his integrity and honesty. I am glad to say that he
is still living as one of the foremost citizens of his city.
The Hon. James A. Connelly, who for two terms represented the
district in Congress, was a very influential and popular member of
Congress; and being a good lawyer he was a prominent member of the
Judiciary Committee of the House. He is a forcible speaker, and
has always taken an active part in behalf of the party in campaigns
in the State.
Mr. E. F. Leonard--Frank Leonard, as he was familiarly known among
his friends--was my secretary when I was Governor of Illinois. He
was later president of the Toledo, Peoria and Western Railroad,
stationed at Peoria, and I have always believed him to be one of
the best railroad presidents in the State. He was particularly
noted for his sound common sense and as a scholarly, well posted
man in public affairs. I do not think he ever said or did a foolish
thing in his life. He has retired from business, and lives quietly
and elegantly, being a man of wealth, at the beautiful little
college town of Amherst, Massachusetts, in the vicinity of which
he was born.
One of the oldest men in Springfield is Edward Thayer. He has been
a merchant in that town ever since I first went there, and was
engaged in business some years before that, I believe. His father
was living when I first went to Springfield, and was a very refined,
cultivated, elegant Eastern gentleman. Mr. Thayer, although over
ninety-five, still seems to enjoy the best of health, and attends
his store every day.
The present Governor of Illinois, the Hon. Charles S. Deneen,
although a citizen of Chicago, has lived in Springfield for nearly
six years, during his incumbency of office. Governor Deneen has
had a very successful public career. He has creditably filled
every public office which he has held. I have been interested in
him, not only on his own account, but on account of his father,
whom I knew well and whom I respected highly. Years ago I obtained
his appointment in the consular service, in which he served during
the Harrison administration. Governor Deneen has taken a prominent
part in public affairs in Cook County and has held several responsible
positions there. He made a splendid State's Attorney of Cook
County. His honor and integrity were above suspicion. His record
as State's Attorney paved the way to the higher office of Governor
of Illinois. He is a conservative man, and has given the State a
conservative administration. Unfortunately he has had difficulties
with the Legislature, but on the whole I regard his administration
as a successful and creditable one. Governor Deneen and I are the
only two men in the history of the State who have been honored by
its people by being re-elected to succeed themselves as Governor.
CHAPTER V
NOMINATION OF LINCOLN AND DOUGLAS FOR THE PRESIDENCY
1859 and 1860
Returning to the period preceding the Civil War, we observe that
the whole nation was stirred by the conduct of a man whom most people
believed to be crazy, but who in my judgment was not. He was an
enthusiast, fired by an abnormal zeal, perhaps; but he filled a
most important place in the development leading to the Civil War.
I refer to old John Brown.
With a score of followers he seized the arsenal at Harpers Ferry
in October, 1859. The nation was then on the very verge of civil
war. There was tremendous excitement even in far-off Springfield
when the news came over the wires that John Brown had opened war
almost single-handed and alone. Under orders from General-in-Chief
Winfield Scott, Colonel Robert E. Lee with a battalion of soldiers
marched on Harpers Ferry, and, after a series of siege operations,
summoned John Brown to surrender, the demand being borne to the
besieged by J. E. B. Stuart, a young lieutenant, afterwards
distinguished as the foremost cavalry leader of the Confederacy.
The story of John Brown is too familiar to be repeated here; but
how strange that in so short a time his captor, Robert E. Lee,
should become famous as one of the greatest leaders of force in
rebellion against the government he then served.
John Brown was captured and hanged. He had but few sympathizers
in the North, but his attempt to incite the slaves to rebellion
greatly stirred up the entire South, and hastened secession.
Very soon the second National Republican Convention was held at
Chicago. At this convention, which nominated Lincoln for the
Presidency, the resolutions declared for "the maintenance inviolate
of the right of each State to order and control its own domestic
institutions according to its own judgment exclusively," and
condemned the attempt to enforce the extreme pretensions of a purely
local interest (meaning the slave interest), through the intervention
of Congress and the courts, by the Democratic administration. They
derided the new dogma that the Constitution of its own force carried
slavery into the Territories, and denied the authority of Congress,
or of a Territorial Legislature, or of any individual to give leave
of existence to slavery in any Territory of the United States.
After the failure of the efforts to make of Kansas a Slave State,
it had become plain that the South could not hope to keep its
equality of representation in the Senate without reversing what
appeared to be settled popular opinion concerning the status of
the Northern Territories. Resolutions to this general effect were
moved by Jefferson Davis early in February, 1860, and passed by
the Senate. It was in effect the ultimatum presented to the
Democratic party at its National Convention when it assembled,
April 23, at Charleston, S. C. The warring factions failed to come
to an agreement, and the convention adjourned to meet at Baltimore
on the eighteenth of June. There Douglas was at last nominated.
The delegates who had seceded at Charleston were joined by other
seceders at Baltimore, and nominated John C. Breckinridge of Kentucky
for President. A month later, May 19, a third faction, calling
itself the "Constitutional Union Party," assembled in convention
at the same city, Baltimore, and nominated John Bell of Tennessee
and Edward Everett of Massachusetts, on a platform whose distinguishing
battle-cry was "The Constitution, the Union of the States, and the
enforcement of the laws." Three days before this, May sixteenth,
the Republican Convention had met at Chicago, and had nominated
Lincoln and Hamlin on a platform which rang true on great principles
and with high resolve.
In many particulars this platform was a contrast to, rather than
a growth from, that of 1856. It asserted that the normal condition
of all the territory of the United States was that of freedom; it
denounced the outrages in Kansas, and demanded her immediate
admission into the Union, with her Constitution, as a Free State;
it branded the re-opening of the African slave-trade as a crime;
and in expressing the abhorrence of the Republican party to all
schemes of disunion, the Democratic party was arraigned for its
silence in the presence of threats of secession made by its own
members. The doctrine of encouragement to domestic industry was
announced; the sale of the public lands was condemned; the coming
measure of securing homesteads for the landless was approved; and
a pledge of protection was given to all citizens, whether native
or naturalized, and whether at home or abroad. The party was again
pledged to the construction of a railway to the Pacific Ocean, and
to the improvement of the rivers and harbors of the country.
During the four years preceding, the home State of Lincoln and
Douglas had decreased its public debt $3,104,374. She had become
the fourth State of the Union in population and wealth, having
during the decade then closing outstripped Virginia, Massachusetts,
North Carolina, Georgia, Tennessee, and Indiana. In production of
wheat and corn she now surpassed all other States and occupied the
foremost position. She had in successful operation two thousand,
nine hundred miles of railways, being surpassed in this respect by
Ohio only. Chicago, her marvellous lake mart, had grown from a
population of 29,963 to 109,206, an increase of nearly three
hundred per cent. From nine Congressmen in 1850, she was entitled
in 1860 to thirteen; and so, on every hand, might the recital of
her growth be continued indefinitely.
For the first time in twenty years, during the progress of a
political campaign in Illinois, the voice of Lincoln was not heard.
But the record of his former speeches, printed by an enterprising
Ohio publishing firm, in a volume which sold in enormous numbers,
afforded the text from which the Republican stump-orators in every
Free State gathered at once their logic and their inspiration.
Though the orator himself remained silent, the potent echo of his
eloquence resounded in countless voices from the Atlantic to the
Pacific.
The political contest that followed the various nominations was a
memorable one. Douglas made his last effort for the Presidency
with wonderful vigor and spirit. He canvassed the whole country,
and great throngs were greatly moved by his eloquent and energetic
oratory. Jefferson Davis and other Southern orators canvassed
portions of the Northern States in support of the nominee of the
Southern wing of the Democratic party. In some parts of the North
fusions were attempted among the opponents of the Republican
candidate. In the South the interest in the contest was even more
intense than in the North. Douglas had a good following in many
portions of the South, but a majority of the ruling class there,
whether they had formerly been Democrats or Whigs, were now disposed
to bring the long sectional controversy to an issue. Therefore,
besides the debate over the Presidential issue, there was a serious
discussion also of what course the South should take in the event
of Mr. Lincoln's election. In all the Cotton States the sentiment
for secession was now very strong. The Alabama Legislature, early
in 1860, had instructed her Governor to call a convention in case
a "Black Republican" should be elected President in November.
South Carolina had long been ready to join in such a movement, or
to lead in it.
At last, election day came, and the results, immediate as well as
ulterior, are deserving of some remark. The aggregate popular vote
exceeded four million, six hundred and eighty thousand; and of the
total, one million, eight hundred and sixty-six thousand votes were
given for Mr. Lincoln; and of the three hundred and three electoral
votes, he received one hundred and eighty. Mr. Breckinridge, the
candidate of the South, received eight hundred and forty-seven
thousand votes, and seventy-two votes in the Electoral College;
while Mr. Douglas received only twelve electoral votes, although
his popular vote reached a million, three hundred and seventy-five
thousand. Bell received thirty-nine electoral votes on a popular
vote of less than six hundred thousand. Thus the popular vote for
Mr. Lincoln was nearly a half-million less than a majority; but
his predecessor, Mr. Buchanan, was also a minority President, so
that this fact as a pretext for secession was wholly without point.
Eleven States voted for Mr. Breckinridge, including Delaware and
Maryland; and eleven States became members of the Confederacy,
including Virginia and Tennessee, which had voted for Mr. Bell.
It all went to show that the Democratic party as represented by
Breckinridge was in fact a secession party first of all. The
division of the Democratic party decided the election in favor of
Mr. Lincoln.
Had that party supported Mr. Douglas in good faith, his election
would probably have been secured; but the South would have been
left without excuse had it persisted in the scheme of secession.
