Gutenberg · e01.org
Cover of Gilbert Keith Chesterton
Project Gutenberg cover, or a typographic cover where none is held.

Gutenberg · ebook 18707

Gilbert Keith Chesterton

by Maisie Ward · English · public domain in the US

  • Language English
  • PG edition 2006
  • Rights public domain (US)
  • Source Project Gutenberg
0%

Contents

    CHAPTER I

    Background for Gilbert Keith Chesterton

    IT IS USUAL to open a biography with some account of the subject's ancestry. Chesterton, in his Browning, after some excellent foolery about pedigree-hunting, makes the suggestion that middle-class ancestry is far more varied and interesting than the ancestry of the aristocrat:

    The truth is that aristocrats exhibit less of the romance of
    pedigree than any other people in the world. For since it is their
    principle to marry only within their own class and mode of life,
    there is no opportunity in their case for any of the more interesting
    studies in heredity; they exhibit almost the unbroken uniformity of
    the lower animals. It is in the middle classes that we find the
    poetry of genealogy; it is the suburban grocer standing at his shop
    door whom some wild dash of Eastern or Celtic blood may drive
    suddenly to a whole holiday or a crime.

    This may provide fun for a guessing game but is not very useful to a biographer. The Chesterton family, like many another, had had the ups and downs in social position that accompany the ups and downs of fortune. Upon all this Edward Chesterton, Gilbert's father, as head of the family possessed many interesting documents. After his death, Gilbert's mother left his papers undisturbed. But when she died Gilbert threw away, without examination, most of the contents of his father's study, including all family records. Thus I cannot offer any sort of family tree. But it is possible to show the kind of family and the social atmosphere into which Gilbert Chesterton was born.

    Some of the relatives say that the family hailed from the village of Chesterton--now merged into Cambridge, of which they were Lords of the Manor, but Gilbert refused to take this seriously. In an introduction to a book called Life in Old Cambridge, he wrote:

    I have never been to Cambridge except as an admiring visitor; I have never been to Chesterton at all, either from a sense of unworthiness or from a faint superstitious feeling that I might be fulfilling a prophecy in the countryside. Anyone with a sense of the savour of the old English country rhymes and tales will share my vague alarm that the steeple might crack or the market cross fall down, for a smaller thing than the coincidence of a man named Chesterton going to Chesterton.

    At the time of the Regency, the head of the family was a friend of the Prince's and (perhaps as a result of such company) dissipated his fortunes in riotous living and incurred various terms of imprisonment for debt. From his debtors' prisons he wrote letters, and sixty years later Mr. Edward Chesterton used to read them to his family: as also those of another interesting relative, Captain George Laval Chesterton, prison reformer and friend of Mrs. Fry and of Charles Dickens. A relative recalls the sentence: "I cried, Dickens cried, we all cried," which makes one rather long for the rest of the letter.

    George Laval Chesterton left two books, one a kind of autobiography, the other a work on prison reform. It was a moment of enthusiasm for reform, of optimism and of energy. Dickens was stirring the minds of Englishmen to discover the evils in their land and rush to their overthrow. Darwin was writing his Origin of Species, which in some curious way increased the hopeful energy of his countrymen: they seemed to feel it much more satisfying to have been once animal and have become human than to be fallen gods who could again be made divine. Anyhow, there were giants in those days and it was hope that made them so.

    When by an odd confusion the Tribune described G. K. Chesterton as having been born about the date that Captain Chesterton published his books, he replied in a ballade which at once saluted and attacked:

    I am not fond of anthropoids as such,
    I never went to Mr. Darwin's school,
    Old Tyndall's ether, that he liked so much
    Leaves me, I fear, comparatively cool.
    I cannot say my heart with hope is full
    Because a donkey, by continual kicks,
    Turns slowly into something like a mule--
    I was not born in 1856.

    Age of my fathers: truer at the touch
    Than mine: Great age of Dickens, youth and yule:
    Had your strong virtues stood without a crutch,
    I might have deemed man had no need of rule,
    But I was born when petty poets pule,
    When madmen used your liberty to mix
    Lucre and lust, bestial and beautiful,
    I was not born in 1856.*

    [* Quoted in G. K. Chesterton: A criticism. Aliston Rivers (1908) pp. 243-244.]

    Both Autobiography and Prison Life are worth reading.* They breathe the "Great Gusto" seen by Gilbert in that era.

    He does not quote them in his Autobiography, but, just mentioning Captain Chesterton, dwells chiefly on his grandfather, who, while George Laval Chesterton was fighting battles and reforming prisons, had succeeded to the headship of a house agents' business in Kensington. (For, the family fortunes having been dissipated, Gilbert's great-grandfather had become first a coal merchant and then a house agent.) A few of the letters between this ancestor and his son remain and they are interesting, confirming Gilbert's description in the Autobiography of his grandfather's feeling that he himself was something of a landmark in Kensington and that the family business was honourable and important.

    [* See Appendix A.]

    The Chestertons, whatever the ups and downs of their past history, were by now established in that English middle-class respectability in which their son was to discover--or into which he was to bring--a glow and thrill of adventurous romance. Edward Chesterton, Gilbert's father, belonged to a serious family and a serious generation, which took its work as a duty and its profession as a vocation.

    I wonder what young house-agent today, just entering the family business, would receive a letter from his father adjuring him to "become an active steady and honourable man of business," speaking of "abilities which only want to be judiciously brought out, of course assisted with your earnest co-operation."

    Gilbert's mother was Marie Grosjean, one of a family of twenty-three children. The family had long been English, but came originally from French Switzerland. Marie's mother was from an Aberdeen family of Keiths, which gave Gilbert his second name and a dash of Scottish blood which "appealed strongly to my affections and made a sort of Scottish romance in my childhood." Marie's father, whom Gilbert never saw, had been "one of the old Wesleyan lay-preachers and was thus involved in public controversy, a characteristic which has descended to his grandchild. He was also one of the leaders of the early Teetotal movement, a characteristic which has not."*

    [* Autobiography, pp. 11-12.]

    When Edward became engaged to Marie Grosjean he complained that his "dearest girl" would not believe that he had any work to do, but he was in fact much occupied and increasingly responsible for the family business.

    There is a flavour of a world very remote from ours in the packet of letters between the two and from their various parents, aunts and sisters to one another during their engagement. Edward illuminates poems "for a certaln dear good little child," sketches the "look out from home" for her mother, hopes they did not appear uncivil in wandering into the garden together at an aunt's house and leaving the rest of the company for too long.

    He praises a friend of hers as "intellectual and unaffected, two excellent things in woman," describes a clerk sent to France with business papers who "lost them all, the careless dog, except the Illustrated London News."

    A letter to Marie from her sister Harriette is amusing. She describes her efforts at entertaining in the absence of her mother. The company were "great swells" so that her brother "took all the covers of the chairs himself and had the wine iced and we dined in full dress--it was very awful--considering myself as hostess." Poor girl, it was a series of misfortunes. "The dinner was three-quarters of an hour late, the fish done to rags." She had hired three dozen wine-glasses to be sure of enough, but they were "brought in in twos and threes at a time and then a hiatus as if they were being washed which they were not."

    In the letters from parents and older relatives religious observances are taken for granted and there is an obvious sincerity in the many allusions to God's will and God's guidance of human life. No one reading them could doubt that the description of a dying relative as "ready for the summons" and to "going home" is a sincere one. Other letters, notably Harriette's, do not lack a spice of malice in speaking of those whose religion was unreal and affected--a phenomenon that only appears in an age when real religion abounds.

    Doubtless her generation was beginning to see Christianity with less than the simplicity of their parents. They were hearing of Darwin and Spencer, and the optimism which accompanied the idea of evolution was turning religion into a vague glow which would, they felt, survive the somewhat childish dogmas in which our rude ancestors had tried to formulate it. But with an increased vagueness went also, with the more liberal--and the Chestertons were essentially liberal both politically and theologically--an increased tolerance.

    In several of his letters, Edward Chesterton mentions the Catholic Church, and certainly with no dislike. He went on one occasion to hear Manning preach and much admired the sermon, although he notes too that he found in it "no distinctively Roman Catholic doctrine." He belonged, however, to an age that on the whole found the rest of life more exciting and interesting than religion, an age that had kept the Christian virtues and still believed that these virtues could stand alone, without the support of the Christian creed.

    The temptation to describe dresses has always to be sternly resisted when dealing with any part of the Victorian era, so merely pausing to note that it seems to have been a triumph on the part of Mrs.

    Grosjean to have cut a short skirt out of 8½ yards of material, I reluctantly lay aside the letters at the time when Edward Chesterton and Marie were married and had set about living happily ever after.

    These two had no fear of life: they belonged to a generation which cheerfully created a home and brought fresh life into being. In doing it, they did a thousand other things, so that the home they made was full of vital energies for the children who were to grow up in it.

    Gilbert recollects his father as a man of a dozen hobbies, his study as a place where these hobbies formed strata of exciting products, awakening youthful covetousness in the matter of a new paint-box, satisfying youthful imagination by the production of a toy-theatre.

    His character, serene and humorous as his son describes him, is reflected in his letters. Edward Chesterton did not use up his mental powers in the family business. Taught by his father to be a good man of business, he was in his private life a man of a thousand other energies and ideas. "On the whole," says his son, "I am glad he was never an artist. It might have stood in his way in becoming an amateur. It might have spoilt his career; his private career. He could never have made a vulgar success of all the thousand things be did so successfully."

    Here, Gilbert sees a marked distinction between that generation of business men and the present in the use of leisure; he sees hobbies as superior to sport. "The old-fashioned Englishman, like my father, sold houses for his living but filled his own house with his life. A hobby is not merely a holiday. . . . It is not merely exercising the body instead of the mind, an excellent but now largely a recognised thing.

    It is exercising the rest of the mind; now an almost neglected thing." Edward Chesterton practised "water-colour painting and modelling and photography and stained glass and fretwork and magic lanterns and mediaeval illumination." And, moreover, "knew all his English literature backwards."

    It has become of late the fashion for any one who writes of his own life to see himself against a dark background, to see his development frustrated by some shadow of heredity or some horror of environment.

    But Gilbert saw his life rather as the ancients saw it when pietas was a duty because we had received so much from those who brought us into being. This Englishman was grateful to his country, to his parents, to his home for all that they had given him.

    I regret that I have no gloomy and savage father to offer to the
    public gaze as the true cause of all my tragic heritage; no pale-faced
    and partially poisoned mother whose suicidal instincts have cursed
    me with the temptations of the artistic temperament. I regret that
    there was nothing in the range of our family much more racy than a
    remote and mildly impecunious uncle; and that I cannot do my duty
    as a true modern, by cursing everybody who made me whatever I
    am. I am not clear about what that is; but I am pretty sure that
    most of it is my own fault.

    And I am compelled to confess that I
    look back to that landscape of my first days with a pleasure that
    should doubtless be reserved for the Utopias of the Futurist.*

    [* G. K. Chesterton. Autobiography, pp. 22-3.]

    CHAPTER II

    Childhood

    GILBERT KEITH CHESTERTON was born on May 29, 1874 at a house in Sheffield Terrace, Campden Hill, just below the great tower of the Waterworks which so much impressed his childish imagination. Lower down the hill was the Anglican Church of St. George, and here he was baptised. When he was about five, the family moved to Warwick Gardens. As old-fashioned London houses go, 11 Warwick Gardens is small.

    On the ground floor, a back and front room were for the Chestertons drawing-room and dining-room with a folding door between, the only other sitting-room being a small study built out over the garden. A long, narrow, green strip, which must have been a good deal longer before a row of garages was built at the back, was Gilbert's playground. His bedroom was a long room at the top of a not very high house. For what is in most London houses the drawing-room floor is in this house filled by two bedrooms and there is only one floor above it.

    Cecil was five years younger than Gilbert, who welcomed his birth with the remark, "Now I shall always have an audience," a prophecy remembered by all parties because it proved so singularly false. As soon as Cecil could speak, he began to argue and the brothers' intercourse thenceforward consisted of unending discussion. They always argued, they never quarrelled.

    There was also a little sister Beatrice who died when Gilbert was very young, so young that he remembered a fall she had from a rocking-horse more clearly than he remembered her death, and in his memory linked with the fall the sense of loss and sorrow that came with the death.

    It would be impossible to tell the story of his childhood one half so well as he has told it himself. It is the best part of his Autobiography. Indeed, it is one of the best childhoods in literature. For Gilbert Chesterton most perfectly remembered the exact truth, not only about what happened to a child, but about how a child thought and felt. What is more, he sees childhood not as an isolated fragment or an excursion into fairyland, but as his "real life; the real beginnings of what should have been a more real life; a lost experience in the land of the living."

    I was subconsciously certain then, as I am consciously certain now,
    that there was the white and solid road and the worthy beginning of
    the life of man; and that it is man who afterwards darkens it with
    dreams or goes astray from it in self-deception. It is only the grown
    man who lives a life of make-believe and pretending; and it is he who
    has his head in a cloud.*

    [* Autobiography, p. 49.]

    Here are the beginnings of the man's philosophy in the life and experience of the child. He was living in a world of reality, and that reality was beautiful, in the clear light of "an eternal morning," which "had a sort of wonder in it, as if the world were as new as myself." A child in this world, like God in the moment of creation, looks upon it and sees that it is very good.

    It was not that he was never unhappy as a child, and he had his share of bodily pain. "I had a fair amount of toothache and especially earache." But the child has his own philosophy and makes his own proportion, and unhappiness and pain "are of a different texture or held on a different tenure."

    What was wonderful about childhood is that anything in it was a
    wonder. It was not merely a world full of miracles; it was a
    miraculous world. What gives me this shock is almost anything I
    really recall; not the things I should think most worth recalling.
    This is where it differs from the other great thrill of the past, all
    that is connected with first love and the romantic passion; for that,
    though equally poignant, comes always to a point; and is narrow like
    a rapier piercing the heart, whereas the other was more like a
    hundred windows opened on all sides of the head.*

    [* Autobiography, pp. 31-32.]

    These windows opening on all sides so much more swiftly for the genius than for the rest of us, led to a result often to be noted in the childhood of exceptional men: a combination of backwardness and precocity. Gilbert Chesterton was in some ways a very backward child.

    He did not talk much before three. He learnt to read only at eight.

    He loved fairy tales; as a child he read them or had them read aloud to him: as a big boy he wrote and illustrated a good many, some of which are printed in The Coloured Lands. I have found several fragments in praise of Hans Andersen written apparently in his schooldays. In the chapter of Orthodoxy called "The Ethics of Elfland" he shows how the truth about goodness and happiness came to him out of the old fairy tales and made the first basis for his philosophy.

    And George Macdonald's story The Princess and the Goblin made, he says, "a difference to my whole existence, which helped me to see things in a certain way from the start." It is the story of a house where goblins were in the cellar and a kind of fairy godmother in a hidden room upstairs. This story had made "all the ordinary staircases and doors and windows into magical things." It was the awakening of the sense of wonder and joy in the ordinary things always to be his.

    Still more important was the realization represented by the goblins below stairs, that "When the evil things besieging us do appear, they do not appear outside but inside." In life as in this story there is

    . . . a house that is our home, that is rightly loved as our home,
    but of which we hardly know the best or the worst, and must always
    wait for the one and watch against the other. . . . Since I first
    read that story some five alternative philosophies of the universe
    have come to our colleges out of Germany, blowing through the world
    like the east wind. But for me that castle is still standing in the
    mountains, its light is not put out.*

    [* Introduction to George Macdonald and His Wife.]

    All this to Gilbert made the story the "most real, the most realistic, in the exact sense of the phrase the most like life" of any story he ever read--then or later! Another recurrent image in books by the same author is that of a great white horse. And Gilbert says, "To this day I can never see a big white horse in the street without a sudden sense of indescribable things."*

    [* Ibid.]

    Of his playmates, "one of my first memories," he writes in the Autobiography, "is playing in the garden under the care of a girl with ropes of golden hair; to whom my mother afterwards called out from the house, 'You are an angel'; which I was disposed to accept without metaphor. She is now living in Vancouver as Mrs. Robert Kidd."

    Mrs. Kidd, then Annie Firmin, was the daughter of a girlhood friend of Mrs. Chesterton's. She called her "Aunt Marie." She and her sister, Gilbert says in the Autobiography, "had more to do with enlivening my early years than most." She has a vivid memory of Sheffield Terrace where all three Chesterton children were born and where the little sister, Beatrice, whom they called Birdie, died.

    Gilbert, in those days, was called Diddie, his father then and later was "Mr. Ed" to the family and intimate friends. Soon after Birdie's death they moved to Warwick Gardens. Mrs. Kidd writes:

    . . . the little boys were never allowed to see a funeral. If one
    passed down Warwick Gardens, they were hustled from the nursery
    window at once. Possibly this was because Gilbert had such a fear of
    sickness or accident. If Cecil gave the slightest sign of choking at
    dinner, Gilbert would throw down his spoon or fork and rush from the
    room. I have seen him do it so many times. Cecil was fond of animals.
    Gilbert wasn't. Cecil had a cat that he named Faustine, because he
    wanted her to be abandoned and wicked--but Faustine turned out to be
    a gentleman!

    Gilbert's story-telling and verse-making began very early, but not, I think, in great abundance; his drawing even earlier, and of this there is a great deal. There is nothing very striking in the written fragments that remain, but his drawings even at the age of five are full of vigour.

    The faces and figures are always rudimentary human beings, sometimes a good deal more, and they are taken through lengthy adventures drawn on the backs of bits of wall paper, of insurance forms, in little books sewn together, or sometimes on long strips glued end to end by his father. These drawings can often be dated exactly, for Edward Chesterton, who later kept collections of press-cuttings and photographs of his son, had already begun to collect his drawings, writing the date on the back of each.

    With the earlier ones he may, one sometimes suspects, have helped a little, but it soon becomes easy to distinguish between the two styles.

    Edward Chesterton was the most perfect father that could have been imagined to help in the opening of windows on every side. "My father might have reminded people of Mr.

    Pickwick, except that he was always bearded and never bald; he wore spectacles and had all the Pickwickian evenness of temper and pleasure in the humours of travel." He had, as his son further notes in the Autobiography, a power of invention which "created for children the permanent anticipation of what is profoundly called a 'surprise.'" The child of today chooses his Christmas present in advance and decides between Peter Pan and the Pantomime (when he does not get both).

    The Chesterton children saw their first glimpses of fantasy through the framework of a toy-theatre of which their father was carpenter, scene-painter and scene-shifter, author and creator of actors and actresses a few inches high. Gilbert's earliest recollection is of one of these figures in a golden crown carrying a golden key, and his father was all through his childhood a man with a golden key who admitted him into a world of wonders.

    I think Gilbert's father meant more to him than his mother, fond as he was of her. Most of their friends seem to feel that Cecil was her favorite son. "Neither was ever demonstrative," Annie Firmin says, "I never saw either of them kiss his mother." But in some ways the mother spoilt both boys. They had not the training that a strict mother or an efficient nurse usually accomplishes with the most refractory.

    Gilbert was never refractory, merely absent-minded; but it is doubtful whether he was sent upstairs to wash his hands or brush his hair, except in preparation for a visit or ceremonial occasion ("not even then!" interpolates Annie). And it is perfectly certain that he ought to have been so sent several times a day.

    No one minded if he was late for meals; his father, too, was frequently late and Frances during her engagement often saw his mother put the dishes down in the fireplace to keep hot, and wait patiently--in spite of Gilbert's description of her as "more swift, relentless and generally radical in her instincts" than his father. Annie Firmin's earlier memories fit this description better. Much as she loved her "aunt," she writes:

    Aunt Marie was a bit of a tyrant in her own family! I have been
    many times at dinner, when there might be a joint, say, and a
    chicken--and she would say positively to Mr. Ed, "Which will you
    have, Edward?" Edward: "I think I'd like a bit of chicken!" Aunt M.
    fiercely: "No, you won't, you'll have mutton!" That happened so
    often. Sometimes Alice Grosjean, the youngest of Aunt M.'s family,
    familiarly known as "Sloper," was there.

    When asked her preference
    she would say, diffidently, "I think I'll take a little mutton!"
    "Don't be a fool, Alice, you know you like chicken,"--and chicken
    she got.

    Visitors to the house in later years dwell on Mrs. Chesterton's immense spirit of hospitality, the gargantuan meals, the eager desire that guests should eat enormously, and the wittiness of her conversation. Schoolboy contemporaries of Gilbert say that although immensely kind, she alarmed them by a rather forbidding appearance--"her clothes thrown on anyhow, and blackened and protruding teeth which gave her a witchlike appearance. . . . The house too was dusty and untidy." She called them always by their surnames, both when they were little boys and after they grew up, "Oldershaw, Bentley, Solomon."

    "Not only," says Miss May Chesterton, "did Aunt Marie address Gilbert's friends by their surnames, but frequently added darling to them. I have heard her address Bentley when a young man thus; 'Bentley darling, come and sit over here,' to which invitation he turned a completely deaf ear as he was perfectly content to remain where he was!"

    "Indiscriminately, she also addressed her maids waiting at table with the same endearment."

    A letter written when Gilbert was only six would seem to show that Mrs. Chesterton had not yet become so reckless about her appearance, and was still open to the appeal of millinery. ("She always was," says Annie.) The letter is from John Barker of High Street, Kensington, and is headed in handwriting, "Drapery and Millinery Establishment, Kensington High Street, September 21, 1880."

    MADAM,

    We are in receipt of instructions from Mr. Edward Chesterton to
    wait upon you for the purpose of offering for your selection a Bonnet
    of the latest Parisian taste, of which we have a large assortment
    ready for your choice; or can, if preferred, make you one to order.

