Gutenberg · e01.org

← catalogue

The Rise of the Democracy

by Joseph Clayton · English · Gutenberg #19609 · 421,824 chars · public domain (US)

The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Rise of the Democracy
    
This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
before using this eBook.

Title: The Rise of the Democracy

Author: Joseph Clayton


        
Release date: October 23, 2006 [eBook #19609]
                Most recently updated: January 1, 2021

Language: English

Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/19609

Credits: E-text prepared by Afra Ullah, Keith Edkins, and the Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team


*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK THE RISE OF THE DEMOCRACY ***


E-text prepared by Afra Ullah, Keith Edkins, and the Project Gutenberg
Online Distributed Proofreading Team (https://www.pgdp.net/)



Note: Project Gutenberg also has an HTML version of this
      file which includes the original illustrations.
      See 19609-h.htm or 19609-h.zip:
      (https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/9/6/0/19609/19609-h/19609-h.htm)
      or
      (https://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/9/6/0/19609/19609-h.zip)





THE RISE OF THE DEMOCRACY

by

JOSEPH CLAYTON

Author of "Leaders of the People" "Bishops as Legislators," etc. etc.

With Eight Full-Page Plates







Cassell and Company, Ltd.
London, New York, Toronto and Melbourne
1911
All Rights Reserved


[Illustration: KING JOHN GRANTING MAGNA CHARTA

From the Fresco in the Royal Exchange, by Ernest Normand.

_By permission of Messrs. S. Hildesheimer & Co., Ltd._]





PREFACE

This short account of the rise of political democracy is necessarily but an
outline of the matter, and while it is not easy to define the exact limits,
there is no difficulty in noting omissions. For instance, there is scarcely
any reference to the work of poets or pamphleteers. John Ball's rhyming
letters are quoted, but not the poems of Langland, and the political songs
of the Middle Ages are hardly mentioned. The host of political pamphleteers
in the seventeenth century are excluded, with the exception of Lilburne and
Winstanley, whose work deserves better treatment from posterity than it
received from contemporaries. Defoe's vigorous services for the Whigs are
unnoticed, and the democratic note in much of the poetry of Burns, Blake,
Byron and Shelley is left unconsidered, and the influence of these poets
undiscussed. The anti-Corn Law rhymes of Ebenezer Eliot, and the Chartist
songs of Ernest Jones were notable inspirations in their day, and in our
own times Walt Whitman and Mr. Edward Carpenter have been the chief singers
of democracy. But a whole volume at least might be written on the part the
pen has played in the struggle towards democracy.

Again, there is no mention of Ireland in this short sketch. A Nationalist
movement is not necessarily a democratic movement, and the Irish
Nationalist Party includes men of very various political opinions, whose
single point of agreement is the demand for Home Rule. In India and Egypt
the agitation is for representative institutions. Ireland might, or might
not, become a democracy under Home Rule--who can say?

The aim of the present writer has been to trace the travelled road of the
English people towards democracy, and to point out certain landmarks on
that road, in the hope that readers may be turned to examine more closely
for themselves the journey taken. For the long march teems with adventure
and spirited enterprise; and, noting mistakes and failures in the past, we
may surely and wisely, and yet with greater daring and finer courage,
pursue the road, not unmindful of the charge committed to us in the
centuries left behind.

  J.C.

  HAMPSTEAD,
  _September, 1911._




CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

The British Influence--"Government of the People, by the People, for the
People"--The Foundations of Democracy--British Democracy Experimental not
Doctrinaire--Education to Democracy

CHAPTER I

THE EARLY STRUGGLES AGAINST THE ABSOLUTISM OF THE CROWN

The Great Churchmen--Archbishop Anselm and Norman Autocracy--Thomas à
Becket and Henry II.--Stephen Langton and John--The Great Charter

CHAPTER II

THE BEGINNING OF PARLIAMENTARY REPRESENTATION

Democracy and Representative Government--Representative Theory First found
in Ecclesiastical Assemblies--The Misrule of Henry III.--Simon of Montfort,
Leader of the National Party--Edward I.'s Model Parliament, 1295--The
Nobility Predominant in Parliament--The Medieval National Assemblies--The
Electors of the Middle Ages--Payment of Parliamentary Representatives--The
Political Position of Women in the Middle Ages--No Theory of Democracy in
the Middle Ages

CHAPTER III

POPULAR INSURRECTION IN ENGLAND

General Results of Popular Risings--William FitzOsbert, 1196--The Peasant
Revolt and its Leaders, 1381--Jack Cade, Captain of Kent, 1450--The Norfolk
Rising under Ket, 1549

CHAPTER IV

THE STRUGGLE RENEWED AGAINST THE CROWN

Parliament under the Tudors--Victory of Parliament over the Stuarts--The
Democratic Protest: Lilburne--Winstanley and "The Diggers"--The Restoration

CHAPTER V

CONSTITUTIONAL GOVERNMENT--ARISTOCRACY TRIUMPHANT

Government by Aristocrats--Civil and Religious Liberty--Growth of Cabinet
Rule--Walpole's rule--The Change in the House of Lords--"Wilkes and
Liberty"

CHAPTER VI

THE RISE OF THE DEMOCRATIC IDEA

The Witness of the Middle Ages--The "Social Contract" Theory--Thomas
Hobbes--John Locke--Rousseau and French Revolution--American
Independence--Thomas Paine--Major Cartwright and the "Radical
Reformers"--Thomas Spence--Practical Politics and Democratic Ideals

CHAPTER VII

PARLIAMENTARY REFORM AND THE ENFRANCHISEMENT OF THE PEOPLE

The Industrial Revolution--The Need for Parliamentary Reform--Manufacturing
Centres Unrepresented in Parliament--The Passage of the Great Reform
Bill--The Working Class still Unrepresented--Chartism--The Hyde Park
Railings, 1866--Household Suffrage--Working-class Representation in
Parliament--Removal of Religious Disabilities: Catholics, Jews and
Freethinkers--The Enfranchisement of Women

CHAPTER VIII

DEMOCRACY AT WORK

Local Government--The Workman in the House of Commons--Working-class
Leaders in Parliament--The Present Position of the House of Lords--The
Popularity of the Crown--The Democratic Ideals: Socialism and Social
Reform--Land Reform and the Single Tax

CHAPTER IX

THE WORLD-WIDE MOVEMENT: ITS STRENGTH AND WEAKNESS

East and West--Tyranny under Democratic Forms--The Obvious Dangers--Party
Government--Bureaucracy--Working-Class Ascendancy--On Behalf of Democracy

LIST OF PLATES

  KING JOHN GRANTING MAGNA CHARTA

  MAGNA CHARTA--A FACSIMILE OF THE ORIGINAL IN THE BRITISH MUSEUM

  SIR JOHN ELIOT

  JOHN HAMPDEN

  THE GORDON RIOTS

  THE RIGHT HON. JOHN BURNS, M.P.

  THE RIGHT HON. D. LLOYD GEORGE, M.P.

  THE PASSING OF THE PARLIAMENT BILL IN THE HOUSE OF LORDS





THE RISE OF THE DEMOCRACY

INTRODUCTION

THE BRITISH INFLUENCE

Our business here is to give some plain account of the movement towards
democracy in England, only touching incidentally on the progress of that
movement in other parts of the world. Mainly through British influences the
movement has become world wide; and the desire for national
self-government, and the adoption of the political instruments of
democracy--popular enfranchisement and the rule of elected
representatives--are still the aspirations of civilised man in East and
West. The knowledge that these forms of democratic government have by no
means at all times and in all places proved successful does not check the
movement. As the British Parliament and the British Constitution have in
the past been accepted as a model in countries seeking free political
institutions, so to-day our Parliament and our Constitutional Government
are still quoted with approval and admiration in those lands where these
institutions are yet to be tried.

The rise of democracy, then, is a matter in which Britain is largely
concerned; and this in spite of the fact that in England little respect and
less attention has been paid to the expounders of democracy and their
constructive theories of popular government. The notion that philosophers
are the right persons to manage affairs of state and hold the reins of
Government has always been repugnant to the English people, and, with us,
to call a man "a political theorist" is to contemn him. The English have
not moved towards democracy with any conscious desire for that particular
form of government, and no vision of a perfect State or an ideal
commonwealth has sustained them on the march. Our boast has been that we
are a "practical" people, and so our politics are, as they ever have been,
experimental. Reforms have been accomplished not out of deference to some
moral or political principle, but because the abuse to be remedied had
become intolerable. Dissatisfaction with the Government and the conviction
that only by enfranchisement and the free election of representatives can
Parliament remove the grounds of dissatisfaction, have carried us towards
democracy.

GOVERNMENT OF THE PEOPLE, BY THE PEOPLE, FOR THE PEOPLE

We have been brought to accept Abraham Lincoln's famous phrase, "Government
of the people, by the people, for the people," as a definition of
democracy; but in that acceptance there is no harking back to the early
democracies of Greece or Rome, so beloved by the French democrats of the
eighteenth century, who, however, knew very little about those ancient
states--or any vain notion of restoring primitive Teutonic democracy.

The sovereign assemblies of Greece--the Ecclesia of Athens, and the Apella
of Sparta--the Comitia Centuriata of Rome, have no more resemblance to
democracy in the twentieth century than the Witenagemot has to the British
Parliament; and the democracy which has arisen in modern times is neither
to be traced for its origin to Greece or Rome, nor found to be evolved from
Anglo-Saxon times. The early democracies of Athens and Sparta were confined
to small states, and were based on a slave population without civic rights.
There was not even a conception that slaves might or should take part in
politics, and the slaves vastly outnumbered the citizens. Modern democracy
does not tolerate slavery, it will not admit the permanent exclusion of any
body of people from enfranchisement; though it finds it hard to ignore
differences of race and colour, it is always enlarging the borders of
citizenship. So that already in the Australian Commonwealth, in New
Zealand, in certain of the American States, in Norway, and in Finland, we
have the complete enfranchisement of all men and women who are of age to
vote.

Apart from this vital difference between a slave-holding democracy and a
democracy of free citizens--a difference that rent the United States in
civil war, and was only settled in America by democracy ending
slavery--ancient democracy was government by popular assembly, and modern
democracy is government through elected representatives. The former is only
possible in small communities with very limited responsibilities--a parish
meeting can decide questions of no more than strictly local interest; for
our huge empires of to-day nothing better than representative government
has been devised for carrying out the general will of the majority.

As for the early English Witenagemot, it was simply an assembly of the
chiefs, and, though crowds sometimes attended, all but the great men were
the merest spectators. Doubtless the folk-moot of the tribe was democratic,
for all free men attended it, and the English were a nation of freeholders,
and the slaves were few--except in the west--and might become free men.[1]
The shire-moot, too, with its delegates from the hundred-moots, was equally
democratic. But with feudalism and the welding of the nation, tribal
democracies passed away, leaving, however, in many places a valuable
tradition of local self-government.

THE FOUNDATIONS OF DEMOCRACY

A steady and invincible belief that those who maintain the defence of the
country and pay for the cost of government should have a voice in the great
council of the nation, and the conviction that effective utterance can be
found for that voice in duly chosen representatives, are the foundations on
which democracy has built. Democracy itself comes in (1) when it is seen
that all are being taxed for national purposes; and (2) the opinion finds
acceptance that responsibilities of citizenship should be borne by all who
have reached the age of manhood and are of sound mind.

To sketch the rise of democracy in England is to trace the steady
resistance to kings who would govern without the advice of counsellors, and
to note the growing determination that these counsellors must be elected
representatives. Only when the absolutism of the Crown is ended and a
Parliament of elected members has become the real centre of government, is
it possible, without a revolution, for democracy to be established.

Much of this book is given up, then, to the old stories of kingly rule
checked and slowly superseded by aristocracy. And all the old attempts at
revolution by popular insurrection are again retold, not only because of
the witness they bear to the impossibility in England of achieving
democracy by the violent overthrow of government, but because they also
bear witness to the heroic resolution of the English people to take up arms
and plunge into a sea of troubles rather than bear patiently ills that were
unseemly for men to endure in silence. Popular insurrection failed, but
over and over again violence has been resorted to in the resistance to
tyranny, and has been justified by its victory. If Wat Tyler, Jack Cade,
and Robert Ket are known as beaten revolutionaries, Stephen Langton, Simon
of Montfort, and John Hampden are acclaimed as patriots for not disdaining
the use of armed resistance.

The conclusion is that a democratic revolution was not to be accomplished
in England by a rising of the people, but that forcible resistance even to
the point of civil war was necessary to guard liberties already won, or to
save the land from gross misgovernment. But always the forcible resistance,
when successful, has been made not by revolutionaries but by the strong
champions of constitutional government. The fruit of the resistance to John
was the Great Charter; of Simon of Montfort's war against Henry III., the
beginning of a representative Parliament; of the war against Charles, the
establishment of Parliamentary government. Lilburne and his friends hoped
that the civil war and the abolition of monarchy would bring in democracy,
though democracy was never in the mind of men like Hampden, who made the
war, and was utterly uncongenial to Cromwell and the Commonwealth men. But
the sanctity of monarchy received its death-blow from Cromwell, and
perished with the deposing of James II.; and there has been no
resurrection. To the Whig rule we owe the transference of political power
from the Crown to Parliament. Once it is manifest that Parliament is the
instrument of authority, that the Prime Minister and his colleagues rule
only by the permission and with the approval of the House of Commons, and
that the House of Commons itself is chosen by a certain number of electors
to represent the nation, then it is plain that the real sovereignty is in
the electors who choose the House of Commons. As long as the electors are
few and consist of the great landowners and their satellites, then the
constitutional government is aristocracy, and democracy is still to come.

And just as discontent with monarchy, and its obvious failure as a
satisfactory form of government, brought in aristocracy, so at the
beginning of the nineteenth century discontent with aristocracy was rife,
and a new industrial middle-class looked for "Parliamentary reform," to
improve the condition of England.

BRITISH DEMOCRACY EXPERIMENTAL, NOT DOCTRINAIRE

Resistance to royal absolutism, culminating in the acknowledged ascendancy
of Parliament and the triumphant aristocracy of 1688, was never based on
abstract principles of the rights of barons and landowners, but sprang from
the positive, definite conviction that those who furnished arms and men for
the king, or who paid certain moneys in taxation, were entitled to be heard
in the councils of the king; and the charters given in the twelfth and
thirteenth centuries--from Henry I. to Henry III.--confirmed this
conviction. The resistance to the Stuarts was still based on the conviction
that direct taxation conferred political privileges, but now the claim to
speak in the great council of the realm had become a request to be listened
to by the king, and passed rapidly from that to a resolution that the king
should have no money from Parliament if he refused to listen. The practical
inconvenience of a king altogether at variance with Parliament was held to
be sufficient justification for getting rid of James II., and for hobbling
all future kings with the Bill of Rights.

The dethronement of aristocracy in favour of democracy has proceeded on
very similar lines. The mass of English people were far too wretched and
far too ignorant at the end of the eighteenth century to care anything
about abstract "rights of man," and only political philosophers and a few
artisans hoped for improvement in their condition by Parliamentary reform.
Agricultural England accepted the rule of landowners as an arrangement by
providence. It was the industrial revolution that shattered the feudal
notions of society, and created a manufacturing population which knew
nothing of lowly submission to pastors and masters. A middle-class emerged
from the very ranks of the working people. The factory system brought
fortunes to men who a few years earlier had been artisans, and to these new
capitalists in the nineteenth century the aristocracy in power was as
irksome as the Stuarts had been to the Whigs. If, as the Whigs taught,
those who paid the taxes were entitled to a voice in the government, then
the manufacturing districts ought to send representatives to Parliament. It
seemed monstrous that places like Manchester, Leeds, and Birmingham had no
one in the House of Commons to plead for the needs of their inhabitants.
The manufacturer wanted Parliamentary representation because he hoped
through Parliament to secure the abolition of the political disabilities of
Nonconformists, and to get financial changes made that would make the
conditions of trade more profitable. And he felt that it would be better
for the country if he and the class he represented could speak freely in
Parliament.

The workman wanted the vote because he had been brought to believe that,
possessing the vote, he could make Parliament enact laws that would lighten
the hardships of his life. The whole of the manufacturing class--capitalist
and workman alike--could see by 1820 that the House of Commons was the
instrument of the electorate, and that to get power they must become
electors. (Yet probably not one per cent. of them could express clearly any
theory of popular sovereignty.) The old Whig families, kept out of office
by the Tories whom George III. had placed in power, and who now controlled
the House of Commons, supported reform and the enfranchisement of the
middle class because they saw no way of getting back into power except by a
new electorate and a redistribution of Parliamentary seats. At the
beginning of the twentieth century the landowner, still Whig, though now,
as a general rule enrolled with the Unionist Party, has not been excluded
from political power, but the representatives of the middle-class and of
the working people are predominant in the House of Commons. The claim of
the House of Lords to reject the bills of the Commons has been, in our
time, subjected to the criticism formerly extended to the royal
prerogative, and an Act--the Parliament Act--has now been passed which
formally requires the Lords to accept, without serious amendment, every
Bill sent up from the Commons in three successive sessions.

The transition from monarchy to aristocracy in England was brought about at
the price of civil war. In many countries democracy has been born in
revolution, and the birth pains have been hard and bitter. But in England
in the nineteenth century democracy was allowed to come into being by
permission of the aristocracy, and has not yet reached its full stature. It
is true that violence, bloodshed, loss of life, and destruction of property
marked the passage of the great Reform Bill; that more than once riots and
defiance of law and order have been the expression of industrial
discontent; but on the whole the average Englishman is content to wait for
the redress of wrongs by Parliamentary action. Women have quite recently
defied the law, refused to pay taxes, and made use of "militant methods" in
their agitation for enfranchisement. But the women's plea has been that, as
they are voteless, these methods have been necessary to call attention to
their demands. Democratic advance has often been hindered and delayed by
government, and by a national disinclination from rapid political change;
but as the character of government has changed with the changed character
of the electorate and the House of Commons, so resistance to democracy has
always been abandoned when the advance was widely supported, and further
delay seemed dangerous to the public order.

The House of Lords is thus seen to yield to the popular representatives in
the House of Commons, and the government, dependent on the House of
Commons, to listen to the demand of women for enfranchisement.

While the House of Commons completes its assertion of political supremacy,
and insists on the absolute responsibility of the chosen representatives of
the electorate, the agitation for the enfranchisement of women is the
reminder that democracy has yet to widen its borders. Progress to democracy
in the last one hundred years is visible not only in the enlarged number of
enfranchised citizens, but in the general admission that every extension of
the franchise has been to the public good; not only in the fact that men of
all classes and trades now have their representatives in Parliament, but in
the very wide acknowledgment that women without votes cannot get that
attention by members of the House of Commons that is given to male
electors. That the majority of electors have expressed a decided opinion
that the power of the House of Lords should be curtailed, as the power of
the monarchy has been curtailed, and that the decisions of the House of
Commons are only to be corrected by the House of Commons, is evidence that
under our obviously imperfect Parliamentary system the will of the electors
does get registered on the Statute Book.

EDUCATION TO DEMOCRACY

Apart from the direct political education to democracy, it is well to note
the other agencies that have been at work, preparing men and women for the
responsible task of national self-government.

In the Middle Ages the religious guilds and the trade guilds, managed by
their own members, gave men and women a training in democratic government.
The parish, too, was a commune, and its affairs and finances were
administered by duly elected officers.[2]

But the guilds, with their numerous almshouses and hospitals, were all
suppressed early in Edward VI.'s reign, and their funds confiscated. As for
the parish, it was shorn of all its property, save the parish church, in
the same reign, and its old self-governing life dwindled away to the
election of churchwardens.

It was not till the beginning of the nineteenth century that the working
classes, by the formation of trade unions, once more took up the task of
education in self-government. From that time onward, through trade unions,
co-operative societies, and friendly societies, with their annual
conferences and congresses, a steady training in democracy has been
achieved; and our Labour Party of to-day, with its Members of Parliament,
its members of county and district councils, and its Justices of the Peace,
would hardly have been possible but for this training. Other agencies may
be mentioned. The temperance movement, the organisation of working-men's
clubs, and the local preaching of the Nonconformist Churches--particularly
the Primitive Methodist denomination--have all helped to educate workmen in
the conduct of affairs, and to create that sense of personal responsibility
which is the only guarantee of an honest democracy.