Therefore it came to pass that the Democratic party was disorganized
by its own leaders of the South as a step preliminary to the election
of Mr. Lincoln, and the making of that election a pretext for
disunion. This part of the conspiracy was managed with consummate
skill and eminent success; but the conspirators were perfectly well
aware that ultimate success depended largely on prompt, effective,
and decisive steps which must be taken while their efficient friend
in the Executive Mansion still remained in office.
This allowed them four months of precious time between the election
of Mr. Lincoln and his inauguration as President. The vigilance
and effectiveness of their work is an interesting and familiar
story, but I shall not attempt here a narration of it. This work
eventuated in war, and with the opening of war, Mr. Douglas was
quickly found in the attitude of a leader in the cause of the Union
--the closing and the noblest episode of his whole remarkable
career.
I knew Senator Douglas quite well. Of course, he was considerably
older than I, and was one of the great men of the Nation, when I
was just starting in public life. I knew him before the Civil War.
He was a wonderful man with the people. I do not think there was
ever a man in public life who was more thoroughly loved by the
party to which he belonged than Senator Douglas. His adherents
were devoted to him at all times and under all circumstances. When
he came through the State, the whole Democratic party was alive
and ready to rally to his support. I heard him deliver addresses
on two occasions before the War. I heard one of the Lincoln-Douglas
debates at Ottawa. I heard Lincoln deliver the famous Springfield
address, in which he uttered the immortal sentiment, "A house
divided against itself cannot stand." To this address Douglas
afterwards replied. When Lincoln was inaugurated, Douglas was
present on the platform and held Lincoln's hat while he delivered
his inaugural address; the tremendous significance of which trivial
act can be appreciated only in the light of later years.
But Douglas did not hesitate for a moment after Fort Sumter was
fired upon, April 12, 1861. He voluntarily called upon President
Lincoln and tendered his support to the cause of the Union, and
immediately gave out to the Associated Press a statement, calling
upon the people of the North, regardless of party, to rally to its
defence.
I believe it was Mr. Lincoln who asked him to visit Illinois, where,
especially in the southern part of the State, there was considerable
disunion sentiment. There was a great effort to induce the region
where the Democracy predominated, the people being loyal followers
of Douglas, to go with the South instead of the North. Douglas
alone could save it. He came to Illinois, as he told me, partly on
that account; to rally the State to the support of the Union,
earnestly desiring that the country should understand where he
stood.
He visited Springfield while the Legislature was in session.
Senator Douglas was invited to address a joint session of that
body, which he did on the evening of April 25, 1861. Being Speaker
of the House, I presided. In addition to the members of the
Legislature, there was a great crowd present.
I have a vivid recollection of the evening. Prior to that time I
had not believed in Senator Douglas; which was only natural, I
having been a Whig and an enthusiastic adherent of Lincoln. The
duty of introducing Senator Douglas to the joint Assembly devolved
upon myself; I cannot at this late day recall the words I used,
but I am sure that I presented him in as complimentary a manner as
my prejudices allowed.
As he continued speaking, however, I, as thousands--nay, millions
--of others had done, succumbed to the magic of his eloquence and
the irresistible logic of his brilliant mind; and I must here
confess that never before or since have I heard a more masterful,
a more inspired, plea for the integrity of the Union and the
indivisibility of the Nation than Senator Douglas delivered upon
that occasion.
It seemed to me, as he hurled the thunders of his eloquence broadcast,
that the very rafters rang in harmony, that the air vibrated in
accord with his denunciations of rebellion.
The address was not a long one. As it was printed by order of the
General Assembly, I shall take the liberty of presenting it in full:
"Mr. Speaker, and Gentlemen of the Senate and House of Representatives:
I am not insensible to the patriotic motives which have prompted
you to do me the honor to invite me to address you on the momentous
issues now presented in the condition of our country. With a heart
filled with sadness and grief, I proceed to comply with your
request.
"For the first time since the adoption of the Federal Constitution,
a widespread conspiracy exists to destroy the best government the
sun of heaven ever shed its rays upon. Hostile armies are now
marching upon the Federal Capitol, with a view of planting a
revolutionary flag upon its dome; seizing the National archives;
taking captive the President elected by the votes of the people,
and holding him in the hands of secessionists and disunionists.
A war of aggression and of extermination is being waged against
the Government established by our fathers. The boast has gone
forth by the authorities of this revolutionary Government that on
the first day of May the revolutionary flag shall float from the
walls of the Capitol at Washington, and that on the fourth day of
July the Rebel army shall hold possession of the Hall of Independence
in Philadelphia.
"The simple question presented to us is, whether we will wait for
the enemy to carry out his boast of making war upon our soil; or
whether we will rush as one man to the defence of the Government
and its capital, and defend it from the hands of all assailants
who have threatened to destroy it. Already the piratical flag has
been unfurled against the commerce of the United States. Letters
of marque have been issued, appealing to the pirates of the world
to assemble under that revolutionary flag and commit depredations
on the commerce carried on under the Stars and Stripes. The
navigation of our great river into the Gulf of Mexico is obstructed.
Hostile batteries have been planted upon its banks; custom houses
have already been established; and we are now required to pay
tribute and taxes, without having a voice in making the laws imposing
them, or having a share in the proceeds after they have been
collected. The question is, whether this war of aggression shall
proceed, and we remain with folded arms, inattentive spectators;
or whether we shall meet the aggressors at the threshold and turn
back the tide of revolution and usurpation.
"So long as there was a hope of peaceful solution, I prayed and
implored for compromise. I can appeal to my countrymen with
confidence that I have spared no effort, omitted no opportunity,
to secure a peaceful solution of all these troubles, and thus
restore peace, happiness, and fraternity to the country. When all
propositions of peace fail, and a war of aggression is proclaimed,
there is but one course left for the patriot, and that is to rally
under that flag which has waved over the capitol from the days of
Washington, and around the Government established by Washington,
Madison, Hamilton, and their compeers.
"What is the alleged cause for this invasion of the rights and
authority of the Government of the United States? The cause alleged
is that the institutions of the Southern States are not safe under
the Federal Government. What evidence has been presented that they
are insecure? I appeal to every man within the sound of my voice
to tell me at what period from the time that Washington was
inaugurated down to this hour, have the rights of the Southern
States--the rights of the slave-holders--been more secure than they
are at this moment? When in the whole history of this Government
have they stood on so firm a basis? For the first time in the
history of this republic, there is no restriction by act of Congress
upon the institution of slavery, anywhere within the limits of the
United States. Then it cannot be the Territorial question that
has given them cause for rebellion. When was the Fugitive Slave
Law executed with more fidelity than since the inauguration of the
present incumbent of the Presidential office? Let the people of
Chicago speak and tell us when were the laws of the land executed
with as much firmness and fidelity, so far as the fugitive slaves
are concerned, as they are now. Can any man tell me of any one
act of aggression that has been committed or attempted since the
last Presidential election, that justifies this violent disruption
of the Federal Union?
"I ask you to reflect, and then point out any one act that has been
done--any one duty that has been omitted to be done--of which any
one of these disunionists can justly complain. Yet we are told,
simply because a certain political party has succeed in a Presidential
election, they choose to consider that their liberties are not
safe, and therefore they are justified in breaking up the
Government.
"I had supposed that it was a cardinal and fundamental principle
of our system of government that the decision of the people at the
ballot box, without fraud, according to the forms of the Constitution,
was to command the implicit obedience of every good citizen. If
defeat at a Presidential election is to justify the minority, or
any portion of the minority, in raising the traitorous hand of
rebellion against the constituted authorities, you will find the
future history of the United States written in the history of
Mexico. According to my reading of Mexican history, there has
never been one presidential term, from the time of the Revolution
of 1820 down to this day, when the candidate elected by the people
ever served his four years. In every instance, either the defeated
candidate has seized upon the Presidential chair by use of the
bayonet, or he has turned out the duly elected President before
his term expired. Are we to inaugurate this Mexican system in the
United States of America? Suppose the case to be reversed. Suppose
the disunion candidate had been elected by any means--I care not
what, if by any means in accordance with the forms of the Constitution
--at the last Presidential election; then, suppose the Republicans
had raised a rebellion against his authority--in that case you would have
found me tendering my best efforts and energies to John C. Breckinridge
to put down the Republican rebels. And if you had attempted such
a rebellion I would have justified him in calling forth all the
power and energies of this country to have crushed you out.
"The first duty of an American citizen, or of a citizen of any
constitutional Government, is obedience to the Constitution and
laws of his country. I have no apprehension that any man in
Illinois, or beyond the limits of our own beloved State, will
misconstrue or misunderstand my motive. So far as any of the
partisan questions are concerned, I stand in equal, irreconcilable,
and undying opposition both to the Republicans and the secessionists.
You all know that I am a very good partisan fighter in partisan
times, and I trust you will find me equally as good a patriot when
the country is in danger.
"Now permit me to say to the assembled Representatives and Senators
of our beloved States, composed of men of both political parties,
in my opinion it is your duty to lay aside, for the time being,
your party creeds and party platforms; to dispense with your party
organizations and partisan appeals; to forget that you were ever
divided, until you have rescued the Government and the country from
their assailants. When this paramount duty shall have been performed,
it will be proper for each of us to resume our respective political
positions according to our convictions of public duty. Give me a
country first, that my children may live in peace; then we will
have a theatre for our party organizations to operate upon.
"Are we to be called upon to fold our arms, allow the national
capital to be seized by a military force under a foreign revolutionary
flag; to see the archives of the Government in the hands of a people
who affect to despise the flag and Government of the United States?