    Our assistant will wait upon you at any time you may appoint,
    unless you would prefer to pay a visit to our Millinery department
    yourself.

    Mr. Chesterton informs us that as soon as you have made your
    selection he will hand us a cheque for the amount.

    We are given to understand that Mr. Chesterton proposes this
    transaction as a remembrance of the anniversary of what, he instructs
    us to say, he regards as a happy and auspicious event. We have
    accordingly entered it in our books in that aspect.

    In conveying, as we are desired to do, Mr. Chesterton's best wishes
    for your health and happiness for many future anniversaries, may we
    very respectfully join to them our own, and add that during many
    years to come we trust to be permitted to supply you with goods of
    the best description for cash, on the principle of the lowest prices
    consistent with excellence of quality and workmanship.

    We have the honour to be Madam Your most obedient Servants

    JOHN BARKER & Co.

    The order entered in their books "under that aspect," the readiness to provide millinery "for cash," convinces you (as G.K. himself says of another story) that Dick Swiveller really did say, "When he who adores thee has left but the name--in case of letters and parcels."

    Dickens must have dictated the letter to John Barker. After all, he was only dead ten years.

    "Aunt Marie used to say," adds Annie Firmin, "that Mr. Ed married her for her beautiful hair, it was auburn, and very long and wavy. He used to sit behind her in Church. She liked pretty clothes, but lacked the vanity to buy them for herself. I have a little blue hanging watch that he bought her one day--she always appreciated little attentions."

    The playmates of Gilbert's childhood are not described in the Autobiography except for Annie's "long ropes of golden hair." But in one of the innumerable fragments written in his early twenties, he describes a family of girls who had played with him when they were very young together. It is headed, "Chapter I. A Contrast and a Climax," and several other odd bits of verse and narrative introduce the Vivian family as early and constant playmates.

    One of the best ways of feeling a genuine friendly enthusiasm for
    persons of the other sex, without gliding into anything with a
    shorter name, is to know a whole family of them. The most
    intellectual idolatry at one shrine is apt to lose its purely
    intellectual character, but a genial polytheism is always bracing and
    platonic. Besides, the Vivians lived in the same street or rather
    "gardens" as ourselves, and were amusing as bringing one within sight
    of what an old friend of mine, named Bentley, called with more than
    his usual gloom and severity of expression, "the remote outpost of
    Kensington Society."

    For these reasons, and a great many much better ones, I was very
    much elated to have the family, or at least the three eldest girls
    who represent it to the neighbourhood, standing once more on the
    well-rubbed lawn of our old garden, where some of my earliest
    recollections were of subjecting them to treatment such as I
    considered appropriate to my own well-established character of
    robber, tying them to trees to the prejudice of their white frocks,
    and otherwise misbehaving myself in the funny old days, before I went
    to school and became a son of gentlemen only.

    I have never been able,
    in fact I have never tried, to tell which of the three I really liked
    best.

    And if the severer usefulness and domesticity of the eldest
    girl, with her quiet art-colours, and broad, brave forehead as pale
    as the white roses that clouded the garden, if these maturer
    qualities in Nina demanded my respect more than the levity of the
    others, I fear they did not prevent me feeling an almost equal tide
    of affection towards the sleepy acumen and ingrained sense of humour
    of Ida, the second girl and book-reader for the family: or Violet, a
    veritably delightful child, with a temper as formless and erratic as
    her tempest of red hair.

    "What old memories this garden calls up," said Nina, who like many
    essentially simple and direct people, had a strong dash of sentiment
    and a strong penchant for being her own emotional pint-stoup on the
    traditional subjects and occasions. "I remember so well coming here
    in a new pink frock when I was a little girl. It wasn't so new when
    I went away."

    "I certainly must have been a brute," I replied. "But I have
    endeavoured to make a lifetime atone for my early conduct." And
    I fell to thinking how even Nina, miracle of diligence and
    self-effacement, remembered a new pink frock across the abyss of
    the years. . . . Walking with my old friends round the garden, I
    found in every earth-plot and tree-root the arenas of an active
    and adventurous life in early boyhood. . . .*

    [* Unpublished fragment.]

    Edward Chesterton was a Liberal politically and what has been called a Liberal Christian religiously. When the family went to church--which happened very seldom--it was to listen to the sermons of Stopford Brooke. Some twenty years later, Cecil was to remark with amusement that he had as a small boy heard every part of the teaching now (1908) being set out by R. J. Campbell under the title, "The New Religion." The Chesterton Liberalism entered into the view of history given to their children, and it produced from Gilbert the only poem of his childhood worth quoting. I cannot date it, but the very immature handwriting and curious spelling mark it as early.

    Probably most children have read, or at any rate up to my own generation, had read, Aytoun's Lays of the Scottish Cavaliers, and played at being Cavaliers as a result. But Gilbert could not play at being a Cavalier. He had learned from his father to be a Roundhead, as had every good Liberal of that day. What was to be done about it?

    He took the Lays and rewrote them in an excellent imitation of Aytoun, but on the opposite side. In view of his own later developments such a line as "Drive the trembling Papists backwards" has an ironic humour. But one wonders what Aytoun himself would have made of a small boy who took his rhythm and sometimes his very words, turned his hero into a traitor ("false Montrose") and his traitor Argyll into a hero! I have left the spelling untouched.

    Sing of the Great Lord Archibald
    Sing of his glorious name
    Sing of his covenenting faith
    And his evelasting fame.

    One day he summoned all his men
    To meet on Cruerchin's brow
    Three thousand covenenting chiefs
    Who no master would allow

    Three thousand Knights
    With clamores drawn
    And targets tough and strong
    Knights who for the right
    Would ever fight
    And never bear the wrong.

    And he creid (his hand uplifted)
    "Soldiers of Scotland hear my vow
    Ere the morning shall have risen
    I will lay the trators low
    Or as ye march from the battle
    Marching back in battle file
    Ye shall there among the corpses
    Find the body of Argyll.

    Soldiers Soldiers onward onward
    Onward soldiers follow me
    Come, remember ye the crimes
    Of the fiend of fell Dundee
    Onward let us draw our clamores
    Let us draw them on our foes
    Now then I am threatened with
    The fate of false Montrose.

    Drive the trembling Papists backwards
    Drive away the Tory's hord
    Let them tell thier hous of villians
    They have felt the Campbell's sword."

    And the next morn he arose
    And he girded on his sword
    They asked him many questions
    But he answered not a word.
    And he summoned all his men
    And he led them to the field
    And We creid unto our master
    That we'd die and never yield.
    That same morn we drove right backwards
    All the servants of the Pope
    And Our Lord Archibald we saved
    From a halter and a rope
    Far and fast fled all the trators
    Far and fast fled all the Graemes
    Fled that cursed tribe who lately
    Stained there honour and thier names.

    CHAPTER III

    School Days

    CURIOUSLY ENOUGH Gilbert does not in the Autobiography speak of any school except St. Paul's. He went however first to Colet Court, usually called at that time Bewsher's, from the name of the Headmaster. Though it is not technically the preparatory school for St. Paul's, large numbers of Paulines do pass through it. It stands opposite St. Paul's in the Hammersmith Road and must have been felt by Gilbert as one thing with his main school experience, for he nowhere differentiates between the two.

    St. Paul's School is an old city foundation which has had among its scholars Milton and Marlborough, Pepys and Sir Philip Francis and a host of other distinguished men. The editor of a correspondence column wrote a good many years later in answer to an enquirer: "Yes, Milton and G. K. Chesterton were both educated at St. Paul's school.

    We fancy however that Milton had left before Chesterton entered the school." In an early life of Sir Thomas More we learn of the keen rivalry existing in his day between his own school of St. Anthony and St. Paul's, of scholastic "disputations" between the two, put an end to by Dean Colet because they led to brawling among the boys, when the Paulines would call those of St. Anthony "pigs" and the pigs would call the Paulines "pigeons"--from the pigeons of St. Paul's Cathedral. Now, however, St. Anthony's is no more, and St.

    Paul's School has long moved to the suburbs and lies about seven minutes' walk along the Hammersmith Road from Warwick Gardens. Gilbert Chesterton was twelve when he entered St. Paul's (in January 1887) and he was placed in the second Form.

    His early days at school were very solitary, his chief occupation being to draw all over his books. He drew caricatures of his masters, he drew scenes from Shakespeare, he drew prominent politicians. He did not at first make many friends. In the Autobiography he makes a sharp distinction between being a child and being a boy, but it is a distinction that could only be drawn by a man. And most men, I fancy, would find it a little difficult to say at what moment the transformation occurred.

    G.K. seems to put it at the beginning of school life, but the fact that St. Paul's was a day-school meant that the transition from home to school, usual in English public-school education,* was never in his case completely made. No doubt he is right in speaking in the Autobiography of "the sort of prickly protection like hair" that "grows over what was once the child," of the fact that schoolboys in his time "could be blasted with the horrible revelation of having a sister, or even a Christian name."

    Nevertheless, he went home every evening to a father and mother and small brother; he went to his friends' houses and knew their sisters; school and home life met Daily instead of being sharply divided into terms and holidays.

    [* The terminology for English schools came into being largely before the State concerned itself with education. A Private School is one run by an individual or a group for private profit. A Public School is not run for private profit; any profits there may be are put back into the school. Mostly they are run by a Board of Governors and very many of them hold the succession to the old monastic schools of England (e.g., Charterhouse, Westminster, St. Paul's). They are usually, though not necessarily, boarding schools, and the fees are usually high. Elementary schools called Board Schools were paid for out of local rates and run by elected School Boards.

    They were later replaced by schools run by the County Councils.]

    This fact was of immense significance in Gilbert's development. Years later he noted as the chief defect of Oxford that it consisted almost entirely of people educated at boarding-schools. For good, for evil, or for both, a boy at a day-school is educated chiefly at home.

    In the atmosphere of St. Paul's is found little echo of the dogma
    of the Head Master of Christ's Hospital. "Boy! The school is your
    father! Boy! The school is your mother." Nor, as far as we know has
    any Pauline been known to desire the substitution of the august
    abstraction for the guardianship of his own people.

    Friendships
    formed in this school have a continual reference to home life, nor
    can a boy possibly have a friend long without making the acquaintance
    and feeling the influence of his parents and his surroundings. . . .
    The boys' own amusements and institutions, the school sports, the
    school clubs, the school magazine, are patronised by the masters, but
    they are originated and managed by the boys.

    The play-hours of the
    boys are left to their several pleasures, whether physical or
    intellectual, nor have any foolish observations about the battle of
    Waterloo being won on the cricket-field, or such rather unmeaning
    oracles, yet succeeded in converting the boys' amusements into a
    compulsory gymnastic lesson. The boys are, within reasonable limits,
    free.*

    [* MS. History of J.D.C. written about 1894.]

    Gilbert calls the chapter on his school days, "How to be a Dunce," and although in mature life he was "on the side of his masters" and grateful to them "that my persistent efforts not to learn Latin were frustrated; and that I was not entirely successful even in escaping the contamination of the language of Aristotle and Demosthenes," he still contrasts childhood as a time when one "wants to know nearly everything" with "the period of what is commonly called education; that is, the period during which I was being instructed by somebody I did not know about something I did not want to know."

    The boy who sat next to him in class, Lawrence Solomon (later Senior Tutor of University College, London), remembered him as sleepy and indifferent in manner but able to master anything when he cared to take the trouble--as he very seldom did. He was in a class with boys almost all his juniors. Lucian Oldershaw, who later became his brother-in-law, says of Gilbert's own description of his school life that it was as near a pose as Gilbert ever managed to get. He wanted desperately to be the ordinary schoolboy, but he never managed to fulfil this ambition. Tall, untidy, incredibly clumsy and absent-minded, he was marked out from his fellows both physically and intellectually.

    When in the later part of his school life some sort of physical exercises were made compulsory, the boys used to form parties to watch his strange efforts on the trapeze or parallel bars.

    In these early days, he was (he says of himself) "somewhat solitary," but not unhappy, and perfectly good-humoured about the tricks which were inevitably played on a boy who always appeared to be half asleep.

    "He sat at the back of the room," says Mr. Fordham, "and never distinguished himself. We thought him the most curious thing that ever was." His schoolfellows noted how he would stride along, "apparently muttering poetry, breaking into inane laughter." The kind of thing he was muttering we learn from a sentence in the Autobiography: "I was one day wandering about the streets in that part of North Kensington, telling myself stories of feudal sallies and sieges, in the manner of Walter Scott, and vaguely trying to apply them to the wilderness of bricks and mortar around me."

    "I can see him now," wrote Mr. Fordham, "very tall and lanky, striding untidily along Kensington High Street, smiling and sometimes scowling as he talked to himself, apparently oblivious of everything he passed; but in reality a far closer observer than most, and one who not only observed but remembered what he had seen." It was only of himself that he was really oblivious.

    Mr. Oldershaw remembers that on one occasion on a very cold day they filled his pockets with snow in the playground. When class reassembled, the snow began to melt and pools to appear on the floor.

    A small boy raised his hand: "Please Sir, I think the laboratory sink must be leaking again. The water is coming through and falling all over Chesterton."

    The laboratory sink was an old offender and the master must have been short-sighted. "Chesterton," he said, "go up to Mr. ---- and ask him with my compliments to see that the trouble with the sink is put right immediately." Gilbert, with water still streaming from both pockets, obediently went upstairs, gave the message and returned without discovering what had happened.

    The boys who played these jokes on him had at the same time an extraordinary respect, both for his intellectual acquirements and for his moral character.

    One boy, who rather prided himself in private life on being a man about town, stopped him one day in the passage and said solemnly, "Chesterton, I am an abandoned profligate." G.K. replied, "I'm sorry to hear it." "We watched our talk," one of them said to me, "when he was with us." His home and upbringing were felt by some of his schoolfellows to have definitely a Puritan tinge about them, although on the other hand the more Conservative elements regarded them as politically dangerous. Mr.

    Oldershaw relates that his own father, who was a Conservative in politics and had also joined the Catholic Church, seriously warned him against the Agnosticism and Republicanism of the Chesterton household. But even at this age his schoolfellows recognised that he had begun the great quest of his life. "We felt," said Oldershaw, "that he was looking for God."

    I suppose it was in part the keenness of the inner vision that produced the effect of external sleepiness and made it possible to pack Gilbert's pockets with snow; but it was also the fact that he was observing very keenly the kind of thing that other people do not bother to observe. I remember my mother telling me, when I first came out, that she had almost ceased trying to draw people's characters and imaginatively construct their home lives, because for the first time in her life she was trying to notice how they were dressed.

    She was not noticeably successful. Gilbert Chesterton never even tried to see what everyone else saw. All the time he was seeing qualities in his friends, ideas in literature and possibilities in life. And all this world of imagination had, on his own theory, to be carefully concealed from his masters.

    In the Autobiography he describes himself walking to school fervently reciting verses which he afterwards repeated in class with a determined lack of expression and woodenness of voice; but when he assumes that this is how all boys behave, he surely attributes his own literary enthusiasms far too widely. One would rather gather that he supposed the whole of St.

    Paul's School to be in the conspiracy to conceal their love of literature from their masters! Such of his own schoolboy papers as can be found show an imagination rare enough at any age, and an enthusiasm not commonly to be found among schoolboys. A very early one, to judge by the handwriting, is on the advantages for an historical character of having long hair, illustrated by the history of Mary Queen of Scots and Charles the First. In the contrast he draws between Mary and Elizabeth, appear qualities of historical imagination that might well belong to a mature and experienced writer.

    . . . As in the cause of the fleeting heartless Helen, the Trojan
    War is stirred up, and great Ajax perishes, and the gentle Patroclus
    is slain, and mighty Hector falls, and godlike Achilles is laid low,
    and the dun plains of Hades are thickened with the shades of Kings,
    so round this lovely giddy French princess, fall one by one the
    haughty Dauphin, the princely Darnley, the accomplished Rizzio, the
    terrible Bothwell, and when she dies, she dies as a martyr before the
    weeping eyes of thousands, and is given a popular pity and regret
    denied to her rival, with all her faults of violence and vanity, a
    greater and a purer woman.

    It must indeed have been a terrible scene, the execution of that
    unhappy Queen, and it is a scene that has been described by too
    many and too able writers for me to venture on a picture of it. But
    the continually lamented death of Mary of Scotland seems to me
    happy compared with the end of her greater and sterner rival. As I
    think on the two, the vision of the black scaffold, the grim headsman,
    the serene captive, and the weeping populace fades from me and is
    replaced by a sadder vision: the vision of the dimly-lighted
    state-bedroom of Whitehall.

    Elizabeth, haggard and wild-eyed has
    flung herself prone upon the floor and refuses to take meat or drink,
    but lies there, surrounded by ceremonious courtiers, but seeing with
    that terrible insight that was her curse, that she was alone, that
    their homage was a mockery, that they were waiting eagerly for her
    death to crown their intrigues with her successor, that there was not
    in the whole world a single being who cared for her: seeing all this,
    and bearing it with the iron fortitude of her race, but underneath
    that invincible silence the deep woman's nature crying out with a
    bitter cry that she is loved no longer: thus gnawed by the fangs of a
    dead vanity, haunted by the pale ghost of Essex, and helpless and
    bitter of heart, the greatest of Englishwomen passed silently away.
    Of a truth, there are prisons more gloomy than Fotheringay and deaths
    more cruel than the axe.

    Is there no pity due to those who undergo
    these?

    It is surprising to read the series of form reports written on a boy who at fifteen or sixteen could do work of this quality. Here are the half-yearly reports made by his Form Masters from his first year in the school at the age of thirteen to the time he left at the age of eighteen.

    December 1887. Too much for me: means well by me, I believe, but has an inconceivable knack of forgetting at the shortest notice, is consequently always in trouble, though some of his work is well done, when he does remember to do it. He ought to be in a studio not at school. Never troublesome, but for his lack of memory and absence of mind.

    July 1888. Wildly inaccurate about everything; never thinks for two consecutive moments to judge by his work: plenty of ability, perhaps in other directions than classics.

    December 1888. Fair. Improving in neatness. Has a very fair stock of general knowledge.

    July 1889. A great blunderer with much intelligence.

    December 1889. Means well. Would do better to give his time to "Modern" subjects.

    July 1890. Can get up any work, but originates nothing.

    December 1890. Takes an interest in his English work, but otherwise has not done well.

    July 1891. He has a decided literary aptitude, but does not trouble himself enough about school work.

    December 1891. Report missing.

    July 1892. Not on the same plane with the rest: composition quite futile, but will translate well and appreciate what he reads. Not a quick brain, but possessed by a slowly moving tortuous imagination.

    Conduct always admirable.

    What is much clearer from the mass of notebooks and odd sheets of paper belonging to these years than from the Autobiography is the degree to which the two processes of resisting and absorbing knowledge were going on simultaneously. At school he was, he says, asleep but dreaming in his sleep; at home he was still learning literature from his father, going to museums and picture galleries for enjoyment, listening to political talk and engaging in arguments, writing historical plays and acting them, and above all drawing.

    To most of his early writing it is nearly impossible to affix a date--with the exception of a "dramatic journal," kept by fits and starts during the Christmas holidays when he was sixteen. G.K. solemnly tells the reader of this diary to take warning by it, to beware of prolixity, and it does in fact contain many more words to many fewer ideas than any of his later writings. But it is useful in giving the atmosphere of those years. Great part is in dialogue, the author appearing throughout as Your Humble Servant, his young brother Cecil as the Innocent Child.

    The first scene is the rehearsal of a dramatic version of Scott's Woodstock. This has been written by Your Humble Servant who is at the same time engaged on a historic romance. At intervals in the languid rehearsing, endless discussions take place: between Oldershaw and G.K. on Thackeray, between Oldershaw, his father and G.K. on Royal Supremacy in the Church of England. The boys, walking between their two houses, "discuss Roman Catholicism, Supremacy, Papal v.

    Protestant Persecutions. Your Humble Servant arrives at 11 Warwick Gardens to meet Mr. Mawer Cowtan, Master Sidney Wells and Master William Wells. Conversation about Frederick the Great, Voltaire and Macaulay. Cheerful and enlivening discourse on Germs, Dr. Koch, Consumption and Tuberculosis."

    "Conservative" Oldershaw regards his friend as a "red hot raging Republican" and it is interesting to note already faint foreshadowings of Gilbert's future political views. His parents had made him a Liberal but it seemed to him later, as he notes in the Autobiography, that their generation was insufficiently alive to the condition and sufferings of the poor. Open-eyed in so many matters, they were not looking in that particular direction. And so it was only very gradually that he himself began to look.

    Your Humble Servant read Oldershaw Elizabeth Browning's "Cry of the Children," which the former could scarcely trust himself to read, but which the latter candidly avowed that he did not like. Part and parcel of Oldershaw's optimism is a desire not to believe in pictures of real misery, and a desire to find out compensating pleasures. I think there was a good deal in what he said, but at the same time I think that there is real misery, physical and mental, in the low and criminal classes, and I don't believe in crying peace where there is no peace.

    Of his brother, Gilbert notes, "Innocent Child's fault is not a servile reverence for his elder brother, whom he regards, I believe, as a mild lunatic." And Oldershaw recalls his own detestation of Cecil, who would insist on monopolising the conversation when Gilbert's friends wanted to talk to him. "An ugly little boy creeping about," Mr. Fordham calls him. "Cecil had no vanity," writes Mrs.

    Kidd, "and thoroughly appreciated the fact that he was not beautiful; when he was about 14 he said at dinner one day: 'I think I shall marry X (a very plain cousin); between us we might produce the missing link.' Aunt Marie was shocked!"