       *       *       *       *       *


CHAPTER I

THE EARLY STRUGGLES AGAINST THE ABSOLUTISM OF THE CROWN

THE GREAT CHURCHMEN

We are far from any thoughts of democracy in the early struggles against
the absolutism of the Crown. The old love of personal liberty that is said
to have characterised the Anglo-Saxon had no political outlet under Norman
feudalism. What we note is that three Archbishops of Canterbury were strong
enough and brave enough to stand up against the unchecked rule of kings,
and the names of these great Archbishops--Anselm, Thomas à Becket, and
Stephen Langton--are to be honoured for all time for the services they
rendered in the making of English liberties. Not one of the three was in
any sense a democrat. It is not till the latter part of the fourteenth
century that we find John Ball, a wandering, revolutionary priest, uttering
for the first time in England a democratic doctrine. Anselm, Becket, and
Langton did their work, as Simon of Montfort, and as Eliot and Hampden
worked later, not for the sake of a democracy, but for the restriction of
an intolerable autocracy. All along in English history liberties have been
gained and enlarged by this process of restriction, and it was only when
the powers of the Crown had been made subject to Parliament that it was
possible, at the close of the nineteenth century, for Parliament itself to
become converted from an assembly of aristocrats to a governing body that
really represented the nation.

But in considering the rise of democracy we can no more omit the early
struggles against the absolutism of the Crown than we can pass over Simon
of Montfort's Parliament, or the unsuccessful popular revolts, or the war
with Charles I., or the Whig revolution of 1688. They are all incidents of
pre-democratic days, but they are all events of significance. Democracy is
no new order of society, conceived in the fertile mind of man; it has been
slowly evolved and brought to birth after centuries of struggle, to be
tried as a form of government only when other forms are outgrown, and cease
to be acceptable.

All the great men--heroic and faulty--who withstood the tyranny of their
day, not only wrested charters from kings, they left a tradition of
resistance; and this tradition has been of incalculable service to a nation
seeking self-government. It is easy to dismiss the work of Anselm and
Becket as mere disputes between monarch and Churchman, to treat lightly the
battle for the Great Charter as a strife between king and barons. Just as
easy is it to regard the Peasant Revolt of the fourteenth century and Jack
Cade's rebellion in the fifteenth century as the tumults of a riotous mob.
The great point is to see clearly in all these contests, successful and
unsuccessful, the movement for liberty, for greater security and expansion
of life in England, and to note that only by a stern endurance and a
willingness not to bear an irksome oppression have our liberties been won.
In the winning of these liberties we have proved our fitness for democracy,
for a government that will allow the fullest measure of self-development.

Now, what was it that Anselm contended for, first with William II. and then
with Henry I.?

ARCHBISHOP ANSELM AND NORMAN AUTOCRACY

Anselm was sixty when, in 1093, William II. named him for the Archbishopric
of Canterbury. In vain Anselm, who was Abbot of the famous monastery of
Bec, in Normandy, protested that he was too old, and that his business was
not with high place and power in this world. The King seemed to be dying,
and the bishops gathered round the sick bed would not hear of any refusal
on Anselm's part. They pushed the pastoral staff into his hands, and
carried him off to a neighbouring church, while the people shouted "Long
live the bishop!"

What everybody felt was that with Anselm as Archbishop things might be
better in England, for Anselm's reputation stood very high. He had been the
friend of Lanfranc, the late Archbishop; he had been an honoured guest at
the Court of William the Conqueror; and he was known for his deep learning,
his sanctity of life, and simple, disinterested devotion to duty. It was
hoped that with a man of such holiness at Canterbury some restraint might
be placed on the lawless tyranny of the Red King. Lanfranc had been the
trusted counsellor and right hand of the Red King's father: why should not
Anselm bring back the son to the paths of decency--at least? The Archbishop
of Canterbury was the chief man in the realm next to the king, and for
three years since Lanfranc's death the see had been kept vacant that
William Rufus might enjoy its revenues for his own pleasure. It was not
unreasonable that men should look to the appointment of Anselm as the
beginning of an amendment in Church and State. The trouble was that William
stuck to his evil courses.

The rule of William the Conqueror had been stern and harsh, and his hand
had been heavy on the English people. But there had been law and justice in
the rule; religion and morality had been respected, and peace and security
obtained.

The rule of the Red King was not only grievous, it was arbitrary,
capricious, cruel, and without semblance of law. The austerity of the
Conqueror had been conspicuous; equally conspicuous was the debauchery of
his son. The Conqueror had been faithful and conscientious in seeing that
vacancies in the Church were filled up quickly and wisely. The Red King
preferred to leave bishoprics and churches empty so that he might annex the
profits. Lanfranc, a wise and just man, had been the Minister of the
Conqueror; the Red King made Ranulf (nicknamed the Torch or Firebrand)--a
clever, unprincipled clerk--Bishop of Durham and Justiciar. It was Ranulf
who did the King's business in keeping churches and bishoprics vacant, in
violation of law and custom; it was Ranulf who plundered the King's vassals
and the people at large by every kind of extortion, thwarted the protests
of Anselm, and encouraged William in his savage profligacies.

Meek and gentle as Anselm was, he had all the courage that comes of a lofty
sense of responsibility to God, and he stood before kings as the Hebrew
prophets of old had stood, calm and fearless. At Christmas, 1092, three
months before his nomination to the See of Canterbury, Anselm was in
England over the affairs of his monastery, and William invited him to Court
and treated him with great display of honour. Then some private talk took
place between the two, and Anselm said plainly that "Things were spoken
daily of the King, openly or secretly, by nearly all the men of his realm,
which were not seemly for the King's dignity." From that time Anselm stayed
in England, for William refused to give him leave to return to Normandy.

Then in March, 1093 came the King's sickness, which most men expected to be
mortal. Anselm was summoned, and on his arrival bade the King "make a clean
confession of all that he knows that he has done against God, and promise
that, should he recover, he will without pretence amend in all things. The
King at once agreed to this, and with sorrow of heart engaged to do all
that Anselm required and to keep justice and mercy all his life long. To
this he pledged his faith, and made his bishops witness between himself and
God, sending persons in his stead to promise his word to God on the altar.
An edict was written and sealed with the King's seal that all prisoners
should be set free in all his dominions, all debts forgiven, all offences
heretofore committed pardoned and forgotten for ever. Further, good and
holy laws were promised to the whole people, and the sacred upholding of
right and such solemn inquest into wrongdoing as may deter others."[3]

William did not die, and his repentance was short-lived; but the one act of
grace he did before leaving his sick bed was to fill up the empty throne at
Canterbury by the appointment of Anselm--Anselm's protests of unfitness
notwithstanding. Then, on the King's recovery, as though to make up for the
penitence displayed, all the royal promises of amendment were broken
without shame, and "all the evil which the King had wrought before he was
sick seemed good by the side of the wrong which he did when he was returned
to health." The prisoners who had been pardoned were sent back to prison,
the debts which had been cancelled were re-claimed, and all legal actions
which had been dropped were resumed. Anselm was now enthroned at
Canterbury, and his appointment could not be revoked; but the King was
quick to show his displeasure at the new Archbishop.

The first point raised by William was that those lands belonging to the See
of Canterbury, which had been made over to military vassals of the Crown
while the archbishopric was vacant, should remain with their holders.
Anselm said at once that this was impossible. He was responsible for the
administration of all the estates of Canterbury, and to allow these lands
to be alienated to the Crown was to rob the poor and needy who, it was
held, had a just claim on the property of the Church. Besides, Anselm saw
that the lands would never be restored once an Archbishop confirmed their
appropriation by the King's military tenants. There was no one in all
England save Anselm who dared withstand the Crown, and had he yielded on
this matter resistance to the tyranny of the Red King would only have been
harder on the next occasion.

Then came the question of a present of money to the King, the customary
offering. Anselm brought five hundred marks (£333), a very considerable sum
in those days, and William, persuaded by some of his courtiers that twice
the amount ought to have been given, curtly declined the present. Anselm,
who disliked the whole business of these gifts to the Crown, for he knew
that many a Churchman bought his office by promising a "free" gift after
institution, solemnly warned William that money given freely as his was
given was better than a forced tribute, and to this William answered that
he wanted neither the Archbishop's money nor his preaching or company.

Thereupon Anselm retired and gave the money to the poor, determined that
he, for his part, would make no attempt to purchase William's goodwill.
Henceforth William was equally determined that Anselm should have no peace
in England. It was hateful to the King that there should be anyone in the
realm who acknowledged a higher authority than the Crown, and Anselm made
it too plain that the Archbishop rested his authority not on the favour of
the Crown, but on the discipline of the Christian religion. William was
King of England indisputably, but there was a higher power than the King,
and that was the Pope. William himself never dreamed of denying the divine
authority of the Pope in spiritual matters; no one in all Christendom in
the eleventh and twelfth centuries questioned that at Rome was a court of
appeal higher than the courts of kings. Strong rulers like William the
Conqueror might decline to submit to Rome on a personal question of
marriage, but Rome was the recognised centre of religion, the headquarters
of the Christian Church, and the supreme court of appeal. Apart from Rome
there was no power that could curb the fierce unbridled tyranny of the
kings of the earth, and the power of Rome was a spiritual weapon, for the
Pope had no army to enforce his decisions. So Anselm, conscious of this
spiritual authority, refused to bow to the lawless rule of the Red King;
and his very attitude, while it encouraged men to lift up their hearts who
erstwhile had felt that it was hopeless and useless to strive against
William,[4] enraged the Red King to fury.

The things he wanted to forget were that the chief representative of the
Christian religion was a greater person than the King of England, and that
the Archbishop of Canterbury could be a Christian minister rather than a
King's man.[5] And Anselm was the constant witness to the Christian
religion, and, by his very presence, a rebuke to the crimes and cruelties
of the Court of the Red King. William actually wrote to the Pope, naturally
without any success, praying him to depose Anselm, and promising a large
annual tribute to Rome if the request was granted.

For years the uneven contest was waged. The bishops generally avoided
Anselm, and were only anxious to be accepted by the King as good servants
of the Crown, with the result that William despised them for their
servility. But the barons began to declare their respect for the brave old
man at Canterbury.

At last, when Anselm was summoned to appear before the King's Court, to "do
the King right," on a trumped-up charge of having failed to send an
adequate supply of troops for the King's service, he felt the position was
hopeless. Anselm's longing had been to labour with the King, as Lanfranc
had laboured, to promote religion in the country, and he had been
frustrated at every turn. The summons to the King's Court was the last
straw, for the defendant in this Court was entirely at the mercy of the
Crown. "When, in Anglo-Norman times you speak of the King's Court, it is
only a phrase for the King's despotism."[6] Anselm took no notice of the
King's summons, and decided to appeal to Rome. For a time William refused
permission for any departure from England, but he yielded in 1097, and
Anselm set out for Rome.

He stayed at Rome and at Lyons till William was dead, for the Pope would
not let him resign Canterbury, and could do nothing to bring the King to a
better mind. Then, on the urgent request of Henry I., he returned to
England, and for a time all went well. Henry was in earnest for the
restoration of law and religion in England, and his declaration, at the
very beginning of his reign--the oft-quoted "charter" of Henry I.--to stop
the old scandals of selling and farming out Church lands, and to put down
all unrighteousness that had been in his brother's time, was hailed with
rejoicing.

Anselm stood loyally by Henry over the question of his marriage with Edith
(who claimed release from vows taken under compulsion in a convent at
Romsey), and his fidelity at the critical time when Robert of Normandy and
the discontented nobles threatened the safety of the Crown was invaluable.
But Henry was an absolutist, anxious for all the threads of power to be in
his own hands; and just when a great Church Council at the Lateran had
decided that bishops must not be invested by kings with the ring and staff
of their office, because by such investiture they were the king's vassals,
Henry decided to invite Anselm to receive the archbishopric afresh from the
King's hands by a new act of investiture. To Anselm the abject submission
of the bishops to the Red King had been a painful spectacle; and now Henry
was making a demand that would emphasise the royal supremacy, and the
demand was intolerable and impossible. Again Anselm stood practically alone
in his resistance to the royal will, and again the question in dispute was
whether there was any power in England higher than the Crown. The papal
supremacy was no more under discussion than it had been under William. All
that Henry wanted was that the archbishops and bishops should acknowledge
that their authority came from the Crown; and at Henry's request Anselm,
then 70 years old, again journeyed to Rome to lay the matter before the
Pope.

Pope Paschal was fully alive to the mischief of making the bishops and
clergy mere officers of kings, and it was soon seen there could be no
dispensations from Rome even for Henry. All that the Pope would allow was
that bishops might do homage to the Crown for their temporal rights, and
with this Henry had to be content.

It was three years later before Anselm returned, and his course was now
nearly run. He died at peace on April 21st, 1109, having wrought to no
small purpose for religious liberty and the independence of the clergy.
(The demand for political and social independence always follows the
struggle for independence in religion.) Anselm spent the greater part of
his life after his enthronement at Canterbury in battling for independence
of the Crown; a century later Archbishop Stephen was to carry the battle
still further, and win wider liberties for England from the Crown.

Of Anselm's general love of liberty and hatred of all tyranny many stories
are told. One fact may be recalled. The Church Synod, which met at
Westminster in 1102, at Anselm's request, attacked the slave trade as a
"wicked trade used hitherto in England, by which men are sold like brute
animals," and framed a Church rule against its continuance.

In spite of this decree, serfdom lingered in England for centuries, but
hiring superseded open buying and selling of men. (The African slave trade
was the work of the Elizabethan seamen, and was excused, as slavery in the
United States was excused, by the Protestant Churches on the ground of the
racial inferiority of the negro.)

THOMAS À BECKET AND HENRY II.

Resistance to autocracy is often more needed against a strong and just king
than it is against an unprincipled profligate. Henry II.'s love of order
and peace, the strength and energy he spent in curtailing the power of the
barons, and in making firm the foundations of our national system of petty
sessions and assize courts have made for him an enduring fame. Henry II.
was a great lawyer; he was "the flower of the princes of his world," in
contemporary eyes; but it was as an autocrat he would rule. Against this
autocracy Thomas à Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury, protested, and the
protest cost him five years of exile, and finally his life. The manner of
his death earned for the Archbishop the title of martyr, and popular
acclamation required him to be canonised as a saint,[7] and his name to be
long cherished with deep devotion by the English people. Both Henry and
Thomas stand out honourably, but the former would have brought all England
under one great centralised authority, with the Crown not only predominant
but absolute in its supremacy, and the Archbishop contended for the great
mass of poor and needy people to mitigate the harshness of the law, and to
maintain the liberties of the Church against the encroachments of
sovereignty. "Nothing is more certain," as the old writer put it, "than
that both strove earnestly to do the will of God, one for the sake of his
realm, the other on behalf of his Church. But whether of the two was
zealous in wisdom is not plain to man, who is so easily mistaken, but to
the Lord, Who will judge between them at the last day."

Becket was the first English-born Archbishop of Canterbury since the Norman
Conquest. Henry, on his accession, clove to him in friendship, made him
Lord Chancellor in 1155, and on Archbishop Theobald's death, the monks of
Canterbury at once accepted Henry's advice and elected him to the vacant
see. Becket himself knew the King too well to desire the appointment, and
warned Henry not to press the matter, and prophesied that their friendship
would be turned to bitter enmity. But Henry's mind was made up. As
Chancellor, Becket had shown no ecclesiastical bias. He had taxed clergy
and laity with due impartiality, and his legal decisions had been given
without fear or favour. Henry counted on Becket to act with the same
indifference as Archbishop, to be the King's vicegerent during the royal
absence in France. And here Henry, wise as he was in many things, mistook
his man. As Chancellor of England Becket conceived his business to be the
administration of the laws: as Archbishop he was first and foremost the
champion of the Christian religion, the protector of the poor, and the
defender of the liberties of the Church. All unwilling, like his great
predecessor, St. Anselm, to become archbishop, from the hour of his
consecration to the See of Canterbury, in 1162, Becket was as firm as
Anselm had been in resisting the absolutism of the King. To the King's
extreme annoyance the Chancellorship was at once given up--the only
instance known of the voluntary resignation of the Chancellorship by layman
or ecclesiastic,[8] and all the amusements of the Court and the business of
the world were laid aside by the new archbishop. The care of his diocese,
the relief of the poor and the sick, and attendance at the sacred offices
of the Church were henceforth the work of the man who had been Henry's
best-loved companion, and within a year of his enthronement friendship with
the King was broken.

The first point at issue was whether there should be one common
jurisdiction in all the land, or whether the Church courts should still
exist. These Church courts had been set up by William the Conqueror and
Lanfranc, in order that the clergy should not be mixed up in ordinary law
matters, and should be excluded strictly from the common courts. No penalty
involving bloodshed could be inflicted in the Church courts, and all the
savage barbarities of mutilation, common enough as punishments in the
King's court, were forbidden. Henry II., apart from his strong desire for
centralisation in government, wanted these Church courts abolished, because
every clerk who offended against the law escaped ordinary punishment, no
matter what the charge might be. Archbishop Thomas saw that in the Church
courts there was some protection, not only for the clergy, but for all
minor ecclesiastics, and for widows and orphans, against the horrible legal
cruelties of the age. "It must be held in mind that the Archbishop had on
his side the Church or _Canon Law_, which he had sworn to obey, and
certainly the law courts erred as much on the side of harshness and cruelty
as those of the Church on that of foolish pity towards evil doers."[9]

Before this dispute had reached its climax Thomas had boldly taken measures
against some of the King's courtiers who were defrauding the See of
Canterbury; and he had successfully withstood Henry's plan for turning the
old Dane-geld shire tax, which was paid to the sheriff for the defence of
the country and the up-keep of roads, into a tax to be collected by the
Crown as part of the royal revenue. Thomas told the King plainly that this
tax was a voluntary offering to be paid to the sheriffs only "so long as
they shall serve as fitly and maintain and defend our defendants," and said
point blank that he would not suffer a penny to be taken off his lands for
the King's purposes. Henry was obliged to yield, and this is the first case
known of resistance to the royal will in the matter of taxation.

The case of clerical offenders, and the jurisdiction of the courts came
before a great council at Westminster in 1163. Henry declared that
criminous clerks should be deprived of their office in the Church courts,
and then handed over to the King's courts for punishment. Thomas replied
that the proposal was contrary to the religious liberties of the land, but
he met with little support from the rest of the bishops. "Better the
liberties of the Church perish than that we perish ourselves," they cried
in fear of the King. Henry followed up his proposal by calling on the
bishops to abide by the old customs of the realm, as settled by his
grandfather, Henry I., and to this they all agreed, adding "saving the
rights of our order."

A list of the old customs was drawn up, and sixteen _Constitutions_, or
articles, were presented to the bishops at the Great Council of Clarendon,
in January, 1164. To many of these Constitutions Thomas objected; notably
(1) That clerks were to be tried in the King's courts for offences of
common law. (2) That neither archbishops, bishops, nor beneficed clerks
were to leave the kingdom without royal permission. (This would not only
stop appeals to Rome, it would make pilgrimages or attendance at General
Councils impossible without the King's consent.) (3) That no member of the
King's household was to be excommunicated without the King's permission.
(4) That no appeals should be taken beyond the Archbishop's court, except
to be brought before the King. (This definite prohibition of appeals to
Rome left the King absolute master in England.) The last article declared
that neither serfs nor the sons of villeins were to be ordained without the
consent of the lord on whose land they were born. Against his own judgment
Thomas yielded to the entreaties of the bishops, and agreed to accept the
Constitutions of Clarendon, but no sooner had he done so than he bitterly
repented, and wrote off to the Pope acknowledging his mistake. Pope
Alexander III. was mainly anxious to prevent open hostilities between Henry
and the Archbishop, and wrote calmly that he was absolved, without
suggesting any blame to the King.

Henry now saw that the Archbishop, and only the Archbishop, stood in the
way of the royal will, and when another Council met at Northampton, in
October, 1164, the King was ready to drive Thomas out of office. Before
this Council Thomas was charged with having refused justice to John, the
Treasury-Marshall, and with contempt of the King's court, and was heavily
fined. It was difficult to get sentence pronounced, for the barons declined
to sit as judges on an archbishop; but at length, Henry, Bishop of
Winchester, on the King's order, declared the sentence. Henry followed up
the attack next day by calling upon Thomas to account for 30,000 marks
spent by him while Chancellor. In vain he proved that the Justiciar had
declared him free of all claims when he laid down the Chancellorship, that
the charge was totally unexpected; the King refused to stay the proceedings
unless Thomas would sign the Constitutions of Clarendon.