I am not willing to be expelled by military force, nor to fly from
the Federal capitol. It has been my daily avocation six months in
the year, for eighteen years, to walk into that marble building,
and from its portico to survey a prosperous, happy, and united
country on both sides of the Potomac. I believe I may with confidence
appeal to the people of every section of the country to bear
testimony that I have been as thoroughly national in my political
opinions and actions as any man that has lived in my day. And I
believe if I should make an appeal to the people of the State of
Illinois, or of the Northern States, for their impartial verdict,
they would say that whatever errors I have committed have been in
leaning too far to the Southern section of the Union against my
own. I think I can appeal to friend and foe--I use the term in a
political sense, and I trust I use the word _foe_ in a past sense
--I can appeal to them with confidence, that I have never pandered
to the prejudice or passion of my section against the minority
section of this Union; and I will say to you now, with all frankness
and in all sincerity, that I will never sanction nor acquiesce in
any warfare whatever upon the constitutional rights or domestic
institutions of the people of the Southern States. On the contrary,
if there was an attempt to invade these rights--to stir up servile
insurrection among their people--I would rush to their rescue, and
interpose with whatever of strength I might possess to defend them
from such a calamity. While I will never invade them--while I will
never fail to defend and protect their rights to the full extent
that a fair and liberal construction of the Constitution can give
them--they must distinctly understand that I will never acquiesce
in their invasion of our constitutional rights.
"It is a crime against the inalienable and indefeasible rights of
every American citizen to attempt to destroy the Government under
which we were born. It is a crime against constitutional freedom
and the hopes of the friends of freedom throughout the wide world
to attempt to blot out the United States from the map of Christendom.
Yet this attempt is now being made. The Government of our fathers
is to be overthrown and destroyed. The capital that bears the name
of the Father of his Country is to be bombarded and levelled with
the earth among the rubbish and the dust of things that are past.
The records of your Government are to be scattered to the four
winds of heaven. The constituted authorities, placed there by the
same high authority that placed Washington and Jefferson and Madison
and Jackson in the chair, are to be captured and carried off, to
become a byword and a scorn to the nations of the world.
"You may think that I am drawing a picture that is overwrought.
No man who has spent the last week in the city of Washington will
believe that I have done justice to it. You have all the elements
of the French Revolution surrounding the capital now, and threatening
it with its terrors. Not only is our constitutional Government to
be stricken down; not only is our flag to be blotted out; but the
very foundations of social order are to be undermined and destroyed;
the demon of destruction is to be let loose over the face of the
land, a reign of terror and mob law is to prevail in each section
of the Union, and the man who dares to plead for the cause of
justice and moderation in either section is to be marked down as
a traitor to his section. If this state of things is allowed to
go on, how long before you will have the guillotine in active
operation?
"I appeal to you, my countrymen--men of all parties--not to allow
your passions to get the better of your judgment. Do not allow
your vengeance upon the authors of this great iniquity to lead you
into rash, and cruel, and desperate acts upon loyal citizens who
may differ with you in opinion. Let the spirit of moderation and
of justice prevail. You cannot expect, within so few weeks after
an excited political canvass, that every man can rise to the high
and patriotic level of forgetting his partisan prejudices and
sacrifice everything upon the altar of his country; but allow me
to say to you, whom I have opposed and warred against with an energy
you will respect--allow me to say to you, you will not be true to
your country if you ever attempt to manufacture partisan capital
out of the misfortunes of your country. When calling upon Democrats
to rally to the tented field, leaving wife, child, father, and
mother behind them to rush to the rescue of the President that you
elected, do not make war upon them and try to manufacture partisan
capital at their expense out of a struggle in which they are engaged
from the holiest and purest of motives.
"Then I appeal to you, my own Democratic friends--those men that
have never failed to rally under the glorious banner of the country
whenever an enemy at home or abroad has dared to assail it--to you
with whom it has always been my pride to act--do not allow the
mortification, growing out of a defeat in a partisan struggle, and
the elevation of a party to power that we firmly believe to be
dangerous to the country--do not let that convert you from patriots
into traitors to your native land. Whenever our Government is
assailed, when hostile armies are marching under new and odious
banners against the Government of our country, the shortest way to
peace is the most stupendous and unanimous preparations for war.
The greater unanimity, the less blood will be shed. The more prompt
and energetic the movement, and the more imposing in numbers, the
shorter will be the struggle.
"Every friend of freedom--every champion and advocate of constitutional
liberty throughout the land--must feel that this cause is his own.
There is and should be nothing disagreeable or humiliating to men
who have differed in times of peace on every question that could
divide fellow men, to rally in concert in defence of the country
and against all assailants. While all the States of this Union,
and every citizen of every State has a priceless legacy dependent
upon the success of our efforts to maintain this Government, we in
the great valley of the Mississippi have peculiar interests and
inducements to the struggle. What is the attempt now being made?
Seven States of the Union chose to declare that they will no longer
obey the Constitution of the United States; that they will withdraw
from the Government established by our fathers; that they will
dissolve without our consent the bonds that have united us together.
But, not content with that, they proceed to invade and obstruct
our dearest and most inalienable rights, secured by the Constitution.
One of their first acts is to establish a battery of cannon upon
the banks of the Mississippi, on the dividing line between the
States of Mississippi and Tennessee, and require every steamer that
passes down the river to come to under their guns to receive a
custom-house officer on board, to prescribe where the boat may land
and upon what terms it may put out a barrel of flour or a cask of
bacon.
"We are called upon to sanction this policy. Before consenting to
their right to commit such acts, I implore you to consider that
the same principle which will allow the cotton States to exclude
us from the ports of the gulf, would authorize the New England
States and New York and Pennsylvania to exclude us from the Atlantic,
and the Pacific States to exclude us from the ports of that ocean.
Whenever you sanction this doctrine of secession, you authorize
the States bordering upon the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans to withdraw
from us, form alliance among themselves, and exclude us from the
markets of the world and from communication with all the rest of
Christendom. Not only this, but there follows a tariff on imports,
levying taxes upon every pound of tea and coffee and sugar and
every yard of cloth that we may import for our consumption; the
levying too of an export duty upon every bushel of corn and every
pound of meat we may choose to send to the markets of the world to
pay for our imports.
"Bear in mind that these very cotton States, who in former times
have been so boisterous in their demands for free trade, have,
among their first acts, established an export duty on cotton for
the first time in American history.
"It is an historical fact, well known to every man who has read
the debates of the convention which framed the Constitution, that
the Southern States refused to become parties to the Constitution
unless there was an express provision in the Constitution prohibiting
Congress to levy an export duty on any product of the country. No
sooner have these cotton States seceded than an export duty is
levied, and if they will levy it on their own cotton do you not
think they will levy it on our pork and our beef and our corn and
our wheat and our manufactured articles, and all we have to sell?
Then what is the proposition? It is to enable the tier of States
bordering on the Atlantic and the Pacific and on the Gulf, surrounding
us on all sides, to withdraw from our Union, form alliances among
themselves, and then levy taxes on us without our consent, and
collect revenues without giving us any just proportion or any
portion of the amount collected. Can we submit to taxation without
representation? Can we permit nations foreign to us to collect
revenues off our products, the fruits of our industry? I ask the
citizens of Illinois--I ask every citizen in the great basin between
the Rocky Mountains and the Alleghenies, in the valley of the Ohio,
Mississippi, and Missouri to tell me whether he is willing to
sanction a line of policy that may isolate us from the markets of
the world and make us dependent provinces upon powers that thus
choose to surround and hem us in?
"I warn you, my countrymen, whenever you permit this to be done in
the Southern States, New York will very soon follow their example.
New York--that great port where two-thirds of all our revenue is
collected, and whence two-thirds of our products are exported, will
not long be able to resist the temptation of taxing fifteen millions
of people in the great West, when she can monopolize the resources
and release her own people thereby from any taxation whatsoever.
Hence I say to you, my countrymen, from the best consideration I
have been able to give to this subject, after the most mature
reflection and thorough investigation, I have arrived at the
conclusion that, come what may,--war if it must be, although I
deplore it as a great calamity,--yet, come what may, the people of
the Mississippi Valley can never consent to be excluded from free
access to the ports of the Atlantic, the Pacific, and the Gulf of
Mexico.
"Hence, I repeat, that while I am not prepared to take up arms or
to sanction war upon the rights of the Southern States, upon their
domestic institutions, upon their rights of person or property,
but, on the contrary, would rush to their defence and protect them
from assault, I will never cease to urge my countrymen to take up
arms and to fight to the death in defence of our indefeasible
rights.
"Hence, if a war does come, it will be a war of self-defence on
our part. It will be a war in defence of our own just rights; in
defence of the Government which we have inherited as a priceless
legacy from our patriotic fathers; in defence of those great rights
of the freedom of trade, commerce, transit, and intercourse from
the centre to the circumference of our great continent. These are
rights we can never surrender.
"I have struggled almost against hope to avert the calamities of
war and to effect a reunion and reconciliation with our brethren
of the South. I yet hope it may be done, but I am not able to
point out to you how it may be effected. Nothing short of Providence
can reveal to us the issue of this great struggle. Bloody--calamitous
--I fear it will be. May we so conduct it if a collision must
come, that we will stand justified in the eyes of Him who knows
our hearts and who will judge our every act. We must not yield to
resentments, nor to the spirit of vengeance, much less to the desire
for conquest or ambition.
"I see no path of ambition open in a bloody struggle for triumph
over my own countrymen. There is no path for ambition open for me
in a divided country, after having so long served a united and
glorious country. Hence, whatever we may do must be the result of
conviction, of patriotic duty--the duty that we owe to ourselves,
to our posterity, and to the friends of constitutional liberty and
self-government throughout the world.
"My friends, I can say no more. To discuss these topics is the
most painful duty of my life. It is with a sad heart--with a grief
that I have never before experienced, that I have to contemplate
this fearful struggle; but I believe in my conscience that it is
a duty we owe ourselves and our children and our God, to protect
this Government and that flag from every assailant, be he who he
may."