    Many of the games arise from the skill in drawing of both Gilbert and his father. A long history of two of the Masters drawn by Gilbert shows them in the Salvation Army, as Christy Minstrels, as editors of a new revolutionary paper, "La Guillotine," as besieged in their office by a mob headed by Lord Salisbury, the Archbishop of Canterbury and other Conservative leaders. Getting tired at last of the adventures of these two mild scholars, Gilbert starts a series of Shakespeare plays drawn in modern dress.

    Shylock as an aged Hebrew vendor of dilapidated vesture, with a
    tiara of hats, Antonio as an opulent and respectable city-merchant,
    Bassanio as a fashionable swell and Gratiano as his loud and
    disreputable "pal" with large checks and a billy-cock hat. Portia was
    attired as a barrister in wig and gown and Nerissa as a clerk with a
    green bag and a pen behind his ear. This being much appreciated, Your
    Humble Servant questions what portion of the Bard of Avon he shall
    next burlesque.

    The little group seems certainly at this date to be living in a land in which 'tis always afternoon. In one house or another tea-time goes on until signs of dinner make their appearance. The boys only move from one hospitable dining-room to another, or adjourn to their own bedrooms where Gilbert piles book on book and reduces even neat shelves to the same chaos that reigns in his own room.

    The Christmas holidays to which the "dramatic journal" belongs came a few months after the founding of the Junior Debating Club, which became so central in Gilbert's life and which he treated with a gravity, solemnity even, such as he never showed later for any cause, a gravity untouched by humour. It was a group of about a dozen boys, started with the idea that it should be a Shakespeare Club, but immediately changed into a general discussion club. They met every week at the home of one or other and after a hearty tea some member read a paper which was then debated.

    At the age of twenty, when he had left school two years, G.K. wrote a solemn history of this institution in which the question of whether it was right or wrong to insist on penny fines for rowdy behaviour is canvassed with passionate feeling! One boy who was expelled asked to be readmitted, saying, "I feel so lonely without it." Gilbert's enthusiasm over this incident could be no greater had he been a bishop welcoming the return of an apostate to the Christian fold.

    I suppose it was partly because of his early solitary life at school, partly because of the general trend of his thought, partly that at this later date he was under the influence of Walt Whitman and cast back upon his earlier years a sort of glow or haze of Whitman idealism. Anyhow, the Junior Debating Club became to him a symbol of the ideal friendship. They were Knights of the Round Table. They were Jongleurs de Dieu. They were the Human Club through whom and in whom he had made the grand discovery of Man. They were his youth personified.

    The note is still struck in the letters of his engagement period, and it was only forty years later, writing his Autobiography, that he was able to picture with a certain humorous detachment this group of boys who met to eat buns and criticise the universe.

    A year after their first meeting, the energy of Lucian Oldershaw produced a magazine called The Debater. At first it was turned out at home on a duplicator--the efficiency of the production being such that the author of any given paper was able occasionally to recognise a few words of his own contribution. Later it was printed and gives a good record of the meetings and discussions. It shows the energy and ardour of the debaters and also their serious view of themselves and their efforts. At first they are described as Mr. C, Mr. F, etc.

    Later the full name is given. Besides the weekly debates, they started a Library, a Chess Club, a Naturalists' Society and a Sketching Club, regular meetings of which are chronicled.

    "The Chairman [G.K.C.] said a few words," runs a record, after some months of existence, "stating his pride at the success of the Club, and his belief in the good effect such a literary institution might have as a protest against the lower and unworthy phases of school life. His view having been vehemently corroborated, the meeting broke up."

    In one fairly typical month papers were read on "Three Comedies of Shakespeare," "Pope," and "Herodotus," and when no paper was produced there was a discussion on Capital Punishment. In another, the subjects were "The Brontës," "Macaulay as an Essayist," "Frank Buckland" (the naturalist) and "Tennyson." A pretty wide range of reading was called for from schoolboys in addition to their ordinary work, even though on one occasion the Secretary sternly notes that the reading of the paper occupied only three and one-half minutes.

    But they were not daunted by difficulties or afraid of bold attempts.

    Mr. Digby d'Avigdor on one occasion "delivered a paper entitled 'The Nineteenth Century: A Retrospect.' He gave a slight resumé of the principal events, with appropriate tribute to the deceased great of this century."

    Mr. Bertram, reading a paper on Milton, "dealt critically with his various poems, noting the effective style of 'L'Allegro,' giving the story of the writing of 'Comus' and cursorily analysing 'Paradise Lost,' and 'Paradise Regained.'"

    "After discussing the adaptability of Hamlet to the stage, Mr.

    Maurice Solomon"--who may have been quite fifteen--"passed on to review the chief points in the character of the Prince of Denmark, concluding with a slight review of the other characters which he did not think Shakespeare had given much attention to."

    In a discussion on the new humorists, we find the Secretary "taking grievous umbrage at certain unwarrantable attacks which he considered Mr. Andrew Lang had lately made on these choice spirits." This discussion arose from a paper by the Chairman on the new school of poetry "in which, in spite of its good points, he condemned the absence of the sentiment of the moral, which he held to be the really stirring and popular element in literature."

    Evidently some of his friends tended towards a youthful cynicism for in a paper on Barrie's Window in Thrums Gilbert apologises to "such of you as are much bitten with the George Moore state of mind."

    The book which describes the rusty emotions and toilsome lives of the Thrums weavers will always remain a book that has given me something, and the fact that mine is merely the popular view and that what I feel in it can be equally felt by the majority of fellow-creatures, this fact, such is my hardened and abandoned state, only makes me like the book more. I have long found myself in that hopeless minority that is engaged in protecting the majority of mankind from the attacks of all men. . . .

    In this sentiment we recognise the G.K. that is to be, but not when we find him seconding Mr. Bentley in the motion that "a scientific education is much more useful than a classic."

    "Mr. M," reading a paper on Herodotus, "gave a minute account of the life of the historian, dwelling much upon the doubt and controversy surrounding his birth and several incidents of his history"; while "Mr. F. read a paper on Newspapers, tracing their growth from the Acta Diurna of the later Roman Empire to the hordes of papers of the present day."

    Perhaps best of all these efforts was that of Mr. L.D., who "after describing the governments of England, France, Russia, Germany and the United States, proceeded to give his opinion on their various merits, first saying that he personally was a republican."

    Of the boys that appear in The Debater, Robert Vernède was killed in the Great War; Laurence Solomon at his death in 1940 was Senior Tutor of University College, London; his brother Maurice who became one of the Directors of the General Electric Company is now an invalid. I read a year or so ago an interesting Times obituary of Mr. Bertram, who was Director of Civil Aviation in the Air Ministry;

    Mr. Salter became a Principal in the Treasury, having practised as a solicitor up to the War; Mr. Fordham, a barrister, was one of the Legal Advisers to the Ministry of Labour and has now retired.

    The two outstanding "debaters" in G.K.'s life were Lucian Oldershaw who became his brother-in-law and will often reappear in these pages, and Edmund Clerihew Bentley, his friend of friends. Closely united as was the whole group, Lucian Oldershaw once told me that they were frantically jealous of one another: "We would have done anything to get the first place with Gilbert."

    "But you know," I said "who had it."

    "Yes," he replied, "our jealousy of Bentley was overwhelming."

    Mr. Bentley became a journalist and was for long on the editorial staff of the Daily Telegraph, but he is best known for his detective stories--especially Trent's Last Case--and as the inventor of a special form of rhyme, known from his second name as the Clerihew. He wrote the first of these while still at school, and the best were later published in a volume called Biography for Beginners, which G.K. illustrated. Everyone has his favourite. My own is:

    Sir Christopher Wren
    Said "I am going to dine with some men,
    If anybody calls
    Say I'm designing St. Paul's."

    Or possibly:

    The people of Spain think Cervantes
    Equal to half-a-dozen Dantes,
    An opinion resented most bitterly
    By the people of Italy.

    Bentley was essentially a holiday as well as term-time companion and when they were not together a large correspondence between the two boys gives some idea of how and where Gilbert spent his summer holidays. They are very much schoolboy letters and not worth quoting at full length, but it is interesting to compare both style and content with the later letters. All the letters begin "Dear Bentley."

    The first use of his Christian name only occurs after both had left school.

    Austria House
    Pier Street
    Ventnor, Isle of Wight
    (undated, probably 1890)

    Although you dropt some hints about Paris when you were last
    in our humble abode, I presume that this letter, if addressed to your
    usual habitation, will reach you at some period. Ventnor, where, as
    you will perceive we are, is, I will not say built upon hills, but
    emptied into the cracks and clefts of rocks so that the geography of
    the town is curious and involved. . . .

    My brother is intent upon "The Three Midshipmen" or "The Three
    Admirals" or the three coal-scuttles or some other distinguished trio
    by that interminable ass Kingston. I looked at it today and wondered
    how I ever could have enjoyed his eternal slave schooners and African
    stations. I would not give a page of "Mansfield Park" or a verse of
    "In Memoriam" for all the endless fighting of blacks and boarding of
    pirates through which the three hypocritical vagabonds ever went. I
    am getting old.

    How old it will shortly be necessary for me to state
    precisely, for, as you doubtless know there is going to be a
    Census. . . .

    I have been trying to knock into shape a story, such as we spoke
    about the other day, about the first introduction of Tea, and I should
    be glad of your assistance and suggestions. I think I shall lay the
    scene in Holland where the merits of tea were first largely agitated,
    and fill the scene with the traditional Dutch figures such as I sketch.
    I find in Disraeli's "Curiosities of Literature" which I consulted
    before coming away that a French writer wrote an elaborate treatise
    to prove that tea merchants were always immoral members of society.
    It would be rather curious to apply the theory to the present
    day. . . .

    11, Warwick Gardens,
    Kensington.
    (undated.)

    I direct this letter to your ancient patrimonial estate unknowing
    whether it will reach you or where it will reach you if it does;
    whether you are shooting polar bears on the ice-fields of Spitzbergen
    or cooking missionaries among the cannibals of the South Pacific.
    But wherever you are I find some considerable relief in turning from
    the lofty correspondence of the secretary (with no disparagement
    of my much-esteemed friend, Oldershaw) to another friend
    (ifelow-mecallimso as Mr.

    Verdant Greene said) who can discourse on
    some other subjects besides the Society, and who will not devote the
    whole of his correspondence to the questions of that excellent and
    valuable body. The Society is a very good thing in its way (being
    the President I naturally think so) but like other good things, you
    may have too much of it, and I have had. . . .

    As I said before, I don't know where you are disporting yourself,
    beyond some hurried remark about Paris which you dropped in our
    hurried interview in one of the "brilliant flashes of silence" between
    those imbecile screams and yells and stamping, which even the
    natural enthusiasm at the prospect of being "broken up" cannot
    excuse.

    6, The Quadrant,
    North Berwick, Haddington,
    Scotland.
    (? 1891.)

    You will probably guess that as far as personal taste and instincts
    are concerned, I share all your antipathy to the noisy Plebian
    excursionist. A visit to Ramsgate during the season and the vision of
    the crowded, howling sands has left in me feelings which all my
    Radicalism cannot allay. At the same time I think that the lower
    orders are seen unfavorably when enjoying themselves. In labour and
    trouble they are more dignified and less noisy. Your suggestion as to
    a series of soliloquies is very flattering and has taken hold of me
    to the extent of writing a similar ballad on Simon de Montfort.

    The
    order in which they come is rather incongruous, particularly if I
    include the list I have in mind for the future thus--Danton, William
    III, Simon de Montfort, Rousseau, David and Russell. . . . I rejoice
    to say that this is a sequestered spot into which Hi tiddly hi ti,
    etc. and all the ills in its train have not penetrated.

    In these last two letters there are sentences of a kind not to be found anywhere else in Chesterton. The disparagement of Lucian Oldershaw's excessive enthusiasm for the Junior Debating Club, the solemn reprobation of the "imbecile screams and yells and stamping" of the last day at school before the summer holidays, the antipathy expressed for the rowdy enjoyments of the lower orders--these things are not in the least like either the Chesterton that was to be or the Chesterton that then was. But they are very much like Bentley.

    He was two years younger than Chesterton, but far older than his years and seemed indeed to the other boys (and perhaps to himself) like an elderly gentleman smiling a remote amused smile at the enthusiasms of the young. I get the strongest feeling that at this stage Chesterton not only admired him--as he was to do all his life--but wanted to be like him, to say the kind of thing he thought Bentley would say. This phase did not last, as we shall see; it had gone by the time Chesterton was at the Slade School.

    6, The Quadrant,
    North Berwick
    Haddington, Scotland.
    (undated, probably 1891.)

    DEAR BENTLEY,

    We have been here three days and my brother loudly murmurs that we
    have not yet seen any of "the sights." For my part I abominate
    sights, and all people who want to look at them. A great deal more
    instruction, to say nothing of pleasure is to be got out of the
    nearest haystack or hedgerow taken quietly, than in trotting over two
    or three counties to see "the view" or "the site" or the
    extraordinary cliff or the unusual tower or the unreasonable hill or
    any other monstrosity deforming the face of Nature.

    Anybody can make
    sights but nobody has yet succeeded in making scenery. (Excuse the
    unaccountable pencil drawing in the middle which was drawn
    unconsciously on the back of the unfinished letter.) . . .

    9, South Terrace,
    Littlehampton, Sussex.
    (undated.)

    . . . I agree with you in your admiration for Paradise Lost, but
    consider it on the whole too light and childish a book for persons of
    our age. It is all very well, as small children to read pretty
    stories about Satan and Belial, when we have only just mastered our
    "Oedipus" and our Herbert Spencer, but when we grow older we get to
    like Captain Marryat and Mr. Kingston and when we are men we know
    that Cinderella is much better than any of those babyish books.

    As
    regards one question which you asked, I may remark that the children
    of Israel [presumably the Solomons] have not gone unto Horeb, neither
    unto Sittim, but unto the land that is called Shropshire they went,
    and abode therein. And they came unto a city, even unto the city that
    is called Shrewsbury, and there they builded themselves an home,
    where they might abide. And their home was in the land that was
    called Castle Street and their home was the 25th tabernacle in that
    land. And they abode with certain of their own kin until their season
    be over and gone.

    And lo! they spake unto me by letter, saying,
    "Heard ye aught of him that is called Bentley? Is he in the house of
    his fathers or has he come unto a strange land?" Here endeth the 2nd
    Lesson.

    Hotel de Lille & d'Albion,
    223, Rue St. Honoré,
    Paris.
    (undated, probably 1892.)

    . . . They showed us over the treasures of the Cathedral, among
    which, as was explained by the guide, who spoke a little English, was
    a cross given by Louis XIV to "Meess" Lavallière. I thought that
    concession to the British system of titles was indeed touching. I
    also thought, when reflecting what the present was, and where it was
    and then to whom it was given, that this showed pretty well what the
    religion of the Bourbon regime was and why it has become impossible
    since the Revolution.

    Grand Hotel du Chemin de Fer,
    Arromanches (Calvados)
    (undated)

    . . . Art is universal. This remark is not so irrelevant and Horace
    Greeley-like as it may appear. I have just had a demonstration of its
    truth on the coach coming down here. Two very nice little French boys
    of cropped hair and restless movements were just in front of us and
    my pater having discovered that the book they had with them was a
    prize at a Paris school, some slight conversation arose. Not thinking
    my French altogether equal to a prolonged interview, I took out a
    scrap of paper and began, with a fine carelessness to draw a picture
    of Napoleon I, hat, chin, attitude, all complete.

    This, of course,
    was gazed at rapturously by these two young inheritors of France's
    glory and it ended in my drawing them unlimited goblins to keep for
    the remainder of the interview.

    In May 1891, the Chairman of the J.D.C. attained the maturity of seventeen.

    The Secretary then rose and in a speech in which he extolled the
    merits of the Chairman as a chairman, and mentioned the benefit which
    the Junior Debating Club received on the day of which this was the
    anniversary, viz., the natal day of Mr. Chesterton, proposed that a
    vote wishing him many happy returns of the day and a long continuance
    in the Chair of the Club should be passed. This was carried with
    acclamations. The Chairman replied after restoring Order. . . .

    Naturally this question of order among a crowd of boys loomed large.

    At the beginning a number of rules were passed giving great powers to the Chairman, "which that gentleman," he says of himself, "lenient by temperament and republican by principles, certainly would never have put in force. . . . It was seldom enough," he continues:

    that a boy of fifteen* found himself in the position of the
    Chairman, an attitude of command and responsibility over a body of
    his friends and equals, and it was not to be expected that they would
    easily take to the state of things. Nor was the Chairman himself,
    like the Secretary, protected and armed by any personal aptitude for
    practical proceedings. But solely by the certain degree of respect
    entertained for his character and acquirements.

    This respect, sincere
    and even excessive as it frequently was, contrasted somewhat
    humorously with the common inattention to questions of order, nor
    could anything be more noisy than the loyalty of Fordham and Langdon
    Davies, with the exception of their interruptions.

    It may then fairly
    be said that the troubles and discussions of the first months of the
    Club's existence centred practically round the question of order, the
    first of the great difficulties of this most difficult enterprise.
    How boys who could scarcely be got to behave quietly under the
    strictest schoolmasters could ever be brought to obey the rebuke of
    their equal and schoolfellow: how a heterogeneous pack of average
    schoolboys could organise themselves into a self-governing republic,
    these were problems of real and stupendous difficulty.

    The fines of a
    penny and of twopence, which were instituted at the first meeting,
    were found hopelessly incompetent to cope with the bursts of
    oblivious hilarity. Fordham in particular, whose constant breaches of
    order threatened to exhaust even the extensive treasury of that
    spoilt and opulent young gentleman, soon left calculation far behind,
    nor can the story be better or more brightly told than by himself.
    "Mr.

    F.," he wrote, "at one time, after considerable calculation
    found that he was in debt to the extent of some 10 or 11 shillings;
    but as he felt that by refusing to pay the sum he would be striking a
    blow for the liberty of the subject, he manfully held out against
    what he considered an unjust punishment for such diminutive
    frivolities as he had indulged in." . . . At times incidents of a
    disturbing and playful nature have roused the wrath of the Chairman
    and Secretary to a pitch awful to behold. At one time Mr.

    H. (a
    member who soon resigned) spent a considerable part of a meeting
    under the table, till he found himself used as a public footstool and
    a doormat combined. At another as Mr. Bentley was departing from the
    scene of chaos a penny bun of the sticky order caressingly stung his
    honoured cheek, sped upon its errand of mercy by the unerring aim of
    Mr. F.**

    [* He was, in fact, sixteen when the J.D.C. began.]

    [** MS. History of the J.D.C.]

    Mr. Fordham well remembers how G.K. one day took him aside at the Oldershaws' house and told him that he really must be less exuberant. This historic occasion was always alluded to later as "the day on which the Chairman spoke seriously to Mr. F."

    After various resignations order was restored, and a little later two of the chief recalcitrants asked to be received back into the Club. "I feel so lonely without it," one of them had remarked; and G.K. comments, "This has always appeared to the present writer one of the most important speeches in the history of the Club. . . . The Junior Debating Club had come through its moments of difficulty and was a fact and an establishment."

    Nor was the circulation of The Debater long confined to members of the Club and their own circle of friends and relatives. Some of the boys had no doubt a regular allowance, but probably a small one.

    Gilbert himself says in his diary that he had no income "except errant sixpences." And printers' bills had to be paid.

    Moreover in the first number the editor Lucian Oldershaw confessed frankly that one reason for the paper's existence was "that the Society may not degenerate into the position of a mutual admiration Society by totally lacking the admiration of outsiders." The staff were able immediately to note, "Any apprehensions we may have felt on the morning of the publication of The Debater were speedily dispelled, when by nightfall we had disposed of all our copies." Of a later issue the energetic editor sold sixty-five copies in the course of the summer holidays.

    Masters, too, began to read it and at last a copy was hid on the table of the High Master, Mr. Walker. Cecil Chesterton describes the High Master as a gigantic man with a booming voice. Some Paulines believed he had given Gilbert the first inspiration for the personality of "Sunday" in The Man Who Was Thursday. Another contemporary says that he was reputed to take no interest in anything except examination successes, and that the boys were amazed at the effect on him of reading The Debater.

    Reading in the light of his future, one sees qualities in Gilbert's work not to be found in that of the other contributors, but it is worth noting that the J.D.C. members were in fact a quite unusually able group.

    Almost every one of them took brilliant scholarships to Oxford or Cambridge; the High Master had never boasted of so many scholarships from one set of boys. And in reading The Debater (an enjoyment I wish others could share) one has to bear in mind the relative ages of the contributors. It is, I think, striking that all these boys should have recognised Gilbert's quality and accepted his leadership, for they were all a year or so younger than he was and yet were in the same form. They knew that this was only because G.K. would not bother to do his school work; still, I think that at that age they showed insight by knowing it.

    Gilbert's work is to be found in every number of The Debater--usually verse as well as prose. Both Fordham and Oldershaw remember most vividly the effect of reading a fanciful essay on Dragons in the first number. "The Dragon," it began, "is the most cosmopolitan of impossibilities." And the boys, rolling the words on their tongues, murmured to one another, "This is literature."

    Except for a very occasional flash the one element not yet visible in these Debater essays is humour. This is curious, because some of his most brilliant fooling belongs to the same period. In a collection made after his death, The Coloured Lands is an illustrated jeu d'esprit of 1891, Half Hours in Hades: "an elementary handbook of demonology" which is as amusing a thing as he ever wrote.