Consultation with the bishops brought no help. "The King has declared, so
it is said, that he and you cannot both remain in England as king and
archbishop. It would be much safer to resign everything and submit to his
mercy"; thus spake Hilary, of Chichester, and his fellow-bishops all urged
resignation or submission.

Two days later the Archbishop came into the Council in full robes with the
Cross in his hand. Earl Robert, of Leicester, rose to pass sentence upon
him and at once the Archbishop refused to hear him. "Neither law nor reason
permit children to pass sentence on their father," he declared. "I will not
hear this sentence of the King, or any judgment of yours. For, under God, I
will be judged by the Pope alone, to whom before you all here I appeal,
placing the Church of Canterbury under God's protection and the protection
of the Pope."

There were shouts of anger at these words, and some tore rushes from the
floor and flung at him, but no one dared to stop the Archbishop's passage
as he passed from the hall. It was useless to look for help or justice in
England, and that very night Thomas left England for Flanders to appeal to
Rome.

But Pope Alexander could do no more for Thomas than his predecessor had
done for Anselm; only he would not allow any resignation from Canterbury.
Henry himself appealed to the Pope in 1166, fearing excommunication by the
Archbishop; "thus by a strange fate it happened that the King, while
striving for those 'ancient customs' by which he endeavoured to prevent any
right of appeal (to the Pope), was doomed to confirm the right of appeal
for his own safety." The Pope did what he could to arrange a
reconciliation, but it was not till 1170 that the King, seriously alarmed
that Thomas would place England under an interdict, agreed to a
reconciliation.

On December 1st the exile was over, and Thomas landed at Sandwich, and went
at once to Canterbury. There were many who doubted whether there could be
lasting peace between the King and the Archbishop, and while the bishops
generally hated the Primate's return, the nobles spoke openly of him as a
traitor to the King.

The end was near. Thomas, asked to withdraw the sentence of excommunication
he had passed against the Archbishop of York and the Bishop of London and
Salisbury for violating the privileges of Canterbury, answered that the
matter must go before the Pope. The bishops, instead of going to Rome,
hastened to Henry, who was keeping his Court at Bur, in France.

Henry, at the complaint of the bishops, broke out into one of those
terrible fits of anger which overcame him from time to time, and four
knights left the Court saying, "All this trouble will be at an end when
Thomas is dead, and not before." On December 29th these knights were at
Canterbury, and at nightfall, just when vespers had begun, they slew
Archbishop Thomas by the great pillar in the Cathedral. So died this great
Archbishop for the liberties of the Church, and, as it seemed to him, for
the welfare of the people.

Henry was horrified at the news of the Archbishop's death, and hastened to
beg absolution from Rome for the rash words that had provoked the murder.
In the presence of the Papal legate he promised to give up the
Constitutions of Clarendon, nor in the remaining eighteen years of his
reign did Henry make any fresh attempt to bring the Church under the
subjection of the Crown.

To the great bulk of English people Thomas was a saint and martyr, and
numerous churches were dedicated in his name. More than three hundred years
later Henry VIII. decided that St. Thomas was an enemy of princes, that his
shrine at Canterbury must be destroyed, and his festival unhallowed. But
the fame of Thomas à Becket has survived the censure of Henry VIII., and
his name shines clearly across the centuries. Democracy has been made
possible by the willingness of brave men in earlier centuries to resist, to
the death, an absolutism that would have left England bound and chained to
the king's throne.

STEPHEN LANGTON AND JOHN

Stephen Langton was consecrated Archbishop of Canterbury in June, 1207, on
the nomination of Pope Innocent III.; the monks of Canterbury, who had
proposed their own superior, consenting to the appointment, for Langton had
a high reputation for learning and was known to be of exalted character.
But King John, who had wanted a man of his own heart for the
archbishopric--John of Gray, Bishop of Norwich, commonly spoken of as "a
servant of Mammon, and an evil shepherd that devoured his own sheep"--was
enraged, and refusing to acknowledge Langton, defied the Pope, drove the
monks out of the country, and declared that anyone who acknowledged Stephen
Langton as archbishop should be accounted a public enemy. So it came about
that the great English statesman who broke down the foulest and worst
tyranny the land had known, and won for England the Great Charter of its
liberties, was a nominee of the Pope, and was to find himself under the
displeasure of the Papal legate when the Charter had been signed! For six
years John kept Stephen out of Canterbury, while England lay under an
interdict, with its King excommunicate and outside the pale of the Church.
Most of the bishops fled abroad, "fearing the King, but afraid to obey him
for dread of the Pope," and John laid hands on Church property and filled
the royal treasury with the spoils of churchmen and Jews. But in 1213
John's position had become precarious, for the northern barons were
plotting his overthrow, and the Pope had absolved all his subjects from
allegiance, and given sentence that "John should be thrust from his throne
and another worthier than he should reign in his stead," naming Philip of
France as his successor. John was aware that he could not count on the
support of the barons in a war with France, and a prophecy of Peter, the
Wakefield Hermit, that the crown would be lost before Ascension Day, made
him afraid of dying excommunicate. Accordingly John decided to get the Pope
on his side. He agreed to receive Pandulf, the Papal legate; to acknowledge
Stephen; make good the damage done to the Church, and, in addition,
voluntarily ("of our own good free will and by the common counsel of our
barons") surrendered "to God and to the Holy Mother Church of Rome, and to
Pope Innocent and his Catholic successors," the whole realm of England and
Ireland, "with all rights thereunto appertaining, to receive them back and
hold them thenceforth as a feudatory of God and the Roman Church." He swore
fealty to the Pope for both realms, and promised a yearly tribute of 1,000
marks.

This abject submission to the Pope was a matter of policy. John cared
nothing for any appearance of personal or national humiliation, and as he
had broken faith with all in England, so, if it should suit his purpose,
would he as readily break faith with Rome. But the immediate advantage of
having the Pope for his protector seemed considerable. "For when once he
had put himself under apostolical protection and made his realms a part of
the patrimony of St. Peter, there was not in the Roman world a sovereign
who durst attack him or would invade his lands, in such awe was Pope
Innocent held above all his predecessors for many years past."[10]

Stephen landed in June, 1213, and at Winchester John was formally absolved
and the coronation oaths were renewed. It was very soon seen what manner of
man the Archbishop was. In August a great gathering of the barons took
place in St. Paul's, and there Langton recited the coronation charter of
Henry I., and told all those assembled that these rights and liberties were
to be recovered; and "the barons swore they would fight for these
liberties, even unto death if it were needful, and the Archbishop promised
that he would help with all his might." The weakness of the barons hitherto
had been their want of cohesion, their endless personal feuds, and the lack
of any feeling of national responsibility. Langton laboured to create a
national party and to win recognition of law and justice for all in
England; and the Great Charter was the issue of his work.

The state of things was intolerable. The whole administration of justice
was corrupt. The decisions of the King's courts were as arbitrary as the
methods employed to enforce sentence. Free men were arrested, evicted,
exiled, and outlawed without even legal warrant or the semblance of a fair
trial. All the machinery of government set up by the Norman kings, and
developed under Henry II., had, in John's hands, become a mere instrument
of despotic extortion, to be used against anybody and everybody, from earl
to villein, who could be fleeced by the King's servants.

John saw the tide rising against him, and endeavoured to divide barons from
Churchmen by proclaiming that the latter should have free and undisturbed
right of election when bishoprics and other ecclesiastical offices were
vacant. But the attempt failed. Langton was too resolute a statesman, and
his conception of the primacy of Canterbury was too high for any turning
back from the work he had set himself to accomplish. The rights of election
in the Church were important, but the restoration of justice and order and
the ending of tyranny were, in his eyes, hardly less important. John, who
had been at war in France, returned defeated from his last attempt to
recover for the Crown the lost Angevin provinces, to face a discontent that
was both wide and general. The people, and in especial the barons and
knights whom for fourteen years John had robbed, insulted, and spurned, and
whose liberties he had trampled upon, were ready at last under wise
leadership to end the oppression.

In November, 1214, the Archbishop saw that the time was come for action,
and again the barons met in council. Before the high altar in the Abbey
Church of St. Edmundsbury they swore that if the King sought to evade their
demand for the laws and liberties of Henry I.'s charter, they would make
war upon him until he pledged himself to confirm their rights in a charter
under royal seal. "They also agreed that after Christmas they would go all
together to the King and ask him for a confirmation of these liberties, and
that meanwhile they would so provide themselves with horses and arms that
if the King should seek to break his oath, they might, by seizing his
castles, compel him to make satisfaction. And when these things were done
every man returned to his own home."[11]

John now asked for time to consider these requests, and for the next six
months worked hard to break up the barons' confederacy, to gain friends and
supporters, and to get mercenaries from Poitou. It was all to no purpose.
As a last resource he took the Cross, expecting to be saved as a crusader
from attack, and at the same time he wrote to the Pope to help his faithful
vassal. The Pope's letters rebuking the barons for conspiracy against the
King were unheeded, and the mercenaries were inadequate when John was
confronted by the whole baronage in arms.

THE GREAT CHARTER

In May a list of articles to be signed was sent to John; and on his refusal
the barons formally renounced their homage and fealty and flew to arms.
John was forced to surrender before this host. On June 15th he met the
barons at Runnymede, between Staines and Windsor, and there, in the
presence of Archbishop Stephen and "a multitude of most illustrious
knights," sealed the Great Charter of the Liberties of England.

This Great Charter was in the main a renewal of the old rights and
liberties promised by Henry I. It set up no new rights, conferred no new
privileges, and sanctioned no changes in the Constitution. Its real and
lasting importance is due to its being a written document--for the first
time in England it was down in black and white, for all to read, what the
several rights and duties of King and people were, and in what the chief
points of the Constitution consisted.

[Illustration: MAGNA CHARTA

A facsimile of the Original in the British Museum.]

The Great Charter is a great table of laws. It marks the beginning of
written legislation, and anticipates Acts of Parliament. Unwritten laws and
traditions were not abolished: they remain with us to this day; but the
written law had become a necessity when "the bonds of unwritten custom"
failed to restrain kings and barons. The Great Charter also took into
account the rights of free men, and of the tenants of the King's vassals.
If the barons and knights had their grievances to be redressed, the commons
and the freeholding peasants needed protection against the lawless
exactions of their overlords.[12]

Sixty-three clauses make up Magna Charta, and we may summarise them as
follows:--

(1) The full rights and liberties of the Church are acknowledged; bishops
shall be freely elected, so that the Church of England shall be free.[13]

(2-8) The King's tenants are to have their feudal rights secured against
abuse. Widows--in the wardship of the Crown--are to be protected against
robbery and against compulsion to a second marriage.

(9-11) The harsh rules for securing the payment of debts to the Crown and
to the Jews (in whose debts the Crown had an interest) are to be relaxed.

(12-14) No scutage or aid (save for the three regular feudal aids--the
ransom of the King, the knighting of his eldest son, and the marriage of
his eldest daughter) is to be imposed except by the Common Council of the
nation; and to this Council archbishops, bishops, abbots, earls, and
greater barons are to be called by special writ, while all who held their
land directly from the King, and were of lesser rank, were to be summoned
by a general writ addressed to the sheriff of the county. Forty days'
notice of the meeting was to be given, and also the cause of the assembly.
The action of those who obeyed the summons was to be taken to represent the
action of all.[14] (This last clause is never repeated in later
confirmations of the Great Charter.)

(15-16) The powers of lords over their tenants are limited and defined.

(17-19) A Court of Common Pleas is to be held in some fixed place so that
suitors are not obliged to follow the King's Curia. Cases touching the
ownership of land are to be tried in the counties by visiting justices, and
by four knights chosen by the county.

(20-23) No freeman is to be fined beyond his offence, and the penalty is to
be fixed by a local jury. Earls and barons to be fined by their peers; and
clerks only according to the amount of their lay property.

(24-33) The powers of sheriffs, constables, coroners, and bailiffs of the
King are strictly defined. No sheriff is to be a justice in his own county.
Royal officers are to pay for all the goods taken by requisition; money is
not to be taken in lieu of service from those who are willing to perform
the service. The horses and carts of freemen are not to be seized for royal
work without consent. The weirs in the Thames, Medway, and other rivers in
England are to be removed.

(34-38) Uniformity of weights and measures is directed. Inquests are to be
granted freely. The sole wardship of minors who have other lords will not
be claimed by the King, except in special cases. No bailiff may force a man
to ordeal without witnesses.

(39-40) No free man is to be taken, imprisoned, ousted of his land,
outlawed, banished, or hurt in any way save by the judgment of his peers,
or the law of the land. The King is not to sell, delay, or deny right or
justice to anyone.

(41-42) Merchants may go out or come in without paying exorbitant customs.
All "lawful" men are to have a free right to pass in and out of England in
time of peace.

(44-47) An inquiry into the Forest Laws and a reform of the forest abuses
are promised. All forests made in present reign to be disforested, and all
fences in rivers thrown down.

(49-60) The foreign mercenaries of the King, all the detested gang that
came with horses and arms to the hurt of the realm, are to be sent out of
the country. The Welsh princes and the King of Scots (who had sided with
the barons) are to have justice done. A general amnesty for all political
offences arising from the struggle is made.

The last three articles appointed twenty-five barons, chosen out of the
whole baronage, to watch over the keeping of the Charter. They were
empowered to demand that any breach of the articles should at once be put
right, and, in default to make war on the King till the matter was settled
to their satisfaction. Finally there was the oath to be taken on the part
of the King, and on the part of the barons that the articles of the Charter
should be observed in good faith according to their plain meaning.

The Great Charter was signed, and then in a wild burst of rage John shouted
to his foreign supporters, "They have given me five-and-twenty over-kings!"

Within a week of Runnymede the Great Charter was published throughout
England, but neither King nor barons looked for peace. John was ready to
break all oaths, and while he set about increasing his army of mercenaries,
he also appealed to the Pope, as his overlord, protesting that the Charter
had been wrested from him by force.

Langton and the bishops left for Rome to attend a general council. Pope
Innocent declared the Charter annulled on the ground that both King and
barons had made the Pope overlord of England, and that consequently nothing
in the government could be changed without his consent. But with Langton,
the bishops, and the Papal legate all away at Rome, there was no one to
publish the Papal repudiation of the Charter, and the King and barons were
already at civil war. Pope Innocent III. was dead in the spring of 1216,
and John's wretched reign was over when the King lay dying at Newark in
October.

Stephen Langton was back again at Canterbury in 1217, and for eleven more
years worked with William the Marshall and Hubert of Burgh to maintain
public peace and order during Henry III.'s boyhood. At Oxford, in 1223, the
Charter was confirmed afresh, and two years later it was solemnly
proclaimed again when the King wanted a new subsidy. As long as the great
statesmen were in office Henry III. was saved from the weakness that cursed
his rule in England for nearly forty years. But William the Marshall died
in 1219, Archbishop Stephen in 1228, and Hubert was dismissed from the
justiciarship in 1234. A horde of greedy aliens from Poitou fed at the
Court of Henry and devoured the substance of England, until men arose, as
Langton had arisen, to demand the enforcement of charters and a just
administration of the laws.

Again a national party arises under the leadership of Simon of Montfort,
and in their victory over the King we get the beginnings of Parliamentary
government and popular representation. Every step forward is followed by
reaction, but the ground lost is recovered, and the next step taken marks
always a steady advance. Over and over again it has seemed that all the
liberties won in the past were lost, but looking back we can see that there
has been no lasting defeat of liberty. Only for a time have the forces of
oppression triumphed; it is soon found impossible in England to rest under
tyranny, or to govern without the consent of the governed. And every fresh
campaign for the restriction of kingly power brings us nearer the day of
democratic government.

       *       *       *       *       *


CHAPTER II

THE BEGINNING OF PARLIAMENTARY REPRESENTATION

DEMOCRACY AND REPRESENTATIVE GOVERNMENT

To-day democracy takes the form of representative government in civilised
countries; and for representative government contend the nations and
peoples seeking democracy.

The weak spots in all popular electoral systems are obvious, and the
election of representatives is always a subject for jokes and satire. It
could hardly be otherwise. For the best machinery in the world needs some
sort of sympathetic intelligence in the person who manipulates it, and the
machinery of popular elections can only be worked successfully with a large
measure of sincerity and good will. In the hands of the ambitious, the
self-seeking, and the unscrupulous, democratic politics are a machine for
frustrating popular representation, and as this state of things is always
prevalent somewhere, the humorist and the satirist naturally treat politics
without respect.

But in spite of all its faults and failings--glaring as these are--mankind
can at present devise nothing better than representative government, and
the abuse of power, the cunning, roguery, and corruption that too often
accompany popular elections and democratic administration, rather stir
honest men to action than make them incline to dictatorship and absolutism.

The present notion about representative government is that it makes
possible the expression of popular will, and can ensure the fulfilment of
that will. In the thirteenth century, when we get the beginnings of
representative government, there is no question of the people making
positive proposals in legislation, but there is a distinct belief that the
consent of the governed ought to be obtained by the ruling power. The mere
legal maxim from the Code of Justinian, that "that which touches all shall
be approved by all,"[15] "becomes transmuted by Edward I. into a great
political and constitutional principle."[16]

REPRESENTATIVE THEORY FIRST FOUND IN ECCLESIASTICAL ASSEMBLIES

More than a century earlier the first recorded appearances of town
representatives are found in the Spanish Cortes of Aragon and Castile.[17]
St. Dominic makes a representative form of government the rule in his Order
of Preaching Friars, each priory sending two representatives to its
provincial chapter, and each province sending two representatives to the
general chapter of the Order.

In England, Simon of Montfort, the son of Simon, the great warrior of the
Albigensian wars and the warm friend of Dominic, was in close association
with the friars. Hence there was nothing so very remarkable in Earl Simon
issuing writs for the Full Parliament of 1265 for the return of two
burgesses from each city and borough. He had seen representative government
at work among the friars in their chapters. Why should the plan be not
equally useful in the government of the country?[18] There is no evidence
that the summons to the burgesses was regarded as a revolutionary
proposal--so lightly comes political change in England.

The name of Simon of Montfort, Earl of Leicester, must always be associated
with the beginning of representative government in England. Let us recall
how it was the great Earl came to be in power in 1265.

THE MISRULE OF HENRY III.

Henry III. was always in want of money, and his crew of royal parasites
from Poitou drained the exchequer. Over and over again the barons called on
the King to get rid of his favourites, and to end the misrule that
afflicted the country; and the King from time to time gave promises of
amendment. But the promises were always broken. As long as Henry could get
money he was averse from all constitutional reform. In 1258 the barons were
determined that a change must be made. "If the King can't do without us in
war, he must listen to us in peace," they declared. "And what sort of peace
is this when the King is led astray by bad counsellors, and the land is
filled with foreign tyrants who grind down native-born Englishmen?"

William of Rishanger, a contemporary writer, expressed the popular feeling
in well-known verses:

  "The King that tries without advice to seek his country's weal
  Must often fail; he cannot know the wants and woes they feel.
  The Parliament must tell the King how he may serve them best,
  And he must see their wants fulfilled and injuries redressed.
  A King should seek his people's good and not his own sweet will.
  Nor think himself a slave because men hold him back from ill."

"The King's mistakes call for special treatment," said Richard, Earl of
Gloucester.

SIMON OF MONTFORT, LEADER OF THE NATIONAL PARTY

So that year a Parliament met in Oxford, in the Dominican Priory. It was
called the "Mad Parliament," because the barons all came to it fully armed,
and civil war seemed imminent. But Earl Simon and Richard of Gloucester
carried the barons with them in demanding reform. Henry was left without
supporters, and civil war was put off for five years.

The work done at this Parliament of Oxford was an attempt to make the King
abide loyally by the Great Charter; and the Provisions of Oxford, as they
were called, set up a standing council of fifteen, by whom the King was to
be guided, and ordered that Parliament was to meet three times a year: at
Candlemas (February 2nd), on June 1st, and at Michaelmas. Four knights were
to be chosen by the King's lesser freeholders in each county to attend this
Parliament, and the baronage was to be represented by twelve commissioners.

It was an oligarchy that the Provisions of Oxford established, "intended
rather to fetter the King than to extend or develop the action of the
community at large. The baronial council clearly regards itself as
competent to act on behalf of all the estates of the realm, and the
expedient of reducing the national deliberations to three sessions of
select committees betrays a desire to abridge the frequent and somewhat
irksome duty of attendance in Parliament rather than to share the central
legislative and deliberative power with the whole body of the people. It
must, however, be remembered that the scheme makes a very indistinct claim
to the character of a final arrangement."[19]

For a time things went better in England. The aliens at Henry's Court fled
over-seas, and their posts were filled by Englishmen. Parliament also
promised that the vassals of the nobles should have better treatment, and
that the sheriffs should be chosen by the shire-moots, the county
freeholders.