Of all the members of that joint assembly who listened to the
eloquence of Senator Douglas that evening, forty-nine years ago,
aside from Dr. William Jayne of Springfield, and myself, I do not
know of a single one now living.
After he concluded his address, the joint session of the Legislature
dissolved. He and I remained together in conversation, and I
accompanied him to his hotel. During that talk he expressed to me
the great anxiety which he felt for the safety of the country and
the preservation of the Union. I am satisfied that it was his
ambition to enter the army and possibly lead it in suppressing the
Rebellion. What would have been the result in that case, no one
can tell; but I am inclined to think that he would have made a very
great general.
Senator Douglas's Springfield speech had a tremendous effect on
public opinion. It brought his followers, and they were legion in
all parts of the country, to the support of the Government and the
North.
Senator Douglas went from Springfield to Chicago, where he delivered
another eloquent address, along the same lines as the one delivered
at Springfield, to tens of thousands of people. Very soon thereafter
he was taken ill with pneumonia and passed away.
He was a man of extraordinary intellect. He did his full part, at
one of the most critical periods of our history, in saving the
Nation. His speeches in and out of Congress are among the most
able and eloquent delivered by any American statesman.
CHAPTER VI
SPEAKER OF THE ILLINOIS LEGISLATURE AND A MEMBER OF CONGRESS
1860 to 1865
The election of Mr. Lincoln was made the pretext for secession.
It has always seemed to me that the South was determined to secede
no matter at what cost; and it has also seemed to me that this
determination was not due to the great body of the people of the
South, than whom there were no better, but to the jealous politicians
of that section, who saw the gradual growth in wealth and power of
the Northern States threaten their domination of the National
Government, which they had firmly held since the days of Washington.
They saw that domination slipping away, and they determined to form
a nation of their own--in which slavery, indeed, would be paramount;
but it was not so much slavery as it was their own desire for
control that influenced them.
As soon, therefore, as Mr. Lincoln was elected President they began
the organization of a Government of their own. President Buchanan
declared in his message that the Southern States had no right to
secede--"unless they wanted to," as some one aptly expressed it;
in other words, that he had no right under the Constitution to keep
them forcibly in the Union, and thus the constitutional opinions
of the President harmonized effectively with the purposes of the
secessionists. Fortunate it was that Mr. Buchanan had so short a
term remaining after the election of Mr. Lincoln. Had a year or
two elapsed, the Confederacy would have been firmly and irrevocably
established.
It has never been quite clear to my mind whether Mr. Buchanan cared
to preserve the Union or not. In the heat and passion of that day,
we all thought he was a traitor. As I look back now and think of
it, remembering his long and distinguished service to the country
in almost every capacity--as a legislator, as a diplomat, as
Secretary of State, as President, I think now he was only weak.
His term was about expiring, and he saw and feared the awful
consequences of a civil war.
One State after another seceded; the United States' arms and arsenals
were seized; on January 9, the _Star of the West_, carrying supplies
to Fort Sumter, was fired upon and driven off. South Carolina,
Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas went
out. The Confederate States of America were organized in the capital
of Alabama on the fourth of February, and Jefferson Davis was
elected President.
We watched with great interest the famous Peace Conference which
met in Washington and over which John Tyler, ex-President of the
United States, presided. It sat during the month of February,
preceding Mr. Lincoln's inauguration, and recommended the adoption
of seven additional articles to the Constitution, which were
afterwards rejected by the Senate of the United States.
But the fourth of March finally came, and new life was infused into
the national councils.
Mr. Lincoln's speeches on his way East were a disappointment, in
that they failed in the least to abate the rising Southern storm;
the calmly firm tone of his inaugural address impressed the North,
but his appeals to the South were in vain. Said he:
"I declare that I have no purpose, directly or indirectly, to
interfere with the institution of slavery in the States where it
exists. . . . The Union of these States is perpetual. It is safe
to assert that no Government proper ever had a provision in its
organic law for its own termination. The power confided to me will
be used to hold, occupy, and possess the property and places
belonging to the Government and to collect the duties and imposts."
It was a notable appeal that he made, in closing, to the
Southerners:
"In your hands, my dissatisfied fellow countrymen, and not in mine,
is the momentous issue of civil war. The Government will not assail
you. You can have no conflict without being yourselves the
aggressors. You have no oath registered in heaven to destroy the
Government, while I shall have the most solemn one to 'preserve,
protect, and defend it.'
"I am loath to close. We are not enemies, but friends. We must
not be enemies. Though passion may have strained it must not break
our bonds of affection. The mystic chords of memory, stretching
from every battlefield and patriot grave to every living heart and
hearthstone all over this broad land, will yet swell the chorus of
the union, when again touched, as surely they will be, by the better
angels of our nature."
At the same time that Mr. Lincoln was first elected President of
the United States, I was for the second time elected to the
Legislature of Illinois. I received the vote of what they called
the Republicans, or Free-soil men, and of those who were previously
known as Fillmore men. I was always in thorough accord with Mr.
Lincoln in political sentiment, though I had supported Fillmore
rather than Fremont in 1856. I most heartily supported Lincoln's
candidacy, and as candidate for the Legislature received more votes
than Mr. Lincoln received in Sangamon County. Douglas carried the
county as against Lincoln, and I carried it as against my opponent.
There was great enthusiasm for Mr. Lincoln in the county, but he
was so positive and outspoken in his convictions on the slavery
question that he failed to get a considerable number of votes; many
went to other Republicans who did not express their views so
vigorously as he did. Of course, what he lost at home because of
zeal and earnestness in his cause, was more than made up to him on
the wider field covered by his candidacy.
Stephen A. Hurlbut was a member of that Legislature, and afterward
became a prominent general in the army. I might say that General
Hurlbut and Lawrence Church were two very strong men, both from
the northern part of the State, and both became prominent in the
public service. I might say also that but for these two men, who
put me forward as a candidate for the Speakership, I probably would
not have become a candidate. On the Saturday night before the
Monday on which the Legislature was to convene, they pressed me so
strongly that I consented, and became the nominee of my party
associates. J. W. Singleton was the Democratic nominee. Before
the Legislature convened, and during the intervening Sunday, a
feeling got abroad among the older members of the Legislature that
I was too young to be trusted in such a responsible position as
that of Speaker. When I came down-town on Sunday I found that
feeling prevailing.
I at once took notice of it, and stated that if there was any
feeling that I had done wrong in becoming a candidate, I would
submit the question to another test of the sense of the Republicans
in the Legislature, and if they thought I ought not to have the
position I would cheerfully yield to their judgment. The caucus
was called together Monday morning, and I stated that I had heard
that there was some dissatisfaction, and I desired to have another
vote. A vote was accordingly taken, and I was again nominated,
and by a larger vote then in the first instance; whereupon the older
men gave in, and I was duly elected, receiving thirty-nine votes
to twenty-nine cast for the Democratic candidate.
I think I made more friends, in the conduct of the office of Speaker
during that term, than I ever did afterwards; and in subsequent
campaigns I was frequently gratified to find men, some of them
Democrats, who had been in the Legislature with me at that time,
working for me with a stronger zeal and earnestness because of the
associations and intimate relations there formed and cemented.
All classes, Republicans and Democrats alike, took occasion to
manifest their satisfaction, and some who became my friends then
continued so as long as they lived. I think, of all that Legislature,
I am the only one left.
A little incident occurred at a reception given by Mr. Lincoln
after he was elected President, but before he left his home to come
to Washington, that vitally affected my life. In speaking to the
President, I expressed a desire to visit Washington while he was
President of the United States. He replied heartily: "Mr. Speaker,
come on." And that was about the origin of my thinking seriously
that I would like to come to Washington as a member of Congress.
The more I thought of the idea, the more interested I became, and
I so shaped matters during that session of the Legislature as to
secure a district in which some Republican could hope to be elected.
In the apportionment under the census of 1860, I had our Congressional
district elongated to the north and south rather than to the east
and west, and let it be known that I would be a candidate.
But when the time came for a nomination the Hon. Leonard Swett,
who was then a prominent lawyer and politician, also took the field
to secure the Republican nomination. He visited Springfield, and
persuaded some of his friends there that he ought to be the nominee,
and they determined to try their hands toward securing my withdrawal,
if possible by persuasion. They sent for me to come to the library,
where they were proposing to hold a meeting. I went over, and
found that their project was to get me to withdraw in favor of
Swett, and I declined. But I said I would "draw straws," or assent
to any other fair means that could be found by which it was to be
settled who was to be the nominee of the party. Then, after some
further parleying, I finally left the conference.
That evening after dusk I met Swett on the street. We sat down
upon the curbstone, as it was growing a little dark, and talked
the matter over. Swett said to me that he was an older man than
I was; that he had been knocked about a good deal, and, though he
had done much work for the party, he had never got anything; and
if the present opportunity for reward for services were allowed to
pass him by another opportunity was not likely, at his age, to come
to him. Finally, I said: "Mr. Swett, if you had come to me and
made this suggestion at first, I would have been very glad indeed
to make the concession to you, and I am ready to do so now. Here
is my hand on it, and I will help you at the convention." He became
the party candidate by general consent, as I remember it. At all
events he was the candidate, and unfortunately he was beaten at
the polls. That was in 1862. So that while the Congressional
district was made by me, and for myself, I gave way to Mr. Swett,
and the opposition carried it. Two years afterwards I was the
candidate and was elected.
The majority in the counties composing the district was ordinarily
Republican. As a result of Mr. Swett's defeat, he left the district,
though a very prominent lawyer, and went to Chicago, never to return
to the Congressional district in which he had lived so many years,
really quitting politics entirely.