    The drawings he made for it show specimens of the evolution of various types of devil into various types of humans: the devils themselves are carefully classified--the common or garden serpent (Tentator Hortensis), the red devil (Diabolus Mephistopheles) the blue devil (Caeruleus Lugubrius) etc. Mr. J. Milton's "specimen" is discussed and various methods of pursuing observations in supernatural history which "possesses an interest which will remain after health, youth and even life have departed."

    There is nothing of this kind in The Debater. Besides the historical soliloquies mentioned in the letter to Bentley, there are poems in which he is beginning to feel after his religious philosophy. One of these in a very early number shows considerable power for a boy not yet seventeen.

    ADVENIAT REGNUM TUUM

    Not that the widespread wings of wrong brood o'er a moaning earth,
    Not from the clinging curse of gold, the random lot of birth;
    Not from the misery of the weak, the madness of the strong,
    Goes upward from our lips the cry, "How long, oh Lord, how long?"
    Not only from the huts of toil, the dens of sin and shame,
    From lordly halls and peaceful homes the cry goes up the same;
    Deep in the heart of every man, where'er his life be spent,
    There is a noble weariness, a holy discontent.
    Where'er to mortal eyes has come, in silence dark and lone,
    Some glimmer of the far-off light the world has never known,
    Some ghostly echoes from a dream of earth's triumphal song,
    Then as the vision fades we cry, "How long, oh Lord, how long?"
    Long ages, from the dawn of time, men's toiling march has wound
    Towards the world they ever sought, the world they never found;
    Still far before their toiling path the glimmering promise lay,
    Still hovered round the struggling race, a dream by night and day.
    Mid darkening care and clinging sin they sought their unknown home,
    Yet ne'er the perfect glory came--Lord, will it ever come?
    The weeding of earth's garden broad from all its growths of wrong,
    When all man's soul shall be a prayer, and all his life a song.
    Aye, though through many a starless night we guard the flaming oil,
    Though we have watched a weary watch, and toiled a weary toil,
    Though in the midnight wilderness, we wander still forlorn,
    Yet bear we in our hearts the proof that God shall send the dawn.
    Deep in the tablets of our hearts he writes that yearning still,
    The longing that His hand hath wrought shall not his hand fulfil?
    Though death shall close upon us all before that hour we see,
    The goal of ages yet is there--the good time yet to be:
    Therefore, tonight, from varied lips, in every house and home,
    Goes up to God the common prayer, "Father, Thy Kingdom come."*

    [* The Debater, Vol. I. March-April, 1891.]

    Gilbert's prose work in The Debater must have been little less surprising to any master who had merely watched him slumbering at a desk. His historical romance "The White Cockade" is immature and unimportant. But essays on Spenser, Milton, Pope, Gray, Cowper, Burns, Wordsworth, "Humour in Fiction," "Boys' Literature," Sir Walter Scott, Browning, the English Dramatists, showed a range and a quality of literary criticism alike surprising. Perhaps most surprising, however, is the fact that all this does not seem to have made clear to either masters or parents the true nature of Gilbert's vocation.

    He suffered at this date from having too many talents. For he still went on drawing and his drawings seemed to many the most remarkable thing about him, and were certainly the thing he most enjoyed doing.

    Even now his school work had not brought him into the highest form--called not the Sixth, as in most schools, but the Eighth: the highest form he ever reached was 6B. But in the Summer term of 1892 he entered a competition for a prize poem, and won it. The subject chosen was St. Francis Xavier. I give the poem in Appendix A. It is not as notable as some other of his work at that time: what is interesting is that in it this schoolboy expresses with some power a view he was later to explode yet more powerfully. He might have claimed for himself what he said of earlier writers--it is not true that they did not see our modern difficulties: they saw through them.

    Never before had this contest been won by any but an Eighth Form boy, and almost immediately afterwards Gilbert was amazed to find a short notice posted on the board: "G. K. Chesterton to rank with the Eighth.--F. W. Walker, High Master."

    The High Master at any rate had travelled far from the atmosphere of the form reports when Mrs. Chesterton visited him in 1894 to ask his advice about her son's future. For he said, "Six foot of genius.

    Cherish him, Mrs. Chesterton, cherish him."

    CHAPTER IV

    Art Schools and University College

    WHEN ALL GILBERT'S friends were at Oxford or Cambridge, he used to say how glad he was that his own choice had been a different one. He never sighed for Oxford. He never regretted his rather curious experiences at an Art School--two Art Schools really, although he only talks of one in the Autobiography, for he was for a short time at a School of Art in St. John's Wood (Calderon's, Lawrence Solomon thought), whence he passed to the Slade School. He was there from 1892 to 1895 and during part of that time he attended lectures on English Literature at University College.

    The chapter on the experiences of the next two years is called in the Autobiography, "How to be a Lunatic," and there is no doubt that these years were crucial and at times crucifying in Gilbert's life.

    During a happily prolonged youth (he was now eighteen and a half) he had developed very slowly, but normally. Surrounded by pleasant friendships and home influences he had never really become aware of evil. Now it broke upon him suddenly--probably to a degree exaggerated by his strong imagination and distorted by the fact that he was undergoing physical changes usually belonging to an earlier age.

    Towards the end of his school life Gilbert's voice had not yet broken. His mother took him to a doctor to be overhauled and was told that his brain was the largest and most sensitive the doctor had ever seen. "A genius or an idiot" was his verdict on the probabilities.

    Above all things she was told to avoid for him any sort of shock.

    Physically, mentally, spiritually he was on a very large scale and probably for that reason of a slow rate of development. The most highly differentiated organisms are the slowest to mature, and without question Gilbert did mature very late. He was now passing through the stage described by Keats: "The imagination of a boy is healthy and the mature imagination of a man is healthy; but there is a space of life between"--a period unhealthy or at least ill-focussed.

    Intellectually Gilbert suffered at this time from an extreme scepticism. As he expressed it he "felt as if everything might be a dream" as if he had "projected the universe from within." The agnostic doubts the existence of God. Gilbert at moments doubted the existence of the agnostic.

    Morally his temptations seem to have been in some strange psychic region rather than merely physical. The whole period is best summarised in a passage from the Autobiography, for looking back after forty years Gilbert still saw it as deeply and darkly significant: as both a mental and moral extreme of danger.

    There is something truly menacing in the thought of how quickly I
    could imagine the maddest, when I had never committed the mildest
    crime . . . there was a time when I had reached that condition of
    moral anarchy within, in which a man says, in the words of Wilde,
    that "Atys with the blood-stained knife were better than the thing I
    am." I have never indeed felt the faintest temptation to the
    particular madness of Wilde, but I could at this time imagine the
    worst and wildest disproportions and distortions of more normal
    passion; the point is that the whole mood was overpowered and
    oppressed with a sort of congestion of imagination.

    As Bunyan, in his
    morbid period, described himself as prompted to utter blasphemies, I
    had an overpowering impulse to record or draw horrible ideas and
    images; lunging deeper and deeper as in a blind spiritual suicide.*

    [* Pp. 88-9.]

    Two of his intimate friends, finding at this time a notebook full of these horrible drawings, asked one another, "Is Chesterton going mad?"

    He dabbled too in spiritualism until he realised that he had reached the verge of forbidden and dangerous ground:

    I would not altogether rule out the suggestion of some that we were
    playing with fire; or even with hell-fire. In the words that were
    written for us there was nothing ostensibly degrading, but any amount
    that was deceiving. I saw quite enough of the thing to be able to
    testify with complete certainty, that something happens which is not
    in the ordinary sense natural, or produced by the normal and
    conscious human will.

    Whether it is produced by some subconscious but
    still human force, or by some powers, good, bad, or indifferent,
    which are external to humanity, I would not myself attempt to decide.
    The only thing I will say with complete confidence, about that mystic
    and invisible power, is that it tells lies. The lies may be larks or
    they may be lures to the imperilled soul or they may be a thousand
    other things; but whatever they are, they are not truths about the
    other world; or for that matter about this world.*

    [*Autobiography, p. 77.]

    He told Father O'Connor some years later* that "he had used the planchette freely at one time, but had to give it up on account of headaches ensuing . . . 'after the headaches came a horrid feeling as if one were trying to get over a bad spree, with what I can best describe as a bad smell in the mind.'"

    [*Father Brown on Chesterton, p. 74.]

    Idling at his work he fell in with other idlers and has left a vivid description in a Daily News article called, "The Diabolist," of one of his fellow students.

    . . . It was strange, perhaps, that I liked his dirty, drunken
    society; it was stranger still, perhaps, that he liked my society.
    For hours of the day he would talk with me about Milton or Gothic
    architecture; for hours of the night he would go where I have no wish
    to follow him, even in speculation. He was a man with a long,
    ironical face, and close red hair; he was by class a gentleman, and
    could walk like one, but preferred, for some reason, to walk like a
    groom carrying two pails. He looked like a sort of super-jockey; as
    if some archangel had gone on the Turf.

    And I shall never forget the
    half-hour in which he and I argued about real things for the first
    and last time.

    . . . He had a horrible fairness of the intellect that made me
    despair of his soul. A common, harmless atheist would have denied
    that religion produced humility or humility a simple joy; but he
    admitted both. He only said, "But shall I not find in evil a life of
    its own? Granted that for every woman I ruin one of those red sparks
    will go out; will not the expanding pleasure of ruin . . ."

    "Do you see that fire?" I asked. "If we had a real fighting
    democracy, some one would burn you in it; like the devil-worshipper
    that you are."

    "Perhaps," he said, in his tired, fair way. "Only what you call
    evil I call good."

    He went down the great steps alone, and I felt as if I wanted the
    steps swept and cleaned. I followed later, and as I went to find my
    hat in the low, dark passage where it hung, I suddenly heard his
    voice again, but the words were inaudible. I stopped, startled; but
    then I heard the voice of one of the vilest of his associates saying,
    "Nobody can possibly know." And then I heard those two or three words
    which I remember in every syllable and cannot forget. I heard the
    Diabolist say, "I tell you I have done everything else.

    If I do that
    I shan't know the difference between right and wrong." I rushed out
    without daring to pause; and as I passed the fire I did not know
    whether it was hell or the furious love of God.

    I have since heard that he died; it may be said, I think, that he
    committed suicide; though he did it with tools of pleasure, not with
    tools of pain. God help him, I know the road he went; but I have
    never known or even dared to think what was that place at which he
    stopped and refrained.*

    [* Quoted in G. K. Chesterton: A Criticism. Alston Rivers Ltd. 1908, pp. 20-22.]

    Revulsion from the atmosphere of evil took Gilbert to no new thing but to a strengthening of old ties and a mystic renewal of them. The J.D.C. was idealised into a mystical city of friends:

    A LIST

    I know a friend, very strong and good. He is the best friend in the
    world,

    I know another friend, subtle and sensitive. He is certainly the best
    friend on earth.

    I know another friend: very quiet and shrewd, there is no friend so
    good as he.

    I know another friend, who is enigmatical and reluctant, he is the
    best of all.

    I know yet another: who is polished and eager, he is far better
    than the rest.

    I know another, who is young and very quick, he is the most beloved
    of all friends,

    I know a lot more and they are all like that.

    Amen.

    THE COSMIC FACTORIES

    What are little boys made of?

    Bentley is made of hard wood with a knot in it, a complete set of
    Browning and a strong spring;

    Oldershaw of a box of Lucifer matches and a stylographic pen;

    Lawrence of a barrister's wig: files of Punch and salt,

    Maurice of watch-wheels, three riders and a clean collar.

    Vernède is made of moonlight and tobacco,

    Bertram is mostly a handsome black walking-stick.

    Waldo is a nice cabbage, with a vanishing odour of cigarettes,

    Salter is made of sand and fire and an university extension ticket.

    But the strongest element in all can not be expressed; I think it
    is a sort of star.*

    [* From The Notebook.]

    There are fragments of a Morality Play entitled "The Junior Debating Club," of a modern novel in which everyone of the Debaters makes his appearance, of a mediaeval story called "The Legend of Sir Edmund of the Brotherhood of the Jongleurs de Dieu." Notes, fragments, letters, all show an intense individual interest that covered the life of each of his friends. If one of them is worried, he worries too; if one rejoices, he rejoices exceedingly.

    They write to him about their ideas and views, their relations with one another, their reactions in the world of Oxford life, their love affairs. "I am in need of some literary tonic or blood-letting," says Vernède, "which you alone can supply."

    "I only hope," writes Bertram, "you may be as much use in the world in future as you have been in the past to your friends."

    "Most of the absent Club," writes Salter separated from the others, "lie together in my pocket at this moment." And Gilbert writes in The Notebook:

    AN IDYLL

    Tea is made; the red fogs shut round the house but the gas burns.
    I wish I had at this moment round the table
    A company of fine people.
    Two of them are at Oxford and one in Scotland and two at other
    places.
    But I wish they would all walk in now, for the tea is made.

    Gilbert was devoted to them all. But as we have seen, Bentley's was the supreme friendship of his youth. It was a friendship in foolery as we are told by the dedication of Greybeards at Play:

    He was through boyhood's storm and shower
    My best my nearest friend,
    We wore one hat, smoked one cigar
    One standing at each end.

    It was a deeply serious friendship as we are told in the dedication of The Man Who Was Thursday. With Bentley alone he shared the

    Doubts that drove us through the night as we two talked amain,
    And day had broken on the streets ere it broke upon the brain.

    Most young men write or at least begin novels of which they are themselves the heroes. Gilbert wrote and illustrated a fairy story about a boyish romance of Lucian Oldershaw's while two unfinished novels have Bentley for hero. He is, too, in the mediaeval story, Sir Edmund of the Brotherhood of the Jongleurs de Dieu. Gilbert sings, like all young poets, of first love--but it is Bentley's not his own: he was as much excited about a girl Bentley had fallen in love with as if he had fallen in love with her himself.

    And where a London street has a special significance one discovers it is because of a memory of Bentley's. To Bentley then, with whom all was shared, Gilbert wrote, when through friendship and the goodness of things he had come out again into the daylight. The second thought that had saved him had largely grown out of the first. The J.D.C. meant friendship. Friendship meant the highest of all good things and all good things called for gratitude. As he gave thanks he drew near to God.

    Dunedin Lodge
    Forth Street
    North Berwick.
    (undated, but probably Long Vac., 1894.)

    Your letter was most welcome: in which, however, it does not differ
    widely from most of your letters. I read somewhere in some fatuous
    Complete Letter-writer or something, that it is correct to imitate
    the order of subjects, etc. observed by your correspondent. In
    obedience to this rule of breeding I will hurriedly remark that my
    holiday has been nice enough in itself; we walk about; lie on the
    sand; go and swim in the sea when it generally rains; and the
    combination gets in our mouths and we say the name of the Professor
    in the "Water Babies." Inwardly speaking, I have had a funny time.

    A
    meaningless fit of depression, taking the form of certain absurd
    psychological worries came upon me, and instead of dismissing it and
    talking to people, I had it out and went very far into the abysses,
    indeed. The result was that I found that things when examined,
    necessarily spelt such a mystically satisfactory state of things,
    that without getting back to earth, I saw lots that made me certain
    it is all right. The vision is fading into common day now, and I am
    glad. The frame of mind was the reverse of gloomy, but it would not
    do for long.

    It is embarrassing, talking with God face to face, as a
    man speaketh to his friend.

    And in another letter:

    A cosmos one day being rebuked by a pessimist replied, "How can you
    who revile me consent to speak by my machinery? Permit me to reduce
    you to nothingness and then we will discuss the matter." Moral. You
    should not look a gift universe in the mouth.

    Another powerful influence in the direction of mental health was the discovery of Walt Whitman's poetry. "I shall never forget," Lucian Oldershaw writes, "reading to him from the Canterbury Walt Whitman in my bedroom at West Kensington. The séance lasted from two to three hours, and we were intoxicated with the excitement of the discovery."

    For some time now we shall find Gilbert dismissing belief in any positive existence of evil and treating the universe on the Whitman principle of jubilant and universal acceptance. He writes, too, in the Whitman style. By far the most important of his notebooks is one which, by amazing good fortune, can be dated, beginning in 1894 and continuing for several years. In its attitude to man it is Whitmanesque to a high degree, yet it is also most characteristically Chestertonian. Whitman is content with a shouting, roaring optimism about life and humanity. Chesterton had to find for it a philosophical basis.

    Heartily as he disliked the literary pessimism of the hour, he was not content simply to exchange one mood for another. For whether he was conscious of it at the time or not, he did later see Walt Whitman's outlook as a mood and not a philosophy.

    It was a mood, however, that Chesterton himself never really lost, solely because he did discover the philosophy needed to sustain it.

    And thereby, even in this early Notebook, he goes far beyond Whitman.

    Even so early he knew that a philosophy of man could not be a philosophy of man only. He already feels a presence in the universe:

    It is evening
    And into the room enters again a large indiscernable presence.
    Is it a man or a woman?
    Is it one long dead or yet to come?
    That sits with me in the evening.

    This again might have been only a mood--had he not found the philosophy to sustain it too. It is remarkable how much of this philosophy he had arrived at in The Notebook, before he had come to know Catholics. Indeed the Notebook seems to me so important that it needs a chapter to itself with abundant quotation.

    Meanwhile, what was Gilbert doing about his work at University College? Professor Fred Brown told Lawrence Solomon that when he was at the Slade School he always seemed to be writing and while listening to lectures he was always drawing. It is probably true that, as Cecil Chesterton says, he shrank from the technical toils of the artist as he never did later from those of authorship; and none of the professors regarded him as a serious art student. They pointed later to his illustrations of Biography for Beginners as proof that he never learnt to draw.

    Yet how many of the men who did learn seriously could have drawn those sketches, full of crazy energy and vitality? I know nothing about drawing, but anyone may know how brilliant are the illustrations to Greybeards at Play or Biography for Beginners, and later to Mr. Belloc's novels. And anyone can see the power of line with which he drew in his notebooks unfinished suggestions of humanity or divinity. Anyone, too, can recognise a portrait of a man, and faces full of character continue to adorn G.K.'s exercise books.

    Of living models he affected chiefly Gladstone, Balfour, and Joe Chamberlin. In hours of thought he made drawings of Our Lord with a crown of thorns or nailed to a cross--these suddenly appear in any of his books between fantastic drawings or lecture notes. As the mind wandered and lingered the fingers followed it, and as Gilbert listened to lectures, he would even draw on the top of his own notes.

    He had always had facility and that facility increased, so that in later years he often completed in a couple of hours the illustrations to a novel of Belloc's. Nor were these drawings merely illustrations of an already completed text, for Mr. Belloc has told me that the characters were often half suggested to him by his friend's drawings.

    On one, at any rate, of his vacations, Gilbert went to Italy, and two letters to Bentley show much of the way his thoughts were going:

    Hotel New York
    Florence.
    (undated, probably 1894.)

    DEAR BENTLEY,

    I turn to write my second letter to you and my first to Grey
    [Maurice Solomon], just after having a very interesting conversation
    with an elderly American like Colonel Newcome, though much better
    informed, with whom I compared notes on Botticelli, Ruskin, Carlyle,
    Emerson and the world in general. I asked him what he thought of
    Whitman. He answered frankly that in America they were "hardly up to
    him." "We have one town, Boston," he said precisely, "that has got up
    to Browning." He then added that there was one thing everyone in
    America remembered: Whitman himself.

    The old gentleman quite kindled
    on this topic, "Whitman was a real Man. A man who was so pure and
    strong that we could not imagine him doing an unmanly thing anywhere."
    It was odd words to hear at a table d'hôte, from your next door
    neighbour: it made me quite excited over my salad.

    You see that this humanitarianism in which we are entangled asserts
    itself where, by all guidebook laws, it should not. When I take up my
    pen to write to you, I am thinking more of a white-moustached old
    Yankee at an hotel than about the things I have seen within the same
    24 hours: the frescoes of Santa Croce, the illuminations of St.
    Marco; the white marbles of the tower of Giotto; the very Madonnas of
    Raphael, the very David of Michael Angelo. Throughout this tour, in
    pursuance of our theory of travelling, we have avoided the guide: he
    is the death-knell of individual liberty.

    Once only we broke through
    our rule and that was in favour of an extremely intelligent, nay
    impulsive young Italian in Santa Maria Novella, a church where we saw
    some of the most interesting pieces of mediaeval painting I have ever
    seen, interesting not so much from an artistic as from a moral and
    historical point of view. Particularly noticeable was the great
    fresco expressive of the grandest mediaeval conception of the
    Communion of Saints, a figure of Christ surmounting a crowd of all
    ages and stations, among whom were not only Dante, Petrarca, Giotto,
    etc., etc., but Plato, Cicero, and best of all, Arius.

    I said to the
    guide, in a tone of expostulation, "Heretico!" (a word of impromptu
    manufacture). Whereupon he nodded, smiled and was positively radiant
    with the latitudinarianism of the old Italian painter. It was
    interesting for it was a fresh proof that even the early Church
    united had a period of thought and tolerance before the dark ages
    closed around it. There is one thing that I must tell you more of
    when we meet, the tower of Giotto. It was built in a square of
    Florence, near the Cathedral, by a self-made young painter and
    architect who had kept sheep as a boy on the Tuscan hills.

    It is
    still called "The Shepherd's Tower." What I want to tell you about is
    the series of bas-reliefs, which Giotto traced on it, representing
    the creation and progress of man, his discovery of navigation,
    astronomy, law, music and so on. It is religious in the grandest
    sense, but there is not a shred of doctrine (even the Fall is
    omitted) about this history in stone. If Walt Whitman had been an
    architect, he would have built such a tower, with such a story on it.
    As I want to go out and have a good look at it before we start for
    Venice tomorrow, I must cut this short.

    I hope you are enjoying
    yourself as much as I am, and thinking about me half as much as I am
    about you.

    Your very sincere friend,
    GILBERT K. CHESTERTON.