But Henry's promises were quickly broken, and war broke out on the Welsh
borders between Simon of Montfort's friend Llewellyn and Mortimer and the
Marchers. Edward, Prince of Wales, stood by the Provisions of Oxford for a
few years, but supported his father when the latter refused to re-confirm
the Provisions in 1263. As a last resource to prevent civil war, Simon and
Henry agreed to appeal to King Louis of France to arbitrate on the
fulfilment of the Provisions. The Pope had already absolved Henry from
obedience to the Provisions, and the Award of Louis, given at Amiens and
called the _Mise of Amiens_, was entirely in Henry's favour. It annulled
the Provisions of Oxford, left the King free to appoint his own ministers,
council, and sheriffs, to employ aliens, and to enjoy power uncontrolled.
But the former charters of the realm were declared inviolate, and no
reprisals were to take place.

To Simon and most of the barons the Award was intolerable, and when Henry
returned from France with a large force ready to take the vengeance which
the Award had forbidden, civil war could not be prevented. London rallied
to Simon, and Oxford, the Cinque Ports, and the friars were all on the side
of the barons against the King.

On May 14th, 1264, a pitched battle at Lewes ended in complete victory for
Simon, and found the King, Prince Edward, and the kinsmen and chief
supporters of the Crown prisoners in his hands.

Peace was made, and a treaty--the _Mise of Lewes_--drawn up and signed.
Once more the King promised to keep the Provisions and Charters, and to
dismiss the aliens. He also agreed to live thriftily till his debts were
paid, and to leave his sons as hostages with Earl Simon.

Simon at once set about the work of reform. The King's Standing, or Privy,
Council was reconstituted, and the Parliamentary Commissioners were
abolished, "for Simon held it as much a man's duty to think and work for
his country as to fight for it." A marked difference is seen between
Simon's policy at Oxford and the policy after Lewes. The Provisions of 1258
were restrictive. The Constitution of 1264 deliberately extended the limits
of Parliament. "Either Simon's views of a Constitution had rapidly
developed, or the influences which had checked them in 1258 were removed.
Anyhow, he had genius to interpret the mind of the nation, and to
anticipate the line which was taken by later progress."[20] What Simon
wanted was the approval of all classes of the community for his plans, and
to that end he issued writs for the Parliament--the _Full Parliament_--of
1265.

The great feature of this Parliament was that for the first time the
burgesses of each city and borough were summoned to send two
representatives. In addition, two knights were to come from each shire, and
clergy and barons as usual--though in the case of the earls and barons only
twenty-three were invited, for Simon had no desire for the presence of
those who were his enemies. The Full Parliament sat till March, and then
two months later war had once more blazed out. Earl Gilbert of Gloucester
broke away from Simon, Prince Edward escaped from custody, and these two
joined Lord Mortimer and the Welsh Marchers.

On August 4th Edward surprised and routed the army of the younger Simon
near Kenilworth, and then advanced to crush the great Earl, who was
encamped at Evesham, waiting to join forces with his son. All hope of
escape for Earl Simon was lost, and he was outnumbered by seven to two. But
fly he would not. One by one the barons who stood by Simon were cut down,
but though wounded and dismounted, the great Earl "fought on to the last
like a giant for the freedom of England, till a foot soldier stabbed him in
the back under the mail, and he was borne down and slain." For three hours
the unequal fight lasted in the midst of storm and darkness, and when it
was over the Grey Friars carried the mangled body of the dead Earl into the
priory at Evesham, and laid it before the high altar, for the poorer clergy
and the common people all counted Simon of Montfort for a saint.

"Those who knew Simon praise his piety, admire his learning, and extol his
prowess as a knight and skill as a general. They tell of his simple fare
and plain russet dress, bear witness to his kindly speech and firm
friendship to all good men, describe his angry scorn for liars and unjust
men, and marvel at his zeal for truth and right, which was such that
neither pleasure nor threats nor promises could turn him aside from keeping
the oath he swore at Oxford; for he held up the good cause 'like a pillar
that cannot be moved, and, like a second Josiah, esteemed righteousness the
very healing of his soul.' As a statesman he wished to bind the King to
rule according to law, and to make the King's Ministers responsible to a
Full Parliament; and though he did not live to see the success of his
policy, he had pointed out the way by which future statesmen might bring it
about."[21]

In the hour of Simon's death it might seem that the cause of good
government was utterly lost, and for a time Henry triumphed with a fierce
reaction. But the very barons who had turned against Simon were quite
determined that the Charters should be observed, and Edward was to show, on
his coming to the throne, that he had grasped even more fully than Simon
the notion of a national representative assembly, and that he accepted the
principle, "that which touches all shall be approved by all."

Henry III. died in 1272, and it was not till two years later that Edward I.
was back in England from the crusades to take up the crown. It was an age
of great lawgivers; an age that saw St. Louis ruling in France, Alfonso the
Wise in Castile, the Emperor Frederick II.--the Wonder of the World--in
Sicily. In England Edward shaped the Constitution and settled for future
times the lines of Parliamentary representative government.

EDWARD I.'S MODEL PARLIAMENT, 1295

For the first twenty years Edward's Parliaments were great assemblies of
barons and knights, and it was not till 1295 that the famous Model
Parliament was summoned. "It is very evident that common dangers must be
met by measures concerted in common," ran the writ to the bishops. Every
sheriff was to cause two knights to be elected from each shire, two
citizens from each city, two burgesses from each borough. The clergy were
to be fully represented from each cathedral and each diocese.

Hitherto Parliament, save in 1265, had been little else than a feudal
court, a council of the King's tenants; it became, after 1295, a national
assembly. Edward's plan was that the three estates--clergy, barons, and
commons: those who pray, those who fight, and those who work--should be
represented. But the clergy always stood aloof, preferring to meet in their
own houses of convocation; and the archbishops, bishops, and greater abbots
only attended because they were great holders of land and important feudal
lords.

Although the knights of the shire were of much the same class as the
barons, the latter received personal summons to attend, and the knights
joined with the representatives of the cities and boroughs. So the two
Houses of Parliament consisted of barons and bishops--lords spiritual and
lords temporal--and knights and commons; and we have to-day the House of
Lords and the House of Commons; the former, as in the thirteenth century,
lords spiritual and temporal, the latter, representatives from counties and
boroughs.

The admission of elected representatives was to move, in course of time,
the centre of government from the Crown to the House of Commons; but in
Edward I.'s reign Parliament was just a larger growth of the King's
Council--the Council that Norman and Plantagenet kings relied on for
assistance in the administration of justice and the collection of revenue.
The judges of the supreme court were always summoned to Parliament, as the
law lords sit in the Upper House to-day.

Money, or rather the raising of money, was the main cause for calling a
Parliament. The clergy at first voted their own grants to the Crown in
convocation, but came to agree to pay the taxes voted by Lords and Commons,
And Lords and Commons, instead of making separate grants, joined in a
common grant.

"And, as the bulk of the burden fell upon the Commons, they adopted a
formula which placed the Commons in the foreground. The grant was made by
the Commons, with the assent of the Lords spiritual and temporal. This
formula appeared in 1395, and became the rule. In 1407, eight years after
Henry IV. came to the throne, he assented to the important principle that
money grants were to be initiated by the House of Commons, were not to be
reported to the King until both Houses were agreed, and were to be reported
by the Speaker of the Commons' House. This rule is strictly observed at the
present day. When a money bill, such as the Finance bill for the year or
the Appropriation bill, has been passed by the House of Commons and agreed
to by the House of Lords, it is, unlike all other bills, returned to the
House of Commons."[22] The Speaker, with his own hand, delivers all money
bills to the Clerk of Parliaments, the officer whose business it is to
signify the royal assent.

In addition to voting money, the Commons, on the assembly of Parliament,
would petition for the redress of grievances. In the thirteenth and
fourteenth centuries, they were not legislators, but petitioners for
legislation; and as it often happened that their petitions were not granted
in the form they asked, it became a matter of bitter complaint that the
laws did not correspond with the petitions. Henry V. in 1414 granted the
request that "nothing should be enacted to the petition of the Commons
contrary to their asking, whereby they should be bound without their
assent"; and from that time it became customary for bills to be sent up to
the Crown instead of petitions, leaving the King the alternative of assent
or reaction.

THE NOBILITY PREDOMINANT IN PARLIAMENT

In the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, the power of Parliament was
strong enough to force the abdication of two kings--Edward II. and Richard
II.--but not strong enough to free the land of the turbulent authority of
the nobles. This authority went down in the struggles of the Lancastrians
and Yorkists.

"The bloody faction fights known as the Wars of the Roses brought the
Plantagenet dynasty to a close, weeded out the older nobility, and cleared
the way for a new form of monarchy."[23]

"The high nobility killed itself out. The great barons who adhered to the
'Red Rose' or the 'White Rose,' or who fluctuated from one to the other,
became poorer, fewer, and less potent every year. When the great struggle
ended at Bosworth, a large part of the greatest combatants were gone. The
restless, aspiring, rich barons, who made the civil war, were broken by it.
Henry VII. attained a kingdom in which there was a Parliament to advise,
but scarcely a Parliament to control."[24]

It is important to note the ascendancy of the barons in the medieval
Parliaments, and their self-destruction in the Wars of the Roses. Unless we
realise how very largely the barons were the Parliament, it is difficult to
understand how it came about that Parliament was so utterly impotent under
the Tudors. The Wars of the Roses killed off the mighty parliamentarians,
and it took a hundred years to raise the country landowners into a party
which, under Eliot, Hampden, and Pym, was to make the House of Commons
supreme.

"The civil wars of many years killed out the old councils (if I might so
say): that is, destroyed three parts of the greater nobility, who were its
most potent members, tired the small nobility and gentry, and overthrew the
aristocratic organisation on which all previous effectual resistance to the
sovereign had been based."[25]

To get an idea of the weakness of Parliament when the Tudors ruled, we have
but to suppose at the present day a Parliament deprived of all front-bench
men on both sides of the House, and of the leaders of the Irish and Labour
parties, and a House of Lords deprived of all Ministers and ex-Ministers.

THE MEDIEVAL NATIONAL ASSEMBLIES

Before passing to the Parliamentary revival of the seventeenth century,
there still remain one or two points to be considered relating to the early
national assemblies of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries.

(1) _Who were the electors in the Middle Ages?_--In the counties, all who
were entitled to attend and take part in the proceedings of the county
court had the right of electing the knight of the shire; and "it is most
probable, on the evidence of records, on the analogies of representative
usage, and on the testimony of later facts, that the knights of the shire
were elected by the full county court."[26]

The county court or shire-moot not only elected knights for Parliament; it
often enough elected them for local purposes as well. The county coroner
was elected in similar fashion by the county. All the chief tenants and
small freeholders were therefore the county electors; but the
tenants-in-chief (who held their lands from the Crown) and the knights of
the county had naturally considerably more influence than the smaller men.
"The chief lord of a great manor would have authority with his tenants,
freeholders as they might be, which would make their theoretical equality a
mere shadow, and would, moreover, be exercised all the more easily because
the right which it usurped was one which the tenant neither understood nor
cared for."[27]

It is difficult to decide to what extent the smaller freeholders could take
an active interest in the affairs of the county. As for the office of
knight of the shire, there was no competition in the thirteenth or
fourteenth century for the honour of going to Parliament, and it is likely
enough that the sheriff, upon whom rested the responsibility for the
elections, would in some counties be obliged to nominate and compel the
attendance of an unwilling candidate.

(2) _Payment of Parliamentary Representatives._--The fact that Members of
Parliament were paid by their constituents in the thirteenth, fourteenth,
and fifteenth centuries[28] made certain small freeholders as anxious not
to be included in the electorate as others were anxious not to be elected
to Parliament. It was recognised as "fair that those persons who were
excluded from the election should be exempt from contribution to the wages.
And to many of the smaller freeholders the exemption from payment would be
far more valuable than the privilege of voting."[29] But the Commons
generally petitioned for payment to be made by all classes of freeholders,
and when all allowance has been made for varying customs and for local
diversities and territorial influence, it is safe to take it that the
freeholders were the body of electors.

In 1430, the eighth year of Henry VI., an Act was passed ordering that
electors must be resident in the country, and must have free land or
tenement to the value of 40s. a year at least; and this Act was in
operation till 1831.

The county franchise was a simple and straightforward matter compared with
the methods of electing representatives from the boroughs. All that the
sheriff was ordered to do by writ was to provide for the return of two
members for each city or borough in his county; the places that were to be
considered as boroughs were not named. In the Middle Ages a town might have
no wish to be taxed for the wages of its Parliamentary representative, and
in that case would do its best to come to an arrangement with the sheriff.
(It was not till the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries that a
considerable increase of boroughs took place. The Tudors created "pocket"
and "rotten" boroughs in order to have the nominees of the Crown in
Parliament.) The size of the borough bore no relation to its membership
till the Reform Act of the nineteenth century, and as the selection of
towns to be represented was arbitrary, so the franchise in the towns was
equally unsettled. One or two places had a wide franchise, others confined
the vote to freemen and corporation members. But in spite of the
extraordinary vagaries of the borough franchise, and the arbitrary
selection of towns to be represented, these early medieval Parliaments
really did in an imperfect way represent the nation--all but the peasants
and artisans.

"Our English Parliaments were _un_symmetrical realities. They were elected
anyhow. The sheriff had a considerable licence in sending writs to
boroughs, that is, he could in part pick its constituencies; and in each
borough there was a rush and scramble for the franchise, so that the
strongest local party got it whether few or many. But in England at that
time there was a great and distinct desire to know the opinion of the
nation, because there was a real and close necessity. The nation was wanted
to do something--to assist the sovereign in some war, to pay some old debt,
to contribute its force and aid in the critical juncture of the time. It
would not have suited the ante-Tudor kings to have had a fictitious
assembly; they would have lost their sole _feeler_, their only instrument
for discovering national opinion. Nor could they have manufactured such an
assembly if they wished. Looking at the mode of election, a theorist would
say that these Parliaments were but 'chance' collections of influential
Englishmen. There would be many corrections and limitations to add to that
statement if it were wanted to make it accurate, but the statement itself
hits exactly the principal excellence of these Parliaments. If not 'chance'
collections of Englishmen, they were 'undesigned' collections; no
administrations made them, or could make them. They were bona fide
counsellors, whose opinion might be wise or unwise, but was anyhow of
paramount importance, because their co-operation was wanted for what was in
hand."[30]

(3) _The political position of women in the Middle Ages._--Abbesses were
summoned to the convocations of clergy in Edward I.'s reign. Peeresses were
permitted to be represented by proxy in Parliament. The offices of sheriff,
high constable, governor of a royal castle, and justice of the peace have
all been held by women. In fact, the lady of the manor had the same rights
as the lord of the manor, and joined with men who were freeholders in
electing knights of the shire without question of sex disability.[31] (A
survival of the medieval rights of women may be seen in the power of women
to present clergy to benefices in the Church of England.)

In the towns women were members of various guilds and companies equally
with men, and were burgesses and freewomen. Not till 1832 was the word
"male" inserted before "persons" in the charters of boroughs. "Never before
has the phrase 'male persons' appeared in any statute of the realm. By this
Act (the Reform Bill), therefore, women were technically disfranchised for
the first time in the history of the English Constitution. The privilege of
abstention was converted into the penalty of exclusion."

NO THEORY OF DEMOCRACY IN THE MIDDLE AGES

The years of Simon of Montfort and Edward I., which saw the beginnings of a
representative national assembly, were not a time of theoretical discussion
on political rights. The English nation, indeed, has ever been averse from
political theories. The notion of a carefully balanced constitution was
outside the calculations of medieval statesmen, and the idea of political
democracy was not included among their visions.

"Even the scholastic writers, amid their calculations of all possible
combinations of principles in theology and morals, well aware of the
difference between the 'rex politicus' who rules according to law, and the
tyrant who rules without it, and of the characteristics of monarchy,
aristocracy, and democracy, with their respective corruptions, contented
themselves for the most part with balancing the spiritual and secular
powers, and never broached the idea of a growth into political
enfranchisement. Yet, in the long run, this has been the ideal towards
which the healthy development of national life in Europe has constantly
tended, only the steps towards it have not been taken to suit a
preconceived theory."[32]

Each step towards democracy has been taken "to suit the convenience of
party or the necessities of kings, to induce the newly admitted classes to
give their money, to produce political contentment."

The only two principles that are apparent in the age-long struggles for
political freedom in England, that are recognised and acknowledged, are:
(1) That that which touches all shall be approved by all; (2) that
government rests on the consent of the governed. Over and over again these
two principles may be seen at work.

       *       *       *       *       *


CHAPTER III

POPULAR INSURRECTION IN ENGLAND

GENERAL RESULTS OF POPULAR RISINGS

Popular insurrection has never been successful in England; a violent death
and a traitor's doom have been the lot of every leader of the common people
who took up arms against the Government. The Civil War that brought Charles
I. to the scaffold, and the Revolution that deposed James II. and set
William of Orange on the throne, were the work of country gentlemen and
Whig statesmen, not of the labouring people.

But if England has never seen popular revolution triumphant and democracy
set up by force of arms, the earlier centuries witnessed more than one
effort to gain by open insurrection some measure of freedom for the working
people of the land.

No other way than violent resistance seemed possible to peasants and
artisans in the twelfth, fourteenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth centuries, if
their wrongs were to be mitigated and their rulers to be called to account.

Langton and Simon of Montfort had placed some check on the power of the
Crown, had laid the foundations of political liberty, and marked the road
to be travelled; but the lot of the labouring people remained unheeded and
voiceless in the councils of the nation. What could they do but take up
arms to end an intolerable oppression?

WILLIAM FITZOSBERT, CALLED LONGBEARD, 1196

The first serious protest came from the London workmen in the reign of
Richard I.; and FitzOsbert, known as Longbeard, was the spokesman of the
popular discontent.

The King wanted money, chiefly for his crusades in Palestine. He had no
inclination to personal government, and the business of ruling England was
in the hands of Hubert Walter, Archbishop of Canterbury, the justiciar or
King's lieutenant. Richard left England for Normandy in 1194, and returned
no more. England to him was a country where money could be raised, a
subject-province to be bled by taxation. Archbishop Hubert did his best to
satisfy the royal demands; and though by his inquisitions "England was
reduced to poverty from one sea to the other"--it is estimated that more
than £1,000,000 was sent to Richard in two years--the King was left
unsatisfied. The nation generally came to hate the Archbishop's taxation,
the Church suffered by his neglect, and he was finally compelled to resign
the justiciarship.

It was the London rising, under FitzOsbert's leadership, that directly
caused Archbishop Hubert's retirement, and FitzOsbert is notable as the
first of the long line of agitators.

The political importance of the capital was seen in the reigns of Cnut and
William the Conqueror. It was conspicuous on the arrival of Stephen in
1135, and its influence on national politics lasted till the middle of the
nineteenth century.[33]

By its charter London had the right of raising taxes for the Crown in its
own way, and in 1196 the method proposed by the Corporation provoked the
outbreak. "When the aldermen assembled according to usage in full hustings
for the purpose of assessing the taxes, the rulers endeavoured to spare
their own purses and to levy the whole from the poor" (Hoveden).

The poorer citizens were voteless, and the plan of the aldermen was to levy
the tallages per head, and not in proportion to the property of the
inhabitants. This meant, practically, that the whole, except a very small
fraction of the sum to be raised, must be paid by the working people.

Thereupon FitzOsbert protested, and the people rose in arms against the
demand.

FitzOsbert was an old crusader, and he was something of a lawyer and a
powerful speaker. Not a rich man by any means, FitzOsbert was yet a member
of the city council when, "burning with zeal for justice and fair play, he
made himself the champion of the poor." To his enemies he was a demagogue
and disreputable--so Ralph de Diceto, Dean of St. Paul's at that time,
described him. To others of more popular sympathies he was heroic and died
a martyr's death. Across the centuries he is seen as "an agitator"--the
first English agitator, the first man to stand up boldly against the
oppression of the common people. This palpably unjust taxation of the poor
was intolerable to FitzOsbert.