I suppose I ought to state the fact that, having made the district
for myself and then given it up to Mr. Swett, I determined to be
a candidate at the next election; whereupon I found that Mr. James
C. Conkling, a friend of mine, and a special friend of Mr. Lincoln
also, some of whose family are still living, was disposed to try
for the same office. I made up my mind that in order to keep myself
in trim for the future it was well to keep in touch with the voters;
and I determined to run for the State Senate, though the four
counties composing the Senatorial district were all Democratic and
all in the Congressional district in which Swett was the defeated
candidate, yet I desired to run for the Senate, in order to keep
Conkling from getting such a hold on the district as to strengthen
him for the contest two years afterwards.
So I made the run, and was beaten, of course, every county in the
district being Democratic; and the rest of my plans also worked
out as I had calculated they would.
Soon after I was elected to Congress, and soon after Mr. Lincoln
was elected the second time, I came on to Washington. Having been
intimate with Mr. Nicolay and Mr. Hay who were his secretaries, I
was in the habit of frequenting their rooms without ceremony. One
evening, just after dusk, I went to the White House and quietly,
as usual, entered Mr. Nicolay's room. It so happened that Mr.
Lincoln and Mr. Seward, with some other cabinet officers, were in
the room, holding a consultation. I had opened the door before I
observed who were there. President Lincoln saw me quite as soon
as I saw him, and I was very much embarrassed. He sang out cheerily,
"Come in!" and turning to his Secretary of State, he added, "Seward,
you remember my old friend Stuart? Here is the boy that beat him."
I stayed for only a moment, and then went out. That is the nearest
I ever came to participating in a cabinet meeting.
That incident in my life, as I now look back, punctuates, in my
individual way of thinking at this moment, the substantial close
of what was mortal in that great man's earthly career. The close
of the four years of civil war was clearly in sight. It was in
many respects a record-making and a record-breaking war. The navies
of the world, rendered helpless by the incidental effects of its
thundering guns, had to be rebuilt. For the first time in the
world's history the railroad and the electric telegraph played a
very considerable part. The grip of insatiate despotism on Democratic
institutions was effectually loosened far and wide. For the first
time in war the lessons taught in the art of warfare by Alexander
and Caesar were utterly ignored, and the "Maxims of Napoleon" were
relegated to the shelf, there to gather dust. In short, in
inaugurated a new era in the history not only of our own country
but of the entire world.
CHAPTER VII
LINCOLN
1860 to 1864
As days and years pass by and an enlightened humanity studies and
comprehends the real greatness and simplicity of Abraham Lincoln,
he comes nearer and becomes dearer to all. No weak compliment of
words can add to his renown, nor will any petty criticism detract
from the glory which has crowned his memory. The passing of time
has only added brightness to his character; the antagonisms of
bitter war have left no shade upon his name; and the hatred which,
for a brief time, spent itself in harmless words has turned to
reverence and love.
Had he lived until February 12, 1911, he would have been one hundred
and two years old. Less than forty-five years ago, in the very
prime of life, he was the Chief Magistrate of the Nation, guiding
and controlling it in its great struggle for national existence.
Such a vast accumulation of history has been compressed into those
years, and such a wonderful panorama of events has passed before
us in that comparatively brief time, that we are apt to think of
Lincoln as of the long ago, as almost a contemporary of Washington
and of the Revolutionary fathers. The immensity of the history
which has been crowded into those forty-five years has distorted
our mental vision, as ordinary objects are sometimes distorted by
refraction. Yet when we reflect, the distortion disappears. But
the wonder still remains. The years during which the deeds of
Lincoln have been a memory to us do not carry us back to the early
days of our own country. They do not carry us back even to the
time of Jackson, Webster, Clay, or Calhoun; yet the sacred halo of
patriotic veneration invests as completely the name of Lincoln as
of Washington.
The many personal memories of the martyred patriot that I can recall
seem almost a dream to me. It seems almost a vision of the
unsubstantial imagination, when I think that I have known the one
immortal man of the century, and enjoyed his friendship. He was
the very impersonation of humanity; his stature was above and beyond
all others. One hand reached back to the very portals of Mount
Vernon, while the other, giving kindly protection to the oppressed,
still reaches forward to guide, encourage, and sustain the people
of this Nation.
It was my great good-fortune to know something of Abraham Lincoln
from the time I was about twelve years old, and even earlier than
that I have a distinct recollection of hearing my father advising
men to employ Lincoln in important litigation. Lincoln at that
time was about thirty years old, and even then was regarded as a
really great lawyer.
The first time I ever saw him in court he, assisted by Colonel E.
D. Baker (afterwards a senator from Oregon, and killed at Ball's
Bluff), was engaged in the defence of a man on trial for murder.
The conduct of the defence made by those great lawyers produced an
impression on my mind that will never be forgotten. Lincoln became
then my ideal of a great man, and has so remained ever since.
In 1846, Mr. Lincoln was the Whig candidate for Congress, and it
was then that I first heard him deliver a political speech. The
county in which my father resided was a part of his Congressional
district. When Lincoln came to the county my father met him with
his carriage and took him to all his appointments. I went to the
meeting nearest my home--an open-air meeting held in a grove. On
being introduced, he began his speech as follows: "Fellow citizens,
ever since I have been in Tazewell County my old friend, Major
Cullom, has taken me around; he has heard all my speeches, and the
only way I can hope to fool the old Major and make him believe I
am making a new speech is by turning it end for end once in a
while."
When I determined to abandon the hard work on the farm to enter
the study of law at Springfield, my father being so close to Mr.
Lincoln, I went to him for advice. He expressed a willingness to
take me into his own office as a student, but said that he was
absent on the circuit so much that he would advise me to enter the
law office of Stuart and Edwards, two prominent Springfield lawyers,
of whom I have written more at length in an earlier chapter. There
I would have the advantage of the constant supervision of one or
the other member of the firm.
From that time until he left Springfield never to return, I had
constant means of observing Lincoln as a lawyer. I was at times
associated with him as a junior counsel in the trial of law suits.
I was employed in a murder case which Lincoln and Logan were
defending, I being the boy lawyer in the case. They made a wonderful
defence. I do not know whether the defendant was guilty or not,
but I do know that he was acquitted.
During my life I have been acquainted with very many able lawyers,
and I have no hesitation in saying that Lincoln was the greatest
trial lawyer I ever knew. He was a man of wonderful power before
a court or jury. When he was sure he was right, his strength and
resourcefulness were well-nigh irresistible. In the court-room he
was at home. He was frank with the court, the juries, and the
lawyers, to such an extent that he would state the case of the
opposite side as fairly as the opposing counsel could do it; he
would then disclose his client's case so strongly, with such honestly
and candor, that the judge and jury would be almost convinced at
once in advance of the testimony. Judge Davis once said that the
framework of Lincoln's mental and moral being was honesty, and that
a wrong cause was poorly defended by him.
The story is told that a man offered to employ him in a case and
told him the facts, which did not satisfy Lincoln that there was
any merit in it. He said to him: "I can gain your case; I can
set a whole neighborhood at loggerheads; I can distress a widowed
mother and six fatherless children, and thereby get for you six
hundred dollars, which it appears to me as rightfully belongs to
them as to you. I will not take your case, but I will give you a
little advice for nothing. You seem to be a sprightly young man,
and I advise you to try your hand at making six hundred dollars in
some other way."
Mr. Lincoln was for a time employed by the Illinois Central Railroad
as one of its attorneys. In a case in one of the counties of Judge
Davis's circuit to which the railroad was a party, it was announced
that the company was not ready for trial, and the court inquired
the reason; to which Mr. Lincoln replied that Captain McClellan
was absent. The court asked, "Who is Captain McClellan?" Lincoln
replied that all he knew about him was that he was the engineer of
the Illinois Central Railroad.
What a strange juggling of destiny and of fate! In little more
than two years McClellan's fame had become world-wide as the general
in charge of all the armies of the Republic, only to prove in the
estimation of many people the most stupendous failure as a commander
in all our military history; Davis had become a Justice of the
Supreme Court of the United States; and Lincoln had reached the
Presidency.
In the trial of the murder case to which I have referred, I never
saw more striking evidence of Mr. Lincoln's power over a court.
There came a question of the advisability of certain testimony
which was very vital to the defendant. The question was thoroughly
argued by Judge Logan and Mr. Lincoln until the court took a recess
for dinner at noon. The Judge announced that he would render his
decision when the court reconvened. The courthouse was filled on
the reconvening of court in the afternoon, and the Judge began
rendering his opinion on the point in dispute. It seemed to Mr.
Lincoln and those present that he was about to decide against the
admissibility of the evidence. Lincoln sprang to his feet.
Apparently he towered over the Judge, overawing him. He made such
a tremendous impression that the court apparently gave way, and
decided the point in the defendant's favor.
Mr. Lincoln was not only a great statesman, but he was one of the
ablest, most astute, and shrewdest politicians whom I have ever
known. From my earliest recollection of him he took keen interest
in public affairs and was the foremost public man or politician in
his section of the State. He was not among the first to join the
Republican party. He clung to the old Whig party as long as a
vestige of it remained. Almost immediately after he drifted into
the Republican party, he became its recognized leader in Illinois,
and his public utterances attracted the attention of the Nation to
him.
I recollect having heard him utter the memorable words in the
Republican Convention of my State in 1858:
"A house divided against itself cannot stand. This Government
cannot permanently endure half slave and half free. I do not expect
the Union to be dissolved--I do not expect the house to fall--but
I do expect that it will cease to be divided. It will become all
one thing, or all the other."