    No one would have enjoyed more than Gilbert rereading this letter in after years and noting the suggestion that the fifteenth century belonged to the early church and preceded the Dark Ages. And I think, too, that even in Giotto's Tower, he might later have discovered some roots of doctrine.

    Grand Hotel De Milan
    (undated)

    DEAR BENTLEY,

    I write you a third letter before coming back, while Venice and
    Verona are fresh in my mind. Of the former I can really only
    discourse viva voce. Imagine a city, whose very slums are full of
    palaces, whose every other house wall has a battered fresco, or a
    gothic bas-relief; imagine a sky fretted with every kind of pinnacle
    from the great dome of the Salute to the gothic spires of the Ducal
    Palace and the downright arabesque orientalism of the minarets of St.
    Mark's; and then imagine the whole flooded with a sea that seems only
    intended to reflect sunsets, and you still have no idea of the place
    I stopped in for more than 48 hours.

    Thence we went to Verona, where
    Romeo and Juliet languished and Dante wrote most of "Hell." The
    principal products (1) tombs: particularly those of the Scala, a very
    good old family with an excellent taste in fratricide. Their three
    tombs (one to each man I mean: one man, one grave) are really
    glorious examples of three stages of Gothic: of which more when we
    meet. (2) Balconies: with young ladies hanging over them; really
    quite a preponderating feature. Whether this was done in obedience to
    local associations and in expectation of a Romeo, I can't say.

    I can
    only remark that if such was the object, the supply of Juliets seemed
    very much in excess of the demand. (3) Roman remains: on which,
    however, I did not pronounce a soliloquy beginning, "Wonderful
    people . . ." which is the correct thing to do. Just as I get to this
    I receive your letter and resolve to begin another sheet of paper. I
    did read Rosebery's speech and was more than interested; I was
    stirred.

    The old order (of parliamentary forms, peerages, Whiggism
    and right honourable friends) has changed, yielding place to the new
    (of industrialism, county council sanitation, education and the
    Kingdom of Heaven at hand) and, whatever the Archbishop of
    Canterbury may say, God fulfils himself in many ways, even by local
    government. . . .

    Several things in your letter require notice. First the accusation
    levelled against me of being prejudiced against Professor Huxley, I
    repel with indignation and scorn. You are not prejudiced against
    cheese because you like oranges; and though the Professor is not
    Isaiah or St. Francis or Whitman or Richard le Gallienne (to name
    some of those whom I happen to affect) I should be the last person in
    the world to say a word against an earnest, able, kind-hearted and
    most refreshingly rational man: by far the best man of his type I
    know.

    As to what you say on education generally, I am entirely with
    you, but it will take a good interview to say how much. As for the
    little Solomons, I am prepared to [be] fond of all of them, as I am
    of all children, even the grubby little mendicants that run these
    Italian streets. I am glad you and Grey have pottered. Potter again.
    I have had such a nice letter from Lawrence. It makes me think it is
    all going "to be the fair beginning of a time."

    Had the months of art study only developed in Gilbert Chesterton his power of drawing, they might still have been worthwhile. But they gave him, too, a time to dream and to think which working for a University degree would never have allowed. His views and his mind were developing fast, and he was also developing a power to which we owe some of his best work--depth of vision.

    Most art criticism is the work of those who never could have been artists--which is possibly why it tends to be so critical. Gilbert, who could perhaps have been an artist, preferred to appreciate what the artist was trying to say and to put into words what he read on the canvas. Hence both in his Watts and his Blake we get what some of us ask of an art critic--the enlargement of our own powers of vision. This is what made Ruskin so great an art critic, a fact once realised, today forgotten. He may have made a thousand mistakes, he had a multitude of foolish prejudices, but he opened the eyes of a whole generation to see and understand great art.

    G.K. was to begin his published writings with poetry and art criticism--in other words with vision. And this vision he partly owed to the Slade School. Here is a letter (undated) to Bentley containing a hint of what eight years later became a book on Watts:

    On Saturday I saw two exhibitions of pictures. The first was the
    Royal Academy, where I went with Salter. There was one picture there,
    though the walls were decorated with frames very prettily. As to the
    one picture, if you look at an Academy catalogue you will see
    "Jonah": by G. F. Watts, and you will imagine a big silly picture of
    a whale. But if you go to Burlington House you will see something
    terrible.

    A spare, wild figure, clad in a strange sort of green with
    his head flung so far back that his upper part is a miracle of
    foreshortening, his hands thrust out, his face ghastly with ecstasy,
    his dry lips yelling aloud, a figure of everlasting protest and
    defiance. And as a background (perfect in harmony of colour) you have
    the tracery of the Assyrian bas-reliefs, such as survive in wrecks in
    the British Museum, a row of those processions of numberless captives
    bowing before smiling Kings: a cruel sort of art.

    And the passionate
    energy of that lonely screaming figure in front, makes you think of a
    great many things besides Assyrians: among others of some words of
    Renan: I quote from memory: "But the trace of Israel will be eternal.
    She it was who alone among the tyrannies of antiquity, raised her
    voice for the helpless, the oppressed, the forgotten."

    But this only expresses a fraction of it. The only thing to do is
    to come and look at this excited gentleman with bronze skin and hair
    that approaches green, his eyes simply white with madness. And Jonah
    said, "Yea, I do well to be angry: even unto death."

    He had learnt to look at colour, to look at line, to describe pictures. But far more important than this, he could now create in the imagination gardens and sunsets and sheer colour, so as to give to his novels and stories pictorial value, to his fantasies glow, and to his poetry vision of the realities of things. In his very first volume of Essays, The Defendant, were to be passages that could be written only by one who had learnt to draw. For instance, in "A Defence of Skeletons":

    The actual sight of the little wood, with its grey and silver sea
    of life is entirely a winter vision. So dim and delicate is the heart
    of the winter woods, a kind of glittering gloaming, that a figure
    stepping towards us in the chequered twilight seems as if he were
    breaking through unfathomable depths of spiders' webs.

    In the year 1895, in which G.K. left art for publishing, he came of age "with a loud report." He writes to Bentley:

    Being twenty-one years old is really rather good fun. It is one of
    those occasions when you remember the existence of all sorts of
    miscellaneous people. A cousin of mine, Alice Chesterton, daughter of
    my Uncle Arthur, writes me a delightfully cordial letter from Berlin,
    where she is a governess; and better still, my mother has received a
    most amusing letter from an old nurse of mine, an exceptionally nice
    and intelligent nurse, who writes on hearing that it is my
    twenty-first birthday. Billy (an epithet is suppressed) gave me a
    little notebook and a little photograph frame.

    The first thing I did
    with the notebook was to make a note of his birthday. The first thing
    I shall do with the frame will be to get Grey to give me a photograph
    of him to put into it. Yes, it is not bad, being twenty-one, in a
    world so full of kind people. . . .

    I have just been out and got soaking and dripping wet; one of my
    favourite dissipations. I never enjoy weather so much as when it is
    driving, drenching, rattling, washing rain. As Mr. Meredith says in
    the book you gave me, "Rain, O the glad refresher of the grain, and
    welcome waterspouts of blessed rain." (It is in a poem called "Earth
    and a Wedded Woman," which is fat.) Seldom have I enjoyed a walk so
    much. My sister water was all there and most affectionate.

    Everything
    I passed was lovely, a little boy pickabacking another little boy
    home, two little girls taking shelter with a gigantic umbrella, the
    gutters boiling like rivers and the hedges glittering with rain. And
    when I came to our corner the shower was over, and there was a great
    watery sunset right over No. 80, what Mr. Ruskin calls an "opening
    into Eternity." Eternity is pink and gold. This may seem a very
    strange rant, but it is one of my "specimen days." I suppose you
    would really prefer me to write as I feel, and I am so constituted
    that these Daily incidents get me that way. Yes, I like rain.

    It
    means something, I am not sure what; something freshening, cleaning,
    washing out, taking in hand, not caring-a-damn-what-you-think,
    doing-its-duty, robust, noisy, moral, wet. It is the Baptism of the
    Church of the Future.

    Yesterday afternoon (Sunday) Lawrence and Maurice came here. We were
    merely infants at play, had skipping races round the garden and
    otherwise raced. ("Runner, run thy race," said Confucius, "and in the
    running find strength and reward.") After that we tried talking about
    Magnus, and came to some hopeful conclusions. Magnus is all right. As
    for Lawrence and Grey, if there is anything righter than all right,
    they are that. . . .

    There is an expression in Meredith's book which struck me immensely:
    "the largeness of the evening earth." The sensation that the Cosmos
    has all its windows open is very characteristic of evening, just as
    it is at this moment. I feel very good. Everything out of the window
    looks very, very flat and yellow: I do not know how else to describe
    it.

    It is like the benediction at the end of the service.

    CHAPTER V

    The Notebook

    I AM WRITING THIS chapter at a table facing Notre Dame de Paris in front of a café filled with arguing French workmen--in the presence of God and of Man; and I feel as if I understood the one hatred of G.K.'s life: his loathing of pessimism. "Is a man proud of losing his hearing, eyesight or sense of smell? What shall we say of him who prides himself on beginning as an intellectual cripple and ending as an intellectual corpse?"*

    [* From The Notebook.]

    SOME PROPHECIES

    Woe unto them that keep a God like a silk hat, that believe not in
    God, but in a God.

    Woe unto them that are pompous for they will sooner or later be
    ridiculous.

    Woe unto them that are tired of everything, for everything will
    certainly be tired of them.

    Woe unto them that cast out everything, for out of everything they
    will be cast out.

    Woe unto them that cast out anything, for out of that thing they
    will be cast out.

    Woe unto the flippant, for they shall receive flippancy.

    Woe unto them that are scornful for they shall receive scorn.

    Woe unto him that considereth his hair foolishly, for his hair will
    be made the type of him.

    Woe unto him that is smart, for men will hold him smart always,
    even when he is serious.*

    [* Ibid.]

    A pessimist is a man who has never lived, never suffered: "Show me a person who has plenty of worries and troubles and I will show you a person who, whatever he is, is not a pessimist."

    This idea G.K. developed later in the Dickens, dealing with the alleged over-optimism of Dickens--Dickens who if he had learnt to whitewash the universe had learnt it in a blacking factory, Dickens who had learnt through hardship and suffering to accept and love the universe. But that he wrote later. The quotations given here come from the Notebook begun in 1894 and used at intervals for the next four or five years, in which Gilbert wrote down his philosophy step by step as he came to discover it. The handwriting is the work of art that he must have learnt and practised, so different is it from his boyhood's scrawl. Each idea is set down as it comes into his mind.

    There is no sequence. In this book and in The Coloured Lands may be seen the creation of the Chesterton view of life--and it all took place in his early twenties. From the seed-thoughts here, Orthodoxy and the rest were to grow--here they are only seeds but seeds containing unmistakably the flower of the future:

    They should not hear from me a word
    Of selfishness or scorn
    If only I could find the door
    If only I were born.

    He makes the Unborn Babe say this in his first volume of poems. And in the Notebook we see how the babe coming into the world must keep this promise by accepting life with its puzzles, its beauty, its fleetingness: "Are we all dust? What a beautiful thing dust is though." "This round earth may be a soap-bubble, but it must be admitted that there are some pretty colours on it." "What is the good of life, it is fleeting; what is the good of a cup of coffee, it is fleeting. Ha Ha Ha."

    The birthday present of birth, as he was later to call it in Orthodoxy, involved not bare existence only but a wealth of other gifts. "A grievance," he heads this thought:

    Give me a little time,
    I shall not be able to appreciate them all;
    If you open so many doors
    And give me so many presents, O Lord God.

    He is almost overwhelmed with all that he has and with all that is, but accepts it ardently in its completeness.

    If the arms of a man could be a fiery circle embracing the round
    world, I think I should be that man.

    Yet in the face of all this splendour the pessimist dares to find flaws:

    The mountains praise thee, O Lord!
    But what if a mountain said,
    "I praise thee;
    But put a pine-tree halfway up on the left
    It would be much more effective, believe me."
    It is time that the religion of prayer gave
    place to the religion of praise.

    If the mountains must praise God, if the religion of praise expresses the truth of things, how much more does it express the truth of humanity--or rather of men, for he saw humanity not as an abstraction but as the sum of human and intensely individual beings:

    Once I found a friend
    "Dear me," I said "he was made for me."
    But now I find more and more friends
    Who seem to have been made for me
    And more and yet more made for me,
    Is it possible we were all made for each other
    all over the world?

    And on another page comes perhaps the most significant phrase in the book: "I wonder whether there will ever come a time when I shall be tired of any one person." Hence a fantastic thought of a way of making the discovery of more people to know and to like:

    THE HUMAN CIRCULATING LIBRARY NOTES

    Get out a gentleman for a fortnight, then change him for a lady, or
    your ticket. No person to be kept out after a fortnight, except with
    the payment of a penny a day. Any person morally or physically
    damaging a man will be held responsible. The library omnibus calls
    once a week leaving two or three each visit. Man of the season--old
    standard man.

    Or better still:

    My great ambition is to give a party at which everybody should meet
    everybody else and like them very much.

    AN INVITATION

    Mr. Gilbert Chesterton
    requests the pleasure
    Of humanity's company
    to tea on Dec. 25th 1896.
    Humanity Esq., The Earth, Cosmos E.

    G.K. liked everybody very much, and everything very much. He liked even the things most of us dislike. He liked to get wet. He liked to be tired. After that one short period of struggle he liked to call himself "always perfectly happy." And therefore he wanted to say, "Thank you."

    You say grace before meals
    All right.
    But I say grace before the play and the opera,
    And grace before the concert and pantomime,
    And grace before I open a book,
    And grace before sketching, painting,
    Swimming, fencing, boxing, walking, playing, dancing;
    And grace before I dip the pen in the ink.

    Each day seemed a special gift; something that might not have been:

    EVENING

    Here dies another day
    During which I have had eyes, ears, hands
    And the great world round me;
    And with tomorrow begins another.
    Why am I allowed two?

    THE PRAYER OF A MAN WALKING

    I thank thee, O Lord, for the stones in the street
    I thank thee for the hay-carts yonder and for the
    houses built and half-built
    That fly past me as I stride.
    But most of all for the great wind in my nostrils
    As if thine own nostrils were close.

    THE PRAYER OF A MAN RESTING

    The twilight closes round me
    My head is bowed before the Universe
    I thank thee, O Lord, for a child I knew seven years ago
    And whom I have never seen since.

    Praised be God for all sides of life, for friends, lovers, art,
    literature, knowledge, humour, politics, and for the little red cloud
    away there in the west--

    For, if he was to be grateful, to whom did he owe gratitude? Here is the chief question he asked and answered at this time. At school he was looking for God, but at the age of 16 he was, he tells us in Orthodoxy, an Agnostic in the sense of one who is not sure one way or the other. Largely it was this need for gratitude for what seemed personal gifts that brought him to belief in a personal God. Life was personal, it was not a mere drift; it had will in it, it was more like a story.

    A story is the highest mark
    For the world is a story and every part of it
    And there is nothing that can touch the world or any part of it
    That is not a story.

    And again, with the heading, "A Social Situation."

    We must certainly be in a novel;
    What I like about this novelist is that he takes
    such trouble about his minor characters.

    The story shapes from man's birth and it is as he meets the other characters that he finds he is in the right story.

    A MAN BORN ON THE EARTH

    Perhaps there has been some mistake
    How does he know he has come to the right place?
    But when he finds friends
    He knows he has come to the right place.

    You say it is a love affair
    Hush: it is a new Garden of Eden
    And a new progeny will people a new earth
    God is always making these experiments.

    Life is a story: who tells it? Life is a problem: who sets it?

    The world is a problem, not a Theorem
    And the word of the last Day will be Q.E.F.

    God sets the problem, God tells the story, but can those know Him who are characters in His story, who are working out His problem?

    Have you ever known what it is to walk along a road in such a frame
    of mind that you thought you might meet God at any turn of the path?

    For this a man must be ready, against this he must never shut the door.

    There is one kind of infidelity blacker than all infidelities,
    Worse than any blow of secularist, pessimist, atheist,
    It is that of those persons
    Who regard God as an old institution.

    VOICES

    The axe falls on the wood in thuds, "God, God."
    The cry of the rook, "God," answers it
    The crack of the fire on the hearth, the voice of the brook, say the
    same name;
    All things, dog, cat, fiddle, baby,
    Wind, breaker, sea, thunderclap
    Repeat in a thousand languages--
    God.

    Next in his thought comes a point where he hesitates as to the meeting place between God and Man. How and where can these two incommensurates find a meeting place? What is Incarnation? The greatness and the littleness of Man obsessed Chesterton as it did Pascal; it is the eternal riddle:

    TWO STRANDS

    Man is a spark flying upwards. God is everlasting.

    Who are we, to whom this cup of human life has been given, to ask
    for more? Let us love mercy and walk humbly. What is man, that thou
    regardest him?

    Man is a star unquenchable. God is in him incarnate.

    His life is planned upon a scale colossal, of which he sees
    glimpses. Let him dare all things, claim all things: he is the son
    of Man, who shall come in the clouds of glory.

    [I] saw these two strands mingling to make the religion of man.

    "A scale colossal, of which he sees glimpses." This, I think, is the first hint of the path that led Gilbert to full faith in Our Lord. In places in these notes he regards Him certainly only as Man--but even then as The Man, the Only Man in whom the colossal scale, the immense possibilities, of human nature could be dreamed of as fulfilled. Two notes on Marcus Aurelius are significant of the way his mind was moving.

    MARCUS AURELIUS

    A large-minded, delicate-witted, strong man,
    following the better thing like a thread between his hands.

    Him we cannot fancy choosing the lower even by mistake; we cannot
    think of him as wanting for a moment in any virtue, sincerity, mercy,
    purity, self-respect, good manners.

    Only one thing is wanting in him. He does not
    command me to perform the impossible.

    THE CARPENTER

    The Meditations of Marcus Aurelius.
    Yes: he was soliloquising, not making something.
    Do not the words of Jesus ring
    Like nails knocked into a board
    In his father's workshop?

    On two consecutive pages are notes showing how his mind is wrestling with the question, the answer to which would complete his philosophy:

    XMAS DAY

    Good news: but if you ask me what it is, I know not;
    It is a track of feet in the snow,
    It is a lantern showing a path,
    It is a door set open.

    THE GRACE OF OUR LORD JESUS CHRIST

    I live in an age of varied powers and knowledge,
    Of steam, science, democracy, journalism, art:
    But when my love rises like a sea,
    I have to go back to an obscure tribe and a slain man
    To formulate a blessing.

    JULIAN

    "Vicisti Galilæe," he said, and sank conquered
    After wrestling with the most gigantic of powers,
    A dead man.

    THE CRUCIFIED

    On a naked slope of a poor province
    A Roman soldier stood staring at a gibbet,
    Then he said, "Surely this was a righteous man,"
    And a new chapter of history opened,
    Having that for its motto.

    PARABLES

    There was a man who dwelt in the east centuries ago,
    And now I cannot look at a sheep or a sparrow,
    A lily or a cornfield, a raven or a sunset,
    A vineyard or a mountain, without thinking of him;
    If this be not to be divine, what is it?

    Cecil Chesterton tells us Gilbert read the Gospels partly because he was not forced to read them: I suppose this really means that he read them with a mature mind which had not been dulled to their reception by a childhood task of routine lessons. But I do not think at this date it had occurred to him to question the assumption of the period: that official Christianity, its priesthood especially, had travestied the original intention of Christ. This idea is in the Wild Knight volume (published in 1900) and more briefly in a suggestion in the Notebook for a proposed drama:

    Gabriel is hammering up a little theatre and the child looks at his
    hands, and finds them torn with nails.

    Clergyman. The Church should stand by the powers that be.

    Gabriel. Yes? . . . That is a handsome crucifix you have there at
    your chain.

    That the clergy, that the Christian people, should have settled down to an acceptance of a faulty established order, should not be alert to all that Our Lord's life signified, was one of the problems. It was, too, a matter of that cosmic loyalty which he analyses more fully in Orthodoxy. Here he simply writes:

    It is not a question of Theology, It is a question of whether,
    placed as a sentinel of an unknown watch, you will whistle or not.

    Sentinels do go to sleep and he was coming to feel that this want of vigilance ran through the whole of humanity. In "White Wynd," a sketch written at this time,* he adumbrates an idea to which he was to return again in Manalive especially, and in Orthodoxy--that we can by custom so lose our sense of reality that the only way to enjoy and be grateful for our possessions is to lose them for a while. The shortest way home is to go round the world. In this story of "White Wynd" he applies the parable only to each man's life and the world he lives in.

    But in Orthodoxy he applies it to the human race who have lost revealed truth by getting so accustomed to it that they no longer look at it. And already in the Notebook he is calling the attention of a careless multitude to "that great Empire upon which the sun never sets. I allude to the Universe."

    [* It is published in The Coloured Lands.]

    Most of the quotations about Our Lord come in the later part of the book: in the earlier pages he dreams that "to this age it is given to write the great new song, and to compile the new Bible, and to found the new Church, and preach the new Religion." And in one rather obscure passage he seems to hint at the thought that Christ might come again to shape this new religion.

    Going round the world, Gilbert was finding his way home; the explorer was rediscovering his native country. He himself has given us all the metaphors for what was happening now in his mind. Without a single Catholic friend he had discovered this wealth of Catholic truth and he was still travelling. "All this I felt," he later summed it up in Orthodoxy, "and the age gave me no encouragement to feel it. And all this time I had not even thought of Catholic theology."