Fifteen thousand men banded themselves together in London under an oath
that they would stand by each other and by their leader; and FitzOsbert,
after a vain journey to Normandy to arouse Richard's attention to the
wrongs of his subjects, bade open defiance to the justiciar and his
tax-gatherers.

For a time the Archbishop's men were powerless, but weakness crept in
amongst the citizens, and the aldermen were naturally on the side of
constituted authority. FitzOsbert's success meant a readjustment of
taxation quite unpalatable to the City Fathers.

In the end FitzOsbert was deserted by all but a handful of his followers
and fled with them for sanctuary to the church of St. Mary-le-Bow in
Cheapside. Pursued by the officers of the law, FitzOsbert climbed up into
the tower of the church, and to fetch him down orders were given to set the
church on fire. This was done, and the only chance of life that now
remained for the rebels was to get out of the church and cut their way
through the ranks of their enemies.

At the church door FitzOsbert was struck down, and his little company
quickly overpowered.

Heavily chained, and badly wounded, FitzOsbert was carried off to the
Tower, to be tried and sentenced to a traitor's death without delay.

A few days later--it was just before Easter--FitzOsbert was stripped naked,
and dragged at the tail of a horse over the rough streets of London to
Tyburn. He was dead before the place of execution was reached, but the
body, broken and mangled, was hung up in chains under the gallows elm all
the same; and nine of his companions were hanged with him.

The very people who had fallen away from their leader in the day of his
need now counted FitzOsbert for a saint, and pieces of his gibbet and of
the bloodstained earth underneath the tree were carried away and treasured
as sacred relics. It was alleged that miracles were performed when these
relics were touched--so wide was now the popular reverence for the dead
champion of the poor.

Archbishop Hubert put a stop to this devotion by ordering sermons to be
preached on FitzOsbert's iniquities; and an alleged death-bed confession,
containing an account of many evil deeds, was published. It is likely
enough that an old crusader had plenty of sins to answer for, but
FitzOsbert's one crime before the law was that he had taught the people of
London to stand up and resist by force of arms the payment of taxes--taxes
levied with gross unfairness in popular judgment.

The monks of Canterbury, to whom the church of St. Mary-le-Bow in Cheapside
belonged, had long had their own quarrels with Archbishop Hubert, and on
this firing of their church, and the violation of sanctuary, they appealed
to the King and the Pope--Innocent III.--that Hubert should give up his
political work and attend exclusively to his duties as Archbishop. Both the
Pope and the great barons were against him, and in 1198 Archbishop Hubert
was compelled to resign the judiciarship.

THE PEASANT REVOLT AND ITS LEADERS, 1381

The great uprising of the peasants in 1381 was a very different matter from
the local insurrection made by FitzOsbert. Two centuries had passed, and in
those centuries the beginnings of representative government had been set up
and some recognition of the rights of the peasantry had been admitted in
the Great Charter.

The Peasant Revolt was national. It was carefully prepared and skilfully
organised, and its leaders were men of power and ability--men of character.
It was not only a definite protest against positive evils, but a vigorous
attempt to create a new social order--to substitute a social democracy for
feudal government.[34]

The old feudal order had been widely upset by the Black Death in 1349, and
the further ravages of pestilence in 1361 and 1369. The heavy mortality
left many country districts bereft of labour, and landowners were compelled
to offer higher wages if agriculture was to go on. In vain Parliament
passed Statutes of Labourers to prevent the peasant from securing an
advance. These Acts of Parliament expressly forbade a rise in wages; the
landless man or woman was "to serve the employer who shall require him to
do so, and take only the wages which were accustomed to be taken in the
neighbourhood two years before the pestilence." The scarcity of labour
drove landowners to compete for the services of the labourer, in spite of
Parliament.

Discontent was rife in those years of social change. The Statutes of
Labourers were ineffectual; but they galled the labourers and kept serfdom
alive. The tenants had their grievance because they were obliged to give
labour-service to their lords. Freehold yeomen, town workmen, and
shopkeepers were irritated by heavy taxation, and vexed by excessive market
tolls. All the materials were at hand for open rebellion, and leaders were
found as the days went by to kindle and direct the revolt.

John Ball, an itinerant priest, who came from St. Mary's, at York, and then
made Colchester the centre of his wanderings, spent twenty years organising
the revolt, and three times was excommunicated and imprisoned by the
Archbishop of Canterbury for teaching social "errors, schisms, and
scandals," but was in no wise contrite or cast down.

Chief of Ball's fellow-agitators were John Wraw, in Suffolk, Jack Straw, in
Essex--both priests these--William Grindcobbe, in Hertford, and Geoffrey
Litster, in Norfolk. In Kent lived Wat Tyler, of whom nothing is told till
the revolt was actually afire, but who at once was acknowledged leader and
captain by the rebel hosts.

From village to village went John Ball in the years that preceded the
rising, organising the peasants into clubs, and stirring the people with
revolutionary talk. It was the way of this vagrant priest to preach to the
people on village greens, and his discourses were all on the same text--"In
the beginning of the world there were no bondmen, all men were created
equal."[35] Inequalities of wealth and social position were to be ended:

"Good people, things will never go well in England, so long as goods be not
kept in common, and so long as there be villeins and gentlemen. By what
right are they whom men call lords greater folk than we? If all come from
the same father and mother, Adam and Eve, how can they say or prove that
they are better than we, if it be not that they make us gain for them by
our toil what they spend in their pride?

"They are clothed in velvet, and are warm in their furs and ermines, while
we are covered in rags. They have wine and spices and fair bread, and we
oatcake and straw, and water to drink. They have leisure and fine houses;
we have pain and labour, the wind and rain in the fields. And yet it is of
us and of our toil that these men hold their state.

"We are called slaves; and if we do not perform our services, we are
beaten, and we have not any sovereign to whom we can complain, or who
wishes to hear us and do us justice."

The poet, William Langland, in "Piers Plowman," dwelt on the social wrongs
of the time; Ball was fond of quoting from Langland, and of harping on a
familiar couplet:

  "When Adam delved and Eve span,
  Who was then the gentleman?"

Besides the sermons, some of the rhymed letters that John Ball sent about
the country have been preserved:

    "John Ball, Priest of St. Mary's, greets well all manner of men, and
    bids them in the name of the Trinity, Father, Son and Holy Ghost, to
    stand together manfully in truth. Help truth and truth shall help you.

  "John Ball greeteth you all,
    And doth to understand he hath rung your bell.
  Now with right and might, will and skill,
    God speed every dell.

  John the Miller asketh help to turn his mill right:
    He hath ground small, small:
    The King's Son of Heaven will pay for it all.
  Look thy mill go right, with its four sails dight.

  With right and with might, with skill and with will,
    And let the post stand in steadfastness.
  Let right help might, and skill go before will,
    Then shall our mill go aright;
  But if might go before right, and will go before skill,
    Then is our mill mis-a-dight."

Sometimes it is under the signature of John Trueman that John Ball writes:

  "Beware ere ye be woe;
  Know your friend from your foe;
  Take enough and cry "Ho!"
  And do well and better and flee from sin,
  And seek out peace and dwell therein--
    So biddeth John Trueman and all his fellows."

A more definite note was struck when it seemed to Ball and his colleagues
that the time was ripe for revolution, and the word was given that appeal
must be made to the boy-king--Richard was only eleven years old when he
came to the throne in 1377.

"Let us go to the King, and remonstrate with him, telling him we must have
it otherwise, or we ourselves shall find the remedy. He is young. If we
wait on him in a body, all those who come under the name of serf, or are
held in bondage, will follow us in the hope of being free. When the King
shall see us we shall obtain a favourable answer, or we must then ourselves
seek to amend our condition."

In another letter John Ball greets John Nameless, John the Miller, and John
Carter, and bids them stand together in God's name, and beware of guile: he
bids Piers Plowman "go to his work and chastise well Hob the Robber (Sir
Robert Hales, the King's Treasurer); and take with you John Trueman and all
his fellows, and look that you choose one head and no more."

These letters and the preaching were accepted by willing minds. John Ball
was in prison--in the jail of Archbishop Sudbury at Maidstone--in the
spring of 1381, but the peasants were organised and ready to revolt. If Wat
Tyler is the recognised leader of the rebel forces--"the one head"--John
Ball's was the work of preparing the uprising. The vagrant priest had rung
his bell to some purpose. In every county, from Somerset to York, the
peasants flocked together, "some armed with clubs, rusty swords, axes, with
old bows reddened by the smoke of the chimney corner, and odd arrows with
only one feather."

At Whitsuntide, early in June, 1381, the great uprising began--the Hurling
time of the peasants--long to be remembered with horror by the governing
classes. A badly ordered poll-tax was the match that kindled the fire.

The poll-tax was first levied, in 1377, on all over fourteen years of age.
Two years later it was graduated, every man and woman of the working class
being rated at 4d., and dukes and archbishops at £6 13s. 4d. More money was
still wanted by the Government, and early in 1381, John of Gaunt, the chief
man in the realm, called Parliament together at Northampton, and demanded
£160,000. Parliament agreed that £100,000 should be raised, and the
clergy--owning a third of the land--promised £60,000. But the only way of
raising the £100,000 that the Government could think of was by another
poll-tax, and this time everybody over fifteen was required to pay 1s. Of
course, the thing was impossible. In many parishes the mere returns of
population were not filled in; numbers evaded payment--which spelt ruin--by
leaving their homes. £22,000 was all that came to hand.

Then a man named John Legge came to the assistance of the Government, and
was appointed chief commissioner, and empowered to collect the tax.

The methods of Legge and his assistants provoked hostility, and when the
villagers of Fobbing, Corringham, and Stanford-le-Hope, in Essex, were
summoned to meet the commissioner at Brentwood, their reply was to kill the
collectors.

The Government answered this by sending down Chief Justice Belknap to
punish the offenders, but the people drove the chief justice out of the
place, and Belknap was glad to escape with his life.

This was on Whit-Sunday, June 2nd, and two days later the revolt had spread
to Kent; Gravesend and Dartford were in tumult. In one place Sir Simon
Burley, a friend of Richard II., seized a workman, claiming him as a
bondservant, and refusing to let him go under a fine of £300; while at
Dartford a tax-collector had made trouble by gross indecency to the wife
and daughter of one John Tyler.[36]

Thereupon this John Tyler, "being at work in the same town tyling of an
house, when he heard thereof, caught his lathing staff in his hand, and ran
reaking home; where, reasoning with the collector, who made him so bold,
the collector answered with stout words, and strake at the tyler; whereupon
the tyler, avoiding the blow, smote the collector with his lathing staff,
so that the brains flew out of his head. Wherethrough great noise arose in
the streets, and the poor people being glad, everyone prepared to support
the said John Tyler."

Now, with the fire of revolt in swift blaze, it was for the men of Kent to
see that it burned under some direction. Authority and discipline were
essential if the rising was not to become mob rule or mere anarchy, and if
positive and intolerable wrongs were to find remedies.

At Maidstone, on June 7th--after Rochester Castle had been stormed, its
prisoners set free and Sir John Newton its governor placed in safe
custody--Wat Tyler was chosen captain of the rebel hosts.

History tells us nothing of the antecedents of this remarkable man. For
eight days, and eight days only, he plays his part on the stage of national
events: commands with authority a vast concourse of men; meets the King
face to face, and wrests from sovereignty great promises of reform; orders
the execution of the chief ministers of the Crown, and then, in what seems
to be the hour of triumph, is struck to the ground, and goes to his death.

Under the accredited leadership of Wat Tyler the revolt at once took form.
Five days were spent in Kent before the peasant army marched on London. The
manor houses were attacked, and all rent rolls, legal documents, lists of
tenants and serfs destroyed. The rising was not a ferocious massacre like
the rising of the Jacquerie in France; there was no general massacre of
landlords, or reign of terror. The lawyers who managed the landowners'
estates were the enemy, and against them--against the instruments of
landlord tyranny--was the anger of the peasants directed. In the same way
John of Gaunt, and not the youthful King, was recognised as the evil
influence in government; and while a vow was taken by the men of Kent that
no man named "John" should be King of England, the popular cry was "King
Richard and the Commons," and all who joined in this were accounted friends
of the insurgent populace.

Blackheath was reached on the evening of June 12th, and early the following
morning, which was Corpus Christi Day, John Ball--released by a thousand
hands from his prison at Maidstone--preached to the multitude on the work
before them:

"Now is the opportunity given to Englishmen, if they do but choose to take
it, of casting off the yoke they have borne so long, of winning the freedom
they have always desired. Wherefore, let us take good courage and behave
like the wise husbandman of scripture, who gathered the wheat into his
barn, but uprooted and burned the tares that had half-choked the good
grain. The tares of England are her oppressive rulers, and the time of
harvest has come. Ours it is to pluck up these tares and make away with
them all--the wicked lords, the unjust judges, the lawyers--every man,
indeed, who is dangerous to the common good. Then shall we all have peace
in our time and security for the future. For when the great ones have been
rooted up and cast away, all will enjoy equal freedom and nobility, rank
and power shall we have in common."

Thirty-thousand men--yeomen, craftsmen, villeins, and peasants, were at
Blackheath, and these were soon joined by thousands more from Surrey.

John Wraw and Grindcobbe came to consult with Wat Tyler, and then returned
to Suffolk and Hertford to announce that the hour had come to strike.

The Marshalsea and King's Bench prisons, and the houses of ill-fame that
clustered round London Bridge, were destroyed before Wat Tyler led his army
into the city. An attempt to meet the King in conference was frustrated by
the royal counsellors. Richard came down in the royal barge as far as
Rotherhithe, but was dissuaded by Sir Robert Hales, and the Earls of
Suffolk, Salisbury, and Warwick, from "holding speech with the shoeless
ruffians."

Richard rowed back swiftly to the Tower, and Tyler and his army swept into
London. The city was in the hands of the rebel captain, but the citizens
welcomed the invaders, and offered bread and ale when Tyler proclaimed that
death would be the instant punishment for theft.

John of Gaunt's palace at the Savoy, on the river strand, was the first
place to be burnt; but Henry, Earl of Derby, John of Gaunt's son (eighteen
years later to reign as Henry IV., in place of Richard), was allowed to
pass out uninjured, and a wretched man caught in the act of stealing off
with a silver cup was promptly executed.

The Savoy destroyed, the Temple--a hive of lawyers--was the next to be
burnt, and before nightfall the Fleet Prison and Newgate had been
demolished.

Again Tyler demanded conference with the King, and Richard, lying in the
Tower with his counsellors, unable to prevent the work of conference,
boldly decided to come out and meet the rebels. Mile End was appointed for
the conference, and to Mile End Richard came with a very modest retinue.
The King was only fifteen, but he was the son of the Black Prince, and he
had both courage and cunning. He was fully aware that the people did not
lay on him responsibility for the sins of the Government. "If we measure
intellectual power by the greatest exertion it ever displays, rather than
by its average results, Richard II. was a man of considerable talents. He
possessed along with much dissimulation a decisive promptitude in seizing
the critical moment for action."[37]

At Mile End Tyler stated the grievances of the people. But first he asked
that all traitors should be put to death, and to this the King agreed.

Four positive articles of reform were put forward, and were at once
assented to by the King:--

1. A free and general pardon to all concerned in the rising.

2. The total abolition of all villeinage (forced labour) and serfdom.

3. An end to all tolls and market dues--"freedom to buy and sell in all
cities, burghs, mercantile towns, and other places within our kingdom of
England."

4. All customary tenants to become leaseholders at a fixed rental of
fourpence an acre for ever.

That all doubts might be removed, thirty clerks were set to work on the
spot to draw up charters of manumission, and banners were presented to each
county. At nightfall thousands returned home convinced that the old order
was ended, and that the Royal charters were genuine assurances of freedom.

But Tyler and the bulk of the men of Kent and Surrey remained in the city.
It seemed to Wat Tyler that better terms still were to be wrung from the
King. It looked that night as though the insurrection had triumphed
completely. Not only were the charters signed and the royal promises given,
but several in high office, whom Tyler held to be "traitors," had gone to
their doom. Sir Robert Hales, the Treasurer, Archbishop Sudbury, the
Chancellor--a gentle and kindly old man, "lenient to heretics"--John Legge,
the hated poll-tax commissioner, with Appleton, John of Gaunt's chaplain,
and Richard Lyons, a thoroughly corrupt contractor of Edward III.'s reign,
were all dragged out of the Tower and beheaded on Tower Hill on Friday,
June 15th.

On Tyler's request for another conference with Richard on the following
day, the King saw he had no choice but to yield. For the second time Wat
Tyler and Richard met face to face. The conference was held at Smithfield,
in the square outside St. Bartholomew's Priory. The King and two hundred
retainers, with Walworth the mayor, were on the east side of the square.
Tyler and his army were on the west side, opposite the Priory.

In the open space Tyler, mounted on a little horse, presented his demands;
more sweeping were the reforms now asked for than those of the previous
day.

"Let no law but the law of Winchester[38] prevail throughout the land, and
let no man be made an outlaw by the decree of judges and lawyers. Grant
also that no lord shall henceforth exercise lordship over the commons; and
since we are oppressed by so vast a horde of bishops and clerks, let there
be but one bishop in England; and let the property and goods of Holy Church
be divided fairly according to the needs of the people in each parish,
after in justice making suitable provision for the present clergy and
monks. Finally, let there be no more villeins in England, but grant us all
to be free and of one condition."

Richard answered that he promised readily all that was asked, "if only it
be consistent with the regality of my Crown." He then bade the commons
return home, since their requests had been granted.

Nobles and counsellors stood in sullen and silent anger at the King's
words, but were powerless to act. Tyler, conscious of victory, called for a
draught, and when his attendant brought him a mighty tankard of ale, the
rebel leader drank good-humouredly to "King Richard and the Commons." A
knight in the royal service, a "valet of Kent," was heard to mutter that
Wat Tyler was the greatest thief and robber in all the county, and Tyler
caught the abusive words, drew his dagger, and made for the man.

Mayor Walworth, as angry as the nobles at the King's surrender, shouted
that he would arrest all who drew weapons in the King's presence; and on
Tyler striking at him impatiently, the Mayor drew a cutlass and slashed
back, wounding Tyler in the neck so that he fell from his horse. Before he
could recover a footing, two knights plunged their swords into him, and
Tyler, mortally wounded, could only scramble on to his little horse, ride a
yard or two, call on the commons to avenge him, and then drop--a dead
man.[39]

And with Wat Tyler's death the whole rebellion collapsed. Confusion fell
upon the people at Smithfield. Some were for immediate attack, but when
Richard, riding out into the middle of the square, claimed that he and not
Tyler was their King, and bade them follow him into the fields towards
Islington, the great mass, convinced that Richard was honestly their
friend, obeyed. At nightfall they were scattered.

Wat Tyler's body was taken into the Priory, and his head placed on London
Bridge.

Walworth hastily gathered troops together, and the leader of the rebels
being dead, the nobles recovered their courage.

The rising was over; the people without leaders were as sheep for the
slaughter. Jack Straw was taken in London and hanged without the formality
of a trial; and on June 22nd Tresilian, the new chief justice, went on a
special assize to try the rebels, and "showed mercy to none and made great
havock." The King's charters and promises were declared null and void when
Parliament met, and some hundreds of peasants were hanged in various parts
of the country.

John Ball and Grindcobbe were hanged at St. Albans on July 15th, John Wraw
and Geoffrey Litster suffered the same fate.

All that Wat Tyler and the peasants had striven for was lost; but the
rising was not quite in vain. For one thing, the poll-tax was stopped, and
the end of villeinage was hastened.

The great uprising was the first serious demonstration of the English
people for personal liberty. "It taught the King's officers and gentle
folks that they must treat the peasants like men if they wished them to
behave quietly, and it led most landlords to set free their bondsmen, and
to take fixed money payments instead of uncertain services from their
customary tenants, so that in a hundred years' time there were very few
bondsmen left in England."[40]

JACK CADE, CAPTAIN OF KENT, 1450

To understand the character and importance of the rising of the men of Kent
under Jack Cade in 1450, the first thing to be done is to clear the mind of
Shakespeare's travesty in _King Henry VI._, Part 2. In the play the name of
Cade has been handed down in obloquy, and all that he and his followers
aimed at caricatured out of recognition. The part that Jack Cade really
played in national affairs has no likeness to the low comedy performance
imagined by Shakespeare.