What words of wisdom! He looked through the veil between him and
the future and saw the end more clearly than any other man in public
life. This was a carefully prepared speech, in which every word
was weighed. Some of his friends, to whom it was read, advised
him not to use the clause I have quoted, "a house divided against
itself." He was wiser than any of them. With a self-reliance born
of earnest conviction he said that the time had come when the
sentiments should be uttered, and that if he should go down because
of their utterance by him, then he would go down linked with the
truth.
I listened to much of the great debate between Lincoln and Douglas,
the greatest political debate which ever took place in this country.
I have always felt that Lincoln never expected to be elected to
the Senate in 1858. I think he saw more clearly than any of us
that the advanced position which he took in that debate made his
election to the Senate at that time impossible. He was then fighting
for a great principle. He did carry a majority of the popular
vote, but Douglas secured a majority of the Legislature.
His defeat apparently affected him little, if at all. I felt very
badly when it became apparent that Douglas had secured a majority
of the Legislature. I met Lincoln on the street one day, and said:
"Mr. Lincoln, is it true that Douglas has a majority of the
Legislature?" His reply was an affirmative. I then expressed the
great sorrow and disappointment that I felt. He placed a hand upon
my shoulder, and said: "Never mind, my boy; it will all come
right." I believe that he then felt certain that the position he
took in that memorable debate would make him the logical candidate
of the Republican party for the Presidency in 1860, which it did.
And two years from that very day the Republican party celebrated
its first national victory in his election as President of the
United States.
It has been said that Mr. Lincoln never went to school; and he
never did to any great extent, but in a broad sense of the word,
he was an educated man. He was a student, a thinker; he educated
himself, and mastered any question which claimed his attention.
There was no man in this country who possessed to a greater degree
the power of analyzation.
He was a student all his life. One incident that occurred in
Springfield, some years before he finally left, will serve as an
illustration.
An old German came through the town and claimed that he could teach
us all to read and speak German in a few weeks. A class was
organized for the purpose of studying German. Lincoln became a
member of the class, and I also was in it, and I can see him yet
going about with the German book in his pocket, studying it during
his leisure moments in court and elsewhere. None of the rest of
us learned much, but Lincoln mastered it, as he did every other
subject which engaged his attention.
His home life was a pleasant one. I often visited at his home,
and so far as my observation went, I do not hesitate to say that
not the slightest credence should be given to the many false stories
that have from time to time appeared, manufactured largely by those
who desired to write something new and sensational concerning the
life of President Lincoln in his home, and concerning Mrs. Lincoln.
Mr. Lincoln was regarded generally as an ungainly man, and so he
was; and yet on occasions he appeared to me to be superior in
dignity and nobility to almost any other man whom I have ever seen.
I was present when the committee from the National Convention, that
gave his first nomination for President, came to Springfield to
notify him of his nomination. He stood in the rear of a double
parlor in his home, and as the Hon. George F. Ashmun, president of
the convention, presented the members of the delegation one by one
to him, I thought that he looked what he was--the superior of any
man present. Many of the eminent men composing that delegation
had believed that Lincoln was some sort of a monster. I stood
among them after they had met him and listened to their comments.
The lofty character, the towering strength, the majesty of the man
had made a great impression upon them. They had come expecting to
see a freak; they discovered one of the princes of men.
In this connection, I must be permitted to refer to another occasion.
It so happened that I was in Washington when the President's son
Willie died. The funeral ceremony took place in the East Room of
the White House, in the presence of the President and his cabinet
and a few other friends. When the ceremony was about concluded
and President Lincoln stood by the bier of his dead boy, with tear-
drops falling from his face, surrounded by Seward, Chase, Bates,
and others, I thought I never beheld a nobler-looking man. He was
at that time truly, as he appeared, a man of sorrow, acquainted
with grief, possessing the power and responsibilities of a President
of a great Nation, yet with quivering lips and face bedewed with
tears, from personal sorrow.
The morning that Abraham Lincoln left his home in Springfield never
to return is not to be forgotten. It was early on the morning of
the eleventh of February, dark and gloomy, with a light snow falling.
There was a large crowd of his neighbors and friends at the station
to bid him good-bye. He held a sort of impromptu reception in the
little railroad station. There was no noisy demonstration. As I
recollect it now, it was a solemn leave-taking. Just before the
train pulled out, Mr. Lincoln appeared on the rear platform of his
car. Every head was bared, as if to receive a benediction, as he
uttered his farewell address:
"My Friends: No one not in my situation can appreciate my feeling
of sadness at this parting. To this place, and the kindness of
these people, I owe everything. Here I have lived a quarter of a
century, and have passed from a young to an old man. Here my
children have been born and one is buried. I now leave, not knowing
when or whether ever I may return, with a task before me greater
than that which rested upon Washington. Without the assistance of
that Divine Being who ever attended him, I cannot succeed; with
that assistance, I cannot fail. Trusting in Him, who can go with
me, and remain with you, and be everywhere for good, let us
confidently hope that all will yet be well. To His care commending
you, as I hope in your prayers you will commend me, I bid you an
affectionate farewell."
I was not present at the first inauguration of President Lincoln,
but I visited Washington many times during the years that he was
President, and, knowing him as well as I did, and having known both
Nicolay and Hay, his secretaries, in Springfield, I naturally spent
much time around the executive offices. I had many conversations
with him during the early years of the war. He had no military
education, but he soon demonstrated that he was in fact the real
commander-in-chief. He liked General McClellan, and stuck to him
until McClellan had demonstrated his absolute inefficiency for
command. McClellan was a great organizer. He made the Army of
the Potomac the most perfect fighting machine, I might almost say,
that was ever known in military history. But there he stopped.
He could organize, but he could not and did not, despite the urging
and the anxiety of Mr. Lincoln, push forward his army to victory.
I knew something of Mr. Lincoln's anxiety at the failure of McClellan
to inaugurate an aggressive campaign.
The late O. M. Hatch of Illinois told me of a rather interesting
incident which occurred on one occasion when the President,
accompanied by Mr. Hatch, visited McClellan's army a few days prior
to the battle of Antietam in September, 1862. They spent the night
in a tent, and, rising very early, at the President's suggestion
they took a walk before sunrise about the great camp, inspecting
the field, the artillery, the quarters, and all the appurtenances
of the army. Lincoln was in a pensive mood, and scarcely a word
was spoken. Finally, just as the sun was rising, they reached a
commanding point; the President stopped, placed his left hand upon
Mr. Hatch's shoulder, and slowly waving his right in the direction
of the great city of tents, seriously inquired: "Mr. Hatch, what
is all this before us?"
"Why, Mr. President," was the surprised reply, "this is General
McClellan's army."
"No, Mr. Hatch, no," returned Lincoln soberly, "this is General
McClellan's body-guard."
It will be understood what these utterances signified: they
expressed perfectly the prevailing belief that McClellan had failed
to appreciate the purpose for which that magnificent fighting
machine had been created.
I think I am justified in saying that after the earlier contests
of the war had proven that great soldiers and great generals were
not always great leaders, President Lincoln became the able director,
the actual commander-in-chief of the forces of the United States.
He planned and ordered the larger movements of the War, and he held
the reins above and about all his armies, scarcely relaxing his
watchful care for a moment,--until events demonstrated the wisdom
with which he confided the military interests of our beloved country
and the conduct of the war to Ulysses S. Grant.
Some of us remember with what persistence during the Winter of 1862
and 1863 many newspapers and a large share of the Northern people
joined in the cry of "On to Richmond!" Censure and criticism ran
riot even among Northern Republicans. In a three-line memorandum
the President showed the fallacy of that outcry, when he wrote:
"Our prime object is the enemy's army in front of us, and not with
or about Richmond at all, unless it be incidental to the main
object." At a later day he said to Hooker: "I think Lee's army,
and not Richmond, is your sure objective point."
Modest and simple as he always was, never seeking power with
inordinate ambition, simply that he might use power; still he was
never afraid to assume responsibility when it was his duty to assume
it.
I called on him one evening at the Soldiers' Home. We spent the
evening together, and naturally we talked of the war. He discussed
almost all of his generals, beginning with McClellan. At that time
McClellan was down on the James, and Pope was in the saddle in
Virginia. Pope, he feared, would be whipped, unless he could get
more troops, and he was trying to get McClellan back in order to
save Pope. At that time he had not yet lost his faith in McClellan,
but he was complaining that McClellan was never ready for battle.
After making all possible preparations, and with the enemy in front,
he would overestimate the size of the enemy's force, and demand
more troops. Yet Mr. Lincoln said that he would rather trust
McClellan to get his army out of a tight place than any other
general that he had.
After his election he invited his principal competitors for the
nomination to enter his cabinet. He had not the slightest jealousy
of any living man. He was not afraid, as some of our Presidents
have been, to have his cabinet composed of the greatest men of his
time. He was a bigger man than any of them, and no thought of
jealousy ever entered his mind. Both Seward and Chase fancied they
were greater men than Lincoln, and each of them, at the beginning
at least, entertained the idea that on him rested the responsibility
of the administration. Seward felt that he should have been the
nominee of his party. Chase felt perfectly sure that he, and not
Lincoln, should have been President.
Before many months had passed, Seward was compelled to acknowledge
that Mr. Lincoln was the superior of any of them, as he expressed
it in a letter to his wife. He soon became one of the most devoted
friends and loyal supporters of the President. The publication of
the diary of Gideon Welles, Secretary of the Navy from 1861 to
1865, shows that Mr. Lincoln was the leader of them all, and was
in fact the real head of every department of his administration.
Chase was an able man, and loyal to the Union; but, unlike Seward,
he was never loyal to the President personally, and was constantly
plotting in his own interest to supplant Lincoln as the nominee of
his party in 1864,--a most reprehensible course on the part of a
cabinet officer. This did not give concern to Mr. Lincoln in the
slightest degree. He cared very little what Mr. Chase said or
thought of him personally, so long as he was doing his duty as
Secretary of the Treasury.