    CHAPTER VI

    Towards a Career

    A CURIOUS LITTLE incident comes towards the end of Gilbert's time at the Slade School. In a letter he wrote to E. C. Bentley we see him, on the eve of his 21st birthday, being invited to write for the Academy:

    Mr. Cotton is a little bristly, bohemian man, as fidgetty as a
    kitten, who runs round the table while he talks to you. When he
    agrees with you he shuts his eyes tight and shakes his head. When he
    means anything rather seriously he ends up with a loud nervous laugh.
    He talks incessantly and is mad on the history of Oxford. I sent him
    my review of Ruskin and he read it before me (Note.

    Hell) and
    delivered himself with astonishing rapidity to the following effect:
    "This is very good: you've got something to say: Oh, yes: this is
    worth saying: I agree with you about Ruskin and about the Century:
    this is good: you've no idea: if you saw some stuff: some reviews I
    get: the fellows are practised but of all the damned fools: you've no
    idea: they know the trade in a way: but such infernal asses: as send
    things up: but this is very good: that sentence does run nicely:
    but I like your point: make it a little longer and then send it in:
    I've got another book for you to review: you know Robert Bridges?

    Oh
    very good, very good: here it is: about two columns you know: by the
    way: keep the Ruskin for yourself: you deserve that anyhow."

    Here I got a word in: one of protest and thanks. But Mr. Cotton
    insisted on my accepting the Ruskin. So I am really to serve Laban.
    Laban proves on analysis to be of the consistency of brick. It is
    such men as this that have made our Cosmos what it is.

    At one point
    he said, literally dancing with glee: "Oh, the other day I stuck some
    pins into Andrew Lang." I said, "Dear me, that must be a very good
    game." It was something about an edition of Scott, but I was told
    that Andrew "took" the painful operation "very well." We sat up
    horribly late together talking about Browning, Afghans, Notes, the
    Yellow Book, the French Revolution, William Morris, Norsemen and Mr.
    Richard le Gallienne. "I don't despair for anyone," he said suddenly.
    "Hang it all, that's what you mean by humanity." This appears to be a
    rather good editor of the Academy.

    And my joy in having begun my
    life is very great. "I am tired," I said to Mr. Brodribb, "of writing
    only what I like." "Oh well," he said heartily, "you'll have no
    reason to make that complaint in journalism."

    But here is a mystery. Nowhere in the Academy columns for 1895 or 1896 are to be seen the initials G.K.C., yet at that date all the reviews are signed. Mr. Eccles, who was writing for it at the time, told me that he had no recollection of G.K. among the contributors--and later he came to know him well when both were together on the Speaker. In any case, the idea of reviewing for no reward except the book reviewed would scarcely appeal to a more practical man than Gilbert as a hopeful beginning. Perhaps the mystery is solved by the fact that soon after the date of this letter Mr. Cotton got an appointment in India. To Mr.

    Eccles it appeared somewhat ironical that the unpaid contributors to the Academy were circularised with a suggestion of contributions of money towards a parting present for their late editor.

    The actual beginning of G.K.'s journalism was in The Bookman; and in the Autobiography he insists that it was a matter of mere luck: "these opportunities were merely things that happened to me." While still at the Slade School, he was, as we have seen, attending English lectures at University College. There he met a fellow-student, Ernest Hodder Williams, of the family which controlled the publishing house of Hodder & Stoughton. He gave Chesterton some books on art to review for The Bookman, a monthly paper published by the firm.

    "I need not say," G.K. comments, "that having entirely failed to learn how to draw or paint, I tossed off easily enough some criticisms of the weaker points of Rubens or the misdirected talents of Tintoretto. I had discovered the easiest of all professions, which I have pursued ever since." But neither in the art criticism he wrote for The Bookman nor in the poems he was to publish in The Outlook and The Speaker was there a living. He left the Slade School and went to work for a publisher.

    Mr. Redway, in whose office Gilbert now found himself, was a publisher largely of spiritualist literature. Gilbert has described in his Autobiography his rather curious experience of ghostly authorship, but he relates nothing of his office experience, which is described in another undated letter to Mr. Bentley:

    I am writing this letter just when I like most to write one, late
    at night, after a beastly lot of midnight oil over a contribution for
    a Slade Magazine, intended as a public venture. I am sending them a
    recast of that "Picture of Tuesday."

    Like you, I am beastly busy, but there is something exciting about
    it. If I must be busy (as I certainly must, being an approximately
    honest man) I had much rather be busy in a varied, mixed up way, with
    half a hundred things to attend to, than with one blank day of
    monotonous "study" before me. To give you some idea of what I mean.

    I
    have been engaged in 3 different tiring occupations and enjoyed them
    all. (1) Redway says, "We've got too many MSS; read through them,
    will you, and send back those that are too bad at once." I go slap
    through a room full of MSS, criticising deuced conscientiously, with
    the result that I post back some years of MSS to addresses, which I
    should imagine, must be private asylums. But one feels worried,
    somehow. . . .

    (2) Redway says, "I'm going to give you entire charge of the press
    department, sending copies to Reviews, etc." Consequence is, one has
    to keep an elaborate book and make it tally with other elaborate
    books, and one has to remember all the magazines that exist and what
    sort of books they'd crack up. I used to think I hated
    responsibility: I am positively getting to enjoy it. (3) There is
    that confounded "Picture of Tuesday" which I have been scribbling at
    the whole evening, and have at last got it presentable.

    This sounds
    like mere amusement, but, now that I have tried other kinds of hurry
    and bustle, I solemnly pledge myself to the opinion that there is no
    work so tiring as writing, that is, not for fun, but for publication.
    Other work has a repetition, a machinery, a reflex action about it
    somewhere, but to be on the stretch inventing fillings, making them
    out of nothing, making them as good as you can for a matter of four
    hours leaves me more inclined to lie down and read Dickens than I
    ever feel after nine hours ramp at Redway's. The worst of it is that
    you always think the thing so bad too when you're in that state.

    I
    can't imagine anything more idiotic than what I've just finished.
    Well, enough of work and all its works. By all means come on Monday
    evening, but don't be frightened if by any chance I'm not in till
    about 6.30, as Monday is a busy day. Of course you'll stop to
    dinner . . . what an idiotically long time 8 weeks is. . . .

    This letter does not seem to bear out the suggestion in Cecil's book* of Gilbert's probable uselessness to the publishers for whom he worked. After all, literacy is more needful to most publishers than automatic practicality, because it is so very much rarer. Probably G.K. would have been absolutely invaluable had he been a little less kind-hearted. His dislike of sending back a manuscript and making an author unhappy would have been a bar to his utility as a reader. But there are lots of other things to do besides rejecting manuscripts, and two later letters show how capable Gilbert was felt to be in doing most of them.

    [* G. K. Chesterton: A Criticism, see p. 23.]

    The exact date at which he left Redway's for the publishing firm of Fisher Unwin (of 11 Paternoster Buildings) I cannot discover, but it was fairly early and he was several years with Fisher Unwin, only gradually beginning to move over into journalism.

    "He did nothing for himself," says Lucian Oldershaw, "till we [Bentley and Oldershaw] came down from Oxford and pushed him."

    The following letters belong to 1898, being written to Frances when they were already engaged, but I put them here as they give some notion of the work he did for his employer.

    . . . The book I have to deal with for Unwin is an exhaustive and I
    am told interesting work on "Rome and the Empire" a kind of
    realistic, modern account of the life of the ancient world. I have
    got to fix it up, choose illustrations, introductions, notes, etc.,
    and all because I am the only person who knows a little Latin and
    precious little Roman history and no more archaeology than a blind
    cat. It is entertaining, and just like our firm's casual way. The
    work ought to be done by an authority on Roman antiquities. If I
    hadn't been there they would have given it to the office boy.

    However, I shall get through it all right: the more I see of the
    publishing world, the more I come to the conclusion that I know next
    to nothing, but that the vast mass of literary people know less. This
    is sometimes called having "a public-school education."*

    [* Extract from undated letter (postmarked, Aug. 11, 1898).]

    • * *

    I have a lot of work to do, as Unwin has given the production of an
    important book entirely into my hands, as a kind of invisible editor.
    It is complimentary, but very worrying, and will mean a lot of time
    at the British Museum.*

    [* Extract from undated letter (postmarked, Aug. 29, 1898).]

    11 Paternoster Bldgs.
    (Postmark, December 1898)

    . . . For fear that you should really suppose that my observations
    about being busy are the subterfuges of a habitual liar, I may give
    you briefly some idea of the irons at present in the fire. As far as
    I can make out there are at least seven things that I have undertaken
    to do and everyone of them I ought to do before any of the others.

    1st. There is the book about Ancient Rome which I have to do for
    T.F.U.--arrange and get illustrations etc. This all comes of showing
    off. It is a story with a moral (Greedy Gilbert: or Little Boys
    Should be Seen and not Heard). A short time ago I had to read a
    treatise by Dean Stubbs on "The Ideal Woman of the Poets" in which
    the Dean remarked that "all the women admired by Horace were
    wantons." This struck me as a downright slander, slight as is my
    classical knowledge, and in my report I asked loftily what Dean
    Stubbs made of those noble lines on the wife who hid her husband
    from his foes.

    Splendide mendax et in omne virgo
    Nobilis aevum

    One of the purest and stateliest tributes ever made to a woman.
    (The lines might be roughly rendered "A magnificent liar and a noble
    lady for all eternity"; but no translation can convey the
    organ-voice of the verse, in which the two strong and lonely words
    "noble" and "eternity" stand solitary for the last line.) In
    consequence of my taking up the cudgels against a live Dean for the
    manly moral sense of the dear old Epicurean, the office became
    impressed with a vague idea that I know something about Latin
    literature--whereas, as a matter of fact I have forgotten even the
    line before the one I quoted.

    However, in the most confidential and
    pathetic manner I was entrusted with doing with "Rome et l'Empire"
    work which ought to be done by a scholar. . . .

    2nd. Then there is Captain Webster. You ask (in gruff, rumbling
    tones) "Who is Captain Webster?" I will tell you.

    Captain Webster is a small man with a carefully waxed moustache and
    a very Bond Street get up, living at the Grosvenor Hotel. Talking to
    him you would say: he is an ass, but an agreeable ass, a humble,
    transparent honourable ass. He is an innocent and idiotic butterfly.
    The interesting finishing touch is that he has been to New Guinea for
    four years or so, and had some of the most hideous and extravagant
    adventures that could befall a modern man.

    His yacht was surrounded
    by shoals of canoes full of myriads of cannibals of a race who file
    their teeth to look like the teeth of dogs, and hang weights in their
    ears till the ears hang like dogs' ears, on the shoulder. He held his
    yacht at the point of the revolver and got away, leaving some of his
    men dead on the shore. All night long he heard the horrible noise of
    the banqueting gongs and saw the huge fires that told his friends
    were being eaten. Now he lives in the Grosvenor Hotel. Captain
    Webster finds the pen, not only mightier than the sword, but also
    much more difficult.

    He has written his adventures and we are to
    publish them and I am translating the honest captain into English
    grammar, a thing which appals him much more than Papuan savages. This
    means going through it carefully of course and rewriting many parts
    of it, where relatives and dependent sentences have been lost past
    recovery. I went to see him, and his childlike dependence on me was
    quite pathetic. His general attitude was, "You see I'm such a damned
    fool." And so he is.

    But when I compare him with the Balzacian
    hauteur and the preposterous posing of many of our Fleet Street
    decadent geniuses, I feel a movement of the blood which declares that
    perhaps there are worse things than War. (Between ourselves, I have a
    sneaking sympathy with fighting: I fought horribly at school. It is
    well you should know my illogicalities.)

    3rd. There is the selection of illustrations for the History of
    China we are producing. I know no more of China than the Man in the
    Moon (less, for he has seen it, at any rate), except what I got from
    reading the book, but of course I shall make the most of what I do
    know and airily talk of La-o-tsee and Wu-sank-Wei, criticise
    Chung-tang and Fu-Tche, compare Tchieu Lung with his great successor,
    whose name I have forgotten, and the Napoleonic vigour of Li with the
    weak opportunism of Woo. Before I have done I hope people will be
    looking behind for my pig-tail. The name I shall adopt will be
    Tches-Ter-Ton.

    4th. A MS to read translated from the Norwegian: a History of the
    Kiss, Ceremonial, Amicable, Amatory, etc.--in the worst French
    sentimental style. God alone knows how angry I am with the author of
    that book. I am not sure that I shall not send up the brief report.
    "A snivelling hound."

    5th. The book for Nutt [Greybeards at Play], which has reached
    its worst stage, that of polishing up for the eye of Nutt, instead of
    merely rejoicing in the eye of God. Do you know this is the only one
    of the lot about which I am at all worried. I do not feel as if
    things like the Fish poem are really worth publishing. I know they
    are better than many books that are published, but Heaven knows that
    is not saying much. In support of some of my work I would fight to
    the last.

    But with regard to this occasional verse I feel a humbug.
    To publish a book of my nonsense verses seems to me exactly like
    summoning the whole of the people of Kensington to see me smoke
    cigarettes.

    Macgregor told me that I should do much better in the business of
    literature if I found the work more difficult. My facility, he said,
    led me to undervalue my work. I wonder whether this is true, and
    those silly rhymes are any good after all.

    6th. The collection of more serious poems of which I spoke to you.
    You shall have a hand in the selection of these when you get back.

    7th. The Novel--which though I have put it aside for the present,
    yet has become too much a part of me not to be constantly having
    chapters written--or rather growing out of the others.

    And all these things, with the exception of the last one, are
    supposed to be really urgent, and to be done immediately. . . . Now I
    hope I have sickened you forever of wanting to know the details of my
    dull affairs. But I hope it may give you some notion of how hard it
    really is to get time for writing just now. For you see they are none
    of them even mechanical things: they all require some thinking about.

    I am afraid . . . that if you really want to know what I do, you
    must forgive me for seeming egoistic. That is the tragedy of the
    literary person: his very existence is an assertion of his own mental
    vanity: he must pretend to be conceited even if he isn't. . . .

    Beginning to publish, beginning to write, and still developing mentally at a frantic rate--this is a summary of the years 1895-8.

    As the Notebook shows, Gilbert was reflecting deeply at this time on the relations both between God and man and between man and his fellow man. The realisation that their relations had gone very far wrong was necessarily followed--for Gilbert's mind was an immensely practical one--by the question of what the proposed remedies were worth. He has told us that he became a Socialist at this time only because it was intolerable not to be a Socialist. The Socialists seemed the only people who were looking at conditions as they were and finding them unendurable.

    Christian Socialism seemed at first sight, for anyone who admired Christ, to be the obvious form of Socialism, and, in a fragment of this period, G.K. traces the resemblance of modern collectivism to early Christianity.

    The points in which Christian and Socialistic collectivism are at
    one are simple and fundamental. As, however, we must proceed
    carefully in this matter, we may state these points of resemblance
    under three heads.

    (1) Both rise from the deeps of an emotion, the emotion of compassion
    for misfortune, as such. This is really a very important point.
    Collectivism is not an intellectual fad, even if erroneous, but a
    passionate protest and aspiration: it arises as a secret of the
    heart, a dream of the injured feeling, long before it shapes itself
    as a definite propaganda at all. The intellectual philosophies ally
    themselves with success and preach competition, but the human heart
    allies itself with misfortune and suggests communism.

    (2) Both trace the evil state of society to "covetousness," the
    competitive desire to accumulate riches. Thus, both in one case and
    the other, the mere possession of wealth is in itself an offence
    against moral order, the absence of it in itself a recommendation and
    training for the higher life.

    (3) Both propose to remedy the evil of competition by a system of
    "bearing each other's burdens" in the literal sense, that is to say,
    of levelling, silencing and reducing one's own chances, for the
    chance of your weaker brethren. The desirability, they say, of a
    great or clever man acquiring fame is small compared with the
    desirability of a weak and broken man acquiring bread. The strong man
    is a man, and should modify or adapt himself to the hopes of his
    mates. He that would be first among you, let him be the servant of
    all.

    These are the three fountains of collectivist passion. I have not
    considered it necessary to enter into elaborate proof of the presence
    of these three in the Gospels. That the main trend of Jesus'
    character was compassion for human ills, that he denounced not merely
    covetousness but riches again and again, and with an almost impatient
    emphasis, and that he insisted on his followers throwing up personal
    aims and sharing funds and fortune entirely, these are plain matters
    of evidence presented again and again, and, in fact, of common
    admission.

    Yet that uncanny thing in Gilbert which always forced him to see facts, mutinied again at this point and produced another fragment in which he has moved closer to Christianity and thereby further away from modern Socialism. The world he lived in contained a certain number of Christians who were, he found, highly doubtful about the Christian impulse of Socialism. And most of his Socialist friends had about them a tone of bitterness and an atmosphere of hopelessness utterly unlike the tone and the atmosphere of Christianity. Just as atheists were the first people to turn Gilbert from Atheism towards dogmatic Christianity, so the Socialists were now turning him from Socialism.

    The next fragment is rather long, but it was never published and I think it so important, as showing how his mind was moving, that it cannot well be shortened. It is a document of capital importance for the biography of Chesterton.

    Now, for my own part, I cannot in the least agree with those who
    see no difference between Christian and modern Socialism, nor do I
    for a moment join in some Christian Socialists' denunciations of
    those worthy middle-class people who cannot see the connection. For I
    cannot help thinking that in a way these latter people are right. No
    reasonable man can read the Sermon on the Mount and think that its
    tone is not very different from that of most collectivist speculation
    of the present day, and the Philistines feel this, though they cannot
    distinctly express it.

    There is a difference between Christ's
    Socialist program and that of our own time, a difference deep,
    genuine and all important, and it is this which I wish to point out.

    Let us take two types side by side, or rather the same type in the
    two different atmospheres. Let us take the "rich young man" of the
    Gospels and place beside him the rich young man of the present day,
    on the threshold of Socialism. If we were to follow the difficulties,
    theories, doubts, resolves, and conclusions of each of these
    characters, we should find two very distinct threads of
    self-examination running through the two lives.

    And the essence of
    the difference was this: the modern Socialist is saying, "What will
    society do?" while his prototype, as we read, said, "What shall I
    do?" Properly considered, this latter sentence contains the whole
    essence of the older Communism.

    The modern Socialist regards his
    theory of regeneration as a duty which society owes to him, the early
    Christian regarded it as a duty which he owed to society; the modern
    Socialist is busy framing schemes for its fulfilment, the early
    Christian was busy considering whether he would himself fulfil it
    there and then; the ideal of modern Socialism is an elaborate Utopia
    to which he hopes the world may be tending, the ideal of the early
    Christian was an actual nucleus "living the new life" to whom he
    might join himself if he liked.

    Hence the constant note running
    through the whole gospel, of the importance, difficulty and
    excitement of the "call," the individual and practical request made
    by Christ to every rich man, "sell all thou hast and give to the
    poor."

    To us Socialism comes speculatively as a noble and optimistic
    theory of what may [be] the crown of progress, to Peter and James and
    John it came practically as a crisis of their own Daily life, a
    stirring question of conduct and renunciation.

    We do not therefore in the least agree with those who hold that
    modern Socialism is an exact counterpart or fulfilment of the
    socialism of Christianity. We find the difference important and
    profound, despite the common ground of anti-selfish collectivism.

    The
    modern Socialist regards Communism as a distant panacea for society,
    the early Christian regarded it as an immediate and difficult
    regeneration of himself: the modern Socialist reviles, or at any rate
    reproaches, society for not adopting it, the early Christian
    concentrated his thoughts on the problem of his own fitness and
    unfitness to adopt it: to the modern Socialist it is a theory, to the
    early Christian it was a call; modern Socialism says, "Elaborate a
    broad, noble and workable system and submit it to the progressive
    intellect of society." Early Christianity said, "Sell all thou hast
    and give to the poor."

    This distinction between the social and personal way of regarding
    the change has two sides, a spiritual and a practical which we
    propose to notice. The spiritual side of it, though of less direct
    and revolutionary importance than the practical, has still a very
    profound philosophic significance. To us it appears something
    extraordinary that this Christian side of Socialism, the side of the
    difficulty of the personal sacrifice, and the patience, cheerfulness,
    and good temper necessary for the protracted personal surrender is so
    constantly overlooked.

    The literary world is flooded with old men
    seeing visions and young men dreaming dreams, with various stages of
    anti-competitive enthusiasm, with economic apocalypses, elaborate
    Utopias and mushroom destinies of mankind. And, as far as we have
    seen, in all this whirlwind of theoretic excitement there is not a
    word spoken of the intense practical difficulty of the summons to the
    individual, the heavy, unrewarding cross borne by him who gives up
    the world.

    For it will not surely be denied that not only will Socialism be
    impossible without some effort on the part of individuals, but that
    Socialism if once established would be rapidly dissolved, or worse
    still, diseased, if the individual members of the community did not
    make a constant effort to do that which in the present state of human
    nature must mean an effort, to live the higher life.

    Mere state
    systems could not bring about and still less sustain a reign of
    unselfishness, without a cheerful decision on the part of the members
    to forget selfishness even in little things, and for that most
    difficult and at the same time most important personal decision
    Christ made provision and the modern theorists make no provision at
    all. Some modern Socialists do indeed see that something more is
    necessary for the golden age than fixed incomes and universal stores
    tickets, and that the fountain heads of all real improvement are to
    be found in human temper and character. Mr.

    William Morris, for
    instance, in his "News from Nowhere" gives a beautiful picture of a
    land ruled by Love, and rightly grounds the give-and-take camaraderie
    of his ideal state upon an assumed improvement in human nature. But
    he does not tell us how such an improvement is to be effected, and
    Christ did. Of Christ's actual method in this matter I shall speak
    afterwards when dealing with the practical aspect, my object just now
    is to compare the spiritual and emotional effects of the call of
    Christ, as compared to those of the vision of Mr.