It was a popular rising in 1450, but it was not a peasant revolt. Men of
substance in the county rallied to Cade's banner, and in many parishes in
Kent the village constable was employed to enrol willing recruits in the
army of disaffection.[41]

The peasant revolt was at bottom a social movement, fostered and fashioned
by preachers of a social democracy. Cade's rising was provoked by
misgovernment and directed at political reform. It was far less
revolutionary in purpose than the revolt that preceded it, or the rising
under Ket a hundred years later.

The discontent was general when Cade encamped on Blackheath with the
commons of Kent at the end of May, 1450. Suffolk, the best hated of Henry
VI.'s ministers, had already been put to death by the sailors of Dover, and
Lord Say-and-Sele, the Treasurer, was in the Tower under impeachment.
Ayscough, Bishop of Salisbury, another Minister, was hanged by his
infuriated flock in Wiltshire, and Bishop Moleyns, of Chichester, Keeper of
the Privy Seal, was executed in Portsmouth by a mob of sailors. Piracy
prevailed unchecked in the English Channel, and the highways inland were
haunted by robbers--soldiers back from France and broken in the wars.

The ablest statesman of the day, the Duke of York, was banished from the
royal council, and there was a wide feeling that an improvement in
government was impossible until York was recalled.

Whether Cade, who was known popularly as "Mortimer," was related to the
Duke of York, or was merely a country landowner, can never be decided. The
charges made against him after his death were not supported by a shred of
evidence, but it was necessary then for the Government to blacken the
character of the Captain of Kent for the utter discouragement of his
followers. All we _know_ of Cade is that by the Act of Attainder he must
have been a man of some property in Surrey--probably a squire or yeoman.

The army that encamped on Blackheath numbered over 40,000, and included
squires, yeomen, county gentlemen, and at least two notable ecclesiastics
from Sussex, the Abbot of Battle and the Prior of Lewes. The testimony to
Cade's character is that he was the unquestioned and warmly respected
leader of the host. The Cade depicted by his enemies--a dissolute,
disreputable ruffian--was not the kind of man to have had authority as a
chosen captain over country gentlemen and clerical landowners in the
fifteenth century.

The "Complaints" of the commons of Kent, drawn up at Blackheath and
forwarded to the King and his Parliament, then sitting at Westminster,
called attention in fifteen articles to the evils that afflicted the land.
These articles dealt with a royal threat to lay waste Kent in revenge for
the death of the Duke of Suffolk; the wasting of the royal revenue raised
by heavy taxation; the banishment of the Duke of York--"to make room for
unworthy ministers who would not do justice by law, but demanded bribes and
gifts"; purveyance of goods for the royal household without payment; arrest
and imprisonment on false charges of treason by persons whose goods and
lands were subsequently seized by the King's servants, who then "either
compassed their deaths or kept them in prison while they got possession of
their property by royal grant"; interference by "the great rulers of the
land" with the old right of free election of knights of the shire; the
mismanagement of the war in France. A certain number of purely local
grievances, chiefly concerned with the maladministration of justice, were
also included in the "Complaints," and five "Requests"--including the
abolition of the Statutes of Labourers--were added.

Henry and his counsellors dismissed these "Complaints" with contempt. "Such
proud rebels," it was said, "should rather be suppressed and tamed with
violence and force than with fair words or amicable answer." But when the
royal troops moved into Kent to disperse the rising, Cade's army cut them
to pieces at Sevenoaks. Henry returned to London; his nobles rode away to
their country houses; and after a fruitless attempt at negotiations by the
Duke of Buckingham and the Archbishop of Canterbury,[42] the King himself
fled to Kenilworth--leaving London at the mercy of the Captain of Kent.

On July 2nd Cade crossed London Bridge on horseback, followed by all his
army. The Corporation had already decided to offer no opposition to his
entry, and one of its members, Thomas Cocke, of the Drapers' Company--later
sheriff and M.P.--had gone freely between the camp at Blackheath and the
city, acting as mutual friend to the rebels and the citizens. All that Cade
required was that the foreign merchants in London should furnish him with a
certain number of arms and horses, "and 1,000 marks of ready money"; and
this was done. "So that it was found that the Captain and Kentishmen at
their being in the city did no hurt to any stranger."[43]

On the old London stone, in Cannon Street, Cade laid his sword, in the
presence of the Mayor and a great multitude of people, and declared
proudly: "Now is Mortimer lord of this city." Then at nightfall he went
back to his headquarters at the White Hart Inn in Southwark.

The following day Lord Say-and-Sele, and his son-in-law, Crowmer, Sheriff
of Kent, were removed by Cade's orders from the Tower to the Guildhall,
tried for "divers treasons" and "certain extortions," and quickly beheaded.
Popular hatred, not content with this, placed the heads of the fallen
minister and his son-in-law on poles, made them kiss in horrible embrace,
and then bore them off in triumph to London Bridge.

A third man, one John Bailey, was also hanged for being a necromancer; and
as Cade had promised death to all in his army convicted of theft, it fell
out that certain "lawless men" paid the penalty for disobedience, and were
hanged in Southwark--where the main body of the army lay.

Cade's difficulties began directly after Lord Say-and-Sele's execution.
London assented willingly to the death of an unpopular statesman, but had
no mind to provision an army of 50,000 men, and, indeed, had no liking for
the proximity of such a host. Plunder being forbidden, and strict
discipline the rule, the urgent question for the Captain of Kent was how
the army was to be maintained.

Getting no voluntary help from the city. Cade decided that he must help
himself. He supped with a worthy citizen named Curtis in Tower Street on
July 4th, and insisted before he left that Curtis must contribute money for
the support of the Kentish men. Curtis complied--how much he gave we know
not--but he resented bitterly the demand, and he told the tale of his
wrongs to his fellow-merchants.[44] The result was that while Cade slept in
peace as usual at the White Hart, the Mayor and Corporation took counsel
with Lord Scales, the Governor of the Tower, and resolved that at all costs
the Captain of Kent and his forces must be kept out of the city. After the
treatment of Curtis the fear was that disorder and pillage might become
common.

On the evening of Sunday, July 5th, and all through the night battle waged
hotly on London Bridge, which had been seized and fortified before Cade was
awake, and by the morning the rebels, unsuccessful in their attack, were
glad to agree to a hasty truce.

The truce gave opportunity to Cardinal Kemp, Archbishop of York, the King's
Chancellor, to suggest a lasting peace to Cade. Messengers were sent
speedily from the Tower, where Kemp, with Archbishop Stafford, of
Canterbury, had stayed in safety, to the White Hart, urging a conference
"to the end that the civil commotions and disturbances might cease and
tranquillity be restored."

Cade consented, and when the two Archbishops, with William Waynfleet,
Bishop of Winchester, met the Captain of Kent in the Church of St.
Margaret, Southwark, and promised that Parliament should give consideration
to the "Complaints" and "Requests" of the commons, and that a full pardon
should be given to all who would straightway return home, the rising was at
an end.

Cade hesitated, and asked for the endorsement of the pardons by Parliament;
but this was plainly impossible because Parliament was not sitting. The
bulk of the commons were satisfied with their pardons, and with the promise
that Parliament would attend to their grievances. There was nothing to be
gained, it seemed, by remaining in arms. On July 8th, the rebel army had
broken up, taking the road back to the towns and villages, farms and
cottages in Kent, Sussex, and Surrey. Cade, with a small band of followers,
retreated to Rochester, and attempted without success, the capture of
Queenborough Castle. On the news that the commons had dispersed from
Southwark, the Government at once took the offensive. Alexander Iden was
appointed Sheriff of Kent, and, marrying Crowmer's widow, subsequently
gained considerable profit. Within a week John Cade was proclaimed by the
King's writ a false traitor throughout the countryside, and Sheriff Iden
was in eager pursuit--for a reward of 1,000 marks awaited the person who
should take Cade, alive or dead.

Near Heathfield, in Sussex, Cade, broken and famished, was found by Iden,
and fought his last fight on July 13th, preferring to die sword in hand
than to perish by the hangman. He fell before the overwhelming odds of the
sheriff and his troops, and the body was immediately sent off to London for
identification.

The landlady of the White Hart proved the identity of the dead captain, and
all that remained was to stick the head on London Bridge, and dispatch the
quartered body to Blackheath, Norwich, Salisbury and Gloucester for public
exhibition.

Iden got the 1,000 marks reward and, in addition, the governorship of
Rochester Castle at a salary of £36 a year.

By special Act of Attainder all Cade's goods, lands and tenements were made
forfeit to the Crown, and statements were published for the discrediting of
Cade's life.

No allusion was made in Parliament to the "Complaints" and "Requests," and,
in spite of Cardinal Kemp's pardons, a number of men were hanged at
Canterbury and Rochester for their share in the rising, when Henry VI. and
his justices visited Kent in January, 1451.

The revolt failed to amend the wretched misrule. It remained for civil war
to drive Henry VI. from the throne, and make Edward IV. of York his
successor.

THE NORFOLK RISING UNDER ROBERT KET, 1549

A century after the rising of the commons of Kent came the last great
popular rebellion--the Norfolk Rising, led by Ket. This insurrection was
agrarian and social, concerned neither with the fierce theological
differences of the time, nor with the political rivalries of Protector
Somerset and his enemies in Edward VI.'s Council.

At the beginning of the sixteenth century England was in the main a nation
of small farmers, but radical changes were taking place, and these changes
meant ruin to thousands of yeomen and peasants.

The enclosure, by many large landowners, of the fields which for ages past
had been cultivated by the country people, the turning of arable land into
pasture, were the main causes of the distress.[45] Whole parishes were
evicted in some places and dwelling houses destroyed, and contemporary
writers are full of the miseries caused by these clearances.

Acts of Parliament were passed in 1489 and 1515, prohibiting the "pulling
down of towns," and ordering the reversion of pasture lands to tillage, but
the legislation was ignored. Sir Thomas More, in his "Utopia" (1516),
described very vividly what the enclosures were doing to rural England; and
a royal commission, appointed by Cardinal Wolsey, reported in the following
year that more than 36,000 acres had been enclosed in seven Midland
counties. In some cases, waste lands only were enclosed, but landowners
were ordered to make restitution within forty days where small occupiers
had been dispossessed. Royal commissions and royal proclamations were no
more effective than Acts of Parliament. Bad harvests drove the Norfolk
peasantry to riot for food in 1527 and 1529. The dissolution of the
monasteries in 1536 and 1539 abolished a great source of charity for the
needy, and increased the social disorder. Finally, in 1547, came the
confiscation by the Crown of the property of the guilds and brotherhoods,
and the result of this enactment can only be realised by supposing the
funds of friendly societies, trade unions, and co-operative societies taken
by Government to-day without compensation.

All that Parliament would do in the face of the starvation and unemployment
that brooded over many parts of England, was to pass penal legislation for
the homeless and workless--so that it seemed to many that Government had
got rid of Papal authority only to bring back slavery. The agrarian misery,
the violent changes in the order of church services and social customs, the
confiscation of the funds of the guilds, and the wanton spoiling of the
parish churches[46]--all these things drove the people to revolt.

Early in 1549 the men of Devon and Cornwall took up arms for "the old
religion," and were hanged by scores. In Norfolk that same year the rising
under Ket was social, and unconcerned with religion. Lesser agrarian
disturbances took place in Somerset, Lincoln, Essex, Kent, Oxford, Wilts,
and Buckingham. But there was no cohesion amongst the insurgents, and no
organisation of the peasants such as England had seen under John Ball and
his companion in 1381.

In 1548 Somerset, the Lord Protector, made an honest attempt to check the
rapacity of the landowners, but his proclamation and royal commission were
no more successful than Wolsey's had been, and only earned for the
Protector the hatred of the landowners.

The Norfolk Rising was the one strong movement to turn the current that was
sweeping the peasants into destitution. It failed, as all popular
insurrection in England has failed, and it brought its leaders to the
gallows; but for six weeks hope lifted its head in the rebel camp outside
Norwich, and many believed that oppression and misery were to end.

The rising began at Attleborough, on June 20th, when the people pulled down
the fences and hedges set up round the common fields. On July 7th, at the
annual feast in honour of St. Thomas of Canterbury, at Wymondham, a mighty
concourse of people broke down the fences at Hetherset, and then appealed
to Robert Ket and his brother to help them.

Both the Kets were well-known locally. They were men of old family,
craftsmen, and landowners. Robert was a tanner by trade, William a butcher.
Three manors--valued at 1,000 marks, with a yearly income of £50--belonged
to Robert Ket: church lands mostly, leased from the Earl of Warwick.

Ket saw that only under leadership and guidance could the revolt become a
revolution, and he threw himself into the cause of his poorer neighbours
with whole-hearted fervour. "I am ready," he said, "and will be ready at
all times to do whatever, not only to repress, but to subdue the power of
great men. Whatsoever lands I have enclosed shall again be made common unto
ye and all men, and my own hands shall first perform it. You shall have me,
if you will, not only as a companion, but as a captain; and in the doing of
the so great a work before us, not only as a fellow, but for a leader,
author, and principal."

Ket's leadership was at once acclaimed with enthusiasm by the thousand men
who formed the rebel band at the beginning of the rising. The news spread
quickly that Ket was leading an army to Norwich, and on July 10th, when a
camp was made at Eaton Wood, every hour brought fresh recruits. It is clear
from Ket's speeches, and from "The Rebels' Complaint," issued by him at
this time, that the aim of the leaders of the Norfolk Rising was not merely
to stop the enclosures, but to end the ascendancy of the landlord class for
all time, and to set up a social democracy.

Ket's address at Eaton Wood was revolutionary:

"Now are ye overtopped and trodden down by gentlemen, and put out of
possibility ever to recover foot. Rivers of riches run into the coffers of
your landlords, while you are par'd to the quick, and fed upon pease and
oats like beasts. You are fleeced by these landlords for their private
benefit, and as well kept under by the public burdens of State, wherein
while the richer sort favour themselves, ye are gnawn to the very bones.
Your tyrannous masters often implead, arrest, and cast you into prison, so
that they may the more terrify and torture you in your minds, and wind your
necks more surely under their arms.... Harmless counsels are fit for tame
fools; for you who have already stirred, there is no hope but in
adventuring boldly."

"The Rebels' Complaint" is equally definite and outspoken. It rehearsed the
wrongs of a landless peasantry, and called on the people to end these
wrongs by open rebellion. The note of social equality is struck by Ket
throughout the rising.

"The present condition of possessing land seemeth miserable and
slavish--holding it all at the pleasure of great men; not freely, but by
prescription, and, as it were, at the will and pleasure of the lord. For as
soon as any man offend any of these gorgeous gentlemen, he is put out,
deprived, and thrust from all his goods.

"The common pastures left by our predecessors for our relief and our
children are taken away.

"The lands which in the memory of our fathers were common, those are
ditched and hedged in and made several; the pastures are enclosed, and we
shut out.

"We can no longer bear so much, so great, and so cruel injury; neither can
we with quiet minds behold so great covetousness, excess, and pride of the
nobility. We will rather take arms, and mix Heaven and earth together, than
endure so great cruelty.

"Nature hath provided for us, as well as for them; hath given us a body and
a soul, and hath not envied us other things. While we have the same form,
and the same condition of birth together with them, why should they have a
life so unlike unto ours, and differ so far from us in calling?

"We see that things have now come to extremities, and we will prove the
extremity. We will rend down hedges, fill up ditches, and make a way for
every man into the common pasture. Finally, we will lay all even with the
ground, which they, no less wickedly than cruelly and covetously, have
enclosed.

"We desire liberty and an indifferent (or equal) use of all things. This
will we have. Otherwise these tumults and our lives shall only be ended
together."

But though the method was revolution and the goal social democracy, Ket was
no anarchist. He proved himself a strong, capable leader, able to enforce
discipline and maintain law and order in the rebel camp. And with all his
passionate hatred against the rule of the landlord, Ket would allow neither
massacre nor murder. There is no evidence that the life of a single
landowner was taken while the rising lasted, though many were brought
captive to Ket's judgment seat.

Ket was equally averse from civil war between the citizens of Norwich and
the peasants. When the Mayor of Norwich, Thomas Cod, refused to allow Ket's
army to cross the city on its way to Mousehold Heath, where the permanent
camp was to be made, Ket simply led his forces round by Hailsdon and
Drayton, and so reached Mousehold on July 12th without bloodshed. A week
later, and 20,000 was the number enrolled under the banner of revolt--for
the publication of "The Rebels' Complaint" and the ringing of bells and
firing of beacons roused all the countryside to action.

On Mousehold Heath, Robert Ket, with his brother William, gave directions
and administered justice under a great tree, called the Oak of Reformation.
Mayor Cod, and two other respected Norwich citizens, Aldrich, an alderman,
and Watson, a preacher, joined Ket's council, thinking their influence
might restrain the rebels from worse doings.

Twenty-nine "Requests and Demands," signed by Ket, Cod, and Aldrich, were
dispatched to the King from Mousehold, and this document gave in full the
grievances of the rebels. The chief demands were the cessation of
enclosures, the enactment of fair rents, the restoration of common fishing
rights, the appointment of resident clergymen to preach and instruct the
children, and the free election or appointment of local "commissioners" for
the enforcement of the laws. There was also a request "that all bond men
may be made free, for God made all free with His precious bloodshedding."

The only answer to the "Requests and Demands" was the arrival of a herald
with a promise that Parliament would meet in October to consider the
grievances, if the people would in the meantime quietly return to their
homes.

But this Ket would by no means agree to, and for the next few weeks his
authority was supreme in that part of the country. He established a rough
constitution for the prevention of mere disorder, two men being chosen by
their fellows from the various hundreds of the eastern half of the county.
A royal messenger, bearing commissions of the peace to certain country
gentlemen, falling into the hands of Ket, was relieved of his documents and
dismissed. Ket then put in these commissions the names of men who had
joined the rising, and declared them magistrates with authority to check
all disobedience to orders.

To feed the army at Mousehold, men were sent out with a warrant from Ket
for obtaining cattle and corn from the country houses, and "to beware of
robbing, spoiling, and other evil demeanours." No violence or injury was to
be done to "any honest or poor man." Contributions came in from the smaller
yeomen "with much private good-will," but the landowners generally were
stricken with panic, and let the rebels do what they liked. Those who could
not escape by flight were, for the most part, brought captive to the Oak of
Reformation, and thence sent to the prisons in Norwich and St. Leonard's
Hill.

Relations between Ket and the Norwich authorities soon became strained to
breaking point. Mayor Cod was shocked at the imprisonment of county
gentlemen, and refused permission for Ket's troops to pass through the city
on their foraging expeditions. Citizens and rebels were in conflict on July
21st, but "for lack of powder and want of skill in the gunners" few lives
were lost, and Norwich was in the hands of Ket the following day. No
reprisals followed; but a week later came William Parr, Marquis of
Northampton--Henry VIII.'s brother-in-law--with 1,500 Italian mercenaries
and a body of country squires, to destroy the rebels. Northampton's forces
were routed utterly, and Lord Sheffield was slain, and many houses and
gates were burnt in the city.

Then for three weeks longer Robert Ket remained in power, still hoping
against hope that some attention would be given by the Government to his
"Requests and Demands." Protector Somerset, beset by his own difficulties,
could do nothing for rebellious peasants, could not countenance in any way
an armed revolt, however great the miseries that provoked insurrection.
The Earl of Warwick was dispatched with 14,000 troops to end the
rebellion, and arrived on August 24th. For two days the issue seemed
uncertain--half the city only was in Warwick's hands. The arrival of 1,400
mercenaries--"lanzknechts," Germans mostly--and a fatal decision of the
rebels to leave their vantage ground at Mousehold Heath and do battle in
the open valley that stretched towards the city, gave complete victory to
Warwick.

The peasants poured into the meadows beyond Magdalen and Pockthorpe gates,
and were cut to pieces by the professional soldiers.

When all seemed over Ket galloped away to the north, but was taken, worn
out, at the village of Swannington, eight miles from Norwich.

More than 400 peasants were hanged by Warwick's orders, and their bodies
left to swing on Mousehold and in the city. Robert Ket and William Ket were
sent to London, and after being tried and condemned for high treason, were
returned to Norwich in December for execution. Robert Ket was hanged in
chains from Norwich Castle, and William suffered in similar fashion from
the parish church at Wymondham--to remind all people of the fate that
befall those who venture, unsuccessfully, to take up arms against the
government in power.

So the Norfolk Rising ended, and with it ended all serious popular
insurrection in England. Riots and mob violence have been seen even to our
own time, but no great, well-organised movement to overthrow authority and
establish a social democracy by force of arms has been attempted since
1549.