I was in Washington the latter part of February, 1864, before he
was nominated the second time. I happened to hear of the Pomeroy
letter in behalf of Mr. Chase, and I learned with amazement that
Chase was conspiring with his friends to secure the nomination for
the Presidency, and was untrue and unloyal to his chief. I felt
justly indignant. I saw Mr. Lincoln and talked with him about it
with great earnestness. I told him that Chase should be turned
out. He answered by saying: "Let him alone; he can do no more
harm in here than he can outside."
If things did not go to suit him, Chase was in the habit of tendering
his resignation every few days. It was not accepted; but he offered
it once too often, and, very much to his surprise and chagrin, it
was promptly accepted; and Chase was relegated to private life,
where he belonged, and where he should have remained.
Chief Justice Taney passed away unmourned, the most pathetic and
desolate figure in the Civil War, with his long, faithful, and
distinguished service on the bench forgotten. Chase's friends,
and Chase himself, at once commenced overtures of friendship toward
Mr. Lincoln, in the interest, solely, of securing Chase's appointment
as Chief Justice. Considerable pressure was brought to bear in
behalf of Chase. The President would give no intimation as to what
he intended to do, although I myself believe that he all the time
intended appointing him to the vacant position, and that the so-
called pressure on the part of Sumner and other radicals had little,
if any, influence with him.
During this period, after the death of Chief Justice Taney, Chase
was not at all averse to writing the President the most friendly
letters. One day his secretary brought him a letter from Mr. Chase.
The President asked, "What is it about?" "Simply a kind and friendly
letter," the secretary answered. Mr. Lincoln, without reading it,
replied with his shrewd smile: "File it with his other recommendations."
Chase was finally appointed Chief Justice of the United States.
After his conduct as a member of the cabinet, I do not believe we
have ever had another President, except Lincoln, magnanimous enough
to have made that appointment under similar circumstances. Lincoln
entertained a very exalted opinion of Chase's ability as a lawyer
and a man. He believed that he possessed the qualifications of a
great Chief Justice, and the appointment was made entirely free
from any personal feelings or prejudices.
I happened to be alone in Mr. Nicolay's room in the White House
when Mr. Chase called to thank the President for his nomination.
He came into Mr. Nicolay's room first, and inquired of me if the
President was in. I told him I did not know, but his room was next
to the one we were in, and he might ascertain for himself. Knowing
of Chase's disparaging remarks concerning Mr. Lincoln, and of his
disloyalty as a member of his cabinet, I was very curious to hear
what he would have to say to the President. He left the door ajar,
and I overheard the conversation. Mr. Chase proceeded to thank
the President for his nomination. Mr. Lincoln's reply was brief,
merely that he hoped Mr. Chase would get along well and would do
his duty. Very few words passed between them, and the interview
closed.
Montgomery Blair was Postmaster-General in President Lincoln's
cabinet. He was appointed from the District of Columbia. He was
a man of considerable ability, and was thoroughly loyal to the
President. Montgomery Blair became exceedingly unpopular among
certain classes, not only on his own account, but because of his
brother Frank, whose home was in Missouri. I thought his remaining
in the cabinet was injuring the Administration, and I told Mr.
Lincoln, in a conversation I had with him at the White House, that
under all the circumstances Montgomery Blair should be relieved
from office; that he was unpopular; that the people were not for
him. Mr. Lincoln seemed annoyed, even to the extent of petulance
(a rare thing with him), that I should say anything against Montgomery
Blair. He asserted that Blair was a loyal man, was doing his full
duty as Postmaster-General, and that he would not turn him out.
Later, Montgomery Blair, always loyal under all circumstances, told
the President that he was ready to tender his resignation whenever,
in the judgment of the President, his remaining in the cabinet
would be an embarrassment; and Mr. Lincoln in a very kindly note
sometime afterwards said that he felt himself compelled to accept
Mr. Blair's offer and ask for his resignation. They continued
personal friends until the President's death.
The year 1862, on account of the proclamation of President Lincoln,
in September, that he would free the slaves in those States or
parts of States whose people continued in rebellion on and after
January 1, 1863, was a disastrous year to the Republican party;
but the final effect of the proclamation was beneficial to the
cause of the Union. It stimulated greater enthusiasm on the part
of those who desired to see the end of slavery in this country.
Many people so hated that institution that they were more desirous
of having it abolished than to have the Union preserved with it.
While President Lincoln was always opposed to slavery, unequivocally
opposed to it, yet his oath called upon him to preserve the
Constitution and the Union. He said that his paramount object was
to save the Union and not to save or destroy slavery.
In 1862 President Lincoln appointed three men, namely, Governor
George S. Boutwell, the Hon. Stephen T. Logan, and the Hon. Charles
A. Dana, a commission to go to Cairo, Illinois, and settle the
claims of numerous persons against the Government, arising from
property purchased by commissary officers and quartermasters in
the volunteer service before the volunteers knew anything about
military rules or regulations. Judge Logan went to Cairo, remained
a few days, became ill, tendered his resignation, and returned
home. The President telegraphed me an appointment, and asked me
to go at once to Cairo for duty, which I did. I had not known
either Boutwell or Dana before. The commission finished its work
in about a month, and forwarded to Washington all papers, with its
report. The claims were paid on the basis of our allowance, and
justice was done to all concerned.
Early in 1862 an old friend of President Lincoln's, James Lamb,
came to see me, stating that he had been furnishing beef cattle to
the army; that he had received orders to furnish a given number on
the hoof at a certain place in the South, which he had done; but
before his cattle arrived the army had gone, and he had thereby
suffered great loss. He asked me to look after his claim when I
went to the National capital, and I agreed to do so. I knew nothing
about such things in Washington, nor how such business with the
Government was transacted. I went to the President as the only
official with whom I was acquainted, and stated to him, "Uncle
Jimmie Lamb, your old friend, has a claim," setting forth the same
in full. "You know he is a good man," I urged, "and he ought to
have his money." Lincoln answered me by saying: "Cullom, there
is this difference in dealing between two individuals and between
an individual and the Government: if an individual does not do as
he agreed and the other person is injured thereby, he can sue the
one responsible for the injury, and recover damages; but in the
case of the Government, if it does not do right, the individual
can't help himself." He gave me a note, however, to the proper
officer and the matter was arranged.
The gossip around the Capitol in Washington among Senators and
Representatives is a very poor gauge of public sentiment in the
country toward a President. I was in Washington a few months before
the second nomination. I talked with numerous Representatives and
Senators, and it really seemed to me as if there was hardly any
one in favor of the renomination of Mr. Lincoln. I felt much
discouraged over the circumstance. When I was about to leave for
home, I called at the White House. I asked the President if he
permitted anybody to talk to him about himself. He replied that
he did. I said: "I would like to talk to you about yourself."
He asked me to be seated. Whereupon I told him that I had been in
Washington some ten days or more, and that everybody seemed to be
against him.
"Well, it is not quite so bad as that," he said. He took down his
directory, and I soon discovered that he had a far more intimate
knowledge of the situation than I had. He had every one marked,
knew how he stood, and the list made a better showing than I had
expected.
The truth is, however, that many of the strong men in Congress,
especially the radicals, were against his renomination, and would
have rejoiced to see some one else the nominee of the party; but
they knew full well, that the great body of the people of the North
were with him, and that it would be useless to attempt to prevent
his renomination.
The next time I called at the White House after the convention, he
reminded me of our previous conversation, and remarked that it did
not turn out so badly after all.
He was reminded of a little story. A couple of Irishmen came to
America and started out on foot into the country. They travelled
along until they came to a piece of woods. They thought they heard
a noise, but did not know what it was. They deployed on either
side of the road to find out, but were unable to do so, and finally
one called to the other, "Pat, Pat, let's go on; this is nothing
by a domned noise." So the opposition to him, he said, was apparently
nothing but a noise.
But if he never had any doubts as to his renomination, he at one
time almost despaired of being re-elected, as did many of his
closest and most intimate friends. The Democrats had not yet
selected their candidates, and as he remarked: "At this period we
had no adversary, and seemed to have no friends."
An incident in this connection is related by the late Secretary,
John Hay. The President felt that the campaign was going against
him, and he had made up his mind deliberately as to the course he
should pursue. He resolved to lay down for himself a course of
action demanded by his then conviction of duty. He wrote on the
twenty-third of August the following memorandum:
"This morning, as for some days past, it seems exceedingly probable
that this administration will not be re-elected. Then it will be
my duty to so co-operate with the President-elect as to save the
Union between the election and the inauguration; as he will have
secured his election on such grounds that he cannot possibly save
it afterwards."
He then folded and pasted the sheet in such manner that its contents
could not be read, and as the cabinet came together he handed this
paper to each member successively, requesting him to write his name
across the back of it, without intimating to any member of the
cabinet what the note contained. In this manner he pledged himself
to accept loyally the anticipated verdict of the people against him.
Mr. Hay's diary relates what took place at the next cabinet meeting
after the election, as follows:
"At the meeting of the cabinet to-day the President took out a
paper from his desk and said: 'Gentlemen, do you remember last
summer I asked you all to sign your names to the back of a paper
of which I did not show you the inside? This is it. Now, Mr. Hay,
see if you can open this without tearing it.' He had pasted it up
in so singular a style that it required some cutting to get it
open. He then read this memorandum (quoted above).
"The President said: 'You will remember that this was written at
the time, six days before the Chicago nominating convention, when
as yet we had no adversary and seemed to have no friends. I then
solemnly resolved on the course of action indicated in this paper.