    William Morris.
    When we compare the spiritual attitudes of two thinkers, one of whom
    is considering whether social history has been sufficiently a course
    of improvement to warrant him in believing that it will culminate in
    universal altruism, while the other is considering whether he loves
    other people enough to walk down tomorrow to the market-place and
    distribute everything but his staff and his scrip, it will not be
    denied that the latter is likely to undergo certain deep and acute
    emotional experiences, which will be quite unknown to the former.

    And
    these emotional experiences are what we understand as the spiritual
    aspect of the distinction. For three characteristics at least the
    Galilean programme makes more provision; humility, activity,
    cheerfulness, the real triad of Christian virtues.

    Humility is a grand, a stirring thing, the exalting paradox of
    Christianity, and the sad want of it in our own time is, we believe,
    what really makes us think life dull, like a cynic, instead of
    marvellous, like a child. With this, however, we have at present
    nothing to do. What we have to do with is the unfortunate fact that
    among no persons is it more wanting than among Socialists, Christian
    and other.

    The isolated or scattered protest for a complete change in
    social order, the continual harping on one string, the necessarily
    jaundiced contemplation of a system already condemned, and above all,
    the haunting pessimistic whisper of a possible hopelessness of
    overcoming the giant forces of success, all these impart undeniably
    to the modern Socialist a tone excessively imperious and bitter. Nor
    can we reasonably blame the average money-getting public for their
    impatience with the monotonous virulence of men who are constantly
    reviling them for not living communistically, and who after all, are
    not doing it themselves.

    Willingly do we allow that these latter
    enthusiasts think it impossible in the present state of society to
    practise their ideal, but this fact, while vindicating their
    indisputable sincerity, throws an unfortunate vagueness and
    inconclusiveness over their denunciations of other people in the same
    position. Let us compare with this arrogant and angry tone among the
    modern Utopians who can only dream "the life," the tone of the early
    Christian who was busy living it.

    As far as we know, the early
    Christians never regarded it as astonishing that the world as they
    found it was competitive and unregenerate; they seem to have felt
    that it could not in its pre-Christian ignorance have been anything
    else, and their whole interest was bent on their own standard of
    conduct and exhortation which was necessary to convert it. They felt
    that it was by no merit of theirs that they had been enabled to enter
    into the life before the Romans, but simply as a result of the fact
    that Christ had appeared in Galilee and not in Rome.

    Lastly, they
    never seem to have entertained a doubt that the message would itself
    convert the world with a rapidity and ease which left no room for
    severe condemnation of the heathen societies.

    With regard to the second merit, that of activity, there can be
    little doubt as to where it lies between the planner of the Utopia
    and the convert of the brotherhood. The modern Socialist is a
    visionary, but in this he is on the same ground as half the great men
    of the world, and to some extent of the early Christian himself, who
    rushed towards a personal ideal very difficult to sustain.

    The
    visionary who yearns toward an ideal which is practically impossible
    is not useless or mischievous, but often the opposite; but the person
    who is often useless, and always mischievous, is the visionary who
    dreams with the knowledge or the half-knowledge that his ideal is
    impossible. The early Christian might be wrong in believing that by
    entering the brotherhood men could in a few years become perfect even
    as their Father in Heaven was perfect, but he believed it and acted
    flatly and fearlessly on the belief: this is the type of the higher
    visionary.

    But all the insidious dangers of the vision; the idleness,
    the procrastination, the mere mental aestheticism, come in when the
    vision is indulged, as half our Socialistic conceptions are, as a
    mere humour or fairy-tale, with a consciousness, half-confessed, that
    it is beyond practical politics, and that we need not be troubled
    with its immediate fulfilment. The visionary who believes in his own
    most frantic vision is always noble and useful. It is the visionary
    who does not believe in his vision who is the dreamer, the idler, the
    Utopian.

    This then is the second moral virtue of the older school, an
    immense direct sincerity of action, a cleansing away, by the sweats
    of hard work, of all those subtle and perilous instincts of mere
    ethical castle-building which have been woven like the spells of an
    enchantress, round so many of the strong men of our own time.

    The third merit, which I have called cheerfulness, is really the
    most important of all. We may perhaps put the comparison in this way.
    It might strike many persons as strange that in a time on the whole
    so optimistic in its intellectual beliefs as this is, in an age when
    only a small minority disbelieve in social progress, and a large
    majority believe in an ultimate social perfection, there should be
    such a tired and blasé feeling among numbers of young men. This, we
    think, is due, not to the want of an ultimate ideal, but to that of
    any immediate way of making for it: not of something to hope but of
    something to do.

    A human being is not satisfied and never will be
    satisfied with being told that it is all right: what he wants is not
    a prediction of what other people will be hundreds of years hence, to
    make him cheerful, but a new and stirring test and task for himself,
    which will assuredly make him cheerful. A knight is not contented
    with the statement that his commander has hid his plans so as to
    insure victory: what the knight wants is a sword. This demand for a
    task is not mere bravado, it is an eternal and natural part of the
    higher optimism, as deep-rooted as the foreshadowing of perfection.

    I do not know whether Gilbert would yet have actually called himself a Christian. He was certainly tending towards the more Christian elements in his surroundings. It seems pretty clear from all he wrote and said later that he did not hold that transformation to have been fully effected until after his meeting with Frances, to whom he wrote many years later:

    Therefore I bring these rhymes to you
    Who brought the Cross to me.

    These papers are undated and are arranged in no sequence. It is possible this last one was written after their first meeting. Certain it is that in it he had begun feeling after a more Christian arrangement of society than Socialism offered--and particularly after an arrangement better suited to the nature of man. This thought of man's nature as primary was to remain the basis of his social thinking to the end of his life.

    CHAPTER VII

    Incipit Vita Nova

    IN THE NOTEBOOK may be seen Gilbert's occasional thoughts about his own future love story.

    SUDDENLY IN THE MIDST

    Suddenly in the midst of friends,
    Of brothers known to me more and more,
    And their secrets, histories, tastes, hero-worships,
    Schemes, love-affairs, known to me
    Suddenly I felt lonely.
    Felt like a child in a field with no more games to play
    Because I have not a lady
    to whom to send my thought at that hour
    that she might crown my peace.

    MADONNA MIA

    About her whom I have not yet met
    I wonder what she is doing
    Now, at this sunset hour,
    Working perhaps, or playing, worrying or laughing,
    Is she making tea, or singing a song, or writing,
    or praying, or reading
    Is she thoughtful, as I am thoughtful
    Is she looking now out of the window
    As I am looking out of the window?

    But a few pages later comes the entry:

    F.B.

    You are a very stupid person.
    I don't believe you have the least idea how nice you are.

    F.B. was Frances, daughter of a diamond merchant some time dead. The family was of French descent, the name de Blogue having been somewhat unfortunately anglicised into Blogg. They had fallen from considerable wealth into a degree of poverty that made it necessary for the three daughters to earn a living.

    Frances was never strong and Gilbert has told how utterly exhausted she was at the end of each day's toil--"she worked very hard as secretary of an educational society in London."* The family lived in Bedford Park, a suburb of London that went in for artistic housing and a kind of garden-city atmosphere long before this was at all general.

    Judging by their photographs the three girls must all have been remarkably pretty, and young men frequented the house in great numbers, among them Brimley Johnson who was engaged to Gertrude, and Lucian Oldershaw who later married Ethel. Some time in 1896, Oldershaw took Gilbert to call and Gilbert, literally at first sight, fell in love with Frances.

    [* Autobiography, p. 153.]

    TO MY LADY

    God made you very carefully
    He set a star apart for it
    He stained it green and gold with fields
    And aureoled it with sunshine
    He peopled it with kings, peoples, republics
    And so made you, very carefully.
    All nature is God's book, filled with his rough sketches for you.*

    [* The Notebook.]

    When almost forty years later Gilbert was writing his Autobiography, Frances asked him to keep her out of it. The liking they both had for keeping private life private made him call it "this very Victorian narrative." Nevertheless he tells us something of the early days of their acquaintance. Gilbert had mentioned the moon:

    She told me in the most normal and unpretentious tone that she
    hated the moon. I talked to the same lady several times afterwards;
    and found that this was a perfectly honest statement of the fact. Her
    attitude on this and other things might be called a prejudice; but it
    could not possibly be called a fad, still less an affectation.

    She
    really had an obstinate objection to all those natural forces that
    seemed to be sterile or aimless; she disliked loud winds that seemed
    to be going nowhere; she did not care much for the sea, a spectacle
    of which I was very fond; and by the same instinct she was up against
    the moon, which she said looked like an imbecile. On the other hand,
    she had a sort of hungry appetite for all the fruitful things like
    fields and gardens and anything connected with production; about
    which she was quite practical.

    She practised gardening; in that
    curious cockney culture she would have been quite ready to practise
    farming; and on the same perverse principle, she actually practised a
    religion. This was something utterly unaccountable both to me and to
    the whole fussy culture in which she lived. Any number of people
    proclaimed religions, chiefly oriental religions, analysed or argued
    about them; but that anybody could regard religion as a practical
    thing like gardening was something quite new to me and, to her
    neighbours, new and incomprehensible.

    She had been, by an accident,
    brought up in the school of an Anglo-Catholic convent; and to all
    that agnostic or mystic world, practising a religion was much more
    puzzling than professing it. She was a queer card. She wore a green
    velvet dress barred with grey fur, which I should have called
    artistic, but that she hated all the talk about art; and she had an
    attractive face, which I should have called elvish, but that she
    hated all the talk about elves. But what was arresting and almost
    blood-curdling about her, in that social atmosphere, was not so much
    that she hated it, as that she was entirely unaffected by it.

    She
    never knew what was meant by being "under the influence" of Yeats or
    Shaw or Tolstoy or anybody else. She was intelligent, with a great
    love of literature, and especially of Stevenson. But if Stevenson had
    walked into the room and explained his personal doubts about personal
    immortality, she would have regretted that he should be wrong upon
    the point; but would otherwise have been utterly unaffected. She was
    not at all like Robespierre, except in a taste for neatness in dress;
    and yet it is only in Mr.

    Belloc's book on Robespierre that I have
    ever found any words that describe the unique quality that cut her
    off from the current culture and saved her from it. "God had given
    him in his mind a stone tabernacle in which certain great truths were
    preserved imperishable."*

    [* Autobiography, pp. 151-3.]

    A letter to a friend, Mildred Wain, who was now engaged to Waldo d'Avigdor, makes the future tolerably easy to foresee.

    . . . My brother wishes me to thank you with ferocious gratitude
    for the music, which he is enjoying tremendously. It reminds me
    rather of what Miss Frances Blogg--but that is another story.

    In your last letter you enquired whether I saw anything of the
    Bloggs now. If you went and put that question to them there would be
    a scene. Mrs. Blogg would probably fall among the fire-irons, Knollys
    would foam in convulsions on the carpet, Ethel would scream and take
    refuge on the mantelpiece and Gertrude faint and break off her
    engagement. Frances would--but no intelligent person can affect an
    interest in what she does.

    Lawrence Solomon told me that Mrs. Edward Chesterton did not approve of the rather arty-crafty atmosphere of Bedford Park--that earliest of Garden Cities, so conventionally unconventional--where Frances lived. She did not like her son's friendship with the Bloggs and she had chosen for him a girl who she felt would make him an ideal wife: "Very open air," Mr. Solomon said. "Not booky, but good at games and practical." He was not sure whether Gilbert realised this, but personally I believe that Gilbert realised everything.

    "Of course you know," Annie Firmin wrote to me, "that Aunt Marie never liked Frances? Or Bentley?" Annie was the girl chosen by Gilbert's mother. She was very much a member of the family.

    "Did Gilbert ever speak to you," she wrote to me recently, "of the old Saturday night parties at Barnes, at the home of the grandparents--every Saturday night the family, or as many of it as could, used to go down to Barnes to supper, and the 'boys' and Tom Gilbert, Alice Chesterton's husband, used to sing round the supper table. Many a one I went to when I was staying at Warwick Gardens. We used to go on a red Hammersmith bus, before the days of motor cars."

    On a longer trip they stayed at Berck in Belgium, and Cecil had a strange idea, apparently regarded by him as humorous, which measures the family absence of a Christian sense at this date. "Cecil urged me to sit at the foot of the big Crucifix in the village street and let him photograph me as Mary Magdalen! I didn't, and I don't know how he thought he'd get away with the modern clothing."

    Whatever Gilbert's mother may have planned for them, neither she nor Gilbert had any romantic feeling for each other. Indeed Cecil was definitely her favourite and she believed him the favourite of both parents also. "He had more heart," she says, "than the more brilliant Gilbert." Anyhow, his heart was shown more openly to her.

    "Cecil was not much given to versifying," she wrote in another letter, "he sent me the enclosed when my son was born. I value it so much." Headed "To Annie" the poem is a long one. It begins with the "ancient comradeship, loyal and unbroken" in which they had "first seen life together."

    Shining nights, tumultuous days,
    Joy swift caught in sudden ways,
    All the laughter, love and praise,
    All the joys of living

    These we shared together dear,
    Plot and jest and story,
    This is hid, shut off, unknown,
    Seeing that to you alone
    Is the wondrous Kingdom shown
    And the power and Glory!

    Annie's thoughts, then, and Cecil's were not greatly on the elder brother, who was pursuing his own romance with a heart that seems to have been fairly adequate in its energies.

    Most mothers have watched their sons through one or more experiences of calf love: Gilbert indicates in the Autobiography--and I knew it, too, from some jokes he and Frances used to make--that he had had one or two fancies before the coming of Reality. He must then convince his mother that Reality had come: he must overcome a prejudice avowed by neither: he must call on the deeps of a mother's feelings so effectively that it would never now be avowed, that it might indeed be swept away.

    And so, sitting at a table in a seaside lodging, as his mother sat in the same room or moved about making cocoa for the family, Gilbert tried to express what even for him was the inexpressible.

    1 Rosebery Villas
    Granville Road
    Felixstowe.

    MY DEAREST MOTHER,

    You may possibly think this a somewhat eccentric proceeding. You
    are sitting opposite and talking--about Mrs. Berline. But I take this
    method of addressing you because it occurs to me that you might
    possibly wish to turn the matter over in your mind before writing or
    speaking to me about it.

    I am going to tell you the whole of a situation in which I believe
    I have acted rightly, though I am not absolutely certain, and to ask
    for your advice on it. It was a somewhat complicated one, and I
    repeat that I do not think I could rightly have acted otherwise, but
    if I were the greatest fool in the three kingdoms and had made
    nothing but a mess of it, there is one person I should always turn to
    and trust. Mothers know more of their son's idiocies than other
    people can, and this has been peculiarly true in your case. I have
    always rejoiced at this, and not been ashamed of it: this has always
    been true and always will be.

    These things are easier written than
    said, but you know it is true, don't you?

    I am inexpressibly anxious that you should give me credit for
    having done my best, and for having constantly had in mind the way in
    which you would be affected by the letter I am now writing. I do hope
    you will be pleased.

    Almost eight years ago, you made a remark--this may show you that
    if we "jeer" at your remarks, we remember them. The remark applied to
    the hypothetical young lady with whom I should fall in love and took
    the form of saying "If she is good, I shan't mind who she is." I
    don't know how many times I have said that over to myself in the last
    two or three days in which I have decided on this letter.

    Do not be frightened; or suppose that anything sensational or final
    has occurred. I am not married, my dear mother, neither am I engaged.
    You are called to the council of chiefs very early in its
    deliberations. If you don't mind I will tell you, briefly, the whole
    story.

    You are, I think, the shrewdest person for seeing things whom I
    ever knew: consequently I imagine that you do not think that I go
    down to Bedford Park every Sunday for the sake of the scenery. I
    should not wonder if you know nearly as much about the matter as I
    can tell in a letter. Suffice it to say however briefly (for neither
    of us care much for gushing: this letter is not on Mrs.

    Ratcliffe
    lines) that the first half of my time of acquaintance with the Bloggs
    was spent in enjoying a very intimate, but quite breezy and Platonic
    friendship with Frances Blogg, reading, talking and enjoying life
    together, having great sympathies on all subjects; and the second
    half in making the thrilling, but painfully responsible discovery
    that Platonism, on my side, had not the field by any means to itself.
    That is how we stand now. No one knows, except her family and
    yourself.

    My dearest mother, I am sure you are at least not unsympathetic.
    Indeed we love each other more than we shall either of us ever be
    able to say. I have refrained from sentiment in this letter--for I
    don't think you like it much. But love is a very different thing from
    sentiment and you will never laugh at that. I will not say that you
    are sure to like Frances, for all young men say that to their
    mothers, quite naturally, and their mothers never believe them, also,
    quite naturally. Besides, I am so confident, I should like you to
    find her out for yourself.

    She is, in reality, very much the sort of
    woman you like, what is called, I believe, "a Woman's Woman," very
    humorous, inconsequent and sympathetic and defiled with no offensive
    exuberance of good health.

    I have nothing more to say, except that you and she have occupied
    my mind for the last week to the exclusion of everything else, which
    must account for my abstraction, and that in her letter she sent the
    following message: "Please tell your mother soon. Tell her I am not
    so silly as to expect her to think me good enough, but really I will
    try to be."

    An aspiration which, considered from my point of view, naturally
    provokes a smile.

    Here you give me a cup of cocoa. Thank you.

    Believe me, my dearest mother,

    Always your very affectionate son

    GILBERT.

    What exactly Gilbert meant by saying they were "not engaged" it is hard to surmise, in view of Frances's message to her future mother-in-law. Of his sensations when proposing Gilbert gives some idea in the Autobiography:

    It was fortunate, however, that our next most important meeting was
    not under the sign of the moon but of the sun. She has often
    affirmed, during our later acquaintance, that if the sun had not been
    shining to her complete satisfaction on that day, the issue might
    have been quite different. It happened in St. James's Park; where
    they keep the ducks and the little bridge, which has been mentioned
    in no less authoritative a work than Mr. Belloc's Essay on Bridges,
    since I find myself quoting that author once more.

    I think he deals
    in some detail, in his best topographical manner, with various
    historic sites on the Continent; but later relapses into a larger
    manner, somewhat thus: "The time has now come to talk at large about
    Bridges. The longest bridge in the world is the Forth Bridge, and the
    shortest bridge in the world is a plank over a ditch in the village
    of Loudwater. The bridge that frightens you most is the Brooklyn
    Bridge, and the br

    Edition notice Project Gutenberg source, credits & licence

    The reading text above is the public-domain work. The Project Gutenberg header, production credits and licence are kept here as provenance rather than shown before the book.

    Title
    Gilbert Keith Chesterton
    Author
    Maisie Ward
    Release date
    June 28, 2006 [eBook #18707]
    Language
    English
    Credits
    E-text prepared by David McClamrock
    Most recently updated
    October 20, 2006
    Transcriber and production notes
    E-text prepared by David McClamrock
    
    Transcriber's note
    Front matter as received (title page, contents)
       This electronic edition is intended to contain the complete,
       unaltered text of the first published edition of _Gilbert
       Keith Chesterton_ by Maisie Ward (New York: Sheed & Ward,
       1943), with the following exceptions:
    
       The index, and a few other references to page numbers that do
       not exist in this edition, have been omitted.
    
       Italics are represented by underscores at the beginning and
       end, _like this_.
    
       Footnotes* have been placed directly below the paragraph
       referring to them and enclosed in brackets.
    
          [* Like this.]
    
       Any other deviations from the text of the first edition may be
       regarded as defects and attributed to the transcriber.
    
    
    
    
    
    GILBERT KEITH CHESTERTON
    
    by
    
    MAISIE WARD
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    CONTENTS
    
    Introduction: Chiefly Concerning Sources
    
    
    CHAPTER
    
         I   Background for Gilbert Keith Chesterton
        II   Childhood
       III   School Days
        IV   Art Schools and University College
         V   The Notebook
        VI   Towards a Career
       VII   Incipit Vita Nova
      VIII   To Frances
        IX   A Long Engagement
         X   Who is G.K.C.?
        XI   Married Life in London
       XII   Clearing the Ground for Orthodoxy
      XIII   Orthodoxy
       XIV   Bernard Shaw
        XV   From Battersea to Beaconsfield
       XVI   A Circle of Friends
      XVII   The Disillusioned Liberal
     XVIII   The Eye Witness
       XIX   Marconi
        XX   The Eve of the War (1911-1915)
       XXI   The War Years
      XXII   After the Armistice
     XXIII   Rome via Jerusalem
      XXIV   Completion
       XXV   The Reluctant Editor (1925-1930)
      XXVI   The Distributist League and Distributism
     XXVII   Silver Wedding
    XXVIII   Columbus
      XXIX   The Soft Answer
       XXX   Our Lady's Tumbler
      XXXI   The Living Voice
     XXXII   Last Days
    
    Appendices:
    
    Appendix A--An Earlier Chesterton
    Appendix B--Prize Poem Written at St. Paul's
    Appendix C--_The Chestertons_
    
    Bibliography
    
    
    
    
    INTRODUCTION
    
    Chiefly Concerning Sources
    
    
    THE MATERIAL FOR this book falls roughly into two parts: spoken and
    written. Gilbert Chesterton was not an old man when he died and many
    of his friends and contemporaries have told me incidents and recalled
    sayings right back to his early boyhood. This part of the material
    has been unusually rich and copious so that I could get a clearer
    picture of the boy and the young man than is usually granted to the
    biographer.
    