The characters of Robert Ket and his brother have been vindicated by time,
and the rebel leader is now recognised as a disinterested, capable,
high-minded man. Ket took what seemed to him the only possible course to
avert the doom of a ruined peasantry, and failed. But his courage and
humaneness are beyond question.[47]

The enclosures did not end with the sixteenth century, and for another one
hundred years complaints are heard of the steady depopulation of rural
England. In the eighteenth century came the second great series of
enclosures--the enclosing of the commons and waste spaces, by Acts of
Parliament. Between 1710 and 1867 no less than 7,660,439 acres were thus
enclosed.

To-day the questions of land tenure and land ownership are conspicuous
items in the discussion of the whole social question, for the relations of
a people to its land are of very first importance in a democratic state.

       *       *       *       *       *


CHAPTER IV

THE STRUGGLE RENEWED AGAINST THE CROWN

PARLIAMENT UNDER THE TUDORS

The English Parliament throughout the sixteenth century was but a servile
instrument of the Crown. The great barons were dead. Henry VIII. put to
death Sir Thomas More and all who questioned the royal absolutism.
Elizabeth, equally despotic, had by good fortune the services of the first
generation of professional statesmen that England produced. These
statesmen--Burleigh, Sir Nicholas Bacon, Sir Walter Mildmay, Sir Thomas
Smith, and Sir Francis Walsingham--all died in office. Burleigh was
minister for forty years, Bacon and Mildmay for more than twenty, and Smith
and Walsingham for eighteen years.[48]

[Illustration: SIR JOHN ELIOT]

Parliament was not only intimidated by Henry VIII. and Elizabeth, its
membership was recruited by nominees of the Crown.[49] And then it is also
to be borne in mind that both Henry and Elizabeth made a point of getting
Parliament to do their will. They governed through Parliament, and ruled
triumphantly, for it is only in the later years of Elizabeth that any
discontent is heard. The Stuarts, far less tyrannical, came to grief just
because they never understood the importance of Parliament in the eyes of
Englishmen in the middle ranks, and attempted to rule while ignoring the
House of Commons.

Elizabeth scolded her Parliaments, and more than once called the Speaker of
the House of Commons to account. The business of Tudor Parliaments was to
decree the proposals of the Crown. "Liberty of speech was granted in
respect of the aye or no, but not that everybody should speak what he
listed." Bacon declared, "the Queen hath both enlarging and restraining
power; she may set at liberty things restrained by statute and may restrain
things which be at liberty."

Yet Elizabeth raised no objection to the theory that Parliament was the
sovereign power, for her authority controlled Parliament; and so we have
Sir Thomas Smith writing in 1589 that "the most high and absolute power of
the realm of England consisteth in the Parliament."

In his "Ecclesiastical Polity," Book I. (1592-3), Hooker argues that "Laws
human, of what kind soever are available by consent," and that "laws they
are not which public approbation hath not made so"; deciding explicitly
that sovereignty rests ultimately in the people.

VICTORY OF PARLIAMENT OVER THE STUARTS

When he came to the throne in 1603, James I. was prepared to govern with
all the Tudor absolutism, but he had neither Elizabeth's Ministers--Cecil
excepted--nor her knowledge of the English mind. The English Parliament and
the English people had put up with Elizabeth's headstrong, capricious rule,
because it had been a strong rule, and the nation had obviously thriven
under it.[50] But it was another matter altogether when James I. was king.

"By many steps the slavish Parliament of Henry VIII. grew into the
murmuring Parliament of Queen Elizabeth, the mutinous Parliament of James
I., and the rebellious Parliament of Charles I."

The twenty years of James I.'s reign saw the preaching up of the doctrine
of the divine right of kings by the bishops of the Established Church, and
the growing resolution of the Commons to revive their earlier rights and
privileges. If the Stuarts were as unfortunate in their choice of Ministers
as Elizabeth had been successful, the House of Commons was equally happy in
the remarkable men who became its spokesmen and leaders. In the years that
preceded the Civil War--1626-42--three men are conspicuous on the
Parliamentary side: Eliot, Hampden, and Pym. All three were country
gentlemen, of good estate, high principle, and religious
convictions[51]--men of courage and resolution, and of blameless personal
character. Eliot died in prison, in the cause of good government, in 1632;
Hampden fell on Chalgrove Field in 1643.

As in earlier centuries the struggle in the seventeenth century between the
King and the Commons turned mainly on the questions of taxation. (At the
same time an additional cause of dispute can be found in the religious
differences between Charles I. and the Parliamentarians. The latter were
mainly Puritan, accepting the Protestantism of the Church of England, but
hating Catholicism and the high-church views of Laud. The King was in full
sympathy with high Anglicanism, and, like his father, willing to relax the
penal laws against Catholics.)

"By the ancient laws and liberties of England it is the known birthright
and inheritance of the subject that no tax, tallage, or other charge shall
be levied or imposed but by common consent in England, and that the
subsidies of tonnage and poundage are no way due or payable but by a free
gift and special Act of Parliament."

In these memorable words began the declaration moved by Sir John Eliot in
the House of Commons on March 2nd, 1629. A royal message ordering the
adjournment of the House was disregarded, the Speaker was held down in his
chair, and the key of the House of Commons was turned against intrusion,
while Eliot's resolutions, declaring that the privileges of the Commons
must be preserved, were carried with enthusiasm.

Charles answered these resolutions by dissolving Parliament and sending
Eliot to the Tower.

For eleven years no Parliament was summoned. Eliot refused altogether to
make any defence for his Parliamentary conduct. "I hold that it is against
the privilege of Parliament to speak of anything which is done in the
House," was his reply to the Crown lawyers. So Sir John Eliot was left in
prison, for nothing would induce this devoted believer in representative
government to yield to the royal pressure, and three years later, at the
age of forty-two, he died in the Tower.

It was for the liberties of the House of Commons that Eliot gave his life.
Wasted with sickness, health and freedom were his if he would but
acknowledge the right of the Crown to restrain the freedom of Parliamentary
debate; but such an acknowledgment was impossible from Sir John Eliot. For
him the privilege of the House of Commons in the matter of free speech was
a sacred cause, to be upheld by Members of Parliament, even to the death--a
cause every whit as sacred to Eliot as the divine right of kings was to the
Stuart bishops.

Charles hoped to govern England through his Ministers without interference
from the Commons, and only the need of money compelled him to summon
Parliament.

John Hampden saw that if the King could raise money by forced loans and
other exactions, the days of constitutional government were over. Hence his
memorable resistance to ship-money. London and the seaports were induced to
provide supplies for ships in 1634, on the pretext that piracy must be
prevented. In the following year the demand was extended to the inland
counties, and Hampden refused point blank to pay--though the amount was
only a matter of 20s.--falling back, in justification of his refusal, on
the Petition of Right--acknowledged by Charles in 1628--which declared that
taxes were not to be levied without the consent of Parliament. The case was
decided in 1636, and five of the twelve judges held that Hampden's
objection was valid. The arguments in favour of non-payment were circulated
far and wide, so that, in spite of the adverse verdict, "the judgment
proved of more advantage and credit to the gentleman condemned than to the
King's service."[52]

The personal rule of Charles and his Ministers, Laud and Strafford, came to
an end in the autumn of 1640, when there was no choice left to the King but
to summon Parliament, if money was to be obtained. Earlier in the year the
"Short Parliament" had met, only to be dissolved by the folly of the King
after a sitting of three weeks, because of its unwillingness to vote
supplies without the redress of grievances.

The disasters of the King's campaign against the Scots, an empty treasury,
and a mutinous army, compelled the calling of Parliament. But the temper of
the men who came to the House of Commons in November was vastly different
from the temper of the "Short Parliament."[53] For this was the famous
"Long Parliament" that assembled in the dark autumn days of 1640, and it
was to sit for thirteen years; to see the impeachment and execution of Laud
and Strafford, the trial and execution of the King, the abolition of
monarchy and the House of Lords, the establishment of the Commonwealth; and
was itself to pass away finally only before Cromwell's military
dictatorship.

Hampden was the great figure at the beginning of this Parliament. "The eyes
of all men were fixed upon him, as their _patriæ pater_, and the pilot that
must steer the vessel through the tempests and rocks which threatened it. I
am persuaded (wrote Clarendon) his power and interest at that time were
greater to do good or hurt than any man's in the kingdom, or than any man
of his rank hath had at any time; for his reputation of honesty was
universal, and his affections seemed so publicly guided, that no corrupt or
private ends could bias them."

Politically, neither Hampden nor Pym was Republican. Both believed in
government by King, Lords, and Commons; but both were determined that the
King's Ministers should be answerable to Parliament for the policy of the
Crown, and that the Commons, who found the money for government, should
have a definite say in the spending of that money. As for the royal claim
of "Divine right," and the royal view that held passive obedience to be the
duty of the King's subjects, and saw in Parliament merely a useful
instrument for the raising of funds to be spent by the royal pleasure
without question or criticism--these things were intolerable to Hampden,
Pym, and the men of the House of Commons. The King would not govern through
Parliament; the House of Commons could govern without a King. It was left
to the Civil War to decide the issue between the Crown and Parliament, and
make the House of Commons supreme.

Things moved quickly in the first year of the Long Parliament. The Star
Chamber and High Commission Courts were abolished. Strafford was impeached
for high treason, and executed on Tower Hill. Archbishop Laud lay in
prison, to be executed four years later. The Grand Remonstrance of the
House of Commons was presented to Charles in December, 1641. The demands of
the Commons in the Remonstrance were not revolutionary, but they stated,
quite frankly, the case for the Parliament. The main points were the need
for securities for the administration of justice, and an insistence on the
responsibility of the King's Ministers to the Houses of Parliament. The
Grand Remonstrance was only carried by eleven votes in the House of
Commons, 159 to 148, after wild scenes. "Some waved their hats over their
heads, and others took their swords in their scabbards out of their belts,
and held them by the pummels in their hands, setting the lower part on the
ground." Actual violence was only prevented "by the sagacity and great
calmness of Mr. Hampden, by a short speech."

Charles promised an answer to the deputation of members who waited upon him
with the Grand Remonstrance, and early in the new year came the reply. The
King simply demanded the surrender of five members--Pym, Hampden, Holles,
Strode, and Hazlerig--and their impeachment on the charge of high treason.
All constitutional law was set aside by a charge which proceeded personally
from the King, which deprived the accused of their legal right to a trial
by their peers, and summoned them before a tribunal which had no pretence
to a justification over them. On the refusal of the Commons to surrender
their members, Charles came in person to Westminster with 300 cavaliers to
demand their arrest. But the five members, warned of the King's venture,
were well out of the way, and rested safely within the City of London--for
the citizens were strongly for the Parliament. "It was believed that if the
King had found them there (in the House of Commons), and called in his
guards to have seized them, the members of the House would have endeavoured
the defence of them, which might have proved a very unhappy and sad
business."

As it was, Charles could only retire "in a more discontented and angry
passion than he came in." The step was utterly ill-advised. Parliament was
in no mood to favour royal encroachments, and the citizens of London were
at hand, with their trained bands, to protect forcibly members of the House
of Commons.

War was now imminent. "The attempt to seize the five members was
undoubtedly the real cause of the war. From that moment, the loyal
confidence with which most of the popular party were beginning to regard
the King was turned into hatred and suspicion. From that moment, the
Parliament was compelled to surround itself with defensive arms. From that
moment, the city assumed the appearance of a garrison.

"The transaction was illegal from beginning to end. The impeachment was
illegal. The process was illegal. The service was illegal. If Charles
wished to prosecute the five members for treason, a bill against them
should have been sent to a grand jury. That a commoner cannot be tried for
high treason by the Lords at the suit of the Crown, is part of the very
alphabet of our law. That no man can be arrested by the King in person is
equally clear. This was an established maxim of our jurisprudence even in
the time of Edward the Fourth. 'A subject,' said Chief Justice Markham to
that Prince, 'may arrest for treason; the King cannot; for, if the arrest
be illegal, the party has no remedy against the King.'"[54]

Both King and Parliament broke rudely through all constitutional precedents
in their preparations for hostilities.

The King levied troops by a royal commission, without any advice from
Parliament, and Pym got an ordinance passed, in both Houses, appointing the
Lords-Lieutenant of the counties to command the Militia without warrant
from the Crown.

A last attempt at negotiations was made at York, in April, when the
proposals of Parliament--nineteen propositions for curtailing the power of
the Monarchy in favour of the Commons--were rejected by Charles with the
words: "If I granted your demands, I should be no more than the mere
phantom of a king."

By August, Charles had raised the royal standard at Nottingham, and war was
begun.

Five years later and Charles was a prisoner, to die in 1649 on the
scaffold. That same year monarchy and the House of Lords were abolished by
law; the Established Church had already fallen before the triumphant arms
of the Puritans.

Then, in 1653, the House of Commons itself fell--expelled by Cromwell; and
the task of the Lord Protector was to fashion a constitution that would
work.[55] What happened was the supremacy of the army. Parliament,
attenuated and despised, contended in vain against the Protector. On
Cromwell's death, and the failure of his son, Richard, the army declared
for Charles II., and there was an end to the Commonwealth.

THE DEMOCRATIC PROTEST--LILBURNE

In all these changes the great mass of the people had neither part nor lot;
and the famous leaders of the Parliamentary Party, resolute to curtail the
absolutism of the Crown, were no more concerned with the welfare of the
labouring people than the barons were in the time of John. The labouring
people--generally--were equally indifferent to the fortunes of Roundheads
and Cavaliers, though the townsmen in many places held strong enough
opinions on the matters of religion that were in dispute.[56]

That the common misery of the people was not in any way lightened by
Cromwell's rule we have abundant evidence, and it cannot be supposed that
the substitution of the Presbyterian discipline for episcopacy in the
Church, and the displacement of Presbyterians by Independents, was likely
to alleviate this misery.

Taxation was heavier than it had ever been before, and in Lancashire,
Westmorland, and Cumberland the distress was appalling.

Whitelocke, writing in 1649,[57] notes "that many families in Lancashire
were starved." "That many in Cumberland and Westmorland died in the
highways for want of bread, and divers left their habitations, travelling
with their wives and children to other parts to get relief, but could find
none. That the committees and Justices of the Peace of Cumberland signed a
certificate, that there were 30,000 families that had neither seed nor
bread-corn, nor money to buy either, and they desired a collection for
them, which was made, but much too little to relieve so great a multitude."

Cromwell, occupied with high affairs of State, had neither time nor
inclination to attend to social reform. Democracy had its witnesses;
Lilburne and the Levellers made their protest against military rule, and
were overpowered; Winstanley and his Diggers endeavoured to persuade the
country that the common land should be occupied by dispossessed peasants,
and were quickly suppressed.

Lilburne was concerned with the establishment of a political democracy,
Winstanley with a social democracy, and in both cases the propaganda was
offensive to the Protector.

Had Cromwell listened to Lilburne, and made concessions towards democracy,
the reaction against Puritanism and the Commonwealth might have been
averted.[58]

John Lilburne had been a brave soldier in the army of the Parliament in the
early years of the Civil War, and he left the army in 1645 with the rank of
Lieutenant-Colonel (and with £880 arrears of pay due to him) rather than
take the covenant and subscribe to the requirements of the "new model."

The monarchy having fallen, Lilburne saw the possibilities of tyranny in
the Parliamentary government, and at once spoke out. With considerable
legal knowledge, a passion for liberty, clear views on democracy, an
enormous capacity for work, and great skill as a pamphleteer, Lilburne was
not to be ignored. The Government might have had him for a supporter; it
unwisely decided to treat him as an enemy, and for ten years he was an
unsparing critic, his popularity increasing with every fresh pamphlet he
issued--and at every fresh imprisonment.

Lilburne urged a radical reform of Parliament and a general manhood
suffrage in 1647, and the "Case for the Army," published by the Levellers
in the same year, on the proposal of the Presbyterian majority in
Parliament that the army should be disbanded, demanded the abolition of
monopolies, freedom of trade and religion, restoration of enclosed common
lands, and abolition of sinecures.

Both Cromwell and Ireton were strongly opposed to manhood suffrage, and
Cromwell--to whom the immediate danger was a royalist reaction--had no
patience for men who would embark on democratic experiments at such a
season.

Lilburne and the Levellers were equally distrustful of Cromwell's new
Council of State. "We were ruled before by King, Lords, and Commons, now by
a General, Court-martial, and Commons; and, we pray you, what is the
difference?" So they put the question in 1648.

To Cromwell the one safety for the Commonwealth was in the loyalty of the
army to the Government. To Lilburne the one guarantee for good government
was in the supremacy of a Parliament elected by manhood suffrage. He saw
plainly that unless steps were taken to establish democratic institutions
there was no future for the Commonwealth; and he took no part in the trial
of Charles I., saying openly that he doubted the wisdom of abolishing
monarchy before a new constitution had been drawn up.

But Lilburne overestimated the strength of the Leveller movement in the
army, and the corporals who revolted were shot by sentence of
courts-martial.[59]

In vain the democratic troopers argued, "the old king's person and the old
lords are but removed, and a new king and new lords with the commons are in
one House, and so we are under a more absolute arbitrary monarchy than
before." The Government answered by clapping Lilburne in the Tower, where,
in spite of a petition signed by 80,000 for his release, he remained for
three months without being brought to trial. Released on bail, Lilburne,
who from prison had issued an "Agreement of the Free People," calling for
annual parliaments elected by manhood suffrage and the free election of
unendowed church ministers in every parish, now published an "Impeachment
for High Treason against Oliver Cromwell and his son-in-law, James Ireton,"
and declared that monarchy was preferable to a military despotism. At last,
brought to trial on the charge of "treason," Lilburne was acquitted with "a
loud and unanimous shout" of popular approval.[60] "In a revolution where
others argued about the respective rights of King and Parliament, he spoke
always of the rights of the people. His dauntless courage and his power of
speech made him the idol of the mob."[61]

Lilburne was again brought to trial, in 1653, and again acquitted, with
undiminished enthusiasm. But "for the peace of the nation," Cromwell
refused to allow the irrepressible agitator to be at large, and for two
years Lilburne, "Free-born John," was kept in prison. During those years
all power in the House of Commons was broken by the rule of the Army of the
Commonwealth, and Parliament stood in abject submission before the Lord
Protector. Only when his health was shattered, and he had embraced Quaker
principles, was Lilburne released, and granted a pension of 40s. a week.
The following year, at the age of 40, Lilburne died of consumption--brought
on by the close confinement he had suffered. A year later, 1658, and
Cromwell, by whose side Lilburne had fought at Marston Moor, and against
whose rule he had contended for so many a year, was dead, and the
Commonwealth Government was doomed.

WINSTANLEY AND "THE DIGGERS"

The "Digger" movement was a shorter and much more obscure protest on behalf
of the people than Lilburne's agitation for democracy; but it is notable
for its social significance.

While Lilburne strove vigorously for political reforms that are still
unaccomplished, Gerrard Winstanley preached a revolutionary gospel of
social reform--as John Ball and Robert Ket had before him. But Winstanley's
social doctrine allowed no room for violence, and included the
non-resistance principles that found exposition in the Society of Friends.
Hence the "Diggers," preaching agrarian revolution; but denying all right
to force of arms, never endangered the Commonwealth Government as Lilburne
and the Levellers did.

Free Communism was the creed of more than one Protestant sect in the
sixteenth century, and the Anabaptists on the Continent had been
conspicuous for their experiments in community of goods and anarchist
society.

Winstanley confined his teaching and practice to common ownership of land,
pleading for the cultivation of the enclosed common lands, "that all may
feed upon the crops of the earth, and the burden of poverty be removed."
There was to be no forcible expropriation of landlords.

"If the rich still hold fast to this propriety of Mine and Thine, let them
labour their own lands with their own hands. And let the common people,
that say the earth is _ours_, not _mine_, let them labour together, and eat
bread together upon the commons, mountains, and hills.

"For as the enclosures are called such a man's land, and such a man's land,
so the Commons and Heath are called the common people's. And let the world
see who labour the earth in righteousness, and those to whom the Lord gives
the blessing, let them be the people that shall inherit the earth.

"None can say that their right is taken from them. For let the rich work
alone by themselves; and let the poor work together by themselves."[62]

With the common ownership and cultivation of land, an end was to be made of
all tyranny of man over his fellows.