I resolved in the case of the election of General McClellan, being
certain that he would be the candidate, that I would see him and
talk matters over with him. I would say, "General, the election
has demonstrated that you are stronger, have more influence with
the American people than I. Now let us together, you with your
influence, and I with all the executive power of the Government,
try to save the country. You raise as many troops as you possibly
can for the final trial, and I will devote all my energies to assist
and finish the war."'
"Seward said: 'And the General would have answered you, "Yes,
yes," and the next day when you saw him again and pressed these
views upon him, he would have said, "Yes, yes," and so on forever,
and would have done nothing at all.'
"'At least,' rejoined Lincoln, 'I should have done my duty and have
stood clear before my own conscience.'"
Not the least of his troubles and embarrassments during the trying
period preceding his second election was the overzealous advice,--
persistence, I might say--on the part of certain New Yorkers and
New Englanders who seemed to think that they had the interest of
the Union and the country more at heart than had Mr. Lincoln.
Horace Greeley was one of the most troublesome of this lot. He
was an honest and a most loyal man, but was willing to temporize
upon the most vital questions. At one time he advised that the
"erring sisters" should be permitted to depart in peace. At this
particular time of which I speak he had devised a plan for a peace
conference, with certain prominent Confederates, Clement C. Clay,
among others, to be held in Canada. Mr. Lincoln felt sure that
the conference would do no good, and that the Confederates were
fooling Mr. Greeley, and that they had no real power to act.
This turned out to be exactly the truth. I was with the President
just as he was sending Mr. Hay to Niagara with written instructions,
which were given to see that nothing which threatened the interests
of the Government should be done. The President was very much
annoyed, and he remarked to me: "While Mr. Greeley means right,
he makes me almost as much trouble as the whole Southern
Confederacy."
While, as I have previously observed, Greeley was intensely loyal
to the country, yet he was so nervous and unstable in his mind that
he could not resist the effort to bring about a condition of peace.
I think he would have consented to almost anything in order to
secure it. He was very anxious for the issuance of a proclamation
abolishing slavery, and on the nineteenth of August, 1862, addressed
a very arrogant open letter to President Lincoln on the subject.
Lincoln's reply was so good, so perfect, and so conclusive that I
give it, as follows:
"Executive Mansion,
"Washington, _Friday, August 22, 1863_.
"Hon. Horace Greeley:
"Dear Sir: I have just read yours of the nineteenth instant,
addressed to myself through _The New York Tribune_.
"If there be any statements or assumptions of facts which I may
know to be erroneous, I do not now and here controvert them.
"If there may be any inferences which I may to believe to be falsely
drawn, I do not now and here argue against them.
"If there be perceptible in it an impatient and dictatorial tone,
I waive it in deference to an old friend whose heart I have always
supposed to be right.
"As to the policy 'I seem to be pursuing,' as you say, I have not
meant to leave any one in doubt. I would save the Union. I would
save it in the shortest way under the Constitution.
"The sooner the National authority can be restored, the nearer the
Union will be--the Union as it was.
"If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could
at the same time save slavery, I do not agree with them.
"If there be those who would not save the Union unless they could
at the same time destroy slavery, I do not agree with them.
"_My paramount object is to save the Union, and not either to save
or destroy slavery_.
"If I could save the Union without freeing any slave, I would do
it; and if I could save it by freeing all the slaves, I would do
it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone,
I would do that.
"What I do about slavery and the colored race, I do because I
believe it helps to save the Union, and what I forbear, I forbear
because I do not believe it would help to save the Union.
"I shall do less whenever I shall believe what I am doing hurts
the cause, and shall do more whenever I believe doing more will
help the cause.
"I shall try to correct errors when shown to be errors, and I shall
adopt new views so fast as they will appear to be true views.
"I have here stated my purpose according to my view of official
duty, and I intend no modifications of my oft-expressed personal
wish that all men everywhere could be free.
"Yours,
"A. Lincoln."
It is said that Mr. Greeley remarked after reading the letter that
he had been knocked out by one letter from Mr. Lincoln, and that
he "would be damned if he ever wrote him another."
There was more personal bitterness evinced against Mr. Lincoln in
the campaign of 1864 than ever before or since in a Presidential
campaign. He was denounced in the most intemperate language as a
tyrant, a dictator, whose administration had proven a failure. A
certain element of so-called "high class" New Englanders, men of
the Wendell Phillips type, were particularly bitter in their
denunciation. And I may remark in passing that the New England
men of letters never did have a proper appreciation of the worth
of Abraham Lincoln.
He was triumphantly re-elected amid the universal rejoicing of the
friends of liberty throughout the North. He took the election very
quietly. He apparently felt no sense of personal triumph over his
opponents and those who had so bitterly attacked him during the
campaign. He seemed only to have a feeling of deep gratitude to
his fellow citizens who had testified their confidence in his
administration. On the evening of election day, when it became
evident that he was re-elected to the Presidency, in response to
a serenade he said:
"I am thankful to God for this approval by the people. While deeply
grateful for this mark of their confidence in me, if I know my
heart, my gratitude is free from any taint of personal triumph,
but I give thanks to the Almighty for this evidence of the people's
resolution to stand by free government and the rights of humanity."
And again in that eloquent, simple little response which he made
to the joint committee of Congress appointed to wait upon him to
notify him of his second election, after the count of the electoral
votes by a joint session of the Senate and House of Representatives
in Congress, he said:
"With deep gratitude to my countrymen for this mark of their
confidence; with a distrust of my own ability to perform the duty
required under the most favorable circumstances, and now rendered
doubly difficult by existing national perils; yet with a firm
reliance on the strength of our free Government, and the eventual
loyalty of the people to the just principles upon which it is
founded, and, above all, with an unshaken faith in the Supreme
Ruler of Nations, I accept this trust. Be pleased to signify this
to the respective Houses of Congress."
These utterances show more clearly than any one else can describe
the state of mind in which the President received his re-election,
and in which he was about to enter his second term as President of
the Republic. Without any personal feeling of pride, he was certain
in his own mind that his re-election was necessary in order to save
the Union.
I attended the second inauguration, March 4, 1865. I have a
particularly vivid recollection of the scene which took place in
the Senate chamber when Mr. Johnson took the oath as Vice-President.
The simple truth is, and it was plain to every one present in that
chamber, Mr. Johnson was intoxicated. Johnson delivered a rambling,
senseless address. I sat next to Senator Lane of Indiana, and I
remarked that somebody should stop him. Lane sent up a note to
the Secretary of the Senate, telling him to get Johnson to cease
speaking and take the oath. We felt Johnson was making an exhibition
of himself in the presence of the President, the Cabinet, the
Foreign Representatives, and two Houses of Congress, and a gathering
of the most distinguished men of the Nation. The Secretary wrote
some lines and placed them before Mr. Johnson, who did not appear
to notice them. Finally he was made to understand that he must
take the oath, as the time had come when the President, according
to usual custom, would have to go to the east front of the Capitol
to take the oath as President of the United States. Johnson, with
a sort of wild sweep of his arm said, "I will take the oath, but
I regard my devotion to the Union as greater evidence of my loyalty
than any oath I could take."
I was close to Mr. Lincoln at the solemn moment when Chief Justice
Chase administered to him the oath of office. There was a vast
crowd of people, great enthusiasm and rejoicing, and the war was
practically over,--a far different scene from the one which took
place just four years before, when Chief Justice Taney in the same
place administered the same oath. At that time there was no noisy
demonstration. There was a solemn hush, as every one realized that
the country was about to be plunged into one of the mightiest civil
wars of all history. Indeed many men believed that there was a
concerted plot to assassinate Mr. Lincoln at that time, and that
he would never be permitted to enter upon the duties of his office.
I heard him deliver his second inaugural address,--one of his two
greatest speeches.
The last time I saw Abraham Lincoln alive was about three weeks
before his assassination, as I now recollect. He was at the White
House. There had been constant rumors throughout his first term
that he was in danger of some such outrage, but as the war drew to
a close, with the natural bitter and resentful feeling in the South,
these rumors seemed to increase. I told him what I had heard, and
urged him to be careful. It did not seem to concern him much, and
the substance of his reply was that he must take his chances; that
he could not live in an iron box, as he expressed it, and do his
duty as President of the United States.
It is difficult for one who did not live in those terrible days
from 1861 to 1865 to realize the awful shock of horror that went
through the whole Nation on the morning of April 15, 1865, when
the message came, "Abraham Lincoln is dead." In his old home at
Springfield, it seemed the whole population assembled in the public
square, and the duty devolved upon me to announce to the assembled
people that the great President had passed away. There was intense
suppressed excitement. No one dared utter a word in disparagement
of Abraham Lincoln. The crowd was in the humor for hanging to the
limb of the first convenient tree any one who dared to make a
slighting suggestion. It was not alone in Springfield, but it was
throughout the entire North that this feeling prevailed. There
was fear that the Government would go to pieces, almost that the
end of the world was at hand.
Soon the news came from different sources that he was to be buried
in Washington, or somewhere in the East. The people of Springfield
became very much worked up. A committee was appointed to go to
Washington to insist that the remains should be taken to Springfield.
I was a member of this committee. We left immediately, but before
we arrived at Harrisburg it had been determined that the only
fitting final resting place of all that remained of the immortal
Lincoln was at his old home in Springfield; and the funeral train
had already left Washington. The committee waited at Harrisburg
for its arrival. Through the courtesy of Governor Curtin, of
Pennsylvania, we were permitted to board the train, and we accompanied
the remains from there to Philadelphia, New York, Albany, Buffalo,
Cleveland, Indianapolis, Chicago, and finally to Springfield. At
each place the remains lay in state and were viewed by hundreds of
thousands of peopl
Showing first 200,000 characters. Full text: gutenberg.org/ebooks/23097