    The book has been in the making for six years and in three countries.
    Several times I hid it aside for some months so as to be able to get
    a fresh view of it. I talked to all sorts of people, heard all sorts
    of ideas, saw my subject from every side; I went to Paris to see one
    old friend, to Indiana to see others, met for the first time in
    lengthy talk Maurice Baring, H. G. Wells and Bernard Shaw; went to
    Kingsland to see Mr. Belloc; gathered Gilbert's boyhood friends of
    the Junior Debating Club in London and visited "Father Brown" among
    his Yorkshire moors.
    
    Armed with a notebook, I tried to miss none who had known Gilbert
    well, especially in his youth: E. C. Bentley, Lucian Oldershaw,
    Lawrence Solomon, Edward Fordham. I had ten long letters from Annie
    Firmin, my most valuable witness as to Gilbert's childhood. For
    information on the next period of his life, I talked to Monsignor
    O'Connor, to Hilaire Belloc, Maurice Baring, Charles Somers Cocks, F.
    Y. Eccles and others, besides being now able to draw on my own
    memories. Frances I had talked with on and off about their early
    married years ever since I had first known them, but she was, alas,
    too ill and consequently too emotionally unstrung during the last
    months for me to ask her all the questions springing in my mind.
    "Tell Maisie," she said to Dorothy Collins, "not to talk to me about
    Gilbert. It makes me cry."
    
    For the time at Beaconsfield, out of a host of friends the most
    valuable were Dr. Pocock and Dr. Bakewell. Among priests, Monsignors
    O'Connor and Ronald Knox, Fathers Vincent McNabb, O.P. and Ignatius
    Rice, O.S.B. were especially intimate.
    
    Dorothy Collins's evidence covers a period of ten years. That of H.
    G. Wells and Bernard Shaw is reinforced by most valuable letters
    which they have kindly allowed me to publish.
    
    Then too Gilbert was so much of a public character and so popular
    with his fellow journalists that stories of all kinds abound:
    concerning him there is a kind of evidence, and very valuable it is,
    that may be called a Boswell Collective. It is fitting that it should
    be so. We cannot picture G.K. like the great lexicographer
    accompanied constantly by one ardent and observant witness, pencil in
    hand, ready to take notes over the teacups. (And by the way, in spite
    of an acquaintance who regretted in this connection that G.K. was not
    latterly more often seen in taverns, it was over the teacups, even
    more than over the wine glasses, that Boswell made his notes. I have
    seen Boswell's signature after wine--on the minutes of a meeting of
    The Club--and he was in no condition then for the taking of notes.
    Even the signature is almost illegible.) But it is fitting that
    Gilbert, who loved all sorts of men so much, should be kept alive for
    the future by all sorts of men. From the focussing of many views from
    many angles this picture has been composed, but they are all views of
    one man, and the picture will show, I think, a singular unity. When
    Whistler, as Gilbert himself once said, painted a portrait he made
    and destroyed many sketches--how many it did not matter, for all,
    even of his failures, were fruitful--but it would have mattered
    frightfully if each time he looked up he found a new subject sitting
    placidly for his portrait. Gilbert was fond of asking in the _New
    Witness_ of people who expressed admiration for Lloyd George: "Which
    George do you mean?" for, chameleon-like, the politician has worn
    many colours and the portrait painted in 1906 would have had to be
    torn up in 1916. But gather the Chesterton portraits: read the files
    when he first grew into fame: talk to Mr. Titterton who worked with
    him on the _Daily News_ in 1906 and on _G.K.'s Weekly_ in 1936,
    collect witnesses from his boyhood to his old age, from Dublin to
    Vancouver: individuals who knew him, groups who are endeavoring to
    work out his ideas: all will agree on the ideas and on the man as
    making one pattern throughout, one developing but integrated mind and
    personality.
    
    Gathering the material for a biography bears some resemblance to
    interrogating witnesses in a Court of Law. There are good witnesses
    and bad: reliable and unreliable memories. I remember an old lady, a
    friend of my mother's, who remarked with candour after my mother had
    confided to her something of importance: "My dear, I must go and
    write that down immediately before my imagination gets mixed with my
    memory." One witness must be checked against another: there will be
    discrepancies in detail but the main facts will in the end emerge.
    
    Just now and again, however, a biographer, like a judge, meets a
    totally unreliable witness.
    
    One event in this biography has caused me more trouble than anything
    else: the Marconi scandal and the trial of Cecil Chesterton for
    criminal libel which grew out of it. As luck would have it, it was on
    this that I had to interrogate my most unreliable witness. I had seen
    no clear and unbiased account so I had to read the many pages of Blue
    Book and Law Reports besides contemporary comment in various papers.
    I have no legal training, but one point stuck out like a spike. Cecil
    Chesterton had brought accusations against Godfrey Isaacs not only
    concerning his own past career as a company promoter, but also
    concerning his dealings with the government over the Marconi
    contract, in connection with which he had also fiercely attacked
    Rufus Isaacs, Herbert Samuel and other ministers of the Crown. But in
    the witness box he accepted the word of the very ministers he had
    been attacking, and declared that he no longer accused them of
    corruption: which seemed to me a complete abandonment of his main
    position.
    
    Having drafted my chapter on Marconi, I asked Mrs. Cecil Chesterton
    to read it, but more particularly to explain this point. She gave me
    a long and detailed account of how Cecil had been intensely reluctant
    to take this course, but violent pressure had been exerted on him by
    his father and by Gilbert who were both in a state of panic over the
    trial. Unlikely as this seemed, especially in Gilbert's case, the
    account was so circumstantial, and from so near a connection, that I
    felt almost obliged to accept it. What was my amazement a few months
    later at receiving a letter in which she stated that after "a great
    deal of close research work, re-reading of papers, etc." (in
    connection with her own book _The Chestertons_) and after a talk with
    Cecil's solicitors, she had become convinced that Cecil had acted as
    he had because "the closest sleuthing had been unable to discover any
    trace" of investments by Rufus Isaacs in English Marconis. "For this
    reason Cecil took the course he did--not through family pressure.
    That pressure, _I still feel_,* was exerted, though possibly not
    until the trial was over."
    
    [* Italics mine.]
    
    It was, then, the lady's feelings and not facts that had been offered
    to me as evidence, and it was the merest luck that my book had not
    appeared before Cecil's solicitors had spoken.
    
    The account given in Lord Birkenhead's _Famous Trials_ is the Speech
    for the Prosecution. Mrs. Cecil Chesterton's chapter is an
    impressionist sketch of the court scene by a friend of the defendant.
    What was wanted was an impartial account, but I tried in vain to
    write it. The chronology of events, the connection between the
    Government Commission and the Libel Case, the connection between the
    English and American Marconi companies--it was all too complex for
    the lay mind, so I turned the chapter over to my husband who has had
    a legal training and asked him to write it for me.
    
    _The Chestertons_ is concerned with Gilbert and Frances as well as
    with Cecil; and the confusion between memory and imagination--to say
    nothing of reliance on feelings unsupported by facts--pervades the
    book. It can only be called a Legend, so long growing in Mrs. Cecil's
    mind that I am convinced that when she came to write her book she
    firmly believed in it herself. The starting-point was so ardent a
    dislike for Frances that every incident poured fuel on the flame and
    was seen only by its light. When I saw her, the Legend was beginning
    to shape. She told me various stories showing her dislike: facts
    offered by me were either denied or twisted to fit into the pattern.
    I do not propose to discuss here the details of a thoroughly
    unreliable book. Most of them I think answer themselves in the course
    of this biography. With one or two points I deal in Appendix C. But I
    will set down here one further incident that serves to show just how
    little help this particular witness could ever be.
    
    For, like Cecil's solicitors, I spoilt one telling detail for her.
    She told me with great enthusiasm that Cecil had said that Gilbert
    was really in love not with Frances but with her sister Gertrude, and
    that Gertrude's red hair accounted for the number of red-headed
    heroines in his stories. I told her, however, on the word of their
    brother-in-law, that Gertrude's hair was not red. Mr. Oldershaw in
    fact seemed a good deal amused: he said that Gilbert never looked at
    either of the other sisters, who were "not his sort," and had eyes
    only for Frances. Mrs. Cecil however would not relinquish this dream
    of red hair and another love. In her book she wishes "red-gold" hair
    on to Annie Firmin, because in the _Autobiography_ Gilbert had
    described her golden plaits. But unluckily for this new theory
    Annie's hair was yellow,* which is quite a different colour. And
    Annie, who is still alive, is also amused at the idea that Gilbert
    had any thought of romance in her connection.
    
    [* See G.K.'s letter to her daughter, p. 633 [Chapter XXXI].]
    
    When Frances Chesterton gave me the letters and other documents, she
    said: "I don't want the book to appear in a hurry: not for at least
    five years. There will be lots of little books written about Gilbert;
    let them all come out first. I want your book to be the final and
    definitive Biography."
    
    The first part of this injunction I have certainly obeyed, for it
    will be just seven years after his death that this book appears. For
    the second half, I can say only that I have done the best that in me
    lies to obey it also. And I am very grateful to those who have
    preceded me with books depicting one aspect or another of my subject.
    I have tried to make use of them all as part of my material, and some
    are "little" merely in the number of their pages. I am especially
    grateful to Hilaire Belloc, Emile Cammaerts, Cyril Clemens and
    "Father Brown" (who have allowed me to quote with great freedom). I
    want to thank Mr. Seward Collins, Mr. Cyril Clemens and the
    University of Notre Dame for the loan of books; Mrs. Bambridge for
    the use of a letter from Kipling and a poem from _The Years Between_.
    
    Even greater has been the kindness of those friends of my own and of
    Gilbert Chesterton's who have read this book in manuscript and made
    very valuable criticisms and suggestions: May Chesterton, Dorothy
    Collins, Edward Connor, Ross Hoffman, Mrs. Robert Kidd, Arnold Lunn,
    Mgr. Knox, Father Murtagh, Father Vincent McNabb, Lucian Oldershaw,
    Beatrice Warde, Douglas Woodruff, Monsignor O'Connor.
    
    Most of the criticisms were visibly right, while even those with
    which I could not concur showed me the weak spot in my work that had
    occasioned them. They have helped me to improve the book--I think I
    may say enormously.
    
    One suggestion I have not followed--that one name should be used
    throughout: either Chesterton or Gilbert or G.K., but not all three.
    I had begun with the idea of using "Chesterton" when speaking of him
    as a public character and also when speaking of the days before I did
    in fact call him "Gilbert." But this often left him and Cecil mixed
    up: then too, though I seldom used "G.K." myself, other friends
    writing to me of him often used it. I began to go through the
    manuscript unifying--and then I noticed that in a single paragraph of
    his _Bernard Shaw_ Gilbert uses "GBS," "Shaw," "Bernard Shaw," and
    "Mr. Shaw." Here was a precedent indeed, and it seemed to me that it
    was really the natural thing to do. After all we do talk of people
    now by one name, now by another: it is a matter of slight importance
    if of any, and I decided to let it go.
    
    As to size, I am afraid the present book is a large one--although not
    as large as Boswell's _Johnson_ or _Gone with the Wind_. But in this
    matter I am unrepentant, for I have faith in Chesterton's own public.
    The book is large because there is no other way of getting Chesterton
    on to the canvas. It is a joke he would himself have enjoyed, but it
    is also a serious statement. For a complete portrait of Chesterton,
    even the most rigorous selection of material cannot be compressed
    into a smaller space. I have first written at length and then cut and
    cut.
    
    At first I had intended to omit all matter already given in the
    _Autobiography_. Then I realised that would never do. For some things
    which are vital to a complete Biography of Chesterton are not only
    told in the _Autobiography_ better than I could tell them, but are
    recorded there and nowhere else. And this book is not merely a
    supplement to the _Autobiography_. It is the Life of Chesterton.
    
    The same problem arises with regard to the published books and I have
    tried to solve it on the same line. There has rung in my mind Mr.
    Belloc's saying: "A man is his mind." To tell the story of a man of
    letters while avoiding quotation from or reference to his published
    works is simply not to tell it. At Christopher Dawson's suggestion I
    have re-read all the books _in the order in which they were written_,
    thus trying to get the development of Gilbert's mind perfectly clear
    to myself and to trace the influences that affected him at various
    dates. For this reason I have analysed certain of the books and not
    others--those which showed this mental development most clearly at
    various stages, or those (too many alas) which are out of print and
    hard to obtain. But whenever possible in illustrating his mental
    history I have used unpublished material, so that even the most
    ardent Chestertonian will find much that is new to him.
    
    For the period of Gilbert's youth there are many exercise books,
    mostly only half filled, containing sketches and caricatures, lists
    of titles for short stories and chapters, unfinished short stories.
    Several completed fairy stories and some of the best drawings were
    published in _The Coloured Lands_. Others are hints later used in his
    own novels: there is a fragment of _The Ball and the Cross_, a first
    suggestion for _The Man Who Was Thursday_, a rather more developed
    adumbration of _The Napoleon of Notting Hill_. This I think is later
    than most of the notebooks; but, after the change in handwriting,
    apparently deliberately and carefully made by Gilbert around the date
    at which he left St. Paul's for the Slade School, it is almost
    impossible to establish a date at all exactly for any one of these
    notebooks. Notes made later when he had formed the habit of dictation
    became difficult to read, not through bad handwriting, but because
    words are abbreviated and letters omitted.
    
    Some of the exercise books appear to have been begun, thrown aside
    and used again later. There is among them one only of real
    biographical importance, a book deliberately used for the development
    of a philosophy of life, dated in two places, to which I devote a
    chapter and which I refer to as _the_ Notebook. This book is as
    important in studying Chesterton as the Pensées would be for a
    student of Pascal. He is here already a master of phrase in a sense
    which makes a comparison with Pascal especially apt. For he often
    packs so much meaning into a brilliant sentence or two that I have
    felt it worth while, in dealing especially with some of the less
    remembered books, to pull out a few of these sentences for quotation
    apart from their context.
    
    Other important material was to be found in _G.K.'s Weekly_, in
    articles in other periodicals, and in unpublished letters. With some
    of the correspondences I have made considerable use of both sides,
    and if anyone pedantically objects that that is unusual in a
    biography I will adapt a phrase of Bernard Shaw's which you will find
    in this book, and say, "Hang it all, be reasonable! If you had the
    choice between reading me and reading Wells and Shaw, wouldn't you
    choose Wells and Shaw."
    
    
    
    
    GILBERT KEITH CHESTERTON
    Header as received
    The Project Gutenberg eBook of Gilbert Keith Chesterton
        
    This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and
    most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
    whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
    of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online
    at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States,
    you will have to check the laws of the country where you are located
    before using this eBook.
    
    Title: Gilbert Keith Chesterton
    
    Author: Maisie Ward
    
    
            
    Release date: June 28, 2006 [eBook #18707]
                    Most recently updated: October 20, 2006
    
    Language: English
    
    Other information and formats: www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/18707
    
    Credits: E-text prepared by David McClamrock
    Full Project Gutenberg licence
        
    
    Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
    be renamed.
    
    Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright
    law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works,
    so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United
    States without permission and without paying copyright
    royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part
    of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG™
    concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark,
    and may not be used if you charge for an eBook, except by following
    the terms of the trademark license, including paying royalties for use
    of the Project Gutenberg trademark. If you do not charge anything for
    copies of this eBook, complying with the trademark license is very
    easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose such as creation
    of derivative works, reports, performances and research. Project
    Gutenberg eBooks may be modified and printed and given away—you may
    do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks not protected
    by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the trademark
    license, especially commercial redistribution.
    
    
    START: FULL LICENSE
    
    THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG™ LICENSE
    
    PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK
    
    To protect the Project Gutenberg™ mission of promoting the free
    distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work
    (or any other work associated in any way with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg”), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full
    Project Gutenberg License available with this file or online at
    www.gutenberg.org/license.
    
    Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg
    electronic works
    
    1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg
    electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to
    and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property
    (trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all
    the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or
    destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg electronic works in your
    possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a
    Project Gutenberg electronic work and you do not agree to be bound
    by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person
    or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8.
    
    1.B. “Project Gutenberg” is a registered trademark. It may only be
    used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who
    agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few
    things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg electronic works
    even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See
    paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project
    Gutenberg electronic works if you follow the terms of this
    agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg
    electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below.
    
    1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation (“the
    Foundation” or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection
    of Project Gutenberg electronic works. Nearly all the individual
    works in the collection are in the public domain in the United
    States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the
    United States and you are located in the United States, we do not
    claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing,
    displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as
    all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope
    that you will support the Project Gutenberg mission of promoting
    free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg
    works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the
    Project Gutenberg name associated with the work. You can easily
    comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the
    same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg License when
    you share it without charge with others.
    
    1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern
    what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are
    in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States,
    check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this
    agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing,
    distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any
    other Project Gutenberg work. The Foundation makes no
    representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any
    country other than the United States.
    
    1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg:
    
    1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other
    immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg License must appear
    prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg work (any work
    on which the phrase “Project Gutenberg” appears, or with which the
    phrase “Project Gutenberg” is associated) is accessed, displayed,
    performed, viewed, copied or distributed:
    
        This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and most
        other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions
        whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms
        of the Project Gutenberg™ License included with this eBook or online
        at www.gutenberg.org. If you
        are not located in the United States, you will have to check the laws
        of the country where you are located before using this eBook.
      
    1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is
    derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not
    contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the
    copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in
    the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are
    redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase “Project
    Gutenberg” associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply
    either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or
    obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg
    trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg electronic work is posted
    with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution
    must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any
    additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms
    will be linked to the Project Gutenberg License for all works
    posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the
    beginning of this work.
    
    1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg
    License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this
    work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg.
    
    1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this
    electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without
    prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with
    active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project
    Gutenberg License.
    
    1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
    compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including
    any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access
    to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg work in a format
    other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in the official
    version posted on the official Project Gutenberg website
    (www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense
    to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means
    of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original “Plain
    Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must include the
    full Project Gutenberg License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1.
    
    1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying,
    performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg works
    unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9.
    
    1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing
    access to or distributing Project Gutenberg electronic works
    provided that:
    
        • You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from
            the use of Project Gutenberg works calculated using the method
            you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed
            to the owner of the Project Gutenberg trademark, but he has
            agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid
            within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are
            legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty
            payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project
            Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in
            Section 4, “Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg
            Literary Archive Foundation.”
        
        • You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies
            you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he
            does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg™
            License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all
            copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue
            all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg™
            works.
        
        • You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of
            any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the
            electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of
            receipt of the work.
        
        • You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
            distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
        
    
    1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work or group of works on different terms than
    are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing
    from the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the manager of
    the Project Gutenberg™ trademark. Contact the Foundation as set
    forth in Section 3 below.
    
    1.F.
    
    1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable
    effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread
    works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project
    Gutenberg™ collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may
    contain “Defects,” such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate
    or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other
    intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or
    other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or
    cannot be read by your equipment.
    
    1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the “Right
    of Replacement or Refund” described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project
    Gutenberg™ trademark, and any other party distributing a Project
    Gutenberg™ electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all
    liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal
    fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT
    LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE
    PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE
    TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE
    LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR
    INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH
    DAMAGE.
    
    1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a
    defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can
    receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a
    written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you
    received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium
    with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you
    with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in
    lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person
    or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second
    opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If
    the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing
    without further opportunities to fix the problem.
    
    1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
    in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
    OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT
    LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
    
    1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied
    warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of
    damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement
    violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the
    agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or
    limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or
    unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the
    remaining provisions.
    
    1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the
    trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone
    providing copies of Project Gutenberg™ electronic works in
    accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the
    production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg™
    electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses,
    including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of
    the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this
    or any Project Gutenberg work, (b) alteration, modification, or
    additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg work, and (c) any
    Defect you cause.
    
    Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg
    
    Project Gutenberg is synonymous with the free distribution of
    electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of
    computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It
    exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations
    from people in all walks of life.
    
    Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the
    assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg’s
    goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg collection will
    remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project
    Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure
    and permanent future for Project Gutenberg and future
    generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see
    Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org.
    
    Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation
    
    The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non-profit
    501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the
    state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal
    Revenue Service. The Foundation’s EIN or federal tax identification
    number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by
    U.S. federal laws and your state’s laws.
    
    The Foundation’s business office is located at 41 Watchung Plaza #516,
    Montclair NJ 07042, USA, +1 (862) 621-9288. Email contact links and up
    to date contact information can be found at the Foundation’s website
    and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact
    
    Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg
    Literary Archive Foundation
    
    Project Gutenberg™ depends upon and cannot survive without widespread
    public support and donations to carry out its mission of
    increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be
    freely distributed in machine-readable form accessible by the widest
    array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations
    ($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt
    status with the IRS.
    
    The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating
    charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United
    States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a
    considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up
    with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations
    where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND
    DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular state
    visit www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we
    have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition
    against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who
    approach us with offers to donate.
    
    International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make
    any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from
    outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff.
    
    Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
    methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other
    ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To
    donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
    
    Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg electronic works
    
    Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project
    Gutenberg concept of a library of electronic works that could be
    freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and
    distributed Project Gutenberg eBooks with only a loose network of
    volunteer support.
    
    Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed
    editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in
    the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not
    necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper
    edition.
    
    Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
    facility: www.gutenberg.org.
    
    This website includes information about Project Gutenberg,
    including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary
    Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to
    subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks.

    Source: Project Gutenberg ebook #18707. Public-domain status is recorded per item; the licence text above is reproduced unchanged.

    Source
    Project Gutenberg
    Record
    ebook 18707
    Rights
    public domain (US)
    Rendered
    2026-11-21
    Completeness
    First 200,000 characters rendered.