[Illustration: JOHN HAMPDEN

_After the Engraving by G. Houbraken._]

"Leave off dominion and lordship one over another; for the whole bulk of
mankind are but one living earth. Leave off imprisoning, whipping, and
killing, which are but the actings of the curse. Let those that have
hitherto had no land, and have been forced to rob and steal through
poverty; henceforth let them quietly enjoy land to work upon, that everyone
may enjoy the benefit of his creation, and eat his own bread with the sweat
of his own brow."

Winstanley's argument was quite simple:

"If any man can say that he makes corn or cattle, he may say, _That is
mine_. But if the Lord made these for the use of His creation, surely then
the earth was made by the Lord to be a Common Treasury for all, not a
particular treasury for some."

Two objections were urged against private property in land:

"First, it hath occasioned people to steal from one another. Secondly, it
hath made laws to hang those that did steal. It tempts people to do an evil
action, and then kills them for doing it." It was a prolific age for
pamphlets, the seventeenth century; the land teemed with preachers and
visionaries, and Winstanley's writings never attracted the sympathy that
was given to the fierce controversialists on theological and political
questions.

Only when Winstanley and his Diggers set to work with spade and shovel on
the barren soil of St. George's Hill, in Surrey, in the spring of 1649, was
the attention of the Council of State called to the strange proceedings.
The matter was left to the local magistrates and landowners, and the
Diggers were suppressed. A similar attempt to reclaim land near
Wellingboro' was stopped at once as "seditious and tumultuous." It was
quite useless for Winstanley to maintain that the English people were
dispossessed of their lands by the Crown at the Norman Conquest, and that
with the execution of the King the ownership of the Crown lands ought to
revert to the people; Cromwell and the Council of State had no more
patience with prophets of land nationalisation than with agitators of
manhood suffrage. Indeed, the Commonwealth Government never took the
trouble to distinguish between the different groups of disaffected people,
but set them all down as "Levellers," to be punished as disturbers of the
peace if they refused to obey authority.

Winstanley's last pamphlet was "True Magistracy Restored," an open letter
to Oliver Cromwell, 1652, and after its publication Gerrard Winstanley and
his Diggers are heard of no more.

To-day both Lilburne and Winstanley are to be recalled because the
agitation for political democracy is always with us, and the question of
land tenure is seen to be of profound importance in the discussion of
social reform. No democratic statesman in our time can propose an
improvement in the social condition of the people without reference to the
land question, and no social reformer of the nineteenth century has had
more influence or been more widely read and discussed than Henry
George--the exponent of the Single Tax on Land Values.

Winstanley was very little heeded in his own day, but two hundred and fifty
years later the civilised countries of the earth are found in deep debate
over the respective rights of landowners and landless, and the relation of
poverty to land ownership. State ownership, taxation of land values,
peasant proprietorship, co-operative agriculture--all have their advocates
to-day, but to Winstanley's question whether the earth was made "for to
give ease to a few or health to all," only one answer is returned.

THE RESTORATION

Under the Commonwealth the landowners were as powerful as they had been
under the monarchy. Enclosures continued. Social reform was not
contemplated by Cromwell nor by Councils of State; democracy was equally
outside the political vision of government. Church of England ministers
were dispossessed in favour of Nonconformists, Puritanism became the
established faith, Catholicism remained proscribed.

The interest in ecclesiastical and theological disputes was considerable,
and Puritanism was popular with large numbers of the middle-class. But to
the mass of the people Puritanism was merely the suppression of further
liberties, the prohibition of old customs, the stern abolition of Christmas
revels and May-day games.

Lilburne did his best to get Cromwell to allow the people some
responsibility in the choice of its rulers. Winstanley proposed a remedy
for the social distress. To neither of these men was any concession made,
and no consideration was given to their appeals.

Hence the bulk of the nation, ignored by the Commonwealth Government, and
alienated by Puritanism, accepted quite amiably--indeed, with
enthusiasm--the restoration of the monarchy on the return of Charles II.,
and was unmoved by the royalist reaction against Parliamentary Government
that followed on the Restoration.

The House of Commons itself, when Monk and his army had gone over to the
side of Charles, voted, in the Convention Parliament of 1660, "that
according to the ancient and fundamental laws of this Kingdom, the
government is, and ought to be, by King, Lords, and Commons," and Charles
II. was received in London with uproarious enthusiasm.

The army was disbanded; a royalist House of Commons restored the Church of
England and ordered general acceptance of its Prayer Book. Puritanism,
driven from rule, could only remain in power in the heart and conscience of
its adherents.

To the old Commonwealth man it might seem, in the reaction against
Puritanism, and in the popularity of the King, that all that had been
striven for in the civil war had been lost, in the same way as after the
death of Simon of Montfort it might have appeared that "the good cause" had
perished with its great leader. In reality the House of Commons stood on
stronger ground than ever, and was to show its strength when James II.
attempted to override its decisions. In the main the very forms of
Parliamentary procedure were settled in the seventeenth century, to remain
undisturbed till the nineteenth century. "The Parliamentary procedure of
1844 was essentially the procedure on which the House of Commons conducted
its business during the Long Parliament."[63]

With Charles II. on the throne the absolutism of the Crown over Parliament
passed for ever from England. Cromwell had set up the supremacy of the army
over the Commons: this, too, was gone, never to be restored.

Henceforth government was to be by King, Lords, and Commons; but
sovereignty was to reside in Parliament. Not till a century later would
democracy again be heard of, and its merits urged, as Lilburne had urged
them under the Commonwealth.

       *       *       *       *       *


CHAPTER V

CONSTITUTIONAL GOVERNMENT--ARISTOCRACY TRIUMPHANT

GOVERNMENT BY ARISTOCRACY

For nearly two centuries--from 1660 to 1830--England was governed by an
aristocracy of landowners. Charles II. kept the throne for twenty-five
years, because he had wit enough to avoid an open collision with
Parliament. James II. fled the country after three years--understanding no
more than his father had understood that tyranny was not possible save by
consent of Parliament or by military prowess. At the Restoration the royal
prerogative was dead, and nothing in Charles II.'s reign tended to diminish
the power of Parliament in favour of the throne. Charles was an astute
monarch who did not wish to be sent on his travels again, and consequently
took care not to outrage the nation by any attempt upon the liberties of
Parliament. Only by the Tudor method of using Parliament as the instrument
of the royal will could James II. have accomplished the constitutional
changes he had set his heart upon. In attempting to set up toleration for
the Roman Catholic religion, and in openly appointing Roman Catholics to
positions of importance, James II. set Parliament at defiance and ranged
the forces of the Established Church against himself. The method was doomed
to failure. "None have gone about to break Parliaments but in the end
Parliaments have broken them."[64] In any case the notion of restoring
political liberty to Catholics was a bold endeavour in 1685. Against the
will of Parliament the project was folly. To overthrow the rights of
corporations and of the Universities, and to attempt to bully the Church of
England, after Elizabeth's fashion, at the very beginning of a pro-Catholic
movement, was to provoke defeat.

Parliament decided that James II. had "abdicated," when, deserted by
Churchill, he fled to France, and William and Mary came to the throne at
the express invitation of Parliament. The Revolution completed the work of
the Long Parliament by defining the limits of monarchy, and establishing
constitutional government. It was not--this Revolution, of 1688--the first
time Parliament had sanctioned the deposing of the King of England and the
appointment of his successor,[65] but it was the last. Never again since
the accession of William and Mary have the relations of the Crown and
Parliament been strained to breaking point; never has the supremacy of
Parliament been seriously threatened by the power of the throne.

The full effects of the Revolution of 1688 were seen in the course of the
next fifty years. Aristocracy, then mainly Whig, was triumphant, and under
its rule, while large measures of civil and religious liberty were passed,
the condition of the mass of labouring people was generally wretched in the
extreme. The rule of the aristocracy saw England become a great power among
the nations of the world, and the British Navy supreme over the navies of
Europe; but it saw also an industrial population, untaught and uncared for,
sink deeper and deeper into savagery and misery. For a time in the
eighteenth century the farmer and the peasant were prosperous, but by the
close of that century the small farmer was a ruined man, and with the
labourer was carried by the industrial revolution into the town. The worst
times for the English labourer in town and country since the Norman
Conquest were the reign of Edward VI. and the first quarter of the
nineteenth century.

The development of our political institutions into their present form; the
establishment of our Party system of government by Cabinet, and of the
authority of the Prime Minister; the growth of the supreme power of the
Commons, not only over the throne but over the Lords also: these were the
work of the aristocracy of the eighteenth century, and were attained by
steps so gradual as to be almost imperceptible. No idea of democracy guided
the process; yet our modern democratic system is firm-rooted upon the
principles and privileges of the Constitution as thus established. Social
misery deepened, without check from the politicians; and the most
enlightened statesmen of the Whig regime were very far from our present
conceptions of the duties and possibilities of Parliament.

CIVIL AND RELIGIOUS LIBERTY

James II. was tumbled from the throne for his vain attempt to establish
toleration for Catholics and Nonconformists without consent of Parliament.
Yet the Whig aristocracy which followed, while it did nothing for
Catholics, laid broad principles of civil and religious liberty for
democracy to build upon.[66]

The Declaration of Right, presented by Parliament to William and Mary on
their arrival in London, was turned into the Bill of Rights, and passed
into law in 1689. It stands as the last of the great charters of political
liberty, and states clearly both what is not permitted to the Crown, and
what privileges are allowed to the people.

Under the Bill of Rights the King was denied the power of suspending or
dispensing, of levying money, or maintaining a standing army without
consent of Parliament. The people were assured of the right of the subject
to petition the Crown, and of the free election of representatives in
Parliament, and of full and free debate in Parliament. Any profession of
the Catholic religion, or marriage with a Catholic, disqualified from
inheritance to or possession of the throne.

So there was an end to the doctrine of the Divine Right of Kings, and four
hundred non-juring clergymen--including half-a-dozen bishops--of the Church
of England were deprived of their ecclesiastical appointments for refusing
to accept the accomplished fact, and acknowledge William III. as the lawful
King of England. By making William King, to the exclusion of the children
of James II., Parliament destroyed for all future time in England the
belief in the sacred character of kingship. The King was henceforth a part
of the constitution, and came to the throne by authority of Parliament, on
conditions laid down by Parliament.

William resented the decision of Parliament not to allow the Crown a
revenue for life, but to vote an annual supply; but the decision was
adhered to, and has remained in force ever since. The Mutiny Act, passed
the same year, placed the army under the control of Parliament, and the
annual vote for military expenses has, in like manner, remained.

The Toleration Act (1689) gave Nonconformists a legal right to worship in
their own chapels, but expressly excluded Unitarians and Roman Catholics
from this liberty. Life was made still harder for Roman Catholics in
England by the Act of 1700, which forbade a Catholic priest, under penalty
of imprisonment for life, to say mass, hear confessions, or exercise any
clerical function, and denied the right of the Catholic laity to hold, buy
or inherit property, or to have their children educated abroad. The
objection to Roman Catholics was that their loyalty to the Pope was an
allegiance to a "foreign" ruler which prevented their being good citizens
at home. Against this prejudice it was useless to point to what had been
done by Englishmen for their country, when all the land was Catholic, and
all accepted the supremacy of the Pope. It was not till 1778 that the first
Catholic Relief Bill was carried, a Bill that "shook the general prejudice
against Catholics to the centre, and restored to them a thousand
indescribable charities in the ordinary intercourse of social life which
they had seldom experienced."

The last Roman Catholic to die for conscience' sake was Oliver Plunket,
Archbishop of Armagh, who was executed at Tyburn, when Charles II. was
King, in 1681. After the Revolution, Nonconformists and Catholics were no
longer hanged or tortured for declining the ministrations of the
Established Church, but still were penalised in many lesser ways. But the
spirit of the eighteenth century made for toleration, and the Whigs were as
unostentatious in their own piety as they were indifferent to the piety of
others.

The killing of "witches," however, went on in Scotland and in England long
after toleration had been secured for Nonconformists. As late as 1712 a
woman was executed for witchcraft in England.[67]

GROWTH OF CABINET RULE

William III. began with a mixed ministry of Whigs and Tories, which
included men like Danby and Godolphin, who had served under James II. But
the fierce wrangling that went on over the war then being waged on the
Continent was decidedly inconvenient, and by 1696 the Whigs had succeeded
in driving all the Tories--who were against the war--out of office. Then
for the first time a united ministry was in power, and from a Cabinet of
men with common political opinions the next step was to secure that the
Cabinet should represent the party with a majority in the House of Commons.
Our present system of Cabinet rule, dependent on the will of the majority
of the Commons, is found in full operation by the middle of the eighteenth
century. The fact that William III., George I., and George II. were all
foreigners necessitated the King's ministers using considerable powers. But
George III. was English, and effected a revival in the personal power of
the King by his determination that the choice of ministers should rest with
the Crown, and not with the House of Commons. He succeeded in breaking up
the long Whig ascendancy, and so accustomed became the people to the King
making and unmaking ministries, that on George IV.'s accession in 1820 it
was fully expected the new King would turn out the Tories and put in Whigs.
William IV. in 1835 did what no sovereign has done since--dissolved
Parliament against the wish of the government.

From 1696 to 1701 the Whigs were in office. Then on the death of William
and the accession of Anne, Tory ministers were included in the government,
and for seven years the Cabinet was composite again. But Marlborough and
Godolphin found that if they were to remain in power it must be by the
support of the Whigs, who had made the support of the war against France a
party question; and from 1708 to 1710 the ministry was definitely Whig. By
1710 the war had ceased to be popular, and the general election of that
year sent back a strong Tory majority to the House of Commons, with the
result that the Tory leaders, Harley (Earl of Oxford) and Henry St. John
(Bolingbroke) took office. The Tories fell on the death of Anne, because
their plot to place James (generally called the Chevalier or the old
Pretender), the Queen's half-brother, on the throne was defeated by the
readiness of the Whig Dukes of Somerset and Argyll to proclaim George,
Elector of Hanover, King of England. By the Act of Settlement, 1701,
Parliament had decided that the Crown should pass from Anne to the heirs of
Sophia, Electress of Hanover and daughter of James I.; and the fact that
the Chevalier was a Catholic made his accession impossible according to
law, and the policy of Bolingbroke highly treasonable.

George I. could not speak English, and relied entirely on his Whig
ministers. Bolingbroke fled to the Continent, but was permitted to return
from exile nine years later. Oxford was impeached and sent to the Tower.
The Whigs were left in triumph to rule the country for nearly fifty
years--until the restiveness of George III. broke up their dominion--and
for more than twenty years of that period Walpole was Prime Minister.
Cabinet government--that is, government by a small body of men, agreed upon
main questions of policy, and commanding the confidence of the majority of
the House of Commons--was now in full swing, and in spite of the monarchist
revival under George III., no King henceforth ever refused consent to a
Bill passed by Parliament.

The Whigs did nothing in those first sixty years of the eighteenth century
to make the House of Commons more representative of the people. They were
content to repeat the old cries of the Revolution, and to oppose all
proposals of change. But they governed England without oppression, and
Walpole's commercial and financial measures satisfied the trading classes
and kept national credit sound.

WALPOLE'S RULE

Walpole remained in power from 1720 to 1742 by sheer corruption--there was
no other way open to him. He laughed openly at all talk of honesty and
purity, and his influence lowered the whole tone of public life.[68] But he
kept in touch with the middle classes, was honest personally, and had a
large amount of tact and good sense. His power in the House of Commons
endured because he understood the management of parliamentary affairs, and
had a genius for discerning the men whose support he could buy, and whose
support was valuable.

George III. went to work in much the same way as Walpole had done, and only
succeeded in breaking down the power of the Whig houses by using the same
corrupt methods that Walpole had employed. The "King's friends," as they
were called, acted independently of the party leaders, and in the pay of
the King were the chief instrument of George III.'s will.

THE CHANGE IN THE HOUSE OF LORDS

But George III. not only turned the Whigs out of office, he altered
permanently the political complexion of the House of Lords. From the time
of the Revolution of 1688 to the death of George II. in 1760, the Lords
were Whiggish, and the majority of English nobles held Whig principles.
They were, on the whole, men of better education than the average member of
the House of Commons, who was in most cases a fox-hunting squire, of the
Squire Western type. The House of Lords stood in the way of the Commons
when, in the Tory reaction of 1701, the Commons proposed to impeach Somers,
the Whig Chancellor, a high-minded and skilful lawyer, "courteous and
complaisant, humane and benevolent," for his share in the Second Partition
Treaty of 1699, and this was the beginning of a bitter contest between the
Tory Commons and the Whig Lords. An attempt was made by the Commons to
impeach Walpole on his fall in 1742, but the Lords threw out a Bill
proposing to remit the penalties to which his prosecutor might be liable,
and the King made Walpole a peer. George III., by an unsparing use of his
prerogative, changed the character and politics of the Upper House. His
creations were country gentlemen of sufficient wealth to own "pocket"
boroughs in the House of Commons, and lawyers who supported the Royal
prerogative.[69]

From George III.'s time onward there has always been a standing and
ever-increasing majority of Tory peers in the House of Lords. And while the
actual number of members of the Upper House has been enlarged enormously,
this majority has became enlarged out of all proportion. Liberal and Tory
Prime Ministers were busy throughout the nineteenth century adding to the
peerage--no less than 376 new peers were created between 1800 and 1907; but
comparatively few Liberals retained their principles when they became
peers, and two of the present chiefs of the Unionist Party in the House of
Lords--Lords Lansdowne and Selborne--are the sons of eminent Liberals.

So it has come about that while the House of Commons has been steadily
opening its doors to men of all ranks and classes, and in our time has
become increasingly democratic in character, the House of Lords, confined
in the main to men of wealth and social importance, has become an enormous
assembly of undistinguished persons, where only a small minority are active
politicians, and of this minority at least three-fourths are Conservatives.

This change in the House of Lords began, as we have seen, in the reign of
George III., when the Whig ascendancy in Parliament had passed. But the
Whigs did nothing during their long lease of power to bring democracy
nearer, and were entirely contemptuous of popular aspirations. At the very
time when the democratic idea was the theme of philosophers, and was to be
seen expressed in the constitution of the revolted American colonies, and
in the French Revolution, England remained under an aristocracy, governed
first by Whigs, and then by Tories. It is true democracy was not without
its spokesmen in England in the eighteenth century, but there was no
popular movement in politics to stir the masses of the people, as the
preaching of the Methodists stirred their hearts for religion. Democratic
ideas were as remote from popular discussion in the eighteenth century as
they had been made familiar by Lilburne for a brief season in the
seventeenth century.

"WILKES AND LIBERTY"

A word must be said about John Wilkes, a man of disreputable character and
considerable ability, who for some ten years--1763-73--contended for the
rights of electors against the Whig Government. The battle began when
George Grenville, the Whig Prime Minister, had Wilkes arrested on a general
warrant for an article attacking the King's Speech in No. 45 of the _North
Briton_, a scurrilous newspaper which belonged to Wilkes. Chief Justice
Pratt declared the arrest illegal on the ground that the warrant was bad,
and that Wilkes, being at the time M.P. for Aylesbury, enjoyed the
privilege of Parliament. A jury awarded Wilkes heavy damages against the
Government for false imprisonment, and the result of the trial made Wilkes
a popular hero. Then, in 1764, the Government brought a new charge of
blasphemy and libel, and Wilkes, expelled from the House of Commons, and
condemned by the King's Bench, fled to France, and was promptly declared an
outlaw. He returned, however, a year or two later, and while in prison was
elected M.P. for Middlesex. The House of Commons, led by the Government,
set the election aside, and riots for "Wilkes and Liberty" broke out in
London. The question was: Had the House of Commons a right to exclude a
member duly elected for a constituency?--the same question that was raised
over Charles Bradlaugh, a man of very different character, in the
Parliament of 1880. Again and again in 1768 and 1769 Wilkes was re-elected
for Middlesex, only to be expelled, and finally the House decided that
Wilkes' opponent, Colonel Luttrell, was to sit, although Luttrell was
manifestly not chosen by the majority of electors. The citizens of London
replied to this by choosing Wilkes for Sheriff and Alderman in 1770, and by
making him Lord Mayor four years later. The Government gave up the contest
at last, and Wilkes was allowed to take his seat. Besides vindicating the
right of constituencies against the claim of Parliament to exclude
undesirable persons, Wilkes did a good deal towards securing that right of
Parliamentary debating which was practically admitted after 1771.

But the "Wilkes and Liberty" movement was no more than a popular enthusiasm
of the London mob for an enemy of the Government, and a determination of
London citiz

Showing first 200,000 characters. Full text: gutenberg.org/ebooks/19609